01/12/1998 (2)
.' .
., .
I.
'. "'d
"'.{' .
. .' .. .
.,,' , ,
., .
, ,~, '
: ,
. , . > 'I,
'> I .
. .,' ~ :
. . .
c . .
, .
I .". F' . ..
.~. ... ',' ~. ." I. ,.. :- "::".'."
<" K1
. . .;, "'.
. .' .
'I ,. > ' .
'.1 .
~~,~fi':.:~:';'~'::;" ;..'i.
, '; '. <
; 'c' ,I. '" +.",.
. '. " I',
. ..' , .. . I." '. 'I ~ . ...... ~.. . " '. .:. ." ~ .' ~ .. :. ' \:.
: ",
'< '.
. ..~. '. .
, . .
,
, .
, .
,
. I
,'. .
, " .
. .'
,.:.. " .1'
'" .
~ ",
.~ :
,. .
~. .' .
.'
\' :
';
. .
I
,.
I..' .
i".: .
WORKSESSION
~ ,',"
. '.
L, : I
.~':. "+, '
.::.' t"" '. {..-.
"
<.;:-.: ". "
~ity Commission Worksession Minutes
~'. '
>,. .
;:", . .' .'
f,~, :'"
, .1
"
~'. :. '.
:~..:., . ". I > ,
.........
~',l:,:.~ .
:,', '."
i., .. ,:
. ..
,l-'f .'
......~. Date
an
2
'lg
'r.:'. . '
r>:
"/' .
" .
, ,
..., ,.'
~ '.' \.
'I '.
. _ ' I ,
I
. .
, 1, '
..,
?;LfCo
..'.' .
:'.:'<~'
. . .....~..;..
€I
w
CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION
CITY OF CLEARWATER
January 12, 1998
Present:
Rita Garvey
J. B. Johnso'n
Robert Clark.
Ed, Hooper
Karen Seel
Michael J. Roberto
Kathy S. Rice
Bob Keller
Pamela K. Akin
Cynthia E. Goudeau
Patricia o. Sullivan
> Mayor/Commissioner
Vice-Mayor /Commissioner
Commissioner
Commissioner.
Commissioner
City Manager
Deputy City Manager
Assistant City Manager
City Attorney
City Clerk
Board Reporter
The meeting was called to order at 1 :00 p.m. at City Hall.
Service Awards
Six service awards were presented to City employees.
The Commission recessed from 1 :08 to 1 :49 p.m. to meet as the Pension Trustees
and eRA (Community Redevelopment Agency).
PUR PURCHASING
Gaylord Brothers; extension, maintenance of Galaxy hardware & s'oftware utilized by all
Library branches, 01/01/98 ~12/31/98, $42,202 (LIB)
Mid~Continent Electric, construction of mast 8rm foundations for traffic signal poles,
01/09/98 -12/31/98, $73,728 (PW)
M.T. Deason Company, Inc., gas materials ~ steel pipe & fittings, 01/09/98 -01/31/99.
estimated $54,885.05 (GAS)
Grinnell Corp., brass waterflttJngs, 02/01/98 .01/31/99, estimated $120,000 (PW)
PeopleSoft, Inc., maintenance, upgrades, source code updates & telephonic support for
payroll/human resources software system, 02/01/98 -01/31/99, estimated $66,067 (1M)
Brad Ragan, Inc., vehicle tires (new), 01/15/98 -09/30/99, estimated $305,000 (GS)
Pride of Florida, recapped vehicle tires, 01/15/98 -09/30/98, estimated $71,000 (GS)
Ed Morse Chevrolet, threo 1998 Chevrolet Monte Carlo sedans (r.aplacement), $46,632;
funding to be provided under City's master lease-purchase agreement (GS)
,
j
1
1
I
,
,
\
i
t.
mws0198
1
01/12/98
~
. . ~... ~
"'~
.~
-')
...-."
~
Don Reid Ford, four 1998 Ford Ranger plckup trucks (replacement and three 1998 Ford
Tauru8 4 door sedans (replacement), $97,442; funding to be provided under City's master
lease-purchase agreement (OS)
Southern Sewer Equipment, ona 1998 Vac-Con Model VPD~3690THA sewer cleaner
vehicle (replacement), $159,770; funding to be provided under City's master lease-
purchase agreement (GS)
Environmental Holdings, Inc. d/b/a Vantage Equipment, one 1998 Vector Sewer Cleaning
Unit mounted on a Ford LT8513 chassis (replacement), $164,600: funding to be provided
under City's master lease-purchase agreement (OS)
Ed Morse Chevrolet, one 1998 Chevrolet Suburban, $27,487; funding to be provided under
City's master lease-purchase agreement (GS)
Carlisle Ford, twelve 1998 Ford Crown Victoria police pursuit vehicles, $287,988; funding
to be provided under City's master lease-purchase agreement (GS)
Kelly Services, temporary employment services, award date through 11/30/98, estimated
$45,000 (HR)
Onyx Petroleum, 87 octane vehicle fuel, award date through 12/15/98, estimated
$230,000 (OS)
I
Declare surplus to needs of City one 14'x36' Derrick Barge, FL 7109 EG, asset number G-
485 (FN) .
In response to a question regarding the contracted services with PeopleSoft, Inc.,
Deputy City Manager Kathy Rice said the "year 2000" has been solved. This contract will
provide ongoing maintenance for the program. The City also ;s purchasing the source
code.
In response to a question regarding the contract with Pride of Florida for recapped
vehicle tires, Purchasing Manager George McKibben said Pride is exempt from the
requirement to bid.
In response to a question regarding the purchases of one Chevrolet Suburban and
12 Ford Crown Victoria vehicles, Mr. McKibben said these are replar.ements.
In response to a question regarding the contract with Kelly Services for temporary
employment services, Ms. Rice said the City awards this contract every year.
In response to a question regarding the contract with Mid-Continent Electric for
construction of mast arm foundations for traffic signal poles, Mr. McKibben said this
contract covers the wiring and concrete for the project.
mwsO 198
2
01/12/98
.~
/F....aJi-
C ~ \
'\'S"'/
.~
In response to a question regarding the contract with Brad Ragan, Inc. for new
vehicle tires, Mr. McKibben said this Is the first time the City has worked with this vendor.
In response to a question regarding the contract with Ed Morse Chevrolet for .
vehicles, Mr. McKibben reported this purchase is for undercover vehicles.
In response to a question regarding the contract with Onyx Petroleum for vehicle
fuel,' Mr. McKibben said the contract expires in less than 1-year as this agreement
piggybacks on the County's contract.
First ReadinQ Ord. #6218-98 - Relating to utilities; amending Secs. 32.062, 32.066,
32.070, 32.071, 32.072, and Appendix A, Art. XXIV Utilities - General and Deposits, and
Appendix A, Art. XXV Public Works - Fees, Rates and Charges
Under the proposed change, utility deposit requirements are reduced from 3 months
to 2 months. Condominium associations with good account experience will be exempt
from utility deposits. The lien process is streamlined. Changing many mandatory "shall(s)"
to advisory "may(s)" allows Utility Customer Service personnel flexibility in applying
ordinances. These changes empower staff to assist customers' at the first point of contact
and will allow Utility Customer Service to be more customer friendly.
Assistant Director Finance/Utility Customer Service John Scott said the proposed
changes will allow more flex:ibility and improve customer service. Members of
condominium associations will be exempted from deposit requirements. The lien process
will be streamlined and the size of deposits reduced. It was suggested deposits be based
on previous usage at the address as well as a resident's current usage. Mr. Scott said the
City will be able to increase deposits on delinquent accounts. In response to a question,
the City Manager said the proposed changes will improve flexibility in providing good.
customer service. In response to a question, Mr. Scott said the City currently does not
require signatures for utility customers who apply for service via telephone. Other public
utilities do not require signatures. The City Attorney said the City can still collect for
delinque'ncies. In response to a question, Mr. Scott said 'the City had wanted each unit of
a duplex or triplex to have a meter but will consider waiving that requirement.
FN FINANCE
Res. #98-09 - orovidlng for sale of. not to exceed $9-million Gas System Revenue
Refundina Bonds. Series 1998 (FN)
Gas System Revenue Bonds, Series 1998, In an amount not to exceed $9-million,
will be used to refinance Series 1 994A, Gas System Revenue Bonds, at a present value
savings greater than 4%. The bonds will not be refunded unless the 4% savings is
realized. In October 1997, the City attempted to refinance the 1994A bonds but interest
rates were not low enough to generate a 4% pre,sent value savings. The 1997B bonds
were issued to refinance the 1991 bonds. Market conditions have improved and the
1994A bonds can be refunded at a present value savings of 5.35% ($434,OOO). The City
mws0198
3
01/12/98
. '
:..' t. " . '., . '.....,. '. . .. , . .
~
has selected William R. Hough & Co... Merrill Lynch & Co., and Raymond James &
Associates to serve as underwriters on these bonds, which will be sold through negotiated
public sale.
This resolution authorizes the City Manager and Finance Director to award the sale
of the bonds and to determine if it is in the best interest of the City to purchase a debt
service surety bond or to fund a debt service reserve.
In response to a question, Finance Director Margie Simmons said payback of the
debt would be shortened by 1-year.
...
GS GENERAL SERVICES
Don Reid Ford. one 1998 Ford Taurus 4 door station wagon. $18.169; authorize funding
under City's master lease-purchase agreement
ti-&~
t::;:;~"
Unit G282, a fully depreciated 1988 Ford Tempo assigned to Engineering Services
requires $2,300 in repairs. Life to date repairs are $7,793.50, or 94% of original purchase
price of $8,212.57. This unit is not on the FY 1997/98 approved replacement list and the
purchase will require a 1 st quarter budget amondment to increase the project budget in
motorized equipment-LIP, for $17,258. In addition, the Engineering Department will
provide the additional $911 to upgrade to a station wagon from savings in department
personnel service costs. Savings in departmental personnel service costs also will provide
funding for monthly operating charges.
!
!
1
'!
Considering the cost of required repairs and life to date repair costs, replacement of
the unit is the most economical approach to providing the department comparable
transportation support.
In response to a question, Ms. Rice said this purchase was not listed under
"Purchasing" as this vehicle had not been included on the replacement list. As the 1988
Ford Tempo has averaged 3,000 miles a year, it was recommended this vehicle is not
necessary. General Service Director Bill Baird said the vehicle is used for numerous short
trips. In response to a concern that none of the vehicles considered today is being
purchased from a Clearwater dealership, he stated every automobile dealer in Florida can
participate in the State contract. It was suggested staff check dealerships to see if lower
prices are available locally. Staff will report by Thursday.
License Agreement. BellSouth Mobilitv. Inc.. for non-exclusive use involvina installation &
oDeration of pes (personal communications systems) equipment at City's communication
tower located at 3290 SR 580, for initial 5 year term, with 4 automatic options to renew
for 4 additional terms of 5 years each, unless City is notified to contrary
According to the proposed licensing agreement, BellSouth Mobility, Inc. will pay
$21,600 lease payments for the first year. Each year the payment will increase by 4%
over the prior year. The initial 5-year period will commence no later than 60 days
following Commission approval. BellSouth Mobility, Inc. shall establish the
J
mws0198
4
01/12/98
I,
.'
~
"....)
r"':-qlJ1
--J
commencement date by written notification to the City Attorney's office at least 10 days
before it wishes to access the site to commence construction. Site installation will include
ground base communications equipment on a concrete pad not to exceed 375 square.feet
(, 5-fget by 25-feet) linked by coaxial cable to 6 antennas at an elevation of 240 feet. The
antennas will be located on the existing radio communication tower, The ground space
under and near the tower is used for communication equipment. Rent is payable in 4
quarterly payments of $5,400 for the first year. Subsequent year's rent will increase by
4%. The total rental payment is $21,500 for the 1 It year and a total of $116,992.56 for
the first 5 years.
Other license agreement provisions include: 1) BellSouth Mobility, Inc. will be
responsible for all maintenance and utilities related to its installation; 2) BellSouth Mobility,
Inc. shall provide combined single limit bodily injury and property damage insurance of not
less than $1-miUion with the City as additional insured; 3) BellSouth Mobility, Inc.
covenants that its installations will not interfere with any City communications equipment,
or that of others currently operating under any agreement with the City; 4) BellSouth
Mobility, Inc. is responsible for removing aU equipment upon final license termination, and
for site restoration; and 5) either party has the right to terminate this license for reason
with 30 days advance written notice.
The City Manager said BellSouth Mobility, Inc. had approached the City regarding
this tower. He said little interest in this issue has occurred. Communication towers
already stand in Countryside. It was noted communication equipment also is located on a
water tower. Concern was expressed the City has few structures as tsll as the subject
tower. It was questioned if $1-milJion in liability insurance was adequate. In response to a
question, Controller Fred Belzoll'said other offers were lower. A staff survey indicated City
fees charged for this type of agreement are in the top 90 percentile. The City Manager
noted the license agreement is for 25 years. In response to a question, the City Attorney
indicated the termination clause is narrow. In response to a question, the City Manager
said should Clearwater ever raze the subject tower, a replacement would be necessary to
carry City communication equipment. Should that occur, the City would be responsible for
moving the subject BellSouth Mobility, Inc. communication equipment.
The City Commission recessed from 2:27 to 2:41 p.m.
HR HUMAN RESOURCES
Aporove revision to SAMP pay Dlan incorooratinq modified concects that restructure 1 3
SAMP pay ranges into 6 salary bands
The SAMP (Supervisory, Administrative, Managerial, and Professional) Pay Plan
Revision Project was initiated to revise and restructure the compensation plan for non.
represented City employees. The proposal addresses existing pay issues and aligns the
non-union compensation program with the City's need to attract and retain competent and
motivated employees.
mwsO 198
5
01/12/98
.~
-
. \
......)
.~
Approval of this pay plan is Phase I, which will implement a modified broad banded
pay plan with all SAMP classifications allocated to 6 broad salary bands. The .modified pay
plari structure will reduce the number of salary ranges in the SAMP plan, provide greater
flexibility for Implementing organizational changes, and flatten the City's hierarchical
structure. Phase 11 will be accomplished administratively and, over 2 years, will maximize
the effect of the broad banded pay structure by further reducing the number of overly-
specialized job classifications and by implementing a SAMP performance evaluation review
process with innovative merit-based compensation programs which reinforce the values of
the organization.
The 13 pay ranges in the current SAMP pay plan have not been adjusted during the
past 4 years. During that time, the City has negotiated several annual pay range and wage
increases affecting all union represented job classifications causing significant salary
compression with unadjusted SAMP pay ranges. The broadbanded pay plan model was
researched and sel.ected to establish a more effective compensation structure that will
provide greater administrative flexibility and financial controls necessary to facilitate
organizational changes. It also allows the City to resolve perceived pay inequities, avoid
the necessity of granting pay increases due to minor job restructuring or transfers to
equivalent level jobs, and flattens organizational structure.
Broad SAMP salary bands for 6 organizational job categories are based on current
labor market studies. The top 3 salary bands cover unclassified executive, administrative,
and operational management SAMP job classifications. The 3 lower salary bands cover all
non-represented supervisory, professional, and technical level employees in cfassified
positions covered by Civil Service Rules. The broad banded SAMP pay plan can be
implemented with costs of less than $500 since all but a few recently hired SAMP
employees currently earn salaries above the salary band minimums for their job
classifications.
Interim Human Resources Director Steve Rosenthal recommended SAMP salary pay
ranges be broadbanded. He distributed copies of the SAMP Broadbanding Pay Plan
Proposal. The SAMP Pay Plan is a compensation program for non-representod employees.
Regarding the present SAMP Pay Plan, he reported: 1) salary ranges last adjusted 4 years
ago; 2) competitive edge within labor market compromised for numerous classifications. A
recent survey indicated 72% of SAMP salaries are lower than those paid by other
goyernments; .92% lower than the private sector; 3) lack of flexibility impedes
organizational restructuring; and 4) represented employee pay grades have encroached on
SAMP salary ranges.
Mr. Rosenthal said characteristics of broad banding include: 1) fewer levels or pay
ranges; 2) salary differential between the minimum and maximum is wider; 3)
classifications grouped in Salary. Bands based upon functional level and market value. He
said the current pay plan has too many ranges. Controls will be in place to be certain
employee salaries remain under control: 4) target entry and maximum pay levels based on
Labor Market data; 5) flexible guidelines enhance City's ability to remain competitive
within the Labor Market; and 6) structure accommodates individual and team performance-
based merit programs.
mwsO 1 98
6
01/12/98
".
~
.~~)
~J
Mr. Rosenthal said advantages of broadbanding to the City include: 1} reduces
organiiationallevels; 2) facilitates restructuring; 3) increases flexibility to remain
competitive; 4) allows performance-based merit pay concepts; 5) reduces salary range
compression; and 6) eliminates focus on minor differences in job levels. This rE)vision will
allow flexibility so that only major department restructuring will result in job changes
requiring promotions.
The revision would establish 6 SAMP Salary Bands: 1) unclassified ~ Executive
Management; 2) unclassified. Administrative Management; 3) unclassified - Operational
Management; 4) classified - Supervisory/Professional; 5) classified - Professional; and 6)
classified w Technical. Classified employees work under Civil Service Rules.
Under the proposal, the Human Resources Department would administer the
guidelines and controls for the restructured Pay Plan: 1) allocates classifications to
appropriate salary bands; 2) monitors labor Market data; 3) determines market-based
target entry and maximum salaries for classifications; and 4) recommends revisions to the
Plan for City Manager approval. Mr. Rosenthal said the restructuring would allow
innovative techniques to be used to compensate long term employees without salaries
getting out of kilter. Regarding the cost to implement this change, Mr. Rosenthal said the
current salaries of most SAMP employees Bre within the proposed salary bands. He said
placing all SAMP employees into the proposed salary bands would cost $ 500 in additional
salary.
It was suggested the City Manager should make the decision regarding this issue
instead of the Ci~y Commission. It was noted discussion of this proposed change is similar
to union negotiations. The City Manager indicated the costs will be included in future
budgets. Mr. Rosenthal said the restructuring reflects the parameters where the
organization of the City is headed. Staff's intention is to not come before the City
Commission regarding every change. He said this revision is being presented to the
Commission as the current SAMP Pay Plan was approved previously bV the City
Commission.
Support for the proposal was stated. Mr. Rosenthal said this restructuring is
important when targeting entry level positions. Ms. Rice said the revision is being
proposed in response to Commission direction to the Human Resources Department to
review the Labor Market and to develop a pay structure flexible enough to reward
employees. The City Manager said not all employees are covered by bargaining units and a
degree of flexibility is necessary. The proposed plan allows management more flexibility in
dealing with a range of circumstances. It was noted some City positions require
significant expertise. The City must compete with the private market.
In response to a question, Ms. Rice indicated this change will have some impact on
the Pension benefits for those at the top of their current range. The City Manager said in
the current Labor Market, the City must be more competitive in attracting quality
employees. He said these revisions place the sole rBsponsibility on him to meet futlJre
mws0198
7
01/12/98
,
.~")'
'I>
.-J
budget demands. It was noted the change will olimlnate SAMP employees from earning
less than those they supervise.
In response to a question, Mr. Rosenthal said the shelf life of the proposed pay
ranges is 2 to 3 years, although some may be valid for 5 years. It was stated virtually all
proposed SAMP maximum pay rates are increased in the revision. Concern was expressed
regarding the long range implications of this change on future budgets. Mr. Rosenthal said
the proposal will allow employees who are at the maximum of their range to earn more
money. Every 2 years, staff will Identify the maximum for each band. Recommendations
regarding individuals wilf be made at that time. In response to a question, he said 72% of
all SAMP positions earn less than the average minimum and maximum of their counterparts
in other govornment organizations.
In response to a question, Ms. Rice felt the City does an adequate job in promoting
its total benefit package when recruiting employees. In response to a question, Mr.
Rosenthal identified one challenge of broad banding as maintaining flexibility without
requiring instant rules for every case. The biggest challenge will be keeping the survey
data current. He agreed the entire effort of employee recruitment could be improved.
Concern was expressed employees not earn salary adjustments just because they
increased their knowledge. It was felt doing so would violate the Commission Vision
Statement. Mr. Rosenthal said the value of additional education would need to be
considered. Under the proposed concept, the next step up is in the same band. It was
noted this concept provide3 the City the ability to compensate employees for newly
acquired skills without having to promote them.
In response to a question, Ms. Rice said the survey did not address benefits. It was
noted public sector benefits are good. The City Manager indicated most municipalities
offer benefits similar to the City. It was felt comparing benefits with the private sector is
necessary to provide a total picture employee costs. It was felt the pay structure should
be oriented to improved customer service. It was noted this proposed plan provides
flexibility for change. It was felt the plan must be a market-based system. In response to
a question, Ms. Rice said when negotiating with the unions, the City Commission was
never cognizant of the level of that year's SAMP increase. In reference to department
heads and senior staff, the City Manager said results of the survey are difficult to measure.
He has been considering outcomes as a measurement. He said the pay plan requires a
certain level of flexibility.
PO POLICE
Aoorove donation to CHIP (Clearwater Homeless Intervention Protect, Inc.) for funding of
operations in the amount $100,000; funding to be provided by unappropriated retained
earnings of the Special Program Fund
On June 5, 1997, a presentation was made to the City Commission concerning
CHIP (Clearwater Homeless Intervention Project, Inc.) construction and operation budgets.
The City Commission approved an additional $55,000 contribution in construction funding
to be provided by unappropriated retained earnings of the Special Program Fund. Funding
mws0198
8
01/12/98
'1
.::)
--J
for operations also was requested. A projected $320,000 annual operations budget was
, anticipated and funding had not been raised. .
Former City Manager Betty Deptula had reported unappropriated retained earnings
of the Special Program Fund had accumulated sufficiently to contribute $100,000 annually
to CHIP operations. During discussion of the operating fund request, it was determined the
3 proposed $100,000 contributions should be handled through the budget process. The
current year's fiscal budget does not include the $100,000 contribution to CHIP. The
CHIP shelter is almost complete and should be open and functioning within 3 months.
Operational funds are needed. The City's $100,000 contribution is essential to CHIP's
successful operation.
It was noted this is the 111 of 3 annual requests. Staff was requested to report on
the funds available in the Special Program Fund.
PW PUBLIC WORKS
Presentation - Island Estates Park
In his January 6, 1998, memorandum, Public Works Administrator Rich Baier
reviewed a conceptual plan for a proposed park on the vacant lot at 204 Windward
Passage. A small playground for children and a paved linear walkway are proposed. He
recommended discussion concerning; 1) construction costs; 2) benefit to community; 3)
land use alternatives; 4) proximity to other park facilities; and 5) community enrichment.
The City Manager said the City does not have the capability to expand the park at
St. Brendan's Church. Mr. Baier said the City has received several reques'ts f9r a
playground on Island Estates. The subject property is at the West end of the Windward
Passage. Currently, the subject property is used as a storage area for the ongoing
reclaimed water project. The proposed development is similar to the City Park on Sand
Key. This property is one of the few vacant lots remaining on Island Estates. The Parks &
Recreation Department has estimated installation of a park would cost $54,000, not
including parking or stormwater facilities. In response to a question, Mr. Baier said less
than 1 FTE (full~time equivalent) would be required to maintain the park. Funds are
available for 0.5 FTE. Mr. Baier indicated the City would have to pay the fair market value
reimbursement to the Water and Sewer fund which owns the property. The most recent
appraisal valued the property at $230,000. Another appraisal is necessary. In response to
a question, the City Attorney said the reimbursement must be based on the current fair
market value of the property. Mr. Baier said the City could purchase the property over a
number of years for cash or in exchange in.kind services. If the City Commission is
interested in this concept, the Engineering Department will add it to their list of projects.
In response to a question, Mr. Baier said the park would be similar in size to the one
on Enterprise, West of Landmark Drive. It was felt the location of the proposed park ;s not
good. Mr. Baier said many children live on Island Estates and town homes are located near
the site. It was felt the aesthetics of the park would be a positive improvement. Mr. Baier
said other vacant lots on Island Estates are quite expensive. The subject lot has a
mwsO 198
9
01/12/98
~
'''')
'~~"(.'"
J
,:'..I'd' -I; h-~' ~.
Southwest exposure and is close to the Marine Science Center. It was suggested children
on school field trips to the center could enjoy their lunches in the park.
Mr. Baier reported the City does not own the water lot South of the subject
property and may not be able to construct a dock there. In response to a question, he said
some impact fees, available from Sand Key, may not be needed for Sand Key. He
reviewed how past fees were spent. Concern was expressed the majority of funding for
the Eddie C. Moore recreation complex had come from Sand Key impact fees. Mr. Baier
said 576 homes and approximately 1,200 condominiums are located on Island Estates. In
response to a question, he said the estimated cost includes new playground equipment. It
was felt a park in this location would provide open space, aesthetics, and a picnic area for
the Marine Center.
Concern was expressed regarding the $O.25-million cost to develop City-owned
property into a park. Support for the park was expressed. In response to a question, the
City Attorney said according to bond covenants the City could lease the subject property
for fair market value. Mr. Baier said bond covenants allow storage. He said different
types of compensation are possible if a park is constructed there. In response to a
question, he reported an 8 - 10 unit facility is planned on Island Estates. New construction
. normally pays a fee rather than setting aside land for park space. The City can require
land be set aside.
Consensus was for staff to bring this issue back.
Receiot/Referral - LDCA re Tree Protection Ordinance reauiring triole Dermit fees for
violations
l~ an effort to reduce the number of trees removed without required permits, staff
proposes to charge a triple fee for all "after the fact" permits. This change would conform
with the Land Development Code fee structure for building permits. Approval of the code
amendment will assist Public Works Administration staff in enforcing the Tree Ordinance
provisions, thereby enhancing the City's overall aesthetic qualities and protecting the
citizens by regulating the tree service industry more effectively.
In response to a question, Mr. Baier said"staff is reviewing the Land Development
Code regarding the possibility of increasing fees for tree removal. The City Manager
indicated the City currontly does not have the ability to help residents who wish to replace
the canopy. Most property owners who remove trees are not aware a permit is necessary.
The City does not want to punish residents regarding this issue. Mr. Baier noted several
repeat offenders violate the subject code. In response to a question, he said staff is
addressing this issue before revisions to the Land Development Code are completed.
Currently, contractors top trees without penalty.
Authorize use of $40.000 from City Tree Reolacement fund for a Contract Registered
Landscape Architect position
mwsO 198
10
01112/98
J.' '.'
~
o
~
" ,
In an effort to reflect the City's vision for overall beautification and Improve
landscaping along major street thoroughfares, parking lots, etc., it is necessary to employ
the services of a Registered Landscape Architect. The Registered Landscape Architect will
assist the Central Permitting, Public Works Administration, and Parks & Recreation
departments in creating a master landscape plan that will coordinate landscaping
throughout the City. .
The City Manager indicated this item will provide the City the ability to help
residents who wish to replace the canopy. The proposed position will be filled by a
contract employee.
CP CENTRAL PERMITTING
Public Hearina & First Readina Ords. #6226-98 & #6227-98 - Annexation & RS-6 Zoning
for orooerty located at 181 Pinewood Ave., Eastwood Terrace 1st Add., Blk 0, Lot 2
(Alfonso Tundidor, A98-01) .
The applicant has requested annexation and zoning of Single-Family Residential
"Six" for 181 Pinewood Avenue to obtain sewer service. The Planning & Zoning Board
unanimously endorsed the request.
A request was made for a list of enclaves where sewer pipes are located.
Eublic HearinQ & First Readina Ord. #6228-98 - RM-8 Zonina for orooertv located at 524
Bamboo Lane, Bamboo Sub., Lots 4, 11 & 12 (Carlisle Motors, Inc., Z98-01 ~
.Carlisle Motors, Inc. has requested to rezone vacant lots it owns at 524 Bamboo
Lane, and approximately 310 feet South of Gulf-to.Bay Boulevard. The proposed rezoning
involves Lots 4, 11, and 12, in Bamboo Subdivision. The applicant wishes to rezone these
properties to allow access into the commercial property from a residential street. No land
use plan amendment will be involved in this rezoning. The proposed Zoning Atlas
Amendment is requested so Lot 4 can be used as a driveway from Bamboo Lane. Lots 11
& 1 2 are being incorporated to ensure all residentially zoned lots in this portion of the
dealership have RM-8 zoning which is consistent with abutting properties to the East.
The combined lots are 33,977 square-feet (0.78 acres). The proposed devE:tlopment
;s subject to Planning & Zoning Board approval of a conditional use request for nonw
commercial parking. This request would be consistent with surrounding land use patterns
and in character with the neighborhood, considering the residential proporties to the South
and East of the subject properties.
In response to a question, Central Permitting Manager Sandy Glatthorn said the
request would permit direct access from the subject property to Bamboo Lane. The City
had received objections to this request. In response to a question, the City Attorney said
the issue relates to the approprioteness of the requested zoning. It was questioned why
the site plan had been included with the item. In response to a question, Ms. Glatthorn
said the conditionsl use for non.commercial parking had been approved. It was noted
mws0198
11
01/12/98
~
nearby residents are upset Carlisle Motors, Inc. had purchased 3 houses which they plan to
raze for the construction of a parking lot. It was recommended the entire Carlisle property
be considered so the proposed redesign is not offensive. Ms. Glatthorn indicated rezoning
of the property last occurred in 1988 and 1989.
eM ADMINISTRATION
Authorize D8rtnershlo with North Ward Elementary School: authorize creoaration of
Interlocal sareemen! with Pinellas County Schools
Pinellas County schools has designated North Ward Elementary School as eligible
for a Partnership School. The City will enter into a' relationship with the school and provide
needed items and in-kind services. In turn, employees' outside the district can place
children in the school. An employee survey indicated more than 35 parents were
interested in pursuing this option.
Suggested commitments from the City include: 1) in-kind printing; 2) tree trimming
help; 3) installation of a lamppost; 4) volunteers; 5) landscaping and maintenance help; 6)
partnership with the Police/Fire substation; 7) staff environmentalist work with classes; 8)
Harborview Center chef help with special occasions; 9) computer and television staff help;
and 10) like-kind supplies. Many Clearwater residents have attended North Ward, which
was established in 1915. The school has a strong alumni group. The City would have an
open house in February and registration in March for new students.
J""''''
\=)
In response to 8 question, Ms. Rice said staff will review the cost of this agreement
each year and will come back to the Commission with an agreement. She indicated the
City will not know how many employees will participate until March 1998. In response to
a question, she said the school is excited about this partnership and can handle an
increased student population.
Soecial Events Grant Fundina - Pilot Proaram Recommendations
In keeping with the City's vision to enhance Clearwater's "environment with festive
activities," the Special Events Granting Program is designed to encourage new and
expanded events and to provide a systematic approach of granting City co-sponsorships
for special events on an annual basis. The goal is to provide matching grants funding for
Clearwater non-profit organizations so they may facilitate new or expanded events which
will benefit the organization and citizens of Clearwater.
The pilot program provides $50,000 for eligible applicants. Grants will be awarded
in variable increments with a maximum of $10,000 per event. Funds will be awarded on a
matching basis of 2 to 1. Matching funds may be in the form of in-kind services or cash.
If City services such as Police, Fire, Parks & Recreation services, etc. are requested, such
services must be estimated and included in the grant funding request. City co-
sponsorships on in-kind services will not be provided in addition to grants.
J
mws0198
12
01/12/98
C I . ~
.~
()
.........
\....)
'.
Special events held on public property or events that affect public property require
approval of the City's Special Events Committee. Events are subject to the established
regulations governing public health and safety. Based on the type of event, various
permits may be required and the cost of those can be included in the request for grant
funds.
Call for applications in March 1998, will be by notification through daily newspaper
notices and/or by letters to non-profit organizations within the City. The application
deadline is April 15, 1998, with recommendations presented to the City Commission
during the first Commission meeting in June 1998. Funds will be disbursed from June 15,
1998 through September 30, 1999. Documentation and a final report will be required 45
days after the completion of the event.
Criteria include: 1) applicant(s) to provide verification of being a not-for-profit
organization or a notwfor-project Florida corporation, in good standing, pursuant to Chapter
617 of the Florida Statues; 2) applicant(s) organization must have programs operating" in
the City; 3) matching funds may be anticipated at the time of application, but must be
received by the applicant and obligated by the ending date of the grant; 4) applicant(s)
organi,zation must have been incorporated or operational for a least 1-year at the time of
application; 5 applicant(s) must furnish a financial statement of condition for the
organization's previous year; 6) applicant(s) must provide e complete application package
by specified deadline; 7) applicant(s) must agree to comply with all legal, financial, and
operational requirements of the City's Special Events permitting process; 8) event must be
open and accessible to the public; 9) only one application will be considered for each
event; 10) only applications from organizations in good standing with the City will be
considered; 11) applicant(s) must agree to provide a full accounting and documentation of
aU expenditures allowed by the grant; 12) applicant(s) must use the grant funds solely for
the purposes of the grant; 1 3) applicant(s) must agree to provide appropriate promotional
credit to the City; and 14) applicant(s) must agree to use the funds within the grant period
specified on the grant application.
In response to a question, Ms. Rice said a religious organization could compete for
these funds to put on an event. It was agreed religious organizations be removed from
those qualified for these funds. It was felt the City wou(d be better off paying $50,000
for a Special Events Position. It was noted this pilot program is designed to provide value
for the money the City is donating. It was stated many local non-profit organizations need
sponsorships for events. In response to a question, Ms. Rice said the makeup of the
committee has not been determined. It was noted only 5 organizations can be sponsored
under proposed the level of funding. In response to a question, Ms. Rice said in-kind
services would be counted as part of the grant.
CLK CITY CLERK
leaislative Package
According to the City's 1998 Legislative Package, priority issues include seeking
funding through varjous avenues for: 1) beach redevelopment and beautification; 2)
mws0198
13
01/12/98
!J" '
,~
.:)
u
economic development including job creation and clean-up of Brownfields area; 3) tourism
development; 4) Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard (SR 60) enhancements including traffic flow and
aesthetic Improvements; and 5) transition from welfare to work.
The City will support legislation that will: 1) allow municipalities to annex Type A
enclaves of 3 acres or less; 2) remove the works "slum and blight- from the Community
Redevelopment Act; 3) enhance the effectiveness of the 1997 Brownfields Redevetopment
Act by addressing the glitches in the 1997 legislation; providing a permanent funding
source for the "Brownfields Redevelopment bonus refund"; allowing a Brownfields Area to
be considered fo; Enterprise Zone designation and designating USF (University of South
Florida) as the State Brownfields Research Center.
The City Manager said staff will work with the lobbyist to identify the specific
funding needs. In response to a question, he reviewed the need to continue recycling
grants. COl:1sensus was to removed page 10, Exclusion of Cable Television Public Service
Tax, and page 11, Limitations of Telecommunication Franchise Fees and Utility Taxes.
Clarification was requested regarding removing the final cost increase from utility taxes.
Staff will'report back on this issue.
Aooointment of Charter Review Committee
In response to a question, the City Attorney stated most issues recommended for
review are housekeeping and property issues. Committee members must be appointed this
month. A Work Session to provide direction can be schedured at a Jater date.
Consensus was for each Commissioner to appoint 2 members to the Charter
Review Committee on Thursday.
In response to term limits, it was noted Commissioner Clark will not qualify to serve
a total of 6 years. Concern was expressed the Charter guard against abuses whereby one
could resign for 2 months and then run for office again.
CA LEGAL DEPARTMENT
OTHER CITY ATTORNEY ITEMS
ADDroval of settlement stiDulation in Patrick Media (Eller Media) vs. City
Regarding Eller Media, the City Attorney said the proposed settlement is based on
Commission discussions at closed sessions. In response to a question, she said the
ordinance will be considered after approval of the settlement. In response to a question,
she said staff had provided William Jonson with a copy of this settlement.
Discussion of eRA/DDS boundarie~
Concern had been expressed regarding a comparison of the boundaries of the CRA
(Community Redevelopment Agency) and DDS (Downtown Development Board). The City
mws0198
14
01/12/98
, ..
:.~.>< " "'o'.
,'')
....)
'..~
...~
I.
Attorney reported membership in the DOB is based on property ownership. She reported
one downtown parcel is within the CRA's boundaries but not the DDB's. She suggested
consideration of amending the boundaries of the DOB to match those of the CRA.
Camo Soule ProDertv
The City Attorney reported a grant application has been filed with the FCT (Florida
Communities Trust). Negotiations to purchase the property had been unsuccessful. -rhe
Commission had been asked if they were interested in acquiring a conservation easement
for the Camp Soule Property. She said the FCT had expressed reluctance to pay toward a
conservation easement for 8 property with strict limits on public access. With its
investment In 8 conservation easement, the FCT wants some pUblic use of the property.
The City Attorney said the Boy Scouts had indicated they want very limited public access.
She said the FCT wants to know if the City Commission is willing to commit City funds to
a conservation 9asement when public access is not guaranteed. In response to a question,
she said the advantage of a ConsGrvation Easement is that the property would forever
remain a campground. The property could be sold but that use would be guaranteed. In
response to a question, she said the cost of 8 conservation easement cannot be
determined until the property is appraised. The FCT will not move forward with an
appraisal until the City indicates a continued interest in the easement. The City's
commitment would require a matching grant for the cost of the easement. In response to
a Question, the City Attorney could not identify the cost of such an Rasement. She noted
the Boy Scouts did not initiate these negotiations. Efforts to purchase the property were
based on a' citizen initiative. She said a Commission decision must be reached by April.
City Manager Verbal Reports
The City Manager reported the agenda of the January 20, 1998, meeting will be
changed to discuss Penny for Pinellas projects. The meeting's location will be announced.
The City Manager said the official roll.out of "One City. One Future." is scheduled
for January 23, 1998.
Other Commiss,on Action
Commissioner Johnsol1 congratulated Mayor Garvey for being chosen to be on the
reviewing stand at the Opening Ceremony of the 1998 Winter Olympics in Nagano, Japan.
Commissioner Johnson Questioned if the City responds to letters from citizens. The
Mayor indicated she handles such correspondence. I
Commissioner Johnson Questioned when the County Economic Development
Council will be established. The City Manager said the County is working on establishing
the new board.
Commissioner Seel announced Barbara and Otis Green have been named this year's
Mr. and Mrs. Clearwater.
mws0198
15
01/12/98
" ''1; 'c.f
,.'
~ ''; .
'.,
. ..~
~~; ~
( .,c'
.;., "
"~I : ~ C'::; :'
,i
: ',' ~
. . <c~ .,' ,. .
:) ::.
': '~'. c",. .'. ' I <-
',"c '!o': \")~>:...:~,
,'" '1'..,
, 1.:'<1,
;'Yil"~:
;:;{:'..~:"i)'
~",::. '
,.:):i
~:' ;".' >
~I~"i:,:'., ': '
'1 c ::' l
~~<'. ')'
l"
~ .
<:,<
~\.,;+:
.t'L~ ,,- .' 1 ..'
~ :'r :
r(~'>. ',:,..
{:"'",,"
I~.' ,
lV/'.
~~~1J ~.~ ,.
~;: <: I '
~i": ,
;:-' /"
..../:
: ~
t,:" .
....0
.' ".
.c' +, >
, . ~ ;
'c' ~'
;
i'
':'f.':, ,
;~
~,
< '."
"
.":',
V'
:;,"
. . i'
?:>'.~'
;\ ~ :' '
...,. ~.
"J
I ~ '
, "
,',
.,....
, t,
3:
",
'(::'
','" .'j ,+
, . 1 ~ :" ., " ~ ": 'c: ~" ~
~ ..,
, c/', ,'cO
<' ,
'.
"J', ".
."
,; _" \ , J ~
.,
"" ,....:... '
( .
';.
,c,~
....; "I
" ,
. .
.,
,'I'
/', .
~ ,.
Commissioner HooDe,' sold today's newspaper had indicat"ed approximately 300-
milUongollons of under-treated sewage had been discharged into local waterways after
r~ce~t heavy rains. He noted none of the spill come from .the City of Clearwater.
Adjourn
The meeting adjourned at 4:56. p.m.
';
'j "
.','J,
.,
;!
'I
'~~"':"'::"';;'~J;;'>"" r; ,f,'>i' '.; """'i:,;(:'L,/: ,'" .:,'. ';
..~........'pl.' ~..~ ~\ ,,~r'JJ~~"'~~..~'~.t~;r...'.J:-=-~l"li,... '~."t~~+.' ," ~ ~ .', '
~~itt~lr~"~i~J,:Ii>'t~'ri~~)"~..i"t'!';'~f: ~l.tt'.l'" {\';i' /.:.-\\..':' 1'- ~..' , .r':'
~1.f1't~'41r,,": j",1 -1,1 I}.. ";;1 '1.....-; ...,1, .0'\_ :-~~/l r\1 ''':'1.:1 ' 1+,
~~;!:::fw;;;;~:(,1!\!!;;;~:::~0:~~";~; ',;: ::,:~\::,;' · ,'....,.
~H _...~~ ''I ~
:fd:':--!~,<.,-;'.'. -'
~\.li" .c~ I 1:.' '-. ":' /'
~,f';\"\'::' '~.','.: I ' .:
;', ~ .. L.. I " c'
w-: ,. .' ,
~ " ,
..1
I ~ , '
" ~,
1.{
,t
,
,.
...
"
'f
,.
mwsO 198
16
'01/12/98