11/20/2012COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING MINUTES
CITY OF CLEARWATER
November 20, 2012
Present: Chair Nicholas C. Fritsch, Vice-Chair Thomas Coates, Member Frank L.
Dame, Member Brian A. Barker, Member Kurt B. Hinrichs, Member Norma R. Carlough,
Acting Member ponald van Weezel
Absent: Member Richard Adelson
Also Present: Attorney for the Board Gina Grimes, Assistant City Attorney Leslie
Dougall-Sides, Planning & Development Assistant Director Gina Clayton, Development
Review Manager Robert Tefft, Board Reporter Patricia O. Sullivan
A. CALL TO ORDER, INVOCATION, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Chair called the meeting to order at 1:00 p.m.
B. ROLL CALL: Chair Fritsch Vice Chair Coates Members Adelson Barker
Carlouqh, Dame, Hinrichs, Alternate Member van Weezel, City Staff
C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING: October 16 2012
Member Dame moved to approve the minutes of the regular Community Development
Board meeting of October 16, 2012, as recorded and submitted in written summation to
each board member. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
D. CONSENT AGENDA: The followinq case is not contested by the applicant,
staff, neiqhborinq propertv owners, etc. and will be approved bv a sinqle
vote at the beqinninq of the meetinq: (Item 1)
1. Case: CPA2012-10002 - Amendments to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan
Level Three Ap lication
A�plicant: City of Clearwater
Reguest: Amendments to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan amendinq certain
provisions of the Utilities Element related to potable water and natural qround
water aquifer recharqe needs based on the city's 2012 Potable Water Supply
Facilities Master Plan Update and updatinq Map #D-2 Potable Water Wells and
Wellhead Protection Zones.
Neiqhborhood Association: Clearwater Neiqhborhoods Coalition
Presenter: Lauren Matzke, AICP, Lonq Ranqe Planninq Manaqer
See Exhibit: Staff Report CPA2012-10002 2012-11-20
Community Development 11/20/2012
Member Coates moved to approve Case CPA2012-10002 on today's Consent Agenda
based on evidence in the record, including the application(s) and the Staff Report, and
hereby adopt the Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law stated in the Staff Report,
with conditions of approval as listed. The motion was duly seconded and carried
unanimously.
E. LEVEL TWO APPLICATION (Item 1):
1. Case: FLD2012-08015 - 300 Venetian Drive Level Two Application
Owner: Nick Szirmai Venetian Shores Condo Assoc. President
Aqent: Lisa Ryan; Advanced Marine Construction (1041 Harbor Lake Drive,
Safet� Harbor, FL 34695; phone: (727) 712-3909�
Location: A 0.498 acre waterfront lot located on the north side of Venetian Drive
at the northeast corner of Venetian Drive and Venetian Point Drive/Sunset Drive.
Atlas Paqe: 259B
Zoninq: Medium Density Residential (MDR) District.
Request: Flexible Development application to permit a 96 square-foot addition to
an existinq 852 s uare-foot Multi-Use Dock as accessory to an existinq attached
dwellinq with a decrease in the side (west) setback from 32 feet (one-third of the
width of the property) to 10 feet to an extension of an existinq catwalk and 12
feet to a proposed boatlift associated with slip seven and approximately 26 feet
to a proposed boatlift associated with slip six, a decrease in the side east)
setback from 9.5 feet (one-tenth of the width of the property) to five feet to a
proposed davit and an increase in the maximum width of a dock from 71.25 feet
(75 percent of the width of the property) to 75 feet (78.9 percent of the width of
the propert�), under the provisions of Communit� Development Code (CDC�
Section 3-601.C.3.
Existinq Use: Attached Dwellinqs
Neiqhborhood Association: Old Clearwater Bay Clearwater Neiqhborhood
Coalition
Presenter: Mark T. Parrv. AICP. Planner III
See Exhibit Staff Report FLD2012-08015 2012-11-20 and Exhibit FLD2012-08015
2012-11-20.
Member Coates moved to accept Mark Parry as an expert witness in the fields of
redevelopment planning, comprehensive planning, annexation implementation, zoning,
land use/rezoning applications, land development general planning code amendments,
landscape ordinance, and special area plans/overlay districts. The motion was duly
seconded and carried unanimously.
Community Development 11/20/2012 2
Russell Latimer requested Party Status.
Member Coates moved to grant Russell Latimer Party Status. The motion was duly
seconded and carried unanimously.
Planner III Mark Parry reviewed the staff report. Staff recommended denial and
reducing the scope of the application. In response to questions, Mr. Parry said the
proposed davits and two outer catwalks do not meet Code criteria. Davits for Slip 2
would meet side setback requirements. Existing catwalks would not have to be
removed as they are considered an existing non conformity. The staff report includes
conditions of approval should the board approve the requests.
Lisa Ryan, of Advanced Marine Construction, representing the applicant, said the
current dock, built in 1989, was permitted by Clearwater and Pinellas County but under
current rules is non conforming. She said safety is an issue during low tide when water
levels in the cove are low. She said the subject slips are small and most boats must
enter bow first. She said it is difficult for boaters to maneuver when they board or exit
vessels; catwalk extensions would ease these difficulties. She said davits would be
permanently affixed and extend into the side setback when they swing in and out. She
said the homeowners association to the east has granted permission to install davits on
the east slip. She said the single family residence on the west has a boat lift on its
eastern property line. She said the applicant, who owns Slip 8, only proposes to extend
the catwalk. She said boat lift requests are for inside slips. She submitted a petition
signed by neighbors indicating no objection to the request. She said no one was at the
adjacent homes when she sought signatures.
It was commented that none of the petition signatories lived near the subject property
and would not be affected by proposed changes.
Party Status Holder Russell Latimer said since this safe harbor was built nearby
construction has filled the cove with silt. He said water was sufficiently deep when the
subject docks were constructed but boaters now struggle to board and exit their
vessels. He supported the request as pilings already are in place and people are
endangered and could be injured when they must leap between their boats and the
docks. He said few area docks conform to Code.
In response to questions, Mr. Parry said applications must comply with all deviation
standards. The center catwalks could be extended. The outer catwalks would cause
the width of the docks to exceed Code by 4 feet and are not permitted as a matter of
right. The Planning Department did not receive any letters of objection.
Ms. Ryan said FDEP (Florida Department of Environmental Protection) and the Army
Corps. of Engineers had issued permits for the changes; Pinellas County did not object
to the request. She said each slip is owned by individual condominium owners.
Community Development 11/20/2012 3
Party Holder Latimer reiterated his support for the application.
Discussion ensued with comments that the request addresses a safety issue related to
shallow water, which requires boaters to access watercraft via the bow rather than the
stern. It was indicated that Clearwater is a boating community and should support
boating activities. It was stated this morning and in the photograph, some boats were
backed into slips. Concern was expressed that approval would add to a non conforming
situation and side extensions should not be approved. Opposition was expressed to
davits proposed for Slip 1 as they would infringe on the required setback. It was felt as
a practical matter and due to safety concerns, the catwalks, extended within acceptable
outlines, would not infringe on property owners to the left or right. It was agreed that the
cove has many non conforming docks and it was felt that adding inches to a 75-foot
wide deck would be negligible.
In response to questions, Marine & Aviation Department Director Bill Morris said the
MAB (Marine Advisory Board) does not consider residential dock requests; the subject
dock is in a residential area. As Harbormaster, he had no problem with most of the
request based on his concerns for the safety of boaters boarding and exiting vessels
when the water is shallow but expressed concern requested davits would extend into
the side setback. He said boat sterns backed into slips sit on the bottom during low tide
and stir up silt when departing, which contributes to silt accumulation against the
seawalls. Residents would be responsible for costs to dredge the cove, which would be
expensive and not successful if done for only one property.
Member Dame moved to approve Case FLD2012-08015 based on the evidence and
testimony presented in the application, the Staff Report and at today's hearing, and
hereby makes the following Findings of Fact based on said evidence: literal
enforcement of the provisions of this section would result in extreme hardship due to the
unique nature of the project due to the shallow depth of the water and the requested
extension sought to be granted is the minimum deviation that will make possible the
reasonable use of the applicant's property with the exception of the request for davits on
the east side of the dock and to permit extension of two outer catwalks and installation
of boat lifts in Slips 6 and 7 and hereby issue the Conclusions of Law that the
application complies with the City Community Development Code Section(s) 3-
601.C.3.i.(iii and iv), and adopt Staff's submitted Conditions of Approval. The motion
was duly seconded. Members Coates, Dame, Barker, Hinrichs, Carlough, and Acting
Member van Weezel voted "Aye"; Chair Fritsch voted "Nay." Motion carried.
Community Development 11/20/2012 4
F. DIRECTOR'S ITEM: (Item 1)
1. Charity
The majority of the board voiced support of HEP (Homeless Emergency Project) to be
the board's holiday charity. Staff will provide a wish list of needs to board members
G. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 2:25 p.m.
„`�- " • '�-' , C,� �`�' i
�. Chair t
Commun Development Board
Community Development 11/20/2012 5
LL
V
} -�e�r�a �r
�
U
Interdepartmental Corr�spondence Sheet
TO: Community Development Board Members
FROM: Robert Tefft, Development Review Manager
COPIES: Leslie Dougall-Sides, Assistant City Attorney; Susan Chase, Documents and Recards
Specialist, /Pat Sullivan, Board Reporter
SUBJECT: Agenda Items for
DATE: November 08, 2012
CDB packets being distributed contain the following
Site investigation form
Unapproved minutes of previous meeting October 16, 2012
Agenda
Level Two Applications (Items 1-2
1. Case: FLD2012-080 — 300 Venetian Drive
Yes No
2. Case: CPA2012-10002 mendments to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan
��
Yes No
Signature:
l�l��%� �--_�__
PRINT NAME
Date: � � ' � a ° C�
S: IPlanning DepartmentlC D BlAgendas DRC & CDBICDBI2012111 November 20, 2012V Cover MEMO 2012.doc
�
O
} �e�rwa �r
� _ _.
U
Interdepartmental Correspondence Sheet
TO: Community Development Board Members
FROM: Robert Tefft, Development Review Manager
COPIES: Leslie Dougall-Sides, Assistant City Attorney; Susan Chase, Documents and Records
Specialist, /Pat Sullivan, Board Reporter
SUBJECT: Agenda Items for
DATE: November 08, 2012
CDB packets being distributed contain the following
Site investigation form
Unapproved minutes of previous meeting October 16, 2012
Agenda
Level Two Applications (Items 1-2
1. Case: FLD2012-08015 — 300 Venetian Drive
Yes � No
2. Case: CPA2012-10002 — Amendments to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan
Yes No I
Signature: ��1—;1�'� Date: /�`�����-----
�F�� � - J�-�-�,�-
PRINT NAME
S: IPlanning DepartmentlC D BlAgendas DRC & CDBICDBI2012111 November 2Q 201211 Cover MEMO 2012.doc
LL
V
} ���� ��
H.,.. ,�,�,
U
Interdepartrnental Correspondence Sheet
TO: Community Development Board Members
FROM: Robert Tefft, Development Review Manager
COPIES: Leslie Dougall-Sides, Assistant City Attorney; Susan Chase, Documents and Records
Specialist, /Pat Sullivan, Board Reporter
SUBJECT: Agenda Items for
DATE: November 08, 2012
CDB packets being distributed contain the following
Site investigation form
Unapproved minutes of previous meeting October 16, 2012
Agenda
Level Two Applications (Items 1-2
1. Case: FLD2012-08015 — 300 Venetian Drive
Yes '/ No
2. Case: CPA2012-10002 — Amendments to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan
Yes No
Signature:
PRINT N
Date: j �' � � ' 1 �
S: IPlanning DepartmentlC D BlAgendas DRC & CDBICD812012111 November 20, 201211 Cover MEMO 2012.doc
LL
V
} ���� ��
H
U
Interdepartmental Correspondence Sheet
TO: Community Development Board Members
FROM: Robert Tefft, Development Review Manager
COPIES: Leslie Dougall-Sides, Assistant City Attorney; Susan Chase, Documents and Records
Specialist, /Pat Sullivan, Board Reporter
SUBJECT: Agenda Items for
DATE: November 08, 2012
CDB packets being distributed contain the following
Site investigation form
Unapproved minutes of previous meeting October 16, 2012
Agenda
Level Two Applications (Items 1-2
1. Case: FLD201 -08015 — 300 Venetian Drive
Yes No
2. Case: CPA2012-10002 — Amendments to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan
Yes v No
Signature:
Date• r! Z� l Z
<<� (L. � +�`a - t-�r\ �,I �, � C l-%.5
PRINT NAME
S: IPlanning DepartmentlC D BlAgendas DRC & CDBICD8120/2!11 November 2Q 2012V Cover MEMO 2012.doc
LL
�
� ��r�a er
U
Interdepartmental Correspondence Sheet
TO: Community Development Board Members
FROM: Robert Tefft, Development Review Manager
COPIES: Leslie Dougall-Sides, Assistant City Attorney; Susan Chase, Documents and Records
Specialist, /Pat Sullivan, Board Reporter
SUBJECT: Agenda Items for
DATE: November 08, 2012
CDB packets being distributed contain the following
Site investigation form
Unapproved minutes of previous meeting October 16, 2012
Agenda
Level Two Aqplications (Items 1-2
1. Case: FLD2012-08015 — 300 Venetian Drive
Yes No
2. Case: CPA2012-10002 — Amendments to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan
Yes � � No
Signature:
PRINT
Date• 11
S: IPlanning DepartmentlC D BlAgendas DRC & CDBICD812012111 November 2Q 2012V Cover MEMO 2012.doc
EXHIBIT: STAFF REPORT CPA2012-10002 2012-11-20
CDB Meeting Date
Case Number:
Ordinance No.:
Agenda Item:
November 20, 2012
CPA2012-10002
8368-13
E.1
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
STAFF REPORT
REQUEST: Clearwater Comprehensive Plan Amendments to the Utilities Element
to Update Provisions Related to Potable Water and Natural Ground
Water Aquifer Recharge Needs Based on the City of Clearwater's
2012 Potable Water Supply Facilities Master Plan Update, and
Updating Map #D-2 Potable Water Wells and Wellhead Protection
Zones.
INITIATED BY:
BACKGROUND:
City of Clearwater Planning & Development Department
Florida's Community Planning Act (Chapter 163, Florida Statutes (F. S.)) and Water Resources
Act (Chapter 373, F. S.) establish a process for water supply planning to ensure adequate water
supplies in the future. The state's water management districts must periodically evaluate whether
adequate water supplies exist to meet the needs of their areas. If a district finds that the water
supply will not be adequate, it must prepare a regional water supply plan, identifying alternative
ways in which water supply needs can be met for the ne�t 20 years.
The Southwest Florida Water Management District (SWFWMD), the city's regional district,
approved its updated Regional Water Supply Plan on July 26, 2011, which includes projected
water demands for the region and potential sources of water to meet these demands from 2010
through 2030. Section 163.3177, F.S., requires local governments to update their comprehensive
plans, including their 10 year Water Supply Facility Work Plans, to incorporate relevant water
supply options, conservation initiatives, and updated service area projections within 18 months
after the approval of the regional water supply plan.
The consulting firm of Tetra Tech, Inc. was retained by the city to complete the city's 2012
Potable Water Supply Facilities Master Plan Update. This plan was last updated in 2008
following the SWFWIVID's update to the regional water supply plan in 2006. The city adopted
significant amendments to the Public Utilities Element of the Comprehensive Plan in 2008 to
comply with the requirements in Section 163.3177, F. S., and was determined to be in compliance
by the Florida Department of Community Affairs (now Department of Economic Opportunity).
This amendment updates the Utilities Element by modifying policies related to the Potable Water
and Natural Ground Water Aquifer Recharge Needs subsection to include updated information
based on the 2012 Potable Water Supply Facilities Master Plan Update. This amendment also
Community Development Board — November 20, 2012
CPA2012-10002 — Page 1
EXHIBIT: STAFF REPORT CPA2012-10002 2012-11-20
updates Map #D-2 Potable Water Wells and Wellhead Protection Zones to reflect the locations
of the new wells constructed since the Comprehensive Plan and Map Series was amended in
2008.
ANALYSIS:
There are no substantial changes proposed within this amendment, which primarily incorporates
updated data from the 2012 Potable Water Supply Facilities Master Plan Update. The
amendments adopted in 2008 incorporated the city's 2004 Water Master Plan into the Utility
Element and ensured consistency with the requirements in the statutes for this required element;
therefore, this amendment involves updating existing policies, previously found to be in
compliance with state requirements, based on more current data.
Since 2008, the city has increased the number of wellheads operated by the city from 19 to 46,
thereby reducing the percent of water supply emanating from Pinellas County from 63 percent to
55 percent. The city's efforts implementing various conservation and consumption measures has
led to a reduced water consumption rate of 90 gallons/person/day, down from 100
gallons/person/day in 2008. Total number of customer accounts in the Clearwater service area
has increased almost four percent, from 40,390 to 41,973 since 2008.
This amendment involves updates to the following sections of the Utilities Element:
1. Introduction to the Utilities Element, Potable Water and Ground Water Aquifer Recharge
Needs subsection (pages D-3 and D-4 of the Comprehensive Plan), to include updated
data and references;
2. Objective D.5.2 and its policies (pages D-15 and D-16) to include updated data and
references;
3. Policy D.5.5.1 (page D-17) to reflect the adoption of Ordinance 8070-09, which modified
the requirements for a wellhead protection permit; and
4. Map D-2 Potable Water Wells and Wellhead Protection Zones to include new well
locations.
STANDARDS FOR REVIEW:
Pursuant to Community Development Code Section 4-603 F., no amendment to the
Comprehensive Plan shall be approved unless it complies with the following standards:
1. The amendment will further implementation of the Comprehensive Plan consistent with the
goals, policies and objectives contained in the Plan.
The proposed amendments to the Cleanvater Comprehensive Plan are consistent with
existing goals, objectives, and policies in the Plan. The proposed amendments, related to
water supply planning comply with statutory requirements and update the city's long range
planning policies related to the provisions for the city's water plan.
2. The amendment is not inconsistent with other provisions of the Comprehensive Plan.
Community Development Board — November 20, 2012
CPA2012-10002 — Page 2
EXHIBIT: STAFF REPORT CPA2012-10002 2012-11-20
The proposed amendments are not inconsistent with other provisions of the Comprehensive
Plan and bring further consistency between the goals, objectives and policies and the map
series.
3. The available uses, if applicable, to which the property may be put are appropriate to the
property in question and compatible with existing and planned uses in the area.
This is not applicable to the proposed amendments as they do not relate to a specific property
or properties.
4. Sufficient public facilities are available to serve the property.
This is not applicable to the proposed amendments as they do not relate to a specific property
or properties; therefore, the adequacy of available public facilities will need to be assessed on
a case-by-case basis as development proposals are received.
S. The amendment will not adversely affect the natural environment.
The proposed amendment includes updates to data and references for other related Plans.
The policies contained within the Utilities Element provide consistent and coordinated efforts
for the processes and procedures for water management within the area governed by the
Southwest Florida Water Management District (SWFWIVID).
6. The amendment will not adversely impact the use of property in the immediate area.
This is not applicable to the proposed amendments as they do not relate to a specific property
or properties.
SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION:
The purpose of this amendment is to update the Utilities Element, Potable Water and Natural
Ground Water Aquifer Recharge Needs subsection, to include updated information based on the
2012 Potable Water Supply Facilities Master Plan Update, as well as other updated data since the
Cleanvater Comprehensive Plan was amended in 2008, and ensures consistency with the
regional water supply plan as required in Section 163.3177, F. S. The proposed amendment is
consistent with and will further the goals, objectives and policies of the Clearwater
Comprehensive Plan, will not result in inappropriate or incompatible uses, will not adversely
affect the natural environment or impact the use of property in the immediate area, and sufficient
public facilities exist to implement the proposed amendment.
Based upon the above, the Planning and Development Department recommends APPROVAL of
Ordinance No. 8368-12 that amends the Cleanvater Comprehensive Plan.
Community Development Board — November 20, 2012
CPA2012-10002 — Page 3
EXHIBIT: STAFF REPORT CPA2012-10002 2012-11-20
Prepared by Planning and Development Department Stafi
Lauren Matzke, AICP, Long Range Planning Manager
ATTACHMENTS:
❑ Ordinance No. 8368-13
S: lPlanning DepartmentlCOMPREHENSIVE PLANI2012 Comp Plan AmendmentslCPA2012-10002 - Water Supply PlanlStaffReportlCPA2012-
10002 CDB StaffReport.doc
Community Development Board — November 20, 2012
CPA2012-10002 — Page 4
L 1 -'i"
��'7�
� {
�.
y ��. . . ' 3, ; a `..
■ ��E �r� �x � �
v 3't p �,
.. �s -�= �'� ��. ��'1' _ .�
�'�uh
. rt` .. � . �:t . ..
.'S � F.n
,- ,.. �•
. �:.I , � � . ..._ � . .-r,c�c.a� • s.
• • , ,
,.
� : �. . .. . .i . . . . ..... ....... .. . . . . . ..... . . .. ...... . ... ... .
.. A. :. _. . � • .
' � �'.. . ' . � . ,n �' � , ' _
- . . .. ' . . ..e�.... .. . � .. . .. .. ..... .. . ... . . _... ' ... ..
..� .. . ..__. _ _
•
�
_— . . ....
L. p : :
•_. - '- ..-r..: : . ... .' _ _ _ _ _
� .. .
� - ' ... . .• ....:
. ..�. . � �': . .. ::..
. .. ... . ..:. . .. ..:.. . ...... �... : . � .
. .. . . .... . � . . ... . . .
'.. , . ���� '. � '. ... [ . .. ... .. .. ... . ... ... .... .
r �� .
_ . . . . . ..... .
• ..... ...
,
. .. ... ....
- . _ r. _ -. -
, . _. -...._ ,... , .
zr ::... .-.;,....': .:. '. #. - - _
, _. .:: :.�.:: -
_ ::'-
,.
:....
,,
� F, �..��� ,�:'`. �. , .
�� �-,. ., •:
Y
� .: . .'': . . _ .
. . . ' , ' .- '- . ' . . '
� '�� • . ... :, . ' : l• ..... �. �. . ..... . .
._ ' ' _ ' ' " �'F" ' _ _' _ _�-' ___ _ _ ' '-T
�-
. I� t i ' c..• ' �I
. � . . .. . . . . . . � ,. , . . . . . . . .., � . _ . . . . .. .
Y.v"'o� +e/ Y�
. . . .. .. .:. .
.r: . :. ... ' - . . . .. ' . �. .
..�
n' '�i ' . . : ' �'! �: +�x�. %
. .. . . : . . . ' ! _
, .......:�'_--:..: .�..� .....: .r�..•"""""' .... ....:..�_ �• � - f .��$.:I
,'• ' I
' _ _ S_"'"� .... . . _ . � .. .- . . . .. _ _ i . _ _
� � . � . . . ��' .
' l. ":.
_ ...�i--. , : . - - .. .
. .-`,� .� . . . . "
11 . . . . . . .. . . . .. . ..... .
_ - 1 'i • _ _
. . .. _l. . . . . .. .
�% ' �� . � ,. %� , �. , �1 .:u�� � . . I . II • . . .
.._.. . .........:_. . _ . _
� . . . . ..; �. . .. _ . . _
, , ,. - •� . �.. ... . ,
i� � . .. '.i�� ' _ �.:. : ,. ' �< .-. .. . .. ,..��R''':":�F'• i::"'�'�".�:� 2<y���.
:�Zi " 'f" �£.: P. :`��. '9ZA': .�� �.C�,-.�'.','Y��':r�
-. . .. .. . _ �"��"' —_= 3'��'�5:.a,'w?3" -?r�rt�ini+�5.�v'��w. 'sF��a,�F � . .... . . ... _ . ..
�;:!aC: _���::ti:�:,�.l�z ��.;,.� .�3...�,},
�
I�
�
.y:� .• .y �.. �: � �'¢�;.2°; :".�i�: r;?- c-^� r; : ^:.r��.
i ;n. :t3�: i� �e .a, �r����s;
x.�.��a�i _���� '�° ��a�� '�;i�e.;�h:�eg;:�i ���ay.:��n'' .a;'�.,'.'�?5�$,�s,_•`,�s?
�:�:
�
,.... ..
.:.. "9
' Yi'. �''. I. '.I - '
_ -
_ .
�..
. r . x A:f:: �.::��.:?!i::.`...��.s�•.�.ri. �4?.14... �. x:^' �.i' : X!.` _
. . . - '. _ ' -----_ __ —p-� � _ _ _ -ai.:, ."sii'r: _ � _ _ _ �a . _ _.. . ..- ...... ......... `i
!
6�9.�+1� i4�7
�
,. �; � ' � : : :
� � ��� ,,` �'^
.�..
;��. ;
,. . �:� .
s.
��s;°.
i �`•.-
i :� -_�,.
,r �v !. �
�
�
-'�- ..�w' [ �� &`�. ^ki: °:f<:•r'i&' .;3. E�: s.�.: �'w:�i:".s�: �.; .�...�: ...qaau•_ �. �i:�,�•,. .�C� '45 q i'K� � _
_ g _ _
..=eS!7� ,a�^.� :.z, _ �"ti`_�.R.- ::L4.����:T§i t` .'S° .,. .,.._. . ��'::i . r`,h`��i� . _ _ �;�� a?cl�„� za• .-•;`:b ,<i•:�� .s�a� ,"P'.Y:' r: _ .
.. . .,:. : ..: .,
��{ :..., � , , . •
Y.. • . ' �� dri ''-..:.:!. .r' •• r:.. � . .�..: -. •.:.:.. � c. .'-:..x'.:n .. ;., . .R:'•I.' '+ y-�' •...d�
:...:.'.. ' '. .' V -���,�^�
:r :. . � ' .:... :'�:ir�{'.�.e�ezrrY' ��F�.N�V : �tn :i-�"'CiF` —].�Eac „.a.xnT�+2 . Y:•uM".vt�'I '':\: •! x �. ":'J ='.li :...
.. . ..::'•"s2'�:r.�:�.•;� ..
. � .. ``�', _�
r;-.�;�
_ .:.�.. _
k. �' :.. . . .
�:..� .. i . . y. . ...�f:�,.. :9. .. ' ....::.�....: � , .: ..
.y....--r`.ai� �' ` ea_•.a,� •.�'•:�.�.;.:.f o.. .
�;.: ,
' _ c`—��' .�-.a. " — -e_<, a.�+.w,� _ _L�a _ ,.� sS5 _ "" — — —'.- a
. .. . � . ... ...r�� .�,r. r
,.�i!l'�:...9_. ..' .. . .'3$..i4.".°:
� J�. � _ -�r.e ^�- .;s..: _ .
. .. � .{ � .. ` m:'vr 's�aa_ �r.a e � _ _. . _ ..�.�e. .� ,.�y. .,,,.., o....x..�.
AF.! �,
, .. �. . _
�� n, �' "
,',�:'-'. - .::...,..
_ ._.... � . ,.,� .;
�-�:�.sx�`. ..� �
U. � .
x_..,...._. .
��'�. �..�:
�
� �+: • aN �r
�i:;u'..•v
u.'" t��
-� A' -�`?.E :7 fR:
• ?'�. .� ; �ii
;� .�..�.:..l��_�..: ;: i;
�.���. ._.
;�¢.",, 31 -;j, . „
w h..s. �_, �. :.z y :. :. . __.:
� :{-
�
_ ..., ��� x_�;��"�� �:r,°' ii� �;
�
�
{ P _ -'�'yr�-�: ': " hi �..
� . - '-�abw a _ x„�....:��..... .� b . .a,. .r.a _.,... . �'....a:lh _ — — � _ ....�..f>: :�.-ralb`s+..r. e..�;as��
. cbv�__. :3a `• ��_ .,...a���,�.��,
�E�?r:Tf.+,�xa.r3i�
-e :. �?,i ;.�;.. '�a; . �� lii ;.. :0.�-.`�� ��s: � . ... �. ' i �.
�
IIY. '. '?� � .:f .�.i�...: i: . .
- . .. .. -. - _" ..u.w .w�... � ���_
� ._
��:�
- .a� ��„ , .�: -
N �.!�.: „ ��`sr..0 e. _._.;.� ..,.�.� 'a :K�.� ....
�.-. .�
�
�
�
�.�-�.;��; �� .�� � � ��.—.. f�_ - �s.��=�•��•. •s�
5 ,.�� ��...._S. F ��e�. . ...�+��'a . .ex ���" :2?i,s' "n.� fx . � � .e . .� . �:�`..F%�: „ ., fm .� . �e �
:.. . . .. . . . . .. . .. E:�R^:c:�S�.:..� . �:.aF:l�` . . �:�$.���s:�id�.�._'�. '�� .
t:r f5e.-:i�eist�:.=ct-��� nT,�
� �R,.rrCL'�I��.:S:l�r_�.vS`�?k':�;Y.S.:4iYx:�.sv:::;lx:.::•e;33fib`:;i'ial�lR5-7.:,�
..;'.��v:.3...� ���.��: "a.'�?i�3��;.r'�a'i
��
� �i�y� 1" �-�'r.w�� : p�'a Y.,�,� .w�'.—.��.�yr.�".:.a — s',p'.�'�;. ."��HF"
_ ... � w.x. .ih%i�xe.x .w.... _ ..c . .-�. ..... — . . .. _. . .. ..
_ 8'�.:*n _�_.. v� ' _ _ _ . - -
." �� . -��' �'.
.. . . . .t �'.. . .. .. . _ : R:� �`:.:� .
�
�.. - --� - " -- — �
.....a,,.a...�,_�.�.,,:-,..,r,.,....�,,. .. ..�.... V �� .
--
I�".`E ,f .:'�
' A ".._. _....... .. _. . ....._ _ ..., _ .
��
���
I : � re; .:�. . w �
^'k�: � . ... � � . . . - ... .
�
�' �. �: . - . . _
�i�' ��;"�: �'`;��::. °`�:�. `•�' �'SS ���' ,r�.�', i -.�;_ - �.i;`: ..�X` :R•`�{;� '.,�;z� ..i+'?F;.
��m j���.�., .1: .�.•: ...r:' z; 'a• �%9�:',�n,<'. - g�. ..�e: _ � :-.o_ �ro. _ �s - :.F:
r+'r:::i .� ..4:wc�.':�:,9::� ." i�:� :f ' -�'P li' ':':ti.., s
�
�
;s,
u: .�, , �
;' �' �'`�_
-�. �R—
�.<�.+..'''r.�.:.�
�
�:;:: .
�
,
:�
-= -�- __ .
' �
�
�
�
ti�;';:�, :�
�.. . �� [.
;�
�K:- � ;�
- ; �
�-: .. ' �' z ' � :. _ :�•_. ._ �:
: 3� � '.::...1�4
5f �� � '' .: �' ' . ' ' . , _ w
C3 p. ���i�: .. 'L� ';�.Q� :�L ��'� .'9Y � .i� , �.°: , �.�<.
�
:� .. _ �....r_ .s' .,... � �_. ..�—.,- � ...•�. . —a. -���. -�.. .�w�.i
;� , � :� � �-: . H, �� r`..� ,'�: .� :x�� •� � . �' .�`� � .�..
��,���. � _ . .
k , � „�- . ' . ,,� .'r �_ ; '�d,r .. �r
�!!'��:�._ .,. ....'�� .:�. ..,_..:� ..i� .,i .�a. `�.� ..
- :- �F �. - v �- �, gti - -.�,x - -m. .; - . ..d.. � .. .... _�,._
s'�, . ?`` ` M �.�'r ,� � .S� i 'g .. s �.z a�" '� � �� .:i�. ' - �. � �� .f• '�
��:.
� .��
�
�
�
,�� - ___
� �, �.
- r:� . _ �.,
�` �-
�'
,�
, ��..r'� � ;:;�;:,�%�:: :,��
�
� t:r'+' ..,..-�_. -:, .��yy,e',1
.. ��: .. .:::�o' .�:s-�p�i�'t:'yie:: :: Kz i..•a�r�..s.
!�
�•