Loading...
06/18/1986�� �����'q./••r����;,'i����:,,'i;�t�� ' , � . ' ' � i . ' � ,1� . , , � ' � ' . . � . . . ' , f • � ,��y ^W� i�����, :1 � ' . � ..F . , . � . 4� o-ry,,:y� � .5� .i�' ,'�...4� , r. ' ' . . ' . ' � � • ' . 4{{j{ � :�+,. �� `S" . � . � . ' � • j�,� f . . � i . � . � f. Y. � � � . � : r .' , . . . ' ' . , ' " � • . . . . . • . � !. • �. .' ; . I ! w e i , � ' , • } F�.• „. � � .. 1. . , ' . . � � ' . � ;�.�._;'... � :i. . � 1 .. , . , , � iIr' � � R . . r " . � • � • r , ' � 1 � 1 �' ' ' . • . i , • , � .. I rf �'•� ` '�' � � i!: .1�� � � ' `. ' � ' . � I • ' � , ., ' ' � . •' 'r . � . 1 • ' f <�il �.� • ' , ' I . �t� . I � 4 ' � . � . . II ..; ' ; � � ' ' . . �;'1 .±�.�''' . . � . :]' ... . � � � � .t r . . . , '. . ' . ) . . .e �1 j ` ' . . � � ! � ' • • ..�� y�t'` �� 1J ' t . ; •.. . t ' . • � . . . . � • 1r . � . , . . e ' 1 ' , r£� �,�f ����, . '�l� • � .. ... � 1' �. . " .. � i . !' .. . . . � . . , ' � � 'f � i7 � � . .f . . • ' . � • ' � � ' ' � � , . � �:��_�... . .., .. ::�:�' ... _. w . . .� .. .._� . _:�'. .� . .. � , _ . �;.. ... . ' . � .. . - �_ . . , . �, j � . '. . F '. ,` . � � ' �:�=a , , ,. , . . , E . , . � � . . , , � . . , , �, - . . �� , � � � ' ' ' ` �, , '. . . . � - . � .�� . . - � � . � � . . . . . , , , : ' .� ` .. � � � �. � � � � � ` � '. : . . , . , , ' , . . • , . ��� . . , � . , l�TUT� S . . .. . . : ,� ; � ,..�, , , .. . � -. . � . . ,� � . . . � . : . � - �. � � �,: ���� � ; . .. _. , �A . . . . . . ; .,,,... A. �_ . . . . . . ,. ., . , . . , . . .., ,., , . . , ;s. - �� .� � � - � � - � . � : . � �. . � ��� � � �� . . � �. � � � . � �. . UI�]�IT�T� � �'I..���I� , F "� . i � ' ' � . , � . . . 31 ' � .• , � � ' r � , I ' . r , . � � , 1 , ' r � . � ; ' DATE � � �,,, / ..,, � � . . � ,- � � .. , . , . � � � � � �- . � , . � , . . . ; � `��.�t..G�:.f,�,-�..r�,�. � 1 D� J . . . , . , • • T � . � � � , � � , � • . . ' ' . • . � , F . � ' . i � � e 1 , ' . . ` ' � ' � � � ' ' � � � � , ' � � � • � . ' i . . . . ' k . . . 1 � i ' ' � . 1 I ' ' ` 3 � � ♦ , � . ! � ' � i � . i ' . . ' ' ! '[ . r . � � ' � ' . . " . 1 ' . . � . f � � , � , ����' . . � . � � � . . . � ' '� ' ` �,!�; .'.ti' 3'� t i`.s.;dc.f,� .,�., j'A f`c',�} :�u� �.l'. _ :�.:. �fG •�i, .. . , ���'4�31'A�R,rr�,~ •i'• �i�' . . , ' .� � � ' . . . . � . ' . � ' � , t .. . , ,• � . )�� . � ' , �}7��''3 ;.#.. , :.1. , , . ` . ' � . • � t' � Y� � � 4�' '' ~ . J ' r � • ' . � . � . , , . . . . , . . e . 5 .1. `; . �ii , i r ' . : . . . • � , � . .. . , . . e ` ' , , � . � _ `,'.t ,,, i ''. . ' • . . . P I r � _ I , .a,``S,'� f``r`Ryy � � t '�r . . � . . � � . , , � [ S ! ` r'.' �. Cr•.<< . . � . � . . ' ' ,. .. � � � . . ' � . . . .S'}}: .,+• . . � . . , '� '. . . . ' . . , ' i� , ' ' , , . .� � , ' ' ' ' . . �tr ',, '4 � ,.'� '3� .• � �� . � ,. .� ' . '. � , . " • . ' . . 'f � � t . . , � I . ' ! , ^ . `x2�i {� . , . r . I . . . , '1 r . . , . : ?f••'�.; ;,.f ' � . . ' f , IY . . r . . , ' ' . ' . , • . ° l 7'r�7 �$ " 1 . . i . 1 '' 1 ' � � ' . . •, + . ,' r ' � �. '�dr� `4� i s . ' ' S . � ` ' . ' " � � . ' . r . . . ' �' •.l� 'i� � 4a�� ' ,+ i � , . � � ' x � � � t . . . . . . • � . � . . . ' � . , �S/;-�; i'" ' i .1. . ' � 1 . . . ' ' ' � � . . , �� 'd.,E,� � :: �. , , . .. , , i., ' _ . . . � ' ' � . , ' . . ' , , : ' • �.�fT' : ��{•.i: �•:: s,' . � .", `'� : f . . . � . � • � � . ' � � . . � � ' � ' ' ' ' �iri Xa.�...� �. - '.t � . ,,�t. . ,. . ., _, ,''��a.o `, , , _ . . .. . . . . • . . . ` , � . . . ' . " . . � . . . . , , e - ' . . .. ���Li � . . ' � � ' ' . . � . �x ' a - � ' , . ' ; , ; , � non�tn, oF ����rsz�M�r�� & �i�p�nt� , . _, ' , � � . . , � � , ' BuzLnzr�c/r�do� � coNmROL . . . . . ° . ' � , . . , , . . . . . � . . .. �,� . : Wednesday, �une 18, 1986 , � � . , . . . . � � , � �� , , ' � , , , . , , � - I�CT�ON AG�NDA - . , , , ACTZON ' ' � 1. Pub�i,c i[earinys � ' . £ � �� . . , , . , � �a) - 530 Mandalay Avenue� LaSa1. Mo�e]. - requesting ,Denied .�• vaza.ance irom Standard I3ui�.d�.ng Codc .Section � . .� ,� � � ' '+ , ].�13�.3 �o ,�aermit insta].la�ion o� outside ' , . � spiacal. stairway. (i�iammond) � ' � , • (b) I.7'67-3.771. Leo Lane, Leo Lane t�paar�ments, request- , i� ' a.ng� variance trom Standard Sui.Iding Code for :.i.n- � , . s�alla�ion of wire glass/a].uininum�iram�d wiridows �. . 10.1 f�. L-ram property line. (3M� Znvestmen�s) ` Granted .,.,,�',�- � ,. , . , . . �{c) . 1198 Manda].ay riai.n�, E. R. Hun�e� residencef re- , . � , . ques�ing variance Erom i'edera�. 'i"1,aod Regulat,a.ons° � ° �� . . � . `� � to permi� consi:a:uc�ion a£ garac�c/storage areas . . . . ' � � w��h bre�k--away wa1�.s' below �1ood ��ve].. � . • � . � (�dwin R, Ifunter) • � ; ' Gran�ed . � ° � � "(d) 7J.5 S. Gul�view B1vd; iii]..ton !-to�el, requesting � � � . � vazi.ance irom Coastal Consiruction Code, Chap�er � ', ', . ' . , 39, �o ex�end exis�:ing removable wooden deak 14.6 _ : . � i't. in�o 18 �t. seawa].t se�k�ack area. (Lane ,� . Indu's�ries}. , .' � - � Granted� � f � ' , •" , . � ' 2. rSeeting ad�ourned 3:25, �. m. � ' - , , .. . . ,' . � , ' ' � , ' . ,� � ' , � , , ` ; , ' � � � � � � ' �. ' . . � � f �' '. . � , , , , - , . ' , � , , � ' , . . .' . ` . '. ` � � � , , . , � , . I � . ♦ . . . ' . . � !� � � ' � , . � .. i � .. , ' � 1 � . � � . . � . . . ' . ' ! � ' '. . , ' ' � ,, . . i . '1 ' . � • � ' . . . ' � ' � ' • t.r. . ' .! R 1 . • .• � � , c , � ' __'� _ _ '�`i^��ir, �.1�'>!�!i`�'l:}�.'�� . t. . � 1: . . r � r . . i - J ; � t•�:�.�.`c��.f.�'a��'•.��'�03,° A%' . , , . .. . . : • . . , ` , . ; ' � ' 1 . , , � . . . . 'r . . . �:`��F�a�y'w',r• �� •.^.k ; . ' ' • . ' .' . � j .i . �Te� ; �. • \ . � ` � '��� • ��.` � ' .1 � � ' , ' ' � 5 : . . ' ' . . � ' ' � ' , � . � F ' ' ' , � � � }. ' ' • � � 1� . . ' ' . . � , ' � , � • .�`5;�, . Yr.�. .�.A.. . ' �l � . � . , . , ' � . ' ` ' ' , ` " a{.S:F.. ; 1 . !. . 15 i, , f .' � . . � .v . . ' ' � , • ` � f ' ' . 1 `6���'`•• �j' .1��� ' 1 , �1 � ,, � . . ' f . ' � ` '' ' , ' „ � . '' .' ` . T.�7�`1 " .f' A/.s� . ' '. . . .. � . . . . , . . , r , � � _ {'^,,�1;, ' . . , � ' �,•....'r . ' .. � . � . . . . . � � � ' . ' .� ' . : $��. . r � . . . . , � i� ., :. j' 'I. . ' . . , . , i . ., � � , 1 . �� �^'j. ' 3" 4 $ : :y � � 1 , � ' ! � � . . � . ' � . . , r � , ' . , f�s ��C.��'� t . . . , . . i ' . ' 3 + ' '� 7 . , � 4 ' � . . • � �,"l ��1 ' . �. � � , � E . . � � � . . � F � � , � . `.�} � �' r ;I, ' ' . , . ' �� , �. ' „ ' . . " � � � • 5 � " t � . . ��+f,, �t�,'i ��t 1. `'`1 ��� + ' �' ` , 1 . ( � . j �. , � ' . . , , i + . �. . . . � . � . 6 . ,. '`� , _ ..,..�i.�'..�ii.1.4'�.�.r�6.., ,_.'i:��x- ....'L.�.. ..�... � . . o .. . . � . ' . �:��.SiA � . ..� ' �� r r � �a • � ! � , r�u�+t�n a� nr�,��.,r.r,irw�,r r. �� �a�nr.� , � �u�r����t�c/���,oc:ra cor���:a� , � . . ° , . j � ' t•Fec'file,day, Jt�tic 1.£:,- 19E3G ' . � ' ' . , . ' , � 2 p-m, ` ' . ��ic�nber.� flxe��cnt: � . ! • . ,t�lc�m�c�r .��bs�n�: ' , . ' , �_" .f . John .Log�n, Gizairn�atti • . � , ' , �.c��•:arc'� Sa�i3.k��: . . . , ,Tc�se�ah S'�xa�sf�, � . 1i�11k at. Je�r� , . • I�sid.rew t�i.chol,�on (Arrivcd I :3q p. n�. ) � ' � � . . Ar.drew i3'. qtiui:ci:, 1lcting �oaru Secrei:azy ' ; � ' ' � � 71�.so pLeseni.: � � . ' , . ` , , ' llavi.d Chzis�:i.ans,etl - Ch�.e.£ a� T.��S�JCCLl.R315 � � � Jef� Danie3.s - L'.i.r� 1]e�a�rtmesil: , . � � '. .� • , , � , . . ,. � ' . ° � �Chai.zman� Lbgt'�n ca].led the meet�ia�g L-a orrlat a� .I_ ��. tn. I'oui: cases �a be . � n {X ul X'a , � � . � . . . � • � ' ' � � � � � � � I. . � � � , i>: i', . . . . � , - , f- . , r ' � � � , � . . . - _ �:•:) ,ti�'�nci�l�y Avc:ttuc; LaSa�. tdnL-e� - i-er�u���Li�1g v�t��'i.:.ince �za:n �.i�c SL•andarci , � . �,Iiuil.da.r�� Ca�e�. Sea��o�n 11�3.3 �o' �:1.3.a�a in5tx-�17.a-�a.o�t �o�. �zn ot�t-;ic3'� s��iral. ; •` st,a'irway. Repr�sen�.i.ng L15a,1 Alo�e�. �ai� i:3�e !h'e,�z.i.n�,� wex.e� Ales;s3-s. °.3�t�mond; ' �� ' awnex� -..�ohn �Sommeis,� Contzaci:o�. � Chuck� �otnmers anci t;lmn ��y3.o�,� p�:o�eci: -�, �. superii�t�i�denL-,' - and i��rry iJ13.man, azLh�.�:cct. Ma:�.� U3..lm��i dcscr,zt��d� th� ' pza��c�: .and renovaL•ion.; oi .�h� mote3. atid rar�vi.s�d 4�h� s���.ra7. stai�;case w�1s� � � , sitowri o.tt t��e oa:igi.nal ��.ans and..w7s ��t'.z�3ciy z�� ;��.acc. ' ��a:� .i,iiyE�c�tia�i, � �he' ean�r�zctnz wK�ts 'a�vi.�ecj by t3�e iilsp�ci.rrz th<'�� �iie i.rcr�c3 wic9klSS and riser, , , hea.glii:s dici n�af: con.iorm ta cacle.� PLapc'r_ corr�ci:a_c�ns u�ci � m�7c�e ar�c1 upan ap- . . p].ying' �or� a cczL-�£ica�c� o� r3CCLik]cci1C�'� co�ztracl:ox' �a7;: .�n�`carmcc� that t11c� . sta�.rV�ay 4TOU�.C.� ��ave �o t�e.'icraovecl�c:nt»irel.y ��s ����3:�I. st�t�i_, wcr.,e noi: ��er- ' , ma.tt�d �.n �a car��mer_cxal �s�ablxsl►;tican��. 7:�. vT�s ��n�.cd �a.�.sn,.L-�7��t a.r.��inakzng � � , �i�c riscr anc� �re<�d ca��:�c�ians, the hea8rc�r�i� �•��,:� m�ide lown� t}zan. rc��uire�l Uy Coc�e . • ' " , ' � . � .. , �+7r. i-I�zinrn�nd, cr�•rrez a�', i,aSa:�, at�Ztec� ilc �ci.i,rl not a.ntcz�Lei: i;i1c� cn�ie a:; pr,o- , ' hibiti.ttr,� i:hc; tisc o� ,pa:::al sL�i�� ,iri l�is �r.�j�:ct,. t�t1. . Sc�mmer,s, can�rac4or., ', `� furtiz'�r �bj�ci;�d i�n Lhe ta.m�ing o� Lt7e 3�ui.l.dii�g U�paxi:mcnk:.' .� nni��.cc: L•1ia1: Ehe ��taixs w��u7.c1 not be �.t�.awec3 and a:oui.cl l,�ave �o Ur �:emo�ccl, c�i:KYta.ng �hcdX �tirez� �� ', shaUrn c�n L-lie a�ig�.na1. p�.�'zns, wezc �.n,�i:a�.?eci, L�end pra�e� cozrecL•ians made ' ai: in�i:.rcict.ic�ns oi: t3ze �.nspect�ox. I�Ir. 5ommer:, �ii:.-th�r ac��ris�ci ��:at L•t�e ,� � , � �ieaciroom nro���.em Gc�u1.c3 x cac�a.ly �e Goa'�: ec kcc, . � . . ' . � . . . � , ,, . . , � Ni� ., Chr�,sta.arzsen � Cj11.Ci o� '�n:',pect5.ons ,� s�:af:�ci �13e coc�e is sp�:c:x£ic ' in � �, � acive.rinc; s�tzuGtu��� ���ZC�e si�i.r.al. ytc�I.ZC:1S�a 3re acee�l-.a�:�e a:ic:l �.�� �i��. ��r7s. . i:jie it��en� ���� t��e cociG �o all4�r stz�:�� irt��a�.�.at�,ons �.n cami��xc;�i��� bux3.d,ings, . this wp�zl.d hat=e bcen cle�-�xly sp4c:��zeci xs1 the cc�c�,e: '�1�� 3uil.cl.ing De�ar.L•- � men�'; a.iii:erp�:���-tL•i.c�n of the, co��� i��u been. ver:iii,e� l��r SatiLhe�xn 13uiZding , � . COdc7 'CaI�gY'CS..�3, ' . ' � � � - ' , � . , . '� Tt w�� �ur�i7er b�c�u'c�11t aut tliat t�tra c�,L-h�� s�a5,zw�ys are �.ti ����ce �ro1 exi.t-- � iny w�i�.cti n7ce� codc rec�ua.re�nenf:u' �tnci,tl�is s�t�:a� stairc�sc i� noi: �t re- • � qui.reyneni� �at� i.fl].S �zo�eci;. .t�3�:. Chr.�.:�l:ianse�i si:a�cd �.ri de,cez�:iing .�:hc�e �. s�'siral stai.x�� ai�c can ei:i.mas�, �tc� c�vcr �whe _31��ndr�t�.�. m,nk�.z3r} it�,t�t�t e:;�zt�mel.y ' �. hazaxcious c:si�. `S']f,is ��lns con�izmcu by .7e�i' Ua��icls ;ti�ho sL-rsf:ed .�th�L' i� the �, � . . � 'variaytee s•��-�a �-�r�n�ec1 � tlrte E�'i�:e l��:�sari:ene,i,t� ��rcau�.d �rc:qua.r.e acldi.�iosiaZ ��e�cinc� 1. � axt;ltougl� �hc: st��.xs wau�.d sii�.I na�: r:ot7!'uxt�t i:o't13c: L�.f:c� Satety Codn: ' , �. • • , , ° , ,. � . , , . � . ,.. , , . . �� , �� , . , < � �i���`�:, . �.� . . . .�_ r .:.. � :. �. ..,; . ., , . � . - ' . .....n.«..:.a�........ .:,."' . ' ' � ' , • • • .. .. c. i1: '.e„� . : t :'.�.r,.`�', t"i 1- � � ;'i.. �. .r,'e 1, F� � . r�. �. .. ' . s . ._. _.._ fq�I��'.:;j�V�;`Lj�'.ti�'� M��., : y . ' , . . � . , . ' . . . . . . . . ' . , , . ! _ ' ' • . } ' . sk .�`��� .•���� � � i r .. � . � � � ' . ' . .. i . YF ., � .. . . ' 1 ' , . � ' / . • � � � . . , 1 ' � . . f . ' . • . � i � 5 � � . , . '! . ; • . 1 � f ' I ' . , . � � I ' ' ! , � � � � � 1'i . . � � � . i . '�•�t' � 1 ' . . �+ ° , ` ' Y I ' ` ' . , , . ' , 1 , ' ' • ' i ��;`''7 .•,t, 4 ' , . . � • : .. . , i � r � . . , � .' ..�.i ; ,'y. , . � � , ,. . � , . ; _ , � h�,�'1.. . .� .�. . � ` •� . '' ..��! .i � . . . � , ' . • '. . . , .� � � . 1 ' . , . '. . '�� . ! . ` .� . . � ' . ' ,. , . , ' , , . . . , . � �. � '� . . , �! { . � , � ' . ;' . , , . . . � , . . , , . �' " , ` . ' . • . , . � . � , - , . . � . • . . ', . , . �t�l.'n::`,.. ,:"' ,'..'.... � � ' •''r .�,,,.� � ' . ' . ' ' " . � , � �a , [i-. �d� ....+�� . ..1� , . . . .. . � � �.._.i.s , " � . � � , , � i ' . . ' , , , ' �7� �s i . , � U�!]!1 ' �' � , - . � ' ' . • , • ' . •13u�.�.�ciiiic�/T'l;ooc'i L'onCzol. , . . . , . � '; , 3une �l�i, .l9EiG � , . , , - � , , � . .' . Th� �coni:rraci:��: ancl F!'r.njec� �u��c,t.inl:.�nd�t�� yL-�t:od f:]t�1L•. �iti mc���a,nr�s with ; . �o�:mcr da.�ec:f:r��: Ld�rard BL?�.I1L'�..,�'1G' h���i znclicaL-ed t1��iL� L�hr�:,t? .�3�.t.z:L�l- st:��.�s taer.f� acce�t��,l�la. R�coLCis �.n' the bui::3.ci�.ny cirJ��-tz t;n�eri� .�}zaal �+�lt��� �e 'con- . di�zona�. ce�:i:i�ica�e o�' ,nccu}�ar►cy �vas a.,;;tiec� on i1�sr.i1, 7.5, ]�:i�G �1nd� � Iette�' � waa �ciit tn L1zc con�i:racL•az ,i�y Ldwax'c3 i3c�;ic1 ��r�v:i��.nc� �h�t�'bc;Eaa:c: a�a.i�a�. Ca cou�.c3 bc is�azec�, Lhe ,p�.r��. si:aa.zc���}� wou:l.d ]ti�ve �o l�e rem�,.�vccl. Atr, Lcscfati ; � rcm�rkccT �thai: .ii: Ur�u' i�n�oxtuna�:c i�h�: conL•�:�-�c-�or w�s not ��dvzsec� t17e's�7xx'z�. _ si:air��a,y w���� na� accepL•�tla�.c pr.ior �.c� in::;i,;�3,].a�.ian <�tnc�i n,�iar t.� khe cor- ' � recL-i.ons i:h�L- �,�ere mac��. „ t�lx. Fa���r:in �r�J:eci �ar ��uoLin�1; � inot.i.at� m�-�c�e hy � liank 5i:. Jean. � ' , . � . . . 19Q�'IOPI:�� Lvith �ega�c� ��a the � rGque��� �o� �t *raxitznce ; xc�.�n tl�c f3ui1c1z�zg Coc3�, Sectioit i�.i�.3, �'o� a struc�u�e Xoc�t.ec� �tt 53� !•i�nda�.a;r 11Vesiu��, thc i3oar,d �'inds ii: �o k�c' wi�hin ii:s aui:ltiar�.t�� L-o aci� up,on Lhc r'rc�u� ,� ]auL• dertie:; , , �he �variance b�sed upon {.he �03,7.o�,.i.n�c i:tte �cac�c:� -� :.,�.�c: ���sfc:Ly anc� t�he - . �iuilding Codc - .ar� qui.i:e .c�.e��r 'itt i:l��.�i� �:1;e� u�e � oa: �i�c :;L�,i.z: il:�. 5t1041f1 0» , i:lie �].ans r�ae� .noi� �ne�t tlie. in�e�ii: c�f� �iir. ca�3e., ' , ' � . . .� � f • . ` ' Tiai�xoti secoricic:c�, ia�� t�iz'. . St,�au3��. � . � � , � � ' � : � � . . , ' P�3o�xott amended k�y I1n'cly �3icho}.son �n�sti�iul�x�c �ht�t thc� :;nir.,�c1. �L-aa.rwa�� 'a.s . �.<. ...�oi: .rc��ui,�:ed.. as ad�c�ua{�;c ��ai�:s' a�c k��ovicied el. ,�����t�c�i:�. c:nrI z3ci a��t�dsh:�p pre- .' . . vci1.7.�a. , ., , � , � , ; , � , . , , t4ai:�,o�t a� ;�m�nded seconc�ea and c��-ric�l ui�a�r5,mou:;.�.y. V�7:3.�i�lce ciGt�a.ec�. . �• x767-].77�. i�ea.Lanc�, E,eo T,anc �ipa�:�menL-:.;. -- �:ec��u�s{:iI1C� e4 v�r.i�ince f:rori Lhe . . S�an'd�t�:d i3uiZrlang Code to al.low .:i,nstal���t�r��� �,� v,i.r� c�].ri:; ,�r�.�d�ti•rs wa.th a].umiriinum �rames iU.3. f�.� .�rom �xaper�}� .la.ne. rtiuhaic3 D. 'i�rit:�u•, I���tii- � . . �ec�, re��:eseni:ec� .the a�•rf�ers, '3AI �r�vc:',L•m����u. t•7ire �yl�_:s5,c1.�.L1[R3.I711t�1 �x.�med � , . windows are a�.ready in �pJ.�c:�. : Stzuck:u�:e .i�� ].0.1. tt.. �a-ort �zo�a�:i:y 1ine; , _ � eade xequa.res �te�1 f:ra�ne�, because n� li�.��ier �:esisranc:r: ta kic�►t�, rr,ttsf: bc , .. `uaed an si:.ruCt�zr�s ,�,ri�:i�i:t I5 F�. u� a pze��e�L.;� �lin�. I�rcl:ic.ecL• ac�visecl �: �:here axe on�.y twa manu�ac�uies� o� s�ee1 �r�m�s 3.n tlte co�intry zit�c� Lhes� . ,� ar� an�.y �:v�iilable it� c���a�.n .limi.tLC: � ires. �J�'vid Ch:.-i.s�a.c.nscst i.��ia�:mecl i:ho I3oaxd �ilc�l� �:�13.5 13�s b�en ���lci can�.i�ise�� t� ae' a���:U}77.em i.�I:UUCj�lOLIi: th� GiL•y. I3ec�zusc of �lze un�7va�.1a1�1.a.�Ly o� 'st�c�.. £rames 'anci }scc;ausc: oC� itigl��x s°. re�istanc� .�o corrusinn, ��luma.i�um a.s �ri:�crr'ed��t��tiough coc�e clearly specxfies stce�.. , t�1r. Ch�i�i.ian�en at'aGc�c3 � hc �1ad �io k��c,�7.l�ant w�a.��� c�ran'E:it�q n� �his vaii.-- � ��znce iri�stnu�ti as �he s��:xttctuz:e is �.0 i��. f..r_oin i:he �;�ro�ac,rty �i.i�t� a:id �ii� , , neighboa:.ing s�.�uci.ure zils� �.� tt. �x��zn li�le, oi �. tnt;a]. a�: 20 �L. 'She� �'iz:e � � l3er�rtmeri�, eoncurr�d wa.�t�h �.he Bui�c�ir�c� De�aar�:m�n�. ii�nk Si�: '�ean caEntnetltcd � � �, , °,thz;.: s�ee,�. daes tio�. t�a�.d u;,7 '�clX�1CU,Larl.y as iar, as betich� aan�ix:ucE:ioil is cor..:�Xned. , A2�dy Na.c�io].san �ugc�estecl �hat si.nce i:iii� a.s ac� ois--g�ing,Prob].em t.ha� �hc �3aa�c1 �aonsic3ez: ,c�ran�i�tg �p��ravril' an a 7.nn� tcrnl i�z-�si �, sa ��l�a� • sucti vaxi�.nce rec�ues�s �will. nal: �iavr� to lae bzouc�tit� 1�acY. bc�:ore E.ile 13o�'ird. . �� Th� f3oaia agrr�ed and turt�l�ez- �zskaci � L•1��€: �i�� iiui3:cia.izg t�a�i��i�r�ic��� a.ilvestigate � �hiN �ur. E:l�r�x wi,th Sl3CC artc� �-t�i:�m��4 mar3e� �.o i3ave t�he ecc�e aznen,:ler1. A�no��.on . was made }�y l�ir'. Si:raui�. � ' �, , � • A107�'xOid: t�Ii1:1► xec�a�d �o �i1e i�rques� fnr �1 �arza�l�e, �ram the i3u�i,X�ing �Code �' �ax a �L'�uctux� ].ocat.ec;t a�. 1.7G7-].771 I�en I��n�,, L�ca ��a33�? llpaYt�nent�a, the Boar� , "" 2 � ' ' , . � , f�/3.t3�F3G � y' � ' t • . � . • , '. ,,.. ��Gr ' ` . • , ! . . � - ---=•!M�� ' ;����"�l'�r: P;?-t.� , � .'r : , t .'�r �. ' • . � . , , � �..:; • . �; .,, , , . , , . . rl• y • '•';+ ; �„� . , � - , � . , . , ��. -;, . . , , , �. 1.'�*� � . . , 3 . ���e s r . . � . �Y f,���•�.ti" r. .� ' , ' , • • ki� ' ' ' I.. � . _ , . ik ' , � . , . . � , , � . � ' � � .� � . � � . � . . I ' ' � • � 1� ! � . ' . � ' . ' . .. . . .s.; :.A . .� a . ., . � � . ' ' 1 �.(�� ,':` ' � � �,+ � ` � � i � � . , 1. . . f . i6>'+�° � .'i . �;' /' ' • ` � . , . , ' + ' � � ' . � ` ' ' - f�j • ' �"� � � ,�! " � � , , . � 1 ' . '� � �, . �, � .?.i'' . ' . , ' . ' , r' . � ' ` , � � • . ' ' . ' . : � - , � > �iy.. ;, ' . ' , � �, . , 1. , , . � ' ' ' < . �. ; +;,�, s i . ' , . . , 3 , 1 ` . , . ' . i�f'.F�....: ... . ri'.r'�'�..,1:�1�,� �'.�f�'.r � ., . ., .,. . . . ... . , .• ' ' . e � . +' r ' . . ' . • ' . ' . 'I .��� � � � 7 ' + . . �,. . ' , y � y ��. ' ' . . . . + I ' ! • , ' � . . . . • • �,• � aonr� , � , � � • r 13 Ll �. a. C� �. Il �7 � I" �. O CT 1.�,� C o iy t� 0 7, � . . ' ' � . , ,. . Jutte ].E3, J.9a5 ' ,. , ' ' , ' , . , ' ' . . ;. ��incis .xt �a he ca�.t�hin i�,� aui:hori.i:y L-c� act: u�otz klze �er�,uest: �-�nc� �icrcuy �gr�nL•. , `, tlie var.i.4�nce wa.tl� i:ha .fc�].l.awi.nc� concia.�a.a�Y; Gt��ii. titG, Bu.i,.Zc3i.17rJ i7e�artmen�: con�-� si.d�r�, t�tis 3:n .�uf:ure i.n.; �anc�� ��ic1 i:h�� t� in �.Ize �1�75[?I7CG' o� unu.�ua�:E cpndi tio�is , , ' aluminun� is r3GCC�i:f1}J.LI?. �, . .'. , � , � : , • t�lot�an• s�ca�ldec3 .anci ca.t-�ic�d un�nintou�ly. , � � , , � •� ].19a A11nc1�1].ay �Pbznk., �f 53.CI�!'1G� Q� �. R. 1ltsn�er, iec�uest:i.ncf v�.�ianc� fxam , . E'cde�a� llood �Regulat:ioy�s L-o permi�. coi�si:r.�zei:ian ,c�f c�a�:ac���/;;�or.zg�e �r,e��s with .� :. �break�-a��ray w�lis belo�v t�no� el�vai:ion. t•ir. T.c�g�-�n decl�ir.cci a canf'la.ct'�af . � int�rc�i:� i.na�muci-� �;; l�c .is .thc: canLa:,�ctar bIl' t11C3 l�r.�o;jccl.. i�1r.•-. i1�L�y S. Cline, �. .� ai:�arney, reprcwc:iiLed ti�e c�w�ic�r �.n pzcsc�rii:ii�g .�the c�:sc i:o i:Yie Bc�ar,c�. � I�ir. , . ' C].in� inform�d i:h�: boazd t:}1:��: this is thc �.L�si: �].a�tecl lc�i: on Lhe nar�h enc� � � oi G�1ezr.vrat�r 13eacil. iEo�nc i, pre�enl:Zy under COilsL•ructio» �nd o�s�nei: w�-�nLs � t'o eiiclose �wa:, l�ax}:xnc� bay� . w;i�li brr�-�;c-�����y wti]_�.s L-c� �,�rc�l:e:c� ��ina..:�y ai�tamok��.l�s��,:°, ' �zom e.�emeni:s. �`hex� wou].d 3�e na ].�.vii�c� cruai:i�ers c�r n�lier �LOhi}aiL•ive uses; . �,��- � ', ar.ca. troultl br �oa: au�.bnto}�i�.�?� ,bC��t1: '�tt�d bc�cii pa�:��p}�err7,:�:E.i,ei� : �or.ac�e nr�1y. � � �-� : �:"�. Garage/starage areas wou].d Y�e .oti eii:her s5.cie' c��' thc hau,:,� � �ra.�.t3., �r�y�r ent�y in , �.eenter. �Anr'iy�.On�sfer intoznaed t�hn boa�:c7 tl7sr� lie h�ic3 i7o r�r.ob.lem �.,�a.�:lZ' tliis can-' � c�ructio:i and.•�•�oul.d r1o� �a�1��a.aa.pzte any c�s:c�bl.ems �7s� tar �:; I'EI�il1 i.:�= r,anc�rned, . �but. he wa�z�c:c� ta bc sure� �he a�ojie�''w��;� ac,��7xe �F, t•.?nr },i.�ti�:r: co�� f�f 'hi� Flood , • a.n�urance inasmuch .�, 't3�ez�� a. , nnr_e L•��ut� 30D sqts�-�re 'fc:��: invc3.vcci. ,t�lr. C].zne .,' , can:�.�.xmed . f:hat'• th� owncr I��ad cl�cckec3 :�i,�o t��a. ��r�ci kn�:: �rrhat .:7.i.s� insu�:aitce ; xa�.c::s wauJ.d be. �Mr. �t'�ufex� st�t�c:d 'i�lia�: L-h� de,i�ln a3nc1 �.�r�� a� ba:ca��w�y cori- ��ruct�6xnn woul.cl meet i'Ll��1', czi�L�raa. I•1��c;;; ��r� Sra�e �pf3zqv��. 31z:� b�r.n sc- ` , 'aurecl. i�.�z .%,cg�►ri asked �o�� a maGa.an is�a�le � 13y. t�1x . ii���tk S�. Jc:at�, : t•lCiTTOi3; S•Tith rec��id .L-o t�ttie .requ�•,5L- fo�: a v�ri�ncc; .�'rc�rn �l:c. 1 1o��ci �tisur�nc� Regul�ttion 'for. � s�:ruc�.ure .�oc:a�:eti �t: 11��3 t•iancialay �c7i,tL•, C�z.r.:laue.l. �'O].t]t.r ��he Board r"�,nd:; a,L• tti�ii:liiri ii.y au�:hoz-i�j �.� ��ct upon .i�itri i�r;uc�;�: atid he�:eby , . . '� g�ant� the va�: i.ance . � �: � MoL-ion seeondeci. .[�i_e�eussion on t�iot�.on. I+nciy I�iclic�3.�c�t� a.-hque�,i:ec3. �he motion • bc a�menc�ecZ �a rei�.ccC i3oarc� :�lao h�►s ;jur5.sc��ci:i.an undr:r Cn�ptc:a- 39; and i,� � �, cave�s �h� samc: taY�a.c, and it is: i:ll�. a.n�erprr+���t;�.as1 at f�lz:i. � L�o<<z:c.i t]�at �nY ze��xence i:o c.tiL-er3,a uncier S�c��,on 3�'�r�.2(f} r�oes naL a���.y ,�:tnd E:t�ezc�ore . � � . grants i:h� v'a�i.��ncr. ' , � . • , � rloti.on. as amciid�c� :�econded and carric�c' u�aa�lwmoa�sJ.y. ,' ' �i�� , . . � . . . � . , , , , �` ': 7�.5 S. Gul�viet�� f31vd. , i�iilton iIot�:l., rer�urst:�_iig v�Li��ej�cc .�r.oi�l C:aa�tal Can- , �' . � ��ruc�ic�n Coc�c. �:c� c�.:�;eiir� e:ta.�ta.ng. .��r�ovable ��roor�cn �ec:1c 19.fi £�. �ini�o 3.8 �t. . .'. seawa�.1. setkit�cf: �xea. t•tr. De.zn Gnoclsrtsii:�1 0� G�od,�ntzf:tl l:;nterF�riscs Cci�p. ` �S�e ,ented tl�is f:o i:tie F3or3ru. ?1 v��ri.ai3r.c hac� ��rr�viousJ.�+ beerti c�z�'�rtted per- . ma.i:�ing c:o��s�ruc{:i.ar, cvitl�a.l� i:17c s�a:a�l�, are�� anr�i Chis rec�ues�� `i�; tos: ��er� . mis�iori, to ex�en.d �{:hiN exista.ng dec;k. 1� '[iioti.on was made �z°�+ And�� r1icl�aXs�n. -� , d�S�'.l'zOt3: .� move l-.ha� tl» l���zd ha� juz�.r,dic�i.ol� a.n, i:his� case; a var�ance from �:' �l�c �I3 xi:. scE:br.�ck �rom �.t��� sezwa:Ll: �� f�rc7�.ri�dec� �in �:}Eapl:c:r. 3� Co�zstai' Con-- :�Lruc��.vr� Ca�{�, that r��;avi.deci the aprsl.icat�t��kaeps t;l�e COIlS�r'L7G�.10�1 cons,is�ent � . � ,' . �:` ,�::. � . . . - . . , : , , -- a — � , � , � • . r,���/a� - - - .._. ' _______�.� - � � �' �>� .� ��€,'�`�����'��s��=<: . . ::,. � . �a �fA��� r{t� ,'t r+':';''t';,:'. �! � � ' ; , , . . ; � , . � ' � � .' ' '. ` � ' ` '. ' � • ' , � . .' .., . °�7•!.:'Mt�',r�'i < ��.;. ' � � . �� �� , • , . . i ' ' � . ' , �•¢��k.,' �.! . . , . � ; ' ., ' , ' � ` ' � ' . . . .i.. , ; ,f t) , ' . i J' �7 ' ..�F �t:�,� �. . .. ' ' ' . , . 1 , ' . . {, , �. , f' �. . . � , i. � ' , . . � ' . . . � . , sjs•�i�t�'� :, t `,�. ; '�tr'.�,'. '.1� . � � .. , � . � ' ' . . . , . ' i i�•l��'' ;'� �!'. .. , I . . . . . i � + t� �fSt( � ' � 1 r' ' ,'.• is 'r � � � ' r . � . � ' ' . � , i . . �����' '!v1•: ; 1 . . ` ' ' , . , , ' ' ,r . " , r . , . , � . � . , ' ' .4 ' £. :�y. : ' : ' .�. '� . '. ' , . . , . � : . '. �. , • . • '' :;•� ' �.F � , , f ', 1' � -f r ' ' , ; . � , . . . 3 . . � , . ' , ' . s , . . , e ' ' ' � � � �� . ' '. , • �'t S �'�� �. ' � . ' E ' I : 1 � ' ' . . ' � � S . 1 • ` ' , " 1 � � �1 � l /' 1' � • ,� f � 1 � ' � e � t . ` i 3 {.; wi. .E' .t?� ' . A. � I ' . . . . ' . I . . . , . ' . ' , .. . ' • . estl ;�.� • , . ° . . 'r ! . ' � • • � . . . . . � . � . . , . '� . ��.�. r . � . . . r`i1.• ri 1' . . . z . •t . � 1 1 . . � . 5 , ' � � . I• , Ji' ..i� ;`' I ' r, ' ,.f•'' , ' ' ' � ��r� � i .�Lr �.',J:..:'r.; i �; . ' , ' .� � .I ' ' . � '. . , . .. • :iF; ��.Fw��'��ILf..'..�•� . . � •� � . . 6 , . . . • .. . . . f , . . , ' ' . r, ' . ��s, iv �;+; ..F . ,1j'1�'a<.. ��:5� . . ..... . . . . .. �. � . . . . . , . . . • . � . . � ' , . .. . . � � .. . a � ., ,. . . . . ' Ii��; ,. ' � ' . . ' ' . . ' r , . ' . . . ' - ` . . '� � . . . . 1 . ' . ' , i • . . . � � . .. ' �� ' ' , _ ` � ' �" ' ` . . ' � . � � � • ' ' ' r ' ' • r , . . - , . . . . . , . ] � 3 ' . . � � . j . na�n t� . . � •. � � T3ui7.c�l�.ng•/L 1.aaci Goni:xo]. : , ° , • . � ' ' .7un�: ,I.�, 1.�1F3G , , � � . . . ., ' , ,. - •� . , . . , , ia�.th �ather •car►s�zuc�xoii.,, �iea.ng modu7.a�: at�d t��il.y NCL C�J�.cic fax maintenanc.� .. ; ��".�c�zc���Ils; �I�cre :�:� l�a c�n�3.�.ct :��a.tf� the �.rtt�nt b� t-.f7r� �Ccde �nd 7' rttove , tha� the variai�re be �c�r.atiGcd. , < - . , ' . � , , . � , ' �, � .� E�otion secbnf.�c�d b�� [ian3t � SL- ..�ea�i �r��o � ask;�,ci � Li»t the motian be ziine�ldcc� ro be .� �; a.r�:qu�st �h�t �tiis be ��t cx��nsi�iz Ut �1�e ��reviau;;7.y gz�aill:eck v�rianc:��. . [4q�ion. as �m�na�a� ���ona�a� �anrl c�-�rz:�.ed unanimous�.y. � - . .° � :� , � . . . ,. . . . ,. , . � , , , .� No'�lcl Uusine'ss ar new. hu��.n�ss �o ,l�`r„ c:a.scussed. . � . . : . . , . , � :, ,. � .tdc;et�.ng �tdjou�ncd .al: 3:25 �.. m. � . ' . . , � . ' • . � . � � .. , . . , , . . . , � , , : ' , ` : ' , , . ' . ; ` • , ' S �I , . . , ' - ' • '. , • � ,. � � °�� [;' , • ' ' f . !� . . ' '`' 'i; ��� � , • . . , � ; ,. . �: , .. . , ' = �!��'�. ��-�d�. . , ,� �, . 3ohn ti.`'.Lo an �,r. Chairm�n' , � . ` . � . / g ���xe�t�ry', . � � , � .. ► . . : F .Lf ecorc�i.�� . f , , , , . , �'' , •F , , , . ,. , . , . , • �' ' , • � � ' ' , � . �.' . , . . . . . • .. . . , • , , • , , , ' � . ; : � ., � , � - . • . , �. • � k' . . ' . . ' . � . � � � � . . , � ' ' . . . . • • t. . , ' . i. � ' . . . ' r . ' ' . . F' � . ' S . . ' , r. � � . . � ' � � ' ' 1 � : f , •f .. . j . + ' ' . ' . � ' � ,. ' r ' � . � . . ;�; � . ' -, ' . ; ' . , ' � � . . , . . . . � • � ' . ' � ' , ie �. . , • ' . � . ' . . • , ' . ' , . ' � .� .t . ' . .. ' , ' , ` ', . .. . � � � . t ` ' • , � . . , � . ' . . ' . . , . ' , ' ' • . . .. � � � . . � ' ' . � � . . . . � . r. .. . � .�� . � � ' . � . � , . ' ' , . . � , • . � . �' � ' � . . . ' , � � . - ' , ' ' . ' , i ' � ; ' . , � . � . � ' . . . ' ' ' , . . ' , . • . f, ' ! y �l. . I ' � ' . � � . ' � � . . . • � . . 1 . , r . . ' � , � 1 , i ' � � . . . - i � 1 �c �� � " i . � � ., � ' • . . ' , , � ' .. , ' ' a � ' . „ , . f . " • I . ' ' ' . i ' ' . � f � . ., . , � • ' i . ` ' . ! ' � � � � ; .. � � . . � � . ! � . . . � ' . � . • � �� . . • '. 1 . . ' � . ' . � . it�i•tl�•l�':! ,CS" '�', •� �.• . � Y.J'1:MIl:' �`i�irTirU;..,, �� �'�x.s'< .�. , , . � , . � ,y `�r. „ . Y . � � t . • t ° ` ' ti p i' . ' ./ 1 �d� ., � �, . '1 ...�.. � . � � ' �. , i ' f• . ' ' , • �. � : . , . ' � � ' IIQARA'O�' ADJU5TM�NT 6 APP�AL � BUTLD'iNG/�'LOOD C�NTROL � F . Wednesd�y, �un� 1F3, 19F36 2 p.m. ,. ' �r F f .' 'tc � , ' ' I M�mbers presen�: � Member absent: , John Logan, Chairr�an � �dward ��Jalker Joseph Straub � Hank S�. Jean Andrew Nicholson {Axra.ved 1:30 p. m. ) . , Aredrew B. Onu�er, Ac�xr�g Soard 5ecreta�y � , . , � Aiso present,: , ", David Christiansen - Chief of Inspec��,ans , � � ��e£f Danie�s - Fire Depar�m�nt � � � Chaa.rman Logan called the mee�ing to order at 1 p, m. Four cases to be , heard, .� . � 5.3a Manda�.ay Avenue; LaSal Mo�el �- requesting v�ri,ance from the 5tandard Building Code � $@C�].OII 1I13, 3 to allow install.ation o� an ou�side spira��. ' �stairway. Representing LaSal rsotel a� the hearing weze Messr�. ii�mmond, � � owner , JoYir► Sommers i COl��]^c'1C�Ux' - Chuck 5nmmers and �].ma �.'ay�.ar, pro ject superintendents -- and Barr.� U11man, a:�chitec�. Mr. U1.].man de�cribed the project and renova.tions of the mat�l.and adv�.sed �.he spiral s�aircase wa.s 5hown ort �he orig'inal plans �nd was a1.r�ady . ii� place . Upon inspection, � t,he con�ractor 'was adv�sed by the inspector tha� the �r�ad widt��s and risex , hei.gh�s did not con�orm �o code. Proper correciions we�e mac�e and upon ap- pl.ying fa� a certi�icate o� occupancy, contractor was inL-ormed �ha� the . stairway wou�.d have to be removed enti�ely as spzral stairs we:re not per- mz�ted i.n a commercial es�ab�ishmen�. z� was nokecl also tha� in making . the riser and tread ca�rections, �he heac�room was made lvwer than required , by cod�. M�. Hammand, owner o,f� LaSal, s�a�ec� he r3id no� interpret the code as ��ro- ` hibi�ing the use of spiral stairs in ha.� project. Mr. Sammers, con�rac�or, further objected ta the tir�ing of tl�e Bu�.ldi.i�g Department's notice �ha� thE stairs,wouid not be'allowed and would itave to b� �emaved, stating �hey were shown on the or�.gareal plans, were ins���led, and p�op�r correctidns made at inst�uations o� �he �.nsgector. Mr. Somrners fur�her advised �hat the headraom probl.�m couZd ��adi}.y be carrected. Mr. Christianseii� Chief of �nspections, stated the code is speci�ic in ' covering struc�ures where spiral staircases are acc�ep�ab7.e and i� it was '"�the inten� a� �he code to a�law such i.nsta�.la�.ions in commercial buildings, tha.s would have been clearly speci£ied in the code. The Building Depart- � ment's i.n�exp�e�a�i�n �f the cade has be�n veri.�ied by �Sou�hern Building Code Ca�gress. . ' yt was further brought out �ha� �wo qther si:airways are in place for exit�- � iilg which meet code requir�ments and �his spiral staircase is not a re-- quixement a� #:his proj�ct. �ir. Christ9.ansen stated in descending these spiral s�ai.ars one can aZmost step o�er �he handrai7. maki.nr} xt an extr�melx hazarclous exi�. Th�.s was confirmed by Je�f Daniels wi�a stated that iE the ' variance was grant�d, the I'ixe bep�rtm�nt would require ac3ditional fEncing al�hough �he sta�ra wou].d sti1.1 not cc�nfqrm �o the Life 5afety Cac�e. , .� � , , . ' � . ` _ . ' . ` u�3:��;�2��#�.f'.��i}:�'f�:z:�,��s��:Fs�i`'��_ss��:,� . ' ' � - ---- �,� : �� „� � , � �. M� �,����*; •'• . f r � ' � , � . � ' ' . . e , ,�� . . �. , . �. . i r, ., 2�:. . 1 � �. . . . . . � . r � . f � . . E , ' . . , � ' � . -2- ' ' � . , $pAA ' � . � C3uilt�irtg/rldod Control . � �une 1,8, 1986 . • � �'he contxacCor and projec� su�e�in�:enc�en� s�a�ed �hat in meetxngs w�.�h , former dir�ctor Edwar� Be�h�l he liad indicated �ha� �h�se,spira� s�airs were aacep�able. Records in the build�.ng depaz�ment show that a con- � ditional certificate of occupancy was issued on Apri1.Z5, 198G and a].et�ez was sent to the cGn�ractor by �dward Bath�I. advising that befaxe a fina�. CO � cauld be a.ssued, the spiral staa.rway woul.d have to be removed. Mr. Logan �, remarked fhat it was unfaz�una�e the contractor was not adv�.sed the � spiral stiaa.�way was not � acceptab].e prior tio instal�.ation and px�.or �o �he car- rect�.an� that were made. Mr. Logan asked Eor a mation� mo�ior► made by Hank S�. Jean. � �,� , ' .�� ,t MQT�ON: �With regard ta the recZuest �or a vaziance fzom �he Bui�ding Coci�, Sec�ion �.ii�.3, for a structure located a� 530 Manc3alay Avenue, �he Baard � finds it �o be•wi�hin i�s authority to ac� upon the request but deni.e� the variance based upon �he fol�.owing: �he.cades -%ife Safe�S► and �he ,Bui.lding Cade � are.qui�e clear in �hat �he use of tihe st�az,� as shown on �he plans does not meet �he in�:cnt of tlze code. � Motian secandsd by Mr. Straub. • Motion amended by Andy Nicholson �o sti�ulate �hat �he spiral stairway is not requi.red as adequate stairs are pravided elsewh�re and tto hardshi� pre- vai].s. ` � �l+io�i.an �s amended s�condec� and c�rried � unana.mou�ly. Vara.ance den�ed, 1767-�.77�. L�o Lan�, Leo Lane ApartmenL-s - requesting a variance fram �he Standard Bui�.ding Code �o allaw ins�allatzan af• wa.re g].ass windows w3.�h alumininum �rames 10. �. ft, fxa�n prnpe�ty line. Richard D. Pritts, Archi�- tect, represented the owners, 3M InvestR��nts. Wire g�.ass/al.uminum framec� windows are aZready in place, St�ucture a.s I0.]. ��. from pxoper�y. lin�; code requires s�eel �ram�s, because of higher r�sistanc� to heat� mus�•be used on s�ructures within 15 �t. of a property 1ine. Architec� advised � there �r� only two manu�ac�u�es o� s�ee1 �rames in �he cnurt�.ry and �liese are only availab3.e in cer�ain 1.imiL-ed sizes. Davic� �Christiansen a.nfoxmed the �oard that tlzis has heen and contir�ues to be a problem �hraughaut the City. Because of the �navailabli�y o� s�.eel frames ��nd because of higher resistance �� carrusion, aluminum is preferred a�.hough cade clear}.y speci�ies s�ee].. Mr. Christians�n sta�ed he had na problem wi.�h granting of this vari- ance inasmuch as the structuze is 10 �t. from the pxoper�y line and the nei.ghbozing s�ructure also 1Q ft. trom iine, nr a totia7. of 20 ft. The Fi�e Department concuarred with the 13uilding Departmen�. Hank St. Jean cominen��ec� �ha� s�eel does not'hald up pa�ticularly as far as beach construction is conc�rned. Andy Nicho�.son suggested tha� si.r►ce �his is an on-going problem that the Board conside�'gran�.xng ap�raval. on a long �erm basis so that such variance requests will not have to be brough� back be�are the Board. The Boa�d agreed and fur�.her asked that'the Building Department xnves�igate thi.s furthez with SBCC and at�empL- made 'to have �he aode amended. A moti.on was made Y�y Mr. Straub. � riE7T�ON: j4ith regard to �he reques� fpr a vara.ance from the Bua.ld�ng Code far a s�ructt�re io���ea a� 1'1G7-�.771 Leo Lane, �eo Lan� Apar�men�s, the Baard s''r�� f � �� � .,, . - � - 6/18/B�i ,� ;�'��Yy�;,:!;.-'�° �' �; j , � � . �':, � , � . + .. .�� . f . . . :E . �,. . 1 . ! ' � :'� . ' r � �, 1 f " f '. . 1 • • . � 1 • . I i �'•'`` , ' k� . , '� �r �' , ' � . ' , � � s � . . . . I . .� ' � � 1 i �' 1 � ,� � : �7 �'f. ,,5�.. � , . ,t�' .. � .. �- . � . � . . � SOAA , , Su�.l.cl�.ng/�'1.oad Con�ro�. ' � June 1.8, 19BG � - . •� � finds 3,t �o be wi�hin its au�hari�y to ac� upon the zequ�st and hereby grants , �he var.�ance with �he following condita.an: �ha� �he Building Depar�men� con- � sider �his in.future 9.n,s�ana�s and �h�t in th� absence of�unusua� conditions, aluminum �.s acceptable. ' Mot3.on seconded and carried unanimously. ��1198 Mandalay Poin�, residence o� �. R. ilunte�, requesting varzance frc�m Federai i'lood Regu].ati,ons �n permi� cans�ructi.on a£ garagcJstorage areas wi�h breaic-away wa1].s beZow flood eleva�ion. Mr. �ogan dec3.ared a conflac� of, .�nteres� inasmuch as he is the con�ractor on �he project. Mr. Harry S.,Clxne, a�tc�rn�y, rep�esen�ed �he owner in presenting the case �o �he i3oard,. Mr. ' C].ine infarmed the baard that this is the last p�atted Zot on �hc north end of Clearwater Beach. I�lome is presently under construc�ion and owner wants �o encZose �wa parking bays with break-3way�walls to protect �amily automobiles � fram eZements. There would be no living quarters or o�her pzoh�.b�.�a.ve use�; • area wou�.d b� for automobile, boa� and beach parapherna�.ia storage onll. . Garage /s�orage ,areas would be on ea, �h�x s�.de of uh� hous,� wi.�h £oyer entzy in , �'center. Andy Onufer xnformed the boarc� �hat he had no prablem with this can- i ' s�ruction and•would no� anticipate �ny prob�ents as Car as �E�fA is concerned, � � bu� he wanted to be sure the nwne� wa� awar� of the,higher cost of Uis flnod .�insurance inasmuch,as �here is marc than 3QQ square fe�t�invv�ved. Mr. C�ine con�irmed that �h� otaner had checked into this anci knew wha� his insurance � rates would be. Mr. Onuier statcd thaL• the ciesign and ty�e o� hreakaway con- struction wou].d mee� I'EMA criteri�. Necessary S�a�e approval has been se� cured. Mr. Logan asked for a moLion m�.de by Mr. Hank. St. �7ean. , � MOTION:� Wi.th r�gard to the reques� For a var�a�lce from �he T'l,00d Snsurance Regu].ati.on for a structure located �t 1�9$ Mandala�► Poin�, Carlouel Poa:n�:, �he Board finds it wi�hin i�s authori�y �o act upon the reques� and hezeby ,grants the variance. . Motion seconded. Discussion on Mo��on. And}� Nicholson requested the mo�ion be amended tc re�lect Boa�d also has jurisdic�zon under Chap�er 39, and it� covers tYte same toPic, and i� is the inter�retaL-i,on of �his �3aard that any '� referQnce �o cri�exia und�r Sec�ian 390G.2(ij dnes no� ap�ly and �herefore gran�s the variance. 2�fotion as amended seconded and carried unanimc�usly. � ' 715 S. Gul�view �lvd:, iiilton Hote�, reques�ing vari�tnce ��am Coastal Con- s�ruction Code to extend ex,istittg removai�le waaden decFc 19.6 ffi. in�o IB ��. seawal.l setback area. Mr. Dean Gaadsmi�h of Gaodsmith���nterprises Corp. � presented this �a ��e�Board. A variattce had previously been yranted pex- c�itting const�uc�ian wi�hi.n the seawa].1. ar�a and this rec�uest is far peac- mission Co 'extend ttiis existing deck. A r�otion was maae. Y�y Andy Nich�lson. �' �4pTION: x move 'that the Board has jurisdiction in this case;.a variance fram the li3 ft. setback �rom the seawa�l as provided in Chapter 39 Cpasta]. Con-- stxua�3on Gade, that provided the applieant keeps the consf.ruc�a.on c�nsistent � -�� x F � ; �, ; � --- - .,� . �f. , . ' � � - 3 - 6/18/86 . :,.�� �i ;�ti+�sti�i tk:�:��: , � ••4R ` .�+h�n� �!� :���i��! v�{ �.'j < , . . ... • . � . . . :�`�, .i�ag ; e1 b. ' �.[: {�.:� ! . . . �,,�q� >,�C}:.T.�C�Y?�!.1;`�a� '#' .�� �,� �. ..� ; . � . , . , � . �:- "r� F�. 1 � r I-F . , . ' ' , . µt3° �;,":I ; r: . . . , , f ,i�:�.,.r.`1��.. ''`. y., • ; �i � � y, e ' ' , ' � t . �� �,4�/ •�F, . . . . , � � . " . �;�;1'i1ti i';a' , ft ' . e , . " s . �"i,'' _� . 1. � w . . , � , , , !,'. t. '• . . � • . . . � 'i : � .+. : f �'I 3 � . . � . � . . . ��; rc �� ,j; F , , . . • . • . , . � ��, i,�t'c{j : `•4,..� ��' � .. �- .? . Y ` . .. , • ' ' . iFt..��. , ti? i `.t, � '- 'ff1 ' , � ' _• . . . ' ' �. , , • ' ' • �}!��, . . . � . .,i; . � . � • • . . f��t ' ,,�• F 1 i ' •�, , . � :�.• � . . . • ' � , . , � . , .�i'.'��V ..'.S:.t 1 ' 1, 1 't .F� � � ,, ' . �. � . ' � , � . il.: . �. � .;�, . �, , ' , r , ' . . }' s�.; t�, ,� � . ; , ; ._ , . `. � : . ' . 1.? ' '.. . ' ' . ' . . '7r.�':':ti;'.:� .`•73t?��:%'��t. ..%:'s�X�';a'��5���.L'�i`r�... < . � . � � �. '. . .. .. �� + , � . . . , + � , IS ' . . � ' ' �� � ' ' ' — � - . %. 1 } . 1 ' J. .'' , . '� . . .$• , ir �1 , � , . ' 1 . 1 � ' ''t��. . . � ' 1.: , . . , j' � ,t � . . � • ' � ' • . � ➢ � . � ' . � , { � , . ' � ' . ' ' _ , }. � . . • , I' ' . ' , ' . ... . � �F' • � � ; � • r.,`a: f� � ' : ,, . ' . ' '� , . ' I . . � .. ' f , . '_ ' .. . .'Xk� . . . . . . . .� • ' .'f:�. 'i�'4� , . . .• ' 1 . , ., � , ' �; { ' . . �.�I . . .r . , .` , � .. � , , , �.. . . , , yi ���3:i�: . , , . � . \ ' � i� , � . , . � . . ' BOAA ., r . . : ' , • . ..Bu�.lding/F1aod Con�rol . . � . ;. .. , � , . .. , June' ].8, :�986 • � . ` ` . �� , , . . . � . �, . � , , � . , � � . • ` . : :; 'w3.th other canstruct3.on., ,being modul,ar .and easily set aside �or mai.ntenance • of seawalls, �here is.no aanf7.ic� wi�h the inten� of �he Code and z�move ` � � �that the variance be gran�ed. . , , . � � , , . Mo�ion seconded by Hank S�. Jean who asked that the moti.an be�amended �o be � ,-, a request that this be an �xtensicin oE the preva.ausly gran�ed varianc�.� ' ��Mo�ion as amended seconded and caxried unan�.mousl.y. � � ,� . . , � ' , .. -t! . No old bus:Eness or new' business to he da.: cussed. � � . � .;;; : � � � � , � ,� , � Meeting adjauxned a� 3:25�p. m. � ` . . , • � . , ' ' • . ' . . • � ' '.. � . � � � • , , , � . . . ' �. I , . ' ' . . � .� i . • .. ' I t • � , . � , I , � . 4 � o H. Logan, Jr. , Cltairman , -- ecord�.ng r�.�ary �' . . . • ' � � ' ' , �� • , ,. < , . . ,s , . , , , . ,. . � . , , . � . .,-, j' . � � . ,' , � , �. , , ' , �. � " ,. ;� : � ' ,. , ,. - - �`Jf,,. � . ' , . . , . . . � � . , '' . �, , , . ' . ' � , . f� �. � , . � , , . . . � �, . �..' � �� , '. , � � . . y!t': ' 1 , '. ' 1 ;, j , . . . , , ' . . . . 1 , t • ! � I•l � • . - . . . , ' e . � . k. �•+ .. , , . . ,1 ! , , 1 1 �� . � ' � S • ' . '" � ' . , . . , , ' �, i , ' ' �� . ' � � � � . { ` , i . . � • , ' 1 , . . � ' � . . � { . • ' ' ' �!t " . . . . • , ' ' � . ' . ' . � , ' l ' . . � F . . � , ' � ' ' . , ' 1 . , . . , 1 ' ' , • . , . . . . . . ' � . � . . � ' , r 1�j ♦ � . � �� ' . ' r � , . . . . ' . . • , ' .' . , . � } , . , . . Y�� .. � 1 � �. 3 . . ' .. , , , • , . , . .'.i„� I.3 ei• . � . .� ; .'. ,,! I 1S t ��• __ " i .�'is' •� iT.R��1';ti'e1L1_i�:,�: *"C7,� f�L'i`�1''°r� sr '`, � �' �4� it•' s . . � . . , . . . , ' , , ' . ' '' - . +� ����� 4J. ,1��f � ,f .�.., i'� ' � , i � ' . ' ' . . ' r � � ' �,.11n,X� ° �}'7 � I } • � . � . . ' . . i i . � � ' . . �Y i���'.i, �fj' ' . ' ' . . . • , . ,i 'f.�� . • . � ' ' � . , ' , 3 . , . . � •7�� . , ' �. � ' � � . . . ' . � �, � T� ,. � . � � ' , ' ' . � . � . .. � . � � • . ' �S�E� ..�..� .•r.� � . �. ; v' , . . , r . . . ' � - 1 , , ' ' ��^•�i .. " !� � .. SJ � f . . . . � ,• � . � ' . . . f', „ . , ° i y '' ' � :r r -. . ' ` . . , " , . ` . i . . .�.�� . .. �. .. .. � , � , . +f , � f . .f . � � . ` . . . • ' . . � � . . ' . . . � . , , . , ' ? � � ' r '� . , , �. l . .. � ' . . r � ' ' . ' , � . , , � • 1 � . �.. .. F' . ' . , . ' • � r � . , ' 1 l . , . . . . . , . 1 . ' 1 . ' . I ' . 1 1 i�. ,fY�..;••9� s�'i....r•a.'-I-�l.��..�r��r.{.� .f,..i � .. I ' . . 7' . . ' � . r . ' . . . • , • � � . . . . i . . �1 ' , . , • 1 �~5 ' , [ � , ' , . �t • . . ' • ; � ' . . � . . son�n o� nA,��s�.CM�I3T n�ru n���nL, . � , � . • ' � ' � ' BUI�DING/1�'LOO� CONTROL . � , . . . . ' . � . . � ' W�dnesday, �Sune 3.8, 3.986 , ' � � �1G�NDA � ; � ,. � , � ' , , ,' , ' • � �. , -. . ' , ' l. . Public , lieaxings ' , ; . ��� , ;(a)'�'S30 Mandalay Avenue, LaSal t�ia�el, xeques�ing � � ,' , . � , var�.anae, �zom S�andard �uilding Code; Sec�i,on ' . . .� , � ].1].3.3 (aopy attached) to pc�rmit �insta�.].a�i.on , , • � . � � of 'ou'�side �pix�aX stai.rway. ' �. :,• �F ` � I �` Owner - �'im Itammand ` .`. r. ,� , � , � , Represen�ative - A. T. Doy�.e� Firs� South�rn . � � . Builders , . � . , • , ' ' " (b}w ].767-1:77]. L�o Lane� Leo Lane Apar�ments, '�eques�-- � , � , �3.ng variance fram S�andarc� BLil.ding Code to allow ' , installation of wire g].ass windows with al.uminum '., �' � ' , . t��mes id.l f�. from prop�r�y li,ne. (copxes oE �'� , � Secta.on 702. 1 - 703. � (a) � 703. � (� ) , att�,ched. ) , . � Own�r -- , 3 M Ynvestm�nf:s = ` � Representativ� - �tic�iard D. .Pra.th�s, �12A ' � � (c) - 1.x98 Mandalay Pozn�, E. R. Hiunter, residence, va�a.- - �. ance from �'ecleral I'�ood Regulati.ons �o pe�mit con-, . � struction of garaq�/sL•ox�ye area with break--away � . ' waZ3.s beiow f].00c1 e�.evation. . ' ' ' � � . Owner - �dwin R: �tunte� ' • , . ,-� ' .� 1 , Repres�n�ative - I3arzy S. Cline, A��orney . . (d) - 71� S. GulEview A].vd. , Hi].i:on ilo�el, variance� ixom ' = Coas�al, �ans�xuci:�.on Code �o extend existing remov� . : : �. � � able wooden. dec}c ].4.G ft�. a.n�o x6 ft. seawall a,�ea. , , : �-,. � ' . , . Owner - I,ane �Indus�tzios , Inc,. . . . � Represen�a�ive - Goodsmi.i:h �nt�szprises , , . . ' 2. New .I�usiness � � . ., � 3: Ol.d busin�ss, , " ,. . � ` . , �. Adjouxnmenl: � � �� , . , . � , � � � . , . ;, , a. . . ; , � , ' . �. . - ' � < ' �'� � � . . , . `{ . {,,. ,.k, F�. �, . .. . _ , � �Ew� ,. ... . ��a . , `_� �.��' : •.,� -, . . . . , `'�, .,�. �:.,; d n ' „'^----------•.�.-.��.----�-� .......�..��...�._-..--�.—..._.... �..�....—,.....M ..............._.....,r......�.,....-�r..�,..,� —' ' f : . . . . . - -- . � ' � � . ° �`Y. � . . . , 'i t ' ' � ' , ', � , ' + ,�� kl! , � , .�yy' f ,� 4 v+ U,r y �' � O 1N� pl ' ? ' � � ' ' � ' � ' -� � f ,_-� � iF � ,� ' � ' . 1• ! l. � � � . • ` . '� •� . • Q• � . '�rr� � . ' � � . � , • , , r1, �� . +�� . � ' �� l�3 �: 'i'� r ' .. . . . � � � ���� � �j;� . ' �'" '� . �� ,��+ .�1"�,'� . , � �� � � 1+�'� � L� ��r� �5�� : ' a .,� 3''� . • �;' : � M ' � �w� � �t�� '���, ' � . , a � (� . : CR " ' ' ' � � C a r' Sxi �� w..a � � � � W . • ' � � • � Ci � �, � �' i.! ,.-r• � ' H � , . �.' . , ,1 h ��� , ,,,,. x � � �� �� a �` � � i a .��e : .� � . � � s �� , �''' , :s a . �� � � � oa ,.., : �o � s a � +n < < . b��'' � � � � � � �� ' �i y. � F .. ,�•?!��^ co ± �;m m � h � %�t,� ..�{ •�,a. .�� � . �, � . .�i . . �, 7 , . I � � .� � . , � , � � . ", � �, ' � Y-j („�,� ' . . �' � , � � � . ' j.-ty�t.fi. �j .4 i l, ' � � : i � � � d . , .. � � l' �:1� .k,{^�i:�.,� '��y. '.i.. � ' � r `� b � , . � , , ., � . ;� �,�; 1 �. 'li.t ;�'t� � "�^i �� �j ' � . . • :�' a+ � �� . ' "?"�p !'i' . . . . , t�. ; �.�. LZ 11i ' • iY' F.- .�'t : , �. � , � m � � � � ' `� � - t' � . . k.�` • ■ ■ �A ' ° � m o � . °r° � , , , t . oo � .-t • ..., , a , m � ♦ `, ; �. `" � , . . � " . ° a , ��, , � � �.. .F � � � � . c� ... � a �, a� .� � .- ,� � � �' ° � o , n • � , Q • p � ' ►� A '. • . ! , !7 Q� � , � � ' ,, Ci C1 � ' , . � � , .. � .� . . � � a�i � . � •�� . � ` , o i � � � ' " t � �. ` , . �.� � Q ' � �`".. . �.,� ■ �r1 Q! � � . . " . , . A4 v+ v �y . , , . � , " '� , � 4 Q . � , . . 3 . . � , � � � � . . � , � �"f .' ,� �a�a � � � ' ' � "`� '. ° ` a o� o � , � � � � w�e p � • ' . W � O q ' ,..� ' . � '. . � . . ' • ►d �A� ' +�1 Q � �,.. , � �1 f��l � , . - � � . ' � ar � . ' ' � � w � � � � � ' . . � � H '� �• � O Q � • C x. .O�a � , !,! • ' � a m �aQ W p� - � . - m . ' . � � w � . ' t � ' F; S ' (� `� �• Q s�!'� . �' •, � � . , • , � « �� Q� � i , O , ' � • (t . � M , fA ? ' - • . � l ,��, � � . • � , � � � i � . i � . � _ . . � . , . , r . � • . , , . �, . � , . . .. . , ' "i{-'r�H�.d�4S'rka.�rii�::1�i7."y��ii�ki:.� � � 4 i �'c�_{•�,:.k:�'�.' ;r. :,}' ; , , ' . , - � . �. •. :. . . ' �������''h. i ` � ` .{,�f{�'S��ti ��1 � •.�',,� • .� . '�, ' ' . �� ,� . � L ' ' ' ' - . , . i. ,r L ' . . . . ' . ' , � � � � . ' . � < , � ' . � . �'' .�. ` � � . i . , . , � 1 � . � 4J. � , . ' . � . . . . � � . .1 , . 1�,��'��, ��`. .... �� .F� . . � ' � , . ' � ' ',§b� , S'�` :�: -: C ^ � '. . . . . , ' ' i . . � ' fJ 1 ' ' , ' � ';1'� 7, . •' . •'E��,,' ` {�4 �r� ' r' '� � � �• � � � . . � ' �. , .. . . ' . .� ., 1. ��, ,� . , .F` . . ri ' j . ' � , . � i . . . ' . , . . ' . }' . . 'F � � ' � ', '. � i . ' ' � . � . ' ', . : ' .' . . :i. �; i,. - }. 3�, .' „ �', u , . . , , , , ' . , . j ' ��' �.f '' y � ' -i�, !,•`'• • �� �` , , . , i � . , ' � - � ' �'_.`' ltY�='.%iS':��"�x' ��;"�''�'D•:,tt'... ,� i:. . _ ��.rz . n..�. �i , . . . � ` ' � � � . � . � . . • � � � � , � . ;� ;,Ta . ' ' r,a-�� * ' ' r ' , ' � . .. + , , j� � � ' , ' ' , . k ' �. . . . .1 .I ' , ' � . " ' . , ° . , � , � ' No�xxC,� o� nvnT,zc tic;n�zttac � . � ' . Board of. Ad3ustmen�' and Ylppeat nn I311xlding/1 load ConLrol. . ; � Annex ConLerence Room, Citiy 1ia11 1lnncx, XO Sou�h Misspuri 7lvenuue � � � ,. � �Wednesday, June 18, 198G at 2 p. m.. ' ,, • , � 1. ,j J � ° Ta consxder the following reguests: ' , � . • I, � � . ,� � . 1. 530 Aiandalay 11vc�tiue, T.�tSal t4ote�, vazi.ance �zotn SL•andard , � � , � i3uilding Cocie Sec�a.on 1,Z13.3 l•.o permxl: ins�alla�ion o�� �• � � � , ou�side spiral staa.rway. (Ilamm��}cl} . . , ' , . , , 2'. 1.767��i��i Leo Lane, Lea Lana Ap�zrtments variance irom � ' , . ; S�andard 'Bui.�di.ng Code �or ins�al.lation a� wire glass/ � � � � alumi.num tramecl windows 1.0. � it. �rom pro�er�y line. � . ,;: :3: � . ' ( 3 M. �nvestments ) . . � : . � � , , r , , ���'�� �. 3. � 3.198 hSanclal.ay Pc��.rrt, �. � R. iiuntcr residence variat�ce T�om � : r Fecleral �lood Reg'ula�ions �o permit aonstruai:iorti' o�' garage . � , ��. , areas with break-away walls beiow �lood ].evel. �(�dwin R. iiuntez? -. f- " '. �. 715 S. Gul�view II�vd. , IIilton� llotel variance �rom Coasta3. � �., e Cons�xuci:ion 'Code La extend exi.st�zng removable wooden deck , •-, � . � ' � �.�E.6 �i: in�o• 1t3 f�. seawaZ3. area, (i��ne �ndusL•ries) . , - , . , I'l.nrida Sta�u�e 286.01.05 states : Any aPplican�. a�peal.ing a d�-- ' . cxsa.on of Ghis I3oard mus�'lzavc a vcrb.�L'�.m rc•cord �� th� pro- ' �' aeed�.ngs .ta suppo,r� sucii an appea�.. , ' , . • . '" , ' � �i�izens may appear to be heax,c� or �i.J.e wxit�l:en no�ice a£ � ' aPPxoval� or oUjec�i.,on wiL-h the [3ua.�ding I]�.rec�or, P. 0. C�ax . '' • �� 474'8, Clearwater, rioria� 3351a ► rprior f:o aJ�propri.a�e Public .� . lieazing. � ' � , , ' � � , � ��,, � . � � . , ' � ' , , . �i,. .� � ADV, G/13/8G ❑ynGlyia T:. Gaud'c�u, C:�,�y Clerk „ � �:�. . , , . . � , f ' . ' ' , . � , . • � , , . ±� 3 . . . , . . . � � , I . i . � Y e . ' , • . „ � . . . I , � � � . �I i 1 ' ` �[: i t , . ' . , . t . . . . . . � 1 . � . . . . y . , . F. . , � . . 'f � � ' . , � , ' , . • � �� . . i ' . . , ' , � . � ._ , . . i , ' 1 '�� . � ' . � , � � � � . . � ' � . � , ;i f .. . , � , .. � . 0. . � ` . � ' . , i � �... ; ,.,��� '��1. � I . ' � ! , . i � . . . /}� .y{" �t� . . Y'�f+iiF . !-;'1.it�: �i�'��f�+�F:�1;��:��i Wi^:(. .�-.. i}ry�,�} 2 a; ..f.,i "�1� . � ` : :.: <'i � ,r� tJiy •.i .`I. , r'�y' .. .. . . r ..1 .