06/21/2005
..
.
.
.'
SENIOR CENTER TASK FORCE MEETING MINUTES
CITY OF CLEARWATER
June 21, 2005
Present:
Debra Shade
Dr. William E. Haley
Dolores "Dee" Fry
Dr. William E. Hale
Mayme Hodges
David Nisivoccia
Lynne E. Robinson
Walt Schoenig
Chair
Vice-Chair
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Absent:
Evelyn R. Bethell
Rachel Bryan
Reverend Herb Freitag
Stuart Jonap
Shirley Hill Moran
Ron Whitcomb
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Task Force Member
Also present: Eleanor Breland
Kathy Baird
Patricia O. Sullivan
Equity Services Director
Senior Staff Assistant
Board Reporter
The Chair called the meeting to order at 9:11 a.m. at the Long Center.
To provide continuity for research, items are in agenda order although not
necessarily discussed in that order.
1 - Approval of Minutes - June 7,2005
Task Force Member Haley moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June
7,2005, as submitted in written summation to each board member. The motion was duly
seconded and carried unanimously.
2 - Clearwater Parks & Recreation Senior Proarammina Statistics - report to be submitted.
3 - Preparation of Outline for Task Force final report
The Chair distributed a draft outline of the report, including a completed cover page.
Discussion ensued with comments, recommendations, additions, and offers to draft
sections:
Chair Shade accepted responsibility for writing the cover letter to thank the City Council
for the opportunity to serve on the Task Force and to include bulleted points emphasizing
Clearwater's demographics, with the highest number of seniors in the country, their contribution
to the community through volunteerism, and the economic impact of their presence, including
the taxes they pay and disposable income they spend locally.
Task Force - Senior Center 2005-06-21
1
'-
.
Equity Services Director Eleanor Breland reported the Human Resources Department is
developing a job description for the Task Force recommended position, a professional director
on aging issues. The information will be submitted to the City Manager. He then will determine
if he supports the request and if he will present it to the City Council.
Staff will compile the final draft report with a standard font and "voice" and distribute it to
Task Force members for review and input. Exhibits will not be resent and copywrited materials
will not be copied. Ms. Breland has maintained a master file of all distributions for submission to
the City Council.
It was recommended that the cover letter and executive summary be brief, with the
remainder of the report demonstrating that the Task Force has performed its due diligence. It
was recommended that the report and exhibits be presented in a folder, decorated with a
collage of photographs of faces representing the diversity of the City's Senior population, which
ranges in age from 55 to over 100.
I. Purpose of Task Force
Section completed, based on original letter from the City related to Task Force activities.
II. Executive Summary
Chair Shade accepted responsibility for completing this section.
. III. Members
Section completed.
IV. Meeting Schedule
Section completed.
V. Review of Clearwater Senior Demographics and Economics
Vice-Chair Haley accepted responsibility for completing this section, to include
information on the demographics of the City's population, including enclaves.
It was recommended that pie charts and other visual devices related to current and
projected demographics would provide a wake up call regarding the City's Senior population.
This information would allow the City to proactively address future Senior needs. It was
recommended that demographic and economic issues be presented separately.
VI. Review of Other Senior Centers I Costs
Member Nisivoccia accepted responsibility for completing this section with information
on Senior Centers, including comparisons of budgets, staff, organization, and services. It was
suggested that this report should be longer than two pages.
.
Task Force - Senior Center 2005-06-21
2
.
.
.
~
VII. Review of Services / Programs for Seniors in Clearwater
A. Recreational services/programs
Recreation Supervisor Dawn Lewellyn was tasked with completing this section, reporting
on recreational services/programs available for Seniors in Clearwater, such as library and Parks
& Recreation Department programs.
B. Social services/programs.
Member Fry accepted responsibility for completing this section.
Social services help prevent the institutionalization of Seniors. The report will review
available social services/programs such as Meals on Wheels, home health care, transportation,
home services, personal care, homemaker services, pest control, etc., regardless of which
agency or private firm provides the service. The report should indicate if the availability of
services is sufficient to meet the needs of Clearwater Seniors.
It was recommended that a gap analysis separately identify shortfalls to funding, such as
the current 350-person waitlist for Meals on Wheels services and other unmet transportation
needs, as well as shortfalls of necessary services.
VIII. Review of Funding for Senior Services in Pinellas County
Chair Shade accepted responSibility for completing this section.
(Review of Potential Funding Resources)
Vice-Chair Haley recommended this section would help the City Council to realize that
the whole process does not have to start from scratch.
After discussion, the members determined that it would not be advisable to make such a
report at this time due to the insufficiency of information at hand.
IX. Recommendation / Conclusions
Member Schoenig accepted responsibility for completing this section.
The Task Force has recommended that the City create an Office on Aging within
Clearwater, and fund a position for a professional director on aging issues, as a recurring
budget item, and appoint an advisory board on aging to make recommendations to the director
on Senior issues and to act as a resource. Task Force members could serve on the advisory
board. It was recommended that qualifications for the professional director position require
visionary leadership skills and a core competence on aging issues.
Also recommended was a needs assessment, which includes a survey of community
Seniors, before it is determined if a Senior Center is needed. It was recommended the report
indicate that the Task Force did not recommend a Senior Center at this time as they felt they did
not have sufficient information to make such a significant recommendation. More information
Task Force - Senior Center 2005-06-21
3
< .
.
.
.
first must be gathered via a concentrated department effort. The breath of needs is so great
that the Task Force could not determine which social or recreational services, or combination of
both, are most important and/or needed. City recreation centers currently have available space.
Multiple centers with different uses could be considered. All Senior services need to be
coordinated and tracked so that needs are properly targeted. The changing interests of younger
Senior populations need to be considered.
It was recommended that medical services, health screening, and some health delivery
be a component of aging issues in the City. The City has three different populations of Seniors,
ranging from baby boomers to the frail elderly. Activity needs and social consciousness differ
between the populations. It was suggested the City's Office on Aging could collaborate with the
Alzheimer's Association to provide screening. It was stated the geriatric screening program at
Morton Plant Hospital is a great resource.
Information related to a Senior Center location as well as collaborative opportunities and
strategic alliances will be submitted to the new staff position.
x. Exhibits
Ms. Breland accepted responsibility for completing this section.
Final Discussion
Drafts are due to Ms. Breland by July 11, 2005. Staff will distribute copies of the draft to
Task Force members by July 18, 2005, with member comments due back to staff by July 20,
2005. The Chair will make a final review of the document to ensure against contradictory
statements. The final report will be completed by the end of July 2005.
The draft document will be distributed prior to the final Task Force meeting on August 2,
2005, at 11 :00 a.m., at the East Library.
The City Manager will review the final report and may meet with the Chair or Vice-Chair
with comments and/or questions. The report will be presented to the City Council on September
1, 2005, via a Power Point presentation. A copy of the presentation needs to be submitted to
the City Clerk prior to the meeting.
Discussion ensued regarding funding issues, with comments that the number of people
requiring services continues to increase while levels of available funding remain stagnant.
Funding levels have not kept pace with increased life expectancy. It was suggested there has
not been a groundswell of protests from Seniors as they have struggle with other issues, such
as the rising cost of medication and health care access. It was stated that the County has 36
taxing authorities, for libraries, the JWB (Juvenile Welfare Board), etc., and previously has
opposed any set aside to meet Senior needs. It was noted other States have taxing districts to
fund senior issues.
Task Force - Senior Center 2005-06-21
4
'. '
.
.
.
.
It was felt the City should be proactive regarding Senior issues and that the community
needs to address local issues. It is much less expensive for society when Seniors remain in
their homes, active, paying taxes, volunteering, and participating in the community, instead of
relying on expensive, tax-funded nursing home care. Special State allocations currently are
difficult to obtain.
4. Adjournment
eting adi7d at 10:08 a.m.
~~Ad(
Task Force - Senior Center
Task Force - Senior Center 2005-06-21
5