09/28/1998 (2)1
??
I 339
CHARTER REVIEW COMMITTEE MEETING
CITY OF CLEARWATER
September 28, 1998
Present: Timothy A. Johnson, Jr. Chair
Douglas Hilkert Vice Chair (arrived 4:35 p.m.)
Richard Fitzgerald Committee Member
Pat Greer Committee Member (arrived 4:08 p.m.)
Judy Mitchell Committee Member
Mayme Hodges Committee Member (arrived 4:08 p.m.)
Carolyn Warren Committee Member
Jackie Tobin Committee Member
William Justice Committee Member
Absent: Grant Petersen Committee Member
Also Present: Rita Garvey Mayor
Pam Akin City Attorney
Cyndie Goudeau City Clerk
Brenda Moses Board Reporter
The Chair called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. at City Hall.
To provide continuity for research, items are in agenda order although not
-? necessarily discussed in that order.
Item 2 - Approve Minutes from Meeting of September 14. 1998
Member Warren moved to approve the minutes of the meeting of September
14, 1998, as submitted in writing to each member. The motion was duly
seconded and carried unanimously.
Item _3 - Follow-u FrorC Previous Meeting
Open items from previous meetings were reviewed.
Article 11 Legislative
It was determined the City Attorney does not need to research what the
term "legislative" means in the title.
Section 4.03
It was remarked grammatical changes involving the consistency of gender
references throughout the Charter can be addressed when other grammatical
changes are finalized.
H rlil
mch09b98 1 09128/98
Section 10.05 (b)
In response to a question, the City Attorney said the special election for
Charter amendment may be held in conjunction with regular elections.
Article 10. Section 10.1
Consensus was this section is no longer necessary.
Member Greer moved to recommend deleting the entire section. The motion
was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
Section 2.03 - paragraph 4
The Committee had asked the City Attorney change this section to suggest
language that would prohibit the Commission from taking any action between the
election and the time the new Commission takes office. She suggested language.
regarding the newly elected Commissioners taking office at the next Commission
meeting following certification of election results. A 24-hour period would exist in
which the Commission could have a special meeting. It is important not to create a
situation where the Commission cannot sit or take action when needed.
Member Warren moved to recommend changing Section 2.03, paragraph 4
to read "Newly elected commissioners shall take office at the next commission
`?- meeting following certification of city election returns." The motion was duly
seconded and carried unanimously.
Section 7.02
The committee had requested the City Attorney propose, language that
would address the composition of the Charter Review Committee and have its
recommendations go directly to the voters. The City Attorney suggested language
modeled after the County Commission's charter. Discussion ensued regarding the
proposal.
Consensus was for the City Attorney to rewrite this section incorporating:
1) the Charter Review Committee be not less than ten members, not more than
two of whom may be City Commissioners; 2) the Committee submit a report to the
City Commission on or before December 1 of the year; 3) the report shall include
proposed amendments with the wording of the ballot question or questions; and 4)
a referendum election will be held with the next City election to vote on the
proposal or proposals submitted by the Charter Review Committee without change
to those questions.
Section 2.03
Discussion ensued regarding changing terms of office for City
Commissioners from three to four years. The City Clerk said if four-year term limits
mch09b98 2 09/28/98
d
were approved on the next ballot, it would go into effect beginning with the March
J 2001 election. Consensus was not to change term limits.
Item 4 - Conti nu i nDiscussion of Charter Revisions
Article 2- Section 2,01 (d)-f-4) 1
In response to a question, the City Clerk said if a lease is less than five
years the property does not have to be declared surplus. The City Attorney said
the recommendation to delete the language "... or to the lease for a term longer
than.five years..." would not preclude the City from leasing an item longer than five
years.
The Chair distributed copies of grammatical changes to the Charter. It was
suggested separate questions be placed on the ballot regarding substantive and
non-substantive changes. All changes must be voted upon.
It was noted the current charter, Section 4.01, is recommended to become
Section 3.04.
Section 3.04 (a)
It was recommended changing this section read "... and keep minutes of
proceedings."
Article IV
It was noted "City Clerk" should be deleted from the heading and the
remaining sections of Article IV be renumbered.
Section 4.03 is)
It was noted the "t" in "the Florida Bar" in the last sentence should be
capitalized.
Section 4.05
It was requested "the" be deleted before "compensation" and "City
Attorney,"
Section 2.01(c)
It was suggested the current Section 5,01 be placed under the duties of the
Commission in Section 2.01: "As part of the discharge of its duty the city
commissions shall: regulate comprehensive planning, zoning, and land
development as provided by law,"
Section 2.01Sd_?
=i
mch09b98
3
09128/98
in
?o
Discussion ensued regarding the City's ability to rent materials and services.
Member Hilkert moved to recommend subparagraph (d) (2) read "The city
commission shall by ordinance adopt procedures for the purchase or rental of
goods and services." The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
Section 2.03
It was suggested paragraph 4 read "No person who has, or but for
resignation or, forfeiture of office would have, served as a commissioner for two
consecutive full terms, shall serve • as a commissioner other than mayor-
commissioner for the succeeding three-year term. No person who has, or but for
resignation or forfeiture of office would have, served as mayor-commissioner for
two consecutive'full terms, shall serve as mayor-commissioner or commissioner for
the succeeding three-year term."
Section 3.03
It was suggested subparagraph (f) requires a financial and administrative
report. '
Section 10.05
Sentence 2. subparagraph (a)
Discussion ensued regarding whether changes suggested in Section 2.03
would impact the effective dates of term limits in this section. The City Attorney
will review this section for appropriate language.
Consensus was for the City Attorney to integrate the subsequent changes
into nonsubstantive changes.
It was requested the next meeting scheduled for October 5, 1998, at 4:00
p.m. will be noticed for public input. The Chair requested members review the
suggested grammatical changes before the next meeting.
Item 5 - Adjourn
The meeting adjourned at 5:12 p.m.
n
Ch
Review Committee
1
1
I
i?
Attest:
Board Reporter
mch09b98
4
09/28/98
E.. 1
I