APP2004-00003
APP2004-00003
2959 EAGLE ESTATES CIR W
J FFREY AND AMBRYN FINSTA
PLANNER OF RECORD:" WW
ATLAS # 200B
ZONING: LDR
LAND USE: RS
RECEIVED: 03/30/2004
INCOMPLETE:
COMPLETE:
MAPS:
PHOTOS:
STAFF REPORT:
DRC:
CDB:
CL W CoverSheet
"
- ....
Planning Department
100 South Myrtle Avenue
Clearwater, Florida 33756
Telephone 727-562-4567
Fax. 727-562-4576
CASE#' ~ t) 000'3
DATE RECEIVED _ ~+ -=
RECEIVED BY (staff Initials) ~W
U SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIGNED AND NOTARIZED APPLICATION
o SUBMIT 12 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION
o SUBMIT APPLICATION FEE $~~~~
APPEAL APPLICATION
L...\ dOn... ,mtl L...\ d T\\tl R..."...\" (R...\'l.....tI 03 29'0 I)
-PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT-
APPLICATION/NOTICE OF APPEAL (Code Section 4-502.A & B)
An appeal of a level one approval (flexible standard) may be mltlated by a property owner abutting the property which IS the subject of the approval
within seven days of the date the development order IS Issued The filing of an applicatlonl notice of appeal shalf stay the effect of the decIsion
pendmg the final determination ofthe case
An applicatlonl notice of appeal of appeal of any deCiSion of the city, as proVided In Section 4-501, may be Initiated by the applicant or any person
granted party status Wlthm 14 days of the deCiSion Such application shall be filed with the city clerk In a form speCified by the community
development coordmator Idenllfymg WIth speCificity the baSIS for the appeal and a=mpanled by a fee as reqUJred by Sedlon 4-202 E The filing
of an appllcatlonl notice of appeal shall stay the effect of the deCISion pending the final determination of the case
A. APPELLANT AND AGENT INFORMATION:
APPEllANT NAME M " d19..~i__t__S:b:f~~ ~e
MAILING ADDRESS 2~"'0 Tc..\ot'\ l)~~ve
PHONENUMBER 111 1'1"- 501 b
MQ.~k~~~_______________________
C lea. V UI ~-it.~ F L. ~'?, 1 b \
FAX NUMBER ,"1 4i~ - "s1's
AGENT NAME
MAILING ADDRESS
PHONE NUMBER
FAX NUMBER
B. APPEAL INFORMATION
CHECK THE SPECIACAPPEAl
Aooeals to the Commurotv Oeveloorrent Board
o Orders, requirements, deCISions or determmatlons made by
an admmlstratlve offiCial In the administration of the
development code, except for enforcament actions
o Administrative mterpretatlOns of the development code
o level One (FleXible and Minimum Stanclan:l) approval
dooslons
o Denials of any permit or license ISSUed under the provIsions
ofthls Code
Aooeals to a hear/na officer
o DeCISions of the community development board regarding
level two approvals
'tit DeCISions o(the community development board regarding
level one approvals
o OTHER (as allowed by Code)
SPECIFIC CASE NUMBER TO BE APPEALED (If applicable)
DA 1E OF DECISION J.l' (. \ 0 +
Ea~le ~~~tes C'~G\-e \N.
^PP'tOO~ - OOOO~
ADDRESS OF SUBJECT APPEAL (If applicable) 2't 51
Page 1 of 2 - Appeal Application (level One and level Two Revlews)- CIty of Clearwater
..
C. BASIS OF APPEAL
Explain In detail the basIs for the appeal Use additional sheets If necessary
<1LA\\ ~ S5\\eS i~ ~e O\l'i~~MA.l ~eA.\ Atfl;.-f~+;!"'~ D.*"C~(,~-"
&-I~~__~d:i3-_~CN\G..(a~_~L__9Nhc~h'~~L~d' ~_~~C).
~W\P" ~er 4ff\~'o" of *hL_b~~de~ ~f froof - frt~ h,,~
~ ~v,Y't ~,~C~__~~ l'~ to s~tl~.ny__~V!re"'fl\~_
~ ~~~C}-;-~l~ C,t:\-\"O'" \r\ ~e fi~t ~,e
@J i~l~~~~~\4f__~~C~~ tYE:~ +,~~ If ~eQ.1 \) of C,'~ staff
____!kc.\'\i I)" o.s a. * ~~ea.t 'W ;~_~e \od-e.~ s" ifl~:~L
:hL--:-~~j ~t__~~.eV'~_~~_~-,-iv ~ll~_~_~~~~~ t.s _<L-4e ~ ~VQ
\'e\l\eW j ~\.AI'tI'le" I w~ ~~ de l~t>~ ve"levJ-7~~~-h'D~_
____~2~1L_'_)--~~.H~w~~ l)J; __ ~_ Q.&~ ---~"'-Y--- c J't-y--~"htff----
___~ec.~'f)V\ ~~ ~~jUj. \'t5~'G~ COB ~ ~~e..\y
. . . u. -.. l ))
v-tv,ew 'A!-+~ Q..Ne~
D. SIGNATURE:
I, the undersigned, acknowledge that all representations made In this
application are true and accurate to the best of my knowledge
STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINELLAS IIq+-h
~H t~ I_and subscrIbed before me thiS ~ clay of
~l;!..J..____ A D 20J:2!::1: to me and/or by
I~h()e I C~~~_, who IS Jl8rsonally Imn1111Q has
produced _~= as
Identification
;t:tQ cMe-
~'~a.I~R
Notary public,
My commiSSion expires-
Signature of property olMler or representatJve
\IMS2.PDW/anmng DepartmenflApplicalloo Fotms'deve/opment f8VIevM.ppeal AppliCBItoo doc
~",,\"11l ""////.
~",,,, ~e~\ne A ~ I'IJ'~
~ CJ~ ........ 19% ~
~ ...~"'\SS,OAt~...fO ~
~ ........ CjO ~~er 10 ~... ~
: :~ ~'lJ "~a~" ~
=*_ C) ~(I>.::
=: ..... :*=
~ ~ \ #00054679 i 3" ~
~::A.. ..~~
;'-;,;~/_" ~~edll\~ ..'~~
~ T,C,"7.<anHnSlJf"':-.. ~ ~
~ U'B. ........ cf< ~
;.'1,1. 'LtC ST""i~ 1\"~
I"'//,ill II 1""\''\
Page 2 of 2 - Appeal Application (level One and level Two Revlews)- City of Clearwater
...
'"
CASE #:
DATE RECEIVED
RECEIVED BY (staff mrtlals)
, ' ,
~ SUBMIT ORIGiNAl SIGNED AND NOTARIZED APPLICATION
o SUBMIT 12 COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL APPliCATION
~ SUBMIT APPUCATION FEE $ lOO.DO '-~,
"
-.
"
. ,
.,."" ....~::-.. :4
APPEAL APPLICATION
1: ..-~ '!...~
L.<~t.'l On....md L.<vt.'l T'kll R.,~1~ (R;n'.....d 03;29;01,
j--
-PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT-
APPUCATIONINOTlCE OF APPEAL (Code Section 4-502.A & B) '""
_ _ ., .. "_. :-.._ :....f_ ~ _~_I...~ >..~t_ .. .~... ........__.....''>f_1
;. _.r ~
...
An appral of a level ate approval (f1exlble standard) may be InrtJatecI by: a property owner abutlmg -the property wtuch IS the suqect of the approval
'Mthln seven days ri the date the development order IS iSsued. The fiung ri an application/ ootJce of appear shalt stay the elrect of the deCl5lat
pencingthefi!'8l_deterlmmtlo_n~t~e_case. ____:._:.r>~ _~~-:..:___ !:::'..:...~'(~_'~~'_.::'~_"~.,__.:'-'._'.:- _ ___: _:;\ _~ "~':
An application! ncllce ci appeal of appeal af any decslon af the CIty, as proVIded In SectJat 4-501. may be InitIated by the applicant or any parsat
granted party status 'Mthm 14 days af the decslOn. Such applicabon - shall be filed WIth the CIty clerk In a fonn speCIfied by the community
- - development coorrfnator Idenf1(ymg 'Mth speatiClty the ba5lS for the appea and a=mpBlled by a fee as requred by Sedlon 4-202 E The tilIng ._
.afan appllcalJonI notice ci appeal shall stay the effect afthe deClSlat pendIng the final detennmatJat afthe case.
I
A. APPELLANT AND AGENT INFORMATION~ ,. ,
AP~um'~E. M~ v~e~ - ~. S{eJ~~,~' M~k~ ;: ':'\-- ~
MAlUNGAOORESS. trI lCf(QD -rttQ.<n\ 1)~i're C\la~'~~
PHONENUMBER: ~h,7 1'1. b- 507to
... r',.,.
~1b'
FAX NUf.>B~: 7 i 1 41- ~ - ~ 51 8
J
AGENT NAME.
t 1"" l..l k
~ .. t ~~
MAlUNG ADDRESS
-
). .-=~ /"f'. r '""
Ilo.\. <(,. ......~__ ~ ", ~
PHONE NVMBER:
, ... - ~'FAXNVAiER-'-~'
B. APPEAL INFORMATION
;;:
CHECK THE SPEOACAPPEAl '"
Aooeals to the Commurotv DeveIooment Board
o Orders, reqUIrements, deCISions or detennlnaboos made by
an admlnrstrabve offiCIal In the admlOlstration af the
development code, ex=~ forertcrc;ement actlOIlS.
o Admmlstrabve Interpretatlons of the development code
V level One (FreXlbre and Mlnrmum Standardt approval
deCISIOns
CJ Denrals of arry pennrt or 'Icense ISSUed under the prOVISions
ofthls Code
ADoeaIs to a hearlna officer
o DeClSloOS of the communty development board regarding
level two approvals
o DeClSlatS o(the commul1ty development bOard rogardlng
level ~~e approvals
CJ OTHER (as alrowed by Code)
ADDRESS OF SUBJECT APPEAl ~f apprcable). '2. C{ 5''9 '
~{~' 'k-~~ C;rc-le
f LS :2..00?, - O~ 0';'3
\Nest-
SPEOAC CASE NUMBER TO BE APPEAlED (If applcable)
DAlE OF DEosrON. (0 12- "t I 0 ~
.
" -
. ~ '1 ..
Page 1 FA 2"7' ~ppe~ Appl;~at q.~~(~1i ~g l~! l:~ ~>-i...~Y !?!.qlE!.~.er
, ' _ , "i'
~ ....;. ~\'l -' ,. .....,.
t ~
, '
t
, I,..) .t ?<t'
~i~ ..._
_ ~ t"~ , .. ~~.. ~
... 1( J ... ...
, '
,- ,
, }\ h 1'\1 ~~"'~ 'l" ~... l"\-f~
\. r' ... ( ...., ~s". \ t "..." _,,;: '" .. ~.
"
, ,
- ,
, , ~ ~ ;r." ~ ",
~.. " ! 1 r"'" ',. " - '"
rJj..?!~J '+ "
."...... ../~, ..... ..,
;. }":~ ;
\. t~;}tX", . ,
~.J;, l' " " ",
')~"Y ~\... .' ., , ~
f
"
,
r/
C. BASIS OF APPEAL:
Explain In detail the baSIS for the apPeal Use additional sheets If necessary.
Ba.<es ~: ~ '" d v.{1.p ..fL,. ~ U l:)w ~3 :' " .'
I} -ttu G.ff11wle s~L\&.s ~ Cr-,~~Cl C~ VMc."I\S~+~o"v\o..(\y \(~\{e Cl..n& ~~l~
. ,\\ AV\ ,~~e.t" ~kl^j of ~~1I~t'5 p ~~ ~11Ac.ut: &.~e. PvO<:..HS)
-.1:lif V'u.L'cl) --rLte Uf.pliu...hle ~~~&A ~ Cr~~,~ eA.h1\'ot be. ~"rly &pplie&.-h
~e.. V"eG\v.zs+e& W\o~- \L.H~. \Iq,V'I~tt: .
\ ,
3) +~e ~\\~-t ~ ~lec! -to ~~)i1h a,.,..y
+) ~e &evtlopMe...it ~ l; \\.<>+ S'ffCkU ~
e-v, del\c.e ; _
Athe ~ rovt.,J. \S CtA~I~Y J dikr;M;AI1'\-nvy ~&. UNlrt.a.tdV\cJ.,k "
(p) t~e ~V1'C~ I'?, 11\(''"'f.~1 s+e...k, v...~ ...-eccv-ckc! c9.-u&- ~-h--; (~'OIIS ~& ~Ill+s
ly\ ~ vi~\t\.~o(\ o-f CtJlfe.tl~-1i ~irnc:tvcJ.. * ~~ -"'W'-~j\~;' a..,&.
...J.) +4f l:.M&.I~OI\S - c&. \.\.of MI^:Mi zP. o.d\l'e...vse_ e.tfe.c.1;.,
"} 'h''''~ I "'-,'
~~ bY Ihlrra.d'\c~l;~.;
$~Sn....~'cJ. .~~
D. SIGNATURE:
/LQer Jt.Q{L ,
Signature of property Cl'M1er or representative
STATE OF FLORlDA, COUNTY OF PfNElLAS J 'f-h
to a d subscnbed before me thIs ~ clay of
A.D. 20..QE to me and/or by
. h who IS personally known has
produced as
ro.R~iL (L [.ffl/JP
Notary public,
My commiSSIon expires:
I, the lUlderslgned, acknowledge that all representatIons made In this
applicatIon are true and a=rate to the best of my knCMIedge.
\\MS2tPDSlPJanning DepartmenMpp/icat1OO t=rJmWdeveJopment revifNMppaal Applir;alioo doc
"
"'
~\\\\\I\lIl'''''ll -
~"" ~etlne A ,,'11/,;
~ C;?f< ......~ '16'"" ~
.;::; ..' "'ISS/Q '0 "fa ~
~ .' Qv,.... w~7..::'C ~
.;::; o' "., G ,,\\\ber 10 't"<>.. '. ~
.... __--.. 'U'U I_~ ~. ~
=- .~~ ~-~.::;.
:*: <1'(1): =
=z: .... :*=
~ a ~ #D0054679 : ~
:;~ e. .. ~~
~~"'~~~ o"~S"
~_.... '. ~., ~.SS ~
....~ G1'~,,"'''''''_~ ....~'"
~/" ~ STA1t. \J',\,"
1/111I'/1111\"""
"
Page 2 r:J 2 - Appeal Application (level One and level Two ReVlews)- City of Clearwater
I
Receipt #: 1200400000000003340
Date: 03/30/2004
3/30/2004
24105PM
Line Items:
Case No
Tran Code
Descnption
Revenue Account No
Amount Paid
APP2004-00003
Appeals Fee - Heanng Officer
010-341262
Lme Item Total:
500 00
$500.00
Payments:
Method
Payer
Bank No
Account No
Confirm No
How Received
Amount Paid
Payment Total:
"
500 l '
$500.00
Check
MICHAEL C MARKHAM
dr
4635
In Person
,~
THIS IS NOT A PERMIT.
ThiS IS a receipt for an application for a permit
ThiS application will be reviewed and you will be notified as to the outcome of the application
cRccelpl rpl
Page I of 1
Wells, Wayne
From
Sent
To'
Subject
Gerlock, Chip
Thursday, July 01, 2004 9 51 AM
Wells, Wayne
FW Markham v City
Looks like It IS finally overl
-----Onglnal Message-m-
From: Tarapam, Cyndl
Sent: Thursday, July 01, 20049 17 AM
To: Watkins, Sherry
Cc: Gerlock, Chip, Fierce, Lisa
Subject: FW Markham v City
Sheuy-please pnnt and put a copy of the DOAH order ill the flie and close out the file
Clup-please share wIth the ca~e planner-I can't lemember whose case thIS was Thanks
Cyndl Tarapani
Planrung Du:ector
(727) 562-4547
cynd1 taraparu@MyClearwater com
--mOnglnal Messagem--
From: Dougall-Sides, Leslie
Sent: Wednesday, June 30, 2004 3 46 PM
To: Tarapam, Cyndl
Cc: Hollander, Gwen
Subject: Markham v City
The Order ClOSing File was posted on the DOAH webslte yesterday
http //www doah state fl us/docdoc/2004/001673/04001673DWHO PDF
ThiS Will conclude the case for purposes of permit Issuance to the Flnstads
1
,,1 . '\
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
MICHAEL MARKHAM AND STEFANIE
MARKHAM,
Appellants,
VS.
Case No. 04-1673
CITY OF CLEARWATER,
Appellee.
ORDER CLOSING FILE
This cause havlng come before the underslgned on the Notlce
of Wlthdrawal of Appeal, flIed June 28, 2004" and the
underslgned belng fully advlsed, it lS, therefore,
ORDERED that:
1. The flnal hearlng In thlS cause scheduled for July 21,
2004, is hereby cancelled
2 The flle of the D1V1Slon of Admlnlstratlve Hearlngs In
the above-captloned matter lS hereby closed.
DONE AND ORDERED thlS 29th day of June, 2004, In
Tallahassee, Leon County, Florlda
8~
J. LAWRENCE JOHNSTON
Admlnlstratlve Law Judge
D1V1Slon of Admlnlstratlve Hearlngs
The DeSoto BUlldlng
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Florlda 32399-3060
(850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675
Fax Flllng (850) 921-6847
www.doah.state fl us
,/ . c.
Flled wlth the Clerk of the
D1V1Slon of Admlnlstratlve Hearings
thlS 29th day of June, 2004.
COPIES FURNISHED:
Leslle K Dougall-Sldes, Esqulre
Clty of Clearwater
Post Offlce Box 4748
Clearwater, Florlda 33758-4748
Mlchael Markham
Stefanle Markham
2960 Talon Drlve
Clearwater, Florlda 33761
~
Watkins, Sherry
From'
Sent
To
Subject.
Tarapanl, Cyndl
Monday, June 28, 2004 11 13 AM
Planning
FW Markham Appeal Withdrawn
FYI
John-please put a hold on any pernnts until we get the DOAH order
Sherry-please file with appeal case Thanks
Cyndi Tarapani
Planrung Dltector
(727)562-4547
cyndt taraparu@MyClearwatercom
-----Onglnal Message--m
From: Dougall-Sides, Leslie
Sent: Monday, June 28, 2004 11 06 AM
To: Tarapanl, Cyndl
Subject: RE Markham Appeal Withdrawn
Yes, however, any permit should not be Issued until DOAH Issues Its Order closing the file ("final determination of the
case"), which should be promptly
-----Onglnal Messagem--
From: Tarapanl, Cyndl
Sent: Monday, June 28, 2004 10 51 AM
To: Dougall-Sides, Leslie
Subject: RE Markham Appeal Withdrawn
so dlat means that the CDB declSlon stands::>
Cyndi Tarapam
Planrung Dltector
(727)562-4547
cyndt taraparu@MyClearwater com
-----Onglnal Message-----
From: Dougall-Sides, Leslie
Sent: Monday, June 28, 2004 10 50 AM
To: Tarapanl, Cyndl
Subject: Markham Appeal Withdrawn
We have Just received by fax a Notice of Withdrawal of Appeal filed by the Markhams
Therefore, DOAH Will be canceling the July 21 oral argument and clOSing ItS file
1
Jun 15 04 04:58p
C 1 t. qttorne~
727c:q,24021
p. 1
'-'
---
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
MICHAEL MARKHAM AND STEFANIE
MARKHAM ,
Appellants,
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Case No. 04-1673
vs.
CITY OF CLEARWATER,
Appellee.
NOTICE OF HEARING
Oral argument will be held in this case at the City Hall,
Large Conference Room 313, 112 South Osceola Avenue, Clearwater,
Florida, on June 29, 2004, at 1:00 p.m., or as soon thereafter
as can be heard. Continuances will be granted only by order of
the Administrative Law Judge for good cause shown.
ISSUE: See Appeal Application, filed May 7, 2004.
Section 4-505, City of Clearwater Code.
AUTHORITY:
May 21, 2004
B~
J LAWRENCE JOHNSTON
Administrat~ve Law Judge
Division of Administrative Hearings
The DeSoto Bu~lding
1230 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3060
(850) 488-9675 SUNCOM 278-9675
Fax Filing (850) 921-6847
www.doah.state.fl.us
7671
Date
From
/ '7 .' ~
CoJDepl
Co
Phone II
Fax # J ~ ~:s-
Phone 1/
Fax #
..It,,>
\
.
c,> ':f"';/
~-~-~"lc ~
J.(.I ITY OF
C -L -E~ A-RW ATE R
!
POST OFFICE Box 4748, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33758-4748
CI1Y HALL, 112 SOUTH OSCEOlA AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756
TELEPHONE (727) 562-4010 FAX (727) 562-4021
Ci1Y ArroRNEY's OFFICE
May 5, 2004
K[EC[E~V[ED
James W York, Deputy Chief Judge
DIvIsion of Administrative Hearings
The DeSoto BUilding
1230 Apalachee
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1550
~{~y 0 0 2U04
r~J\~~:;\jG [[)[EPAR1M~u\]T
cnv OF CLEARWATER
RE'
r of Board Decision Upholding Staff
Dear Judge York
Enclosed are two copies of the following file documents, together with one verbatim
cassette audio recording of the proceedings regarding the above-referenced case
before the Community Development Board, whose decIsIon IS being appealed by
Michael and Stefanle Markham
1 Appeal Application by Michael and Stefanle Markham, Appellants, received
March 30, 2004
2 Minutes of March 16,2004 Community Development Board meeting
3 Materials from prevIous appeal to Community Development Board.
4. Planning Department file on Flexible Standard Development application No
FLS2003-08038, including supporting materials
For the convenience of the parties and witnesses please schedule the oral argument in
Clearwater. You may contact Gwen Hollander In the City Attorney's Office at 562-4010
to schedule City Commission chambers, the City Manager's large conference room, or
other City locations
BRIAN] AUNGST, MAYOR-COMMISSIONER
HoYT HAMILTON, VICE MAYOR-COMMISSIONER WHITNEY GRAY, COMMISSIONER
FRANK HIBBARD, COMMISSIONER . BILL]ONSON, COMMISSIONER
"EQUAL EMPI OYMFNT AND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION EMPLOYFR"
I
(
tJ
"
~
Please advise the parties as soon as an administrative law judge IS assigned to this
case.
Very truly yours,
') &-
\ ' It,) .
I .I', '/_ '
't ~ ( ^ I Irff(J - J..(!,
Leslie K. Dougall-Side's )
Assistant City Attorney
Enclosures
Copies [letter only] to.
Appellants /
City Clerk
Planning Director