The URL can be used to link to this page

APP2005-00002 APP2005-00002 1242 CLEVELAND ST VERY IMPORTANT PET PLANNER OF RECORD: JVS ATLAS # 287B ZONING: D LAND USE: CBD RECEIVED: 10/17/2005 INCOMPLETE: COMPLETE: MAPS: PHOTOS: STAFF REPORT: DRC: CDB: CLWCoverSheet ;. ~, Clearwater jj~ ~ Planning Department 100 South Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, Flonda 33756 Telephone 727-562-4567 Fax 727-562-4576 AP!eaJ J.[f)5 CASE #: DATE RECEIVED RECEIVED BY (staff initials) ORIG\NAL CI SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED AND NOTARIZED APPLICATION CI SUBMIT 12 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION CI SUBMIT APPLICATION FEE $ APPEAL APPLICATION Level One and Level Two ReViews (Revised 03/29/01) -PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT- APPLICATION/NOTICE OF APPEAL (Code Section 4-502.A & B) An appeal of a level one approval (fleXible standard) may be Initiated by a property owner abutting the property which IS the subject of the approval within seven days of the date the development order IS ISsued The filing of an appllcatlon/ notice of appeal shall stay the effect of the deCISion pending the final deterrmnatlon of the case An appllcatlonl notice of appeal of appeal of any deCISion of the City, as prOVided In Section 4-501, may be initiated by the applicant or any person granted party status Within 14 days of the deCISion Such application shall be filed With the City clerk In a form speCified by the community development coordinator Identifying With speCifiCity the baSIS for the appeal and accompanied by a fee as reqUired by Section 4-202 E The filing of an application! notice of appeal shall stay the effect of the deCISion pending the final determination of the case A. APPELLANT AND AGENT INFORMATION: APPELLANT NAME Jaycee Roth, OWner, " A Very Important Pet" MAILING ADDRESS Please use agent REC8\tED PHONE NUMBER agent FAX NUMBER 1.J\.: I 1 '7 2n~S PLANNING DEPARTMENT C\lV Of ClEAR'_^.lAlfR AGENT NAME Todd Pressman MAILING ADDRESS 28870 U.S. Hwy. 19, N., #300, 'Clearwater, FL 33761 PHONE NUMBER 727-726-8683 (Pressinc@AOL.co~ NUMBER 727-669-8114 B. APPEAL INFORMATION CHECK THE SPECIFIC APPEAL ADDeals to the Commumty Deve/oDment Board ~Orders, requirements, deCISions or determinations made by an administrative offiCial In the administration of the development code, except for enforcement actions lOQ(Admlnlstratlve interpretations of the development code [J Level One (FleXible and MInimum Standard) approval deCISions [J Denials of any permit or license Issued under the prOVISions of thiS Code ADDeals to a heanna officer [J DeCiSions of the community development board regarding level two approvals [J DeCISions of the community development board regarding level one approvals [J OTHER (as allowed by Code) ADDRESS OF SUBJECT APPEAL (If applicable) 1242 Cleveland Street SPECIFIC CASE NUMBER TO BE APPEALED (If applicable) Ci ty' s letter of 9/28/05 (attached) DATE OF DECISION 9/28/05 , . " c. BASIS OF APPEAL: Explain In detail the basIs for the appeal Use additional sheets If necessary The central issue is the use of Animal Boarding in the Ibwntown Gateway District. The lntent of the diStrlCt is to be a "vibrant, stable and diverse neighborhood". The Ciy's Ibwntown Plan calls for encouraglng more residential, new rnultl-fanuly and the repair of the ~cl[Jting r"C3idential. '!'fiis 15 admessed ~11 Pol.l.I.,;Y #2, #5, #6. PoI.l.L:Y #1 L:dlb fUL- attracting and assist exisbng retail and personal servlce to create nelqhborhood ernolovrn ent.. .Developnent patterns of the Plan call fot new comrnerclal that ".. . serve the dally a nd commorai.J.I .J.Ild pcrDoml [JerVlce occoo of the neighborhood". The cornprehernsive use of anlmal care, from grooming to roarding, is an lInportant neiqhbor hood element in any communi ty . There is alot of residential now, the hope is to lmprove and attaC't oottQr r-elindontial, .Jnd thoDe homeD COfRC 'irith d0g:3. '!'fie3e are and will be resldents that need thlS servlce for a hopeful burgeoning corranunity. Comprehensive Plan policles '-. 4. I and '-. 2. 1 also support this redevelopnent and relnvestrnent of the site. There are Jobs associated with this proJect and business: 0 D. SIGNATURE: I, the undersigned, acknowledge that all representations made In this application are true and accurate to the best of my knowled e ........." BARBARA GOPSU !~m'~~Y Pll~~~ NotaIy Public . Stale of Florida ~ . . pdY CommissIon Expires Jun 30, 2009 \~~ '!f..."I Commission' DO 401536 "T,,'ff,r,~.'" Bonded By NatIonal AaIn STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINELLAS ," Swor and subscnbed before~..;ne- this ...(......,.L- day of ~ ' AD 20fLL ~::d/~:::~r ce I)lA.L^- ,who IS p. onally known a: dentlficatlon No ry public, , & Assoc., Inc f!1 Cjl.~on expires to /60 12-009 \ S2IPDSIPlannmg DepartmenMppllcatlOn Formsldevelopment reVlewlAppeal Application doc RECEIVED OCT 1? 2005 PLANNING DEPARTMENT CltV OF CLEARWATER Receipt #: 1200500000000010454 Date: 10/19/2005 10/19/2005 8 08 OOAM Lme Items: Case No Tran Code DescriptIon Appeals Fee - Commercial Revenue Account No Amount PaId APP2005-00002 010-341262 Lme Item Total: 100 00 $100.00 Payments: l~ Method Payer ImtIaIs Check No Confirm No How ReceIved Amount PaId Check PRESSMAN AND ASSOC R_D 3626 In Person Payment Total: 100 00 $100.00 THIS IS NOT A PERMIT. This IS a receipt for an application for a permit This application will be reviewed and you will be notified as to the outcome of the application cRecel pI rpl Page 1 of 1 Co-n ,,\Is- APP2005-00002 1242 CLEVELAND ST Date Received: 10/17/2005 VERY IMPORTANT PET ZONING DISTRICT: D LAND USE: CBD ATLAS PAGE: 287B PLANNER OF RECORD: :TeJ s · CLWCoverSheet Receipt #: 1200500000000010478 Date: 10/19/2005 10/19/2005 1 37 42PM Lme Items: Case No Tran Code Descnption Appeals Fee - CommercIal Revenue Account No Amount PaId APP2005-00002 010-341262 Lme Item Total: 150 00 $150.00 Payments: Method Payer ImtJals Check No Confirm No How ReceIved Amount PaId Check PRESSMAN AND ASSOC R_D 3630 In Person Payment Total: 150 00 $150.00 THIS IS NOT A PERMIT. This IS a receipt for an application for a permit This application will be reviewed and you will be notified as to the outcome of the application cRecel pI rpl Page 1 of 1 ., \ I .J." ) ~ ..... . I , .-.v" ) . Y('P ~~~ ~ I, t '- ~-.....'" .::."~ I . ~ .. r ; t/(") J . . .~;;.- , ) f",,,. ') . n I' '(,'.,~ ~f /1/-_1<' '~'\J])~~. ~Q<J>.'l fJrE?t,~ ~ 0 0 0 <7"'LJt1S'" CITY OF CLEARWATER LONG RANGE PIANNING DEVELOPMENT REvIEW PlANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORJDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVlCES BUILDING, 100 SOUTH MYRnE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORJDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 January 4, 2006 Mr Todd Pressman 28870 US HIghway 19 North, #300 Clearwater, FL 33761 RE Development Order regardmg reconsIderation of case APP2005-00002 at 1242 Cleveland Street Dear Mr. Pressman ThIS letter constitutes a Development Order pursuant to Section 4-206 D 6 ofthe Commumty Development Code On December 20, 2005, the Commumty Development Board (CDB) revIewed your request for reconsIderation regardmg the demed appeal applIcatIOn heard on November 15, 2005, appealIng an arnmmstratIve determmatIon denymg the abIlIty to apply for an Ammal Boardmg FaCIlIty use m the Downtown East Gateway Character DIStrICt as a ComprehenSIve fufill Project, under the appeal prOVlSlons of SectIOn 4-501 of the Commumty Development Code The Commumty Development Board DENIED the reconSIderation request because the appellant dId not show that the declSlon was based upon mIstake, fraud or mIsrepresentation If you have any questIOns, please do not heSItate to call John Schodtler, Planner I, at 727-562-4547 Smcerely, '0 ~~ ~~l~~ Plannmg DIrector S IPlannmg Department\C D BIAPPEALSICleveland I242 - A Very Important Pet appeal (D)IAPP2005-00002 ReconSIderatIOn Development Order doc BRIAN' AUNc..,I, MA\oR FRAI\K HIHH\RD, VICC MAYOR BIl L JON'ON, COLlNCIL'vlr\IHCR ~ HoY! HA.\1lI10N, COUNUL\lf\lHCR CARLCN A PC!CR,CN, COUNUL"'lC\IHCR "EQUAL EMPLOYMEN I AND AFFIRMAJIVE Au JON EMPLOYER" ..._--........"....,.,..,."..,..-",.-,.. - .-.-..............-............ ...-............. ---- ......--~--~-.------... ~_...- ----...........~~---~.....---~_.-........ __L__%--_c-cl ~L~-- -~~~ -""",,-...-.-~...--"""'" .............----_....---.-----~-~.-........,.-~~............-.-.........- .....--.-.. """ -"...,........................, . _~.B-~~ ~~y~~.--~._...--..~n--..-.~--.- ___.z.._~ _w _0 ~-f?- L r)~~lL~_._ ~-_._--~--- --",~--....-.................-"""~ -..---<~...............~...,........-.~-..."..- --~..............,...,''''~..,.,- -~---"""'-=- --~....-.-..-.-.-- ""'........-~" .........-.--~ --""'.....--....."" -"'-......~."..-. _~_______..._w-__~w._ ~J=2_~~__~L~-- - .- , --- C1... b ~...,..t. .s V\. o(l..\ 't- ~ __ .__~__w ...... ..-..""~_...". ~ .~~ _ i_: :..~~ ..........--.........."..".......-0,..""....... ..................,..,._-rO"'T' -.--...,....,., \A...~~ '5t~ ~ cW-...... "........"....,..,....~,.,.......-...~ .......~__.......................__...__... .. r_....... ____... -....." ~ ~,...,..." ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~...~......-'""~.......,......-,....,....,- ... ,.....~.."". -..........-.. ..,- -",..--"- ..~.............-,.,....,.,.,--=-~_................,...- -~-~ _.w.-w-----~.~.~~~~--~~~--- ~ ~ ..,....."...... ... -"""""'- ..-._-~~ ~~ -C~ ~-- ...."..,..... --~.... _______ ~ "...._........ ~~_...",___.- .....~v .......--...............~~-.,.~.......~ _z;~~~...............-,...........-.~-=---.--...".r--~~......-....-.--~.... w "'"=-_ _ ",...~.........- .,-..-~............... ...w.. .,. - ...-.,,,-,..,,,-- ."......,.-,............,...".- - ..,-,............""... -",-~- -,.- -"'" -- ","" .........-.>;'= ..,-............. ."......-- ~ PRESSl\tIt\N & ASS<X:., INC. Governmental and Public Affairs 28870 U S HIGHWAY 19, N, SUITE #300, CLEARWATER, FL 33761 PH 727-726-vote (8683), FX 727-669-8114 OR 727-796-3975 CELL, 727-804-1760, E-MAIL, PRESSINC@AOL COM MEMO TO John Schodtler FROM. Todd Pressman DATE 12/06/05 RE. ReconsIderatIOn / AVery Important Pet, Reason for the Request FIrst, John, please be aware that I am a Govermng Board member of the Southwest Flonda Water Management DIStnCt Our Board has been called to an official and specIal meetmg on the mornmg of December 20th. That meetmg IS expected to last untIl noon or 1 pm. So, I wIll not be able to be at the begmrung ofthe CIty'S CDB meetmg I am requestmg a deferral of thIS non- notIced Item untIl I can be at the CDB meetmg I appreciate your, and the CDB's consIderatIon "Aruma1 boardmg IS not a neIghborhood commercial use supportmg the resIdentIal uses of the area . " ThIS IS the statement that staff used m theIr staff report on thIS case, and then verbally backed up thIS statement as a premIse and cntIca1 pomt m the reVIew of thIS case. Further, It was presented at the heanng, m my opImon, m the realm as a type of "development code" backed defimtIOn Staff used the neIghborhood commercIal term throughout staff reports. ThIs was presented as a mam cntenon for allowable uses m the over lay dIstnct My follow-up research, and m meetmg WIth the staff, has determmed, to my best understandmg, that there IS no defimtIon nor any dIrectIOn m the code as to what a "neIghborhood use supportmg reSIdentIal" IS It was clear m my mmd that thIS begmnmg dIscussIOn had a huge and Important beanng on the Board's perspectIve on the case r Page 1 of2 Schodtler, John From: Clayton, Gina Sent Wednesday, November 23, 2005 9 08 AM To: Schodtler, John Subject. FW Pressman FYI -----Onglnal Message----- From: Delk, Michael Sent: Tuesday, November 22,20053:53 PM To: 'Presslnc@aol.com' Cc: Clayton, Gina Subject: RE: Pressman Todd, I am not sure the board misunderstood I thought you stated your position clearly, and when questioned about your reading of the code definitions, the record reflects we concurred Our position remains that the request IS at odds with the Downtown Plan Whether or not all of the Board would agree, they didn't find that an error sufficient to overturn had been made The CDB meeting date In December IS the 20th Regards, Michael Delk, AICP Planning Director City of Clearwater, FL 727-562-4561 myclearwater com p s Please update your file with my correct emall address so I'll get your correspondence Thanks -----Onglnal Message----- From: Clayton, Gina Sent: Monday, November 21, 2005 9.51 PM To: Delk, Michael Subject: RE: Pressman FYI - I'm not sure you received this and I thought you might want to respond From: [Delk, Michael] [mallto'Presslnc@aol.com] Sent: Mon 11/21/20058:14 PM To: mlke.delk@myclearwater.com; Clayton, Gina Subject: Pressman RE Animal Boarding /Jaycee Roth/Cleveland and LIncoln Request for Reconsideration 11/23/2005 Page 2 of2 I am very concerned In that I believe that the Board was unintentionally misdirected on this Issue There were a wide variety and number of Issues raised dUring the hearing, and one of the most Important, If not the most Important, Juncture was the characterization of "neighborhood commercial supporting residential" I believe that the Board had the direction from staff that "neighborhood commercial supporting residential" was a defined category, or concrete zoning and or land use definition upon which Animal Boarding IS specifically not permitted In my follow-up research In the last few days on thiS Issue, It has become apparent to me that there IS no category nor concept nor definition that describes thiS "support use" and certainly none that specifically calls out permissible uses or, on the other hand, defines prohibited uses That definition, and associated uses, It appears, IS defined and derived completely by the staff Please correct me If I am wrong I am firmly of the opinion that the Board terribly understood thiS concept The very first portion of diSCUSSion from Mr Plisco centered on thiS concept of neighborhood commercial supporting residential He was firmly Informed of the above staff direction, I believe, and the Issue was primarily lost at that pOint The purpose of thiS communication to request a reconsideration of thiS Issue before the Board at their next meeting May I also please ask the date of that hearing Thank you Todd Pressman, PresIdent, Pressman & AssocIates, Inc. 28870 US HIghway 19, N., SUIte #300 Clearwater, FL 33761 Phone 727-726- VOTE (8683) Fax, 727-725-2933 AlternatIve Fax, 727-669-8114 Cellular phone 727-804-1760 11/2312005 Mr Pressman We were able to place the reconsideration of the A Very Important Pet decIsion on the December 20, 2005, Community Development Board (COB) meeting However, we do require before Friday, December 9,2005 (10 00 am) a letter addreSSing why the reconsideration IS warranted so that It can be submitted to the COB for review I apologize for the short notice, but as you know due to the uniqueness of this reconsideration, It reqUIred gOing to the utmost powers to be for what IS required for submittal Sincerely, John Schodtler Planner I :c-:]$; '::-!-7.1g.~~ /(1.1~"\..",.t~ '\fI1t!",", '!~ ,~r:.\ ~~J~~;;,-~ '!:" "" 1 '-~~ \~:'t'(<:"-;\"4F~1 - ~t..~ ~.:..-..",'f I, .,. Ii;' ~"...'\._rr"'~1 ("'t_..~"){1-,,_1"_Jd >.JI_- ~ = ...'<- ~ f~t~:':...1~~ =-~-::. ~.J- ) i,.~J' ..\.::~.: ~ ,,1', ....<-..,'<- 11 -) i.'''''- "" ~ '" ~Vf' .~- '\"}1t, A po '4..{.. ~-'P=-j---.y..v:ft: ~ J ':;.k.. .14t R....:{ 'f ~> ':'0;/' _ ~ t 1 '9c<r(}Y - !;-':-'-_'Ut.~" CITY OF CLEARWATER POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 CITY HALL, 112 SOUTH OSCEOlA AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4010 FAX (727) 562-4021 CI1Y ArroRNEY's OFFICE December 1, 2005 A Very Important Pet c/o Ms Jaycee Roth 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, Fl 33755 BY CERTIFIED MAil, RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Re Heanng Officer Appeal Dear Ms Roth, On November 30, 2005, you attempted to file an appeal to the Hearrng Officer of the Commumty Development Board's decIsion of November 15, 2005 In Case No APP2005-00002, "appeal of an admlmstratlve determinatIon denYing the ability to apply for an Ammal Boarding FacIlity use as a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment Project In the Downtown East Gateway Character Dlstnct, per Section 3-502", upholding the Planmng staff's determination It has been determined that the appeal was untimely Commumty Development Code Section 4-502B provides that an appeal must be filed within 14 days of the deCISion/Board meeting Section 8-101, Rules of Construction, Subsection M, sets forth the method for computing time penods under the Code As the appeal was untimely, the City IS returmng to you herewith the Appeal Application packet, together with a credit card refund receipt and the receipt for the onglnal credit card charge Very truly yours, .. y; - (" - . o{L .j'{ L L Y >6.C~i{.,.,t'-{( ~J.~'C leslle K Dougall-Sides :,j ASSistant City Attorney c Mary K Diana, ASSistant City Clerk Michael l Delk, Planning Director Gina K Grrmes, COB Attorney ~ ~"jJ/~:E> [J) ~\\ "'-::;;':1 t:~ > \1 J i ~,)} }j~.~.r fE 1 ~IJ :~ L ) "1-1, 'L t4..>>\f: '& ~.. -' &1 ~~ [ 1..J ~-'if"../ ~- enclosures r<'-" n 1 2005 }, ~ 1 rt"'" l ",,'0f1l~~ f~ ~!" , r_ h, rf~ " '1.l,,\\II\\,h, nJ ..~,~ ~i\. &, ~ L.' /' , fi't!\ \\ ..... ... ..,.. r.... '--'\1 f ... -,.. {~ ,:~n\' O~ {Jr--~wd\!fU~.\.. FRANK HIBBARD, MAYOR BIll JONSON, VIC[-IY!AYOR HoYr HAMilTON, COUNCILMEMBER * JOHN DORAN, COUNCILMEMBER CARl EN A PETERSEN, COUNCILMEMBER "FnrlAf FMPlnV1l.At::l\lr Al\lTl deCIDUA rnrr Arrlr\lI.! J;unTr\\.rrn" Message Page 1 of2 Schodtler, John From Sent To' Cc Subject Clayton, Gina Thursday, December 01,20051005 AM Watkins, Sherry Schodtler, John, Thompson, Nell, Delk, Michael FW Pressman The reconsideration of the Doggy Retail/Day Care can be heard by the Board at the Dec meeting Please work with John to get this on the agenda Mr Pressman needs to provide us information In wntlng e g why the reconsideration IS warranted so that It can be submitted to the Board We also need to discuss If we should prepare any type of response to Mr Pressman's arguments Thanks -----OnglnaJ Message----- From: Gina Gnmes [mallto.GGnmes@hwhlaw.com] Sent: Thursday, December 01, 2005 9 02 AM To: Clayton, Gina Subject: RE' Pressman I agree with Leslie, It can be filed Gma K Gnmes, Esq HIll, Ward & Henderson, P A 101 East Kennedy Boulevard SUIte 3700 Tampa, FL 33602 Telephone (813) 221-3900 DIrect DIal (813) 227-8421 Fax Number (813) 221-2900 E-maIl ggnmes@hwhlaw com CONFIDENTIALITY STATEMENT ThIS electroniC message transmISSIOn contams mformatIOn from the law firm of HIll, Ward & Henderson, P A and IS confidentIal or pnvIleged The mformatIon IS mtended to be for the use of the mdIvIdual or entIty named above If you are not the mtended reCIpIent, be aware that any dIsclosure, copymg, dIstnbutIOn or use of the contents ofthts mformatIOn IS prohtbIted If you have receIved thIS electrOnic tranSmISSIOn m error, please notIfy us by telephone (813) 221-3900 unmedIately Thank you for your cooperatIOn IRS CIrcular 230 DIsclosure Any federal tax adVIce contamed m thIS communicatIon (mcludmg any enclosures) was not mtended or wntten to be used, and cannot be used by any taxpayer, for the purpose of (1) aVOIdmg penaltIes under the Internal Revenue Code or (ll) promotmg, marketmg, or recommendmg to another party any transactIOn or matter addressed herem If you would lIke us to prepare wntten tax adVIce deSIgned to prOVIde penalty protectIon, please contact US to dISCUSS the reqUIrements for such adVIce --mOnglnal Message----- From: Gina Clayton@myClearwater com [mallto'Gma.C1ayton@myClearwater com] Sent: Wednesday, November 30,2005 1.54 PM To: Leslie Dougall-Sldes@myClearwater com, mlchael delk@MyClearwater com Cc: Gma Gnmes 12/1/2005 Message Page 2 of2 Subject: RE Pressman Gina - do you believe the appeal can be reconsidered? If so - we need to add to the CDB agenda Thanks -----Onglnal Message----- From: Dougall-Sides, Leslie Sent: Wednesday, November 23, 2005 9 25 AM To: Clayton, Gina, Delk, Michael Cc: 'ggnmes@hwhlaw com' Subject: RE. Pressman Importance: High Article VI, Section 3 , of the Board's Rules proVide that reconsideration or reheanng of a "deCISIon of the Board" may be requested by the Planning Staff, applicant or Interested party So yes, he may ask [unless, Gina G , you have a different view] Did the property owner file an appeal With the City Clerk? I have not received any copy of It If so On another note, are we including resumes of planners as an attachment to the Staff Reports In the December packets? -----anginal Message----- From: Clayton, Gina Sent: Wednesday, November 23,20059'11 AM To: Delk, Michael Cc: Dougall-Sides, Leslie Subject: FW' Pressman Can he ask for a reconSideration of an appeal??? -----anginal Message----- From: Presslnc@aol com [mallto Presslnc@aol com] Sent: Tuesday, November 22,20053:56 PM To: Delk, Michael Cc: Clayton, Gina Subject: Re Pressman OK Thanks I would like to appear under a reconSideration Thanks Todd Pressman, PreSIdent, Pressman & ASSOCiates, Inc 28870 US HIghway 19, N , SUite #300 Clearwater, FL 33761 Phone 727-726- VOTE (8683) Fax, 727-725-2933 Alternative Fax, 727-669-8114 Cellular phone 727-804-1760 121112005 142 L_ increment in the Community Redevelopment Area. This estimate will assist the City in planning and budgeting for capital improvements and other expenditures of the Community Redevelopment Agency. RELATIONSIDP OF DOWNTOWN PLAN TO COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE In addition to the Clearwater Comprehensive Plan, the Downtown Plan is the official statement of policy regarding the Downtown and in particular with regard to the use of land and public policies. All development of land, both public and private, undertaken within the Downtown shall be consistent with and further the goals of the Plan. All new or amended development regulations for Downtown shall be consistent with and further the goals of this Plan. The Plan establishes categories of permitted uses' and prohibited uses; based on this Plan, the Community Development Code will enumerate the specific types of permitted and prohibited uses and their related development standards consistent with this Plan. The Plan establishes development potential and height for each character district that will govern all redevelopment activity. The tools identified in this Plan to consider additional development potential (Transfer' of Development Rights and the Public Amenities Incentive Pool) may be used to increase the development potential in excess of that specified in the Character'District upon a determination that the increase is consistent with and furthers the goals of this Plan. The Public Amenities Incentive Pool is the only tool identified to consider building height in excess of that set by the character districts. Other than those two tools specified above, the Plan's statements regarding development potential, allowable and prohibited uses and, maximum heIght shall not be varied except through an amendment to this P Ian. Although the m axrmum height established by the Plan cannot be varied, except as described above, the process to reach maximum permitted heights within the allowable range is governed by the Community Development Code. Any development regulation not specifically addressed in the Plan objectives, policies, character ,districts and design guidelines shall be governed by the Community Development Code. However, should there be any discrepancy between this Plan and the Community Development Code, the goals and policies of this Plan shall govern. PUBLIC AMENITIES INCENTIVE POOL Purpose To overcome the numerous constraints affecting redevelopment, the Downtown Plan establishes the Public Amenities Incentive Pool to provide an opportunity for the private sector to gain additional development potential while assisting the public to achieve its redevelopment goals for Downtown Clearwater. oouUilL7O/co: \\O~:Q ~ ,\1"; '/ ~f'''' ,~ \ "0''-.,~ <;,' ~\'.{~$')"t!i ....1Y/~\ ~ &~ (,-' I ~'-:..t/ '; , ,,~~.' \ I t; rC'y ~ <-," '-I ~~...."/---\Jt\ \. ':. : $ t:)<5"J'.=L._~ -~ ft:l "'[f' ~~ - -- - <; S(C~ ':) ';\f;<-O; _ _ --:: ~ S~__, 'y \,,<.&~~~ - _- ,f.tl'J,,,,,tJ n~t ...~ ,j. ~~~'1 0", ~",;"P"'~~~'o ""......~~?J1~\1,<o~~~ QL7L7JJUDy . \ C IT Y , - I CLEARWATER OF LONG RANGE PlANNING DEVELOPMENT REvIEW PIANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, 100 SOUTH MYRTIE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 November 21, 2005 Mr Todd Pressman 28870 US HIghway 19 North, #300 Clearwater, FL 33761 RE' Development Order regardmg case APP2005-00002 at 1242 Cleveland Street Dear Mr Pressman ThIS letter constItutes a Development Order pursuant to SectIOn 4-206 D 6 of the CommunIty Development Code On November 15, 2005, the CommunIty Development Board (CDB) reVIewed your apphcatIOn appeahng an adnumstrattve detemunatIon denymg the abIhty to apply for an Ammal Boardmg FacIhty use m the Downtown East Gateway Character DIStnCt as a ComprehensIve Infill ProJect, under the appeal prOVISIons of SectIon 4-501 of the CommunIty Development Code, for property located at 1310 Cleveland Street The Commumty Development Board DENIED the appeal apphcatIon because the appellant dId not show comphance wIth all of the followmg cntena 1) The decIsIon appealed from mIsconstrued or mcorrectly mterpreted the provlSlons of the Commumty Development Code, and 2) That the declSlon WIll be m harmony wIth the general mtent and purpose of the Commumty Development Code, and 3) WIll not be detrImental to the pubhc health, safety and general welfare. The decIsIOn of the CommunIty Development Coordmator of the letter Issued September 28, 2005, was confirmed by a maJonty of the members of the CDB Please be aware that an appeal of the CDB declSlon must be InItIated wIthm 14 days of the date of the declSlon by the Board The appeal penod for your case WIll expIre on November 29,2005 If you have any questIOns, please do not heSItate to call John Schodtler, Planner I, at 727-562-4547 Smcerely, ./ ~N PlannIng DIrector S IPlanmng DepartmentlC D BIAPPEALSICleveland 1242 - A Very Important Pet appeal (D)IAPP2005-00002 Development Order doc BRIAN J AUNG~l, MAWR FRANK HIBBARD, VI( C MAYOR BILL]ON'ON, COlINrIL~1r~IHCR * Hoy! HA.~lILI ON, COl'NUI \IC\lHCR CARl CN A PCICR,CN, COUNUL\[C\IBCR "EQUAL EMPLOYMEN 1 AN]) AlTIRMAllvr ACIION E\1PIOYER" '::.Et 1[1 I t lei F'EP[lF'T .1" Nov. 22 2005 07:47AM YOUR LOGO YOUR FAX NO. 7275624865 NO. OTHER FACSIMILE 01 96698114 START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT Nov. 22 07:46AM 00'47 SND 01 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MENU' m34. ~ SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTFIGE l=lSS I STANCE, PlEASE CALL l-000-tH..P-FAX (435-7329). f! ... ~ 1,. <4 .' CITY OF r"'l CLEARWATER LONG RANGE PlANNING DEVELOPMENT REvIEW PLANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUIlDING, 100 SOUTH MYRTIE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 September 28, 2005 Ms Jaycee Roth A Very Important Pet Center 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, FL 33761 Re Allowable Use m the Downtown - East Gateway zomng dlstnct - Zonmg InterpretatIOn Letter Dear Ms Roth. The purpose OfthIS letter IS to respond to your request for an mterpretatIon of the abIlIty to apply for an Ammal Boardmg FaCIlIty use m the Downtown East Gateway Character Dlstnct as a ComprehensIve Infill Project The mterpretatIOn IS as follows In addItIon to the Clearwater ComprehensIve Plan, the Downtown Plan IS the offiCIal statement of polIcy regardmg the Downtown and m partIcular WIth regard to the use of land and publIc polICieS governmg declSlons All development of land, both publIc and pnvate, undertaken wIthm the Downtown shall be conSIstent WIth and further the goals of the Plan The Plan establIshes categones of permItted and prohIbIted uses The Commumty Development Code then enumerates the speCIfic types of permItted and prohIbIted uses and theIr related development standards conSIstent WIth the Plan The East Gateway DIstnct VISIOn for Uses supports the contmued development of the Dlstnct as a low and medIUm denSIty reSIdentIal neIghborhood supported WIth neIghborhood commercIal and profeSSIOnal offices concentrated along the major comdors of Cleveland Street, Gulf to Bay Boulevard, Court Street and MIssoun Avenue AddItIonally the Dlstnct VlSlon for Development Patterns for the area enVISIOns that new commercIal development should prOVIde employment opportumtIes for the DIstnct's reSIdents as well as serve the dally commercIal and personal servIce needs of the neIghborhood Ammal Boardmg IS not neIghborhood commercIal supportmg the reSIdentIal uses of the area, nor IS It profeSSIOnal office Ammal Boardmg IS also not a use speCIfically enumerated m the Downtown Zomng Dlstnct S IPlannmg Depar/men/IC D'BIAPPEALS\Cleveland I242 - VIP Center Appeal (D)\In/el pre/a/IOn letter VIPEr doc BRIAN ) AUN(,~ I, MA lOR FRA"" IIlflflARD, VllL MAl OR BiLl JON,ON, COliN( II \1f\lflCf< ~ !-IOYI &\IIL1 ON, COLI"UL\lf\IBCR elRI CN A Pi: I LR~C", COL'NUL \!C\lBfR "EQUAL E.\IPLO'rMEN I AND AfnRM~ I lYE ACIION E~IPLO)ER" -/ "] , " ~' Should you wIsh to appeal thIS detemlInatIOn you must do so wIthin 14 days of the decIsIon by filing the attached appeal applIcatIOn WIth the reqUIred fee to the CIty Clerk's office Please contact John Schodtler at 727-562-4547 WIth any questIOns SIncerely, ;:.' ;,.r(/'f~'lA'v7' /."///~~// MIchael DeIIC, AI ,/ Planning DIrector S IPlannlllg DeparlmentlC D BlAPPEALS\Cleveland 1242 - VIP Center Appeal (D)\Intel pletatlOn letter VIPET doc .. '" I \ '"', 'lI August II, 2005 To The CIty of Clearwater Planmng Development From A Very Important Pet Center 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, Flonda 33761 Case # FLD2005-06058 Response' interpretatIon of code feOoMdtng the boarding of canines at a VIP Center The staff and the Committee Development coordinators indicated that such boardIng use -cm.llHdl1'1l((llt be apphed for umder tms ~ of SjpJPhcatiOlDl I wounJldl spprecllare a.l wnttcn JresjpOlThse to my request foil' boardIng dogs umder ilie FleXIble DeveRopmem apphcatlon The ~amnes Will be cared for and managed at all times Mr Todd Pressman wIll be representing me. Sincerely, Jaycee Roth A Very Important Pet . ... August 11,2005 To The CIty of Cleanvater Planmng Development From AVery Important Pet Center 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, Flonda 33761 Case # FLD2005-06058 Response' 1 Hours of operation are currently set for A. Open for drop off at front door 6 00 A M B. Close the evening at 9'00 P M May not pIck up dogs after that tIme. C. Dogs must m be InsIde bwldmg by 7'30 P M 2 ,How much area to be used busmess A 300 Sq Ft Retail area B 550 Sq Ft. Grooming Area C 400 Sq Ft BakIng Area D 1000 Sq. Ft. Cageless dog area 3 How is thIs proposal charactenstIc of the adjacent propertIes: A The landscapmg will be in compliance and give a clean and well- mamtaIned appearance, B. The bwlding to the west is only the block side facing the A VIP. C The BuIldmg to the East IS across the street Wlth street nOIse on both the west side and the south SIde It IS a motel that the center would have no Impact It would provide anyone staymg at the motel a place for theIr dogs to stay when they are away from theIr room D The Bwldmg on the south SIde of the street has no affect It IS across Cleveland Street E Area to the north IS a vacant lot that IS apprmomately 100 ft from the 6 ft fence m the back of A VIP center. ThIs has very lIttle Impact on thIs area due to the dIstance from the commercIal area of the center with a commerCIal vacant lot between. I feel tlns has less unpact on the area than a restaurant that is open much later m the evenings NOIse WIth trash bms In the back and cars commg and going. ThIS area is fenced and dogs WIll be in by 7:30. F This center WIll support the needs of the commumty In many ways There are over 58,000 dogs In Clearwater. Just 10 years ago there was only about 38,000 dogs In Clearwater. It IS groWIng and people are becommg more and more attached to theIr ca..tUne compamons Weare short on evacuation centers according to the SPCA TIns wIll glVe the local (i , resIdents a secunty I have been told It is not 10 a flood zone Most of the boardIng facIlitIes In Clearwater are cages and lock up the dog until the owner comes back to pIck them up. I am offenng a much more frIendly and healthy atmosphere. All dogs WIll get basIC trmmng and attentIon This is exactly what the CIty of Clearwater needs for so many reSIdents commg to the area that will be bnngmg even more camnes. I have the talent and the paSSIon to work WIth these dogs My goal IS to have an establishment that the CIty of Clearwater can count on In cases of emergencIes A VIP will pick up the dog and take It to the center so It IS not unatt G nded or left alone 10 tunes of desperation. With the 6' fencesurroundmg the outsIde area should create low impact on the area and enhance It's charm The majonty of the customers WIll be piclang up or droppmg off which again IS much lower impact than a restaurant I want to work With the CIty of Clearwater 10 every way to bnng good thIngs to the area and make us all proud 4 ThIs business will not hinder busmesses In the area. It wIll be a trammg facility for reSIdents and theIr dogs. It WIll be educational center that WIll bnng more balanced fanuly pets I will have employment opportunItIes for the area. The dtstance of the homes WIth another commercIal property between would not create any unpact on any homes 10 the area. It IS mostly a commerctal area. 5 The estunate to develop tlus bwld10g and lot IS about $30,000, not including the mtenor. 6 Gwdehne checklIst ~Clearwater FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100 S. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARW A TER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FA: (727) 562-4865 ~/ /\/1 f?b /VI ; TO: ~U/ IL/ SfpC)- 1081,0 FAX: Phone: FROM:~~ Phone: . DATE: 10 f /9 SUBJECT: Ap~ V{f}~ MESSAGE: NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) f FROM :CltyOfClearwater-Plan Dept . . FAX NO. :727 562 4865 net. 11 2005 09:24AM P1 ORIGINAL CITY OF C tEA R W-A T E R PlANNING DEW\.RTMENT POST O~rlCl! Box r174H, Clr<ARwA'rnll, FI.ORm/\ )3758-4718 MUNICIPAl S~RVlCR~ H(lILDINl~, 100 ~()lJTlI MVIH LE AVl'NIIE, ('I !'ARWA1TR, FLORTnA 33756 TElJ'I'KONJ: (727) 5('7-~S67 FAX (727) ';62-1576 I.oN<.r RANG! [lLANNlNC, DINH 0PMI NT RIM! W September 28, 2005 RECEIVED Ms. Jaycee Roth A Very Important Pet Center 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, FL 33761 oc r 1 7 2005 pLANNING DEPARTMENT C\1V OF CLEARWA1ER Re, Allowable Use 10 the Downtown - East Gateway zoning district - Zoning InterpretatIOn Letter Dear Ms. Roth. The pwposc OfthiS letter is to respond to your request for an interpretatlon of the abihty to apply for an AnImal Boarding Facility use in tho DownLown East Gateway CharacteJ DIstrict as a Comprehensive Infill ProJect. The interpretation is as follows. In addition to the Clearwater ComprehenSIve Plan, the Downtown Plan is the official statement of policy regarding the Downtown and m Pdrttcular with regard to the use of land and public policies governing deCiSIons. All development of land, both public and pnvate, undertaken withlO the Downtown shall be consistent wILh and further the goals of the Plan. The Plan est<lblishes categories of permitted and prohibited URe(; The Community Development Code then enumerates the specific types of permitted and prolubited w,es and their related developmL.-nt standards consistent with the Plan. The East Gateway District VISIon for Uses ,>upports the continued development of the Distnct uS a low and medium density residential neighborhood supported with neighborhood commercial and profeSSIonal offices concentrated along the major corridors ofCteve1and Street Gulf to Bay Boulevard, Court Street and Missouri A venue AdditlonaJly the DIstrict VISion for Development Pattern~ for the arca envislOos that new commerolal development should proVIde employment opportunities for the Dt~tnct's resIdents as well as serve the dmly commercial and personal SeTvlce needs of the neIghborhood. Animal Boarding is not neighborhood commerctal supportmg the residential uses of the area, nor is It professional office. Arumal Boarding is also 1I0t a use spccIfically enumerated in the Downtown Zomng DistriCt. \' IP1Q,ming f)(tpllRmentlC D 1J\APPP AI..'l\C16vdtlna J :/42 - VIP Center Appelll (TJ)l/lIIerpretalllln leuI'./' VIP/!'1 noc' nRlAN 1 AIIN("~I, MAVllR rll \i'll\. f JIII[;,\RIl, Vll r MAy,)\( IIlfI JON,()f1, COLINe.!l ~4P,lIlrR iil Ho) I 1I,\~f11 rrm, (OPNUL'IL\IIIPR l^~lrN ^ I'C1LRHt'l, Col'N! I!~I!-\IIII R , Il,lIlAI EMI'IOYMEN I AND Al'l1IlM^nVI ^n'!pN EMl'll,lYrll" '::::.Et j[I I I lCi F'EF'CiF'T Oct. 19 2005 07:48RM YOUR LOGO YOUR FRX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 I NO. OTHER FRCSIMILE 01 4086 STRRT TIME USRGE TIME MODE PRGES RESULT Oct. 19 07:47RM 01'17 SND 03 OK , TO lURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MENU' 1f:04. TI-IB-I SELECT OFF BY USI NG '+' OR '-'. FOR FRX ADUANTRGE ASS I STANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HELP-FRX (435-7329). '::H1II I t JC:i F'EF'CIF'T Oct. 19 2005 07:49AM YOUR LOGO YOUR FAX NO. CltyOfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 ~O. OTHER FACSIMILE 01 4086 ! I START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT Oct. 19 07:48AM 00'43 SND 01 OK , TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MENU' **04. THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HB.P-FAX (435-7329). ~ l> THE REQUEST Animal Boarding, Outdoor Training, Grooming, Retail Sales, and Baking Dog BiSCUits .. . Comprehen~;ve . InflJr Rede~ropment . . .Prolect . ... . . . . . . . . . . Staff determined that the Animal Boarding use was not a neighborhood supporting use The proposed busmess did involve an outdoor run and training area . ... .... .. .... .. .... . . . . . . . . . . . . CDB did not support the appeal because the appellant had not proven that the three appeal cnteria had been met .~ DEFINITIONS AND IWLI<~S OF CONSTIWCTION poundmg and photographIc plOcessmg facIlItIes and faClhtles for the assembly of electrolllc com- ponents, optical eqlllpment, and preCISIOn lllStru- ments or laboratones or blllldmgs the pnmary use of wluch IS the research, testmg and develop- ment of goods, matellals, foodstuffs 01 products Resident of a COIl1/JUlIllty I eSldcntlOl home means any of the followlllg an aged peIson, a physIcally du:,abled or handIcapped person, a non-dangerous mentally III person or a chIld as defined m the Flonda Statutes Resldentwllllfill project means a development approved pursuant to fleXibIlity clltena th,lt al- low the development of plOpeJ ties whIch nul:' to ulllque condItIOns or hI5toncal patterns of dev~l- opment and ownershIp could not otherwIse be developed ') Resldentwl sheltel means a blllldmg or buIld- mgs or portIOns thereof, the U'3e of whIch IS fOI ,1 nonprofit serVIce provldmg a place of temponlry Ie'3Idence or sustenance to homele5s 01 needy persons or fanuhes Resldenttal use means a pernMnent place of resIdence for a farmly A resHlentraluse located m any resIdentIal zonll1g dIstnct shall not mclude rentals for penods of less than 31 days or one calendar month, whIchever IS less, or whIch IS advertIsed or held out to the publtc as a place Iented for penods of less than 31 days or one calendar month, whIchever IS less Residentially zoned pI opel ty means any pal cel of pI opel ty located m one of the followlllg ZOl1lng ClI'3tllCtS Low Den~Ity ResHlentwl ("LDR"), Low MedlLlm DensIty ResIdential ("LMDR"), MedIum Den5Ity ResIdentIal ("MDR"), Mechum HI~h Den- '3Ity ResIdentl,ll ("MHDR"), HIgh Dpnblty Re5lden- twl ("HDR"), NeIghbOlhood ConservatIOn GvCl by ("NC"), MobIle Home Park ("MHP") as cont,lLI10d m Al tIcle 2 of tlus Development Code ) Rl'sta/ll ant llleans .luse provIdll1~ fOJ the prl'p- alation or sale of pIepmed food for consumption by customeIS pllmallly on the [lrf'IllI"f'<;, lIldud- lllg the subolChnate sale of ,1IcoholIc lWVl'I ,U~C'" fOI ('on~umptlOn on prenuse~, but P'\dudlng fart/ILIC'':; WIth prepared food serVIce Wlthlt1 gLUC PI V "tOI C':" and deltc.ltessens Sllpp ;\/0 11 ~ B- 102 Restalll ant, fast food means a busll1ess mvolv- Il1g the sale of food and/or bevetages ordeIed at eIther a counter or dnve-thtough facthty for eI- ther consumptIOn on the pt emIse5 usmg dIshes and utenSIls whtch are dIsposable, 01 consump- tion off the prenuses Retail sales a/Jd sel ulces means a bUIldll1g, property, or actIvIty the pnnclple use 01 purpose at wluch IS the sale or lea'3e of goods, plod ucts, matellab, or servIces dIrectly to the con5umel, lOcludmg finanCial mstttutlOns, grocet y store'3, ,ldult day care, cluld care, personal servIces, fu- neral homes, art gallenes, arttsans, farmeI mar- kets, SOCIal and commul1lty centers, vetelll1at y offices and annual boardmg WIthout outdoor cclge5, runs or pens .lnd mcludll1g the sale of alcoholtc beverages for off-prenllses consumptIOn prOVIded that the sale of alcohohc beverages IS subordll1.1te to the pnncIpal use and d (splay of alcohohc bev- erages occupIes less than 25 pel cent of the floor .11 ea of the use Not mcludll1g plOblE'lllatlc use'3, street vendors or the on-prenllse consumptIOn of alcohohc beverages RetentIOn Olca means an excavated stormwater holdmg area WlllCh has no deSIgned dtscharge Rlght-orwa)' means a stnp of land reserven, used or mtended to be used for vehlculat or pedestnan travel, mcludmg lllghways, stI eets, alleys, w,llkways, dramage faCIlItIes or other pub- hc plllp05e, whether pubhc or pnvate RUlloff means the qual1ty of stormwater thdt IS un,lble to soak mto the ground due to the PH'b- ('nce of lIupermeable cover and whIch flowb OV(;'1 l.lnd to <1 lower elev,ltlOn followll1g d 5tOt m RUI/way means a defined area on an ,1JrpOlt plepaled for tll1dlllg and t<lkeoff of allcL1ft along ItS length Salllagl' Y([Jd mE'ans an ,11ea of land wluch IS [11mclpally u~ed for the 5tOIage, collectlOn, tn",lt- ment, pUlcha:"e or s,lle of refuse or ~Clap Illdt(,ll- ,lIs, mdudmg but not IUllltcd to Wt ccked 01 sCl.lpped vplllcles, r ,lg5, P,lPPI pLOducts, scr.1p metaL u"ecl <lpplt,lI1(,(,<;, "Clap plutllbll1g supplieS Ot P,lI h of ,my of the forcgolllg or bllllll.U propE'rty SrllllC 0(('1/('/ slllP 111P,lIlS ownel "hIp by tlw ',.1l11e pC'1 "on, COlf)oJ.ILlOll, linn, enLlty, p,u tnel-..]lIp, Of (' UK :2 ') CDB Meetmg Date Case Number Agenda Item Owner/Appellant Representative Address November 15, 2005 APP2005-00002 El A Very Important Pet, Ms Jaycee Roth Todd Pressman 1242 Cleveland Street CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF SUMMARY OF EVENTS GENERAL INFORMATION: REQUEST: Appeal of a Level One declSlon by the Commumty Development Coordmator who demed the abIlIty to apply for an Ammal Boardmg FacIlIty use I~ the Downtown East Gateway Character DIstnct as a ComprehensIve Infill ProJect, under the appeal prOVISIons of SectIOn 4-501 of the Commumty Development Code BACKGROUND: ThIS 0 48 acres sIte IS located at the northwest comer of the mtersectIon of Cleveland Street and Lmcoln Avenue It IS a comer lot wIth frontage along Cleveland Street and Lmcoln Avenue (south and east, respectively) and has been developed wIth a 3,200 square foot, one-story bUIldmg constructed m 1948 and a IS-space parkmg lot. On August 11,2005, Ms. Jaycee Roth, filed a wntten request for an mterpretatIon (ExlubIt A) of the abIlIty to apply for an Arumal Boardmg FaCIlIty use m the Downtown East Gateway Character DIStnCt as a ComprehensIve Infill Project By letter dated September 28, 2005, the followmg mterpretatIOn (ExhIbIt B) was Issued by the Commumty Development Coordmator (Plannmg DIrector) In addItion to the Clearwater ComprehensIve Plan, the Downtown Plan IS the officIal statement of polIcy regardmg the Downtown and m partIcular wIth regard to the use of land and publIc pohcIes governmg declSlons All development of land, both publIc and pnvate, undertaken wIthm the Downtown shall be conSIstent WIth and further the goals of the Plan The Plan establIshes categones of permItted and prohIbIted uses The Commumty Development Code then enumerates the specIfic types of permItted and prohIbIted uses and theIr related development standards conSIstent WIth the Plan The East Gateway DIstnct VlSlon for Uses supports the contmued development of the DIStnCt as a low and medmm denSIty reSIdential neIghborhood supported wIth neIghborhood commercial and professIOnal offices concentrated along the major comdors of Cleveland Street, Gulf to Bay Boulevard, Court Street and MIssoun A venue Staff Report - Commumty Development Board - November 15,2005 - Case APP2005-00002 - Page 1 " AddItIonally the DIstnct VISIon for Development Patterns for the area enVlSlons that new commercial development should provIde employment opportumtIes for the DIStnCt'S resIdents as well as serve the dally commercIal and personal servIce needs of the neIghborhood Ammal Boardmg IS not neIghborhood commercial use supportmg the resIdentIal uses of the area, nor IS It profeSSIOnal office Arumal Boardmg IS also not a use specIfically enumerated m the Downtown Zonmg DIStnCt APPEAL PROCESS: The appellants filed thIS appeal on October 17, 2005 SectIon 4-501.A 2 of the Commumty Development Code states that the CommunIty Development Board has the authonty to hear appeals from orders, reqUIrements, deCISIons or determmatIons made by an arummstratIve offiCial m the arummstratIOn of the Commumty Development Code SectIOn 4-502 A provIdes that an appeal of an orders, reqUIrements, deCISIons or determmatIons made by an adnumstratIve offiCIal m the achmmstratIon ofthe CommunIty Development Code may be mItIated wIthm seven days of the date of the order, reqUIrement, deCISIOn or determmatIon made by an arummstratIve offiCial NotIce of the date of such meetmg shall be provIded the apphcant and the appellants by mall and by telephone. Pursuant to SectIOn 4-504 B, the CDB shall reVIew the apphcatIOn, the recommendatIOn of the Commumty Development Coordmator, conduct a quasI-JudIcIal pubhc heanng on the apphcatIon m accord WIth SectIOn 4-206 (notIce and pubhc heanngs) and render a deCISIon m accordance WIth the provIsIons of SectIOn 4-206 D 5 grantmg the appeal, grantmg the appeal subject to specIfied condItIons or denymg the appeal Pursuant to SectIon 4-504 C of the Commumty Development Code, m order to grant an appeal, (overturnmg or modIfymg the deCISIon under appeal), the CDB shall find that, based on substantIal competent eVIdence presented by the apphcant or other party, all of the followmg cntena are met. 1) The declSlon appealed from mIsconstrued or mcorrectly mterpreted the provlSlons of the Commumty Development Code, and 2) That the declSlon WIll be m harmony WIth the general mtent and purpose of the Commumty Development Code, and 3) WIll not be detnmental to the pubhc health, safety and general welfare Prepared by Plannmg Department staff ~~ J Schodtler, Planner I LocatIOn Map Aenal Photograph of SIte and VIcImty Zomng Atlas Map Surroundmg EXIstmg Uses Map Photographs of SIte and VIcImty ApphcatIOn ExhIbItS A - B Staff Report - Commumty Development Board - November 15,2005 - Case APP2005-00002 - Page 2 ~?( ..0& ".., A ... -:! August 11, 2005 To The CIty of Clearwater. Planmng Development From A Very Important Pet Center 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, Flonda 33761 Case # FLD200S..o6058 Response InterpretatIon of code regardIng the boardIng of canines at a VIP Center The staff and the Committee Development coordinators indicated that such boardIng use -colUllldl n~t be apphedl for 1Il1ll1der tJ'm.s 'Qype of aJPi1Phcati~n I wOllnJIdl apprecnare a\ wntten resjpOll1Ise to my request for boardtng dogs Wlder the FleXIble DeveRopmem 3.ppbcatlon The camnes Will be cared for and managed at all tunes Mr Todd Pressman WIll be representing me Sincerely, Jaycee Roth A Very Important Pet August 11,2005 To rne CIty or Clearwater Planmng Development From AVery Important Pet Center 1242 Cleveland Street Clean-vater, Florida 33761 Case # FLD2005-06058 Response' 1 Hours of operation are currently set for A. Open for drop off at front door 6 00 AM B. Close the evemng at 9'00 P M May not pIck up dogs after that tIme. C. Dogs must In be inSIde bUlldmg by 7'30 P M 2 How much area to be used busmess. A 300 Sq Ft RetaIl area B. 550 Sq Ft Grooming Area C 400 Sq Ft BakIng Area D 1000 Sq. Ft. Cageless dog area 3 How is thts proposal cbaractenstIc oftbe adjacent properties A The landscaping will be in compliance and give a clean and well. maintaIned appearance, B. The building to the west is only the block SIde facmg the A VIP C. The Budding to the East IS across the street Wlth street nOIse on both the west side and the south SIde It IS a motel that the center would have no impact It would provide anyone staymg at the motel a place for theIr dogs to stay when they are away from their room. D The BuIlding on the south SIde of the street has no affect It IS across Cleveland Street. E. Area to the north is a vacant lot that IS approxunately 100 ft from the 6 ft fence in the back of A VlP center. TIns has very httle Impact on tlus area due to the chstance from the commercial area of the center with a commerCIal vacant lot between I feel this has less 1lllpact on the area than a restaurant that is open much later in the evenings Noise WIth trash bInS in the back and cars connng and going. ThIS area is fenced and dogs Will be in by 7.30 F This center will support the needs of the commumty In many ways There are over 58,000 dogs In Clearwater. Just 10 years ago there was only about 38,000 dogs m Clearwater. It is growing and people are becommg more and more attached to theIr canine compamons Weare short on evacuation centers according to the SPCA This wIll give the local resIdents a secunty I have been told It is not m a flood zone Most of the boardIng faCIlitIes m Clearwater are cages and lock up the dog until the O'WIler comes back 1:0 pIck them up I am offenng a much more fnendly and healthy atmosphere All dogs will get basIC traunng and attentlon Tills IS exactly what the CIty of Clearwater needs for so many resIdents commg to the area that will be bnngmg even more camnes. I have the talent and the passion to work with these dogs My goal IS to have an establishment that the CIty of Clearwater can count on In cases of emergencIes A VIP wIll pIck up the dog and take It to the center so It IS not unart G nded or left alone m tunes of desperatIon. WIth the 6' fencesurroundmg the outsIde area should create low impact on the area and enhance It's charm. The majority of the customers wIll be plCkmg up or droppmg off which again IS much lower Impact than a restaurant. I want to work Wlth the CIty of Clearwater m every way to bnng good thtngs to the area and make us all proud, 4 This business will not hinder busmesses In the area. It wIll be a trammg facIlity for resIdents and theIr dogs. It WIll be educatIonal center that w111 bnng more balanced famIly pets. I will have employment opportunItIes for the area. The distance of the homes WIth another commercIal property between would not create any nnpact on any homes In the area. It IS mostly a commerctal area. 5 The estnnate to develop tlus buddmg and lot 15 about $30,000, not includmg the mtenor. 6 Gwdeline checklIst I, ~ ~~H"S' T B ,7" ~! I ~ \\J 1 y ."- I'" U t, {1~1 \~1 L El\RWA'fER PLANI'TING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Bo~ 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUIlDING, 100 SOUTH MYRnE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 LONG RANGE PiAl'lNI:-iG DEVELOPMENT REVIEW September 28, 2005 Ms Jaycee Roth A Very Important Pet Center 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, FL 33761 Re Allowable Use m the Downtown - East Gateway zomng dIstnct - Zomng InterpretatIOn Letter Dear Ms Roth The purpose of thIS letter IS to respond to your request for an mterpretatIon of the abIlIty to apply for an Ammal Boardmg FaCIlIty use m the Downtown East Gateway Character DIStnCt as a ComprehensIve Infill Project The mterpretatIOn IS as follows In addItIon to the Clearwater ComprehensIve Plan, the Downtown Plan IS the offiCIal statement of polIcy regardmg the Downtown and m partIcular WIth regard to the use of land and publIc polICIes governmg deCISIOns All development of land, both publIc and pnvate, undertaken WIthm the Downtown shall be conSIstent WIth and further the goals of the Plan The Plan establIshes categones of permItted and prohIbIted uses The Commumty Development Code then enumerates the speCIfic types of permItted and prohIbIted uses and theIr related development standards conSIstent WIth the Plan The East Gateway DIstnct VISIon for Uses supports the contmued development of the DIstnct as a low and medIUm denSIty reSIdential neIghborhood supported WIth neIghborhood commercial and profeSSIOnal offices concentrated along the major comdors of Cleveland Street, Gulf to Bay Boulevard, Court Street and MIssoun Avenue AddItIonally the DIstnct VISIOn for Development Patterns for the area enVISIOns that new commercIal development should prOVIde employment opportumtIes for the DIstnct's reSIdents as well as serve the daily commercial and personal servIce needs of the neIghborhood Ammal Boardmg IS not neIghborhood commercial supportmg the reSIdentIal uses of the area, nor IS It profeSSIOnal office Ammal Boardmg IS also not a use speCIfically enumerated m the Downtown Zomng Dlstnct S IPlonnzng Depor/men/IC D B\APPEALSIClevefand 1242 - VIP Center Appeal (D)IInterpretatlOn letter VIPET doc BRIAN J AI ,,,(,~ I, MA,OR Fft-\.l\l\ HlBfl\RD, VIlL MAl OR Hm-j tl-\.\llLlO"J, COl''lUL\If\lflCh Bill JON';ON, COlI~'( fl\If\lflCR f1f'h C\RICN A P,'LR';f\" COL'NUL\lC\IHfR ~1 "EQUAL E~lPLmMENl AND Arnl{~L~IIYE f\llION EMPLOIEI{" Should you wIsh to appeal thIS detem1matlOn you must do so wIthm 14 days of the decIsion by filmg the attached appeal applIcatlOo wIth the reqUlred fee to the CIty Clerk's office Please contact John Schodtler at 727-562-4547 with any questlOns Smcere1y, ,,~/'-1 J -/ - '--:,/ --:' //. / ./ .//~ -/ MIchael DellC, I ~ Planmng DIrector S IPlannmg DepwlmenllC D BIAPPEALSICleveland 1242 - VIP Cenler Appeal (D)\Inlel plelallOn lelte! VIPET doc ST :~~ ~ ~Q ~D Ii=- l! o I Moo. I 0 ~ D~:' I~ ~ I n 1jDIlD n D ,---, .--. . . ElDRIOOE ST U ~ ~ U MAPLE L----J L-J MAPLE Sf I ~ '" WPLE " ~ C:=J = MAPLE '!! Q ~~D\-~D~L ! !! !! ~ 'DHO~ ~ I L-.--.1 JACKSON RD FOREST RO 0 PIfEWOOD ~ ST D~O 0 DiD~D~D'!!D~D~D ~D O~Oi9~ OMW~ i o [][[] 0 ~~ 0 CJ D ~ ~ ~ < ~ It ~ CJ D~ ",,~WooD 5l ~~J:J O:n!d;t=J ~DI !~ID'U~~~ITJ~D~D!D c=J O~~~D ~~D N 0 ~~Q ~GR)VE ~ Sf 3 0< ~ ~ c=J O~r:::;;;:J>-D rOD O~c=J ~ I D ~ [==:J~c=J 0 c=:J~D S R 60 CLE\.RAND ST . c=J Q.EVElAND D Q D~Lj Sf D~D PiD~fWlb. PARl< llc;=J ~ Offir---, o!illi'lw!!; n,,-U~ O~Dl;; ~gJC=:J ~L--J L-J ~ !f Sf ~ PIERCE ~ D ST W 5 ~1' PIERCE Sf CJ o CJ eJ 0 ~~RCE iD\D" rz<~~[QJ ~ ~.~ ~ ~ ~c:::;J FRANKlIN ST b ~ ~ :r ~ ~o ~ ' IN ~~ ~ C] c:J] 0 DI ~ i !~D ~ Sf ~ ~~ PROJECT DELEON ~~ ~DDD~~ ~~L5AROM~ SITE ~ ~ r=-'IDDDI- · I~,,' I <? !~~.o:O,[}D ~ 0 D ,TURNER I ~~<~ ~ ~ ~ TW<>ER ~ > < eJ [] I · I !L3i~ " ICJ'~I~ DIDOD mUID RD g D P ~g~1 :~ I ~~~~l'i ~GLm"'NE q~ JASMIIE~ DO D RK ~c=J~c=J ~ ~bl '!! '!! -"<1" DR W\GNOUA OR :i MJlGNOlIA CR ~ }f u~ 4( <( o D~D CJ c=J ~ ~ ~~OUA LOrus PATH LOTUS PATH LOTUS PATH c=J .'~l ~D D~' ,~ P"-M D-UFF Sf iDSAllE[DJ' S:AlM ;~u~D; ,8 "-"GENS ST ~ g is c:::J ~z Iii - '" ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ Location Map Owner I Jaycee Roth I Case Property Slze(Acres)' APP2005-GOOO2 Site 1242 Cleveland Street 0.48 A Very Important Pet PIN 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 Atlas Page. 287B . Aerial Map Owner Jaycee Roth Case. A P P2005-00002 Site' 1242 Cleveland Street Property Size(Acres) 0.48 PIN 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 Atlas Page: 287B 11" 1 124 r--l ," L__J ! 1113 ":L; 1--~16 1 riM II 12~1J L~ 1 : ~ 1ffJ!h, 'I 1--.t.(4 :q: f10711J III ( - a:: ::>> o CI) CI) Si ~ ,"'f64--1 I I I I ___r r-I I 1 I I 1 I l_...J ~ I~---{i ~ L,,___~ - o ~. ~ r.J~ r---' r I I I .J ~ ---rtJ : 15 I 12 :z: I __...J 0 LJ CI) a:: ~ ~ :z: ---I I g I ~ I 11 1 1 1 1 I I L____.J r- I ~ Q_Jc-., ~ ~ N I ~ 1) ~ 0::( ~ o CI) CI) Sif Cl)l I I 1 1 I I I I : ,---""!-_-----, I I I I : L") 1 ;. ....-------1 r.J' '_I I---------J I L__ ~I ~I ~I I I r-~----------, I : ~ Ii: L--~r------=----I L__J I ~l I ~I I I 1 1 1 I c! I I II l___1 [~~~_~M}JJlR--~-~--! ,--I i- ~~-- --, ~J h"--.... U l 1 --I '" I~ I ,~.,. ~ c6 ;l- I.... ~~ ~ L,..p CL- _:~ J! ~~~j I __JE GROVE ST to li;~_ ~ '" '" ~ ~ 0; r--p ~-e" 1-~ r-~ r--~ ~-l~ r J' i-J1 ~_J I ~- r-I ~ --.J J L_J 17 -, M I l-.rtI I" L, I JJ L__~ ~ , L I --- -1 I - I -- ....~IO"'.... ~ '" 0 I '" ~ ;i~I~~~ 1:\1 ~ ~ I (') ~ "-'--1--- ........ - ~ ~ CLEVELAND ST [1 c ~ 0::( :z: ... o u ~ - ... o:gg (")1.0"""01_(")...., ~~~ ~~~~~~~ ~_(')LO ------------~-~~-~- -------------- 1 I I I 5 I I I 7 j'1-----=i--' Owner' Site A Very Important Pet r------ I ___r---------~J c-... ~ Fl~ 1E~J ~ 119 117 116 !J.I :s 1--1-fr4 0::( ~ 115 L tt2 Q 113 _ ,-rrll I ! 0 .... _ 1 L 1~0 0 :5 -'1o~ [. 1G{j :it I I I ~ 8 1 1- J 10~ LU ~ I" 1 ~ ... Ia...TI~ :z: ~ ~ . 1 I 1 , I I L___... li ,-- : ~4 I I l-r- - 1--' f--'11 : 1...L-L 111 -1._1 __, 1ff. J 19\1r----, 1 1 ~ L,,_J L_l r 1-... L, I ~ I J .... 1 L__ l I L r~~...J :5;& 1J I :~ ~ ~ ~-~o 117 115 "-_~ ~ cnlt)~ ~-- ...-"t"llI ~-.... ~ 10 It) 10 ~ ~ ...t ~I II~ I ...~- 'CV\~- _ - ~ 1;"""--1 \ : J!: l_ , 14 1 ----...1 : 1 1 1 , LJ f-""'- ~ 1 , 01 101 ~ ~J ~ to ~ ,-----..,.. 1 1 I I , I I I 1 i '" to ~ 125 1263 -'" r.:. U 12 12 2 1 pr--- T Zoning Map Jaycee Roth 1242 Cleveland Street Case Property Size (Acres) . PIN r I I ,-------- I L---1 i I i-------J :z: I I I 1 ... I I: : ). I '_J I I:: 'I LU ~l IL____...J.... 1XI ~j ~ ~ C.J q; ~ J---l L___J r~ ~ I ~ ~ ~65: :--- ~ I 1 .... L_J ~ I:: LU 1XI 20 CI) '" ~ L~I [~ I~ L tO~ r-l;; ~ I""~ --" '" '" '" ~-l LJ .. ....... ~ 100 r--- 11'111 " I'lL ~ 10 I_r-~ ~~ m 0 .....~ (\I...... C\I ----:: ~ r::- ~ @ 1"'"--' 1 1 L__I ~ r---'_______ - I 1 l-L l __ ..., I r----' J , I I I 0 I '" I ~ l___________, r==- I~I I~I L...J ....' ........ \ \ ....,) \...-.... --I :Ii l I ~ I I I I 1 ' I Lr--- I ... I- I L, ,- ~1:;tO ~ LT l 10 oc::: ---tr ~ fJH ~po~ ~ l~ f\ \\ \\: v~\~ DADV ~T APP2005-00002 0.48 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 A tlas Page: 287B r1&l--1 ~ 1___) q: ~ o CI) ~ c: ~ q: - !5 o CI) CI) Sir Cl)l I I I I I I I I I Owner: I Site: 1>1 1--1 L__J 1124 ," I ! 1--~16 I I I : r--~4 Ii: ~ 'i1n2 1pl : I --~ 1 6 119 116 117 r-Hj4 115 l d2 nnl I I I L. 1bo r------iij-----: r------W----, 10~ ~ 19ft I ~ I I ~ I .J, .-1 L ~ L - - I I..:! lU<1 rJ~ !-il[=i-~~I~~ ul~iil3 GROVfHL~idential I---------J I L ~I ~I ~I I I r-~----------, I I I '" II I I ~ II I L--...r-________--I L__.J ,-i; ~-~!t~-~ r-~ r'" If II rl J ,--I -_-I........ 1__......- i (17 --, ~ , M I r I : 113 I rr , 111 r'L I L__...J ~ r'l:1iJ ,--1 I I I I I I L.J ~ I~--~ l:! L~___~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ r-l--": r---' IIICt r I I : ..Jr ~ --~ c: I 0 115: 12 CI) I __...J a:: I I ... -~ ii: La.: r ~~~1 au ~~ Df I 8 1 '" 0_%'" c: I ~ l ~ E ~ I 1'" I - L____.J -- 1---'-------1 I I I I : l"} I ~ L..-------1 rJ RetaitSale~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ice ~ ~ - L I --- -, I - I -- ~~I ~~~ ~~ ~ I ~ ~ co ~~l~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ CLEVELAND ST (j & Service 0I_C?1O C\l C") C'? CO) ~ ~ ~ ~ ---------------------------- ~~~~- C") LO ~~~~~ ~ ~ 5 7 f.I J , - ,------ I I_____________.J PIERCE ST . I ~l I ~I I I : I d : 1 I, ,___I I : I I l___J il 117 ,.--- I ' I 1'14 I I l_,...... 115 r '11 ~ :--1 I I ~ I I 111 -,--I --1 1f( ... J 1llf/r---, 1 ~ ...~ II I : I 1pL~__J L_J ~ I" L:ll_.J ~ : : :3:] ~ ~ l~ I _r'ft" C'\I C'I C'tl-J10 .... ............ 113 r--~ "" -,~ -I r r-I ., J~ J I~-- r~, ~I~ --I '" ].-~t"'~ j- ~ ~ r;---' " _: __J I : ---- ---- ,_ ! ~___ I r -~ I ,_______.J I ....1 I L____ I J I I I I I 1 --------~ U O~e~night r--'_ I I I I. : \n omWla~on~J I I I ~J ~ ~l IL____...J ~ J 14 ( I. I J L__~ ~ L1 '" '" '" '-----T I I ! OffJce I I r I I I I 1 I I 20 c: .... ).. I::: UJ III CI) ;0 ~ J---j L___J ~.....,. '" I "- "- I ~ ~ I 1___ 651 I I I L_J ~ q: c: .... o ,0 l:it ~- \.... I I I I PARK ST ~ I ~ 12 5 -':...r- ~ t::: L~I [~ 1263 -,J~ :e~ r~~ --~ "" '" '" ~lJ 100 r--- r 12~ 12 2 12 61 I, L ~ 10 Lr-~ ~~ ~ 0 :.:-.: ~ ~ ~ PIERCE ST Existing Use Map Jaycee Roth 1242 Cleveland street A Very Important Pet I Case: Property Slze(Acres)' (6) ~ r--, I I L__J - r---'1_______ - I I l-l ~ __ -.., I r---..J I I I , I 0 I '" I ~ l___________1 ~ ill I~I I_...J --... ,- \ \ -..I \-- --, :ll : I ~ I I I I I I I !...r--- I 100 T r-- ,- I ,..:"1 I I LiJ H ff(j 110 I \: ~-r !.., 1 0 I I ~ 1170 U\\\ A PP2005-00002 0.48 PIN: 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 I Atlas Page 287B Subject Property - South Elevatton Subject Property - South-west ElevatlOn ~ Adjacent parking lot to the North 1242 Cleveland Street APP2005-00002 . ,r Subject Property - East Elevatton Non-conformmg freestanding sign " ~ - ~ - ~...."'~ ._~~ - ~ - -...._--.,..w..~~.. _____f' Single and Multi Family Residential to the North Page 1 o ....' -- -- - 'A.'--' - .-- ..,... ........z'!'l' -. / ~ Office to the South-East .-~- ~ ~_.::L ~~.. ""- -- Overnight Accommodations to the East " r ,/",- !t - -"--- I~;-' " ~<~!:' L ~ttIt"'h~ .... ~..<; Retail SaleslRestaurant to the South-west Retail Sales to the west Iv // I RetaIl Sales to the west 1242 Cleveland Street APP2005-00002 Page 2 11- \1--05.11 ~ I~L~~~a2::~~1JT' ~;CENE~ v , t' ~;iW 04 200r- I , ~LA''l''''!f\I(, ~ ~'(VElOPMEt. -:- svcs ... oJ CITY OF aEARw~iERLE.ARWA Tt.'1 JOFFlCIt\L RECORDS AND NOTICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD PUBLIC HEABJlSOlIwE SRVCS DEPT 59AM,Offrclal Records t The Community Development Board of the City of Clearwater, Florida, wIll hold public hearings on Tuesday~ November 15, 2005, beginning at 1:00 p.m., in the City CouncIl Chambers, m City HaIl, 3rd floor, 112 South Osceola Ave, Clearwater, Florida, to consider the following requests: NOTE: All oersons wishinp to address an item need to be present at the BEGINNING Gf the meeting. Those cases that are not contested bv the applicant. staff. neimborilU! property owners. ere. will be placed on a consent Henda and approved by a sin2le vote at the bet!innine: of the meetine:. Javcee Roth is requesting an appeal of an admmistrative determination denying the ability to apply for an Animal Boarding Facility use as a Comprehensive In.fill Redevelopment" Project in the powntown East Gateway Character District, per See 3-502. (proposed Use: Animal Boarding Use) at :i24J ueveJand. ~( Padgett's bstates Su6 Lot 3 & parts of Lots 2 & 4 Assigned PGinner: John Schodtler, Planner L APP2005~00002 -7 Interested partIes may appear and be heard at the hearing or fIle written notice of approval or - objection WIth the Planning Director or City Clerk pnor to the hearing. Any person who decides . to appeal any decision made by the- Board or Council, with respect to any matter considered .-at such hearings, will need to request a recoro of the proceedings an~ for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, WhICh record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based per Florida Statute 286.0105 Community Development Code See 4-206 states that party status shall be granted by the Board m quasi-judicial cases if the person requesting such status demonstrates that slhe IS substantially affected. Party status entitles partIes to personally testify, present evidence, argument and witnesses, cross-examine witnesses, appeal the decision and speak. on reconsideration requests, and needs to be requested and obtained during the case discussion before the CDB. An oath WID be administered sweanng m ail persons giving testimony in quasi-Judicial public hearing cases. If you wish to speak at the meeting, pleake wait to be recognized, then state and speD your name and provide your address Persons without party status speakJ.ng before the CDB shall be limited to three minutes unless an indiVidual is representing a group in WhICh case the Chairperson may authorize a reasonable amount of time up to 10 minutes. Five days prior to the meetmg, staff reports and recommendations on the above requests will be available for review by mterested parties between the hours of 8'30 a.m. and 4'30 p.m., weekdays, at the City of Clearwater, Planning Department, 100 S. Myrtle Ave., Clearwater, FL 33756. Please contact the case presenter, at 562-4567 to discuss any questions or concerns about the project and/or to better understand the proposal and review the SIte NOTE: Applicant or represe g. 9/!?+ /115 - WE ~!-fV r jVUI) IhVj /3J1/rf{ lIfe 7 D~CS fo/f:J- NJfb/) 1-&5;' ;./{)IS~ -- /\10 7 n(J"f/~ -~~ Z;?)~ .....--::::' /"" ----- City of Clearwater P.O. Box 4748, Clearwater, FL 33758-4 IV p///f JJ )'/!' - I City of Clearwater, Florida Official Records & Legislative Services Department Phone (727) 562-4090 Fax (727) 562-4086 11-,4-05,11 59AM,Offlclal; Re_cords t ..... u. '"'J'.'I" o II' II i 11\11')\11 ' I I '5 dll, , ::" ;,;:, earwater . " - U FAX MESSAGE TO: Sherry Watkins LOCATION: Planning FAX NO.: 4865 COMMENTS: Objection to APP2005-00002 FROM: Trish Zitouni, (727-562-4098) I DATE: 11/4/2005 -A ,727 562 4086 # 1/ 2 NUMBER OF PAGES TillS MESSAGE (INCLUDING THIS PAGE): 2 ... "- ST , .;:n, ID Dl, '! :~~ !1ewF!J;~ ~ijj sr P"-M "-UIT ST iOSALLE IOJJSTpALM ;~u~D: 18 ~ ~ 0 .l.RG8'4S 51 ~ 0 B =' CEDAR = C:::Z:--Z Iii" '" ~D ~~~~ ~ ~ ~ :: og: -8-BOO 11= ~! o ~ !lLGE I 0 I ST SETb~11 ST ST I n IElDRIOOE ST I ~8:[]][J~~ ~ c::::J CJ ""'-E UJ _ ~ gfj'" MIRE >I V:::D~c:J ~ DO 0 DMlRE~ c:J8 ~ <( PlAZA ~ ~ ~ ~ iii ~ ~ ~cfiJ'NOA RJ~ " ~ DO ~ m ,~" m 0 ~ I' tJ D~O 0 DiD~DaD~DiD~D !D DI0io~ OAAWOOD ; D OlD 0 ~~o c:::J D j ~ ~ <( ~ 8' j! CJ DJ: ~WOOjj ~ 1;QrJ Dnld;~ ~~ !~!O'D~~IIi[]~D~D!D c=J D~Q~D ~~D ~ 0 ~J:Q ~GroVE i ST 3" ~ ~ c=J D~~~D ~;< 0 D D~c:=J ~ I D i c=:J~c=J 0 c=J~D D Q D~CJ <>E\RNa)ST D~D ST PiD~rwlb: c;;:JS1c::;=J ~ <>E\lBJ\ND Oilir--l D~r--li'lw "i n~UiE D~D~ ~~c=J D~~ DEd~ ~uEiD~OST: q/l~~~ ~ D ~"' - ~ \'\j~tE:"I U -.. ST t; ~ 3 ~ g ~~"-J U~U .. ~~ ~ C] c=ID 0 DI ~ i LCD ~ ST ~ ~~ PROJECT DELEON ~~ ~DDD~~ ~~t==rROSA~ SITE ~~ r==~-I 0 0 CJ I -" " I. ~,l "I Cl ~~~n:O!O!D ~ 0 Q I ST I ~PI~ ~~ I1Tl ic=J!CJ~C~~YD~DsT ~D 0 CJ 01 I qPI~~ ~Lji~ ~ ~ J:DiD! ~ i OO:UID RD i DRUID ODD CJ~c:=:J ~~~'" ~[{ffi c=::J~ ODD ORK~~C?: ~ ~D~D 3 ~ 0 <( J:r ~ ~WAY MAGNOllA DR ~ ::E MPGNOUA rn ~ ~ U~ <I{ o D~D CJ c:=:J "~ "''''QUA LOTUS PATH LOTUS PATH c=J D Jl\SMltE W/4. MAGN<lJA DR LOrus PATH Location Map Owner Jaycee Roth Case' A P P2005-00002 Site' 1242 Cleveland Street Property Slze(Acres): 0.48 A Very Important Pet PIN 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 Atlas Page 287B '''' I 124 r--l I~ L__J i r 113 -1L' r-~16 I r~ I I l~~1JL~ I I ~ rl1tl9j'-l r--.t.{4 <( 1,107 I!! II I ~ - 0:: ~ o CI) ~ :z: ,-#14--, I I I I ___.J- ,--I I I I I I I L...J ~ I~---S ~ L>>___\l o ~ o ,.J~ r---' r I I I .r ~ ---n, - i 15 I I ---' LJ r ---I 1 0 I : ~ I ~ I - I) ~ I L____.J r- , Q_Jr\l ~ 5 I ,----~ n ~ <( ~ o CI) ~ ::ef Cl)l I I I I I I I I : 1---'-------, I I I I : L"') I .; L.._______, rJ' '_I o ~ g ~ ~ ~ I---------J I L ~I ~I ~I 1 I r-~----------~ I I '" II I I ~ II I L.--....r_______~--1 L__J L~~-_~-_~~M}JJlJl--~-~--! [--I r ij:-- --, l\,,-' ~-~ ... LJ' I --I ~ I:! t 1_ ~ ~ cb ~ I I~ ~J ~ L.,j~ C!-- _:~ J1 ~~~JI!' __JE GROVE ST I ~1 I ~ 1 I - -- ';~IO~-'; ~ '" 1 0 I ~~I~~~ ~~ a I '" B '" '" '" ~ ~ CLEVELAND ST (j Q) _ <-) Ii) C\I CO) ~ CO) C"I C\I C\I C\I --------------------------~-~~-~- ~~~~- CO) I() ~~~~~~~ 10 I:i; ~ '" '" '" ~ --...- r-~ ~-~ ,-~ r-~' r--~ ;>I--,:::l r'" I' II J I ...... I J 1-- I -_..J......... l.r- r-I 1 12 0 L_J 17 CI) 0:: ~ La: ~ :z: 5 7 :F------:;--L ~.. Owner' Site' A Very Important Pet r------ I 1_____________.1 '~T ~ -, ~ I r 12 i5 I I ~-'-, I r:, I I TJ 12 r' L, I 1 I r L__~ ~ L1 ~ <( :z: .... o o :z: - .... i ~ I I ~I I ~I I I I I <! : I 'I L___I 'il~ 'E~J ~ 119 116 117 ~ r-tt' <( ~ 115 U~ Q _ I "I I I 0 ~ __ I L, 1~0 0 :z: -'fo~ [. 198 ~ .... I I "1.... o ,- ~ __" ... o I - 1uy LU a: I" 1 ~ .... :!-T'~ :z: ~ ~ Ll.!E I I I I I I L.___.... ,-- : ~4 I 1 l~"'" I---- 1__' [--Ll' : :~ 111 -1._1 --, 11G J 19pr---.., 1 l II , I 1 1P L,,__J L_J 1 L ~ 'I ~ I I ~I L~_ ~ L-:x I Lr~ J ~ ~ ~-~o 117 115 113 14 .... _~ ~ It) ~ It) ~ ...... ..-- J-.... ~-_ L..n: 10 ~ 10 '" '" ~ ~I'~ II"~ ,,,.,~- ~ I~ I I I I" ~ ("--I " I - 1 I '_ I I ----...1 I , I I I LJ f I I-------J I L___, I J I I I: r-------~ :z: I II I .... I I I I >- f-- I L1 I 10- I I 10- I I LU !i 'L____-1 ~ (Q J :z: r--'_ I I I 01 lQl ~ ~I ~ ,- ,-~ 1...__, 10 10 '" ,-----,.. I I I I I I I I I I L I I I I I 1 1 ~ <0 ~ J---l L___J ~..,.,. '" I.... .... I ~ ~ , ,--- 651 I I I L_J :z: .... ). I:: LU (Q 20 CI) 1263 <0 ;::: L~I [~ I~ 1_ ~~ f~~ -....-' ~ '" ~ -, t_1 12 2 1 .. ........ .... 100 IJYI II '(" ~--II I. 1 r_l~ - ~ p/.-r.".- T ~~ Q:) ~~ ~ ~ C\.I ~~!:- ~ Zoning Map Jaycee Roth 1242 Cleveland Street Case: Property Size (Acres) @ ,..--, I I L__J '-- r---'_______ - I I L-l J -, ' -- I r---.J I 1 I , I 0 I '" I ~ L___________I~ I re I I" I ~ I~I , I ~ L.J I I /' 1 I // \ I I \ ~) I Lr--- v~ I ... DJJ.PK !:T 1- r-=-' I ~:lO ~ LT l 1 ~ ~ -----il Ifl ~ ~~ IT? r I t"" I U\\\~ A P P200S-QOOO2 0.48 PIN. 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 A tlas Page 287B 11!l 1--1 L__J r I : 113 In 1111 rll I__...J - 1124 I" I I ,-"-16 I I I : r--~4 rl ~ ,r1tllrj ,-, 1.107 I! J ,-1Qf--1 ~ :_--) q: ~ o CI) CI) :i =2: ,-I I I I I I I L...J ~ I~---S - L",___~ III o.~ :s; ~ TJ~ .1--, -q: r I , I rr ~ --~ =2: I 0 115: 12 CI) i __...J It I ' ,.. -" i:i:: LL: r .J!.~11311 I I I 0 I I 0 I : ~ 11 I L____J ,- ,- CfJ Q_fC\l :z: ~ t! ;;; - I - ~ q: ~ o CI) CI) :if Cl)1 I I I I I I I I I 1---'--------1 I I I I I l~ I ( L-------l r...r'" RetaitSale' (; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'il~ 1E~J ~ 119 116 117 r~ 115 l t1'2 711 I I __ I L, 1~0 r------<:;-----I r------w----, "10~ [. ~ I ~ I I - I I I I L______:..____J L _ _ I :-.J 10* ~J ~ I !J~JI[~i--~IJt-~ ul~iilJ GROvmiE..~identis I I---------J : : I L____________J -I g:1 -I I I r-...-----------, I I I g: II I I - II I L--...r_____-:--__I L__J r-"ti~~.-~i f~-~ r-~~['--~ r r- I r I I I I J ,-- I -_..J.......... L.....- r-I r i _.J .r~ I r 17 --, ^ I M I ice ~ , L I --- -, I - I -- ~~I~~~ ~~ (:) I C\I ~ CfJ ~~I~~~ ~ ~ E I ~ ~ ~ CLEVELAND ST [j & Service Q) _ C"') to C\l C"') ~ ('W'J --------------------------~-~:_~- ~~~~~ ~ LO ~~~~~ ~ ~ 5 : -I , g: I I -I I I I I c! I : II .___1 r' I I "1 : r '---~ ~ L1 ~ q: =2: -.! o ,0 ,=2: i:;j I I I I I 7 r------ I " 1!1---------L----1------------- I - PIERCE ST Owner I Site A Very Important Pet I I I I l___J LL1E 117 ,--- I l I 1-%4 I I l_,....... 115 r "11 c: :--1 I I.... I I 111 -1._1 --, 11C 10- J 1119r---, l!, Io-~ II , I 1 1~ L,,__J L_J _ ~, I, I ~ I : ~I L-O- ~ l1& : Lr~ J ~ ~ ~-~o 113 ~ -l~ , , J ~--~ r~ ~-I 10 -i- ~~- ~ l. _:t--J! : ____ ____ 1"--: I II [____ ",'_______J I, -----.....1 I I I I I --------" U ~et1rtight r-">- I!~ I 1 reromusJions:-.J I I I ~ I ~ -arl lL____-.J ~ ~ I ~ ~I f'I ...... ~ -J - 14 10 10 '" 1------,- I I ! Offlce I I r I , I 1 I I I - '<> ~ J---l L___J ~-..,. '" I... ... I '" '" 1:>65: :--~ I I 1 I L__ 20 =2: -.! PARK ST ).. l:: '<> ;::: :e- O) UI L~I [~ 'il!, '" '" tQ L-,.J~ '" - -, CI) -d~ L.J 100 ~ 12 ~ 1263 -L, ~"__J I r--- I 121a 12 2 12 61 II L I r-I~ - ~ ~fO co ~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~ PIERCE ST Existing Use Map Jaycee Roth 1242 Cleveland street Case Property SizelAcres): 16') "-N~ - r--, I I L__l e-- r---'___~___ - I I l-l t __ -, , r--oJ I I I , I 0 , '" I ~ l___________, -=== :~I 1-' L.J ....' '(.....- \ \ ....j \--- --I ~ I I ~ I I 1 I I I I Lr--- I - 1- L ~_1 I 100 I I If'-~~ ~ I J~ ~ ff~ U\~ ~ APP2005-DOOO2 0.48 PIN' 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 I Atlas Page 287B Aerial Map Owner I Jaycee Roth I Case' Property Size{Acres) A P P2005-00002 Site. 1242 Cleveland Street 0.48 PIN 15-29-15-65268-000-0030 Atlas Page' 287B , .J APP2005-00002 1242 Cleveland Street --. I--~~~ . ~.'H,IIIII ~,., " '{. ( ;>- - .,.....-- ~ ~.. ~ - - ~- - ..... South Elevation. ..... . .' .. . . , , ( I ~ ~ -- - __ l . ". . :...;~] r=---~'.a. I.. I.---~~ _: r < l - \, ' -<T<-",\. 1 ~ ~"^' ~ ~ ,..,.. '/:- v,... ....J .' "- "p~'\" '~ , -'""~", , South-east elevation. ..",r- ..-*.tI ~~l ~' .:;~f, , " ~J"~ I "!fe' ~ ~. . " t r' I I c-c ' ~ East Elevation. East Elevation Along Rear Property Line. I&.~. ~ ~-~~~ ;v.( ,- ,~ ;>, ~ "-ft - f '" Adjacent parking lot to the North. Adjacent parking lot to the North. ...---- - I . l ~- -"' ( """ Single Family and Multi Family Residential to the North. Single Family Residential to the North. -...---..........- ---- -~ ------- ----------- li- I ,1\ >r ~ ~~"",," )- t'p-~tf:,.r;.,,... ~ r.J ,>~~!'7'''\ ;J;;;''''",r-,~ - """ A\1.o "'o."'~ -\ jt:~~_y~4.;!c .... ...... J.-~t1-~ "..il-tllt~ /~ :.J- "\1 'I' '-- '1t ...-J~ j ': "I. ~:t l '.L......r~ ~ - " " ~ , I ,< >- , Overnight Accommodations to the East. 1__ u____ I """ '-> 0, - -...-- -- .... '"", _1.- ~<>1lJ&., :}~ lJ,~~(~ Office to the South-east. South-west elevation. I - I ., x--~ I I I I - -------' \ West elevation and parking lot. } f __~ v (\ , \ r (\ I' ! I , 1---,,- _ .. - ~ i ~ - ]lJ!' ---- , -- 'JI ',~ . ..~_~ -~~....-<.. < 1[ Non-conforming freestanding sign. Retail Sales/Restaurant to the South- west. - -~-------. -- I' h ~ ......~;~~ \~,.':.~ '~ Retail Sales to the west. Retail Sales to the west. Retail Sales to the west. . , 'i' CITY OF CLEARWATER NOTICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD PUBLIC HEARINGS The Community Development Board of the CIty of Clearwater, Flonda, wIll hold pubhc heanngs on Tuesday, November 15, 2005, begmnmg at 1 00 pm, m the CIty CouncIl Chambers, m CIty Hall, 3rd floor, 112 South Osceola Ave, Clearwater, Flonda, to consider the following requests: NOTE: All persons wishin!! to address an item need to be present at the BEGINNING of the meetin!!. Those cases that are not contested bv the applicant. staff. nei!!hborin!! property owners. etc. will be placed on a consent a!!enda and approved bv a sin!!le vote at the be!!innin!! of the meetin!!. 1 Jerrv and Teresa Tas are requestmg FlexIble Development approval to permIt 17 attached dwelhngs wIthm the Tounst (T) DIstnct wIth an mcrease to bUIldmg ht from 35 ft to 78 ft (to roof deck) wIth an addItIonal 14 ft for archItectural embellIshments (from roof deck), a reductIon to the front (north) setback from 15 ft to zero ft (to pavement) and a reductIOn to the mImmum lot wIdth from 100 ft to 675ft along Coronado Dr and to 71 64 ft along Harnden Dr as part of a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project, under the provIsIOns of Sec 2-803 C (Proposed Use: Attached dwellmgs) at 342 Hamden Dr and 343 Coronado Dr, ColumbIa Sub No 2, Blk A, Lot 11 & part of Lot 10, and Columbia Sub No 3, Lot 7 and part of Lot 6 Assigned Planner: Robert G Tefft, Planner III. FLD2005-07066 2 Griffin International. Inc. IS requestmg FlexIble Development approval to perrmt AlcoholIc Beverage Sales m the CommercIal (C) DIstnct on a parcel of land contIguous to a parcel of land whIch IS desIgnated as resIdentIal m the Zomng Atlas as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project per Sec 2-704 C (Proposed Use: AlcoholIc Beverage Sales) at 1575 Hi!!hland Ave S, Sec 23-29-15, M&B 34 03 Assigned Planner: Robert G Tefft, Planner III. FLD2005-08082 3 Beach & Gulf Sands. Inc. and North Clearwater Beach Development. LLC (Anthony Menna) are requestmg 1) TermmatIon of Status of NonconformIty for densIty (11 eXIstmg attached dwellIng umts to remam where a maXImum of 10 attached dwellIng umts would be permItted under current Code), 2) Transfer of Development RIghts (TDR2005-03019) of 2 dwelhng umts from 116 Bnghtwater Dr under the provIsIOns of Secs 4-1402 and 4-1403, and 3) FleXIble Development approval to permIt 13 attached dwelhng umts m the TOurISt (T) DIStnCt wIth an mcrease to ht from 35 ft to 5966 ft (to roof deck) wIth an addItIonal 42 mches for penmeter parapets (from roof deck), a reductIon to the front (north) setback from 15 ft to 2 ft (to pavement), a reductIOn to the SIde (east) setback from 10 ft to zero ft (to pool deck), a reductIon to the SIde (west) setback from 10 ft to 1.5 ft (to pavement), a reductIon to the rear (south) setback from 20 ft to 10ft (to bUIldmg) and zero ft (to pool deck), and to allow 5 parkmg spaces to encroach wIthm the reqUIred SIght VISIbIlIty tnangles along Bay Esplanade as part of a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project under the prOVISIons of Sec 2-803 C. (Proposed Use: Attached Dwellmgs) at 657 & 663 Bav Esplanade, Mandalay Umt No 5 Replat Blk 77, Lots 4-5 Assigned Planner: Robert G Tefft, Planner III. FLD2005-08087 4 400 Cleveland. LLC. Mainstreet Clearwater Development. and Whtbuff. Ine (TH Management, LLC, Laura Street Development, LLC) are requestmg FleXIble Development approval to permIt a mIxed-use development m the Downtown (D) DIstnct wIth 245 attached dwellIng umts (WhICh mcludes an Illcrease III densIty of 36 dwelhng umts from the Clearwater Downtown Redevelopment Plan PublIc AmemtIes IncentIve Pool) and 186,300 sq ft of non- resIdentIal floor area (restaurant, retail/movIe theater, and eXIstmg office), an mcrease m the . ) . perrmtted heIght from 30 ft to 380 ft (to roof deck) wIth an addItional 27 ft for archItectural embellIshments as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment ProJect, under the provIsIOns of Sec 2- 903 C [Proposed Use: MIxed-Use (245 attached dwellIngs, 98,500 sq ft retaIl/restaurant/movIe theatre, and 87,800 sq ft office)] at 400. 410. 418. & 420 Cleveland St and 416 Laura St, Sec 16-29-15, M&B 12-03, Earl & Tate's Sub Lots 1,3,5,7,9-10, 19-21 and part of lots 2, 4,6,8, 11, 17, & 18 Assigned Planner: Robert G Tefft, Planner III. FLD2005-08084 5 Ronald E & Karen L Kozan (NewkIrk Ventures Inc) are requestIng a FlexIble Development approval to permIt the addItIon of a pool to a preVIOusly approved attached dwellIng project (FLD2005-05045, approved August 16,2005) In the MedIUm HIgh DensIty ResIdentIal (MHDR) Dlstnct WIth a reductIon to the rear (east) setback from 15 ft to zero ft (to pool deck), as a ResIdentIal Infill ProJect, under the provIsIOns of Sec 2-404 F [Proposed Use: Attached dwelhngs (26 cOndOmInIUms) WIth pool] at 405 Island Way, Island Estates of Clearwater, Umt 2, Lot 15 & S Y2 of Lot 16 Assigned Planner: Wayne M Wells, AICP, Planner III. FLD2005- 08086 6 Dam Devon LLC (City of Clearwater) are requestIng a FleXIble Development approval to permIt a parkIng lot In the Tounst (T) Dlstnct WIth a reductIOn to mlmmum lot area from 20,000 sq ft to 16,500 sq ft, a reductIOn to the front (north along Devon Dr/FIrSt Ave) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to pavement) and a reductIOn to the front (east along Harnden Dr) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to pavement), as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment ProJect, under the prOVlSlons of Sec 2-803 C (Proposed Use: Pubhc parkIng lot for 25 parkIng spaces) at 41 Devon Dr, ColumbIa Sub, Blk B, E Yz of Lot 1 Assigned Planner: Wayne M Wells, AlCP, Planner III. FLD2005-08089 7. Peter Pan Develooments LLC (PanaYIOtIS VasIloudes, Petnt MerolI, Somerset COndOmInIUm) are requestmg a FleXIble Development approval to permIt 8 attached dwellmgs m the MedIUm HIgh DensIty ResIdentIal (MHDR) Dlstnct WIth a reductIon to the rmmmum lot area from 15,000 sq ft to 13,087 sq ft, reductIOns to the rmmmum lot WIdth from 150 ft to 120 ft along Bay Esplanade and from 150 ft to 110 ft along Somerset St, a reductIOn to the front (west) setback from 25 ft to 22 ft (to water feature), reductIons to the front (south) setback from 25 ft to 11 ft (to bUIldmg and pavement) and from 25 ft to zero ft (to trash stagIng area), a reductIOn to the SIde (north) setback from 10 ft to 31ft (to pavement), a reduction to the SIde (east) setback from 10ft to zero ft (to pool deck), an Increase to buIldmg ht from 30 ft to 46 83 ft (to roof deck) WIth an addItIonal 4 17 ft for penmeter parapets (from roof deck) and to permIt the bUIldmg wlthm the VISIbIlIty tnangles, as a ReSIdentIal Infill ProJect, under the prOVISIOns of Sec 2-404 F, and a reductton to the landscape buffer along Bay Esplanade from 5 ft to 3 ft (for the retentIOn pond plantmg area), a reduction to the landscape buffer along Somerset St from 10ft to zero ft (to trash stagmg area) and a reductIon to the landscape buffer along the north property lIne from 10 ft to 31ft (to pavement), as a ComprehensIve Landscape Plan, under the prOVISIOns of Sec 3-1202 G [Proposed Use: Attached dwellIngs (8 condommIUms)] at 693-699 Bav Esolanade, Mandalay Umt No 5 Replat, Blk 76 & unplatted Blk 76 Assigned Planner: Wayne M Wells, AlCP, Planner III. FLD2005-08090 8 Peter Pan Develooment LLC & Eoic Holdin!!s South LLC (Bay Esplanade COndOmInIUm) are requestmg a fleXIble Development approval to permIt 8 attached dwellmgs m the Tounst (T) DIStrIct WIth a reductIOn to the front (west) setback from 15 ft to 13 ft (to water feature), reductIOns to the front (north) setback along Somerset St from 15 ft to 1267 ft (to bUIldmg), from 15 ft to 9 83 ft (to pavement) and from 15 ft to zero ft (to trash stagmg area), a reductIon to the SIde (east) setback from 10 ft to zero ft (to pool deck), an Increase to bUIldIng heIght from 35 ft to . l 46 83 ft (to roof deck) wIth an addItIonal 4 17 ft for perImeter parapets (from roof deck) and to permIt the bUIldmg wIthm the vlSlbIhty trIangles, under the prOVlSlons of Sec 2-803 B [Proposed Use: Attached dwellmgs (8 condommIUms)] at 685-689 Bav Esplanade, Mandalay Umt No 5 Replat Blk 77, Lots 12-13, & part of Lot 11 Assigned Planner: Wayne M Wells, AICP, Planner III. FLD2005-08088 9 Javcee Roth IS requestmg an appeal of an admImstratIve determmatIon denymg the abIlIty to apply for an AnImal Boardmg FaCIlIty use as a ComprehenSIve Infill Redevelopment Project m the Downtown East Gateway CharactehULshiLc1~%>iL~~~-:,;~Vf_-(rrqpos~d Use: AnImal Boardmg Use) at 1242 Cleveland ~<tge~~~6~6ft3"- -&-paf'ts-of-lJoti 2' 8Pf." 3~!~ed Plannem~~~~Q~~t=!i - -- Interested partIes may appear and be heard at the hearIng or file wntten notIce of approval or ObjectIOn WIth the Planmng DIrector or CIty Clerk prIor to the hearIng Any person who deCIdes to appeal any declSlon made by the Board or CouncIl, WIth respect to any matter conSIdered at such hearIngs, wIll need to request a record of the proceedmgs and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatIm record of the proceedmgs IS made, whIch record mcludes the testImony and eVIdence upon whIch the appeal IS to be based per flOrIda Statute 2860105 Commumty Development Code Sec 4-206 states that party status shall be granted by the Board m quaSI-JudICIal cases If the person requestmg such status demonstrates that s/he IS substantIally affected Party status entItles partIes to personally testIfy, present eVIdence, argument and WItnesses, cross-examIne WItnesses, appeal the deCISIon and speak on reconSIderatIon requests, and needs to be requested and obtamed dunng the case dISCUSSIon before the CDB --------., J ---J An oath WIll be admInIstered SwearIng m all persons gIvmg testImony m quaSI-JudICIal publIc hearIng cases If you WIsh to speak at the meetmg, please WaIt to be recognIzed, then state and spell your name and prOVIde your address Persons WIthout party status speakmg before the CDB shall be lImIted to three mInutes unless an mdIvIdual IS representmg a group m whIch case the ChaIrperson may authOrIze a reasonable amount of tIme up to 10 mmutes FIVe days prIor to the meetmg, staff reports and recommendatIOns on the above requests WIll be aVaIlable for reVIew by mterested partIes between the hours of 830 a m and 4'30 pm., weekdays, at the CIty of Clearwater, Plannmg Department, 100 S Myrtle Ave, Clearwater, FL 33756 Please contact the case presenter, at 562-4567 to dISCUSS any questIOns or concerns about the project and/or to better understand the proposal and reVIew the SIte plan MIchael Delk Planmng DIrector CynthIa E Goudeau, CMC CIty Clerk CIty of Clearwater POBox 4748, Clearwater, FL 33758-4748 NOTE ApplIcant or representatIve must be present at the hearIng A COPY OF TillS AD IN LARGE PRINT IS AVAILABLE IN OFFICIAL RECORDS AND LEGISLATIVE SERVICES. ANY PERSON WITH A DISABILITY REOUlRING REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN TillS MEETING SHOULD CALL (727) 562-4093 WITH THEIR REOUEST. Ad 10/30/05 , /cJ.'I~ ~P200F-f)0002 -147 . 109 KENvVOOD AVE TRUST 411 CLEVELAND ST# 182 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4004 ADAMS, MICHAEL J TRE ADAMS, PAMELA G TRE 15 N MISSOURI AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4830 . jVS ANDEREGG, EARL E 7067 70TH ST N PINELLAS PARK FL 33781 - 3935 ANZELMO, VINCENZO ANZELMO, ANTONIA 2 CALABRIA CT WOODRIDGE ON L4H 1 G5 00030- CANADA ATANASOV, MILAN ATANASOV, MIRA 1361 VILLAGE VIEW RD RR#1 BRESLA V ON NOB 1 MO 00030- CANADA AUSTIN, THEA TRE AUSTIN FAMILY TRUST 4639 MOUNTAINGATE DR ROCKLIN CA 95765 - 5280 BAIDOO, PETER 116 JEFFERSON AVE N CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4949 BAKER, SABINA A KAUCHER, DAVID P 1221 DREW ST # D-6 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4927 BANKS, DAVID BANKS, ALISON 19 ST JOHNS RD EAST GRINSTEAD WEST SUSSEX RH193LG 00003- GREAT BRITAIN BARRON, RICHARD B PO BOX 1661 CLEARWATER FL 33757 - 1661 BAUERMANN, ELIZABETH L 1321 N SATURN AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 3666 BAUMGARDNER, WILLIAM D 1221 DREW ST # E6 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4928 BERA, W AL TER BERTSCHE, EUGENE BIANCO, PATRICIA L BERA, GENOWEFA BERTSCHE,MARY 4756 7TH ST NE 1221 DREW ST # C-12 1237 GROVE ST COLUMBIA HEIGHTS MN 55421 - CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4926 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4945 2221 BIERITZ, RICHARD BLANSKE, BERNARD BOGDANOV, DUSAN BIERITZ, ALICE BLANSKE, RITA L STANULOVA, ZORICA 1221 DREW ST # C7 1221 DREW ST # C11 PO BOX 43 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4926 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4926 CLEARWATER FL 33757 - 0043 BRANCATI, ALEXANDER BRANIGAN, NANCY JO BULA, RICHARD W BRANCATI, VICTORIA 959 EAST 13TH sa 1221 DREW ST # E4 166-14 CROSS ISL PKWY VERO BEACH FL 32960 - 2109 CLEARW A TER FL 33755 - 4923 WHITESTONE NY 11357 - 2941 BURKHART, JANICE CALDERON, MELCHOR CAMPAGNARO,ERNESTO 1221 DREW ST # A22 1221 DREW ST # A14 CAMPAGNARO,NATALlNA CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4996 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4915 3232 APRI L LN PALM HARBOR FL 34684 - 1642 CASTLEMAN, KENNETH R CASTREJON, LETICIA CENTER FAMILY LTD CASTLEMAN, ELIZABETH M CASTREJON, LORENZO 1744 N BELCHER RD # 200 404 N SHADOWBEND 101 S AURORA AVE CLEARWATER FL 33765 - 1305 FRIENDSWOOD TX 77546 - 3839 CLEARWATER FL 33765 - 3519 CENTER, JERRY H CHADDER, JOHN P CHAPLIN, PAUL D CENTER, JAMES H CHADDER, MARY E 1744 N BELCHER RD # 200 BLENHEIM STUDIO 1210 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33765 - 2699 LEWES RD CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4940 FOREST ROW SUSSEX RH185EZ 00003 GREAT BRITAIN . ; CHEN, SU-HUI CHEN, CHIAO 1221 DREW ST # 3-C CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4921 Clearwater Neighborhoods CoalitIon Doug Williams, President 2544 Frisco Drive Clearwater, FL 33761 CLEVELAND PLAZA L TO 1213 CLEVELAND ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4908 COLAIANNI, BARBARA M 1649 WILLOW WAY WOODSTOCK GA 30188 - 4649 COLLINS, CHERIE 1241 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4945 COWAN, WALLACE F 1221 DREW ST # 5-B CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4925 CYR, ROSE MARIE DESROCHERS, GESTION M INC CVETKOVSKI, BORIS 285 DE VIMY APP 406 2250 ZENIA DR 12407 GREENLEE WAY ST BRUNO TROY MI 48083 - 6130 RIVERVIEW FL 33569 - 6838 DE MONTARVILLE PO J3V 6J5 00030- CANADA DICKSON, PATRICK H DIONISOTIS, JIM DONZE,RENE DICKSON, LOIS M 1221 DREW ST # 22B SEESTR 26 990 9TH AVE NW CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4997 6375 BECUENRIED 00008- NEW BRIGHTON MN 55112 - 2600 SWITZERLAND DOUBLE 0 INVESTMENTS DREW RIDGE CO-OP ASSN INC DUNN, E M 25 2ND ST N # 210 1221 DREW ST DUNN, JEAN F ST PETERSBURG FL 33701 - 3362 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4904 PO BOX 13095 ST PETERSBURG FL 33733 - 3095 FERGUSON, DAVID B FIELD, DEREK B FAYOCAVITZ, WALTER PERKINS, ANTHONY 2828 ROCK DR 1221 DREW ST # A9 31 MILL WAY E CLARKS SUMMIT PA 18411 - 9646 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4929 GRINSTEAD SUSSEX RH194DD 00003- GREAT BRITAIN FRANCE, JOHN V FREEMAN, JERIL Y K GARBER, DONALD R FRANCE, ELIZABETH A 8927 ANGOFF DR GARBER,MARYCE 1629 CLEVELAND ST NEW PRT RCHY FL 34653 - 6740 1234 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 6102 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4942 GARRETT RICHMOND INC TRE GIFFORD, GORDON III GIOL, JUAN 1274 SEMINOLE ST GIFFORD, AMY J GIOL, MILAGROS 110 BETTY LN N 1221 DREW ST # 013 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4348 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4903 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4927 GIOVAGNOLl, BEATRICE L GODSCHALK, DIKLA ROSI GRIESHABER, GARY GODSCHALK, A Y A GRIESHABER, SHARON 1221 DREW ST # C14 1221 DREW ST # 02 RR 1 BOX 14 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4926 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4922 FALLS PA 18615 - 9706 GTE FLORIDA INC HADDAD, SIDNEY HANDA, NARINDER HADDAD, DAVID KATARIA, ROMESH PO BOX 152206 1221 DREW ST # A-13 1296 MOUMOUTH DR IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4915 BURLINGTON ON L7P 3J6 00030- CANADA HATCHELL, CHARLES 549 JACOBS MILL POND RD ELGIN SC 29045 - 9300 INSURANCE CENTER REALTY INC PO BOX 14757 CLEARWATER FL 33766 - 4757 Jaycee Roth 330 Duncan Loop E, #102 Dunedin, FL 34698 KAZNOWSKI, ROMAN KAZNOWSKI, ALEKSANDRA 1221 DREW ST # B14 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4939 KOUSARI, ATTA 0 1009 PEARCE DR CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 1100 LA SALA, GERALD J 34 CEDAR ST BUTLER NJ 07405 - 1329 LEWIS, NORMAN A 103 DUNNINGS RD E GRINSTEAD WEST SUSSEX RH 194AQ 00009- UNITED KINGDOM M N E K INC 1274 CLEVELAND ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4911 MAXA ENTERPRISES INC 1275 CLEVELAND ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4910 MELNIK, FEDOR 225 SW 146TH ST SEATTLE WA 98166 - 1913 HELLER, DANIEL M 14 N MARS AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 6225 INTEGRIDENT PRECISION DENTAL E 18 N JEFFERSON AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4947 JONES, AVIS C 103 N JEFFERSON AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4950 KELLY, RON 5-6476 HUGGINS ST NIAGRA FALLS L2J 1G9 00030- CANADA LOP A LLC 2840 WEST BAY DR # 335 BELLEAIR BLUFFS FL 33770 - 2620 LABRE, ROBERT GAGNON, HELEN 3220 BOUL CENTRAL QUEBEC PQ G1 P 39 00030- CANADA LOMAX, ERIC B TRE LOMAX, OLGA M TRE 1221 DREW ST # E7 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4928 M N E K INC 2076 SUNSET POINT RD APT 147 CLEARWATER FL 33765 - 1231 MC KENZIE, PATRICIA A 1221 DREW ST # A-3 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4924 METZLER ENTERPRISES INC 1212 CLEVELAND ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4907 . HUGHES, GARY A 1221 DREW ST # A16 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4915 JADE GROUP 830 ISLAND WAY CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 1825 KAKAR, ABDUL KAKAR, FARISHTA 4414 MAYFLOWER DR MISSISSAUGA ON L5R 188 00030- CANADA KIRKCALDIE, ANTHEA 109 N LINCOLN AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4958 LA MANNA, JOE LA MANNA, LENA 42 HEWLETT CRESCENT MARKHAM ON L3P 7J8 00030- CANADA LAWLER, R C INC PO BOX 7792 ST PETERSBURG FL 33734 - 7792 L YDA, ELEANORE F 147 BIRCHWOOD PASS CANTON GA 30114 - 7754 M N E K INC 2447 ISLANDER CT PALM HARBOR FL 34683 - 2608 MC PHERSON, RICHARD D MC PHERSON, SANDRA 4005 BA YSHORE RD CAPE MAY NJ 08204 - 4109 MONTROSE, WENDY S 7254 MITCHELL RD BROOKSVILLE FL 34601 - 5663 MRSIC, KATA 1221 DREW ST # A1 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4924 NIES, JOHN R 1218 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4942 PAPIESE, CARL PAPIESE, MONICA 1221 DREW ST # C10 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4921 POULIN, WILLIAM L 1250 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4946 PUGLlATTI, LUISELLA 14 AV DUMAS CH-1206 GENEVA 00008- SWITZERLAND REMARK, MARIANNE TRE 11513 STREAMVIEW AVE NW UNIONTOWN OH 44685 - 8214 ROBERTS, ANN 103 ROCKWOOD PARK ST HILL RD E GRINSTEAD SUSSEX RH19 4JX 00009 UNITED KINGDOM ROBSON, FRANK ROBSON, EMILY 1228 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4942 ROMERO, CIRO 1247 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4945 SCHILL, VINCENT L SCHILL, SHARON E 1221 DREW ST # C5 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4926 Ms Jaycee Roth 1242 Cleveland Street Clearwater, FL 33756 NORRIS, WAYNE J NORRIS, ANN L 64 ABBEY LN LEVITTOWN NY 11756 - 4009 PAUL, CHANDRA PAUL, OLDA B 1221 DREW ST # B13 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4939 POWER LEGAL ADVISORY INC 617-A CLEVELAND ST STE 2 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4190 RACCO, COSIMO RACCO, MARIA 2062 HEADON FOREST DR BURLINGTON ON L7M 2C7 00030- CANADA RENFROE FAMILY TRUST RENFROE, CLYDE E JR TRE 1221 DREW ST # B12 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4939 ROBINSON, CAROL C 1221 DREW ST # E2 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4923 ROMANO, ANTONIO ROMANO, MARIE 369 WHITMORE AVE TORONTO ON M6E 2N5 00030- CANADA SAVIO, TIMOTHY PO BOX 1117 CLEARWATER FL 33757 - 1117 SCHLOSSER,KARLJ 606 S BETTY LN # 5 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6052 . NEWMAN, EDWARD C NEWMAN, AUDREY L PO BOX 4073 CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4073 NOTARO, CATHERINE 1221 DREW ST # C2 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4921 PAULL, BONNIE 11755 RIVERVIEW DR ST LOUIS MO 63138 - 3610 PRETZLAFF,GUSTAV 1120 VILLAVIEW RD CLEVELAND OH 44119 - 2942 RANIERI, ANTONIO RANIERI, ANTONETTA 4 LARK PATH LIVERPOOL NY 13090 - 2924 RMS FAMILY RESTAURANTS INC 9400 S DADELAND BLVD STE 720 MIAMI FL 33156 - 2844 ROBSON, FRANCIS 0 ROBSON, EMILY A 1225 GROVE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4943 ROMEO, PASQUALE ROMEO, CARMELA 388 AVENUE RD CAMBRIDGE ON N1 R 5S4 00030- CANADA SAWYER, BEATRICE P 1221 DREW ST # C-9 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4921 SECCHIARI, W RICHARD 111 N LINCOLN AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4958 SEMBLER E D P PTR # 13 L TD 5858 CENTRAL AVE ST PETERSBURG FL 33707 - 1728 SHERMAN, PHILLIP SHERMAN, VIRGINIA 2409 UNITY AVE N GOLDEN VALLEY MN 55422 - 3449 SMITH, HAROLD D NEWELL, EUNICE P 1875 PIERCY DR AKRIN OH 44312 - 5440 Todd Pressman 28870 U S Highway 19 North, #300 Clearwater, FL 33761 TZEKAS, RAIM TZEKAS, XHEZIJE 255 BAYSIDE DR CLEARWATER FL 33767 - 2504 VASH, JOHN G HUBER,HAZELI 1221 DREW ST # A10 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4929 WEBER, CLEMENT WEBER, JOAN 5716 W 15TH ST SIOUX FALLS SD 57106 - 0221 WOLKOWSKY, THOMAS C WOLKOWSKY, PATRICIA A 1450 MAPLE ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 5014 SHARP, STELLA A 1221 DREW ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4904 SIERRA, VIRGINIA 1221 DREW ST # A6 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4924 SMOUEVSKAYA-KHALMOV, GAUNA G KHALMOV, RAKHMAN N 1221 DREW ST # A2 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4924 TOLIN, ELMER J 2509 43RD ST NW CANTON OH 44709 - 2123 UGOLINI, MICHAEL D UGOLINI, BARBARA A 2839 N 2350TH RD SENECA IL 61360 - 9549 VILLANI, GIOVANNI 5 DENIS MONTREAL EAST PQ H1 B 5H4 00030 - CANADA WINDLE, LEIF G WINDLE, KATHLEEN M MILLWOOD LAKEVIEW RD FURNACE WOOD FELBRIDGE WEST SUSSEX RH19 2QE 00003- GREAT BRITAIN WYRWAS, KRYSTYNA WYRWAS, JAROSLAV HORAK 3636 1 03RD AVE N CLEARWATER FL 33762 - 5472 . SHARRON, ANNA C R PO BOX 905 L1NDALE TX 75771 - 0905 SIMMONS, FRANCIS E 1267 PARK ST CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 5827 SNEDEKER, CLIFFORD E SNEDEKER, DEANNA L 100 N MISSOURI AVE CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4862 TSAMBIS, CHARLES TSAMBIS, JEAN 1221 DREW ST # B-1 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4925 VASCONI, SHIRLEY L 2493 ALHAMBRA CT CLEARWATER FL 33761 - 2624 WALDNER, MONIKA 1472 BYRAM DR CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 1504 WOLFF, TARA 64 YAIR ST RAMAT-GAN 52243 - 0001 ISRAEL ZUCCARO,ANNETTE 30 CALABRIA CT WOODBRIDGE ON L4H 1 G5 00030- CANADA