11/21/2000 (2)
"
.J
, , .
,". , I
. , . ~~
. \ . . . ".. . , ..1
.~:". ::.,:.,.'.>>:": : :.> ',',t:", J;~I.';'.::.: ~ ' >, I.
:~,~;;}:v .i . :;:: .. ....;.', "~"::''; '., 'i'):::' ',. .,
. ,
, .
, ,
.'. J
"\ !
,
.'
"" ,
..,
, ,. "
, ..,. 1 t ~
. '0
<'. "
.JfIl4t.
" 'Ii
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD MEETING
CITY OF CLEARWATER
November 21, 2000
, Present:
.. Gerald Figurski
Edward Mazur, Jr.
William Johnson
Shirley Moran
Carren A. Petersen.
Alex Pliska
Absent:
David Gildersleeve
Also Present: Leslie Dougall-Sides
Ralph Stone
Cynthia Hardin
Lisa L. Fierce
, Patricia O. Sullivan
Chair - arrived 2:27 p.m.
Vice Chair - departed 2: 17 p.m. .
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Assistant City Attorney.
Planning Director
. Assistant Planning Director
Development Review Manager,
Board Reporter.
. The Chair called the meeting to order at 1 :00 p.m. at City Hall, followed by
the Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance.
~,~m~
,:f" ,
:a. }.~.!
. ~a -40~(:
To provide continuity for research. items are in agenda order although not
necessarily discussed in that order.
ITEM A - REQUESTS FOR CONTINUANCE/RECONSIDERATION
Cases: FL 00-08-32 - 443 East Shore Drive IPortofino VillaQe}: LUZ 00-08-10 -
1106 Druid Road South (Chapman): and ANX 00-08-20 - 2217 South lagoon Circle
(Shawl
Development Review Manager Usa Fierce reviewed the requests for
continuance.
Member Johnson moved to continue Case FL 00-08-32 at 443 East Shore
Drive and Case LUZ OO~08-1 0 at 1106 Druid Road South to a date uncertain; and to
continue Case ANX 00-08-20 at 2217 South Lagoon Circle to December 12, 2000.
-:The motion was. duly seconded and carried unanimously.
ITEM B - CONTINUED ITEMS - See Item #04, page 9.
Item He 1 - Downtown Clearwater PeriDherv Plan 2000 Update: Planninq
Department - Aoolicant, Request recommendation for approval of update to 1993
Downta~n. Clearwater Periphery Plan.
ITEM C - LEVEL 3 APPLICATIONS
~
mod1100
1
11/21/00
c, ,l
. I.
. I';
't ' .. ~ .:: .' ,
" '. . ";' :.::, :,.': .":'!' ":::., .
L ,\ '.
, 'j" (,
, .
-t '. , .'
.' ,
',I ;C.','c.! :;>> ", ", '. ." ..,
'" ~ I . I "
. .
. ,
, "
, ~. ' ,
, , '~T.
,I, , , ..
.: 'I
, ,
~
. " '~
Senior Planner Gina L. Clayton reviewed the request. In 1993, the
. Clearwater City Commission approved the Downtown Cfearwater Periphery Plan,
. which Included extensive revisions to the Downtown Redevelopment Plan. The
Periphery Plan considers the development potential of four areas on the edge of
downtown Identified as important to the success of overall downtown' .
redevelopment. These areas are the "Northwest," "Southwest," Northeast," and
. Southeast" expansion areas.
.'
. .)
. j'
<
\
.! .
.. J
'.1
. 1
,.j
The Northwest area is bound by Clearwater Harbor, Nicholson Street, the
Pinellas Trail/Myrtle Avenue, and Jones Street. The Southwest area is bound by
South Fort Harrison Avenue, Chestnut Street, the Pinellas Trail/East Avenue, and
Druid Road.
In addition to the Periphery Plan, the Commission also adopted ordinances,
which changed the Future Land Use Map designation of each expansion area to
Central Business District (CeO). The Northeast and Southeast areas were rezoned
'later in 1993 to Urban Center.
,c,
In 1995, the City submitted the amendments to the Future land Use Map
and Periphery Plan 'to the PPC (Pinellas Planning Council) and Countywide Planning
Authority. The agencies approved the Plan, including the re-designation of the
~xpansion areas to CBO with tho condition that the City would submit a specific
plan that fully qualifies for COB designation.
. C;:)
...:,~~ ~
The Downtown Periphery Plan 2000 Update revises the original Periphery
Plan. Its purpose is to better define the land use plan and development potential for
each expansion area and provide recommendations to guide redevelopment. The
Update shall supersede the original plan and fulfill the requirements of a SpeciEII
Area Plan for the Countywide Planning Authority. The future land use plan
categories for these areas will remain CBO and the Periphery Plan 2000 Update and
Downtown (0) zoning district will govern the development potential.
In response to. a question, Ms. Clayton said the update affects all four areas.
The following item supports amending the zoning for the Northwest and Southwest
areas. She reviewed which nonconforming uses would result from a change in
zoning.
Planning Director Ralph Stone stated staff had sent notice to all property
. owners in the periphery area and invited them to attend the October 1 2, 2000
public workshop. In response to a question, Mr. Stone said some people had
expressed concern that heavy industrial use's not be allowed. All properties would
be subject to reconstruction limits of 50% of the property's value should disaster
strike. If repair costs are greater than permitted, the structure and use would have
to conform to Code.
"~II)
A resident of the Southwest Area opposed proposed limits for retail sales to
properties fronting Ft. Harrison Avenue.
mcdl100
2
11/21/00
, ..
'II. <c.
~ ." .
c' / ,
'. . J
" .
, ,
, .,
. .
,
"
, .
. \. ~.'
" I
. ~
"
I,
\ .
J
I
l' ~
,
,
Mr. Stone requested the COB (Community Development Board) to determine
f if the periphery areas are appropriate for inclusion in downtown. The alternative
would be to perpetuate the current mix of uses. In response to a question, ,
'Assistant City Attorn'ey'leslie Dougall-Sides said if approved, the City Commission
would codify the Periphery Plan as an ordinance.
>,'
"~I
,i
Mal'Dber Johnson moved for the COB to recommend approval of the
Downtown Clearwater Periphery Plan 2000 Update to update the 1993 Downtown
Clearwater Periphery Plan. The motion was duly seconded and carried
unanimously. , \ .
',',
.1' \
I.
.'r
" ,
I.;
< I~
,
.-:....
Item #C2 - Downtown Clearwater PeripherY Plan - Northwest Expansion Area
between Clearwater Harbor. Mvrtle Street/Pine lies Trail. Nicholson Street. and
Jones Street and Southwest Expansion Area. between South Fort Harrison Avenue.
ChestnUt Street, the Pinellas Trail/East AVF.!nue, and Druid Road: PlanninQ Department
- Applicant, . Request recommendation for approval of the Northwest Expansion Area
as part of the 2000 Downtown Clearwater Periphery Plan. ZOO-10-01
-..-'
.:, '<
'), : ~
. II'
/;: ,
" ,
'!(i
\)
,", .
'r:;
~ '".
l~~.
I:;JI~
I,
. ".
.:/~i f,
J::: :'
:/t./;
.' "
..~ ~~
<Ii;
\"" .
.ri~/~'
';),i'
. ,t'...\;
l ;'1
'<'1: ~
'" ,', ~,'
;'v,
.:1,",:
1'1"
,/.,./
\~i{';
,~,{/
'/'1'
;':)
"i<'~
"'I:',>
;"k,
. i'. ~. J
I i ~ !:
'/'f(
':~1
f.?'(
'\\"
"~ ':~.
..f~I'
Ms. Clayton reviewed the request. In 1993, the City Commission approved
the Downtown Periphery Plan, which governs four expansion areas on the edge of
downtown. Although outside the CRA (Community Redevelopment Area), the
Commission had specified detailed zoning and redevelopment concepts for these
areas.
'r~","~
r "','
t,1 \~."
'I,....
. In 1993, the City changed the use designation within the four expansion.
areas to Central Business District. In 1995, the PPC (Pinellas Planning Council) and
. Countywide Planning Authority approved the Future Land Use Map amendments.
Shortly after the plan was approved, the Northeast expansion area was rezoned to
Urban Center (Transition) and the Southeast area was rezoned to Urban Center
(Eastern). No zoning changes were planned immediately for the Northwest and
designated areas, however, staff had drafted a new performance, zoning district to
govern these areas. The Periphery Plan appendix included this proposed zoning
district.
Current zoning in the Northwest Expansion Area ranges from Medium
Density Residential to Industrial, Research and Technology. While the Southwest
Area is zoned Commercial and Office, the only zoning district consistent with the
undorlying Future land Use Designation of the CBD is Downtown (0). The
proposed rezoning of these two areas will fulfill the intent of the Periphery Plan and
reach consistency between the City's zoning map and the Future Land Use Map.
: ",f
~:', ........
. ~~ '
.1 ~ \'
r: v;
';
,'.'~):
.::.,/.
. \ i'1
~~ i./,,;
(:1
. /.{
,:r, ill
".
'\ ~~
(
. I;:!~
\",
,I i
,/
~J;
,: '.
.' '\
, .'
~,'
.,.
.,
Member Johnson moved for the COB to recommend approval of the rezoning
for the Northwest Expansion Area, between Clearwater Harbor, Myrtle
Street/Pinellas Trail, Nicholson Street, and Jones Street, and the Southwest
Expansion Area, between South Fort Harrison Avenue, Chestnut Street, the Pinellas
Trail/East Avenue, and Druid Road. The motion was duly seconded and carried
unanimously.
mod1100
3
11/21/00
,f,~ j
:/
"
, \
'Y.:",
..,/. !
.~ ~ .\ \
\\ ,
'):~!'"
<\'f"
~, \
::".>~
1(',
'.<~I :/'
:'~. .1'.;.i ~ ~,~ '," ' . '
I . ,. ' .~
. .l.' ~ I,,:~ ) ~ '~..
" '.. ./~
'.'..., rlv".
" .1'.' ~,I/> '<),~ .
"
. .. ','.. '. '. .' '''', 'I ; I ".'
" . 1 I ( ill.' '" ~ f " ( !', ' , I .'" ~ ' '.
'. '/OJ''' ,'. \. :' , ',I J . ." .~".' ,'.' '.,,", ..'; < ,;.:.:;:, '. 'i:,.", '.: .;.:;; ,>/~ ':'< >. .".:}:.",:' ':,\ <,.'::', <:.>.'< ~...: '.:: ", ;~',:> ~::; :::; ~~,',:. ',:; '>'~"<,~ '.':,,::':'.::,:/1.> /,;!' ~':: :,::..>?
,1:"~':~"'I~~'."')/I\',;.,.II: :...,(..1, (/,[,.... "),011"".,..;\,, I.. . I., ')-,',' "I'.~ f. '.r t,'.', ...~,\iA:..)....',;~L /......\.. I ..'..~I/\
"""\""'/' ',(, ,,,." 1.'(,,': "'1".;1:,..'..,,.., ",': '~J_._"j', ':"_"'''''... "" "I'",s"":""" "'V ',.
"'" ','I \,,A"'I"'.;,"""..:"/,',." ',J:" ,;, .~, _.~: .:...'tl.... ,.... "(''''''':'f.;,'7'''li'..\;~'''''' '"......:/'. ,,',~.:t.. :,.';:':.. I'. .'/' ':'( ,.',,'.
. '. '.. i'.:\;;::Y,~(';:' :;;.' :~< '; ;,~(> <>~'/. ~(,~:"I.; ;:' ;;\0 . :;, . ";::;;:'::" <' '.:'., ';.' !. ""
,
'"
..,
.'
I- ' ~ ,
'1 c
, I
:t ' .'
',fic'
. 'c' ,:' \ . ~, j
. . 1
,f ".
.'!, .
'.
,
c ".. ~ ,
. I:'
'I) >'
'.. .
1,' .', I
, I
",
'.1,
'\,.
'.'~
'I' \
,(.
I;'
"I
\
~
Assistant Planning Director Cyndl Hardin reported staff would renotlce 'all
property owners in Periphery Plan areas before the City. Commission considers this
Issue in February 2001.
\.
.(, :
:,":1
~ "
ITEM 0 ~ LEVEL TWO APPLICATIONS
1:\/1
'I',
'\"
:~, ~ J
, )/
Ii
C'')'
.'
.,':/
Item #01 ~ 27001 US 19N: Bellwether Prooertles of Florida. Ltd./J.C. Penny Co.
Inc./Allied Stores General Raal Estate Co./Dillard Deot Store Inc./Sears Roebuck &.
Co. - Owner/Aoplicant, Request amendment to flexible development application
conditions of approval at See 30-28-16, M&B's 41.01, 41.02, 41.03, 41.04,
42.01,42.02 & 42.04. Fl1999.F~1008
," ~,
Development Review Manager Lisa Fierce reviewed the request. On June
15, 1999, the CDS approved a Flexible Development application, as part of a
Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project, for Countryside Mall (VAR 19S9-F-
1008). The approved plan permitted a 73,000 square foot addition to Dillard's .
. Department Store and a 73,000 square foot addition to Bu~dines Department Store.
. An attached signage proposal for Dillard's also was approved as part of the
application. Approval required a Comprehensive Landscape Program to exceed
standard requirements. Most landscaping will border the property's perimeter and
entrance drives~
~/ I
f\ ,t
/,\l,'
~ );,~
/"\
l-:
:t\i.
'/'1'
IC
(~~\.)
,tt'-
;.,\, ~
.,,1
/..[
/,,,:,
;'~).
:,:X:}'
. '.
t. rll.
>~;~.:
, . <
;;~.~
1 " ~' /
:i~~'.i
;:~~:
c,l}: ~I
'.
,. ,~
" 'j
l: f\ ,
. ~.':
, ~ C~'I..
l~ ,,,:)
When approving the request, the CDB had imposed conditions: 1) all
landscaping shall be installed as part of Dillard's expansion, except for interior
parldng lot landscaping which may be installed in phases. Completion to be no later
than 3 years after issuance of main construction permits for DiIlard's addition.
Status - To be completed: 2) final landscape plan shall be.submitted within 45 days
of development order approving project. Landscape plan shall Include calculations
for internal open space & vehicular use area & other such requirements established
in the Code. Status - Comple~od. Approved by Staff: 3) alllandscapin9 areas shall
feature shrubs, 9round cover, trees and/or perennial beds, and a year-round
maintenance program. Sod shall not be allowed in these landscaping areas. Status
- Shown on approved landscape Plan: and 4) all trees determined by City Arborist
to be declining, dead, or hazardous shall be removed & replaced tree for tree. Tree
removal/replacement shall be accomplished as part of Dillard's addition
construction. Status - To be completed.
~,; I~':'.~
{{'I",
. (,....
"1'/
: \~ I. ~
, , ,~\~.
:.1'-'.
.'
~~/:~11
"~ I)
,1 :'.
.'
r /~ \.,
~ '.';i,
",,tJ f~
",1 f
The applicant had anticipated construction of the Dillard's addition would
commence in mid 1999, while construction of Burdines would begin 6 months later.
However, Burdines submitted its permit request first. The City received Dillard's
request for a building permit on January 3, 2000. Based on CDB conditions,
completion of interior landscaping is required by January 3. 2001.
~"'! )
J /r .
flf"
\{~:i
. ,
\ .
.)'11
;'~I~
:~~ ~"'i
. ,
. ).1 i,:
:\:,./
-'"
.:~' '
\.~.!J
The applicants request to amend a condition of the approval of their Flexible
Development applJcation, stating a time extension is needed due to a change in mall
ownership and problems related to renovating an older building. The request is to
extend the landscape completion date to no later then September 1, 2001.
('
j'
,\ ;;
;. 'IJ
mcd1100
4
11/21/00
I ':"l~,
'j \
','
J'\'.
::1' \
.\.";-.
,'.. \.
J\'~ '
')~,,: .
'\.
.~~: "
"'."'. ..... . .,. ... . '\~ ' I', /, / . I' "./...," .11,1f'.....)....",...,'J,.'... I'" co.,' .,.....'., ,,'I. '1,'\' c'.'"
~ ". ~,.' 'I c "/< I'.' v',,\..l,'. ','......1 ' ',"t.,. .~ '. "'I \; .'1 ,t,
............',\/.,.,<'. "r-.\,... . ;.~.I. r <,~ '" ", ~4"/.~' :.(,' .'.' ."\:::",. ..../'~I: " ~., '. 't ~f'~"" 'I" I . I .,. " J
" r I ..rj.' , J 'I' /' I.. :/' :" '\:'",~:'"".'./ """".""}'!"'" .',' ....,.' .,.,..'.,'., "'<""'J"':\' ,.'..'., . ,',',' ,_,l
,~,;ll" .. \ .p . . '\ .. ... 'f~ I,. ~. , ','M;' r: -(' f ..' 'I~ I .', 'I . t \. \. '.1. t ') ,. ......' \ J . r .
.. ,,), , .,. . ,1."/.\.' ,...,',.:..,. ..,/,,:..,\ .;'~.....,...\.I':'.-\.,'c,),':"'''~.'''''':j~i;.,.'~:''~',1\'\\'.\.'11./.'1,'.....:...:
"",:,'::~:""',<,',','\,;,"'\~.~:'.' ~';:l_~";L')~..' l /'\ "\ .> \' '.1"..' I, I \ .1. .l'I{::'~I,.:' '.. "),, 'r;., ~':'.;~..'.::'...'!\.,f.\'<':,..~~_jJ..,,1"",. >~/I :,/j,~:~,I:':c "'",'.~~;'.<','..,,.:<:,~:',_I~I}.,~,::
, ,..'~.:.:\;_.','.:,,::,.:,/'.:,.,..'(,:,:.;'.;.::,.:.l.."\':','\""':'\.:\':1\:"1:,'.~:..'::. ,..:\..:..;....,....,\,..~,I.'.,~:.:'.... "', I ", / '1~1" " '''-I J. ' ,1" ,\. .,.,~ fij'" 'I ','" \{"'I .' . " .,:' ""','
. , _. ,", t'\...' . ,~',I.. \'~JI" ','1'. I ,I' 0/ ,',.,~., 1~'.....~ . I!..~I,\.,'....,.:':..;. ,I.'
I.:.'.:.~~l:...::<~: .:I~:-I.,:~~~.,,~...,.I,I'\~I\c:)...',J tf>\,.,..'\"I'\" 'I'~' ,jl { r~\ J "",~ { ,'...\,l, \ .,,' 'I :..r" "'\"'.".
,f' ,~--r q .~). ~i"\,, II ./,' ,:,,::" .'.r.."": ;1:' ,,', ':l .,/~.>:,r~~.~, '(;l.~I,:,: " I.:~;:..:~ .',"',::: .,.:', .'..4'..J....':. .,:>'~<::...i',~::,,'q~:...;I.
',.'.
(-.
"
..
. i ' .; ..... i' J" . . . 1'. ~ .,~'.'
I '. 1 ' ~ :,..
. ,:'y: . .... :~ . ,.'. ,~' .:..;.;'.;;'; ;, ;....
. '\. ,',. ' " j. ' . II ,,:. ,c ,
, ..
. ~ ", + d
.'
n
" I,
~ . . ~ ~
. , ,
. ,'I
,;t "
I. I"
'. :
.' ,
1,<',.
'. /., .
"
, ,.
\-"
I, !
\1.,
.),-
.,' I
{I
\. ~\
~
. Delaying ins'tallatlon of the landscaping will be more cost effective than Installing it
during construction, which could damage plant material.
. ,
~\
. \)
~. . .
01,1
. j
., .
, 'I
I
I
I
I.
1 ,
"f .
The applicants also request extending the time frame required attaining a
. Certificate of Occupancy permit, pursuant to Section 4.407 of the Code. The
Certificate of Occupancy for the Dilliard's addition is required by March 30, 2001.
The applicants request an extension to September 1, 2001 for Burdines and
.Dilliard's.
f
" '
','J !:
Staff recommends approval of the request to amend V AR 1999-F-1008
. Condition #1 to require completion of all interior and p.erimeter landscaping in
accordance with the approved landscape plan, with a condition that it be Installed
with the issuance of the certificate of occupancy for the latest building expansion
(Burdines or Dillard's), but no later than September 1, 2001. Should installation of
t.he landsc'aping not be completed by that time, the City will agree to accept a bond
in the amount of 125% of the value of landscaping not yet installed. A date for
work completion would need to be addressed at that time.
, ..
il'
',~
~ ""1 i
';VJ
,<'d 'j
."1 .
:\,".
,~I ~~
.Tr.,
',~ I
I'" ,
i.\'.
",. II'
~i;',~.:
";'l\
1.1;'"
"J I'
;",1/'"
":,lj,~
1" '"
J/.~I
,",i .,
;.'(2/:
" ;,.~: ..~
:\~: f ,\i
. ,,,a::.j
'(j'I';..,
':\'1 'J'
.~\~~\;; "
\f,~':
I~>''';:I;
,1',- \\
l.;';l~{
'.,~ 1
........} , ~,;
Staff also recommends extending the time frame requiring a Certificate of
Occupancy for Burdines and Dillard's to September 1, 2001.
,
,
(
I
!.
\.'
1
I
I
I
!
One letter opposed the extension and requested installation of a signal light
at the Summerdalel SR 580 intersection.
0/ ~t. .
I:"';~:~
~ ~...,>::P
"~~7...
Tom Marsicano, representative, reviewed the history of the expansion
project. He said the firm is prepared to bond unfinished landscaping but did not
expect that would be necessary.
'\~~-"
} ,'.'".~
:-:1 \<~
~f.~'I:~ \!\
Member Johnson moved to approve an amendment to the flexible
development application conditions of approval at See 30-28-16, M&B's 41.01,
41.02, 41.03, 41.04,42.01, 42.02 & 42.04 with condition: landscaping to be
installed with issuance of certificate of occupancy for latest building expansion
(Dillard's or Burdines), but no later than September 1, 2001. The motion was duly
seconded and carried unanimously.
'i~:;~'j~ ;'
:i\;i;
~.' ,1,
\1 J, ....~
" '~ ..11.'-;- \
,l",h:,,:
.,.....1"
.\. " ~'I
~ ~ '
\
. " \
'::"'11\.
.:--,V
,\i. ...f~
,:,<\~
.~} /\1;.
, ~"'=} t . t
(.~.~ l:
\/ ...,','
'~, lot.\; >'
'. p..,;.,
... ':' 1'.\
.:-1",),.
. H<f~lf
I . ~ \
,. .I;.~ ~~.~ \'
,.J';\. ,
~ ., ~ ~ "
; ..i.\
,.:~~ \<c':,
... "
.. "".'
Item #D2 - 2104 WinQs Way: Larrv B. & Marcella M. Winq 1 Scott & Wanda Moeller
- Owner/Aoplicant. Request flexible development approval of a Residential Infill
Project to reduce the front setback from 25 feet to 10 feet along Wings Way, to
reduce the north side setback from 15 feet to 5 feet and to increase the height from
30 feet to 31 feet, at Sec 32-28-16, part of M&B 43.06. FL 00-09-35
t~
Planner Ryan Givens reviewed the request. The 0.5-acre site, at the corner
of Union .Street and Wings Way, is heavily wooded with live oaks and is within the
newly platted, six-lot, Whispering Wings subdivision,' A 0.25-acre detention basin,
on the ~outhern portion of the lot, serves the entire subdivision. One lot in the
subdivision is developed. The lot to the north is vacant. The applicants propose to
construct a 3,000 square-foot, two-story, brick colonial-style house with a 3-car
mcd1100
5
11/21/00
';', \
.,1 :',
, '\"
: ,;, ~
V, '
\ ';, ""i
; 'f
" .... r\
I,. \ :"
:::'i.~ ~ \ :r~
or.
\..
. \
", '
'J' ~I
,
:: '
,.'.::;1,
.. . ~. '~II. / 'iI" .\1 . .1' t'.', '. ,'. ..,'1""'. ',: \ ,"',' : ' .",1, _,1.1. ),'. J" ;' L,'" \ ',I~"~"
l-,"\'".....~'t'~.1 ".~~I'''~ 'c j.""/",.,\..,.,:..>,'.\t'\~\\'~I,,.,'.i','rc.;/'I'-' ",>,:",".' './'" 'I" I" :...1. tjf..,:,.-/;-O,(,> I~'\'
I' '.: :;:;L:,,<: {:':, }:'.;;:S;;'<:>(( ~'k(/::;,:;~ >:;:~..(,s?;;;)) ;,'P\~;;?<','/;S(,::i';;\:~; f:~:: \ n~;;,
.' . ,... ,.'\.... ,,," ',..,... ...,...../.,.....;;:!..'.'1.' ,/ "t: ""i' 'I'S' \....,,::t"..17. ,.'1., (I,'.,' /\,..'1"
;'<, I ,:~ /: .1:' '/ '; ::.':\' . .: ; ;, \,.:,.:,.." ,,;.: \:.. .~.'; ,.:....(,...'} '" ", '. / ..' ,,~, 1,;-':.--: .'-, 'j,;., . o. '/,', '.\: : ' 11,' " ':0/',:/:.: i':',' ,:. .,:> ":', .~,:.\ ".'.' , ' ... . " ~
'..." 'l' ~ 'I \" :... \\. ,~'.,II.' .....".j I)' ~J.', ,/';.. r ';\~II '1',',,~,., orJ I'~' c ~."~ l ,,',1 l.'l"'~\' 'i.."J.;:.
';. ~~~",\,1'..~ " ,..' ,.......::. ,',',-..~, j'~,~~;~~;\,,'_~_:~~\:\'~.~":l"'~~.,~/'.."',..J' ~ :~., c.~~",\,~.'''~'',' .:..:.....;','.~,<,~1..':..:. :"!.';"'II~,:><.,I..:,rj",~"::<'(..~
:~':i }}/,'; F ~::: '>::r.': '..'!.~,
,
';/
"
,.
'i
~ ~." . , I,
" >
;,,:
'j
'"
,...
I, /,
>. J
\
\",
J ~~
,.,'1
/\ I
"
',,',
j(iJ'<:':~;'~':,' '\.:.' :;'" ":"";,' "'<i.: .: ,,' '. ',' " '
, I J- ~ '
I,!
, ' .,.
, : I"
':\;t.
it,ll'
'.\ I
'1\1
>V
\
, ,.
, .
" .
" ~ .'. I , I
'1\
\
/
.11,
I.
~ ,
, \'
."j'\
\ .
) ,
~ \
'\
. " \
:'f:
',\.,
,\
'J?
Ib.~
....,
"
garage on Its north side. The house will be consistent with the size and character
of houses proposed for the subdivision.
<. )
, I.'
/"\\
,(,\
: I
J'~:: I
" .
.: :.\
\.
..,
,; /
/ \\
/.
\. ,
"f,"
<:t.,
J. ~
:\<
:;..\
~ ,. i
:~\.~
l' .
!;f~~
,.\ "l
'~;.i
,I
:,~:.~~
';'1,'~
,::t
l'~.-;; ".i
....'p'
'f"
l.',> ,I
\~.1~
( .,
\ ~ -,:
i.,;
~,'. ,r~
\~. r
i:.')
. \,a/
c'.,""
, I ~r'
'~;...';
~'!/"
""':'.
""~".I::
:Ii .
,v, .
, The applicants request reducing the north side setback from 1 5 feet to five
feet. The applicants have designed the house around the natural environment and
request the reduction to .save trees and preserve the tree canopy. The detention'
basin also constrains the home's design by reducing the effective lot width to 80
feet and its size to 0.25 acre. Only a portion'of the garage will encroach into the ,
side setback. Living areas wilt be farther south to establish privacy for the
homeowners and future neighbors to the north. Staff feels the hornets placement Is
the best possible.
it
The applicants also propose to install a 5-foot wide sidewalk to connect the
front porch with the driveway. The main porch will have a 25-foot front setback.
Also, the applicants propose for the house to be 31 feet high, one foot above the
Code standard of 30 feet.
In response to a question, Mr. Givens said trees will create a large buffer
between this property and the abutting lot to the north. The proposed variance will
not impact adjacent property own.ers.
In response to a question, Steve Fowler, representative, said the requests are
based on the location of the trees. As the tree survey is not exact, he needs to
determine the exact layout of the house. The setback from the adjacent property
C:~ will be at least 5 feet.
,.~"'''"
Larry Wing, subdivision owner, said to save as many large oaks as possible,
the purchase agreements for the lots require marked trees to remain untouched. He
said the basin on the subject lot is dry.
It was noted a front yard variance is not required for the front door sidewalk.
Ms. Dougall-Sides recommended that issue be deleted from the request.
',1 '
:/<.... .
:y;,
:..i'
~;'L .::
/qil
;,,)
I,
\'" 'j,
, , 1~.~
:,.,'(
;,"."
",':',.
L,~,
>, 'I ~
\;I'~\..
IS,
/.,'; 1
~'I ~
(' :
h\i,~
.\1'/.'
I /,
,<' I;;
;: ,I~":
.)" .
,'1. "
.\\~ .
,
i:>.\
Member Petersen moved for the COB to approve the Flexible Development of
a Residential Inflll Project to reduce the north side setback from 1 5 feet to 5 feet
and to increase the height from 30 feet to 31 fe.6t for Sec 32-28-16, part of M&B
43.06. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
The meeting recessed from 2: 17 to 2:27 p.m.
Item #03 - 7 Rocl(8WaV St.: Charalampos & Sevasti A1axioll (Kirk Construction) -
Owner/Applicant. Request flexible development approval of a Comprehensive Infill
'. Redevelopment Project to reduce the front setback from 10 feet to 0 feet, reduce
the rear setback from 10 feet to 0 feet and reduce the required number of parking
spaces from 71 spaces to 1 3 parking spaces, and reduce required number of
handicap spaces, at. See 32-28-16, part of M&B 43.06.
FL OO~09-35
\;;;. .J
~W
mcd1100
6
11/21/00
'.)
:i
,
. I 1
. ':--/ , .". . \ ' , " \' ,
'. J'" .\l . 'i;1 . . ::: " " ,_..' ,
' . ',f. I , . . ~.. E"\ ~'
\ \ I ':10..\) ...... '.' ;;;, '..
. ,..J. .' .. I','
.;>~j;/<
~~. ~ .
~ ' ~, '.\;' ( ~,
. ".
. . '" '/ .., t'.~' "1. ','.,\'\:l/.,/j. ';'~ '/'(,.'; :./..':'\":,:':~~,:~I:'I':;"~"'.i<:'.."~}~:.'<:.:.''':;'~\r.{;';':~'
. , '\'..'- '/J'I,' "';' \" ...,1'1... .,',.. "f r., ''/" /,' ,,' i: "'.1.,; ",.\ ".: ,. .., . . ""., . I' . /.
:, '~ :. ',':' i?,. ' ,\) <~":'<::::~ :,i, <<.)-, : Ii:,::,,} ,',y.::\: I:, :'i';l,':;i:~j;i';i ',,:; \~ <~?} ii~' ':;:.: ll:'::,: '.';: r; ~ /'i' ,;:,'.: I;;
." ....,>.'/1>1.." "''''(\'' "'~I' ,)/~.,,-':., " '.,:..... 1,,1. "~t. ""'.'/" 1"...."8'., "",/.'. ,.' ,. I""
:";"CI<~ '>\.l ,;,":<\'",1 L; EC',t1~: .l~..\.",t~ ''''';;.c.."jL''~<'t''.'.I'',lr..~.\/.-:.~/.1, ,:;!''':);~J',;( t .i:,:.'.'.,,:. ,n~:',.;il..:~,:,C\"'\+',.'I. ~',''''''I
"",..,,/1'/1\, , ,', ,,' ,/ .'-7." "':.', '......\ to...,. I'"'''''' , ,',. "../.., \'1 " I
' ('.: '"",, '. ., .', ,...;,.-'..'..../,. ',"'.., ':.oc ),' .' ,. "'j.,. ,1.,./',....... ',:"''','''''..' .',: ".,.'.' :"I:"'~'",,::, ;",'I~.'<.,
" ..... ./1-/0.....\ ' .,",. '.,' ", ' ',. I, r,; " 0.' ."',~\ "'N""',. _ ,;" .'f.. " ",1.\1. .'
",.~ <~?:L(.~,,,.:.....,:.~.. IJ:.>.,..~.:..:,:';,,:~.'c.!.. 11.,~f.::.-.IJ:,'.,>,...,... ,:;',./c........'.' I; ., /, .'.~, .~, ','>'. '. .~"
), "
~:i ,.:,'. '
'!, ,.'. '
"
(.
, '. ~ "., ; :,~ ~',
'j. ,',i,: :"..
.'1'.' \ .
, .'
.(
"
l '
",!
, "
"
, .
"
~
Planner Mark parry reviewed the request. The 0.38 acre site, on the south
, side of Rockaway Street approximately 500 feet west of Mandalay Avenue, fronts
the Gulf of Mexico and Rockaway Street. The site features a 6,723 square-foot,
one-story restaurant and a one-sto'ry, 21 0 square~foot storage building, which is 3.7
feet from the south rear property line and 2.5 feet from the east side property line.
The restaurant sits on the rear property line and is 1.7 feet from the front property
'line. The parking lot, on the east property line, has 13 parking spaces.
. ,
The site is in a desirable commercial neighborhood. The wooden, Florida-
Cracker style structure has a metal roof and sand-colored, stucco siding. The
restaurant' 5 entrance, a covered, wood deck with ramp on the north side of the
building, encroaches 5.3 feet into the public right-of-way. A partially covered wood
deck is attached to the building, approximately 20 feet from the west property line.
To improve customer service, the business owners wish to expand the
restaurant by adding a 3,487 square-foot, second story with approximately 1,200
square-feet of open deck and 2,300 square feet of enclosed space. Both sections
will accommodate bar patrons and diners; the enclosed portion will include bar
seating. The addition will accommodate 92 diners and 32 bar patrons and increase
the building's si:ze to 10,210 square-feet and the total number of seats to 372. The
applicants also propose to remove and replace the storage room, which is
structurally unsound and unsafe.
"
,I, 'I,
(,\,/J
The second-floor addition and replaced storage room will not extend farther
into the front or rear setbacks than currently exists and will occupy its current
foundation. The project also will renovate and improve the restaurant's interior and
exterior. The second~floor addition will enhance the restaurant's architectural style
and feature stucco walls, decorative railings, and a metal roof. The existing sign.
will be removed during construction but later reattached. The applicants have not
proposed additional signage.
The applicants request reducing the required front and rear setbacks from 10
feet to zero feet, the number of required parking spaces from 71 to 13, and the
number of required handicap parking spaces to zero. The City.owned lot, north of
the restaurant, has five handicap spaces. One handicap space is adjacent to the
restaurant. The restaurant currently is required to have 47 parking spaces. The
proposed addition will require an additional 24 spaces.
Before the parking analysis was done, staff concurred with its methodology.
Florida Design Consultants has submitted a parking analysis, which includes a
survey of 100 Frenchy's customers, and a parking accumulation study performed
on a Friday and Saturday between 11 :00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m. of Frenchy's parking
lot, Municipal Lots #36 and 38, on-street parking along Bay Esplanade, on
Mandalay Avenue between Baymont Street and Bay Esplanade and along Rockaway
Street.
\
~Q';tJ
The study indicated 309 parking spaces are within 1,000 feet of the
restaurant and that at least 45 parking spaces are available within the study area at
mcd1100
7
11/21/00
.' '
,", CI
:'{",::::"'Y':; " ~ ..:;'. < ,',' ....;\ 'i:.:,:.">,, ';>~!'~>>"'! ", I.,
"1 :.> ~ ,'. , .,.J ' ,< i : ". ' .: l '. I ' , .
.,
"
../
., .
.'
~ any given time, including peak times. The study also Indicates that the majority of
. ,} restaurant patrons use the City-owned, metered parking immediately to the north.
This parking lot serves beach visitors and patrons of other area businesses. Of the
100 customers surveyed, 49 stated their primary destination was tho beach and
that eating at Frenchy's was a secondary purpose. This data indicate dual reasons
for restaurant patrons to visit the area and that th'e use of shared parking is valid for
thi"s business.
, Ed Armstrong, representative of the applicant, said he had discussed this
plan with Harry Cline, representative of the adjacent Clearwater Beach Hotel, to
mitigate concerns. Mr~ Cline reported he had agreed to conditions related to the
expansion: 1) addition of restaurant bar & deck to be limited to north half of
building; 2) restaurant to construct a concrete block-wall that extends 8 feet above
the deck to act as a sound barrier (not shown on plan); 3) hours of operation for the
second floor deck will not extend later than 10:00 p.m. on weeknights and 11":00
p.m. on weekends; 4) no outside speakers or live music; 5) lights to be directed
away from the hotel; and 6) City to provide Mr. Cline with copy of site plan for
review.
(1';;\ .
i(.;;J.'!I '
, , ,
Concern was expressed the proposed wall does not meet code. Steve Klar,
architect of the applicant, said an additional wall will not be constructed. Added
height will be constructed on an existing wall. The elevator is required for
compliance with ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act). The bathrooms, on the
south side of the second floor, will be enclosed and buffer noise. A cabana will
cover the bar area only.
In response to a question, Mr. Cline said the hotel's manager would prefer no
nightclub activities occur at the subject property but is willing to make reasonable
concessions. His Interest is to protect the guest's sleep.
One property owner expressed concern regarding the extent of the parking
variance requeste~ and related parking problems, stating the study had occurred on
a weekend when It rained and a football game took place.
Robert Pergolizzi,' representative of the applicant, said staff had approved the
methodology used to conduct the study of parking within 1,000 feet of the
restaurant, which was done on August 25 - 26, 2000, between 11 :00 a.m. and
10:00 p.m. Mr. Armstrong stated the LOS (level of service) on Mandalay Avenue is
rated "B." He said the Code does not recognize a business operating in an area
with high pedestrian traffic. Ms. Hardin said it would be unfair to conduct the
study during Spring Break. She said this action does not preclude the owners of the.
Palm Pavilion from requesting an expansion, although staff is mindful of the
cumulative effects on parking. The City is working on a new beach plan.
Ilj,,%~
It was noted the disabled parking spaces in the City's lot are not free. It
was stated variances for handicapped spaces are not permitted. Ms. Hardin said
staff will make sure handicapped spaces on the subject property comply with
Federal and State law.
mcd1100
8
11121/00
,"
'.., '",
'c' .. , .'
I c [, '. ",~ , ,;" .. ':,,~ 'I ,.'
. '.',:;": '),::'.:;>::'
,. ,
. :',,":) :,
, ~. ':; .,' ,
,.
,~~>:'~:,~.:.:>~<:':':,/,:. ': ',\'0: ,;':': ':':,
~~}<',':,}.::~\:'..'''..':':' .: ;"."" I I.
'.( .'.
> 'I..
l I .,
';',
" ,
. '; I'"
, ..
.. '.'
.l'.
, .
, '
;,\;,
. '
'Ii
"
,"
~ Concern was expressed the expansion will compound beach parking
problems. It was noted the City had never granted a parking variance this large. ft
was felt the request is nor an overuse of the property. It was suggested parking
spaces would turnover more quickly if the restaurant is expanded and patrons are
seated sooner. It was noted beach parking will continue to be difficult until new
facilities are constructed. It was suggested the request will not increase parking
problems. In response to a question, Ms. Hardin said it is natural for businesses in
urban settings to COllnt on public parking.
l:
':.,\
:,
\ \ ~
'>'.
,',
. \1\
I\~'
"\~
. J ~.
, .
. I
f
'I
'. "
.;, ~,I
,. '
".!
Member Johnson moved to approve the request for flexible development of a
Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project to reduce the front setback from 10
feet to 0 feet, reduce the rear setback from 10 feet to 0 feet and reduce the
required number of parking spaces from 71 spaces to 13 parking spaces, and
reduce required number of handicap spaces to 0, if allowed by'law, at Sec 32-28-
16, part of M&B 43.06. The motion was duly seconded. Members Petersen and
Johnson and Chair Figurski voted" Aye" Members Pliska and Moran voted "Nay."
Member Mazur abstaIned. Motion failed due to requIred fOIJr affirmative votes.
Item automatically. continued to December 12, 2000.
,
,.
~<
.~/.,
1<
~!~i
.): ,
I'
"~
\j.:':
~I: ~'.~
'N,
!~/
~1(~
'..;,,'
J: ,(
\ "
. c':-'
'll~~'
u:, j
...:~,:<,
.Y",":>,
tr: ~.
",:,{: \
.' r
:?;~
~ \ '-:,'
.; ~., 1'.
~';,.l.
r~' :;.,
~ /J ,1'1 \
Vii
i;~'l'~
,~., ~ "
,./ ;,
':...."",.l
, I....
Item #04 - 3006 Gulf-to-Bav Boulevard.: Thanh Phuoc & Kimtruc Thi Nguven -
Owner/ADDlicant. Request flexible development approval of a Comprehensive Infill
Redevelopment Project with Comprehensive Landscape Program to operate a
nightclub within the Commercial District, and to reduce the required number of
f~~~} parking spaces from 20 spaces to 18 parking spaces at Bay View City Sub, Blk 8,
Lots 8, 9,. 10 & 1/2 of vac alley on Niess Rd. right-of-way on S. FL 00-08-33
The applicant requested a continuance so request is heard by full board.
. .
Member Johnson moved to continue Case FLOQ-09-33 to December 1 2,
2000. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
ITEM E - DIRECTORS ITEMS
Approval of Minutes
,':,.-.,';
';'.~
":1'11
, .)";
~;(.\
G.I/\
h'(,'
"+I~)
:\).'
:i<
. ;)
1,\ ':~~,I.
'\ .
{\'t!~
"i~i!.\
~.' ),
'/\" \
/..:
ll\.,.
(; '{,
"".1
\.',
Member Johnson moved to approve the minutes of the special meeting of
October'10, 2000 and the regular meeting of October 17, 2000, as recorded and
submitted in written summation to each board member. The motion was duly
. seconded and carried. unanimously.
Annexation, land Use Plan Amendment & Rezoning Cases
Ms. Hardin reported the City Commission to hear the rezoning request for
the Connelly property, adjacent to Bayview, on December 12, 2000.
I.
\(~;
2001 Meeting Schedule
"
mcd1100
9
11/21/00
./,
..
~\>
."
J '
'/'
\\~, .
'/>(.
,',-
; ,>'1,.
~ I:'.
, "
.,
~'~ " "'.
,'.. \,'.
,; {/'~/
.,' '..J:"
:.', \'.~t:.:,<,
. . ~. . ":
...
. 'I,,' L
...., \\ 'j'
"I':.'''') ,."
~: :.': ~';'J"",,::;:::.,,:,:::,. ,{./( ;::: ":.',:,:.:." ':/',yf: ," ;~;'~.l ://,(,: '. / " I"~ >',' ;' ,',j:. ~. ;~":;' ,~<. ' ;\ ; ';':,~,;"',\' ,,,:' :'!::', :(" ., ,.',..",.,X>;:,;'
(' ")',.1 '., '~--.. -'I.. ~.:'. 'i 'f ,.-./.<.I,~ f 1/1".. ,.\'., ""r~ "",. f .t. 'J I" ~/\/'\ ',.,' ~~...~_ ~' ,l.,. ~ ..j
'11 ,1\. ,'IJ'r'" \" /,.'/l ,_ "." ' ....", ,~.:' 1\'.1.'; I "'t,', ' " '. I"'" ,'\ 1:,1,'...\" ,\. ,',' ('
'I) ". 1 ,': '~~.~~, ~ ".' .,.11,..0,. ,~ ." ''',' 'I "I" ,;-.,........ "I ",jh, .)'. " " j' ,-'I, il '~" !' ...... \ i ,'. . 1
.....~,._: !,...J. ('.'. ,1".~....I'(~'>..'JI" -.~ ,I'" ___..'. ,.\---..~~I " ;./ " I\'~"'\' "'.~~'......,
":: ".',...,... "', "I:"" ,"'," ,,,;"."';1..'..: \t~I,,(:/;"'7"J"'.r""" ".\ "11",,. .'1"",",.'/".1.',:;.';""
:.,.\.'-:,:.,.,....:'....:.\, :..~,.':...',...:~,~., ',.;. ':', ','.~.' 'I ~";"':\'\:>j" ,:,.',;c,.'~ I/{':':'::~"'" ,~..h,\:\..',' ",.!, ,.'..
....~.,..." 1,(", it.. . ,J,' ,l ,.r','r,'., I ,f " l\" \, .: I I ,l~, ,oF 'I /' I ('I ,.'.~ \ ,.'I.,..'.,i~~.:i,:'I:,,\.,//..'.
., . .\-.,r~"", /' I ""! . ,.". /. " I, ,'I: }.,'. " " j, ':...... '.\.' ",.~,...-. . 'I"~ '1,'"1
.. ,
"I' i I
I".C
, ~., \: ,~
'.
, '
, .
I \:' .,.,'if. . ,;':' c"H,I"; Y\ '-\ '>~!".:':I: ,/f., ~,c',"',' ~;
:::>.::':.:'.:':::,~~,;'i":~:\'::'::",":"':::';:>\":;''''~'' >:-' ..,; '::<"', ',. ,.:' , ""
, { ..; , , l,. ~
'~ ,'.'. ': c r I I. '
,,'I.
"
I ,\
'I
, .
, .
'. '
. I
.' .
, .:"
. "
. .'
, l
~'!
j~\'..
q
).,
;~~II
~i1i:
..)l
.'i .
.t'
,.)
~.J
'j
t,
o
. Ms. Fierce distributed the proposed schedule of COB meetings for 2001 .
, Consensus was to the December meeting during the second week. It' was
recommended the board also consider rescheduling the November meeting.
,
I
J. ~. '
. .
The 2001 COB meeting schedule: 1) January 23; 2) February 20; 3) March
20;,,4) April 17; 5) May 15; 6) June 19; 7); July 17; 8) August ,21; 9) September
18; 10) October 16; 11)'Novernber 13; and 12) December 11,2001.
10-.,'
, ,.
,. .
\ .;
I, ,
.,
. .
J"'
1
I "
I
'.'1
I
l
Holidav Luncheon/MeetlnQ
,
'c't
~j. .
\,' :
, \,
1)/,1
(
\<
,,"
The Holiday Luncheon is scheduled for December 1 2, 2000, at the
Harborview Center at 11 :30 a.m. Canned goods and unwrapped toys will be
collected for the Officer Friendly holiday drive.
;i"
, 'l
/'
',.
..
"fhe CDS meeti~g . will follow at 1 :00 p.m. at City Hall.
i'
J.
~ ",I
" 1
I"
1.' ...
, \;
',:\1
\ '
~I::
Appointment of Alternate Board Member
,r';.
'.
C\'i
.':-:,:i
\~ 1-'-'
!('; .
0;;;~~
, ,\ ~
. ~~)'
., 'j
/".)
t j ~:{
, 1, ~'
. ~J
11,~I.
,.J'
./"-;. .
'/'X,
. ;',.
;'. ':1
'~l t"'~
ii:-:.' ,
:~ I )',
,I"
~ : ~
~.\! .
,..,{"\
,,:t.~
f ,,,,!
~..!;,\,
" Mr. Stone requested board support of a Code amendment to appoint an
alternate board member to serve when board members are absent. If the full board
is present, the alternate would listen to the meeting. The position would provide
experience before appointment as a permanent member and reduce continuances
due to absent members. Discussion ensued regarding other cities' boards.
I~' ,
.I}:,
"
" Jl'
,. \
'"
Consensus was to recommend appointment of an alternate board member.
,:"1'
~ "'~~
I. :~
,~.~!, ,
1~'
, },
;):,
,~ ~,
Board Member Comments
)Jj
1:\,'.
1. '. ~
~. ~, ,
1"~I,
.. ',,~'
/F.'
, '~.'
:j ~'
~.:ri~
'. .
~~,<
.'1 '1
'oN,
"(11:'
I ~,
,~~ .';
" '.,
:,t
It was noted the cell tower, under construction near Gulf-to~Bay Boulevard,
looks terrible and does not blend into its surroundings as promised.
,"
;~?~,
:,.,',
", \,V
"" !
;,"'>
.., ,; ~'l.
.\ "
\", .,{
:'t \ .
:;,\ :
'{
.;;, i,
1.1;:11,
" (I
,': I,
I'.,.... '
\ \':\,\.:
;' ..\ I
'4\.'
/~.
\.)
.. I ~ '
;/.' ( :.~
II
. It was recommended City' applications be heard at the end of the agenda;
Mr. Stone said staff would do that. Today's items were placed at the beginning of
. the agenda as approximately 35 residents had attended the workshop and may
have wished to provide input to the board.
(:d0-
: '.; '~
.t.,....
. '.
.~t.,'~
.. ~~
It;i
,1....
ITEM F - ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 3:24 p.m.
~~
".
. ,
1 ,
ir
Community Development
.'
:,'.,{
.~ ,~
~ ':
\
,'.~ '..
,1''''
'15-
:~:;
~',~ '
'.,f;
,.,
'~i
mcdl100
10
11/21/00
.\ .
/',
C.
.' ~ "
/r .-
'."
I ,~.
,
,./
','
"j
! ,.;.
~',~
:("<."~
, ,
, ,
. .\.~
, i
, , ' ~
,(>
~~(, f,
, "
" :. ~
.,
"
,
.......,.
'"..:.',
'. ,
~\ '.1....
,I',. . ~~.,: :'>~;~ ::<<',<j~~ <,;..' :;.:<;,
.: ' .. ': ~ . :,.; '~ . \'
., ,<>~~:':: ~
I', ' ~
~ .J (.:;;,::, , ,":' ;':',' ".: :~ ':.'.' ..~>,>' ':\<: '.; .:: ,:' . ',: ~,' :,\~.:~" :''''; ~~.~.~,:~ :,'<:':'>}:/.<~<..;~:',::' ,~~'\, ';'.::::,<'.;.:i".": '<:.:':"',',: :;.':, ':;'.; ". ::','::, '.~. ' (~:;~;:; ;',. //, ,/,.~,;: :;':,.'
'-., , i' ,\ ","., .". .....,..\.\ ./ ',' ,\ ,'" ... ,-,'., . ,...,.., I....'l'~.... ... ",.,. ')i I
.. 1 '" . \ ,II ~../ \, \" ~ \........ ,I 1.' ~.",,;,~,~,,":',',':.':.',(._..I ".'.'," .I'~,.,.,;.".:;...,.:.' '.,:.,','..'1.....,...:" ,;".:".,:';,.:I.',':'.,',:'J,'~l"
.' I'" :\:::~:. :.: ;~:: ..~:./:~/ ..;",.~,..,..~,.::.::" .',! : ;'.i<' ,':~>,,:"\ ,:,'\:;:':,:: "':~I>~" :'~':"''':.:~:';'7-\<; t, \'~'I ,',,, t';.) ..: ,. ", . ','.' ,I ':'1,
'.'."'?'<\"',:,',:,~,:\'-:', '" ,..,."":",;,,,);;,,~;. /\Y ',?;',:' ::<(1:,,. I ';:>'!-):" ..I':.~';;;'r:.t" :<~~..~',:~,.I' :;/, '.":"'::'/:"~:<\>,;;;:I,. ":;-::',:';'
, ,.-"-"-,
,. ,
. .
",
"
\: ~.
, '1"
I ~,~ .
,';,"
'~,q
tl,'
~~Ir
V
.:'J}
./.::....
'.~ ';,~.
':;~
\;'1
,.I ~
'.~~;~
~~ p
,",\;
I ,~,
\.:/..~'
:1\
"'11
},\:. :"
fl""~<l
"~':~ I:~:O-)'
'::"-i
.(~:. '
.,..,
'.~~ ..1/,
".
.,;~'
\. .
~~ ;.~
'/'
i/~,
{~~, :
~J
: ~:~~
i/
\f.",:...
. ~
~) ,;,,1:
:",.
l..../~
,~ '\
"'J',
',.
;l'" .
~;: ;'
, t
;~..\'"
" ,\;',
(.'f #<~:. I
).' \,
.\1...
:.t
;'./,
.\. ./
, ,
'- ,/'
."'ll'"
, .,
i ~,~' "j
, 1'..
i ~ . '.
'I.
,.( .
I, . ;'
. ~,
.::\'S\
,./;.
... ")'
.....
::It ..
HI,I',
,:1: !~,',:"':\.,,! :',,:" ','. ... :.: I
, . \. '.. J ,.... ~ .~.. :.'
?; ":;t~;',/' "".' ,
';
FORM 88 MEMORANDUM OF VOTING CONFLICT FOR COUNTY,
MUNICIPAL, AND OTHER LOCAL PUBLIC OFFICERS
ME . FIRST NAME. MIDDLE NAME
"ZtI/l. .;r.-
MAIUNG ADDRESS
t"J~ hi,
CITY COUNTY
(,~ tlJA ~,.. It..e,/J
DATE ON WHICH VOTe OCCURED
"/"', .".1
NAME OF BOARD, COUNCIL, COMMISSION AUTHORITY OR
COMMITTEE 't /)
THE BOARD, COUNCIL, COMMISSION, AUTHORITY OR
COMMmEE ON WHICH I SERVE IS A UNIT OF:
CITY 0 COUNTY 0 OTHER LOCAL AGENCY .
NAME OF POllTICA~IVISI0N:
C/t..t"~ ,It
PGf POSITION IS:
o ELECTIVE
APPOINTIVE
WHO MUST FILE FORM la
This form is for use by an pel'$Oll serving at the county. city, or othor Ioc:al 16vol of govemmont on an appointed or elected board, council,
commission. authority, CI' committee. It applies oquany to membero of advisory and non-advisory bodies who are presented with iii voting
cannict of interest undor Section , 12.3143, Florida Statutes.
,
Your rosponsibilities undor the laW when fK<<I vMh II measure in which you haw a conniet of rntere-st will vary greatly dopending on,wnethor
you hold an t!lective or appointive pouition. For thb r~son, pl6aso pay close attention to the Instructions on this form before complotlng the
reverse sido and filing the form.
INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPUANCE WITH SECTION 112,3143, FLORIDA STATUTES
A person holding eklctive CI' IiIppointive county, municipal. or other local public office MUST ABSTAIN from voting on a measuro which inurll'S
to his specllll prtnto gain. Each e\octod or appointed local offICer also is prohibited from knowingly voting on a measuro which inures to the
specral gain of a principal (other than a goYl)mmont agency) by whom he is retained (including the parent organization or subsidiary of a
CCI'pOf'ate principal by which he is rotllned); to the spec~ privata galn of iii relative; or to the spooial private gain of a business associate.
Commissioners af community redevelopment agonclos under Sec. 163,356 or 163.357, F.S.. ond officem of Independent special tax districts
electod on a Ol1O-aeTe, one-vote basis are not prohibited from voting in that capacity.
- .
For PUrpos&S of this Law, a "relative" includes only the offICer's father, mother, son, daughter, husband, WIfe. father-in.law, mother-in-law,
son-in-law, and daughter-io.law. A "business associate" mea~ any person or entity ongaged in or carrying on a business enterprise with the
office( as a parmer, joint venturer, co-ovmer or property, CI' corporate shareholder (where the shares of the corporation are not listed on any
national or regional stock exchange).
ELECTED OFFICERS:
In addition to abstaining from voting in the situations dltSCribed above, you must disclose the connict:
PRIOR TO THE VOTE BEING TAKEN by p4Jblicly stating to tho assembly tho nature of your interest in the measure on which you are
abstaining from voting: .nd
WITHIN 15 DAYS AFTER THE VOTE OCCURS by complsting and filing ttlia foml with the person responsible for recording tho mlnutos
of the meeting, who should incorporate the form in tM minutes.
AP~NTED OFFICERS:
Although you must abstain from voting in U'Mt situations described above, you otherwise may participate in these matters. However, you
must dIsclose the nature of the conflict before making any attempt to Jnnuenco the decision, wtlether orally or in writing and whether made by
you or your direction.
IF YOU INTEND TO MAKE ANY ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE THE DECISION PRIOR TO THE MEETING AT WHICH THE VOTE WILL BE
TAKEN:
. You must complete and tile this form (before making any attempt to Influence the decision) with the person r'3sponsibla for recording the
minutes of the meeting, who willlncorporata the form in the minutes.
. A copy of the form must be provided immediately to the other members of the agency.
\j\J 6L ==?
. The form must be read publicly at the next meeting after the form is filed.
CE Form 88.10-91
PACe I
. ., j
.~'::'. i.:';.'\', :,:;. ~'I:;' ;...,':. ',';/<
I .. ;1 . '., ~ I " r 'f\.' '/ '-I ...,.. ~',~I~' ~' I....~ -, " ~',' 'I~, ". " _I ,: 1'1,~" ~ 1
.. ., I" ~.. <'.Il'l'~~'.t", ,I ~ I f,~}"\I.,.ltl../l',{,,J)~ I\~/:'. ~', '. ""'1"(',1"/,1 ,~'. ~}, r" ,...,oJ',.,. '~,:.r'\" \.'\.' ~',I'
::, ,;.,',>~::::::. ~~ ,:~ \',' :-, :.'.' \>'f< ~'; ~", :', ~:,: /: :":'.' /~~. ';''',: ;.~ ;','i"'::. ::.i '/' ~::;\\/';:';':;:, ::,':\: ".';'::"~ ':" (;:.<~:':,~,"; .': ';:":..;:.~'::':~;' '; i,.:~<.< '<:':":"("\' ~~},' \":i~ (.~
\ 1 , I ,I I ' I #) 1.,. ., I ":'\~ , ~ I ~ .. " '..,.. . t ~,~. ,~d,' ~I.' I ' ~i f,P ~, ..: _,'. l . f, i'L I ;.(' ~, ,../., ,..... .
, ",' . ~ " I 1'1 "'.. I' ~'~., ".............-; '.,., . .-, , I ..,,~,' , ,.....1 ~ ' .." I''''
",'":,, ~-'I' """~"""".~I""\"',J,,,-,,.1""''l-f'' .'.~,.,.,...";,."" ",' I..., "'d~":,'",,,'\;'."'..I:,'"
,:' ;:~::::::',~';: ::'~<,;:>,,< '<:'.:,:.:',~' ::::':;:\:'.'-..::':'~::?\ <I:, J.~;,:;::":,: :";,,:\\t:',: '.r,/} (;:: ;::,1 ,:~', ,.t.~>:{" ~,'.",I::'<I./ tj."",).:.H~');}/ .:'~i;:;;:.::):"<,
< -'I'" .
~! " " .1 ..
. .
IF YOU MAKE NO ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE THE OECISION EXCEPT RY DISCUSSION AT THE MEETING:,
· Yoo rrut chcIoIl.n ~ tho nuturt of )1CU' cordIc:t In the rneaur. before plIf1Sc;lpiltlng.
· You mull COlnpltae 1he fonn and.. It within 115 dlV-lIfflDr tie "'* 0CCln wfth h penon ~ far ~ the minutH of the
meeting, who nut Incorporate the form fn the rnInutM. A 00frI at the foon m.at be provided 1nvnedIa~ to the other mtrnboR of the
1tQIWlCy, If1d tie tarm muet bI rnd pubIic:Iy lit tM nG:t mt;et/ng after tht fomt ,. tBed.
(~
. DISCLOSURE OF LOCAL OFFICER'S INTEREST
I, ~J ftlC") /VI 4..... ti#- :r"... . hereby cIlSCloM that en
(a) ^ l1l8lmJr'e caine CC' Wdt~ befQra my QOl!lOC)' wtlich {chec'k one}
.19
inured to my special privato gain;
Inured to the special g.;/n of my business asaocIate,
,Inured to the spoclal gain of my ~3tive.
)( Inured to the special gain of t '/tit f -
inured to the special gain of
J::. / S .e,1/~"
,
. .
,4. k~ am retained; or,
. which is the parent
organization or subsldlary of a prioclpQI which haB reblined mo.
(b) The measure bofore my agency and tho n:;ature of my connlctlng interest In tha rne;;asurs is as folk7ws:
t-,. Jf'I- l'iAA~"1 n.t.-J...."C... - · ..
Mr~ V"ON+~ ~~/~
~ -.I ~ ~ Yi.yL""";/ k ~U ~~
I(~~J
Data Filed ..
NOTICE: UNDER PROVISIONS OF FLORIDA STATUTES !i112.317 (1991). A FAILURE TO MAKE ANY REQUIRED DISCLOSURE
CONSTITUTES GROUNDS FOR AND MAY BE PUNISHED BY ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOWING: IMPEACHMENT, REMOVAL
OR SUSPENSION FROM OFFICE OR EMPLOYMENT, DEMOITION, REDUCTIONS IN SALARY, REPRIMAND, OR A CIVIL PENAL TV
NOT TO EXCEED $5,000. ~rdf;
",.
CE Form SS . 10-91
PAGE 2