Loading...
06/10/1969 .~ t, ,'-.. . ......../ 'l'ur. PLANNIHG Arm 'l.ONING nO^R]) Min~'tefJ of the Neetine. Tuesday t Jllnf~ 10, J 9G9, / ~/ , . The meeting was called to order in the PreAs Conference Room at 2:30 P. M. by the .Chairman, Mr. Kruse. Prcnent were Members Mylandcr, Reade, Spier, Butler, Schut~cndorf and'Ho~ris) Mrs. Alice Bush of the Engineering Department, Mr. Paul Bergmann, Planning Director, ~nd Mr. ~lo11e . The minutes of the meeting of May G, 1969, were approved as sub- mitted in written summation to each member. REZONING REQUESTS - Public Hearing City Com. set for 6/23/69 (continued 'from 6/3/69 -.copies applications prcviousl~ distrihuted) 1. Turner - From R-2 to "B" - \-lest 1/2 of Lots 7 & 8 less road right-of-way, Block 9, Pine Crest Sub (GENERAL LOCATION: N/E cC?.rner Nyrtle Ave. and Eldridge Streot) - The Board revicHed.the application with study of land use and zon- ing of surrounding properties. A first motion for approval of the re- quest was withdrawn after recommendation of the Department was offered for disapproval. Hr. Bergmann made reference to reasons for prior dis- .... approval of change to f'B" zoning (Salvage application) for lots in the north section of this same block, on the south side of Seminole Street. He pointed out that there was a surplus of Businc~s zoning in the area and raised the question of possibly initiation other r~zoninB along Myrtle to correspond to the existing lane use. He further noted, however, that consideration of an area re~oninB should be hcJ.d in abeyance pend- ing submission of a revised communi1:y plan Hhich the City hoped to have compl~ted under' the 701 program VIi thin 9 or 10 months. The Board voted to recommend denial of subject reQuest fo!, chanl?,e to '1 B II ~ , Business, zoninr;. "'-111I Such recommendation was based on the same reasons as expressed for denial of the prior Salvage application (Case Z-3-269). 2. Turner Brandon Am. Lcr;:i.on Post no. 7 - frol:\ ~-lE to R-3 - Lots 1-.5 incl.. and So. 30 ft.. of Lot 6, ~lock E, Suburb Beautiful Sub. (GENERAL LOCATION: NIE cor. of Druid Rd and Phoenix Ave., ex- tending Northerly from Druid Rd. G,bout 330 ft. - The Board reviewed the application ~rith study of land use and ~ .'~. '.,_l. .. P&Z Bd rH.nutco 6/10/69 , PaBe I/? 7.oni ng of SU1"T'ounding propc'"l't:i.co. 'l'he Department's recornmenclation \-filS for denial of the request. After some dincussion, the Board voted t~ flcce,E't the Depnrtmcnt t 5 recommendation and rcco.mmen.d denial o~ subject ~quH_nt for chc1np;e to I3-3 zoninp., based on the reasons that mul t:i.-family zoning was not nceded in the area and that a spot Gtrip of apartments on t:h.e -mi.nor street \-lould change the character of the area and affect single family valua'tions. The meeting was then recessed for conduct of a Publlc Hearing before the Boal"'d, opening at 3:00 P. H., at which the ,applications for zoning and annexations of the following three properties were heard: . . . PH Ite~ #1 Kamensky - Metes f. Bds. parcel the Northeast.Quarter of North\-lest Quarter less road right-of-way in Section 1-29-l5 (located on West side of Hercules 'Ave. between Union Street and Moritclair Road) Re uest R-4 (multi-family) for the West 250 ft., .... and t c balance HH mobJ,le home parr.: PH Item #2 Unity of Clearwater - Metes & Bds. parcel the North Half of West Half of South~est Quarter of Sciutheast Quarter less the West 300 ft., Section 19-29-16 and Lots land 2, South Haven Sub. . (located on the South side of Mursery Road extending approxiJ.lately 500 ft. Hest of South Haven Dr.) Request R_l~ (mul'ti-family) PH Item fI. 3 RiddJ.ebal"'ger - Lot 2 5, Boy Ian Sub. (located on ~.'Jest side of Boylan Ave. about 700 ft. North of Bellevuc Blvd. ~e9uest R-2 (duplex) Record of such hearing was taken on taP9 and is on file in the Planning Office. Present at the hearing t-lere Cha~rman Kruse, NemberG Hylander, Reade, Spier, Butler and Morris, tirs. Alice Bush of the Engincerine De- partment, Mr. Paul Bergmann, Planning Dircctov, and Mr. Wolle. The same I' were present at the meeting reconvened in the City Hall Auditorium at Q:30 P. .M., with the exception of Mr. Morris. ~ pr,Z Ad HinutcG 6/l0/GD Pugc 113 ANNE:<NrrON ^ND 7,ONING - ACTIOn FROll PUBLIC HEARING L . ~ Item II? Unity of Clearwater ~ After review of the application. and an evaluation of the evidence ,. preGented at th~ Board's public hearing, upon motion by Mr. Rende, seconded by'Mr. Butler, ~he Board voted to recommend approval of annexa- tion request for R-q, Multi-family, zoning for acreage tract (proposed . church site); and in lieu of requested R-4 zoning for lots 1 and 2 (parsonage site) to recommend ~n auprop'r~ate R-l, Sin~le Family, 015si- ficatio~ (proper~ies of reference as legally described in Item #2 of Notice of Public Hearing for June 10/69). It was also recommended that .. ,. . /"'-..., /. '-'" above tract and lots be'designated as Fire Distri9t No.2. Such zoning recommendatioI1 Has based on the follmTinr, considerations: . R,_ll zoning is the most .restrictive classification permitting the church use intended and site conforms to minimum acreage requirement. . The attorney, representins the appJicant, had stated. that a cammi tmcnt for church use only' .would be made to ~he City Commission. :' Recornmended zoning for ~he parsonage lots is in conformance to the use intended and' higher restrictive than existing Coun~y zoning. . It was noted that Nursery Road one-half right-of-way'of record on plat. is 33 ft.; one-half right-of-way on .acreage upon annexation should be j. 50 ft.; further that South Haven Drive is standard subdivision 60 ft. right-of-~lay.. " I~em #3 Riddlebarger After review of the application, and an evaluation of the evidence presented at the Board's public hearing, upon motion by Mr. Butler, seconded by Mr. Reade, the Hoard vot~d to rccornm~nd ap~roval of annexa- tion request fot' R:-2 f Duplex, zonin;.r" for lot as lccally described in Item U3.of Notice of Public Hearing for June 10/69, as consistent with , .,-./ prior Board recommendation of approval of DupJex 7.onjne for an adjacent lot on Boylan Ave. Such recommendation considerl';d City DupJex zonine :~ : ';'.. ~ '. 1/'.;'~.:. ~ .')/L -, ',':",~~' ,. ~,:;. I~" ',' ,: .:.. i f.~:: ','" :". ~ t\:'.', ; :~.\ :. :.'~. '~,!:::. ::. ':+ ..' :;. .!: : ~: .:. . :":; ;: i :; \' > . ~ <:.? " ',L.' ~~L >:.:".<..:' :':: \..~; ,I , :. ~ .'. ~ I, : ~ +;;. . ':.:.: ,(,~;. ., ,:.,~L , ~;' ~ ~ " : '.~ '; .,:, \ ,: :.~,\!.:;.' ,..:.",;~;:~. ~..,.;,~: :'~ :~~:~'; ':"<: ",:'\~/ ", ',.1,:'..~.~ :l;~:; ~ \'.:~( . ,: :"~r'~: P&Z Rd Minutes 6/10/6~ PuBe . If II os pe~mitFing the hiChest and bc~t uno of the lot of requcDt. It W^s .~ also recommended that the ahove lot be deoienatod aD Fire Distr'ict Nc.). ?. It was noted that Boylan Ave. is dedicated with adequate 60 ft. right- of-way and that street is unimproved (lot is just beyond the termina- tion of a standard city paved street). Item #1 Kamenskv . After review of the application, and an evaluation of the evidence presented at the Board' s public hear.ing, it was the general opinion of the Board that it did not want a mobile home park in that area (even \o1i th the combination usage proposed). There Has a discussion. .of Ar;end~ 7tem D. 1. 9(under Chairman's Items) concerning the City Commission's de- sire to hold mobile home or trailer park approvals pending ordinance updating. Upon motion by Mr. Nylander, seconded by Mr. ~eade,the Board ..~ "'-""~ ~oted to recommend disapproval of annexation request for R_l~, Multi- Family, and MH, Mobile Home Park, zoning for parcel as legally de- scribed in Item #1 of Notice of Public Hearing for June lO/69. .Such recommendation was based on the following considerations: The requested zoninB. if granted. would lower home values in the abutting single family, subdivision and retard future building .in the subdivision. ~ . .Such zoning vlould have a detrimental effect on the future potcn- .tial residential character of the immediate area. A mobile home park iri this location would set the trend toward mobile horee parks only--and not only may retard the market for single family subdividingt but may totally eliminate it. . DIREC'l'OR f S ITEt1S: 2. Information - rc Department nol:icv on Hotification of Afl'DJicant ~ . _....l . ~ Mr. Bergmann inform~d th~ Board of directive from the City Cor.nnission, received through the City ~1ana&cr, that the: Departm'=!nt establish a poli- \. i -.... cy of notifying applicants of Board recommendations prior to the City Ccrnmission meeting. It vTaS J.E.:i1!'ned that this t/m.~; to be (lone imrned:i.cTtcly .~..~. .: .' : ..' ':' (/ ' :~ .' : '.~ . ..'. .: .", . ~. .: . . ~ ~ ~:, ~; ~ :'.. : . . '.. ,.:.;': .:', ~ :. : : :":r . : ~:. ... .' :;. I.~; .: :. ~ ,: ~. ~ .;': ~l'.': '.~ .. I:.: ' . . . ~, :" ',~ .." d , " .' I ,.., ,), ."~.'.": : \ ~~ :;<....:. ;.". '''<~..'' :."l, .;. ~ ~~ ; ~. :.; ". ..;. ... :., :: : ~ j ~\. ".~.: ;:',. j '. '~', ,. , Ii., ^ , P&Z 3d Minutes 6/J.0/69 P~ec if 5 ~ . , in most bases, and that if a determination wan made by the Department that the application was a controversial ones -such notice was to be . .~ given at the same time as the Commissioners rece.ive the Board's recom- mendation at their work session. CHAIRHAN r S ITE~m: 2. Belated con-ratulations - reannointDcnt iarl~~es, an 1Ior1"J.s to Boar"\J Hay 19 6 nized these reappointments by the City Commission. 3. Community Facilities Ouestionnaire - (di.stributed at 6/3/69 Board meeting) - continuation . By consent this item was deferred until the next Board 'meeting to gi ve members m'ore time for revievt. DIRECTOR'S ITEMS: .--" . \ 1" nee R-11 - lidll meetine . :. .. ...--:" Mr". Bergmann advised that before the next .TucRday he would distri- bute to Boa~d members copies of a revised R-4 ordinance incorporating in.the text the adjustments approved in intent (as presented in memo form to the Board on May 6). He stated that formal Board approval was nee?ed at this June 17 meeting, in order to have Board recommendation fol'"' . the Commission Ylork sessi.on the 'l'huT"sday follot.ling. Expression of Board sympathy was .extended to Mr. WolJe in the recent death of his mother. Mr. Wolle thanked members f~r their thought of hilA and for the wire of condolence he had received. Planning literature was .distributed. The meeting was adjourned at 5:05 P. M. I ...,..., , I: " "..' NO'l' ItJ:: or PUBLIC 1U~^l\XJ.JG . '(' . r-" ~~... :t n! iI. nd h(')l1.i. nn Bel'.l pd of the City of Cl(F,lr'~'H b~ 1', rl(n>id~'\ J \0/.111 hold cJ. pu ..lot.! ll.;t /,' .ng ,]' tlVJ City lJ.:lll ^udil;Ol'll1lll, II? S. Osccol.!l, Ave., Clcil.!"'Hittct'. l'J.orida, ber-inning at 3: 00 P.H. 1l~"''I~ ,T ['::9 "Ifiii;P-~J.I" \June 3.0, l~hl t __ ~ .. .. l~ AND . T~ C~~...Gp.1~mi Gsion of the City of Cle.:ll'\va tel:' wi 11 hold .a public . . nCul',rng at the~7tyHaJ.l Al.lc.litO'I.~itlln, J.12 S. Osceola Ave..t Cleart'latet", F~orid,3. t beBinning at. l't 0 Honda ~ ?.a. 1 r.lli q .' . or the purpose of considcrina the f01 .OWLng items: The request fot' annexation into tha City of C1cart'Ja.tar and the determination and establishment of the zoning and fire district classification for the follo~tinB dencribad real properties in Pinellas, COUlyty, Florida.: .1. The Northeast Quar"tQI" (NE 1/4.) of NOr'thtJes'c Qtlarter (tH.; l/ll) less l'oad I"ight-of"'Nc1.Y in Section 1-29-15. (Kamensky) Pr~~erty is located on \veot side of Hercules Avenue between Uni6n Street and Montclair Road. The owner' of said property has requeated that the City of ClearHater establish the H~~st 250 ft 0 as R-4 (multi- family) zoning and the balance as HH (mobile home park) zO~ling and Fire District No, 2 classifica'~ion 'thereon. .,. ._+ 2 I . North Half eN 1/2) of He 5t Hal f Ov l/ 2) of Sou-thHcst Qual'\tel,'\ (8\'1 l/l~) of Southea 5t Quarter (SE l/l~) less the.. Nest 300 ft.... Section 19-29-16 and Lots 1 and 2, South Haven Sub. (Unity of Clca~water) Property is locclted 'on the South side of Nursery Rd. extending approxima.tely 500 ft. \!lest of South Haven Dl:', The Ovlner' of said property has requested that tl1e City ,of Clearwater establish R -tl (multi-:family) zoning and ril'e District No.2 classification thareon to permit erection of church and church parsonage. 3. Lot 25, Bo~lan Sub. (Riddlebareer) Propcr'ty is located on Hest side of Boylan Ave. a bout .700 ft. North of Bellevue Blvd. Th~ OHner' of said pl"OpCT."ty has requested that thlJ City of Cloarwater establish R-2 (duple:.,:) zonine and riI"'s Distpi.ct No. 2 classification thereon. The ci ty Commissi.on, after considel;ing D.lI the facts, the recommenda. tion of the Plctnning and Zoning Board t and the zoning T'eqllBst of the oHner, 'Hill rcndut:'. a cl~cis:i.on and, _place the pl.'\operty in a zoning c lassifica tion r]eem,~d pl"opcr. .. ',.J ThOSE:! parsons intcrest'3d arc requested to be prt~Sellt fot'" the purpose of being- heard or may file t-l[litten u.pproval or objections ,tlith the Plannj.ng and Zoni ng Boal:'c.\ for tha t Board's puhlic heari.ng ane! \./i th the City Clerk fot' 'the City CommiBs:i.on public hC.:\Y.'inr., at Clnilt,r~'utet' City Hall, 112 So OSCGO)."l Av~., Clo.=;trt-Htcro,. Flopid.1, p'(l.1.or to the. da te of the appropr'ia te publ ic hca ring.