Loading...
FLD2005-01007 (2)• • FLD2005-01007 15 AVALON ST Date Received: 01/31/2005 AMBIANCE ON WHITE SANDS ZONING DISTRICT: T LAND USE: RFH ATLAS PAGE: 258A PLANNER OF RECORD: WW CLWCoverSheet .., ~ ... ... y f,,:Fi... '~.~:i: CASE 1~'. /'r(~I'Jll;~ ... ~e:~~wa$er Planning Department DATE RECEIVED: ~"~ `~~ ;~ 1 100 South Myrtle Avenue ', RECEIVED 8Y staff initials ~ Clearwater, Florida 33756 ATLAS PAGE #: Telephone: 727-562-4567 ZONING DISTRICT: ~~°`'°~' Fax: 727-562-4865 LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: SURROUNDING USES OF;ADJACEN7 ^ SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED AND NOTARIZED APPLICAT{ON PROPE-RTIES: NORTH: D SUBMIT 14 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION including SOUTH: 1) collated, 2) stapled and 3) folded sets of site plans WEST. EAST: ^ SUBMIT APPLICATION FEE $ ~` NOTE: 15 TOTAL SETS OF INFORMATION REQUIRED (APPLICAT{ONS PLUS SITE PLANS SETS) 0 R `~ I ~~~ ;~~ ~~ FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project (Revised 10-10-2003) ~PI. EASE TYPE OR PRIlV'T^~ use additional sheets as necessary A. APPLICANT, P OPERTY OWNER AND AGENT INFORMATION: (Section 4202.A) APPLICANT NAME• !,/~~l~hru~~ fir'-~'~~'L~Q ~ LU MAILING ADDRE \ :'~~ ~L~+~ •t-/elf ~ g~~' HL,~ ~.~l/ [ • /6~/~L~/~ 't~.C YG ~~1~~ E-MAIL ADDRESS !,~•- - PHONE NUMBER: 7• ~' f~ ~` 7 7.~~ CELL NUMBER: /~ FAX NUMBER: ~ ~ - 5~l ~ - ~ ~~ C-~ PROPERTY OWNER(S): `~~ And,-r~ ~ ~f t " ~/I/ ~~~-r G L~r (Must include ALL owners as listed on the deed - pnrvide original signature(s) on page 6) AGENT NAME(S): S ~ ~ P '`~~ MAILING ADDRESS:~i2,/ ~~~ `~~Gl aCl ~~ ~ ~, c . ~.~'I/fuJ~''T~~ /~ ~y''~C~ ~ E-MAIL ADDRES ~ y r ' ~ /~1~ 'i-~~~N~~i~ ~~a't • PHONE NUMBER:~ `l - 'Y "`~7 - ~y ~o ~/ CELL NUMBER: ~ ~7 - `70 C/- G~~'y'J FAX NUMBER: `~ 7- 5/~/ ~ - ;~~3~ B. PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT fNFORMATION: ~ ~~ STREET ADDRESS of subject'site%(.~~'~Q L ~ ~f~ fS /y ~-~ X2„3 ~.~ ~-- d h ~tUfd ~y LEGAL DESCRIPTION: 1~7~ ~ l___,_- r_-~ t%~ ~"l ~C~l ~, ~, ~~/-1~77~~,~"~` ~`~~ /~ I~~7~ (if not li ted h e, p ase note th ocatlon this document in the submiita~ PARCEL NUMBER: ~ ~ ,e~~©~ ~ /%~%~~~ l>~~j D~~~ ~~~% ~Jlx~~ /~t~ / PARCEL SIZE: ~~[~~~ ~,~ ~ ~ 7 ~ ``F f" ---- (facres, square feet) /' / ~ ~ 1~`~ n PROPOSED USE AND SIZE: /~~ ~~.~t~ ~~t~ / L %~-~ ~ eC~i ~ I\\ ~~~~~r; t+-k, ~r (number of dwelling units, hotel rooms'or square footage of nonresidential use) ' DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST(S):,~~' Q L-C~t L` a(.~~ ~SL~I,~/Z ~~ Attach sheets and be specific when identifying the request (include all requested ccde ite~iat~on~~~e~g~. ezluct~on in~re~ ~~rn~~ ber of parking spaces, specific use, etc.) ~`~'''~/ OF CI ~AlnlA/~~~~g n__.. . _c ~ ri _..; ~..i_ n... ...7............1 A...,R n•.+i.... (`....~,.....h......n.,, Inflll D...~L,.,nl.......nv.1 Orro nn~__ r`ih, ..i !•`In.~n..afnr 1 BQSt ~+Opy APPLICATION INVOLVE THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS (TDR),~"A~PRELY APPROVED PLANNED UNIT j ~,i ' O ~%~ c T S,~ D ES DEVEL,~ ~~ENT, OR A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED (CERTIFIED) SITE PLAN? YES NO fi ",_ (if yes, attach a copy of the applicable ~:"jrT, F''~li~ i: ~'I ,/ '".4 ~ t ~IFj~~ r~tl. ~'~;~i ~_tti:r~•' v r ".'iii", C. PR;OF4F QF DUVNERSHIP: (Section 4 202.A) ~ . - ..y 1. '~ ~ ti. ~: : y: C~~SU6MIT A COPY OF THE TITLE INSURANCE POLICY, DEED TO THE PROPERTY OR SIGN AFFIDAVIT ATTESTING OWNERSHIP (see Page g);`t,`!~`:: D. WRITTEN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 3-973.A) f~ Provide complete responses to the six (6) GENERAL APPLtCABILlTY CRITERIA -Explain how each criteria is achieved, in detail: 1. The proposed development of the land will be in harmony with the scale, bulk, coverage, density and character of adjacent properties in which it is located. -t~~ ~~ ~ c ~ f}~.t~i~i% ~' 2. The proposed development will not hinder or discourage the appropriate development and use of adjacent land and buildings or significantly eo f _ impair the value ther f~ -/ / ~ , s'~1%' f~ Q ~ ~GL ~ 7L cE L~' ~~/,~1~ 3. The proposed development wilt not adversely affect the health or safety or persons residing or working in the neighborhood of the proposed use. '~5- t ~ ~- /~ ~ ~ ~ ~~i~/l,~ C 4. The proposed development is designed to minimize traffic congestion. 5. The proposed development is consistent with the community character of the immediate v(cinity of the parcel proposed for development. 6. The design of the proposed development minimizes adverse effects, Including visual, acoustlc and olfactory and hours of operation impacts, ert ies. on adjacent prop ` ` r / Y ' ^ 1. Provide complete responses to the ten (10) COMPREHENSEVE INFiLL REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT CRITERIA (as applicable) -Explain how each criteria is achieved in detail: The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for development is otherwise impractical withts~t~deuiations,froi'n'the rise; iitteh ity and development standards. ~~C'~~[ ~ ~ ~ ~~~ -Syc` ~ ~~~N~~~ ~~.i~i,~'~' ~ ADD ~Q~~ !7'L' (°11~~V~~~C~ ~~~~Y~I IVI~1 1 +aiYY Y rj'Y 'r/Y.~r ~.MtivY ~Y Y.Yy Best copy Availably ~. 2. The developme~t;'of the parcel proposed for development as a comprehensive infill redevelopment project or residential infili project wilt reduce the faii;!market value of abutting properties. (Include the existing value of the site and the proposed value of the site with 3. The uses within the comprehensive infili redevelopment project are otherwise permitted in the City of Clearwater -~~ 4. The uses or.mix of use within the comprehensive infill redevelopment project are compatible with adjacent land uses. 5. Suitable sites for development or redevelopment of the uses or mix of uses within the comprehensive infill redevelopment project are not otherwise available in the City of Clearwater. 6. The development of the parcel proposed for'development as a comprehensive infill redevelopment project will upgrade the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development. ~f ~ ~L~~~~~/ ~,~%/~-rte ~ 7. The design of the proposed comprehensive infill redevelopment project creates a form and function that enhances the community character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole. ~ff C~ GE L~/ Gr~-f ~ C~' ~'~i~l~i~ ,~ 8. Flexibility in regard to lot width, required setbacks; height and off-street parking are justified by the benefits to community character and the immediate vicinity o€ the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole. 9. Adequate off-street parking in the immediate vicinity according to the shared parking formula in Division 14 of Article 3 will be available to avoid on-street parking in the immediate vicinity of parcel proposed for development. s~~ ~ ~L~' r~~~ ~~.~~~ k 10. The design of alt buildings complies with the Tourist District or Downtown District design guidelines in Division 5 of Article 3 (as applicable). Use separate sheets as necessary. r~ r-n ~~ r--~ nn nr~ r~ APR 0 6 1Q05 (CITY OF ~L~RWA~'~R Paoe 3 of 7 -Flexible Development Application -Comprehensive infili Redevelopment Project- City of Clearwater • • ORIGINAL Revised Exhibit "A" to Flexible Development Application (Comprehensive Infill) Ambiance on White Sands NES Project #0501 Description of Request(s): To demolish an existing 15-unit, overnight accommodation building, 8-duplex/triplex residential structures to construct a six (6) story (five levels above parking}, 15 unit condominium project. This request to construct 15 attached dwelling units through the utilization of the City's provision for Termination of Status of Nonconformity (Section 6- 109 of the Community Development Code) and utilization of the City's provision for Transfer of Development Rights (Section 4-1401 of the Community Development Code). This also includes requests to reductions to the required front setbacks from 25' (MHDR- Avalon) to zero feet to the trash staging area and 10' to building, from 15' (Tourist - Kendall) to 10' to building, reductions to the required side setbacks from 10' to variations of 7 feet on the north-west side and 3 feet on the south-west to building, reduction to the required reaz setback (MHDR) from 15' to 10'. Additionally, the applicant is requesting a deviation to the maximum allowable height from 50' to 52' 8.' to the top of the roof deck and an additional 3' to top of decorative parapet edge. CALCULATION: 15 transient units x .75 = 11 residential units n 08 residential units x 1 = 08 residential units llu~~~~~~,,; Total Residential units = 19 / 15 to be constructed on site. APR Q ~ 2dQrJ No signage is proposed at this time. PLANNING dEP,ART~v~ENT CfTY t~F CLEt~R~1lAT~R Written Submittal Requirements: 1. The proposed development will be in harmony with the surrounding area and other existing and proposed residential uses. The subject site is located within the Old Florida District of Beach By Design which anticipates low to mid-rise development. Although the proposed project exceeds the maximum height limitation, not that long ago a project by the name of Larissa was proposed at 69.5' to the highest roof deck, (the proposed project is 14'5" under this height). The proposed increase in height for the parapets will help to conceal roof top air conditioning equipment and will lend in creating a balanced appearance for the proposed Mediterranean design. Other projects similar to the proposed height and setbacks were approved in the same vicinity under the names of Chalets on White Sands and Chateaus on White Sands. 2. The proposed development will only entice appropriate development of surrounding properties and will serve as an incentive for either re- development of other nearby sites or upgrades to current uses and will not adversely impact the surrounding property values. • ~ ORIGINAL 3. As the proposal is for a residential use, the health and safety of persons in the neighborhood will not be adversely affected. Appropriate visibility triangles will be observed and maintained and all required parking will be provided on site in lieu of within the right-of--way. On-site retention will be provided on site where none exists now. 4. Proper traffic flow was designed to and from this proposed project. This was designed as to not interfere with the abutting City parking lot traffic. 5. The proposal is consistent with the community character of the Old Florida District as great effort has gone into the attractive Mediterranean design so that Beach By Design concepts are enjoyed. 6. No adverse effects to adjacent properties are anticipated as this is a residential use. No commercial uses are being proposed for this site so noise, olfactory and hours of operation impacts are not an issue. Comprehensive Infill Project Criteria 1. The subject site is desirable for redevelopment due to its close proximity to the beach and beach related amenities. However, adjacent properties are not available for purchase therefore leaving a very irregularly shaped parcel on which to develop a high quality residential project. In order to make the project financially viable, the request for the 15 units, at the size being proposed is necessary. The need to provide on-site parking (23 spaces are required and 24 are being proposed) is driving the requested reductions to setbacks and increase in height. T`he proposed height will also allow the scale of the building to be in concert with the desired Mediterranean design and allows for all required parking to be provided on site. 2. Per the Pinellas County Property Appraiser the existing just market value of subject site is $2,010,200.00. With the proposed improvements to the site, the estimated value upon completion would be $25,000,000.00. This type of potential increase to the subject site's property value can only work towards increasing the value of surrounding properties. 3. Attached dwellings are permitted uses within both the Tourist and MHDR zoning district and within the City of Clearwater. 4. The proposed residential use is compatible with other surrounding and adjacent land uses. 5. The development of the uses within the comprehensive infill redevelopment project, are not otherwise available in the other areas of the City of Clearwater. The proposed site has been designed and redesigned for the allowed uses within this district. The proposed development is a residential use where other residential properties lie within. 6. Just razing the transient units and duplexftriplex building will upgrade the immediate vicinity of the parcel. With the development of the parcel, this will also increase the property values of the surrounding neighbors. 7. The design of the project will bring parking onto the site in lieu of within the right-of way, will provide on-site retention where none exists at this time and will provide areas of tropical iandscaping.where little to none exis~~~~nn n~~ e PR ~ 6 2005 PLANNING aEP~RTi~ENT • • ORIGINAL I~~C ~9~O~D APR ~ ~ ZQD5 8. Flexibility in regazd to required setbacks and increased height are justified by the benefits provided to the surrounding community. The immediate neighborhood and users of the City owned public parking lots and beach areas will enjoy the redevelopment of the site from a predominantly overnight accommodation use into an attractive owner occupied high-end residential project with secured on-site parking via infrared lasers versus fences, gates and walls. 9. No off-street pazking will be required at the proposed site. All pazking will be contained on-site. 10. The design of the proposed building complies with the Tourist District design guidelines in Division 5 of Article 3. The proposed building is a residential building with requirements being met whether by the flexible development or by being able to meet the minimum requirements. Transient, run-down units are being replaced by a more attractive building which falls within the City's plans for redevelopment. PL~INNING dEPRRTi'~1ENT CITY OF OLE~RWATER r •~ ~ _ LL ~ - :'';:::. Planning Department o : + . 100 South Myrtle Avenue J •~ > ` j~,~a,~~~ Clearwater, Florida 33756 " Telephone:727-56211567 o Fax: 727-562865 ^ SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED tiND NOTARIZED APPLICATION ^ SUBMIT 14 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION including 1) collated, 2) stapled and 3) folded sets of site plans ^ SUBMIT APPLICATION FEE $ ~ ORIGINAL CASE #: DATE RECEIVED: RECEIVED BY (staff initials): ATLAS PAGE #: ~ ':ZONING DISTRICT: LAND USE CLASSIF1CATlON: SURROUNDING USES OF ADJACENT ~ PROPERTIES: NORTH: SOUTH: . WEST: EAST: '~ NOTE: 14 TOTAL SETS OF INFORMATION REQUIRED (APPLICA710NS PLUS SITE PLAN SETS) FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIO~1~~~~~,~~ Residential Infill Project (xev;sed ziovaooa) PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT A. APPLICANT, PROPERTY OWNER AND AGENT INFORMATION: (Code Section 4-202.A)., /' c.,~ l ~ OF ~~E~;RWATE APPLICANT NAM ~~/~ ,E~InI ~~.~'~~ ~~~ ~~~ MAILINGADDRESS~~ /~f~~~~7~ ~~~9 ~~ii~/~/,/~.( LZ'[1. ~/~ ~~~/.~.~ PHONE NUMBER: ~ ~ • 'YLo~- ~ 7~1o FAX NUMBER: `~.-~ `1 - ~~,~~ ~ ~~ PROPERTY OWNER(S): ~ _ , (Must include ALL owners) AGENT NAME: j ~ - ~ C MAILING ADDRES ' /'~~ ~ ~~ PHONE NUMBER:` i~.~ ~I ~o~/~;E.7 r~ ~ FAX NUMBER: `7 - CELL NUMBER: ~Z `~ - `7O l • c~ ~`/c~ E-MAIL ADDRES ~ ~ ~ ~ e ~~ B. PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT I,~N,F,~ORMATION: (Code Section 4-202.A) STREET ADDRESS: ,~~ ~~C~l y'~Llrl ~ f ~~ I ~3 ~~5 ~-~ y ,~ll'~~ LEGAL DESCRIPTION: ~ -~ ~ - PARCEL NUMBER: G' ~1~ /~~Srll?~!7 /~~Sc~ O„ I ~1~~, ~! 7 d ~3~ fJ~ C,l~~ I PARCEL SIZE: ~/~ ~ ALA /G~~ ~ 01 ~t, ~ ~/' ~7 ~` l (acres, square feet) PROPOSED USE(S) AND SIZE(S):,f ~ ,4.sC~~////,•~ (/ /,cf~ j_! ,dtj".~5 (number of dwelling units, hotel rooms or square footage of nonresidential use) DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST(S)~~ ~j~~f/~ ~ . ~~Gi,.~iLh's f-' ,/~ (include all requested code deviations; e.g. reduction in required number of parking spaces, specific use, etc.) ASR n s zaa~ 1A 11A.A,h /T.r*. ~n k:.Fyw~rYV~~Vi/Y.~lLit"uCII1V(t'{~11 Pane 1 of 7 - Flexihle Develnnment Residential infill Aoolication -City of Clearwater t • ORIGINAL DOES THIS APPLICATION INVOLVE THE TRANSFER OF DEVEi_OPMENT RIGHTS (TDR), A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT, OR A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED (CERTIFIED) SITE PLAN? YES NO ~ifyes, attach a copy of the applicable documents) I C. PROOF OF OWNERSHIP: (Code Section 4-~~2.A.5) ,{r~' SUBMIT A COPY OF THE TITLE INSURANCE POLICY, DEED OR AFFIDAVIT ATTESTING TO THE OWNERSHIP OF THE PROPERTY D. ^ 1. WRITTEN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Code Section 3-993.A) Provide complete responses to the six (6) GENERAL APPLICABILITY CRITERIA -Explain how each criteria is achieved, in detail: The proposed development of the land will be in harmony with the scale, bulk, coverage, density and character of adjacent properties in which it is located. ~ /J 2. • The proposed development will not hinder or discourage the appropriate development and use of adjacent land and buildings or signiflcantiy impair the value thereof. 3. The proposed development will not adversely affect the health or safety or persons residing or working In the neighborhood of the proposed 4. .The proposed development is designed to minimize traffic congestion. 5. The proposed development is consistent with the community character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development. 6. The design of the proposed development minimizes adverse effects, including visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operation impacts, on adjacent properties. ~~~' Q ~-c~.~ ~ ~~i~i ~ ~ A APR 0 6 2005 Pt.~41VN11~0 61=PeRRTi~1ENT CITY OF CLE~RWAT~R • ORIGINAL ^ Provide complete responses to the seven (7) RESIDENTIAL INFILL PROJECT CRITERIA -Explain how each criteria is achieved, in detail:: 1. The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for development is otherwise impractical withqut deviations from the intensity and development standards. 2. The development of the parce! proposed for development as a residential infill project will not materially reduce the fair market value of abutting properties. (Include the existing value of the site and the proposed value of the site with the improvements.} 3. The uses within the residential infill project are otherwise permitted in the City of Clearwater. 4. The uses or mix of use within the residential infill project are compaSble with adjacent land uses. ~~ ~ ~~ 3~. PLA~I~I~~t11G ~Il~pa~~~,~~n,~~ CITY OF CLE~RV!/ATE~? 5. The development~of the parcel proposed for development as a residential infill project will upgrade the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development. ' 6. The design of the proposed residential infill project creafes a form and function that enhances the community character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel pro/posed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole. 4 7. Flexibility in regard to lot width, required setbacks, height and off-street parking are justified by the benefits to community character and the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole. l~a....F (`in.,......a..~ • ~ ORIGINAL ' E. SUPPLEMENTAL SUBMITTA!_ REQUIREMENTS: (Code Section 4-202.A) i~StGNED AND SEALED SURVEY (including legal description of property) -One original and 14 copies; EY" TREE SURVEY (including existing trees on site and within 25' of the adjacent site, by species, size (DBH 4" or greater), and location, including drip lines and indicating trees to be ; emoved); ~ LOCATION MAP OF THE PROPERTY; ~ ~ y ~~ PARKING DEMAND STUDY in conjunction with a request to make deviations to the parking standards lie. Reduce number of spaces). Prior to the submittal of this application, the methodology of such study shall be approved by the Community Development Coordinator and shat! be in accordance with accepted traffic engineering principles. The findings of the study will be used in determining whether or not deviations to the parking standards are approved; =~ GRADING PLAN, as applicable; RELIMINARY PLAT, as required (Note: Building permits will not be issued until evidence of recording a final plat is provided); i . COPY OF RECORDED PLAT, as applicable; F. SITS PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS; (Code Section 4-202.A) SITE PLAN with the following Information (not to exceed 24" x 36"): _/ All dimensions;. / North arrow; Engineering bar scale (minimum scale one Inch equals 50 feet), and date prepared; ,i Location map; ./ Index sheet referencing individual sheets Included in package; ~C Footprint and size of all EXISTING buildings and structures; ./ Footprint and size of all PROPOSED buildings and structures; ~ All required setback; :L All existing and proposed points of access; ,~ All required sight triangles; / identification of environmentally unique areas, such as watercourses, wetlands, tree masses, and specimen trees, including description and location of understory, ground cover vegetation and wildlife habitats, etc; :/ Location of all public and private easements; Location of alt street rights-of--way within and adjacent to the site; ~ location of existing public and private utilities, including fire hydrants, storm and sanitary sewer lines, manholes and lift stations, gas and water lines; All parking spaces, driveways, loading areas and vehicular use areas; Depiction by shading or crosshatching of all required parking lot interior landscaped areas; ./ Location of all solid waste containers, recycling or trash handling areas and outside mechanical equipment and alt required screening {per Section 3-201(D)(i) and Index #701); ./ Location of all landscape material; Location of alt onsite and offsite storm-water management facilities; ./ Location of all outdoor lighting fixtures; and / Location of alt existing and proposed sidewalks. 0" SITE DATA TABLE for existing, required, and proposed development, in written/tabular form: _,~ Land area in square feet and acres; ,,~ Number of EXISTING dwelling units; ,.;,G Number of.PROPOSED dwelling units; ,G Gross floor area devoted to each use; ,G„ .Parking spaces: total number, presented in tabular form with the number of required spaces; ..~ Total paved area, including all paved parking spaces and driveways, expressed in square feet and percentage of the paved vehicular area; „G, Size and species of all landscape material; ~ Official records book and page numbers of all existing utility easement; ~ Building and structure heights; ~ Impermeable surface ratio (I.S.R.); and ,,L FIoo4 area ratio (F.A.R.) for all nonresidential uses. Ca/ REDUCED SITE PLAN to scale (8'/~ X 11) and color rendering if possible; R[~C~~~M!~~ ^ FOR DEVELOPMENTS OVER ONE ACRE, provide the following additional Information on site plan: One-foot contours or spot elevations on site; pPR n ~ ?~In~ Offsite elevations if required Po evaluate the proposed stormwater management for the parcel; _ All open space areas; ,_ Location of all earth or water retaining walEs and earth berms; ~~~N~~~ [~~P.~,RT~iEIVT `~ Lot lines and building lines (dimensioned); CIT1~ OF CLE~RWAT~R _ Streets and drives (dimensioned); Building and structural setbacks (dimensioned); _ Structural overhangs; _ Tree Inventory; prepared by a °certified arborist", of all trees 8" DBH or greater, reflecting size, canopy (drip lines) and condition of such trees. Paoe 4 of 7 -Flexible Develooment Residential Infill Aoolication -City of Clearwater • • ORIGINAL G. STORMWATER PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (City of Clearv+r•a#er Design Criteria Manual and 4-202.A.21) ^ STORMWATER PLAN including the following requirements: ~ Existing tnNOgraphy extending 50 feet beyond all property lines; Proposed grading including finished floor elevations of all structures; .. . ,~ Ali-adjacent streets and municipal storm systems; / Proposed stormwater detention/retention area including top of bank, toe of slope and outlet control structure; ,/ stormwater calculations for attenuation and water quality; ' ~ Signature of Florida registered Professional Engineer on all plans and calculations COPY OF PERMIT INQUIRY LETTER OR SOUTHWEST FLORIDA•WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT (SWFWMD) PERMIT SUBMITTAL (SWFWMD approval is required prior to issuance of City Building Permit), if applicable VIO COPY OF STATE AND COUNTY STORMWATER SYSTEM TIE-IN PERMIT APPLICATIONS; if applicable H. LANDSCAPING PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 4-1102.A) ~~~~;~~~~~~;~~~ ^ LAN~7SCAPE PLAN: L'~ ~,~' / All existing and proposed structures; HrR Q s 2~~J i Names of abutting streets; ~ Drainage and retention areas including swales, side slopes and bottom elevations; [~' p` Delineation and dimensions of all required perimeter landscape buffers; P~ n~~ItV~7 ~EI~AR~~"jU.~E1tlT -! Sight visibility triangles; 1.n Ilt~ .r Delineation and dimensions of all parking areas including landscaping islands and curbing; CIIY QF CLE~R~IIATEER ~ Proposed and required parking spaces; ~ Existing trees on-site and immediately adjacent to the site, by species, size and locations, including dripline; ? Location, size, description, specifications and quantities of alt existing and proposed landscape materials, including botanical and common names; ,/ Typical planting details for trees, palms, shrubs and ground cover plants including instructions, .soli mixes, backfilling, mulching and protective measures; ~ Interior landscaping areas hatched and/or shaded and labeled and Interior landscape coverage, expressing in both square feet and ~ percentage covered; Conditions of a previous development approval (e.g. conditions imposed by the Community Development Board); / Irrigation notes. O • REDUCED LANDSCAPE PLAN to scale (8 %z X 11) (color rendering if possible); l~ IRRIGATION PLAN (required for level two and three approval); ^ COMPREHENSIVE LANDSCAPE PROGRAM application, as applicable. BUILDING ELEVATION PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 4-202.A.23) Required in the event the application includes a development where design standards are in issue (e.g. Tourist and Downtown Districts) or as part of a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project or a Residential Infill Project. lY BUILDING ELEVATION DRAWINGS -all sides of all buildings including height dimensions, colors and materials; C,Y' REDUCED BUILDING ELEVATIONS -four sides of building with colors and materials to scale (8 YZ X 11) (black and white and color rendering, if possible) as required. J. N~~ S1G~NAGE: (Division 19. SIGNS /Section 3-1806) ^ All EXISTING freestanding and attached signs; Provide photographs and dimensions (area, height, etc.), indicate whether they will be removed or to remain. ^ All PROPOSED freestanding and attached signs; Provide details including Location, size, height, colors, materials and drawing ^ Comprehensive Sign Program application, as applicable (separate application and fee required). ^ Reduced signage proposal (8'/s X 11) (color), if submitting Comprehensive Sign Program application. Ponn r. of 7 - Flavihlc rlcudnnmanf Raci`icnti~l In£il An~lir~fiinn - (:ihi of laaanualnr ORIGINAL • • K. TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY: (Section 4-801.C) 0 T~5 ~ /' / ~N~ Le O ~~s S~a3' ^ Include as required if proposed development will degrade the acceptable level of service for any roadway as adopted in the Comprehensive Plan. Trip generation shall be based on the most recent edition of the Institute ofTra.nsportation Engineer's Trip General Manual. Refer to Section 4-801 C of the Community Development Code for exceptions to this requirement. L. SIC-NAT! IFtE: - I, the undersigned, acknowledge that all representations made in this application are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge and authoriz Ci representattves to~ visit and photograph the property descriE~i ip~is application. Signature of property owner or representative STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINELLAS `"~vom to and subscribed before me this ~_ day ~ of i A.D. 20~'s to me and/or by ~i .%~ who is personally known has 'I produce as identification. 'I No ry public, My commission expir __ - ~ ~,, _ _ .., , , ', _ eenn Ge~[~C~~~~~~~ APR 0 6 2005 PLAfVfVIPIG DEPRRT1~1EfVT CIiYOF CLERRWAl'ER o....., a ..c ~ n~~ai~ n..,,..~.,.,..,....~ o„~:.:.,..+r.,~ i..ru n.,.,r...,a:~.. tea., of f loonu~lcr ---~• •.IAN ~~ ~fif1~ ~1 ~ ~ ~tiP~~-~--.,,,~ ~IIN I1FVF1(1PMFNT tvurcina~LC c~~ ~~ N(1 ~Fh rF ^ n.sin.s _ - Best copy Av~ilabl~ CITY OF CLF.~twATFR ~ R I G i N~ L ~~~~'~ ~'~'Ili7-A,~',~~ T'0 ,~iU'I'HO~ZE AGENT rLt-~,viv~tWV ~r ~~v~Y,i~i~11~~i'T SER~CES AD~VIIriISTRAT~ON Mq'1VTCIPAL SERVICES BUIL~DllVG, IOp~SOUTH-MYI2TLE AVENUE, Zb FLOOR PHONE (727)-562-4567 FAX (727) 562-457fi /~ t AtSe~R,Da.tik(~t,- ~>f e:pxz,.~n~r~~! .~A P~ r.,~, ~ (tJamrr of all p-opariy t4glpra) 1, That (! am/lwe are) the Owner(s) anc! record Fide holti~rf~1 of thc, fnun.ennn ~o~..~>.e~ rw,r r.wi_ i~.... ~vr~~~r~~~v ~u~ ~ ~IAI~Ut~i ~'~7t'- A C,7 R~~tg//rrYON fir: 'AddrCSS Dr Ganeiel Lae~tfanl ~. `~ rya his prapan~f ~O~~trfu~es the propeq#y for wh(ch a request far a: iI ~ t 3. That the endersigned (haslhavral annnint~~ ?~~ ~~t~ect.+.,~ h«,.,..~..F i'~o4Z'~-I~~t: b~ ,~~~I~.,, tr~1{G~...~ 8S (AlEllk,el~ ggg~t(g) to t2Y0oute em! Ablttlan$ q~ Mhc,r ~Inr•~ ~mnr.p ~ne~3^. _ _ _.., Q. That thlS affidavit has bee118Xacutad to indtace thr~ 1~ifii of r-ln~n~.o~~.a Cy jvi,~~ ~w, ~~~~iu~ . ~r_l~ ~~p an the above described property; -,~ ~~-. 5. That (I/we), the undersigned authority, hereby cerfify that the toreaofno is true ~inct cnr~P~~, ~ // ./~ ~ ~.r- ~y "~~i~ .. _T~~ ...:._: STATE ~~ ~'LflRiDA, GoUNTV nF w~tFi,i.ee ,„.Before m® the vnearst ned, an offeerduty CommisslOnQd ' ~~ y e lave of tho State of Ficrlda, on thle .~~ ~ pvrsoneUy appeared ~,~ -~ day or eposes ~ d $ays that he/she flatly undPrct~n~te~~,..,,,~....M .~.~._ .:m, `.:,. ,~.- . who having been fret duly swum •. •. ... v. c_.L '...!'Y„'_6:_ i..lu! JY~~:i i2 n.l:~C::;it1. apt'' CheriAEkturs Myco~tmission a ~,. MYCpMMISS~orl~ DROd5E73 EXPIRES ", ]uiy 29, 2005 '-.'iji 1R~' i:.r^.~,NS::...,:¢ci:y;ia i?I~~~F:=rrti'K t\i. g HPplleftllan fotmeidevelapment -evie,v/AEAdavieto AuthorQe Agem C°~~~'~9~~~ APP 0 5 2005 PlANNIt~G 6~PRRT~IE(~T CIN OF CLE~RWAT~R • • oRiciNa~ Revised Ezhibit "A" to Flezible Development Application (Residential Infill Project) Ambiance on White Sands NES Project #0501 Description of Request(s): To demolish an existing 15-unit, overnight accommodation building, 8-duplex/triplex residential structures to construct a six (6) story (five levels above parking), 15 unit condominium project. This request to construct 15 attached dwelling units through the utilization of the City's provision for Termination of Status of Nonconformity (Section 6- 109 of the Community Development Code)* and utilization of the City's provision for Transfer of Development Rights (Section 4-1401 of the Community Development Code). This also includes requests to reductions to the required front setbacks from 25' (MHDR- Avalon) to zero feet to the trash staging area and 10' to building, from 15' (Tourist - Kendall) to 10' to building, reductions to the required side setbacks from 10' to variations of 7 feet on the north-west side and 3 feet on the south-west to building, reduction to the required rear setback (MHDR) from 15' to 10'. Additionally the applicant is requesting a deviation to the maximum allowable height from 50' to 52'8" to the top of the roof deck and an additional 3' to top of decorative parapet edge. CALCULATION: 15 transient units x .75 =11 residential units ! 08 residential units x 1 = 08 residential units ~~~~~ Total Residential units =19 / 15 to be constructed DPR (!Fi 20Q5 No signage is proposed at this time. PlANNlNC D~PRRT~IENT CITY QF Cz~~R~/f~T~R Written Submittal Requirements: 1. The proposed development will be in harmony with the surrounding area and other existing and proposed residential uses. The subject site is located within the Old Florida District of Beach By Design which anticipates low to mid-rise development. Although the proposed project exceeds the maximum height limitation, not that long ago a project by the name of Larissa was proposed at 69.5' to the highest roof deck, (the proposed project is 16'7" under this height}. The proposed increase in height for the parapets will help to conceal roof top air conditioning equipment and will lend in creating a balanced appearance for the proposed Mediterranean design. Other projects similaz to the proposed height and setbacks were approved in the same vicinity under the names of Chalets on White Sands and Chateaus on White Sands. 2. The proposed development will only entice appropriate development of surrounding properties and will serve as an incentive for either re- development of other neazby sites or upgrades to current uses and will not adversely impact the surrounding property values. ~ ~ ORIGINAL 3. As the proposal is for a residential use, the health and safety of persons in the neighborhood will not be adversely affected. Appropriate visibility triangles will be observed and maintained and all required parking will be provided on site in lieu of within the right-of--way. On=site retention will be provided on site where none exists now. 4. Proper traffic flow was designed to and from this proposed project. This was designed as to not interfere with the abutting City parking lot traffic. 5. The proposal is consistent with the community character of the Old Florida District as great effort has gone into the attractive Mediterranean design so that Beach By Design concepts are enjoyed. 6. No adverse effects to adjacent properties are anticipated as this is a residential use. No commercial uses are being proposed for this site so noise, olfactory and hours of operation impacts are not an issue. Residential Infill Project Criteria 1. The subject site is desirable for redevelopment due to its close proximity to the beach and beach related amenities. However, adjacent properties are not available for purchase therefore leaving a very irregularly shaped parcel on which to develop a high quality residential project. In order to make the project financially viable, the request for the 15 units, at the size being proposed is necessary. The need to provide on-site parking (23 spaces are required and 24 are being proposed) is driving the requested reductions to setbacks and increase in height. The proposed height will also allow the scale of the building to be in concert with the desired Mediterranean design and allows for all required parking to be provided on site. 2. Per the Pinellas County Property Appraiser the existing just market value of subject site is $2,010,200.00. With the proposed improvements to the site, the estimated value upon completion would be $25,000,000.00. This type of potential increase to the subject site's property value can only work towards increasing the value of surrounding properties. ' 3. Attached dwellings aze permitted uses within both the Tourist and MHDR zoning district and within the City of Clearwater. 4. The proposed residential use is compatible with other surrounding and adjacent Land uses. 5. The proposed improvements to the site inclusive of ahigh-quality residential project with on-site retention, parking and landscaping will be significant for not only the site but the surrounding area'as well. The applicant is also proposing to construct covered parking azeas on the adjacent City owned parking lot and is proposing to install and maintain landscaping on another City owned parking lot across the Avalon right-of--way. These improvements will be a much needed breath of fresh air for the surrounding beach community.. 6. The design of the project will bring parking onto the site in lieu of within the ' right-of--way, will provide on-site retention where none exists at this time and will provide areas of tropical landscaping where little to none exists: ~~~~~~~ ~ APR n s 2005 PlANNI~G d~PP,RTi~~NT ,~ _I7V t1F +C`~_~~~?1i11~T:~t~ • ~ ORIGINAL 7. Flexibility in regard to required setbacks and increased height are justified by the benefits provided to the surrounding community. The immediate neighborhood and users of the City owned public parking lots and beach azeas .will enjoy the redevelopment of the site from a predominantly overnight accommodation use into an attractive owner occupied high-end residential project with secured on-site parking via infrared lasers versus fences, gates and walls. ~~ ~~~ ,--~ ~~ APR ~ 6 2005 C ~Nl~tr 1;~~,~~~~ENT' QF ~=~~RW~F~R .~ _, C ~ - >~. } r- - ' -•, U Planning and Development Services 100 South Myrtle Avenue, Clearwater, Florida 33756 Telephone: 7'27-562-4567 Fax: 727-562-4576 ^ SUBINtT ORIGINAL SIGNED 9NII NQTartc~II APPLICATION. ^ SUHMIT 1 COPY OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION including folded site plan C1~45E #: DATE RECEIVED: RECEIVED BY (staff initials): ATLAS PAGE #: ZONING DISTRICT: LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: ZONING $ LAND USE CLASSIFICATION OF ADJACENT PROPERTIES: NORTH' 1 SOUTH• / WEST:. t EAST: / ORIGINAL COMPREHENSIVE LANDSCAPE PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS {sedisea 9n9nno~> D, ~ APPLICANT, PROPERTY OWNER AND AGENT INFORMATION: (Code Section4-40D9) APPLICANT L L~ MAILING ADDRESS/~~-:J ~~~~~/f L T ~~ .L f `~'~~~ PFiONB NUMBER: l~ ~ - ~+' ~P I - 7 ~7~ ~o FAX NUMBER: ~~~L~1 • ~I ~~~/ PROP>rRTY OWNER(S): AGENT NAME: {ContaeL Person) CtiCy ~~,C.J/~f`S ~~~~ MAILING ADDRESS• ~ ~ ~~ PHONE NUMBER:~~ ~ ~~ Z~ ~ ~ FAX NUMBER: ~ `/ 'Y'Y~D - ~~ The landscaping requirements of~Articie 3 Division 12 may be waived or modifed as a part of a Level One or Level Two Approval, as the case may be, if the application for development approval includes a Comprehensive Landscape Program, which satisfies the following criteria. The use of landscape plans; sectionsfelevations, renderings and perspectives may be necessary as sclppiementary information in addition to the information provided on this +~raricsheet: T. ~ Architectural Theme. a. The landscaping in a Comprehensive Landscape Program shall be designed as a part of the architectural tYfeme of the. principal buildings proposed or developed on the parcel proposed for the development. ~~ 'P'1~.~11~111'r!'~fia ~I~~tzitllVll:l~l OR b. The design, character, location and/or materials of the landscape treatment proposed~in the Comprehensfve Landscape Program shall be demonstrably more attractive than landscaping otherwsse permitted on the parcel proposed for developmenf under the minimum landscape standards. . oRi.~i~aL.~ ~. 2. Lighting. Any lighting proposed as a .part of a Comprehensive Landscape Program is automatically controlled so that the lighting is fumed off when the business is closed. ~, 3. Community Character. The landscape treatment proposed In the Comprehensive Landscape Program will enhance the community character of the City of Clearwater. ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ .~ , ~.~ ~~~ .,~. pp~ 0 6 2005 PLANN~[~~ iS~F,ARTri 1~NT CITY OF C~F1'~R',NATFR • • • q, Property Values. The landscape treatment proposed in the Comprehensive Landscape Program will have a beneficial impact on the value of the property in the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for developmen#. ;,~~~ ORIGINAL S. Special Area ar Scenic Corridor Plan. The landscape treatment proposed in the Comprehensive Landscape Program is consistent with any special area or scenic corridor plan which the City of Clearwater has prepared and adopted for the area in which the parcel proposed for development is located. Cl~~~~~~~~--=~~i~~l,~~'~f~~ ~P~ ~ ~ 20Q5 ~LAflINI(~O ~EP~~'~,1EIVT . ~ l CITY OF C~.EI~tRIi!/~,TER Please return checklist for review and verification. 6. That (llwe), the undersigned authority, hereby certify that the foregoing is Owner Property Owner STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINEI.La3 Before me tha undersigned, an officer duty commissioned by the/l~aws of\th,,e State of Florida, ~ ~ day of ~ on this .ltcSA~ (~ ~~~~ ,_ personally appeared ~ _ _ _ - who having been first duty sworn ~ ep es a d says that he/she fully understands the contents of the affidavit that h he signed. - y ,I , , . My Commission Expires: ~(~ ~ [~f-d(-t Not Public ~Y ~~rr~ DOREEN A. WILLlAM~ y @ MY COMMISSION # DD 155802 ~~'pt; {~~~ EXPIRES: October 14, 2006 S: appiicatton forms/development review/comprehensive landscape program apptication.do Z.gppglgpTpgy ~ ~, ~,,,;~ $ ~, I,;~. ~~:. JAN, 23. 2015 ~12: 2~PNF,~..o~~ SUN DEVELOFNIEN I r,UrtIN5lllt ~n~ 5~ N0. 256 Fp, ~ 02/03 ORIGI NA [~ UTTER OF A[!TH[)RI~'dTlnlu - This letter will serire as authorizatipn for Hon~h Ghovaee uvith N~trtlr~ide En~eering 5erv-i~es, Ian. fc- acx as an agent for ~'~ A,~ ~N l~(.t!~ ~,. ~G.~ and to execute any and all dACUments related to secu~nn dArmite and approvals for the consetruCtiar~ on the property generally Located at ~ i~ ,L1-~nA1_n~l 2( 7~ ~~ ~-7 '~~+V~V 1~~ ~ iti'1 Avgt,ON ~t/~oa _., lying within -- . ~-~. County. State of ~LfJ~ d~ _ /j /~ /' r,.~'''~ ~) ..~'" 9 ` fem.... 1 r.. SiBna ~ of property Sumer Print Name of Prdoer[v t]wner ~ l~.Qrc~4~ ~v ~F ~ ~ ~ ~q ~ ~ ~ Address [Yf Prnnprtv r)-r~r~rsr r.,r~,..w_~_ .~..__,. _ . , r.~;~;~,a~d~~ ~~~~v~r~r~;.e ~--. - .v__...._._ ._..._ _.._... ~ , . State of ~ ~++ The faregving rostrum ~ was acicnovy(edge before me this -~~,-~---„~_ day o~~~r~ty~r.~- i,~ ~:t~ll.~ cr~U9l~,G~~`t ~~~:;iu ~ -, ..~........ _ ~ c who is p2rsvnslly imowh to me or whn has produced --- .` ~' id~P'ig(~ic~47~iTi :and 1-Yi'ia did (did not! lake an n~~;1, i l ~ ,~ / ~~ r d 'A r/I Q~ ~ ~c;,..,...,,..... Nataty Public ;~~~~ `_''~i-'4s Cheri A pw~ , ...~,.....,... _; - _;r; ., MYCOMMISSIOx;~ DOW5673 Emission # r• ~ 3uy z9, zoos "' ~` 89NDED7HRUTlOrPUU~ua~r~unamr ~.nc; (s~~. AeovE ..y l ~ r° r 1 v `S (Nome of Notary Typed, printied or Scam Pte) a~R ~ s zoos P1AN(~I[!~Q 6~F~',~Tc~IENT CITY QF C~~r!;I~'~Ur':TiFR • • aRt~f~~~ Ezhibit to Comprehensive Landscape Program Application Ambiance on White Sands NES Project #0501 1. Architectural Theme a. The irregularity of the subject lot and necessary building size limit the amount of available area for Landscaping, however, the proposed landscaping will be grande in appearance and in harmony with the Mediterranean building design. Proposed plantings include but are not limited to Tabebuia (Gold trees), a wide variety of Palm Trees Xanadu. The combinations of proposed landscape materials will make a statement for this currently blase property and will be a significant improvement for the adjacent properties and surrounding area. Due to the varied setbacks being requested on the west side of the building, it is not possible to meet the required 10' of shrubs sa a large mix of Palm Trees and Xanadu have been arranged to make a large buffering appearance. b. The area being landscaped along the eastern side of the site will provide a welcome buffer for the adjacent properties, while the lack of area for landscaping on the west will not be an adverse impact to the adjacent open public parking lot. The proposed building design alone will .be a welcome aesthetic improvement for users of the public lot. We have also vaulted the retention as to open up the site for additional landscaping on this site. 2. Lighting No landscape lighting is proposed at this time. Lighting will consist of fixtures attached to the proposed building and will not spill onto adjacent sites. 3. Community Character The proposed landscaping will be a significant improvement for the site and surrounding area. Currently, the site has maybe a couple of dying plans. Almost 100% of this site is currently asphalt or concrete. 4. Property Values The proposed landscaping will be a significant improvement to the subject site and surrounding property values when in concert with the proposed high-end residential condominium building. Currently the Property Appraiser lists the just market value of the subject sites at $2,010,200.00. Upon completion of all improvements including the new condominium building, on-site retention and landscaping, it is estimated the value of the site will be $25,000,000.00. APR, 0.6 20D5 Pl.AIVIl~Src~ ©~P~~~T1~~9Ei~T CITY OE C~E~,R~~3ER • • 5. Special Area o R I G I~~ I,_, The subject site lies within the "Old Florida District" of Beach by Design. Beach by Design contemplates landscaping that will set Clearwater Beach apart from other municipalities. Not only are the proposed landscape materials drought and salt tolerant but they will also enhance the proposed high-end condominium project creating a tropical and grande Mediterranean appearance for this site and surrounding area. -~ --, ~, ~ p~~ ~ 6 2005 . PLAN~~~~O G~E~~3iv1EMT CITY O~ C~E~°.I`'~3r~LR ~ AVALON STREET ~~~~~~~ N~ NEW 5' fOkfO' I1U91 ,_...._ ENTERT NEW N.G RAAfP NEW ZOxZO' crows w,iur sr~aNC ,vrEw sar ~gT. 9/AfX Jg4 ~~ mlavctE ~~ i~ C~' PA~t~i7T ~ _ _ ._____, ~~ ~~' 8 80t70`QO' E 10400' _ ~ _ ac~r-~--~xr 1p ~ LOGi f2 c 12'. ' c 1~ ~ i 10' _~ ._ - i~YA01tl3W3 ~ - - - - -r - - -- ._ _.. ~....~. _, .._ .~ Sztiitt}ng Lina par pirst'~ . 6, ~jp~18-) ° - ® --I _ BuNd;r;g Llna per jeaafcd (tarn p1aQ} T ~~ ~ossv ~ $ ~` ~~ ~ ~ fscat^~i 9rctt~ ialat ~+ 2-S"I L9~Y ~ ~ 16 15 14 13 m p UNDERGROUND 2 ~~ ~ ~ta~~ 19 sov y 9 IRfATiVENT VAULT O ° #~~ N ~ f9' S6~' 19.3 ° ~ ~~ W$ ASPHALT 1 1~ ~ T 25' t9Z6 11 t '~ 5 I ~ C.~ £,p~ r ~ ' ~- ~ ~ ~- N r- 7 .A90MF:Yi I w 1r , ; ~'.. CV ~ ~..~ 1 ~1 I . 7tW~1F~ ~~ 6LCkG. 7 ~~ ~'1 ~ ~ 1 s• ND EXIT ~ ~.~ i fI b srlav ~~ ~~ ~1. a~~--mac.-~~~~~~ .... ~ /_ !L _.~ ~ fir' 1 In/d7A4 a~s at ~wsev R ASPHALT 22 i + W 1 9 • a 23 / 3 ~ 1J' 18.B' ~ pp °u 1 24 ~• ~ e' ~ ~ z, t1uCSrling Linei pa;^ plat•'l^. ~ .~ ~ ~ - _- ~ ~ ~.._ ~Sui4~1,n~ LGra psr pSo~ (x:nted trn¢n pEai} __, i i ~. (ecc~fsd fram piat) ~~x ~^~ wAllf g SfpV '~ KENDALL STREET kSPHAIT 1C{~CiT-tN'-MR7 t"Y.. ~77~+~. ruar.~ ~.2 UN. ±.:? •i ~q O~/ "`~I N~ vi ~~ ~~ • • • ORIGINAL AVALON STREET „~„,~T ~q' 89DGID171D'E ~ D ~ ~ - ' ~ I ~ NEW 20'x20' --- I e e e e I 7R/ANGLf I ~, UNDERGROUND I ~ ~ ~. F I I TREATMENT VAULT 56'x22' v ~ S ASPHALT 3 I I W~ ~, I I ~ I I I IB I ~~°` W ~° I ,N - . ~~ m s' G1FO 'W s nF I BLDG. ASPHALT 3 U s ar W O O ~~,, x - mff OF PAVEidT KENDALL STREET ASPHALT IOfi1T-0F-wA7 6' IXF an rAsoNer wALL APR 0 6 2005 PLp-Nt~~~' ~ ~~~",~T-v~ENT GI~Y ~~ ~#.~r~^~ :'~~i~'R APR 0 6 2005 PLANNING ©EP~RT~IENT CITY QF CLEAI~WATER nN WI-IITE S~N~~.~ n a c• x i i r. c• 'r • ORIGINq~ ON WH[TE SANDS EXTERIOR BUILDING COLORS C~L~R # ~ C~L~R # ~ C~~..OR # ~ BUILDING COLOR NAVAHO WHITE BM947 BUILDING BAND COLOR BUILDING TRIM COLOR GLIDDEN KITTEN WHITE 30YY78/035 RAILINGS/FASCIA/ ORNAMENT/ WINDOW TRIM GLIDDEN KITTEN WHITE 30YY78/035 ~~~~~~~~ APR 0 6 2005 PLANNING ~~PA,12T~~IENT CITY QF CLERR~-~I.~TFR ROOF TILE MCS CLAY TILE # 8204 152'-10" i rem a s 3'-3 12'-0" 108'-1 12" 9 4 -- ---I-- N - ' ----- --- -- ----- ' h m ~ ; ~ - T-1" X ~ N ~ v ~ 25'-312" 18' 0" iO m 2~-0" e~~~ ~~ W 5 i o F :69$~~1 1 ~;~;s:~ 1 ~ a;~ s eol.~l~ 4 ~ ~ 24, `^ ~ i'~~46 lli ;i ' 15-0" ! s li Ee a i~ fl;yl~ - - 1o•-i" SETBACK jEyii~~ ~ I11/ i~l y `S u 148 ~ A ~ _- ~ _ ~E - T-0 a NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES: 0 a 24 PARKING SPACES INCLUDING 1 HANDICAPPED PARKING SAPCE ~ ~ oow z '~ 3 5 Q ~ U ~ N W E 2 e3 S 13'-0" 1 B " ~ ~ ~~ '3 1 1" u tl V 7~ g a Ap~2 ~ ~ 2~a~ A ' l PLANNING G~Pl~RTf~1ENT ~~--~--- ----- CITY OF CLE~l~WATFR ~. SITE PLAN \ c SCALE: 1/8"=1'-0" § _ 13'A 7/8" 9'-11 7l8" 3=1 1 ` 1 5'-,~' 1 ~J V I 7 18105 b ~ ~ ~ _ _, ~ __ m -- oz - -. ny HD °o-. I A°c~ to oz °o~ ~ ~ i ..I $~o o~ ~~ x o ~~ ~ p 17C9 ~ o ° ~ RBipfI°~ i[alj Cpl 3 m )6p;$~t i. i m i a i ` $ mo ;?I~BfN O< $ ~ ~ ; > ia9ii~E FOYER ~i ,I - :"!L..~ ~ r,°i~o,a ;iiii ~~ __" ~ 1 p II~+~m i~f= O m m - O11II4~ ~- I ..p ~ll~~~ 79~f ~~~ ,~ ~ Z 8~mU ~~ 3.qj" -~, s s UNIT AREAS: il,~~~ ~> UNIT A (NORTHERN UNIT): 3800S.F. o a UNIT B (MIDDLE UNIT): 3640 S.F. o UNIT C (WESTERN UNIT): 2730 S.F. Z m ;~ m°z k' "~3 m t ~~~ `~S .. "~Il~~i N < o p3 W E $ i :;~ m S v ri ~_~~.~ ag .. .Ills: 4 w m~ c ,I BAIL - _ _ FIRST LIVING LEVEL A 2 • V / r~ 1 1 3IBI05 ~ ~ ~ ~ b LJi '.h ~~' $Z z - - ~ - m r _ m ~ - - o~ m m o c. ~ 1.__ ~~ = ~~ I. ~~ 3p _ I ~ ~~ '= p ~ 3 z I I I;: L __ u 0 n TO '-~"=~ m m ' m z z ;~ ~I~:~ pt k~:iu:a~j Illy' r.:l °m Om o o p i ~~i'~ii' i ~liy)y~~ A z p o+-; ~' Z z o 3 O In ~ n 3 5 Q ~i111FN ~j~r1lpp i{ Q FOYER I~~ _ p ~I~( i 71 6 iil~ BRIDGE --~ ~ a 0 i~~i~~~ L_i ~_ a l1~ils)~ f~J rl _ i 'i p0 8~ O p ~..' ~a T. ::~~'~=r;' p; UNIT AREAS: ~ ~,~ o ~~ >• UNIT A (NORTHERN UNIT): 3800S.F. o UNIT B (MIDDLE UNIT): 3640 S.F. o UNIT C (WESTERN UNIT): 2730 S.F. Z m ,_I °~k' w i r ~ 5 ~_ 8 r~ ~$~ Az ~ ~ W E S ~ _~ ~ - a~~ n 1u05 W ~ m ~ c :.I ~ ; ~ PlAIVNING ®EF' 4RT~r1ENT SECOND LIVING LEVEL ~ CITY OF CLE~RWATER ~rA 3 • O f 1 31&03 y 'i yy yy `f `f ~. y ~-{ lip, ~r ~ OZ ~~ _ - - m 3 Aw O ~ O1 Of o Il• o O ( ; ~~ ~ 3 1~ ~ DC O A _ ..~ _.__.Il ~iJ I O Z 3 L7 ~ i I:. 7< ~ _ _ o -.::J K A ~~ ~ :_. a p "7 - ' ~ p~ ~ I~ A ~4 _:' q A~f~ai ~( m Z p; m Ov ~> ~' ili QIi ~~ 1a19 ~ z $~ $~ 8D ) 1 of+~ii~ FOYER ,a_I - -~~~_, o ~ (~il0 ~,~ - 3 m ;~ „ili QA O TO - 3 ~ D ~::~ '-'"`.tee ~~(~ za UNIT AREAS: ~-~~ 7}E 0 UNIT A (NORTHERN UNIT): 3800S.F. o UNIT B (MIDDLE UNIT): 3640 S.F. o UNIT C (WESTERN UNIT): 2730 S.F. z N ~ .i w z a z '~ 3 ~ NQ { _.__tli~ 1 WW o: ~ ~ 6 111 8~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~~ N W E S #~ ' ~ .. r l § r..•~~ L'~ _. I u - y APR 0 6 1005 W ~ J ~ - - ' PLANNING [~EP~-,RT~IE NT ,.~__ _ ' CITY QF CLEARWAT~R THIRD LIVING LEVEL ~A 4 • _~ _ . O O 2 ~~ pC 8 ~ n = Z O m D i,_1Y_ °~ =r~ 1 A _ _ ~4~~-~ z 8 ~ O O FOYER ~~ ,'' ~. ,, a z pv_ z g o ~ ~ b `~ po m m~ _,__ o ~~~ v ~ NA uD o m $ yIII i a I m ~ O3 O 3D ~} ~~ i', z~ o m UNIT AREAS: j ~T4 S SD UNIT A (NORTHERN UNIT): 3800S.F. UNIT B (MIDDLE UNIT): 3640 S.F. UNIT C (WESTERN UNIT): 2730 S.F. m pr ~ ~~ ,;~ o ~~~~~~~ °~ i ~ ~ __ll~§ ~;,- ~~, ~~ ~ - ~~~ ~ h ~QQ~J Oy ~ ~ _ _' PLANNING DEP,~iRTir~ENT CITY OF CLEAR~IIATER 3D N W E s FOURTH 8 FIFTH LIVING LEVELS 1 YBNS i~~;~l ~~I,~ii ~I6`)'~ ~ytyl3py~~ 'l~if~~ i~~~id +~~~a~1 ~i;~~~~ ~'°91f ~~~~:li 'rj c,. 0 0 oow w z a m ~ Q ~ U ~I a y 7 718105 ? 8~ iin I ' ~, PHONE/ CbMP ^ ^ ^ ^ ~ E ~ ROOM ^D I I }D{ Cl .............:~ ~ 1..............._Z ^ C ~ H Zy 5g~ i~SFi.Ij~~~ ' WATER :'~ ~C= ^ iI1~I~~ ' ~ SOFfNEN j ~? O B i o A~ ~ _'-~EQUIPM T t Z y N 'i x D ROOM m ~ii,,~ ~ ~ ~ m p ^ i='3y~~ ^ ^ °_ ~ sl,ii,6 y 63~~Is ^ ^ ^ ^ i~f~~B9 13,.11 ! IIO~i :~~i:ai T.~ ELE TOR ~•• MACNI 0 K O Z Na' W Q Q N m~ O.N• ' H, sJ tl~ V ~~~ ~ F W E APR ~ 2~~5 S W PLANNIl~G ®EP~,RT~IEIVT s CITY OF C~.F~I211UATFR ROOF LEVEL z~ ~~A 6 • G~ I~ .. __.. ~ ~ p~ ~ pR Q 6 2005 g ~~ ~~ .. J 4 ~ .Q, m q b b ~ '~ ~ ~ 4 ~ ~ m 4 ~ m 0 ~ m ~,, a .. ' ~ [S Rg p C f tTfO Ca ___.____.. .__- __ 31BI0$ I I AT 3' SETBACK, 10% OPENINGS ALLOWED TOTAL AREA CALCULATED: 8834 S.F. 10% OF AREA CALCULATED: BB3 S.F. TOTAL OPENING S.F. ALLOWED: 883 S.F. ^ TOTAL OPENING S.F. DESIGNED; 802 S.F, < 10% AT 15' SETBACK, 20% OPENINGS ALLOWED 10%OF AREA CALCULATTED3778.24 S.F. i~i13~~1 TOTAL OPENING S.F. ALLOWED: 778.24 S.F. ~{~;~ii ~i6 !°i TOTAL OPENING S.F. DESIGNED: 775 S.F. < 20% 1!i''~ u i ; 1y1 6 (6 I i'~I` i ,~~` ,,:,,!6 ;~ g ............_ y~ ~b ~6~.,,i ............................ I ............. ...: -- 1/8„_~,_p,~ i11 i. i,~ ~. m ~ ^ ~m m O ~ m ~' m ~ QQ m 0 m ,~ ~m OPENING PERCENTAGES ~'•'~ AT 10' SETBACK (FROM KENDAL), 20% OPENINGS ALLOWED 0 TOTAL AREA CALCULATED: 2201.8 S.F. tt 10% OF AREA CALCULATED: 458.32 B. F. TOTAL OPENING S.F. ALLOWED: 456.32 S.F, O o Z w g 3 TOTAL OPENING S.F. DESIGNED: 225 S.F. < 20% Z v AT 10'-4 7/8" SETBACK 20% OPENINGS ALLOWED a W ¢ m C , Q ~ V TOTAL AREA CALCULATED: 5044 S.F. 10%OF AREA CALCULATED: 1008 S.F. TOTAL OPENING S.F. ALLOWED: 1008 S.F. j O \\OTAL OPENING S.F. DESIGNED: 815 S.F. <20% w m~ z ~ ®~ SOUTH ELEVATION ~~A 1/8„_~,_~„ Q CITY OF CI.FI~R~II~TFR APR 0 3 2009 AT 10'-1 3fB" SETBACK, 20% OPENINGS ALLOWED TOTAL AREA CALCULATED: 9288.5 S.F. 20% OF AREA CALCULATED: 1857.3 S.F. TOTAL OPENING S.F. ALLOWED: 1857.3 S.F. TOTAL OPENING S.F, DESIGNED: 1725 S.F. <20% :; O O O O "` !v a O ~_ ~ 4 ® ® ® ~' g O 6 y 4 ~3 ^ m m ~ 3 ~, 4 Q ® m d e ~~ ; ~ ~~ __ PLAt~lNIN~ dEP~ZT~iE(11~ ; J~4N5 CITY Q~ ~LEJ~t~w">'.~' ~° G ® ~ ~ {~iiI4B 1 ~ ~!!' { ~ , I ~ i ~ ............... .... ~ ~.,<~....,~, „.,, l" i 6 NORTH ELEVATION m O ~ ~ OPENING PERCENTAGES AT 12' SETBACK, 20%OPENINGS ALLOWED m ,.,.u. ^ ~ TOTAL AREA CALCULATED: 5248 S.F. 20% OF AREA CALCULATED: 1049 S.F. TOTAL OPENING S.F. ALLOWED: 1040 S.F, ~81!~i ,5- 0 0 LL O O W~ F Z W K s F_ m Q ~ V ~ m TOTAL OPENING S.F. DESIGNED: 505 S.F. <20% w O O 0 • O G~ z r T-424 File No. R-33G98 • KARLEEN F. DE pLl;XER, CLERK OF COURT PINEI.LAS COUNTY FLORIpA Parcel I,D. No : OS/28/15/16362/Q~7/Ot760 WSTii 2p044t30908 12rt•Ol2004 at 19:b~1 AM c s pFF REC BK; 1$994 pG: 1449.1449 B~S# Cj~yrhis Instrument Prepared By and Return to: DocType:DEEt7 RECORDING: 310.00 •+ D DpC STAMP: S499o.pp y~ h R. Carlton Ward, Esquire AV~~~~b~ld Richards, Gilkey, Fito, Slaughter, Pratosi $, Ward, P,A, 1253 Park Street o R~ G~ N A~ Clearwater, Florida 337y0 jSpace Above This Line for Recording Data] NIAR~iANT~ ®~~® This Indenture made this ~' day of ~~,~ 2004 BETWEEN MGSmith, Inc., aFlorid-a corporation, having its principal placo of buslnoss at 24x0 Roberta Lane, Clearwater, Florida 33754, party of the tirst part, and Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC., a Florida limited liability company, whose maninq address is ?_71 South Myrtle Ave, Clearwater, Florida 3375G, party of the second part- tv i T iV ~ a S E i H, That said party of the first part for and in consideration of the sum of TEN AND 00/~00'S ($t0-00) Dollars and other good and valuabb considerations to Said party of the first Hart in hnn._+ ..,r.r ,... ~, __ ~: -- ;:.- :_~ ~:.~ ;:~::, ar recclN, wacreor is i1Erc'by acknowledged, has granted, bargained and sold to the said party of the second part forevor, the following described land situate, lying and belnq Pinollgs County, Florida, to-wit: Lot G, Block 7, CLEARWA7ER BEACM REVISED, according to the map ar plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 11, page 5 of the Public Records of Pinellas County, Florida. Subject to easements, restrictions and reservations of record and taxes for the year 2005 and thereafter. and said party of the first part does hereby fully warrant the ti11e to said land,"and wll! defond the same against the lawfn! claims of all persons whamsoevcr. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said party of the first part has caused theso presents to bo signed In its name by its authorized corporate officer, and its corporate seal to ba affixed thereto, the day and year above written. ~:.. ...+ ~r.~ - ~ , -... ..~ --_. _,~,._~~« ' .:vr ;~resenoc as Wi'i;nesses: ~t D 1 ,; Pr' Witn s Name:` I1 /-) ~ /> /1 ~ 1 t Print WLee~~ Tl,n n.... ~~/_ ...~A . _... Nesmith, Inc. a Flor" cor^^oration { ~~ t ~~ ~. t~i`-~Vf'ilsort, President ---~ STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF P!NELLAS I HEREBY CERTIF`( that on this day the next above named State and County before me, an officer duly authorized and acting personally appeared D. Lance Wilson, President of McSmith, Inc., a Florida Corporation to me known and he Is the nnrcnn rlrncnrlhe.+ r,..,,,.....~„ ...__....., .. . - _,~..,_- ;:.'- I-r~yvr•:9 :nsir•:,~en;, and i;e ackr;owlr.dgad that he executed the same as such officer for the purposes therein expressed; that ho affixed thereto the offlciat seal of said corporation; and that the said instrument is the ac: and deed of said corporation. WITNESS my hand and offlclal seal in the County and State last aforesaid thisc~ day of~4-~'~^~{/, 2004, Name: .~ ~---- •-- r~otary r~bllc j ~--~ ~~.:fru rfasw~.~i. c. //~~ ::TS~t"rytsly Commission exnlrAC• '~~~~n ~~n _ =' '•.: ,rrontus G. Hcrse 9f V f~J '.JJJ _~'~:~ •'•b*' Seple;nber?2•~p006 EX?IP.Eg QOYFAINnp~UF~;~F N,i N1AR ~ Q 2005 PLAN!~[NG DEPARTti!lEt11~' ~i ;~ w , ~~n OF CLEARWATER -~ ~ ~, File No. R-33709 • ICARLEEN F. q~KER, Ct_t=RK of COURT PINEiLLAS COUNTY hLORIDJI !^:-T'i 200aa803a71ai&l;tyUq.afiU;S.AM Parcel I.D. No_: t75/29/1 5 /1 6 3 6 2 /Ot77/0050 OFF REC BK: 13994 PG: 1448.1448 } /'- pocType:DEEq RECORt}1NG, 510.00 St COY D DOC STAMP; $9800.00 B~ ThFS Instrument Prepared By and Return to: p~~ilabla R. Carlton Ward, Esquire Aiehards, Gilkey, Fite, Slaughter, Pratesi & Ward, P.A. t253 Park Street O rti I /~ ~ ~ /t [space Above This Line for f~ecnrdinrr nat?i - ~ ~ ~ R a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ This Indenture mado tn;s day at ~,_ , 21)pa eETwEI:Nr LaMar E3 each Cluo, LLC., a Colorado Limited Liability company, having its principal place of business at 200 Brightwater pr., Jt7, Clearwater, Florida 33767, party o1 the first part, and Panorama On C1earWateC Beach, LLC., a F10ride limited liability company, whose mailing adtlress Is 277 South Myrtle Ave, Clearwater, Florida 33756, party of the second part. ,•~ - ,- ~' " "' ~' rt, ~v;a >:at, party of the first part for and in considoration of the sum of TEN AND 001tOD'S ($10.00) Dollars and other good and valuable eonsidorations to said party of the first part .n hand paid by said party of the second part, the receipt wher0of iS hereby acknowledged, has grantod, bargained and sold to the said party of the second part forevor, the following described land situate, lying and tieing Pinellas County, Floriria, to•wit: The North 63 Y/2 feet of Lot 5, Block 7, R>vVISBD MAP OF,CLEARWATER BEACH, according to the map or plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 11, page 5 of the public Records of Pinaltac f^~„r,r=, t=t,.~t.,.. Subject to easements, restrictions and reservations of record and taxes for (~ ~i-~~ 1~ the year 2R05 and thereafter. 1,~~~~~~n Up V~~ MAR 10 1005 and said party of the first part does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and wilt defend rhA camp a., r.~~• "I, VG DEPgR /~E~d ^ ~.~...;~ ui alt Nersois whpm908v<r. _ c '~~~~ of CLEgRN/gTER Y IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said party of the first part has caused these prosents to b0 signed m its name by it^, I (,' authorized Corporate .officer, and its corporsto seal to bo affixed thereto, the day and year above wr;tten. Signed, seated and delivered in our pr ~_~ ~J ~~nt Witn -Nato - - -- - --- _ __~G~-~ .rte Print Witness Name:_ fi~rf,~~ j~ Sr~,ta~~ STATE OF CG, QRADO COUNTY OF ~~~~- ~sence as Witnesses: __ LaMar 13cacfi Club, LLC. J~, r~ `~~`. _. V raig Nassirf?"residen I Hf;REBY CERTIFY that on this day the next above named State and County before me, an offi:ar duly authorized and doting personalty appeared Craig Nassi, President Of LaMar Beach Club, LLC„ a Colorado Limited Liability Company to me known and h0 is the person tlescribetl in and who executed the loregoing ?^art~rr~2,~trand .:e aCn;;awic'u'=dud ;oat i:o execotod the same as such officer for the purposes therein expressed; that he affixed thereto the official seat of said corporation; and that the said instrument is th`e act and deed of .aid corporation. yJITNESS my hand and official seal In the County and State ( foresaid this `~~ 1~~.. ,~ ds~Y of - ~,.,.(_~. _. 200x. Name: ~ 1.0.E c t:.....,~ +~,iL.vL;:.: v~i~ ,LLC ~ Netsry Public _._.._ ~._...~.~s<;t~~~ NOTARY PUBIC }} Commission No. STATF OF Goi_ot~ann Z •_. ~. 4 r- rw-r...:<v ,.;, ... ,,..~,.,,;c;r~ axrrts: ~~~,SIUJ ll~j My (rDntn11551nn Fvniroc nRrZNOnnn File No. R-33710 • Parcel I.D. No.: 05/29/15/16362/007/0140 This Instrument Prepaietl ey and Return for R. Carlton Ward, Esquire r ci.e ds, G~.kcy, 'r'ite, Siaughtsr, i'rzta~i &'vJaro, P.A. 7253 Park Strec[ Clearwater, Florida 33766 ~Q~S•t ^/r,~~ Grantee S.S. NO.: ^ (1 ~i~i. Name: Panorama on Cla&rwator Beach, LLC. [v[ K A~~`~~~.~;~A'~ Grantee S.S. No.: Name: (Space Above Thfs Line for Recording pate] W A R R A M T Y ~~~ This Indenture made this ~ da of . v -~~c~~~1b' ~y~-, 2004 BETWEEN Allan J. Crooker, married, whose mailing address iS I6 Kendall Street, Clearwater, Florida 33767, GRANTOR', .tnd panorama CIn Clearwater Beach, LLC., a Florida limited liability company, as GRANTEE", who:;e malting address is 211 South Myrtle Ave, Clearwater, Florida 33756. KgRLEEN F- DE E3LAf(I%R, CLERIC OF COUF~T PINELLAS COUNTY FLORJDq LNSTW 2004d$pRR9 1~!? p12^7,", .~• 7n;.,,~~, qy7 'Fr' RcC BK: 1399d P(i; te50-1430 bocType:bEEb RECOK•t)ING: 570.00 D DOC STAMP; $75071,00 W I T N E S S E T H, Thai said Grantor, for and in consideration Of tho sum of TEN AND OO/t04'S ($10,00) Dollars and other good and valuable ctlnsiderationS to Bald Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee, tho receipt whereof Is hereby acknowlodgetl, has grantod, bargained and sold t0 the Grantee and Grantee's heirs anti assigns forever the fallowing described land situate,, lying and being Pinellas County, Florida, to-wit: The South 23.5 feet of Lot 5, and all of Lot 14, Block 7, REVISED MAP pF CLEAR WATER BEACH, aCCOrdind to the man nr .,la. +tio.a....... ~___..~,. ~ ,._ Fie: rsook 1°., page 5, NuBtic ReCOrds of Pinellas County, FlOrida.~ ~"`~~uVu ttt Subject to easements, restrictions and reservations of record and taxes far the year 2005 and thereafter- Th;s property is not now, nor has it ever been, during the peripd of Grantor(s) ownership, homestead property as defined by the constitution of the State of Florida. _,~- sulG dranior dens hereby ;oily wawarit the file to said land, and wilt tlefend the same against thc• lawful claims of all narennc .,,hnn+~....••n•, '"Grantor" and "Granteo" are used for singular or plural, as eOntext requires. IN WITNESS WWERF_OF, Grantor has horeunto set Grantors hand and seal this day and year firs) abovo written. Signed, sealed and da!Ivered in cur presence as witnesses' `~~~ ~ , Print Wit0ls5 ei %'~ i r r~ n -r... F'iinl~iness Name: G` --~=y7„v'' ,i~ 1 GINAL f.. i~3,i v. ..Y i:UriE:' MAR :~ 4 1005 STATE OF FLORIDA h' ~Q COUNTY OF PINELLAS PLANNING DEPARTMEi1~6 f HEFlEBY CERTIFY that on ibis day bsfore me, an oificor duty authoriz d to t <e a nowledpem nro Alhn ,1. Croc1•~%;'~ ~F CLEARWATER married. whn is p=sonalty ;;ne;.n to rna pr who has produced - uv/~j,~sl1•~~~'y1~,- he/she is the person descrbed in and who executed the Warranty Dead and he/she a0knowletlged the,t Iandtlthore peforra mo that ho/she executed the 5amo for the purpasos therein expressed. WITNESS my hand and official Seat in the County and State last 9tor~sale tnt/ ~ir ..~_., n. SC,-~iyv..,./_ - //~/ // +.'^' 1'ZUv4. r~ /J //~4 .Y _, Name: ~ ~~~~~ ~~ No hlic •~-~. R.C~tltcnYla;d t>~ rzFs slon expfit89]rtay16,2000 e`rT' ~ ss ' ~ . ~ IL~,.a1 01-21-05 14:53 From-RICHARDS KEY ATTYS • This document prepared by And after recording return to_ John B. Gibbons, Lsq. Saxon, Gilmore, Garraway, Gibbons, Lash & Wilcox, 1'.A. 201 l;sst Kennedy Boulevard Suite 600 Tampa, FL 33602 PARCEL LD. NOS. OS-29-IS-I63bZ~007-0070 OS-29-15-16362-007-0071 OS-29-15-16362-007-0080 OS-29-15-16362-007-0081 727-447-8830 ~V'A,1k~tANTY DEED • T-424 P.05/O7 F-196 ORIGINA'~ This Indenture, is made this _~ day of January, 2005, between Pasqu<~le Calderoni, as Trustee of the Pasquale Calderoni Revocable Trust, by trust instrtime.nt dated .Tune 7_5, 7001:, and Aida Calderoni, as Trustee of the Aida Calderoni Revocable Trust, by trust instrument dated June 2S, 2001, whose address is "45.1:6 W. North B Street, Tampa, Fiorxda 3:1609 (together, "Grantor"), and Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, whose address is 483 Mandalay Avenue, Suite. 209, Clearwater, Florida 33765, of the County of Pinellas, State of Florida ("Grantee"). WITNESSETH, that Grantar, for and in consideration pf the sum of Ten Dollars ($10.00), an,d other good and valuable consideration to Crrantor in hand paid ley Grantee, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bargained and sold t.a Grantee and Grantee's successors and assigns forever, the following described land, situate, Tying and being in the County of Pinellas, State of Florida, to wit: SEE EXHIIJIT "A" ATTACHED HERETQ Grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same against lawful claizx~s of alt persons whoimsdever. IN WITNESS WHEREQF, Grantor has hereunto set its hand aztd seat tree day and year rirst above written. Witnesses: Print Name: hen/ ~ ~ ~(/,~ Print Naive: ~~' ~' :~~~,~ Pt"~SQUAL$ CALDEIZONT, AS TRLiSTEE QF TIDE PASQIJALE CALDERONI REVOCABLE Tlt'~ST, BY TRUS T INSTR~'TvIENT 17A.TEJa JUNE 25, 2001 G~[~C~[~g~~~D MAR 10 2005 .- -, ; ~ ~ ~ ~ .~a t. ' ~ ,~ ~~ PLANNING DEPARTMENT CITY OF CLEARWATER O1-Z1-05 14:53 F rom-R I CHARDS ""-KEY ATTYS Print Name:. /~l~ ~/~ ~ Print Name: C ~~s~ ~~ ,~ ~.~.~ = 727-447-6830 T-424 P.O6/07 F-196 C7 AT17A CALDERONI, AS TRUSTETs OF THE AIDA CALDERONI REVOCABLE TRUST, BY TRY.TST INSTRUMENT DATED JUNE 25, 2001 c~,L-G.~i~C: ~ ORIGINAL STATE OF FLORIDA CQUNTY OT= I~ILLSBORQUGH 'l'he foregoing instrument vlras acknowledged before me this .5~ day oE' January, 2005, by Pasquale Calderoni, as Trustee of the Pasquale Calderoni Revocable Trust, by trust instrument dated June 25, 2001. He is personally known to ><ne ar has produced. _ __._ _ __ . _.___ as identification. r J zwr,N, E, ~nsn Notary Public, State of Florida I!!Iy C!3:=_-la~.:vSayn E~i~i 1~A.Ci. ~~~~o~~ STA'T'E OF FT nRTJ?A. M~~ i O ZODS 'C r1 ST7 F C~ /~ T .~ :.~r LEeL:sw~43~~T4 ~~ PLAN N I NG~DEPARTNiEf~' The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this _~~day dt~~'~,~2~~U5, by Aida Calderoni, as Trustee of the Aida Calderoni Revocable Trust, by trust irxstruznent dated ,Y~~riP 7.5;, ?.00?., Shy is r-ersonafly kuovvn~ to me qr h_ac prpdugecl as id~i1'C:~riaviG_c. ~_. AAy CpRY1fk~~{p(~ C1D2b2b7Z er ~ F~Ins Febnrary 04, 2000 c:~caldcrvn i\c lo~docs\deedtin~il.doc: ~, r,M...w-,,.., ~.....M.- . .. _„ z. ~~+k6s FelxW-ry OR; ?IY1~r pXiTlt NF~I7? ~; 1..rC/~ Notary Public, State of Florida Print Name; My Commission Expires: `~~~ e -- ~ ,~, 1 { .tea 0~1-?1-05 14:53 From-RICHARDS ' `KEY ATTYS 727-447-8830 T-424 P.07/07 F-196 Best copy Available EXHIPIT "A" a . _ . _ __, .. ...-..,~~nrr~ ,~ ~ o n~ rT Fe R wa.~.R t3EACH. according to Che map or plat tt~eis4f recorded iii Flat Lbt5 ! aAG i$, i~~v~K , aw.L ro ~~r-:,e> r= _ ~. 9 Book 11, page 5, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida. ORIGINAL ~~~~~~~~ MAR 10 2005 PC~II`l pPF CLEARWA~R Nor~hs~le ~i«g s ~~. • ORIGINAL STORMWATER REPORT CIVIL • LAND PLANNING • ENVIRONMENTAL • TRANSPORTATION • ~~~~~~~ FOR dam'!? ,"1 ~ ~~~ Pi~ANNII~~ t`~~I' ~li~'~~ ~_~ ~~~~~~~~ AMBIANCE ON WHITE S'ANDS' PRO~IECT ~ ~~._. Ram A. Goel, P.E. #47431 Apri12005 Project No. 0501 601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33755 NESADMIN@MINDSPRING.COM NESTECH®MINDSPRING.COM 727 • 443 • 2869 FAX 727 • 446 • 8036 ~~ ~ f • NORTHSIDE ENGINEERING SERVICES 25 YEAR STORM EVENT PROJECT: AMBIANCE ON WHITE SANDS PROJECT NO. 501 ORIGINAL • RUN-OFF COEFFICIENTS PRE-CONSTRUCTION TOTAL DRAINAGE AREA= 21,730 SF 0.50 AC IMP. AREA= 15,996 SF OF IMP. AREA @ C = POND AREA= 0 SF OF POND AREA @ C = PERV. AREA= 5,734 SF OF PERV. AREA @ C = C = 0.38 ~` C = 0.9/2 = 0.45 PER CITY OF CLEARWATER REQUIREMENTS POST-CONSTRUCTION TOTAL DRAINAGE AREA= 21,730 SF 0.50 AC IMP. AREA= 15,967 SF OF IMP. AREA @ C = POND AREA= 0 SF OF POND AREA @ C = PERV. AREA= 5,763 SF OF PERV. AREA @ C = C = 0.71 STORAGE CALCULATION PRE-CONSTRUCTION DRAINAGE AREA = 0.50 AC TIME OF CONC. Tc = 60 MIN I @ Tc =60 (25 YEAR EVENT= 3.60 IN/HR O(out) = C x I x A= 0.69 CFS POST-CONSTRUCTION TIME MIN. I IN/HR Olin) CFS INFLOW CF OUTFLOW CF STORAGE CF 60.00 3.60 1.28 4,618 2,483 2,136 MAX. STORAGE = 2,136 CF WEIR DESIGN TOP. OF WEIR ELEV.= BOT. OF WEIR ELEV.= H= 0= TOTAL VOLUME REQUIRED = MAX. STORAGE REQUIRED = TOTAL VOLUME PROVIDED = MAX. STORAGE PROVIDED = 4.92 3.33 1.59 FT. or 1' - 7" 1.28 0.22 FT. or 3" 2,136 CF 2,735 CF 0.45 1 0.2 0.9 1 0.2 APR 0 6 20Q5 PLANN~l~G 6~P~lRTt~ENT CITY OF C~ER~iNATER ;, • ORIGINAL t PROJECT NAME : AMBIANCE ON WHITE SANDS PROJECT NO.: 501 POND'S STAGE STORAGE DATA T.O.B. EL.= D.H.W. EL.= W.Q. EL.= BOTTOM EL.= STAGE ft-NGVD AREA SF AREA AC STORAGE CF 5.33 1,130 0.026 3,198 4.92 1,130 0.026 2, 735 4.00 1,130 0.026 -1,695 3.33 1,130 0.026 938 3.00 1,130 0.026 565 2.50 1,130 0.026 0 TOTAL WATER QUALITY CALCULATIONS: DRAINAGE AREA = REQUIRED WATER QUALITY DEPTH = REQUIRED WATER QUALITY VOLUME _ PROPOSED OUTFACE ELEVATION = AVAILABLE WATER QUALITY = 21,730 SF 0.50 IN 905 CF 3.33 FT ,_.., ~ ,~ 938 CF Qp~ n. ~ ~c1c1~ PLANNIRlO dEPRR~~IENT CITY OF Cl.E~RiNAT~R ~ ORIGINAL ~ MODRET SUMMARY OF UNSATURATED & SATURATED INPUT PARAMETERS PR07ECT NAME : 0501 Ambiance on White Sands -Pollution POLLUTION VOLUME RUNOFF DATA USED UNSATURATED ANALYSIS INCLUDED Pond Bottom Area Pond Volume between Bottom & DHWL Pond Length to Width Ratio (L/W) Elevation of Effective Aquifer Base Elevation of Seasonal High Groundwater Table Elevation of Starting Water Level Elevation of Pond Bottom Design High Water Level Elevation Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Unsaturated Analysis Unsaturated Vertical Hydraulic Conductivity Factor of Safety Saturated Horizontal Hydraulic Conductivity Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Soil for Saturated Analysis Avg. Effective Storage Coefficient of Pond/Exfiltration Trench Hydraulic Control Features: Top Bottom Left Right Groundwater Control Features - Y/N Distance to Edge of Pond Elevation of Water Level N N 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 N 0.00 0.00 N 0.00 0.00 Impervious Barrier - Y/N Elevation of Barrier Bottom N N 0.00 0.00 N 0.00 N 0.00 APR 0 6 2005 1,130.00 ft2 2,735.00 ft3 2.60 0.00 ft 1.60 ft 2.50 ft 2.50 ft 4.92 ft 0.30 13.33 ft/d 2.00 30.00 ft/d 0.30 1.00 PtANN~~lC D~P~RTi~ENT ~ ORIGINAL ~ MODRET TIME -RUNOFF INPUT DATA ~ PRO]ECT NAME: 0501 AMBIANCE ON WHITE SANDS -POLLUTION ~ STRESS PERIOD NUMBER INCREMENT OF TIME (hrs) VOLUME OF RUNOFF (ft3) Unsat 0.97 305.10 1 1.00 599.90 2 24.75 0.00 3 24.75 0.00 4 24.75 0.00 5 24.75 0.00 6 24.75 0.00 7 24.75 0.00 8 24.75 0.00 9 24.75 0.00 r. PU4NNI~lG d~~p,RT~~IENT CITY QF CLE~~W,'~r~~ ~ ORIGINAL ~ MODRET SUMMARY OF RESULTS PRO]ECT NAME : 0501 Ambiance on White Sands -Pollution CUMULATIVE TIME (hrs) WATER ELEVATION (feet) INSTANTANEOUS INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) AVERAGE INFILTRATION RATE (cfs) CUMULATIVE OVERFLOW (ft3) 00.00 - 0.00 1.600 0.000 0.00000 0.00 1.600 0.06308 0.05917 1.97 2.929 0.05526 0.00 0.00618 23.78 2.500 0.00432 0.00 0.00246 51.48 2.248 0.00194 0.00 0.00141 76.23 2.137 0.00119 0.00 0.00096 100.99 2.061 0.00084 0.00 0.00071 125.74 2.005 0.00063 0.00 0.00055 150.49 1.962 0.00050 0.00 0.00044 175.25 1.927 0.00040 0.00 0.00036 200.00 1.898 0.00 -~ ~~r n-. r ~.i'' ~ C74~ 4~ ti t ~ ¢ ' T f - ~ e `` e` '' g kI~L~`~ y ~ J 'JL~J t!~.x~F~ ~~ Y YY~' YY rY VYY r~~ ~; i~ Y.M1'aY~ Y~`YY Yr YYnY V.k ~ ~ ~etn~~,~n~A Maximum Water Elevation: 2.929 feet @ 1.97 hours Recovery @ 23.784 hours * Time increment when there is no runoff Maximum Infiltration Rate: 4.523 ft/day INFILTRATION : 0501 AMBIANCE ON WHITE SANDS -POLLUTION n~ ~ ~' o~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ C~ rrt ~ ~ ~ ~ 7 l1 ~., ll ._----~ ~ ''~ --~ +.~ ~ y ~ "' ~ 1_l ~ l~ ~ ~ G ~ ~ ] a~ w c a~ 0 .~ ~7 D 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 Time (hrs) Total Volume Infiltrated = 905 ft3 Page 1 of 1 Wells, Wayne From: Wells, Wayne Sent: Monday, April 24, 2006 5:41 PM To: 'Hunraf@aol.com' Cc: Ehooper1 @aol.com Subject: RE: Joe Burdette Re: Ambience Project Clearwater Beach Joe - 1. The transformer may go within the front setback so long as it is screened from view by vegetation. This transformer location should be shown on the building plans/site plans when such is submitted. 2. The original architectural plans had the condensing units for the clubhouse on the roof of the taller portion of the building (above the fifth living level). I am not so enamored with the proposal to cantilever the condensing unit out from the clubhouse into a setback area, especially since it wasn't in the original proposal that went through public hearing and since it would be adjacent to abutting development which would then receive the visual and noise impacts of such condenser. I would like to see the architect come up with an alternative location(s) that would be able to be within the project in a location that would look good (cantilevering doesn't off-hand sound like it would look good; kind of stuck on the side of the building) and be maintainable. While I am not the designer, it may appear that the pitched roof could be modified for such or the condenser could be located on the west side of the clubhouse as an extension of the stair landing or potentially on the first living level. Depending on the solution from the designer, such may or may not be required to be submitted to the Planning Department as a "minor revision." I would recommend the designer provide the solution to me for review (potentially it might later be something we just deal with through the building permit). Wayne -----Original Message----- From: Hunraf@aol.com [mailto:Hunraf@aol.com] Sent: Saturday, April 22, 2006 5:47 PM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: Ehooperl@aol.com Subject: ]oe Burdette Re: Ambience Project Clearwater Beach Wayne Progress Energy would like to put a transformer in the setback on the North side of the Ambiance project. Is that a problem? On the east side(out of view of the public and above the flood elevation) I would like to cantilever a condenser for the club house. It would extend out a little bit into the setback. Is that a problem? If so is there a remedy. Please let me know your thoughts 4/24/2006 ~., f~x~~,~' '-9 ' ,,k~~~` -. gTER, -t LONG RANGE PLANNING DEVELOPPdENT REVIEW Ms. Anj ani Abhyankar Panorama on Clearwater Beach LLC 483 Mandalay Avenue, Suite 209 Clearwater Beach, FL 33767 RE: FLD2005-01007 - 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street Time Extension Development Order Dear Ms. Abhyankar: April 18, 2006 On April 19, 2005, the Community Development Board (CDB) APPROVED the above Flexible Development application for (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units, to be converted to 11 dwelling units, plus eight existing dwelling units), under the provisions of Section 6-109; (2) Flexible Development application to permit a total of 15 attached. dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square. feet, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 feet to 50 feet, reductions to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building) and from 25 feet to zero feet (to trash staging area), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south -MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 feet and in the T District from 35 feet to 52.67 feet (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Section 3-1202.G. Section 4-407 of the Community Development Code requires the application for a building permit within one year of the date the CDB approved the request. This .same Section allows an extension of time to initiate a building permit, provided good cause is shown and documented in writing within the original period of validity. The Planning Director may also consider whether significant progress on the project is being made and whether or not there are pending or approved Code amendments that would significantly affect the project. On April 17, 2006, you submitted a request for a time extension to apply for a building permit to construct t1-~e im~prcvements on this parcel. Your letter cited the problem of the original architect passing away after CDB approval of the project and having to obtain releases and a new architect of record to prepare the construction documents. FRANK HIIS13nRn, MnvoR • ~'~~ ~~ LEI~RWA`I'ER PLANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE SOX 4745, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, lOO SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TEL EPHoNE (727) 562-4567 FAx (727) 562-4865 1311.1. JONSON, VICIi-MAYOR JOHN DORnN, COUNCILh1EMBC•R HOYI' HAMII:IY)N, COUNCII,MIiMIiBR CARLIiN A. PE"1'GKSIiN, COUNCIIIdEM131iR ~~I,QUAI, EMPLOYMI:N'I' AND AI'I'IRNA"1'IVIi AC'T'ION LMI'LOYIiR~~ `~ • • April 18, 2006 Abhyankar -Page Two In accordance with the provisions of Section 4-407 of the Community Development Code, I APPROVE aone-year time extension to April 19, 2007, to submit an application for a building permit to construct the site improvements on your parcel at 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street. The CDB may approve one additional extension of time after the Planning Director's extension to initiate a building permit application. Such extension shall not exceed one year, shall be for the project originally approved and shall be for good cause shown and documented in writing. The CDB must receive the request for this extension within the time frame granted by the Planning Director (period of validity after the original extension approved by the Planning Director). Good causes may include but are not limited to an unexpected national crisis (acts of war, significant downturn in the national economy, etc.), excessive weather-related delays, and the like. The CDB may also consider whether significant progress on the project is being made and whether or not there are pending or approved Code amendments that would significantly affect the project. Please be aware that the issuance of this Development Order does not relieve you of the necessity to obtain any building permits or pay any impact fees that may be required. In order to facilitate the issuance of any permit or license affected by this approval, please bring a copy of this letter with you when applying for any permits or licenses that require this prior development approval. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call Wayne M. Wells, AICP, Planner III at 727-562-4504. Sincerely, `/G% Michael Del , AICP Planning Director Cc: Ms. Doreen Williams, Northside Engineering Services, Inc. S: (Planning DepartmentlC D BIFLEX (FLD)Ilnactive or Finished ApplicationslAvalon I S Ambiance on White Sands #2 - (MHDR + T) - ApprovedlAvalon 1 S Tirne L•xtersion Development Order 4.1 R.Ob.doc • • Panorama on Clearwater Beach LLC April 17, 2006 Mr. Michael Delk Director of Planning City of Clearwater Municipal Services Building 100 South Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, Florida 33756 Re: Extension Request for Ambiance Project FLD2005-01007 Dear Mr. Delk: Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC is requesting a one year extension of our Development Order FLD2005-01007, Ambiance on White Sands, which expires on April 25, 2006. The major reason for this request is due to the fact that the original architect John Marshall Scott passed away after CDB approval. Releases were obtained and a new architect of record was granted to Collman-Karsky of Tampa Florida. The project is underway with our sales trailer in place and operating. Our construction drawings are at 50% CDs with Collman-Karsky Architects and we are finishing up our value engineering and should be ready to submit them next month for permit. A large portion of our delay is due to our attempt to satisfy the new life safety codes as we are still working with the Fire Marshal's office. Voeller Construction has been selected as the general contractor and we would hope to break ground in early August. We are also still waiting on some information from the building department which will help us expedite our construction even further. Our plans are complete enough for submission for permitting but our goal is to have them sufficient so as to save time and effort by all of the City's departments during their review. . Thank you in advance for your help in this matter. Sincerely, ~ D L~i'1/~ Anj ani Abhyankar '~ r General Manager Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC n N • C1~~ ®~ ~~~~~~~~~ PLANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE BOX 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, LOO SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPxoNE(727) 562-4567 FAx (727) 562-4576 LONG RANGE PLANNING DEVELOPMENT REVIEW Apri125, 2005 Mr. Housh Ghovaee Northside Engineering Services Inc. 601 Cleveland Street, Suite # 930 Clearwater, Florida 33755 RE: Development Order -Case FLD2005-01007 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street Dear Mr. Ghovaee: This letter constitutes a Development Order pursuant to Section 4-206.D.6 of the Community Development Code. On April 19, 2005, the Community Development Board reviewed your request for (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units, to be converted to 11 dwelling units, plus eight existing dwelling units); under the provisions of Section 6-109; (2) Flexible Development application to permit a total of 15 attached dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square feet, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 feet to 50 feet, reductions to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building) and from 25 feet to zero feet (to trash staging area), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south -MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 feet and in the T District from 35 feet to 52.67 feet (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Section 3-1202.G. The Community Development Board (CDB) APPROVED the applications with the following bases and conditions: Bases for Approval: 1. The proposal complies with the Flexible Development criteria as a Residential Infill Project per Section 2-404.F. 2. The proposal complies with the Flexible Development criteria as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project per Section 2-803.C. 3. The proposal is in compliance with other standards in the Code including the General Applicability Criteria per Section 3-913. BRIAN J. AUNGST, MAYOR-COMMISSIONER HOYT HAMILTON, VICE MAYOR-COMMISSIONER WHITNEY GRAY, COD1h1ISSIONER FRANK HII36ARD, COMp115SIONER BILi.,JONSON, COMMISSIONER ~~EQUAI. EMPLOYMENT AND AFPIRMAI'IVE ACTION EMPI,OYF.R~~ rj., ~ • April 25, 2005 Ghovaee ~- Page Two 4. The development is compatible with the surrounding area and will enhance other redevelopment efforts. 5. The proposal is in compliance with the Old Florida District of Beach by Design. Conditions of Approval: 1. That the final design and color of the building be consistent with the conceptual elevations submitted to, or as modified by, the CDB; 2. That, while the proposal totals 19 dwelling units through the Termination of Status of Nonconformity and only 15 dwelling units are proposed, the four remaining dwelling units cannot be constructed on- site and cannot be transferred off-site in the future; 3. That a Unity of Title be recorded in the public records prior to the issuance of any permits; 4. That, prior to the issuance of any permits, the stormwater treatment vault be enlarged and be designed to satisfy all City design and construction requirements; 5. That, prior to the issuance of any permits, additional planting materials be incorporated to the landscape design of this site, especially the west side, of an appropriate material and size, including the relationship to windows and balconies, acceptable to the Planning Department. The minimum size of palms (except pigmy date palms) must be 10 feet of clear trunk; 6. That future signage meet the requirements of the Code and any future freestanding sign be a monument-style sign a maximum four feet in height, designed to match the exterior materials and color of the building; 7. That any future storage units on the ground floor be used for storage only, in compliance with all Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA) rules and guidelines. Should such storage units be proposed and approved by Staff as a Minor Revision to this approval, evidence of this restriction of use, embodied in condominium documents, homeowner's documents, deed restrictions or like forms, shall be submitted to the Building Official prior to the issuance of the first Certificate of Occupancy; 8. That all proposed utilities (from the right-of--way to the proposed building) be placed underground. Conduits for the future undergrounding of existing utilities within the abutting right-of--way shall be installed along the entire site's street frontages prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. The applicant's representative shall coordinate the size and number of conduits with all affected utility providers (electric, phone, cable, etc.), with the exact location, size and number of conduits to be approved by the applicant's engineer and the City's Engineering Department prior to the commencement of work; 9. That a condominium plat be recorded prior to the issuance of the first Certificate of Occupancy; 10. That all Parks and Recreation fees be paid prior to the issuance of any permits; and 11. That all Fire Department requirements be met prior to the issuance of any permits. Pursuant to Section 4-407, an application for a building permit shall be made within one year of Flexible Development approval (April 19, 2006). All required certificates of occupancy shall be obtained within one year of the date of issuance of the building permit. Time frames do not change with successive owners. The Community Development Coordinator may grant an extension of time for a period not to exceed one year and only within the original period of validity. The Community Development Board may approve one additional extension of time after the community development coordinator's extension to initiate a building permit application. The issuance of this Development Order does not relieve you of the necessity to obtain any building permits or pay any impact fees that maybe required. In order to facilitate the issuance of any permit or • • !f April 25, 2005 Ghovaee -Page Three license affected by this approval, please bring a copy of this letter with you when applying for any permits or licenses that require this prior development approval. Additionally, an appeal of a Level Two approval (Flexible Development) may be initiated pursuant to Section 4-502.B by the applicant or by any person granted party status within 14 days of the date of the CDB meeting. The filing of an application/notice of appeal shall stay the effect of the decision pending the final determination of the case. The appeal period for your case expires on May 3, 2005 (14 days from the date of the CDB meeting). If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call Wayne M. Wells, Planner III, at 727-562-4504. You can access zoning information for parcels within the City through our website: www.myclearwater.com/ og v/depts/plannin>;. *Make Us Your Favorite! Sincerely, Mic ael De , AI P Planning Director S: (Planning DepartmentlC D BIFLEX (FLD) Ilnactive or Finished ApplicationslAvalon 1 S Ambiance on White Sands #2 - (MHDR + 7J - ApprovedlAvalon IS Development Order.dor. Page 1 of 1 • Wells, Wayne From: Doreen Williams [doreen@northsideengineering.com] Sent: Friday, April 15, 2005 11:41 AM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: 'Uday Lele' Subject: Ambiance on White Sands Wayne, just a quick note to inform you that Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC accepts the conditions of approval for the development order. And on a personal note, I spoke with Uday Lele this morning and he wanted me to pass along to you a BIG THANKS for all your help and support (and continued support) in which you have offered. We will see you on Tuesday at CDB. Have a great weekend!!! Doreen A. Williams Project Director Northside Engineering Services, Inc. 601 Cleveland Street, Suite 930 Clearwater, FL 33755 Phone: 727-443-2869 /Fax: 446-8036 /Cell: 235-8474 Email: doreen@northsideengineering.com 4/15/2005 • • Wells, Wayne From: Wells, Wayne Sent: Thursday, April 14, 2005 10:39 AM To: Doreen Williams (E-mail) Subject: Staff Reports for the April 19, 2005, CDB meeting Doreen - Attached are the Staff Reports for the April 19, 2005, CDB meeting starting at 1:00 pm for the following cases: 1. FLD2004-10076/TDR2004-10014, 12 Idlewild Street. 2. FLD2005-01007, 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street. I also have the signed versions for you. I will place these at the greeter's area in our lobby and you can pick them up at any time. need to know if the conditions for both of these cases are acceptable or not, preferably by 10 am on Monday, April 18, 2005. If you have any questions, please let me know. Thanks. Wayne Idlewild 12 Staff Avalon 15 Staff Report for 4... Report.doc 1 CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTli~IEleTT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE. CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-465 TO: FAX: . ~ ~0 ~ ~ 03 Io Phone: ~'~' 3 -L`a (o ~l FROM: .~ Q.~~~ Phone: S ~ Z- -~S 0 ~}- DATE:_ ~ / L ~ OS RE: I S fT Jw. ~ on S ~ ; MESSAGE: NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) Z-- • • Apr. 12 2005 03:23PM YOUR LOGO CityOfClearwater-Plan Dept YOUR FAX N0. 727 562 4865 N0. OTHER FACSIMILE START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT 01 94468036 Apr. 12 03:22PM 01'07 SND 02 0K TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MENU' ##~4. THHEIVV SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE GRLL 1-800-hiELP-FAX C43S-7329). ,` • • Wells, Wayne From: Rice, Scott Sent: Tuesday, April 12, 2005 2:59 PM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: Barker, Brian A.; Faessler, Heather Subject: FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Wayne, See following comments regarding the revised stormwater system: `The City's Storm Drainage Design Criteria does not allow water quality treatment (1/2" runoff over redeveloped site) in underground vaults unless specifically allowed by the City Engineer. Prior to CDB, provide justification for the use of a vault to allow consideration by City staff. 4/11/05 This site has changed dramatically from original submittal. Comments on revised submittal are: 1. Discharge point for pond/vault has changed from original submittal. Provide drainage basin delineation to show pre- and post-construction drainage patterns. 2. If discharge point from site is being re-directed to Mandalay Avenue, evaluate the capacity of the receiving pipe on Mandalay. 3. Provide the size/type of pipe on Mandalay that the site will tie into. 4. Additional topography is necessary to determine what City owned facilities will be impacted during the construction of the stormwater outfall pipe. 5. The storm pipe constructed in the ROW needs to meet City standards. This needs to be reflected on the plans. 6. It is unclear how runoff will be directed to the vault and it appears adjacent property may be affect. These issues need to be addressed prior to CDB. D. Scott Rice Land Devel. Engr. Manager 727-562-4781 scott.rice@MyClearwater.com Norths~de ~~ s ~~. CIVIL • LAND PLANNING • ENVIRONMENTAL • TRANSPORTATION • ORIGINAL April 5, 2005 Mr. Wayne Wells City of Clearwater Planning Department I00 S. Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, FL 33756 RE: FLD2005-01007 15 Avalon Street Responses Dear Mr. Wells: ASR ~ ~ ~~~~ PLANNING Q-~IaP,RT~r1ENT CITY OF CLE~RtNAT~R Listed below are our comments regarding the above mentioned project before CDB submittal. Landscape Perimeter Conditions: 1. A Comprehensive Landscape Application is attached. Landscape 1. See Sheet L1.1 for revised plantings 2. See Sheet L1.1 for revised plans. We have made adjustments for smaller plants to be erected as to not block windows or balconies. 3. Retention has been removed and a vault added so additional landscaping may be planted. 4. Using an automatic parking system is not an option. The retention has been deleted and a vault added. Parks & Recs 1. All recreation facility impact fees (if applicable) will be paid prior to issuance of building permits. Solid Waste Condition 1. Dumpster will be rolled out on trash pick up day to dumpster pad. Traffic Engineering 1. See Sheet C3.1 mirrors have been added. 2. See Sheet C3.1 spaces have been property dimensioned. 3. Transportation Impact Fees to be paid prior to C.O. Zoning Conditions 1. It is understood staff will not support proposed height. Issue will be taken up at CDB. 601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33755 N ESADMI N@MI N DSPRI NG.COM NESTECHQMINDSPRING.COM 727 • 443 • 2869 FAX 727 • 446 • 8036 ~; w .. Mr. Wayne Wells April 5, 2005 Page Two ORIGINAL 2. It is understood that condition of approval regazding Termination of Status of Nonconformity. Additional units will not be transferred to other pazcels. 3. See Sheet C3.1, trash staging area has been relocated to northwest corner. 4. There is no longer on-site retention. All retention has been moved to a vault. 5. Trees have been changed so views from the first floor units will not be blocked. See Sheet L1.1. 6. See Sheet Li.l for revised plantings. 7. See Sheets A7 & A8 for colors and textures used on proposed building. 8. Additional vertical banding has been added to building. 9. West landscape buffer cannot be increased anymore. 10. Comprehensive Landscape program application has been submitted. 11. Reduced floor plans and elevations aze included. 12. See Sheet C1.1 and C3.1 for correct heights. This concludes the responses to the final comments received. ~ Sincerely, ~- ~: ,d ~ifAams Project Director R[~C~C~9~~D m~R o s zoos PLANNING ~EPART~PIENT CITY 4F CLEARWATER ~ ~- ., LONG RANGE PLANNING DEVELOPMENT REVIEW CIT'YOFCLEARWA'I'ER PLANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFPICE BOX 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, ZOO SOUTH MYRTLE~AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAx (727) 562-4576 .March 25, 2005 Mr. Housh Ghovaee Northside Engineering Services Inc. 601 Cleveland Street, Suite # 930 Clearwater, Florida 33755 Re: Community Development Board Meeting (Case No. FLD2005-01007) Dear Mr. Ghovaee: The Case No. FLD2005-01007 for (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units, to be converted to 11 dwelling units, plus eight existing dwelling units), under the provisions of Section 6-109; (2) Flexible Development approval to permit a total of 15 attached dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square feet, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 feet to 50 feet, reductions to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building) and from 25 feet to zero feet (to trash staging area), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south -MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 feet and in the T District from 35 feet to 52.67 feet (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Section 3-1202.G, for property located at 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street, has been scheduled to be reviewed by the Community Development Board on April 19, 2005. The meeting will take place at 1:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers, 3rd floor of City Hall at 112 S. Osceola Avenue, Clearwater. BRIAN J. AuNCST, MAYOR-COMMISSIONER HOPI' HAMILTON, VICE MAYOR-COMMISSIONER WHITNEY GRAY, COMMISSIONER FRANK H113DARD, COMMISSIONER BILL JONSON, COMMISSIONER ~~EQUAL EMPLOYMENT AND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION EMPLOYF.R~~ ~~ ~~ March 25, 2005 Ghovaee -Page 2 C If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call me at 727-562-4504. Sincerely, ,~ ~``~~ ~1~0 Wayn .Wells, AICP Planner III S:IPlanning DepartmentlC D BIFLEX (FLD)IPending caseslUp for the next CDBIAvnlon IS Ambiance on White Sands #2 - (MHDR + 7) - 4.19.05 CDB - WWIAvalon IS 4. /9.05 CDB Letter.doc FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. M~'RTLE AVE. CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-465 TO: ~ ~ c.Q.~_ ~~ 1 i o~.~s FAX• q'4 b - ~O ~l b Phone: 9'"g' 3 ' Z~ ~ 5 FROM• 1~,. _ Phone• .~ bZ. " ~' a O ~" NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING TIIIS PAGE) ~-- • Mar. 23 2005 06:14PM YOUR LOGO City0fClearwater-Plan Dept YOUR FAX N0. 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FACSIMILE START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT 01 94468036 Mar. 23 06:12PM 01'46 5ND 04 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MENU' #84. THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADIJANTAGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HELP-FAX C435-7329). { +; ;~1`'` ~~t~t~* ~~g~iA;,~~, 1~1 • Conditions Associated With FLD2005-01007 15 AVALON ST Landscape Perimeter Conditi Arden Dittmer 562-4604 03/17/2005 2/10/2005 Not Met Plan does not meet the requirements of perimeter plantings in Code Section 3-1202.D. Revise accordingly or submit a Comprehensive Landscape application as required. Landscape Arden Dittmer 562-4604 03/17/2005 3/17/2005 (A_D) Not Met Palms have been changed to a low dwarf variety, this will do little to buffer the large building. Revise plans to include taller palms (Washingtonia or Sabal) in the areas of the building where they could be placed with minimum impact on the views from within the structure, yet break up the expanse of wall where they are to be planted. 2/10/2005 (A_D) The plans show a multitude of palms on the west side of the building where balconies and windows will be obstructed. If this is the proposed plan that is approved, it will be the plan that will be required at building permit application and completion for certificate of occupancy. Consideration should be made as to location of the materials proposed and the impact of those materials. 03/17/2005 same comment, this would most likely solve many site concerns. The fact that there is only one Not Met foot of level ground before the slope for the retention areas is creating a hardship on placing the proposed plants in this area. 2/10/2005 The area between the building and the property line for landscape will not be sufficient for some of the proposed palms. Consider an automated parking system to allow for more open space on this parcel as they do not require the drive isles. Parks & Recs Condition Recreation Facility impact fees of $650 is due for 3.25 net new units prior to issuance of building Not Met permits or final plat (if applicable) whichever occurs first. Contact Art Kader at 727-562-4824. Solid Waste Condition Dumpsters and recycling containers are to be staged by on site maintenance personel Not Met Traffic Eng Condition Bennett Elbo 562-4775 02/15/2005 1. Parking spaces numbered 16, 17, 21, and 22 have limited site visibility, please demonstrate Not Met how these spaces comply with Community Development Code Section 3-1402.A. 3/14/05 - APPLICANT RESPONSE IS THAT MIRRORS WILL BE USED. MIRRORS NOT SHOWN ON PLANS. APPLICANT MUST DEMONSTRATE HOW MIRROR WILL PROVIDE ENHANCED VISIBILITY FOR PARKING SPACES 16 AND 17. 2. Show angle (in degrees) for the angled parking spaces. All parking spaces must comply with City standard dimensions (Community Development Code Section 3-1402). 3/14/05 -PARKING SPACES NOT PER CODE. 45-DEGREE SPACES REQUIRE A DEPTH OF 19.8-FEET PERPENDICULAR TO THE DRIVE AISLE. THE DEPTH SHOWN ON THE PLANS IS 18-FEET. The above to be addressed prior to CDB. Print Date: 03/23/2005 CaseConditons Page 1 of 3 • FLD2005-01007 15 AVALON ST • Traffic Eng Condition Bennett Elbo 562-4775 1. General note: Transportation Impact Fees to be determined and paid prior to C.O. Zoning Condition Wayne Wells 562-4504 02/20/2005 Proposal is for attached dwellings (condominium flats) in the Old Florida District of Beach by Not Met Design. Single family dwellings and townhomes are the preferred form of development in the Old Florida District. Additionally, the proposed building exceeds 50 feet in height, which staff is deeming to be the maximum height for mid-rise buildings. Staff cannot support the proposal. 03/17/2005 3/17/05 - WW Not Met Include as a condition of approval. 3/3/05 - W W The proposal is to pemit 15 attached dwellings. Based on a calculation of 30 du/acre, 14 dwelling units maximum can be requested. The proposal is currently only requesting the Termination of Status of Nonconformity for the existing overnight accommodation uses of 15 rooms. Application should be amended to request Termination of all units on the property, including the existing dwelling units. If amended, and based on Section 6-109.B, reconstruction of any Terminated density may only be on the same parcel (ie: no future transferring off of unused dwelling units to other parcels). 2/20/05 - W W Staff will not support the requested Termination of Status of Nonconformity, as it produces an excess number of dwelling units. Proposal indicates that the excess units are intended to be sold off (additional profit, over and above what is necessary to construct the project). Alternately, use the normal 30 dwelling units per acre and a Transfer of Development Rights to this site of one unit. 03/17/2005 3/17/05 & 2/20/05 - WW Not Met Unclear how the dumpsters will be moved to the trash staging area in the front yard on Avalon Street. Suggest switching the location of the trash staging area and the retention pond. 03/17/2005 3/17/05 & 2/20/05 - WW Not Met Unclear how there is sufficient room to plant landscaping along the edge of the retention pond when the planting area is only one-foot wide. Also, unclear how the root balls for the trees will be planted with the slope of the retention pond in mind. Provide details of such planting on the slope. Provide narrative as to how such plantings will not reduce the drainage capacity once constructed and how the mulch will stay around the plantings without being washed away. 03/17/2005 3/17/05 & 2/20/05 - WW Not Met Based on the clear trunk lengths indicated for the proposed trees, it appears that most views from the first floor units will be blocked. 03/17/2005 3/17/05 & 2/20/05 - WW Not Met Explain how the proposed palms will be planted and how they will grow and be maintained within the three-foot area on the west side of the building. Would appear that the fronds will scrape the building. . 03/17/2005 3/17/05 & 2/20/05 - WW Not Met Sheets A7 + A8 -indicate the proposed exterior building finishes and colors of all architectural elements. 03/17/2005 3/17/05 & 2/20/05 - WW Not Met Add vertical banding to reduce the blandness of large expanses of flat walls (all sides). 03/17/2005 3/17/05 & 2/27/05 - WW Not Met Staff cannot support the proposed reductions to the west setbacks and the west landscape buffer. 03/17/2005 Submit a completed Comprehensive Landscape Program application (original plus 14 copies) Not Met providing the justification for the reduction to the landscape buffer along the west side in the MHDR District. 03/17/2005 Provide one copy of the reduced 8.5" x 11"floor plans and elevations. Not Met Print Date: 03/23/2005 CaseConditons Page 2 of 3. • • FLD2005-01007 15 AVALON ST Zoning Condition Wayne Wells 562-4504 03/17/2005 Need to know the height of the parapet (either three feet as shown on Sheet A7, East Elevation, Not Met or 3.66 feet as stated on Sheet C1.1 and in the Description of Requests in Revised Exhibit "A"). Make consistent. Revise either Sheet A7, East Elevation, or Sheet C1.1 and the Description of Requests in Revised Exhibit "A". Print Date: 03/23/2005 CaseConditons Page 3 of 3 lorthside ~~. • ORIGINAL March 7, 2005 Mr. Wayne Wells, Planner III City of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S. Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, FL 33756 CIVIL • LAND PLANNING • ENVIRONMENTAL • TRANSPORTATION • ~~~[~9~9[~~ M~~ U ~~~~ RE: FLD2005-01007 -15 Avalon Street DRC Response Comments Dear Mr. Wells: PLANNING DEPARTMENT CITY OF CLEARWATER Please find our responses to the Mazch 3, 2005, DRC Comments in regards to the above case: General Engineering 1. Site plans have been signed by a registered professional engineer. 2. Doghouse manhole will remain as shown on Sheet C4.1. To tie into the manhole on Mandalay Ave. would be in conflict with other utilities. 3. Doghouse manhole will be placed on top of a poured in place slab. 4. See sheet C3.1 for new 5' sidewalk along Kendall Street. 5. Double detector check valve with bypass meter for internal fire protection line is noted. 1. A separate right-of--way permit will be obtained for manhole installation in Avalon Street prior to building permit. 2. Fire hydrant /fire sprinkler lines to be constructed on 6" ductile iron pipe. See sheet C4.1 Fire 1. Fire hydrant at s.w. corner of property is not behind a block wall, it is shown inside the property line. Land Resources 1. See demolition plan, Sheet C2.1 Landscaping 1. See Sheet L1.1 for all utilities. 2. Due to site constraints, 100% perimeter landscaping cannot be achieved. A Comprehensive Landscape program application has been submitted. 3. See Sheet Li.l for palms on west side of building, these have been revised as to not block windows and balconies. 4. An automated parking system wi11_ net be provided on si±e. Proposed palms v,~ll be revised with other suitable materials. 601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33755 NESADMIN@MINDSPRING.COM N ESTECHQMI NDSPRI NG.COM 727 • 443 • 2869 FAX 727 • 446 • 8036 -. • • OR161NAL Mr. Wayne Wells March 7, 2005 DRC Response Comments ~~~~ FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Street ~aalz ~ o X005 Parks and Recreation plA~INING DEPARTMENT 1. Impact fees will be paid prior to building permits. CITY pF CLEARWATER Stormwater 1. The revised calculations for runoff co efficiency for the site has been corrected and attached. 2. You should be able to read grades better now that our blueprint machine is in proper working order this time around. 3. Outfall location has been revised to spill into driveway instead of sidewalk. Solid Waste 1. Dumpster will be staged by on-site maintenance personnel. Traffic Engineering 1. Parking spaces 16, 17, 21 and 22 will not longer have limited site visibility due to the installation of mirrors. 2. Angled parking spaces have been dimensioned in degrees. All Transportation Impact Fees will be paid prior to C.O. Planning 1. Although staff's preferred form of development in the Old Florida District is town homes and single family dwellings, our proposal is for attached dwelling (condos) and we all agree to disagree. 2. Application has been revised to request Termination of all units on the property. Unused density will not be used in future for transfer off-site. 3. Survey has been revised to include Lot 5 in the legal description. New survey is enclosed. 4. Sheet C 1.1 has been revised to accurately reflect legal description. 5. Concrete has been reduced at the south end of the building and additional landscaping has been added. 6. See architectural plans 7. See architectural plans 8. See architectural plans 9. Drive isle has been dimensioned. 10. Dumpster location has been moved. 11. Sheet C3.1 now have southern stairs indicated on plan. • • ORIGINAL March 7, 2005 DRC Response Comments FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Street Page Three 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. Removed plants in front of retention ponds. Sabal Palms will be planted on the slopes as will some of the trees just like Sabal Palms are planted on the slopes of nearly all our highway overpasses throughout the State. Removed all trees from the west side of the building. The other sides still contain trees to meet minimum requirements. Removed plants in front of retention ponds. Sabal Palms will be planted on the slopes as will some of the trees just like Sabal Palms are planted on the slopes of nearly all our highway overpasses throughout the State. Retention area is now correctly shown on Sheet L 1.1. Parking spaces 22-24 have been dimensioned in degrees. See Sheet C4.1 for revision Irrigation plan has been redesigned. Sidewalk has been continued and retention pond has been revised. See architectural plans See architectural plans See architectural plans See architectural plans See architectural plans See architectural plans See architectural plans See architectural plans See architectural plans Colors have been revised. G~~~C~9 /F/~~ MAR ~ ~ 2005 PLANNING DEPARTMENT CITY OF CLEARWATER 30. At a previous meeting with Chip Gerlock, it was agreed that this would be acceptable and all staff members received a copy of his a-mail. With all the significant changes made to this proposed project from our previous submittal, this was found to work. This concludes the DRC comment responses dated March 3, 2005. We look forward to being on the April 19, 2005, CONSENT CDB hearing agenda. Sincerely, r ' een A. illiams Project Director Norths~e OR16~1gL LETTER ~ F IRAN 5 M 1TTAL Date: March 9, 2005 To: City of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S. Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, Florida 33758-4748 Attn: Sherry L. Watkins, Administrative Analyst Refierence: Ambiance on White Sands / 15 Avalon NES Project #501 / FLD2005-01007 We Transmit: (X) Enclosed ()Under Separate Cover ()Mail ()Courier () Pick-up (X) Hand Delivered Q Per Your Request ()For Your Review & Comment () For Your Use (X) For Your Approval ()For Your Files ()For Your Information CIVIL • LAND PLANNING • ENVIRONMENTAL • TRANSPORTATION • MAR ~ ~ X005 PLANNING DEPARTMENT CITY OF CLEARWATER (X)Originals (X) Prints ()Addendum ()Shop Drawings ()Specifications (X) Applications ()Floppy Disk COPIES DATE DESCRIPTION 15 3/05 Civil 8~ Landscape Drawings (9 sheets) 1 sets si ed & sealed 15 3/05 8'1/2x11" Civil Site Plan 15 3/05 8'1/2x11" Colored Landsca a Plan 15 3/05 Flex Develo ment Res. Infill A lication 15 3105 Flex Develo ment Com . Infill A lication 15 3/05 Letters of Authorization 15 3/05 Warran Deeds 15 3/05 Surve s 1 si ned & sealed 15 3105 Stormwater Re ort 1 si ned & sealed 15 3/05 8.5x11" Colored Renderin s Architectural 15 3/05 8.5x11 ° Buildin Elevations 3105 Color Char! 15 3/05 24x36 Architectural Drawin s 1 3/05 Com rehensive Landsca e A lication 8~ Sheet L1.1 1 3/05 DRC Res onse Letter Comments: For Community Development Board hearing 4!19/05 By. D en A. !!l~illiams Project Director 601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33755 NESADMIN@MINDSPRING.COM N ESTECH®MI NDSPRI NG.COM 727 • 443 • 2869 FAX 727 • 446 • 8036 FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTIi~IENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE. CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-465 To: lJ o~ ~~ 1~J'.~ ~' FAX: ~-4-1Q - ~ ~ 3 Ro Phone• q"~' 3 " Z~ b FROM: ~ Q.\~'~. Phone: ) ~ Z-~J 04-; DATE:_ Z ~I Z~ I ~ s RE: I J /1V o.-1~~, 1 `1 S rn. Q.x-se~ NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLIJDING THIS PAGE)~_, MESSAGE: ~ (~.~~ Ce~nw~a.~~ ~or 3 . 3. ~J • ~« .~.~..- a Feb. 27 2005 07:30PM YOUR LOGO City0fClearwater-Plan Dept YOUR FAX N0. 727 562 4865 N0. DTHER FACSIMILE START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT 01 94468036 Feb. 27 07:26PM 03'49 SND 11 OK TO TLIRH OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MENU' #04. THEfJ SELECT OFF BY USING '+' ~ '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-•~P-FAX C435-7329). Northside E~ s o~. February 7, 2005 Ms. Cindi Tarapani City of Clearwater Planning Department Planning Director 100 S. Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, FL 33756 RE: Ambiance on White Sands FLD2005-01007 Dear Ms. Tarapani: C ~ ~ ;~ E' ,~' ~~ ~t FEB ~ 1 2005 f ~ p~. .. . ~' r :r, .._ CIVIL • LAND PLANNING • ENVIRONMENTAL • TRANSPORTATION • Our clients, Panorama on Clearwater, LLC are working with Signature Bank to secure financing for the Ambiance on White Sands project. The bank has asked for a letter from the City of Clearwater confirming the number of units allowed to be constructed on this site in regards to "Termination ofNon-Conformity". The contact person at Signature Bank is: Covington Sharp Senior Vice President Signature bank 100 Second Avenue North St. Petersburg, FL 33701 Please copy me on the attached letter. Your prompt attention to this matter is greatly appreciated. If I can be of any assistance, please feel free to call. Sincerely, Doreen A. Williams rN~ Project Director Cc: Panorama on Clearwater, LLC Robert C. Decker File 601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33755 NESADMIN@MINDSPRING.COM N ESTECH~MI N DS PRI NG.COM 727 • 443 • 2869 FAX 727 • 446 • 8036 o. ~_ : ~arwater U February 04, 2005 CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING 100 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE: (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4576 W W W . MYC LEARWAT ER. C OM Northside Engineering Services Inc. 601 Cleveland Street Suite 930 Clearwater, Fl 33755 RE: FLD2005-01007 -- 15 AVALON ST -- Letter of Completeness Dear Northside Engineering Services Inc. The Planning Staff has entered your application into the Department's filing system and assigned the case number: FLD2005-01007. After a preliminary review of the submitted documents, staff has determined that the application is Comalete. The Development Review Committee (DRC) will review the application for sufficiency on March 03, 2005, in the Planning Department conference room -Room 216 - on the second floor of the Municipal Services Building. The building is located at 100 South Myrtle Avenue in downtown Clearwater. Please call Sherry Watkins, Administrative Analyst, at 727-562-4582 no earlier than one week prior to the meeting date for the approximate time that your case will be reviewed. You or your representative (as applicable) must be present to answer any questions that the DRC may have regarding your application. Additional comments maybe generated by the DRC at the time of the meeting. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at 727-562-4504 or ~~:lay..e. vv~eiiS~iiiyCieai watcr.Colll. Sincerely yours, Wayne Wells, AICP Planner III Letter of Completeness - FLD2005-01007 - 1 S AVAL0IV ST FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE. CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-465 To: FAX• ~~~4 ' ~0 3~ Phone: ~' q' 3 " 2-~ ~a I . FROM: ~ 21` s Phone: , h Z~ S ~ 4' DATE•~_ Z~7 ~ U j RE• FZD 7.~?~S- ~ 1 ~ 0 ~J ~0.1,~ S-}-~ MESSAGE: ~.O~M~P 1 ~ NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLITDING THIS PAGE) ~ ~ Feb. 07 2005 12:01PM YOUR LOGO CityOfClearwater-Plan Dept YOUR FAX N0. 727 562 4865 N0. OTHER FACSIMILE START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT 01 94468036 Feb. 07 12:00PM 01'10 SND 02 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MENU' #04. THEhI SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-F~LP-FAX C435-73291. CITY OF CLEAR WATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE.,2ND FLOOR CLEAR WATER, FL, 33756 PH - 727/562-4567 FAX - 727/562-4865 FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET TO: NORTHSIDE ENGINEERING FROM: WAYNE WELLS COMPANY: DATE: 2/4/2005 FAX NUMBER: 727-461-7789 TOTAL NO. OF PAGES INCLUDING COVER: 2 RE: 15 AVALON STREET ^ URGENT X FOR REVIEW ^ PLEASE COMMENT ^ PLEASE REPLY ^ PLEASE RECYCLE NOTES/COMMENTS See attached letter. WEB - WWW.MYCLEARWATER.COM Trm i ss~ on~ Repo r t Date/Time Local ID Local Name Company Logo This document was confirmed. (reduced sample and details below) Document Size Letter-~ _°ry_ .i'~a~er V CITY OF CLEARWATER PLAP(1HIN0 DEPARTMENT LOO 8. MYRTLE AVE.,2~p FLOOR CLEAHWATER, FL, SS~758 PH - 747/582-45$7 FA% - 747/562-4888 FAC8IMILB TRANSMITTAL SHEET xo: Noxxasms sNaHOaclsl+nta moat: wwnvs wsus coMraNY: naTE: 2/a/coos FAX NUMBER 727-a81-7789 T01'AL NO. OF PAGES INCLUDING COYER: 3 RE; 16 AVALON STREET ^ Ui10RRT XFCA REVIEW O PLEiV9E COMDlENT O PLBA.SE REPLY O PLBA98 RECYCLB 1101L9/CCAIF.N18: Sre RS7SChBt1 letter. 2- 4-OS; 4:12PM 7275624796 wEH - WWW.IQYCLEARWATER.COH Total Pa~g es Scanned 2 Total Pages Confirmed 2 No. Doc Remote Station Start Tlme Duration Pages Mode Comments Results 1 4t 946'17789 2- 4-05; 4:11PM 32^ 2/ 2 EC CP 28.8 Notes - EC: Error Correct BC: Broadcast Send CP: Completed HS: HOSt SCan HF: Host Fax RE: Resend MP: Multi-Poll RM: Receive to Memory HP: Host Print HR: Host Receive PD: Polled by Remote PG: Polling a Remote DR: Document Removed FG: Forced Output FM: Forward Mailbox Doc MB: Receive to Mailbox PI Polder Interruption TM: Terminated by user WT: Waiting Transfer WS: Waiting Send Norths~e S~q s ~~. CIVIL • LAND PLANNING • ®~ ~ ~ I ENVIRONMENTAL • ~~~SPORTATION • LETTER O F TRAN S M ITTAL Date: January 30, 2005 To: City of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S. Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, Florida 33758-4748 Attn: Sherry-L. -W Administrative Analyst Reference: mbiance on White S ds / Avalon 8~ Kendall N We Transmit: (X) Enclosed ()Under Separate Cover ()Mail ()Courier () Pick-up (X) Hand Delivered () Per Your Request (X) For Your Review & Comment Q For Your Use ()For Your Approval ()For Your Files ()For Your Information (X)Originals (X) Prints ()Addendum ()Shop Drawings ()Specifications (X) Applications ()Floppy Disk COPIES DATE DESCRIPTION 15 1/4/05 Civil & Landscape Drawings (9 sheets) 3) sets si ed & sealed 15 1/4/05 8'1/2x11" Civil Site Plan 15 1/4/05 8'1/2x11" Colored Landsca a Plan 15 1/4/05 Flex Develo ment Res. Infill A lication 15 1!4/05 Flex Develo ment Com . Infill A lication 15 114/05 Letters of Authorization 15 1 /4/05 Warrant Deeds 15 1/4/05 Surve s (1 si ned & sealed 15 1/4/05 Stormwater Re ort 3 si ned & sealed 15 1/4/05 8.5x11° Colored Renderin s Architectural 15 1/4/05 8.5x11" Buildin Elevations 15 1/4/05 Color Charts 15 1/4/05 24x36 Architectural Drawin s 1 1/7/05 Ck #109 in the amount of $1,205.00 2 1/20/05 Comprehensive Landscape Application Comments: Design Review Committee for January 31, 2005 deadline Copies To: File U oreen A. Williams, Project Director 601 CLEVELAND STREET, SUITE 930 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33755 NESADMIN@MINDSPRING.COM NESTECH~MINDSPRING.COM 727 • 443 • 2869 FAX 727 • 446 • 8036 CDB Meetin Date: Aril 19 2005 II Case Numbers: FLD2005-01007 Agenda Item: ES Owners/ Applicant: Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC Representative: Mr Housh Ghovaee Northside En ing eerin~ Services, Inc. Address: 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT GENERAL INFORMATION: REQUEST: (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units, to be converted to 11 dwelling units, plus eight existing dwelling units), under the provisions of Section 6-109; (2) Flexible Development approval to permit a total of 15 attached dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square feet, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 feet to 50 feet, reductions to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building) and from 25 feet to zero feet (to trash staging area), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south -MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 feet and in the T District from 35 feet to 52.67 feet (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Section 3-1202.G. EXISTING ZONING/ Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) LAND USE: District; Residential Facilities High (RFH) Category PROPERTY SIZE: 0.498 acres; 21,729 square feet Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 1 of 14 PROPERTY USE: Current Use: Overnight accommodations, detached dwelling and attached dwellings Proposed Use: Attached dwellings (15 units -condominium) ADJACENT ZONING/ North: Open Space/Recreation, Medium High Density Residential LAND USES: and Tourist Districts; City parking lot and overnight accommodation uses East: Tourist District; Detached dwelling, overnight accommodation uses and restaurant. South: Tourist District; Overnight accommodation use and restaurant West: Open Space/Recreation District; City parking lot and beach CHARACTER OF THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY: The surrounding area is a mixture of attached dwellings (condominium), detached dwellings and overnight accommodation uses. Commercial uses are to the south and along Mandalay Avenue. A City parking lot and the beach is to the west. ANALYSIS: Site Location and Existing Conditions: The 0.498 acres is located between Avalon Street and Kendall Street, approximately 100 feet west of Mandalay Avenue. The site has 200 feet of frontage on Avalon Street (north) and 50 feet of frontage on Kendall Street (south). The proposed site is composed of seven parcels. On November 16, 2004, the Community Development Board (CDB) denied a similar request for 13 attached dwellings on 0.299 acres, composed of the three western parcels (Cases FLD2004- 08059/TDR2004-08008 for property at 15 - 17 Avalon Street and. 16 Kendall Street). This prior request included reductions to lot area and lot width in the MHDR and T Districts, similar reductions to setback requirements (with the west side setback requested at zero feet to building) and a building height of 69.5 feet (to roof deck). The applicant has since purchased four small lots, with an additional 100 feet of frontage on Avalon Street, in order to respond to design issues outlined in this prior application. The parcel at 15 Avalon Street is zoned Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and is currently developed with a nonconforming, five-unit overnight accommodation use. The parcel at 17 Avalon Street is zoned MHDR District and is currently developed with one detached dwelling. The parcels at 21 - 27 Avalon Street are zoned MHDR District and are currently developed with seven attached dwellings, which are nonconforming to density. The parcel at 16 Kendall Street is zoned Tourist (T) District and is currently developed with a nonconforming, 10-unit overnight accommodation use. All existing improvements are planned to be demolished. While there is some existing on-site parking, there is existing parking that straddles the front property line along Avalon Street (partially on-site and partially within the right-of--way). There are City metered Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 2 of 14 • • parking lots to the west and north (across Avalon Street) of the subject property, as well as existing overnight accommodation uses. The Palm Pavilion restaurant and overnight accommodation use is to the south across Kendall Street. Existing development to the east of the subject property includes retail and a restaurant along 1l4andalay Avenue, overnight accommodation uses and a detached dwelling. Proposal: The proposal includes a request for Termination of Status of Nonconformity for the nonconforming density on the overall site. Based on current Land Use Category density limitations of 30 dwelling units per acre for residential uses, the overall subject site may be redeveloped with a maximum of 14 dwelling units. The two overnight accommodation uses at 15 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street currently total 15 overnight units/rooms. The applicant is requesting to terminate the nonconforming density for these two parcels in order to convert the 15 overnight units/rooms to 11 dwelling units, based on the 40/30 conversion factor. In addition, the seven dwellings on 21 - 27 Avalon Street calculate to an existing density of 35.175 dwelling units per acre. The applicant also requests to terminate the nonconforming density for these four parcels. Under the Termination of Status of Nonconformity calculations, when all conversions are factored in and all dwelling units are totaled, including the one dwelling unit at 17 Avalon Street, there are 19 units that could be placed on this site. The request is for only 15 dwelling units. Under the Termination of Status of Nonconformity provisions, there are four required improvements: 1. Installation of perimeter buffers. Perimeter buffers are not required in the Tourist District (southern portion of the property). On the northern portion of the property zoned MHDR District, the applicant is providing the required 10-foot wide landscape buffers along Avalon Street (with the exception of the dumpster staging area) and along the east and south sides of the property. The applicant is requesting to reduce the landscape buffer along the west side of the property from 10 feet to seven feet, which is adjacent to a City parking lot. 2. Improvement of off-street marking lots. The applicant is removing all existing improvements and is providing parking that meets Code provisions in the parking garage. 3. Removal of nonconforming signs outdoor lighting or other accessory structures. The applicant is removing all existing improvements. Any future signage will need to meet current Code provisions. 4. Use of Comprehensive Sign Program and Comprehensive Landscape Programs to satisfy requirements. The Comprehensive Sign Program is not available under the Code to residential properties. The applicant has submitted a Comprehensive Landscape Program to satisfy the requested reduction to the 10-foot landscape buffer requirement along the west side of the property (see discussion later in this Staff Report relating to landscape buffer reduction). As stated above, the proposal is to construct 15 dwelling units on the subject property, where under the Termination of Status of Nonconformity a total of 19 dwelling units could be requested. Based on current Land Use Category density limitations of 30 dwelling units per acre for residential uses, the overall subject site may be developed with a maximum of 14 dwelling units. Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 3 of 14 • • In light of the fact that the applicant is seeking to construct only one dwelling unit above that which is permitted under the Land Use Category density limitations and the 19 dwelling units potential under the Termination calculations, Staff supports the proposed 15 dwelling units. Additionally, this support is based on the provisions of Section 6-109.B that require the terminated density to be reconstructed on the same site. This provision does not allow for the future transfer of the remaining four dwelling units off-site to another site on the Beach through the Transfer of Development Rights provisions. Any approval of this request should include a condition regarding this restriction. It is noted that Staff's support of this means of calculating appropriate density for this project was based on a preference over the use of a Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) of one dwelling unit to this site (as requested in the prior request), where the TDR provisions allow for increased building height under certain circumstances. Reductions to lot area and lot width for attached dwellings are part of this proposal in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square feet (lot area) and from 100 feet to 50 feet (lot width). While these reductions have been advertised, and the reduction to lot area amounts to a 56.5 percent reduction in the T District, when viewed in light of the overall property the development concern is diminished. However, these reductions should be reviewed in light of setback reductions requested (see discussion below). The request is being processed as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District due to the height increase and setback reductions being requested to the building and dumpster staging area. The proposal includes reductions to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building) and from 25 feet to zero feet (to dumpster staging pad), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the rear (south - MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building) and a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building). In regard to the front setback reduction related to the trash staging area, the building will have refuse collection rooms on the ground floor within the parking garage. Dumpsters will be rolled out to the staging area on collection days. The location of the trash staging area within the front setback is necessary to eliminate the necessity of the trash truck coming on-site. Staff acknowledges that the reductions to the front setbacks from Avalon and Kendall Streets are similar to those reductions approved for the projects at 14 Somerset Street (FLD2002-09031, approved by the CDB on November 19, 2002) and 15 - 17 Somerset Street and 16 Cambria Street (FLD2004-01002/TDR2004-01006, approved by the CDB on June 15, 2004). The lot depth of 87 feet restricts site design, especially compliance with front and rear setback requirements. The prior request for the western portion of the subject property (FLD2004-08059/TDR2004-08008, denied by the CDB on November 16, 2004) requested a zero side setback on the west side of the property. With this request, the applicant has requested aseven-foot setback (to building) within the MHDR District and athree-foot setback (to building) in the T District, which is greater than the zero setback previously requested, but still less than the required 10-foot setback. While the abutting property to the west is a City parking lot, it should not be discounted as not being affected. The narrowness of this area on the west side of the proposed building affects the type and amount of Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 4 of 14 • • landscaping that can be placed within this area (see discussion below regarding site landscaping). The lot width reduction in the T District can be viewed as a contributing factor to the requested setback reductions. It is noted that the proposal complies with the required 10-foot side setback on the east side of the southern portion of the property zoned T District. It is further noted that the project at 12 Idlewild Street was "conceptually" approved last month by the CDB (this case is on this sa-me April 19, 2005, CDB agenda for inclusion of conditions of approval) with a side (north) setback of 5.9 feet (to building). Building Code provisions also restrict the amount of openings in the exterior wall based on how close the building is to the lot line. At between athree- to 10-foot setback, only 10 percent openings are allowed and 20 percent above a 10-foot setback. The applicant has indicated on the building elevations how the proposal meets these Building Code restrictions. Concurrent with the front setback reductions, this proposal includes reductions to the front landscape buffer along Avalon Street in the MHDR District from 10 feet to zero feet (to dumpster staging pad) and to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building). As with the front setback reduction requested, the location of the trash staging area within the front landscape buffer area is necessary to eliminate the necessity of the trash truck coming on-site. Site drainage has been designed to be located within a vault under the building, allowing the proposed setback areas to be fully usable for landscaping. The reductions on the west side, especially the three-foot area, restrict the amount and type of landscaping to buffer this side of the building. The landscaping proposed is an improvement over the plan denied by the CDB in November 2004. Primarily within the three-foot planting area the applicant proposes a hedge of silver buttonwood. Due to window and balcony locations on this west side, placement of appropriate landscape material and the size of the material are extremely important (so that views are not impaired). Any approval of this request should include a condition that the applicant work with City Staff to improve the landscaping, especially on the west side, to strategically place appropriately sized landscape material. The minimum size of palms (except pigmy date palms) must be 10 feet of clear trunk. The site today has some existing on-site parking spaces, but there is existing parking that straddles the front property line along Avalon Street (partially on-site and partially within the right-of--way). The applicant has advised that some guests of the existing overnight accommodation uses at 15 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street utilize parking spaces on the adjacent City parking lots to the west and/or to the north. The proposal is to eliminate all parking within the right-of--way and provide 24 parking spaces on-site (Code requirement is 1.5 spaces per unit or 23 spaces; proposal is at 1.6 spaces per unit): Parking will be provided within the ground level parking garage and will be fully screened from view by solid walls. The driveways on Avalon Street will not be gated, but will have sensors alerting residents that vehicles are entering the parking garage. The driveway on Kendall Street will be gated and will be an exit-only driveway. The proposal .includes constructing 15 attached dwellings (condominiums) in a building with five living floors over ground level parking. The proposal includes an increase to the building height from 30 feet (MHDR District) and 35 feet (T District) to 52.67 feet from the Base Flood Elevation (BFE) to the highest roof deck. The eastern portion of the building, which is for a pool, building and pool equipment roorr~s and clubhouse, is at a building height of 25.5 feet to the midpoint of the Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 5 of 14 ~ • pitched roof (from BFE). The site is located within the "Old Florida District" of Beach by Design where the preferred form of development includes low- to mid-rise new single-family dwellings and townhomes. The Planning Department has interpreted mid-rise as maximum of 50 feet based on the height standards in the Medium Density Residential (MDR), Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) and High Density Residential (HDR) districts. Beach by Design calls for renovation and revitalization of existing improvements with limited new construction where renovation is not practical within the "Old Florida District." The immediate vicinity is composed of attached dwellings and small motels and condominiums. Building styles generally resemble architecture from the 1950's and appear to have been progressively expanded. Two blocks to the north on the north side of Glendale Street and adjacent to undeveloped Beach Drive is a residential condominium building of five living floors over ground level parking. The Colony Surf Condominium building on the north side of Cambria Street is three living floors over ground level parking (approximately 35 feet in height [from BFE to roof deck]). Under construction on the north side of Somerset Street is a project by the same developers as this proposal (Chalets on White Sands residential condominiums) with five living floors over ground level parking at a height of 56 feet to the roof deck (FLD2002-09031, approved by the CDB on November 19, 2002). Between Somerset and Cambria Street is a project (Chateau on White Sands residential condominiums) approved by the CDB, but not yet under construction, in a building of five living floors over two floors of parking at an approved height of 61.66 feet to the roof deck (FLD2004-01002/TDR2004-01006, approved by the CDB on June 15, 2004). At their meeting on March 22, 2005, the CDB "conceptually" approved the project at 12 Idlewild Street (three streets to the north) at a building height of 64 feet (from BFE to the highest roof deck). It is also noted that the "LaRisa" project at 650 Bay Esplanade (Case No. FLD2002-09030, approved by the CDB on November 19, 2002) was approved with its highest roof deck at 69.5 feet above the BFE line (although only accounting for 57 percent of the total roof -other roof decks were at 58.5 feet above BFE [17.5 percent], 48 feet above BFE [18.1 percent] and 37.5 feet above BFE [7.4 percent]). While the proposal is not one of the preferred development types in this "Old Florida District," the proposed height of this building at 52.57 feet to the roof deck may be viewed as being consistent with building heights approved by the CDB in the "Old Florida District," and close to that interpreted by Staff as being "mid-rise" in height. The proposal includes a request to increase the height of perimeter parapets around the edge of the roof deck an additional 3.67 feet (from roof deck), where the Code permitted maximum is 30- inches. This increase maybe viewed as making the parapets proportional in respect to the height of the building and to aid in the screening of the rooftop air conditioning units. As indicated previously, the proposed building will have five living floors. Levels 2 - 6 are proposed with three units each, with units ranging between 2,730 and 3,800 square feet of living area. Level 2, separated from the residential portion of the building, provides areas on the east side of the building for pool and building equipment. Level 3, above the pool and building equipment rooms, is proposed with a pool and clubhouse. The southern units are oriented Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 6 of 14 • • north/south with a westerly view, while the northern and middle units are oriented east/west with views in all directions. Sidewalks will be constructed within the rights-of--way of both Avalon and Kendall Streets for pedestrian safety, where no sidewalks presently exist. Site drainage is proposed within a vault under the east side of the building. Engineering review of the drainage plans for this site indicates there may be insufficient capacity within the vault proposed. The vault may be required to be relocated to the west side of the building, due to sheer walls on the east side of the building, in order to enlarge it for additional capacity. Prior to the issuance of any permits, revised drainage plans and details, meeting the requirements of the Engineering Department, will need to be approved. The applicant is not proposing any signage at this time. It is noted that the Code does not provide the ability to request a Comprehensive Sign Program for a residential property. Future signage will need to meet the requirements of the Code and any future freestanding sign must be a monument-style sign a maximum four feet in height, designed to match the exterior materials and color of the building. Staff s support for this proposal is based on the reasons enumerated above. The proposal is compatible with the surrounding properties. The redevelopment of this site will improve the appearance of this site and the surrounding area. All applicable Code requirements and criteria including, but not limited to, General Applicability criteria (Section 3-913), Residential Infill Project criteria (Section 2-404.F) and Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project criteria (Section 2-803.C) have been met. Code Enforcement Analysis: There are no outstanding enforcement issues associated with this site. Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 7 of 14 • CnMPLIANCE WITH STANDARDS AND CRITERIA: (Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C): STANDARD PROPOSED CONSISTENT INCONSISTENT MAXIMUM 15 dwelling units (a) X* DENSITY (30 dwelling units per acre) (14 dwelling units maximum IMPERVIOUS 0.73 X SURFACE RATIO (ISR) (0.85 maximum - MHDR; 0.95 - T LOT AREA (For 0.498 acres; 21,729 square feet X* attached dwellings: 15,000 sq. feet minimum - MHDR; 10,000 sq. feet minimum - T LOT WIDTH (For North: 200 feet (150 feet in MHDR X* attached dwellings: and 50 feet in T) 150 feet minimum - South: 50 feet (T) MHDR; 100 feet - T FRONT SETBACK North: 10 feet (to building); zero feet X* (15-25 feet -MHDR; (to dumpster staging area); 0-15 feet - T South: 10 feet to building) REAR SETBACK 10 feet (MHDR and T) X* (10-15 feet -MHDR; 10-20 feet - T SIDE SETBACK East: 10 feet (to building) (MHDR & X* (0-10 feet -MHDR; 0- T) 10 feet - T) West: Seven feet in MHDR and three feet in T to building) HEIGHT (For 52.67 feet (to roof deck) with X* attached dwellings: perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from 30-50 feet maximum - roof deck) MHDR; 35-100 feet - T PARKING SPACES 24 spaces (1.6 spaces per unit) X (1.5 spaces per unit - attached dwellings; 23 s aces re uired (a) Includes the Termination of Status of Nonconformity for 15 existing overnight accommodation rooms, being converted to attached dwellings at a 40/30 ratio) for 11 units, plus the eight existing dwellings at 17 - 27 Avalon Street. Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 8 of 14 • * See discussion under Analysis. • COMPLIANCE WITH RESIDENTIAL INFILL PROJECT FLEXIBILITY CRITERIA (Section 2-404.F1: Consistent Inconsistent 1. The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for X development is otherwise economically impractical without deviations from the intensit and develo ment standards. 2. The development of the parcel proposed for development as a X residential infill project will not materially reduce the fair market value of abutting ro erties. 3. The uses within the residential infill project are otherwise permitted in X the district. 4. The uses within the residential infill project are compatible with X* ad' acent lands uses. 5. The development of the parcel proposed for development as a X* residential infill project will upgrade the immediate vicinity of the arcel ro osed for develo ment. 6. The design of the proposed residential infill project creates a form and X* function which enhances the community character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole. 7. Flexibility in regard to lot width, required setbacks, height and off- X* street parking are justified by the benefits to community character and the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole. Building height may only exceed 80 feet, however, if the parcel proposed for development fronts on Clearwater Bay or is only separated from Clearwater Bay by a public o ens ace. * See discussion under Analysis. Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 9 of 14 • • COMPLIANCE WITH COMPREHENSIVE INFILL REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT FT ,F.XTRTT ,TTY ('RTTF.RiA (Section 2-803.C1: Consistent Inconsistent 1. The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for X development is otherwise impractical without deviations from the use, intensit and develo ment standards. 2. The development of the parcel proposed for development as a X Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project will not reduce the fair market value of abuttin ro erties. 3. The uses within the Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project are X otherwise ermitted in the City of Clearwater. 4. The use or mix of uses within the Comprehensive Infill X* Redevelo ment Project are com atible with ad'acent land uses. 5. The development of the parcel proposed for development as a X* Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project will upgrade the immediate vicinit of the arcel ro osed for develo ment. 6. The design of the proposed Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment X* Project creates a form and function that enhances the community character of the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for develo ment and the Cit of Clearwater as a whole. 7. Flexibility in regard to lot width, required setbacks, height and off- X* street parking are justified by the benefits to community character and the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the Cit of Clearwater as a whole. 8. Adequate off-street parking in the immediate vicinity according to the X shared parking formula in Division 14 of Article 3 will be available to avoid on-street parking in the immediate vicinity of the parcel ro osed for develo ment. 9. The design of all buildings complies with the Tourist District design X* guidelines in Division 5 of Article 3. * See discussion under Analysis. Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 10 of 14 C] f nMPi.ielv~''F. wTTN fiFNF,RAi, STAN>nARDS (Section 3-9131: Consistent Inconsistent 1. Development of the land will be in harmony with the scale, bulk, ,~ coves e, densit and character of ad'acent ro erties. 2. Development will not hinder or discourage development and use of X ad'acent land and buildings or significantl im air the value thereof. 3. Development will not adversely affect the health or safety of persons X residing or working in the neighborhood. 4. Develo ment is desi ed to minimize traffic con estion. X 5. Development is consistent with the community character of the X* immediate vicinity. 6. Design of the proposed development minimizes adverse effects, X* including visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operation im acts on ad~acent ro erties. * See discussion under Analysis. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW: FINDINGS 1. The subject 0.498 acres is zoned Tourist District and is located within the "Old Florida District" of Beach by Design; 2. The current use of the site is for overnight accommodation uses totaling 15 rooms and a total of eight dwelling units, which is nonconforming to current density maximums; 3. Based on current Land Use Category density limitations of 30 dwelling units per acre, the overall subject site maybe redeveloped with a maximum of 14 dwelling units; 4. The applicant is deriving the proposed density through the Termination of Status of Nonconformity for the 15 hotel rooms at 15 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street, converted to 11 dwelling units, together with eight dwelling units on the remaining parcels, for a total of 19 dwelling units; 5. The applicant proposes to redevelop the entire site for 15 attached dwellings in a residential building 52.67 feet tall; 6. The future transfer of the remaining four dwelling units off-site to another site on the Beach through the Transfer of Development Rights provisions is prohibited under Section 6-109.B; 7. The lot depth of 87 feet restricts site design, especially compliance with front and rear setback requirements; 8. Reductions to setbacks to building and pavement proposed are similar to those approved for other projects within the Old Florida District west of Mandalay Avenue and represent improvements over that existing; 9. The proposed height of 52.67 feet is considered amid-rise development; Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 11 of 14 10. The proposal is compatible with the surrounding development, will enhance the character of the immediate vicinity and will improve the appearance of this site and the surrounding area.; and 11. There are no active code enforcement cases for the parcel. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW " 1. Staff concludes that the Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density complies with the criteria of Section 6-109; 2. Staff concludes that the proposal complies with the Flexible Development criteria as a Residential Infill Project per Section 2-2-404.F; 3. Staff concludes that the proposal complies with the Flexible Development criteria as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project per Section 2-803.C; 4. Staff further concludes that the proposal is in compliance with the General Applicability criteria per Section 3-913 and the other standards of the Code; 5. Staff concludes that the proposal complies with Beach by Design; and 6. Based on the above findings and proposed conditions, Staff recommends approval of this application. SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION: The Development Review Committee reviewed the application and supporting materials on March 3, 2005. The Planning Department recommends APPROVAL of the Flexible Development request for (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units, to be converted to 11 dwelling units, plus eight existing dwelling units), under the provisions of Section 6-109; (2) Flexible Development application to permit a total of 15 attached dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square feet, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 feet to 50 feet, reductions to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building) and from 25 feet to zero feet (to trash staging area), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south -MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 feet and in the T District from 35 feet to 52.67 feet (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Section 3-1202.G for the site at 15-27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street, with the following bases and conditions: Bases for Approval: 1. The proposal complies with the Flexible Development criteria as a Residential Infill Project per Section 2-404.F. Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 12 of 14 • • 2. The proposal complies with the Flexible Development criteria as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project per Section 2-803.C. 3. The proposal is in compliance with other standards in the Code including the General Applicability Criteria per Section 3-913. 4. The development is compatible with the surrounding area and will enhance other redevelopment efforts. 5. The proposal is in compliance with the Old Florida District of Beach by Design. Conditions of Approval: 1. That the final design and color of the building be consistent with the conceptual elevations submitted to, or as modified by, the CDB; 2. That, while the proposal totals 19 dwelling units through the Termination of Status of Nonconformity and only 15 dwelling units are proposed, the four remaining dwelling units cannot be constructed on-site and cannot be transferred off-site in the future; 3. That a Unity of Title be recorded in the public records prior to the issuance of any permits; 4. That, prior to the issuance of any permits, the stormwater treatment vault be enlarged and be designed to satisfy all City design and construction requirements; 5. That, prior to the issuance of any permits, additional planting materials be incorporated to the landscape design of this site, especially the west side, of an appropriate material and size, including the relationship to windows and balconies, acceptable to the Planning Department. The minimum size of palms (except pigmy date palms) must be 10 feet of clear trunk; 6. That future signage meet the requirements of the Code and any future freestanding sign be a monument-style sign a maximum four feet in height, designed to match the exterior materials and color of the building; 7. That any future storage units on the ground floor be used for storage only, in compliance with all Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA) rules and guidelines. Should such storage units be proposed and approved by Staff as a Minor Revision to this approval, evidence of this restriction of use, embodied in condominium documents, homeowner's documents, deed restrictions or like forms, shall be submitted to the Building Official prior to the issuance of the first Certificate of Occupancy; 8. That all proposed utilities (from the right-of--way to the proposed building) be placed underground. Conduits for the future undergrounding of existing utilities within the abutting right-of--way shall be installed along the entire site's street frontages prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. The applicant's representative shall coordinate the size and number of conduits with all affected utility providers (electric, phone, cable, etc.), with the exact location, size and number of conduits to be approved by the applicant's engineer and the City's Engineering Department prior to the commencement of work; 9. That a condominium plat be recorded prior to the issuance of the first Certificate of Occupancy; 10. That all Parks and Recreation fees be paid prior to the issuance of any permits; and 11. That all Fire Department requirements be met prior to the issuance of any permits. Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 13 of 14 • C: Prepared by: Planning Department Staff: ayne Wells, AICP, Planner III ATTACHMENTS Aerial Photograph of Site and Vicinity Location Map Future Land Use Map Zoning Atlas Map Application S:IPlnnning DepartmentlCD BIFLEX (FLD)IPending cnseslUp for the next CDBIAvalon IS Ambiance on White Sands #2 - (MHDR + 7) - 4.19.05 CDB - WWIAvalon 15 StaffReport.doc Staff Report -Community Development Board -April 19, 2005 Case FLD2005-01007 -Page 14 of 14 ~~ ~, 4 ^~~ ~~ q ~ ~~ sr - `~ ~~D DAP . ~~ o a ~. ~D ~CT W ~ z ~~ ~Y o~ a ~~ ACACIA Sf ~~ ~ PROJECT ~ o s~~ o ap ~ ~~ E O e~ caarnue ~ - ~~d~R F~'~ ' IffIL eAY .ML Z a ry Y~ g~ a~ a ~ BAY ppE N,p e~' o ~~ ADOtAMY ~ e~ ~~ BAYMOPf~ Sr `gyp ~iy( Va~ u~ a ~ j~$+ff /{yam O 9W ` F ~ ""Y pplllT ro ' PPPAY4A rSfg 7 ~ tl? Cpµ~ PAB9AC'E c £ `te'°° O (~uiewa Btve WNDNARD P E s 'R. FIASr sr ~ ooo ~~ Location Map Owner. Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC I Case: FLD2005-01007 Site: 15 - 27 Avalon Street Property 0.498 16 Kendall Street Size(Acresj: 05/29/15/16362/007/0050, PIN: /0060, /0070, /0071,/0080, /0081, /0140 Atlas Page: 258A • • '' ~ ~ rs " ~' }. ~ = NL ALL" ~' ~ ? ` * ~ ~~ ~ i .~~ ~ ~ - al'~,L'~'tl F ~ ~ f ~: ~J « r< I r ~- ' y + ~ ~ ~ _ :i , I J ` ~ ~ .~ ~ti ~~ ~ _ ~` ~ 1 v ~~ ,4 ,~ .. ~. j ~ '~ i11/~ ~~,.-+i v.a~s.,.... /~~~~1 'ii7 !'f I.~~~li~ r ... ... - t 1 Li[ ~ a, sir # ~ i. ! ~ a ^ ~ IL I'. ~ ~ ~k~ ~ ~ .. - .-. - .. . ,+ ' ~ v ~ . .., .. ,, .. _ . ~' ' ~' .# , t a r' ~ ~ L~ 1 . ~, *IaE s „ _ ,Yi, .:F ~T ~ ~ i~ ter' 't Z v ~~ x ,, `' Aerial Map Owner. I Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC ~ Case: FLD2005-01007 Site: 15 - 27 Avalon Street Property 0.498 16 Kendall Street Size(Acres): 05/29/15/16362/007/0050, PIN: /0060, /0070, /0071,/0080, /0081, /0140 Atlas Page: 258A • • I - / ~ I I I 1 I I 1 ~~ -~~ i~-_ f _I I f I 64~ I I- ~ Iv 1 ~ __ j Il I - ~u I I j t i ___-' ~\ I f r I ~~ I ~I 1~-~ I I i I---- I ~~ I m l ~ I I~ _I ~ I 1 ~~° I 1 I ~ " r-i 639 - _ ~ ~ --I 1 r ' ~ GLENDALE ST I ~ - ~' ~ `.. ROYAL ~----- -~~ _ -- --, 1V~1~~R ' __ _ I ~; 1,-,_' ~ ~ -- - I ~ I i r i I I I 1 ~ I"' I 6l9 I-- 4 ~~ : ~~ ~ -,__~ r 1 ~ f I I B32 ~,~ ~> ~ ~ - $ ~ ~ ~ ~ --1 81 i I ~ i ` % ~ nl ``~ ~ ~~~ -- P 1 ~ I ~ ~ 11 -~jl 1~ fl ~i22'I ` 822' A~iq I MADE ~ -' --I I i ~--I - r ° ' - I ,& ~ f 'I L^ 2 i I L f l ¢f 1 r i1tiLr o ~ m ~ I r~ ~ r--- - ///~~ I I r--- ~-, I ~r,',1 ~ ` _I F'~~i ~ I I I i ; C ~1 I f 1 ; I i ~ L 1 1 ~ - y --1 =tea' a _ ~ ~ I `Ln_I~ ~ ~ BOL.- f -~N i o I I- I -~~ ~3 I ~ 1 KENDALL ST I ~ t I p- ..~e~sva 1 1 I r I ~ i ~~ 1 I I 1 _ _____I I__ I ~ ~ I I 579 I __ L' I ~ 4. ~I 1 I I 1 L I I ~ , _ I I 804 ~ 1 fit' -- 5~0 5 5 I I _ 8 I i - ~ I I 1 I -~ ~ I i_~, 1 I I 1 I ~ I ~ I L__., ~ tl L 1 -- - f 1 o I m I~ ~ ~~ I I f~ I _ 1 I - j I _- I I - ~ _ 1 1-_ I L-- `--' `l / ~t ~ y OI // 1 ~ ` ~ .. \\'~ 532 Zoning Map Owner. ~ Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC + Case: FLD2005-01007 15 - 27 Avalon Street Property Site: 498 0 16 Kendall Street Size(AcresJ: . 05/29/15/16362/007/0050, PIN: /0060, /0070, /0071,/0080, /0081, /0140 Atlas Page: 258A u GLENDALE ST ~_--__-_~ T-------_ Attached ~v_~elln~ !~ , ~ ~- I ____ + ~ -- i j i ~ r-" ~ I Alf ~~~ I ~ Ili J ~ " Pad 'ng Lot ~~ ^~ ~ i m AVALON ST Q D 2 Q e~ 639 6za __ Q City Park z a 605 JUANITA WAY ~~v ig~t~ 5Bi ~ i 604 ~? 5, <<_, BAY ESPLANADE ~, a City Park ROYAL WAY Ut~i Parking Lot 532 Existing Surrounding Uses Map nt bl 70 C N C m Owner. Panorama on Clearwater Beach, LLC Case: FLD2OO5-01007 Site: I 15 - 27 Avalon Street (Property 0.498 16 Kendall Street Size(Acres): 05/29/15/16362/007/0050, PIN: /0060, /0070, !0071,/0080, /0081, !0140 Atlas Page: 258A --~ ~, I r-----I 1_ ' ~Oln. i I I ~ , ~ I ' taura ~ t I Ga~° N ~a~iQ View looking north at existing overnight accommodation building at 16 Kendall Street ,~ ~-- ~` 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street FLD2005-01007 Page 1 of 3 View looking southeast at 17 Avalon Street View looking southeast at existing overnight accommodation building at 15 Avalon Street View looking southwest at g~.~b~ect gropertg~ on south side of Avalon Street View looking southeast at 21 - 27 Avalon Street View looking N along common property line between Citv narking lot & W side of 16 Kendall S~ parking lot west of subject property 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street FLD2005-01007 Page 2 of 3 View looking northwest at motels on north side of View looking south at commercial uses at SW View looking north at attached dwellings & motels View looking northwest at City parking lot on View looking northwest from Kendall Street at City parking lot and beach beyond west of subject property View looking north from Kendall Street at City 15 - 27 Avalon Street and 16 Kendall Street FLD2005-01007 Page 3 of 3 View looking southeast at existing Palm Pavilion View looking southwest at Palm Pavilion restaurant on south side of Kendall Street View looking northeast at existing detached dwelling & motels on north side of Kendall Street • • Wells, Wayne From: Rice, Scott Sent: Thursday, April 14, 2005 1:16 PM To: 'rkelley@northsideengineering.com' Cc: Barker, Brian A.; Wells, Wayne Subject: FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Rich, Based upon our meeting of April 13, 2005, it is understood that stormwater treatment for the subject project will be revised including expanding the vault and relocating it to beneath the northwestern portion of the building. To allow for review of the proposed redesign, at building permit the proposed storm drainage design and calculations shall be revised in accordance with the following: 1. Provide drainage basin delineation to show pre- and post-construction drainage patterns. Discharge to Mandalay shall be limited to preconstruction flowrate. 2. Provide the size/type of pipe on Mandalay that the site will drain into. 3. Provide additional topography to demonstrate that City owned facilities will not be impacted during the construction of the stormwater outfall pipe. 4. The storm pipe constructed in the ROW needs to meet City standards. 5. Demonstrate how site runoff will be directed to the vault. 6. Provide revised drainage calculations and vault design These requirements will be included in a general condition of approval for submittal to the CDB. If you have any questions please contact me. D. Scott Rice Land Devel. Engr. Manager 727-562-4781 scott.rice@MyClearwater.com • • Wells, Wayne From: Rice, Scott Sent: Tuesday, April 12, 2005 2:59 PM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: Barker, Brian A.; Faessler, Heather Subject: FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Wayne, See following comments regarding the revised stormwater system: The City's Storm Drainage Design Criteria does not allow water quality treatment (1/2" runoff over redeveloped site) in underground vaults unless specifically allowed by the City Engineer. Prior to CDB, provide justification for the use of a vault to allow consideration by City staff: 4/11/05 This site has changed dramatically from original submittal. Comments on revised submittal are: 1. Discharge point for pond/vault has changed from original submittal. Provide drainage basin delineation to show pre- and post-construction drainage patterns. 2. If discharge point from site is being re-directed to Mandalay Avenue, evaluate the capacity of the receiving pipe on Mandalay. 3. Provide the size/type of pipe on Mandalay that the site will tie into. 4. Additional topography is necessary to determine what City owned facilities will be impacted during the construction of the stormwater outfall pipe. 5. The storm pipe constructed in the ROW needs to meet City standards. This needs to be reflected on the plans. 6. It is unclear how runoff will be directed to the vault and it appears adjacent property may be affect. These issues need to be addressed prior to CDB. D. Scott Rice Land Devel. Engr. Manager 727-562-4781 scott.rice@MyClearwater. com • Wells, Wayne From: Rice, Scott Sent: Wednesday, April 13, 2005 1:51 PM To: Wells, Wayne; Barker, Brian A. Subject: FW: FLD2OO5-01007 - 15 Avalon i cannot spell. D. Scott Rice Land Devel. Engr. Manager 727-562-4781 scott.rice@MyClearwater. com -----Original Message----- From: Rice, Scott Sent: Wednesday, April 13, 2005 1:49 PM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: Barker, Brian A. Subject: FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Wayne, Engineering has completed review of the subject application and updated Permit Plan. The following should be conditions of approval: Prior to building permit, the stormwater treatment vault shall be enlarged and shall be designed to satisfy all City design and construction requirements. Transportation Impact Fees to be determined and paid prior to C.O. D. Scott Rice Land Devel. Engr. Manager 727-562-4781 scott.rice@MyClearwater.com • • Wells, Wayne From: Rice, Scott Sent: Wednesday, April 13, 2005 1:49 PM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: Barker, Brian A. Subject: FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Wayne, Engineering has completed review of the subject application and updated Permit Plan. The following should be conditions of approval: Prior to building permit, the stormwater treatment vault shall be enlarged and shall be designed to satisfy all City design and contraction requirements. Transportation Impact Fees to be determined and paid prior to C.O. D. Scott Rice Land Devel. Engr, Manager 727-562-4781 scott.rice@MyClearwater.com • D1007 ?~s•t~ AwJM 5~.+ ~~ l~..i.~ll X. ~ _ • 249A 2498 ~ CITY OF CLEARWATER q t9 >1 > 7 'O q t2 nr S As7ER $1REET ~S eo ~ Itgr AND VICINITY FLORIDA ELLAS COUNTY ~~ >t6 tJ nv eD fB eB m 3 13 +m 7 3 6 to 7 ' . PIN ~ 1~r ` rm +l'> -6 9 ~ ~> e ~ ~ e _ ~ PflEPARED BY yD ~ ~~ DNiN1STRATION >ae 21 6 n 2 74>pq ~ >B9 >ti +aB Lp PUBLiC WORKS A ~ ~ i ENDINEEAIND Y ~' ~ ,rob 5 >Je ~ >IB 2 a t2 5 pp ~ 100 S N 11e Ave., pemxoter, Fl 33756 (~ ;~ I d nt ~ >pri 23 ~f D16 15+88 ;~5 3 1 ~l2 a 4 7 eyl `- Pn: 1727)562-6750. Fox: (727)526-1755 Fr1 ~ I J W $22 ~ 1 a~: N- ~ 'ro 11 lA n1lfA llrmw•d¢erWOitr-B.COm~C11yJ1eP0r1meD19IDUDlfe-WOrk9/nnglneerl 1~~ 3 '[a ACApA STREET .`? 3 ~ ~ pVy Duel Amer: 2 >pa fj & $ $ n a ~.o ° 0 7 2 , 1 W PuDPC Informolton dolo Is turnlsnetl Dy the pty of p¢orwater t d F 2 4 3 1 t a ~ - Iw 10 9 B 6 15 a', 3 2 ~; cat" 1 e PYDII< Work9 Atlmtn191ratbn~EngboMlnq, and mull De occep 81- and used DY the redDlenl wllh the underat¢nd41g 1Dat Ue dpla 1 > eea . eoeJVed vas callecled for the purpou f tlevelopklq o grapnlc I y~ ~ 3 a 5 CON Bre ~ dog 2 9 8 7 6 5 4 3S a2 ~ ~~ 1 'i frostruNUre Inventory. N auto, the CRy Oi Cleor.vpler PWA/E oxen no xpmantlea, ¢nDreae¢tl or ImOtletl eanceming ine of tnb dote ror tldDilR l l ll $ !l- ~ bat ~ AB , $ b Q°m ~ 1 ~ y y. or ay aD l ~ arcurpey. comDlelmeaa, rN D y ocher DDr1i<vlar vae. FurlMrmore M< City of Clnrwaler ~ I $ 5Ut4ER5E7 g c e & _- ,; I se PWA/E Dnsumea no IbDlllly wDOlaaever esgociofetl wllh Ine u rd J;~ misuse of auto Beta 3 d S 6 7 8 9 14 1 1 10 ~ ? Bw10 ti ~ m ~ ~ ~ ~ 13 ~ ee n ee> G+~ , '~i,`[yA ~~ Tnla Allas page Ja auD~¢1 [o P<rlDdk enang<e. m¢tlen oeoul loleal revlnlona peoae toll PwA/E or I f "K a F 1 t 9 I 12 e+t BBa 5 6 ¢e6 ~ tas 12 ~ n or a vfalt our Weo all e. ,J I cAMBRIA sr g p e t3BBt ` eeJ a P6 OUSB roc,. - _.SNORES -'~ e ~ ~ I N ,.\ j~ I ~8 a s 6 7~ 6 e9 1 e e A L1W ~ON00 ,~ kO,rt1,. e+7 u ~ 3' CONDO. . I \ ,1 i N 4 13 1 it 10 Ba esl 15EN ~{ 2 73 11 ~-69 ~ \~ 1 $ $ $ g IOIEWILO S7 S 13 O Qe ~ i6 Ba0 ~ 1 ~ t2 .6DD ea9 8 g ~ 5.17 we, 7 0 700 200 400 600 I ~ $U B CO 6 6 70- R Y 3 X18 efe ~ 9y 0a to 8 ~ ~ I I 14 t3 1 11 10 ey 3 a 8 ~ D t ~ ~ 2 Sao SCALE: 1" 400' 8 @ $ q. E 97 4 _ 1 ~ .,. 20eae e4e 1 AS~OF CLW, sROYA<I m wAY LEGEND: I B A CON ePB1 9 73 I I P so-118 7R g 0 MEM1N000 T 2 oat ed e72 ~1t f0 9 .B li 3 ° 7 ~ I O BLOCK NUMBER • THE CAY T ' a g~ e $ A ;a~ B ear a, a °~ $ °'~ a ' ~ P ~ 1234 LOT ADDRESS CLW, BEA H r ~ 3+ s 6 7 6 e " nt ESPLANADE g 5 ~ ~~~~- CITY LIMITS LINE 1$ CONDO 11 - I BJ s 11 10 - -- en 6° r0' ~ it e~ - eet. 5. 13 6 Q~ I ~, 1 xm 99e $A $ ~ t q 766 •r ~ H ~ a ~ I r-.-7 SHADED AREA -PROPERTY I B AY N aB a¢e eN ~ ea: 1;De ~ L'=~J OUTSIDE CLEARWATER CITY LIMITS ~ ~~c[ ~ 6 a1 °0 ~ p0e 6da + 2 ~ ~ I • AGREEMENT TO ANNEX 2 1 t d 3 14 ee ' e03 ~~ ~i 3 e01 9e t I ~ t U $ e A ~ ~• ee ~m yA 6 aeo 9~" • CITY OWNED PROPERTY I I e a13~ A D° tfi ~ e0 '. 1 I MDR ZONING DESIGNATION \ rv3 d 5 - 6 9 2 .a < e n s ~ ~ SV 1~• ee t7By6','; 3 D (1c~ ZONE UNE T/~ t 75 14 11~ 11 10 ,'~ 7 6 e> tBeee 3 Isar r ~ a .7~1 I v1 C.J g ,p , s a 19 5 I O 6~ BAY ~ I A[mN[aaD I lap ~/ ~ „ Pa nri71 ~ I p 6m 1p/p1/e> ~~ ~416N 0.EARWATER BEACH R£C: COMPLEXO C / ~ meslx lxnxrol b 9 Bab • 33/07 A.7 ~ MANDALAY • 0.endd~ P4> y D. 101-Jta PARK t ~ S oeD.ln,>ae-aJ DA a+- of Y I I ~ ~ P ~ s 1 6 D Q ROCKAWAV $ 97REET 6o M1 a ~ $ ~ .~ c COPP[CTiq! 09/x6/9x 5 BELLE HARBOR I Y _ ~ et. ~ 1 10 9 6 7 ® 1 ~ I REVISED: 002 2 1 sa b - lb 12 09/09/2 - - _ - B , vc Da. the-J+a ~ ~ K 9~ i4TLAS ZONING T 100 e¢D epJ oN Q /~ sW ~ 5 ~ /'~ 2678 ~ 5 - 29 S - 15 E • • 267A FLD~aeS • • • s Wells, Wayne From: Rice, Scott Sent: Monday, March 14, 2005 10:51 AM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: Elbo, Bennett Subject: FLD2005-01007 - 15 Avalon Wayne, There are Traffic Engineering concerns outstanding on this application: 1. Parking spaces numbered 16, 17, 21, and 22 have limited site visibility, please demonstrate how these spaces comply with Community Development Code Section 3-1402.A. 3/14/05 -APPLICANT RESPONSE IS THAT MIRRORS WILL BE USED. MIRRORS NOT SHOWN ON PLANS. APPLICANT MUST DEMONSTRATE HOW MIRROR WILL PROVIDE ENHANCED VISIBILITY FOR PARKING SPACES 16 AND 17. 2. Show angle (in degrees) for the angled parking spaces. All parking spaces must comply with City standard dimensions (Community Development Code Section 3-1402). 3/14/05 -PARKING SPACES NOT PER CODE. 45-DEGREE SPACES REQUIRE A DEPTH OF 19.8-FEET PERPENDICULAR TO THE DRIVE AISLE. THE DEPTH SHOWN ON THE PLANS IS 18-FEET. The above to be addressed prior to CDB. There is still a Traffic HOLD on this case in Permit Plan. D. Scott Rice Land Devel. Engr. Manager 727-562-4781 scott.rice@MyClearwater.com • • ,~~ Wells, Wayne From: Albee, Rick Sent: Tuesday, March 15, 2005 8:4.7 AM To: Watkins, Sherry; Planning Subject: RE: resubmittals for April 19, 2005 CDB Meeting I reviewed al! eases and updated aN conditions in Permit Plan. 430 Gulfview- No Issues. 15 Avalon- Condition Met. . 715 Gulfview- No Issues. 2520 Sunset Point Rd- No Issues. 830 Bayway- Condition #20 was not met, changed requirement to be submitted at Building Permit. 665 Bay Esplanade- No Issues. 200 Skiff Point- Condition Met. 600 Bayway- No Issues. -----Original Message----- From: Watkins, Sherry Sent: Thursday, March 10, 2005 3:09 PM To: Planning Subject: FW: resubmittals for April 19, 2005 CDB Meeting April 19 CDB -----Original Message----- From: Parry, Mark Sent: Thursday, March 10, 2005 2:23 PM To: Watkins, Sherry Subject: RE: resubmittals for April 19, 2005 CDB Meeting I believe that would be the April 19 CDB Mark T. Parry Planner III City of Clearwater Planning Department 727.562.4558 mark.parry@myclearwater.com -----Original Message----- From: Watkins, Sherry Sent: Thursday, March 10, 2005 1:41 PM To: Plarining Subject: resubmittals for April 19, 2005 CDB Meeting Importance: High Good Afternoon Everyone, Today was resubmittal date for the April 15, 2005 CDB Meeting. Here is a list of cases with planners for you all. Alissa and I will be date stamping these cases and will get them to you as quickly as we can. Have a Great Day! Sherry Watkins Planning Department Administrative Analyst 1. FLD2005-01005,SGN2005-01016 & Comp Landscape Adams Mark Hotel - 430 S Gullfview (Planner: Wayne Wells) 2. FLD2005-01007 & Comp Landscape -Ambiance on White Sands - 15 Avalon (Planner: Wayne Wells) 3. FLD2005-01016, TDR2005-01017 & Comp Landscape - Sunspree - 715 S. Gulfview Blvd (Planner: Wayne Wells) • `~z 4. FLD2004-02011A, PLT2004-00007 - Townhome Manors - 2520 Sunset Point Road (Planner: Mike Reynolds) 5. FLD2005-01008 - Clearwater Yacht Club - 830 Bayway Blvd (Planner: Marc Mariano) 6. FLD2005-01009 -Robert Pennock - 665 Bay Esplanade (Planner: Marc Mariano) 7. FLD2005-01012 & Comp Landscape - 200 Skiff Point (Planner: Marc Mariano) 8. FLD2005-01010 -Bay Harbor - 600 Bayway Blvd - (Planner: John Schodtler) • • Wells, Wayne From: Watkins, Sherry Sent: Tuesday, March 15, 2005 4:25 PM To: DRC Members Subject: Resubmittals for April 19 Importance: High Good Afternoon DRC Members Plans for the following cases have been resubmitted for the April 19, 2005, CDB meeting: have placed one copy of the case resubmitted package on the cabinets outside of Room 216 in our office for your review (please do not take it, as we need it for the CDB mail out). Please review your comments/conditions for this case in Permit Plan and determine if they are met. Whether the conditions are "met" or still "not met," please affirm to me via email. Please have these cases reviewed, if possible by 4:00 pm on Wednesday, March 16, 2005. 1. FLD2005-01005,SGN2005-01016 & Comp Landscape Adams Mark Hotel - 430 S Gullfview (Planner: Wayne Wells) 2. FLD2005-01007 & Comp Landscape -Ambiance on White Sands - 15 Avalon (Planner: Wayne Wells) 3. FLD2005-01016, TDR2005-01017 & Comp Landscape - Sunspree - 715 S. Gulfview Blvd (Planner: Wayne Wells) 4. FLD2004-02011A, PLT2004-00007 - Townhome Manors - 2520 Sunset Point Road (Planner: Mike Reynolds) 5. FLD2005-01008 - Clearwater Yacht Club - 830 Bayway Blvd (Planner: Marc Mariano) 6. FLD2005-01009 -Robert Pennock - 665 Bay Esplanade (Planner: Marc Mariano) 7. FLD2005-01012 & Comp Landscape - 200 Skiff Point (Planner: Marc Mariano) 8. FLD2005-01010 -Bay Harbor - 600 Bayway Blvd - (Planner: John Schodtler) 9. FLD2004-02015 - 483 Mandalay Avue (Planner Wayne Wells) • Wells, Wayne From: Watkins, Sherry Sent: Thursday, March 10, 2005 3:09 PM To: Planning Subject: FW: resubmittals for April 19, 2005 CDB Meeting April 19 CDB -----Original Message----- From: Parry, Mark Sent: Thursday, March 10, 2005 2:23 PM To: Watkins, Sherry Subject: RE: resubmittals for April 19, 2005 CDB Meeting I believe that would be the April 19 CDB Mark T. Parry Planner III City of Clearwater Planning Department 727.562.4558 mark.parry@myclearwater.com -----Original Message----- From: Watkins, Sherry Sent: Thursday, March 10, 2005 1:41 PM To: Planning Subject: resubmittals for April 19, 2005 CDB Meeting Importance: High Good Afternoon Everyone, Today was resubmittal date for the April 15, 2005 CDB Meeting. Here is a list of cases with planners for you all. Alissa and I will be date stamping these cases and will get them to you as quickly as we can. Have a Great Day! Sherry Watkins Planning Department Administrative Analyst 1. FLD2005-01005,SGN2005-01016 & Comp Landscape Adams Mark Hotel - 430 S Gullfview (Planner: Wayne Wells) 2. FLD2005-01007 & Comp Landscape -Ambiance on White Sands - 15 Avalon (Planner: Wayne Wells) 3. FLD2005-01016, TDR2005-01017 & Comp Landscape - Sunspree - 715 S. Gulfview Blvd (Planner: Wayne Wells) 4. FLD2004-02011A, PLT2004-00007 - Townhome Manors - 2520 Sunset Point Road (Planner: Mike Reynolds) 5. FLD2005-01008 - Clearwater Yacht Club - 830 Bayway Blvd (Planner: Marc Mariano) 6. FLD2005-01009 -Robert Pennock - 665 Bay Esplanade (Planner: Marc Mariano) 7. FLD2005-01012 & Comp Landscape - 200 Skiff Point (Planner: Marc Mariano) 8. FLD2005-01010 -Bay Harbor - 600 Bayway Blvd - (Planner: John Schodtler) • __ • ~~ ~~ 2:00 pm Case Number: FLD2005-01007 15 AVALON ST Owner(s): Panorama On Clearwater Beach, Llc ~ a~ O~ 483 Mandalay Avenue 209 ~ ~ Clearwater, F133767 TELEPHONE: 727-461-7786, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No Email I~%~ Applicant Panorama On Clearwater Beach, Llc 483 Mandalay Avenue 209 Clearwater, F133767 TELEPHONE: 727-461-7786, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No Email ~~ Representative: Northside Engineering Services Inc. . 601 Cleveland Street Clearwater, F133755 TELEPHONE: 727-443-2869, FAX: 727-446-8036, E-MAIL: debra@northsideengineering.com Location: 0.498 acres located between Avalon Street and Kendall Street, approximately 100 feet west of Mandalay Avenue. Atlas Page: 258A Zoning District: T, Tourist Request: (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units - to be converted to 11 dwelling units), under the provisions of Section 6-109; (2) Flexible Development approval to permit a total of 15 attached dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square feet, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 feet to 50 feet, a reduction to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south -MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 feet and in the T District from 35 feet to 55 feet (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from roof deck) and to permit a building within the visibility triangles, as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Section 3-1202.G. Proposed Use: Attached dwellings Neighborhood Clearwater Neighborhoods Coalition Association(s): Clearwater, Fl 33761 2544 Frisco Drive TELEPHONE: 727-725-3345, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: Djw@gte.net Neighborhood Clearwater Beach Association Association(s): Clearwater, F133767 100 Devon Dr TELEPHONE: 443-2168, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: papamurphy@aol.com Neighborhood Coral Resort Condominum Association(s): Clearwater, Fl 33767 483 E Shore Drive TELEPHONE: 727-446-3711, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: cora1483@aol.com Presenter: Wayne Wells, Planner III Attendees Included: City Staff: Wayne Wells, Mark Parry, Scott Rice, Ann Blackburn Applicant/Rep.: Doreen Williams, John Marshall Scott, Anjania Abhyankar, Kalpesh Patel, Rich Kelly, Ed Hooper The DRC reviewed this application with the following comments: General Engineering: Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 23 1) Site plans shalsigned and sealed by a registered (State of F1oTda) ' professional engineer (Florida Administrative Code 61G15-23.002). 3/4/05 -PLANNING HAS SEALED PLANS 2) Is the installation of doghouse manhole required when sanitary lateral appears to be available at nearly same location (190 ft. west of manhole in Mandalay Ave.)? 3) If required, doghouse manhole is to be placed on top of a precast or poured in place slab. 4) New 5 ft. sidewalk shall be constructed in Kendall Street right-of--way per City standards. 5) Double detector check valve with bypass meter shall be required for any internal fire protection line. (Clearwater Ordinance 32.103). ,. 6) details on Sheet C5. I not per City standards. All of the above to be addressed prior to CDB. The following to be addressed prior to building permit: 1) A separate right-of--way permit is required for manhole installation in Avalon Street. Contact Don Melone (727.562.4798) for permit information. 2) Fire hydrant lines/fire sprinkler lines shall be constructed of 6-inch diameter ductile iron pipe (Clearwater Contract Specifications and Standards, Article 41). General Note: DRC review is a prerequisite for Building Permit Review, additional comments maybe forthcoming upon submittal of a Building Permit Application. Environmental: 1 . No Issues. Fire: 1 . This DRC Review by Fire is not an approval or review of any construction plans or documents other than site work. 2 . Fire Hydrant at S.W. corner of the property appears to be behind a block wall. The Fire Hydrant and FDC must remain accessible from the street, unobstructed by fences, walls, shrubbery, etc. Please acknowledge PRIOR TO CDB. Harbor Master: 1 . No issues. Legal: 1 . No issues. Land Resources: 1 . Show to be removed the 21" palm trtee in the retention pond prior to building permit. Landscaping: 1 . Provide ALL the utilities on the landscape plan to avoid conflicts with proposed plant materials. 2 . Plan does not meet the requirements of perimeter plantings in Code Section 3-1202.D. Revise accordingly or submit a Comprehensive Landscape application as required. 3 . The plans show a multitude of palms on the west side of the building where balconies and windows will be obstructed. If this is the proposed plan that is approved, it will be the plan that will be required at bbuilding permit application and completion for certificate of occupancy. Consideration should be made as to location of the materials proposed and the impact of those materials. 4 , The area between the building and the property line for landscape will not be sufficient for some of the proposed palms. Consider an automated parking system to allow for more open space on this parcel as they do not require the drive isles. Parks and Recreation: 1 . Recreation Facility impact fees of $650 is due for 3.25 net new units prior to issuance of building permits or final plat (if applicable) whichever occurs first. Contact Art Kader at 727-562-4824. Stormwater: 1 . 1. It appears that the runoff coefficient for the site was incorrectly calculated. Please revise. 2. It is difficult to read existing grades on the east side of the site. Therefore, cannot verify that offsite runoff is not entering the property. Suggest seperating the Utility sheet from the Paving, Grading & Drainage sheet for legibility. 3. Change outfall location to spill over into driveway instead of onto the sidewalk. These issues need to be addressed prior to CDB. Solid Waste: 1 . Dumpsters and recycling containers are to be staged by on site maintenance personel Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 24 • • Traffic Engineering: 1 . 1. Parking spaces numbered 16, 17, 21, and 22 have limited site visibility, please demonstrate how these spaces comply with Community Development Code Section 3-1402.A. 2. Show angle (in degrees) for the angled parking spaces. All parking spaces must comply with City standard dimensions (Community Development Code Section 3-1402). The above to be addressed prior to CDB. Planning: 1. General note: Transportation Impact Fees to be determined and paid prior to C.O. Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 25 1 . Proposal is for atted dwellings (condominium flats) in the Old Florida District of Beach by Design. Single family dwellings and townhomes are the preferred form of development in the Old Florida District. Additionally, the proposed building exceeds 50 feet in height, which staff is deeming to be the maximum height for mid-rise buildings. Staff cannot support the proposal. 2 . 3/3/05 - WW The proposal is to pemit 15 attached dwellings. Based on a calculation of 30 du/acre, 14 dwelling units maximum can be requested. The proposal is currently only requesting the Termination of Status of Nonconformity for the existing overnight accommodation uses of 15 rooms. Application should be amended to request Termination of all units on the property, including the existing dwelling units. If amended, and based on Section 6-109.B, reconstruction of any Terminated density may only be on the same parcel (ie: no future transferring off of unused dwelling units to other parcels). 2/20/05 - WW Staff will not support the requested Termination of Status of Nonconformity, as it produces an excess number of dwelling units. Proposal indicates that the excess units are intended to be sold off (additional profit, over and above what.is necessary to construct the project). Alternately, use the norma130 dwelling units per acre and a Transfer of Development Rights to this site of one unit. 3 . Revise the survey to add Lot 5 into the legal description. 4 . Revise Sheet C 1.1 for the legal description to indicate all lots that are part of this request (Lots 5,6,7,8 + 14). 5 . Revise Sheet C3.1 to reduce the amount of concrete sidewalk at the south end of the building. 6 . Unclear why a double door entrance is necessary on south side of the building on Kendall Street, since this is primarily an exit. It is also unclear the need for the double door when there will be a beautiful DCVA right outside the door (see Sheet C4.1). 7 . Unclear as to reason for the pedestrian door on the northwest corner of the building, since it goes out into landscaping. 8 . Sheet C3.1 -unclear how the western "assigned storage" will be laid out to provide a safe means for the residents to obtain access to them with the major entrance drive aisle adjacent to it. Provide layout. 9 . Dimension the drive aisle backup area south of spaces 13-16. 10 . Unclear how the dumpsters will be moved to the trash staging area in the front yard on Avalon Street. Suggest switching the location of the trash staging area and the retention pond. 11 . Indicate southern stairs on Sheet C3.1. 12 . Unclear how there is sufficient room to plant landscaping along the edge of the retention pond when the planting area is only one-foot wide. Also, unclear how the root balls for the trees will be planted with the slope of the retention pond in mind. Provide details of such planting on the slope. Provide narrative as to how such plantings will not reduce the drainage capacity once constructed and how the mulch will stay around the plantings without being washed away. 13 . Based on the clear trunk lengths indicated for the proposed trees, it appears that most views from the first floor units will be blocked. 14 . Explain how the proposed palms will be planted and how they will grow and be maintained within the three-foot area on the west side of the building. Would appear that the fronds will scrape the building. 15 . Sheet L1.1 -retention area incorrectly shown on the northwest comer of the building. 16 . Provide the angle of parking spaces 22-24. 17 . Sheet C4.1 -unclear if Section A-A is typical for all retention areas, including the north side of the building. 18 . Sheet I1.1 -does it make sense to have the irrigation lines and heads in the bottom of the retention ponds? 19 . Sheet A-1 -where does door between the southern elevator and southern stairwell go to, since outside the building is a two-foot drop into a retention pond? 20 . Sheets A2, A7 + A8 -provide dimension of balcony projections. 21 . Sheets A7 + A8 -clubhouse arches and medallions are out of character with the architecture of the main building. Revise. 22 . Sheets A7 + A8 -indicate the proposed exterior building finishes and colors of all architectural elements. 23 . Sheets A7 + A8 -provide the height dimension for the clubhouse to the midpoint of the pitched roof. 24 . Provide the location of the a/c units, including the clubhouse. Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 26 25 . Sheet A 1 -provide the dimension of the entry overhang from the fa• f the north side of the building. 26 . Sheets A 1 + A7 -explain the purpose of the window in the "assigned storage" area on the north side of the building. Provide a layout of the "assigned storage" area. 27 . Add vertical banding to reduce the blandness of large expanses of flat walls (all sides). 28 . Sheet A8 -roof line wrong. Suggest additional balustrades at north and south ends of west elevation, much like the north elevation. 29 . Colors provided of exterior of the building is white, while the perspective colored drawing appears to be in the pink. colors.. 30 . Staff cannot support the proposed reductions to the west setbacks and the west landscape buffer. Other: No Comments Notes: To be placed on the 4/19/05 CDB agenda, submit 15 collated copies of the revised plans & application material addressing all above departments' comments by noon, 3/10/05. Packets shall be collated, folded and stapled as appropriate. Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 27 2:00 pm Representative: Northside Engmeenng Services Inc. ~ ~ D n~ Case Number: FLD2005-01007 -- 15 AVALON ST Owner(s)• Panorama On Clearwater Beach, Llc ~ ` ~ . O 483 Mandalay Avenue 209 Clearwater, F133767 TELEPHONE: 727-461-7786, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No Email Applicant Panorama On Clearwater Beach, Llc 483 Mandalay Avenue 209 ~~~ Clearwater, F133767 TELEPHONE: 727-461-7786, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No Email 601 Cleveland Street Clearwater, Fl 33755 TELEPHONE: 727-443-2869, FAX: 727-446-8036, E-MAIL: debra@northsideengineering.com Location: 0.498 acres located between Avalon Street and Kendall Street, approximately 100 feet west of Mandalay Avenue. Atlas Page: 258A Zoning District: T, Tourist Request: (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units - to be converted to 11 dwelling units), under the provisions of Section 6-109; (2) Flexible Development approval to permit a total of 15 attached dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 square feet to 4,350 square feet, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 feet to 50 feet, a reduction to the front (north along Avalon Street -MHDR District) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall Street - T District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west -MHDR District) from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 feet to three feet (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south -MHDR District) from 15 feet to 10 feet (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 feet and in the T District from 35 feet to 55 feet (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 feet (from roof deck) and to permit a building within the visibility triangles, as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Sections 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 feet to seven feet (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Section 3-1202.G. Proposed Use: Attached dwellings Neighborhood Clearwater Neighborhoods Coalition Association(s): Clearwater, F133761 2544 Frisco Drive TELEPHONE: 727-725-3345, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: Djw@gte.net Neighborhood Clearwater Beach Association Association(s): Clearwater, F133767 100 Devon Dr TELEPHONE: 443-2168, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: papamurphy@aol.com Neighborhood Coral Resort Condominum Association(s): Clearwater, F133767 483 E Shore Drive TELEPHONE: 727-446-3711, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: cora1483@aol.com Presenter: Wayne Wells, Planner III Attendees Included: City Staff: Wayne Wells, Mark Parry, Scott Rice, Ann Blackburn Applicant/Rep.: Housh Ghovaee, Doreen Williams, John Marshall Scott, Anjania Abhyankar, Peter Govetoso, Kalpesh Patel, Jack Diberardino, Roger Larson The DRC reviewed this application with the following comments: General Engineering: Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 25 • 1 , 1) Site plans shall be signed and sealed by a registered (State of Flor•) professional engineer (Florida Administrative Code 61G15-23.002). 2) Is the installation of doghouse manhole required when sanitary lateral appears to be available at nearly same location (190 ft. west of manhole in Mandalay Ave.)? 3) If required, doghouse manhole is to be placed on top of a precast or poured in place slab. 4) New 5 ft. sidewalk shall be constructed in Kendall Street right-of-~vay per City standards. 5) Double detector check valve with bypass meter shall be required for any internal fire protection line. (Clearwater Ordinance 32.103). All of the above to be addressed prior to CDB. The following to be addressed prior to building permit: 1) A separate right-of--way permit is required for manhole installation in Avalon Street. Contact Don Melone (727.562.4798) for permit information. 2) Fire hydrant lines/fire sprinkler lines shall be constructed of 6-inch diameter ductile iron pipe (Clearwater Contract Specifications and Standards, Article 41). General Note: DRC review is a prerequisite for Building Permit Review, additional comments maybe forthcoming upon submittal of a Building Permit Application. Environmental: 1 . No Issues. Fire: 1 , This DRC Review by Fire is not an approval or review of any construction plans or documents other than site work. 2 , Fire Hydrant at S.W. corner of the property appears to be behind a block wall. The Fire Hydrant and FDC must remain accessible from the street, unobstructed by fences, walls, shrubbery, etc. Please acknowledge PRIOR TO CDB. Harbor Master: 1 . No issues. Legal: 1 . No issues. Land Resources: 1 . Show to be removed the 21"palm trtee in the retention pond prior to building permit. Landscaping: 1 , Provide ALL the utilities on the landscape plan to avoid conflicts with proposed plant materials. 2 . Plan does not meet the requirements of perimeter plantings in Code Section 3-1202.D. Revise accordingly or submit a Comprehensive Landscape application as required. 3 , The plans show a multitude of palms on the west side of the building where balconies and windows will be obstructed. If this is the proposed plan that is approved, it will be the plan that will be required at bbuilding permit application and completion for certificate of occupancy. Consideration should be made as to location of the materials proposed and the impact of those materials. 4 . The area between the building and the property line for landscape will not be sufficient for some of the proposed palms. Consider an automated parking system to allow for more open space on this parcel as they do not require the drive isles. Parks and Recreation: 1 . Recreation Facility impact fees of $650 is due for 3.25 net new units prior to issuance of building permits or final plat (if applicable) whichever occurs first. Contact Art Kader at 727-562-4824. Stormwater: 1 . 1. It appears that the runoff coefficient for the site was incorrectly calculated. Please revise. 2. It is difficult to read existing grades on the east side of the site. Therefore, cannot verify that offsite runoff is not entering the property. Suggest seperating the Utility sheet from the Paving, Grading & Drainage sheet for legibility. 3. Change outfall location to spill over into driveway instead of onto the sidewalk. These issues need to be addressed prior to CDB. Solid Waste: 1 , Dumpsters and recycling containers are to be staged by on site maintenance personel Traffic Engineering: Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 26 1. Parkin s ace mbered 16, 17, 21, and 22 have limited site vility, please demonstrate g P how these spaces comply with Community Development Code Section 3-1402.A. 2. Show angle (in degrees) for the angled parking spaces. All parking spaces must comply with City standard dimensions (Community Development Code Section 3-1402). The above to be addressed prior to CDB. 1. General note: Transportation Impact Fees to be determined and paid prior to C.O. Planning: Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 27 1 . Proposal is for attached dwellings (condominium flats) in the Old Florida District of Beach by Design. Single family dwellings and townhomes are the preferred form of development in the Old Florida District. Additionally, the proposed building exceeds 50 feet in height, which staff is deeming to be the maximum height for mid-rise buildings. Staff cannot support the proposal. 2 . Staff will not support the requested Termination of Status of Nonconformity, as it produces an excess number of dwelling units. Proposal indicates that the excess units are intended to be sold off (additional profit, over and above what is necessary to construct the project). Alternately, use the normal 30 dwelling units per acre and a Transfer of Development Rights to this site of one unit. 3 . Revise the survey to add Lot 5 into the legal description. 4 . Revise Sheet C1.1 for the legal description to indicate all lots that are part of this request (Lots 5,6,7,8 + 14). 5 . Revise Sheet C3.1 to reduce the amount of concrete sidewalk at the south end of the building. 6 . Unclear why a double door entrance is necessary on south side of the building on Kendall Street, since this is primarily an exit. It is also unclear the need for the double door when there will be a beautiful DCVA right outside the door (see Sheet C4.1). 7 . Unclear as to reason for the pedestrian door on the northwest corner of the building, since it goes out into landscaping. 8 . Sheet C3.1 -unclear how the western "assigned storage" will be laid out to provide a safe means for the residents to obtain access to them with the major entrance drive aisle adjacent to it. Provide layout. 9 . Dimension the drive aisle backup area south of spaces 13-16. 10 . Unclear how the dumpsters will be moved to the trash staging area in the front yard on Avalon Street. Suggest switching the location of the trash staging area and the retention pond. 11 . Indicate southern stairs on Sheet C3.1. 12 . Unclear how there is sufficient room to plant landscaping along the edge of the retention pond when the planting area is only one-foot wide. Also, unclear how the root balls for the trees will be planted with the slope of the retention pond in mind. Provide details of such planting on the slope. Provide narrative as to how such plantings will not reduce the drainage capacity once constructed and how the mulch will stay around the plantings without being washed away. 13 . Based on the clear trunk lengths indicated for the proposed trees, it appears that most views from the first floor units will be blocked. 14 . Explain how the proposed palms will be planted and how they will grow and be maintained within the three-foot area on the west side of the building. Would appear that the fronds will scrape the building. 15 . Sheet L1.1 -retention area incorrectly shown on the northwest corner of the building. 16 . Provide the angle of parking spaces 22-24. 17 . Sheet C4.1 -unclear if Section A-A is typical for all retention areas, including the north side of the building. 18 . Sheet I1.1 -does it make sense to have the irrigation lines and heads in the bottom of the retention ponds? 19 . Sheet A-1 -where does door between the southern elevator and southern stairwell go to, since outside the building is a two-foot drop into a retention pond? 20 . Sheets A2, A7 + A8 -provide dimension of balcony projections. 21 . Sheets A7 + A8 -clubhouse arches and medallions are out of character with the architecture of the main building. Revise. 22 . Sheets A7 + A8 -indicate the proposed exterior building finishes and colors of all architectural elements. 23 . Sheets A7 + A8 -provide the height dimension for the clubhouse to the midpoint of the pitched roof. 24 . Provide the location of the a/c units, including the clubhouse. 25 . Sheet Al -provide the dimension of the entry overhang from the face of the north side of the building. 26 . Sheets A 1 + A7 -explain the purpose of the window in the "assigned storage" area on the north side of the building. Provide a layout of the "assigned storage" area. 27 . Add vertical banding to reduce the blandness of large expanses of flat walls (all sides). 28 . Sheet A8 -roof line wrong. Suggest additional balustrades at north and south ends of west elevation, much like the north elevation. 29 . Colors provided of exterior of the building is white, while the perspective colored drawing appears to be in the pink colors. 30 . Staff cannot support the proposed reductions to the west setbacks and the west landscape buffer. Development Review Agenda -Thursday, March 3, 2005 -Page 28 • • Other: No Comments Notes: To be placed on the 4/19/05 CDB agenda, submit 15 collated copies of the revised plans & application material addressing all above departments' comments by noon, 3/10/05. Packets shall be collated, folded and stapled as appropriate. ~ a l~'~essage ~ ~ Page 1 of 2 Wells, Wayne From: Wells, Wayne Sent: Friday, February 18, 2005 10:00 AM To: 'rainas@jpfirm.com' Cc: Watkins, Sherry Subject: RE: Ambiance on White Sands Raina - As to the Staff Report, are you looking for the Staff Report for Case Nos. FLD2004-08059/TDR2004-08008, which was denied by the Community Development Board (CDB) on November 16, 2004? If so, I am attaching that Staff Report and Development Order for your information. Alternately, are you looking for the Staff Report for the new case for the project under FLD2005-01007, which is scheduled for review by the Development Review Committee on March 3, 2005? If so, there has been no Staff Report prepared yet. As to minutes, I am assuming you desire the minutes from the November 16, 2004, CDB meeting. If so, these minutes are available from our Official Records and Legislative Services Department. Wayne -----Original Message----- From: Watkins, Sherry Sent: Wednesday, February 16, 2005 3:21 PM To: Wells, Wayne Subject: FW: Ambiance on White Sands Importance: High -----Original Message----- From: Haines, Angel Sent: Tuesday, February 15, 2005 11:34 AM To: Watkins, Sherry Subject: FW: Ambiance on White Sands Importance: High Hi Sherry, How are you handling these? are you emailing them to people who request Staff reports and are you able to email minutes? Angel -----Original Message----- From: Raina Sullivan [mailto:RainaS@jpfirm.com] Sent: Tuesday, February 15, 2005 11:27 AM To: Haines, Angel 2/18/2005 Message • . Page 2 of 2 ~l ~ Subject: Ambiance on White Sands Importance: High Good morning Ms. Haines, I am trying to track down a Staff Reports and Minutes from Hearings on Ambiance on White Sands - Application in the Old FL District. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you, Raina M. Sullivan Administrative Assitant to Troy J. Perdue, Esquire rainas ;ofirm.com 2/18/2005 ~~~ ME,j~age ~ . Page 1 oft Wells, Wayne From: Raina Sullivan [RainaS@jpfirm.com] Sent: Friday, February 18, 2005 10:39 AM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: Watkins, Sherry Subject: RE: Ambiance on White Sands Mr. Wells, Thank you for your assistance on this. I think the information you provided was sufficient. Have a nice day. _) Raina -----Original Message----- From: Wayne.Wells@myClearwater.com [mailto:Wayne.Wells@myClearwater.com] Sent: Friday, February 18, 2005 10:00 AM . To: Raina Sullivan Cc: Sherry.Watkins@myClearwater.com Subject: RE: Ambiance on White Sands Raina - As to the Staff Report, are you looking for the Staff Report for Case Nos. FLD2004-08059/TDR2004- 08008, which was denied by the Community Development Board (CDB) on November 16, 2004? If so, I am attaching that Staff Report and Development Order for your information. Alternately, are you looking for the Staff Report for the new case for the project under FLD2005-01007, which is scheduled for review by the Development Review Committee on March 3, 2005? If so, there has been no Staff Report prepared yet. As to minutes, I am assuming you desire the minutes from the November 16, 2004, CDB meeting. If so, these minutes are available from our Official Records and Legislative Services Department. Wayne -----Original Message----- From: Watkins, Sherry Sent: Wednesday, February 16, 2005 3:21 PM To: Wells, Wayne Subject: FW: Ambiance on White Sands Importance: High -----Original Message----- From: Haines, Angel Sent: Tuesday, February 15, 2005 11:34 A{:1 To: Watkins, Sherry Subject: FW: Ambiance on White Sands Importance: High 2/18/2005 Message ~ • Page 2 of 2 Hi Sherry, How are you handling these? are you emailing them to people who request Staff reports and are you able to email minutes? Angel -----Original Message----- From: Raina Sullivan [mailto:RainaS@jpfirm.com] Sent: Tuesday, February 15, 2005 11:27 AM To: Haines, Angel Subject: Ambiance on White Sands Importance: High Good morning Ms. Haines, I am trying to track down a Staff Reports and Minutes from Hearings on Ambiance on White Sands -Application in the Old FL District. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you, Raina M. Sullivan Administrative Assitant to Troy J. Perdue, Esquire rainas ~pfirm.com 2/18/2005 Division of Corporations Page 1 of 2 F~nr;~t~~I~e~~r~a9~tlr~ylt~/`~,(iS1~~7{ ~c ,~3t?t~~c~J]~c~f~`!•~~~,~? ~].~~~?{Tf .. , .~ ~_ -.~.~ .~ ~.. ,. ~,~. ~ ~ .,~. --.,,..._ .~ j~ ~.,` , 71Fz~?zi~M Ii~Il2I,.,.nrS~ ~t~,~~~ l~„Z~{~~` .~ Florida Limited Liability PANORAMA ON CLEARWATER BEACH, LLC PRINCIPAL ADDRESS 211 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE CLEARWATER FL 33756 MAILING ADDRESS 211 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE CLEARWATER FL 33756 Document Number FEI Number L04000087561 NONE State Status FL ACTIVE Total Contribution 0.00 Date Filed 12/03/2004 Effective Date NONE Re istered A ent Name & Address WARD, R.CARLTON 1253 PARK STREET CLEARWATER FL 33756 per/Member Detail Annual Re orts Report Year Filed Date http://www.sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?a1=DETFIL&n1=L04000087561 &n2=NAMFWD... .2/3/2005 Division of Corporations ~ • Page 2 of 2 ~. Y'M Ij Y Previous Filing ~ Return to List ~ Next Filing No Events No Name History Information Document Images Listed below are the images available for this filing. THIS IS NOT OFFICIAL RECORD; SEE DOCUMENTS IF QUESTION OR CONFLICT ~vxp®ratio~ts Inquiry ~ ~orporahons Help s M _.__ -- _ .T _._. _ .._ x.,. - __ http://www.sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?aI=DETFIL&n1=L04000087561 &n2=NAMFWD... 2/3/2005 ~~ --Y =Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 2 of 5 f ~. a~ ~ z~ ~ 1~ ~ 1a~a~ ~ aa~ ~ aa~a ~~ ~% ~/ 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:44:07 Ownership Information Non-Residential Property Address, Use, and Sales PANORAMA ON CLEARWATER BEACH LLC OBK: 139.94. OPG: 1448 2ii S MYRTLE AUE CLEARWATER FL 33756 EVACUATION ZONE: A Comparable sales value as Prop Rddr: 15 AVA LON ST of Jan 1; 2004, based on Census Tract: 260.02 sales from 2002 - 2003: 0 Sale Date OR BooklPage Price {Qua11UnQ} VaclImp Plat Information 1212,004 13,994/1,448 1,400,000 {Q} I 1925: Book 011 Pgs 005- 3 12,004 13,415/2,092 1,050,000 {Q} I 0000: Book Pgs - 1012,002 12,27312,235 530,000 {Q} I 0000 Book Pgs - 0 11,971 3,6801 687 8,000 {D} I 2004 Value EXEMPTIONS JustlMarket: 700,000 Homestead: NO Ownership ~ .000 Govt Exem: NO Use ~: .000 Assessed/Cap: 700,000 Institutional Exem: NO Tax Exempt ~: .000 Historic Exem: 0 Taxable: 700,000 Agricultural: 0 2004 Tax Information District: CW Seawall: Frontage: Clearwater View: Wat er 04 Millage: 22.9694 Land Size Unit Land Land Land Front x Depth Price Units Meth 04 Taxes: 16,078.58 1} 50 x 64 110. 00 3, 175. 00 S Special Tax .00 2} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3} 0 x 0 .00 .00 LJithout the Save-Our-Homes 4} 0 x 0 .00 .00 cap, 2004 taxes will be : 5} 0 x 0 .00 .00 16, 078.58 6} 0 x 0 . 00 . 00 LJithout any exemptions, 2004 taxes will be 16, 078. 58 Short Legal CLEARWATER BEACH REU BLK 7, H 63.5FT OF LOT 5 Description Building Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-scr3?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ~, Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 3 of 5 Property and Land Use Code descriptions a~ ~ ~~ ~ 1~ ~ 1a~a~ r aaa ~ aa~a :a1 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:44:06 Commercial Card 01 of 1 Improvement Type: Motels Res Const Property Rddress: 15 AUALOH ST Prop Use: 313 Land Use: 39 Structural Elements Foundation Special Footing Floor System Wood WI Subfloor Exterior Wall Frame Stucco Height Factor 0 Party Wall Hone Structural Frame Hone Roof Frame Gable & Hip Roof Cover Composition Shingle Cabinet & Mill Average Floor Finish Carpet Interior Finish Plaster Furred Total Units 6 Heating & Air Heating&Coaling Pckg Fixtures 18 Bath Tile None Electric Average Shape Factor Rectangle Quality Average Year Built 1,935 Effective Age 15 Other Depreciation 0 Function Depreciation D Economic Depreciation 0 Sub Areas Description Factor Area Description Factor Rrea 1} Base Area 1.00 1, 610 7} . 00 0 2} Utility .35 138 8) .00 0 3} Open Porch .20 322 9} .00 0 4) Upper Stry Base Area . 90 1, 356 10} . 00 0 5} .00 0 11} .00 0 6} .00 0 12} .00 0 ~a-mmercial Extra Features Description Dimensions Price Units Value RCD Year 1} PATIO/DECK 6X46 iD.00 276 2,760 1,210 1,982 2} ASPHALT 6X200 1.50 1,200 1,800 1,800 999 3} .00 0 0 0 0 q} .00 0 0 0 0 5} .00 0 0 0 0 6} .00 0 0 0 0 TOTAL RECORD VALUE: 3,010 Map With Property Address (non-vacant) http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-scr3?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ . IS ~7 H i d I l~ D H ~5 D r r r r ~~ 1 t e 0 i i IL NOi~$IL I LSAT ~~ c 'V ALA ~ r' ~~ r~~t K ~K E 18 10 BAY .z BAY SA~~1C~E ~Y ESF'L AtdADE ~,P~,AN,ALI LEARINAT~R T 1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002) Page 4 of 5 ~.~ s I r~ar~oa.~~.Y AvE AY ~~ ~ ~.'L!~ .~ f ~'~ -~~ J Y Y _?~.`~` ~~~ N~C~A~. A 1~ AVE A~ http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-scr3?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 5 of 5 ~~ r Ft, t Pinellas County Property Appraiser Parcel Information Back to Search Page An explanation of this screen http://pao.co.pinellas. fl.us/htbin/cgi-scr3?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 y ' . .Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ ,. .= ... a~ ~ z~ ~ ~~ ~ 1s~s~ ~ aa~ ~ a~4a Page 2 of 5 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:44:40 Ownership Information Non-Residential Property Address, Use, and Sales PA110RAMA OH CLEARWATER B-EACH LLC OBK: f3994 OPG: 1450 211 S MYRTLE AUE CLEARWATER FL 33756 EVACUATION ZONE: A Comparable sales value as Prop Addr: 16 KEH OALL ST of Jan 1, 2004, based on Census Tract: 260.02 sales from 2002 - 2003: 0 Sale Date OR Book/Page Price {Qual/UnQ} Vac/Imp Plat Information 1212,004 13,99411,450 2,145,000 {Q} I 1925: Book 011 Pgs 005- 0 /1,969 3,1991 210 55,000 {U} I 0000: Book Pgs - 0 10 01 0 0 { } 0000: Book Pgs - 0 /0 01 0 0 { } 2004 Value EXEMPTIONS Just/Market: 521,300 Homestead: HO Ownership ~ .000 Govt Exem: NO Use ~: .000 RssessedlCap: 521,300 Institutional Exem: HO Tax Exempt ~: .000 Historic Exem: 0 Taxable: 521,300 Agricultural: 0 2004 Tax Information District: CW Seawall: Frontage: Clearwater View: 04 Millage: 22.9694 Land Size Unit Land Land Land Front x Depth Price Units Meth 04 Taxes: 11, 973. 95 1} 50 x 111 110. 00 5, 575.00 S Special Tax .00 2} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3} p x 0 .00 .00 Without the Save-Our-Homes 4} 0 x 0 .00 .00 cap, 2004 taxes will be : 5} 0 x 0 .00 .00 11, 973. 95 6} 0 x 0 . 00 . 00 Without any exemptions, 2004 taxes will be : 11, 973. 95 Short Legal CLEARWATER BEACH REU BLK 7, LO T 14 & S 23.5FT Description OF LOT 5 Building Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ,• Pixiellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 3 of 5 05 ~ 29 / 15 / 16362 / 00 ~ / 0140 : 01 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:44:41 Commercial Card 01 of 1 Improvement Type: Motel/Hotel < 4 St Property Address: 16 KENDALL ST Prop Use: 313 Land Use: 39 Structural E1sm~nts Foundation Continuous Footing Floor System Slab on Grade Exterior Wall Cvnc Block/Stucco Height Factor 0 Party Wall None Structural Frame None Roof Frame Flat Roof Cower Built UpfComposition Cabinet & Mill Average Floor Finish Carpet Combination Interior Finish Plaster Furred Total Units 10 Heating & Air Heating&Cooling Pckg Fixtures 30 Bath Tile Wall Only Electric Average Shape Factor Rectangle Quality Average Year Built 1,957 Effective Age 25 Other Depreciation 0 Function Depreciation 0 Economic Depreciation 0 Sub Areas Description Factor Area Description Factor Area 1} Base Area 1.00 1,680 7} .00 0 2} Base Semi Finished .85 780 8} .00 D 3} Open Porch .30 890 9} .00 0 q} Upper Stry Base Area .90 1,680 10} .00 0 5} .00 0 11} .00 0 6) .00 0 12} .00 0 C amm~r c i a1 E xt r a F e at ur ~ s Description Dimensions Price 1) ASPHALT 9X200 1.50 2) . 00 3) . 00 q) . 00 5} .00 6} . 00 Units Value RCD Year 1,800 2,700 2,700 999 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TOTAL RECORD VALUE: 2,700 Map With Property Address (non-vacant) http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &Y=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ N A I L V~'~~u [~ O N ~~ti~ v r , ; ' r r i t t r i r ~' 1 r i r r r i M f~ A IL T~r~ I cJT ~~S ~V4~ I ~ G~lgt ' ~ r F~~~~ `, M~ h ~r7 ~'~ ~ 2'4 2F ~ ~ ,~'}r?~L~ ~:L[? ~-r s~n~r~~~ `~ J ~,~ Svr~L ~,~ r ,~ ' `~ ~ ~ '~ ST v ' ` 'J ` `l~ I ~ . ~r I ~ ~' t~~A N T~ L1~Et~~4~ A`1' L , ~T~, flG1~l1..~t'1~1~ ~..~ 1 Page 4 of 5 y~,ary~~ L,~~' I~ ~V~E B;~`r SPA-,~tk1DE BF'~~ Fpl ,~ND,+~L,A1 ~I~E CLEAF~WATER 57 r- - -~ 1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002) http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ,, Paellas County Property Apper Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ ~~ ~. ~- ., t. ~:. s~~r C. 3 ~, ~' [•r~ r,~' ~ ~ 4 a ~ ~ } { ; i ; . i t . ~ , r ~. R ti # '~r„ R 4 ' y ` t ~' t tc f~ .~._. Page 5 of 5 ', Pinellas County Property Appraiser Parcel Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 <. _Pinelias County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 2 of 5 ,~ ~, t .,, ' 05 / 29 I 15 I 16362 / 00~ / 0060 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:45:06 Ownership Information Residential Property Address, Use, and Sales PANORAMA ON CLEARWATER BEACH LLC OBK: 13994 OPG: 1449 211 S MYRTLE AUE CLEARWATER FL 33756 EVACUATION ZONE: A Comparable sales value as Prop Addr: 17 AUA LON ST of Jan 1, 2004, based on Census Tract: 260.02 sales from 2002 - 2003: 299,400 Sale Date OR Book/Page Price {Qual/UnQ} VaclImp Plat Information 1212,004 13,99411,449 700,000 (Q} I 1925: Book 011 Pgs 005- 4 11,997 9,66311,360 172,000 4Q} I 0000: Book Pgs - 0 11,967 2,7311 663 1,100 (U} I 0000: Book Pgs - 0 10 01 0 0 4 ) 2004 Value EXEMPTIONS JustlMarket: 255,100 Homestead: NO Ownership ~ .000 Govt Exem: NO Use ~: .000 AssessedlCap: 255,100 Institutional Exem: NO Tax Exempt ~: .000 Historic Exem: 0 Taxable: 255,100 Agricultural: 0 2004 Tax Information District: CW Seawall: Frontage: Clearwater View: 04 Millage: 22.9694 Land Size Unit Land Land Land Front x Depth Price Units Meth 04 Taxes: 5,859.49 1} 50 x 87 60.00 4, 350.00 S Special Tax .00 2} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3) 0 x 0 .00 .00 Without the Save-Our-Homes 4} 0 x 0 .00 .00 cap, 2004 taxes will be : 5} 0 x 0 .00 .00 5, 859.49 6} 0 x 0 . 00 . 00 Without any exemptions, 2004 taxes will be 5, 859.49 Short Legal CLEARWATER BEACH REU BLK 7, LO T 6 Description Building Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.uslhtbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinel~;as County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 3 of 5 05 / 29 115 / 1362 / 00~ 1040 :01 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:45:06 Residential Card 01 of 1 Prop Use: 210 Land Use: 01 Living Units: i Imp Type: Single Family Prop Address: 17 AUALOH ST Structural Elements Foundation Continuous Wall Floor System Wood Exterior LJall FramelStucco Roof Frame Flat-Shed Roof Cover B U Tar&GraVel/Othr # Stories 1.0 Floor Finish Crpt/HdTl/HdMar/Prgt Interior Finish Drywall/Plaster Quality Average Year Built 1,923 Effective Age Z5 Heating Central Ouct Cooling Cooling (Central) Fixtures 3 Other Depreciation 0 Functional Depreciation 0 Econonomic Depreciation 0 Sub Areas Description Factor Area Description Factor Area 1} Base Area 1.00 816 7} .00 0 2} Open Porch .20 3Z 8} .00 0 3} .00 0 9} .00 0 q} .00 0 10} .00 0 5} .00 0 11} .00 0 6} .,00 0 12} .00 0 Residcntial Extra Features Description Dimensions Price Units Value RCD Year 1} PATIO/DECK 145sf 3.00 145 440 180 1,923 2} PATIO/DECK 10X20 3.00 200 600 240 1,980 3} .00 0 0 0 0 4} .00 0 0 0 0 5) .00 0 0 0 0 6} .00 0 0 0 0 TOTAL RECORD VALUE: 420 Map With Property Address (non-vacant) ®®~ http://pao.co.pinellas. fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ,. Pinel,~as County Property App~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ ~F ~~ t 1 1 r ,~ 1 r ,~ r t ++, 1 1 7 1 r 7 ~ ~LEAI~WATER ~~ ~~r} ~~ J .~ Page 4 of 5 6. NAI ~" I ~~15~ ~' E ~~ I~ ~~ ~~~ 1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002) http://pao.co.pinellas. fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ~~~ Pine)Jas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 5 of 5 ~'~; ... ~\E. s ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w~ ,~~ - * -:.~_ Pinellas County Property Appraiser Parcel Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property Appr~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 00~ Page 2 of 5 ,. ~. ., ~. o~ ~ ~~ ~ 1~ ~ ~~~s~ ~ oo~ ~ oo~a 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFR Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:45:27 Ownership Information Residential Property Address, Use, and Sales GAL~ERONI, PASQd1ALE THE OBK: 11449 OPG: 0537 CALDEROHI, AIDA THE 4516 W NORTH B ST TAMPA FL 33609-2032 EVACUATION ZONE: A Comparable sales value as Prop Addr: 21 A UALOH ST of Jan 1, 2004, based on Census Tract: 260.02 sales from 2002 - 2003: 167,400 Sale Date OR BaoklPage Price {QuallUnQ} VaclImp Plat Information 1211,998 10,365/ 3 80 95,000 (Q} I 1925: Book 011 Pgs 005- 0 10 0/ 0 0 { } 0000 Book Pgs - 4 /0 0/ 0 0 ( } 0000: Book Pgs - 0 /0 0/ 0 0 { } 2004 Value EXEMPTIONS JustlMarket: 138,200 Homestead: NO Ownership ~ .000 Govt Exem. NO Use ~: .000 RssessedlCap: 138,200 Institutional Exem: NO Tax Exempt ~: .000 Historic Exem: 0 Taxable: 138,200 Agricultural: 0 2004 Tax Information District: CW Seawall: Frontage: Clearwater View: 04 Millage: 22.9694 Land Size Unit Land Land Land Front x Depth Price Units Meth 04 Taxes: 3,174.37 1) 25 x 87 60. 00 2, 175.00 S Special Tax .00 2} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3} 0 x 0 .00 .00 Without the Save-Our-Homes 4} 0 x 0 .00 .00 cap, 2004 taxes will be 5} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3, 174.37 6} 0 x 0 . 00 . 00 Without any exemptions, 2004 taxes will be 3, 174.37 Short Legal CLEARWATER BEACH REU BLK 7, W 1/2 OF LOT 7 Description Building Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 3 of 5 05 I 29 I 15 / 10302 I 00 ~ I 00 70 : 01 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFR Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:45:28 Residential Card 01 of i Prop Use: 220 Land Use: 08 Living Units: 2 Imp Type: Duplex/Triplex Prop Address: 21 AUALOH ST Structural Elements Foundation Piers Floor System Wood Exterior LJall Frame/Siding Roof Frame Gable-Hip Roof Cover Composite Shingle # Stories 1.0 Floor Finish Crpt/Unyl/SftWd/Terr Interior Finish Wood/Wallboard Quality Fair Year Built 1,925 Effective Age 30 Heating Central Ouct Cooling Cooling {Central} Fixtures 6 Other Depreciation 0 Functional Depreciation 0 Econonomic Depreciation 0 Sub Areas Description Factor Area Description Factor Area 1} Base Area 1.00 880 7) .00 0 2) Open Parch .20 60 8} .00 0 3} .00 0 9} .00 0 4) .00 0 10} .00 0 5} .00 0 11) .00 0 6} .00 0 12) .00 0 Residential Extra Features Description Dimensions Price Units Value RCD Year 1} PATIO/DECK 20x24 3.00 480 1,440 580 1,945 2} .00 0 0 0 0 3} .00 0 0 0 0 4) .00 D 0 0 0 5} .00 0 0 0 0 6) .00 0 0 0 0 TOTAL RECORD VALUE; 580 Map With Property Address (non-vacant) ®oaa http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &i=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 4 of 5 Y ~ ~r (~ ~l.} r .' i r i ,+ i r 0 r GLEARVI~ATEF~ ~Yjj ~~ ~~ ~" ~r J ~ PLAY 1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002) 636 ~AUET I hJ~E7 A'~~ ~~IN~ET ND~SI.L~. 4U ,~b'E BAS CAE http://pao.co.pinellas. fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property Appr Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ ~' I .. e t ~ ~' e ~~". • f ' i' ,, ~ N ^~+w ~~ v~,~Vr Pinellas County Property Appraiser Parcel Information Page 5 of 5 http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ., Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 2 of 5 ~; i ,; a~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~~s~ ~ ao7 ~ ao~~ 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:45:47 Ownership Information Residential Property Address, Use, and Sales CALDERONI, PASQUALE THE OBK: 11449 OPG: 0550 GALDEROHI, AIDA THE 451b W NORTH B ST TAMPA FL 33609-2032 EVACUATION ZONE: A Comparable sales value as Prop Addr; 23 AVA LON ST of Jan 1, 2004, based on Census Tract: 260.02 sales from 2002 - 2003; 166,600 Sale Date OR BooklPage Price {Qual/UnQ} Vac/Imp Plat Information 0 11,975 4,313/ 728 15,000 {Q} I 1925: Book 011 Pgs 005- 0 10 01 0 0 { } 0000: Book Pgs - 0 10 01 0 0 { } 0000: Book Pgs - 0 /0 0{ 0 0 { } 2004 Value EXEMPTIONS JustlMarket: 137,600 Homestead: HD Ownership ~ .000 Govt Exem: HO Use ~: .000 Assessed/Cap; 137,600 Institutional Exem; HO Tax Exempt ~: .000 Historic Exem; 0 Taxable; 137,600 Agricultural: 0 2004 Tax Information District: CW Seawall: Frontage: Clearwater View; 04 Millage; 22.9694 Land Size Unit Land Land Land Front x Depth Price Units Meth 04 Taxes: 3,160.59 1} 25 x 87 60. 00 2, 175.00 S Special Tax . 00 2} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3} 0 x 0 .00 .00 Without the Save-Our-Homes 4} 0 x 0 .00 .00 cap, 2004 taxes will be ; 5} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3, 160. 59 ~} 0 x 0 . DO . 00 Without any exemptions, 2004 taxes will be ; 3, 160.59 Short Legal CLEARWATER BEACH REU BLK 7, E i/2 OF LOT 7 Description Building Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r-.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 3 of 5 a~ ~ ~~ ~ ~.~ ~ ss~~~ ~ oo~ ~ ao7~. : o~ 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:45:47 Residential Card 01 of 1 Prop Use: 220 Land Use: 08 Living Units: 2 Imp Type: Duplex/Triplex Prop Address: 23 AUALOH ST S~ruc-tural E1~men~s Foundation Continuous Wall Floor System Wood Exterior lJall Frame/Siding Roof Frame Gable-Hip Roof Cover Composite Shingle # Stories 1.0 Floor Finish Crpt/Unyl/SftWdfTerr Interior Finish Wood/Wallboard Quality Fair Year Built 1,925 Effective Age 30 Heating Central Duct Cooling Cooling (Central} Fixtures 6 Other Depreciation 0 Functional Depreciation 0 Econonomic Depreciation 0 Sub Areas Description Factor Rrea Description Factor Area 1} Base Area 1.00 840 7) .00 0 2) Open Porch .20 24 8} .00 0 3} Open Porch .15 140 9} .00 0 4} .00 0 10) .00 0 5} .00 0 11} .00 0 6} .00 0 12} .00 0 Rssid~n-tial Extra F~atur~s Description Dimensions Price Units Value RCD Year 1} SHED 10}C10 8. 00 100 800 390 1, 925 2) .00 0 0 0 0 3) .00 0 0 0 0 4) .00 0 0 0 0 5) .00 0 0 0 0 6) .00 0 0 0 0 TOTAL RECORD VALUE: 390 Map With Property Address (non-vacant) ®~~ http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &1=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pi~.ellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ ti~~ ,~ r e i 1 1 1 i ~LEARINATEF~ ~~ ,~`~'' ~r- Y Y _ A`~` Page 4 of 5 MAt DAE A'r IIV5~ET1 A''r' i r~~E~ I E~ N, i~~i ,~I~ANI 1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002) http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ~E~AY Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 5 of 5 ~~ ~, v .. ,< , ~, .~ k ' 4. `: ~~ ~ 9 T i .~ , t f £ 4 r' ~ T :~~ Pinellas County Property Appraiser Parcel Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ,; , .Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ ~, ~. 05 / 29 / 15 / 10302 / 40 7 / 0080 Page 2 of 5 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:46:09 Ownership Information Residential Property Address, Use, and Sales CALDERONI, PASQUALE THE OBK: 11449 OPG, 0557 CALDERONI, AIDA THE 4516 W HORTH B ST TAMPA FL 33609-2032 EVACUATION ZONE: A Comparable sales value as Prop Addr: 25 A UALON ST of Jan 1, 2004, based on Census Tract: 260.02 sales from 2002 - 2003: 183,300 Sale Date OR Book/Page Price {Qual/UnQ} VaclImp Plat Information 0 11,978 4,763/ 2 97 25,000 {U} I 1925: Book 011 Pgs 005- 0 10 OJ 0 0 { } 0000: Book Pgs - 0 10 0/ 0 0 { } 0000: Book Pgs - 0 10 0/ 0 0 { } 2004 Value EXEMPTIONS Just/Market: 156,000 Homestead: ND Ownership ~ .000 Govt Exem: NO Use ~: .000 Assessed/Cap: 156,000 Institutional Exem: NO Tax Exempt ~: .000 Historic Exem: 0 Taxable: 156,000 Agricultural: 0 2004 Tax Information District: CW Seawall: Frontage: Clearwater View: 04 Millage: 22.9694 Land Size Unit Land Land Land Front x Depth Price Units Meth 04 Taxes: 3, 583. 23 1} 25 x 87 60. 00 2, 175.00 S Special Tax .00 2) 25 x 32 32.00 800.00 S 3} 0 x 0 .00 .00 Without the Save-Our-Homes 4} 0 x 0 .00 .00 cap, 2004 taxes will be 5} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3, 583.23 6} 0 x 0 . 00 . 00 Without any exemptions, 2004 taxes will be 3, 583.23 Short Legal CLEARWATER BEACH REU BLK 7, LOT 8 LESS E 25FT Description OF THE N 55FT Building Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 3 of 5 0~ ~ ~~ ~ 1~ i ~~~~~ ~ 007 ~ 00s0 :a~ 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:46:09 Residential Card 01 of i Prop Use: 210 Land Use: 01 Living Units: i Imp Type:, Single Family Prop Address: 25 AUALON ST Structural E1sm~nts Foundation Continuous Wall Floor System Wood Exterior LJall FramelRclad A1mIVny1 Roof Frame Gable-Hip Roof Cover Composite Shingle # Stories 1.0 Floor Finish Crpt/Vnyl/SftWdlTerr Interior Finish DrywalllPlaster Quality Average Year Built 1,925 Effective Age 20 Heating Central Ouct Cooling Cooling {Central} Fixtures 3 Other Depreciation 0 Functional Depreciation 0 Econonomic Depreciation 0 Sub Aromas Description Factor Area Description Factor Area 1} Base Area 1.00 640 7} .00 0 2) Base Semi Finished .80 120 8} .00 0 3} Utility .25 36 9} .00 0 4} Open Porch .15 84 10) .00 0 5} .00 0 11} .00 0 6} .00 0 12) .00 0 Rssi.clsntial Extra Features Description Dimensions Price Units Value RCD Year 1} pATIO1DECK 10X14 5.00 140 700 280 1,980 2} .00 0 0 0 0 3} .00 0 0 0 0 4} .00 0 0 0 0 5} .00 0 0 0 0 6} . DO 0 0 0 0 TOTAL RECORD VALUE: 280 Map With Property Address (non-vacant) ®~~ http://pao.co.pinellas. fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pin;llas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 4 of 5 P,~IA.ND E ~ ~IF~I hdAEET I f` r ~ /"'~ },~ Cl.r'1 r i t1 1 1 M i r 1~ ,~ ~~ r~ ~ `rte ~J ~I _ ~. Y ~~ ~E~~ IN~VET I. ~- S g ~~y~~ v ~J ,.+ J 6Ci~ NC7~LA.1r ~~trE ~JIh1ETl r~ a~l~~.~~?,~ ktrE L.~h~ DE ~LEAF~INA7EF~ ~ ~3AY 1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002) ~, http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pirn~llas County Property App~er Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ 4 i~ f' '„"fie.. (Y~ ~ ty ~.. e~ , a' a • '~ y _. ~ ZA 2~/ '~;~ -~ ,. Pinellas County Property Appraiser Parcel Information Page 5 of 5 http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.1.6&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ~, w . Pinellas County Property App~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 2 of 5 ~, a~ ~ ~a ~ ~.~ ~ 1a~sz ~ aa~ ~ aas~ 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFR Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:46:25 Ownership Information Residential Property Address, Use, and Sales CALDERONI, PASQUALE THE OBK: 11449 OPG: 0562 CALDERONI, AIDA THE 4516 W HORTH B ST TAMPA FL 33609-2032 EVACURTION ZONE: A Comparable sales value as Prop Addr: 27 AUA LOH ST of Jan 1, 2004, based on Census Tract: 260.02 sales from 2002 - 2003: 122,500 Sale Date OR Book/Page Price {QuallUnQ} VaclImp Plat Information 3 11,996 9,2791 721 66,900 {Q} I 1925: Book 011 Pgs 005- 0 11,969 3,0931 287 11,000 {U} I oooo: Book Pgs - o to o! o o { } 0000: Book Pgs - 0 /0 OJ 0 0 { } 2004 Value EXEMPTIONS Just/Market: 102,000 Homestead: HO Ownership ~ .000 Govt Exem: HO Use ~: .000 Assessed/Cap: 102,000 Institutional Exem: NO Tax Exempt ~: .000 Historic Exem: 0 Taxable: 102,000 Agricultural: 0 2004 Tax Information District: CW Seawall: Frontage: Clearwater View: 04 Millage: 22.9694 Land Size Unit Land Land Land Front x Depth Price Units Meth 04 Taxes: 2, 342. 88 1} 25 x 55 60. 00 1, 375.00 S Special Tax .00 2} 0 x 0 .00 .00 3} 0 x 0 .00 .00 Without the Save-Our-Homes 4} 0 x 0 .00 .00 cap, 2004 taxes will be : 5} 0 x 0 .00 .00 2, 342.88 6} 0 x 0 . 00 . 00 Without any exemptions, 2004 taxes will be : 2, 342. 88 Short Legal CLEARWATER BEACH REU BLK 7, E 25FT OF H 55FT OF Description LOT 8 Building Information http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 t Pinellas County Property App~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ Page 3 of 5 a~ ~ za ~ ~~ ~ ~s~s~ ~ aa~ ~ aa~~ : a1 03-Feb-2005 Jim Smith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 20:46:26 Residential Card 01 of 1 Prop Use: 210 Land Use: 01 Living Units; i Imp Type; Single Family Prop Address; 27 AUALON ST S~ruc~ural E1em~nts Foundation Piers Floor System Wood Exterior LJall Frame/Siding Raof Frame Gable-Hip Roof Cover Composite Shingle # Stories 1.0 Floor Finish CrptJUnyllSftWdJTerr Interior Finish Drywall/Plaster Quality Average Year Built 1,925 Effective Age 30 Heating Central Duct Cooling Cooling {Central} Fixtures 6 Other Depreciation 0 Functional Depreciation 0 Econonomic Depreciation 0 Sub Areas Description Factor Area Description Factor Area 1} Base Area 1.00 760 7} .00 0 2} .00 0 8} .00 0 3} .00 0 g} .00 0 q) .00 0 10} .00 0 5) .00 0 11} .00 0 6) .00 0 12} .00 0 R~sicl~ntial Extra F~a~ur~s Description Dimensions Price Units Value RCD Year 1} SHED 8X8 1.50 64 100 100 1,980 2} .00 0 0 0 0 3} .00 0 0 0 0 q} .00 0 0 0 0 5} .00 0 0 0 0 6} .00 0 0 0 0 TOTAL RECORD VALUE; 100 Map With Property Address (non-vacant) oa®o http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 Pinellas County Property App~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ r ~~ a ~LEAF~INATEF~ T 1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002) ~Y~ ~t Y J ~~ _~.,. N ~ I LAY Ca .+~ M?~ INSE77I }EVE AVE r IPd~E~T I .~',fE Page 4 of 5 ~~ -~ ~' i ~~~~ I I ~ ~- r ~`~J ~ ~~lANI TA http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 ~~AY Pinellas County Property App~r Information: OS 29 15 16362 007 0~ a ~~. E ~ .- 4~` ..,~. '§ f T 0 pal R y w y .~~,,..` Page 5 of 5 Pinellas County Property Appraiser Parcel Information _t~ %~ c ~.~ .~ http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi-click?o=1 &a=1 &b=1 &c=1 &r=.16&s=4&t3=1 &u=0&p... 2/3/2005 • ''` CITY OF CLEARWATER NOTICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD PUBLIC HEARINGS The Community Development Board of the City of Clearwater, Florida, will hold public hearings on Tuesday, April 19, 2005, beginning at 1:00 PM, in the City Council Chambers, in City Hall, 3rd floor, 112 South Osceola Ave, Clearwater, Florida, to consider the following requests: NOTE: All persons wishing to address an item need to be present at the BEGINNING of the meeting. Those cases that are not contested by the applicant, staff, neighboring property owners, etc. will be placed on a consent agenda and approved by a single vote at the beginning of the meeting. 1. (cont. from 1/18/05) LBJ, LLC (BJE, Inc.) are requesting (1) Flexible Development approval to permit a mixed use (proposed parking garage and attached dwellings in conjunction with existing retail sales) with a reduction to the front (east) setback from 25 ft to 4.77 ft (to building), a reduction to the side (north) setback from 10 ft to 2.91 ft (to building), reductions to the side (south) setback from 10 ft to zero ft (to dumpster enclosure), from 10 ft to 1.74 ft (to pavement) and from 10 ft to 2.6 ft (to building), a reduction to the rear (west) setback from 20 ft to 0.5 ft (to building), to increase the building height from 35 ft to 70 ft (to roof deck) with an additional 4 ft for perimeter parapets (from roof deck) and an additional 16 ft for rooftop pavilion (from roof deck) and to permit a building within the visibility triangles, as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project, under the provisions of Sec 2-803.C., and a reduction to the width of foundation landscaping along Poinsettia Avenue from 5 ft to 4.77 ft, as a Comprehensive Landscape Program under the provisions of Sec 3-1202.G; and (2) Transfer of Development Rights of 4 units from 656 Bayway Blvd, under the provisions of Sec 4-1402. [Proposed Use: Mixed use (4 level parking garage with 355 parking spaces and 28 attached dwelling units [condominium] in conjunction with 37,940 sq ft of existing retail sales)] at 483 Mandalay Ave, Clearwater Beach Park, ls` Add Replat, Blk A, Lots 2-7, & 15 ft Vac Alley on W & Lot 8. FLD2004-09072/TDR2005-01015 2. (cont. from 3/22/05) Liberty Bank (Liberty Realty Group) are requesting Flexible Development approval (1) to permit retail sales and service (bank) and offices in the Commercial District with a reduction to the front (north) setback from 25 to 23.5 ft (to pavement), a reduction to the front (east) setback from 25 ft 20 ft (to building), an increase to building height from 25 ft to 28 ft (to roof deck) with an additional 3.33 ft for parapet (from roof deck) and an additional 8.83 ft for architectural embellishments (from roof deck), a reduction to required parking from 38 to 35 spaces and a deviation to allow direct access to a major arterial street (Gulf to Bay), as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project, under the provisions of Sec 2-704.C; (2) to permit non-residential parking in the Medium Density Residential District with a reduction to front (east) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to pavement) and a deviation to place landscaping on the inside of the buffer fence along the west and south sides of the property, as a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of 2-304.G. (Proposed Use: Bank and office space) at 1611 Gulf to Bay Blvd, Longview Sub, Lots 3-4, 19-21. FLD2004-11080 3. (cont. from 3/22/05) Haddon House Inn, Inc. (Haddon House of Clearwater, LLC) are requesting (1) Flexible Development approval to permit 14 attached dwellings with reductions to the front (south) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to building) and from 25 ft to 4.2 ft (to trash staging area), a reduction to the front (west) setback from 25 ft to 8 ft from the Coastal Construction Control Line (to pool deck), reductions to the side (north} setback from 10 ft to 5.9 ft (to building), from 10 ft to 5 ft (to pool deck) and from 10 ft to 2 ft (to sidewalk), a reduction to the • • `' side (west) setback from 10 ft to 3.2 ft (to sidewalk), a reduction to the side (east) setback from 10 ft to 6 ft (to sidewalk), and an increase to height from 30 ft to 64 ft (to roof deck) with an additional 4.16 ft for perimeter parapet (from roof deck) and an additional 15.83 ft for a rooftop pavilion (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of Sec 2-404.F; (2) a reduction to the landscape buffer along Idlewild Street from 10 ft to 4.2 ft (to trash staging area), a reduction to the landscape buffer along the north property line from 10 ft to 5.9 ft (to building), from 10 ft to 5 ft (to pool deck) and from 10 ft to 2 ft (to sidewalk), a reduction to the landscape buffer along the west property line from 10 ft to 3.2 ft (to sidewalk) and a reduction to the landscape buffer along the eastern property line from 10 ft to 6 ft (to sidewalk), as a Comprehensive Landscape Program, under the provisions of Sec 3-1202.G; (3) Transfer of Development Rights for one dwelling unit from 321 Coronado Drive, under the provisions of Sec 4-1403. [Proposed Use: Attached dwellings (14 condominiums)] at 12 Idlewild St, Clearwater Beach Rev, Blk3, Lots 1, 13-15 & W 1/Z of Lot 12. FLD2004-10076 4. George C Clark Investments (Global Financial Investments, LLC /Equity Investments, LLC / KB Home -Tampa, LLC) are requesting Flexible Development approval with reduction of the front (east) setback along Lawson Rd from 25 ft to 18 ft (to building), from 25 ft to 14 ft (to pavement), reductions to front (west) setback along Lawson Rd from 25 ft to 7 ft (to patios), from 25 ft to 11 ft to (building) and from 25 ft to 10 ft (to pavement), a reduction of the front (south) setback along Blackburn St from 25 ft to 10 ft (to pavement), and a reduction to a landscape buffer from 10 ft to 7 ft (to patios) along the east side of Lawson Rd, as a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of Sec 2-304.G. and Preliminary Plat approval for 248 lots, and as a Comprehensive Landscape Program, under the provisions of Sec 3-1202.G. (Proposed Use: A residential development of 248 attached dwellings) at 2520 Sunset Point Rd, Blackburn's Sub, Pt of Lots 10-12 & Vac St. FLD2004-02011A/PLT2004-00007A 5. Bay Harbor, LLC (Baywatch Suites, Inc.) are requesting Flexible Development approval to construct a 1,376 sq ft multi-use dock facility to provide 8 slips as an amenity to 19 condominium units. The request includes an increase of the width of the dock from 75 percent of the lot width (135 ft) to 77 percent of the lot width (139 ft), and a reduction of the side (west) setbacks from 17.98 ft to 10.3 ft to the dock, per Sec 3-601.C.3: (Proposed Use: Construct amulti-use dock of 1,376 sq ft for 8 slips) at 600 Bayway Blvd, Bayside Sub No. 5, Blk A, Lots 6-8 & Riparian Rts. FLD2005-01010 6. MSPA Acquisition II, LP is requesting (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density to allow the continuation of an existing 217-room unit hotel (where 74 rooms/units are permitted today) and for height to allow the existing 155-ft high building (where a maximum height of 150 ft is permitted today); (2) Flexible Development approval to permit a 217-room/unit overnight accommodation use with a reduction to the rear (west) setback from 20 ft to zero ft (to patio/pool decking and tiki bars) and to allow patio/pool decking seaward (westward) of the Coastal Construction Control Line, an increase to building height from 35 ft to 155 ft (to existing roof deck) and a reduction to required parking from 217 to 201 spaces (existing), as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project, under the provisions of Sec 2-803.C; (3) a reduction to the required interior landscape area, as a Comprehensive Landscape Program, under the provisions of Sec 3-1202.G; and (4) Comprehensive Sign Program approval, under the provisions of Sec 3-1807 (SGN2005-01016). (Proposed Use: Retain existing 217-room overnight accommodation use) at 430 South Gulfview Blvd, Lloyd-White-Skinner Sub, Lots 33- 35 & Pt of Lot 36 & Subm Land on W. FLD2005-01005/SGN2005-01016 7. Suns~ree Green, LLC is requesting (1) Termination of Status of Nonconformity for density for the existing 105-room hotel tower, located on 2.383 acres (density to be converted to 78 • • ~' dwelling units); (2) Flexible Development approval to permit attached dwellings with reductions to the front (north along S. Gulfview Blvd.) from 15 ft to 11.88 ft (to security guard house) and from 15 ft to 6.42 ft (to pavement), a reduction to the front (east along Gulf Blvd.) from 15 ft to zero ft (to pavement), a reduction to the side (west) setback from 10 ft to 4.29 ft (to pavement), a reduction to the side (south) setback from 10 ft to zero ft (to boardwalk), an increase to building height from 35 ft to 150 ft (to roof deck) with an additional 11 - 21 ft for decorative mansard architectural embellishments, an increase to fence height within the front setback from 6 ft to 7 ft and a deviation to allow a building within visibility triangles, as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project, under the provisions of Sec 2-803.C; (3) Transfer of Development Rights of 10 units from 41 Devon Dr and 3 units from the Sandpearl project located generally at 500 Mandalay Ave, under the provisions of Sec 4-1402 (TDR2005-01017); and (4) Preliminary Plat for 1 lot (PLT2005-00002). [Proposed Use: Attached dwellings (149 dwelling units)] at 715 S. Gulfview Blvd, Bayside Shores, Blk D, Lots 1-2 & Accreted Land to S. FLD2005- 01016/TDR2005-01017/PLT2005-00002 - A f - .) ~ Panaroma on Clearwater Beach, LLC is requesting (1) Termination of Status of V Y i/~ Nonconformity for density (15 overnight accommodation units, to be converted to 11 dwelling units, plus 8 existing dwelling units), under the provisions of Sec 6-109; (2) Flexible Development approval to permit a total of 15 attached dwellings in the Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District and Tourist (T) District with a reduction in the T District from 10,000 sq ft to 4,350 sq ft, a reduction to lot width in the T District from 100 ft to 50 ft, reductions to the front (north along Avalon St - MHDR District) setback from 25 ft to 10 ft (to building) and from 25 ft to zero ft (to trash staging area), a reduction to the front (south along Kendall St - T District) from 15 ft to 10 ft (to building), a reduction to the side (west - MHDR District) from 10 ft to 7 ft (to building), a reduction to the side (west - T District) from 10 ft to 3 ft (to building and pavement), a reduction to the rear (south - MHDR District) from 15 ft to 10 ft (to building), an increase to building height in the MHDR District from 30 ft and in the T District from 35 ft to 52.67 ft (to roof deck) with perimeter parapets of 3.67 ft (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project in the MHDR District and as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project in the T District, under the provisions of Secs 2-404.F and 2-803.C; and (3) Reduction to the side (west) landscape buffer in the MHDR District from 10 ft to 7 ft (to building), as a Comprehensive Landscape Plan, under the provisions of Sec 3-1202.G. [Proposed Use: Attached dwellings (15 dwelling units)] at 15 - 27 Avalon St and 16 Kendall St, Clearwater Beach Rev, Blk7, Lots 6-8, 14 & Pt of Lot 5. FLD2005-01007 9. Robert M Pennock Melodie A Ferguson, Robert M Pennock II THE REM, &Melodie A Ferguson THE REM are requesting Flexible Development approval to permit 5 attached dwelling units with a reduction to the minimum lot width from 100 ft to 51 ft; an increase in height from 35 ft to 59 ft to top of roof deck, an additional 3.5 ft to the top of mansard roof (from roof deck) and an additional 11.75 ft for stair/elevator tower (from roof deck) and architectural embellishment; a reduction in the rear (south) setback from 20 ft to zero ft to pool deck, 3.5 ft to pool and 18 ft to building as a Flexible Development project, under the provisions of Sec 2- 803.B. [Proposed Use: Attached dwellings (5 dwelling units)] at 665 Bay Esplanade, Mandalay Unit No 5 Replat, Blk 77, Lot 6. FLD2005-01009 10. Clearwater Yacht Club, Inc. is requesting Flexible Development approval to permit a 3 story, 18,500 sq ft Yacht Club with offices, exercise room, restaurant and parking garage structure, with reductions to the front (south) setback from 15 ft to zero ft to pavement and 4 ft to building structure; to permit a building within the sight visibility triangles along Bayway Blvd, a reduction of rear (north) setback from 20 ft to zero ft to paver deck and 18 ft to building and an increase in building height from 25 ft to 46.5 ft to mean roof height, as a Comprehensive Infill • • ~" Project, under the provisions of Sec 2-803.E. (Proposed Use: Marina) at 830 Bayway Blvd, Bayside Sub No 6 Unit A, Blk D, Lots 5-11 Incl. FLD2005-01008 11. Skiff Point of Clearwater, LLC is requesting Flexible Development approval to permit 15 attached dwelling units with reductions to the front (east) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft to building and from 25 ft to 3 ft to pavement; a reduction to-the side (north and south) setbacks from 10 ft to 6.5 ft to building and 5 ft to parking; a reduction to the rear (south) setback from 15 ft to zero ft to pool deck, 5 ft to pool and 7.5 ft to parking; and an increase in height from 30 ft to 49 ft to roof deck and additional 4 ft for parapet (from roof deck to top of parapet) and an additional 16 ft for elevator overrun (from roof deck), as a Residential Infill Project, in the Island Estates Neighborhood Conservation Overlay District (IENCOD) /Medium High Density Residential (MHDR) District under the provisions of Secs 2-404(F) and 2-1602(C). [Proposed Use: Attached dwellings (15 dwelling units)] at 200 and 201 Skiff Point, Island Estates of Clearwater, Unit 5-A, Lots 35-36. FLD2005-01012 Interested parties may appear and be heard at the hearings or file written notice of approval or objection with the Planning Interested parties may appear and be heard at the hearing or file written notice of approval or objection with the Planning Director or City Clerk prior to the hearing. Any person who decides to appeal any decision made by the Board or Council, with respect to any matter considered at such hearings, will need to request a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based per Florida Statute 286.0105. Community Development Code Sec 4-206 states that party status shall be granted by the Board in quasi judicial cases if the person requesting such status demonstrates that s/he is substantially affected. Parry status entitles parties to personally testify, present evidence, argument and witnesses, cross-examine witnesses, appeal the decision and speak on reconsideration requests, and needs to be requested and obtained during the case discussion before the CDB. An oath will be administered swearing in all persons giving testimony in quasi judicial public hearing cases. If you wish to speak at the meeting, please wait to be recognized, then state and spell your name and provide your address. Persons without party status speaking before the CDB shall be limited to three minutes unless an individual is representing a group in which case the Chairperson may authorize a reasonable amount of time up to 10 minutes. 5 days prior to the meeting, staff reports and recommendations on the above requests will be available for review by interested parties between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m., weekdays, at the City of Clearwater, Planning Department, 100 S. Myrtle Ave., Clearwater, FL 33756. Please contact the case presenter, at 562-4567 to discuss any questions or concerns about the project and/or to better understand the proposal and review the site plan. Cyndi Tarapani Cynthia E. Goudeau, CMC Planning Director City Clerk Ciry of Clearwater P.O. Box 4748, Clearwater, FL 33758-4748 NOTE: Applicant or representative must be present at the hearing. A COPY OF THIS AD IN LARGE PRINT IS AVAILABLE IN OFFICIAL RECORDS AND LEGISLATIVE SERVICES. ANY PERSON WITH A DISABILITY REQUIRING • • REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING SHOULD CALL (727) 562-4093 WITH THEIR REQUEST. Ad: 04/03/05 ~ [~e,~ 1 S - 15 ~rc~,~o n _ F L-D2.OC~S - O l OC5-( '~` ~ i • CLEA~WATER, CITY OF BAY ESPLANADE AT BORUTA, SCOTT V PO BOX 4748 CLEARWATER BE 611 POINSETTIA AVE # 101 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 2110 DREW ST # 100 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - CLEARWATER FL 33765 - 3231 BAY ESPLANADE APTS INC PARALITICCI, JESUS MICHAEL, BASKOVICH 2110 DREW STE STE 100 61.1. POINSETTIA AVE # 103 MICHAEL, SANDRA CLEARWATER FL 33765 - 3231 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2866 QUAIL HOLLOW RD W CLEARWATER FL 33761 - PARKS, DANA L STANLEY, BRYAN J BARKES, MICHAEL G 114 TURNER ST 11961 LOCUST LN CLEARWATER FL 33756 - COLUMBUS 1N 47201 - GLENNON, VICTORIA SOBOLESKI, JAMES W 10521E 1700 N RD 191 DEVON DR PONTIAC IL 61764 - CLEARWATER FL 33767 - CAY AT CLEARWATER BEACH MILLER, DIANE LYNN CONDO BROOKS, CAROLYN C 620 MANDALAY AVE 622 MANDALAY AVE CLEARWATER BEACH FL 33767 - CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1632 WISEMAN, SHANE 618 MANDALAY AVE # C CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1632 CLEARWATER, CITY OF PO BOX 4748 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 WAMO 1211 COURT ST CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 5801 POOK, PEACHES 234 DOLPHIN POINT RD # 1 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2110 CLEARWATER, CITY OF PO BOX 4748 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 OGILVIE, SCOTT 18 GLENDALE ST # 1 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1566 KNOWLES, NANCY 141 LAKESHORE RD E OAKVIL,LE ON L6J 1H3 00030 - CANADA PIERSON, DON C PIERSON, GLORIA G 5833 MARINER DR TAMPA FL 33609 - 341 1 BRUGGE,KATHLEEN BRUGGE, RICHARD 2628 SUNLIGHT DR ARLINGTON TX 76006 - ANDRESON,DEAN ANDRESON, ANN 2046 BRENDLA RD CLEARWATER FL 33755 - GEMETTE, GREGORY S ACKERMAN, GLEN H PO BOX 3176 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 8176 CHITRANEE-B INC 1003 BAY ESPLANADE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1019 PELLEGRINELLI, GUY A JR PELLEGRINELLI, MARY 459 FENN ST PITTSFIELD MA 01201 - 5262 BAILEY, DANIEL E RAII,EY, ANN H 1345 S MISSOURI AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6533 BROOKS, CHARLES E 11 HEILWOOD ST CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1623 13 HEILWOOD STREET LLC GENCO, FRANK RAII,EY, DANIEL E 7105 PELICAN ISLAND DR 3019 W PALMETTO ST RAII,EY, ANN H TAMPA FL 33634 - 7461 TAMPA FL 33607 - 2936 1345 S MISSOURI AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6533 MEROLI, PETER VON FELDT, PAUL G 967 ELDORADO AVE CLEARWATER BEACH FL 33767 - 1020 ALBANESE, MARIA G 9 CORNELIUS PKWY TORONTO ON M6L 2K2 00030 - CANADA PANORAMA ON CLEARWATER BEACH L 211 S MYRTLE AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - CALDERONI,PASQUALE THE CALDERONI, AIDA THE 4516 W NORTH B ST TAMPA FL 33609 - 2032 LOPEZ, CHARLIE 3307 W GRACE ST TAMPA FL 33607 - 5014 CLEARWATER, CITY OF PO BOX 4748 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 PANORAMA ON CLEARWATER BEACH L 211 S MYRTLE AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - CALDERONI,PASQUALE THE CALDERONI, AIDA THE 4516 W NORTH B ST TAMPA FL 33609 - 2032 LOOKRETIS, JOHN L YEAROUT, JANET A LOOKRETIS, SOPHIE YEAROUT, JAMES R 29 AVALON ST 806 NARCISSUS CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1602 CLEARWATER BCH,FL_33767=.1334 SOULOUNIAS, KALIOPE 30 KENDALL ST CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1624 XAN1A INC 1299 MAIN ST STE E DUNEDIN FL 34698 - 5333 SAMARKOS, ANTHONY M 106 MIDWAY IS CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2313 HAMILTON, H G HAMII,TON, JEAN B 10 BAY ESPLANADE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1603 MAG LAND DEVELOPMENT 3385 OLD KEYSTONE RD TARPON SPRINGS FL 34688 - 7800 PANORAMA ON CLEARWATER BEACH L 211 S MYRTLE AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - PALM PAVILION CLWR INC 18 BAY ESPLANADE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1603 WHITEHURST, DON R 1801 SE US HIGHWAY 19 CRYSTAL RIVER FL 34429 - 9065 ~RENDEL, JEROLD S THE 990 BAY ESPLANADE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1003 CLEARWATER, CITY OF PO BOX 4748 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 CALDERONI, PASQUALE THE CALDERONI, AIDA THE 4516 W NORTH B ST TAMPA FL 33609 - 2032 CALDERONI, PASQUALE THE CALDERONI, AIDA THE 4516 W NORTH B ST TAMPA FL°33609 - 2032 YEAROUT, JANE R YEAROUT, JANET A 806 NARCISSUS CLEARWATER BCH_FL.33767_-.1334 AERQ INC 22 KENDALL ST CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1626 HAMILTON, HOWARD G HAMILTON, JEAN B 909 BAY ESPLANADE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1112 NOSTIMO INC 1036 MCLEAN ST DUNEDIN FL 34698 - 3533 ROYAL CAMELOT LLC 5560 BATES ST SEMINOLE FL 33772 - SHEAR, L DAVID SHEAR, L DAVID BREEZEWAY INC 401 E JACKSON ST STE 2700 401 E JACKSON ST STE 2700 602 POINSETTIA AVE TAMPA FL 33602 - 5841 TAMPA FL 33602 - 5841 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1635 r~ U MEROLI, PETER 967 ELDORADO AVE CLEARWATER BEACH FL 33767 - 1020 AlELLO, ITALO RUFFOLD, LILIA 93 CORNELIUS PKWY TORONTO ON M6L 2K6 00030 - CANADA GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED PO BOX 152206 IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 PRESTON, MICHAEL G THE 419 EASTSHORE DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2028 FLORENCE ENTERPRISES 603 INDIAN ROCKS RD BELLEAIR FL 33756 - 2056 NATSIS, EVANGELOS NATSIS, MARIA 622 POINSETTIA AVE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1638 CHAPEL BY SEA CLEARWATER BCH C 54 BAY ESPLANADE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1607 SURFSIDE OF PINELLAS CONDO ASS 11 IDLEWII,D ST CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1563 GARBIS, WII,LIAM BUMGARNER, DANA GARBIS, GLENNA S BUMGARNER, MARTHA 7900 TAMELING 5303 ANSONIA CT ~PALOS _HII.,LS.IL.60465~1672 ORLANDO_FL.32839. -5249 EMERY, NEIL J EMERY, JOANN S 13101 APPLE AVE RAVENNA MI 49451 - 9755 WESTER, ROBERT M THE WESTER, PATRICIA A THE 6 WOODGLEN ST CHARLES MO 63304 - 7609 ROWE, ROBERT B THE ROWE, WENDY A THE PO BOX 3711 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 871 1 DYER, FREDERICK T DYER, ROSE L 210 E GOVERNOR PL ST CHARLES MO 63301 - 4573 BANNON, MARY KATHLEEN TRUST 8013 WII,DWOOD LN DARIEN IL 60561 - 5914 WESTER, ROBERT M WESTER, PATRICIA A 6 WOODGLEN ESTATES DR ST CHARLES MO 63304 - SOTTILE, BENJAMIN J SOTTILE, ILEANA 24 S PARK DR TENAFLY NJ 07670 - 3025 ROHEN, WILLIAM A 1704 N 12TH AVE MELROSE PARK II, 60160 - 2251 CLEARWATER, CITY OF PO BOX 4748 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 WALLACE, A BARBARA 606 CYPRUS AVE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1620 CHAPEL BY SEA CLEARWATER BCH C 54 BAY ESPLANADE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1607 WII,SON, WILLIAM D JR 245 SANDRIDGE CT ALPHARETTA GA 30022 - 7064 KINNARD, LOUIS R KINNARD, LUCRETIA L VIA S MARTA 24 _ FIRENZE-50139-00026-- ITALY HUNTER, RICHARD F HUNTER, PEGGY P PO BOX 3646 CHATTANOOGA TN 37404 - 0646 RASCONA, LISA RASCONA,ANTHONY 45 ELAINE DR STANFORD CT 06902 - 8312 SHAY, BRIAN J THE SHAY, STEPHANIE A THE 938 110TH AVE NE STE B405 BELLEVUE WA 98004 - 8510 ROHEN, WILLIAM 1704 N 12TH AVE MELROSE PARK IL 60160 - 2251 ROBERTS, GERALD D SHII,OH INV INC VILLAS OF CLEARWATER BEACH ROBERTS, PATRICIA K 3133 W 300 S CON 219 S INDEPENDENCE # 1 TIPTON IN 46072 - 8103 15 GLENDALE ST APT A14 TIPTON IN 46072 - 1932 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1514 MANUS, GEORGE E 9480 BRYNDALE WAY NE ADA MI 49301 - 8854 MANUS, GEORGE E 9480 BRYNDALE WAY NE ADA MI 49301 - 8854 TALON PROJECT 3437 OTHERDAY CIR SHAKSPEE MN 55379 - GUNTHER, EDWARD F GUNTHER, APPLE R 3 ASTOR CT LAKE FOREST II., 60045 - NAGENGAST, WILLIAM NAGENGAST, JUDITH E 925 ANDERSON FRANKLIN RD ANDERSON IN 46011 - 8737 MII,LARD, EVANGELINE G 15 GLENDALE ST # A-5 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1551 SAMPSON, THOMAS A SAMPSON, CAROLYN L 11 SAN MARCO ST # 1202 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - TALON PROJECT 3437 OTHERDAY CIR SHAKOPEE MN 55379 - 9615 i PAYETTE, R J III THE PAYETTE, BONNIE M THE 7946 31ST AVE KENOSHA WI 53142 - 4618 GUNTHER, EDWARD F GUNTHER, APPLE R 286 PRAIRIE VIEW LN WHEELING IL 60090 - 3223 NAGENGAST, WILLIAM E NAGENGAST, JUDITH E 925 ANDERSON FRANKTON RD ANDERSON IN 46011 - 8737 NELSON, EARL G NELSON, GLORIA M 2060 ARCADE ST ST PAUL MN 55109 - 2565 PORTER, THOMAS MORAITIS, DENIS PORTER, MARCELLA MORAITIS, MARY 2256 VICTORIA 147 AMBLESIDE RD WIl~TDSOR ON N8X 1R1 00030 - DES PLAINES IL 60_0162652 `CANAD'A IGGESUND TOOLS INC 220 SCARLET BLVD OLDSMAR FL 34677 - 3016 CORNELL, MICHAEL CORNELL, JANA 1525 WINDING WAY ANDERSON IN 46011 - 1661 HUCKER ENTERPRISES PO BOX 43 BERKELEY HTS NJ 07922 - 0043 LO, JAMES K LO, KAREN A 2966 POST ROCK CT TARPON SPRINGS FL 34688 - 7309 PARE, CAROL A 15 GLENDALE ST # 15 CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1552 JACKSON, LANKY R JACKSON, VICKI J 15 GLENDALE ST #A17 CLEARWATER BEACH FL 33767 - EVERETT, JOE S PO BOX 803 CLEARWATER FL 33757 - 0803 ROPHIE, RALPH A ROPHIE, VANESSA 450 PALM ISL SE CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1938 HUBER, RICHARD C HUBER, DIANE M 9217 SUNNY OAK DR RIVERVIEW FL 33569 - 5672 SIBERT, LUTHER L JR SIBERT, SHARON D 1199 SHIl'WATCH CIR TAMPA FL 33602 - 5740 PRESTON, MICHAEL G THE 419 EASTSHORE DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2028 GIBBON, JACK R JR 4725 SEYMOUR RD JACKSON MI 49201 - 7636 ADRIC, ALFRED C JR ADRIC, ALMUTH H IN DEN WEINGAERTEN 23A 65835 LIEDERBACH TS 00004 - GERMANY SANFILIPPO, JAMES A MARTIN, JOHN E 47 BLACK HAWK CT HOLMDEL NJ 07733 - 2523 HOUSH GHOVAEE NORTHSIDE ENGINEERING SERVICES, INC 601 CLEVELAND ST, SUITE 930 CLEARWATER, FL 33755 JAY KEYES CLEARWATER BEACH ASSOC. 100 DEVON DR. CLEARWATER, FL 33767 DOUG WII,LIAMS, PRESIDENT CLEARWATER NEIGHBORHOODS CORAL RESORT CONDO COALITION 483 EAST SHORE DRIVE 2544 FRISCO DR CLEARWATER, FL 33767 CLEARWATER, FL 33761 15 Avalon Wayne Wells FLD2005-01007 • LOWNDES CONSULTING INC. ;~ 7331 San Moritz Dr, Port Richey, FL 34668 Home/Fax (727) 844-3868, Cell Phone (727) 457-6804 Lowndes@earthlink.net Employee ID # 01-0642507 PANORAMA ON CLEARWATER BEACH, LLC REVISED REQUEST; THIS REVISED INCLUDES THE ACQUISITION OF ADDITIONAL PROPERTY TO BRING THE TOTAL LAND AREA TO 0.499 ACRES UP FROM THE ORIGINAL 0.299ACRES. THE HEIGHT OF THE BUILDING WAS REDUCED TO 52.67 FEET DOWN FROM THE ORIGINAL 65.9 FEET. THE UNDER BUILDING PARKING WAS REDUCED FROM TWO LEVELS TO ONE. THE REVISED SITE PLAN INCLUDES NEW AND IMPROVED LANDSCAPE BUFFER AREAS. THE SUBJECT REQUEST IS LOCATED IN BOTH THE MEDIUM HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL (MHDR) DISTRICT AND THE TOURIST ("T") DISTRICT. THE APPLICANT HAS HAD NUMEROUS MEETINGS WITH THE STAFF IN ORDER TO ADDRESS THEIR CONCERNS. AS A DIRECT RESULT OF THESE MEETINGS, THE APPLICANT HAS ACQUIRED ADDITIONAL PROPERTY, REDUCED THE HEIGHT OF THE BUILDING TO 56.67 FEET, PROVIDED A 3 FOOT TO 10 FOOT WIDE BUFFER ALONG THE WESTERN PROPERTY LINE ADJACENT TO THE CITY PARKING LOT. THE REDUCTION IN THE HEIGHT OF THE BUILDING IS BELOW THE BENCHMARK WHICH THE STAFF HAS STATED WAS 69.5 FEET SET BY THE APPROVAL OF THE CONDOMINIUM PROJECT AT 650 BAY ESPLANADE. THE LAND USES ADJACENT TO 650 BAY ESPLANADE ARE COMPATIBLE TO THE LAND USES ADJACENT TO THE SUBJECT REQUEST. SECTION 6-109 (TERMINATION OF STATUS AS ANON-CONFORMING USE); THERE ARE CURRENTLY 15 OVERNIGHT UNITS/ROOMS AT 15-16 KENDALL STREET AND 7 UNITS/ROOMS AT 21-27 AVALON STREET. THIS CALCULATES TO AN EXISTING DENSITY OF 35.175 DWELLING UNITS PER ACRE. WHEN ALL CONVERSIONS ARE FACTORED IN AND ALL DWELLING UNITS ARE TOTALED THERE ARE 19 UNITS THAT COULD BE PLACED ON THIS SITE. • • 2 THE APPLICANT IS ONLY REQUESTING 15 DWELLING UNITS. THERE ARE FOUR REQUIRED IMPROVEMENTS STATED IN SECTION 6-109: 1. INSTALLATION OF PERIMETER BUFFERS. THE APPLICANT IS PROVIDING A 10 FOOT WIDE LANDSCAPE BUFFER ALONG AVALON STREET EXCEPT AT THE DUMPSTER STAGING AREA AND ALONG THE EAST AND SOUTH SIDES OF THE PROPERTY. THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A REDUCTION IN THE LANDSCAPE BUFFER ALONG THE WEST PROPERTY LINE FROM 10 FEET TO 7 FEET. WHICH IS ADJACENT TO THE CITY PARKING LOT. 2. IMPROVEMENT OF OFF-STREET PARKING LOTS. THE APPLICANT IS REMOVING ALL EXISTING PARKING AND IS PROVIDING PARKING THAT MEETS THE CODE IN THE PARKING GARAGE. 3. REMOVAL OF NON-CONFORMING SIGNS, LIGHTING OR OTHER ACCESSORY STRUCTURES. THE APPLICANT IS REMOVING ALL EXISTING IMPROVEMENTS. 4. USE OF COMPREHENSIVE SIGN PROGRAMS AND COMPREHENSIVE LANDSCAPE PROGRAMS TO SATISFY REQUIREMENTS. THE COMPREHENSIVE SIGN PROGRAM IS NOT AVAILABLE UNDER THE CODE TO RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY. THE APPLICANT HAS SUBMITTED A COMPREHENSIVE LANDSCAPE PROGRAM TO SATISFY THE REDUCTION TO THE 10-FOOT LANDSCAPE BUFFER ALONG THE WEST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY. SECTION 2-404 (THE LEVEL TWO FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS AND CRITERIA FOR THE (MHDR) DISTRICT: FRONT SETBACK 15 - 25 FEET SIDE SETBACK 0 - 10 FEET REAR SETBACK 10 - 15 FEET MAXIMUM HEIGHT 30 - 50 FEET SECTION 2-803 (THE LEVEL TWO FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS AND CRITERIA FOR THE TOURIST ("T") DISTRICT: FRONT SETBACK 0 - 15 FEET SIDE SETBACK 0 - 10 FEET REAR SETBACK l 0 - 20 FEF_.T MAXIMUM HEIGHT 50 - 100 FEET • • THIS PROPOSAL MEETS THE ABOVE STANDARDS AND CRITERIA. SECTION 2-803B (ATTACHED DWELLINGS): 1. LOT AREA AND WIDTH: THE REDUCTION IN LOT AREA WILL NOT RESULT IN A BUILDING WHICH IS OUT OF SCALE WITH EXISTING BUILDINGS IN THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY OF THE PARCEL PROPOSED FOR DEVELOPMENT. THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY CONTAINS 2-4 STORY CONDOMINIUMS, MOTELS AND COMMERCIAL USES. IT IS OUR POSITION THAT THIS PROPOSAL MEETS THE ABOVE CRITERIA. 2, LOCATION: THE USE OF THE PARCEL PROPOSED FOR DEVELOPMENT WILL NOT INVOLVE DIRECT ACCESS TO AN ARTERIAL STREET. THIS PROPOSAL DOES NOT ACCESS ONTO AN ARTERIAL STREET; THEREFORE, MEETS THE CRITERIA. 3. HEIGHT: a. THE INCREASED HEIGHT RESULTS IN AN IMPROVED DESIGN AND APPEARANCE. b. THE INCREASED HEIGHT IS NECESSARY TO ALLOW THE IMPROVE- MENT OF OFF-STREET PARKING ON THE GROUND FLOOR OF THE RESIDENTIAL BUILDING. THIS PROPOSAL IS AN IMPROVED DESIGN AND APPEARANCE TO THE EXISTING RENTAL STRUCTURES THAT DO NOT COMPLY WITH THE OFF- STREET PARKING REQUIREMENTS OR THE LANDSCAPING ORDINANCE. THIS PROPOSAL WILL HAVE OFF-STREET PARKING AT GROUND FLOOR UNDER THE RESIDENTIAL UNITS AND LANDSCAPED AREAS GREATER THEN THE EXISTING USE. THE APPEARANCE OF THE PROPOSED STRUCTURE WILL BE FAR SUPERIOR TO THE EXISTING STRUCTURES. THIS PROPOSAL MEETS THE ABOVE CRITERIA. THIS REQUEST IS SIMILAR TO THE CHALETS ON WHITE SANDS CONDOMINIUMS WHICH HAS FIVE (5) LIVING FLOORS OVER GROUND LEVEL PARKING AT A HEIGHT OF 56 FEET. THIS PROJECT IS LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF SUMERSET STREET AND IS OWNED BY THE SAME DEVELOPER. THIS PRO.IECT .'VAS APPROVED BY THE C.D.B. ON NOVEMBER 19, 2002. CHATEAU ON WHITE SANDS CONDOMINIUM IS LOCATED ON THE • • 4 SOUTH SIDE OF SUMERSET STREET AND CAMBRIA STREET WAS APPROVED BY THE C.D.B. ON JUNE 15, 2004. THIS PROJECT HAS FIVE (5) LIVING FLOORS OVER TWO (2) LEVELS PARKING. THE HEIGHT OF THIS STRUCTURE ISbl.bb FEET. THIS PROPOSAL IS COMPATIBLE TO THE ADJACENT LAND USES AND WILL UP GRADE THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY. THIS PROJECTS DESIGN CREATES A FORM AND FUNCTION THAT ENHANCES THE COMMUNITY CHARACTER OF THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY AND THE CITY OF CLEARWATER AS A WHOLE THIS PROJECT MEETS THE CRITERIA ESTABLISHED IN SECTION 2-404F. FOR RESIDENTIAL INFILL PROJECTS. THE SUBJECT REQUEST IS LOCATED IN THE "OLD FLORIDA" DISTRICT AS REFERENCED IN THE BEACH BY DESIGN. THERE IS A STATEMENT THAT SAYS NEW SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS AND TOWNHOUSES ARE THE PREFERRED FORM OF DEVELOPMENT. HOWEVER, IN THE AREA OF THIS PROPOSAL SINGLE FAMILY WOULD NOT BE COMPATIBLE TO THE EXISTING PATTERN OF DEVELOPMENT. THE PROPOSED REQUEST IS MORE COMPATIBLE TO THE EXISTING CHARACTER OF THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY, WHICH IS CHARACTERIZED BY MULTI STORY (3-5 STORY) RENTAL STRUCTURES, MOTELS RESTAURANTS, AND RETAIL COMMERCIAL USES. THEREFORE, THIS PROPOSAL IS CONSISTENT WITH THE PURPOSE AND INTENT OF THE BEACH BY DESIGN DOCUMENT. THIS REQUEST SHOULD BE APPROVED BASED ON THE FOLLOWING: 1. THE PROPOSAL COMPLIES WITH THE FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA AS A RESIDENTIAL INFILL PROJECT. SECTION 2-404F. 2. THE PROPOSAL COMPLIES WITH THE FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA AS A COMPREHENSIVE INFILL REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT. SECTION 2-803C. 3. THE PROPOSAL IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH OTHER STANDARDS IN THE CODE INCLUDING THE GENERAL APPLICABILITY CRITERIA PER SECTION 3- 913. 4. THE PROPOSAL IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE SURROUNDING AREA AND WILL ENHANCE OTHER REDEVELOPMENT PROJECTS. 5. THE PROPOSAL IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE OLD FLORIDA DISTRICT OF BEACH BY DESIGN. • • RESUME RESIDENCE Frederick J. Lowndes 18521 Winding Oaks Blvd. Hudson, FL 34667 BUSINESS West Pasco County Gov't Center Growth Management/Zoning Dept. 7530 Little Road, Ste. 320 New Port Richey, FL 34654 PRESENT POSITION: Zoning Administrator - GROWTH MANAGEMENT/ZONING October 1, 1991 to Present. Directly supervises a staff of twenty (20) consisting of clerical, tech- nicians, and Code Compliance Officers. I~ prepare the agenda items on all rezoning, conditional use, special exception, variance and administrative appeals cases. I present the agenda items to the Planning Commission, Development Review Committee and the Board of County Commissioners. I am responsible for the interpretation and , the enforcement of Article 500 (Zoning) of the Land Development Code. I am a staff representative to the Land Development Regulation Committee during revisions to the Land Development Code. I often am called upon to testify in Court proceedings, i.e. condemnation and zoning cases. I do extensive research and analysis of data pertaining to zoning cases, administrative appeals and interpretations of the code. I frequently speak before civic associations, Rotary Clubs, and other groups. I have a thorough knowledge of Chapter 163, Florida Statutes and DCA Rules 9J-5, 9J-lI and 9J-16. I review and approve changes in operating procedures prior to adoption and implementation. PRIOR WORK EXPERIENCE: ASSISTANT PLANNING & ZONING DIRECTOR/ZONING ADMINISTRATOR. Pasco County Planning Department. August 25, 1985 to October 1991. Serve as the Assistant to the Director of Planning. Directly supervising a staff of fifteen (15) and in the absence of the Director supervise the whole staff of twenty-six (26). I am responsible for preparing and coordinating the County's Comprehensive Plan. I have a thorough knowledge of Chapter 163., Florida State Statutes and D.C.A. Rules 9J-5, 9J-11 and 9J-16. Research data on Vested Rights cases; prepare reports and present before the Board of County Commissioners. I make presentations on Rezonings, Variances, Special Exceptions, PUD's and other planning issues before the Planning Commission, Board of Zoning Adjustments and the Board of County Commissioners. I am frequently required to speak before Civic Associations, Rotary Clubs and the Committee of 100. I have a thorough knowledge of Subdivision and Site Plan Review. I am involved with Transportation Planning through our MPO .Section. ZONING ADMINISTRATOR. Frederick County Department of Planning and Zoning. April 1, 1979 to August, 1985. Served as the supervisor of the Department's Review Section directing and coordinating the County's subdivision review, zoning enforcement, site plan review, processing zoning certificates, and Board of Zoning Appeals (Variances and Special Exceptions); process, prepare and present reports on variances and special exceptions on Board of Appeals applications; write resolutions on the outcome of Board of Appeals cases; supervise the day to day operation of the Zoning Section of the • • Planning Department; participate in Board of Appeals and Planning Commission meetings; examine all site plans Ind suhdi.vision plats far c.nmrl.ilnce with regulations ~+nd present same at Planning Commission ~tieetings; review, prepare and present all rezoning cases to the Planning Commission and County Commissioners; write new zoning regulations; have properties inspected for violations to the Zoning Ordinance. PRINCIPAL ZONING EXAMINER. Board of Municipal & Zoning Appeals of Baltimore City. 1973 to April 1979. Review and process applications and plans for compliance with the Zoning Ordinance anti Subdivision Regulations of Baltimore City, supervise Zoning Examiners engaged in such work; investigate and prepare reports on complaints of zoning violations, and prepare cases for prosecution of violators; examined and reported on. applications for zoning and other municipal appeals; assisted in the preparation of plat plans, appeal form:,, and other data in connection with appeals; maintained file of legal zoning decisions, and kept zoning maps current in accordance with zoning changes; assisted in the review of proposed zoning legislation; conducted studies of existing zoning laws, and written new legislation; answered inquiries and advised individuals, organizations and official bodies on zoning regulations, enforcement policies or proposed legislation. ' SENIOR ZONING EXAMINER. Board of Municipal and Zoning Appeals of Baltimore. 1964 to 1973. Examined building and other applications for permits as filed with the Board for compliance with the Zoning Ordinance; made inspections, investigations and reports regarding complaints and zoning violations; answered inquiries of the public concerning zoning regulations and Lheir applications. Assisted the public in perfecting their appeals to the Board anti the scheduling of such appeals. Supervised three (3) employees, i.g. two (2) Senior Clerk Typists and one (1) Zoning Examiner. DRAFTSMAN. Bureau of Surveys - City of Baltimore. 1962 to 1964. Examined and reported on zoning appe:~.ls; maintained and revised Zoning Maps by City Ordinance; answered inquiries relating to zoning and tax appeals; made field inspections of properties involved in zoning appeals; maintained records, files and plats of the Department. Computed anal compiled records and prepared drawings; re-draw and revised block plats, checked builder's applications and other related civil drafting duties. ENGINEERING AIDE. Bureau of Surveys - City civil engineering inspections; assisted in helped to revise block plats and did other the public in securing information. SUBSTITUTE TEACHER. Subs*_itute teacher at Poly':echnic Institute EDUCATION: of Baltimore. 1960 to 1962. -Made minor determining and computing property lines; related civil drafting duties. Assisted Department of Education - City of Baltimore. 1960 to 1961. Hamilton Junior High School in i~iechanical Drawing; Baltimore in Engineering Shop. University of Maryland(T;dight School) - Behavioral & Social Science-B.A. Degree-1978. Community College of Baltimore - 1968 - A.A. Degree. Maryland Institute - Engineering, Architectural Drafting - 1965 - Diploma. Baltimore Polytechnic Institute - High School - 1960 - Diploma. University of Maryland - Course in Building Inspection - 1965 - Certificate. Department of Personnel of Frederick County - Supervisory Training - 1981. Civil Service Commission of Baltimore City - Supervisory & Management Training - 1967. -2- OTHER COURSES TAKEN: Stress Management Workshop - Bio-Feedback - Stress Management Institute, Columbia, MD. Advanced Management Prl~~ciples-Mt. St. Mary's College, rmmitsburg, Maryland. First Line Supervision - Frederick Community College Erosion & Sediment Control Training Program - State of Maryland Water Resources Administration. CONFERENCE PARTICIPATION: Zoning Roundtable - Coi.iference of Municipal & County Planning Commissioners - Held in Annapolis, Maryland - :;eptember 23, 1982. APA:Conference - Subdivision Process - Harpers Ferry, West Virginia - September 26, 1983. Taught Course in Zoniii;; & Subdivision Regulations to Real Estate Agents - March 26, 1984, Frederick Community College References: James Shaw, Director of Planning, Frederick County, MD 21701 (301) 694-1145 Dara Khoyi, 8906 Bermuda Lane, Port Richey, FL 34668 (813) 849-8104 Malcolm D. Davis, Felluws, Read & Associates, 1185 Mt. Aetna Road, Hagerstown, MD 21740 (301) 739-5660 Edward~Hutchins, 6301 Dogwood"Drive S., Neia Port Richey, FL 34653 (813) 847-3355 Samuel P. Steffey II, 7530 Little Road, New Port Richey, FL 34654 (813) 847-8132 -3- ~ ~ ~ i ._ _ -~ ~ ~ '~ y. ~: - b ~•• ~ • . :r /~/ . ~ ~ . i ,i ~~ ~ .~ ~~ ~ ~ I ,} ~ ~`_~ ~v~~~ccn ~zc~'~o~~i,n ~,~/J~~.,~rrcrra) ic~co»~ r,~c~%o~»~~.-,~`~c~ ~~~~~iiili~i~ c~~ir~:Jcin~.~1~ii~~;.rr~~~/nw,~z~~~~iiz~rfn~i~ n~f/~;/ncii~~~ n~ .f/~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~J f ~ / I ~J ~l I ~i /~ ~I ~~~~~~~J~,n11 DJI~ ~~~~Jl1n11~1.~1~.~1,.~~ ~lnli~ ~'L~~s~tz~ ~;~L;1~4';11;~!',~~r I ~ • J ~~I. •• r l/;~;~ir~ic;n~/~~ril'/r~~~~~i ~ ~-rr. ~ifc~G .l/;~~rr~~~fc~~~r~f%r ~%rt~, %i~~r.~'i ~/r't~7rr! ~,~' ~ J ,~n~ ~c%cn~ ~ ~:1%r~ n~ v '~ ~` ~ 11' ~` t .C It J ~ ~~ .~ 11~ It ~ ~ .~ ~;4.ti~~~ l.,.l~ ~...~~ ~.~ ~~~a ii-~l/~r~:~lf%;%n~2n~.y;/I'~~/lJ,:;rr~rrl~~~ir..-ch~c~•,t~c~rc~<~~1'~;rr//c~f~i~rr~r~, . •~ ~, iiarr~ ~c.,IJ;ri~crc ; f%iJ~~~~ h»>~rs .fir. »~R!,~ ;t~~~ merit%nir' ~~!; i~c~a~ ,~/f~~ ~l ri~ ~~ JrfJ;rx~t~ c .. c Grr~r~~: f~c;~~~/rn~~1`c:..lcr~li, ...•.-f%•`?lirr.~r~Jr~ ;,rJ;~~'~~rr»fr~ ../rc~~vut'%~~ .~ c.~~'~.~.~»~~~~~ ,ec' f~teen ~/ ,c~~u ~ ~ ~,ec~rr.Ge~~- ,r.». ~ ~ ~ ~-~ .~~iri~cu~ ;~irorcte~v,~~~t~c~,eeve~zt~,ec~/i~ D/.~. ~/~atinta~ts ~nr~rr~~~~~o»~e- ~sz°,&e.~,, ~~~~~~t i ~' • _., ~ ~ o~~~ ~, r ~~~~~~~~~~.~~~ ~~ ~ ~ TO ALL PERSONS TO WI-IOM TIIGSE I RESENTS MAY C0141Es, C~RI:L1'IN(~: f3L IT KNO~'VN TI~IAT F'r~~erick 1ohn5~n I~o~n~de~ HAVING COMPLETED ~THI: STUDIOS ANU :SATISf~IED Tf~IE REQUIREMENTS FOR TfIL i)EGREE Ot~ ~.~~o~i~ct~ i~..E~rts HAS [3CL'-N ADMITTED TO THAT DEGREE WI'1'I-f ALL THE HONORS, , RIGI~TS, AND PRIVII..I:GES THEREUN'1'U API'ERTAINTNG IN WITNESS WI•IEREOF Ti31S Uil'I_OMA I~AS [3t;I:N AWARDFU 13Y TIIE E30AitD O~'i'RUS-TI~tsS OF TI-If? CUMMUNI"fY COLLEGE OI' 13A1_TIMORE AC"1'INc; UNUER'I-I•IE AU'THORI'i'Y Oi~ 'T"IIE S'fA'tl: UI' MARYLAND AS C~NTAINEU IN'1"1 tl~ I'IZOVISIONS OF'1"l il: CIIARTER QF TFIE CITY OF 13AL"I"IMOItE Gi rrvr rrrtrlc•r nrrr /rends oral Ihr• sr•nl u/ /hr• c•ih~ n/ /!allinun•r Ilris r ~ninlh dcrp vl lone l y 68 ~,. I ~'gF.S10ENt OF pnAgp OF TqV EEe ~ '/A ..-, ..d ~ o ~ a c~ir %a,,u,Gtior ' - , . i.Pi ~ ~ , .~~2~ir .-~~~.ai ~ /r'j ~G' ~ ~~~Pi ~~ ~~/,/a' ~.Ai-Z~ ~~~.~1-L',~i~ ~~; ci'io~2. , D ~~~~~ ~~ ~.G iI~<P~' ~~~ ~ ~'"!" i~!!fZP~ ,.~,~.~~ , j~ZUd/CC~~t~i!'~°e~/~~~~z.~~t.- ~ ~ T :~ rep erlc~. ; o nsor~ ~ ~ cS ~ c~wn e~ . ~~ ~'~rclitreC ital~l"~~~tl . ~ ~~ / , lt~'LL/7.~1,/.it'',Pi/j~G~~'~,e,,~~u.~'~i~~L/~i~til~'tilli/,P ;r..1,~.P/j-~.i.~~~~rl~a'y~i~~•~cn~~ri~~ ~ ~~/,~zcee~1.'~.e~~7~~,~~o~,t~.Pi~7~~io~1~~rai,Gl~.~i,~1.c ~z2~a~-c~~o ,. S ~~GL/J~.G/.~//!~/,L7.'~/.~fr./~Yf .~~/jp~~~Gf.~~`.1~1.~/YP.I.I~O jIa~~~~P.~. C.~ . ~~~v~a~ .~.~r,G~~rcof~ ~~~ ~i, c~t111e 11.1965 a~~~ ~~ ~<:,, ~--.. , .. ~l ~.~Ye:..di.~ct 1w~ww~+~+w~ry.n..r - . a ~~tl#im~re ~nl~terl~ntr ~n~fifufp • BY AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF MARYLAND VESTED IN THE BOARD OF SCHOOL COMMISSIONERS UNDER PROVISIONS i OF THE CHARTER OF THE CITY OF BALTIMORE THIS ~t~lamtt • ' •HAS BEEN AWARDED TO .~~~d~~t.~~ J. ~~- . ~~~~~ . UPON THE SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF THE TECHNICAL CURRICULUM J.~r~v,r,~.,~zc~~.ou~~-.~ta~~~ .~zn~i~L'~v .~~,cr. ~~~~ Page 1 of 1 ORIGINAL Wells, Wayne From: Ann ERooney-Quinn [aerq@juno.com] Sent: Monday, April 18, 2005 4:37 PM To: Wells, Wayne Cc: aerq@juno.com Subject: Objection to FLD2005-01007 To :Wayne M. Wells & City Planning Department RE: Objection to proposal by Panaroma on Clearwater Beach LLC @ 15-27 Avalon St and 16 Kendall St. FLD2005-01007 Objections: Poor Design, Setbacks, Height, Timing etc. I ,Ann Rooney Quinn, President of AERQ, Inc, and owner of Snowflake Inn strongly object to any consenting of this project. My husband and I operate the Snowflake Inn, a small Mom & Pop Motel business at 22, 26, & 28 Kendall Street . We are adjacent to the above mentioned project and we strongly object to any approval of the proposed building project. We are participating in the Old Florida Districts hearings . Why is this item even under consideration while the proposed changes are being discussed? We hope and trust the City demands good designs, plans to utilize what they learn in the Old Florida meetings and expects high quality in terms of the developer and the builder. The proposed set back at the rear of our property is only 10 feet from our Cottages which have been in place for 40 years. The regular building set back is 15 feet which we feel should be maintained. The design is -again L shaped and minimal. The goal of Clearwater Beach Old Florida discussions was to build a community we could all be proud of, not one that is an embarrassment. The effective height of this upside down and backwards L shaped building will tower 6 stories which will be at least 60+ feet and at some points only 36' 10" wide. In the future, we maybe building 5 condos or 7 condo/hotel units. Those Panaroma Condo owners will then be clamoring to City Hall because of the loss of their view. In addition to this, we,question the ability of the developer to 1) keep the construction site clear enough & clean enough to maintain safe egress for the tourists & the public to get to the beach and back, 2) maintain the safe passage of fire trucks who may have to navigate the street 3) provide Garbage Collectors access so they can maintain services and 4) maintain the sanitary conditions of the Porta- Potties. 5) properly position the construction crane to provide easy access on the Street Our concern is based upon personal observation of this developers project at 14 Somerset St. We feel this project should be put on hold till these concerns are addressed. Ann Quinn Snowflake Inn 1 877 879-4484 toll free 22 Kendall St. North Clearwater Beach, Fl. 33767 www. snowflakeinnclearwater.com 4/19/2005 • • Wells, Wayne From: Wells, Wayne Sent: Tuesday, April 19, 2005 8:48 AM To: 'fig@fhlaw.net' Subject: 15 Avalon Street Jerry - Attached is a letter of objection. Wayne Email from Ann E. Rooney Quinn...