Loading...
01/15/1985 . . . . '. , . '" . . _". ~ l p;:1;':'''''''; :, ,;- !. ~( ,,' t~~:':: ~:'. .. :~~!"~: .', , '., \~; ~." .. .. ' ilj;-~ : ,~"Y::;'.';'>, ' .'j." . f' J ' . . .\U,;.:',.:, ~.; ~~,' > ' ~f~,> "-; : ,~; - ... ..:: '" , '. !: f':' " ~ :r:{,~,': ';: . ;';; ~.: l,'1 \::..~ I , ,< ~ .~?~ ,', " "t ~ , .~ t. , "':". ... c~ ~ \. , I:' ;~ . . I ~, '. . . .\...> :,' ' ;r,;, . ": ' :;:'~\ :': '" ..~.. 1......:. '.>,' !;J,iL:;::( . ,!it,,~ ' rtr,(jJ" g;:~}....';f:~~ ~>:;~:::,; . ~~/:.<~.:::'''.'' . l~i:"'" , .. ) ~~3}~~~:~;' '::. ., ::' t{!~.>:.> ' ~i,Ti" ~\,> " .... , it~i,~<'.'~;"'.' ~H'.'" ,.,' . ~:'~;':':' X:~?': , , "',~, t1.;~: ~~;'~:~ ~,,;:,)'. 't' . ,!4t" ' . " , . ~~;~':~n:':.~,:~':: : ~''''..., ' ~i,;;{~;); "' ' ,,~ ,-'I '.. . . " , '. .. " ".' 1\ ..,': .' .:. ~':~ 'I ;~. , . , " :, ',:.1.: ',':0 :.<~~ ;:.t ,{~ ~. . .':, ~ ~ . ~. ': ,. ~ " :. ~ ;., " I.'..; ".,' " u ~ ,.h :~ . .~ . '. ~; ./.. It.,. ", . f '. , ,~,; Proceedings of the Civil Service Board Meeting of January 15. 1985 Present: Nugent Walsh. Chuirman Mary Drew Kane. Member Dr. Joseph Carwise. Member Absent: Louis Hosch Member Tom Chenoweth, Member , I .J Visitors: Sergeant Hebert Cary Singletary Mr. & Mrs. Robert Brumback Cecil Henderson Captain Ed Desmarais Chief Sid Klein Tnomas Hej I, Jr. .- Raymond Parke Gary Smith ...... " '.... '......'.............. .......... .... ' ......",.. Mr. Walsh called the meeting to order. Mrs. Kane moved that the Minutes of the meeting of November 20. 1984 be approved. Seconded by Dr. Carwise and motion carried. Mr~~ Wals~ initiated discussion on the Hearing Officer's Recommended Order in the case of City of Clearwater v. Raymond W. Parke. Copies of the Order had been '.previously provided to the members by the Personnel Director. Mr. Walsh noted that ..the:,Notice of Suspension referenced Civil Service:Rule 145 Section 1 "b'~ although . .:thecharge actually listed was that found under '''e'' of the same section. This mistake was apparently continued throughout the hearing process as the Hearing .Off~cer' s Repor't contained the same error in referencing the charge against the employee. Members discussed options of the Board as provided from Chapter 25.05 (d) ,'of' the City Code (read by th~ persomiel Director). Mr. Parke requested that the Board review the entire transcript of the case. ,.Mrs. Kane moved that the Board review the transcript in total. Motion failed' for lack of second. Mrs. Kane moved ,that the Board reject the Hearing Officer's Report. Motion failed for lack of second. . , Dr. Carwise moved that the BoaTd accept the Hearing Officer's Report. Motion failed for lack of second. Mrs. Kane moved that due to the fact that the report is incorrect from Hearing . Officer Mr. Ayers, that the Board review the Findings of Fact from the tape or 'tr'anscr:lpt. " Mr. Walsh asked Dr. Carwise to accept the Chair to allow him to second ehe'motion. Dr. Carwise declined. Mr. Walsh seconded the motion. Dr. Carwise .' asked if the Chair WIlB able to second the motion. Nr. Walsh stated he was going to . .' ~ second the motion so the Board could go~ and if the City feels there is a problem with it. they will appeal it. Motion carried with Mr. Walsh and Mrs. Kane voting .~ '. ~~: . . , ...~ .'~ ,: .. '.~~, .. .. '...,,'.' " ' '" .. ~ , ",' " ':; ',;, \':i;'~':"":':~:: . ..". , ' . . '." .', ".....,:." .,' ,..;:'~ .., "I . "' "'. . " " " , :~l?::::'::;:~i ".,...v,. "';:"", .,' . :""" , , . ,.., . ," ~..,' __: ~ :..<:,.'::;':.:"i:.:>"'(<..:.::':: :,' ;~',;,', :::.;~,: :1/ .:~ ' . .' ~ ~ . .. \ /', : ..., .. ~ ~: . ' ';' :'.';:: :/:' ....\~,:;~';,>):i.:::..:'. '::;;':'1',\ ,.,.,.. ,: . :.... , , . , . ".,., . : .' ' .., ,'. ,. '; '" .",' ~ ;'jC ..~..~...,.' ,.~..~::','. ..' ,; -....>::' . ,,', ..,. '. :: .:" '.: .;-:.' ' " ..., '.,t., .....' " ,., .', ..' Ii!';ft-:. ,.+. !'. :. .'" , ., t . ,. -: '. <" :.,.. '.~' /- ::''';'~f'i~~)';;,' ,I' 'I<,~,i,,:f,.;,:/:',; :~ ,iT" I. ' ., '''' ,: '",. .. ~~.. " ' " " , . . ~ " ~' > .,,:,/;,t T ~ ;,,' .'.'" '.'. ' , . . ~ " ,,':,s "':":",,~:'\I; ,.' ..../,;' :.':, 'i:, II ' ': ,:'.' ':.-. '.:: '.:0.' ~ :' p,,:c/>> jiJ ' . ,..... ;:-- ~ ' . ::'. I. t r: : ': ',,, +. "..'..' . . .:> ,. . :. " .1 :..: ":'1 . '. ,~ ':.',"':". ,<': /'. .~:~::::>', ." :. :' J,' . :.r . " .:. .'., " ,. . .. ,.' , . ' .. ' " . ~.', , ' I ;. '\ ., ~. , .' ~ " I' . ..'.... '., '..... ,,' . iP.' I , :J. '. ': ,;.,.'. '. '. ',:..:'': :""~....,:',::~/':'" . ,.".. .' .::...:,",: ' : <. . .' '. ;,.. ; ), . I . ,~'.:. ~.... q ':' .... .~ ..;.. ...." ,," .. '. j+: d .'. . ','- . 'i' , - -:. .: :.,~ " . - ... ... ...., .', ..~ .' f' ,;. , " (' " I :. , : . -, .'. '/, .1,'" " ~ I . ": ~ :- . " , . .: ,. . tn J :.,. J' ,.' .".( ...,:'::.( '. . :::: ....!} " . ~ . ,..; ." .. ',; ~ ': .".. , ' ..J ..:'_. ll?i~. Y~'::~:~>,': ,.-'1 l\~t'" .1 ,,'. :lr/':' :;.,..' > , i~i;.l..,'" ':' f't... . .t ~~~~' ~:~:\:'.:',': ' ~i;<', ,-,::' n;;," .' ,~:"..:' . {~:,;. '. .' :?'~ .,' 1/ . t;fl: \'. .. . '~~J... ~\ ': . ~f}}':' IJifi; I~',i:,; ~~~t~8', rr:~t~ " ~~#i;i{.i~{::)j , , w.::;,:~.~1,~t':,) :":,: ~1~~~~:,~ ~'HW',~:,,: iltjl!lt'y, ,.::,' ~~'ljJ~i~~:: .; '; ",' ,Wjh'''''', i ' ~~1;u~~:~:<~ ",' " Re'spectfully ,'Ill,.."",." .; l~'f.:\ ," ~'I\i),:,"" . .f;}Jt~~~:;{:'r ..' ~~d1~~~'~!:~';1.'~. t Wlt3~~':;;< ~j-(,;,~-;,:~';i' . ?Jj~,~./}:,~': :,:~? m;p' ,.',,'';,'' I~N P}:D:'~;"':""':" ~. '.': ~~- :~. :mi,-J'tPi:.,'." ' " ~b.tf~'~:'/): : ' .....~~iyll'.t.<....'. 't~;~~m:{j" '. , . > '. '.' 1:'t!~\';i;f~li't..i..'':; ..; i ~'_:.c .. ~. ~ :', >, ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ .: '.. ;~r-. , . '.'," , I ~ '.. .. ". ~ 1 < . ,'. :~ :'J, ", ", ,. ...~f ~. <4 . ~. ~ ..,i, ,', 1 " ,.' ! .' :,""~:I '/ ':', ".~, . :,~',:i~ ;t;::':::~,... ':~,::,/ ,," . I. .~.. ,.<,.; Ii h '~t ,": ~ , ~I" ,.: : ',~ : ..;:'.. . ~. '..,':' ;~/,': :' ..', "~;.. :'L :~'~~_.,: t '~t 'g~ . " , , Civil Service Board Meeting January 15. 1985 in favor nnd Dr. Cal~iBe opposed. Mr. Walsh advised next item was the request of Police Sergeant William Hebert for further appeal of Suspension following denial at the City Manager's level. Cary Singletary, Attorney for Sergeant Hebert, introduced himself. Dr. Carwlse excused himself from the meeting. Mr. Walsh offered Mr. Singletary the opportunity to state the reasons for his appearance, noting that the Board did not now have a quorum. Mr. Walsh advised Mr. Singletary that the Board could not make any decisions and that any comments would be for informational purposes only. Mr. Singletary related that the suspension of Sergeant Hebert was made on the basis of: the Chief' B opinion that Sgt. Hebert made an arrest he should not have,,'made. Sgt. HebertcreBP.ontled to the City Manager's Notice of Suspension with an Explanation . and Response to the Charges on 12-21-84. The City Manager had ten days to review that Explanation and to respond to the employee. It was sixteen days before any response was received by Hebert and that response was not from the City Manager~ but from the Asst~ City Manager. Therefore, Singletary indicated that the charges should be dropped. Mr. Singletary requested that the Board appoint a Hearing Officer for this case . ratherthanus1ng the State appointed Hearing' Officer. . Mr..Walsh related that there was no purpose in continuing to discuss other Agenda . items. He asked if anyone else wished to he heard; there being no one, the meeting was concluded. H. M. Laura Personne1 rector & Secretary to Civil Service Board ., of' , , , " t.., t" .\1., , 'L. ",:"':::,:,~ " i;'. "~/,.;,. '..,'.' : . "'L::~::","'.,:,:; ':':, '. ! ~', ".", ' , ., .' . " I ' , ",',. ' " '. t. ","~':. ~';" : '. ',',' k.', 'r', .', '" .,. . .'. . ,..... '. ' '.' .., .>. , " '.,' ~. . ... ",,'..,. , '. , ','.. ~:,' l. " " ',.,..,'., , . "", >>.., .. '''':'.f ...1"; ..' i .. ',:;.'" , "' .. . , :'",' '.';i""'''' ",' ",,"': .</... .." ,_ . . ".. ,.' ':. ,":;" , ">{':'~<;", :",,',.., ...'::: '.., '.' " ... ,,:', "/,', l. ~".' .' , ::. .. ," '. ..... ~~'. .,' ,. , .. ~. ~...: It :. . , " . " V" " , .,' ~ ':<....ir<:..,.~ <':. '. ,.~~./,",,~:~ ,', ,. . . ~ . , \, ' :;~ ~ 'r: .,. t, ',,: . , .' " , " ;' ~., ; . , ~."'., >' ,> . ~, .. .. ,'r " ,," 1 ". . " :,. ~ ".",. : . ',' ~ I: ~ , . '11' .< , " . ~ 't ~ .. ,. .' 'r. .: . . 't .... .1,. ',f . "'..' ". , '." ". ~" '. :l:"{ J "":". ':.' .: <, . '. "~.. ,.. , :"" I, . ""'?' , '. ".<.-.e ; ~;. ~. '," . . . 0,' 'I . .. I ~' : ' ':- ," ," 'i' " "'... , '. " . ;,";:,', 'a .> ~.' , '..'. r-,' . '. . ... ',.' t.: . ..' .", I, ,,~,:~~, T" ,,': '. . J < :;".~,:, .~';' ,:, ::.. . :' .',;: ~~: ',', ~: .' ,. .' ,.'. , "" , \r< .~ . .'; . ''', t ". ~ ". . ,..)" ^ .' " , '., " '" : '.' " " .. ~ ." .... :',' .. . ,', : , i~' ': ',. ,." '\ ::,<1 ::,"\: , t ~ ~ . I . , . , . . . ,; ~ ~.'~.' . " , , . ". ; ; ','.\<<;: ;':'i~:,:,," ':' ;:,:,: I" : i ".'~ '..., , ' 'I":' :'>j:'~\{" ,'.,:" ~ , ", ~'I , r:' ..1' " . ,~ . . .' , ,. ." . . .. . ",! ~. ':. ' ,~ ,:' ,/ ';. t. , ".... ' 1 "<'. .' . ...~ ~".~ I ' ~ "'. :,'. .,. . , " ; . ..:, . L d"<': ;:" ('; . . :-: ~ J .,' . ,~. , . ,'. '.'/ '. 't ' . .' I .... .'. ~ '. . ,! " ...../." '" . .~ c c,', ',/. , J.