Loading...
AGREEMENT (7) I I A G R E E MEN T between CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA and INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, AFL-CIO Local 1158 Fiscal Year 1987-88 ) I TABLE OF CONTENTS PREAMBLE ARTICLE I - RECOGNITION ARTICLE II - REPRESENTATIVES OF PARTIES ARTICLE III - CITY'S MANAGEMENT RIGHTS ARTICLE IV - GRIEVANCE PROCEDURES ARTICLE V - NO STRIKE ARTICLE VI - STEWARDS ARTICLE VII - CHECKOFF ARTICLE VIII - NO DISCRIMINATION ARTICLE IX - HOLIDAYS ARTICLE X - VACATIONS ARTICLE XI - WAGES ARTICLE XII - PERSONNEL PRACTICES Section 1 - Pay Plan Section 2 - Promotional Examinations Section 3 - Promotional Lists Section 4 - Appointments Section 5 - Probationary Period Section 6 - Seniority Section 7 - Vacation Leave Section 8 - Sick Leave Section 9 - Absence Without Leave Section 10 - Time Off From Duty ARTICLE XIII - POSTING OF AGREEMENT ARTICLE XIV - BULLETIN BOARD ARTICLE XV - WORK SCHEDULE ARTICLE XVI - WORK RULES AND PREVAILING RIGHTS ARTICLE XVII - SENIORITY AND LAYOFFS ARTICLE XVIII - PARAMEDICS ARTICLE XIX - LINE-OF-DUTY INJURY PAY I Page No. 1 2 3 4 5 9 10 11 12 13 15 17 18 18 22 26 27 27 28 30 31 39 39 41 42 43 46 48 51 55 I I ARTI CLE XX - LEAVES OF ABSENCE 58 ARTICLE XXI - MISCELLANEOUS 60 ARTICLE XXII - PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS 64 ARTICLE XXII I - AMENDMENTS 66 ARTICLE XXIV - SEVERABILITY AND WAIVER 67 ARTICLE XXV - CONTRACT CONSTITUTES ENTIRE AGREEMENT OF THE PARTI ES 68 ARTICLE XXVI - DURATION, MODIFICATION AND TERMINATION 69 I I PREAMBLE This Agreement is entered into by the City of Clearwater, Florida, hereinafter referred to as the "City" and Local 1158 of the International Association of Firefighters, AFL-CIO, hereinafter referred to as the "Union", for the purpose of promoting harmonious relations between the City and the Union, to establish an orderly and peaceful procedure to settle differences which might arise, and to set forth the basic and full agreement between the parties concerning wages, rates of pay, and all other terms and conditions of employment. 1. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE I RECOGNITION Section 1. The City recognizes the Union as the exclusive bargaining representative in accordance with Chapter 447, Florida Statutes, as amended, effective January 1, 1975, for the following agreed upon bargaining unit: All persons in the classifications designated Firefighters, Fire Lieutenants, Fire Inspectors shall be in the bargaining unit. All others shall be excluded. Section 2. Should the City establish new jOb classifications within the Fire Department that are to be in the bargaining unit the City shall, not less than thirty (30) days prior to staffing such classification, provide notice to the Union of the establishment of such classification, and, if requested, bargain with the Union concerning wage rates and hours of employment for such classification. 2. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE I I REPRESENTATIVES OF PARTIES Section 1. The City agrees that during the term of this Agreement it will deal only with the authorized representatives of the Union in matters requiring mutual consent or other official action called for by this Agreement. Authorized representatives shall be defined as elected Officers of the Union and duly elected or appoi nted stewards, provi ded that not i fi cat i on has been provi ded in writing to the Office of the Fire Chief at least twenty-four hours in advance or next regular work day of 40 hour personnel. The Union agrees to notify the City of the name of such authori zed representatives as of the execution of thi s Agreement and replacement therefor during the term of this Agreement. Section 2. The Union likewise agrees that during the term of this Agreement the Union and the employees covered hereunder shall deal only with the City Manager or his representative in matters requiring mutual consent or other official action and specifically the Union agrees that neither the Union nor the employees hereunder shall seek to involve the City's elected officials in the administration of this Agreement or otherwise in the operation of the City's Fire Department; provided that nothing contained herein shall restrict an employee's opportunity to present non-employment related matters to such elected officials. 3. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE III CITY'S MANAGEMENT RIGHTS Section 1. Except as expressly limited by any provision of this Agreement, the City reserves and retains excl us i ve 1 y a 11 of its norma 1 and inherent ri ghts wi th respect to the management of its operations, whether exerci sed or not, including, but not limited to, its rights to determine, and from time to time redetermi ne, the number, 1 ocat i on and type of its va ri ous operat ions, funct ions and services; the methods, procedures and policies to be employed; to discontinue the conduct of any ope rat ions, functions or servi ces, in whole or in part; to transfer its operations, functions or services from or to, either in whole or in part, any of its departments or other divisions; to select and direct the working force in accordance with requi rements determi ned by the City, to create, modify or discontinue jOb classifications; to establish and change working rules and regulations; to establish and change work schedules and assignments; to transfer, promote or demote employees; to layoff, furlough, terminate or otherwise relieve employees from work for lack of work, lack of funds, or other legitimate reason; to suspend, discharge or otherwise discipline employees for proper cause; to alter or vary past practices and otherwise to take such measures as the City may determine to be necessary to the orderly and efficient operation of its various operations, functions and/or services. Secti on 2. If in the sole di scret i on of the City Manager or Mayor it is determined that civil emergency conditions exist, including, but not limited to, riots, civil disorders, hurricane conditions, or similar catastrophes or disorders, the provisions of this Agreement may be suspended by the City Manager or Mayor during the term of the declared emergency provided that wage rates and other direct monetary payments shall not be suspended. 4. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE IV GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE Section 1. A grievance shall be defined as any difference, dispute or complaint regarding the interpretation or application of the terms of this Agreement. Probationary employees (only new hires) shall not have access to the grievance procedures during the probationary period with respect to disciplinary action including termination. The Preamble to this Agreement shall not be cited as the sole basis for a grievance. Section 2. All grievances filed shall refer to the specific section of thi s Agreement upon whi ch the gri evance is based and sha 11 conta in a conci se statement of the facts all eged to support the gri evance. Gri evances sha 11 be processed in accordance with the foll owi ng procedure and sha 11 be determi ned by appl i cat i on of the terms of thi s Agreement, the 1 aws of the United States, the State of Florida, and the Charter and Ordinances of the City of Clearwater. Step 1. The aggrieved employee or employees shall present in writing on approved grievance form, his (their) grievance to his (their) Captain/Fire Marshal within twelve (12) calendar days of the occurrence of the matter giving rise to the grievance. The aggrieved employee may request that a Union representative be present. Discussions will be informal for the purpose of settling differences in the simplest and most direct manner. The Captain/Fire Marshal shall reach a decision and communicate it in writing to the aggrieved employee within twelve (12) calendar days from the date the grievance was presented to him. Step 2. I f the gri evance is not sett 1 ed in the fi rst step, the aggrieved employee, within twelve (12) calendar days of the date of the answer in 5. IAFF 87/88 I I the first step, shall present it to the Fire Chief or his designee. At the same time, a copy may be forwarded to the Ci ty Manager's Offi ce by the Uni on for informational purposes. The Fire Chief or his designee shall obtain the facts concerning the alleged grievance and shall, within twelve (12) calendar days of receipt of the written grievance, meet with the aggrieved employee. The aggrieved employee may be accompanied at this meeting by his Union representative. The Fire Chief or his designee shall notify the aggrieved employee of his decision not later than twelve (12) calendar days following the meeting date. Step 3. If still unresolved, the grievance and all responses may be submitted to the City Manager or his designee within twelve (12) calendar days. Within twelve (12) calendar days from receipt, the City Manager shall notify the employee, in writing, of his decision. Section 3. In the event that the grievance is unresolved, the matter may be submitted to final and binding arbitration in the manner provided herein. Section 4. Arbitration A. Within five (5) days from the receipt of the decision of the City Manager, the party requesting to arbitrate the controversy shall give written not ice to the other and sha 11 at the same time request a 1 i st of fi ve (5) arbitrators from the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service. B. Within seventy-two (72) hours after receipt of the list of arbitrators, the Union and the City shall meet and each strike two (2) names therefrom; the remaining name shall designate the arbitrator. The party seeking arbitration shall strike the first and third names. C. As promptly as can be arranged, the arbitration hearing shall be held and within fifteen (15) days thereafter, the arbitrator shall render his decision. The arbitrator, in rendering his decision, shall confine his decision 6. IAFF 87/88 I I to the controversy inquest i on and he sha 11 not have the authority to add to, take away from, alter or amend any provision of this Agreement. D. The decision of the arbitrator, insofar as it is in conformance with paragraph C hereinabove, shall be final and binding on both parties. E. The expense of the arbitrator shall be borne equally by both parties, except that if either side desires a written transcript such side shall bear the costs thereof. When a deci si on is made by the arbitrator, the non-prevail i ng party shall pay all costs of the arbitrator and for attendance and transcripts, if necessary, and shall reimburse the other party for such payments, if necessary. F. The arbitrator shall arbitrate solely the issue presented. G. Any decision of the arbitrator shall not be retroactive more than ten (10) days prior to date grievance submitted. Section 5. Nothing contained herein shall prohibit the employee from utilizing the Civil Service grievance machinery, except that once an employee proceeds accordi ng to the steps in thi s Agreement he shall not thereafter have access to Civil Service for the resolution of the grievance involved. Section 6. Grievances arising out of the discharge, demotion, suspension or written repri mand shall be commenced withi n twelve (12) days of the action gi vi ng ri se to the gri evance and sha 11 be commenced inStep 2 of the gri evance procedure unless the employee elects to utilize the Civil Service grievance machinery. Section 7. If the aggrieved employee fails to receive notice from the responsible City party, in a timely manner, at any step in the grievance procedure, the grievance shall automatically be advanced to the next step, including the last step. If the aggrieved employee fails to advance the grievance as provided herein the grievance shall be deemed denied and abandoned. 7. IAFF 87/88 I I Section 8. When a grievance has been resolved in any employee's favor at any step in the grievance process, including arbitration, the City will make a diligent good faith effort to eliminate the condition that gave rise to the grievance for other employees of the Department, so as to avoid repetitious grievances. Section 9. All of the time limits contained in this Article may be extended by mutual written consent of the parties. 8. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE V NO STRIKE Section 1. The Union agrees that during the term of this Agreement, it shall not authorize, instigate, condone, excuse, ratify or support any strike, slowdown, sit-down, work stoppage or any other act of like or similar nature likely to interfere with the efficient operation of the City's affairs engaged in or supported by members of the Union and/or employees represented by the Union or other agents or representatives of the Union. The parties specifically incorporate herein the provisions of FS 447.505, 447.507 and 447.509. Section 2. Should the Union or a majority of the Union employees covered by this Agreement within the City's Fire Department breach this Article, the City may then proceed against the Union as covered in FS 447 and such sections of State and Federal law that may apply. The City would also be entitled to obtain an injunction with notice at ex-parte hearing for breach of this Article. 9. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE VI STEWARDS Sect ion 1. There shall be one (1) Union Official in each district on each shift and one for fire inspection. Section 2. An employee having a grievance shall have the right to take the matter up with his Shift Steward or other Union Officer during working time, provided that neither the employee nor the Shift Steward may leave their assigned Fire Station or work area outside a Fire Station without prior permission of the Assistant Chief/Fire Marshal or his relief to do so, and, provided further, that the employee and the Union Official shall not interfere with the normal operations of the Department. 10. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE VI I CHECKOFF Section 1. The City sha 11 deduct dues and uni form assessments owed by the employee to the Union in an amount certified to be correct by the Union Secreta ry- Treasurer on a bi week 1 y bas is; provi ded, that pri or to such deduct ion the Union has provided the City with a signed statement from each employee whose dues are to be deducted that such deduction is authorized; provided, further that such authorization is in a form satisfactory to the City. Section 2. Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, any authorization for dues deduction may be cancelled by the employee upon thirty (30) days written notice to the City and the Union. Section 3. The Union shall indemnify and hold harmless the City from any and all claims or demands and expenses in connection therewith based upon the City's participation in dues deduction. Section 4. Nothing contained herein shall require the City to deduct from a salary or be otherwise involved in the collection of Union fines, penalties or special assessments. Section 5. In the event an employee's salary earnings within any pay peri od, after deductions for withho 1 di ng, pens i on or soci a 1 security, hea lth and/or other standard deductions, are not sufficient to cover dues it will be the responsibility of the Union to collect its dues for that pay period from the employee. 11. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE VI II NO DISCRIMINATION Section 1. The City and the Union specifically agree that the provisions of this Agreement shall be equally applicable to all employees covered herein without regard to race, color, religion, creed, sex, national origin, membership or non-membership in labor organization, or age, as provided by law. Section 2. All references in this Agreement to employees of the male gender are used for convenience only and shall be construed to include both male and female employees. 12. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE IX HOLIDAYS Section 1. The following holidays shall be observed: New Year's Day Memorial Day Independence Day Labor Day Veterans' Day Thanksgiving Day Christmas Day Day after Thanksgiving The above 1 i sted hol i days wi 11 be pai d accordi ng to the current practice, except that the following four holidays will be compensated at a premium rate of 16.8 hours base pay for employees on a 56-hour schedule: Christmas Day, Thanksgiving Day, New Year's Day, and Independence Day. Section 2. In addition to the holidays listed in Section 1, each employee may receive four additional "floating holidays." For such floating holidays the employee sha 11 recei ve hi s regul ar rate of pay for such day if he does not work that day, but sha 11 not recei ve addi t i ona 1 compensat ion. Nei ther the ho 1 i days listed in Section 1, nor any day for which an employee is not scheduled to work, may be designated as a floating holiday. New employees hired prior to September 30 who meet compliance with or upon successful completion of State Minimum Standards training as a Firefighter and Emergency Medical Technicians training and after thirty (30) days of employment will receive four (4) "floating holidays." Section 3. Floating holidays will be selected after all vacation days and longevity days have been scheduled. It is not necessary for an employee to schedule his floating holidays during the vacation selection process. Any employee selecting floating holidays after the vacation selection process will give the Department 72 hours' notice in writing of his/her request. This notice 13. IAFF 87/88 I I give the Department 72 hours' notice in writing of his/her request. This notice will be given to the Captain for his approval based on vacation selection criteria. This permission shall not be arbitrarily withheld. In case more than one employee requests apart i cul ar day and the Department determi nes that both employees may not be off duty on that particular day, the senior employee shall be given preference. Section 4. If the employee chooses not to take a floating holiday, he will make a written request to receive 11.2 hours of pay for 56-hour week or 8.0 hours of pay for 40-hour week in lieu thereof payable prior to December 31. 14. IAFF 87/88 - I I I Section 2. If a holiday occurs during a vacation period, the employee shall receive holiday pay at the current rate. Section 3. With the consent of the Department, vacations will be selected by department seniority for regular vacations (6 duty days), with the senior employee on each shift selecting first. Longevity vacation days will be selected in reverse seniority, after regular vacations have been scheduled. All vacation days and longevity days will be scheduled during the selection process. However, if an employee exercises his/her option to pass on scheduling these days, he/she must request permission from the Fire Chief or his designee, whose permission shall not be arbitrarily withheld, provided that: (1) an employee who is scheduling his/her retirement in the year for which vacation selection is being made may request of the Chief, in writing, that his/her longevity days be withheld for use by or payment to the employee upon his/her retirement; or (2) an employee may opt not to se 1 ect longevity days, thereby forfeiting hi s/her 1 ongevi ty day vacation se 1 ect i on preference ri ghts, and may thereafter attempt to schedule such days individually. If times are not available due to scheduling conflicts or staffing needs, days not able to be scheduled during the calendar year shall be forfeited by the employee. Section 4. Employees becoming sick or having a death in the family while on vacation may use sick time or death leave for such period of illness or death providing the employee calls the City to notify such change of time. This period of time shall be added to his vacation. If the employee desires to use sick time, his illness must be verified by a physician. Section 5. Any employee who is separated from service shall be compensated by check for all unused vacation time accumulated at the regular rate of pay at the time of separation. 16. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XI WAGES Sect ion 1. Basic wage rates for all members of the bargaining unit shall be increased by: 5% for fiscal year 1987-1988, effective October 1, 1987. Section 2. In addition to the rates above, the additional factors for compensation as provided in the Pay Plan shall prevail. 17. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XII PERSONNEL PRACTICES Sect ion 1. Pay Plan A. An approximate five per cent increase over an employee's base pay shall be provided upon promotion. (Five per cent is determined by taking the difference between the employee's current base rate before promotion and the base for the same pay step two ranges higher.) B. If a Firefighter, Fire Lieutenant or Fire Prevention Inspector is receiving additional compensation over base pay under the provisions of Headquarters Lieutenant assignment, Driver-Operator assignment, or Leadworker assignment and upon promotion, the application of an approximate five per cent increase over said base pay does not reflect an increase in overall compensation, such employee shall be placed in a pay step in the class to which promoted which will provide an increase over the former base pay and designated assignment pay. C. If a Firefighter, Fire Lieutenant or Fire Prevention Inspector possesses EMT I certification, the following shall be done upon promotion: (1) If an employee was among personnel "grandfathered-in" to EMT I pay by the original and subsequent City-IAFF Contracts, such employee shall, upon promotion, be promoted in accordance with paragraphs A and/or B above and shall thereafter have the EMT I pay added as a supplement to the new base pay in the higher class. (2) If the employee was not "grandfathered-in" to EMT I pay by the original and subsequent City-IAFF Contracts, but is currently certified as an EMT I to an emergency medi ca 1 servi ces team and recei vi ng 5% EMT I incentive pay, such employee shall, upon promotion, be promoted in accordance with paragraphs A and/or B above. The employee shall 18. IAFF 87/88 I , recei ve no other pay cons i derat i on for EMT I duties except when such duties in the new position are assigned in accordance with the current contract. (3) If the employee possesses EMT certification but was not "grandfathered-i n" to EMT I pay by the ori gi na 1 and subsequent City- IAFF Contracts and is not currently assigned EMT I pay duties to an emergency medical services team (and receiving incentive pay therefor), such employee sha 11 not be gi ven any cons i derat i on upon promotion for EMT I designation. D. Paramedic pay shall not be considered in computing promotional payor placement; however, paragraph C(1) will apply in cases where the employee is a "grandfathered" EMT I. E. I f a Fi re Lieutenant who was "grandfathered-i n" to EMT I pay by the original and subsequent City-IAFF Contracts changes his status from "line" to "paramedic" or "paramedic" to "line," the following shall apply to pay adjustment: (1) If a "line" Fire Lieutenant or paramedic firefighter is receiving 5% "grandfathered" incentive pay and is subsequently assigned to, and functions as, a "paramedic" Fire Lieutenant or paramedic firefighter, sai d employee shall recei ve 15% over base pay and the 5% "grandfathered" EMT I incentive pay shall be deemed to be incorporated therein. (2) If a "paramedic" Fire Lieutenant or paramedic firefighter drops from the paramedic program, whether voluntarily or involuntarily, said employee shall cease to receive the 15% incentive pay over base pay. However, if such employee was a "grandfathered" EMT I the employee sha 11 then recei ve 5% EMT I i ncent i ve over base pay, provi ded he meets the requirements therefor. 19. IAFF 87/88 I I F. Rate of Pay on Changes in Status - Each person who sha 11 be inducted into a position in the classified service shall receive compensation at the minimum rate prescribed for the class of position except as provided in Rules for Administering the Pay Plan of the City of Clearwater, April 1, 1965, and except as follows: (1) An employee who is demoted for lack of work occasioned by consolidation of a municipal function by another governmental agency, shall have his compensation fixed at the step in the range for the class to which he is demoted which is the same as the rate which the employee previously received or at the highest step in the range of the class to which he is demoted if that class maximum rate is less than the employee previously received. Such employee shall be placed at the head of the re-employment list for the class from which he was demoted. An employee otherwi se demoted for 1 ack of work, 1 ack of funds or other causes beyond his control shall have his compensation fixed at the step in the range for the class to which he is demoted which is next lower than the rate which the employee previously received. Such employee shall be placed at the head of the re-employment list for the class from whi ch he was demoted. An employee who is demoted for any other reason shall have hi s compensation fi xed at the step in the rate for the class to which he is demoted to which he would be entitled had his previous employment with the City been in such lower class. (2) An employee who is transferred from a position of one class to a position of another class shall continue to be paid at the same rate if such rate is on a step in the pay range for the new class or at the next higher step if his previous rate is between steps in the range for the new class. 20. IAFF 87/88 I I (3) An employee who is appointed from the re-employment list to a position in the department in which he previously served shall be paid at the step in the pay range which is equivalent to the step he was receiving when he was separated and shall be eligible for advancement to the next step when he shall have been re-employed a sufficient number of days to make up the number of days he 1 acked for e 1 i gi bi 1 i ty at the time of separation. (4) An employee who is appointed from the re-employment list to a position in another department than that in which he was previously employed may be paid at the same step in the pay range at which he was being paid when separated, or any step within the range which is not above the step at which he was previously paid. (5) Hereafter, when an employee's position is or has been reclassified to a higher class, the employee may, upon approval of the Board and the Appoi nt i ng Authority, be granted addit i ona 1 step increases above the minimum rate in order to give credit for the period of time the employee has been performing substantially the same duties and responsibilities of the higher class. (6) The Fi re Chi ef, with the approva 1 of the Appoi nt i ng Authority, may assign any Fire Lieutenant to Headquarters (Station #1) duty for such period of time as will, in his opinion, best serve the interest of the City and withi n authori zed 1 i mitat ions. Because of the addit i ona 1 responsibilities incidental to such assignments, the affected employee shall be paid in addition to his regular salary, an amount equivalent to fi ve per cent as determi ned in the current Pay Pl an duri ng the period thus assigned. This provision shall not be deemed to include short term assignments for vacation or other relief periods not in excess of 30 calendar days. 21. IAFF 87/88 I I (7) Firefighters who have successfully passed Fire Department examination and/or test requi red for dri ver-operator and have been recommended by the Fire Chief and approved by the Appointing Authority, shall be paid, in addition to their regular salary, an amount equivalent to five per cent as determined in the current Pay Plan while assigned to driver- operator duties. Section 2. Promotional Examinations (This section applies to promotions to the position of Fire Lieutenant and Fire Inspector only.) A. Promotional examinations will be held within 30 days following the expiration of a previously existing promotional list. B. Each announcement of a promotional examination shall state: (1) The title of the class. (2) The nature of the work to be performed. (3) The names of the organization unit or units for which the examination is given and of the organization unit or units and the lower class or classes of positions within such organization unit or units, of which employees shall be deemed entitled to compete in such examination. (4) The minimum qualifications which may be required for admission to the examination. (5) The general scope of the tests to be used. C. Eligibility for promotional examinations may be restricted to persons employed in designated lower classes and/or in designated organizational units. Such persons shall be required to have completed their probationary period and have been certified to permanent status in the lower class and/or to have had such other length of experience in the lower class or classes as may in the jUdgment of the Personnel Director be deemed appropriate for the particular examination. 22. IAFF 87/88 I , D. Disqualification of Applicants. The Personnel Director, on behalf of the Board, may reject the application of any person for admission to any examination or refuse to examine any applicant or to certify the name of an eligible for appointment if, in his opinion, it is found: (1) That the applicant fails to meet the established qualification requirements for the position. (2) That the application was not filed on or before the closing date for receipt of applications specified in the public announcement. (3) That the applicant has made a false statement as to any material fact, has practiced or attempted to practice deception or fraud in his application or in securing eligibility or appointment. This provision shall be interpreted to include the use of any other than the applicant's legal name in making application. (4) That the appl i cant is affected with any di squa 1 ifyi ng di sease or is physically or mentally unfit to effectively perform the duties of the pos it ion. (5) That the applicant has been guilty of any crime or infamous or notoriously disgraceful conduct. (6) That the applicant has a record of previous unsatisfactory service in City employment or elsewhere of such a nature as to demonstrate unsuitability for employment in a position of the class for which he is applying. (7) That the applicant has received a discharge other than honorable from the armed forces. (8) Any person who, by order of the Personnel Director, is denied permission to compete in any examination or whose eligibility is 23. IAFF 87/88 I I cancelled under the provisions of this Rule may make a written appeal to the Board for a final decision. E. Scope and Character of Examinations. (1) Provisions applying to promotional examinations: (a) All examinations, except transfer examinations, shall be competitive. (b) All examinations shall be of such character as to fairly determine the qualifications, fitness and ability of applicants to perform the duties of the position to which appointment is to be made. (c) Examinations may be assembled or unassembled, and tests may be written, oral, physical or performance, or a combination of these types. They may take into consideration such factors (including age, experience, education, aptitude, capacity, knowl edge, character, phys i ca 1 fi tness, sex, and other qualifications) as, in the judgment of the Personnel Director, enter into the determi nat i on of the re 1 at i ve fitness of the applicants and may include inquiry into the moral character, or any other pertinent quality or attribute of the applicant. (d) No test or question in any examination shall be so framed as to ca 11 for or 1 ead to di scl osure of any i nformat ion concerni ng any political or religious applications, preferences or opi ni ons. Any di scl osure thereof sha 11 be di scountenanced and any such information which may nevertheless be revealed shall be disregarded. (2) Any promotional examination may include any combination of the factors listed in Subsection (1) above, and shall include credit for seniority 24. IAFF 87/88 I I and efficiency as indicated by the candidate's performance rating reports for the most recent three (3) year period of his employment with the City or duri ng such portion thereof for whi ch these reports may be available. Seniority credit will be granted to the candidate pri or to computat i on of the fi na 1 test grade. One-ha 1 f poi nt credi t will be added for each full year of department service, up to a maximum of fi ve poi nts. Effi ci ency credi t wi 11 be granted to the candi date prior to the computation of the final test grade and will be equitably and uniformly related to his employee performance reports for the aforement i oned three (3) year peri od or for the peri od of time such reports are available. F. Rating of Examinations. (1) The earned credit rating of each candi date sha 11 be determi ned by the weighted average of earned credit ratings, according to weights established and published or announced by the Personnel Director, or hi s des i gnated representative, before the exami nat ion. The Personne 1 Director shall establish the minimum passing grade for any examination. When properly authorized and published or announced before the examination, such minimum passing grade shall be deemed to be included herein and made a part hereof. (2) Where it is stated in the announcement that an applicant, to become eligible, must attain a specified acceptable rating in any written or performance test, the remaining tests need not be given to any compet itor who is found not to meet such requi rement, and if gi ven, need not be rated. 25. IAFF 87/88 I , G. Notification of Results. Each candidate shall be notified in writing of his name being placed on the eligible list or his failure to attain a place on the list. Any candidate may, within fifteen (15) calendar days following the mailing date of his notice of results, request permission to review his examination with the Personnel Director or his designated representative, and will be given reasonable opportunity to do so. H. Appeals from Ratings. (1) Any candi date may, withi n fifteen (15) ca 1 endar days from the date of i nit i a 1 revi ew but in no event 1 ater than one month after the posting of employment list resulting from such test, notify the Personnel Director in writing that error, other than error of judgment, exists. The Personnel Director shall thereupon cause a review of such rating to be made. If, upon review, errors, other than error of judgment, which affect the candidate's rating, are found, such errors shall be corrected. In the event such review discloses error, affecting the rat i ng of other candi dates, the ratings of the other candi dates sha 11 also be corrected. (2) No change made in the ratings of any candi date sha 11 be deemed to invalidate or in any way affect any certification or appointment previously made. Section 3. Promotional Lists (This section applies to promotions to the positions of Fire Lieutenant and Fire Inspector only). A. Promotion and Original Appointment Lists. The names of a 11 persons who may be 1 awfu 11 y appoi nted and who sha 11 have attained a passing grade on any promotional examination shall be placed on the 26. IAFF 87/88 I I appropriate promotional or original appointment list in the order of their final grade without regard to time of tests. The names of two or more eligibles having the same fi na 1 grade sha 11 be placed on the 1 i s t by a rrangi ng the names in alphabetical order in case of a list for original appointment, or by arranging the names in order of seniority in the case of a list for promotion. B. Duration of Lists. All promotional eligible lists, whether resulting from examinations having a closing date for receipt of applications or from continuous examinations shall be established for the term and period of two (2) years from the date of the examination which established such eligibility. Section 4. Appointments In certifying from a promotional list for the filling of a vacancy in a permanent position, the Personnel Director shall certify the names of persons highest on the list consistent with the Rule of Five Rounded Scores. Section 5. Probationary Period Before or at the expiration of the probationary period, the Appointing Authority may, by presenting to the employee reasons for such action in writing, dismiss an employee serving an original probationary period, or in the case of an employee serving a probationary period following promotion, return such employee to his former position. A copy of such notice shall be filed with the Personnel Director. Any employee who shall have completed the prescribed probationary period without having been dismissed or returned to his former position shall be deemed to have permanent status in his class of position, provided: (1) That the employee has made application to the Appointing Authority for certification to permanent status, and (2) That the Appointing Authority has issued to the employee a written certificate of permanent status, or 27. IAFF 87/88 I I (3) That within thirty (30) calendar days after the aforesaid application by the employee, the Appointing Authority neither discharges the employee nor certifies him to permanent status. An employee who has been dismissed or demoted in accordance with the foregoing provisions shall have no right of appeal and his name shall be removed from the appropriate eligibility list for the class from which he was dismissed or demoted. Section 6. Seniority A. Definition. Seni ority is hereby defi ned as the 1 ength of continuous servi ce in City employment except as applied to vacation preference, promotions, layoffs, and assignments. B. How Measured. (1) In the event an employee transfers from the Fire Department to another position within the City, and at a later date, transfers back to the Fire Department, the seniority date for the purpose of layoff, promotions and transfers, shall be the date the employee transfers back into the Department. (2) Any employee who transfers from another City department to the Fire Department shall retain full City seniority with regards to vacation and sick leave accrual. However, for purposes of layoff, departmental seniority shall prevail. In regards to pay and pensions, the applicable civil service rules shall apply. (3) In the event two or more employees have the same seniority date, the employee whose first letter of hislher last name is closest to the letter "A" shall have more seniority. 28. IAFF 87/88 J I (4) The seniority list on the date of this agreement shall reflect names, job titles, and seniority dates (departmental and City) of all employees. (5) The City will maintain a current seniority list at all times and will provide the Union with copies of such list in December and June of each year. (6) Emergency, provisional, seasonal and temporary part-time employees shall not accumulate seniority during any period of such employment. C. Continuous service shall mean employment by the City in a position in the cl ass i fi ed servi ce wi thout interruption or break, except that the fo 11 owi ng shall not be considered as breaks in employment: 0) Leaves of absence or time off with or without compensation granted pursuant to this Contract. The length of any such leave shall not be deducted from the length of continuous service in computing seniority. (2) Layoffs for lack of work, lack of funds, abolition of position, or because of materi a 1 changes in duties or organi zat ion, not exceedi ng one year in 1 ength, fo 11 owed by rei nstatement or by appoi ntment from the re-employment 1 i st. The 1 ength of any such 1 ayoff sha 11 not be deducted from the length of continuous service in computing seniority. (3) Disability retirement if and when followed by reinstatement. The length of any such disability retirement shall not be deducted from the length of continuous service in computing seniority. (4) Suspensions in accordance with this Agreement. The length of any such suspension shall not be deducted from the length of continuous service in computing seniority. (5) Di smi ssa 1 s whi ch sha 11 subsequent 1 y be withdrawn or modifi ed by the Appointing Authority or by action of the Board in accordance with this 29. IAFF 87/88 I I Agreement. The length of such separation shall not be deducted from the length of continuous service in computing seniority. (6) Resignations sUbsequently withdrawn, in accordance with this Agreement, within six (6) months after acceptance, followed by reinstatement or appoi ntment from the re-employment 1 i st; provi ded, however, that the actual length of separation from the service shall be deducted from the length of continuous service in computing seniority. D. Uses - In addition to the circumstances and conditions wherein, by the provisions of the Act and/or these Rules, seniority has been determined to be the controlling factor, it shall also be given reasonable consideration in determining the order of layoff, the order of names on a re-employment list and in promotions in accordance with the rules governing those procedures. E. Transfer - In the event of a transfer or appointment from certification to another department, an employee shall retain all accumulated seniority. Section 7. Vacation Leave A. Every full-time or permanent part-time employee who is compensated on a salaried or hourly rated basis shall be entitled to an annual vacation leave with pay at his regular salary or hourly rate in accordance with the provisions hereinafter set forth. B. The vacation year shall be a calendar year, and, except as hereinafter provided, the vacation shall be deemed to have been earned in the calendar year immediately preceding the calendar year in which it is taken or becomes due. Any vacation heretofore taken shall be construed to have been earned prior to the time it was taken. Except when specifically requested by the department head and approved by the Personne 1 Di rector, va cat ion 1 eaves may not be anti ci pated but shall be taken as herein provided. 30. IAFF 87/88 I I C. A full-time permanent employee shall be deemed to have earned and be eligible for his first vacation on the first anniversary date of his employment, provided that such first anniversary date falls on or before the thirtieth day of September in that calendar year. In the event that such employee's first anniversary date falls after September 30 in that calendar year, the provisions of paragraph "D" hereunder will apply. The provisions of this paragraph contemplate continuous service as hereinafter defined. D. Thereafter, and during his continuous service as hereinafter defined, such employee shall become eligible for a vacation on the first day of each succeeding calendar year. E. In the event an employee is on a 1 eave of absence wi thout payor is absent because of sick leave without pay. time off without payor vacation without pay and the total of such absence or absences amounts to ninety (90) calendar days or more in any calendar year, the employee shall not be deemed to have earned a vacation in that calendar year. Section 8. Sick Leave A. Members of the bargaining unit shall accrue sick leave in accordance with the schedule below: Sick Leave Number of Yearly Scheduled Pay Hours Accrued Pay Periods Sick Yearly Sick Period Hours Per Pay Period Leave is Accrued Leave Hours 80 5.0 24 120 112 7.0 24 168 B. Sick leave may be accumulated without limit for each pay period the employee actually works, which shall be deemed to include actual work and periOdS when the employee is using accumulated sick leave (but not borrowed sick leave), holidays, vacation with pay, and the 90 day no-loss of pay injury time. Employees shall not accrue sick leave during any other periOd of time when they are in a non-work status. 31. IAFF 87/88 I I C. All accumulated unused sick leave shall be credited to any employee reca 11 ed from a 1 ay off, trans ferred, or cert ifi ed to another depa rtment or cl assifi cat i on without break in servi ce, appoi nted from a re-employment 1 i st or returning from a leave of absence. If the employee is promoted, demoted or transferred to another City position with a different Scheduled Pay Period Hours other than that defined above, that employee's sick leave balance will be adjusted to reflect equivalent days of sick leave earned, consistent with his/her new scheduled pay period hours. D. In the event an employee has been separated and paid for accumulated unused sick leave as hereinafter provided, or has been dismissed for cause and subsequently is re-employed by the City, his/her subsequent sick leave accumulations shall be calculated as a new employee. E. Under the provisions of this section, an employee may utilize his/her sick leave for absences from duty on any of his/her regularly scheduled work days for the number of regular hours he/she would otherwise have been scheduled to work on that day had not such absence occurred. Absence for a fraction of a day that is chargeable to sick leave in accordance with these provisions shall be charged by rounding to tenths of an hour according to the following: Minutes Tenths of an Hour 1 - 6 .1 7 - 12 .2 13 - 18 .3 19 - 24 .4 25 - 30 .5 31 - 36 .6 37 - 42 .7 32. IAFF 87/88 I I 43 - 48 49 - 54 55 - 60 .8 .9 1.0 F. Si ck 1 eave sha 11 not be considered a pri vi 1 ege to be used at the employee's discretion, but shall be used only for absences: (1) Due to personal ill ness or phys i ca 1 i ncapaci ty caused by factors over which the employee has no reasonable immediate control. (2) Necessitated by exposure to contagious disease in which the health of others would be endangered by his/her attendance on duty. (3) Due to dental appointments, physical examinations, or other personal sickness prevention measures, the scheduling of which at times other than during his/her regular working hours is impossible or unreason able. (4) Due to illness of a member of his/her immediate family which requires his/her personal care and attention, not exceeding in anyone calendar year, the accumulated number of scheduled work hours in the employee's regularly scheduled work week. The term "Immediate Family" as used in this paragraph shall mean parents, grandparents, children, grandchildren, brothers, sisters or husband/wife of the employee and the immediate family as herein referenced of the husband/wife. (5) If an employee is under a doctor's care or if a member of the employee's immediate family is under a doctor's care and the doctor certifies that the employee's personal care and/or attention is required, said time of absence shall not be considered as grounds for any discipline, provided that: (a) Personal sick leave is not used in excess of accumulated sick leave or sick leave advance as provided for in Section (H) of this Article; 33. IAFF 87/88 I I (b) Family sick leave shall not exceed that provided for in subparagraph (4), paragraph F, of this Section; or such personal sick leave or family sick leave is approved by the City Manager or his designee; (c) Employees being reviewed for sick leave use will not have jOb- related injuries/illnesses, Workers' Compensation injuriesl illnesses, or other i njuri es/ill nesses verifi ed by a doctor's excuse used against them when determining excessive use of sick leave. G. An employee absent for one of the reasons mentioned above shall inform his/her immediate supervisor as early as possible on the first day of absence. Failure to do so may be the cause for denial of sick leave with pay for the period of absence. In any event, the Departmental Rules shall govern the notification requirements. H. In the event that an employee's current illness or physical incapacity should continue beyond the point where his/her accumulated unused sick leave has been exhausted, he/she may, upon written request and the approva 1 of hi s/her immediate supervisor, Department Director, and City Manager, and when sub stant i ated by a statement from competent medi ca 1 authority substant i at i ng the continuance of such illness or incapacity, obtain a sick leave advance up to but not exceeding the amount of accumulated unused sick leave which the employee had to his/her credit at the time such current illness or physical incapacity began. The Personnel Director shall be immediately notified in writing of any such advance which shall be charged against the employee's sick leave account thereby creating an overdraft position. Such overdraft shall have the status of a loan by the City to the employee and shall be repaid: 34. IAFF 87/88 I I 0) By the subsequent accumu 1 at i on of sick 1 eave in the amount necessary to retire such loan, or (2) By repayment to the City of such portion of the salary previously paid to the employee under the foregoing provisions as might be necessary to retire such loan. The employee shall not be entitled to use any additional sick leave until the loan has been repaid and in the event of hislher separation prior to such repayment, the City shall retain from the monies otherwise due the employee an amount sufficient to retire such loan. Provided, however, that if the separation is the result of the death of the employee, the loan shall be forthwith cancelled and no claim for repayment shall be filed against hislher estate. The employee shall not accumulate sick leave while being paid with borrowed sick leave. 1. Upon separation from the City service, an employee shall be paid one- half (-1/2) of his/her accumulated unused sick leave, provided: (1) That the rate of payment shall be based on the regular biweekly salary of the employee (including longevity) at the time of separation for which his/her accumulated unused sick leave will be charged with twice the number of regularly scheduled hours of work for that employee in such biweekly period. If an employee is separated upon the termination of a leave of absence or the effective date of a resignation executed under the provisions of paragraph (3) of this subsection, the rate of payment shall be based on the regular biweekly salary of the employee (including longevity) at the beginning of his/her leave of absence or the date the resignation was executed, and (2) That at the time of separation, the employee has had at least five (5) years of continuous servi ce with the City. Leaves of absence without pay, suspensions and layoffs followed by subsequent re-employment shall 35. IAFF 87/88 ) I not be considered as breaks in service; provided, however, that the 1 ength of such time-off or 1 ayoff sha 11 be deducted from the tota 1 length of service except that military leaves and leaves during which the employees are receiving Workers' Compensation salary supplement shall not be deducted, and (3) That the separation is involuntary on the part of the employee to the extent that it is occasioned by factors over which he/she has no immediate control, such as death, prolonged illness or physical or menta 1 i ncapaci ty, i nabi 1 i ty to effectively perform duties because of phys i ca 1 condi t ion, materi a 1 changes in methods, procedures or organizations or for other reasons of like character as distinguished from reasons such as voluntary separation to seek or accept other employment, relocate, attend school, care for relative or friends or reasons of 1 i ke character. If the separation is the result of the death of the employee, his/her estate shall receive payment. An employee who is dismissed for cause shall have no claim for sick leave payment. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this paragraph, an employee who may otherwise be eligible for retirement under the City Employees I Pension Pl an or Federa 1 Soci a 1 Securi ty or Fi remen' s Re 1 i ef and Pension Fund or who may be approaching such eligibility date, and whose purpose in leaving is to retire under either program, may utilize one-half (1/2) of his/her accumulated unused sick leave to the extent thereof to advance his/her retirement date. In that event the employee shall execute a resignation to become effective on the date that such accumulated unused sick leave would be exhausted. Such resignation shall be irrevocable and retirement shall begin at the time such resignation becomes effective. In the interim, payment for accumulated 36. IAFF 87/88 I I unused sick leave shall be made as a continuation of the employee's regular biweekly salary (including longevity) from which all regular payro 11 deductions shall be made in order to preserve hi slher ret i rement status. Accumu 1 ated unused sick 1 eave wi 11 be charged as outlined in paragraph (1) of this subsection. J. An employee may not utilize his/her accumulated sick leave absence for absences resulting from an injury arising out of and in the course of employment, other than City employment, for which monetary or other valuable consideration is recei ved or expected. Any employee who utili zes accumu 1 ated sick 1 eave, or who attempts to utilize accumulated sick leave, for absences resulting from an injury arising out of and in the course of employment, other than City employment, may be terminated or suspended, as in the City's judgment, is appropriate. K. Except in the cases of injury occurred in the 1 i ne of duty wi th the City, employees shall not be entitled to use sick leave until the completion of six (6) calendar months of continuous service following the date of original appointment. L. The employee shall be required to submit evidence in the form of a medical certificate, of the adequacy of the reasons for his/her absence during the period of time for which sick leave is granted: (1) When the illness of an employee necessitates an absence for three (3) consecutive scheduled work days or more; (2) When requested by the Department Director. M. Whenever an employee has advance knowledge that he will require a sick leave of more than thirty (30) calendar days' duration, he shall submit a written request to his immediate supervisor. On approval of the supervisor and department head, the request shall be forwarded to the Ci ty Manager for its approva 1 whi ch must be secured pri or to such 1 eave. Each request of thi s nature sha 11 be 37. IAFF 87/88 I , supported by evidence in the form of a medical certificate, of the adequacy of the reason for such sick leave. The manager may require further medical reports from time to time on all sick leave in excess of thirty (30) calendar days. N. An employee on duty injured in an accident, arising out of and in the course of his City employment, may elect to be continued on the payroll to the extent of his accumulated unused sick leave as hereinafter provided. An employee receiving sick leave with pay under the provisions of this subsection who simultaneously receives income under the Workers' Compensation Act shall receive, for the duration of such income and to the extent of his accumulated unused sick leave, only that portion of his regular salary which will, together with said income equal his regular salary. In that event, the employee's accumulated unused sick leave shall be charged only in the same proportion as his sick leave payment is to his regular biweekly salary which shall be deemed to be that same proportion of the number of regular hours he would otherwise have been scheduled to work for the day, week or other period involved, rounded out to the nearest tenth of an hour. O. These sick leave provisions are designed for the protection and benefit of eligible employees and represent a considerable investment by the City. Few employee benefits can equal the satisfaction and security of a continuing paycheck when illness or accident occurs and yet experience has shown that none is considered more lightly or subject to more abuse. Every effort has been made to encourage the conservation of these benefits for the purposes designated and the provisions hereof contemplate equitable and honorable utilization by affected employees. Fairness, therefore, dictates the reminder that the use of sick leave for purposes other than those designated herein will be considered a major rule infraction to be followed by disciplinary action up to and including dismissal. The Personnel Director and the Appointing Authority assume a joint responsibility 38. IAFF 87/88 I I in this respect and any supervisor use of sick who knowingly condones leave benefits will or be disregards held fully unauthorized or accountable. Section 9. Absence Without Leave A. Any employee who is absent from duty for three (3) consecutive work days without notice and valid reason therefor shall be deemed to have vOluntarily termi nated hi s City employment and to have vacated hi s position and will be separated from the payroll as a dismissal, unless a leave of absence is subsequently granted under any of these rules. B. The failure of an employee to report for duty at the expiration of a leave of absence or vacation leave with or without pay, shall be deemed an absence without 1 eave. Section 10. Time Off From Duty A. An employee shall be granted necessary time-off from hislher duties with compensation for any of the following reasons, 0) Attendance at profess i ona 1 or other conventions, i nst itutes, courses, or meetings when such attendance, is approved by the Fire Chief or his designee. (2) Attendance at in-service training and other in-service meetings when approved by the Fi re Chi ef or hi s designee. The provi s ions of thi s paragraph shall be deemed to include authorized safety meetings. B. The Union may request up to thirteen (13) duty days per Fiscal Year to be excused for Union business, conferences, and training. Any unused portion of the balance is to be carried over into the next contract year. Jointly related business between the City and the Union shall not be subject to deduction from the bank, however, the Union acknowledges that such time needed for arbitration hearings will be chargeable to the account. In any event, the Fire Chief or his improper 39. IAFF 87/88 I I des i gnee, may at hi s di scret i on deny any request not made at 1 east 72 hours in advance and submitted by a Union Officer, or which renders the Department staffed below that level which the Chief determines to be necessary. 40. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XI II POSTING OF AGREEMENT The City and the Union agree that this Agreement shall be posted by the City in a conspicuous place at each Fire Station. Further, the Union agrees, within thirty (30) days after receipt of copies of this Agreement, to supply individual copies of this Agreement to each current member of the bargaining unit and thereafter to provide an individual copy to each new bargaining unit member within thirty (30) days of their becoming a barga-;ning unit member. The City and the Uni on shall each bear one-ha 1f 0/2) of the cost of production of the copi es of the Agreement (250 copies - 200 for Union; 50 for City) The Agreement shall be printed on 8 1/2 x 11 inch paper, shall be bound, and shall have a cover and back. 41. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XIV BULLETIN BOARDS The City agrees to provide a 2 feet X 4 feet space on bulletin boards at each Fi re Station for posting by the Uni on of notices of meetings or other official Union information; provided, the Assistant Chief or his designee shall first review such posting, and if found to be outside of the scope of this Article, such posting shall be modified to the mutual agreement of the parties. The Captain will continue to include the union notices in the intra-departmental mail which he delivers to the stations. 42. IAFF 87/88 COMBAT DIVISION: Shifts to start at eight (8:00) A.M. and end at eight (8:00) A.M. the following morning. Total: Twenty-four (24) hours. Combat Division to consist of three (3) shifts: "A", "B", and "C", who will work in the following rotation (see sample monthly work schedule below). Sun. Mon. Tues. Wed. Thurs. Fri. 1 work 2 off 3 work 4 off 5 work 6 off 8 off 9 off 10 work 11 off 12 work 13 off 15 off 16 off 17 off 18 off 19 work 20 off 22 off 23 work 24 off 25 off 26 off 27 off 29 off 30 work, etc. INSPECTION DIVISION: Inspectors will work in shifts of 8:00 A.M. to 4:30 P.M. and 8:30 A.M. to 5:00 P.M., Monday through Friday, with a thirty minute lunch break for each inspector. The Chief reserves the right to assign the necessary personnel to each shift, but it is agreed that the assignments will not be made in an arbitrary or capricious manner. Section 2. Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary, the City retains the right to adjust work schedules only for the purpose of complying with the Fair Labor Standards Act without providing additional compensation for regularly schedu 1 ed hours. Pri or to making any such change, the City sha 11 provi de the Union not less than thirty (30) days notice and, if requested, bargain with the Union concerning the anticipated change. Section 3. The current practice of selecting individuals required for overtime work shall be continued except that a list shall be maintained so as to I ARTICLE XV WORK SCHEDULE Sect ion 1. 43. I Sat. 7 off 14 work 21 work 28 work IAFF 87/88 I I equalize overtime to the extent practicable. The current practices regarding overtime compensation shall be continued for the duration of this Agreement. Section 4. Employees within the Department may exchange on duty time upon the following conditions: A. That the person filling in be acceptable to the company officer and shift commander prior to the change. B. That the persons des i ri ng the exchange not i fy the company offi cer of the anticipated change not less than forty-eight (48) hours prior to the start of the anticipated change unless such exchange arises under emergency situations. C. That no person may be a 11 owed to exchange more than seventy-two (72) hours per fiscal year unless the shift commander in his discretion allows persons to exceed such limitation. D. That the member working the time will be covered by all applicable benefits in case of injury while filling in, but will not receive pay for this period. E. If the person agreeing to loan or fill in time is sick or fails to appear for the exchange, his sick leave account or pay will be charged. F. The person agreei ng to fi 11 in for another member is ob 1 i gated to remain on duty in the absence of the person with whom the exchange is made. G. Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary above, the City shall not be required to allow an exchange if doing so would impose upon the City liability for any additional overtime compensation over what persons may otherwise be entitled to. Prior to discontinuing the exchange allowance for this reason the City shall notify the Union concerning the legal basis for the decision to do so. H. Time exchange is subject to a one hour minimum and at one hour increments. Further, upon request, the City shall meet with the Union to bargain acceptable changes in the exchange practice. 44. IAFF 87/88 I I Section 5. When an employee is called in at least twenty (20) minutes prior to the start of his regularly scheduled shift, he will be paid a minimum of four (4) hours at the applicable rate. The City may require the employee to remain on duty for the duration of the four (4) hour period or for as long as he is needed, at the option of the City. When an employee is held over more than twenty (20) minutes, he will be paid a minimum of two hours at the applicable rate. The City may require the employee to remain on duty for the duration of the two-hour period or for as long as he is needed, at the option of the City. 45. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XVI WORK RULES AND PREVAILING RIGHTS Section 1. It is understood and agreed by both parties that the duties performed by members of the bargaining unit cannot always be covered by job descriptions and, therefore, members of the bargaining unit may be required to perform duties in addition to all those listed within the current jOb descriptions whi ch are, in the judgment of the City, re 1 ated to the purposes of the Fi re Department, which jUdgment shall not be arbitrary, capricious or unreasonable. Section 2. Any Fire Department Rule or Regulation in conflict with this Agreement shall be of no force and effect. Section 3. Prior to the implementation of any changes in the existing Fire Department Rules and Regulations, the Fire Chief must provide ten days notice and set up a meeting to discuss such change. Any proposed rule change the Union does not agree with must be submitted to the Civil Service Board, which shall conduct a pub 1 i c heari ng on the proposed change, affordi ng the Uni on an opportuni ty to be heard. The Civil Service Board will prepare written findings and recommendations. If the Chief takes an action inconsistent with the Board's findings and recommendat ions, he must submit in writing hi s reasons for doi ng so, i ndi cat i ng the areas in whi ch he di sagrees with the Board. He will submit a copy to the Secretary of the Civil Service Board, and to the Union. The issue of whether such proposed change confl i cts wi th thi s Agreement sha 11 be subject to the gri evance procedure contained herein. 46. IAFF 87/88 I I Section 4. All rights and working conditions enjoyed throughout the Department by the employees at the present time and known to the Chief or Assistant Chief (Operations), which are not included in this Agreement shall be presumed to be reasonable and proper and sha 11 not be changed by the City in an arbitrary or capricious manner; provided that nothing contained herein shall limit the City's rights under Sections 1, 2 and 3. 47. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XVI I SENIORITY AND LAYOFFS Sect ion 1. A. In the event of layoffs, all probationary status Firefighters shall be laid off before any permanent status Firefighters or any Fire Lieutenants or Fire Prevention Inspectors. The order of layoff of probationary Firefighters shall be determi ned by management eva 1 uat ions of the performance and potentia 1 of the employees. B. In the event further layoffs are required, such layoffs shall be accompl i shed by cl ass groups of Fi refi ghter, Fi re Lieutenant and Fi re Prevention Inspector. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Agreement, Management shall determine the number of employees to be laid off and the class or classes involved. Within the involved classes, layoffs shall be accomplished by the following groupings: Group A: Employees with one through three years of service in the Clearwater Fire Department or as a Fire Lieutenant or as a Fire Prevention Inspector. Group B: Employees with four through six years of service in the Clearwater Fire Department or as a Fire Lieutenant or as a Fire Prevention Inspector. Group C: Employees with seven through nine years of service in the Clearwater Fire Department or as a Fire Lieutenant or as a Fire Preventioh Inspector. Group D: Employees with ten through twelve years of service in the Clearwater Fire Department or as a Fire Lieutenant or as a Fire Prevention Inspector. 48. IAFF 87/88 I I Group E: Employees with thirteen through fifteen years of service in the Clearwater Fire Department or as a Fire Lieutenant or as a Fire Prevention Inspector. Group F: Employees with sixteen through eighteen years of service in the Clearwater Fire Department or as a Fire Lieutenant or as a Fire Prevention Inspector. Group G: Employees with nineteen or more years of service in the Clearwater Fire Department or as a Fire Lieutenant or as a Fire Prevention Inspector. All employees in Group A must be laid off before any employees listed in Group B; all employees in Group B must be laid off before any employees listed in Group C; etc. Wi thi n each group, employees sha 11 be ranked by management and employees laid off by the rank order established. Management rating of employees can be based upon performance eva 1 uat ions by management of the precedi ng three year period (if available), suspensions and written reprimands, and physical ability to perform the job. Employees classed as Fire Lieutenants or Fire Prevention Inspectors shall have the right to accept a demotion to Firefighter and be placed in the Group for Firefighter based on total service with the Clearwater Fi re Department. Management wi 11 provi de a 1 i st of the rank order wi thi n Groups prior to the layoff. Section 2. If reduction in force requires the layoff of a lieutenant or inspector, the affected lieutenant or inspector may, at his option, revert to the position he held prior to his promotion to lieutenant or inspector. If this movement requires further reduction in force, the same shall be accomplished in accordance with Section 1 above and the process be continued down through the ranks. 49. IAFF 87/88 I I Section 3. No new employee shall be hired until the employee on layoff has been given an opportunity to return to work at his original seniority date and position; provided, that after one year of layoff the employee shall cease to accrue seniority and that such re-employment rights shall cease after five (5) years from the date of layoff. Section 4. The Fire Chief shall give written notice to the Personnel Director and to the affected employee(s) including the President of the Union, on any such proposed layoff. Such notice shall state the reason thereof and shall be submitted thirty (30) days before the effective date of proposed layoff. 50. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XVI I I PARAMEDICS Section 1. A Paramedic is an employee within the City's Fire Department who is assigned by the Department to perform emergency medical services in an emergency medical services program and who has successfully completed and passed a Paramedic training program recognized by the Department and approved by the local medical community as providing advanced training in the D.O.T. Paramedic such as that offered at the St. Petersburg Juni or Co 11 ege, and who has met such other qualifications as may be established by the State of Florida to be a Paramedic, or such other name as is attached to personnel performing the functions contemplated by the parties hereto. A Biomedic is a Paramedic who is assigned to maintain paramedic equipment. Section 2. The titles of Paramedic and Lead Paramedic are not a separate jOb classifications within the Fire Department and those employees assigned as Paramedic/Biomedic shall continue in the rank they hold while being assigned as Paramedic/Biomedic. Section 3. No employee assigned as a Paramedic/Biomedic shall be held ineligible to participate in promotional examinations held in the City's Fire Department nor shall service as a ParamediclBiomedic otherwise disqualify an employee from promotion. Section 4. When a Paramedic/Biomedic is required by the Department to attend cl asses or semi nars in furtherance of hi s conti nui ng education in the delivery of emergency medical services he will be compensated at straight time for hours spent in attendance and such time will not be included in the hours worked by the employee; provided, that an employee will be guaranteed a minimum of three (3) hours pay at straight time. However, an employee who is required to attend 51. IAFF 87/88 I I but does not do so (except for sickness, vacation, or other authorized leave) shall be subject to discipline, provided the employee is given seven (7) days' notice. Section 5. Should the City's Fire Department cease to operate emergency medical services teams, those employees assigned as Paramedics shall continue to be employed by the City on the same basis as any other employee in the bargaining unit. Section 6. Monetary Incentives A. Employees assigned as Paramedics shall receive, in addition to their base rate of pay, 15% incentive pay while so assigned. B. Employees of the Department who currently receive 5% incentive E.M.T. I pay and who are not assigned as Paramedics shall continue to receive such pay, provided the employee retains his state certification as an E.M.T. I. C. Employees becoming certified as E.M.T. I's to an emergency medical services team shall receive 5% E.M.T. I incentive pay. D. The member of a Paramedic team assigned to maintain biomedic equipment used in Paramedic services shall receive 2-1/2% of his base rate of pay as incentive pay for the performance of those duties and only while so assigned. E. The incentive pay contained herein shall be calculated according to the same methods currently used to calculate E.M.T. I pay. F. The Department agrees to publish a semiannual list of all E.M.T. and Paramedi c employees and the dates of expi rat i on of thei r cert i fi cat ion. The Department also agrees to contact the appropriate person at St. Petersburg Junior Co 11 ege and request that a refresher course be set up, but cannot agree to bi nd the Junior College. 52. IAFF 87/88 I I G. ' Any member of the bargaining unit is eligible to participate in the E.M.T. I training program as classes in the program become available; provided, however, that the Chief reserves the right to deny a request if manpower would be significantly impaired. Those members completing the course and becoming state certified, will be eligible for 5% incentive pay, when so assigned. The member will be required to maintain certification in order to be eligible to receive the incentive pay. Section 7. Assignment and Removal as Paramedic A. The assignment of employees as Paramedics shall be at the discretion of the Department. The Fire Department, with input from the Union, shall prepare a competitive examination for assignment to Biomedic. The Union committee shall consist of one (1) Seni or Paramedi c per shi ft. The Uni on understands that Bi omedi cis not a promotional position or a separate jOb classification. The examination will specify the minimum qualifications and define precisely the role (if any) merit evaluation, City seniority, Departmental seniority and paramedic seniority would play in the competitive process. B. The removal of the assignment as Paramedic/Biomedic shall not be subject to the contractual grievance procedure or civil service grievance procedure when the removal is based upon the jUdgment of the medical community with whom the Paramedic/Biomedic works. C. The removal of the assignment as Paramedic/Biomedic shall not be sUbject to the contractual grievance procedure or civil service grievance procedure when the removal is based upon the jUdgment of the Department that the removed Paramedic/Biomedic was not performing to the standards desired by the Department or the medical community. 53. IAFF 87/88 I I D. The removal of the assignment as Paramedic/Biomedic shall be subject to the contractual grievance procedure or the civil service grievance procedure only if such removal is based on a determination by the Department that the employee is guilty of a breach of discipline. E. Neither the Arbitrator nor the Civil Service Board shall have the power to substitute his (their) jUdgment for that of the Department or the medical community with whom Paramedics/Biomedics work in relation to performance of employees to the standards of excellence desired by the City or the medical community. Section 8. The parties within agree that professional employees Relations Act. Section 9. If the application of this Article, or any part thereof, whether or not relating to pay, is superseded by action of a superior governmental agency, then the City will be absolved of complying with this Agreement to the extent of the conflict. the meaning of Paramedics/Biomedics the Florida Public are not Employees 54. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XIX LINE-OF-DUTY INJURY PAY Section 1. The City hereby agrees to pay the following compensation to any employee injured in the line of duty in accordance with the following definitions, terms and conditions. A. Compensation shall be payable under this Section only with respect to disability as the result of injury to an employee where such injury is incurred in the line of duty. B. An injury sha 11 be deemed to have been incurred in the 1 i ne of duty if and only if such injury is compensable under the Florida Workers' Compensation Law. C. The amount of compensation paid shall be the amount required to supplement funds received from the Florida Workers' Compensation Law and any other disability or other income plan provided by the City, either by law or by agreement, to the point where the sum of the supplement herein provided and all other payments herein described equal the employee's weekly wage at the time of the injury. D. No compensation under this Section shall be allowed for the first seven (7) days of disability; provided, however, that if the injury results in disability of more than fourteen (4) days, compensation shall be paid from the commencement of the disability. E. The term disability as used in this Section means incapacity because of the line-of-duty injury to earn in the same or any other employment the wages which the employee was receiving at the time of injury. 55. IAFF 87/88 I I F. It is the intent of this Section to provide supplemental compensation for line-of-duty injuries only, and this Section shall not be construed to provide compensation in the event of death or injury incurred in any manner other than in the line of duty. In the event of any dispute or disagreement concerning the interpretation of the terms of this Section, then the decisions concerning definition of those terms issued under the Florida Workers' Compensation Law shall control. G. The maximum period for which payment may be made under this Section shall be ninety (90) days from the date of injury for each injury, inCluding recurrences thereof. No payment made by the City during said period shall be charged against any sick leave which the employee may have accrued. Section 2. It is the intention of the parties that nothing in this Agreement sha 11 interfere with the norma 1 procedures under the Workers' Compensation Laws or the requirements of the City's workers' compensation insurance carrier. SUbject to such intended limitations: A. An employee who is injured in the 1 i ne of duty and whose condi t ion requires hospitalization shall have the right to select his own hospital and his own physician. The choice shall be made by the injured person or if the condition prevents him from making such choice, by his family. The Firefighter shall at all times have the right to change his physician. If the injured Firefighter requires hospitalization and medical treatment outside the City of Clearwater, it shall be permitted and will not affect articles and sections of this Agreement. B. In other cases involving injuries in the line of duty which do not require hospitalization, the injured employee shall have the right to be treated by a physician of his own choice. 56. IAFF 87/88 J I Section 3. If an employee is killed in the line of duty, the City shall pay to the spouse, or if there is no survi vi ng spouse, the estate, of such deceased employee his accumulated severance pay. Within forty-eight (48) hours of the death of the employee, the City shall deliver to the spouse or surviving chi 1 dren or the employee's dependent benefi ci ary a check for the sum of one month's current salary of the employee. Section 4. Upon return from working a fire, the employee may request a physical examination by the City physician to ensure the employee is stable and capable of returning to work. This right may be rescinded on an individual basis if repeatedly abused. Section 5. Failure to immediately report a line-of-duty injury at the time of the occurrence to either the employee's immediate supervisor, the City Nurse, the Safety Officer on proper forms, within twenty-four (24) hours of the line-of- duty injury, if possible, shall cause the City to not pay the compensation under this Section. 57. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XX LEAVES OF ABSENCE Section 1. Sick Leave for Family Illness Sick leave will be accrued in the same manner that it is presently earned. An employee may utilize his accumulated sick time due to an illness in his immediate family (as that term is defined in Article XII, Section 8.F.(4) of this Agreement) up to a maximum of 56 hours and 40 hours for 40-hour personnel in each fiscal year; provided that so much of the 56 hours or 40 hours that is not used in one year may be carried over and used in the next succeeding year. Section 2. Funeral Leave A. An employee shall be allowed up to three (3) shifts off with pay in the event of a death in the immediate family, which shall be limited to spouse, chi 1 dren or parent, brother, sister, stepmother, stepfather, or any other blood relative living under the same roof as the employee. This is not chargeable to sick leave. B. An employee shall be granted up to two (2) shifts off with pay in the event of a death in the family specifically defined as mother-in-law, father-in- law, grand mother, grandfather, sister-in-law, or brother-in-law. This is chargeable to sick leave. C. Additional time-off may be granted by the Fire Chief, or his designee. Furthermore, any employee availing himself/herself of a provision in this Section must notify the Fire Chief or his/her District Commander of such intent as soon as possible. Section 3. Right to Contribute Work In the event that an employee's illness or physical incapacity should cont i nue beyond the poi nt where hi s/her accumu 1 ated sick 1 eave, if any, has been 58. IAFF 87/88 I I exhausted, he/she may elect to have other qualified employees of the Department perform his/her regular duties; provided that such substitution would not require overtime compensation for the substitute and the maximum allowable contributed time to anyone employee is a total of 90 calendar days for the duration of this contract. Secti on 4. Any funera 1 1 eave, other than provi ded for inSect ion 2 above, will be governed by Article XII, Section 8.E. 59. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XXI MISCELLANEOUS Section 1. When an employee is assigned in an acting capacity to a higher position he/she shall receive 5% above his/her current base rate of pay, after the employee has acted in the hi gher capacity for 144 hours duri ng the duration of this Agreement (commencing October 1, 1984), provided that no payment will be made or accrual toward the 144 hours will be calculated unless the employee has acted in the higher position for a minimum of 8 consecutive hours. Furthermore, employees presently in the Department will be permitted to grandfather in any hours they have already accrued under any prior collective bargaining agreement as an express exception to this provision. Section 2. All life insurance premium contributions and plans currently in force sha 11 continue for the duration of thi s Agreement. The selection of an insurance company shall be free and without prejudice and of the employee's choice from the twelve companies offered by the City. The Union agrees to participate in discussions of alternative programs. Section 3. All members of the bargaining unit may wear the I.A.F.F. pin on their uniforms. Section 4. The City shall continue to provide the initial clothing and protective devices currently supplied, or their equivalent, and initial safety equipment currently supplied, without cost to the employee, as well as replacement for supplies damaged through normal wear and tear. The employee pays for what he/she loses and what is abused, provided the Department can document employee negligence contributed to the loss or abuse of clothing, protective devices, or safety equipment provided by the City. 60. IAFF 87/88 I I Section 5. The current practice regarding the wearing of hats and ties shall be continued, except that ties need not be worn by combat and rescue personnel while in the station or while responding to emergencies and short sleeve shirts shall be worn. Section 6. During the term of this Agreement, the City shall not subcontract out to private concerns the basic fire suppression and rescue services of the Department. Section 7. The City shall provide and maintain adequate training facilities as recommended by Florida requirements for training centers, or such facilities as may be agreed upon by the City and the Union. Section 8. The City agrees to defend any employee when the employee is sued on any claim arising out of his employment with the City and acting within the scope of his duties. The employee agrees to cooperate in his defense. The City also agrees to pay any judgment rendered against an employee for acts committed when the employee is acting within the scope of his City employment, provided that the employee did not act intentionally, with malice, or with gross negligence. Section 9. To the extent that employees are presently allowed to play handball, such allowance shall continue for the duration of this Agreement. Secti on 10. The current practice of payi ng accrued ri ghts and benefits to the designated beneficiary or next-of-kin upon the death of an employee shall continue. Section 11. Members of the bargaining unit shall be entitled to participate in the City-wide tuition reimbursement program on the same basis as all other employees. Section 12. The Department shall counsel with any employee who is passed over by another candidate on the list of promotions. 61. IAFF 87/88 I I Section 13. Employees covered by this contract shall not be required to perform lawn maintenance at the fire stations. Section 14. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, persons selected for paramedic training, during the training period, shall work a normal combat schedule plus the hours necessary to attend training sessions, such additional time to be paid at the straight time hourly rate of pay. Section 15. Any employee whose appearance is required in Circuit Court or County Court as the result of a matter arising out of the course of his employment, shall receive a minimum of two (2) hours pay if such attendance is during the employee's off-duty hours. This same provision shall also apply when the employee is subpoenaed to appear at the State Attorney's Office, Public Defender's Office, or a private attorney's office, in a criminal case arising from the employee's course of employment. However, this provision shall not apply when an employee or the Uni on has brought an act ion against the City or any City official. Section 16. Sick Leave Accrual An employee may elect to apply 50% of his accrued sick leave toward an early retirement date, or may elect to draw a lump sum bonus equal to 50% of his accrued sick leave calculated at the salary rate applicable on his resignation date. The election is irrevocable. Section 17. The City will reimburse to the employee at the rate of Twenty Cents ($.20) per mile for each move a Firefighter is required to make, and use hiS/her own vehicle, after he/she has reported to hiS/her duty station; or, the City may elect to provide transportation. This distance will be computed by the City, so that both the City and employee can refer to a standard table to ascertain the distance between any two (2) Fire Stations. The money shall be paid September 30 of each year. In the event that an employee is transported in a City 62. IAFF 87/88 I I vehicle under the provisions of this part, the City will provide the employee transportation back to his/her duty station at or before the end of the employee's tour of duty if the employee so requests. Section 18. Health Insurance The City agrees to meet wit~ the I.A.F.F. and other City of Clearwater union representatives to review the health insurance program for the purpose of reducing the cost of such program for the City and the employees. The City further agrees to provi de the I. A. F . F. with such i nformat i on as woul d be requi red to formul ate such a benefit package and to cooperate with the I.A.F.F. and other unions to obtain pertinent information from the present carri er. Unt 11 a benefit package is formu 1 ated and put into operation, the City agrees to continue the current benefits. Any information received by either party from the Consultant or from another carrier will be shared with the other party. Section 19. All members of the bargaining unit are required to launder their own shirts, uniform trousers, uniform jackets and bedding. The City agrees to compensate each employee by a 1 ump sum payment of $250.00 per year. Each employee must supply his/her own sheets and pillow cases. 63. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XXII PHYSICAL EXAMINATION Section 1. Employees covered by this labor agreement who are forty (40) years of age or older shall be required to undergo an annual physical examination as scheduled by the Fire Department. In addition to the above, it is agreed by the parties that physicals for employees covered by this labor agreement shall be given as follows: Paramedics - annually 30 - 39 years of age - every 2 years 18 - 29 years of age - every 3 years Section 2. The employer shall determine the extent of the examination and bear the cost of each examination. The results of these physicals shall be made available to the City and to each employee upon completion of the physical. Physicals shall include but not necessarily be limited to the following: 1. Stress EKG - where indicated and at discretion of examining physician. SMA Profile 12 (liver, blood sugar, etc.) Chest X-Ray Complete Blood Count 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Urinalysis Rectal Cancer Exam Doctor's Physical (eyesight, reflexes, hearing, throat, etc.) Breast/Cervical Cancer Exam (Females) Audiometric Evaluation Section 3. The City agrees to pay all expenses for inoculation or immunization shots for employees and members of an employee's family residing in 64. IAFF 87/88 I I his/her household when such becomes necessary as a result of said employee's exposure to contagious disease where said employee had been exposed to said disease in the line of duty; provided that the employee first makes all reasonable efforts to have this service performed at no cost by the County Health Department. Section 4. The parties agree that the physical condition of the employee is of great concern to the employee and to the City. The parties agree that all employees may be required to participate in a physical fitness exercise program set up jointly by the Union and management. 65. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XXII I AMENDMENTS This Agreement may be amended at any time by the mutual written consent of the parties, but no such attempted amendment shall be of any force or effect until placed in writing and executed by each party hereto. 66. IAFF 87/88 I , ARTICLE XXIV SEVERABILITY AND WAIVER Section 1. Each and every clause of this Agreement shall be deemed separable from each and every other clause of this Agreement to the end that in the event that any clause or clauses shall be finally determined to be in violation of any law, then and in such event, such clause or clauses only, to the extent only that any may be so in violation, shall be deemed of no force and effect and unenforceable, without impairing the validity and enforceability of the rest of the contract, including any and all provisions in the remainder of any clause, sentence or paragraph in which the offending language may appear. Section 2. The exercise or non-exercise by the City or the Union of the rights covered by this Agreement shall not be deemed to waive any such right or the right to exercise them in some other way in the future. Section 3. In the event of invalidation of any article or section, both the City and the Union agree to meet within thirty (30) days of such determination for the purpose of arriving at a mutually satisfactory replacement for such articles or sections. 67. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XXV CONTRACT CONSTITUTES ENTIRE AGREEMENT OF THE PARTIES The parties acknowledge and agree that, during the negotiations which resulted in this Agreement, each had the unlimited right and opportunity to make demands and proposals with respect to any subject or matter included by law within the area of collective bargaining and that all the understandings and agreements arrived at by the parties after the exercise of that right and opportunity are set forth in this Agreement. Therefore, the City and the Union, for the life of this Agreement, each voluntarily and unqualifiedly waive the right to require further collective bargaining, and each agrees that the other shall not be obligated to bargain collectively with respect to any matter or subject not specifically referred to or covered by thi s Agreement, whether or not such matters have been di scussed, even though such subjects or matters may not have been withi n the knowledge or contemplation of either or both parties at the time that they negotiated or signed this Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire contract, understanding, undertaking, and agreement of the parties hereto, and finally determines and settles all matters of collective bargaining for and during its term, except as may be otherwise specifically provided herein. 68. IAFF 87/88 I I ARTICLE XXVI DURATION, MODIFICATION AND TERMINATION Thi s Agreement shall be effective as of the 1st day of October, 1987, and shall continue in full force and effect until the 30th day of September, 1988. At 1 east one hundred twenty (20) days pri or to the termi nat ion of this Agreement, either party hereto shall notify the other, in writing, of its intention to modify, amend or terminate this Agreement. Failure to notify the other party of intention to modify, amend or terminate, as hereinabove set forth, will automatically extend the provisions and terms of this Agreement for a period of one (1) year, and each year thereafter absent notification. 69. IAFF 87/88 I I IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have hereunder set their hands ,~\ (;t and seals this Lf day of '-~~/-^^~ -D<j, , 19rt'."-Y ';- \ Attest: CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA '-I ,'r' " /,j :.' . '-.l , ' /~. '. ci t~-'c;e~~kJ" ( ". ~'-'~~-CA BY~;~~ "rh)rl-~:.c t-// Interim City Manager Approved as t~_form,and correctness: ~~J> ..../ '/ City Attorney U Signed, sealed and delivered in presence of: INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, AFL-CIO, Local 1158 B~ " QQ..~ Y~ident, Local 1158 70. IAFF 87/88 . , ~{j , \_,