APP2005-00001
APP2005-00001
3280 MCMULLEN BOOTH RD
EILAND, DOUGLAS & SIRNA,
PLANNER OF RECORD: NOT ENTERED
ATLAS # 190A
ZONING: LDR
LAND USE: RS
RECEIVED: 05/31/2005
INCOMPLETE:
COMPLETE:
MAPS:
PHOTOS:
STAFF REPORT:
DRC:
CDB:
CL W CoverSheet
FROM .Clt~OfClearwater-Plan De"
FRX NO :727 562 4865
3~ 20 2005 11:19RM Pi
; Oearwater
o~~~
"'F>".J"~.,,~/
Planning Department
1 00 South Myrtfa Avenue
CIMrwater, Florida 33758
Tel8phone 127-582-4567
FlOC 727-.562--4576
CASE t#: !
DATE RECEIVED.
RECEIVED BY (staff initials)'
tJ SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED ~ND NOTM!ZfD APPLICATION
o SUBMIT 12 COPIES OF THE QRIGINAL APPLICATION
o APPEAL TO THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD. RESIDENTIAL $100.00
[J APPEAL TO lltE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD - NON.-RESIDENTIAl $250 00
EI APPEAL To HEARING OFFICER $500 00
APPEAL APPLICATION
l.Qvl,IOne II/Id I.evd Two ReviuwR (Revmcd 0:;1127104)
-
-
-PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT....
APPLICATION/NOTICE OF APPEAL (COde Section 4-S02.A & 8)
Section 4602.A An ~I of .. I.Bvel One approval (Fl8Jdble St8nl:lW Oev8Iapment) may be inltlllted by II property owner lIbutllng the properly which Is
the GUbjact of 1M approlllll within 88Wln days of the date the ~lopment Order iliIlSSUId. Th8 filing of an ~ of aPJ'JIIIII .8 SbIy the
lIft'ec:t of the decillion pending the llnel CIlIlIlrmlnatlon of the CIII8 Th8 hIIIrlng before the Communlly ~ Boani 8hIIn be GCIl8duled 8f the first
8'VllllllbIe rne8ting of the Board (9Ufl'IcIent to pnMde notice IJIlder SectIon 4-206) and may be continlMd at that meetl~ of the Boani $0 that the Boatv,t may
NIetIlI/e IIlOftt Informatlon. darlblkm, or~. ThB Commuhlly Developl'rlllnt Bo8rd shall render iii decision at the l'tlIIIIIlng but not Illter than 70_
Iiun the IeCeipt of the noIR of appeal. un1e8s the partkI$ by mutuel consent exl&nd the lim& I'nIme lOt the Boenrs decf&ion unlII a ~ meeting.
s.::tton 4-502.B An ~ of appeeI of ~ of any c:IecIaIon of the City. .. providIId In SectiOn 4<<J1, may be indlUad by the applicant or
rmy per8Ol'l gnlnted party status lIWlthln 14. of the decision Such appllr;allgn Gh811 be tiled WIth the City CIefk in . l'ann epfKllfjIId by lhtiI CIll"lllYlWlity
~ Coordinator 1denII~ wllh 8puci1kllty the brIele for the IIppe&I and IICCOmpanllld by a t8B . requlnKI by s.ctlon 4202 E. The flUng of In
appllcldian1notice at eppllill shalISl8y_ IIfrec:t Of the declGion pllnCllng the nnal del&rmlndon Of Ih8 ...
A. APPELlANT AND AGENT INFORMATIOt4:
APPELLANT NAME. T)rl1 'IE 1 fll=: J. W~i 1 anct and Elizabeth C. Sirna
MAIUNGADDRESS 3273 Landmark Drive; Clearwater, FL 33761
PHONE NUMBER. 727-772-0085 FAx NUMBER. 727-772-0095
AGENT NAME: Alan S. Zirrrret - Zirrrret, Unice, Salzman & Heyman, P.A.
MAIUNG ADDRESS
P.O. Box 15309; Clearwater, FL 33766
PHONE NUMBER' ~ 727-721-1772
FAX NUMBER 727-723-1421
B. APPEAL INFORMATION
CHECK THE SPECIFIC APPEAL.
~ tq fflfJ Community D8ve1oDmBnt BOIIf!J
~ Ordn, I1IqUlremEll'll$, decI8ions or detmninatlons made by an
admlnllllndtYe officIllln the adrnlnlstrallon of 1h1l Community
Development COde, GXCeJll for ~ actlonG
IJ AdrninIstratlve tnIefpmlallons of the Conununlty Development
Coc(e
Cl l8\fl!ll One (Flelclble SlBnderd DIlV'lfClpment tlnd Minimum
standard) approval decisions
[J Derullls of any permit Of license lGGUed under the pl'ollllllons of
thll Community Development Code
lJ Any denlahi dllllmed to have 0CCU1nId as result Of1tnt fellure of
the Community 0ev8i0pment Coordlnator 10 act wlthln th8llme
limo JBUIIlded In thI& Communlly D~oprnenr Gode
FROM 'Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dc
FAX NO .727 562 4865
'a~ 2121 21211215 11: 2121AM P2
Appeals to Q hBSnnf} officer
Ql Deelafon& of the Commllnfty Oev@loprnem Board "-gardll1g level Two approvals
lJ Daclslons of tl'le Community Dev@lopment Board regarding ll9VEd One approvals
Q OTHER (as allowed by Cod@)
ADDRESS OF SUBJECT APPEAL (If applioable) 1280 Mct1i;J.l,.leD J3QQtl:l, .E9C!~
SPECIFIC CASE NUMBER TO BE APPEALED (lfappllcabte). FLD200S-01014
OATE OF DECISION.
5-17-05
C. BASIS OF APPEAL:
explain In detail the basis for the apPltill Use additional sheets it necassary
1. The decision is not in harnDny with the general intent and purpose of this
develoRrrent code.
2. The developrent is inconsistent with the corrmmity character of the i.n'm2diate
vicinity.
3. The developrrent will sigt'lificantll negatively impair the value of the i.nm=diate
vicinity.
4. The decision is detrirrental tQ_1:;.b? ,:e3:P.!:~c health, safety and general welfare.
5. The decisiQU of the carrmmity developrent board cannot be sustained by the
eviggnce before tRe board. and the decision of' the board' departs from the
essentia~ reqJ'; rerrents of law.
D. SIGNATURE~
l. the und8rs19ned, acknowledge that an repre$$ntations made in thl&
application are true and accuratll to \tn, baat of my knowledge
STATE Of: PLORlDA, COUNTY OF PINELLAs
Sworn to and $ub8crlbed before me Ihlll ~ day of
May AD 20-05 to me end/or by
MllFl S. Z~t- . Who is persc",aJly known has produced
as Identification.
PI/oat/1m FomI6'd8Vfllopmflfl! f9VfeWlAppeaf Application 2002 doe
~~., ~~ MY COMMISSION II DO 340387
. . ~~ EXPIRES Augus120, 2008
. . Bandfd 1l1ru Notary N1Ic lJncleIWIllels
II
':::B j[I I t ~I~ F'EF'I]F'T
Jun. 02 2005 09:10AM
YOUR LOGO
YOUR FAX NO
Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept
727 562 4865
NO. OTHER FACSIMILE
01 95624086
START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT
Jun. 02 09:08AM 01'34 SND 02 OK
TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MENU' #04.
~ SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'.
FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HB...P-FAX (435-7329).
~~
1
'::,Et III I t jCJ F.'EF'CiF.'T
Jun. 01 2005 09:32RM
YOUR LOGO
YOUR FRX NO.
Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept
727 562 4865
NO. OTHER FRCSIMILE
01 4021
STRRT TIME USRGE TIME MODE PRGES RESULT
Jun.01 09:31RM 01'15 SND 02 OK
TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MENU' 1*04. -p, ^..... ~ C"' " 0 \.
THEN SEl.ECT OFF BY US,'''' '+' rn '-'. ~ \..J.o C<..'~ ~ d---^
FOR FRX RDVANTRGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HELP-FRX (435-7329).
Jul ~5 05 02:19p
v' _c"
Clt~ Attorne~
7275624021
p. 1
,(\ \ '-"
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
,
I
I
I
I
, I
ARGUMEN-rL
DOUGLAS J. WEILAND and )
ELIZABETH C. SIRNA, )
)
Petltloners, )
)
vs. )
)
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD, )
CITY OF CLEARWATER and )
SPINECARE PROPERTIES~ LLC, )
)
Respondents. )
)
Case
NOTICE OF ORAL
No,.-- 05-.2265
if" ~(C~~w~
o I-~"=-l
: Jll-5~
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT
SERVICES
CI"l' OF CLEARWATER
Oral Argument wlll be held ln t01S case at the Clty Hall,
Counsel Chambers, 112 South Osceola ~venue, Clearwater, Florlda,
on July 29, 2005, at 1:00 p.m., or as soon thereafter as can be
heard. Contlnuances wlll be granted only by order of the
Admlnlstrative Law Judge for good cause shown.
,
ISSUE: As stated ln Appeal Appllcatlon.
AUTHORITY: Sectlon 4-505 Clty of Clearwater, Communlty
Development Code.
All partles have the rlght to present oral argument.
Fallure to appear at thlS hearlng may be grounds for entry of a
recommended order of rlisffilssal.
-.-----
Phone II ,
Fax II
lC-
Fax # tJ:" J
i::,
Ju~ ,05 05 02: 19p
./ 'l
Clt... Attorne~
7275624021
p.2
The Agency shall be respons1ble for making arrangements for
the court reporter.
July 1, 2005
aA./.~a~
CHARLES A. STAMPELOS
Admlnistrat1ve Law Judge
D1V1Sio~ of Admlnistratlve Hearlngs
The DeSoto Build1ng
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Flor1da 32399-3060
(8S0) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675
Fax F1l1ng (850) 921-6847
www.doah.state.fl.us
COPIES FURNISHED:
Leslie K. Dougall-Sides, Esqulre
City of Clearwater
Post Offlce Box 4748
Clearwater, Florida 33758-4748
David A. Therlaque, Esqulre
Davld A. Ther1aque, P.A.
1114 East Park Avenue
Tallahassee, Flor1da 32301-2651
Alan S. Zimmet, Esqulre
Zlmmet, Unice, Salzman, Heyman & Jardlne, P.A.
Post Office Box 15309
Clearwater, Florlda 33766
Gina Grlmes, Esqulre
Hill Ward & Henderson
3700 Bank of America Plaza
101 East Kennedy Boulevard
Tampa, Florida 33602-5195
In accordance w1th the Amerlcans wlth Disabl11t1es Act, persons
needlng a speclal accornmodatlon to part1clpate 1n this
proceed1ng should contact the Judge's secretary no later than
seven days prlor to the hear1ng. The Judge's secretary may be
contacted at the address or telephone numbers above, V1a 1-800-
955-8771 (TDD), or 1-800-955-8770 (Volce) Florlda Relay Servlce.
2