The URL can be used to link to this page

APP2004-00006 APP2004-00006 1310 CLEVELAND ST MANAL OIL, INC PLANNER OF RECORD: ATLAS # 287B ZONING: C LAND USE: CG ww RECEIVED: 09/24/2004 INCOMPLETE: COMPLETE: MAPS: PHOTOS: STAFF REPORT: DRC: CDB: ." CLWCoverSheet "RIGtNAL Plannmg Department 100 South Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, Florida 33756 Telephone. 727-562-4567 Fax-727-562-4576 (' ~ Clearwater o~ ~ <., APPEAL APPLICATIO Level One and Level Two Reviews (Revmed 02/27/04) , 0) [E (C [E ~ W [E rr.:),,' =l~ " ! Ll ~I:P /. 7 2004 l" ~ ~"Vj,,' I a SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED AND NOTARIZED APPLICATION I a SUBMIT 12 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION ~PEAl TO THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD - RESIDENTIAL $100 00 APPEAL TO THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD - NON-RESIDENT~ ~ a PPEAl TO HEARING OFFICER $500 00 PLANNING & CEVELOPMEN1 SERVICES CITY OF CLE/,RWATER -PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT- APPLlCATIONlNOTICE OF APPEAL (Code Section U02.A & B) Secbon 4-502 A An appeal of a level One approval (Flexible standard Development) may be m1bated by a property owner abutbng the property which IS the subject of the approval withm seven days of the date the Development Order IS ISSUed The filing of an appIJcabon/notI of appeal shall stJJy the effect of the decision pending the finaJ detennmabon of the case The heanng before the Commumty DeveJopment Board shall be scheduled at the first available meeting of the Board (sufficient to provide notice under Secbon 4-2(6) and may be contmued at that meeting of the Board so that the Board may receIVe more Information, clanficabon, or research The Community Development Board shall render a decISIon at the meeting but not later than 70 days from the receipt of the nobce of appeal, unless the partles by mutual consent extend the bme frame for the Board's decision unbl a subsequent meeting Secbon 4-502 B An appIlCat1on1nobce of appeal of appeal of any decISIon of the City, as provided In Secbon 4-501, may be Initiated by the applICant or any person granted party status wlltlln 14 days of the decision Such appIicabon shall be filed with the City Clerk In a form specified by the Community Development Coordmator identifying with specdicdy the basis for the appeal and accompamed by a fee as reqUired by Secbon 4-202 E The filmg of an appIlcabonInobc of appeal shall stJJy the effect of the decISIon pending the final detennlnabon of the case A. APPELLANT AND AGENT INFORMATION: APPELLANT NA~E MHJM,; 0\ L... I Nt. . .. J MAILING ADDRESS ',\310 c L.J::.VIZ--L.P-JO ~. CL~ \-...J~) fl... ~ 315G PHONE NUMBER ~ fft . a:? 2. -z, FAX NUMBER 1 ~3. 30'1 1 AGENTNAME .Y~ ~t:IA1'!-S ~~I~t!.r5/1~. MAILING ADDRESS 1+1,( WUf2.T~. ?c.J/712 0; t:L.G.M..\\/A.~ I FL "3315ft:, PHONE NUMBER +M. 10 'Z.l FAX NUMBER 44 1. ? -3 3~ B. APPEAL INFORMATION CHECK THE SPECIFIC APPEAL ApDeaJs to the Commumty Deve/ooment Board a Orders, reqUIrements, decISIons or detennlnabonS made by an adrmmstratJve offictal m the adrmmstrabon of the Community . /Devetopmerll Code, except for enforcement acttons tI AdminIStratIve mterpretabons of the Community Development Code a level One (Flexible standard Development and Minimum Slandard) approval declstonS a Densals of any permll or IICeI1SEl ISSUed under the provISlOI'IS of the Community Development Code a Any denials deemed to have occurred as result of the failure of the Community Development Coordinator to act wlttlln the bme limits provided In thIS Community Development Code '. Appeals to a heanna officer Q DecisIOns of the Community Development Board regarding Level Two approvals Q DecisIOns of the Community Development Board regarding Level One approvals CJ OTHER (as allowed by Code) r' ADDRESS OF SUBJECT APPEAL (If applicable) _ \ I SPECIFIC CASE NUMBER TO BE APPEALED (If applicable) JI, A- . DATE OF DECISION C. BASIS OF APPEAL: Explain 10 detad the basIS for the appeal Use additional sheets If necessary I) To sj.p~r> 1l-le. CDN\I~t--!llUlc~ ~rz.[t Porzr~ L(),..J,L'I l)~ ~ ~1~111J6i ~f-..lveNI J:;I'J~{:. ~~e / ~"1~'5c!)L'''-lc 'DISf'P;;.J~,NGs OPlll2.,6c-l'D"-J ' 11ti- ~PANS'o,.J \-JIlL ~ 1D ~f-4~ A r-Jfl"" ~N\fe,,,.hE.N~t= ~ t?v\L..-Or...Jl1 o? AP(2JU'~. I,':b 10 ~, ,.JHaf!.fl \11'1 f-J'J~ e~. 1$ ;0"2 ~ fo-Jo NODrf1~AL- f\J~P-::' WIL.L. ~~ IN~'jALL Ei!D} ~o N~" LhJD ~/,.JGy MD ?~N5 :,"ILL (3{! 1N~i:!Q D. SIGNA lURE: STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF P1NELLAS .. ~J.," ~ .."""'... ...... me th. U day of I en, ,A D 20 0 '-f to me and/or by S Iv Vl .v I e.T , who ~rsonally kiiiWii has produced as Identification I, the undersigned, acknowledge that all representations made In thiS application are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge J iAA M- Lr-~""f Notary publiC, / My commISSion expires S \Planning De ........--- I Ap~/lcat/on 2002 doc \ , ~ ) f iI' i 1 ! II 7 ,/ I" SEP L 2004 L2 \ PL^NNI~~G &. ["'C:'vELOPMEN1 \ SEfl,\llrE~ CI""0' ore CI L, , 'NI\T'::o, J ORIGINAL 11"',,"'1'" .... 10. .J1o. "' : :11 '" .... 22 July 2004 - - - ~ .. "' Ms. Cyndi Tarapani Director of Planning City of Clearwater 1 00 S. Myrtle Ave. Clearwater, FI 33758 Re. Fast Track 011 1 31 0 Cleveland Street Case # FLD2004-05038 Dear Cyndl, As a follow up to our meeting of 7 July 2004, the owners wish to expand the convenience store portion only of the above referenced site. We understand that the existmg IS a non-conforming use and that we are requesting to expand the convenience store/retail portion only. Should you determine that all the eXisting uses are non-conforming, we can appeal this decision to the Community Development Board. Please keep in mind that we are requesting an expansion to the convenience/retail sales operation of the existing business only. Please find attached a check for $50.00, as requested and thank you for your attention to this matter. Please feel free to contact our office should you or your staff have any questions or comments. ORIGINAL [5llE~[E~wlE m\l lrJ ' SloP L7 2004 i J j I Ste en R. Fowler, AlA, NCARB SRF: mmf Cc: Nick Khelreddine PLANNING & OEVELOPMEN1 SERVICES CITY OF CLEARWATER : FOWLER ASSOCIATES ARCHITECTS, INC. ' , AAOO 1665 1421 COURT STREET ,CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 : 727-449-2021 ' , ORIGINAL ,.."111, t.'ClX.~LOF Tiff ", \\.~ \)"..,....,~;-- \ 1':. "." ~"--~';. ..\~" \ I J r; ";.. ",,, .... ~--......'.....- ~ - ...... .. :C"':>>: - - - ~'<t:; ....:;. ~ Q.. ....-.. ~\ ':..-?.L\"', ,.'r--........:i" --7Jf.""""'~~\' ',,)1TE~,. II. 'II~" CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT Posr OFFICE Box 4748, ClEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MLJ~IClPAI S~RVICl ~ BUilDING, 100 SOU I!I MYRIl E AVFNU"-, C1 "-ARWATFR, FlORIDA 33756 TEl FPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 Lo\c, RANG I PIAl\NIMJ Drvl LOI'MI1\ I RrVIL"W Stephen R Fowler, AlA, NCARB Fowler ASSOCiates Architects, Inc 1421 Court Street CleaIwatel, FL 33756 September 17,2004 o ~(c~~%7~ ro0 U SEP 272004 [1Vi Re FLD2004-05038, 1310 Cleveland Street, Fast Trac Oil Oem Mr Fowlel PLANNING & DEVELOP~ENl SERVICES CITY OF CLE,\RWATER '- The subject plOperty IS zoned Commercial (C) Dlstnct and IS consistent with ItS underlymg lar:d use deSIgnation of Commercial General (CG) Category The site had been developed as an automobile service statIOn 111 the past, was vacant for two to three years and was reopened m August 2002 On March 18, 2003, the Commul1lty Development Board approved a FleXible Development applicatIOn (FLD2003-0 1003) with five conditIOns to pe1l11lt the additIOn of a canopy over eXlstmg gas pumps and slgnage for an eXlst1l1g automobile service station with a reductIon 111 the front (south) setback from 25 feet to five feet (to canopy) and a reduction 111 the front (south) setback from five feet to zero feet (to sIgn), as part of a Comprehensive lnfill Redevelopment Project ThiS site IS located m the East Gateway DIStIlCt of the newly adopted Downtown Plan (effective upon adoptIon by the CountYWide Plannmg Authonty on February 3, 2004) Automobile serVIce stations are now listed as a prolllblted use wlth1l1 the East Gateway Dlstnct As such, the eXlstll1g automobile service statIOn IS now deemed a nonconfon11lng use You filed on May 26, 2004, on behalf of the property owner a request to expand the automobIle service station (FLD2004-05038) to pe1l11lt the addition of a second gas pump Island, expand the canopy and I elocate the I etaIl sales blllldlllg to the northeast comer of the property Conta1l1ed 111 our "mcomplete" letter 1'01 thiS new lequest IS the plOhlbltlon by Section 6-103 B of the Commul1lty Development Code (Code) of the expansIOn of nonconform1l1g uses AdditIOnally, Policy 11 of the new Downtown Plan state~ that the use of the Code tool known as "Ten11lnatlon of Status as a Nonconformity" IS not permitted wlthlll the Downtown Plan area You have now requested the ability to expand only the convel1lence store/retail sales bmldmg portIOn of the automobile service station The defil1ltlOn of "automobile servIce statlon" IS A IIlolIIohile .'JerVIU! .'JtallOI/ means ,my buIldmg, Stl UCtlll e, 01 lot used for the followmg dl ~pel1~1I1g, ~clIlI1g 01 0 tTCIlIlg fOl I etdIl sdlc gdsolll1e, h.closene, lulmcatll1g oil, or grease for the operation and mallltenance of automobiles ThiS may lI1clude buIld1l1gs or structures that are used fOl the I eta II sale and dll ect dell very to motor vehicles 0 f cigarettes, candy, soft dnnks and other llltlAN I Alfi\:(,,>I , II \\()H-( ()\I~Il"'j()I\I H 11m 1 II \\IIII(J\, VIl I IIIA\OH-('()M,\tI'>'lI<Jt\II( '\oIIlINI \ Ch\\, (<l\I\tI'>'>IOI\I H 11(\\h IIIIIB\HIJ, (()\I\tI,>,>I()!\I H * Bill ION'>()!\, (O\I\II,>,>l()I\I H "h211A1 !, MI'l OYMI N I AND AIIIRMA I IVI A( I ION LMI'I m I r~" September 17, 2004 Fowler - Page 2 related Items for the convel1lence of the motonng publIc, and may mclude facIlIties for lubncatmg, mmor repairs or vehicle service Such establIshments shall not include facIlIties for major vehicle service It IS staffs detenl1lnatlOn that the use of the property IS an automobile service station, and that the expansIOn of any portion of the use constitutes the expansIOn of the use PortIOns of the use cannot be separ <lted from the other portions of the use to get around the Code provIsIOns, In a reverse circumstance of where a parcel IS developed With a convel1lence store/retail sales use only (no gas pumps) and the owner wants to add gas pumps, the use of the parcel would change from "retail sales and services" to "automobile service statIOn," requmng compliance With all Code provIsions for tIns changed use of the parcel ThelefOle, sll1ce the Downtown Plan now prohibits the use, makmg the eXlStlng use d nonconfonmng use, and the Code prohibits the expansIOn of a nonconfomlmg use, the expansion of the convel11ence storelretall bUlldmg portion IS also prohibited Should you disagree With this detemlmatlOn, you may appeal this determl11atlOn to the Commumty Development Board 111 accordance With SectIOns 4-501 A and 4-502 A Such appeal must be filed With the Plannmg Department wlthl11 seven days of the date of this letter 1 . AdditIOnally, as of January 21, 1999, the City adopted the Commumty Development Code In the event a stl ucture 111 which a nonconfonnmg use IS located IS destroyed or damaged to the extent of less than 50 percent of the assessed value of such structure, the nonconforml11g use may be re-established If a complete and legally suffiCient application for all reqlllfed penl1lts to repair or restore IS submitted wlthll1 SIX months of the date of the damage In the event a structure 111 which a nonconformmg use IS located IS destJoyed or damaged to 50 percent or more of the assessed value, these structures may be repalIcd or restored only If the structure and the use confonns to the standards of thIS development code for the zonmg dlstnct 111 which It IS located Should you have additIOnal questions, please contact Wayne M Wells, AICP, Planner III, at 727-562- 4504 S/)~rn~ _./W ~t/lJ1U;HuL Cyndl H Tarapam, AICP Plannmg Director OR\G\NAL --:O-.~~~~~~lt fT .I) 'II <, II L \ SEP Z 1 2004 1.....:: " PLANr-JING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES CITY OF CLErlRWATER ~ \Plalllllllg Depart/llel/tlC D BlrLEXlll/w/IlpletelClcl'clalld 1310 Mal/al Ot! (C)IClcl'elaI/(I131 0 Leller Ie Expal/d Retat! PortlOll 9 17 04 doc '- O' (Q \J '- -o~ Q).Q '--u c: ::J () .a ...c +-> ::J -+-> () ,-tJ) o Z! x x ~ ~'~ ~ ~ >< ~ x X&~ x x X I~ X X~ ): x XX x X ~ Yo( X~ X x X >2'x ~ ~~ x0?'x It< X \( x >< Ni Xx X bl )t ~ ('x '-2 : 'lii )< ~ Xx .J. )< lil( ~ X)< xz.~ XX ~ X XN X XXxx ,'-0' ><x- ;< X xxx x ><>. ,x X x X . N> X ><.N s> ~ M2' ..... Disabled parbnS S1~. I Q) > ;:: 1 ~I ~ % ~ 2 ----t c " ~ :' I ".~ r 4'~; ~ ' . I I :, 1 I. \! \ I " l' (c') ~.' ~ (-..~; r o ibJ loP , h , ,.. --;;; I'-o'~ ~'>' t' L; ~J "\ ... \ \ \ 10' Setback Ltne ~O' ,4'-' (Side) \J- Dum~s~er end I :, I r ;""Llne of eXist I pavement I lit: b' Setbllck Line I ( Front ) - : ~ Io-EXI&t. Illndscape I I Ilrells to be : I expllnded I I I \ (:) I Q " (:) , 0- .... . --fk Clevelan_d Street -+ SIte Plan CR I I 0' 5' 10' 25' 50' North :I Cb ;z l '--- bJ. I '" I 9 I ~5l: ~r-.... Q) 9 ~ \ ~ ~ !!! IS'S tba Line - ~ E Q) A 0 ... '11'-0' Q) ~~ -u~ ~~ --- ~ ~ I ___L----""" I x", ~ I LUCI T.~~ ~ " , canopy ~ I b I ~ I l' .--- Cc: 0: S I 9 , , , ~Relbc:lIte eXist SIgn " , , '1" /" . l~ I , , , ,____________________J________________~ I (~ Line rJ :g~ trlmgle .J~- ~ 0 ~EXI&ttn9 drives to remain /' / PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES CITY OF CLEARWATER o ;0 - G> - Z )> I " '. " CLWCoverSheet ... ORIGINAL APP2004-00006 1310 CLEVELAND ST Date Received: 09/24/2004 MANAL OIL, INC ZONING DISTRICT: C LAND USE: CG ATLAS PAGE: 287B PLANNER OF RECORD: WW 1if1Dr..}T D ~ ~ ~ OF rltiJt~ \~~ . .." ~Q~~e(,7))~ ~~V.1 ~~~... ~~~' \ L '::.. ,,~ ;:~~~\. / \ \ ':.-.. ...=- - - ,_, ".-Iiil to""'" = .......1l1 ,..rC, l ==== ~~, ,",If" : ';. -=- ;:;:.~ ...~~+~- 1 ~-:, ~~~~"~~l ~~)1rH\'..-,.~ ~1J11l" CITY OF CLEARWATER LONG RANGE PlANNING DEVELOPMENT REvIEW PlANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, 100 SOUTH MYRTIE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 October 22, 2004 Mr Stephen R Fowler, AlA Fowler ASSOCIates ArchItects, Inc 1421 Court Street, SUite D Clearwater, FL 33756 RE Development Order regardmg case APP2004-00006 at 1310 Cleveland Street Dear Mr Fowler ThIS letter constitutes a Development Order pursuant to SectIOn 4-206 D 6 of the Commumty Development Code On October 19,2004, the Commumty Development Board (CDB) revIewed your applicatIOn appealing an admmlstratlve determmatlOn denymg the expansIOn of the retail sales portIOn (convemence store) of a nonconformmg automobIle servICe station, under the proVISIOns of Sections 4-501 A 2 and 4-503, for property located at 1310 Cleveland Street The Commumty Development Board DENIED the appeal applicatIOn because the appellant dId not show compliance WIth all of the followmg cntena 1) The deCISIOn appealed from mIsconstrued or mcorrectly mterpreted the provIsIOns of the Commumty Development Code, and 2) That the deCISIOn WIll be m harmony WIth the general mtent and purpose of the Commumty Development Code, and 3) Will not be detnmental to the publIc health, safety and general welfare The deCISIOn of the Commumty Development Coordmator of the letter Issued September 17, 2004, was confirmed by a maJonty of the members of the CDB Please be aware that an appeal of the CDB declSlon must be mltlated wlthm 14 days of the date of the deCISIOn by the Board The appeal penod for your case wIll expIre on November 3, 2004 If you have any questIOns, please do not heSItate to call Wayne M Wells, AICP, Planner III, at 727 -562-4504 CynthIa H Tarapam, AICP Plannmg DIrector S \Planl7lng Depm tmentlC D BIAPPEALSICleveland 1310 Manal 011 Ine Appeal (C) - DentedlCleveland 1310 Development Order doe BRIAN J AUNGST, MAYOR-COMMl~SIONER HoYT HAMIl TON, VICE MAYOR-COMMI'i~lONER WHITNEY GRAY, COMMI~~lONrR FRANK HIBBARD, COMMISSIONER * BIl I JON'iON, COMMI~SIONFR "EQUAl EM PI OYMrNT AND NTIRMA1 IV!: AC1 ION EMPIOYFR" ~(JJ{JJTQgU.8' ~o~~t~LOF 71/.......",.... A~!':.~.:..\ ~.,"'TflQQQ~.;-_ ..~ ~1' ;; //- ~..~ ,,1 I mM-_.......... I:l~",\ 1/ f/'jj -;.. ~'" t-.. 11,....... "" M ~ Q ,,~- - -'I "'.-':. =-=_ ~l:! "'~" -- ~I:) "'If":;' ==::::. ;;:. t:, ~~"'--- .,~~, ,. ~~~ .t \ -... ff.."I#""~'\;.." "#.,1I1E~,...t '~11I1l CITY OF CLEARWATER LONG RANGE PlANNING DEVELOPMENT REvIEW PlANNING DEPARTMENT POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FWRIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, 100 SOUTH MYRTIE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 September 27,2004 Mr Stephen R Fowler, AlA Fowler AssocIates ArchItects, Inc 1421 Court Street, SUIte D Clearwater, FL 33756 Re Commumty Development Board Meetmg (Case No APP2004-00006) Dear Mr Fowler The Appeal applIcatIOn (Case No APP2004-00006) appealmg an adnumstratlve determmatlon denYIng the expansIOn of the retall sales portIOn (convemence store) of a nonconformmg automobIle servIce statlon, under the provlSlons of SectIOns 4-501 A 2 and 4-503, for property located at 1310 Cleveland Street has been scheduled to be revIewed by the Commumty Development Board on October 19, 2004 The meetmg wIll take place at 2 00 pm m the CIty CouncIl Chambers, 3rd floor of CIty Hall at 112 S Osceola Avenue, Clearwater If you have any questlons, please do not heSItate to call me at 727-562-4504 Smcerely, /1~: w1J.: ~~ Planner III S IPlannll1g DepatlmentlC D B\FLEXlPendll1g eases I Up for the next CDBICleveland 1310 Manal Ot! fne Appeal (C) 101904 CDBICleveland 1310 CDB Letter doe BRIAN J AUNG'iT, MA, OR-COMMISSIONER HoYr HAMIlTON, VICE MAYOR-COMMI';';IONER WHITNEY GRAY, COM~m'loNFR FRANK HIBBARD, COMMISSIONER * BIll JONSON, COMMI,~IONl R "EQUAl EMPLOYMFNT AND AFHRMA1 IVI ACTION EMPI OYFR" FOWLER ASSOCIA TES ARCrlITECTS, INC. 1421 COURT STREET CLEARWA TER, FLORIDA 3315' (121)449-2021 AAOOI"5 PROJECT: Manal Orl, Inc. FILE NO.: I.l t Chrono. TO: City of Clearwater Budding Department 100 s. Myrtle Ave Clearwater, Fl 33l5~ ATTENTION: Sh~y COMM. NO.:04-21l DA TE: 21.Sept.04 WE TRANSMIT: ~Herewlth DUnder Separate Cover via. Din Accordance with Your Request I ,.---. ......- I - r- ':'''' II .--= ~" .. \-;1- '\' -- {-, '. \ , j, L-. .. ' _'"' , -1 1 I (I \! \[ -' I '\ ' \ \, ,I", I II I ' =-.::::'.1 L: ~ U \.., ---:..--: _ I! )\ I II \",- ,-- 11 i' I IJ ~ \ l \ ~t~ I.. 7 LuU4 \ ~ l -". /: \1 L:; I"~-/ I PL!\t'H';ING 8. r;-VElOPMErn SERVICES \ C\TY Or: Cll ,qWATEq 1_- OR\G\NAL THE FOLLOWING: DDrawlngs DShop DraWing Prints DSpeclflcatlons DShop DraWing Reproduclbles DChange Order DCertlfrcate for Payment DSamples ~Other: DProduct Literature DElectronlc Data COPIES DESCRIPTION DATE I Original 12 copies I Appeal Apphcatlon Appeal Apphcatlon Check for $250.00 21 Sept 04 21 Sept 04 21 Sept 04 ACTION: o Approval o ReView and Comment DUse and InformatIon VIA: ~Dlstrlbutlon to Parties o Record o For Signature DForwardlng as Noted DReturn to thIs OffIce o No Actlon Requrred DMal1 DPlck-up IZIDehver COPIES TO: NICk Khelreddtne wi copy BY: Stephen Fowler, AlA, NeARS REMARKS: Signed and Sealed ~ Clearwater FAX COVER MEMO CITY OF CLEARW A TER PLANNING DEPARTMENT 100' s. MYRTLE AVE., 2nd Floor CLEARWATER, FL 33756 (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865 TO: l>-t~~Yl -=t-D~ FAX: 4~1-5S~9 Phone: ~ FROM: ...::Pru>m~ ~ Phone: S~ - Lj. s 82-. DATE$EPT 2Lj~4 SUBJECT: fl PPEPrL APPI,Ufn oJ MESSAGE~ ?J~~ CorY1plet-e. -+-he 4PPgA- L ~~-t' Y) ~L2. O/';'~~~~j)+OLt?t: ::~~?;;ti!J~1ile:~;!!~~ ~ t,^nn-K you .:5h~ t""Yl J W An-: 1f\}S~ NUMBER OF PAGES (INCLUDING THIS PAGE) ~ '::B,m I ~ lei F'EF'[iF'T Sep 24 2004 02:44PM YOUR LOGO YOUR FAX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FACSIMILE 01 94475339 START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT Sep.2402:42PM 01'54 SND 03 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MENU' mM. THEN SB.ECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASS I STANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-80eHiB.P-FAX (435-7329). Watkins, Sherry From Sent To: Cc Subject: Tarapam, Cyndl Fnday, September 24, 2004 2 00 PM Gerlock, ChIp, Wells, Wayne Watkins, Sherry Fast Track 011 appeal I signed the letter to Fowler re Fast Track 011 I also called Steve Fowler and told hun that if he got the appeal ill by Tuesday that we would put hun on the Oct 19 heanng for the appeal Please followup as needed Thanks Cyndi Tarapam Planrung Dltector (727)562-4547 cyndt taraparu@MyClearwater com Nbrrluy ~ ~~ N~ VCf ~ Owt Qa11tf ~ 2001/1 ...; 0.00 rv A-pf ~ 1 ''-' ,. fI Wells, Wayne From Sent To Cc Subject \( Dougall-Sides, Leslie Fnday, November 05, 2004421 PM Tarapanl, Cyndl Gerlock, Chip, Wells, Wayne RE appeal filed by Manal 011 High Importance I agree that there does not seem to be an avenue for Heanng Officer appeal In these cases The applIcant may attempt to pursue an appropnate action In Circuit Court -----anginal Message----- From: Tarapanl, Cyndl Sent: Fnday, November 05/ 2004 4 00 PM To: Gerlock, Chip, Wells, Wayne Cc: Dougall-Sides, Leslie Subject: appeal filed by Manal 011 Wayne and I buefly dIscussed tills Item yesterday I do not see any authotlty 111 the code far an appeal af an mterpretatlOn Wayne and ChIp-please confllm wIth LeslIe (I bnefly dIscussed It WIth her on Thursday) and then return the appeal and check Tills should be done plOmptlY-Ie no latel than Monday, s1l1ce the applIcant's only chOlce IS CltCUlt cOUlt and theIe IS a t:lme flame on that as well Please let the attorney know by phone so he can make othet plans If he desltes, then lettet to follawup Thanks Cyndl T arapam Plann1l1g Dllectol (727)562-4547 cyndI talaparu@MyClearwatel com 1 / ~ CDB Meetmg Date Case Number Agenda Item Owner/Appellant RepresentatI ve Address October 19,2004 APP2004-00006 HI Manal 011, Inc Stephen R Fowler, AlA Fowler AssocIates ArchItects, Inc 1310 Cleveland Street ORiGINAL CITY OF CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT ST AFF SUMMARY OF EVENTS GENERAL INFORMATION: REQUEST: Appeal of an admImstratIve determmatIOn denymg the expanSIOn of the retaIl sales portIon ( convemence store) of a nonconformmg automobIle servIce statIOn, under the provIsIOns of SectIons 4- 501 A 2 and 4-503 BACKGROUND: ThIS 0 25-acre SIte IS located on the northeast comer of Cleveland Street and North Frednca Avenue ThIS comer lot presently contams a 312 square-foot, smgle-story commercIal bUIldmg, a fuelmg Island wIth two pumps and a canopy over the pumps Access IS presently prOVIded from two dnveways off of Cleveland Street and one dnveway from Fredenca Avenue The property IS zoned Commercial (C) DIstnct ThIS case IS an appeal of an admmIstratIve determmatIOn denymg the expanSIOn of the retaIl sales portIon (convemence store) of a nonconformmg automobIle servIce statIOn The SIte had been developed as an automobile servIce statIon m the past and was vacant for two to three years On May 7, 2002, a Development Order was Issued approvmg FleXIble Standard Development Case No FLS 02-01-02 to establIsh an automobIle servIce statIOn wIth two pump Islands The automobIle servIce statIon was reopened m August 2002 On March 18, 2003, the Commumty Development Board approved a FleXIble Development applIcatIOn (FLD2003-01003) WIth five condItIOns to permIt the addItIon of a canopy over eXIstmg gas pumps and sIgnage for an eXlstmg automobIle servIce statIon WIth a reductIon m the front (south) setback from 25 feet to five feet (to canopy) and a reductIon m the front (south) setback from five feet to zero feet (to SIgn), as part of a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project ThIS SIte IS located m the East Gateway Dlstnct of the newly adopted Downtown Plan (effectIve upon adoptIOn by the CountYWIde Planmng Authonty on February 3, 2004) AutomobIle servIce statIOns are now lIsted as a prohIbIted use wIthm the East Gateway DIstnct As such, the eXIstmg automobIle servIce statIOn IS now deemed a nonconformmg use Staff Report - CommunIty Development Board - October 19, 2004 - Case APP2004-00006 Page 10f3 /" The applIcant filed on May 26, 2004, on behalf of the property owner a request to expand the automobile service station (FLD2004-05038) to permIt the addItIOn of a second gas pump Island, expand the canopy and relocate and expand the retaIl sales bUIldmg to the northeast comer of the property Contamed m the "mcomplete" letter for thIS new request IS the prohIbItion by SectIOn 6-103 B of the Commumty Development Code (Code) of the expanSIOn of nonconformmg uses AddItionally, PolIcy 11 of the new Downtown Plan states that the use of the Code tool known as "TermmatIon of Status as a NonconformIty" IS not permItted wIthm the Downtown Plan area By letter dated September 17, 2004, the Commumty Development Coordmator Issued a letter determmmg that the use of the property IS an automoblle servIce statIOn, and that the expanSIOn of any portIOn of the use constItutes the expanSIOn of the use It IS thIS determmatIOn that the appellant IS appealmg APPEAL PROCESS: The appellants filed thIS appeal on September 24, 2004 SectIOn 4-501 A 2 of the Commumty Development Code states that the Commumty Development Board has the authonty to hear appeals from orders, reqUIrements, deCISIOns or determmatIOns made by an admmIstratIve offiCIal m the admmIstratIOn of the Commumty Development Code Section 4-502 A proVIdes that an appeal of an orders, reqUIrements, deCISIOns or determmatIOns made by an admmIstratIve offiCIal m the admmIstratIOn of the Commumty Development Code may be ImtIated wIthm seven days of the date of the order, reqUIrement, declSlon or determmatIon made by an admmIstratIve offiCIal Notice of the date of such meetmg shall be prOVIded the applIcant and the appellants by mall and by telephone Pursuant to SectIOn 4-504 B, the CDB shall reVIew the applIcatIOn, the recommendatIOn of the Commumty Development Coordmator, conduct a quaSI-JudIcIal publIc heanng on the applIcatIOn m accord WIth SectIOn 4-206 (notice and publIc heanngs) and render a deCISion m accordance WIth the proVISIons of SectIOn 4-206 D 5 grantmg the appeal, grantmg the appeal subject to speCified condItIOns or denymg the appeal Pursuant to Section 4-504 C of the Commumty Development Code, m order to grant an appeal, (overturnmg or modIfyIng the deCISIOn under appeal), the CDB shall find that, based on substantial competent eVIdence presented by the applIcant or other party, all of the followmg cntena are met 1) The deCISIOn appealed from mIsconstrued or mcorrectly mterpreted the proVISIOns of the Commumty Development Code, and 2) That the deCISIOn WIll be m harmony WIth the general mtent and purpose of the Commumty Development Code, and 3) Wlll not be detnmental to the publIc health, safety and general welfare Prepared by Planmng Department Staff Staff Report - Commumty Development Board - October 19,2004 - Case APP2004-00006 Page 2 of3 A TT ACHMENTS LocatIOn Map AerIal Photograph of SIte and VIcmIty Zonmg Atlas Map Surroundmg EXIstmg Uses Map Photographs of SIte and VICInIty ApplicatIon ExhIbIts A - F S IPlanl1lng DepmtmentlC D BIFLEXlPend/llg eases I Up for the next CDBICleveland 1310 Manal 011 fne Appeal (C) 101904 CDBICleveland 1310 Appeal Staff Report doc Staff Report - Commumty Development Board - October 19, 2004 - Case APP2004-00006 Page 3 of3 CASE NO. APP2004-00006 LIST OF EXHIBITS A Development Order for FLD2003-01003, dated March 19,2003 (two pages) B SIte Plan for FLD2003-01003 (one page) C Letter of DetermmatIOn, dated September 17, 2004 (two pages) D Excerpt of East Gateway DIstnct of the Downtown Plan (three pages) E Amemty Goal 3 and PolICies of Downtown Plan (two pages) F SectIOn 6-103 B of the Commumty Development Code (1 page) S IPlann/llg DepmtmentlC D B\FLEXiPendll1g caseslUpfor the next CDBICleveland 1310 Manal 011 Ine Appeal (C) 101904 CDBILlst of Exlllbtls doe CITY OF CLEARWATER POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, 100 SOUTH MYRTIE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756 TELEPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4865 PlANNING DEPARTMENT March 19,2003 Mr NIck Khelreddme Manal 011, Inc 1310 Cleveland Street Clearwater, FL 33755 RE' Development Order regardmg Case FLD2003-01003 at 1310 Cleveland Street (Manal OIl/Fast Trak) Dear Mr KheIreddme' ThIs letter constItutes a Development Order pursuant to SectIOn 4-206 D 6 of the Commumty Development Code On March 18, 2003, the Commumty Development Board revIewed your applIcatIOn for FleXIble Development approval to permit the addItIon of a canopy over existing gas pumps and sIgnage for an existmg automobIle servIce statIon WIth a reduction m the front (south) setback from 25 feet to five feet (to canopy) and a reductIOn m the front (south) setback from five feet to zero feet (to SIgn), as part of a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment ProJect, under the provIsions of SectIon 2-704 C. The proposal IS to construct a canopy over the eXIstmg gas pump Island and to construct sIgnage next to Cleveland Street. The Commumty Development Board (CDB) APPROVED the applIcation WIth the followmg bases and condItIons Bases for Approval' 1 The proposal comphes WIth the Flexible Development critena as a ComprehensIVe Infill Redevelopment Project per SectIOn 2-704 C. 2. The proposal IS m complIance WIth other standards m the Code mcluding the General ApplicabIhty Cntena per SectIon 3-913. 3 The development IS compatIble WIth the surroundmg area and WIll enhance other redevelopment efforts CondItIons of Approval 1 That the color of the canopy match the color of other SIte Improvements, as approved by Planmng Staff, 2 That the color of the freestandIng monument SIgn be approved by Plannmg staff pnor to Issuance of the SIgn permIt, be a maXImum of SIX feet In heIght and Include the SIte address, 3. That attached slgnage meet Code proVISIons; 4. That hghtmg under the canopy be contamed on-SIte through pOSItIonIng of the hghts or tlrrough cut-off fixurr~ to aVOId :~:l:~~~:::,:o::,~~,~mmg ~ k, \,; >, A WHITNEY GRAY, VICE MAYOR-COMMISSIONER HoYT HAMILTON, COMMISSIONER ,) FRANK HIBBARD, COMMISSIONER * BIILJONSOrr-OWjSSlONER "EQUM EMPI OYM'fIT AND AmRMATNE ACT,ON EM" ow," \. '- ,~d March 19, 2003 Kheueddme - Page 2 " 5 That the A-frame SIgn be removed and the appltcant obtam a permIt for the attached sIgnage withm 30 days of CDB approval. Pursuant to Section 4-407, an apphcatIon for a bmldmg permIt shall be made wlthm one year of FlexIble Development approval (March 18, 2004). All reqmred certificates of occupancy shall be obtamed wlthm one year of the date of Issuance of the budding permIt. TIme frames do not change WIth succeSSIve owners The Commumty Development Board may grant an extenSIOn of time for a penod not to exceed one year and only wlthm the ongmal penod ofvahdlty. Please be aware that the Issuance of thIS Development Order does not reheve you of the neceSSIty to obtam any bmldmg permits or pay any Impact fees that may be reqmred. In order to faclhtate the Issuance of any permIt or l1cense affected by thIS approval, please bnng a copy of thIS letter WIth you when applymg for any permIts or lIcenses that reqmre thIS pnor development approval If you have any questIOns, please do not heSItate to call Wayne M. Wells, AICP, Semor Planner, at 727-562-4504. You may access our Planmng Department through the CIty'S webslte: www clearwater- fl com. Smcerely, ~~ CynthIa H. Tarapam Planmng DIrector cc Joe Russell, R & W SIgnS Mary Jo Fox, Development ServIces II' r---------------------- ------1 ! .~._ ~ i ...._--~ 1/~~1 ~ /' ~ - -- ~ ~--,.. --=-- -- -- .. _ -.... CI:ICIe1Ii IUBl BCU.- .._Clt~ _P<_ - - _P<_ ---- .._~ .---.,. DII:P'" --~ ..-..- P<_ .._--~ _OUB>BCU.- -..... ...... IIlIIl -....--.... ~-- IDCoIL _ CIXllI1llIe - .........., DUllPSTER ENCLOSURE ... . r.". . ~ LANDSCAPE NOTES: . __'IDer_",....l.-..s>-.. _.......__ -----------------~~-~::::~~~-~------------------~.~~ lJlICI'e I 'a-;----Z";;;~- ~, m~~(-: C ~ I I '-' I 1 II~ -~-. I' ., ,.-, -~ I I ~ ~: ." ,) c ~ I .. I '~". "'TAC_~ : -.11 1/ :~ =.rl f r--. ~, 'j '" .,..",1)L1~~:.-~--~----- .---) II II - I - : I r~~~ I . ..:-~ I \ . II :J--~ III _10 ~~ - ... r .......m , I \. !6==T:b! I 1.:.1 I I I -\~I "\I ,-" /1: = I I '", ~~ I ... lJlICI'e'~1 ~~ I I I :='IDlI'" L_____L_~:':"=:___J~. ~J (LOT (LOT 321 '(LOT 331 -- -- -1--- \ 01 I -~- -f- " \- ~/ . , ",'" , ._ __...a~ -~T__ , CLEVELAND <C>:, -' <C~ o ()Z _5 m a:~ w~ o!: w a: 11. i K I l ,-- i-=r~ I I L-.. u;c-- STREET '..... -----. Ii, , . .. ~ ...... M" .,... oc. .J.....~........ TAl. ~.M"1D..OC' ~.".....-=- . J...... M.tB. yr' IV TIU. ~.trlO"oc.. . ~ ,~ .~; ~. ~ " ..;a .....~" ~ SITE .~ PLAN . .' l N'OIII"IATlOt llNOUC ON SITe I"\.AH r& eAeED ON N'ORMATlOt .......IJ!D I5T CllIN!JIt . ~~ ICNOIII IT NClIIlInc.. W'5'1 Ham -. '521 ~~ 346'!IIt "1n 48 ~ 1. -. TO CGM&l1IlIIC:TIClN. THI! ~ ~0Il! ~ ~ AL.L. ITB't& IlWCIU4 A& I!XI8TWD ClNlMlelI ~ · NOl'I'T lWI& c:;Fl'lCI! OF /lH'r CI8CRl!J-~ 1 corntACTOIl! I1BT T.ucE f'RI!GAUTION6 TO I"IlOTECT 0IIIER'9 ~.. _ CClN&TIlIJe'I1ClN t:II"l!RATt<:Na. n.s ~ 01' ne ~0Il!'$ IIClIllK . &TOIl!AGe AN!A6 uu. ee CI!I'lIeD TO r'UT\Wl.. .-s'II!NT !5T ~ 4. llNOlI.D PlI!I.J) C(lIClIT1CIN8 c_ _ P'l..Ml& TO I!)(11!Nf 1I'~.,..,. C061& _ ~ OIl! cmA'Y'&'- NmCl- "A1I!D ne QIfeR . ~ ~ l!llI! CCINIllL11!D AN AI. 11!JlIMATI'ooE l5OEI"E. F P"'CleeI!lLI!. lIlIU. I!lE eaT AeL$EP TO AT11!I"PT TO !lOl..vt! THI! ~I!M ~- s LANCICM"E I"UN!I N.J.C. I I ! 1 .1 8I1E NOTES I SITE AREA "5l#}eQFT I LANDSSCAPE AREA ~ ,_eQFT I 1 BUILDING AREA '12 SGl FT I j PERVIOUS AREA 1_ SGlFT j I IMPERVIOUS AREA III 63' SGl FT I . FLOOR AREA RAllO I 2...". I r . PARKING REQUIRED 312 &c::I FT x !l/I _ SGl FT . l!l6 t . PARKING PROVIDED S, NCUJDING 1 ACCE86I!lLE I e,,~.\'.'\- ! , I 1 J ,~..) SITE DATA j (\ J .. . _ n . Q ~ I a.- ~J t3 ~ ~ ~ ... ~ ..~ !. Ilill ili~1 . bl -' I --3 o -IIIJII!!!II ~- A 100 .... t.. ,," \ . " " f" It- :l ... .' '-i . "" fi . Ell. \\. \.;\ !> (, p~.) j -", ~ 9- '!> ORIGINAL ",IF'" ,"~x.1\LOF 'II?...... ,...\. \),...""",~r-_ ..'!':. ,.,1 #M"'-~':. ..I~.' \1/ (;; ":;. ~.. ""~.., ~ ... ~ "- "'_:' ~--' .... "- ---.. .. G".. ~ L:::) lo ....-.. ;::;;:... ':.~'-- ..'~-'~ -.:..r $,'" "'."~ 'Vt,'" .........,I1TE~"jj' "16,1 C I T Y 0 F CLEARWATER PLANNING DEPARTMENT Posr OFFICE Box 4748, ClEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748 MU""IClP..1 SI-RVICrS BUilDING, 100 SOUIII MVRIlI: AVFNUI:. CU,ARWA1ER. FlORIDA 33756 TI:LFPHONE (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4576 LO'\G R\NC,1 PIAl'-t\I'\G 01 VI l OI'Ml t\ I Rl:V1I W September 17,2004 Re FLD2004-05038, 1310 Cleveland Street, Fast Trac Oil OJ~(C~~~~ r~' rlj.~EP 272004 ;,J:I I pL;\Ni~:r"G 8, r;::1 ELOPMENT I SE:R\lIC'=S CITY OF ClE r\;IJATF"R Stephen R Fowler, AlA, NCARB Fowler ASSOCiates Architects, Inc 1421 Court Street Clearwater, FL 33756 Oem Mr Fowler The subject ploperty IS zoned Commercial (C) DistrIct and IS consIstent with ItS underlY111g l~l).d use desIgnation of Commercial General (CG) Category The site had been developed as an automobile service statIOn 111 the past, was vacant for two to three years and was reopened 111 August 2002. On March 18, 2003, the Commumty Development Board approved a FleXIble Development applIcation (FLD2003-0 I 003) With five condItIons to pen111t the addItIOn of a canopy over eXlst111g gas pumps and slgnage for an eXlstll1g automobile serVIce statIOn WIth a reductIOn 111 the front (south) setback from 25 feet to five feet (to canopy) and a reductIOn 111 the front (south) setback from five feet to zero feet (to sign), as part of a ComprehenSive Infill Redevelopment PloJect TillS SIte IS located 111 the East Gateway D1StIICt of the newly adopted Downtown Plan (effective upon adoptIOn by the CountYWIde Planmng Authonty on February 3, 2004) Automobile serVIce stations are now lIsted as a prohIbIted use wlthll1 the East Gateway DistrIct As such, the eXlstll1g automobile service statIOn IS now deemed a nonconfonmng use You filed on May 26, 2004, on behalf of the property owner a request to expand the automobIle servIce statIon (FLD2004-05038) to pen11lt the addItion of a second gas pump Island, expand the canopy and relocate the I etml sales buildll1g to the northeast comer of the property Contall1ed ll1 our "ll1complete" letter fOl thiS new request IS the plOhlbltlon by SectIOn 6-103 B of the Commumty Development Code (Code) of the expansIOn of nonconformll1g uses AddItIOnally, Policy 11 of the new Downtown Plan states that the use of the Code tool known as "Ten11lnatlon of Status as a Nonconformity" IS not permItted wlthlll the Downtown Plan area You h,lVe now requested the ability to expand only the convel1lence store/retaIl sales blllldll1g portIOn of the automobile service station The defil1ltlOn of"automob1le service statIOn" IS L/lIlOlIIohde ::,en'lU:' sIal/Oil means any buildmg, stIllcture, or lot used for the followll1g ll1speJl~lIlg, ~c1ll1lg 01 0 flCllllg for I ctail sale gasolllle, h.clOsene, I ubrlcatlllg 011, or grease for the operatIon dlld I11dmtenance of Jutomobiles ThIS may mclude bu1ld1l1gs or structures that are used fOI the retail sale and dnect delivery to motor vehicles of cigarettes, candy, soft drInks and other BhIAN J At i\l.\ 1.1\ \)()H ( O\l\lI""lll1\1 H Illl\ I 111\1111"" Vie I M,\)()j{ CO\l\II"\I()t\I H \\ 11111'11 \ GI{~I\II\4)1\1 H.\ · \ ,. II{"~ 111II1l\I{I), (()\\\II\',i()1\1 H * Bill J01\"( ~'t\J, ....,. \...- "L<JlIAI hl!'I OYMl N I AND Allll(MA I IVI A< I ION EM!'I m I R" z., ~ e4. ) September 17, 2004 Fowler - Page 2 related Items for the convemence of the motonng pubhc, and may mclude faclhtles for lubncatmg, mmor repairs or vehicle service Such establIshments shall not include faclhtles for major vehicle service It IS staffs detem1matlOn that the use of the property IS an automobtle service station, and that the expansIOn of any portion of the use constitutes the expansIOn of the use PortIOns of the use cannot be separated from the other portIOns of the use to get around the Code provIsions In a reverse circumstance of where a parcel IS developed With a convemence store/retatl sales use only (no gas pumps) and the owner wants to add gas pumps, the use of the parcel would change from "retail sales and services" to "automoblle servIce station," requlflng comphance With all Code provIsIOns for thiS changed llse of the parcel ThelefOle, smce the Downtown Plan now proll1blts the use, makmg the eXlstmg use J nonconformmg use, and the Code prohibits the expansIOn of a nonconfom1mg use, the expansIon of the convemence store/retall bUlldmg portIOn IS also proll1blted Should you dIsagree With thiS detem1111atlOn, you may appeal thiS determmatlOn to the Commul1lty Development Board 111 accordance With SectIOns 4-501 A and 4-502 A Such appeal must be filed With the Pldnmng Department wlthm seven days of the date of t111S letter I' AdditIOnally, as of January 21, 1999, the City adopted the Commumty Development Code In the event a structure m which a nonconfonnmg use IS located IS destroyed or damaged to the extent ofless than 50 percent of the assessed value of such structure, the nonconfol1mng use may be re-estabhshed If a complete and legally suffiCient applicatIon for all reqUired penmts to repair or restore IS submitted wlthm SIX months of the date of the damage In the event a structure m which a nonconformmg use IS located IS destloyed or damaged to 50 percent or more of the assessed value, these stmctures may be repaIred or restored only I f the structure and the use conforms to the standards of thiS development code for the zomng dlstnct 111 which It IS located Should you have addItIOnal questIOns, please contact Wayne M Wells, AICP, Planner III, at 727-562- 4504 S/)~rni A.~ ~anvrhi- Cyndl H Tarapal1l, AICP Planl1lng Director OR\G\NAL -------- ~---- \'..,... (_".......... --.rnn-:l '\ Ir--Jr........\l ,_J I' ',' I 'I r ...............\ I '--~ :. I' 1 ~-., I I ", fl \ I I 1 " C:J'::::"/ ~ U ~__=- \ 1,."., ,..----- ---- I \ JF \ \ \ SE.P Z7 2004 ~ l" I l PLANr~Ir\jG & Ci:YELOPMENl SERVICES CITY OF CLc,riWi\T[D , , I ' J:'A~- .'I Wlalllllllg DeparllllelltlC D fllrLEXl/llcolllp/etelClevelalld 1310 Mal/al Ot! (C) IC/evelalld 1310 Letter Ie Expal/d Retatl PortlOl/ 9 17 04 doc 4'" 74 6~~:\t~\- D (3 ,~&s) . I I - . . " . . . . . . . . . . . . East Gatewav District The East Gateway DIstnct IS bounded by Drew Street on the north, HIghland A venue on the east, MIssoun Avenue on the west and Court Street on the south and IS shown on Map 8, page 57. ThIS DIStrict IS compnsed of 686 parcels totalmg 175.6 acres and represents 32.5 percent of the Downtown area. Existing Character East Gateway IS generally charactenzed by a mixed land use pattern of resIdentIal housmg mterspersed wIth pockets of poorly maintained rental propertIes and outdatei' stnp commercIal. Tills DIstnct struggles wIth a negative Image of crime due to the location of problematic uses such as day labor facIlItIes, old motels and SOCIal servIce agenCIes that provide services to the homeless populatIon. The commercial sector is burdened wIth a declInIng busmess base, an array of detenorating mfrastructure, a 1ll1smatch of uses, and an mcreasing number of vacant storefronts. RelatIvely well- mamtamed small professIOnal offices and St. CeCIlIa's CatholIc School anchor the southern edge of the East Gateway. District Vision Uses It IS enVISIOned that the East Gateway WIll be a VIbrant, stable, dIverse neIghborhood defined by ItS unIque cultural base and 1ll1xed land uses. It WIll contmue to be developed as a low and medIUm denSIty reSIdentIal neIghborhood supported wIth neIghborhood commercIal and profeSSIonal offices concentrated along the major corridors of Cleveland Street, Gulf to Bay Boulevard, Court Street and MISSOUri A venue. The areas northeast of Gulf to Bay Boulevard and north of Cleveland Street and east of HIllcrest Avenue should be mamtamed as a pnmanly low denSIty, low-nse reSIdentIal neIghborhood. The areas southwest of Gulf to Bay Boulevard, south of Cleveland Street, and north of Cleveland Street west of HIllcrest Avenue are appropnate for medIUm- and mgh-density multI- fa1ll1ly reSIdentIal. instItutIonal uses should remam pnmarIly south of Cleveland Street. FunctIOn Although the East Gateway DIstnct IS predominantly a reSIdentIal neIghborhood, It WIll be the pnmary entrance to the Downtown Core once the new Memonal Causeway Bndge opens Consequently, thIS presents an opportUnIty to define and Improve the functIon of thIS DIStrICt wIth attractive streetscape and landscapmg elements along wIth appropnate wayfindmg sIgnage. "" ~ ~..... .' I - I " ";q ~~ - ~~ .~ . . . . . .. '''' .. ~ .- '" .. ~ . .~ ... A . . . "\ ... -" . Development Patterns The existing resIdentIal areas should retam then scale and development patterns and any mfill development m this area should reflect the existmg low-nse pattern. New multi- famIly development should be developed at a medium denSIty and scale and provide vanety m housmg types and pncmg. It is envIsioned that new commercial development should proVIde employment opportumtIes for the DIstnct's residents as well as serve the dally commercIal and personal service needs of the neIghborhood Commercial and office development should be redeveloped at a scale compatible with the neIghborhood; consolidation of small obsolete development parcelslbUlldings is encouraged to create an adequate lot SIze for modern development standards. ProhIbited Uses Automobile service stations, all types of vehtcle sales and service uses, fast food restaurants WIth dnve-through servIces, adult uses, mdustnal and problematic uses (examples mclude, but are not llImted to, day labor, pawn shops, check cashtng and blood plasma centers and body pIercmg and tattoo parlors.) Intensitv A. A portIOn of the East Gateway has a future land use plan deSIgnation of Central Busmess DIstnct (CDB) and IS zoned D, Downtown. This section IS generally located between Mlssoun and Fredenca Avenues one block north and south of Cleveland Street and IS depIcted on Map 9, page 77. Development shall be perffiltted as follows WIthin thIS area. Floor Area Ratio - 0.55 FAR; Density- 30 dwellmg umts per acre HeIght Office - 50'; CommerCIal - 25' - 35' B. The remammg portIon of the East Gateway does not have the Central Busmess Dlstnct (CBD) land use category and IS governed by a vanety of reSIdential and nonreSIdential plan categories. These categories. along WIth the current zonmg deSIgnatIons shall govern mtenslty and denSIty, as well as heIght. However, development shall also be consistent WIth the East Gateway character district. # East Gateway District Policies Pohcy 1. Any proposed rezomng and/or land use plan amendment wIthm the East Gateway should be conSIstent with this Plan. 75 76 ,I I I I I I I II " I " , II " I I . I " II . . . . Pohcy 2: The residential base mc1udmg rental propertIes should be stabIhzed by providmg for an Improved ffilX of affordable and market-rate housing optIOns mc1udmg mfill developments, rehabIhtatIOns, homeownershIp and rental housmg chOIces. Pohcy 3: The expansIOn of the existmg Clearwater Homeless Intervention Project (CHIP) facihtIes should be supported as a Downtown "campus" that wIll address the emergency and transItional housmg needs of the Downtown homeless (withm a structured/supervIsed program), and wluch WIll prevent future intrusion of scattered homeless facIhtIes throughout the neIghborhood Pohcy 4: The concentration of problematic uses, especially day labor facIlIties, shoutf! be reduced through voluntary relocatIOn or amortIzation. Pohcy 5: The rehabIhtatIon of existing motels mto resIdential apartments shall be prohIbIted. Pohcy 6: Foster a sense of neIghborhood cohesIOn through urban deSIgn elements, as well as through the creation of neIghborhood aSSOCiatIOns. Pohcy 7: Attract and aSSIst eXIsting retaIl and personal serVIce establishments m order to create neighborhood employment opportumtIes. Pohcy 8: New development on Gulf to Bay Boulevard shall be onented toward the Street to encourage pedestnan activIty. Policy 9. Evaluate hffilted expansions of the Commercial and Downtown zoning DIStrICt boundarIes on Gulf to Bay Boulevard and Cleveland Street that may create opportunities for commercial expansIOns and/or redevelopment that IS consIstent with Commumty Development Code reqmrements. Pohcy 10: ReSIdential development frontmg on Cleveland Street may only be pernutted if part of a ffilxed use development. Pohcy 11: Encourage the assembly of vacant and underutIhzed propertIes, as well as the demohtlOn of detenorated bmldmgs to accommodate redevelopment projects that meet Clearwater Commumty Development Code standards. Pohcy 12. Encourage the adaptive re-use of underutihzed bmldmgs m the event redevelopment IS not feaSIble. Pohcy 13: ProVIde neIghborhood-wIde education programs relating to housing mamtenance and hfe safety Issues pnor to conducting any systematic code enforcement program 14 I Amenity Goal I Goal 3: Create Downtown as a memorable place to be enjoyed by resldents and vlsitors that capltalizes on Clearwater's waterfront 10catLOn, natural resources, built enVlronment and history. I: I' I: I: I: I; Ii Objective 3A: Coachman Park shall be redeveloped and expanded as a waterfront park accessIble to all resIdents and VIsItors contammg active and passIve open space, an improved regIOnal outdoor entertaInment venue and a manna Objective 3B. The new Main Library wIll serve as a cultural attraction and an anchor fq};: the northern section of the Downtown Core. ".. Objective 3C: A varIety of visual and perfornung art activIties and programs shall be encouraged WIthin the Downtown. Objective 3D. Redevelopment is encouraged to create a VIbrant Downtown enVIronment contammg a varIety of bUIldmg forms and styles that respect Downtown's character and hentage. Policies PolIcy 1: The deSIgn guidelmes establish the qUalIty and deSIgn features expected for renovation, redevelopment and new construction 10 Downtown WIth wluch all projects must be conSIstent. II II I' I; I I, I I I PolIcy 2. The character of each distnct shall be remforced through the SIte plan and deSIgn reVIew process. Projects shall be conSIstent with and contnbute pOSItively to the VISIOn of the character dlstnct in WhICh it is located. PolIcy 3: The deSIgn of all projects 10 Downtown shall make meaningful contnbutlons to the pedestnan enVIronment through SIte and buildmg deSIgn. Policy 4: RenovatIOn, rehabIlItation and reuse of lustonc resources are encouraged. FleXIbIlIty through the SIte plan reVIew process should be utilIzed so that hlstonc resources may be retamed and reused. PolIcy 5' The City shall pursue varIOUS strategIes, mcentives and planmng tools that WIll aSSIst 10 the preservation of hlstonc resources. Policy 6' The City shall establish a PublIc AmemtIes Incentive Pool that provides density and mtensity increases for projects located in all character dIStriCtS, except as IIrruted 10 Old Bay, 10 excess of the allowable maxImum development potential based on a proVISIon of selected public amenities The SIze of the Incentive Pool shall be the mcremental dIfference between the 51 SA ~,\a~~ )E t 1.. ,~&~ maximum development potentIal permitted by the 1995 Redevelopment Plan and the maxImum amount of development pernutted under thIS Plan as determmed by the bUlldout scenarIOS. PolIcy 7' Transfer of Development RIghts are penmtted for all projects to assIst development proVIded that both the sendmg and recelvmg SItes are located m the Downtown Plan area Approval of Transfer of Development Rights on a SIte may allow an mcrease m the development potential m excess of the maximum development potential of the applicable character dlstnct All uses of transfer of development nghts shall ensure that the receivmg SIte remains conSIstent with the VISIOn of the applIcable character dlstnct. 1(" .!J , PolIcy 8: MaintaIn the deSIgnation of Downtown as a Regional ACtIVIty Center so that,:' the thresholds for Development of RegIOnal Impacts remain increased. i l " ,~ Policy 13: Places of worslup and Social/community centers are considered mtegral parts of the Downtown character dlstncts. They are penrutted uses that may locate or expand at a scale conSIstent WIth the character dlstnct in WhICh they are located proVIded that all SIte plan reqUlrements are met. .. %"'~ ;; i ,,:~ .. IJ:5 ,~ ' II II '4 II po "h" .. . Jl 'l~ PolIcy 9 Projects located at or near the border of the Downtown Plan area shall use effective SIte and buIldmg deSIgn features to ensure an appropnate tranSItIon and buffer between the dIfferent areas. PolIcy 10' Uses along the Pmellas TraIl should be onented toward the Trail to take advantage of the people drawn to this recreatIonal/transportatIOn amemty. Connections to the Pmellas TraIl should be mcorporated m SIte plans when property is adjacent to the TraIl or when the proposed use would benefit through a connection. ~ PolIcy 11: Nonconfornung uses are encouraged to relocate to a zoning dlstnct that permits theu use. The CIty shall explore all mcentIves and planning tools that wIll assist m the relocation of nonconfonmng uses Use of the Commumty Development Code tool known as "TerminatIOn of Status as a Nonconfonruty" IS not penmtted withm the Downtown Plan area. PolIcy 12: Dnve-through facilities shall only be pernutted as an accessory use and through a design that numnuzes the VIews of the facilIty from nghts-of-way and preserves the urban character of Downtown. ,J'). " I 52 II II II . PolIcy 14. The educatIOn of Downtown property owners should be emphaSIzed regarding Clearwater bUlldmg and property mamtenance standards. LItter control and maintenance of landscaped areas shall be a pnonty for Downtown The CIty wIll mamtam ItS propertIes and pubhc infrastructure as the example for other property owners. ;: ~ 6-102 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE E. In the event the use of a nonconforming structure IS abandoned for a period of six consec- utive months, the future use of the structure shall be required to be brought mto compliooce with all the reqUIrements of this Development Code F. Any part of a nonconforming structure winch is destroyed or damaged to the extent of less than 50 percent of the assessed value of the entire structure may be rep81I"ed or restored If a com- plete and legally sufficient applicatIOn for all required permits to repair or restore the damage is sublDltted within six months of the date of the damage. Any nonconfornung structure which IS destroyed or damaged to 50 percent or more of the assessed value may be rep81I"ed or restored only if the structure conforms to the standards of tins development code for the zoning distrIct in which it 18 located. Assessed value shall be determined by reference to the offiCIal property tax assess- ment 1'Olls for the year the structure is destroyed or damaged. The extent of damage or destructIOn shall be determmed by the building offiCIal by comparing the estImated cost of rep81I"S or resto- ration with the assessed value (Ord. No. 6928-02, ~ 114, 5-2-02) Section 6-103. Noncomorming uses. A. Nonconforming uses of land or structures, and nonconformmg structures that contam non- confornung uses, may be mamtained only in ac- cordance With the provisions of this sectIon tI B. Nonconformmg uses of land or structures shall not be expanded but normal rep81I" and mamtenance may be performed to allow the con- tinuation of the nonconformmg use C Except as prOVIded m 6-109, a nonconform- ing use shall not be changed to any other use unless the new use conforms to the standards of the zoning dIstrIct m which it is located Once a nonconfornung use IS changed to a conformmg use, the nonconforming use shall not be re- established or resumed and any subsequent use of the land or structure shall conform to all of the requirements of this Development Code. E. In the event a structure m which a noncon- fornung use is located is destroyed or damaged to the extent of less than 50 percent of the assessed value of such structure, the nonconforming use may be re-established if a complete and legally sufficient apphcation for all required permits to repair or restore is subnntted within six months of the date of the damage. In the event a structure m which a nonconforming use is located is de- stroyed or damaged to 50 percent or more of the assessed value, these structures may be repaired or restored only if the structure and the use conforms to the standards of this development code for the zoning distrIct in which it is located, except that a nonconforming owner-occupied smgle- fa.mJl.y detached dwelling unit may be recon- structed within the associated structure's original setbacks througl1 a Levell (minimum standard) approval process. Assessed value shall be deter- mined by reference to the official property tax assessment rolls for the year the structure is destroyed or damaged. The extent of damage or destruction shall be determmed by the building official by comparing the estimated cost of repairs or restoration with the assessed value. F. In the event a nonconforming use is dam- aged or destroyed to the extent that the cost of repair or replacement of the fixtures and/or in- ventory used in the business equals 50 percent of the value of the fixtures and inventory at the tIme of such damage or destruction, the use may not be re-estabhshed except in compliance with all re- qmrements of tins Development Code. (Ord No. 6526-00, ~ 1, 6-15-00) Section 6-104. Nonconforming sign/redevel- opment of principle use/struc- ture. A In the event a bUIlding pernut is reqUIred for the redevelopment of a pnncipal use/struc- ture, or a pnnclpal use/structure is vacant for a penod of 180 days, SIgnS on the parcel proposed D In the event a nonconfonmng use IS discon- for development shall be brought mto compliance tinued or abandoned for SIX consecutIve months, by obt81mng a level one approval in accordance : :e ~ shall not ~~aW be re-emblffihOOCD6 :~ ~e provffi>ons of Arb~ ;f~~ f :-~~ ~ ~Q ~D CARROLL Sf 00 I c=J ~ '*BRlOK [Jl , ~ ;. """'RAL I WOODSllN lA ~~ i K Sf ..\ 1.,1 lIE I Il I Ii i\ !i!N H'.'SCUS >- i5. ::: NSf HIBISCUS ST "I I ~ l l I Is HIBISCUS ~ NAIR Sf . .1 /" l:1 -.00 CJ D [] PIUlETTO ~ c:::m 0 c=j~ C ~ 54B DO i II -l! 01=1, . / !LID[;;:~rDII' 'nl_. I Q~~ I ~i[[ll[]~ ~ c=J CJ ! W4'LE Sf LlJ l 1 ~ D C::3v Sf -. WPLE v:::: [:=J = 0 0 D~ c:rk ] ~ D~ PlAZA ~EESfSf, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ PROJECT I!iD~ ~ ~~ "OGE>\<)QO Sf oufb DiES ~ DrDiD~D~D~DiDRD SITE ~D~=rn)8 ~n~ []I] 0 n~D c:=J D ~ ~ < ~ ~ c=J D" ~~U~~ o 6nID;~ ~DiDI~!D' 'D~D~DtD c=J O~I GRNE I~D<< hD~"Q~GRDVE m Sf ~~ ~ ~ CJO~ODo o D D~c=J ~ I 0 D~D c=J~c=J 0 lI~D CJ D~u aBtiJI<O D!l!D sr 0 D ~ )-r;:::JI~ C:=J c=:J ~ ClE1IELAND ~ """" ~ Sf < """" Sf !! ~~ PARK ~ Sf :5 o 0 01 :" I '_J [\\ I ~"_ DI~~ P1"""" sr PlEIlCE~O~D r7 f1~r-=\drt~ EJg !> ~c=J ~ 0 Q~ ~ui ~ i ~~'-J USU:~ I'N'I'~ ~ ~ Dg~ ~ I :OQO~sr ~~~< ~:J~~fl 0 O 0 ~~ ~ c:=J c=J L:5SANTA ROSA ~ SI\N .llAN ~ BROINNB.l Sf r----l = = L---J 0001 ~'. · I,~ll' 1 18~!aDIO'O~ O y r Sf I ~ P1NE ~~o [l]t< ic=J~c=JoD OOioST ~D D D D I I '" PINE Z ' g ~" PINE ~ Sf "I ~ ~ o ~ !j lA c=J~c=J tll ., 5 ~ i ~ D 0 D c=J~c=J o DO ORK~~~ ~D~D OR ~ :::E tAAGNOlIA DR Location Map Owner. Manal Oil, Inc. Case: APP2004-00006 Site: 1310 Cleveland Street Property Slze(Acres): 0.25 PIN. 15/29/15/12276/002/0300 Atlas Page. 287B Aerial Map Owner: Manal Oil, Inc. I Case: Property Slze(Acres) APP2004-GOOO6 Site. 1310 Cleveland street 0.25 PIN: 15/29/15/12276/002/0300 Atlas Page: 287B 6 6 I I I , : I I I I , L.___, ~ I--~I ~ 117 r-I. : ~1 ,-'"- - r--L I I L..L --1 1 !:, lIC I I , I L_J 4 115 J13 I -, I I I I -1.-' f2 o ~ , I ~ lIJ ;Joil, r---1 I' I jJOj'-' L..,,__J --, L, , \ I Ll L__ 1_ I ,:t, O~Wl I _JiCr ~ ~t..-J 1 2 ~ ~ ~ GROVE ST ~ 1 ~ '" ~ '" t-~ h~"'" 1-,:::\','; "- I "' ~ ~ ("--I ~ I l L-. ' 1--1 L__I I , - --' I r---'-------I ,-, J ---I I , ,-------1 , I I I --I I , , I , , I I I r----' I I , , I I I , I [~ I I -~ , I I I I j) "\ l...____..J !it I ~ "- I I '" '" 1 J ~ ~ l ~ --- r to ~ j--l ~___J Ilr ~ 1 '" '" I '"i.__':. , I , I , I L__ i'fl I , ~. r~ , I , ~ CI) , I_.J I , OJ 'C'............., I I , Lr--- rn \ ~.-\ , .... \~~ I .... "< r- :t 20 _._u__ l;; ~ ~~ -I~ I _To:.. ,.J ~.... t'? f!ll~ ~ -..-' fJ 100 F-ll0 J I I, ~ f\\\ c--, 1- MD' D I )1- n ~ 10 Lr-~ ~ '0 '" ..... ~~'OO MjfIDR r--J22 I , I , ~ ! ------, I I , I , I I I , -------' I I -I L I ..._1 rr-t24 I I -I"J '~-, JfJf"- '-nJ!: lbf 11~ I , r l(t~ ~ lJ. 107 -jOt l_____ -1.~1 !...., 1 I" : J ,~ ..J 122 120 118 r--r-11t 12fT-~ 12LJ 1]"9 ., l!'l.._J 113 I--~---- I 1 I 11 1____ 1-' r -, lQs 1-- I_~ L 106 104 102 lOG ~---~ r 3a 1 II I " I I L..r- L___' 1 I 111 , ~ 1 ~5 ,-_J ~ rJ J7 r-' o :;; ___...j-'L.__ I , I "'_, 1 : I I I I I I I I I I I " I L,J I L, l. L-1 bJ ,~ CLEVELAND ST ~-I I ., , r-'~ Ll I I I , I , , , , , I I I I , I I I , , '----, IJ 'I L~ '1011 "I', ~oj r- 'I' 1 I IliA ~ OJ ~_~ ~j ~ ~ Zoning Map Owner: Manal Oil, Inc. Site" 1310 Cleveland Street Case: Property Size (Acres) PIN A tlas Page: 'j I I I I i I ~ I, _______.~I r ,---- I" v ~ ::::; ~ ;1/ \ // I 1- MnR r~J r-- , L '--1 r--- , I' l J r "I - L_.J____ I ~ L______ r---r- --, i' r-- I, ". ~ ~ Ll~ I~ I 'I - :t ( - 1 r- "I~-l %~llill ----~ :b ~ I : r r 0 rJ I I I ,-~ I I "< , I 1_, I ----,_ I ~ , I " ' , I s I I I ----.., ,. '- L _ ::0 L_I /- I "< L~ _ 0 ::0 PARK ST ~--1 ,_I I -, , rJ"L____..J I , I L______ _ J 111 I' r-----... L I I L I ---"'-..1 105 " LJ r r------, I L_, I I I J -~' I , !w-~ , I I --1 II l__J o ~ IJ---~ ;1; '" _J ... f-1 --!, I --I ! ,I I I l", "'---1 I 1- I 1 I L..__..I I I L~I ~ ,-"" I"~ r l-.!:l i;1-, : -'I r_, - I I" I : , i-=i Ml >>Ii h .... t""f..... ..., ~ APP2004-QOOO6 0.25 15/29/15/12276/002/0300 287B I III ~ I IlL"'chel ~~)ing fS "'-----..! ,...-~ L-~1 r~" ;1-, ~ 1 ~ I_JlO in8 uetacIICU 106 . n. 104 = : ~~ ! .r1 ,__'::'32 r " '30 1__ I I I _28 r--, ,___.,.'00 , I I 124 l _J r t.,., r- f 12.1 L_.J____J 1 1-~-11 L______.J 1 ! I I G7' 1 1 L__J 111 r-} 11 5 r-=c- 113 r' [--'I : :..L.L 111 -l..J --, f'O~ [---1 1 I J1( o-,J L......_J L_J -, L, I ' 1 1 "j ..__ 1 I L'!-' ~ ~ '~LJ 1112 GROVE ST ,_.::r 122 120 ,__r.o\18 1 III ~--, I_I 1 -, I rJ"'L____-' I L____ I 1 r dwelliifgs L L___..._.J 113 r--~---- I I k(tta...c~l 1f~J L dwelli.ji Ii 102 101 ~---~ r ;.{ 1 II I II I Ii r- , 1"- L__ 1 Parkin~ lot 105 I , ~1 I lfr 1 ~s _-1 9fl~f.be4 ,.--, I I L__I " LJ ,_-):12 I , 1 r ~ I 1 : ~ ,-~~': ("-\ ~ J ----~---- L~ i -, I ,_______J : I 1 J I , I I -_______" I I I I I I I I I II 1 1 U I - : 1 L:] I I L____...J llt ~ l; .... .... 17 ,-"'\ I I Parking _ :i!: I--~ L-l.. ;g ot Pvernig ~t 111 I ,-, I tJ akc~)I~~ I ;:a 11't., U ...... , -, (? <> "-1 bj ... ~ I! ). ~ CLEVELAND ST r----.., I 1 I __ I Office: , 1 _~r~ 1 1 u-~ 1 I 1 --1 rl L__" r---~-------, &'-1 J J1-llilityl I ------1 1- I I Infrastru ture ) I I I Facility I I <> ' 1 CIO ' L -~_ ---__.J ------" Vacal L, .. r .-- ~ I Jr-b ~ Ll~ r: ~ ~ ~ :i!: r;;-l I"'" r...l~ 1..1 ;t.. I 1 tJ I I "< Ma+ufac~uring ~ 1 1 ::a I : "< , I tJ '____, ,J _ " "" L" ~ -, __, r~ e 1 <q <q II a~i,oF 1 1 I~ ot~ljip jU~1 s~~ sa\ti9ri i 1...,.lVPr ight 1 1 .... : a~coR . 1 1 I Lr--- I I %-1 ~ ) ----~ ~est~u~ ant ----tJ " I , ,- .... __J~-I 1 .... I Vehicl~ I 1 service: I " ----, I L, Vacan ,_ ,-.., r'=-I 1 r - ~ -]1 - utnlly' 20 CI) Infrastructu e ~ Facilitv ~ ,... ~ PARK ST r-1:l rl'il I-~ I ~ i;1 1 1Il 1....) ... r.l P'1 , IL, -- , ri , [ ... J L_...J I - -I I 1 ,..:" 1"~4 I 1 -,J 1.,_. PARK ST J---~ ~ '" ~ ........ --~ ,- '--I ! " I 1 ~ :e....g} , I~ r~l~ ~ 1 - -.... lJ 100 I r-l l. (\ \\ ~~ ~ I ) I 1lt~ ~ 1~ 107 -riif 11gj I r-., I I I ~ " f-' 1 I ! 'I I I ~ L.!.J L~ L_. ~ J L-;! ~ ~ ~ t.._ ~ l 1 r r---" , ..._-~ I I ~--- ~_~J ~_~ P'1 P'1 ~ ~ r-l ~ ~:1 -, r l~- ..-1'0 ~ u ~~ .... <q ~ r Existing Surrounding Uses Map APP2004-DOOO6 Manal Oil, Inc. Case: Owner: Property Size (Acres) . 0.25 1310 Cleveland Street Site: 15/29/15/12276/002/0300 PIN: 287B Atlas Page View looking north at subject site View looking northeast at property to the east of subject site View looking south at property across Cleveland Street from subject site 1310 Cleveland Street APP2004-00006 View looking east at rear of subject site View looking northwest at property across N. Fredrica Avenue from subject site r - - - - -- View lookmg southwest at property across Cleveland Street on west side of Fredrica Avenue " /4 ~tf{Jle~rwater I- 't~;< ':~, ~ o CIty of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S Myrtle Ave, 2nd Floor Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone (727) 562-4567 Fax: (727) 562-4865 Fax Cover Sheet To: Kathy Milham Fax: 727-461-1005 Phone: From: Sherry Watkins Date: October 15, 2004 Subffiect: Signed APP2004-00006 1310 Cleveland Street Message: The copy you received in your packet was unsigned here is a signed copy of the staff report. Thank you. ~ Q[r]J (d11JJtA~ Number of Pages including this page 1- " ':::B 1[1 I t lei F'EPC::IF'T /" \,~ Oct. 15 2004 11:06RM YOUR LOGO YOUR FRX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FRCSIMILE 01 94611005 STRRT TIME USRGE TIME MODE PRGES RESULT Oct. 15 11:04RM 01'45 SND 04 OK TO n.JRN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MENL.J' ~. THEN SB.ECT OFF BY USING ' +' OR ' -' . FOR FRX RDVRNTRGE RSSISTRNCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HELP-FRX (435-7329). i \' ~,ijl~hrwater _ "'W_/ .-"""~ () CIty of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S Myrtle Ave, 2nd Floor Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone (727) 562-4567 Fax (727) 562-4865 Fax Cover Sheet To: Susan Chase ^I 08(0 Fax: 727-562-4090 Phone: From: Sherry Watkins Date: October 15, 2004 Sub~ect: Signed APP2004-00006 1310 Cleveland Street Message: The copy you received in your packet was unsigned here is a signed copy of the staff report. Thank you. yJ,btMfI (/ htk-rLJ Number of Pages including this page 1 t '::.Et 1[\ I t 1r:i F'EF'CiF'T Oct. 15 2004 11:20AM YOUR LOGO YOUR FAX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FACSIMILE 01 4086 START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT Oct. 15 11:18AM 01'20 SND 04 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MENU' tt04. ~ SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASS I STANCE , PLEASE CALL l-000-HELP-FAX (435-7329). f , " \l' LL 0Jd:}S' ~:fi Uarwater .- 4$~ € ,,~ o CIty of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S. Myrtle Ave, 2nd Floor Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone (727) 562-4567 Fax (727) 562-4865 Fax Cover Sheet To: Leslie K. Dougall-Sides Fax: 727-562-4021 Phone: From: Sherry Watkins Date: October 15, 2004 Submect: Signed APP2004-00006 1310 Cleveland Street Message: The copy you received in your packet was unsigned here is a signed copy of the staff report. Thank you. Number of Pages including this page 'i0 '::B j[I I t j[l F'EF'C1F'T I, Oct. 15 2004 11:15AM YOUR LOGO YOUR FAX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FACSIMILE 01 4021 START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT Oct. 15 11:14AM 01'29 SND 04 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MeU' 1*04. THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HELP-FAX (435-7329). J _,,. CIty of Clearwater Planning Department o 100 S. Myrtle Ave, 2nd Floor Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone (727) 562-4567 Fax (727) 562-4865 Fax Cover Sheet To: Daniel Dennehy Fax: 727-466-6186 Phone: From: Sherry Watkins Date: October 15, 2004 Submect: Signed APP2004-00006 1310 Cleveland Street Message: The copy you received in your packet was unsigned here is a signed copy of the staff report. Thank you. ~fj IAJJ j-}JM~ Number of Pages including this page 1 I " '::B I[i I t jC.i F'EF'CiF'T Oct. 15 2004 11:10RM YOUR LOGO YOUR FRX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FRCSIMILE 01 94666186 STRRT TIME USRGE TIME MODE PRGES RESULT Oct. 15 11:09RM 01'40 SND 04 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MeU' t:t04. THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FRX l=lDUANTAGE RSS I STRNCE, PLEASE CALL 1-8OO-HEI....P-FRX (435- 7329) . .. LL .1/';<"'''1'''''' ~ Ot- ff;~c. '!' ': L' \ J J 4; ~~; ~arwater o CIty of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S. Myrtle Ave, 2nd Floor Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone. (727) 562-4567 Fax (727) 562-4865 Fax Cover Sheet To: John Doran Fax: 727-443-0163 Phone: From: Sherry Watkins Date: October 15, 2004 Subffiect: Signed APP2004-00006 1310 Cleveland Street Message: The copy you received in your packet was unsigned here is a signed copy of the staff report. Thank you. JJ1QM~ jili~ Number of Pages including this page 1 '::B III I ~ lei F'EF'CiF'T Oct. 15 2004 11:02AM YOUR LOGO YOUR FAX NO. CltyOfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 _. NO. OTHER FACSIMILE 01 94430163 START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT Oct. 15 11:00AM 02'19 SND 04 OK TO TURN OFF RelORT, PRESS 'MBIU' **04. 11-lB>I saECT OFF BY USI NG '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADUANTAGE ASS I STl=INCE, PLEASE CALL l-BOO-HELP-FAX (435-7329). -, , < ~ , , l.L ,,/#~' "'1"-' ~. o /. ~ I f..'" ~~e Earwater ~ ~~~~ifif' ,t~ u CIty of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S. Myrtle Ave, 2nd Floor Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone: (727) 562-4567 Fax (727) 562-4865 Fax Cover Sheet To: Alex Plisko Fax: 727-447-6914 Phone: From: Sherry Watkins Date: October 15, 2004 Sub~ect: Signed APP2004-00006 1310 Cleveland Street Message: The copy you received in your packet was unsigned here is a signed copy of the staff report. Thank you. ~i uh:t,lliM Number of Pages including this page 1 t;~ \ " ':::,Et j[I I t j[l PEF'CiF'T Oct. 15 2004 10:59AM YOUR LOGO YOUR FAX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FACSIMILE 01 94476914 START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT Oct. 15 10:57AM 01'21 SND 04 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'MB>ILJ' 1*04. THEN SB...ECT OFF BY US lNG' +' OR '-'. FOR FRX ADVANTAGE ASS I STANCE, PI...EASE CAL..L 1-800-HEL..P-FRX (435-7329). \ \ ~. ~l LL ,8~~" ~i~le"~a'.~ rwater ~\,~~ o CIty of Clearwater Planning Department 100 S Myrtle Ave, 2nd Floor Clearwater, FL 33756 Telephone. (727) 562-4567 Fax (727) 562-4865 Fax Cover Sheet To: David Gildersleeve Fax: 813-884-5990 Phone: From: Sherry Watkins Date: October 15, 2004 Sub~ect: Signed APP2004-00006 1310 Cleveland Street Message: The copy you received in your packet was unsigned here is a signed copy of the staff report. Thank you. ~0~aJcdhiw / Number of Pages including this page if , . ~ ':B jI' I t j[i F'EF'CJF'T Oct. 15 2004 10:57RM YOUR LOGO YOUR FRX NO. Clt~OfClearwater-Plan Dept 727 562 4865 NO. OTHER FRCSIMILE 01 98138845990 STRRT TIME USRGE TIME MODE PRGES RESULT Oct. 15 10:55RM 01'39 SND 05 OK TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS 'Mea.I' ttlM. THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'. FOR FAX ADVANTAGE RSSIST~, PLEASE CRLL l-BOO-HELP-FAX (435-7329). Wells, Wayne From Sent To. Cc Subject Tarapanl, Cyndl Fnday, September 24, 2004 2 00 PM Gerlock, Chip, Wells, Wayne Watkins, Sherry Fast Track 011 appeal I sIgned the letter to Fowler Ie Fast Track oil I also called Steve Fowler and told hun that If he got the appealm by Tuesday that we would put hun on the Oct 19 hearmg for the appeal Please followup as needed Thanks Cyndl T arapam Planrnng Dltectol (727)562-4547 cynd1 taraparu@MyClearwater com Aff2-004 ,. 27fJA 65 taS ~ I ~ ~' ~~~e~ ~.: · ,j, rY1~,~" '![ l..t1 - ~ to rB-- ~.) ~O ~,~ ... . '''2/'0''''- a:: .: : ~ ' k Ii, : ,:! ... r.. .tol,. 16117 bF;s ~!~ i 10 ~~ ~ 50 i 1. ~',: .. J 2 1 .m 23 24 Z5 ~ f I. ~3 ~2 --r " ~ I ~ /" ~~~~~n~ B 2 ~ <I; I . I~ -t ~ I ~~ I DREW RlDGE CO-OP UNREC ~Q I I ~. A.J MO !lr:.!,_~~B ~4~ 5~ fi gl~I~~8~ 9~ GRO~ 19~.I~r~g21 _22.~~~'~ 60r I"",,! 22 or ' PJx:I!:~S ~ -3_~' T;r1iO] I' 3 S~~~~II~SI~~ g o ooOL. ... 2788 "1, L ~ .., . ~ I" ~ ,. p "GE'l'l's Jl,.1\. ~. 16 ES't 4-11 .. ~ ~ Ii ~ z: 72111.,.soo Jl I~IO ct ... , ~ II'P r~ &..\Ie 279A ~ {fff S~.1t CITY OF CLEARWATER I" JO 1 I J 1'.~~ AIID VlCltllTy JD 60' i (~ ,\ I ~ PIIlEILAS COUIITY. rLORlDA ~ ~_ PREPARED BY ~ ~ _ d!J PUBLIC WORKS ADMINISTRATION 1""0:1,: ::: X~ ~ 100 S ")(ll~ EA~IN~~~~~ltf fL 33756 i 1 ~ ~1fR ~ Ph {81J)561-04750 rOI (8'13)526--4755 B~ II' 2 , "lip //wwwch!Q.,."I..r-f1c:om/eng\rleer/ ~fl;::>> < J 1 D,selolrnrr - ~" PUblIc Information data I. furniShed by th, City or Cltorwol.r Putl4lc Walk. Adm\rlI.\toUolI/En9Jn..tlnq and mu~l bl' 0~"pI8d ond ulIed by t,,~ rec1f1lcnt Yrlth ll'le undellllond"'; l~ol lhc dolo lec:.lwd 'Was col..c:tt'd for Ii'll' purpoR of develop"'ljj a qroph!c 'nfrostruc:lure Il'\venlOf)' As 'SUCh It'lc City of Ch:orwolcr PW..../E moku no warrollt'-' .Apr..,ed or Impllod cor.cernln9 tn. occurocy complctenettl relloblUly Of wltobUlty of 11'1111 dolo for on)' other porh('ulOI UN F'udhrrmore Ihe City of C1.Cl'r'NCl'I~ PYlA-IE assumes 110 IlobUII)' w~at$oeW'1 associated with Ihc u.. 0( ml3Ux or s.ct1 dolel 13 ,. ---;; (D 2 " Ul /I r-. ;} ~~ ~ IIJ. ~ ~ 5: ~ 11:6 , i ~ I; ~o "9 '6 IgI 4 ., ., g 6 II u 7 1/ \~~. t-- ~. Nll!.E. T/'II, .A.t1o. page I, .ubject to periodic:: changes for InrO(mot!an about latest revIsions pleose ('011 PWA.!t or ",llIlt our Weob sileo EB o I 100 I 200 I 400 I 600 I SCALE ,- = 400 LEGEND @ 1234 BLOCK NUMBER LOT ADDRESS CI TY LIMITS LINE ...--, SHADED AREA - PROPERTY l..__.1 OUTSIDE CLEARWATER CITY LIMITS . AGREEMENT TO ANNEX . CITY OWNED PROPERTY MDR ZONING DESIGNATION - ZONE liNE RElQll[ CIAO III 4]1'1 0'/71/ae W 55550'/21/8' 111112111 Oll/eS/Vll [!I SUO IO/OI/8S I REVISED 1/19/0 ZONING ATLAS NE 1/4 OF SECTION 12878 15 - 29 S 15 E 1'\'0 C~~vZJ \ , CITY OF CLEARWATER NOTICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD PUBLIC HEARINGS The Commumty Development Board of the City of Clearwater, Flonda, will hold publIc heanngs on Tuesday. October 19, 2004, beginnIng at 200 pm, In the CIty Council Chambers, In City Hall, 3rd floor, 112 South Osceold Avenue, Clearwater, Flonda, to conSider the followmg requests: NOTE: All persons wishinl!: to address an item need to be present at the BEGINNING of the meetinl!:. Those cases that are not contested bv the applicant. staff. neil!:hborml!: propertv owners. etc. wIll be placed on a consent al!:enda and approved bv a sinl!:le vote at the bel!:mninl!: of the meetml!:. I K & P Clearwater Estate. LLC the CIty IS requesting for the only purpose of attachmg condItions of approval, of (1) FleXIble Development approval to Terminate the Status of a Nonconfonruty for denSIty WIthIn the Tounst DIstnct, under the proVISIOns of SectIOn 6-109 C, (2) FleXIble Development approval to penrut 350 overrught accommodatIOn uruts and 75 attached dwellings as a rmxed use (WIth Increase In denSIty of 250 hotel rooms from the Beach by DeSign denSIty pool), WIth a reduction to the front (east along Coronado Dnve) setback from 15 feet to zero feet (to bUIldmg), a reductIOn to the front (south along proposed Second Street) setback from 15 feet to zero feet (to bUIldIng), a reductIOn to the front (west and north along South GulfvIew Boulevard) setback from 15 feet to zero feet (to bUIldIng), an Increase to the bUIlding heIght from 35 feet to 150 feet (to roof deck) WIth an addItIOnal five feet for penmeter parapets (from roof deck) and an addItional 33 feet for elevator, staIr, mecharucal rooms/arclutectural embellIshments (from roof deck), deVIations to allow stacked parlang, allow access to a major artenal street and allow a bUIldIng wlthm the reqUIred SIght VISIbIlIty tnangles at the intersectIOn of Coronado Dnve and proposed Second Street, as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project, under the prOVISIOns of Section 2-803 C, and to elIrmnate the reqUIred foundatIOn landscapIng along Coronado Dnve and proposed Second Street, as a ComprehensIve Landscape Program, under the prOVISIOns of SectIOn 3-1202 G, and (3) the vacatIOn of a portIOn the nght-of-way for Gulf VIew Boulevard between Coronado Dnve and proposed Second Street, the vacatIOn of the FIrSt Street nght-of-way between Coronado Dnve and GulfvIew Boulevard, the dedIcatIOn of nght-of-way for proposed Second Street between Coronado Avenue and GulfvIew Boulevard and the dedIcation of nght-of-way for Coronado Dnve between proposed Second Street and Gulf vIew Boulevard [Proposed Use: Hotel of350 rooms (127 78 rooms/acre on total SIte), 75 attached dwellIngs (2738 uruts/acre on total SIte) and a maXImum of 37,000 sq ft (031 FAR on total SIte) of amemtles accessory to the hotel, at a heIght of 150 ft (to roof deck) WIth an addItional 5 ft for penmeter parapets (from roof deck) and an addItIOnal 33 ft for elevator, staIr, mecharucal rooms/arclutectural embellIshments (from roof deck)] at 100 Coronado Dr & 201. 215 and 219 South Gulf VIew Blvd, Lloyd-Wlute-Skmner Sub, Lots 44-55,90-100, 102, part of Lot 56 & 101, and ColumbIa Sub, Blk A, Lot 1 FLD2004-02013 2 (cont from 9/21/2004) Virl!:inia B. Franks (RadclIffe Development Company, LLC) IS requestIng a FleXIble Development approval to develop 4 reSIdentIal attached dwellIng uruts on a 6,479 sq ft lot (10,000 sq ft IS reqUIred), WIth a rmmmum lot WIdth of 60 ft (100 ft IS reqUIred), a reductIOn In the front setback from 15 ft to 5 69 ft to pavement, a reductIOn In the SIde (south) setback from 10 ft to 4 ft (to extenor staIrs) a reductIOn of the SIde (north) setback from 10 ft to 672ft (to bUIldmg), a reductIOn of the rear setback from 20 ft to 10 ft to wooden deck, and a bUIldIng heIght Increase from 35 ft to 51 83 ft from FEMA to roof rmdpoInt under the proVISIOns of SectIOn 2-803 B (Proposed Use: Attached dwellIngs) at 669 Bav Esplanade, Mandalay Umt No 5 Replat, Blk 77, Lot 8 FLD2004-03018 3 (cont from 9/21/2004) Bnl!:htwater Point. LLC IS requestIng a FleXIble Development to penrut a multi-use dock, under the proVISIons of SectIOn 3-601 (Proposed Use: Construct 2 multI-use docks of 2,478 sq ft for 14 slIps) at 205. 209 and 214 Bril!:htwater Dr., BaysIde Sub No 2, Lots 27, 28 & 29 FLD2004-06046 4 (cont from 9/21/2004) 1504 Garden Inc. IS requestIng a FleXIble Development approval to permIt retail sales WIthIn an eXIstmg two-story commerCIal bUIldIng WIth a reduction to lot area from 10,000 sq ft to 7,720 sq ft, a reduction to lot WIdth (west) from 100 ft to 5081 ft, reductions to the front (north) setback from 25 ft to 19 ft (to eXIsting and proposed bUIldIng) and from 25 ft to 14 ft (to proposed pavement), a reduction to the front (west) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to proposed pavement), reductIOns to the SIde (south) setback from 10 ft to I ft (to eXIstIng and proposed bUIldIng) and from lOft to zero ft (to proposed pavement) and a reduction to reqUIred parkmg from 5 to 4 5 spaces per 1,000 sq ft, as a ComprehenSIve Infill Redevelopment ProJect, under the prOVISIOns of SectIOn 2-704 C, and a reduction to the landscape buffer along the south property lIne from 5 ft to zero ft and a reduction In the WIdth of the reqUIred foundatIOn landscapIng adjacent to the bUIlding (west SIde) from 5 ft to 3 75 ft, as part of a ComprehenSIve Landscape Program, under the proVISIOns of SectIOn 3- 1202 G (Proposed Use: RetaIl sales and serVIces) at 503 Marshall St , E A Marshall's Sub, Lot 10& W Y2 of vac alley on E FLD2004-02010 '1 5 (cont from 9/21/2004) QualItv Boats Inc. & Clearwater Manne AQuarIUm. Inc. (Harbour Watch, LLC) are requestmg a FlexIble Development approval to permIt 31 attached resIdential umts wIth a front (north) setback of 66ft (to pavement) and 26 12 ft (to bUlldmg), a sIde (east) setback of 22 75 ft (to bUilding), a rear (south) setback of 20 ft (to pool and cabana) and 53 56 ft to bUilding, and a sIde (west) setback of zero ft (to pavement) and 22 74 ft (to bUlldmg), and a bUilding heIght of 85 ft from Base Flood ElevatIOn to mIdpomt of the roof, as part of a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment ProJect, under the provlSlons of SectIOns 2-704 C (Proposed Use MultI-farruly reSIdential) at 279 Windward Passa2e, Island Estates of Clearwater Urnt 5, Blk C, W 50' of Lots 1 and 4 and all of Lots 5, 6, 7 and 8 FLD2004-06042 6 Windward Passa2e Condominiums. LLC / Hi2h and Drv Manna. Inc. IS requesting a fleXIble Development to penrut a multI-use dock wIth a reductIOn to the sIde (east) setback from 429ft to 187ft, under the provlSlons of Section 3- 601 [Proposed Use: ConstructIOn of a multi-use dock for 20 slIps totaling 4720 sq ft, WIth each dock measunng 50 ft In length from a 10 ft WIde boardwalk adjacent to the seawall (In associatIOn WIth an approved 55 umt condorrumum proJect)] at 202 WIndward Passa2e, Island Estates of Clearwater Umt 5, Blk D, part of Lot 9 and all of Lots 10-13 Incl FLD2004- 05035 7 The MoorIn2:s Town Homes II. LLC IS requestmg a FleXIble Development to penrut a multI-use dock, under the prOVISIOns of Section 3-601 [Proposed Use: ConstructIOn of a 740 sq ft multI-use dock for 6 slIps, WIth each dock measunng 40 ft m length from the seawall (In aSSOCIation WIth an approved 6 urnt townhome project)] at 674 Bavwav Boulevard, Moonngs Townhomes II, Lots 1-6 FLD2004-07049 8 BrI2htwater Cove LLC IS requesting a FleXIble Development approval to penrut a multi-use dock for 9 slIps WIth a reduction to the SIde (east) setback from 179ft to 7 ft, a reduction to the SIde (west) setback from 179ft to 9 ft and an Increase to the WIdth of the dock from 75 percent of the lot WIdth (134 ft) to 90 5 percent of the lot WIdth (162 ft), under the prOVISIOns of Section 3-601 [Proposed Use: ConstructIOn of a 1700 sq ft multi-use dock for 9 slIps, WIth each dock measunng a maXImum of 589ft In length from the seawall (m aSSOCIatIOn WIth an approved 9 urnt townhome proJect)] at 130 BrI2:htwater Dnve, Bnghtwater Cove, Lots 1-9 FLD2004-07051 9 David A. & Sharon A. Cote are requestmg a FleXIble Development approval for (1) the TenrunatlOn of Status of NonconformIty for denSIty for the purpose of adding a 3 car garage, under the proVISIons of SectIOn 6-109, and (2) the expansIOn of attached dwellmgs WIth a reductIOn to the front (north) setback from 25 ft to 20 ft (to bUIldmg) and a reductIOn to the SIde (south) setback from lOft to 5 ft (to bUIlding), as a ReSIdential Infill Project, under the provlSlons of Section 2- 203 C [Proposed Use' ConstructIOn of a 3 car attached garage m associatIOn WIth an eXIsting nonconfonrung attached dwellIng (duplex)] at 115 North Kevstone Dnve, Keystone Manor, Blk D, Lot 1 & 20 FLD2004-06044 10 John S. Tavlor. III/Interstate Hotels and Resorts (Continental DeSIgn & SupplIes, LLC) are requesting a FleXIble Development approval to penrut a reductIOn to the number of parking spaces from 445 to 324 spaces at an eXlstmg overmght accommodatIOn and retaIl sales use (HIlton Hotel), as a ComprehenSIve Infill Redevelopment Project, under the prOVISIOns of SectIOn 2-803 C [Proposed Use: ElImmatIon of35 eXIsting parkmg spaces In Conjunction WIth Improvements to an eXIsting hotel (HIlton)] at 400 Mandalav Avenue, Sec 08-29-15, M&B 2301 FLD2004-04027 11 City of Clearwater are requestmg a FleXIble Development applIcatIOn to amend a preVIOusly approved FLD2002- 07021A (eDB approved on Apnl 15, 2003) to elIrrunate landscape Islands and separators In the parking area south of the stadIUm and to add addItIOnal land area wltlun the Progress Energy nght-of-way south of the stadIUm for grass parkmg, under the proVISIOns of SectIOns 2-704 Band 2-1404 A and to amend a prevIously approved ComprehenSIve SIgn Program (SGN2003-01002) for the stadIUm, under the prOVISIOns of Section 3-1807 (Proposed Use: AddItIOn of grass parking area wltlun Progress Energy nght-of-way adjacent to and southwest of the Bnght House Networks stadIUm, elIrrunatIon of landscape Islands and separators from paved parking area south of the stadIUm and amendment to the approved sIgnage) at 601 Old Coachman Road, Sec 07-29-16, M&B 4101 & 4301 & Clearwater Collection 2nd Replat FLD2004- 07055/SGN2004-08001 12 Clearwater Seashell Resort. L.c. IS requesting a FleXIble Development applIcatIOn to amend a preVIOusly approved FL 01-01-01 (CDB approved on February 20, 2001) to permIt an addItional 24 overnIght accommodatIOn umts from the denSIty pool (In addItion to the preVIOusly approved 250 overmght accommodation urnts) as a mIxed use, WIth a maXImum of 70,000 sq ft of amerntIes accessory to the hotel and a minImUm of 400 publIc parking spaces, as a ComprehenSIve Infill Redevelopment Project, under the prOVISIOns of SectIOn 2-803 C [Proposed Use: Hotel of 250 rooms (153 37 rooms/acre on total SIte), 18 attached dwellings (11 04 umts/acre on total SIte) and a maXImum of70,000 sq ft (0 98 FAR on total SIte) of amemtIes accessory to the hotel, at a heIght of 150 ft (to roof deck)] at 229 and 301 South Gulf VIew Boulevard and I , 230,300 and 304 Coronado Drive (Related to DV A2004-00002), lloyd-WhIte SkInner Sub, Lots 57,58,59, 104, 105 & 106 and part of Lots 56, 103, & 107 FLD2004-07052 13 Bavwatch SUItes Inc. / Valentmos Koumouhdls IS requesting a FleXIble Development application to penrut attached dwellings wIth reductIOns to the front setback from 15ft to zero ft (to pavement and trash staging area), a reductIOn to the sIde (east) setback from lOft to three ft (to pavement), reductIOns to the side (west) setback from 10 ft to 71ft (to pavement) and 73ft to bUIldmg, reductIOns of the rear setback from 20 ft to zero ft (to pool deck) and from 20 ft to 97ft (to bUIldmg), as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project, under the proVISIOns of SectIOn 2-803 C and the Transfer of Development R1ghts for 3 dwelling umts from 620 Bayway Boulevard (1 umt), 674 Bayway Boulevard (1 umt), and 645 Bayway Boulevard (1 umt) [Proposed Use. Attached dwellmg umts (19 umt condomImum, 4 levels of liVing area over ground-level parkIng)] at 600 Bavwav Boulevard, BaysIde Sub No 5, Lots 6-8 & npanan nghts FLD2004- 07050/TDR2004-09012 14 Elhs & Co., Ltd. a Flonda LimIted PatnershIp IS requesting a FleXIble Development approval for the change of use of an eXIstmg automobIle servIce station to a 2,266 sq ft restaurant, WIth a reductIOn to the front (west) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to pavement), a reduction of the front (north) setback from 25 ft to 15 ft (to pavement), reductions of the SIde (west) setback from 10 ft to 3 ft (to bUIldmg) and 10 ft to zero ft (to extenor seatmg wood deck), a reductIOn of the SIde (south) setback from 10 ft to zero ft (to pavement), as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project, under the proVISIOns of Section 2-704 C, and as part of a ComprehensIve Landscape Program, under the proVISIOns of Section 3-1202 G (proposed Use: Restaurant) at 2201 Gulf to Bav Boulevard, Sec 18-29-16, M&B 32/04 and 32/05 FLD2004-08058 15 CItv of Clearwater IS requestmg a FleXIble Development approval for mstallatIOn of a secunty fence at an eXIstIng potable water faCIlity The request Includes placement of an 8 ft fence conslstmg of masonry columns WIth substantial alummum gnllwork WIthin a front (north) setback and exemptIOn from the landscapIng reqUIrements along the proposed cham link fenCing proposed for the eastern and southern property boundanes, as a ComprehensIve Infill Redevelopment Project, per sectIOn 2-1204 A (Proposed Use: Secunty Fence) at 2775 State Road 580, Sec 29-28-16, M&B 31/01 FLD2004-09064 16 Ronald J. & MireJlle Pollack are requestmg a FleXIble Development for an addItion to an eXIsting sIngle-fanuly reSIdence The request IS for reduction to the Coastal Construction Control Lme (west) setback from 25 ft to 8 ft to the structure, as part of a ReSidential Infill Project under the proVISIOns of SectIOn 2-203 C (Proposed Use: Detached Dwelling) at 1000 Eldorado Avenue, Mandalay, Blk 69, Lot 6 & part of Lot 5 & npanan nghts FLD2004-08056 n Manal 011, Inc. IS requestmg an Appeal of an adnumstrative detenrunation denymg the expanSIOn of the retaIl sales portIOn \.(Jonvemence store) of a nonconfonrung automobIle servIce statIOn, under the proVISions of Sections 4-501 A 2 and 4-503 (Proposed Use: ExpanSIOn of an automobIle servIce statIOn) at 1310 Cleveland Street, Brookwood Terrace ReVised, Blk 2, Lots 30-33 APP2004-00006 Interested partIes may appear and be heard at the heanngs or file wntten notIce of approval or ObjectIOn WIth the Planmng DIrector or City Clerk pnor to the heanngs Any person who deCIdes to appeal any deCISIon made by the Board, WIth respect to any matter conSIdered at such heanngs, will need to request and obtam party status by the Board dunng the case diSCUSSIOn, a record of the proceedmgs and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedmgs IS made, whIch record mcludes the testimony and eVIdence upon whIch the appeal IS to be based per Flonda Statute 2860105 Commumty Development Code Section 4-206 states that party status shall be granted by the Board If person requestmg such demonstrates that s/he IS substantially affected Party status entitles parties to personally testify, present eVIdence, argument and Witnesses, cross-exanune Witnesses, appeal the deCISIOn and speak on reconSIderatIOn requests An oath Will be admImstered sweanng all partICIpants m public heanng cases If you WIsh to speak please Wait to be recognIzed, then state and spell your name and prOVIde your address Persons speakmg before the CDB shall be limited to three mmutes unless an mdlvldual IS representmg a group m whIch case the Chairperson may authonze a reasonable amount of time up to 10 mmutes FIve days pnor to the meetmg, staff reports and recommendatIOns on the above requests WIll be avaIlable for revIew by mterested parties between the hours of 8 30 a m and 4 30 pm, weekdays, at the City of Clearwater, Planmng Department, 100 S Myrtle Ave, Clearwater, FL 33756 Please contact Frank Gerlock, Development ReView Manager, at 562-4557 to dISCUSS any questIOns or concerns about the proJect and/or to better understand the proposal and revIew the site plan ThIS notice was sent by the OffiCIal Records and LegIslative SerVIces Department, CynthIa E Goudeau, CMC, CIty Clerk l CyndI Tarapam Planmng Department CynthIa E Goudeau, CMC CIty Clerk City of Clearwater POBox 4748, Clearwater, FL 33758-4748 NOTE Apphcant or representatIve must be present at the heanng YOU ARE BEING SENT THIS NOTICE IF YOU ARE THE APPLICANT OR OWN PROPERTY WITHIN 200 FT OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY A COpy OF THIS AD IN LARGE PRINT IS A V AILABLE IN THE OFFICIAL RECORDS AND LEGISLATIVE SERVICES DEPT. ANY PERSON WITH A DISABILITY REQUIRING REASONABLE ACCOMMODA nON IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING SHOULD CALL THE OFFICIAL RECORDS AND LEGISLA TIVE SERVICES DEPT WITH THEIR REQUEST AT (727) 562-4090. Ad 10/03/04 $ /lJ/() - /JfJl. /1~()'I" daOdltJ -/3/~ C L,:t/6L-J'lII/) oJr TRUSTEE CO TRE #\)55011006 TRUST 31564 US HIGHWAY 19N PALM HARBOR FL 34684 - 3723 AUSTIN, ANN S TRE AUSTIN, ROBERT P TRE 9490 HARBOR GREENS WAY # 402 SEMINOLE FL 33776 - 1269 FORREST, YVONNE 100 WAVERLY WAY # 205 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6062 TSAI, STANLEY T TSAI, ANNE R 1886 DEL ROBLES DR CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 6429 KAJGANIC, MILAN KAJGANIC, LJUBAN 1 00 WAVERLY WAY # 203 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6062 CAUSEVIC, ENVER 383 REVERE BEACH BLVD # 12 REVERE MA 02151 - 4857 SMILEY, DAVID 48A FENTIMAN RD OVAL LONDON SW8 1 LF 00003 GREAT BRITAIN DA ROS, GRAZIELLA 100 WAVERLY WAY # 106 CLEARWATER FL 33756- OLIVETO, SUSAN 100 WAVERLY WAY # 302 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6089 JENSEN, KURT SPELL, C BRUCE DUNN, E M JENSEN, LEORA L SPELL, MYRTLE DUNN, JEAN F DORPSSTRAA T 98 100 WAVERLY WAY # 307 PO BOX 13095 NIGTVECHT 1393 NK 00015- CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6089 ST PETERSBURG FL 33733 - 3095 NETHERLANDS LUHOWY, GEORGE GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED PAP ADAMI, PETRO 100 W A VERL Y WAY # 208 C/O PROPERTY TAX SECTION PAPADAMI, EDUART CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6062 PO BOX 152206 1861 S BETTY LN IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 CLEARWATER FL 33756 -1718 FERWERDA, DIANE L THOMAS, KlMBERL Y D KENT, BYRON A 302 CHANNEL DR 100 WAVERLYWAY#407 KENT, LINDA TAMPA FL 33606 - 3718 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6094 10649 BRIDLE PATH LN UNION KY 41091 - 9519 BARRON, ROBERT S QUICK, LOUISE D CLARK, DA VID BARRON, PATRICIA S PO BOX 5 100 WAVERLY WAY # 304 2196 LAMAR ST POLO IL 61064 - 0005 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6089 EDGEWATER CO 80214 -1050 CLUSTER, EMMA DIAMOND, SPURGEON 0 GUILFORD, MARILYN B 100 WAVERLY WAY # 202 JESSUP, SHARRON R 306 PEACHTREE RD CLEARWATERFL 33756 - 6062 130 HICKMAN ST WALTERBORO SC 29488 - 2883 BOLTON ON L7E 2P2 00030- CANADA GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED JADE GROUP GARCIA, BRENDA C/O PROPERTY TAX SECTION 1255 CLEVELAND ST #300 PO BOX 94 PO BOX 152206 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4917 TAMPA FL 33601 - 0094 IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 LOPEZ, EDGAR M JOHNSON, STACEY QUINONEZ, MYRIAM LOPEZ, CHERYL A 100 WAVERLY WAY # 402 100 W A VERL Y WAY # 406 254 ANDOVER SPARTA RD CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6092 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6094 NEWTON NJ 07860 - 6103 ~ \. C00K, DAVID J v COOK, BETTY L 347 E THIRD AVE MOUNT DORA FL 32757 - 5654 FRANKS, ERNEST W 1 00 WAVERLY WAY # 408 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6094 ORTIZ, JAIME A 100 WAVERLY WAY # 110 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6062 VAUGHN, PAT A 1326 PIERCE ST # 2 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6083 AUSTIN, ANN S 9490 HARBOR GREENS WAY # 402 SEMINOLE FL 33776 - 1269 LITTON, JEFFREY R 100 WAVERLY WAY # 102 CLEARWATER FL 33757- KNELL, CARMEN BEl WESSNER JOSEPH- TREFFERT STR 8 64625 BENSHEIM 00004- GERMANY VLACIC, MIRKO VLACIC, JELA 100 WAVERLY WAY # 210 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6062 DURHAM, MICHAEL 100 W A VERL Y WAY # 401 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6092 VA TIST AS, PETER VA TIST AS, ELENA K 2969 FIELD BROOK PL CLEARWATER FL 33761 - 2599 SMADJA, JEAN-CLAUDE SMADJA, MARIE C C/O CHIC REALTY 631 CLEVELAND ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - GENTILIN, DA VIDE VIA CERCHIARA # 55 CASTELFRANCO- VENETO TREVISO 31033 00026- IT AL Y VERHOEVEN, PETER BARONE, LESLIE 1 00 WAVERLY WAY # 409 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6094 SCHIESTL, JOHN H 100 WAVERLY WAY # 201 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6062 WAVERLY TOWERS CONDO ASSN 100 WAVERLY WAY STE411 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6094 F Y P ENTERPRISES INC 6518 THOROUGHBRED LOOP ODESSA FL 33556 - 1859 J P MORGAN CHASE BANK TRE ATTNWATSON,J 345 PARK AVE NEW YORK NY 10154 - 0004 POCOTOPAUG INV INC 1315 CLEVELAND ST CLEARWATERFL 33755 - 5102 MC CLERNAN, GARY M 2232 WILLOWBROOK DR CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 6743 GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED C/O PROPERTY TAX SECTION PO BOX 152206 IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 MC FADYEN, BARBARA 100 WAVERLY WAY # 310 CLEARWATERFL 33756 - 6092 FINKLE, LARRY ALTNER, MARTIN PO BOX 1992 LARGO FL 33779 - 1992 ANDERSON, CARL ANDERSON, SHANNON 2716 LAKE HOLLOW RD BERTHOUD CO 80513 - 8413 JANNELLI, GILBERT G 909 S FORT HARRISON AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 3903 LAGOS, MARKOS K LAGOS, SEV ASTI 1452 STURBRIDGE CT DUNEDIN FL 34698 - 2262 SOCIETY ST VINCENT DE PAUL COUNCIL PINELLAS COUNTY INC 1015 CLEVELAND ST CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 4515 VICTORE, ANTJE E 100 WAVERLY WAY # 405 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 6094 OLIVETO, MARY LOU 1 00 WAVERLY WAY CLEARWATER FL 33756 -7022 SPAULDING, MARTHA A PO BOX 1049 HOLLIS NH 03049 - 1049 BEAULIEU, PETER G BEAULIEU, CECILIA R 18 MOUNT AINVIEW RD LEOMINISTER MA 01453 - 3439 ~ LOFGREN, ANNA CLEARWATER, CITY OF MNEKINC LOFGREN, CHRISTOPHER G PO BOX 4748 2447 ISLANDER CT 10 1 GARLAND CIR CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 PALM HARBOR FL 34683 - PALM HARBOR FL 34683 - 5171 ANDRUS, BRIAN L ANDRUS, BRIAN L GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED 500 N OSCEOLA AVE # PH-E 500 N OSCEOLA AVE PH-E C/O PROPERTY TAX SECTION CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 3947 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 3933 PO BOX 152206 IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 TURNER, WILLIAM D CAROTHERS, WAYNE C ESMAIL, Y ASMIN TURNER, DOTTIE CAROTHERS, JOYCE B 16378 NORTHDALE OAKS 531 GREENWOOD AVE 1475 EXCALlBER DR TAMPA FL 33624 - 1319 CLARKSVILLE TN 37040 - 3713 CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 2873 GENTILE, GERALD T LOFGREN, ANNA DURFEE, JOHN A GENTILE, DENISE 101 GARLAND CIR 22 N FREDRICA AVE 1965 MAGNOLIA AVE PALM HARBOR FL 34683 - 5171 CLEARWATERFL 33755 - 5136 CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 4791 LENSE INC GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED MNEKINC 1320 CLEVELAND ST C/O PROPERTY TAX DEPT 2447 ISLANDER CT CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 5101 PO BOX 152206 PALM HARBOR FL 34683 - IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED MIDNIGHT ROSE INC TRE TOMIK, RUDOLF C/O PROPERTY TAX SECTION TRUST 108 LADY MARY 30 N LADY MARY DR #7 PO BOX 152206 PO BOX 413 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 5126 IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 CLEARWATER FL 33757 - 0413 BEAULIEU, PETER G CLEARWATER, CITY OF SMITH, ALICE M BEAULIEU, CECELlA L PO BOX 4748 113 N FREDRICA AVE 18 MOUNTIANVIEW RD CLEARWATER FL 33758 - 4748 CLEARWATERFL 33755 - 5139 LEOMINSTER MA 01453 - CAROTHERS, SHIRLEY S MNEKINC GTE FLORIDA INCORPORATED 21 N FREDRICA AVE 2447 ISLANDER CT C/O PROPERTY TAX SECTION CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 5137 PALM HARBOR FL 34683 - PO BOX 152206 IRVING TX 75015 - 2206 MANAL OIL INC WRIGHT, DAVID H BEAULIEU, PETER G 1310 CLEVELAND ST WRIGHT, TINA V BEAULIEU, CECELlA L CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 5101 3102 BISHOP DR 18 MOUNTIANVIEW RD SAFETY HARBOR FL 34695 - LEOMINSTER MA 01453 - 5007 PINELLAS PUBLIC LIBRARY J P MORGAN CHASE BANK Fowler ASSOCiates ArchItects, Inc COOP TRE 1421 Court St - SUite D 1330 CLEVELAND ST 375 E ELLIOT STE 12 Clearwater, FL 33756 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 5103 CHANDLERAZ 85225- .. q~teway Neighborhood Paul Charles 1367 Park St Clearwater, FL 33756 Clearwater Neighborhood CoalitiOn Doug Williams, PreSident 2544 Fnsco Dr Clearwater, FL 33761