Loading...
1981 ;, ?„ , N S. ?'??tl?'`it.'r ?F ? F 41 4J 0 41 JJ JJ 41 JJ 1J 41 •rl •ri rt ri ri r1 r1 r1 -,4 A A A A A A A A .[] A rl •r•1 •,4 -ri ri r1 ri .ri k x x k x x x x x x w w ca w w ca W cd w ra W W W W W dl W W W Cl N W W W W W W W W W W cn w In to w w cn In cn to 44 N rl 0 r R s r-4 I -4 1 H r ri , 1 N f 1 i I i 0 to w r r b W 'd W 13 W z3 ; W b W 'd •t7 to •i3 41 W tp W W [? W tT W w d) r-I d1 r-1 W r1 W r-1 W r i W j V W, fd lJ tt1 4.1 rd 4.1 td 41 JJ 41 1J 11 ? O 114 C a, !~ a >: Rr O a t~ W C W s~ W C W i~ W W' W rtl rd cd ni !a W ri 13+ rd w ra to m rn w 1 ' W 1 W ~ e I4 \ 14 rd $4 rd 1.1 rd e , 1•r to k M ca .-1 ca r i La H r-I (D 0••1 t o a to a U a ? a Ca W * C W W r-1 r 1 ul _ 1 • '? O •r{ rl t U rl r•. I U r•1 C I W .i U U •ri U •rl U W r'1 I ? 4J , JJ 0 rd 0 rd 0 C: rl 41 r<l RS r-I 11 W "I •rl O •14 O •ri O M rl w 4a 1}4 W ri fT 'c1 H w 1.1 Or k 04--1 A O j u, r -I .0 rd 0 ?- b •r-1 A W >4 4a 0 0 E r- ;J w •r•1 O M 0 .C ' -. rd a -. w > w to ra O 04 rC '0 O ' • w W U $4 0 s4 w rd e . rz ii > 0 r i 0 r-i •.I . W 4J +1 41 rd y w 44 0 0- o •• O Z w 'd k O H 0 U4 rn +W (n - w cn ?I 0 0 0 1- 0 Ln 0- 0 0 14 4J O 41 O O= 0 W 41 .-1 la $4 l0 k N 14 r- •rl W w Q+ w 134 U ra ... . >.I ? 14 C 0 4-1 4J - 4J tD 4J - :3 W W C >1 _ O O W N r1 w en w . U rn b+ p 0 1 i U 0 s~ 4J 4.1 A 4.) >c' •ri 04 W 1 W W m O r rl rl •rl U r- U' A u A 43 ' ? 1.1. 1.1 I w 1 1.1 41 44 r-1 44 r-1 4J rd (U :? 0 :1 A qt U t n Clr '4J C 0 0 •O O A U W E 4J f4 r•1 0 H O, ` 'vU W • ::1 9: U ?. U C U C.' rn -PA y : O W A Or 'r- 41 ri .1J r-i a% 4•1 11 •ri \ •r4 •rr •r4 .,A ri •ri a A [ C 04 C Rs 1-i rl 0 w N W w •ri w s 1 11 W ri (a r-i rd r1 b 0 it 0 0 O 0 W O E rw . O .-1 C 1J Id W rn w tr rLl rI A r-I A r•i U •rl ri 'rI U4 •r4 144 tT w Qa 0 1.1 P4 0 0 +-i f C ri RS 0 04 .? ' 04 O 04 3 4J 0 0 JJ 0 14 rd W •r'; U rd U 11 04 tr O k $4 azr jai Or , 14 U U u O S4 O > to rd ' rn W U W 0 '1:1 rO ra 0 (n O O- O- 44 O .O tar 0 cd a 0> 'z1 w. x 4•1 44 0, w 0 44 0 44 5' )4 u rn w to iJ U W 31 W 0 41 W 0 U 1 0 ul O 0 0 0 O O 0 4•1 V rr 4J r- W W W H r-f H 0 W 44 r•-t r-•1 ri a) 0 W Ul U] U W 44 W W 44 W Ql ri < U W - C 44 C tw f~ 4a U $4 C O t~ , C C C $4 .Q 0 U U 44 hi A U 41 In O O O Ir 41 U O •11 O •ri ca 0 pG M C C E . l 3 r-i 3 •ri 3 rd N U U .C U A •ri W 14 W W O W U! $ i rt: •ri R3 W 0 4J O 4-1 0 41 0 •rl W o •rJ N w •r1 •rl W r-1 ri W O 1-i ri E O () ri U PA U r-1 1•i 1.1 f 1 > I •r•1 44 •ri ' rli t31 tit M >`I •rr W 14 -1 1-•1 N w W Fi :' W W O W to 0 0 s 0 3 > C r•1 Q.r cc V A rd aJ W Q .> W U )4 .0 A 14 .Q > u 44 44 44 •ri r-1 W > .14 > •r1 A O > rd •i•1 41 4J 11 ri w w - qC 0 14 r-i sn r•1 O r 4 ul w W Ul W (1) W - r-'I r-i - - W - W l0 H $4 - •r4 4J - •ri E: ?4 o CL W. Ci 't3 C 'b 9 ra to A 0 rn in •rl kro •11 'in •ri JQ w O U "41 0 U 0 arr • W W O •r'i 0 -A 0 •ri • 'J' 0 • • 4j • 11 r : ' E 0 • td r~ • ra O U3 M - U U) U w U w rn Q! Ot •-? r, 'r? cn A 0 44 ?r w kD 44 f4 44 t n r-1 r i O r~ r I r-1 r-i co H co •,.i co co rn ?% co a) $4 \ \ to \ r••1 4J (d V cq ra W ?. Q x M rr'1 Ln Ql Cl 4J 0 0 •ri a. w 41 4J In .! 't3 U •ri U U U U .. r••1 u 'O U 1.1 U $4 U . I to O W > ' rd 0 rd >1 rd "O rd rp td ca rd cu td dJ rd 41 ra . ' W 0 A> H W a' W W W > W > 41 W' 0 W (n 41 ul a) $4 rr Q •rl Ql W PR .i CA r-I ftl r•i W 3 in ctl W W W' ' 'L7 H In 14 C fn !? W r-4 W 'd 't] r I a >1 N r1 W FO p m $4 • r 1 114 Or f"i r-4 14 r1 14 " ry ri SG Ed W 19 W f•. W 44 41 44 W > W N W rt1 W •r{ 41 ? .. > iJ 0 3 4-j 04 a•1 it ¢J r1 4 r-i 4.1 144 AJ W V *iy 4J rd rd ra >, W ri W 0.4 td O +d p W r4 W M L.' W 41 cd P4 alr W W 3 0 3 w 3 ca 3 ca 3 O 3 >1 3 W 3 ri 3r C fn ?i ? w H N >•1 14 Ca N it 11 r-1 N b> I r 1 ' -14 >i 0 M Id ra r^4 ra Q 11 td m ra Ca b H W W 4J 1•i v W o W In W." r1 W Ln a) a. W W W W •r•1 •H 0 N rA a r•'1 111 rl W H N r-i O H' O r-i Ill A r -I ri at u C.1 r` U N U ?D U H U r-I U co U 1-•1 U r--I V r i' U i. r I '. _ __- __?_. - _?.- .-.?-_ -_ __?_.-..._._ ,...?...•.__..__ _?......-.. __.:.____=:i. ?`?'' ,?r:.7 .. .- Ili .. •:F 1 ..fit ?i"ty' r'k '?r.?.t ?' IMF ?, ?, i . ?. ?. `. ' • ,• 4'• 41 • ` . W W W ,N . a a a a to a a (n ul N • rr rd N N .. O I I ! A a a 4) t 41 X11 r0 al a 0 ' U a (a 41 N a +b d 4.7 n7 41 W 4J a ;... sr 14 . ' ' • c7 to o ? +? ?, 1 T ro $4 ' w c o t 4 O 14 0 O O a U O O .. .,..I . o+ '-i 4J U) O U z 41 ' 4a :1= r4 u .r{ r1 .f] ! 0 O a (d r-4 r -I 14 O > A A a C7 41 $4 W.' o . ml ki al ra 4-) 1>a O , . .• orI U- 1: +1 ; j y O, rd 10 44 a U 1 ' ri a CO -p •k•1 O 4j w 4. (n 1n 4 . O r 1 ul - .N 4J ' r-i .. 41 rI 4.1 Z M •r1 to o rz= o r ' . er ;t a a s o r a A V) 1% Ri 'H 4 •r1 04,-4 , . [c7 a), 41 4 4-) , C.) , a I ...Q 4 O uI ' % rC ' o ul H'. b? 3 k H (a 4) . ro G l••'. (D a (••. •11 U 3 •^I (o U1 o r 1 3 11 .9 to r1 41 O 44 • , ra (13 , a r -I 1.1 •ri ra O r4 -A 40 •rl rd 1-I rt 131 . >4 `a r.3' > •rl O p .0 r? m . O 'o o > • U r4 :? •rl a a C a O U Q 4-1 O r54 '0 O • rd O - ra ' H M U o fn 44 a co '> t w ! tw o O co 41 $4 co a a IN. r+ 14 f _ ' 41 fo > ?d > c CA $4, $n 0 4 m a{ . U N 41' a W b ; a r-I r-I r I >?' Q) • 1•t ? U ? ra .Q1 ' .. , 'o C'1 [ ry r_4 to 1 rd 1''i to >1 to >s >~ 4J to a to . a (a rd .1~ } 1 . ' r4 'o . U r4 rq V' rd Q (a O O Ln' a " to r b a to «) r4: r-I ri (n m r•I W r-l U 1 4•. •f .. .. , '} ... ' . •? .:1 1. '`k . . ..' a: ,. • .. 1 i?(, ?-•?} J AA, ...tHY L'?iS•• , IbA SAi?34??1' Lw 113.r•?3r't',,'i., i', ?(. ..f?LSi'Ib•<=17f???M??'!W'f17?fE7QltYir.7{y?y??1?,. _r.,1ii.'.•. :'Srrl. Board of Adjustment & Appeals on' Building (Flood Control) Meeting of Wednesday, March 4, 1981 Page 2 glass requirements,'with the condition that, should any situation arise that would change the distances to the other buildings, the owner will be required to install wired glass. Motion seconded by Mr. Logan; and motion, as made, passed unanimously. Inasmuch as Mr. Forrest Watson also represented, and is the architect for the construction at Pier Pavillion (Case VI on agenda) this case was,next presented to the Board. Mr. William Alexander'is lessee of Pier Pavillion - a City owned property -- and requested a variance to build an addition/replacement. to existing pool facility, at six feet below ,100-year flood level, where a portion of the structure will be in seaward portion of Zone 2. Mr. 0. Stephen Thacker, attorney for Mr. Alexander, and Mr. Andrew M. Nicholson, City of Clearwater Oceanographic Engineer, assisted'Mr. Watson in presentation of this case. The building will house restroom facilities, storage area, and a pump room with its, respective equipment. The design of the building was thoroughly discussed. Openings in building have been designed for panel installation in event, of hurricaine. Roof system, walls, and foundation systems, have been specially designed to withstand storm surge. Mr. Logan moved the*Board grant the request to Mr. William Alexander to build his addition as e- signed and situated, six feet below the 100-year flood level. Motion' seconded by Mr. Dean. Motion passed unanimously. Case II, Case III and Case IV were presented, to the Board and heard at one time inasmuch as they are of similar nature, and Frank M. Bosworth represented each of the three property owners.. In order to comply with state health regulations requiring restrooms to be located with. 75 feet of a public pool, oirners required variance to construct said facilities below 100-year flood level. Structures in all three cases will be _ separate, independent buildings, not attached to main buildings. Mr. Bosworth supplied information as to the amount of variance required in each case. Mr. Walker made motion to approve requests for variances. Motion seconded by Mr. Dean. Motion approved unanimously to allow the variances hereafter described: Brigantine Condominium (Owner, Bayway Properties, 'Inc.) Unit A; 724 Ba w_ay Blvd. Variance - 3.b7 feet below 100--year flood level., Isle of Clearwater Condominium (Owner, Houle Industries, Inc.) Lots 13 and 14.1 Unit 5A, 200 Dolphin Point Variance -- 3.25 feet below --year flood level. Placid Harbor Condominium (Owner, Windwood Development Company, Inc. Lot 13 and north 23.5 feet of Lot 12 -- Unit Island Estates ar a.nce : ? 3. 7 feet below .100--year flood level. EXHIBIT 1 PAGE 1 , . t s - ' Board of Adjustment & Appeals on Building (Flood, Control) Meeting of 'Wednesday, March 4, 1981' Page 3 Last case presented to board was Case N, The Harborage-Condo- ininium, 1631 Gulf Blvd. '. Southeast American`Development Corporation is owner/developer of the property and Mr. Robert J. Fleck, Assistant Vice, President, presented case to,the'board. To comply with state health 'regulations requiring; rest room facilities within 75 feet.of a public pool; owner requested a 3.5 foot variance. The building housing'these' facilities will be a separate and•independent building, unattached to main building itself., A motion was made by Mr..Dean that the appeal be granted in accordance with the application submitted. Motion seconded-by Mr. Logan. Motion passed unanimously with no•further dis- cussion. Meeting adjourned at 3:45 P.•M. P .'S s r EXHIBIT 1 - PAGE 2 1 t r BOARD OF ADJUSTM}1NT A.-APPEAT; ON BUILDING _:_,?60D CONTROL) Wednesday, May. 6, 1981 NO'S' OFI+ICIAL MEMBERS PRESENT:. FXICUS'ED, MEMBER : John Batstone,.Chairm'an Forest' Dean John Logan Joseph Straub Edward Walker Roy J. Ayres, Secretary The meeting,was called to order by Chairman John Batstone at 2:10 P, M. Wednesday, May 6, 1981. • 1 The only case on the agenda was a request from Cheezem Corporation for two structures to be constructed below 100-year, flood :Level at Landmark Towers II, 1250 Gulf Blvd., the second phase of their condominium project. Mr., Michael Reichard presented the'case for Cheezern as follows: (1) con- struction of a guard house at front,' and between entrances, of their project (Landmark Towers.I and Landmark Towers II) ,'and construction of bath„facilitie, within:75 feet of pool area as required by State Health regulations. Both - structures to be 4,.5 feet below 100-year flood level. In response to ' questioning, Mr. Reichard advised guard house would be on same level as parking lot and only equipment therein woul'd'be air conditioning unit and ' control panel fo'r operation of electric gate. Building would also contain small toilet 'facility. 'Guard house and bath house facilities would be separate, independent buildings, not, attached to main buildings.. After consultation and discussion between board members, motion was made by i,r. Talker to approve request for variance as requested on,.both structures. Motion seconded by Mr. Logan and carried unanimously. Mr.. Reichard was reminded and cautioned that due to lower construction level, all electrical outlets, panels, receptacles, etc, must be located at higher level in build- ings, or 12 feet above mean sea level. µ Mr. Ayres requested the Board's approval an new procedure for handling minutes of board meetings. Unofficial copy of minutes of each meeting will be prepared and sent to each board member` as soon as.possible after every meeting. At subsequent meeting, the minutes would be approved with or with- out amendments/corrections, signed by Mr. Batstone, Board Chairman,' and would-then become a part of City of Clearwater official records. Further,, applicants requesting variance-would be advised by letter, written under Mr. Ayres' signature immediately after each meeting as to whether or not their request=for variance has been approved. Board members approved of and agreed to new procedure. Minutes of the meeting of Wednesday, March 4, 1981 were approved and signed by Mr. Batstone. Meeting was adjourned at 2:30 P. M. John; Bat stone., Chairman 1 _ J'an M, JensL ,Recording Secretary EXHIBIT 2 - PAGE I I 9 WARD 0,' , ADJUSTIdENT & - APPEAL QF 7CIAL BUILDING/FLOOD CONTROL Wednesday, July 15, 19€31 Members Present: Excused Members: John Batstone, Chairman Forest Dean John Logan Edward Walker Joseph Straub Roy J. Ayres, Secretary Also Present: Patti Stough, Code Analyst The meeting was called to order by Chairman John.Batstone at 2:15 P. M. Wednesday, July 15, 1981. Minutes of previous meeting of May 6, 1981 were reviewed and approved as submitted. The first case on the.agenda was,a•request from Metro Development Company to construct toilet facilities adjacent to s'wimming pool, 7.6 feet below 100-year flood level at Clearwater Point Condominiums, ?00 Gulf- t yj_ew.Boulevard. Mr. Earl Cravens of Enterprise Building Corp., presented the case for.Me-ro Development, stating since State health regulations re- quire toilet facilities within 75 feet of pool area, only feasible location for such facilities in this case was in area 7.6 feet below flood level. No one spoke in 'opposition and Mr. Straub moved that hav3 ng- held this duly constituted hearing that there 'are practical difficulties and unnecessary hardships in carrying out the 'strict letter 'of the provisions of the Flood Control Ordinance as it affects such structure and that the same can be varied within the intent of the Flood Control Ordinance, that such appeal be granted. Motion seconded and carried unanimously. ; ,At this point, Mr. Ayres.introduced Patti. Stough, the City's new Code Analyst, to members of the-board and briefly outlined her various areas of duties. Mr. Batstone questioned why two cases were being heard at this July ` 15th- board meeting whereas he' had received a copy of the agenda which listed only one case. Mr. 15atstone was specifically concerned as to whether the second case had been properly advertised, Mr. Ayres explained that the second case involved a portable building to be placed at 2166 Palmetto Street by- Florida Power Corp., to be used as office space by, them for a period of four years. This case had already been before the Zoning Board of Adjustment and Appeal.. This board ruled favorably on the portable building being placed on this property but was not able to rule on 'the time extens3.on. Because. Florida Power had been indirectly led to believe that their variance request could be handled by one board, where- as only the Building Board of Adjustment & Appeal could rule on the time element, the City Clerk expedited advertising and we were able to include this case in this July 15th. Board -meeting. . Mr. Tiro J. Gelvin presented the case for Florida Power Corp. Mr, p EXHIBIT 3 - PAGE 1 7--15-81 CASE NO.' II -- C. D. Carley, Jr., '320 Harbor Passage (Owner) Representative - Mr. Randall Pickelmann C. F. Curtis Const., Inc. Mr. Pickelmann presented case for owner advising size and contour of owner's lot presented-difficulties in locating a swimming pool but if the 12 ft. variance requested is granted, a pool could be located between the seawall and house. A 34 ft. continuous pour deck has been designed by, an engineer, 5 ft. back from seawall, which will provide security to seawall during and after construction. Also approximately two feet of open area - not con- creted -- is provided between edge of wall and pool deck to provide for any needed fill and maintenance. Discussion followed.regarding batter piles or deadmen to ensure proper bracing of seawall. MOTION: Mr. Walker moved as follows: "Mr. Chairman: With regard to the request for a variance from the Building Code for a structure located at 320 Harbor Passage, I move for a decision by the board as - follows: that the-board finds it to be within its authority to act upon the request, and hereby'grants the requested variance, with the following conditions; (1) that the, engineering of the deadmen and bracing of seawall be approved by the Engineering Department." The motion was immediately amended to state that the conditions be waived upon confirmation of Andy Nicholson's signature on the plans in file. Motion was duly 'seconded as amended and carried unanimously. Granted'as requested. '(Walt Hilton left meeting to check initials on plan and confi-rme'd, that the plan in files has been properly approved by Engineering Department), CASE N0. III - H. G. Hamilton Lot 5, Bldg.., 10-Bay Esplanade " With regard to this case, Mr. Ayres stated that because time did not. permit a thorough examination of plans, there is a possibility that a Zoning variance might also be required, although prel.ianinary examination-did not indicate this to be a fact. Mr. Ayres advised, however, that the owner should be aware of this possibility before the fact, as if a zoning variance is necessary, the action of this Board today would not cover.such a variance. Mr. Hamilton presented. information as to location of this strand steel building, which will house beach vehicle(s) and 'peach chaires, umbrellas, etc. Equipment will be stored in building at night and brought out for beach usage during daylight hours. There is no electricity or plumbing involved. Will be on grade only slightly higher than present parking area. Some discussion•followed but no Droblems seen. - MOTION: Mr: Straub moved as follows: "Mr. Chairman: With regard to the request for a variance from the Building Code for a structure located at-10 Bay Esplanade, I move for a decision by the Board as follows: 'Granted as Requested.' The Board finds it to be within its authority to act upon the request, and.:hereby grants the variance as requested." - 2 - EXHIBIT 4 - PAGE I a?s'S2t%s ?. Y?.{4f•'? 's R'1 ` t S a? ' : r'' ? . ?P,`. . , - , ' F ?, I ? a 5, ,. • - ' . f' d F, ' t .. i .. f y ? . '' r , , ` ' , f?i ' . ,I tlx: • , , , ;'iY? ayes., Motion seconded" and carried with. four Mr. .Logan abstained due to , personal interests'. Granted' as requested. Mr. Ayres reminded Mr. Hamilton that'it [ would b'e'to his interest to'. ;::=?y3 Official in the Building with Zoning crieck Department before leaving to ?.s , . not required that a Zoning variance Is- ensure . . . r. 'The meeting was. adjourned at 3k15 P. M. , l ,fie - .SS - - ? ti}1 i-e v y John St e; Chairman Recording Secxte'tary• ! ' . EXHIBIT A PAGE 2 '^ - • ? w = ` ,. i Y t •• i+,. S.. .,...-._ _.. .. w+ ... .... .. , . ? oe Pa K., e'.,', .. j [. r r 1 a r {',!!', 1 .. ,•, is • • ?.lt , ' ,1 l ' • • , f BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT & APPEAL BUILDING/FLOOD CONTROL September 23, 1981 Members present: Members absent:' John Batstone, Chairman Forest Dean Edward Walker John Logan Joseph Straub R. J. Ayres, Secretary Also present: Walt Hilton -- Ch-ter, Permits & Inspections The meeting was called to order by Chairman John Batstone at 2:05 P.M. in the Conference Room of the Engineering Department, City Hall Annex. CASE NO. 1 - Villas of Clearwater Beach, 15 Glendale Street z Owner -- Sea Eagles Corporation Representative Mr. Peter Narich Mr. Marich presented the case for the owner. Three, variances were re-- , quested as follows: A. One foot variance to construct Pool 7 ft., below existing grade so that a pool eight feet in depth can be 'constructed to provide for safer diving and swimming acc-omodations. B. Through construction error pile caps 1 ft. 4 inches in depth rather than 2 ft. as' required. An eight' inch variance requested. C. A four foot variance to permit construction of pool toilet facilities, elevator lobby and storage units below 100-year flood level.. . Any W necessary electrical outlets, etc, would be above flood level. MOTION:. By Mr. Walker. "With regard to the request for variances from the, building code/flood insurance regulation for a structure located at 15 Glendale Street, I move for a decision by the Board as follows: Granted as requested. The Board finds it,to be within its authority to act upon the request, and hereby grants all three variances as re- guested. Motion seconded by Mr. Straub and carried unaydimously. CASE NO. II - Surfs1de Condominium, 111 Idlewild Street Owner - Cosa Bella, Inc. Representative - Mr. Peter Marich Mr. Marich presented the ,case for the owner. A six foot variance requested tp permit 'construct3on of, pool toilet facilities, elevator lobby and trash room below 100-year flood level. r All electrical outlets,•etc. will be above' flood level. No problems foreseen and no objections presented by, any Board member. MOTION: By Mr. Straub. "Mr'. Chairman - with regard to the request for a variance from the building code regulation for a structure located at EXHIBIT 5 - PAGE 1 •M Board of Adjustment & Appeal. Building/Flood Control September 23, 1981 k Page 2 1 Idlewild Street I move for a decision' by- the board as follows: Granted as requested. The Board finds .-it to be within its authority to act upon the request, and hereby grants the variance as requested." Motion, seconded by Mr. Walker and passed unanimously. T. CASE N"0. III - Mr. William Kimpton, Owner 265 Bayside Drive Representative - Mr. Randall Laird A 13 ft. variance requested for construction of swj-Tming pool 5 ft. from seawall rather than 18 ft. required. Mr. Kimpton and Mr. Laird presented the"case stating only way pool can be. constructed' on lot' would bring it within five feet of sealwall. Also second problem exists in location of pool in relation to existing concrete porch slab. Cannot violate angle of repose and pool must be-five feet from porch slab. Discussion and questions ensued regarding engineering confipgurations on placement of pool. Question as to whether City would accept, engineer's design if sealed by engineer. Mr.-Ayres stated Building Department would believe design to be sound, and would accept engineer's sealed drawings. MOTION By Mr. Walker. "Mr Chairman -- with regard to the request for. a variance from the building" code/flood insurance" regulation for a structure located at 265 Bayside Drive, I move 'for "a decision by the.. board as follows: The Board.finds it to be within its authority to act upon the request, and hereby grants the variance as requested." Motion seconded by"Mr. Straub and carried unanimously. Request granted." Some' discussion followed regarding -interpretation of Section,3906 of the Coastal Construction Code in relation to 18 feet required distance from seawall for tiebacks. Walt Hilton will pursue this further with Andy Nicholson and-the matter will"be -discussed at a future Board meeting. Meeting adjourned at 2:50 P. M. 1 ?1f John B -one, Chairman J/: M.- Jensen,! Recording Secretary EXHIBIT 5 -- PAGE 2 i 3 1 f 4 ' 1 f BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT & APPEAL BUILDING/FLOOD CONTROL r November 18, 1981 MI:.,. .. t 01.c Members present: Member absent; John Batstone,.Chairman Mr, Forest Dean John Logan Joseph Straub Edward Walker R. J. Ayres, Secretary Also present: Walt Hilton - Chief, Permits & Inspections Pattie Stough -- Code Analyst' The meeting was called to order by Chairman John Batstone at 2:10 P. M. in.'the Operations Center. Conference room, City Hall Annex. Minutes 'of the September ,23, 1981 meeting were reviewed and approved as submitted. First case to be heard - South.,Bay Condominium, located at 1501 and 1551 Gulf Blvd., Clearwater Beach_.' Representing South Bay were; .Frank Hegner - Project Manager, Realty Developments U. S.Steel Corp. J. P. Blair - Project Engineer !' Ben Christopher - Greiner Engineering Dennis Thompson -? Richards Nodine, Mr. Hegner presented the case. Due to contour of construction area, the southeast corner of the building located at 1501 Gulf Blvd. will en- croach eight feet within flood plain area. Mr. Hegner explained the difficulty was in attempting to mitigate the e;'feet of traffic on to Gulf Blvd. by, having one 'entrance and one exit -,for two buildings. Also parking requirements had to be considered, as well as•drainage require- ments to ensure proper drainage to retention areas on the property. In response to various questions from Mr, Walker, Mr. Hegner elaborated on designs of building. Drawings have been submitted to and approved by the City-Engineering Department. A variance in elevation to permit construction of mechanical rooms three feet below flood plain, and a variance to-install concrete walls around the parking area three 'feet below flood plain also were requested for this building. Several questions were presented 'by the Board and're- sponded to by Mr. Hegner'. MOTION: By Mr.,, Logan. With regard to the request for variances from the Flood Insurance regulation for a structure located at, 1501 Gulf Blvd., Sand Hey, Clearwater Beach, the Board finds it to be within its authority and hereby grants,the variances as requested. Motion duly seconded and .carried unanimously., A request for variance, for construction of mechanical rooms, and variance EXHIBXT 6 - PAGE I ----?-__..?-...?__?,.n._...__ .e.?.?_. .. ..__» •. ....._. .».?. ...... ....:..? .« ,_ r,?..4d?`t?J'y'ff;ESiL«iiir2??,!ti;ssfixs?'. r.'?TL'£kt? { r 2 - ?.• fOr.construction of a break-away wall. around the parking area for the building located at 1551 Gulf Blvd. were presented to the Board. These are identical to requests for variances at the 1'01 address, Finally, a request for variance for construction 'of poolside toilet facilities to be located between 1501 and 1551 was presented to the' Board. State Health regulations require bath facilities within 75 feet of pool area and to'comply.with regulations entails construction three feet below 100--year flood level.. There were no problems or questions from the board members regarding this 3 ft. variance request. MOTION: By Mr. Walker. With regard to, request for variance from the 'Flood Insurance regulation for a structure located between 1501 and 1551 and at 1551 Gulf Blvd., items A, B and C, I move for a decision by the board as follows: that the board find it to be within its authority to act upon the request.,and hereby grants the variances as requested. Motion duly seconded and carried unanimously. Case No. 3. The third item on the agenda was a request' for variance to permit remodeling and construction of additions to an'existing residence at 1154 Mandalay Point. Mr. Nelson J. Simmons presented the case for the owner, Mr. Jack Eckerd. The existing structure setbark. is within flood plain. The outside of the first floor of the present structure will remain basically the same. The interior of first floor will be remodeled and present garage made-into living quarters. A three car garage will be added on to the, first floor existing -building. The roof of the present first floor structure will be removed and an entire .second floor rebuilt with open porches, etc. After considerable dis- cussion Mr. Batstone called for motion. Notion made by Mr. Logan. MOTION: With regard to the request for a variance from the Building,Code and Flood Insurance Regulation for a structure located at 1154 Mandalay Point, I move for a decision by the Board as follows: the oar `1nJs it to be withinin its authority to act upon the request, and hereby grants 'the requested variance,,i.e. $ feet below 12 ft. flood plain, linc and to change the existing, garage into living quarters with the existing floor elevation. I Motion seconded by Mr. Walker and'carried unanimously. Case No. 4 - Anthony Cicotti,,2833 Meadowhil.l Drive, Landmark Woods. 'Case presented by Mr. Richard Griffith of Griffith Roofing Company., A var•l.ance from Section 107 requested to permit installation of roof coverings on a roof slop of 6/12 without the use of nails. Mr. Griffith stated exper- ience has proven that it is not practical to use nails on this 6/12 pitch roof as roof will not hold up after being subjected to wind-driven rains whieh,cause water to enter beneath tales resulting in rust and softening of sub-roof. Roofing Association is aware of problems presented with this type of Installation and currently code is being rewritten but in meantime, variance is required to install roof of this pitch in the more practical manner, without use of nails. MOTION: By Mr. Walker. With regard to the request for a variance from the Building Code for a structure located at 2833 Meadowhi.ll Drive, Land- mark Woods, I move for a decision by the Board as follows: Granted as re- quested. The Board finds it to be within its authority to act upon the request, and hereby grants the-variance as requested. Motion seconded by Mr. Logan and carried unanimously. EXHIBIT 6 - PAGE 2 F _ _ .._ _ .^a .. ..._?... .. .-. ....?.i'??tiMY?i??k?•t.'y i ., ?_? ?`???r?Yk!!?c[+?Yr. rr. ??'?':r??kya?.b1+`?I..i?i,';Lr?1', a° '• , ..? ? ., ? ? 7 '! ? ;?. ....p r ? .. ' IM" MINUTES IAA 'BUILDING & FLOOD DATE r r r r. .,,.. , -. .t `vI . . .. 1,. ti r? T, ,;-II,u,-?g?rrr.el,...,r ;r' r,• .j' ;r` •r si...:'r. .a..'a','s. ',z Vrt,-', :. : .r` •Jl,?N .a . ` 5 1S' '.}. 11 j ''??.i? ' `? :;h.{,.! s,_,t ,. I }l. ! • , r. 'i f • ? ';-,', `3: x.41 ;; ,i. r' .. * r r %'!''i.'`it .y ,? xI 1. . ,. 'r- r' 1 i :t;y:.. .,r.I._. = rT t' . '. ;'. , J• .' t., .. J 1 .1': ,1'.'..S I .....Ry ',y , . - I I 1 ' Z,a C.:? ,;,? I,.-. - 2? ? , .? ? ? I , . - , . , . , ? . . I I ? . .. - I? . I . . . :, .: I , . . , - I " ? - ?. I ,?, ..I : ,?? , . I - . Jr • . , 1 , 1 I A g -•Ie, d °, j,`" 1.'y, -'?` lF,r•' •i r . .I s Mii 1}S??y{,: ;.yL;".4,r Ira' ?'t,' .?f ff° !- , 11' , 1. `, I ,,• fi . `f,-P'1L ' 1. '{'J• ', ,,e ..I'i rl.. .'i`_' .o- .t, ?''.i, ,i, j[[`'r fry7. , ='. i ;t'I"e':5 ,''? •r,? + .Ir.. f r , 1 r •-1' r' .' ° r I•R, A• .I,P 'l ti , J. +(w '•ir ''S' r'';i 1, I Si?1'i ,' ,1. 1.C '.,TeoS S,•,?,• 'i c. 4 .'r' ' t ' 11x x, it . I.. j i? •t ill., ?t 1r. ..' - ;'?, ° ', ..',.r.? ,. :i r . i. ,I, ,, .IT :•4,r. ;,,r 'f. ,yr,SkFl.`,.'-•rr'3`4i1, .r.{I fir. + 1 . - .J E .. 1 , s,. ,. .i 5". ?i¢l.: }'1'd :'?,y '!.1~ :. 14,, Qx , •I. i, .", - .. 1 '. - y. ••1 '?d' f :5'•' •i 9;.r `, i?• +. 4(f? ,?:4: n;i' ,?k, j"' .. Y, }F t.. } .1 :y.,' ir.,`; fix: : a. t .i,; l:. rit ` J . ,i t ! e-i ? :1; . I . ..j.. , . .. r . .: r ,'Sr. , r:i..- Ijs .ij/6rIW..;q?acJ3!: }. "y" f ; 1' 1 1 !; •ti'a>. 3r;i. ?iv J7}.... :?y4I .; s{ ,'{'1'" 11!<.,+1•C', ,"'„!'1.`.?','.'ti(•'if r, -? i. ',?e 't, ,,1} 'J 6• ` ?"I ?i?yy 1'. v:,tr1r-,J, f,sl ?,l,. ;s"t' ..i E7?.,°, " _ !, i ';`r, :'' d'r *4 :a rt ;t c. fti? s'• F.' S;.I' z: ,. 7,y j`3 °:., f1 1 i f°al ti :i' r!: sl,,r 3_'•. ,. .i<:, 1?Y rA.:.t .'r. •r1. f' i' , ,. ,i' - jr , +.L zti'°`"•i ? :1,r`. .?' :l'l.:w''+"':•1 °F;•nsr•'?'Srt ?• '1's , r', .?. i . J{EA ti s .. ., : e,h i,{5`I. •'S°?F. v. r, . I ' ,1f.E ', •i'7 + {I rt.' :I?,b!%-ot, r£cl.Ji,?:?•?yi?•'..i, t %i^ ,.r,:_ . , '?.. ,. , .. c?. .. e¢: '.,?..? .-? ? 4, ..`- e?ts .,, ; tlli?',jf:?",'1!1'., t " •" i:fn.','"(rr i; .:'?a? i'f `, pl. u„t:F',. fj(i '; 9: r: •,I . 11 ?,r..,. i'r:e 'r' I 'yi: I', ?^ '-.z`•?I,•.t .. . .! ! 1 'l.TI5-: i,-;." q)1w.r °. /.; .r, Pt .d Sf-,`C ' ,'° - , `''i '.'i ."?" I`', "'I", ?,I >'<.T.,.f,": . y .r. . f .. i1. • 'I 3 i ??3.t.' :r k,t17` :i5, .f1 c`ric:?•"' rE.:.•,f t'.,'.t 7iIl,'.' !,h +iy„ Li -T;•• '?. 1. `.{:'':'•-.%L'. Y:•rt. r,S,tlS•ir•t ?y ,.I:r .,, ,?: .1 '1` t; i.L:: r.t?' .1 -. ,y} '.I ri• „ ? r`t. '' _1, ,i: `'a.... }' I .. .. ,) y- •..:;i;;f,I?x, if'a :,l J1. l,r =,s 3 S `Fd T .yy •x p''S5,?R, ; .),. • 3? + 1 , - .: i'a % 4.., .f, ,,3:rr. 1`:f'%+ e_° 'R. y., rt'S'' ,Sir. r•f,ir ` (j'f 1, i{'r.'?',, S' .. k ?....,:t !. i 4 . Jr lol, •+S :?+iY, ;Xi `r?(.f. .r ',`1`r .' :I: ',. ! ;gyp,.:: .'; r.,;:; .L, ;3- d' , qr,'.. ",;4 rt ." -i h,?s• .r,. fr 'i. ..,y ,,'t ;.,- 'fS?..YF„I-',; r1 ',' ,i )r, 7S, :f,J°rl,r?, '.• y r$• t Vii, .ri r'e. ;i ) ,....,... ,1: ,,1'. :'4,,,-'t':>'f t' r.-pirY,.i. ?,,,.i",J, 1' :'7.. !S ;" , ?'?fp,'v?r - r'?f< ,?4.. ,4 ..r., - .2 ;'},i.;jJ,r.,•:.?; . . .L; stx' rvlrl" '`i.:i'sr.:r-r ; •J'' {l .. I:' .",i.y .( , 1. .-r,` ,S: '1! -% "'.ice :t? t`,. 11,' i"'''°'4'''.1.?`t'.i' i I 'r: ,?•a.. _"F. e `i. s 'F. .ri' I '' ui+.t1ka::aYJ;. it ..:`7, . 1, Pt;S-.:fy, ,.'fill' ':irns'.; 1... 'i:JC_ f . i_r , c f •hrt:; .i ,L', ???;, i:.v - ,, :.. I_..t.' 1 •ir?6ry, 1 I>c' :,Ir ?,4 ?1` '' ?•' '?'1'? l •?' .i. "r r'?... -i •s" 4• I .w.?... .f•': •+!, '""`A•,f.>P',fjy.P,r F"'[i'Ki;,Y?ia: '.+,:,:!., rGd,',!. ? .Si -1* e ry? . • '_ •u.! a'?,y. ''! : j•,:: 1 r'Y "3i 2 i ,•(•.`t}o,u;, ?.• jl._. t'•fr .. y.1ti.i:,> ,°{'y: _WC;r.'.il. yJf: ^=?iL: ??.,?, ,a -?. '?{1'.` ,fS' 'I. ,R)n..'F'<c.' i?,''' .i i f5'`?:P1. , ' ' -+,, J, ?. .S`t y. r {,e Y??i1 ?.'.'..•;y.}, k +i?r1 1f t. 1.1 ! •.'C•r` y,;t g+ 's :i ? '. i ? r-?i' " •i,,. • 7 , ?? I . . App?'w ??) le'. ?' ' 1,?,r+ ' 5i ! L }f •r.rl J• °Y , ?' ' `,?. • r ?I. ,r , I brit l t;r?'r.J...x?:,; ° `h ° ; ,.,, ; .c .t B[IILDINGfFLODD C t ) L. ~'`^!Q.:s . M-?,3i:. .i.. :..•i s,:y,,..,, ?.c•}.s",s?IT.:;;ir,ra. ;lr'.er: 'C... ?'. }.... _r. UN rROL`*r :;'??8?.•-;?; :,i. -.F; •'3 .3hf. I , .. , I e ri .!'r:;' .r•f :Pr:, k. IV..k,.,,-,• ?•r ,_ - . . .. „ <. . . . ° , , I. .: - I .1W .'L=. S:,S I.I. ?,II-,;. i 'r.' '-' .?l.1 . r . . I . : . , . , . . . . . , I ' .. + 1, `f . 'r 4 l' `• t ••11 I. .. , f .!•'... f' .. js,.1. ?`rl.r-11 ?, ?5. , , f .I! it'r y,. : I'', 'r -. .. . ': ?ll`_" ?4 1::•`:`;1 ..: i . '+?I r ' . .. , , 4 1 , , r- `-,'• •r ?t II ' , Jq,F+'- I '• ' ., ` .I I il?`! yf11.. _ f li ,,' ,l 1 e l f . r: '-> J, ; , ; hv.riit3;, r';; ,:z-- ,? . .. . .i vl . . 1' . , f,: v" ',:, -,?r.v_ 11 .l... rl-,:;^,"' ,,ia'M1iS ::', 7'•.,,a, J', -- kl 'ry:, , , . .. 1 ..1 I .. - W.,.'' '. };.. '.. ?j 5yi ?•-<r: 'fh ' _ :L<-,C. • ! rl . , I `f r .,r .Sv._',?. r /,r , I T. Sr«tt'Ii I r' 4 J `f I , r , -, _ „.l, ei.,, ,11• ,' S 1411 ; _ i If' e1 {`rd . II ,?Cit 4:^(, t , .. .. ,.1 '', .j :r ,.i`I r :A. ?'%. ''4 t:: .r' ,f'"`Y. '•'1 •. i} AI ,..T - . .. 'I, 1.. J, .. J+ r fr•..t"'S`=!I VF•"v.4?? I 1' " •,. {' a .1r ,,v...,ar , . . f ` I i .": II , , ? 'J 'I. . `4, - x • y t •' .F :C, . ?.a:'? + 1( I ,f ! .. r}, -';r 1 ' '. 1 . L , " .. . , ' ' _.' :k .f f. 1f . .•'f ` _.._I 1-',, f'..1y,3•., r, I Y'. I ,.('r I. , i..' R.' r .fL•, ,iii t t;, r I `} , --}1"I l ' I ' ,f-, .1 j' •i9 - ' .I ,f,t. •3 , '' , _ t . 1• I I f 1._ 1. i 6 I I I .) I . , I it - •! 'i r :•: I. I , . . .. ,;%I r (gl'r.1 • 1 ., ' .r : 1' I, l: I •: 'rl. .'i .'£,.. £', 1. ;•.,: 'l I •. ,1 ,,,'r' ..i',- .I t y ), I'•J• I - .. j , .. . , ' !'.? .. , , ' r ' I f " 1 1 1.! k .,I' It ..' '.i.• SS I.1 ., I. I,.=2 i iI a ... I' - - I• 'l ?;S' • t 1.'•T`; I ,. •l. . ,Y . `?'' i. • ` • , , - . i 'il' 'Y. e. 1's-` 3, i"ll 11'I4 .r s ..L. f . -I. f' .r'. . :I'•J.'. a'+. ',I1. s,i _.Ifj,?'}•w,.. .+??. r I . . .. }I `II3• L•.. •,I": 'l"i" 'E`IF? 1-,! r ''. ..? `;: ' "}! ? I ;, ., r .. t 1, `. v 4;..-I 'Il-,.a °:". ts•" ' 's.. . is ,. ;r.,-.},•,.. ,17 :.i..:: .r-t3i:-a`,;. c,xu:>I:..qi:'? f'' '•; .,t,;.: t,.,r,J s• .17rrra'1a?.. .,.?-.a'S• , . "::-'< if,`.r. ?, r'' ''S. 2 ' , I :b"+re;l„w}a; /.i,i; 'r.`w ....•s3e"'^••'?' .. .W- '',• .ri'•}~ L..•, ' i c tk'v, p..' r ?Sh'? >'A17?i? J 4 : o . , , '' 4 . T r . s' :1. 1 E • I :--,, ? F' b i P. : .r; e S i ?ii .' A: Y :'? r. t+ 'r.,. ,I, ,. :!'• 11. . f? °.. ,! .'t.,, .f,''.L•. L ealr,..rw`sr.r.?er.??r -- --- -- L..........k.....,.r...,r..?.,.i.,..._r...Y.___.1.i.. _..-- --?_.. .. .__.. - I. •! ,a;.-,. . 4•-y L. s, `-? ' _ d, -. 41'f l ' .. 1 I r 1 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT & APPEALS ON BUILDING (FLOOD C ONTROL) '. WEDNESDAY, MARCH 11, 1981 MEMBER PRESENT: .John Batstone, Chairman Forest Dean John Logan Edward Walker ' Roy'J. Ayres, Secretary EXCUSED MEMBER: Joseph Straub OFFICIAL The meeting was called to order by Chairman John Batstone at. 2:20 P. M; Wednesday, March,4, 1981. Prior to the first case listed on the agenda, Mr. Ayres polled the Board relative to a'proposed store to be known as "Kid's Point of View" adjacent to Maas Brothers.Department Store in Countryside Mall. The code requires two 3--hour walls between the two stores. Inan almost identical case heard.by the Board on October '10, 1979, approval was granted to install metal studs with two layers of gypsum sheetrock adjacent to the existing 3-hour' wall to serve as a 4-hour wall in lieu of the two 3-hour walls. The Board stated that it was uncertain as to whether Board approval was required-for ' the substitution, and that the Building Official was granted their approval to issue permits for similar configurations in the future, provided he polled the Board members to determine if any member felt that the Board should take formal action on the particular case. The four members bf the Board individually ,concurred that it would not be necessary'for the Board to hear the present .case, and they would agree in the use of metal studs and two layers of sheetrock as being necessary and sufficient. The first case presented to the Board was request for variance to use regular bronze.plate'glass in lieu of wireglass as required by Sec.'703.1, SBCC.on property known as Executive Place, located at 2505 Enterprise. Road, Mr. Forrest E. Watson 'represented the owners - Thomas Eddy and William Hackenberger. Mr. Watson presented views as .to aesthetic advantage of regular bronze plate,glass and furnished information-regarding location of this building in relation to surround- ing properties. Mr. Batstone questioned possibility of future build- ing in parking areas; that possibility determined to'be remote. . Motion was made by Mr. Dean to approve the request for a waiver of wired 5 Board of Adjustment & Appeals on Building (Flood .Control) Meeting of Wednesday,-March 4, 1981 Page 2 glass requirements, with the condition that,,should any situation arise that would change the distances to the other buildings, the owner will be required to install wired glass. Motion seconded by Mr. Logan; and motion, as made, passed unanimously. Znasmuch,as Mr. Forrest Watson also represented, and is the architect for the construction at Pier Pavillion (Case VI on agenda) this case was next presented to the Board. Mr. William Alexander is lessee of Pier Pavillion - a City owned property - and requested a variance to build an addition/replacement to existing pool facility at six feet below 100-Year-flood level, where a portion of the structure will be in seaward portion of Zone 2. Mr. 0. Stephen Thacker, attorney for Mr. Alexander, and Mr: Andrew M. Nicholson, City of Clearwater 'Oceanographic Engineer, assisted Mr. Watson-in.presentation of this case. The building will house restroom facilities, storage area, and a pump room with its respective equipment. The design of the building was thoroughly discussed. Openings in building have been designed for panel installation in event of hurricaine. Roof system, walls, and foundation systems have been specially designed to withstand storm surge. Mr. Logan moved the Board grant the request to Mr. William Alexander to build his addition as de- signed and situated,,six feet below the 100-year flood level. Motion seconded by Mr. Dean. Motion passed unanimously. Case II, Case III and Case IV were presented to`the Board and heard at one time inasmuch as they are of similar nature, and Frank M. Bosworth' represented each of the three property owners. In order to comply with $ state health regulations requiring restrooms to be located with 75 feet of a public pool, owners required variance to construct said facilities below 100-year flood level. Structures in all three cases will be separate, independent buildings, not.attached to main buildings. Mr. Bosworth supplied information as to the amount of variance required in each case. Mr. Walker made motion to approve requests for variances. Motion seconded by Mr. Dean. Motion approved unanimouss1y to allow the variances hereafter described: Brigantine Condominium (Owner, Bayway Properties, Inc.) Unit A, 7214 Bayway Blvd. Variance - 3.67 feet below 100-year flood level. 'Isle of Clearwater Condominium (Owner, Houle Industries, Inc.) Lots 13 and 14, Unit 5A, 200 Dolphin Point Variance -'3.25 feet below 100--year flood, level . Placid Harbor Condominium (Owner, Windwood Development Company, Inc.. Lot 13 and north 23.5 feet of Lot 12 -'Unit 2, Island Estates Variance - 3.67 feet below 100-;rear flood level. s r Board,of Adjustment & Appeals on''Building ,(Flood Control) Meeting of Wednesday, March 4, 1.981 Page 3 Last case presented to board was Case V, The Harborage Condo- minium, 1631 Gulf Blvd. Southeast American Development Corporation is .owner/developer of the property and Mr, Robert J. Fleck, Assistant Vice President, presented case to the board. To comply with state health .regulations requiring rest room facilities within 75 feet'of a public pool, owner requested a 3.5 foot variance., The building housing these. facilities will be a separate and,independent building, unattached to main building itself. A motion was made by Mr. Dean that the appeal be granted in accordance with the application submitted'. Motion' -seconded by Mr. Logan. Motion passed unanimously with no further dis- cussion. Meeting adjourned at 3:45 P. M. John Batst ne,,Chairman 4YJean M. Je en Recording Secretary t , e r t 1. ' . F t .1 , I 1 r F ' wM1l , 1 1 ' }tI it I r y r i - , . r I sir March IS., 1981 Sou,t'hehgt -American, Developmeht Corp. ..'Lincoln' Center, Suite. 110,0 ' 5? 01 W. Kennedy' Boulevarc3 ;'1~ Tampa,, Florida 33609. Attention: Mr 'xoiaert J. Flack.. ,'Assistant Vice Pre--dent Gentlemen:. k; A?meeting of thb?Buildin Board of Adjust-- ment &`,A 'peal,- Flood -Control,'. was, hold at City. Hall - Annex on Wednesday-,. ldarcl? ??., 1981: . Your request f. or' vAriance from -th ' City of Clearwater Flood 'Control Code of Ordinances '.:., has been., granted on' this property as stated F; below: The Harborage.. 1631 Gulf , Blvd'.. Varianoe granted - 3.5 feel:. be' lo,a 100-year Flood r level. Very .truly yours, 1. r R. 'J. Ayres,.' Secretary BoA-rd of Adjustment, & Appeal RJA/j till ?J t.1K.'°'?b$1 .r.'.. .",'1?1 . ... •!r` - __.__...?..r! _?'YfL_.,rrelr..? ???.._,? ??...?_? __ _?-_?.?.. .°1,i ':S'?f.lilM(l .?? _