Loading...
04/20/1971 L~'" 'I' . .{~' ~ ~,: ., ~~' : '." '" j',: ""::I"~ :, I. ,'.:',.~.. :".,;' .~".,I 1,'.,1 J ,i' ,"':;':' :' ",~,,:: ','; ,"('\ :'1' ',' ' ,II' :L:' ',I,l:L', "'i"" "",',. ,.' , rt,~ ..::,,,.'~ <. . ....d ~'."'. '" , ,', " l.' , I. \'.'. . . HINUTES TilE PLANNING r. ZONIflG BOARD City of Clearwater, Florida No~th Conference Room April 20, 1971 - 3:45 PM Chairman Kruse, Vice-Chairman Mylander, Butler, Reade, Spier, Harries, Davenport, Morrie; Paul Rettie, En- gineering Dept.; Paul A. Bergmann, Planning Director, and Jack ~lol1e, Chief Planner Absent: Mr. Schutzendorf Also present: John Lankford (St. Petersburg Times) . ::'~ OHembers present: I.' "':, ' , ' . ~ ;, , ,. ,: , :...., ,'. \. I: I, ~., . ,t. " ',i,' " '..: ' ~:.' . , . . ,"", , .. ;.r _ ::,:,:":" .... .... -, "'I .' , .' I:r t't', Public hearing was held at 1:30 PH prior to the regular ~~etine re appli- .catIon for annexation and zoning for the followinR: 1. Govt. Lot 2, Sec. 16-29-16, less N 800 ft., less W 483 ft. of S 100 ft. of N 900 ft., and less that part now within City limits, including abutting streets (~. J. & E. S. McMullen) Request: R-3B, Multi-family 2. Lot 6, Block 19, 3rd Addn. to Highland Pines Sub., together' with abutting streets (Hayman) Request: R-lD, Single Family 3. Lot 10, Block D and Lot 1, Block F, Oak Lake Estates Sub., . ~oBether with abutting streets (Shanaberger and Neal) Request: R-lB, Single Family . 4. Lots 10 and 11, Canterbury Heights Sub., together with abut- ting streets (O'Neil) 'Request: R-lC, Single Family .5. Lot 3, Block. B" Oak Acres Addn., together with abutting stree1:s (Fay and Murphy) Request: R-IC, Single Family 6. .Begin 33 ft. Sand 1213.3Q ft. E of NW corner of SW 1/4 of SW 1/4, Sec. 19-29-16 fo~ P.O.B., thence S 966.51 ft., W 1172.62 ft., N 200 ft., E 450' ;:t., N 613.27 ft., E 150 ft., N 150 ft., E 580 ft. to P.O.B. (Southern States Lan9 Co., Inc.) Request: R-3B, Multi-family 7. Lots 19, 20, 21, Block A, and Lots 16 to 21 incl., Block B, Sunset Point Estates Sub. (Huntley) Request: at Business 'Tape of hearing is on file in Planning Dept. 1 Minutes of April 6, 1971, were approved as ~lritten on motion by Hr. My- lander, seconded by Mr. Butler. ChaiI"'man Kruse read a letter from ?{nyor Hougen, dated Apri I 7, 1971" and addressed to Mr. Kruse, approving the reappoint~ent to the Board for t~essrs. ,;,. .' Butler" Reade and Schutzendorf. t~ention t-laG also made' that Rev. P. E. ~~;<aavenpor~, was appointed to fill Hr. Gallot-lay I s unexpired term. .,'. . Chairman Kruse and the Board tolelcomed Rev. Dav.enport, who \.1as attending his first meeting. ... .. 'Y- ::' "j . LlF....1\':.. 1~,:,J",fl.4, :.l". .~.," '.: ','d'~: "",\':":::..>:',,:,,' ~ ,'::,'~"~' ,:'.I"l'..,.if:':~', "~""'.I:':":JJ~;'I;" ,'.,' :"/":'4 , ,; ," .. ... Minutes of the Plnnning & Zoninr, BQa~d - April 20, 1971 Pagn /I 2 . Motion was made by Mr. Reade, Gecondcd by Mr. Mylandcr, to recommend ap- ;. proval of (1) above. Motion cnrried un,:J.nimously. Zonin~ is in accard- '" f'rnce with Comprehonsiv~ Plan residential density. Motion was made by Mr. Reade, seconded by Mr. Mylandcr, to recommend ap- proval of (2) above. Motion carried unanimously. Zoning in in accord- ance with building and lot regUlations, and standards reflected in the immediate developed area. Motion WdS made by Mr. Readp., seconded by Mr. Mylander, to recommend ap- proval of (3) above. Motion carried unanimously. Zoning is in accord- ance with building and lot regulations, and standards reflected in the immediate developed area. Motion was made by Mr. Reade, seconded by Mr. Mylander, to recommend ap- proval of (4) above. Motion carried unanimously. Zoning is in accord- ance l~ith building and lot regulations, and standards reflected in the immediate developed area. Motion was made by Mr. Mylander, seconded by Mr. Reade, to recommend ap- proval of (5) above. Motion carried unanimously. Zoning is in accord- ance with lot and building standards reflected in the immediate area of ~esidential development. ", I.':'" -::"1 >-':.:: '.: Motion Has made by Mr. Butler, seconded by Hr. Mylander, to recommend :::" , :: approval of (6) above, subj ect to limiting density to 16.2 un! ts per ,',.. '. acre. Notion carried unanimously. Zoning is generally Hi.thi.n the spirit '-;;.. . .' and intent of the Comprehensive Plan lo1hich provides for adequate set- ;::",:' backs, height and density control" drives, parking and buffering to the ;; abutting residential developments. .p " c , ;-:":';' Moti,on vlas made by Mr. My1andert seconded by Rev. Davenport, to recom- i'.m~n~ denial of (7) above. Considerable discussion ens~ed re County f,::.. zoning and established land use pattern. Motion carried. Mr. Spier voted against motion. Zoning request is contrary to the Proposed Land ~:. Use Plan and would have an adverse effect on the Comprehensive Plan. ;,:: '. Public Hearing - Annexation & ZoninR - To be Received: 1. Lot 4, Block It Bay View City Sub. (Bray) Request: R-ID, Single Family 2.., Part of Lot 8, riosell Acres, described as follows: Begin NE corner of Lot 8, thence run'Southeasterly 279.94 ft., Southwesterly 200 f~., Northwesterly 109.94 ft., Northeaste~ly 100 ft., Northwesterly 170 ft., Northeasterly 100 ft. to P.D.B. (Congregation Beth-Shalom) Request: ISP, Institutional Semi-public ',' I. 'it '. , . . 3. North 240 ft. of W 250 ft. of SW 1/4 of SW 1/4, less roads, Sec. 19-29-16. (Humble Oil) Request: B, Business ::::Of"'~ . ~ ,.." ::'.. : \. .' , lJ. . ( A ) NH 1/4 0 f N W 1/4) Sec. 17- 2 9 -16, 1 e s s ro a rl s , less S 200 ft. and less the following property: Begin 100 ft. Land 30 ft. S of NW corner of ::." c,.. '.' " ." , . , ~\ . .' 'MLnutas of the Planning & Zoning Doard - April 20, 1971 Page n 3 .\(, .~ ,"" . ,. . (B) Sec. 17-29-16 t run 1: 700 ft., S lIDO ft., SVl 427.99 ft., W 400 ft., N 700 ft. to P.O.B. (Sackheim, et all Request: R-3C, Multi-family Be&in 100 ft. E and 30 ft. S of NW uorner of Sec. 17-29-16, run E 700 ft., S lIDO ft., SW 427.99 ft.t.W 400 ft., N 700 ft. to P.U.B. (Sackheim, et all Request: PKE, Parkway Busineos; ~ :~~ " 5. NE 1/~ of SE 1/11 of SH 1/11, Sec. 9-29-16. (City) Request: P, Public .~: ~ '{, Mr. Bergmann reviewed plan for SherHood Garden Apartments on Saturn Avenue (Baumann). Motion was made by l1r. Butler, seconded by Mr. Mylanqer, to recommend approval of plan. Motion carried unanimously. Discussion ensued re Bayshore PUD-R, ~1ith comment on administrative change and adjustment of apartment sites due to topographic limitations. Discussion and re-affirmation followed re subdivision plat review for College Hill Estates. Chai~man Kruse advised the Board that he wou~d fo~ward Hr. Galloway's name plate to Mayo~ Hougen, who would be asked to give it to Mr. Gal- low~y in recognition of his years of service. " :. , . ,". . 'l.':' " ?": . '. ~'/< " . ,'., . :.: ' &'.R~port of City Commission action of meeting of April 19,1971 follows: ~(:. ~ :'T . I c...., . /:'<.. . 1. . Annexation g Zoning: ..~ .. I .~. ~!~ '.. . . . }{;.., . a. E side of Old Coachman, 600 ft. S of Sunset Point Road (Flaquad, Inc.) Approved R-1C Lot ~t Block 19, 3rd Addn. to Highland Pines Sub. (Velong) Approved R-ID L,ot 20, Block F, Sunny Park Groves Sub. (Hylton) Approved R-ID A: {:.:\: . .!~~ . .iy':..... i-.. . ,'. '. ~ ~.~ . c .. . " . -t.: ',' b. c. ~:': " , . ,; ~ ~ ". ;2. Zoning Amendment Contd.: a. Lots 1 to 10 incl., Block D and 'Lots 1 to 10 incl., Block E, Edcnville Sub. (Zechiel - HLM) Denial without p~ejudice - R-4D amended to R-3A & R-3B .' " ,.' "..' , l(~' .:.: .~!~~ .. '. I ..:. i, 3. Bleakley Tract - City Manager's letter re contractual commit~ ,.: " ment exp1.ained higher density under PUD-R, original R-4C zoning and moral commitment to guarantee sam~. ~:.., .AA. Mr. Bergmann commented briefly on the TBRPe quarterly meeting which \-1as .....'. .... . 'held Ap1'lil 16, in Tampa. ..' I ~. ~ ) T .........". ~~:.". .Mr.' Bergmann advised that the City Commission vlork Session of April 7 t:' 'genet'lally approved the "B".Zone Front Setbacks to be set up for City ;~" ,'" Commission Public Hearing on May 3; and that Haterfront Side Setbacks ::: :: ,~~I~; r 't II : 'J ,..... ".. 1. . ~'- ,,' <,.". .,' .", ...~r4~...... . ' '1"'/" . ", '" ,. " I '.. ". '. ,.. H' . .,.t., d .' ,. 10',,,,, ". I. ..'., "'J I . 1 \ I . . ~ . :1 . . :....1 . ., I /1 " I ~ I' I '. l ~ 'n '/ ~. ',e 1 . ~ I f;1","" .'>".' ~ ',r.. ~ : ,.,-1- . .; ~ < .,' ,'.j:." /..)-",:"::,\ I, .' ; ~ . . , '11" . , ~ ': " : : ,; 11 :,.. ',". ';..\ ,iU \";",,/.:i,' , . ;..... ,'. c:'.... ", "'1 / :,", ". . .... 1"<',: .~\ ~ ~ .t.' .' ,'!,,' '. , .. \ . J .' /J...... .~ ~ i.' ~ '.... I,'.'. ' ~S;:;::::,MinuteB of the Planning I) Zoning Board ~j,.(.../.i Page if 4 i;:',. \ . . ~t,~)';:be vrapl1red for City Commission Public Hearing "lith the addition of, e~a:~:.'bo~us prcvinions. !V~ J .' ' . , +;,..~ ' .' ~~',:;: "MX'..' Bergma.nn advised ..\ ~~. . r;1.'.':":, Work PX"ogram and the ::.. able. April 20. 1971 that copies of the drafts of both the Five Year Fiv.e Year Capital Improvement Program \>7ere avail- " , .:, .i'~ l', \. , ',' There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 5:15 PM. " Respectfullysubmitted~' ~;{)'i.":':~,:C:' ""A"~' , 1','."i-"..., '" 'l.. n '. ' . . if~l;f',:" .' ,~ · ~t+;'.~".:. aul:, ~, ~e.::gm ) Secretary W.;.,j;, PlannJ.ng DJ.rector . . !("t,~:'" '.', .', ~; .: . .' " . \'. l~;[<~,':i' ...'. ~""",. '0' . ;t"'J ...... I" . .~i"~ I..H... ;1' , ' "i:~"t!)V~.:.I" . .' "l.J.~'!.I' I ,'," , m'\4:.";,:+;;:'::" : . .:: "t,t),. ,',' ,. e,. ~~~f;:.;:'.':. '.' : >:,:':-' :: ik"r.,"n ." . ~~t~~~~... ~:~; : ::. :', '. ~if!1;j::II" :\. . ,', .",' · r'''4~,?t~~'::~L''>:~ I.:.', ':._~., ! ,;(is.\1 ", . ,." , ~tr/\,i':{,;},~" " '. . ~ . I" ,. {f;~,)':'::.."'~:.:,:."':' ..' ....." , . t~~:~.l;:,: ,;" .'". .... . . " .' ... :: ~~'~~I'<:l." " ~ . ~J[\~;^{/'..., ......,..'~.:" ..... J(~ ", ".'" ,. , ~f~;~~~~?':': .li;;':~' , "':..,' " ~';<.""""'c Ie' ,,' ~!~"~:i~'. :::?'." ...., ...... . ~.,... ..' " :~{~;{~:':,.' :.... 0:\" . ~. '." :~~{:'.. ; ':' '. .Q'F)}.. ' " '. . -, ." ~)t~:.f\\'/;'\<' ..,' ..r,fJ4T; ~". 'I ,'. ,~~. I c', : i;~;~:) .";'. ': :f""Qr: " '. 1"~1 t r' '-<{t. '. I.', ~ .:.", .' "'fl,', .'" .~~,\!;f~,;,(~ : ..... ~ :.- ..... ~($l;tl." , ~ c '.. ..' . ff; ~;;/:: ; ; '. i (, . , .,' , :\ ~F.ld;...(j' '." ','.. " ~ti~' ~ ," ~..'." . " '. . ' . I". . c iV';'."" ',:", '. . ,: ." .' , '. ?t~I~.~~::;':,,>,:':; ,:'./;r~<: ':-.: ,~. '.'':', :',', ..':' ,:....' " ~\... " 'n".j "." ,>" '. 0 , , t~~~~{t~~~';~~";';~:'::~;Y!i~~,~Ji~~';I~ <~" .~:.;:/;: :/~ ~ :.: ': '. :c', '",: ; :.0: ::, ~c, , '. .- , ,'{i 1, ,. -'. " ": ,':':',)~ Ii '. . . :.' :>'~ +:. :{. '\. . <."/t;: ... :.::.:}\ " , .'. " "~' .~{~. 'd, .J.... .,". .' , " , ," " ,~c. ; .; \, ..:. '. ; ,~;,:,;:~:'~ '~>;'::t. .' "; }~;,: . . . '" '. ::.:;~if: " "..,\.-!/ " ,.~,;:. 'j" '.';. ".' ',~( . t: '., .,' . . ." .' , ~ II ". . ' ,.'1': .... ;l.tl. , , ..... f ;'.. . '1. ., ~ . .~~, , , "", '1) . ; ~ , ',\\ " ,'. , . ':;'-: - . 'j " ~.\. " . ',' .' .. , , I,. \. '. F,. . , .:~ ::,1 '. ., ,.,:'t .'.,J " . .r ~ .; , 1 . .,', :," Approval of Minutes of April 6, 1971. "'r} '. ,...... A,.. Public Hearing.. P & Z Dd., April 20) 1971, 1:30 PM t~l.\ : > : ;:~~~,:<;....." I I i0fL'.:..", :.. fM:;;::,.'" :.. . . .' 7. ;~~~~T~>>"~" ,,,:.<, ~{,),,~:-, ., ~:i~1~~~ .' r~~ ~. ~ij}:',.' " (SEE ATrACRED NOTICE OF PUIlLIC HEARING) , ~~:>'.'. .... B- Annexation Items to be Receivcd - P & Z Dd.: .'1',' ., ~~;>:'I:"':'::':-' .' '.' 'l~.i:.". :. . : '<:\] ....,. .'(' ., :}::,:.:i',;i,{'::;::,' ~,,:,;::~1;:i<,"f?(;t~''ti:.::,:f;:::i\~1:~~i,::ii\'~fjl}::,\;';',j@:,;:'t"';:";'/:i:;':',':;.,:i':: '., ': :".'f,,!:' " ~::.,;", /:,;,:',:' ""',, ;:,,::;,::. ,', ";', " .,' ',;., ' ,,'. ", .;' .; l ,j" ", '" "". ';1, ", ,,, v, ," '"." · ." " ., ',:,', " ,', ,," l" i':':'';':/:;{i,''.', ", , ;, ,.",::::,: ":," ",., ,;' :",,~,;:.,'i"":'~;:i1::,j.;.:;..,,"i!:t,;'\I,,:,~,::::;{i ;''::}\;~::':~';::'::;'::/~:''':''''':':'':':':':'::;'':'JJj:::',' ',,;,,', ::, .," ',',' ',: "';I::il:'~,\'~:; ".'.'..',',..., !,','.," . . ....l " f..../...'.~.:.;l.... . '. .r{', "::' '::1 ':' ,.I:.:~.i:':~';";I':,',~.,.:~.;:::;..,."",',"'.;~r':',',' '.c, ,I,... ..J...."..;:I .~. \,. '. :,>':'~'.:.:~\. ',~1't ... . ." . <. ., I <:'.:' "i:..:. I '" . I /i>':'.:r:~:tl'" '.:, :\' .,''.: ~,' f,' ,.::.:,:,~;:? '.. :.'~ ;:,'~: ......,"\:~L,\..:>.j,:.~> ~I :\~.:'~',. :''',.1'' ,., "e.,.."".,, ,. :',\. .. . . . 'f;>, ....~'~:..,.),: ,'; :.....:;":...... '.., '-'c" ,,'"~ "'''~.' ~I,' ~';\"::,;"l: . 1 JJf\2\;' ',\1 " , }. .'. ' i'~' :, :J ..~. . L,; I . '" ~ . ' '. . i,. ".: ' .' .: d "' ~~ ' f}:... ',' : ~ : . , ...J., . , .' ;~ . ..,.... ':..;', " '. J<. '.,,' ~:::'. ,', '. ..... . : ;,~: ~ 'I:' . {. ::', l',H .. . ~'~ ;: .. . ~(~ 1 " ... ,. . , . ~.. . .~ .' "';' " .,:<', ~'r: :n :t~ I,' '";'. ! ,t ~ !'~ c, J:r~; '1: "~ :.~' :.. ?}: t'; , '.. ", c'.,. '\ ;;/' :> >~.: '( :,\'. '; b\' ><' ~ ~ I . <~.j i' ~ ,<,I, o. l~> '~~~c; , \,'. <.' ',. I, '~"" " ..t :. ~::'o::': . ':'.'. C fl" . f~;'~:'~,:,~:, . ~'" .;, . . )1}:'>.:.' . w~~~:..:: '. ,., .'OJ' ;'1, :..' .', ~~ , ~ 4 ~. . .~;:}:::: . " , , :J,\~, .... '.i.' .' ' ;~. ;. . /.. ~ AGENDA TilE .rLANNING & ZONING nOAlill April 20, 1971 ~ "- "~ > ~---...... . 1. Govt. Lot 2, Sec. 16~29-16, 1css N 800 ft., less W 483 ft. of S 100 ft. of N 900 ft., and less that part now within City limits, including abutting streets (E. J. & E. S. McMullen) Rcquest: R~3D, Multi~fomi1y 2. Lot.6, Dlock 19, 3.rd Addn. to Highland Pinos Sub., togcther with abutting strcets (Hayman) ,Request: R.ID, Single. Family 3.' Lot 10, Block D and Lot 1, Block F, Oak Lake Estates Sub.) together with abutting streets (Shsnabcrgcr and Ncal) Request: R-1B, Single Family 4. Lots 10 and 11, Canterbury Heights Sub., together with abutting strcets (O'Neil) Request: R-le, Single Family ,.5. Lot 3, Block B, Oak Acres Addn., together'with abutting strcets (Fay & Murphy) Request: R-le, Single Family 6. Begin 33 ft. Sand 1213.34 ft. E of NW corner of SW 1/4 of SW 1/4, Sec. 19-29-16 for P.O.B., thencc S 966.S1'ft., W 1172.62 ft.) N 200 ft., E 450 ft., N 613.27 ft., E 150 ft., N 150 ft., E 580 ft. to P.O.B. (Southern States Land Co.) Request: R-3D, Multi-family . , Lots ~9, 20, 21, Block A, and Lots 16 to 21 incl., Block B, Sunset Point . Estates Sub. (Huntley) Request: B, Busincss ...'1' . 1. .... ,SE comer Belcher & Nursery (Humble Oil & Refining 'Co.) . Request: B . 2. Portion of Lot 8, l-fosel1 Acrcs (Cons. Beth Shalom) Request: . ISP 3. Portion of Sec. 9-29-16 (City) . .Reques t : P 4.' Lot 4, .Block 1, Bayvicw City Sub. (Bray) Request: R-ID J\ 5. Portion of Sec. 17-29~17 (Sackheim, et al) Request: PKB & R-3C - Review Items: , h 1. PUP ~ R 'review: a.' Saturn - plan review b. ' Bayshore - comment on administrativc change 1" III .'" ,\ j.'. "\ "1':, './'~.:,:'-: . 'f: .; I )) . ;::.F fll"y"":: ,^". ,. ) ,'.'''' ", ..... ~f:;!,~:\.~.j'r:/~'~. :.'~:",,~~~ '. ',"~':':.' '. ',J.ftlenda \!'I" .\..."...~ . . "">'1" ,,'.. ',~' f ;;,{~~!t~<.:", '. ~ge :::;,:.:',':; ," ' 2. ..., '.. r:~;~ ::- .' '.-". D ~f thO.Planning & ~ing Board - April 20, 1971 . . .,11 Subdivioion plat review: a. College HUl Estates .. \ \ hi I ~'i discussion and re.offinnotion Choi rtJIO'l '8 I tam!.!. .: ~1.. .'. " 1. Award name plate to Mr. Galloway ;. ,'. ',.' . 2. Introduce new Board member ~" . . ,,' . , . 3. Report on City Commission nction(April 19, 1971): .,' '.<1 " ~i/:. a. Annexation & Zoning: _ ~l, . ;. . :'~~... '. ' I'i~:l .~.. ,_ . ~h.'" ;-,(.'.,",.' . :(~.~ .' '.' . . :~. )" . . c .' i:~;.. .: 'c' . ~:; !'I~~;\'~ .: !rk:~:;.': . ~~~'i,' ~""""L,, \17-!:/~"<', ":". \ Jffti~';-:'.\:::,"".', . ~y~:,{.:.\: ";.. .'. " c. Bleakley. Tract." City Manager's letter re contractual committment ~""0't' ";'. ".. ' . ~':~t";:':' ,':" ':':E '. -" 'Director ~ 8 I terns: 1j~,::: .': ,': ' . . lj." . ' ,,'. . il€;'}~,;H.:. ;': ':, . 1. Comments re TBRPC quarterly meeting - April 16 ~;:;;~::(2. CitY Commission Work Session at 8 AM, April 7, re "n" Zone Front Setbacks .i'.:~-' and, Waterfront Side Setbacks f~\);;','>,:: . :::::.:: :::: :::: ::pr:t::o::::o:::::b::ogram available ~W~~~".:::- ..: 'F, B.oard and Staff Comments ~:~:~.:."::' ';....c.',.. Literature to be distributed ~\)j/:;'::q"... . ~~.:.:.: c~ ' .c.' . ..~ ;~;{;.y;,; ,:.... ;:"5;- ;' . t:,,~- " -;rO, .' .~:~:;... ~Ir.:~~ ~r' -.,.;,;.,J ,t.i,' . , 01;'';'', . 1>-, ;. . . .~f~...' :'. + ': . ., . ~~.~J::" L' . , x~,-;~' ,. . ~j;i", .;~,;,'; ~:;,j";,, 1. E side of Old Coachman, 600' S of Sunset Point Road (Flaquad, Inc.) ApprCilved R-lC 2. Lot 4, Block 19, 3rd Addu. to Highland Pines Sub. (Velong) Approved R-lD .-' 3. Lot 20, Dlock F, Sunny Park Groves Sub. (Hylton) Approved R..lD ., '.1 b. Zoning Amendment Contd.: 1. Lots 1 to 10 incl., Block D and Lots I to 10 incl., Block E, Edenville Sub. (Zechiel HLM) Denial without prejudice': R-4D amended to R-3A & R-3B . ..~ ~ '.'. r -..