01/10/1995 (2)
';~~1=. . ;~~ . > ~
.:.!~.: ,,'" .' ~
,.~
,~' ,
'-.........'
','
',' .
. '
":f.
'\'
. '.'
;';,:..
" ,
~ I . .
';',: ;
,r. .<.
\;:.,'.:' '
. "
:~T . ."
;....~t;~<,'
:~ I ',l,
" ,
.,,1<
,."' I
:~,~ /"
, ,
..'. "
:;"':",.
'. .
. .
ACTION AGENDA
PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD
Tuesday, January 10, 1995 ~ 2:00 p.m.
Commission Chambers, 112 South Osceola Avenue, Clearwater, Florida
I
,
,
\
1
ITEM:
A. APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
Action: Approved minutes of the December 13, 1994 meeting as submitted.
B. ,REQUESTS FOR EXTENSION, DEFERRED AND CONTINUED ITEMS:
B(A). (cont from 12/13/94) Grace Lutheran Church to pennit Child day care at 1812 N.
Highland Ave, See 02~29-1S, M&B 32.12, Brentwood Estates, Lot A, zoned P/SP
(public/Semipublic). eu 94-104
Action: Granted with staff to coordinate with the applicant a change in location of playground,
subject to the following conditions: 1) The applicant shan obtain the requisite occupational license
within six months from the date of this public hearing; 2) the outdoor play area shall not be used
before 9:00 a.m. or after 7:00 p.m.; and 3) appropriate transportation impact fees shall be paid prior
to the issuance of the occupational license.
C. CONDITIONAL USES:
Cl. John K. & Demetra Lainas (Smart Stop Mini Mart, Inc) to pennit package sales of
beer and wine (new license) at 1208 N. Ft Harrison Ave, Enghurst 2nd Addition, Lots 62
& 63t zoned CI (Infill Commercial). eu 95~01
dct;on: Granted subject to the following conditions: 1) The requisite occupational license shall
be obtained within sixty days from the date of this public hearing; 2) the perimeter landscaping
, requirements of Section 42.27 shall be provided along the western property line prior to issuance
ofa certificate of occupancy or occupational license, and continuously maintained thereafter; 3) this
approval shall be for a 4 month trial period, after which the application shall be reviewed for
compliance with the established conditions of approval; 4) the parking lot shall be re-striped and a
parking space provided for the handicapped within 60 days; and 5) hours of operation are weekdays,
8:00 8.m. to 9:00 p.m., and weekends, 8:00 a..m. to 10:00 p.m.
C2. Jonathan & Janet M. Leonard (Duraseal Asphalt Sealing Co.) to pennit a home
occupational license with more than 3 employees at 2964 Hillcrest Cir N, Countrypark, Blk
D, Lot 12, zoned RS 6 (Residential Single Family). CU 95-02
Action: Granted subject to the following conditions: 1) the applicants shall obtain the requisite
occupational license within six months from the date of this public hearing; 2) no sale or trading in
actPZOln.95
01/10/95
1
,
,
..,...., . ..
:>:." '. , , , ___-~ ,,;~,.;.~,- ' >,~,-,.;q,,::;' ':':,,"11':~';:';(\,~'<:':";;'~:.,'~",';~>/,~~~::::>,~~.::;':::~,~~:C'~'::~~'~(:~:"":~~~,>7;'+:s~f2-~~(~;~~,~.:::~;,:;i~~f~(f~;:~~
~-!~ ~ ..'~ .' ~.. ~~~~~~-c"~;~ ~1~,:~~i~;'~.li~~0~..t:'.\;?<.i::;; ~;l";'~~: 1:~{:;:,,,": ~'i~ .~.~t~'~;I,,:-tit:-.;;;/t~"'~t=:-.t.Z::~i.~ ~t:"~~~.~.,~;:-;' ..~~ :'..~'l.'q;t ~:~:~t ~~ ~/*;Y4;-y.~~,~&:V;"';~~t.~~c:J~f~~'(f.~:i: .',\.:- J . ~.' l~'~" ~
"7..-............. ' . ". . . .. '1.~",' J.....,~.....u.~. ,~"'r_..-,.'...'
/~';,,,:,!..i~.: ",' ", .'. I
" '
~
.', .
~; ,~:'. .
.~;} :.
:'\.
::~ ' .
, ,
'0
. . . ~ .
..... .
..
. '.
. "c.
. '-< ',p
:'~~'('~ c
-~. >'.:~ ~".
, "
~....! ,:' .'.
~" .
.. I'
, '.
; , :~
~,~ ',.,"
. .,., +
{:{,,; ,
".' ~. ;
;)':i:':, '
.;~:~..: i' -
.'J'. '.:
~ c \ .
~ '. I.
~ ~~ ',' J
:1 ;,
"
':.:',:, .
,....~c '. . '" .
.,..f~
~.",(~
, .....
I:~" .\ ,
. ,
I '. ~
MC',
.' ....
.(.~';~ .
,I'. .
merchandise shall be carried on from the property where the home occupation is located; 3) the
occupation shall not involve the use of a commercial vehicle for delivery of materials to and from
the premise except for travel from the home occupation site to a job location and to return; 4) no
marked vehicle or equipment used in conjunction with the home occupation shall be parked on the
property; 5) no display of products, operations, signs or nameplates shall be visible from outside the
dwelling; and 6) the applicants shall comply with all of the standards for alJ home occupations
contained in Section 41.161(4) of the City Land Development Code.
C3. E.G. Bradford & Sons, Ioe to permit outdoor retail sales, display, andlor storage at 111
S Belcher Rd, Sec 18-29-16, M&B 23.03, zoned CG (General Commercial). CU 95-03
tfction: Continued to January 24, 1995.
D.
ANNEXATION, ZONING, LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT, LAND
DEVELOPMENT CODE TEXT AMENDMENT, AND LOCAL PLANNJNG
AGENCY REVIEW:
Dl. 1947 West Skyline Drive, Skyline Groves, Lot 105 (C.M.L. Building Company Ine).
A 94-27; LUP 94-31
LUP: Residential Low
ZONE: RS-8 (Single Family Residential)
Action: Recommend emlor.fement
D2., 24244 U.S. I?, (part A-annexation), Haas Sub, Lots 3-8, Blackburn Sub, part of Lot
3 and abutting right-of-way for Lawson Rd & Haas Ave, (Part B-zoning), Haas Sub, Lots
1-8, Blackburn Sub>> part of Lot 3 and abutting right-of~way for Lawson Rd & Haas Ave,
(Ridge Haven Associates, Ltd). A 94-28; LUP 94-32
LUP:, Commercial Retail
ZONE: CPD (Commercial Planned Development)
Action: Recommend endorsement subject to the following preliminary conditions: 1) A fire
hydrant assembly shall be installed not more than 300 ft.. from the structure; 2) if structure requires
or has installed an automatic fire sprinkler system, a Fire Department connection shall be installed
with a minimum of 15 ft. from the structure, adjacent to a paved driveway and within 30 ft. of a fire
hydrant assembly; 3) prior to certification, the Dumpster Requirement Fonn must be completed and
returned to the City Solid Waste Department; 4) prior to certification, a copy of the SWFWMD
permit application is to be provided to Engineering Site Plan Review; 5) prior to issuance of a
.. building pennit, a copy of the approved SWF\Wv1D pennit is to be provided to Engineering Site Plan
Review; 6) prior to certification, the final site plan must be signed and sealed by a Professional
Engineer registered in the State of Florida; 7} a Pinellas County Public Health Unit Permit,
IngresslEgress and a 10 ft. utility easement over the proposed water mains up to and including
meters, bacldlow prevention devices and hydrants are required prior to issuance of a building pennit;
8) backflow prevention devices must be installed by the City with applicable fees being paid by the
nctPZOla.95
01/10/95
2
~~T,L w, " ~~~. ~l' I '~.,li> '~; ;;"'ii:f.;:~ifJir(/jii,fl~'~C~;::,:Yi~"'{,~,;;?';i.iki~~~,'.~;('{::;~;~~~';};:'~;'~k~: :~:i~ L~;~,;:,~,;~,:{i~;!J.;~k;Lj.<:~\i:r~~{~~~~;! ;~.:{:;j:, ~:,,~.: ,:. ;;:;' .';;;,
."fi~'?:,.I,.'i 0;'. I ,L ...... l ,,:. ......"
,,~
-,.. ,
"~~
\' "
I'
~.' >
L:, '
: ~ '-~ .. '.,'
J,.'
1
,-
'",
"
\', .
"I>
I.'.'.
,:.; ,
t."-
';'
{ ,
:. -'. ~ ~~.: .
;.
. '
,;..,'C),
!.,.
, ,
, .'
L i": ~ ,
.".': \::, I .
: r .~, <.
~)":c ~ .
~:'~:,/ : "
. = ..
~ :. ~ "
. ,.,. 'c. ,,"
.' ,J ..:",:, ".
/f:;/,:' ': '
~~1 ':;c.'; c' ". ' "
rp.",.
.",.:c"". .
tc~;. '. ,
,~,~ ~'~'T' < .
J;;:,/; ,
"' <,
'~.~ 'f.., '"
r',;'.,:-::,
.:~~; . ..: <
:~'~.:'.} ~ .. 'I
" .
j",: p. , '
. . ~ '
~: '. .."", ,
:'':,':''1.'. .
'~. c'. '.
"
.. ~ 'c<c. .
.. ...,
~;u~;~{:. :;,,: ;',",
c,.,"':J
owner; 9) all existing and proposed utilities are to be shown on the site plan prior to certification;
10) prior to certification, plans are to show 50 ft. of adjacent topography around perimeter of site;
11) sidewalks are required adjacent to an street rights~of-way, and shan be shown on the site plan;
12) handicap spaces must be adjusted to meet government standards; 13) parking and/or driveways
(placement of wheel stops)and traffic sign placement shall be approved by the Traffic Engineer and
shown on the site plan; 14) dimensions to be shown on the plan shan denote measurements for
aisles, parking stalls, entrances, etc. 15) prior to issuance of a building permit, a copy of the
approved SWFWMD permit shall be submitted to Environmental Management; 16) signage should
be as specified on the site plan; 17) the requisite building permits must be procured within one (1)
year from the date of certification of the final site plan and all requisites certificates of occupancy
must be obtained within three (3) years of the date of certification of the site plan; 18) a Unity of
Title shall be recorded with PineUas County Official Records prior to issuance of any building
permit; 19) all pennitted uses and any approved conditional use permits or variances for the
Commercial Planned Development shall be listed on the final certified site plan; 20) the applicant
shall contact Parks & Recreation for the required recreation/open-space assessment fee, which shall
be paid prior to certification of the site plan; 21) FOOT approval of proposed access to U.S. 19 shall
be obtained prior to second reading of the rezoning ordinance and approval of the final site plan.
D3. 509 Bayview Ave and 508 Meadow Lark Lane, McMullen Bayview Sub, Tract A,
Blk 3, Lots 1 & 2 and south]/2 ofrightwof-way to the north. (R. Roy Meador). Z 93w54;
LUP 93-43
LUP:
ZONE:
From Residential Urban to Commercial General
From RS 6 (Single Family Residential) to CPD (Commercial Planned
Development)
Action: Continuell to February 28. 1995.
Ordinance No. 5720-94 ofthe City of Clearwater, Florida, relating to the Land Development
Code; amending Section 41.053, Code of Ordinances. to reduce the minimum lot area
requirement for manufacturing uses in the IntiU Commercial Zoning District; creating
Section 42.36. Code of Ordinances, to prohibit driveway access for nonresidential uses
across residential zoning districts; providing an effective date.
A~tion: Recomnreml endorsement
Ordinance No. 5740-94 of the City of Clearwater. Florida, relating to the Land Development
Code; amending Section 41.171, Code of Ordinance, to revise requirements for temporary
,'commercial parking lot uses; providing an effective date.
Action: Recommend endorsement
nctPZOln.95
3
01/10/95
.', "",.. :"1 :
,:'" ' l... c ~. ,J ,~, .. I
~{r~z~'~'i:~'" ,:., I '
~~J> '> .
t~ ':
:~(} .
'-t~.;~. /t
~:~ '. \
:i.? .
,..'
l.~f. .
:;, .: '
;C'I
~ ~ ~~:.: c ;
"
"
. "
. ~:
". >' . <.
'.... ':".,," ..........\.)"':......i:.......::.~1r~~~:~r~\:~.<~..;. :\.~ ..~', ~~:.~~.:~.I "..
~~~i<.,f.I""~ ~ 'tt't \1,.. '....~~..'~. . ~.:. ~ , . '. , .
~;;;t~...i/...!..~~/. <'. :-~, . <" <' . ~ ' ". .
""'.. ..,
, ,
......
"
". ;,
',' y i. '.!
~ .~. ~ '.toO":.'"
'J~ .
';':'''0
:: .. :
:-".l '.' .
.. . ." ~
.1 ._
,.: r :
, . ~,
Ordinance No. 5755-95 of the City of Clearwater, Florida, relating to the Land Development
Code; amending sections 40.356 and 40.404, Code of Ordinances, to provide for outdoor
retail sales, displays and/or storage in the Beach Commercial and Resort Commercial
zoning districts as conditional uses; amending Section 41.053. Code of Ordinances, to
establish additional supplementary conditional use standards for outdoor retail sales,
displays, and/or storage; providing an effective date.
, ,
.-"
:"'1' ~' t
~,: .
t~<, '
,....r,
i~::c " .
i~f - ,
...... ,,' ~
~:'~':'4~'
Action: Recommentl emlorsement
'~.....
~'1~ .
:Jt. :',;' :
l~: ,,'
~:.':.' ,'..
tJbl .'
(~?):,'
~;,;:;:','::'.': '
~,};:~~ ~,,: :,. '
~~~\ '\":: ,
liti~'/: ' .
~!:j~/:/ ",.. '.
tFri\~:" ; ,
5;'~'().:',,:'<:::z:~: '.:~:' ,,'
WI:,,:,:,l'.\'" ','" ,
, F1I,:~~:),'~::":,)':''>, :' ,
.~t(t~t{~:~~<~::I::<;..;... :.. "
_):;j:~~(i\:YE::"./: :",
i;-'},t"~: ;.. ,'I; ':. " f.
1',;.>:.0...", ' ""';", , :, "
k('~~..:I.' r....... . ~ ..
~~~~2~ ~ ~>':.~:.. 'r'.~ " '. '
~/J1.{l" ..II :.-, . .
'it1E~,,"\ ,..,.
~~h-t~'I...)L.. ",,' ~ . ..".
. , '~ti{~~;.'r::.
~'l':l""".f~ ,'" " ',' ,
g~~:!~~ :j'~~P ':;' . ~,
;i'8' r,hf:,; r:'" " ,
~r~):;:p~~;:I<', ','< "~ "
~k,fi"i" " , "
~:l\r,~F;';'; ~'>;:, ,', "
;; s,L~:t-\"\. ~.: .~, : "
f.~,',f':"'.', :, ',' :,: '
tit~:,.p.:,~~: ~;.: '~.':
~;iC",.\"~ " '.~= . 0 . I )'.
:t.... ."l.... J "" .)~.. ,
0~iU':({,.'::~:;">,' , ',:
i}~.':;:':'<': ,
9t..~~~l':~.'. ";: ,:" "actPZOla.95
!~;i'l'1';;": '
'~'''i'j'<; "',1,.: " ,
.f.~~~\f~; ~(r, .": . .. '.' .
~,~:~I':,< :
:~4~(~";:{ J ;:,': ~.
E.
CHAIRMAN'S ITEMS:
1.
Review of Rules and Procedures
Continued to February 28, 1995.
2.
Election' of 1995 Officers:
Kemper Merriam, Chair '
Jay Keyes, Vice Chair
'4
01/10/95
" L>:,:,:' :,> ,:~;~::L::":~:'..J ~:::,~~.'~'
. . .. '.
.:\'~., ~........~~.:.;;:II\J!:f;':lI~~ ~ . .._-< <,
",
'.;">
~~ . .
Members present:
John Carassas, Chair
Robert D. Bickerstaffe
Jay Keyes
Edward Mazur
Kemper Merriam
Brenda Nixon
. ., ~
. '.
....,~.,_...:..r.,.....l.'..
.........\ ~ ,.. ...... ~ '"1 .'
i
,'4
. .\~....
MINUTES
PLANNJNG AND ZONING nOARD
January 10, 1995 ~ 2:00 }'.M.
, Commission Chambers. 112 South Osceola Avenue. Clearwater FL
'"
" ,
" ,
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
lNVQCA TION
"".
" ~
; ::'i : :.
k;:' .(~~,.~"
\i~7.~'. :":;.~ .
,',' " Members absent: Lois M~rtin, Vice Chair
. . Also P,resent: Scott Shuford, Director, Central Permitting
" ' Sally.Demarest, Board Reporter
Chairman Carassas outlIned the procedures for conditional uses and advised that anyone adversely
~:~;;', '" " -:,' affected by a decision of the Planning and Zoning Board, with regard to conditional uses, has two
~~~;.>', ":,, weeks'~om this date in which to file an appeal through the City Clerk's Office. Florida Law requires
t,:~,> ;:, ,~ny, party appealing a decision of this Board to have a record of the proceedings to suppon tl~e
,!y.,\:':,..',';" ,,' "'ap' p' eal' ,.." ' .
. \;"-;i. ", .. '," .. ..~. .' . '" .
,~[~~!~,::c~::..~. '., "., .~. ...... .'.\_' ',' ,
}J~~{~,::,:.. ,':; :,,,::,'BY'- motion ,duly 'seconded, the minutes of the December 13, 1994 meeting were approved as
i~~"':,::,' ,":,,': .. submitted'" .
t.;~~{~(t,"::~':.,'>,.,~,':',,';,,':.: :,:'" , ,
;~~':,/~'/',.':': '. :' '.':: Atthis Point, Mf; Shuford noted staff's'recommendation of continuance of item D3 to February 28,
Wtf~:""":,;',, ,\; ,1995"due'.to en~ironmental.concems which may affect. site ~esign. In co~sideration ofthe.numbe~
~:;<:~':',";"!:' ',.,', .,,'~fpersons attendmg the m~etmg'who would have to walt until much later, It was suggested Item D"
7\;;)',:~:::'<":" :' : ',tie addressed first (see, p.7). '
~J,~~:~;.D :\.:',:.:' ~-~ :l.~: .~, Cl,. .." '." ". ~ ' ',..
.~rIX(::~;:'~<;,;, ".The following requests for extension, deferred and continued items were considered:
!~X!:';:,::,:' "'B(A), (oont from 12113/94) Grnee Luther"n Church to permit Child day care at 1812 N.
j;?::);:'::.,:,:,'.',:,.,,~'., ..~ighland:Ave, Sec 02~29-15, M&B 32.12, Brentwood Estates, Lot A. zoned P/SP
~;:,;;;y,,>'.'>'i :',,'~' " "(public/Semipublic). CU 94-104
}:i::,;:";~,t','\':',"':..,:" :- . ' ,',', '
~J~~'~}<.<',',':::,~"Mr~..,'S~uford gave the background of the application and presented, in wntmg, the staff
ft,:,}(,.;", ':" recommendations. He indicated this item was continued from December 13, I 994 to enable the
~~t~~:,Ol':;:;,;,,>", ~i~Ola.95 1 01110/95
'"
" .
~. .,""""'<fI', . ":'Y~~;~:I ".-~ > ~. ~.i~t.t-1'i1~~"'7..~,,;U~ ~~"l:~~f:~""l..'~~"'" \..~.'ir.';;r":.i.I~L~......i~~.;.-~ r'.~:.i.~l"':'.'.~P~l~~~f~~~':......tIJ,.t:'~.~.I:. :..~\...."!;.'I..;..;,:~.J.,.."".r. ..:.;f~;~/..+....--;--.li.:~'~i.;(~I.}.....~~~'t~~dt~'4I.
r 1-,.."".,...... ~I~' .-'-, 'l"" j .'~l \ ......:1 '!o(~~ql .....,.(1.;..."'1. ..........I..\i~...,. h-.' '. ,. \1 '. ~"'i:
;"'''\''''~'';''~' .r."..,..,' ",., '. ,',.. .,,1., ,,. ',' .. .~ "":!\~", !'....t,'f.llr{t',.,I''.,t,,, .
:'M\>::.~i;l.J\~';"';,~,:.::'<r'.",~~';":.)T:",,' ..',' :'",.,', : . ',' . ~Yf*.f(!'N., 'ol'
~~"i..i;.-~jol:>("'~}"!I''''l-'''~:' ~...'''... .r'.;'-.._.i....,.., . ,.:', ..' '. ..'" " '. . .~.tI'..~t.,...~ ~~/;:
.' ,.~;~~,:~{f;~~i~E~J.~~~;~::;:;\~;';~1k~~\:::;~~~\:~;;I:'~L,:':,,~.~~,,'\:>:::~.,,~,';i{\i:':~,':.> :~. ';~ ,', -"" '. .: " ,,',.. '. " ,',',' ';. ':",~:" c ,: "",: ;':.. .', ~ J,'~, " ,'~'
f..':-<".t,.s.......~.."". ~.~..
o
/'~ ;0' n'~'
, ..
applicant to submit a site plan of the church showing the location of the outdoor play area. The
applicant submitted 3 plan showing limited possibilities for relocating the playground.
The applicant. Douglas Langholz. 7 Clearview Drive, Safety Harbor. Pastor of Grace Lutheran
Church. apologized for the oversight ,,,-'hereby an occupational license had not been obtained for the
day care center. Explaining the site plan, he said the present sile was chosen in consideration of the
safety of the children. '
In the ensuing discussion, questions were raised relative 10 alternative locations bordering Joel Lane
on the east and Highland Avenue on the south side of the propeny. Doubt was expressed that the
alternate locations, with fences and trees, would be a danger to the children.
Speaking in support of the application. Wendell Davis, 1475 Otten Street. Clearwater. said his
property is on the south side of the church grounds and he was unaware of excess noise from
children playing.
Gary Johnson, 2058 Timber Lane, Clearwater, speaking in suppon of the application, said his three-
year old twins attend the day school and presented a petition signed by 54 parents in support of the
, present location of the play area. He also offered information from MPO concerning traffic on
Highland Avenue. Responding to a question from the Board, Mr. Johnson said to the best of his
knowledge none ofthe other persons signing the petition lived in the area bordering the playground.
. : ~ .
,Also in support, Alan Jones. 1368 Fairfield Drive. Clearwater, echoed previous sentiments and
mentioned safetY hazards and automobile exhaust.
,:' Speaking in opposition. John Brown, 1448 Bentley Street, Cleanvater, said his property borders the
'." ' ,', playground areaand presented photographs of possible alternate sites. He located the proposed sites
'~, ;::-,<, : " ,'" 'on the site pl~m and said they were equally desirable for playground use. He noted absence of toilet
r,;':;::':,; 'i:' 'facili~es near the present playground, adding in order to reach toilet facilities, the children presently
:;;): ::: ,':, ,,: ,: :, cross two driveways. His inspection of five day schools revealed playgrounds were located directly
{):,::... ':/;': against the church or day school facility. He asked what the regulations were. how decisions are
:::/,,\:, .,,','; , , r~ached as 10 location of this type of use, and how much space is required per child. He said the
i/,~::',::, .,', . ", ',playground abutting his propeny is located three times as far from the church as from his house and
C::':>,:':: .. '.", ' , ; felt he ~as unjustifiably subjected to the excessive noise nuisance on a daily basis. He and his
;J'~:": "":,, ,', '; 'retired neighbors purchased their homes because of the quiet location and he fears further
~I:',',<: ..',;, , devaluation of his propeny's value.
.', .'
:~::.:..;.: . L: ..
',."., . I .
~~. I,~: ,,' , .'.
)'," .
.,. (: ~ .1'
\.;.',:;:. t
, ..
[".:' ,.
;/-. /". I: .: .
., '. .l. .
~ .. ':':-. .
. '. .
,:;",~"
:....~~
;..: ~, ,
." >
:::.5: ~ .<'~ .'. '
. '..... "
,:::',':,,: "",
, It was asked that the record state an additional person was present in opposition to the application.
,butdid not speak.
At this point. Architect Rod Coleman, 54 Valencia Drive, Dunedin. a member of Grace Church.
spoke in suppon of the application. He explained the driveways mentioned were low-use. and
minPZOlu.95
2
0] 110/95
r': ..f, '.
.l <. ~ .
.~ ~ .I ~~",
.~; ".:, .", .. ., u,. .....Ii. . .io,. .", ..','. - ~''I, ..,I1...'....p.~ '\-.~..~.>y;.i,.of~..."'1~,~-:....,,,',.."l;~.\1)(. "1". '~.tf~~' .~." "~'i~:~
~npWfWl1tl-~ : 1 . . '.".- ~.~~' ::to:,: r. .J~~.~i~~~-t 1r~*)jl~j(4~it~.~:s.{rJ;;.~(~';~~.~~~~~f~:;~i~~.~r~:.::~.5l~~~~~i.:~~i;$1\!-:.~!~.l(.;!l~~;itSf:~A~{:.;~~~."f~:-.~.i~~~\4~~.~:,~ ~~~.,~t
;:~~;;i ~~,"\r4,~/,~4.1:..;I:.,~, t' .'" ..~.T .j.. .' ::- I ..~I. c' L C. .. ~. .c ....." I ." <. . . -
.r" ...r....
'} described alternate areas, indicating they were less desireable for the church. Funher discussion
revealed the Board deemed several alternative sites appropriate,
- ,
.1,'.
", '
';i.'C)
, , ,
. ,
, ,
. ~ .':
. " .
1\".::- ',. :"
Responding to B question from the Board, Sue Steiner. 2220 St. Charles Drive, Clearwater. said 90
square feet per child-in~use is required for cenification by the Pinellas County License Board. There
are a total of 42 children in the school~ however. she stated the maximum use of the playground is
only 16 children at a time. The present playground site is 4.900 square feet in size. It was noted that
the 16 children would require only 1.500 square feet of play area.
Rebutting, Mr. Langholz said the neighborhood is changing from retired to younger families and the
playground contributes to the area.
In the closing discussion it was agreed that a six fOOl fence and landscape buffering would not
adequately cushion the noise 3t the present location and t~le playground should be moved,
Motion was made by Ms. Nixon to nppl"ovc the request subject to staff coordinating with the
applicant a change in location of the playground to the northeast section bounded by Joel Lane and
Highland Avenue. and the following conditions: I) The applicant shall obtain the requisite
occupational license within six months from the date of this public hearing; 2) the outdoor play area
shall not be used before 9:00 a.m. or after 7:00 p.m.~ and 3) appropriate transponation impact fees
shall be paid prior to the issuance of the occupational license. The motion was duly seconded and
cnrried unanimously.
The following conditionn) use items were considered:
CL John K & Demetra Lainas (Smart Stop Mini Mart. lnc) to permit package sales of beer .
and wine (new license) at 1208 N. Ft H:lrrison Ave, Enghurst 2nd Addition. Lots 62 & 63,
, zoned CI (InflU Commercial). CU 95-01
l\'lr. Shuford gave the background of the application and presented. in wfltmg, the staff
reco.'mmendations, indicating this is a continuation of an existing use. He stressed the need for
perimeter landscaping on the western side of the property and the necessity of ensuring the adjacent
,. ' . arcade use is properly handled. There were no obj ections voiced by the Police Depal1ment.
The,Qwner, Demetra Lainas, ] 120 Carlton Road, Tarpon Springs. described the business and said
s~e is'selpng a beer and wine license to the applicant.
" ,
The appHcant, Jamala Qandil, 702 Bayside Boulevard. Oldsmar. said he leased the property from
M,s'..Lainas and paid $6,000 to the former owner for equipment on the premise. He said he has
considerable food market experience and has a very clean record. The owner has agreed to provide
. landscaping, and Mr. Qandil said he understands if the work is not completed, he will be
, " responsible. ,~
" "
t/'~ ' . 'minPZOlu.95
, .
" ,
~ . > I . "
\" T ~ ,
.....
, "
:.\
01110/95
.,' "f'. ~ ' ;-'::' .
. :,", ".-" c . .'
. .' '. ". '." ' '. :. . : ',.'. > . :. I'" ~ . . . .. ','., t" ... '~ '..: . I. . "....: "'. . '.. . .' :. :.' . '. .
."'"".,a..M.......~, -'.,.,.,,~..'I ....... .&..,
.'l There were no persons or documents presented in support orthe application.
A letter in opposition dated January) 0, 1995 from Kathy Milam, President of Old Clearwater Bay
Neighborhood Association, was presented in opposition. Bob Wright, 400 lsland \Vay, Clearwater, '
spoke in behalf of Kathy ~1ilam and read' her letter for the record,
~... .
. ,
....., '
~.1 , .
:..; <<
"
. ~ :.. .'. I,
~'~~~.'.." c
(llO.""
." ~,> . 'c : ..., ..'
'"~ i
:~"
..' 0
' ' c . ,
..-.. .
~. . ~
...;: '.
"
,\ . ~ 1,.'
'." "
./'. .
,;t(, '
\\~~ . ., ,
:".',: >:: ~ . "
:.'.:\. ,',
',~~ : '~ '
~)::;~:~: . ~ .' ,
.~. ',. >,'
~i:","" :
.'.... . .
~;.~::;c::~. <
.". ..,
: i,.,~ ':.!..
~}.~ "', ,. ',. .' ,
\:'>;.','~,'
~.":~.' 'J' .
:~'/: ;,~. ..r .~
:,-'..{:.,. ""
'''''.'f '.
:~:~::,:" , ',' '.'
,:~"'~r: ',~'
," 'i. '
c' ~:'.. . ' .:'
,+, h.
. '>' .
" .:-'
,.' .'
:""'0)'
,'.. .
~ , '
, ". .
c .l.' . .
,< .>:, <'
.. ~ ,
',::'..', c,
. In the ensuing discussion, underground sprinklers for the west side were suggested; however, it was
detennined that it would not be required for the trial period if the landscaping were maintained. It
was noted parking is grand fathered in. The arcade between the grocer)' store and pizza restaurant
does not have an occupational license or zoning approvals; the situation is being addressed by the
code enforcement process.
Motion was made by Mr. Keyes to npJ))'ove the request subject to the following conditions: I) The
requisite occupational license shall be obtained 'within sixty days from the date of this public
hearing; 2) the perimeter landscaping requirements of Section 42.27 shall be provided along the
western property line prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy or occupational license and
continuously maintained; 3) this approval shall 'be for a 4 month trial period, after which the
appli cation shall be reviewed 'for compliance with the established conditions of approval; 4) the
parking lot shall be re-striped and a parking space provided for the handicapped within 60 days; and
, 5) the hours of operation are weekdays. 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.; and weekends, 8:00 a.m. to 10:00
. p~m.' The motion was duly seconded and upon the vote being taken, Chairman Carassas, Ms. Nixon.
,Mr. Mazur, Mr. Keyes and Mr. Merriam voted Uaye'\ Mr. Bickerstaffe voted lInayll. Motion
c.'lrried (5-1).
, C2. Jonnthan & Janet 1\1.. Leonard (Duraseal Asphalt Sealing Co,) to permit a home
. occupational license with more than 3 employees at 2964 Hillcrest Cir N, Countrypark, Blk
D, Lot 12, zoned RS 6 (Residential Single Family), CU 95-02
"Mr. Shuford gave the background of the application and presented, in wntmg. the staff
recommendations. He indicated, the applicants' request is for a home occupation license and their
" " s,ix employees work in a Largo warehouse where all equipment is kept.
, ,
The applicant; Jon Leonard, 2964 Hillcreek Circle North, Clearwater, said he and his wife have had
, 'the business for eight years. He said business is conducted over the, telephone, and his wife does the
bookkeeping, The warehouse is not air-comitioned and mainly a construction yard.
, Mr. Shuford noted a conditional use permit is required if more than three persons are employed
away from the home, adding that home occupation requirements wil1 be addressed when code
'chapters are reviewed for modification this year.
There were no persons or documents in support of or opposition to the application.
minPZOln.95
4
01110/95
~~~~.li4'i..'''! .~'~~"'I-t,,..~~. u.....-..~ '~.~.<,\,t'~'t-..'I'."/ ,,,,".;""~,I .'....,. ,.,~""\ '.......;Y~.,.;... .......,.t ~,. "T"~''',;I.~n.';,1-. ~n~ r'c;. /,.'+b~.:"" ~,,"'~"':"1'~t;:';:\'t;"-~< -:--:.'"'i"'~~,~~. ~ .,',.- :,..i' ,':,' ~ l ;. .....:
-V'i~. T ~
1
'.C'
\". ..''iI
. .'"
;1,:": ,
.."\ c" .
'i
:,-,,: "(,
~ . ,"
. ..' .
.. .
..' I, . '.
:~. r.:~. . ,. . .'
.~',,". ~
":. ,,'
;;;"'1; . ,; ..
:"<'~'IJ' i, ': .
~~~<.:, :, '~
. ',. > c.
: . ~:.: ~ '.' ' c' .
.'~. "c: ",' c
';',;~'Ol": , '
" ,
'~ '. . t, .
, , '
.c.t.
'. .,
~. . .. . '
;, ~. . .:. c
.~'. . ' .... "
~. - . "'.' .'
. ,.... ." > .
Motion was made by Ms. Nixon to nppro\'t' the request subject to the following conditions: I) the
applicants shaH obtain the requisite occupational \icense within six months frolll the date of this
public hearing; 2) no sale or trading in merchandise shall be carried on frolll the propeny where the
home occupation is located; 3) the occupation shall not involve the use ofa commercial vehicle for
delivery of materials to and from the premises except for travel from the home occupation site to a
job location and to return; 4) no marked vehicle or equipment used in conjunction with the home
occupation shall be parked on the propeny; 5) no display of productSt operations, signs or
nameplates shall be visible from outside the dweUing,; and 6) the applicants shaH comply with aH
of the standards for all home occupations contained in Section 41. 161 (4) of the City Land
Development Code. The motion was duly seconded and cnrricd unanimously.
C3. E.G. Brndrord & Sons, JIlC to permit outdoor retail sales, display, and/or storage at III
S Belcher Rd. See 18-29-16, M&B 23.03. zoned CO (General Commercial), CU 95-03
Mr. Shuford indicated statT is requesting continuance due to absence of a satisfactory site plan.
The applicant did not attend the meeting. There were no other persons or documents in support of
or opposition to the application present.
Motion was made by Mr. Mazur to continue the request to the Januar)' 24. 1995 meeting. The
motion was duly seconded and cnrried unanimously.
n.e following nnnexnt,iont zoning, Land Use Pin.. Amendment. Lnnd Development Code Text
Amendment nnd Locnl Plnnning Agency Review items were considered:
Dl. 1947 West SJ<yJine Drivet Skyline GraveSt Lot J05 (C.M.L. Building Company lnc).
A '94~27; LUP 94~31
LUP: Residential Low
ZONE: RS~8 (Single Family Residential)
Mr. Shuford gave the background of the request and presented, in writing, the staff
recommendations~ indicating, annexation is requested to obtain City sewer service for a new single
, family home'. Staff recommends the Future Land Use Plan Classification of Residential Low and
, a zoning ofRS-8. ,
,Moti'on was made by Mr Mazur to recommend endorsement to the City Commission. The motion
, was duly seconded and cnrried unanimously.
D2. 24244 U.S. 19, (PnrtA-nnnexntion), Haas Sub, Lots 3-8, Blackburn Sub, part of Lot
. 3 and abutting right-of-way for Lawson Rd & Haas Ave. (Part B-zoning), Haas Sub. Lots
, 1~8, Blackburn Sub, part of LOl 3 and abutting right-or-way for Lawson Rd & Haas Ave,
(Ridge Haven Associntes, Ltd). A 94~28; LUP 94~32
LUP: I Commercial Retail
, . ZONE: cpn (Commercial Planned Development)
minPZOln.95
01110/95
5
.... . .
>.. - I
:~. ..:;. c . 'T . ~.
.' . ~ ..,. I ; .
~::,;,.>"','" , "'if" ::-:' ,'. '-'I!llU.; .,-, "'~'-,i,"'j",:,.,:.. !\.:.;;,:;;"':':"J,,j,'..,\~,',,' ,<,..,':...!'",..,:, ;.,:'..."'<c:;,';.~'.,','...,.",':;::,.,, ""'.;"".'< .,,:~..:,':", ,'::" '.:;::."~
~~S 'i~ ' ,',> ";' " ..; i ." "; ~~~~Q;"...~~!';#~~l)~~~,~);.:~,\\~it1!bitlk)~;r-Mi.~~.;}.i;':iliJ.'{i~~i':r:d.:'"'f;-.:;~liti~~L1J:>~~&'l1:.'.:i !:};:%t~~'j',l~"'::tit:(;: <.::~,~,~
t:'\~,\~i:~~f~~~V~~.Y~:'t~;.:~>;'.i: ':;:". ~ :<:' .~. . .' >":- ~,.T. .: ~. -.,.., '.. ,~ . c: . c.c .. . / " t' L .", 'tl , .I~.: :~) ~\,{l~f.'Mifi\~l~~:.';.~;t::i~~~~!~~;,.:{~~~ff,~.a~~.j~:~;~\:,:~~\..\i;~
~~~f~\~.~';':~ii~rt..~......q,..;.... ..'.:,.:..d"~ <' '.'~*('r~'-:~/'<*~;'<":' .:' ..... ". , . . .' ...... J', ,. '., h .'~". '.
. ..'.. . . . . . .' . . . . .... . . . '., , '. '.,., . ' . . : . . . ~ '....... " I . . ", .' . . : . .,.... '. I '" . . :: ..' .' J . ..h
..,......~1t..~~~~. . ..>...'. !
1)
'.,'~'
':~.
" ,
'>:Cl
Mr. Shuford gave the background of the request and presented, in writing, the staff recommen-
dations, indicating the subject is an existing mobile home park located between US 19 and Lawson
Road. '
At the request of the Chairman, the meeting recessed at 3:59 a.m., reconvening at 4:05 p.m.
Continuing, Mr. Shuford said the back two-thirds of the property is in the County, zoned commercial
with Countywide Future Land Use Plan Classification of Residential/Office/Retail. The front
portion of the property is in the City and has Highway Commercial zoning. The applicant requests
City services and negotiated development requirements with the City. He noted the specific
development requirements included in the application and added the site plan is compatible with
surrounding residential uses. Mr. Shuford stated the application is in accordance with Florida
Statute trailer park rezoning procedure requirements, and staff has worked with the City Attorney
in this regard.
Responding to a question from the Board, Mr. Shuford said impact fee credit will be given for
residential use of the property: Retail buildings will pay the difference between what their square
footage will generate and the residential use credit. .
Attorney Ed Armstrong of Johnson, Blakely, 911 Chestnut Street, ClealWater, represented the
applicant, Harrison Bennett, the developer and contract buyer. He explained the annexation and
zoning request. adding the present mobile home park use is a non-conforming use under the present
zoning. A significant number of meetings with City staff established development parameters and
produced the applicant's very detailed site plan. Mr. Armstrong indicated the applicant has fully
complied with FS eh 423, the Mobile Home Act. An impact statement will be delivered to the City
wnich wilt' show where the displaced residents are relocated. A total of 59 spaces of the total 66
spaces are presently owned by the developer.
. ,. Discussion ensued detailing lot rent, proper notification to residents, future or existing right~of~way,
alternate sign locations and setback from the south propeny line. Joe Kobicki, King Engineering,
, 24945 US Highway 19 North, Clearwater, clarified the location of the sign. The petition received
, at the time of the receipt and referral hearing by the City Commission was briefly discussed arid it
\Vas noted the Ridge Haven residents had little input into that petition.
There were no persoris or documents in support of or opposition to the application.
:Motion was made by Mr. Keyes to recommend endorsement to the City Commission subject to
,the foilowing conditions: 1) A fire hydrant assembly shall be installed n01 more than 300 ft. from
the 'structure~ 2) if structure requires or has installed an automatic fire sprinkler system, a Fire
Department connection shall be installed with a minimum of I s.ft. from the structure, adjacent to
a paved driveway and within 30ft, of a fire hydrant assembly~ 3) prior to certification, the Dumpster
Requirement Form must be completed and returned to the City Solid Waste Department~ 4) prior
minPZOlu.95
01110/95
6
"'. ~~....~.-.....-:...... ''''''''~' '.0- ...;..p............-:,. >,.....,...,j.:.,./....;. . ',,:- ..',.:;...~.'~~,.l'.:.:i:r::,~~...l~ :l..~....;~:".l:.:....:;....:.:....~,.~...[.~,'~.::.+:~~~;,;f:
......wv."'1T u " ' ' . ' , ~~<:1.'f.J~:1Jt~;4~')~;;;liN-M~t~a...:;tt"~,,>,.:,,:.!,,~;~.$'~~;r' <.:',!'/:~.:~b~i.t;:;,;: {;,!;H~~,~;;~;J:i:&~\t\;;~~~i@~~~~.{.',~. ~," '...'h> ':'''':.~;Vr(
'},;:>Y l.': :',:, , ::' ,', ", ...,,' ,,': '/~,' ,;. : ' ,,: ' ,,~, , l'I!;':"l"J~i'.;rM~~~ii~!>~&~~f~4~~~~~-i~~~~~(~~~'~.JI;';;:'~~~
{;~:~!.~~~;/~.:;~l:.~./?:.l~ri.:.....,.::.~ -; ..".Ct. :..c.1.:.>~1ti,M\":-;\.. .~.:c. ~'~'. .<. .. c.' .,' " . . > . . (, ...~, -.....~t,~ ...~. ." .. ~c" ...~ ~~,k~.
.......,.~ . H. ... I
r4
J
:'-c\
t.,c.,:" .'
" ,
,.. .'.
....
I"c . ~ ..... ~. > .' ,
,
" . '
"'0
..,
.=i~,: '.
..
"
~'.\ ~ .: :
~. ~. .
s~. ?~~,.. '
i{, '. ~
"
1'> '
.:~, . ,
~,~ ". c r ~
!{I: :j. .>< ,I;
...,i ~~ ~~:...
cl;-,': : ..... c
'c_,., c .
~.:.~ i-;'."
\<,:~":'~:' : '..
to certification, a copy of the SWFWMD permit application is to be provided to Engineering Site
Plan Review; 5) prior to issuance of a building permit, a copy of the approved S\VFWMD permit
is to be provided to Engineering Site Plan Review; 6) prior to cenification, the final site plan must
be signed and sealed by a Professional Engineer registered in the State of Florida; 7) a Pinellas
County Public Health Unit Permit, lngress/Egress and a lOft. utility easement over the proposed
water mains up to and including meters, backflow prevention devices and hydrants are required prior
to issuance of a building permit; 8) backflow prevention devices must be installed by the City with
applicable fees being paid by the owner; 9) an existing and proposed utilities are to be shown on the
site plan prior to certification; 10) prior to certification, plans are 'to show 50 ft. of adjacent
topography around perimeter of site; 11) sidewalks are required adjacent to all street rights~of~way,
and soaU be shown on the she plan; 12) handicap spaces must be adjusted to meet government
~dards; 13) parking and/or driveways (placement of wheel stops) and traffic sign placement shall
be approved by the Traffic Engineer and shown on the site plan; 14) dimensions to be,shown on the
plan shall denote measurements for aisles, parking staUs, entnmces, etc. 15) prior to issuance of a
building permit, a copy of the approved SWFWMD permit shall be submitted to Environmental
,Management; 16) signage should be as specified on the site plan; ) 7) the requisite building permits
must be procured within one (1) year from the date of certification of the final site plan and aU
, requisite certificates of occupancy must be obtained within three (3) years of the date of certification
, of the site plan~ ] 8) a Unity of Title' shall be recorded with Pinellas County Official Records prior
to issul;lnc~.of any building permit~ ) 9) all permitted uses and any approved conditional use permits
or variances for the Commercial Planned Development shall be listed on the final cenified site plan;
20) the applicant shall contact Parks & Recreation for the required recreationlopen~space assessment
fee,which shall be paid prior to certification of the site plan~ 21) FDOT approval of proposed access
to. U.S. 19 shall be obtained prior to second reading of the rezoning ordinance and approval of the
" final site plan. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously,
D3. 509 Bnyview Ave nnd 508 Meadow Lark Lnne, McMullen Bayview Sub, Tract A,
Blk 3, Lots 1 & 2 and south 1/2 ofright~of~way to the north, (R. Ro)' Mendor). Z 93-54;
LUP 93~43
LUP:
ZONE:
'From Residential Urban to Commercial General
From RS 6 (Single Family Residential) to CPD (Commercial Planned
Develoment)
{:',:;, ;:: < .. ,: TheBoard:~fHJdregsed-item D"3:-i1Hhe-t1rst- agenda Item tor co--nsraeration-:-:1V1f~ 'Shuford gave the
':.i:, ':: ": " ~ .. background of the application and presented, in writing, the staff recommendations. He indicated
r:t'>:",', : ,staff is ~ecommending continuarice based on environmental concerns which may affect the site plan
J '. ~
,',"~ ", , " ' and zoning issues.
~:,,::.~ ~.': ," :::
..... ,.
',' . ..
.','1'
......, >, . .
~..~)~ ..r
.. ,. \.
<,.
:. . ~
.<A'\
.~c'Y.1
" -;.; .-
;::::: c",
"
"",c, .
5:'" '. ~ ' .
" '
~d... . c
~. f I ~
'Attorney Harry Cline, representing the applicant, objected to the continuance. He said the issue was
':' , ,a",'reC;t henirig" and distorted the truth. He said minor contamination on the site has been on the ED!
, pJ:'ogram since'] 985 and is totally under control.
-.
minPZOln.95
OlllO/95
7
~0~'J :\' v " "' ,::;: ~'.;'/.' ;~~. c.... .,~'~~~~_~,{~$~:;";~:;,~t~.tl;l~\"'::~t~~J.t..<~.;..: '~,..: ....:~ ::.'~.i ~\ '".. ~..:.~ "~' .~,1I ,': " ~.: ;~> . .~. .~'.~ ,... : .,~~. :'-r'/:' < ~:.':l ..~: .~:.r ':.: "::;. ;:'~~ I :~.,"', ;. '~ '<' ~1~'::I'~~
::T;~{(i.~ ' ~~,~~/: . ~ :.: '.. >~.: ~ .'.1 I. '.. \..~ ".. I .'.. .~~~~"io~~~u~G:;7J~.?:;;'{~}}Pli')itJ~:r:;~~l::I}~~~,~ki;~~t\~, ~~'.~~~~~f11~.\"'~N;;~~~iJ/;J\'~~~~~i~~'..~/il~':;o~:~.,. ::.~~; ~~l"~J!?:~~:t!Y;~I~)t3:' i:.=~\; ~:~\ti~'}" ~ 1
'l~!~tr...~'t:f~,!' ...~ ~ :'~r ".., . ,', \. - I . .> .O~ ..... .' '. ' . .' ~~, f1;,-"'~'\. ".,N:-t.{\:.."',t}.t~,"~i.'i. r ,';r.l,d,~.-i~~;.~r'i~ ~ .1~~tf~~\fr~,~l'r';~:1J.~~~~~'_';".j~~j..~!:."l'~;~t,':{ ~ ~.
I )"-r. ~<",...' . "'1.' ~ c".".." ..... " ..,...."1. "..... \.)'f"t:":" , ?r~~ ~,..I.t~.{,...."~ro-/~..t\...r'''~'''''''j''''o-(i1:
tr;:~~~&/2~;t(1~:~<:i~":';:::'~';^'::\\:""'~"'~;\;"~':, ',,:.,' .. " . ': .. ' '.'.' """', ",r-,<, ":::', '~'''' a.~\ "'. ':"'~~"':'~'"'<' .\":.'
-
,~
...')
"0'
0' . .
'::' ..:;
.', .
. ~. "
" ..
..
. "..'
"0
:;. .'
. ' .
~.\" .
.',,' :
':/::
'>:::.: ;. ,~
""
.,. . c
C,.C,
A disruption of the meeting ensued from persons in opposition to the proposed planned development.
Mr. Allan Stowell. a leader of their opposition, refused to yield the podium despite instructions from
the Chairman to do so. Order was restored some time later. 1\10tiol1 was made by Mr. Bickerstaffe
to consider the. item as an agenda item. There was no second.
A Board member was accused by Mr. Stowell of conflict of interest which was emphati cally denied.
It was noted by a Board member that, historically. when a considerable number of persons wish to
speak on an issue, the Board allows them to speak if they are unable to attend a rescheduled meeting.
There was general consensus to continue the item to February 28. 1995 and hear those persons who
will not be able to attend on that date to speak.
In the ensuing discussion it was stated that, if the issue which created the delay had to do with
contamination of soil, there is a way to address contamination of soil, which would not change the
site plan; J\1r. Shuford disagreed. adding the site plan is essentially the zoning for the property. citing
certain conditions which mig.ht require relocation of the building. Concern was expressed that past
absences of signed. sealed. certified site plans has been problematic,
M:otion was made by Mr. Key'es to continue item D3 to February 28, 1995 providing the people in
attendance have an opportunity to speak if they are unable to attend that meeting, The motion was
.duly seconded and upon the vote being taken. Chairman Carassas. Ms. Nixon. Mr. Keyes and Mr.
Merriam voted II aye II; Mr. Bickerstaffe ~nd Mr. Mazur voted "nay". l\1otion carried (4-2).
The Board recessed at 2:33 p.m.) reconvening at 2:43 p.m.
. Following a brief discussion. it was suggested that those persons wishing to be speak on item D3
would be heard later in the meeting in agenda order so that other applicants would not be further
delayed. Motion was made by Mr. Bickerstaffe to hear comments relative to item D3 in proper
,agenda order. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
At 4 :25 p.m. Chairman Carassas summarized the Board's actions relative to item D3 earlier in the
meeting and said, as a courtesy, the Board would hear those persons who wished to speak on this
issue. He stated that it was necessary to"vacate the meeting room by 5:00 p.m. due to another
meeting scheduled; therefore, all speakers' presernations would be limited to three minutes. - ,
. Jack Alvord. 606 BayviewAvenue, Clearwater, was assured that he would be able to speak again at
the rescheduled hearing. He addressed the matter of gasoline on the property and cited his attendance
, , at past meetings. He questioned past continuance decisions.
Michael'SandersJ 411 Orangeview Avenue. Clearwater. said he was a member of the 1980
architecturaVsurvey team which prepared Florida site master files on the Bayview property. In his
opinion, the subject house. one of the oldest homes in Clearwater. is historically significant. He
opposed rezoning, adding the cpn zoning is addressing the buffer of trees and the retention pond.
a.nd overlooks the houses. In his opinion. moving historic houses is impractical and unrealistic,
minPZOln.95
01110/95
8
, .
~~~:,:~:,::,:; ~ ~" '. ..~IloAlii.~~~,'&~'~ii;'/'~}A i.A~,i:f.i;,,~,')(~\\~~.t~\:;~;;;:k'!:~<~;,~V+J'i :,:~\.:~'~~,.;,~~,;;~-,::~;tj:;'J.;..\~j:~,i;:~~.),~,'..~,;~,+.~;:~.y~;,~:.,::, I,:\\~~~.
Earley Sorenson, 517 Bayview Avenue. Clearwater, indicated his mother and grandmother were
present, and all oppose rezoning. He expressed concerns that the commercial zoning to the property
line will destroy his propeny and described his unsuccessful eOons to reach an amicable agreement
with the applicant. '
,..."'.,..~~~" ........ i .. .,.. ~ ... ..'~' . ."
o
'--
, ,
: ",' .
:"~ :; . e ~
!,,:"O
'i,.
,,, , .
"."
'. "
~ " .
........
. J. '
, "
':';-:,.'" ,'.. ,"
, . ~ > .
,'., . '-
. '. .
, ,
;<'~:,' .
":.~:- " > ."'
.; " .
,I. ~.;". ~ .
.".w.. \, ", .
",:. : c .~., .'
.: <~. ~.~ .
~} ~J.:: . " ,
.....
. 'I'
::/0"
(_. I
~.' .' .' .
Y/..',', .
1"" '<
":',. '.~' . >'
.~ y .- ;. ~ " . I
~: ~:Ij' >. '
Barbara McMullen-Sartor spoke in opposition. She said the property at 517 Bayview Avenue,
Clearwater. presently owned by her mother, will eventually be hers. She recalled McMullen family
gatherings at the home. Gulf-to-Bay traffic and noise will be aggrevated by the proposed car wash,
parking and additional pollution, She expressed the family's desire to keep the home and trees intact
for future family gatherings.
Mary McMullen also spoke in opposition. She said she would not want a car wash in the bach.)'ard
of her home, and asked for help to see that,this did not happen.
Allan Stowell, 2873 Thornton Road, Clearwater, identHied himself as a neighbor and cousin, and
said his subdivision was part of the historic town ofBayview. He quoted passages from the History
ofBayview previously distributed to Board members and askeo that staff provide the Board with
additional historical inventory' of Bayview. Mr. Stowell said he was aware of stafl's recommen-
dation for continuance today, but was unsure whether the applicant would want to proceed.
There were no other persons to speak, no further discussion and no other documents in support of
or opposition to the application.
D4. Ordinance No. 5720-94 of the City of Clearwater, Florida, relating to the Land
Development Code; amending Section 4] .053, Code of Ordinances, to reduce the minimum
.. lot area requirement for manufacturing uses in the Infill Commercial Zoning District~
creating Section 42.36, Code of Ordinances,' to prohibit driveway access for nonresidential
uses across residential zoning districts~ providing an effective date.
.' Mr. ' Shuford gave the individual backgrounds of items D4, D5 and D6 and presented, in writing, the
staff'recommendations. There were no persons or documents in support of or opposition to the
,,' applications. Items D4, D5 and D6 were briefly discussed and voted upon individually.
'. Mf?tionwas made by Mr. Mazur to recommend cndoJ'sement of item D4 to the City Commission.
The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
DS. Ordinance No. 5740-94 of the City of Clearwater, Florida, relating to the Land
'Development Code; amending Section 4 1.17 r. Code of Ordinance. to revise requirements
for temporary commercial parking lot uses; providing an effective date.
, Mr. Shuford indicated staff opposed a IIrent-a-heaptl type operation and quoted the provision on p. 2
, relative to compatibility with surrounding land uses, Responding to a question from the Board, Mr.
Shuford indicated IItemporary" meant 90 days per calendar year,
minPZOln.95
9
01/10/95
.~.. .
~~W--~, ~ ,,::'7'7,-:~~~.~o'-,I~\;"~'li.tJ/.w-':l'i"
1.':.~" . ~ . ~'F''''' ,~'~"'.'.J- ".-' ....~. ~ J-'~'. .~.. .~I~,,-;,~r~,,,
~,....~., ~. " I..,.. ... , ~-Y-
'r~,\ M .
", J otlon was made by Mr. Keyes to recommend endorsement of item DS to the City Commission.
The motion was duly seconded and curried unanimously.
:::. .
~, '. ~
'.. .
.... .
:.,.;,', .
, >,"
Ie", .
~:':'Q..,'~
.. '.I >
, "
..;
\~ <.", .
....., .
" .
7 '.' .
. ".<
~. . .-
':~~, ;:~ ~ \' ~ .
;,
;' '~.,:.... . .' .
. .,,:~ .. . '. . '
. ..,', ..
,:t:.',:::>,:,
.:. ',. ~ .' ~ ,. +: "
:~.~~:,:'!' ,u:' .:,'
:. :.c'.\.
.~ ~ >..
I, .
'~i~~::.,~'< ~ .'~.
~_:.; ~'f:~'.:-~' ...
:..<" ,
"".:.1:1:,":'
~ ~ .}.. " . ,
r:"_ '~~.., . I
?t;~,,::., ..
j~'::":J i. .
'. ."<
r . ~ ~
,?:". ,
J .:,~ ' ,
" ','
':. '"": ~
:'."0'.."
~ ",.
. l . .
~:i.. . . .
" '\' .
+" .'
; > ~ .. . .
".
- I.. .
. .~. "
'. ~.' .
D6. Ordinance No. 5755~95 of the City of Clearwater, Florida, relating to the Land
Development Code; amending sections 40.356 and 40.404, Code of Ordinances, to provide
for outdoor retail sales, displays andlor storage in the Beach Commercial' and Reson
Commercial zoning districts as conditional uses; amending Section 41.053, Code of
Ordinances, to establish additional supplementary conditionnl use standards for outdoor
retail sales, displays, and/or storage; providing 'an effective date.
Motion was made by Mr. BickerstafT'e to recommend endorsement of item D6 to, the City
Commission. The moti.on was duly seconded and cnrricd unanimously.
The foJlowing Chnirm:m's items were considered:
Review of Rules llnd Procedures
Motion w~s made by Mr. Mr. E!ickerstaffe continue review of rules and procedures to the
January 2~; 1995 meeting. The motion was duly seconded and cllrried unanimously.
;Election of Officers
The Chairman accepted the resignation orMs. Manin due to personal obligations.
, Chairman Carassas expressed his pleasure to serve the Board and called for nominations for the
o~ces of Chair and Vice Chair. Motion was made by Mr. Mazur to nominate Dr, Merriam to serve
the Board as Cl}air; Dr. Merriam accepted the nomination. Mr. Bickerstaffe seconded and the
m~tion carried unanimously:
, M~tion was made by Mr. Carassas to nominate Mr. Keyes to serve the Board as Vice Chair; Mr.
Keyes accepted the nomination. Mr. Merriam seconded and the motion carried unanimously.
The following nre Director's items:
.. , Mr. Shuford offered Ms. Martin's letter of resignation. She wished the Board good luck and
. '.')
progress.
, Mr. Shuford revisited the controversial D3 item and pointed out th~t staff had met with persons in
,,', . opposition the day before the meeting and indicated they were aware the item would be continued
due to their concerns; and at that time they were in agreement with the continuance. He expressed
, his surprise at the vehemence of the arguments today and indicated he had not anticipated such
: contentious behavior.
'Mr.Shuford requested a work session at the close of the January 24, ]995 meeting to discuss site
" plan issues and the Board's needs and expectations regarding site plans, He noted that City Code
minPZOlu.95
JU
01110195
~~v --:-~~~'~-~~~~i~':"'~~l'1j.';f~{~-;~.i..}J.>~~'~~~~';~'.t~~l~<...~'r:':... :~~"~i',,;;.: 'I'<:.;:~~~ '::;~'..:.-.~.. ',. \' :..' ~:~:_ : .~,' "~ ::~,',',;' -.~~::~~~r'~~'~'~"'~I;..,.\I:~:.~::.:' 'f~.:<:t:,)"& ~.
".._ ",''''.'::>,.:, ,,',' ',.,;",' ' <kJ ,l"..x"'tif.1l\l~ii,'~}:;)ijt'~:;J.t'M~~~~i~l~~'t'"~:;fti~r~:~~~q~:~'!,}~);'''~;')I,:;t:''':~'~,l'\H\~3?~ir,,~},::.,h'f.f\..,r,~'~:h~' ,
::;,:(~':,;:: ':\ ,:",:' ;~, ,'..,' '. . , " ',..' , f,., "''t''~'lf'~;:,i'-..r,''':t1:~sJfr~;~~':'f.~g.~'$.\'!.~ ' "~'i.;'i.{;"~~~'''/''lp':l~~~~t~t.~~,
~~;~~~i,:i~}:,;'::;:~ },': :,:C'I:',;, ,; ',<,', ,.', ".",:,), ' "'" '" "" "" ..!:oi"~,,,,fi!~"?c' ii,' ',":'
j\/:\..'.., ...'.0
::.I.J~ r
". .
,
~ .. ( :
-: ,'.' ~
.; .
. ,., .
.,' r"
01 :',
.~~ ": < I. ..
:';',l
, '".
~ ,~.
.<' \ '."';~.'. .' ~ +
", ,~
. ~.. . .
~"""""'I,~:U..~-"''''_f.,!T"-'l''''','' .
'f ~.., ~. ,
",..". .
, ,
c.~: \;, .
S/:> . c
~,~~,~:r;?:\'" ::,' , ':, '
=tK;'. ~.; ..~ p~' ..
~:.., ....."d. C.. :.
'~'Ci::.. ~ ~ c: " : .
~;'~~r~A<!~ '. "
-W-'{)~~;T. I: .. ~ ..-
~qJn'~ :" ',: i:: :': ,': S COlt, Shuford .
"t1].;.'), ,,', ',' " '," " ", .', '.,
J.$~~'<C:;,~,;:--',' "..Direct~rt Central Per~itting
~;~~;~;~;:'" /q" ,,'
~",~"~I\: . 0( .. .".. .J ~ . < I ~
~~}:'-i~i.">/,~:"",;:, '~. :,::' :",
~..~""",""
:~!{1~>>" ,:,:' .'J',':. ',',
~~n. ". - /'~..' I .. I '
f!~f;tti"";~",, ...",..,','. .
~-.,. .l...". .. . ,'.. ,
~~!\"-LoI"~ .., .... . ... ~".
ri#i~t~;:. ~:\~ ~-: 1~,~.: ~~::'I~'::. < ,.' '.
{,tM"~' " ",.,'. , ,',.-
~~gJ?~::;':~'\: :Y:: ,><> , .> :-.' ,
~~'l... ~.-;.i.^... > "(1' I
~~~~.;; 1~:<.7\~~~.~:. ~ .:.. '~ . I .
If.! ~'{,--i 1'." .. i';' '.' .
g~j~,~,;,..}' J,," ~,' '.
i';~~~,s-""""", ,
'*'$~",,:' ,,'" .
(t;;(t."".~,:<" ,.... ", minPZOlll.95
tt~~p):.C';:,~ ,', ' " '
~. ~:11J~' ~:c\,,~"j:~ "., -: '
hatfti:~~~f(':'> ",:"
~:~J:~~'..~~,:r,;-:.:'..". '.~ . ... ,",
~'fi>!' ,~,L, : 0 '..' ','
~1~;i~'~;P,:' , '
~ . - 1U~~~~p.e,,). ~:,l t~~~ I r i'*:r;~:ttl i~ ~;i.~;:.~~..~ ~: ". .. ,'. ~.
\ ' '
,'0
" \ ~l J
- ~. ~
~! ~ .
.'
.:.~ .
'!. u
'. '
'"
::~: ~ '"
. IC';
~. . ,
~;;.;:.. .
"L~ ~.' +
~"o; ~'l .,'
~! ~/', .
conditional use requirements state DRC staff is nOllo review site plan unlil after the Planning and
Zoning Board has approved the conditional use.
The City Attorney will be invited to attend the next Board meeting. Mr. Shuford said Ms. Glatthorn
will be handling the scheduling of the Boardls tour of Central Permitting for any individual member
who desires to tour. ,
Mr. Shuford noted a minor scheduling change in the 1995 meeting schedule.
There being no further businesst the meeting adjourned at 5:07 p.m.
..
,Lj' ,
.....
":' .
,I
11
01110/95
"
'"
. ~ .....-;.: ~