02/20/1998 (2)
" ,
I,' .
., ;
; . I
,
t~~...:.:: : d :,: ' . I. ",.... .
. ~. , <
I'T . d
,
'i. >
\.'
'.',
I.'.
1....
"
..". ,..,.,' .,1
,'" .' .
, ,
, ,
. . I .
:., .,.:" ", c,
o . . . > "~ .
"
':-+. ..". . '.'
....".: "'. ,," < .' "
'.,
f.........., LIBRARY
1,:' ... ..'. .." ........ .' . S' OAR" D, ",
;'",: 'I I,
I,T I' . .," i.
't,' .
.' \ '
, ' , MINUTES
: ) , ' ,
" " .'
I'
" I
I
j
, r
I
. ,
. ., ,
, I' , ',',
, ..' . .
.
, I
I
1
"
, ,
\.
, 'Date
. 20
,
!
I
, I
, I
, !
'.
. .
. ~
, .
. . "."
'!
/7cf
,
~(~~~I,l.":'""'"''''"'''''''~'''.) :". ~ ". '"..:?. J", '." .;.,,:\'~ ".' H~ . to"," >~"(' >.;<....:>~>:.:I: :.,.l. .'~,' I'~';' '. ,'" . ;. ,.~~", ~ ">"j"~~,~;';'.JII,,,,'~."J"""'."""'U
~ ' . . ' '.': > , . .' ..'. '.' ':. .. , . . ! '. . . ' '. " . "
, '
~~: .;.:
~:~.. '
','
..
'e~
~)
,"
o. C.'
LIBRARY BOARD MEETING
CITY OF CLEARWATER
February 20, 1998
Present:
Christine Morris
Joanne Laurenti
Estelle Dunn
William Raffaniello
Tom Leavy
Judy Melges
Howard Adler
Glenn Garte
Dr. Arlita Hallam
Gwen Legters
Marshall Bennett
Chair
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
Member
, Library Director
Board Reporter
Member
Absent:
The Chair called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. at the North Greenwood Branch
Library. For continuity, the items are listed in agenda order, although not necessarily
discussed in that order.
I. Welcome
Dr. Hallam and the board, said farewell to Joanne Laurenti, who is completing her
second consecutive term on the board. Ms. Laurenti was thanked for her years of service
and praised for her level head, leadership, cheerfulness, and ability to "cut to the chase."
Ms. Laurenti indicated she has enjoyed serving the board and wishes to pursue
volunteering for other City advisory boards.
11. Minutes Approval - January 16, 1998
Member Adler moved to approve the minutes as submitted in writing to each
member by the Board Reporter. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
III. Library Director's Report
A. Main Librarv Selection Process
Dr. Hallam was pleased to report RFQ's (Requests for Qualifications) for the new
Main Library architect will be opened today at 4:00 p.m. Of the 50 packets distributed,
none had been submitted by yesterday afternoon. She was aware of at least two who
would submit today, adding it is not unusual to receive submittals at the last minute. On
Monday, a staff committee consisting of Finance Director Margie Simmons, Assistant City
Manager Rick Hedrick, Dr. Hallam, Public Works Administrator Rich Baier, and Purchasing
Manager George McKibben will evaluate submittals based on a criteria sheet that weights
qualification factors. A short list of possibly three qualified candidates will be determined
and presentations scheduled. Dr. Hallam requested input regarding the Library Board's
,desired level of participation in viewing presentation of the architects' ideas.
mllb0298
1
02/20/98
.')
(t1b~
, ~~~'il.J
.~
~'''''.1'> .
(
In response to questions, Dr. Hallam said the RFQ process does not solicit bids, but
, hopefully will find, qualified people who have designed public libraries of a comparable size.
The board may recommend selection of a particular candidate they feel is qualified. The
final decision is made by the City Commission. Because architectural design must be site
specific, it was indicated selection of an architect will probably speed site selection. Dr.
Hallam took note of a suggestion to involve library staff in the design process to ensure
functional spaces result. Board discussion ensued regarding how many Friends,
Foundation, Library Board and City staff members to invite to the presentation to ensure all
entities are represented without making the process unwieldy. The board supported Dr.
Hallam's recommendation to include three representatives from each group. Consensus
was Members Morris, Dunn, and Leavy would represent the Library Board. Member Melgas
will serve as one of the Friends representatives.
B. Plans for Beach and North Greenwood Libraries
Dr. Hallam said the Clearwater Beach and North Greenwood branches will be
replaced during the "One City. One Future." process. The Clearwater Beach library is in the
top five on the for Penny for Pinel/as projects priority list. A potential location north of the
westerly end of the new bridge was discussed. There has been discussion of incorporating
a library branch into a proposed North Greenwood civic complex.
C. East Librarv/ SPJC Joint Proiect
Dr. Hallam reported she and City Manager Roberto are meeting with St. Petersburg
Junior College President Dr. Carl Cutler next Friday to talk about getting this project
underway.
D. MeetinQs with Commissioners reoardinQ Space Allocation and Donor Naminq
Policv
Dr. Hallam is in the process of discussing main library space allocations with
Commissioners. She compared the current library space allocations to space needs as seen
in building programs prepared in 1993 and 1997. Dr. Hallam stated she had explained in
detail how the allocated spaces in the building program are designated for specific library
functions. Finding room in the new library for additional activities would involve cutting
planned library programs. A suggestion was made to rename 28,013 square feet of space
from "unassigned" to I'infrastructure" to clarify the space is not up for grabs, but is
assigned to restrooms, lift equipment, hallways, stairwells, walls, electrical and mechanical
systems, maintenance closets and emergency exits. Discussion ensued regarding library
programs and features listed on a detailed report. Many were surprised to note the 1993
space allocation was obsolete by 1 997.
Dr. Hallam stated the City Commission is aware of the Library Board's
recommendation for a donor naming policy and understands the importance of not
attaching donor names to the new main library. While it was agreed the land donor should
be recognized if land was donated for the library, it was strongly felt the library's name
must remain "Clearwater Public Library" to avoid confusion. Dr. Hallam related the
difficulties associated with naming a public library a name that has no association with the
mlib0298
02/20/98
2
j " ..
<" t..
, e,l
" .
<
~ 3City. Strong concerns were expressed that individuals who do not represent the Library
. .. ,) Board have been speaking for the board recently. This was felt to be a good reason not to
associate the Library Board too closely with other groups.
'\
i
, ,
'-~'
<)
Discussion ensued regarding two suggestions for recognizing the donor if land
was donated for the library: 1) erecting a plaque on the property; and 2) naming the
land where the library is built after the land donor, such as "Clearwater Public Library
at (Donor Name) Square." Member Adler expressed concern about the naming policy,
stating for the record the library may be doing itself a disservice.
IV. Handouts
'North G~eenwood Branch Manager Paul Ritz provided numerous informational
brochures.
V. Reports ~~ Friends, Foundation
Ms. Morris reported on behalf of the Friends of the Clearwater Library, that a
Volunteer Tea will be held April 19 at the Countryside branch library. Althea Andersen
will speak. This will be the first time an outstanding Friends volunteer has been
honored at the tea. Library board members will be invited to attend. Ms. Morris
looked forward to a possible Friends meeting with Mayor Garvey to hear of her trip to
Nagano, Japan during the Winter Olympics. Ms. Morris reported the recent
Cognoscenti Auction sponsored by the Foundation was an enjoyable event that raised
$1 5,000 for the library.
VI. Board and Staff Comments
Dr. Hallam reported she has been asked to take over the General Services
Department as Interim Director until the director's position is filled. She will 'continue
as Library Director. Discussion ensued regarding responsibilities of the new position
, and her dual role.
Dr. Hallam said library staff is looking forward to the next Foundation~sponsored
Cognoscenti Auction on Feb 15, 1999. The theme will be "Literary Lovers."
, In response to a question, Dr. Hallam said the Countryside branch circulation
desk is being recabled to create a self~service check-in area similar to the one at the
East library.
Discussion ensued regarding dates for National Library Week April 20 through
25, and Volunteer Week April 27 through May 3. Dr. Hallam noted the Florida Library
Association Conference is in Tampa, April 2B through 30, 199B.
Ms. Laurenti, a Beach branch volunteer, praised the two Beach library staff
members for their hard work.
mlib0298
3
02/20/98
, "
:'l.
p, ,
C~~1~~~~;;'~~t.~:.~'.,'J<'I':.l":' . ::~.><.l ,~~ '.~I'i' >!
" ,
":)
,-
: .1 ~ .
i'
()
,.
I',~
J
.. . ~ .
. .1
"
Mr. Adler raised discussion regarding a recent lawsuit in Louden, Virginia, filed
by a group of citizens because Internet websites were being filtered.
" Dr. Hallam provided details related to a news story ,concernIng a woman who
,was arrested for failure to return an overdue library book. The woman had signed for
certified letters of notification, but had changed her residence before receiving
notification of the court date. The court found her in contempt and issued an arrest
warrant when she did not appear on the scheduled date. It was thought a Clearwater
police officer had notified the media of the arrest. Concerns were expressed that the
library's, side was not represented in the news reports. Dr. Hallam said she and
Assistant City Attorney Rob Surette were interviewed, but their information apparently
did not make it into a sound byte. Benefits of the incident have been overflowing book
drops and drastically reduced overdue materials lists.
VII. New Business
The next meeting was called for March 20, 1998, 9:00' a.m. at Clearwater Main
',Library. A brief tour of the North Greenwood Library followed.
VIII. Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 10:20 a.m.
~-t~ ;tr./f~Q.
Chair, Li,brary Board ,
Attest:
.~,~~
Board Reporter ' ' '
mlib0298
4
02/20/98
.... .
.. ". '.'. .... ". ......