06/11/1973
.. \, ., Y; ~ ~.' . ~, '
.~' :
1- '.
j: :"
~.. .
~ ~ .
f.~': .
f:~"~
t'.. .
:; . ~
r;
',' ~
,>
~;:: '.'. . .
1- 1 ~ .
~ ,. .
~'i..';', .
,(.:. . .
* , :. >. ,.
r'> .';.
~t .1: ". :'
r. >:': ;
C:' ..,
;J.t;';.: :~. '..'
~~: / l ',:
[;?
F:~~'.~':: ~~,: .: ~
~L:,Y,~ ' :
~:rr
~:~~~l':'I:)'~,:'i i i .
ft. ....,...l .
~;t~0i:':
Rh:.8..
~~l;.: .~.~~; .~. '"~ .
f,;.i,Jii' t~~'~:,;- ',~
~~~itii;."
~i1',;\", . ',.
tg?;~11j:r~::~', .
}:f1";-( :;:.;'," ':..j.. -'j'
t~~\;:::":;~.~ ;'J
~~s.~Y,~~01t~
0-'g'\i' \ I\: ;,
U~)}2t~//
~tf(;;:i{::
~":;...,. .,.....!
~;~:t'~J::
;;. ..., "J' . ....
r:~p)'\:...~;.~~, ,!':
f~(l'" ';',:1... j .
;";L,C'. .:t, .;) . ~ ,
~,\'t... ..:~ .'1'~ > ~.
~n~~' ~~::~'i'~'~.! J
t"~,. ". .1""...., \
Iwi.,~f,\.'"
~;:Q":
it:.. ."
i~l::";:' ., ;:::
t~l~~~::~(
~'fj.",,' ~'..o ~ ,;
"f - . ,..,. .
~J;I:':''':;i''i\'
!';'t:~~;~~1/.r';
/
Proceedings of Civil Service Board meeting hold Juno 11, 1973.
The Clearwater Civil Service Board mot in regular session on 110nday evening,
June 11, 1973 in the Civil Service Office, City Hall.
Members present: William A. Ramsey, Cliff Stephens) Arlie A. Schardt and
Glenn Finkenbinder
Visitors: Mary Drew, President of Employees' Association, Shirley Fass,
Paul Kane, George Odiahoo, Bill Bryant, Chief John Pitts,
Judy Adriance, Lucile Allen, Mrs. Kathleen DeBlaker and
George Cody.
Director read letter from Cal Blackstone resigning from the Civil Service Board and
then introduced new Board Member, Glenn Finkenbinder, to other Civil Service Board
Members.
Chairman Ramsey called meeting to order.
Mr. Schardt moved that the minutes of the meeting of May 14, 1973 be approved.
seconded by Mr. Stephens. Motion carried.
Director reported on assembled exmninations conducted.
Director reported on certifications and appointments.
Director reported un Emergency Appointments.
Director reported on Lay-Offs, Suspensions, and Dismissals. No Board action
necessary.
.Mr.. Schardt moved that the resignations of Sandra F. Dow, Clerk-Typist II, Garage
Division, Central Services Department, Raymond J. Murray, Ins~rument Man, Public
Works Department, James W. Hill, Communications Clerk I, Fire Department,
Lynn A~ Bingham, Clerk-Typist I, Library Department, Suzanne C. Gomez, Library
Assistant I, Library Department, Scott A. Murtagh, Bridge Operator, Marine Depart-
ment, Theodore J. Motry, Toll Attendant, Marine Department, Grant H. Scully, Toll
Attendant, Marine Department, Dorothy A. Balas, Clerk-Typist I, Municipal Court
Department, James Seagle, Recreation Supervisor I, Parks & Recreation Department,
James York, Recreation Specialist, Parks & Recreation Department, Gregory Appenfelder,
Recreation Leader, Parks & Recreation Department, Steve Pickern, Recreation Assistant,
Parks & Recreation Department, Vincent A. Ignico, Edwin Edsall, Fred Mancuso,
. Howard Sheets, Charles Laney, Angelo Pappis, Lee Shuster, Marie Rohlfing,
Marykate Brady, Charles Smith and Marvin Washington, Laborers, Parks & Recreation
Department, James W. Evans and Bruce N. Ragan, Police Patrolman, Police Department,
Robert E. Snide~ Jailer, Police Department, Albert L. Copeland, School Patrolman,
Police Department, Tommie L. Carisle, Anthony G. Floyd, Harold R. Stafford, and
Richard Coley, Laborers, Public Service Department, Steven H. Hoehn and ,Clyde Grimes,
Equipment Operators, Public Service Department, John J. Watts, Electrician-Lineman
II, Traffic Engineering Department, Willie Covington, Terry Porter and
Chester L. Smith, Laborers, Public Service Department, Daniel L. ~lagilligan) Laborer,
, (
'. ~, .
., ,
(' ,:".':i ,.';.;
~f~.~c,.' ~
:-.,"( '.
i.' r
.... , .
'c,I':
" ;','
.~~y.
- 2 -
., ~r :
~':~':.~
)=;X'j
Civil Sorvice Board meeting
June 11, 1973
."If:
. ; '. ~
. ~\, I
~ " ,,'
Traffic Engineering Department, Donald Yomnick, Robert Smith and Larry Smith,
Laborors, Gas Divioion, Utilities Department, Mark D. Summerfield, Bobby L. Marshall,
Willie Paaco, David L. Adams, Carl R. McMullen, Jr., Dale Gibson, Edward L. James,
Thomas M. Payne, William U. Zellner, Horace J. 'Usher, Ray B. Nesmith, Damon A. Nehan,
Jr., Dennis L. Higgins and Henry L. Johnson, Sanitation Workers, Sanitation Division,
Utilities Department, Lucille Gingras, Clerk-Typist I, W.F.C. Division, Utilities
Department, Kenneth A. Bostic, W.P.C. Attendant, W.P.C. Division, Willie Drown and
David A. Hall, Laborers, Water Division, Utilities Department be accepted. Seconded
by ~~. Stephens. Motion carried.
. l' ~ .~.
,'"
~.'" .!.:
\'!~
j:.'"I:i
..t~<.
"~I:.
....
<.'
'. ~ ~:'
~:'\,. ;
'-6'
~ ':
~ :', ~.,
~,' :'..
~(r
"~~ "
Mr. Stephens moved that the Board ratify the Director's action in approving transfer
of Susan Straughan, Clerk-Typist I, Purchasing Division to Clerk-Typist I, Library
Department. Seconded by Mr. Schardt and motion carried.
<I,:'..
-.,!::
".,.
~~1
:"~i)
.....
. ~~'~ .
Mr. Schardt moved that the Board ratify the Director's action in approving one
additional position of Clerk-Typist I, Range 29, in the City Manager Department.
Motion seconded by Mr. Stephens and carried.
';', :.
',"
"1:'
',1\:,.
';~'\
'.~~'
~~~,:'5
}'~;'
~E~
'j{i
I hi
<i
Z'
'"
\-..,\
!l~,~
;c
~!,S
.~ ..
".',
:'~:i
i~/'
:?~
Mr. Schardt moved that.the Board ratify Director's action in approving Maternity
Leave of Absence for Patricia Carney, Clerk-Typist I, Library Department starting
June 8, 1973. Seconded by Mr. Stephens and motion carried.
Mr. Stephens moved that the Board approve request from Joseph ~liller, Laborer,
Parks & Recreation Department, for a voluntary demotion to the position of
Recreation Leader. Seconded by Mr. Finkenbinder. Motion carried.
Mr. Stephens moved that the Board approve request from Lutre11 Evans, Meter
Repairman I, Meter Shop, for a voluntary demotion to the position of Distribution
Serviceman I, Water Division, Utilities Department. Seconded by Mr. Finkenbinder.
Motion carried.
Chief Pitts spoke before the Civil Se~vice Board and asked that all Firefighters
and officers in the Fire Department be given parity with the Police Department.
Mr. Cody explained the reasons why his recommendation maintained the present dispa~ity
between the Police and Fire Departments. He stated that out of 57 cities in the
State of Florida, 48 cities had no parity and 9 cities had parity. Mr. Schardt moved
that the Fire Department be placed on parity with the Police Department. ' Motion
seconded by Mr. Stephens for discussion purposes. After a lengthy discussion,
.Director recommended that the motion be'withdrawn. Mr. Stephens asked Chief Pitts
if he had any objections to this matter being tabled for the next meeting and Chief
Pitts had no objections. Mr. Stephens withdrew his second to Mr. Schardt's motion
and Mr. Schardt reluctantly withdrew his motion. The matter was tabled fo~ the July
Civil Service Board meeting.
.:.
.jl....
~/tt
"
',i.;
~~'~0
:~~ .
Director recommended that the Board accept Cody's report in principle and Mr. Stephens
moved that the Board adopt, in principle~ the classification and pay plan as submitted
to the City of Clearwater by George F. cody & Associates subject to the recommendations
of the Personnel Director and Appointing Authority and adequate funding by the City
of Clearwater for the 1973-74 Budget. Seconded by Mr. Finkenbinder and motion carried
unanimously.
. '~:"}.~~;~~~I'~~
.!k!'F'~\'" :
~%lY<"::'U"i'~
....H.t .t~~}\f ~.,:
')~'\.{.J:~jo.~r '\.
;.\;.~F ~'</~'~';. :,'i
/;~ ~;/~ .~1 \ : t
,~,""+~:'~cl',r/... .
~I!ij t;; '': . '. I,:
~ i ~ '\, T', . .' ~
N I. ''''> I .'
'~::.'~'~\' .~.' ~
f~"'-a" '::
'(].::.:"'4....,. .'.
k ....
l'~'. ~ i. .." C
I:.... '.,. '.
~i' . ., ....
~f',{ ),:~' .<
1>\';"'" .
f'f~~:.:'~.~::.::: Lt":.:
fr.:>'.,."".. .
fl' ....., L~ ~'
l~i~jt ::~.~: :::'-t.':': :,' \
":<.:>> ?",~
'" of. ~,
f~:~:!1t:X: :'~i~
r.t.! j,",,;;,. .
IN ~'~.\,-o' .~<I~ I '. 'j
~h)':"'IJ!"::":
~'F:I.:\ <'i: ': ".
~$t,(. ,'..... .j' " I
~ ~~.\~~t.~: ,: !. r ,"!
!,',''''J'' ""..'
~~?f:i?\i;. :;'~
~''''1~'' ..' ,
~i~~~i:;~..~.:j,~
~",. J ,'.Ii'" ,
.......{l:. .:/'~ t'" ~
~. y' ",,", .
~\i}i:/;:~/X:;
~,..... cr~j., 1
~;l~~P~~:? ~
~.,., ....t...
l~i:'O' "'::"
I':;;, . .~:! "
"'~l\. ,I.. .
" {':t ;. ..:..:;Jll..~,
f"~H~I~';. I',.. e~;-' \
f~~j1~}~t}tJ. .
~~I\""',,,,,,,,,,, .
~",l~",.::~\"" }
~if~~{l
(~~if';;'~.~* ~t~i~
i~(t;lj'1U~+',~\
....: (~"J~' I",: >'\.
~ ~ri:(~~:1i':~~:)~
J.~~;~\~~::i ,) ,
~~i'.f':'l~'!" :'i'
~O~,~;;. .lr.., .:1
f(,;~~l~>/:~.!;.c'~~~ ~
%f.'" ,', ';" '..'
~:l~t!~~~ -.;> :>~. ~~
fy/ \. "n.: ....
l).::?~:l~~,~t.:l '.> I
,,~...r>)., .;,,' ,;,
rf::~~'~:.:;~.,.',,~
:8'i;~:i~:.;,~:U :.
~n~;~lliL.:! .'
~fjj?JtM:r :::
~'~Bi',,).f"\ ,
i:t{:.>~7~~ ~*~:i~>
lir.~,,,,' '''''''~
"., .."..'I '"
~"W,hf<';t:i;'
;ltl~'.\''''''' .'F
'~:{.'i'.':;.~'l';'
!.~,\J:~:~.iI\":' ;
~'t}.i~I'''.~'~-;{I;'
1';;~J1;.~ ~:J;,:.~;~~\~ .
"j'i~.". I' "'1
~: cll':"'" '-. '';'i .
~"."'i.
.&, /~
;O.lit Ji :~ I~ .
~~V:;~Wt
.' ~~f;'~;:.. .
~" r", .,' f
l..... r.i:\C~jj\~' >.' .
~ ~.:~~'}.{~:r~\'
~~:'\::;!I'l~\~t I~;I' .
~'\:';l~' '(~"l' .
, .~ ~~~~./(:i~';~ .
~<\1'~.4J",,~ . .
il t'i ~ i"~~;'~~i~ . ..
I'lo. .r~!~:,.'., .t.r.:::>,.::..'.
- 3 -
. \
Civi1 Service Board meeting
June 11, 1973
l-lr. Stephens moved that the Board adopt "The Pay Plan - City of Clearwater - Fiscal
Year 1972-73" with an effective date of June 11, 1973 which provides for a five
per cent (two pay range) salary adjustment for all classified service employees
retroactive to April 7, 1973 provided, however, that the two range adjustment
granted by 'the Pay Plan - City of Clearwater - Fiscal Year 1972-73 (effective
date June' 11, 1973) be considered as a portion of the cody & Associates
recommendations at such time as it 1s implemented. Seconded by Mr. Schardt and
motion carried.
Mr . Stephens moved, Mr'.
Doug Wagner, Asoistants
to April 7th.
Schardt seconded and motion carried that Jeff Harper and
to Personnel Director be given a 5% increase retroactive
"
Mary Drew said she would like to bring to the Board1s attention that Kathy Carrell
. had been hired as an Emergency Clerk-Typist I after she had failed the examination.
Mary Drew told Board Members that the Civil Service Act had been placed under Home
. Rule effective 10-1-73 as a result of action in the State Legislature.
Mr. Stephens moved that Mike Laursen, Personnel Director be given a 5% increase
retroactive to' April 7th. Seconded by Mr. Schardt and motion carried.'
Mr. Stephens said he would like to express his personal appreciation to Mr. Ramsey
. for his sincere int~rest, commended. him for the job he has done as Chairman and
. regrets very much that Mr.' Ramsey finds it necessary to leave the Board. The Board
and' Director concurred with the comments.
Mr. Schardt moved the meeting be adjourned.
Seconded by Mr. Stephens.
Respectfully
Approved:
Personnel
~./1{
& Secretary
'1
-, .