FLD2004-11081
CL W CoverS heet
FLD2004-11081
3070 GULF TO BAY BLVD
Date Received: 11/23/2004
COMFORT SUITES
ZONING DISTRICT: C
LAND USE: CG
ATLAS PAGE: 292A
PLANNER OF RECORD: WW
CL W CoverSheet
~
ORIGINAL
FLD2004-11081
3070 GULF TO BAY BLVD
Date Received: 11/23/2004
COMFORT SUITES
ZONING DISTRICT: C
LAND USE: CG
ATLAS PAGE: 292A
PLANNER OF RECORD: NOT ENTERED
ill I:E @ I:E 0 W I:E ~
NOV 2 3 1004
.--J
PLANNING 8. OEVElOPMENT SVCS
CITY OF ClEAPWATER
; ,
... ~ IJli'''~ ~';d \:
l'''h~ r~...~
~ 1~~1~'''~(
;;..~-~~1'1
j '.t"'~r;n
... m'''''-li')t,. " ';Ti- '" \' ,
~~
u~
,..
-<" ~ '1.
"
','
" ,
-.;:
CASE #: ~ I- I
DATE RECEIVED,
RECEJVED BY (staff lnltlals)
ATLAS PAGE #
ZONING DISTRICT
LAND USE CLASSIFICATJON- ,
SURROUNDING USES OF ADJACENT
PROPERTIES-
NORm
SOUTH
WEST.
EAST
-'I I
Planning Department
100 South Myrtle Avenue
Clearwater, Flonda 33756
Telephone 727-562-4587
Fax 727.562-4885
o SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED AND NOTARIZED APPUCA nON
o SUBMIT 14 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION Including
1) collated, 2) stapled and 3} folded sets 01 sIte plans
o SUBMIT APPLICATION FEE $
OR/GINJ\L
FLEXIBLE DEVELOP:MENT APPLICATION
Comprehensive Intill Redevelopment Project (Revised 10-10-2003)
* NOTE 15 TOTAL SETS OF INFORMATION REQUIRED (APPLICATIONS PLUS SITE PLANS SETS)
-PLEASE TYPE OR PRJNT... use addItl.Onal sheets as necessary
A. APPLICANT, PROPERTY OWNER AND AGENT INFORMATION: (Section 4-202.A)
AGENT NAME(S)
MAILING ADDRESS 'S
t-....' C;. '- l' '1'.P. eL;c~...!Qp~f\
E.MAll ADDRE5i~ ~\1l<iie:::...f'\0 ,~n~ ,A~ ~e. "rQ\' PI'iONE NUMpER "7 d- J ~yLi 3'- :+?r ~ 1
CELL NUMBER o;}- / ) "70::1. --DC{ L\ ~ FAX NUMBER (I;).. 'J ) 41-\ b -"R' 0 oL:,
B. PROPOSED DEVEL.OPMENT INFORMATION:
STREET ADDRESS of subject site
rD')~Ll~ i>> [~~
11\\ ~L, \ --7 1_: II ,'/ :C~ iLl)
LEGAL DESCRIPTION,
JAN 0 G 20(;5
PARCEL NUMBER
P~ ;, ~nl'\.r~,\r,~ DIE';>F' ~ "ij,\"~~rl,.RT
~'\~'J~... -..J\rl! 1:::1I'1= f ~.... ~ .I b:..~'J
PARCEL SIZE
PROPOSED USE AND SIZE
DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST(S}
Attach sheats and 00 specific when Identlfymg the request { elude all requesled code deViations, e g reduction In reo.ulred number of
pa rkIng spaces, specl!lc use, ete}
" '!t~~ , ,c<
, "~;~1&.:i> ~, t ",:" (" I 1,1 f.l'~(~l': ~
_, ,"1J:1tf l, , \llt"~I"- /
-"'III~J 'I..~ ".. !Ij' "?,,Y'
00E3 n'IS APP~f9ATION INVOLVE THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS (fOR), A F:RE;Vrdu,SL Y APPROVED PLANNED I:Jr'IIT:;'
DEVELOPMENT, OR A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED (CERTIFIED) SITE PLAN? YES _ NO ~ (If yes, attach a copy of the applicable
, . ~
documents) ..c "_Ai! C
~ I~f
'i',
';,. II
PROOF OF OWNERSHIP, (Section 4-202.A)
SUBMIT A COpy OF THE TITLE INSURANCE POLICY. DEED TO THE PROPER11' OR SIGN AFFIDAVIT ATIEST1NG OWNERSHIP (see
page 6)
D/ WRITTEN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 3~913.A)
, ProVIde complete responses to the SIX (6) GENERAL APPLICABILITY CRITERIA - Explaln!l2!t. each cntefla IS achieved, In detal!
The proposed development of the land Will be In haflTlony with the scale. bulk, coverage, density and character of adjacent properties In
which It Is located c; '-' c:::. ,\,.. L ~ll t). Ii
\...",Jf>f - L.Xl \1 !Ul- .--\
. I
2
The proposed development WIll not hinder or discourage the appropriate development and use of adjacent land and buildings or significantly
Impair the value thereof ~ '" (~\ \' -\- 'I [1/ j
'--Je L:- L-'f'. ~\ f) \
,
3
The proposed development WIll not adversely affect the health or safety or persons reSiding or working In the neighborhood of the proposed
use Se~e- ~ 2)5... "'\\JI-~J1-/I
4
The proposed development Is deSigned to mlmmlze traffic congestion
C:)e~_ Z~w,\~\)\'-\--~ ~L
5
The proposed development ]~nslstent with the community character of the Immediate VICinity of the parcel proposed for development
~)('e.. E X\~'oi-~I
6
The deSign of the proposed development mmlmlzes adverse effects, Including Visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operatlon Impacts,
on adjacent properties ~)c -e- L_~~, ~) \ ~ \ __ It ~J t
ProVlde complete responses to the ten (10) COMPREHENSIVE INFILL REDEVELOPMENT PROJECLC(RITERIAT(as apPhCa~Dble) - Explain
how each crltana IS achIeved In detail 11,_~j \ 'r--::J (( - \ '- 1 ~ I \\//1 ~~ - t:
U~ l'.:::::, ~ [;:..::J J V ~
The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for development IS otherwise Impractical Without deViations from the use, intensity
and development standards .c::-- c:- '{(, If JAN 0 6 2005
"
" ."", D~tr;;'\":""r..Jut""'\.nT
i"lJD &\\",1i\l.P l'c51 ~'I-' ..'-'" "._""
to CO>II .. - ~-t '\; l'?IE~
cny Or ctE/',,{ \ ,-'.~ '::L~
Page 2 of 7 - FleXible Development Appllcalion . ComprehenSIVe Inllll Redevelopment Project- City of Clearwater
1:I;t'~'t
~~~W,r~i
~ I)'b'...,. ...
~~~~;rtr ~L I j
~"I\ I' ~ 2'
~l-I !.Ii
\'ij'\-I .-
ir,' 1
~\I~
"
if.;'
t"~
"
l',
r
J.?;-~~:'A'(:~1t~~
\~I\ ~t;t.ill
-tl~I' ~\L...
-',..,...". "Z'J
~j ~r ~
I
The development of the parcel proposed lor development as a comprehen~~y~ mlil! redevelopment project or re I t I I II riot
reduce the faIr market value of abutting properues (Include the eXlsting 'value of the site and the proposed value at the slle With the
ovements ) I ,1,6\(
lmpr (' 1 ,,<,,.,1,,"
See... CX\-\l bl t- II '1~1tr
rll~t
11~
3
"1
The uses within the comprehensive Inhl! redevelopment project are olherwls errl1ltted In the ClIy of Clearwater
S fC'~ E, l, II ~711
4
The uses or mix of use within tl1e comprehensive mfill redevelopm nt p!'CJect are compatible with adjacent land uses
c::; ~ t l _I I
5
Suitable slles for development or redevelopment of the uses or mIx of uses Within the comprehensive mfill redevelopment prOject are not
otl1erwlse available In the City of Clearwater.
c::::.
,-)c.12-
;? j(~\\o; +- I} f~1f
6 The development of the parcel proposed for development as a comprehensive Inflll redevelopment project Will upgrade the Immediate Vlcmlty
of tl1e parcel proposed for development
See ~\-\l'o'1- II rr
7 The deSign of the proposed comprehensIVe mllll redevelopment project creates a form and functJon that B!1hances the community character of
the Immediate VIcinIty of the parcel proposed for development and the CIty of Clearwater as a whole
Ge e ~ <;:.x.\r,,/\O; \.~ II fl) I
"
8. Rexlblllly In regard to lot Wldlh. reqUired setbacks, height and off-street parking are Justified by the benefits to community character and the
Immediate VICinIty 01 the parcel proposed for development and the Cl of CI ter as a whole
c:: e- ~_ ( .(....--. II II
9 Adequate off-street parking In the Immediate v!clnlty according to the shared parking formula m DIVISion 14 of Article 3 will be available to
aVOid on-street parking In the Immediate vIcinity of parcel proposed fo development
C-:' C~ II ~ I{
10 The deSign of all bUildIngs compiles wrth the Tourist District or Downtown Dlstnct deSign gUidelines In'R~VI~191);5 01 Mlcrle,\3 (as, ~pphcable)
Use separate sheets as necessary fi ".> Il::.lr Ie" il \\1/ I _1 if';)
~ C~_ '- \ ,\ H f\)t u~LS~bu J L1l!d
0e~ - c:. X1=4~ u'+ -L-l
.IAN 06 2R05
~U\l\j:i\'llt...';'; Ud",'~ :'IN!;:;i~ I
CIIY 0;- Cl1:Af{\"J,":i~~'?
Page 3 of 7 - FleXible Development Application. ComprehenSive Inflll Redevelopment proJect- City of Clearwater
, " ";>~:;':4'~@}W~~W'w<! ,~, '
E, SUPpLEMENT AL SUBMITTAL ~t1r,~Mll'~~TS: (Code Section 4-202.A) , )~ ~
l\Y" SIGNED AND SEALED SURVEY (lnCIUdl~9 1~~'~' .aesC.!1Ph~n of property) - One anginal and 14 caples, 0 RIG I N A L '.
/; .,I~,"j~~\'lII1fl'j.
11,.\1t:~1!J1
TREE SURVEY (including eXlstrng trees on site at\~.wlthln 25' of the adjacent site, by specIes, size (DBH 4" or greater), and location.
JI~ \'1(, ':t
including dnp lines and lndlcatlng trees to be removep),~'please deSign around the exlstmg trees,
~ ' 'k''"(iiAr~::JJ
't: ~ "i! "
LOCATION MAP OF THE PROPERTY, ,~',i'~?~'1
r.d~ARKING DEMAND STUDY in conlunctlon WIth a ~~~ekt to make deVlallons to the parking standards (I e Reduce number of spaces) Prior to
I~ the submittal of thIS appllcallon, the methodology of such study shall be approved by the Commumty Development Coordinator and shall be In
accordance with accepted traffic englneenng prinCiples The findings of the study Will be used In determining whether or not deViations to the
?l'1<lng standards are approved.
~^ 9RADING PLAN, as applicable.
p \~PRELI MI NARY PLAT, as required (Note BUilding permits WIll not be Issued untll evidence of recording a final pial 15 provIded),
\KoPY OF RECORDED PLAT, as appllcablej
F. ;;ITE PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 4-202 A)
~ SITE PLAN WIth the following Informallon (not to exceed 24w x 36")
All dimensions.
North arrow;
Engineering bar scale (mmlmum scale one Inch equals 50 leet), and date prepared.
Location map,
Index sheet referencing IndIVidual sheets Included !n package,
Footpnnt and sIze of all EXISTING bUildings and structures,
Footpnnt and sIze of all PROPOSED buildings and structures,
Include fioor plates on multl.stmy bUildings.
AU required setbacks,
All eXlsbng and proposed pomts of access.
All required Sight mangles.
Identification of envIronmentally unique areas. such as watercourses, wetlands, tree masses, and specimen
trees. Including desorlptlon and location of understory, ground cover vegetanon and WIldlife habitats, etc.
Location 01 aU public and private easements,
location 01 all street rights-of-way within and adjacent to the site,
Location of existing publiC and private Ul1litles, Including fire hydrants, storm and sanitary sewer Unes, manholes and lift statIOns, gas
and water !lnes, (" Note Per SectIOn 3-911, all utl!llles shall be located/relocated underground)
AU parking spaces, driveways, loading areas and vehicular usa areas, including handicapped spaces,
Depiction by shading or crosshatching of all reqUired parkmg lot Intenor landscaped areas,
Location of allsohd waste contall1ers, recycling Of trash handling areas and outside mechanical eqUipment and all requIred screening {per
Secllon 3--201 (0)(1) and Index #701},
Location 01 all landscape material,
location 01 alljUrlsdlctlona1l1nes adjacent to wetlands.
Location of all onslte and offSlle storm-water management faCilities,
Location of all outdoor lighting fixtures. and
_ Location of all exlstlng and proposed sidewalks
~ ITE DATA TABLE for eXlstlng. reqUired, and proposed development, In wnttenftabular form:
land area In square feet and acres,
Number of EXISTING dwelling units,
Number of PROPOSED dwelling Units,
Gross floor area devoted to each use,
Parking spaces total number, presented In tabular form WIth the number of required spaces,
Total paved area. IncludIng all paved pa!klng spaces and driveways. expressed In square feet and percentage of the paved vehicular area.
Size and species of all landscape material.
Official records book and page numbers of all eXIsting utility easement,
BUilding and structure heights.
~ Impermeable surface ratio (I S R ), and
Floor area ratio (F A A ) for all nonresldenbal uses
FOR DEVELOPMENTS OVER ONE ACRE, prOVide the following additional Information on site plan
One.loot contours or spot elevatlons on Site,
Oftslte elevations If required to evaluate the proposed stormwater management for the parcel,
AI! open space areas,
Location of all earth or water retaining walls and earth berms,
Lot hnes and bUilding hnes (dimensioned),
Streets and dnves (dimenSioned),
Bulldll1g and structural setbacks (dImenSioned),
Structural overhangs.
Tree Invenlorj. prepared by a "certified arborlst", of ell trees 8" DBH or greater, reflecting Size, canopy (drip lines) and condition of such trees
~~~l~0:j\\'lFDO
U~~~b~ J LS
JAN 0 6 2005
PlANM~~C Dr:Pf~,~7MENT
CITY O~ Cl~tJ~ ~?/~\.i~R
Page 4 of 7 - FleXIble Development Application. ComprehensIVe Inllll Redevelopment proJect- City of Clearwater
GV"
,I,
"
::
'.
G: LANDSCAPING PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 4-1102 A)
~:
,
LANDSCAPE PLAN
All eXlsling and proposed structures,
Names of abutting streets,
Drainage and retenbon areas lncludmg swales, side slopes and bottom elevations,
Delineation and dImensions of all required penmeter landscape buffers,
Sight visibility tnangles,
Dellnealion and dImensions of all parking areas Including landscaping islands and curbing, ,:WJ I,~, f.
Proposed and rsqUlred parking spaces, ).llrt1 ".
EXlsling trees on-sIte and Immediately adjacent to the site, by species, size aIld locations, Including dnpllne (as Indicated on
reqUIred tree survey), ,'-);. [
Plant schedule with a key (symbol or label) Indicating the size. descrlpllon, specifications and quantities of all existing and proposed
landscape matenals, including botamcal and common names, ~ ",':
Location, size. and quantities of all eXisting and proposed landscape matenals, indicated by a key relatmg to the plant schedule,
Typical planting details for trees, palms, shrubs aIld ground cover plants Including Instructions, SOil mixes, backfilling, mulching and
protecl1ve measures,
Interior landscaping areas hatched and/or shaded and labeled atld Interior landscape coverage, expressing Jn both square feet and
percentage covered,
Condlllons of a prevIous development approval (e g conditions Imposed by the Commumty Development Board);
Imgatlon notes
7" REDUCED LANDSCAPE PLAN to scale (8 ~ X 11), In color
~ lifk' IRRIGAT!ON PLAN (required for Level Two and Three appllcatJons)
f1' COMPREHENSIVE LANDSCAPE PROGRAM apphcallon, as applicable
-"
,~
,
H, STORMWATER PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (City of Clearwater Design Criteria Manual and
4-202 A.21) ~~rr -:l ,~~ /7G71Dn
/ lJ~~ 0i.-~;J \1/ II--IU
W STOAMWATEA PLAN Inc!udlOg the fonowlng requIrements L.....::;:.J v ~
ExIsting topography extending 50 feet beyond all property lines,
Proposed grading Includmg finrshed floor elevallons 01 all structures, JAN 0 6 2005
All adjacent streets and munICIpal storm systems.
Proposed stormwater detentJon/retentlon area Including top of bank, toe of slope and outlet control structure,
Stormwaler calculallons for attenuation and water quality, f'liLf~". - "'" ",,'I-I"',~ ~ """Jlr-r:.!T
Signature of Flonda regIStered ProfessIonal Engineer on all plans and calculatIOns \l.j J'\j., v W'. ~"f , ",,' "",j"
C1-"" r-" ' C~ ". i\,11'" "1\ "rl")
U;l:i!f "j," l..::;;o~\I~\,,1,.V~~6h"(
o COpy OF PERMIT INQUIRY LETTER OR SOUTHWEST FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT (SWFWMD) PERMIT SUBMITTAL
(SWFWMD approval !s required pnor to Issuance 01 City BUlldlng Perml~), If applicable
o COpy OF STATE AND COUNTY STORMWATER SYSTEM TIE-IN PERMIT APPLICATIONS, II applicable
I. BUILDING ELEVATION PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 4-202 A.23)
Required In the event the application lncludes a development where deSign standards are In Issue (9 g Tourist and Downtown Dlstncts) or as part
of a Comprehensive InflJl Redevelopment Project or a Resldenllallnllll ProJect.
~ ~ILDI NG ELEVATION DRAWINGS - all sides of all bull dings Including height dimenSions. colors and malerlals
~ REDUCED BU!LDING ELEVATIONS - four .sJdes of bUilding wllh colors and materials to scale (8 Y.t X 11) (black and while and coior renderIng, If
possible) as required
J. JIGNAGE: (Division 19. SIGNS I Section 3-1806)
r/ All EXISTING freestanding and attached sIgns; PrOVide photographs and dimensions (area, height, stc). Indicate whether they Will be removed or
to remain
J\,f\lI PROPOSED freestandmg and attached signs, ProVide details mcludmg locallon. Size, height, colors, materials and draWing, freestanding signs
F shall Include the street address (numerals)
~~omprehenslVe SI9n Program application. as applicable (separate applicatIOn and lee reqUlfed),
.~ \ ~educed slgnage proposal (8 1h X 11) (color), If submlttmg ComprehenSive SIgn Program application
Page 5 01 7 - FleXible Development ApplicatIOn - ComprehenSive Inllll Redevelopment proJecl- City 01 Clearwater
" 71~'111;!
11 !.{;.wo
"' rl~14 ~~fJ.
,......~ \'fi. ~ \ J~\J
K. TRAF:~iq IMPACT STUDY' (Se "~~ 4-202.A 13 and 4-801.C) , ' ~~~~It\~' 0 RIG I N A L
1/ pi iPrr"r ..~l' ",,~ 1 ~ .; ~d
Q' I~CIUd~' ~-requlred If proposed developme~1~u degrade the acceptable level of service for a'~;c~d~dway as adopted In the ComprehensIVe Plan
Tnp generatIOn shall be based on the most, recent edition of the Inslltute of Trans ortatlon EnglnEler's Trip General Manual Refer to Sa Uon 4-801
C of the Commumty Development Code fof~xceptlons to thiS requirement ~ c-;;, , '',AtUf' 11tX~&-. r/ "I
<'~ "'IS
L. SIGNATURE:
~~
r. the undersigned, acknowledge that all representations made In this
appllcal10n are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge and
authorlze City representatIves to VISit and photograph the property
described I this appllcallon
r
STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF P1NELLAS )CJ iJ:.
~wprn to find subscnbed belore. me thiS ~ day 01
fi..~I..:~ mnt'r- . AD 20Q::L to me and/or by
ff-'v.. ~ h (. J..M ( 't', 1:' e.. I who Is ("..personarry--kilO'iN(t... has
'produced __ < -- - -- ~ as
Identification
r-
~ ---'\ F}
wQO~~ VL,~
Notary publ1c,
My commission expires L L l' c:'
/ " ::J.-
~ BlI ~ r().','JA Jofr1
DE8RA ANN a\JTLEA
MY COMMISSION t 00 36057&
eXPIRES: A~;~11161 2001
81lt1GM 'f!1f11 Nelll'/ 1liM1~ U~liIl'i/llll!l
EIre & Cl {'INvite)) F"",1/
it" PH PK, ~ ft"',Y/ x &. 7b/r:r.,,~ ({<,Iii) ': 4:L :,11
'* J>AH.j Vul., (10 {):>to," ^ 't1t/rul"1 (f~h) Z 5'" lr!
1~..,f~./ t/'I l-'d..t>lC' In.,,, k r"'fU'~.1 (J6 t~~I~ lz,Jd c.L~ J'ur 2I-otJ Cd! ts f~~I.I
f/ ,10- .,. ft;.
f0: ~ L Ire n~:f;j= iN
U~lb~lS~ V ~U
JAN 06 2005
PLANN~hO D~?i\(rM[!\!T
ell\' OF Cl~A~t^!j~I~R
Page 6 of 7 - FleXIble Development Appllcallon . ComprehenSive lnflll Redevelopment ProJect- City of Clearwater
L I~ l GIN A L
LETTER OF AUTHORIZATIDN
".
This letter wiU serve as authorization for Housh GhOV8e8 with lartbsldl
IallaBlllaD SI.,SltU. to ad as an agent for 0fE ftrrllCtl Ed L'8, I
(Prcperty Owner's Name)
And to execute any and all documents related to securing permits
cia
and approvals for the construction on the property generally located on the
I I J tfIc-mvu..W-
N W caUJ~ 0 a.u . R>' flJ'V f2J.JJd + acorn zoik/ . lying within
(Property Location) ,.- ·
PU"fJI..J-A-& County, State of l-UJ~dA .
~~~
Signature of Property Owner
~+-II CJ::x)'j]f L (' ll~J..; aLl! c1
Address of Property Owner
11 ~ I v f. Z S I rV.. 7 ffU( , 11... 1.3~2.01
City/StatelZlP Code
DPrlI d JJ. J3{iLCfhJ( -rfvSTU
Print Name of Property Owner
"
q 4-1- oSq - 8.303
Telephone Number
:
The foregoing Instrument was acknDwlodge before me this t.i3 day
of r oS 6?/ . 2ad by j)(+Jld 13~, as ~bi1J J
WhD Is ~IY ~ to me or who has produced
8sldentlficaUon and who did (did not) take an oath,
Stall of ~I n '21 ria
County of tYJ fttJ ITftL
RoJS' ~ AlIOlll H Ga)'Wn
;.,,~ ,: MyCommlaslon001S8658
~ 0"".1 ElqJI res Merch 31 2OiJ7 ~
Notary Public
Commission #
(SEAL ABOVE)
(Name of Notary Typed. Prlntod or Stamped)
rctm. ceBi
~' f?C~f?nVPD
~-:) ""'(! ~I~_jl\\ I~ 0
~tb ~U' lb
JAN 06 2005
rev 10118/99
PLAN N ~~ ~::; D[~i\::TMI:NT
C!fV 0;: Cl;:j\R;"~.iATER
C""n;?rJ ?r:"1r-f....1
C"l^C t:1f..I"':i -:I(TTeW [),Inr.J
q~c;j~qbbI71
1~'b1 ~~~~jZ1/G0
JAN 6,2005 10 32AM
(tJ)~~~ ~~/i7~rr D
u\S. !b ~ ~_-:J J 'J l= lS'l
NO 874
p, 2/4--
I
In re: Randall Benderson 1993-1 Trust
under Trust Arrreement PlA.NN~: ~~ D::?~.-:~~,,~ENT
'd dS b ca"ii1!Ol~C~I'"'I'"t"J{\"~n
ate eptem er 22, 1993 au~ {' ~ __, -.;" ,'....., ~.'I:
JAN 06 2005
ORIGINAL
,~
DELEGATION OF TRUST POWERS
AN]) PO'WER OF ATTORNEY
1 On September 22,1993, RANDALL BENDERSON, as Settlor~ executed a
Trust Agreement commonly knO\VD. as the Randall BendersOD 1993-1 Trust (heremafrer
~'Trost") in which he named NATHAN BENTJERSON, RONALD BENTIERSON and
DAVID H. B.A.LDAUF as Tmstees.
? NATIiAN BEN""DERSON has heretofore resigned as a Trustee of me Trust,
leaving the underslgne4 RONALD BENDERSON and DAVID H BArfl~_T~, ~~,"'.::.;;
as the lrusIees of toe Trust.
3. The undersigned have decided that in order to facilitate the unplementatlon
and admimstration oitrust transactions, they shall authorize each Trustee to execute
separately any lIlStruments and to omer'Wlse act pursuant to the terms of the Trust
Agreement in cODllectlou with all trust transactiollS.
Or
Accordingly, intending to be legally bound and in accordance with the proVIsions
of Arhcle NTh'E, Section A, paragraph 15 of the Trust Agreemen~ the undersigned
Trustees hereby authonze each Trusteel for and on behalf of both Trustees, to exerclse
any and all powers granted to the Trustees by law or under the proVlSions of the Trost
Agreement WIth respect to any trust rran-5ilcnO"tl E:J.ch T!l.tS'tee mal" :?ct sepaT.ately
pursuant to this mstrument without the jomder of the otber Trustee and ;:IT1Y t'h;,n ~:l!"1':'
ShaLl be: authonzed to rely upon thls instrument without the consent of the non-act1'r1~
.L ruscee 1 JJ.1~ mscrum.ent snail be considered. a. delegatlOn of trust powers pursuant to the
Trust Agreement and shall be- considered a power of attorney gnmted to the acting
'T"'_.&, t
.... ..... .nn..;:...'fIiI/.....~1
'Flus Delegation and P Ower of Attorney may be T"t"'vn k-f'n "hy eit'J:o e;: ,-,f +"h~
underSlgned at any time, by insnument m ~ntlllg delivered to the other Trustee.
:eN' WTThTESS V!HEREOF) we have hereunto set Our hands and seals effecnve as
of the "7.P~ t1J:l\1l'\f ~~"c".....nl "2001
- -- - ~~--, p - J ~~~
-~ ~ e,q
... , W~tless
\. j--...
~ ~~/4
, WItnesS
~.
-??...;. _ '--"'r/A.. _
....-: .
./ Ronald Benderscn, Trustee A
\ ,f1 ,,., I II
Q.,~ f4 /~ \ (L.S.)
David H Baldauf, Trustee I
(LS)
JAN, 6 2005 10 33AM
- NO 874 -- P 3/4- -- -
STATE OF 1\TE'W YORK
OR\GlNAL
COTJNTY OF FRW
: S,S.
<?,.........1h ../ I
: vn tills"'-u ' day of (CJ)(UMLf ,2001, before me, a Notary Pubbc in
and for the State and county aforesaid1 personally appeared RONALD BE1\1J)ERSON, to
me knO"WD. and knO'W:lJ. to me to be the person mentioned and described in. aTId wnn
;:;h~'-''-'-I.'''': ":':e iu...t~I..i.uIs 1l!s1rurnem, and he duly acknowledged to me that he executed the
t"'~"'I"""IPII~
WItness my hand and seal the day and year aforesard.
A IJ A .I11~ ! w;] ) i.1a .r
q I..fotary P~bc
c:;~~ ;)'F }:\1', ~t i JK&
1~;:ll\CY j~.A:i1 ~ SCAIII
NOTARY PLJSL'S: ST A7i: Or ,\~N YO=t~
R~~ ~,~ j~SC~.oCSt:9
Q~';L;t:'::C [u E~r~ CO\J 'I ~
i\l~. C~~J'", E.S!:t :;:,;iras !\~~I.., 2.J::lLj..
,
CCu1<~7 ..:...:' Di(lc
8,S.
, On this ~~ day of ftbvuMq- , 2001, before me. a Notary "Pn"h li (' WI
a:..:J.1 Lr ilic 5[2.1:e ana. county arores3.1~ petsonally appeared DA VID H BALDAUF, to me
knuwn and bo\VU to me to be the person mentioned and descnbed in, and who executed
the foregOIng instroment, and he duly acknowledged to me that he executed the same
WItness my hmd and seal the day and year aforesaid,
! h . 1>. 11 Ii A 14 44", IJ,....
,q, A"O N~~~~ibliC I
~lECJ:~VED
JAN 0 6 2005
11;,11; -~ ... ~ I'bI +--''-.It I ........
~ -....,~ ......... t I ..,... ~..f -, t.L.....J
,
.. ..... ~ ~ l
~ ...1"_ j .._
PLANN~~6 D[fAr'{lM~NT
... C' ""A In' HI\\':j'Ir.:P)
,erN Or ~IQ i!t'\ 1.'\1."'"i:B".
-([)d
n<:(' 1",';-'H "
JAN 6 2005 111 33Mv\
- - ~-
-NO 874 u P 4/4-
In re: Randall Benderson 1 QQ~ 1 T,..",,-f
under Trust A I7rpp.m':-'nf
- dated September 22,1993
ORIGINAL
RESIGNATION O:B: !~rrC;:'l'1i'l?
:, On September 22, 1993, RANDALL BENDERSON, as Settlor, executed a Trust
Agreement commonly known as the Randall Benderson 1993-1 Trost (heremafter
.'Trust") in wmch he named NATHAN BENDERSON, RONALD BENDERSON and
DA vio H. RAT n,A T_lJ::" ~': T:-::"'~:.,;=.
: WHEREAS, Secnon D of ARTICLE EIGHT ofth.e Trust Agreement provides that
a Trustee is authorized to resign at any time and for any reason bv an acknowle(lg,:"d"
",""""';:4......- -~ ----J. J .. 'l~"
"L!..~............J. ......!................~,Ir,....ti~ .;Jl....J.
"WHEREAS, NATHAN BENDERSON desires to resign as a Trustee oftbe said
Trust.
NOW, THEREFORE, intendmg to be legally bOUIld, I, NATHAN BENDERSON,
hereby,reslgD. as a Trustee of the Trust effective Immediately, and agree to funnsh notice
as required by the Trust Agreement.
"
~ VrITNESS iN1ffiREOF, I have bereunto set my hand and seal effectlve as of
the ~ day of rl".W{Ul rV __, 2001
,: I bl
i)iJiu"/rIJ//(/;:'-- ~~ ~'-R-S)
WJ.tness \ Nathan Benderson
"
Sworn to and subscnbed
berore me thisJlo <.Aday
ofFe~(M rv' ,200L
,
('II " 11 \/,,"~
.....y{JJf~ h, ~(iOJ? Y.sk
No Public
I
SHERRY A. KEKLAK
NOTMY PUBliC, STAn;: OF NEW YORX
REG No 01KE601349,!!
DSC 764413.211 QUALIFIED IN EPJE COUNTY
My CO"'Jl1 ts;!on E,;pJ~a J 6 n ~QI}' 11 J 2O.Q.3
~
to .,
'\
MAY lb IUU~ Ub~~
- (1~t .r
'\ B6
P 5
I-
I'
" ; ).
eS-1Si7a~ HA~- 7-1989 5'e~
PINELL~; CO BK leso! PG lorB
liUllllllml!Ill ml m DI UlI Illn
ORfGINAL
" ,
" \
")0
",
~ "
1 /'j;1COOOWi'.l
R!:C l!E..@
tfIl::1;.&r,..U.1 tLl
08 II
-
lNT .......:....._ -~A
~ _ THIS INDEN'I'CRE, 'made and executed this ~ day of May,
eM! -"' _19 9 9, J:ly KBRLE F. AKIC and nOLo:aES !JI:l:C, husban4, ana. vif 8,
--;. ~harainafter ca.lle.d the qrantor, to 0-3 :USOCIA~ES, & Raw York
~~" ~ qelleJ!al pa.r1;Jl,.a%ship, a. tWilnts in ClommOD vl'th an lU:uSiviced
;'lEv -- 65.12.31' b.tQl:eat~ n'mU BBJiDEJ,SO!I~ 1I.0NU.D ButlIRB:ON 5: ~a.VID H.
- , 'B1.LtIADJ', ... 'rns.tees un4e.t' 'Z'rust 1qreaent datel! Septemtlar 22,
TOitul'Ar~~13 DOWU a. the ~ BEND'DSOB .1i13-1 'rRUST, a.s teJI.ant in
llllll.Cl!l. with an \U14ivi4ec! U .87U% interest and W1l-I ASSOQU'rSS,
, 1'D., a. rtorieS&. limit&a partnership, 11.8 tenant in oommon. with an
un4ivi4ac! ~O% inte:ost, whose ~ost office address is 2555
Enterprise Road, Su1~a& 14 and 15, Clearwater, Florida 33763-
1118, her.inaftar called ~e grantee:
1lARRA!ITYD'SZD
I J t!' ~I
~ ~ ~ :
,I" '!I 'Ii
'I'"l1!: r. ~
.... "i- ! -
.:!>--:i <f ~
--' " ..)
,~ ,t~
"1 '.I:~
j . Js.
... .
j ~,
~ r-,
J "
..
(Whereva:r used hB1:ein the terns "grantorll and lIgranteatl
include all the parties to this inst'l:U1l\ent and the heirs,
legal representatives and aasiqn~ ot individuals, and tha
successors and ~ssiqns of corporations)
WITNESSETH; That said qrantor, for and in ccml1daration of
the sum of Ten and no/l00 ($10.00) Dollars, and other good and
valuable considerations to said grantor in hand paid by said
;rant.., the reoeipt whereof is hereby aCknOWledged, hereby
qrants, bargains, sells, aliens, ram1~&s, releases, conveys and
confirms unto the said Grantee all that certain land situate in
PINELLAS,county, Florida, to-wit:
. "
SEB EXHIBIT "A" lL'l'l'ACDD XDE'l'O AND HADE A 1"Aa'l' BEtula!'
stJBmc![' '1'0 OOVEllAH'lS, RJ!lS'l'RIC~'IOllS, JUlSE3VU'IO!l"S NlD
EASEJo1B1f'rB LIS!t'ED CJN UHIB'I'l' "all A'I!'l'ACKED BUETO UD !l!J.XES
P'01l. 'I!D 'YBAR. .1999 AND ALL StfllSIQUBN'I' 'YEnS.
TOGE~RER wi~h all tha tenements, bereditament and
appurtenanoes thereto belonqing or in anywise appertaininq.
'.1:0 HAVE AND TO HOLD, the same in fee simple forever.
~he property eppra~ear parcel identification numbAr of ~h&
proparty is 16/29/1~/00000/~30/0200 & e300t and said grantor
hereby covenant W.1.th said ';ran't... 'that the qrantors are lawfully
seized of said land in fee simple; that the grantors have good
riqbt and lawful authority to sell and convey said land, and
hereby warrant the title to said land and will defend SBES
against the cla~~ o~.all persons whomsoever, and that said land
Q frs8 of all encUNbranceB.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has caused these presents to AS
f-
PREPARED BY AND RE~naH ~Ol
Willi~ J. Kimpton, Saqu1re
KIMP~ON, BUlIXE, WH~~B & REIDSNj P.A.
28059 a,8. Bighway ~9 North, SUite leo
Clearwater, ~ 33761
h~(i! ,a., j~ i17 ).')r.
Cl I:IWfOiN..:
.. Tk tl\1 (.:.
\l\li~~,,,~ ...~ ~f<l.,.
11:'. ;i;.l1 - n"~l i
,1U:un~ I1..LS
L" u.. '.. ti.
m :~
.1~1 ;..1 .,
it ,~
[Q~C~uV~[)
1Dln!. t "'h.,'1",,1 :PI dt.l, 1'I.11i h.~I~:r~, lll,.171 II ~4'
Q\'",,::r, .'
JAN 0 6 2005
PlAi\lK~;~G DfPP :rMfNT
CI'N Or Cl~;{,:J,"Jr;R
M~V 26,2004 8 36PM -
"
"236 -P 6
f1INE'llRS C:CUNTY rL.JI
orr R[C,e~ IO,os fiG 1011
ORtGINAL
in 1:htJir nUla$ the da and year firlit al:love. written.
l~_L '7 12.__
M::C /:"'_
.. 7W4.~ =us >xzc ~
a9.'1'1 OJ' PL01l%DA
COtni'rY OJ' 1lJ:JOUoLU
'l'ha for.gainq i:t'lStrul'Ilent VIIS acknowledgad hafore me this 3th
: dt.y of Kay, ~9, by XDL!l ,. ~c &n4 DOLOltE8 loXIa, hus:buA anI!
,I rife, who (0 ara par.anally Jml:Xln to ma or ( ) have pro4uoe;i
drivers' licenses as identification and who ( ) did or (~d1a
not talc. an oath.
My Commission Expires:
~~~~
~\I\\\lIIII'/ff'/J,:
I2r~.~!t.~~
>>ION '..
11?1~(\\
~"i\ ~\4 ,i.-
~,~~..
.011I....".. ~
l 1~lrJ~
",
~IEC lr: ~ViE ID
JAN 0 P 2a05
PlANNDNG D!E?JA[trMfNT
CITY O~ CLE/\l~WAV::R
MAY, 26 2004 8 36P/I!
') 236
FINELLA! COUNTY FLA
orr RtC,eK 105O! pa 1012
ORIGINAL
i'AACEL 1,
II
::rh4 lleuth 1/2. of the S10utbuat 1/4: o~ thll iOUthwllllC 1/4. Q~ the North_It 1/4 Ilf ..&fIClt~Co.
1~, '1!llwn1l1up :.Ill l::lml:h, lll\llgn 11: \{;\DI:, 111noll/UI Counl:y, n;lJ:it!ll.. loaa that PII.:I: tho;,o...!!
lying Iwith:LU tl:la riShl:-of -WilY of Statll 1loA4 60, IJld lelul tha 8alltn .:l7D "lOt; at ~ .ltl!l...t
300 feat thereof, and. 111I&11 the ElI.lIt 33 t:aac and, t.hc !feet 30 het tl1uccf <fOX' euael:..ll.
ALSO, LotB 18 to 33, inclusivlIl, in Block 1 of Bayviow te~ece, acco~=~ to the plat '
thcraOf recorded ill. Plac. Book 12, Pas. n, pWllic ;'ilCOm. of JiMl1u COIml:y. Fla:ddA. d
Lot 1 of Kij or' B I4r.n01:', a.~riin.g to the plat thUecf n;co:4.4 1n Pat Book 31'1, Pas' 14.,
pubUliI roeorda of imll... COW1l:.Y. I'lo:ricl&/ tOgeeha% 'With VLClllted c&%oli.Jl.a St:r:cet abuteing
all of n1d 10'Cs OJ:!, the South.
LiSS and ZXCUPT thes, p~tc ther'of descrihod in Order! of ~aking rccordlld in O.R. ~ook
68&0, Jjlll.!ilo :l3'11. O,R. Book '7041., pago 1.238. amS. 0,11. Dock 7.:l.:l.:l, pago 210'1, of thl:l publ.:Li:
r.cords of p1n.~lal County, Flor~d&,
iUcEL 2. I
Th. 50llth 270.00 foot of t:hlt .a:.at: :I 00.00 foot of Us South :a./2. ef tbo SO\.:Lt:hout: 1/4 cf thl
sou~hwas~ 1/4 of ~ North,o.t ~/, of Section 15. Townab1~ 2' Sou(h, R~ 16 KLSt:,
p:l.nIlU'!'I toWlty, llouda, ,
waS ,I~ UCEi'T the South tiO, 00 fellt tWllof for tight-of-way for Gult'-tg-BlIoY ioulevard
19t.~i' Road No. SOl,
.>>m 1J!ISS .un 1rJtCE,n the Rut 31.00 feet thanof fer rieht-llf.way fer BWS.lI Rod (State
Roadl snJ .
>>lD ,!.1l;BS _IS DCBP'J: t:hac pa.rt of the. p&'oP~Y t:aken by coo.denmatioD by the tlllpartll\cnt ot
'r:z:~rt.t1C1Jl, of ehe at:.aea 0:1: Plorlda &II lilt. f=tb in ~O=IlJ: of orllkU1v" dat.4 July 12,
15189 lUld 10. ur~ Ju~t u t;l t'lU'liIo1 131, Wcllfod c:o~cn:atieJ:l, an4 llunfaS'4, :tnc, n
dal:.ad Se:pte=ar 2d', 1 PI 9, in ~c aedOZl io..t.ituta4 1n tbft e;:I.S'cuit e;ow:t of the s:Ucrh
J\l.dieial Ci:r;c\l1t il:l. and. fo'l: iinallu e;;lWl.ty, StaU of 1'1orida, Civil D1vill':l.o=., e..1iJ1!l No.
1'."05-19 .n4 rlle~d :I.~ O.R. Doo~ '1041, p.ge 1242, &D4 in O.X. look 7095, pag. 1525,
n~.Clt1valy of t~ pub1:l.c S'OoClxdA of JiI,l.nellu (:Wft.t:y. 'lotil1a.
4 t;. '110
)Jfl) ILESS u-t part: ot: l:.ha proputy cuea. by COMIIlIM.l::l.OI1 ':i'/ iinelllUl COW1t:y all IUIt: tor~ll,
in "st::l.p.ll&t:cl! J:LDal Ju~t ;u 'oro iarcal NQlil'. 100 .Ii. '1Un \.\aced JWl.C 27, USlO :i.ll. the.
aetioo. ilUtituted in t:ho 1::l.xouit Cow:t for 1:l.llOeU&& t:ounty, plod.4a. CU'l:luit Civi~ No
8:8-U17S-:aO,
~~a~u'j~D
EXHIBIT A
JAN 0 6 2005
PlANN~NG D1ErJ~RIM~NT
ellV Or Cl~ARWATH~
MAY, 16 20U4 H:j6~M
~u {j 6 ~ H
PIHr~~s CQUNTV r~
orr,Rtc BK lOSQS FG 1013
Exhibit "B"
ORIGINAL
Reservanons of road rights of way In favor of the State ot'Florid, as set forth m
deed fro the Trustees of the Internal Improv!ID.ent Fund. recorded in Deed Book
892. page 401, (As to parcels 1 and 2)
Easement in favor ofFlonda Power Corporation as recorded in O.R, Book 3303.
page 51S. Pubhc Records ofPinellas County. Florida. (As to parce12)
"
Easement in favor of PiDeUas County set forth in instrument recorded m 0 R Book
6860, page 2371. Publtc Records ofPineUas County. Florida.
-.
~[fClT:;~V[fD
JAN 0 6 Z005
PLANMNG DfPA :<TMENT
CITY OF ClEARt~.~~II:R
r,
EXHIBIT B
"
M. AFFIDAVIT TO ,fJJTHORIZE AGENT:
ORIGINAL
(Namu of AU. propany OWt\811 en died - pliUS PRINT full names)
<.,
1. That (I amiWe 81.) the cymer{a) and rGCCIta title hclJdar(s) ol1hQ tgIJlNIing rJilI5etltlacl proplll''l)' (llddres& or seMrallocatlcn).
1i8--'!, R:hOCJ1+rE...S j Ijtttldp.L-L- AbJrlE2J:,otJ J'I93-} -riU6r i tJ~~r ~jOCJ.ATtS, J...TJ.
of~Lj.t.fJ ca:J?fL ('2~tL ~d'J llN\"~2.<..n1j }?R"U I t=L .~4z.o1 J
'PWPtlJ1.j: .,..luJ CO~u.. 0{ Gilll- rO;BRV1jwd ~ rlJe.mvw-uJ ~ "Boom ?d.) C.L~fffC.lt -PlfJtu.A5
.2. ThalINa plOPWty CQl'\4tltUl8a 1he propaJ'ly to( which a reque11 far a: (descllbe reqlJ85t) CJ)JtJry, 'R...--
3. 1llallhe undGraIlF'1lcI u-llllVi) appointllcl and (do"'"') appoint ~(;> (/.6 I-, fu17 "'- e" -P 'l- ::b ,--+ '1'1 "'" Ide.
( - I
" ..,p,f ~, ~ <. 'pc - .
BtPJ fJ8tltloM or other documents na~SliIWY 10 affad such pe~Pcn;
S. Thal1NG aflldaviI /1U been em:uted 10 lndl.lL':ll tha City gf ClowwalElr, Florida to consider 8l1rJ act en Ihlll abo....a dsscribad prcptirty;
4. 1Nt the applicant ~g8& Vvu eJllmplG't la. (pSlb IftCf ra~Pn, traffic, etI:..) wUl ba paid PAIOR to the lseuance 01 a building perm!!,
canw:caIa crt ~. or other mldmnlsrn. YItlIeh8v8t' OCCUIS IrBt
I .
5, Tbai: ill8 WilCl tg.... property we necasaary by Clb' I'liIpl'8llentmlveall} ordet to procese thla appDcaUon &nO the owner aIJ1hollzBS City <.
rllpn:lW1lalfvllI to vila and phoIogmph lJ'le prapertY described 10 1hla appllcatlon;
.
8. lhaI tVwe). the undelalgned aulttortt)!, haraby osrtily 1I18t!hEII forlilgolng Is trull and co!,ect.
Property Owner
~[C[JV~D
JAN 0 b 200~
F'roperty Ownar
propartj OWnar
PlANN~NG D~PAl!!\fENT
, <rr-R STATE OF FLORIDA.
C~'N OF Cl:EA~t':Jr;.;~.;: COUNlY OF P1NaLAS roANAi""U,.
SftIta InQ tI\a undar1I;nDCl. an offlc8/' duly comml8signlld by !he- . of U1s 5~tQ r F19'fda, on lhIfJ '2 }7S day of
ofePr' . ~ peROMDYlIIlplW&d" -:r.AJlrt-'d. 1:>_e&i:: ~t whohavtngbilenflfSldlJlyswcm
~I and ~ ~ hllly undennands 11'1_ ~Ili alIM IIffiQavlt that she signed.
bA'I CammlBaIon E:t.plras;
"
",.., ~~ AliCIa H GII~
i ~ ' MyCommlsslon 00198658
'1"-'/.0,....1 E"llIIU March J 1 2Q(J1
&
n(lO
OG
cnJcn '::J.~~--1
~....,^~ t'tH:J ':l(TT<:CW I ~n,,1
q~I;;HNbbI71
Ib bT b~~7171/b0
ORIGINAL
Revised Exhibit" A" to Flexible Development Application
Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project
3070 Gulf-to-Bay Blvd - Fairfield Inn - Comfort Suites - NES Project #0463
Description of Requests:
To construct an addItional hotel building on SIte with 55 rooms bringmg the total number
of hotel rooms on SIte 182 with a reduction to the requIred front yard setback (sout4 along
Gulf-to-Bay Blvd) from 25' to 15' to pavement and to allow direct access to a major
arterial street and a request to Increase maximum allowable height from 50' to 48.33'
* At the same time thIS applicatIon IS being processed, a request for vacatIOn of nghts-of-
way IS being processed through the CIty'S Engmeering Department for a portIOn of Bay
Street and for the 16' foot alley at the northern SIde of the site which would allow for the
total number of rooms on site being requested
Written Submittal Requirements:
}, The proposed development will be in harmony with surroundmg propertIes as
this property is located on a heavIly trafficked commercial corridor and the lot area bemg
added to the SIte as a result of the proposed vacatIons of rights-of-way will provide ample
lot area for the proposal The request contained herein to allow direct access to a major
arterial street IS a "technical" request due to the fact that the access already exists for the
eXIsting FaIrfield building on site. There IS no other <"frontage road" available for access
and the vehIcles entering this site would be commg from the major corridors anyway,
2 Actually, the proposal should only encourage the development of adjacent lands
and surrounding uses as this hotel will provide for additional space for tounsts and
busmess travelers which in turn will benefit busmesses WIthin the immedIate area and the
City of Clearwater as a whole. More than adequate on-site parking IS bemg provIded as
well as on-site retentIon and landscaping.
3 The proposed development will not adversely affect the health or safety of
persons within the immediate area as the proposed overmght accommodation use already
exists on site, no additional curb-cuts are being proposed and all visibIlIty triangles are
being observed
4. The proposed development WIll not create a traffic congestIOn problem
AddItional on~site parkIng is being created and an additional drop-off area is beIng
provIded for the proposed buildmg so as to keep vehicles and people moving flUIdly. No
addItional curb cuts are being created as a result of this proposal and the Traffic
Engineering Dept has SIgned a statement regarding thIS proposal not creatmg a need for a
Traffic Impact Study,
@~r[l"~\\ Il?~
5, The proposed development is consistent with the character of the adjacentU;~ ~ ~ ~ \; L; t1Jf
corridor and is only a small addition to an eXIstmg use, The new hotel building will
JAN 0 6 2005
PIJ\I\~N[ ~~ D[;;~,::ir~\,q;::\!T
C!Ne:: Cfif"{i~ "f'-":~
D 0Wi'-lt ........ ....., J .':'::;jt'\
OR\G1NAL
function as a part of the existing hotel use and will share the existing on-site pool, solid
waste disposal, etc.
6. No adverse impacts are anticIpated to adjacent SItes as a result ofthts request.
The proposal IS for an additional 55 rooms of the same nature of what already eXists on
Site, Hours of operation win be the same as the eXlstmg use and areas of activity face
mward to the site (entry doors/park1Og area) in heu of facing adjacent sites.
Comprehensive InfiIl Redevelopment Project Criteria
1. The only reduction being requested here IS to the pavement from the front
property line along Gulf-to-Bay. All other setback reqwrements are being met and the
reduction being requested is for a 15' setback to pavement m lieu of25' This 15'
setback IS allowed through the Flexible Development process. This 15' will still allow
for required landscaping and will not adversely impact the adjacent comdor or
sUlToWlding sites. The proposed building IS only 4 stories 10 height whereas the
previously approved Fairfield is 5 stories in height.
2 Per the Pmellas COWlty Property Appratser's office, the subject site has an
existmg Just Market Value of $5,400,000.00 Upon completion of the proposed project It
is estimated that the site Will be worth approximately $7.500.000,00.
3. Overnight accommodatIOn uses are permitted within the City of Clearwater and
Wlthm the Commercial Zomng District.
4. The proposed additional increase 10 rooms to the existmg overnight
accommodation use IS compatible with adjacent sites and commercial uses, The property
is located at the intersectIon of two major commercial corridors and will be a convenient
location for busmess people staying in town for business use as well as tourists.
5 This particular location is prime for the proposed use as an overnight
accommodation use already exists on site, the proposed vacation of rights-of~way Wlll
provide adequate lot area for the additional units and the sites' locatIon being at the
intersection of two heavily trafficked corridors would be hard to find available anywhere
else Within the City.
6 The proposed project can only serve to upgrade the immediate area. Busmesses
Wlthm the vICmity should only want to upgrade their properties in order to attract users of
the overnIght accommodation use,
7. The design of the proposed building will be a welcome addition to the Gulf-to-
Bay corridor and Wlll fit right in with the eXistIng Fairfield Inn structure already approved
by CDB,
8 Flexiblhty in regards to the front setback of 15' to pavement is justifil~b~~I-~~;,an~ 1;= ~\\ flrr
adequate landscape buffer along the Gulf~to-Bay comdor Will still be provld~ctl@..d~ t.: U \? lc: D
JAN 06 2005
PlANNL:'~(J D!::Pt~. ~7'M!ENT
CluV ere: C" '" 4 'y, 'r-~\"'
~ i r ~ 61E.,';"lIlr'i l \.IM)~J ~R
ORIGINAL
additional rooms are meetmg a need witlun the City of Clearwater for quality overnight
accommodations close to the downtown area The requested front setback reduction to
pavement will allow for a building that is under the maximum allowable height and that
wIll not create a greater buIldmg coverage for the SIte Less budding coverage allows for
landscapmg and adequate parking By meetmg the front setback reqwrement to
pavement we would either have to provide a much smaller building with even less units
which would make the project financIally non-viable or we would have to ask for a
parktng variance which is not desirable for a hotel use, With the proposed budding
footprint and setbacks to pavement, all required on-sIte parking can be provided with a
few additIOnal spaces. The trimming back of the additional parkIng spaces would not
alleviate the proposed front setback reduction and the required 15' landscape buffer is
being provided. Not all travelers wish to spend the extra money to stay at hotels on the
beaches and prefer to be close to downtown busmesses and commerclal corridors for ease
in reaching various destinatiOns
9 All required parking and plus 1 0 additIOnal spaces IS being provided on-site wrth
the proposed development
10 Not applicable,
"V,
~~C[2~VED
JAN 0 6 2005
PlA.\\1Ni~'~G DIEPA:1."rMENT
A Fl' ~ i 1\ '"fi"'ff')
erN Of Cl&"!J'i.tv,,...l~1":
i
i I I I
, I '
I r~ .;r
I I I
I I
,
I
,
I
,
I
J I
I
I
i I
I I
II~ I
!~
~\ \
~~!
.....~,
~I
"I" i \,
I
I
,
I
,
~I
,
I
~~ l
t i
, j
)
I
I
'" ~
,
I
,P
(
~~tEClE~V[ED
JAN 06 2005
\,1
I Wrl'
,
I
Lh_
.
~ ,lL
J~~n-
I 'r--
f) 1-
Ifl 'II
I I li I I
) I( 'IlL.
I I : f I
I I r
II
I I
r I I
III
1 ,I'D
I Ii
I \.
III ' ",
I '~~~~~~~- :- ~ -
r >//:l/~Y~-~;-
/ / r- _J!>~~_
---"~ /
( (
!" I
I ~I
I I
L_ t~------~-
I ...,....-'" ,f'~""'f'- "'"
/
"'-
""
--~-~~ ~ -~~~ ----~~~- ~
...
..
-- ~~~ ~-~- - ~ ~~---~ -- -- ~
+
-- ----,--------- .- - ----
\
JR\G\NAL
~GMULLlN-BOOTH ROAD
;0 --- -l--iw v_---~-It-
J
,\,d
I 1
I I
I
~fEC[~VrE[D
JAN 0 6 2005
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CI~ I)f ClEARwi.\TlER L
0...
Ira Ira
!
J
J
"'0
-
...
...
...
...
...
(
ORiGINAL
McMULL N-BOOTH ROAD
-... ~ .. '" - .. '" - - --- (ILt'N VAIlIIID
FDL2004-1108l
3070 Gulf To Bay Blvd
URIGINAL
7' H X 6'W x 2'D
3'Hx3'Wxl'D
3'H X 3'W x lID
~,
JAN 0 b 2005
11..1'" I.
':11
'I T
Iill
[;J
cp r Ii
~~
.~ r
~
~ II
r
~
=;Jl
II l>
I, 7
'.
,I
II
IL_ __
cp
l"
-~
'OJ
~
2
;II
;JI
~
~..-t-.,. r"L
oo~1 oo~1
rn
~~tJ i~! "'0'"
[ID 10..,,,,
a::<z
'O"""
~ ~i'i S~g
C> ~ _t'l2:
. 0,:2:
! ",...,l
~ - PROPOSED HOTEL 88 ~ ..'.' '..' '~,
~ MCMULLEN BOOTH AND GULF TO BAY 'G ~ I.~"" ~""",.,...,,,,,,,,,
r; CLEARWATER R...ORlDA -
ill
~ COMFORT SUITES B
111!!lli
lj: l!'l'll
I,. '111
'j <; Il~!
II" 1111
J 'II
11 111'1
(, -i=
\ 1-
t:.J
I[}
Q)
H:
II
11
;~
n
r
<l
~
II
L-_~_-
I! ~~~~~ ~-
~
,1 ~~~ ill
jj ~5'" is
;: -<"ill ,\)
~ 1<:0 ,l!
~. _""Z ~
Z""-
~ "'....
$
:~
i"
<l
<l
~
,
~
oo~1
oo~1
rn
PROPOSED HOTEL 8~
MCMULLEN BOO111 AND GULF TO BAY 'fl ill
CLEARWATER F'LOAIDA
. .. COMFORT SUTES B
D! j fl , , 'I 1!1!11 .
~ ~" ~-,
, ~ l~ jl,I<I .M ~f'Ol~~ !! .
I! ~ i!jll -
;
I. . I!!I
'I ~ 01
II - \If
ii!:l
I!
I
~~[J
[ s -I
~ I I , I
".< I I Ii II I !
:~
! ~ I ! II Ii
m II
,-
In
~
~
~
I I v
II ~ I
I~II
II I I
I I
: : ;; ;1 : J I
~ h~~~~
h \, ~ ri~ ~~ )~ ~ ~ ~
ffl ~ [} . ~I!~~~\W
l!J LJ LJ ~"'" ~
ill! 0"''''
~~~"a;;ja
..,...- . ~. Sib!::1
_ ... ~ ..('U",
. '-' - ~. ;':0
. - ~~ 'Z '" '"
C> i n~
~
ttl-
~
2
'"
-.,
!hliiljll
I!~ .il'!
'II" !ll!!
!II!
!l ll! j!
i\ ;,! &~
~IIJ! '
Ii I! !
'! II
!
o
n~v~ ~~ ~nVB 'V~
n h Ii ; u; II I
Ii ij ;! un Ii
~ ! j I~n !
I ; i~i~
I
~
o
o
88 '"'' "
PROPOSED HOTEL ~ " .. .....,
MCMULLEN 80011-1 AND GULF TO 8,1, Y '" ] - , . ~" ..:!:!... .',,,,,,, """'"''''''
CLEARWATER FLORIDA
, 'COMFORT SUITES 8
II Iii!!'
'I' ~"ll
1- il'!
f ~ 'llll
'I;; .lli
II" hIll
III ii::,
, 1'1
,
~z
~~
, t
In
,-
m
~
9
I
I I
l
jl
II
,
~-'-"-II
II I I
.111' II l I
H ~~ li~ ~~ H ~ ~ tl
rflMr:l
liJ~u ~~ 8~r:1
[ID ~11l:t:ii3
:l> . b ~S;ti
_.... ~"""O",
1_- ;:: 1<:0
- . ~~ _"'Z
C> j"if:'i
I ,
Wllin H 'if ~ ~n~ ~
,II 'Ii,' ill i ~ ~ & ~ ! ~ ~ - I " - 5 lA ~
. 0 !, I!' m ;i i Ii i II I
JI!!!l!l i i! I, U!! Ii
II !H~ !! un!
Illl! I t U ~ i >
IjllP i
.1 I! !
I
EB
z
Hl
<1 '
~ll
~~
o
O'!! "i
o
o
. t' i I II 11!!I! :
~ ~" . -~
, I ~II!I~ J'1 li'aDf'E!i!11Q'.tJTI~"l 11
Ij z i!ll!
J, ~ II !\
'I " Ilij
r lIlt
II jl;'!
j' III
- 1- ,
. PROPOSED HOTEL 88
MCMUllEN ElOO~ AND GULF TO BAY III ill
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA .
, COMFORT SUTES G
I
~ J:: r..
c'
. ~
~-
"
I ~--
I '" '- "'
1- .:
1- "
1- _
I ~- ~
I
-'
~ ~ ~ ~~~~~!
l!J LJ lJ ~i 8~;
[ID 8il ~"'t:l
..-- :: i~ ~~~
c.u - ~ - Ill:o
C::> ~ ;9 ~~z
~~ 'PRoPOSED HOlEl..
YCt.U..I..f:N BOOTH AN) CJ.LF 10 BAY
<J a..EAflWA TBI. R...ORDA
'"
In
~ /' . , ]
'" COMFORT SUITES
~
88
G
,< -
&& "lJ "'\----): ~)___"~ "': ,..,
-...
''"
;;;
'"
~
2
EB
f "
~ 0
o
.it.., R. ~ 1 ,.... I' I
~ ... - - ,
, -.. ,It """'.......,....... I .
I I
I
I
I~ I
OR1GIN~\L
Tree Inventory
Fairfield Inn Site
As reqUITed by the City of Clearwater Community Development Code, I have completed an
assessment of all trees (8" dbh or greater) on the subject site and within 25' beyond the property
hnes,
My opinion is set forth below as to the viability (ratmg of 1-5) and potential hazards of these
trees.
Ratmg Scale 1 through 5 (l -= poor, 5 -= excellent)
#
Ra-
d th
Tree Size & Species tmg an 0 er uertment comments
1 13" W ashingtoma Rating = 4
2 13" Washingtonia Ratmg == 4
3 13" W ashingtonia RatIng -= 4
4 31" Live Oak Rating == 3, two foot tree well, thinning
5 23" & 31" Twin Rating = 3, thinning, mechanical damage to branch over
Live Oak driveway
6 8" Laurel Oak RatIng = 4, good structure
7 15" Washingtoma Rating = 4
8 19" Washingtoma Rating = 4
9 21" W ashingtonia RatIng = 4
10 18" Washingtonia Rating = 4
11 22" Washingtonia Rating = 4
12 14" Washingtonia Rating = 4
~
13 26" Canary Island Rating = 3
Date Palm
14 26" Canary Island Rating = 3
Date Palm
15 16" Waslungtonia Rating = 3
16 15"Washingtonia Rating = 4
1
Ok\G\NAL
17 20" Washingtonia RatIng = 4
18 MultI-stem Rating:= 4
Reclmata
19 Multi-stem RatIng = 4
Reclinata
20 26" Slash Pine Rating"'" 4, slight mechanical damage
21 MultI-stem Rating = 4
Reclinata
22 Multi-stem Rating = 4
Reclinata
23 20" Slash Pine Rating = 4
24 12" Washmgtonia Rating = 3
25 II' Washingtonia Rating - 3
26 13"Washangtonia RatIng = 3
27 23" Live Oak Rating - 3, thinning, poor branching, railroad spike In trunk
28 1 0" W ashingtonia Rating = 3
29 12" Washingtonia RatIng = 3, thin
30 11" Washmgtonia Rating - 3
31 11" W ashmgtonia Ratlng - 3
32 II" Washingtoma Rating = 3, thin
33 12" Washingtonia Rating = 3
34 12" Washingtonia Rating - 3
35 11"Washingtonia Rating - 3, thIn
36 12" Washingtonia. Rating = 4
37 8" Washingtonia Rating = 3, thin
38 11"Washingtonia Rating - 3
39 II" W ashiDgtonia RatIng = 3
40 11" W ashingtonia Rating = 3
2
ORIGINAL
41 10" W ashingtonia Rating == 3, thin
I
42 II"Washingtonia Rating == 3
43 29" Laurel Oak Rating = 4, well-branched
44 13" Sabat Rating = 3
45 12" W ashingtonia Rating = 4
46 12" Washingtonia RatinJ;!; = 4
47 12" Washingtonia Rating = 3
48 13" W ashingtonia Rating = 4
49 12" Washingtonia Rating = 4
50 14" W ashingtonia Rating = 4
51 27" Laurel Oak Ratin1Z. = 4, well-branched
52 21" Laurel Oak Rating = 4, well-branched
53 24" Laurel Oak Rating 4, slight surface root . e, slight decay
54 20" Laurel Oak Rating = 3, old mechanical damage to trunk, slight decay and
die-back
55 26" Laurel Oak Rating = 4, slight die-back
56 23" Laurel Oak Rating = 3, poorly pruned, slight die-back
57 24" Laurel Oak Rating = 3, decavand dIe-back
58 27" Laurel Oak Rating = 3, trunk cavities, needs oruning, has cross branching
59 , 20" Laurel Oak RatinR = 3, slight decay
60 11" W ashmgtonia Rating = 4
61 11" W ashingtonia Rating = 4
62 11" W ashmgtonia Rating = 4
63 12" Washingtonia RatmJ2: = 4
64 11" W ashingtonia Rating = 4
65 10" Washingtonia Rating"'" 4
66 11 " W ashingtonia Rating = 4
67 ' 8" Saba! Rating = 4
68 12" Saba! Rating =" 4
69 9" & 11" Live Oak Rating c::; 2, potential hazard, severe lean
70 17" Live Oak: - . 3, poor branching, co-dominant
~
71 18" Laurel Oak - . 3
72 18" Laurel Oak: Rating = 4, cavity at base
73 24" Live Oak: Rating = 3, poor branching
74 11" Laurel Oak Rating = 3, crowded, trunk decay
75 17" Live Oak Rating = 4, die-back, deadwood needs prumng
76 20" Laurel Oak Rating = 3, crowded, one-sided
77 1 T' Live Oak Rating = 3, one-sided
78 13"VVasbrnngto~a Rating = 3
3
OR\G\NAl
79 17" Live Oak Rating = 3, mechamcal root damage, co-dominant, sigruficant
deadwood
80 13" & 14" Live Oak Rating = 3, twm, co-dommant, crowded, poor branching,
one-sided
81 29" Live Oak Rating::= 4, mechanical root damage
82 20" & 23" Live Oak Rating = 2, co-dominant, thmmnl!, potential hazard
I affinn that my opinions have been made in good faith, with no coercion from others. I further
affirm that I have no interest with the parties or people mvolved with neither this issue nor any
interest with regard to the outcome.
Sincerely,
~43~
Chuck Butler, Certified Arborist
Certificate #FL-1235A
Butler's Nursery, Inc.
7011 7Slb Street North
Pinellas Park, Florida 33781
(727) 544-0445 - phone
(727) 541-5027 - fax
4
Nonhsille
;1-'ll, . t! . .,
~~M1UWif:' ~e~Jltl)Zi! liute.
ORIGINAL
(IVII. .
LAND PLANNiI''lCJ .
::NVIRON!v\ENTA.l .
TRA~~5PORTA:ICl'-i .
STORMWATER REPORT
FOR:
COMFORT SUITES
PROJECT
[)) ~ r jC? r~ /lr~ n
u\f:~~lS; II \~/ ~tld
JAN 06 2005
PlANMl\JG DEPA~rMENT
CITY OF ClIEAR\^JAT:ER
~.
01 \OAl\OJ
er~"'"
~
.....
Ramanujachari Kannan, P.E. #38688
January 2005
Project No. 0463
601 CLEVEL,<>',ND 5 PUET, SuiTE 930
CLEARVJATE i"{, FLOl"\1 DA 33755
N ESADM: N@/V\i N DS P P I hie (Oi~/\
N ESTEC l-'@MI!'\:DSPi< I ~~G COr~
727 443 2869 FAX 727 . 446 . 8036
NORTHSIDE ENGINEERING SERVICES
25 YEAR STORM EVENT
ORIGINAL
PROJECT Comfort SUites
PROJECT NO 463
RUN-OFF COEFFICIENTS
PRE-CONSTRUCTION (PRE-DEVELOPMENT)
TOTAL DRAINAGE AREA= 187,466 SF 4 30 AG
IMP AREA TO REMAIN" 42,820 SF OF IMP AREA@ C =
POND AREA= 0 SF OF POND AREA @ C =
PERV AREA= 144,646 SF OF PERV AREA@ C =
045
1
02
C=
026
* C" 0 9/2 = 0 45 PER CITY OF CLEARWATER REQUIREMENTS
POST -CONSTRUCTION (EXISTING PERMITTED)
TOTAL DRAINAGE AREA" 187,466 SF 4 30 AC
IMP AREA= 122.478 SF OF IMP AREA@ C =
POND AREA= 15,812 SF OF POND AREA@ C =
PERV AREA= 49,176 SF OF PERV AREA@C"
09
1
02
C=
072
STORAGE CALCULATION
PRE-CONSTRUCTIQN
DRAINAGE AREA =
TIME OF GONG Te"
I @ Te :60 (25 YEAR EVENT):
Q(oul) '" G x I x A "
430 AG
60 MIN
360 INfHR
3 98 GFS
POST -CONSTRUCTION
TIME I Q(ln) INFLOW OUTFLOW STORAGE
(MIN) (INfHR) (CFSl (CF) (CFl (CF)
6000 360 11 23 40,426 14,340 26,086
MAX STORAGE =
26,086 CF
TOP OF WEIR ELEV "
BOT OF WEIR ELEV "
H=
Q"
9 27 FT
777FT
1 50 FT
3 98 CFS
~u '> Fc~r\\ IF?Di\
" -oj i F' I -- I' \ \ I, 1 ~'I j
"" L'= L!:: _, ~ 'v l.-:...:J --"-
WEIR DESIGN
JAN 0 & 2005
L=Qf3 31 *H^1 5 '"
o 67 FT
PU\NNll\lG D[Pi ~:IMENT
CITY Of ClEf,,-~\J~~T::=R
WATER QUALITY DEPTH =
05 In
TOTAL VOLUME REQUIRED = MAX STORAGE REQUIRED =
26,086 CF
TOTAL VOLUME PROVIDED = MAX STORAGE PROVIDED@ ELEV 927=
26,124 CF
NORTHSIDE ENGINEERING SERVICES
25 YEAR STORM EVENT
ORIGINAL
~[EC~~\~f~D
JAN 0 6 2005
PROJECT Comfort SUites
PROJECT NO 463
PlANN!N:; D~rp,}lM~NT
CIN O~ cU=P(~"( ~i'y:;.Y~R
RUN-OFF COEFFICIENTS
PRE-CONSTRUCTION (EXISTING PERMITTED)
TOTAL DRAINAGE AREA= 187,466 SF 430 AC
IMP AREA TO REMAIN= 82,702 SF OF IMP AREA@ C =
IMP AREA NOT BUlL T= 39,303 SF OF IMP AREA @ C =
IMP AREA TO BE REMOVED: 473 SF OF IMP AREA@ C =
POND AREA= 15,812 SF OF POND AREA@ C =
PERV AREA= 49,176 SF OF PERV AREA @ C =
09
09
045
1
02
C=
072
*
C = 09/2 = 045 PER CITY OF CLEARWATER REQUIREMENTS
POST-CONSTRUCTION (P ROPOSED)
TOTAL DRAINAGE AREA=
IMP AREA=
POND AREA=
PERV AREA=
187,466 SF 430 AC
125,157 SF OF IMP AREA@ C =
15,812 SF OF POND AREA@ C =
46,497 SF OF PERV AREA@ C =
09
1
02
C=
073
STORAGE CALCULATION
PRE-CONSTRUCTION
DRAINAGE AREA =
TIME OF CONC Te =
I @ Te =60 (25 YEAR EVENT)=
Q(out) :: C x 1 x A ::
4 30 AC
60 MIN
360 IN/HR
11 21 CFS
POST -CONSTRUCTION
TIME I Q(In) INFLOW OUTFLOW STORAGE
(MIN 1 (IN/HRl (CFS) (CF) (CFl (CF)
6000 360 11 38 40,984 40,363 621
MAX STORAGE::
621 CF
WEIR DESIGN
H::
Q::
9 63 FT
777FT
1 86 FT
11 21 CFS
TOP OF WEIR ELEV::
BOT OF WEIR ELEV::
l=QJ3 31*H^1 5 ::
1 34 FT or 16" (EXISTING)
WATER QUALITY DEPTH::
05 In
TOTAL VOLUME REQUIRED:: MAX STORAGE REQUIRED:: (621 CF + 26,086 CF)::
26,707 CF
TOTAL VOLUME PROVIDED:: MAX STORAGE PROVIDED @ ELEV 963=
31,128 CF
PROJECT NAME:
PROJECT NO. :
OR\G:I~AL
Comfort Suites
463
EXISTING PERMITTED POND'S STAGE STORAGE DATA:
T.O.B. EL.=
EX. GRATE EL.=
PROP. D.H.W. EL.=
EX. D.H.W. EL.=
W.Q EL.=
BOTTOM EL.=
STAGE AREA AREA STORAGE
ft-N GVD SF AC CF
1050 15,812 0363 44,196
10 12 15,121 0347 38,319
963 14,229 0327 31 , 128
927 13,574 0312 26,124
777 10,844 0249 7,811
700 9,443 0217 0
r--~ IE r [I' ~\\ fir? rR\
lI\& lb ~ b ~ ~! le l1:JJ
TOTAL WATER QUALITY CALCULATIONS:
JAN 0 6 2005
DRAINAGE AREA =
PlANMNG D~PA TiWIENT
CI1V OF ClEARW/WiER
187,466 SF
REQUIRED WATER QUALITY DEPTH =
050 IN
REQUIRED WATER QUALITY VOLUME =
7,811 CF
PROPOSED OUTFALL ELEVATION =
7 77 FT
AVAILABLE WATER QUALITY =
7,811 CF
OR \ G\ NAL
NQRTHSIDE ENGINEERING SERVICES
POND DRAWDOWN ANALYSIS
(existing previously approved Fairfield Inn)
PROJECT
Comfort SUites
PROJECT NO
463
VOLUME PROVIDED '" 7 811 C F
BOTTOM OF SLOT ELEV :: 777 POND AREA (SF) '"
BOTTOM OF POND ELEV = 700 POND AREA (SF) =
UNDERDRAlN INVERi ELEV = 600
COEFFICIENT OF PERMEABILITY (K) = o 09 FTIMIN
LENGTH OF UNOERORAlN = 70 FT
SIZE OF UNDERORAIN = 6 INCH
10&14SF
9,443 S F
ElEV AVG HEAD INCR HEAD L(AVG) HYO GRAD FILTER AREI FLOW POND AREA INCR VOL INCR TIME
FT FT FT FT FT/FT SF CFM SF CF MIN
777 10,844
142 019 275 052 110 512 2054 401
758 10,494
123 019 275 045 110 443 1986 449
739 10,144
104 019 275 038 110 374 1919 514
719 9,793
085 019 275 031 110 304 1,851 608
700 9443
TOTAL ORAWDOWN VOLUME::
7,810
CF
TOTAL ORAWDOWN TIME =
329
HOURS
NOTE THE POND HAS BEEN INSPECTED AND THE EXISTING UNDERDRAlN SYSTEM
APPEARS TO BE FUNCTIONING PROPERLY
ut~C~~V~D
JAN 0 b 2005
PLANNIl\JG D(PA~n\'~ENT
cnv OF ClEARVJ,~T~R
'"I;l
""
(J<:l
.,.,
-l
::r
iii
III
"'0
"2..
(')
Cl
-
(5
:J
~
0"
CD
it1 -l
< ~
ffi ~
~ 1.11
m III
0.-,
IllCD-I
:J @ :I:
0.__
,<-g(/)
0......_
CO(/)
:;;; ~ Z
=:JO
O"Cl-l
CD "'0 )>
:J"'O
0=-0
e!;lm
ffi'5~
Q.:J;::a
III -
1.110'-1
- -,
o Cl
-"'0
::rCD
~ 3
C -
n-
o
3
CD
o
......
~
(tl
Cl
"'0
"2..
(')
~
i5
:J
"'Q
()~
::Zz
0-
.."z
()G>
r-CJ
i~
~~
~~
mm
;OZ
-4
o
.....,
;Z.
2
rv
c...o
~
~
.v
;:a
rT1
(1
IT'
~
m
o
nO='
o~
tl
tn
Itl
I:/l
o
Z
o
tTi
<::
tTi
r'
o
'i:l
3:
~
-l
~
:.:>
~
a
rl>
=
...
..,
o
...
;
("J
::r
g
:>;"
I:'
;AJ
i
tv
v..>
0,
o
-<
:::l
'"tl
ro
...,
'"
o
:::l
3:
~
S'
o
=-
"'!;1
II>
"<:
'I>
...,
a
...
Eo
'"
()
=-
'I>
.,.,
:0:-
:z
o
n
o
=
:l
..
=
z
o
::t
:=
::;
::tl
'I>
""
'I>
<
..
=-
~
:.:>
~
a
It>
=
...
""
t""
:;
II>
-
.." () it
r ., e
o ~ '"
N Z
g :=
f'"
.....
o
00
o -3
-/>0 ...,
III
=
()
:=
=-
~
.., '='
(i) ..
>: i!l
0- .,
cr ~
("J o'
o ::I
8
8
ro
...,
n
@..
C"
:;
..
-
;-
e
-3
o
~
o ::tl
..... ..
o ~
I !\l
W ::I
-/>0 I:
..... ~
tv ;0.-
0, I'>
tv r>
:=
I:
=
...
~
tt>
r':l
~
-.
'"0
.....
::jt:
~
;:. :,...0
""'N
~ 0
_0
...~
--0
f::o
NO
=0
=0
.j;:>.O
o
o
o
I-'
N
Ut
0\
~
~~-J
, -r
'-
..:>
)
;0.- >
v. = GIl :I
" .... 0 - 0 t
~ N Iv = N lv c N:
~ 0 ::I 0:> 0 = tv W
" !JI V'l ... t.Il V'l ... 00 N:
.g 0:> 0 ""I:l b 0 "d ;r.. 0
= III
~ 0 0 5- 0:> 0 i5. 2: ~
'Z
<:>
\;
~6paJr.;rPD-"
~~Il&\\~LOF rift):....
~~~~~\ ~"....n......~~.I......'"
A.-.~i,1 ......_
!lj"~.' I~" ..
;..G!'~~It.....~ './ I:. ":. ~ "'"
""">ilI~'- .,' '"
~~. __ ' ~ '<l('"
r':' =~ l::l
"'~':. ==-. .91:1
"'lr':-~ ~q
~~~.......::-::.::.. .,~~\
"1:10- .......-----""""'- ,1 '\
- If;rm."<v..'" ~\
................, TEl\.. jlt'
'0'<(111'
CITY OF
CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATFR, FLORIDA 33758-4748
MUNICIPAl SERVICES BUll DING, 100 SOUTH MYRUE AVFNUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756
TELEPHONE (727) 562.4567 FAX (727) 562-4576
LoNG RA.\JGF PlANNING
DEVTLOPMENT REVIFW
February 16,2005
Ms Doreen Williams
NorthsIde Engmeenng Services, Inc
601 Cleveland Street, SUIte 930
Clearwater, FL 33755
RE Development Order - Cases FLD2004-11 081
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
Dear Ms Williams
ThiS letter constItutes a Development Order pursuant to SectIon 4-206 D 6 of the Commumty
Development Code On February 15,2005, the Commumty Development Board revIewed your request
for FleXible Development approval to permit an overnIght accommodatlOn use with 55 additIonal
rooms/umts with a reduction to the front (south) setback from 25 feet to 15 feet (to pavement), a
reduction to the side (north) setback from 10 feet to 95 feet (to eXisting pavement), an mcrease to
bUlldmg heIght from 25 feet to 4833 feet (to mld-pomt of pItched roof) wIth an addItIonal 12 083 feet for
archl tectural embelll shments (above the mId-pomt of pi tched roof) and a deViation to allow direct access
to a major artenal street, as a ComprehenSive Infill Redevelopment ProJect, under the provlSlons of
SectIon 2-704 C The Commumty Development Board (COB) APPROVED the applicatIon with the
followmg bases and condItions
Bases for Approval
1 The proposal complies wIth the FleXible Development cntena as a ComprehenSive Infill
Redevelopment Project per SectIOn 2-704 C,
2 The proposal IS m compliance with other standards In the Code mcludmg the General Apphcablhty
Cntena per SectIOn 3-913, and
3 The development IS compatible wIth the surroundmg area and WIll enhance other redevelopment
efforts
CondItIons of Approval
1 That thiS approval be subject to the annexatIOn of the alley to the north by City CounCil pnor to the
Issuance of any permits,
2 That thIS approval be subject to the vacahon of those portiOns of the Bay Street to the west and alley
to the north nghts-of.way by City Councll pnor to the Issuance of any permIts,
3 That the overnight accommodation use of thiS property meet the defimtlOn of the Commumty
Development Code, WIth owner and guest stays not to exceed 30 days and where occupancy of
rooms/umts anse from a rental agreement, other agreement or the payment of consideratiOn At the
request of the Clty Manager or deSignee, the records of the busmess shall be made avallable for
BRIAN J AUNG<;T, 1\'IAYOR.COMMI""IOI\~R
Hon HA\11110N, VICF MAYOR.COM~U<;S]ONFR WHIT!\LY GRAY, COlhlllS'IO!\I R
fRfu'Jl\ IImuARD, COMMI'.,S1UNfH * Bill J ON<'O,\, CO,\I.III,~IO" I R
'T QUAI EM PI OYMI NT AND An IRMA 1 [\IE Ac liON fMPI0\1 R"
"
>
i
February 16, 2005
Williams - Page Two
examinatIOn to determine whether the length of stay complies with these provISions Failure to
provIde ~uch records upon request shall be grounds for ImposItion of appropnate fines, revocatIon of
the occupational hcense and/or any other enforcement afforded by law or by CIty regulatIOns A
hcense must be obtained and maIntained from the Flonda Department of Busmess and ProfessIonal
RegulatIOn, DIVIsIOn of Hotels and Restaurants A registration lobby operated 24 hours a day, seven
days a week, shall be malntamed ThiS development shall not be deemed attached dwellmgs With
mdlvldual dwellmg umts, nor shall rooms/umts quahfy for homestead exemption or home or
busmess occupatIOnal licenses,
4 That comphance be demonstrated on bUlldmg plans pnor to the Issuance of buJidmg permIts
mdlcatmg the number of rooms/umts approved under thIS applIcation WIll not be exceeded Hotel
rooms/umts shall not mcorporate lockout rooms/umts With separate comdor doors,
5 That, pnor to the Issuance of any permIts, the site plan be reVIsed to demonstrate actual eXlstmg
parkmg spaces and the provIsion ofreqUlred parkmg for the overall slte,
6 That a Umty of Title be recorded 10 the public records pnor to Issuance of any permits,
7 That the final deslgn and color of the bUlldmg be conSIstent With the conceptual elevations submitted
to, or as modIfied by, the CDB,
8 That all freestandmg and attached sIgnage meet Code provlSlons, mcludmg the height and setback of
any freestandmg SignS The ComprehenSIve Sign Program may be utIlized to provide addItional
freestandmg and attached SIgnage m accordance With Code provlslOns, but freestandmg slgnage be
!tmlted to SIX feet III heIght above the fimshed grade of the front property hne,
9 That, pnor to the Issuance of any permIts, the landscape plan be reVised to ensure the proVlslOn of
reqUired mtenor landscape area, the mdlcatlon of eXlstmg tree canopies and the appropnate locatIOn
of plant matenals,
10 That, pnor to the Issuance of any permits, SIte constructlOn drawmgs be reVIsed to ensure no grade
cuts occufflng under the 27-mch oak tree's canopy, the proposed SIdewalk bemg constructed "on
grade" WIth a monohthlc curb and the provIsIOn of a WAN E aeratIon system,
11 That, pnor to the Issuance of any permIts, a Tree PreservatIOn Plan prepared by a certified arbonst,
consultmg arbonst, landscape architect or other speCialist 10 the field of arbonculture be submitted
ThIS plan must show how the proposed bUlldmg, parkmg, stormwater and utIlIties Impact the cntIcal
root zones (dnp hnes) of tree to be preserved and how these Impacts are addressed (Ie, crown
elevatmg, root prunmg and/or root aeratIOn systems) Other data required on thiS plan must show the
trees canopy hne, actual tree barncade hmlts (2/3 of the dnp hne and/or m the root prune hnes If
reqUIred), the tree barncade detail and any other pertment mformatIon relatmg to tree preservation,
12 That all FIre Department reqUIrements be met pnor to the Issuance of any permits, mcludmg revIsmg
the site plan to mdIcate HS-20 grate mlets,
13 That draw down calculatIOns be prOVided pnor to the Issuance of any permIts to ensure the eXlstmg
pond functions as ongmally deSigned,
13 That, pnor to the Issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy, traffic Impact fees be assessed and paId,
and
14 That all Parks and RecreatIon fees be paId pnor to the Issuance of any permits
\",
,
February 16, 2005
Williams - Page Three
Pursuant to Sectton 4-407, an applicatiOn for a bUlldmg permIt shall be made wIthm one year of Flexible
Development approval (February 15, 2006) All reqUIred certificates of occupancy shall be obtamed
within one year of the date of Issuance of the bUlldmg permIt Time frames do not change wIth
successive owners The Community Development Coordinator may grant an extensIOn of time for a
penod not to exceed one year and only within the onglnal penod of vahdlty The Commumty
Development Board may approve one additIonal extenSIon of tIme after the communIty development
coordmator's extenSIOn to InItIate a bUilding permIt apphcatJon
The Issuance of thiS Development Order does not relIeve you of the necessity to obtam any bUlldmg
permits or pay any Impact fees that may be reqUIred In order to facIhtate the Issuance of any permIt or
license affected by thiS approval, please bnng a copy of thIS letter with you when applymg for any
permits or hcenses that reqUIre thiS pnor development approval
AdditIonally, an appeal of a Level Two approval (Flexible Development) may be InIttated pursuant to
SectIOn 4-502 B by the apphcant or by any person granted party status wIthm 14 days of the date of the
CDB meetmg The filing of an apphcatlOn/notlCe of appeal shall stay the effect of the declslOn pendmg
the final determmatIOn of the case The appeal penod for your case expIres on March 2, 2005 (14 days
from the date of the CDB meetmg)
If you have any questiOns, please do not heSItate to call Wayne M Wells, Planner III, at 727-562-4504
You can access zomng mformatton for parcels wlthm the City through our webslte
www mvclearwater com/gov/depts/plannmg *Make Us Your Favonte'
Cynthia H Tarapam, AICP
Plannmg Dlrector
S \Plllnnmg Deparlmen/\C D B\FLEX (FLD) IJnactlve or FInIshed AppllcatlOnslGlllf 10 Bay 3070 Comfort Swles (C) - ApprovedlGlllf /0 Boy
3070 Developmenl Order doc
Nonhsitle
&~ s~ 1ne,
CIVIL.
LAND PLANNING.
ENVI RONMENTAL ·
TRANSPORTATION ·
January 6,2005
ORIGlf~AL
CIty of Clearwater Plannmg Department
100 South Myrtle Avenue
Clearwater, FL 33756
Attn Wayne Wells, Planner III
Re
FLD2004-11081
fREC[E~V[ED
Dear Wayne
JAN 0 6 2005
The followmg are responses to DRC comments
General Engineering
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CI1Y OF ClEA.I(WATER
1 The vacatlOn of Bay Street IS currently underway and will be fmallZed pnor to
CDB
2 Pnor to CDB, dependmg on the vacated Bay Street, It wdl be determmed If a
SIdewalk easement wdl need to be granted for the eXlstmg SIdewalk Wltlun the
southwest comer of the property
Fire:
1 All underground water mams and hydrants are to be mstalled completely m
accordance per NFP A 241 (See Sheet C5 1 Note)
2 All grate mlets located Wlthm dnve aisles Wlll meet FFDOT HS-20
specIficatlOns (See Inlet DetaIl on Sheet C6 1)
3 It IS our understatmg that FIre'S DRC reView IS for sIte work only and does
not pertam to approval or reVIew of constructIon plans or documents (See
Note on Sheet C5 1)
Legal:
1 Power of Attorney Forms attached
Land Resources
1 All tree canopIes are shown on the attached tree mventory and wdl be shown
on all plan sheets pnor to CDB
2 Redesign IS not reqUIred
601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930
CLEARWATER FLORIDA 33755
NESADMIN@MINDSPRING COM
NESTECH@MINDSPRING COM
727 443 2869 FAX 727 446 8036
ORIGINAL
Mr Wayne Wells, Planner III
January 6,2005
Page Two
~[2C[E~V~[D
JAN 06 2005
Land Resources continued: pn A.
!..p\\NN!NG D~pAR1MI:NT
3. Tree #27 has been removed (See S~bWG2f1):mrd~a:rep.tl!g~ment tree Will be
Installed (See Sheet L 1.1 )
4. Due to location of proposed structure, trees #52-59 Will be removed and
replacements will be mstalled.
5. EastlWest section shown on plans
6. UtilIties has been rerouted outside of the canopy of tree #51 (See Sheet C5.1)
7. N/A
8. Tree Preservation (Tree Inventory) plan has been provided Within this
package
Landscaping:
1. All tree canopies are shown on Tree Inventory attached hereWith
2. See Sheet Ll.l showing additional of Palms
3. Tree located in the island has been removed.
4. Sight triangles have been shown on landscape plans (See Sheet L 1.1)
5 See Sheet Ll.1 for plants added to meet code
6 Per Section 3- I 202.E.l all requirements have been met (See Sheet L 1.1 )
Parks & Recreations
1. We feel that we have paid the reqUIred amount In open space, recreation land
and recreatIOn facilities impact fees. If it IS determined that an additional
amount is due, the fees will be paid prior to issuance of building pennlts.
Stormwater:
I. Draw down calculations for pond IS mc1uded in this package A verification
stating the pond IS functioning as designed wIll be addressed pnor to buildmg
permt 1.
Solid Waste:
1 SolId Waste Will be shared between the two hotels. ThIs Site will be shared
between the two hotels. There is no sale m the future.
Mr Wayne Wells, Planner III
January 6, 2005
Page Three
ORIGINAL
~~C[E~VlED
JAN 06 2005
Traffic Engineering PLANN~~JG DEPf',~TMENT
CI1Y OF ClEAR\\fP.'fER
1. An accessible route from one hotel to the other per Flonda AcceSSIbIlity Code
for BUIldmg ConstructIon Chapter 11 has been provIded. (See Sheet C3.1)
2 All9x19 parking stalls has been noted as "typical". (See Sheet C3 1)
3. Load space measunng 9'x35' has been establIshed on Sheet C3 1
4 All above Items have been or will be addressed pnor to CDB Impact fees
Will also be paId prior to CDB
Planning:
1 FAR reqUirement on SIte Data Sheet has been removed on Sheet C 1 1
2 Setback dImensions have been shown from eXIsting north property line to eXIstmg
pavement (Sheet C3 I)
3 Existmg easement has been shown on Sheet C3 1
4. Existmg parkmg spaces have been dImenSIOned on Sheet C3.1
5 Wheel stops have been provIded adjacent to landscape and SIde walk areas (See
Sheet C3 1)
6 Two handicap spaces have been removed on the east side of FaIrfield Inn and
replaced WIth three regular spaces (See Sheet C3 1)
7 The proposed Comfort SUites and F3lffield Inn Will share the use of the pool and
dumpster.
8 See Sheet C3.1 shOWing the handIcap ramps and crosswalk for handIcap
accessibIlIty to Gulf-to-Bay
9. Sheet Cl.l aenal map IS lightened as much as possIble Unfortunately, It darkens
after each set whIch IS out of our control
10 Locations of all proposed lightmg fixtures are now shown
11 Proposed BFP will not block VIews of eXIstmg sign on Gulf-to-Bay Blvd
12 8 5"x 11" landscape plan of L 1 1 is attached.
13. Existmg SIte sIgnage photos, dimenSIOns and heIghts are attached
14 The word '"tranSIent" was changed to "tourist and travelers"
15 BUIldmg height has been lowered at sIgnage to be 43 88'
16 A Unity of Title Will be recorded With PublIc Records prior to issuance of
permits.
17. PortIons of Bay Street and alley to the north rights-of-way wIll be vacated prior to
Issuance of any pennlts
18 Prior to Issuance of any pemits, annexation of the alley to the north Will be
approved by City CounciL
19 See Sheet C3 1 for reVIsed parking showing allowable spaces and mterior
landscaping Islands.
Mr Wayne Wells
January 6, 2005
Page Four
Planning continued:
20 The legal Issues regardmg the vacation of Bay Street are stIll bemg worked-out
and WIll be resolved pnor to Issuance of any pennits
Please feel to contact us regardmg any addtttonal questIons pertauung to thIS project
~relY
DO~~
PrOject DIrector
.'
'"
J
; ~fJ.;~~,_u';;l~ :~~~;t'a' rwater
,~ ~,_II ,J II J
~ - 1 ~ ,=.
:> '1 II ~f ~ If :;~I~I
1-- : fL.1 .,.- '" ~ _ :~ -::~\
(j
FAX COVER MEMO
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
100 S. MYRTLE AVE.
CLEARW A TER, FL 33756
(727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865
TO: Y \) ~ L.L..-.. \-J"~ \" Ii\..~
FAX: ++ ~. ~ 0 3 to,
Phone. 44\- '3 . L 2> (0 Cj
FROM: \N~'('L 1-J~\\-S
DA TE:_ _\ 2- U RE:
Phone:~ 'cJ 2-~:r-O 4-
3u7C () \J\+---\-o- B~a.
FLU 2.ot> + - \ \ 0< ~ \ ) -r A I\J 1\'2.b ~ + # l 'Lo 2..,0
\)\O\it \L~ \)4- \) ~c.... ~~~-..
N n-e... ~ \lL. r"-f f' ~ \ ,,~~ '\ ~ ,\ ~. :;Q ~
',,, "\6.._"" '"") \)~IiJ-.~1:
MESSAGE:
NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) S-
u
C I T Y 0 F C L ~ ~\. R W ATE R
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
MUNTCIP AL SERVICES BUILDING
100 SOUTH MYRTLE A VENUE, CLEAR WATER, FLORIDA 33756
TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576
WWW MYCLEAR WATER COM
~~ Clearwater
December 02, 2004
Northslde Engmeermg
601 Cleveland Street
SUite 930
Clearwater, FI 33755
RE FLD2004-l1081 -- 3070 GULF TO BAY BLVD n Lettel of Completeness
Dear NorthsIde Engmeenng
The PlaImmg Staffhas entered your apphcatlOn mto the Department's filmg system and assigned the
case number FLD2004-11081 After a prehmmary review of the subml tted documents, staff has
detenmned that the apphcatIon IS Complete
The Development Review CommIttee (DRC) wIl! review the apphcatlOn for sufficiency on December
30, 2004, m the Planmng Department conference room - Room 216 - on the second floor of the
Mumclpal ServIces Bmldmg The butldmg IS located at 100 South Myrtle Avenue m downtown
Clearwater Please call Sherry Watkms, Admmlstratlve Analyst, at 727-562-4582 no earlrer than one
week pnor to the meetmg date for the approXImate time that your case WIll be revIewed You or your
representative (as apphcable) must be present to answer any questIOns that the DRC may have
regardmg your applicatIon AddItlOnal comments may be generated by the DRC at the time of the
meetmg
If you have any questIons, please do not hesitate to contact me at 727-562-4504 or
Wayne Wells@myclearwatercom
Smcerely yours,
:~l':::; W~
Planner III
Leller of Completeness - FLD2004-1108/ - 3070 GULF TO SA Y BL VD
Nonhsile
&~ Sf1Wiu4 1fte,
November'30,2004
CIVIL.
LAND PLANNING.
ENVIRONMENTAL.
TRANSPORTATION.
City of Clearwater Plannmg Department
100 South Myrtle Avenue
Clearwater, Flonda 33756
Attn. Wayne Wells, AICP, Planner III
Re' FLD2004-11 081- 3070 Gulf-to- Bay Boulevard-Comfort SUites
Dear Wayne,
The followmg are responses to your Letter of Incompleteness'
h.
h
J3
/4
J5.
J6.
J7
([)
'9
ho
I am replacmg the 1 sl page of the application to reflect the one parcel
number only and to reflect 55 units proposed in heu of 60
Piper Rudruck IS submlttmg an annexation apphcatlOn for the
proposed alley being vacated Additionally we are now only mcludmg
the southern half of the alley as part of our lot area proposed whIch
bnngs the maximum urnts allowed on site to 182 thus we have
adjusted the number of units bemg proposed as new to 55
Lot area on C 1 1 has been revised to depict accurate numbers as well
as the proposed additIOnal rooms to 55 in lieu of 60 and the proposed
height from ground level to mId pomt of roof is actually 4833'
Height IS no longer an issue so the narrative has been revised and
JustificatIon for the reduction to the reqUired front setback to pavement
IS now included Wlthm the narratIve
Floor plans have been reVised to accurately depict 55 rooms as well as
on all cIvil plans,
BuIlding elevatIOn now depicts accurate height from ground to mid
pomt of peaked roof
Sight tnangles are now accurately reflected on C 1 1 and L 1.1
Crosshatching now shown on Sheet C3.1 deplctmg all reqUired
parkmg lot intenor landscaped areas
Imgation plan now mcluded
Narrative now reflects request a deviation to allow direct access to a
major street although these access pomts already eXist
Please feel free to contact us With any questIOns related to this project
. ~~~
Debra Ann But er, Executive Vice PreSident
~~r'~~D
601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33755
NESADMIN@MINDSPRING COM
NESTECH@MINDSPRING COM
727 443 2869 FAX 727 446 8036
UI:L 0 1 200\
PlANNING DEPARTMENT
CITY OF CLEARWATER
ogOIIJi'Ur,....,
t~'~~OF FIr,:r..,.
~~~ ~",w.........,,~7A~
'\~-V'\t- ....-4'4I'r"t:=go,
~~~' \1/ ~':. G>~
;;_~,--.., '~rfl~-"
\:o~. -~-= ..::lC~
..~~ ~~= ~Il'
"'''' ~ ':. - "'- =- ;:;::4
~~.*~ ~- - ';~':~
.... ........~Jt1 ,.
- '!fJJm..' ~"> "
........,.........i'f TE\\., Iltt
q"'.a}flr r
-
,
~
.,i"
CITY OF
CLEARWATER
PlANNING DEPARTMENT
POST OHIO Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FlORIDA 33758-4748
MUNICIPAL SFRVlCF.5 BUILDING, 100 SOUfH MYRfLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756
TELEPHONF (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576
loNG RANGe PLANNING
DEVELOPMeNT REvIEW
Jl
12
I,
November 29,2004
Ms Debra Butler
NorthsIde Engmeenng Services, Tnc
GO 1 Cleveland StIeet, SUite 930
Clearwater, FL 33755
RE Case No FLD2004-l1 081, 3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard, Comfort SUItes
DeJr Ms Butler
The Plannmg staff has revIewed your appl1catIon for FleXIble Development approval for property
generally located at 3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard for the Comfort SUites After a prelImmary revtew of
the submitted documents, staff has detennmed that the application IS incomplete Section 4-202 of the
Community Development Code states that If an appl1catIon IS deemed 1l1complete, Staff shall specify the
deflClenCles of the applicatIOn No further development review action shall be taken untIl the
defic]enclcs arc corrected and the applicatIOn IS deemed complete In order to stay on the current
schedule for review for suffiCiency by the Development Review CommIttee (DRC) on December 23,
2004, the followmg mfomlatlon IS reqUired to be submltted bv 9 am on Wednesday. December 1.2004
(should you be unable to meet thiS tune frame, the next submittal deadlme ]S December 22,2004 [noon]
to be reviewed for suffiCiency by the DRC m January 27, 2005, If the apphcatlOn IS deemed complete)
The tollowmg Items and/Qt mfonnatlOn are reqUIred In order to make vour apphcatIon complete
Appl]catlOn mdICates two parcel numbers (16/29/16/00000/230/0200 and
16/29/16/00000/230/0300) A check With the Pmellas County Property Appraiser records does
not show pal cel 16/29/16/00000/230/0300 AdVIse
The submItted site plan mcludes all of the alley (to be vilcated) on the north slde of the property
A reView of CIty records and that of the Pmellas County Property Appraiser mdlcates that
portlOn of the alley north of the Major's Manor, Lot 1, SubdlvlslOn has been already vacated,
only the southern half (eight feet) of the vacated alley IS part of the subject property and such
vacated portion has been annexed mto the CIty of Clearwater The western portIon of thIS alley
(north of Lots 18 - 23, Bay VIew Terrace, Block 3) IS not wlthm the Ctty limits (still
umncorporated County) and has yet to be vacated An applicatIOn to annex thlS alley mto the
City of Clearwater must be submitted to the Plannmg Department AddltlOnally, rules governmg
the vacatiOn of nght-of-way evenly split the nght-of-way between the plOperty ownerS abuttmg
the nght-ot-way bemg vacated when It IS part of a platted subdlvlslOn (such as thiS sttuatIon)
rhe &Ite plan submitted wrongly assumes the entire vacated alley to become part of the subject
property, whereas only the southern eIght feet of the vaGated alky would become part of the
subject property ThiS reduces the acreage for the subject property, affectmg the number of
overnIght accommodatIOn umt5, allowable on the subject propel ty
BRI \N J AUNCO, r, MA i OH-CO\lM1~~ION[R
IIOIT IIAMII TON, VlCF MIl YOR-COM MI~'ilON FR WHlrNFY GRI\ \, (O\J \1 1~~IOt'.1 R
FRMK HIBBARD COMWSSIONLR * Bill JONSON, CO\I.\II"~IOMH
"[QUAI rMPI OYMrN rAND AFlIRJI.1Al IYF ACllON t~lPI QYFR"
,
13
J4
J5
./6
h
~
JlO
November 29,2004
Butler - Pagc 2
'Based on SIte Data on Sheet ell of 4633 acres and 40 rooms/acre, only 185 rooms maximum
are allowed on this site (See also Item #2 above) A total of 187 rooms have been proposed on
the subject property Revlse
Provide JustlficatlOo for mcreased height and reduced front setback (to pavement) per cntena for
"overlllght accommodatlOns" use m Section 2-704 K (cntena #3 and 6) of the CommercIal
Dlstnct
Floor plans submitted (Sheet A 1 0) mdlcates 72 rooms proposed, not the 60 rooms mdICated on
Sheets ell and C3 1 See also ca1culatlOn of density (number of rooms permitted) above
Revise
BUlldmg elevations submltted (Sheet A2 0) depict a pitched roofbUl1dmg Provide the heIght
dImensIOn from ground to mld-pomt of the pItched roof
Sheets C3 I and L 1 I - Show sight VISlb1l1ty tnangles at all dnveway locations
DepIct by shadmg or crosshatchmg all reqUired parkmg lot mtenor landscaped dreas
Provide an lfngatlOn plan
Request w1l1 need to mc1ude a devJatlon to allow direct access to a major artenal street
Fifteen caples (one ongmal and 14 caples) of revised apphcatlOn matenal addressmg the above
comments must be submItted to the Plannmg Department
If you have any questIons, please do not heSitate to call me at 727-562-4504 You can access zomng
mformatlon for parcels wlthm the City through our webslte www myc1earwater com
Smcerely,
b!:J ~II~~~~
Planner III
S \P!fllI""'g Depar/111CIlI\C D BIFLEX\incompletelGlllf to Bay 3070 COJJJfOl1 Surles (C) - WWlGI,lj" to Bay 3070 Comforl Sillies incomplete
Leiter If 29 04 doc
,~\ ~
LL ,.~1\:.,
o ~~!;i,-,~~ 7~~~~>~arwater
I-~ {I-J 'I~ r r-""_ f J
>- Iln ,~"5 d II ~ r- I-~
I ~~ I} I ,jll
I-- I I - I"'" - -- ':; I 1'01
u
FAX COVER MEMO
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
100 S. MYRTLE AVE.
CLEARW A TER, FL 33756
(727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865
TO: Ve. k tlJ- 13J+l tr
FAX: t.+-\, . '00 J L"
Phone. +- f ~ ..Z-~ ~ ~
FROM:----hh., 1"1- Wtll:(
DATE.~ 1l)~
Phone:_
MESSAGE:
RE; 1.0 0 fl r
3~ ? 0 C) w \{. +0 n"'1 i3\vd..
\ ^- t.~ f \Lk LL\\er-
'C!:l to : j \ C'Q. \ n cU "".J N"Q : )L d .
NU1VIBER OF PAGES(lNCLUDING THIS PAGE) .3
CDB Meetmg Date
Case Numbers
Agenda Item
Owners
ApphcantJRep
Address
OR!Gli~i'~L
February IS, 2005
FLD2004-11081 (Related to ANX2004-12020)
D4
RB-3 Associates, Randall Henderson 1993-1 Trust and WR-I Associates Ltd
Henderson Development Company, Inc
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
ST AFF REPORT
GENERAL INFORMATION:
REQUEST:
EXISTING ZONING/
LAND USE:
PROPERTY SIZE:
PROPERTY USE:
ADJACENT ZONING/
LAND USES:
(1) Flexible Development approval to permit an overnight
accommodatIOn use with 55 additional rooms/umts with a reduction
to the front (south) setback from 25 feet to 15 feet (to pavement), a
reductIOn to the sIde (north) setback from 10 feet to 95 feet (to
eXlstmg pavement), an Increase to bUlldmg height from 25 feet to
48 33 feet (to mld-pomt of pItched roof) wIth an addItIOnal 12083
feet for archItectural embellIshments (above the mld-pomt of pitched
roof) and a deViation to allow dIrect access to a major artenal street,
as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project, under the
provISIons of Section 2-704 C, and (2) VacatIOn of a portion of the
Bay Street nght-of-way to the west and a portIOn of the alley to the
north
Commercial (C) DiStrICt, Commercial General (CG) Category
4 578 acres (mcludes the east 30 feet of the requested vacated Bay
Street to the west and the south eIght feet of the alley to the north
[eastern portIOn already vacated and the western portIon requested to
be annexed and vacated])
Current Use Overnight accommodatIon use (127-rooms/umts)
Proposed Use Overnight accommodation uses (exIstmg FaIrfield
Inn of 127 rooms/umts and proposed Comfort SUItes of 55
rooms/umts)
North Institutional Dlstnct, Retention pond
East CommerCial and Medium DensIty ReSIdential Dlstncts,
AutomobIle service station and attached dwelhngs
South MobIle Home Park Dlstnct, Vacant
West CommerCial and Low MedlUm Residential Dlstncts, Offices
and detached dwelhngs
Staff Report - Conunumty Development Board - February 15, 2005
Cases FLD2004~ 11 081 - Page 1 of 8
CHARACTER OF THE
IMMEDIATE VICINITY: The surroundIng area IS a mIxed-use area wIth nonresIdential uses
along Gulf to Bay Boulevard and resIdentIal uses adjacent to these
nonresIdential uses
ANALYSIS:
Site Location and Existmg ConditIOns: The 4 578 acres IS located on the northwest comer of
Gulf to Bay Boulevard and McMullen Booth Road The sIte has approxImately 465 eXIstIng hnear
feet of frontage on Gulf to Bay Boulevard and 400 lmear feet on McMullen Booth Road The sIte
currently Includes the south eIght feet of the eastern 160 feet of an alley along the north property
hne that has been annexed and vacated The western portIOn of the platted alley nght-of-way IS
currently located In umncorporated Pmellas County The Bay Street nght-of-way IS located to the
west of thIS parcel The parcel IS currently developed wIth the FaIrfield Inn overnIght
accommodatIOn use with 127 rooms/umts
A retention pond abuts to the north, wIth the eastern portion wIthm the CIty and the western
portIOn located In unmcorporated PInellas County A two-story, over ground-level parkIng, office
bUlldmg IS located to the west The area north ofCarohna Avenue west of the subject SIte IS zoned
Low MedIUm DensIty ReSidential DIstnct and IS developed WIth detached dwellmgs The area
south of Gulf to Bay Boulevard was formerly a mobIle home park, has been bought by the CIty
and IS mtended as a park
Proposal: The proposal Includes constructIOn of a new four-story bUIldIng m the southwest
portIon of the SIte for a 55-room/umt overnIght accommodatIOn use (Comfort SUItes) The
southern portIOn of the SIte IS currently undeveloped AddItional parkmg WIll be constructed In
thIS southern area for hotel guests
Related to thIS apphcatIon IS the requested annexation of the western portIon of a platted alley
adjacent to the subject property The eastern 160 feet of thIS platted alley has already been
annexed Into the City and vacated The apphcant IS also seekmg to vacate thIS western portIOn of
the alley to the north By rules of vacatIOn, thIS site WIll obtam the southern eight feet (half of the
alley WIdth) The apphcant IS also seekIng to vacate a portIOn of the Bay Street nght-of-way to the
west The site plan mdIcates, through tills vacation, that thiS site WIll obtam the east 30 feet of the
nght-of-way
The proposal mcludes a reduction to the front (south) setback from 25 feet to 15 feet (to pavement)
and a reductIon to the Side (north) setback from 10 feet to 95 feet (to eXistIng pavement) WIth
the constructIon of the new overnIght accommodatIon use (Comfort SUItes), addItIOnal parkmg
spaces are reqUired to be proVided The apphcant proposes the new pavement edge 15 feet from
the Gulf to Bay Boulevard property hne ThIS proposed I5-foot setback COInCides With the
reqUIred 15-foot landscape buffer along thIS artenal roadway Staff mcluded m the advertIsed
request the reductIon to the setback along the north property lme from 10 feet to 95 feet (to
eXIstmg pavement), as the apphcatIOn approved to construct the Fairfield Inn (FLS 00-07-46 and
Staff Report - CommunIty Development Board - February 15,2005
Cases FLD2004-11 081 - Page 2 of 8
FL 00-12-64) indicated compliance with the 10-foot reqUired setback Should the balance of the
alley be annexed and vacated, thiS eXisting setback would then meet Code reqUirements
A deviation to allow direct access to a major artenal street has been mcluded as part of thIS
request ThIs SIte has been granted a deVIation to thIs dIrect access restnctIon prevIously for the
FaIrfield Inn under FL 00-12-64, approved by the Commumty Development Board on February 20,
2001 A dnveway access was constructed and IS bemg retained WIth thIS request Since thIS
request IS to construct an addItIonal overnight accommodatIOn use on the property, whIch carnes
the same access restnctIOn, Staff has mcluded the deVIatIon In the request There are no new or
addItional dnveways proposed on Gulf to Bay Boulevard The grantmg of a deVIatIon for thIS
request IS appropnate
The SIte plan indicates 130 eXIsting parking spaces on-sIte SIte mspectIon reveals that north of
the eXIsting FaIrfield Inn some 900 parking spaces have been modIfied to angled parking, WhICh
reduces the amount of eXIsting parkmg The proposal mcludes constructing an addItIonal 53
parking spaces on the southern portIOn of the SIte to accommodate the new use, WhICh WIll exceed
the mmlmum reqUirement by one space PrIor to the Issuance of any permIts for the Comfort
SUites, the SIte plan must demonstrate reqUired parkmg for the entIre SIte IS bemg provIded
The proposal Includes an mcrease to bUilding height from 25 feet to 4833 feet (to mId-pomt of
pitched roof), WIth an additIonal 12083 feet for archItectural embellishments (above the mId-pOint
of pItched roof) The main roof for Code heIght determmatIon IS a pItched roof HeIght IS
measured to the mld-pomt of the pItched roof The Fairfield Inn was granted a heIght mcrease
from 25 feet to 50 feet (to the flat roof deck) The requested 48 33 feet appears compatIble WIth
that eXIsting on the property and WIth the office bUlldmg to the west ThIS pitched roof does have
a parapet as a vertIcal extensIon of the extenor walls that IS lower than the mId-pomt of the pItched
roof The proposal has been advertIsed for the addItional 12 083 feet for archItectural
embellishments (above the mId-pOint of pItched roof), WhICh IS a bUlldmg prOjectIOn above the
lobby area While thIS archItectural embellishment projectIOn IS limIted m locatIOn and SIze to the
rest of the bUilding and may not be disproportIOnate to the character of the bUlldmg, It may allow
an unnecessary mcrease In attached sIgnage area that the applicant has not suffiCiently JustIfied
The FleXIble Development case approved In 2001 mcluded the condItIon "That any proposed,
freestandmg SIgn be limIted to SIX feet m heIght above the fimshed grade of the front line of the
parcel unless part of a Comprehensive SIgn Program, as requued by Code" There IS an eXIsting
monument type SIgn adjacent to Gulf to Bay Boulevard east of the dnveway A ComprehensIve
SIgn Program was approved for thiS SIte, but only dealt With an mcrease from 24 to 45 square feet
of SIgn area for attached sIgnage for the Fairfield Inn bUlldmg WhIle no addItIOnal freestandmg
sIgnage IS proposed WIth thiS request, a Comprehensive Sign Program would be required for any
such addItIonal freestandmg slgnage, which should also be SImIlarly restncted to a monument type
SIgn a maXImum of SIX feet hIgh The buIlding elevation drawmgs for thIS proposal mdIcate two
attached SIgnS on the east elevatIon and one attached SIgn on the south elevation Code provIsIOns
only permIt one attached Sign per busmess of a maxImum of 24 square feet The large attached
signs are approxImately 104 5 square feet m area A ComprehensIve SIgn Program Will be
Staff Report - Commuruty Development Board - February 15,2005
Cases FLD2004-11 081 - Page 3 of 8
reqUIred for at least the attached slgnage shown, which wIll evaluate the appropnate number and
SIze of attached SIgnS
The site today IS well landscaped WhIle the southern portIOn of the SIte WIll be redeveloped to
provIde for the new bUlldmg and parkmg, It IS the mtentIon of the proposal to retam the eXlstmg
landscapmg along Gulf to Bay Boulevard Pnor to the Issuance of any pemllts, the landscape plan
will need to be revIsed to ensure the provIsion of reqUIred mtenor landscape area, the mdIcatIOn of
eXlstmg tree canopies and the appropnate locatIOn of plant matenals AdditIonally, Staff IS
concerned with constructIOn adjacent to the 27-mch oak tree Just east of the proposed bUlldmg and
north of the porte cochere Care must be demonstrated on constructIon drawmgs to ensure no
grade cuts occumng under this tree's canopy, the proposed sIdewalk bemg constructed "on grade"
wIth a monohthlc curb and the provISion of a WAN E aeratIOn system A tree preservatIon plan
IS also reqUIred pnor to the Issuance of any permits
All applIcable Code reqUIrements and cntena mcludmg, but not lImited to, General ApplicabIlIty)
cntena (SectIon 3-913) and ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project cntena (SectIOn 2-
704 C) have been met
Code Enforcement Analysis: There are no outstandmg enforcement cases pendmg agamst this
site
Staff Report - Community Development Board - February 15,2005
Cases FLD2004-11 081 - Page 4 of 8
COMPLIANCE WITH STANDARDS AND CRITERIA: (Sections 2-701.1 and 2-704):
STANDARD PROPOSED CONSISTENT INCONSISTENT
MAXIMUM 182 rooms/umts
DENSITY -
(40 rooms/units per X
acre) (182 rooms/units
max.)
IMPERVIOUS 062
SURFACE RATIO X
(ISR) (0.95 maximum)
LOT AREA 4578 acres
(20,000 - 40,000 sq. ft. X
minimum)
LOT WIDTH South 465 hnear feet X
(100 - 200 feet min.) East 400 lInear feet
FRONT SETBACK South 15 feet (to prop pavement), 25
(15-25 feet) feet to prop bUIldmg) X*
East 25 feet (to eXlstmg pavement)
REAR SETBACK N/A X
(10-20 feet)
SIDE SETBACK North 9 5 feet (to eXIstmg pavement) X*
(0-10 feet) West zero feet (to eXlstmg pavement)
HEIGHT (25-50 feet) FaIrfield Inn 50 feet (to roof deck)
Comfort SUItes 4833 feet (to X
mIdpomt of pItched roof)
PARKING SPACES 183 spaces X
(one space per room
min.) (182 spaces rea.)
* See diSCUSSion under AnalysIs
Staff Report - Commumty Development Board - February 15,2005
Cases FLD2004-11 081 - Page 5 of 8
COMPLIANCE WITH COMPREHENSIVE INFILL REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT
FLEXIBILITY CRITERIA (Section 2-704.C):
ConSistent Inconsistent
1 The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for
development IS otherwise ImpractIcal without deviatIons from the use, X
mtensltv and development standards
2 The development of the parcel proposed for development as a
Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project Will not reduce the faIr X
market value of abuttmg properties
3 The uses wlthm the Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project are X
otherwise penmtted m the CIty of Clearwater
4 The use or mIx of uses wIthin the Comprehensl ve Infill X
Redevelopment Project are compatIble with adJacent land uses
5 The development of the parcel proposed for development as a
ComprehensIve Infi 11 Redevelopment Project WIll upgrade the X
Immediate VIClnItv of the parcel proposed for development
6 The deSIgn of the proposed Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment
Project creates a form and functIOn that enhances the commumty X
character of the Immediate vIcmlty of the parcel proposed for
development and the CIty of Clearwater as a whole
7 Flexlblhty m regard to lot Width, reqUIred setbacks, height and off-
street parkmg are JustIfied by the benefits to commumty character and X
the Immediate vlcmIty of the parcel proposed for development and the
City of Clearvvater as a whole
8 Adequate off-street parkmg m the Immediate vIcImty according to the
shared parking formula m DIVIsion 14 of ArtIcle 3 will be avaIlable to X
aVOid on-street parkmg In the ImmedIate VICInIty of the parcel
proposed for development
* See diSCUSSion under AnalysIs
COMPLIANCE WITH GENERAL STANDARDS Section 3-913 :
1 Development of the land WIll be m harmony wIth the scale, bulk,
covera e, densIt and character of ad acent ro ertIes
2 Development Will not hmder or discourage development and use of
ad acent land and bulldm s or Sl Ificantl 1m aIr the value thereof
3 Development Will not adversely affect the health or safety of persons
resldm or workm III the nel hborhood
4 Develo ment IS desl ed to mmlmlze traffic congestIon
5 Development IS conSistent with the commumty character of the
Immediate VIcml
6 DesIgn of the proposed development mmlmIzes adverse effects,
mcludmg Visual, acoustIc and olfactory and hours of operatIOn
1m acts on ad acent ro ertIes
* See diSCUSSIOn under Analysts
Staff Report - Commumty Development Board - February 15,2005
Cases FLD2004-l1 081 - Page 6 of 8
Consistent
InconSistent
X
X
x
X
X
X
SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION:
The Development Review Committee reviewed the apphcatlOn and supportmg matenals on
December 30, 2004 The Planmng Department recommends APPROVAL of the (1) flexIble
Development approval to permIt an overnight accommodatIOn use with 55 addItional rooms/umts
with a reduchon to the front (south) setback from 25 feet to 15 feet (to pavement), a reductIon to
the side (north) setback from 10 feet to 95 feet (to eXlstmg pavement), an mcrease to bUlldmg
height from 25 feet to 4833 feet (to mId-pomt of pItched roof) wIth an additiOnal 12 083 feet for
architectural embelhsbments (above the mld-pomt of pitched roof) and a deVIatIOn to allow direct
access to a major artenal street, as a ComprehenSive Infill Redevelopment Project, under the
provIsIOns of SectIon 2-704 C, (2) VacatIOn of a portion of the Bay Street flght-of-way to the west
and a portiOn of the alley to the north [or the site at 3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard, WIth the
followmg bases and condItions
Bases for Approval
1 The proposal comphes WIth the FleXible Development cfltena as a ComprehensIve Infill
Redevelopment Project per SectIOn 2-704 C,
2 The proposal IS m complIance With other standards m the Code mcludmg the General
ApphcabIlIty Cfltena per SectIOn 3-913, and
3 The development IS compatIble WIth the surroundmg area and wIll enhance other
redevelopment efforts
Conditions of Approval
1 That thIS approval be subject to the annexation of the alley to the north by City CounCil pnor to
the Issuance of any permits,
2 That thiS approval be subject to the vacatIon of those portIOns of the Bay Street to the west and
alley to the north nghts-of-way by City Council pnor to the Issuance of any permits,
3 That the overnIght accommodatIOn use of thiS property meet the defimtIOn of the Commumty
Development Code, With owner and guest stays not to exceed 30 days and where occupancy of
rooms/umts aflse from a rental agreement, other agreement or the payment of conslderahon
At the request of the CIty Manager or deSignee, the records of the busmess shall be made
available for exammatIOll to determme whether the length of stay comphes With these
prOVISions Failure to prOVide such records upon request shall be grounds for ImpOSitIOn of
appropnate fines, revocatIOn ofthe occupatIOnal hcense and/or any other enforcement afforded
by law or by CIty regulatIOns A lIcense must be obtamed and mamtamed from the Flonda
Department of Busmess and ProfeSSIonal RegulatIon, DIVISion of Hotels and Restaurants A
regIstratIOn lobby operated 24 hours a day, seven days a week, shall be mamtamed ThIS
development shall not be deemed attached dwellmgs With mdlvIdual dwellmg umts, nor shall
rooms/umts quahfy for homestead exemptIOn or home or busmess occupatIOnal lIcenses,
4 That complIance be demonstrated on bUlldmg plans pflor to the Issuance of bUlldmg permits
mdlcatmg the number of rooms/umts approved under thiS applIcatIOn WIll not be exceeded
Hotel rooms/umts shall not mcorporate lockout rooms/umts WIth separate comdor doors,
5 That, pnor to thc Issuance of any permits, the site plan be reVIsed to demonstrate actual
eXlstmg parkmg spaces and the prOVISion ofreqUlred parkmg for the overall SIte,
Staff Report - Conunumty Development Board - February 15,2005
Cases FLD2004-11081 - Page 7 of 8
6 That a Umty of TItle be recorded III the pubhc records pnor to Issuance of any pennlts,
7 That the final desIgn and color of the bUlld10g be consistent with the conceptual elevatIOns
submItted to, or as modified by, the CDB,
8 That all freestandmg and attached slgnage meet Code prOVISions, 1Oclud1Og the height and
setback of any freestandmg'slgns The ComprehenSIve Sign Program may be utilIzed to
provide addItIOnal freestandmg and attached slgnage 10 accordance wIth Code prOVISIons, but
freestand10g slgnage be limited to SIX feet In height above the fimshed grade of the front
property l1Oe,
9 That, pnor to the Issuance of any permIts, the landscape plan be reVised to ensure the provISion
of reqUired mtenor landscape area, the mdlcatIon of eXlstmg tree canopIes and the appropnate
locatton of plant matenals,
IO That, pnor to the Issuance of any permits, sIte constructIOn drawmgs be reVIsed to ensure no
grade cuts occurnng under the 27-1Och oak tree's canopy, the proposed sidewalk bemg
constructed "on grade" with a monohthlc curb and the prOVISIOn of a WAN E aeratIOn
system,
11 That, pnor to the Issuance of any permits, a Tree PreservatIOn Plan prepared by a certified
arbonst, consultmg arbonst, landscape architect or other speCialIst In the field of arbonculture
be submitted This plan must show how the proposed bUlldmg, parkmg, stormwater and
utthtIes Impact the cnttcal root zones (dnp lInes) oftree to be preserved and how these Impacts
are addressed (Ie, crown elevatmg, root prumng and/or root aeratIon systems) Other data
reqUired on thIS plan must show the trees canopy line, actual tree bamcade hmlts (2/3 of the
dnp hne and/or In the root prune hnes If reqUired), the tree barncade detaIl and any other
pertment mformatIon relatmg to tree preservatIOn,
12 That all FIre Department reqUirements be met pnor to the Issuance of any pemnts, mcludmg
revlsmg the site plan to mdlcate HS-20 grate mlets,
13 That draw down calculatIOns be provIded pnor to the Issuance of any permIts to ensure the
eXlstmg pond functIOns as ong1Oally designed,
13 That, pnor to the Issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy, traffic Impact fees be assessed and
paid, and
14 That all Parks and RecreatIOn fees be paId pnor to the Issuance of any perml ts
Prepared by Plannmg Department Staff
A TT ACHMENTS
Aenal Photograph of Site and Vlclmty
LocatIon Map
Future Land Use Map
Zomng Atlas Map
ApphcatIon
.) IPlrmml1g Dcprlflmel1t\C D RIFLEX (FLD)IPel1dmg cases I Up for the nexl CDB\GulflO Bay 3070 Comforl Sillies (C) 2 1505 CDB - WWlGulf
10 Bay 3070 Slaff Reparl doc
Staff Report - COllIDlumty Development Board - February 15, 2005
Cases FLD2004-11 081 - Page 8 of 8
"'"'w
!i! -~ -~ ~
I , 0
~ -,
~
01
i ~
-z
0
i
j';
-:"",,y ~
ii , !XMt<,., ~ stREET ~
:~
I
I
I
I
I
location Map
O I RB-3 Associates. Randall Benderson 1993- 1 c
wner ,ase'
1 Trust and WR-l Associates ltd
Property
Size (Acres),
SIte.
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
PIN,
I Atlas Page
sR '"
PROJECT
SITE
FLD2004-11081
4.33
16/29/16/00000/230/0200
292A
Owner.
Site:
Aerial Map
RB-3 Associates, Randall Benderson 1993- I Case:
1 Trust and WR-I Associates Ltd.
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
Property
Size(Acres):
.
,f I '
Pt
\. - .
\
~ .....
L.
t
. ~"
..
I ~
I r.
.
FLD2004-11081
4.33
PIN: 16/29/16/00OCXJ/230/0200
I Atlas Page: 292A
200
201
"
1"'-,
l_-, 210
1--,
I I
I I
I ,
I I
L_.J
220
225 ___
I r
c
, ,
I ,
227'-
11 ~
~- I I
1 ~ :t:
...,
~
- 0{
i-~, ~ ~ ...,
I : '-I :it
L/-- 0
Q
l3
:e
r
II
-,
~
...."
gg ~
407
r--------
,.I
~,
,
"---I ~
, v.
I ).
<> I ~
~ '-IT
r-l
1 _
, I
'"
~"'9 <CC13
lI$g ~g
'"
g
OSR
I
r-' --
""-'
l ~:2'OO-l
<. -,
, I
'\,...._L..~.....r-.r-J
3(J(}
-~L....IL..rL....t
r-s---------- ----1
I ,
I.., :
~ I-
I I
I I
l__J
~
g
~
GULF- TO-SA Y BL va
~
Zoning Map
Owner:
RB-3 Associates, Randall Benderson 1993- 'case'
1 Trust and WR-I AssocIates Ltd.
Site:
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
Property
SlzefAcres} ,
PIN
, Atlas Page:
Q
a:
i:
o
o
~
1l.i
...,
5
~
r~-"l
~.m 1
I ..
I ~
~2lI7 ~
I I
___J
r2~;}
I r
: 21b
" I
" ,
~-~
311
I~~'"
.I 338-, r--'
, I [343~
nR/U1:
1 33'1 \ ?
,,-~....J -...~.....!
r---""I
I I r
I I I
igr--- ~ i
1,,",,1 ;, l
I"'] -""1
<.!)
a:
1ZI
1IJ
51
~
~
,0 E eRG
-.lS
q,'t-
FLD2004-11081
4.33
16/29/16/00000/230/0200
292A
2fJ(J
2fJ1
t1
.....-,
L-", 210
Detached
I I
225~~ llfn~
l r L_.J
f -,
L...J
227
.,.-.....--
, ....._J
I ~'l'il/)-'
SociallCommt(nity L,
, I
Center ',...._...--"
2ZO
1 r ~
~- I I .c:
I ~4 -.I
:~
let
:5
~
o
Q
~
:!!
... ...
;-~, '; ~
r ! L", {W)
1 I I
L_J"' _J
3()7
30SJ
I 300
Retention Pond
r-S-~-~~--~-- ---1
I I
[, :
--.,. ,---
r' -I
I 1
~_~,..Io
IIfgS
LI
l OJ if,O ~
-~g ~ ~
CAROLINA AVE
...'"
gg ~
407
j--------
,"
",
Offit-eS-i t.:
I -,
1 >-
Q: :!
;It L'I-_
os ~-
l;l
!'l
Offices
~
!'l
r-1
I _
~ I
'"
N... ~r;o
~!il g~
<0
<;
.,
GULF.. TO-SA Y SL VD
~
"
a::
OJ
au
S
~
~
Existing Surrounding Uses Map
Owner
RB-3 Associates, Randall Benderson 1993- I Case.
1 Trust and WR-I Associates Ltd.
Site.
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
Property
Slze{Acres)
PIN
I Atlas Page
~
i:
o
o
lEI
:e
lU
....
5
~
r-:\
,-~, 1 213(
,1<l)51 I r
A1tt~1 he{l211f
~'l. . ~J ,
It: ID S2Of1/
__I --~
I
I
L 311
r.i3l, ,--,
~tt;ic~:eif~
~~li~gB~
___J 11....__1
Aqto.m.p ive
Sd"Vic~ :-
kil~o-n- ~ I
~~ ., I
J ~I
\oIE eR:G
",c;,
~..
FLD2004-11081
4.33
16/29/16/00000/230/0200
292A
...
'" ..,~
.. r""'~
1,II,UJl 'ff --.......
.,~ ,... ",-~....
· .iitt'A
:QJ .. ~~!KIfr\ ~:
:e'?C:"" -~ ..,' ~:
:-;;. =- ~..
-~i)\;- ~
':... ~1i5''''''''~'-$''
........}ITE~:,O II'
~II'.'
Fire Condition
01/10/2005
Conditions Associated Witn
FLD2004-11081
3070 GULF TO BAY BLVD
Joe Colbert
562-4567 xt 3548
All grate Inlets located Within drive aisles must be designed to meet FOOT HS-20 specifications
PRIOR TO COB
1/10/05 J_C Condition NOT met on revised plan Plan call out H-20 rather than HS-20 as
required These are two totally separate weight ratings
Not Met
Arden Dittmer
562-4604
01/10/2005
landscape Site Tnangle Cond
Not Met
1/10/2005 (A_D)
same comment
12/16/2004 (A D)
Landscape Plan does not show the sight tnangles as descnbed In Article 3, DIVISion 9, revise the
plan to show these tnangles at all the street and dnveway intersections Although the street (Bay
St) IS to be vacated II will remain as a shared drive and will most likely have vIsibility concerns
Landscape 10% Intenor Candl Arden Dittmer 562-4604
01/1 0/2005 Per Section 3-1202 E 1 Code req U Ires a m In 1m um of 10% Intenor green space of gross vehlcu lar
use area or 12 % of gross vehlcu lar use area If parking spaces area greater than 110% of the
required parking Intenor Islands shall be designed so that In most cases no more than 10
parking spaces are prOVided In a row
Landscape
01/10/2005
01/10/2005
01/10/2005
Not Met
***Interlor Islands shall be a minimum of 150 sq ft, and be 8' of green space from back of curb to
back of curb
Arden Dittmer
562-4604
1/10/2005 (A_D)
same comment
Not Met
12/16/2004 (A_D)
Show ALL eXisting tree canopies on plans and conSIder the height of the bUilding In relation to the
tree canopies
1/1012005 (A_D) Not Met
same comment
12/16/2004 (A_D)
The Island In the center of the main drive seems to be shrinking, try alternate layouts for the
parking to lessen the number of drives crossing the center drive and this would ehmlnate the need
to Impact the large tree In the Island
The plants In the landscape Islands should be reversed placing the softer Lenope along the Not Met
curbing and the Indian Hawthorne on the Intenor around the trees
12/14/2004
land Resource Condition
Rick Albee
562-4741
12/14/2004
1113105- The canopy of tree #51 stili nol shown on ALL plans Not Met
12/14/04-Show the canopies of "ALL" trees, on "ALL" plan sheets prior to COB
1/13/05-Could not locate the section Not Met
12/14/04-Show an east/west section through tree # 51 No grade cuts can occur under the canopy
of this tree Recommend concrete "on grade" with a monolithic curb and WAN E aeration
CaseCondltons
Pnnt Date 01/13/2005
Page 1 of 3
it..........
FLD2004-11081
3070 GULF TO BAY BLVD
Land Resource Condition Rick Albee 562~4741
system Provide onor to CDB
12/14/2004 1/13/05-Could not locate the preservation plan
12/14/04-Provlde a Tree Preservation Plan prepared by a certified arbonst, consulting arbonst,
landscape architect or other specialist In the field of arbonculture This plan must show how the
proposed bUilding, parking, stormwater and utilities Impact the critical root zones (drip lines) of
tree to be preserved and how you propose to address these Impacts Ie, crown elevating, root
pruning andlor root aeration systems Other data required on thiS plan must show the trees
canopy hne, actual tree barncade limits (2/3 of the drip line and/or In the root prune lines If
required), and the tree barncade detail And any other pertinent Informallon relating to tree
preservallon PrOVide prior to bUilding permit
Not Met
Parks & Recs Condition
Open Space, Recreation land and Recreation Facilities Impact fees are due for additional
property and 55 hotel rooms prior to Issuance of bUilding permits These fees could be
substantial and It IS recommended that you contact Deb Richter at 727-562-4817 to calculate the
assessment
Not Met
Storm Water Condition
Before BUilding Permit
Not Met
1) Provide draw down calcs for pond and verify pond IS functioning as deSigned (24 hour draw
down)
Zonmg Condition Wayne Wells 562-4504
01/13/2005 1113/05 & 11/29/04 - WW
Show location of eXisting easements on-site, as Indicated In Exhibit B of the deed
01/13/2005
01/13/2005
01/13/2005
01/13/2005
Not Met
1113105 - WW Not Met
May need to reqUire wheel stops for eXisting Fall11eld Inn
11/29/04 . WW
Wheel stops required adjacent to landscaped areas and Sidewalks, but are not required where
abutting (front to front) other parking spaces, Including eXisting parking lot ReVise
1113/05 - WW Not Met
Applicant removed two eXisting He spaces from east Side of Fairfield Inn Need to IndIcate on
Sheet C3 1 that thiS area to be restnped as Indicated
11/29/04 - WW
Only SIX handicap spaces required, based on number of required parking spaces, but there are 10
proposed (existing or new) Suggest redUCing by two handicap spaces by eliminating eXisting
handicap spaces from east Side of Fairfield Inn and replace With three regular parking spaces
1113/05 - WW Not Met
Area where slgnage IS proposed IS solely architectural embellishment of additional bUilding area
facade that IS excessive and Will need to be advertised Stili may not support thiS portion of the
request
11/29/04 - WW
Area of bUilding where attached Slgnage IS proposed on Sheet A2 0 IS Just added height for
Slgnage, not for elevators or stairs Request needs to Indicate, and Sheet A2 0, the highest pOint
of thiS portion of the bUilding above the midpOint of the pitched roof Staff may not support thiS
additional height
1/13/05 & 11/29/04 ~ WW Not Met
Condition to be Included In Staff Report That a Unity of Title be recorded In the public records
prior to Issuance of any permIt
CaseCondllons
Print Date 01/13/2005
Page 2 of 3
J.......
FLD2004-11081
3070 GULF TO BAY BLVD
Zonmg ConditIon Wayne Wells 562~4504
01/13/2005 1/13/05 & 11/29/04 - WW Not Met
Condition to be Included In Staff Report That this approval be subject to the vacation of those
portions of the Bay Street and alley to the north rights-of-way by City Council prior to the Issuance
of any permits
01/13/2005 1/13/05 & 12/19104 - WW Not Met
Condition to be Included In Staff Report That thiS approval be subject to the annexation of the
alley to the north by City Council prior to the Issuance of any permits
01/13/2005 1113/05 - WW Not Met
Engineering now THINKS that this site MAY get the east half of Bay Street when vacated Don't
really know If they will or not If not, Staff Report may be recommending denial or, If Legal agrees,
condition of approval will be necessary
12/22/04 - WW
Based on General Engineering's comment regarding the vacation of Bay Street, since this project
won't get any of the proposed vacated rlght-af-way, the number of overnight accommodation Units
will exceed that permlted Reduce and revise cIvil and architectural plans
CaseCondltons
Pnnt Date 01/13/2005
Page 3 of 3
View looking north at existing Fairfield Inn
building on north side of site
View looking north at proposed location of
Comfort Suites building
/
~_. 1~1~' .'r(
..~. I ~"L 't".
.,., . .",. . ':'F< fA
. . '.. I" '. ~. . " I,.. ..,.....
. ' ,. . I '. "".~' ~ ~... ';. 'i.. R}jr1,
"- .. -. J ~ .~ . .' '
~ -' . '
-----'- . __ . I 1'~J);r'-1D I
, ,,,... "" .J:a
, --
, '~
i'
/
'\.
.
..
:~.Jii
'-s,.
/
~~"'. ~
"or
.~J~ .
'.
T~
""":"fL.-
View looking west along Gulf to Bay Boulevard
(includes Fairfield Inn signage)
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
FLD2004-11081
.r
View looking northeast at existing retention
pond for site
--
View looking northeast at proposed location of
Comfort Suites building
View looking east at existing Fairfield Inn
building on north side of site
Page 1 of 2
...
......,
l
-
View looking south along McMullen Booth Road
at existing landscape buffering
View looking west along north side of site and at
retention pond to the north of subject site
~ -. - ~
. .
View looking west at existing office development
to the west of Bay Street
3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
FLD2004-11081
View looking west within existing parking lot at
proposed location of Comfort Inn building
View looking northwest at retention pond to the
north of subject site
~,.,.- - ..
..
View looking south along Bay Street and at
existing office development to the west
Page 2 of 2
Wells. Wayne
From
Sent
To
Subject.
Doherty, Steve
Tuesday, January 25, 2005 4 11 PM
Wells, Wayne
RE FLD2004-11081 - 3070 Gulf to Bay Blvd
I now believe Comfort Inn will retain the east 30 feet I will see you tomorrow to discuss
-----Ong In a I Messa ge-----
From, Wells, Wayne
Sent. Monday, January 24, 2005 1 48 PM
To: Doherty, Steve
Cc Rice, Scott
Subject: RE FLD2004-11081 - 3070 Gulf to Bay Blvd
Steve -
What IS the status of this determination? I am running out of time regarding the Flexible Development case
Wayne
-----Onglnal Message---..
From: Rice, Scott
Sent. Tuesday, January 11, 2005 4 29 PM
To: Wells, Wayne
Subject: FLD2004-11081 - 3070 Gulf to Bay Blvd
Wayne,
Engineering has completed review of subject application Per research by Steve Doherty, It IS now believed that
the applicant would receive a portion of Bay Street when It IS vacated I am waiting for a conclusion on thiS Issue
The only other comment would be on Traffic Impact fee at CO
D. Scott Rice
Land Devel. Engr. Manager
727-562-4781
scott.rice@MyClearwater.com
1
'V
DIll:
~hl 1 ~~~~
I ~ I - r-'- - - ~
~ _ LJ I
"~~ liT''''' H
~. - I 0; - :0. ----.:.:~' ,,: - bI,' -r 18 117, !
I ~- ~ -:: ,,~- < . '" ,Ulll "'" ~ ~ "H
" I ---:.... "'" " ' Ii:::L ;:'''''''_' :' · 12l : ~ ,,=: .,(') !
1 '!i.~ I . .~~ .a I-"-"~ I'>:'~? .g~ 1-.~!9~ ; ~ 't l
~\ . ~~ J 1 ) 'i.fi,"'R ~"" 01 - m Ij;:J ~ ,
~ I - - .... ,_ I"" ~ Ji'li\ll\1 -. iF . ~ 'I
. I'~ ~ .r"'l ".......,:
\ ;,... ~ El ...."""d ~";::~ 1 ~~": . -~ rid 1) 0'1' \
~ "." -. e' - u. ~ ~ > ;:/,' )
: ::0: -, ~:': I - : , :. l: ~'-"'! cJ' to)D(J :
- 1:. I * _ ~ . . I . ~ . I i t)~,,"
~ -.
~~ J
, ~~
~~~
"L ;--"IR\
~* .. \~
-.'~ 1
~1
~ I
J
....,..'- .~
~ I'.!!
"'" I ~
I
I
I
I
: !
~t i r JI-
,... I ""(:) ~ ~
~ - : ~
~ ~~~ 1
~ '"
- ~~
...
e1
ill
J 1-0(
~
~0
0Cj
;.
) ; ~
_ 1 _
I
N
<0
N
)>
~I , ,
.. g} ~ 1 .fiC
. . s:-I! : ""I~\i->" "
1 ~~ ~ IIIC
!! I ~ ~ il r.l '~ ~ D.
~ I I~I ."". 1""_" "I~.... ,
! ~ f~ - LJ "I;;l :;~.....(9 'I~J., "."
~ ---,-- rl\ 'L J.. 6 ....-
CJ ~.~'.I~}... ~~Ei:~' i~ ~1~f;~tQ ~~;:
- I ~ ~ -{ ~'~. ;~ :2 '~1E J d~ ~ tJ;WJJ,p~s ~u'"
~.. L =r'=~l ~ ,', '51 I ".. , - ~ - 1.44 \, ,!~ "io' " . .
,- iJ'J" -- Ii ',:- -'Ll, '"' rlle'~ '... I..
~ ~ ~ ~ !~ ~ -", ~ ',~ !~Ii j -l'J11I-~ Ii Ii'" _<RE':" .
I ! I I 1 ~ ~ "I J :,);pt- ! ~Jt~ ,.~. . I-- "'"
"~ -J ~.. I-';;;-:- R'~ < ":-.m.-.J. ~..~: - T: /~ ~ w,,_
L ~ I ~ ---;;;; l..u-- ~, _ . $ I. --'--':/'. . ~
\ 'I ~O I." - -~ ~ i .m - I .~ ";W\-t,jmr~\'\':\"~ ,'If ',~.: L-..,.... 0 ...."
" " ,~~ ,~ ""..'"" T' ,,- ,'\'\'\ ~ r-;:-, . "'l ....
I ~ ~ ~ .m - 1 ' ~ t ' , . , , " $ . . ::'-J' ~ _ .... ~" ~ ,. ...
I~ .-i". fj: I~ i ': ~:r 1...:1: . ~,- /i;ll1~
~"~'~L' : T'-MHi'-""- -~~-----~ T~~ .. :
i'0 _"\~. ~ _ .
:<:
:;:: ;:
.::: ..
... ."
<> '"
... '"
~ ~
'" '"
~ ~ D)
en
My
a
--~ ~-'" """ ,,-
j .
~ ".
~: ~
""
~1 "f11
~
+1
r
~
~
~
~
~ ~~
,
N
o
::I
::I
10
~
G]@G
~ ~ g
:I: "' Z
Gi '" :!
~ ~ ~
~ ~
\
\
\
~ ~, .-
1 /
I!ifAtl!.l
t " .
~ r~l. "
I ~ [0 "
LJ' ~ :
~.
~ !;
. >Cl,
Ii
, ~.
- \
-~
.
i*
L
':.
~ il
f s
~
, I' I
000u
0:; 1:1 10 ..
05'~D
~ " <il'"
n 5 ~ ~
g a ~ ~
" - c-
D"tl
< 0 s-.g
" '"
o ~ ~
"
III
~
!'l
"
"
."
s::
:l
rn
D
'"
:ii
D
'"
"
6
Z
..
g
"
D
"
:31
i
Cl
~
"
c
'"
'"
"'
"
~
'"
c
'"
~
"
~
z
c
~
'"
;0
'"
R
"
%
~
'"
"
'"
c
'"
%
C
;ji
"'
"
..,
s::
%
"
'"
o
!il
(';
o
;:
;;:
o
"
~
"
",
"
'"
I
:E
/1'1 F-'
,
SANOUWOOO t DR"
~....-=-=
...
00'0 I ; ~n~~ii i
nir ~ EUHiHF!
. iH!l!lJfJ
i i~!J~ji
;~J~ ~ I; ~~hi
if <[I ~ f i I i
~ ~ 11'I [") i.
h . c .
nq q
! .
!!
!
, I
~
!
1
'VE"",
,..
"""
- ...
:::
...
~~
'- "~
t'1(Jt !2 ::
.e. ~ ~"
r --=
~ ~
.[ ~ Ii "'" -
L'. =
""
""
... .
'--
~
.....J
8t1
~o!>
I '
"
_I~
(0
-----
"
~
~e)
.li (
~
li-
-I--
.
"oil
I -
:~
,
-~
!i ~ i" 0
; -0
-----,,-
".;;l !D1~
~
i ~ ..
~:
1
~(
-,
. =,
~
.......:.......
~I
I---
~~
---=--
---=-
t~~~
l
~"
~.
"X ~m~.:1
"''''~
<<'t'
o 01"
i! :i:~
~
~ i~
~ 'H~
~I$ ~ , IY
:;:
~z ~niUHU I ~g." .~
~ ~~j'~l; ~ ~ <A c:._
ht"h!~~~ ~;;: ~ CI""m
'" j~hnrf~ ~j}~~ (~;; ~
~ ~ "~~.i - ~'" GlO""~.
.r~.J! ~H~ !l.'/'Ol:'z;lJil:{t~
Ii '. ~ ~~ ~ '" ...... m;O;." ~
i!i . ~t~~,,-[!'~ ~ g:- m"'J> ( ~
E ...~ ~ if~ ~ if; :" O;oJ ~;:II ,
~'~.Hnp !B~~ii:a ~\
~Sh";rlf ""~i!i -~~ ...-..- i
~~~~ "r1tH 83 .:l_~ ~ ~ )~
~i~~ hn~ ~." l'
i~Q.J ~;!' ~~ g
~~~in:i;~~ ~'::':l z
t~~ ~~EL~ s: g
. ~
~~
i
- '.
S \ENGINVlUTOCADVlTLAS\3(llA dwg 02113/011039 54 AM eadams. eoglnJ,.merge pc3
A. J008
g (
~
"..
"
tl'
~V
N
OJ
"'"
N
o
z
z
G)
)>
--i
0Jr
0)>
--lo.UJ
-l.Il
"'=E
I~
......
"'....
"'0
l.Il-"
Il.Il
,..,
~n
"'::I
o
Pl;Z
@I@Gl0S0
;:pH~ I
:8;=;; ~
~h~H i
HH~a-
s::
t::1
~
.
~@
"
!i'
"
."
3.
a,.
f~
Jl
- . .
~[~13
'1'[~
~"- ~
. ~ Q
..~
1<[
l.-
i1
~~
~
~
!l;;~n:5!ii~~ ~
3~"o;::!:~1!.. ~~ ~
il;:'H'5i~"~ ,
l:a!:t-.;:~;ii l:l! ~
"-h~s~!:=~
~.nH".itj'
~~ Hr!.~d2
~! ~ a- .~ a.f~ ;
!~a!i:!;g:.
~ ~ ~i ~ .i ~~~
~1!II~4"'~ ~oir
~i~2~~:iii
I:;~lf:;h~~
; 5"~~g~!t.p:
~ .i"~ -..~ if
!l. 2"9 'l, fl-! Q a
!!.~~H!~,l.;:
3.g.I;t"j!:ooA:io
!. ~;~~ J ir ~
:r';a-~i"!:J:~ ~
'i' I g-3.."l 3 ~ .
~ iQ'. fi~;!
!! il ;:'n~l-
.0;'18
~aLb
?i! =-=
~!: ~g ~
~ ~ ~ ~~!ti
.~:?:::.. ~
1:5! q2iOO
~ :II! z!i:: I2t
i &,!\.(1i: 0.(
~~ 6j
J~ ~
~ I .....
!III: ~ _
...... "
~ '"
~
611
ld
g~
....,.
!ag
go
.-,,.
,.-'"
..,'"
... ,.
"
:1'1
,.
....-"
M '"
"'0
gg
-< ....
..,
g
..,
,.-
;;::
:;
'"
.....
z
,.,
~
'"
~
v>
'"
'"
:;
"
'"
z
c
;::
~
"
III
"-
...
..
-g
EfjZ
8
N
'"
z
,.,
.....
z
,.,
N
'"
:z
%
o
~
VI
2
~
15
z
o
....
-<
'"
~
M
'"
."
~
,.,
~
-<
)>
"
'"
,.,
..,
'"
M
"';
a
,.
z
'"
'"
x
s
,
I"'l
C)
rr1
Z
o
8
-,
..
"
"
O;v
"'Pl
6:5
"'<11
......",
..,0
ID
8
~ ~
8 :2
~ -
p
...
~
'"
g
)>
11:30 am
Case Number' FLD2004-Ilu.sI -- 3070 GULF TO BAY BLVD
Owner(s): Rb-3 Associates
2555 Enterpnse Rd # 14
Clearwater, Fl33763
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax, E-l\.1AIL No Emall
Owner(s), Wr-l Associates Ltd
2555 Enterpnse Rd
Clearwater, Fl33763-1160
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Email
Owner(s)- Randall Benderson 1993-1 Trust
2555 Enterpnse Rd
Clearwater, F133763-1160
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Emall
l=;.... ,
\'1..10.04
t>TU-
c....~C
~, ~
Representative' Northslde Engmctnng Services Inc
601 Cleve land Street
Clearwater, Fl33755
TELEPHONE 727-443-2869, FAX 727-446-8036, E-MAIL debra@northsldeengmeenng com
Location' 455 acres lOCated at the northwest comer of Gulf to Bay Boulevard and McMullen Booth Road
Atlas Page: 292A
Zomng DiStrict, C, Commercial
Request (I) Flexible Development approval to penmt an addltlonal overnight accommodation use with a reductIOn
to the front (south) setback from 25 feet to 15 feet (to pavement) and to allow direct access to a major
artenal street, as a ComprehensIve Intill Redevelopment ProJect, under the provIsIOns of SectIon 2-704 C,
(2) Vacatton ofa portIon of the Bay Street nght-of-way to the west and a portIOn of the alley to the north
Proposed Use: Overnight accommodations
Neighborhood Clearwater Neighborhoods CoalIllOn
AssoclatlOn(s): Clearwater, Fl 33761
2544 Fnsco Dnve
TELEPHONE 727-725-3345, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL DJw@gtenet
NClghborhood Bay Breeze Trailer Park
AssoClatlon(s)' Clearwater, FI 33759
2975 Gulf To Bay Blvd
TELEPHONE 727-796-2175, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No EmaIl
Presentcr: Wayne Wells, Planner III
Attendees Included Staff Wayne Wells, Chip Gerlock, R1Ck Albee, Scott Rice, Joe Colbert, Mark Parry
ApphcantlRep Housh Ghovaee, Doreen Williams, Truett Gardner
The DRC revlcwed tlus application With the follo\'\'mg comments:
General Engmeermg
1 1) The vacalIon of Bay Street would not benefit thiS property for adding additIonal square footage
to overall land area ThiS property was M & B 23 02 and M & B 23 03, and not a part of the
subdiVISion that dedicated thiS nght-of-way to the CIty Therefore, thiS proposed vacated
property would go to the owners on the west slde of Bay Street tf approved, not be splIt 50/50
Therefore, should not be shown on site plan
Prior to C 0
1) Unless Bay Street IS vacated, grant a Sidewalk easement for the eXlstmg Sidewalk wlthm the
southwest corner of property
EnVironmental:
No Issues
Fire:
Where underground water mams and hydrants are to be Installed, they shall be Installed,
completed, and m service pnor to construction as per NFP A 241 Please acknowledge PRIOR
TO COB
2 All grate iDlets located wlthm dnve aisles must be deSIgned to meet FOOT HS-20
speclficatlOns PillOR TO COB
3 ThIS DRC ReVIew by Fue IS not an approval or review of any construttlOn plans or documents
other than site work PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE
Development ReVIew Agenda - Thursday, December 30, 2004 - Page 20
Harbor Master:
1 No Issues
).
(From Leslie Dougall-Sides) I noticed the Letter of AuthonzatlOn IS signed by Mr Baldauf as
one Trustee of three of one 0 f the coowner~ You may want to have the apphcant obtam the
approvals of the two cotrustees, Nathan Benderson and Ronald Benderson [unless the Trust
Agreement authonzes Mr Baldauf to represent them], as well as representatives of the other
coowners, RB-3 Associates and WR-l ASSOCiates, LId
Land Resources,
1 Show the canopies of "ALL" trees on "ALL" plan sheets pnor to COB
2 If redesign IS requlfcd or considered preservation of trees #20,23,43 and 51 must be considered
3 Remove tree #27, this tree IS declImng due to prevIOus construction actlvltIes (fill)
4 The proposed structure IS too close to trees #52-59, either move the structure outside of the
canopy or remove the trees ReVise pnor to COB
Show an east/west sectIOn through tree # 51 No grade cuts can occur under the canopy of tins
tree Recommend concrete "on grade" with a monohthlc curb and WAN E aeratlOn system
Provide onor to COB
Reroute utlhtIes outside of the canopy of tree #51, revise pnor to CDB
Utilization of your arbonst could have avoided ALL of the above reqUirements Recommend
utlhzmg your arbonst to assist With pre\Jmmary deSigns so tree Impacts can be addressed and
numnuzed pnor to plan submittal
Provide a Tree PreservatIOn Plan prepared by a certified arbonst, consultmg arbonst, landscape
architect or other specialist m the field of arbonculture This plan must show how the proposed
bUlldmg, parkmg, stormwa ter and utIlitIes Impact the cntlcal root zones (dnp Imes) of tree to be
preserved and how you propose to address these 1mpaets Ie, crown elevatmg, root prumng
and/or root aeratIOn systems Other data required on this plan must show the trees canopy hne,
actual tree barncade linuts (2/3 of the dnp lme and/or III the root prune Imes IfreqUlred), and
the tree barricade detail And any other pertment mformatiOn relatlllg to tree preservatlOn
ProVide pilar to bUlldmg pernut
Landscapmg:
1 Show ALL eXlstmg tree canopies on plans and consider the he1ght of the bUlldmg III relation to
the tree canopies
There IS a row of "LI" on the west side of the retentIOn pond which will look great III the
summer months but serve little puprose m the wlllter months, revise this by addmg palms
and/or substJtutlllg some of the trees With non-deCiduous ones
The Island III the center of the mam dnve seems to be shrmkmg, try alternate layouts for the
parkmg to lessen the number of dnves crossing the center dnve and this would ehnunate the
need to Impact the large tree III the Island
Landscape Plan does not show the Sight tnangles as descnbed In ArtIcle 3, DIVISIOn 9, reV1se
the plan to show these triangles at all the street and dnveway mtersectlOns Although the street
(Bay 5t) IS to be vacated It WIll rcmam as a shared dnve and w111 most likely have VISibility
concerns
Plan does not meet the reqUirements of penmeter plantmgs III Code Scctlon 3- I 202 D Add
plant~ as needed to meet Code or show the "exlsltng landscapmg" III conjunctIOn With the
proposed
Pcr SectIOn 3-1202 E 1 - 1 Treehsland nummum, 1 Tree!150 sq ft ofrequued green space,
Shrubs 50% of reqUIred green space, and Groundcover shall be utilized for reqUired green
space III heu of turf
Parks and Recreation,
1 Open Space, RecreatIOn Land and RecreatIOn Faclhtles Impact fees are due for additIOnal
property and 55 hotel rooms pnor to Issuance ofbUlldmg pernuts These fees could be
substantial and It IS recommended that you contact Deb Richter at 727-562-4817 to calculate
the assessment
Stormwater:
1 Before BUlldmg Pernut
Legal'
1
5
6
7
8
2
3
4
5
6
I) ProVide draw down calcs for pond and venfy pond 1S functlOnmg as deSigned
Solid Waste'
1 Please explam how Solid Waste Will be handled now and III the future If slte IS sold off
Development ReView Agenda - Thursday, December 30, 2004 - Page 21
;.
Traffic Engmeermg:
1 I Provide an accessible route from one hotel to the other per Flonda AccesslbilIty Code for
Bmldmg ConstructIOn Chapter II (SectIOn 11-432)
2 Use the word "typical" for dimensIOning regular 9' x 19' parkmg stalls
3 Provide a CIty standard loadmg space (12' x 35') outside of parkmg spaces and dnve alsles
per Community Development Code, (Section 3-1406)
4 All of the above to be addressed pnor to COB
Traffic Impact Fee of $85,63500 to be paid pnor to C 0
Planmng:
1 Remove from Site Data on Sheet C I 11he "ReqUired" bUilding coverage and FAR (as there IS no
requuement)
2 Provide setback dimensIOn from eXlstmg north property Ime to eXlstmg pavement
3 Show locatIOn of eXlstmg easements on-sIte, as mdlcated In Exhibit B of the deed
4 DimensIOn eXlstmg parkmg areas
5 Wheel stops required adjacent to landscaped areas and sidewalks, but are not reqUired where
abuttmg (front to front) other parkmg spaces, mcludmg eXlstmg parkmg lot Revise
6 Only SIX handicap space~ reqUired, ba:>ed on number of reqUIred parkmg spaces, but there are 10
proposed (exlstmg or new) Suggest reducmg by two handicap spaces by ehnunatmg eXlstmg
handicap spaces from east side of Faufield Inn and replace with three regular parkmg spaces
7 Will proposed Comfort SUItes u~e the eXlstmg pool and dumpster west of Fairfield Inn'~
8 Extend proposed sidewalk on the east Side of Comfort SUites north to the eXlstmg pavement and
provide handlcap ramps and a LTosswalk to provide handicap accessIblhty to Gulf to Bay
Boulevard
9 Sheet C I 1 - Lighten aenal map, as It IS too dark
10 Sheet C3 I - Show location of all proposed outdoor hghtmg fixtures
11 W III proposed B FP block views of eXlstmg sign on Gulf to Bay Boulevard? If so, relocate eIther
BFP or Sign
12 Provide reduced (8 5"xl1 ") copy of landscape plan Sheet L1 1
13 Site plan mdlcates three eXlstmg signs on Gulf to Bay Boulevard Provide photographs of these
eXlstmg freestandmg Signs, as well as entrance and eXit signs, with dimenSIOns ofhelght and sign
area Include photographs and same mformatlOn for eXIstmg Fairfield Inn attached slgns
14 General Apphcablhty cntena #2 response - Change m second lme "transients" to other
appropnate temnnology
15 Area of bmldmg where attached slgnage IS proposed on Sheet A2 0 IS Just added height for
slgnage, not for elevators or stans Request needs to mdlCate, and Sheet A2 0, the highest pomt
of this portIOn of the bUlldmg above the nudpomt of the pllched roof Staff may not support thiS
additional height
16 Condltlon to be mcluded m Staff Report That a Umty of Title be recorded III the pubhc records
pnor to Issuance of J.ny penmt
17 Condition to be mcluded m Staff Report That thiS approval be subject to the vacation of those
portIOns of the Bay Street and alley to the north nghts-of-way by City CounCil pnor to the
Issuance of ,jny permits
18 Condition to be mcluded In Staff Report '1 hat thiS approval be subject to the annexatIOn of the
alley to the north by City CounCil pnor to the Issuance of any pemnts
19 Code requnes an mtenor landscape Island every 10 spaces (maximum allowable by staff IS 15
spaces m a row) Proposal mcludes eastern row of 16 spaces and southern row with 17 spaces
ReVise
20 Based on General Engmeenng's comment regardmg the vacatIOn of Ray Street, smce thiS prOject
won't get any of the proposed vacated nght-of-way, the number of overnight accommodatIOn
umts will exceed that pemnled Reduce and revise civil and archltectural plans
Other.
No Comments
Notes: ThiS apphcatlOn IS insuffiCient for the COB, due to ROW vacatIOn Issue & denSity If 11 can be resolved, then resubnut on
1/6/05 for 2/15105 COB Or, sub nut reVised plans and apphcatlOn package by noon on 1/31/05 for review by ORC on 313/05
Development ReView Agenda - Thursday, December 30, 2004 - Page 22
11:30 am
Case Number: ANX2004-1Lu20 -- 3070 GULF TO BAY BL VD
Owner(s)'
Rb-3 Associates
2555 Enterpnse Rd # 14
Clearwater, F133763
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Emall
LocatIOn AN UNNAMED RIGHT-OF-WAY 16 FEET IN WIDTH AND 300 FEET IN LENGTH ADJACENT TO THE
NORTH EDGE OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3070 GULF TO BA Y BOULEVARD, AT THE NORTHERN
TERMINUS OF BAY STREET AND APPROXIMA TEL Y 170 FEET WEST OF U S HIGHWAY 19
NORTH
Atlas Page 292A
Zonmg Dlstnct: C, Commercial
Request: AnnexatlOn (ANX2004-12020) approval to permit an unnamed flght-of-way 16 feet m WIdth and 300 feet m
length Site, located along the north edge 0 f 3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard and cons Istmg of one parcel
totalmg 0 II acres, mto the City of Clearwater and mltlal City Future Land Use Plan desIgnatIOn of
Commerctal General (CG) and Imtlal City Zonmg Atlas designatIOn ofC, Commercial (C)
Proposed Use Overmght accommodatIOns
NeIghborhood No NeIghborhood AssocatlOn Data
AssoclatIon(s),
Presenter: Mark Parry, Planner 1lI
Attendees Included:
The ORe reviewed this applicatIOn with the followmg comments:
General Engmeenng:
I I) No Issues
EnVironmental'
No Comment~
Fire'
No Comments
Harbor Master:
No Comments
Legal'
No Comments
Land Resources:
No Conunents
Landscapmg:
No Comments
Parks and Recreation'
No Comments
Stormw.l.ter'
No Comments
Solid Waste:
No Comments
Traffic Engmeermg:
No Conunents
Planmng,
No Comments
Other:
No Comments
Notes:
Development ReView Agenda - Thursday, December 30, 2004 - Page 23
,,.Ii'
Rb-3 Associates
2555 Enterpnse Rd # 14
Clearwater, Fl33763
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax, E-!vlAIL No Email
Wr-I Assoc13tes Ltd
2555 Enterpnse Rd
Clearwater, FI 33763-1 160
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax E-MAIL No Email
Randall Bcnderson 1993-1 Trust
2555 Enterpnse Rd
Clearwater, FI 33763-1 160
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Emall
~f\
'I..".'.
Ou.
~~
Owncr(s)'
CilSC N umbel FLD2004-11UlS 1 -- 3070 GULF TO BAY BL VO
11 30 am
Owner(s).
Owncrh)
RepresentatIve' Northslde Engllleenng Services Inc
601 Cleveland Street
Clearwater, FI33755
rEI EPHONE 727-443-2869, FAX 727-446-8036, E-MAIL debra@northsldeengllleenng com
LOl,ltlOtl 455 acres located at the northwest comer of Gulf to Bay Boulevard and McMullen Booth Road
Atld~ P,lgC 292A
Zonmg Dlslnct C, Commercml
Req u est ( I) F lex I b Ie Development approval to perm It an addltlonal ovem Ight accommodatIOn use wIth a reductIon
to the front (south) setback from 25 feet to 15 feet (to pavement) and to allow dIrect access to a major
artendl street, as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment ProJect, under the prOYISIonS of SectIOn 2-704 C,
(2) VacatIOn ofa portIOn of the Bay Street nght-of-way to the west and a portIOn of the alley to the north
Proposed Use Overmght accommodatlOns
Ne]ghborhood Clearwater Nelghborhoods CoalItlOn
As~ouatlon(s): Clem water, Fl 33761
2544 Fnsco Dnve
TELEPHONE 727-725-3345, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL DJw@gte net
Ne]ghborhood Bay Breeze Trailer Park
AssouatlOn(s): Clearwater, FI 33759
2975 Gulf1 0 Bay Blvd
TELEPHONE 727-796-2175, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Email
Presenter Wayne Wells, Planner III
Attendees Included Staff Wayne Wells, ChIp Gerlock, Rick Albee, Scott Rice, Joe Colbert
Apphcant/Rep Housh Ghovaee, Doreen WIllIams,
fhe DRC revIewed thiS application With the followrng comments.
CencI al Engllleerlllg
1 1) The vaUlllOn of Bay Street would nol benefit tlllS property for addmg addltlonal square footage
10 overallldnd aJea ThIS property was M & I3 23 02 and M & B 23 03, and not a part of the
subdIVISion thai dedIcated thIs flght-of-way to the City Therefore, thiS proposed vacated
plOperty would go 10 the owners on the west Side of Bay StIeellfapproved, not be splIt 50/50
Therefore, should not be shown on slte plan
PnO! to C 0
]) Unless Bay Street ]S vacated, grant a Sidewalk easement for the eXlstmg Sidewalk w]th1l1 the
southwest comer of property
En Vlronme ntal'
No Issues
Fire
Where undel ground water ma illS and hydrants are to be lllstaIled, they shall be 1I1stalled,
completed, and 111 servIce pnor to constructIOn as per NFP A 241 Please acknowledge PRlOR
-10 COB
2 All grate mlets located wlthlll dnve aIsles must be deSigned to meet FOOT HS-20
specifications PRIOR TO COB
3 TI1lS ORe Rev]ew by F]re IS not an approval or reVlew of any constructIOn plans or documents
other than sIte work PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE
Development Review Agenda - Tlullsday, December 30, 2004 - Page 20
-' ~,
Harbor Master,
I No lssues
Legal
1 (FlOffi Leshe Dougall-Sides) I notIced the Letter of Authonzatlon IS signed by Mr Baldaufas
onc Trustee of three of one of the coowners You may want to have the apphcant obtam the
approvals of the two cotrustees, Nathan Benderson and Ronald Benderson [unless the Trust
Agleement authoflzes Mr Balddufto represent them], as well as representatives of the other
coowners, RB-3 AssoClates and WR-l AssocJates, LId
Land Resources ....
I Show the canopies of "ALL" trees on "ALL" plan sheets pnor to CDB
2 If redesign IS reqUIred or considered preservatlOn of trees #20,23,43 and 51 must be considered
3 Remove tree #27, thIS tree IS dechnmg due to prevIous constructIOn activities (fill)
4 The proposed structure IS too close to trees #52-59, eIther move the structure outside of the
canopy or remove the trees ReVise pnor to CDB
5 Show an east/west sectIOn through tree # 51 No grade cuts can occur under the canopy of thiS
tlee Reconunend concrete "on grade" with a monolithic curb and WAN E aeratIOn system
Plovlde onor to CDB
6 Reroute utilities outside of the canopy of tree #51, revise pnor to COB
7 UtilizatIOn of your arbonst could have avoIded ALL of the above reqll1rements Recommend
utlhzmg your arboflst to assl~t with prehmmary deSigns so tree Impacts can be addressed and
mmlmlzed pnor to plan submittal
8 Plovlde d. Tree PreservatiOn Plan plepared by a certIfied arbonst, consultmg arbonst, landscape
\
ale/lIlect or other specwlist In the field of arb on culture ThiS plan must show how the proposed
bUlldmg, parkmg, stonnwater and utilities Impact the cntlcal root zones (dnp hnes) of tree to be
preserved and how you propose to address these Impacts Ie, crown elevatmg, root prumng
and/or root aeratIOn systems Other data reqUlred on thiS plan must show the trees canopy hne,
actual tree barncade hnuts (2/3 of the dllp hne and/or m the root prune hnes If reqUIred), and
the tree barncade detaIl And any other pertlllent lllformallOn relatmg to tree preservatIOn
PlOvlde pnor to bUlldlllg perrrut
l and sea pmg
I Show ALL eXlstlng tree canopies on plans and consider the height of the bUlldmg III relatiOn to
the tlee canopies
2 There l~ a row of "LI" on the west Side of Ihe retentIOn pond which wl11look great In the
surnmel months but serve httle puprose m the wmter months, revise thiS by addmg palms
and/or Substltutmg some of the trees With non-deciduous ones
3 The Island In the center of the mam dnve seems to be shnnkmg, try alternate layouts for the
pal kmg 10 lessen the number of dnves crossmg the center dnve and thiS would elurunate the
need to Impact the large tree m the Island
4 Landscape Plan does not show the Sight trlangles as dcscnbed 111 Article 3, DIVISIOn 9, revise
the plan to show these tnangles at all the street and dnveway mtersectlOns Although the street
(Bay 5t) IS to be vacated It WIll remalll as a shared dnve and wlil most hkely have VISibility
concerns
5 Plan does not meet the reqUirements of pen meter plantlngs III Code Section 3-1202 D Add
plants as needed 10 meet Code or show the "exlsltng landscapmg" III conjunctIOn WIth the
proposed
6 Per SectiOn 3-1202 E 1 - 1 Treehsland nulllmum, 1 Tree/ 150 sq it of requued green space,
Shrubs 50% of reqUIred green space, and Groundcover shall be uhhzed for reqUIred green
space In heu of turf
Parks and RecreatIOn:
Open Space, RecreatiOn Land and Recreation Facilities Impact fees are due for addltJonal
ploperty and 55 hotel rooms pnor to Issuance ofbUlldmg pernuts These fees could be
substantial and It IS recommended that you contact Deb Richter at 727-562-4817 to calculate
the assessment
Slormwaler'
Before BUlldmg Perrrut
1) ProVIde draw down calcs for pond and venfy pond IS functlOnmg as deSigned
Sohd Waste'
1 Please explam how Sohd Waste will be handled now and m the future If site IS sold off
Development Revlew Agenda - Thursday, December 30,2004 - Page 21
,;;. i<t
'1 raffle Engmeenng.
1 1 Provide an accessible route from one hotel to the other per Flonda AccessIblhty Code for
BUlldmg ConstructIOn Chapter 11 (SectIOn 11-4 3 2)
2 Use the word "typlca]" for dlmenslOnmg regular 9' X 19' parkmg stalls
3 Provide a CIty standard ]oadmg space (\2' x 35') outSide ofparlang spaces and dnve als]es
per Commumty Development Code, (SectIOn 3-]406)
4 All of the above to be addressed pnor to CDB
Traffic Impact Fee of $85,635 00 to be paId pnor to CO
PI an Illllg
]
2
3
4
5
Remove from SIte Data on Sheet C] 1 the "ReqUired" bUlldmg coverage and FAR (as there IS no
reqUirement)
Provide setback dlmenslOn from eXlstmg north property hne to eXlstmg pavement
Show locatIOn of eXlstmg easements on-site, as mdlcated In ExhibIt B of the deed
OlmenSlOn eXlstmg parkmg areh
Wheel stops I eqlllred adjacent to landscaped areas and Sidewalks, but are not reqUired where
abuttmg (rrontto front) other parkmg spaces, me!udll1g eXI~tmg parking lot ReVise
Only SIX handIcap ~paces reqUIred, based on number of reqUIred parkmg spaces, but there are 10
proposed (exlstmg or new) Suggest reduc mg by two handicap spaces by ehmma tmg eXlstmg
handIcap spaces from east Side of Fairfield Inn and replace with three regular parkmg spaces
Will plOpo.'.>ed Comfort SUites use the eXlstmg pool and dumpster west ofFalrfield Inn?
Extend proposed sldewalk on the east Side of Comfort SUites north to the eXlstmg pavement and
provide handicap ramps and a crosswalk to provide handicap accessIbilIty to Gulf to Bay
Boulevard
Sheet C I I - Lighten aenal map, as It IS too dark
Sheet C3 I - Show locatIOn of all proposed outdoor hghtmg fixtures
\ViiI propo<;ed BFP block views ofexlstll1g sign on Gulf to Bay Boulevard? Uso, relocate either
nFP or sign
Provide reduced (8 5"xl1 ") copy oflandscape plan Sheet L1 I
SIte plan ll1dlCa tes tlu ee eXlstll1g sIgns on Gulf to Bay Boulevard PrOVide photographs ofthese
eXisting freestandmg Signs, as well as entrance and exit signs, WIth dImenSIOns of height and sign
aJ ea Include photographs and same mformatlOn for eXIstmg F anfield Inn attached signs
General ApplIcability cntena #2 response - Change m second Ime "transients" to other
applopnate temunology
Area of bmldmg where attached sign age IS proposed on Sheet A2 0 IS Just added height for
slgnage not for elevator;:, or stairs Request needs to mdlcate, and Sheet A2 0, the highest pom!
oftlus porllon of the bUlldmg above the nudpomt of the pitched roof Staff may not support IhlS
addlllonal height
Condillon to be ll1e!uded m Staff Report That a Umty of Title be recorded m the pubhc records
pnor to Issuance of any pernut
Condltl on to be me! uded m S taft Report That thiS approval be subJ ect to the vaca lion of those
portIOns of tile Bay Street and alley to the north nghts-of-way by City Council pnor to the
Issuance 0 f any perl11lts
ConditIon to be ll1c1uded m Staff Report That thiS approval be subject to the annexat10n of the
alley to the north by City CounCIl pnor to the Issuance of any pernuts
Code reqUires an mtenor landsca pe Island every 10 spaces (maximum allowable by staff IS 15
spaces 111 a row) Proposalll1e ludes eastern row of 16 spaces and southern row With 17 spaces
ReVise
Based on General Engmeenng's comment regardmg the vaealion of Bay Street, slllce thiS project
won't gel any of the proposed vacated nght-of-way, the number of overnIght accommodation
umts Will exceed that penruted Reduce and revise CIvil and architectural plans
6
7
8
9
10
II
12
13
14
]5
16
]7
18
19
20
Other'
No Comments
Nolc~, TI1lS apphcatlOn IS msufficlent for the COB Subnut reVised plans and apphcatlon package by noon on 1/31/05 for review by
ORC on 3/3/05
Development ReView Agenda - Thursday, December 30,2004 - Page 22
-'
Pmellas County Property Appr~- "er Information 1629 ] 6 00000230 02(1n
,..
Page 2 0[5
,
16 I 29 I
16 I 00000 I 230 I 0200
28-tlov- 2: 0 04 JU'1 Sru th, CFA Plllellas County Property Appralser 19 11' Z3
Ownershlp Inforl'latlon lion -Res1.de n t 1. al Pl'opertlj Address, Use, and Sales
RB-3 ASSOCIATES aSK 10509 OPG 1010
B EtW E R5 011. N AT HA II TRE \
WR-l ASSOCIATES lTO
2:555 ENTERPRISE RD " 14
CLEARWATER Fl 33 7li 3-116 0
EVACUA TIO N ZONE, E
COl'lparab Ie sales value as Prop Addr, 3070 GULF TO BAV BlUD
of Jan 1- 2003, based on Census T r ac t 2:68 08
sales frof"l 2002 - 2003,
0 Sale Date OR Book/Page Price (QuaI/UnQ) Vae/Il'lp
Plat Inforl'lation 5 11.999 10,509/1,010 2:,391,000 (H) U
0000, Book Pgs - 0 /0 0/ 0 0 ( )
0000. Book Pgs - 0 /0 0/ 0 0 ( )
0000' Book Pgs - 0 /0 0/ 0 0 ( )
2004 Value EXE~'lP T 10 i~5
Jus t iI'larke t, 5,400,000 HOl'l8stead tlO Ownershlp % ,000
Govt Exel'l 110 Use % ,000
Assessed/Cap, 5,400.000 Instltutlonal EX81'l 110 Ta'{ E .{ e r'1p t %, . 000
Hlstorlc E~ePl 0
Ta'(able' 5,400,000 Agricultural 0
2004 Tax Inforl'latlon
Dlstrlct CW Seawall Frontage
Cleal'watel' Vlew
04 rvl1llage 2:2: 9694 Land Slze Unlt Land Land land
Fron t · Depth Prlce Unlts Meth
04 Tax ee . 124,034.76
1) 0 x 0 10 00 189,050 0 5
Speclal Tax , 00 2) 0 x 0 00 00
3) 0 y 0 .00 00
Wl thou t the Save-Our-HOl'lee 4) 0 '{ 0 00 .00
cap, 2004 taxes wlll be 5) 0 x 0 00 ,00
12:4,034.76 6) 0 x 0 00 ,DO
Wlthout any exel'lptlollS,
2004 tayes wlll be ,
12:4,034.76
Short Legal BAV UIEW TE RRAC E. BlK 3, lOTS 18 THRU 2:3 !tIel 8:
Descrlptlon HAJOR'S HAtIOR, LOT 1 8: 1/2: UAC All EV atl t{ 3: Ut~PlATTED
Building InformatIOn
http //pao co pi nel1as fl us/htbm/cgl-scr3 70= 1 &a= 1 &b= 1 &c= 1 &r= 16&s=4&t3= 1 &u=O&
11/28/2004
Plpellas County Property Apprp ~er Information 1629 16000002300:7(\1)
Page 3 of5
PI oRert~ and Land Use Code descnQtlOns
16 / 29 / 16 / 00000 / 230 / 0200
:01
28-Noy-2004 Jlm Smlth, CFA Plnellas County Property Appralser 19 11.23
C omrrler C lal Card 01 0 f 1 Irrip 1'0 vefllen t T yp e Ho tel/Ho te I ) 3 S t
Proper ty Address: 3070 IiU LF TO BA'i B lUD Prop Use, 31 Z Land Use: 39
Structural Elements
Foundation
Floor 5ysteM
Exterior Wall
He 19h t F ac tor
Party Wall
Structural Fraflle
Roo f FraMe
Roof Cover
Cablnet & 1'1111
Floor FJ.nJ.sh
Interlor FinJ.sh
Total UnJ.ts
special footing
Slab on Ii,'ade
Conc Block/Stucco
o
Ilone
Fire Proof St Steel
liable .& H~p
Celllent Tile
Aye"age
Carpet COMbinat~on
o ,'ywall
o
Heatlng & All' Heat~ng&Cooling Pckg
FJ.xtures 390
Bath Tile
ElectrJ.c
Shape Factor
Quallty
Year BUJ.lt
EffectJ.ve Age
Other Depreclatlon
FunctJ.on DeprecJ.atlon
Econoflllc DepreCJ.atlon
Floor Only
Aye rage
Square
Ayerage
Z. 001
3
o
o
o
81..1.1::> Areas
Descrlptlon Factor Area Descrlptlon Factor Area
1) Base Area 1 00 69.625 7) ,00 0
2) Open Po rch 30 1,596 8) 00 0
3) 00 0 9) .00 0
4) ,00 0 10) .00 0
5) 00 0 11) . 00 0
6) 00 0 12) 00 0
COJrnnercial Extra Features
Descrlption D1MenSlons Prlce UnltB Value ReO Year
1) ASPHA LT 31750 1. 50 31.750 47.630 47,630 2,001
2) PATIO/DECK 2196SF 3.00 2,196 6.590 6,060 2,001
3) POOL 3 5X 18 25,000.00 1 25.000 23,000 2.001
4) SPA/JAC/HT 4.500 00 1 4,500 4,140 Z. 001
5) fEtlCE 200U 11 00 200 2,200 2.020 2,001
6) ElEU PASS 30.000 00 2 60,000 55.200 2,001
TOTAL RECORD VALUE 138.050
Map With Property Address (non-vacant)
~~[!][!]g]BJ
http Ilpao co pmellas f1 us/htbm/cgl-scr3?0=1&a=1&b=l&c=I&r= 16&s=4&t3=I&u=0&
11128/2004
Pl,nellas County Property ApPl - ~el In formatIOn 16 29 16 00000 230 Q71l')
NUE
3GAO
Gwtr
Tel
~
3DD \ \
>- 8 '\
.",
<( ~ 4 5 --, :::I
CO -:) tl 2 _( b I
,..)
(j)
c'
,n
1'1
I<APOK
TRAILER PARI<
31)7[l
@T~ 52
OJ
ul
I'J
f')
I
!
I
I
I
I
I
~(,
-' II
't.-" 223 !7
10097 :r::.r:: a
thY....;
J
GULr:- TO BAY 1
~ GULr-TO~8AY I
~
-~ -"'-..................':....
'~'\
\ \
\ \
r- - =:-:= ,I \ \
\
v ..J II 1
I~. ,~,'O
/1 --, /1 ,
-'i . ~) Lt ,'-\ ere)
Page 4 of5
r
I
r
1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002)
http //pao eo pll1ellas fl us/htbl11/cgl-scr3?o= 1 &a=1 &b= 1 &c= 1 &r= 16&s=4&t3= 1 &u=O& 11/28/2004
PlI1ellas County Propel ty ApPl" "er Information 16 29 1600000230 O/A')
Page 5 of5
Pinellas County Property Appraiser
Parcel Information
Back to Search Pag~
An eXR1ananon of thIs screen
http //pao co pmellas fl us/htb1l1/cgl-scr3?o=1&a=l&b=l&c=1&r= 16&s=4&t3=I&u=0& 11/2812004
Page 1 of 1
~ ,i4. .,.)1_
I
From: Wells, Wayne
Sent: Tuesday, February 17,2004627 PM
To: 'Debra HarrIs'
Subject, RE FaIrfield Inn at Gulf~To-Bay and McMullen-Booth Road
Debra -
Checkmg my computer files, as the hard copy case file has been microfilmed, It appears that under FLS 00-07-46
Falliletd Inn was approved for 127 rooms/unlls on 4 3 acres (later the CDS approved on February 20,2001,
access to Gulf to Bay Boulevard for Fairfield Inn under case FL 00-12-64) Based on a maximum of 40
rooms/units per acre, a maximum of 172 rooms/units were possible Unless the outparcel (I think there IS one) IS
brought mto the miX, Increasing the lot area, it looks like only 45 rooms/units are available to be bUilt
Check With me tomorrow (Thursday) to set up a time to see me With the site plan
Wayne
-----Onglnal Messagen---
From: Debra Hams [mallto'debra@northsldeengmeenng com]
Sent: Monday, February 16, 2004 2'17 PM
To: Wells, Wayne
Subject: Fairfield Inn at Gulf-To-Bay and McMullen-Booth Road
Wayne,
I don't believe It was that long ago that this project of ours went before CDS (It was before my "tenure" here
at Northslde) The owner now would like to go back to the aoard for a second bUilding on site to house 93
additional rooms Housh IS skeptical of that bemg approved as he doesn't believe the site could support
that number of Units based on allowable denSity I have ,a ~ough draft site plan and we wowld ,like to meet
With you on II ASAP ~ ,;
Thanks,
Debra
~
;
fi Ie / ^ \MSSc\PDS\Planmng%20Department\C%20D%20B\FLEX\InactIve%20or%20FIms
2/19/2004
,~;;J ~
CHECKLIST FOR RESIDENTIAL AND ACCESSORY STANDARD
DEVELOPMENT
Name
Fairfield Inn
Address
3070 Gulf to Bay Blvd
Legal DescnptIon
see attached
File Number
FLS 00-07-46
Proposcd Use
Overnight Accommodations
Zomng Dlstnct
C - Commercial
Future Land Use Dlstnct
CG - Commercial General
-----------------------------------------@---------------------------------------------------------------
PROPOSED REQUIRED O.K. NOT 0 K.
PLANNER:
1 PERMITTED USE Retail Sales and Service Retail Sales and Service OK
2. COUNTY WIDE
PLAN
FAR 037 055 OK
ISR 045 095 OK
Density 127 UnIts 172 UnIts @ 40 unIts/ac OK
3. DISTIRCT
MINIMUM
ST ANDAROS .I\.J .Q.
LOT SIZE 187,466 sq ft 40,000 sq ft OK
FLAG LOT (3-105) N/A ""0:,.< N/A OK
LOI WIDTH 223 feet 200 feet OK
MAXIMUM 50 feet 25 feet NOT
HEIGHT OK
FRONT SETBACK 25 feet 25 feet OK
SIDE SETBACK ' 10 feet 10 feet OK
REAR SETBACK N/A N/A N/A
# OF PARKING 138 spaces 127 (lIumt) OK
SPACES
4 SJ<:TBACKS:
# OF FRONT YARDS Two N/A OK
CCC LINE N/A N/A OK
ENCROACHMENTS N/A N/A OK
SCENIC N/A N/A OK
BUILDING N/A N/A OK
PROPOSED REQUIRED OK. NOT O.K.
. a~~ - '"
WATERFRONT NO N/A OK
ACCESSORY N/A N/A OK
STRUCTURES
PLANNER CONT.
S UNITY OF rITLE N/A N/A OK
REQUIRED?
6 COLOR gansh? N/A N/A OK
7 EASEMENT? N/A N/A OK
8 MECHANICAL N/A N/A OK
EQUIPMENT
SCREENED?
LANDSCAPE:
1. PERIMETER
REQUIREMl.NTS
# OF TREES N/A N/A N/A
SIZE N/A N/A N/A
# OF SPECIES N/A N/A N/A
GRADE N/A N/A N!A
# OF SHRUBS N/A N/A N/A
SIZE ' N/A N/A N/A
GRADE N/A N/A N/A
2 IRlUGATION
SYSTEM
N/A N/A N/A
3. TREE REMOVAL
PERMIT
4. CLEARING
PERMIT
CIVIL
ENGINEERING
1. EROSION
CONTROL
2. STORMWATER
DETENTION
3 SIDEWALK
4. DRIVEWAY
Mark T Parry 7121/00
PRINT NAME OF REVIEWING PLANNER DATE REVIEWED
,
, ,
March 6, 2001
Mr Housh Ghovaee
NorthsIde EngmeerIng
304 S Belcher Road
Clearwater, FL 33765
RE Development Order regardmg case FL 00-12-64 at 3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
Dear Mr Ghovaee
This letter constitutes a Development Order pursuant to Sectlon 4-206 D 7 of the
Community Development Code On February 20, 2001, the Community Development
Board reviewed your applIcatIOn for Flexible Development apphcatIon to permIt direct
acecss to a major artenal street (Gulf to Bay Boulevard) for a proposed overnight
accommodation establishment as part of a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project
The proposal mcludes a 69,625 square foot, l27-room hotel Based on the applIcatIOn and
the staff recommendatIOn, the Board found that the proposal IS m compliance with the
standards and cntena for a Comprehensive Inti]] Redevelopment Project, the maximum
development potcntlal standards and all other applicable standards of the Community
Development Code The Community Development Board approved the appbeatlOn with
the followmg four condItIons
That access be hmlted to nght-m/nght-out on Gulf to Bay Boulevard wIth a raised
Island, per FOOT reqUirements,
2 That a certIficate of occupancy for the hotel not be Issued pnor to FDOT's mspectIOn
and approval of the rmsed safety Island and traffic "uprIghts",
3 That any proposed, freestandmg SIgn be limIted to SIX feet m height above the
finished grdde of the front lme of the parcel unless part of a ComprehenSive Sign
Program, as reqUIred by Code, and
4 That all future access to the outparcels be restrIcted to thIS smgle dnveway Requests
for an additIOnal dnveway for one or both outparcels WIll reqUlre further review by
the Planmng Department and Community Development Board
. ,.
March 6, 2001
Ghovaee - Page 2
Pursuant to SectIon 4-407, an applicatIon for a bUlldmg penmt shall be made wlthm one
year of Flexible Development approval (March 6, 2002) All reqUired ccrtlficates of
occupancy shall be obtamed wlthm one year of the date of Issuance of the bUlldmg
penmt TIme frames do not change wIth successive owners The Commumty
Development Board may grant an extension of time for a penod not to exceed one year
and only wlthm the ongmal penod ofvahdlty
Please remember that a bUlldmg permit and Impact fees wIll be reqUIred pnor to the
construclIon of the project Should you have any questlOns, please call Mark Parry,
Planner at 727-562-4558
Very truly yours,
Gerdld FIgurski, Chairman
Commumty Dcvelopment Board
<, \Plannmg Department\C D IJ\FLEX\lnnactlve or Fl1l1Shcd ApplicaltOns\Gulf to Bay 3070 Fairfield Inn - Approvcd\Gulflo Bay
3070 DEVELOPMENT ORDER doc
CDB Meetmg Date
Case Number
Agenda Item
February 20, 2001
FL 00-12-64
C4
BACKGROUND INFORMATION:
O\VNER:
LOCATION:
REQUEST:
PLANS REVIEWED:
SITE INFORMATION:
PROPERTY SIZE:
DIMENSIONS OF SITE:
PROPERTY USE:
Current use
Proposed use
PLAN CATEGORY:
ZONING DISTRICT:
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
ST AFF REPORT
RB-3 ASSOCiates, Randall Benderson 1993 - 1 Trust
3070 Gul f to Bay Boulevard
Flexible Development applIcation to permit direct access to
a major arterial street (Gulf to Bay Boulevard) for a
proposed overmght accommodatIOn establIshment as part
ofa ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project
SIte plan submitted by Northslde Engmeenng, Inc
4 3 acres, 187,466 square feet
464 feet Wide by 391 feet deep
OvernIght AccommodatIons (under constructlOU)
Overnight AccommodatIOns
CG, CommercIal General ClaSSIficatIOn
C, Commercial DIstnct
Page 1
ADJACENT LAND USES:
North RetentIOn pond
South CommercIal
East CommercIal
West Office
CHARACTER OF THE
IMMEDIATE VICINITY:
The ImmedIate vlclmty IS dommated by commercIal uses
ANALYSIS:
The site IS 43 acres located on the northwest comer of Gulf to Bay Boulevard and McMullen
Booth Road and east of Bay Street A 69,625 square foot, 127-room hotel (Fairfield Inn) IS
currently under constructIon The building Will be fifty feet m height and five stones Building
features mclude a charcoal-gray, shmgle roof, whIte and tan, stucco extenor and lattIcework
Other architectural features Include cornice !tnes and detailed wmdow treatments There IS one,
eXlstmg freestandmg Sign of 64 square feet approxllnately 20 feet In height, 10 feet from the
front (south) property lme The SIgn provided IdentIficatIon for a former RV/tral1cr park that
occupIed the site It will be removed WIth the development of the hotel
The site was the subject of a FleXIble Standard Development apphcatlOn (FLS 00-07-46) The
proposal mcludcd an mcrease m heIght from 25 feet to 50 feet for the overnight accommodation
establishment That application was approved on October 9, 2000 The site WIll also be
developed WIth two future commercial (outparcel) uses As a condItion of approval, all
development on the SIte WIll share access
One CrIterIon whIch must be met for an Increase In heIght as part of a FleXIble Standard
Development app!tcatlon IS that the parcel proposed for development fronts on, but will not
Involve dIrect access to, a major artenal street The approved sIte plan proVided access from a
secondary street (Bay Street) located on the west SIde of the property and from the McMullen
Booth Road service road on the east Side of the site The appltcant IS seekmg to amend that sIte
plan by provIdmg nght-m/nght-out access along Gulf to Bay Boulevard, a major artenal street
The only available optIOn IS to request a ComprehensIve Infi]] Redevelopment Project use
The current proposal remams otherwIse the same as prevlOusly approved An eXlstmg entrance
on Gulf to Bay Boulevard located approxllnately 180 feet west of the McMullen Booth Road
service road will be removed The proposal also mcludes extensive landscaping on the Intenor
of the site and along Gulf to Bay Boulevard, McMullen Booth Road and Bay Street The
landscapmg Will be mstalled along all three street frontages prIor to the Issuance of a certificate
of occupancy for the hotel
Page 2
An analysIs by the City's Traffic OperatIOns Engmeer shows that provldmg the proposed access
pomt along Gulf to Bay Boulevard may help prevent potentIal congestIOn on Bay Street The
proposed access pomt may also encourage motonsts who desire to travel east on Gulf to Bay
Boulevard to travel west and use a proper U-turn approximately 300 feet west of Bay Street
Staff was mItIally concerned about the use of the Gulf to Bay Boulevard curb lane as an
acceleration lane for motOrists headmg west from southbound McMullen Booth Road and as a
deceleratIon lane for motonsts seekmg to entcr the SIte Staff was concerned that there would be
a potential for aCCidents as motonsts slowed to enter the site from the Gulf to Bay Boulevard
deceleration lane while southbound, right-turn motOrists sped up to merge onto Gulf to Bay
Boulevard Field observatIOns by the City's Traffic Operations Engmeer showed that motonsts
merge WIth traffic on Gulf to Bay Boulevard pnor to reachmg the eXlstmg access pomt located
40 fect east of the proposed nght-m/nght-out access pomt
The Traffic OperatIons Engmeer's observatIon also mdlcated that traffic travellmg southbound
on Bay Street turns left (eastbound) onto Gulf to Bay Boulevard The current users of Bay Street
are the occupants of the office bulldmg directly across Bay Strcet from the hotel DUring heavy,
eastbound traffic, thiS movement IS made through or temporanly stores m the eXlstmg stnped
safety Island before contmumg eastbound on Gulf to Bay Boulevard ThiS optIOn will soon be
ehmmated as the Flonda Department of TransportatIOn (FDOT) IS proposmg to remove the
stnped area by constructing a raised Island With traffic "upnghts" The mstallatiOn of a raised
Island IS a conditIon for recelvmg a dnveway permit that FDOT has placed on the apphcant Staff
recommends d certIficate of occupancy not be Issued pnor to FDOT's mspectIon and approval
the mstallatlon of the raised safety Island and traffic "upnghts" ThiS request IS Important to
directly correspond use of the new Gulf to Bay Boulevard dnveway With safety Improvements
directly related to the hotel's traffic
The safest method of headmg eastbound on Gulf to Bay Boulevard from the SIte IS to travel west
(approximately 300 feet) and make a U-turn from the two-way, left turn lane By provldmg a
nght-m/nght-out access po lOt along Gulf to Bay Boulevard, motonsts will have an additIOnal
optIOn for eXIting onto Gulf to Bay Boulevard and aVOldmg potential problems that eXIst at Bay
Street A nght-out only eXIt onto Gulf to Bay Boulevard may also encourage motonsts leavmg
the Site, who desire to travel east on Gulf to Bay Boulevard, to utIlize the much safer method
outlined above
A nght-m/nght-out access pomt along Gulf to Bay Boulevard proVIdes an alternatlve to traffic
seekmg to travel either cast or west bound on Gulf to Bay Boulevard, and may help prevent
potentIal congestIOn on Bay Street
CODE ENFORCEMENT ANALYSIS:
There are no outstandmg code enforcement viOlatlons related to thIS site
Page 3
A. COMPLIANCE WITH MAXIMUM DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL STANDARD IN
THE C, COMMERCIAL DISTRICT:
STANDARD PERMITTED/ EXISTING PROPOSED IN
REQUIRED COMPLIANCE?
FLOOR AREA 055 Under 037 Yes
RATIO Construction
IMPERVIOUS 095 Under 045 Yes
SURFACE Construction
RATIO
B. FLEXIBILITY STANDARDS FOR COMPREHENSIVE INFILL
REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS IN THE C, COMMERCIAL DISTRICT:
STANDARD PERMITTED/ EXISTING PROPOSED IN
REQUIRED COMPLIANCE?
LOT AREA N/A 187,466 187,466 square Yes
minimum square feet feet
LOT WIDTH N/A 464 feet 464 feet Yes
mInimum
HEIGHT N/A Under 50 feet Yes
maximum ConstructIon
FRONT YARD N/A Under Gulf to Bay Yes
SETBACK Construction Boulevard 130
minimum feet
McMullen Booth
Road 25 feet
Bay Street 25
feet
SIDE YARD N/A Under North 10 feet Yes
SETBACK ConstructIon
mInimum
Page 4
STANDARD PERMITTED/ EXISTING PROPOSED IN
REQUIRED COMPLIANCE?
REAR YARD N/A* N/A* N/A* N/A*
SETBACK
minimum
PARKING Detenmned by Under 129 Yes
SPACES the Commumty Construction
mlDlmum Development
Coordmator
based on specific
use and/or lTE
Manual ·
*
Corner lots have two front yard setbacks and two Side yard setbacks
. Staff used the reqUired ratIo for parkmg spaces for overnIght accommodatIons In the
CommerCial Dlstnct (1 space per umt (127 umts proposed) = 127 reqUired parkmg spaces)
C. FLEXIBILITY CRITERIA FOR COMPREHENSIVE INFILL REDEVELOPMENT
PROJECTS WITHIN THE C, COMMERCIAL DISTRICT:
1. The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for development is
otherwise impractical without deViations from the use, intensity and development
standards.
An overnight accommodatIOns use, without any vanatlOns from Code, would otherwIse
be permitted direct access from a major artenal In thiS case, an mcrease m height was
requested as part of the ongmal FleXIble Standard development applicatIOn access be
prOVided from the McMullen Booth Road service road and Bay Street as part of the
ongmally approved site plan The Code cntena for overnIght accommodatIOns under
the FleXIble Standard and FleXIble Development reqUire frontage on an artenal road
wIthout access to that road
The access pOll1t along Bay Street presents an eXlstll1g, dangerous ll1tersechon for
motonsts attemptmg to travel and ellher temporanly store of Immediately cross through
an eXlstll1g stnped safety Island FDOT has recogmzed thiS problem and has proposed
to replace thIS area with a raIsed Island and traffic "upnghts " A nght-m/nght out only
access pOll1t along Gulf to Bay Boulevard will not negatively Impact the level of serVIce
on Gulf to Bay Boulevard It WIll encourage motonsts leavmg the site to merge with
traffic on Gulf to Bay Boulevard and utIlIze a proper U-turn located approximately 300
feet west of the SIte
Page 5
2. The development of the parcel proposed for development, as a Comprehensive
Infill Redevelopment Project will not materially reduce the fair market value of
abutting properties.
The current assessed value of the property IS estimated to be $750,000 After the
proposed Improvements are made, the value IS expected to be $1,500,000 The
proposed access pOInt IS Intended to present safer alternatives for rnotonsts seekIng to
travel eastbound on Gulf to Bay Boulevard The added curb cut may also prevent
congestIOn on Bay Street which provIdes access to a residential neighborhood
3. The uses within the Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project are otherwise
permitted in the City of Clearwater.
The Commerc13l Dlstnct and the City permIt overnIght accommodatIOns
4. The uses or mix of uses within the Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project
are compatible with adjacent land uses.
The surroundmg uses are commerc13l and thIS proposal wIll be compattble wIth adJ3cent
land uses
5. SUitable sites for development or redevelopment of the uses or mix of uses within
the Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project are not otherwise available in the
City of Clearwater.
A five-story hotel IS currently under constructIOn on the site Although the Code
restncts hotel access onto artenal roads, thIS proposal IS lImIted to and nght-m/nght-out
tummg movements only
6. The development of the parcel proposed for development as a Comprehensive
Infill Redevelopment Project will upgrade the Immediate vicimty of the parcel
proposed for development.
Improvements planned for the site Include landscapIng In excess of the Intent of Code
and constructIng an attractIve, new bUlldmg Other architectural features mclude
cornice lines and detaIled WIndow treatments The economiC value of the property IS
expected to Increase with the proposed enhancements and wIll complIment the highly
vIsible McMullen Booth Road and Gulf to Bay Boulevard comdors Improvements to
thiS site may lead to reInvestment In adjacent properties aIdIng m the sustamabIlIty of
the neighborhood
Page 6
7. The design of the proposed Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project creates a
form and function that enhances the community character of the immedIate
VICIDlty of the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a
whole.
The mvestments made to property will benefit the Immediate neighborhood through
enhanced aesthetics, mcreased property values, and the potential to mfluence adjacent
property owners Provldmg direct access from Gulf to Bay Boulevard may ehmmate
problems mcludmg congestion on Bay Street and dangerous, illegal U-turns by
motonsts eXltmg Bay Street to eastbound Gulf to Bay Boulevard
8. Flexibility in regard to lot width, required setbacks, height, off-street parking
access or other development standards are justified by the benefits to community
character and the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and
the City of Clearwater as a whole.
An analYSIS by the CIty's Traffic Operattons Engmeer shows that prOViding the
proposed, restncted access pomt along Gulf to Bay Boulevard may help prevent
potentIal congestIon on Bay Street and confllctmg turning movements The proposed
access pomt may also encourage motonsts who desIre to travel east on Gulf to Bay
Boulevard 10 use a proper V-turn approximately 300 feet west of the SIte
9. Adequate off-street parking in the immediate vicinity according to the shared
parking formula in Division 14 of Article 3 will be available to avoid on-street
parkmg in the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development.
Ovcrmght accommodatIOns reqUire one parkmg space per umt The hotel will have
127 rooms requmng 127 parkmg spaces The applIcant IS proposmg to locate 129
parkmg spaces that WIll meet all parkmg reqUirements All reqUired parkmg wtll be
contained on.slte
l
Page 7
D. GENERAL APPLICABILITY: Conditions which are imposed by the CommuDlty
Development Coordinator and the Community Development Board pursuant to a Level
One or a Level Two Approval shall ensure that:
1. The proposed development of the land will be in harmony with the scale, bulk,
coverage, density, and character of adjacent properties in which it is located.
The hotel under constructIon wIll be an attractlve Improvement to the sIte The area has
been developed with a mix of offices and retail uses The development of a hotel will be
In harmony with the scale and character of adjacent properties It wIll provide a
restrIcted access pomt along Gulf to Bay Boulevard that may reduce traffic congestIon
along Bay Street These problems Include motonsts makmg dangerous, Illegallefi turns
In order to travel east on Gulfto Bay Boulevard
2. The proposed development will not hinder or discourage the appropriate
development and use of adjacent land and buildings or significantly Impair the
value thereof.
Thc site IS zoned Commercial Dlstnct and the proposed use WIll be m complIance with
that zonmg The proposed development should not dIscourage approprIate development
and use of adjacent land bUIldmgs Site Improvements mclude landscapmg m excess of
Code reqUirements and an attractIve, new bUIldmg Locatmg a nght-m/nght out access
along Gulf to Bay Boulevard will provide motonsts with a safer alternatIve ThIs access
pomt may allow motonsts who desIre to travel eastbound on Gulf to Bay Boulevard the
opportumty to merge with traffic and use a safer V-turn 300 feet west of Bay Street
3. The proposed development will not adversely affect the health or safety or persons
residmg or working m the neighborhood of the proposed use.
Accordmg to the City's Traffic OperatIons Engmeer, the proposed access along Gulf to
Bay Boulevard may Improve potentIal traffic conflIcts at Bay Street
4. The proposed development is designed to minimize traffic congestion.
Gulf to Bay Boulevard operates at Level of ServIce D McMullen Booth Road operates
at Level of Service F The capacity of Gul f to Bay Boulevard can absorb 683 peak hour
directIOnal tnps The proposed hotel Win generate 597 tnps per day and only 77 peak
hour tnps The proposal WIll allow provide for easy access Via Gulf to Bay Boulevard,
McMullen Booth Road or Bay Street It also reduces the potential for Improper and
unsafe V-turns at Bay Street
Page 8
5. The proposed development is consistent with the community character of the
immediate ViCIDlty of the parcel proposed for development.
The hotel under construction wIillmprove the commumty character of the Immediate
VICInIty The site improvements Include landscapmg m excess of Code In association
with an attractIve new bUIldmg Providing a nght-m/nght-out only access pomt from
along Gulf to Bay Boulevard WIll provide motonsts wIth a safer alternatIve travelmg
west or eastbound on Gulf to Bay Boulevard and may prevent potentIal congestIOn on
Bay Street
6. The design of the proposed development mlDlmlZes adverse effects, including
visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operation impacts, on adjacent
properties.
The overall sIte, mcludmg outparcels, has been desIgned With umform landscaplllg and
coordlllated access No addItIonal access pomts will be provided
Page 9
SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION:
The apphcatlOn and supportmg matenals were reviewed by the Development RevIew Committee
on January 18,2001 The proposal IS m compliance with the standards and cntena for FlexIble
Development approval, the maximum development potential, reqmrements of ComprehensIve
Infill Redevelopment ProJects, and with all applicable standards of the Community Development
Code
The Planning Department recommends APPROVAL of the Flexible Development applIcatlOn to
pennlt direct access to a major artenal street (Gulf to Bay Boulevard) for a proposed overnight
accommodatlon estabhshment as part of a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment ProJect, for the
site at 3070 Gulf to Bay Boulevard with the followmg conditions
That access be limIted to nght-m/nght-out on Gulf to Bay Boulevard WIth a raised
Island, per FDOT reqUlrements,
2 That a ccrtlficate of occupancy for the hotel not be Issued pnor to FDOT's mspectlon
and approval of the raised safety Island and traffic "upnghts",
3 That any proposed, freestandmg sign be bmlted to SIX feet III heIght above the
fimshed grade of the front Ime of the parcel unless part of a ComprehensIve Sign
Program, as reqUIred by Code, and
4 That all future access to the outparcels be restncted to thiS smgle dnveway Requests
for an additional dnveway for one or both outparcels WIll reqmre further review by
the Planmng Department and Commumty Development Board
Prepared by Mark T Parry, Planner
A TT ACHMENTS
Aenal Photograph of SIte and VICInity
LocatIOn Map
Future Land Use Map
Zonmg Atlas Map
ApplicatIon
S \Plllnnmg Deparllllem1C D B1FI.EX\Pendmg ApplwalwnslGldflO Bay 3010 Fmtfleld InnlGlIlflo Bay 3070 !!.lAFF REPORl doc
Page 10
r{
"
\;
CITY OF CLEARWATER
NOTICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD PUBLIC HEARINGS
The Commumty Development Board of the City of Clearwater, Florida, will hold pubhc heanngs on fuesday, February
15,21105, beglnmng at 1 00 pm, In the City CouncIl Chambers, m City Hall, 3rd floor, 112 South Osceola Ave, Clearwater,
Flonda, to consIder the foJJowmg requests
NOTE All persons wlshml! to address an Item need to be present at the BEGINNING of the meehnl! Those cases
that are not contested bv the applicant. ~taff. nell!hbonRlZ property owners. etc, Will be placed on a consent al!enda
and approved bv a smele vote at the beemmne of the meetmg.
1 Clearwater Bav Manna. LLC (5 I D Clearwater Manna, LLC) are requesting approval of a prehmmary plat
(Proposed Use: 133 attached dwcllmg umts) at 900 North Osceola Ave, J A Gorra's Sub, Blk 2, Lots 2&3, part of Lot I
and VAC Nicholson St, Sue Barco Sub, Lots 1,13&14, Lot 23, part of Lot 22, FT Blish's Sub, Lots 1-3, Lots 8-10 and
tnnglland to West, Sec 09-29-15, M&B 1401 Presenter Mark T Parry, Planner III PL T2004-000t2/FLD2004-07053
2 Court Street Townhomes. LLC (Court Street Villas, LLC) are requestmg a FleXible Development approval to pcrrmt
the transfer of 2 dwellmg umts from 608/610/611 Harold Ct to 830 Court St to be mcluded as part of a 13-umt attached
dwelling development (case FLS2004-06045) under the provISIons of SectIOns 4-1402 - 1403, Flexlb]e Development
apphcahon to penrut attached dwelhngs (13 Ulllt<;) wlthm the Downtown Dl<;tnet and a bUlldmg wlthm the reqUIred sIght
vIsibility tnangles along the unnamed alley along the north <;Ide of the site under the provIsIOns of Sec 2-903 C, as part of a
ComprehenSIve Infill Redeve]opment Project and a prelnrunary plat (PL T2004-00008) (Proposed Use 13 attached
dwellmgs) at 830 Court St, Aiken Sub, Blk 10, Lot 6 Presenter Mark T Pany, Planner III TDR2004-080101
FLD200S-010011 PL T21104-00008
3 JMB&A Developers LLC (R&S Investments of Pmella&, LLC & La Fiesta Bnghtwater, LLC) arc requestmg a FleXible
Development approval to penmt attached dwellings with a reductIOn to lot area from 10,000 to 7,214 sq ft, a reductIOn to lot
Width from 100 ft to 60 ft and an mcrease to bmldmg height of an additional 3 ft for penmeter parapets (from roof deck -
roof deek at 35-ft heIght) and to penrut a bUlldmg Wlthm the vIsIbility tTlangles, under the provIsIOns of See 2-803 B
(Proposed Use Attached dwellmgs (3 condoll1l111ums) at 105 Brll!htwater Dr. Bayslde Sub, No 2, Lot 2 Presenter:
Wayne M Wells, AlCP, Planner III FLD2004-09065
<;>
~
'lf1
4 RB~3 ASSOcIates. Nathan Henderson. Tre. and WR-1 ASSOCIates LTD (Benders on Deve]opment Company, Inc) are
requestmg (I) FlexIble Development approval to pemut an overnight accommodatIOn use With 55 addltlOna] rooms/umt<;
With a reductIOn to the front (south) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to pavement), a reductIOn to the Side (north) setback from
10 ft to 95ft (to eXlstmg pavement), an mcrease to bUlldmg height from 25 ft to 4833 ft (to nnd-pomt of pitched roof) WIth
an additional 12083 ft for architectural embellishments (above the nnd-pomt of pitched roof) and a dtvlatlOn to allow direct
acces:;, to a major artenal street, as a ComprehenSive Intill Redevelopment ProJect, under the p~ovlslOns ofSec 2-704 C, (2)
VacatIOn of a portIOn of the Bay St nght-of-way to the west and a porhon of the alley to the north (Proposed Use:
OvernIght accommodatIOns (addltlonal 55 rooms/umb) at 3070 Gulf to Bav Blvd. Bay View Terrace, Blk 3, Lots 18-23
Incl & Major's Manor, Lot 1 & 'h Vac Alley on N presentcrS::WaYrle-M :"Wells,_AlCuratmer [II FLD2004-11081
5 Haddon House Inn. Inc. & Roland ROller.. (Hdddon House of Clearwater, LLC) are requestmg (1) Flexlble
Development approval to pemut attached dwelhngs WIth reduchom, to the front (&outh) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to
bUl]dlng) and from 25 ft to 42ft (to trash stagmg area), a reductIOn to the front (west) setback from 25 ft to 8 ft from the
Coastal ConstructIOn Control Lme (to pool deck), reductIOns to the Side (north) setback from lOft to 59ft (to bUlldmg) and
from 10 ft to 5 ft (to pool deck) and from 10 ft to 2 ft (to &Idewalk), a reductIOn to the Side (we<;t) setback from 10 ft to 32ft
(to Sidewalk), a reductIOn to the Side (cast) setback from 10 ft to 6 ft (to :>ldewalk), and all merease to height from 30 ft to 64
ft (to roof deck) With an additional 4 16 ft for pen meter parapet (from roof deck) and an additIOnal 15 83 ft for a rooftop
pavilIOn (from roof deck), and change of u:>c from Overmght AccommodatIOns to Attached Dwellmgs, as a Res1dentlallntill
ProJect, under the provISIons of See 2-404 F, and (2) Transfer of Development Rights for I dwelling Umt from 321
Coronado Dr, under the provISlOn& of Sec 4-1403 (TDR2004-10014) (Proposed Use Attached dwellings (]4
condommmms) at 12 IdleWlld St, Columbia Sub, No 2, Blk A, Lot 6 and Clearwater Beach Rev, Blk 3, Lots 1, 13-15 and
part oflot 12 Presenter. Key! L Groff, Planner II .'LD2004-)1I076/TDR2004-10014
6 Valerie LAvers. Tre (Jonnattl Architecture, Inc) arc requestmg a Flexible Developmt.nt approval to penmt d 151 &q ft
addltlOn to an cXlstmg bUlldlllg Wlth a reduetlOn to the front (we<;t) setback from 25 ft to 2 9 fi (to pavement) dnd 169ft (to
\'\
\ r
\ J
\ I
j
eXlst111g buddmg), the front (north) setback from 25 n to 39ft (to pavement) and 207ft (to eXI~tmg bUlldmg), a reduction
111 the SIde (east) ~etback from lOft to 5 ft (to pavement), and the ~Ide (south) setbdck from 10 ft 103ft (to pdvement) under
the provl~lOns of See 2-704 C , as a Comprehensive Infil! Redevelopment Project, and a reduction to the laml~cape buffer
along the west side from 15 ft to 29ft, a reductIOn to the landscape buffer along the north SIde from 15 n to 39ft, and a
reductIOn to the land~cape buffer along the ~outh side from 5 ft to 3 ft, a" a ComprehensIve Land"cape Program, under the
proVISIOns of Sec 1202 G (Propo"ed Use. Dental office) at 501 S. MiSSOUri Ave, HIbiscus Garden", Blk R, Lots 21, 12-
35 & part of30A Presenter Michael H Reynold", A1CP, Planner 111 FLD2004-11079
7 Florence Panteles IS requesting a Flexible Devdopment approval to re-establIsh a major vehicle ~erVlce use .....,th a front
(west) setback reductIOn from 25 ft to zero ft (to eXisting pavement), an east Side setback reductIOn from 10ft to LCro ft (to
eXisting pavement), a south SIde "ctback reductIOn from 10 ft to zero ft (to propo"ed pavement), as a Compn:,henslve lnfill
Redevelopment Project under the proVISIon" of Sec 2-704 and as a ComprehenSive Landscape Program under the provlSlOn~
ofSec 3-1202 G (Proposed Use Auto body shop), at 1501 S. Ft Hamson Ave, Sec 21-29-15, M&B 4408 Presenter
MIchael H Reynolds, AICP, Planner III FLD2004-0100S
Interested parties may appear and bc heard at the heanng" or file wntten notice of approval or objectIOn wIth the Planning
Interested parties may appear and be heard at the hearmg or file wntten notlce of approval or objection WIth the Plannlllg
Director or City Clerk pnor to the heanng Any person who decide" to appeal any decI~lon made by the Board or Councll,
with respect to any matter conSidered at such heanngs, wIll need to request a record of the proceedmgs and, for such
purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim rCLOrd of the proceedmgs IS made, wluch record mc1udes the testimony and
eVIdence upon whIch the appcalls to be based per Flonda Statute 2860105 Commuruty Development Code Sec 4-206
states that party status shdll be granted by the Board m quasI-JudICial case~ If the peThon requestmg such status demonstrates that
s/he IS ~ubstanhally affected Pdrty status entitles partIes to personally testify, present eVidence, argument and Witnesses, cross-
exarrune WItnesses, appcal the decIsIon and speak on reconSIderation requests, and needs to be requested and obtamed dunng
the case dlscu~slOn before the CDB
An oath Will be admmlstered sweanng m all persons glVlllg teshmony III quasI-JudicIal pubhc heanng ca"e" If you wIsh to
speak at the meetmg, please walt to be recogrnzed, then state and spell your name and prOVide your address Persons
Without party status speakmg before the CDB shall be limIted to three rrunutes unless an mdlvldualls representmg a group
In whIch case the ChaIrperson may authonzc a reasonable amount of time up to 10 rruoutes
Five days pnor to the meetmg, stafT reports and reconunendatJons on the above requests Will be avmlable for revIew by
mterested parties between the hours of 8 30 a m and 4 30 pm, weekdays, at the City of Clearwater, Planmng Department,
100 S Myrtle Ave, Clearwater, FL 33756 Please contact the case pre"'enter, at 562-4567 to dl"'cuss any questIOns or
concerns about the projcct and/or to better understand the proposal and reVIew the site plan
Cyndl Tarapam
PIannmg DIrector
CynthIa E Goudeau, CMC
City Clerk
City of Clearwater
POBox 4748, Clearwater, FL 33758-4748
NOTE Apphcant or representative must be present at the heanng
YOU ARE BEING SENT THIS NOTICE IF YOU ARE THE APPLICANT OR OWN PROPERTY WITHIN 200 IT OF
THE SUBJECT PROPERTY
A COpy OF THIS AD IN LARGE PRINT IS AVAILABLE IN OFFICIAL RECORDS AND LEGISLATIVE
SERVICES. ANY PERSON WITH A DISABUxrV REOUIRING REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION IN
ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING SHOULD CALL (727) 562-4093 WITH THEIR REQUEST
Ad 01/30/05
, I--
~
FERRARA, LEONARD V
221 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 162
, ,
CLEARW A TER FL 33759 - 4434
PEKAREK, ROBERT C
PEKAREK, MARY A
756 OAK KNOLL DR
LAKE FOREST II.., 60045 - 2632
EDSALL, DANlEL
EDSALL, BRENDA
3101 DOWNING ST
CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 4504
GEORGE, UBALD C
GEORGE, JESSICA
223 TlMBERBANK BLVD
SCARBOROUGH ON M I W 2A 7
00030 -
rANADA
COGSWELL, TIMOTHY R
PO BOX 120444
ARLINGTON TX 76012 - 0444
TRADEWINDS CONDO ASSN INC
CIO MATA ENTERPRISES
130 I SEMINOLE BLVD STE 110
LARGO FL 33770 - 8]24
BLOMMEL, RONALD J
601 E 16TH AVE
DENVER CO 80203 - 2015
BRANCO, TEOFII,O A
BRANCO, MARIA B
50 LEEWARD DR
BRAMPTON ON L6S 5V7 00030-
CANADA
MALONE, RICHARD M
353 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # ] 33
CLEARW AIER FL 33759 - 4526
GUTHRIE, JOYCE A
337 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 157
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4518
SMEKT ALA, SLA WOMIR
MACHON-SMEKT !\LA, HANNA
225 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 172
CLEARW A TER FL 33759 - 4436
ST ARCZEWSKI, STEPHEN W
STARCZEWSKI, EVELYN M
21209 ALEXANDER 8T
ST CLAIR SHRS MI 48081 - 1823
BAPTISTA, ARNOLD A
BAPTISTA, HAZEL M
2065 LYNN HEIGHTS DR
PICKERING ON LlX IP9 00030-
CANADA
STEVENS, FRANCIS A
STEVENS, JANICE A
272 SHA WO.MET AVE
WARWICK RI 02889 - 3641
DENOW,H KATHERINE
1901 N OLDEN AVENUE EXT # 14
TRENTON NJ 08618 - 2111
CARDOZA, CHARLES M
CARDOZA, ROSE A
213 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 196
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4430
BAEZ, JAVIER
205 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 201
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4426
CLARK, JAMES E
CLARK, JOANN
7575 HOLDERMAN ST
LEWIS CENTER OH 43035 - 6007
HEPBURN, MARASHII, D
221 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
CLEARW ATER FL 33759 -
KILLENBERG, JOHN P
KlLLENBERG, CARYL E
3447 N NEENAH AVE
CHICAGO IL 60634 - 3826
KELL Y, ALGXANDER E
KELL Y, ROWLENE L
640 S GAINSBOROUGH AVE
ROY AI.., OAK 111 48067 - 2913
KALAJDZIC, MARKO
KALAJDZIC, SLADJANA
1155 50TH AVE N
ST PETERSBURG FL 33703 - 2725
TAYLOR, rvIURIEL A TRE
359 MCMULLEN BOocI H RD # 121
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4529
SPTNE, SAM
355 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 114
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4527
CORRY, CATHERINE G
PL YER, DAVID A
3021 TENNESSEE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4334
HESSNER, CHRISTOPHER W
206 BEDFORD S1'
OLDSMAR FL 34677 - 3310
MAHRTNGER, GUENTER
MAHRINGER, BETTY
AM URNENFRIEDHOF 40
24790 SCHACHT-AUDORF 00004-
GER1v1ANY
CRUM PROPERfrnS
3040 GULF TO BA Y BLVD # 200
CLEARWA'IER FL 33759 - 4318
PITZAFERRO, MICHAEL N III
PITZAFERRO, CAROL YNN
3818 COUNIRYSIDE
GLENVIEW II, 60025 - 3707
FIAMMA, TERESA A
393 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 4
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4546
CRUM PROPFRTlES
3040 GULF 1 0 BAY BLVD STE 110
CLEARWATERFL 33759 - 4317
QUISH, THOMAS
379 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4539
BLISS, PATRICIA E
359 MCMULLEN BOO'I H RD S # 124
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4529
DEGARLAIS, LLOYD J
237 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 50
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4441
FINCHAM, JOAN M
SMALLEY, KARA B
BLDG 13, UNIT 104
2400 WINDING CREEK BLVD
CLEARW ATER FL 33761 - 4326
BAUMEl', GEORGE A TRE
BAUMEl', EVEL)TN A TRE
194 GULF WAY
OLDSMAR FL 34677 - 2414
SKOGLUND, LAVINA H
237 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 52
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4441
WECHSLER, SERGIO
670 ISLAND WAY # 300
CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1970
REBELLO, MELVILLE S
REBELLO, DENISE M
48 POINSETT A DR
THORNHILL ON L3T 2T6 00030-
CANADA
RB-3 ASSOCIATES
BENDERSON, NATHAN TRE
2555 ENTERPRISE R D # 14
CLEARWATER FL 33763 - 1118
CALASCIDETTA, SAM
CALASCffiETTA, PATRICIA A
680 I W DEVON AVE
CH1CAGO IL 60631 - 2032
WILLIAMS, VIRGINIA A
BLOMBERG,MARGARETL
1850 JUANITA C1
CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 6681
MUGICA, FERNANDO
213 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 193
CLEARWATERFL 33759 -4430
CABRAL, MARY R
229 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 59
CLEARWATERFL 33759 - 4437
MC MAHAN, LISA E
10120 CEDAR DUNE DR
T A1\1P A FL 3 )624 - 5099
CHRISTIE, ROBERT
16 PANORAMA CRESCENT
BRAMPTON ON L6S 31'9 00030-
CANADA
CHRISTIE, MARY
16 PANORAMA CRESCENT
BRAMPTON ON L6S 3T9 00030-
CANADA
KISH, JAMES P
KISH, MARILYN A
]718 W 96TH AVE
CROWN POINT IN 46307 - 2119
SCHWARZ, BEGNNFR M
SCHWARZ, CLAUDIA Y
39650 US HWY 19 N # 756
TARPON SPRINGS FL 34689 -79]9
ZOANETTE, VICTOR
247 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
CLEARWATER FL 33759 -
LANGSTON, JARRETT V
249 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
CLEARWATERFL 33759-
CRABB, JOHN R TRE
CRABB, DOLORES U TRE
6160 AVOCET CIR
HOBART IN 46342 - 6938
DURSHORDWE, WILLIAM G
51 ISLAND WAY # 508
CLEARWATER FL 31767 -2213
PANAGIOTAKOS, GREGORY
PANAGIOTAKOS, JANET L
POBOX 5029
SALISBURY MA 01952 - 0029
SWARTZ, RALPH P
9014 TRINITY CIR
REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 - 9532
MOONEY, SANDRA K
SADGEBURY, WILLIAM 0
3761 SKYROS DR
DAYTON OH 45424 - 1812
DUPUIS, FRANK P
DUPUIS, LORA L
5289 SHATTUCK RD
SAGINAW MI 48603 - 2853
FRUCCI, BRUNO L
FRUCCI, FRANCA
343 EVERARD ST
DIX HILLS NY 1 [746 - 7025
STEW ART, RA YM:OND
STEWART, :MARGIE V
38 PHILLIPS RD
STILLWATER NY 12170 - 1611
BOGDANOS, LEONARD
1414 EASTFIELD DR
CLEARWATERFL 33764-
WET. LS, SCOTT T
373 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 92
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4536
MALONEY, PATRICKG
MALONEY, ANDREE R
219 MCJ\1ULLEN BOOTH RD S # 174
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4433
BECKER, ROBERT P
360 I ALLEN PKWY # 75
HOUSTON TX 77019 - 1609
TUPPER, BEN
TUPPER, ERIN
229 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 58
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4437
HANSON, JAY P
1408 S EVERGREEN AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2213
PAOLUCCI, PAT
PAOLUCCI, LINDA
47 LAUREL CT
LONDON ON N6H 4W2 00030-
CANADA
SALISBURY, ORVILLE W TRE
SALISBURY, DONNA M TRE
631 WARNER DR
POBOX23
L1NDFN MI48451 - 0023
GOGGINS, LARRY
349 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 125
CLEARWATERFL 33759 -4524
MONAHAN, CHRlSTlNA E
SCHAAR, THOMAS J
2036 NUGGET DR
CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 1346
WILSON, ETHEL
3109 DOWNING S1'
CLEARWAfER 17L 33759 - 4504
SCIALPA, CHRISTOPHFR
357 MCMULLEN BoorH RD # 120
CLE AR WATER FL 33759 - 4528
GIANT OIL INC
3904 CORPOREX DR STE 150
TAMPA FI.... 33619-
PICANSO, JOSEPI-I
PICANSO, MARY R
383 MCJ\rfULLEN BOOTH RD S # 67
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4541
KOTEFF, RANDY
KOTEFF, CARL
69 PUCCINI DR POST STAB
RICHMOND HILL ON IAE 2Z2
00030 -
rANADA
RICHARD, LAWRENCE M
RICHARD, THERESA L
39 CRESCENT ST
UNCASVILLE CT 06382 - 2447
CAMPANALE, PHILIP E
CAMPANALE, MARY A
36 WES1MINSTER LN
KENT OH 44240 - 7264
HOLDSWORTH, GARY
HOLDSWORTH, PATSY
229 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 57
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4437
PERRY, RAY BERN
PERRY, MARlLOU
215 MCJ\rfULLEN BOOTH RD S # 184
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4431
T ARAJ, SHAWN S
PO BOX 5327
CLEAR WATER FL 33758 - 5327
YORK, EILEEN
241 MCJ\rfULLEN BOOTH RD
CLEARWATER FL 33759-
LANIFR, JERRY M
343 S MCMULLEN ROOTHRD# 151
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4521
NAGY, ROXIE M
580 DEAUVILLE DR
DA YTON OH 45429 - 5935
BELLOMO, JOI-IN R SR
249 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
CLEARWATER FL 33759-
LEANDRO, JOSE M
LEANDRO, ANA P
726 PEBLE CT
PICKERING ON I.... 1 V 3Z6 00030-
CANADA
BOOHER, HENRY J
BOOHER, JOANNA F
3018 CAROLINA AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4303
FOX, SAMUEL
FOX, LILLY
215 MCMULLEN BOOTHE RD # 182
CLEARWATER FI.... 33759-
DILLON, NICOLE E
383 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 66
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4541
SILJAK, MIRZA M
211 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 191
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4429
LEWIS, DENNIS
LEWIS, ELIZABETH M
3017 TENNESSEE A VB
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4334
COTTON, LYNDA L
377 MCJ\rfULLEN BOOTH RD # 99
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4538
WEBSTER, FRANKLIN D
WEBSTER, BETTY J
14 BENDWOOD DR
SUGAR LAND TX 77478 - 3701
EBERWEIN, DAN
EBERWEIN, DEBRA
383 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 68
CLEARWATERFL 33759 -4541
DRADER, MARlOR Y
5104 TURTLE CREEK CT APT 5
INDIANAPOLIS IN 46227 - 1856
WEEKLEY, A S JR TRE
6914 E FOWLER AVE STE J
TAMPA FL 33617 - 1705
THIBEAU, PAULA J
345 MCMULLEN BOOIH RD # 142
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4522
ENRIQUEZ, ALMA F
227 :MEADOW LARK LN
CLEARWATERFL 33759-
BLANCO, ALFONSO J
BIANCO, VONDA D
507 WOODBINE SE
WARREN OH 44483 - 6050
WHITEHEAD, JAMES J
WHITEHEAD, SHARON E
103 E AUSTIN ST
VERSAILLES IN 47042 - 9463
COLLINS, JEREMY M
10 YONGE ST # 2002
'TORONTO ONTARIO M5E lR4
00030 -
CANADA
GTANT OIL INC
3904 CORPOREX DR STE 150
TAMPA FL 13619-
CRUM PROPERTIES
3040 GULF TO BAY BLVD # 110
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 43]7
LILOIA, MICHAEL V
LILOIA, THERESA
7-B YORKSHIRE C I
LAKBHURS r NJ 08759 - 4515
HAMPTON, REGINALD
HAMPTON, NELLY
389 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD #12
CLEARWATERFL 33759 - 4544
BAKER, EUGENE N
387 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 14
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4543
SCHAUB, MAUREEN A
347 MCMDT.LEN BOOTH RD # 13 8
CLEARWATER fL 33759 - 4523
GUNN, DEBRA A
369 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 83
CLEARW A TER FL 33759 - 4534
HOLMES, GENEVIEVE G
823 PEBBLEWOOD DR
BRANDON FL 33511 - 7725
LIVINGSTON, KEITH M
221 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 164
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4434
BA YVlEW BAPTIST CHURCH OF
CLEARWATERFL INC
PO BOX 1108
CLEARWATER FL 33757 - 1108
HOFFMAN, RICHARD H
HOFFMAN, FLORENCE
1960 DOGWOOD DR
HOFFMAN EST IL 60195 - 1527
CHOUElFATY, YOUSSEF
CHOEF A TI, ABOO
16212 MARSHFIELD DR
rAMPAFL31624-1016
SWANK, TANYTAR
217 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 177
CLEARWATERFL 33759 -4432
CRUM PROPERTIES
3040 GULF TO BAY BLVD STE 200
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4318
TOSH, PETER
363 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 107
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4531
LEWIS, DELANO
LEWIS, GA YLE
PO BOX 1189
MESILLA NM 88046 - 1389
CORDINA, J A
CORDINA, JUNE
1330 MISSISSAUGA VALLEY BLVD
MISSISSAUGA ON L5A 3Tl 00030-
CANADA
CLEAR W KI ER, CITY OF
PO BOX 4748
CLEARWATER fL 33758 - 4748
PICANSO, ROSEMARY
381 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 69
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4540
LEWIS, DELANO
LEWIS, GAYLE
PO BOX 1389
MESILLA NM 88046 - 1189
MORREALE, JOSEPH C JR
3169 SAN MATEO ST
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 3530
SW AR TZ, RALPH P
9014 TRINITY CIR
REYNOLDSBURG OH 43068 - 9532
STONER, VICKI L
381 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 70
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4540
HANSON, JAY P
1417 LEMON ST
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2340
RAHER, PATRICK
RAHER, GERALDINE
7650 W GRENNAN PL
NILES IL 60714 - 2530
MC QUILKIN, KENNETH
375 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 93
CLEARWATERFL 33759 -4537
WAUGH, BRIAN J
407 S ORION AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33765 - 3431
COUSINS, CLAIRE T
343 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 149
CLEARWATER FL 33759 -4521
GUILLEMETTE, LEONARD A
RAMALHO, ERNEST L
38 THORWALD AVE
l-IAMPTON NH 03842 - 4266
MAROSJ, LOUIS J
MAROSI, CAROL J
7071 W TOWRY AVE #208
NILES IL 60714 - 5320
F AMA, ANTHONY
CATAPANO, MICHELLE
21 VJCKIES PL
MILLINGTON NJ 07946 - 1364
A THANASON, ANTHONY N
337 MC MULLEN BOOTH RD # 160
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4518
HOOKS, VERA A
353 MCMULLEN BOOTH S # 135
CLEARWATERFL 33759 - 4526
MILLER, SHANNON
WOlTOVICH, ALEX
70 LEVERSEE RD
TROY NY 12182 - 1614
DEMPSEY, MARY J
379 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 73
CLEARWATERFL 33759 - 4539
MAC CARONE, PATRICIA
MAC CARONE, WILLIAM A
120 SISSON RD
GREENE RI 02827 - 1732
MANCINI, JOHN G
MANCINI, JANICE M
39 PLEASANT ST
AYER MA 01432 - 1336
MC DONNOUGH, TERRY H
209 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 188
CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 4428
HORSTMANN, CLIFFORD J
HORSTMANN, HOPE
247 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
CLEARWATER FL 33759-
HERMAN, JULIE A
225 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 169
CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 4436
ARDAGNA, PETER
ARDAGNA, ANNE L
17 PATCH'S POND LN
WILMINGTON MA 01887 - 3920
GUTHRIE, CRYSTAL
225 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD #170
CLEARWATER FL 33759-
HUTCHINSON, JEROME
347 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 137
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4523
EYRE, GILMOUR
EYRE, ELIZABETH
518 MAPLE AVE
HAMIL TON ON L8K 1 K8 00030-
CANADA
KNEPPRA TH, DEAN L
KNEPPRATH, CANDIE S
373 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 89
CLEARWATER FL 33759-
SHREVE, MARK R
339 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 154
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4519
CORRIGAN, MICHAEL J
CORRIGAN, LOUISE M
27W408 MELROSE LN
WINFIELD IL 60190 - 1083
CRUM PROPERTIES
3040 GULF TO BAY BLVD STE 110
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4317
ORBL YCH, MELODYE
SMIAROWSKI, MICHAEL
13268 HARBORVIEW DR
LINDEN MI 48451 - 8414
WILDER CORP DELAWARE
3000 GULF TO BA Y BLVD FLR 6
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4321
SCHEIDT, KATHRYNW
217 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 179
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4432
BARTLETT, ERIC MC GARRY, JEROME J DEMPSEY, CAROLYN S
BARTLETr, ORA H MC GARRY, MARY L 239 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
197 QUEENSDALE AVE 391 MC MULLEN BOOTH RD # 8 CLEAR WATER FL 33759 -
TORONTO ON M4C 2B 1 00030- CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4545
CANADA
CABRERA-DIAZ, YURIMA ZANCA, ROSARIO SCHWARZ, BEGNNER M
PEREZ, ALAIN B ZANCA, ANNA SCHWARZ, CLAUDIA Y
239 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 31 107176THST 19650 US HWY 19 N # 756
CLEARWATER FL 33759- BROOKLYN NY 11228 - 2319 TARPON SPRINGS FL 34689 -7919
BURNS, PATRICK J JR DAVIS, BRETT J AGAR, ARTHUR P
BURNS, MARGARET 209 MCNfULLEN-BOOTH RD S # AGAR, GERTRUDE M
71 TOPSAIL CT ]86 44 HA WMAN AVE
BAYVlLLE NJ 08721 - 1409 CLEARWATER FL 13759 -4428 WOODBRIDGE ON L4L IS2 00030-
CANADA
MORENO, LillS B PANAOU, ANTONIA BOSQUE, JOSE L JR
MORENO, MARGARITA M 349 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 127 7026 SAM POTTS HWY
381 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 71 CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4524 LAKE W ACCAMA W NC 28450 -
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4540 9480
SOW ADA, TERRANCE J BROWN, JERRY E GIORGI, ANTONE
341 MCMULLEN BOOTl-I RD # 147 205 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 204 GIORGI, SANDRA C
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4520 CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4426 112 SMOKE RD
V ALPARAISO IN 46385 - 9604
NELON, JOHN DARKO, ANDREW BRINKMAN, JANICE J
337 MCMULLIN BOOTH RD # 159 DARKO, PAULINE E 5 CHURCH TWRS # 5G
CLEARW A TER FL 33759 - 4518 1949 CARLOS AVE HOBOKEN NJ 07030 - 2763
CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 1511
WALKER, JUNE SI-lERRI, FRED ITALIAN-AMERICAN CLUB CLW
PO BOX 370796 SHERRI, JESSIE 200 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
DENVER CO 80237 - 0796 61 RlCHJEW RD #604 CLEAR WATER FL 33 759 -
TORONTO ON M9A 4M8 00030-
CANADA
GODARD, KEITH W FALER, DAVID KOLAR, GORAZD
GODARD, ROSA I 249 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD #28 BARATlC-KOLAR, ELIZA BETH
41 COOMER CRES CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4447 C/O KOLAR, KLENEN
AJAX ON LIT 3C7 00030- 7332 BRUNO AVE
CANADA SAlNT LOUIS MO 63117 - 2410
ADAMS, THOMAS D COCHRAN, FRANCES E TRE CHADWICK-ROSS, LYNN
2000 S BISHOPS POlNT RD 602 W LONG LK 175 VlEWBANK CRES
INVERNESS FL 34450 - 5621 LAKE ORION MI 48362 - OAK VILLE ON L61 1 R3 00030-
CANADA
CARAPEZZA, EDWARD J KROWIALTS, BARBARA F CURRENT OWNER
PO BOX 27306 ] 255 AUTUMN WIND CT 603 SA YVIEW AVE
TAMP A FL 33623 - 7306 CENTERV]LLE OH 45458 - 6034 CLEARWATERFL 33759 -4214
JONES, CHERISH J BELL, RICHARD FAMA, AN"I HONY
241 MCMULLEN BOO] H RD 213 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 195 HORSTMANN, CUFFORD J
CLEARWATER FL 33759- CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4430 2 I VICKIES PL
MILLINGTON NJ 07946 - 1164
CHAPMAN, JEAN E EST CA RAPEZZA, EDWARD J WILLIAMS, CONWAY S
C/O CHAPMAN, JOHN P PR PO BOX 27306 Wll.UAMS, SHIRLEE C
475 NHAYMORl::<. AVE TAMPA PL 33623 -7306 28]9 RIVERRD
WORTHINGTON OR 43085 - PL YJvlOUTH NH 03264 - 5724
HENDERSON, STEPHANIE A SOARES, ELIANO L WOOD, LORA H
351 MCCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 129 SOARES, MARlA A 391 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 7
CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 4525 46 HOWARD ST CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4545
LUDLOW MA 01056 - 2748
ELGIN, GALP PARKER, WENDY J MA.C KAY, CHRISTOPHER
ELGIN, ANN M 123 PAULANNAAVE 341 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 145
1 ] 5 RODNEY CT BAYPORT NY 11705 - 2]65 CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 4520
PALM HARBOR FL 34684 - 4642
CONRAD, SARAH H PINELLAS COUNTY PLANTE, EOW ARD J
209 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # ] 87 A TTN ENGINEERING R/W PLANTE, CATHERINE E
CLEARWATER l'L 33759 - 4428 315 COUReI ST 95 CRi\NDALL DR
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 5165 MARKHAM ON L3P 6LI 00030-
CANADA
PASSMORE, JO ANN TRE GRA Y, LILLIAN F HOLDSWORTH, GARY
PASSMORE, DONALD A TRE O'LEARY, ELIZABETH HOLDSWORTH, PATSY
162 N HARVEST RD ]883 ELMRIDGE DR 229 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
WILLIAMSV]LLE NY 14221 - 66]9 OTTAWA ON KlJ 8G7 00030- CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4437
CANADA
MC DONALD, SCOTT MANSOORIAN, KAMRAN DAPICE, MARK D
235 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 2984 FIELDBROOK PL 339 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 155
CLEARWATER FL 33759- CLEARW A TER FL 33761 - 2513 CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4519
HARRIS, BETTY K EST
C/O QUISH, LOUISE
223 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 168
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4435
CLA WSON, KATHLEEN
37] MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 87
CLFARWATER FL 33759 -4535
COWLES, GENE E TRE
COWLES, AMELIA TRE
475 MAPLl'.WAY
SAFETY HARBOR FL 34695 - 2957
WILKERSON, JEFFREY M
WILKERSON, BILLIE C
3014 CAROLINA AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4303
JONES, PHILLIP F
JONES, DIEM T
343 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 150
CLEARWATERFL 33759 - 4521
DURAND, JEAN P
309 VENETIAN DR
CLEARW A TBR FL 33755 - 1749
HODA Y, FRANK
HODA Y, KATHERINE A
40,6 MONTCALM CRESCENT
NIAGARA FALLS ON L2G 6L8
00030 -
rANADA
CRUM PROPERTiES
3040 GULF TO BA Y BLVD # 200
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4318
DURSHORDWE, WU....LIAM G
5 I ISLAND WAY # 505
CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2213
HERZING, DOLORES S SCHMIERER, DAN C LIMA, JOSEPH C TRE
922 TWIN OAKS DR SCHMIERER, ADAM C 5 BARBARA. AVE
DA YTON OH 45431 - 2928 345 MCMULLEN BOOTHRD S # 141 SALEM NH 03079 - 3826
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4522
SCHUTZ, JAMES M JR BROPHY, JOHN F ANCELL!, EMMA M TRE
MCCOWN, MARY E BROPHY, JEAN A FANCELLI, DINO
339 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 153 50 HEA THLANDS 4711 ESTERBROOK RD
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4519 WESTFIELD EAST SUSSEX TN35 COLUMBUS 01-1 43229 - 6308
4QZ 00009-
I rNITFD KTNGnnM
KIRKIRT, JUDITH E MC GUIRE, MAUREEN A VELLA, JOHN C
375 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 96 380 N BA YSI-IORE BLVD # 202 VELLA, MIRIAM Y
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4537 CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 3841 22 CELESTINE DR
"I ORONTO ON M9R 3N 1 00030-
CANADA
MURCEK, ANNABELLE M PINELLAS COUNTY CHAPMAN, JOHN P SR
219 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD S # 176 A TTN ENGINEERlNG RJW CHAPMAN, JOY L
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4433 315 COURT ST 475 HAYMORE AVE N
CLEARW ATER FL 33756 - 5165 WORTHINGTON OH 43085 - 2466
HALLOCK, JEAN C CRUM PROPFRTrES SCHMIERER, ADAM C
224 MILL VILLAGE RD 3040 GULF TO BAY BL VD # 110 SCHMIERER, DAN
PO BOX 66 CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4317 239 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
GOSHEN NH 03752 - 0066 CLEARW ATER FL 11759 - 4442
HAREN, CAROL SANDVIL, MARK WILKERSON, JEFF
345 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 143 SANDYIL, JOSEPH WlLKERSON, BILLIE
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4522 343 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 152 3014 CAROLTNA AVE
CLEAR WATER FL 33759 - 4521 CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 4303
DRAGICEVIC, DRAGO ELLIOTT, DEBORAH A MASLAN, PATRICK Y
DRAGICEVIC, BOJANA 239 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 32 MASLAN, PATRlCIA D
389 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD CLEARWATER FL 33759- 26 YORKLEIGH AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4544 ETOBICOKE ON M9P I Y 4 00030-
CANADA
CRABB, JAMES R DUBRIC, MARA GIANT OIL INC
CRABB, JANTNE M 339 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 156 3904 CORPOREX DR S]E 150
231 S MCMULLEN BOOTH RD # 56 CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4519 TAMPA FL 33619-
CLEARWATER FL 33759 - 4438
ECKHARDT, CHERYL J KARSTEN, JACK A TURKOSZ, PETER P
517 S BAYVIEW AVE KARSTEN, MARTHA A TURKOSZ, AMELIA R
CLEARW ATER FL 33759 - 4211 PO BOX 608 25 SUMMER ST
BLOWING ROCK NC 28605 - 0608 METHUEN MA 01844 - 3172
BOSNIC, lBRAHIM SUTHERIN, CAROL D Housh Ghovaee
BOSNIC, ARIFA MC KAY, DAVID G JR Northslde E.ngll1eerll1g SerVices, Inc
6239 W LAWRENCE AVE 225 MEADOW LARK LN 60 I Cleveland Street, SUIte 930
CH1CAGO lL 60630 - 2941 CLEAR WATER FL 33 759 ~ 4326 Clearwater, FL 33755
Bay Brceze TraIler Park
Robert, Domzalski
2975 Gulf to Bay Boulevard
Clearwdter, FL 33759
Clearwater NClghborhoods Coal1tlon
Doug Wilham!:>, President
2544 Fmw Dnve
Clearwater, FL 3376 I
3070 Gulf To Bay Blvd
FLD2004-ll08\ W W