07/14/1998 - Special (2)
.: :
NAHAS
" '
,;
," .
t,;,i.', ,(UP,\" :.>
,'I ,
(
... 'r .. .., .. . ~ .'
, /
.' . '.' I c 1. ~ "..
. , " ',' < : ,~
I J
"
." .
,.
J.',
~: .1., , .
",
~" ' -. .
. ' ,
,~ :
,
~~.( < '.. c
.~, .. , ~
.',
,~" .
. '~CI ','
;s,: ,;".::,' ·
','T..;,.T" l ,"
.~: : ~ .
>~i , . C
j- :'r ' .'1' ,<..
11.;,);',,:' ·
JI;";'\ .
;.~: ~.! ,: ,.' : "',.
", ,":~" Neighborhood & Affordable Housi'ng
Advi~ory Board .
MINUTES
, "
I
I
f
r
,~! >:~ . ,',
~;:; : .. ,. n.' ~ C
t :.'. ~. <'.' . '
~,' . c,' 'p' ,,:: .
'. ! l
'" ,
. ,
. 'T' .,',"
,. .
t ..' ~ ~ "
, ;"\ ~'
t I ".
T., f
., .e
,
j
i
I
I
:~".'~ ..,
. . ~ ' \ :. ' >
Colj.
~.. .'
: ,..
",I
"
';.'i'" '.
~ 2 j '.
. '. ,. \
, '
, b~te:;'.:ru1j
1'4,j'l't!
, ,
, . ~
'.
. .
I"';'
'.) :.
. ,.
,: '
, ,
" 1
.'., "
..,
','
" "
.
, .,
,'. . .
, 'c/
I ,
, "
. \, ~
, .,' '
.:' ,. 1-
, ~ ~ ,
,. ,",
" ,
, "
i'
. '. . ~ n
, \
"
cl,'.:.P:>
.< '.
,\ .l.
." ! ."
, "
'..
, > ~ .
:.
'W{)'
: , .
; ,
l .
,\
.
n
",-.
,.,'''L',
,0
" ~,
~. j. >
NEIGHBORHOOD & AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY BOARD SPECrAl MEETING
CITY OF CLEARWATER
July 14, 1 998
Present:
Mary Myhill
Howard Groth
Rev, William Graham
Milly Joplin
Mayme W, Hodges
William Turner, Sr.
Warren Hunt
Joyce L. Smith
Peggy M. Cutkomp
Alan J, Ferri
Michael Holmes
Patricia o. Sullivan
Chair
Vice~Chair
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member - arrived 10:04 a.m.
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Housing & Urban Development Director
Housing & Urban Development Assistant Director
Board Reporter
The Chair called the meeting to order at 10:00 A.M. at City Hall.
, ,
ITEM # 1 - Proposed Section 108 Proiects
Housing & Urban Development Director Alan Ferri reviewed rules pertaining to
Section 108, A city, that identifies needs which cannot be met by annual CDBG
(Community Development Block Grant) funds, can compete to borrow against future
grants. Interest rates for 20-year construction loans are tied to the treasury rate plus a
markup,
According to Coordinated Child Care, the North Greenwood, South Greenwood, and
Wood Valley communities have a shortage of more than 500 day~care slots, Due to
welfare program changes, it is anticipated the shortage will Increase to 800 slots on
October 1, 1998, Non~profit agencies can obtain capital to cover operational costs but
have insufficient funds and borrowing capability to acquire new facilities, In North and
South Greenwood, approximately 1,200 families receive AFDC lAid to Families with
Dependent Children) benefits, Mr. Ferri recommended the government find resources to
provide for these children.
Brownfields 'Economic Development Initiative (BEDI) will provide a 50% match for
money borrowed under Section 108. In response to a question, Mr, Ferri said due to State
mandated representation regulations, adding NAHAS members to the Brownfields board
would have expanded that board's size to more than 20. In addition to appointing industry
representatives to NAHAB as required by the State, the Commission also appointed
geographic representatives.
Mr, Ferri exprossed concern entitlement funding is to be reduced substantially.
Under Section 108, the City can address important issues before funds are depleted. It
was noted the problem cannot be solved prior to the October welfare deadline. Mr. Ferri
said the City is not mandated to solve the problem. While several employers provide child
mna07a98
07/14/98 '
',. ..
t")
:,
'~)
"..-r"
'I
--J
day~care, most do not. Welfare-to-work parents most often are employed in minimum
wage jobs with few or no benefits, The Federal government is aware of this problem.
In response to a question, Mr. Ferri said JWB (Juvenile Welfare Board) statistics
indicate the greatest shortage of slots in Clearwater is in the North and South Greenwood,
and Wood Valley neighborhoods, On-site child day-care facilities at the new Wellington
Apartments will serve complex residents only. Meeting local day-care needs will require
the collaboration of staff, the industry, and non-profit agencies. As banks are responsible
for community development lending and investment, it was suggested a partnership be
developed with a bank. Mr. Ferri agreed developing a partnership with the private sector is
important. The City has generated a public sector match for entitlement funding at a ratio
of 1 :8. He said community needs for home ownership, rehabilitation, etc., will not decline.
In response to a concern, Mr. Ferri indicated Federal funds defray child-care costs
for some low-income families. In response to a suggestion, Mr. Ferri said churches had
been contacted to fill this need. County child day-care regulations are more stringent than
the State's,
Martha Skelton,' Executive Director of the Community Pride Child Care Center, said
her organization has served North Greenwood for 40 years and South Greenwood since
1985. Most children are members of low-income, families headed by single mothers. A
child-care facility is required to meet minimum size, parking, and playground requirements.
The agency is considering several bUildings in Clearwater for renovation. This week, the
agency will decide which property to pursue, She estimated a day-care facility that meet
the needs of 87 infants and toddlers will cost $1-million, including land. The need for staff
will provide local economic development opportunities. She said her organization cannot
afford a bank's required 20% down payment to qualify for a mortgage. Each classroom
needs approximately $ 7,000 worth of equipment, Playground equipment costs are
additional, Regulations provine for child safety and quality care,
In response to a question, Mr. Ferri said CNHS property must be used for housing,
It was recommended the School Board address the educational needs of young children and
that lottery money be used for early childhood intervention. It was,suggested right-to-life
groups be approached to help with this issue. In response to a question, Ms, Skelton said
the grant would cover construction and land purchase costs. Other grants for equipment
shall be pursued. The agency's budget can afford operational expenses plus a small
mortgage payment. If half of the costs are covered by a Brownfields grant, mortgage
payments would be affordable: In response to a question, she said Coordinated Child Care
funds children to attend private centers, however, many private centers will not accept
their funds. The government reimbyrses her organizatirn at a rate of $4 - $60 weekly
depending on the child's age and family income. The United Way helps funds some slots.
In response to a suggestion, Ms. Skelton indicated SPJC (St. Petersburg Junior College)
works with a nearby church to provide child-care for students and educators.
John Lowry, Head Start Executive Director, said his organization serves 1,326
children at 1 5 centers in Pinellas County. Head Start is proposing to construct a facility to
serve 160 children. Federal funding for child care is restricted to 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m,
mna07a98
07/14/98
~~.:~~:i +,'.1" ...'. ,. -il;.,' c.
. .: ' ' " ',:, ... ,~ . ',' '.- ~ : .':.. ' , ....':' I ':' " :, ',' .,... . . ..
Mr. Lowry said Head Start would use the loan to construct a facility that serves 1 60
children, The agency is challenged to build a facility large enough to meet minimum space
requirements, Each classroom must have bathroom facilities, a washing sink, and nearby
drinking fountain. Head Start is considering to lease City-owned land near Ross Norton
Park for their site. Mr. Ferri noted in the Consolidated Plan, Head Start had been awarded
$134,000 in CDBG funds to begin October 1, 1998, When school is out of session, plans
are to raze and replace the current facility with modular buildings. In response to a
question, Mr, Lowry said Head Start does not anticipate any shortfall in construction funds,
',~}
Head Start has extended care hours slightly thanks to fundraising efforts, A pilot program
will oxtend care to 12 hours. Head Start collaborates with Coordinated Child Care to
review family eligiblllty. Mr. Lowry said Head Start could not purchase facilities until 1994.
Currently, the agency serves children, age 3 through mandatory school age.
Younger children require a higher ratio of caregivers. Head Start requires 2 staff members
to attend each classroom. Head Start uses church and community facllities as much as
possible.
He hoped by 2002, all County Head Start facilities will provide 12-hour-a-day child
care. The project will serve Clearwater as Head Start places children in facilities as close
to their homes as possible,
:~)
Mr, Ferri said the Section 108 program will be presented to the City Commission, In
response to a suggestion, he indicated Coordinated Child Care acts as the County's child-
care "czar." This county-wide awareness group coordinates child-care services. Providers
of early childhood education meet monthly along with representatives of some
municipalities. It was recommended the press be made aware of this shortage. The
difficulty and expense of caring for children younger than 3 was noted. It was
,recommended JWB establish a database to help meet the unmet needs of this large group
of children. A county-wide referral telephone number for child-care related questions is
available.
Lois Cormier said this meeting had been advertised in the St. Petersburg Times. She
supported the child-care providers' plans, She said it is important for parents receiving
welfare to receive training, noting their critical need for transportation. She said property
purchased for housing should not be used for public facilities. She expressed
environmental concerns'regarding the proposed site near Ross Norton Park. As funding for
nearby apartments has been approved, she felt the day-care center, apartments, a planned
family center, and police substation will be too much for a small area. She said the
Woodlawn Church of God had received a conditional use to operate a day-care center for
up to 60 children, She felt the property is not large enough to care for that many children
and traffic problems will result. She said an agenda for today's meeting should have been
published and information regarding the public hearing posted.
In response to a question, Housing & Urban Development Assistant Director Mike
Holmes said the City can borrow up to $5-million from this fund. Staff has recommended
J
mna07a98
07/14/98
'The meeting adjourned at 11: 19 a,m.
~~~~
Chair, '
Neighborhood & Affordable Housing
Advisory Board
! "
? ,.;':'
, ,
. 'c" '+ ~ ~
d'
, ,
'.- ,
"
"
, ,
. '
, ..
,'.,'
,"
"
,c." ..
". ....~>::: ::.'>"
,. '\ :'l".
';'::;:~ '~>'
. .
1; "':" ; '~<',,',...,;~,: ""')':;~:..;t.tj,~~~:<~;~~::;> ;i,){, ~:,;>,: ' ':' , .'::~~,,\
~~(.i~\.:./~> I" ~ \ )",i' ~! ~~"~r'J,: i..r'~l.-r~.~ ,t/<~~~ . ~H ..\.t . " .."" ~ J,., ~ " , ,~"
)J~'hoJf,:--"~,,,'~(""ltl~,~ ;'~\"'i.}.';:I ~..],..... '\.j, ,~J-, ~.., ,,' <.~. .",' < ." ,1 . _>" L
'fl(lf.1..dO,... LI_-&,' ~/""J:..ll,(, , '"......~ .} .,-t", ",~. .~ 'I'.. '. L
\i~~t:i/(~r'\?!,','~~i",'" '.;'. "
~:,;.::.;,:u
{j~~1 .~. .:. ': .1". I \ I
~~v'~'.~ ..(. .
%:;'. ~1~~ ;:;;>;: ,
f#t:. .,! \ ,:1 ;
Ir.:,>" ,
11":,'(7)' '",
...~ h
1;'1 ''II>.r,.-t,.
i> :' ,
r.,. " ....
~~! +.' .;, . "
~~'( ~":
r',""
,"',-
'. '.y
. . . '.!. ' ': : ~ . I ..'. .' " . '. ., I 'j ,
..', borro~ing between $1.3- and $1.6-mllllon.
this Issue,' , ' .
,The City 'Commission will 'hold a hearing on
,ITEM #2' -,Adlournment
f\/'
P' '
1r:.~::~' ,','
~;\i' 'I ',: "
~~.'- .' . L. , ,
l'.\; <.' "'.' .'
~;y~:,' , ':',
~i;:<::.
12'~' \; .1 .'
~;~~:',,~'i k , , ''-
1~'-' ,', '" ,
1~~;.'''~, ','; ,~1.: d '
t;t,,>,':.,\.::':'C"
tf' L :'.'
~'" ,I. ~+
{~',: "
(..I,' .
>.";' _ .. I t ~.
~'(:b'
.:.':l.!' ,
':/. ~'~
.... .~' ". .
!'
, Attest:
:,
','Boar
C, "
,\
, \
',\
"
,'C'
! '
"
"f
T~/ .
, .
",
, '.'.
I '.
1.1.
, ,
"
'};
,',
.>1
"
I' '"
'.,
'.I
,
'.'
"!
.' ,,'
,i
. :,'
'I'
','
,',
..',.\ '
"~'i
I'" 'V'
><'i;;',~ ~
1"
mria07a98
07/14/98
.",
i'
f.ii,'/: :,:;',~. ,:,:: :,'
iti;i~',I;:\:" II,'
.'
"