11/19/1991 - 03:00 PM
,.
... , ..' c "
I ,
. .' ,
. . . .
.' ,
" .
. ,
.
. .
~-.ll ~.~ "",." '.' : ......;'::.tt.;~:'''. {, ~"~"'.4'.......:. '. .' .._ ~. , ...~, ..,., .......... .....
. i <
HEARING
OFFICER
APPEALS
" Date
. ,
... ...... ... .. . [1Jay A. bnulloytl VS,. (lrlj
, d..~~3.'
t1'}~11i1(,\\\r.\\~~~~,f!"T'
<~';~ (:>'~:'>.:;',::Y);;"::: .
.: >, ~., : '. ::. "::,': .: :',: " ;.,,:..',:."., . ::':':'. . "'-,': ::...,::::', ",".',: ':, ,,'~..;.; .. :..., ','.:~',,: ::~ .: :...., . .-~;... .; "',:':. :.',: -.;. '.:' '.\ ,,:.., '.' ...... . :." "" '.' ' , " ,:.: :
" \'.'." """",'. ". ~'" '.;)., "."" .'. ~". " " '".' .,.'
I .' ~\ ~,' . '., . I ',: " I . '. . .' ',., . . I . ~ ~ I' I' ~ =t ~ .' . '," .".; ~. I: . ' . '
"
.... . ~..
,,~,.'~'~:....~l .'.~:q;~~~~~. '.'.~~ !.~' ': I
I ~' -' I
f)
" .
PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE A HEARING OFFICER
November 19, 1991 - 3:00 p.m.
Robert Kapusta vs. City of Clearwater and Edgar A. Bradford
Hearing Officer:
J. Lawrence Johnston, Division of Administrative Hearings
Also Present:
Robert Kapusta, Jr., Petitioner
Irene Heinige, Petitioner
Arlene Woldt, Petitioner
Sandy Glatthorn, Senior Planner
Miles Lance, Assistant City Attorney
Dottie Reehling, Staff Assistant II
Issue:
Edgar A. Bradford for variance of 80 ft to permit
establishment of A.C.L.F. 920 ft from a similarly
licensed facility at 1835, 1837, and 1839 East Dr, Quail
Run, Lot II, zoned RM 8 (multiple family residence).
V91-47 Case 91-005219
.,....
o
Upon the failure of Edgar A. Bradford to appear, the
Ass i stant City Attorney checked with the City Clerk
Department to verify that notice of the hearing was sent
to Mr. Bradford. The City Clerk's Department mailed
notices on 11/06/91 per Affidavit of Mailing Notices.
'It was determined that Mr. Bradford had not received the
official notice from the Division of Administrative
Hearings in Tallahassee.
Mr. Lance telephoned Mr. Bradford asking if he could
attend the hearing. Mr. Bradford declined.
It was decided to re-advertise the hearing and set
another date.
,.
',!
.'
.f'."'
The meeting adjourned at 3:37 p.m.
",;
',I'
:"
o
'I: '.
,. :.
,':'
" ;'. >:.::.:',.' I,.:
.. "..,0
, "", , '":i:' ,,;," "" ",:'::'::ii.::t,:
""~:,/.', ii .':!,>.:, :.,';:.:',,: '';::.:'. ',: ,":. "":);!",:'ii. ",":. .,:';:b:"',':i<,";~!.i :;)44,."':.."::::':,:,:' ,::,) "i..:"'::.";:":,}: :,:;
;,:.:';L)l;:';.:',':-;""" . . . . . '. ~.' ',' '.
" (.,
:-'1"
, . ~
~" 'I
,
, .
. 1- .. ~.'
I) 'ie'
1. ..
1 , ....,. .," .,...t........~ _............-...4..:........_~.. L"" ' .'. '. ,:.' , r .~... :"
~
n I. ~, 'r
, .... \ >, .~ " .r i. .
, .'.
"
. ~ I
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
, ,
, ,
iii, '\" J.~N 2 ~ 1~=~,
\ (" '
..--..-' . .
~-_.._...
CITY OF CLEARWATER and
EDGAR A. BRADFORD,
ROBERT KAPUSTA, JR., ARLENE WOLDT, )
FURMAN KEPLER, and H.C. KEGEL, )
)
)
)
)
}
)
)
)
)
)
Appellants,
VS.
CASE NO. 91-5219
Appellees.
FINAL ORDER OF DISMISSAL
(~ ,
..J
A formal administrative hearing was to have been held
in this case before J. Lawrence Johnston, Hearing Officer,
Division of Administrative Hearings, on November 19, 1991, in
Clearwater, Florida. At the hearing, it was discovered that
proper notice had not been furnished to the applicant, Edgar A.
Bradford. As a result, the hearing was rescheduled to
January 15, 1992.
By letter dated January 10, 1992, the city advised that
it had received written notice from the applicant stating: "I
have no interest in having a distance separation variance for the
'purpose of operating an ACLF. Please withdraw my request. II The
city's letter also advised that the'Development Code Adjustment
Board acted on the applicant's representations at its meeting on
January 9, 1992, and revoked Mr. Bradford's variance.
o
Based on the foregoing, the January 15, 1992, hearing
is cancelled, and this case is dismissed as being moot.
. .
'..'._" "', '," ",' "':' .""\::{"".:.' ,,', r<~. ,,",,' ".'..;,' ",' "":':J',l'h'~:>'.,,:,:"':,"""\<,
, I" ." , ' , " I e' ~. .:1... , S.., , . " '"'',''' "
.\'..".:. ;' ..,.:.. ....',.,...,., ".,1' :"". " .' 'I'~'-:" "'1' ," .,',....::......'i" ":.::',....,::.'<...r,-'::....:
I ' 'i' } . ~. ~. lit .' .' . " ,.. .' . ." ., \.' ','. . . " .
1 , . . " "'..' .......... ~. I ~ ".,_ .", .',' I"'~"""
, ' . . ' .... _"_, ~ _..-'. ~_r ~ .. .. I' '., " ,
"
~, ',: ~ '. ':' ....
~ ''I',cL ~.'.~ 'l~ ~ P" ~1"...... ,
/ t
. "
DONE AND ORDERED this
/6'~
day of January, 1992, in
.Q
"
Tallahassee, Florida.
J LAWRENCE J
Haring Offi r
ivision of aministrative Hearings
The DeSoto Building
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Florida'32399-1550
. (904) 488-9675
Filed with the Clerk of the
Division of Administrative
Hearings this ~~~ day of
January, 1992.
COPIES FURNISHED:
,,~,
;l~
Robert Kapusta, Jr., Esquire
1410 45th Avenue North
st. Petersburg, Florida 33703
Miles A. Lance, Esquire
Assistant city Attorney
city of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
Edgar A. Bradford
1655 Midnight Pass Way
Clearwater, Florida 34625
cynthia Goudeau
city Clerk
city of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
Final order, Case No. 91-5219
III
2
.
........i_...... ........ ....... .'\ ...... '..>:'::.);/.::'),::;,:'),2':\2';:.". /,', :.,', ,""'.,,"',':,..
.. ....,,-,...'..,.) ..,.". ...,.::~:t,.,.,.....u....,.:.. .t::. \,' .,..... ,...,
. " :1 '.. ..',"..~ ::: :.:. '.:: ~ ~ :::.....:: ~ :', ':' :~',' ..,' ..~, .... ':",', I d\:'~'" .:':::.'1 ..,,,,',,".~ 1'~<':' .J~.. ": :'~ ."" ':', 13 .:~. -:. :'.., j: ~," -':~ " ," . .', ~'"
. . ' ,I:'. . _" _~_ ..-:.-.. .......,....... ,_ , ~;. . ,..,., . .' ~ ,':.,
.
. < , , ~
:, / ~"::~ ';! ; . . /, ~
, ,1'", ~ >
. ~ . I
JD) m@rnnwrn fn)
lIl1 DEe 27 1991 ~
M
rJ
. -,..~.
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
CITY CLERK DEPT.
Petitioners,
)
)
)
)
)
) CASE NO. 91-52l9
)
)
)
)
)
)
ROBERT KAPUSTA, JR., ARLENE WOLDT,
FU~~ KEPLER, and H.C. KEGEL,
vs.
CITY OF CLEARWATER and
EDGAR A. BRADFORD,
Respondents.
*AMENDED ORDER CONTINUING FINAL HEARING
It having appeared at final hearing previously
scheduled for November 19, 1991, that proper notice had not been
furnished to the applicant, final hearing is continued to
I:)
2:00 p.m. on Wednesday, January 15, 1992, in the Large Conference
Room, city Hall, 112 South Osceola Avenue, Clearwater, Florida.
DONE and ORDERED this ~~ay of December, 1991, in
Tallahassee, Florida.
. LAWRENCE J.
Haring Offi
D'vision of Aoministrative Hearings
he DeSoto Building
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550
(904) 488-9675
Filed with the Clerk of the
Division of Administrative
Hearings this hl3/Ld -Aay of
December, 1991.
c:J *AMENDED TO CHANGE DATE OF HEARING.
"',:._" :,' .., " ":,.:'k(}:,:;.:C,....:'~::;:,.,d'.:,.,'...6y,,...f::,::>";.,:~",.,:,,.:r
. l ' .' .' .' " ',' I" . . !~;.i.:...I... I '. . ..,. I " . ' ,. ." , ...,.
. . ~ '...'. '.' f L.., I,., ---.........'. . ." ~" .' I :', . ,'..:; ~ ~. ~ " .,.'
Miles A. Lance, Esquire
city of Clearwater
post Office BoX 4748
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
Edgar A. Bradford
1655 Midnight Pass Way
Clearwater, Florida 34625
'~ '
.~c, \ '" ,
..
,
, "
. I:
~./'J}(,';:',~ ':~.'.,:'::;' 'f:,:~\;:""~' "''':r~l,,:(,~ ~"'t~""~;""'k"~"';"'~~; ".,', . ,_ ...."... .,' .'
. .' "" _. . - '. .... ,". ~ . .,
--
copies furnished:
Robert Kapusta, Jr., Esquire
1410 45th Avenue North
st. Petersburg, Florida 33703
cindi Goudeau, Clerk
city. of clearwater
Post Office Box 4788
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
Room confirmation:
0"
Ms. Betty Blount
city Manager's Office
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater Florida 34618-4748
813/462-6700
Case No. 91-5219
i' ~c ,
o
I . .' ~
. , ' .
. . . ~' " . . __ _ ~_' ., _...-.. :...:--- ~ .' _ '. " " t' . "',"
..
. ;.
'.~'r'h" "'::,.l..".-':::;I;~':J'.~'~~'. ..~.~.\.
o
44
[D) ~ @ IH WI ~ ~L /
!Jl) DEG 19 1991 ~i~
STATE OF FLORIDA CITY CLERK DEPT.
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
,
ROBERT KAPUSTA, JR., ARLENE WOLDT,
FURMAN KEPLER, and H.C. KEGEL,
Petitioners,
)
)
)
)
)
) CASE NO. 91-5219
)
)
)
)
)
)
vs.
CITY OF CLEARWATER and
EDGAR A. BRADFORD,
Respondents.
ORDER CONTINUING FINAL HEARING
o
It having appeared at final hearing previously
scheduled for November 19, 1991, that proper notice had not been
furnished to the applicant, final hearing is continued to
2:00 p.m. on Wednesday, February 5, 1992, in the Large Conference
Room, City Hall, 112 South Osceola Avenue, Clearwater, Florida.
DONE and ORDERED this It, & day of December, 1991, in
Tallahassee, Florida.
J. LAWRENCE J
He ring Offi
'vision of ~ ministrative Hearings
The DeSoto Building
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550
(904) 488-9675
Filed with the Clerk of the
Division of Adm~z:~rative
Hearings this day of
December, 1991.
o
'.: ,'. _" ',' 'd' '.' "\,':, ""'::~"":'::-:':''''':':'.:''.',,'~':''<: :. '::'",..",,:-..:', \:,<:~,::,:".:,:,::".<":,...,,.:,,:::'::,' :>..,,: . :', ,"'<" .": ",... ...<..,',,' '. :-. " <:,1," .
",." ',',....,:'.: ..>,:;..'...~,...:'::..<':.'..:.;:.,..',.','. "';.it., ,.".._t." . :j,'\'. Q (..',' " ,:'.'., n"":.'
.' ' . .,.'..' .'. < ..:"',';,,::',,:':',~.;\<.,.<:-d:...'.,,<.",:..,< ':.....c:\::..\.,...c'..,:"..'...',.~ \. ,.:.. ,;:' :I~':"" .\ ':. '.', ': -.: ::' :,.' ::
. ~ ....' _..... . ~...~.... ......., " 'i, . I '. I . . .' . /I .
.,
..., .'.,.
t',
,
'., 0" I
l ',. ". ,0 I .
r""""~,,,,,'~.'o"l n;...........,.......,......:...., :...~. .~: .......
o
Copies furnished:
Robert Kapusta, Jr., Esquire
1410 45th Avenue North
st. Petersburg, Florida 33703
Miles A. Lance, Esquire
city of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
Edgar A. Bradford
1655 .Midnight Pass Way
Clearwater, Florida 34625
cindi Goudeau, Clerk
city of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4788
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
Room Confirmation:
1::)
Ms. Betty Blount
.'city Manager's Office
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater Florida 34618-4748
, r
813/462-6700
Case No. 91-5219
. "
I
~{~
-.
.
].
"", '_' " ',":"'."";"".""""".'.'."':'",'~,",i,:;".":' ,",j,:,;.:.....';: :"",,",,,
, , '(\, '."'. .,' .~~.. '~:J .,,3, ..l I " ,
\\ . I 'L.' r, .' . ..c: . . -.. . ,~~ . ' .,
, .\, . ......_........._........_.....'_. . ..... . . '. ~ .' ,'. . I
..
. ;
. ". ~ . 1 ,: 1 .
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS ern' c.:_ r:RK
n ..., r' 'lr:' 1.~~ ~jJY
. }-. · ~'. . 1~' I,~. J- b
SEP 2 n 1991
J
Petitioner,
)
)
)
)
) CASE NO. 91-5219
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
ROBERT KAPUSTA, JR.,
.vs.
CITY OF CLEARWATER and
EDGAR A. BRADFORD,
Respondents.
AMENDED
NOTICE OF HEARING
AS TO PARTIES
A hearing has been set in this case in Large Conference
,
Room, city Hall, 112 S. Osceola Avenue, Clearwater, Florida, at
.. () ~), or as soon thereafter as can be heard, on
------= ---
~mber 19~. Continuances will be granted only by order of
--------
the hearing officer for good cause.
ISSUES: Whether Respondent Bradford shoUld be granted a variance
of 80 feet to establish an ACLF 920 feet from a similarly
licensed facility at 1835, 1837 and 1839 East Drive, Clearwater,
Florida.
AUTHORITY: Section 120_57(1), Florida statutes, and city of
Clearwater Land Development Code.
The parties shall arrange to have all witnesses and
evidence present at the time and place of hearing. Subpoenas
will be issued by the Hearing Officer upon request of the
parties.' All parties have the right to present oral argument and
::)
')
" , ,-" ' , ..' :~', ':',':,.'" . ,,:.' '~';,:' :','. :,::' ',.:':,,:.:':~::-;,: ',':..:.. ';~.' ':.' ~",..':. ,: :', :\,,'/, ,.:..:'.:.:.,>'.>,'.":',':.::.;<,':'::~:.','::..:.'..:.:~:.~~.'.".:',':,:\'....
'. ,\ ' . . " " '.' .:~ ,.1"::1' 3 . "." ..,'; ',.,,','......,..,
, , \', I' . " ' ;",: ". .: ':~,<," ,-;,'" '>'1' ."... "',,\_ ::. ,..',.:' ::.,.":, ,..,..::-:~~./:..<,::,:.',:..::.,' ';,>..'i:>' ::',':
.. '. ........:..._.,.__:.._,...... ./.... . j J, '.' j". ,t,'
"
,
to cross-examine opposing witnesses. All parties have the right ~
to be represented by counselor other qualified representative,
in accordance with Rule 221-6.008, Florida Administrative Code.
September 17, 1991
DATE
A2~T
Hearing Offi r
Division of Administrative Hearings
The DeSoto Building
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, FL 32399-1550
(904) 488-9675
'Copies furnished to:
Miles A. Lance, Esquire
city of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, FL 34618-4748
Cyndi Goudeau
Clerk
City of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, FL 34618-4748
{
..~"'" .
,
"
Robert Kapusta, Jr., Esquire
1410 45th Avenue North
st. Petersburg, FL 33703
ROOM CONFIRMATION TO:
Ms. Betty Blount
city Hall
City Manager's Office
112 Osceola Avenue
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, FL 34618
(813) 462-6700
No. 91-5219
~
...-.........--.............~-..",.,..'I onI,.~I..J -'>1-<+" ~.""
. '.' . I.. .". >' ....:".:~..:~,.;'.", ". ,',,' :"';"." ..' '~'>"':'.,',.,"..:.,' '.,':,> ~"'..,.:".:.:'.:;~,,.,:.' ....,. ;...:'.::<',...!..:..:...:.....::::::,
_' ,." ,-., I!'- 3'~ .~.. .'. ," ,.
I '. ., ".:....' 'I" ,"..< .... ,:....:,.<'~~. ,:., , :,~ ..'....:-',wJ ....-...~.:.,..,:..~~'.<' ..... :.',"~".'-
. ,~"'..' ~ i . ,~ . . C 1 .' t _ . . .......; ./. .-.,'. I L . . " ..' .. .,.' . . ',_' .~' .
, '} ,I" '" '~ . ......._,_....-..-......__- . ~.... . t I, : . ",' ,'" j \ . 'llI "
"
,
'; "..' ~
'}
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
EDGAR A. BRADFORD, ) nECT::IVi~D
) SEP 0 1 1991
Petitioner, )
) CITY CLERK
vs. ) CASE NO. 91-5219
)
CITY OF CLEARWATER, )
)
Respondent. )
)
)
NOTICE OF HEARING
4W
()J(
r
A hearing has.been set in this case in Larqe Conference
Room, city Hall, 112 S. Osceola Avenue, Clearwater, Florida, at
3:00 p.m., or as soon thereafter as can be heard, on November 19,
1991. continuances will be granted only by order of the hearing
officer for good cause.
ISSUES: Whether Petitioner was wrongfully denied a variance of
. f~ 80 feet to establish an ACLF 920 feet froln a similar licensed
facility at 1835, 1837 and 1839 East Drive, Clearwater, Florida.
AUTHORITY: section 120.57(1), Florida Statutes; and city of
Clearwater Land Development Code.
The parties shall arrange to have all witnesses and
evidence present at the time and place of hearing. Subpoenas
will be issued by the Hearing Officer upon request of the
parties. All parties have the right to present oral argument and
to cross-examine opposing witnesses. All parties have the right
to be represented by counselor other qualified representative,
in accordance with Rule 221-6.008, Florida Administrative Code.
Auqust 30, 1991
DATE
J( hyF
Hearing ~
Division of Administrative Hearings
The DeSoto Building
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, FL 32399-1550
(904) 488-9675
...........
-J
copies furnished to:
. .-........'./~1~. ......~.~f)...u>.~.'...~..~ .~u..u
"'----..-,...\... .........J~ ':.\.
,,' ':"-':'''' ":',' ...' ...' ....,.... .':'.'<':': .',\:',.":'.':':'..:.:".:','.::-:.::,:~'.':':,'" ...,:'..'...."': ' . ,'; ..;.... : : ,~):,':'~',.,.>'" :':~3" ,.' '" .' ',:: ......3. ,.)... ..,..: ::,>,..:~.:..:'..,.~;.,,,.' ,::. '., .<
. ,',. ;". ".' , .' ':. . " ? ::' p' '.'. -,' ...... '.". ,,' ,',' . " ,
,. ' , I ' \ . . . I " " ' ~ .' \ l ", 1".,1, '.,
'.'" .:' ,,'.' ':"',:. :_...:'~,';.:.,:.', . ',_ ~..: ,', ,'.; ,,~:'.'. \: "'. .~:-. .' ."i" _ .::, ", ,.:', I ;, ,','.,' "
, .u:~..
.. ._ __ .. .....~. ... _..IWI .' .+ ~ ~ .." .' .. ' .
.~ .'~' ~ .
f'
.
:[.
..... "4'o"lt.,~.cp~~.....~ '".....~.
"
;,
.;. '.
I" ".
.'L ..' ",' ,
. .
, .
:': t .
"
'. '
"
.. cl
. ,.
Miles A. Lance, Esquire
city of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, FL 34618-4748
()
Cyndi Goudeau, Clerk
city of Clearwater
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, FL 34618-4748
RObert.Kapusta, Esquire
1410 45th Avenue North
st. Petersburg, FL 33703
ROOM CONFIRMATION TO:
'Ms. Betty Blount
. city Hall,
city Manager's Office
112, Osceola Avenue
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater,' FL 34618.
. (813) 462-6700
No. 91-5219
/'
.....~. /;
;.
, ,
. "
, .
~
"
'~",;:, :::;'':;\:~\:: ',',".
'. _' :_.1, :.:.~.;v.....i~.~3.. :>