Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
01/11/1984
�,� �t��.�, t,°, •r'; ',r`. . ' i . . . . . , . . . . , : . . . , , . �I�t,���;. : y�' '�, � .: . . . . . t ' 1��s �1•i j7� �,, ' . . � . � � � . .�r��� F: : Y .' � Y , . . . ' � . , ' ►.�'' � . . ' . s . , �, � � .. ' 1 • . , I I � ' . • � ' ' � ' ' . . r. . . , . . , , . . F , � ' . , . ' , � . , . . . . � , � 4 . . i#f� . � . '.i. . ' 1 . . � � � ' ` � , . ' t� ,�:�s'. ' , ' . , � , , . . �, ' , ' ,. s . . � ". . . : ., > , , � ' � � � ' , �� ' ' • . ' ' ' ., ; .. . ,; � >d , ` , . , _ , , . °'; l,t,,�-.f , . 'c. . -, , . � , . �;f� .� . . , � ' � �, , ' ' 1 � 'f S . . � � . � ' r • ' . - ' , ' � :Y. � . � � � .t�� � � , � , � ' ' '_ . . ' . � . � 't,:� t.�5 . , • . . : . . ' . ' . ' . � , � � i •u.� , � . � , . � � ' � " . ' r ' � ' . 7 r � . . . ' ' . . ' � - :�f � ' .'. • •/ 'E � - . ' ' . . � F ' : , ,. . ! . .t' IUl�...n . � . F � , �,�1:.? . .,..�3�.ia ., s .. . . � . �. . � . �� � . . . ' � . � !� . �.I �,,. J. v'�..7� . . / .� � . � � ' . ' � ' , ' ' • ' , f . . . ' . � . ' . ' � � . . � � � � , ` ' . ' . , . � ' . , � � . . ' , � � ' . ., d . ' � ' � , � , , � ' . . i. . � � , ' ' ` � ' , ' � • . . . . . � ' � I. 7 , . , � • � . . .. i. �� � � . � �. � � 1VIII�ZJ'�ES . . � -. , : . � � , E.. . . . , . . . : , � , ., . . � . . - � . ��j� �� �� � : � � � � � � �.A�.,A►� , � . � � �� � �� � � . : . _ . � . � . �. -� . . . � ��.�� F , , . ', � ' . . ' . . ' � . . 1 i . � . ' . . , r � : r. .. . , . , . 'r,.. , . , . . � . . � �,� . � �� �IJI]C�I]�l�G� �i �`L��Y) � . � � ., . � � , . . . ' . � . , . k ° ' ' • r � � , . , . .� � � . ' . . . � � • � � ,� ' . � • � , � ' ' , ,' • ' ., , , � � � DATE ! ,.,,,. ..o. � � � � � � , . , . � � , ,� . . . , � . . . , � � � . . , - � � -����. _. ( � ��� , � � �� . . . . . , . ., . . . � . � � ' . . . . . . 1 ' . . . I � � � � . . ! . � � � � . r. . � . . • ♦ . ' . . � . . ' 1 . . ' ' ' , � . . . . . . � I . � ' ' i ' , 1 � 1 , F e . ' ' 5 • ` . . . . ' r I � . . ' ' � i , � , ' . } . . . ` . M1 ' �... y��4�1�' ' } ':a .,�� ^ � f. � ....�a . , ti� 1+-.�� .. .. .•A'.. . - ��, �.f{�A .� � . ' • �t ��� �I. � . 1 ''. .. n �� � 5 ��i ti � '� � ! S Ft , � ' , � _ ' . � - . f' � '�� = I , . , � I: • . , 4 ; , . . , 1 , f E� • 1°, • � � , , ! S . > � . . ' . ' f , . r��;.. � ., . 1`�i. . .. � . , . ... . .,. . � ,. , 41 � . , • � � � � ' , 'l ��` i � . � i� ,. �, , aa��r� or n�s�M�t��r & ����r��, $tJILDING � ��,00n cor��l��o� wednesaay, January �.�,, 1984 � e � �Members presen�: ,• . � , 'John i,ogan -- Chair�nan � � � Edward Wal,ker , � � �. Joseph Straub . . ,' , � Gearge Biron ' � , � � Andrew Onufer� �Secretaxy of E3oard • , . A�so present :. " ' , � , �David Chris�iansen - Chie� of Snspecti.ons � � t3ick Lewis - Fire xhspectar • Tne maeting�vras called �o a'rder by Chairman Logan at '2:05 p. m. , . . � Mr. Logan adv�.sed th� Board that Case,No. 2 nn the agenda requcst- ;, a vara.ance to construc� a swi,mmzng paql encl.osure.a� G96 Snug xsiand had been wi�hdrawn. ' - � � Cas� No. 1- Ruth �ckerd Hal]. i�'AC'�) J..1�.1 r1cMu1].en-Bonth Raad - a var.i.ance . from S�andard Building Code, Sec�ion �.121, �xit Si.gn Rec�uirements.� Repre- senting PACT were Mess�s. A�.�red Hoff.nian, Presiden� - I�loward Gro�h,..Secre- -� tary - Wesley Pe�ers, Chie� Architec� for Frank.Lloyd Wrxght �- John {GUS) D�fenkolb, ca�sul�.ant �o I�ir. Peters - and' tavo �epxesentatives of th� con- tractor. Mr. Loqan asked for a spnkesman from the group to pr'esen�. their case or arguments to �he Board. ��.. , , Mr.'Hoftman advised �he Board tha� PAC'I` was cert�in thex had co�npii�a wi�h Code regarding ��ze f#.re ex,i� sign� �rtd Mr. Pei:exs �nc� 1�3r. Degenkolb were a�. this meeL'ing �o es�abliah th.is with t�ie Aoard. Mr., Hoffman xefexred �o the continenta�. seating arr�ngeme�z� which has a beaxing on this case, , . and stat�d he a�so ��anted ta da.spel any iears i:hat PACT was more sensi�ive ° to aesth��ic va].ues �.han in sa�ety factors. Mz. HoFfman further.°�nade re�erence �o newspap�r 'az:�icles regarc3�.ng ceztain o�hsr vi.ola�i.ons a� PACT whi.ch he indicated were furnished or. "1.eaked" L-a i:he news media }�y �he : � au�.3.ding I7epar{:ment. ' ° � t '. Mr. Onu�er, Acting Buildiizg Director abjectec� �a the a�.legati.on that the � ; Building Denax�ment.had °�eaked" informatioil st•a�ing tlie Building Depaztmen�, has no secrets and anyane in �he`Ci,L-y has access to public records. Any-- �hi.ng rela�ive �o PACT �hat had been made publa.c was in�ormation secured , by xeques�s ta examine �he rer,qrds. t•Sr. f-ioEfman apolig�.zed but 8�d sia�.e �hat a m�mk�er of �he bui.].ding depar�m�n� hac3 made a state�nen� tv a xepor�er to the effect that a nu�nb�er of continu�.ng vzoZa��.ons w�re being bypas�ec3 , and overl.oak�d and thi.s particular exit• sign issu� was one, oF them. Mr. Onu�er coun���ed that �h� r'epar�er �nd sevc:ral others haa examin�d �h� Liuilding Departmen� files. , � Aix. Wesley Peters spnke advising the board �ha� his firm had�been extrem�ly assiduous in designing a buildin,g whicYi is no� onl.y in conformance w�.th the spirit bu� with �he le�ter. oP �he prevailz.ng govern3ng codes.� p9r. Degenkolb . � : � . 'Y' ,� �� . .'.� � � �, s + �.=9;�.' , . � t • .+(?:;'; r', • � - � ! n.. ... , r �f � � , 3 .. � . ,., • .1 . � .. � . •� � . i r . S � . � . . r , ,i i � . ?.} � �� ' � � { r ` . ,BOAA Eiuilding/I'iaod Coritroi • � � 3anu�ry 1.1, �984 • ' � , Page 2 �' ' ' whom they�consider to b� an outstandir►g co.de comp�.ianC� expert, was em- pl.oyed by �hem as a consultant, and it was neve� .their izitenr'i.on a� any time to vary from the strict int�rpxetation af the cade. Mr. Pet,ers st�ted they believe what they are dc�ang i� coirect and it ther� w��s ar►y v�.ol�tian of �he code, they wou7.d want �o fcnnw �bou� i� and wouZd never�want.�o see i.� built. , '. ,Mr. �7ohn (Gus) Degenko].b was, �.ntzoducer�, hir. DegenkoJ.b s�a�'ed he had been brought in by �'ranlc Llpyd Wright ma.in�.y because he was xesponsxbl� � for �he in�roduc�ion o� cc�ntinent'al type s�a�i.ng �nd its incluGian into the buil.di'ng code. � M�. Degat�kol.b st�ated seating . arr�ngements for �he PAC� auditoxi.um were care�ull.y research2d and simula��d ta make surc dist�nce �rom the most remote seat in the ha].1. did not exceed 150 Ft. which is s�a�utory ].itn�,t under� code tor dis��nce �o an �xit. Becaus� oE some confusian regarding the wo�d "exir" in �he �ode, I�ir. Degenkd�.b had been in 'touch with b�r. Manna.ng of Southern Bui�lding Cada Congress. Inte�nationai. 2rrc. and Mr, rlanning agzeed that �he daers frotn � the audi- fi.orium, into thc�lobby are no� "ex�t daor�" bu� are "exit 'acress doors", Tf �he dis�ance of trav�l exceeded 1.50 �t. then o�her prov3.sions wou�d have,had to been made �ax exi�ing, i.e. fire separation, etc. etc. Since Zess fihan 15D ft. they are exit access dooars and �here�are na� reW quired under 5ectian 3.I.Z]. af the Code. Cantinental seating grovides for £.ive rows o� s�a�ing with,pairs u� doors ai:�each end so that ger- sons entering and �eav�.ng �he theater use ozsly �hose doors �t,either end of the z4ws as st�.pu7.a�ed� on their t3seatr� ticke�s and �.t zs not ri0Ce5S�Yy �ar �hsm �o ��avei lat�erally th� length of the �heatre. Ii thexe were a prob�.em on on� side o� �he theatxe� persons would �ravel sideways ta other side for exxt.� It �.s �o� that reason that there is �ddi�ional spaci.ng between rows of seat9. t�ir. D�genkoib elaborated � � further on o�hear principles o� design and l.ighi:ing o� PACT ha�� which ensured emergency exit oE people in �wa ma.nu�.�s,as com�a�ed with five' minu�es to �xit �rom conven�ional. th�atre. Nir. �eg�nko�.b then re�era�ed � �0 5ec�ion 404.150 af �he Cod� khich sta�c�s �.ighted exi� signs ar� not requix'ed a� each indivi,dual doo�way where daors apen Pram main auditar-- ium seating area. ' At this point Mr, A�fred �lofFinan stated tha� mare �han anytl�ing e1se.PACT �.s very sensi.�ive �o the desirability and necess�.�y of pro�ecting �he public. Tha� is t;hc number one priority. eu� having aomplied with cod�s they �ee1 very s�rongly abaut �he aesthetic distraction exi� ].igh�s v�ould crea�e. . , Mr. Onufer spoke in opposi.i:ion st�t:ing he fe��. exi� signs are beau�i�u1� �'and not an unsightly dis�raation, par�icular�.y in �his ar,ea wh��e tttere is an abundance,af.el.derly people who waulc� need h�].p in an emerg�ncy ' exi� fram . �he builr�ing. Mr. Chzistiansen•con�inued ma]cing re�erenc� �o many in�ractions o� tl�e cade pertaining �o por�als, 1igh��.ng, ais�.e spacing� etc. and s�.ated �he City has be�n workinq c�osel.y wx�h PACT in att�mp�ing �o correc� these viol.3�a.ons bu� were not g�tti.ng the desirec3 cooperation from PACT. _ ._,��_.�----...__.�.._.._.-- .� .� - - . ... . ,� `.,�������:'�� �.� � .,�� . . , i ,� � .�',�a':,�I l � , �iq`' t `. ' . . � . r. ' , ' � , ' � „ . l F.' , ' � . k � � . � , . , . . , • . ) . ` . , � , �. . i � .. 3 ' � s � � s � � � � i • � � � . , �;. . i �•, � � �a f}• � , HDAA Au�.].d�.ngfF].00d Control � . �anuary 11, 1984 � . Page 3 , Mz. Chris�iansen then•read from�a I�tter,From Mr. William Tangye, Executive 1]irectior of� SBCC who stated "only pzablem with the system is i�i not pro- ` vid3.ng exa.� sa.gns �rom �he assemb�.y area. Sectioi�s 90�.15 anri 1123 re-- quir� tha� �hese cloorways be identi�ied by �xit signs and tha� �he oniy �ime exit.signs can be omitted is over �he main entxance door �c� �he building." A�,Chaxxman Logan's xequest, Dtr. Chris�iansen re�zd from 5ec�ion '40�l. �.5. � Speaking' in behal.f of tYie �'ire Depar�mer�t Na.ck Lewis said �hey were very , hard set on the requirement For �xit signs, no� only from a code campli- �ance standpoint but a7.so consxdezzng �tte �ype of s�ruc�u�e, its use and the age bracke� o� �he. many cit�.zens wl�a use i.t. Mr. Lewis referrcci to Sections 8-2.1� and 5�.0.1.0 of the Lif� Sa�et}• Coc�� �to su�port h�.s argu- ment tha� visib].e exit signs are mandatary. He furt�hex q�o�ed from � Appendix A- A-5-1D.0.0 -- which states th� need ior sxgns. is grea�er in any building subjec� to tr5nsient occupan,cy. Mr. L�wi.s continued by citing from hi.s own abservat�ons anfractions that should be corrected in additian �o �he exit si.gns �o ma}ce �it p�ssibl� to have saf� and rapid ,egress �rom the buiiding in �.he cven� of,an emexgency. Mr. pnufe� sup- ported Mr. Lewis' arguments and alsa m�n�i.aned some o� his awn persona]. observati.ans. , ' . A very �.engthy discus,sion fallowed l���ween City' and PAC�' representativ�s. Various sections oE codes w�re ci.�ed an� arg�sments and code in�erpre- ' tatiaris pzQSented by boi:h sides. Infzacta.ans were menL-ioned nat p�r- tinent,�o this meeti.ng and assurance was given to th� City �hat �hese wauld be co�xected by pACTi a.n .a titn�ly tn��nner. t�ir. Ftoffman assured the Board and th� City �ha�t � he wouYd personally see ttiai: al]. , areas of vio- latiotts wer� corrected immedia�ely, but�an �he matt�r a�� self-i�lumin- ating 3.ic}hts, PAGT felt �hat for. aesthe�ic purposes they should continue to p,ress Eor what �hey feel is a cpxrect interpre�atian o£ th� cocie. Be- ,cause o� the conflic�ing infor[na��.on (exchange of inEarmati.on between SBCC and Mr. D��g�nkolb and informati.on supp�.ied by b1r. Tangye, Si3CC ir► a letter) Mr. �ioffman asked �ha� �]}e � Soar.a withhald any c3�cisxon un�il � c�.a�i�i�cation is recea.ved from SisCC. � A� Mr. Logan's reques� Inspector L�wi,s c�mmen*ea further on sec�.ions of �he code dealing wi�Y� exi� s�gns anc� s�.ated he disagrsed wi�h PAC�"s in- ' terpretat�an of the code. He' also menta.oned �he many �calls he hac3 r��- ceiv,ed from concerned citizens voiaing thei'r conasrn abou� paor lighting ' and ].ack of exit signs in the n�w building. , � , . Aiore� da.scussion followed regarding not anly �he exit signs but �he sub�- jec� n£ ligYs�a.ng and Chairman Logan a�ked tli�t a11. d3,scussion be re- la�ea to 'the subject at hand -- cxit signs. , Chairman Logan asked for commen�s from board members. Mr, �i.ron responded � tha� (}.) withou� �.he background on the ma�ter tha� l�oth City and. PACT xepresentatives hav� he found the confXfc�ing interpretations coniusing; •�. . , � , . '. a � � ,� ���.... � r i .' . �� ,� ,� ,� � :', j � �': ' � •. t: ��'• , �•: °� . `� , ,n'. � , . , �� , . . •F i 1 � ,. F . � ' . = 1 1 . � ' . / , ' , , , R.r.II ' . y. •, y :�i .. y, . . .. . � E 1 / 1 � ��"' ' � e�'' � , . . , # . , , ' � BOOA i3�uilding/�1.00d Con�.rol ' January 11, Z984 � " � ' . . Page 4. . . , (2j he wouZd ].ike an oppartunity �o �iew the site; and (3) he wau].d - l�,ke �o knaw .ff Mr. Tangye's, opinion naw differs From �he op.inion ' expressed in hi.s l.et�er to the City in �ep�ember oE 1380. h1z. 5traub , agreed tha'� clarificatian from Mr. mangye and�SBCC was necessary, , . particulazly considering �he �.i�e safety Eacto�, Gliaizman Logan � stated �he ma�tex had to�be resolveci.� There seemec7 to he no hope of a compromise. � � MQre discu�sion.and.argumen�s pro and con follow�d �aetween City and �.. PACT. rfr. Logan reques�ed that hlr. Christiansen r�ad �rom thQ se��ion �! of the code pertaining to exit lights. � •Tn response t4 t9r. I,ogan"s request fnr a vote, the boaxd stated� �hat they - were unable to arra.va at � decision on the mattex. Mr. �,or�an suggested ', that��he Baard adjourn°at this time, xe-conven� at the PAC� site,�and � � then� a�tempt to arrive at a�decisa.on. , I� �aas mutua �.1y agreed that the -" Board and City represen�a�ives wauld meet a� PACT,a� 9 a, m. L'r.iday, � ' �7anu�ry 1.3, 1.984. , � . � � ' � ,, The mee�i.ng was adjourned a� 3:4Q p, m. td�.11 reconvene" at 9 a. m. at PACT, 1111 McMu�len-Booth'Road an January 13� 198�1. , �� , The �oZ'�.ow�,ng infoxmation svas ph�ned �o �he xecording s�cxetary by Air. •� ��'ohn L'ogan fal].owing the �meeta.ng with �ACT at the PACT sit� on Friday, � � January 13: � ., mhe commiti��e (�oardj concurs wi.th Scction 4D�1.Z5, paragraph (o? pf �- 'the SBCC in r�gard to the Exi�. signs over th� por�als. The Baard de- �cided �hat �hey,we�e nat gxanting � variance since a varian�e was no� required si.nce they a�ready con�orm wit� SBCC �as:ag�rapti (o). The . Board further c]ee�.ded �hat the lighti.ng i.11uma.na�ion ,oF the portal would conform �o �hc: requireman�s of the SBCC and Cha� �he exit 1i,ghtis outside o�'th� portals would alsp canform. � � The Baard �ur�.hex requested cl�ra.�ication o� the 1.etter sent to �he `, C1ea�water Bui].d�.ng D�par�men� �rom SBCC in xegard to the exi�•l�.ghts as they felt �he first Ie�ter was in error and want con�S.rmation o� ' �his, ' . � ' Mr. Loc}an �urCher stated �ha� �he Hoarci was.not granting a variance �rom ��he Lif� Safety CflC�P. The I�oard does not have t�.he authari�y to gran� variances �rom l,ife Sa�ety Cc�de. � ` � � . ' John Logan, Chairman �' . �;,, : _, r , .r : -_"__"�'"''� , , f �i ' e 1 t� ecording S r�tary I ..e � w .�i :� .,� ���.���v���,Y��� :;��'`�-t , : ..' . . . �, � � . , . ' � , , . � `,�rit�i�y.�'a`c.s; . . , , . . , . .` ' . . 'j' . i �, ��;, ' . • . . � ' ' . . ' 5 ' � o . / • . . . � . 'I'.'! ?�.``} . �F' , .� r • ' ` . ' . i • ,' . .. . � � ' . � � � 1 . , . •i. . . � f . . . ' � � . �� �•�.- `a� I . . =i ,. . . . � ' r . . . . 1 � ' � ' ' � ' . . vP. . . i i , } ' f i . . �' • . ' � i • � . � f . . I s ' � . ! �y 1 , . . � � . � ' . . ' . ' ' r � 'I '� � � ,Se, `. .♦ �'. 11' !, . �- � I . '' �1�'i � ' ; ' �. r .i } ' ' r r . . , . . I . i' ` ',1 , • . � � � I ' , P , , _ . ' ' �_�ir'� , .,`�£':� . ., _. , ,y.,"..�k:i;:.?i�w"n'o'{.j.r , , .. .- _ .. . . . . ' •f, ' . . ' . , , ' . . , .. , ,�.,t� - ' - , , , ' • � " � � ' . . � � � r � . . ' f/}5?'" , . . . . ' . ' . i ♦ � r " • ' ' t.j, . � ' ' . . ' ' . . . . � . � . . � ' . ., i . " . . , ', • . ' ' � , • � � I� . . . � . � ' • ' . ' � � ' ' . . . . ; , , , ' .. HOARD pF ,ADJUST�ENT & APP�AL � , , , ' , . . • ' � � ' ;BUILDING/FLOOb COI3TROL ' � � , . � � , . SVednesday , �anuary � 1 , ].,984 � ' ,; � , , � , � . : . . , , . ' , ACTION AG�NDA ' � ' , • � � � , . , , � � ; � : � � ACTION � , �. � . 3..' 'Pub�.ic Iiearings ' . . ' • r i 1 ' � . ' . � �� � (a) , Ruth �ckerd �ia11, (PACT} 11I1 !•!cl�7ullen- Con�inued� u= - ,� .�., I3ooth' Road, variance �zom Standard �ui1d- � ti1..1/13/Bi f ,'ing Code, Section.,112]. Exit Sign.require- � , , � ments. (�ACT) . , , , � �� � , . ;, . , . � � ,(b) . G96 Sn�g zs�and (Lot 57, i3nit 7B I,1.�nd Widthdrawn �' , • Esta�esj - variance�from Coastal. Con- ' ' ' si:ructzc�n Cade 390G.2 for construc�i.an . � ' ` , . of swimming paa1. enclosure, (B�ank) � ' '' .2. Minu�.es o� Meeting af Decer�ber 14, ' 1983 �.Continu�d � � •t ;�� . . , , , , - .. 3. Acijouxnment : ' � E Adj�urned 3.:40 � , �� p.m. -- �o� rE-- � . � . , � . • , . convene J./13/84 , . . � � A. Pd. ' �. • .. Januar 13, 1.9F34' (9 a.m. ) , � � •1. i'ub].ic Hear.ing (At FACT,site�-��i1 McrSu:llen-Baoth) ' � ' '� (a) Continua�ian of Ru�h Eckerd iia1Z request Grant�d. P:.CT ., • , ior variance.� (PACT) � � , �. � �� to apply �n •�� ._ ,. ' . . , , , ' � PCGL}3 Life Safe�y . ' ,. .' ' . � • for additional ' �.� � . , ,' variance. � , � 2. .Adjourninen�. � . • ' , � APPrax: ].Q a:m. ,. . 3 . . ' . ' . � ! . • 1 . . ' ' I . � � � . fE ' t , � ' 1 � i . . � � � • � � •�' � e � . • ' . , . , ' . . . t ' . ' � } I � . ' , r . � „ � . ' . y t ' • t . , ' � � ' . ' � � . . , ' ' ' . � � , ' a ' . � � . , • ' . � . ' ' ' � � . � . . , � . � . , ' � . , � , . � - . t• , � � ' . � ` . � ' ' ' , . . � :f' � � e ' t � ' � ' � � ' • ;.si�.'�4 +.,r�' =C., •a<, '.}. S. ,( � . . . . . . ' . ' SLi r� !4 3i:xii�'' r''' . . : � s- . . . . " . r �. , . . , . . _ . � �irg� ,,�.r.�.�.�>.•V c ,; � . '• .. . � • ' ' . .. � . . ,� ' , . � 1. , ' , . � , . . ' ' . ` . . ;��j+�Yta'j��r: ��j�S� ,,`: ir'. . �'�, ' . . . i . . ,,h_.�y �?� :�}r'.�i '. ';�• ' � . ' ' . . , . r , �i r rj,':�f�' , ��, � ' �' ' .. r � . � . . F � i . . ' ' � , �� ` ` }r . a . , . � . � F • . . , ' �".W�� .� �i. � . . . e . . . . ' � r ' . . . , . �. . � s �r� �^41� ; :.' ' . ', • . ' , , . , r . . . . . � . . � . �i ` ' . p � • . ��. ' , � i` • _. ' ' • ,�' � , � ' . ' , � ' . "' . ' , � ' ! � .! �`.i�, V�. ;�fy .° �� ,;�, ... � � . . � � � � ' � , .. , . ,,�� . .' , . ��! � .. ,`� � • . , . . . r ' , : � , . � �. �, . . ' r' . , , , ' � . ' . . , , ' � ' ' � . ' r � �:'�•'3' 1. ' F � � .. , t� � , � � ' . �1 � . � : � s . . , � . � , .' r. 1, f � , �, _ , ( , ', t �„fs: ,'' �. , . -s ��. ,�� . , � t . . ', , � ' ' . : � � � , � ' � , ' , .� � � . ' � N'. � ? . ti'�j . . , . . . � . ' , < � ; . t�R.� e• '� � �� �.=T.'k`�.:e�} � �/•u�'y: l,z • t . ' . ' � . ' � ' � , � . , , ' ' .. . ` �Fi..:s:«;.�:;�.�,. .., �{i:. .. . .'sy:+:•..�.E;�r1i:�s�... ..,�;.�f_:i �"'.. � . ' ., .�., � , , r. ' ` . • . . ., r . . . . . � .,.. r. ����. , _ r , . • � . ' . ', 1 � '� '�1' ' . , r . ' • �� . . � . .�� , �� � , , � k. ' ' � , , . � . ' 1 ' r . �. ' . '' � �� ' , ' ! , , . � ; � , . .� . . i' . . . , . , � � i , , " � � , � , s . . � . . ' ' . ' � . � , : • � . ' gOARD OF AC3�7USTMENT & AI'I'�AL ' . � • ' � �� . � ' � . . � BUILDINGIF'I,�On CONTROL ' . � . .. �t , . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . ' . � . . , t Wednesday, January J.1•, .].98� � � . ' , �. � , , . . . , . � AGENDA ° - � . • . � . . � ' . . . , , . . F , . . ' ,t . '. � ' . � � . , . . . � . . s � � �. Pub}�ic He��a.ngs • ; � � � � � . :, _ . . , � � . , . • � , . . . - : � . . ., , . . � � ;' -� (a) Ruth Eckerd Ha11, Zi11 McMullen-Boa�.h�'Road- :. :�,� , . - �requesting varia,nce f�om 5tiandazd .Buildinr} �� ' " � . �, , � Code, Sec�ion �1�2�. Exi.t, Sxgn r�quirements. . � ' ' . ' � � ;s �. � (PACT) � ' • , , . , , � . . . . � . ., , . � f , • , . •. , , , , ..' ' , Representa�ive - Haward G. Groth � ` � - _ � • '. � ', . � ' , � • .. � , . • , . . ��. � (h) 696. Snug Island (Lot 57, ilnit 7B Ts].and �• a"� � � <<:�::': : � . , .. . 1�1, . , , , :, , �states) - reques�ing vazzance from Coastal \�� . r �'���:-' '• Constxuc�ion Code 3906.2 tor cons�ruction a� �r ' , � ' ,, . • ` � . �' • . �°�'�-_ � . � swimming poo� .enclosure. . (Blank) ' . � . ,. �. , , . . � . �'. ` . , � � a . �� ' . � � R�presentata.ve - �'red, B1.ank � - . � . , . , ' , , . � � ' � .. 2. Mi;nu�es of Mee�ing of �e'cember 14, Z.9a3 , --' :. � �. 3. Adjournment . , , � ' � . � ,� . , . , . , � , ' . . , � � , ' . , ' ,. , . ' , • - . . e . � . ,� , . � ' � , , . • . ' ° � , , . . . � , � ' ' ' � . ,' ° . � � � �� . � � . . � � � � . ' f ` . , . . � � �. �. , , . . ' , ' � ' � � ' � . . � � , ,- � � , . � . � ,� � � , � , . , � ° � � � � � , . , , , . , . � , .. . . , � , . ; . , , i,. , , , . . . , . � . . . F . . ' , . , .[!: � . ' . . ' ' . . . . , . , s .. . � .. , . � . � � , � � � , ' . . ' � . ' . ') `. `. .� 4 f � ` � . F .� . . . " ' ,'�tln'irv{�..�,'-'�!' . �"fr.%::i��:L:Y'.. � i` ;s � 'f . , _ . ft�;�f• x' � �� .i.: ,f�� , . . . .. � . . . , " . , . � , �� . i � _ , . . �" L' �'�' o " ' ' ` �' ' ' ' ' ' � . ,�l; � Y'- . , . . . . . . . , . . . . . , � , . .. . y:,;;,�,���� ��,: :f . , , , . , , , �fi' � �� � ; .F ' � E . ` ' ' . � ' ' . . ', � . � , . . � ' ` .,. ..� . , . � , ' , . . ' . � . . . " . . . .. � ' �. , � , . . � j. • � • . ' . . � ' � . . . � . a i ' ' . ] . ' - < . ` 1 ' 1 '4Y� � -i-�. ' , `,i'! , ,r' � , , , . . ; ' ' ' � r , i .. ` � . , , t: ' 1. , ,S'r �,�,�i �s: 3 .: � , , . ' � � t . ' . � ' . . , j ' r . . � ., r . ' , ' : ' ' � , . . . ; . .� ` . � . ' ' ' 'i `. r '� ,` , } ` . • f f . , . , ' . � =.:9� , . i . • v • , f ' E..c ,. � ( . . , i , � � � � ,' • + � � `' ' ;�'• 'j.t ' . . . . � � . � , . . ` n . . ! � � � � . � , � • � � . +�tt'�.i', .. ? r . � . .. , �s ' . . .6 . • ' .� ' '' '.Y ' ; . .. . . . ' - :� �`�`. . .` �.}: . � . I. ^a � � .. , ' . I •. 1.f� e. ' ' � ' f J ' � .. ' � , ' • ' � ' ,�iE �•� ' � , � � � .�e , �. . ' � . ' . . . . ! . . r ` ' , . � , ,��1 3�3�Y .... A.iY' ' '^4` '{f.v_•k'p ; . .'; , . . . . . f . . . . . . . � . f5 ce_ . `:.Yii. �i..i ... `1.F'. 0. t: •..�. . .. i s, .7'.. • ' 1 . (: . . . � � , i � ,� , . ' .7 . ' , . . � . . .. . . . , . .. . . . . .. 1 .... ,�'. . , . 5 ' - . � , ' . r . t I , J�'� y j `. . ' F � F' I ' F ' ' ..� ' •/ . � . . ' �) • ' , . ' ' ° . . � � r� . . ' ' . ' , t ' ! , , ' � ! ' . . , t I . , . � r . . � t � ' � .. � ' J • � . ' . 1 - ' � , . . 1 . ' ` ' •{ . ' ) � . . , ' � ' � , ' , , ! . . " , . . , , . � ' � � ' ' • • ' ' f . ' 1 . ` - a . . . � . ' � .1 ' t . . . ' � . • • • . . . a . � � e . . r ' .I . . ' � ' ' ' � e a ' . .� . . . 1.. . . .. . - . . .. ' . i . . . . � r � . . L:11 , ' . � � ' • . � ' � � ' ^ [ � • � � • � , ' , i � . . � � . . � , . . , ' , � � . . ' 1 ' ! .. . . . . d ' � � i. . � ' • 1 � . ` � • � � � '. BOARD' 0�' ADJUSTMEI�T AND� AP�'�AL . � ' � �. ' � � ' � " � � ' OK. SUZLDING%�`LOOD CONTROL , , � � , ' � � ' : � � . , . , . . , . . . ; . , . � � � - . � � . ' . � '., � , . , . , . . � . � , . . ., . . . , , , ,. • .,. . .-, . , . . , . � , . . , � � . ' , � , . ,`� �. > . � ' . ,. . � , , � . . ti �`, •"r , + . . • . , - ' � ��f � NOT�ICE OF .PUHliIC' HEARiNG'• � ' � .. � � . . . , , . ' . "1 1 ` ' ` i , ' . , �' . . . 1 . ` . ' . ' " , . ` r I . , 1 ,, , - � � � �A .mee�ing of your flaard �o .l�ear �he cases � � � � t. ' . . ' • , � . ' +i �.. � as desoribed in tlie attached No��.ce o�' Pa.�b3.�c , , �, Hearirig has beeri scheduled f;o b� held �n the .. ;� �� � • Operat�ons Cen�er Conference Room, C3.ty Ha�.l . � � Annex;� IO South Missou�i' Avenue. on': '. � , :� ' � � , . � . . . ' • . '�. � , `� . Ap�licants have been duZy no�•:Lf�.ed and � i ; F . ' -. . wil�� be' presen� , a� this mee�ing �o pres�n� '' . , the�i.r requ�s�s for varianc�s . � • � � ' � . � � ,.� � . . . � �`� � � V�ry� tru�.y . yaurs , � ' ' . � ' �� . � . . ; . , . , . r� � f � — . � � � ' .. � . J Ayr ,' Direc�or � � '. , � . . Bui],ding D�partm�nt �, � : � � ' , , . , - ,� . ; ,k, . . • . , . , �. ' � � � , RJA%� � . � � � , � � . ` , , . � ` . , . '� . Enc. ,� . , ' � . . , , , , - , , . . � . , . . . ' � . . . ' E 1 . . I J � Fs . . , 1 . � � � • ` .• � • � , ' � 1 . . � � . . . . . . . . � ' . ' ( � . . . . +� y • . .. . . .' ' , 1 r. . r . . ' . ' � .,�f•�{;9��,yc .R. ,�.' � S�_ � ���t:`�=-- -'- � ---- -'------ ,. ' .. . .' � .. . • .,�'r�'1��.�'i'i:.�tf�l`3.�17YYfE ;h . }���`,.�"ds.ei:`„c..,�_.°S �� . • . ��� i ' ' i ' . . _. _ r" ;'�i#: .�-:•�e , :,i�ti �c : ! , ., .: �.tr . '.E:< . ;t., . . .. „ , � , . „ . ° ,. ;' . , r: ,. �'����i,o«}-' .°�;1. �'3.ii! . , �F'� `,r, ; ' .. � . ';r.l • , , .. � , .. . �, , ' . . , S; ,'' � . 1"k�¢"Mot� � �� �,'� ' •ri ' , . . ., + . . . . .. � ° . . r � ' ' � . , , . . � • i � . . � ' '� •• J � �I � .. ' � � . . E . ' . f + . . � � - , i i � � r ,}� �� � . �'{ ' . ' , . F'� : ' ' ` ' . � � i . . , : ' ' • . , , ' . ' . , ` . . , j . k � ' . � . � . . � �� . . A . . . . . � ' ' 1 . . ' . . Ye '�. . � ` . , , . . . � . . . ` ' ' J .. , ' � y .. . � . � r' . +�fi� : '1 _ ' .� , . • .. . � . � ' . ' • . � �. ' � � . . " , . . � . � . ?fa�'k� �}` � �� T ���t�,.. . � .. . � � . . ' . ' ' .. . .1 , . , . . . ' ' � „ ' � • � 1 � r� � Y ; i / � . ' � . ' ' � . . ' � � . f ` .. . . ' � � � ' � , > 1 � }��.�f�`p�.'l��ti`P�' `��'�, �rs� ' � . ' `. " ' . . ,' . , , . ' „ . . . ' . . .i ` i ����. �j,'� �.i: . � , . '.!' f . � � t � � , � . . . ' ' . 1� ; . .' ° . ' ' . ,''':.�'� �,� .!'1 . . . t . 5 �� ' . ' ' . f ' . � � � . . i . . ' . ' • ' • ` ii' 5�: � F`� � �j'! fi'' ��, �7. _ ' .i��,,. `4. ' ei � � . . < � , . . . . . . •. . • ,F . .. ' .. ,t� .:Z,r'y; • • '.� ' . • . , o . ., �� . . . , � . . ' , �• . , � i„ ,".j .';,. . , 6 ,. � -1� :�� ' � ' .. . ' ' , � ° . 't , . ' ' � , . . .S . � . ` � �� .. , � •��'� . � � �I� . � s � . , i I , .'%. ��'4 � .t�' 'I t , , .. . '� i I� ' '. ' , 'J. . , . �' . . . . ' )' ' �. � ',. :r: ,i �' .. . .•?, . , .. � � .1 . �,a , . ,.4,. �� ''t , � ' � .�c' �� :r. ' • ' _ �' , ' ,� , � . � .� � , . � . , �•;�i y ,: � � I �e, : 6.[: � :�.'. �e ' , t , � . , . . �,�` r � . , . e . , f , '.`i: E�,•y": ry >;1,! ���f.r` �� �i . r � , . . ; � . .� t' ` ' . , . ` . . �' ,4; ?'.6x'e. . �I:tc4 :.�r�t�'.i� :`�.^ . ,� . .., � � . . � � i � , .� ' , . ' •i� � .. � � jr.1li� Jc{rr•..3'` „ . 'r..'`�'St:`V:��3j^.�2}�'l�t; �. :r',ir.t;':.�i� ... �..5, .... .� . . . � . . ' . .. . . .,, .� . . .� . . . . � �� . . „ . , ���e >. � ' � , . , . . .. .C�'�,'gs , w , ; ' '. r , - ' , , i , �� • a t'` � � ; 1 `, ' ' . i . .: / . . . � � ' '.F • 1 . . . ' . , ' ' , . � , , � ' , . . . ' . ,'i . � ' �r . � � . . . ' ' • ' ' � r �_.' . ' ' . < , ' ' , � . . , , , , • . �•. ' , . . , } ' . " k [' . . � ' I . . . . j1. . e Fr �. ' . r, '{'''r„, � , � t '�� 1 � �. . ,,r ' ' � . , � e . . �. ` . ' �. . ' ; ,. av . i, - � . . ' r : � . . ' � � . ' ; ' . . � , . ' ', . . . . . , . + :.'' . . � . , . � . . . . . . . . . .. ' � . ' , . \ � � . ;�� . ' .• . • . � • � � , � � � ... . .` ' . • . � . . ' '.f� . ���� �. ' , ` ' , j' [.•, , . ' � .. ' - • 1 .. . .1 ' ,s , ; n� � . , I . ,`' . � , � � .. .. E -� ' � , s . � y ', � ' , .'ai. , - ... � .. � . , e . .` �D�G'@�Ler �28,� 1983 . ' . . .'. . � . o�. � . . '. � �� ° . � � � . . '., . � � . ."'��1 .... � '4 .. '1.'a . . � , � . .. i . . � . . . � ,� . . . . .. •�• , ' •. ' .�I � ��, 'ti• � I � . . ' ' .1 � 5 r , � .. . 1 . .. f, r ,. . " . � � , . ' , . . � r . . . ' . . . � � ' . . .5., � ' , , . , . � � � ' �. � : . E , - , �1 , , ' , `' � • • , , . ` i ,1 • . • . . . ' . . � . • ' ' ' .1 ' ' . . ' . ' . ' ' �r, . . � . ' ., . . . . . ' I , . � . , v • � �� i . � ' , ' � , r � . . . . ' . • ' , Mz.' Gea�ge �R. B�.ror► . ' � , . � .. � � � � . `� , ' - 'IE322 D�ew� .�Street : . � � , • � . , , �:, . . ; . , . . ' .C3.earwa�o� , Flor�.da 33515� � �. . . . • ' . . _ . , . . .;'_,,�l, .' ., . .� �. .' �i ,.� ,` ,. . �� • . r ; ; �'' r , : ,. , .. ,- ..k' ' � ' ' � . � , . . . i . . . • • � ,. I ° . ' , S r , ' . ; 1 ' ' ' . . . ,. )': . � . � . '. � . , . , ` . � � . ' ° . � � . � • . �' 'r . 1a.. . . .. �� � � . � . ' . . . , ' 1 . ' , . . : . � . ' , . . . . r • ' � � ' .,. . ' - ' .r' , . . ' � . . . . , ' ' , , ,' , � . � . . � . . . � ' , t ��+'. • . ' . . , �' .. � � ' ' • . , • ' ''1 . ' . .. , . ' E ' • . ` i ' ' . ; � . � ' � ' ' � . .•i ' � . , .�! ` ' . ...r ' � ' , ' ' � ' , � . . ' . . . ' ' � ' ' � . . ' � ,� . y .. . �} . . . �� � ', _ . � � � , . . ' ` ' .. ' ' � ` . . , � i � . ' �� � . . ,> � , . . . . . , . , .. ,. . , , � �.�: . . , , . . . � � ' � `� ' � ' .� 'I• . . • ' ' � , ' ,r ��r' . ' , ..i ' . � � ' ' ' � ' ,f ' . . � . . . . : ' . ' . ' . . . �,i , ° ` � Wc�dnQ'scia � . : .; ,f� � � - ° . ', � , .Y, January .�1r�, ].9g4 - '2 p. m. . . , , ;r'�'. . . , . , . . . .. ' �. ' , . � . '. . .'J'F� .'�� , ' r ' , ' ' 1 . . . ' r . � , . ' . ' . ' .s F '. . . . � � . F. � . . , . . i . . � � � �':�4 . •a 'F ; � , � ' � b , � ' ' . Y � � � r ' . . � ' a, , . ,�� . ' . � . � . . ' . . � r • .. • , = � ' ' � . • . . � . . . , � . � ' � . � . . . ' . i ' .. . ' } . ' . � . , . .. � � . . . � ' . ' . ' , � ,' . ,. .� ` � �, . . . ' �� . �° ` , � ' , . ' , � . , � ' . ,' . ' t. , � t . . . . . . . . . ' , ' . , r . • , • - � ' � . . � . , ' .. , , ' .. . ' . . . . ' . . �'i.�� t # •� .t .� .. .� .l � , • ' ` . •r ' . . , . ' '' ,. . . . ��. ,r' , � � ' .. 1 ' . r. } 'I , , ` ' .. 'r. r' .' �' . � � .. , � . �1 . 1 � , � . , . � ' . 1S '�i.� ' � � ' + �,. If .. ' ,. ' ,, ti {' ;i � ' ... ' �' ' ' ' ; '' R. ,r.• .�'�� ' ,' ' ` , R' ' • ' , '. f � ` • i. ' � � � � � . : ; ' � ' • � , v , ' , . ? � � ' ' r . � . � �. , • . � . . � � � ' _ ' . . • ' ' . . . � . . . .�� ' t, ' . . ' . � . ' • - � . . � . . . . - r . � ' ' , .. i �� ,' . . • � - . � . ' ' . . � � � � • ' � ' � . . � . . � ' ' � ' - • . , . . � ' . . i � . �� • , ' . ' � ' � � ' . 1 . , . � ' . ' , � . . � � � I � , ' ' ' � � � . . , � � . , ' ' . � . � � . . � ' , � . . �'�-. . � . � t ' ' ' I � <�v � ' .. ' , , f . . �k � , � 1� ' � � �. , . . � ' $ ' . . ^ ' � ' �'1 5,. .��r i , f . � . ' � . � . f . .. � r , . . . . ' � . . ' � . ` . $ I ' I r ' s . �i. :' . • . 1 , ' ' • . .. ' ' . , , r , . . � ��`:���'�aE,•�. 1.. .F�'."�"i-,* .i+'t'°���, S,, j .. � .. { . a'��.F��� f � _. _.._.__ _ _.... ._._.,__...��.. � . � , . I. Y..._�.�" __. _F . .. ._. . _ . . � � �. .. . . ' . . i �F�'r�yf'�s�'���� � i'::�.f � � i'e.'�. � ..W''���.�••.. , '�; � �� �9�4��'4::: 'r.�l� '�\t' ' �.(.x: � � . . - . , � � . . f • ' . , � , il' ' •, . , � ' � rt: � ' . . ' � � . ' . • ; � .Y�����`���t�ri'e �.'iyy,i� ' I .. . '., . .'.. , � .. .., , , , � Y�'� . . • ' F• � '. . ' ' .•. i � .. "- . x�J� `t, .•;;' ; . �., . , ' � . ; , ; • , . : , , ' . , , � i • , �� . � , . � � ' F ` � � � .r ; . . t . - 1 ; , '_ , '� . . . ' . . , �,> ; ' } � . . , i , � � � . . ' ' . . i . � i ' � . . . � � � . . . ' � � " . . . 'j:�� . � . . . . . ' . , � t . i . ' ,��`t: `�y: `,. , e�,a�' . , . , ; , , � . : �� . .. - ' ., ; . . . ;'. . ..t . �. 'Y ' . . �Ei�''t��,ti',' , ,� .., . . ` � � , , . �- . , � • �.• � �. �, .. ' ' ' . �3����`i � `t,�r .: ��.j:..[ r . � ; • • r � ' . � _. ' . - � � , � ' � . . , '' ' ' ' .�'. �:%' .. .L . ',{, . � �•' ' t,. ' ' I �. � , • . � ' ' . °` i' . � . .. .P;,` ' " ' . ' ,'� . ' . . . . . ' � - � . - . , . . ' i. .i� '�. . . .. ,, S ...+ : . � e ,.2 � ' t � . ' � • ; r ' . � . . . , . y ' I � r ' e . . . " � , ,� ' " `��� , �S'' , •.I" :'•".+SJr.�'3 �,l.'' ` . '('I ! 1� ,� 1 . ' . 1 + • .. � . . � • � . F• • ' . . ' y, ' + f ! • ' , ' � 1 ,�. ' , 1,� ��•:f.a ' ' }' �f � . . • . . � . . . ! l ' . } � �� . �• . . . ��� e � ' � ��`� �.f: •' �� ,f. V .. � .. .. `'S ,. y i ' .. ' . . •. � . . . , � � .1"}I h�'tv'1 • , se' . . - `� � . : e: �•1,�?�� . � f',l .. ,�� .4 • i''� ' . � .. • i - ' . , • � . . � , . ' .. � . , ' . . ' • �t� Jxs � t r .'� .r•. ' !r-i^ � , . . . t•' . . , , . . . , � , . �����4�: �'. ',; . �'.l;�r.:,'": "�.r :'.'' ��i.:.� � . . ..'i . 1 . . t ' . . , . ' . . , . . a rN.X€y. '-'�i;t!t,t.si ��. .�.'.l��'.k :t'�: �,.�':�i�;:. . .'i.., � . � �. � � . . ., .. r � � . . .. • � r . r � . . , . . . .. . , i..,� ', ; j � • � � ' �V i .. r 'r ., � V:s - � , i � � f ..1 �F . . � . , � . ' .. - 'y, / 3 !.i �, ' � . �' . � � � � , ; �w: . . . � . ; . , �f � � � � � 5. � ' t . � � ' . . . � . ., . : ' . . . , . ' � ' `, - . . , r . ', .. � ' ' , . .� . ; , • . � . • '.� ' . . , . _ . ' . , 'i' � � = c ' y �. . ,,:� ' , , • ' . I ' z . . . j , t , • ; ' ' ,ji. ' . . . . ., . . ' � , ' , ' , � . '. / � F . ' . � . ' . , . . . , . :` , �- - . , . �. . ' : , . f • ` , . .. . . , . . . ' ; . , .' � _ ' . ' ," ' ' � , , . ' , . . . , , . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . "r, , . , . . . . , ' . . �� . . . . ' . ' . . - . . . � i . � � . �^ , . . . � . . , . . , . . , ' , . . ' ' i , • ' � .. . ' , , . . . . . „ . ' , ' � . . . . . �, . ' . . 1 ' , � .. . . � ' � . . , ,. : ..... .-... ..' '- > �Dracember 28� 1*�83 . . � • � . ', ' � . . . : � .`. � �. � . . . : . . . . / ' r ' , °I 1 . ' . . 1 ' �� ' � . . �I - ' � � � ' � . � . . ' ' . . . � . . . ' • ! . . . . . . �1 � � . • i � ' . • . . . '' ' 1 ' r ' , . , ' � I ' ' . � • . � . . . � . . . . . . . . . t . ^ ' 1 • . . � • , '� • ' � • ' , j , • ' • h�, ' ' '� f. . , � . . • ' . . .. ' , ,, �. �' . •3 t- � . , � �fr. Jaseph Straub _ , � , � � , . . �`f`.. , : �. � � . � �.4�. , S. Mis'anur�.�, Sui �e � 300 ' . . ' ' . � ���,� . � r . . ,.� . CZearwatar, F3.ori�da 3351G . . , .. , � , . � . . !�c' J,' ,� ' . , . . � � � . . ` . � . , . .� � ' , t �. . . , '. �i�5•, . , ' . . �S ' . . . � . � . . . . I . . . . , rr � ; ' . `� . %; •T, •1 ' . � ' . . , . � ' � . . � . . . . ��/.:t.,E�+ � ' . . . � ' ' �1 ' - � . , ' . I � ' . � , � f , . �; � ' . ' 1; � ��• ' . � . . ' , ' . . � . . J � . . . . . , �i ;eF ' .1 .:' ' . . ; . • :r , �. � ' ° ,' ; 4• �'-': : r . , , , i , � , , ' . `` — . � , i � . o . . ' � - � . . . , . . . i � . , � � . ' . l. � - � ' . r . . � {".;;1^ .. . , , .. . . '� .'� } ' � . . � '. , .•� � � - . - ' , . � �. ' �[ . , , . r 'a,'ia..� . � . , . � i � .. � . : . . • � ! ' . - , : e , ' . . '�„',_r. , . . . . . . . . . , i . ' . ' . • ,'�`�� . � . ' ` , - Wednaa�da ' `Januar 11 -- -' � � �� • , � ,. Ya . Y , 3.�8!1 2, p. �m. � ,,,�:` , � . . . . ,�{ �.' . , ' . ' � , • � , ' . . , ' . , � . . . , . , �,.: . . ' : . • . : . ; . � ��''� i, � : ' ' + . ' ., . . , . < , ` ; . . . . � : . , 3 . E, ' . , � , , � . �.� . , ,.' ' � . . , : , - , , � ., . , . . � . . , . . . � E' �. . ,. . ..� , ' . .� . . . � k � ' .. � � 1 • . . w .. A � ' � . i � . {� S' ` I 1 . . . ! . r 5 ' ' ' , r ' � . I • ' 1 . �' Y . � . , ' '(' , ' .� t . , � ' , . . .. ' ` 1; , . � I . . � . t ; � .� � . �Il . � : , . .�1 t� , .. . ' . . ` t . , , . � . ' f ° . • . . . . , � . ' , � . i� , � � < ., , ' ' . � ¢ ' j . a . ,. � � - . . . � , , , '. .. S, i . ' ' � . ,. . �6 . . . � . ; � ' . � � . , , ' . ' ? ' . f . , , . , . . ' ' . . ` ' . , " t � . . i. `. '� , � r ^ t . 1,� � ' ' � r � � �. ' . r . ' , . . �.. ' ' . . ' • f k ` ' • i t � . � ' .5 . . . , - . s � 1 . . . . ' . ' � . . ' � . ' ` � ' ' , � ' � . . . ' �i. ;e. ' . . A � � . . , , ' � ' : ' ' ' • f • 6 ' . , . . , ; . . . , . ' ' . : . . ' • � � ,. . � , . ' . . � � • i e ' ' ' . ' � ; � - . ��r�ti•F��'. . ' � . . . � . � �'` . ' r � , , . . . '- ; � ' � � , , � � 'f . ,' ' f, �, , ' � . . , �iW` }i. . . ' , i ,' . ' . , , . .r ,. � . - � . . � • `.I, .• � • . � , . ..�., . ,'''' ,. • �, ' ' . . ' , ' . � ' ' � , � i , t , ,.; � . '�',�ti; ' � . .�. . . . � . ' .`. . . t , ' . � �i. . . ' . �E ,'' :3' .. '" �y F F , . 'r,` `' ii ur.�.r�.rrr.....��.rrr.�.. — .__ . ti� �. � �. � . �. �iiilt�l� . .�:1:•:_=�'.C_2Y. 1 !" ;;f,� � r4 r _. . . • �j.���j;''f� ".h�;��:a�'k��_%ty'F���;: �' ' • �' r� ., �• . , ' . ,. . _ ' Y° , . , . „ . ' • ,. . • '�'�..;is`��r�:,i:•�'`��� ;;�, ,•'`��r . _ ; , .� '.r? :� . � � ' ; � . . , . . , .. . : . �,•+�y'.,5. . .s°`. . • �i' �j� . , . , .. ` � , � ' . .' . ' ,� C'�' `����} �i. � •' � . , . � � a,` ;a..v_';• '.P�' .r�. . ' . • , � � . . . , ' ' r ' i , � . . ; ; ' ` • . . . � . , � ,� . � . i. ` - , , , , . � � � . Y, • " •, r • � ' ' . , , . . . . . ' � � ' ,` . ' , . •� . , , ' ' . .. ''=f ' ',�`. . . . .. .� . . . . � . 7 , ' , . . � . � . . . , �.. . ^;,.^ .,+r �...} .. . � f•i. , . . . . ° ', „ ' ' ' ' . , � • ` , . ' . , , r, `�: ';~ . �i-: � , , �' � � , . �. ' �' , ' , t . . ` . ,. .. . ' .� '.'�.5. . ' , , ' • • t , � � , �r! kf�. ,r,'. � '+i, � � . . - . , • . ..� ��. ' � �.� .�. � . .. . i. . . � , � . ' ' �' . t ' �. . � . . ;^i ti ; � � .` . � %' ��.�. F 3 t � . '� . �' ' ' ' i ' ' , . ' � . � ' 1 , . � = 1 5 . : �>, • . � • • • f . . . . . ' . . . ' � . . e • , !. .. r�s . i� .. ' . , i(� �t".r . . , . I , 3 , . . .i 't- '��•! .. , . , . , �.I � . . � ' � . r . sr. }�'.. �. . , . ':�° '' ' ' ' .�, • . .Fs-. f` . . �'� , =r !s ' .,; , � ., . ' . . ' . . . ' ' ' �7' �;i,. f'•�'r' . v � . ' ,�i ,' �'`#' , ° " i.. ' , . ,. � t . ; ' � • _ ` , ' . , , ! � . . . � i .'.1i E,r�; . •�. . ' '.`�' � , . . . ,' „ . . • F- ' . ' , , r ,' � ' , . � . ' . ,�t�' ic•^.}:' � ... .� . , . -. r..�ai.s ,�f �� �I��! �. � � � . � � ' .. ,. • . . > � ,. � � . , , ' , ' , s . .. ..�i.K.....3<, . . . ,;r e . .. . .. . • , . , , i . > -.'t1 j. . . . . . .. , . . . . . , • ' ' ' ; � 3 ' . • � ' � ' 1 • �...... ^ � �' � � , • ��� � , . . � . . � i r`'` � ` . . � . . � ' s 1, i . � � � . �.��,. . , . ' ' ' ' . • . . i%' �� , � ' . . . , . � ? � . . . ', � .. , ' ' • : ' ' - . � , . , , . •','• '�, ' � . �' . r' ,� ,. � Y . . � �� � , � ' . ' . , . . . . , . � ' � ' f .ti • .� � .. � . " . , ... � � � . . . � '. . ' " ' ' i . ' . .� , . . . . i�. ' ' ' . ' � ' ' , � .. . ��, .. � ' . .. . ' y. . , � . . . .. . , . , , ' 'i' ��' � � � . � ' - . ' � ' . . , . ' . . . . ' .• r ' � . � . .. , . , , . . � . ' . t � , • . ' � . � . .{'„ . , � ' ' ` . ., , . . � • r: i r . • r . . ' ' i. . � ' ' , .. . • ,. . ' ..°�., , � � .� ' . . . .. �..Deaembar . 28', .].983 . .- _ , ' , '� , ., , . . � � � , :�. �.' s, � . �, �� ". . ' .. , '. ' , . ; , . . , , . , . ' ' . � ' ' � . � ' � �.I ` , ' ; ' � � , '. � � , � , . . • , .t3' , . , .,i . , � , , . , � ' � � ' � f � . � � . }} � • , , . .. . ` . .. . , � � , , • -• . , , '. �', . � . � ' . . ' . � • � . . . e � . , . :,;� � , , � . . ' .Mr: ,John� Cornett � ; :, - . . � : , .r•, 'i�; -t: ' . _ .,. . ,� , � �.7 U�ew�; s�xe�� - ' . ' . .;. , . . . . � ., , � _ . � ' � � ' , C�.earwa�er; . i��.or�.da 335�.5 . . , . . . � � : :, • � _ , . , • . . . : . ' �_; �� . , i ' i .. . ' ; . . . . � ' , '� ' ' � � .. 1. � � �:1'�� 'r � ' ' . � � �, ' • .s . ' ' . ' . � .. , d . .i� . . . � '' ; 1 . ' f . . . ' t I 1 . .' ' . ' �I� ' ' . . 1 ° ' . . , .. �jS �` " . . , ., ;1. `'���, , j . ' �, +� .! f . . . j . . . ' ` . � ' ' ' r r ,� . , ' , , � � ' . . . - � ' ,. . . , • . ' �. . . . . ' . .� . ' . S . ,' � � . . :3 . ' , ' ' .' . , . . • , ' . ' , . ' 't_ ++�,: . . . ' . . , , ' ' � � � - ' .. . " � ' .. • � ' , ' ,. ' . ' .,, ' . ` . ' ' 1. ' � ` , ,f: , ; ' . . . . . ` . s . ' ' . . . - �� �. . . � • ' . ' . '�, . . � . . . , � . . ' , . . , ) , � � ' . . i ��� . -sanuary , 11, 1�64 - 2 ,.p. m. � � 1 � ' � f , � . , . . . . , , . . , . `� . ., ,., . � � � ' . � �, . ' . • . . . : .� r . , ' ' . . � , . ' . �. ��''�! ' +; . . � _ . �. ,� , : ,: � .� .. � , ' f • . .' , � s ' . . r��� • • • , , � , ii�' , � • . . � _ ` , . , � ' � ' . ' ,' , . ' • . ' � , , ry� 1 Y` ' . � ; i , . . , ' • .. , r � } .r . . . S � 3 ' � ' . � ' . . � ' � . � � � . . !• k � �' .. .. , }, i . • E , . . � ' � `• . . . . . . . . - , t , . I s � � . . . � �:. .'i f. . � ' . ' , n � . f, � . , , . . . . . � r ' . . 1 r , . �1`.' �`}.�'. � � ' .. } ' I. : . , . . , ' ' . , '. . r ' . �r . , ; 'i i,T+( � / , . ", ' ' . . , � , , ' r , � ' ' ` � . � .,� � z� , ' .� .` ., i . . • ' E ; , � , ' � . � ' � . . . � , . , ' . ' � _,�:� f r` `E '•. .. . . ��( . , , i. , � . .1 . ' � . - 1 , ' .� ' ' � �' . � r . . ' r . . , . • � . , ' �� .i �{{,..n1,.~ , , ' r' . . • . . . r , . 3 ' �' ' . . . . .. � . F ' .' . . . . 1 ' . . � �'i S. • �' � : . .. ' , ' e. � . ' . .. � - . . . ', y , . . . . • � ;,t •.}�: ' •t' S , � � • � , , . ,� , , � , • : k . , � '�A{"'�f> . . . � ' � � � ., ..� . , � .... i , i . . . �� . . , - • � . • ' . , ' � � ', ' � � ' � � . ' , . �c' '�� ' �. '' , . . ' � ' .� . . ' . .. _I � ' , ' , � ' . ° � � � . '' , , - ` , ' � � ` � � . � • �.".•�: . . . ,. . . , . . . ' ' . '{,.. � , . � , . '� ry�':j:: ��1 .,. ' .. � � 'F1'... . , . .' , '`r... ' :,, '�f� � f� . :�,;, . �:' ° � ' � 4 'z�,1�i,'�. �c.:i i,. ` ;t�° .i tri.• ,n� `���' �� ,� ° c o F ��1t't: ti �;ir%i, �?, . °�t. ;t.i:.� i�i �, � ;�a- t,�'. j {' -..:` ' ,( ..i: � � '.i:. .N , . "t�°4,'t" '�t'�'�}t�' . . �f��,'� _�^,h�.,e�..fi,� �v�.r��_ . "..'e'�A ,, ..�� — b; . en. tw:�t:.:-'. �L; kat t"'i, :.'��` '.;��3:. � 29f M�C}!� • ti';Y ' ' . .. , �,2�, , i . . , , . ' . . . � ' . � .�i . � � . t ��, . . . ' .hv . }�{��`�.�la��•��i� �!'''''�' y=k;. . . . , " . t . . , . � . ' . , . � , i , , " ' ,� ��,� ���,�.ii;: `.�ti e'': 'y=i 4 f} � . F . • . ' i '. . • , . ' , . , • ' , ' . . ' , . 1 r' r . � ' . . , i�.. ;,: `3'. .s �t , ' . . ' � ' : . . , . ' , ; . � r � ' . : ti�'S�: ..+ � .. �� +. . ` . ��• . ' . • . � � � , . � � � � + ' . �`, .e. �'. :. �' ; ? , �. , � .' .. • ,� � ' ` . , ' ` . r . , . r r ' , . ��'' . i' �� i • , 't " � + . . ' , ' . . + . � ' � . , � ` , . . . , '`. i r t . � s .' ' � - . .. . . � � . � � � . . . . ' � . . . � � . . . ' . . L'_i;.�'.r��' �1 �7:.3F . . . . . ' � .� � ' � . r1 , . � , . , . . .. . . . • P ! �•i. � � f� ���V�,,�£Se' �.�.� i •,• , , ... � .v ' ' . .� ' e� � ` `; , ' . y ( . . . • � r .. ' • .• '� . , �1� r . . , ` � .. ;'9'Jr "S; " ' ', . � • ' . � . ' . > ' • • ' . ' i'' ` :- . � �� '��1 . •. . ' - . ' � 3 ' . .. ' . . � ' ' . ' . . � ' . �'i Z,.r` �� . '°. i�. `�s- � ' .. . , . 't, ' . � . ' . , , � „ . � . .i �'f: 'r 1:� i '� y�" , . . , . . 'rv � . . 3' . . ;�. ' . ' . , ! ' . . , . ' F: ' . . " . ,� . . . , , ' `� ��r'.�� ,,'� .... ,` '�' ',�f.� � f ' . � ! ' . , + �i `f 1,' ' .' ' � _ . . � l, � • , . � , °�� �'3,'' a � .. t .1 . . . . .. . . � i . , . M1�� �'3y t • , . ."t;. � • . • . .. s � � ld�J,i��• . • ^'; ' �` .. f , ' � � . ti� . . ' � vt: . . . � i . ' � ' . .' �� j `�s : �I • if. ' •� � ' ' ' . . . . . p ` . � . ' . � . . � . . , . � . ' .;�i :,",,i,.� .. .:;' r . �'' , . . r : ' . .. ,- . , . F +' . �k, ��, '` u!I � ' ..� . ' ' . , I '., ' � , ' . . , . . ' . . . . . � ' :i . .e� t`i .M�' 'i. �;".'i, •. :�; `r .; a �.,: : :.':;�1: • � � 1 . � . ' , . . 1 .. y ,'xtl •' . i•.�i.... '1.. .� ��ai::�'�a��':.k;,��.:�,7� .�.•d�.:::Li� �i'°t5°r� .yi...7;'.�.�;,..� . .'„+� ,. � .. .� ' , • � �� � . � � ' , , � ' . . . , ' � � re . . , t . . . , . . . . . ' � F, ` � ' . . . . . . . .. . . , ': A• ' . � . . . �. . . �.. . . � i . . . - . . . ' ' . . ' _. , . .. � . - . , �,7 ' � � • - , 4 . . �R. T � ' . � ' . , , ' ' �.r... ' ' , . . . � � ' ' , . . r �. , . ` � 'i . � . . � r ' . . . � . , e . . . ' . , `�res r . . . 'L ' I' . . ' . . , ' , 1 � ; I . � r ' , . `�' � �� � . r�' . �� . . ' . � . . . � � . . •� ' � . . � . . � .(�� ;i� , ' ' . . , .. ' .. ' , '. ./ , �..� � . � . , . . ' ! ' . . � . . � . . � . . ' . � � � �' i . ... � , . ' � � . . r , � . • � • . • . � . • ' ' . . � � . 1" � �. .. . .F . � . � ' " k ', : . , . . • I ' ' � ' ��` � . � ' � .. .. ' " . ' ' . . . � i . ' ' . . . , , � � . . , � � -r' r ' , • '', . .. i � ' . ' ` . . . ` . . , . . . .. . . . ! . .. !: . _ . . � . . ' . - i � ,' • � s ;' t , � , , F . . � `�, � y 3 1 . , , ' • j , • . 1' . r !•: . . '. ' , � � ' ' y ' � . � �� .��t'. a... . .. . . . � . . . f �. . . . .i.. . .. , � . . ' . . . . . . ^ , i . . . . � .1 .. ,. . ' . . _ � T . � �:�Y ;k;=: , "- , . � : ��c�ttibor.� 28, 1983 �. , . .. '_ � � � . � . . . � � . ��,-�. � . ,. . . ' . � �. . .. . � :�_ • , : , , . . � : � � . . ' ' f . . , ' ' . ' F. � � ' , r 'tr, ,� ' , ' . .' . _ r. � . . . . . .. . ' . . � , � .. . '�a'..FI . , � . , ' � . . . ' .. • ' �, . � . � ' � . . • ., . 1 � � ° , ' , ' �,`. . . . . ' �. . . � . � � ' ' � ' . ' , ' . . � , ..ii': � e . ' , r ' r . . � . . r r . ,. ,�:� :$� . . � ` � Mr.�, Edward .Walker . , . � , . : � � , . ;�3� ' , - . ' k445 'Cdurt S�xaet . ' ' . . , . , , , . ' , , , "'': ' . :` �b,:�._ • . ` ', . ;.' - ,,'.C].e�irwttter; :Flaz�.da 3351G . " � , . . . . , . , ' ,. . .•, . , ?iS`. . ., -' r 'ii. ':;. ' ' � . . ' • � '.� • ' . ' � ;s't.. . .' � ' ' . � , . ' . . . i' . . ' �. . _'�r' . ,��, • . . ` . e . . . . . . . � , � , � . . . . i � . '''�� I't .. o. . • I ' � . • ' � � ` . � ` . � . � } ' , � � . . , • , ., . .1 . ' ' . . F � ` ` ` . 1, i. ' ' ' ,, � . .i`; . . . . e � . ' . , • , . 3 i . . . , .. . � ' . . . . . . ' ' . ' . � ��`�. . � ' ` � .. ' � � ' ' . � . Y ' • • ^. ' . , . � k � ' . . . , q� I ..¢�� ' :. ' ; ' ' , , . .: . • . . � ' � (R' . I� ' . � ' ' t ' e '� ' .. ( , ' .�.- .V � . ) : , . • � . . � . , • . . . i . . , . . � �, , � i �r : � . .. . � ' � , k , � . ' 1 � , , . . , ' . , . ' ' �T . , , ' ' ' :tl� �� �5..' .�. : ' � ! ,' ' ' ' . - . - � . . .I ' .� ' .. � . i ,, l;�:,, . . ,. � �Wednegday, Jantxary 1.Z. �19$4�. 2 pi., m. ' ' , , ' ��_ . .• � � � ' , ' . • ? ' , - � .. ' `�, .. • . , r < , . . , , ,. ° . . . ' . � , , , , � , . , ,� . �" � . ° , ' . . , . . •. , , , � .. .. • ''. ' ". ' • • �' , •. . . :. ' ' . . ' ' � } ,. i.�� � ' ;, . � '� � ,> : . . . � , ,. . . ' f+ , . , . . . . t;�; *'' '' � . ', . , � " ' A Y ' . � , . � , ' ' � , . ` � � ' j ' . ' , �, ', � , ' { � .'. . ,:1 ' � ' , . . � � ' ` , ' � � " . . . . � . . . - � I ' � � � . . � � ' a , 3 ,' , ' ' , i FIj'�•,.'-`� . . �7 . . . ' ' ' ; ' .� ', '" ' " { ' , ; , . �. . � .. . . . i' ' � � ! . �, ,,,�' . . � r . i . ;.', ' . �. '. � , . . ' ' ..' . , i , . ,. . , + ' '. � � � '. 'ire .. . ` � . ' � . �t 1�3- •�� ' . ' . ' .. ''' ' ' ` . . ' , . . , e . i . � . . . • . ,; (s��1, '�I• � � ' + ' . ..� � ,I� . � � y � � � y , , j � ; _' . � � . . . :.�5� . . , ,t �. . ; , , . j'� yil� , , ' _ ; , • - ' ' - ` . � � , }. ' . ' . ' � . , . � ' • . " ' ' , . ( � . . .`. � , " ' , , • , . ; . ' , ' , � � ' ! :y: . . ' " ' . . ' � . , . . . ' , i ' t ' ; , ' . ' . � ' ' . � ' . � . � � 1 F' 1' � ,. . ' ' '� ; � , � , ' �' ' ' � ' � y ,. . . � ' , 11' � �' � , ' , � , ' ., 6 � . . £i,Y . � . ' e : ' � r. S � � .. : . . ,• � . � . � ,_ � , � � ' ; .. ' ! ' . . . �'i: �' . � � � '' 1 , ' '! 1 • ' .. k ' . , • � � ., " � . . ' . . . ��`� ' . � �! . ti�;.'`:. . ' , ' ''l' - . , � � , `�>. , � , ; ' . ' i F ' ` .I..`. j :`r . ..�7' (. .. � •�,d ` .�' ," . r. s a' "�•:,r' .3 'I-��': i� � s . •i .i' -------- ---��`_-"'_ � r��{--- --- ---......._...- ��' ��..._Y.�_':l'...:�,�.� ��._...---.-.,� .. ,. , . �. ... .r:at ��.ttt �i�_C,idi.�.'r........ :�� _ }�•.. � .�i:, =,�j.r.wi i�i � • ' �. . � r..,a ..-. �'� �'',+���';r:'+'�'�`'rk'!i'. �F',:Ti t�.�17 �.:. �. : ; . �,_ , . ' " .. . . . . . � ,. .:� . . . • , �� . � . , . � ' . � r ' .��' . . Y. i��"',i�. _=aE�'- ;:�tV�'�"�`,'�:;:`, i' . .. � . . , i � . . . . . ,., . � ' �. � ' �r � . ' I' ' . � . . . :f.5,��i'�xl���.� •' ��Sft'ei'. ��uy.' �r �, 4 � 1.' , '..3`. � f . . � • • . � . ' . . , i� . 1 . � ' � � � � � � . ' � . . �FS�� .1�. ;r� '�' . , ' , , ,. � ' . , , � � , 1 � . . .`,,' � '��� .� � � . � . . . ; , � , • ' � , , ' , � f ` r ' ' , - ?'i! )aJ'' ' ' ' � � . � � . � � ' : ' . • . � •i ' , . i . ., t . .;i �s.:ti,'`ly.;.. :!`1` . , . .. , . • . • .. . . . 'l'�,�'r•i�i -•, • . � •;''iiti • � . . .. ' . � ' � , . . ' . � � � . � ' , i � . r� �,}q�4���•i;,`]i��:�• . � ��!� °�f�. ', .' ; �,Y . , .. . .. . . ' . ' . . � , f, ' . . .. � , ' " � :S��IJt. j..� o. �.vr. L�. . .' .� . . . . f , 1 .. ' ' . . . � • ' F"� S "y`'�+':', t :': ' '�.. . i" � • ,, " . • � . , ' ' , • " . • � . . �';. ;�:�:_�y :1�, � ' ' , "; . :`.; � . fu ';, , 7r ,r , i . . , . . ' . i�' , . ' ! i ' . ' , • � . ��T''� '1.; : ��:'�•. , . .r` , . . �, . • . . • , � . . , '�- :_ "� , '.l,.' t:_�F - . , .. ' . . . . , � • . . . . ,. � , � .. ��•;..,f:'� �. . �. �:. �::��i;,�,�' � °:�� �{- .. .. .. ' , . . . � . , . ' ,�. " � .� . ' � , �. ' . ��' '.�j:``, �, t . . ' � • � . `.'s � r. ;1 : > ! F' . . , . � `,�,.;� l. .'�.r .. �,t• ' ' , . , , � 3 . . ' ,' " . ' ' ' , . :4 '_� :; . .";" c .� . , , , . . : ` • . ' . � �,���. �. � .. � . , . , L � , ,E� ,' . � . . . � . , ` ' ' . ' . _ • � , • "' ; ' i � ' ' . ���: i; �� ��' �` . '` . �; Et , v{� � - • , . � • . , . t'�1 �;� :' - � � '�:� "+:.� � �... . � . . , � .:; sy i�:;i.� . ,. .,:r"' �•:. , ' �.. E ` ,. 'r. . , , . , ..,: i ; '��," �. ' � : . . . . •. ' .ar. Fx' � . .. � ; .. .. .. .. . . . . . . ., . . o . � ' _ . . :' y � , ' t' ,r L�w-.►..u. :el-.r'�rr}.ra",�f� :t.. '� i� � ,y`, , ' � � . . S� ' r . , . ' ' . . . . . � . ` ... . ' . S .'. . � ,;`, ' v ' �. ' r'� ' . ' , ' ' � } , ' , ' ' ' ' _ ' .. . �,� ' � : � . . .... , . . . , �� , , !. . . . °' � . .I , �. . � � ' . ,7 • '%� ' . � . , . , , � . . ' � ' .)' . a � � ' •. �� .1 . ' .. . f . ' ' . .� ` I I . . . ! � ' � .l, ��y� :LF! . . . ' " �! . .f �. � > , , " � � 1 �� � . ' . � .. r'E` . �. . . � . ' ..4 .. � '' .- ; . . '; •f'. � � . . ., . ' . , f.' . � :F' 1, ' • . . . ., � . , • . � • . , 1j,S n' f' v . ' , ' . i , ' . ; . . . , ' � _ ,�. , .. ' . " , . ' . . ' ' , i , . . . ' ' ' i. • . , ' , . � �.. :, „ `' •� ` . .. I r •�. �, y, ' ., , . ; J . ,' � ' , " �r. , ' , -. , �.�. . ., , ; . ' ; �i . . ,,'F � . . . ' ' ` . .. , ' . ' . ' . �' � . • , . . ,.L[ �` , . �. . . . . . Dec4mber. 28, 198�. � . ' . . � �� � . _ � . . .. � , " , , � , ; �,��; . . � . . ' � , a. , . �- • �,.� � - ' ' � . . � ' . : , . .. . , .. ./ . . .'r: ;��,� , ; . , � - ' ' � . � ' . ' . , r . .' - , , i ` , , , � ' . F° . ,. , , . . ��.' - ; � . - . � ; , , , , . . .. . . . .... _ ,. � . � . ';; :�:; . . •, ` . '� ,. �,� . . . .�: ': v, . , , , . . . , � � . � . , . � . i;,. .4'.. . � . .. , . . , . , r . . , . ' ' � � ' • , . � . . 1.. . , . 1 . . ' � , ' ' ' , . . ' , ,.. . ' . . . 1� ,;�. . . . . . . ,blr�."�oiin �Lvgan. � � � • � ' . , � ; � . ;: �i: � � � . . l:].►78' E�,dz3.dge r St�xee� , � ; � , , . . • �� ,:� . , . : �, Clsa�rwa�ex,:� F].or�.da .335].5�. .. . � ' . . � _ : . � , - .. ,, • '1�ss�� 'i� ' . ' , . . , � . ' , � , . • . . , � � - . .. .�4 • � � ' ' , ' � ' . • � . . ' - " :''.;�Y r' , ". . , ' , . ,' . ' . ' , ' . ' � , • . �. , �' . ' : [�:i ' f.' , : f � . .. 1 . . � . . I ' - � , . . ' ' . � . � � � . . . . . . . � "'4•, t. r ' , j' ..� .� . � � � •' ' . . ' .' . ' ' ' . � ' I . ' , .' ; '`1 } � ' ,. . . . 1 . � ;'� ' .�� '1.' � ; , . . . I . . , j. .; .' . . t i . . , . 1 '.. � . ' ' . � ' ' . . . . 1 ' . �;I ' � ' . . , �. , 't. ' � � ' d ' . ' � � . .' ' ` , . � 1 . 1 ' � i . � ' . � . i . ' . '. i� . '. ' ' . . 'f . . � , . . � ' � , � . . ' � : � � : � ' � �i i . � . � . . . . . . 1) . ' , y ' ' ' • � . ' i . . S1,^ V � . . .' , . . • . . � t �, ., . � • • • � ' � , . � . • t ' � ' ' � , �. �::':� - . , , - `Wenne�day� January �.1"� 1984 2 �p.° m. , : � , , � �, � • , , , � ' ' ! . . , " . . � . .. ' �' , � ' . . �.- , • . � . . . .. . . . . . , . ' . . ' e . 3 . . . ' , ' ' a .' iC. � � � . . � . . . , i ' r . � ' . . . ' ii�.•�` ' ! � �r . .. ' . ' . . • • . ' ' . . � e • . � � � ', � • `� �r 1 I�i: ��� .. , � ' . - , . . � , t . . , . � . . . �,'� ' �i:.: ' d , • . ' � . , � � � , ' � ' . `. � . ' . ' iYSr`%. '.1 t� t . • ; _ • . f , I . . , ' , .. ` ;;�� , . . , ` . . . . f • • � . , ' . ; . , ' �. � a':-: ' � . , . , C�:?. �, . i ' , , • �, �' • ' ' � ' . • ' � , i . ;"s� .. • , . . � , ; :: . � . ` . . , . . _ , ', . . ' , ".. ' 9 . ' , i ' � .. t ' ' ' . ' . " .: � - . . , ' ' .'i � . . . , r � , . . ' ' � ' ' , . ' � . � . ' � ' • , ' . , . ' ' • .. . . . . , ' . . � ' • � j . � . � • �.��r: . . ; ' . . ' � , � , , �,' t . . - ' ' _ ' 4 .. , :.,, . . . , ' , , ' , . .. , ' .. . . � �-i ;:, . . ' � • , ., . : ; ; ' . . •" , ' a � ` . �•6 ' , . � ' ' ` • ' . � . ` . . . . . . 3 ,,' � ' • . , � ' ! , F � . . � . � . . . . . . . . . I . . . � . , � � Fa,'. f, � 1 ' � � j � ' • � • ' �' ` ' � . . • � . . � . ' � , i , � E , , _ . t � � . � • � � � :� . ^.',. . !' i � _ � ` , ... i ! . ' . , � , . ' A � . � , � ' • � .1 � . . � - • . � S . . � � �.� . . . . . � . . . . . ' . ;fyyF, n 1 . ' . . . 1. ' ' . � , . . . . � , . . . . • ' . . ' 1 . . , rt ���„`•� . ' • i � . . . � � • . • ' . �'� , . . 1 , ^� . : , i . .. i..��:, ��,f � .. . . � . ' . , r ' . . � . t - �' �,ir 'j �,. � f.. F. ..1,,'. '. � i � .. � �` . .� . . ,� E � 't'� 'i:.'K• ^�Sy 3 `e''.;� i�. 'i:,��.•> '�' '°:t`• �'�� - � --:a.S_ �+s° � - - ' , .F ,.. .. '�. ,.... , . :..i�i 's ,�':�j���� .; 4 , .,,+ „ty� ,r, _ r...�.,..,.Y.._���_.._.___._.�._..__�..:s....:.-'--� . . .. .. �,�i5ard..it�i'" i?f:..:az:;.`�cr .:.i 'i,�i ?`��:f.� .fi� i' . . ... �: ,�.��:. ���Y_q`�• 1 r�i,ir. ^i 5�'. i," 1 . � � , . � . F . ' . . 51 . � � . . . ' " � ' I. � , • '�' .Sl�} 4� ~ i4 � � ti,h¢1r}� . , :�� . � . , � � . � � , � . . � `'' ' t ; ' , . � . ' . • ` � � . i , , . . ' . � � . � . • , ' • . �, � � ° � . � ' � ,f , i✓ •,,' . . ' /� �' , t I . , . • . ' . ' ' • . . . 1 . ' � . , � . i s , . � .. . ���,.� . ' ?� ' • ' � � . � ' . . . . � . . . � � ' • . , ' , . � . � ,r -. . ♦ I • 1.� ' • . `• �� '. i� i . . . . . . . �� ' � ' . . . i 'f. . . ' J • ' • � • • � � � • 1 • . ' . . . � � ' . R2 .. . a � . . . . . . . 1• . . ; . . AJ'� � � �''. ..`. ��� . ,. . • ' ' • ` . � . ` ' ' ' . � � ' • I ' ' . ' 1 ., t •'' + � ,' !. � � . . � ' � � t i , ! . � . . � % y � 1 • . . • . I � ' ' � � � ' ' ' . . . . - i 1 �. . � . 1' . � � ' 3 �I�.: . . ...'(r.' i:�. x:j.,�. ��� .. —o.e ,:�:�... r. ... o. . . r -� , . � . " . : . ` ' ' , . , . ' f. i ' , �. • ' � : ' , 1 • � ' ' � ' , e . � . . . . . �Y � � ' �, . , ' . . . hQTICE Or �'UiiLIC ii�Ai:i11G � ' , , . , . '. . • � . � � ' . `Boarc3 .of Ad jus�ment and Appea� an Suilding�'�'lood Cvntrol,. Operatioris Center .� �Conference Room, �City fiai� Annex, 10 5vuth M].55qLiXJ. Avenue, Weane�day, January = I1; I984 a� 2�� p. m. ' , . , , �To consider the �ollawing requests: ' , ' ' , � ,� � . � . Ruth Eckerd.Ha3.2, 1111 Mcl�ulle'n-Booth Road; 5ection 9--295--�6E, variance from S�andard Building.Code, 5ect�.on 1I21 Exi,t Sign requirements. ,'{PACT) � � � . . . , � ': 695 Snug zsl.and, Lo� 57, Unit 7B zsland Estates vaxianc� fram�Caastal Con- , stxuction Code 39Q6.2� for construciian of swimming pooZ enclosure within ].8 • ft. of �xisting seawall. � (Bl.ank), • F1ori.da S�a�ute 286.0].QS states; Any app],ican� appealing a decision of.this �' board must have a verbatim z�r,cird of the proc�edings�ta suppart�such an � � apPeal. - . ,' . , < , . Citizens may, �appear ta be he.src3 or fiXe writ�en no�ice of apnroval 'or ', � � �� objec�ian with the Huilding Director pr�.ar �.o �he Public Hearing. ,� • ' , , City of Clearwater, F1. Lucille [aiZ�.,iams, City C1erk Adv . . � , , ' ' . ' , ' . , , . . • , . . . . " . . ` � ` , . . , , ' , , . . ` . � �� �� Yau are being sent �his no�xc'e if you are the appl.xcan't or � , own property within 20Q ft.�oE �he subjec�,property. � � ,, • , . � , � i . �_ ., ' ' . . . � ' . . ` . � � . ' ' � . ' � � ' � ' � , . . , , � . . . . , , ' . . . ., . � . . � . , , � ' , . . � . ' , . . � � � o . • , ' ,. � ', , � . � � 1 , _ . . , , . , . • ° . . r . . � ' � ' .. �; � . , .. . � .. � , . • _ � . ' - • ' '� .n .r' �,y 'cF. > , _ . . _ . , . �_� � ��,;,,WS%'��yy' J � ! �L.i—„��i€.'.ti � �+`,:f-. (�� l �^ ,i . . >' �` , .' � /' � , . 1 ` . . • r • . ll � � � . . . t e , l ' • r . , ' � � � � � _ � ' . ' ••.� � � . f. � . � ' � . . . ' ' ' ,+ . , . 5 .. � . , � . . f ' ' . , . . , , , ' . , � . . . ! . � . � 31'+ fr ..r ' . •4 . . � ��r �. � '. - ' • ' � . � .. � . . ' � ' . , ' . . . � 1 . � . � . , ,. . � , . / t i � , . ', L:' ' . . �' � ' , , . . • , � . �� . � . o . G . '' � " �d . ` :�: , d � U � . , m . � , � . � ' . ' � Q� • � � - . '.� �. •. , , . �. � � • . +� . • . . , , tr . � Qb H � � a� '� � , ' � � � = � . �. . , , . •n ro • � �, - . u> � ZT ,t7 CV !J1 + � ,� . ` ,� 4�i � ij , � - w � �� s . O s� tR � + , . � ° ' t6 4i Q} ' . :: ' 'b a1 . ti f7 r li... r '�+ ' }.� r•-; •,i . � , . ' ' y , ' R1 . +s ' � ' - ,_ . . . � , 1R b' 4 � O ' � � � , (:� ' . �'., . , CD � f:1 ri ' �." a W � r- . , i Qj . . i11 rl a C1 f7 �- . � �j r-E 1 � � �' ;: • ' � � 'iy � Q • � ' - ' � {} . :� • . tr � � a .� ' • � .z � � ' s4 . .-V � � � S�, . , • ' u► � ; y r-I •rl :! ' ', tr� 'rs � "o . 07 " h . ... , , f� � � �Ci . C , ' �' � ' ' . � Ar � n1 rJ •�i r-I , �n • � ., � � � � M� � � D �� .. . • VJ � � ': o � 1 Cl � . '� . ' � •� . , • � Is. ■ . . i,'' tJ ia] N • • � . a , - `. �J ••-1 ri � . N � , . . , , ' F] �--t . � � � O . . � , . . , , 'ii�! , ! � � O � . �-1 . '~ . � W � W 4a y , � . � ¢ � � Q ' Cl •�I . � ' � �rl 0 � � �1 � � � , � y,� ' 4-I �d r-i � . , ' [1 • , RS Q �lt � rSf � � , ti - . • , a �� p b•.� . � I , , � � W � ai , G� � � � � . � �� • f v � W �ii . � . .,� a� ir W iL � � , ca � r-i ilJ �'i � W � , • , ' . � � '.� . � •�i � u ro- � , ` � � � c� I � 4 . i` � � � o � � . � � , , • � � ,.� � � � o v c� � o � . � � ' � � , . � �. � � � � 3 ' , � � ' .. � v! ' . � � �.i � . , � . ' , . t w ' � ' N O fd � , ' , : � . � ,� . � , . ' ' }.� ' Ql � 04 < � ► . . G} � � . �j �d .-i . .d . + ri . •.i Cf . rd ri C} '. U .i.� ,Q Gl r# p . • , , . i� ` o w •a ,-� D�r ' 41 ' � rt! W ' 3 O ' � : ^ , � r n , �s. ' , b . "+� � P ' ag U � s� � tt! � -,i ' ' ' ' . o X ' , ' , ' . �•� � , � , . . o �� , , u �; . � � ' � T � ai �. � � ' o y �° � .• ' , 1 U y �y 'CI. . w ' '] &� . . �d � � d +G- , • • ' [l." , � � Q � r • .' M �n I ' 1 I, ��a , �. ,. ., • , � , . . � , . ' . _ . ' � � � �6r��'�.rll:�Yli::ti�li �.:�}�... ' ♦ _ . . � _ � , / / � . � . i � � �: `1 . �f- , • . . . ' � ' , � . . ' � . ' . ` .� � . , . .+ , , � � • , � . � . , • ` ' . . . ' � • � . ` ' . ' . . ! ,�i .. • ' ' '� r . . . . ' . ' I .. ' ' ' , . . . � . ' j f. . . , . . , ' ' , � i � . � , ' s . . ' . . � . . � , r . , . � . � � . I . . . ' � . ` ' . � , . . . ' ' • • . . � 3. • . . . � ' � . i � . . � � . ' . . .. . , , . F. ' - • ' . 1 � - � . � ' . . ' 1 . � . � ' � � . ' ' ' � i/� . � � . . 4� •. • �,:1, e.7r_.. ..� . .. .. . . � , . . , e . . ' �� .. . ' � � '. , e � 1 . 1 • . ��',} . , � . � . � . ' � . . . . � ' ; . . �. . . . . . . � f � ' . 1 . , . �l . . . � , . � : .�� -�. ..�.. . -� � : � , . . � - _ ��.� . -.. .- � . � . . .. . . . : . .... . . ..: :. _ _ W. :� .�,. �,.. . _ � - . � � . ��.... ... .. � i � . . � ��. .�.� �`� �--. �2�: .�-� . . . : , � .. .. . ...� ._ :�. . . .. �� . - -� . . . �. , , � � . . ��.. �. .. ... �i � � � +� M..... � . ���� - ���`� �' ? � �;'�-�`, . ' � . .� �� � . �� . � � CN � _ ' .��'..�'" �. � �a.,.�- ,'' • ' . . , . � � ,. . � ���- � : �� ... ... . ,. .. . , .. . � . .-� .. . ��/ - ���z � _ ' � , . c�/� � �� � � . . . � . � . . .�. � _ . :i , . .. � .. � _... . ' . . . _-- , �.�� - �'-� . � �� . ' . . . . � � . � . .... ._ . �� ; � -��d-���..��. , , . . , .. � �. . ; . .. , ' ' .� � . . . . ' . .. . . .. ..,�...... . ... . _ ... . . .. ..�. _ . .._ � . . - � . •5�f- .��- /��� �, . . � ''�!/�3 - . Q ,f:� - � .'�-,.t . , ,+�'� " . ' . � ' ' ,i 1 . , � � , ' � • ... . . .. . . ' � . . ` . . . . ' . . . ' ' • •. � . . � . . •. . .� . ' ` � . 1 . . .. , _. � � , ' � I � � � . • ' • I. ...�,,.. . . . . , . � • . t . • - . � . . . . ' . . , � ; . .... 3 . . , i •... .� .r... �. , i r....� . ' I . '. ..... � !. n ! . . . . � . . . . . . . .. . . . r ' . . ' r � 1 ' . . . . .. .' , .. i .. ... . . ..• .... 1 � . � ; � . . . . . ' . . . . ..;. _ �..... . . -� � . �.;. .. . . � . r.i .. . � . . . � . . a . . . . ' + i . . �. .I i . � � , � � . � ���� . i -.. . _ .... ' . . • � . . . . . . . . � . . _ � � � � . � . F , o . . i . . � I . � . � . . . . . . . � . . .p , i .. . .. _. � � . . . . . . . . . ' . . . . ' , � . ! , . _ , � ' f , � . , . ` ' ' ' , .. . . . , '. . .. . ' . . . .. � _ • , !a . � ' ' y � I , _ . . . _ .. .. . . . . ... .. . . . . .. . . , . . . . _ . . . , .. . . � t' �. . . . . .. . � 7 , , , ! . , i e ..s-. _ .. . __. .. .� ..'. ; . ' . . . } ' . .'' ' • . . • . � . ., . .. . .. + � . ! f'�•� 1 � � !. • , � ' . . .N�...... _. . . . . . . . . . � � r.... .. . : . ... . .. . _ . . _. . .. .. . . ' . . . . � � . , , . .. . ' . . .. .. . . "... . . . . .. . . . .. , .. . . .. . � _. ..... ' i ' . , . , � � i � . . . . . . . . ' i . .. ; _ . , . . , . � . ., . . ' . . . . ' , . . : .. '.. ; . �. . , � � � i = � . . - ---- . -.. ... �.. :.., ... _ .. ., .��' .. . , , :.. , :., , _ . , .R�.. . . . ' . .. . . . � ' I � � � , ' ., ' c! i � . � • ' ` . ' . ' � . . .......... _ .. ... . .. f . . .... . . . .. ... . ....1 � . , . . . .. . , . . . . . .. . �. .. � . .e 1 . . � . : • .. , � . ' � • . .. t . ... , . . .. ... . . . . � t , . } , . � � ' ' � � , . .. .. . , . . . �. .. � : .. . . '. , . . . . ` . . . . ._ ` • . • � . , ' . , . � �. v ,.. .�` ` � i� • ; , , � .. . � , � . . , � �,. . .; _ . . . �. .., ..._ � , . .. . .. �, . ' . } . ; .... . . . . .. .. . ...t . . � <. .fr��n",�'r.N}�..ti� :}��.ix'_i 1� . .'r. Y - ,�i, .i. °5�13'i."��t '�.,;•. , . ' . . . , t� , ,. �,'. « °Er �r'• .;' • . � � r ', ' ' , . . ... . • . . . • , . � ' : . �M vp'd•�� k S` . .. � ' , " � ' ! e � . .i '�... . a ' '� . . . ' , . ' i � , ' I - � f. . , � . � ' . , � . � . . . � . . J . . . . � . �, I' ' � � ' Tr:.�� • . . ��:'., . . . � . � . . ' � � . , `'�r�`ff k , � . ' � ' . . . .. , ' . , . , , � r ' . • i' ' , ' ' ' . � �' , J ' ' . ' ! � . � . .. ' �A ., � .. x.� . ' . ' ' y • � � ' . . ' , . , , . . . �j,; . �S � ` . . .I �. � .. � t � . � . . ,�� , r . , ' � r , , ' . � � , . � ' . �f ` . . ' . . ` , . I 'i' . . � � � ' , • .. . � � ., . P ' , . �4' ' . . ' ' �} � �. . ' . . � ' ' ' ' �� � . . ' . . � ' ' . J�.K^`.»�i'. . .. .. � t.cr:.�fr«.x7 i.��. r'f ' � v .. . .. � .,.� � r . . . . � , � 1 . r � , � „ � . � • . . � . �. � r : �'j� , ' . �u , ' � .7 : + , � , , . � ' , ' � � • ' , , ' ' ' ' ' � � Phoned fzom Mr. Loqan -' I/1.3/�4 -- af�sz meeti.rsg at site with PACT , '' of�icials and HOAA baard members - � ' • , Comi�ittee (board) concurs wa.th S�ction 404.1.5, paragraph {o} �o�' �he -, SBCC in regards #:o th�: �xxt sir�ns over the por�als'being required. �� Iiaard decided they wer� na� granti�ig a variance sa.nce a variance. . was not required because �h�y con�orm w�,th SBCC Paragraph{o?�. Hoard ,� ,� �ur�her d�ci.ded �ha� the �.ighting illum�,natii.�n of �he poz�a�. wou].d , � confazm to �he requir.ements o� the SSCC and �ha� �he exi.� 1igh�s � ',. ° e outsa.des of �he poztal�s wauld alsa conform. . � � . The Board a].so requested clarifica�ian of t.he let�er sen� to��he � � Clearwater Bua.].dinq Dept. from SSCC in regards ta t2ie exit� lights . � . because �hey though� tha� the �irs� Xe�ter was.an error and wanfied '- • ,. �confi�matian. - , � ;°,'� �' A�,so. advised that th� Board' was np� granting � a vari�nce fxom �1ie . •�; ;�;�,; Li�e /Safe�y Code =-�h�y had no au�hari�y to gran� var�ances from L�.�"e,/� ' . Saf��.y Code. . , , � ; ' .. r.. � i , � :t. � ' t . � � � ' , ' . <: . ' ' � , . . . � �,� ' . . � e ' � . , . ' � � � . � ' ' ' , � � , . . ' ! i ', f ' , 7 . J t � / � , . . . f i . , . � � . . , � ' . . � r' / , � i' . , � . ' . . . , ' . +. r. � � ; �, . � �J��-". ��' 3�� t��: ' � . � t: . " � . j. . . . , , �'-. ,,. . ' . ' .. � � � � ,-.'�t,,,,. .,. .. � � . , . ' � . . ' . t ,.+:�'�td � . ris: .«.�t;. � �����i�t> ., . ... ! .i � � . r+ . . �� . _ - SOAA - X/11/84 - Members presen� - , ���`�°`'�� - /...�/f'�P�' ��`� J`'�.rJ�.v ° ��5. a � ��C� � � � Jy ]'" r �- � L'� ���/' (i/�.A .�S � Y C'`i i c xC'�r �° ' G 1 �-tC�� ~ (� p�1.su �7c�n �' 7° � 2� �n ch, ���7� , �. � - � John Logan - Chairman �dw ard Walke� �7oseph S�raub Geox'ge �iron Andrew Onufer, Secretary p� IIaard _�� � � �",�� , A].so Presen� �- David Christiansen - Ch,i�� of Inspec�.�ons Nick Lewis � �'ire Inspectar r The m�eting was call.�c1 ta ord�r by Ch�irm�n Lo��n a� ?:05 p. m. Case No. 2 on the agenda reques�ing a'variance to cons�xuc� a swimming poo,l enclosuxe at G96 Snug �s�.and�withdrawn. � W�s Case No. 1 on Agenda• - Ru�h �ckPrd ��1a11, 1].11. McMullen-Boo�h Road - a variancr: �rom S�andard Buildi.ng, Code, Secti.on 112]., Exi� Sign re-- quirements., Mr. T,ogan asked fa� a spokesman �rom the gra.up representa.ng PACT to presen� th�ir case or a�gumen�s �a �he Board. � ��4 • , ..('�Ji�('j11E•. ;��'"'� Mr. Alfred Hoffman,f�Pxesiden� of PAC�', s�ak�-.i�_}ie.h.al£_a£_LZ�C`l:. ac7vis�d the B�ax'd that PAC�haq�,cocnplied wi�h Cade �cgarding tf�e fire exi� siqns yL and Mr. Wesl�y Peters, Chi.�f, �lrehi�ect and Mr. ,3ohn (Gus) 'Degenkol.b we,re ` at th9.s' meet�.ng to �x�s�x�¢kxe�tv�u�3��i�exx make compl.ete Presen�ation to 13oard. �\ Mr. Hoffman �efer�ed to �he continen�a� seaCing arrangement wh.i.ch has a bearing an this case an�l a].so he wan�ed �o disp�l any fears �hat F�CT \� a` "was more xHi�sxesks�xsRx sensi�ive to aesi.h��a.c va�,ues �han in safety ��M fac�ors. Mr. Ho�fman fuXther made re�'er�nce to news��per ar�icZes re- ` garding certain other.vio7.atians at PACT which he fe1� may have been � furnished to �he news med�. Ir�_-rt�his �co.nneation �Mr. Unufer� state�-��at "�_.._ . .�, the'"Kti•�J:d�3.ncj'aepax men� �r��cords�are��ubl�.c L�cords; PACT records had been � ,: ex�al}t�iieci�'by I3efore tur'ning mee�ing over �o Mr. LVes�.ey P�ters; Chie� ' Architeat w,i�.h Frank Lloyd tidriqh�, I+ir. iio�'Cman p��,s��t�kgdx�xsdxxx listed' creditentia3.s of r1r. John iGus } Degenkolb, consu�.tan� to Mi . Pe�ers. . � At tha.s point Mr. On�fer, Acting Building Director interjected, objecting to the al�lec�a�ion that the i�uilding i]e�arkmen� "leaked" inFormation on � tlle PAC'T Cen�er. Mr. Onuf�r stated thati the nuilding Depar�.ment has na 's�crets RR� anyone in the Ci�y has access ta p�iblic xecords - and it any � i,ttformaCi�n was gi,vei�, i� was secu�eci by r�quests '(o���wli•ic�h. tl�e.re°�w,e��.e , seue.r..�,�,a� �a s�e �he records. Mr. i�io�f►nan apoloqi7�:d.�nd adva,sec3 wl�at ,he shauld have sa9.ci was �hat a m�mber of. the build�ng dep�rLmeszt . did make a pub�ic s�a�emen� to a reparter �hat i.here,were a number af can- , I �i.nuing viol.a�zons in the ha�.l �ha� were being bypassed an3 ov�rlooked �nd , � this pax�icul:ar fire exi.� sign was one o� them. Mr. Onuier stated tha� ths xeporter �nd sevezal o�hers aa�rakx�iaxm�aa�D�xe��xxgac��sxx di,d � go �hrouglZ � building d�:partmen�� .f�.1es. �� .; �,,�, , ��..,.�.` � � ��i` �•��' . ���� . �� Mac. WesJ.ey �eters spoke advisinq tlte boarci �hat ��iej� h•�,v� been ex�r�me�.y �ssiduous in designing a building which xs no� only in con£ormance wi.th �' the spix�.t but with the letter of the prevailing gov�rning codes. I " , � . . � ' _ _.__ _..__ _ _• . . ' . . • *��t � ' ' __ Ij:.0�1!2:LtLit.�i'�s�k!tl+r'iif��!.:L.�•1'CI..'Li:tdu�:NS! i E .. � . . �-�: , . . . , � � � �� �•. , ' , ' , - ',��:.� ;� � , ' ' ' �• �t . , . L•o be a i�4r. Degenkol.b rra�-em��epee��-a9weer��a�#.ant whom �hey consi�3e�-er�e-�f���e ` ���a�ar►d-eoe�e---ot����aad�ng--eemg}�nrsce outs�.anding cade compliance expert was empl.ayed by them as a consultant and it was never the�t�.intention at , � any �ime to regu�.t�_r-��n -�� ---���=��v�a:�"tt9no�e fram �he s�rict in�erpreta�i�n �of the cndc�. Mz. Peters said �hey bel.ieve what they are daing is correct and i� ther� is any vio],a�ion of the coe they an� tio know about i.t and wou].d never want to see �.k bui�t. , h1r. John (Gus) D�genkolb, consul�ant ta the Architects, w�s ir��rdduced. Mr. Degenkalb s�a�ed he had been, brnught i.:n as consultant �o �'rarik Loyd � Wr�ght maily because con�inental seating a�-��►e-��epd�e�,-�'�E'�-een��r^-�•--- � . was wanted at �he new PACT Cen�er anc�, Mr. L?egenkn�.b was pez�son wha �fi�st introducdd cont�.nental. seating into the (three model) bui.ldi.�g code. ' i ��_ �t. ��, �< <'- :t�- � s.� � '� ,.. � � Seating a�:ranc�ements+ carefu].,ly researctled and simul.ated to make sure distance €rom mas� r�mo�e seat di.d not exceed 1.50 �t. which is statu�,a�ry ��c.� � ' cia.�r�]xi;e under cod� Eor distance . to an exi�, Because of svmP' confusion regarding the word "�xit" in the code, M.�. Degenkolb had been in tQUCI� wzth � , Mr. Manning of Snuthern Build,ing Code C�ngress Iritezna�ionaZ, �nc. and 1�1x. � Manning�agreed that �he daors from the auditorz�m into th� �obby axe no� � "exit doors" bu� are "exit access doors". If the distance�of *ravei exc�eded 1.50 f�, then other prov,isions would have had to beeh made �ar exi�,ing - �ire separation, etc. e�c. Sznce Iess �.iz�n �.SCi ft. they �re exi.t access doars. and �hex'e�ore not requa.red .und�r Sec�i.on 1121 0� �he Code. Can- � �i.nen�.al sea�ing pravides for five rows af sea�ing with pairs of doors at . eachend ao that qtk'sr�x���s�xxxxxx persons en�ering. and ieavirtig. �he �heater � use orily those doars at either end +�� i:he rnws as stipulated on thei� '�r . �� ' ,theatre ticke�s and i1: is not necessary�for them to tr�vel Iaterally ttte �� yy. leng�h of the the��re. �f th�re i.0 any prablem on a�ze side oi.thea�re � persons would ��ravel sidewaxs �o other sid� for e.xit Tt is for that. �� �� �, reason that there is more spacing between iows o�' seats: rfz. vegenkol,b � e�eabarated �ur�her on other pxinci�les o� design and lighting of �ACT�},)",CU� which ensured �me�gency exit of peap7.� in two minu�.es as compar�d with fa.ve minu��s from a conventional thsatre. M�. Deg�nkaib then referrec3. �o Section 404.15b a� the Code cahich states ligh�ed exi.t s.igns are no� ra- �. quired a� each individual, doo�wa'y where c�oors open from main �udi�orium seating area. , ' � � •� - __ ___ _ =�±1�c��.ri.v�'la a:iilh4.!�.ail•' r_r_.anu_.zr..v�..s._......._. _ _ . . � ,.�Y1�ln.M��i��.R�C'�3.w.'s.`.i�:�4.�..�r.i .._ c � .I . . , , . ' s i, _ .. , .�� � � � � , ,. , . ' i �3 �� ``f l � � . .,At this poin� Mr. A�fr�d Haffman stated that �A��'-£ee��-- more than anything else PACT is very se�si.tive to �he desirability an�d necessity • of protec�ing the.public - tha� is th� number one priority. Bu� having' complyed with codes tkiey feel very"strongly,a�out the aesthetic distraata.on exit light� woul.d cr�ate. ' Mx.�Onufer spoke in oppasi.tion stating he �elt exit signs aze beau�iful and not an unsightly c3is�raction, particularly in tihi� area wliere there is an abundanae o�f elederl.y people.wha W���d neefl.h?�p in an emergency �' exit from �he buiZding. `. Mr. Ghra.s��.ansen continued, ma�{king re�erence to many in��actions of �he c,;, �,�`.i' codss pertaining to par�a�s, lighting, aisle spacing, �tc. and stated �j�1,},L�s, 1a _._ �`� • � t . �he �Ci�y has been working closely with PAC7.'[at�empt�.ng to correct��buti , 'not ge��ing �he desixed cooperation from pACT. hir. Christiansen read from a letter from Mr. W�.11iam Tangye, �xecutiv� Direc�ox of SHCC wlio s�at�d on3.y problem with the systiem is in na��arovic�ing exi.t signs from . the assembly area. Sectians 40�l.15 and 1�.23 requirG �hat th�se doorways be a.d�nti�iedb� exit signs and tli'at the only time exit signs can be o�nitted is ovez/main entrance door to the huilding. At clzairman Logan's reguest Mr. Christiansen rear� �rom Sectxon 4D4.].5. , 5peaking in behalf o� the i'ire D�partment Nick L,cwis said they were very hard se� on the requirement ior exit signs not only �rqm a code co��pliance angle but also considering �he type o� stru�L-ure, its us� and the age . bxaaket of the many citizens who us� it. Mr.. Lewis ref�rred to Sec�ions 8-2.�d and 510.I_0 qf the Lif� Safety code to suppor� hi.� az'gument tha� va.si.b3.e exi.t signs a�e mandatory, H� furLher quoted from Appendix A- A--5-1.0.1.1. .-- whicti s�ates the ne�d fo� signs is grea�er iit any building subject �o �ransien� occupany. Mr, i,ewi.s cont.inued by ca.ting Trom his own observations in�'ract�ons �hat should be co�rected in ac3ditiqn to thc exit signs ta make.i.t possibl� ta have•safe and rapid egress ��otn the building in the event of an �mergency. Mr. On�u�er supported Mr. Lewis' arguments and als� mentianed his own persanal a3�servations. � A very leng�hy disaussion Eollowed between Ci�y anci PACT representatives, � ' various sections of codes were ci�ed, and argutn�nts and code in�erpretations prQSented by both sides.� Infractions were mentinned not pertinent tn this �,, ;ny. meeL•ing �nd assurance? given to �he C,ity that the�y would be corr�c�c�d by' FACT in a timely manner. �-rr�,�%:�`, � . � _r— ' ' ___�_�....�. "__` __ _ � , :iC.'::,t,2;L�l�.:i3:'15��::�a�.n.n��.'d�IIC..�vrt:� . .. w. . , . �; '� ! . . , � i . ! . ' , ' �h, - - , , fr t{„ . J ' �Mr.,Hotfman assured the Doard and the City tha� h� wouZd persona�,ly s�� �ha�'all areas o� violation�wexc: correc��d imm�diate],y but on the s , mat�er of self-�.11uminating Z,ights, PACT �E1� that tor aesthetac purposas �hey should cantinue to press �or what they £ee]. is a coxrec� interpretati,on of �he code. Becaus� of � tlYe conflicting ---tn�e�mn��or�- �.nformation fzam SBCC - the le�ter to �he Ci�y frarn i�1r. Tangye and the inforrna�a.on suppZied by Mr. .Degankalb -�ir. Ho�fman asked tiha�. �he Baard perhaps shou�.d wi�hhold any decision �n�il c�.�rifica�ion received from SBCG. , , � � � . A� Ckia�.rman Lagan's �equest Inspec�o� Lewis commen�ed1fur�her on secCions � ai the code dea�ing with exit signs and s�ated he disagreec3 wikh PACT's �.interpre�ation of the cade. He a�lso mentioned the many calls he h�fl received from concerned ci�izens voiczng �h�a.r concErn with poor l.igh�ing and 1ack, a� exit s,igns i.n the new building. , >, ' MoLe discussion �ollowed �egarding na� only the �xit signs bu� subjec� of 1.igh�ing and Cha�.rman i,agan asked that all discu�sxpn be xelated to , tYte sub�ec�. ai hand -- exit signs. , � Chairman Logan call,ed ��z cammen�s ��om t�oard memb�rs. hSr. Biron responded that without �h�: background on the ma�ter tha� }ao�h City and� �ack repre-- sentatives l�ave, he found th� conilicting interpre�a�i.ons confusing. Secondly, he wauld 1.ike �he opportunity �o vi.ew th� site, and third, wou�d like �o know if Mr. Tangye's opinion now differs �rc�m the opinxon given � in ha.s l�tter �o �he City i.n , Septeinber of 1980. i�� . S�raub agr�ed . that c�.ari�ica�ior► irom Mr. 3.'angye and SHCC was necessary, espec�.a.11y � considering the li�e safe�y factor. 'Chairman Logazz sra�ed �he ma��e� ��..� rf'r.:;� �<l.: � �.; I � � , had to be �esolved and there seemed �o be no t�o�ie o� a comproma.se between . the Ci.�y and PACT. . � ' ' � More discussion and argumen�s pra and can between City anc� PACT. Chair-- man �ogan,requested that Mr. Chr�.s�ian� read �rom section o� code pex- . . �ai.ning, to exit la.ghts. , M , � In answer to/hxs qu�s�ion �he �oa�d s�a�ed thati they were unable �o r�e�e-- � . an-tisc--- arrive a� a clecision on L'his matter. rir. E�ogan suggest�d that the i3aard inspec� �his site l�efcsre maki.ng a decision. Tt w�s agreed that tYte Board and City r�presen�a�ives would meei at the PACT si�e a�. � 9 a. m. Friday., January 13, 3.964.� � .,,, . ' 'r_�,f1�"� i o� ,� �ir.,,� .� j1 ���. 1� . . , . . � , f . . � , . . . � . _ � . . ' . ' . .1�i"�y �I,''1. . .� ' . e � . ' .. . ' , '1 ' , . . � ' t, . . ��.,,q; >: � •. , . . ; ' ' , . � , . . , . ' . � , k�. � . , . . . ` i i � ' i , . , r '. ,+� . , � . . I . ' ' � � 1 , . . ti • , � � ' , i , ' � � . � � . ,• . ' � � ' � � i '�:j,f .� 'Y ' � . . l , r . I • ' � .' : � � .. • ' .. . . , . ' ' ' �r � ' , • � . '' ' ' �. '' i .. . ' f ' _'• � . ,'. + ' 1 � . . . , ' r. . , I F ' r. • • ' �'I ' 1 , . .+ . i . � • " � � ! �f ' . . . ' � � ' . ' � 'G . . .:., � ,' • i ' �. . . ' � 4f ' j . , . . , � t`' y .. �? ' Y , ' f ? F! F. , i , � ',. . 1 . . �. . . , � . {'� ' :. ' ,. �. , . '. F� . �.. . '. , : �- +' r. , r �'. . „ � , f1. • ' , . ' ' c ' ' . .�r .. �', � ' .. � . � ' . . . . � ' . - , � .. . ..' , . l,; � .. . � . . • ' ' . ' . ' ' '.i . . . ' ,f . ; , . . . t•.7d `'.yr• ,s :� . ;jrrl,..r" vr. ' � ' ' + - � _ . .. r < . , . � .. . , ' . ' • ,:' �:�_ ... � . �- , . �.. .. .. ..�'a,: T'� .. . , ... . '�.• � � . . , , .. . . . . . . . , ' .. . .� . . . . . . � . � ' !; . ' . , � .. ' � , . . . � ' i . • t , � � . , �'F �• � �., . ' ' . � _ ' � f , ' ' r • « '� �.. � �t� I {� . il� . . � . . . - . . . _ � . � ' , . � ' . � � . + , . . . . � , . , , ' : Frank �Lloyd ,Wright/ � 5 " • ' ��. � �..�?���� rep:res�ntati.ves shawed �i�.a�� a� o�her $a.mildr :auc3i�oriums � � . �; they had 'canstruct�ed in� other areas. of �he country.� � � ;r', . . . . , . . .. „ . . , :�y,' ,'� � . ' . . , ' ,I ',� The mee�ing was .adjourned a� 3:40�p. m. WiXI reconvene �t 9 a. m. �- '.. . . �.,� , . .. . ' , " . . ' �...,�� . , . • � , ' . ' Friday,. January 3, 198�1. � � , , ' , . '. - � . : � � . � ; � � '. � ,�. :_ . , . , . . ° • .' ' � : . � i . � ; 1 . ` k • � , � ' . . . : . . � ' ' . . . . ' ' • � . . ' ' � . . . , p . � ' � ' , ' . , ' . � � ' , ' .. � � . � ` . . . , . {, . ' i . . , . . . . ' � . .5 . , . . . , . . . . ' . a . . �' ��;.: . . . . � , . ' � , � � . , .. . . . � . . . ` � . . , . � ' t. #.• •_f;'; '' , ' . ' . r. � ' ' � .r' � . . `i . ' , , . , ' :✓;�i , � . „ � ' � : � , ' . . t � , , ", ' , . F . ' � � • _ ' � . . . . � ' � ' • ' o t ' � � ,' � . . � F . . - ' .. � ' . . , ' . . . � � f ' � � . „ . ' . � ' . . . i ' - ' ' ' ' , ' r' .r • � ' . . '` ' � � � . � . � '�, r . .. , r � � ' '' . r . • 1 . .. �. . '` � ' . ,,,rl • J � .! I � ' .• � r � , . ' � . � Y , i . 1 . �� � ' •' .{ � , - ' ,' ' ' � . � � , . � ' . � � � � � . � s � , � . � . � . . . � . irt< ' e .. . . . , ; � . .. . , , . ' , ' • . , .. . � . . � , . . � ' � ' , ' ' � . � ' . , ' . '. � � '� d ' � � . ' , �Y � ' ' � ' � . .. 1 1. ' � , . , . . � . . . . . � . . . - , . . . 7 ii•.. 1` � . • � ,f . ' . €; . . ' . . [ . ' , i . .. . . ' ' . , ' . . . ' r ' , ' . � , ,`. � , , . , ' • ' � , ' s . �'�' ` , . i , • , , � };' r .. ' , . ,.� .. • � , . , ,�' ' . �Yt. . . ' . ' . . 3 . . . . � � . • ' � � ' . r. . ' r � . � . , • , ' . � . � � , , . ' • . . . � '.. � .. �' � . . ' ' . ' F ' �} � . e ' . . . '1� � ..1" . ' . . ' � � � � • � . . • ,. . ' � ' ` ' , ! � ' ' , 1 1 ' , � , , ' � ' 1 . ' ' , ' ' . . . . ' . . f . , ' . . . , . . . , . , . . � ' F } [ � ' '. .1 . 7 ' � a, f � ' . . ' . ' [ . . � � � . 1 . . � . . � ' �. � ). . . . - ' 1 . � j' • ' . . .. . ' � ' • � • . ' , ., . , � . , . . ' 1 , • ^ .. I•l t 1 t . ' , ' � , ' ' . . t ' ' . * . . � � I , � . ' . � , . 1 f . r ' � � . , l , � . . , .. ' • ' ' � . . " . . . . .. .�, r .� ' , . • � . . . � . � . ' ' � . , � ' ' . r � � � � � . . . � � � � r . . . � ' ' . ' I . ' � . � . ' ' � � . . . . ; � � . . . . k ' . . 1 � . . . � I ' ' � � r • • ' • • • . . . • � ' • • . • • i ' , ' ' . • . ' . le � � , i 1 , ' , . ' . • " . . . . . , � . . $ i , . ,o . � � , . . E , .. � . .. . !.l..' . , ' ' � . �. . � ' � � . ^:.��o°.�.l.�i�t .."" � 1 '�i;r, ' , ..`---�—`�— ------- _ °t—.9_ W �� 7� - - --- vt�������::� �; :'. o ; •f � r �. f•� ` �'t �.�� � � t . . . . . ' ;` � , 'i , _ . . . , ., . . . '.0