05/01/1997 - SpecialNEIGHBORHOOD AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING
SPECIAL PUBLIC HOUSING MEETING
CITYOF CLEARWATER
May 1, 1997
Present: Alan Ferri Director, Clearwater Housing and Urban Development
Michael Holmes Asst. Director, Clearwater Housing and Urban Development
Bertha Kelley Neighborhood and Affordable Housing Board
Nick Masters Nick Masters Realtor
Jerry Spilatin CSF
Sylvia Castle PSS
Tom Smith General Home Development
Jeff Daines General Home Development
Gregory Schwartz Tampa Bay CDC
Randy Harvey Homebuyer Club
Ron Mores Lyon Mortgage
Brenda Moses Board Reporter
The meeting was called to order by Director of Clearwater Housing and Urban Development, Alan Ferri at 10:15 a.m. at Condon Gardens, Clearwater. In order to provide continuity for
research, the items listed were not necessarily discussed in that order.
Mr. Ferri noted that the City holds 4 public information meetings a year. Today’s meeting is important to identify which programs should be scrutinized, and how to effectively modify
what is currently being done for housing needs. Attendees were encouraged to share information regarding the affordable housing crisis so that infomation may be incorporated into the
consolidated plan. He explained the consolidated plan, which is a vehicle used to allocate funds under the Community Development Block Grant Program, the SHIP Program (State Housing
Incentive Partnership), and HOME??? The HOME and SHIP programs are geared exclusively to housing. The Community Development Block Grant is also frequently used for housing. Last year
the City had $2.3 million to allocate. Of those funds, $1.5 million was allocated to housing and $800,000 of the funding had to be allocated to housing from SHIP and HOME funds. In
the first consolidated plan submission to HUD 2 years ago, it was projected that the City had a 350-unit demand for new affordable rental housing and a 400-unit demand for new home ownership
due to anticipated population shifts and growth. Over the last 2 years 10% of the new home ownership goal has been accomplished. Later this year, one project alone will help accomplish
80% of the County’s rental needs. The Wilson Company in Tampa is developing a 356-unit housing complex. Under the low income housing tax credit program, 246 units will be
made available to low to moderate income tenants with income ranges between $16,000 and $24,000 a year. It will have a 3,800 square foot clubhouse, an outdoor swimming pool and daycare
facilities on site. This is the second development ever to be done in Pinellas County. The program in Pinellas Park only had 48 units. It was noted that turnover in the Housing Authority’s
Section 8 Federal Assistance Program is high because of one bedroom units for the elderly population. Turnover is minuscule on the 2 and 3 bedroom units. There has not been a new allocation
under the Section 8 Housing Program from HUD in years. It is estimated that a national loss of upwards of 50,000 affordable rental units may occur in coming years.
The President’s budget submission to Congress beginning this year and extending over the next 5 years, calls for a 26.6% reduction in the Community Development Block Program. That
means the City’s entitlement allocation will be reduced to $750,000 from $1,035,000. Under the Home Program, the current allocation is $408,000, and the President is proposing a reduction
to 46.6%. This diminishment of resources will prompt everyone to look for more resources and diversify. Mr. Ferri will be submitting a request to the City Commission to join forces
with the NDC (National Development Council). The NDC is a not-for-profit agency which has 200 client communities across the country and charges a fee to become a member of their organization.
The member benefits include sharing of 2 funds, one of which is called ProAmerica. This fund has 1 of 6 SBA small planning business licenses, which means they are not required to go
through the debenture process of the SBA and federal credit banks. They can go directly to secondary banks with Federal guarantees on their loans through the SBA to raise money. They
have been raising rather sizable sums of money to finance business development loans for communities at 7 to 15 year terms with competitive rates. This funding vehicle will open new
doors for the housing market. The NDC has another national nonprofit subsidiary which offers direct access for 203K mortgages, which are HUD-insured programs. This program allows buyers
to acquire properties that may have functional defects and allow rehab of properties at approximately 2 points below conventional rates. Residents who have owned property for 20 to
30 years and cannot maintain them can obtain 203K loans to avoid any further property deterioration. Investor-owners are able to obtain loans easily because banks look at financing
cash flow, not the condition of the property. Investor ownership further stresses the market value of properties in a depressed community. By diverting some of
those properties from this negative spiral, the HUD 203K Program can provide a good resource for the first-time home buyer. The National Finance Organization is able to issue direct
tax exempt housing bonds under their portfolio. Their rates are competitive, offered at the tax exempt rate, and they bring lots of technical and financial expertise for housing opportunities.
Annually, the City of Clearwater allocates from its resources $30 million in (CIP) Capital Improvement Projects. The City Commission is holding public meetings on May 21, 1997 at 7:30
p.m., May 27, 1997 at 7:00 p.m. and May 29, 1997 at 7:00 p.m. The meeting sites have not been identified at this time. One will be held at the Morningside Recreation Center, the Main
Clearwater Library, and the Countryside Recreation Center. The public is encouraged to attend the public hearings, share information, and offer suggestions regarding public housing
needs in the community. On May 6, 1997 at 10:00 a.m., there will be a special public meeting at the Chamber of Commerce on economic development. On May 10, 1997 a special needs public
meeting will be held at the Salvation Army on North Belcher Road. Mr. Ferri urged those attending today’s meeting to attend these special meetings, or submit in writing before June
6, 1997, their suggestions and observations regarding housing needs and trends in the community. In 3 years the City must report their progress to HUD. It was noted that the affordable
housing development for rentals will be at 80% of original goals. Hopes are to obtain more diversified product and more resources to enhance the mix that is currently available in order
to attain home ownership goals.
Under the Community Development Block Grant Program, the City will submit a neighborhood redevelopment strategy. Elements of the Weed and Seed Program and the Brownfield Redevelopment
Initiative will be incorporated into the neighborhood redevelopment strategy that will be submitted to HUD. The boundaries are Ft. Harrison on the west, Stevenson’s Creek on the north,
Betty Lane and Missouri Avenue on the east, and Belleair Road on the south. There are 100 potentially contaminated sites in that area, and through the Penny for Pinellas, the City will
have $5 million for assessment and remediation on those sites. Thanks to the State Legislature, the City will receive an additional $500,000 for a variety of items related to the Brownfield
Initiative. Over $150,000 of the $500,000 will be dedicated to employment development
resources. Under the Weed and Seed Program next year there will be another half million dollars in federal money for Clearwater to address crime and crime prevention.
Discussion ensued regarding the high price of land for new housing projects, tax credit recipients, and other methods of funding. Mr. Ferri re-emphasized the importance of everyone
attending the upcoming special public informational meetings, as well as the City Commission meetings to voice their opinions and offer suggestions to the current public ousing problem.
The meeting adjourned at 11:00 a.m.