10/04/1995
,I. " " , I " , ' I ~ I ' " , ' . ~, ,. '. ." . ,~ ' . , f , '. :, I ,. ': .. .' ., ,4 ~. " ,'~ .: . . .;.... ',~ '
!,";:Yir;:,\'.
'- l ~ j'. {( " ,
" .1' ,.\\ I.. "
\' '~',
, . >1 > ~ .
'"
'".,[j'
,',
", T
.. I:~
,'+' ',.: ,.:.
1 . ;' < ~ . '::
I'
\' ,,~; .t<,'
"
, \,
c'.1
.. ~,II I',
".
,',
I,
,~' ;-
J'
c ~~~\''1 >.
., ~'
, "
~;j>..
~ '
"t.
'.' ~ f ,
_,1:,
'"
',I;,
;,
l,.ft, ,
1 , ~ i ,
'I ; ~',
,I, >..
i"'"
,H,
\'
, It':. ':
,'p,
, ".
,I
i i
I':
t,,'
"
?
. ~,~ I
":' I ' '
t ',Il
: '
~"II
j' "
. ,
c ~, . ' .' ~
~. , ,'~
:J:,~' :
~',I -:,'. ,O.~,:' :~,./,
,':;\.:" ":~'>(:>'.-
,~ . .. '...
";,, :1',';
.!, :,',i',. '.
'.
"
'...V}, :
,!
, ..-
."
,
, f~' ,
, ";/)/,:'" \,'
, ". .,... j: ~'
:'<:','
't.
,', t.
I,
",:'
L '. cO
,,'.
'~ I;,:r
l,,/
. ~ ' '\ ~ ~,
,:
, ,
",1
;,',l
','
','
, "
'., I;'
"
"
(' . :.\ '.7 . T 'c'
';i}~" ,..' :' ,\,
ac\,U,~;:"N'H''''''
. ',\,
1 ' ~:,"
"
.,' }~,.
,;.}
).
"
I > c ~ ~ : ~
or t.' . ~ ii, 'I, c' 0, '~.., , '
: .. .t"-. """'" ..,J.r'fl :..,.. ~ ..t ...~" 'N'H:"":' ":,'~.q,.,,,>.,..,.~, sit.: .'1:-r!~ ~"t~ ;1;,.. > :.': ,!-'.I:.I'~~:I~ '-.' 'I(~ ~.,.;: "/cc fot",.., ~ f q A'!
I '
" ,i
','
~ L
'.
',' I,
! '
'.1>
"
': :':':~I":' , <",,' (\ . l ~,." '" . ,
, "
I
+i,
t'
;.
Ii,:
;,';,1..:
,I,
l
;:,
"
'.t'
.L
I' '
,f> It,
"
"
I,
" '
;: ' .' .
.1
"
p'
~. ' .
. 'I ~
!'
! 1:
,.
,"
r,:
\.
. ,
,'..
, "
"
PAC
,.
I
',I
(
"I
"
(t
~ 'I
'j
t,;.,
,Pension AdvisOl)7 Committee'
: ',. ." .
Minutes
;.<
'.'
. '>.
., C.j,
',' '
"f.
I. 1..:
"
;. . . ~ I
".1
If) - () if - qs
'.Date
"
i,
"l
/ {)/f
, '
:,
Ed Hooper. Chairman
Fred Ratley. Member
Richard Breest, Member
I '
,,,u,~ .
\ ,~c:- '
. ',l"
Proceedings' of the Pensio,n Advisory Committee Meeting of October 4.' 1995. Page
Prescnt:
Deborah Ford, Human Resources Department
H. Michael Laursen. Human Resources Director
Timothy DeBord. Firefighter
Jon Marcin, Risk Management Specialist
Gary Lutman. Mechanic II,
Leo Thompson, Spray Technician
The meeting was called to order at 9:02 a.m.
Richard Brcest moved to' approve the minutes of September 27. 1995. The motion was duly
seconded by Fred Ratley and carried unanimously.
With respect to the request from Timothy DeBord, Firefighter, Fire Department, for
a job-connected disability pension, Mr. DeBord submitted a'letter with an impairment rating
from, Dr: ,Davis and several other medical reports. His IME is scheduled for October to.
With respect to the request from Gary MlIarck, Marinc Facility Operator,
Marine Departmcnt, for a job-connected disability pension, we are waiting for a new letter
, from his doctor. He will be here on October 18,
.,;?I
;~ ' ~
',':-,
",;
~j,:
"/ 'I
'J\~:'
'\'
;\ ';
c~ 't~,
: I:,'
1 ~ ~
},II
:fi
t'l"
I;..;,
;t')
~/.
( '~'I \
,.,1
.' ,;-
,,'
:J){,
,"
l /
~ ,....
With respect to the
I}ivision, General
still pending.
request from William Matlin, Mcchanic II, Fleet Maintenance
Services Department,for a job-connected disability pension, this is
With respect to the request, from Linda Traub, Container Maintenance WorkcJ
Solid Waste Department, fora job-connected disability pension, we are waiting for the IME
report.
With respect to the request of Cora Bennett, widow of Ernest Bcnnctt, Solid Was t c
Worltcr, Solid Waste Dcpartment,for a survivor's pension, we are still waiting for the
legal opinion.
; ,'I
'.:1 ~
,\',.'/
:i; r
, "'\
'\-k
,f"
I" ','
':;"i
.: ~:~l;
j:
),,:
;. '\
{r
With respect to the request from Lco Thompson, Spray Technician, Parks &
R4:!creation Departmcnt, for a job-connected disability pensIOn. at the last meeting it was
, determined; that his letters were not acceptable. Mr. Thompson was not informed of the, change
in .time. The Committee deferred action on this until later in the meeting since Mr. Thompson
was supposed to be here.
/"
With respect to the request from Robert Battcn, Equipmcnt Opcrator III, Public Works
Dcpartment, for a job-connected disability pension, Mr. Battcn is following up with his
doctors to get the proper letters.
The Cominittee considered the request from Gary Lutman, Mechanic II, Fl e c t
Maintcnance Division, General Services Department, for a job-connected disability
pension. Mr. Lutman's file was quite lcngthy and the Committee did not have time to review it
{':"';\ p'roperly before the meeting, Mr. Lutman's Workers' Compensation file is in order. The
x:::,y Committee was presented with a memo from Bill Baird. General Services Director, advising that
there is no position .in General Services that Mr. Lutman could fill with his current physical
limitations. Mr. Lutman is close to being in a "no pay" status. The Committee will review this
fil~ thoroughly prior to the next meeting and discuss it further at that time.
,I,
i>'.:
"1\\:
" ,
,: \:
I
'j ,",
(~. '\ ~
fl"I,
I" '
Iu''';':
I
..'"
~I ~ I .
'/, ,
.' ,\. Ifl',:-,," "~,\ ,\, I; <", ','. j'" f"'" ('.'.",< ~ ~, I ".t.'/."'~f""...... )/f,. ~'I'" I"'l (.1" j{i . ....' I ",t ~
, ',\ ~" ',l~..~.\.' ;, I.' \' 1',\-" \' :'-. ',' '1.1 't' \ ',' .,/" ,'. ,.....,.'f.,.-,,'. , .1 . ,~." ~ ,fJ,~' \" l~'" '
,<"'".".;",::,'~:.;: ""I'~~',:,':r~:<:,:~,~,I/:':'I,'\,,';>,~',',:>~';:';J,,::~: ;:'. ,"/ ',1: ,\' ( i: '.. 0'/: ':" ,f' <,' ,''', '{-'.\ i, "'/,~' ,t" \,.,', ~' ,) ~' I." ,',1 "" ,: ",~', ' \...,',';',". ,I;v' ,; ,'",' / '/,
r " I I I\,.,~, \..:' "}...,"( ,Ii. ,~, ,,';',', '.\","',/',. ,.,1",,:".,,', ,I,' 1"'~"'I,\ll""I''-;':/; ,:,,::', "':\ \, t'j' ".' ,','J, .:'!',.(\ II"-:',I,/'! J'
., , I, (, t ' I ' , .. " ,,~ "I" '" 'I \ ." 1 ' , " , " , " I I' "
,I /~, ~ ~ "I,..~J"'I,",~"',:"~"\" ' ,.' t,' .~",~,"~. :"..fl,...,,/i f.:.~....:.,\: '~,:7' i;..,..,'~, .J-',',:, ::'\\.\',.+'...'~(ll ~"I,11 '.'~+ .110....(.': 10; .'!
~:.":;:"~I,,;.;,,. ' ",' "', 'J"'\ '\' ," ,\;"" "" \''''r~\,'' ,oJ" I' ," ,,' '\ "-" ,-'."" '{" 't""
I. ~"'~, ~::r'~ I'....\~'....~,,~I'. .~\:~.'~'~ir::~.,~;..~:'...!".'.'~'l,f:-~~.\Ir.' ~ ,,';/1,\" ,~' ~lh:'~,\...... t,,\I~ ,t'. ;,.,'.~~,'~~'..'.'I~.'1~~".\',
. ':; (',~ ,:' ' '\ ,",' , ,', ,', '," ,1 ','...' /" \, 11" "", " ,[ " I " ' \ ..' \ , t t '/' I , ,I . . \)'" I ... I
"I. ,\",,: +t'.J./.r','1 "'..,:'.,',I:,JI~~1:..I..!:.:..'1j,. .,.,l~.~\(;"I,;O',t>:: ;.....;,,:, ,"::. '.r ;,.:.~:" ,,':~'j( ,(f .'\ 'I'.~I( ,...~,', ~.:.~.;, ,',../ ~'~~~.
, '.
'\ '
,'J',
" .
" '
"
:,
, I,
"
, ,
.1:
" ,
I . ~ .
" ,'.
, "
, "
, .
';' ,
, i
"
, ,
'. ~~..."oI'll&...~^l' . r:>", '; ~ ". i.. . ,.,,;,!..' I~',. '.' ,~. ~'t" b.'~'" ~ 1. n. c.j~r "'I:~' ~ ~
!.' ., ..:'
~ ',C) The motion was duly seconded by Fred Ratley and carried unanimously.
v.
, ,
: \
/. ~
\\
, "/
). '
,: \
;, \:
t. \
.:, \
'. '.'
,I:,;;
, "
, ~i(
, ''f'
'I
I,'
11,',
,;'i
.~. '\
) ~ ~,~
:(','
'J, r~J
. ,,', ,
....,.'
"V:;"
il,."'"
11'..\
,'/,
:..)~~(:
~....:"" '. I'
. ;' '
';:' ,\
',:~ \
~/\ ~:: '
:;, ::\
':'/:/ \~
::J
"-"It
,;"I/.
;::1' ~ :,
... l. ,.
/:~\:\~
I~'A
~".J'< ;.\\::'
1,J'i
nil'..:'
\N~ '
:'i\t(
V ~~'Il
. X;.\
'. "\,
,{:~:~,
"-I"."
)~)\~",
'>~~'>';"
!:,::,:\.~
/';',';(:
,\1" ';
:\:.:.:
..' ,c...
;",r",..
'\"" ,J
~;~')X'
, ,j /
'. , ~ .
> } ,
:;'.;,)'
/ .~. .'
;j '~J
: I ~:,
" '1\.';
i.. \'
(:', ,:,'..,
;I)?';;
":,(
, I I.,
J '
,'. \.,
of) ~ I~
,.J, \
'. /".J,
','1. ,":\,,:
, I,'. 'l'
< ' '
, I ' (
.'\i'
': I
I. \
) ,'",
J". I
.'
\~
:.',':,::
, m'tl."tl
I'.~
, "\...,1
',.1,'
,',
\ ~/l. 'l '\'
'.' "
\ .." ~ '
.' I'.,,:. "
~ '~.. ~ ~ ~/."
'. . '
I ~ ;; : <;:r ~:' ..':' ','
. "'I' ... \: '"..'
, . ,
'; '~ '.
, ' ,
.!,... .ii..'.",... .., '0
'r" \l: '," '.
I & .,1',' ,...:'.
, I
Proceedings of the Pension Advisory Committee Meeting of October 4. 1995.
I, Page 2
Chairman Hooper, introduced' !ackie Kline to the Committee members.
, The' meeting recessed, from 9: 13 10 9:22 a.m.
Mr. Hooper. proceeded to rend the names of ,the new members. It was discovered that there was
nn ,error on the list and the meeting recessed from 9:23 to 9:43 a.m.
L~o ,Thompson' appeared before the Committee and presented two ,letters from psychiatrists
attesting to his problems as related to his job-connected injury. Mr. Thompson sfated he never
kept. information regarding h,is previous injuries from the City, The injuries he had when h e
was workin~ for St. PClers~urg were to his. neck and arm, not his leg and back. '
" Mr. Hooper n~vised Mr~ Thompson that the burden of proof was on him ,to provide informatio'n
in ,support of, his request. ' His letters do not address the issues required by the Committee.
Mr., Thomps~:m was advised to contact orthopedists and get the appropriate letters.
Richard Breest moved that the :following ,employee(s) be accepted into membership in Lh e
'Pension Plan:,
Date of
Employment
Pension,
pHI:. Date
Charles Clark, Custodial Worker
Jean Griggs, Accounting Clerk 1
Joanne Lindstrom,' Paralegal
10/2195
10/2/95
10/2/95
Library
Police
Legal
10/2/95
1012/95
10/2/95
Fred Ratley moved that the meeting
Richard Breest nnd carried unanimously.
be adjourned. The motion was' duly seconded by
The meeting adjourned at 9:58 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
~~
--l
H. Michael Laurs n
Human, Resources Director and
Secretary, Pensi on Advisory Com mi ltee
"
"
, "
, '
.".'" '. '~,' ,~ , ' " ~J ,1'1,,""" . ,. I",' ~ ',\. i. .; ~ . .'.,.. . ":"~:" tJ .:i' .,11" ,,' ~"" r', ;z.':
,t".://,..~,,';.';.',~.~ ," "," '" "I ':; , \', ,.. .~., I,',", '.... ..,.' , '(' '-( ;1' ',..' ,'\, ), \ ".., '
! '..: ,":', :,'>.' { : ."';':, '; 1'/: 'i" ':,::" ,'::"";,:-,,. ,..: '. "'::", ; . ,.''.'::',', ,:'.. ",,>,',':,~ :,','.:,~.,;,',',",,",:,"':"~"~ <',:,~::: ',~":,,,:,:~,,:,"",~": ;',.':,,'.~ ~,..,:,:',:".:/,,;,;.',.':'.:I.:.:'~ ',',,: '.,:~'"'"',,',',',':",,,!,:",,',:;'~.;:',~:',,,:::.~~,~,',',:::,:~"'."::"~,.,;,:':",',:.'.~,',,~:,~\,',.;,::.,::,',,;,: :,' ~"'\,;,...,'~,:,:,,\,',,,~,{II':;"':~'"
'~';~~'::')"(""I"~'>\:"':":'>'<:;:'~::"'::>"'.'"':;;'''''':''~:'''''':'''l':"',.;,',',::I::':\J:,, . (", .i" 'l" , -,,1\,1.1 ,'"\',~,, ".., "." ",' ~ , '-"'" ,.,.,<~
.," , ',l.'"(~:'.:''' (, ',....' .~,',..', 1',\'.,'...,.'. " .))~;"