10/25/2018 Sister Cities Advisory Board Meeting Minutes October 25, 2018
City of Clearwater
City Hall
112 S. Osceola Avenue
Clearwater, FL 33756
ap
m
Meeting Minutes
Thursday, October 25, 2018
4:00 PM
Council Chambers
Sister Cities Advisory Board
Page 1
City of Clearwater
Sister Cities Advisory Board Meeting Minutes October 25, 2018
Roll Call
Present 4 - Acting Chair Hoyt Hamilton, Board Member Candace Hays, Board
Member Pamela Gene Benton, and Board Member Michael Ballard
Absent 3 - Chair Terrence Gourdine, Vice Chair Sallie Parks, and Board Member
Hannah Joseph
Also Present - Natalie Lamb —Volunteer and Environmental Lands Coordinator,
Patricia O. Sullivan - Board Reporter
1. Call To Order
Acting Chair Hamilton called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. at City Hall.
To provide continuity for research, items are in agenda order although not necessarily
discussed in that order.
2. Approval of Minutes
2.1 Approve minutes from August 23, 2018 Special Sister Cities Advisory Board Meeting
It was noted the amount of money CSCI (Clearwater Sister Cities, Inc.)
raised and donated was misstated on pages 3 and 4, the correct amount
was $2,200.
Member Benton moved to approve minutes of the August 23, 2018
Sister Cities Advisory Board special meeting as corrected. The
motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
3. Citizens to be Heard Regarding Items Not on the Agenda
Visiting exchange teacher Takafumi Yamada said he taught English at
Sabu High School in Nagano, Japan. He spoke about his itinerary visiting
Pinellas County schools and experiences he had enjoyed at the schools
and in Clearwater. He thanked the City for its kind, warm reception and the
opportunity for him to visit as an exchange teacher. He said he was having a
good time and appreciated the hospitality of the teachers and his host family.
Geri Craven said she was an exchange teacher in Nagano last year and
discussed her experiences in Nagano and teaching at about 20 schools.
She said the father of her host family was a Buddhist priest and they lived
on the grounds of a Buddhist temple. She said Nagano residents were
quite hospitable and she enjoyed her time there.
4. New Business Items
Page 2
City of Clearwater
Sister Cities Advisory Board Meeting Minutes October 25, 2018
4.1 Discuss Bourges, France as a Potential New Sister City
Volunteer and Environmental Lands Coordinator Natalie Lamb said the
Deputy Mayor of Bourges, France had emailed the City expressing interest
in forming a relationship with Clearwater. Monin, Inc., a Clearwater
manufacturing firm with approximately 100 employees, was headquartered
in Bourges. She had several conversations with the Deputy Mayor via
phone and Skype. Bourges was interested in expanding its athletic,
cultural, and business ties with Clearwater and establishing a connection
between Bourges and Clearwater students via Skype and a student foreign
exchange program.
Discussion ensued with comments that the City already had a significant
financial commitment maintaining its long-term relationship with Nagano
and that a relationship with Bourges may not require a financial commitment
from the City. It was noted Bourges was rural, about 100 miles from Paris,
and similar in size to Clearwater. Support was expressed for a Sister City
relationship with Bourges. It was commented the current program was
wonderful but limiting, adding Bourges would not diminish the City's
relationship with Nagano but could increase community involvement with
the City's Sister City program. It was stated a Sister City relationship with
Bourges would benefit the Pinellas County school's French language
program, Japanese was not taught. It was suggested a relationship with
Bourges may open opportunities for French speaking students to intern
at the Monin plant and encourage corporate interaction with Clearwater
and Pinellas County schools. It was felt a corporate relationship with
Bourges would be worth investigating once costs were identified. Bourges'
expectations were questioned.
Ms. Lamb said she would discuss the concept with the Mayor and City
Manager. Bourges was enthusiastic about developing a relationship with
Clearwater.
4.2 Discuss Nagano High School visit in October 2018
Ms. Lamb reviewed the itinerary for the 5 female Nagano high school
students and teacher who arrived in Clearwater on October 20, 2018.
During this visit, students spent more time at schools and interacting with
their host families than touring the area. She invited members to attend the
Sayonara party and thanked Member Benton for all of her work arranging
school visits.
It was reported that language teachers reported having a great time with the
students and Countryside High School students were excited about their
interactions. It was stated several Japanese students attended
Countryside's Homecoming Dance with their teacher acting as chaperone.
It was noted the exchange program resulted in lasting friendships.
Page 3
City of Clearwater
Sister Cities Advisory Board Meeting Minutes October 25, 2018
4.3 Discuss Nagano Middle School visit in February, 2019
Ms. Lamb said Nagano Middle School students will visit Clearwater from
February 8 to 13, 2019. Staff will reach out to the community for homestay
families. Members were invited to the Sayonara party.
Ms. Lamb said it was unlikely future Middle School student visits could
be scheduled in the fall or combined with High School student visits.
Concern was expressed it had become harder to attract Young Ambassador
participants, a fall visit from Nagano would promote the program and
encourage more students to apply, applications were due prior to February
visits. It was noted only one Sayonara party would be needed if Nagano
Middle and High School students visited at the same time. It was stated that
exchange students bonded with their foreign counterparts and it was hoped
that Young Ambassador families would host visiting students.
Concern was expressed it already was difficult to attract host families for
separate visits. It was stated that schools were busy in October with magnet
fairs and thespian festivals and schools would not host visiting students
when testing preparation and testing were underway. It was questioned if
parents of high school foreign exchange students would be willing to host
visiting students after their own children had graduated and left home. It was
recommended that Young Ambassador host families be identified before
scheduling changes were considered
Ms. Lamb said she was the only staff member working on Sister City
visits. The logistics of hosting Middle and High School students at the
same time would be difficult to plan and manage.
4.4 Discuss Council visit to Nagano in October 2019
Ms. Lamb said the City Council's visit to Nagano and Japan was
tentatively scheduled for October 18— 27, 2019. She will share information
about ticket prices and the itinerary when it becomes available. Delegation
members will represent Clearwater and need to travel together and
participate in all scheduled meetings and events. She asked Board members
interested in joining the trip to contact her. CSCI representatives could
participate in an official capacity, the trip was not open to the public.
Additional information will be presented at the next meeting.
5. Old Business Item: None.
6. Director's Report
Board Member/CSCI Representative Hays thanked Ms. Lamb for scheduling
the Young Ambassadors at a City Council meeting. She expressed concern
the Proclamation did not include requested language recognizing CSCI as a
City sanctioned program. Ms. Lamb said the City was provided the CSCI
Page 4
City of Clearwater
Sister Cities Advisory Board
Meeting Minutes October 25, 2018
language; the Mayor wrote the Proclamation.
It was noted CSCI had been recognized as a City sanctioned program
even though the Proclamation did not include that language.
Ms. Hays reported CSCI raised less money this year than last year at their
annual Hamburger Mary event. She said CSCI had discussed asking the
City to match the organization's fundraising efforts. She suggested leftover
money budgeted for the high school trip could be used for Young
Ambassadors' scholarships. She reported the recycling perks program had
ended.
It was suggested Ms. Lamb could check if the recycling perks program
would reopen.
7. Board Members to be Heard
Member Benton said interviews were scheduled for next year's teacher
exchange program to Nagano. She said costs incurred by participants
limited the number of potential applicants.
Concerns were expressed re Chair Gourdine's absence. It was requested
that staff check on him.
8. Adjourn
Attest:
The meeting adjourned at 4:45 p.m,
Chair - Sister Cities Advisory Board
Page 5
City of Clearwater