The URL can be used to link to this page

FLS2004-05028 C L W CoverS heet RlECE~VED 1 f~ if f2Q "-- MAY 18 2U04 lPLAN~~NG DEPARTMENT CiTY OF CLEARWATER - FLS2004-05028 193 DEVON DR Date Received: 05/18/2004 '. ~ 4~ ZONING DISTRICT: LMDR QJ LAND USE: RU MARIANI ATLAS PAGE: 276A PLANNER OF RECORD: PA~ 0 o.f '50 Ob CK.NO. ~o -, ~ Or<. DATE _0 I rot..{ , ORIGINAL , , ~/;.<'c~I'~ Planning Department t.? W"-'.<0 ' . i "$ - 100 South Myrtle AV€flue :',;;;: ~~arnrater J Clearwater, Florida 33~56-=C~~Vf;=>~- ~ Telephone 727-562-4567 = 1.= :: "-C:/--..;;:;;r"'-~.::::/,::../"o-/ Fax 727 -562-4865 ~ \\ -= _ lb ~ o SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED AND NOTARIZED .APPLICA TIONv1A Y 18 20U ~ o SUBMIT 14 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION Indudlng 1\ 1 ) collated, 2) slapled and 3) folded sels ~f site' Pi~1tUiMG 1Ql~[?ARI , f OF CIL(EAIRVV~ f ~ o SUBMIT APPLICATION FEE 1. * NOTE 15 TOTAL SETS OF INFORMATION REQUIRED (APPLICATIONS PLUS SITE PlAN SETS) , CASE # DATE RECEIVED RECEIVED BY (staff Initials) ATLAS PAGE# ZONING DISTRICT LAND USE CLASSIFICATION SURROUNDING USES OF ADJACENT PROPERTIES NORTH SOUTH WEST FLEXIBLE STANDARD DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION (ReVised 11!l8/03) - PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT - I I A APPLICANT, PROPERTY OWNER AND AGENT INFORMATION (Code Section 4-202 Al I AP"L1CflNT NAME Chrlstopher C. Marlanl MAILING ADDRESS 310 Llve Oak Lane, Largo, Florlda 33770 PHONE NUMBER (813) 623-3941 FAX NUMBER (813)626-4103 PI~OPERTY OWNER(S) Chrlstopher C. Marlanl (Musllnclvde ALL owners as I,sled on the deed - prov'de onglnal Slgnatufels) on page 6) AGENT NAME Tlmothy A. Johnson, Jr., and E.D. Armstrong III Johnson, Pope, Bokor, Ruppel & ~urns, LLP P. O. Box 1368, Clearwater, FL 33757 ~ll\'L1NG ADDRESS DHO~E NUMBER (727) 461-1818 FAX NUMBER (727)462-0365 CELL NUMBER (727) 709-0123 E-MAil ADDRESStlmJ@JPflrm.com ~B PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT INFORMATION (Code Section 4-202 A) 193 Devon, Clearwater, FL Is TRE..ET ADDRESS of subject site I Lot 31, Replat of Bayslde Sub., Plat Book 23, Pgs. 14-15 lEGlIL DESCRIPTlON PAF<CEL NUMBeR ('b'g?2t~l/I"5 !/j~9 f~e;l:J'd'IJ~'B'3'i~'s documenl ,n the submIttal) P'-\RCEL SIZE 0.33 acre (acres, square feel) PROPOSED USE{S) AND SIZE{S) slngle-faruly dwelllng Wl th dock (number of dwelllllg unrls hotel rooms or square footage of nonresidential use) DE'SCRIPTlONOF REQUEST(S) Level One (flexlble standard) approval of a dock 92 feet In P~ge 1 of 6 - ~Iexlblc Standard Development Appllcat'on- City of Clearw~ter . - Attach sheets and be specIfic when IdenlifYlng the request (Include all requested code devIations e g reduction In reqUired number ot parking spaces sllec,hc use, etc ) length where 60 feet ~s perm~tted. See sketch attached as Exh~b~t A. DOES THIS APPLICATION INVOLVE THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS (fOR), A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT, OR A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED (CERTIFIED) SITE PlAN? YES _ NO ~ (If yes, attach a copy of the applicable docLJments) C PROOF OF OWNERSHIP (Code Section 4-202 A 5) Qi SUBMIT A COPY OF THE TITLE INSURANCE POLICY, DEED TO THE PROPERTY OR SIGN AFFIDAVIT A TIESTlNG OWNERSHIP (see page 6) D WRITTEN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Code Section 3-913 A) Ila ProVIde complete responses to the SIX (6) GENERAL APPLICABILITY CRITERIA - Explain how each criteria IS achieved, In detail The proposed development of the land Will be In harmony with the scale, bulk coverage, denSity and character of adjacent properties In which It IS located The proposed dock 1S s~m1lar 1n length to the two docks located on the property adJacent and westerly of the subJect property. See photographs and Exh1b1t B attachec. 2 The proposed developmer1t Will not hinder or discourage the appropriate development and use of adjacent land and butldlngs or Significantly Impair the value thereof See Exhlblt B attached. The adJacent propert1es are developed and have docks. 3 The proposed development Will not adversely affect the heallJ1 or safety or persons reSiding or working In the nelghbortlood of the proposed Tt~ proposed dock does not result 1n a hazard to nav1gatJ.on. lR fee ~ ~~,frE:ro ) MAY 1 H lUUIt 4 PLA~U\\~~G D1EPA~lMlE~ ~T No addltJ.onal veh1cular traff1c w1ll be generated by the propG~~d~~~l~R~A11E[~ The proposed development is deSigned to mlnrmlze traffic congestIon 5 The proposed development IS consistent With the commUnity character of the Immediate ViCInity of the parcel proposed for development Most lots on Devon Drlve have docks. The adJacent westerly property has two docks of Slm1lar length. 6 The deSign of the proposed development minimizes adverse effects, including Visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operation Impacts, on adJacent properties See Exh~b~t C wh~ch descr~bes a dock and l~ft arrangement that can be bUllt as a matter of rlght and WhlCh would more adversely affect the westerly adJacent property. Page 2 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Apphcatlon- City of Clearwater f5I: Provide complete responses to the applicable flexibility cntena for the specific land use as listed In each Zoning Dlstnct to which the waiver IS requested (use separate sheets as necessary) - Explain how each cntena IS achieved In detail See Exh~b~t D attached. See attached Pr~vate Dock Perm~t Appl~cat~on - Plnellas County Water and Nav~gat~on Control Authorlty E STORMWATER PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (City of Clearwater DeSign Criteria Manual and 4-202 A 21) o STORMWATER PLAN including the following requirements EXisting topography extending 50 feet beyond all property hnes, Proposed gradll1g Includ Il1g fil1lshed floor elevatlOl1s of all structLJres, All adjacent streets and mUniCipal storm systems, Proposed stormwater detentlonlretellllon area Includ Ing top of bank, toe of slope and outlet control structure Stormwater calculations for attenuation and water quality, Signature of FlOrida registered Professlol1al El1glneer on all plal1s and calculatIons o COPY OF PERMIT INQUIRY LEITER OR SOUTHWEST FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT (SVVFWMD} PERMIT SUBMITTAL (SWFWMD approval IS reqUired pnor to Issuance of City BUilding Permit), If applicable F SUPPLEMENTAL SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Code SectIon 4-202 A) la SIGNED AND SEALED SURVEY (including legal descnptlon of property) - One ongmal and 14 copies, o TREE SURVEY (Including eXisting trees on Site and Within 25' of the adJacent Site, by species Size (DBH 4" or greater), and location, Including drip lines and Indicating trees to be removed) - please deSign around the eXJstmg trees. o LOCATION MAP OF THE PROPERTY o PARKING DEMAND STUDY In conjUnction With a reque~t to make deViatIOns to the parking standards (Ie Reduce number of spaces) Prror to the submittal of thiS application, the methodology of such study shall be approved by the Community Development Coordinator and shall be 111 accordance With accepted traffle engineering prinCiples The findings of the study Will be used 111 determlnll1g whether or not deViatIOns to the parking standards are approved, o GRADING PLAN as applicable, o PRELIMINARY PLAT, as reqUIred (Note BUilding permits Will not be ISsued until eVidence of recording a final plat IS proVided), o COPY OF RECORDED PLAT, as applicable, G SITE PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Sectton 4-202 A) ~, ~ f"\> ~ ~~ 17hU ~ ,\ -=.-.r '0 sU W If;lbV o SITE PLAN With the follOWing information (not to exceed 24" x 36 ') All dimenSions, North arrow, Englneenng bar scale (minimum scale one Inch equals 50 feet) and date prepared Localion map, Index sheet referencll1g IndiVidual sheets Included 111 package, Footprint and size of all EXISTING bUildings and structures, Footpmt and size of all PROPOSED bUildings and structures, t. fJ.,{ i Ii LUO~ ,......~~i t.J\I ~ v ;' \.) D:=~A~lM~lNJ1r ....~ ClEARWA~\R --., i\p.., .., , JI~-"I ~ Page 3 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Apphcatlon- City of Clearwater All required setbacks, All eXisting and proposed pOints of access Afl reqUJred Sight triangles, Idenlrflcatlon of environmentally unique areas, such as watercourses wetlands, tree masses, and specimen trees, Includl ng description and locatron of understory, grou nd cover vegetation and Wildlife habitats, etc, Location of all public and prrvate easements, Location of all street rrghts-of -way Within and adjacent to the SIte, Location of eXlsllng publiC and private utrlitles, including fire hydrants, storm and sanitary sewer lines, manholes and 11ft statJons, gas and water lines All parking spaces, dnveways, loading areas and vehicular use areas, Depiction by shading or crosshatching of all reqUIred parking lot Interror landscaped areas Locallon of all solid waste contamers recycling or trash handling areas and outSide mechanrcal equipment and all reqwred screening {per Section 3-201 (0)(1) and Index #701}, Locahon of all landscape matenal, Locallon of all onslte and off site storlnwater management faCilities Location of all outdoor Ilghtmg fixtures, and Location of all eXisting and proposed Sidewalks o SITE DATA TABLE for eXisting, reqUired, and proposed development, m wrrlten/tabular form Land area In square feet and acres, Number of EXISTING dwelling units, Number of PROPOSED dwelling units, Gross floor area devoted to each use, _1_ L ~_ ~l_ .,. Total paved area including all paved parking spaces and drrveways, expressed In square feet and percentage of the paved vehicular area Size and species of all landscape materral, OffiCial records book and page numbers of all eXisting utility easement, BUilding and structure heights, Impermeable surface ratio (I S R ), and Floor area rallo (F A R ) for aU nonresldenhal uses o REDUCED SITE PLAN to scale (8 Yo X 11) and color rendenng If pOSSible o FOR DEVELOPMENTS OVffi ONE ACRE, prOVide the follOWing additional I nform allon on site plan One-foot contours or spot elevations on Site, Off site elevations If reqUired to evaluate the proposed stormwater management for the parcel, All open space areas, LocatJon of aU earth or water retamlng walls and earth berms, Lot lines and bUilding lines (dimensioned), <:'._^^,~ BUilding and structural setbacks (dimensioned), Structural overhangs Tree Inventory, prepared by a "certified arbonst", of all trees 8" DBH or greater, reflecting Size, canopy (dnp Imes) and conditIOn of such trees H LANDSCAPING PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Section 4-1102 A) i -~ ,I 1'-" -=- rl \\ /IFF rn 1'-"',\:'1,;=1 _1= 11 \\ 1:=11 II u ,,= '=" ~u v r.=~ 1:1 LANDSCAPE PLAN All eXlstrng and proposed structures, Names of abuttrng streets, Drainage and retention areas rncludlng swales, Side slopes and bollom elevatIOns, Delineation and dimenSion s of all reqUired penmeter landscape buffers Sight VISibility tnangles, Dellneahon and dimenSions of all parking areas Including landscapmg Islands and curbing, Proposed and reqUired parking spaces EXisting trees on-site and Immediately adjacent to the Site, by speCies, size and locahons, Including dnpline (as indicated on reqUired tree survey), Plant schedule With a key (symbol or labelllndlcatlng the Size, descnptlon, speclflcatrons and quantities of all eXlstmg and proposed landscape matenals, Including botanical and common names, Locahon, size and quanllhes of all eXlstmg and proposed landscape matenals, indicated by a key relating to the plant schedule, TYPical planting details for trees palms, shrubs and ground cover plants Including instructions SOil mixes, backfilling, mulching and protective measures, Interior landscaping areas hatched and/or shaded and labeled and Intenor landscape coverage, expressing In both square feet and percentage covered, MAY 1 R 2004 PLA~N:i\:G \:~-t ":TMiENT CITY CF C,-..:.r~.~vVATER Page 4 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development ApphcatlOn- City of Clearwatf'r Condllwns of a prevIous development approval (e 9 condlllons Imposed by the Community Development Board), Irngalron notes o REDUCED LANDSCAPE PLAN to scale (8 Y, X 11) (color rendenng If possible), o IRRIGATION PLAN (reqUired for level two and three approval), o COMPREHENS[\fE LANDSCAPE PROGRAM apphcaton, as apphcable BUILDING ELEVATION PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Secllon 4-202 A 23) ReqUired In the event the application rncludes a development where deSign standards are In Issue (e g Tounst and Downlown Districts) or as part of a ComprehenSive Infill Redevelopment Project or a ResldentJallnfill Project o BUILDING ELEVATION DRAWINGS - all Sides of all bUildings Including height dimenSions, colors and matenals, o REDUCED BUILDING ElEVATIONS - four Sides of bwldlng With colors and matenals to scale (8 Y, X 11) (black and white and color rendermg, If J SIGNAGE (DIVISion 19 SIGNS I Section 3-1806) o All EXISTI NG freestanding and attached signs, PrOVide photographs and dimenSions (area, height, etc) mdlcate whether they Will be removed or to remain o All PROPOSED freestandmg and attached signs, ProVide details mcludrng locahon, Size, height, colors, materials and draWing, freestanding signs shall rnclude the street address (numerals) o Comprehensive Sign Program apphcahon, as applicable (separate application and fee reqUired) K TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY (Section 4-202 A 13 and 4-801 C) o Include as reqUired If proposed development Will degrade the acceptable level of ser.llce for any roadway as adopted In the ComprehenSive Plan Tnp generation shall be based on the most recent editIon of the Instlute of Transportation EnglOeer s Trip General Manual Refer to Secbon 4-801 C of !tie Community Development Code for exceptions to thiS requirement L SIGNATURE I, the underSigned, acknowledge that all representations made In thiS application are true and accurate to the besl of my knowledge and authonze City representatives to VISit and p,otograph the property descnbed In thiS appllcatJOn // ~lg9ature of --"perty owner or representative Timothy A. Johnson, Jr. STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINELLAS Swam to a nd subSCribed before me thiS 10 f7t.. day of March A D 20~ to me and/or by ,Ji"'~O IS personally known Il'i1S t-.~ ~~C~~VE[) 1~t;AY 18 LUU4 "S;'~';.;;' '. Jayne E Sears i::f. @. ":~ MY COMMISSION 1/ DD041066 eXPIRES ~~ ~,;: September 2, 2005 ":~"9~,,lr1' IlO NO> 0 IHRU rROY FAIN INSURANC~ INC PLA%~'~ 23 ~E~/~~~lMlENT CiTY Of Cu::,~rqWATlER Page 5 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Apphcatlan- City of Clearwater ~ ~ r:. '= 1 ~J=[J) -..J ' !,== 0 - -- -<.~--,j ! ~ f. : f ~ u - r; , Jlh , ".. -I ~l:~lM~l :", ....:ARWArrErP< AFFIDAVIT TO AUTHORIZE AGENT Chrl.stooher C. Mar1an1 (Names of all property owners on deed - please PRINT full names) 1 That (I am/we are) the owner(s) and record title holder(s) of the followmg descrrbed property (address or general location) 193 Devon, Clearwater, Florl.da 2 That this property constitutes the property for which a request for a (describe request) Level One (flexl.ble standard) approval for a dock 92 ,feet l.n length where 60 feet 1S permltted. Tlmothy A. Johnson, Jr. and or 3 That the underSigned (has/have) appomted and (does/do) appornt E. D. Armstrong III as (his/their} agent(s} to execute any pelilions or other documents necessary to affect such petition 4 That thiS affidaVit has been executed to Induce the City of Clearwater, Flonda to conSider and act on the above deSCribed properly Page 6 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Appllcatron- City of Clearwater . .~ 5 That site VISitS to the property are necessary by City representatives In order to process thiS apphcatlon and the owner authonzes City representatives to VISit and photograph the property described In thiS apphcalJon 6 That (I/we). the undersigned authOrity hereby certify that the foregOing IS true and correct .~Ck~' Property ner Chrl.stopher C. Marl.ani Property Owner Property Owner Property Owner COUNTY OF PINELlAS STATE OF FLORIDA, Before me the underSigned. an officer duly commissioned by the laws of the State of Flonda. on thiS 1/"/1 I ..!!1a~ 2004 personally appeared Chrl.stopher C. Marl.anl. Deposes and says that he/she fully understands the contents of the affidavit that he/she Signed ~ day of My Commission Expires 5 IPlanmng DeparrmemlAppltcatlOn Formsldevelopmem revlewlflexlble standard developmem applIcatIon 2003 doc ~~~~~V~[)) dU~ ~1M~~u · l~lTE~ Page 7 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development ApphcatlOn- City of Clearwater ... . Application # (OFFICIAL USE ONLY) IV. PROJECT DESCRIPTION: A Nature and Size of Project Construct a new 487 sq ft dock consisting of 4' x7?, walkway leading to a 12' x 12' "L" head with a 3' x 12' lower landing Install 10 plhng to create two boat slips Square feet 487 Yes 0 Length L NO [X] B Variance Amount In variance Setbacks WIdth R other NOTE: It IS the applicant's responsibility to clearly demonstrate that any requested variances are consistent WIth the variance criteria of the Plnellas County Water and NaVigation Control Authority Regulations The applicant must submit a written variance request outlining the nature of and need for any variance The applicant must demonstrate that a literal enforcement of the regulatIOns would result In an extreme hardship due to the un/que nature of the project and the appllcanfs property Thehardshlp must not be created by actlon(s) of the property owner(s) The granting of the variance must be In harmony With the general Intent of the regulations and not Infnnge upon the property rights of others The variance requested must be the mlntmum possible to allow for the reasonable use of the apphcanfs property Should the applicant fall to demonstrate that any vanance request IS consistent WIth the crltena outlined In the regulations, staff cannot recommend approval of the application v. CONTRACTOR INFORMATION. I. Robert Ress , a certified contractor, state that the dock has not been constructed and that rt Will be bUIlt In compliance With all reqUirements and standards set forth In the "Rules and Regulations" of the Plnellas County Water and NaVigation Control AuthOrity, and In accordance With the attached draWings which accurately represent all the mformatlon required to be furmshed In the event that thiS dock IS not built In accordance With the permit or the information furnished IS not correct, I agree to erther remove the dock or correct the defiCiency Signed Cert No C-4192 Company Name Ress Marine Construction Company Telephone No 727-446-2945 Address 435 Woodlawn Avenue, Bellealr, FL 33756 VI. OWNER'S SIGNATURE: I hereby apply for a permrt to do the above work and state that the same will be done according to the map or plan attaChed hereto and made a part hereof, and agree to abide by the "Rules and Regulatlons" of the Plnellas Cou nty Water and NaVigation Control AuthOrity for SUCh construction and, If said constructions Wlthm the corporate limits of a municipality, to first secure approval from said mUniCipality, to first secure approval from said mUniCipality I further state that saId constructIOn Will be maintained In a safe condition at all limes, should thIS applicatIOn be approved, that I am the legal owner of the upland from which I herem propose to construct the Improvements, and that the above stated agent/contractor may act as my representatIVe I understand that I, not Pmellas County, am responSible for the accuracy of the information proVided as part of thiS apphcatlon and that It IS my responSIbIlity to obtain any necessary permits and approvals applicable for the proposed actiVities on either private or sovereign owned submerged land Date Legal Owner's Signature D48WDJar1/ENVMGMNT/PrAAd2 4126194 .r;- . !-,. & --:. "'7".,. ,--- ;..C' __ : -:,~~,,~ ~.,~: ~4ts;6" - ~- -- ~ 'HS:. 54 ',- I I I \ ~(EC[E~V[E[~ I MAY 1 R LUU~ I PLANNING DEPARTMJ NT crrv OF ClEA..~WATE R ~U~-Ia-.. ..~s~ p" '.L~~QI_~...JU ! .hd WalTaIlty. ~ ... ~,Uu. .. '" .ru., A.D :ooa lor .U~ ;J. V1Ao.~1L .t.- bzRm .. 12.bar1: J. V1ac.U,1. uad ..~... na"eU1. ~.-.... eIl4 wtfe !on aIIle Qd~. _it....:. no 31411 llo:ir~~..,-,l" Cll.I'~.~ c:. -.riaai. a in it 1 e. , ;::.... -,,;:- - "'::" , "."""'tff~ F. ~ i.ti. tJ:;~ 'i';.if~);:YYi _ ,>f' '.~ ..r'.].~' =t.:.? " ;" . _r- ,- ~ i I ":illY.., ~ ~* l' ~ ;"1t .! ~..I'':;_~:1., ~-. -i - ',)'l . . :';;.' ~ . - - ":/-.:.1 .L~r l~~:" .; -~-- . -~:< I.;'~_'i"~'.'..). '" ' . . . I;: f.. -~,:. . :;;-; ~ P'h.1I"'-;1(, ~ ~ p=~:- IJ..\.,,~: ;1 ~-. ~;..fof ~ ;,...~: - ::' t- -~ ~- ~~'- _ ..... .... .J.. -!:....t:. .. ~--- ......,.. ~:~ -:'T~: ~' CI4.Ij A/'Ii, "'~"'!€~:S~ ~ ~: .............~it~~ 1i~, ~Il" ;-\~ r---- _......-_~_"'..~'lo...,_..- ~... ~._ ~... _.- _...... __..... ....,.-1 ~.. _1_'-.'" -' J. "..... ~~.. o/,J 1I.IHI ......-.....h.oNo ~ ~........ a ~....a...- . b.. ~ 1ootIbJ.,-.............. ......- .-.- __ ..., .-a... _0..... .-""' oRlb.ol ___ ~ _~ .. .'-11u ~,. ""'1M. . ... ~it a. _tt~ U;rIoU u4 !or do,l_ r.'~~. -.ds - ,..~ ~~...,. ~ ~ d!&=.ddr-. 10: 11"V r..1_ CI4.Ir. ~. w.va. K .i nHl .,.:Na ftI ~Cl.&IIt.. cUU'1.oU-.. _~b 01. "'..clOn aDd ~ !C' u.. ~l;:: ,........ ,.,14 'P"""P~ h "-,,c. u. ~t.-.4 at: U. ~cl.1 ~ ~ 1...- ~ Q/l:Ut.1.~~t.:l.ao g' U. u..u ot: .1ol'~ U u-r:. .-..~ ~f.1 oC UI.l' ~. gt! U. '-am>1.4 ar 1k_t4J'(.j "'.."'- ~_. '&ZOel. ~~~C'~\!Ga~' O'_1'_1'.04'1.-'OO.Q~1a ~"".o:lllbo>.._1Io.- rr----'..,I..- ~Q...~..!.--_......... To ~ .. tII HtlI4. I!oo _.. b ___--- .6.ad *.-~ _"-..d~" "a.puI.....-.nr~ ~...... ..-a-,r. ... "'- ,- ..... P'I"l <1PI .... y,.N __ III .... ... -,. aololl...L 1M ilia "L!II. "'rdor ftIllr -- ... ..,. Ill-.... ...s...c Ml.-t.. _.... _ ~ ~ IIIl 04 pa--. L . __ ~ .....10. """" vi.. ~ -.......,. _ ...-.- .. ~ )1, 1'" fa -...,....~. lk.....:l._.... ___ .. c.lo4 .- ~. 1100- ltoy -' JUlIlN *- .....\0.1__ .r~~d!L;ut c. :I. YUIl.U1 =:~~du~ : ...,.,..-- .,. ,..,.. "" ..,. YOU c"IIM, "" T&nO ".. ,""..... \w,..~.t _ _~ _~.... dI. I ~~., '" "'Ul'K :I. "1000.111 a.l.o ~ ... >>:11.-.4 3. YllU:1.1.11. eo4 1&ll'~ ._ ",__U.L. bu.bul4 t.AO .u. ~~. oh'__.__.~_ 4 ()~ -- ~~~"- _~r....,.. ~ :.. 'l'- llI:l~-~t-....... ao"/-. . c.., . '-!llDlIw.... - , - - ~ ,,' I pu.. "'U ao-uU ~~,!.~~ ;,~~ .-:.L ~ .......~~:o{_ ....~"\....~_ ....._.. ,....-. -~=. S'l;" t{ ~;.?~}~::rY --.........i.......~~:~ <;...-,~~.. ~;!o. j,. ~.;....... ~I-;-- ~.... \ I I 1_, I ,,. ....P&U:Il ..... ,./'" ~. ~:I:I. La~ or.1.o.. or ~14 .. &'1 :ZDdl_ ......... &064 ..11..lr. .~~i6a ,.~,. 'l.tt. ~~;;I~~:~~"'. . ,.,-........-,..:..;,....,.....~!' .f.~: ~~.r:,~~:~ .:...:-~ ,..l~~~?~f{:..T'~'. .... ~1:t UDG, t., {."' 'l::<' · .- L'.,,~-~ t~:;~_ -~ _w "'0 r:z'? , JU . - - - ..- _ . i:~. '..... - - ;a.8L::' -_~ - -. ~-- ~. .Jrk: ---?', .~-' .-:5- ."c .;!- - -- :i ~ rw :::r-:. :f' '^ } "'-~,,<- -: _ 1 L~-1 -"""'~ &~~ P, ' .. , - . , . ".. ...,-- -... ... ...~: ) --L~ .... ~ ~ .7::::.. ~- -"l;,iI:+'" "_,~"\:,,.l:,; ~ .:1""'~~$: - - ~_-'~~~'::~7.':' ';: y-~*\;':$;g I ~_:~.... ~.,..'f'r_...i;~ll< ...~"""':r-- 1...,1: ~~~,,<<';:01 ;page ~ --- ~~:!Lr...~:",-,,~ ;.:,'" '_l.~-<i'}~:::::d~":~ ~ ~ -7~ ~~i_)'~~~~~~~~ - -=- -;;~'~~:-':'?.;:r,,:>;~-,:t;r::::!;Pi?j ~~. ~ _~.... .....30......,;.._1' -:- 1{...-;.::- ~~~ 2~..~.... .-- Da:6Cri.p:b.an- ;Pin.~l.a3.J:r. Do~t:-Boak.F..g- ~;;9B5_22~l. ~..-I ;P.g~ ;1-2 ~... l.,y ~ ~- .....j "':;: 1. ~ ~ ~ JL"4~ .(...t.~ I.. "'.......,.,.. Tz'f "'J~:~ ... ...-....~ .... ~ ...., ~~ ~....- '"'J r. 4.~~ tr--::') J; ... -... '5.~ ....,r..... ... ...... ~ .-....:.-...I...~.... r .~.. J~.16~.. .t:~2 ~. . j \. ... ;: .. ,. U~1..1.A8 ~"'TT "U'. QF"r _'tEe._ ICS~ ,.Q UIIZ kllLbU. .. ""'c- ;U., IRfoU' CII" .......SIIlI ~.tTI:~.=:.. -.~ - tllooo .:1..1:. u..c-.C .rWcI;Jra.4 to .".t ~ :;tJ. ....,.. 1& ... U. ~11c;: ..........s. .C ".L.-1~ cz..a~, J'lGC"J.ar ~~_ ft'Z:I tlliiIMe l.&Dlb 1'J"1llG ScII.I~ly ..t .-.ld loOt:. )1. .. ......." _ _11.4 .'--11: ot u:::rt.U' DIf" U2Smc saurn:Slal. _ u.. l~ o.l.~t.a .-.I....~<I La..- .... _..do .1.1; _. pU'~"CI,I1.&rly d"cll"Uoad ." 101..1_ 1 _P"! (' ~~ ...~ ~ _~"I' ~ aC ..1Q Lot. n., ~~T 01 ....y~JlliIl; S'ftDtv:r.~]"~. ~ So<IUI. ".:1-1.5 30. ~..t. .l.a:aq ~ Kaec..,ly :u.... o( ...... 1001: 3.1.. 110.:'" 1:_10 100 .. pout .~CII:IlJ _.l.a. 'h~ ~~a > .. .lIooooa. _ _J.4 'ut;, tll.A<::. .1C1D9 -.1.4 .....l..~ ~ ~1A.- 1.IIS_I'O f:_~ .1~ UIao ~ ..C . C'K"9'" to:> ~ C.l.4'tl.1:. ba..s.... . 'l:a41'N ot ""'.110 f._I:. cb00&-4 of U3_J' f:_I;. ~ ~ SGOt1Io ., .01" II'. ..... C u.-.:. TicNtJa .," 31. J'. ...t U .110 t_t alaov _Ld. .....,~ .. L~-J dwm_ 'WG1:c..ll 1I11"2:::1.'J,a _.e: 1.00.)1 I:_t al~ u. ....~ly U.I:Io. vI: ...'4 tat S1.. ~. :n..H .l!_t ..1"'""2 e. &1:0: ..I: . "'~. ~ c:a. ,l...tl:., .......s.a.r '" 11"-.41_ at 40.1111 t_C. o-.-.s .e. la.S' (_t. ~4:t-u::Uoa' "'",U n.:::I.,')I- &ut:. t... tA- ..olac: 0.11: .... 1.... 'a<9 - " r~.J.. _..I 01l~'1lI..s I ~ i -....~:c~..~: ::r '!......... ~ -. , ~~}~-:C (~~~\ I'i,. .:..:: ~ .~ - ........~... .....1.,.,: ;:;'1 .....~~"f' ~ r~ ~,... ...!" .' <r. ...~..:;. . >.. -' :':~) .. I ~ ., . - , ,'";... . - ..~~:-:":'.. ~;.:.>~ . ~. -- . ~~- ,,_ f1i. '; ,. ,.. _ . "1 ." ~:..~. ' . ~t ~ . ... . ....::~: :J.;.! "": . '- . "t_.-'" ~ ~ . ;.! ,; T \ .~ \.~~Jo ..-& '1 ... . l'... ~I": , 10 . "'J ;"1;'::'~~ . & .=' ~ \ l";; ".Ai.~.;. ; ... ...~-~ lE\; :...,..".. ~.:i"". .. .,. : -. ..- (.. ~ - ~-- .- -::~""- ... -: ~ ~- : :- ~ ~"':-'. JOHNSON, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELLORS AT LAW E D ARM:STRONG III BRUCE H BOKOR JOHN R BONNER, SR · GUY M BURNS JONATIIAN S COLEMAN STACY COSTNER MICHAEL T CRONIN ELIZABETH J DANIELS BECKY FERRELL-ANTON COLLEEN M FLYNN MARION HALE SCOTT C ILGENFRlT L FRANK R JAKES TIMOTHY A JOHNSON, JR SHARON E KRICK ROGER A LARSON JOHNR LAWSON,JR. LEANNE LETIZE IvI1CHAEL G UTTI E MICHAEL C MARKHAM LACHARY D MESSA A R ''CHARLIE'' NEAL TROY J PERDUE F WALLACE POPE, JR ROBI:RT V POTIER, JR AUDREYB RAUCllWAY DARRYL R RICHARDS PETER A RIVELLINl DENNI') G RUPPEL. CHARLES A SAMARKOS PHILIP M SHASTEEN JOAN M VECCHlOLl STEVEN H WEINBERGER JOSEPH J WEISSMAN STEVEN A WILLIAMSON .OF COUNSEL PLEASE REPLY TO CLEARWATER FILE NO 42809 104550 July 27, 2004 VIA FACSIMILE and U.S. MAIL Mr John Schodtler Development ReView SpeCialist Planning Department Municipal Services BUilding 100 South Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, FL 33756 ~~ 4 C~ ~ .#~ ''':1/ ~ "\,'l~. '" V~ ""',...~l9'tk ~9 ,'^ 0,,('0 &a ~ V 01"~ ":9 ,A ~ ...:;.., ~l~ " ~. ~ r:>..~ '~".. ')7jf<... .-oJ'.." ,~ ~~'l=1l.r I have reviewed a copy of Mr Battle's letter under date July 26, 2004, In connection With the Mariam dock application Much of the letter IS a rehash of old Issues, so my response to hiS letter Will be brief Re 193 Devon Drive - Mariam Dock Application 1 Ms Soboleski's due process argument IS Without ment She had the same opportumty to attend the ORe meeting as did Mr Mariam She could have determined the "time, location and date" of the meeting Just as Mr Mariam did, by calling the Development ReVIew Services office and asking Contact Informatlon was provided In the notice to Ms Soboleski Further, the time for Ms Soboleski to submit Information to the City was extended at her request She availed herself of the additional time Any matters Ms Soboleski wants considered by the City after thiS pOint may be presented to the Commumty Development Board (COB) In an appeal of any development order the City may Issue 2 The applIcation IS complete Mr Mariam has the nght to cover hiS boat slips at anytime as a matter of right, as does Ms Soboleski If he chooses to do so, he Will apply for the appropnate permit, as she would be required to do There IS no reqUIrement at thiS time that the covers be shown Further, "detailed plans and specifications, prepared by a FlOrida profeSSional CLEARWATER OFFICE 91] CHESTNlfT S T POST OFFICE BOX 1368 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33757-1368 TELEPHONE (727) 461-181 g TELl:COPIJ:R (727) 462 OJ6'i TAMPA OFFICE 100 N TAMPA ST SUITE 1800 POST OFFICE BOX 1100 TAMPA FLORIDA 33601-1100 TELEPHONE (g])) 22'i-2'i00 TJ:LJ:COP I],R (8U) 223-1118 '. JOHNSON, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELLORS AT LAW Mr John Schodtler July 27. 2004 Page 2 engineer, bearing the seal and signature of the engineer" are reqUired for "permits," not a Level One (flexible standard development) approval 3 Mr Mariam's application meets some or all of the criteria of Section 3- 601 C 1 g 1 for a "deviation" He need meet only one such criteria for a deviation to be granted Ms Soboleski has not disputed that Mr Mariani meets some or all of these criteria 4 Ms Soboleski claims Mr Mariam's proposed dock will "have a negative Impact on the value" of her property She does not claim It will "significantly Impair" the value of the property as described In Section 3-913 A 2 Nor could she The report of Countywide Appraisal Corporation submitted with Mr Mariam's application establishes that the value of Ms Soboleski's property Will not be significantly Impaired by Mr Mariam's proposed dock 5 Cla]ms of deed restriction violations, whether founded or unfounded, are not the concern of the City'S 6 With regard to the prevIous application filed by Mr Mariam a It was for a dock located substant]ally closer to Ms Soboleski's property than the current proposal, and b The City Improperly denied the application follOWing remand by Judge Demers Mr Mariam wIthdrew his application and the City corrected ItS error by revoking ItS denial of the Imtlal application City'S have the Inherent authority to correct their errors 7 I defer to the City Attorney as to whether "offiCial notice" should be taken of entire file In connection with Mr Marlan]'s prevIous application It would appear that that file IS Irrelevant, however, as Mr Mariam's prevIous application was for a different dock In a different location If there was specific Information In that file that was pertinent to thiS appllcat]on, Ms Soboleski could have submitted It to the CIty Alternatively, If Ms Soboleski chooses to appeal any development order the City may Issue, she may appeal to the COB and produce at the appeal hearing whatever eVidence she chooses 1 All Section references are to the City'S Community Development Code .. JOHNSON, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELLORS AT LAW Mr John Schodtler July 27, 2004 Page 3 Thank you for your consideration of these pOints ~ Timothy A Johnson, Jr 07/27/040952 AM #324516 v1 - MARIANI - Response Itr Message Schodtler, John Page ] of 1 I have not received an appeal application as of this morning I will notify you when It IS received 1 John Schodtler 1 I I I I I Please advise If an appeal has been filed In this matter and, If so, please fax a copy of the notice of appeal to me at 462-0365 I I I I I I I , I I I I To Tim A Johnson Cc ccmgemseal@aol com Subject RE Mariani Dock Application -----Onglnal Message----- From: Tim A Johnson [mallto TlmJ@JPflrm com] Sent: Monday, August 09, 20048 21 AM To: Schodtler, John Cc: ccmgemseal@aol com Subject: Manam Dock Application Timothy A Johnson, Jr Johnson, Pope, Bokor, Ruppel and Burns, LLP 911 Chestnut Street Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone 727-461-1818 Facsimile 727-462-0365 1!m.L@JPflrm com The ,nformation contained In this transmiSSion may be allomey/cllent p~vlleged and therefore confidential This information IS Intended only for the use of the indiVidual or entity named above If the reader of thiS message IS nollhe Intended recipient, you are hereby notified Ihat any dlssem Inatlon, dlstrrbulron, ponllng or copy of the communication IS stnctly prohibited If you receive thiS transmiSSion In error, or If you are not the IndIVIdual or enhty named above, the receipt of thiS transmission IS not Intended to and does not waive any priVilege, attorney/client or othelWlse If you have received thiS commUnication In error please notify US by telephone al 727-461-1818 or e-mail Thank you I I I , ! I I I I 8/9/2004 1",T"""i- ,.I~\ALOF rlltAi- ..~~ ~1JfJ.#~"'#;;'7~ \"'!V..i ##".r,...... ~~....,II -~~ ~':.. .._~~~'1" -.. ~~:-~ <e: ...C.l ===-- 9i1rl ...-.~-- ~iIrl .. ~-- -==- .~ -~ ~ ~ ~ ':. ~##"~."'~~ ~\ ............)1TE~'dt ,l "71.f~ CITY I I I OF I CLEARWATER LoNG RANGE PIANJ\ING DEVFI OPMENT REvIEW IPLANNING DEPARTMENT PO'IT OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FlORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAl SERVI( E~ BUILDiJ\G, 100 SOUTH MYRTLE AV.lcNUE, CLEARWATFR, FLORIDA 33756 TIoLEPHON1. (27) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 I I I Mr Chnstopher C ManaOl 310 Live Oak Lane I Largo, FL 33770 I RE Development Order regardmg Case FLS2004f5028 at 193 Devon Dnve Dear Mr Johnson: I ThiS letter constitutes a Development Order pursuant to SectIOn 4-206 D 6 of the CommuOlty Development Code On July 8, 2004 the Develdpment Review Commlttee reViewed your apphcatlOn for FleXIble Standard Development approral to Increase the length of a dock from 60 feet (50 percent of the WIdth of the property) to 92 feet (76 6 percent of the WIdth of the property) I under the provIsIOns of SectIOn 3-601 The Develo~ment Review Committee APPROVED the applicatIon Wlth the followmg bases and condItIons I Bases for Approval I I 1 The proposal comphes with the FleXible Standard Development cntena per SectIOn 3- 601 C.l g, \ 2 The proposal IS In comphance with other standards m the Code mcludmg the General I ApplIcablhty Cntena per SectIOn 3-913, I 3 The development IS compatible With the surroundmg area I ConditIOns of Approval I 1 That the fmal deSign of the dock be consistent With the conceptual elevatIons and SIte plJn submItted to the DRC, I 2 That a copy of the SWFWMD and/or FDEP PenOlt, Corps of Engmeer's Pennlt and I Submerged Land Lease be subITIltted to the PlanOlng Department pnor to commencement of , constructIOn, and I 3 That any future additIOns or amendments be consistent to SectIOn 3-601 C 1 g(oocklManne Standards) I July 28, 2004 Mr TImothy A Johnson, Jr Johnson, Pope, et al POBox 1368 Clearwater, FL 33757 Pursuant to SectIOn 4-407, an apphcatlOn for a bUlldmg pennIt shall be made wlthm one year of FleXIble Development approval (July 28, 2005) All reqUIred certIfICates of occupancy shall be obtamed wlthm one year of the date of Issuance of the bUlldmg permit Time frames do not BKIAN J AlJt$'~T MAYUK COM\IISSIONJ R HOiT HAMII10N VIU MAYOl{-CO~\MI~,)IONrR \\rlllTNI \ (jR$, COM\jl~"'Ot\1 R rR~NK HIBBARD '( O\t\lI~~l()NJ It * IIlll Jo;..~ot\, CO\l\II~'iIOt\1 R "LQIJAI eM!'1 OY~\J !\ I AND Anml\l\l IVI Ac 110'1 }< ~\1'1 OYI R" July 28, 2004 Mr Johnson - Page 2 change with succeSSlVe owners The Commumty Development Board may grant an extensIOn of tIme for a penod not to exceed one year and only wIthm the ongmal penod of valIdity The Issuance of this Development Order does not relIeve you of the necessity to obtam any bUIldmg permIts or pay any Impact fees that may be reqUIred In order to faCIlItate the Issuance of any penrut or ltcense affected by thIS approval, please bnng a copy of thiS letter WIth you when applymg for any permIts or licenses that reqUIre thiS poor development approval If you have any questIons, please do not heSItate to call John Schodtler, Planner I at 727-562- 4604 You can access zonmg mformatIOn for parcels wlthm the CIty through our webslte hUp //www clearwater-fl com! Cynthia Tarapam, AICP Planmng Director S \Plaamag Deparlmeaf\C D B\Slandard FleNendmg CaseJ\2 - ReVIewed and Pendmg\Devon J 93 Manam IflDevon 193 Development Order doc DRC Meetmg Date Case Number Apphldnt Address Julv R. 2004 F LS2004-0502 8 Mr & Mrs Chmtopher Manam 193 Devon [)nve CITY OF CLEARW A 1 ER PLANNING DEPARTMENT REVISED S r A. F REPORT GENERAL INFORMATION, REQUEST: FlexIble Standard Development approval to mlred~e thc length of a dock from 60 feet (50 pcrGent of the wIdth of the property) 10 92 feet (76 6 percent of the wIdth of the property) under the provlSlOn<; of SectIOn 3-601 ZONING LMDR, Low MedIUm Density Resldentlal Dl<;tnlt EXISTING USE' Smgle-fdmrly resldentlal AnJACENl LAND USES North South East We,>t Smgle-famlly re<;ldent1d1 Clldf\Nater Bay Smglc-famlly rC'>ldentldl Smgl e- faml1 y rG'>ldentldl STAFF ANALYSIS The 0 33-acre slle 1<; <;Ite located on thl <;outh ~Idl of Dcvon Dnve approxImately 1,350 fect Cd<,t of Hdmdcn Dnve Thcrc 1<; lUITcntly .I new ~lngle-fdmrly reSidence under constructIOn on <;IK undcr budding permIt number BCP2003- 10348 The apphcatlOn mcludes a 488 square foot dOlk and two boatlIfts The proposed dock and bOdtl,ft,> .Ire to blloldtcd .I lmmmum of30 feet from the SIde (east and west) property lme,> The locatIOn of the dock In the center one-thud of the <;lte <;hollld reduGG or elImmdte dny negative Impacts on adJdccnt propert1C<' All other Code reqll1rcmcnt<, rcgdrdlng docks WIll be met All reqU1red GOI1,>tructlon and navigatIOnal penmts would need to be obtdlncd pnor to constructIOn The site IS located 111 a <;table re<;ldGntldl neIghborhood that IS underg01l1g redevelopment The reque,>t to mcrease the pcrmltted length of the dock IS 111 keep10g WIth the e:>tablI~hed chardcter of eXlstmg docks 10 the area and thc Pmellas County Department of EnVIronmental Mdndgement has Issued a report, which <;tate<; <;Gagrd~~ beds are located along thl'> entire property, and extend out to a maXlmum of 65 feet from the seawall 111 the area of the proposed dock although It become<; <;par<;e at apprOxlmdtely 60 feet rhey hmlt <;tructure<, over sedgrasse,> to 4 feet 111 WIdth and to placl the tcrmlndl platform,> dnd boat shps beyond the limits of thc '>Cdgrd~~c~ wherever pOSSIble CountYWIde Appr,u'>dl CorpordtlOn'<, Impact report mdlcates that the proposed dot-k ,>y<,tcm WIll not '>Igmficantly Impair the value of tht- ddJdccnt Idl1d or bUIldings B. FLEXIBILITY STANDARDS .'OR nOCKS IN ASSOCIATION WITH SINGU-I<AMILY DWELLINGS IN I HI<: I.M DR, LOW MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDEN IIAt. DISTRICT (SectIOn 3-601) STANDARD REQUIRED/ EXISTING PROPOSED IN PERMITTED COMPLIANCE? LENGTH 50 percent of the Width of the V 3C3nt 92 feet (76 percent) No maximum propertv (60 feet (IV, 120 lot Width) WIDTH Thlrty-fivG (35) pLrccnt of the Width Vacant 12 feet Ye<; MaXimum of the property (42 feet) or fifty (50) feet, whIchever IS less Page 1 STANDARD REQUIRED/ EXISTING l'ROPOSED IN PERMITTED COMPLlANCb'l SIDE Docks the ccnter one-thud of the lot Vacant Doek Ed~t 10 feet Yes SETBACK (40 fl-l-t) or twenty (20) feet from any (minimum) propcrty lme, whlLhcver 1~ k~~ We<;t 10 feet Boathfts/servlce catwalks mmmlum (mmlmum) of ten (10) feet from ,lilY property Boathft lme W e~t 30 feet (mlmmum) C. FLEXIBILITY CRITERIA FOR DOCKS (SectIOn 3-601)' 1. The proposed docl.. will result Jfl no nclvlgatlonal conflicts and the length of the proposed dock will not exceed twenty-five (25) percent of the Width of the waterway, or The City of Clearwater Harbormaster <;tate,> that there are no navIgatIOnal eoncem<; WIth the proposed devclopment, therefore meetmg the fi rst part of the condl lIOn Thc length of the proposed dock WI II be ] 4 percent of the Width of the waterway, therefore me.ct,> the ~econd half of thiS conditIOns 2 The proposed dock locatIOn need!> to be adjusted to protect envlronmentdlly senSltl\C areas, or fhe Pmellas County Department of Envlronmcntdl Mdnagement has Issued a report whIch states seagrass bcds arc 10l-dtcd dlong thl~ entire property, and extend Ollt to a mdXlmum of 65 feet from the seawall In the drea of the proposed dock allhough It bccome,> <;parsc dt dpproxlmately 60 feet It I'> the pollcy of thiS [PmclIa,> County EnvlronmcntdI M,lnagementJ department to hmlt ,>tructurc~ over seagrasses to 4 fect In Width and to place thc temlmal platforms dnd boat sl1ps beyond the llmlt,> of thc ~e.dgrd~~es wherever pO'>~lbk Thcrefore, thl~ proposed dock meets thiS conditIOn bd~ed on the report of the Pmclla<; County Depdrtment of EnVironmental Management 3 The property configuratIOn preeludes the pldeement of a dock III compliance With the reqUlred dimensIOnal standdrds; however, the proposed dock will be 'Ilmdclr m dimenSIOnal charactenstlc!o .1'1 surroundmg docl.. patterns. Not apphcable D. GENERA.L APPLlCABILI I Y (Section 3-913): ConditIOns "hlch arc Imposed by the Commumty Development Coordmator and the CommullIly Development Bo.trd pursudnt to a Level One or a Level Two Appro"dl shdll en!oure that 1. The proposed development of the I.md will be m harmony with the scale, bulk, coverage, den~lty, and character of adjacent properties in whllh It IS located. Mo~t of the. propcrtlC<' m the neIghborhood have docks approxlmatcly 35 to 90 fe.elm length 1 he proposed dock of 92 feet In length clppears to be consistent with the character ofthc dred 2. The proposed development Will not hmder or dl<,courage the appropnate development and u~e of adjacent land and bUlldmgs or slgmficantly Impdlr the vdlue thereof [he slte IS zoned LMDR District and the propo,>cd u'>c Will be m compliance wlth that zonmg The propo~cd development Wll[ not discourage appropnate Jevdopmcnt dnd u<,e of ddJdcent land bulidmgs dlc.ordl1lg to the Countywide Appraisal CorporatIOn',> Impact report of the propo~ed dock ~y~tem Page 2 3 'I he proposed development \\111 not adversely ilffeLt the health or safety or persons re\ldlng or norl..rng In the neighborhood of the proposed use The development will not negatIvely affect the hedlth or ~dfcty or per~on~ re~ldlIlg or workmg m the neighborhood '] he City of Cledrwater Hdrbormaster's office mdleate<; the propo<;al will not result 111 a hdZdrd to ndvlgdtlOll 4 The propo<;ed development IS designed tu mlnlm.,e traffic congestIOn The propo<;ed dock will have no mcreased etTect on trdffic' l-Ong,,~tlOn 5. The proposed development IS consistent with the community chdrdcter of the Immediate vlclmty of the parcel proposed for de\'e1opment. Mo~t of the propertJe~ In the neighborhood hdve docks approximately 35 to 90 feet m length The proposed dock 0 f 92 feet lTI length appear<; to be COn'>I <;tent wllh th" ehdr deter of the d red 6. The de<;lgn of the proposed development mlnlml7CS adverse effects, Ille]udlllg visual, acou1otlC and olfactory and hours of operatIOn Impacts, on adjacent properhe~ The locatIOn of the dock will reduce or ellmmate VIsual Impacts on ,>uIToundmg propcrtK~ to the west STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Ba<;ed on the apphcatlOn, the propo<;al 1<; 1Il compliance wIth the ~tdnddf(b dnd entend for FleXible Standard Development approval with the maximum development potenttal, the Dock/Manna Standard<; for deVIatlOn;. (two of the cntena have been met where only one IS reqUlred) and With all applicable standards of the Community Development Code Therefore, staff recommends APPROVAL of the application for Flexible Standdrd Development dpprovdl to lnerCd"e the length of d dock from 60 fcet (50 pcrc'cnt of the WIdth of the property) to 92 feet (76 6 percent of the Width of the property) under the provIsIOns of SectIOn 3-601 on the follOWing bd'>(,<; dnd GOndltlOn Ba<;e<; for approval The proposal compltes With the FleXible Standard Development cntena under the proVI<;10n'> of Section 3- 601 C I g 2 The propo;.dl, ciS dmended, I;' In complldnce With other ;.tdndards III the Code meludmg the General Appllcablhty Cn tcn d per SectIon 3 -9 I 3, dml 3 The development IS compatible WIth the surroundmg area CondltlOn<; of approval That the final deSIgn of the dock be conSistent With the conceptual elevatIOns and sIte plan submitted 10 the DRC, 2 That a copy of the SWFWMD and/or FDEP Pem1lt, Corps of Engmeer's Pem11t and Submerged Ldnd LCd"e be submitted to the Pldnmng Department pnor to commencement of eonstructlOn, and 3 I hat any future additIOns or dmendment;. be con~l~tent to SectIOn 3-601 C I g Dock/Mdnne Stdndard<;) ~ IPlan/J/Jlg Departmel1l\C D lJ1Standard Fin IPendlllg Cases\2 - Rel-le\lcd and l-'endmglDcwJI 193 MOIlOI1l f/\lJCWI1 193 Repoll Revl\ed doc Page 3 ~ {S:l~,a~ rwater ~, ,- ~\-, ! ~ -= I IN"":.:.... "'11-1--== o FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 s. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865 ::MNG-r N \6 MJ:1I>.,.,)-N TO: FAX: 1- <671 - ZSJ - 3'81 MESSAGE: ~I\IJEIUI O~ NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) SEHD 11>~G F'EPDRT Jul 29 2004 08: 14RM YOUR LOGO YOUR FRX NO Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4855 NO. OTHER FRCSIMILE 01 918772513681 STRRT TIME USAGE TIME MODE PRGES RESULT Jul.2908'13RM 01'07 SND 03 OK TO TI.JRN OFF REPORT. PRESS · MENU' m!W. THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX AD\..IANTAGE ASS I STANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-8OO-HB...P-FAX (435-7329). Page I of 1 Schodtler, John From Morris, William 0 Sent Wednesday, July 28,20041041 AM To Schodtler, John Cc Buysse, Beverly A Subject RE FLS2004-05028 - Manam dock John, thanks, got It, reviewed It and I see no navigation problem, specifically It IS not a hazard to navigation As I have mentioned with other "new" docks as the county requires a certain water depth under the boats and forces the docks out from shore, I encourage the dock owner to consider some light feature at the end of the dock as many docks now have done, so that boaters In the habit of cutting the corners are now faced with longer docks It IS not a condition and there IS plenty of navigable water past the dock This IS also In keeping with the dimenSions of docks adjoining and the multiuse town home docks on the end of Brrghtwater -----Ongmal Message----- From: Schodtler, John sent: Wednesday, July 28,20048'08 AM To: Morns, William 0 Cc: Buysse, Beverly A Subject: FLS2004-0S028 - Mananl dock Bill, The Marram dock went before the ORC on July 8th and there were no comments from the Harbor Masters office Could you please mdlcate by replYing to this e-mail that there were or were not any Issues with regards to water navigation I need to have a reply this mornmg Thanks, John Schodtler Planner I 7/2812004 ,-Me%age Schodtler, John Pdge I of 1 From Sent To Subject Tim A Johnson [TlmJ@Jpflrm com} Tuesday, July 27,20041051 AM Schodtler, John #324516 v1 - MARIANI - Response Itr Please see the attached, which I also faxed to you 7/27/2004 PLANN1~G & DEVelOPMENT , CiT" or ClEAPl/IJA,TEA .' JOHNSON, POPF BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP A I I ORNrv>. f\N I) COUN~CLLOR>. ,\ I I -\w CD .\RM>.lRONG III flRUCC II 1301-01{ JOHN R flONNCR ~R * (JUY M BURNS JONA 1 HAN SCaLEMAN STAL V COS I NCR MICHAEL T CRONlN CLILABIoI H J DANICL>. flrCKY FERRIoLL-<\NTON COI LCLN "I fL YNN M-\RION HALe, ~COTT C II GENfRl1 L fRANK K JAKC~ TIMOTHY \ JOIINSON, JR SHARON r KRICK RUGER A LAR>.ON JOHN R LAW~ON JI{' I EANNIo LETlZE MIUI'\e,LG L1TTl E MIUIAe,LC MARKII-\"I Z.\CI 1'\ R I' D MIoS::.A A R CBARUC Nb\L IRO'\' J PFRDUE e WAll ACC POPE 1R ROBCRT V PO n loR JR AUDREY 13 RAUCHWAY DARRYL R RICHIl,RD::. PrTCR <\ RIVELLlNI DrNNI~ G RUPPLL' CHAR U:;S \ S \M Il,RI-()~ PHILIP M SHASTFrN JOll,N M Ve,CCHIOII ~ TEVIoN H WFI NflERGER JOSEPH J WrI~SM-\N S II:: VEN.\ WI I UAMSON *Qr COUNSEL PLEASE REPLY 10 U r~Al{WATER FILE NO 42809 104550 July 27,2004 VIA FACSIMILE and U.S. MAIL Mr John Schodtler Development ReView Specialist Planning Department Municipal Services BUilding 100 South Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, FL 33756 Re 193 Devon Drrve ~ Marranl Dock Application I have reviewed a copy of Mr Battle's letter under date July 26, 2004, In connection with the Marranl dock application Much of the letter IS a rehash of old Issues, so my response to hiS letter Will be brref 1 Ms Soboleski's due process argument IS without merrt She had the same opportunity to attend the DRC meeting as did Mr Marranl She could have determined the "tIme, location and date" of the meeting Just as Mr Marranl dId, by calling the Development ReView Services office and asking Contact information was provided In the notice to Ms SoboleskI Further, the time for Ms Soboleski to submit Information to the City was extended at her request She availed herself of the additional time Any matters Ms Soboleski wants considered by the City after this pOint may be presented to the Community Development Board (COB) In an appeal of any development order the City may Issue 2 The application IS complete Mr Marranl has the rrght to cover hiS boat slips at anytime as a matter of rrght, as does Ms Soboleski If he chooses to do so, he Will apply for the approprrate permit, as she would be required to do There IS no requirement at this tlme that the covers be shown Further, "detailed plans and specifications, prepared by a Florrda profeSSIonal CLEARW,\TFR 01 Flrb 911 ( Hb~lNUT ST POST OFFICE IlOX 1368 CLEAR\\ATER, H ORIDA 3J757-136~ TELEPHO!\ I (727) 461 1818 TJ:tbCOP1ER (727) 46Z-03(,5 TAMPA OFFlle lOON T~MP'\'>T ;UI rE 1800 POST OFFICF BOX 1100 TAMPA fLORIDA 3,601-1100 I ~I rPHONE (~13) 22,2,00 I EL[COP1ER (81 J) 223-711 S ~ . JOHNSON, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, L II ~@~a~~m Pl.AN~~ fjCEY~~OPMENT VCS '-O\AWATER A I TORNEYS, AND COUN~I=.LLORS AT LA W Mr John Schodtler July 27, 2004 Page 2 engineer, beanng the seal and signature of the engineer" are reqUired for "permits," not a Level One (flexible standard development) approval 3 Mr Manam's application meets some or all of the cntena of Section 3- 601 C 1 g 1 for a "deviation" He need meet only one such cntena for a deViation to be granted Ms Soboleski has not disputed that Mr Manam meets some or all of these cntena 4 Ms Soboleski claims Mr Manam's proposed dock will "have a negative Impact on the value" of her property She does not claim It will "significantly Impair" the value of the property as descnbed In Section 3-913 A 2 Nor could she The report of Countywide Appraisal Corporation submItted With Mr Mananl's application establishes that the value of Ms Soboleski's property will not be slgmflcantly Impaired by Mr Manam's proposed dock 5 Claims of deed restnctlon Violations, whether founded or unfounded, are not the concern of the City's 6 With regard to the prevIous application filed by Mr Manam a It was for a dock located substantially closer to Ms Soboleski's property than the current proposal, and b The City Improperly denied the application following remand by Judge Demers Mr Manam Withdrew hiS application and the City corrected ItS error by revoking ItS demal of the Imtlal application City's have the Inherent authonty to correct their errors 7 I defer to the City Attorney as to whether "offiCial notice" should be taken of entire file In connection With Mr Mananl's prevIous application It would appear that that file IS Irrelevant, however, as Mr Mananl's prevIous application was for a different dock In a different location If there was specific Information In that file that was pertinent to thiS application, Ms Soboleski could have submitted It to the City Alternatively, If Ms Soboleski chooses to appeal any development order the City may Issue, she may appeal to the COB and produce at the appeal heanng whatever eVidence she chooses 1 All Section references are to the City's Community Development Code ., .. JOHNSON, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPI::L & BURNS, LLP AT fO R Nt, Y ~ AN]) CO U N S [L LOR ~ A r I_A W Mr John Schodtler July 27,2004 Page 3 Thank you for your consideration of these pOints Sincerely, Timothy A Johnson, Jr 07/27/04 11 17 AM #324516 v1 - MARIANI - Response Itr SChodtler. John From: Sent To Subject Tarapanl, Cyndl Tuesday, July 27,2004446 PM Schodtler, John FW Request for AddItIonal TIme fYl Cynd~ Tarapan~ Plannlng D~rector (727)562-4547 cynd~ tarapan~@MyClearwater.com -----Orlglnal Message----- From T~m A Johnson [ma~lto T~mJ@Jpflrm com] Sent Tuesday, July 27, 2004 4 39 PM To Tarapanl, Cynd1 Cc ccmgemseal@aol com SubJect. RE' Request for Addltlonal T1me Agreed. -----Orlglnal Message----- From Cynd~ Tarapanl@myClearwater com [mallto Cyndl Tarapanl@myClearwater.com] Sent Tuesday, July 27, 2004 4 34 PM To Tlm A Johnson Cc John Schodtler@myClearwater com; Ch1p Gerlock@myClearwater com, Leslle Dougall-Sldes@myClearwater.com SubJect. Request for Add1t~onal T~me Please conslder thlS a request for one add~tlonal day for me to reach a decls10n on the Marlanl flex standard appllcat1on, Case FLS 2004-05028 I would llke to request that we mutually agree to extend the date for a declslon to tomorrow, wednesday, July 28, 2004 I apolog1ze for any 1nconvenlence but my absence from the off1ce coupled wlth the demands when I returned has necessltated thls need for an addltlonal day Please respond as soon as posslble Thank you Cyndl Tarapan~ Plannlng Dlrector (727)562-4547 Cyndl tarapan~@MyClearwater com 1 Schodtler, John From: Sent. To: Cc: Subject. Tarapanl, Cyndl Tuesday, July 27, 2004434 PM 'tlmJ@lpflrm com' Schodtler, John, Gerlock, Chip, Dougall-Sides, Leslie Request for Additional Time Contacts: Tim Johnson Please consIder thIs a request for one adilltlonal day for me to reach a declSlon on the Manafil flex standard apphcatlon, Case FLS 2004-05028 I would hke to request that we mutually agree to extend the date for a decIsIon to tomorrow, Wednesday, July 28, 2004 I apologtze for any 1I1convemence but my absence from the office coupled wIth the demands when I returned has necessItated dus need for an adchtlonal day Please respond as soon as possIble Thank you Cyndl Tarapani Planrung DlIectot C12 7) 562-4547 cynill tarapam@MyClearwater com 1 BATTLE & EDENFIELD, P.A. AlTORNEYS AT LAW MAXWELL G BATTLE, JR ALSO ADMITI ED COl...ORAOO NEW MEXICO FLORIDA 206 Mason Street Brandon, FL 33S II rEI... (813) 685-3014 July 26,2004 John Schodtler Development RevIew SpecialIst Planning Department Mumclpal Services Building 100 South Myrtle Ave. Clearwater, FL 33756 Re: 193 Devon Drive; Lot 31; Application of Chris Mariani for Flexible Development Standard Approval; FLS2004-05028 Dear Mr Schodtler I represent James and Deborah Soboleski who own the resIdence to the Immediate West of Mr. ChriS Mariam's lot (Lot 31, 193 Devon Drive) for which the above apphcation was submItted My clients are vehemently opposed to Mr MarIam's request as It IS now constituted. I wrote to you on July 7, 2004 askmg that the Development ReView Committee meetmg scheduled for July 8, 2004 at a tIme and location not dISclosed in your ''NOTICE'' dated June 17,2004 be continued to a date not earher than August 5, 2004 and that you re-notIce the meetmg specifymg the TIME. LOCATION and DATE ThiS request was based upon Due Process considerations and the fact that your ''NOTICE'' dId not III our view comply WIth procedural due process requirements or the requirements ofthe Commumty Development Code because It failed to specIfy the TIme, Date and Location of the meetmg whIle the Code speaks m terms of "substantial competent evidence" being provided prIor to, OR AT THE MEETING [So does the "NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004]. The City failed to honor thiS request WIthout faIT and proper notice, the SoboleskIs were demed procedural due process As I suggested to you m my letter of July 7, 2004, the legal doctrIne ofprocedural due process is the means by which our legal system insures that basiC fairness is afforded all whose substantive rIghts are at Issue, Kev's CItizens for Responsible Government. Inc, 795 So 2d 940 (Fla. 2001) It restrIcts the means by whIch agencies of our government reach declSlons that adversely affect both the liberty of and the property rIghts of our people County of Pasco v. RteW, 620 So 2d 229 (Fla 2d DCA 1993) The FlOrIda Supreme Court has clearly stated that Procedural due *** process requIres both fair notIce and a real opportumty to be heard "at a meanmgful tune and m a meaningful manner" Key's Citizens, supra, @ 948 [cltmg Mathews v EldrIdge, 424 U S 319, 333, 47 LEd. 2d 18,96 S.Ct 893 (1976) Although you wrote advismg that the Commumty Development Coordmator had agreed to delay her decision until July 27, 2004 to allow my Chents an opportunity to provide addItional information, the Community Development Meetmg was apparently held on July 8, 2004 Because the Commumty Development Meetmg referenced m your "NOTICE" dated June 17,2004 was not rescheduled and properly noticed, It is clear that my Cbents were not granted either" faIr notIce or a real opportunity to be heard at a meamngful tune and in a meaningful manner" In addition, the faIlure to reschedule the meetmg as requested m my July 7,2004 letter to you dId not provIde sufficient time for my Chents to prepare the sort of mformatIon and presentatIon that I suggested m my letter and that they should be entitled to present at the Community Development Board Meeting. Although my Clients have been demed sufficient time to prepare and submIt the mformatIon that I outlmed m my July 7, 2004 letter to you, I remind you of the following Issues addressed in my letter. FITst, I am concerned that you do not yet have a complete application. It appears to me that the Section 4-202 , Community Development Code requITes 1) Subsection A, 12( e) that structural overhangs and bUlldmg heIghts be depicted. The Applicant has reportedly communIcated to my Clients and his compamon Kymm Kidwell that he intends to cover the dock and boatshps as depicted m hiS prevIous ApplIcation No. 02-01-03, and 2) Subsection A, 24 appears to requITe detaIled plans and specIfications prepared, Signed and sealed by a Florida Registered ProfeSSional Engmeer It does not appear from your NOTICE dated June 17, 2004 [BUT MAILED SUBSEQUENT TO JUNE 21, 2004 that either a plan depicting the structural overhangs or detaIled plans and specifications signed and sealed by a Florida Registered Professional Engmeer has been submitted The Plan given to my Cbents by the ApplIcant [Copy attached} With a representation that It was the plan submItted does not meet these criteria. The Applicant's need to exceed the length and dimensIOnal standards arises not from any mescapable or Wlfeasonable hardship, but rather from the ApplIcant's desrre to 2 place his dock out of his sight and in that of my Chents. By placmg the Dock In the middle of his Lot, Mr. Mariam creates a situation where the water depth IS too shallow at the allowable length of approximately 60 feet If Mr Marlani places the Dock further East adjacent to the Blum's property [Please note that Blums dId not object preVIously to this location in responding to Mr Mariam's prior Application No 02-01-03], the water depth appears to be of sufficient depth that the extra 32 feet would be unnecessary The shorterung of the dock along WIth Its movement to the East would save the Applicant substantIal money and provide a more environmentally conscious end product due to a decreased shaded area of sea bottom and a deeper water depth beneath the dock footprint, both ofwhtch enhance the growth and survIvabIlity of sea grasses! Unfortunately your Staff Report erroneously concludes that the requested increased length of the dock will provide a "... mo re environmentally sensitive situation over existing conditions." HOW CAN YOUR STAFF CONCLUDE THAT GREATER COVERAGE OF THE SEA BOTTOM IN AN AREA WITH MORE GRASS AT A SHALLOWER DEPTH IS MORE ENVIROMENT ALLY SENSITIVE THAN THE EXISTING CONDITIONS ? AT PRESENT THERE IS NO DOCK AT ALL! The proposed length and configuratIon of the dock Will destroy the scemc view from the Soboleskis' property, Will have a negatIve Impact upon the value of the Soboleskis' property and can not conceivably enhance the value of the either the Soboleskts' property or the surroundmg property Smce these negative impacts can be aVOided at a savmgs to both the Applicant and the Environment, It seems clear that the ApplicatIon Violates [and is intolerably inconsistent With] the precepts of Code Section 1- 103, Part I, Community Development Code Your Staff Report erroneously concludes that: "The location of the dock, as suggested by Staff, will reduce or eliminate visual impacts on surrounding properties to the West." This statement bv Staff is totallv lackine: in merit and does not aooear to be suooorted bv the evidence. It IS also instructive to note that the dock length and configuratIon proposed by the ApplIcant appear to clearly VIolate the provisions of Page 2, Paragraph 8 of the Restnctive Covenants recorded at 0 R Book 860, PG 51, 52, Public Records of PIn ell as County, FL. I also call your attention to the fact that a substantIally SimIlar ApplIcatIon was previously filed by Mr. MarIam last year, to Wit - Application No. 02-01-03. That ApplicatIon was ultimately denied after beIng reversed by the CrrcUlt Court of Pmellas County Then It appears that upon request of the Applicant, that the dental was rescmded after the tlTIle for appeal had expIred. There seems to be no proVISIon In the Community Development Code for the PlannIng DIrector or any other CIty OffiCIal to alter, amend, or rescmd deCisions rendered on Level One ApplIcations and certamly not after the tlTIle for appeal has expIred Therefore, I suggest to you that your office is without jurisdiction to entertain, much less grant, the present Application. I Shadmg the sea bottom nnposes a slgmficant negative Impact on sea grasses dependant upon photosynthesis Decreasmg the shaded area and lflCfeaslflg the height above the grass from which the shade emanates lflcreases the light transmitted to the grass 3 Finally, I ask that you take official notice of the entire file [includmg without lImItation all Items in the Appellate FIle] from Mr. Mariam's prevIous Application No. 02-01-03, incorporate it into and include it in the record OD the present Application. As you can see from the foregomg comments, there are many disputed Issues that should be addressed m substantially more detail before the Commumty Development Coordmator renders a deciSion. This ApplIcant has already had one deCISIon of the CommunIty Development Coordinator [Ms. Tarapam] reversed for Due Process Violations I hope that before thiS occurs agam that the City Will reopen thIS entire matter for PublIc Comment, schedule another Community Development Meeting on tlus ApplIcation and provide proper Constitutional NotIce to all affected parties Very truly yours, Maxwell G. Battle, Jr. Maxwell G. Battle, Jr. Cc James and Deborah Soboleski 4 OH7-04 10 15am Frcm.JOHNSON,pr 72744186 IT T-Z94 P 01/04 F-ZS9 -'" JOHNSON. POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS LLP 911 Chestnut Street, P. 0 Box 1368 Clearwater FL 33757-1368 Telephone: (727) 461-1018 Fax: (727) 441-8617 Facsimile Cover Sheet ~~f/~ To: Company: Phone: Fax: /;7 ? ~.~~ J (J tj LJ t;7) From: Client Name: CIientJM:atter Number: Date: Pages including this cover page: ~ Lj Comments: The: ;'If<)fll)S.lIon con~lIlW1l In lhls tfllllS1fIlSSlOO ffi>.~ ~ nuomcylcllen, pn Yllegcd ~nd lIm~rOte mnlUltllllll! Th" ",fmmao on '" inlO:lldcd only for d1B use of lhc rndl rl~ or en~ 'Y ~ "bo.~ If (h. ",oder of lb.. moS""llc ~ !101 I/U mtendrd """p'enl, y"" at. hi o'clly I'IOllficd dm nn y dl50~nnuon, dlstnbu lien or ropy o( dllo oommumi:allCll II .<I(,c(l~ l'rohllnlcd ff yo~ reoe.vc duo lrnrmru..1Cn ,n etl'Qt onf you lite nO! 1M mIL Y1dm1l. orolltJ!)' named nlln~e, lhc ICCCl pi of tlus 1I1lMlJUl$Illn 1'1 nnllmended to ,nd(lOoS not WllVe OIly ,,",ilngo,aaorney/cllenl or olhc\",,'c Jfy..... have =clved lbll wmmnn.eaIlon ,n enat, please nOllry IlII by "'lcphono.,wIIcCI, ""d rcNIlllhc OOCIMI 'JlU!lIlflC 10 U'.u th~ .\>(1'. add=. VI' US P{J!,a1 Sel';,e" You w,ll be fClml,un."" fOr iIIly pOll/lllC at allY oWer C:X~MC WOCI~1cd ""llh 1II~ return of Ib,. dooylll"'Jl, Thank YOll 07-27-04 10 15am From-JOHNSON,POr 7274418617 T-294 P 02/04 F-289 . " JOHNSON, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP ATTORNEY'I AND COUNSELLOrS AT LAW E. D ARMSTRONG IU BROCE H BOKOR JOHN II. SONNER. SIl: · GUY M BURNS JONATHAN S COLEMAN STACY cosrnf,.lt MICHAEL T CRONIN j;UZABEfli J DM1EL~ BEa.. Y fERRELL-A."IT~ COLLEEN M FLYNN MARION 11 Al.-E SCOTI C lLGENFRlTt fRANKR JAKES TIMOTHY A JOHN~ON,:m. SHARON So KRICK ROGER A. LARSON .ImN R 1-A W~ON,.rn.. LEANNE lETIZB MICHAEl G L1m~ M1CtlAE.l c. MARKHAM ZACHAR 'I D MES~A A II.. "CH, ~tu.IE" NEi\L TROY J l'ERDUE F WAJ..l-ACEPOPE lit R09UT v POTIER. 3R AUOREY B RAUCI1WA Y DARRYL II. RICHAflPS PETER. ^ (UVELLINl DHNMS G RUPPEL" CHARLES A SAMARKOS Jl'liII.IP M SlL\STEEN )CANM. VECCtllOU STEVEN H. ~nmERGER JOSEPH J WflSSMAN STEVEN A. WlLUAMSON "OF CotJNSa PLEASS l'tEPLY TO CLEARWATER FI~E NO 42809 1 04550 July 27,2004 VIA FACSIMILE and u.s. MAIL Mr John Schodtler Development ReView SpecIalist Planning Department Municipal Services BUilding 100 South Myrtle Avenue ClealWater, FL 33756 Re 193 Devon Drive - Manam Dock Appllcatlon I have reviewed a copy of Mr. Battle's letter under date July 26, 2004, in connection with the MarIani dock application Much of the letter IS a rehash of old issues, so my response to his letter will be brtef 1 Ms Soboleski's due process argument is wrthout ment She had the same opportunIty to attend the ORC meetmg as did Mr. Manam She could have determined the "time, location and date" of the meeting just as Mr Mariani did, by calling thEl Development ReVIew Services office and asking Contact Information was provided In the notice to Ms Soboleski Further, the tIme for Ms. SoboleskI to submit information to the CIty was extended at her request She availed herself of the addrllonal time. Any matters Ms Soboleski wants considered by the City after thIS pOint may be presented to the Commumty Development Board (COB) In an appeal of any development order the City may issue 2 The application IS complete Mr Manam has the nght to cover hiS boat slips at anytime as a matter of right, as does Ms SoboleskI If he chooses to do so, he Will apply for the appropnate permit, as she would be required to do There IS no reqUirement at thiS time that the covers be shown Further, lldetalled plans and specificatIons, pmpared by a Flonda professional ClEARW A TllIl Ol'l'lCB 911 CHf.S'fN1Jl' ST /'OST OFFICE IIOX ll<iS CLJi:AAWATER. rLORIDA 3~7S7.136a TI!l..EPHO'ijj (12') ol6l.18\ ~ ll'l"-COPlER (7:!7) 4Ii200l<i' T,.I.MpAO~~lCE. 100 N T/lM'PA no ~Ul're \ROO P051' Q~~lCl! BOX 1100 TAi.'\1PA, FLQ!UDA ~J6tll'IIOO Thl-ePUONli (81;1)";" 25<<1 Tal>COPlEIl (8 m 2~-' II S 07-27-04 10 15am From-JOHNSON,Pr 'A 7274418617 T-2S4 P 03/04 F-28e JOHNSON, POPE. BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP ATT01l.NEn AND COUNSELLORS At l.AW Mr. John Schodtler July 27,2004 Page 2 engineer, bearing the seal and signature of the engineer" are reqUIred for "permits," not a Level One (flexible standard development) approval 3 Mr Mananl's application meets some or all of the criteria of Section 3- 601 C 1 9 1 for a ndevlabon I' He need meet only one such criteria for a deViation to be granted Ms SoboleskI has not disputed that Mr Mariam meets some or all of these critena 4 Ms Soboleski claims Mr Mariani's proposed dock Will "have a negative Impact on the value" of her property She does not clallll It Will "significantly Impair" the value of the property as described In Section 3-913.A.2 Nor could she The report of Countywide Appraisal Corporation submitted with Mr Mananl's application establishes that the value of Ms Soboleskl1s property will not be Significantly Impaired by Mr Mariam's proposed dock 5. Claims of deed restnctlon violations, whether founded or unfounded, are not the concern of the City's 6 WIth regard to the previous application filed by Mr Manam a It was for a dock located substantially closer to Ms Soboleskl1s property than the current proposal: and b The City Improperly denred the appllcatron follOWing remand by Judge Demers Mr Mariani withdrew hiS application and the City corrected Its error by revoking Its demal of the imtial application CltYS have the Inherent authonty to correct theIr errors. 7 I defer to the City Attorney as to whether "offiCIal notice" should be taken of entire file In connection with Mr Manaru's prevIous application It would appear that that file IS Irrelevant, however, as Mr Manani's prevIous application was for a dltferent dock 10 a different location. If there was specific Information In that file that was pertinent to this appllcatlon4 Ms Soboleski could nave submitted It to the City. Alternatively, If Ms Soboleski chooses to appeal any development Older the City may Issue, she may appeal to the CDB and produce at the appeal heanng whatever eVidence she chooses 1 All Sc;otlon rtlfcro:o.-.ees. are t<;> t"'e C.ty's Ccmmunrty DevelopmeJ'lt Code 07-27-04 10 16arn From-JOHNSON,P~~~ PA 7274418817 T-284 P 04/04 F-288 JOHNSON, POPE~ BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, LLP A iTORNEYS A NP COUNSELLORS A T LAW Mr John Schodtler July 27, 2004 Page 3 Thank you for your consideration of these pOints Sinceroly, cT~ TImothy A Johnson, Jr 07/27/04 09 52 AM #324516 v1 . MARIANI - Respoose Ill" r Schodller, John From Sent r- To Subject Schodtler, John Tuesday, July 27,2004753 AM Tarapanl, Cyndl FW Application of Chns Mananl, App# FLS2004-05028, 103 Devon Dr, Lot 31 ~ E.J Schodtler Itr 7262004 ESCRIPT -----Orlglnal Message----- From M Battle [mall to maxsmlles2004@hotmall com] Sent Monday, July 26, 2004 10 40 PM To Schodtler, John SubJect Appllcatlon of Chrls Marlanl, App# FLS2004-05028, 103 Devon Dr , Lot 31 Dear Mr Schodtler please see attached letter The orlglnal was faxed to you today, July 26, 2004 Thank you Maxwell G Battle, Jr Battle & Edenfleld, P A -,. 1 Schodtler, John From Sent To Subject Schodtler, John Tuesday, July 27, 2004753 AM 'M Battle' ) RE Application of Chrrs Marranl, App# FLS2004-05028, 103 Devon Dr, lot 31 Thank you for your correspondence Vla Fax and E-mall John Schodtler, planner I -----Orlglnal Message----- From M Battle [mallto maxsmlles2004@hotmall com] Sent Monday, July 26, 2004 10 40 PM To Schodtler, John subJect Appllcatlon of Chrls Marlanl, App# FLS2004-05028, 103 Devon Dr , Lot 31 Dear Mr Schodtler Please see attached letter The Orlglnal was faxed to you today, July 26, 2004 Thank you Maxwell G Battle, Jr Battle & Edenfleld, P A 1 Schodtler, John From Sent To Subject "- Schodtler, John I _ Tuesday, July 27,2004749 AM / 'TlmJ@Jpflrm com' FW Application of Chns Mananl, App# FLS2004-05028, 103 Devon Dr, Lol31 ~ Schodller Ilr 7262004 ESCRIPT -----Qrlglnal Message----- From M Battle [mallto maxsmlles2004@hotmall com] Sent Monday, July 26, 2004 10 40 PM To Schodtler, John SubJect Appllcatlon of ChrlS Marlanl, App# FLS2004-05028, 103 Devon Dr , Lot 31 Dear Mr Schodtler Please see attached letter The Orlglnal was faxed to you today, July 26, 2004 Thank you Maxwell G Battle, Jr Battle & Edenfleld, P A 1 07/25/2004 20'17 00000000~~ LAW OFFICE PAGE 01/05 FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION COVER SHEET , . Battle & Edenfield, P A 206 Mason Street Brandon, FL 3351] (813) 685-3014 !e @ !e 0 \)'7[~ riD JUL 2 7 20D\ lliJ TO: John Schodtlcr, Development Review Specialist DEVaOPMENTSERVlCESDEPT FROM: Maxwell G. Battle, .Jr. DATE' 07/26/2004 FAX #: 727~562-4S76 RE: ] 93 Devon Drive; AppbcatioD of Chris Mariani Number of Pages Including Cover Sheet: 5 r X] The onginal of all documents, Includmg correspondence. bemg transmitted herem are being forwarded to the above named addressee tlns date [ J The onginal of all documents, mcJudmg correspondence, bemg transmitted herem have not been forwarded to the above named addressee by regular US. Mail, but have been retamed in our file THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS FACSTMILE TRANSMISSION IS AITORl\TEY PRIvILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION INTENDED ONL Y FOR THE USE OF THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY NAMED ABOVE. IF THE READER OF TIlIS MESSAGE IS NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT. YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED THAT ANY DISSEMmATION . DISTRIBUTION, OR COpy OF TRIS COMMUNTCATJON IS STR1CTLY PROHIBITED IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS COMMUNJCA nON IN ERROR . PLEASE IM:MEDIA TEL Y NOTIFY US BY TELEPHONE AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE TO US AT THE ABOVE ADDRESS VIA TIIE U S POSTAL SERVICE THANK YOU PLEASE CALL (813) 685-3024 or (406) 270-5336 IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE THE CORRECT NUMBER OF PAGES 07/25/2004 20 17 00000000l"I> LAW OFFI CE PAGE 02/05 BA TILE & EDENFIELD, P .A. ATTORNEYS t\ T LA W MAXWELL G BATTLE, JR. AL';;O ADMITTF;;1) COLORAOO NEW MFXlCO FLORIDA 206 Mll.Son Street Brandon, FL 33511 TEL (m) 685-3014 July 26. 2004 John Schodtler Development Revlew SpecIalIst Plan1ung Department Murucipal Servlces BUIlding 100 South Myrtle Ave Clearwater, FL 33756 Re: 193 Devon Drive; Lot 31; Application of Cbris Mariani fOr Flexible Development Standard Approval; FLS2004-05028 Dear Mr Schodtler. I represent James and Deborah Soboleski who own the reSIdence to the lTnmedlatc West of Mr ChrIS Manani's lot (Lot 31. 193 Devon Dnve) for which the above application was submitted My clIcnts are vehemently opposed to Mr Manam's request as It IS now constItuted I wrote to you on July 7, 2004 askmg that the Development ReVIew CommIttee meeting scheduled for July 8, 2004 at a bme and location not dlsclosed m your '"NOTICE" dated June 17,2004 be continued to a date not earher than August 5. 2004 and that YOU re~notlce the meeting suecIfyIng the TIME. LoeA nON and DATE Tills request was based upon Due Process conslderabons and the fact that your "NOTICE" dId not In our view comply W1th procedural due process reqU1rements or the reqUll'ements of the Community Development Code because It Duled to specify the Tune, Date and LocatIon of the meetmg willie the Code speaks In terms of "8ubstantml competent eVldcnce" bemg provIded prior to, OR AT THE MEETING [So does the "NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004] The City faIled to honor trus request WIthout fau and proper notIce, the SoboJeskls were dented procedural due process. As I suggested to you lH my letter of July 7,2004, the legal doctrme of procedural due process IS the means by ""hIoh our legal system Insures that basic faIrness is afforded all whose substantIve nghts are at Issue Kev's Cltlzcns for Resuonsible Government Inc., 795 So 2d 940 (Fla 2001) It restricts the means by wh1ch agenCies of our 07/26/2004 20 17 0000000000 LAW OFFI CE PAGE 03/05 govemment reach deC1SJOnS that adversely affect both the hberty of and the property nght'; of our people County of Pasco v, Riehl. 620 So.2d 229 (Fla 2d DCA t 993) The Flonda Supreme Court has clearly stated that Procedural due *** proccss reqUlres both fair notice and a real opportunity to be heard "at a rneanmgfu1 tfTne and in a mearungful manner" Key'S CItlzens, '!'upra, @ 948 [citmg Mathews v Eldndge, 424 U S 319,333.47 LEd, 2d IS. 96 S Ct 893 (1976) Although you \>I1'ote advlsmg that the Commumty Development Coordinator had agreed to delay her decision until July 27,2004 to allow my Chents an opportumty to provide additIonal mfmmation, the Commumty Development Mcetmg 'Was apparently held on July 8, 2004 Because the CommunIty Development Meetmg referenced III your "NOTICE' dated Jlme 17. 2004 Was not rescheduled and properly notIced, It IS clear that my Chents were not granted eIther' faIr nottce or a real opportunity to be heard at a meantngfuJ time and ill a meaning[ ul malJ1ler" In additIon, the fallure to reschedule the meetrng as requested 111 my July 7 2004 letter to you dId not provIde suftlcIent tIme for my Chents to prepare the sort of mfonnatlOn and presentatIon that I suggested m my Jettc! and that they should be entItled to present at the Community Development Board Meetiog. Although my Chents have been derued sufficient time to prepare and submit the informatIon that J outlmed in'rr{y July 7. 2004 letter to you, I remmd you of the folloWIng issues addressed In my letter Plrst, J am concerned that you do not yet have a complete application It appears to me that the SectIon 4.202, Cornmuffity Development Code requires 1) SUbsection A, 12( e) that structural overhangs and bud dtng heights be depleted The ApphcaJ.1t has reportedly commumcated to my Clients and his companion Kymm Kidwell that he Intends to cover the dock and boats1ips as depIcted III hiS preVIOUS ApphcatlOn No, 02-0 J ~03, and 2) Subsectron A, 24 appears to reqUIre detmlcd plans and SpecWeatIons prcparcd, sIgned and sealed by a Flonda Regtstered Professional Engmeer It does not appear from your NOTICE dated June 17, 2004 [BUT MAILED SUBSEQUENT TO JUNE 21,2004 that either a plan depIcting the structural overhangs or detalled plans and specIficatIons sIgned and sealed by a Flonda Registered ProfessIOnal Engmeer has been submItted The Plan given to my ClIents by the Applicant [Copy attached] with a representatIOn that It was the pIau submItted does not meet these critena The Applicant's need to exceed the length and dimcnsIOnal standards arIses not from any inescapable or unreasonable hardship, but rather from the Apphcant s deSire to 2 07/26/2004 20'17 0000000f'1r>"l LAW OFFICE PAGE 04/05 place hts dock out of Ius sIght and tn that of my Chents By placmg the Dock in the mIddle of his Lot, Mr Manani creates a situatton where the water depth IS too shallow at the allowable length of approinmatcly 60 feet. If Mr MarIam places the Dock further East adJacel1t to the Blum's property [Please note that Blums lid not obJect: previously to this locatIOn in respondmg to Mr Manani's ptlor ApplicatIOn No 02~Ol-03], the water depth appears to be of suffiCIent depth that the extra 32 feet would be lU1necessary The shortenmg of the dock along with lts movement to the East \,,"ould saVe the ApplIcant substanttal money and provtde a more euvlronrnentaJly conscious end product due to a decreased shaded area of sea bottom and a deeper water depth beneath the dock footpnnt, both of wIuc h enbanee the grov.,.th and sUlVlvab1l1ty of sea grasses '. Unfortunately you f' Staff Report erroneously concludes that the requested increased length of the dock 'Will provIde a "... more environmentally sensitive situation over eXISting cond.tions." HOW CAN YOUR STAFF CONCLUDE THAT GREATER COVERAGE OF THE SEA BOTTOM IN AN AREA WITH MORE GRASS AT A SHALLOWER DEPTH IS MORE ENvIROMENTALLY SENSITIVE THAN THE EXISTING CONDITIONS ? AT PRESENT THERE IS NO DOCK AT ALL! TIle proposed length and configuratIOn of the dock. will destroy the sceme Vlew from thc Soboleskis' property, Wlll have a negatIve Impact upon the value of the Soboleskis' property and Can not conceJVably enhance the value of the ,either the Soboleskls' property or the surrOundTUg property Since these negative Impacts can be avoided at a saVIngs to both the Apphcant and the EnVIronment. it seems clear that the ApplicatlOn v1Qlates [and IS Intolerably lDeonslstent WIth] the precepts of Code SecDon 1- 103. Part T, Communlty Development Code Your Staff Report erroneously concludes that: "The location of the dock, as suggested by Staff, will reduee or eJjminate visual impacts on surrounding properties to the West." This statem.ent bv Staff is total lackm lD merit and does not a ear to be su orted b the evidence. It 1S also instructIve to note that the dock length and configuratIOn proposed by the Applicant appear to clearly vlolate the ProvIsIons of Page 2, Paragraph 8 of the Restnctrve Covenants recorded at 0 R. Book 860, PG 51, 52, Public Records of PmelJas County, FL I also call your attentIon to the fact that a sUbstantlaJly snndar ^pplicatlon was prcv10usly filed by Mr Man ani last year, to Wit - Application No. 02~01"()3. That Appllcatton Was ultimately demed after bemg reversed by the CirCUIt Court of PmeUas County Then It appears that upon request of the ApplIcant., that the demal was rescinded after the time for aopcal had exoiTed There seems to be no proVlSlon 10 the Community Development Code for the PlanJ1lng DIrector Or any other Clty OfficIal to aJter. amend, or resclOd decIsIOns rendeIed on Level One Appltcatlons and certamly not after the tJ.nle for appeal has expIred Thcrefovc,.1 suggest to you that J'our office is without JUrisdiction to entertain, much less grant, the present Application. 1 Shading the sea bottom lmpO~es a slgmficanr negatJYe Impact on sea gras~es dependant upon photos}'T1thesl5 DecreaSing the shaded arca and increasing the l1etghr above the grass ITo!tJ whIch the shade emanates Increases the lIght transmItted to the grass 3 J -; , , 1'17/25/21'11'14 21'1 17 1'11'11'1001'100""" LAW OFFICE PAGE 85/1'15 Fmally, I ask that you take official notice of the entire file rmcluding W1thout lmu tation ail Items m the Appell ate File] from Mr Manam' s previous Application }\; o. 02-01-03. incorporate it into and include it in the record on the pre~eDt Application. As you can see from the foregoIng comments, there are many dIsputed issues that should be addressed In substantlally mOle detail before the Community Development Coordmator renders a del;lslon Thl$ Appltcant has already had one declsIon of the Commuruty" Development CoordInator [Ms, Tarapam] reversed for Due Process VIolations I hope that before thiS occurs agam that the CIty wIll reopen thIS entire matter for Pubhc Comment. schedule another Commumty Development Meetmg on this Apphcatton and provIde propet: ConstItutlonal Notice to all affected partJes Very truly YOur<J, Cc James and Deborah Soboleski 4 ......\' Schodtler, John From Sent To Subject M Battle [maxsmlles2004@hotmall com] Monday, July 26,2004-1040 PM Schodtler, John _ Application of Chris Mariani, App# FLS2004-0S028, 103 Devon Dr, Lol31 ~ Schodtler Itr 7262004 ESCRIPT Dear Mr Schodtler Please see attached letter The or~g~nal was faxed to you today, July 26, 2004 Thank you Maxwell G Battle, Jr Battle & Edenf~eld, P A 1 I ...~. BATTLE & EDENFIELD, P.A. ATTORNEYS AT LAW MAXWELL G BATTLE, JR AI SO ADMIn E:.D COLORADO NEW M[XICO FLORIDA 206 Maso~ Street Bra~don I L ,35 I I TEL (S13) 685- ,014 July 26,2004 John Schodtler Development RevIew SpecIalist Plannmg Department MUnicIpal ServIces BUlldmg 100 South Myrtle Ave Clearwater, FL 33756 Re: 193 Devon Drive; Lot 31; Application of Chris Mariani for Flexible Development Standard Approval;- FLS2004-05028 Dear Mr Schodtler I represent James and Deborah SoboleskI who own the resIdence to the Immediate West of Mr Chns Manam's lot (Lot 31, 193 Devon Dnve) for whIch the above applicatIon was submitted My clIents are vehemently opposed to Mr Manam's request as It IS now constituted I wrote to you on July 7, 2004 askmg that the Devclopment RevIew CommIttee meetmg scheduled for July 8, 2004 at a tIme and locatIon not disclosed 10 your "NOTICE" dated Junc 17, 2004 be cont1Oued to a date not earlier than August 5,2004 and that YOU re-notlce the meetmg speclfymg the TIME, LOCATION and DA TE ThIs request was based upon Due Process consIderatIOns and the fact that your "NOTICE" did not m our VIew comply wIth procedural due process requIremcnts or the reqUIremcnts of the Commumty Developmcnt Code because It faded to specify the Time, Date and LocatIon of the meet10g whde the Code speaks m terms of "substantial competent eVIdence" bemg proVIded pnor to, OR AT THE MEETING [So does the "NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004] The CIty faded to honor thIS request Without fair and proper notIce, the Soboleskls were demed procedural due process As I suggested to you m my letter of July 7, 2004, the legal doctnne ofproccdural due process IS the means by which our legal system Insures that baSIC faIrness IS afforded all whose substantIve nghts are at Issue Kcy's CltIzen& for Respon<;lble Government, Inc, 795 So 2d 940 (Fla 200 I) It re<;tncts the means by whIch agencies of our \ ..... government reach decIsIOns that adversely affect both the liberty of and the property fights of our people County of Pasco v Rlchl, 620 So 2d 229 (Fla 2d DCA 1993) The Flonda Supreme Court has clearly stated that Procedural due *** process requIres both fair notice and .1 real opportumty to be heard "at a meanmgful time and 111 a meamngful manner" Kcy's Citizens, 5upra, @ 948 [cltmg Mathews v Eldndge, 424 U S 319,333,47 LEd 2d 18,96 S Ct 893 (1976) Although you wrote advlsmg th.1t the Commumty Development Coordmator had agreed to delay her decision until July 27,2004 to allow my Chents an opportumty to provide additIOnal mformatIon, the Commumty Dcvelopment Meetmg wa') apparently held on July 8, 2004 Because the Commul1lty Development Meetlllg referenced 111 your "NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004 was not rescheduled and properly notIced, It IS clear that my Clients were not granted either" faIr notice or a real opportul11ty to be heard at a meamngful time and m a meal1lngful manner" In addition, the faIlure to reschedule the meetmg as requested m my July 7, 2004 letter to you did not provide suffiCient time for my Chents to prepare the sort of mformatIon and pre~entatlon that I suggested III my letter and that they should be entltlcd to present at the CommuDlty Development Board Meeting. Although my Chents have been dellled sufficient time to prepare and Eoubmlt the III fa rnlatI on that I outhned In my July 7,2004 letter to you, r rcmmd you of the follOWing Issues addressed III my letter First, I am concerned that you do not yet have a complete appheatlOn It appear~ to me that the Section 4-202 , Commul1lty Development Code requIres 1) Subsection A, 12(e) that structural overhangs and bmldmg heIghts be depicted The Apphcant has reportedly commumcated to my ClIents and hIS compamon Kymm Kidwell that he llltends to cover the dock and boatshps as depicted III hIS prevIOus Apphc.1tIon No 02-01-03, and 2) Subsection A, 24 appears to rcqU1re detaIled plans and specificatIons prepared, signed and sealed by a Flonda Registered ProfessIOnal Engllleer It does not appear from your NOTICE dated June 17,2004 [BUT MAILED SUBSEQUENT TO JUNE 21, 2004 that eIther a plan depletll1g the structural overhangs or detaIled pldns and specifications Signed and sealed by a Flonda Registered Professional Eng111eer has been submitted The Plan given to my Clients by the ApplIcant [Copy attached] with a representatIon that It was the plan submItted does not meet these cntena The ApplIcant's necd to exceed the lenf,rth and dImenSIOnal standards anse') not from any mescapable or unreasonable hardship, but rather from the ApplIcant's deSire to 2 \ ~';., place his dock out of his sight and In that of my ClIcnts By placmg the Dock In the middle of his Lot, Mr Manam creates a sItuatIOn where the water depth IS too shallow at the allowable length of approximately 60 feet If Mr Manam placcs the Dock further East adjacent to the Blum's property [Please note that Blums did not object prevIOusly to this location m respondmg to Mr Manam's pnor Application No 02-01-03], the water depth appears to be of sufficICnt depth that the extrd 32 feet would be unnecessary The shortenmg of the dock along with Its movement to the East would save the Applicant substantial money and provide a more envIronmentally conscIous end product due to a dccreascd shaded area of sea bottom and a deeper water depth beneath the dock footpnnt, both of which cnhance the growth and survivability of sea grassesl Unfortunately your Staff Report erroneously concludes that the requested increased length of the dock will provide a "...more environmentally sensitive situation over existing conditions." HOW CAN YOUR STAFF CONCLUDE THAT GREATER COVERAGE OF THE SEA BOTTOM IN AN AREA WITH MORE GRASS AT A SHALLOWER DEPTH IS MORE ENVIROMENTALLY SENSITIVE THAN THE EXISTING CONDITIONS .? AT PRESENT THERE IS NO DOCK AT ALL! The proposed length and configuration of the dock will destroy the scemc view from the Soboleskls' property, wIll have a negative llnpact upon the value of the Soboleskls' property and can not conceivably enhance the value of the either the Soboleskls' property or the E.urroundll1g property Smce these negative Impacts Cdn be avoIded at a savlI1gs to both the Applicant and the Environment, It seems clear that the Application violates [and IS mtolerably mconslstent With] the precept') of Code SectIon I- 103, Part I, Commul1lty Development Code Your Staff Report erroneously concludes that: "The location of the dock, as suggested by Staff, will reduce or eliminate visual impacts on surrounding properties to the West." This statement bv Staff is totallv lackinl! in merit and does not appear to bc supported bv the evidence. It IS also lI1structlVC to note that the dock length and configuratIOn proposed by the Applicant appear to clearly Violate the provlslons of Page 2, Paragraph 8 of the RestnctIve Covenants recorded at 0 R Book 860, PG 51, 52, Public Records of Pmellas County, FL I also call your attentIon to the fact that a substantially Similar AppltcatlOn was previously filed by Mr Manam last year, to Wit - Application No. 02-01-03. That Application was llitImately demed dfter bemg reversed by the CIrcUIt Court of P1l1ellas County Then It appears that upon request of the ApplIcant, that the demal was rescmded after the tIme for appeal had expired There seems to be no proVISion m the Commumty Development Code for the Plannmg Director or any other City Officml to alter, amend, or rescmd declslOnE. rendered on Level One App!JcatlOns and certamly not after the tnne for appeal has explred Therefore, I suggest to you that your office is without jurisdiction to entertain, much less grant, the present Application. 1 Shadmg thc :;OCd bottom Imposes a slgmficant negative Impact on sca gra55cs dependant upon photo:;oynlhc51s Dccrca5mg thc ~hdded drCd dnd mLTeasmg the hClght dbove thc grass from whIch the shade cman,llCS merC35C<; thc hght transmitted to the grdss 3 , \ ". F1Oally, I ask that you take officldl notice of the entire file [mcludmg wIthout Itmltatlon all Items 10 the Appellate File] from Mr Manam's prevIous Application No, 02-01-03, incorporate it into and include It in the record on the present Application. As you can see from the foregomg comments, there are mdny disputed Issues that should be addressed In substantially more detat! before the Commumty Development Coordinator renders a decIsion This Appheant has already had one decIsIon of the Commumty Development Coordinator [Ms Tarapam] reversed for Due Process VIOlations I hope that before this occurs again that the CIty will reopen thl.~ entire matter for Public Comment, schedule another Commumty Development Meetmg on this Application and provide proper ConstitutIOnal Notice to all affected parties Very truly yours, Maxwell G Battle, Jr Maxwell G Battle, Jr Cc James and Deborah Soboleski 4 Message Page 1 of I Schodtler, John From Schodtler, John Sent Monday, July 26,2004800 AM To 'TIm A Johnson' Subject RE Mananl Dock Application Mr Johnson As of this morning (7/26/04), I have receIVed no additional information -----Onglnal Message----- From: Tim A Johnson [mallto'TlmJ@]pfirm com] Sent: Sunday, July 25, 2004 10 14 AM To: Schodtler, John Cc: ccmgemseaJ@aol com Subject: Mananl Dock Appilcatlon Please advise If any information has been submitted to the City since the ORe meeting In Opposition to the referenced dock application Thank you 7/26/2004 ~llfJITD.Q, ~~~~'t~lQf TI/;;r... ....I;,~ "@"..m$"f#7x_ "'fl'.,.'" ~##-.f~--;' ~/;":i." III - ~ "" '" "'"",",~'!/rI""""""'/ ::-.r-rtb l:l~ - -, <'" ~r:~ :"'^~"= ~: ..:r:t1: ~ --=--. 6:3tl ~?L5"-#-- "C"..,~.. ~"(If/.~;;",~....-;;:...... ....##~1ER f~' ""o#.J1J1I' J C I T Y 0 F CLEARWATER PlANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLFARWA1ER, FlORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SFRVlCES BUllJ)ING, 100 SOUTH MYRnE AVENUF, CLEtlRWATFR, FLORID';' 33756 TEl FPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 LONG Rfu\lGF PlANNING DfVFl OPMl:NT RFVIEW July 9, 2004 Mr Maxwell G Battle, Jr Battle & Edenfield, P A 206 Mason Street Brandon, FL 33511 Re FLS2004-05028, 193 Devon Dear Mr Battle On July 8, 2004, we receIved an emat! and a fax sent July 7, 2004 from you concernIng the FlexIble Standard Development apphcatIon for approval to construct a dock at 193 Devon Dnve At the scheduled Development RevIew Comnuttee (DRC) meetIng on July 8, 2004 the case was reviewed In response to your concerns the folloWIng comments are offered 1 The Apphcant and City Jomtly agreed (per SectIOn 4-207 B) to extend the tIme for a decIsion by the Commumty Development Coordmator untt! no later than July 27, 2004 2 Regardmg your allegatIOn that the DRC meetmg was not properly notlced, the City's Commumty Development Code does not estabhsh the DRC meetmg as a pubhc meetmg nor a public heanng I am refernng your letter to the CIty Attorney's office If you wish to dIscuss thIS matter further I would pomt out that the notice to surroundmg property owners was sent approximately 3 weeks pnor to the DRC meetmg and proVIded a planner name, phone number and e-maIl address with whom you could commumcate for more mformatlon The Planmng Department has had no contact wIth either you or your chent unul we receIved your letter July 7,2004 at approximately 630 pm 3 WIth regard to the mformatlon In your letter regardmg thIS apphcatIOll, we Will consIder It m our reVIew of thIS applicatIOn We appreCIate your concerns Any addItIOnal mformatlOn regardmg thiS case may be submitted for further review by the DRC and Commumty Development Coordmator Should you need additional m forrnah on, feel free to contact me at 727-562-4604 or John SchodtJer@myclearwater com Smcerely, ~~.f!v.- Jo~ Schodtler Planner I Cc Cynthia Tarapam, Plannmg Director S \P/annmg Depar/lnenf\C D HIS/antlard Flei\Pendmg Case~'\2 - ReViewed and PentlmglJ)evon 193 Marwm 11\]93 Devoll Dr - Bailie Reply (C) do!.' BRIW J AUNGST MA i'Ok-CO.IIWSSIONFR HO,"I HM1IIl ON, VICE MAYOR COMMI~S]ONII{ WHI mf! GRAY, COi\tWS~IONFR fRANK HlHlll\RD, COl\t~t1SSI0NrR * Bill JONSON, COl\I1\\I"'Oi\1 R "EQ VAl l'.M 1'1 OYMl NT AN 0 A 111I<M'\ llVL AC1ION EM I'] 0\1 j{" .. ~!!~:}E}trwater :t- I""'" - "- IIIII -- o FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865 TO: ~~:D. FAX: 4-0 Z-{ Phone: FROM: 3~""",, S ~-\ ,~ Phone: DA TE: 7 r '=t 10-1- SUBJECT: M1l/L4 AN I C>OCJ<- c:..,rs-e.. F~ z-oo"'" - 05oz..f MESSAGE: Arr'lC4115ri Is, OUfL R.t!ii6.Po"';Sf!:., Th M.4J< '84.-n"1 P- r ~~J-It3az:5 4~yt: · @ NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) ... ~#!J(}fTg.JT./7" 1 eg~:~5~ l\LOF rill;;'" ~~:::\~~''''-'', rhY~"'- '\L- ,.~' ..,.".~?~ ~ ",fI,~'I~'" '" ~~'t",......\ I, 1 "S. ~~ q~"'" \'.. ..~~ - ~---==- ~'" ",. _. =- -...a", "'~~ ---=.- . ~~ ~~--,-~- ":CS-::\ .....,#...........~I. '\ ~ fj/,~'m.."y.:'\;.\ .........,)4TE\\,., let Q4"DI'~ CITY OF CLEARWATER PlANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICF Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SI:RVTCES BUilDING, 100 S015f1! MYRTIE AVI:Nur, CLEARWATl:R, FLORIDA 33756 IELEPHONI: (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 LONG RANGE PiA1\iNING DEvnOPMFNT RI:v:rcw July 9, 2004 Mr Maxwell G Battle, Jr Battle & Edenfield, P A 206 Mason Street Brandon, FL 33511 Re FLS2004-05028, 193 Devon Dear Mr Battle On July 8, 2004, we receIved an emaII and a fax sent July 7, 2004 from you concernmg the FleXIble Standard Development application for approval to construct a dock at 193 Devon Dnve At the scheduled Development ReView Conuruttee (DRe) meetmg on July 8, 2004 the case was revIewed In response to your concerns the foUowmg comments are offered 1 The Apphcant and City Jomtly agreed (per Section 4-207 B) to extend the time for a decIsion by the Commumty Development Coordmator until no later than July 27,2004 2 Regardmg your allegatIOn that the DRC meetmg was not properly noticed, the City's Commumty Development Code does not estabhsh the DRe meetmg as a pubhc meetmg nor a pubhc hearmg I am referrmg your letter to the City Attorney's office If you wish to diSCUSS thiS matter further I would pomt out that the notice to surroundmg property owners was sent approxImately 3 weeks pnor to the DRC meetmg and provided a planner name, phone number and e-maJ! address with whom you could commUlllcate for more mformatlon The Plannmg Department has had no contact with either you or your chent until we receIved your letter July 7,2004 at approxunately 630 pm 3 With regard to the mformatlon m your letter regardmg thIS apphcatlon. we Will consIder it m our review of thiS apphcatlon We apprecIate your concerns Any additional mformatlon regardmg thiS case may be submitted for further review by the DRC and Commumty Development Coordmator Should you need additional mformatIon, feel free to contact me at 727-562-4604 or John Schodtler@myc1earwater com Smcerely, ~~-+Iv- Jo~ Schodtler Planner I Cc Cynthia Tarapam, Planmng Director S \Plannmg Deparlmen^C D /JISW/Jdard FleX\Pelldmg Casei12 - ReVIewed and Pelldmg\Devo/J 193 Mana1ll1^193 DeVOll Dr - Bailie Reply (C) doc BRIAN J AUN(,<; r, Mil YO~-COMMI""'ONt~ HOi"1 HMlIlTON Vlel M,\YOR-C()MMI"l"lONr~ WllITNF\ GRA\, COMMI"~IONfR FRANR ]-!IKIIARr1 '(OMMI~SION"R * 13111 JON<;ON, CO~tMI"~IO,\fR "LQUAI EMPI OYM) N I ANI) ArHRMA I 1\ r ACTION LMPI OYl R" Schodtler, John From Sent To Subject Schodtler, John Thursday, July 08, 2004837 AM 'M Battle' RE FLS2004-05028, 193 Devon Dr, Clearwater, FL Thank you for your correspondence and I am 1n rece1pt of your fax John Schodtler, Planner I -----Or1g1nal Mes5age----- From M Battle [ma1lto maxsm1les2004@hotma1l com] Sent wednesday, July 07, 2004 8 02 PM To Schodtler, John SubJect FLS2004-05028, 193 Devon Dr , Clearwater, FL Dear Mr Schodtler Attached 15 my letter to you on behalf of the Sobolesk1s who oppose Mr Chr1stopher Mar1anl'S above referenced Appl1cat1on The letter and all attachments referred to there1n were faxed to you today Please be sure that they are In the F1le Maxwell G Battle, Jr 1 ...\ ~-ttL IOdAtU ~~:'\fijarwater II FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865 TO: -r?mJ:;lJiMfU FAX: ~-rMlf 44/- f;t;/1 Phone: #/1"'18/~ FROM: ~ 1/J)JI;J/I~ . Phone: -tU-1f7f. (tJdf) DATE: SUBJECT: ~Uh/'PuzA- MESSAGE: NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) It{ 07/07/2004 17 57 -. 0000000P"'> LAW OFFICE , . FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION COVER SHEET Battle & Edenfield, P A 206 Mason Street Brandon, FL 33511 (813) 685-3014 TO: .John Schodtler, Development Review Specialist FROM: Maxwell G. Battle, Jr. DATE: 07/07/2004 FAX #: 727~56.2~4576 . . RE: 193 Devon Drive; Application of Chris Manani Number of Pages Including Cover Sheet: 18 [ X J The ongmal of all documents, mcludmg correspondence, bemg transm.tted herem are betng forwarded to the above named addressee this date ( ] Thc ongmal of a1) documents, including correspondence. bemg transrruttcd h.erem have not been forwarded to the above named addressee by regular U S Mati, but have been retained in our file THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN TIllS FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION IS A TTORNEY PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL lNFORMA TION INTENDED ONL Y FOR THE USE OF THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY NAMED ABOVE. IF THE READER OF THIS MESSAGE IS NOT THE INTENDED RECIPJENT , YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED THAT ANY DISSEMINATION, DISTRiBUTION, OR COPY OF THIS COMMlJNICATION IS STRlCTLY PROHIBITED. IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED TInS COMMlJ"NICA nON [N ERROR PLEASE IMMEDIATELY NOTIFY US BY TELEPHONE AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE TO US AT THE ABOVE ADDRESS VIA THE US POSTAL SERVICE. THANK YOU. PLEASE CALL (813) 685-3014 Or (406) 270-5336 IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE THE CORRECT NUMBER OF PAGES PAGE 01/14 07/07/2004 17'57 00000000Pl"l LAW OFFICE PAGE 02/14 BA TILE & EDENFIELD, P.A. A TTORNEVS AT LAW MAXWELL G BA. TTlE. JR. AlSO ADMlTTfiQ COLORADO NEW MEXICO FLORIDA 206 MMQn Street Bmndon, FI, 3351 I TIoL (&13) 685-3014 , . July 7, 2004 John Schodtler Development Review Specialist Pl8J1ntng Department Municipal Services BUlldmg 100 South Myrtle Ave C1eaDNater,FL 33756 Re: 193 Devon Drive; Lot 31; Application of Chris Mariani for Flexible Development Standard ApprO\'alj FLS2004-05028 Dear Mr Schodtler I represent James and Deborah Soboleski who own the reSIdence to the lmmedlf1te West of Mr Coos Mariani's lot (Lot 31, 193 Devon Drive) for WhlCh the above application was submitted My chents are vehemently opposed to Mr Manani's request as It i5 now constltuted T \"oi11te to ask that the Development Revlew CommIttee meeting presently scheduled for July 8, 2004 at a tIme and location not disclosed ~n your "NOTICE" dated June 17. 2004 be continued to a date not earlier than August 5, 2004 and that vou re-notlce the meetma soeclfvInlZ the TIME, LOCATION and DATE. This request is based upon Due Process considerations and the fact that your "NOTICE" does not comply WIth procedural due process reqmreroents or the requirements of the Communlty Development Code because it does not speCIfy the Tune, Date and LocatIon of the meetmg whlle the Code speaks m terms of "substantta1 competent evidence'" bemg proVided pnor to, OR AT THE MEETING [So does the 'INOTICE" dated June 17, 2004] Without fair and proper notice, the Soboleskls VII11 be demed procedural due process The legal doctnne of procedural due process IS the means by which our legal system msures that basIC faIrness IS afforded all whose substantive rights are at Issue Kev's CITIZenS for ResponSIble Government. Ioc , 795 So 2d 940 (Fla 2001) It restricts the means by wluch agencies .of our goverrunent reach decisions that adversely affect _0J/07/2004 17'57 0000000l'1"'" LAW OFFICE PAGE 03/14 both the liberty of and the property rights of our people County of Pasco v RIehl 620 So 2d 229 (FIa 2d DCA 1993), The Florida Supreme Court has clearly stated that Procedural due '" '" '" process requIres both fatr notIce and a real opportunity to be heard "at a meaningful time and In a meanmgful manner~' Key's Citizens, supra, @ 948 [citIng Mathews v Eldnde:e, 424 U S, 319, 333, 47 LEd 2d 18, 96 S Ct 893 (1976) Unless the Community Development Meeting referenced ill your "NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004 IS rescheduled and properly nonced, it IS clear that my Chents Wlll not be granted eIther" fau notIce or a real opportl.lTllty to be heard at a meamngfuJ trme and ill a meanmgful mannerll, In the event that you proceed with the Development RevIew CommIttee meeting on July 8. 2004 I also wnte to ask that you extend the bme for my ClIents to provIde you WIth substanbal competent eVidence and that the Plannmg Drrector refram from Issumg a deCISIon on Mr Manam's request lUltI! at least August 5 2004 to allow us time to provide you \VIth addItIonal mformation whIch we belIeve Wlll be helpful to the CIty m reachmg a fully mformcd deGISlOn The reasons that we need this addItional t[me are 1) I was Just tetamed by the Soboleskis \VIth respect to thts Application because the Applicant had been discussing a settlement WIth Soboleskis and dId not advise them that he would not agree to delay the ApplrcatlOn prQCCSS until July J, 2004 The Fourth of July weekend intervened and I lUst returned to my Out of State Office. Accordmgly, I bavc been unable to reVIew the City'S file ObvlOusly I need Some time to reVIew and fully dIgest the file and respond to the contents thereof: and 2) We Wish to provide you with a graphic plctonal representatlOn of what Mr Manaul' s proposed dock will affect the view from the Sobeleskrs property as well as conduct a water depth and rnarme vegetation survey of tbe area contIguous to the Apphcant's seawall and provide that inf'ounatlOn to you as well ThIS requIre') actual field surveYIng and photography as well as a substantial amount of computer ",",ork to generate the visual models, and 3) We need tune to assemble pictorial evidence of how the proposed proJect \VIII affect the character of the neighborhood I hope that gIven the depth of OPPOSItion to Mr Manam's applrcatIOn that you can grant us the addItional time J would not ask for the addltIonaltirnc If T did oot truly behove that It was necessary to prOVIde the addItIonal information and vIsUal tools to you and that thiS mformatlOn would have an effect upon your deCISion 2 07/67/2064 17'57 ,- 06000000,"11I LAW OFFICE PAGE 04/14 Whlle we are workIng dIligently to prepare and submit the above mfonnatJon to you, I felt that it would be appropnate to address several ISSueS mihally. These comments follow First, I am concerned that you do not yet have a complete applIcatIon, It appears to me that the SectIon 4-202. CommlUllty Development Code reqwres' 1) SubsectIon A. 12(e) that structural overhangs and bUIldtng heights be depicted The ApplIcant has reportedly communIcated to my Clients and hIS comparuon K:YJl1fi1 Kidwell that he Intencl<; to cover the dock and boatshps as depicted in his prevlOUS AppIicauon No 02-01-03, and 2) Subsection A,24 appears to require detailed plans and specIficatIOns prepared, signed and sealed by a Flonda Registered ProfessIonal EngIneer It does not appear from your NOTICE dated June 17, 2004 [BUT MAILED SUBSEQUENT TO JUNE 2J, 2004 that either a plan depIctmg the slructural overhangs or detailed plans and specificatIOns signed and sealed by a Florida Registered ProfesslOnaJ Eng11leer has been submitted The Plan given to my Chents by the ApplIcant [Copy attached) WIth a representabon that 11 was the plan submttted does not mect these cntel.'la. The Appbcant's need to exceed the length and dlmenslOnal standards arIses not from any mescapable Ot unreasonable hardship. but rather from the ApplIcant's des1re to place lus dock out of Ius Sight and m that of my Clients By placmg the Dock In the middle of his Lot, Mr Manani creates a srtuatlOn where the water depth IS too shallow at the allowable length of approximately 60 feet If.Mr Mariani places the Dock further East adjacent to the Blum's property [Please note that Blums dId 110t object prevIously to thIs location In respondmg to :vIr. Mariam's prior ApphcatlOn No 02-01-03], the water depth appears to be of sufficIcnt depth that the extra 32 feet would be unnecessary The shortemng of the dock along with lts movement to the East would Save the ApplIcant substantIal money and prOVIde a mOre environmentally ConscIous end product due to a decreased shaded area of sea bottom and a deeper water depth beneath the dock footpnnt, both of which enhance the growth and survivablhty of Sea grassesl The proposed length and configuration of the dock will destroy the scenIC view from the Sobol eskts , property, 'W1lJ have a negative tmpact upon the value of the Soboleslas' property and can not concelVably enhance the valuc of the eIther the SoboJesIos' property or the surrounding property. Smce these negatIve Impacts Can be avolded at a savmgs to both Ole Apphcant and the Environment it seems clear t11at the Apphcation VIOlates [and]s llltolerably mconSlstent With] the precepts of Code Section 14 103, Part I, Community Development Code T Shading the sea bOLtom Imposes ~ s;gnlficant negatwe Impact on sea grasses depe.l:ldant upon photosyntheSIS Decreasmg the shaded area and mcreasing the heIght above the grass trom whIch the shade emanates mcrcases the IIghL tran'\mitted to the grass 3 ~7/~7/2~04 17 57 ...~- .... ~~~~~000~0 LAW OFFICE PAGE ~5/14 It IS also IDstructrvc to note that the dock length and configuration proposed by the ApplIcant appear to clearly ViOlate the provIsions of Page 2, Paragraph 8 of the Restrictive Covenants recorded at 0 R Book 860, PG 51,52, Public Records ofPmeUas County, FL I also call your attent10n to the fact that a Substatlttally sU1l1lar ApphcatlOn was prevIously tiled by Mr Mariani last year to wlt . Application No. 02-01-03. That Apphcat10n was ultunately denied after bemg reverscd by the CircUIt Court of PtnelJas County Then it appears that lIpon request of the Apphcant, that the demal Was rescInded after the time for anneal had explred There seems to be no prOVISion III the CommUIllty Development Code for the Plannmg Director or any other Clty Official to alter, amend, or rescind declslOns rendered on Level One ApplicatIOns and certamJy not after the tune for appeal has exprred, Thercfore, J suggest to you that your office IS WIthout JUrIsdictIOn to entertaIn, much less grant, the Qresent Apphcatlon Finally, I ask that you take officIal notICe of the ent.1te file [mcluillng WIthout bm1tation all 1tems m the Appellate FIle] from Mr, Ma.nam's prevIOUS Application No. 02.01-03, incorporate it mto and include it in the record on the present ApplicatIon. As you can see from the foregomg bnef comments. there are many disputed Issues that r need to address for the Sobolesk.1s. I hope that you WIll either reschedule the presently scheduled meetmg, and failing that, agree to grant the additional t111le for my ClIents aud r to respond further prlOr to reaclung a declsion Very truly yours, __ -;~~~ Max\Vcll G-&ttle, ir CC' James and Deborah Soboleski A ttachmcn1s. Notice Dated June 17,2004 Mariam Letter dated July 1, 2004 Mariani purported Dock Plan RestnctIve Covenants, 0 R Book 860, PGS 51-56, Pubhc Records, Pmel;las County 4 ,~7/07/2004 17 57 00000000~~ LAW OFFICE PAGE 05/14 e7lB2/2se4 14: 12 Ell~684&:u:2 BATTLE & EDENFIEL/J PAGE 132 ,r3u1 O~ 04 01:13p DEBORAH SOBOLESKI 7!? ~S6 6~G5 p.~ -~ 12::51 ~ ~ 7Z7 44a B4'7fl P.91 ," ~lPr PLANNING DEPARTMENT ~ 'MmUaPALSEllVICSSBUJI.DlNG ~ 100 SOtmtMYR.TLB AVSNt1S,. CIJiAR"'A'I'ER; ltORIDA 33756 'TEtSI"RONB: (121) 5Q.4SG7 FAX,; (727) S62-457(i WWW.MYCI.JWtWATER.COM .NIle 1" :mo4 IE; NO'IICI: OF:nLllfG OF M:'l A.PP1.XCA'tIONJI'OR rLEXrBLE STANDARD ~ APF.a.OVAt AT 193 DEVON rm.(FLS2~ ~ , TD~Pw.t'WIyOwaem: ~~ ~ 'IIHthl'}Jj.'~i9; DEvOl'iDR. ..~.,,~~~ siwsDUtice blllllpp1icaticab' ilDiblc Bamdatd ~ awmwl1g ~ dle JeDsih Of a sfoek fhJm 6D ht (SO psceD1 offb wtdth orb JifA'o'.I!...l,.) to 92 fbct (76.f pacmt of'tbc. width otthe Jlil.1.lpQ\Y.J m2dIr t1Ie ~ oI:kx:IiA ~l.. OIl J1IIy08, 2OD4, 1be~bricW~~ (w~ofthe C!t1t }M~"'doml sa1l) ,yj]l mum,"" 4Mf~I.'D.'""~!be uppt:N1Nnft dem.....~ ~ wifb die ~ Cuw.u.r.~~ eo.k J'OIlO'WUr81batmJaw _~b..~nlftticm, tile P.I:1aWagnbctorwill iMae. De:vtIopmmt ~ ap,pm.iq,. "'i'P"~ tiMg WiG1l!nfttf1t(~ or da)iag dB ~ Tho eIZti_ &Ire IbU me CiI;y"\lFill1JDlb a deeiDtIa oa a. ~ will be JoIy08,. 2004. T.b:I ~ ~~~)'OII topardcdJ:w;le m 'lie =*wofltda WiI~ YoaIMYIXIDMf.ZJ2Ie. 727..s62-4604<<- Sr<<m.~... .... b' f'tdler~ VitUnroftlel tD ~ .. - -bI ta.k~IlC<medlU4beCi~~. _.__ ____ --...... .-I'IeMct.e~~t-addfI(-..~...... j~ ~.lfhl tt.;1O.~~ w1dcIa }'VD JIB]' mieW daring repbJr bDsizas baanJ. ~, no'" JlliiIIkB will be pm1de4 to )leU ~ IU: IPpIicatiOA be IIMIIINI~ . .AD app:a1 otik I.: . i1r''W) Dftbe P2mmI.Dg ~ maybe mttiNd 'bribe appJiemIt Dr property cnr.et8 Widdn theftCltUMuotice III:Il ~ pre:lJIII1 ~ &UbsamtiIJ elIt~ at, ClI' pdt:rAto, tbe ~ ReviIw CormMme ll2tedag oalu!y OR. 2004. AD lIJIJjIeB1 must bit &led,. ~ = tWealliJe" wriIll the PlamI&t.g ~",,*.~.,. oftlltdtmt ld'the~Ordw. 'IbIDk)VII fa:r:l'oat~ mt!le Cit10t ~8 ~mvi_pa.'lWSI. Y0'll1ZlJll':l acx:tlII3 oar PIm:lr.W2a D'-i'-_ ~ the City's wabsite.: www~.com. .Pitf -- LAW OFFICE 57 00000000r~ 07/0J :}::/~1'Il!l~7' 14: 12 81368 22 -8ATTLI; & El&IFI~ _.]~lM.~5.. 9..4 !!.~:}~.e. ......v1!~,!ilJ~RRH SOROhir~:ASI'&IL:rotrm.u. 7a7 4SS 84&5 e-a.maria.ni aaphal't compa.ny - -- ... ~~ · po... ~ ~..... Ii. ~ · p~ \111:1;1 lltH!I41 . !In f8'r81 -''In PAGE 07/14 PAGE e14 P~1- aOtl2 1QJ)> I, 20IU Mr. If:. Mm.lMD W. SobvlesJ<i 191 ~ Prm: ee... ..uk:r, II. 331S6 De:tr DaIJbit and lib..: JCJIDDltlDdt are ~tbM~ JJq Its, wmdd !ib"I8IoMthh ~~ .thttba-.IegaJ, cost. It ~ _ WI! 1Ihl!! 1balxJ SVlnc COiIIllmu __ II ~ 5lI:p 1DWIId "=5DJarbx. We %IRlI' dM~ 1II_4II~ "1Ie~ ~u JIeI'}'OIW~ t "-a;,Jd hykymm dIIz)Va df&l ~ it. 'We wiD_ ~ to )WI'.retplSttlw we.. in 'IIVl'idq":no 00'VIt' WOUld .". ~ pIIa:d Cm OlD" bolt ~ .. tD do so 1iIImdd co__ a ""~ f1fa~~~ _ ~ we'VeI)" nmeb.dI!Iire B ~ II) dIsQm o:PCicmt. Jab'tIIe 11 wm:b fbcr U:J 11II WIII_ fUrtbtt ..., )oa.tidm.,. ~ -....Jr3l;r4.. \Vc~)'aufr..- ..".~ I,Q,~ _ ~ t&at ~~ib ~ ottks!llllhuld be ~ .f.ilIcew _ _ remlvothis JDlItta' ~b'. A qaie1c ~ i! - nlllUi&a:l em ~ptQ1111f ~.Il:Ilv!l 1m ~1IS (ff I)ae. l1Itt IIIi4, hDwawr. d. ~pl'CH:ets Wit! CObtbIe to DIO'\'e Jb.rwmd. We - C8bI:Q aara:: -)1*r ~ lO ~ 0IZl' 9JlI1Cl'ItIo:t1es. pre-coDdltitm to ov:r~ .If'1w:l1llllda .-...-... ~ wtn ~ till f.l;pp~ '10 refIa!t __ 1Il.~ 1f)tJIl rhI:irtc fo ~ tdJa 1It'rJDless: we ...ItM.... onr~ then we wiUJlIOO2d MIl O1R'Pkn.I!AI~ ~ udt ~ _'bs wcmJd bca =RRte since a..c:o~~ III tbis III8ittet Day be wilbiDR:IlCh. Jt is in 0Ilr ~ besr h=rtst1lO nsoJft thfs muter. We SIc Fl'.fNuc4 to meet ~ (fa .h4y J Jill or~ ~wiU be.in ClODbM:t ~ ~ to dbc:uq: tiww IDd phee aDd,. at COIIIlIe, J'OII_ ftMQb e.ilbl:r ODe of Il:S 'lcdlt;rCl1' Oft<< the "'~ by ll:elI pIJcme (K;)'mIQoo 727.~~ Ozit..m,422.102l). ~lG.db. t7- ~ _- CBI:i$ Maim!( R~~ Kymm~ &. IS) -....J -..l ...... ....... 1SI 031 -....J I'-J ...... ..... I'..l N Cil m 1SI 13 .p,. a ..... I--' '" --.J I-" U1 N --.J 0) Cil ..... (S) (,oJ Cil 0"1 (S) co Cil """ (S) l:I U! Cil l1'l .cJ Cil III l'J "il 0 '" ) 'II ~f 'Ctl "0 I~ I~ w ~ r D :E J' 0 l I<'D '1 "'Tl 8 H n ...:l fTl I\) " ... H .... ~ a~ N IWlllliT A en -~ ... (D aI "WRMI~_lQI"" "TI lil -a IT'I-u 1> (,) (SlG1 wlT'l 1SI 00 ...... ..... .p,. 0000000f'\n,> LAW OFFICE PAGE 09/14 . 07/07/2004 17'57 D~bor&~ SObol~.kl >'cu &2._ On Um m."q $IllI I ~m en m tJJ> me( .Jul 07 0" 06:'50.. j ~ ..... ~t...~ t"f".. .... " , , _ { .... ..' IiIUiI' AU. t~ I3I 'nlEst l'Ia::Illn'3 '11U.TI ~. tfO. "" _/lCl"- ,(,~ ~'1ll.aJle4, ~ tllo (I....llt' of thll PI'O;tet1 hi M1'S1VS~. 8!1.1d ~P'" <2f-' . , ~,ot' IIriT lIl:I1.II8 lcolll.l. u4 111. P'XRlIU.A.IJ OCIUIil'T, 'S"ij .... .....~ I jl ~ ;: 't ~:nbe4 d tuucme: '~"-'':';" " , " ~ ;;. ;, I,r r 1.0\. .II to ~ bo1l4lll"",,, or tV.ide SuIl~'I1."lon. ....C1ell1"d1~ to Dmp J..~~ ! n,~' ~OI' plAt t~C>t' j:'t!<I02'ded 1n J'l....t :0..0.0: 2:s o.! PagO 1'7 ut" ~lIll 1"Ibl1o .. '. r, nODl:'\1.:l ot p.l.DelLol tcwrty, 'JI'lwjJ5l.1. ~ ~ ~ l.. ~ ,. l j ~7 J.it '11t1!!:UlA.<J, ,nI, tll& CMleZ'1I ot 1;110 ....00..... <tOIIl:r11:1e\l pJ:VP"rtl.... ~ ~ t.no ,"',I{ l{ ~ ~. -..: ~... I 1" . , l lI!Io..l>;vIui ot pl.A<I1Dj; (,.},.U d -..1. n. 8t rl 0 1:1 or\3 1111 ',hi Q ~O lit lIll1d pl:'OJlll:l'ty 'tor ~ ~ f '11. t ~\'1res1d,",UG1 JIII.:po"Ooll, rj1 ~ ~'I f "'... ! . ' ,~< t ., ~ll!:. 'i"l~":' ~"l':; "'I:ems~~ ':'l:ot t.!::... p3rtl~ to thill , } 1I.I;:r_.R.t. tilt' aaII 'P "1'ii111l<1oM.1llll ot \Iltl ::'.1 tuul Oll"lOJlI""' 'I h_in eDntl)jD.e~, , . -, \t. nJJtlIDA. 11M ~o purtlo:o.11M'11 '~-" , '! ~ " .# a.:ul tlI!l tu n'l.:r.t:' .:o,,.ld,,raU<>n or 011') &,1] ~r I ~)...QQ) 111 h.IDd. .r:J.d. III "reI:; Cot tIo,c:o ~rt.h.C1 to 1.1,.. t.~IOl', t!'/I :<"1""'''1;''' wt>'l1'O:lt 1<1 be",l'.:- .Je~led;od, e;fIll; . , '.tor ""!wr tlWd .....:; 'l':.o.l'l.l~bl.. '....tl.dil..=_U....I9. olo l,l!l'l: 1-: ~oJ hor<'l':1 er.-r=t WOo'L'~. _ ~"h tllO <<tl,,,t'. ~W' '....r...,l.....~. "u" h..1...:I. 'lI.Il!OO.llwr':, 11111,:119 >lnIl le~ !'lop1"e~')JIt(lt1'l'''4, t.!1I,f. t <l." tC' ' ht ; ::'.>)tlrt;;- ..~ye C.Ol:lQri blld. tb" - " toUO'o/1d.l: noblrlet1I1JlJ m'" 1"'I'oW i>1 d1-N Ilj"'l'l ~ r.,..l'c-.:U..... h::>1At~ 11;.11 , " I - 1f.I.tIl11l UJ.. ~lI.lbf'l..D "wvo 4";Qrllx>;l " 1,. loll lot 0 1.1 tll.. tl:'l.let ::.l'!l1i. bO ~t! n!l4 tl.clIol'lbe<1 boll ",",1dVl- t.1o.1 lQt.ll. J'\P \!tl.'\loru~'o ..t."n bO Ol"Ve\ud, :iltoowd, .f.:l..eOd., ..1' l'<lmt'tte-l. to 1'>L:I.1", on (Ill", 1"101111<:n'10,1 11\111<1111.; .1<1'" c.t!l<'ll' till!..:!. CIlia 1101:<>01,..11 "Il.rlclh-:'"",,l.1o' dWU1"l! Or" I:tlll"'lll. nut too ",,<:"4 t.,;, "~<lr1"J 1n l.ol~' .ftol u Jll:'1Tl1h ~ lWl nVllO.ll4G.t:'"J 'lr.l, "lln\' g 1l..Jll.%"tbrll lit t.Q,~h~ t(, tho:. II2I.lll. 4'11l111n,:. :e. Vir l<lt ~ lctll ...: tltllG tl'Qd .:Ji'uU ..t lIlI1 tl."'IlI b':! ltlbdhld!l4 or ".,111 ~~l't. ......h lot ,,01 .. '161"1.., O1Ioj /111",1], b.. 4..o(l.l'4, "I tll. ....r,";,.,,,,:O' to tho ~p or pht tl....rollr rl":'''ro\~ 1n Flal BrJolr. :3, a1: PA&O ll. or tho I'\I~U.. 3eOqr4!1 or :P1lWllDlI Or..lI~Y. 7;J..orlGA. tut till" f'Il'"tJ"!eUoD. ..toQl1 not pro'l'!II!'\I. tho Ooo:D.or ~ IXID1'O:f u.::: 1UI1 linn or lJllJ." lot. "r lqt. G t<l tb6 0f'l)01'" << 'tl>." , I ~.. ~, ~ tIl1~OJ.utlll!: leIt.. ~'" ~ ,. ... [ , . ~ .. t'" . t . . ' , y) , I ~;,~t \ 'f'...r I t ~:~---~~-=-.. . ~ .. .t_" ____ " " .' ~ , 1 '. , . " .... !'i, ,> },I , ., ,1 , " '. A '. , ' '. ~ ~! ~1i::'~~:>-'''~~:<''''''''''-' ....... J.,......_______~j. ..... ;~'m '< 'CD Dlcn 'IliIlIlI .. tDllllII ~.n cro i~ B7I07120134 PAGE 10/14 LAW OFFI cE SobOI~~kl IB47B2~S2~ p ~ o....n~ Or # Bh...u ~, ten · J "" f j ~ '. - , " -, , ~.' .... ~ , \ ~ , , , ;t ~' ~ . , , , /"'r , ~ "/ -1".~'t::l.i2:.t"~':.t~~-,,- " " "'0) Duarm O~ U~ - .. -- .&Q a~ 07/07/2004 17 57 LAW OFFICE PAGE 11/14 r 7 - I ~ I I J 0001'1001'101'10 Jul 07 0... 011 O.~er~h 50bOl~~kl 11l418Z4seS2 ~ -" " , " -~~~~~- !"D" OP liD'~. ) ~ \..r ~ .,.),{ .. . ~.001m' 01> J'4SS.uC 1 ss. . \,~ 0>\' t';,; I m:!tlllIr CElt'nn:, thA t. ell tlU ~ J.L.d <l"l'" 0) r .nt....- BU;"=~ An lleh4!7 publ1",- pi! r'''~''''l::r "l'l>~nre~ l1e_ Ad",,!: n. 1940. ~,~ bi 't . "!Iobco:r;r, m... "Uo' O/U'I'ot.A Iloba -, . ..........~Wry 4n:l : a..: ~ "J n...Vld R. l1o.lId lU>d Jl:otJ:1l\.-.tno 11' ~ I h rt nr oD<1 Jilmott.<> nGh ..t. ';r 'lI:I to lilt to ba tho 11141..1<luo,ln ~ ~ h "1fo. to ... ...11 ]a\< "'~. ,. I>l'08~8 1n "1::1....", t. Olld tll..,. "0"01'&11 oer '" 1n nil'" who U'O"'" t<ld th..- . ~,'bo their tNO ....t o.ll/l dood tor.~ ::r &Olmo"l~<lG"d tho ""OeuUOIl th<Ir.ot it ~... "".... ..nd plU'pDo&a tbol'01n ...,Uo .d ~"1t, . -. , f" > ;'. ~ . ", -. C - , ..- , ,) ~-.,.:~~-~~~:....-....~....-,......, ~""""~-.. , j 07/07/2004 17.57 000000001"'> PAGE 12/14 LAW OFFICE 1 B4782109<fe:_ p.s 'f , '" . I -.. 411>> r 1flRTHmI, ~Tm th.tlt tho oa14 B:lJ.u'both R. Elngabm7: Rano"1!.o &bl.rt and K!/.tbarlne 21. HlUl<\. tb,o -11'08 or tbe eud. K"lU7 A. E11l811~, Ouret A. lIobA,l:ot. 11:% Gld De.v1<11t. JlII.nd. :rollpeot1TolT. rotD . 1I0Pif"1l.l;o 8M prl".h l!XllIllnat.J.DII hkoll b:r and botoNI n, IU'PD.t'Rhl,. ..nO *pn:rt tt'olIII. thoir u,1d hullba'fJc1o, IUd, ..okno.1e~e thAt t:luI:r QOcute.O tbe tOI'i!lSrot1Y18 11111tl'\UllODt treely nm Tolunl:4r11:r ...nd 'ltlthtrut 0."1" oo~e.lc;lJI. egl'l"~l"II.1Pt.. "PF 02:le1l11101l 01'" to,,-;r or or :l:'rOlll tbell' /l1l1d !mabO;lIda. Tl.tTIiESS P:J babd e.l:l.d. orUolAl. (1,,111 8t (:..LA.II. _'. Illtd. Claa.nty meS. $tQ~, tho day Gnd. ;TlllU" laet afoZ'en1c1. . ~.r~ - ~~~'L~ ..""71'" (/ - 7 ~~(:.. ~ ~ I'. /1~~~v-!""'" . I ....,~...... '\ I , .... I ", ~ e , '11ft! lot l'~ .~ ~'f.-.If~ .l.~/r ".1.1,10 rile r-t lIMeo! ~ nlllll~ ~ -~l'nl.lI, RAY It. PJl:m, C:I~~ ui ellll Cheall O-r. fJ",Un """11, f'llWlu. Dr... ~~.~ bc:p.ay CltrL ~~I''!'''' ."~." 1'llC'.......-..,.~~~..,..."..,..__,_ - -- ". u"'---", . -,----.J!r~,~-.........~"":lIl'....__.............~- j 07/07/2004 I ~Q) c,_ O.a CJns .- .., ..- cnfG ~~ 17,57 00000000~~ .JUI o? 04 OelSl".. LAW OFFICE aebo~.h So~olesk] le~7B24 PAGE .:: p.l:: ...... , . DUD tiUO PJln 5:; r :... .... In ... -.... ., · .::::_""" ....~ .....,....... JIo "'11- ~.;., ins or OAbana oo"Ung 101l1l tha~ $4,000.00 .mc..ll be po""'-t.ted 01:1 lot" 7 lod , .' r ~, 52 ot ~, trao". 'tho. IPVI,Uld nOO:!" Ol'&(l or the IlIAln doI'ellinS, exelulIlv" Q ":-r.,,-:-:r ~~~" OM-a t<ll'J!{opcnJ po robes Ill'ld ganSl!la. .Moll be not. lea s thAn 1,100 equn:!"e tell t ~i' In the o,n.. 0 r 8 01:\0.. oto.t7 I! th.lO t\lJ" l! nD" llUll1l than 800 11I qUIlt"lJ to:Ol1l t In t 11" ~,%' ~ I~:::.: :.:'': ~~.::~ ::: :~:::::.,,: ;:11:,:,::::., , ' ;"thh tract. '1'hl1I ground. !'lollI' fl.re" or the IIIl)j,n lItl"UotU:l'O, lIJI:olun1,ve ot line.. ~i,,~, . l- >>r-~' ,. tory Oplll! porohell and gA2'll.I5Ill! shall b8 no t ll1la~ t....n 1,200 equGl"O to.. t In ~~the case or D one-lItor, Attuoturo nor lell~ thnn SOO root In tho CO~e ot 0 o,ne ~~\ !!,'))f' - nd Ollll-h:;!;lf or two et.a17 . trl1~ t\lre. ~ \ 11. UIl O\ltddll toll<l t ehnU be p02"Zll' too:l, bu.t thor. aWl bo OOItBtruC ted .' r1n oonnaotlon wl;h any d~e11in~ or onbann on n~ ot 4a14 lot~ ~ 8~ptlc tank, .1.tM looatlon 8n<l COl'lllthlCtll)Q or wlu,oh (lOota 1111 the r8q\llromonts or th~ t~l oOa1 ana. So tu. to ho a1th nu tho 1'1 t.lo~ and. "MOh hno \JOG'1l II PPt'O'Il'od. 1n wr1tln,g by' ~..'th6 O"f",.re 411d. d6Ye1opora Dr Ba101d.o .!I~l;J<J1.'II'lelo.,. "; , :'12. ile. bu11dln.s: lI:hD.ll b, 'l1"ootod on 10toll 2 t~ ;:i1 InolulIlv., nu.l'O:l' tMIl 20 ~ - :r,tsot to tho lnllkhli811 I1ne pn'" no bu.lld~ 8bol1 bo "rlteted 011 lota .:s2 to 53 ,rlol~d...o noarel" thlUJ 2S %'oot to th<l bulkhfllW. l1no nor n"lU'el" than tWl:lnty ~(~Ol . foet. to IlcJTOn Drlvo aa Ihol'l'n Oil tile IIlAp 0:1' J~" t or oald BlQ"old. SQ1;ldlvhlon. t(Uo bu.U41na: Moll !XI iOORtOll no_or than rho feet ~ any a1de lot l1n<'J. ~).;;.' fig 0_11" 01' 1IUl;)" lot 01" lote 100fltell withln th1~ Su.~b1810n -hAll be ~':\~ltted to' 1'111 in 01' aaUII" to bo f1lJ.oo:l 111 1ItlJ' 8ubmol"6"d Innd.~ wbJ.ob .j ;, _lllJ:'\ll l!o:.r;t..oncI ~:t'thlll:' Into Gl"DrWoto)" Do]' tha,n I:.};tO 808 "811 l1no 0..0 IIh(lwn on ~ l~ t II or1a:.1nBl =.p Ol" 0I1al: 01' th.ti!! Sllbdlv1aJon. ~llo;.. '.' '. 1,']\ Bo IUla wall 0:' 1'oto.1rllnc wall Dhall be ~llt abuttIng Am' 01' t.hfl 10tE! .f..r..ltl.... " ~~!lteo:l 1n Ul.18 Sub..u.vblotl, "MOp!: on th,,," Uno doa1gno.tOd OD tho or1g1na.1 . , '~j\"-:\. '- r" I , f . t'.. tho a&. .&11 11ne. ~~'''''>i '" ' . 1t < · .~aO!OOV"Z:UUlto are to nan "'lth the land o.ml ahQu t)o b.1~1ng on lLll.. I II. ".L v. ... ,~ _ 1;g.:P~t.1",. 1It1<l all >>OrlSOnl claltl11as \U1dOl' t!wm unt11 Ja,nulU'-ol 1 '19.... D...' , ifJf~~. ~"1" ~ ----..-.-" . ~. .... , ~ -t1_ lald "O~VQn_nt.ll Ghall bo IlUtQll\ll,'t10811Y extsn4114 1'0" -~aOfll!;elVe "r~1;048 of' ,teA ~"ll1'. UDleu b:1 8, Votlll or the IlIl"Jor1ty or th~ than ~ner.ll ~t' ' "P...;' " , . , ~h It 1_ "'6Z'~d to db.8.QSO th& Bud O()VenMtD 1n Wholo or In p8rt. .E.. J y-'.. .,. _t, ." y> .. ~ j./o, , II" . f..F~~ ~ '!. ~ r_ ~tJ t. ~ It ... , , ~11.,. 4(" \ ":"'+1 ~' ~ . "'" ..~ r. ~t!l ...."", .:.,,..~.... ., - ~ . , , ~, , , ": r.'l/ " .' ..' " ~.. ,.. j t ~ . , ' ~ ,', . 1 , , " . , I ~.. 'J'" "",{ 1''' l,j.j I " I' ... ~,' ~-='~~~2;.)I;'k", v-'~ -"'~"'~~~~.7"""":;:-~.,-.. ",' .~- 13/14 ~ 67/07/2004 t . ~I D._ O.a CJCU - ., .- rn~ ~> car( 17,57 00000600Pl"l LAW OFFICE PAGE Ju1 07 04 O~:S~~ Deboren Sobo1e~k~ 11l471324S2h.. p.e r - ~~ I~j ,....r.l}~u.. .. ~ .. "',J , , , .-- , I!ttIJ l;f.iO rAti, .{] ,I .- ~a.~ (SEAL) ~~d~(SEAL)' ~a.1Izrttza 'It!. ISlW.l --...:Jft 0 J. ~ft ~}( ~AL) ":bRM-~ct Z. ~ (SEAt) 1 ~ ~on;~ ~. ~. (SEAL) ^d ~O~D ~ ~~ ~ ln~UBlv~J lotA ~ 29. 30. 31, Iota ~Z. 3I~ 10t.1I 36 ~ ; 5:1 !nol""l"'e. . , .. : !' ) -, !" ~ ll'l'!' "0 P, ,:Dm.u.s l sa ").', ' ,1 ... ,..... to'[l j t./.:"": I hDrob;r oertl!)' that thll'l \Illy 11'1 the n...~t above n8.tlJ94 Stlte and" , Ooun t,' befo:M =, aD Oa'leor dub' Q.utbor.l.z\!,,- n mJ A ot1t1~, perl!u;ln.u.y "P" - '~"'pea:Md~ ~ J. l::nowlo:u, !lnd BenJo.m1n 1:. J:noll'1en, b&l' huabAl'Io:1; V1T!"n Y. P~~k1n; ond D. O. 'ork1DD, her huD~nd: BernAdotto A. ~lllook ond M. . - pro.noh \':J'll11ClDk, bot' 11WIbnn,l. UlU'cuerlto L. nu,t.tOl', III ..140"_ '$. K. 'rflt"V1D . _~'J allll ItIlobol n. '.t'M'vln, hi" .,ifei 1:1'.,. E, lJolohor Rn<1 I. J. Belohor. hOl" lnl."l1l1nd; tg 1Il8 wel1 knoun and kn'">wn to T,lQ to J,o tho lncllvlr.1unls dO.:JClrlb/)d In And who l:o,to:J:e~tot1 t.ho fO:l:'o001"8 lnDt;l:'lU'lOnt. nnl1 thll,. (IOknl'lfllo~"'" than Dna. t;h~rll 1)_ ~. ,? ~o:: mCl tJ;uat tM~ C1xool,lted Odd 1nlJt.2"W'lent fat' tho \\80.:1 llnd. pu.tyCl~IUI m"lItl11no~ ~ .., 'AJIJ) I Pl1R'l'Iw.R CNt'l'In, t1lnt tho l)Q,1<1 I.o:gnQ. ;r. Know]."", Vlvl"n Y. -\.l'e.l:"klnll, D~ac.1C1~t." ^. OJhlUoek, Cn.lIo1 D. ~nrv1n, l1nd "'117 g. DolQhtll', knOTm. ~"'I.,tc. l:lKt to be thCl .1Tu 01' tho lu\1(1 Do:nJtl.tlin J:~ knOI1).Qn: D. O. Fcr:kl:nllJ ~~-:{.. FrnnO~lI WhlllookJ w. H. tnr?1n, ond X. J. DolQhor. renpoctiToly, on a ' ,?01.~ '1I0:DU~ll' d prlvllt" aXIlD!.1lll\t1ot:l. ttJk"n IIt1II l:;I\(I;" 1n tt18 sbovCl nAlrlDc3 St.Qt." ~"-:Ilt:\cl'" .' ~.JIrld t;>OrON Ill.,. D"Pl\rll.~11 Mid llj)t1rt tram tholr M:td hunbnnt;to, '~~'~~14;. ~ .~~odge borClro mo. on ottienr Quthorl&ad t.o take l1okno~le~. 'I" ~!t~ lIal,J;-t1a1 U.C1ou,tocl t:;o tor 1I go ins: lnstrwm,nll ('reol)'" llrld VCll\U1tQ r117 'I ;:~~~~DMllpulDlon, eonst.I'Q1at, l'I.PP"oholls1on Cor fetll" or Clr t..om ' ~r~.~~ n~. , r'.~~,.....~...(', ~.., ;.e '" 11q' hand ll.hd 01' tlo1fl1 0 ".1 eM. 4q 01' A. n. , ~~;,.'1I"1'~'1'\!':\ { ""'=-<':... ..'a '!, ~. "~r ~ ":.... ,...\. ~ I '<:' ..", . c'f:;1. "': f' "Ii.... Jl1 "t: ~"':~ :so '"~ ~_f. .. , l;l",~~~" ~I ~c ~~n..l "'"/ "..,:r~ ..:f_""" .J~~~~ ,l,. ~ 'fJtni'I!2.~ I)l" mm: JBllm::r: ) ~~~...."'~" e.. JrI{',.. ) ss ...d01m'r.( 01' P ASS,uC } , , "\ r<~$;' " ~-:'.! J: HEn1lSr ~. t;hD, t on th.1" 3 1 d doy Q t ~ II. n. 1 ~O. tl ". o ~ro be, a Uot:Ql'T pubHCl.."per!lotmll~D:!'ert neh1'7 AfEJaD8I!.ttu.ry IUld 'Ellub&t.h II. tI.bs;lIbuZ7. 1118 "Uo; OnM'ot A. nobcirt lIt ana. );Qnot.te Bob l't ,;lUlI ~~~oJ 2).:"1.11 &~ DDJ:ld CLIld Ko.thAr1no U. IrClohd. bh vlf'o to illS ~ll kl'l! wn' · ~ BD4 ""lKItII'I t:I) IllO to bo IlM 1nd1vlclunJ.o doacrlbod 1~ and. who e~ooutod. th., ' ...tfl~go1115 1.QAtrw:::lent and tbe)" 1I0'V1III1'1I,11)" nolrnD171t!dCo4 t110 o~oCl..l.t:hD thllr.'tot ~ ~"".j b 'iro I. 01 thAll" tl'lle Qat n.nd. d.O'll'd for tbo lain and plU'pooell ~rolD JIIlI!itt1Ol l)d. 'i%'J,l! ; . . . . . ~ , . " '1\'" ':r~'If." -, A b'" ... .,.:.. . ~~ ~h ~~ , ! i" '(,-:- ., t 1;.:, ~...I' ;l,W~", . "~'. ~ ~-r..'"!J Il: \: 1.."IJr f\ ,~ ' l.~' .. oil ~ t l' Ill,'.., '- I.... l""..J"; It:... ......,. ~:J..i " .. . . 'p ~ " .( , '", ., - I , '0:. " " .- ,1't-~~)."7{, ~~......<"....;>-....."....~ _ ~ 14/14 10:35 am Case Number. FLS2004-05028 -- 193 DEVON DR (~~~~1 I /! I I r - !, ~) ! I i Manam C Chnstopher 310 LIve Oak Lane Largo, FI 33770 TELEPHONE 8\3 6233941, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Enwl Representative. Ilmothy A Johnson 911 Che'ltnut Street Clearwater, FI 33756 TELEPHONE 727461 1818, FAX 727 462 0365, E-MAIL l1mJ@Jpfim1 com LocatIOn. 033 acre lot located on the ~outh 'llde of Devon Dnve approxlm.Itely 1000 feet east of Hamden Drive Atlas Page 276A Zomng District. LMDR, Low MedIum DenSIty Residential Req u cst. Flexl b]e Standard Development app roval to tncrea~e the length of a dock from 60 feet (50 percent of the wIdth of the property) to 92 feet (76 6 percent of the width of the property) under the provIsIOns of SectIon 3-601 Proposed Use: Detached dwellmg NClghborhood No Neighborhood Assocatlon Data Assocla tlOn( s): Presenter. John Sehodt]er, Planner I Attendees Included Applicant The DRC reviewed thIS applicatIOn With the following comments. General Engmeermg 1 No I<;sues E nVlro "menta I: ProvIde cople<; ofSWFWMD dnd/or FDEP Penmt, Corps of Engmccr'~ Penmt and Submerged Land Lease pnor to th(, commencement of constructIOn Nute~- Fire' No ]<;,;ue Harbor Mastcr: No Comment~ Legal. No Comments Land Resources. No Comments La ndscapl ng. I no Issues IV ()..,., c.... rc .:::r u -v6 {7. ~ ~ rfAl~ ~::r~ ;J-~-Jh WId ~ -r..:f. l'arks and RecreatIOn No I~~ue<; on dock request Stormwater: I No Issues Solid Waste. No Comment~ Trdffic Engmeermg I No bsuc<; Planmng I ExhibIt A ha<; what appear~ to bc .In CHoneou<; ]me runmng through the mldd]e of the property cdlllllg out the "center ]me of ,;cawall" Please exp]alll or reVl<;C plan 2 Pk.I<;e provide an e~tlm.Itcd project value for the entire dock <;y<;t~m "'to So .t='. 3 ExhibIt B has the dock drdwn to the nght of the catwalk and ExhIbIt A has It drawn 10 the left Ple.Iseexplamorrevlsep]an 1!!> ~ ~~ '1'",:, J t'........r+~ ~ Other' - II No Comment'; )9 ~ ~ t:'" . ....0 Development Revl(,w Agenda - Thursday, July 8, 2004 - Page 14 OE\lHOI-'AAENl S€.RVICES OEPT CltV Of ClEARVIIAr'ER Dale and Janet NIemann 177 Devon Dn ve Clearwater, Flonda 33767 July 4, 2004 TO 562-4576 PAGE 00 004 Home 442-2079 Office 877-251-3681 Fax 877-251-3681 John Scholdtler Development Review Speclallst Ctty of Clearwater Plannmg Department 100 South Myrtle A venue Clearwater, Ftonda 33756 Fax 727-562-4576 Dear Mr Scholdter We ask that the Planmng Department deny the approval of the applicatIOn for FleXible Standard Development Approval at 193 Devon Dnve (FLS2004-05028) We obJ ect to the grantmg of a vanancc for the fo !lowmg reasons (1) Deed restnctlOns exist for our area which prohibit all covered docks and docks of lengths greater than 60 feet. We ask that the plannmg department adhere to these restnctlOns for all proposed vanances gomg forward (2) The proposed length and configuration of the dock will destroy our sole scenic view. A key part of the value of our home 1S to be found m our eX1stmg V1ew (from our hvmg areas and porch) ofbeaut1ful Clearwater Bay The proposed dock wm have a negative impact on the value of our property and will defimtely not enhance the value as encouraged by the Code in Section 1-103 General B.2. As the code states" It IS the purpose of thIS Commumty Development Code to create value for the clt17en <; of the City of Cl earwater by ensuring that development and redevelopment Will not have a negative impact on the value of the surroundmg properties and whenever practicable promoting development and redevelopment that Will enhance the value of surroundmg propertIes" It 1S notable that our neIghbors, the Sobeleskts, were very cogruzant of not Impedmg our View m any manner when deslgIung both their home and Iandscapmg Wlule 1t IS true that there are two docks of slll111ar length to that proposed by the applicant on their property, these docks eXJsted pnor to the1r purchase of the property One was buIlt by Mr John i!B!" 11 50 AM fROM Fax TO 562-4576 FAGE 001~. ~03 177 Devon Drive Cleal\o'i'ater, Florida 33767 Cell phone 727-492-8041 faxi den t al roJf! [!rn! 00 JUL 0 8 2004 . ~ To Fax Number Cynthia Tarapam I John Schodtler 562-4576 OEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPT -C-!u..ot-.cl~AQ.WA f"E R- -- From Fax Number Business Phone' Home Phone Janet Niemann 1-877 -251-3681 1-727 -442-2079 Pages Date/Time SubJed 3 7/8/2004 11 50 36 AM RE FLS2004-05028 - letter requesting denial of application Dear Ms Tarapanl and Mr Scholdtler I orlglnlally faxed thIs Jetter on 7/5/04 I asked by fax and vOice malls that a confirmation of receipt be faxed to me at 877-251-3681 (Alternatively you may ernall rne at Janet_n1emann@yahoo com) I have never received confirmation Mr Tlrnothy Johnson, Mr Mariani's attorney, Just called me to state that your department had faxed him the fl rst page of the letter a nd that you r department had Indicated that was all they received from me Conseqeuntly I am refaxlng the letter once again PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT Also I have requested several times that Exhibits A, 8, and C plus page 6 be faxed to me since I did not receive them In the original fax you provided I realize that your department IS very busy but I respectively ask that you respond Thank you 7/0/2004 11 50 AM FROM Fax TO 562-4576 PAGE 002 OF 003 Dale and Janet NIemann 177 Devon Dnve Clearwater, Flonda 33767 July 4, 2004 Home 442~2079 Office 877-251-3681 Fax 877~251-3681 John Scholdtler Development ReVIew Speclahst City of Clearwater Planmng Department 1 00 South Myrtle A venue Cleanvater, Flonda 33756 Fax 727-562-4576 Dear Mr Scholdter We ask that the Plannmg Department deny the approval of the apphcatlOD for Flexible Standard Development Approval at 193 Devon Dove (fLS2004-05028) We obJcct to the grantmg of a vanance for the folJowmg reasons (1) Deed restrictions exist for our area which prohibit all covered docks and docks of lengths greater than 60 feet We ask that the plannmg department adhere to these restnctlOns for all proposed vanances gomg forward (2) The proposed length and configuration of the dock wIll destroy our sole scenic view. A key part of the value of our home IS to be found In our eXlstmg view (from our hvmg areas and porch) of beaul1ful Clearwater Bay The proposed dock will have a negative Impact on the value of our property and will definitely not enhance the value as encouraged by the Code in Section 1-103 General B.2. As the code states" II IS the purpose of thiS Commumty Development Code to creale value for the Cltl7ens of the CIty of Clearwater by ensuring that development and redevelopment will not have a negative impact on the value of the surrounding propertles and whenever praCl1cable promotmg development and redevelopment that Wll1 enhance the value of surroundmg propcrhes" It IS notable that our neighbors. the Sobeleslas, were very cogtUzant of not Impedmg our view In any manner when deslgnmg both their home and landscapmg Wlule It IS true that there are two docks of s1l111lar length to that proposed by the apphcant on thelf property, the~e docks eXisted pnor to theu purchase of the property One was bUilt by Mr John Blakely and was opposed by us (3) An alternative location eXists for a dock that wdl provide the applicant wi.th the same amenities as the proposed dock. ThiS locanon does Dot negatively impact the environment oor does It negatively Impact surrounding properties. The request to Increase the length ofthe pemutted dock from 60 feet to 92 feet 1S necessary only because the proposed locatIOn reqU1re~ a walkout of that length to place the platform and boat shps beyond the hffi1t of the sea grasses at that location The dock could be placed oil the eastern Side of the propeny where sea grasses end about 50 feet from the seawall. Smce the neighbor to the left of Ihls lme hd<; hvmg areas onc floor above ground level, there would be no view obstructIOn to thiS neighbor Similarly, <;mce the apphcant IS bUlldmg one level off the ground, the apphcant's view would not be negatively Impacted 7/B/20 1 50 AM FROM Fox TO S62-~S76 PAGE 003 0- "3 (4) The property configuratIOn does not preclude the placement of a dock in comphance with tbe reqUlled dJmensional standards [Partl Corrunumty Development Code Article 3 Development Standards Dmslon 6 Dock/Manna Standards SectIOn 3-60 I C New Docks g Devlalions 111 ] A dock of approximately 60 feet can be bUllt off the eastern Side of the property and be III wmphance with the reqmrements (5) The proposed dock IS almost ldenhcal to one proposed by the applicant In February, 2002 (FLS 02-02-03) rhl~ configuratIOn Included two covered hfts It is our understanding tbat the apphcant intends to add these roofs 10 the future. The covered hets will completely block our view. Wlule we certainly beheve that a property owner should have the nght to bmld a dock that meets hIs boatmg needs, a property owner also has a responslblhty to the surroundmg neighbors to not decrease or destroy their property value In domg so Snmlarly, we beheve that the mtent of the provIsIOns to grant vanances pnmanly eXl ~t!> for those cases where docks cannot be bUllt that comply WIth the provlSlOns We respectively submit that a vanance IS not requlred nor should It be granted Thank you for your conSideration of the dbove Smcerely, ,- ~ .i ,. " ./' Lt'lIq,'t I V'V L./ , I ,,1 t( , , ) ~,/ - ~,~. <.. - Dale Niemann Janet NIemann 7/81 1 53 PM FROM Fax TO 562-~576 PAGE 001 ( 177 Devon Drive Clearwater, Florida 33767 [0) rnm1rnOW~ rm lill JUl 0 8 2004 lill Cell phone 727-492-8041 DEVELOPMENT SERVICES OEPT .-CJI~Of Cl Ff\AWAfER-- faxi den t al To Fax Number. Cynthia Tarapanll John Scholdtler 562-4576 From. Fax Number. Busmess Phone Home Phone Janet Niemann 1-877 -251-3681 1-727 -442-2079 Pages DatejTime SubJed< 4 7/8/20041 5356 PM FLS2004-05028 - Letter requesting denial of application This IS the third time I have faxed this letter and asked for confirmation of receipt Similarly, I have requested that Exhibits A, 8, and C of the application be faxed to me since they were not In the anginal fax provided to me by Mr Schodtler Please emall or fax confirmation of receipt of the attached letter as well as the above requested documents Thank you Th I S document (reduced Document Total pages Scanned NO DOC Remote Station 95 918772513681 Notes EC Erro~ Co~~ect Be Broadcast Send CP completed HS Host Scan HF Host Fax Tra - : smlsslon Report Date/Time Lace I 10 Local Name Company Logo 7- 8-04, 1 57PM 7275624796 was conf rmed. e and deta Letter-S be low) Is sarnp Size FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE A VR., :zI>d Floor CLEARWATER, FL33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX. (727) 562-4865 ::r"oJeT' N \ So M"',.l.,.I TO FAX'~Z - 251 ~3'BI l'bone. "'\'\'2- oMI FRO)1. :::f....J.. ~ :,\, t..-A+ 1"..... rhoDe: DATE nit 2.~... cnD~ MESSAGE SUBJECT, ~E- 1'13 'DSlkw..ll'>l\! '"'- ~'UMBER 01' PAG~NCLUDING THlS PAGEl CP 14 4 RE Resen MP Mu I t I -Po I I RM Receive to Memory HP Host Print HR Host Receive y Remote polling a Remote Document Removed Forced Output Fa rWe rd Me I I Dox Doc MB Rece I ve to Me I I box P I power I nter,-upt Ion TM Terminated by user WT Waiting T,-ansfer WS Waiting Send u FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865 ~ TO: .::..JA..,)€'1"" Nt 6 M" N~ FAX: 877 - 2S I - 3~81 Phone: .,.'\"2. - O~"\: I FROM: ::fDh t"'I Sf ~r!+ I..e/ Phone: DA TE: oCt 2.t 0 1- 0'70901 MESSAGE: SUBJECT: ~ € Iq3 t::lEV6t.J t;:>y<". -PfPL- N1J1VffiER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) ,ORIGINAL ! -:(~rl~ , - ,=11 ", CASE # DATE RECEIVED RECEIVED BY (staff Initials) ATLAS PAGE# ZONING DISTRICT LAND USE CLASSIFICATION SURROUNDING USES OF ADJACENT PROPERTIES NORTH SOUTH WEST m<'~r- ~ Planning Departmeill ~.f1 ~ I 100 South Myrtle Avenue " ,";. ~ ~arwater I Clearwaler Flonda 33756 ~'Telephone 727-562-4567 ~ r--.::/ Fax 727-562-4865 o SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED AND NOTARlZEDAPPUCATION~AY 18 20u I o SUBMIT 14 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION lildu"dl1l9 '.... ...."_ 1} collated. 2) stapled and 3) folded sets of site plails '.;l DEIP!., '~- CLEAr", o SUBMIT APPLICATION FEE i. * NOTE 15 TOTAL SETS OF INFORMATION REQUIRED (APPliCATIONS PLUS SITE Pl.JIN SETS) FLEXIBLE STANDARD DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION (RevIsed 11/18/03) - PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT - r I A APPLICANT, PROPERTY OWNER AND AGENT INFORMATION (Code Section 4-202 A) I APPLICANT NAME Chrlstopher C. Mar1anl MAILING ADDRESS 310 L1ve Oak Lane, Largo, Flor1da 33770 FAX NUMBER (813) 626-4103 PHONE NUMBER (813l623-3941 PROPERTY DWNER(S) Chrlstopher C. Marlanl (Must onclude ALL ownefS as I,stod on lhe deed - p'ov,de onglnal slgnature(sl on page 6) MA'LING ADDRESS Tlmothy A. Johnson, Jr., and B.D. Armstrong III Johnson, Pope, Bokor, Ruppe~ & Murns, LL~ P. O. Box l368, Clearwater, FL 33757 AGENT NAME I I I PHOr,JE NUMBER (727)46l-IBlB FAX NUMBER (727)462-0365 CELL NUMBER (727) 709-0l23 E_MAILADDRESSt1mJ@Jpflrm.com 8 PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT INFORMATION (Code SectIOn 4-202 A) 193 Devon, Clearwater, FL STRfET ADDRESS of subject site Lot 3l, Replat of Bays1de Sub., Plat Book 23, Pgs. 14-l5 LEGAL DESCRIPTION PARCEL NUMBER I'M3'Y'2tg~)fr~ !15~S9 f"4e)t1d'tii'5'3'i ~'" ~ocument ,n the sUbm,ttall PARCEL SIZE 0.33 acre (acres square feet) FRa:DSED USEI'3) AND SIZE(S) slngle-farnlly dwelllng W1 th dock (number of dwelling units, hotel rooms or square footage of non reSidential use) DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST(S) Level One (flex~ble standard) approval of a dock 92 feet In Page 1 of 6 - Flpxlble Standard Development Applicdtlon- CIty of Clearwater AttBch sheels and be .pec,flc when Idenhfylng the request (Include all requested codo devlallons e 9 reduc lion on required number of p~(klng spaces, speclftc use elc) length where 60 feet 1S perm1tted. See sketch attached as Exhlblt A. DOES THIS APPliCATION INVOLVE THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS [TOR), A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT, OR A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED (CERTIFIED) SITE PLAN? YES _ NO ~ (If yes attach a copy of the appltcable docllments) C PROOF OF OWNERSHIP (Code SectIOn 4-202 A 5) €:I SUBMIT A COPY OF THE TITLE INSURANCE POLICY, DEED TO THE PROPERTY OR SIGN AFFIDAVIT A TIESTING OWNERSHIP (see page 6) D WRITTEN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Code Section 3-913 A) lia ProVide oomplete responses to tl1e SIX (6) GENERAL APPLICABILITY CRITERIA - Explain how each cntena IS achieved, In detaIl The proposed development of the land WIll be In harmony with the scale, bulk, coverage, denSity and character of adjacent propertJes In which It IS located The proposed dock ~s Slm2lar ln lenqth to the two docks located on the property adJacent and westerly of the subJect property. See photographs and Exhib2t B attachec. 2 The proposed development W1llnot hinder or discourage the appropriate deve\opment and use of adjacent land and bUildings or Significantly Impair !tie value thereof See Exh2blt B attached. The adJacent propert2es are developed and have docks. 3 The proposed development will not adversely affect the health or safety or persons reSiding or working In the neighborhood of the proposed T~~ proposed dock does not result ln a hazard to navlgat1on. ~ ~-~ -- -- -, ~ 1::;'" 0 IVt~\Y 1 b lUlJ~ 4 P' II ".'\" - - ....... ""T~ ~...~ IT .J.. " J jI '-'. _ r: ~~.. ~;;".cu:a f'" !'",/.. f G' -,." - ~ i"'\ 1l1;\'TEf:! No addltlonal veh2cular trafflc w2ll be generated by the proposed dock.. ~..", Jlf!-'\, !b'" The proposed development IS deSigned to minimize traffic congestion 5 The proposed development IS conSistent With the community character of the Immediate VICInity of the parcel proposed for development Most lots on Devon Dr2ve have docks. The adJacent westerly property has two docks of slm1lar length. 6 The deSIgn of the proposed development minimizes adverse effects, Including visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operalion Impacts, on adjacent properties See Exhlb2t C Wh2Ch descr2bes a dock and llft arrangement that can be bU2lt as a matter of r~ght and Wh1Ch would more adversely affect the westerly adJacent property. Page 2 of 6 - FlexIble Standard Development Apphcatlon- City of Clearwater Oil: Provide complete responses to the applicable flexibility cntena for the specific land use as listed m each Zoning District to which the waiver IS requested (use separate sheets as necessary) - Explain how each crltena IS achieved In detail See Exhlblt D attached. See attached Prlvate Dock Perm1t Appl1catlon - Plnellas County Water and Nav1gatlon Control Authorlty E STORMWATER PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (CIty of Clearwater Design Criteria Manual and 4-202 A 21) o STORMWATER PLAN Including the follOWing reqUirements EXisting topography extending 50 feet beyond all property lines Proposed grading Indud Ing finished floor elevations of all structures All adjacent streets and municipal storm systems, Proposed stormwater detenbonlretel'ltlon area Includmg top of bank toe of slope and outlet control structure Stormwaler calculatIOns for attenuation and water quality Signature of Flonda regIStered Professional Engineer on all plans and calculallons o COPY OF PERM]T INQUIRY LEITER OR SOUTHWEST FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT (SVIIFWMD) PERMIT SUBMITTAl (SWFWMD approval IS reqUIred prior to Issuance of City BUilding Permit) If applicable '-' vue ~ ''-'UUI~ll "L-'" , u".", rv ," F SUPPLEMENTAL SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Code Section 4-202 A) ~ SIGNED AND SEALED SURVEY (mcludlng ]egal deSCription of property) - One orlg I nal and 14 copIes, o TREE SURVEY (including eXisting trees on site and Within 25 of the adjacent Site, by species, Size (DBH 4" or greater), and location including drip lines and Indlcaling trees to be removed) - please deSign around the eXlstmg trees, o LOCAT10N MAP OF THE PROPERlY o PARKING DEMAND STUDY In conjunction With a request to make deViations to the parking standards (Ie Reduce number of spaces) Prior to the submittal of thiS application the methodology of such study shall be approved by the Community Development Coordinator and shall be In accordance With accepted traffic engmeo:>nng prinCiples The fmdlngs of the study Will be used In determining whether or not deViatIons to the parkIng standards are approved i:I GRADING PLAN, as applicable, o PRELIMINARY PLAT as reqUired (Note BUilding permts Will not be Issued until eVidence of recorchng a final plat IS proVided), o COPY OF RECORDED PLAT, as applicable, G SITE PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Section 4-202 A) -.,,-, 1"1 I!~n' -, 7'"!:;O~~) I) , J Ill.""" .:t: o SITE PLAN With the follOWing Informallon (not to exceed 24' x 36") All dimenSions North arrow, Englneenng bar scale (minimum scale one Inch equals 50 feet) and date prepared, Location map, Index sheel referenCing indiVidual sheets Included In package, Footprint and size of all EXISTING bUildings and structures, Footpnnt and size of all PROPOSED bUildings and structures, I - LUlJ4 1 -~'-\\ :S;\l'7 1 .. ~ ~~ ': 1~~:7~ Page 3 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Appllcatlol1- City of Clearw<.Jter All required setbacks, All eXisting and proposed pOints of access, All reqUired sight tnangles, Identification of environmentally unique areas, such as watercourses, wetlands, tree masses, and specimen trees, including descnpllon and locallon of understory, ground cover vegetation and wildlife habitats, etc, Location of all public and pnvate easements, Location of all street nghts-of-way w,thm and adjacent to the Site, Location of eXisting public and pnvate Uti hiles, Includmg fire hydrants, storm and sarlllary sewer lines, manholes and 11ft stations gas and water lines All parking spaces dnveways, loading areas and vehicular use areas, Depiction by shadmg or crosshatching of all required parking lotlntenor landscaped areas, LocatIOn of all solid waste containers, recycling or trash handling areas and outside mechanical equipment and all required screening {per Section 3-201 (0)(1) and Index #701}, , Locallon of all landscape matenal, Location of all onSlle and off site storm-water management faCilities, Locallon of all outdoor Ilghtmg fixtures, and Location of all eXlstmg and proposed Sidewalks o SITE DATA TABLE for eXlsllng, required, and proposed development, In written/tabular form Land area m square feet and acres, Number of EXISTING dwelling Units, Number of PROPOSED dwelling Units, Gross floor area devoted to each use, Total paved area, Including all paved parking spaces and driveways, expressed In square feet and percentage of the paved vehicular area, Size and species of all landscape matenal, OffiCial records book and page numbers of all eXisting utility easement, BUilding and structure heights, Impenneable surface rello (I S R ), and Floor area rallo (F A R ) for all nonresldenllal uses o REDUCED SITE PLAN to scale (8 y, X 11) and color rendenng If pOSSible, o FOR DEVELOPMENTS OVffi ONE ACRE, proVide the follOWing addltlonallnfonnatlon on site plan One-foot contours or spot elevations on site OIlSlle elevations If reqUired to evaluate the proposed stormwater management for the parcel, All open space areas Location of all earth or water retain Ing walls and earth berms Lot lines and bUlldmg lines (dimensioned), C"'m~'_ BUilding and structural setbacks (dimenSioned), Structural overhangs, Tree Inventory, prepared by a "certified arbonst", of all trees 8" DBH or greater, reflectmg Size, canopy (dnp lines) and condition of such trees " " \ !;~~\ "/1 I~-urzlfl I) .:r____~u V~L:n,..,..I H LANDSCAPING PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Section 4-1102 A) o LANDSCAPE PLAN All eXisting and proposed structures Names of abutting streets, Drainage and retention areas including swales Side slopes and bottom elevations, Delineation and dimenSions of all reqUired penmeter landscape buffers Sight VISibility tnangle s, Dellneahon and dimenSions of all parking areas mcludlng landscaping Islands and curbing, Proposed and reqUired parking spaces, EXisting trees on-site and Immediately adJacent to Itle Site, by species size and locabons, Includmg dnplme (as indicated on reqUired tree survey), Plant sclledule With a key (symbol or label) Indicating the Size, descnpllon, speCifications and quanlllles of all eXlstmg and proposed landscape matenals, including botanical and common names, Location size and quantities of all eXlslln9 and proposed landscape matenals, Indicated by a key relatmg to the plant schedule, TYPical planllng details for trees, palms shrubs and ground cover plants Including Instructions, SOil mixes, backfilling, mulching and protective measures, Interior landscaping areas hatched and/or shaded and labeled and mterlor landscape coverage, expressing In both square feet and percentage covered, I'MY 1 R 2D04 I-=" f ~ L. - -. .-\,- , 1 s""< '" \1 vi ~ \ If .~11 Page 4 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Apphcatlon- City of Clearwater Conditions of a prevIous development approval (e g conditions Imposed by the Community Development Board), Irrigation notes o REDUCED LANDSCAPE PLAN to scale (8 Y2 X 11) (color rendering If possible), o IRRIGATION PLAN (required for level two and three approval), o COMPREHENSIVE LANDSCAPE PROGRI\M applicabOll as applicable BUILDING ELEVATION PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS (Section 4-202 A 23) ReqUired In the event the application Includes a development where deSign standards are In Issue (e g Tounst and Downtown Districts) or as part of a ComprehenSive Infill Redevelopment Project or a Resldentlallnfill Project o BUILDING ELEVATION DRAWlNGS - all Sides of all buildings including height dimensions colors and matenals, o REDUCED BUILDING ELEVATIONS - four Sides of bUilding With colors and matenals to scale (8 Y2 X 11) (black and white and color rendering, If J SIGNAGE (DIVISion 19 SIGNS I Section 3.1806) o All EXISTING freestanding and allached signs, PrOVide photographs and dimensions (area, height, etc ), Indicate whether they Will be removed or to remain o All PROPOSED freestanding and attached signs, PrOVide details including localion Size, height, colors, matenals and drawmg, freestandmg signs shall Include the street address (numerals) o ComprehenSive Sign Program appllcalion, as applicable (separate appllcalion and fee requ,red) K TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY (Section 4-202 A 13 and 4-801 C) o Include as required If proposed development Will degrade the acceptable level of service for any roadway as adopted In the ComprehenSive Plan Tnp generation shall be based on the most recent edition of the Inslitule of Transportation Engineer's Tnp General Manual Refer to Section 4-801 C of the Community Development Code for exceptions to thiS reqUirement L SIGNATURE I, the underSigned, acknowledge that all representations made In thiS application are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge and authOrize City representatives 10 VISit and ~otograph the property descnbed In thiS appllcatlon ----/'-- /j---' J , I' ;' > / ~lg9ature 01 perty owner or representative Timothy A. Johnson, Jr. STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINELLAS and subSCribed before me thiS loth.- day of A 0 20-.M to me and/or by ,J'r'l:!o is personally known 1m T pr d I~n ~~. Mltary pZ'bllc, My commiSSion expires ~ r .... -.....- ,- ..., ~~ --~-......... " I '-;.';;""'9' , Joyne E Sears -/' A Y::--. MY COMMISSION # DDO-iiD6o EXPIRES ~'" ~~: September 2, 2005 --'". 0' ,,&': IlO~DED IH~U WOY FAIN INSU~ANCE INC. 11'1" \f ,'I 1 r.; LUU4 Page 5 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Appllcatlon- City of Clearwater r- ....~ -"""'" -~ ~'"'i '--'""~ - ,~ , 1 I, '1 "d~ ~ It~ !~""ir, f""'l:u> ~ }~ tl "") ~ j ~\"Yf"'iB \.... J -..!l Lo"\. AFFIDAVIT TO AUTHORIZE AGENT Chr~stooher C. Mar~an~ (Names of all properly owners on deed - please PRINT full names) 1 That (I amfwe are} the owner(s) and record IItle holder(s) of the follOWing described property (address or general locatIOn) 193 Devon, Clearwater, Florlda 2 That this property constitutes the property lor which a request for a (describe request) Level One (flex1ble standard) approval for a dock 92 feet 1n length where 60 feet ~s peTIU1tted. T1mothy A. Johnson, Jr. and or 3 That the underSigned (has/have) apPointed and (does/do) appoint E. D. Armstrong III as (his/their) agent(s) to execute any petitions or other documents necessary to affect such petition, 4 That this affidaVit has been executed to Induce the City of Clearwater, Florida to conSider and act on the above described properly Page 6 of 6 - Flexible Standard Development ApphcatlOn- City of Clearwater 5 That SIte VISitS to the property are necessary by City representallves In order to process this application and the owner authorizes City representatives to VISit and photograph the properly described III this application, 5 That (1Iwe) the undersign ed authority. hereby certify that the foregoing IS true and, c,orrect '" /- (J , (' -;/::7:;/":" ......~/t ~t--G-._ Properly O'$mer Chr 1 s tophe r C. Mar 1 anl Properly Owner Properly Owner Properly Owner STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINEUAS .~- It. ./ day of Before me the underSigned, an officer duly commisSioned by the laws of the State of Flonda, on .~~:'" I)ll'~ I ~m~ 2004 personally appeared Chrlstopher C. Marlanl Deposes and says that he/she fu Ily understands the contents of the affidavit that he/she Signed My Commission Expires who having ~e~n it duly sworn -- / ~/-1~ Notary f&.bllc ,""';l\"~tl,j1; --, );,~y~~ TJ1l10111.". A. J(JJ.n:~!Ym_ Jr ~ "'.,........~ =~/'~*EGI}C1lr,)"'!lOn 'it f'C 5' j.-<Q61, ~5~' Aj~;: R\pl:~' J!llie 29 2r;0-1 ~ '" ~~ B! ' ~ fii;'f..w.... lon' edThr<l "lIull'''\: l'\.t1E1"'.....1C Ec"la.!~ Cc... .!t..~ 5 IPlanmng Oeparlmenf\Applr~a!lo" Formsldevelopment reVlew\flexlble standard development appl'caflon 2003 doc e--........~ , ... '\ r---:=.~ "."'~1)j .r"""3r:"'~Y ,J~ l....t";_ \ .., , Page 7 of 6 - FleXible Standard Development Appllcatlon- City of Clearwater 'll'>-o" ~i ~i I:>- uliiI ~ ~ ~ Q :< ,'" 7 X I,~ , ~ -'- "'- -~ m ~~ ~ :I: <:: 0 0 ~ <Em""U ~:.<O ~ 6 O~ tll Z CJ ;iI CJ (\ ~ ~ I o <~ Z rn lfI S ('\:r r)- ~AJ jUP ~Z nlCJ jUg 7\ -n r .c- UI Ul ~ ~ "'"-<I'" ~ : ~ ~ .. ~ ~ ill' ~~ 1~,.;IO(Q LaT~2 ~~ i1PJ"5..oo' Ha(J"~," "'>D<>3'< ,\"'t\ nl\ !~ d ?\ \ ! \ .lj \ O~~J(~ ~~ ~ """"""" L.IE QC\ ""'!j! i~ 1------- -- ,~ '-. , ~ ~ , f... ",LV ~.... ~j ...._\. 'l:J '1..-...... /l ~ .. ~ :! .. ., Countywide Appraisal Corporation 1201 So. HIGHLAND A VENUE SUITE #6 CLEARWA TER FL 33756 727"446"6550 727~446wB5B3 FAX WWW APPRAISE NET Lot 31 in Bayside Subdivision Devon Drive, Clearvvater FL Information report For: Mr. Christopher C. Mariani EXHIBIT "B" Countywide Appraisal Corporation REPORT FINDINGS Scope of 1m e~tl~atlon: To msptct vacant lot at. Lot 31, Devon Dl1ve. Bayslde SubdIvIsion" Cleal\v<:!tcl FIOlldcl to detelllllne II n pac I, 1 fall y of a plOposed doc k r ha ve personally mspected the above named vacant ~Ite, dnd have 1 ecelved a copy of the plOposed mallne dock plal1~, wlm.h I have also I eVlewed It I ~ my pI otess IOna I op 1111 on that th e pi oposed dock as descI I bed 1Il the p I an S da led Febwaty 3rd, 2004, (copy plOvlded 1Il tillS lepOtt), will not sIgnificantly Impdlf the value of the adJ'lcent land 01 bmldlllgs The ploposed doc"- plans ale well wlthll1 the halmony, scale, bul"-, coverage, denSity and chalactel of adjacent plOpertle<; along thiS stlcet and those wlthlll the Stl bd I v I SlOn The pro posed doc k w II I be eon S Iste n t \V Ith the com IllUllIt)' eha ractel 11l lh IS Ill1med late VIClIl1ty I have been applalslIlg reSidential Real Estate hele 111 Pllleltas County, full hme, SlIlce 1984 I am the owner of C ountywl de A ppl a I sa I COI pOI atl on IDeated 1 n C leal IN <lter, I have been a full tIme reSident ofClear\vater sme 1979, and recently leslded 111 the Clearwatel Beach <lIe,1 known as I s land Estates lam qUI te fa III II Jar \V lth rea [ estate va I ues a nd over d II mal k.et III terests III thl') watelfront community My qUclhfic.dtlOns ale attached S lIlCel ely Yours, 57~~ /Pl~~ AVC:u: e1U. CREA. eCI PreSident/CEO 'State Cel trfled ReSidential Real Estate Appl alsel #RD703 I?roQosed Docli Placement ~ 9 ~ --- ~ , .u ' , , s-: , 1) , , , , , ~ , I , . 1_______1 I__~__-~~ ~ ILl ~ ;Z: I :J ~ ~ / '.i \ l!l \ ~ II ltl 1? \ L <;> e""- " \ Elf'L '" 12' \ ~ " ~ \ ~ \ OXlMAn.: i! , l10N OF .. \ NoS> ~ IE-NCE \ -- " -- -- . -- .. l' , ~ 0 " I -- -- -- -- -- ...,J- ..... ~ "'1:1_ ---" ...IJ".l"..........mf'1 -- ]~r""" '" . ---- . ....... .. ~~"'i l!ii..cc ~~J GENTER UNI OF SE..AY'IAL 54-0" IOOCK '" 4D" SFI ----~ .. / \ \ , ~\\ _.<1//: __ - ~~~ ~~C1 ~- -- --~..""...~~. \?-?:/\--~---- - --.. -,,~~'--: \._-- _.- .- -- -- ~,,~~ "'''''' .. "'\ -- ------ -- - ~~~, q~' - -.-/ . -- -:~";:~~~ . ';\-\ _:~ -- .. - - ,"',::: :--:::.,,<-,~ - \ ^ \ '\....... ........ ........ "\ ...... - 1""'" ,>...-- <:' -.., '- <>,.)..,0- -- 0.............................. ~ .. - ~ ~'t..:.._'- <. ~ - - __ \.. Subject's Proposed Doca \ \ I I ~) i ,n --I ~ r1 \ \ ^ , IF ~14\ . I" , . , , I -, p i - I - j! ~"'- J ~'--: ..- - ----=1 r-- L I r- J ~ , Exlstl", AdJilce"t Dods i .0- Ob .O-Qb J_~~ .. '- '--: z: o ~ <.) o ....l ~I 61 , l.Uon !:(1- XI x~ Oij (l[ n...Q. ~~ - I ~ooooo U ~~ ~ lCIo1J..:J\IJ'fICI Ii ..g:gg:~:;:: ~n~r"ll') m mm[j)lDmm ~~5~~S~ ~i~~~~ ~~:~~8i I"11'T11'T1..,MM ~~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~2:m::;Q ~ p5i5~~ . 00 <;! L!'........IJlN > if: . ~ ~ . > ~ ~~ "'.... d'I ~~;;::'j~:; ~ !~ ~j ~ ~~S~~~ i ~:i:::j z ,=,01'-1 0 ~~~ ~~i ~!:!!!:!! ,ll~> ~~~ ~; i ~ o.....Jo. I"'l ~~~ ~ CI ~...... n ... [;D Q <) P.9l! ~"ll I:r'i i!IDl lim ~ f'~ J ilW. J '1;:11 'Iii', lilll , + + ~~ "(1) . ! I Ii -u 0 II 1m Ii . Z "'0 ~ " i1 i I '1 . "'0 fTl 0 " r ~ Ii ~ . ~ r I'" ~ " ~ . i en 0 'oil J> -< "' " ~ . :l: i' <- " r1 it 11 ~ II '" ::t ;:' V1 0 'Il g 01 I' 0(1)' I .- ":l -< i ~ '" ~ LJ I,r.... + '" @ ~ Ul n ~ t :<l 'l:: ~ "'0 ;;; ~ " 0 ~ i ~ ~ I ! i I ~ II z . ~ '" --< C :r ~ r !l 'I m il 0 C> >- I 'ij z _ " i(\ ~ ~ I! i :r z 1 ~Il ij: '" '" --l ~ i ! . -< ." I" ~ ! '" tHE-*- I!~ ! f ~ cO .... l EJ(!l0~ . . . A t.mrHu.:!'r AU a lIfic n. fltJlI ,... ~/11l ~ r:-nlfl'llJ~(l!I f":'"R It.... ("'(':1 , bnona1llndlgrpuntJ. S ta fF A IJIHal ser F londa Feder~ I S~Ylllgs BaNk ,SI P~Itr5burg, Fltrrldn April 1983 Tlltou~h March 1986 Soulh enS lern ft~~ I ESlate A DDrals~ I COlJloration - Sl Pnlersburll, Florida Mareh l!fa G Throullh Noyember 1991J F t!e A pprcdser , Pre.,denVCE;O Counlywlde Approlsnl Cl>rp\ltutl\ln - Cleou:water, Flol:'ida Ju I)' 1990 Throllgh Present P l"''C''I re.3:t';lnll:a] ot"f!RulzntlnI1S o ~ lell 0 lIuflL. National AssOclallotl Of Independent fee Appmims Appr" '" "llnstllU Ie N a t1 elils I Assot:lal[otl 0 r R~al E~late Approlsell Amerlcnn A~ade,"y Of S!al~ CertIfied Apprebers Nil (Ion a I Assoclallon 0 f Realtors National Assocmllon Of Reallors (AppraI5RISeclIOIl) FLorida Assoclal!i;1I1 or Reallprs Ass ocl atl on 0 f ConstrUellon 1l1Speclors Grealer C h:anvaler Assocmtlon Of Reallors Independent ree Appt1User' IFA (pendlllg) ~i1ole C~rtllied R~,ldelltl~l Apprnlser ~IUJ DDOIJ7DJ R~~blerd Real BsIDt~ Broker U 1)44556 Certl ned Reel llilsle Apprels!:r CMA Certllied Construction Inspectur Cel R~cel1l ~~I1lIIID IS .'It t'::nll rs~s T~ Iten Course 101 To AppraiSing Plepallng Ba3h: EnvlronmentallnspecUnns R~s Identlnl COl'Is!ru~ lion Prlnclplc3 & Practices I'rlllcl~les & Tel:hnlquD' or Apprnlsal R.evlew A Dpr~ Iser Certl ficlIllon ~ CA J , Pcrfennlng & M0I111t>rlng Construction InspectIons Prll1Llples & F'r.chces . Real Estate Btoker VelusUon Slrlltegles In Dlvo~e Prim;ip les & Pr~cl ices - Real Estate Salesmen ReviewIng Re5ld~nUal Apptnls~l, 1-10w The R~nl E.lnte Merkel Hns Chnnged YDI~e;! Approlllng Cllndomlnlums Appr<llsill RCl3ulatlOfls I Apprmers & Lenders Approising For Rclocollon Purposes Updale & R"Ylew OfTh" U RAR Form (lut) How To Be An E~llert Wllness Appraisal Fraud Prllgrllln Appml:llng Resh:lenllallllMrne l'rop~rt)' Environmental Assessmenls - AppraIsers RtJle UndmlB.ndlng T1n: USPAP Appraisers Liability U,lng 111~ Revised URAR FDtm (06-P3) PI ellurlng ReSldenllal Nmrative Reports MDllgBll1! Underwrlllng, ApPTll\501 Guldellnes AppraiSing Vacanl Land Huw !lnvlranmcnlol f'rob'ems Arreel ValUe Purpos e 0 f TI1 e Cost ApproBch In Res AppraIsals Legal Obllgohotl8 0 f Appr~imS' Construction lnspecllohS (Pre-Requl.llle for CCI DeSignation) Wbal bo Appral~crs Look Fl>r &. Why (I speke on Illla pon!! \0 GlIllnly Realhltll wllh FHA Chief Ap\lrnlscr Dnd COlin I)' f'roperty Appndser) , ., .!..ill;l or Anrrrn...ell ..liell!, P I ease ask [or ml>~ I cUrre.,t re v Ised list, (Ienglhy) Phil A Cous I neall, CREA, CeliS Ihe owner of"Counlywldo Appmlsal COtpotDtllln", Dud has been Rctlrely el1guged in the Real Eslate "Appraisal" Professlllll so]ely since 1983 The N allonal Assocmllon 0 f Real Estale A.ppmiseu, The Approlsallnstltule, The Slnll! Of Florida Certlticuficln Bou rd and The N ahonal Assoclatron Of Indepem:lanl Foe AllPT1l1w!l' all have mandatory tonlinu rng edllcal\~" programs for both ~ertlfied and designated member:; I hava been end cenllnue III h bolh deslgnn\ed and certified . 1tT...1'e 01' I'UJh1DA Al]l tl b 9 0 b 7 0- DJWAltTlmNT OF lft1l:1rnss ANV PRO"BSSI..o~'R~GlJLATION ..... - ~... II ~ RD703 -,~ -f)!j04~;:. 716D2:31U .. l~:r I ./ ~ ClmTrnEO: _lh:\!iX,QJt.UTJ:ML~Ii'RAIBl!R t:OtTSZNBAU'? .l,it;ubif~; Ie \ .r~tr. 1 t -; :'J~}' ~ ~ , ....1r Ii"it#<' .. _...J" l~rl ..'\.... ~ . ~ ~~~...~ STATE OF FLOI'\IDA Dep;:Jrllll~"1 of 9uslll\l"5S nlld Prl>to55lol1al R9yuMIlln fulunnlUft ~Fftl 'S'ftl~ Arl'HAlinL ~u , IJrn 'IOOlIlSOIf Sf lHLftllUU H J<aUi-on . , I g crll.~J:p:l:lUJ lInau u.. 1I"'&.-hh... d "h 4 7.!i .., bplnU~..d_hl "OY HI. 20Ut no ~ r;Ul1UoUIJ \. 100 WI ~d CO 00 tOOo/CO/CO ill ~ ----> "lJ $ ~ ij} }.1 x 500 ~~!J!1J ~ ~ 0 8QOg; (ii Z 0 ;Ii CJ (\ ~ }l I 5 <}l Z m- 8 (\ ~ r)> & ';/U \/I ~ ~f IJ '1& -0" -~ nJ8 ~j /U(\ .-() (\ 7\ *2 r -n "'). j r Ulnl \J 0 ~ ~ (\ 71 ~ ..,...,. -n ~ (; - JJ '" '" G 8 >" ~ ~~u !l~i ~~ ... 6 bO'-O" BJO rCJ 1. 0 T ;:!I:2 M;I(I""~ oIl"l'tiQC 1'10O""2224,., (1.1I' 1OO1YJ ~bSI~J<!1i~Y*;IlI ~-q~1...I.e l:'l ;; nil 'Q ~~ O~rt> ,. '>.. - , ~I -' t~j .: .. -- Sea grasses eXist seaward of the seawall at the subject property (See attached envIronmental report) The proposed dock Will lessen the Impact on sea grasses as compared with the dock that the applIcant can bUild as a matter of nght The proposed dock Will result In no navigational conflicts and the length of the proposed dock will not exceed 25% of the waterway By locating the proposed dock In the middle of the property, neither adjacent property IS unduly burdened The proposed dock meets the deviation cntena set forth In CDC Section 3- 601 C 1 9 r) and II), eIther one of which IS a proper basIs upon which to grant thiS application f ~ ~,..., ,"""-' ~~ 1'1'-" D- ~ 1 ,,~~ l~.j.t :'\~Yb,.~ \It ~ t~AY 18 2004 312608V1 ~ ....._n n,..." \_ r'trd:\OI.'-r.r-....., "jie' "'I ,.I ~ \ ~ 1 I.. I I )... I \,a ~ '1 1- rl~~' '.... -', . ,;'\\1'\ ....: rR ~ ~ ~ l' \ ... ~ I ." , .. EXHIBIT D SUBJECT: FROM: TIIRU= DATE: I PINELLAS COUNTY DEPARTlVIENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL MAl~AGEMENT WATER AND NAVIGATION REPORT Dock Preapp Chnstopher Manam Lot 31 Devon Dnve, Clearwater Susan Puolo ~ EnvlIonmental SpecIalist IT Department of EnVIronmental Management DavId L. Walker, Jr., Env. Program Manager~ Water and Navigation SectlOn '. Department of EnVIronmental Management November 26) 2001 The subject SIte was rnspected by tlus Department on November 8, 2001. PROJECT AND SITE DESCRJPTION: The applicant proposes construct a pnvate dock in the waters of Clearwater Harbor The proposed dock wIll conSIst of a 4 ft. x 86 ft:. walkout with a 26 ft. x 2.5 ft. catwalk. a 25ft x 36 ft. catwalk. two boat lifts, and a roof. The total area of the dock WIll be 499 sf. The waterfront WIdth of the property is 120 ft. The proposed structure will be located 56 ft from the east property line and 315ft from the west property line The total length of the st.n.lcture will be 86 ft. and the Wldtl-t of the structure Will be 325ft. The water depth wd! be greater than 5 ft (ML VI) at the end of the proposed structure. The WIdth of the navigable portlOn of the waterway at this locatlOD 1S approxrmately 570 ft. The structure extends a total of 86 ft.. 15 1% into the naY1gable watel"'Nay The shorelIne 1S seawalled at thiS locatIon Oysters (Crassosrrea vlrgrnlCa) are attached to the seawall Dense seagrass beds conslstmg of cuban shoal grass and manatee grass (Halodule wrrghlll and Synngodrum filiforme, respectIvely) are located offshore along the enUre property The seagrass IS located from I ft to 65 ft from the seawall In the area of the proposed dock No emergent vegetatIOn IS present on thiS property Wlldll fe observed dunng the field review tncluded a brown pelican (Pelecol1us occldenrol1s), cormorant (Phalocr-ocorax at/TIlliS), and great egret (CasmeroJws a/bus) \4-'/11 Fjeld conditions at tlus SIte were as follows. Depths at left sIde of proposed dock' Distance from seawall 0' 1 ' 4' 10' 20' 30' 40' 50' 60' 62' 70' &0' &6' Depth o 3' (0.1' ML W) 09' (07' MLW) 1.3' (1.1' MLW) 1.8' (1.2' ML W) 26' (2.4' ML W) 35' (3 3~J.w) 43' (4.1' MLW) 5.8' (5 6' ML W) 6.1'(59'MLW) 6.3' (6.1' ML W) Notes start of mod. sparse Halodule start of dense Hal very dense Halodule U.. Il" tc.. tc' t.t U u. oC.. ~~ ......-..-.-....-- moderately sparse seagrass v~rY ~arse seagrass no seagrass Depths at nght sIde of proposed lifts DIstance from seawall 0' 2' ..." .J 4' ~ 0' 20' 30' 40' 50' 60' 62' 65. 70' 80' 86' 90' Denth 02' (00' MLW) o 5' (0.3' ML '}..') 08' (0.6' MLW) 1 2' (1 0' MLW) 1 9' (1.7' MLW) 2.4' (2.2' ML W) 3 8' (3 6' MLW) ~-------.....--~----- -~- Notes a few pieces honzontal concrete nprap start of sparse Halodule moderate Hal dense Hal very dense Hal. u. t.t " -, '" " << ~, ~, ~--- -- _ end_?!jense seagrass __encLni all seagrass 46' (44' MLW) 5 -1' (5 2' ML W) 5 7' (5 5' ML W) end of ad] dock to nght (pates extend further), property curves to nght t s /rr;; Note Inner 10' (east Side) to 20' (west SIde) of roof and structure wIll be over dense seagrass Depths at nght (west) property hne DIstance from seawall Depth Notes 0' 02' (00' MLW) 6' 10' 20' 30' 40' 50' 60' 70' 80' , 90' o 3' (0 l' ML W) 01' (0 S' ML W) 09' (0.1' MLW) 1.5' (1 3' ML W) 21'(l9'MLW) 3 3' (3.1' ML W) 42' (.1.0' ML W) 49' (4.1' MLW) 55' (53' MLW) start of seagrass dense seagrass u.. u u u -t" Col. u u n U end of most seagrass Depths at left (east) property line DIstance from seawall Depth Notes 0' 03' (0.1' MLW) 1 ' start of Halodule (mod. sparse) .., dense Halodule J 8' very dense Halodule 10' 1 0' (0.8' ML W) " " 20' 1 6' (1 4' MLW) " " 24' SyrzngodlUm mixed m wIth Hal 30' 23' (2.1' MLW) mostly very dense Syrmgodwm 40' 3 l' (29' MLWO 50' S 5' (5.3' MLW) stIll some moderate seagrass 60' 58' (5 6' MLW) no seagrass 70' 6 S' (63' MLW) 80' 6 9' (6 7' ML W) 86 73' (7 1 MLW) rlolr7 : COMMENTS: Seagrass beds are located along thIS entire property, and extend out to a maxmmm of 65 ft from the seawall III the area of the proposed dock although It becomes sparse at approximately 60 ft It IS the polley of thIS Department to Jimlt structures over seagrasses to 4 ft. In Width and to place the termmal platforms and boat shps beyond the limits of the seagrasses wherever possIble. In the proposed locatIOn, the walkout would need to be lengthened by 10 feet to meet thIS cntena. The applicant IS adVised. however. that the proposed le~gth would be consIstent Wlth the environmental cntena of the Pmellas County Code If the dock were moved to the eastern SIde of the property where seagrasses end about 50 ft from the seawall. 2 The applicant IS also advised that It is the policy of thIS Department that all boat slips be located adjacent to the mam dock, and therefore one boat lift Wlll need to be located on each Side of the mam dock. FINDINGS: No findmgs are bemg Issued at this time pendrng receIpt of a formal applIcatIOn. The apphcant IS adVised that approvals for thIS prOject may alsooe reqUIred from the Flonda Department of Envirornnental ProtectIon and the U S. Army Corps ofEngmeers. Any modlficatlOns required by these agencIes must be reflected ill reVised plans submItted to the County. STR. S 1/2 8-29-15 mananle2.doc / r 7 1(7 , 1 ~~ ~,=:n p n l\ I"(~ r;""', r'(( ~~:Vl ~n' = iJ II ~,-" [l I ~~_-~ Co"" ~ -' \1 V \~_':l ~__/ t'lhY J K Ll'u I DIrect all correspondence 10 Clerk of Water and Navigation Control Aulhonly 315 Court Street Clearwater, FL 33756 Apphcallon # PLA~~~\U' --- \"" ~-', . "\ r.'-'\'T r~l'.J \.....JJ _ '11 II. j C:ITV OF r:! ~'::~r . /--: ~R (OFFICIAL USE ONLY) PRIVATE DOCK PERMIT APPLICATION PINELLAS COUNTY WATER AND NAVIGA liON CONTROL AUTHORITY Please type, or hand print In BLACK Ink I. PROPERTY OWNER INFORMATION: A Applicant's Name Mr Chris Marrannr B Mailing Address 310 live Oak Lane City Largo State FL Zip 33770 C Telephone No (s) II. AGENT INFORMATION: A Name Ress Manne Construction Company B Address 435 Woodlawn Avenue City Bellealr State FL Zip 33756 C Telephone No (s) 446-2945 III. SITE INFORMATION A Construction Site Address 193 Devon Dnve City Clearwater State Fl Zip 33767 B Parcel 10 Number PARCEL # 08/29/15/04914/000/0310 C Incorporated fKI Umcorporated D Clearwater o Affected waterbody Clearwater Harbor E PrevIous permits none F Date applicant assumed property ownership monthlyear G Obstructions (dogs, fences, etc) N/A H Attach 8 - 112" x 11" vlclnrty map shOWIng specific project location (Attached) I All other Information pu rsuant to P C 0 90-19 (amended), Section 10 8, as needed J For projects reqUlrl ng a pu bllc heanng, attach a copy of the complete legal descnptlOn D48/WD/arl/ENVMGMNT/PrAAdl 4126/94 lna}J\,,(U"'::O~ lnay::o YIIIIl rl1gc I 01 1 - v "1~~E5't : ~~. The 2004 Entertainment@ Savings Book is Here! ~ Send To Printer Back to MaR. 193 Devon Dr Clearwater FL 33767-2439 US Notes: 'ei:s' Gel Savings Up to S{tD!... Ofll Almost Evervwhero "'fi:!:J" $1 0.00 Off! "~" FREE S'hlppntg! f:;:--MA~Il~f;'5~'" ~. " I' " I" !,~ l I r , " ~'l i! ,.. I [ql <' ':3oom ~~~ '. ) " ...-) " t I~i~ \:5': > " li~' i .... , a.: ~ J., -" III "':. " "~I , !', . 'r t ' I. ( "., r \ ~ I F ('il) ~""" . I I , , I ~ ; Jol-- .... ." ;. :- r",," '). II " J ' " >, 1 " k " . { . '^'- ,. , , - ., , "I [I, " , , " "'/:!:" \ ~....... ;..... !' , ~ ' , .' f , '{!r , " ,. "i\.." = !> \ ~ <J ~ ." t' c, f f' ~ IV " ".1 'h.(}~ ~ " ~ ~t " .., I ....,,1''' >' , ~ \>' '" ~ " ' c. I....) t ~ , ..,.....n 't ; _ 1 -," 1< , " p. ~ _h -i , , ',- .'l" { ,- " ' ""/! l) '" " "" ~ ~ ,. .-;6 1 (L~l.. , , ", \~ ,,~l~ h~ f ...,v' ""Ir'" .f All rlahts reserved Use Subject to lIcense/CoDVrlQht I ~end ~^V-r~<:;f J n-.. ...y--.~~ This map Is Informational only No representatIon Is made or warranty given as to Its content User assumes all risk of use MapQuest and Its suppliers assume no responsibility for any loss or delay resulting from such use Privacy. PoliCy': & legal Notices @ 2004 MapQuest com, Inc All rights reselVed http //www mapquest com/maps/pnnt adp?mapdata=bLaOkxtG3xs72QcY6LF%252f6wWt 3/10/2004 Appllcatlon# OFFICIAL USE ONLY) DISCLOSURE FORM In order to alleVIate any potential conflict of Interest with Plnellas County staff, It IS reqUIred that the Authority be prOVIded with a listing of PERSONS being party to a trust, corporation, or partnership, as wetl as anyone who may have beneficial Interest In the application whIch would be affected by any deCISion rendered by the AuthOrity (Attach additional sheets If necessary ) A PROPERTY OWNERS: Name Address Chns Mananm 310 Live Oak Lane Largo, FL 33770 Name Address Name Address Name Address B REPRESENTATIVES Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Address C OTHER PERSON HAVING OWNERSHIP INTEREST IN THE SUBJECT PROPERTY Interest IS contingent D absolute ~ Name speCific Interest held D. DOES A CONTRACT FOR SALE EXIST FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY? YES NO X If so, the contract IS contingent D absolute 0 Name of parties to the contract E DOES AN OPTION TO PURCHASE EXIST FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY? YES NO X Name of parties to the option F OWNER'S SIGNATURE I hereby certify that the information stated above IS complete, accurate, and true to the best of (/ my knowledge ~ X dff/:.-(7 ~ ~ · Dale '-fIe; D i I , D48foNDfarl/ENVMGMNT IPrAAd54126/94 PRIVATE DOCK MHWI.... MLWY BOTTOM -------------- ---- ENG. SCAl.E: I" ::: "2..0 \ \ \ \ \ ~~~ ' \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ 6~ ~ Application # (OFFICIAL USE ONLY) I II II I II ~! -- - J =- ~---I~I_ _ - ~E-= - -~1-~- -- ~lFI - -- --- , ' I I ~ I~ Ii ~ ,j I Profile View . 13' TIl.' t ! TOTAL SQUARE FEET NEW SQUARE FEET WATERWAY WIDTH WATERFRONT WIDTH Co~ I f { { I 'P-! I I / I { ~ '-188 '-189 51D I :l..O A: 3~B B ' I~Y 1~1 c: 3'~ --'18 g (::30 ' Plan View (applicant and adjacent doc s) I.I'-I"I...I).:~ I'I~ ',. 77 A The undersIgned does not object to the proposed dock and requested varIances as drawn In the space prOVided above Left Owner Right Owner '-I -- SHORELINE Signature Date MumClnalitv Annroval Signa ture Date Water and NaV1oratlon Annroval _ _ _ _ _ ..-~ __........oa...o Schodtler, John To Subject M Battle RE FLS2004-05028, 193 Devon Dr , Clearwater, FL Mr Battle, -----Or1g1nal Message----- From M Battle [ma1lto.maxsm1les2004@hotma1l com] Sent wednesday, July 07, 2004 8 02 PM To Schodtler, John SubJect FLS2004-05028, 193 Devon Dr , Clearwater, FL Dear Mr Schodtler Attached 1S Chr1stopher attachments they are 1n my letter to you on behalf of the Sobolesk1s who oppose Mr Mar1an1'S above referenced Appl1cat1on The letter and all referred to there1n were faxed to you today please be sure that the F1le Maxwell G Battle, Jr -- 1 07/07/2004 18 25 00000000~~ LAW OFFICE PAGE 01/14 FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION COVER SHEET Battle & Edenfield, P A 206 Mason Street Brandon, FL 33511 (813) 685~3014 TO: John Scbodtler, Development Review Specialist FROM: Maxwell G. Battle, Jr. DATE: 07/07/2004 FAX #: 727-562-4576 RE: 193 Devon Drive; Application of Chris Mariani Number of Pages Including Cover Sheet: 18 I X] The ongmal of all documents, includmg correspondence, bemg transmitted herem are bemg forwarded to the above named addressee thl s date [ J The ongrnal of all documents, mcludtng correspondence, bemg transmItted herem have not been forwarded to the above named addressee by regular US Mall, but have been retained in our file THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS FACSIMILE TR.Al'fSMISSION IS ATTORNEY PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION INTENDED ONL Y FOR THE USE OF THE INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY NAMED ABOVE IF THE READER OF TI-liS MESSAGE IS NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT , YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED THAT ANY DISSEMINATION. DISTRIBUTION, OR COPY OF TInS COMMUNICATION IS STRTCTLY PROHIBITED IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS COMMUNICATION TN ERROR , PLEASE TMMEDIATEL Y NOTIFY US BY TELEPHONE AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE TO US AT THE ABOVE ADDRESS VIA THE D.S POSTAL SERVICE THANK YOU. PLEASE CALL (813) 685-3014 or (406) 270-5336 IF YOU DO NOT RECEIVE THE CORRECT NUMBER OF PAGES 07/07/2004 18'25 000000001i10 LAW OFFICE PAGE 02/14 BATTLE & EDENFIELD, P.A. ATTORNEYS AT LAW MAXWELI.G BATTLE.JR. ALSO ADMITUO COLORADO l'"EW MEXICO flORIDA 206 Mason Strol:! Brandon, FL 33511 n.L (813) 6R5.3014 .Tuly 7, 2004 John Scnodtler Development RevIew Speclahst Planning Department Municipal SeMces Buildmg 100 South Myrtle Ave, Clearwater, FL 33756 Re: 193 Devon Drive; Lot 31; Application of Chris Mariani for Flenble Development Standard Approval; FLS2004-oS028 Dear Mr, Schodder 1 represent James and Deborah Soboleski who own the residence to the immedIate West of Mr elms Manani's lot (Lot 31, 193 Devon Dnve) for wlucb the above applIcatlon was submitted My chents are vehemently opposed to Mr Mariam's request as 11 is now constJtuted I wnte to ask that the Development Review Committee meetIng presently scheduled for July 8, 2004 at a time and locatIon not disclosed In your <'NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004 be contlDued to a date not earlier than August 5, 2004 and that you fe-nonce the meetm~ specifvmlZ the TIME. LOCA nON and DATE This request is based upon Due Process consideratIons and the fact that your 'NOTICE" does not comply With procedural dne process requirementS or the requrrements of the Community Development Code because It does not specify the Ttme, Date and LocatIon of the mcetmg whlle the Code speaks in terms of"substanttal competent evidence" bemg prov\ded pnor to, OR AT THE MEETING ISo does the '<NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004] Without [air and proper notice, the Soboleskis W1Il be derned procedural due process The legal doctrine of procedural due process is the means by which our legal system msures that baSIC farrness is afforded all whose substanttve ngbts are at issue Key's CIUzenS for ResponSIble Government. Inc , 795 So 2d 940 (Fla 2001) It restricts the means by w111ch agencies .of our government reach deCISIons that adversely affect 07/07/2004 18'25 000000001'10 LAW OFFICE PAGE 03/14 . . both the liberty of and the property nghts of our people County of Pasco v. Riehl~ 620 So 2d 229 (Fla. 2d DCA 1993) The FlorJda Supreme Court has clearly stated that: Procedural due * * '" process requires both faIr notice and a real opportunity to be heard "at a meaningful tune and in a meanmgful manner" Key's Citizens. supra, @ 948 [citing Mathews v EldridlZC, 424 US 319,333,47 LEd 2d 18,96 S Ct 893 (1976) Unless the Comm:umty Development Meeting referenced In your "NOTICE" dated June 17, 2004 IS rescheduled and properly noticed. It 15 clear that my Chents will not be granted eltber " fall" nonce or a real OpportuXHty to be heard at a meamngful tlme aud in a meamngful manner" In the event that you proceed vvith the Development RevIew Comnuttee meetmg on July 8, 2004 I also wnte to ask that you extend the tune for my ClIents to provIde you WIth substantlal competent eV1dence and that the Planning Director refram from lssmng a decu;loll on Mr Manam's request untIl at least August 5, 2004 to allow us tIme to provlde you with a.dditional mforroation wh1ch we bel1eve will be helpful to the Clty in reaclung a fully mformed decision The reasons that we need tlus add1tional time are: J) I was JUSt retained by the Sobolesk1s \Vlth respect to thIs Appl1catlOll because the Applicant had been discussmg a settlement with Soboleskls and did not adVlse them that he would not agree to delay the ApphcatLOn process \ll1ttl July 1, 2004 The Fourtb of July weekend mtervened and I Just returned to my Out of State Office Accordingly, I have been tmable to review tbe City's file ObVIOusly I !leed some time to reView and fully dIgest the file and respond to the contents thereof, and 2) We Wish to provlde you with a graphic pictonal representation of what Mr Manam's proposed dock W111 affect the view from the Soheleskts property as well as conduct a water depth and manne vegetation survey of the area contIguous to the Applicant's seawall and proVide that mformatlOll to you as well ThIS requires actual field surveymg and photography as well as a substantJ.al arnOW'll: of computer work to generate the vIsual models, and 3) We need time to assemble plctonal eVIdence of how the proposed project wIll affect the character of the neighborhood J hope that g1Ven the depth of OPPO'litlOn to Mr Mariani's applIcatlOn that you can grant us the additional time. I would not ask for the additIOnal time If I did not truly beheve that it was necessary to proVIde the addItIOnal mformation and visual tools to you and that thIS mformation would have an effect upon your deCISIon 2 ~7/07/2004 18 25 000000000'" LAW OFFICE PAGE 04/14 Wlule we are workIng diligently to prepare and submIt the above informatIOn to you, I felt that It would be appropnate to address several Issues miually These comments follow, First, I am concerned that you do not yet have a complete applicatIOn. It appears to me that the Section 4-202 . Commumty Development Code requires SubsectIOn A, 12(e) that structural overhangs and bwtdmg heIghts be depIcted The Apphcaot has reportedly commumcated to my Chents and hls companion Kymm KIdwell that be lntends to cover the dock and boats bps as depIcted In hIS prevIOus Apphcation No. 02-01-03: and Subsectlo-n A.24 appears to require detaIled plans and speclficatlODS prepared. sIgned and sealed by a Florida RegIstered Professional Engmeer It docs not appear from your NOTICE dated Tune 17, 2004 [BUT MAILED SUBSEQUENT TO JUNE 21.2004 that either a plan depIctlI1g the structural overhangs or detailed plans al1d speCificatiOns sIgned and sealed by a Flonda Regtstcred ProfesslOnal Engineer bas been submitted The Plan glvcn to my Chenis by the Applicant [Copy attached] Wlth a rcpresentatlon that It was the plan submitted does not meet tbese cnteria 1) 2) The Appl1cant's need to exceed the length and dimensional standards arises not from any mescapable or unreasonable hardshlP, but rather from the Applicant's deSIre to place lus dock out of his SIght and 10 that of my ClIents By placmg the Dock m the ml ddle of his Lot, Mr Mariam creates a sItuation where the water depth j s too shallow at the allowable length of approxImately 60 feet If Mr Manam places the Dock further East adjacent to the Blum's property [Please note that Blums dtd not obJcct previously to this locatton m rcspondmg to Mr Mariam's pnor Appl1catJon No 02-01n03]. the water depth appears to be of sufficIcnt depth that the extra 32 feet would be unnecessary The shortenmg of the dock along wlth ltS movement to the East would save the Appltcant substantIal money and ptovlde a morc envIronmentally comcious end product due to a decreased shaded area of sea bottom and a deeper water depth beneath the dock footprint, both ofwluch enhance the growth and survlVabJlity of sea grassesl The proposed length and configuratIon of the dock will destroy the scernc view from the Soboleskls' property, WIll have a negaTIve impact upon the value of the Soboleskis' property and can not conceivably enhance tbe value of the either the SoboleskIs' property or the surroundt11g property Smce these negaTIve Impacts can be aVOlded at a savmgs to both the Appheant and the Envrronment. it seems clear that the ApplIcation vlolates [and IS intolerably mco:osistent W1th] the precepts of Code SectlOn 1- 103, Part T, Commumty Development Code ] Shadmg the sea bottom Imposes a ;;;gmfil:aTlt T1egatlve Impact on sea grasses dependant upon photo:>ynthes15 Deerea:>mg the ~haded 31 ea and mcreasing the heIght above the grass from wh lch the shade emanates increases the light transmitted to the grass 3 07/07/2004 18 25 0000000fi""liJ LAW OFFICE PAGE 05/14 It 1$ also mStroct1Ve to note that the dock length and configuratIOn proposed by the Appl1cant appear to clearly Vlolate the provJSlons of Page 2, Paragraph 8 of the Restnctlve Covel1ants recorded at 0 R Book 860, PG 51,52, Public Records of Pm ell as County, FL T also call your attention to the fact that a sub~tantIally SImIlar Apphcabon was prevIously filed by Mr Manaru last year, to WIt - Application No. 02"'()1"'()3. That ApplIcatIOo was ultlmately derued after being reversed by the CIrcu,t Court of Pmellas County Then It appears that upon request of the ApplIcant, that the denIal was resemded after the tIme for appeal had expIred There seems to be no prOVlSlon m the Commumty Development Code for the Planrung DIrector or any other Clty OffiCIal to alter, amend, or rescmd deCISIOns rendered on Level One ApphcatIOns and certamly not after the time for appeal has explred Thereforc, I suggest to you that your office IS WlthOut JUIlsdIctIOn to entertam, much less grant, th~ I?resent ApplIcation Fmally, T ask that you take OffiCIal notIce of the entIre file [mcluding W1thout limItatIOn all Items HI the Appellate File) from Mr Manaru's preVIOUS Application No. 02-01-03, incorporate It into and mclude it m the record on the present Application. As you can see from the foregomg bnef comments, there are many chsputed Issues that I need to address for the Soboleslas I hope that you Wlll either reschedule the presently scheduled meetmg, and falhng that. agree to grant the adchtlOnal tune for my Chents and I to respond further pnor to reaehmg a deCISIon VerytrulY~YOUrs, __ ~-~~ /.. .".-TJ......'11 ./ Maxwell tr--i3-;ttle, Jr Cc James and Deborah Soboleski 1\ttaelunents . . Notice Dated J1Ule ] 7,2004 Manaru Letter dated July), 2004 Manam purported Dock Plan Restnctlve Covenants, 0 R Book 860, PGS 51-56 PublIc Records, PinelJas COtmty 4 .07/07/21l~ 18.25 00000000V11i1 LAW OFFICE PAGE 06/14 PAGE 132 07/02/21304 14:12 8136845922 BATTLE & EDENFIELD Jul 02 04 01:~3p DEBORAH So80LESKI 127 466 S4S5 . -J1.ft-i'!3-2eiM 1C!:S~ ~ 'F'ERlUlO'l Ton 442 S47IlI P.l'a1 . ._ ~ PLANNING D:KPARTM~NT ')IlIJNIClPAL snV1CBS Bll1lJ)tN(t ~ 100 SOUlltMYJ,TLEA'VENUE, CLBARW'ATER;ft.OPJDA337,6 ~ en1) 5624SlS7 FAX: (727) 5624S1G WWW.MYCLURWATER..COM p.2 Jv:t1e 11 J 20M d= l'I1Iaflo; OJI FIL1NQ 0'1 ~ A.PPlJCA'11ONJi'OR n.1XDILE S'tANDABD ~ APPB.OVAl. AT 193 pJ:YON:D1l f;l'X.SZOI)4..GSO'JI) , , ~ To ~fJ:op::ItJo.mem: AI ~m!DI!rafiUn2fip' ti:eUk'.9l nEvoNDlt. dl.aggat~~~ ~ DPt;it:a "-11I1 applieBdOb b- ~lc stIIIdl:a:d. ~1IW..."n11O~ the Ie:qth or.. dock fnml60 8:d (SO p:rt2Dt. t41b 'Width oCtile 1M1oI1t'~ t;:() W 92 fi:d CTG.6 pera:ml ontJe. width of the ~1DIIrthe~ot~!-601.. 0Il11l!y 08, 2004. tae ~J.ope-M R.ericnf 0 '11-"']"'- (~ of the eifJ's ~""41lA1l11afi) will ~ smd &lb4...- ~'4le apptiodnn ~...~t4.mnl!l wllb 1be CitJft e..:.:..~...ai~ ~ c:ode. FoUOWi:b8 _ milm" 11I4 dt;l>..ft'Il~=.. the PlIDPiDg DiDcWJr wiD iuae 8 ~..--4 ~ iIIppIoV"ia.I, q;pmjDI1Vi'lb f'1\ftdI~l'WtI\ t;fr deI:Dytug - ~ tho eatliell: 4D; a. me CiIy'"-1JIII3ke A ~ 011 tIle.~ 1riIl be Jc\y 08, 2004. 11= CitJ' _";lW'-' yr1G to parIicIpdc ill _ ~ at\tU apJlil::IIIi& Yo..., c:md8Ct_ It 727..S62-4604<< J~~"dtb. ~ fbt~~ viJIlOWoftlctUlu:YieW .. ~ _ .tbeil.ll&-.4I..~PIltmto.k~.,;., _e~:bJ._C(~gf~1klISiao..._.-' .--- __"'~ .~IIe~"" ~-maar\?'~t ~ W-~ ~'~''''I t1ri1lLc:llD8;. "fIblch )'UlI1IIII)' ~ daribS repIsr ~ 1aIm. ~. AD fb:rt'h!:r JlDt1.ar wiJ1 he pI'09icW.lD Jon abaII1d dzc: 2Ip(l'JiCCd:iea be ~ AD appeal oftk ~.~ ott1le PIlaJabIg Dilector may"- iai$tlId 'by" .oprr.oant ar ~ mmeo widIiIl t;be ~ Datlcc ..,. wh9presem_"",1wl ~ ~at, QI' priorto, ibe Deve10pment RtMew Comnu2O ~ val1l1y 01. 2004. M IIfpaII tmIlJt be: filed, ~ aD eppea1 ~ with the PJIIlJIJiIlg DepartmctW'itWD.K1ICQ'" of1be dm: ofdm ~ Or<<kr, '1'baIt: )'Dll1br)'OVt~ ita the Citt of~8 ~1I'Yie:Wpruc=& Y(ftl11/iA'1 acaeu 01l: ~ D\Fya(--.4. ~ ihe CitY! WbsifIl: W'IV'W~.emn. ~::l' ;ri~.~ ~)'MD, \ ,'" A ~(, (111 I,. . '1.AV"'\"'(:..L~ , J~ SobodIler lkr~~~ . ~ - , . . " .07/07/2004 18'25 00000000lilC9. LAW OFFICE BATILE & ErnlFIELD 07/02/2e104 14; 12 8136645922 SOBDLESkI 7~7 -4SS G4ElS . J u 1_. ~~..,~" P.. ~ =}~.e. .....,P.,~~v~RFlH lWHA.9-lJA5PBAJ.JaSEAL ' .. e_a...m a.ria.ni il5aSllphe.lt c~rnpEl.ny -- 1120'I ~MfC. . P..o, """ ~ . '1ItlIIpa. A. ~ . p.,. \l1ll) RlI4M1 . Fn '''3) B:!lIo4'1D Jqq 1,2004 Ml\'. ,At. Mm. Samet w. &tlloleski J'l~rt~ ~,..dtg.fL 331S6 D= Deltbic ad. JiI:a.: Kyimnd l_~tImt,oa.. ~~ wcn.dd &b. ,.,h<etbll ~~ fiJ:RbIr .IegIaI Q;ICt, It. ~ thIr 11ft: lMve finIod SIll\tftC Q:)~ ~ a first *'P ~rQD~ We l8lftI SIll! &......~ ~ .. -~ GppIioalba _ per J01W 1Cl9,ue:st. I Vftll!J Q:tJd by~ dm)'tKI did fIlIt8tve it. We w:DI Jmt lip W)'GIII' teqDC 1hIt "' ep:e ill writiu:g tbmt 1IO ClOWf'MJllld' m::r be p.IBeed 0" 1M' boar ~ .IE 10 do Sl:l "lIIUIIJ4 (lO~ a.~ of. ~~t,).'" ~ we 'IlIIIY 1DQCh~. J:JBIi:DS 10 dIIQJ5s opdom:. _ tIE 11 __ b-us ami WI:I ~ i'i..dtIr.anag 19 p.~ any IIteJmIc - da- JrzI,r,,-, Werespe;t,..-DJqtlC& &JrdraMrqp iQ.~ _ ~t&at illwb..<J..ng iIr ..~ otdcsJp aIloaJd be ~.fIlee w fitee ft) ~ this IIIIImf ~. A quick. dr!cilIbl is DOt req~ on )'Wtpedaud "'= Ilawl m ~. f1f ODe. l'hM:III:id. ~..~~ tbe IIppHaltiolll;matsa wW caotimre 10 mow .tOtMp1 W~ oko emwn sgrce wbb)'Qtlr ~ 10 .ifl!dul\lo' owlpJll~ as a ~ltion.ro Q8l ~ 1f"M! IIIIDdI &I@JICIDw4 ~ wUI ~ tile appJiaBtkm to ~ 0lIl' '"5'0~ rt)oa dcctJie..1DII!lt 'IIrith Q!l: __ WIl ..irMl- 0Dr~ dim WI! wm JIIOCCCIlf witb 01a' pial as Sb'tllaiDd, ~ mil ~ tbIt this WOIIfd lie. m.m.te ~ Q. """-.I"'0QlIse to this lDiUc't.y 'I;wl wflbmImOh. It is in oar ~ - mresz IQ X1!ISOJwe tllfJ 1llIDtr. 'Wo 8ft!! ~..4 to .IJ;I:Cd; yua on JaJy 11"W'eIIIiic ~wm bemQO.:Dllt~,oo to ~t'-l!dd place ~ of Q;I~}VII. Olfl toadll!lftiler Om q'US ta4ay'or emit the ""'..d..:Q:I by oeD pbom (!t)'Dl:D'J,- ?27.5W.9tiG" Czri5.. 727.422.1021). .r:..",....1 G.dl.7~ a~"~. R,('~ ~~ Chris :M.iua PAGE 07/14 PAGE El4 p.4 fll Gill! I. I - - a ;; ~ > EO" eB :3E)\1d 171/80 39l;7d illlOIL'l 99ir9 9S. L~L al3I~ '8 31ll'V8 381.::1.::10 Ml;7l "WIQIlI!I!l1'W1WClrTW"," IltAI"KlI'....'. """" iAf'J~J"" ~.~ IXS310S0S MW~OKaa GE1:tD ~D ao tnr ~Z6St7age18 tt'pl pB0~/~BIL0 111100000000 96 81 17006/L0/L0 07/07/2004 18 25 ~ebor.h Sonol@ski ~Q) D._ O.a uca .. .. IID.!l.l cnfa ~~ 00000000vHij PAGE 09/14 LAW OFFICE le4782.490:. .~,.z . . '<~' !llf$h~U ... -.. ~1.~ Q t tj~~-""~..~r'" ,., "t>"~il\';,:f,...~...,... r ,\{.~~\, I 1ll ~. ........ ~~:..,./I ~(' J/' "'III'\~.IlJ' ~I: \.r I !;J ..:......""1 ~ - """"" r II s.t~~!!>~l':" '~'. '1 ~.- ,~...~~~~"'",-t fI' -- .....nwPJ. )' "'~ ~,~"'l"4I ,.~- ) I }. .. ClOtIm'J"Q7~.) I J:J1Gi' ~ , . .;,.... , zku:t W. 11m B1' '1l'1t3P.: I'I~ '11r41'1 ~. till. tllO ~er- ....1 ~ _ ':J ' ! ~ \ .. 1I1gM4. ue tho Ollll.Grll of 'toM ~poriy b. !.\.YSIDS Smm:Vmall. 1:114 ~p- " t t40~' tIolM ~,ot 111 PD:l':tWi catn:rrr. lIT.O'IlIJ)A, ~ _" P>rl1~ Mlll-- ~"!tt- ~ ~I 'rI~ . ~ \ l ~ ' l~~,1" orlW u tI;lUr:nm: ' , I ..r.~rI':,,"~....:~, ~ 4 ... = ," ,<,10\:..\1 'to '03 1::Io1ul.... C Ba:t1l1411 SII~:l:1T1I1J.oD. o.ocwdUlc to map ~~~ }.U,~ \01'" l'lAt -tbeNOt ,.oGW11e4 1n n~t nt.o.l: 23 o.t. ~II 11 ot ntl J'lC.U1tl , '': \' __td" at l'.l.QI!11.DII CClUDt,.. )'lorl'lllh ~\ (' I~" ~ . , III ~f. ': ,; :J'" ''WBilf:A!I 1IO t]w ~D or ,bo o.boyo otoller1bDol properU." IIJ"ll ~ ..w~ 4'.... ,. I ,(~~A.., 1::. I Iii! a , ...o.c' '4G'1r_ (It :pl.D.a1n~ ad.J.lt1_1 NlltriOU l>reI uu tM "'0 \It a.u14 proP":M:1 rw jf ~ I 4"'~ . I~ r"1o!ct;1~ pll'PO'702~ i ,,'I ,.. i l " < I,., " 'l:J1!r:::;7'OR! 'i'l!t..;: ~~ ~~l ':but t!:.ot plU"tl~ ta tll,l.lI 1 ~,~ ~ ~ I .. r ~""'''D', rur.- d 111 OO:llllllono.l.lon ot 1.l111 :-,..l'lUw. OO'tC2llUlh bomlt.n CO.llU.1l1.e:I, lri: ~r- ~ , , , -, , " , ~ . # n:u:! tho tIU''t''''~ <:O..."td"ftltl..... fA Q.,lQ I>~Ul>r U1.col 111, b >lil.<l ~d ~ o~,,~ (,r tha ~rt.lo~ 'to 1.1", "~lor, 'the no\Ol:11: IrIlt..ro~r b }:crf:l'.' .lCl"..lIOWlo~'OIi!. 10M . I .:... ~",-," for I>'t~ D;!<;oll 1olIt,l mu.:.l>l.. clm...l~1l.e-"'1.1wl:il. Ila 1.l!1'l:1'1 ~""J l\cr<'l~ e./I"ll:lIl.:It lllIo4 W$I'Q., :ce loll" tl.lo ..:tI,...t', :1J1" ,......1>..1......" IJIjI' 11'.11':1, 'Illeoo'MM. !Iss1c:;n!l .!I/l;\l. ~.zal t'ttPl'O.,(llItntlTc.., l:'w.1. U:! tl' ; .111 r ....;>CIr1.~. ~1'" <<o:::ol"l 'betl, "1'0 I , tollOOl:l,!-~ """'tl"lct~"~ 'IrQ h'lli'OIq 111 ,c"'"' I'J"''' "ur n~Il11"U't'(l ll.:tJ,.!,ll'.o ~ \ , ' .~~ ~t;lWl nil bo\I.rnIu.r1"" IoWvO d"::~rl't.u.l: 1: l.u 1O'tl> 1:1 ~ll" h'lIot =1,~n to.. k:l.m.lt ADd W1:1CrlbiI:<J '''" ro,ll1$n.. t.l.o.l 1at,. I 0;0 .JtJ:'<l O~l'" ..1'lIlt lxo iJol"OlI1.a<l, I;IHl! l'd, .1,1,,"04, U' ro.....:t.ue<i to . rwr.:oJ.lI OIl. ~ .l",I.lJ.<I"l!.Uo.l 1"'.11i11l1_ ll<lt o:.'UI<)J;' tLILl <>110 ,(Iot(ool,e.:l ,111C18-!:IJ111.7 ~Wllll 01' enb'<U\l. nut !,o CW:~ ,",0 ,tol'lol1 tQ. 1"'lOat '.04 U pl'1vate ~ lID4 nOO<lUmq ,,<;or1'\llIt':I or~Qr't Ii1' II "UII:h ~ Ut tho 1l'b.11l dl'lOl UA:::. ii, 1;:u lOot or- lot II ..: tlth ~",ct .'I1uU .it lID;' "I::!:lo ll<) ft4Wl1'll1!o1 a", *<old OXe<ll'~ "..<II, l.lI~ .... .. 'tftl,,""', """ ~blI.ll bll C1"o(lOll, \5'J.1.h ="'to'nl'nCO to thlll !.:I!lp l!1' Jlht tllCl.no~ .euo:aJ'll.od b1l'lut .800.0: E, at ~ l!,. of" tho l'U.~llo ae.eo:M~ at J'1Iw]J.a,1I OI.'\Ill.Qr. 'Ilona, W t. th.1.11 t'OlJtzo1etJ.(.oil a2lQl1. lI.Ot P1'V'nin-' the ClrIl.etr h'aIlI CODTlIYlA:;: UJ p<V't ot 11I..14 lc:.~ 01' 1<>1.0 1=0 'tIIo ~ fit tli" . ' , culJolda.s 1.q\.s. '- ~"" ~ t. .. ~ , " r . " l ..r' '\. .,....' ~~ .. l.. ".,..1", 1 I w..&... ..l....,~~ ~~__.. 1 , ' ~~ --...... .. -!IIItIoll4&_....... , ..........-.11.......- , , '. "..1 n , u 1"t.... l , " I -' ~~ ... ,L l~ ~~...~~c,:r..)"_ ...,;; ~Iro--.J"W__ ... , _~.;... 'J .07/07/2004 )\G) D._ 0-'2 U~ - ..... .- U)~ :~ 18 25 0000000P~" LAW OFFICE p.~ PAGE , /L..~'D.' "~ -. \ ,..'1 Gc.'~~ l.' .....1'.1 '-'1tii. , I, :o.bW"l.r.'/ol~ ~ '\Lf... :1...... ~~.l(.....lo.~~.. ~),.I~' f ,\'~\. ~ l....t ~.a-r\.. ~-:.."t /~ ~ ':~'l ~...t 1;j.-..:. l'~ "')4.~~ ~~t~; OJ, .Eh" "I..r;\~ r 1'.. ',." ".~'l .., :1."'.. "'!:(.l~ t! j (1;'\.-' '''. oJ, e<<:'., ~ l ~ , t~ I ~l ~"4"!1il'l ~..IJt t~r~- I~"$ ...~ .... Lif.'''' l ~ ~I t.... ....... it , I \\~.".... , ~~\ \"";'~...f"" ~ ;:;l~:,r · ,I;.). l. . t~"J.-I"j,. '.:.,,'rr...... '.':' ~'~I I' /".......ylv..lo;~ ~~., ~~~gJ.._ ,~..JI,.'d' ~~~ . ~ . ..~'I,~,'I' lo . ~ 1 I"''to~''( ~~ /'r It "t;"f 01 (~~~.. I~h[l".... ~t~,.,",:\",,~"'''t f~. ' : l ... -r." "Lo..' on; 'i.i~ ", Il" ,""',~', df.J~'J~i:~:W"':l.!:(""1-..1~ fJ(" ~. ~'\o'>,j.3.t<~ pan or 1l~4'10t'<I~tO=~.Gi:aii'"1a.,~ttu13l.1Ire1D ellDU)bo !W-"'I~~"'J"," ~~!.I .~.......,. ~ t~1Z (~~_" . W:V{r, ~ ol, .' "t'.... ....1"'1', ~ ,. ,~ . 4 _ ~ '. $'t'e:lh4, loaaed; (Ill~ml\or llUll:"~ .'to, bJ}(I perlIQD "",' ~''''~ ,of';-':.l..r."....' , I.J..~.~' -1"1' ~~\o;..'lll,.:~,;:> .'1il1~'~ 'c ": '~,~. ~.~.. ~ iffl'" · ,~...-,ll! ;r'~;' r,' , \l~' 0'1:,"0 _ :all~Il.~U.!l&ll!llt.,;-l~'i'lr '\.1":'''' ~ ',' · '''" . .. :".J. ~/ ~." ~"llttf 10 "....t -~.~,~ ...~,.~ ~l\'~f" "~ ~ "aI~ 1'1wuo'~ .,r>1rlOat1CU' tlJ,"II1!' ~t ,at ilitl' or 1IU\.I1l~ ~",;-: ....;" 1\., .,'" 1("1' ,\'~... ~I .. ',,; ,:.,) r -. , .v;>~ 'I ~ ~ ,.':-..-J ~ c ," r, h r 1.. , j.:I',. tlM"~ 1l',oml'l:lIlItili>1:U bU1.l41.Dg w: p1a~iI.i. ~ ~ ).ot = l,crllIO ].ontDd , ~',"'~ "',,,~.t.'f"";II(.i~'..., :!.~~J,,-~!t,~ ,.'~. ... "'Y~ i,"" '. j \' '\ j .... ~~ Is", ....~', , · ' ., l~(SQ.'lMl1"I."lOD '.llh!I.J,J. Yll.''=iut.< tltll1:/01l,1IU.'l:II::I1'5ted 'to 'Ulo _1':11 c4 ~~,tTJ"\t,~: \~j ,.l\, or: . V d f -.: t ~; ~ '~~r r "e.~;\jl r A' I ;sm~'(lf" ~1l111 !;Iu.W1T1I:1,on.or 111011' d\I~'1I.P.P"1JI1:~ ~u tit" t1Jg ....."Il' :t~:~Jo~I~ I "lit..... r,t ..4n;4""'.~~JI'!VI~'(I.~-;J ~"I'f ~""'I ~'.. ~.,...~~ 11,,:[... 4 . l "fI'.. ~ 4 ' ~ ' v. ,O'II'Dtll'1l.l5'''ld ),oti:l l:J":~ ~pJ"q MY Ytr1lC: em .DD7 nS'llctll" or bIdl41:rt. .~I"'~' ,~I .. V loo!;'II.,. ~ ~ ~ I, '"".....~ \~"~l l ... ,.. "l.... ' ; ,~.,'~;!, IS. ' 110 hr'V':Iu11!"' '~l!rIl. ~ ,,~ ...,lIll13A1ag ':It =-1 b.rl4 01:' S .~I.!~ '{~~' . (, . ~ '" ' .~\, ,,:,"ltY'~" it: ~tun'r',l!~pt:l.Ba: <mlJo' .....0, G\~~4,to tho mG1A'1lu.1.ltU.ag sl:r1i1,J. bn ..reo'ted or ill *!.r\'lu~)' U I":iI t .j ....,... ~"'''i!I ...... ... ~ ""~' ~'~~ C"'.,. I :IJI' ~ r l j "'~ .. ~..~. :>.1- ~:i,OO~:E'IICI'te4 OD .t1no :lot O;r lOtu ~jI"IIln 4oIJOll'l:bO(\... "',' ~'~ ' Jtiijf~ ~~ .r~ f \ I ..'~ L .. ......,t .;1 ~'i",- $~~~ u.." No u.!.aI8J.. 01' pou1t~ OXOlll>till& 1l0ll!jClbD14\ )'01;6, 1Ih..u b. lI:ol/ll ",.. ~-~"~." ~f... ~ J " .... '~~~-:-':"I Lf ~~ ~-t~. ';~( 4 ~~} ,crr,.l~111!f:~'ao.l.~ .1ut.OI' :LIlt.. ,,~ ",;v'V' . ... _ $; i,"I~ r.,1 . ...~. ... ~."'Il .. t .... ........! ...... , ~~.l;;<.'J.f ~"tnUer.'l:I............t, t~t, (Ih*~ ~I ~ or <>Uln' ~'t- ~;.t j \.. ~~:'\~~ ..,~~. "" "' ~ \., ':.. ~~~~~. '~). liu~~~t~ _I.~. \II., t=t IIlla.ll 0.1: IJtr1 t 1118 ";'~od lllI .. f'fIs141J1,", 't~_ ~"'f,.~. to ~ ... -'-f~ " I~ "1: II .II... ~ I~ ~ ~ . t ...~ ~.~~, Ii G%'tl,. 9,lpemMtlD't1,. , r\~ *"-11 "bY It:N(ltur. at". tSIpllt1o.r7 o~er bo'u~ .. ~~ ~ - II", 1 (,l 4, . t ~ (' ,. ." 1ll\1r' ' . t-jl';'":.i./'..4i- ..... ~ '" t' I ~. I ~ ~ II .",t ~ )"/rr ~t.. '1 ) ... .. ~..~ri. ":l;d.Oll,: '," : : J;(, ~. 0 "' ',r (, ~ "i'i~, . ,":>) ..r-~~' 'J .r.y-...~~;?'...tt(~ r ~~ ~~l..r...\ " t' .. ....~ 4 ~ ~ 't ~ jj ~~"~1'~~""'?" ~, ~ . !Oo:t.:. ~ ;.,~".. ~;'.:; '6{~ 8. ~ "'''lIl:t1elna: display or- Otll.$l' l'J~,l'o~ :...,. 12Qt\!l'il <>:' ~&"sOTb-' r:~PI )....: ~t~ \.... ~l"l~!t~j"l~ l ~~:i; it... (Of' .. I ~ '-. /' ~ ;.frl~l""~ I I \., I 'Y.\'; .': t:i.0Jl0 ~~";01'O;t.OO',o'r(F7"a~ \ij)OA ;~-,l~t ~:]'al),. ~l"~" C1C1!Z'f'07''';r, w1tbout: i'.~ "'" t 'Ltc 11 ~ ..~ *'.. ~e I .- ~ ~ ~ .. ~ ~' ~ IIIh I ~i' I~\ \ 'tb.o~nnullu mttoll.~ea~l at ~ho a,rtleJ:/!)' lIJ\d.Il.OT'tllo~ Of &.7"1411. Subdl'O'l.roI.OD. .. :.~ ~~.. ..;::'1 l ~*f' ~ I -~~ (1';~rl. ~., ~)\~ ~ l.r{~ "l'u'a?~ ~ ;~:1;' j ...;' . 'fi \. ~~ ~.. \ '~"19.\ IS'(I'. botl.tllO'lUlo. e04ll:. $rt.' or llll.11U~~~ ot_ 6tNatnre 9holl nJ~,~;' 1>,; ~~; ~t; ~?~~tGr~;;"~: ~ ~:~!~~);~~~ M~,~ ~o' =.; ~. lUi'r:1j .~:-; "'rli'~i.., ~ 1 ~ r{H~~{ l~~l,,>". .,(~,. ,rt.7~I<~~l,: ,0'. e ~ .~' {.~'~e14' I>>bll1'1U1.llA~~, ~, ~Ol.i.O:( CJ,'tlP.:BtQ' _. e:toe,Pt tllo own.,r ''';,oJ ~1-lIi:';~,lUt:: i. 'J ~~~;:;;Y!." ..'\..~..;, I",,' " '''hiy:IJ:f':'f')..~~_ ' " ". t'!"bl:j,lo~~ ~ m ~~Cl7l<1ot. -m'ted. 111 'thl' ~~vit1011.. aha.U boo 'plln\ltted to ~",' 'ff{ .~ ,..sw6 ,[ ~ ,.f, '~f:: ~"'-'1Jtfl. t,,,,::- ' " '~~il'~\~'?~.~ ~"";~;' , '~,f/ ' ':. , ~ ~, ~iI ~oo e,t. Cltt'~'1fIIJ.1 1bo ~ f) ~4 p1.a't GDd.1.D. _ e?~'t "ifj),,'o, . :1:.' -:t1;~.;,..-J.'fIt'~.l!.:t1.'{';' . .,.li)fr~~~ f."'f-.{',,, ''':. "', ,-l ~", ; iAiA~ ,f'a$~'I:hIld 1nt~tb. ~~ ~~C1. ~. +;0.,,,,,," tblJ1 tbll 4cjalc l1Aa .21_ ffii""":~~ ~i..~~".\" " 1~},'r..;1,,"t..:l'~\. ,~, ~1o'..~::~:1l1J 'm', I 'f~.'l '\. ~....,<(;, '".{- : , F~DD 'b-"~~ ... tI ... ....".t'l!i~....~...... ~~.,. ',"1'l,,(\1;"1i't..n." ... , 1IiII.... # f'\ ..... lrtll'>'l" ~!M"'; ..,) ,y,.,"'."<tjl'1\~ff'dd''''1'~ .'1.!~1/-"I~..f,,'t' "'" !.' fn7.~'" "';../ Ti1JA ~.,~ ",,'" ~~ l"'if:./"1 \.', ",\.LI'\~, 1.......(.)",. ~ t". ' . ~.:: , ,~."'.I" o.r. .1l.'0 4_1l1zI6: 0:" ..'In!im ..."nt"S', ltlllli r'hllll. -13,&10.00 ~ bo po~ ~r . :. ~ "';,, Jtt'-~;...z..;'t~ ~ ~.:.'" :,":~i' I~J.~.... ;".l.~H,"':r".; , , ; '':''.,', . -!. r,'" ~ttc~~'%RIIll;'S, Z',....;~~,-:.G'l'.(lll;, or't!le' ':r:ul"t~'TJi.'poouM floor &:reo,1{ot tD '.j ~ co :rJ ,,~~ k'~ lr " "1l,Lo ~~ "" ...,', ~,~ ~ ....... ' ~ ~....: '~f "'....~~1.(.!=~; ~. . ~ ~ ~ ,-1 ,,~~ .~..." f4fr'. dVto l~ I ~ ~ , ..!,\. -; o!. - ;';'....Ua '<l.1IIUJ.1JI&~;' .hut,.. :af.<eJl"""totY (IP!to:l ~oJliN;""'" ~. 'NA11.. bo :=0'11 ~~~~ ~:.r..~,.~, ~31i" i. '" ~.. ..~...\~-:.~ ~ ,'" n: .~ ~~J. ~rt ~j' ~ · ~ -- fWO-\'IJ' 01 ~~ ~ ;~~l..: ~... . J'~l""", ;. '(.Cl)LIl:t"lo=taot,~ 'l;h Ollllll for '\ all.~rr 1IwllG ....,a.l"'lluIJ"tba 'tOO ' . l\ ~~~-}~:O;~';~'~"~"f.~'M;'~"~ '"". X :;.~ "":l~~ "")I /:, "t..:'. c./": ~,. 2., ,"',J. ~,~~ U., . ~ ". ", ~ j. "1 ~~i).,.f't ~."*.;r~ .lJ...l"l'o!' ",~'III .j~~ ,;r.f'tiC ...~~\ I,t -.. '?+"l.l lj t I rf",.l.. * C ~~kt".,.~):; ~ ~~t\'" ~k..:.~t~~. I ~;~, ~.... ":p'''\~ ~~~~/~~;.~..:~ Ll t~i\t ~~ -i.~ ~ I ;,,' ~ 1 ~~ .. \l ; ;~~,." ..4 '1 ~ ~ ~i~,..:'.:~i<;~\~~';::;~t;'~~~~lfi~J .::.n l';: :f';;' - :,itt!:r.:.~~-'~ "(~\" ~ "J';,~~l,,'~i~}t -: ~;( ,i;, ,~1'....~lJ~'~.tr.J!..~~".b.l""1d.1..-'.""t..;~_~ -~":"~_~...-...__.. Ji~..fA'~ ",-"_"'_:_;~~ ~~ III uI I J. -:t 4 t' .... 1'~ 't ~ ,.... ~f ~ 'Ii, ... ,.~j.oj .,. .. ...... J ... ...~ ,..- ..~'II" 1 ~ fIo...t--l:l'l..\.~ 'I' r~..1 ::.l\.~"'" ''''''1.\'/ t~~.;'~r'" J.. 1- ~ ' . i;J.~ LI.1 ~ ~1f'~' ,( t;~" . ~..;", ...., ( . '" ',,' .;!, . ~.' '. ", , . 1i " .<' '. \. .. ~ .f..,. "" " . iI\ _ 'f" - .......~.. , .. t ~ I 4 .... ,...-l.l'" ."J .... ~4 I~, i ~j'" 4 ! U J iI'.i ~ ~ ! t ' iIIV: ~~;" ~ .........;, ~I .. ~ ..("t~ 1t1r I I- J....., j j 1....4j~'". l'''':tll' ~ #'~ :",. U,L t 1 'II'!" I \\ :.~ .....A~,.:1~.., j~ +(,f~q,..... I it ,""'l~'" ...~, Jj '~,",t;'~", ""'\.i'~I~1 ?-U'~~4 ~':~"". ~ t"--'.t' 't\t l~ ~ ~1"A': ',' .'tl? t~' :;..h't \ . ' " , ":\ e.v -; .r'~," $i .~..r;"""'l.",f ".1:,J.......... b 'fI, ..."'\~~rA IJJ;-'-_I-~ I...l,..... ..1 ~ 't'- I.. _. "":1' ,"",illiL t 'I. ~ 'i~ ~tI'.T' ; ;~lV . ..'Jf';' ~.l: ,A1'J"~t 14 '^ t~ ft "....'" .... ":-' . j t 'J ,......J~~~ ..i J '~~~~.("~~~.~ ~";~!'~J.i'~~lt.t;'~:'Ilfl\;~lt;,:i"'i.,\ ''1;fl ~l:;..J~'., /;>}S' .' ,;rZt.a'~~;"":i ~~ . . , , :r.:::~ :~"", :~'I:,~;~;:r~Y~~j,t?{~,rf!1';;r~: ~"l,i"{,~\ '3::. t!:~;~,{lfh....%:!.~"~l';(. ~ l~)" ~L~ ~i t ~-t4~,';<'Io~h:~.I'1i~(' '..\1;: '.' 11~~1"':.;.~UI '" ',;.., "'. ' ),"lj,I:..'tibL'C ,,~ t:'''... ~..;;~ '.F'~;4 ;\J;1;,j ,e'i:dt...,.~~ \-...." . , ,~ -'~>1:.~iii'l'; .,.....:00- ,,~ ~.JrflH.:#'~ ,~...~(" .. ..r.'1~',.~.....7, ,;'1.J"1i! '..l'"f,:\:'r"'" l t-' " ;'': ir'~: ~)J;S(~\~;~;..: :a.J.~' i\.. 'n:~~~ ~~. J.;Y':1'~, . .:/f tliI:. ~, ..........fit~~~... 1fI-.l.....~ .. ~ 1- t<< .. (;pJ4't.:1.,.~ r.~( ~ <<, .i\~ "'-of: r"~~~ :.:1It; ~ ~ ~~"'&"I~~~~~:--~~..$':'(.-.........~,,--.....:..- ~ .' ,I ~ , , , t '11 l~ 115' .H ", t "" $ ... ..< 10/14 .~ .07/07/2004 ~Q) 12.- O.D UCG - .. .- cnCG :~ 18 25 00000000"'&1 LAW OFFICE PAGE Jul 07 0.. 08:523 D~bar8h Sabal~sk; le"7e24.._~2 p.6 , , CllD Hf..iO rAG( 5:1 I",,:. I; . . ~..A" in the- Dll.~$ I) r 0 Gt)lJI ll. nd on.,.!lu\lt' OJ' -1:.""0 ,,1;:017 boQJ'lo. I'JI:) ""ell- : "'lfIIn:re.' u" ~ 1118 or csbana Ooeting lDIIlf thlU) $4.000.00 ~ll be pormitted On lot" 'T and ~:' 52 of' tho trAot. ThlO szvuDd. floor DNa Or th& "8.1.n d1r&l11ng, Itll:c11\81Vl:l of' '~.... ~~;:.\ onO'<"lI'to~ope.n peroh" IJ 0 nd ~s 1'aS'1l1. aholl be not 1e l!Ia thM 1,100 l'lqusro fll B t ~:' ln the DI\!IlI" of' . one-:I t017 b tt"Uo tur b noll' 1""8 t.han BOO II qullrl! foa t In t h... ~<-'\ - I~"~~.. OUIlo of Ill, Dna and. ano-holt or 1:"0 "tory atruoture. No d..ll1l1n,s 01' oat)atlll ..~'ooat.1lll!: leu than $5,000.00 ~hftll bo ~rm1tted on lottr B to 51 1nalu!lb.. ot :"'\'tl:11a tract. The grOUl'ld noor are<< of t.he 1lIl!.1n at.ruot\1l'O, OXOlull1ve or 000" ~: b't.O:ry open p)robAs ...00 gN'.soll sh.o.l1 'bl! not lC13s tMn 1,200 "quaro hat 1n ~ tho eoee Dr a one-etory atruotUVe nor l&a~ thAn 800 foet 1n the oa~a of I!l one ~i:" ~ "n4 onl!l-half or two etory et:r\lctllJ'e. Pa(;1I {}::r- ,j \ 11. Jhlo QUt:A14e !;o1b t aMI1 1)e par:r. t.od.~ bIlt thot'o) ahttll tier CQnet.l'UC I:lJd ,~ l' ~ 1n oOhl'loot1on ..,lth /lIlT 4w-81U.1l& 0'1' C1ftbll.nn on n.ny of add. lo;ot:e. '" oep't1Q tank, ~ -- t.he 100<< t.lon and. OoluII l'\ICI t10!,\ or ....IUoh ~lOota nll th<'l l'eq'\l1rOlllOnt:l or the ~ 1100a1 and So ta tll hcol th IlU thorl tIo 8' nnd: "hloh h!lB boon II.ppf'tlV ~cl 1n wr1t1nS by OW%let'o Qful developere ot &.ydJ,c1o ~'btJ1Thlon. Jle btdldlns ohoU b:!! IJl'ootod on Iota 2: thru 31, inclusive nlllat'l!Jl' thll.n 20 relit to the bulkhl!olld 11M IIn"- no bulld.lns ahal}, 'be "'roOl:04 on Iota ~2 to :i::l , ,nolu,dvo ne_or them 28 1"00t to tho 'bulkh'lad. 11M no\" n'lOCl.f'el' 'han tl'lGntJ (o;v) foot to De.-vn Dz'1ve .IUI abowb l:n tho IIIII,p 01' 111..t. or 15-14 BI!l7111dll .$.JJ.l)dlvl$1.ou. ~fNO bu.1l~1nS ahAI). 'to 1000to4 ntlGl'or t.nan flve felllt: to an7 1I14e lot llnl'. ~~, ... ~13:' tro own.,1(" of IUI1 lot or Iota loode4 lIIith1n tbll11 su'bdhb10n -hall \Jo .~ f.~~ttt9d to Ul1 1n o~ llflUtlo to tlo rUled tl1 anT aubmol:'f!;o:rd In.nd.a whlob \,,1 ~.. ~b.ll IIXt.4n~ ru~thor into Ql"~D~or 9Q7 thon the H08 wall l1ne aa BhQwn on ~t ~ , ._ . ol:'1g'lnal mdp, or i'l~ or this SU,bc:llvl",,ton. ~:~~' "II"" ~_ll.or ra:01n1nc wall Dhnll be bd1.lt: o.b'att1116 1l.J1Y ot tho lQta l".l' " '" ~ :w' OOated 1n thla 3ubc11Y101oa, oxoept 011' th.o 11no dtIa1srmtOd on t:het o.rluual _~"'I'" ~',.. I ... tall th$ neU. wall 11no.. :"-'I---f'l1; .r- r\ I 4' ..lrf'" · ~l1'b$.O ~OO'l'I"l.nt;o a.X'1lI to rue wUh t.M land: anll aball bo bindlltB on eJ.1." . ~"I ...e. Jl ..." '!Io ,... , ~ ~t1~e A~.a~1 persona cla1m1ns undo~. tbollll untl1 Jo.~UfU7 I,: 19B5, B;t, ~ t!IIII!I' eoJ.d cOVAn"nte eha.ll bB llutomat1olllJ.1y 'll;Jl;tonded ror ,,"acee.lYe . - J pl,blolla or tllb 7as.ra unllllll 1I7 III vote- or the II1llJo1'1ty or tb~ then -noZOIl .~ ~ ,"f..:'- "" - . . "loti, it 1a .gl'ofld to cblne;e tl10 Bud OOVOft'Il1'It:s 121 wholo or 1n pllrt. .. f iii" ., ... ~ (AJ ~' ~ ""''' tl...J , , \. \ J' ,.~l ,. , , . ., , 1:'~'- 1" ..~ ~f ~ .. ~;:- ...~ ~~"f ~p .",. ;,,,. ~ r 1 io ;"'" :f ': ~. . "'"- '1 'lor t ( " .' .. ! , " , " ~ ~"'_' ~.. l l" ~,' ..j';.'" I , ~. . '" , , ~I I ~~.Ai!s.~~~~~ ."'~"'~~i'X'?~"""""..':""'~-I"'.. 11/14 . 07/07/2004 18 25 0000000P""'l LAW OFFICE PAGE 12/14 Jul 1947824925'2 p.? - ~ , r 1 ~Q) D._ 0.0 uca - ~ ... .. tn~ I~ #' , , ,A . f \ -1 ; , "" . 07/07/2004 )\Gt &2._ On uca .- .. .. cnC\1 a~ 18.25 0000000~~~ .J1oI1 O? D.... 013:5508 LAW OFFICE I Debo~eh Sobo1@skl 184782.... 2 * I -.":' ---. ~ ~ ~.,. If .J,,~rf.. . t. ..... ~ ,/ PAGE f1.E! -~ .. D!.t'D ~60 1'lII1l: f; I t- ~ I,. , " ,I ($tAL) " '}~'d: L. I~ ':;'" , '~.J."'YU"'>4.1 ,1\..., u.'rU'-1'f7_ );l? I : ~~ ,1 ~ L.'r ' I , " .~r.~~ '" ; j.. J I"" . ~ fC:l~ ...1.... moA'l'E 01' .n.omDA J : __ .P,~mu... I so ., "I ~~........ to ,', I he.reb7 Ofll't1tr that I.>b!a t.b7 1n tb~ noxt obo....e nMl$d aut" iIIIn4. , ~ COUh ty, b"t'o:re lIlD, o.n oa leor d.w.y QUth0r1zo4 nnd a II e1np,:, f!8:-lJOnlll17 .p" . . r :pee.:-f1d. LoNnllo :. :Dl:OwlOD tU14 ~nJQm!D 1:. IOl.cw1o D. her m,U'l>U%l4: Vi vinYl Y. ' .Pl'l'lr.lnlll anti D. O. P&2'ldnlll. her hllobllnd; 13l'mndott" A. t~111ook and K. r p'rllbCl h t:'hlU oak. bor ll'l\.!Ibrm.l: Itftr(;\lllot"lto L. fiqHoZ'. II w1do..; \'J. B. 'I'OM'''11 '~""1.D4 }label D. 'I'lIl'Vin. hi3 "It". z:n,. E. ne-Ioh!!:r Mitt I. J. Belcbor. her hu'bllnrJ.; to. IDe ",,11 Ja)D'"l IUld 1Ulfl.1'I'n to lJQ to bo the 1nd1v,tc1uol" de3Cl'lbIJd 1n Il.nJ who ~teJ!:L'IC\1to<1 tho rorot>Oll1S: lnetl:'lttoont. (l,nd, tho,.- aOkD''''1o~M th...~ ond th(Jro ~&- I f'ro;r$ IlID thot the,' "'Moutod. ORid. 1.l:l.Q;b-unollt for tho UlIOII' ond. PW'POUOlJ mel'lt.iol'll:ltl ~J"'~ , ~",~i"'; AnD I I"lnl'1'RIaI. ~IPr. thnt tho IUl.U T.o:'OmI. 3. F:bo'll'le e ~ VIViAn Y.. ';}...h~k.1no. :D~dottll .(I.. Vh111ollk, l~bol n. 'rIl:'Vln, Mil 1:0.,. 11;.. Deloher, known ~~,~ m~ to be ~bo w1Yes or tho on1a nDnJ~~n ~_ r.~o~l~D; D. o. ~~k1no: ......,q,1.{l!. Pro.n:ols Wb.11100l!;: It. 8. Tnrv In, and. I. ~, Dolch"'r. No cPo ot! "'/lily. on ... ~} lI11illU'.t!l lY d. Fl Yo. to oxtUlr1na t1ot:!. to.l{on anll '=I!.d.e In the lll:l OVo nnmod. state ,~~\~tJ.l:a1. ..~"fnd befll'%'(I mo. 1l0~rQl.ol::r and 1l.1l00:-t 1'ron theIr Ihl1d hulltlllndtl. ;AJ' r~,t . 1".~,lol1so boto:l'o Dlll, Gn OrnCOI' Il.I.\~ho1"ll::ed to tak... aCknc"'lo~ l\"~1=!! 11I)t,,~.~ ~OCll:ltod tho ro:rn601ng "n3t.l:'Umont f"roely DtJcl vOlo.mtll'Uy ;;; ~ ~;oDlllP\UDIWl, con.!ltn1Dt, appJ'<!IolwnlllIon or fOllr of 01' t'l:'01ll · ~.,~Ir,~~Ddl!l. . , lAQSL~r_~... {'~ ~ " ~~~~~.", ,lIand. Ilnd ort1011l1 . olll tbh Qtl7 or A. D. :&1'11," m\' 1\ ' , ~ ~~ /...1. ~ 0\ ~ '.... r-- " ~... 1\,4" 411 ,. a.~~~~ ' , ,~~-'_ .or ".' ',' :.{:~.J(.......t~/...\ ,.. ..~ ""r"'" ~ '..III. ~"\I.I:.~;':. 1': : I.I!I _, 11 ~C"'t.... 1..,... I ~ ~ ~ 'lA~- o-P nb,~: ) ....,. ..... ~l. ~ .l"l' j t J SS .emntT;r OP l'ASSA;J.:c; ) (J~'. _ ,.s.~..... 'J _..I. ~ ~ ~f... I!:U:REBY ....-...u-,I;, that o~ th1,,~. 40)'" ot JI. D. 29-10, b,'- Core 1ZItt. A Uot.':U7 PUb~lo1. fn!l'QOftnn,. tlPP9G:reC' II<'lm'y A Jtlcg.!lbtll'T n.nd 'Elhtl,be~ If. X1tl5Dbuq, lUll "it",: On1'.zoot A. 1tobtJr-t III and, Jba.z:lDt:te Ih)b, l"t. ~ ,~a , l'f.1to J' ])IlVld E. :!land. Il.M Xa:thn:01..,o If. !fatuI. bill ~Co, ~ _ '"ell )m!_n ~ aB4 ~~ to IlIl!I to be tho 1QlJi'V'11JUr1.1.a daaorlbo4 111. and. "ho O)tOOttted tb" ~ .tO~801:lg 1Dl!ltrubtllt 1In4 thDT 0tI'fG:t'kl1:r tl,olmo~ll1dcod tho oxewt1oQ thflJ:'jot ~ ~~~!be theIr Creo .ot Ilnd 4a..4 for the UtJ.~ .rld parpoa.. there1u me,~lol ~d. "~IZ'r"it.... . . .... , . . ~. , 'PJ ~"", , ~J" . ~ 'r:' '" c ~" I-~ 1 I' ~, (SEALJ rlaJt~ ~. ~. C~J A'i"to .Lot:! <:: 'to:! ~ ~O.LU.ll1v.; "Iij"t:4lI . 29, .w, 31, loti! 33, 34, lot. .36 to . 63 1nolus1.vCl. .. l ,~~ ~ , . ' ... ~.,..) [\ ;; . L~' ~. , .f '~""I '#' 1 \"'.11 .. ... t.~J.: It:.. '.. .~ 1~.: . r.... I ~,.,. l ~ ~~.... ~w.;tt ~ i r . ~ I' .' ~il'.<~!$~~'.5::.~':.~"')'"N- ~~"'<'_'.:-.'""1-~ " ".. i " ,I ,~ I"I,M '. . ~ _J 13/14 .07/07/2004 18.25 p.s ~CD 12._ O.a Uta - .. -- cnla :~ 00000000p1lil " LAW OFFICE PAGE 14/14 ,.. , ... ,. . ..... _ AliP J PtlR'J!l1KI'l:, OERtIPI thot tho eaid El1J'A.b.,l;J). B. E!MIlb\u7; MRn,rae Hotulrt And lAthlU'bte I. HlDld. tho 'II'1TU. of "th~ 0..5.4 S..tu'1 I.. I1ng"~, QlU'J"ot A. Hobart II::r eld Dav1d E. BMd. l'ollJM'lot1'1'el,.. 01:1 " e"Jl;t"Il.~o Q~ ~5.,.ate eltGlll!nl!l.t.1on tukeu by Md b"'t'o1"fo DO lI&pGl'a1:1I1,. am!. apart ~l'o:m th<o1r (o..1~ bullbBbd", IUd .OImOYlIl~O tllat tbo,. B;;I;o~tf!o. tho !tlf'o601JtS, 1Dlltnua.Oll.t treel,. ond voluntarily an<< "5.~ t11V oompulolon. ccrult.l'alnt. approbeD41oD or too.r or ot" rrOlll. ~o1r uJ.l.'I. tro.&bal1l\ft. wrrm.:SS tJtf barJL1 qd or noW 00-.1 at.f~ - .. ~' . ea14 OOWlt)' lID'" stat.o. tblil dAJ' and 71l1U' Illll!: R1'Ol;'III1a1d. ~.r~ - . ~~41;f/~~~ ~4~~ ~ , F /1., 1''-f~:.Jv~t . ~~/.... '\ , A . ., i FII~ tOl' r.oem ~ ~oJ-,:_I!PLII .t:./.L: ~M,trJ Ie bo<it IIlIle4 .Ilowe IP1d th tff(/l" ",rWtd. RA)" E. ,GIl.EEN. eler' oj cbll Clnal, COul "meltu ~Ir. FlotIlla. It _ ~ ~~ Dc(Iatr CI~ ~~~ ~- - _~ _ _lf~""""""~~~~~~~........_~,..~",--.._ -- v . ~ ';'l'$;,''f'~:C~I'~ :e' ~;'-a',. rwater 'l_ <... 1111~ 1 i"!: _ ;;: '~1111 )- 41~r~ ~~I~~= l ~ !. ! I-- II II~ po x..~ f ,,~ ~_ - - II U TO: FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865 - rllvl '"'J 6HN.sO ,..r 6ft!- CIA ,J 6 ~5 ~2.- 03'~ FAX: Phone: FROM: ~h1"'\ S~&il-u- Phone: S2.-~ocr DATE: 07070'1- SUBJECT: 193 DE;vo..... Of2..,. MA IIL\ Afoo,.l t CIo" c.K ft..s 2.004- uSO'2.1l MESSAGE: N6!6H/3oIZ-I,.JcSp "6~r'!.["'j~N NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) r/ 7/6/ 12 49 PM FROM Fax TO 562-4576 PAGE 002 03 paWffJm lJUJ JUl - 6 2004 UlJI Dale and Janet NIemann 177 Devon Dnve Clearwater, Flonda 33767 July 4, 2004 Home 442-2079 Office 877-251-3681 Fax 877-251-3681 DEVElOPMENTSER~CESD8PT CITY OF CLEARWATER John Scholdtler Development RevIew SpeCIalIst CIty of Clearwater Planmng Department lOa South Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, Flonda 33756 Fax 727-562-4576 Dear Mr Scholdter We ask that the Plannmg Department deny the approval of the applicatIon for FlexIble Standard Development Approval at 193 Devon Dnve (FLS2004-D5028) We object to the grantmg of a vanance for the followmg reasons (1) Deed restnctlons exist for our area whIch prohibit all covered docks and docks of lengths greater than 60 feet We ask that the planrung department adhere to these restnctlons for all proposed vanances gomg forward (2) The proposed length and configuration of the dock will destroy our sole 'lcemc VIew. A key part of the value of Our home IS to be found m our eXlstmg vIew (from our IIvmg areas and porch) of beautIful Clearwater Bay The proposed dock will have a negative Impact on the value of our property and will defiDltely not enhance the value as encouraged by the Code ID SectIon 1-103 General B 2 As the code states" It IS the purpose of thIs CommunIty Development Code to create vdlue for the CItizens of the CIty of Clearwater by ensuring that development and redevelopment will not have a negative Impact on the value of the surroundmg properties and whenever practIcable promotmg development and redevelopment that wIll enhance the value of surroundmg propertIes" It 1<; notable that our neIghbors, the Sobcleskls, were very cognlLam of not Impedmg our view In any manner when deslgnmg both theIr home and landscapmg Wlule It IS true that there are two docks of sunIlar length to that proposed by the applIcant on theIr property, these docks eXisted pnor to theIr purchase of the property One was bUllt by Mr John Blakely and was opposed by us (3) An alternatIve location eXJsts for a dock that WIll provide the applIcant WIth the same amCOltles as thc proposed dock ThiS locatIOn does not negatIvely Impact the envIronment nor does It negatIvely Impact surroundlDg properties The request to mcrease the length of the pLrmItted dock from 60 feet to 92 feet IS necessary only because the proposed locatIon requIres a walkout of that length to place the platfonn and boat <;IJps beyond the hnut of the sea grasses at that locatIOn I he dock could be placed at the eastern SIde of the property where sea grasses end about 50 feet from the seawall Smce the neighbor to the left of this hne ha:, IIvmg areas one floor above ground level, there would be no view obstructIOn to tlus neIghbor Slnularly, :,lnLe the applIcant I, bUlldmg one levd off the ground. the applIcant's view would not be negatIvely Impdcted 7/6/20C 49 PM FROM FaR TO 562-4576 PAGE ( , 003 (4) The property configuration does not preclude the placement of a dock in complIance with the requked dimensional standards [Part I Commulllty Development Code Artlcle 3 Development Standards Dl V1SlOn 6 D ockIM an na Standards SectlOn 3-60 I C New Docks g DevIatIons III ] A dock of approxImately 60 feet can be built off the eastern sIde of the property and be In complIance wIth the requlrements (5) The proposed dock IS almost IdentIcal to one proposed by the applicant III February, 2002 (FLS 02-02-03) Tills configuratlon lOcluded two covered lifts It is our understanding that the applicant IUtends to add these roofs IU the future The covered hfts will completely block our Vlew. Wlule we certamJy belIeve that a property owner should have the nght to bUIld a dock that meets ills boatmg needs, a property owner also has a responslbllity to the surroundmg neIghbors to not decrease or destroy thelT property value m domg so SlIrularly, we believe that the mlent of the provIsIons to .-.,."..t ""... .,....."'~ ""...,........,.., h, pv,{'t<, f,,'r" th,,<,p ,...""p<, utj,P"'" r1l\f'k-~ f'::1nnnt he h1111t that cnmnlv with the 1 f t -tHIS ,~ ALL- :J: 12.EZ---' C / / \ \ \.., DRe Meetmg Date Case Number !\ lteant Ad July 8, 2004 FLS2004-05028 Mr & Mrs Chnstopher Manam 193 Devon Dnve CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT GENERAL INFO REQUEST: ~ Flexible Standard Development approval to mcrease the length of d dock from 60 feet (50 percent of the width of the property) to 92 feet ~ / (766 percent of the Width of the property) under the provIsIOns of 7 SectIOn 3-601 /:::::> ~MDR, Low MedIUm Dcn<;lty RC<;ldcntldl DI~tnct ZONING: EXISTING USE' Single-family residential Clearwater Bay Single-family residential S I ngle- f dmlly remlentl a I All reqUired eon~truetlOn and navIgatlondl permit'; would nee The site IS located In a stable, residential neighborhood that IS u ergoln redevelopment T~ request to Increase the permitted length of the doc.k I'; m keepmg With the estabh<;he c.hara er of the area anct.wlII provide a more envIronmentally sensitive situatIOn over eXlstmg COnditiOns) , r,U. B. FLEXIBILITY STANDARDS FOR DOCKS IN ASSOC ~TlO WITH SINGLE-FAMILY DWELLINGS IN THE LMDR, LOW MEDIUM DENSITY RESIDENTlA DlS I RICT (SectIOn 3-601) STANDARD REQUIRED! EXISTING PERMITTED 50 percent of the wldth of the Vacant ro crt 60 fcct 120 lot Width Thirty-five (35) percent of the Width Vacant of the property (42 feet) or fifty (50) feet whichever l~ Ic";!, LENGTH IN COMPLIANCE? No maximum WIDTH Maximum I 2 feet (~. ~)y.A-J L~~ Page 1 ST ANDARD REQUIRED/ EXISTING PROPOSED IN PERMITTED COMPLlANCP SIDE Docks the center one-third of the lot Vacant Dock East 30 feet Yes SETBACK (40 fcct) or twenty (20) feet from any (minimum) property ]me, whKhever 1<; less West 30 feet Boathfts/servlce catwalks mmlmum (mInimum) of ten (10) feet from any property Boathft lme West 30 feet (mInimum) C. FLEXIBILITY CRITERIA FOR DOCKS (SectIOn 3~601): 1 The proposed dock will result III no navigatIOnal conflicts and the length of the proposed dock will not exceed twenty-five (25) percent of the width of the waterway; or The Pmella<; County Department of Envlronmenta] Management has Is~ued a report, which states that there are no navIgatIOnal concerns WIth the proposed development The length of the propo<;ed dock wIl] be ]4 percent of the Width of the waterway 2 The proposed dock locatIOn needs to be adjusted to protect environmentally sensItive areas, or The Pmellas County Department of EnVironmental Management has Issued a report, which "tates scagras!:. bcd~ arc located along thiS entire property, and extend out to a maximum of 65 feet from the seawall m the area of the proposed dock although It becomes sparsc at approximately 60 fcct It I~ thc pohcy of thiS [Pmellas County Envlronmenta] Management] department to limit structures over seagrasses to 4 feet III Width and to place the termmal p]atform<; and boat slips bcyond the hmlt~ of the ~eagraS!:.es wherever possIble 3 The property configuration precludes the placement of a dock III compliance With the reqUIred dimensIOnal standards, however, the proposed dock will be Similar III dimensional characteristics as surroundmg dock patterns. Not applicable a<; the only one of the above three cntena mu~t be met The first two cntena have been satisfied, however, the proposed dock, as amended, Will be Similar to surroundmg dock patterns D GENERAL APPLICABILITY (Section 3-913): ConditIOns which are imposed by the Commumty Development Coordinator and the Community Development Board pursuant to a Level One or a Level Two Approval shall ensure that 1 I he proposed development of the land Will be III harmony With the scale, bulk, coverage, denSity, and character of adjacent properties m which It IS located. Most of the properties In the neIghborhood have docks approXImately 35 to 90 feet m length The proposed dock of 92 feet m length appears to be consistent With the character of the area 2 The proposed development Will not hmder or discourage the appropriate development and use of adjacent land and bUlldlDgs or slgmficantly Impair the value thereof \ The site IS zoned LMDR DIstnct and the proposed use Will be m complIance With that zonmg The proposcd development "hould not dl~courage appropnate development and use of adjacent land butldmgs . - ,Aff~~t.-- Page 2 3. The proposed development will not adversely affect the health or safety or persons re~ldillg or worJ..illg ill the neighborhood of the proposed use. The development will not negatively affect the health or safety or persons resldmg or workmg In the neighborhood It w1l1 not result In a hazard to navigatiOn 4. The proposed development IS deSIgned to minimIZe traffic congestIOn. The proposed dock will have no mcreased effect on traffic congestion 5. The proposed development IS comlstent with the commumty char.Kter of the Immediate vlclmty of the parcel proposed for development Most of the propertIes m the neighborhood have docks approximately 35 to 90 feet m length The proposed dock of 92 feet In length appears to be coml~tent wIth the character of the area 6 The deSIgn of the proposed development mlmml7CS adverse effects, meludmg vIsual, acoustIc and olfactory and hours of operatIOn Impacts, on adjacent propertIes. The 10catlOn of the dock, as suggested by Staff, wlIl reduce or ehmmate visual Impacts on surroundmg propertle~ to the west STAFF RECOMMENDATION Bascd on the on the apphcatiOn, the proposal IS m compltance with the standards and cntena for FleXIble Standard Development approval, wIth the maxmmm development potent131 and wIth all appltcablc standards of the Commumty Development Code OtJt..>t ~~ ~ ~ ~\q..\ ~ l.A:f(.. tJ6r ? 1 herefore, staff recommend,> APPROVAL of the application for FleXIble Standard Development approval to . mcrea,>e the length of a dock from 60 feet (50 percent of the Width of the property) to 92 feet (76 6 percent of the ~ Width of the property) under the provl~lon5 ofSeGtlOn 3-601 on the followmg base~ and condItIOn W ~ Bases for aooroval ~ ~ The propo~dl compile,> wIth the FleXlblc Standard Development cntena under the provIsIOns of SectIOn 3- 601 Cg, 2 The proposal, as amended, IS In comphance with other standards In the Code including the General Appllcablllty Cntena per Section 3-913, and 3 The development, 1<; compatIble With the surrounding area CondItIOn" of dpprovdl ThJ.t any future additIons or amendments be eon~l~tellt to SectIOn 3-601 C g S \Plalllllng Depmtment\C!) 8\~t(JIlJwd fledPe/Jdmg Cases\3 - Upjor the Nell DHC\Devo1l193 Manam f!\De\C!/l 193 Hepoll dor Page 3 r~~.rwater u CITY OF CLE ~RWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT --- MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING ----------- 100 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEAR WATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 WWW MYCLEARW A TER COM June 17, 2004 RE: NOTICE OF FILING OF AN APPLICATION FOR FLEXIBLE STANDARD DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL AT 193 DEVON DR (FLS2004-0S028) To S uIToundmg Property Owners As a property owner wlthm 200 feet of 19~ DEVON DR, the City: of Clearwater_ Plannmg DeJ~artment gives notIce that an applIcatIOn for FleXible Standard Development approval to lI1crease the length of a dock from 60 feet (50 percent of the Width of the property) to 92 feet (766 percent oHhe Width ofthe property) under the provIsions of SectIOn 3-601 On July 08,2004, the Development ReView Committee (composed of the City'S professIOnal staff) Will review and deterrmne whether the applIcation demonstrates complIance with the City'S Commumty Development Code Followmg that review and deterrmmahon, the Plannmg DIrector Will Issue a Development Order approvlI1g, approvmg wIth condItIOn<;, or denYll1g the applIcation The earlIest date that the CIty Will make a deCISIOn on the apphcatIOll WIll be July 08, 2004 The City encourages you to partICipate m the reVle'l," ofth!s apphcat!Ol1 You may contact me at 727-562-4604 or John Schodtler@myc1earwater com for further mformatlOn, VISit our office to review __ -the files-and/or- submit wntten-comments to-be conSidered m-the-Cltis-revlew-of-the applIcatton - --- -- P-I ease-be-advlsed-that-the-appllcant-may-subm It-addl tIonaLor-new-m forma tlOn-regardmg_trns-case, wlnch you may review dunng regular busmess hours However, no further notice WIll be proVIded to you should the applicatIOn be amended An appeal ofthe decIstOn of the Plannll1g Dlrector may be Initiated by the'applIcant or property owners WIthin the requlfed nottce area who present competent substantml eVidence at, or pnor to, the Development ReView Conumttee meetmg on July 08,2004 An appeal must be filed, mcludmg an appeal fee, WIth the Plannmg Department wlthm seven days of the date ofthe Development Order ~ Thank you for your mterest 111 the City of Clearwater's development reVIew process You may access our Plannmg Department tlrrough the CIty'S wcbslte www myc1earwater com t,Ct\\!€.O ~ \) 1\)~l\ )\j~ <J :\~€.l-\\ ~G C~..~.~~f'1~~ ~~\,\\ c\..~~ ~ c\"'{'( Of- S lllcerely yours, /'i-' ,-~ I) ''-L n (), I : /C)jt'I.JtA..-e')...-Vc-od-Lej\,__ , I Jolm Schodtler Development R~vI~w S!2S~Ial~st __ .~ , ~ ----.....--- _~""~___....... __~ L-- ".> ) [ ) , t l' -- ... I ~ - - " ~ -:--,'- -... -": ~J< ; r -Cellftr:oj (DI1ijJletene:.:. - / LS2004-05P2} - /93 DEV0V f~Hf. ---..-;: '-: -","-'-;-~. ')',ij t -r:~- - ~ ...."...~I"" ~...~~{:lr~~'7":"p~~~;::~-- _1:.- ~ _ ~ _ _..._:...~'"t'..7'::::~~': _ ~t~"" _ _'f6 .. -;;--- ~~-=-...::;;... ~.....--~- - ~ --- - ~ -- ~~-.,.--:::::::::::"-:::::::'-~ - .....~-~-~..........., .....~. .,. _.... ....,t..._ _j"-r'___--..'" -~............- \ ~-~~--~~~ -~~ -~~~ = - I ,< ....'c..i -o;,-""".!" - ....,.~ -,... 'r-"l"""":t'o """ :- _~,. _ _l ......-"1- t"'"r' ""';-"r -. ~l~~~r N~t5~~~~r~~.NT --. ~~. ~._~ ~~~\0"~ ~t 100"$ MYRTLE AVE. ' '-~.:,./ ~~ CLEARVVATER, FLORIDA 33756 ROGERO - 1 72 ' MAR Y - - C DEVON DR __"~~,.,?~....--.- LEARWA -.ij,~-- T..$:Ri.I!PL 3 - 3767 - 2438 / ~ I "'1--~""""'" - . . - ~~~ _;~~t. 1 ~ .........y......... J .., - ... I~'" 4' - ~.:...,.-.........r-~-~~ ' .. t.....~ j;~..-:~~': - ~~~I :. -~"1 '$ ~ :~.-i:~,~-=-;;PI ~~____ . -/7 I, ,II" 11I.!111111111111,1111 j III r I! 11111111,,11,111 [111,11,11 /"" , " ,Dr". 1m' -, Llrt f "'L:;- 'J Q -'~ 'ZtJ~ \ Y 1 H METER .7000BB 'tl' >, 'f<~' L Page I of 1 Schodtler, John From Schodtler, John Sent Wednesday, June 30,2004845 AM To 'tlmJ@Jpflrm com' Subject FLS2004-05028 - Mananl Attached are comments generated at the Pre-DRC meeting Please be prepared to discuss these and any others that may come up at the DRC meeting on July 8, 2004 You may contact Sherry Watkins (727-562-4582) for your time If you have not received It yet John Schodtler Planner I 7/12/2004 10:35 am Case Number FLS2004-05028 - 193 DEVON DR Apphcant Manam C Chnstopher 310 Live Oak Lane Largo, Fl 33770 TELEPHONE 813 623 3941 , FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Emall RepresentatlVe' Timothy A Johnson 911 Chestnut Street Clearwater, FI33756 TELEPHONE 727 461 I 818, FAX 727 462 0365, E-MAIL tlmj@Jpfinn com Location 033 acre lot located on the south Side of Devon Dove appTOxlUJately 1000 feet easl of Ham den Dnve Atlas Page 276A Zomng Dlstnct. LMDR, Low MedIUm Density ReSidential Request FleXible Standard Development approval to mcrease the length of a dock from 60 feet (50 percent ofthe Width ofthe property) to 92 feet (76 6 percent oflbe Width of the property) under the proVISIOns of SectIOn 3-601 Proposed Use Detached dwelling Neighborhood No NeIghborhood Assocatlon Data AssoclatlOn(s) Presenter John Schodtler, Development Review Speclahst Attendees Included The DRe reVIewed thiS application with the following comments General Engmeerlng 1 No Issues EnVironmental Provide caples of SWFWMD and/or FDEP Pennlt, Corps of Engmeer's Pennlt and Submerged Land Lease pnor to the commencement of constructIOn Fife No Issue ~. 1:@'JJ1- 3-'0 I Legal No Conuncnts Land Resources No Conunents Landscaping I no Issues Parks and Recreahon No Issues on dock request Stormwater I No Issues Solid Waste No Conunents Traffic Engmeering I No Issues Planmng I 2 3 Exhibit A has what appears to be an erroneous Ime runnmg through the middle ofthe property calhng out the "center hne of seawall" Please explam or revise plan Please prOVide an esl1mated project value for the enllre dock system exhibit B has Ihe dock drawn to the nght ofthe catwalk and Exhibit A has It drawn to the left Please explam or revIsc plan Other No Conunents Notes Development ReVIew Agenda - Thursday, Ju]y 8,2004 - Page 12 ~ FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865 TO: F [}),LJ/rL +/uno'fck IuDS I/(p) -9.5;5'1 FAX: Phone: FRO~L DATE: ~Rd3 -0-1 Phone: S0~ -'" 1-5'5/ SUBJECT: l\'[ESSAGE: NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) ;0 Page 1 of 1 Schodtler, John From DHemenck@aol com Sent Tuesday, June 22,20042 30 PM To Schodtler, John Subject RE 193 Devon Dr RE 193 Devon Dr (FLS2004-05028) Notice of filing of an application for Flexible Standard Development approval Please fax me a copy of the dock application for the above referenced property or you may also mall to my home address at 192 Devon Dr Clearwater 33767 Thank you F David Hemenck, DDS Fax #727 -461-955 7 6/23/2004 _ ,"'","':~i \q 3~uC' -- e-,. FL.. ~OL4 - Cjtbc7% TREZEV ANT, DOLORES C vIOT AKIS, CHRIS B '!:A CAPTAIN 2420 W MISSISSlPPI A VB 141 DEVON DR 526 BELLE ISLE AVE TAMPA FL 33629 - 611 0 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 BELLEAIR BEACH FL 33786 - 3612 JEDE CORP INC 2919 WEST BAY DR LARGO FL 33770 - 2621 MARIANI, CHRISTOPHER C 310 LIVE OAK LN LARGO FL 33770 - 4011 JOHNSON, RUSSEL B JOHNSON, SARA F PO BOX 17 NEWARK OH 43058 - 0017 NIEMANN, DALE K NIEMANN, JANET R 177 DEVON DR CLEAR WATER FL 33767 - 2439 W ANIO, T A TIANA A 14 GRENVlEW BLVD N TORONTO, ONTARIO M08X 2K 1 00030 - CANADA TALLARIDA, STENIO TALLARIDA, DENISE 165 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 CUSTER, GERALD 2152 LONG BOW LN CLEAR WATER FL 33764 - 6414 PETRIK, DAVID S PETRIK, MARY T 302 CEDAR ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 3001 P APP AS, TOM PAPPAS, ANASTASIA 115 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 STEEVES, MICHAEL B STEEVES, AMADA G 173 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 WELLBORN, HAZEL C 150 DEVON DR CLEARWATERFL 33767 - 2438 BASKIN, H H EST OWENS, W D 703 COURT ST CLEARWATERFL 33756 - 5507 KING, CHRISTOPHER C TRE 136 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 SOBOLESKI, DEBORAH L 191 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 TRACEY, ISABELLA S 135 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 ~ 2439 MARQUARDT, CAROL S 845 INDIAN ROCKS RD CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 1084 EVERETT, HENRY A EVERETT, FRANCES B 188 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 CHRISTMAN, KENNETH R SR CHRISTMAN, LINDA J 225 CORONADO DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2431 ROGERO, MARY 172 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 GONATOS, OLYMPIA IRE GONA TOS, MICHAEL 0 TRE 1460 GULF BL VO # 1004 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2848 ROSS, WILLIAM A III ROSS, DORIS H 125 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 PANOS, STEVE S PANOS, FILITSA 109 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 HAMODI, AHMED A 116 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 HEME RICK, F DAVID HEMERICK, MYRA B 192 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 GIANFILfPPO, JOHN F GIANFILIPPO, LAURA L 2079 SAN SEBASTIAN WAY N CLEARWATER FL 33763 - 4138 MARTIN, JAMES A JR 145 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 NIERENGARTEN, BERNADINE J 132 DEVON DR CLEARWATERFL 33767 - 2438 .. ... -- ~f/II'-.... , KREPLEY, JOSEPH F TRE ~UNRISE ON THE BEACH INC - BLUM, MARK S 50 INDIAN FIELDS TRL 229 CORONADO DR BLUM, DIANNE P LOWER BURRELL PA 15068- CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2431 195 DEVON DR 9700 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2439 VENDITTO, CARLO M CARLSON, EDWARD D HAMMOND, TOM G VENDITTO, ENRICA M CARLSON, PHYLLIS HAMMOND, CAROL YN 124 DEVON DR 140 DEVON DR 130 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 V ASILAROS, SOPHIA V AN ZANTEN, KOENRAAD CASSELL, FRANCES T TRE 111 BAYSIDE DR VAN ZANTEN, RENEE D 180 DEVON DR CLEARWATERFL 33767 - 2502 157 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 CLEARWATERFL 33767 - 2439 KEYES,JAYF TRE MATTOX, MARK S KRECOM CORP KEYES, JANET D TRE MATTOX, PATSY 714 SANDY POINT LN 100 DEVON DR POBOX 8143 ROUND LAKE PARK IL 60073 - CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 GREENWOOD MS 38935 - 8143 2787 LENART, DIANE TRE WELLER, HARRIETTE M CAGNI, DIANE W 8556 W WINNEMAC AVE 110 DEVON DR 144 DEVON DR CHICAGO IL 60656- CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2438 CLEARWATER, CITY OF PO BOX 4748 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 DENELL, MARGARET M 94 DEVON DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2436 S EA CAPTAIN C/O EIFERT, DONALD F 526 BELLE ISLE AVE BELLEAIR BEACH FL 33786- 3612 r .............., &~ , -'.... --::, / Il I I I , l--c1earwater Neighorhoods CoalItion 2544 FrISCO DrIve Clearwater, Florida 33761 A~IN: Doug_WIlliams Clearwater Beach Assoc. 827 Mandalay Avenue Clwer, FlorIda 33767 ATTN: DaVId MacNamee -' , ( ~.. ~~ ~"",,r.........~~~"";:""'_"':;' L.~........:;:;...&.~_7.;:o.~....."w.....~ _ \ ~~ l~~arwater CITY OF CLE'RWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUTLDING 100 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 WWW MYCLEAR WATER COM (j June 17, 2004 RE: NOTICE OF FILING OF AN APPLICATION FOR FLEXIBLE STANDARD DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL AT 193 DEVON DR (FLS2004-05028) To Surroundmg Property Owners As a property owner wlthm 200 feet of 193 DEVON DR, the City of Clearwater Plannmg Departmcnt gIves notIce that an applIcatIon for Flexible Standard Development approval to mcrease the length of a dock from 60 feet (50 percent ofthe wIdth of the property) to 92 feet (76 6 percent of the width of the property) under the provIslOns of SectlOn 3-601 On July 08,2004, the Development ReVIew CommIttee (composed of the CIty'S professlOnal staff) wIll revIew and determme whether the applIcatlOn demonstrates complIance with the City'S CommunIty Development Code Followmg that reVIew and determmratlOn, the Plannmg DIrector wIll Issue a Development Order approvmg, approvIng with condlhons, or denymg the appltcahon Thc carhest date that the CIty WIll make a decIsIon on the appltcahon wIll be July 08, 2004 The CIty encouragcs you to partICIpate In the reVICW ofthls apphcatlOn You may contact mc at 727-562-4604 or John Schodtler@myclearwater com for further mformahon, VISit our office to review the-fi les-and! or-s UbillI t-wn tten-comillents-to-be-con5.ldered-Ill-the-GIt-y~s-revIew-of-the-app ItGatIon Please be adVIsed that the applIcant may submIt add1ttonal or new mformatton ref3~lng ili.~.cas~~:\ ~..-: r;' jJ which you may review dunng regular bus mess hours However, no further n9ttc~ wlll.be provided to you should the apphcatlOn be amended 1.1_.1),,\ . . ~ ~" ' I g::> .. - P' -", .... I" ~ '. t . , 1Il"~ iM.__~'~ An appeal of the deCISlOn of the Plannmg DIrector may be Imttatcd ey~thej'appheant- or propcrty owners wIthm ""I rt'\,f., ~ j Y i '" thc reqUIred notice area who prescnt competent substantial eVldence'at~ or"pnor to~ the'Devel'opment ReView CommIttee meetmg on July 08,2004 An appeal must be filed, mcludmg an appeal fee, with the Plannmg Department wlthm seven days ofthe date of the Development Order Thank you for your mterest III the CIty of Clearwater's development review process You may access our Planmng Department through the CIty's websltc www myclearwater com Smcerely yours, ~~ JO~ SchodtIer Development ReVIew Spcctaltst Leller o{Compleleness . J LS2004-05028 - J 93 DEVO'V DR~ .'-': ~ CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT , 100 S. MYRTLE AVE. CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 ;(Qtarwater o ,CITY OF CLEaRWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING 100 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 WWW MYCLEARW A TER COM May 20, 2004 Timothy A Johnson 911 Chestnut Street Clearwater, Fl 33756 RE FLS2004-05028 -- 193 DEVON DR -- Letter of Completeness Dear TImothy A Johnson The Plannmg Staff has entered your apphcatlOn mto the Department's filmg system and assIgned the case number FLS2004-05028 After a prehmmary review of the submItted documents, staffhas determmed that the applIcatIOn IS Comvlete The Development ReVIew CommIttee (DRC) will review the apphcatIon for sufficlencv on July 08, 2004, III the Plannmg Department conference room - Room 216 - on the .'iecond floor of the MUlllclpal Services BUlldmg The bUlldmg IS located at 100 South Myrtle Avenue m downtown Clearwater Please call Sherry Watkms, AdminIstrative Analyst, at 727-562-4582 no carher than one week pnor to the meetmg date for the approximate time that your case will be reViewed You or your representatIve (as applicable) must be present to answer any questions that the DRC may have regardmg your apphcatIon AddItIOnal comments may be generated by the DRC at the tIme of the meetmg If you have any questiOns, please do not heSitate to contact me at 727-562-4604 or John Schodtler@myelearwater com Smcerely yours, r;pw~ John Schodtler Development ReView SpecIah::.t Lellef oj Compleleneos - FLS2004-05028 - l(}l OFVOIv OR ;ll ~ ..... 11 m",ill~ I: 'GO ~~11J1I ~ :<.() 840M; 3 zG ~ '0(\ -1 AI :J: - <AJ ~ miji _8 (\ X r)> ~ rn ~ UI ~)> ~ z ~ ~8 jO~ i ~ ~ ! ti ~ ). .. '0~ ijj ~Q :<~ ulnl R 71 R ~ ~ ..,..,. ~!It ~;;I '" :i .- ":1 ~ ""AO' (Q LO 'r ~~ HOc7~ Ob"!it1ldl!"JI.~ ~~ ~~ue '-'- .<:) - W '~-'\.." 40 -':~1" 'J.., . I " ~ =f ~ ~.( -, .". { ~ { , Countywide Appraisal Corporation 1201 So. HIGHLAND A VENUE SUITE #6 CLEARWATER FL 33756 727446-6550 727-4468583 FAX WWW.APPRAISE.NET Lot 31 in Bayside Subdivision Devon Drive. Clearvvater FL Information report For: Mr. Christopher C. Mariani EXHIBIT "B" Countywide Appraisal Corporation REPORT FINDINGS Scope of investl2atlOn: To Inspect vacant lot at "Lot 3 I, Devon Dnve, Bayslde SubdivISion"' Clearwater Florida to determ Ine 1m pact, If any, of a proposed dock I have personally Inspected the above named vacant site, and have receIved a copy of the proposed marine dock plans, which I have also reviewed It IS my profeSSIOnal opinion that the proposed dock as desCribed 111 the plans dated February 3rd, 2004, (copy prOVided 111 this report), Will not slgmficantly Impair the value ofthe adjacent land or bUlld1l1gs The proposed dock plans are well wlthm the harmony, scale, bulk, covel age, denSity and character of adjacent properties along this street and those wlthm the subdiVIsion The proposed dock will be consistent With the commul1lty character In this nnmedlate vlcmlty I have been appralslllg reSidential Real Estate here m Pmellas County, full time, S1I1ce 1984 I am the owner of Countywide Appraisal CorporatIon located 111 Clearwater, I have been a full tune reSident of Clearwater S me I 979, and recently reSided In the Clearwater Beach area known as Island Estates J am qUite familial With real estate values and overall market mterests In thIs waterfront community My quailfications are attached SlI1cerely Yours, Phil A Cous au, CREA, eel Preslden tiC EO State CertIfied ReSidential Real Estate Appraiser #RD703 "'- I ~ \ '; .~~"'! /- .\ /~~"'/- . ,~ _ _/ </ _~~~;~ 3-" - ~<...,""~~~ ,,' \-"~y _~,~,'0.';" · - .' ~ . "'" . '" --------- "' . _ "",-"" ------------ . ~'~ ~ -----~ -~I "---~ ----~ -~ \ .~- \ ' . I \ \ r Subject's Proposed Doclf \ I " I \ ~. j. i \ . \ .~" \ I ::l I . . __. ", J. It I ~ .O-.Ob o-.Qb . t :z () ~ ~ ~r I ~~ g~ ~~ ,..:IrmrP7/w D!(iJflfir:::rrtlallw...PIIIl.... l:'t.I~'~d1.B: r:nJ:\A. eel ~ '" , Personsl Bn~llground: S tn ff A ppralser F londa Federn I S~V hlg; Bank ,SI Pclersburg., Flonda April 198 J Through Mardi 1985 ~ r~" A ppra I ser Soulheas\ern n.,,~ 1 Estale AppflIlsn I C~rporatjon _ St, Petetsburg, Florida Mnr~h 1986 Throul:h NlIvcmbar 1990 'Pr~sld~nVetO, Counlywlde Apprnls"1 C"rpctalllln . ClE!aJ:Water, Florida J u I)' 1990 Thrcugh Pies en! p""orCS:dnllil] f) rf;F.IulzBUI;:"'1~ Desl~t1~lIl1M. NallOrial Assoclalion Of Independent Fee Apprmsm AppC"'S~llnstllule N <l tl onoj ASSOCiation 0 f Rea I Estate Appraisers Amerl~i1n Aeader\'1Y Of State CertIfied App,alsers Not lonol Asso~ lallO 11 0 f Rea Itors N<1tlonal ASSOClollon Of Realtors (Appraisal SeclIoll) PI Or! da Ass 0 c la lion or Rea l!prs Ass o~ I all 0 n 0 f Cons(rUttlon Il1speclors Grealer C I earwnler AsgoclDt Ion Of Renllors Independenll'ee AIIPttUm IFA (pendll1ll) Slnle Certified Rl!.!Ilden\lml Appniser /lItO 0000703 Rnglslered ReHI HsIDt" Broker 11044"5 Cnrtlfled ltaBI ElII!l" Appmlser CREA Certified Conslruehon Inspeelor CCI J1;.~~ell t Sellllnns .'lr ('::011 rsu 'TAlten Course 101 To Appr~ISInl!. Preparing .BasIc EnvlronmenlBllllspe~llmls Res Id 81"111111 ConslrucllOn Prlm:lples &: PractIces Prlnelples &: Techniques or Appllllull\evlew A pprll15er CerLJ oculi an - CA I , Perfonnlng & Monllb't1ng Conslructlal1 Iflspe~lIOlls "rJl\cl pies &. Pr.ch~e5 . Real E51~ Ie BrQker VulunllOJI1 8tralegles In Dlvon;c Prine; p 10::5 & Pr~~t ices . Reall;$l~le Salesm.n Il..evlewlng Re5ldef1llal Appl1llsols 1-10"1 The Real E.llIlc Market Has Chunge!! Value.!' Appmlslng Condominiums A ppralsill ReGu I ~ [I 1;1 115 f Appra 15tt5 & Lendm ApprnlslI1g Fur Relocallon Pllrp05e5 Update & ReView OrThe URAR FOri" (tts!) HlIw Tu Be An w:pert WlI.\lel5 ApprOlsal Fraud Program Appm19lull Re~ldenllal lutlllr1t Property Envl10nmental Assessmenls - Apprar:;ers Role UnderstandIng 11le USPAP Appr\llsers Lmbllity U31ng 111e RtIvised UlIAR Form (06-93) PI eplrlng ReSldenllil1 NDrn.tlve Reports Morlgdge Underwrlllng, Appraisal Guldellnus A ppralslng V IClIn l Land ijlJl\' EnvIronmental Proh'ems Affect Value Pu rpOse 0 f The Cost A p'proach In Re~ Apprnlsals Legal Obllgallons IJf ApP/1lisers ConstructIOn Inspections (Pre-ReqUIsite for eel DC5fgllsllon) Wha t Do A ppra ISer~ I..ook For & Why (I ~poke on thl! \I1IlIello COlin,>, Il..eatlllrc wllh l'HA Chief Avvrnlscr and COllnly Propet1y Approlm) , 'r LI~t 0 r Armroyc[J \.lIen!, Please ask for must current revlEedllsl, (lengthy) Ph i I A COU$111 call, CR.EA, eel IS lhe owner of "CollnlywtdD Appraisal corporation", and hiS beeM aCllyely en goged in the Rea I Estate "Appraisal" Pro re~slon ~olcly ~Ilice 1963 The NIllOllul Assoclallon of Real Esl~tt Apl'raism, The Appraisal InsUlule, The SIgle Of Fl:Jtida Certinuulidn Borrrd 111 d The N DtlOllal Assoclntion or Independcnl Fee Appral3en- all have mandatory continuing ecfu~nJiol1 ~ rogrnm.l for both ~eMlfied and des Ignaled members L !laVD been Hnd conllnuH 10 be boUI d~5lgnnted Dntl cerllfied. ~1 'J1 'l i~ ~-=-~ STATE 01' I'LOJ:IID.ll, D~/l;;JrllnIHII of Busll1ess ond Pro!~.'l51{111~1 Regulolllln ~ lUUn ~l un IIF ^I F i 1 ^,,, ^~I'Il^1 llll ~u I \Ie 5 T 1l001l1Sn~1 :; r 01\ l!\ II U U f l ~ 0,'0 0 ~ -1771 . ,"/I.'t'I! OF FLORlDA Ar;1 tl b 90"i: 70- 1JKl'AllTDRT OF BUSr.mnJ9 MD PROPBSS~O~'~fGULATIOR ....., ....11: - 1tD703 .,'~ '~~jD4A);. 716D3:.l1U I ~ j ./ ~ CnTI1I':rlW~ -JtIl:~,t>>Bn~ 'Atll?lU\IBlI:R tzOUSINBAU, ,1'!lt.r.i!~PJf; ^.,.,...~ t~j'"r 1"1' .. "!'''' t 't. ~~JPil" , -I . .. "r1i~;'3f.'rW: +,..._~ J ..f....~l....~ ~ . , I S C!:R.TrF.t IOl ....01... ~... p~"Thl..",. o! "11 .. 7 S no. Ibpt...~:I.""o!"'bl NuY 30. ;l001 hlQ ~ r.UUhcuuU \.. 1001Pl XVd to .. tOO./CO/CO Sea grasses eXIst seaward of the seawall at the subject property (See attached envIronmental report) The proposed dock will lessen the Impact on sea grasses as compared wIth the dock that the applicant can bUild as a matter of nght The proposed dock Will result In no navigational conflicts and the length of the proposed dock Will not exceed 25% of the waterway By locating the proposed dock In the mIddle of the property, neither adjacent property IS unduly burdened The proposed dock meets the deviation cntena set forth In COC SectIon 3- 601 C 1 9 I) and II), either one of which IS a proper basIs upon which to grant this application 312608V1 RECLE~VE[o) MAY 18 2004 PLANNING DEPARTMENT CiTY OF CLEARWATER EXHIBIT D FIeld conditions at tlus SIte were as follows Depths at left sIde of proposed dock DIstance from seawall Depth Notes 0' 03' (0.1' MLW) 1 ' start of mod. sparse Halodule 4' start of dense Hal. 10' 09' (0 T MLW) very dense Halodule 20' 1.3' (11' MLW) " " 30' 1.8' (1 2' MLW) " " 40' 26' (2.4' MLW) << " 50' 35' (3.3~I,W) << " ...-&~---..-........~ 60' 4 3' (4.1 ' ML W) moderately sparse seagrass 62' __.YJ~fY 2Jarse seagrass - 70' 5 8' (5.6' ML W) no seagrass 80' 6.1' (5 9' MLW) 86' 6.3' (6.1' MLW) Depths at n ght SIde of proposed lIfts DIstance from seawall 0' 2' Depth 02' (00' MLW) Notes a few pIeces honzontal concrete nprap start of sparse Halodule moderate Ha/. dense Hal very dense Ha/ t"- u. "I' :J 4' 10' 05' (03' ML'N) 08' (0.6' MLW) 1 2' (1.0' ML W) 1.9' (1 7' MLW) 24' (22' MLW) 3 8' (3 6' MLW) " " 20' 30' 40' 50' 60' 62' 65' 70' 80' 86' 90' " ,. " " t"- tiL --..-- - ~ _ end.ofjense seagrass __----- ----~-~~_eDcluf aU seagrass 46' (44' MLW) 54' (52' MLW) 5 7' (5 5' ML W) end of adJ dock to nght (poles extend further), property curves to nght t sJrT:} COMMENTS: Seagrass beds are located along thIS entire property, and extend out to a maxImum of 65 ft from the seawall III the area of the proposed dock although it becomes sparse at apprOXImately 60 ft It IS the pohcy of thIS Department to limIt structures over seagrasses to 4 ft. In width and to place the term mal platforms and boat slIps beyond the limIts of the seagrasses wherever pOSSIble In the proposed locatIOn, the walkout would need to be lengthened by 10 feet to meet thIS critena. The applicant IS advIsed. however. that the proposed le~gth would be consIstent WIth the enVIronmental cntena of the Pmellas County Code If the dock were moved to the eastern sIde of the property where seagrasses end about 50 ft. from the seawall 2. The appltcant IS also adVIsed that It is the poltcy of this Department that all boat slips be located adjacent to the mam dock, and therefore one boat lift WIll need to be located on each sIde of the main dock. FINDINGS: No findmgs are bemg Issued at thIS tIme pendmg receipt of a formal applicatIOn. The applIcant IS advised that approvals for thIS prOject may alsoDe reqUIred from the Flonda Department of EnVIronmental ProtectIon and the U S Army Corps of EnglOeers Any modIficatIOns reqUIred by these agencies must be reflected in reVIsed plans submItted to the County. STR S 1/2 8-29-15 maname2 doc I r 7 1(7 MapQuest Maps pont Page 1 of 1 " -: 'MAPe\.lESfa = ~~ The 2004 E1ntertainment8 - - Savings IBou'k is Here! ~ Send To Printer Back to MaD 193 Devon Dr Clearwater FL 33767-2439 US 0.,' Get Sn~ lOp to 150% Oft AlJDtJSt Everywben 0." StQ.OO Off! "liJJ!Jo n& Shipping!' I,~ "Ya \' \\ ~ ... ' l4'"'o..i-- i\ - "'",,- '~ ~ !I\ ~~ Notes: ----~- ---~ .~-- CUek Here For Gr'eat Savings! - - - ~ ~ '" - - -~--- -- .Vt'S'f - .: (Ol ::SOOm '~ 02004 MaDQuasllXlm, Ino 02004 NallQiJtDn TechnobOIB$ All rlohts reserved Use Subject to Llcense!CODyrlQht I MaD Leoend ~ H^y"'j"~el-l ~ .'W1~"~ This map Is InformatIOnal only No representatIon IS made or warranty given as to Its content User aS5lJrnes all risk of use MapQuest and Its suppliers assume no responsibility for any loss or delay resulting from such use Prlvacv Pollcv & LeQ,]1 NotIces @ 2004 MapQuest com. Inc All rights reserved, bttp //www mapquest com/maps/pont adp?mapdata=bLaOkxtG3xs72QcY6LF%252f6wWt 3/1 0/2004 . I, PRIVATE DOCK Application # (OFFICIAL USE ONLY) MHW l.> MLW'-l -------~ BOTTOM Profile View ENG. SCALE: 1" = La . I';' 30' TOTAL SQUARE FEET NEW SQUARE FEET WATERWAY WIDTH WATERFRONT vrIDTH \ \ \ \ \ -"~- ~ /f" r { I I f ~;l..' I { I { { { ~ Plan VIew (applicant and adjacent doc s) l~ /1-( "I" f;1.: ~I 1.II'..j f3' 12' t , ) \ \ \ \ \ 71 A \ \ \ 6'"' ~ '-l -- (.,~ SHORELINE -:f! - it::. -'I I J '-Lge '-\88 510 { 2.0 I A: Bofj B ' /lJ'L lj ~ !J. c: 3' ~ -'18 g Left Owner Right Owner The underslgned does not obJect to the proposed dock and requested variances as drawn m the space provided above Slguature Date MumClpahty Approval Signa ture Date Water and NaV1gation Approval _ _ _ _ _ ~ _ __ __ ;"tt.!lq...ll m ~:ii-o 1: mU)~ ~ ~,,() z .- m -0 m ~ < () S q()lf\ z Z rn ~ ,,0 'I ~ ~ (\ o _:I z < ~ S m(j\ (\3: ~~ qe.'-O" & r)> i~ UI ~~ I :t:)o utnl a n1" . ~R ~ I ' II^ ~ ::t r 0 q::) .e- x j!! ~ ~ .\p ~ ~ .t>. ,..... 0- 13.<<nc.J L..OT 92 ~Ob5' , I"Ildo: >< 9't ! Jj " tr:l >< ~ - ~ - .-i > . , 1-' rl"'r, II '(.^-l T_ t I ,t.J:. OF/1ft -.... \\~~ ~","U"..~i::7.~-_ ~~,.>" yff1A~._~":. ....G.' II, -", ",,- .. ..."..........---...; ':. .- -; ..~.- -~<t:.. ...~;. === Q.. ':..~ '"- -==- " ;::;:... -T.L')...,.- "r-,........" -:':f ~~~~JUI~I~)~~~\ ....-__:4TE'i\"". -".,." CITY OF CLEARWATER LoNG RA.'GE PlA..'1Nl'G DEVELOp\IE\'T REvIEW HOUSING DMSION NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES PlANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MU'llCIPAl SERVICES BUILDING, 100 SOUTH MYRTlE AVE.''UE, ClEARWATER, fWRlDA 33756 TELEPHOi'<E [i27) 562-4567 FAX (J27) 562-4576 July 22, 2002 Mr_ Timothy Johnson Johnson, Blakely, Pope, Bokor, Ruppel & Bums, P A 911 Chestnut Street Clearwater, FL 33756 RE. Development Order regardmg case R.S 02-01-03 at 193 Devon Dnve Dear Mr Johnson' ThiS letter constItutes a Development Order pursuant to SectIon 4-202 E of the Commumty Development Code On February 14, 2002, the Development ReVIew Conuruttee (DRe) revIewed your apphcatIon for FleXIble Standard Development approval to mcrease the length of a dock from 60 feet (50 'percent of the wIdth of the property) to 92 feet (766 percent of the wIdth of the property) under the prOVISIOns of Section 3-601 The apphcatlOn mcludes a 440 square foot dock and two 532 square foot covered boathfts to be located a mmm1Um of 30 feet from the SIde (east and west) property hnes The DRe recommended approval of the apphcatlOn WIth COndItionS I concur WIth the findmgs of the Development ReVIew Comnuttee and, through thIS letter, approve your apphcauon for FleXible Standard Development WIth the followmg bases and condmons Bases for approval 1 The proposal complies WIth the Rexlble Standard Development cntena under the prOVISIOns of SectIOn 3-601 C g, 2 The proposal, as amended, IS III comphance with other standards In the Code mcludmg the General Applicability Cntena per SectIOn 3~913, and 3 The development, as amended, IS compatible wlth the surroundmg area B~II."\ I AI "\(,\1 \hHlH (., J\\III\\I!lr>,i I{ r n H II{ r VII F \t\\{)R (O\l\lI\"II )"\1 I{ \\ Ull "\f.' GR.I' \...UII'll\\IO"\1 I{ Hun H '\.lllt 10"\ li )11 111\"\J()"\ f. I{ @ BIIJ J ()"\\()"\ CUll 11[\'il )"\1 ~