Loading...
10/24/2001 (2) , . " : .' ., " 'L . ',. ," ';' " ~. ':' \ ~,;'., I., l;" ' . . .: " " . I " " ' ., 'I', ',' " .' .. , .,' . >. >t.: .' " ; .' :' ~ ': ' ..',.".. + '" '. ~. ,. . '. I, '. . .. . ~~. I" "I, :;~:'~'l./;'.'I,.~\i,.,\,-:;.. ':." " ',.,: " , ~ 1 e!' :. .\ ;,:, \'. , " ,\1 ~ ",.: i '. ,,) " T~~ ~ :+: ,. , :~'.f : .~ .:' ",./ ~L l ~ J '. . '" "'~:".... . , ., .'. .' ;:':.' !l-;:..I , ~ ' :' , ;' :(1' . . L:.I;;' '," > I~ ~ ' ,::":-'" ,;.'/. 1,".' .'. -'c' t'le " , I! ~ \ ~~. .': .t:.,,:>. . 'I , ' j. YC~.f::: :I'\~ ~ .:.'~"" ~ ;};'i:,::::},:, , ?::./;:'\/...":: ',' " . . ~ <: .er f;":';:S t. >' ~,,::.d. 1\:\',. ' ., '.,'. ''t< ':'. . ,. , ~..::i i , ., (, ~ , ~l:::.. ., , " ,. ;:::~: . '.' :.;:.T;'. ,'ll}, . .1 . " .. . , " '!;' ~. " ,. , \. . ',: ~ . .'. :-: o#-.~:. h .~, +, '. ti . , 'J . ,. .... . '!; ,t I ..'~. :T/ ".' .?~. , ' /. ~ '. , '. . " ~ .,:. , , , .! . \ I ., ~ . . j . ~ " ,. " . '. ~ . ",f Date \ ': ,. '.!p; . ,.,: ;~. . . . " . ' : ' . 'I,' !;. , " '., . " . :1, .\ " .i ~. .. '. :j' ,\ " . ~" "0 , .' ~ ,', t. d .' ., ,. " .~ ,\ .' , /"" :: _,' t, h ~...' ,. ..... >~. 'J. .. ;i". '4, :' I. i .1 ., j I . ~ ". \, " , ': ~ . , ~. '":'> ., , . " ./ :' ell" ,'1. , ., '- '..' '" j)/' '. , . .' MCEB ',er" ',1" I ." I , '.; " ~ i I . I . M:unl~ipal' Code.~nf~rceme~tBoard: .,'.... Minutes fI' " ..1 " I, J " I Ol'~.lflo J f' .. ". " ' .: , ,~ '.... .,' ", . , :1. . ,. " I'" .. '.,' ~ .., ,. , ~ . . . (\ " . , ..1 '.. ... , '" '\: ,1 " ., ." <'.; '.' " .: l I" ,. I. ~ I v I : " ., :_~: t I > ~e " '-, ,. > ;:;(!'7 .. , ., , .' , ,. . . . ; ~. ~ :.' ,I " . " ',. ,'" ,t '.. ~ ".;.;.; '",":: ~"."'i\',": '. ~ .1..... .", -:. "'.. .:'~ l:\d:l , ,,' .. .j""'" +..' ~r'i~~:':" ,?"~.>.,,:.:; .. \ ;, ~~. , ,; ,;::'::~. . .., ACTION AGENDA CITY OF CLEARWATER MUNICIPAL CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD . October 24, 2001 .3:00 p:m. () , . ."'1. PUBLIC. HEARINGS ~' , ':, T : '. , '~ 'I, I: . <1 ..' .,1.0 ','c . /,;:/, '~ , /.,,: . A, Case 16M01 - (Cont. from 4/25/01). Adriano Battaglini . 500 N. Ft; Harrison Avenue. (Development Code/Landscape) - Kurleman . Withdrawn per Section 7-102(C), B, Case 40~O 1 Comple.te, Automotive Repair 203 S. Myrtle Avenue (Development Code/Sign) - Fox Continued to 11/28/01 , , "c. Case 41M01 Loni J, Shutler. 273.1 Poppyseed Court , (Building Code) - .Coccia . . . Ordered comp1ian~e within 30 days or $1 OO/day D, .Case 42-01 Richard A. Hoffman. and Maxine I Nordmann 1 91 9 Kings. Highway (Building Code) - Coccia Continued to 11/28/01 2. UNFINISHED BUSINESS A. Case 26-01 - Affidavit of Compliance lfran and Advije Ismaili , ' 620 S. Betty Lane . (Building Code) -"Wright Acc~pted ' . . B. Case 27M~1 - Affidavit of Compliance Ifran and Advlje Ismaili , 622 S;. Betty Lane . (Building Code) -. Wright ~ccepted .. C. Case.29-01 - Affidavit of Non~Compliance Sonny's ~SuperService Stations, Inc. ' 1 3.10 Cleveland Street . (Development Code/Sign) Fox ' Accepte.d; Issued order imposing fine 10/24/01 , 1; .' . c ' , ' -t,l; . . '....,.1 ," ,I..~,"'I";",":'.'I .-<.iII,.......~./ '.',"',:"Itl.j',',~.::", ~I' ',"" . ~ :rt ..'. .... .... ~' . .... ;.... ~ ~:', '."". ....... r.' ':, ", .~'... ......;.....{ '.':. ..:....:...:.'..:. ~'I':" ~....... ..:...~. ":"':'. ';. ....:.. ...... ",""..' , , "i ~~: .' ~~ ~.:,' . + .. ',,, .. < .... " . '.. 'I . < '. , . . .' . ~ . . . , .' . t.' >,"1,.,. " ..; , , " < '. ( . ,., '" I D; Case ,1.S-()1 - Affidavit of Non-Compliance , Clearwater Moose Lodge #1,030 1101 Cleveland Street II") (Development Code/Landscaping) - Kurleman ." ',^ ~ccepted; Issued order imposing fine , .' 3. OTHER BOARD ACTION/DISCUSSION , , A, Rules of Procedure, . .Dlscussed; continued to 11/28/01 B. December Meeting , Canceled 4. NI:W BUSINESS. none . 5. NUISANCE ABATEMENT LIEN FILINGS - Accepted .,. , I, . , . .3 r . " . ~. " , .' Agnes Bach 14,30 North Highland Avenue Highland Terrace Manor, Blk H. Lot 8 , . I Susan Bell 1128 Carlton .Street Greenwood Park, Blk H, Lots 29-30 'E. Bradford. 111 South Belcher Road . See 1, 8-2~-1.6, Metes & Bounds 23/03. . Norton and Bessie Clearwater Sr. . 2301 South Corona Avenue Skycrest Unit 5, Blk D, Lot 9 . , Stuart Eiseman . , . 1 531 Ridgewood Street Glenwood, Lot 118 Carol Fildes . .' 102 South Evergreen Avenue Tagarelli Sub, Blk 2, Lot 1 . , Angela Glidden 11 28 Palm Bluff Street Greenwood Park.#2, Blk F, Lot 7 Robert Hall "844 Overbrook Avenue 'Sunset Polnt.1 st Addition, ~Ik 0, Lot 8 I Oliver Harrison . . 1344 South Washingto.n Avenue '. Lakeview Heights, Blk B, Lot 24 1 0/24/01 o COD2001.04355 $ 250.00 COD2001-03858 . $ 200.00 COD2001-04592 $ 250.00 COD2001-03630 $ 283.00 COD2001-04614 $ 250.00 . . COD2001-05002 $200.00 COD2001-04116 $ 250,00 COD2001-04290 $ 28~ .00 COD2001-05271 $ 250.00 2 '. . . . 4.~ 1+ ,"', \.... ..... ..... L . " J.. .. _ .'\:. I ..'.. .'. " I ,': .' ~ .: 1 . f'~' '. i" . " J :. . ,::..' ;,'. ,. . " " , . . ~ , ' , , : ': ~ /.. ,J, '. i,,',T),>,:~\,'~";;:j' :" " , ," ,,' ';) .,. ,/<:;..< , " , '~ ~ .:: I! , . . ,n , : L..~~ r ,'.> . , ~ ' . . - . " ,. "\ ~ ' , . ' I,. . ~. I .. : " I ~ . , ;} ... .' > .. , . 0', " . ".'John Harvey . ,. 11 30 Queen Street Alfred Ennis Sub, Lots' 6 and 7 . Trlsha M, Jacobs 718 Fairwood Forest Drive Fairwood Forest, Lot 102 Elbert Madsen 41'2 Pleasant Street North Shore Park, Blk 7, Lot 18 Albert Morrison 1503 North Saturn Avenue Skycrest Greens, Lot 5 COD2001-04153 $284.00 . COD2001-04900 $ 550.00 COD2001:,05135 $ ,250.00 COD2001-04859 $ 250.00 Neyrey Financial Group Inc C00200 1-05224 905 North Fort Harriso.n Avenue. $ 278.00 Ira E. Nicholson's. Addition, Blk 3, Lot 4 . Willie .Parker 1129 Grant Street . 'Greenwood Park, 81k 8; Lot 3 COD2001-04404 $ 200.00 , ,Emilia and Guiseppe Planzo COD200 1-04480. 1768 Druid Road East $ 250.00 Hollingsworth Estates', Lot 21" Is E7' ROW . Charles Rutledge Tre .1109,LaSalle Street Greenwood Park #2, Blk F; Lot 30 Juan Valdez 2233 Hemerick Place Palmetto Terrace, Blk C, Lot 9 COD2001-04981 $ 200.00 COD2001-04297 $' 250.00 . 6. . APPROVAL OF MINUTES - 9/26/01 - Approved as submitted " ,7. . ADJOURNMENT - 3:33 p.m: , 0.'11". , ' I ., , . . 1 0/24/01 .,': ..1, ", J t,.'. L L ".' .'i;..';': " . 3 .' '. ,. .1 ,,, ., . .i ", ~ .t. ., ,. '. c.', .,~t , . .' ~ , c', ,. , ..,~ . I: . } ....' . 'i,', C.' " > ~ I , tli\ ~.:.' ifd' .u....; . ' , '. ~ . ., . : . . ~, I . ' '.'.:'-" >. ~"1\/< 1< \' '.. . . , ~ .t I, .." ,. . ,; :'. . c. .,. ~, \ '. .. '.' ' '.' " ' 1 ~ . t' , .' c I " I ~:. ' "', ".'< j.' . "., . . I I MUNICIPAL, CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MEETING CITY OF CLEARWATER . October 24; 2001 Present: . ., I Helen Kerwin Sheila Cole Franke Huffman Joyce Martin Peter Caffentzis David Allbritton Chair Member Member Member Member Member .Absent: '. Lawrence Tieman Vice-Chair ., Also, Present: . Lesli~ Dougall-Sides Andy Balzm'an Sue Diana. Brenda Moses , Assistant Clty Attorney Attorney for the Board Secretary for the Board , Board Reporter The Chair called the meeting to order at 3:03 p,m. at City Hall. To provide continuity for research, items. are in agenda order although not necessarily discussed in that order, ., The Chair outlined the procedures and stated any aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative,order of the Municipal Code Enforcement Board to the Circuit. , Court of'Pinellas County within thirty (30) days of the execution of the order. . , . FI~rida Statute 286.0105 requires any party appealing a decision of this Board to have a record of the proceedings. . 1. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Caso 16-'01 - (Cont. from 4/25/01) Adriano Battaglini 500 N, Ft, Harrison Avenue (Developme'nt Code/Landscape) -. Kurleman Withdrawn per Section 7-102(C) Per Sec. 7-.102(C) of the Community Development Cod.e, as the violation . was corrected, the item was continued automatically to this meeting. As no recurrence of the violation h.as occurred, the item is withdrawn. . B. Case 40-01 , Complete Automotive Repair 203 S, Myrtle Avenue (Development Code/Sign) - Fox Continued to 11/28/01 Case 40-01 has been continued to the November 28, 2001, meeting. mcb1001 1 10/24/0'1 ~ . I '1 I '.' ...'.'l~' ,-," ",1 ,,:.':1. ;'. ~.~ ',' ~: 1,\, "l: ....:.', "~.~'L':':.':':'.:;.' '4" ".,' >l~" '...'": "." ~~,.'\:""':~ ~ , (1;~) "J(I;r;\l o , ,. C. Case 41.01' . Loni J.Shutler 2731 Poppyseed Court (Building ,Code) ~ Coccia Board Secretary. Diana read the Affidavit of Violation & Request. for Hearing. . Service on the .notice of hearing was obtained by certified mail. It was noted that no one was present to represent Ms. Shutler. In. response to questions from Assistant City Attorney Leslie Dougall-Sides, City Inspector Mike Coccia said the property had come to his attention on June 20, 2001, following an anonymous complaint. He observed a new patio structure and a new six-foot fen~e had been built without permits or inspections. He posted a . notice .of violation on the property on June 20, 2001, sent the notice'via certified and regular mail on July 30, 2001, and posted it at City Hall. He spoke to Ms. . Shutler on May 21, 2001 regarding the violation. She said her friends had helped her build, the structures and indicated she would obtain engineering drawings and permits. Mr. Coccia said he has not heard from her since that time and no permits or inspections have been done. He was unaware of any electrical violations" as he was not able to enter the property. He recommended the property owner could come into compliance within 30 days: . ' Ms. Dougall-Sides submitted City Exhibits 1- 8. Member Huffman moved that concerning Case 41-01, the Municipal Code EnfoTcement Board has heard testimony at its regular meeting held on October 24, 2001, and based on the evidence issued its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order as follows: . FINDINGS OF FACT - After hearing testimony of Inspector Mike Coccia for City (Respondent was not present and had no representation) and viewing the evidence., . City Exhibits 1-8 [Ex. 1 - notice of violation and order to stop work; Ex. 2 - notice of violation and receipt for certified mail; Ex. 3 - affidavit of posting; Ex. 4 - property appraiser printout; Ex. 5 - affidavit of violation and request for hearing; Ex. 6 - notice of hearing; Ex. 7 - code sections; and Ex. 8 - composite photos dated 1 0/2~/O 1}, it is evident the property is in violation of the City code in that a patio deck and overhang and fence were constructed without permits and/or inspections. CONCLUSIOr\lS OF LAW - The Respondent by reason of the foregoing is in violation. of Chapter 47, Article IV, Section 47.083(2) and Article V, Section 47.111 of the Code of the City of Clearwater, Florida, in' that the Respondent has failed to remedy. the cited violatlon(s), ORDER - It is the Order of the Board that the Respondent is to correct the aforesaid violation by within 30 days (November 23, 2001). The burden shall rest upon the Respondent to request a reinspect ion by the Code Inspector to verify, compliance with this Order. mcb1001 2 10/24/01 ,'I; . ' . ,I \ . :':c:r."\,: .""1 F' . \ ... i~ / . >, ,r'j >.:.;,,~, " . 1;'.:"".\ V ,r.", e ; :. ~ '. 'Ie , , . . . , . " In the event the' aforesaid violation Is found, in subsequent proceedings by this Board, not to have been corrected on or before November 23, 2001 ~ the Resporldent may be ordered to pay a fine in the amount of one hundred and nol100 .dollars ($100.001 per day for each day the violation continues beyond November . 23, 2001. . If Respondent does not comply within the time specified, a certified copy of the Order imposing the fine may be recorded in the Public Records of Pinellas County, Florida, and once recorded shall constitute a lien against any real or personal property owned by the Respondent pursuant to Chapter 1 62 of the Florida Statutes. Should the violation reoccur, the Board has the authority'to impose the fine at that time without a subsequent hearing. Any aggrieved party may petition the Board to reconsider or rehear any Board Order resulting from a public hearing. A petition for rehearing must be made in writing .and filed with the Board Secretary no later than thirty days after the execution of the Order and pri.or to the filing of any appeal. Upon receipt of the petition, the Board will consider whether to reconsider or rehear the case. The , Board will not hear oral argument or evidence in determining whether to grant the p.etition to reconsider or rehear. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously, D. Case,42-01 , Richard A. Hoffman.and Maxine I Nordmann , 1 91 9 Kings Highway' (Building Code) - Coccia Continued to 11/28/01 ,Case 42-01 has been continued to the November 28. 2001, meeting. 2. UNFINISHED BUSINESS A. Case 26-01 - Affidavit of. Compliance . Ifran .and Advije Ismaili 620 S, Betty Lane .. (Building Codel - Wright B. Case 27.01' - Affidavit of Compliance. Ifran and Advije Ismalli 622 S.. Betty Lane (Building Code) - Wright Member Cole moved to accept the Affidavits of Compliance for Cases 2~-01 and 27-01. The motion was duly seconded and 'carried unanlm~usly,. ., , mcb1001 3 10/24/01 . , : :.. y:,.;:.t. :j.::;,:<."." , ~, ,. .: ,. , , '~t~; ~ -. 1'- 1 . ,. ~ ':,.,.t~ ." "'. /," "~ <~ ,-.' ! . \' ..' :. . ~, , .1\ :. '. . . .. I' l ~. , I . I :.' ,I: ~ .' ,'tl, . ' C. Cas,s 29-01 . Affidavit of Non-Compliance . Sonny's'Super Service Stations, Inc', 1310 Cleveland Street IDevelopment Code/Sign) Fox , . D.. Case 15-01 - Affidavit of Non-Compliance Clearwater Moose Lodge # 1030 1101 Cleveland Street . (Development Code/Landscaping) - Kurleman. , Member Huffman moved to accept the Affidavits of Non-Compliance and issue the orders imposing the fines for Cases 29-01 and 15-01, The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously, . 3. OTHER BOARD ACTION/DISCUSSION . A. Rules of Procedure , ' , Discussion ensued and the following changes were suggested: 1) standiuizing words; 2) adding language regarding the Board's role being only to dete~mine if a violation exists and not to. suggest possible remedies; and 3) adding language s~ating the Board may limit presentations at their discretion, Board Attorney.Salzman recommended language limiting presentations be added to the opening statement and rather than adding to the rules, the Board adopt' as policy not to suggest corrective actions for the violators, B. December Meeting Discussion ensued regarding the December meeting, Consensus was to cancel the meeting unless cases arise that must be addressed, 4, NEW BUSINESS - None. 5. NUISANCE ABATEMENT LIEN FILINGS Agnes Bach 143q North Highland Avenue Highland Terrace Manor, Blk H, Lot 8 COD2001-04355 $ 250.00 , Susan Bell 1128 Carlton Street Greenwood Park, Blk B, Lots 29-30 COD2001-03858 $ 200.00 , E, Bradford . 111 South Belcher Road . Sec 18-29-16, Metes & Bounds 23/03 COD2001-04592 $ 250.00 . mcb1001 4 10/24/01 ;. , .' ., " .. ' . ~ :.: .....:; ~ .~~...>:~J,+.'I:..:, .i:'.\,:;:,:;,:~~.., '~~~r:~:c:"~ .'~"'.'~ "" . . I ., < '. ,.' ,. . ~ ~ L I . . .. , ~" ., . ',. l' '..E. . , . :. .(') ,) i...": , > Nor~on and Bessie Clearwater Sr, 2301 South Corona Avenue Skycrest Unit 5, Blk 0, Lot 9 , : Stuart Eiseman 1 531 Ridgewood Street GI,enwood, Lot 118 ;.. Carol Fildes 102 South Evs'rgreen Avenue Tagarelli Sub, Blk 2, Lot 1 .:' t.l':. L .: : "> . .... c.: ~, F Angela Glidden 1128 Palm Bluff Street Greenwood Park .#2, Blk F, Lot 7 ~.<:.."" ~::.:. . L\":' . COD2001-03530 . $ 283.00 COD2001.04614 $ 250.00 COD2001.05002 $ 200.00 COD2001-04116 $ 250.00 . Robert Hall COD2001-04290 .1844 Overbrook Avenue $ 281.00 Sunse~ Point 1 stAddition, Blk 0, Lot 8 . . Oliver Harrison COD2001-05271 1344 South Washington Avenue $ 250.00 Lakeview Heights, Blk B, Lot 24 ,- , , .~ : '... (. " :,,~' l_~ . John Harvey' 1130 Queen Street . ., Alfred Ennis. Sub, Lots 6 and -j '. I Trisha M. Jacobs 718. Fairwood Forest Drive Fairwood Forest, Lot 102 ,. Elbert Madsen 412 Pleasant Street North Shore Park, Blk 7, Lot 18 Albert Morrison 1503 North Saturn Avenue Skycrest Greens, Lot 5 Neyrey Financial Group Inc 905 North Fort Harrison Avenue Ir!3 E, Nicholson's Addition,Blk 3, Lot 4 Willie Parker. 11 29 Grant' Street Greenwood Park, Blk, B, Lot 3 ' () mcb1001 5 , . ;' . 1,1.~ -: ~ . COD2001-04153 $ 284.00 COD2001-04900 . . $ 550.00 COD2001-05135 $ 250.00 COD2001-04859 $ 250.00 COD2001-05224 $ 278.00 COD2001-04404 $ 200.00 10/24/q1 , . .., ., - , " ~ I ..., t.~. ,r~. J I I,' '.. J i-,. .r .) , J I , ' , " ., ': ~' ,. , . . ;~~:.t-' :.:!~ .:3 ;\0 ':. ,',"i" ", . , 'I. .' , \. '. ..~ ' .. , ,. .' t, . '. .. . l ,j'. '. . i,\'.i'~ '.. " , ~?",;.:,:\ ',. /. 1. I, ,. ,~ . f . '. Emilia an'd GulseppePlanzo COD2001-04480 .,1768 D,ruid Road East' $ 250.00 ;Hollingsworth Estates, Lot 21 less E7' ROW '.'.0. " :' ' ~}:>', ' +, '. ....~ J.,\ f ~ " 0 .... ., ~: i ,. , . ~ '. ._. 0 ,. ...eh'arle.s Rutledge Tre ,.1109 LaSalle Street. Greenwood Park #2, 81k F, Lot 30 COD2001-04981 $ 200.00 ~' , . ,. J , . <I.,' . ., . "y' 'i . , , . "' ' ' . ~ '1" ,,' , .0. ;/.<' ~'~,,:.(.f, .. ;"'ll, ::~'" ..., Juan Valdez 2233 Hemerick Place Palmetto Terrace, Blk C, Lot 9 COD2001-04297 $ 250,00 Member Allbritton moved to moved to accept the nuis~nce abatement lien : filings. T~e motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously, i,~ ,:,; : . ?~!:.:/:.,..., '.' .. ~ , . (f' ; ,". ; " ,; 6, APPROVAL OF MINUTES - 9/26/01 ' ..., . ~,'. .- ',. ,> " " . ~ '\ I '. I . ., Member Huffman moved to approve the minute,s of the regular meeting of .' '. September 26, 2001, as submitted in written summation "to each board member. , " ,The motion. was duly seconded and carried unanimously. .... , ,~ , ,~ ',., .7. ADJOURNMENT. I~ \~ . The me~ting adjourned at 3=3~ p.m. Attest:' MuniCipal :Code Enforcement, Board ~ . .ez'.. .- , , . . . . ~ ~~ -()~hair !~ the Board ; , .. . " " lo ',' '01; , .' .','. ' ;'., :1 , ' ',' " '. ' :-':.'~.O. .!. "\, . '. ..' . < ~ t. ' < 'I ' . f mcb1001', '.6. . ,.10/24/01 .' ./ . .' ., , . , . , .. " , . ]i ,.;~; -~.: -, ..:....< .... -..' w., 'h':'.'A"~"J!, j. :,'H1;\"'L\":.": "."\ ".;, .~;. .' .~;.h;j'i;.:I";J:,W'{'..'.':i: I:~; I .":';,,:j',~,,:"~~li~;>'i,"{~"::;'.:.~~""'\ ',. ",:".\ . h'..), !~,.;:";!,, '::';~;,:..}/J .,:: d~J. ':;.:, :'::." \1'~'~l.~'~,,;~.);rB:,:;;~