01/04/1995
,',"
:l:',
;1>":.:,.': '.j
" !
','t
. "
- )',
:. ~ J -:' I'
. :,1
..11'
..<'.
"
",
,
':
"
. ~ .<
',.
f ~
....
,,'
,I,
~,;:;)Aj;<" ':1);,:':", ',,),', ":"~'~':..',;Jl;:~{ ;;,;:\'" ;: ,::::,\,- '.',:, '~:''-' ";,.;:\:-',;,, < ~':, , :~!, ,:' ,,: ':', " ",' ,,+.'~ ' )i
"'I'-r~'l-.t'.fr;H~\~I',<,~i;~:/'}~'I'~.: ..+~;t ~,/~f::'.:t.~.~I~~I':l;.""\i"':l'..: ,J"'i?' , ~ 'c~ ..1;'II'H'j..1 I. :\,~ .-t,~,. :.~. . 1 '\'~ ,.' 1 I" "J " r' ..
'?;iti"L'I;~ ~./.^ ,q"\.;,,i.'i"" f~ "'J.' , "t;'",:,~ ,.{ I, ".'- I"I,' .,; ,f; , ; 'j,' ,',C"," 1" "'.,,' ',' """ ,l,;,,/.: :,',,::'.:',/..:;i,:, ':, :,,":,!:::'I;r.'..,
~f~*>>/.~~:,~!!iVtl:ci;~i',\Ji,:{~~1~~,1\\fMr;C;;1::'~,': ,\;' :;l!!, , ; '::! i ;:\,' ,;//" ';' ". ;': ,', ,:ii, .,,';' ;;::~,':r;;;it':,,':;',',':;.:;'~,:,~:,,'\:'.:,".,',';',~'::"".:;""'":":"'::\':'.'."':J:""'; ,:t"'~:':':'I::"''''':':'''~~I'';,'!'',~, ',,':,:,,','~:~~,:,\"!;: ~ ;\,', ' 1\:' , .
~~~(!;i""ll'~:'J,~.JI'~~~''''(~'')'\Y''''''l..\l,t.,~",\, \".'1,/'''.',; T~""', 1.'....,......"1.1.:' ;' ',I \"'d,,' t '" ,0'.
! .. '.. ,.. r1 ~, \" , " ". ~ ... I \<., , , '., ,. , ":"~~"\,' '"',:,",".,:~,:,':,',~\','~,:,::;',,:,':','~,,,i~:~,.,;,'I:'~,~:,:",j~",:::,'>::,::~:::,'",;:;,',:,:::,:~/:""'",:~,
f;~'J';"I,{;,/,,~"I.I':-:-' .':-~:'~ft'~>"1lt'~"il."t, ,....ll.::";.:;..".',. '.' ....i:.. ".,,\ \'1. (' "~"~I i~.'> :..,~.'}:,'",,~,}'. ,:'>.'
:~';'J:~~j'l'i).~V;.-'''~f'j.,J-~,J/.q-'r\~t''~:,~U ':\.~'~r.'''>f..t:",.\:.(J~,{~,,'J) 1..{1',;;.:',~-:: '1~"/,' i "'(I"'\~" ,',f'~ '+", .~ '., ,',..'<. 'jL.i ~.
\'.6~Ct~1\.",S'. !,.;>.. 'f',:..~' "......;\. "'.., .~..~,I.,.~'...~'. ~ l' /.<.,-,~'" >," I, : . ., ,<'"
,l~r","jl' ";,'''',''1,' """..",.." ,\ \'1,\,1,," "', '"'.''''' .., . \. '''"
,;~;~,~h~~~'~,<::;r,';S'~';" "'\~~,i:i:'~<;~\:):.':::<',;\',',\l:::,',;,:",:,.>,'.i'" ",,' ;-',.' ' ""';,' \".':",,',,'; "1. ,'f :':, '". ", "" "" .\ :,' ," :' '."', ,. "I'
j' ,
'/ :t/. 11'
:'~;: .:.:
1 : ~
"
" ,
, !
')
i! ,,\
"
'.,
I"
.. ~ ,
.' :
", "
"
!'
"
"
'I
PAC
I,'
I,
Pension Advisory C~mmittee
'Minutes'
J'
"
,/.,
() I. ~ '1- 'Is-
"
',I
Date,
~' .'
I
~ '
:~
0,970
1
'\ \':
"
/
.. ,
.l~t.:,:' ,'. . f . "', \
~':i:i/\'+,' ",: ,i;':~}:~:"
. '+. ,t I '. . . ~ '1 ' .
t',' ';
"
..!
.' ~
'\\ (
'\ ,
, "
"1"
'. I.:'
"
,;
"
;' .
'1 "
,'/'1': ' '
iv.
f
./. :.:,'
:';,:.::.'::\ :~.:<:' .: ":',,,' .
':"c
"
"
.+.-.,.;.....
~.,~t,.~. \..(~j ,f, ':'~~I.\.;" ".,~ ,~I\t~'
: ic: 'X'"" ):,:; ~ ..... :'~' ~>i:,:. '.. ." ?,: ',\,;, : :'<;;.:;': /:~
, ': "" >. 1 : ",,' ': ': :': ::.." ':: " , ,,'J, "': ,,',,::".', ~,':;,",,~' " /, ; ,:~: ""',:: ,f',',.~:,J""',~.~,,., ';", ,I, ',:
" . '~, :,:;' :,."~I~',:,:. ,:,' ., : '~,' /
~ '/,':, ""',i,~l,, '.."~I 1,':.:,".'.Jc~<~, ~., ',.t:,,:
" ' " ( ',"'-, "'" "; ,! '''t 'J ' / , I "
~' 1,\, . /', '. ,\ ~ j .. I, , . . \. . .1' ....,.. ~ I
I\r~ . . \. . .~ L' 'r\+ '\ { 'I. I~.~ ~ "..', :."*!'.~,
' ", . . .... .. ""1"',\ .,.. r ~. ;.'. ~ . ), ~~I I ' . ~. I. :
:,:~ :,','::,<}!"~,;\, .'''.'':'::'::~':,,:: 'l::;'; "~~~ ',' " ",1:,:;",:
',' ' '" I,. "'-\ . \.
J;. ,\ . ,.', "I,', ',,' ',', ' l .' I ..;. \ :"" .~'::;, ,;; '.'
, \ : ~ L.,": ~ '.' . ~', 1
(", ,:' \' '.~
r ".":. . ,f.: 1""" ' '-..~..,' ,.t.......I..~::. . " .',' .',' .1.....:. .... ...., . ,', :'~I",' 'J.~, f" '1.'):/', ., "" ,","\'~ I
. '.. t,
,,'. .
I ,
,I
!
. ,
Proccc~ings of the Pension Advisory Committee Meeting of January 4, 1995.
Page
Present:
Jim Heinz, Chairman
Ed Hooper, Member
Fred Ratley, Member'
Deborah Ford, Human Resources Department
H. Michael. Laursen. Human Resources Director
Jon Marcin, Risk Management Specialist ,
Joseph Pidala. Assistant Fire Chief ,
Lawrence Hahn, Jr., Public Service Worker I
The meeting wns called to order at 9:58 a.m.
Jim Heinz moved to approve the minutes of December 21, 1994. The motion was duly seconded
by Fred Ratle,y and carried unanimously.
With respect to tht: request of Lawrence Hahn, Public Works Service Worker I, Public
Works De par tine nt, for a job-connected disability pension, the Committee requested that a
representative from. Risk Management be present with the Worker's Compensntion file.
Jon Marcin, Risk Management Specialist, was present. and stated the file was in order.
\ '
Mr. Hooper asked Mr. Hahn if his nttornt:y still, wanted him to find alternative employment.
Mr. Hahn advised the Committee that his attorney told him to file his papers. Mr. Hahn has two
,dependents under the age of 18.
c;
Ed Hooper moved that Lawrence Hahn be granted a job.connected disability pension effecti ve
on, a date to be determined based on Mr. Hahn's disability that resulted from on~thc~job
circumstances which is described as an injury to his right hand, wrist, and arm, said disability
making him permanently unable to perform, his job, and documented by medical statements of
Dr. Maria-Carmen B. Wilson, dated. December 6. 1994; Dr. R. W. Springstead, dated April 4, 1994:
. Dr. John M. Rayhack, dated February 7, 1994; and Dr. Joseph M, Sella, dated January 27, 1993.
The motion was duly seconded by Jim Heinz and carried unanimously.
With respect to the request from Joseph Pidnla, Assistant Fire Chief, Fire Department,
for a job-connected disability pension, the Committee has not. received a written response from
Fire Chief Robert Dayidson as lo whether or not Mr. Pidalu would be required to perform
fi rcfighti ng duties ill an emergency.
Mr. Pidala submitted letters from Dr. Martinez and Dr. Siek which give him a disability rating
of 5% and 7% respectively. He has reached MMI. Mr. Pidala was sent lO Dr. BHattn for nn IME,
and Dr. Bilotta has given him a disability rating of 5%.
A lengthy discussion ensued concerning whether or not Mr. Pidala would be required to
perform firefighter duties.
Jim Heinz moved' to deny Mr. Pidala's request for a job-connected disability pension based on
his administrative position as Assistant Fire Chief. Ed Hooper seconded the motion for purposes
of discussion. Mr. Hooper amended the motion to reflect that the pension be denied pending
'r:;..., receipt of a memo from Chief Davidson and with the understanding that Mr. Pidala would
'~ continue to enjoy the rights and privileges of being a State-certified firefighter. Fred Ratley
seconded the umcndmcnl.
"
~ t , .
":.;, :;,~;,:/,,':':;:',(~,'~'
, , 'I '
, , ,
., ~;,.. .. \ ...
'. ~~ ! .,
:,:)t; :':;::~}~':::':'\::, ;,>, :;:::;'" ,,';/~; !;+;:,t)~:h(~;~'\:~.iY/:Io'~ ),:;{,~,'}~~';, ,::;;}./!.;!:,,;':f:;,):i:';)':';:',::}
'\.":""~" '.,,11 ", ",,,,,.,,,.,,/,- ,1"~.I,r""'i"'J:""" ,t.. ',. 'j" ' '""" ," '~l'
-t ~"I"'~";r: '~.\ f.Jf. ~;:- ',l \'.~J,,'''''' ,\j,::",.: .1::.1/' :\,. .~.~ ~ ILf.., 0'.,\"," .," \ ',.' '\' ,:......, It..',' .~',.t..
. '., ..
, "
. > ,.' ..
, .:.. '.:.'U'~~ p~; ...t.~.th'(~~\;~Jr~..J.'''''''''', ..:
, "
. . . .-. ,<<,\,. >'.
'1 '" h
,.J: ',.
'1. '
, "
~ t' . .
, ,
.. ~.
I....
. f . .
". "
I, "
.,':i
"
I'. . j C
. ;, i ~
, "
,
',' I, " ,
l: .
~' , ..'
>' ...
'. ,fJ
."...... ,
t,~
'I,
'T,
-: I
t,~'
/,
I; ,
Proceedings dr,the Pension Advisory, Commiuee Meeting of January 4t 1995.,
Page 2
,.,...
:" I
,t.
Further 'discu'ssion, ensued. " The motion was voted on and carried unanimously. Mr. Pidnln t s
deninlis, ,co,ntingent upon the ,receipt of a written response from Chief Davidson stati~g,
,Mr. Pidatn wo~ldnol be required to perform firefighting duties.
Ed Hooper moved to reappoint Jim Heinz as Chairman for 1995. The motion' was duly, seconded
by Fred Ratley and carried unanimously (Mr. Heinz abstained).
\~. ~
I'
I:"
\':, '
;1
,\,
"
~,"!"
/,
A memo wilt be sent to all' unions regarding appointment of a representative for the election
" Nomin~tj'ngCommitlee;
Jim' Heinz moved that. the following employee(s) be accepted' into membership in the 'Pension
Plan:'
\,1 ~I
.,1.:".
1\
II.; \.
:Ii
,'to
. ~.
Date of .
Employmen1
Pension
Elie. Date
1..;""
.,'.t
1,,<
.,~ ~>: ~
'Sean Allastert Police Recruit
Linda' Burch, Police, St';fvice Tech.,
"Christopher Villano. Co~puter Oper.'
Nancy, Patula, Compo Training Tech.
.- ,Dnvid, Stoner; 'Library Assistant I ,
Police
Police
Information
Information "
Library
Mgmt.
Mgmt.
7/13/92
1/23/95
1/9/95
1/9/95
1/4/95
12/27/94
1/23/95
,1/9/95
1/9/95
1/4/95
.,
,
,.':'
'I,'
r ",
~. ~,
"
~ j....
.' ,
l' ''r
j,
L;.\ ~
,,0
The mot~on ,was duly seconded by ,Fred Ratley' and carried unanimously.
Jim, Heinz moved that the' meeting be adjourned. . The motion was duly seconded by' Ed Hooper
and carried unanimously. The meeting adjourned at 10:41 a.m.
R,espec.tfully ~~brnitted, ' /), '
, , -/ // '
'~/lZ(c/V/~>.~-'-'----'-"--"
H. Michael L~.L- " )
Human, ResoUlices Director and
Secretary, Pension Advisory Committee
:q,
, -
~ .....
..~: /
. ':~!~.
" ,
,,'
, '
: ..(
';",.-.
.I.~ ~ . :
,'r" ~' r
,,'
..:~~~.
'l'...,.
',: i
,,;'t
':". .
,-"'i'
t".
:,l..:',:
';.i,.i'
I.'
I:~\:.
~' ,.(/
)" ",
"E';lt
I..,
",
I: . ,',
, ii
/',
.,.,.J
, I
, ..'
';\ 1:/,
", ";
1/;::'
1-.' .-
,\j,'
t:. '.
/: '
j..,
'...
i:'.'\)
. l'
',; i
,1'1 ~
~
'~1
" '
III"
\ 1:-
. , <I ~
;: ~. ~ .
,
\.. >;
l""{
"
v,
.. f".
I' ',' :.
1.'\ ..
, .'j
.'
, ,
I"." " . ~/~', .'~",'}. .:'., ,/>.: " I :.:.. ~'I r: 1\,'.,,1 "i/, .... I /. ., I ~',! II ,.
, ,.'/. ". ( " ~'I' ,_"" J,' .....<\...:~'.\::\].~.:..~. :..'. '...\',',1' .....~ '; ,t'I'
. . ':.i': ":,;);;":;:,'::" ,~','\' :':',',f,:!~:, :'~,~\, 'I: ~ '::;:: (:/<': ~ :\'~,,' ,;,~~'I.~" /> ',:, I/~
..... .'.. ': ~ .,j }.. . , : ,~. . , \ ~ t,; j:".' I . .' . .
/....~.. ,. L. ~ " -: .';\. i "I~l '.' .~. . : .i..\ :~'..'\ ,'........
..< '.'1; ~,>j~c',.:.'>: :'.::'_..,1' ~.',~ ~', .. ,>,'" i:,,'::-:: >, , !" 'l;:,,[:';,\/
( I,,' ,'< " : \ ,"," \': ~: ",.' J,' ! , ;, ,... 'I
1,<",,:, ':';':" '.. :(':Ii;' .';:~'~,<,~> ;'~;,: .': '\'.<, :.,\\ ;I;~. L~.r,\ I
. ....1. ~., .' ~ ,t.. . ~\~. t'. . . ~4. ". \ i',.......
,','t, I:"~?? ,';, .>"I)'~! .<'..: ':.x,;,~:,\ ';.'/,,\.' i' ~,1
,~ ':'1;1 . . _' . i \., I
.. I . .~, ., ',Il.'..~. I .'.~ ',:,-
\. I I I . :.' V.o(. ,I ~ t .
.,'Lll" ~ '::,:' :~\
. \':. '. :.. .~, :::
, ..