CONSULTING ARBORIST SERVICES
TO
N N
E E
Y Y
E E
R R
T T
0 0
0 0
l S
A 0
T ADOPT 0
E A N
TREE
ROBERT A. KYLE
TREE SERVICE & LANDSCAPING
PHONE 885-5517
4810 BRAY ROAD
TAMPA, FLOR I DA 33834
FOR
MR GARY JOHNSON
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
PROJECT COORDINATOR
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA
PROPERTY OF
ALLAN STOWELL
RE: CONSULTING ARBORIST SERVICES
CITY OF CLEARWATER
BY
ROBERT A KYLE
ARBORIST CONSULT ANT
ARBORICULTURAL CONSULTANT IN THE CARE AND REMOVAL OF TREES
{/C'-:} / /. )
TO
N N
E E
Y Y
E E
R R
T T
0 0
0 0
l 5
A- 0
T ADOPT 0
E A N
TREE
ROBERT A. KYLE
TREE SERVICE & LANDSCAPING
PHONE 885-5517
4810 BRAY ROAD
TAMPA, FLORIDA 33834
Mr. Gary Johnson
City Of Clearwater
Public Works Department
Project Coordinator
10 South Missouri Avenue
Clearwater, FL 34616
RE: Stowell Property, East Advanced Pollution Control South Interceptor Line
Tree Preservation Specifications,
Dear Gary:
Thank you for the opportunity of preparing the "Futuristic Planning And Construction
Techniques for the Preservation of Trees and Wildlife", the Stowell Property.
Enclosed please find a signed copy of the specification for the Stowell Property. Also included
is a signed and sealed copy from challenger Enterprises, Inc, for the Revetment Materials Study
prepared for the erosion protection of the Live Oak Tree (Quercus Virginiana).
This report is based on your letter of April 27, 1994 for the protection of the Stowell Property,
It does not relate to the trees on the Thornton Road located in the access corridor.
I hope these specifications meet with your approval. Should you have any questions, I will
meet with you at your request.
May The Forest Be With You
Robert A Kyle
Arborist Consultant
Incl.
CC: Allan Stowell
Claude Howell
Allan Mayberry
ARBORICULTURAL CONSULTANT IN THE CARE AND REMOVAL OF TREES
TO
N N
E E
Y Y
E E
R R
T T
0 0
0 0
l S
A 0
T ADOPT 0
E A N
TREE
ROBERT A. KYLE
TREE SERVICE & LANDSCAPING
PHONE 885-5517
4810 BRAY ROAD
TAMPA. FLORIDA 33834
August 6, 1994
City of Clearwater
Environmental Management
RE: SPECIFICATIONS FOR TREE PRESERVATION: ALLAN STOWELL PROPERTY
EAST ADVANCED POLLUTION CONTROL PLANT SOUTH
INTERCEPTOR LINE FUTURISTIC PLANNING AND
CONSTRUCTION TECHNIQUES FOR THE PRESERVATION
OF TREES AND WILDLIFE
DESCRIPTION OF WORK
1) INFRARED PHOTOGRAPHS
A set of infrared photograph will be taken of the property
before construction. A second set of infrared photographs
will be taken six (6) months after completion of work on the
pipeline. These photos will enable us to evaluate the
progress of the trees. The camera will be outfitted with
Wratten filter #12
2) ROADS AND ENTRY WAY'
The entry road from the wetlands on to the Stowell property
will be in areas as staked and surveyed by the City of
Clearwater. All equipment will be operated and parked in
specified areas as delineated on the plans and as approved by
the Owner, Arborist and city of Clearwater. These areas have
been located to be of least impact to the environment and
wetlands and uplands, including trees and vegetation. No
encroachment will be allowed out of the specified and
delineated road and wOEk areas unless approval is granted by
the Arborist, owner~ City of ~l~r~p~~7'
~. ~ ~.......~. '"Ie..( ~el8{q1
Where woody roots are involved, either in the road way,
excavation site, or where excess soils are to be stored, the
Arborist will be notified and consulted before they are cut,
removed or covered up. SEe PA&E '7 NoTE K~' ACJ..G.q'f
te~~.,q~
The City of Clearwater has, on file, a vide~ film that
shows the boundaries as defined by stakes and marking
tape for all roads and working areas.
1
ARBORICULTURAL CONSULTANT IN THE CARE AND REMOVAL OF TREES
I
I
3) TREE TRIMMING
NO trees will be trimmed to gain entry or to dig trenches
unless the Arborist grants permission. When and if permission
is granted to trim any tree, the Arborist will be present at
the location while the trimming is in progress.
4) ROOT PRUNING
All root pruning will be completed before the renovation of
the pipe line is started.
The pit areas were root pruned and lined with plywood in July,
1992. These areas will be evaluated as to their
effectiveness.
If additional root pruning is required, the Arborist will
grant permission and be on location before and durinq the
root pruning process.
The root pruning will be accomplished by using a root pruning
machine, stump machine or excavated by hand to a depth of 18
inches. This will eliminate the ripping and tearing of any
large woody root systems extending back toward the tree trunk.
5) TRENCH WORK AREAS2
The trenches to be dug to gain entry to the existing pipe line
and to dig and change the man holes will be root pruned by
hand, root pruning machine, or stump machine. This will be
determined by the Arborist before the trench is dug by the
backhoe.
The length and width of the trench will be kept as small as
possible and still allow working room. The parameter of these
pits have been predetermined and marked on the site plans, as
well as in the areas with plywood.
Soils to be removed from the site and stored will be placed in
an area away from all plant material that may be effected by
the salt-water content.
All trucks to be loaded with excavated soils will be loaded on
the beach side of the existing pipeline and travel along the
high tide mark until they have reached the road built and
designated for ingress and egress.
2
NOTE: No building materials, excavated soils or fill dirt
will be stored under the canopy of the trees. All build-
ing materials, excavated soils and fill dirt will be
stored on the beach side of the pipeline. This area
appears to have a high water table; therefore, any major
grade changes under trees would place them in great
danger.
2
I
I
TRENCH WORK AREAS continued
When excavated soils are loaded, spillage should be kept at a bare minimum if the
loaded material can fall in the protected land areas. Spillage of soils in protected
areas will be removed at the end of each day.
If excavated soils are to be stored on the beach, the storage pile should be as
close to the high tide mark and beach as possible or in specified areas that have
been secured to prevent soils from entering into the Bay waters and areas outside
designated use areas.
The foregoing is governed by the Dredge and Fill Permit specifications.
6) TREE REMOVAL
NO tree removal on the Stowell site will be approved or granted unless approved
in writing by the Arborist, property owner and the City of Clearwater.
7) UTILITY LINES
The installation of utility lines shall be in areas with the least impact on any tree to
be saved. No underground electrical wires, sprinkler lines or other utilities will be
installed under the canopy of any tree to be saved.
8) CONSTRUCTION ENTRANCE & COMPONENT STORAGE
The roadway for construction equipment storage and building components shall
be in open areas away from all trees to be saved.
Mortar boxes and/or mortar mixers shall be set up 50 feet or more from the drip
line of the trees to be saved and out of any area proposed for roadway or parking
areas.
Cement trucks are to be washed out in one area 50 feet or more from the drip line
of any trees to be saved. A safe area for washing out cement trucks and to set
up mortar mixers is in the retention pond areas. When the ponds are dug, the
concrete, mortar, and excess builders sand can be hauled away. If the soils from
these areas are to be used on site, they shall not be used under or around any
trees to be saved because of the lime content and other contaminates that may
be present.
.3
I
I
9) CONSTRUCTION DEBRIS
Roll off containers for construction debris shall be set up
away from all trees, driveway areas and parking areas so the
construction areas can be kept relatively clean of all debris.
No construction areas can be kept entirely clean of all
debris; however, no construction debris is to be piled under
the canopy of any tree to be saved. Again, the access road to
these containers for loading debris and pick up for hauling is
to be in areas away from all trees. The containers will be
located on roadways and parking areas.
10) RESTORATION OF ALL DISTURBED AREAS
All disturbed areas will be returned to their original
condition and to wetland specifications as set forth in the
Dredge and Fill Permit #522419663, dated May 5, 1994:
Completeness Response, January 27, 1994, Page #3, Item #5.
Since the wetland and upland vegetation are intermixed, the
same specifications where applicable to upland plant material
shall be enforced for all replaced upland grasses and
vegetation to include all watering, mowing, fertilization and
general upkeep where required.
The water schedule will be predicated on the watering
restrictions set by the City of Clearwater, climatic
conditions, and good horticultural practices for upland
grasses and plant material.
The replaced upland grasses, that will require mowing, will be
maintained by the installer. The grasses will not be mowed
any lower than 3" in height at any time during and until the
grasses and plant areas are accepted by the property owner
and/or as specified in Item #5.
Since the wetland grasses and vegetation has grown together,
it will be the Arborist's decision to determine the species of
grasses and plant material to be restored in the uplands.
The watering source will be from the adjacent home or homes in
the general vicinity of the restored areas, with the
permission of the home owner or as set forth by an Agreement
between the home owner and the City of Clearwater.
11) RIP RAP REVETMENT
The rip rap revetment location is governed by D.E.P. The
specification for installation is governed by a detailed
report from Mr. Andrew M. Nicholson, President of Challenger
Enterprises, Inc. The plans for this revetment will be drawn
and submitted by the City of Clearwater.
4
I
I
RIP RAP REVETMENT continued
The extent of the rip rap revetment will extend from the
eroded area west of the affected Live Oak (Quercus virginana)
tree just west and north of manhole #18 and east to tie in
with Thornton Road regrading for access section E-E.
The height of the revetment will be governed by the grade
levels of the existing bank and tree root levels not to exceed
12 inches above these levels, and/or as specified by the
Thornton Road Tree Protection Revetment Study by Challenger
Enterprises, Inc. and the final drawing to be submitted by the
city of Clearwater, Engineering Department.
12) SILT AND SOIL CONTROL
No fill or silt shall be placed or collected under any tree on
this site.
This control has been addressed and specified in the Dredge
and Fill Permit #522419663, dated May 5, 1994: completeness
Response, January 27, 1994, Page #3, Item #4.
13) BARRICADE FOR CORRIDORS AND WORK AREAS
All areas designated, specified and shown on the survey will
be marked with 2" X 2" X 6' stakes driven 2' into the ground
and on 8' centers and marked with heavy plastic tape which
specifies "caution - No Entrance To This Area" or other
suitable language. These posts and tape areas will be put in
place before construction starts, maintained and kept in place
during the entire life of the project.
If said posts or tape is broken, knocked down, destroyed or
become ineffective for the intended purpose they must be
replaced immediately.
There will be no encroachment into the protected areas at any
time.
14) INGRESS AND EGRESS OF WORKMEN
A specified area will be selected and approved by the Owner
for workmen to enter and leave the work areas. This area will
be of least impact on the natural bluff and/or at the least
slope of the bluff. The preferred location is on the western
most edge of the property in the vicinity of manholes #21 and
#22.
At no time will pedestrian traffic be permitted over any part
of this bluff except in predesignated and approved areas.
5
I
I
INGRESS AND EGRESS OF WORKMEN continued
Should additional areas of ingress and egress be required,
wood (or other approved building material) stairs will be
constructed, put into place and removed with the absolute
least damage to this fragile bluff. During the installation
and removal of these stairs, the Arborist must be on site
until all work is completed to his satisfaction.
15) MATERIALS
Any material and/or machinery that must be used in the work
areas will be brought in over the access corridor road.
Should it become necessary to bring this material in over the
bluff (like the pipelines) by rolling them down~htt-..Slo~, it.~ L 5......;;
. . .. . A 'IS Ttl~ I,; . 1)/"-1:ib.. "'-
WJ.ll requJ.re permJ.ssJ.on from the ArborJ.st an se 0 hJ.s ad.!. "
design plan to protect the bluff at all times before any ~r/).' A..tl.JfI<. 1{
attempt is made to move any material over the bluff. ~~yq{
Heavy equipment, which can not be brought in over the access
corridor road, shall be set on the working site by crane or
other approved lifting device. Prior written approval for
this activity must be obtained from the Arborist.
16) PARKING
A specified area or areas will be agreed upon prior to the
start of construction for all workers and company vehicles as
well as all equipment.
Random parking on the Stowell property will not be permitted.
17) STABILIZING PIT WALLS
Manhole #20 is in close proximity to the woody root system and
base of a group of Live Oak trees. If it becomes necessary to
prevent the soil from eroding under the woody root system and
stump in this sensitive area, it will be necessary to
stabilized with sheet piling (or other approved material).
Manhole #19 may also require a soil retaining wall to prevent
soil erosion. If so, the same precaution outlined for Manhole
#20 shall be used.
If either of these events occur, the Arborist will be on site
for the entire operation of placing erosion barriers and back
filling the eroded areas.
These erosion controls if installed shall be inspected and
maintained on a daily basis for the entire time that the pit
is open.
6
I
I
18) WELL POINT DEWATERING
No water shall be pumped, in any manner, under any tree in the uplands on this
property.
19) THORNTON ROAD ACCESS
During the construction phase of the Thornton Road Access Corridor, close
monitoring of the excavated areas and the reshaping of the west bank, the woody
root systems of trees located on the Stowell property may come into conflict with
the grading work. Should this become apparent all grading work will cease and
the Arborist will be called to the site to evaluate the root system and prepare a
plan to preserve or remove the affected roots before work may commence.
The above does not include the Thornton Road trees located on the City of
Clearwater property. Governing conditions for these trees will be set by Mr. Allan
Mayberry, Certified Arborist for the City of Clearwater.
20) INSPECTIONS BY ARBORIST
Daily inspections shall be required by the Arborist during any preparatory work
involving the Stowell property and/or any trees.
Inspection time and reports will be documented by the Arborist on a weekly
basis.
NOTE: L1ouveras, Baur & Stevens Boundary Survey dated August 3, 1992, and with
overlay 1 of Thornton Road access corridor from City Right-of-Way extending
into the lands of the State of Florida and crossing wetland and upland areas
owned by Allan Stowell as plotted by Novo of the City of Clearwater on May 5,
1994. All construction work and related activities are to
be kept within these boundaries.
~~~=
Ro~ert A. Kyle, Arborlst nsultant
Approved B~& ~f/?i'f"
Sto I, rop y Owner
Approved By:
Gar
?