05/06/1997 - Special (2)
." ,':' ..,. " ,". ", :,' ',/,."': ":",~._; -- ,',' ,":...' .',' : ,,' ," ..".,' , '." " :,:,', '. '," " ' ',:'.', " :;' ",:..' , .." . "
.'
, '
. ~,.
I ,!.,~.._
. ,.1 ' ,. 'f
': .,...~~,<1'..,.:..: ...... .,", .,H.~~... ,
NAHAS.
Neighborhood & Affordable Housing
Advisory Board
MINUTES
Date
a/a_i fMhoffli~ ~V(bIo(Jntnt
P~/(i Mee:b~
:Zo 0 ~
, ,
._......._HU_ ~_........~. . ". "--" ............,..~...._,.lI......l.o.~...:..t'li'..~_t.l~,.................."-"I!/oJ-... II ~ ~l -T1 ~~......_~' ~ .
'-'~~-~'''~I...:'j I .
", ',,"_. . ... ...'I'..";:'....~ ....L;.. ,'<I': ........'
, .; ",' '. ,I., , , '. " , _ I I \ . " ",
NEIGHBORHOOD AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING
SPECIAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PUBLIC MEETING
CITYOF CLEARWATER
May 6, 1 997
-
Present:
Roger Woodruff
Vicki Crouch
Denise Unley
Bilal Habeeb-Ullah
Dee Frye
Mike Meidel
Gary Gray
Alan Ferri
Michael Holmes
Diane Hufford
Brenda Moses
Downtown Development Board
Clearwater Chamber of Commerce
Barnett Bank
African American Leadership Council
Ultimate Learning Center
Florida Power Corporation
Citizens Bank
Clearwater Housing and Urban Development Department
Clearwater Housing and Urban Development Department
Clearwater Housing and Urban Development Department
Board Reporter
The meeting was calted to order at 10: 15 a.m. by Director of Clearwater
Housing and Urban Development Department, Alan Ferri, at the Clearwater Chamber
of Commerce, Clearwater. In order to provide continuity for research, the items
listed were not necessarily discussed in that order.
>fit).
tN'
Mr. Ferri explained that the City annually compiles information about 4
specific areas for the Consolidated Plan. Meetings have been held on housing and
homelessness issues. The last meeting will be held on special needs issues for the
handicapped and disabled. Today's meeting will cover economic development.
Three years ago the City compiled a Consolidated Plan for submission to
HUD. Clearwater is in the third year of a 5-year Plan. Any and all information that
community organizations can share with the City to help obtain additional funding
for economic development for incorporation into the Consofidated Plan would be
welcome. He noted the majority of the money received from State and Federal
government is slated for housing. It was noted that the CCBG (Community
Development Block Grant) Program is part of the Consolidated Plan. Other services
such as code enforcement, public services, nonprofit organization staffing
requirements to run programs within communities, and economic development can
be accomplished through the plan. NonMprofit agencies are eligible for funding for
construction of public facilities.
Two years ago the City began an economic development loan program.
Using $176,000 in Federal money and leveraging another $4 million from the private
sector, production and performance was improved in almost every area of the
Consolidated Plan. Approximately 53 new jobs were created in the community.
The issues of concern for the future are job development, integration of business
expansion and job development services. Any and all linkages possible through
employment and economic development is desperately needed to improve and
enhance quality of life. As part of this year's Consolidated Plan cycle, the City will
submit a neighborhood redevelopment strategy. This strategy will incfude issues
that the City will focus resources and energies towards, such as the Brownfields
o
mNAHOSB.97
05/06/97
,..
and Weed and Seed funds. This should open up additional resources from the
Federal government. The area designed as Brownfields is almost identical to the
Weed and Seed area, which means this will be the neighborhood revitalization
strategy area. When agencies apply for outside additional resources, especially
Federal funds, they can site the fact that they are in an improved Weed and Seed
area, an improved Brownfield area, as well as a neighborhood strategy area.
One of the possibilities the City is exploring with private sector lenders is the
establishment of a CDe (Multiple Bank Community Development Corporation). This
corporation is a banking device allowable by the Federal Reserve and the Office of
Thrift Supervision that allows banks to act in ways they currently cannot. The two
major differences are: 1) banks currently cannot be a participant or investor with a
business; and 2) banks currently cannot own real estate and lease the property for
non-banking purposes. Bank CDC's can perform both these functions, providing
core services to help businesses grow within the community. Bank COC's can also
become involved in financing remediation '=05tS. Most small businesses are
undercapitalized and the City is looking at other venues to provide more capital to
them.
.~
f.::>
In June, Mr. Ferri will petition the City Commission to become a member of
the NDC (National Development Council). The NDC is a national non-profit
organization established in 1975. Over 200 communities participate in various NDC
programs. By becoming a member of this organization, the City can access 2
specific areas which are vital to accomplishing the goals of the City's Consolidated
Plan: 1} access to housing financing under a federally-insured program called HUD
203K; and 2) the SBA (Small Business Association) 7 A Loan Guarantee Program.
The City does not currently have a market to sell secondary mortgages. Joining
NDG will allow the City to sell these mortgage notes by purchasing its performing
notes.
It was noted that in the North and South Greenwood communities alone
there are 1,200 families currently receiving public assistance benefits. Due to
Welfare changes, these families will lose that assistance over the next 17 months.
Any and all resources that the City and non-profit groups can put together to
address this problem will be critical to preparing these families for employment. Job
creation and training will be a critical element to the successful transition from
public assistance to independence for these families.
A question was posed regarding whether the enterprise zone would be
revived. Mr. Ferri indicated that he did not foresee the enterprise zone being revived
since it was reduced to the point that it was not competitive on a State basis.
Given State budgetary issues, it is anticipated that the window for funding will not
be open for quite some time.
o
It was noted that the major battle with HUD over job training and placement
services is that they insist that funds are allocated to pay for agency staff time
because it is classified as "public service", rather than economic development
activity. Congress mandates that no more than 15% of the City's entitlement under
the CDBG Program can be utilized for public services. The competition for funding
mNAH05B.97
2
05/06/97
~ I. . ~ .,
, . . ,.>
..' .'
. " ..+'. .' .' ". .... :: : '. ..... .:.:......_:.~~--.:..,..._.,.. ',....,., "'.,", ,', \ ':/ '" ,,', I .' ',' ':
, .
j'
.
"
"
;\
,--,
is extremely fierce. Only 1 out of 4 applicants receives funding. The last 2 years,
the lion's share of funding has gone to the Salvation Army to administer the City's
drop~;n homeless facility. The second largest subgrantee receiving funding was
Partners in Self-Sufficiency to run a program geared toward taking single parent
households off AFDC.
Mr. Ferri explained the State WAGES IWork And Gaining Economic Self~
sufficiency) Program. Ms. Fry of the Ultimate Learning Center offered her services
in applying for additional licenses for certification programs. She noted that
although some of the existing programs are 5 weeks in duration, students must be
compensated by no less than minimum wage during training. Some type of
compensation is necessary to survive and ensure the success of these programs. It
was noted that the City is in the process of conducting an inventory of existing job
training and placement services currently available throughout the City.
Recommendations regarding gaps will be presented to the City by August 8, 1997.
At that point, the City will be able to determine where additional programs are
needed.
~
The City has been relying on United States Census information from 1990 for
incorporation into the Consolidated Plan. Community program records can supply
more specific trends and problems that could not be identified through Census
records. Mr. Ferri requested that all community agencies submit in writing to his
office, no later than June 6, 1997, any pertinent program specifics which would
assist the City in obtaining additional funding for economic development In the
community.
The meeting adjourned at 10:51 a.m.
()
mNAH05B.97
3
05106/97
t"'....'\~t'l'i'!.._:i.:;.,:,1~.':..:.l,i~J~:.;~.\~.~~~h..';.ll:..~:.~~.';:..;.J~r:".l' ..::....,.,.. ".' < i ~, .'
.. ,', \ ' . " .... ' . .,. ','" . , . "
, , . . ," " .., \ ., \ '. ,. .
.,,:,':_,.,..,.,.., ,.... ,.",..., ..'.. ',,',:,, .,',.. ( ",' ...., ...'..'. ':'.. :..,' .'.. "'. " .',:'..,'
, . " ' . \ " ' ,'.,' ',''''' ", . ~ ," ...... ' .', ' ,,' , " .
, .' ..' 'I ~I' -. . '--, ," \, ' ;
". .' L, I .'~, "........ . ... . "