The URL can be used to link to this page

03/18/1993s 'i r , t r . ° I I ' ! . ! ,`I -`:r' !?ti •.itd`1 hl.A,.,v i; ?! y?t-?=..? A-rf .rc % T )t I . .. _ ' i ; rT -p '---.', It, .r _ t"I ;, i'y,? h I f r,. . , c t'` r . . , . ,, . -. . ,. . ?f . a If' - I .. , r . .. 'r:, ,I . . t i'•`•;114?.' t t I - t_Y is l' r .: ti' :s? .. rt. r .r,. l,. •:f ..`q.,F r'?{r=r'T, I i, .. .i I ; - .; ,. ..?. ',' ,.p- .1,. ..aisI'y,^?- •+. .f, DI !. ', ` .f?., r.' ,!, ,. - I , ; ..l;, "f . I ,'•???. ?5ihh' •°' a ? r. f~ . i' .a4; i .?., r f. 'f .?), .? L°.'• " , . 1 ., ,1' , ,pC". I.1 v `'S. 'Y, .!i` i-I-i ",' i {' -i .t +rrrl," i ,i ale '•r .,. r. ;r•,. .3: 'I I :1 I T,t, ,' r.Of: e.+ ' ,; of - ' + ,1s• N'tTS:'0"WI r.. Y51a .AY r. . , ,.. . 3: l.-.- .„• -1. .F. ,.,< 'f. (' z f? '•I 'i.' t,.i' ''t .Y .?.( 'i, a. •f "iF^1'. ,p.. .-}q} °a. t. y .tt "Yr' .?.. .tr 't 'f. k t. '' j : "i { :.t i' ^':, .gyp ,.,. i' 'S . r 1 ,s J, .4r a. T+T1.d'. t'r ` : €Si ;;, ` ' , , r :'r. 'fir , . f..b i' • ''f . I .i ' I ` •1... 1 ' .? ` i7tt f, - ,, .`' ri i' 1,:Fi r,. ?F '; f . . ' -v " ti. . Z; r i' ." . ., . . •,. . .°. . . . , It ... e< . . . . +.-. , lit .... ,.'I„ . _ n . .-"y'4 .. . F}` „ ' t/ i ' ' r • . . .f i. .- t •133yR ;.5,'r; a .r.r . z •'l11' ,:r,' •,IC ._.". . I r r . . ... 3 1 r'. . .'t ', F '':a s ., - -+- . -.-.-...-l'..'.. , ''....-.. - AG?E.N' . ''.-?.-'?" I', '-,? -';?. ?'..-!- ?. I., . , .. ? ?. . A'4' .. -'?'-- , ? .e^ - p. `,t.. _ r ,,t . . .?i_, -"' . . .I -r, , . , .. I' 'r • C` . ?.e S' z.1sJ.`a{S' -- f I .; . r `. i t ;,.i T - , J 1' I L; "r Y J}'?=1. , ! ` - ' , ' ( '} •'I, . (t1'f! 1 , •.4 •1, r.'lf ' . . . . . . . . I ? . '? . . - '? 9* ? - - I - ' I . ' '. ? I I ? " - - - , . '-, - . ? I - ' ? ?: 11 ' 1. " ?. C? ' ' ? ' ?' . - % . ? .? ? : . '? - -. ' ? ? ! '.l. .. '? " . '` i.`. : j,, F ;'. IDIOT • . ', ? : ..I. . . ' . V.i$- T ' . . , , rf. :?':N".' . ' . , . . 1 ? t, . A f.= :r' ' . I ' " f y, I', >. tom, %; ( '- I I .. I :S,.'S 1?1.'l`f:.:W _ t t -t•'Y)i i ? ?. . ' --' ??- , ?V? . - I I "' ? ? , - ,- , '" i ,"'T? ,.' , ??'..' , - i -"? ? - '. ( '.' I - ' , '' .. 1 { { 'T , !.i r, , r e . + f F. I s ,,{ ' rid. . , t l t! f . 'i' ?l I i i° ' I r Y ,.f?l .?!a • - 1'r' q` S ^`f. . ! I r , 1 ` I °, f II t., .E i . "i. ,,i,,, i' ' : I ° } I r^ , ..? 1 - . .. I .I' •'i .- I f. I• „ r•'_ ELY, t'' 3' 1 a i :;r,YT ' i'' ; C.. : 'Yr,t . s:1. '1.. •t •'t'i si'' r. .{ i'-. '.s ?t..f1 j. T•!/ }3:f 14? .} } rl ,'?.w .w. !. •1'• .!p J. Y. _ ' ? .a+P°G>?-3 11 " ,,. 't , .f pI} ,'1 i , l. llf Y1' .1•' : +'f . ?5,3 •,ttiit: S'1:` .t 3; i ' S 7jk '.°,,,:i'r`:jFj;k' 4.: ,it.-$.- .I: l1 ,e ,'. J r.. t' I :1' ff,. lr, :e :r':i s' .tt' fi-f 'i'x• •. •e'f {! , Y,rf t r ., k S-' , r r 1, . , .+ I - ',I 11,1? x ' ' F . . YI . , y' r , • . , ' ( • i 1 ,Itb• rfl If. :f, 'f.r - f- ' f.. 1 ,F. w `[, . .r, ,r, °°f,,? d ;. =,?,: ,r. / 1 I•. i.If ii ,,: :t" J, 1,, . .'r ' , , .. . ` . • + ' 1!' ,` __ A.r`i'.' ,s r,,` {.. r .T x .= t .'t, 9 s,. . . - f? - .•F " .•,t,, :.{:. 'f.'4-' ,' '. t:'1' `} !q f , •i ,. , >•. . , 'i, i J. .r,.. ,fr?,,cJpf !•J• , a . :?, 'at 1., ,?° e?. ,°A5!e7' 1, i .Y'' 'r S r tyJf f -, 5I': <I +a i ,',4',r ;i. ..'.' I. , , r :J. •!.'i?'iir, 11 r r,?j 1s'l E? ?.' '.r; ,?` ! . .'' `i?• 1 C. " J .r?, 1" `s '+ -+ J. 'it; re :,Ali... IY!, .,r !•.z e 'k', t .4' •4 '.3` ,?.t.:".?',er `.f,.ij+ 'r'' '?. ',l4. :ter .'? i. ,f. J' .•'4:., I f •.I - l rl, 'ttr :f!', -, ,r', •,'1 , .lam' , f r„ .. "," , #. r. _ ; p t. >.:;,: Sri, •?,! ?a. ?i.- t.,,, ; . li. 0.'" i it• .. ,.i , r a. y. Jt f'ir` 'b" :l?r r, v..'. I!---:-.-, ,,.1, :,: C^ J?+r'-1:. f+ fF-. f ,4.'i; .lrr. :s :.t' { _ ,t., .. 'J' ,;,,l .lry :.. ';. r t i . . 'p . .? ;? r1 , t r ,. J'.. •' `sr L? ' t ,< f;. ; :'.:. - :. 1,, t' .i..• iti:, ,, f ,'3i ..il +}' •s:',•, , ,, •4 _-. ;,I f .;,'.. fn.t..ewl7:'e5.a.:i':a..:.,.. ,r.. .? .. .: s.':' .. r ,.. r.. - .r.Fr'.?:f' a.'J^..° .:p'd?:-• .,,,. _ .1ir` v , .?f ,,. «i•?• . ,- .... ...a.•.'l?sA I 11 ,- t? ., ?, o- •: , • Rp!•. ?1/ I 1, L. . , - , - I . . I . ? . : ? . I I I L ? . . ? 5 , _, . . ? . ., ? . I 1, I . ,j; 0 r 1 ' ..,o, . , ,., -.,? - I +L- " 1, y c {' • , r - , . : I'e: ?, ,',.,, - ' ' - 3` `? F?..'•' !_ 1 Fey '• r ' o , ' 1 fit'(., t,''f f . , , ,,? ,? I ,. 3-- .'' ' - ? . , -l': r: ?r ' . t i ','} - -- " , 1 8 9 -, ?, L ' ,' ;' , ? .'?Lt, . ? . . . I I . , ? Ul , ?? , -?,,- -?,t, ,- _ . . j f - ' ' . L • tit. .. 11 ,J' i,' F', j f r -e . ?.. t ' 1, f .. - `i.rl• ',`' ? : !' . . t 1. S _ ° r , , f : f . I r! '' • . >' ' 1 ` . ,- ,i' :, . t J Y F , f I ' . r , . y.' • t ' ! i, 1, ti , €`4 . ! '! t • .. t , I. , .. N - 'AI, ;?-, fJF of I fl. , '( - ;:r]j . 'r . . f' .. i, r J u ' 'I 1 . f -ai € ° I. r" ! , f: T„ ` •+ , ! ''f,` F - f r.I . rc i . . ` 'it, ' ' r.J , 'J. I..d - iL" 1.z , .. .'r' ' 1 '1. , r' k o F ?`'. !' , . . , r,', r' r r y ?- . .. .. ; o" -'J, a >,, .p -1' 4._ 1 . .. c ?.. , L f 'i [?, 'IY.?i",: j"r<y?.. :. !t .•?i., : ?,7- :.P_S. . o .-" - +i"-ywt 9\fr 4`rYV ti 1L} N . t-,1, '..rt #t..•..t, ,-,?} , f Order of Agenda Packs for 1992 Action Agenda - listing the Thursday, Commission Meeting Date. Preliminary Agenda (This is the agenda for the worksession that is held on the Monday prior to the Thursday meeting) Any items that were "Work Session Only" and any items that did not continue onto Thursday's' agenda as in they were "Pulled" off to possibly return at a later date. Some "WSO" items may not have any paperwork, i.e. Discussion - re:...... unless something is handed out. Any information that was received at Worksession Final Agenda - the start of the Thursday meeting "pack" the beginning 7 items are standard: Pledge of Allegiance Invocation Service Pin Awards Introductions and Awards Presentations Minutes of meetings to be approved Citizens to be heard re items not on agenda There may or. may not be any. paperwork for the above 7 items. The action agenda lists the, results of each. Also, items at the end of the agenda (Other pending matters - Other City Attorney Items - City, Manager Verbal Reports and Other Commission Action) often have no paperwork. Starting with #8 are the Items for the meeting. After each item there may be memos/information that correlate to that item which will be noted as "RE: # ". This information was not actually part of the item, it is not part of the attachments, for the item but is information that will stay in the agenda pack. to be microfilmed. After some of the items there may be, information marked as City Manager Back Up, abbreviated as CM b,u.. Again this is information that is not actually part of the agenda item but it is placed in the agenda pack. After each item there may b information regarding that item that was handed out at the meeting. This information should have the notation "Rec'v (date) When looking at an agenda cover memorandum for an item, look at the listing of attachments at the bottom of the page. If something is listed as a "plan" or, "manual" this means the agenda item could be man pages in length as that type attachment was probably in notebook form for'the meeting with the binder being removed from the original for microfilming. r '?1(. .L:r i v J r 3.. J , ' I ACTION AGENDA - CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION MEETING - March 18, 1993 (6:00 P.M.) Welcome. We are glad to have you join us. If you wish to speak please wait to be recognized, then state your namg and address. Persons speaking before the City Commission on other than Public Hearing items shall be limited to 3 minutes. No person shal l speak more than once on the same subject unless granted permission by the City Commission. 1. Pledge of Allegiance 1.'' Mayor. 2. Invocation 2. Rev-John Palarine, Episcopal Church of the 3. Service Awards Ascension. 4. Introductions and Awards 3. 2 awards presented. .5. Presentations: 4. 3193 Employee of the Month - LaVonne a) Swearing in of Police Officers Newcomber, Legal Department. 6. Minutes of.Regular Meeting March 4, 1993 Proclamation: Arbor Day - 3127193. & Special Meeting March 10; 1993 5. a) 7 Officers were administered the oath of 7. Citizens to be heard re items not on the office by the City Clerk. Agenda 6. Approved as submitted. 7. Bob Clarke said an educated workforce is necessary to compete in industry. He expressed concern regarding the incompency of bus drivers. He felt "boiler rooms" should' be legislatively controlled. Bob Wright urged review of all codes and asked same be agendeed. He complained regarding violations at 1132 Sunnydale Dr. Lois Cormier complimented the new hearing impaired devices available for meetings. She commended and thanked Commissioner Hodges for the fine job she has done. Virainia Robinson informed the Commission that Trail Ways Skate will be nationally broadcast. Not Before 6:00 P.M. - Scheduled Public Hearings (1) Presentation of issues by City staff. (5) Comments in support and in opposition: (a) (2) Statement of case by applicant or individual (3 minutes); (b) spokesperson for 'representative (5 minutes). groups (10 minutes).. (3) Statement of case by opposition (5 (6) Commission questions. minutes). (7) Rebuttal by opposition (5 minutes). (4) Commission questions. (8) Final rebuttal by applicant or representative (5 minutes). 3/18/93 1 1 r, 'r PUBEICHEAR INGS 8. Alcoholic Beverage Separation Distance 8. Approved a variance of 200' to allow Variances for property (Fiddlestix Cafe and alcoholic beverage sales within 0' of a Grill) located at 2569 Countryside Blvd., similarly licensed establishment and a Suite 15, Countryside Village Sq., Lots 5, 7 variance of 15' to allow sales within 285' & 8 less street (Countryside Village Ltd/HRE of a residential zone. Properties/Gentile A1393-05)(PLD) 9. Major amendments to CPD Certified Final 9. Continued to 4/1/93. Site Plan for Wal-Mart located on the NW corner of NE Coachman Rd. and US19N, Loehmann's Plaza, part of Lot 1 and Loehma'nn's Plaza Replat; Lots 1-3 (Principle Mutual Life Insurande)(PLD) 10. Second Reading Ord. #5287-92 - Final Site 10.' Continued to 411193. Plan and amendment to CPD Zoning for property located at 2201 Sunset Point Rd., Sec. 6-29-16, M&B 32.01 and portion of vacated Pinellas Groves easement in Sec. 1-29-15; approx 1.24 ac. (Sun Bank of Tampa Bay Z92-08)(PLD) i 1. Public Hearing & First Reading Ords. 1 1. Approved. Ords. #5349-93 & #5350-93 ' #5349-93 & #5350-93 - Land Use Plan passed 1st reading. Amendment to Public/Semi-Public. and P/SP Zoning for property located at 2965 , C.R.193, part of Sec. 5-29-16, M&B 41.06 & 41.08, approx. 7.47 'ac.(Oak Leaf Ltd. LUP93-01, Z93-01)(PLD) 12. Public Hearing & First Reading Ord. #5351- 12. Approved. Ord. #5351-93 passed 1st 93 - IL Zoning for property, located at 2144 reading. Calumet Street,'Clearwater Industrial Park, part of Lot 10, approx. 0.8 ac. (City Z93- 02)(PLD) 13. Public Hearing -'PPC Consistency Program - 13. Approved modified Exhibit A of Res. #92- reconsideration of various land use plan 69. amendments; modification of Exhibit A of Res. #92-69 (PLD) Public Hearing - Second Reading Ordinances 14. Ord. #5332-93 - RS-8 Zoning for property 14. Continued. located at 300 Venetian Dr., North Shore Park Sub., Bik 1, Lots 10, 11 and part of 9, approx. 0.84 acre (Owens/City Z92-10) To be Cont. 1 3118/93 ITY MANAGER REPORTS CONSENT AGENDA Items #15-29) - Approve as su mitts . The following items require no formal public hearing and are subject to being approved in a'single motion. However, any City Commissioner or the City Manager may remove an item from the Consent Agenda to allow discussion and voting on the item individually. Bids & Contracts 15. Extension of contract for paging service with Pac-Tel Paging, St. Petersburg, FL, for the period 411193-3131194, at an est. $12,939.17 (AS) 16. Contract to retain outside environmental counsel (Akerman, Senterfitt & Eidson), Orlando, FL, for matters related to the DER 'investigation of the former Clearwater Gas Manufactured Gas Plant site, at a cost not Y to exceed $40,000 (GAS) 17. 'Joint Project Agreement with Pinellas County to relocate natural gas mains during improvements to Drew St. from Hercules Ave. to US19N, at an est. labor cost $87,300 (GAS) 18. Contract for labor to replace gas mains and service's on Cleveland Street to Gulfcoast Utility Constructors, St. Petersburg, FL,,at an est. $65,100 (GAS) '19. Contract for study of gas rates to Coopers & Lybrand, Tampa, FL, at a cost not to exceed $45,500 (GAS) 20: Purchase 200 complete series of Energix B Hepatitis B Vaccine (3 units per person) from the Pinellas County Health Dept. for $99/series to be administered by the City's Fire Dept EMS Division, total cost $19,800 (PD) 21. Declare city vehicle 1331.97 surplus; Purchasea thermoplastic striping unit for the PW/Transport ation Group from Pave ' Mark Corp, Smyrna, GA,, for $153,766; ' include trade-in of vehicle for a credit of ` $10,500, (results in net cost of $143,266); ? . authorize lease/purchase thru 1998; financing to be provided under City's s` Master Lease/Purchase agreement with AT&T Credit Corp. (PW) 3118/93 3 'Y' f 22. No Item. Citizens & Staff Requests 23. , Approval of mid-year General Fund budget . . amendment to appropriate $32,100 from 'the unreserved, undesignated fund balance ; of the General Fund for the 3 month f continuation of the Beach to Downtown Trolley Service (CM) Plans & Plats .... 24. Preliminary Subdivison Plat for Kings Highway Subdivision (Woodland, Scholl, Austin, Dillinger, Nealy, A.H.W.; Fitzgerald, Pittman, Golden, Nikolaus)(PLD) Receipt & Referral 25, Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential and RS-6 Zoning for property located at 714& 716 Bayview , . Ave., part of. Sec. 16-29-16, M&B 32.03 & .32.04, approk. 0.60 ac. (Logemann/Parker A93-01 & 04; LUP 9303 & 07)(PLD) 26. • Annexation; Land Use Plan Amendment to , Low Density Residential and RS-4 Zoning for property located at 1812 Beverly Circle, Meadow Creek Sub., Lot 15, approx. 0.25. ; ac. (Nikitas, A93-05; LUP 93-06)(PLD) 27.. Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential and RS;-8 Zoning for property located at 1400 Regal Rd..' Solar Crest Sub., Lot 1, approx. 0.20 ac. (Forgacs, A93-08; LUP 93-10)(PLD) 28.' Land Use Plan Amendment to Commercial/Tourist Facilities and CG Zoning "for property' located at 2339 Gulf to Bay Blvd., part of Sec. 18-29-16, N 280,01'' of Hillcrest Mobile Home Park, ' approx. 0.64 ac. (Lokey Oldsmobile, Inc., . LUP 93-12, Z93-03)(PLD) CITY ATTORNEY Agreements, Deeds & Easements 3118193. 4 jti?: ,:i+' ,'ji??.t',` •;,a? ., !, alp < }• • s } . x . i 'jq 29. J Amendment to Agreement with Dimmitt Chevrolet, Dimmitt Cadillac and Richard Dimmitt re: Third Avenue South T ER ITEMS `CITY MANA ER REPORT ' 30. Approval of Pinellas Trail primary and 30. Approved Option •2 as primary route secondary route options thru Clearwater; to through Clearwater with south end be forwarded to Pinellas County for their alternate. ' consideration (PR) 31. Harbor Oaks Association request, to close 31. Denied Harbor Oaks Association request; ' Druid Road and Bay Avenue at their direction given to investigate 4-way stops intersections with Jeffords Street; direction on Druid Ave. and to pursue staff's re:. proposed traffic action plan (PW) recommendation for traffic action plan. 32. (Cont. from 3/4/93). Space Needs Study - 32. Accepted space needs" study. New CO Hall (CM) a) Authorized City,Manager to negotiate .; a) Sun'Bank Building purchase of the Sun Bank Building for a price not to exceed $6.5 million plus e customary closing costs. 33. Res.-#93-12 - authorizing a cooperative 33. Res. #93.12 adopted. assistance agreement with the State re: feasibility study for replacement of the Memorial Causeway S.R.60 Drawbridge with a high-level fixed bridge (OW) 34. Res. #93-15 & Res. #93-16 transmitting 34. Res. #93-15 & Res. #93-16 adopted. Land Use Plan Amendments associated with the Downtown Dev. Plan & the NXt.Harrison/N.Myrtle Ave. zoning study to the PPC for review (PLD) 35. Other Pending Matters 35. None. CITY ATTORNEY REPORTS ' First Reading Ordinances ` 36. Ord. #5354-93 - Amending Secs. 36.114, 36. Ord. #5354-93 passed 1 st reading. 36.118, 36.121 & 36.125 re: development agreements Resolutions r 37. ' Res, #93-11 - Assessing property owners 37. Res. #93-11 adopted. the costs of mowing or clearing owners' lots 38. Res. #93-14 = Amending commission rules 38. Continued to 4/1/93. of procedure-re: conduct of business 3118193 5•. I' .r . , V J ^ i "r. i { y r 0.?1 rr Other City Atto rney it ems 39. License Agreement with'Dioceseof St. 39. Withdrawn. ' 'Petersburg for driveway encroachment re: ' property city is purchasing at' St-Cecelia's ' for Stevenson's Creek project ITEM: Res. x/93-19 re: opposing Private Property -- Res. a93-19 adopted. - Rights ? Bill . , , .40. City Manager Verbal Reports 40. City Manager reported the bids -for Pier 60 are less than budgeted. Agendaed-for nekt, meeting. ! 41. Other Commission Action 41., Deegan said he does riot favor ticketing. ..: speeders'only, after the speed limit is r exceeded by '10 miles: Police Chief, to report.. He questioned when. the .•,: Community Development Update will be available. 'Staff waiting for HUD . information for follow'-up report. B re field referred to an article regarding "` . trolley service in Ft. Lauderdale costing $28,300. annually. , Staff to pursue. Ho a requested consideration be given to' consolidating the various groups in the North Greenwood area., She stated she felt 7 the salary,of the Commission should be reviewed. 42. Adjournment „ 42. 12:05 a.m. r 3118193 , 6 t 'Vq 1177 - T.i1. +:r. ..fir,. ?.Ir? ,l. ;r..•t iii.:=?e lot, 4r. b•-.. ;° ••?' r`"l+t' rf- PRELIMINARY AGENDA Work Session - 9:00 A.M. - Monday, March 15, 1993 Clearwater City Commission Meeting - 6:00 P.M. - Thursday, March 18,1993 Service Awards AS ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES 1. Extension of contract for paging service with Pac-Tel Paging, St. Petersburg, FL, for the period 411193-3131194, ,at an est. $13 3"8:99-(Consent B&C) la,`g39.1r7 1. Contract to retain outside environmental counsel (Akerman, Senterfitt & Eidson), Orlando, FL, for matters related to the DER investigation of the former Clearwater Gas Manufactured Gas Plant site, at a cost not to exceed $40,000 (Consent B&C) 2. Joint Project Agreement with Pinellas County to relocate. natural gas mains during improvements to' Drew St. from Hercules Ave. to US19N, at an est. labor cost $87,300 (Consent B&C) 3. Contract for labor to replace gas mains and services on Cleveland Street to Gulfcoast Utility Constructors, St.-Petersburg, FL, at an est. $65,100 (Consent B&C) 4. Contract for study of gas rates to Coopers & Lybrand, Tampa, FL, at a cost not to exceed $45,500 (Consent B&C) PD POLICE 1. Purchase 200 complete'series of Energix B Hepatitis B Vaccine (3 units per person) from the Pinellas County Health Dept. for $99/series to be administered by the City's Fire Dept EMS Division, total cost $19,800 (Consent B&C) P PAR AND RECREATION 1. Pinellas Trail (WSO) PUBLIC 1.. Harbor Oaks Association request to close Druid Road and Bay Avenue at their intersections with ti. Jeffords Street; direction re: proposed traffic action plan (CM) 2. Declare city vehicle 1331.97 surplus; Purchase a thermoplastic striping unit for the PW/Transportation Group from Pave Mark Corp, Smyrna, GA, for $153,766; include trade-in of vehicle for a credit of $10,500 (results in net cost of $143,266); authorize lease/purchase thru 1998; financing to be provided under City's Master Lease/Purchase agreement with AT&T. Credit Corp, (Consent B&C) 3. tank removal 4. Res. ##93-12 - authorizing a cooperative assistance agreement with the State re: feasibility study for replacement of the Memorial Causeway S.R.60 Drawbridge with a high-level fixed bridge (CM) ADMINISTRATION 1. (Cont. from 3/4/93) Space Needs Study - New City Hall (CM) 2. Approval of mid-year General Fund budget amendment to appropriate 532,100 from the unreserved, undesignated fund balance of the General Fund for the 3 month continuation of the Beach to Downtown Trolley Service (CM) 3115/93 1 1, 1 . t;: ¦ PL &D PLANNING DEVE P ETTT 1, Public Hearing & First Reading Ords. #5349-93 & #5350-93 - Land Use Plan Amendment to Public/Semi-Public and P/SP Zoning for property located at 2965 C.R.193, part of Sec. 5-29-16, M&B 41.06 & 41.08, approx. 7.47 ac.(Oak Leaf Ltd. LUP93-01, Z93-01)(PH) 2, Public Hearing & First Reading Ord. #5351-93 - IL Zoning for property located at 2144 Calumet Street, Clearwater Industrial Park; part of Lot 10, approx. 0.8 ac. (City Z93-02)(PH) 3. Public Hearing - PPC Consistency Program - reconsideration of various land use plan amendmants; modification of Exhibit A of Res.'#92-69 (PH) 4. Preliminary Subdivison Plat for Kings Highway Subdivision (Woodland, Scholl, Austin, Dillinger, Nealy, A,H.W., Fitzgerald, Pittman, Golden; Nikolaus)(CM P&P) 5. Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential and RS-6 Zoning for property located at 714 & 716 Bayview Ave., part of Sec. 16-29-16, M&B 32.03 & 32.04, approx. 0.60 ac. (Logemann/Parker A93-01 & 04; LUP 93-03 & 07)(Consent R&R) 6. Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential and RS-4 Zoning for property located at-1812 Beverly Circle, Meadow Creek Sub., Lot 15, approx. 0.25 ac. (Nikitas, A93-05; LUP 93-06)(Consent R&R) 7. Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential and RS-8 Zoning -for property located at 1400 Regal Rd., Solar Crest Sub., Lot 1', approx. 0.20 ac. (Forgacs, A93- 08; LUP 93-10)(Consent R&R) 8. Land Use Plan Amendment to Commercial/Tourist Facilities and CG Zoning for property located at 2339 Gulf to Bay Blvd., part of Sec. 18-29-16, N 280.01' of Hillcrest Mobile Home Park, approx. 0.64 ac. (Lokey Oldsmobile, Inc., LUP 93-12, Z93-03)(Consent R&R) 9. Major amendments to CPD Certified Final Site Plan for Wal-Mart located on the NW corner of NE Coachman Rd. and US19N, Loehmann's Plaza, part of Lot 1 and Loehmann's Plaza Replat, Lots 1-3 (Principle Mutual Life Insurance) ({GM- 4xy? H) 10. Alcoholic Beverage Separation Distance Variances for property (Fiddlestix Cafe and Grill) located at 2569 Countryside Blvd., Suite 15, Countryside Village Sq., Lots 5, 7 & 8 less street (Countryside Village Ltd/HRE Properties/Gentile AB93-05)(PH) 11. Second Reading Ord. #5287-92 - Final Site Plan and amendment to CPO. Zoning for property located at 2201 Sunset Point Rd., Sec. 6-29-16, M&B 32.01 and portion of vacated Pinellas Groves easement in Sec. 1-29-15, approx 1.24 ac. (Sun Bank of Tampa Bay Z92-08)(PH) 12. Res. #93-15 & Res. #93-16 transmitting Land Use Plan Amendments associated with the Downtown Dev, Plan & the N.Ft.Harrison/N.Myrtle Ave. zoning study to the PPC for review (CM) CA - LEGAL DEPARTMENT Second Reading Ordinances 1. Ord. #5332-93 - RS-8 Zoning for property located at 300 Venetian Dr., North Shore Park Sub., Blk 1, Lots 10, 11 and part of 9, approx. 0,84 acre (Owens/City Z92-10) To be Cont. First Reading Ordinances 1, Ord. #5354-93 - Amending Secs. 36-114, 36.118, 36.121 & 36.125 re; development agreements Resolutions 1, Res, #93-11 - Assessing property owners the costs of mowing or clearing owners' lots 2. Res. #93-14 - Amending commission rules of procedure re: conduct of business 3115/93 . k 2 M x?+Y .. • r' '' '', . r A°' _ +., t .:? , ' '?, ?• -. r' '? l ? Sa. •' '•?` f'?, t_ , y r . ! rl I.f :S 1 ,. ' l1? a Y - ' , - ' d ` r t ' ' • , r ? ^" ' '1 ' 7`' " . t : • Eq .? l J ?.' , ; a °Y ?' ? ??•"I . ' ? n ' } 3-' , [ '' . S .. • • 4r . .. ••S' ', , ? - y ???.? wpb'+•j' a 'ti ?' i ? i .. ?; • ? S .. 1 ? ` r i , ' _ - .. ? '' 5 ' ' ; 6 . F '` , ' .. J . z , .4r ><e1 ? j'y 54 ,?1'•r ':R• ii. -?I.?SF 1erf .l jti,+`?': .X'y?•'t?? t?^59.f `.''• f.f".. 1 r., ?": N .? -J 4 ''sri• ? , ? ~,7 " [ r ' • • ) J 'i` ' " .. .. e .E rii.?,t?? r?,. , , .. ., .,.J . ? , ti{ ..+??' }':, • ?i" .' . c - ,.. .. . i#; " e ;'b; . _i:r " ,oJ Agreements, Deeds and Easements :1. License Agreement with Diocese of St. Petersburg for driveway encroachment re: property city, is purchasing at St..Cecella's for Stevenson's Creek project 2. 'Amendment-to Agreement with Dimmitt- Chevrolet, Dimmitt Cadillac and Richard Dimmitt re:,, Third Avenue South' ' OTHER CITY ATTORNEY ITEMS r City Manager era Reports .:< ommission Discussion Items . 1. " Trolley Options . E< Other Commission Action" bourn • :: .., ? • . • ", 3/16/93 • . 2 is J ????•?.` ins:+"i??l j`F 1;"S.?i.l?'N'{?? e 4 ' I f F CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION Agenda Cover Memorandum Itam Subject: - SERVICE AWARDS Flecommendation/Motion: The following employees be presented with service awards for their length of service in the employment of the City of Clearwater. ? and that the appropriate, officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: S YCRfS: Cindi R. Hoehberger Fire Department Thomas P. Burns Public Works/Public Service Cornelius Legters III Planning & Development Dennis L. Allen Parks. & Recreation Charles ' E. Porthouse Parks & Recreation Laura G. Chase DOAS/CIS l0 Years: James Ruggiero Fire Department Beverly Ncwbanks DOAS/UCS l' years: Lawrence. J. Anderson Public Works/Infrastructure Helen Davis DOAS/UCS 2Q Yew: Carolyn M. Moore Library, 25 Years: Samuel Collie Public Works/Utili'ties/Solid Waste Mi c Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: Costs: Commission Action: Legal Human Resources Total ? Approved ' Budget El Approved wlcondilions Purchasing User, Dept.: ? Denied Risk Mgmt. Current FY ? Continued to: DIS Source: Fundin g ACM Advertised: Ll Capt. Imp. Other Date: ? Operating Attachments: Submitted by: raper: ? Other ? Not required Affected parties Appropriation Code: ? Notified City. Manager ? Not required ? None 1 1=1 _I =f`; ;`, ';,J. r. '.. .,,; ?'. r:.Y. .', - !p ?' ,. , t ?J; S . . .}?y ',J ?-. ??tYinf?Yyll • ... • , e?' ,:t i k ? ? ?. •' •, ? ? ? - ? - `r ? ? ? t ? .- . t , . _ , t r` F ., ? ? y + J ?i? j f ? ? ? ? P h ' F: J r r' . ?' • •.1? , ?, r `F. s :r ' ?'? ' - r v A: e t .• , . •,,s.,?; ?,,':e :, ., ., ?. ? ? t'r s.f J , , .{,J I ?..r,=? .r0 - :?`?. •,! d ?;yfwfw5: 5 i ` 's ' r;4 ' k• J'r : ? ? r• ' •. . ? r ? . ? ' ! . .... r >. ? + •, rY . ,: •:i. .w c_, ,k i d, ... . / >t G . .+ " ..... ,. .r ,-... . . ..+. .,,,.. .. ... TO: Mayor Rita Garvey. -FROM:, Betty J. Blunt, Confidential Clerk Receptionist '• COPIES: City Commissioners, Michael Wright, Cyndie Goudeau . . SUBJECT: Presentations at' the March 15, 1993 Work Session ,. DATE: March 15, 1993. The following presentations will be made at the March 15, 1993 Work Session, SERVIQE PINS `Cornelius, Legters III, Planning & Development (letter of appreciation & service pin) ; Dennis Allen, Parks and Recreation (letter of appr ciation' &service pin),. Laura Chase, Department of Administrative Services '(letter of appreciation & service pin) .• :'.: • Beverly Newbanks, Department of Administrative Services/ Uiil iti es (letter.'of appreciation and'desk clock with City Seal) ° fir , f ? I ' ? ?•', !+, , , ? , _ ,! ?' i - . - . {!rl7f ?j}(:C•?Jy^?-kw`" ij ?':; 1>r I ,r?s? l" ' ;?. `4 - 'j J 1 L 1114 ?uY rls.: •; 'x ` = • :1 1 kN?Mi :[¢ .,R. ;, ?tif'?' !.`}•.}.. .v is ..r s< II Uri ARI I ( L IIP°M L DR EW ST &R. nD , (A till licit ffffileLt% z LAURA a 3 C?" 7 LAURA El 0 01 ` S.R• 1,11 m ORIGINAL ROUTE PARK PIERee a sr =0? ??Cla'C ADVANTAGES FIERCE sT 1. Avoids residential neighborhoods. ? ? = ll 2, Proceeds through center of downtown { FRANKLIII ST 15 business district. couRT sr ? a 3. 'fakes advantage of abandoned railroad caur:r a sr right-of-way from Magnolia to Lakeview Road. q MAOEY= DISADVANTAGES cllE`+111UT sr nncER sr ? RorERS I 4?? (? ?? ?, 1. large trucks frequenting businesses pose unsafe, situations. tuI1r1ER sT ' 2. Active trains could dislodge and throw stones that could be' hazardous to trail users. ?'nr "u'a 3. Route crosses the 'active railroad line Tis (N K aplu ST PRIE Sr PINE o cr ?On two times resulting in risks of bicycle fires, roller blades, etc. becoming lodged in track ? 1 -, E o El & DRUIn, RD . W DRUID no openings. a. (questionable as whether or not there is JASMINL WAY ASAIINE Ul WAY sufficient width on the east side of the ? ?a a (racks for the placement of the 10' wide bike L_ _J trail and 2 wide separation curb. q?g? MnG1TOI-I 5. Railroad indicated they did not want trail within a few feet of their active LOTUS P_ _ AtN otus railroad line and, if they have the L= opportunity, would possibly not provide a jJEEF ORDST permit to construct in that portion of their ?_L right-of-way. RAND CENTRAL 6. At the southern end of this route, °rid PI SADLER ?x?? ?UC between Lakeview and Qeileview Road, it is mcKaR M nINELLas highly unlikely that the Department of ?0 Transportation will issue a permit necessary waTKlrls wA?xuls to construct a portion of the trail within a $ TUSKAWILLA few feel of the sbbstandard section of CDIT°ErT _ E Alternate Highway 19, sr A S 7. Along the southern portion, where stores o ST front on the sidewalk, there is not physically o ° s' yap enough room to construct a 10' wide trail given, there is a minimum A required LAKEViEW separation distance between the trail and the C?) , I I = u edge of pavement.? Lfv E ST MUE11HAN O 51 , YC RELLEVIEw1 r RD BELLEA[W ST _ t %ILDWOOD WAY N rwTRAIL dwq 3/10/93 WOOOLAWN _ AVE w4nDLAyV11 sl Layn Ori9...o1 t, , t r r • , . lAr1T EU15 xllArtF `- ' {l, to JONES ?5 ' ST 000 =1 n lrlur2n - ..?F _ Sr S.R._59U P0 a K IIENDRicK ! _ r_I LL AURA a LAURA, r-- J l?J LJ 4_.JW S.R, 60 " Ir PARK n' a m PIERCE ST OPTION 1 PIERCE, m L? I (Recommended) nN?cLIrT 51 ADVANTAGES N [] COURF 5T ?1 u ? ?a COURT ¢ sl 1. Takes advantage of views of Clearwaterps t < 0 unO[r bayEronl. .. , 2. Portion of route on Turner Street could ' ROCCRS L NocErISCHESTNUT sT be constructed down the center of the roadway ?,[ I DO, leaving driveways of adjacent businesses and [[?_JJ D El a homes unobstructed. TuRr1LR ST ¢ T 3. . Takes advantage of abandoned railroad 5 05U a. right-of--way from Magnolia, to Lakeview. sc?arn q rARDL 4• Does not cross railroad tracks. 1. S r nraWSPI14E SF PINE ST PING Cr) DISADVANTAGES E / nrTUfn Rb_ w DRUID 1.' Parking will need to be removed on Turner 3L?J ' Street• from Oak Avenue to l=ast Avenue, on Oak eq Q? 0 JASMINE WAY j A54fIfyE ? VIAY Avenue and through some County employee parking' lots. a ?lncNOi o, t DR 2. Unless a different route is found to connect Turner Street to Magnolia, 'this route Lotus PAIR LOTUS would also have to parallel the active railroad tracks' which could subject trail JEI ORDS S1 users to stones thrown by trains. ??3.' South of Lakeview, this route may have to t RAITD CENTRAL t-- follow hamlet and l3elieview. Rood which are low nl.„tl'1 SADLLrlvolume residential strclels. / tAElm A. Railroad. might not permit trail between r1icKEri 7 f---? PIraELtn S o Turner and Magnolia. {{?? rc 11'A1KRJ5 WAIKINS TU5KAWILLA , r x R . J CoRerrr_ -" - ---__ si - A _sr sT © S1 1, LAh "VIEW tf?, C) St E ST Preferred Route A4cLEIMA71 ST v -Alternate Route WILDWOaE) YlAY ? , POITRAR. dog 3/10/q! WOODLAWN AVE J ]/1D YVOOULAWhI ! Lnyn - pp1loni S1 , l . , r' f 11 , f i r I 1 r ? i ? .. HART CIJj ?, ?z ut JONES [? 5 ST I , ?vf? ? ? [tt? ? ' ' n DREW ST S.R. 590 Fitt 4LAURA a ? LAURA S.R. 60 o ?? ?? ?? fr ?C PARK P+ERCE ST 3:E:1% I OPTION 2 PICRCE 5T r? ? ADVANTAGES FRANKLIN ST F- ? ?n 1r Proceeds through the center of downtown N COURT, sr o which could stimulate business and Promate COURT a ST renovation. MAn?KLEV ? 2. Takes advantage' of the abandoned railroad CHESTNUT ST right-'of-way from Magnolia to Lakeview. RocERS ST ? . 3. Uses the.west side of East Avenue which ROCERS n El I I a is wider than the east side as in original TURNER sr r route: 4. Does not cross' railroad track. n 4 ; r9 Sporn n.aM ? Aaa 1 ? DISADVANTAGES l qp Ir INE ST?? PINE S1 1 Pwe n $ ? .? 1. This route still parallels' the active { et) ° cLJ ? ? a DRUID RD MW DRUID j railroad lines and rocks could be thrown. ?? ?W causing problems to trail users. JASMINE WAY ASIJINE o WAY 2. Railroad will quite likely, continue to C object to the trail sharing the active o MACNOI tL. DR railroad, right - of- way. 3. Parking will need to be removed from the Lotus PATH I-o?r"usll, !? east side of the Post Office. However, the City's new parking lot may resolve this problem. JEF OR05 St 4. Toward the south end of East Avenue, a ??? .___J =4=W large trucks are active and driveways to r SAND' ctNtRAL warehouses and/or commercial businesses are PI SQUAW 3 ?L? l: involved. RICKER W?= ---?-r P+NtLL?S 5. South of Lakeview, this route may have to. follow Homlet and Belleview which are low +? Q Ik ?0 WAVONS 3 WA4KINS ll TUSKAWILLA volume residential streets, o- a 6. Some parking will have to be removed on COR13E I SI A 5T -- Gorden Avenue and Hendricks Street, 7. No traffic 'lights exist where East Avenue p sT p e T crosses. Chestnut Street and Court Street, ao ??°?a C LA, -VIEW 0 ST E ST LfcLCl+ffAN 5T ? BELLEVIEW no -C ST I a WIL015000 WAY 2 I ???a =xC If{TRAIL.d¦q 3110193 WOOOLAWN AVE WOODLAWN I--f La{W - oath"? J-1 = i I ?- Preferred route Allernald Route r_ 3 ' 1 f R , 'L ¦1' TART 51 :a i-?- u I I ATt T ' Ln W L°n' JONES = ?S ST o mo - Si 5,f2, ;; ' C1wCi Ehc URA IND L1L?-AURJJA UP ALL ?El a?Mp S,R. 60 vi z PARK PIERCE ST PIERCE ST r?. ? ? ? • OPTION 3 .' . l ra:nrarcurT sr Ei 'ADVANTAGES. l COURT 5T. a t El COURT EL Sr 1, Takes advantage of the view of K MOcr? ? ? ? Cl, earwoter's bQy#ront. T:IIESrraut sr 2Could be constructed inside the medians RUGERSJ 5? W [?------- I of Bay Avenue, between Druid end. Jeffards, • ??L! u?IJ RDCef7s ?, leaving driveways open. a u IJ LJ?C 3, Does not cross the railroad tracks. TURNER a 4. Is the mgst direct of all routes. spprn J V C / 014AROLt DISADVANTAGES (41 venchWplik ST PINE { PINE ST ?cen 1 Difficulty in getting the route from EJ E ' D, DRUID RD W DRUID RD Turner Street to Druid Road along streets that a?? ??']uf are narrow and which include residential JASMINE WAY PASMINE Q WAY driveways, etc. ?a 2. At the south end of day Avenue, the trail ?ncloGla = DR?I would, intersect at Jeffords which is a busy •o?? ?? ? ? 'intersection for emergency fpcililies of Morton Plant Hospital, ` Lotus ?PAUL Lows 3, A route from deflords through the Morton 1--- ? Plant Hospital's Campus Picn to Corbett Street -- JEF656 ST= would require significant dedication of J 9 • _ u =W w--C property by, the hospital for the trail. cRAIM c£rrrRAL 4, getting from Corbelt Street to Belleview . Boulevard will 'Involve the perimeter of the RICHCfi n PINELLA5 golf course which will require golf course Lon approval? WA THINS WhI INS L,, u IUSKAWILLA coReErT a- -? Sr A 5T r ST ' 13 S1 o Pa ? OE?I' , jC . LAKFVICW 4 ST ? • E 5r ' i McLUINAN O ST r 13ELLEMEW r RD [3ELL? EW= ST a WILOWODO WAY a 1101 raArl.a•q 7 . 3110140 WOaDLAWN ? WOO La?M - °plion3 ' .I } .i .? • ?t IS a? ihS ?. r Tft. ?r '•.4.'•' " ', 1 IARr 5r IIART -- - E, 1?!V' JONES s S r DREW St 5.R. 59- DWI= \ NCtrDRlcres El LAURA a tAIMI El ; o m S.R. 60 OPTION 4 (As suggested by'residenl) ?I E ?V PAR, (_ PIERCC o sr z? E] 2 C ADVANTAGES.' for El PIERCE 5r 1, Troll proceeds through the downtown rRANKLIN ST _ business district. COURT ST rr11 a f? f?l V ?? ?.1 DISADVANTAGES " uARKLcr COURT ? ? ? I. It is questionable as tp whether or not l CHESTNUT L?1 St there is sufficient space for the trail, on -ROCER5 5t -East Avenue between Tones and Laura. 4t__I 0 `? R0 2. There is no traffic light at East Avenue f__1 and Drew Street. rLIRItEIt st ` 3 a 3. The railroad will more than likely abject ` A to the trail sharing this route with active sn°,rns ??? Ell '""°r ? tracks and rnblerns could be encountered b ('?cgC,T _f?IrrC 5T PIN[ 5r PINE p by cr Y Crevern rocks thrown by trains. oS -C O ']a s? El E 4. This route will have to cross the IN DRUID RD zW DRUID RD railroad tracks in two locations, once at the Li north and once at the south end. JAS-MINIL ?ynY PA I WAY 5• Although. Prospect -Avenue is a straight ml? line from Laura to Lakeview, bicycles will o MAGNOLIA R hope to share, this roadway with,, traffic and safety would be a primary concern becouse. of LOlus PArII J C the numerous driveways and parking lots from -? r- - LOTUS which vehicles are.entering and exiling. . IE ?. C G. A good portion of route is through JEFFORDS sir residential areas. 7. The use of Lakeview Road from Prospect to . T] x GRAND CENTRAL = I•lornlet is questionable due to very heavy , '"°Lr?94 __ traffic on Lakeview and the possibility of not , _ RIMER 'n PINELLAS L having sufficient rourn for the trail on the rC right -- af- way. WAIN NS WAIKINs rusxnv itn 8, As with other routes, the south end of m this route will use the residential road of 3 coRgrrT a Hamlet. ,r`? ?-A--?-s-r- g, Traffic lights do not exist at Chestnut, ,J SL, pmt 5r . Court or Cleveland 'Street. qm_! LAKI C?s o } D 51 -? o [? 5T McLEIM lI SI N ©ELLEMEW RD ST W7LDWOOD WAY 3 x 3/10/73 4YDDOLAWN AVE WDDULA1hTr 5; , ton - llcnl mom J SEAIw. I tam i Clearwater City Commission Meeting Date: 3/18/93 o Agenda Cover Memorandum i 5 W 2s `? - Q ? W KS e-S t U 4- ¦ 14e-ol d o,,+ CONSENT 3 IWY....Y?YIY I 1 M Y 111 II 11 II IW YIIY SUBJECT: Ccmi4; v1Ue_ on -to -f ?ur_q Petroleum Product Tank Removal and Closure at City Transfer Station and City Hall Annex RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Award a.contract to in the amount of $ , being the lowest and most responsive bidder, for the removal and closure of one ten thousand gallon diesel fuel tank, prior to March 31, 1993, and one five hundred gallon waste oil tank. ® and that the.appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The underground diesel tank at the City's Transfer Station on old Coachman Road is required to be removed or replaced by March 31, 1993 in accordance with Florida Department of Environmental Regulation's Chapter 1.7-761 FAC, Underground Storage Tank Systems. This regulation is intended to provide guidelines for the sound operation of underground storage tank systems and require the removal or replacement of outdated tank systems. The tank at the Transfer Station has been in service since January of 1972 and must be removed prior to the end of March 1993 to remain eligible for restoration funding through the State should contamination be found at the time of closure. The existence of a waste oil tank at the north end of the annex was brought to the City's attention during a survey,to determine the location of unregistered pollutant storage tanks. This tank had been out of service since use of the property by Montgomery Ward. Abandoned tanks are required to be removed within nintey days of discovery. Therefore it is imperative that the tank be removed in timely manner. Bids for the work were opened on March 15, 1993; a bid tabulation is attached. is the lowest qualified bidder at a cast of _$ for the Transfer Station Fuel Tank and _$ for the Annex Waste Oil Tank. Funding for removal'of the Waste Oil Tank will be transferal at mid-year from operating codes 566-06610-546.500-590-000 (Garage Equipment repair) to 566-06610-546800-590-000 (R&R In Ground Facility), having an available, balance as of March 12, 1993 of $225,226. Funding for the Transfer Station Fuel Tank has been budgeted in the Solid Waste Capital Improvement Project code 315-96435-546800-534-000 which has an available balance as of March 12, 1993 of $80,000. Reviewed by: giimting Dept: Costs: Commission Action: Legal 13/_A___ ublic Nor Env Total 13 Approved Budget P h i W •C.:batty .- ? Approved w/conditions urc as ng C15k Mgmt. NIA er Dept; Current Fiscal-F-. ' © Denied A General Services © Continued to: AGM Funding Sourcc: Other ® Capital Imp. Advertised: 0 Operating Attachments:' Date: Paper: ? Other Bid Tabulation 11 Not Required S fitted by: / ?[ - ujd Affected Parties ® Notified Appropriation Code: ? None , * r Manager I Not Required 315-96435-562300-534-000 566-06610--5468X1`-590-000 t"i? Printed on recycled paper 1 t t. FINAL AGENDA - CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION MEETING - March 18, 1993 (6:00 P.M.) Welcome. We are glad to have you, join us. If you wish to speak please wait to be recognized, then state your name and address. Persons speaking before the City Commission on other than Public Hearing items shall be limited to 3 minutes. No person shal l speak more than once on the same subject unless granted permission by the,City Commission. 1: Pledge of Allegiance 2. Invocation 3. Service Awards 4. Introductions and Awards 5. Presentations: a) Swearing in of Police Officers 6. Minutes- of Regular Meeting March 4, 1993. & Special Meeting March 10, 1993 7. , Citizens to be heard re items not on the Agenda Not Before 6:00 P.M. - Sc e u e ? Public Hearings (1) Presentation of issues by City staff. (5) Comments in support and in opposition: (a) (2) Statement of case by applicant or individual (3 minutes); (b) spokesperson for . representative (5 minutes). groups. (10 minutes). (3) Statement of case by opposition (5 (6) Commission questions. minutes). (7) Rebuttal by opposition (5 minutes). (4) Commission questions. (8) Final rebuttal by applicant or representative (5 minutes). PUBLIC HEARINGS 8. Alcoholic Beverage Separation Distance 11. Public Hearing & First Reading Ords. ' Variances for property (Fiddlestix Cafe and #5349-93 & #5350-93 - Land Use Plan Grill) located at 2569 Countryside Blvd., Amendment to Public/Semi-Public and P/SP Suite 15, Countryside Village Sq., Lots 5, 7 Zoning for property located at 2965 & 8 less street (Countryside Village Ltd/HRE C.R.193, part of Sec. 5-29-16, M&B 41.06 Properties/Gentile AB93-05)(PLD) & 41.08, approx. 7.47 ac.(Oak Leaf Ltd. 9. Major amendments to' CPD Certified Final LUP93-01, Z93-01)(PLD) Site Plan for Wal-Mart located on the NW 12. Public Hearing & First Reading Ord..#535'1- corner of NE Coachman Rd. and US19N, 93 - IL Zoning for property located at 2144 Loehmann's Plaza, part of Lot 1 and Calumet Street, Clearwater Industrial Park, Loehmann's Plaza Replat, Lots 1-3 part of Lot 10, approx. 0.8 ac. (City Z93- (Principle Mutual Life Insurance)(PLD) 02)(PLD) 10. 'Second Reading Ord. #5287-92 - Final Site 13. Public Hearing - PPC Consistency Program - Plan and amendment to CPD Zoning for reconsideration of various land use plan property located at 2201 Sunset Point Rd., amendments; modification of Exhibit A of Sec. 6-29-16, M&B 32.01 and portion of Res. #92-69 (PLD) vacated Pinellas Groves easement in Sec. 1-29-15, approx 1.24 ac, (Sun Bank of Tampa,Bay Z92-08)(PLD) 1 3/18/93 a i a 1 ' j, f , ' , a 7 f ' I , Public Hearing - Second Reading Ordinances 14. Ord. #5332-93 - RS-8 Zoning for property ' located at 300 Venetian Dr., North Shore Park Sub., Blk 1, lots 10, 11 and part of 9, approx. 0.84 acre (Owens/City Z92-10) To be Cont. CITY MANAGER REPORTS CONSENT AGENDA (Items #15-29) The following items require no formal public hearing a nd are subject to being approved in a single motion., However, any City Commissioner or the City Manager may remove an item from the Consent Agenda to allow discussion and voting on the item individually. ., Bids & Contracts 15. Extension of contract for paging service 21. Declare city vehicle 1331.97 surplus; with Pac-Tel Paging, St. Petersburg, FL, for' Purchase a thermoplastic striping unit for the period 411193-3131194, at an est. the PW/Transportation Group from Pave $12,939.17 (AS) Mark Corp, Smyrna, GA, for $153,766; 16. Contract to retain outside environmental include trade-in of vehicle for a credit of counsel (Akerman, Senterfitt & Eidson), $10,500 {results in net cost of. 5143,266); Orlando, FL, for matters related to the DER authorize lease/purchase thru 1998; investigation of the former Clearwater Gas financing to be provided. under City's Manufactured Gas Plant site, at a cost not Master Lease/Purchase agreement with to exceed. $40,000 (GAS) AT&T Credit Corp. (PW) 17. Joint Project Agreement with Pinellas 22. No Item. County to relocate natural gas mains during improvements to Drew St. from Hercules Citizens & Staff Requests Ave. to US19N, at an est. labor cost $87,300 (GAS) 23. Approval of'mid-year General Fund budget 18. Contract for labor to replace gas mains and amendment to appropriate $32,100 from services on Cleveland Street to Gulfcoast the unreserved, undesignated fund balance Utility Constructors, St, Petersburg, FL, at of the General Fund for the 3 month an est. $65,100 (GAS) continuation of the Beach to Downtown 19: Contract for study of gas rates to Coopers Trolley Service (CM) & Lybrand, Tampa, FL, at a cost not to exceed $45,500 (GAS) Plans & Plats 20: Purchase 200 complete series of Energix B Hepatitis B Vaccine (3 units per person) 24. Preliminary Subdivison Plat for Kings from the Pinellas County Health Dept. for., Highway Subdivision (Woodland, Scholl, $991series to be administered by the City's Austin, Dillinger, Nealy, A.H.W., Fitzgerald, Fire Dept EMS Division, total cost $19,8,00 Pittman, Golden, Nikolaus)(PLD) (PD) 3118193 2 S' • . ,5:31, e r • F r Receipt & Referral 25. Annexation', Land Use Plan Amendment to 28. Land-Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential and RS-6 Zoning Commercial/Tourist Facilities and CG for property located at 714 & 716 Bayview Zoning for property located at 2339 Gulf to Ave., part of Sec. 16-29-16, M&B 32.03 & Bay Bled., part of Sec. 18-29-16, N 32,04, approx. 0:60 ac. (Logemann/Parker 280.01' of.Hillcrest Mobile Home Park, A93-01 & 04;'LUP 93-03 & 07)(PLD) approx. 0.64 ac.' (Lokey Oldsmobile, Inc., 26. Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to LUP 93-12, Z93-03)(PLD) I Low Density Residential and RS-4 Zoning for. property located at 181'2 Beverly Circle, CITY ATTORNEY _ Meadow Creek Sub., Lot 15, approx. 0.25 Agreements, Deeds & Easements ac.? (Nikitas, A93-05; LUP 93-06)(PLD) 27.. Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to 29. Amendment to Agreement with Dimmitt Low Density Residential and RS-8 Zoning Chevrolet, Dimmitt Cadillac and Richard for property located at 1400 Regal Rd., Dimmitt re: Third Avenue South . Solar Crest Sub.,' Lot 1, approx. 0.20 ac. (Forgacs, A93-08; LUP 93-10)(PLD) i OTHER ITEMS ON C1TY'MANAGER REPORT 30. Approval of 'Pinellas Trail primary and 33. Res. #93-12 - authorizing a cooperative secondary route options thru Clearwater; to assistance agreement with the State re: be forwarded to Pinellas County for their feasibility study for replacement of the consideration (PR) Memorial Causeway S.R.60 Drawbridge 31. Harbor Oaks Association request to close with a high-level fixed bridge (PW) Druid Road and Bay.•Avenue at their 34. Res.493-15 & Res. #93-16 transmitting intersections with Jeffords Street, direction Land Use Plan Amendments associated re: proposed traffic,action plan (PW) with the Downtown.Dev. Plan & the 32. (Cont. from 314193) Space Needs Study - N.Ft.Harrison/N.Myrtle' Ave. zoning study New City Hall (CM) to the PPC for review (PLD) a) Sun Bank Building 35. Other Pending Matters CITY ATTORNEY REPORTS First Reading Ordinances 36. Ord. #5354-93 - Amending Secs. 36.1 14; 36.118, 36.121 & 36.125 re: development agreements, Resolutions 37: Res. #93-11 - Assessing property owners 38. Res. #93-14 - Amending commission rules the costs of mowing or clearing owners' of procedure re: conduct of business lots 3!18193 3 1 1 .. 'i,a,?". Fi#;9:r,': :,{%.F,°,.`,? 'af,:?'M1JM1. f•A:. 1-' `ir,: .,f.. ,P . ,1 ., .F_.., j5i:i• ,1f,P!}:.': .i mot,: :d r ':N n.v =ii 2k1' Si:'' '.a t;jm ' ;,.?' r ?•.,.;: ?C4 ,` '^ .5.. 'r, `:T,:` <'.-I, t ?F.'. I J .T. f.: ,'t -,-.' 1y' 41??,r•,l...F '3F , to,oi .: }'? (+ ,p"j ,;*P"', iSr,•'7• r, t•pi n,.F.,V' •i"•, f ), '•i - ,:rt; i, .I• ',„ e`lf'. `,;•1't' ?a. 1, `'° '' ..E. - r: L. 1, r " ` f `• ,i" ; . , y; P 'i, '?'1,• Y'. `ti ?•'I t;,rj ,+? - 't. 1 ., ,! , ' ' `JS , .L•` fPr-;.. , K,<•,Ix, 5'i.' rl. '+ AI +.e + I . I a1 < ;I'1?1` ',`a 'j-1, 7'i° - , 1,-r`' - ` ,. Y ,i-- ' y`' 1 I , . r' f' • , a V,i ,?,``y .4:fN J !.' Yte' " '.is, r I.. A', •';' .4J?' ? ,la'1 /,.f,. a .1 ,1 - , I ' , e !-, . / • - ,. . > ..t? .Et v.! A..,. 'i --f:.f It1 €°'-! ', c ,t, r$. , t?=:'.'.'1: , - • '=•j. • , .-f a. J1 'rS°- '•t.x ., . °s' 'rqY "I., '- .f,< ®'!;?:; t'"tt': 41,,,,- :;. 11 r .`, ,i, . s°. ;( ? ?'`?'' ` F `! . } ,4'i,'* s t t, it a 1 G i PS i !!, "./.' <P'.,I' ,P >}i' -J' .IS '•!' t !9, 'j' i. Z %' X1''.1.. ,. f" ,ftI ,a'!" I'i .i' } 44i,,,, _ .;f. , Y';', -' :`t•f i.,' _ I 'a - ° ',. .i ',I •S :1,'.l: `,Y, i f r{' I , ,. I :1 'd 1 !< ' ' J ' i q>I' i'f.. e ? ? [ F• l C - , f-'1 t,',` ,,! f , ?Of-, !J _ d" .1• •''f iN .•:? V-,, .F. ',. , 1 "1 ?•' s'f. l' fd, .t•A' t. `,5,..d ?,, 'A' I, ?,` 16 ii `r S, ci i . .i ff:, '*"p. °U. w!'..Y eF"F. tf ` s, ! y• f ;; '. z,' ¢ }- - Y: `:, ,, /`•f Cry :ti? ]. f'. '.t ll. .'I:,f'I 1I '- A L :i.I" .f ` je•r 1,::1'- .Ir ?fd': p,, " :,:,, fi!> (.. '.f .I zs . ?,.. 'r' Td Tr?,`?'tF%!fi fi' if • -7 :# .f o l - {, i'? ;t?1'r . '4a 't. /" ?'f .rC.'4. 1.v. .1. J. ,•' ! ,9' . :P, ,P J -7 ,F tt. -Y .Ar.r:s -Y' I. ~`/ •-x: 'Y:`dnC' ,. ;?' .?. r' ,p. ,f,,,.,1 'i, i ' _ .t,. {?'>h Af•-%Za,{}., ??. ::r, ., b '11 ,.1-'.: .!, .+•t ?? ?ql ?? ?j' ,U• ?.r '`r rF Y" ., x :r`P vE: p 5, 'F+'+?`4 Eis' ,1, :'Y. i.Y.- `' Cd-'s .kf` ..i?-': 1 . SS 7f, ,P' t }(, - If• • :=j' J :li', ,'" .-I. M1(' `1 r :I v'i+ •. fa ' rI ? Ii' ,,Yr •T• ,rs" t r., >C•li :•tj e`' i? 'i4i ,. n"'9Y?~ ' i F."-r a , r' T- '`y ?.,6. ?y; " ,'t. ?,° ' 1 t ?k „Pf '?•'•-i; '.A a - ,3:°.!- s' ?, , q,. t 1! i l' ._` ' / " , ,n?. -- :•!,. .. f ? r - ?, , $t?',`i" •q ;i' .S, ua5.^-.1" . ' ,t 'Y: i -:1.; :r " i;1 .ra:l .,? • ., ,ter 1'i r Wi`t', e. r' 4? , .! 1' , f : , `(.. 'Cr-:.. 'I!.V. `3 :?• I• .n•,', rf -Yf _ '.'d.' !, S' , t 't -fr :? 4Cf,t I?? ,d?' f. i,l. IV y .f, si y+r? ry4:j?•s.I ?I..I J• , {.. -,s ':a. yi'i: .l .,:' ;f ...,, ? ;- i ?'r E., 1-°d<r,. 'i,. 'y. Wf- Iy.,l'l+.+ ',t .' r' 1r.- !>< Cf :: 's to s• i, '1 .t .? 'I ?: =1J -,.dl ? 5?.. .1.? ,y{'! .J it..; -5-.ti-:f ?F;. ;y .,,-,j, yl 1p, C•f: ,. T ,.dfi ;'7. i? :?'• .;t•` ,v' + 1,,;i:,",";' .•r ,i :`i, a'"e", .i 'A r_,>,•-. .',, ...e:.°`J ":k R ,,.7 w - ' df'.y ?1ft r st'.c>(.'L' r: °: e' .. t , , .' J,... . 1r,{e., r .. ?. r:" , lyl''-' : i°.:+,w. f."I' . r' ,,4" 'Y.i d ' , i r,; 'r , .,I r - ,r a t. -"}: ' - , : +i Other. City Attorney Items' .. ' - . .s' .. .I , ,d. .,t,, ,: - 1• I .'f' , ,1 -aF`. '' :39. License Agreement with Diocese of St.' " ' 11 ', ,"''- ,, , .Petersburg for driveway encroachment ?re: j , ;I f, .. , :x Property city is purchasing at St. Ceceiia's }, r .: ;; :• .- for: Stevenson's Creek project . ` . - .. . -, ' ,. , a: ,' < ,` ',r: y; w :IT' ' . , I i r . .r • i ,` Pi e1Fyv 40. City Manager' Verbal Reports ' '' f "; '1 , • i - .3:45 , ` ; '',?,., Y, A 47.- '-Other Commission AAction ' r'. , - • , _ , .' - - ; i 'MSS`;, - 42. -Adjournment, 11 . .. I F . ,I ' i ai . f I ", .1,' , • '°;, £1' r' , , :1 ,1.1 ... - ,1 ',, .+ I .'tt, ,'' _ '1. ,'?7 C ',<- ;,- ! .f' i „ ' , f, III Yi;.?.t' i ' , hS .3; i : T,f u . - - , . trS l `. 'f,.'•'i, `$. r'f, i' .. , .. .. 1 I - .. , 1, - '1. ?'r r.l >•a "ry''t -..' 'q ', f ,1. f' ' J' f. , . . . ,l + I .' i ,•f.%G,j 1 :F , . - { y ' , .. .I ..Y r ,'• .{., ,'aired. . i . . fp i 4 11s-?i"(( f I e k1; . i . , ; f . I .f . 1, ? y ` 1' . t„ . + -. .,_ :1 i, 7 . . . ..1. t, ,. 'r .iit1, 4 }' _ ,e , y , , 1 . . . ` .Y, ! - I ,? .i,s, ` 1 ";a•`i - i I' ?.4, ,,, "O .I r 'f ' 'ti , "' ' ' I' , e L ,t' a'e.l Y ` - 'T „ . , , , ,.1 ,fir=?,lt. , . i F''.4;:.y 3118/93. ' ` ., 4 ?`{`, . d;_" f E`, .i :f - +s %r-?I,':r a `I,t,,.• .s:f1l: 1.' ','11', :r „I yi. .i.r 1".. i'.' r`u' ?ry''J;,' f'.:? E? i.{; ., .?. I?. -s.'•r''.'1,'',:: D• .?i ., i _(, •J f,4 •s, .1"1 .- __._.._..__ 1,- ,. ,. pl`:1 ., ,°I-, .I r"r . "1,}i,A:",'.FSRw -,yzas. ,i; ,,A y } . tI f. L 1Y .'+?e.y ?.J''w J ... 1'• 'f: ii.,1 tL=)r.: ''•+'? :+. .',_s C, :-?, x?¢9?;. 4??r.1?g1' r•e .e a' ..?,. ;rr.i .\. '•i,er '• ?r ,7: Y.v °iV'??:? l,i; i¢',f ?.r,Nt.r; ,. ?.?.' 3., p'?Y .i,? i . ?,} '. •<' :'+? '' , S', , E , !y ,' ,, t., '.1`N ??J . ?:`. .t. ,1! : •i°. ,{k...) .cl" i 1..° .t• "?. J' c` ,'?. ,'?; ?. .. ? 'i: .. e?j?t?? f' •1'r''3j.?°E3.{?' Ty "v ?` , • ? 'f j - J'Z ; , r. ie. .,, ..) ,'}t .. ? . . r`! ! 1 f.'1 • IrJ't?' p .4', / s. •!. .f 'F', .?,9 tr'• `.,?. t.•F? ?+? ' .'` ,r°•, ? `:i ? J f.. r^d r G, f,- '!. :s'. ,y' :ti .???,ff ..4E,?;•' :f`r ?•?e .}e , ,?f'r :? i; :r'?. rfE wgjtF:• .Ij7. .3' ,f w?. 'Lf• r.. s ., .e' .j? _ ..?):;%° ?1 !' ,T; ??i' _ i•'). ?, '?'t i i? _ + rh J t 'Y j'" '1- `}Y' ?'P ?'{?t71' ? 1•, s: z;'' `l:'?e 1$I:r, t'i"fi'r' 's: t,' .f',a f- .9.• .o?' .r'?t'.t. sr:? ?' ?i'i e?!'?`?'t{;s. b•. `tr., ,r °?"'X,,P, ,f -'e +3',ltd;'•'" _f, r'?:. ,"a?"'?g"p' .r.'. ., 3. '1; °•df ;f .b•: ?-.3+ "f+• ' .; CITY, OF C L E A R W A T E R + Interdepartmental Correspondniace 1r .. . ' . ' fir;' "` - ?. , ? t ? r i `. ? •.1 ?- °.?? TO: ' Mayor Garvey. ' .FROM:.. Sally'Thomas, Agenda Clerk SUBJECT: Invocation COPIES: Cynthia Goudeau, City Clerk =+ rj, DATA: ) March 18, 1993 Tonight's ,invocation will be given.'by Reverend John+Palaririe, Episcopal Church ,of the ''Ascension •7 fir.,'. ,F,31 01 ' Orange; Avenue Clearwater FL'' 34616. " .', `•,f' FJI?<°<.. j f e1, ' .. .. - y Y '.,.?1' ` ?. , lS:• I .! .. Yi?,•f?T i,?y CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION {4 Agenda Cover Memorandum item 0 31L 8193 Meeting Date: Subject: SERVICE AWARDS Recommendation/Motion: The following. employees be presented with service awards for their length of service in the employment of the City of Clearwater, ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: 5 Years: Cindi R. Hochberger Fire Department Thomas P. Burns Public Works/Public Service Cornelius Legters III Planning & Development Dennis L. Allen Parks & Recreation Charles E. • Porthousc Parks & Recreation Laura G. Chase DOAS/CIS 10 Years: lames Ruggiero Fire Department Beverly Ncwbanks DOAS/UCS 15 Years: Lawrence J. Anderson Public Works/Infrastructure Helcn Davis DOAS/UCS Carolyn M. Moore Library 25 'Years: Samuel Collie Public Works/Utilities/Solid Waste Reviewed by: Originating Dept.: Legal Human Resources Budget Purchasing User Dept.: Risk Mgmt. DIS .ACM Advertised: Other_ Date: Submitted by: Paper: ? Not required Affected parties ? Notified City Manager ? Not required Costs: Commission Action: Total ? Approved ? Approved wlcondillons Current FY ? Dented ? Continued to: Funding Source: ? Capt. Imp. ? Operating Attachments: ? Other Approprialion Code; ? None s? Ir 4;. s ' rr`' y'3S% , ? "!E '. «. '{'. .aY7v.?.5•':`,.:F..,'a'._ Lj..t ° ,. . ? _, ° •,1 .. .' t, ... ,f-f:d'5,? TO: Mayor Rita Garvey . FROM: Betty J. Blunt, Confidential Clerk Receptionist COPIES: City Commissioners, Michael Wright, Cyndie Goudeau SUBJECT: Presentations at the March 18, 1993 City Commission Meeting ; DATE:,, March 18, 1993 f The following presentations will be made at the March 18, 1993 City Commission meeting. , f SERYLCE PINS ' Carolyn Moore, Library ( letter of appreciation & watch) } Samuel Collie, Public Works/Utilities/Solid Waste ( letter; of appreciation,- day off with pay and dinner certificate} EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH for March, 1993 is LaVonne Newcomber, Legal Staff Assistant, 'Legal Department. (write-up and check) PROCLAMATION ARBOR DAY - REAM WILSON ,,y,!!x!• ?.,`,;'•r. • • ' 'rte r , W.'' ?J . f. i Agenda No. MEMORANDUM TO: Meeting Date: 3/18/93 The City Commission of the City of Clearwater Special Meetings of 1/15/93 & 3/10/93 SUBJECT: City Commission Minutes of Regular M eeting of 3/4/93 RECOMMENDATION: Approve minutes as submitted by the City Clerk ? And that the appropriate ?offlclals be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND:, Subject minutes were submitted to the Commission with regular daily mail. Commission Disposition; Follow-up Action: 1. Approved as Recommended/Revised/Conditional Z Continued to date Submitted by: Advertised: C1 Af facted Costs: 0Attachments: ' Date: Parties ' Funding Source: Notified ? Capital Improve- City Manager Paper: of Meeting ment Budget ? Operating Budget 0Not Required C3 Not Required ? Other Originating Department; Date aSe4uential Appropriation Code oda Reference ? None f ? w?t,•+.' ''}i• vr.f '. r' 4' F. -f "1'. 'C • i .. ?+..{ef.• .•S `lI ? '(:.'.' :'?4, w'k• Mi. ' i, ? .. cat , rt l.. ...+?4! 'la .tip ;1•, .1 j d - .?t .. !J. ?lf((+? .'>? ?,•,{ >! •JA •? ?'1 . .'t. j •e ? ,: i j` .. ?F .r F. , ?'r .SJ 1. '?` ? • '?' j . t e '.F ?.+ Pr ? , I , , - 'f • (1 3.'1 ? F?? ? M. „ ,.?S j:,'?°?F.', •'' i I-?+t: ?-F,o ,r 5' ?;l' ';'r i.: ?r'y.,y ar. ?.,F,. ? A. f .4 n ... ! ,j. •,•,,J;? ), ?•7' ? , r. 3l, ! '.-1- '' '3' `Fy r sY., i• .E '?!r 1 S' .3 r1 .'.tw { 'r ?';= ,'t- -. r ,? ''{+ ?J `Y'`?F -1 xaa'?1`x i y ,'l. i .. rr'~ ,{l,, •r •rat l' r ?s11':M"rePdaA{;: .k,' r ..A,,.. .. .<f,'s.K:..:S.li.-:ri'n,.ja..?.i-°,., <.., i.. ... ... °, ... .. <a° °i. r•?i? .e•!' r ... ..- .... `/ a?+?i ., J'x' ? ? i., ?k .. l ? . ° ?a I , r, r r .. ., j •3 .1., 1 >( } tom.. ,.. .., ... - ? , .. .. .. < a ... .. .. •. .. ' .. a •?, }:,° 71 Is Y.. .'y. ,! t'1 ' {..1" ? • , . ,!' ... - .,j? 'Et ..t',. L•F'-+?, e?.t?,'t.4!'.+rs5• +.Ai` -____ • , 1. ,. .f,, tl.,. .. t..! .. T. ,. i'.•:. Ai f'.F'?F!>•T. ',i31s' ??•tisj;ir?t+l?.S°fiis4r%,y r . ?..?ir ¦ Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum PUBLIC Ito Meets e: 3 PI.D I6 SUBJECT: Alcoholic Beverage Separation Distance Variance; 2569 Countryside Blvd; Countryside Village Ltd (Owner); Fiddlestix Cafe and Grill/Gentile (Applicant/Representative) AB 93-05 RECOMMENDATIONWOTION: ? Approve variance of 200 ft. to allow alcoholic beverage sales within zero ft. of a similarly licensed establishment, and ? Approve. variance of 15 ft. to allow alcoholic beverage sales within 285 ft. of a residential zone for Countryside Village Square, lots 5, 7 and 8 since the applicants have met all Standards for Approval of Land Development Code Section 45.24 ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicants are requesting two variances to permit a 2-COP alcoholic beverage establishment to locate zero ft. from a similarly licensed establishment and 285 ft. from a residential zone. The subject ,property is a restaurant named "Fiddlestix Cafe and Grill". The distance separation variances are required because the subject property is closer than 200 ft. to Jo To Japanese Restaurant, and closer than 300 ft. to a. residential zone. The subject establishment is under new ownership and has a new alcoholic beverage license. The property is zoned Commercial Center. No additional parking is needed. There are 1,950 parking spaces at Countryside Village Square, and the, applicant intends to share with other tenants at this shopping center. The police department has no concerns with this request. The applicant's request for a conditional use permit was unanimously approved by the Planning and Zoning Board.on February 16, 1993 subject to the following three conditions: 1) The requisite occupational license shall be obtained within six .o Reviewed by: , Originating Dept: ? Costs: NIA Commission Action: Legal N/. PLANNING AND I V L P T Total Approved Budget N/A ?? 111 ? Approved w/conditions N/A Purchasin N/A g © D ied Risk Mgmt. N/A gser Dept: Current Fiscal Yr. en cis N/A © Continued to: ACM E Funding source: other N/„A --- d Capital Imp. Advertised: 0 operating Attach Date: 3/9/93 ? other Monts: 1,1 Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE APPLICATION © d i CONDITIONAL USE APPLICATION Not Requ re Submitted by. Affected Parties Appropriation Code: MAP ? ® Notified None . Not Required 13 C Manager sit Printed on recycled paper C.C. 3118193 AB 93-05 Page 2 months of the date of this public hearing; E 2) The operation is limited to consumption on premises only with no package sales; and 3) The ,applicant shall obtain from the City Commission the necessary separation distance variances. i A summary of relevant information on the subject property is highlighted in the following two tables: PROPOSED ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE 2-COP LICENSE DESIGNATION PROPOSED INTERIOR FLOOR SPACE 1,178 sq. ft. ALLOWABLE OCCUPANCY 50 seats as determined by the Fire Marshal OUTDOOR SEATING None PARKING REQUIREMENTS No additional parking space will be required. There are 1,950 parking • spaces at Countryside Village Square and the applicant intends to share with other tenants at this shopping center. PROPOSED HOURS OF OPERATION 11:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. Mondays through Fridays, 11:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. on Saturdays. Closed on Sundays. SEPARATION DISTANCE VARIANCE Will be required. PROPOSED ENTERTAINMENT None ALCOHOLIC SALES ESTABLISHMENTS WITHIN 300 FEET OF SUBJECT SITE -. "I ESTABLISHMENT NAME ADDRESS LICENSE DESIGNATION Countryside Cuisine 2541 Countryside Blvd. 2-APS Knickerbockers 2543 Countryside Blvd. 4-COP-SRX Albertons 2545 U.S. 19 North 2-APS Jo. To Japanese Restaurant 2549 Countryside Blvd. 2-COP Basket of Joy 2559 Countryside Blvd. 2-APS The following variance worksheet table summarizes staff findings concerning the approved standards for variances. Staff finds that all eight standards are met. ! O m Q cc W m z /uj V/ U m Y m u.! U Q C) y a m y a N ?? co 'C • w m C N 13 ' ro y O a) cm C Q c r m C l ca ? m • u U) " m :n m n - %_ b m Co N a C a - m N° G m m m to r- y c o N a E o - O C O C > Cp ++ w G L7 r '?" +. V) ' in d U C L C 14 C ,` a c U o C m e C) n3 C C a .w ro Q O"- -14 r O a O C O' m w Q r m E N E N o c E .0 4) m S N C ?s ~ C `C C U C 3 N CD !2 m g CV 41 ro a) o d) o? L?° N> a) 1E ma tz"E 4m cm .vaCi L Q V aN+ I Q U ,N-. 1 w U c N m ' CD W Q ' C m m 'U N O + -' O '_ U w W C •« v M d C - . N Cl 0. ? ' m N Cs Q v1 V c O_ C E 4 a A G c CD - w +» ° w c O , ?,, O co U O m ro O an U E m O N U • C a O H N O U N w a; E i O L c U O m O O m c N a 4 O U C• 4 W O O C CD N m m m G 'ra _ m m C > ' u E ° w sfl p m C [a E CwL a 1 L C m m C) m C) CS - a E i C! W '? E ro L C C 'w C L m •^ CU a ?+ m l w O C c C N N. E E t, . N CD a m p•- cu TJ c? +' y N : c.c N Q 0 w i m c E j , i o E U E C U C y } , G `?' O E 6 ,? r U m 'w a C C m C a .- a ( m L Q , O Ql m o a) ro 9 E L m N C i?+ ro N O ,N U N• V N Cl C C, • ? ' p •a C) -0- M 0 E .L C Q cs C G Q v _ a T' m a m C ? a 7 * ., n c m c y Q ? L ?' ` N m o E L its to TA m cn C i e 70 .c o ? m [i m m c) m a m Q p c m tn % Lo m (n m m c .? i i? cl) ° o r V) m CD ° v°1i s a C ° w O O a- O C I- Co a)) m (" ? _.., O a- E- > w w Z .N Q ?- V t s O O a) C N p C -C ca •`= N m _ U .C C) u ' ' N u •+- O G C O L •,.. L Q N N O N a N w N O C) C O N ?+ U Y C7 . O C a ; U O C C (D a] . 0 a + N . 0 a 7 .Q 4 -jB .- 0 U '> O W. CI w O } ID N C U 7 CS m d m a Q • N o 7 m m .o C > CL p c O d o- a C w Q c a ` a U ° (' ._, (?,.? C • o 'o u) m °C. Q O CL d ` c am. CD w 6- E c m a .? m :3 o a c m ?' 'w .¢ m ?' w -o m e 4-j m' y. p q1 O C 6 A ?C, t4 C m C1 E ,ti C ? O o a c 'c N -o CU `Q c? . d E 'L m Cl) C? c w a w E > w?o?w ' as•°y °L Eo E•a,? avic°s o ... o Cm W 00 -CL w- E,c mo?s??, , 4: a) c • a? C a +-• cl a Q E +-' U L L > o a . to N C Q 7 m C to m r- N x ` ++ E u 0 CU CD A C to ? a C E¢ O N C C1 a%. .O C C d C} +., m d IV CD L O U C 47 C: a' m 0 ' G _ w . 0 V y ,n c m m c C CO c C) m C L O U C c L m co 3 C C a 4' ? a a o w ro ' C O= a.l E c N G CL U E [A +? p w O U a >• S3 C E C7 ` C L m C G` C 1 0 p U w C C .] m w O acnCL . N a O C C) c° U W m p . t7. L U 0. "aE C m C) LE 4? y ' ? n a E > > ? y ? o a w a O a m m D c L 'O CD m c Co, L Q O rn ° m co N C) am 'C > Co .O W I m 0 N N w O .-1 O C C) L N o W N > L or C U L CI c o Q , p m m ?. o + ., L w b c L ,v1 m a .? w o t] m 1h w .?. p p O V p w? C U O 0 CL) r O m O v m O 4- w tO.ti L C71 n) m Q .O E d m .C C O G .a w ' O,, U U C` N N Cl N C N C N a D m N C L) C, L 4I M, .` W m ,h O a O C= ro> m N ?' (n ?;d 4 o E > 0 L- ,? 12 0 a N Q m m' ° > G CD c m N a° a. °' C W N C '+- ° ' a C a v C m U E c c N c O G U w o Q O a O m = E ro m 41 m L m .G c O . N a a M .O N O a m i"1 .C d m Lo.E w td O U ,C N n Q 00 m P- :7 03 EXIT OP MPIARWAIVI ALCUI IULIC IILYm ACjl: SAI.t'S . MINIhiUhi D1SrANOt VA1UANCr. AI'1'UCA11W4 (Plcuc I'Ant or l pc, Black Ink Only) '1`110PURTY OWNURS NAMU do ADDRESS: 'RV-rRPS ArrATIVL-S (U any) RAMn AND ADDIUMS: (Allach Venal Pct Instructions) t A7 5yZ dnau fr12tlCi2>? JT? 1??UrT? ?? r?L g LO mr- TF?f.Ll'l1OtJLh,*_ JSS? -?1,??['Y,la? 'I'L4I:PfIO 73 17:112:7 AAI413 Or BUSINL'SS:_ 'r ADDIL?r1M a 1'ItOrL'1LTX (Subject oI ltequcl): r? ti L.' `ti ?. i v d t I ?% rl?. • . LLCiAL DL?SCIW'1701J OP.1'ILOCLrfLTY (subject of Requrst); E ZONWO D15"I'RICT: en v Q L VARIANCE RCOUEST (Dc=ibc Ma SpcaficlAiinch Additional 8 1/2 s 11 inch sheet it needed): Valiance or 2prb reel rrom minimum distance rcq+dremetnt to allow nlmho evrrn(te saes within reel- from (checl: one r"mare): CburcI4 School, Hospital, Residential Zanc, Srmllarly Ucenced Alcoholic Beverage Establitiuncut (COP License). State (leverage License Designation: JJr l lolder of Stale Ucense•? C !7 C A& -Z e2 A CONDITIONAL USE ArrL[CATIO FOR Or10LlC BEVERAGE SALES MR 11'IYS PROPERTY WAS ArrrtOvnD UY 1Tir-PLANNING do zoNtNG OARD ON (DATE). 0'14iSR Vn]LIANCFS (CHECK ON ARE NOT NECESSARY, OR WERE ArrILOVI D BY T1m - DaveLOrmotr CODE AD7US'rhmNT 5aARD ON (DATE)- I HAVE TLEAD ORDINANCE 4420.57 AND SECi10N 137.012, CODE OF ORDU-ANCES Or. JIM- L= C)F CLEARR'ATE L l JWiASON FOIL" VARIANCE REQUEST - in order for the City Commission to snake the determination prestribed by Ordinance 4420.87, the following statements hiUST be completed: ??1.++ There are special conditions or eireumstances applicable to the property involved bccausc:_ l.. O Z Such valiance is necessary for the praservalion nod enjoyment of a zubstan6al properly right possessed b other pro erry in the Santa district under the terms of this ordinance and denied to the propetly in question because. .- r 1 ka. W1fil 3. The granting of this vttriagcc will not confer any spacial privilege denied to other lands, structures, or dwellings m th - same district and Kill not be Injurious to the neiglrbarbood, or otbcruise detrimental to the public welfare because: LL-x E'S ? ..1???i--,?-•4v ts1aG?? d1?.G.? t! O•t??C,r rlc. ?-?t.t_?.?.-. c1 t,u,L 1:?1)?Si.ti?s'S SIGNATLII- Olr 1'RO 'L-:ILZ•Y OWNER ("DIE ILL'r•rLfsur rnr rvY ; mired !7r x- t';who bring duly %morn, Before me the un rsi ac out ran ,cross i u Before p ?J says under oath the rnallers and Inds set Clot above are true and correct Vo tire best of his/her knowledge Rnd belie( _?., 14 f Sworn to rind subscribed before she this day of "' u A,,Djll.t .*nr.lRV // r'k:nt.tc. crntl: nr n•nrtn,w , 1 ?" gx r'sr.l+'.rtae':Irru.r?k: 1.Al 4. lq'rs. rY Public aa vanocu nuau MalAav rusuc unuxaeurs Not 'I'ROPLRW OSWNLR Olt RLI'ALr4Lx AT[VI3 jrs 5T larEND IiLARING. J AWitlll?r114ff "Altndr I'uit•cr Clr Atinrnry or notnrircrl statement final owner nulltor'uSng represaatirivc - not appliable it rcpresct6live is a plactianr, altonrcy Wing on behalf nf'ihc property nwrhrr(S), Altach pruuuf of 11Cloal rlislnrrre (See Land D=1013menl Ccrdc Sm l2v5,02A(d)(3) for rtmrtliml of mcmuremcal), l k .. ). ! Ie / i , Irk is AI,COI IE)LTC IIH%TJ A e1! SALMIS MII MILIhl 1)=AI4= VARIANCE A)'1'I. CAT1ON , '. fast ' I ficleby alrtrm that 1 aai aprrying for ¦ variance for praperty addressed as lallows: from the distance requirement lobe heard by-the City Coutmisslon, and liave paid the at+plicAtion fee according to the current seheduleor fees, wldch will be used Ia offaeI the costs to the City or Clearwater for adverlising public bearing notices' ' and other expenses. This application 1s being riled prior to a decision being rardctcd by the Planning and Zoning Board .on a Conditional Use request for the same property. By signing this form f am acknowledging that, ahould the planning and Zoning Board deny the request for Conditional Use, orshould the Planning and Zoning Board grant,lhe request and the decision be appealed to the State Ilearing Officer lie variance application will be removed from the City Commission Agenda and the application fee will J>¢.L be refunded: Also, should the Planning and Zoning Board continue a decision nn the Condidanal Use request necessitating additional advertising. I will bear the additional advertising costs. f°altlhcrtnarc I ealed in the State Bearing Officer 6iaUld the decision of the Plannin 'and Zonin Board be a , , g pp g tindeistand flit variance application will be on Bald pending the Pleating Officer's decision and, depending on that decision, . I % either be liable for additional advertising costs or will forfell my application fee. ?= Applicant's Sign tuc . Sworn to and subscribed befose'me this day of Notary Publi ' ' NOTARY rUJILIC. &rATr: OF FI.tIRInA. TERRY ANN WbFlA i ^ ' OMMISSIO` MY Mt. %P April a. 1991. ¦anaen nilU NOTARY 11:IILIC t itw k T maC iti 6 s. VARIANCE- INSTRCIC770N5 Apt) LU.1ioll and ,53t?missian_Revuirc:rseots: 1, The application must'be fully completed signcd by • the property owner (or a rcPresentadvr. of the oivncr )r ' and notarized. Any application signed by a representative of the owner must be supplemented by a power of attorney or nolat zed statement from the owner autbnrirang representative. Proof of property ownership . "' i must be attached for an application to be considered complete. Adequate proof shall consist of one of the i ' , falloxinE:. ' a. A copy of the deed. ' b.- A copy or title insurance, i •. ' c. A'Ictter from a praetichig attorney conrtrming property mvocrsltip. { 2. The application sliall tic riled at the office or the Development Code Administrntor. At the titilc of riling . a fee shall be paid according to the current schedule of fees. 3. Any supplemerilary Information; exhibils, plans or tnnp% which tire In accompany and constilufc part Of the ; application must be sUbtuitted at file time of rd'uig of tic application. Twelve (12) copses of all such documents if larger than 8 VZ x 14 incises, shall be furnished by the applicant for distributional purposrs. { 41 041 1= .. ..cu,...:itrtaw. t. a. /?j•ilu:.w:llrl,. H,ex,eluutl,?•K.in=.. ,:wl: , Blsca 5:11 (lA? 'SSIT.'t..SS Q13'" 0 p W"Lct Proo. Pc: 1rss?urions) (Hold= o! State lixniC) J r e. L) C. =Uq L, ri v m t n C 1 cn 'S -T., (Z r r Ps_s (n c JCCI Y- L,=,-(C a i .1 L) F6 Tcl_p5on fur r elephone T r 66i ..h?, ! L •P.EPR F-h-PATE NAME A' 'ADDR'SS5: P? ri L-, r, ? / P, CI NAME OF ABLLSHM.. N TO BE LILEN5E7: li-!!,I 1 ?- CFa-??L t ?_ - - - --• '--- LEGAL DF-SCRIPTION OF ROPERTY: k • ' u (Subject of Requ=t) r LAND USE PLAt: C C C -7' • ZONING DIS TMCT: • CLe155>?ChTj DN: , r "•'FRVSEW USE, OF PROPERTY: o&4 r Ir5 - ""PROPOSED L}I5 OF YR0.' TELTY:'I'j • I " ' '- ' SURROUNDING Lmm USES: North - "- Smith t'.. • - East vrti i- - vb z A-I CCHO'_.IC BElER.AGE r1: Lcr,7s=r5c_ ? r _IC:fSs DaSIGNAMON: - [ ] paritg: S a- DO YOU PROPOSE TO PROVED : ZN==R frDOMN'T ON 11QNSED PREIMES7 If v cs, d=gibe T YP?• OF R QG :ST (Crsack Apoli:ble B= nr Bm--, ):. M Ncw U==--- [ ] Adaress c7h=za _ [ ] BS in=s Onn=sWp Cax.nge [ ] I;==zs Desi_Cnauon Carnes [ ] Exxp=sio n IlwIMMOR OU CDOOR Sr?'ITS: FLOOR ARB-k. • pAR12ING: LAND AR=-.1: S-E1-rYNG AREA: scurg M=ii S soS . E::i:iag b_ .?--isr'og s-.tl Ul bsai- =-"dg C) •^_°. P 3 d rapos: Propos: so Praaased iq SC? PTDPPS?dC f S, Prposed s?? ?iDUPS OF OPFp.ATION. W e=kda-?1 ALLAWhBL-E CAtiAC*T:' (D:t-_ 3•-1^=d by =r Aiatsaa]} Ci 516 5o-.c f Indom D p ? c - d I ut : SIGNAT ME O F HPZ MAI'SI:iAL .d o nq ORALg.TION LN Suppoya 0- r=- at 7.=Z -?'3y-Sly-G? - 531f e ?a.Vrn'S p SIGNF.;-)?F0- Dp?? (..05 p-.n nc='? :. =T11 = OF. SUSLTti=SS O vJh } °°S ??'l'_ Y? • '? s. o 1?'^ `.' Vc - _.. . ? .. .? ' Bela: .e, •?.:::na="y= == =:::s?:inr F?ar.?.li}• agp?..? ,?g /Q+/A ??•? ? • G ?,c1 f'i1 Y ?f a•: ^ psi ?'??• sw•[:.? s'}y - ?.w' fl2•? .__ ..._,.c.. ! __. ..ti, _ ..: .. __..., __ ;?_ ate. c_• za aac - ?• f -'• • n';:^••- a_. a. .._. Sao _r - 93- frr • r l?l I ? 11 1lrts r rUAI&A r ..•L.f u• e.., lw . T.Ira. V?h?' u: JAN • C AN . 1ra.. r t..l ?lr [.tr. lr. tel. > f" cA N?T? /SbQ?prn M1 _ be nuxr= T,d aY 1?7 Moen on c ti.dLr..Css. •O DVYf i.8LL15W,FSS.t7YV1iEe? MM-OR WATWE MUSS ATTEND )-MV .-t FMFI gNdflSAi= F?tw„ CHM =- OF t LLW4r.SS vwrr?H:n OF AN N-t.'7 W-i= 0--- AGES ° UM* iXE NEW RUSJNE3 . On THAT CMN=-- W-y, iTATiv=- SHA:;• ATTMm TH-- FMAMN.a 1 Ym AL,- msTi i noNS ON S>D--^ j FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY r rZC)L'IR.,w J $ l [I 41 C?AC$F OL . --"? 1 1{N YQR• SEP r RCS, ZoN? . . CDftitl?4L 5IC? i-- - - .. w NONE L , 1 yS i 1 ??l': iJ•">h,;= '?f'Fir?:• s'<- 'fit: -r; .>>?t:: a.:° •r F'{•.r„_ A a,ra •i,:r a+• nn '?skrr„ d, . r:li Ff''{';E. '•i art •"r''. .t i,; r: i ?i X1.1'.'' fY :'? ?! .e rA ' ?`?, ?` Y"r.z iyi.. f'r, r-I %+', f '?. ai ,f .l •r``° r i? .!', ?? 'r•F, r ';air i;, ss' 11,f°? ?YJ,?Iy?,. 'ri(, r:.?;l. ': •.Y n•i• 'J ,. .:'_ ,. <1i ?"¢'e r'is?yf?;I Sty/f.•° .. 1: r .? ?. 7. 1= .€, ! !'i ? _ F' 't ,? `:TS';e • ?'E ' ., . `'? ?? ? ? .a, a; t'?6 'r xi #' `. f, ., F , .. .. r 1 .. ?' ? 's`§',:€S??i '?'+ r ?4' ?•• ?-,, tA. :.?• ,7?>, tf :1.1'.Ai `, , r•. .s ? 'Il... ,!• ?•i rf:fla' ??z1.. .. :,j '. ?? , ;i , o . i.f ryr 7,?•'! ?''r i v r t r + •.. J'3• ... . ?J`.'J?56? ?i¢r1. :??. ,Y f . i' •',:/?'F? ??, i ' 'S? ! ? r1 4?• '' ?r {' R,';i`t:?? ¢`!., "tF. r, ,! '? .? °'l. ¢4r?;'. .i. , ., ? ,. 'a 'i', !• t? ?'t.iF',A,:'?. ^SL.. ,.i?;'i 'r:•. .;. 1, 1°'•, ifs .6 ,r'?, ..1 ?r.,?1°,?'r•? ? 1 .. "?:cL•" :.iA.•1. ,.c. 't f ; €:? ? !'? ''•?• { 11 S: i' ,? r` 'r { r. r ?G?`' u.Y rrc r.f }a r.3' .`!•. `l, i•.: p.' F' . `-T ?A Jt? ?•!',.. r?r .s• k•'??• 16, `'r, '#?.`,Y,!•' »I l,??„ `c •tr ,?. ??» 'J' .i. 't 'rr, ,.§ ,{'-r'':•r i?' y°44'. :?? ??? .€ `i. L f?f t fii .k: .: Fr' , A' r' ' ?`.'. ,;r','.',?}?: d z.. r, 1, 'f! , it' 4, ??'t.'ti ? S?r ? 'r' ? ° e :• r;t: ,f {- , a ?i ?. .!»,> .J?tr° 1'-3? !?'. y'd?r r.. •.?' '>• "i' i' '?1,• Y? :Y. tSy° J, ;5. r,' F t. _ s,.f"7?;?' ?., ":: ?.t' .! 1 • ?, . '•j ',?i '. f. t?'•?t f )7•a-f. ,r ? r F >;.1: ';. ',zl"Rr.ift'3 t ,4 -rl -!. . .a' , r.. . f??'? ?s.c? ?='r -. '. r" .? ;i;1s? ?sF ,;r r,-,`},' ??. :.;'s `r rpr,: •?-f? ? _. _ 1 ? aj .r '?rl. / •r. •.r ! ¢'?..:.j'.. s'??r t - j...'e: •J' ..f - ! 't' 5 w?. '.?S.F-,?.. 'pi'e, _ {I A'd•?` ,']?`.ii -'Y. f' ;?i' r. r ? t. :,i,;J` ?,?..r ?,t? '?.? ?j`~?r?:y?.', ..Ft . r, _.fY r ? j•. ,,=i : r rF' •'f , .. ,. ° 1 , t• ,lam,. ri FINS, 4' •°r' :?f•'o, ! ti's r' rk -??'` . `S:. ??....?'Y,•,..} { ,w. d?..I ?`?:t': ;:kr„ ,i,. ?, .: t?: ?, a*:". °. ,...,. ? ,•r`.l. r;?i•::;'. ;:; ,., r. "f.`?r.Yi?s. :;,a:.r.i°1r'r,;; .,...r> r` f ,'To. Wholly ! t. Maly Concern We have, ollened.a cafe 1n Countrys?cI' bgl.l vl , Iage F We" sei;vc gc,lod, qLt I ? L;f food etl ui-.tsr.ile, ?1.•' pi, J-cec4 ca Lar:L u ?o the inov, •. goel•s .. ?l r?l ll rt 1•:! . 1'r?.1 ' ' trnxki t?g nInop ; Tn 'two :I f rmr. ,,r'ev inr'Is busjnesses i-i hi.ufi 15.r our 'guLs .r,raer 'And 4'} I1, l+if: ; X12"Gllgi? rionce, we1'I u11de1=sLaltd f:h+- t'cspUrlsilJi ] a`E:ti? r;i ,'1'?'r''F rr t 'vlIIIg liI and.?r'1FIC 'tQ guesl.: Wlttl 1ll'UIjf.'1•'.1Ctti1+. #:. t.s'_rII ,i11,1 upll• ![??.i1Ci ttlr }]) 'xJt4'!1'' 'l?J.9 '1 %1r?111: Ilartkyou Kaithryne aciiid A11t}ica3yy G, II I. i ] t ;, 100 rJ; '•.7 ? >'. r, a .. %. ?,• , 'S r? ? ' ??. ? ?x• '? !if 1 s A ,' r .'1 •. ;# 3 r r - .F.r4? •rf ?µ ?I• r •t i ?. ` ,4, '.S ? A•?, ?ri ' . ) fF .? '-4'•f .''#, e fy ?.. A .P, :# .i.. i? ? .. ',6 ?fr • -.;:. ') 11r f'•, '??f?i1?.i1,, '? 1. .. ,. . rsF. .?'• r51' ?4 ;' `li 1t,,.',? :?]ii`?'?. l.?}:Si?r'i`'?'4sP: f A?fr': Iirtti ,Dr rt ?. y. 4.,lii•???,yl y, .r,', r`i F?€., w'af 't, .. fide M I?? S ??'?ti?4•??'? S ?= '„ ,?1'¢ t . r -At AFFIDAVIT' -Ppope ?: ?? • s Pry H14R. I, a±4NKIF., n 2N as eaamr of the property described as {Include positron and name of company (f applicable), ` nr?i. s rb bra r,? _ tio4?,PlT t? do hereby authorize Ati_STwAyZ CI.-•_M t CH ("'n rr t3T l LE to appear before the: LJ Development Coco Adjustment Board (Variance) t-----? Pl=ning.& Zoning Board (Conditional Use) City Commission (Alcoholic Beverage Distance Variance, Sign Variances') to request approval of t-?1=R 4„• VJ 11,7E L i c N59: :.:? _ ?u:. ,tip.., t.•• :.wc?"n?..+......?^?:..r'i+...' aril. •. .. - _ n:Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) before me this 23 P2day of , A.D. 19-12--, -aw:.-*:... "by Ja°?tHa N1lCf ssf Pro Goa u- , who is rsonall own ._ _, .. Print Now (enelude position and nano 0 oamparsY (plieable) to me and has produced as identification, (Type of aaet fcation) t STATE. OF-FLORMA tM- COUNTY OFN 0.S 4 r t. •' f Notary Publir., Commission No. NOTARY PUIIL *S67?Vd'o'r%A. MY UUMIn1551ON EXPIRES: OCT. 9, t9PL.. 04MAC0 THRU NOTARY Punic UND"WWWC1 1 ' (Name of Not ry typed, printed or blamped} 1 y.: is c' r tit `+y? ' ;r FI a [, : 1 .' r ' .sl ' .e`` f .,i r , ` rs f ' rf , r e i^ } a r •.r'?.,'r .',y is •' ,. r f., '` ? ? ''j, _ r , ,. 1f, ' ? r I'1 9 Sketches should be drawn in ink and include all walls, doors, counters, sales'areas, storage areas, restrooms, bar locations and any other specific areas which are part of the premises sought to be licensed. A multi-story building where the entire building is, to be licensed must show each floor. • r J s_.. ?. 0 ;?? VI I ' 0 D V) i l? ' ,t, ' .r Ir .?Y?},k?•? r,,r 'ir••'ri?i'-r =Lf'1rl % f r r r , r E ` , r , .i riVt7.E-57'IX CAFF_; GIRILL sECTioN ._. ? CEnTIPIED TO• 1OYYNSIIIP ? nANGE _._.lfp?• couw-t'1_7sIpr_ 15L-vv. • t;1? r1r7 ? ? ' S r IN •o p 3" At L,, De, ?O T tL G ?1?rt?O1P ('C-5.¢3 nrC „ aIS?! 2 7? ? !+? Qotl SniC ?'' ?f1 E Ins 1K.1' rn. t ,•.YA-LAtIT 1 • ? ,e.n. wfrl¢drs w•turtr.. J ytc.4 ' I"rnDLGS'TIX ?r I YAG. , '. i C^ Ste. ,[ r+T ftI•L ?tPMit rKa'a. yl 4 n..i. "Tiltl'kc cRo,.,..1 A%Ir.n?L rs•,S r u F• on- Trial ANgLG `Q`V V }A PILL Soul-If CLEANCrt:S "l. PA . -L` nS.+s S,c tp ?ql (sue { ? p,. Q.. IIfJMIt wt4 13 .c {PJ ry ? 0'l1 e, .1 LQ ?,..,a r.n Cj .0,ylT? ?rJ,,5 1 qti s„N?+A/ IJ r .`t t 4 ! ?Q IT U m :: ly J Y9 A _ {E' ? . .J• i6 p ` 0 g 11-1 ltrtJT Tr'? X,,; ler' ?? vur ?r ?r I s m *? O t X44 ? . q &A W L J_ m ,?+7? si:4s a W 4 Z557 RIB Of PRp P05 E D L`!-!LI $EE:f? WI?JE. WCHNSE. ti SLjlt-v"[ "POUT 7AKE" fgDM riTy D? CLr-ARrJrt7•EF•. Z17"11445t IMF (AkTZp ?•t5 ?`Y ) EVANS LAND SURYEVr NG INC 2300 IN T FL 4598 18131734-3821 UNED N D 1 DESCRIPTION AS PROVIDED BY CLIENT SURJEV TYPE DATE nro n 2. SURVEY YWS PERFORMED WITHOUT BENEFIT OF AN ABSTRACT OF TITLE U ILvEvE p IZ•tg- 2 9L• fd? a CTT}IER THAN SHOWN ON PLAT THIS FIRM MADE NO ATTEMPT TO RESEARCH 1NVIUMENTS OP nECORD REFLECTING EASEMENTS RIGHIS OF WAY APV T)tu Cll IaN . ANDIOR OWNERSHIP THAT MAY EXIST AND ARE NOT SHOWN ON THIS DKIvr; SURVEY NO UNDEFIWOUND INPR(NEMENTS WERE LOCATED I HERE"Y CERTIFY THAT THE SU MIEY REPRESE NTED NFRECIN FCM •FOUNDCONOTETE MONUMENI PCP •PERMANENI COIITFI(X POINt MEETS THE MINIMUM REOUIREMENTSOFCHARTEn21 NHF FIP .FOUND FION PIPE PRM PERMANENT RFFErtfriCE MOtJtIMENt OF THE FLORIDA ADMIrjpITATIVE CDDE FPP -FWM PRICH PIPE CONC 'CONCRETE FIR •FOUTDRTONROO ESMI 'EASEMENT ?+ .' S FN A3 •FOUNO NAIL IN DISK DRN •C RAINAGF -' LAn L E N FLOI;IW RE TRAlIOIi NO S' SNfD .SET NAIL IN DISK M ' MEASURFO JOHN C BI FLORIDA REOISTRATIC+Ntfp HPP SIR -SET FTONROD G CALCULATED rt+??tlrtmn?,cn[?I,asxn+s+I . y 1 .• ?E f• + ?" 1 i. 41 r 8 3 4 it ,?` ?f L M Q ' f COUNTRYSIDE ?a,??3, ?°-- VILLAGE < • +s r? HD R ?f• •' 7 SQUARE \ '- t 155 ?? ss?' 92-07 C, C n6 C/TF -? 4, o• h . au aannrrrrs 1 6 -48 \ r', '? J orr riwurorslpr n r ` G LP ; L 4 & ? ! app '' ? ? C7 ' ? s ? c _ '- c • , hAL 73- 9 ' 43/12 %GE AT ,EFLAT.92-90,.'O? s -. - ??.: MM YIfUGZ AT. ?..-tr 'LR --t CDVItIYLDX C 1 oi{'R M G 03 T _3'_A?? - GE- QUARE -07 t NIU.AGE A COUNTRYSIDE REPLAY ,?\ti. tt/oa 10 .;t.-f 92-90 • • ; _ ... * _ ?\ o ` \ 11/ 2 "s . ? • ®?6? a? ,?`?\ ~+~? Ram ,C C k1% 0.1 00 160 A • w• +}Y.L47 ?UiJ4t?t+r}cF:iY.`' S ~T,. w f•. 'i: ?;- 4•]:}• f;,av•rrrrw,.-..•?Y•rr..?,. ?.!^.:h Sr<"S?':FR:4?• ^! rr r f. o7CN4 a4cw.,•.. r ,, :4?4 n; ?..N r, r.,Y7:c>:a. 4t?;. i.,r {{• ;d 1N .? ;.i. .e; .. ?fq .. ;?sa• • ?.vn .s: e z s m.,.,:cx. Y4%b:' y}t:,ty d.. r ?' ? ' r ?Fr r:? i"4 ;..?• ;.•. f•;?• • }'4" :.'w7.s ??....,uua[?? "'? r,.f. ? ti: ' .y f •? :r; ' ? ';"Y y ' ?;{? ? ? r., -:2t: r:,?;%::;::`'> g?,.r}?:: rrY:?• '< }` ':{+. ,ti ? s°, :. • :f . ?;...f„ ,f . a; r ?i .4•i ;,• E•: .?,. t..:.? S ?r: t}.?N •:: } t 4• .%k? I : : r` ;,+Y}?f•S: '4i :fir}'r4''':. .;41 y.hrxF ? :•r•^.:.vd:?i:{•4 •:f4 ":••.n v f0.t' ? J?. ri??i:t: ;i •:;'X• •?r. ??? ?, ??,wf ,.,vi?• r. v. .:':r .f?f.. r,y,i Kf =. :.,... . ? ti • .{•:•r.; 1 r.?.:za?} '??{i?3. . ?(• . r :.;.. ,+}..,?;'f ,• : }'.:.::.; }•t "J{ ?,J.r.es f,,, :• fr•?r: • s . •{r{' rt .?•.r,4••:4i::: v,, .#.. r:4{r)f:Ai;:•S'•5.`.:;?;•r..:!'af?•f,.:.:?;fi's::r>'•:;:t'}ru;';?:r?•??r;r:•r::?.Fr,.•,',:?;•r'3•+.::}:••,••: :f?;sr,.;?.5:+:;• <,.:df?L;4?: y:; i6-<r. 4r,.. ,4?5 ,:?;Lt #C•r., •f.•* <.g• #. 2.}. r:S . ;.;:•ir..'k,: 3r`.%'f' : n :r:.:}•: r., r),. :r?;{,. r:.•? ..L,..?. .4 .•• F;,. [4 {ivZ,.•..:4 •?fi?.} . fr: ,:?v...'y.; 'tf?f . r''•t: •? :¢ `§}`ff:'d+'' '`f rr:.2:?,r?., . ?. :3... x: :: ». "<r i }.. •k x: 4::? •r+r?. "tr.};. •: n . '4. . r ,Y w;:•}•: xi }sZY:: }'. .y .}. ...{ • . }?, ' •: /'r, r..; : F .. i ..ts' ,5.1}. :'!•?. _7r.'i?r .? :,;:?. 11R, r ;?4''? v s,} rc .{.; Sw 3; :u??;• .r, t ,r,3::t} :S:.cC?,:• ? ;?` ' Y• .'i'' '?3' :e J•-;???r. s ... 3: :d,?• .'Y •? r ?; ••#?,ot3 ? :c Yr; ,,.?y•+}.v i 'rs /?,y/ /y,?? fr ?y,,?//Y?/?i ..?CiY.;•i/ i•;,i;.?yi.l ?,? S..Fj•r t?: d?.:.2• ?:'''•' ????•?:'f.,?.'?5?1':• H-y?•, `'???3iiM; ?a.?Y/l^?????.f •'?w?/i•.M?i?,M?:::,:.:.•.tin ? ...•:i]?'.:ia v. Y. Y•..t?.Y r?w?JJCtlrwtht? r?"i11:^Wli'?s?'arNai:iwxt+e? ..w': - . i?..w•1.:•a.:v:..? r... wrw v-.... N AM E:1 PF. :.. ?F1P'D1:ESTIX CAS GRILL Z6LNTIL C u +1.93 c9 P&z FEB. A B 9 , p5 PUBLIC' HEARINGDATES: cc AR ATLAS' PAGE ZZ I B SEC' 3o TWP•,28 S• RGr= AO E •rr.. •: ;. rr.•r.}!:{:r r4.:{:':?}?. ,..Ntn••• •r.y?}ir., r.•r4; r,•rry;r.};.,rrx.v.....4•r..?M1rti:fy{r,.^,.•:i•}ry *V^MM •::r.•. ..r., .: rrl4, •F"S.. '?:+•:• '•r.: ,d•r:?.r:. ,., :. ?) . :.{ •.2.. .?.. :•r •. 'irk:: .!7:i ? <?•: .`•:4> :•)',: !Gr. .w i.e , i•, i ' { R 11'111` , N J ~ IM ` ` C2 • ? "ice K ?n ? ? ? W -1?-{w?•1.+?F-?•i..t- , Pa X13 oop L'? 1 ? nlt?lt •JQ S ? 'I 0. 6 'S •n d ?1 1 N is _a ? ? Q frr on .• Pon .Pti s•ysl,a a~i a O 0 u +o • .::. Cc,• `.' ? f"_ •o?`? [aSnblo ?? •,.? rye pit. 0 uzox -;?, .. Q 4 r• a ., • o u AV PUCTtt3jjj O gel A*nt{blli titull 'PAY jAnOttlif _ 'DAY DT7a.tit • uo5Ts.rt:ii •,? 4 f .,.4 i i' ?ySEhlMti?? .x,06 Item # _ o Meeting Date: L3-18-93 9 p? Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum SUBJECT: Major amendments to the Commercial Planned Development (CPD) Certified Final Site Plan for Wal-Mart, Located on the northwest corner of Northeast Coachman Road and U.S. Hwy. 19 North; Principle Mutual Life Insurance (owner); King Engineering and Associates, Inc. (representative) (PSP 91-10). RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve the amended final site plan for certification on property identified as Loehmann`s Plaza Replat Lot 1. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The certified final-site plan for the proposed Wal-Mart Store has been amended to reflect four significant changes to the certified final site plan. On January 14, 1993, the DRC approved the amendments subject to the conditions listed on pages two and three. The following four changes "to the final site plan are listed below: 1) Retaining an existing 13,205 square foot building located in the northwestern part of the site. 2) The re-establishment of the easternmost entrance to Stag Run Boulevard due to retaining the, existing building. The driveway will be required in order to provide a truck loading dock area to the building. 3) Revision of the site data table to reflect the addition of the 13,205 square feet of additional retail area and additional impervious surface associated with the building. 4) The relocation of the handicap spaces along the front of the proposed building to one central aisleway with a five foot sidewalk in between. The proposed new location of the handicap parking spaces moves these spaces closer to the entrance. Reviewed by: Originating Dept: Costs: S NIA ___ Commission Action: Legal N/A Planning 8 Dove Total ? Approved ' Budget N/A ? Approved W/conditions h i P N/A S urc as ng p Denied Risk Mgmt. N/A User Dept: Current Fiscal Yr. cis N A Continued to: ACM Funding Source: Other N/A ? ital im ca p. p Advertised: ? Operating Attachments: Date: 3-8-93 ? Other Application Paper: Tampa Tribune Letter ? Not Required Map Pl Affected Parties an Submitted by: ® Appropriation Code: r Notified ? Not Required • City onager 13 None fad Printed on recycled paper C.C. 3-18-93 PSP. 91-10 Page 2 Prior to this public hearing, Planning Services Division staff met with John McBain, President of the Coachman Ridge Homeowners Association, and 'Mr. Robert,Losi, to discuss the modifications to the . final site plan. Neither Mr. McBain or Mr. Losi has expressed any problems or concerns with the modifications to the final site plan. Loehmann's clothing store will occupy the existing 13,205 square foot building. All prior City Commission and Planning and Zoning Board conditions of approval are proposed to remain valid. With regard to concurrency management, adding the 13,205 square foot building for retail use would still result in less floor area for the redeveloped site than exists in the current Loehmann's Plaza 'development. The property is therefore "grandfathered" with regard to concurrency management. DRC COMMENTS - January 14, 1993 Planning and Development 1. Signs and fencing/walls are subject to separate review and permitting processes. 2. The requisite building permits must be procured within one (1) year from the date of certification of the final site plan and all requisite certificates of occupancy must be obtained within three (3) years of the date of certification of the site plan. 3., A Unity of Title shall be recorded prior to certification of the site plan. 4. Prior to certification, the preferred site data table shall be shown on the site plan. 5. Prior to certification, all Planning and Zoning Board and City, Commission conditions of approval shall be shown on the site plan. 6. Prior to certification, the finial site plan shall return to City Commission for formal review with regard to the Stag Run Boulevard driveway entrance. 7.' Prior to certification, the most recent revision date shall be shown in the table on the site plan. Fire Department 1. Prior to certification, a fire hydrant shall be located not more than 300 ft, from the existing structure to be shown on the site plan and approved by the Fire Marshal. Public Works/Engineering 1. Prior to certification, an agreement shall be made by the developer with the City to construct two cul-de-sacs at Stag Run Boulevard and have completed within the first 30 days of issuance of a building permit. F, '1: .'f," '•:r•. ,. v',' :.3,' .•- J' a '! 1'ir i. f' >a •:+'?'.i,:a ;r? xx',. ?1,}1, .. > ' ,` I 'n,J ? ,'a'L' ,F ? ,`F, " - i • t r ! I , _ .. 1 s '_ , e', •I'? F:'rr. ?'?' J''t i' f'• '•ry" i.P, ,l .. ? :'.i. "lea , a '! , .> .. '? 'fir ' ji' t. ,' , !. } r ?:'1?'^. ' ? . ;.';r?'?i,'q • ';'` ' ^ r e ,1, . I , „ .' 11 U. C.C. 3-18-93 ' PSP 91-10 Page 3 2.: Prior to certification, drainage calculations shall be submitted subject to Engineering approval. ,,,,..Public: _Works/Tra f fic_Engineering 1. Prior. to, certification, 'the parking plan shall be reconfigured to relocate handicapped parking .'' spaces subject'Jto Traffic Engineering approval: .. Public Works/Environmental Management ; 1. Prior- to the issuance, of a building'permit, a revised landscape Plan in compliance With.the Land, 'Jbl Development Code. requirement shall be submitted for approval by the Environmental., Management Group. 2. Prior to the-issuance of a building permit, applicant shall acquire,a clearing and grubbing permit ?ahd a tree removal,permit (or a'no tree verification form) from Environmental. Management.`' ' I'r '. ', ,. I' Ufa f? S?rjfS. .' .•'{ft ?r 3r'l? ? ;5:1.3 '•"'it;,??A?,rf'?'ij??,??? i?;?y,'.l• : i.i,vo .•, 't iii ?, r ? ' _ r, ??' ".3tf. i} is , • r, • r { Deparlinciti of Planning and Develn?mettt r City Hall Anna:, 10 South Missouri Avenuc +ff P.O. Box 4748 4. r Clearwater, Florida 34616.4743 APPLICATIVIf EQB SEE& I IAI3.Iif:Y11:3Y 4 e, Applicant (owner of retard): WAL-HART STORES INC. Phone (Area Code):;_(- 50 1_]-273 --4001] Address; 701, SOUTH WALTON BOULEVARD City: _BENTOLIY11.1.C _-SUlc S Zip:_72714-0095 t Represealativc: KINC' ENCINEERINC ASSOCIATES. LNC. Phone (Area Cola): ( 8131_ 44172074 Address: 5440 t1EAUHONT CENTER BLVD.,_ _SUITE 460 City: ' TAMPA StatcFL-ORIDA Zip-.-33634 RICHARD D. HARRIS, P.E. ' ?,S$-)??J Preparer of plan: KING ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES, INC. Profcssional Title: 2ilQE (?. F.bCiN£ER ' Address-5440 EAU 0 City; TAMPA _ Slate: FLORIDA Zip: '1'1614 Phone (Area Code):-( 813 ). 441 •! -2074_ ;• !n n I __ _ - __- ? •. • • ? 111. •,t ' r PLAZA REPEAT) Tide of Site PlanfProject: WAL-HART CLEARWATER (LOEIINIINN' S t7encml location of property: NORTHWEST QUADRANT - U.S. 19 NORTH. NORTHEAST 'COACIUTAN'ROAD INTERSECTION Zoning: CC -COMMERCIAL CENTER '• Lind Ijto Plan Classification:' COMMERICAL A'd ' Existing use of property:_ RETAIL ' ".• :r: ' :fir... }3 .•; Proposed use of property: RETAIL + R' " 1 - If va[iance 11adlar conditional uses are involved, explain (if more spac4.ls required attach separate sheet): • ?. ?.?io•f-11. Ri? •i? •1 la . ?L'1 ' •?? ,f. ,tit ,?. City Ordinance No. 3128-83 and No. 3129.83'tequiro a parks ind secreitlon impact fee to be paid for all nonresi dential projects aster i 1 acre in sire and all residential developme W,To your knowledge, has this property complied with Ordinances No. 3128-83 and No. ; 3129.83? YES If yea, explain bow and.when: • WHEN ORIGINALLY DEVELOPED ' i js L. r. w ,t• 4 % ..» NOTE: For further details regarding this fee, plest4 contact Parks di Recrestion Department at 462.6531..;1 r?!w.? 1?. .r•1, ;y • .i't% lit ,'+. ' Assessed just value of property (attach veriCseatlan); , Moat recent asks price (stuch verific+llaa)i 41-t i• ._ Fee for Site Plan Review: , ? 14; :? wtt,'r s 'f 1. Duo charge for each On Alin ..................... 4.$750.00; plus 1• f. is (a) For each acre or frxcitaa tlecrcu.................. 50.00 2. Revalidation of a certlw site plan .............. .L50.00 ..50.00 3. Site plan anscndment................................... y. The applicant, by filing this application agcea: that 11:1511c Will comply Willi Section 137.010 Sple Plans of the City's Und Development Code. ' (Owner of Record) r?.i? r •.ra- 'If the application is signed by nn indivldua! blhe'r thin ilia property owner (e.g. Ilse representatlre), Mass e allach a sUatersient signed by ilia properly Owner nuthnrizlna lllis individual to sign 11u-application. e NOTES: i 1. THE SITE PLANS MUST I3h DRAWN WITH .THE "I OF TIDE PAGE. e? 2. THE PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER'S TA PARCEL, SHOULD BE GIVEN WITH THE LEAL DESCRI11910N OF THE PROPCItTY. 3. IT IS RECOMMENDED THE SITE PLAN SUBMITTAL BE LIMITED-TO ONE SHEET. t Revised 1013190 e r c ' > ' 1 ' ' • t 1. ' x' i , • . i. r '1 1 . •' , 1 + , s r-- P • r • r I , r. King Engineering Associates, Inc. 1440 Beaumont Center Uoulevard, Suite d6O • Tampa, Florida 33634 • (813).886•0111 • Fax; (813) 882.3539 Engineers Planners. Scientists Surveyors December 7, , 1992 , N1 r. Lou Hilton ! ' City of Clearwater Planning and Developrilcnt Department Post Office Box 474$ Clearwater, Florida '34618-4748 RE:,. Wal-Mart - Clearwater (Lochniann's Plaza) Dear Lou: We are enclosing for your further handling, fifteen (15) copies of the revised final site plan for the above referenced project. Also, enclosed . is a $150.00 check payable to the City of Clearwater for the review fee. The revisions made to this Finial site plan are as follows: 1. The relocation of the handicap spaces along the front of the building to one central aisleway with a five (5) foot sidewalk in between them. 2. The retainage of an on-site building in the amount of 13,205 square feet for the relocation of an existing on-site tenant. `.' 3. The reestablishment of the eastern most entrance 'to Stag Run Boulevard' due to, the retainage of the on-site building. This roadway will be required in'-order to provide a truck loading dock area to this building. Tlie'existing truck loading for this building,ts., . ' on the north side in the area;Ahere this.roadway was previously scheduled for removal., > • 4. Revision of the site data table to reflect' the addition'of•13,205'square feet of additional retail area and additional roadway surface. Citrus Hillsborouah Pasca Melia• "r. ,err" ,, Y}?-y.. e;S?i`''-r.r.tl,?',f?'jf".,i?fftts: 11,',-a r1u7!'f'-i'x >?, 'P" 1.`, r.' 3 , a ..r. .[, .3. ?•rf. .f rtt? f?,.>Tr. r,. .. ?,. •yw:s,?a' ?:ji,e •th r• d '•?••.?• .r'. x.^4? ?•?i:• ':l, -t' .? ,'!,?' .•''s• .I:... ?..1 :a ft:,'.F.!eF.r?,,•..1s,.,?D '%;.;?•?s?i ?'? .t,rP ? i'i??r%' 4'. !?: .. 'r ? ? '7, y..d r'?:.°ts'•. is ??? i?il.r i' •!. -l•Td lt? ,.,lr ,. r? ,`r'' - r•.14.. ': r'. Ci. ?1: J,'1•- .lY t Pif??f ? ,. .?t •1',t i• a? .' ?/` - a 'f + ? r r• :a, !fs Y?., •?tyYi..'i ??• .'i d e ,h,e.` F: 'I •• •,.}`,{. 's` r r ? i' 1. ?` e1??y??F [ 1 ?. ? •S aivP . -. .. ' i4.1r- ? t • `. _ .. .. .. r ? .?l '1 ' , I . , .,r ? .d F •l , ?, J^= t'S' yf^t ,• ,.• ? "01 ,j. ?i S,?,•I?1 ?t; r ? '? r ?rt f ?p`l M.t?„'?? Ey ,, i.. df•-t 'if. 'f'•' i'e: Y{r •r 'i ?+'. ., .r• 1.. }.' y rf. EAR r .1 ?:7 !i. ? •" r,x;? 'i' ,l:.i ?,, :i.• : r ? .'r .f?" `5 '• ,t: !f o: t. r ? t `s !r''•r?`. ZdF? •Y` f 3 '{'.'.r - '1' •i.J.i' :}.r _ r 'S .;' h•1 tj'?. rir t '1ra. ?. i; i ?'b' r it+' ? 'J •`. `b.iG' ` •'a'' • ' 1. ??" °f L ;.(1/ ..j? ..j; :.3 'fr :z„F. ,1.`?'F, ,7 ?1i'e ') ?( r?' ? '?' .. ? •%J?I :<.? :.i s ':1, .t'' „-'Fr r`,` ,ir' ?- '!' .r.•r'. yea<.,.,,,L: .41 `d a. r . ?'P ?: r' %'tt? •'4. ?t :S.'?? ''.% ? f ' f:l' ? ? °r'. ?r l' "f ?i: ? ? ' 1.? ?iq? nF c/? t L,rv1,s :?: i'i.'•?;,,',r ,`;?„ '7 ':t ai 't } 'i r?' • } ? J' .spa':. >fr '?{{?l; 1 r ',?• "fir 3. .'S S- -, r(e Y,• 1. is .'f• , 4?. ! % .ri • ,l.: .,?? ? ?` , RI>#AA!•:fr •<.-1 •rr+, .^r :, d. f; ?,. il?.,•?s.? f;rr,;rL ?. W4•i.2 L: r.'?'r ..,. .? 'i`' ,. p .?° ?? ??d' . ? r ? -.... .. ..r, .t;.,. .s •:t - ni•.... ,'i'...:. ... .,- •r•ia:b?i -Mr. Lou Hilton December ;7, 11992 ° Page 2 j ?;.. I le.ase'do not hesitate to contact 111C it you 'linve,a .n y questions or steed addi tional information. Thank you for your assistance. Very' truly yours, Richard D. Harris, P.E.r.;. Proj ect Manager .?i ? •' I ' ? ° - ? , e - ? .. , ? ? - ' • ? ?' i L'ea'f ` RH:vg l=nciosures ; . f cc: Ti r; m Johnson, .Johnson, Blakely, et.ai: (w/cncl• f ' Ed Mazur )' T r ;. , KLA w/encl f Bvb KUrlander Landmark, J . Commercial Rcaity Inc. (w/encl:).. rt Margaret Bowles, Smitlt, Williams'arid Bowles 'lwlencl File i 13-OQ2.R.355a'rtl[,TVN3.RUitt • 111 3 t,:?'f•?•? ? .. 1' "ie u` ' r?a?, :r. ?'?,'1 ,F ?.f .. .1, ? ?. °.1?' '.?1.' [>.,e:' '.•(,.'f?L ??i f' Y i L• * . • L J 2 0 'L 3 7 F w ,ICE 'Oor foot SS SrS ? 54 Not S4 #80 73 10 lom n 52 FI • lose 51 7 lorr h 50 49 lo+r 4e 47 :r 6 42 : 4] 1 ^I D 12 ' II PROPOSED AMENDMENT OF SITE PLAN OWNER: Principle Mutual Life Insurance PSPIf 91.10 APPLICANT: King Engineering & Associates,. Inc. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION LAND USE PLAN: Commorcialffourist Facilities Let 1, Loohmann's Plaza Replat ZONING: CPO CITY COMMISSION: March 18, 1993 SECTIONS 08 & 07 TOWNSHIP S 29 RANGE E 10 ATLAS PACE 283 B & 273 9 1 , C 3 33/04 rrrr { a 399 rise nn Mr 232 j 331C. 33/00 C H 33;L rn, lops a a a 'nn 33/07 foil Jill 23x77 ' 1VRi• ? or" 33/07 33. _ i ? .y„naaea A fd47- A'?? fort-ru ,!?- "l.. ?r"{i.. f •s .. r i. { - r. .. r ii: "e ::°= .'r"?.?w.'r .i"!,! N ' ..F., .. . .. r .r .I"cif: ' , ?.' 'F:1 , .F e#n .'; . • 'fl 1. .d. • .•W ..i'. Jr • 5 ?'ti?.. °.i ,? S '' , d 1 , . 7:', .?•- r, .i Ir I i• ?t .'Jt r 1 ' /- .r; ' • ?? '. . • ? , ? , .. ? ?. r4:. '' J _ : 1 4.' a •'r f. u0: (. '1' '_ f: , Y , r ' ., r.. . 1 r . . [ f , .'! Y.., i?.'k! C, I T Y O F C .'L E A R W A T E R Iaterdepartmeat Correspondence' TO: Mayor and'City Commission -? FROM: James M. Polatty, Jr., Director of Planning 'and 3?p Development SUBJECT: Wal-Mart - Continuance COPIES: Michael Wright, City Manager' Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager Cyndie Gaudeau,, City Clerk DATE: March 15, 1993 " .k The-Commission had several questions concerning the development of the .'Wal-Mart site. Immediately after the' work session,. .staff , 'learned that the applicant was requesting a continuance of the; item ' ° - to the April 1, 1993• City Commission meeting to allow more time, for negotiations between Wal-Mart and Loehman's. Staff would recommend ., that` the Commission ;continue the request. Because we are anticipating: same additional site plan changes, , Y . will not address the questions concerning, signage, ,the lease' term's . and. the site 'design at this 'time. Should you have questions or comments, pleasercontact me'. plnImbnart.cc 1 A A, t o Ma , f t a ' / P 14, RECEIVED MAR 17 1993 R?ng r??gIROUT/ng HSSUGIMOS, 1176. E 5440 Beaumont Center BoulewtO, Suite 460 • Tampa, ' Florida 33634, • (813) 886.0111 • Fax: (813) 882-3539 Engineers Planners, Sclentists Surveyors March 15, 1993 Mr. Lou R. Hilton, Planner II . City of Clearwater' Planning Services Division Post Office Box 4748 'Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748 RE: Wal-Mart - Clearwater Dear Lou: As representative for Wal-Mart Stores and Principal Mutual Life Insurance Company at the above referenced project, we hereby request that the modification to the Final 'Site Plan for this project be continued -for two (2) additional' weeks before it is heard before the City, Commission of Clearwater, Florida, The new hearing date would-be on April 1, 1993, Please do not hesitate to contact, me if you have. any questions or need 'additional '. information. :Very truly yours, Richard D. Harris, P.E. Project Manager , RDH:db cc: Jim Webster, Wal-Mart Stores, inc. Tim Johnson, Johnson Blakley, et.al File #1113-002.8355 (#1111iiton2.R11) , citrus Hillshorvugh Pasco Pinellas F• (t?P ',N' i [ .a4, iii ° r gEl?1"? lot: Meet _03/18193 Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum PUBLIC PLb- SUBJECT': Final Site Plan and Amendment to Zoning Atlas; 2201 Sunset Point Rd.; Owner: Sun Bank of Tampa Bay; Representative: Theodore C. Taub; Approx 1.24 acre. (292-08 & PSP 92-12) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve Final Site Plan and Amendment of Zoning Atlas from OL to CPD for a portion of Sec. 6-29- 16, M&B 32.01 and adjacent portion of vacated Pinellas Groves basement in Sec. 1-29-15, and adopt Ordinance No. 5287-92 on second reading, ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: This item is continued from the January 21, 1993, City Commission meeting. At that meeting, the City Commission approved on second reading the ordinance amending the Future Land Use Plan from Limited Office to Commercial/Tourist Facilities, but continued the rezoning ordinance (5287-92) to enable the applicant to modify the site plan. On January 14, 1993, the Development Code Adjustment Board denied the applicant's request for a parking variance: The applicant chose to reduce the size of his retail sales building, and has revised the site plan accordingly. The final site plan provides the parking required by the Land Development Code. ,On October 8, 1992, the DRC approved the site plan with conditions. The conditions listed in the attached minutes, required to be met prior to certification,. have been met by the applicant. Reviewed by: Driainating Dept: '?- Coet:: NIA Commission Action: Legal N/A PLANNING 8 DEL J Total ? Approved Budget --N/A Purchasing N/A ? Approved w/conditions _ _ Risk Mgmt. N/A Cis N/A User Dept: Current Fiscal yr. 13 Denied C ti d t ACM #Z ft Funding Source: on nue o. Other NI ? Capital Imp . Advertised: ? operating Attachments; Date: 3/05/93 ? other ORDINANCE NO. 5287.92 Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE ? DRC MINUTE rq - ip V Not Required 5ubm Affected Parties I ' ? None V ? Notified Appropriation Code: City ar ® Not Required V Printed on recycled,poper r. ORDINANCE NO. 5287-92 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE ZONING 'ATLAS OF THE CITY BY REZONING CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF SUNSET- POINT AND BELCHER ROADS, WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 2201 SUNSET POINT ROAD; AS DESCRIBED MORE PARTICULARLY HEREIN, FROM LIMITED OFFICE (OL) TO COMMERCIAL PLANNED DEVELOPMENT (CPD) DISTRICT; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the amendment to the zoning atlas of the.City as set forth in this ordinance is found to be reasonable, proper and appropriate, and in'dompliance with Florida law; now, therefore, f BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF. CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section I.` The.fo11owing•described property in Clearwater, Florida, is hereby rezoned, and the zoning atlas of the City is amended as follows: Property Zoning District See Exhibit A attached hereto: From:, Limited Office (OL) m (Z92-08) To: Commercial Planned Development (CPD) Section 2. The City Commission does hereby certify that this ordinance is consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan.' Section 3. The Planning and Development Director is directed to revise the zoning atlas of the City 'in accordance with the foregoing amendment. Section 4. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption, subject to the approval of the, land use category set forth in Ordinance No. 5285- 92 by the Pinellas County Board of County Commissioners., PASSED ON FIRST READING 'November 5, 1992 p;.. PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL I READING'AND ADOPTED Rita Garvey Mayor-Commissioner Approved as to form and correctness: Attest: M. A. Ga rait , Jr. Cynt la E. Gou eau City,Attorney City Clerk p-1 f i ..L.F r .' " f .xr, -. t . /„ ,• .. ?. ., -. ..rlt.' F .,?''' rr)j?PJ',??"?'ra?? • ,e, .{: .. Yt . s _• • , 7 r 7. .. {x';,4.1 ?,y,. r q. ,, ? ..1 ..a Y'>, 'F.,. . ..d, 1r''= Fw •, - , • .. .7 .. ::'e : tt , F A 'portion of ,the Northwest 1/4. of the Southwest 1/4 of Section 6, ' '16 East, and that portion of vacated. .Township 29 South,, Range ' , Pinellas Groves easement (night-of-.way)' in the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 1, Township 29 South, Range.15 East,'lying adjacent thereto, described as,follows: ' From the East 1/4 corner of Section 1,'Township 29 South,'Range 15' East, ' also being• the r Kest 1/4 corner of Section 6, Township '29 ' South,' Range 16 East,' run thence S 00°05'04" W, along the section line,:50.00 feet'for.the POINT OF BEGINNING; thence N 89°51'.29" E,' along the Southerly right-of-way of Sunset Point Road, '174.66 feet; ' thence S 45°08'31"-E, 28.28 feet;,thence S 00°08'31" E, along, the ' :>.-..., Westerly right-of-way of Belcher Road, 106.24 'feet; 'thence S.' 34 °49' 32"' W, a 1 ong said right-of-way, 89.58 • feet; thence conii nue ' ' along said Westerly right-of-way S 32°54•'45" 'W, 121.91. feet to a 4 . poir't.of curve; thence along a curve to-the left, whose chord bears,. S 32°04`42' 'W, 18:64 feet, arc of 18.64 feet and a,radius of 635.50 ' . feet; thence leaving said Westerly right-of-way N 89°54'56" W, 83.14. feet;`thence N 0000510411-E, parallel to and 15;00 feet West of the ` section line, 317.53 feet to 'the Southerly right-of-way line' of. ° ' Sunset Point Road; thence S-89'07'16" E, along said Southerly right-; ' f• of-way 1 ine, 15.'00 feet to-the POINT 'OF BEGINNING. i r • , 11 .; EXHIBIT A w =f ,7 - 3i ' €.. ,. 1 ' .• ! 1 ' ' l.sl a !1; `,5 ti. '?3:?N ,^t,t i'}'t{(" a,4! ••?{?'?ii 1. ?; f'?. -.•j'. ?4 ?F?-c''7't ,?.'f.i??i.? it m : -27. - 7?. j ?fAr _ CnuNTV Zo G FZPt? 7, i5 P19s A L/ lot, ;t 26 26 5 A 24 P 1 7. RS 8 U ROAD SUNSET Rona -- _ _.. w sUtisa T PT R D 1.9 .9 -701 - 700 + J?' '( 1 Y j;r. ' MOO AGE ?.? =!I " ??[ )X' 3 ' I I , , ,?} 37.?Of 3 N N rY AUBMGHT 1Sol - Ova o RS ' o n ... T_ }FF ??,J1 v ' i 60 a0 ? •il VI k ?1+71Y ? t t;?•••1 1 .F??I ? j? y 1876 1876 b',;, I V 1, ; ;? °? 7 30 31 54 Ia76 ,?¢ .,..1 r k k i / ti t876 ?f Z O 0 -ran a v 29 r9a 32 53 1AF1 f870 1863 r863 f 32/011 273 >??r ' Z 1k I a ?I '• q ,, ' 9 1Aa4 33 52 led P rp; B O rAa7,4 27 1067 51 57 '/a 1069 E 34 1868 cm - 1_. 1861 26 1961 co 11, us35 cp 50 E401 1,196z ot, l1:=?A. 4?kF!a15E:Cl E ie 'f?j.: #'. ?Lc i ? ^- [? ?1 r9?6 25 r9t6 ?J ; O P D Z 2 B.e 36 49 ray ?' ' l93a tdJfl :.:.13 24 37 48 ??•?, ? I p '• ? r9.sa ?? 23 ? ra33 1iL? ro - 14 47 S U P-1 d' D F 183 = 38 1831 • ( ?,? ? ; ? ; 'r rear © cD c 1 G ?+ rear 15 22 39 46 tQ t i ' r9re a c! CD Ism e o d Pi !az! U fax! 1, .. .., I ° 16 21 lAtS 4a 45 nr.5nlu 11011 ? o -"? =r i n,w. U.n. sn59--1727 0. FT, 5.310-435 " 1916. lots 1 I W _ 17 20 lsi6 '11 44 tare a.c.1%i1.oA p rv a a OA 5790--21)46 I ?} i t>i w j l 18 19 47 . 3 .. fAlo 50 rnnn r9rn c?U' rar. ` as teao PROPOSED LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and.REZONING OWNER SUN BANtC aF `t",q Pt, -0 A`f ?iQ2 --68 - Lute (?Z- ILI APPLICANT P1IOPERTY DESCRIPTION 'LAND USE PLAN ZONING M B 3 2 i 01 I"ROM R E S I D E_QTI A L f L. TO Cpm MF-9,0- f d l,?y iiCnF_8 PLAH14111d nnd'ZONING GOAnt) CITY COMMISSION SECTIONS. 0 TowNSIIIP RENO t ATLAG PAGE -.Z 63 A 0 Single Family 43 ; QrJS1 NESS \l= VA CAN 1' ? IE •'r ? i t , ? , r ? ? ' r TO: Mayor and City I FROM: James M. Polatt r , 3! I'T Y' O F C L E A R W A'T E'R Interdepartment Correspondence fission ! • ? inn Jr.. Director of Planning and a?E' SUBJECT: Sun Bank Commercial Planned Development - Work Session Questions COPIES: Michael Wright, City Manager, .3ZQ y Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager, f Cyndie Goudeau, City Clerk's 1 DATE: March 15; 1993 Concerning variances requested by the applicant, the only variance =t processed-for this site was for' five parking spaces. This parking- variance was denied' by the Development Code Adjustment tBoard, in December of 1992. r Concerning' landscaping, the applicant's site plan meets all on-site. ` landscaping requirements.. In addition, the applicant proposes'off - site landscaping for the right-of -way,. This. landscaping- will. be ' installed and maintained, by the applicants pursuant to an installation and maintenance 'agreement with Pinellas "'County. Should'the right'-of-way ever be needed for roadway improvements',' the landscaping would,'of course, be removed. The.road.right-of-way shown on the site plan reflects the'revised' right-of=way to accommodate the road improvement project for Sunset' - Point Road. Should you have'questions or comments, please contact me. ` v plnl?unbaok.cc • r . tit •,, .t,, i 1,,.. r:. 1` a ' t. .', ,11?•? 77 'jj 11 r 1 ' l ,A I• 1 ' I C I T Y OF C L E A R W A T E R Interdepartment Correspondence TO: Mayor and City Commission FROM: James M. Polatty, Jam, Director of Planning and Development SUBJECT: Sun Bank Commercial Planned,Development - Signage COPIES: Michael Wright, City Manager Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager M.A. Galbraith, City'Attorney Cyndie Goudeau, City Clerk DATE: March 15, 1993 Section 44.51(4)(i) of the sign regulations empowers the City Commission to determine the signage allowed for Commercial and Industrial Planned Developments consistent with surrounding zoning and land uses. Since we are at second reading of.the ordinance establishing 'Commercial Planned Development (CPD) zoning for the subject property, it is appropriate that the signage issue be addressed at this time. Our review of surrounding zoning indicates that the property has (County) RPD - Residential Planned Development zoning to the north, (City) CPD zoning to the northeast, (City) OPD - Office Planned Development zoning to the east, (City) Limited Industrial zoning to the south, and (County) C-2/General Commercial zoning to the west. Allowable sign sizes are indicated in the following table for each zone/direction. DIRECTION 'ZONING SIGN SIZE ATTACHED SIGN SIZE FREESTANDING NORTH RPD N/A 24 SO. FT. NORTHEAST CPD 128 SQ. FT.* 64 SQ. FT.* EAST OPD 56 S Q. FT, 50 S Q. FT. SOUTH IL 64 SQ. FT. 64 SQ. FT. WEST C-2 150 SQ. FT. 100 SQ.'FT.' EiXISTINC. CURRENT CODE ALLOWS COMMISSION TO DETERMINE SIGN SIZE .Given these surrounding zoning classifications and allowable sign, sizes, staff would recommend applying the Office Planned Development district' signage requirements to the subject property. This would allow the property the same signage as the OPD development across Belcher Avenue - a 50 sq. ft, freestanding sign for each frontage and up to 56 sq. ft, of attached signs for each frontage. A. motion to amend reflecting this recommendation will be presented by the City Attorney. Should you have questions or comments, please contact me. • 1. ?'l I ? f i 7 i:x-;'r ':j'.,' ???:??I'3" °d.:'?;?`j .'r- ®? 'r .: e. .:1 ..rr -r..,?l ? r `zc)?Fi.,r?•' t 77j?r r?+ ..?j S,x I:E -.a ;{.r..:A. ., r' i? r ••+?' ? 7. 'r'.. S .. i' ei?' ,S; J?? ?., _y1 ,s ?1,? `.rlr; ,'eyi,` 9 1s}': t'. r ?` ,. 3.. .1' •l r,.--•.' ..?.'? r?E'?.I`'f {r.?1 i, r t J ,S:?rS?l: .' •F? .'?r. ...rr ??`. -' °iFe, ?, Y? - - ir+ ''•riA`i` iif ., , ., f:..°' :s},.A '; i .t ? ? ? i ,', ? ? .. r •1?•'kaa ?=tie {f / r -,r •r E F'i I-'-!; ,,?! 1 .T,.rI?' , e ' -•'7-"i ; +F6°r ?-?:'` ?. t'j. ^ i'`. r rr 7?Pr r? ? ° • . r' :'?1`.. .'•f. i.? ??;t ^r?',? ,.?r1-Y,: -r' '1,' •? `?1„ 1;i ? :1`• : ? ?r: r ! y: t r' ? ... ,. .. 1 - ? ? .6? ? .. ?f ..EC, p? ir':', 'i• •i; 'rr, '? 9` '?i' r?''?M1., .,r, .?- r r a': =,tet`u ?'; ?tt ,t.l'I, 'r. ','gip-. .t: tl ,'Le r•?, r.-? i• 'I'e ., 't •yi '?_. .??"?1 i?" - ,? ?y ?' .:r'..+ "g?^?;;..i. ;:ir, ..;.. - :# :i?:1 ++,,'y;f`".' iii, r'1' ,Y . . ,.. .; ?y,+• ;+ •? ?`aj' cP1?,y''f' ?:'J ?.. Ji" ? rv'arrll? ",?i. t ?•?. 1. ..tr', t• r t.• .+;t ??`-*?'.'rT, a.,?(•.,Ey'ef!•r. .ae: 'r•: ;r7?,a.' •f. 'rf itl"rru } ?d..' ,. .,.. ,Ji?;;? AdG?lrlyi?.`?r,r; ?r.'.? t,. !,J's..=, v ....?+f f,.r?i?..r ., ..,r'?.?. ?. t`°" "f'. .Jr'?r :.+,s„ ?: r .. ,. r-?•.^. r ... '?- .. ? .: ?r.i'-? ... trlt?i r7e .. I MOTION TO.AMGND ORDINANCE 5287-92 On -pag'e'j1, insert a new Section 2 to read as follows, and renumber existing sections:, ., rR< ~Section 2.' raking into consideration the existing land uses 4 " tsurrounding the 'property. described herein, -the -City' Commission hereby determines thai the sign regulations for the' Off i ce 'P 1 anned ' 'Development District are the most appropriate' a'nd- shall apply to':the development of the property. s'i I , ? r r + , r r ?!: '. Al ? ?`•";.}!s ,? ti cS NOTE'': This amendment is ,'a' tho'rized 'by. Section '44.51.(4),(1) of` the 'Code of Ordinances'. ' ?+ r ? ? r ? ! , ? ? .Z• :f Jas: ??, a?:°I",? ?: i.r 3 .1 r 1I.r.. •,3 r 1 ?. i .9 1 '+, .ISS, I ti'' ?'E', ?S'A} '?+.??;E. ?-•'{R€?.tit•?. .r'?r?----.-??--_. ?--- .. r"- 'r. , r '1 -- ---- -- - -- ? ? ., f e.?E`ae .3•l':ai'` M•w'i•',.irli.{•,;tri6'+t'?•?;?i'? ?g ALMa r +.1 Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum PUBLIC 1 m Meetin D le: 03/18/93 SUBJECT: Amendment to Future Land Use Plan and Zoning Atlas; 2965 C.R. 193; Owner: Oak Leaf Ltd.; Representative: Timothy A. Johnson, Jr. (7.47 acres m.o.l.) (Z 93-01 & LUP 93-01) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve Future Land Use Plan Amendment from Low Density Residential to Public/Semi-Public and Zoning Atlas Amendment from RS-6 to PISP for part of the SE 114 of Sec. 5-29-16 (M&B 41106 & 41108), and pass Ordinances No. 5349-93 and 5350-93 on first reading. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The School Board of Pinellas County has a contract to purchase this property. The property is on the south side of C.R. 193, south of Sunset Point Rd. just west of Landmark Dr., on the east side of the Paul B. Stephens Exceptional Student Center. The School Board would like to use the property to expand the Center. The property is contiguous to the City on.its west and south sides, and along part of the north, and east sides. Adjacent County property has a Countywide Future Land Use Plan Category of Residential, Low. The remaining land to the north (Castle Woods) and east (Forest Wood . Estates) is in the City and has a Future Land Use Plan Classification of Low Density Residential and zoning of RS-6. The property to the south (Sails' Lake Park Subdivision) is in the City and has a Future Land Use Classification of Low Density Residential and zoning of RS-8. The property to the west is owned by the School Board, and has a Future Land Use Classification and zoning of Public/Semi-Public. The City's Comprehensive Plan shows Landmark Drive extending south through the east side of the applicant's property. However, according to the Public Works Director, this segment of Landmark . Drive extension is no longer considered necessary, desirable or feasible due to traffic engineering considerations and environmental constraints. The improvements to McMullen-Booth Road have eliminated the need for this road, so right-of-way dedication is not an issue. Reviewed by: Originating Dept: (r? Legal NIA_ 'PLANNING & DC 01 I?JTT 1 Budget N/A Purchasin N/A g Risk Mgmt, N/A User Dept: CIS N?-- ACM 1V0 K Other N/A Advertised: Date: 2/16/93 & 2/25/93 q? Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE 13 Not Required Submitted by: Aifeoted Parties 'j 19 Notified ?T ?' Not Required CI Nan or 40 Printed on recycled paper t Colts: ii NIA Commission Action: Total Approved ? Approved w/conditions S Currant Fiscal Yr. U Denied 0 Continued to: Funding Source: n Capital imp. ? Operating Attachments: ? Other ORDINANCES NO. 5349-93 & 5350-93 LOCATION MAP Appropriation Code: 1 •? None •y'l?FC ? ?. 1. ?? t ?, .'t ,?' .3: .. J '7 t. ,. .4.?.?. .iP it '?.*. .?,x rj7 "1f 'tj: 5„! 'l ..- I y°? k?:... .-?f. ''r. ' .!, .. (.? a d1'i;r• 't 'i 1? ?r?.. r??^'^ '.%:. 'p`fi l?7 -^}.4` f. ( !" w . , • . .. J 'iY , 1 qtr , ,? S , r ' H .. ! ' .11 • I 'i r ' i r ?. `?' ? ? 1?F1??? ' ? ' rr" ? - ? I i'? r "a ? 1 f . ' t " 'gtj ,°? i -l. ° !f ' S . ' J ;1'f ?rY "?.` ' Z' - ? ,.d ,,, ? ., d ?? . .. ii •1 1 ., r i}r• ?' + ?' .?V: ' ? r J ? Vi • J #Y.: .. , ? +: ii ' , ., .r ?g ' ' ' ? ? _ f _ • i. .. ??.; ;l,' y ..[ ?jt'l;?.l r ' i j s r7 l.k, ? ' r yrx ?;F:Jr .l ?. _ r ..}• .1', :i ? ? .. - J ` , ? ' ,• ? „ a. ,r-" :i"?'k}''1: ?r , i k` a ?S S . rr r ^ 7 . .r .` 'S f•j4'. ! ,. .. p I L e ? ? ' ? i'f. ?L t•I.?,e ,! '' 1 x ?t'j: y;r -d tr ''` ?e ?;' «?d.. ?? ?i ? '. ? - '? ' • : 4 - • ? ? ? l a " , I r ? : 4 ." ' ?- rr . ? ' °i k v " ? `.. : ' .t ? ? ' .A i '-Y ,.iP ' • ',t ..F3. ?'.L-. r. `} ".r. . , . ,•r ? ,'1? ? r, ?t . e'r r?.• r. ?. ' ..1.?,:i , lD.,l:kfde' i ' "s . . .. , . f.. ; A+?, s.•'?° o ' .... r ... , _ ... , ? , t t •. . a_ ,. ,? .. . ; ., . , .. ?.b•rlK 1 r ' - 2 • r 1 s • t ? ? t r A . .. e r • x r r 1 '.. .. ` r C.C. 3118193 r Z, 93-01 '& 'LUP 93-01 '. ' 2 Page ,.,.The. Planning & Zoning Board held a public hearing on this matter on March- 2; 1993; and unanimously. endorsed the request. ,a -'The applicant's property has a City Future Land Use Classification of Low Derisity and zonin ''of RS- , 6. Its Future Land Use Classification will be going from a Countywide Plan Cl . assification of Residential to Institutional, and PPC review of the'proposed Land Use Amendment will'be'required. + t •,A, .r . , . . ' ; .. r s ", a ,?FY, - t . ' I 1 I . ' - r ^ ? • • 1 e y [ ' ` _ ? . 1 • d , t . ' .?, j "(? t J `' s ' i . .' , e r ? ' , .. 1, .. ,. r • ? e i ? ,1 ' . rM1 :e •. fSQQq'}1'r.4 , ORDINANCE NO.'5349-93 ' AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PLAN ELEMENT OF THE , COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF THE CITY" TO CHANGEJHE LAND USE, DESIGNATION FOR CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE .;. SOUTH SIDE OF COUNTY ROAD. 193, SOUTfi OF 'SUNSET POINT ROAD AND WEST OF LANDMARK DRIVE, WHOSE 'POST. OFFICE ADDRESS IS 2965 COUNTY ROAD 193, FROM. LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL TO PUBLIC,'SEMI-PUBLIC; PROVIDING AN ; EFFECTIVE DATE. .WHEREASthe amendment to the future land use plan elemeni of the. .,: comprehensive plah of the City as set forth in this ordinance is 'found to be :.: . reasonable, proper and appropriate, and in compliance with Florida law; now, 'r theref=ore, ;. BE IT ORDAINED BY' THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY, OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section 1. The future land use plan element of the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Clearwater is amended by changing the land use category far the hereinafter described property.'as follows: Property_ Land Use Category. See Exhibit A attached hereto, From: Low Density Residential (LUP 93-'01) r; Tb: Public/Semi-Public Section 2. The City Commission does hereby certify that this ordinance is consistent with the City's Comprehensive Alan. s Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption,,. subject to the approval of,the land use designation by the Pinellas County Board of County Commissioners.- ; PASSED ON FIRST READING I PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL i READING AND ADOPTED f Rita Garvey Mayor-Commissioner ' Approved as to form and correctness: Attest: M. A. Ga raft J Cynthia E. Gou eau i City Attorney City Cleric r { r' The West 1/2 of`the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section. 5' Township 29 South, Range 16 East, Pinellas County, Florida, less,and except the North 30.00 feet thereof and being more particularly described as follows: Commence at the Northwest corner of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 5, Township 29 South, Range 16 East, Pinellas County, Florida; thence S 00°19'10" W, along the I•lest line of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5 (being the basis of bearings s. for this description), for 30.00 'feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING; thence S 89°40'32" E, along a line being 30.00 feet South of and parallel to the'North line of the Southeast 1/4-of the Northeast 1/4 of. the Southeast 1/4 of said, Section 5, same also being the South line of, that certain properly deeded as, right-of-way and recorded in Official Records Book 3640, Page 871, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 335.10 feet; thence S 00°19`04" W, along the East line of the West 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, for 637.54 feet; thence N 89°39'.30" W, along the. South line ,of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, same also being the North line of that property shown on the plat of Sall's Lake Park Third Addition, as recorded in Plat Book 71, . Page 21, of the public records of. Pinellas County, Florida, for 335.12 feet;, thence N 00°19'10"'E, along the West line of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, for 637.44 feet to the POINT-OF BEGINNING. AND The Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast'1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4• of Section 5, Township 29 South,, Range 16 East, Pinellas County, Florida,'' as described, in Official Records Book 5757, Page 851, of the public records of Pinellas County,-Florida, and being more particularly described as follows: Begin at the Southeast corner of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 5, Township 29,'South, Range 16 East, Pinellas County, Florida; thence N 89°39'3O" W, along the South line of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5 (being the, basis, of bearings for this description), same also being the North line of the plat of Sall's Lake Park Third Addition, as recorded in Plat Book 71, Page 21, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 335.12 feet; thence N 00°19'04" E, along the West line of the Southeast 1/4 of the'Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, same also being the East line of that certain property described in Official Records Book 3352, Page 579, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 333.77 feet; thence S',89040'01" E, along the North line of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4•of.the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, same also being the South line of that certain property described in Official Records Book 5757, Page 846, 'of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 335.11 feet; thence S 00°18'58" W, along the East line of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, same also being the Wes' line of the plat of Forest Wood Estates, as recorded in Plat Book 69,-Page 17, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida,. for 333.82 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. EXHIBIT A 53gjA3 i CS' p' sus •, / l - ORDINANCE NO. 5350-93 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY, BY, REZONING' CERTAIN' PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF COUNTY ROAD 193, SOUTH OF SUNSET POINT 'ROAD AND WEST OF LANDMARK DRIVE, WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 2965 COUNTY ROAD 193, AS DESCRIBED MORE PARTICULARLY HEREIN, FROM SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL "SIX" DISTRICT "(RS-6) TO ;I PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the amendment to the zoning atlas of the City as set forth in this, " ordinance is found to be reasonable, proper and appropriate,,and in compliance : with,Florida law; now, therefore, 1. BE- IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section 1. The following described property in Clearwater, Florida, 'is hereby rezoned,.and the zoning atlas of the City is amended as-follows: , Pro0erty Zonin District See Exhibit A attached hereto. From: Single Family Residential RS-6 (Z93-01) To: Public/Semi-Public (P/SP) Section 2. The City Commission does hereby certify that this ordinance is . consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan. Section 3. The Planning and Development Director is directed to revise the .' zoning atlas of the City in'accordance with'the foregoing amendment. Section 4'. This ordinance shall take effect immedia•tely'upon adoption, subject to the approval of' the land use category set forth in Ordinance No. 5349- 93 by the Pinellas County Board of"County Commissioner. PASSED ON FIRST.READING PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL READING AND ADOPTED Rita Garvey Mayor-Commissioner Approved as to form and correctness: Attest: M. A: Ga' rait , J Cynthia E. Gou eau ' City Attorney City Clerk f j • ;rf'' - '?5'4t l The West 1/2 of.the Southeast '1/4 of the Northeast-1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 5, Township 29 South, Range 16 East, Pinellas County, Florida, less and except the North 30.00 feet thereof and being more particularly, described as follows: Commence at the Northwest corner of the Southeast'1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 8, Township 29 South, Range 16 East, Pinellas County, Florida; thence S 00°19'10" W, along the Hest line of the Southeast 1/4 of-the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5 (being the basis of bearings for this description), for 30.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING; thence S r 89°40'32" E, along a line being'30.00 feet South of and parallel to the North line of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, same also being the South line of that certain property deeded as ;., right-of-way and recorded in Official Records Book 3640, Page 871, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for-335.10 feet; thence S 00°19'04" Vl, along the East line of the West 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of-the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, for 637.54 feet,' thence N 89°39'30" W, along the South line of the Northeast 1/4 of the'Southeast 1/4-of said Section 5, same also being the North 1 ine of that property shown on the plat of Sa11's Lake Park Third Addition, as recorded in Plat Book 71, Page 21, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 335.12 feet; thence N 00°19'10" E, along the West line of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast'1/4 of said Section 5, for 637.44 feet to'the POINT OF BEGINNING. AND The Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4r. of Section 5, Township 29'South, Range 16 East, Pinellas County','Florida, 'as described' in Official Records Book 5757, Page 851, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, and being more particularly described as follows:' Begin at the Southeast corner of the'Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 5, Township 29 South, Range 16 East, Pinellas County, Florida;, thence N 89°39'30" W, along the South line of the Northeast 1/4 of the ' Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5 (being the basis of bearings for this description), same also being the North line of the plat of Sall's Lake Park Third Addition, as recorded in Plat Book 71, Page 21, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, -for 335.12 feet; thence N'00°19'04" E, along the West line of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, same also being the East line of that certain property described in Official Records Book 3352, Page 579, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 333.77 feet; thence S 89°40'01" E, along the North line of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the,Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of-said Section 5, same also being the South line of that certain property described in Official Records Book 5757,- Page 846, of.the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 335.11 feet; thence S 00°18'58" W, along the East line of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 5, same also being the West line of the plat of Forest Wood Estates, as recorded in Plat Book 69, Page 17; of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida, for 333.82 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. D', X 11:1 i3 .T. `i' A X354-93 Y r •}1 C. R. 41/05 P/ S P sr-0oo?. f n fa7S 34 7'L :. WOODS ? raga ?! 43 57 ? t < s 5 3J Q fads lass 1869 test 7 ? ?' 44 56 55 tn to 01 32 fa59 1459 C lase 55 ASILE WOODS l.A o 45 fesr 88 ?1 F- rays raas 1852 :X 46 fat r 67 30 ?- 1810 87-13 ? 4 z f8t6 3 6 M fate 60 yF^ 17 rasa G0 1891 V 29. 1811 '? t/ rata O 52 O 607-iB54 48 rasa 'e ?"' ;y"."` .?,n•,:?t 28 f85J ,,e ?: RS 28 '.?+ r= ,.: C Q u N T Y 7-0 N I N Cr .., A, E' !wr ' N q 'I,?.?'T 1a 27 ra2t o fa2r50 rO 17 26 Iola a t'E' r • ? ,,?, $ :t O a 19 25 Iro 1812 20 41/06 ` ?. 21 24 a U, ::jy 06 , %2 03 40 41 2 43' 4 16 !F/ At 4M ?l 5#1. 503 . t!. .....r >, + Jq L L G 41 I-,A rti^ 44 7 f78f S' ? ?C 74 C A v' b, f Nqq In H N 01 A f q u q ,n ev N ry N N ^+ a N N ?•! H _l1?•r K f7f'1 N h m t ?^^ -ey 01 r? ST k w .• AFL„ ^:' :? P : i i }, • . , I ?f t 3 h A, D r rsa o t?a9 r't':,sr. ,+•,. -'(:E?.:f• 0'Sf R:.•:'oi.?,:isi??::_'`{ °w ST. CFiOIX DRIVE N omi 1 ?..c • ;?.:}y= ••}ii:: ?F•'' + rn {•. ti:•7: ?..•?f".', F a::'i•bl?.. ::: . i ,•i a V -- yy+lr^afs?i ?7 ? .? .?r?.::??J?t3i1 i'+i i?:it';:?r1'.:?r 29 ? :4 2El 1781 o? a n q a q `'°` o -t-4?ry66n.-.?..?~`?.??',?.:?r'?':t:.'..?1?A'?V.'I?l:+'?,?7''??i'?.7?5++'?.-'. ?r...•?.?'??.ti .11.. 1i] n n •• -r•---..?.. ... .. • PROPOSED LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and REZONING OWNER 'x 9.3-0 1 LUP q ,3-o 1 APPLICANT D A K L.E A F LT O PROPERTY DESCRIPTION '-LAND-USE PLAN ZONING M9i81s r-{I ?oG C, yi SOB FROM LoW UENS1`C?{ ?S- .PLAl1NING'•and..zONit{G I30ARD? CITY COMMISSION 1 .SECTION C)5 TOWNSHIP 'Lq S RANGE 16 E ATLAS PAGE 2G L{ $ '0 Single Family V .^ VACANT -- - - L .J r• t . f?' "fart , , , - - Ft, Harrison MY rtIc Ave ----___- Missouri Ave. s H to { C • .? n f ] LA 0 i A Kings Ilighway ' u' in f, „Ft Ilighland Ave. C N U n ' Lai:a Ave . S n t -c? ri n d *- y I Keene Rd. I>• U, "' `o Nerculei Ave. 4 - R• u. G C.) ?' • ` Vs ! r~. ?h r, Lie I ell t: r Rd. N a r I u w p ! n i? Q I1. 5. l y a !D ?? s ! N Countrysled ,? ! ! m 42 C13 o O t ` Landmark t1r. Mcm%lilca Booth Rd. ??- - . m %? ` ? 4. ;?, awr uur d . s S.4 Sr r i r S LM. l t e AI, Clearwater City Commission Meeting 03 11l 93 ' nAAgenda Cover Memorandum PUBLIC C1 HEARING SUBJECT: t Amendment to the Zoning Atlas; 2144 Calumet Street; Owner: City of Clearwater; Approx. 0.8 ' ac. (Z 93-02). YYY?uum?.? Y. i I IIYI.Yi nr?. -r?inn?i.unrrr RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve the Zoning Atlas Amendment from P/SP to IL for Lot 10 less the west 430 feet thereof, s Clearwater Industrial Park, and pass Ordinance No. 5351-93 on first reading. j ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same, i BACKGROUND: The request is to amend the Zoning Atlas from P/SP to IL for approximately 0.8 acres of City owned land on the north side of Calumet St. approximately 800 ft. west of Belcher Rd. The property was formerly the National Guard Armory. The City proposes to lease 'or sell this parcel for industrial use. The City Commission has declared this parcel to be surplus. The surrounding properties are in the City.and have a City and Countywide Future.Land Use Classification of Industrial and zoning of IL. It is proposed to assign the same Future Land Use Classification and zoning to the City owned parcel. The City and Countywide Future Land Use, Classification for this parcel is Public/Semi-Public. The PPC as part of the, Consistency Program has proposed to reclassify this parcel as Institutional. The City has requested that the parcel be reclassified by the County as Industrial rather than Institutional as part of the Consistency Program. Final action on the rezoning will not be taken until after the City and the Countywide Future Land Use Classifications have been amended by the Consistency Program to Industrial. The Planning and Zoning Board held a public hearing on this request on March 2, 1993, and unanimously endorsed the zoning change. Reviewed by: Originating Dept: M -1 P Cas": _¢_NJA Commission Action: Legal N/A PLANNING & DEII ME T Total 11- Approved Budget Purchasing N/A N/A ? Approved u/conditions Risk Mgmt. NIA Of°r Dept: g Current Fiscal Yr. © Denied cis NI 0 Continued to: ACM [p Funding Source: Other N/A -" ' ? Capital imp . Advertised: ? operating Attachments: Date: 2/20/93 Gi other ORDINANCE NO. 5351-93 Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE ? Not Required Submitted by: Affected Parties Ci None ® Notified Appropriation Code: 13 Not Required Citq Man or 0 Printed on recycled paper ,i , .,, • r ., ; , .`T 111 It r r f ' , + • f. tr ?l ORDINANCE NO. 5351-93 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF' THE CITY BY REZONING CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED ON T1IE NORTH SIDE OF, CALUMET STREET, APPROXIMATELY 800 FEET WEST OF BELCHER ROAD,• CONSISTING OF PART OF LOT 10; CLEARWATER INDUSTRIAL PARK, WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 2144 CALUMET STREET, AS DESCRIBED MORE PARTICULARLY, HEREIN, FROM PUBLIC/SEMI- PUBLIC (P/SP) TO INDUSTRIAL (IL); PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. r It WHEREAS, the amendment to the zoning atlas of the City as set forth in this ordinance is found to'be reasonable, proper and appropriate, and in compliance i with Florida law; now, therefore, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section 1. The following described property in Clearwater, Florida, is hereby rezoned;,and ,the zoning atlas of the City is amended as follows: Property Zoning-District Lot,10,.less the West 430 feet, From: Public/Semi-Public (P/SP) Clearwater Industrial Park, according to the map or plat thereof as recorded To: Industrial (IL) in Plat Book 44, Page 46, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida. (Z 93-02) Section 2. The City -Commission does hereby certify that this ordinance is consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan. Section 3. The Planning 'and Development Director is directed to revise the zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment. Section 4. 'This ordinance shall take effect'immediately upon adoption. PASSED ON FIRST READING PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL i READING AND ADOPTED R.i to Garvey Mayor-Commissioner Approved as to form and correctness: Attest: ti c M. A. Galbraith ®r ' Cynthia E. Gou eau City Attorney City Clerk , 16 t, Fj i?'t T «y H `v 1 „y N 4 ;_too, ?? 5 v N NY 0 q L'G BLVD VAC. R.O.W. O.R. 5089-62 R.O.W. O.H. 5859-1727 REMUTION ti OR 3318-435 h O.C.O. R.O.W. 1 ry 1+ N Ia ` n to O.R. 5294•-2045 6 L; I L GV I CLEARWA7£R `r v C-00 ?1 TY 2;:, u I N C tvi I' 1'Iyq. CITY y?!! II n ter, h 4V44EO P14O 1 • a + , rq ?tJ r1, ?c p PNDPERTT ??V11 . w 333. F ., 5 A O C fit fit `r ?f S P f a Lw?•`!a ?1{?,,i?t , 9. 1t h H X} ' r i?lv N 1`firi ''1}??jK/•A C!?LVMET STREET b = '*. ~ r irr.r- I ' I Y O.R. 34653-346 17 12 5 O.R. 4138-1950, ,Y-- 1$ LIAIITED COMMERCIAL r_ ul F 1 PER CPA ACTION 05108190. I L MEARWA7ER v1 + 1 • ..... ' ! 1 * `. ? 'yr'Y?•G +.. : p„ r may` PROPOSED LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and REZONING OWNER . APPLICANT G t-T ?C O F I L E A R.w A-r E P - I '-LAND USE PLAN ZONING ' FAOM PUBk-[ C SEW((- P s P 4 u C'? L. ? c. • TO I W.o.U STRI i+ L 1 L I , PLANNING and ZONING BOARD i Z q3-o2 Lup ROPERTY DESCRIPTION P /a RT i, o -7 10 [LEA RLW AYt:TZ l?Jp . PK CITY COMMISSION SECTION -01 TOWNSHIP ?-q S RANGE is E ATLAS PAGE 265 2 Fj B'= 8 U S l' IJ E S S V= ?! A C. A tJ `? D.9o ACRES . i i o r w a? 0 v , ??, I h n o t h x w u. , R ?-l ' , ' -, ' ark, Dr. r .F.'d`i ..M?..L y}? a v?li' r1: .'t. .. r r? 3 ,i - . ? ' , _ .. .';. '!1: :J'.. N1,. .'-. r11•}'9'?ff j:ii ??`ry?/gq?yyll 'i,' ••'i. :r'r ` 7 r '1. . 1F f, r ,. - f J ' r 1 .. `? „?. ?,°'?'•p°,'rr j ? • t ? ? . rift' '- ?+• I' Jr ? d ? ' r ?7r KnC al'a ,?{r, '3, I• •y? P` aF? f; ?1`? 1 , tl -1 ?Yi y aJ;Si, '{• '' rJ`r e. • 1'sVS I i ? . •M'S .rj "ct j4 i-.:i' 'rJ ??' ?f ?,F: f."t";. 't 't'?•',r ?r JAP'?',3 .3 f •? 3 .. ,r. • I j .. d, Lr°,•6,r2;1, z°. `?'•?' :.i-?St?'•?i .j .. !c¢>d ',r '+'?:? ^tr?'il:3i':,y.? r .f... - ". e'. r ?, J 'f' j• .?.y,' k.<'•1? ia' r.f.1 F •I' _ f' ' •r•r ?''. rrff?. ._ - •^E •r"„?: ?41 '!?' 5 .F. f. •yJ 1 0 S,' r. `4 `fle f".i j.L ' .=+'.. .r. !,' ? j." ^r'?• ' of otoa .?'rPr ai "'i. .. •,, + , , .J '? } ,' , , r r r ,? ',i ?i 1 r Al , j t,ro f.Y rFr ,!, , r ,A? J, !iy' J•t,i '='4 9}i,i+•{,j 's. r,r ,t"' ? _,'? 6.!• - ..ti i fJ r•, ;. , - '1 ? '. ? V .•,y •17. ;r,.: 7 . ? ? ? ?• Mkt ,.•SI,. ? i " ? r r' - ' . . , r r ' x.11 % ,,ltw r. 2 ` t` I ?• ?1 ? }r - i, :. .. ? •? , ? ? ' ? ? I ? ?, r • ? .. J ?' i ?,4 `q. ITEM i;y` .. •?+. - .! I' ', 1 rF.t. ,? j r .r 'e ..' X30; ? 'S r I •a? RI..?-. .+.' r'I... d.r .•'[- ,+ ..S E, r` .3c ?.S '{.a' _ `-tt r `T.? •r`1a d. it' . s, ry+ Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum r t Meets SDe- 03/18/93 PAD 3 SUBJECT : HEARING Pinellas Planning Council's Countywide Consistency Program - Reconsideration of Various Land Use Plan Amendments. RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Hold public hearing and modify Exhibit A of Resolution 92-69. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: On December 17, 1992, the City Commission.approved the following ordinances (on first reading) and resolutions involved with the PPC Consistency Program: ? Resolution No.•92-69 which authorizes the Pinellas Planning Council to request certain changes to the Countywide Future Land Use Plan Map as they relate to the City of Clearwater in order to achieve consistency. ? Ordinance No. 5312-92 which authorizes amendments to the City's Comprehensive Land Use Plan as they relate to the Countywide Consistency Program. ? Ordinance No. 5296-92 which proposes to amend the City's Land Development Code as related to the Countywide Consistency Program. ? Resolution No. 92-78 which requests the Pinellas Planning Council to reconsider certain of its rules. On January 20,,1993, the PPC held a public hearing for the City's requested changes to the Countywide Plan to achieve consistency with the City's Plan. Many individuals and groups spoke in opposition to the Countywide changes - requesting instead that the City change its plan to match the'Countywide' Plan. Most of the concerns were expressed by owners of single family properties who wanted a lower Land Use Plan classification. As a result, the City Commission subsequently authorized City staff to proceed with amendments to divide the low density residential-classification into several classifications to more closely coincide with the assigned zoning districts. The PPC continued approximately one half of the cases due to the concerns expressed by the public. Reviewed by: l ' Originating Dept: Cots: _1_N1A _ Commission Action: Legal Budget A l N/A PW NtNGQ LOPMENT i Total D Approved Purchasing N/A ,, ? Approved w/conditions Risk Mgmt. NIA ser Dopt: ? Current Fiscal Tr - . El Denied cis N/A © Cnntinued to: ACM Fundin g Source: Other ---N/A ? Capital Imp . Advertised: ? operating Attachments. Date: 2/16,2/25,3/11 ? Other Dave Healey Letter w/Table Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE ? and Maps 9 6 Not Required Res. 2. 9 Submitted by: Affected Pafties ? None ® Notified Appropriation Code: cit Man cr © Not Required 10 Printed on recycled paper 1 ?? 1 CC Memo - PPC March 18,.1993 Page 2 Attached is a copy of a letter from Mr. David Healey, Executive Director of PPC, which outlines his position on the continued items. Also, attached is a listing of the total cases for reference to the cases enumerated by Mr. Healey. City staff has closely examined the continued cases and would group them into seven general categories as reflected on the table provided on page 3 and as discussed in the following paragraphs. The first three issues involve single family residential classifications and how they are applied to the RS-2, RS-4, RS-6 and RS-8 Zoning Districts. The PPC staff recommends that the land use plan classifications correspond with the' average density of the existing single family developments. While in some cases the average density within a single family subdivision may be lower than the maximum permitted density of the assigned plan classification or zoning district, not all of the lots within these subdivisions will meet the dimensional and numerical requirements of a lower classification. This means that establishing a lower plan classification and zoning. district will create nonconforming lots. City staff recommends that-we, continue with previous Commission direction to revise zoning districts and plan classifications only, where nonconformities will not be created. The fourth issue primarily involves commercial properties on US 19 and SR 60. This is an area containing a variety of plan classifications on the Countywide Plan, but the issue of concern is limited to the CG and ROR'categories. The PPC staff is recommending that many properties the city has proposed for a CG classificationgo to an ROR classification to reduce conflicts with Pinellas County enclaves which are largely ROR. City staff is opposed to this for three reasons. First, some uses and developments will be made nonconforming. Second, the dominant use pattern is commercial, not mixed residential, office and retail. We believe this use pattern should be•reflected on the Countywide Plan, rather than continuing the current mish-mash of nonresidential classifications. Third, the City staff feels that cities should specify the, general pattern of land use classifications within their planning areas and the County be required to bring its enclaves into conformity with the selected pattern rather than the reverse. The fifth issue involves a single mobile home park, the Kapok Mobile Home Park. The PPC staff feels this park should be placed in a separate land use category because it is less densely developed than other City mobile home parks. The "City staff feels that, since we have only a single mobile home zoning district, we should allow this park to remain under the same land use category as all other City mobile home parks. The sixth issue involves a simple reclassification of current P/SP sites into either Z or T/U categories to reflect the current uses. Both the City and PPC .staffs are in agreement that the property's actual use should determine its classification. The final issue is primarily to correct various scriveners errors, but does include one specific concern. The PPC staff is recommending that the former Siples Restaurant site now owned by Morton Plant Hospital be placed in a Residential/Office General category rather than the Institutional category that was recently-approved on first ordinance reading by the City Commission. The surrounding hospital property is classified as institutional on both plans. Recommendation by the Planning and Zoning Board:__ On March 2, 1993, the Planning and Zoning Board held a public hearing and .reviewed these changes. The board recommended following the City staff's recommendations on the above issues (please refer to the "Prop. Municipal Land Use Categories" column in Revised Exhibit A of Res. 92-69). F? • e • 1 'Z CONSISTENCY ISSUES TO BE RESOLVED _. , City Zoning Previous City Current City Staff Recommendation - District and/or Staff Comments/Explanation Land'Use Plan. Recommendation Classification 1. RS-2 Zoned Classify Classify Residential Suburban (RS) LUP - ' Pro erties Residential 2.5 units per acre (upa). max. p Urban (RU) LUP 2. RS-4 Zoned Classify Classify Residential Low (RL) LUP - max. Residential 5.0 upa Properties Urban (RU) LUP 3. RS-6 Zoned Classify Classify Residential-Urban (RU)LUP - Residential max. 7.5 upa .(note: The RL LUP is too Properties and RS- Urban (RU) LUP restrictive for the dimensional and 8 Zoned Properties numerical development requirements of the.RS-6 Zoning District; nonconformities would be created if RLr' is used) 4. CG LUP sites Classify Classify Commercial General. (CG) Commercial with ROR LUP on General (CG) ? ROR will create non-conformities .Countywide Plan (examples: Dimmitt Cadillac has a .45 FAR, but ROR would only permit .40 FAR; the Celebration Station/Mountasia Miniature Golf commercial recreation use would not be permitted in ROR);, ? Existing developments and uses better meet the intent of CG rather than ROR, a mixed use land use classification; ? The dominant pattern of use-type along . US 19 in the Clearwater Planning Area is CG; and ? Assigning CG to some of the parcels and ROR to the rest would create an uneven pattern of land use in Clearwater along U.S. 19 5. Mobile Home Classify Classify Residential Low Medium• -this is Residential the only LUP classification of which the Parks Low Medium City's only Residential Mobile Home (RMH) zoning district is permitted (max. 10 u pa) 6. P/SP 'sites Classify I or Classify I.or T/U depending on existing T/U depending uses - additional. T/U sites have been on existing identified uses .7. Others (e.g. Various Various (please refer to listing for , City Staff recommendations) scriveners errors, Si lea site) 5 . . i' 3 r S • is' ' 9 CC Memo - PPC March 18, 1993 Page 3 a PINLUASTLANNING COUNCIL Irc M E M O TI A N? U M COUNCIL MEMBERS Mayor George M. prolka, Chm. ' 03"mriuimirr I,ntma S. "jim" rills, Vice Chm.. TO• James Polatty, Director School 11r+ard Member Ron Walker, Sec. Greer. •artment of Planning and Development VIc cormrri5ciP-MayorMaynr eT Tom An An,Trderson son • • Dep City of Clearwater Cornmissloner Sue Berfield VicP•Mayor Temple A. Corson, jr. Mayor Barbara Gilbetg FROM: David P. Healey, Executive Director_• Cmincilmember Conn leKone F . Pinellas Planning Council Ct+inmiWoner Blalne P. Lecouris Vice-Mayor Linda Matthews , Councllmember Tom Pinta SUBJECT: Disposition of City of Clearwater Plan Amendment Cases Vice-Mayor Daniel A.Pohlo r Qontinued at PPC Meeting of January ?0, 1993 David P. I-lealey;AICP Executive Director DATE: January 28, 1993 In follow-up to,our meeting yesterday morning, I have outlined below for your review and consideration our recommended disposition of those Clearwater cases continued at the January PPC, :meeting. The purpose of the list Is to provide you with an advance understanding' of our staff position based on a detailed breakdown of existing use and , density in order that'you may have this.avallable for review and any revision to ilia City's application that: the City Commission may ducido to make. have organized the cases as they'were identilied'In Attachmexit I to the Council action of January 20th as set forth following: 1. 11esidenlial Low to Residential Uiban ; .} Withdraw/Deny: ti. (.12)(39.)(4-1)(43)(4-5)(54)(82)(101)(103)(104)(127) '.:_. (137)(211)(212)(216)(217)(219)(245)(246)(247)(261)(340)(341) • ",.-. ra,r.. +,nnrn r1'7r'• AQ/'+'r 1 ^/.. ". '?i: I<:t4???.7?F5j?v?+:.r1i-?•?:?'il1-tr •.•lI?,JUJtjrPiuj(-.3?J) i + .:} Alternate Recommendation to Residential Suburban: - .i r . .) Approve: ' (1)(2)(11)(13)(44)(74)(75)(87')(86)(90)(97')(205)(258)(262)(263) (361)(362)(363) is 50, FF. I IARRISON A\T., St !I 11. illIII ('I I ARWAI IL It, i I•f MIDA 34616 TELEVI IONS (111 1) 462, 111';'1 VAX 11113) 462.11117 Y. k.+ 3, (. .fit 2., Residential Suburban to Residential Urban ' a.} Withdraw/Deny: ,' . (53)(6.4)(132)(133)(141)(142)(143)(144)(145)(462)(463)(464) b.} Alternate Recommendation .to Residential Low: (10) i. 3. Residential Estate to Residential Urban , .) Withdraw/bPny:. ' (80)(81)(135) ' 4. Public/Semi-Public to Institutional =r • 1 1 I ?a.) Alternate Recommendation to TransportatiorVUtilily: . ' . .' _ (79) (111) (172) (253) (389) (402) (411) (458) 1 Alternate Recommendation to Commercial General: (169) F: c.) Alternate Recommendation to Residential UrbEin: ' r (193) , .. : d.) Alternate Recommendation to Recreation/Open Space • IA4C% i ?•) Approve: 4,5,6,7,9,15,18,20,22,23,25,26,27,28,29,31,33,42,48,51,52`56,57,60;63,68, 71,73,84,89,93,95,96,100,105,108,109,113,114,117,118,123,129,136,138, 150,152,155,160,161,163,165,166,168,171,174,17,5,179,180,181, '=148,149 '. , 187,189,191,192,201,202,206,237,249,264,267,272,274,277,280; :1 82 184 , , 2131,301,302,316,327,330,331,346,353,354,372,380,383,390,391,392,393, ' : (395-401)(403-410)(412-415)(417-420)(422-453),456,457,459,468,470,473, X74,476,479 ' ' ` i • is ? 7 •; 5 : , ;, Vii . 1 ,r y , K r ' - • , , F ,. ? 's" ? .. -r , , ; 1 ., rig .. i. rr y,f°.:lq rar. ' :.': ,• , "1. ' t' ," r"IC's ?, ? ' -, . ,. ? ?r's??;, . ?? r i .:i;?!'•i'' ;: :M'3'g ,;,,' i ;'•?+1°ia}i:? '; ? , . f , ,. : ," ?: + F ? .. , •.} ?`;^.. ,?3 .Y y{ ?„ ?; i ?Y1..?3., '4',•s ,_ . ._, . ! :. .. :l. _V.,ji_ iia,. '. 3" r?,^' .P'?.. ?R•Si ?. ; ,, • ? 1, ` f .. ,.'.. .:.'??.1.fa.-'.'d .,•i"...»"???...9 : ?. 't e ..t,'i:.! ? n r !' f ? s't.i'.. t.. y<{'•} ... r i b ? r 3,? C . i . .. . ? . .. , •k .. J. i .L Commercial General il t l/Offi /R itl t R id ' ° : . e o er a ce a BS r •, ', . Withdraw/Deny: F '(61)(62)(67)(69)(70)(72)(76)(85)(106)(1.1,2)(200) ' ? : b•) Approve: ' ' . . . r ., 6. Fie 'nested B City Withdraw: ` , ; r • e - ;t (356) Alternate Recommendation to industrial' Limited: '_. ?. ;z (224) Approve: % s ' '= f "J284) 7. -Agenda Memo Items a.) Withdraw/Deny: (92)(486)(491)(492) ) Alternate Recommendation to Residential/Ottice General: fj . '404) ' } 4 Y Z. Public Hearing Items ? Withdraw/Deny: : Clarify: •) (49)(487)(1 3'I t r V'I ?1` (A'y' ? i6 t'R.• . J:"` i'rZSe L*^le?. ?''?. r.l ?y ''?i?; r i.:l? r ? :i''' r? .. .. ? ?? •?f ,i" ??: .'r . a .. ! , ;r '..{? rs? ,1 - . 1 . • { .. #. 1 .'fit. ? '>, ° .. . r r q., 1 r .°.r:.l.?.t ?L•??€ ;/ ? .rr 1 .4 *Jy':i ?.. ,? ?l 1' ? E. ? f` + il .," ' z ? ' e : .. t 'lW). •F ' .° "A ?`r ? ; , ? r Y. , ? } .. 1 .1 _ t l 7 `5 !rr ' •,, ,? , ."'_ r`F 1'i `? ' it • . . ?'r ,! ? •? , .? "1;r 5 . of ! /? r _ , . • .1 ' 1 ; r ) ' , • ? „?{.epe, '{' , r - ' „ ?i... o ,t ?1€.fI °s r' 1:is rl r ! ' - ' ?' ?,'"{..? '. :• 'yam .`. elf ,:.','? 5 fl,• . , fs:P.l'J=, ,S.' , .1 r f r - F ! ? % ?P.kSel7td15:iL'.?, aa' r r .t.1,• t .. ., °€ ?;a. ...•/. .; ?+:.1!C???`:??`{,.. .. 1 r ., '1' ? p'' - , .. 'i F1;. ! •ii I • •rra'; "7''P } i. r ? , V:) Approve. '.. , / (3)(128)(134)(244)(295)(460)(485) ' Other, - Modify: i F';'',:• :: ' ' r (139} Modify legal to provide for amendment from Recreation/Open :1. , Space to Residential Low. 4 Reconsider Flesideritial Low en S ace t m Rgcr©ationlC e d f 4 A o, p p ro n 0) m (1 Please s'hare 'our recommended disposition and reasoning , therefor with 'the, City ` "Commission When you revisit your submission with.them. In particular,,it is our belief that for the, consistency process to be. meaningful, it' must consider actual or desired ' simply on existing zoning. use/density and not rely , b!4lfd 1 , .. , -91- K W A dv ? G1 ??+ w N V'} C% w U LO .4?? z 0 Q U E..UUV) H-1 I 1 ?-•? LxL.I < a d LLJ o 1--1 LLI L a w UU z z 0 u 7 > ' "Cy L 4 7 L. A 3 D C Q 00 0 CO N I Q coo S Q i N s ' C •w3 i.. N 6 V O ? _ ? D w V .y = b d ? -0 C M C y > C O D U m 4 D _ GQ • L ¢ ca o p v QO d la as ?a W a.u L ¢ Lei .- o.. ou C) 0 C ca 0.- u O ° 9. V D y rn • o {J N L. a] Q 1 U b 0. ° u 'C] y N ' L. A u G4 C b 43 C ? D p 1 ?. N !., > p ~ ? y +.. H w ? « ts D o ?- a u ? • L) W s O C3 •D a O v? cu u 0 00 - D t., a u , N A u _y . di ' d) G • 7 ?.. d ...7 a D • .. 0 Q t? ? •d w G N b 0 1 D N d) u a v ar w M d . I, u - Q O 3 (,a C? w ca 3 ` D PC CU O 04 Cq . 3 r C -W 41 a N > L .? O E? D N A N Y D O A Y O M p O D ?'' D L CS O p 1.. ,> 0 A. y D L. O c.?d C Zed 3p 94 04 C7 0 w Es au Zw e•s Zaa Z0 o Zr-n N N ? C 1 ? 1 1 C; N Q CD pp" O V N C) O O cm O q 4 N en N10 C \ Ca . -, C] en N r*1 _ Q M ° C p Q u n t^ « `t Doo o C7 o N ° a N A Q w r^ -NO °o O C=l Cl 00 O s C ° m 0 ei . 00 .•"? r ? N C7 1 C .-. h' o 1 1 CO Y yl u I w'1 1 u.y r V kp 1 ?p 1 ?p I Z C ?p I wy w 1 w1 O, 00 00 00 o_R 00 O a\o ?O 0\O Cr% N N N oo N N N _\ N C? N N N N U ?+s r f?r1'o s + O %Q %0 N ry O C N O 1wl C4 N W3 Cn 4 z Ch En v] Z y r1 N V) z-. z NO _ V) O en G 7 C] ; rD 00 Q f ? GO MO C1 to M wn t ~ V N r u c rYI o v? v -. t^ ri t~ •.? d a V7 M Y a a a ,? .. C4 a 56 es u =I LA a ? 4 . 'C] O Y W? k a ? a ? ? ?: i?' a, a a a a N oo in tV N M y ?'?+ rv Cn M 'N M N I N tr CD Ul M U U a I rn eT 1 1 N I M x U A W v d? 0. 0 v W N z # Q O c` ?..UU dW d C O? ? Q >W U U z W H in Ln z 0 7. d • 7 ?! y 1: O m O co O ? w 00 V) O 43 ` .? 'a cl 'C R1 (U .••. O Q 0.i Q z O C 0 U (U 4) • • V) s7 + Q (x •0 0. GC 1~ ar C C3 it L+ V ° .. ? a) v.. r U 7 C 2 N N 41 V: N •C w w r o m ai e U .0 V) = I t4 V) V2 cu C O .C O a ° CIS d L. to r a, rs SAG d ? o y w « ?T+ p r. Q ? Cd O - C q y., I o N v 0 • t.. O . M 07 tv O 6. u O ' G O v O u b ° o q b ? C 00 ev h 4611 'n y R 'T' ¢ • t? G O +v-'? "C C ' ' ,a O C Ln CIS w C5 L14 C j 41 t; 3 H m H t - O m c1 o U C7 a C:3 = y ?«+ O 3 C v i ? N q C C .C 80 b . . 0 c° a o c o° °' 4 0 C 0> o > c 0 0 0 (n V w V) cu V) CS En M N 1 V) Q) N Q n R W d Q m. ° a o a c i o C) p O p 0 r*? O .-:.-: O kn OtoOO? ad d O 00 p Q ,n C] O 1 O O ... `?::?: 1 00 I a%0 %D 1 p,Oa a7 O O C) O CD N C] O N C) v O- CD ? 1 0 0 G ry Q N I :t C) CD I I CD o O v C ° G p \ O \ o C C) ° O O Z o n O o O^ ?° ' t? M ? r w a C) I O CD O O N t'"1 c w) Q C) o C) I 00 tn N o I ?5 o p cn ? n N t O O Zo z o O V) n Q O O O r Q Q MNN" I Kr--:r:NV] Ov C4 044 \ r n1 _ %D 00p 00 O Q C) Q 00 C7% n I OO r1 rn m r4 K' C) O kn ?Q ?C7O0NC5 C c `+11 r- 00 0 I CD © I \ ' ?? d I I I \ OO pM^OO\O y y +r1d +p v1 W O Np i Q as cI 00 - N n 7CNwNt-7 O \ \G \p \ C N Cp O O Q \p O (n - p Ch I a N arc" O N oo v. N ooop ? ......--91 op O O '- I I I 00 ° O ? nQ rq O r4 p? O N O C? m 20 0 O OO M"koZ1 V_ _ z C? C) 00 00 V) V)N Z V) ,V) ZQ V) Zp Z 00 ZCD D OZC0 00 r r 00 r C% to r7 0% u o ri o r o Co 0% o CV N d rn a a. ao °? ] a a a a ? „ ? 4U d? U ,r y ] .- W A q q a, En a `n a a A a. a q R . w a Q' *4 w 1. ? •y ' M+ Ir1 ?+Y 1? O O 3 a C W Q 0. ` R, V R. V 0.' a.. CL4 C: wN yN 'V) yr• ? cn? r /G --? .. ... ?D •-- N _ N r a f A, 6 t t A i r d ;? y ?? ° 0a o 41 ° ' ma G] 7 G V Ln f7 t/J LL. r. N r- 0 > 4y G> ¢ c a 4--1 C S" Q tti ty 0 .. V7 o G :) = = = :1 on O at P. > •G C7 C 0 Q tn p cts 04 N (} y C ! U 0 Gam!! ct ? f Q ,? r- O ?i r U. 9 C V p 4-: ^ • cc M Cl) u bo d ? , Cs •?,'. G ? V) M L. o V W 4 d) O W L. ? N. N .. W'. 4 C7 Lam:. 0 y, 4) O L.... ? ? C . - cl < .00 - (n G O O b. a O c?. C O O O 4. N C 7 V ?> d t j . U •? L. .+ a U C d O C 1 . O 0 4. 0 Lr 4. C O 3 C .. W 43 O .a v ti v w C 4 ayi ? , 'v • . C/J = ? r v? c? v v 'n N y cS . y 3 N 3 .c 3 C-3 3= cl T rs a n? °' Q y w ,,, CA .0 O LA I. o 'd O IS C= 0 'C1 r/I 'o y? 1 O O L ° ZN 0 c°', Cn.-.pG 3 0 z n z ra Z? c° m Z m W? r?[%) n c N M M C O I ' O 4 N 4tr Ln Ln I O I I CO O O r In I "o Cd . 4 p d C7 O oq O O it I O C) C p O O O Cl Cs C? C:) I O Q p w .., d Q I \ p CC \ O p I `D Ca .? ao u 0 0 Ca N p I OC .^ti ? C? C O I O H fi O C) O CD Ory Q CD O CD tn ? O 67 L Md 40 C p p q0 r• C5 Qp lV ?C] ? N N ?O O nCjpC) N a' # wC? G G CD Ln N t?J ?p %0 h04 t^ 1 MpQ vet p O co C] p CT CT OI ON O\ Ln N r9 Qr Q I p Q a f;t .+ a ' O ?p I h O Q M \ Q? -r I I ?O t3' 1 ? O Q \ ON \ C] ? CT pO C \ ? \ ? 4 ? \ CT 1 C3% C Q O C4 O N ! I \ OC N ` N Q ? r< O = ? o `:-ti CO •--• 1 0 'o C3 N ? ZtY Z p p" V Z 00 ZcCD cno C)q N04 V) Z Cq onr Zr C]p 7 Ena 10 - m ' Ch O O M M n tT kn ri O\ O !? rt in n v O O G N w'1 -- • O .-r CD O w O C4 tA CL C ell ., w u. f W J3 cc Y u x a. cw A CL. a CL a a a a Iy „ L 0 'LJ O 04 V U w VJ 4 C7 C7 u a a. U) a. a ? a a V • 0. U a. 0. , rx ? caG cs ?+ r` •v a rn cn r r cn ac b v? cd tJ In ?? cti rJ rn RJ v! 'C v) N N ns M N a N in N N N 00 N O+ N Ca cn -- M• N K1 cn M I ' z z ?o Q? p. O y U. W 'r1 ? S'r! U N EQ, O U 1 I v Q+ LLB ¢ 0 O? 0. Q U zU W N con v? Q U F ? - as tot ro Qt V 0 a) d) C Q3 O O O a) C 0. r3 C C O O c3 N a) O C O G es rn as rr w a i a 3 '- U V > cu 4) E a) > 3 > ¢ ¢ ¢ > Q a .0 ?. p O . al ^a< Q: • ?. ?? ?., > c3 > tn¢ V ¢ i O O o a a di (1) ro , 0 n ,Dro Q= D O C O U O C L. O O +n ?n a± O C O OS 0 U c7 L ti+ L, cj m O y ?" - O k O L G) = v! a) c: H ? x ??.¢ O C) ca u `= 4 W p O C rO ' x O ["' h b 0 a 11 L. 00 (U en j N . O rs a) L `Q O 3` cu C3 3 ti N y c., - y cs tA 'iq a) vs .c 0 cts 6. y a O p O 0 O O O Z n r` to a ?m a 0 v3 04 O zU tz z a0.' a CA 0.' G rnN Z 3 zV2 GN Q V) n 0 c;. zcn O o " o • C) N ° ° co E !S? OC a Q a ` ° O ° ? N C N O O C ' O a 1 CD CD ! C) C> ! C) p °o °a' I CD a = ° a N •: \ r a r a r C o , o -s a C) O r 0 a RI ?o ?a er) o cc o N ° `r v! o o a o C ., fn in Go 00 1^ ? n ? ,N ? ° O m -? a 000 0 000 O a qk +ri V 1 t * 1" N cN17 Q a p a a 00 m CO o _ A' ?A cn 1 _ 4 'n, '? ? r 4' ? C ? v1 r Q 4 c* CO O? O\ O Ch \ \ 0? ch [+? . \ n a% \ a \ c CD \ fV tf) O1 V A4 cqQ N O ; ? \C N C % N \ N N C `? C U N N V7 V1C Gn y CJN ; r,j'C Q d N N ?O r r1-• MQ %0 CN z C z a Z m o o N z a z ! N [ 0 C NO a [y t` N ON z a 0 ul (n Cn En V) ul C5 Q v! 00 00 y N C? to kO Q\ 4 V1 L. ri uu fy 1 O m O C O O Q? --? O co d d °' a d a H v a. a .., bo as .? U .: 4) uo d ar '; ' O C O • Q N N N y M N N N ` N ` ,II eT 1`` ?n %O n 00 c' a% [`1 M en cn [+1 r+7 Q Q Q `V 7 ?a .y a) a) 'U w a r rn N 1 ["1 r z W Q 0 d •d 0. ? W? A V? w ° Ea.UU 1 1 Q W 0 ? 0 < 0? per., 4 U W U z W F to z 0 U d V O 00 Q7 (,.., yj o O 0 (U U 00 • A 3 b 1. •a '? p o v o i. o cv ?.y q ai , 'C7 U a M ° ca W CU V. U ? v y d co A ° 00 f- ? A a o C7 ? a , a o o ai o `? W c 3 aC ' A O 67 ? C7 lw G N ? a U CU 'L3 • o a A ? vCtl ? u •es en Cs ° ?o N U c.. ? ° v°i o a7 .,, ? Z1 •LS o? 4? •D 'd h 't7 ,.., j a? 47 R7 ° E^ o . N 'rs W N E ? C •U Q y .a ; Lq y ? y Q b 0 In o ? 0 0000 4 0°° ' N °.0 a ? co ?Q 7 o c a i t/!Q zn z r? W v 1 j- 3N V ) 404 ?C4m Z Wra rn e0 ton W a z u p O Q a cil O O O O O O O C4 O o r? 1' O o N C4 C) O CD O %0 O C) 4 1 O O 40 O a G O O eT I o0 r'1 00 'cr N N r' S m ' M r. CD 0 NO Q r- M M 1 N 1 `? (/} OI p f V O N O Q m O C C) rq 1 'V O O Q p0 N O O ?c O N ? O a N 1 N a v u N d N M ?O ?D ?D W_ ?D CL l? C N a ` C%J C Q N N 0-3 N ti 00 00 E ?D r? N N ? C4 N Fi eq N V z ON C4 y v -- _ C' 1-1 o _ N ;?z r4 m a O C z Ln z n cn r/7 cn u] z N rn z a M vn m kl C? v ar Olt m %O r? T t` Le) y %C) 47 00 Q m i~ .? u G 06 v7 O . M r+i oo " O o -? Q cn . . N r a '? 03 PA a, w c? a o ? 40 U a r, LO a. U a c?. .a .a AG a, a. C3, C4 u C4 u d T b a .? 0 .. 'x er te ? p , pG IY A . ry AG IY, IY ? . cd N b ob N H ti9 oo J S'1 M ?- (°? N M •N ?+ P ?D NT N Q 00 qT 0% IT O Ln N Ln rrl Ln tr v1 Ir'/ ?D In r` Vb e , r , 1 a ? r V ° ..y .y V 0 Q , Il N W d _ y ' fri ° O C C C W I M "4u ? d) Q ° w G cd p p tu d; L-n d > in " • En U. 6. S. A tu o c/{ Z ate) .? In 0 ?/} U p t= U O aG s~ C O d ?' ° G L ° O N O U V U p a? p e.. ?. . O u pq ° U p ° 0° a) ° p 0 0 ? 'fl a) 3 u O r 'L7 • y ° •th N 47 "7 VI C? y CU •y E.1 Q) .G .C i11 .L y ?Y >1 O O y 0 > LM 0 aCi ' 0 0 •i o p C ? p G W o rnGq WCdw w4 W a r? E-' r4 xx Z0 v) ciW cn co W cvCt? o r-. C) 0 I 1d «? 00 i O1 r'1 O p ?, O O ? ^rG O MQ ?v o ff, Q O p. w O v O " G I n7 C N i N N .r 00 Q O 93 r i C'v N O? CD 0 I C 0 O .T .-, M Q N d O O O ° 00 7, i (L 00 00 C) O I O in N 0 N i` 00 n' o O i 0 W C7 N tn In 0 ,n u1 Q O ao N O 0 0 p 0 0 Qq ?-•? C:p N O I 12 O Q I 'w I O I Q O i w v i tp 1 0 N 00 O (D I .? %0 0 i - ,) t0 I t0 i ?D C4 C4 00 v C% ON M 00 n 0 00 D1 G o v 0% C) a% 01 o, O ` o V) rq I N N V N m O v 1 ^? d0 o t0 ?QO 000 0 C t I= O N O -- Z (n? Z ZOa to Z?p ZN V) Z?•, W Z -+ to vl t? N N qtr t?1 --? ke; %0 cl? G ?. y u o -» ri at %0 rti r• -» o Q a. J o , ¢r ... °° C6P ,a• U u , lu LM ] 42 w U. C4 `? ' LL, n ` A A A ? 0. ? . U . . a a V 0 w r V 0 00 K ? A? G; I?G fx o k W U f.1? L? 0. qG 04 ?, L1C GG Ch N cd 00 Ln CD V) ?' 400 M c-, N 1P t? rQy f? '? ) Y/ w'1 VCt1 t0 tQ w tO tD 10 tD . 1 ..,_¦ w 4 C] d? t N v ' w N "E?..U m fd.UUU l 1 W Q ? O? a UV z w ` H N C/) 4 V u .0 C m n 'v '* o o E a 0 E M a 0 a°, •- ? ? a 0% .-r ?'' s W N , .SC C+S QJ i ? L) y .r a r?'. 4.. 0 G U a) a a cd 0 .o o cn o cs [ ++ C 0 4? tv O i ° W C r O p a 0 , & v i V N o ?. M a? a L. 0 v ,n 0 u y a m a A U m L. U v . CU v v cn :n ?1' 67 ' • o .. a U o cl V 0 0 U , a 0 ?.. a a O U 0 W 0 .? 0 cd m 0' p u 0 ? a .L ca a+ w v .o ° = 'a r = o n .o .0 (} 0 0 ' a" ° 3 3 '? a 3 1- ?? `d CO cu ca o . c . vs 3 > nib y R ai °? cu cl w 'a Z w i a '^ G w a3 ,? c o ai rri ar i n Q o m a c o c ?` oN M ' " 25, Z cn Z rd Z U . . Z L/7 V] N U w N rFiA zw ?A --' .? ? ? wm a G 0 p ^ O O O 4 0000 CY% V p No ^ .r r N tQ C4 q =. O --. =4 Cl ? a co C7 O m = CD 4 O C ° ° ? ° ° ... C) C) CD a • a '- CD 0 C) C k v CD C-4 C) o C7 N a s Co C Co M ? o ; ° N a ° ° v ° N w o .a i ?n a ?. t/1 C) 0 00 o o Cl r - o o Q .° h c, ^ o a 0 Cl %0 CD ea IZ, 9k a o tr C) M CD a o ON Q CD . • o *- N ' 00 0 ° co oa C> Co 00 oa % M 00 n co o a i D Q 0 (D ? C, t w r- BCD ? -- 1C7 00 1CD a' ?n M rq ?N 0) T `N 0% a N CD ? l N Na C+t? N CD CVO N Na N N N 6 %D %0 - O a - - 0 Cl C) U G QN O CJ O C C] ; Z zaa Z ZQ Z --• z o zo zo za V) to cn 00 m r- 00 tA r- N l N M M N D\ C? n 9 6 C7 V'• -i ri • ~ ? ? U U V ? i.c. GG ?/ U U W w FU a. ;r ? d ?] x W ?sFF. 14 ? a i c. ? a a A A t?. U ?u•, . t??,•., a , a A U ? _ U U ? a u u U U U y Q+ G? f? dT 'a o t! U y . r.7 t? W U G»` a Ix C? L? fY' Gd ?. 0. Ix • N T J A «f. N x yr? 7• •N 7' O? ?o Q r? ••-? t- N ? M ? V n t+'1 ? ?C r? I? n 00 r? 0% n C? ov 4 F ' r to ?b I K CY > i7 Q M > •H Q b 0 C 0 U vs 0 ,, 00 s 03 ? 0 u CZ' U 0 ? .o > > :? o er 3 ?' . zs C O 'a o U o 'n , L. Ll ? C °`r' -, o ' a e i CS o a c O O z c; c m ZCa c s v O .S a c a a a E E w N 0o O cl °, = o> I ? u t.. ? 4r m = L r3 M) ed L. 4.r O c.. o ° V) L" C Q7 1/'1 6. O 4. t., A ... s-7 [r «. (U O w ° O C O a h U Q y C U O i 'Cf I O C C p ? V) w p Z S O ?. V ° 3, O? 3 U u u rs . U o w ° o u C S G 1 y v i 'C7 a? '? p G d y vl [} H Q M C (D ca r C E . C t1 y c W) Cl (U ` 3> w .r U tA O N g 0 .C En .G m V) 47 + a. CJ a s L lQ 0 a ° a M o 0 0 ? V c. ?+ C VJ ' V a ?.+ M o w o w 0 0 w 0 ? 0 o ,/ , to C4 ?/ Z WC4 Z U U Z Q [ W O Z r3 4n A En Cd va W V] RS 0 0 cn C,4 C 0 as CD ° °o ° o °o C?:r 46 ko ID C) C? °o C) ° ° CDCD --? Co +f1 Ch 0 0 ?, .. k0 O O N N CD O CD Q C:) Ca O Ca Zl 0 " k0 C7 0 0 CD " = 0 O N Q _ , O, p W a Q ?OQO OM OO. OC70 t+1NOoo IT O v t OkO O O c) CD CaQ e 00 %0 %0 O [V O O d~ Q _ d 10 C3 %0 o O Q Q N .. co 00 . -. 0 C su. GA ?p 00 O 1 Cf+ C 00 C ? C7 O (D CD O ID m o O '1-, O m (n 'Ir en CD b?W p C) M 40 ? ? N (DO o o 00 t i .N., Q? O t V t `O ?.. C7? t q n7 O ?b Q -, i %0 i I I ? C Q , r NO r gyp' O r- -x .r 0 0 C2 CD \ O ON Im CD (O ON A4 Onj r4 o N o0 N O V) o r? N 1 1 r4 N N r4 C4 0 V ',D ?N o %0 ?p?prr r4 Nr Ln Q 'o (m ? t• X000 00 O r z D o IT ) W VCD t• E. z O O . cn CD V) Ca z V] V! o V) O Ln C7 a V W L/7 ) Q ° O [V O O o cn 0 t r- +1 N O a •o a v a. a >_. v ... ? y U .: r ? te A U3 D a . .a y 4 V V Ul ia. A, C C?' ... C? Cs; C1? W ti. 'C O M a U k iy% - 1 - ' 4 x V3 wl z wl ?. 00 N oo fn 00 IT 00 N z 00 . %0 7 00 n co 00 co. tT co O O? -- O+ i 1, t S . . 1 r . ? ? Id CJ ? ti R.' CG 'O r. 0 ' C Q ¢ Q " K vJ Q (D O N -0 Q L. O cd Q O ed a QQ O „ 4„ d • ?' 6 W O G; ca Ca " U 4 v p 0 ? n ? .x ? 4) .. td to m O m ?". O C 0 a rd C03 Q M 47 c.. Q d j , Q m (L) to I ?'. m a) W Lam. e? (% H ?1..r r y W 43 Q ap4 O CD x n"CL) 1 ?.^3+ .U.• ^? tw Q 1,.. •b 0 N Q L ..?.. V tQ ?+ 4. C.5 a+ Ix,,. x4. 63 O .O O U y 0 O 0 0 LS [d y y a C 10 .? .= U C03 cCd U a 0 Q Q? +? o .C O h O O O CC ?+ Q O O? ?' e .I '• in O ' 3 Fem. O V . O h (] :3 v ' N ' ,C '(3 Q .Q O O * t a 3 0 U C cu D W es = 'p .. O Iv C A N? .? O a] b O N di O pa min ;ZS ' y 4] 6 .» cd p; £. w i ?G p 0 .. N M ?+ p4 N (a N . w C O d •ar Cu .?.. ..C " Rf C C ? ,C O C ? ' C N 'C H C .C O O ° Id 6. 9 v O Q N O •C3 O r v1 Q •L7 C w O 7 o w O In C + w C c-, ° ? U C 0 0 ? w Q Q z o dQ WA:U o o U '0 ?U ;Z c sd Z al Q c n iA4U n 3° Zm C 4 •as Q CD Q Q Q C)° m Q Cl C), ?? ?O O CD a a ° Q L C) C) c Cl 4Qi Q Q O CO C) Q Q d G? O C M '? m N Q C7 N N O Q Q N m 'O ! 1 C? 1 c7 I 0 Q I O Q F O 4 I O I Q I O O I kD O I CD CD as u1 CO Q O 4 00 O O O Q O cc Q `T O Q CD Q 0% O CD O Q N I I ?? 1 I v ! N ? C 8! d 4 I to I In H" I c0 cD C' r 1 ds = \ N \ _ \ \ om ` O \ N \ C4 \ N ` \ Q i N cli n ! ` 1 ' 0 U 'wr b "T N m CD C7 T Q C CO ch 1 Ch o 00 N co AM N p 00 Cl ?` c° En Z CD zrno z z r ll zo r4 ZQ Z WC) W In In rn N r- r- 00 m N cn 00 Ci 00 Q 0% N N co O O ?t O C ?- O O a L. a x ] (? , a ?? w A a ? n A O ?" A A a w CLPI x .., 04 ... ?, 04 P4 U r? a ;d o ? d • 0 U w C) a, a. a, a a 0 a a a a n`n, w n: ' p: a a R 3 yN 7 `' b? b.. N L0 ?r 7 3 N K1 Q h r 00 0% o C C 0% ON 1 i d N 1 Q .--• RS 1O 67 a ?. "• lr Ln R1 Ei ' pq v L07 ca ca U. y y 43 C p (U C b 0 C-4 i Ci ?, ' i • ?' y ud C A y C4. E! C1 m i u N > G ca i O C a ??+ m a Z , ?_ C , Q N ?. AJ En .. a) IZ Cd vs e %! ° Q 3 a y *) o `" a m a o . w° > q Q C L3 o r n `, i a C 3 q O cis ti... a ., , cis U G , a ?-- O o a o c U 3 y '? w O A q o m ?.. 4. C A ?'-• C) p ?-• v a c U x o .r w Q [ Q 1; L3 'v C C .d . 4 .? U w U . w 'Ls U .. c .' .r ... vi 3 t. d) c° •„ 0 3 css H a ,5 o a?i 3 'y a> c ai o a .mac li. v m w «. . • °' u a? w ri] 0 0 a y C L7 O L. n w C O C v ttii O ?? w ay3 '? o O C C 'O CD c°n ?r a vs W3 a w m Z in 3 V) C 4 V) 3 W° r W N cn C En cl a 0 i _ CD CD C2 C) ch C, V I?0 \ N Q O C) C N CD C) Q \ Q \ d ? Q C ] O \ C7 i Cj b \ Q i N C O O O ) C N N . d N rq ? o O W i.7 \ C d O C) C i d O .., i N i _ O M 5 N N v i N p t• 1 !? 'Z Q Q N .. Ca C Q C O C) C i Cl N C N O N L b C C) i a ? C3 03 \ NY %p v '0 d C M Cl IT C> Q O L O O M C N C C7 d 00 O O W n n N --• N C Q C) Q C O Ln O v \0 .? i i o °CD `0 c) M ? C O _C7 O `..a° '0G'nNi C5 ?O d ?CQ M 1.0 to ts• of \ \ \ Ch C ' \Q C+ 4 \ d \ ChM \ 0% t" rl ' \ a% M \ CT 'c7' N •--• +? Q Cn _' M .? d? M Rr N N T N \ pi i NO ln'd N C N N 0C%G rgdQ N O V \C? Gr. \ o oC -+ 00C .-+O \p ON 00 © - co ..p n .., Q`1&& .-. L i?CCS " U\+4 \ Ch U]d C4 Cl z? ZC V) C) CD zC ZNNo 2 n dCD z - O _C z 0 . 00 ZN GCC •--? En w ?D M h- N N o0 4n 00 rT N C7 0\ i? er 1O '7 co M e?' CA Y1 m u C7 [] O c ?r c*1 ?O vi vi cD N vi V a 0 rs, r. u as •a V ' y N k A A ¢• LL' a ate' a, a. a, ELL' a a , a.r 1-4 o W V .x U W a a: W x a rx rx {y v a a o, a a a a K 4 a. `" a. 4 a ,, C6 H M ? v ° • h In ?o u.? n r- woo 00 b O ?' '? 1n 'U q '? ry a ' o 4 a o tr o ? p ... fV L M 'cT ti.. 1 no H Z W A NAT 0. ? .C LL v A? ^?V z4 [a.UUU I 1 Q H !? Q C4 aQ U U Z W H vA r~n 7- 0 V i a? h C , C? CC 0 cc C I .?C Gl c'3 C3 C • ! 10 ? C3 'o u C : ", CU 0 sy a vs Q CD > Q m y O> W I 4r ts A I d W r t C Qa C4 = . I C C rt Z7 ..? > C = G CD 0 o >, £ es C C7 o a v m o a Id (? = M Z U 4)0 t) V .a 9: 0 00 0 c.. c o a a a• ,? o N 0 CIS o o OG a ar c) ? a o '-- v '? _ y td tee, V o o W o 'Cf 'Q 'C3 >n U . am fl ?, n .ty a M 'O o y M b fb CS H .^3 y f,' [y r l (ti iI7 ? ! y C7 w C .7 W ".7 w in . _. r3 . 'N ' nm > S tJ .a? 1 v/ ?? L' N .V) u E.1 .y •a 3 M y 3 H C) « a. ? o> . 0p . a o M 0 « o" o 0 « 0 m c 0 0 0 o o rNC:W ZQ ZLn WGGtn ZC7Q] ZUC] V2Im ZAC, r+1M N W O I ++ of -+ - a O C) Q O Q C? p a O P U d O •-• O ` o p ?.. . + 0 \ I O \ Q \ o o p Q C) G o p O •-+ N N C 0 N O Co I C=j O C I C) C Q r- 1 C I C I CD (D C I CD C 1 I CD p -+ r `7 I I O N O Q .. C) i M p ... T In C O 1 C I ? C I O I O N I I O I 000 O I N+ 0 0 ;r NO 14; W C% 0% ON ?` C' I? N N N (N N U N 1 N Cs \ O n p p IO O U "N Q ZO Zo V) Z Z ZO Z Z cnQO /]C C ID %0 Y1 N t- Q N co Ln M CIO ko %0 Q N 00 M y ?t Q? N N N M -? ., ?O C) ?k L. LL4 t a+ a a co: U .: v .4 U. LL. ti a a LL -? C7 ?? C7 L v o 3 0b w Ppt _ c j V w L1., w °. °. a Lo (A (V Y1 Ln IO n 1 + 4n W f gn (7, O V) - + N ? M st I/ 1 *-+ -+ 1 •-+ r -+ -- N N n N N N N '? t V ' L cis ' r a? L .. > ° ?. C1 0 3 L C) . Q o ti pq ° N :3 GQ . . m° - o Q cd A s o co t . C' Ln f o U C1 y aRi ? N x N ? ? L. O G N i M .C o ?+ ¢1 'C1 m di 0 r. 0 "a g3 1. z tu Q ?° c ,? 3 L o o Q1 0 m ? o 0 ca u ca ca O ca O CJ N > 4- L. 06 E r C) N Ln a C: 43 Q] " CL) Cd ? 3 ' ? ' ?' + 4) t.. y .6 .C .) 'O 'y 'L 'L7 .+ a •? ., . ? + ? .Y y .n ?c 4 0 000 000 cts o? oo ?'ey M) o? oo 2° W Loi Ir"'4 sn fs7 'Z W LLB U3 Gq 4? Z 0 V] en fn -M ? z cn A: W ° o • o b _x v ,. ° °o o d0 C6 CO ° o" Ca o CD 0 C7 J6., Q4 ° c7 C3 ° r, O c q CD .._, d a a o •+ N C] O Q Ca 1 C) 1 d _ O q N cq d en a i 3 V] d C} Q C) C ) O O C) ca o Cl "tr N o CDCD cn o O 00 'V' O o °O C3 do CD C:D ° dO O c C5 ° ?G w C] a 00 o CD V (D 00 o .?+ i IL /!1 O %0 iG _ O vs cr1 c , a h o0+ °o ON ? Q 0% nom, a?+ N m ono O a?i a w C clq 00 00 r4 f- rq 00 r4 /- . Q` . CD 00 r 0 0 0 0 d 00 C) 14 V] Z v Z C4 en -T Z v7 O U] < [n Z CD C W Cn a v W t+l O: Q? v N N c*? L. r'i v N ? r. ...1 nl e*1 M ? ? O ? a x x x ?/ x x x x ,? . ? U _r x? w a A ? a ? ? ? A A A ? A d [?] ?+ m S3 .., a. V ? w a `? ` U i1: ?: 0./ CC U GG q: GG q4 0. '° L. ,. n y cD ii. t+ N o0 co' O? *+ O -+ ?• N ?^ M ?n +1 ' tr /' 41 /" + %0 tv '? N r ?' N f V N ? N Nl ? M t t 1 e 1 f 1 t 1 Q (zb w A w ?o Q? 0. O w? WN A? 3 U W ? # Ems.. U U 1 1 Crr Gi• W U W U z W z 0 N + , C L 1 ° 0 y .d Ca 4. (D cl O -X Cl Cd ^ m ,a ,a C C ° O b CA a ar d) ° Qa N •C d 3 > 0 7 a., C4 h 7 ; > ?° ON . am V CS t n G -. A Q ? .o o ?. o o Q o Y C4 > ? ? q W p i a ° 3 ro Lw V v 7 c o o a R• c .4 ° ti w V • a G ? i Q w t.. Co ca C>4w s ?, o c E 0 ?A E ?v c o> :3 ? • "9 a ? W W a.+ C Q? C.r L. ? 6J o u .n Q C ,? w, o L? ?J U V 1, ti tli -' + o m C A L. '" d O O N y i ° •u. tai < ¢ t, . CCd o 4. U Ln ?.. 0 0~ +Dii p V G V GA N ,aid o wQ (U p 0 ++ ` p.c V w O 'n v, H.fl N C °? as 4I 4 oa z U a l C o •d ?, bo L ,3 ° ¢ C: ? a L" ° y 4] x 0 of H C. ' m o ° .C w a i .a cn = o' -oo° p .-: jai l ?y yw 3 Go Cd o o (U c` 'a o o o In a`3 cd o : o •L o o a C o W v z o .-• w o z rx W ':n n Z In Z cn w -? o cn N 3 .r 3 Z A Z cv 3 oq s N C7 0 as o 1. 1 L 1 o o ? o r a, °o 0 0 cn w m r., Q 0 0 oo $ C A o 0 o Q M -¦ Co c;r 000 of R' ?~ C3 O w MCi \ O \ 1 1 ..? \ Q 1 t1'1 Cj ... 1 C) 6% 00 CD 4= C? ?.. &. •G7 f3 I Co 1 0° I o a C d 1 °o 00 ? T N I =ro r m 1 o° I V) co # ? ko %0 Ca co W CD n = + 0 w o w Cl Lrl I z o - N 1 r 4 C7 1 1 61 a ;j . i O 1 .?-? ¢ 1 1 C7 C? rw O a `p = y-Ir - Q A \ all \ vl a] eV \ o0 to 3 \ CA _' o \ Qs N °O Ca \ 00 \ ?7 ?/ o M Wi p 00 \ I OQ C? \ Q% \ 00 E .1 N N N N N o N N 1 11 N C5 DO O N Co \ CA N \ N \ V + M M [? G M C1? o s (N 8 N p I CD z ZC3 z0 z V]C z En Z V]O - N z 14r z Z v ?D M N Vl N CT ?D M C>: -- US ? PO C h C] M C?? C CT n ?D L. N CS C ri •-, -' C3 am .? N r+1 ri ri h ! Y a •o ° ?" J cn ? LO ? to ? H a H w cy .? w - U ] W N A A A A A A A y rA a w ..? • a ?a ..? .a w a a, 04 a. a a a N ' f •? A r 93 ?.I O V X W a. a Cn a ? ? a ? c>r w a N -y N J w u- 'H q° y. 'D +r M oo 0 Ch o y? r+ lV M i+'1 `ct V1 ?O N r- tJ ?' co Q? ??+ I d • 'F { F W A W ^ Q? v W N 7 ? ? ads H°u 1 1 a QW Q.. F G? va ?U W F V] z O a b ?? 00 a L w 0 CIS 0 0 W11 C4 10 C: m > 0 C/3 0 c T: ,C . ° 00 p n CIS ej 3 ?' C `li 0 0 O o 0 ?; to o C4 LA ai -0 0 1 o x a 3 .r '? W ' Q 61 L. 0 o PC ? ' w au w ?' U . c 3 3 00 e, ' m w U CA v C C cu+ O a oMo C +-. ' L y m «+ 41; V a 0 3 op w 3 C y 'c ? w ?' w rn as i ; . v ,? in $ V c o D?«- a t, .0 ? t 3 ? Cap w d) w ° ' o L o ' C (D a C c,, F, o e, o ° r, . ? , ' w p 0 >, U tip ° C t.- o h "O 0 q t,_, O o Q , t- •? C t . z O C , rn Y 3 C 0 Q y cy y.. ... 3 ? , ?.. 'p "I -, o V o ? N q a ?U ? c ?Q O o Via. "a o s d) Lna m +n 3 °O rn a , v 3 t,•ti w '? 3 in o. u, o tis to ? o a P ;v o .o p y y o00 i o a o- ° 07, 3 03 b?? ma ;ts ?¢ a0 0c +n cr C? 0 00 ° ° h + z v Cn Q 0. ° o ° t?s p W 0 aoi o. rn ? to V7 O ^ I a°o z g .? a d Q o (D Q o ?o o ° o o o 0 L. q -- CD o Q ° o CD ? <D C) a O C] CD ?. q O CD (D C] r Q ?j -i. M M M\ O M C 1 M O ?t C7 IN M ?V C7 C) C N E I O - CD c I a Q O CD 00 Q O C . CD CD cm cm a O C) O %D C) CD m C) C) C) C) CD O r4 C) Q+ a C ? O O 0 O C? M _0 1 O O Q O C) O O 1 C7 ? d C p 00 I O? p I Z ` 'L `C I ?O I Z.rN \ ?p %0 C7 i tn C7 ?p p \ \ O O M \ 00 04 rq C ` \ N N \ 0 0 N 0 0 N 0 o N O O z _ N 00 \ N 00 N \ 00 N 00 N N O e0 _ .. N \ U N " N ._ \ 1\ O O iz-:, ON N ? N \ ? _ M C? N -? N O ui p z z N s/] N ri7 N v) M v 0 Va N V) m Z M [i] M V? CD CD z c C1 z vl L .-. v? rr C] 00 M er ,,; M C7 00 n a, --? 00 M a 00 V'1 n u --. v1 N N 00 0o O O Q - •--+ N LA 0.47 .? O ? n D ] ?.1 O Ow C7 \ n. ' u U w c: a En En w CA ? V) a a. c, a, r=. n, a a a, a, a, 'v o u c U k 06 N tn o W, loo V) 0 h ! y? t'? M ^ a1 Tr {v1 Nom ?^ w N N ! (J1 0% CD N ?? . .. E'4 t rt' r' 't r W A O QON p., a ?1 v W N A? ^ U az# 02 F.UU i I Q W o Q O w< UV z z 0 ? l V V O CD V d ' Ccl 4] y ,0 O N O fl lu d i C N 0 6f ? > 3 co y Ln 0 ? c > N > w4 cn ? r •> > co 0 a; 0 cu C4 0 C Q 'o r- '" ,; C ) 0 > p ,:/ s.. Iii r- a w 11 ??. b '[] a .? t» C,. v} co " ?- 0 a. .r ti 0 tw z o a ' a as b i M p. W C. . uQ 0'0 ?W o ?d o rovi o ?.. o °?.. vcn I.. o 3 v M 3 a? .? .N a r c`? w a 3 a? 0 a 0 o H y 0 > cu O- a W 0" a w 0 cts 0 0 0 0 cn Q, 0 v? Q z !n C M Z L n o V] 0 it U W co z .-• 0 z cu a z ry O 3 -- Q I O z 1 N I .. .? O O O O O O Ca O ? O z M p O O Q C O P. C> CD C r N • O C> Q O 0 0 N O C3 *' Q N 0 ?p en 00 O I O oo O Q t/? 0 0 O O Oj O ?8 C O M C7 O O O ~ Q N m Q Q .-r \ \\ .a. 0 0 0 0 O C3 Co C N .Q I N O r I Q C) I 00 1 ?„ •q ?• •--? Ca ago 10 I O ° O O cn a% CM CD ? ' °o 0 v a C) o o CD c° > 'n O c tn kc °o O p„I v Ln Ov ? o L. O N? cc OC o QQMc)? O N Cl .a, 6a Y 1 O ti ? y.1 O Ln I `G O C] O O V'1 O Q? in tn \ ) O 4 - ) \ \ \ Z1 S \ pr N Qi Oj - t/'1 c 5 all r7V o a, ? ry N ? \ O N \ N N • G V N \O Mt*ZQ ~ t0 ?yN ,.. M 1 a,ao?a,O ? N\NN 1 .. C>4 O \.-, 00 \ -, CD cn NO Z 06 4 V)Q Ca OG c -+ "•Q V] O Or- vno_on z t/? O -+ O --? -» M z Cs •, z .... z O z Cn n cn d m ?n it) r r Cl v7 O? CP% N O V: -+ N O N U C N O I•••1 -? ? V1 +n •--? C C1 • •T C7 a o ° ' V T n u •? N r7 ?. w as pr W 11. cw (/} a. W Cl. fn A.. Cn Qy Cn Qti In V) ?w En Ar Q-i QT a Q+ Q. ?v a Q+ Gr Pk a o 1'4 0 0 d L -4 P-4 'C! O ' .r. ? W r . y N U Vv P+ IS. 0. O?? ?i per. Ri Qi Cl. h t '? N 'U ? fin M 'In ? Zr ' `y r N r '0 r r• o N N .H Q , w? ?o ry r as' r? J co .?I a? ."1 O ^I iH ?y i f i 1 Z A W N A M ((a• UU U 1 I C4 Qh 0 C4 aQ • ? w U a z? w z 0 U r 1 • 1 N 4w O [? r r L c ?J y C a o m 03 w v C -0 i Q cl C 70 C3 V C 0 0 C C L C 'C ?C C e.r.. O " Q ' .a Q _ co V) > O L A 3 O n OG I G n r • C y R! C vs C 6. L G) C L L E O O O U .7 L e+r O CU aLi T ''r c`?}C3. L 4 ? C ° u toNU cud O x U O p R+ O 4. [ 'L7 t.. 3 O p u 0 .? ° C y y Z y O M y r N= O - C O 3 d w cl 0 3 o aci a? 0 3 3 as 0 - w 3 C a? °> > U w V2 w c z ° 0 p CU ?^ aC U .C w .° ,c as d o a ? o p a G C b O O c O . - d ? o a (- Z cti a o n i N co Z h cn N C Z cd Z a oo va rn C j ¢ i W L? f s. crJ ! A o s a C Cl ? c c r oo Co N Q © O 0 N 0 d o C7 a ° C-0 o C) L Q co ?o D a O oa o a o o c o• a o o r o N C b d I r 1 a ra O N H 1 vb 1 V I c d lt '?T M a I ' N M 1 of f Q O "tr C a rf . 00 o C) N ? a O r N , h b a , a I nt I of r d C o . -1 C o C o 0 00 0000 C d a d N I -? Q. , C n O Q C] C c q , d o O 0 O o a n O% +n o ° C a ai a 1 1 ^ co c 1 , I 1 1 ' i Ow a N c e as o a ° C ? ` , r v r,4 r4 rq eq 0 0 V NC -' QN NQ OtnC14 ? Nd a N co o Z° Zo craa o c cr,"'RT CO cn vi _ v? ?W) Z _, cr?n M %,O 00 O? ti0 M 00 N %o O ON m N In 00 M N v V Q ?f +r1 M N Oi N V 1 N ?7 Q+ cat' .- •., m I c, ? N i x w a. a a. c' a a a a a a a a a c, a a a, a te CL ?a ? to K cV x V w a, al a, a. a a, a a. CL n.. N N M b N W) .a ?o .y 'b 00 '? a N 'y y Z' rd a- 7 t• g rZr r~ n Y n + n o 00 -» N 00 N 1n 00 M 00 i ^^N V v ? w y 6d 4) Q) loo C* c N 0 . N 00 c GO? GU7 .?.. O 1 td Cd :3 .fl 0 .0 w L. i7 a a o p Q ) C93 a °? cv a? Ln w A C a 0 w a V Qw a4 v g? a m ° cli w 0 o. <U I ' 1 C5 ai !?] L. 6} O ?d o vQ r N O U t., O 43 C) C V as > ... a .r m Cc a e., m x .4. M C ?, G a ? o a W 4) L. O 0 a, O ? W a a n? v l C/3 0 0 a c o ? pq c V o ?''v' O 4 cn C] I ' . a O O O a , u Q c d E o ?c .. 4. p O c0 4. 'O . O 4. O U f~ O O N .+ ? 1y ?, O + N t. N ,p 4) O [3 ?' O O O Q1 H n u u U ` vW? .rw a.+ .1; 6"? Ln . a m H co 3 V LA in y ai V) W b V ?+ 3 ? b [C w o a p .O O v ?:' °' ?='•p ur 3 a y a y1 wig V a m 0.o Coo :3 0a4) n in? o°> 0QQ > o5 oc oc oc i cc ao k1 Lx1 V) L? W N Z N Q Z --? W¢ to Z -- V) m Z m cn 1l t- tef O a G O 1 C? 1 4 I N A O O Q r- C) C) Q C) CD CD n n C) C p C) N NQ O N n C) w CD - O ~ C) w W n n O = ..., Q O C7 n O b n N a a nl o CD "Rr I %0 CD C) .-, .. .„ n r 00 CD u d n O? n Q r-- CD N CD I "Cr a) ? N Y [n n Q G C, O CJ IT -r O n N [] O CD Q _ %a Q C) C C> n a'j ^" C3 Q \ O 00 n C %0 1 .dr 1 I ?p r N ?D C? ?p VA N 1, N t0 d ?p CU n a% V \ e 1 CD py w a' o o t'V "- N _ z N \ N QQi N ON N Q t N 00 N Q 00 N G ?O o I Ql? n Q ? Nn N O m ?N ON ^ -? n \ta Ca ROCS Q Y:) ,.. C) Zc 00 Z Z En , Z w V) .... w Z ZLn eq C/3 CD N V]O N VJOQ w [n o y+ t- MI t- .-+ ?D t- CK 00 Ln C tin 00 n C% O N M CD ti t- ko . 'CI y1 C7. '? ? 1? D lea ` \ \ \ 8 H x A a w V) Flo w to CA In t4 a d ] o a a v N 04 a ?x a'' a. 47w a a a a 4]. cn 0. C6 ri zr Cd U3 -1- -41 CD in l as -w ,!+ yy V+ ?o r~ 00 V• Q% n m N c Q to 00 00 00 co 00 00 Q? Cr 0• 0• 0• cu E" u p .G O Q a ? L+ v W N A r+'+ U p ] as HODU Q w ?a - o? 0. Q U u u z w z O U w ? =? ° ? U 'C3 •o C7 00 03 a •r , O C'J U u ? ' p '? G ° •? rx .O 0 a ° .a 6. a A c3 U a te ' = •v ° a 0- ? o a W CZ ? ? to Q •? ° Q: U C) as u, C v1 ° C ° Q cj s~ ° O ai O q p tA c,., 0 o 0 0 t- r Q ` is ww 3 a? ?-- ?, o a? 3 ° .a?1 CU ° ° o .. en en V7 vi 4n cz O° Q •; O C O Q S" 0,,o O O Q Q Q O cn C?l 4 (n C1 qt O O C) V] R; W 0 . V] 0 vi V) 00 Z in V] h N C Z c7 - r Z c0 +n ? C7 a D r ; v t r+ N CD a O O c C a Q O a 4 G N p d Q v'1 a 00 .•• 01 a O O r4 C:) t+'1 CD C) w \ p \ O O \. O I \ O p \ O \ 0 Cl I O 4 \ O+ p 0 I a N Zo \ O C a.r .4 N N i ! N O CD C) tn 00 Oripd . N \ C) C) •N M C) O N p i CD cm a a\ C Q O + CD co C3 C> tt) N C) U O tf? vi a s O c O C3 O ,r, 00 r? tn0000d00 a A. o '^ o C) E.., t °` o o ao a W r o\0 %0N....-• + O o a ?D + I , I c0 , c0 p , %0 Q o o " C7 O N a oa 00 00 a 00 \ to 00 (Is oo C% a% O I C \ v1 ` N tr `O ^• !7r N I 0 N O N N N N. p C14 1 N U cli M M e O 7 d In O? tn O C) L O n O L a 0 • (5 n OO C\ N z V] ? V) a z O O Z Z Cr z V) O En a C10 C:j) O LA m ?0 ?O 00 ?O ?O vz rat a O C: ON -. v1 00 0 00 ? O a O O Q M 00 O ,? N O M 4) a 0 ? 0 V ? U ? 0 4 ?U 40 PA 0 w 0 A `?' N L14 A o . a 0 O ° LL, „ G4 cY a4 U .. 0; U a: ?.. •v o 3 a?i C3 U x w W °' O V a 0 a s 0, q4 a a, N h N 90 r M 00 H a a 7 C% l ., M 1. N Kl H Q- en m ey ?' M v 1 n M T .,., .d M Q? M Q1 N N N N 0 N .••? ... h . .. N C4 + Eq r W W Q? o. C W N Q M' U Ea. u U 1 1 Q O>1 C+ ?W ZU W F- cn z O ! U . 1 r C , C [, O G O b O D O C C r- C Ch nl cvi U cs ovi U C C Ch C .o l cn rn 'n o,a ° ?. o -o C> a? .- d li! '> ... i to ai vs ° ?, y o a rv U L.. C? o C a u ? ?+ m > > ° Ln 0.. O Cl .C 4+ Q 0 0 cn C O V7 'p (1 .aC O O w 0 'I Q e O 3 L 3 qCj O r4 a) c? n ON [?1 v? O O C 00 C T Q x v ? 6f y ° 1 . y a z O t p O Z O i 3 0 Cl. O yb CO t; +.. ? i.. `. ' ti U 4 cy O C , . t- 0 .. O q t? V U . O m tr R! t.. p U 01 m O t.. 0 c a i. , o W O t, O , t..,, LC O O u Q y y, O O W •p '>:t ? y ? 'p ° ` as O .b 't1 0 w ° ca y r d CU O C p cC O y G O vi y C C k1 C y e5 V y p .C O ` = y to O y (7 Cd N 7 ' C X y 4r Yl y C• N .? Vl i '- y b 1 4 . ... m 3 y . 1 . 3 O a o s o c 0 N cs o co V H rs m O c5 'n o p = o * y y is :3 O C) 0 O ° ? O V] W ° v1 z r N0.! W y c -- W J re O r v2 in C a. 0 U -Q O V] N O W C Z CQ Z Z d) n . Z OO C O O N C) O 00 N M 00 N c Itr 1 t- q a a c %n o o. o O q q c N O q v Q yQ„ C d O? O 4 O C j O 00 O d Q I O ° I Q O i d I N O I N ° 1 N ° O? ap O 1 00 ° N as cn \ a O o 0 O o O a - er v1 tT 00 ?O N O N °° ' Y1 in o O o a. v a o ko o C% v N v d t0 ?D tD 1 tD ?D td v? tD 'o % ° Q4 \ \a a? \0 \ a \A-- V • O Cr\ iN rn m rn \ Q? \ O i/1 \ N O N N 1 \ N \ N O \ N \ N \ N N \ N N O O V O \ d N c0 Q 40 q O + Q Oo r O t co O v, O \ ON b \ CS k r. O \ 1 . Z ... ZQ q Z O M Z i t 7 Z D Z° z Z Z n Co o Q D • . v d o {/] V] 0C V]O N q:r N V'1 Y1 ko C) N 17 00 kn N cf e+1 tD u o c 0 o q o O Co v o 0 0 !C 'U. as y 04 W 03 . ? U J 0) ?? Lq W Q Q A A A ? A x ,. a ] a ° w ] ] x a w ? ar ? ? x x ? ? pG a ? ? pG r? c? o o ' U ?e w C7 ? L7 O ? ....? C7 O ? ..a O a U c? V ? ?: !aG U GL? a 0.! ?; c? td C6 h a. N ' N z - ? N zr- •N N H w t? ' c 00 O? O r O N r*? ? T sn , K7 ?" r Oo 7 ... O? .. x N O N N N N N . N N .., N .. N _ N N N ', cb F" W A 0 Q(ON wV w N Q ri 3 W # FQ,0UV I 1 Q EW"' d ? W r ? UU z w N 0 U r •j u ' r .C 'b •LS ' v y b z C `? ..^+ ' C °' c b 3 a 0 m o O a a ti ed ?+ . «. w 'L7 . ? Q Q) C d: a i . ?• .+ .a y q) N 0? O 4) a.) a y > (d W O A O Q m C O C G) > q) y IL) > v C cd > y q) L. O y Cn L. d) C's 04 d) 43 > 'C7 +r U] to wo ?• ?+ irJ C/I p _ • 3 N 3> 7 3< A O ? CLL.) c U Q vi a .G qLj U .C u .? u cd C 3 O E a? ?" a in 6) N 3 cl ... y a O ' c :. Ir O id C's '.^ a) O (L) r' M c C) d) " 47 L u > ?. q N co A W w» b A a ; . v cti u N = 6) 0- U O U A A L. L- o A , y O 1., A . W v A p e« 0. t... 4. Q O t. , In. O . O 3 p O Q Q 4. o c? O 1.., . O .+ U p l.. . O O e.. 4" 4. 4. 1.. p -0 4) W 90 V m ,? .c 3 .? w 3 ,? ,, 3 c w w ? Vr 6.° '. °) ?.O c TJ a'n a0 as M ?C3 00 -' ?. 0 V3 Ln ` . ado °- Q Z `-' Z ai ° cc Z -°a Z? to 3 r ? U07 3 r M W e 3 -° 3 c 0 O O 0 O 0 O 0 O o a a a CI - o C) a ? C> C) N o0 m\ _ O .-. co C> Q r* 1 O O O .. O O M•) O 11 G O .-? Ca \ 4p. O _ o \ a \ v 1 o 1 0 k 1 0 I 0 ? -? 1 r? \ 0 ? 0 a 0, o C' 14 et m 'qr N a Cl CD a N C? cr I en 0 0 v "a en Q o a O (D C) cn M O I 8 I O 1 C 1 00 1 w k N 1 V C1 1 00 1 Q 1 O Q 8 to u as C) 0 0 C? 0 C) 0 CD 00 IT o -. ON -, 00 - -? oo M %0 o 0 C) 0 1() a N r'1 O O O C Op C) ,O ? ? 000 O C° Od •-• °J 1 ?a i ?o 1 ?o 1 a +n1 IL 1 ? k ? 1In I +n 1 ? Irs 1 00 in °i p, a% N C+ N a% N a% N a, (N ON N a% N ON N a% N a% N a+ N a N N C) \C) °i \ p u' \ 00 \ 00 \ 00 \a n \ --• \ h \ N \Ca N I, y \ N \ N \ N \O N Q cn 1 rv rn C) 0 a CD IT CD CD V CD ] m O n z o z U) W W en C] M V] ) U? C cn Cn En UZ w 00 Y1 -? co In 1l O Q <f ?D 1/1 U O "--? Yl O C] C7 O Q O 10 O Ca O o b ? q :D a o c? a a a ad ? '? a4 oG x u rs: n; u; U d • H Q A A LL4 a a. a a V a U c z, a+ w A4 C4 I?G cl? ' u w .d p 'X CU a> Af a U w U V V U V `" U a a, a 124 a . 1 cd ?• ?' cd In ed H m M) N m N cq w "? co rn cd cd w ' N O tr 4. (y t•1 ? to -Ir %O t? 0y0 G1 O N M N N N 4 ? y N N 4 N ? N N N N N N ,. ? Ike r z W Q O Q Q. Qr ? w? W N Q r? W # a ?4.UU I I ? AC Q 0 ? Fr z U Z 0 U r V Y o C W a cd p4 D td d W m O a p 4) cq cd 03 ; 4.. O y Q (U' p w aw+ p (? L I ° 1 «+ O 1 ? ° I (U ° 3 Q I ° 4. ? h a o n in L ) S] p . cu ° vs u cd T CD N .r.. O O p O p p =1 'C3 '? 00 :3 a L v Cl Q 1.. Q x d .• ' o y c? V) -• [/7 ?.. ?.. m > ?•- C ti ?.. C 'd ii c,. 4? N V7 !., O a o p o M VI O a O cd 0 ° ca o Q) ' n a ?, Li ?o q1 '° b °?` m 'b p ; a b C7 04 v1 ? td O cd td to F ... . in 3 rv > 3 4 c? o > o > > dj . > a3 itl O > O > ? O > y C 'L7 G 43 p 'O G G O o b S =3 a ° a C3 Ca o v ? o ?n Q D W? VOJrI 3 taoC3 z lpV c-;- •', 1W o NWM o Vp]f?R1 m C) G) WQm u c WNR] RI ,'? C7 [? m C4 C] C7 C) C) Cl C7 G O M O C L C) C) C) C> Q CD C> C) en O ? N O [V O C Q G C> 4 O O Cl M C) rt1 y 'n C7 a C 6 p %D 00 o CD C) C) to C) L V? o Co C %o 00 k ?O a ° ° Cl C C) G N CD O : p Q a c, ` ° .. ° C r q N p a C C? 10 + CD d) d I cn I I ? h ?o I ° ' ?D In ?n 'n I +n l Aa N N N N N r ((7? M N N N U °O cV 00 M °o N M C) z z z C ) ) CD c o •-r Z ] -- ? %n CD M 0 0 ) n V] V] cn C H %D 00 C% c q, 0% -- N Co en C) -• •-+ 7 CV to N Q N --? d .O 146 C; C C; O cl O 'Is •? a+ U B x U U u U U LL I a c u a 44. U .: ?A x 91, L14 d, ? a a C7 x ? C7 C7 C7 C7 C7 a ? t=, w U L1,' Cd rM u u I? V U u P4 a ? a . aala ? sv ?. +• a as .3 W U w ? V a a U' ? C? ? x ? C7 a , u x a: a; v CSr ?^ 1A p H r I 'N H Ln w " 17" 7' h N l N V 41 a N h 4n n %n n 00 p? Z p ,,.., t l N n ?'' M v M N c^ N M N M N M N M N v N et N v N '? N N W C3 p„ a W N Q rh 3 W # a . U U a? d O3 ? Ate., W UV Z z U SI i W 4) m ?t %0 ca V W r. al C" C? , lti V ca 3 w o cl v] ai td ?q 'a ai d) C7 g a 0? r- al Q w o 14 .c a c a ca °, cc CL) A ;3 > w [ +, IL) 4) C; 1~ a O A, U s e ern . a y p O .0 4+ ai 4 p , > ?: O A Q ; '° O ° '- O ? y O .17 + r ?' a N Cq 4+ ° ?' H N a? 4. CS m O N M 4) N 00 d) 00 Q a a o ~ a i¢ ca a V y a W c o a 43 04 0 a4 a i ,0 - 4A z 4) O C b O i E m I.. W V, es 0 0? p D ?? V 3 a? 0 L- CL. 0 C. " U W x C7 a y O ^COp D M a v 0 Y ' O wa.. N .. V1 a y O V O O O C) y ?ay? x ,g y tia3 a ° 3ro to y? V y " Q? a> •? ? 4) M as :3 a? •y o V ?..ry 3 3 a . .., u 0 ' ?"' W W o cn H . H ra.ww W A, 4.) y > 0 it. ? t „[ ? i t M iA ° ° o fI > ? ?. ° •' > o ° o ° V Q ?+ V1 q 'w %0c ° . ( o G a C p c i /} in v Q wo A i l -. n m Q t Z N Z ro W-? W v 1 ? y h. A C11 fr1 W to z 3 O 0 s r 0 ° I 0 o O c ° O CD M I ° o „ C I %0 . r o °o a 00 °° °o° ° o ? +' I 1 1 ? ? 1 N ! I d 1 C] O 1 ?' y : C5 C] O ° C5 o C4 C m G m 0 0 C7 Q O C , O C CD a c ., ° 5 a 0 0 m ?. u .p j I a o e ' o te 1 a I N ooo n CD r - k o ON cM r+1 ? ° t o 00 ° CD o a o°O0 U j/ M vi vI O ?1 I n N lit %^ vi p n to I A ?1 Ot co Q\ 0 Ch a% 0% 101 00 Cp 0% 'V' Q _ Ch . CD ch C U ~ M V N C] N qT cO V C) N N G ON f1 0 M O NCB 0 00 MC;? O N Q C5 CZ r10 C? N _O p 00 cq Z z °o z C) u) v7 z z. Z oo Z CD ) v] fn z CS V] 0 OR c : ourt0 z o cn LM W a v ILO rii u a o C; C7 Iq Ca c c ri ». cV c , o • 0 ,. , V Aa ?. AC nv n: t? AC ? c? qC o " . u ... IA !! w Q Q 0 x x V i1, .G .T. a a x v V •C1 a q : ; ? aG o? r? U a . rs a: W a a: fL a H N y N 7' vi N_ y vl a [`. 1`? N ? y 1? R h ly %D 00 T" ? ^? C? N CS r. N ?N ? r+1 'vveT?? C VV'?! %?0 r P I I 1 1 f 1 c 1 1 P 1 N c t P! r €.. 'W H W 4 W dCh a? W N Q 1'+`'I U W ? # M ] a, Fuu I 1 w d F- . Q 0 ? a¢ W U U z w .o v r a h 7 _ CIS r. b c N ' C h h y > tU c °O >. O y c7 y O E 3 e w d t i on a+ a' a' 3 . Q? ?. C, C3 Q l) . ?, O c o y y r Q a..I .M , Li O Intl a) c y ° ° di M p y p ,? ?. p y L. • c .1 , s . O e.. ca .? O G C b C3 y W Iar c ? .>7 1 t ? V) 1. h A?C+S C' v (• h r . Cs N O -G O .r 3 ? CU ° ? a,... o` N Cl u ? Z o ? ? 3 A• .r E a ° c o a, a? U c a? ?.-• U M C a 0 vs C's 0 Ca W 4, cl (, L€ N 00 ... c Cs c N w C c H d y O a.• y a C C C C N (U . l c V «+ > w: v ? C CD a.+ 0) ' p 0 (D c W mcn : Z ci z^ zCl c x wV)cn . w Q10V) zd u1 V) a0 qV)d O 1 I w O I G7 LM O W C) 0 m O p O O oo O O p Q C O as - 0 M CO OM C?j O G N O I? O Q 0 --??OC Q O ? C G QOQ ? N p o a C Q O Q O C) O O O a.. O a d O C)0 M o to o C) Co ZO O C) M C? r: I O O o`ov ab O M C) ,? .. \ a OM%pO I C> O O O I O B OO 1 O c, 5 a oo? I O O O 0 0 v, n r-' O N I u N O I in co l, %0 r4 "Cr I O I C:, 0 0 4C, .-. I I In O ON ft OHO V) %0OON - Q??O? 'o C) M N vi' V1 in 1?0 Op ON 611 p co n 0 c 9 C mp?00Q O \ IV d N 1 O 1 sQ In N -+ O %n I Ln to ^ M •c I O O% CD M00 Ln ? I t N I Q M O? M C? N CK. N O N I as CD p C ? alt N M '0 C> N? ?QO N O O O O C?C E NO a O O O N .-. ?. \ 0 N I \ rr C7 OO I j M ?o co U N"gr%0m CQ m000 0 ipb rko ^Mr-OpO ?4T zO Z N C) C) V] 0 0 0 r4 n O rq CD z Z; _ C) C r a Z z O O M M O z O z V) O c V) O O 01 C, co O% IT M M t? L N rn N ?, N I- ^ ^ ?D V N O -+ O 'tt N O O O 4 a a o a ? a0 . ? U • C7 E7 ..y.€ a " W A A A A A A 0 A c ? a ] 0 5 0 5 -d o w M, U W V) Ln cd " 00 fn h 0% ry C> sn cq -.2 K n MT h ,? h r N N N N N N N N N i P? € _¢a p z A W.. 0.•m w" W N Ayye r W E•. O U Q W O? 0. W UV Z W H VI O U • r a y • ' ? O 'n 'Ly 'L7 O ? ? p 47 ? CA ?' ? K C d 0 :3 V3 cs a , r. cd Q y O O " l C O d >« C 72 Do L > > ? w 43 , W c 3 N y > a a/ O Q En y {? N •L• VJ Q L/} L/} C t%7 ¢ C ai a al "C1 1= 0 .. ¢ N 43 o a .,` Qpl .? N t« ttl o rs 'n? O cu •d y °I.°C V) d M m 1 a u? q> °¢ a o c°1a•C U? p C cu p es tj -0+ p; o y Oti O o w O Z> R N as > 0 t o .[ O a ai ° C U C., W a 4. D, C. C - `= Cam. y aai c i O O m t..., «+ t•... Z t." Z t•.a o sr., .K. t... a Z ? l O ol O t O p Z ° " o a O O C) O t.. v 00 u O t- o t- C o r». ? m - a? 0 w o a? 4- a ar C6 QI o 3 y Ln y CA a a p N 4.w N N N N y ?•' N a N t- a N N N ? h N Q7 ? O N Cl ,? Yl N •d ? O w • .. Z d. .C Z , •. N a a a a ° v v 0 o ? 0 L- o a w'o ° CJ 6. ° 3 c° n Q = Z Ln Cl s° ta g Z 3 Z --• z o Z ro e s Z N s 3 c W C: cJ? 2 C5 C? (D C) 0 C= r a ^-? C) Ln M O ID C) co O (ON O 00 a .at o o C) a o o a a c o o ° o & c W \ vi a a N a o o a rn ^^ c O Cl a o a . o O 0 .. w o I o 1 o N. . C? o a a ? O \ ° ° N in a Q o0 O 00 0 -? O 0 CO IL M 0 O 00 O 0o O p • N Op a, te V) M* to % O co tn I wl O o0 l co r . pi \ f 1 1 D' 4 1 1 O 1 1 I 1 Cq a n W tn In Ln N - - - • O N V1 d Cu \ 1 1 , \ O - \ \ \ N \ N \ N O I O I %0 1 N w G4 N O \ N " \ N N O M C N N O N O O O O \ ` \ (O \ 0% . N N N N C V O p C) CD ?r r d O O tn O z Z _ Z Z [ o v? O v i V} V3 cn v7 o z to DO ?o in -- to t) co y M 00 t'+Y 00 O u C O O O o O C Q O G d O Q . 'a N 93 w • >a a. 0 ] C] 0 O NN U 0~ U U ?? 1..• 1'? I? U .// W M a ? • w u y `? Q Q V U V Q• U I7. V QiM • • a w a cu M. P U 0? U U ?•, C<?i w ?w Cy ti U Cx C 0 to ? a .. p .. W M ? U a `? U U a a V C G 4' p a ed ea ev m vs cd cd td 0 Cd a ca cl a y - h h N r, N N N n N VN N 00 N N 0 N 00 1 ?0 00 %0 0% w n r P n r- n n n 0 r- n N N N N N N N N N N N N N . 7 E r-. t ob tool W ? z W r, J ? v w N ?.., V Ede O U I 1 ¢ W 0. .¢ U zV W V) N 0 U N w a ., Q Q? c V a • > 6 r YI V V3 C . y. ¢ VI Q? Fw L t..1 ? ' 1+ rq to O CD cl y Z' N G R G w c O .?. C d .. N DO p b ?- 0 d G a W j p ¢ ? «. O ?• c« V7 ¢ W c.. G O L- V] O VJ G - t... d ,.. N O O .n O d 0 O O ?+ C w O O L a] ¢ L U a? G d p w' J C N y V) CU..' v a tn' ++ ? y ?+ ~? Z w G 1G cG 1 ¢ ' y q C? w G O Ir1 3 as pa 3 O ? A . 3 o ?, O tr. O O U t.. O c., O O O ., O U 'O . O U C t r ,? 0 L. U N y , V cu O 4) O O U ?"' w`O. d GJ N C y t'7 N .0 + N " ? ? N .C O ... O N cu C3 d b Q v a) yr 4. 3= a G 0 Q p .d O O N N O kA N S: N" ~ G O V N L. ° N 'fl L V L 07 N ° O b O 'C N O V N Q w ZN t) CIS c 3 Zz z¢ 1. , 3 E° 3 r w ° 0 C o o r ° o ° O d Q O O rrn O I I O 1 ? N C O O O O Q Q 00 er O Oa y ) C co C o O O O U II O O .-, O M O M O d Q 1 O Q O i C) .--. C a d Q C C C Cj C C C C7 IT ?r 00 mm \ .o C CD t CD O o G v o° a C v O Q d C) d O O a ?., ?, Cs 00 O ° Q N o0 co 00 00 ° i v ON C O O Z Q h M N d C d Q t? ^ Ln N VI N +n N 1n N 'n M 00 Ln N N M I Q t ^ d N Q ?O M O N N N Cq \ C? N w a d U Q 1r'1 I I Ln C, 1 t W) C 1 W) I In Q I 41 I Ln 1 V1 1- tn %0 O7 N 1 V) Q t VI . . t? a \N G \ \O C, 9 - ' O O \ \... \ \ (31 \N C ?1 \C a \ O r: 0 Q C,4 t N C7, 1 ? C' q C 'tr 0% ch O ON % Qt ^ ^ s d \ N pQp ,,.., \ O yy \ O ON M \ ON \ O\ 0 a \ Q \ C \ O Q \ ?' z \ _Q N ..? CD Co Q z Q z V] N V) O v 0 p V] t V) Q V) V7 cq V? Q IN W) O z C0 V] Q (n L" N 00 ?O c Q 0o 00 r-4 V q M a N C*1 N m to %o N M N --' O C O O O O G O O Q O O a s A? Fri u 0? U V Ki ?: V Fir Qi u U 00 0 U4 R' U 0x u V >x CC a u Pd Q+ b o ? to .?' ao v • U 0 U PG w A, U U R, w u 0.' .G .D td cd cc cd y m m m (tl R7 a VI , r N ?. N N 400 N N 00 N 00 Op N Opp N Oq N QJ N ?"' N%Z,- N Nl N 00 0 0 00 0 00 00 00 CT c 0 0 co 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C* 0 0 0 0 0 0 a% N N N N N N N N N N N N N ' I II I I ?I a a °' ti C " a •v cos ai ? •a 'O C a: G W .4. O O 4) cJ > d 'C7 1~ 4] W d wi V2 En > > fz 'a ': d) u CU • co 0 d) -Z cn u d e Q ? O w > d CJ p °? ' 0 0 rr 4? f ... ai O . . " a i rte' U ' F~ (L] se (L) ?, ti-. O ? •.?. 4] A cts tj w Q H O v C.1 u L u ? O En , C; t. 6 O T~ O t- U Q 4. O O . O ?.. 4] •'O A Q N O y o '" Q .e ] 0 E 1 ,? o_ W cts y r C* a 0 (L) O O w v, t.r y tf G) •CI d y 7 3 w w ea 4 7.. .O O . ?. a Q w h a] ` . 'O Q N ed 4s V) cy fl c) C) Z3 o H ' in ur 4s vi s; ti O .O a] O O in sa 4) O ai p i„ O o VS r O C: CC+1° rj° cis° vin o > C3 BCD O > O G cp rn 3 w c, - W m r/] c7 -- - W N w --+ Z N Z d w N V] d rn d 3 n W r- 0 r Q a v O o a c N o ° O o °Q at a' 0 0 0 0 0 0 o v r a CD IT 0 0 L: CQ C) a o tr O O p o 0 o y i a ? a ° o ^' C r w c r p O Co O O O o o O r O a O Cl O r. o r C %0 CD, %.0 %0 %0 % 1-0 C-4 91 `n o i v W C) M 1= M C) M ?..? C) M N {y M C? ry ?O 00 a oo rq O O 160 tiU., CI Ci Cr Cr O n %10 ° O a M ry ... .--O 00 M 04 tp .-. +n n ... ? N I M W" C4 r - .0 N C14 CON N N O N N Qj CI VI. N Q% N ON r4 - N C `+ r- ?. N ?M \n t %n t^ ?N Ln O N \ N ON ?p - G _Q tn .... _M N Let cli r C4 - - C /1 ID N C C CD 3 3 w ZC ° z Z zN Z O z z znr z" z z 2 Q % Z C 0, 7- C) N z Z Z Z Z C? z z V ] O V3 O A LA rn tT r0 N kn I: 00 O y - C? rn m - r• C? to 'a N "i 00 ?G 00 v d , - co 0 O o Ca o o N o .- • o O a • ca. ] Q C) C? x (? O C7 m C7 o ?.4 a a x U U U x x V v V cs •U U n W A p u. ts, V t]. u p a 1 a ? ?- A U I. W U O ?» x Q . J ? ] ? O C'? C7 x {? ? O C? ? C7 tz, d a rx oC oC U u a u tx ... ..? x u U U d •? •v o k V W U O U Ix ? a U CL a U CL a C G w u ?d m cd ed Cd CG «s m 'C1 m s3 ed M N M M 7 N %^ N %0 w r- V) _ 00 Ut O1 W) C- Vi M r V) N 7 H vti M 'R1' VI V9 N ?-• %0 C7% C` CS m of 0% 0 4 0 G C O C] N N N N N N N r+1 M M m m cn M t . H W Z W .•. ?o dQ a, M W N 0 ? aZ# Ea, 0U . V 1 f Q W x? Q a Q ?w U ZU W Fy an z 0 Q! N a ? a •n b O CIS N •d ro b C C C Cj C CS 4) O •f7 m O O cts Q) Q) > Q) a N ' • V •, ./ ?+ • V I ( ?"' 04 Q p d ^?' a rn ti Q) cy > d C3 Q ? ) > m p in V) Q r A ° > ,,, ? c o pq c < o • Q ? .? . y Q a ; Q a 0 V C O u ` G• C L c ?".' t... Q) U ' W 4 u Q3 Q) a L. t+ 1 , •C1 V + V u M u G C yr O O m Q) O C (U v cu a x a. V - LL. U. a v, (D C7 cl ; a Q°q ° C7 C) ,c a v t... .. cn o o s O o .:= o o o Q ' o o a o .c •ci Q 0 C'3 c> m p- Q Qo t.. O Q •f? Q) ?+ •C7 C i y V c) y .?C 1. Q) r '[] ?• Q) ... d v .,? M Vn E ' T7 y in 1.. 83 Lri 'L7 C3 4. >`3 f co O • Q) •d 0 0 ?o Hy a: 3m a c o c and Q) c 3 o s" ..o> fw w ...o m ... ° c o> v, ar L ?+ cu 1/1 ?' V1 a. ? *0 v7 V•1 N ?I'1 Q) ? O ? V'1 3 d H ? 0 c N L+ ? 3 •? ^ N ?'1 "? cl o r o-, o c ?-- o 000 oM rn- C) co f?,-? 3.-.? 3 c ?yC7 e• wN? C O' O O Q f O O -- O Q d O O CD d O O O . Y O d I I MM 1 O_ ' C) C C' / yy ?? F1? d 17 Q Q •? Q C1 Q I w q O O A C M O O O 0 ' d N O Q N Q C O C c) d 0 d .0 0 00 Ln O ON ` CD %0 C) C Ili 0 0 r1 0 0 [ r1 00 M N i 'p et i W cry w 00 ? 00 V f i C O v'f h N G ? %n o L r Q i 1 o to Ln , ' C7 LA p n \ \ IfT kn 00 I p cV N Qt V m Q1 O % C3 N O .-? I Ch = Ln I +! r f?. a Lr)O W'AO V'hC3 N Ln kr% N N ?C O? E f f f C [ N N ° W W° W° W Q W \ ° W W _ v o --, o o\ V t• V Z G Z Z d 00 N N _ Z Z , ?D t` O C) 0 C4 ] C Z? Z Z° z C Ln V) O Or1 EnO In to N 00 h N - ?O ?D Go w O N w1 d %0 - O M N M M u Q o a --? o 0 0 0 0 o .d , ?i. a ? ? ? C7 C7 ? ? O C? C7 C'} o a, 04 r.,/ W ,.,/ r4 U U / W P? U ,., U U c w r U .: CLI LO) .X A A A U. w ?? W ? ? ? U V ? ? ? U ? U V sy, F,;• a i xE p" C? R: R: U U A» C4 U V V ' ax ? V o V ? Y w O a, 0 U iS G U 04 04 U a u 0 m m vs cd m m m m sa f:k S N to vl srr v?, - vI Q "` N N3- ?/ N M N ? N N `y N co a CD M oo CD [?1 Q M M M? M M s*1 et M 1 M M [ M r1 t !"'1 E 1 F t S ? t w o w W CL) T7 O a) a C CI C C3 > Q cy w CL) d o O Q cS 'd Q C O [!7 w o O v >, ' C .; ;; va a.. a.. c di i> (L) ¢ y du d . ' y 7 C 3 ` O w i.. aL.+ y > C ? Pal ca b y y °? Cn 2 Q Q 0 w L. p rL [n ? • Q w F" ++' .-n 61 y r N Q v 4. H r- ' Q d 47 ' '? U • V G CU a f i . .l, Q .O 64 r. a o a 111 p t- N ? . .L•' 0.1 L = •. L a C 6? tw ?+ p 0 0 64 C p • 3 Q cu V2 .C ?.. u Q O r- S .. w O y w 0 N w no > c s q... C) W c.. w, .. e.. i ,'-j U e•., C7 s. ?-' E..i C7 - •> ??+ ¢ LC O s L3 :?. ° .C V, .0. O a+ C N O M O O O O h + (? 0 <V I y C ES "'• t» cis 'G O .•-. y t . w U. Z] ? y •Ly t!) yL C1 cu 43 ,'? y tn C3 w E] n a1 Ca y 7, 0 . G O 7 v! r? w . .? O p y s~ w U . 3 C >~ Q 3 a s p y 3 w 'n ° o Ln Na y a > o`o o . ao o? o•a awrl?CC7 w%0 a Z 3 wZ W ? con o C: cn°-t ca Zm zd r°iA ° c°s V) m • o I ° 1 Ln -? I o 0 ' 0 0 r Q d C G co v ti ' I C ea '? C:) p CD 'Irr ? <D OI p (Z) Q Q rl 'o CD C=) " C] 1 N O C O O rr ?o r-. IL _. d N Ca I N d1 CD ?O ! %O C ! I C] O C5 CS O O o q 0 , ! CI O ti7 O C] 4 CD Cl C7 C, Q ' O N N O C7 N .? q aW-1 N ! O p o I o I m 00 to IT 3 Ln W -T tT Ln Q %C C7 b C) r ? b y Q C, O k U] C3 C r co I o r tr Ln ko c +n Q 4 ^ to kn CD IT kn wl tt W1 V% 00 m rt O wl © 0o N Cd r- co r4 tn r- 00 N F 1 I 1 ? N C° N ° wl o w w ? O I ? a C V I L 1 \ \ ? ? I ?D d ` \ +? ` ` Q Ca Q? ? a V CD C m Ca p moo° n v c l vi N w1 N 7 v_) to N wl N tn N a% rl I a r4 CqO t ` h rn I q C? -4 W An . . ° U r Qoocooa 00 wl r- cq C o ? t-- a r ?° boo 00 C%l ° W ?°o ?o -17 Eno°ono - Eno rn Ln Zoo tn z oooo Z0 Z Z Z C) Zoo en r o n a n o ?c n - -r N o, r11 o r o CV O O 0 -• IT C7 O CD C] C7 LO) a a V a ° ° a U U U V C4 a? . ? U • IA y LL, r~ W a p" U C? wo U U U U ..? C? , .. d L 3 a 0., a C> •k f y _ y y 4 ~ rJ H N 1? VI O y o Q H a N N- N ' N N N N N N N M t+1 C?1 s+1 e+ I t• 1 C+1 M ?n e?1 M r+1 r'1 M z W A r. CD ate' 0. ? ? .o wy W N ? cn ? UU a? 04 O>, a 4 UV z w F4 cn O V 03 G . - TS ° 'b > 0 •Zy ) > ca :3 cu a tq a 4; 4L) CL) > C93 a 'b o C4 r. •a d; a . ?', ? •E ?C '?[ c a y ,o?` •? ¢ be o ? ° y a? ¢ A >?.' A >a d > c? a A d cti O .., v ° ,^ '0 A S ?. > rd O Q y G a 3 ' 12 0 E .° • co in '" ' C wA CI O o A 0 ° C C 44 0 OJ o.3 o O > d) y • ? /?? V • ` 6. bo co N am a ec G ° V L. sj A w L. cu ° ]C p y d a (D .s o C .r 61 ,:5 L. O o G L .. >r CIS 4 o U ' 1 ° L t . o O U r, 'a U U, r n C7 O . C9 M O - ?.. Q 1« O ° ... O ' w u ° o C'n e r ° v V) C!1 O • «+ j y 3 rG Ln '3 -0 ° .G .? d) 0 y 3 o c ?u? n 1.,• w p° H o a 't7 ° °' N a .? a : t) in 3 y° o ; c N ,c • a = .. >r .c 3 ° o •? «. ° m o 3 ,0 .r rl° ?. o ayi o > o` ° ° ? w o 'n w ° o O o 'n N a '^ VN W U¢ ¢ z it z cu rn v QQ zQ o -?. z° W° W v i 3?0 12 r O Cl `e Cl C=; Q CD Q O ON 00%0 a N C, co O a OV' 0001 ., O Q O Cl Q O 1 O d Zo c) 4 0 0 tY1 G N 0 Q C) C) O C) O b ++ C 1 1 k ._. I I CD I O p I O 0 Q 1 1 q a b O ?? O 4 N 00 O O Ch '17 O 1 tq r- Q I N O ^' &0 O 1 y r 1 O • O 4 C7 %.0 t? rn %0 CD O O y' "5 1 CD 4 p 1?0 :: t- N CD 1 O M %lo 1 0 00 e 0r 4 L40 1 C7 M M N N h ?r c Q N Y7 Ln u'1 r Q C= et ? 0% r o O 00 00 00 p. Q Cl Ln 1. M %o M c CN .., IT o Ln %o M a MO 'T C7 O V1OO i y1 , .., 6! a+ V 1 i k I 1 1 I LA ?o _ a I ?cO = 0% , W 1 k L. go 000 0 C_+ C> C) a) fn ?mCD O~' 1 moo ` N N E a N N N N.` rq N to NoC> N O (? ? ?O ADO ? ?d ti°p ?O ? ?Nd ?O C7 V C7 O et ?C3 O ? ? M M N M N Va V?O? C17 , CAG 1G'T 00 ?jj 0 toM O C z z V V) [n VS C/J an ` 00 N M M 00 •-• n ko C9 CD N O co •-• v-1 n ev N N ? o c -- a --? a •--? a ra o 0 Iq a 0 1 0 D cc M w A I-? O A A 4, A A A 0 w a I1?? o ? ] C7 O ] ? C7 O ? a a 0" 0. ?: V a4 V G4 G4 ;b o a U •x C 7 U w a a 0 O U O a A ' ? ? ? G G c? ?., 4 '00 ca In ca o vi 'v°i N w 4n .o M ?, N N - M V - ko ti 00 ..• Q? N N M t"1 M cn M m M t*1 M t*1 M M M r7 M M r•1 r+1 tT M •et r+1 e! rYs t ,. ., f. , y r ?- . . ? i ? , . ' i r ? ? . . 1 3 OV I? p z A W? QON as ° v W ? Q ? U W # duu 1 1 Q ? Q a• W UU z z O V ' C fr r s a O C' Q1 4I ?..I ? ?...II J O ru M 'L 7 Y 1: O co V tSi 43 •t3 DO O G . O > O C q? Mcts ? _ / C cu o •? O •4.1 ° 0 0 1 v) I ..^^ Y J ? ..y > cis • M 1 0 6. f D O C O C C > ?: ¢ ?3 V3 Q .4 d V 'b N Q 3U 3U aCUi? °' .n no c3 `.? wu Aa ?W a' ?c O 'L1 b c+ a 6. a OO0 ,y ° O L) co H ? C 04 ?o ,b O C', ca C C SG O O H U C °A xx u c ev .C . t0 .0 `; a o c1 s 0 0 it, a 4) 0 L. W k y ? ?", t.. v «. +-. W O 0 d W 1 N 0 O C " 11 U (D O C G C . G ° V3 O ' 3 t- to o 4, V] ° ? t . t.. t/1 b ? a 1 W to o vi . (, ... c.. n rq ?, o R, . c . t,.. ,.? o C. ... , w F„ a 2 vi t... O ° a.. y 0 a, a? 0 ° C n . o n p 3 ° in U ?, ., .d G3 0 3 w ` 3 c 'a a i t? m rq ' ° . .a CO "a CD N rq in :1 r0 v w O tlJ C3 O L3 N H rq U cq = y q? O N 3 H .. • C .O ° C N " I ' .tw V? .. d a'=+ w V L1 ?r' C 1+ Q) o 'ta 00 o ' na o ai > t > v im o A C13 o q W'? ° c ? ° c o > x o Ln M !7G t/] .: GC 3 Q 3 . . N Q N Z al W ca V) m . . Z V) Z N N td G? W Q o O V] ?1 n 0 c O O O ° N CD ^ c N C) C> N = G 1 C7 O m O O O 0 rz co v G7 ? ' O G Q - c to Q CS 1 Co r O \ ++ 1 ' 1 N M •-? M O O O O I O 1 C? i O I O 1 Co r.n H 4 N O N I I 1' 00 O M N O O 'tT O 0 G ` 4 Q Q ?A C] 00 4 O O Q 0 N AID N to .d O O N l 00 00 00 M CJ oOQ 10 ^ cn CD Nr 'IT C) v C) n c q C7% 00 v 00 - C d p AIL , ? Qo %D GO r- O t I a o r- t^ as 1 1 \ \ \ " + A h A 1 try o I Ln Q C I . : CD z 01, C?, 16. W O\ O\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ^' O ? r ? .-, N N N ,. N N N N N N p A O N v N U _ N? _ N N / E N- N N N C, CN` V3 z 0 z o z C 3 z n z 0 t/} to O ! C V] &n cq v] O Cl V7 O L 00 Ln O O kA N t? t- to cu rn ?-+ oo N oo [V .. o o to u O C "••? O C 4 C Cl G C -+ O a a a ? k ? ] C7 C7 ? ? ? C5 a C? F U C4 0: U U 0: 0? RS U C4 U a Of ? C3 ? ] W to A u U. u A A E?"r A rs, V d1 w d H U x x u U x x u x v u •w ro 0 ao d , w ? a u a a r4 ed h tt! N M .? N ca N tti 4n I= m h N rn H Cd V) y .>5 y y !ef {? + Rs wl Go CT Q N cn Ln in W1. vA to %0 ? %0. w ? r rn frl m M tM1 r+1 M M M r"1 r +1 n 1 ? r f. N f ` Y V 'C1 V L C w va 4) Q3 y ?, ^ C C3 C C 4 f CI? C-3 C C C •? s. Ci C ¢2 LS Q - as C N C G ' w ? d C o Q O q p ? w Wit!) c ' Qo?i C ¢o x? Go 0 30 z o cp CJ ? <" ? M o -w ? a on o C I ?.C ,a a? ? u o ?o .. > m es w? uo a3 0alt. OL) ?clov 0 U 00 0 d w a GY 'Q y v7 ?. two cy },C N o 0 w 0 w ego t7 . .s 3o o 3csw? 47 d 4 w cl tiC-• b 0 ? N N W > C d1 .+ •+ L' _ N d tr y 2 C!7 N 4. N -6 a 0 X. w ?? ? C S] V 4. y a 0 h In t: Ln p I '13 CIS n ' C , , O N .C O w 'Ly _y z r r [11N z cn W¢ L U s 7C4 W d co Q ICJ C: ' 1 i 'D CC) i 0 a N O %4D M ' m o a N ° v ° Q o CD Q p 0 N V 1 r? 4 a°o CIO Q C:l C) m 0 r1 N o d an N vO ?,n ko oQOO:-: ? 0 0 0 C O Q o O O C7 G7 4 kpQ O M _; 00 00 Q.? O Q o N ? ? d O N ? cn a 0 G n ? QQ o. ?Q ?' y _ c •1 O1 Q% r *1 t Q m ad 1 Q C) ? 0 y ? t?NQ N a rV, V) N N O n O O p C7 ?D C Q !, .. ^, Q %0 •T G] t? - `?' ??0 p0p? rOOOC o 0 ??„ ?k ?r ? tr1 v'i Ut O '? 0 C+ O tn -Kr 0 p Q oo O in O. 0 ?-' OZ 0 v7 _ _ 0% r- v 6 a C_, a`, ?bo C'4NcO*) NaOO Ocon?M4o°?t-"I 1 . N V N NG aQO _ QOQQOCD r-Ln OCl Q41QOi N N N N r. [ N .•-, N 1 , . . Q (D v N 0 C) v c V 3° 3O 3 o yj ocn boo T ??-=o a% °N ?(IF-: r ? n C Ln V) ?T rn0 CAo V)C) VEel ) zO zOO rgC) V2OCD C) CDQ? zOC?C) a N N O+ 00 00 C? o o o ?n o CON Q a a o a s a a a a to a? u u ..; ? , ?a X A A A o A ? ? .. x x b o oc En w M N v v ?.+ ? a U k a. a. it. a U w V3 a. Ln si V c U U ' rl. %0 w %0 C;% r C14 I? M m f j 1 1 f?? ?q z W r. G a Q ? Lat., .. W N °l HUU ? I ??Q/ Lsa .W Q o? a¢ UU z W H U' r % rj V ? rq •[? V v N I.rl 0 Cy ; fa CS M is iP C 7 N V2 " V, ft . .... Cl ] u D C D b > ) ?.. D V) 0 r d C •.+ ca o u ea ? l V) C D C 0 O :: C O C C o 3 v7 a aw .. s d C S O ? n C 3 e 0 e.. `' Q o '? a O h C eoa D t- a O ?„ • ?! o L C"d u > Q > ¢ a > > c.w D U 00 ` O O U D y . r O O ? 4. ? c a L D .?.. N C3 " OS C O fa r •C D CA D y b O ryj u Ga 4. D 4? ea O U a O •t] ,? 3 3 3 ?, 3 o o H ° ?, ti D a? v C ca y y D y D N y D y D ,u m •C1 G1 co 3 C y c7 D 3 r7 D D C C - w C ta: C y ayi 4> D t. 1 D 'w i .C `• t C OLn Ogo > Ot Ga O Q cC'J ^ •?: O O i Cab C C ? z -• Q z ,-- Q n z^ Q V] N Q z Vl lt7 M u ?. Q z COs 602 En V7 to Q o fart ' C7 M I 0 o M Ln I 4 0 0 a o C o Q ° Cl d o o o c5 C I O ?D I O I C I O O %0 N O N ch O C C7 O a O W Q C? Q O 1 a C1 I CD CD CEO O C) N I O k I I I ~ W4 N 1 4 rq M n t?+F ?O ( t O 'r Q C O [r1 `a C) -Tr q v^ J6. as C) %00 r I I 1 I aJ a \ \ \ t • tn C4 a o0 1 ?r o GT CT ON \ \ rq C4 h ° V >r+. 03 O O C O O N 00 00 o o O ] o o O p I a co a co a o ao o U C) r .-. rQ d ovi a coa,r ..00 1 rq r cn cn CI] tq Q ?/) V) o v] rn cn O V7 C7 v En a ZMMC70) a 00 C? ?O o r Z .. -» p --C;) W% Z rn z V3 z Ln H D Oti L? Q ON CT O v1 M N Q In C7 M fit 00 00 a C7 Ca O C O cq C) U O N • L/] O x Cn O 7 Ln O sa D x Ltr ?. _ r C4 tt I .2 G. , uU 93 9A V2 Ln a V) 0 d ? H 6i v 77 +.? H ti ?r U W U 0. x0.' rx Ln a U U ri V) a S ui r kn v t` cis V r~ N ?. 'd ed "G L4) U) as V) '? M n 00 r- 00 M 00 C4, 00 co ' rn t +1 r M t +t s +l M M F f d N cd r- c"+ . G "" y O O tD t to , 7 'ti O cd ? .. O a 0 e cc Co - 44 aJ u :3 ou cd 4L) q • ? •N > .. 6. .2 ?- .> o as a $ >= °' cd ti , ° •? m 3 N q ?. v? .. cn ,a a x ++ V N Q .0 Ir 4a N > to O f". 0 tr. O E to O tz 0 O W y 'a ?'.• N 0 > 4 " En + y? 0 4 [d a] . 1/, w ?..a V v N > V r ? C O w> au > _ O '? Qi v G G 0 < O y 0 . L p 0' V . 0 o p rJA p4 •C C ,,,,• ?1 U O UZ¢ d CM 0W N f.'". y 0 N .t= N u '. U7 td •p .0 . 4+ y '0 v b T'i •'d '? CS .n a+ IL) w a+ CU N r+ 3 N L'. 0 R ??•• ?? G ., ai > L. L- 1 4n as V) a p '*, 0 E p W ? m al p u p> O O O C: O t• > h ed A . W C n1 C'3 u ry Z"s C/2 cl U02 z x Z co z Q 1 Z t a ?, c n? C) C) 40 co C) C) C) ON Q C7 O ? 4? a ? n a N O e h O O G 0 G G 4 CD p +. + « O f t- •-" to rf M , 04 ,, 4 di O (N %n t 4 f M t 4 C. O C) f 4 r p N t) vs, ra % 4 ?i tY? i •er C-4 IKo (N ° m I 4 o qT c Cl , d i 4? cr1 CQo aJ a 4.0 trt tirj a4" [7 N N oo O N rV n d Q 00 0 o ? Q t i aQOnQ?fj 17 N to c o ?c4v tn a ado°oQ fs ?w ?/"? 4 ~ p N 00 4 t0 Q cc IT t^ O o cr! 4 Q W a 4 ? in cc CD 7 h ? I W, ? 4 y1 ?1 tr, n 0 ?.? d v1 0 . w n, r o_o tn n ??..ON^O nN NO ? C ko a? d_ ? ap 4 + % N O , y G + e•7 , O 00 O U W CD C)-tr C71 OON ?CO %0??C>• "<3 W M N d N C] N 0 ? C O ON M 4 O lqT 0 CD "T M ' .z V3 Mt-4rtoCD bwl ZO •+v?4044 V)Q VS... ,UZ En V7 N Z4 y•--. Fy Ca N Va O o-• 0 CD %-0 Q h -?+ O b N Ot q li OrJ CD Cho w 4 0 ?; 4 M ? •cf 4 12 ba Y 10 " V „ay M a W \ = = 1 U4 L ? ? w ] w a a •a a .:' V -N C v a p p- p a ?.•? c4 a V U ? a; a w r a U u4 : V'1 to ?O r?'i t? Lj oo s 0% 0 d Q 0 wl ?I O N tJ eery 0 - 0 00 en ac e+1 00 t*1 00 M 0 cn % m ? m C7+ M % M % . M 'm . w z ? s3 Qv? p. ? w? ^?V [-y 40? HUU r r Q O? G4 Ry W ? a UU z w z 0u _ CD b o ° b w U W m 41 co cl i a .. cu U U E 9L) 0 4) M > > It: e? 6. d) i .. ,; y cn .... 0 CL4 to C" .- Q p C: V* r:. . v 'C7 ' e? L y of 0 Ei Q7 ?. '? Ln m q D d " y cl 0. V? En CL. ctl 0. t cl N W 4i q y t+S (5 ?"' q r O C ?' ' U O O v O r' ' k" Q V O ?,> 0 U ly > L. O L. N Dq !. w > > 4' Ir 1. U > ?td 2 [ Q > Q a C (U ?. Q Q ',? W .M 6. O C7 d) 0 4) =1 Q C .? ?• > Q Z O A (? z w L. = L. v o> V Q U LG ' U b cu L. U k 4y U 'T3 V> s; U >~ C u Ln cc +' Q 12 6 w .D V+a7 .b O U y rC w U ?' w 4? M) 0 d u 3 3 7 'L7 a 3 j p l 3 m L. .d 3 W o t: 2 '- 3 a ?. N C ? ?"' C c .Cy" ?,?'y Wit.. •? C r?'i '? ?? i y ?1y a o a o + . a o > o c ° . + o , a o a c cn Z Z Z LL. r? z Q Z C7 W cc Q Z cc cz Z to w - Z¢ Z cu 02 rd rn CC r a C] a ON O O O r 1 i r O r Q C:j 00 c a °o ° c a ca Co o q O p o A „Z 0% N O • • O O N a O 00 O N N a yr a ° w O c*? Q a C a ? r v^ a C a q p a :. 97 c C] O O Cj O O a p C> a a b r*1 N O a C> C7 or. CDC o00 ° o o C) (D ... .,O ° O ai «t5 r N i p C] t r M %0 n \ N ?o 1= M (N y i N r 0 N r r N r Q r er a s ,, O O ' i o0 y 03 ?/] \ N a O C7 M v m o r+ ti r- In LM M r 1 C> 0% 00 a, O ov ,.y r+ti O o o O a O V 1 . v l +r1 r- Qk o?0 'n N 'V r ?O co en Ln Ca co O M r a0 \b N O N O vl 00 O a C5 O C] •-? W C) N r •-- ?C d + a V a r Q In Q r r k 1 0 r E vl w r r ?r 1 r ?, vl 1 r kl r ?n i L 1o \ r a ?/ 1 N r v1 p N 4 r?s N N N as ON N N N N N' i N N 0 11 14 '-- C> U as 0co co ..,a O Oa C) (D a O CDa aCD a o .. a p ... N r- - N %0 ... -, M .-y a .-. M U] pp z ZCO Za ZO Z Za ZO Z z z0 Za° z w 4 ?o v1 rti ?n t` CON %0 v N N ko rn to LM O ?C7 ^ W) M M N r O 00 N Q C? C; -? -. p O r+'1 O Cl O O a b ? L a c 0 ? ".' ? w o--? fy dry rr nr 1•N ? ?r ?..? ... Frf W ?U e w H a. a w rs, py py Ay a. r+. a a. a a L4 •"" rn rn v? N En rn rn to cn v? rn W IA D L. a a "G Q w? ? hrM ?M w w ?--? W try M Iry Y.y w W ? ? ay a. a, a. . a a, a a ? a a w ay a ?.. a w ay ay a a. ?; a. a, a. a.. V) 'v vl N b vi ?? w • Q) +n b w 'a vi ` r b ' b •cs h d ? ? ? r r-- 1~ r.. i~ ) n t- h ? V) w r- in r- cn 2 1 v. +o t~ o, oo or CT a. a o c M o m a v o +n o %a a r- o M M rn rri r+1 ?? 'v V Q tT - ?} L- I . 'q7 ? m W Q z ?a d v°? W L W N A? d..UV I i Q ? d d cam, d U u z z O U l LA) o y ai ? m a a ro ~ w y ro F al ro r: cl C: C 0 . + s C ] di y A 10 o ?- L4 d a) co Q ? ~ L c/] E as t C? N a; c d y a; 0 G C . C , o r G a3 cu > d Ri «. R «+ m .d ? ??. 1; C%3 qoj U 0) 0) h (n d d m aWi t.. a Q '•1 ; In ; T c... Q'" ro W Q •' w ro C?ca . a''i «?". S o Q i o¢ d `o 0 0 '? ? 4?. o a a w o u ?.. cd a) .. • r, n , .. .? ?. ? U e. , v a m d) 0 . CU 0 . a 03 > 1.. Z C V} C ..' z H ?+ d y 4 a [ Lam. lr Iw y V ro V c.. CU 4.. a V G a 0 Q 40 'a on o '? 0 i ? o c d ar «+ u C 0 ? Pa C H O :b ji as 3 0 ? O 'ri o ... s c' , n 4) 4) N 3 N> a w 3 y ° Z ys+ti yW wU ed;4! 5 C w- .o m "G b 0 y 'rs '? 'L7 b O ro v? 0> O 0 oya v? co Z ld. W N V) d cY, Z co W m (A W rte'- Z m c'n z Q Z GQ cn x 0 O a - 4 I p ° a 1 ° G N C) 1 o Q O O t7 O d 1 O Q Q Q O N O o o Q Q .-. O p r a O N o vO - o r- 4 o Q r^ o o N p 0 0 0 0 ?.y ` v C) rri O D G O o G O Q O O Q C G w ep ' eT t*3 w w f!1 ?+'1 7 Co ti qtr co O ? C O O O G ro 00 O G O # ti O rn ` V o co a N M Q i ' O 0 0 C +n o0 A l a M ? Ln O O O r- C O o C y a? v I v? ' 00 ~ o vn ` cn n I 1 o I 1 4 In I M g Q N C:, a o Ln N Z-1 , ° ° v. c, o+ a, a, rq cq o, r4 cq ° a r.q U O .. a o0o Qo D a "T s O ^ tm L 1-1 qtr Z V) N V} G O Ln O V] V z 7 iI] N Z O CD n C4 Z c ) y c En ++? O? rq ?D r- 00 O ?G N tom! C ko v O I• 0? ,r Q +PI O? ?D 00 O? Q f*7 u C O O N'1 CJ M vi d O N N o a ? ..+ H I?f f? i \ M 1? I.N 1? s ?I I?1 ? pj u R F ? U .-" .; vi K Al A. iL ?? w V] a V} a V) a V] V] En N V] V] cn V) V] ' a. a a, a ri a w w n, a a n ' yes a ? +. i N r1 r? /'1 rti r\ /\ r\ Iti ?1 r\ r1 I1 ? a w r=. n. a. a. a, a a. a a a, U W cn W N V7 cn cn w N u] V] w v1 n a` c% a. a w a ri. a a a ?• ? 'ty N 'n N ro y ro y ro y u y ro VI ro V Ya 'c? a1 ro ? 00 n dt O + '? tV m a .! ! tin Q c0 c`' y 4 n '" y 90 y p? ~ v a is tr • v a a a h• •a' v a 1 ., E- w ,D w ? W-4 wN A A ?U p ? m O I I Q w F- O c 0. W UU z w H V) W O U ev Q3 C C] C Q1 , C h ? tr .hi W O ' d C U IC. (D Q > v O w O VII CU ai m a C y > CO f"' > ?+ Q ¢ (U > ) o V LL. N om. C d U 7 p - «. c ? C y 00 O p d 'C] C «+ •?: W C A C 1'•7 O 4,. N I w V) rG > C O ca m u fJ} +On C y . ?. L > .... O aCi O d C C 0 0 d ? p r d W p ? ?, ? ?? , C Q W> C d 43 " O> 1 ca > p U C ? n U Ln O U d 0 ?+ ¢ O I.., O O w p> r ' .. O a t: i 0 H Ir U? y, y 1 - U C . '° U - w L3 'In w O v a O 3 a> N w Im H U a ? _ CL) . 41 IU . + W r t- a 4 . :, = O m O In C] U . ? ...1 L. d O o ,? a h I.., v a e/I O w L- o L w o a 4) u ,. •., ?y ai 1.. d d 4. d o> L > a 'C h o' Z i 6 V) o 3 C, 3= Q .Z Z¢ ¢ U w 1.0. Z ca to Im Z Q Z A Z I O O Q ^ G o r- o' O O I O I o 4 O O C) C) Q O 47 O C O Q 0' •' [Q?) N y v C) 1 O I C) C7 ... I .. I C) ' O I O 4+ C, v .. O w C G a 00 0 O 000, r O fV N C 0, ? O _ I O m O m I rr _ 0 D O ?+'1 O O O O . .. I O O p [^J d O Q Q h O 00 n Q N I I rv CD C) I o an - o° 00 V1 V) 00 41 co Co ° N 114 Q Q C) O. C) 00 n cc Q v y? W) a [ M N C O Q I rT M M M o ko Ln C7\ 00 O co rn w D In 4n I .? I o`ao I I vy I In I 'n I v i I i +r'? I r .`. n I d 16. as CD C C\ C) O+ O O C1 Ch Ch Q\ ON Ot \ t ao C \ 1? N ^ N N N I N N N N N N C, 000 0% V .? O Q W*b Q (71 In O 4'I O In I/ I O 4'I W) O yy b Y1 O % ' ) y.l C W0 z z4M za z Z zG z z d 0 T C cl 0 6 V) V)Gvi a V) CD LM m N 00 00 00 r M O to 09 N . u a .. o o? o o -, o W o O qtT O • ? p ? .7 o QI ~ U . ? Ln ? a. cn A a, a i a. a.. cz. a c. a p, a a w ? ? a n a w a a V) a V) \ to _ v) te v) a V7 a c . p ., a , a ° d ; . acs o ao a w . .% w U V) V) v? rn N V) h cn f3. LZ.. rs. 0. U R. Q. a . C 'C7 b b b 'C V b v • ,ry, ?.C N h a., IR N 6, N V7 y _ Vl 4 In ,p cn VI p N N N N N e N N N N r V N M r1 Q et Q Q Q Q 'Q , V eT Q Q { ' s. , e f ' .Y ? f }?t 1 d Ez w Ar O Q 7 0. O v ' W N A e+i 04 ".ODU I 1 Q G.1 O? A., Q .? W z? w H O F . i I _r f 1 d d m v' h m ai O = ai w .? iI] C to aCi N to d y am W n? CIS 4; W c C ? x O L v p 7 > Q o ' M'? W L c , Q 0 U •O p G C N C C N . y h Q >1 C p T w Q• dy 6r ,. / W h C '" C C 7 Ci. CCi d) -C ?+ C 0] CG N ?• C v A r O L T , N C7 +? In N N a o L (l} L. a 1... ° 61 a o t. d •h a O 4-: W O .C ?+ v C y ~ c 62 Q3 M t ¢] I... N W h y 3.. v ca L . y C .1 aek .r E-yo ?x r? y? ?.I. ?? r ,.ao Co o a y o O ?O/ N c., .+ v a «. O N O O ++ u L a s. to a ?.. L ° L t) ,? ?, Fc, N u L. U 0 r u, y ? v (D 0 C7 _ N N _ N O L Ln 0 'n ... En ¢ _ ` ? ? 3 S ' N N M d !, 1 Q a O N w w. N cu 43 a 3 0 w t,..,, 3 y A] 3 d p it N ty >+ i / ? a1 RS r_ N y C'3 p cv ' v . e "' .L L r u C 4w C .0 t%] .L .J"'. t' V] tti Ra .i: Rr ? 4, O M f~ O y O O C G O O, c" 0 CD O C O G OO > a C O C , , 0 0 V] c.. p Z p Z t } A Z • . Q V) cl VJ cS (n Q z ej t) m O V) t0 z ..- O C/) Q p Q e0 ? I I t I ? ae o d O r o e 1, o c O o v ° o N - O CD Co o o o W Q A 4 O C) to p o O^ O ? O 0 C' C 'T N C?? in er1 C- O C) M .. N to in o CD C=) 0 p N N O O Q N o O "'? \ O 0 0 d Q? ? O r 4 0 0 0 Q CD „ O 0 0 o N j V .? I O t r^ 00 I O I O I Ot I p O N ^ O C7 to O 'A O co 00 M1 OD f r- d O O d0 L . IT 47 0 in N *0 r- Ol N tn O eT 4 m q I 0 O IT CQ o Q O ?c •o fa o Go Ln 00 Q04 N c 6m ? 4 I I C7 U '1 4 t . 1j t O N to C O N M %n M O O ! ! O 1 1 00 I N im. al r OO N , ? O (31% 13r N Id N j N Q ?Q N?a 4 -'Cr , D N? Np N N M C4 1 p \ \ v \ 00 CD ON \ \ O r-+ _\ v O _\ \ 1 N V ?r'1 ?gT CN ?? ?ONbQ N O Nq N p NN N N N? [J} V]C V!O Ln VjGO V)O-N-?O Z G z D z0 z8, z O z z0 ?c N a o n-I Ln . co V, CD ?. N O v1 O C V'1 Q ' Q Lot ci. p _ 6C OD U A ?? U x a, a» a. o, a, p, c, n. a w w n. .? h to V) e/] W vi V! e/1 0 fir N a r? a., r ?.y r w r ? r ?? i--? r d '4 b O d0 ? FM r 1? r i ? 4. ?/ y k a c. rs. 0. 0. rt. r a ?.? a. ?I a 1N 0. b.l ca.. r o, U W V) c/1 V1 cn V) cn W vi cn t/7 v] to p, 113 O in !.j ` N. o} to N nl W) M V3 M wl 4n r r N y qw _ %0 ` t- ` 00 ` ~ O ` ~ ~ M ~ e"1 e+1 M en M m f" M NT '7 'rT !t rl V Q 'ef "T qT Q I Q qT '* • s . r , r % v) F-- W Q ? Q, a a w L1.1 W N ^ U .r a z ? E¢.UUV t 1 W Q? d 03 o? ' aQ U ZU W E-y Z. U i d N .fl C w C O O N O C y a CJ O 'O O O W a a i in ' 3 a°i C > 4 . n C 0 > ; C > a c a?i ; C? ' ? •C7 > ¢ o o ¢ 6 cl, k. vs 4 ?c O d° O >w c;? - 3 >N ?° > i b 47 C's CIS .O Y + .O t' ' L. C v> 04 C4 ° o as 3 . ce CS 0) 3m o ? cs ? A w c Q o 4.. L. ' C L. a d x d) O C c c i of ,.? tl °_3 s C A a o .. a. o n p >- Q U >+ I4 o •? a •c; w 6. V) y7 w r~ 0 o :+C C L. _ `^r.-r ° , ? e x ?, •° a ° . _ Q; r?. x `.. p •? _ ??+ x `? as r... o ? a 1.,. CL) ° N W d Q) Q Jr w ? a ° 0) B: 3 ° C O ° Cts C ° Uo W E- 3 ti L_ o o L, o o 2 L- a H 19 o v i w .. L O m ° ` C) O ° U O p ° O (7 C/) Q) O L cu U w QA Q) 1.,. o o V Ln ro w C ctl V) .? . fl .n 0 b 3 cp ,a 3 ?. ? L e O W n C 3 4) . w v V C . va d Q) 3 ai ro sn H O N 4) . s •.7 .r 41) N .. d? y 3 c q> v En i d p c C) a C O Q ° O Q O (n 0 p Z Q ko N W CO V) m 110 en .? C's O rn Z .., O r C Z r+7 C Z m C7 C r- cl Ln h W V] v) C O a x 1 °o O 1 °tr i ° Q O C) C) O o a ? ... O N O O n C) r+1 C) - O m O O O O O O C) O \ 0 ~ O o 0.4 a ' a o o Q N N rn N O Q C) O O O CD I M "T 1 3 C7 ~ O 1 O %0 00 N %D co 00 en 1D _ cc C7 C) O C=) C) C) O v %0 C N R %0 M O tD CT CT C% 00 O O C) CD O CD Ca O Cl O Q Olt Q + M b r i O C7 O N I 1 t ? I 1 I , I I 1 I I C? 03 \ O \ \ \ \ Q CT 0% C% \ \ CA C7? Rn m Ch O N N_ N CT C7? N N CT U N N CT N %D N %D n N N N N ? N N ^ O v1 O {n O V) O V) O V) O co O Z Z Z 0 O V) z O Z V) N d • -• CT N N Q kn N 00 cc rn i- O -? N co O tt C7 km tt O C ; .. C; -• - +? Y C7t oQ Ca O O N C O 1? ed Q CIS U .: V2 (n (4 V) tn Ln Ln V) W V) C/3 a. a. a a R, a a a a, 114 U A, G. LT. w 'w v O na a U K C. U .1 C v C C C a _ •? 0. C,. 0. CL 0. 0. 0. Ll, R+ d U W to V) v] cn rn v) v] V) cn ?? v] 124 C6 •v VI Vc -Z v zs a •v •a •a •o Cd .O 'C7 ad? ¦ 3- *- ~ IT kn Q N %0 Iq N ?. .v Vc co Z' v U) O? c% et V1 ;p Ca to N •,9 N Ln N N . , to N s1-1 %n N et to N v ? +n N %0 h " er v tr v c v tt IT v tr IV tr tr a , l r. F . s . 4 • .4 / ? r ? z W A W ? ¢CP% N W N A_M W dUU 1 1 dW W zU z u V1 _ O• 13 G U C b G C N N C o O i w 0 Qi O «. ed V •a O •."+ G w C: C12 > O > G j Q ct, 4. ti+ C o :3 y 4n 4) 3 a ?.? o o ° a s c ?' Act a QV ? A sa E e 1 bA p U r u p U U t., ?. o N. C (} ;, cti tr a? . h 00 c0 • ao h .. cd as a? r .G ca . O c0. ? e., Q ? O ? V tom. Z; C) Q p j V O c R r?' . [ 'C c., ?"• p a C O C G m i a y L Q ?. ar IU 4+ O O y O y G a G 4+ ca O C tI cV a G O co t. C f/Y Ld '? ... r . •0 Q >1 L y +`• x x• 0 a y ?--? N 1? t+ M N 1r / 1 4. C: Q U U o ? .. U [n a. y c.. o o 0 u t- d O c 010 > G C Q O O O cd h . D A '? .. "C7 d N 3 e... 47 N N as v? y N ?.+ ces .+ y? 4 7 d cu Ir .O 'U 3 ' 4' ° b cu 3 ° y °w y ° °' N ;; ° ? ' ? 3 m i • y 44> ca x - . •' c u cd ` ., cu r« w ,!! .? H o a i G • .? x 4 s. > - a; .3 O 5. J 'L ca ?. O 10 O %0 r 0 0 O •L7 O C C M C 00 --? O C O O .SC .. z V] VO] A cn.. - o, m 3 .c . cn r W o W o W Ln -? Q W cn A cn m in 1 CD CD O 0 Q o V cs N o O k-o O O O ?. a O M r O C) Q Q M O C) O w •. O -? pip Cf O v ?., O O O C N 0 Qti p a •cT cV O Q 7 O 1 O O m ! -W 1 CD O 1 N' r O ! V a 00 N O %0 C) 00 "T 00 Ch v C) CD C) N ? vNs ?O W Q O ! rq N N 1 Ch 1 M 1 Q 1 .--, W kn ... .fir ?D ?- ?O W ! O iS' a N N 00 N N O O\ . O Q O co ) _. N p N ?? \ N N \Q^ [V \ U O L C Q O Q O Q N N N O ?_. w U7 Q z c fn z cn o z z z z cn Q rn w L e+-? .--? oo M1 ?D .-+ e*1 00 N M et M 7n to v N ?t er '17' tt N r-: • cw J LO co q o• T n x a cn EEn En O A A A A A `? ci u ;. an U 0. ?: i a0.' Gy4' ?G a ? c ISM C, H m .^ a' U) 7 1n tr oo ON Q .. N M t wl a N Ln In 10 ?D %D f to z tai A ' w r-. ¢? L r w N Q t? ao E.., u u 1 I Q ? a. Q ? w u z? w. H z O u If d Gq 'r7 a? a .??, Q m ro .: 0 E I ?' q Q O c7 1 0 0 C ? Q C N O 9 a 0 + O y o Q W o e,; N ? 3 ? v? U L. ?. O m a p - G u .C Cd C V > O v. Q , Q 00 0 t3 'L w v d 0 y a {j e7` ir d r a o rs O Q d V) 6. m W vVj O rn Q Ir cl u '-? s, u7 u it tj ?.., w .z, Cs o v ors t.. 0 a o a o v a a o I a CD cn o 0 o x o Q o o cn o. cu v . w .C 4 . e , U R1 CA U G CJ W 4] LO) 67 O U Z C) O C 1... U C93 VI Q Cl u 3 ' ° > ° > 0 ? (5 a a cs o `? a o C a= > .y ta: a o w' r m 0 0 N o tV) y y a i .C Z ".2 ice, i V O a O 'O O d C O p-0 O 0 O W O T3 0.l 0 ?I lrl CIJ M a O O ??, d o CA N m Ga }r m M N m r- M N w Z {/) W ca r r W Q zWx M o a o 1 1 ?. cc 0 0 o o ° Q ? o rn o C O a O a C) O C> O O CD N C C C) O C> v t O O O O O C; G O rm o I O "T 01 O Q M N d V 3 G O O a CD 0' O ?o ? v CD O C? p 0 Q+ C) 4 CD m O en p N Cl Q Q C Q C) O co I M O I 1 O C> lu I 1 1 1 ,? CD 10 - in I I N I 1 all \? ? \ cr\ \ \ \N r. ?'. a p" N \ N \ N \ N .-? \Q N . ? y ? \O N \ \ M O \ N \ . N \[? O U ?. O O O 00 O N 0 N m _ O O H CD Z ?n r/] Cl U7 z ° Z cn r!) - N Oh Q m r+r M N N 00 O 0 10 "a Q1 r --? ?Y r- • %O 00 u r? C? o o -? -? 0 0 o M G Q CL V -u U a d W) ... 9 ^ 0- V3 a tn Q . n Mw n W LL. ] W a. w C4 a A\.. A a U a cti c7 ?E w w; w u P- L>~ ... x b a 3 ate, U C. w U ? a V G4 a\. a a ? ?. V a I Ln h N N In 1r+ In n oo ?' in ?? N y H ?lf L 00 +T Q .- N M v v1 r 1v^ 00 ?o v ?o v r tr r v r v r rt r Ir r v r v r tr r v z W A wQ CP% a a N wv wN QM ?UUU I 1 W ?a o? x • ? W U U z z a f, V N N Sri CCI C> L' ?' CL) Ltl ?' 3 ? °j > 3 o o Cd f? ' Q 0 N 3 ,° V ?r 0 w t3 p m c,3 .> ey ?, 4. n ° a, C's 3 .? o cb ,y C: °o oA tz a 4)-m mA aiti ° CA 0 ` A 0 0 l U a C > cat- 3 t- 0z C? m li. c + d p CL) W ea a° v °' 0 't:t i 3 °' a 'y `' c a~i w d a 3 .. 7 ?,3 Z A O V) y 0 0 . '-' w U. CC . V ?"? O • .? 4. y b y t- w L- 0 0 Pp W Q U L. o O ?,. W 67 "a C, 4. ct) in y y D y 0 a) U O Cts 3 00 O N u V) 4? d) 0 O CD Q3'°a poi ;rs No v3 v_ o . ni X 08? N 9s " y O C C > O y?.C C f M 0 in t W W . cu 0-0 &n ?. , v°, in Z ecaG? ? n Z w 3 r L, 3 v°,¢¢ wax 3?a v°, ? b td I CD O Q Q N C) Q I O 1 Q h CJ C) O N O tr o ° CD C4 ° o o n? O o I" a c .1 Q ? h M O tl j p p i 0O o a Q Q` °, °o c o Q a o Oi mkn d Q a oo Q o Q Q Co C) ~a C) ? r- C) C3 C) C) CD CD C= en 00 q. (D u In, ? °.-° C) W ? o _ c y \ a N N olr ` -,00 [??I q N ? 00 O U N O O \ N 00 4 ir] C7 r% Co C) en N N i C) N O O CJ?. O " O Q ctf Cl ." N to O En CtJ Z V, Q C Z in O V) O ? N cn 4 Z O . 00 %0 NO rV M rn co 01 C O 41 ,? C7 a ?n ni n oo C7 ?D ?D N rV u 00 -? Cq r! ri 00 c C3 r+? ... ... rry ? w ° A" .. F H C G Qr I? o o d CS w a. C" q ` t,.4 w w w A A a r?. 4 ? ? ] ? x x x x kft a H a x ? x ? x ? ? w ? H a, V Q M.n 3 CP .. .. C s u LM o U W a a ? U U V ? V ? ? a; c G p: "b n C% o T^ w rn ao !r w ` ko 00 O? N 00 00 ' 00 ` co 00 w 00 ' oQ OQ 00, ?t IT V ?T R V R R i R R R i;'i, +-Y?ill Jl'it `I`''! ... '?l .. ? s, fi .,i:' ??"t??Ht frf'•.Il..le?' r '?,. ,. ? ( r !. _ r J ••, ?f b ?•' ? 1 ,. , ! .•w, s -"/.•fA3 • G I _? u :3 •a ?. O 00 ?9Ly r W ii a I r ' `' yr 93 Lo V4 A , ?• 1, ry?s+..:S; ??. s.'iSrl.... a .. 1. .•r,. n= .. .••4 ?.. 1.? ... ? I '.. E 1 A O O - O er e-I O , O O 0 O 1 Q O O C`I O v O O O N O N 1 I N r•I N 0 A 0 r-1 to .Zr 0 0 0 1 1 1- I, 0 I 1 1 I r-I O 1-1 O rf 0 O O O O A M 1 O O 1 O N m H O H 0 00 N' O O `1. I N 1 0 ? .I A I I 1 d' O O I G1 0 0 O O co d• 0 ?• m O co O - 0 0 0 0 0 ' In to o co 0 0 a o r'I O O 1 to 0 1 A O 0 0 O ?-I O to to i to 0 N O 0 0) l 1 r•I I N ri l 0 I I I to to 1 to G, ko %D W < H H co H r4 at N A O A ' H A 1 1 N 1ri N O 10 1 1 1 0) m 1 a% to 1 0 co A CO ' 0\ G1 N N N -+ N' 6- to - N O N N (V 1 '1 rn O 1O H O 11 1 1 1 O 00 r{ 0) r- W H 00 r- %;r r- ri 0 r-4 o o z O N H r-I O O W Z U] O 7 O rn O El) -w , rn in rn 1 .? 3 4 b 4-) b •r1 3.t •r1 ?-t CJ ? ' c b $ b u H H H H H H H Q', W a a4 P4 a4 QI P4 Q# P. U1 rn W M rn rn rn ? U w w w aw a+ a w a 4J fCS (0 rA •1• M 0 ?c 'd 3'd U H H H H H H H LY. N a w QI AI N P4 Ra (9 rn U) rn N N rn m U) o N a w 04 41 P4 a P4 a H N m "r Ln tD r co Gr 0 H Gti G1 (n G, a, C1 G, G1 GI 0 0 -r ? "Ir a' r to to ? , • E r?ti , I' `. ? ?•' .? a syx .4,` + ErE { l ? a?? r? r v i s i! ! ? { ... c s i i tal ' RII ' { I w _ s I ! ssl I f f f O f If ! I :' Tti: ! ! :? 'T} .. ' I=l=i'ii' 25 i f f Ilk Rios iE3i i} r s rss s : sr { ! ..._..._....?.......... s si ss is t r. ri s Jf , _ _.__....... t ct: } s M { ili j CC ?s it ;' J - { .! iii s}i r J - , Ru rrrr fsr , i i'i ! ! R'',. Jf - rJ y.. r -4ry i ! ! I i f FIGURE 2 ---1 CASE No. CW92-61 (AREAS 254,266,250,904) LEGEND RES WENTLkL MMI) USE COW[ERCLIL PUBEIC/Sj:W-PUBLIC SPECLAL DESIGNATION RR u MUL R/OL cA?o aGOGw D00 P rtital?n?nah irr'T 12uuucr RB RulDUrn" ' R OG I / CL CuMWz=LAL R OS lt=CIIEllYION/ / ON-COMM3MCILL a ON C IrrA rt CY G=r? LLWTM OPZH rrxc R DI R9 u ? R/O/R ? CR COMIMCUL P/Sp Fume xdt-rvrruc ?/? o d u rn /wtr s ?utau.nOrr S Paut a RL o nrrsaL •? ?? >QO ?7i?Gtcst=d CG cx4lpaL INS u+sn=ONU. CItD D?? =r"WpYrnrr RU u ? IU' RFH t?iaDiuY?rctLmsc INDUSTV14 TU UTMM ars/ CDU Dts cts;vstx=sa RLV j w RFII wGy°tnT Fat?un=s ly Llur a as SCAU 1" = 800•• RM uu L 1G CCinpA R "at PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYII r iac . L GRAPHICS PREPARED IfY TIIE OFFICE OF PWLILAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SMITH CIVICS PREPARED USING ![SUIT VERSION 2.1 0 /I . 6 2-- All 393 P/sY FIGURE 2 --2 HIl r/sE? CASE NO. LEGEND RESEDENTULL fill URAL RE ZS-TATY RS Us BURJILN RL K=KNTLLL RU U'?5 N EZLN Los onlIA Rai Wsso?'' RI1 IuLHDnrrtAl. RZSIDZNTLL fiVll T17tT {II.W Ili E I , pl?R? EL=1 I U I t ? I I °? RIJV I CW92--61 (AREAS 14.10.17,251-253.257,301-393) IMD USE It/OL NWI uxr??.iD R/OG m? c'Ior16uL R/0/R ar argil MORT rAcmrr:js • . OVZRLAT RFN 1's'rT rACA.T.m ItFH Carr ?ACILIMS GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PINELIAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING YEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 i /09 . G 3 COWWERCIAL. CN COMW101MAL Nmoullo iloul) CL CCQMW,-,KW CR RACRRZAR CG CODU WDUSTMA,L IL p`MN IG a u m?L PUBLIC/SCIQ-PUBLIC P PIGtb WATIoll R/OS QvRH ? P/SP `0?11C To-YVB1lc L`4s iiisn V otra .I.U ??oirTAraN/ A.A. Lit ok A Er]t` R1! ' R!t L?lj SPECIAL DESIGNATION *IS'EA RAMAGA w . flu CORRID6RON-cuvuzltcLLL ACTTVM SlilLW' kA" P CftD pow?wxrrT lIiDLYZLW'4ltNT * C64 C11M1tAL ausNnla A h h aura k b,, SCALE L" m 800' PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL o t ,_. qz F-L-LLLL i C6 165 P/sp t. YiR KL 11V 372 RS Q av U Rg E R '- its t L 1 L J 1 1 - - nu xV tV 1t E I W IN I K UAtJ FIGURE 2-;-3 CASE NO. CW92-w61 (MWA.S 10,11,105,257,200,372,089) LEG END RESIDENTIAL 1[MD USE COW[ERCIAL PUBLIC/S61Q-PUBLIC SPECLA.L DESIGNATION RR RL= R/OL o Liar iy CN n4 t000 P PRIMMATION ,?. 17[ A=p9tfRYNAtnAt 6 RE R/ar ? c CL uum? w R/OS ici \\\\ m?moROet-coYUntcuL MAATM t t:YN L, ' o1 7t o c RS y? [ R/O/R " ° CH on R ?p y W -rvtutc P/SP `/01 n? CINTER/ xt veR ct x?r ft ol ?t txrt R i x RL RrnnsxtvL w* UESIMnisurn MAcnmra , OVIPJAY CG C01ik9nm antcrut INS wvrmmoruL CRD p MlYa MOT RU v MN lQrruL RFiI MUM rAcc?mra lNDUSTRLkL TU ?'`?AnOM/ CnD acmTRAL c.? evau+am , RLIL u MxDum RnI RR=Oxr vicum'm n > SCALE 1" = 6001 RBI llElW L WIUL IG cW°[trrn RI1 K'=? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYIi vm=g , ? 1 GRAPIIICS PREPARM nY THE OMCE OF JIM S3IrrQ PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, GRAPHICS PREPAM USING Mrr V&RSION 2.1 0 Y?..r i i r st ! I ?t y l Zt L R 302- II 17 " I I u' ? RAGS -` R ?`? i) l l ? 1 1 4 I 1 k/as /?? _nu_ I 1 ? / 1 iS/4G RU 277 \.. _ _ .. l g I R? cc cc ;'??I RY SUS ?/yq. ? ? r RS I' i 45V III TATIq JUL KS SG IC IL CC FIGURE 2-4 CASE NO. CW92-6I (AREAS 3,8,249.255,277,302,459,400) LEG END HESIDENTI.LL RMD USE. COW)URC[AL PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION ltR p R/OL m?yq? jm GN H?rrcuFuw?aon P 1'nASISftA n o N NUPWJGt ? r u // It/OG SID G IL =UL CL LI t p ? ? n/CS 4S ? ? ?? pp?oH-COYYLCLIAL tAT[ YRAL t 4 Ll [ S4 1 Its HOMO," R/0/R 00-m-co mar 'T'L CR r`aircwca=LkIi? P/SP PKff) -ruulrc ?/ ACrD= R[ to hU SECOND Y Iti. "ES'IORlSlAL lDi / • • RRixi1tT rALUXi'[Si • ? 057r3t11Y CG GN L CNIR&L tYAL INS IPiSISTUTiOHAt (. } [QYYpH(t'r ftXDt/L7.GpYItr1T aLSi7t1CT Ilu lull( YI Y rACarnIS 1NpU9TRiJ1I. TU ?TM4HIAnON/ CUB DLSM c3DCr x? BUSINESS RLM ww wmluw KlEI u "r rACIIrrus IL uY? SCALE 1" =600' EtM umilrN?AL IG llnu"MAL GMKRIL [in NKM?A `PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL IiVB vi Y wruu GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PIWEII.AS COUNTY PROPEIi'1'Y AP PRAISEl2. ]IM SKrrH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING ME017 VERSION 2.1 0 ?3 . FIGURE 2 -5 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 224,237,470) LEGEND RESWENTLiL MD= USR CGHUERCLAL PUBIlC/SE1U-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR R/01. ° CN "ickDa ooa P PH MMATIO N r?yYR pL11tALd ?T RFi i TOR R/OG WiTI.W16AL CL tf?nctAL ? R/CS am sri°cY zm ?o QR°N-c0? cur RS c HUKNTUL R/O/R um {wrrl?w GR ui?casiET[pN P/S?' {?rm?jpn-PUtulc P? ?oH Rssln6nTiaL RL Lur Raspar FAUX= CG COUMEKUL ? oruwur C?[Na:.u. INS u+srrrvnax.t CRD Lv1[yuNrPT Minmrcarsnerr D1sTwLT t RU V TU RFH WoRunCUJ= INDU9fBiAI. TU Tay urAnnN/ CRD y M hk RLM RF}I =011T ?ACar= EL F Inou SCALE I" =600' WINEXAL x11 ? Torn . PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYII ?°, ,, C GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PIHELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JUJ SWIM GRAPHICS PREPARED USING XMtT VERSION 2.1 0 r r ? slow .? ?owl -I ?_ Ll !_ 5°92 P,iP I ca I+H4+F 1 3,93 ? ? k 1 65 P. CR 380', FIGURE 2 -6 38 cc 11 41??4 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS it-SS,IOG,uJ7,258,z8?,283,380,381i,38Q,392,393) LEGEND RES IDENTL L IMD USE COKMRRCLU. PUBLIC/SCHI-PUBLIC SPSC[AL DUSIGKATION R8 u R/OL QmCI uuxxmo CN ssuc" wSooa P PxtswNxnorr ?. 4 T 7R?R/Uyl[?1AGR 1 ? RE R R/OG n CL COU R R/OS n P c ? °?`tUY1tYRvul ??? CO? IC 4 ¦ STSTI o r[r KFA. umrm a r n t lllS 7 ? N R5 Rtmmla = R1X[D?i [ L / / x a R CR CdHY?CIAt {Da11 C/ Rt3i1-PtlFiLC ND N SUUURaLm / ? ? ! Or9[CY fSL "CiOU1110 1 ' IHY31 tfY U)JAARY 011CO RL IRXrLMXInUL LAV •?,. O'rKR??Ytttlllnt9 CG acxglr t INS ttt Jrrrmlcs Cl1I1 oiy??Tf Ktaktl¢APi[tC1T RU ? RFH "plum TAfJRRISC muslT31IA1. T[I uram naN/ CllA otYrM ? +uer a1I51SiitR9 Flu RX? xMMAL lIFI1 n?GURT raCrunrr DUrrRUL U. WumrruD SCALE 1" = 000' Rat Rtsm?mu. Q?i? IG C RR V1GH61IMtAt PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYf, ,I., GRAPHICS PREPARED BY TEM OFFICE OF I' MUTAS COUM P110PERTY APPIULSER, 3111 SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING 1I DIT YE1WJON 2.1 0 v :. 4 :a = i = > ` ? R? 1-1 111 ITI :71: t I?H I VI! CC t 'CG .... r - C f' -r' J ?? - Icy R/U8 .N ? •1•? %4rt1l1iP kla5 1,157 0 i I ••-•• .. Ii/U5 T. T 1 i! ! ' I aC ;.CG I I cl; !IlFti?1! h?, a s: i II 11111111111 t 404 K. NU RH PM M31, cc 4 r c 1F CG i ... ! 403 It/09 g/Ug R/ ...... ? Sfi .IIV.. 11V". 1 ...' ! s I x[t- - I RV FIGURE 2 -7 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 1C1,"1,?,16p,170, 17i.36U,201,'?61-.'3137,270 -275,3DB-39t],3DD,4D0--107) LEGEND RESMENTLAL MMD USE CdUMERCIIIL PUBLIC/SELQ-PUMIC SPEC[AL DESIGNATION R15MLIMLL R/OL o ?? CN CUaMERCUL P twmffAnon ;rruawun,tcn lilt R n u v ?.rtaL I R/OG rn CL Ux= R/Oa icr \Wn ao>WOR tt-coscazxr?u RE t ei c rl c r ?`I u R/o/H t` CH W I r Un ? ? t_rnuuc 1'/SP ? trt mi illln' st7C011D1HY %?, Fltl trt rw tui m / rr n L K a l I R RL R[H9prrial. ?I,CItdTtls • . 1tVI CG CC MWERCIAL INS !MMTUTIONAL cm) DCOWHUNrrY LSMT It7DRTFDPYIIff DI6TL1C7 ICY MA • ? t1YRn11T M CILERU l]t.IL 1111 ? RN}1 iniuu nt7lmts INDUSTRIAL TU U171 TUM ItTAnoM/ C111) DIRMICL eDYtNrs? lu.M [p IDIUU ( iNll WGU? ?A4tlnrs lI 1uNmmm t SCAI.f 1" a 000' R14 tin UM I IC GINIMAAL lilt ris VinuL /i P INELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RY1I ? >4>?. C.? [;11APHICS PREPAMI) BY THE OFFICE OF I'INEIJAS COMM PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SMITH GI[AYIIICS PREPAIM USING MHDIT VERSION 2.1 0 J • rr Il 1 1 _ 1 I HJ • .. i!V I I ............... ... ..... .. 1 w42 C." 8/09 ?? 1 R r-• ...:.:::.:.F:::::' cc' ?............ I ?! I r el I r / CUD ??Ll r i : i I f civ• cc'. rd ,,'? ?.. i j I Q _ ?0 r P/ul -T-T CTC ~ VRT7 ...' Hu .L id? 4 F .CS -a{u.. .li ..... ?? •li s f n L`G H' H ?+ t e I t 77 i I' ° + I FIGURE 2 --8 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AnzAS 24,25.168-170,176,288--270,278,279,282-284.345-398,408-•111,474.483) LEGEND RES LDENTLAL WMI) USE COMMERCM PUBLIC/SERI-PUDEIC SPECLIL DESIGNATION RI{ RUKA1D AL VOL amcm u lmb IMCKuwalooa p rFtaxaltrAnon ?... IAA / RALYACE HE ZL 11grA R/OG ? a Cl, mn,i_ ro ? ^i R/pS o c ici/ mioWaY-ca?m?glnalu c ? T ?!l ! c c t! lm . t rN mlu ul its' U R/O/H 0 a? ? OH CH NMc t?CY!-F'UllilC P/sl, % 1 1 IR O B R N S n. k7 T Ri `I 6UMA Y RIC D T RL m?trlbIImTtAL ••KISORT ACIISII6 OTURUY CC CjIAMMi INS L*1 STISJI19HlL CI{? COVU17ry KKURVEAPMENT l RU W? RFb3 Mum rAautus DMU?AL MR.= nb>:/ CDD oc= ntlwu+xta i k RLM "MaNTUL : usmbiux w RF11 ucu"r raqur>zs IL L [m SMY 1" = 000' RN ma?L IC: at ? ? L RI{ aw u l PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYt1 FmIRDIMLL rimy Walt C ? GRAPMCS PREPARED BY TUE OFFICE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY AP IRMSER, JIM SIIITII GRAPHICS PREPARED USING 1dRD1T VERSION ;.l d P g. x - cr. X/03 It/D9 {) i IVY 1I 0+ ' c [0 I'/cfn ilt iJ, c i l r l? ? I ii 11 a t i i cnD ! ...; titj i?i t E tiri i I t: t i ? : lit jt?cff = ?= I ' j c JJtitf ? fl iPk'I:___ l H/ns P/S]' 4122 F1r,,URE 2-9 CASE NO. CW92---61 (AREAS 31,177.1512.202,28:1.200-291,294,295,297,303-309.347,409-413,422,424-426) LEGEND RESMENTIAL YID USE CODUERCIAL PU[31.IC/S91G--PUS[1C SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR ?? ? R/OL CN CG P Pti1=IVlriDK nTS stjevice tz p HMXH x3f4i n K tiCtIDRlTiLL RL`itD ?/ /OC COILIfY1tQAC CI` WIGRLASSON/ R/Q$ 151`Y1i L7U \\?? Sc1N1cm .?t-comumWuL ?.. tt1K1iN9H • WT&Ti DR1a G KZ{F1L IlYIRD RS R/O/R mnp Kar1n CR yAcwAn?oK P/SP unuc to -ruuur MMY ? ixY px1 mu"m wrram4mu. / •? •, Uy1K?,+I7Tr?cttm?a CG crK UL INS [Kf17TTlTSDIUL CRD VWMc T GIDK9IQ?171sKi RU L 1!1CttTtl?1 RF31 MK MUi INDUSTRIAL Tu VTIL III ?Tp3PtlS19M/ CHI) DMTMM Cgh'MAL RLl9D(1L7 , 11 I t RLM >?y ttnr RfII uWatipT ?iclumn IL uImpet&t SCALE v = 800' RM RMM K?+n" Ic: cr mrrxmui R11 w0i ? P INELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVH .W? GRAPHICS PREPARED DY THE OF1r1CE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPEMY A1 1I1IIALSM JIM SWATH CWIUCS PREPARED UMG UED3T VERSION 2,1 O /V. &a tol, Atf ' j ci Is T?IIU '?•" i ! I I --tbu• CD RR CI U' t ? ??? I ? ! I I tc I ; ita? C? A - All al 0 1 M. 12M ' I L i GG-t i a; i ? f'slJ Gr. FIGURE 2 -1D rr a ±u G RT R CC µ ! 1t/US It/09 CASE ND.' CW92`61 (AREAS al,a0a-aafl,314,3a3-3z0,337,33I1,3t7,421-das,d2s-dal) LEGEND. RES IDENTIAL W=D USE COLWERCIAL PUBLIC/SEIG-PUBLIC SPECLALL DESIGNATION RIi INJUL It/OG rnQ?a CN Kiic[u? [DOD o I' r[usmnan n TiArU&e 106 RE M? =FaMAU R/O(; R, ??L CL uii rr ? It/OS o s ie [ ??? % tt rri r c COREDON RS RI ? ?/ R/O/R "' l CI? coulimm n 1'/SP ralu&)l?n-NVt[uc CINM An ?? P D I/nxrin a C Yt[tut7 bl=ND Itl, A `nw DAL •. •. ov5XRUYr•rI?M CC C ,4 "t INS Inb-nTMONA. CItn 0 7 ptDlcr?anrxu+r RU H sTSWL`MAL RFI1 ?oO? r.Cn=M WDV9TRLAL fU ? NI "CUTA11Qn/ ClJ1} pr nuuT amsrss RLM Inv WK UN rum bleu r.cnrnrs IL IJUMIJ w SCA1Y 1" = DUO' REt iarltvw?' IG CI K W RII lFIG [D?? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYA[ NZMDKRILI. VYiiY [ncn C...? GRAPHICS PR EPARED BY TIIE OF'F'ICE OF PINEUAS COUNTY PROPrUTY A1 111ItA1Sk1i, JIM SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARIM USING MERIT VERSION 2.1 a CL' ! c1ru 422 ' C13U •? 7 -7, { .tZW nR _ 'gym : I ra L p V • jtn. F ?? , LIM12. 4.1-111 0111 1 ... '•, ' fi . -• . n -?-?+?al• ; .i.;:=?. ..RBI.. trill WE pg. lb ( I 'm ¦1 . ......... rrli AH ..... ^RII.. ,T ..... Trft _ R f :. ... city .!_•cec 1'= !i! Eli 01??!i? .60 Pil- vff1q1FrJAm !i yt G own XL11 _ ? } i S . is R/OS n R/OG 9C I! L. V'? RPM v 4n27 rr/OG' rfOS I R t 11 / C h!?] R 1?I f ? R ;?r ? ? I r}?j'1 fl FIGURE 2-11 IuL ? lul HU 14-1 R/0S •AT" R/OS CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 32,291,t;flf1-300,303,307-313,319--321,3.17,417,4213,427,•131) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL WDCHD USE COMMERCIAL PUDUC/SEMI--PUBLIC SPECULL DESIGNATION RR RUH&LEXrML R/OL o Wiaa i ? CN N r.11BORHOOD P PUMT MAnG14 ., . ? ?s47vki RlIIUCY 1{S RLIMMMAL ? ? 1{/OC oi CL c i? R/US n i oH-crouK u cn ?o \M0 Y ?u1 t set rr 1 n[ ? w RS L' ? ?U ? J 11/0/11 C1{ Rr.1C 'f8r1-1'irHtic P/SP p t UN 6 OU Ovncl/Rt:.III. 3tUREAMuti ( , IIFJJLM Sxco"An RL Lor •? •. 0v?i mAr wLrrsrre CG c?4iuRA INS rNSMVMNAL CRD unrm me RmLVRwruu+r RU x=va L RF7l y? rACUrrES9 INpU9Z l3IAL TU 7 rbuuTION/ Cd0 CPYT ? ]trMIMS , RLIi LOW L HFTI w YS rxrura IL LLUMV SCALE 1" =000' Ri9[DAMLL 1LR ivu Il; FrorRPwk GQI6VL 13U ?`? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL Tim rxxYnmL GRAPHICS PREPARED UY TILE OFFICE OF PINI;II.AS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, J[3I SHTI•Ii GRAPIUCS PREPARED USING NEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 i ,_ jog?, & 0- ! ................•...........1 ............. HU [%7' I ICU I. Ru ii i ; OG GC y +? FIGURE 2 --12 4 I I I ?..J _ - .•f- itr. i 17 = i ? 4 t•-?R ......F 11:'• scd i' A44 i1 IL K.t?{Viajhl .s: f, t S i I la CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 26-30,nti,99,323,324-330-332°33(1,3311-349-351,43{1,433--439,443,37(3,4114) LEGEND RESEDENTIAL kmD USE COb(HHI2CIAL PU11LiC/MG-•PUBUC SPZCLkL DESSGNKT10N HR HZSMLNTLLL R/Qk tgu b nuc t' Qrsszic?astun rv1u"u?Ati mo n ? ruo ou K !ik? Iv siDR+sut u/oG RZ-M D1Rf LL/ CL L UMVICIAL Ksc,bu norl R f OS aa[NIC/NON-CQKIiXRQA! \?? c ?vDnn ea-rtn umac aa.,tJtu. uvrr© urts.Y tSCACi u Hs nuxu ? fE/O/11 R ISM M CH uaw uN t?` uac?c U P/&P l v u r ? Ke , l - ? ixr 31=ND rr MK AL 9WDICYTLi1 r?L1llT[[9 • ? ?g CG ;ss Ilya t"Tr noNAL CRT) PLYniCT IfSD1N5a0YSi/M ? . MHLAT t %KLLL * Rl1 uv3da v?t? {1F?5 KtnivUM r•CSltrle9 INDUSTRIAL TU ? TuxrATtnK/ C13L d -mer u3rnr+w A 66 RUN LOw MIWJV i ktl11 JIUM rLUZU?ssx 1T, Wu1J-r%*tL ulum SCALY, 1" 000 RN YlLIMUNTItL 1G IYUW RH nmuD>emu PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL ItVki )ts,M"IL rurr lucx GWHICS PREMED BY THE OFFICE OF PINIM ks COW" k'HolinATY Armui$1:R. JI)a 5111TH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING 3[IIDIT VERSION 3.1 D rw 'I. d. L .., III . I i :l --° D ... -nn .`2 ? ICU k •.r.. ...L-. t S I i t ! i at.?.f i"":Fa°RJ a•1????r `fwLt'+ I Li 11 ! v' HU `? ? R • R L`:G._L?.J I Fl/on ? ? I ? j + i ? ? f ; - ..................... 1 fF 1 _.H/ .4$4 1 ! 1-1 : i a0z ......Udg ...... 17 t = II R R/03 It/US R/0S gm WATQR CC ............................. L-1 Rpri FIGURE 2 --13 CASE NO. CW92--61 {AREAS Bi3,90.301,335,33}3,330,340-.16'3.365,350,430,432,437-441,443,470,404) LEGEND RBSMENTIAL 1Ml) USE C01MERCM PUBLIC/SEIG--PUBLIC SPEC LL DMGNATION RR RXEM Mt.LL nul R OE u9sM1N ./ / amcz Wimp oor>rucctal. C"lfz oattOOU P rRCRarvanan t- •a7WRLMACx ...,nu RE ? R/OG L A ® CL O6 Q ? R/OS o c V m\\ @? ON-COWRCUL vra S B > A cnr SU arrt W ts r ? RS suuuKHX R/O/R or•nru/wttla CR ucl=n n P/SP (vwc T ll-FVFUac ??% vr?i URY 31CONn./Rr RL ?Y aYercw. •? •? oruxiTracnm:c CG JM?, [NS nr?rriwmxu CIt1! oWMCT RxnmaO>'rerr hU URBAN RFH YVAA UU ractunsc ITiI3USTRU?L 'r U crranoN/ UTMM CHI) btY Ci 1?usurttsw RI.AI LOW WWI K R}'!I w?.ntrr rataumc 1E Lim= SCALE 1" =000' RN f ulud IG CWIMAL L R[3 R 1C.M TUL luu PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RV11 ml 9m nxT Ftscrl . . GRAPHICS PREPARED IIY TII>': OFFICE OF i'[NE[.1Jl.S COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SHIM GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 f-,V - &q- S I -........ ....... ._ ........................... 'CC v+ R/03 R/os } k. / k/09 1 89 I /HP Al ssi I R iii 113; iIH 111i 1 € i € ? ! i .. ..,i31ii I iifsili :c r. pc Ii! i CG CG ur- Rv 5 -- ? i ? i CC 4 I ... I I I IRU IS-57 .: 1 •'Hv R/oG cc -- 4 €i lets} IL .I I € A A nu - I I I 146 VIM i i? .. RU cr. `? { ? ? 1 € •_ • • , j CC Ii€ 11 VI I } t g° R/O/R r R/OG L FIGURE 2 -14 CASE NO. CW92--61 (AREAS 40,4.7,1139.357-3 00,360-371,44.1-440,455,485} LEGEND RnIDENTIAL 1[=D USE COm1m8cLk. PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR " 82 R/OL ? m k CN o P rim mmatopi inur+Aac ic ? U" . ta w ti mrm ou Aru i T H/OG m c i? MUM 'u it/as nw" / ? coN scm ON-cnl?nCUc tt WrAA aAi a laa c . a o o I 0 CR W P/S1' -I?Trnic ,'m ¢W R5 URUN XU YY1C vL I / /R YCrg"nnoN Y 6 o F RI. W:10°m" •. •. us xr s cc; CxNn" uy 815 dISIRUT1otfAi cm 010MCCT fumlmnoPYaerT HU uukjtLl( u RFU KMIVW r==IF INDUSTRIAL IU tm?iJ?Y°?AnOH/ CBD Drm"WL L9MC nva+ais lum w: Xtmwkd Iil1t cu+sr raCurlAb Q. uwrm SCALE 1,, ? 800, RV um}uy'nu 1G cmi umcAl RB yicy ?f AL Ulem PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL 3tU L raur iuCU L_J GIUPIiIC9 PREPARED DY 7'11H OFFICE OF PINELLA9 COUNTY PROPERTY API'ItAISEA, Jlkl Sl1ITIi GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MEDIT VRRSION 3.1 a f R 11/ns I C I i R 1 111 /'?Y. Co 5 w?tx ? cc o ?Rv Ru CC RL [ )tL , r Nut , 1! 1 1 1 1 kL E I I{ - ;- Li I 14_1%_1 rlm 1 Lt TI a ? I - H H ;a; i P/8P R/OC H/or. CG P/SP CC RY Ws CASE NO. LEGEND RESIDENTIAL RR ? ? RE rn=nt'fr RS Ftxt smuRnAm RL RX; nnmlxt. RU uURWI L RLI?I Law MXDWU R11 3 a'"UL N1b1vKx tAf. RII LUGH IuslnI=LL RVIi swlr wru CW92-61 (AREAS 43-45,361,:362,964,3ff),452,454) UMD USE COMMERCIAL PUBuc/SxW -PUBLIC R/oL 13u M3t RcL0 CN c P rpEaXYATIOK jpL t i L 111p 0D R/OG n CL u n' R/O5 o a/ ? rrL ?an vex R/O/R Nff ;? ? CR COUM CI t nrtii?Me MI-nnur i'/SI' ' " l •• •I ?s?T xcnxnL1 CG CaWW ALFA INS IN6 ntN71DNAL R FRDWM rlcGlTlrJ ENDUSTRIAL TU Vram T10x/ L'ICONT r?CLLL= RPH L, DUST x1 L uurr3D G a °LltILOb7L . SPEC[AL DESIGNATION r " nn1WxG1 1411 \\\\ CURIl1Ln?N-C0M)dX rr.s. vwy.ulY a1x?DHO Y Clio CUUMUNtry NADMILIJI>r1M ALUYWCT * CDD Crrrrnu. DUSLNICM DLIFMC7 4 6, SCALE: I^ = 600' PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL, GRAPHICS FAXPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPY.RTY APPIWSMt, n)l SMITII GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MIT VERSION 2.1 0 41A). 66 FIGURE 2 -15 I I i Ti I 1IW I -1T I I ' i I ?Ir iTT I I 1 ?I J El ? IRE I C VITI ' KL t S HL 14+?H I I I ?R A d RL f3 pU 4S 14 -'T?+-H H v172 i I wia RL Rk COkUERCIAL CN NncUM ro0 CL coat ILAMD C0MMOCSAL CR RKILUTION CG ND? , ' FTGURF 2 -16 INDUSTHLIL IL LWID°sAc 10 'LOWL CASE NO. LEGEND RESMEN•TIAL YUUMLXXTUL RE mmcvr= R5 U'?Py? 1?t'L* MfruL RU URBAN RLZJ Mr DEi A? R1I ? yL Rli Ill sxtiAt avu "W luou CW92-61 (AnUS 41,43,363.463) kf=D USE R/OL R/OG rsso cs e?L R / 0 / R oris°ci?iL •..' R k00RT IFACILMSS Rpm Us<mogr rAcamn RR=OHT 1ACL>lm WATYR PUBLIC/Sim-PUDlic P I• CUWATIDN R/OS RpY?y SYMST1ADN P/SP 1 uUUC )tli-pulluc INS INS MTIQNA.L TU NWORTATICN/ AL SPECIAL DESIGNATION ,,,.,, .ATSn?awNACr affix, 011" all CDIOLRRCIAI. ALenTm rscaNTn `icY %% p COMMUMTTY Worf8•.DI'INT CRD pznyclr * C11D CWn?AL UOU45MI Dtb-mcT A 6, SCAIX 1" = 000' PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL GRAPHICS PREPARED BY 111E OFFICE OF PINELIAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, M SIU'TU GRAPHICS PREPARED USING (EDIT VERSION 23 0 1111 ITI IT] b •Rra? 3V• 11/06 1 t CO i ' i t I ,L Ftp/s? ...ice..! RU ?U R R Li ?__H I I 1 I F Rid ij I f i ? i I ` 1 r/ur It/03 - it, . . ....... . A .. _ ]i R/Os I CO _.. .i IRS. ca ya__ d .... ? IR j U 0 N}?b R/09 -RUH _x B/OS rt- /Sr .'?.. 1 _.._ i FIGURE 2 --17 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 47,I87,180,339,442,448) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL UMD USE COWMERCLAL PUBLIC/SCW-PUBLIC SPECLAL DESIGNATION RR Ru xYf1T1L Rx= R/0L a?rr?ia Lo itn MRCWR6IW`oob P PH'6L?KYlnox . ;rTul[1rIIaL'IA[:r RE SL KNTUL R/OG CL R/OS a acY ?? COCSn /ROR-C01[iQRCLIL ¦A ClakF1L pnv RS RxFNIIftl1L Nxe?D R 0/R amo¢ s?tizz C°"w"""" CR itxCwunan P/gr rvtt7C anti-r06i]C Il ?fIl P ?N/ RL avauanan low / •. •? am"y ??11iIt8 CG a L INS Um nvnoitl,'. CItD D1FMCT "rtmlcviaarlaRr RU UURW RFH 12,30M rya WDUSTRLAL TU m"ry nJN/ MTKU CND n1b'L Cr >s> SutsM , Fuji Ur ? P tl mecum' ?ACUTMS II. uD?usrWAL SCALE L" = 400' RN rx"Mr, la MU RAM= Ril "'? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYIi 1RT WL GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PW1:TI.LAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, TIM SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING 1UEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 ,cy. a r., . ffi LLt a RV ['/? ? f a/oa 419 R/oG Rif is I T Hu PZF ?Mil' 17 _ L FIGURE Z -1 CASE NO. CW92--61 (AREAS 442-340,419.449,450.476) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL 1tMD USE Ct1MUENCLAL PUBLIC/SEIQ-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR RRVRAc°°n= R/UL am?a `mho CN MAX1 laoon P tiaeanaror+ .w ` ri?0wn+xct RE TtrmL p RjOG 'Lm??/ CL ??OcuL R/o5 ?olr-cmuutau a Ic77 Ra s vu Mr l = CH x uu w L jtrt-rvsuic ? u x a RS tr wr R/D/It cv n n r 1c li rrs tf?+ p x1co . r RL X=xlmu, V .•K%r K r ACn=S UCILL CC 3M INS Ixars=onu. CUD cOmmu4 I=xvxwpml rr DirmcIr Q , ItU unyWT"l ItFK M=uu raautrta INDUSTRIAL ? ttnm:Wrrfr°Rr+not+/ GDD CZKrRAL t ?? RLM 'n' x r RF11 SUtT FAM=b FL IKPM SCALE I" = 600' o TIM KZMK = IC tmutlnmaL Ka m-mwvn.Q PI NELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL ItYll rn?t>pWfKlcyL , GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SMITH LLL???JJJ GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MIT VERSION 2.1 O pg. & 9 ml:; RM P/sp R/os Q . I I .' I -d s i 151;7]i f 0i % ?I: I i G4? I I I ': arac G :Ca I Rp f F y} -g A U =Ij f st 4 . Rif Au P/sr p:] P? F-= RV RIOG 1 n/03 CRES T i c LAKE *LTKH - i ? - B/oG A/os Co - R 1 419 I'/9P rl/oc I RA: CG I All Pfr..TIRF. 2-t9 aO l i KtiTI]i M.% CASE NO. CW92-61 (AlcW '115,319-321,343,410) LEG END RESIDENTIAL YIXED USE COkIMRCIAL PI711LIC/SEW-PU LIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR RIOUL NTSaL R/01, on?Cit ult`icnm CN' NiacuUuowj00O P 1 8lQiLR11T1V11 "w rr?vaP1QiaGx ItE , r XICTIAL xx n?? R/oG CL c 4aL R/os q9o ftn' \ti coS;asnORON-cQm x&Ac . MM c a W4=1 HIS M" 1 2 ' 11/0/R Mp%hYu CH aCOKU Ina P/SP =11) u-PUnLxc N ? SEECOMY RL . ti=DLN74L LOr . • . kstd}[T TaClflrlt5 Ovimuv • CC COYYI]ICIat. G"nkL INS IN077UTi01?a1 CItA DLLY(UCT 1i7Wxtx1f3YYxt1T RU u1=1 tKML 1tYI[ ?L> T 14C =NS 1NU119TRiAL Ttj m vulrrantm/ CUR CPNML uuSUrlrss VILTWcT ItL11 r utn vu RFIi ' nM ?4cnmxt 11 liY SCALE I" = 600' RM t?? L [C C&NM aLL ltll W.IMUMUL PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL Itvn ,?,nt,,t rrrY u,M GRAPHICS PICL'PAAEO IIY '1'E1E OFFICE OF PINE[,IJi3 COUNTY PROPEIt'1Y APPRAISER, JIM S11I71i GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 O pg. 'To " . W -!1 pat W ftft 390 m i [c _ IG t I ? i i [c I tt. i ! P/m. 1 1 73 1 1 -11 H! 1.1 IT i R/ns f '•,s ti t t I• ,•• ? i 7 I ,Y .•Y 12/°5 •Y Rr TI r-1 -1 m P` EE _ ... i 5 ?. T ? tug rTysp4elf - - 178 1P91 P/W tz A P/?h 3 V 73 y r? i ? R/06 ? •' 11 41 R11 H/os FIGURE 2-20 CASE NO. CW92-81 (AREAS 34,35,173.170.19 1.416,410) LEGEND RESIAENTIAL MMD USE COWURKMI. PUDLIC/9SII1-PU73LIC SPEML DESIGNATION RR ? H/OL R1 CN C P TA2?tTaTiOM ipatrfaGit ` `te K rs 7V N3 i ? 71 EAR71D p On:Gwn MGM) .. r RE 111=9MUL R/OG o CL CouxuaAL R/OS vi t e ? R R_GO?estL?c>,L u v ?? rn T t atxtscss s c RS Rz=cq? R/0/R P'1%11 A L [ e°u CR Co P/5P (p°TrWMI)IM-I?uc P71n f1MMIM ILL t+ ? vnuL /IUt I MOR OTMAYT T CG °ow? AL INS EN7MI)T1°NAL CRD (MUM NM UDRVMPWM OWMC7 RU a ®oLtLVruL gym M111tuit riCUmLy INUUSTRILL Tu uTRAX n m'0ar?rt°x/ CUD yDUMCT fnta mu L Kr vkcW lx RF11 IL ° L SCALE 1" s 1300' for r1m Muu u y R14 RISM w lG uf°°LfM L lilt ? ?DenuL PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL H1'II WG "MY NIGH / ( ? GFtAPHiCS i'ILEl'AltiG) BY 'fllE: OFFICE OF P1PfE[.IAS COUNTY PROPERTY AP . PRAISER. II?i 5WM ? .-.....-..J GRAPII= PREPARED USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 ,)as,, 7/1 • ' .5 h CA [1 -1 _WU 380 ? k I111lI LL 4+ 111 II IWll li HAS I I I 1 Rv 1 1 1 lu R ! u I Ilr rH+l v •r - -rt kU t ? ?x Ra Ll' j""I k I 1 1 x? MJ ?T- 1,1114 1 i : wV- i f ;k FIR) A P/sr 111 U-1 11M x • t W l i € TT?q ... . ........ im xv u FIGURE 2--21 CASE NO. CW92--•61 (AREAS L2.172.2139.280.281,300,414) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL. Ilil 0 usK CO MERCIA« PUBLIC/SM-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR Rl=lXrUL RVIIAI R/O1. aMmo" 'J, umm cN eau MlAL E' rraarrinox . ,J r uru?sK"" Gnn nu FU m R/OC o C4 cawl' ID It/05 o ir Ae?a [ Mm co?vunall CODUSRCUt t r m atrrxfLU r RS a ? 12/Q/?t Cl? KI? pN p/gE> (?'11tt]C ?tl-EiT1+lJL P 1RY am"R/ upUi A i H><amturrtu RL LOW mLi/+ l . u><Mm lath! 2t9 + anDt1.1Y CG tQK?L axxzwa INS 'x&ff 4noHif. CRD re?ortrnttY ¢mtvswPUxHT Dtstucz * RIMDKNTLLL ItU RF1i sp y riL7SlS:TH INDUSTR IAI CU UTEM 71UN/ CDD otsmcr QDDINAR9 hL UMAN . . Rlaa PI MAL SAW RFEI ?drtT ?,,L?u I ? SCUD L.' _ Saar REUEDOM" FWIDFUN R1t LG Grrr K" 'HD1f uT af' ?` P INELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL "9mvmaL VII R rrxr rrv:rr GRAPHICS PREPARED BY TEIE OFFICE OF PINIMAS COU?M PIIOPEIJTY APPRAISER. JIM SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 O P2. 414 P/AP CG / rye -Tj Rif CG x/oG 14? I 1 E' M' f I , 9 ii E ? i En E< ........?/oz...... PAP i i 173 in/0e i ; '? ? .1 v9p S ,''ttt B/ac t''•• ?? t 1?tt E./u, li/o6 Yxrua HE] I RH I % I i e y U. i u 1G ti P/6P j i 11 I I? ?? 4 I I ? [L 2 P/BP 3 t .. P 8P G '75 •t ?•'St 'i '•?p/s?j I EiU R/p'3 P/SP flu- -TT I F L P/b? t E U 1[U ?=Tjx /A FIGURE --;e? CASE NO. CW92--61 (AREAS 34,35,173,175) LEGEND RESMEMLAL MDIED USE COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SHM-PUBLIC SPECIAL DRSIGNATION RR IIRUR i?L R/01, pmcs LEmum CN NMCILI0? M00p P E8t3LEtYxnt)N `.".' ?_ p1pr.11rlxcE RE ROmIENTuL fM R/OG 'c CL C 1p? 1i/45 ?i ?s i° 011-CawvM&Cut °a Em ? ? 0 k s a r fsu. rri [ oP > P i o s o it nr rs ? L /O/R anic icYi n N CR c P/St, 0 1 Wo Cro Rs o R c/EOrrtn ? a 1 ss Un rXim"T RL *mLlR7xL •? .? o?vttiuYr ? CO 6YN urtu ?' INS INEi7110?IxL CRU DfSMCi (tIIr[i?tlpYtNY ItU UW KILL ItFI! RESORT 7?c0.tr? INDUSTRIAL '1'U UTL= LTIOii/ C©Il p YRAL C7 f3US?N1S6El , 8111 93 XM U FiFfi KWOUs FAMLI w M uy?v?L SCALT 1" = 6QQ' ILM moluY?L INAUyn"L 1G R11 ?`?? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL Itvu [YPR?t?isu.L GRAPIiIC5 PREPARED BY TIlE OI'FICR OF P1NELi.AS COUNTY PROPERTY APPFaA1.S'ER, 7I1( Ssa'1'iI GRAPMCS PREPARED USING 1(EI)C1' VERSION 2.1 d /;g . 73 i i --- LL I .fit?. H . , R?•• :f •an . ell I IT i 4 CG ® i ...I r` © 7. .1 1 RU .. iTl? t = 1 _ R OG H/06 -tt E(7 i ` GItU G? I./sI. RH R/00 ? P/9P RU R/aa 1 -? CG ? ?y?511? I Cn r : i1sr? TTT -I v- +7u-= 166 p/a, LE -1- ti/u a •Hih %5u 1 111114 111 c ?c / Ispo m :::i- A FIGURE 2 -23 CASE No. CW92-61 (AREAS 37,38,1450,179,230,231,202.293,315,316,•tl8,4B1) LEGEND RESIDENTIGL MMD USE C01/HERC[AL PUBLIC/S810-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION Plmm0MAL RR UutuL ?? R/qL arms trwnn C({ COMMIMMAL N:iGUMIUOaa P pRa'IXItYATIaH ..... l?ATEY/DRAINAAE nuty BE Ry? r R/dC m CL ? xri / xcC I;/OS oia am rnws MOH-Co?RCiu. s ? u? n ia eAr u ? sP Its a? tL A ?/ ? ? ItR 4:R UM s _},tnU1c 1'/5[' %% a Nixtr urT vs iuuH a/iirrln a r?t amara H xcclu I lil w tvRrAL .? .? MORT •Ar3U7gc CG GCo> xu Al INS 1H9?rrtUlIOHAL CRD Cpa RZILIU I1PYHNT mcT IIU QYlIAl3ST1AL }Il'At MUIVIA TA aC LNDUSTPIA.L umim'aR7ATi0H/ TRAL CBD my t:T 11gS11[Et5 RLU to? au uL Itlr}I u I9wr nrl?mtu IL uYrru RN un IIyrnAL. [C ti INDUM"L wim uannaxnAL A*6, st:ALE 1° = lion' HIGH "0I1 PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL t[tmV`?,A[. RVII ,FIST MIGH GIL'{1'1{ICS PREPARED DY THE OFFICE OF PINELIA5 COUNTY PROPERTY APPIlA1SER, JIU SMITH GILWHICS PREPARED USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 ? -7y f ,. v'I ? SP .} I r/SPJ? P/SP ' r/Sul R/OG 175 S' Ilk I i? ;I 1 Ii H A R WATER ?- ?Hu ItU i A C (? ti it {ilir. _ -_ I s! ?I ililii R ? qua ............ P/9P S ?\ R/GG CG G ® I G 4P M. G P34 R/OG P/8P CG P/SP { P/9P iU ? V8 VV ? „. k RIM RIG I or, .... R/pG ? ? OC R/U All QL-FVF: NQ ST flu D ? A I[R RA R/DC FIGURE 2 --24 ? CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS I 36,13©,157,160,173,175,100,101,193,215,220-229,232-234) LEGEND RESIDENTiAI. m=D USE COMWERCLAL PUIIiIC/S811I-PUDLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION R HMIDENTUL Wu)' 7'IAL/ R/01 ' LN C6YLikCIAt. P PQYSEWY1nON ...? WATLK Rl HAU ? ?u'rtr ? R Ru1LL , GPi ICL 7 a NncLWUFWQUD ... RE =LDINTLL R/OG ? y ulf' 'L. CL It/OS CRN „ L'TVH \\M4 CORM It H-4?NICLY+lAL XYrATZ p yry yn Lrw= 90 u' i ? v ?/ I ma R CR ?WnUW ) ?rI-ruUlAC P/SI' Fn =o? oDi1Y i KD ^ Its n wu i/O/ o Ot i u . 1 MINI= MST ACnn t1 . . GG chyme INS INWMMONAL CRD Drumm m9vlLO1wm LU* ? ? Mr mlK7uL L?wuLY RFU ur1Uy ?antr[ua IND[WRIAI, Tu estnnN/ CDD DI MTRAL nusursss , RLM L.9W IuDgVY RFB ?alrr tACLLlfII:S 1L mtrt sCAIB S" ? 000' Itm Yw1w uIn m IG iKn lilt wcu rNTUr PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVII C GRAPHICS PK EPARED DY THE OFFICE: OF PMELLAS COUNTY PROPFUt'TY APPRAISER, JIU SHITII GRAPIUCS PUPARED USING MEW VERSION 2.1 O ?CJ r I I i ' u V V 4 AT 11 R RF1 RI1 TIT- All 14 I` 42CG ? v i 'R?UC? Rll 1 L 1 I RV I I ti t ? P/5p ti P/sl' I Y. A R 7[2H ftU J t u" fH r- R ?_ U RC "LQ R F?1F---S FT-i M - -i 11h?s 41 xf At'R>z RY CASE NO. CW92-61 (AURAS 129,136,148,I63,2 41,242) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL 1=D USE COHYSRCIAL PUBLIC/SF!W-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR u&4TtAL R 11/0L Fzrn"u/,, CN rCOUWMZC%AL OLU001) IJ P I'XK MAnaN / v"rLwYrILINA13 RE ? i m R/OG f n L ' CL ? mm'c" R/US nICKKAT ION/ ? IN08-CUVuutiCw. mm [ at o n , w r L j, t RS 9uouwux'v y R/a/R oYIDCY lII CR wyclxleilnon I'/SN ?gljixFY?1-rvmic :%1 YMm"Y S1?tlNVAkr Ill oxD[NtuL Acnmts, . ORr ? o S CIO CIAL CG N MA INS 3msT7 oNAL C111) COMMUNITY R[P[v1SLOYMICI7T , L • . 1 R" y [ t L G DLrMT RU UkRIMDELNUAL "N IZF?I YmlUM IARi17R8 INDUMV!, 7'U ? OR'1ATIUN/ COD Dls?tkl?CT PVS1N[? BIN SIP Pr MlmmFUU IiFll wG it oltr rAaFmts IL xo DTxa> SCALE 1" = 000' RN rimivurty IC CK"VAL Rli KgSMPJffUL MGM INELLAS LANNING OUNCIL RYII ?T' CIIAPIIICS PREPAftI:U BY THE OFPIL'F. OF PINELLI.S COUNTY PRUPk:RTY APPRAISER, 1111 SMITH GRAI'l1ICS PREPAMI USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 O P-g. I& ico i RO qi, It L ED121 A 1 t7, L 00 ?? t? H H HL ? ..4 . ¦ /sr pq P/6P I L R1 f • Lw? ?L?+1C? R U ?LT G RL LIJA 1 23 4 ?IEW E?12 RL RL _ ff RI RL RL 'PIMIRF 2 --26 CASE N0. CW92--61 (AREAS 123,127.120.137,243-2.15.337-310.:i•10-342,420.451.475,400) LEG END RE9@ENTIAL 1mD USE COWMERCIAL PUBLIC/SM-PUBLIC DESIGNATION SPECIAL Hit L L R ?`R[At H/01 N?xl?M llRUD0L P PHx81tliTAT1UN / x?1NAGx .? ?xA?Ti1RC R UYAL , [? xp n NTUL H/0G o a CL u ° ? R/QS a iciy i 4MM coowULapoH-caulilaLw RE x t a m U s v Us SUM ns 11/0/H MQWL CH RxL'yMMN 1'/SP aeuc wrl-t [7D[7L all PLmy" RB"" SECOND HL A W wruCcruL .? .? a ORT V?rsurars CC COUIM L INS LXsyY=0NAL CRD CWIMN Y RxFKV=Pmjw RU u ,Ates:ue RFH U 1M1UST'RiA1 Tl1 UTUTT ION/ Clip Gtsgm'r nmarrxsa , U otU . It1.N muiiv ftFli ttiicW rA©tmis IL uYIUt M AL SCMX 1" = 000' ON HY?MU IC CKNERJLL Fit! 1pL'1Gs3N PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL HYII TuR6T it[L CELAPIIICS I'ItEPARF.p BY THE OFFICE OF PiNl;LIJIS COUNTY PROPERTY APP1t11i9ER, a11[ SHIM GRAPHICS PREPAIM USING LMIT VERSION 2.1 o L Ll 1 V CG lw1 CG CG R/UC - ?-:7 I RU IiV ? I I p+v! I i ? I I I' vl I ? t 7 T 41 ±v P A_- ..41--.- - n F F'r, N, I Illllik€ill? Nv RL 1rATE1t P/sP 118 I° € R/OG FIGURE 2 -27 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 39,40,93,110,123.240-2.10) LEGEND RXSlDEN'CIkL 110IED USE COMMERCIAL PUIILIC/SRUT--PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION Iili ?KHTL&L R OL Itlb7tit Ll1R?¢p orrxx [ T CN COM)AM L NYuCiWDR&oob P r>o= mulnON .--r. •&T" FAUUGS ....?. "ATUO RE 1 L /? Il/OG Y ??C1AL OL CL l?a oN R/OS D6Q6N-CnMUNCUL \\\ s M&T 1 omcz Clcr ftai 1?1TI op[? EIIl RS ? W x w R/0/R or m on CH lm ? l-[nmuC P/SP V/// p y v j t /itxTiu n?ta c N nKin WD'NuaY , RL ='Wlth L •? ?? ZET TAMIM GVXRIAY CG CQN DI5 ?r+srrrtmahu CRll CDMWNM IL=ff=F'UZKT Ru t wiw m'r RE'u MmK TAcnmxs INDUMIAL TU i "r'OxTxnnn/ COU pc?CCT sua esS , RLM cn`?'?ciu"T"iuy ldF13 n rAaLmas Gil IL uUn urnm SCALE 1" =600' I211 wWWl taL wimiubi IG Dm usymn RII R?axNrui wru PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYlI iucu CRAPIi1CS PREPARED BY 7'1iE OF'F'lCE OF PITIEIIA.S COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, 7IY Slii'CN GRAPIUCS PREPARED USING UEOIT VERSION 2.1 O /, 4f r r u>+ ? - Cx m m p RL RL i l C7 f / III ? I [- I WATIM q?j I I I .... .... CN, Ai n I I ?flli--Tl 1, L P .............. i i ................? i 5 ?. .• : ?;'!'tit•.i;::.' I s1 ! ',•?' ? ? gilt I i!?'ti•. ;;?.?• '? •?. iii • ,.. ?l .• ?;•; ' •., _ .: __:. ' • ',: '•%• : t; i? ' E t ' 1 't ti •''ti ?.` •ti' .,?L?iq P/sp trA'1'ER . arnua -. f 4 Ru. 354 P I •1- -1t to .,r t` Y I R R/05 ? 17171 Mil L--Zl F= F= ?2 F=24 FIGURE 2 -28 CASE NO. CW92'--61 (AREA51,z,15I3,199,331,354} LEGEND RES IDENTIAL. IMI) USE COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SEW-PUBLIC SPECLALL DESIGNATION RR IIRunn" XW7UL R/01. o iac m CN t FWD P rIU9C?raVarr . ? is`iru?i aa¦ RE amuctcrUL R/OG CL CDUMMMUL R/OS ° " / y io alrxcuL :wioeoN-colt QW, ca r omr? a:r orrr+ c a r r R$ VWUHUAM suauwux O u R/0/R omcs k9Y??u CR lucnrarax P/SP !'unuC ?I-rU1[1IC //RY I? P? SWOKU RL lrr oorruL .? .4 UYS ? acutrt» Cr Co? INS 0lcrrrtJZlosial cm) n v "rirr > II?Xor Y RU tim"'n" R1rm ?? racmmzs INDI1Sf13IAL TU ? °Rranor/ C13D DUMP GXXTRAL HUSEM110 Itu ie?nlu? RF13urrr r•cDtrira IL ? SCALE 1" = 800' RK mVW., IG Grin ItII R REMDXN= PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL HIM vm r ? . CRAPd1CS PRHPAI't]:D BY THE 0FF1C3; OF PINELIJ?5 COUNTY PROPERTY APPRA]SEIt, lD[ 9}10'fII GRAPBICS PREPARM USING MEDIT YL'IMON 2.1 b A Y ? r F ILL .... P/5P •? ,- TITFITT". IIAYER . . _? . HL i it ? ? ? L,*TRR p ... r ? f RL C? I I RL Hu RU 1tu P/6P R / th R/AS 1 .Sr.: •t .. ....... i' V P?S `I 10J. Hu r -- RU U 1 E I I I I I Ht n? P/" nu r/? RV RU do ? 4? RV r }ilJ RU RU nu Ru RU $° 0 Y >1u E RU xu Ru Ru R11 RU p, RU RU R/05 fq nU m P/3r Ro R R/o9 FIGURE 2 -29 CASE NO. CW92-61 (ARF.A.S 140,147,488) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL ULM USE COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/sma-PI ouc SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR nRt?lR" R/OL mQ ow. CN j?c o P PREM ATION yTMRAU(AGx RE REM L :cr"rs R/OG ffomFn-iL CL comk' ?M]"1. R/05 0 ?srinc[ ??? c?oRpmoRoN-c0hneott["L R5 °mupliUN ' R/0/R M CR Cr1Kt?L P/SP wuc mtut-PnaLC F"K Yt H sttC0?linkv RL uR=KNTUL w •? •, YZMAYrxcrurras OMMUCUL GC C INS INmnvnolut. CHI) DDcouWu WIRICT RcuxrraorEaNr RU U ° ItFN uxl)gUw ncurrla? INDUSTRIAL. TU THANSP YOSrrArs?N/ UTuJ1 CDD p u uusur:ss RLIi U x rcmluK RZ li 1ra0er r"CU.eruts tticu It. Ar>svsrutaL taur:u SCALE i" = 1300 Rai 3Q bcV t IG INIIS7MUL asxNwt RI` ?n? L PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYIi t ? GRAPHICS PREPARED VY TIIE OMCE OP PINELIAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SWTll GRAPHJCS PREPARED USING HEDIT VERSION 2.1 O lip] r/sp I r RL F WAM LAlIPsR r HL wim?, ?? w! M Ru Ru H IT Y ?...' E'j li/09 IT ?. Ru ru l ti N @ R4? .... _ N1[?•i r. r/slr - ,, r 1 R11 l u 1 Ru r/sr r/ST cam, iUl I - N u r7a-71 pu N/os FIGURE 2 -20 CASE NO. CW92Y--61 (AREA san) LEGEND RES IDENTIAL IImo USE COMMERML PUBLIC/SKLU-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR RMWEIMAl u= LL// R/OL oorrrTwcr?u>itrim Mc?wwap P rUmRV?noly .'' rr?t?v{unws?ca RE rMIntixnUL xrr?rs R/OG L r"T" am ms t CL COQ u+?on g/O5 ori n ar X acnetc9"-WuvX34c[u MR= RS RMm ? uL o t f{/o/Ii o ?' l,V ? u? CR romuzxc P/SP rM airn-NUnue / 1 r t U r i o 1, jnj Rt?uW"=M y ID*mixrl?L ovmrra cu Co ? INS arrnsnrnoxAL CRD DOM= x>mrr>Lpr>tsrrr RU Rn K? IiF1{ UULMIIU?N ncvmr<+ INDUSTRLU. u7uny rraron/ TU C111) aUMM urR=L auswslz RLU ? ? u RFU RRauxr r?aLrn><s IL nUrn SCALE i" = GOO' Itm YMlnrffUL 113T71Lm IG DfulmTNILL crKnw. ' " 'p"`D? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVII 1tttSlpef7lAi nnn' Iota ' GriAI'IIICS PREPARED DY ME OFFICE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY AI IRAISER. 7111 51UTI1 GIWIIIICS PREMED USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 Q po . s/ FIGURE 2 -31 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREA 4,5,52,135,145,148,483,484) LEGEND RES IDENTIAL 6bmD USE COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SEW-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR v ? R/OL rn in c-N tiic D0D P >'ra:n0ertnaN OxuNAcx RE tyr m?' R/OG o?v?Q C[11?)LL ENC CL ?u w ? R/0s OPEN SPACE RS KISMIDMAL R/p/R OMB M CR coum??N P/SP ru ?on-rvauc p?u `? r a?caNWxr RL ?nt amid .? rr a car MUMS CG CQUxM UL INS ?vrw AL CRD COM Unrnr r l=%=,arXxrrr RU srittL M rYal?rtCntsuc GINDUSTRIAL 713 urarTy rioN/ CBD CENTRAL NUMOM Rim {?0xv u°m nn R4'[I tuurif rt a IL ? SCALE 1" 000' Im W v ru IG mu nma r.WfZAAL RR ? ° x PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVIi q? a 41 ?J GRAPHICS PREPARED UY TICE OFFICE OF PrNELIAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, nM SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING UEDIT VERSION 2.1 a P(q. 8a I t? FIGURE 2 --32 CASE NO. CW92-'-61 (AREAS 6.7.160-M,194,462) LEGEND RES IDENTIAL M=b USE COUMERC1AL PUBLIC/SElQ--PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR luHmub-M U>lLL of R/OL orncs?tn . CH i itcu o0b P !•?e;arannse .` ;y ruTO"044 RR a'L R/OC ? 'am"j' ; CL cumwuu= 1t/o5 c?? oK-cn?nctf?cus 9 MATE am pt thrim cro fL5 SVflui e W R/p/R arncs?cs[SS MMM CR R?DCiualOTl N ISI [ UN1C !/i ?D?IR[ MMLAKr R4 smsv+ru>. Ppr . susoRr raratims . . arigLLA7 CC tv a? 41Q?i[1lL tnsarrorioxu INS CRD ep"uttM R=11 MOPuma Dtgmcr RU gownw RPM ii3k rarunns ?7U?TI'RIAL TU o?etarsoa/ CIiv nos cr sUMNIM RLAI Ns uriswrk ORT F.curms RPIi W MGH IL Mirxn SChI t 1" X08' Rll s vy 7LL !C Crt suo urrrrtu PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL 0 GRAPIIICS PREPAMI) 13Y TIIH O"ICE OF MELLAS COUNTr PROPER'L`Y APPRAISHRo nX SUITE . CRAPHIC'S MPARED USING 1MDIT VERSION 2.1 O ? y ? ""e-nmr, CA.5E KU. UWUZ- bl (AREAS 7.9.63) LEGEND RES MENTLkL Lam USE COLYI[ERCIAL PUBLIC/SkLQ-PUSLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR v R/oI, NNIiscu?`MIC'Miaunan P PxssiRVAnon F" s* uci RI: ZVTATZ R/OG nmat'4c CL u r?mK'? = K/OS RS a ? / R/0/R arn CH n f c"" °-rvuuc 1'/Sp ? ??? P ? uu Q srsin u ' r w a cot?u r RismsN LL .. ?. R?6D?TFACUJ= CC COON?MI t INS 9NVM nWUL CRD GOiafL M R[DRTIQ rWXKT IiV Unna7o? L RI7Il Ru Wruu Fat?nifits INDUSTRIAL TU UTOM oar/ CGD cuff= = uvmxm IiI 1[ wK= m? RF}3 HIGH rkcatrus IL uicrrxn S?CJ?LE !" = (100, [iH R IG Gaff lilt OWN P' INELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL 9YII C?? C GRAPIIICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SMIM GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MED1T VERSION 2.1 0 Pa 81Y It/Os P/SP R/OS RH HL XATRR F P/iP 155 RU 80 U - Ru Rl1 I i 5 RL FIGURE 2 -34 t I R/DC 1 0 CG H/QG R/0/R RL RU I I I I I R J±R CASE NO. CW92-61 LEGCiND RESIDENTIAL MMD USE CO.WMERCIAL PUBLIC/SEIU-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR tstzosm i nu? R/OU Q?rvi?oit'?inufyn CN t QLwwR UaL P musauranom .. ?• ?tnacs RI% ? "I R/OG a CL CUMUMCUL R/OS o " V R0.Y-CQLLYIR[ilL ?\M ? D e i ATY ? o? Car Lau= , CQY RI Q RS y?unu R/O/R fW.8/RS•r"I1. CH COwcsuC"L RXcu"nOK P/Sl, rvntc"-rnaur r Amvrry sa°QrOOi m/. HL ? R''T •? •? MMAY cusrua Cr MzMAL L INS ?vnONAL Cltll lrmRrnaFSCxKT JD CT RV ¢U KILSDIMM IiF ?I rur ncusrt><s 2MUSTRLAL T U ?QKrAnor+/ CUD pIS MCS nvs>trRSa RLH LOW K=r "" RFII MOM rACnmss IL LMULTRUI SCALE 1" = 600' RN W=IVU I(; cq?tw K?? ' PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL vi Rv1i RYF[LItN7 [lL tuir alts ' GRAPHICS PREPARED BY TIIE OFFICE uF PINELUS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIU SMITH, CRAPHICS PREPARED USING IJLDIT VERSION 2.1 0 _-3 , I /sp 1 p/ffP i a1 V ?_?? 5 P/8P U RU cc RU /sl 1 54 55 r ',U V I I 1/ I 1 1 {? 1[ R/a5 a WATER -?• •` ??:"•?! l?1?? ? x . K/o& .FRil I ...t6p RM" .... R co r Qr U ENTERPRISE RD .......... -._ . C i s R,fln RN ca ; I 196 19 R/OS t% ti ca ca .f ? }{l3l i p v lu ?.?..?. AMA A IL FIGURE 2 --35 ?A i CASE NO. CW'2-r AREAS pv,1551150,L95,480) LEGEND j^ ? /S-'/ RESIDENTIAL UMD USE CONILERCIAL, PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR KlYmRNTi.1,L FVR?L CN callfLa ML R/OL 3WFMg P PRU'ASVATMN ....+. •ATYR/aRA1NACR . Rp a1r7 NlaG00KHOOD u.u IEATU RE REMMMAL M"TATr R/OG lemu CL µ?lUu. ,LL R/+as tuCRf1T10N/ asttl bra \? 3crmc/NON-cQUl Fj= ??? CORKWOR RS ?" RHO/R Rrn ? A CR COOUMI CU -ranuc PVa 0M P/SP Ll ? s suB UKUM a ?/ >rsr I ? I ca" tA RL n)w <NTUS . RraoRrr^raa+ CG COLM°`" • . QyKnAT CIOW RAC Ir18 uartmtiorrAL Cfi0 corn= rcRARPROPYeiT OMU LT FM=KllT= RU vuw . RyM WART VA=X= "DIUM INDUSTWAL TR"SKW'rAMQN/ MUM CI3a CZK77111. BOwl= atrrWr HIMMMUL f hmm HIM o RFFI Wall lArusm9 U, ? SCALE L" = 600' RM ? IV, MuaTW" cCNRRAI RIi I n L PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL IVii y e G6APLDCS PREPARED BY nm Omcs or PINELLA5 COUIiTY PHoPERTY APL'RAISER, ;im SIIITII GWIUCS PREPARED USING MIT VERSION 2.1 0 S t ?a I ,.. L?•7a G 1\ U . RES IDENTUL I=D USK COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SEW-PUBLIC SPECLIL ORSIGNAnON RR KZ=KhTUL RUM R/OL arvt iruri?u y WER CN CO i o u ooD P r AnoH ? µ iuruQCUU+aaa RE "fflyWA RjOG a %{ CL Mk ? RIDS RZOMAMCIA/ mt c SUBU? R/0/R CR cuo RtCYYI on P/SP runic?n-PLUuc PROLM eWn/ RL f1??SDRii11L Lo• 1B60Ri ?ACi[S]IZ6 • • • • 6vsglJY GG CLi w INS ItimmnottAL Dlymlf17Y 1R06VflAP1[?1iI CRD co'cu TK t RU ourr" FIFK ?inlm r'?curiu6 INDUSTRGLL vrmm rarr/ CAr? DLV Ct>lttsxYm A hk Ftllsl ?es?i?ma" i?u ltFH ujamRT racUis IL ? SCALE I" = cool R11 ??NruL IG cgv-NM4 PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL vu RYFI ?nt??nIIC?' CPAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF P12MLLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAMER. JIU SMITH ' GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MZDIT VERSION 2.1 0 'I 1-I 1= LI I. 1_I _I w . R' \ CN It W, rr - - - - - - - - - - - - kV m p a .............. ! RL AI A R1 P RL RL I :.? I 1 ?? I R t4aR F 15 WA=t P XATXR IT rn 111i I -i I I ?.. I R/oS -Ii11.. si .j• ?t- P/SP - R .t. .? I I t R A FRI FIGURE 2 -37 r CASE NO. CW92-•-61 (AREAS 1,2,1Gn,144,3S1,S54J LEGEND RESIDENTIAL MMD USE COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RH KIMMMAL RURAL R/OL om tmr v CN Kvaulloicnoav 1' Prtarinon . iAlAZaneau+ace BF E>ntlL4Y'11L R/QG m CL u I1/OS ICt/ C ON-COYfliRRII1L \N§ MATE C= [NGiuui. , I'II:# R " C HS K SMIIDMIL R/O/R m C[i cauK?= P/SI' i uc T"U-FU11UC AMVM III ° ": BUBURAUN a/ nwaxy n ,1 HL SMINTtAL w • • o iai r ;9 CG Q "F INS uraTrrvrxviu nORVtnorsiurr CitD commu?fM w . . r Y g " cT HU =?I?• V L /LCR]TSZ9 IIFN R T INDUSTRIAL 0ll:iTION/ RTV-AL EQ11x1tY9 , C111) D RLAN Vnr j UTuxn IbT RLU Low um 1IF11 HIQU raC1LTTn9 IL um? it SCALC L" =600' HU maluum? IC' GC fR H11 n I PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL K GRAPHICS 1111YPARED BY TIM OFFICE OF 1'INELIAS COUNTY PHOPERTY, APPRAISER, JIM SHITH CWHICS PRF.PAIIED USING MEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 m? 99 i ', ¦ FIGURE 2 -38 0, CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREA.5 58,01,02,144,159.1,97,198) LEGEND RES MENTLU MIXED USE COMMFaCIAI. PUBLIC/SKMI--PURIM SPBCIAI. ASSIGNATION RR F.Z7 L LlYGL gIOL Iwimlxru?L DALCI CN corocl? = NAG[H0141D6D 1) r?I,nrinon ... *,r:n D wn •+++ rl1 RE lt=KKTILL R/OG l = W l & j CL tbcw mAL P DH • R/O$ HIC -C4161lC3tC1A1 t \? c II o rj cs v2 , ummo D y o ' \\ its MWUMAL , R/O/R p Q? CR CQ N IrIn-1N¢l1G P/SP ?L W CTFTM j?I 1 Ml ? vupw n WrtJIL WetSirlnU I- 1.1 L n 1 RL UlmtrrruL •? ?? FACUMICA CG CJMWYAL INS DINTRUS1ona c RD DcOWMM >4ZIYRLaPItIHT RU IIX=KN= uxw lif?I m? rJCnm? INDUSTRIAL. TU unim 710 H/ COD DczpnvAL l RMlCf DuaDaas , RLU ? m uu gFli lacm rAeamia IL fD%m," SCALE 1" = 500' R}I amKrnat IG DC QIiR?L L xz?mur uL Jul r D PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVII uL ?yj CRAPIIIC6 PlW'AIMO BY TIfE 0}'}'1CE OF P1NEl.IJS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIY Sld'I'li GIWIHICS PRKPAREO USING YEAIT VERSION 2.1 C 0 p_e .89 I FIGURE 2 -39 CASE N0. CW92---61 (AREAS 23,33,60,141-143,161,201--203,482 LEGEND RESIDENTIAL KIUD USE CommeBCUL PUBLIC/SEiQ-PUBLIC SPECUL DIZSIGNLI70N RR u 14t= R/0L CN cmumm" , P aura-'xn°n .` rW'[HasimACf TL {tE RE y ? ?` R/OG ? CL R/OS aim s icfs/ ? `IMM co 11DU-cowuRCLu. y u r¢ It CAllgil4 ° Lncm p RS auu? R/O/R °"+'r'i?u CR n CHUTION P/SP g ,C r-Mlllo l ?, MO Darr RL auB [oi n?u+tiAr . •' •? Q rr Lcnxms N cc; cuuZz L I S ?u (;RD cobcwwrrr RmsvAwrraxr Durmc? RV u o L !U it un K r v INDUSTPIAL Tlf TRAM WORTATION/ RLq mr m?iuv RFIt ?cdRr nCnsstse IL 1L LW= SCAM v = 600, RiI W ,yMAL IG cox-u L Ry a PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYf1 GRAPl1IC3 PREPARED 13Y THE OFFICE OF PINL'f.i1S COUNTY Pfi0P1:RTY APPRLISER. JIM SMITH. GRAPIIICS PREPAWD USING MEDIT VERSION :,1 0 FIGURE 2 -40 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 20,42,64,65) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL MMD USE COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SEIII-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR X 'u R/OL am? CN xxiuc ooa p rxsEKnATION nuTuge t RE ? R/OG CL C° L R/Q5 ? ` CN \l?? N x-cOYYiRL11L L cII+nt?a rt sr? R A R/O/N rn ? CH u on P/5P "yw-pumx ff f?? Acnwry t u S UUMIAN o a t 91m a?t rr rRou" p M "? RL ? . . a+T ?CII2tAS CG z L ENS > amvnam wcr RintstsoPYtm CRD no y ? ? oy a n RU uX RFY l 7ol ll wR INDUSTRIAL IT Vnwtmom?noa/ C13D WMC7C7 0=n= RI kI XLOW x LwTm RFIi ?QURT FAMITM IL Wa L Sc&u I" =600, RY ? L? IG a4uw t = =? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL xvll v,r u'a+?u GRAPHICS PREPAREA BY THE OFFICE OF i'WELIJ15 COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, 3111 SMITH CWIIICS PRRPARED USING HEDIT VERSION 3.1 O po? - 91 I r Re 1 r L r 1 • ! FIGURE 2 -41. CASE NO. CW92--61 (AREAS 36,87,09,70,72,74 ,85-07,167,200,204) LEGEND RES IDENTLAL LOAD USE COWMERCLAL PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR ? R/OL oZff FMMW CN m P Ply iocrAnon rWnaurl+cc i? o = " oulllomooo r n FMXMTtAL 93 R/QC ma c CL k= uL R/fl$ O w M 3 nn-crolncttclu, a? c TX TAA o ct txu. U O .Pl L OMMA RS n ? ? m R/Q/R `tu ? CH ui ?naN W -runz,c P/SP p tenart X vu orr x. /s;tr l cittu ? PKDELXY fat ifll RL ttrrttat • • ot? r?nus m EcuL CG INS umns 4 OVAL rsxDncnrwoer m CRD So La • • r , c t R RU ? ?u RF7( wwruy rACnrTric; WDUSTRIAL RJ ?Y RTAr[nly/ CUD ut? nuZx?n ? RLL w?mu?ct RIM luQH rAasnt:s IL UK= SCALE I" =600' IiM m e IG ? ul lRL aR PilmDNIMAL PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVH VI'°'a N GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE Or PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER. JIM :,7[ITH ' GRAPMCS PREPARED USING MERIT VERSION 2.1 O /aj . 9a 7 3 l xtl F =Oi 1!Y r AL RL P NUEB ® ® ® $? ® B H ® / RU f' R/Q/N 76 in ? U 1, RN Pb RL if fi k iq !? = f Q Lu E t RI f ! o g lY!(T7C1t, 1 ? t `? fl R! Rll IL ti FIGURE 2 -42 CASE NO. CW92-61 (ARFAS 75,70,79) LEGEND RESWENTf;UL WMD USY CWO[ERCUL PUBLIC/StI&I-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION xR u NMAL R/OL oM -u?A ?U 'ib°o Lo4a P r?aspniav n ?Ywr?cR RS " R/OG g CL / R/OS q o ic AOH-cousntRCtu \\? c ? A ,, ? " tau= p lC 0 1, oR ?3 RS R R/0/11 " ' CR nu k o ot P/Sp iuuntc watt-PUnue LMTW" I uY A r, i/?R Q = t t=u ot n 1 . PULU Y RL LUM P4tsmse I I V 0 a R K CC G rin = nWAL CN5 CRD k 1TY Rm[Y[GOP1[?7 s , 3 t Y T K ARAAL RU MA N? RFI? 1 = UY IAOtJ i1IL INDUSTRIAL ? trrmm 9PORTATION/ CI?U D91-ma B?x? ItI Id oMm lii Reu suucuu? ?,Ctt,ns: IL MNU-.L SCALE I1, = 600' Iw STI TTat, JC t IurYsxtaL x?J UX" PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL xvJl """y"MM cart utcu GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE OFPJC£ OF PJNEUAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAJSF.R, JIM SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MEDIT• VERSION 2,1 O pg 93 , M FIGURE 2 --43 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AR.EAS 00-83,174,205,206) , LEGEND RESIMENTLILL UMD USE CO"FRCfAI. PUBLIC/SCHI-PUBLIC SPECIA.I. IMSIGNAVON RR k"I tinu R/OL mp u o iiacicaow vvn n p ?+ss?rinv µ r*ia?ru?s '?K L RE S T CL C0 R/flG m b / R/OS a mir ??? cooxpSnOpCH-C°YOAaC1A1 I TA Z L l= 7 p c RU PNN k RS xsasinzvL assn CH cowwanc.?t /0 R P/SI, ?ue ?n-tronuc JLcr>Ty C R/? 9MUM" R orr<cg RECMUT10M / L N?dr[t? ruMus CG ' ' o L s°u KN 1HS7TCtTr1vHLL [NS CRD a°C7 a=xvswPKaxr R . , :« s C Y RU va 0?L RFbI Kivu rativnss DpUSTRIAL TU TTPANVroRZenm+/ C131) a T uv9?nss9 Hui OW unluLk RFlf a cuxr rx?urtxs IL WDUMUL SCAM V = 600' RN ywolum !G c wi RIl lu ?L PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYII imul wru GRAPHICS PREPARED iiY THE OFFICE OF PD+ffZUS COUNTY PROPERTY APPItA1S£R, J111 SbilTTi GRAPHICS PREPARED USING URDIT VERSION 2.1 O PF} 9/ i J l II! LOOT I IIIW-I' Ifl If WkTM R/Q/R P/6P ? 1 I 86 - --?- -r- 5 ' pL -T- G - s - ?I 0 `+ C C6 I I a R/O ar?? P/s? 213 z RL Rii_ r a/us iuT 247 RM cr. 0 2g d +' ... .21 RL Ra R/Os is/os I K1?lli xATL'? ? 7iII J [ I I I R I r/sP 2 fl/Os FIGURE 2 --44 CASE NO, CW92--61 (AREAS 86-86,187,207-213,472) LEGEND REMENTLO L mmo USE COMMERML PUIILIC/SEIiI-PUMIC SPECIAL. DESIGNATION Hu R RtalDKN7 L /0L R2ffl& / COMUNR UL UN NRRJL'Rl?n4N p x1TYa/LRLWJOR R ' RURAL OI7iCi iilltill Klir wzuiWa - ! iITU L RE IDMAL RXz R/OG r a'DjN , CL CORUXUCIAL R/OS MMATI N/ ca in ON-comm"= . ar o L m S a R O R M H CR we P/5P (vn?c fasn-Nanuc p R SUUU X cz/xrriu / / an r FR WART a><tvxo HL LDWILYnu. .? .? QTO?uY kCnJnsa CG Coo m aL INS ufmmvr"uL CRII cCOKWU M RZDKV3=FW 47 RU Ulam RPM ?iUM ric>rtiiie INUUS7'RL/?L TU Lrruny noN/ CI3b n=Cr alltaXIM 8121 LOW M"Ju RPII tuasRT rACI]]77ze [I. Wawa SCAL-F. 1" = 800' RM Ris a3zut 1G at MU L Iif( RZ=M ILL mulz p l PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RY1I rvly, 'mx"c ? c:::: {ji(AI'111C$ PR>;PAIlTiD BY THE OFFICE OF I'(NELIr15 COUNTY PROPERTY &MIRAISHR. 119 SMITH GRAPHICS PREPAIISD USING MHDff VERSION 2,1 0 M " -. F/06 I{ 1111 111 - I it III rvI I j I I I j - - v HB- A I --s R/ PM RL ; ?IIIIR??{141{ II_???I?li_?itrrl d L 111 I f - i r { I ST RD 590 -----...... 91 li ?- --------- ; {- E ; y kv i•, t i' ,'i•= CJ `?r rr• 'ii n 8L RL RL a P/SP ....?? J ?\. IL ¦A EL FIGURE 2 -45 CASE NO. CW92-61 (areas Qo-oz,Ia,z1a? LEG END RESIDENTIAL W= USX CGUlaRCLAL PUBLIC/SEMI--PUBLIC SPIiCULL DESIGNATION RR RLbt1 MULL cux" RI61OQMLL/ R/aL aMcx LDtlYtt:! CUMU)MCIAL Cfi K=GILWORS0011 P rtgMMAnoN w.., *ATii71//[I1[iA714ar . .. , rJuru L IE RZ= MLL 1 m1? n / R/OG y zK"LL CL i H/0& Xp? T10n $nAL B 11 faK-CaIOfZ \\\ 0 RU l l C R9 0MAL ? L3/Q/R g CR TR ai iiQ-PV31I]C ))/SP C/G yy all Lmv R Cood FJL LN t/nrrAq n r n P41LL T s P ILL L?O?tNTtAL O,=YrACM=S CG CK?y W INS LKtRTMMONAL CRB DLYMCT R73PIiYA.uPYR+T ITV 41 FMSMENVAL H MFYMMT MUM rJ?CI11Y[lf MDUS 'RML ??II TWAM. ?RTAnoK/ MUM CLjO D THAL C` ntf6ZNCi8 , RL?I LOWWitxv°Mi if RFII WGR rACiIlYtli II. ?m SCALE 1" = 1306' RH jr, WDUWMAL Rti P INELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVIi nRnUAL cuumcm RVA2AR L SY ' 01 P2mr r ¦v c ouxff PST li! l11 . ' . S ?E n. RU Kv AATIR I ............................ P ;? 4 465 RL Ru v Au ? Ru r/gr fit, 94 V/sPi R4 u i 1= 3311E 11111 j1 i l I i i 3313! li ;33113 ii Fr cc ill jl 'si ki i1 iE Ei it iii k! 33'13 it li liil.7 iii 111111 i? l i ;t if t 1 f f :i tI ;' k I? f' f : i i ;:'II 'I lj it II !j I !;t if iii !i 11 ik ii ij jl it 331331 :1 jli it i1 R/os till ili R/os R[!/ 1 ¦ nv .................. 218 I OLI) AuPA 59 - SOO .................. paps G } i os R/Ds FIGURE 2 --46 CA SE NO. CW92--61 (AREAS 59,94-97,218,406) LEG END RESMENML 1(I7i1LIl USE CUIULERCLAL PUBLIC/SE IG-PUDI.IC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR IMMICNTuL RURAL R/OL R?D4tndllJ ORSCI niD CN Ca"M ILL KILGI1L0"00D p rxsaBttATTnM ..• . •AT RM=g .?.w RUM Fie KIM MM R/OG CL - xU=UL 1 P C? It/0s o l\\M 8ox CDOoIt -L'Dim31tC1AI o o?iJl wc PIS 6 A Rs KIKMIof= R/0/R MCVA CR u ? P/SP ?usur snu-PtTpfJC %// uaLLRT a co"ART ovilullILAN r RL NISMraTUL .... Rw+YVA=Lnu8 CG co?Yll?1 INS DaznvTTo"&L ow CDn R ?i?APbtM McT llu 30 ' H kj°irD Y?ApWTRS INDUSTRELL TI! YORTaTTaH/ C111) o ct , Rl.M LOWWi=1 i ltl ll u? rirrunss IL KMDAU SCALY r =600' Itm ??IDiu IO MUTMI' cmilix" R"' cSMEM P INELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL Itvu `? ?E" ILION . ( 1 GRAPHICS PREPARED Al' THE OFFICE OF PWELIaS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, Jui SMITH _ GRAPHICS PREPARED USING UNDIT VgRSION 3.1 0 IM ins L Ll Ll FIGURE 2 -47 CASE NO. CW92-•-61 (AREAS 57,116,134.217,219--222,401) LEGEND RES@ENTIAL 1i0C>"D USE COMURRCLA.L PUBLIC/SRM-PUEILIC SPECLL DRSIGNATION RR mtrl' 7/ R/OL W" CN COMMIA L N 1 ?2?4J7tOH "w L G; u . 1.11[T A D T RE anaL Mafl L R/OG CL ?D? R/03 wn av ? ? oaoX-C0MW a UL WnLT a ua ]IS M R/o/R O m M? CR u n W1a-rcr>tuc P/9P ??? AMMI ROAN o rrt u >;/ y uff y PMARY RL mortut w r?n+r? • ? m CG Q° I INS Ufvnltmawl. f Par" plan CRD 06 r , ? RAAY . uy c RU ? I?FII 1 EMM YL? INDUSTPULL TU VMM +nan! CDA Mmn ? "U5Irrx6s nu JUMN I 21MMI tii I1F'fl UL900T rlrnmrs IL mvfr eas SCALE !" = 800' RFl ? ? `L !C AMS C RU unwzxna PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL IiVli MY wCq r t r,RAPIACS PFtF.PARxn BY THE OFPIrR OF PINiC11a1E C0LTN1'Y PROPRRTY AAPRAIl±FR, AU RJR' u GRAPMCS PREPARED USING MIT VERSION E,1 O M. 9g FIGURE 2 -48 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 4q,51,60,101-105,IUti,106,1Ct1,107,2z3,225,40[1) LEGEND RESIDENTM U=L) US E COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SEIG-PUBLIC SPECULI. DESIGNATION RR )M L r rru?? R/OL mm c 7W( CN Co w"m o P rxaacKrArl rr wnuce , a U a c u m ai Du o .. Tv NE TW ? R/OG m? a C? & CL cD mu' ? l R/OS w sax-cuvuxxa?t Mn i ISTATZ o j E t"cnu 4o vt o a MIDIN UL RS mtox a R/O/R = ComVIRC L CR ut ?utu?c ao-Dubuc P/SP w?, .rrsrtrr ua+?xD! // muR1ux onlcr RMCYL7[ox j 1 Pxw.utr sacaxuaxx BE, wrmirrriu .. .& onf kcunm CG COxv? INS txenrvnax.t CRA d xttntv=pmMff 1{U ? rrrxu RF'ld moiubtit i'cut?+el INDUSTRIAL TU UrnL r°rurDn/ Opn D CZHTRLL uus?xsse RLlS rm(Np U RI''li { ??tr 7AMr ?t IL ?? R11 MIX, IC Gi ? I WiDshim 4*6h.. SCALE 1" = 000' III M'GB PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVIi Yip Y ii au f ' y GRAPLOCS PREPARED VY TM UFPICF. OF PINELLIS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, flu SMITH GRAMUCS PREPARED USING 11EUIT VERSION 2.1 a pa . 99 r 1 ,_ 1 f t 1 -1 F 1 - G F , I P/sr r., 128 CU _R U. -1i F9 M E CG P/gr 1/0/R ?6 R/0/R P/sP ivoc J , T ' - FU lLY 130 R CC CG T A Ru U U H41 I I H i II, C CG I ` C D 240 RY I FIGURE 2-49 P/v 100 R]1 CC 11 1 CC 23? CS} -P/SP 83 CASE NO. CW92-6I (AREAL 100,108,128,130.131,187,183,234,240) TXGEND RES IDENTIAL MDMD USE COHIERCLAL PUSIlC/SEI[I-PUBLIC SPECIAL DRSIGNATION RR ? R/0L o?rr?T9W. CN XWcullalmoan P r1e?Cltlannx w TuarAmGs RE Z `L 11/0c; ? m CL cc R:?., RiW T[0_? R/OS aox-CGlfYItIClai `? sIrTAT iuL cc cur u Um= ? 1 ca uo Rs ? v R/0/11 o m " %Y CI CR CORVZR on-runuc 'll P/SP m M wr y L r // n Rucu"ON l u uRyRr ap T RL mxxrut ID IWORT Facamis • • CC Cli " WS Urgmvn0m" MCT rruorxn? CitD R x ? ? Q vvlAY lm" L T RU UNSM4 lL ? RPl[ 1p?DYlaCIIf??rS 1 INDU9TBIAL rgirr MriLnurr/ TU UT N CDD nCKMAI cTausanss , RLM IO=x?m R "T raffia RFH it cnDmtmrz" crs SCALE 1" =000' RN ?t x IG cixsRLL ?u? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL I1Vti rx L GRAPHICS PREPARED BY T1iE DFFiCE OF PWEI2J9 COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, 7Oi SYITII GRAP1{1CS PRY.PARLD USING NE= VERSION 2.1 o p?. ion , FFTTI BAY ULVU i FIGURE 2 -50 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 106.107,110,112,235) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL 1=D USE CObdURRCIAL PUBLIC/SM-PUBLIC DESIGNATION SPECIAL RR ?L R/DL a U CN ?mommm aeo woad P rastar / . u runrGS RE ?LlQ7UL R/OC GYR/l!. m CL LWfItIIfW nti a„ it/QS ? \\ C9?tmORON-CaIOLIRCIiL RS attuav? R/D/R mC= t CR ica? au P/SP =104 nuc ur u oorrRa?ucr ron RL LOW •. •? VWX=AAT CG COMM2= QVMK" INS V07M OVAL CRD ? lmsvnAPIOC,T RU N RFII 1 matv?7llirnn?• WDUST'RIAL ? Tx&Nm TaRS1i7nNf CIID RvusDt= , RLM wwu?m 'iuu RFII spar riL7 m" n, tr(Dl7?eiX if Lnu SCALB 1" = 600' RH MKOM Jr. crxn=u.= "?? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYQ wsVG t GRAPHICS PRLPARbD BY THE Orr= OY PIHBLIAS COUMY PRDPl:RTY APPRAISER, JI 51 SMITH CRAPIUCS PREPARED USING 3lEDIT VERSION 2.1 0 /?L . for r FIGURE 2-51. ?J, CASE NO. CW92-61 (AkAS 80,124-120,238,407-471) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL. UDMD USE CO"ERCIAL PUBLIC/SEW -PUBLIC DESIGNATION SPRILL RR ? R/DI. orn 3w ca CN i RICKDORHOOG P rxzmwknom / lxfA? rllll its Ws V R/QC ? ? GL Mnff= R/Os i ?utn?rtar. \\? w M a R GQI I YI p 4? II}[[7Vi RS y?vWv mit' / R/Q/R °rncilu`r?lit CR coc / P/SP ?i ,110"'o c V11 AMIMY + ixr RL LOWWa?ttat CUXZ to •. '. GTXRui a CG agm " INS lNrm=ox" CHI) vw cr aomcarmc?s RU c:r" RPM W= vu srnra INDUS' L &L TV UTIIM aa/ C131) DI6T?x[ L '? C7 k° , RI.1I M RPII nsoKt rirninn IL SCALE 1" = 400' ItN ,&nu,, IC c MUM= RII maA PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL 1=r GRAPHICS PREPARED BY THE Oi'f'1C8 OF PLNF.IdA5 COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JI11 B3Q'PIi GRAPHICS PREPARIA IUMNG XUrr VERSION 2.1 O ¦ .', m R - / ,, co?-- . I f. , W10vi 1-4v. L?1i7?-pl (AREAS fi0,85,80,7©,(3?,115,1SSf,120,1w2,102,1EiS,185,i:3U.490) LEGEND RES IDENTIAL l=D USE eo"rRCIAL PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC SPECLAL DESIGNATION RR RJOI r:rrwt o CN IfllaWWWWooa P nmrmumom , iauvIIasinfAut AE fuEnKy= R/OG o a4c ?taL CL ?MYl R/OS ?? ilN-6vWQI1LLL p ??? ??? = Arts li au rn ? P1Ri r A p C RS lYRURW R/U/R omp?/itrrlq CR nna i'/SP nrxxn?t?°?-??? Vf? PRDURT S[W06NIA/Irr RL PCXSMKW= la w •. •. ormuiY aCUTS is CG ? COUXBRCUL INS >2 ==0NAL CRD p?y'? a" ?riaaPVUt1 Ru off, RFH mu14y rAa?mza Yf3fRfAi, MD IlI rxirrsraRCinoN/ tmtrrY CIID arNYru, 4pS717t61 u-nact Iil.hl UM ? x Aril MORt TA=M6 ujoa IL ME= SCA E V _ 600' RW OWN, iC caam- R1! ?? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYII RZMEN AL L? GIIAPIIlC9 PREPARED BY Tfl6 9Ff'1CE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY AP PRAISER. JIM SMITH GRAPHICS PREPARED USING 1LHWT VERSION 3.1 0 //09./o 3 1111 0 ?& , FIGURE 2'-53 ¦ .. CASE NO. CW92-E 1 (LR1 AS 71.73,121) LEGEND RE9mENTLAL UMD USE COMMERCIAL PUBL[G/SCHI-PUBLIC BPgcuL DRS[GNATION RR R/pL aim n m=4B r P r90stYazln I-^A. ; RAM= HE R' ? crnat/ R/OG ? CL Moo= / R/OS a W tc? a o A N-COmkc?ar. e vrirs am aas rs cm K p 4 I: [ its ? y? / ? ? R/QIR Cn CR P/5p roxiac -WifuC IMM" R? wH SUBUU¢ o irt cs/RirflSL s U t PR1 K AL 1S1?IItIIAL L .? ?? oAr ACU=3 co CH> MCuL INS IN6111VI OXLL CRO DwUi? W?? * KIEVENUA N M RFM UNL sACD, "" UD?L '!'C ? FLrioN/ CUD bllMCS 1?7 A 6L 66. Ii1.N ?r m A! 11 1lusj0ii[t 7Lrn,,,," II. SCAM 1" = 900' )tu ?Ciro?Dicnf`' [G an= R`? ji PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL ' AV[1 wrl" ? CRAPIfICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF P[NFD.Ir1.9 COUN'T'Y PROPERTY APPEWSER,,ng SMITH CRAPIIICS PREPARED USING NEDTT YERSIQN 2.1 O r f K/ox P/sp I RIM ? R_ I I „ I 1 11 I L I I I U I I 05P I>iu may.. I? 1 R R 1 r I JfP 3F 1 VI( t fa ?J- 1 -'.-' I I V I I f E v R/Q8/ rc 11 J a I ? t1 R I 1 { •!ui Ku i P/ R. P/sP 1 E 4 v RE Au R/[R3 co nv c? RS RH P/8P ??-- Ru v R/QGI.` Ct: CG P/sv . ee r.. ? ?u sv ? xY f FIGURE 2 -54 , sssssss CASE No. CW92-61 (AREAS 111,113,1aa) LEGEND RESIDENTUL IMED USE COWMERCIAL PUBLIC/Mil-PUBLIC SPECEAl 10291 iNATION RR Rte a // R/OL om uYrYta CN vomk'x xzxuuouuooD P PIMMMnon kia?u??ct r i s u ICE R= L=AL it/or. ? CL COMMMUL R/O5 o 2vw ?c ? vt c N N-cokxn?a.u. IM` ESE 4 F LAG= r C?+Rt Its g MM ? m ? R/O/It m on CR RU A nu-vulrue P/Sp t o / ua cs/urr[ L n M j MM"T WOno is[ HL ?;msxnu . .o FACWMa CC ? ? INS trisT-, LL MnO' CIW ccbMu? RulllWPxt7R ? r tx c ICU P AZ arm b[snmY ruz?ta MUSTP L T U uunimx"?0r sritwty/ C?O DIWerw CC M Rill wi MMUM RFII W CH UK" F unto TL is SCALE 1" = 000' ICU rmw ? IC ciaau iy fill "Muff= lurv PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVH IV's RIM" ( , CRAp1iIC9 PR£P?1CED BY THE OFYICE OF PINBLI.l.9 COUNTY PROPERTY AFPRIISER, Jild SMITH' l _ f GRAPHICS PREPA ZI) USING ![EDIT VERSION 2.1 0 FIGURE 2 -55 CASE NO. CW92- 61 (mw.As 114J17,132,139,1$0,250) LEGEND RESD}ENTIAL MUED 1198 ColmoRML PUBLIC/SE I--PUB11C 5PECL11. DISSIGNA170N RR KK.gmcf LL ri/OL YffiUCM7Ill? m cuumhlo i. P Ylu?l17[4N wU. 1T1?/blaDiiCr ? titi ;aT KUA" 91?TCi b tmClil}WCS10S3D .. HE ? IWTUL R/OG it CI, Rios " u1 ??? R n-? ,c. 1i5 aw R/O/H ? CH RS=U non P/SP ?"YVnuc - LVLMKT imm=r a Rn n F RD RL wi nrmsu . . mr Man= CC 1 INS Ix6srrUnoHU ctin y Ksurr?nca's?arrr ? ? o G riU VXUA rN KKTUL RFN w IVM rl p INIWSTRLAL 7U Kzinosr/ MUM CDD ??stNu? cT ousuom EILH wt ?itni .Fit ImsoFrr rAcuj= IL ?u SCALC 1" 600' RN unmu IG cmai xzsmnlajLL R1I RE S PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL Rv1i Tuff , rc::? GILU'11ECS PREPARED BY TBS Q"ICS OF P[NFS.IA5 COUNTY P1i0PKIi7Y APPRAISER. JIM SIS[TII. GRA.PIIECS PREPARED USING UZDTf VERSION 2.1 0 ?1 1 + M., ¦I, LLlrL1YiJ RESIDENTIAL I=D USE COiaLERCIAL PUBLIC/SEW-PUBLIC , SPECIAL D¢SIGNLTION HR GR?nrsuL R/OL ' amts in CN co isyUL 7) P ria muraN . `TI8/IIIMMAGt RE r aTffnAL R/OG G cq+ CL coax ul R/OS rx sic„? "MM M IXIOH-eomxau RS s?ilp°?[1ffU`L R/0/R R? CR ?p1a?NKR oN fl/sP n?r) l-P9IkJC %% ALIrtw" FRIMAff IDDRDMY RL , ISI MOMAL lD7 .? .? $a rACf rm rmy cc; CONY AL INS Ili3i?T4T10ttLS CRD COMMUNM RMTEorpum RV urrtu RpN Hibm MUMS INDtrSTPIL TU 6RTAT30H/ CBD Dw cr RLN ?r ne°jt y RFLI ffGA3rr MUM ly rvabYxut SCALE 1" =600' RN ?ctnt?tL IO o?ior°iws' R" PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL HYII °???y?' ORM11CS PREPARIM BY TF{E OFFICE OF PINELLtS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, nU SMITIl GRAPHICS PREPARHD USING MIT VERSION 2.1 o } o' ' ?% I FIGURE 2 --57 r CASE No. CW92---61 (AREAS 182,164,373-379,450,457) .LEGEND RESIDRNTIAL MII<HD USK COMMERCIAL PUBLIC'/SERI--PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR IMFMKK= RURAL "imIIf'[!AL/ R/01, t CtiUU; •L CN P etusmvAnun ,,.,,,,, •ArFi aaawacr p ?iYr iD Klocuuonooo ww ?A RE M T u R/OG CL ? R/QS a ° ` ie OK-cn?cuxacxrf 0V C D AI Z o sr cY a 1 o¢co aQ R8 suuuvuRIMN R/O/R maw ?L CR Wcyu? R P/SP elm-nnue ctcOttDiFx RL wim u '. 'r ona"y rAcnnm cc; iN INS Uf7rirvrlONLL CftD D?6 LT Rmgv=Pm " RU MMT" RFl[ x mtuw c IMUTLIS , LNE)USTRIAL T1( nRranon/ VnuTy CUD D16 ?°M5 RI.11 ?a7 u1 RY<fi RICH ?acuaru6 U, ?? SCALE 1" = 000' w{ s?mnyynsu IG carusxruxuL RII PUFM P INELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RYII PUFMOMAL lur vcxx utcRlu ? GRAPHICS PREPARED UY THE OFFICE OF PINELLAS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SUITB GRAPHICS PREPARED USING 11EDTT VERSION 2.1 a 1. i, 07 ' r ? i ?2 FIGURE 2 -5B CASE NO. CW92--61 (AREAS 301--385,458) LEGEND RES IDENTIAL YDMD USE COMMERCIAL PUBLIC/SH1U-PUBLIC SPECIAL DowHATION RR Aux" rbl= R/OL ? CN X P PzcusYanon iu* ?r A amrz uim XIG"w noon n jmmzhn" R/OC 2"?? CL comuzv= R/OS 0 2Y 015/ MIZON-co ?u ?01 " Lumim 11 ,1 ca R5 5 MMINTIAL 111 R/O/R OmQ/KrrAm CR RUX" A/SP ?m-PISfltJC Acts- ttm xn RL wxmLHTIAL •? •? 071=AYIACiiflQts CG CI MALL INS prBrmn"NlL CRII ? xxAt71LWP1iCM t R1! Ham" mft" sacntrux RdN INDUSTRIAL TU ""'70 RTATION/ COD "ammo A y MUM Q RLH tRapro tuw RF7F x luau rrt V40 mmo IL ? SCALB F" a OOO' T;u YimN L jr, rlmx RVs R"?? PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL ym man GRAPHICS PRLPARLD BY TIM OTTICE OP PINLI.IAS COUNTY PROPEMY APPRAISER, RU SIi1T11- GRAPHICS PREPAM USING MEDCT VERSION 2.1 a }3 ??1 pg. FIGURE 2 -59 CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS 368,307) LEGEND RES IDENTIAL M=D USE COL(1[SItma PUBLIC/SCIG--PUBLIC SPECIAL. DESIGNATION RR ? R/OL CN Comma P rXIMMAnaa ry? 11LHAMr R£ ZML R/OG ma a ?ut CL u R/DS OIN BPACt ??? ca man N-camrau. R9 sm u zmuL R/0/R a ? ?y C MWICRCUL CR RECREATION -PVeuc P/SP mu muc// & ? i L=TTrrr crxrsa V?/ PUMART SIMN RL LITIAL up •. •. OVILY ?=3=° CG aOXMII INS 1f??envrrMAL CRD CMI ?rvaaam+r RU UIRIMKX= LLM RFII X= IWM r??iue INDUSTRIAL TU vrum nary/ WTUL CpD ou cT MMOM RU 4 PMMKNTUL L ow Mimi IMI IiayKr ??c"=9 IL ? SCALE !" = 600' RN r?sniuat MPUFMAL IG MMA" R° PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL GRAPHICS PREPARED FiY THE OFPICE OF MELLa9 COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, JIM SIJITA GRAPHICS PREPARED USING MEDIT VERSION 2,1 0 g E"*.' m , , . FIGURE 2 -00 o CASE NO. CW92-61 (AREAS•4©.1BB,487) LEGEND RESIDENTIAL !mn USE CAIt??BCIAL PUBLIC/SEMI-PUBLIC SPECLLL DESIGNATION RR ',UF?? R/0L Q ® CN co" ??p 0 P r?ran 0 ?7vs?paaeic: CATI R/OG omCit gII f [ wl CL LOUTID 1 ? !t/O5 vnuS?uAoC1G mm\ coiamo°/ Is-Ca?tldziinu RS um ? ? t I R/Q/R um l-/%rlu, CR REca K P/SP c??a-ruouc III r isx rYCO?ircux/ T rlrrtaL •? •? OVIRLAAT a IN9 vs:nvnOru. CRD t m=cc r lumLVSLOVfI1ttff RU MrTuL RFW ?? VAcnmFa INDUSTRIAL Til iPO?unar/ CUD ?L WuNwO4 nwTa?cr , RLII ?icm r? RFH VWGUxr ruIInur' Il. rrxut 9CMZ 1" = 600, Rl[ n uL IG °rHM pa =I PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RV11 my GRAPHICS PREPAM BY THE OFFICE OF PMEILkS COUNTY PROPERTY APPR&MER, JIM SMPM . GRAPIBCS PREPARED USING MERIT VERSION 2.1 O .. ;? r FIGURE 2 -61 f i. m CASE NO. CW92---61 (AReAs 50,406) LEGEND 995WEM LL MIXED Use CokmitsCIAL PUBLIC/91L G-PUBLIC SPECIAL DESIGNATION RR VOL amp 01go CN ? P nnaH 'M RE L R/OG on,s? CL col? R/OSc Buz' ??? coaart-w?aatrsur. R3 rvu R/O/R min CR cvyxrsr ut ksaawnON P/SP lurtzaaq-rvu?c oscoND%T RL R DiMSIL L o r? ?? O?DR y aCIISIIIr CG z" INS R18TIIV770NAS. CRD ? HZD APYIRIT * KU v ilt/ti W nC1LttIYi uff I 11 IN DU9 IAL T YQKIItiOH/ CDfl p?FT wnLLL C2 RVd1H[? A 6k r LOf Win' U Brij MOg4' •a==5 IL 2011,L scab I" = 600' R1I ?iv? ruL jr, on? L RIi loauremAL PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVII xmv u C? CRAPIIICS PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF PINE LUS COUNTY PROPERTY APPRAISER, Jp[ SMITH CRAPHICS PREPARED USING ][EDIT VERSION 2.1 0 .M .E 1' f P??. era CITY OF CLEARWATER tar. ' Interdepartment G)rre-spondence Lb 3. TO: Mayor and City Commission FROM: James M. Polatty? Jr., Director of Planning and Development SUBJECT: PPC Consistency Issues - Request by Eagle Estates Homeowners Association COPIES: Michael Wright, City Manager Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager .M.A. Galbraith, City Attorney Cyndie Goudeau, City Clerk DATE: March 15, 1993 Attached please find a letter received in my office on March 11, 1993 from James C. Fausch, President of the Eagle Estates Homeowners Association. Please note that Mr. Fausch expresses some concern about the proposed land use plan classification which we are proposing to place his development. My staff has discussed this issue at great length with Mr. Fausch. His concerns are that we do not have a specific zoning district that precisely matches the actual density of his subdivision. He would prefer to be placed in the residential suburban land use designation (2.5'units per acre). Unfortunately, as his letter indicates, his subdivision is developed at a slightly higher density (2,8 units per acre). Therefore, his subdivision falls under the residential low land use designation (5,0 units per acre maximum), Since It exceeds 2,5 units per acre, we cannot place his subdivision into the residential suburban land use designation. He suggests that we consider a special "RS-2a" zoning district to precisely accommodate his subdivision, in lieu of the current RS-4 district. The setbacks and other development standards to which the structures in his subdivision have been constructed are RS-4. The City staff review indicates that there are no other subdivisions to which the proposed RS-2a zoning district would apply, so we are reluctant to establish a zoning district which meets the needs of only one subdivision in the City. However, in order to accommodate Mr. Fausch's concerns, we feel a residential 121anned development zoning district could be applied to his subdivision which would establish RS-4 zoning district development standards, setbacks, minimum lot sizes, etc., while limiting the development of the property to the actual density of 2.8 units per acre and the specific lot configuration shown on the associated plat. The appropriate land use plan designation would be residential low (5,0 Units per acre maximum). I would like to discuss this issue with you at the March 15 Work Session, At that time, we will seek your direction on how to proceed with the zoning of Eagle Estates. Should you have questions or comments, please contact me. JMPISSIvld PpCooyle.5r f i EAGLE ESTATES AN EXCLUSIVE COMMUNn IN COUN RYME Mr. James M. Polatty, Jr., AICP Director of Planning and Development, City of Clearwater P.O. Box 4748 Clearwater, FL 34618 Re: Proposed Amendment to Countywide Plan: PPC Case #CW 93-2 (53) Dear Mr. Polatty: Thank you,for your recent correspondence acknowledging the concerns of the Eagle Estates Homeowners Association in the above referenced case. Per your suggestion, I have been in contact with your staff. I am told that the current recommendation of the City. of Clearwater Department of Planning and Development on the matter is to apply a "Residential Low" land use designation to our subdivision. I am writing to register our opposition to this recommendation and to offer an alternative solution; we propose that the city create an "RS 2a". zoning district which conforms to the minimum lot size and setback requirements of the current "RS 4" district within the "Residential Suburban" land use designation. This would allow land use planning to more accurately reflect the reality of how the land is currently'developed in subdivisions such as Eagle Estates. The properties within the Eagle Estates subdivision have been developed in accordance with the city's "RS 4" single-family residential zoning district. However, based on the plat maps on file with the Property Appraiser, the subdivision has an actual density of 2.8 units per acre. This density is much closer to the "Residential Suburban" land use designation of 2.5 units per acre than it is to the proposed "Residential Low" at 5.0 units per acre. Use of the higher density could cause city and county planners to over-invest in public services for our area, an inefficiency we can ill afford in these difficult times. We continue to believe that it would be inaccurate and thus unfair to the taxpayers of Clearwater to use the higher density land use designation for planning purposes. Please ensure that this correspondence is recited and entered into the official proceedings of the March 18, 1993, public hearing before the City Commission. Respectfully, James C. Fausch, President Eagle Estates Homeowners Assn. Copses to: The Honorable Sue Berfield, City Commissioner, City of Clearwater Mr. David P. Healey, AICP, Executive Director; Pinellas Planning Council Eagle Estates Homeowners Association Inc. • P.O. Box 15553; Clearwater, FL 34629.5553 A Corporation Nat•for•Profir ?4 . G r? 4< 0 `1 ?. V CL r C) a O z CCN L U'> U w ¢a N 0 U '00 0 U ??, < u o? . -i w (/1 Q O CD C H V w z z a. 0 r V M ro a D CD CL CL U (b O d a a o Q Q CL IE 'C LO a. n a b to 0 Q Q R' N N C7. m =1 :3 E LC] Ln a 7 7 &n cc O :3 LO LO LO E '' O O O C.) ? o n n n I x ° E m m E E c n m c `a cu E co E E E a °G m >i h a cu E E E E E S S S :3 :3 a a ° ' 3 cc oc oc cc r r ' w (a N .0 a 3: c m c c 0 N N LL N ar M . J J 2 co T co T co T U m m io in i in is m in is is C c c C C C C C C C c c c o N a aI a a) a w a a) -L:) a) a a) a a) a Q7 a a) a a) 'LO 4) a 4) a a) a) a) a) m a) 4) 4) 43 4) 4) a) a) n. ? ac i]C Lr ? a lY: ac fX oc OC LY ? So s o ?o 0 0 0 V m m f° ' N T ' to ifl ' v) in ' y N ' of IU w ? ,_ SV ? ._ m ? to ? ._ y to ' N M ' S!) M N C N c M c :. C 1+ c 1+ a. +• !? N C N c N +• c ? ,_ a) c ? a) cu c ? m a) c ? (D 0 c ? v 4) c p as w e ? a) E c a) E c a) E c a) E C m M c © a) m e ? m a) c ? m y y *vi a '0 a a 'iR a 0 ' ?? N cn ;6 :a v m ;D v a) En ;D ty d) N :°_ cA N _ n U V V r a a) J OC 0 LlC J fY W J LY dC 2 a OG Z OG 2. QC Z [X C d oc cn cn oC LA a U) a cn LL. -n a U) N O ? Lo LO LO (nn - O Ln (D { - ° O , u - O v LO to co ? cD LO fA m. o m a m CD CD m ca CD a ro m a m a o a 's m G m 4 Q Q co CL CD cx =3 a a m G ? W r- LO LO LO O Lc) 00 CV CD C. N r w C6 L6 n Pz w O] y C cr- or cc cc cc cc cc rr_ cc cc it U) in U) U) V) U] Ln N U3 U) Us C W 0 LO O 0 CD LO (D in co 0 t` L N n N Q It LO L co CD ~a tU f(S t4 f6 ?O C C C c m L C c C L _ C]. C Cl C C C a , C a ? OL D 0. m Q :3 L1 D CL D a 3 V fn N d D co co N CD N c N co 3 C c ' ? c o 44 N C U) n ) co cn co cn D = cV (_a O ?t co CN 2 v v cc ac ac ae a cc cc a cc W. LY r' ' r W a) DC a .? O w 7 LL C LaL N N ' o V a U LO a 4- Lo .- CL G 7 c in ? v u d U LS) m iLs C Q d a d J m . a) J Q p ?+ c ? ? 12) Z- j! z -j Ln m- to W oc Q ai U 0U Cs o a U) CO) -0 I Cc ti Q 'C H- 'a Q Lin ti v a) tr- N J = W ? o of ? a) Oc `.cn d ` Q a O 7 0 0 14 - 0 N o w- ? y z N Q , L'7 c Lv) cc c mLO p roLn c v u mw y m? N I L`a CD 'L] N W t?LC D N a) CD U N p= q N L E3 & LL LL cc a) a d ? ? E U 11 U C u 10 U" L L ..J G a C7 . J 0 Q a) E c, E D fl (D C co CA CL CL et c d o Q ._. ? ? Z = u p is p C CL p a) a) ) O ac p n. p cc O a U L •p cl cn N a C U) - N d c _ m N c O N m C Q T V v sa co m rq ' ' H c n c ro c n tom c m ai cc p m ,- a) m ?- a) CC LL cC ?- cc o x l u x l E cn s x E x E (n r (n En o y Q m Q N m a a O cu m cu a m c o mLn. m a a ) a LL a m n. ) c o= LL ) o= Ln a U Z ? o_ U m o_ U °? D: a) X C 43 0 U N N m N a) N a) C 0 N I in ? is iti U m LL to U ca LL m ca ra V LL sU La m ? LL V ?, a) .d N C G . C L! L 6 ? L L C m Q L) v, 0 a) cc v,0 CD cc E aF 0 v L E - a? ° V + l E:3 C u E L a? U ca -j cc cc L)) k U k- ) u -- cc LQn oc Ln E , 1 r C LL a U- Y m ° Ci a LY m a # Crl a U- co fl 7 U_) C m Lt) m O LO Cr) Q O a a CD CL LLJ V) n 10 a) LO m Lo LL) L6 Ln ?a LL (r ' G `d Q. C ?•' Lb ?-•- n Ln r co a , n Ln u- c c o Ise `.N a « + LLLi + N 'N Lai Nn Lo ' o a E E a LO r ac LL X C X Or ?r LL cOp LLLL Lat !] m a in . N L r C) O = N o o [fl ? C7 ( Q a c) 10 c CL o cl o ¢ i a t: g Z) o CL :3 CL n . a ?- LL o - csv LC in cc U) 0= ?U 0: ?(n N N - LO Nn r N l? C o m r N G ' N N m C C (D *0 V O CD c -0 v O 0 Z in u CL O U U U U '1 ¢ ? ? ?' a ' m ?' oc ix do o U C) U LO LO C LO LL7 L C to Ln LO LtJ ttS 4?. O w G o O a O a ? 0'- p m a a cl a c to ? ? O C) Na v wpc (n ?, LC7 U) m oc °_ ? ? cc °_ °_ L d7 V ¢ M 0 _ C En Q ac N Q O ¢ C ' N W Lr) O ro OD N tA Ln O ro o0 N N ro cl LL m EE r cr. V i ? C7 , { , 0 LC! H a f7 ro¢ " Ur m¢ ' 0 U' d n U t •' LL U LL m U u r V °' ro y ac o W 4J odd T O ?. y c 8 a c , U C,L c ca m ro W CD 0 m a CL 0) L7 G Q CD C7 C7 ° Y C V L1 ?0 O C d ro O m C d ro Q w L7 CD &- ED p A C6 c +1 rl -r, co (A 2 N? a ? 0 d C d Od m ELn "CS EL ?a) 0 Urn OC ron. 0 U1? Cc ro? O U19 U1 U OR C C N C1 Nl CI U) W W N W T _ G ' 'U i i i 'u m 0 m . v A m c) i LL %v y LL. s s LL n ` LL s ? LL ? E a CM EN E•n E n EN E? ? o? .? E =?. E a? E aF E E > 1 UF°-v cs0 ca U}-0 V ciE°-?' cal-°-u o a0 c ca co m 0) ° ?°, U) C Ltd a C C Ln '. ._ o rn d o E r Ct Ln d V Ln tp 0 00 C) U- cm W- a < CD to C to ¢ C) i CL V) L L U- 0 to O rt CL [1C d? Ln LO f? O N Q ¢ y co ct L L o rorn o[ It ?t * n ED '.' CD n 10 a cn N • - cv • - cl E Cl a cx ,• CL 9 2 0 ac co < LO 6 E ao E a oc 0 r LO ILw C%jU- ? f r * ?? NL¢L L`? Z °n ?u E E E a LO a - N U- U) n d N Ln 4 ca N LLB n LS} O i d O G H c, C? a) C C G¢ m CC C Q ¢ 7 in m EL 0 LL LL - =1 : LL ?.} f!J ?7 co ?- Q N 00 Cf Q co Lq a) C d Lq Z ? m Z tm C ? r D t; w N IS co N c U 0.l w F= ' V U O U U U U > ?yy f•. ? '1 ' r , Pt v:'?'Yf /'?'?r. ? `' .. ,. •i '; ., ?^? . •4?.5',.. 1. .,ill'.: ,; ... • 1 ? , QG CV O cr. v3 in Lt7 CD cc N O O _ O C a p FA . c LL , L L Q C (? Q C LL) N • m _ C1. tp LL O n ' Q c CL N O U CL o ?a cc tC Q r.. LO m O m Q Y N a N V- .J . ? k O r C k d 1 f4 ?yj _ V a a pC ° cn m O C c ° C 0 v U _ t: o ° ° a s cn •Q aC a) U) a 00 CD m co @0 ..JO CI-' it a, z QU U G _ _ ?• C _ C1 ) ° o • 0 C?-LE m. N c N ._ ._ N Dl N N r '? fl O V C Q 0-j0 ? i 0- a u z c k GC ' CD m C in - m C a '? LO ` . I? LC N fY u) O m w "rs W w a a C 'C LL E U) M .a Q1 w' , c, cc o n !x °? _ C1 .. LO v , V p a U) LQL Lal N to C f7. 4 O (D LO Q Q Li] a; C. (a d N '- Z .-- .C N k N ?+ Q u' Cc T cc cc VJ LA U ) V] n O z O z a)) ) a a G O O O O Q m a(a z0 'r7 z z Z C V C , . I a 3 m r n. oc. Q 3. oc a a ,o a¢ 0 Q. • .. k ? ' r'k•'t c O k6 r cLo W r9 U U a. IL a a • N E a II n O co 4Q3 co O O 01 O W U O ca , O C O Y V A a'• sv ro x O c. CL co to . C CD Q ' . N W cl C O a O. II o c O m 6- A:3 a n ? C 0 <fl MD L] II N w , j U 7 cu iL II o ? M a, E o II R r t .?n. . r ' ? r PPC CONSIS'T'ENCY PROGRAM Residential Subdivisions City of Clearwater March 1993 TABLE 1 PPC Recommendation: Withdraw/Deny - RL to RU 1 Item # Fig., No. Atlas No. Subdivision Current City LUP City Zoning Proposed PPC LUP City Recommenda -tion 12 6 261A Grove Circle LD RS6 RL RU 39 27 308B Glen Ellyn Est. LD RS6 RL RU .41 16 315B Bel-Keene LD RS6 RL RU 43 15 315A Highland Lake 4th Addition LD RS6 RL; PSP RU 45 15 323A Southrid e LD RS8 RL RU 54 34 233B Countr ark LD RS6 RL RU 82 43 272A Coachman Ridge Tract A ,I and Il LD RS6 RL RU 101 48 281A Hillcrest Estates LD RS6 RL RU 103 48 281A Rollin Heights LD RS6 RL RU 104 48 281A Rollin Heights LD RS6 RL RU 127 26 308A Lela Manor 1st Addition LD RS6 RL RU 137 26 297B Oak Acres LD RS4 RL RLi 211 44 273A Virginia Groves Estates 1st Add. LD RS6 RL RU 212 44 273A Virginia Groves Estates 1st Add. LD Lot 9= RS6; Lot 34=RS8 RL RU 216 45 274A Kapok Forest LD RS8 RL RU 217 47 283A Kapok Terr. 1st Add. LD RS8 RL RU 279 47 283A Kapok Terr. 1st Add. LD RS6 RL RU 245 26 298A Gracemoor LD R96 RL RU TABLE 2 PPC Alternate Recommendation: RL Item # Fig.. Atlas Subdivision Current City Proposed City No. No. City TOP Zoning PPC LUP Recommenda - J- 4 246 27 308E Glen Ellyn LD RS6 '.RL RU Estates 247 27: 308B Pleasant Ridge LD RS6 RL RU Estates 261 7 '269B Stephenson's LD RS8 RL RU Hei hts 340 26 297B Oak Acres Unit 5 LD R96 RL RU 341 26 307B Oak Acres Add'. LD RS6 RL RU Unit 1 342 26 307B Oak Acres Add. LD RS8 RL RU Unit 1 345 18 307A - Gates Knoll. (and LD RS8 CG & RL RU vac. r-o-w) 365 15 31.4B Sall's LD RS8 RL RU 466. 48 281A 'Oakmount LD RS6 RL RU 475 26 307B Oak Acres Add. LD RS6 RL RU 488 29, 1.78A Wynwoods Landing LD RS4 RL RL 30 and Velventos 489 26 298A M&B 33/07 LD RS4 RL RL 490 52 301A Myron A. Smith's, C RS4 RL R Ba View Item # Fig. # Atlas# Subdivision Current City Proposed LRecommenda- y City Zoning PPC LUP LUP n 10 3 252B Windsor LD RS6 RS RU Woods II PPC Consistency Residential Subdivisions Page 2 PPC Consistency Residential Subdivisions Page 3 'TABLE 3 PPC Alternate Recommendation; RS Item # Fig. Atlas Subdivision Current City Proposed' City No. ,No. City LUP Zoning PPC LUP Recommenda- tion .8 4 262A Pinellas LD RS2 RL RS Groves 65 .40 264B Castle Woods LD RS6 RL RU 66 39 255B M&B 14'/151 LD RS6 RL RU and 14/152 TABLE 4 PPC Recommendation: Withdraw/Deny - RS to RU M Item # Fig. Atlas Subdivision Current City Proposed City No. No. City LUP Zoning PPC LUP Recommenda- tion 53 33 200B Eagle LD RS4 RS RL Estates 64 40 256A Home-stead LD RS4 RS RL Oaks 132 .55 317A, Country LD RS4 RS RL Oaks 133 55 317A Premier LD RS6 RS RU Place 141 39 255B Oak' Ridge LD RS2 RS RS. Court 142. 39 244B Chelsea LD RS4 RS RL Woods Phase . ZT 143 39 255B Part of M&B LD RS2 RS RS 14/13 " 1. ? ' I i , • ! ? PPC Consistency Residential Subdivisions Page 4 Item # Fig. Atlas Subdivision Current City Proposed City No. No. City LIIP Zoning PPC LIIP Recommenda- 144 38 244A Lake Chau- LD RS2 RS RS' tauqua Estates and Chelsea West 145 31 190A Michel LD RS2 RS R5 Tract '46.2 32 190A Turtle LD RS6 RS, P RU (Flood- Brook plain, not Pres.) 463 31 190A Landmark LD RS4 RS RL Palms, & Add. 464 31 190A Geiger LD RS2 RS RS Tract TABLE 5 PPC Recommendation: Withdraw/Deny - RE to RAJ Item # Fig. Atlas Subdivision Current City Proposed City No. No. City LUP Zoning PPC LUP Recommenda- 'tion' '80 43 263A M&B 34/022- LD RS2 RE RS 31 43 263A, Coachman LD RS2 RE RS 272A Ridge Tract A III 135 31 179A Oak Creek LD RS2 RE, P RS at Country- side Shada:rig:;`>xndcaes;:areas: o::agreemen :between 'CIEy. azxd:pPC :ta.' x.•^.4.4 r: V.:4::4.•.:.:. • .. .. i Suhdwn>,'tnb r ' t.' N •r# N N b N 41 1 ? tJ 1 •ri J-1 1 t•I:r N: 4 N N Ul M 4 N b 4 d) a W;Ill;?r1, O 4J U N •r1 $ 41 0 41 . ?; .: o ra 41 a ? r-i (!l sus. 41 O N q U O O :. in 44 4J . M 44 rd 44 'N 'Cf ; N O O rd •r 1 b U1 ?I O O O r1:fSSs.4) ' b o U Ur sw f~ r-I N N (J 0 u 0 8 P4 tU) : U]11-7'<U W U ? 41 Q ? CO) r7 U ? u 11 u C44 u rd .? q rd N s? r d r -1 d 1 0 r Z 41 U i 0 N w a) rd u a) 14 41 ai, . m u M m ' • _ ? ,? `" M rn w ? ? ?%] CT ro R? cf rd W i'.;.. •ri P rd [n 04 p 0' cn •ri 41 .5 4 w o A 10 x tD b 41 N •q £O 'f En Lin L) rd u a) Q) It 0 0 • 5 ? • U rd u rd N sJ d+ O i >? 1A 1i P4 sat N U1 O ..H fd N 4J ^+ u Z U) ? 4j, Ij Z fid U] 04 -f 'd ? U) N rd u a : z # N tD r Ql 01 O 0 4J U? . Ol U] 44 U? la) 0 U N rd rd U JJ O rd ro U v? vi w x q C •rl a tis O ?? N•rgi?' ?? 11 1.1 -r-I c 1!1 A O rd O ?? q q m a w 41 -I ? o 04 M Q} + D r 4 ul Q r^I d u 0 wU Q N CN R, Ncco NU w C to PQ IQ m r•I ' N m r}+ .44 In W I;v qzv V U A, N N N N N N N N b1 b ? A U U U N U U U U U U 43 44 D4 ?14 rX4 rX4 P4 P4 U U U U U U Ui? U U i ° A r 0 a P P4 a a a 114 Z r'7 M M .4 tp W tp d' ?, ` ?• C u . C 1 to l0 W W %D l- l? Y i 4t ? t tI ' ??, `. ,ts. r . .. N ` 3 .N' q r4i f y . y14 ?t . ?I b A A ?A ?? ' Vl,!i3" W U ? ., i -i ; tJ..: f] s Id tR f:? O iQ' sU y. 44 tw '?'. N .: U C7 U U' sU . ' <N < b q ' ; rdy ? .,, r1) rd f? o 'd 9 N Q} •r-f ? • x?- q W? rd a N N 4.) +N U tnq I ' p a U ` a> rd m rd H4)U, ? wq M rd O ' •b O m b v] •r,.? U G $4 Pd a rd O q ' co , W ? rd + U lJ r?l U ri ' m t74 [?D N rd \ 41 .? Q1 4j " 1 O • rd Lo 41 -W 4-r 9 U? . 01 rd 3 M ED m O N .rd 0) A •ri cri .0 bq m Ln U U a O ro a + rd x . u i ` N a . . o b r O .,44 N U o rn ,5?' ri of O d to " L N 0 rd Ln , rn rr d m n rd O r-I W . a' NMN?a N. f? !?,fx W N 1 rn ? O r rp . ri r i Ln -rr 43 W W Ol Ol 41 Ln V 0i N N" N N N N t y q U N U U U O U . U? U U U U ' P4 " W O r.? P4 ', P a 04 04 t; . -H O +'i d? m 0 O m ri P4 ',Z d''K4 v? to N m w Gl . • l0 N c- o b O Ln o , -f M o [) ,?T C0: ra ri ri N 4. 4 N< . Cd a O CSI I?I I .c2; Ste' {`,s. r.r; . ,. i''.. ...' 'i. ;r,a rj'; • Y ' i, .' , 7h: Proposed/Existincl Zoning Districts Key Standards RS-1 RS -2 RS -4 RS-6 RS-8 Minimum.Lot Area 43,560 20,000 10,000 7,000 5,000 .' Minimum Lot Width - Interior 100' 100 80 70 50 Minimum Lot Width - Corner 120' 100 90 .90 50 + Minimum Lot Depth -,Standard 100 100. 90 '85 80 Minimum Lot Depth - Corner 125 125 120 115. 110. Setbacks Front 35 35 30 25 ' 25 . Side 15 15 10 17, .5 " Rear 25 25 20 15 10 F '. Maximum Bldg. Coverage 25 .. , 25 30 40 42 Recommended Zonin g Districts s RS-1 RS-2.5 RS-5 RS-7.5 . Key Standards RS--2 RS-4' Rte- R£-S Minimum`Lot Area 30,000 12,000 6,000 ' 5,000, • ' , ' 'r 29;899 4'?A99 ?-09(? Minim' Lot Width - Interior 100 80 70 50 , Minimum Lot Width - Corner 100 , 90 90 50 Minimum Lot' Depth - Standard 103. 90 85 80 Minimum Lot Depth - Corner 125 120 115 110 ,Setbacks Front 35. 30 25 25 Side 15 10. 7 5 i . Rear- 25 20 15 10 Maximum-Bidg. Coverage 25 30, 40 42 r rya ' .. . ?•tl'N',?? . 7w,.? '£'r??. +3, a •???1. - ,i'ce' 1 . •.t$ a rid •f ; ?t,?+ Jt??, b'j' 't .'.:a .r •? - S'. ..?f . .t_ ,? ?.. . /. r k r?.? . ,.i$.!•. ?1 S 1, . ?1: ?•:?r•:="af i r r .1 r ! , i .. - .2i, ,` ?,? 4 I .•? ":" i ? ? ., t • ? t'• iryi; ? r Iii S: 1' ? ` ' ? CI i? l,?'{. ) •. ,j?s y; 1 r ,, .'?'E ' ( ??`, : • i ... .r,". , ' ' , ? - • ;,. J? ' ' ? • ' t " r r' _ 'i•? f ', .. ,5 ,}-y.!1X J ?, :^ ? t ,r k ?!t'. ' :1 ? '' ` • . t !, . . r.. r JJ?? . ,. k 1 Y(,.t , i' Il • ?Ix1`l',.r ?l ?r• ° ! ' r ., .. :. !}'• ? •'C' ' 'f • j' -. ,5 :?" i. ,! I < .• r r r k . ',f _ !7 .. r i ` 1 _ ' s ?,'F f ° r a 1' J. . r*i?- r•;,.r s , t ' x p, .S'.x ?-.y t"-.L?•?N?: ?R?i .!r .. , .. _ ? ' r.. •- ` G '•: ?}I r s, ?; .. ? , s - ? a : I zI' ' f J I < ? ? , , .. ? k . p ? ? ?.? ?. .., a •s •rf ' ^ ? ; ?4 ' a ' ? , " ' - ' ?{?? ? a ? F-, { 3e ' _ 1 , ? T a?r'`i ,?li / F.if ,`a r• ... ? r ; a ? ' . ? ' ' , ?'?. ?i ':1 ?_,:1.. :' : r. .. '•???''!?•I1`LI' 'q: ?Ct. tO?[i ?'d?: th'Y : t ? t ? {;:? I ' . .. y e • . . .. .•_ , .? , I r ._ .t r s .. .. tk[.M• ' •S ... • I K Y IT R : cc ao co 00 00 00.00 00 co 00 00 00 00 0 A 00 00 00 00 a r 1 r rl 10 ?O U) V) f w uw E/ a. tA tn 1I` , .,,• .. - ` d O 1 to ... 04 t? '7 00 t? .r .-. t? ? ?O M ?o-?O .o? 0o rl r? M O? ; . f r' ' R ? ? ? MNMZ t?in In In 6tol?lfi%oInr?In7 in InMtoIn •"rl s-+ d f4NC+? r?o,.•oIn nNaoe%-s'.4 wIn 00NV,•7ON `T t?-00Inf%IC III- o0411IM000 N In%aM' tOri4 . ? .` . - Z O ? 1 N In m -f c,4 0 0 0 0 N O P o In .•+ Z N t? M ' '. t NI 8 • r1 M . q ti ?O 'T C7 M r ..= tp ' ! ? r ? Y ? J ?! r • ! , a t , • .. - r f: . 1 - Q ?, ; W r , r art ; 3 ; I y , . s ;tJ r' r- cl ca O O > O • 1 :Q F p .. J d aj'C r 3 ¢N 0 tst? rn , a?';" , : • . CJ %0.0% %0 'N N N N In N co 00 In It to W M 7 In to N N M to .•+ 7 Q `r K• 7 .7 R M to to n•1 .+ .r, O O% '4 7 ' ' I r v (` co O. 4 00 - In 00 N M N M ,`? In t, 00 O l? 0 In, %40 %* b kb %a -r, In to 00 ?o %C i r ' L 7 K 7 a•• fy •r.•-• -r r n co 00 0% Q? 11 N N N e q, M . rk. 94 to 'In 91 d u U IA -c , t s ` F SSS • ^ ; r ? . a - . ? ?'-FS ' ? ? ??r ? '," - ; :,;.?r ? {r'( S,t •y. . . s. P _ "t?.. ''1r .I.'.'. ?. .. ? f, ltr _ •'1 fit.' ; f!.' r 1 .?'Y .,. d•? ,^,,,tY}1it'4ykl ity r .... tel. s ..^ ?-f. ? ,•P„ .. •.wa ?.M r. r.l » .p'.. . r r s .. S':K., }, d `f tA'1'R'ty. Cd 04 c cc a? a? ??a? ?Z1 c a a `a? c+c a ac ?a ?` Ic?:'`? a . `7'' •'^ 00'TCO ..T thin M?.n ?Ot+KfrU1?D Ra,,MMI- rya y NN 00?t?otgrlR%Otj t-: 4-i O?V?O?00NC5 7 vO00000 x+00 ' Q f+1 '7 M ? ?f M fn en % fn -f fn -7 rn 'f '7 to n en `T tai fn n WIN p '.'): , '.ti • VS R ?O N ?d °t v1 K ?tl N f~ f` T? N M o0 .•, %o rf C'TmmN?C?O}OIt-1OMPrnMG V1Mt- D6N R?ONM'Obt 1 y r*f o1 Or?N?w V?tir!7IllKN?•f?aNNO??MNNMerJlC7 , • Q O d •? rr 00 7 %O G Q O O O O fa G O, O O p =, CD C• O, O^ C7 C , ?',r it 1 7 . ; , ? .. ?} ' '. .F • :? ' r F "er' A 00 kh Z M r'lr "1 N N N .. N N N A••r N C,4 , PC $A LA 'In a, L. kn .?. 1 g IA S b q a« u u ouo ti ,' b' ?t ?. a r;.r MPC :wooi? w ea h •t a ton u B r'.7 V cti `? b V'? w O'GC :" VI N N p'ti r. 94 V e y a, r, oo nc a+ a 4e 1+. H l"' B e 1°n u u' u :AC c v } 'a Tsl :.? a ? b ,a ? a a ..7 ?? `c ?t at :s ?, W ca a 4 wt Q ? E 'C , F w a ar `u• "_ ,°? '°1'?° a s to ?s a s: . tn' C7Vcaxu°?UU .2 !! cq Ga er e"a a °° ed :eG n000C00, N t-l1cvYln7MOO Wf+6%0KK.1)r-r%ot- r %0 %o%4D 00 4100 0 u ?O r1 r-y +? rr M 7 7 7 17 r1 IT 7 K K 7 rl rl' N Y- rl rl rl - .?+ K N i ' N ?° n rn ?n rs t? ,-r a ., N tn v> >a m . U N O+'w m to 7 N p G O rl 7 7 K ?O ?'T 7 R K %0 %D r- .+M-r -rKtnoo.?-,Ar-,rrNNraraNNNIll en Mfn r m17 "r , 4 ??lr 'r x i '. a .. .. ', ., . •i. r' 1. 't;?r; !f?2 F.?a? •iv' '?Y`°;Y..;; ?°`s'. ..?? Cdr-` ,;? - •?. {. - '`' - i'•d': 'fi`?;tt`•aak-.mss€ :4 k. `;,'. ,[Y' ?, eyf',? .•i? `S.k?••!'''?'i:L'?-?. ?, f ` , - ., •?r ' ? r: ,' f f.l,'! f.. ,r'I , . •r r I, . , r. ..t 'S?t.• :?r't,. ?; rr'd,r.+,{?f, ??f.; ., ?. .?i{aj`:"?'• "yl.o-?l ,r' ?'? ? '_ .. ??' ? 'e ''' ^q':fj".1' T F*,5,??? r?f• ?i S .' ,?Y Ir?'IT'. .?'S `{.f'. `,? '? ? ? , a I - e ^?r?: .'?µ?.•rk'} ?!' ".art ` ,t'? ? ' , r.l, `i'.' ? '. .? ? .. . . ' , • `a ??bia?J'h'•,te.:? ,'??`•?• ,c.;?1; is{aA.7r ? `,!t, :r' ta., ... - ? .. ? .. i?'''t. :t• v 'x5'1?svril. ,0'• .•af`?:€:}• `.?` ='f -',?4 .. t , •j tf,r i' .blr,1 ?''1. ,.x • ••°', . ?•r' ` ''°yiJ•S..'?''/`i i.•.=• h; :' .l : ?• f ''j :r' ? .'"+„. ?' lr,.': y' • •i?,?,'°' `p? .'l' I? . tfs +", ys ;3 , , [ . .. - r . f , j t, ,+• r.,?tr I IT fr ` •? i-.r :'j'' ^sJ k 'it ',SY h ?.' 1 ! ' , ;. I ,! r'f ,• ,t 1' ," ++..,.z >, ,T "'',r •1`x'1 ' s t .''lr •+,'.:? <.1 ;, ?•.'? , S , i ?< ` , •,? ,???Y?4?}". ?',t,'"._i:,•l':.i',."?? .t: ,;?•.?5=?+..???t:i:??.,.aFlrf'?`L..i-... .?.. ,<... "° .. .. .l r ,. ..' .. ? ?..' ., ?., 'r. ^'p '•-e.. .,r.:: .. °,'?N t, ', t '•'! N N N N r) 4A 4L •t K +4 f? ? ?.' .. .'t . H It R F In 00 Oi M , rI I • Y4? 00 00 M M O' . 4 C* 4D K O.O 00m K 11 In .. r??'... '. ? N .•i ,?ri ri ..w 4 .. M N' rl N N .. N ... r . IT" . 4D ..,, r+ N 4d ON lt.: i.• r ? . V ,? f- ? en N 00 ? ? "? G? fr7 yD yD N, K OQ ? - ? . •' ? • '•?: s I R, M K O ri ?. r-r K N .-+ l+j .+ 00 O% , € to 00 a oo O\ o U l ??;', - '_ ?O.1 n00 K N.. r1 .. rl N Go 96 ,'. .. N N0 H E? as k :3 L. m M a z U ei u u q u w= w E ' ? ohm a ? u r ? ' ad a •°`' ? a s°a ? ? . ?'?:? VS U O .3 U a C7 3' U W x G. U In C7% O, oo w r K r*, o IA Cps N ?.+ t , '.S U to M M en rl M M r'l , ' r1 K V) M M en , . . , '? "frl rl N en . . I rl t r l K? t/1 ?T C K M `t K yO ?O In In -r -7. ','f' !4 '. ,,Jc :i?"•,t,jt : r`.?.fi :', i.?'.J?, if.s:... i ;-•: r.. •<•; ,' :rk ", , 1 i; . ?.,•i.: 'F .1•' /'- .1 :):'. r. :f .r r.y.,.-.,. 4... S' i , " --r!,rl.'-d firy.: 4., 'Gds i :+ ,o ri r ;::'J,i' 1 1.., r i"r { ' ?` i 1, i 'r..;. .;h ;::Li l?ti{?.. ei • s ' ,• 1 "a {F w.Y¢ '??it f •F•?„ *:•, „1 r I" .. , '3. „ !" , . ? ? 1-1 ' 1. "5:.?ft L! .? ` '•s t E `" ' ' Y :'`e, ,Irf.e 1:... I.II \•. ',i'•?'c if ,, , ^I'' !}, !. `, y? ? :7 tt a i''; ''L r, :L: 'R f' " l , , . r/ , .. r y' S d,,;;?'/.,?7r •A+o :'i,' 'f ,;i, V. r.fa ..f.I.{?- c.. t. 't' r , c .. r .?'^ ,;4Q'y ?f . , p'c' '' I , t.r t: . I. Sri -;{ .;' +•r `'; .? '; . , ',' r r . - • ! a ° tv. V ?'_';,.: ; 9s' . e i ,si. : f . .4"':' , t' Y f' Ai`I:'1i SL'' t. l ' :.r? ? i?,t? tS}i r.. ::1.. ,i. rrt ' Y' it s t;. i..';`. ,rt?F.: .I< ." ., t:: 't.{`, r1 € 1•.". i` I. r J 1 I } . , ., • .,i''.=ir?'. '3 r?'IZ .v ',;,,?I`j%', rr''' -,r' J "Si; E.7; ''?;;'11 'r r ? •;, .. ',: ,. ., :s` 1..IP,.,y A I;:i •` r L 4 .'!{u ?.. ., .f' !'? '1 #;,.. { i p ?.{' ? 1. . J -.y •tii-'j". ? t: :h .' •'?:f,/ .:•'L, ''i' ,..f f..q f"`. h) ">E :itrt, .? rt."5 f , r. `n - r7. :r?J7,, •!,'',L?'.Y:`'t1 .S'i1- rf. •' 'i'r ,,F E: ?ti1f `.S j °1 ?.. , '.e, r , J r ?'J ,. :._37;x ., 'Ir , ; . •r•.i': `.i,ji.,° 'a c . y _,f ,Y1,'; 3,', r'r ' r •!. i 1 r. ..5 ,' Z ,1 I w-l`,Y i .rr .I I ' ' ? N' f .,i ' Li . '1 r?` . _ R. F?- , 4 i,• ; ' r' ,rd' ..t_.. J .i- .it '? :1'.: i >;' '`a 's` .y ..,; .. f; ;E t. ':]", " r . r Sl •. : l { :£ 'i, .; Yi: .°, 't ,: ldsJ.ti._' . i'. , G, "S' Ab ' , . t .a. J r :_? ,y ' ` 5 r j r ' :w '.• : ! .'.'', `*rl # rtk 5; 4. ,,`?; "i a'. ?ri° ` - ?I e ' •S'? i,. ,•, xl.y:..t j',?r" , r' !, _ as 1 , ^°i°i : y;. , .a. L i`' ''i ;.?'r ^ r'', i•. ; i a _ . :?!'? ,d. ?1' 'i.` i 1,''k' ,r=,?i..;: ?i??rf f.' • "! ? ?;' -? r i' , '4•. r. `;R' 'f,. pi' "r 't' -r .':,,ti ,: ri II'.d j, - .ji V,?,. ..i f°r:. "L ..k '( 'f: 1 r 't'` ^;t',9 L :3 '3 i'1 ,l: rl';'}r . E.. r't,, n+,• Yt is tt?P`- H",? ?#Y•: ..s•'e ?k 't, ',i' f ,. ,I .. `'1 i.' _f 'r !,Y fi ?t, r? t1"Y.eK,rG{:. _, . '.+ ,i .i ?'. ...t.,y :i'.,?.n?.h{rt",1'itT'`'. ???f ? t .r` , .. t. i-, F i r,, , 3L; at1' `k° `i ') :s f'' :f -?, ti •! Y{''']•}h; ?Ih. ,4( . .y alil •E' , •' i 1 ;iY' !. ;i'.i [' s. ' e:if ? . 't ?4 .+. y{x?'t: l-. kf J,I('e" '' ' 'r?. 1. : .:R. iii.- t'! =?.I . .?'e :l: { 3,.1 L , i - 'f ', 1'. r"tH L-.f ,f(r, .l?Iry' ;If '.L' ty.i .'".,1! 1A 1)w- f`. L, r ;! Y l...L x'^ t:hr ..11 !! Lt.;.;i t',' 'a .t`::it..}: 'r, ,t. °r,f}': i?4.;:E, -I, 4,,.r4., .. a-:).; ? ':,. .. ? ,i:? 1( ' ;t :l. 7. ,t i,'i.,.,.{i? .+• .? R;s?; ?. '' ,. I- .'rI - .3, t:,i 'ills ir. "ti, i'!a' :E; Jt "', f ,. .r!k.i i"J'J 1 .I:. I i- ' °'r.r;, 't;' I',':.,v I] E• .?a'z.c,j ,r yfi.';1..' :fj? . of§§ r t'?. ,•,'??? . t'.. 'r f O.1 r,. ? '?. .J 'i•' °L?1" ? :i.Fifi"i ,l,; r#, :.1" 'l.r •f is f,' .. ' L j.'. Y: m? r*btaiJ.:? 1 •?tKn i'..: a:, 't .1 k ,rl 4?i;J '.? a, 3..'. :.. , , ... l.,,, ... zi':'G lr? •I rr •.' .. ri' r ..r • r , . ' ` , ,i '(ri 9 }.1" ! . . R ' , r .t? ' . , . 1 r ` '.r I' , . I.?'r.!:6° ,z.,, , , ' N ' ck'. GAG , . ' - I. , r, ,'ti'.i'. 7. f , . 1i. , , .. I . =, r' t ,:.? , r 1i'?' .; `j,`i'j ; z, . . . . .N . . . , I _. . . . e ; i 1 r(, P ":yt, t, f .11 : , I .. i.y), °.7'F', ?rr',.4 . - , . I , Nr.a , ., '. .1 ? - 1, I ? . I . . .? *. I I , ? *1 "' ? , , 1, , ? . . ., , ? . ?' . . , I .1 I . , ? , , , , '. I i " r., airy,' I ' ..''ty . - i • 'f.• .. .t: ',• ??,'': :.•.: is ' , ,?,.. . , . I ; , I ri yry5i3_.J .n'.t.;., .'f+ . : d : ` - ' ' d .. j - s t,,- {it f.`f fir.' .`' s: . •4' . • 1 .- , C1 ., . i. L ', ' .? r'"',';; ., H Fr , d tom„ •if . _ ; , r, . ' 'wM%? ,. J: ;_ },r. F . :'r - , . i' ylif 's„ r' f { .4 , rr. 41 .r f ,t, ?.' . I. , , . - c Y G, t .. , ' n ', , i, .i ,.kFE t % 4 :. r . 'P ' ' .' I ' . I i m ' = 61 161 W t , t 1 a'L 0 - ? ? tAl L . I L."?.?!; " ij?. , I , , ? '!? { 1 11 I :1 1/11 f ?`aJ a .. ' .I' '? , , I I '3 , 1.. f: - 91 i ,,, 'E,.:i, 1 a fF; Homeowners Association P.O. Box 14455 Clearwater, Florida 34629 TO: Wynwoods Landing Residents From: Wynwoods Landing Board of Directors January 19,1993 Subject: Pinellas Planning Council's Letter (Dec.30, 1992) Clearwater 93-2(488)- Southeast Corner of Curlew Rd. and Lakeshore Lane (66th St.) This tract of land containing 34.26 acres that is designated 488 on the Pinellas Planning Council's Land-Use Classification Map involves the 75 lots of Wynwoods Landing, 12 lots of Wynwoods Landing II around Brewton Court to the North and 7 lots on the South end between Wynwoods Landing and the Florida Power right-of-way. The original. Countryside area was developed under the'City of Clearwater zoning plans which shows areas on the map'.to the South along Northside Drive and Countryside Blvd, and the East along Northridge Drive where the residential areas are designated (RU) Residential Urban which has a maximum of 7.5 units per acre.. The residential areas to the West which include subdivisions of Curlew City and Trails of Countryside.as well as the area directly to the North in Palm Harbor are under County zoning and are designated (RL) Residential Low which has a maximum of 5 units per acre. Since the tract of land designated 48B being originally in the county area-was later annexed into the Countryside area by the City of Clearwater in the early to mid 1980's, it is believed it' carried the (RL) Residential Low designation with the transfer. In,talking with a Clearwater Planning and Zoning Board Representative it was learned that this'requested change of Land Use Classification from (RL) to (RU) is to attain a uniform plan in the Countryside area of Clearwater,'which has been the philosophy of the City's Planning and Zoning Board for years. In discussing this Land Use Classification change with representatives of the Pinellas Planning Council they stated that the 488 tract is practically built-out and since the units per acre are near the present classification of-(RL) at 5•units per acre that the classification should remain . unchanged. They-are presently meeting with Clearwater Planning and Zoning to attempt to hold (RL) and that a letter is being.sent to-the residents to state that this item-on PPC's agenda for Public Hearing will be continued (not heard) until February 17, 1993.' They further related that recent court hearings have precidented that Land Use f , ?t 1 .,15 ' 1 4 ..,A . + , KA= fr RL 'm ; l ) KL , + I1 r sP P 0 1 +. ? RLk t RL? ? e . 4 1 \ i I a]J I Rim} `, ?J f RL' t I ! I s n!sP r I ,11 I m fw ov R RV P/5P RU Hv ri{u a j xu r/Sr I .. . v a/os ` RL r r S WATtR P AL 1 ` I ' + I I F77 f r1 r/ar + RU of 1 v?Y..M ri v v .+ Y ?/ p --4 Rb?1i G J- SptCL1?i, AY?tONATiON RR ? !t/OL a W cm r `- iuIm"74" RE R/OG CL u= R/0s \`\\? R9 R/O/R i F/ RL ,... CG g CRD Qamo amts a nn?r?Kt RU w' RrM M racvstt? INUtT9'I IAL riAnox/ Cgp o rum , HLIL MIM RFIi aca ?&tu 1LL SCALE 1" =600' R1I IG aa?s*s?t PINELLAS PLANNING COUNCIL RVII CR1$l3:C5 PREPARED BY Tom! OPFICt OF PII'1LI1.A.9 COITPt'i'Y PRpPMrY 1I'PRAISER, IAII SUM[ GWMCS PRNPMMD USING MEDIT YOMION 211 0 f1J:'t?r ik`:.+•r-x€A?r,'::4a. "r?r. ••s°. ;. 4. ,. + ... '1• .4 .r• ?- ! J? f' r t. ,. 6? ,fYrrr.. ?•'?',•r....ly' ,?S ??. ??yi.,?=? .!'.f ?'r. r?P.r •a '(i 1,r 3+1.;f"' .+ •r•- ,s :?? ... ? E ? ?a ^.{?.F ta'• ?Y'F. 'i?'+. ,r ti.~t `'?-, , ? ? .. 1 ,? ??e , .'f a ,fir ? .:?.; i,?''r"•.e1 ?•'-,?'4'-'n' ' '1; le '1 ', frg' 9f? •+ ? , ..• , r f f ? ?; g},',It. k. '1'7, r r?3.•-, ?. .5r. ' rf; _ .i, r y 4 j `. ???y +., .l `:1„ ?'? '(('l!;?1.• ;1' f, t: ? ? , ? 1, 'S ? t?'CC .?{F?: r.?. 1;'', =r - .r?? '1 ?a ,»'?''t•j1' .°1 f 'lr . Ir' ?r .•ff;: ?•?,1..? rt?1:; ,`s? fir. :,g. •.1 r _ rk. Y': - 3. ( :+, r t ? r ?Jr"r` +.g':i° ',i; :r4??•r+«:•r ^•1 rr' ? -?6 +'v3' , j, -f. ,'!y':,, j??jH'.. ; r,';°.ri{??_ ..;at; •1~J ??'? 1?.'r'i1,• ?4? • .'FJ I. t •,1 ? ? ? ? ' r' ,r ? ? ? ?, r ? t .'f' = ',A r?.?? ,,?7f"y 's: f J?f• , :j #°? . yt ? ?.° ,r' +??^, :'?, - r ? J ?, IY . ? •? ''i? ry4 rEf(:+';.Y'F 1, [??•! n'ri ?•?<F. '_r. `',1. .f f1 „iro?".Il ..'r:?j':'.'!!?? ''r ?' ?4- f 1•? ? ? n ? L ? t, ??t,???i;,+, `"?i• 'Y`.{.t`i. C`' i ,]{{. ;'f^' 4':v":•,F..fa,?, .i. F. .r r• {. ,r. !', •'4S ???lL,?:?t'fr?r `?: 3 'r' a'?, i'.r' v? _. n: .,r, i' 1r :?' '! i'f. - , •??i, ?-1; :•?? dr .? ;,E f;?°1' .i, 'z`??;'.`i; e:',' `s?+.,4.; •t ,1,. '? a'",y] -?`.. ; .. .r rj"!{ _°? ?9.,?fn. >'• ?r i r,?re i : ,+.''J' r°r• '' r . rj l ''i ,R;• 1? '1 .i 1?.,+. .+a,? ,?. ?+?,, ,-?,'i.' .? ?r r?'Q ,i. '' _ r.•' `s` • ? ,r,l r ..5, "? ` brl . `?fs?.:.`y''y: -' "i'J ,+..s' yr, =+• 'rs+ v ? .. _ ' ?,;• ;7 t.•lr Si:> '? ?' ?'j ,r, t?;Y "ti}•"t r l?6 t.?`Ir ,S ° rF. lr °? r'. ,i d .d •• 3•r .g•.p--ti l•.`v1," ?. L?„'.t.i.:r +C 6•gi};-f it4, hh,?. .,176 .. -i. ('` :'I ?,yf, Y:€{?;C'Y7dt `kS;.I..,i T.?.. ... ., a.. ?. -.f?7j ,F:?r•'Y•?s tl:..k?4. ?.y.., ^F//ts4'.., .:4rrr:?R??. i" r - , , .!r: .'y. ,; r, .i.., .. .. "t. ., ,l•'?:a.a'S??Q ??,F ?? r• ,. ? s ? ? ? ? ? ? fir. - ? ? ? _ 1. E-IN • fr+ J. • 1 j• J.-?1 DATE MEMO* ITEM 3y ?: i '.`r r •. Fr ,(? 'r i. .• .. ? 1' ' j ? ? ? f ' ?, , v 1•' d ? ,, J :1 ?r3 Y k, r; '.. ? i?: ?.,' r• ? '1 , .. ? r. , . ? '2 ? - ,4. ? ? ? rl ...,' f .• y r•?: , I ' ORDINANCE NO. 5332-93 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF 'CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY REZONING CERTAIN,PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF VENETIAN DRIVE, APPROXIMATELY 500 FEET WEST OF NORTH FORT HARRISON AVENUE, CONSISTING OF.LOTS 10 AND 11 AND PART OF LOT 9, BLOCK 12, NORTH SIIORE PARK SUBDIVISION, ,AS DESCRIBED MORE PARTICULARLY HEREIN, FROM MULTIPLE-FAMILY. RESIDENTIAL "EIGHT" (1111-8) TO SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 11EIGHT11.(RS-8) DISTRICT; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the amendment to the zoning atlas of the City as set forth in this " ordinance is found to be reasonable, proper and appropriate, and in compliance with Florida law now, therefore, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY, COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: t Section 1. The following described property, in Clearwater; Florida, is hereby rezoned, and the zoning atlas of the City is amended as follows: Property Zoninq__District Lots 10 and 11, and part of Lot 9,, From: Multiple Family Residential Block 1, North Shore Park Subdivision. "Eight" (RM-8) .(Z92-10). To: Single Family Residential "Eight".(RS-8) Section 2. The City Commission (foes hereby certify that this ordinance' is . . consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan. Section 3. The Planning and Development Director is directed to revise the zoning atlas of the City 3n,accordance with the foregoing amendment. Section 4. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption. PASSED ON FIRST READING March 4, 1993 PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL READING AND ADOPTED Rita Garvey Mayor-Commissioner Approved as to form and correctness: Attest: M. A. Ga rai,t , r. Cynthia E. Gou eau City Attorney City Clerk cc, K4 y) (A ecL . s t s P 44 'fit .!r?P jl .14 t • ! ? 1: r ': i ? -- - , 4 fir' .' r;, 1 k ' ' 12 14 115. 16 17 10 19 20 21 1 4 yy W b hhh??? ? ? . ? ; ? ti f ei 4 ?'?•e U FI IV E RS 8 2 2 2 1 err n1 1? 2U 27 2G 25 2,? IA 10 ? j r U 31r A - - ?. • ?'-. `' inns 7 1a3h 32 A L / C 6 M3 J 33 M1.1 ` 4 d 1 1 0 5 R M L --?" -- 1 ? _-------•- v?ra??Inr? ars1?E I , 611 117 16 r 6 3 2 ... 1..._•____ ?__.. .,.........? ._..-•----- -• 7 ,1117(17 ?. -• ._. ? ... ?. -. I 10 II 12 13 14 1r Q. 17 r LEDEAU SIREET ...... f 2^ 17,12 9 Zt 7 G 5 4 `3 .2 nsn T ___? -4--? 1117 tU •12 13 Iii 15 16 17 4 ?? • _ _; - --1711! __ b ._.. s! .. , ... a..... b .. !;! ? P ?n - i 4 $a of I V) FRO ^iar's o ul ; O ?. r i3ji ?CO M9 iiss 5` Ira t .-. ...:.. ter-• PROPOSED REZONING aEv ISED 0?-o owNhR o w E" S ' z 92. Io APPLICANT CITY OF GL.EA RwA-TC- R PROPERTY DESCRIPTION ZONING ' LbTs 1,0 1 it ? PA RT L.vT C1 , FROM P, M $ N0RTN Sk-? o RE PA1ZV, To' R S $ PLANNING and ZONING BOARD CITY COMMISSION SECTION' pL{ TOWNSHIP a RANGE 15 E ATLAS PAGE 21j9 G • Single F.mllr ` i 'f t r ? ,.1 l l 1 S y r. • ' _,4 ' I V t ' ?SEAI?? ^ _•;? ? CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION 15 Agenda Cover Memorandum Item • ?q `? `pQ' ?' ?? .Meeting ']ate: 37 93 hMM.r? Subject: ` PAGING SERVICE Recommendation/Motion: Extend the contract with Pac-Tel Paging, St. Petersburgr Florida for paging service for the contract period 04/01/93 --.03/31/94 at an estimated cost of $12,939.17. U and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: Paging service is used by 12 city department's/divisions to enable contact with personnel both during duty hours and after. This-award consolidates the annual service for all departments /divisions. This is the first'renewal of two available authorized in the general conditions of the original bid. There will be no change in prices,or terms. The 1992/93 various departmental operating budgets includes sufficient funds for this-contract. Reviewed by: A N Originating Dept / 'Legal DpAS/Purchas: Bud et g Purchasi g User Dept.: Risk Mgmt N A Various DIS ACM Advertised: N/A Other Date, Submitted by: /J •.! `j?`Q alit Pair: • ®Nat required Affected parties {l ? Notified City Manager ® Not required irk' 'Ir ? ) Costs: ' 12939,17 Commission Action: Iota! Approved $6469.59 ? Approved w/conditions Current FY ? Denied 0 Continued to: Funding Source: ? Capt. imp. ® Operating ? Other Appropriation Coda: Various ' Attachments: None , '?;:a?''r;S:d"'"" .?' ?'?'' ;'x+1f. ti'??''1,?'''•-. ?.. 1,. .,_ , . /1. '; ' ' ? ? " 1 ''' • r ? ? ? ` ; ,{ - :t ''a°.?+'' l .'1," .t °r .'a t..,; tr, i ':r ; _ ' ...? ` ???"'?/;''?'?l Y i{S f 4• ? ; . .f j ,?; i'. "< . y x? . . ? F. ? ' f fI 1 F , . _ . : ?, y ;•w '? a7 ?? a jam' -1 .. ? ' r . r ? ?i xS?t . ' • S?ry 1, .. r, 4p f ?r i "i::? •?`? `, 1 ;., ? ?,' 'r. 3,E' ' ?r.?'1?K . s 3 '. 1 r r• ' ' • , , f t •f ? . 'y: ' ' . a ? •1 " ' : f l ' 'r?r ' F. .,.tr , f 1 ??- ?,1 rtr > t ° L . .. ] c / .. . f. ./ .. rj, ?r' ' r1 ?R n ? / t e i,r . • • r i ?, J . , . • j ;?? .lx••j J. •r'? r '? 1'{'•Y?,? '?' ?• 1 ? r ' .. d . '' ,J'. f{'. 1, ,y: F:r ? . ? ' -r ? s : S„ _ r, , . ? l i 'E ? , r ? 1? x: x ' ? 1 G-!\ ?b? ' ' ? r ? -'.1. ' i '? r.. .??., '?. ?. ? }' p' s ? '?. • Vii p ? a , _ , • a ' / '' ? •" :` ' ' ` ! r •?P .J,?ii•? ?• ? ?1S _ . . . 1. • ? 5 .; ; l. ..? . ' " ' t , Sk t f ! M '1 r . . ? ,? '.. la YYr339 S TS 4:i ] ., ; ?. ?•.. dE •; i I - 1• ! i?R'-? r s y ' Y ' i i'1 ' 1s 1 l?. ! . t. jV ?' / .r { , ... !' . 4'I < .• :r A ri , 7? • , v3{,?; a; 1 ,.'t ':e f?,.r.' r? ?'? f t+ ' ., s- rr ? ? ?' ) ? ? ? 1 '?? .''? s?' ' , . ?.7• ,. .'??...?.a?o,r,':S°. ??:?:?<t'''?:,-Lts.,'.Yr.°r:..h ':?:?,. '..;.,>' _ .. 1 ? r ? '.. ,l _ a • °'fdi ... . r y ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES iz5ot? aoosevalt Blvd' March 5 1993' St:13} Petersburg; Florida 33716t, T' (8 5i 3•ie00.' , BRADENTON. Cif Of' Clearwater, 68i5? lath Street 4V„ =101 y o 'Sraaentori; Florida' 34207, , Attn: George McKibben, ' Purchasing ?e?3?i?58-t36o6 714 Maple Street `PXbll HARBOR Clearwater, FL 34615 Crass Country',Plaza 'P?'Im`H&oor..Florida 34683 te13j 766•eco2 ° ' . Dear W 'McKibben: -TAI'l1PA ;330244 Kennedy. .+ _ As per our phone conversation, of March 1 ,,*rnoar:Ftorida 32609. ,ai3?'sr:»500. will not. raise the current paging rate structure °:sACsotwil.LE City 'of Clearwater. PacTel Paging is very. ple 4133,Phillips Highway, ;17o the City of Clearwater's'pagin`g-needs for the -Jacksonvillu, Florian 32256 forward to along continued relationship in,thE •(904) 363.2970 a?taNDa Thank you, , '.5125 Adanson Street, »475 ' /Ollando: #Iorlda 32804 '(407),7,10-8 181 r ?t.'r[? G'••? ?/ 2' SOUTH ORLANDO' ,Florida Mall Business Center ' Dennis W. Kohler. . -1650 Sand'l.ake Rd. `:Orlando, FL 32809 Sales Super.visor ;,(407) 856.4561 FORT MYERS ' Villas Plaza -DWK/ce .12377 Cleveland Avenue,.:; 1 B c Fort Myars, Florida' 33'307 •' '(813)275.1818 . 1 A-5 , CM PAGER CONTRACT E XPENSE CODES AS/Computer intormation Services 555-09860-544100.590--000 Display with vibrator, 2 ea 139.80 Economic Development 010-09216-5441010 ' Display only 1 ea 57.60 Emergency Management 010-09217-544100• " Display with vibrator 1 ea 69.96 r Clearwater Gas System 423-02061-544100-532-000 Tone Only 28 ea :.. Display-only 11 ea Display with vibrator 3 ea Sky-Tel 2 ea 3,734:61 Genera'l' Services/Administration 566-06510-544100 Display with vibrator 6,ea 419.40'. Planning 010-01400-544160 Display with vibrator 1 ea 69.96 Police 010=01145-544100-521-000 Display only 100 ea " Additional Address 1 ea Networking 2 ea Group Call- 2 ea 7,19.9,16 PW/Environmental 010-01360-544100 ".Display with vibrator 1 ea 69.96 PW/I/Public Service 421-01346-544100-535--000 Display with vibrator 4 each 279..60 PW/Transportation Group 010-01331-544100 7 Display with vibrator 5 ea 367.80 , 1 '.PW/Utility Administration 424-02081-544100 Display with vibrator 1 ea 69.96' PW/U/Water 421-02051-544100-533-000 Tone only 7 ea Tone/Voice 1 ea Display only 1 ea ' 461'.16 GRAND.TOTAL $12,939,17 i s M, • Clearwater City Commission ' = `04 Agenda Cover Memorandum SUBJECT: RETENTION OF OUTSIDE ENVIRONMENTAL COUNSEL t Meet 03/1a/93 RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Award a contract to retain the legal firm of Akerman, Senterfitt & Eidson, Orlando, Florida to serve as special environmental, counsel in matters related to the'Department of Environmental Regulation investigation of the former Clearwater Manufactured Gas Plant site at a cost not to exceed $40,000, in accordance with City Code 2.564 (1)(e):, impractical to bid, ® and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND : The Department of Environmental Regulation (DER)- has begun an investigation of the old Clearwater Manufactured Gas Plant site, The site investigation and "remediation will require outside environmental counsel to assist staff in. addressing this specialized issue. Counsel will provide legal and technical experience and support to Clearwater- in negotiating site related requirements with DER. William Pence of Akerman, Senterfitt & Eidson, was selected on the basis of experience. Mr. Pence has had substantiated previous experience with the technical, regulatory, and legal issues associated with former manufactured gas plant sites. Currently, Mr. Pence is working on 7 former manufactured gas plant sites around the State. He has been retained by Gainesville Regional Utilities, West Florida Natural Gas, Central Florida Gas Company (1 site each). and for Florida Public Utility Company (4 sites). in order to provide funds, the Gas Department is requesting a mid year budget amendment to increase the Professional Services operating Code 423-02061- 530100-532--000 by $40,000 to be funded out of retained earnings. Reviewed by: L ! ari inn ing Dept: CIlarNater Gas System Costs: S 40.000 Total Ggmrission Action: d ega , Approve Budget h i h l $ 40 000 O Approved u/conditions Purc as ng i e Risk Mgmt. N/A User Dept. , Current Fiscal Yr. 13 Denied CIS N/A ACM N/A CLearuater Gas System Funding Source: ? Continued to: other 13 capitol imp. Advertised: Operating Attachments: Date: Other Contract for Services Paper: t Re uired ® N q o Af fected Parties Approisriation Cock: ? None t ® Notified 423-02061-530100-532-000 d 11 Not"Required a t PrT?ited on recycled paper 1 '. r. .. r _;E 'tt..tr '.? . r .. a r.S. 1• .... f.A AKERMAN, SENTERFITT 8 EIDSON, PA. i ATTORNEYS AT LAW ' /IRSTATC TOWLR ` 255 SOUTH ORANGr AVENUC ' ' POST pFFICC nom x31 • . ORLANDO, FLORIDA 32002-0231 (407) 043-7860 ' T[LCCOPY (407) 643-6810 ` y r ' March 2, 1993 • Mr. C.. S. Warrington,. Jr. ' Clearwater Gas System. ,.400 North Myrtle Avenue Clearwater, Florida' 34615 Re: Representation of Clearwater Gas System in connection with Former Clearwater Manufactured.Gas Plant-Site Dear Chuck: This.will follow up our previous telephone conversations and our meeting last Friday concerning,the City of Clearwater's,needs for special environmental counsel to assist the City and Clearwater Gas'System in' responding to liabilities associ.atedrwith the former Clearwater manufactured gas plant (11MGP11) site. I previously provided you, by letter dated January, 9, 1993, with' a brief description of my experience at similar sites in Florida. Following our.meeting, 'you requested that I provide you with a formal proposal for the services sought by the City of Clearwater. This letter will ' serve as the proposed terms and conditions of our representation of the City of Clearwater and Clearwater Gas System in this matter. Akerman, Senterfitt & Eidson proposes to serve as special environmental counsel with respect to the investigation and remediation; if necessary, of environmental impacts associated with the former Clearwater MGP site. At present, we anticipate that this representation would include, but not be-limited to, the following: (i) assistance in negotiations with the State of Florida Department of Environmental Regulation .(11FDER11) in response to FDER's issuance of Warning Letter #WL92- 0021GW52SWD, dated December 17, 1992; (ii) assistance in the review of proposals from qualified consultants to conduct contamination assessment. activities on site;; (iii) negotiation of a Professional Services Agreement with a qualified consulting firm to conduct contamination assessment activities on site; (iv) review and revision of work plans and reports prepared by the, environmental consulting firm selected to conduct contamination assessment .wlp/letters/warrington 7537/67833 ORLANDO • MIAMI` TALLAHASSEE • TAMPA , i'f U+ i Mr. C. S. Warrington, Jr., March 2, 19 9,3 Page 2 activities prior to submittal of said- work plans and reports to FDER; and (v) assistance and negotiations with environmental remediation contractors in connection with interim remediation activities that may be required to remove any continuing source of environmental impacts present on the property. Based on the information provided to date, I-believe the fees and expenses for the legal services described above should not exceed $40,000. Once the full horizontal and vertical extent of 'soil impacts are delineated, we- will be able to provide you with an additional cost estimate for legal services which may, be required beyond the submittal, of the Contamination Assessment Report to FDER. Under our proposal, Y would serve as lead counsel to Clearwater Gas System in this matter. My standard billing rate is $175 per hour. We have four other attorneys in the firm's environmental practice section that may be called upon, from time to time, for assistance in this matter. The billing rates for other attorneys,in the firm's environmental section range from $140 to $185 per hour. Our paralegals' fees range from $55 to $65 per hour. In matters of this nature, our firm fees would be based on standard hourly rates. Our fees for professional services are based upon the time expended by our professional personnel in accordance with the hourly rates described above. You will be provided with advance notice of any change in the hourly rates of any individual working on this file. The rates quoted above will not change during calendar year 1993. Every effort will be made to use personnel on this file in the most cost effective manner possible. Professional services will be billed on a monthly basis by a computerized statement which includes a narrative description of the services rendered and the details of the costs incurred on your behalf. Each monthly statement will identify by date, full description of services; attorney providing services, and attorney's billing rate, all work performed. on your behalf during the billing period. The firm's hourly rates include direct and indirect costs, except reimbursable expenses. Reimbursable expenses, which will be billed to you as separate costs in each monthly statement, include,the actual expenses of the firm in the provision of services in this matter, including transportation and subsistence, • toll telephone calls, facsimile transmissions, computer access fees for any computerized legal research required, x1P/letta;a/varrfngton 3537/67837 ff j, , ' 0; • • a a i•s r? +' fir `s r0 .. + z .. . ! A ;' :FBI Mr. C. S. Warrington, Jr. March"2, 1993 Page, 3 expedited-mail service delivery, reproduction costs,-and the costs of materials and supplies directly used in the prevision of services, and similar'service-related charges. We'look forward to serving as special-environmental counsel to , the City of Clearwater and Clearwater Gas System in this matter. If you have any 'questions or comments concerning this letter, please feel free to contact me at anytime. If the terms and conditions of this letter, are otherwise agreeable to yo.u, please have the appropriate representative of the City of Clearwater or "Clearwater Gas System sign' the enclosed copy of this letter and return it to me. With kindest regards, I am Very truly yours, AK , S T RFITT & EIDSON, P.A. f illiam L. Pence WLP/bbs cc; M. Al Galbraith Jr., Esq. an authorized representative of. the City of Clearwater/Clearwater Gas System, agrees to the terms and conditions of this letter.. CITY OF CLEARWATER or CLEARWATER GAS SYSTEM By: - Its: Dated; wlp/letters/wnrringtun 35]]/62833:' " IV. f Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum CONSENT IRS Me i tg: 03/18/93 SUBSECT: JOINT PROJECT AGREEMENT WITH PINELLAS COUNTY TO RELOCATE NATURAL GAS MAINS DURING THE IMPROVEMENTS TO DREW STREET RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve a Joint Project Agreement with Pinellas County to relocate natural gas mains during the improvements to Drew Street at an estimated labor cost of $87,300 ® and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: Pinellas County has a project to widen Drew Street from Hercules Avenue to U.S. Highway 19 North that will require the relocation of existing natural gas mains. This Joint Project Agreement will provide for the relocation of existing gas mains by the County's general contractor for the project. Having the general contractor relocate the existing gas mains will allow for this work to be done in a timely manner and relieves the Gas System from any penalty payments because of delays to the project. All restoration costs are. also saved as the general contractor is responsible for these costs under.this agreement. The Joint Project Agreement provides for labor only at an estimated cost to the Clearwater Gas System of $87,300. The gas materials will be provided by the clearwater Gas System from existing inventory and will include 1,570 feet of 4" PE main, 4,400 feet of 4" PE main, 300 feet of 8" steel casing, 300 feet of 4" steel casing and various other fittings. These materials will be issued from the appropriate inventory codes and charged to the CIP code 315-6340. The estimated cost of these materials is $12,871.82 and has been previously approved. The available balance of $773,670.68 in CIP code 315-6340, Line Relocation- Capital, is sufficient to provide funds for this project. 410;0"? Reviewed fry: Legal ting Dept; Uri foo ?C?arwater Gas System Costs: s 87,300 Total T' Cogmission Action: A d pprove Budgeter N/A Pu ch si - V% f $ 87 300 13 Approved u/conditions r a ng . Risk Mgmt. N/A _ Dept: User Current Fiscal Yr. 13 Denied N A Cis ACM N? Clearwater Gas System Funding source: E3 Continued to: other ® Capitat imp. Advertised: 13 Operating Attachments: Date: 0 Other Joint Project Agreement Paper: ® Not Re ui d submitted by: q re Affected Ponies D Notified Appropriation Code: ? None 315-6340 Ci f nr r ® Not Required 40 Printed on recycled paper r. { 4 yr .a .S''c, F` ".1 '.. y •.1., . . 9 , 41 rirr;:i',:?•Jl..... .. •' .. ,`, `,: , ptF ,•::'i',P'1 t- }'.y"+ .- ',. r, a j : 'JOINT PROJECT AGREEMENT' FOR UTILITY INSTALLATION BY ROADWAY CONTRACTOR PROJECT NAME ; Drew St, PROJECT LIMITS: FROM: Hercules Ave. To. U. S. 19 ( PROJECT PID' NO: 920526 Contract No. 90044 ' This AGREEMENT, made and entered into, on the day of 1993, by and between PINELLAS COUNTY, a political , ?.... subdivision of the State of Florida, hereinafter called COUNTY, and The City, o'f Clearwater,. a corporation of the State of Florida, 'hereinafter called "COMPANY. " WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, the COUNTY intends to construct improvements:to Drew St ' _ hereinafter referred' to as the PROJECT, which shall, call for the adjustment, relocation, and/or installation of the COMPANY Is utility facilities along, over and/or under the PROJECT, and WHEREAS, the above described utility activities are, to hereinafter be designated as "utility," work" and PWETWM:13 Page 1 of 5 05-28-92 ;'i ' - .. a .. r ? , 1• .. 1 r WHEREAS, the COUNTY•'s plans for the PROJECT have been reviewed by the COMPANY and the COMPANY has had an opportunity for input into said plans, and, WHEREAS, the- COUNTY and, the COMPANY have determined that it would be to the best interest of the general public and to the economic advantage of both parties to enter into Lhis JOINT PROJECT AGREEMENT for 'the "atility work" and, 'WHEREAS, the COi?i'ANY has expressed its desire to assume' all reasonable and necessary costs to be 'incurred for this "utility Nock" and 'has requested the. COUNTY to include in said PROJECT certain plans and specifications to meet the COMPANY's needs, and, NOW, THEREFORE, the,'premises considered,,.and in consideration of the sum of One Dollar ($$1.00) each to the other in hand paid, the-receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, and in further consideration of the mutual covenants hereinafter contained, it is agreed by the 'parties asl follows:' 1 .1. The COMPANY's "utility work" within the limits of the PROJECT, is more specifically described as: installing and removing 2' and-0-gas - main along Drew Street -- - - - _- 2. The COMPANY will prepare, 'at 'its expense, the design of plans and specifications for all the COHPANY's necessary "utility work described above and will furnish to the COUNTY no' later than April __ 15 ., 1993 complete and reproducible plans on standard size sheets (24" x 3b"), together with a complete set of specifications covering all construction requirements - for the "utility work". These plans and specifications shall'be complete in every detail and will include a "Summary of Quantities" sheet and/,or "Bill .of Materials" identifying the items of work, with a "final estimate of cost," required to accomplish the "utility work", said estimate' to be satisfactory to the COUNTY. The plans and specifications shall be' signed and sealed by a Registered Professional Engineer.. 3. It will be the responsibility of the COMPANY to 'coordinate 'the development of. the "utility work" plans with the'COUNTY's plans for the PROJECT. The COUNTY, upon request by the COMPANY, will 'Furnish PWETWH:13 Page 2 of 6 05-28-92; R_ M. 1` a ??•s• 1r' f '1 E1 •?tN?'SSr l`a' ? `?• ' II h,,1tEA il?ra•l , F' ,j •? r all available roadway information required 'by the COMPANY for the coordination and development of. the "utility work" plans, and the COUNTY shall cooperate fully with the COMPANY to this end. 4. The COMPANY shall obtain all necessary permits for construction-of the utility work, including the 'Pinellas County's "Right-of-Way Utilization Permit", and provide a copy of the same to the COUNTY so as not to affect the construction of the PROJECT. 5. The -.COUNTY does not warrant the accuracy of the COUNTY's survey information. The COMPANY will be responsible for reviewing, the COUNTY's survey information and will be responsible for any changes to the COMPANY's plans made necessary by errors and omissions in the COUNTY's survey information. 6. All. survey for' construction of the "utility work" will be furnished by the COUNTY"under the direction of the COUNTY's ENGINEER. 7. The coordination of the COMPANY's• "utility work" with that of the roadway contractor and other utilities and/or their contractors will be the responsibility. of the COUNTY, .The COMPANY shall cooperate .fully in this 'matter to ensure that any delays in the construction of any phase of the PROJECT, occurring as the result of unforeseen circumstances involving. the COMPtJIY's "utility work", shall be remedied immediately with the full force and power'•available to the. COMPANY. 8. All of the work, pursuant to this JOINT PROJECT, is to be done in substantial accordance with the plans and' specifications of the COMPANY (if any) which plans and specifications are,' by reference hereto, made a part hereof. All information required for field changes, change orders or Supplemental Agreements pertaining to the COMPANY's "utility work" shall be promptly furnished to the COUNTY, 9. The COMPANY will provide the necessary construction and engineering, inspection of the COMPANY's utility work to determine if construction is generally in comp?iance with the plans and specifications. The COMPANY's inspector' shall immediately notify the COUNTY inspector of any objection to the "utility work". '10. 'The COUNTY shall be responsible for the bidding and award of the Construction Contract and shall include the "utility work" as a separate option item in Ats bidding document. After the COUNTY receives, opens, and evaluates the',bids, the Director of Public Works shall notify-the COMPANY, in writing, of the COUNTY's intent to award the contract to the,. low bidder. This notification shall include the amount for the "utility work" option, The. COMPANY shall have five (5) days. from receipt of the COUNTY'S notification to request,' in writing, that the COUNTY delete this option, and to notify. the COUNTY of the COMPANY Is intent to, perform the "utility work" with the COMPANY's own forces or its own contractor, In order not to delay the construction of this project, the COMPANY must show that it is ready and' able to perform all "utility work" prior to requesting that the COUNTY' delete the "utility work" option from the contract award. The • COMPANY does not have the right to delay or affect, in any way, the award of the contract. PWETWH:13 Page 3 of 6 05-28-92, 91• 3 3. ° = t In the event the COMPANY, ill performing the "utility work", causes a delay to the COUNTY'S construction of this project, the COMPANY agrees to pay all claims and costs incurred due to'the delay. In the event the COUNTY, for any reason, decides either not to proceed with the PROJECT or halts construction of the PROJECT, the COUNTY will not.be responsible for any "utility work" not completed. 11. The COMPANY shall participate in the design; utility coordination, • pee-construction and other meetings as necessary for PROJECT coordination. 12. All adjustment, relocations, repairs, maintenance, and incidentals required to be performed to the COMPANY's existing- utilities within ' this PROJECT, not included in the "utility work" will be the sole • respgnsibility of the COMPANY.' All' such work is 'to be coordinated with the construction of this PROJECT and in a manner that will hot cause delay to the COUNTY's PROJECT contractor. .13. The COMPANY's comments, and suggestions are invited and will be considered by the.COUNTY; however, all services and work under the construction contract shall be performed to the satisfaction. of the COUNTY's Director of Public Works, and he shall decide all questions, difficulties and disputes of whatever nature which may arise under or by reason of such contract for "utility work"; the prosecution and fulfillment of the services thereunder, and the character, quality, amount and value thereof; and his decision 'upon all. P-laims, 'questions i and disputes thereunder shall be final and conclusive upon the parties hereto. 14. The COMPANY hereby certifies that funding for the preliminary estimated "utility work." cost of $ 872300.00 including 57. for construction/contract administration has beenappropriated and is available for payment (attached to this agreement as Exhibit "A".) In the event the actual cost exceeds the 'final estimate of cost, the COMPANY shall reimburse the COUNTY for such actual cost. 15. Upon completion of the entire. PROJECT, which will be determined jointly by -the COUNTY and the COMPANY, the 'COMPANY shah, own, control,. 'maintain and be responsible for all 'COMPANY utility. facilities involved according to- the terms of the Pinellas County Right-of--Way' Utilization Permit as attached as Exhibit B. The COMPANY further agrees that it will maintain and keep in repair, or cause to be maintained and kept in repair, all of such constructed facilities or utilities, 16. The COMPANY shall defend, save and hold harmless the COUNTY from any and all legal actions, claims. or demands by any person or legal entity against the COUNTY arising out of the participation An this. agreement by the COMPANY, including, delay claims arising from the. COMPANY'S 'performance of its own "utility work", or use by the. COMPANY of the completed "utility work", subject to the defenses and limitations available to the COMPANY pursuant to Section 768.28, Florida Statutes, as the same may be amended from time to time. The ' COMPANY and the ` COUNTY agree that' the COUNTY will pay Ten, and, 00/100 Dollars ($10.00) to the COMPANY as separate consideration 'for this PWETWHt13 Page 4 of'6 05-28-92. 4Y r • , • ' ' , f I i ' • ' l • 1 • 1 • _ e ? ? t ' j j Ito indemnification and any other 'indemnification of the COUNTY by the # f COMPANY provided within this Agreement, the sufficiency o.f''such 1 7. separate consideration being acknowledged by the COMPANY by, the COMPANY'S acceptance and execution of.the Agreement. 17. Upon receipt of invoices prepared in accordance with the provisions of this agreement, the COMPANY agrees to reimburse the COUNTY in the amount of such actual cost. The COUNTY will invoice the COMPANY monthly for all costs incurred under this Agreement as certified by the ' COUNTY's inspector, and Lhe, COMPANY agrees to pay the COUNTY ' within thirty (30) days. 18. Upon completion of the entire PROJECT, the COUNTY shall, within one hundred eighty (180) days, furnish the.COMPANY with two'(2)-copies of its..final and complete billing' of all costs incurred 'in connection with the work' performed' hereunder, such statement to follow as closely 'as possible, the order of the items contained in the job estimate and include all monthly payments to the contractor. The final.'billing shall show the description and site of the project, the ,. date on, which the 'last work was performed or the last item of billed expense was incurred; and the location where the records and accounts bill.' can be audited. Adequate reference shall be made in the'billing ' t A11 . to the COUNTY's records, accounts or other relevant documents. , cost' records, and .accounts shall be subject to audit by a representative of the COMPANY. 19.' Upon completion of the entire PROJECT, the COUNTY shad, within one hundred eighty (180) days, furnish the COMPAKY with one.. '(1) set of "as built" ("record"), standard size sheet (24" x 36") "utility work" plans. 20. Upon completion of the. entire PROJECT, the COWJTY shall insure, "that any warranty, including 'materials', equipment, workmanship and closeout documents, by the contractor constructing and/or installing facilities in accordance with this Agreement, is passed on to the COMPANY' under -the same terms and conditions as that warranty. applies to facilities constructed or installed on behalf of the, COUNTY.. • IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused these presents to be exec uted by, their duly authorized officers and their -officials' seats hereto affixed, the day and year first above written. PWETWM:13 Page 5 of b 05-28-92. lpq 4 ' t?' ;> f?- j 4 . • ? 1 '?'? tF•?.a4 ' Y3i. •t .'lr'. a '!F S?: •; r. _ •:'F •!.'':Ls ,4.• .',' '.r •. .. .. ' d'. rl1 i.. .1.: F+,>: ,°. S; ti:*kr? L' ' .. . ? ?``, f _,'': F }, '' , 1'r'l;r'q; •p'i'ftrF.:. rr. 'i ? ? , ? ? ? ? .Ir ,?i `+?j " ' j i ?].j.44' i ?;5 se?, r' a '? ? }F•, I?. ..t.?+.l° °. 3' ?. ?' r. l • ' , r ? - 'r?,=? +.''? r3;'?" ' lr d• ?1'? dil!1.? ?i"1?' ,?'°,i ?j` ? ? , - , 3 + ,.? ???'?? ' = ?.14 + . a S. .1 . 5 ?' 'l.•: F"r?. ill, _' + ? ? , 0 ` ? .. •,..,t-1 r r ' I. h? "f•+'' J ' 'r't• '7' '-Jr ?! S F.' :rlj r . I" a''?y ? ? rr:1•wth+.3t ::4: t ;)7r:•., ???.`<a[F'`F.. „ ,:?,+.dl::. <'itf ?.'.Li.??:'E'S..• ? .r rj1 • f• + , ? t JOINT PROJECT AGREEMENT FOR , ' UTILITY INSTALLATION BY ROADWAY CONTRACTOR ATTEST: PINELLAS COUNTY, FLORIDA; by Xarleer' F. DeBlaker, Clerk- and through its Board of 1 County'Commissioners .• • BY: Clerk (Seal) Deputy . Countersigned: BY: (Seal) APPROVED AS TO FORH 'ATTEST: BY: O££ice' of County Attorney Countersigned:' - ' CITY OF CUARWATM FLORIDA Rita Garvey Michael J. Wright Mayor-Commissioner City Manager Approved as.,to form and ' Attest:. correctness : , M.A. Galbraith, Jr. Cynthia E. Goudeau ' City Attorney City Clerk ' ? .. / t • ? ? ;1? X11• •• ? i' PWEi.WM:'13 r` Ge, 6 of D 05-28-92 fAyr? !`!tll{7+Llrin. R.?w.-.?:?rrr.curt.o..,wr.....,..........?....?_.....?____._-_-._ _.. ? ,.. .. , ., ?-•'? .e f :.;` 1y A• rE ?? Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum ,i Heeti o 03118193 its 3, . - SUBJECT: CLEVELAND STREET GAS MAIN AND SERVICE REPLACEMENT RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Award a contract to Gulfcoast Utility Constructors of St. Petersburg, Florida, which was the lowest, most responsive and responsible bid received in accordance with the specifications, to supply labor to replace gas mains and services on Cleveland Street, at an estimated cost of $65,100 ® and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The Clearwater Gas System wishes to replace the gas.main and services on Cleveland Street from Highland Avenue.to Hercules Avenue. The gas mains and services.are composed of bare steel and galvanized steel. The existing mains are,thirty-seven (37) years old. The Gas System wishes to replace these mains and services in conjunction with the.Public Works Department's Cleveland Street Storm Improvement project. Ten (10) bids were solicited and five (5) were received. There were three (3) no responses and two (2) no-bid responses. Gulfcoast Utility Constructors of St. Petersburg submitted the lowest and most reponsive bid in accordance with bid specifications. Therefore, we recommend Gulfcoast Utility Constructors be awarded this contract. The materials for this project,' supplied by the Gas System, will cost $23,549.09. These materials have been previously approved and will be removed from the inventory code,and applied to CIP code #315-6342. The available balance of $344,312.23 in CIP Code 315-6342, System Renewal & Replacement is sufficient to provide funds for this project. a Reviewed by: Originating Dept: Costs: $65,100 C ission Action:' Legal N/A ' Cl or water Gas System Totai Approved Budget Purchasing S 65,100 ? Approved w conditions / Risk Ngmt. A Current Fiscal Yr. E3 Denied cis N/!' ACM User D . Cleatrwater Gas System Funding Source: 13 Continued to: Other ® Capital Imp. Advertised: ? operating Attachments, Date: 02/12/93 02/19/93 ? other aid Tab & Summary n,7 Paper: Pin Co Rev Tampa Trib ? i Not Requ red Submitted by: Affected Parties Appropriation code: ? None ® Notified 315-6342 Ci Man er ? Not Required 0 Printed on'recycled paper 1.= i t ' ..T. ?.tiF`Y Iii' ,'?n? .,t ,. +t .. " ° .. ,r .f • , ! ' s«r. e„r` :.'" '.?• :•,:>;..yy id r rJ i ',' I - '!'f n f •'' ,.Y: r ?'y?1r'. }'r??? `' : ,? , r, • t 1 , Via,' ? , . . ., .,v"li: ?? ,9,• 1 l.' 'S. I ,f, f , `r' •, ? v ? r i' ? r' i' :, "`.'G?'?y a'Ic'.YI,-?;. "°;^ .. !"•? 4.3' '1 bl .I, ??..'r' .y?s?f'' ",5' 'r ? ' .? ..t?' ? 'F' ' ?? ? ,' ? ... ? ,s'R f,L: iS; ?;{'{e ?tt:, :'7' `'i,< i sf,o. .:eir r,¢?a.1. =,, Ti. !•`' .r r _ :tiS? f.^i i}: Y-r ??'i ri i. r`'?, t , ? ? ' • ' . ?. ? ?t, ? j• `/;Y. l,?.°- '.`f. •s.?6? s"?.fy???;?:?'.'l,:.e - ?r± ? ... r Ei. ?i'? s? ? r"1? r:•'y?°. 'f ?'R:1 ?g r?• '?f+' .?r..'r. r.i:? -t,k"Y' ? r ? .. r rl Ar?',i a::w.:f+?...f. a,. `r.. •. .•.:?., rir'1, :.. t1 A?.M :: 134. •'?'at1!!,hk.if.? ? '? •1,4,0 , l... ,. r?' ,. f -;i I di °o o tle wl P4 -n -t 0 0 0 o tl I- 1' of n d Pi r Yf e_ r' ' W .-7 N O O Ir1 ,I . }r , • I 'r '? ?'r. el ok o o 9 9 9 9 9 $ p 0$ n ° N ° {y. .; 141 n• r P 1/N? n ? ? ? ? .. ? r °?; 40 In fn 0 go 0 8 8 !'. ?Hy eWpE (per WK Sy '^ $ $ qqQ 'Q'' - M ?yWkC 6.'f S ,`,'.•' U w7 'H 14 Q rti V O ?1 N' Q ?j I, j . •r' r.r tjl 9 9 9 9 ol, I Q Q O o o a i O h O 1 1 t 1111.uu????11 w n Q S. N 'k?..,. n a o 0 0 ?,A???;• fl s f'.? ;a ? .?. °? •.^f{ i?7,.:•, 4?'t 1?1;tr 1, A S w Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum SUBJECT: GAS RATE STUDY it Meeting o03/18193 RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Award a contract to Coopers & Lybrand of Tampa, Florida for a study of Gas Rates at a cost not to exceed $45,500 in accordance with City Code Section 2.564(1)(3), impractical to bid, ® and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: I? i The Clearwater Gas System is in need of a Gas Rate Study. Our gas rates have not been thoroughly reviewed for at least .l0 years and are not competitive with. other energy suppliers in our area or gas companies around the State. In particular, our service charges are outdated and do not recover a reasonable margin over our costs and our non-residential rates are very expensive. our firm rates are as much as 30% higher for large commercial customers than those of surrounding companies. This has recently required our development of a discounting provision which was approved by the Commission on February 18, 1993, but requires case-by-case rate making which is not desirable. The Finance Department has done an initial assessment of our rates versus those of six (6) other similar utilities around the State and has confirmed our need for a thorough Gas Rate Study.' Finance has recommended that we employ a Certified Public Accountant firm with expertise in utility rates to analyze our gas rates and provide recommendations to modernize same. Coopers & Lybrand is the City's external auditor, is supporting several other projects for the City, and is best positioned to review our gas financials. Coopers, & Lybrand also has a specialized National Utilities Services Group which has done rate studies for Central Florida Gas, Tampa Electric, Jacksonville Electric Authority, Kissimmee Utility Authority, Reedy Creek, Tallahassee, Gainesville, Ocala, Vero Beach, and others in Florida alone. They have also been the consulting firm to Brooklyn Union Gas, one of the largest gas companies in the East. Therefore, Coopers & Lybrand has substantiated previous experience with the financial, technical, regulatory and legal issues Reviewed by: Originating Dept: costs: f 45,500 Commission Action: Legal NIA earwater Gas System Total Approved Budget Purchasing nJ S 45 500 13 Approved w/conditions Risk Mgmt. NIA User D t . Current Fiscal Yr. E2 Denied CIS W /A ACM - N/A Clearwater Gas System Funding Source: C] Continued to: Other ? Capital imp. Advertised: 0 Operating Attachments: Date: ? Other Coopers 9 Lybrand Proposal Paper: ® Not Re uired t q Affected Parties © Hone ® Notified Appropriation code: 423-02061-530100-532-000 Cit n er Not Required 13 0 Pri ted on racycled paper ,.fr?L v?., µ'F ,,-t 'r• ;"ts ..•'ti s!L€41' r r• S.,?s'.?:? ?i', ., C, i .. 'c.' y ;s. . . - ,€`..., rf ., .'7 n•:}j;F•0 , ,. + ' r' ' ? @ r j a •r. , arse ' 4 ..7 . 1. ? +?•'• - ?. t ?}i A, I- .I}.s6 ' }•?i A°V F?rA- ,L: 1,ry- '?, .. r r i ' r , `••?4t r, .. ;`- •! . r . r` • r -- )?!?1. " ? Y , •p '• r r F + ? r . r r ??'.. j ,S: IIr r , i ?' ?^ r f r', ? ? r?12. ? ? p } - ` ' ? y} rf.,y r j1 Fe?/ k. ?%??'?r?: -r °G• ????r.t .??r '` ?f??? ? r Rr ? ? F t ? ? r ? !? ? •p? ?? ltt?l ? .r? I, •d,} '< '= 5 y ?:,,. Y' ) ,t?" - f j r _ ,, )- ., jAC'i; , , 'I?. n p.ak. • d ICY+ro ?', .?'• y'Y +: ' €i?'i ' ?' ' /. i•, f p ?' ;t It . p : i r. .1 , ' ?. ?. { ••?? r r A T i .,`. `? rr y t ?'E'a y e J?. ? •, ?. 'i./; i, ..,'. , S . .. ? pt ' ?' e•r:+?' jir ?'r' :.If ':t?jts'? 'C?.; °.r•'''` f; .., ?r„??,??'`.//r•. r4i L ? <•3"i:'i ` i' r ' ? ? ' ` ,, v. ;'r., ? 1;3: ?4Md .r3lo:''A?€<°s..?E. ,>,. „. . ,... 5-'Idll?C tu, •? .?.x' .? ? ? :, ? r 9 :/,: >.' ? r - _ 2 -associated with gas rates and is uniquely qualified to serve our needs due to ,their current involvement'with the city's financials. Coopers & Lybrand'stproposal for this:project'appears reasonable'and also takes..,:-.; .into'account''their existing expertise and understandin g of the City's financials. Camp, Dresser'& McKee (CDM) submitted ,a p roposal several years ago ",`(May 81'-'1991) to do a Gas. Rate Study for us 'at a cost of $56; 000.'' We elected ,not to, - do the study at that time.,. Coopers & Lybrand's proposal is, .'::,.:',substantially .lower and, appears reasonable. 7Cn, order to provide funds for this Gas Rate Study, the Gas system is requesting :: •.'e ` ,. a midyear budget amendment to increase the Profession al Services'.operating.",'•' , Code :423-02061530100--532-000 'by $45,50,0 to be funded out-of retained earnings: r ' L i s r. I r , I + -i M'' 3 ? e Proposal For, NRate-Study Pity'of Cledrma-te,r",.G.as --System January 28, 1 X93 ,The ? Caope,rs'. ? LiY7.?)1'i? 11 r 'll-St i1?1 llil, tincilt iti 11M L'ifil?iti+c'1:1Ill, maim{7 11 111c• 1rt,;h level + ? (it qui7lity,service our c lic )lts rxpect: } Arltic'i atin Clr('rlIS' lic'c'ds, 1'('111, j'G'ti1?t1l1Sr??c' ?('11t'11 tlrc't/ c711 Ml 1ar Its ti Mid promptly y dclllrlr? .111ith their r'cMc,c11.11S. . .. Brillsil lti'ilitc orit11 c11I11 jlrcl<<ticnic'lit to 1711 oill' c,tf(?rls. ' , V? rc1 t[7 ?ilr?; irlc?ividual'ilrrtial- ve r7l ? tc? c1'c'lc? ill ittt' 7 " . l l llt MT Ct Y f• helping olrl''peoplc fulfill their 1)olential: fresh Ellcourr7(,111g thc'in to look at c'17C11•Slt11171i0lI f 1mit a - 1 ! ' l ProvialII all (,'11 11,011171c,lit 11'11cre 1111W,ideas cast flolri?ll. g-iritc'1ligc'nce, cra7livilil and 'Stimulatirl therrl to 17r1.17 L current technology to dC171 CffCCti,VCI1.1 Wilh ChallgC. Y ' nally? ve arc cc)lr mitled to'fostc'rirl, a Sense of teamzvor•k Fi . • a111U1'1g 0111' !7C'[1l.11t' and with t)1ri' C'C11rr1?111111t1('S: a. Building a cooj7(T17tiVOTff0rt within the Firal Where cach of . its draws (ill our individual talc Ws, to Support shared,oals ` involved with the communities where 7ve live and min B g eco 11101'k; CUl7tribut111 q, our krlowled' e and cxpe 'ic'rlcc to hel!7 maintain tllc'll' C('311t13'121Cti hc, Ith 17174 prosperity. ?. !l cif which 711akcs f o- ?4ot7c1 ser??ic-('-- ,. << ? alyd good business SO15C . 4 . • . COO GrS certified public accountants Suite 1500 In principal areas of the world 101 E. Kennedy Blvd. • ? Tampa, Florida 33602.5194 n 1 Y rand ' Tampa (813) 229.0221 1 Pinellas (813) 461.1580 Fax (813) 229.3646 January 28, 1993 Mr. C. S. Chuck Warrington, Jr. Managing Director .. City of Clearwater Gas System '400 North Myrtle Avenue ; (' I Clearwater, FL 34615 Dear Mr. Warrington: We-appreciate the opportunity to describe how Coopers & Lybrand can assist City of Clearwater ' Gas System in a comprehensive natural' gas rate study. In preparing this proposal, we have z' 'drawn upon our recent conversations with City of Clearwater personnel and our substantial' experience in performing utility'rate studies. Coopers' & Lybrand is a recognized leader in providing services to meet the expanding and x increasingly complex requirements of the public utility environment.. Our long-standing '. commitment to the utility industry, along with the experience of our professionals, provides us with a thorough understanding of the complex, issues and situations that confront the public sector. In today's,environment it is important not only to design rates, but also to implement ,the new rates. Customer intervention sometimes makes this latter task the most difficult. Coopers & Lybrand has a proven record of implementation. rr ' We are committed.to the success of your engagement. We are pleased that we can bring together the right combination of skills and ' experience for this important work for City of Clearwater Gas System. We believe we are well qualified .to serve you and can perform the . analysis needed-to address and solve the issues you are facing. We look forward to working'' with you and are available to discuss our proposal at' your convenience. Please feel free to. contact Michael Barrett at 8131229-0221 if'you have any questions. Yours very truly, fl r COOPERS & LYBRAND Coopers & Lybrand ranks among the world's largest and most highly regarded professional consulting firms. We have over 65,000 professionals located in 710 cities in 112 countries. in the United States, we have more than 1,300 partners and 16,000 personnel located in 100 offices. We have been 'in practice as a partnership since 189$ and the international organization has been in existence for over 30 years. ; Our growth has been driven by an unyielding commitment to excellence in every area of our professional 'practice: Coopers & Lybrand offers a diverse range of business and financial advisory services. These , services are grouped under four main disciplines of Business Assurance, which includes accounting and auditing, Tax, Performance Improvement Consulting and,Human Resources Advisory Services. Our broad network of offices allows us to bring to our engagements specialized national resources where required. ' OUR COMMITMENT TO THE UTILITEES INDUSTRY Coopers & Lybrand is a recognized leader in providing services to meet the expanding and increasingly complex'requirements of the utilities industry. We have over 100 gas, electric and water/wastewater audit clients and over 150 gas, electric and water/wastewater consulting clients. We do not just pay "flip service" to the fact that we are committed to the utilities industry -- our commitment is evidenced by our development of a National Utilities Services Group. Our National Utility Services Group is one of the largest of any firm's in the United States. Its services include: ' • Cost of service/rate studies Regulatory and accounting reviews • Strategic planning and information technology assessments • Management audits and operational improvements reviews • Profit improvement programs (resource productivity) • Effectiveness assessments • Total Quality Management (TQM) implementation assistance • Technical management and operational consulting Performance management • Information systems planning and organization Compensation and benefits reviews ?L^ rY'?- i ,Nn 1yLt i?- .'4, 1 ' Our natural gas consultants have provided consulting services to all sectors of the natural gas industry: producers, pipelines, local distributors and end users. They are familiar with the complexities of natural gas operations, contracts and, regulations. Consulting services have included: cost of service/rate studies; purchases and sales of natural gas, including in-ground purchases of gas reserves; analyses of, regional and national gas markets and supplies; transportation services and gas contract interpretation, negotiation/re-negotiation and compliance, reviews. Our long-standing commitment to the utility. industry and the experience of our consultants provide us with a thorough knowledge of the complex issues and situations that confront the industry today and into the future. Our professionals -- including management,. systems and regulatory consultants, accountants, economists and engineers -- bring the diverse skills needed to perform a quality gas rate study for the City of Clearwater Gas System. Services for this engagement will be provided principally by members of this group. Personnel in the National Utility Services-Group provide specialized support in areas such as financing, regulation, ratemaking, organization and economic analysis, advice on the regulatory process and testimony on rate and accounting matters. In addition, many of its members serve as audit' partners and managers for our firm's major utility clients. As a result, we will bring to the project broad-based support that is organized to meet the objectives of our engagement. WHY COOPERS LYBRAND Consulting firms, like people, have distinctive personalities. Perhaps the quality that best describes Coopers & Lybrand is our ability to go beyond the routine to provide an extra dimension in quality service to our clients. Our slogan is "Solutions for Business" and our 'professionals' are ready to ,help you identify and find solutions to the challenges you face. Our partners and professional staff provide responsiveness and care that goes beyond what is traditionally expected of consulting firms. Moreover, we are committed to consistently maintain f a high level of quality service, both in what you require for your immediate needs and what you J will, need in the future. ?. I I .J . i$l.f• I J' ? 4? 1 s ..J ,.1 OUR UNDERSTANDING AND APPROACH The City of Clearwater Gas System has maintained steady and continued growth in customers and revenues in the past decade, especially within the past five years. As competitive industry pressures increase, management is questioning the appropriateness of its current customer rate structure and desires a comprehensive natural gas rate study. The 'City of Clearwater Gas, System is operating in an increasingly competitive and complex environment. The energy shocks of the 1970's, the strong growth of the environmental movement, and the increasingly changing regulatory environment have unalterably transformed the dynamics of the natural gas industry. There have been many structural and operational changes within the natural gas markets within the past few years and these changes are continuing at an ever increasing pace. Consider: • Open Access During 1989, Florida Gas Transmission (FGT) filed a, docket with the, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) in relation to FGT's expansion within the state of Florida. Effective August, 1990, the FERC approved the expansion on the condition that FGT begin to transport on an open-access basis, and that they provide firm, preferred, and interruptible. transportation service. As part of this action City of Clearwater Gas . System had to•coinmit to a level of capacity on FGT's system based on its anticipated growth and reliability needs. O Transportation Services In accordance with the new FGT tariff, FGT is required to allow local distribution companies (LDC's) and end users the opportunity to purchase gas directly from suppliers other than FGT; and transport it on FGT's pipeline. This has enabled LDC's a greater variety of gas purchasing options and has led to greater competition in the commodity cost of gas. It has also made the gas procurement process tremendously, more complex. • FERC Omnibus Order. 636 In April, 1992, the FERC issued Order 636, which requires pipelines' to unbundle transportation service from their sales of gas and allows them to sell gas at market-based rates similar to unregulated sellers upon compliance with the order. This rule is intended to ensure that pipelines provide transportation service that is equal in quality for all gas supplies, whether the customer purchases the gas from the pipeline or another supplier. As a result of this order, LDC's will now have to be more actively involved in f t, y 3 ' .a 1 +.J • ' '. . .{ t off • .14 ?• •'JL - ? •k • ?i. ' r. t s r r ' 1 ?i r f f I? h contracting` far their supplies. A more practical result of the implementation of the order in October, 1993, is that FGT will have to determine and resolve any imbalances that occur monthly, rather than the lengthy and cumbersome process now in place. • Alternate rate mechanisms - Flex Rates - Some gas utilities in the state have adopted flex rates for their industrial customers who have the ability to use alternate fuel sources. The utility can increase(flex-up) or decrease(flex-down) the non-fuel portion of their rates charged to interruptible customers depending on the market of the alternate fuel source. The savings, or costs, of this program are generally spread to firm customers on the, system, as the margin generated by'keeping these industrial customers on line benefits everyone on the system. Conservation incentives - Some gas utilities in the state have offered cash rebates to new home builders for the installation of certain natural gas appliances such as central heating, gas water heating, cooking ranges, and clothes dryers to make the installation of natural gas even more competitive. These rebates focus on the conservation aspects of reducing the growth in electric consumption. • National Energy Strategy On the nationaV level, there has been the encouragement of developing alternate fuel sources that are environmentally sound and place less reliance' on foreign oil supplies, The new national presidential administration will likely encourage the use of natural gas in developing a National Energy Policy. • Increased use of Natural Gas in Producing Electricity Within the state, there has been increased interest in and use of natural gas in electricity producing utility, plants and' cogenerating facilities. The use of natural gas as a fuel source at these plants will likely constrain some capacity in the FGT' pipeline, thus improving opportunities for LDC's to market their excess capacity. • Potential Pipeline Competition There has been increased interest in the construction of an additional pipeline to come into the state of Florida with the large electric utilities likely major end-users. There are preliminary plans to construct such a pipeline in the mid-1990's time frame. . The introduction of a second pipeline into the state should increase competitive pressures on FGT and lead to better pricing to the LDC's. I i r - ' r ? , r In order to remain competitive in the natural gas marketplace, City of Clearwater Gas System needs to react to these changes. Appropriate customer rates are central to the financial stability and competitiveness of natural gas utilities. Rates must be set to adequately cover operations and maintenance costs, as well as fund capital needs and reserves. The importance of sound rate-setting cannot be over emphasized. A rate study requires a well-formulated' approach that identifies each utility's needs, recognizes the unique aspects of the utility's service area and customer base, and provides the level of rates and rate structure that will be acceptable to 'the governing body and utility customer. 6 PROJECT APPROACH -1 We will`provide gas rate consulting services to City of Clearwater Gas System to establish rates that recover from each class of customer the cost to serve that class of customer. To accomplish this objective will require the following: x , • Review and analyze available revenue and operating expense data,for the gas system. • Review and analyze' gas consumption data by customer class from the ' City's billing system. • Analyze customer gas usage patterns. • 'Establish customer classification alternatives. '. 0 Establish the annual revenue requirements of providing gas service. 0 Develop rate alternatives, including flex rates to attract industrial customers and transportation tariffs to reduce gas procurement risks to the City. 0 Conduct workshops for the evaluation of customer classification alternatives and rate . alternatives. • Identify alternative marketing and conservation programs to fit within the City's goals. • Provide gas rate schedules. We will develop a natural gas rate model for City of Clearwater Gas System, This model will ' be based on Lotus 1-2-3. After completion of this project, the model will be turned over to the City staff for their use in the future. We have designed our work program and schedule to meet the above requirements. R .« r4 •/ Y ? tjy• .'rs .ir •???. ? f( ?rJ+rf ' ? ? ' ra i t , S PROJECT MANAGEMENT We have organized a superior team that effectively and efficiently blends the broad spectrum of talents, needed to successfully complete this project. Our team is made up of seasoned utility consultants with substantial municipal utility experience. Included in this section of our proposal is a brief' description of the roles and qualifications of our project team.. Following is an organization chart that presents the, reporting structure of our project team. Engagement Partner - Michael Barrett will serve as Project Partner for this engagement. Mike is a member of our National Utility Services Group and is responsible for the utility practice in our Tampa office. He will be responsible for overseeing the completion of the project, directing all aspects of the engagement and addressing key issues. In addition, Mike will be responsible for making the presentations to, present key findings and recommendations. Mike has over 16 years experience in the utiliy industry. Prior to joining Coopers & Lybrand, he was with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. He has been involved in or responsible for gas, electric and water utility consulting services, including cost-of service studies, rate design, total revenue requirements, analysis of federal and state rate filings for compliance with regulatory ,and policy impact requirements. Project Manager - Jim Hanlon, will be responsible for the day-to-day administration of the project, and coordinator` of all project activities. Jim has over ten years of financial consulting and auditing experience with significant emphasis on serving utility clients. He has recently been involved in a number of utility consulting projects, including reviews of financial forecasts and regulatory support to attorneys in purchase power contract litigation. 'He currently serves as audit manager on the TECO Energy/Tampa Electric, Company, Florida Municipal Power Agency and Central Florida Gas Company audit engagements. Municipal Rate Study Consultant - Fred Jordan, a professional engineer licensed in the State of Florida, has over 21 years of experience in the government and utility, industries. His experience includes completing user rate studies for numerous government clients. 'He has developed computer models for seaport financial planning, rate studies, and commercial property feasibility analysis. He has participated in the preparation of many revenue bond official statements, including bond feasibility analysis. He will be responsible for addressing the key municipal rate setting issues. Rate Analyst r Ross Sollosy has approximately three years of experience in the utility, industry. He has recently been involved in developing computer models and rate analysis for the City of Atlanta, City of Houston and. Hillsborough County, He currently'serves as in-charge accountant on the .Central Florida Gas, Tampa Electric Company and Kissimmee Utility Authority audit engagements. 6 I ••Av f • r S • •' 3 ?, Y. _M p' •yr:?f `?;?;+` :t,?T'(gt?yS? h_ u?I?, ^w?. r•. .r r.:l; - a• ? r . , ? ? f ? ;'+"' ': ? s rv ? r • r • tv? ,?: . ,r G?..r. ??YY?? ?•+,??,,: ???t ? s, ?r ?,;'ssdip.h •rr' r'? k'?, ' °?. .. $.'.1 •4(. '.S ,e%;. r:y .,-`. t 1dY/$?,? >?`'F "j°e.t ,?+1+.["• 4.j.: 'e, .f r.? .r?a 'rs .'i CI-."?'i, -j:`,4'f.':; ?'a'y§.?. f :';1a?? .{'` ?S?a. Z ,E;,j ??, r , .'t .1' t•?` ,.?, .d''r,.'t•.. v:i ??? ti", ,r:"?..; i-• N.. 1 eF -'FY>?`L` ^€.... y?. ? ''}- ? [ .; .'.r? .L ,.?Y:?, cf ?Y ?.4,? L';s' . ret' , .K ,L ,' i (.r i•. _? .S ? - , ^r ''t,?3??? ?l_'?F.;[`: F 'I ?1? .}''' C`!- i.. , , ,.? 1 „ - 1 . '' +a', •I?girif?; ? ??7r)!, •r' . ' ; c !rAr•`;'? t::y t. .s 4. + + , r •,, i , ,'.7?'?? tit„ ,f; 1.i [4? L' ,?1 ?.' ?''f'••i L.]' 'J 1''T ?a ..?? •S.' ?? ii{b' '1' =rC "`t: Lh' ,St ?.'..1: [ .?, ss?r';''s" ?,: i.'` .?fr`'+„•'a;T '.i° ? ?. ? r ? i'r',•y -?f i•??L, :l?•r ,<[! ,.r[?k. ???" ,.;z{?a.. ,r,rl-..?. I:; ° :?.'y.'.,?•• ri?c'. 4" 3; 1 ? ., .;' .. ,f -?' ',?•, ?! _°'?:f ?e;,r;,,?:. 4 .,. p: :&:`fi, } .:r .J .r'' •,1 f. 'A i 1Y w y ;'... 4 ! :'a.' . %;. 4 T .Y {?t.l.ta,?::U,i' .t` ?'s • .F? i•: • •r, ?'Y,y i'='•.,< ? r't ° '•r,?,? ';i'. ¢¢iT C ''f:"i' .ai#??,' '"? •,E ";' t: •i f . ?.'l, f' F'I ,? ?14? ?' ??f < r . ? I r 1 i r• + [' r _ _'? :t r , i+•^-[' ??'' -f •? "+'# _ ?.''•`t` ?r e9 °r t I.a,Y. "Y S'' r f ' 3 •??.,')i [•,+ ' 1••.;j,,.. Z3 ?k. ;rs,S,. .:a3 ir`? j.,'?.: i[..i: ? ayr:? •?"! ..s'' "?a .. .•1 ,f T rf-. r.4'Jr '# [.t, r,[ ,a tr,4":f„ z a= ?'}'? 's'` ° ' } , f +' .. + ..e r`,, ',`?. •If „{?,I.::t; "1 ?..>e ..r:' ti. . ! tl.pk? j ? 'r'1 :'.ry ? _•!. `?.•i ?I'', ' , . , f . f r?f! rr'' f"t . • s [r +. s! . L 4 i ? ,7 V. f •? F I.' t r f . r. r [• 7 ,' 1 ? ?+ `. . t 'S NI :?arr 1. "11,? :.l' .? ir'+' i? "7•? •'-I"? ?h•? w?.a .•bi:! ??? -SN'?.1 ./:a+' 4•?+,1 ''li' '1'r v'?' '',?. `, I• .. .. r., J' ''2^..! 1 j',+ ,E ?? s'? ?, t i?y:?f{)'}}?ii'd... ..4?r? S 4'- r: '?• ??: Y'?,?'?, 4.i.? tT' r•, r r i .,_?, ,c t'', t'f'S. ,: i.?:+a'?r!',S•.i?'r :!`???4.4tt 1'.F ','fJ .t. _ 1 ' 'y; ''E't; r"S ?'? ir1i3??v:?'.r :;??; ?5= ..3.. ,y'? ,.?5. jjS.a,r.? •+14. ,'lr, e, E?. : ... .•t=.? '??• `.t .:,.?. ?.y.??,{,. ?C; `,, .'{;. .l ?'' °t• •"??+?Iy. +•`T.-s: i ?. E.'.:?'r? r' .+ t?'s F 'i? ?t? Ti° ?'E ?t` rs+, yl ,, .+}[, °.?sa,.`4 ;j: i.. r, t?.• 1•t'rrEd.+? t? 't ... .. ? t ??s? '#? =s? ?1"ii J ?'°: s'!'#,J [', ,. e., .i: ?ri •_ .a ?1:r 'E3; Z,4•-?? :S+ p .. ,i' ,??' 'f" +,Y?? •'.r .,f? S ?':Jr?r[[• ",W.1' a: :; •.l .sue "?; i"i .?Y. L?1't '+' '3?.1„ 1 r +y+ ' il': :i ,5'•: ,y. .y?? '?{? `•FC' :P'y'`S.Y''C ?'.' .? } ,tk"r .',' '1 .. I'1+r [?fitt ? :'i ,'[i .C+" -L':V. >•,?,fy .l ,?r,.?Ia4' a , :f ? `Y..•?l•? .5.. f..+3'a? e.I'Y??'f fr',>'?'"ii.r,? < i:. ?' „'r - L: .1 ? r f.[1; ;`.f?.• ?l.L?f,???Fi }?y:,. ;rrii3;• j:. ?_ " - ?.,+. . _ , .. . F' i ']:> ,.'+.r 1 ,..$`. F r+.d? .j'r ? •>: •+l11.?1''+r: :1..,? ? ??/c ,'s t'•i:l a J' ! .. , {?,? 't L,j ?. ?w+'?#YTa?f,'.3ltii'd:,.4`.'r s ..?.r4de,'flalr?h`,b >r-!1 ?11?•?? e. ,..?:?'; Ma?laaral ?, ew:a.• L :.. • f e . - , • .. e . r 'f.• , i - r .,.' J:., - '.: e'? • ^ , _> "' ?.' , ',: ... t ,t try" .''.. : YI•[... : v._: f r. .. sin3i' s Project. Staff -owill be assigned- to the project as required,, basdd on the nature and complexity I bf the task. Coopers & Lybrand's goal is to bring the right people at the right time, to our clients. This w i II ensure that all work is successfully completed on time and on budget. ?' '''l ., - f ''r. ' r ' .1 ` • ' ? 5, r ? !• ?• y. , ^?f ,:`mi'l r ?,',. ;!.-.? ,L, ' `i:.. J. +.7 ,t , ! ,i; _ `f r., 'S: `a?,'?_-?•J a -_ _ - -_ ___-- - e: F'. - ? .... a ... . , .. _ .. . i ,ci. r?,Y?:..!>?.I[',?..x.. 3L?'N3'ili 4S ^;- •{^. _'? fs ° r:'v:i , r f .7. ` °i ?.. ., , rf. r r''Y:^•,,`.%i.•+. ?C, w l 3 _ S "'??f: ?P ?,?4lPt ?S .. \?{P,?a?jl' , .1 1 '' i r. .! r ?t ' i? I ' ? ? • J r. •r s j ' : , 1 • , . •'v}f i . .'' ` " t i• i, J s : J- r, : is ? ? i?ra. L ' ; ' ' '? - ' • f : }l+A•.5' ? ?F'?' 8, 'rY' ,wir; r; .. ` . :1 er. . .^ L . ? ? N '? .. . . ? .t it:t.?`.a 'r° ',> r '??i ?,15, 'r, t. T4? .'A. ? ? - ..:?? •.S. Y.t .f kil? :d? a.?` s .. f .;7?5? 1.,'r' a? ? ir{.. f'% . r. ` ? . °:`' i •! % ' ' : i ` • ` ? J?'} : • t? P , ? f Y ` ,t,• 1 f. , t ' : ? 1. .tit ? ?; .?':. N I} .! :a1 t ? r P ' l fi . r ? ; r r a rh yp 1 .. ? r' ,. - +. ,?gk ?yciS;.°; i1i'?'?r '••'i; ?" ,'? '_. ?a?.. _,•i'•,Si,a?. f; i,?r,'.: ?, .b?.t?'•,':. 4: ?; ', .: .. .. r - :r• ,., .' i`.. t .r°' '.Ii:. ' r, :s. .r ,. r .?i1".? . . . • ? .if CITY OF. CLEARWATER : ,. Gas Rate Study', : . .f, Organization Chart ement Partner a E . . g ng j ., . ` M. Barrett. s : + r d - Project Manager y J. Hanlon Municipal Rate Study t lt C an onsu Jordan F ,. . Rate Analyst B. Sollosy Staff App?r('???#.r.I, a '?•. .. ds4????c Tea. :i7??)?%:'??'f; der '}'f•'?J?' :lt. .. ` ?j.sj: 'e - ' . ' iiL•' : tL'. °'>':,? : r?l'R , t, ' a !s • , 'e!. , ..ertf Yf R ''j Ft .r ?j , ' ? f ?? 61 F ! 7: .. r 11 I+i. ,+ i - t.l,r f t„ + r s s .! , 1 ! tftr ?C[ [-i .ti?';' ? '/, • ? , , f Y - fr , . ? 'f 'fir ?SAf 1'll•7 /'. 1. 1-'#/ ' , •as . ! t. ' 'L .' [ .+' ,'r ' `?? J'' ? [ t < S?P.Y ' '. ?? t' i E 1 i Ir .s t'?' 1• ,E [ , • ?.?',^1 ' ' TEM11N.G AND FEES ' We are prepared to beg*'our work within a reasonable amount of time from the date we receive ' F your approval of our proposal. The schedule for completion of the project will depend on data availability. For purposes of our fey quote and based upon our discussions with you, we have assumed that the following information will be provided to us: • Monthly' detailed consumption data, by customer type for prior two .years j:{.' ' • Mean, median and: standard deviation of above data :`'' • Above consumption data by consumption blocks ' • History of applicable gas rates " Io Our fee for the services outlined in this' proposal is $45,500, including out-of-pocket expenses :. (see following page for detail). These fees are based upon our understanding of theservices you ` : ° desire and a recognition on our part that these services will require a substantial commitment f ;'.'' . • " by the partner. and manager assigned to your project: _ -._ _ .. • ? T •r Y<'. .?I'.j+(r,i s[1C s..77J ?i K. ??t-??'?? t .??, :yrr, z'r.l` ?;. ^''r ?• ..I r r .. - a .+??,.:: ?r 'i ;: i?is•e L;'?', af??•. r ¢'t f. .4 ,?,* t ?iy t' ?,• 1 a ,. t ', - - :l3 rf{t`s Y?w:C?` :!' .Af, ,I'iT IS' i i .I r ? il,f1t•. ? ,J • ' r a ? f ` ' t, a s?? Y?t•' ? ! `f ?, ? .t? .@` Sr : J - , r r Y ! _ i. ,• }?? ' ` ' ' • ' 3 . J ',??.•,.;? !,a`,. • }rt? r ?".t:, 'e l: f„ •{, ll ,? r .' .. 3 ? .• ! , ..!. e. .VO? 1 oCOOOOOInC N f7 RV (D CC) t ' rn Ln N O 0 1 o (a 9r co ' N N Lf) 1 t m pye CF)a)W0)CDNN C(a L rZ 1 4 0 N V V; ' N Cdr co co N(7a+fico r-14. a)w(0r- NN+- r f? s '.t M N 0 t1l LO U') r i n M LL 0. .Z' ' .., E - . OOOco ?' N M o lD 0 N LL cn ui . :. w %raco NOit co cc LoNr';r N r to C" o m rkr N O _ 1' • . ? o z CO(n ? ' co co U7 o Q , t , f V trtDtoco0awin(D r7 cD to ?i' lr, rd ' r 1 1 U. O Y O ! f • ? N maw - .NNMtD wCOMW o .1 to t f,: 0 m Q7 cm Eton a CL : 0E y °° s 0 o f t! v CD Cc, 0 '.m .0 .0 CL 4) m - 4N .?a, ? o . G:r.:k.fi, "•£Slf"v jY?° j't ,1'vt'ir ?:?NS: ?.?:? '<_,? a r• I ?. ?rS'. -.`?.?ic' r r7. 14T ii "-!Y• 'ir ?f4' -n,.k x•'. r-l.+ si'. r. y},..,.>2f ,.,?.. ?t,•,... ' ,?.: +!'r•.Re ^,• 'tlt" S"i -'rIr• i ri .r V t.' ,, `u ' ..ty { , q ?,{! •T "? 1, r -k ' •; 't, i ' " L i , .t, rr_' .s , _7'? `;::i S:r..-- r.'C°. ''y,".?: e_s, ::S" c,`<r. P ?;i.iS. "?, !.T '}v a: it t?f ^S?e 3?rf 'F o,.>?}t,k ^1?t:ry?' ?€;':y?r.:?, •;'J' ,i f, ..} .`i`° i, .r'r 'dt•, rrt :t•.: ;fi, ,+ "-'C,, ,'?a t J4?' I t ti.: j} .,` ;? .7ky j?'*? .t. -r. Fs, ,}': f, j 't'' rl,. .. j" 'r:'1,{•4n.tA 'ls: fir, to . !•, -'I;,', r'iP'JrP. ,E t• .? ` i r , -, WE }'y ,: rY f '.\' 1 k <Afq%- ?t ;<. :y r jl:'!f JI-}Y`. '`F" '•.Y' - J' to a-'?f ,k,,, "-'4 - . '? ' r' : . : r (., ' r, - }: 11 S i s'...,? s1' 'r `.Y -4 Z?'sa 'f.', rE ''}i::S l'r r !. 'c & -i - ,', r, 'j+ j''t'- .,? .T tt''>j•t: , ?%r ', . ,'fs E. C. :35. •t?;'(]°? r'. iJ,`[. ,. r r:', -t} t.l, `fi'g`: r:s' 102, i `r' ,, I°-'r,; , ':r.?; ? +y] .?j- r. , ;i . .P, j,. , t' ';'r .F ?,'., io-` D`. ', V, r? ;?•3, `A ,3•r- ', ?f;:. 'ji r:: •ii !,..`h,•?'v'!t. 4.Y , .r 4 1 , t F. t. i• ?.}' ,?ga ?] :; r1#':?, Fi, ,r<:,4 ^,4,i'M•_.." e,t, .; ;. rf., ,£.. -a.x. -r':?!', .i - j ,, Y ac ; ,. i' f , :i: r` Rat 'n ,,:,• '.5., '•?. ,t .:1rf. 5'};.:: r5 -r ,(, r' y',,i?f. i,r b .(1,,1tiy:: Stk° t`` t?))r .ar`''. k ' - X " _ . . - r t p,' " ir'.;. -1 I •r e' , ,r.. ONTO : `+ .{ -k`r ''. i-3-.1 i.! ,lst:: ,1 lS .p.}£, ,'-?'".II. ,.k'r', } !.- t, .. r-, ? , ? ?- ? " ,!. ,' . ft_' '''t."?';'^, j s'rjy?` p ^•?'•?:r 1?•, Div. ,'s!'R; 1, ,fh:++M.f(, ?,.?A .1w J,i to n'.t 1•'- In ,Y Fr : . 1,*5 -f' r .;;., '»')e; .'t.' a.> 7, ,t ?k x {"•r •.S:>b t l'%-, i , 'o-i r -st: , • Sri -' °'t 'Q 1,05 , i}1 11 '{• ,i$ b*L'3 -l,-?•.,•lrx 'e by. F^, Ll "'3 ;ir 'k, f;, „•)si, •y..• 3•!' .i•„•. `.;,, t_., ,E .o7E` -'T S,: s'. •` 't , J. _ J,rl,?.y' rr1 t+ <? . _if all l, ref toy 'cti !r:}5`:?J?;'.7' 's',!: 'W)1 ,l, Y 1i•,',? ',,,.j:-#,r•R'£ IS• ,- i `t . '' Ar ;sf. . 'i it? A < f ;ti., - r: `> 11' :R ,".s•,, "1.' ?,:F.?, fj?, `, t -? ; #• ,fir' }r )„iff j'• .i r°s'•''i`r'j '.]' ;?,e,<i: b i.' 4' , p `:': ,Il,, } : .f -', ( ,'aYf „i.`t., ,`y,-,'tf. :»t? 3.t'33; 'Er::r, !i)1< 'i ; f, ;f y :u: 5t'r rr .f,,? , s ?,_fi. .?6c % "' 1:9€£ 'i, t+ ;s. f 0 1r . i•at ;s i T f",5.,,,5 -It l•i??, }? ,( iP "°.J• JI t;rhr q,r?i`i• i"F ?y, J'. „r. ?r ;r,:,e?: .ir.A. :?a r.?; %':, ?.y: lyy.r- .. Vj2? lsar;l's.:?'-???r, ' '°:r ,R:, " ' .,.'r?.F ?'• ' i f ?• :: >.yI'< ?f'1ANY x is s ' i ? j` ? w, ri •t3 S- , i'rr a r.%.K: t , Y :Y r1 : r•, •?: ' , . 5 . F- .rt r, ` w `i.di ` 3 , 'jr Ai.f'~z' A. a:'r,.y' a+ . .'y ,?"'t,;, ?. y '' ' .r':?i '.ir'F, .s;'r .ip X11. "t,,. : •'}' rfi 1'h1 :f. r;;7 . ".?77.'?''r w^? 't ;?:5 ..`` `ii ::4' , _s :O .. .z,'X., ''i'' .f,:'!'. y? :te :r• ,f,= . +f 3 + t?"° ;i'("..1: ;>fN :<h ',,, 1. 7t1h ,:,, ? 4 .?, ..a .rr .:!' •.f,p.{. .tt? <t s• '' ' ¢,• }:'!GO 39 '•"? ' 'C.''t ,1' :$.i,].r: L ,,?, ? S. 4. ry ,%s,s.t,.- yrS' " .{' ,J ? .',+ u.f'-r i'r ,,s • F.; ' ?er , ,.• .?[?:`F:"'s' .s' " s', j??• •"I • PM '«- ; }i.-„>° (S• j.'?'Lq_'r: ' , +, ., i,yl;:` -.t6-, 4" !+ f.% 'F . ; ] 1 <,r .rf-' i4? ,"Y "F z.Y • ? ..,.: 1. , I-? . ',if, ?.i.;.t`s.: r`r r .t .:YJi.<, ,"i l,,,QL. S • .`°t, ?4", ?S..Lr? : Y -et` •? .:• , l•' • ..$' .t .YY , ' w h,`''t'':v 414rArt .tr,s i? ' < ct%'df i Y 1 o" t Izl' ir i' ' y4 .K?«:".,., ( :. AT J ? f .s! ,`, '! r{+v r*t€f;: y4?y ,r m 11 ,',a 'nC i?C ,r.yt . ,z 1 so 1, ,.' ?',r.,:.P,X,' .r?'' ' ." .:l:i•'?.; ,:.?Vfy' .-lt:j"r j Ys 3. ,1„ T` rgiiI ??r w.'.t' * ti :SsAr i; ,`,:r'T r...: r,i '.. a°.,d"1 l J2f'' :f:.i:''ti 4?;. yI c,iT".,.t_ :f'::#:.`so :? :i:a.' rs; ••F -l?'} I. }'ya:s.V =, k '11111 ,i 1,f9 t .s. ..r.' ''s. •?'{Y•;Qp '.n ,?V"}?'1 'r ^c'-a-t'1i` ,y!.r e m ! y"S' 'r, ,y.:, .:3. ,1' °i ;f`i':.."?,`^ 7 7iq'-" {° : r- S' f•{ s/F ,?•b ., ; •?. ` 3` '.r ,as' . ?''2?' i' , t . 'r r' 11 "?'!SA, J)'' ':r b.j f..M R,- 4, •',f" ?'1 ;r i. Y' e+ -rR' t ,i:'• `,) I,';7. ?i1-n f. '' 24-Ma " ,t' f'? i4Ss` •;'•,'Y 't?[% ]'a '.1; ,ii> „?'",: E ,I :,.,,!: ?r' m:rS' .3 }'.J' r •F.>- ,. r.t:a' 'ir,'' I•,?? •I' ? .){: ;.??i•.iaf','t' ,>•;. P,. j,•r.`.= d• :f .«. . ,r: 1'.' r .{; ?.'i°.t ,. ?: ?..:'t r6 t:, its ' :o Sn ! ..r:;?}.#. 1E. :1?r ? ;?{Hlt tJ~ • 7 ?a~"_ 'r, 5'. r'{ 'y?q'1•;.,° r • , f. f '•j, , . r ., i-4* , rr'?:F b: y.y '-]. ''?,,9' ;'t ,•t1: z .r, _x-. 1>" 1' !.-'':,..,: A. . E'•{`; i rs, t¢„ti r7- rah , . i.? 3' {, t. x' iFi. '. • loo- .j,. , :r,i ! '•> ,_ .1 ' ;it'S Y, f s yr- A, rv, d.. . e'q ,r'' f ,i Y.;'.• .5 r, . ly.S'I,° - r „1"" .'r.`:'.`;tvy" 'si a 1'._. z • + aT'. `? yr.k..(^xUs. :-I::.'. ,.' ": ,:. ,'' S .f? ,s .y ?` I- ? 1r ` ?ti`a . .1 i ! ?I'/:- i •Sk 't ?• r€- S .- /'i LJ 1 .,?_?i'?' ;r'-r (!?r sF. •'! -.f5. _y, S, '°!3 - i'' "I..,`t•'t]' ", .Y ! ` I, ,,' . " Le i y ).-z "f T` r (}, C tr% ' a:_' i>i'. r,. ir?J ' s - s?'.'r` : G?1,' :3 rtA[, i4 ..Lt?L f .,t ?ii,I,tiF.: 't 'o-.? „•,•1rf.l:,,v'. .. }`° _.I. ?'.;.•Y:Jlr', r sr?;'?'•..t•.:,ti -?.'4.?;?.,-"];.'S??'I . f.w ax.C'.,,'v'» .a rr',:•::, ,,-,:. ;.,,,.,, "; F.. r '. ,ir, ,"' . ri; , .' 1 'r, ,. ,I " : , , r r ` S r •, rrt ,i'`•1 ° r Y i' f 3 ?. 'r • „ ? " ,f '' P 1- ,,. , f' z { i :Y. , . t I.. , f ,'li±. .•t:= •l S l ., ? • •! ' 'p ' • F q ,.. "a'. 1 r. ,r r - t , , ,lE- "t• i r '': i e ' S t ': .. .. k: , P„ . ' .. , r' 1'v r , : ' i ? 'rant . , , - f , . f . i ?(„" ' t' , ' 1 F,ly _ . r ,LSE , •:f ' . ' ' r , ,. . b , I - . , s .. iF yj, ")` , r l? 'J f•,' •1 ' J " ' p,t.Y;: , i ,' '' ' ' ' ' w x ' Y . r r ., Y's is 01 , '{'v `fi'r i/ ; : END IX APP x . ,,, :j 1 ' r - :. : , a' r ,i , , , k, .. ? ,,'..,.r"",. ».1;'.h a ! r , 1'. .T' '.7?r"I r ;. ?4 ,;..,?. ,.? ,. . 1 .' . ,: i' :k , °• - f' - ` f .. :C." '? ij' ' . I ' [ ' ' l S f ' ` ' ? P i fl 7- D .1 I• ], , ' K r y . },t f ?. 3 _,7 ,' ° '' , ' !r _,;: r: . ,5.. :. ,c•V•, r, ss,. ' ' 1: :'l i •f i 13. Fr. •.t...P is : e; •i; _ : = E : r.'i :fzr.r: $ ' ? r - r s " ; : ? < , t Ye ;y. . ,, : ?' ova j .(,'r. ,f. :Y!1r t' ) , ,' j ; : "• : : ' r ? '' , ? : . , , at l: i f • .:4 . r l!° r;?-'f-34 •i!" ' T .. . . R• r rf. ,. j. ar:' -e r r ?, " .;, r t : ? , , '+ 'C - .IFf ".t }}]]jj a? ..:1. ? •r r•. I , , s E y I P•e. f i`I`4' zi' r- , .lY. '1, t r S, 1? .. , i:. ? :t ,r'.,,; ,' ?5 ° v.. ';i ;' ; , ? ' . . . . . 0 ' : .. . , ' - , . t _ '; r'iI .t „t.. .. ,4 i ' ' ' N - L - '? ' ' ? ' .' " ?. : ,;,? , - ?- , 1 ? - ? ' -'/1' ? .' I " - ; ; ' ' , ?.,?- , : st r, - " ? . _ v t s. r. R s :1 ' ; : O .?, . ? - '; f . { A N 5: f. , ' ' k 8 . , f i . I. f, t 1- 3'• . .'} y s, '4 Aew } I " h' 4" !'f + k. _, 1 .ti ; :e S' ,'r - [' V f .rl,u ?- , `' (r .' I -i 'E ' •i '. I ;r rf rJ• 5v; -'I.i', 1 f '1 !, . FF . . S 1 :c ., 1M- ,i ?, ", 1: .., , .r. F,s• 1 .i- :y. f ,i .'S.< r;.t?11 r , 'i , P ' ' , 1• ' _' ! f I, ' _ ". ' r ." ` ' ' y ,f " . .r .y.i L5, ?) ' fh'a 1 ' ' >z3 . 1 : ;l il2 J' Y.: i i i-'n'4.:.? ']`. .3' -j:=, s,l. ?i? .. . » ;r'r.: .; j , . ` -.) -Ie. .?.fVie.: . t , _ i. : t: JCL ,. , .t., 1 ,e. P:: ' 'r f ? " , • r.,r, II ' i ! £ts- '.d: ,.1. {j -f., r I fit - S " I,r:..`• ' 1J ' ,i, '' tr'-S' t J' ;r: Jf''• ' F` 11 ?!t-, . } )• 3 3 r ' , P , , , 4-, ''r 1 i / ' , - ' P '.dl? , a is ,: r ' , r , 's r .' fig; ., ; " l '= „ ! ?.. .. : .i .}: , :.h }, M1 !, S,? It . ' ''y" :l . f W r .r ',r }} Lgt'f' i ::;h.. ' i - - r' , ..r ? , .. a ' e .. ]. f, :F' . } 1 I • , . O 71 ' .,l . . - •-', ',t i , f `I ., ',T' ;.I F"„r 'a 'i ,t - 00 'ilk - 'i• A. 't ?- ,., , v . ' ; .. , . . : j,j r1 • ,,}-?, . ?1. .{. n.. - , ' '*'« i _ r. it " ' , r ' 1 I '( ' r I 3, - S , P . ) .1 Y, i I .i r , . ? • .if , . '' _ f!p 1, - .). 't' ' f i =1 f ? - - r, . F. . f - A I . £1, . p .. 'V , . ? _ ' i° , 1 : ' `T; -, rr _ 7 " : ' I ,r,-. .e t, - - t €:j _ V.1,,. g€'.. ,a, r ,1, f }j' , ti, _' a' .t i ,j, t_ 'f,'d '/""L " - , ' ' "' , . _ •r ' .. I ' St. ' •tr .1 1 °'- ''( %,;,.`4i ! r f ' r. I: r" 1-. , -' ! f t t t`, P t' t. ." - ] • • t ' . , . i .. , . ' ''F E r ' ^ r• t E • if ..' P ' r 't' JAM. • . t I t4 , - '1"''Fit :'1 ' ' .. 3 . 'i I - .: } ' ` 1 T . ,. .. ,1 ; :1:. - r r i 'I'. : ' irr'' ,. M: t,: 'I •a? :7 _ ,'. f€ . , j. f l f? '`. ?y'" .t s'f 'w S Ji' lEh`:,' "4 ' {'`-'+ Man 1111 ., I ' :' Fl.,.. '. . } . is -it',-IC '1?':!a?,' .'k'r `M 4?[' ?'}i , Y °E' I 4 ' . . • r i '+v'la ti ?i;?,;.'::r "°n°,r y:: Yv''' r ,11 ) Ys _ .,v r .. ' .?',... , , .' b r-:. t i-- ,r'. ! . . .t . ., -I' . i ," . , „,,IN, ", . '}i - L? - r`s E' .._.5 i-'?',fr 4-??.`',i..?.:a-111 ci.4,. Lx7r€f , '' J y .. ) t 1 1 1 p. ?? Ca O I O LL ¦? C Q O v' - , ¦L ? O C O O ¦ V '0 • m O .?.. e¦?r ? Cc ;» = o ' ! w •..r rr ui ¦ H C E w~ a a m H CD = C' X» V O m C 4? C E OL oc?Ea?°oa ,m v,ORcm 03Vo- U Lo>C:Uco u U ca 0 V otj c AD p? ' c n°. (? L ' L m •C ..? = 03 4i 0? Q G E 4 O>> H ?Z?°?Ur 40. d O C ?W m V? O O O •C M M lti7 O 'L7 O •C C 'a 'O 'a C -y 4? E E U UUUO[L-r (D U), ¦ ' •IS _'x o; .7 'V I REPRESEN'T'ATIVE NATIONAL UTILITY AUDIT CLIENTS Electric and Gas Allegheny Electric Cooperative Jackson County REC Corp. American Municipal Power Johnson County REMC Arizona -Electric Power Cooperative Kansas Electric Power Cooperative ARKLA, Inc. Kansas City Power & Light Co. Associated Electric Cooperative Knoxville Utilities Board Baltimore Gas & Electric Co. Lane Electric Cooperative • Bangor Hydro-Electric Co. Lucky Peak Power Plant Project Blue Grass Rural Electric Cooperative McMinnville (OR), City of Boston Edison Co. Midstate Electric Cooperative Burlington Electric Department Nebraska Public Power District Canby (OR) Utility Board, City of New York Power Authority Carrollton (KY) Utilities New York State Electric & Gas Corp. Central. Electric Power Cooperative New England Electric System Central Louisiana Electric Co. Niles (MI), City of Chesapeake Utilities Corp. Philadelphia, Electric Co. Citizens Gas and Coke Utility Piqua (011) Municipal Power System CT Municipal Electric Energy Cooperative Portland (OR), City of Delmarva Power & Light Co. Puget,Sound Power & Light Co. Delta-Montrose Electric Cooperative Richmond, City of East Kentucky Power Cooperative Salem Electric Cooperative Eastern Utilities Associates Sierra Pacific Power Co. El Paso Ndtural Gas Co. Tennessee Valley Authority ` Energen, Inc. - Texas Municipal Power Agency Eugene Water & Electric Board Tipmont ItEMC Forest Grove (OR), City of Top O'Michigan Rural Electric Company Fruit Belt Electric Cooperative UGI Corporation , General Public Utilities United Illuminating, Co. Gulf States Utilities Co. Warren County REMC Hoosier Energy Rural Electric Cooperative Wilson' (NC), City of Water/Wastewater Atlantic County Utilities Authority Marin Municipal Water District Beaverton; City of Medford, City of California Dept. of Water Resources Municipal Authority of Westmoreland Clakamus Water Northampton Bucks Co. Mun, Auth.' Community Water.Co. of GreenValley Portland, City of Continental Water Company So. Central CT Regional Water Auth. ' Corvales, City of, Tigard 'Water District Denver Water Board Washington-East Joint Water Authority East Bay Municipal 'Utility'District Water Works & Sewer Board-Birmingharn Herst Creek Municipal Water District Westpac'Utilities (div of SPPCo) Lake OsWega, City of Boldface type >a Concurring partner or technical consultation provided by members of the JTampa office, 13 ? r rt ` " ' ' Y sti.x. w ` 1-.. ,r ' n 4. , .{`rf . ' .•+?'J !'' . i'' :l.*'i ?.. . ..' ,! , ' `'. r • ' REPRESENTATIVE NATIONAL UTILI'T'Y CONSULTING CLIENTS Alberta Power Limited Los Angeles Dept. of Water & Power Appalachian Power Co. Louisiana Power Light Co. Arizona Electric Power' Cooperative Madison Gas & Electric Co. . E. Arkansas Power & Light Co. Manitoba Hydro r t . Associated Electric Cooperative Michigan Power Co. . Atlantic City Electric Co. Middle South Utilities, Inc. Basin Electric Power Cooperative Minnesota Power & Light Co. Black Hills Corp. Mississippi Power & Light Co. Blue Grass Rural Electric Cooperative ' New Orleans Public Service Bonneville Power Administration. Niagara Mohawk Power Corp, British Columbia Hydro Northeast Utilities Brooklyn Union Gas Co. Oklahoma Gas & Electric Co. Carolina Power & Light Co. -Orange & Rockland Utilities, Inc.. Central Hudson Gas & Electric Otter Tail Power Co, ' ?• Cammanwcalth Edison Co. Pacific Lighting.Corp. .r Consolidated Edison Co. of New York Plqua (OH) Municipal Power System ' Dixie Electric Membership Cooperative Public Service Co. of New Hampshire' Dominion Resources, Inc, Public Service Co. of Indiana Duquesne Light Co.' 'Public Service Co, of Colorado East Kentucky Power Cooperative -Public Service Enterprise Group Edmonton' Power Rochester Gas & Electric Co. El Paso Electric Co. Saluda River Electric Cooperative ENRON Corp,' San Antonio, City of Eugene Water & Electric Board San Diego Gas & Electric Co. Gas Company of New Mexico South Jersey Gas Co. Georgia Power South Kentucky Rural Electric Cooperative Houston Lighting & Power Southern California Edison Co, Indiana & Michigan Electric Co.' Southern Co. Services, Inc.` Iowa Electric Light & Power Southwestern Public Service Co. . Iowa-Illinois Gas '& Electric Co. Tennessee Valley Authority Johnson County REMC Texas Municipal Power Agency Kansas Electric Power Cooperative • Texas Utilities Electric Co. Kentucky Utilities Company Washington-St. Tammany Electric Cooperative Kingsport Power Co. Western Area Power Administration Lone Star Gas Co. Wisconsin Power & Light Co, Long Island Lighting Co. Boldface type = Consulting or tech nical consultation provided by members of the Tampa office. . .1 14 i T:.' t F r •.r?? .,+ . .L. ; r ,,.., ., .1,•I. .'}..y•l'',, "::l ,t• .i i `.7., F !' .{ . "y": . J. 7" 'Yr rf -v s.7°,"L•?4:. ?.;.?.;??k y'• '4'•4 FSh• '} •r .. ..., r11. _ r, ,}iv.. '^''?, ''?-r <J- I, ',r ?) 'J r r1 'Sk .h' 1''r s''. s'-": J 3'. Y.f. 1 •Ya r .. ' , 'e. i 3?"(i ar -f: ' ':i. 'I t, II) '•A. 11i• ' ° . . 1' , 1, r'*,+ '',, r.. ?-p r?,?.r'; •w` , .,r'f ,f' ..r. Irk, ;7+: •ra s .. -'I', -`I"'.,?,. •f tI ?,- . , a ? - r.• ? i }' :r ?f l: y. ?Ai I '.1?• "`. :'t'. ' .L !'° I(." 'I' --'y Ii ']. } ,°.:7 - - o ? ., rj' .r .4 h1fOM 4-a 1?;, 'k .,I? %r ??:'..r ' S 1' p it} 4 '.r1.` ,?M}`. ,'g' ?' , - . S` ,3, .. .. r.: 't .; 1`,?ty t['ti'=- -' ;;; r'rs T .•.1'(`,r F' r: ` 'v .y" . 'f' x,f ',Y", I . tr• 61i ! . FE •'f` ' i' ''7.' Y'?'51;,q•3 i:4r,., ,•J, e. ,1. . {',p, ? ` s ." ir1•s! ' _ .krr, }s'".'Y'. FI r.: r' '+i f 1. , i I.: , i ,iy ,. : ?,,I I L' t 9. 1$ •,r l Nl'- '? , ' r`i •'-i:. ?. r,, irk'x ?'I f ' I SP e,..?F.` .'S . JA ?:% «N+ a?s:'e-1 :. i?.r' I "•" f' r i . ,`r A, •e ,'t,.Y'4? .p$,?E`, 1`.1,x.' f;,j' }' .'}•' "r':it '. 'C?`,•';d i• I .. '•i .Y ri ..,:;, t-. •p Y. Jd ;a.`•.r> - ''k'wrl j'r' 'dJlr0 %r,''11Rf'rp-?F, i1."',I.a .r:. h i.,. i f' rj'',,?;? >:tir 1•.' .,? j -- 12.?'' 4I r..$, ?Ii f,l '•, ;•a !: .. - J' F " /.', ? ?•ti' .i r °, F' 1j,'-i'.L . 1 R?I.,' } - , lp, a 4 E ti ,c i; y ... J, ' i, r .. .. , r I. • ?' ,, a ?r}}'d S41','i,, '1`. :., ,: .jt 'J£.` ? •r` S:f";..j<• _ r1 :, _ 1 nF,:iy.l' ,??.•',`:.Jr ,r t:: :', k*- ji:, t<'i; •-*! !..#,f:.-r .' , t' .1', .f t +'""ir? f„L-• 6 _ `? ° ,:? J `t4 , J r .! ..F',':sv - - -, s a. ; t? -. ?IV.r?, II' }1.I P. F? . J:i,'i% •A?I. g,'. 1 s,. r:+ti I,f /L':.r`i ?, " F , " ,rl,,•.,'I ',; t - r i F r . .lj e' lkG-;3\.k j >' t, !,'rS:r h Y.i« i?F • t3 { '..JA".f FS ',` .?I-r '1 f ! ' - r , - e°5 tti Yrt•: 'Y£;P.,k?;l'., 'J'r?:,., •° J F.f rti•' '(:,.{ `? . .i .. '.t. ?I , ,7' r '?':f . ..FN",4 ..r' ..,-. . .'•i•r-4'iy`%.=';.7'-., k',1,e.i wFrri,'4•:1.;(c':'. ... o.- , •;"o- c... ,'r' r., . ... F1 ... i- ,. `r.. ... ?l.+. ' .. . 1. ?1J..' s., 5•. ,[T r `. ! , r• ` r +<r i 7 , r _ - -) ,r.P .;: ., i"", , .r r - ,r . . . F, . 1 ,' .:air `. {, . < . fi r . : I . t ', J ' t . , . • , •'J;3 c f -: F 1 . .. t„ F'?f..'?. ,'.1 fl . . ;'.. , J ' F .. . ' . .. - F. .,,., ,.j' y,?k .. J . . , f'.-. . r"; Ifi ;!. - r S I r 4 .r . : r: ',-?' ,??'-.- , .E.'N I :'. I. - ? . il ?- "' ' ? - - L , . , ? : '. ''. ? ' ' If k 4 " " - . ? . ? - . . L . ? -. -.?) }. }R 1 A $[ ,'.;-,;, : " -'?'..-' It, '. L.' ?? ?' L ; . ? , , . ? : I . " I -A, lommomm - , , ' I . : -` , I . . I 4. - -, " - i. ,,r ,',: ' . f , . . . . ' .t. - , r: i} i 1 '.a !Yi .k,. t ,fir. '/ r f , ' i '?.il. •r..1 t', e1, r.- t. .,. iC?:l a?_ ''fi r'' .. rs• ' I' r.J.- ' 5. ^r !?'1 w ?' . 7 F'. 1. . i`ar qtr ': f, r . . ITEM r ' ' 'r, 1t' -2-0- , • r - . . - .• , .1 'L-I , L I W I I ? I - r I I ' - ?- - r - ? . I r : _ d?p/ t r . ? - - ? ' . , , . . ' ' ! . . . I I, , r ? ?? . , , ? . '3 ?'. I I . r I . L . I L , " r ,r l : +.,' ft'fl ..r, •r. 'r ' ''II '`, ' ..( . . I. I r r ,, r , . - ?Lt .' 'l'am°I. , . ' .'I. ' . " . %f • .( ,e " 'r'' `f *^!'34..`r., ?? 1 :le.T .r 'f • 7r r -- _ ,. -.1' r `•; ,f.x: :r.I.S i,? Z}? 14 +?b '.f ...•-:wr .:Ja` xa '! .. 'r .Ir ,.T,',•J.l'{. r:•'I l'kP 1 ! 7 ,r '1.. i"'A r ' ,K, ya S' gin." f :3.' "f ;' ,. ., t . ° , • :, 1. ?'frr' : .r1. ?k ;. r.'h.' -4': a. '.; w.., :f7 Y•__-; `T' 5' . [ ,F . a ... a T4 .7. s..7 :'1 r, __-"'•"r" _-_____ _- . .ti•l,•, ,,,4. 1 1,1 _5.,;,t . i S " Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum i SUBJECT: HEPATITIS B VACCINE Mee t _03/18/93__ RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Purchase 200 complete series of Energix B Hepatitis B Vaccine (3 units per person) from the Pinellas County Health Department for $99.00/series to be administered by the Clearwater Fire Department Emergency Medical Services Division, total cost of the vaccine is $19,800.00 in accordance with Section 2.554 (d) Code of Ordinances, Pinellas County bid for purchase of vaccine. 0 and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: .In December 1991, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). adopted a bloodborne pathogens rule. The State of Florida, Department of Labor has adopted the OSHA regulations as of January 1993. In order to comply with those standards the city must offer to employees in high risk occupations a Hepatitis B Vaccine, various other training programs, and personal protective equipment. This is both a federal and state mandated program for personnel in high risk exposure occupations. The City of Clearwater's Risk Manager has determined that certain personnel of the Police Department are included in the,high risk exposure category. The Clearwater Police Department, in anticipation of the OSHA standards began training in July 1992 for all personnel who are in high risk exposure occupations. Those personnel trained included police officers, detectives, parking enforcement officers, and police service technicians. The training explained the procedures for the administration of the Hepatitis B vaccine. The vaccine consists of a series of three injections. After the initial injection, a follow-up is administered in 30 days and another follow-up in 180 1 days from the original injection. Reviewed by: Legat Budget Purchasing _ N/A Originating Dept: <,p y POLICE Costs: $ 14 800.00 Total 19 800.00 C 13 ission Action: Approved Approved w/conditions Risk Hgmt. /A__ Curr ren[ F scat Yr. D Denied Cis ACH N/A User Dept: POLICE Funding Source: © Continued to: Other Hum.Ret. © Capital imp. eratin ® O p g Advertised- © Other Attachments: Date: Paper: 0 Not Required ttted by ? ?] f - /. r1 t? ? r Affected Parties D Ratified Appropriation Codes: 37,500.to be charged to code 010.01145.521500-5217000 ® None C. `+ } r LL ® Not Required $12,300, to be charged to code it Manager I 590.09831-521500-590-000 0 Printed an recycled paper is k. ez MIA ' . l •` ' • ' I • ! 5 • r. ' p 1, '. ' y. . . j. .';r I r I 1 Y !,•. ?. r r, . i . .. ' r 1 f °S I ?' 'r r ' • ' ' , . • Y t , r r ? ;S ., ' ' f 1 ..ty 11 J.•. • r• 1 V' y+y: ;r?if' , f. J ,. f'J?: f„r:nW'.1i .. . ! .. .. i'.45,,. .?e`?, .'t+•. ?..,i?.?r S'.I -e• 5 : r e, t ....'?'.? The Clearwater Police Department has chosen the Energix B vaccine as the Hepatitis,B Vaccine. . The Energix B vaccine is actually'a double dose and has . . 3.' proven' to be much more effective than 'other brands on 'the'market. ° The..vaccine'will be. obtained and administered through a cooperative effort of the'Pinellas County Health Department and'the Clearwater Fire'Department ',.Emergency,Medical services Division. The vaccine will cost $99.00 per'pe'rson. .-With an estimated 200 personnel having asked to receive the vaccine, the total. cost would be $19,800., The Fare Department's Emergency Medical Services Division will administer the vaccine-at no cost. As `a follow up next year, a Titer,Test'will be administered to; all personnel '.':.-receiving the Hepatitis B vaccine. The test is designed'to test the individual ., ,to ' see. if 1 they have built up the necessary immunities to 'combat the. Hepatitis, B 5. virus.. It-will be administered,by the Fire Department Emergency.Medical Services Division.' Cost 'of,this test is $20.00'.per'individual. The funding .,for the.Titer test wi11'be in.the' 93/94 operating budget, for the Police Department. .Funding for-this purchase is budgeted in operating code, 010-01145-521500-521- r 000 which has available funds'of $18,564.00-and operating code, 59'0-09831- '521500-590--000 which has available'funds'of $26,635.00. All available fund , balances are as of March 4, .1943., {. yi: r f1)?r}''3?`'e `SI. 1`lt i.l?,('i?.3 rA?• Y?1 !• i ?3 ?ry' 1 ' .. ? - ,i ? r 1 . i:.'1' ? Sri •? >?•. y; 1• i r I: :fi Y'?Z .,,t?..}'', ?r=,. .'...: >. ? 14?. r,///I .?;•;t,.,?.?? .{, .r?'t '.. r? -` 1 p'. } ?, ,.r'?I[?y ..k i. f ? 'r?'!r.`I :f . f ', ?<?t F.. i,. r ! , ` r 1•' ? .f r '..Y }? i,3.t.yl,, .. ,fh; s :.t •? ? f''?' '1. it fit' f?: .: ?. ,. ? ` ' r •, ,? f _ {7a? ??,Y i'?, r 'a. ,? . r`e ?? •' r, I, ;1•'r I^ k• ? ' ?! ,. .. i •,,, Is?4 I?S?. v'r 1. rt•..S-• f, /'. .:'t ?. k e..,F'. a.• ?,a?d, '.Y 1' i; ... . ., ? _ .,. .. ,. .r ?. . ?s?' •?'i'', r ,.. ., .. .. .. ,....'.IL 1,' 'eiu•:•4 i??.?SK.`.`yy``??.. al?l,!Lr:. ',1,.4'nd?}"'+.t jtvi_s,li ,•7e ..7'r:d,y;. ? •t ?I .. ' re .fi it.?ty •' .. ,s.,, , 'w., ?}s`? .?1'•.> ?.. .t.w,l v a :r. ;t... .... f r ,'I, G4'i??tlii sl 44- .DEC-17-1992 17:19 -FROM CLW. CITY MANAGER TO \6?0`44?f P. @1' i }(r . f,' y ?'1+• w41141? {IINI$Rilj(pt Mom, M {i ofp?prtl ? ? ? . C, /V1 CITT x w ar ri WATER . e3.. IntcrdeFalr`halent, Cat`reepoodCnce TO: POBC" Chief Sial Ir'l n ' QOM: Michael ri-'I" City Manager SU =T: Hepatit?5 Vac inc5 ?'? 1 L.S?T Dere mbar 17, 1992 171e'police nftiLrn who would like to Ire ex immunized for H aed.% R pense. j The shuts wiiL be admitustcred by City of Clearw the s r p.7ran?rcli s s 00st.Or 5100,00 lrnr Officer. pp ; • ' atartQn cl , 's Tiu'Wst of the. iMmunixatiuns will be 1 s' rdct f paid for•fror?: s as a rout or physicsil examieidtions with 11?,'A the budget savin Ivsult of tha Pamily Cdre' Can will br?U&ed ='590-1-9831-21$/590 and 010-1-114,5.215/521. x5. The hucigel L-Wes. w?tich , .f ,=a TOTAL rP. 01.- T', ;;: ,mot;' :,.7 ?.?•F sSY?? y ?j!I It i~.S<•i'r.'S,[J?,' •i Y•S i 1 + f, Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum n SUBJECT: PURCHASE OF THERMOPLASTIC STRIPING UNIT lte Hcet at 3, /18 993 RECOMM)E VDATION/MOTION: Declare City Vehicle 1331.97 surplus, and award a contract to purchase a thermoplastic striping unit for the Public Works/Transportation Group at a cost of $153,•766.00 from Pave Mark Corporation of Smyrna, Georgia, being the lowest, most responsive bid submitted in accordance with the specifications, and include- the trade-in of City Vehicle 1331.97 for a credit of $10,500.00 (resulting in.a net cost of $143,266.00), and authorize lease purchase through 1998; financing to be provided under the City's Master Lease Purchase Agreement with AT&T Credit corporation 0 and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: The Transportation Group has long used oil-based traffic paint for marking; traffic lines on the City's streets and roadways. Oil-based paint has several drawbacks, including a relatively short life,•a long drying time, and application and clean-up environmental concerns. The pavement marking industry has directed itself towards the use of an alkyd resin based thermoplastic material, applied at a temperature of 400 degrees to till: pavement surRace. Thermoplastic has a much longer life span, cures to traffic impact almost immediately upon application, and minimizes the effects on the environment in that the use of flammable solvents is discontinued. Public Works/Transportation has identified the conversion to thermoplastic as it goal for'Fiscal Year 1992/93. A discussion of thermoplastic pavement marling materials, prepared by the Transportation Group, and a memorandum from the Public Works/Environmental Group discussing the environmental aspects, are attached. The Transportation Group recommends the declaration of the existing paint striping vehicle (City Vehicle 1331.97) a 1983 Ford truck, as surplus, thus making it available tier trade. The Transportation Group also recommends the award of the purchase of the thermoplastic striping unit to Pave Mark, and recommends that City Vehicle 1331.97 be traded to Pave Mark for credit toward the purchase of this vehicle. Lease purchase funding for this purchase will be provided in Project 315-4221 (Motorized Equipment - Lease Purchase) which has available budget authorization as of 3/09/93 of $2,084,200. This lease purchase will be financed under the City's Master Lease Purchase Agreement with AT&T Credit Cornoration, Fiscal Year 1992/93 budgetary impact will be approximately $16,190 (Principal: $14,041; Interest: $2,149). Reviewed by: ,Legal Budget o Originating Dept: PW/TRANSPORTATION GROU? c, ;v costs: $ 143,266.00 - Total C ? ission Action: pproved roved w/conditions A Purchasing 1 4?? L IAV S 143,266.00 pp Risk Mgmt. £i5 ACM Other N/A gfflPTOR POOL ? V User Dept: PW/TRANSPORTATION GROUP Current fiscal Yr. funding source: 0 13' ? Denied Continued to: ,24 capital Imp. Advertised: ? Operating Attachments: Date: 11/13192; 11/20/92 Paper: Pin Cty Rev; Tampa d t R i ? N Trib 13 Other 1) 2) Memo from MEnviramentat Group dtd 1/22/93 Report on Thermoplastic o equ re Subnn b : . Affected Parties ?] Notified 0 Not Required Appropriation Code: 315.94221-564100.590-000 3) Bid Sheet 4 & 5) Memos from Pate Yauch dtd 12/16/92 8 3!10/93 City Man ? None <114 Printed o1M1 recycled paper • ;3 r, ' .. f'"•1 .. ?' ' ?, ?' tai !' .. ? r` F ' ' , Thermoplastic Paveamit Mnrlthigs Pavement markings provide important information to the motorist. They are applied for the purpose of regulating and guiding the movement of traffic, and promoting safety on the highway. In some cases, they are used to supplement the regulations or warnings of other traffic control devices. In.,othcr cases, tlicy are the sole ineans of effectively conveying certain regulations, warnings, and information in clearly understandable terms, without diverting the ' . ' driver's attention from the roadway. For years, the primary material for pavement markings was oil-based faint. Paint can easily be sprayed from a slow moving truck, acid mnde retroreneclive by drooping tiny-glass brads on the,wet paint. The City of Clearwater has long used paint for its long lines. Paint is , typically applied' at a thickness of ,15 mils (or 0.015 inches). At this thickness, it takes , approximately 16 gallons to paint a 4-inch wide line' one mile long. Clearwater maintains approximately 1,500 line-miles of pavement markings. Unfortunately, there are some drawbacks to using paint. It takes at least several minutes to dry, and therefore must be protected from traffic by placing cones on the wet lines. It has . a relatively short life -- as short as six to nine monflhs on higher voltme streets, And, there are growing environmental concerns, not only about the products used to clean paint machines, but also the volatile organic compounds released during the striping process. A water-based traffic marking paint, which resolves many of the environmental,concerns, is available. Unfortunately, it has been found to have all even shorter life span than the oil- based paints, and still has the long drying time problem. In light of the above concerns, the traffic marking industry has been headed toward hot applied,thermoplastic materials. While thermoplastic lines have a much higher initial cost, they eliminate the major drawbacks of paint. They set up almost immedintely upon application, eliminating the need for the placement of cones. They have a much longer life span -- typically several years under most urban conditions. And, they are much less an environmental concern.. Thermoplastic is an alkyd resin based product, heated to approximately 400 degrees, thcn . ' sprayed or extruded through a die onto the pavement surface. A sprayed thermoplastic line is applied at a thickness of 30 to 60 mil (0.030 to 0.060 inches) and is typically used to refresh t previously applied markings. An extruded line is usually placed at a thicluiess of 125, Toils (0.125 inch), often when new pavement is initially, marked, or for transverse markings such as crosswalks and stop bars. A one mile long, 4 inch wide extruded line consumes approximately 2,500 pounds of thermoplastic material. Glass beads are both mixed into the material and dropped onto the surface, to provide retroreflective properties. As the material. wears under traffic, new beads are exposed, lengthening the useful life of the material. . f • ?i, t „j• ' ! : elf t J., ? '! s? ,°?,+•. .41, r?4i•. . ..Y• , ; s i ? .is ?' sf' ,l:r"j 'Y. f1`r ..S .-•{? ?X SY. 7 ,,,??' ' :s.' Ii.''= I.}r?? ,fir' 'j'.> ? 'F ?: ?'` •, lj: fYc I'.?f'. h' 3' f .?.?•l`11 '??., i'-'L?: rrrj? ?}?•;3: ?t?r,. f?r "rf' ,E'"?°•?''s ;!•: ?•`?? S? " !`.• >r .. ? .,? .:r "?.. ^r: .-1ti'i .•r^?. r.. ). a•? r s i ' ar't' y. r j t .-y.' 6,y.. _ : i . s1 ' 4 ?•?,. ? .•i Je ? il.?;d M'r .,l.f ,j 1" l t ... r .' • •' v IW 'ri`'.l_ .??1,".< .e3. .F•.ij •?. ,y ..r ?.? + •,'?, ? .r riq_ {'fir. ., ?•,;f-S-L?.•Y` .E?:'. !r v+?•y.,?., R+?r' -?.,f,•''.r ` .. s'o? ., } i.+ ? ,1 ? b s.+;;,'??a`? }`r.Y?• ?(• ?'? I:1 .' F, s,f = ; ?t+ ,r: , ,. .i r?'i'` ?.';;' ?,'r,i a Cir.T. lt.y i' re1~ •ti E9}• 4,.1 ii4?'t' F • .r r ` : °r'e^'e ,j'• j•rr I. '•Y•};.Z, °, [,;.'? ''.,?w ;.?"?4f <. y: ,;. ?•tr"?','1`;c .??..? s' r •/. ? ..I ..ri.. :-r J..,7.( +`fn 'a?: ;...?:: •j? ,.'S2 ;'[,7;: i "r?" ,f'ir', ,'+ ? ' f' ? +I. .',' ?•_-' •}f 9;rs,??. ??tl'?;`' .?°!?},s`. :q< .r,' •'y :`? ?£,? .??.19?, it ?: 'S. t ?'j? , •. t q ',, .t._'???..,? J. ,; ?+`':r'f'f?7.t? iy';. ?r, ?.3 S, .,s?;<> `?r°? t}??<? r,?, ., t:' !r ? ?'?, .7"?,' ?•i "•1+.v7ir ]="Y'aa, rp rr•i '":'I;',.t ,3., i ?' ': !'e•... - i ,,?? ??`'t?t''1?.'S, ff,f???,''4Y?• ?'r .?f; •l+r l%+`f d.Pf?• •t'.{? r •ir-.S', '? -' ;r' ' r r '"r :?J?:? s,'i'''?Y?'"?b?'•y9 r.t /;1`?iI '!yL, wYv-+v: js-!' :r •. sq' .,r?. }. , ?: i "<+i}? s° .,?' .,',,.'F,•,/. .:i' r"«!'!??, '•. ;,'i ?3;:k ?,rc,: •t i; '.r?1 r' '! r s- a.-„t fix. •A S?;'ti.??:,r.a.°q' a? ,4 :` ?.f', iSI, .,f'. :}?'.: ":;r S+r?¢4?a it J}t.,":..,_?1..'f rl' .. ,;? r"? r'. ,1,'"? `?,r .R i... ??•, ar '1•y')j ? ^S.• .1: ,Y?u 'yi\t t1 •l. ` 1 k?' '?#' .f? iS:Sps •:}:*} :/` .7t '•a.`::(r't°?'rf..r''£• ?•,,:?rl#' y"'•?._>?,a'r :'? .,',, err' ,;?i' •-i•+.t[?S• n..5'".e?y.,r J:;: ?[~ .' ? „fit r. aa1,7.!':?f ? -1 ? +>. !r' ' r', ?.l •S?? `.i a%°,1;'•i; ^! t`: ale S;• r'g ,e„' 1 '•, r ' . . .. r - ' s I.. V ,,?' -i? '1,C 'ro {:??'•?..: fti !-„ s, t?'.. . s, t:: ?l:':::., r'?I t1' .i ,,. t^ •.5. r Tile City of Clearwater has used thercnoplastic material on a small scale for several years, Using a ,'66d propeiled, applicator; - most crosswalks and stop bars > hhve'-been ;'applied : in', thermoplastic:; in addition;'the lane lines oil the recently resurfaced section of Mandalay are also'.' . thermoplastic, ; t Tl?e. quick setting and- long life characteristics- of thermoplastic pavement markings "r"'',••;t enhance the safety of our crew. members, by eliminating the need to place and retrieve cones and. reducing Otte frequency- of crew- exposure to traffic. ;•,a'?.• '•. F• - .. l , 1. ! ' r I ' it '1'+ iii. .. ? r . , . . • ' ? 4' ' ? • t < ? r" - ? ,, r ? ? ? d . , . -i ' r"-. k.^'.T ? 'Fj, 'r '{ ? ' r' ..s.r. ? r r .. i i :} • ?' ?r'? ,.j:+. . ... _- ?__.. _`___-_ ?+. .. .. .?'.' . ? ? . ? 'Y.'t ?• - a .;?ra'I".', :?rrf r}?+':?^A Gai'.4i{."P'7t?5it 4 1 I J r r ) • •' i , ' • 1 • r r 1 : CITY OF CLEARWATER Interdeparlment Correspondence Sheet TO: Peter J. Yauch, Asst. Director/ Public Works/ City Trn i lgint r?l T; {r r! . dd?? ll?r L r !i J?$ rvi 'n' I+1EtUt?4: Miles G. Ballogg, Environmental Specialist Supesor JAN 25 1993 COPIES: William C. Baker, Director of Public Works . Tom- Miller, Asal. Director of PW/Environnictltal TnANS!'ORTATION Terry Iinch, Environmental Program Supervisor John E. Amiro, Signal Systems Engineer SUBJECT: Environmental Advantages of- Thernioplastic Material Al}ElliCatiOll Vs. Oil Based Paint for Traffic Marking DATE: January 22, 1993 The following are sonic of the environmental advantages that should be considered regarding.thc use of, Thermoplastic materials vs. oil based point: 1. Hitzat-dous Waste Reduction - Oil based pnints require the use of finsnrrluble solvente. The current use of these solvents creates hazardous waste. The Florida Department of Environmental Regulation has placed a great deal of emphasis on hazardous waste reduction. in recent months. Discontinuing the use of solvents in traffic marking operations would highlight ilia City's willingness to reduce its hazardous waste streams. 2. Cost Reduction for waste disposal of linzardons baste generrtted f:-om, trnlPic marldlig operntions - I'Ia7•nrdous waste is strictly regulated and the disposal of this wtlsto is very costly. Disposal of a 55 gallon drum of oil based paint waste ranges from $250 - $500. The costs for disposal are expected to be increased as regulations governing this waste are strengthened. The conversion of the current marking operations from oil based to thermoplastic would eliminate hazardous waste disposal fees from this process. 3. Minilni7•ed Regulated Status - Hazardous waste regulations govern the waste from cradle to grave which makes ilia generator of ilia waste responsible for the waste forever. The discontinued use of oil based traffic paint application would lower the rcguhr tcd sintus of ilia Traffic Clighiccring opcrations is 10 the Conditionally Exempt Small Quantity Generator status. The reduction to this status reduces the amount or regulations and reiluirenlents for (lie generators of the waste. This Status change will also reduce the amount of administrative man hours regarding waste management. 4. Elimination of I'Ir17•ardotls Waste Spills fr oin (rllfIlC 1111ti'lilllg npffntlOnS - T11C 11055ibillty of ' hazardous waste spills and clean up will be eliminitted through (lie discontinued use of oil based traffic marking operations. Hazardous Waste spills can result in costly clean tips, complex and costly liability Issues. 5. Elimination of envirounjentully dtini lging storniwnter runoff front trallle marking operatl6us - The elimination of oil based point application to streets will reduce'any inadvertent volatile-organic compounds into ilia storm system during marking opcrations. In conclusion, the use of ilia thermoplastic application is n much less a nvironnientally dwring'ing method of traffic marking than the'current application of oil based paint. If further information is required please contact me at 462-6383. thermogo.nigb i • .i' `'?'.C. ?'F?'`, v1. •{ j.M,•r.?:.??: t ,. ,. .. ir< 3' ? i.. r ,i,,"z,. .A: „e.":?.,••4q i7.{?y. 11' r I !' 'i`• '' , 4 i 1??, `i.. ??'?=?`1 ? y t `,S S}. ?. .? (,; .f'?f, .4 Y€'?. '?'.' f', '?;'_'?;'?j fix' ?M q?s ..,t• ,r. • . ? .. l f '. '•r } • ;`, .a??? i{ ?'?'{sr .1 'f. `7' •":-' ,- :y '? 'f ? .F I f c ? ?r ? ? e' '7? ?f'. i"'?+ ''-`?i,s`r ?hw?,R:?`? ;* ?ja'f,. ; . t o •,?,' i ? S F . _. f I ?1,';'g i I•l.`, f`..,, + '?? ' .1. a ? ..t} ?l ?,.7r.? k °' i ' rv .. ' • ' f , ' .. '-rT,1i ?l?:'1, -?? u` r•?`. ''r',•.?"}r ?'f `'r:{•,; a ? .. r.? ? =f''' .f ?'riE M.'4ia=?5• ytpp :?l'''i([,"R,.? .l•? ? ; i. t', t?'4?'f?• ' •?<ir' ?? '? ; , i y ? ? t r I , ? I ? r :, fF^' ;:. i. , , ., !i ass • 6lk.u?(=y. FEB-:02-1993 50 FROJ`J. CLEARWATER PURCHASI14G DIV' TO 6641 E?.09 ?,•tt / .CI,4i M W.O ..IMP. . jw c s u um uHrr. .?i mmw DXe 23=93 , MEM 12101192 ,• .. SID TM t PAVH 1tARR, CORP. EMIR DYt1AHXCS ING. •r . ". _ATL?I?ITA._Gfi0R0I11?? ?,A1t8IP 1;,,•,1?AEiRt s' ITFH ME . trv,`,.1 OPTION #I ;; r•r 1, THMIOPLASTIO STRIPING UNIT 153,766.00 167,000.00 y'T'°,' ?. ' rrrr rrrrrrrrrrr. "'.4' NO WWI IN )w.r..rrr ? . . 1eA38 ul vALU1i . 101500.00, 6,000.00 ' z t... IA. Ta RMPLASTM STRIPING UNIT' 143,204.00 161,000.00 ir; MTH TR"R, IN r.•w ww....w wwr wrw..w r.w rrwr S'; DELIVERYc 150 DAYS 210 DAYS : . TMis HET 30 HET 30 s GUM" OA A7AS ' BIDS BOLICI77D1 18 '. • - 11ID8 lt$CSI9xDc ? ? ? ? m .?i .. ? NO RSSPOhSNe L ? ? i?. 7 110-DID RHOPONGS2 8 SDZHd11,Y 07 NO AID M1'O sys DO NOT OIPIM, BRRVICEs b U110E8 TO MIST SPHOMUT101102 2 ' TOTAL; P. 01' f<4?.?1?`•.??]': iS.?'?a:; :?.,'?'?t,;: :.r rl. _ .". ,?,t. ? ? J .t,. ? •,!' ?.!'r t .?i ri_?. -r ,..• -.?r,; •r< ?+1 y r:R,. F'•{ 'y, 4. .•}; wr:? t' .L ,. '?•J ! f i',? •? _?' ?i?l?'?y..? ?.3,s''th•_..? r?c? };?qY yISS'ti 1'0. 1, ° t,.t' ` '• F,... i f. 1 < •7 F ' t ='`? }{' i ''`• .. , + •.4,°, ?' y,?? ?.r??t ?':•;. •1 .I.. ?s',t , . '? i1{ •?d t`?tre ? '1. ? , ., , t ', ,.i'. .'?.'? :`';>=,r?P ?.: "?{1.r :3,?'°?•' `t •.il `,?,ia r;y j. 7,: ',F,``` t2s'.•I?,ly?li'?r r,.v,.' S y ?r• {- ,. ? ?.•I. ,, ,i. '?II)y}T? •rt'. .°?,. ? !1, .l?1, ?.r',!'• t I e .. r 'f?'YK., ??'• Sd , F 't , ill ?{'`? ?`, ?'i"?:: 'j F, ?yeR'. - 3'?+ ?(i > ' : I '. df ;`_C11t Y1`. [?? E.d ^ FF' r' ' 1•' ^{ '.'}: J. ''1'„ t" a rfc 'i .1 .. ",r. ?. 7i'.ery Ai, t° ?` < ` , ,.F.. ti2,' '''s?i.? ? r?`•-s;s ?l?', i?. ?'?t?i ' ,rat, 1?,? ` ?f, ,!•a y' y : _ !? ' I ? i ? ? 1 - .h?. r. 7F.: '€•?` . ??#, a ,, i ?1 ?• . ? ?; ` ^ s ,b, },i T,l'I;•+ e +ti 3" ? r;:? I•, .. i , y . ?r , • , r •' it I .. r r , , 'f„ t'ar. CII'Y OF tLCARWA'I'E12' Interdepartmental Correspomlen66 Sheet, TO to Dan Long, Assistant Fleet-Administrator Ka. ?: .. .. ? f Eft Peter J Yaual3, Assist. PW Director .& city Traffic Engineer :'COPIES- SUBJECT: Accept Low Bid -- Pave ,Mark Corp. _ . • 3 .. - - ' =fir DATE: December 16, 1992 Upon'' 'evaluation of the.. bids ' for a Thermoplastic , striping unit', our, recommendation is to accept the 'low bid'' by. Pave Mark Corp. v requirements-of. the PW/Transportation Pave Mark Corp meets the Group u.s fT. k .z. pJY/JhA/sn' fly', '?" r• ,, ," ? , .•`'? 5 r° t 'f , 'il' ^n.` r ,F ;, ; I 1 .i . .. . 'r rR ,(i• '5?° ' 43 ;!.4•,?;,?'?ff e.•A kit, tv7fir`' nl.b?.s . i CITY OF CLEARWATER Interdepartmenfid 'Correspondence Shat TO: Cynthia Goudeau, City Clerk FROM: Pete Yauch, City Traffic Engineer COPIES; William Baker, Director of Public Works SUBJECT; Agenda Item - Purchase of Thermoplastic Striping Unit - 3/18/93 Meeting DATE:. March 10, 1993 Margaret Simmons, Assistant Finance Director, has requested that I provide additional information on the budgeting for this *proposed• purchase. The replacement of our pavement marking truck with a thermoplastic striping unit was budgeted by Motor Pool, at an amount of $ 60,000, during Fiscal' Year 1991-92. As we prepared the specifications for the thermoplastic striping unit, we found several assumptions that we wanted to reconsider. ' Tile original estimate was for 'a portable, trailer mounted thermoplastic kettle, capable of holding 2,000 , pounds of one color 'of thermoplastic, and a portable, lightweight striping unit. The melted, thermoplastic is transferred to the striping unit, which then applies the one color. The ' estimate did not include a tow vehicle. The truck specified in this bid is for a truck mounted, self-contained striping unit with two kettles, one for each pavement marking color (white and yellow), ' The advantages of the self-contained unit are as follows: ' i o By having two kettles on a self contained unit, neither the kettle nor the striper needs to be cleaned when changing colors. The melted thermoplastic can cool in place, then be reheated for the next striping operation, o The self-contained unit includes the ability to spray the thermoplastic material at a thinner application rate than the extruded ribbon guns on the portable unit. This allows the "refreshing" of pavement markings with a significant savings in materials used: , ' . 1 a The small size of the portable unit requires a chase vehicle to provide protection for the equipment operator. The specified vehicle provides its own' protection for the operator, including the placement of a flashing arrow panel on'the truck itself. We feel that these advantages are worth the extra expense'of the self-contained unit. In addition, Motor Pool, when reviewing our specifications, added requirements for a heavy duty engine, transmission, and suspension, which increased the cost 'but will provide for improved maintainability during (lie life of the vehicle. We believe that-the proposed vehicle provides the same operational capabilities as the paint truck ' being replaced, while providing the advantages of thermoplastic striping material. f?•'4 + ? ? •I9 s Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum F it Da • ' 03/18/93 _ iUBJECT: BEACH TO DOWNTOWN TROLLEY SERVICE FUNDING RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve a mid-year General Fund Budget amendment to appropriate $32,100,from the Unreserved, Undesignated Fund Balance of the General Fund to provide funding for the three month continuation of the beach- to-downtown trolley service, ® and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND : On'March 4, 1993, the Commission approved the three month continuation of the beach--to-downtown trolley service, and directed staff to propose alternative .funding resources. Staff will be discussing funding with the Downtown Development Board at their .March 29 meeting, and is researching possible use of Community Redevelopment Agency funds to offset the expense. ' In the interim, it is recommended that temporary funding be provided from the , Unreserved, Undesignated Fund Balance of the General Fund. Reviewed by: i Legal Originating Dept: City Manager' Costs: S 32,100 Total _Ca fission Action-. roved A pp Budget A Purchasing s 32 100 3 Approved w/conditions Risk Hgmt.' N/A User Dept: , Current Fiscal Yr. 13 Denied C1S 13 Continued to: ACM --?- Funding Source: Other ? Capital Imp. Advertised: 0 operating Attachments-. Date: ? Other Paper: ® ® !l Not Required one 5uhsi cd Affected Parties FA Appropriation Code: Notified 410-07000.530300-554 Cit He er 13 Not Required • , f.4! 1 r , . i ¦ i ''REVISED Item 10 `?•' ' ' Ctelater city Co7i]3A1SS1UA Meeting Date: 3.18-9'S AgeCover Memorandum Q PLb q SUBJECT: Preliminary Subdivision Plat for Kings Highway Subdivision; 2052 Kings Highway; John G. Woodland, Donald E. Scholl, Eugene P. Austin, Robert H. Dillinger, Robert J. Nealy, A.H.W., Dennis A: Fitzgerald, Roy Clinton Pittman,.Edward E. Golden, Donald Nikolaus (Owners); Thomas M. Hejl, Sr. (Representative) (SUB 93-01) RECOMMENDATIONNOTI ON: Authorize the Development Review Committee to review-the preliminary plat for property identified as Kings Highway Condominium 89-102,, and return the preliminary plat to the City Commission for final approval. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: The applicant proposes to subdivide an existing four building, 28 unit condominium development known as Kings Highway Condominiums to a fee simple townhouse subdivision. This item will return to the City Commission after the following issues have been addressed and resolved: 1) Existing drainage conditions are modified. 2) Locations of both public and private utilities in accordance with city building code. 3) Establishment of homeowners association and applicable deed restriction documentation. 4) The submission of an overlay of the proposed plat with the as-built conditions. 5) Number and location of handicap parking locations. 'The separation walls between each unit must be reconstructed to meet the requirements of the Building Code, Section 403.5 (attached), Generally the requirement is a two hour fire resistance rating, from the top of the foundation to the underside of the roof sheathing. 11111 : Reviewed by: Legal NZA Originating Dept: Planning 8 Dset?? Colts: NIA Tot l Com fuion Action: a Approved Budget N/A_ ? Purchasing N/A Approved w/conditions Risk Mgmt. N/A User Dept: S Current Fiscal yr. ? Denied cis N/A _? 13 Continued to: ACM j R tcz)cz I Funding Source: Other _ _ ? Capital imp , ,Advertised: ? operating Attachments: Date: ? Other Application Paper: ® Preliminary Plat Not Required Map S nittsd by: • Affected Parties riation Code: pro A Building Code Section 403.5 13 j `x?G 1 W? ? Notified p . p None V City Manager ® Not Required 0 Printed on recycled paper " ,s 1 I 1 CITY OF CLEARWATER - Department of Planning & Development , City Hall Annex, 10 So. Missouri Ave., P.O. Box 4748 Clearwater, FL 34618-4748 Telephone: (813) 462-6880 (Fax 462-6641) AMJQA]]QN 1 1 11EVIE111/ Applicant (Owner of Recordl:see attached list of property ownedone: f 1 Address: City: State: Zip: Representative: Thomas M. i-le -i 1 Sr. Telephone:_( 1934-1446 Address:3600 Keystone Road City: Tarpon Sprin sistate: )~1• zip: 34689 Preparer of P1at:Gerald P. Goulish_ Eng., Inc. Professional Title: Address: P.O. Box 942 City: Tarpon Spring%tate: 1:'1. Zip: 34688-0942 'Telephone:(813 11938-9a32 Title of Proposed Subdivision Plat: KINGS HIGHWAY SUBDIVISION 29/15/03/46789/001/ 001.0 to 0070 &29/15/03/46789/003/0150 to 0210 Parcel Number: ,_29 115 / 03/ 46789 / X21 noFin_ to 0140, & 004/0220 to 0280 General Location of Property: Kings Highway & Arbelia Street Zoning: RM 28 Land Use Plan Classification: iii h Density ResidentiAl Existing Use of Property: Condominium Proposed Use of Property: attached units r City Ordinances No. 3128-83 and No. 3129-83 require a parks and recreation impact fee to be paid for all nonresidential projects over 1 acre In size and all residential developments. Has this property complied with these ordinances? If yes, explain how and when: N/A Assessed just value of property (attach verification): S 12 . 800 / uni t * 2 8 _ uni t s $9 18 , 0 00 . 0 0_ _ Most recent sales price (attach verification): $ 4 9 , 0 00/ uni t= I , 37 2 , O OA of (date): 06/1986 Fee for Subdivision Plat Review: check # 1125 for $1,730.00 attached 1. Base charge for each preliminary subdivision plat ................................ $890 plus tat For each lot included on the plat ..........................................$30 per lot 2. Revalidation of a certified preliminary subdivision plat ......................... . ... $55 3, Subdivision plat amendment (after certification, prior to recording) ..................... $55 4. Administrative lot division ................................................ $150 Any request fora variance from ft regulations set forth in Chapter 133 shall be submitted in writing to the Planning & Development s Department concurrently with the preliminary plat. Such written request shall state fully the grounds for the variance request and all facts relied upon by the petitioner. The applicant, by filing this application agrees he/she will comply with Chapter 133, the Subdivision and Condominium Platting Regulations, of the City's Land Development Code. Signature-,-??f t 7- (Owner of Recardl `if the application is'signed by an individual outer than the property owner (e.g. the representative), please attach a statement signed by the property owner authorizing this individual to sign the application. REV, 2/92 ;r f ,. .tf? ,1lrr 9. ~ ' ? , .. S' ?• 16,.f, iJ . .?•El,•,?11•,: ,??.;. '?1 •'?ry1. ?. k? f " 'R?;lar ? F t'?t f 1 I ? J ' 4p ? r .? , i .. •ly y ?.,? ? 1.:;., 1 t: 7 'Y ' 1 i 7, (4 r ? , ' ' , ° t } ? ,.?' !? / C a ,l ! , ? ?;. {)7,. S' I`r 1 ? ' •!j? , 1 :?a,! •'. ; ?rl e''?7 ?`r .t ? .?",ir''L''.q 1' ' E ? r .P ;F ` E ? r ? ', t' =.( 1 t '.yr.., t. ?..- 4. t1. 1. ',•yt°?. is ,:; i ! 4 ' F ., l.r 'llf3'. 1 r `?'• ,. ,•rl I 'F f . ? Y'i? '?'j ) ?, . . . , ? i 'rlYrr. , : . v ? ` II-- \.aF a r?''1{. .1,E ; f•?.M1. 7 ? ` ? li". t{f'?' t ? ,??,' v 1 M1 t' Y 1 r '/.. ? .. ?'?f' V., . t :'?' t'. . = %1 +? PROPERTY OWNERS' JOHN. G. WOODLAND 733--1552 Units 6 & 25 " .1150 Fairway Drive Dunedin, Fl.' 34698-2107 DONALD E. SCHOLL 937-3111 Units 22,, .23'&'24 ' 620.'E. Tarpon Avenue Tarpon Springs, Fl. 34689, EUGENE P. AUSTIN 93730101 Units 2, .3, 4 & 5 ' 1.410. State Road 595 , ` Holiday, Fl. 34,90 ROBERT ,H. DILLINGER 343-0132'' Unit 1 64.50' 1st. Avenue,North St. Petersburg, Fl, 33710. R06ERT J. NEALY -. 539--3616 (404) Units 26, 27. &..28 ' 420 Broad 'Street ` 'Gainsville, Ga. 30505 ' A.H.W. 584-1199' Units 7," 8, 13 & 14 655 Ulmerton Road.E. `. suite, •?2 ? . - ? '`;. ; Largo, Fl. 34641.' DENNIS A.-FITZGERALD 937-5285 Units -9 &-19 4938 Moore Street ..Tarpon-Springs,, Fl. 34 689 ..' °- ROY CLINTON PITTMAN 934-6799 Units 15,• 16, 17, & 18. 1097 Oakdale-Road N.E. Atlanta, Ga. 30307 EDWARD E. GOLDEN ' •' 733--7848 Unit 20 923 Broadway Dunedin, Fl, 34698 DONALD NIKOLAUS 734--6286 ' Units 10, -11, 12 &'.21 833 Milwaukee Dunedin, Fl. 34698 ' Kings Highway Apartments , 2052 'Kings, Highway J ' Clearwater, Fl. , 34615 !'. ? !t.,r ' ' 1 r 1 ! • I , 1 ?, ? . " ' 1 s' . ? , 1 j. }. .4 1. 7.? ? . ?? ' ' +' 2 ?y?% ? '1• , Z , ' f ? ••1" r It , ,'1 •/ . `f•1 ?:. -T f ? :li'?1`?••,???I `•?.5?•fl? '?'• •'??S l ? t 1, ..f.?' ., ?1 "? I.. t?.l. Y. NI . 11" r• 7.1 M?N.I?.i.Y u...tr?'M ? / ? ? MaN 1+Ar11 ?S'? C I I M. . 1 2? 3 4' ,5 '8', j' $} w r?4 '••?f:ti 'Y'r ? N 66 209 67 1 } ti 06 c AR 65 CONDOS.1:64 1•.1 .'' AA I 132: 1 3 2009 1.?ti ; 62 - --. ' .2063 All - • S9 20 t 131 1 4 !, rf 1 ? ' • 130 1 35 2067 __6 206 Q 1 0 206f !,a rfl`y' 129 6 11 L 128 7 2046 T e E? 1 t 127 2035 " 62058 ?•. ' '.?+ 2 ' ? 1 ; i 12fi W z056 t . : 125 9 2829 0 75 ' 124 2023 ;t '1+ ,i ' ' zaf7 141 2016 117•::;k 76 123 142 11$} 37 X ' y' o ;?Y?ksry • ??? 78 ! I r r CLi,C`IDQ21 a iris ih t 3 ' ? Paso ?9 20711 Y07161, ' `' 2R7R Pns ... J, :1 039 208 VAC AT Ea' 0271•.: a-. 2ofe t 2', r' + 0is•'•" 3' £0YR 10 N fs.' ' 11 0f 2011 + 'j c ,20 12 ' zovy B +? .1 ' 7 R0s ? '14 20041 I.S.101 ' 1 'r ' "" WOOD `` '' I ALPINE sa µN' I' a i.»IERRACE,'. I ?'' / ? ? ? ° ?" r' ROAD '"• ? ?? ' ' 1. ?Z . " 24 23 22 21 20 ,19 '18 f M .%,' ,• '. ?•. 16 ' + ' 17 3 •rw•'1 w -y' ! ?,•A w 5 7 S 1 1 `? 4 A,1.3 r Ili 02 sn 17 i 9 10 11 12 •10 3 'L 9 ;. 4 ti - ' t. ?? ,j t = ? y? ' Ti,Mn . S • S , . I S p "i i .'r . 'y' li 4 ". ?!' t ' ? ? i ? , w ryr' T, i ?y 3 r :r { ?1?; Fs(?ti Is::il s:1,+?A ?f'E i1 ,,l'•?? ,?, ,! ,' .I ! , r• i, i , t' slf? . ?. • I 6'??'' 1`•. r ?r py I t r :.?? ._ ?._???;.....-i ;''7.,i "-? r r.« »ti? • 1 :i . 't."• !u s , :I 'i !<r.,1 rj ',t ? W t:' .,1 ?]f' . +• ( ? Y v+? + ,{,', '• , M } I' r? j!' 1 ?' a. ?., ? 1' , '??'i : ,b; ?, •?y?l???'?r , -{' r ?•. t Y:'?a• ??,?y ? ..rd , ? i?r 1n1!f?ll.? s0 ?,, ???; ?i i '? 1? • ,:u,??n3??3:?'?!? . !!? :?r' •;P: I; q fc,?'??x.f.'??' } i .1 'St? r:? ? ????3 I JY,- i ?y+?!t . fi`?` ? I`LL ?' f ? ?C' 1 Y 1 ? ,? ` ? 1 ?•,? , ( „{?•?; ..}. !"' 1'?' i,c5' ?i '?n'{ ?{ y'?'.}1 } r I }rl?.{ { fit{ S ?r.l fG? ,?•F. 7 1 ! .vi ? r'-ii ? 41U? ' ? F',1 I? '` 4 'pi;i 'Z' +t :it i?' ''r?;? t?' ,t ' t:{ v •!. r, •' Fj? ???' ?'S, r; ?iµ??{?'1 :?', r 1 ? t ' !.J P1 Ll??'? ? -] I :1= i:' I ? '4 ? ?• :.: , ?, '? ?rZr !?f.r.:r r!,t? .??? ?. ?? .:??.. ; ,, ? , NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING ' AND REVIEW OF MASTER SITE PLAN /SUB PLAT OWNER Z APPLICANT PROPERTY DESCRIPTION ZONING FROM TO ACRES PLANNING and ZONING BOARD CITY COMMISSION BECTION TOWNSHIP 22 - S RANGE 1E ATLAS PAGE ZS? •? Single Famlly , •: 4 r N p ?, ; 4.0 zl • fi • 3 m 1 Fa 1 II' . F h >; I 4 I ti' - ' flHll ll•PIIIIIIfHIIINIIItllllllll ?y I.y .?.,.•VI f/JI ' , 1 •?• y 4••I` IM IM L , `?. ?y u V ?r tz M wl 'V I IB G •U 0 0 0 O O .?l C3 if ? .0 -0 0 0 V 4) 'n 'A gr .5 A 41 0 cl C, = '° w ° o C U d o 006 43 .` ? a 0 'v v d cb I.. u o u u en O 0°° 4p, ° O w I? C7 •o [i. 8 O '«? U ~ pp '? ?+ u V •? u O C Q pp? p u b y? y u ;tv b cd '?G •cti 4.. y, C7 :b 0 0 0 ° Sa '« ° ° 'C 0 tot 4° '0 0 DO '? '? ti u ' 0 , • Q 0 u .u. O O l e V R A ?t ?n .C N a O O o.'o u? z 'wco4rr?F?l?' " ° o tS C dp td ' C O A 0' T 9 c~a O 5? uu' , o t o u w u c? u,0 ro Qo c•a-0 9 o 75 w ° 41 3 0 u? ,-a 'v w e O ° .G CD. p u O Q «. [? vi ' 51 A u O QO RI jS E! Lo, c. 0 r_ ?, ' ?t ?+ Llb •a .O yw w O '? b 4i Q• 0 Gr - .., w ed ?? i2 o es O «..° 0 •8 O V, in u y cs 'v Q :3 r U7 S z 'A ?; 4u boo ° a.. -Aw- tw 00 C? co '$u ...o .0 q .c o U L7 a. , L uo .0 U J7 C1• • L: U r?+ ' is w .° en •8 °?-?.c °u ow o ,;oHF. ry o?' ao Q..O CT 0 O G Ai W) O u ,., cv ?; 6• 'd r r r O O r ? ? (Rt 0 0, 0'0 ? o f •a 't7 a. ?i u Q Q A C7 a. 1 ' i II . • • ? e ?j l. t r l k. • . e . t . I a j : "", 1y?'q•'y5., .sib.€ti.s!;:."w.,:lfy ..-?.i},_.. I.. .+?:: r• ?a+" 'i-°::.'li '! •Y• .{• :r > :1 t:1^•:> ;s a,e'.7"<-1.,..y•j 11 ,•r, fn ai .71 • y; e ,r;:',.4°r.1 „-h[, '1' ,'»t iPw'?r :ur 'I(1?53 'a%' S .Ar• "e' '?, f• _ ,'sSd' F jlj}:•.: , ,,..F• 7rfr+ ?, • ,+ ,,, -1. t('".'.' ,r. . ,,; {:P `?44 <° , -CI- i'e ,f. r , ?,E ^r•. fr•• ?I` ?z# •L!. ?w ;y, .,? tllr ?r _!rR a?.,- !; r 1 j;' :r r ..?Pn' t? rFn? .;;# L1}..,'a.;;' ^ rs?'rf:`'1 i,rrl i• ? ,er.r . j.' . ' a '`t' ,, I+. ar'E ;'{. p` I,' _ r. •, o ,. - ., ' . } •-.l .i',.: . drR ^4'?M .1 • .?- ••?; >•r?r+".l'1 Y' ,I r'r".' F` ' I. 1' ! i° 1 t , .'.J 'I 'L;'?{t.. ry1 ,1, ?,,14.'.`.. J. ?' e . ! ,:J`• ! .•4' ,. 1,,, ,r r ,r'. ; S.; F; l ,1, r` ,4? , : I ? r 1' F, Mire ,-..'% :: t? .,r .f',•, r• :r.',: ,.?` ' •! .'1 •• ''r.i `r :x,11 ,y VA,,r ?r ,,t, I. I?. rvt• -?' fl. 'g;yr.. `.t ?', _ - ., •3 f. ,., Paf `M. .? '_' ? rt,, , . 'l i 1 :!_ P. `'•,r - 0 .t. . :})'i,r rl;'?r" ' '!f•,?•..'S`* , , . , II =' ,`rd ??, ' -lf ".!'_.R,IF, . 4 s'r ?}," •F ?.? J'#I",. r.,+':+:`1Y' ,I .. I eat' `+' „ .t r ,,C ,E I.S`. :j5 r?tr - r? ,t, .j. G-, ?.{,IF d {' : ) ', ?I,r:AA ?x.z rr?,I'1:,:,•of f: r, t r '?. . I• i , y,,-,``j ', ? -[}'?",.' v!< ?!-'i: `f e "t s.9?T•l `''')'.heft. °!' :,,;j, ,t „ •+•'Er. i- ",,,; tl" ,f f, , ?',? F. ¢ .L`' .g ", :13r` +i'.-. Y?,l 1%!', ]1 .'?, •)-. A' .i f '^{ `'rr :l',f:a tea, 4,r ; ir! ,Y'FF?... ,? ,`.e T %,U: i}j 'f, , , , ,'i .;r i . ,:aa: r'` ,F+i?:4z.• ,s ' .?u {.'-x• :?p;t ,[? {' •'<:.i I;1 3 ,If :s' .f?. .`•L - •'fr` %I'I '?' sI r•, .g'•':• rf, , ,,`Y .`,+ ' ,1' ,'a'. ,.r,`ci.•,; ?.? i' 7 t 4' '7 1 }ti r' .?, ?T F r .J: :'' :< ',#, i. . }f,' ?:51 '.'S' it li, '4•.- _ ?? }:', .!. ,P'. r., .J';` .?r.f is '?5>t, 1 , :+ Bri :f'` :rI#+y'r:r .?'?, nt ,z{• r ,ei•°,i, i v.] +L- rf. j ., x',? ' ' U,1%?n ,i? . - ?p :,tt4, -.! :f 1. ' 'I 't;'l.r's 1r , r'u,'i t " .{r / i ;t, r', F' LL,'.: 4:. ,hf ^' ei "f!. ",?.'. V}n . Pier`;. ,'' - 'FP.'. 1' dk '}l, .F'. 5•n.!',t, 5.r C, fi. c'1- v`?I 1?i, •_"• ?, .?,? f.r,..,t r, ) ,e' » i t., R .s.. t' :t ?..• E :? '!'' ' r c'. r 'R a., r ;[y 4°. .a v t• ,>- •r'tI ! `'1 '[,'a ?l .. .z?i' :'y.` ?n.,gg S„ _; ,? :.I"O, .zYA* 'f"' a ,tr x 'y r-` ,'.i; °'+ 5' ,'f, ':. 'I i. I A?. X •.j ; ... i j<<- z t ' ' i , r ' . r, '., fr • r_ ` rt'' „` V. .r`;r$,I , .7y,, '°i, 'y?. i i Ir: 'I,r .pr!R:a ! . r . _ :f' ' 1 i'sr:'' `. A. w: ly,Z,7; ir.lp[ fr,r '`+ -:, ''21 r.ltft?, c i F , ,d? 4. / 'Eh d"e i. ,l,., i?? f:d!t . ' :7e{f-S. '-`A ,??,}.. Ir#• M1-/,i (>y •1 •''.: ,,C.r .,, t[ d.. !r %r. "•3,I. :,y'. .;• 'r1'J[rt:l •, .4 f ) .? 'rti jS. ,•J `,-.,4,:,, 4`: ?. ?V' , ?? W..'', ,1 r 1'r jl' R, ' i 'v ..s;„'u1"F#J, i..,'?;r' ar3;Y,?4re;7+;i C } ?' y'rI „ , . i:, tF: yyAY,tr 11fie ??ff i. F, .?Y":ill .r t "7 #',' .•l' C ,?;,v,lie Jl kl a ?? , ,, _t-fW +I . 'a. ,4. 1-i,4„ ;S. 9iF ?. ,. :! 1#T.. _, !}" '> ryi'. .?, ?,. ;,. r - r a• ? t .r C9. . r. I • `k'#' . ...7 °'. , , 's!, , . :. s ,,. %t, .. .,#h. , S , ,. .i.., . .I,. ...,.'.. ,ii. 'i ?- 1:.. 1 , r , , l ' , ' 'I , : f ? I . " , , . . I . . ? .? ?, I I , , I . .,` , . , . , ? . I ? . . , , , w ? . , I., . - . .. ?, , , , : , .l.."', 1. . I ?: ? n . " r "It i,,:r a !' ,.,,-, -.?. ? . 1. I. - - - ". . .t ,?, ? -, - . 11 . I L le ? , , I ? S,,?,.,. ,,-,. . ? L I el , ; - L C? I , llll? , , n, ? , , - ,-- - - . I - ? 8 blLl? , 1!3 ? .. I ? , T`?E"l l . ' F ''1 'It" , ? I . . ? I . I , 10 . . . , . ?. . , ",_ - , . - .? ?. ? .. ? , "., , :. , "., . I .. . . ., , 2 . I ? .; . ? I , lj.? , ,". - I - . , , 41 '. •f?. I , 1 . k,I,l,, ,.f' .1 . jf "'.. .I r, 4, r 1 . „ J , , ,, 11 . .r k? E 5't? ?`fr d 1 :f . L, ,?? -::'.L.t ?f' :Yrj. _. 1 t.: r r l "?: -,;,t tsf: ?f .''f: . r , '}I` '.Y '.1,; r' .?.' '.t: '.,,'3 .,l:..e' ,j4-,." I,Z J „ + r ' . r -. I P a ' „ 't x r?` ?i, tiL tif, '?• ,3• , '! } ' r ' - .11 I I •I I RI ,1A .Y ISFlr 1. 'I '.i 'r rr ,. 1 - , ,(-' ,Fke `d, S, r F , IF %}• • ' !• i - s .?. 'r ,? . . ,bra I, : 13,^, f _ . r F ' I, ' a , . , ! t , , . +1 %,- r', t :?.. A: I. .. .. - - I r . . .. ',?'.i 'x{{.,,Ir,, , i s ',,: + , - r • , , ` , ,-' - ?,. ts" r i. I• '? . r , . : 1 . ; r , . I t r' r _ ' ,'? F,_ . .t. r- ,E Iris „,i ? , , r , , : , ' .. : .,5: ,"'IY., 'r r i - .i. ,t. > I ,,? ' R.; , , '1' $', ,IF ?t, - '?' i° E' , , , A ', . , 3... {f Vii, s r y . r {.• p L s:. CIE ?, .i)f.- .Ij ,5 . , I, r i I ' • ..' «. 1, .. , ¢r,,; l 11. , ,?: lt' , , . 1 - , t f/•??? 1. .' .? "i. - s, f `i:"s c.•.E. L 4. ri:`AI -t: Pr r,1,, .a. ,wn% 'IwA,tT+rt.. ,w,:+-- ., wrrwr?w?N.?r1?w+%r,y i .1 f Clearwater City Commission Qnq?: 03/18/93 Agenda Cover Memorandum i CONSENT SUBJECT: Petition for Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment, and Zoning Atlas Amendment for 714 & 716 Bayview Avenue; Owners: Jacklyn & Jerold Logemann and Michael Parker; Approximately 0.60 acres. (A 93-01 & 04 and LUP 93-03 & 07) RECOMM EN DATIONN OTION : Receive the Petitions for Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential, and Zoning Atlas Amendment to RS-6 for a part of Sec. 16-29-16, M&Bs 32103 & 32104, and refer the request to the City Clerk to be advertised for public hearing. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. ? I IYII I11 I I YYYYIUYYY?I IYilYlYpn'4?Y?? }fYYI/Y?Y BACKGROUND: .The applicants wish to annex in order to obtain City sewer service. The two applications are for adjacent properties on the west side of Bayview Ave. approximately 1,050 ft. south of Gulf to Bay. ,At 714 Bayview Avenue, the owners are constructing a new single family residence under a County building permit. 7'16 Bayview Avenue is an existing single family residence. 714 Bayview Avenue-is contiguous to the City along its north side, and adjacent to 716 Bayview Avenue along its south side. Together, both properties are contiguous to the City. To the west of the two properties is Tampa Bay. The property to the north is occupied by Our Lady's House of Prayer and has a Future Land Use Classification and zoning of Public/Semi-Public. The properties to the east of 714 Bayview Avenue are in the City and have a Future Land Use Classification of Low Density Residential and zoning of RS-4. The property to the east and south of 716 Bayview Avenue are in the County and have a County Future Land Use Classification of Residential Low (5.0 u.p.a. max.) and a zoning of R-4 (7,500 ft. min.) as do the two properties requesting annexation. The applicant/owner of 716 Bayview Avenue also owns the lot directly to the south, but has stated that he does not wish to annex this parcel at this time. The area of 716 Bayview Avenue is less than the minimum lot area for an RS-4 lot (10,000 sq. ft.). It is proposed to assign the properties a zoning of RS-6, the same as the single family residential properties just to the . north along Bayview Ave. Reviewed by: Legal N/A Originating Dept: PLANNING & OESLOPMEN Costs: S NIA T t l ?- Commission Action: - o a Approved Budget N/A Purchasing N/A Approved w/conditions Risk Mgmt. N/A -' User Dept: S Current Fiscal Yr. © Denied cis N/A © Continued to: ACM Funding Source: Other N/A 13 capital imp . Advertised: 13 Operating Attachments: Date: O Other PETITION Paper: MAP ® Not Required Submitted by: Affected Parties i 13 None D Notified App roprietion Code: nager ® Not Required 0 Printed an recycled paper i. 1 1 4 rt,. ` , ' E .? ter: S' a PETITION FOA ANNEXATION s city commission ,City of Clearwater P.O.• Rox 4740 claarwitter, Florida Commissioners: j ' we, the undersigned, being 'n11 owners of the described real property, contiguous to the present bollndnr. ire or'the Clty of Clearwater,. atld situated In an unincorporated nren of rinallns county, Floridn, do hereby. request that Bald property be nnnexed into the corporate limits of the city of Clearwater, •rlorida. We hereby rurther request that said property be rolled and classified I under the Zoning ordinance of the city of Clearwater, no net forth on the' following page. Attached Hereto is'n current murvoy of the described property, (if j it is" unplatted), together. with a cortificnte of title from a title i, company, a copy of the deed'or a letter from n licnnsed attorney getting '• forth the names of all parsons, firms or corpornt.lona owning nny interest ' .`' in the'described property. The undersigned have been advised of, Understnnd and in consideration of annexation,. utility services, and other good rind valuable consideration, do-hereby agree'nnd covenant as follows:'' 1. all structures and improvements which are erected upon said property aubsoquent to the date or tills petition for nnnexation . shall comply with all applicable City of Clearwater regulations and ordinances as set forth in the city Code of ordinances; 2. to convey such recreation land, recreation facilities and open or fee:a in the amount and manner space land dedication and/ , prescribed by Division 2 and 3, Chapter 116, Article' IV of the -Clearwater code of ordinances; gild I 3. when any substandard abutting street or utilities are subsequently upgraded by the city td meet city Standard=s, said improvement will be done on an assassment basis, consistent with City procedures theref=ore. We, the 'undersigned hereby certify that we nave read and examined all.of the statements And allegations in the foregoing Petition including attachments and after being duly sworn, deposed and any that such statements are correct, complete and true and voluntarily made with full knowledge thereof. rC asp - 3G - ,va - 7si -a lc 7,7 25 ' t 7 57fi' V :5 ?31 ,0.. - 0 30 7 - - 4?- S'TA'TE OF FLORIDA COU11TX OF 01HELLAS ) Subs ribed cZnd 6wot.-h' to before me this 1? clay of 199. r/ My Commission Expiros: NOTARY PU tr)i:. STATC OF FLQRMA, Nr GOId1JISR N EXPIRES: Fra it 1901 E . , , . , sONOip,Hiiu.IDTAnT PuatlG U.fPtRWpilfiile. 11a 44(L ?'• -- ` I 'ak V t '.? . F1 • e ' r s;..,>.. •a• .. r . ., .•. rf `c ;'•:, .?r: •r:'' sty},• ;.?-::'?. . f ••fy. PETITION FOR ANNEXATION City•Commisaion` +City of Clearwater- P.O. Box 4748 Clearwater, Florida , Commissioners: ?. we, the undersigned, being. all owners of the described real property, contiguo+ts to the present boundaries of the City of Clearwater, and situated in an unincorporated area of Pinellas County, Florida, do hereby request that said property be annexec; into the corporate limits of -tile City of-Clearwater, Florida. We hereby further request tlsnt said property be zoned and classified under. the Zoning ordinance of the City of Clearwater, as sot forth on the following page. Attached hereto is a current survey of the described property, (if' it, is unplatted), together with a certificate of title ,from 'a title company, a copy of the,deed or a letter from a licensed attorney setting forth the names of all persons, firms or corporations owning any interest in the described property. The undersigned have been advised of, understand and in consideration of annexation, utility services, and, other good and valuable consideration, do hereby agree and covenant as follows:- 1. all structures and impzovemenL•s which are erected upon, said property subsequent to the date of this petition for annexation shall comply with all applicable City of Clearwater regulations and ordinances as set forth in the City Code of Ordinances; 2. to convey such recreation land, recreation facilities and open space land dedication and/or' fees' in the amount and manner prescribed by Division 2 and 7, Chapter 116, Article IV of the Clearwater Code of Ordinances; and 3. when any substandard abutting street or utilities are subsequently upgraded by the city to meet City" Standards, said t improvementrwill'be done on an assessment basis, consistent ' with city procedures therefore. We, the undersigned hereby certify that we have read and examined all of the statements and allegations in the foregoing Petition including attachments and after being duly sworn, deposed and say that such statements are correct, complete and true and voluntarily made with full ' knowledge thereof. STATE OF- FLORIDA COUNTY OF PI14ELLAS Subscribed and' sworn to be Core me this day of , 199 3. F1, U.L. #P626-542»44••414_0 exJ?trr,S 1954. My Commission Expires: ' NOYAIIY runLIC SZAlE of rLON104. MY COMMIU91071 W INCS: FL13, Al. 1004. ¦ONGin 11INU MOTA,.r !U•UC VNUC($w M)itflg. ? .aJ rtJ Notary )r . 1 r N SIR 6: .,ULF 70 BAY %B AYV1 E'Wca 3{0 bOq TOWN AA TRACT A r ? 3 7' St6 r t< ?g 10 T R AI L? 37 _ PARK 3 b s ,. be BAY " 605 VIE; 60 -H6 '23" .A 601 LA 27 J ° `? 1 r`. rr. •? ,;r• .r' .JG/U? ?+rI , . d •? tr`??ll,•, •' a? y,,.,?'•.5='. 1. ,.-r:%''•; '•.'r '' 29 . 2 py „ i' ?^•?T4 `?•:J,i.• .,Z. ? .trv .r,." •.ia•' ,.i'{r'• •.? Tc- Eu+ >9 ! } . , , •, is f'' • : 'Y i:. ?; ;' °t. • 'i-. ?; t 3.1 101 ,021 / mar/ f •; ri:l?""??•'+'--3, GJ7-F09b -r .?•y!:••; ?r?:: '•e•'•.• ".':t?;. h.•: :.ii?r'••S:"r: 'iJ .! O •t::'i <:'::'•' '?y: .s'• '?,•ti,:?L, ?. _ •'[?: ;i:',. r• ' ; ';'.: a 7th ?y ,? :r •,... %?::! O• L'..i; • 4;'?,?,;'; .,",.. :,5,.,I? ? ?F*? ;i' ?E.1 3,39 •'kF':? i•::=,': ',,; -::J;. L?:';.'_Z!:' f 'ti ;4 ?+' ;'F'• .,k. O G?• 4f _.?' 4637-1092 ", :•.3:;: 4. ,;:.:; 'e. rt= ?+ L4 TRACT G ,;.,.,t •:. pP. r• ,•. r ;.'??• 119 :;,.. ,:j L., ••'•:r•'•'' ? ? _ . S 76-125 RS f °,.tr::•,... rr •?i: '5;:: •;i.,.•? is ? ?f'?? '•!i; '•t•'::.''• I '.r 9 ? ?.,: r• •'+: is :5::,?'v..?y •':??r +!f. ::4: Gp '_:.'.;r :; .:'. ?i''t'i'.:•.?;:?pYv:hltr'• ,iJ' t. _ t;: ?:?? •' •;.: ;,:t':, ,•.,'?: ;:,. .. ;: u ov T y 7- v f Nv R -1Y L r„7 P L b P, tom, ?.•' '• ;j,.`, L•,i.•, : ?lti.:,,},'•'r'Y :, pY:: .?r;•-' .7.'':,.r!?i„?{t?'r .?ti},r.•??1(.r•?j::::.?: .???;?4,`}.. ..i 'i..{f:.7 : t . f?•:? ..r? •:I: : i°• Y'? ::, a: :.:' ' 7:•: °r: . ?.: y Ryc i'ar: ^rl••{e'•. .L'v %: ••i?r"'?':?': .l}i:?a, ! •tc ?•?'t !r"i:'?:'?.i;.• yy..aa?•?i; J.. ??•rt: f <-ri?'' :'s' ?sa:•"?r•is. ?.''?'.' ,•J•; ;, :J.i,.ri;'n• •?' •, r??: •.. ;•y.r.•?: ?.' .crr;v'rtL ±ft „Jm;v: nJ.: sJ- tii};. ,.i:, •v!'L :'i• ..hf?. ;'i?? ,•(.r=, t,r.. -q •i'. s• •h' .L. .iYi?r n::::' r„ 'Tr ? f.?..-" :t' ,•Mf '•lt :L' ::F'°•?'•r•L.;,'r7F 'S.- '.l:.i;:'?. :i' ??` :}•?'' r.t•.°•• :n.'r? •s;• -i:,..,5?,?+•i.,?,?;=.i.;?, .'?• PROPOSED ANNEXATION LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and ZONING OWNER A.Q3-DI LUP•Q3'-03 APPLICANT E M A N N r .? ?, J A PROPERTY DESCRIPTION LAND USE PLAN ZONING M Qj 6 3 2/ 03 FROM U N GLA S S t F t E D COUNTY R- Lj 0,37 ACRES TO I.OW DCNStTY •' RIGHT OF WAY RErSI D EW ri AL RS 6 ACRES PLANNING nnd'70NING 130ARD CITY COMMISSION SECTION 16 TOWNSHIP 2 q S nANaE I G E ATLAS PAGE 30( o Single Family ' 1111117 ?--. Tr - ' N g 1I A uAYVI??+? aJ- ?? . A Y?` ! 60S '3B y tg SVI .. ,4 609 TOWN [] 0. At, 5 TRACT a '?'6'J •' ySG tr •?g 1vTRAl_L•f f; y R 317 3 4oF ?'- '% r•Ai?K? I . e• , 5a HAY '? noa ti3 ?? I?=;1`i'Z??? .;..-• SB -•-e?o VIEw -,t= 0 \b a c So 1 . He 23 3 ' 32 /01. .606" tA ' •,• .1 lT O 4 •'? Yr•r? ,1 '•:?f•r•i lil'1C.?...','r.l: ?,?•'rti?: ?;''il I 1 1 t1 't? I 413 j ?.l•r JAY,, ?. '.',t:?r!•... fee y'j'C's" I' • t' r. OWNER t• • ' 'r • ?? .• 4 ''•••• 14, 3 /02 :}" 637•.-1109G ti ? ? ;;, • "r:r,'• •'t:i.?.:;:. .: ?,.::}?:F.`.:?•_?•'.;%•s '? 717 ? :i.,:: ??•:,• :} :?i°•?n,t•?:' Di:?:.:: 1 339 :.;, : : °:T•?:. i• :y 4537-1092 TRAC r{1: .' >O; , ¦ ...: r o I R T G r hRb' l't ?] -145 { %13 i'?'::i' J :4•?` ;.r': r? ,. •'y? :i. ??? .t ?' !'•}t 1• ,'hf '. +.t." :L.;.? :ly,••:'?.1'f.1 r,','' •I?S,s.?J,t• AL G '.t•: i=i ::Ir (.r Lam'' •v• :.r. r: .:. !'i• ii' .'ir tit:.' tr i::• ?r'i •T„• S•Si 1 ':1'J '•1.' • t .i• 'fit: PROPOSED ANNEXATION LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and ZONING P A R A. Q3 -o ? LuP'9 APPLICANT. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION LAND USE PLAN ZONING Al i? B 32/ 04 I 4 FROM UNcLpISS IF1ED COUNTY R`y I i TO Low DeNSITY RESIDENYIAL_ PLANNING and ZONING BOARD SECTION 16 TOWNSHIP 2Q S !] Single Family , ' I RIGHT OF WAY RS 6 0,23 ACRES, ACRES J CITY COMMISSION - RANGE 16 E ATLAS PAGE 3 0 1 A Oil i i f $1 44n y 1 ? d Harrison ' =?--- Myrtle ;.ve, Missouri Ave O m M M" M ? #s e y : n n x 1. "IT r ?'` Clearwater City Commission He 03/18/93 E` Agenda Cover Memorandum SUBJECT: Petition for Annexation, Land Use Amendment, and Zoning Atlas Amendment; 1812 Beverly Circle North; Owner: Charles M. & Theresa Nikitas; Approx. 0.25 ac. (A 93-05 & LUP 93-06) RECOMMENDATIONNOTION: Receive the, Petition for Annexation, Land Use Plan Amendment to Low Density Residential, and Zoning Atlas Amendment to RS-4 for Lot 15, Block C, Meadow Creek Sub., and refer the request to the City Clerk to be advertised for public hearing. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: 'The applicants wish to annex in order to obtain City sewer service for an existing single family house. The property is located on the north side of Beverly Circle North approximately 300 ft. east of Keene Rd. and 730 ft. north of Lakeview Rd. The lot is in a developed single family residential district, and is contiguous to the City on all four side. The lots to the north, east, and west are developed as single family residential. To the south, across Beverly Circle N., is Lake Lela, which is in the County. The applicant's property has a Countywide Future Laud Use Classification of Residential Low (5.0 u.p.a. max.) and County zoning of R-3. It is proposed to assign a Future Land Use Classification of Low Density Residential (8.0 u.p.a. max.) and zoning of RS-4 to the applicants` property, the same as assigned to the surrounding property. As the existing County Future Land Use Classification of Residential Low (5.0 u.p.a, max.) has a lower maximum density than the proposed City Classification of Low Density Residential (8.0 u.p,a. max.), the proposed Land Use Classification will be subject to review of the Pinellas Planning Council. flaviewed by: Originating Dent: p Costs: N/A lip Action: ip Legal N/A PLANNING Fk DI PM NT 1 Total - Approved Budget N/A 13 Approved wlconditions Purchasin N/A g D Denied Risk Mgmt. N/A Elver Dept: Current Fiscal Yr. Cis. N/A ? . Continued to: ACM Funding Source: other .. N/A 0 Capitnl Imp . Advertised: 17 Operating Attachments: Date: 13 Other PETITION Paper: MAP ® d i Not Requ re Submitted by: Affected Parties Appropriation Code: © None 13 Notified ey agcy ® Not Required Printed on recycled paper I r. PETITION-FOR ANNEXATION, city commission, city of Clearwater P.O. Box 4746' Clearwater, Florida Commissioners: We, the undersigned, being all owners of ti:e described heal property, contiguous to the prasont boundnrlert of the City of Clearwater, ant] situated in an unincorporated area of Pinellna County, Florida,-do hereby request that said property be annexr_d into the. corporate' limits of the City of Clearwater,Lr1orida. 'We hereby further request thaL said property be zoned and classified under t=he 'Zoning Ordinance of the City of Clenrwater, no sot forth on the following page.: Attached hereto ,is a current survey of the described property, (if .it: 1e 'anplnt:ted), together with n aertificrnto of titles from a title company, a copy of the deed or n'letter from n,licenaed attorney setting forth the names of all persons, firms or corporations owning any interest in the described property. , e' undersigned have been advii;ed of, underatand Arid in Tl consideration of annexation, utility services, and other' good and valuable consideration, do hereby agree and covenant as follows: ; I,' all structures and improvements which are erected upon said prop erty'subsequent• to the date of this petition for annexation shall comply with all applicable City of Clehrwater,regulations and ordinances as set forth in the City Code', of ordinances; 2. to convey such recreation, land, recreation facilities and open i.. space land dedication and/or fees in the amount and manner prescribed.by Division 2 and 3, Chapter 116, Article IV of the Clearwater Code of ordinances; and 3. when any substandard abutting street or utilities. are subsequently upgraded by the City to meet Citli Standards, said improvement will be done on an assessment basis, consistent with city procedures therefore. We,, the undersigned hereby certify that we have read and examined all of"the statements and allegations in the foregoing Petition including attachments and after being duly 'sworn, deposed and say that such r` statements are correct, complete and true and voluntarily made with full knowledge thereof. i _ STATE, OF FLORIDA } COUNTY OF-PINELLAS Subscribed and sworn to before me this i _day of +199. , My Commission ]Expires: oCnry NOTARY PUBLIC STATE (f FLORIDA Hy COPHsIGH EXP. NOV-29- ' BONDED TIM GER£RAL INS- UM9$ r . 1, . .. ,. °' ' 1. -r sae=3?•. 38 5;,, "y'?"'•?i ? ,, .'? ?• ??;,?;?^?a;.:?? ? ? :; ?,:Z;."'. s?r?{?; , :;.. ? -?: r:= ' "• ?" ; t•?' ;'I ?1 '?'? ,it1 1 ti?.J1: J; .. ,1 } ,1 .?, .a}tl ?.c}: i b'{'{'' ,rJ r??%' y ''?•?'?# ':?.. r•s3- ,ii?d. ., ' !4'?•,: ?..I prr,,''/.Itiii ; E •F'?k.:`•f'=fir: •;lef...fli S{i i ' liJ !I .Lr. , ': Fi:'•i'a I!i Ir '!'..?; r.??: I ,.. c., .i•['? •3': •. .t ' ?... , .• .-? I I'. r? + J ., r .. /e I ` //{{ice+ {i11:. i` ?!IrII^3y??• f ''rJ*i,.?, r rT :L f } '',' 1t?? ?' ,f ';' ' L';'•Jis': "r` f r t .' j"J.r 1 '?? r' L '' 4 .4F ?,' Jf •F:r i? Fya 4'r 7. 1. 1:.J 1r,'7 .. 1• f T':i rl i.•-IIOA [ ?,ei`.• i' i r=" iL'!"f ?ry'"1f !fl??,, • F• . 1 ! ? F?,, ';. j??'r,J } ? tis ?r'•f y ?'LjK ?I ?: ? I j T ? i y?,•''S :!?!1' ?• .? .i '?Il r h'?? pp } ( d.',?11?• jy•dJ rr,,• :,;.: r.. J`•::L, i. ..i :.? r, d...;: • :.?..• I Ip:. .l•. r.i??IW Y ? }r. t n: ..yam T.. t' J ?,:. .??: (. 5' »/ax,•. ': '}:?:.]:41J7•:L??...iJ,., L?I,:G:ti .,,,1•r ,?.1•.'?,,..,.... pRj t ,. `/ a.J, ...;s pr !!,• ,vey T, Y':it?:? ....J::,i ..,5? ?{: 1110 s'=' • h 'r JY"R..::: 11f ?'t.i r},:. i i .1. ,( ? ! ?. t F • • .r a ,; y.: 1„.,, •:S!* :' t ?{ .? ! ' , 1'i. .?i?if'.:l',,,yyyppp y ,? ?rfJ•: {{ ''1': .: liy. _?_.. I 1 , ?? f:' ?s4. t.•r''. ? i71k'.14"sy ? ?, iu .}.lip 5 ?. t ? , ??I. ? „1,,, ,. ,7't:'ir'.•? r •?J " , i, - i•r R'. 4tY•??:e??. 'rV' J. ?:S' •. t• .?7.r ?? . ? ? [?@ 1 ?: r ? r?• ?• ? [JCi-ii '?i:. :}yi ?. sI'?. .t'?•:: .3..4t1 f fr ?w?• 'ry•.r: .r7L[•••?',?i r Il.tF ?` ff ?"?Y y ! ''}:;.?: i .,.,`L;±',J'.:,' ::,'•sw .:r, ?j?7 J•Ti'?•tj j: ::? 91•• •I^ ,???? r,:y-yri Crr `CJ{M?'f: F,y '?J! 7 .1 B! 'I! -;A?: iji .:•? ? .? ?;? .'t?:? ?t'. ?,,: ; ,? ;? ?a1?'??;!{ ?ri#+? ?•? '?? _ •n..? ? ?...:..._ ....'?. ?t31;...,, .u.:cr'`' N ??..??? ,!o•i?r:111` ,?. ;s?i?'Jr •.1:??: MEADOW C 1?f?yRO X SANE n 12 IFl'i• •??' _. .:3??.??t^. V ,?i .•.:' a? ? !?t'ai'•t?i. 'I' xt s::'n:r,.:, si W ?'• r;. ..li' ?'t" ! tc N ,.b l'• d -?9' Y}='?lll}'y: Et3!tii +M. ?i!•i:';'?'.tl, ,''" is • i ' J •.?? ? ,+?,? GI =? I'. n'k?, L..!?,? ?{;+,'te ," t? . f r •. 1 t' . v'Iil: iI},''? 't •.?•t .y'',.ti S?L•f ?f?? ``yy K 38f t li!f r<'t:?. ? r?,',. t; 17 16! Z'S s'.li t yL ,1k A, nr??? FL,?tfJri.. k. ? ?? ? Q'it ,;si ,??Y: 1p ,`.Fr'? ?rn_` •R"!:.'. s , .i ):;??Q ttti ' t 1~ '1:7'I 't{r}^?• 5 i,'YI .?iJ??I, tii l'., lii. ?7'i.n: l 2 33 ? '• `. `'{ ?'i } . .? ;3?'i •it ?' i tt?}ii :r., I j,r.7:?. • BEVERLY ?• ??((?, .LL C(? CI RC E N. i ? •? :r;,; :r: " '',• . i• i.,.--•. ..,;, ::.':.: • . - •-:''3;,y h'?1,... s s •_'p i• r•.:.,g t; ;T.I?,P : 1' Ji' p1'?•? rr?i..4•?;r'y??{!yr: L j.Il'. •i•??J:f.: r: >?{r ?; •t ?. ? •O ??? .G?"'"??1 ?' 11 •`Yt,ar! t3!:•,';} •?is' i.rsi i:,.., ?'w:. r i` :9: yy .?r' •. ,[. .f•%..':'.??r s:.i L's• .'[?.:1... •:?}!'r'?sf%•' s .: fi''I .= Il! '=`?ri ??.F:j;:? t?/?i r?s L'i+,???J %'' .'n J L: { •'?'f': a i.. r Svf' .{ E r: " t .7.'. •eJ 1 ' a ' i i . i ni... _:: 1:.16 V1 I' ?; 'r ..,I'"}t.' :J ;f.7 r? • :r r; ? i_:.. { i?.pfs.(,?'', ? ?°'t^?. ?? :?? i ':.: ?.•i. ,li.r !'ri• ? .•?F%+•• 1s jt?• ?. { .. {{ 11r!., 't '...? v. hr •h7•w ..'?•?sg• Y .,??3 . ... •1:,,11'1•' :; "''= 1M •i "1'. RI'1jf ?i ? wit ::K!1.: !,.}• •.r. ''•:• u '. ... ,IJ.?. ? .i??i.?J:?'.:`•. •.j .F•:ti' .•L,r:='rr 4 5i? ?; ? ? rv .. !?, ,•.r'? '{{' t L t.- r = ? p ?p} . f fir,.. • i.., ::u, K! 'i i• 1?rti=•`•: •?.?P??' is ' z 4 }.1. ir:l' tr•s!. r?,iiq ie.'•pr}r:'r ?.it i'si I?r r r {ti? }' 1 1? r ar .l', ?L;1', ''jj r5; r i i d, i• ?' h >' ?4. r i1? ? ' ? ? Y { iti7• 1 ? 4+' 1 ? I'r. 1?I;,r. i;::?ai,. !.: i'a ' ii 1 YI i ??i?''.! i?'.i?,.. •f}jiTJ?!1; t,?. r'k.?,ls a ?'G'rv4?'- Yi i? r•i; rnt?i ``?F,?a?.. (rrY,•'1' !,}:?':.?' .ri???'{IG rr?:?iy ?i?:}e??::?p Lt?.+'? i>,1 r.r., t.•.Z: n V+.'J•• •i?.?'..u:. ..w• .6r.•: '"???.. ??• ? :.1 ;[v'Y.?? U•• 'l.:?r,?... ?' n 'w?r?if?? }!'•:?!; ? f:44?1•? ,F? .:.,;ti 13REN-rwoOQ sr. Il' 'r•; il•J{ ? •{3 ;+i ?i if: I'.':1? '5':'w!;i%1`' IN r. .•' ?• y '•?r+th RS ~ . '.. 719 J . ?4:[':?}•,.?{•jF tl-t 'rr'JS t?•YJ;!' ?I 7 C?„ i . ,,c., • ,, .c'r?r; , -••fJ;.s r- •?? , s c- a «,•,,,., t[1o••,:rt?t?:;?.tO:?:?l:i:°? :a.:?C] ._.::4' 'F..•. :.??..:3".•. i.(.:,e.k')L. '4::::1.?<;..."cs:?J .i 'i+n? ?51.....ti.L?L i?u..,?rr.:.:. Cr t i J _ ^I FARWATER PROPOSED ANNEXATION LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and ZONING OWNER APPLICANT N 1 K 1T l?, Sy c fvl E, T' A G 3- O 5 LUP' C{3- O G PROPERTY DESCRIPTION LAND USE PLAN ZONING Lo`r IS, GLOC.K LI ME:AZou) CttEEK suB FROM U NCLAS5 I FICD COUNTY Ro.1'3 ACRES RIGHT OF WAY TO t_0W nR_ Nst -q RESI ID ENTIrAL RS W ACRES PLANNING and ZONING BOARD CITY COMMISSION SECTION ?y TOWNSHIP 2.Ct S RANGE 15' E ATLAS PAGE 308 A M giiiiiio 1'no,my s F Ica. t 1 1 V ¢ an Q i ' ';m n C m ' r ' m 'I :? 1.......? 01, 1 f r Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum CONSENT e: 03/18/93 R7 93 f tb r7 SUBJECT: Petition for Annexation, Land Use Amendment, and Zoning Atlas Amendment; 1400 Regal Rd.; Owner: Lois A. Forgacs; Approx. 0.20 ac. (A 93-08 & LUP 93-10) RECOMMENDATIONf MOTION : Receive the Petition for Annexation, Land Use Plant Amendment to Low Density Residential, and Zoning Atlas Amendment to RS-8 for Lot 1, Solar Crest Sub., and refer the request to the City Clerk to be advertised for public hearing. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. .BACKGROUND: The applicant wishes to annex to obtain City sewer service for an existing single family house. The property is located on the northeast cornet of Regal and Park approximately 880 ft. north of Belleair Rd. and 1280 ft. west of Highlands Ave. The lot is in a developed single family residential district. The property to the west, across Park St. is in the City and has a Future Land use Classification of Low Density Residential and zoning of RS-8. The applicant's property and the property on the north, east and south sides are in the County and have a Countywide Future Land use Classification of Residential Low (5.0 u.p.a. max.) and County zoning of R-3. It is proposed to assign a City Future Land Use,Classification of Low Density Residential and zoning of RS-8 to the applicant's property, the same as assigned to the property to the west. As the existing County Future Land Use Classification of Residential Low (5.0 u.p.a. max.) has a lower maximum density than the proposed City classification of Low Density Residential (8.0 u.p.a. max.), the proposed Land Use Classification will be subject to review of the Pinellas Planning Council and the County Planning Agency,. Reviewed by: Oriplnatinp Dept: f?f? Costs: NIA _ Commission Action: legal N/A _ PLANNING & D VE o?MENT Total Approved Budget N/A roved w/conditions A Purchasin N/A pp g Risk Mgmt. NIA Usor Dept: Current Fiscal Yr. © Denied cis N/A © Continued to: ACM Fundin g Source: Other _ _N/A _ © Capital Imp. Advertised: © Operating Attachments: Date: 0 Other PETITION Poper: MAP R i d ® equ re Not Submitted by; Afiseted patties, 13 None " ?? ? Notified Approprietinn Cnde: 1' e ® Not Required CI rfager 0i Printed on recycled paper ;. % PETITION FOR ANNEXATION ; city 'Comminsion City,of'.Clearwater 'P.O.'.Box 4740 Clearwater,.Florida Commissioners: We, the undersigned, being nil owners of the described real property, eontiguoun to the •prenellt boundariers of Elio pity of Clearwater, and situated' in an unincorporated area of. Pirrellrls County, Florida, do hereby request that said property be annexed into the corporate limits of 'the City of Clearwater, Florida. We hereby further request that said property lie zoned and classified Ordinance of the City of Clearwater., as eet forth on the under the Zoning ' • following page. Attached hereto, is a current: survay of the described property, (if it ie unplatted), together with a certificate of title from 'a title, -'' company, a copy of the deed or. a letter from n licensed ntitorney setting' ! forth the names of all persons; firms or corporations'owning any interest in the, described property. The undersigned have been advised -of,, understand and ill consideration of annexation, utility services, and other good and valuable consideration, do hereby agree and covenant as follows: 1: all structures and improvements which are erected upon said property subsequent to the date of this patitian for arlnexatiorl shall comply with all applicable City of Clearwater regulations and ordinances as set forth in the City Code of ordinances; 2. to convey such recreation lnnd, recreation facilities and open • space land dedication and/or fees in the amount and manner prescribed by Division 2 and 3, ChapL•er 116, Article IN of the Clearwater Code of ordinances; and 3. When any substandard abutting street or utilities are subsequently upgraded by the City to meei'City Standards, said Improvement will be done on an assessment basis, consistent with City procedures therefore. We, the undersigned hereby certify t1int we have react and examined all of the statements and al.legattons in the foregoing Petition including attachments and after being duly sworn, deposed and say that such, statements are correct, complate'and true and volunt, ly made with full 'knowledge thereof. STATE OF FLORIDA ) ' . COUNTY OF' PIIIELGAS' ) • Subscribed and sword to before me this My Or My Commission Expires: D _I Ho"Ry PUBLIC SIAIC r ! FLORIDA H, COMISSI0N EXP . HOy,29,1993 ' BONDED THRU GENERAL ! INS. UrAI. 4" f f' iF•Fa : ' t•r _ 3? ' 1 =5, ,- 1?ba flro 11?K?? 14 ?? 1 y, 9 io 13 X69 7 ?b 5pt ?0? r' tab `\ t [J a ?' n ` . ' (L++ RCU ?tyDgg00 1. 'i,1p? 1 0 S50_R?r" ^f5f74 tyt . t 1 L G L' t? 3 4"o ! x? 1548 tyt° •5 J` \ ?L?Vv J t5pp ? , tia4lt ?r 6 ? ? d y ?. ty : ?? m 14 ?:r u 1 ' v ST L m 1 ,? ty ' ? A4 . J1 . t5?'b ??, tyt1?? ? ?? ? ~ f5f8 .'s Ar y w? t 2 rY t"it r t 1a d t5 -0 0 tab "pt" ? ?5by ? 15Fb• •?{?bg r8 •'. ~? h 22 , t??p ?ta66 ?. tc?64 r .J ?56y 8 ~ . 23 13 ?? 14 OF ' "ci 51 ?y S5gt 9 13 ?. 14 fs7f . -;5??' q 11J 12 11 J to 15 E ._ 1576 FC.?? STREET 12 to YS07 V n I •"'i n ISBI ?..._.J --r- ?-- J 1-7 ,~ i 1J I. 9 TG t1 12 ` fkbf! 1n 16s94 r6sf 13 ., ?. ?....ri_....._ _._i..} _?,_.w?69s' =3b, 22a: 21 20 Ti gc I8bi 17 , ?fs96 n n ,`?, n? ?' n I 14 il" 8,4 1 ROAD `?.: s ?. ,•?-.fir I 1 .+s_: ,._•?r?--•r.•-ww?,...-,,,?-.,.,--- ?.t:ft s? ,.? 1''.{:1n:'t'?7-lYC•) l1e: '?i' ;ff-4 ?. i.??.tf rf ?.. ?., c{' 1 s t i i^ wi;::tr1T?11.n'e it I{1 t `?{I: i 4' ?r ?? : { I s? .. +• h• , : l.. ? i...it: to : !. ,`t?t,l, ?f1.1,g! Stih,f 1? . Rf i;tr,? ? . ; n?:•+.i:{1i.4,'?i STRI RS B q5 /SP 33/1 ' CILEAtWATM BErLLEAIR PROPOSED ANNEXATION LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and ZONING OWNER F- 5 f L ,q A. 9? - O B L U P' 9 3 -- 14 APPLICANT PROPERTY DESCIIIPTION LAND USE PLAN ZONING Loll- i S o t~ A R. c: REST S u g FROM U 0 C 1- )A 55 1 F1 ED COUN'T'Y R' 3 A C R E S TO, LOW 0 16) 1'T? FLIGHT OF WAY RF- SIDE'NTI AI- RS 8 ACRES PLANNING and ZONING BOAnD CITY COMMISSION SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP ,'?q S RANGE 15- E ATLAS PAGE 915 A i b ?1FN' 1 1 1' I I 1 1 l A?i w ? o C M . r m 1 ` CIE: •. J.. Ia?? ! ? • I J Y ?1 PM?? ?S ? A 'i?S . 1 i r ,' U fA. 4J. -S I. , .? sI r... / I• i t(:!""r.r•. .? 4-i,1.,t,-,,,v ,L, 1' k, -? .!. _ ?I `S 1}'I?r..? a+i 'e'? (" 14' ti -:'i, k, 1, '.. ,I• -c 3.. 'r^!. 'ii .1 .1'.r•!•?. ;'4;9 ?,: ily . i,-,, - I :?' 1, 'y. 'hyi .'.•° . • ,^.,y a t' •;1'. o t•' -:' - ir! fr. ? %' :54 'e..' {: •' E.' ,F . ?'1 • f' ' ?'st'•g,` d'ty' A;, •,:. ).: ' L.. . F'?•' -1 I 1 , 1r•, : ,,tr I.: :;fr'f°r''a" ti,, '' r .`.:fit,)' ..; eeirr+, 6,"'! I s' i ?? ^2' ?. 1ry' si ° . I . . f' , r. ./ •;: _i1.- . , r?`r•~+r i!' .L,, '}'; ''i .s; ??'17,"'.. .' - ? ' • ., .. .,f•. r ,5. .7Fhrd ? 'I! x-:, r. H tll+'. L _ •1 r I' 'I' . ,+ a1,r4% j'' "1 ^*?i .'r = .i i e`, - ,'k: '.F • , . 3'? , . ? ° . . , .. . , c .i!' r, ?' ig,r'S:3k1 1S./e, ',. , •{ 'I'•d < .. 1. , ,, ;a,,F,.:=.'a I ,:4,'J.. `'t:. ''? ' ..? '•I! ?`di`.? + y!. te," -?• s'. r .f , .. "y',es ,L ,g•TY 1' 'r• I? .. (,'f :•I'. i'. 1. f (. 1 .l, ..s, r',? r,; ?c!? r•? , .i' h`sy i.rfl.?rf :..r', , .I, ' .f-• ,e .eSY : trr';. •.'i . 'r '.t. , 'f ! >I '!I - ''-,;,. H .t , :r.', '.,?.`. , x,' ? ' ° i-. E I i:. ?+" f ?'• s ,I '.9: ' .I'1F i+f ?va t, ;'j.. : i`'% • I Y> g,' 1, . S.' .:rl l i'..' !.',Et 6.!'' "!• " al - • ?: , ., ¢ . :1°,.: rll. j#Tr ` ;!:., 4?`' ..f ?'r,- "<? s. a,., •y'. '?, .? .i<,,. ct'i s. t'. .? F•. ., "y a .I'.a '. ?,-.,i:Y ,tr.f,d: "'?: 1 i 3 ?'.I, ',i:. '. ;t: fr } " }a` G:?' i,: I ` ?! , I, rj,r' k`.i,{b',?) f• _ '=}';si•'•; • `- ',i'..: 't113:. + I ,r '?1 ,! s?'° : yy r".{>4•' ,'.j, ` ..1, .;I'`k. .l1'§i .l..:,' . ,, ? <+' . . I. . , .r•. 's',:;4!, ry3t 'u'tt yZ;?e. :?r'r.' ?i; 1,'Iiv r .ice. 4'(s,-,.. •?. ..E`f 1, f. .,i y'"-Id, :RPt r.?t,-l. r, '.lit {) •s?,f ; '.?).i: .a, I { e<?^ r-=t yi r C. t.I°.• ?q .•i i:;; , ? ,?.. . !'.` ?'i:; ., . I fir S + k- 1 g .. f''t-t:E'' 1+. i'I .f",j?'r''' +'#.iE:; ,1iy.'? ?' i' ., ? eis ?`; :+'Air I _ ref, 't°?', ,,?rl; IF, '!5 - ..?` .. I" '; ;I.y `:x? ' ? '',ki_"?!' nr?Laf .:l+ ?, R1'+i ',° ?•r. ?' , ''i, '1 ,,''`, i. 'si- "I •.'yi, i. ?'f ,r-te ;('(,,J,,4, .,t,. 1?, .,I, ,' + rrs f?' E .:,,i{ rF _I. ,E. j.. f..?,',`,fy{?+;' ?,.i'I, i•`, t , , • - ?...'. Gxt (' ,l •? 4' .4 T' J i'+</ r 4r V'??.a '' `.f f ",1. - '! 1 . E ''E !r'il ;i' rti.? r 'i' Ty(:. t?'1 <,?-, Er': r' s - E '4 ?,r . ?t- . i'.' `; ' 1t,I?T ?, ,? > j :+i , , f, I - ?:. • - rt;,rl' yi `.? a. '.1'' =. ?'2 'es `rb r:-`f' 'r' r•.Sx _ Y '?I, `. . ti:. Li.iA. ,N°," ..St`rlA,Y'V.r a.rtrt? N.1:•efu.r+. ''1M--1 c. f!f, ,I ! !l . ! + i ' 1 - r . ' , e , 'r e . f 1'. I . r - , , - + ,!' , I ,t' .. . r r 1 f e. ii-I ' , . , - , , j r -.r r• r r= ' ? `' ;' ? r ' • I .1, ` x:ili.'/ - '..., . . . + ' ' .) .. r , .. .. . .. , .. . . r. ' " . , - 1 .. 1. : .. :.r,, .,t ' -1 r , - ,, 1. . , , . .gj• .! I i + •F, C. ' R?i•Ira"?... ., • '' f - f .. ,, 'd: • ,1 j .'> l ,4g,J, ri 1'I.' or t' ?1 yv/?.I.F.. t , N ?A ,f' I r '1 . -I'S: .a.. .f .` ' S ? ,,.s •,.,' ;F. .I I '- s . . r / ?ir``f''{: :4: e, . . r . ? . fi . . <' ti a .. , . r; ,r s: ' , . .ry ""l PfvF 'pit ?!? `I° - r !'I •? - . . . .rl .. '' tVffi f lSr.' r. . `I- .r 5 r- , ',. . I r f f r . i , .. r ',S .,,'t-r .,!,.! : ( r: • S `.?'. {. ,,?F1• f • + t• f.' I 'f -f ' ' l? k. , , r1 rL .? f •-!?j 1 I . - .! P?, •I , . r , 1 I .; ' 1. "6 Vii: ,}:. s E : -:: {:;'.4 ' F' 'i €- c:" `'I i ..I I . f t v ° r• ?f. __ -__ ... - _-_-__-___ 'r e:,.: ' -+'i,? .•. 'F?. far et', .+.I .,.. .. :,k. 7.`. ? j t1"' t S .? TE Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum CONSENT R,191:0: 03/18/93 PLD SUBJECT: Application for Future Land Use Plan and Zoning Atlas Amendments; 2339 Gulf to Bay Blvd; Owner: Lokey Oldsmobile, Inc.; Representative: Donald O. McFarland; Approx. 0.64 ac. . (Z 93-03 & LUP 93-12) RECOMM EN DATIONNOTI ON : Receive the Applications for Amendment to the Future Land Use Plan from Medium Density Residential to Commercial/Tourist Facilities and Zoning Atlas Amendment from Mobile Home Park to General Commercial for a part of Sec. 18-29-16 and being the northern 280.01 ft. of the Hillcrest Mobile Home Park, and refer the request to the City Clerk to be advertised. ? and thot•the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant wishes to change the land use and zoning classifications to enable him to incorporate this parcel along Gulf to Bay Blvd. into his auto sales and service center. Presently, the center occupies land on both sides of the parcel. The parcel was formerly part of the Hillcrest Mobile Home Park. At present there are two, 'unoccupied mobile homes on the property that are to be removed by the applicant. The property appears to have been laid out to accommodate an access off Gulf to Bay Blvd. There is also an access to the mobile home park from Druid Road. The property owner has signage stating there is no outlet to Gulf to Bay Blvd. However, the entrance from Gulf to Bay Blvd. is still open, and appears to be used by the residents of the mobile home park.' Staff is concerned about the access issue, and about signage issues that may be created when the two commercial sites are joined. Currently, signage allocations have been based on the two parcels being considered as separate properties. Receipt and referral of this item will allow staff to continue its discussion of these issues with the applicant. The site is anticipated to be developed as part of the adjacent facilities of the applicant. A new or amended site plan will be required by the City before.any development on this property. Reviewed by: Originating Dept: J M Costs: # NIA Commission Action: LegaL NIA PLANNING & D VE( N Total Approved Budget Purcha rchasin NIA NIA 13 Approved w/conditions g Risk Mgmt. NJA User Dept: Current Fiscal Yr. 11 Denied cis N?A ? Continued to: ACM Funding Source: Other -NIA ? Capital Imp . Advertised: ? operating Attachments: Date: ? Other APPLICATION tr Paper: MAP ® N i ot Requ red Submitted by: Alfscted Parties ? Norte ? Notified Appropriation Code: G7 Not Required C1 H agar i? Printed on recycled paper 1 I, ' 1.. - • I . i 1 ., ' • I , ' 1 ' . , I ' 1. X ' • ' + • 'f% ` , ,' :fe1 1 l 1 1 , • 7,ONING ATLAS AUKHOMFNT APPLICATION ,'. DATE. __Feb __17 i- -1993 NAME OF PROPERTY OWNER(S)?t?j3y O1,5jsmils,_._1nr ADDRESS 2 .4.19 Gulf to Day, Clearwater, FL• _ PHONE 799_2151 AUTIIORI ZEU REPRESENTATIVE (IF ANY )_?9nalsLp.?l?Ear1 a,t R_gnlO rP- - - ADDRESS' PHONE _ l?ye,? 461-1111 LEGAU DCSCRI PT'ION OF PROPERTY (5U13J ii 1 OF HUQUEST )r- gQM__PjB C Q NE DE 1 Oil I'll P_UNNINC 5 50 FE[i'I'_--ANI) 4+1 663 i [' T LOH ('_QINTL _Oi' IiFc;IH LING - - _ THEN S 200 FEI;'P_ THEN- W 9-5 F.ERT AS) 'I11ULN-M?FELT,ANIL E 95 FRET 1S}_ TO POINT OF BEGINNING.-_09- BOOK: 7169 PAGC: 1590 GENERAL 'LOCATION Cast _V? FCel 2C 1aj)j--- i_C_qjjjL to 2339 Gulf -t9-Ilay-. - -_ , Clearwater, FL ACREAGE- 0. g4-1' Rrran_._ M. n. t, . PRESENT ZONING DISTRICT•R Ul? REQUESTED ZONING DISTRICT - CC, CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE CATEGORY 1 COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE CATEGORY__.Htj r e'? REASON FOR REQUEST 1n nrrl-- h_n_rnrifnr,n_ # h?r?? s+r? ,_li th whr, aA 1a..,r.ti „ S. r IS THE REQUESTED ZONING DISTRICT 114 CONFORMANCE WITH THE CLEARWATER COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN? YE5 NO?X Note: IS the requested zone change is not consistent with the ;. City's Land Use plan, the applicant will be required to' file a corresponding applicmtlon to emend tte Iand use plan. IS THE REQUESTED ZONING DISTRICT III CONFORMANCE WITH THE PINELLAS COUNTY ,COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN? YES_. -NO .: ,. , LIST A14Y OTHER PERTINENT IXFOMAT ION SUBMITTED (Sk[;uri.ure Paul B. key, President Reviewed b;' , ?' ?,3Rytt LA111) USE PLAN AMI-1111ltiill'1' AI1.111ACA'I'IUII NAME OF PHOPCRTY 0WlW1(S)_ j,Mks,:.Y...j1ds?mpbJ.le...ltic.._Y.------..-_?.? ...._?.._ ?---_ ADDRESS_ 2329-Gul C.?fiLr- - -----_---I?IIUNC_, 7n!)- 2,151 iICP1tCSf;11TATiVE or ANY) i)unaid O. 1•Icrirl-1krdL Iis a M--_---- ADUHESS___aLl..s. Mi?saurl- GaxwAL ._!?L_3dGLG-..1110111',- 6r.r_1 s i ._.._._ , LMAL DESCRIPTION OF P1lOP1iI1TV (SUBJECT OF REQUEST)—t nr SVI 1/4 RUNNING 'S So FLL•P AND -W 6G3_rr.BTT_1-011 i THEN S 200 FEE7TIICN W 95 FE:I I'NLN A -Z-00 FFCI (S) TO POINT OF BCGINNING. _Olt UOONt 7169_P11GCL ' GENUMAI, LOCATION ?EiLfi?_Parcel?n?111214.1113,i1LC?lpk..k.ca_7?17d__r_?1.L s.-U.4" Clearwater, FL r k 71 h e' . ACH AGEr PRESENT 70NHIG DISTRiC•i'_^ktM1t __--- I 11 N- UEsTEU ZONING D IS Tit i CTM Note: A separate application is required if the zokiing district is proposed to 'be changed, Pitt.; SENT 'CLEARWATER COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN CLASSIFICATION (Y" 169 REQUESTED CLEARWA'TER COMPREHENSIVE: LAND USE PLAT. CLASSIFICATION TREASON FOP.' REQUEST In order .ko ?Ql?I9?m XCCUL_W.Lf:h Elie. ai,)sacan1-- _pa eis• f PINELLAS COUNTY CoixlPnEnENSiVE LAND USE PLA11 CW*3IFICATION Rt3? ' IS 'f 1i t, REQUESTED LAND USE CATEGORY Ili C0111`011MANCE; WIT11 TIRE PINELLAS, :. COUNTY LANU USE PLAN CLASSIFICATION? YFS-? NO x -» Note: • County Land Use Plan aknendnients require ..tile approval of tike Pinellas Couuly PlanninG Council and the State of 'Florida (Chapter 163 F.S.). ' State Growth >vianagerneklt Lci.lslalion lirnit.s,liniti npproval of Land Use Plan amettduients,.by--tlie.. ity C ann?Mon to twice a year. , tsir"uarurk: ?-P, u II. •okey, President: F° Reviewed by: e I r ' A. , I •I ?i ' • j r I ! V I • 'at{ iJruriii w l ` ': ¦ N N 4• Q ., rn ? r An r(cngSTµ FFuT,v, 1 ?d r ti rn ' ItOF{.L1Ci{ •?? } t 'fit , :.Z', ^e- ? .?•_,? TEA li,r .r r' v ' f3f ' I I . fr J ' w ? 60 508 ' 607, 23/20 24/01 vf5l N. 23/18 N H ? o o H N co AY BLVD BLVC i N 2DI ' CG IF Q4 3202 ,0o ° N * °° w ?o a o o io e O b b ? f3 ? r. r r r r r tq &'s m rn m n t0 m m la ? m b N n n n i I ! h 597'596 1.595 ' 594 1 60-3 z n i 24/06 01 • '° Mal ISO :3:3 GULF To B AY 'BL.V D ?? -I 3a2 HF-Icm PROPOSED LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT and REZONING OWNER z ? 3 ~03 LI?Ei-G 3 -- 12.. APPLICANT L O 11 E?1 O ADS M o 8[ L E t N ? • PROPERTY DESCRIPTION LAND USE PLAN ZONING M 12% Ps 3 1 / 07 t FROM MED10M DENS 1-'Y RESIDE.N71AL_ TO c- c; ERcL4L 1 TF RMN c. G 0.64 ACRES CITY COMMISSION PLANNING and ZONING BOARD SF,CTION IS . TOWNSHIP S RANGE: E ATLAS PAGE zqq A Bus JwFSS •`t' s !. .irk 6 I . • , MACFARLANE FERGUSOM ATTORNEYS bI COUNSELORS AT LAW 2300 FIRST FLORIDA, TOWER 200 NORTH DATMEN AVENUE , III MADISON STRF.F.•T 210 SOUTH MONROE STREET P. a. DRAWER 2197 , TAMPA, FLORIDA 33602 t+. a, tsox sz' CLEARWATER, t'L0n=% 34617 (813) 273-4200 TALLAHASSEE, rLOnICA 32302 {4131441.1703 FAX (813)273-4390 (904) 224-1218 FAX 10131441-0959 •FhY, JID041222-BaZU MAILING ADDRESS P. O, BOX 1531 TAMPA, FLORIDA 33601 !N' REPLY F7EFER TO: David M. Lee Clearwater. RECE11YED February 24, 1993 FEB 2 ;1993 CITY ATTORNEY M:A. Galbraith, Jr. Esguire City Attorney ',,City-of Clearwater Post Office Box, ,4748 Clearwater, -FL 34618-`4748 Re: Third Avenue South Agreement r Dear Al: Enclosed herewith please find the proposed Amendment to the Third Avenue South Agreement which I have prepared based upon our recent office conference.. As we discussed, under the terms of this Amendment, Cadillac . proposes .to'have the road reconfiguration, project east of Main Street which lies entirely in Pinellas County be constructed as ' soon as possible to avoid the loss of its permits for the project., The proposed Amendment would allow Cadillac and Chevrolet not to undertake construction of that portion of the Third Avenue South• read improvements lying.west of Main Street to U.S •19 until such time as the FDOT overpass is built at the intersection of'U.s. 19 and. Third Avenue South,'and the FDOT road access permit for Third Avenue south'.is available. obviously, before my clients agree to <. build the new improvements east of Main street and give'additional road and utility easements to the county,'it needs to verify that both the county and 'the city will vacate the portion of Main Street south of Third Avenue' a portion of Fourth Avenue South, and all of Fifth Avenue South as set forth in the original, Agreement and Plans. { .' • a,l, , '• ,?• '.r % Y.'J, i ?• r'?i ri 4, • . I". "l'e!. fa t re:y.. 8',;s, a .Y,!•_ ,f.'1 '. -!? 'r, '.'i' ,,,., Y' f, ., .,k .y,.,+i_. .A* ;-,r. ''y"'. „S > l•'.i-• ', .5 ..r .. ''Y -[r y ' "'F't. qt .v??F '•:)#?,?f. ',, 1;: yi....? ?•f ,1 •''> :3?? i , >"r r+a. j 1. 'rr •/?' '.'.. -R ?y i? 1?,r Y.f?a??!?'•51???? ii Yf, . ', , r' ti ?-. •,•=N1.:-+ ?.'. : t r ' r:' ;{,' Ftr (,'r ,." t7 ? F"S!x'1r• !l •73 a 1F'?.s" ?e ?f. r?, ??rJ,t((' t l.J? .1? 1 '' , , J?• '..i'?'m'#.:fgif'. ?,y?,, ,:y ti' •' 'r .,f ? _ ,a,. ,I i. •? r' •rr? -,t_ ',4 ?' ,?si(,;,.?:r: •y, y,. t. ,s ?? r 'f' •I'' ??#:'+t t r .fi ,, ,r" ,+' e' +#? .i.'i/^'f ,y « P. e r ,•??l ?.f , , ?, j('I. •?1 •`l14 Y w?'?. i 1. ?? 'r , tI ? r r 1 ' ° ? ` :t. x /t j }1 )eae:'E',?: .n, .?5•' •1' 6 I'r?.t" -•1.{ t ?'?' ., °?_! .?.s :. 1, t, ,r:'.re?,'? +,k-.(`` 3 .'fi;} - :r` ` 'r .`r ?'! •`Y'; -°r ;'! ,{? •? 1??4,.;1. ?; ?r `.,f ?'4 ? j. ? , • p= p??G R'':s ? ,',S,• m.r " f Y , :i #?4???, !) f c fi? . r1 .. ? ti? '`. ._j; :. r., .{., ;5 i??,d f,.{?: "i°'-.l;ra. :L?. u.rf,: ?'y. ?'.i 7• r' rt? r ?r ,.. '/' ,)'.-? ! ?_ '?': For 'rr .???°>," ,',F 3? d - _ l... - -a`. ? 'Y?'' ?.-f >'"+i'• ??y.: tt??{te,Yr:?"?,4Jrs.r.: `t?: ?? !J"?'r?.ti: Y.. 'a'§.r o<J. `s. (•. .. _, .r. ?'?fi. r' ,zst?,. .?'^r ?FV ,7':? ? • r.?. ?rtd.. :ir HI ,?", r• it ??' _ •?'.,. .fir 's,. .1 _ , t. • .. ?. ' n ? x .. _' ,. ,? • i' : ?` ?'1r#,J.i '.€. .i '' -'A4 `ll ,'.,1'' .;,E°?'Y,'':'f?' ?s:?f{••/,ei •F ? ? ? ? 4r. ',? ? ,r' •?P 'r...,i` !P:'•',°as°l :Yii;ti'.• :p'.'f.?d' ,?'iyn: t ..y li,, .r,' `•,,' .r.` ,t .waa,ra,l., .:yi ,° .. lr,+. f5,• ..»a-.i''Y1?.•'?."n .a .., L. ,,. ;.7d.ye .k Jt.a . .. .. <,. .J,? ?.i: ,. .. .. .. ,.. :ii',? _ , J' > ., .. %PL•. .4r r', .... ;rF .-wv'<L9ft>+ M. A:.Galbraith,'Jr. Esquire 4 r ' February 24, 1993, pa ge --2- "- i Please review and if you, have any questions -please contact the undersigned. Sinc / ly,.. eft,.. ( David M. Lee DML/ph 4?•.:.?` ,`k: Enclosure cc: Rilcheird "Harris, King Engineering .; ?, Richard R. Dimmitt Lawrence. H.'' Dimmitt, III P. S I have not. enclosed Exhibits "A" and' "Ssince you already .have .the ` DML t ?,; I 'o AH9NDHENT 'i4 _AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT dated this day of , 1997 (hereinafter referred to an the "Agreement"), by and between DIMMITT CHEVROLET, INC., a 'Florida corporation, (hereinafter referred to'as "CHEVROLET"), LARRY DIMMITT CADILLAC, INC., a Florida corporation (hereinafter referred to as "CADILLAC"), f YI.? RICHARD R. DIMMITT, individually (hereinafter referred to as •."DIMMITT"), and the'CITY OF CLEARWATER, a municipal corporation o' (hereinafter referred to as "CLEARWATER"), and WHEREAS, the above parties previously entered into an Agreement dated the 10th day of June, 1992 (the "Agreementf{) a copy of which is attached hereto as 'Exhibit "A", regarding the ' reconfiguration and rerouting of Third Avenue South as more ' particularly described in said Agreement and- Plans attached thereto, and ~ - WHEREAS, the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) by letter dated August 27, 1992, a copy of which is attached hereto 'as Exhibit "8", is requiring certain O'Special Conditions'O be, satisfied }before issuing.a connection permit. authorizing the opening of Third Avenue South on to U.S. Highway 19 North, and WHEREAS, the special conditions cannot be satisfied on conditions acceptable to CHEVROLET, CADILLAC, and DIMMITT, and WHEREAS, the FDOT currently has plans to construct an overpass and crossover at the intersection of Third Avenue South and,U.S. Highway 19 North in the near future, and WHEREAS, upon the completion of construction of'the overpaso by FDOT at,the intersection of Third Avenue South and U.S. Highway 19, the Special aonditionsrraised by FDOT in their letter attached horeto as•Exhibit "B", will no longer'be'applicable to'the project' since Third'Avenue South will, upon completion.of construction of - - the overpass, open onto an access road'and not directly'on to U.S. Highway 19 North, and 1 ' WHEREAS, the parties realize need for, Third Avenue south,to be -improved as sat forth in-the Plans will not actually occur until such tiiae as the overpass and crossover is constructed at the .l ?.S FSa s.i'; , ti!F s i.sn5 r '`yF' :4?' ?" :t}IS't?<n!•g'?' 'rr ,tH .1 a r: ? ?'r t T d,?' ,e ' I I I , ?vw ' nr intersection,of Third Avenue South and U.S.' Highway 19 North, and WHEREAS, the parties desire to proceed with that portion of the project an act forth in the Plans the Plane for rerouting Third ". V Avenue South east of. Hain Street at thin time so that the existing regulatory permits for the Plans do not"expire, and WHEREAS, the CITY by Ordinance No. 5266-92 has already .•' approved (subject to certain' conditions) the vacation of."that portion of Main Street south of Third Avenue South and all of Filth %r Avenue South as provided in the ordinance, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "C"; , THEREFORE, the parties hereby stipulate and agree to amend the ' Agreement as follows: 21 - ,.? 1.' Upon Pinellas County approving the"vacation of a portion of Fourth Avenue South and the rerouting of Third Avenue South as set forth in'the Plans, CLEARWATER shall waive the contingencies- net forth in'paragraph 8(a) and (c) of the Agreement and'shall take all steps necessary for,the prior vacations by CLEARWATER of that, portion of Main Street and all of Fifth Avenue South as provided in Ordinance No. 5266-92-to become immediately final and irrevocable without any reservations or contingencies whatsoever and shall record proof of same in the Public Records of Pinellas county. 2. ' CHEVROLET and CADILLAC, in consideration of,the CITY ` waiving the contingencies contained.in the Agreement in paragraph s(a) and (d) and the CITY agreeing to irrevocably granting the vacation of a portion of Main Street and all of Fifth Avenue South, as provided above, agree to construct at their own cost and expense, the road improvements for Third Avenue South west of Main Street to U.S. Highway 19 North as set-forth in the Plans by King Engineering attached to the Agreement at such times as the overpass and crossover to be constructed 'by FDOT at the intersection of - - - - Third Avenue South' and. U.S: Highway 19 North are completed, provided that all necessary regulatory permits-are issued for the Plans as drawn without additional conditions'or exceptions. 3. CHEVROLET and CADILLAC's obligations to construct Third Avenue South west of Main Street to U.S. Highway 19 as provided' M 2 r '-' :I ;r?.; fit. ,i .. ?i•.• . . Y• r , s.E • it ?'?:. t r. r , , a. h`? {f?p, vPY. ^ , ` '!? .` • 1 ? '• 1 y f f • I ' r f? e" ' ' , ? ' f ? ? a ' s ta . • i i % herein is expressly contingent upon Pinellas county first vacating that portion of Fourth Avenue and Pinellas county authoriz.ng the rerouting,of Third Avenue South east of Main Street according to ` the Plans, upon terms and conditions' acceptable to CADILLAC and CHEVROLET, all applicable permits. being granted, and the construction being performed.. -.' 4. In the event Pinellas County fails to approve the vacation of a portion of Fourth Avenue South within a reasonable period of f },' time and the rerouting of Third,Avenue South* as set forth in the Plans, this Agreement shall be null and void. 5. 'In the event Third Avenue South realignment'is completed '. ,,. east of Main Street but the overpass at the intersection'of Third' Avenue South And.U.S. Highway 19 is,not constructed by.FDOT within ,i seven (7), years from-the date hereof, this Agreement and Amendment, ' null and void. to Agreament L -' 6 This Agreament-contains the entire understanding.between ='.rt 7o the parties and cannot be amended unless done so in writing signed ' by, all .parties. 7.' The provisions of the Agreement not in conflict herewith F. r shall remain in full force and effect. , F Witnesses: DIM41TT CHEVROLET; INC. By: Lawrence H. D mmltt, III President LARRY DIMMITT CADILLAC, INC. Sy: President F RICHARD R. DIMMITT, individually. CITY OF CLEARWATER s s gy; r (T tle) ;r, DIM2s. ?? r i I , ' • I • e 1 , ' , ? f ,. ' e. - x ' • l st. F"?ff,•i.'f':tYF.,•tM`?.'.•')iyiSi.:,y?`, k,,3•S'F 7fSF_.}4 fo "J ,tip .F?(7 {'.'?'Y'? f Now l .4 • ' ? ENT -- . , THIS AGREEMENT dated thia'L day otjfar"clf, 1992 "(hereinafter referred to as the ','Agreement"), by and between DIMMITT CHEVROLET, , INC., a, Florida corporation (hereinafter referred to as f "CHEVROLET"), LARRY DIMMITT CADILLhC,,INC., a Florida corporation rt r (hereinafter referred to as "CADILLAC"), RICHARD R. DIMMITT, s individually (hereinafter referred to as "DIMMITT", and the CITY OF i y` CLEARWATER, a municipal corporation (hereinafter referred to as 1 "CLEARWATER"), and " ;. WHEREAS, CHEVROLET and'CADILLAC lease and operate automobile dealerships on real property located in the City of Clearwater, as ' mare particularly described on the plans prepared by King f E:rigineering. Associates, Inc. entitled Third Avenue South, Job 12039-002, (hereinafter referred to as the "Plans"), 'a copy of which nice attached hereto as Exhibit "A"; and 'F WHEREAS, RICHARD R. DIMMITT is.the owner of the real property ' described in the PLANS as the DIMMITT CADILLAC site; and WHEREAS, Third Avenue South runs east and west between the !s.: automobile dealerships of CHEVROLET and CADILLAC; and - WHEREAS, Third Avenue South intersects with U.S. Highway 19 and the Florida Department of Transportation ("F.D.O.T.") presently intends to construct an overpass and interchange at the junction of r U. S., Highway 19 and Third Avenue South; and ? WHEREAS, Third Avenue South is currently an unimproved road right of way; and WHEREAS, CHEVROLET previously entered into an agreement with CLEARWATER to improve a portion of Third Avenue South lying between U.S. Highway 19 and Chautauqua Avenue (formerly Main Street), as more particularly set forth in that cartain Articles of Agreement . dated' September 17, 19037„ a copy of which is attached hereto. as, Exhibit "B"; and 'WHEREAS, Third Avenue South east of.Chautauqua Avenue and the real property described in the PLANS lying cast of Chautauqua Avenue are not located within the city limits of Clearwater, but EXHIBIT A ?'. , .?`-ji:?:1f!!' y r ! ~''!. F fit? ..•ty?{(k \'`kS t f ' ` , ' I ' f 1 •} 1 j ,? ' rr rl t k`'}: .y ?J• •'i^'} ` . ,I .. ' l•.i'b..r„! i r s ., ,. . . , ? instead lie in the unindorporated'part of Pinellas County; and WHEREAS, Fourth Avenue South is located entirely in the _ unincorporated part of Pinellas•County; and °.. WHEREAS-, DIMMITT and CADILLAC are desirous of consolidating the CADILLAC dealership,site and operations; by having that portion of Chautauqua Avenue lying South of Third Avenue South, and all of Fifth Avenue South, vacated by Clearwater, as well as having' Pinellas County vacate a portion of Fourth Avenue south, so as to allow•the realignment of Third Avenue South as more particularly ,described and 'set forth 4n the PLANS attached hereto as Exhibit oAr? and _ 4 - WHEREAS, CLEARWATER is desirous,of having Third Avenue South ; paved and-improved between U.S. 19 and Chautauqua Avenue according' to'the specifications as•set•forth in the PLANS.attached hereto as , Exhibit "A", and is in agreement with and fully supports the 'proposed realignment of Third Avenue south 'east of Chautauqua r 'Avenue and the vacation of a portion of Fourth Avenue South and } Firth Avenue south, as more particularly set forth'in the,PLANS attached hereto as Exhibit "A", it is THEREFORE, stipulated and agreed as follows: 1. CHEVROLET and CADILLAC shall at their own expense, subject to the terms and 'conditions hereinafter set forth, cause Third Avenue South to be paved, realigned, and improved according to the specifications as set forth in the PLANS attached hereto as Exhibit "A". CHEVROLET and CAOILLsAC shall, by separate agreement, apportion the cost of said improvementu between themselves. 2. Richard R. Dimmitt, subject to the terms and conditions hereinafter set forth, shall dedicate.to Pinellas County additional " road right-of-way for. Third Avenue South east of Chautauqua Avenue in order. to realign Third Avenue East of Chautauqua Avenue, as more particularly act forth on the sketch attached hereto as Exhibit 3.. Richard R. Dimmitt, subject to the texma and conditions ! hereinafter set forth, shall grant a drainage and utility easement to Pinellas county on a portion of Lot b and Lots 27 through 32, ? 2 1 r- r rr L w , '? =41. 1.f'1 6. e „ 14 . 41 , ' i tis r r , s f r . ,. f ' • r 1 I' If• f +r ' , 1 r Block 35, unit I, Section A, Chautauqua "On The Lake", as set forth ' r on the sketch attached hereto as Exhibit "'d".'Richard R. pimmitt, subject to the terms and conditions provided herein, will also dedicate a drainage easement to Pinellas County the East 25.00 feet of'Lots 6 and 27, Block 36, Unit 3, Section A, Chautauqua "on the Lake"t as recorded, in Plat 'book 9, page 146, public. Records of _ Pinellan county, Florida,, and as set forth in the sketch attached hereto as Exhibit "E"'. f.'. 4. CLEARWATER, at its own expense, upon the terms '.and conditions contained herein, agrees to vacate as soon as possible ' j that section of Chautauqua Avenue lying south of Third 'Avenue ' South, as more particularly set`forth on the PLANS attached hereto as Exhibit "A", and all of',Fifth Avenue South, reserving a twenty, (20) loot easement for existing sanitary sewer lines and a fifteen ' (15) foot easement for existing water lines. r 5. CLEARWhTER agrees to cooperate, join in, and support DIMMITT and'CADILLAC"s request to'Pinellas county to realign Third Avenue south and to vacate,that portion of Fourth Avesnue'south as ' more particularly set forth in the PLANS attached hereto as Exhibit "A", subject to appropriate easements being reserved for existing _ water (15 foot) • and sewer' lines (20 foot) lying in "a portion of . said vacated road right'of way. CLEARWATER agrees to support and .•'f join in if necessary any application for permits with Pinellas County, Swiftmud, and/or the Florida Department of Transportation " in connection with the construction sot forth in the PLANS attnchad " hereto as Exhibit'"A". " 6. CLEARWATER agrees to grant all necessary permits for construction a''s set forth in the PLANS attached hereto as Exhibit "A", subject to the roadway, drainage, and utility elements of the construction plan meeting the standard requirement of CI.EARWATER. 7. The parties agree that. upon 'execution of this Agreement by all parties, DIMMITT shall 'then execute the legal instruments required pursuant to paragraphs 2 and 3 and deliver said original instruments to be held in escrow with David M. Lae, Esq. of Macfarlane, Ferguson and not released except as specifically not i. Z sal'". '+['• r•?, .r '.,,1' .?'r Vi. r ?•i forth herein. r 6.- CLEARWATER's vacation of that portion of Chautauqua Avenue lying south or Third Avenue South and all of Fifth Avenue south shall be expressly contingent upon the following conditions having ' been met or waived in writing by CLEARWATER: .,. (a) DIMMITT executing the legal documents, as r:ot forth in paragraphs z and 3 above and delivering said documents in escrow as provided in paragraph 7 above. E` (b) Pinellas county's vacation of Fourth Avenue south ? and. acceptance of the proposed realignment of Third `f - Avenue South as net forth in the PLANS attached hereto as '. '. Exhibit "A". (c) The Third 'Avenue South road improvements and, 3 realignment between U. S. 19 and Chautauqua Avenue as set forth in the PLANS boing constructed,' completed, and r accepted by CLEARWATER and the appropriate regulatory ;t agencies which have issued construction permits. 5. Notwithstanding any provisions of this Agreement to the :r> . contrary, in the event that within nine. (9) months from.the date . '''? this Agreement is signed by all parties CLEARWATER fails to approve - L the vacation of.Chautauqun Avenue and all of Fifth Avenue South an provided herein, or Pinellas county and/or the Florida Department of Transportation fails to agree to the realignment of Third Avenue' South as set' forth in the PLANS and/or Pinellas County rails to r' - vacate the portion of Fourth Avenue South as set forth in the PLANS or Pinellas County and/or any regulatory agency requires terms and conditions which. are not 'acceptable to CADILLAC, CHEVROLET or DIMMITT, then DIMMITT, CHEVROLET, and CADILLAC each reserve the right to cancel this Agreement upon ten (10) days written notice to - - CLEARWATER. CADILLAC, CHEVROLET, and DIMMITT reserve the right, in their sole discretion, to extend this nine 5 month deadline for an additional ninety (90) days. DIMMITT, CHEVROLET, and CADILLAC F also reserve the right to cancel this Agreement in the event the r':S required permits'from the applicable regulatory agencies are not obtainable' upon' conditions satisfactory to them 'in their sole 4 ' 4 ; t, A "j, _ ?. I !Ll l ? r ' • • Jib ' F II ' ' '. i I'I . 1 1 '. f j , r?• ,. , ... 'e F • A a'i a ""_ .? '?i. ."s+'l. ? , r discretion. In such event, the Escrow Agent, upon receipt of such notice, in authorized to immediately return all original documents held'ln escrow. purnuanc to this agreement to DIMMITT, without further notice to any other party. In the event of cancellation of this Agreement as provided above, the vacation by CLEARWATER of that portion of Chautauqua Avenue South of. Third Avenue South and all of Fifth Avenue South shall also be null and void. DIMMITT and CADILLAC agree to cooperate in execution of any documents necessary to cancel the vacation of Chautauqua Avenue south of Third Avenue South and Fifth Avenue South in the event of a"cancellation of this Agreement. _ w . 10. In the event of the cancellation of this Agreement as =__•: provided; in paragraph 9 above, nothing herein shall be deemed a waiver by CLEARWATER or CHEVROLET of any of their respective, rights pursuant tc'the Articles of Agreement dated September 17, 1987, a' copy of which is attached hereto as-Exhibit 11. Terms of Escrow.- The original documents as set forth in paragraph 2 and 3 shall be hold in Escrow by David M. Lee of Macfarlane Ferguson-upon the following-terms: ' (a) In the event of cancellation. of this Agreement as 1 provided by paragraph'9 above, Escrow Agent is authorized to / release and return all original documents to DIMMITT upon r.+=,•II ". receipt of written notice of cancellation of the Agreement from either DIMWIT, CADTLLAC, or CHEVROLET and this Agreement shall be null and void. ;I (b), Escrow Agent is authorized to release the original " document described in paragraphs 2 and 3 above and record same in the Public Records of Pinellas County,. only upon completion of the following conditions: - - (1) Vacation of that portion of Chautauqua Avenue and Fifth Avenue South by CLEARWATER as. provided in,the PLANS. (2) Vacation by Pinellas'County of a portion of Fourth Avenue south according to the PLANS. _ ,. 1 (a) Completion of construction and' the ' ? = i " ,? ,- ,{' .'? i • , i 1(( • .?'.. {lt .ein5? .. '1 ', t: { • : 7 1:: ::a ? 'F ri : .. .. . .seirrr .. . ?c , e , •. ,. . ....« ? 6 t J, , r . realignment of Third,Avenue South as not forth ' in.., the' PLANS and acceptance of said _ realignment by Pinellas County:. (c) All parties agree that the Escrow Agent's duties are ministerial in nature, and Escrow Agent shall incur. no liability whatsoever,' except for willful misconduct or grass negligence, Should a controversy arise with respect to this _ escrow agreement or the rights of any party hereto, Escrow Agent shall have the right in its exclusive judgment to .f commence an action or proceeding for the determination of the controversy,, including, an action in the nature of interpleader, in which' event escrow Agent is authorized, to deliver all documents in-escrow to the registry of the court which shall automatically release and discharge Escrow Agent of all further obligations or responsibilities,in this matter. 12'. ,• This agreement contains the entire agreement between ; the parties and cannot'be altered or' amended unless done in writing. sign ed by both perti'es. , i Witn esses: DIMMITT.CHEVROLET, 9140. ?? . ` /-! . ? • 7a Bye Lawrence H.- D mm mitt, III ' ??..c ?. `i +r .. President LARRY DIMMITT CADILLAC, INC. B : y •" '}?'+?.1 President <: 'arc ,/ .rc:rr ICj ARD DIMMITT,. individually F . CITY F CLEARWATE Sy ? ' M chael J. Wr g City/ Manager .. ' 1 ' f • r 1 YS ` ' E ' i' r ' .. ' ' ? ' je.• E ' -?' ' ` , . .ib ,!' ,elf. •t', ,'ie = '+,; Ie ;r ?,4 , ? a } f s• Y it°i 3' 1'k. s,S°'~'4.::x.757: t'?`-T a°"'Y. •t, '•prt .a': 11,1.. r., .p-.,.,.: ,,,tr oa --.J. ,r.r., -r: T,.'t<.'r :a?ri, 'i FK.. ;n ._3 3' r: ..Y.. . i'it . 3y, '" ,? <f_y r••s, ,t,° . ,' IeJSF,I•' .! • .y:: }i •! ' .1°. i 'i., ''`t.' n,: ' . V •,7 - „ .1a3':. '"?'. - e, 1,. 't+u ?,. .rd<.,,:'s P.Eirf•((•.gr. ?`,,r;.,ti^,t r°'i i . , , , ,"' j „E.< W 04.,1,?ott? iP',- I .?'., ;.J ,: N.4.{, ', ?,: ,'?,. .r :ry r' I ! : ,?.' `,? ?f [ ?r i""i: J'? :J(';i?•.'r ' (( ; j',S ` > J, ' r ,, ;' j, f'`' ,,'. ..4,` P :t. i',.. 'J`C' a.... ?' e; t,Y, w,}rin ? Aal r''',r, [' Ir:: ` I: !r ,: 3 1' `r J, 4; { {;1 .°' ,.dash 'i7 .r4 , p -4 '- '! •/ t c .. ,. ,. i:'r r ',+//*,. t?R :% ' r [{ ,{:' Y' r.€, ,. r.r? or ?. ,! .. r " I . . ,`i• 11 ,. 2.'?rr j; t-! t. ,:_'{t '°i ° !?, ;r;' js• ", -, .J, ,,' r' - ,I = y, #I'+a r °` c I } ' 3' ? / :t' :e Il 4 i i ' F' , 'j n' !° ,.•a.,, r° r 't'.r ?F / .. _4 .Y, I +,'r ?.'el '`1 ei,I. .4' ,r•.: ,'i: '?" ' r ;I r.r 1'` `l! . .'. 5. ?; ,'SI'• y?yf:; l';f%?t+1 fi ,- i' •a^'`P.•/t??it '.1 t rr., .4 ,Vv.. ftat •,': ,};r w. ,i.'"`. yr,... .j, , j - ,I ! , '.t.. :.1[' ,-' '. ";?{?=y I,'Y '1: 4J' ;?a. 'r. .[, Y • T I F : f .Y. ,rf.( ?r i, YYr;J'?.,1 ;6'r' I, I . )?j 'f.. :r;} f ' , . . :f• " yyr. ff44la- :t ?•:i-?< 1 r , . ,1 I?. .'I' '?d;lj'+i ".. '1.. :, , ,rJ>'' i•.. ,f" y f. I . •.y 1 .` , I .•, E' .'rI ,1. -.i ;iit.:e. .;rr :K-t. ''I r.,t}. .°°'?- .c I`,,'.. )rf '.o' •?'• ''e,,? •r,7l,:ji" ' S • A 1`':1i' I j ' 4j'%'A ' ; . 1! _ .;'j, .. `, r' ,' ' '.'.• '4't. = F •3 ' •.??' } '' .?i: -;f? ,Sr.S YY ! b. 1.11: •(' `, i' .i 'r.e: ',;_ .t?rd, f 3.' ;. x„' °F +ti,sr, ',})' °', - refF "" ., y:4I' ' ;k": ; , , '?' ; am , . S P: a ,j ..1 ,i ??• . .'! •1 'I S, 1?'k., kit, ;;?? :. fh ' ' , l • pAI??? ` • I! ° a f ' '9 ?'ir '' ' a ?`j..,, l ','. -d.;i, .,i ',{ . .,II ?q = ''f•'' l !z` !J' ,' '1 •'f.• : r:r 'z' r':r '.t i,'t''.e. Z' : e.?- l' I- ;,i r ' f °., . T: ,4,6 r.".. .Y.. Pr?, c r., F}.S'i.' g- •4 -`A^ f. 1, .it,;7 €'' •j` rE- .r.°.e• r'• 'F . ?."r• ''i,a. 31{%?''?.'c t';.s r. a?. ,. ? . • ?•• ' •?4: I`. ! {. "}. , °S',:,. r i E 1•' ." 7 - c. r•.r1.?; ?.•; !t • r' `,L{ _ :,t I'' .SY" '-1,•J _ °.' • .1„ ._aa , x.r.1:i ' i C'''"'r?lt' -.i'J' - . I .17"4'' '!- ? X4.1,,• J '.J. - ;,'?.' :.< [r' '.`.,i' :,?•`1 :f r, ([? (i. } ti• 1.I< 1 r'J,, ?#,' 3 r-y• 4 rIS'' .i',..' !-1''.: i's`.'seT' -,I_ t": v`': ;F ..4 ./' P • la ?'. -at1 ' e N 4j, 'U'.i ,?'? ',. d. S J1 :11 ''ti'er' -?. , !d',v : ?,?:' [l "t `Ve.' s ` r d 1 ° 1•r ' i v} r r. :: . .'sa^S. 4; .•w• ,I-rt= , ,, ,•t.? •r, := .4.. ' `1.1 '? .? - 'J'.f a'l IIV S5: .f .1• •l ?'L'.d". r• ois !! ' .I' p •I•S•'1-1 .,1' Y °S• •P' !€•,!)) .Li.'3 r'?.q.'•,l' , ?df e! v; y:: ?n yy .' y" -!i ,t ti`f!' . ( I . • A [ '1 ' 'r .€ .J/ : i '•!1 , J k .i'1 ' i ,.a, 1i S,P"i' l'J ? '? . 11 +' ; 5, rk-";.:;'•:r ,,,,:i l" ! , 1-" 1 ,.lr J! '[1 _ ' 7. '(7 .f , ,it . . :t,. .f' _ "' , '' J.t ' 3° f /I jj ! 1. r p: :y r ''°r, •.S`; -S' .r J:! ', r ,. , ?.- j. '. ! Z. E.' r J. , ' ' S'{,.-5': 1.'? 'f'.' .•i=. i<:'°v(:`• •jj? ''?c?,"f' ;, . ,i : is . , . f:l l :4, I $ E,i i 4:'y• ;1 1:P1' _! a 5, • 7. a'" r , ^)' J t. ..t , . '<'-f. •`tf , (1'• i', E .$,, t'} ' r: ?-{ :;r,,1 .J.• {.: .J Iw}r }?f '"?.,' 'fi'r :}' rid. " ° ? 'ti ,t .J.: ^ , t' .. ''! I„.., r? :'[ - kr,9; '•'if'' Y 'S ??' ` ? '. - e. 14 : r' .,,A ° ki"1:i,.;? . .? : ,, r Ja: • y r . ,`e:' <'y? :'11 .>?. rF * 3 ;t„ w E r .' i . ?{ Y ] >i, y.r, r t"' i r. +•J'' °e ,'i= ?I, :i. ', .6: ;i,. i,,;. ,rN ...?'g-'"'w. - rp`" .S :a ,r .-i•.l?i,J k a l?- !l' ,P'Ff" !4-!.`? 1•Z' pi; 3i "lr s' _ .4 1 j1,'? ?i.,., 11 r, 1, ,i:t.`.-T :f !.a.? ,rr ,`. "JJ'a.' t,: r?''!? 1,{j .p. F+y f. ''P' .f' 'h. 4 S .:I ,'• i. I>fr.2rir,C .r 'r..`.?:,1'., ,:1.? :t:....3. ;f, s .°'t^F..' 1,i ' r.y,d.4l..:.: ?' :. ?..>:,!,LtazJ.?l@ r+r.r iv, ,;',..1 ,'.r;,.,'.,,,:?-i.i, , :d ..,.4,,Kf'046, } s..el: ... r... ,<;:r, _ , r ''?.. r..... ?,.,1 s 'SJfi.:, •., r .. .1 , . . ' .r r , . I r i,I- Attest: &or?si d: f . > .. is ,,, , ''= b , ; Cynt a . E. Gou eau Mayc R to . Ga Vey 'r` ". ' City Clark ' Approved- as to form and •' ,t., 'I','L f correctness' . %f , e .. F' . ?,% ,"%,,' • M .A. Galbra th, r., r `fit .Y;.;, q[:` :, , . "... ? . I : ? I city. Attorney .. ', r " • ' ' ,_"i ?` ,. r - a :S 1 1-''' :i . f4 :f , , , :f;rw' .. t. 3 ' rt -r. r'? ?t. •9.. -ir. " 4Y?,LI }} `i, . .4 , d , °d . - 1 - ', "7, .'J• ,•ie, '•1J1 J` ' j .. , t ,t fir', 'r iRi? it r. 4', `. ' 11' .! r : f• , . , f'! ' 1"i4f 'r• ,?„ ,:Jr 5 .. , k J J", 3 :J r"!'+gq11r1?} s'r,A , .•t } Aoreelnent:3rd•Ave2.Di? . f I .. % "1' 1'' ,,I .F '! ';• • + ' ' ' ,. , - ti' ' .. j r'1.. ." t Yy,. t., S : . , yr ..?, ., . t . , , F f n7 ? f r.. - "I . 1 r 1•,. F.:.: 1 # r. ?f , - -J . , .,,,:?. f". ,l 11• . •r,, : ,. '•t, .,,' .i - - .. ,4; :?.:> r ii , s;':. . i' i 'S. ,ai?r{r:; r.'- ,.'.I - rI ' - „ .r - j'''" •f• Q0.. rx[Y. .[.- `? °rr+ " r,'Js,r r.,;' A _ ,j` .! .r '!, h11T ` ,. .,. r F 'i' '? ) r :a' rr f ry "t.. 2 ,.,:--i :. (. ';? r*F?S/SS?:,ir7f? Nt• ,a V,S ,°r'i''n W ra,r';ir F,l,ae _•ji 'v0 r:,?...tv' t'. xv•+ t? - ,S7 ?-il p-M'-e I .=a<, ? YS„aS'r•', _?. l-d' ,Al '(••x, :.t, 2•?'. '{ "r"I F. ;•, ,,?,,!.'y',IS_ .:: s"cyl.'`ry-f,.nIJ.4•f j4Yr'.!'. '•flr} ?tie,£rl'I sf }?` 4, I`.,i l,r±?''.i'.t, ., .i at'R 4rg,l' y`d;1':50 ;!r.:'• .Y-':A .:i,r,r .,a•, r`J,1 :•- :1.. Fr,r. ?'M,?:;-., r.?,' -,7Se':,!+!i'r''i'+•."?.5?,4L''f`Rt?'?r E?,t}} r' - f , / i '•L,'y,. .,.y i +,tiS'.. 'a?"'' iF '? Y:¢ . '''r .I I ,,.. ", d` "?, di ., a A; 4: f.., E L sA` wr. Id'', r r ,1,Z.I ,K - _ !f - °'! ";3`,• 1' 4 • .5.:;.R, • -' y§, L 4'-? ::i i • r, . .i ' , f. f,.,.,; b `;;. n2{ ?x,r r'- f • f`: ''r?:. } qq,? °''1, +4'r ??2-,-14-. r'n ,' .f 1 'i - . •--,f." -1 S'. °•" •'j"tt .S?L M °e 9JN.D: ., 1, i'?j ` 1 r '>Xrt' E'r ..s , -' LL l' 'i, !.i'i. ` ' ' v?' a : I `Ifs ., :.{. .., `T?. %1,t,.--L - t t.,t,: J, I . :1.;.1'• •!•' ?, "I ,5 ' -1 ? 'r ` • IA 1 E,. °idt •.-", Nit.r?: ?' , ii, I', 7 rirr'J.. l.. `:}? ,i. Ji. A'r r. tt ,'r` •r L, `f., `'1:,.F=1,.,•rA'y;yl, 'ye fryY' .Y ,4 '•' SI. • 31 .,r'k r , I' . '? /- . ,-i ?ei i,.f L je?17., .': .?. , ,• ...•'9';•'t -} 1 ?t? i'kk • •i'S 4' `` : .'t f ` ,; ..-fit - I. ?: i.' f . t •?`'. I? '-?': ` ,fr' f': I . N,x ..! 'ty.' t . 1. ,fi .IL, +1.`,'' i r _ f! ; I I :2s •a' 1; L EN,f:.•?its'i ip „ .r .: •, :?•'f ,AS• 3.t l: .;. .r r• y'#i,1? . .•ela , ?• ,'f '.a t. f *A . I,J :? .;rL . , :il'f+1,?• . .'q, .3 ?a'NT{i .?Yi V",• 1 I - ,-R:., l ..{ ?Si?+ •1, .I' :I ..L .' .,? .j J' ar l._ ,31'.Els:, r iF,.ti .. i.L l§'. "J. '''' ;.,-`tl'I,,,.. d- -, °l: `, "yV;'' , .I" s '•1, ?` ,y,•r,., , ?r,` t {4 ?' 'f °St• a 4 1f.., .Y' - f'I' ' , ,? : / .f r. (: .,? k ` f?,.i >YE, .. ?.: '.t ,t a.. ?s !.: ,t, .! k'Srt<r J' ,'J, X ? , Y r r' 't l"s .::vi: _Y, , / ,s ' it• :; }^s.i' L' .. ,? 110;1..] } }". .'8 r t a; %f t ..`,' ,, i t': ?r , i `.. 4.,C<s,-1,- i=i,' ^Y r tl,,?. Y:• 61, s:. j•. `?, ;', ,'fp. r .:` .f. `'r "J;,: is C .f,t r i, 11-&- .+r. x . _.klr a t . 1i= `e , 1 : `d S' i',I ?. r.r. l i '/ '}. T E..•`1'?s ::ca•• s%I.i:,° 'i :?' 3 i ter" 'i' '3, l; '1 .E?,,y!:r ,fi r 'p. ;i:'. !+ ; ; r:' a•1; ',tae' 1.i . ,>:, ,S ??. ;,t1'`;S:• { sf., ',J ,., .'r.r 1 ?;. ',i'.` .y' .j;d 'a ' T ie,_ ,I ,it, f. r - F,f'i,i „ . .# . ."1• ; _ l.:1 ; h • •.e. ' •?2?N.f L.,1 F' f?.r':' 'k. '!` '/, ?,Y'' ,3' .d •. "r• .IE}'.3r 111- e`? .n },: ...T"{, ,f. :fi Y',i,.. ;X '?-1. J.. t r rt' ',.i Ik': s r:r .k, :'I! :??i dr11' f t. ,-f' ;n 'i's I • 1 :Yr" sx .,,1 (41 61.." "' f' hF`Sf. °.)•?, wi`.5?,',.tn °f• .{ •,{'r r `. I., :.I'-. fry i' ,l:,'V Y`, S. r•2'" ? Vii. 'a, _ .. y i +f e' e, S ? . ?, ?IS -, rf. r?"r.' :b% ?+',J.> '.?.? .•.r k > y , ?,,'''°•.; - • 1o- , yg,'„i .l' ,? ,-,; .yb {.4. s. :i;,; ?.; j" H.,y, i"t _ •r' .J',I• -r' :1•i'- I: ,:,':. .r., (.•,.<. 1 ^i,,f f: .(: - Ai ; r iJ w^ § V,T'.?(, '7.. '-4 sfi0" +'.}? w?".,J` 7: ^! 'r. fI .`''.` }`• -«r 'e: v '.- :r ,?s rl -P S, i` r sY it* :', r •'•'YT;': ,t 11. -1;`' ,q /:• ..'i •f"' .4 :-[ 'P•3: .\' V .} , t. •1•' 11 ,.?' A' ' E,' ,.'y, ; ,T, 4a':'"' tiri' r {r. j, '",,; s.' f .J it S'1, ;, 1.. kA, h'r_ .F. t'1 !i 1 r }, '?."'..'?',2 . h!t?f?.,.'-a. ,r.. •?}; y.:Z i .`A'r• :,'t °.j•? .i.r.•^J ?' •'i?' i. l..'')•. w.. -4-,.,;-',. .`. ,,.r•t1 ?4' ? :r - ' ? f, ,f. .,"t{ '3':' J??. ?I `;-11 ''elf' •.n r,e`? ft_ '?3 'i?f.?,>?:?? h""11 4i•,t}i, :-i b r 1:.33. .r. .1 `1, ? .t ,s _ ' t •1 i f ;. E.?." >•i- .:}?- • r.l {E,l z :•t'1 r.t<, -r'.:r.?. /• .r : J IL ,,J' .'3{ '7, "„t ; { r•'ti . { '•- °' d ", ., •• J ' ", ' f'<`:-' k ,i+ f A •$, .-1' ri.,,,°.: ? ' a' snI-r', < ,r:'or ':?,I%. .?V,.ata ?'r'I'' .*", ?£'r;?- f_ ' 'r: 4,M. ?,°.'tf .l,f ': ?, Jr "'t' a •r o i d ' r i. 11 r -: . ?'L?l fw,"t1 -' ' ' fY? SF v5.: J. 1''ti .f,I ° Ai/°1FI },' `! rtti SA''..1°Y. r ' ,ri '3 "3` ii-y'4f. .'t nfi. •"f •?,•'1' r 7 r ?? ?f J'. •1 • '1. rY- J .. 1r .n f r'i`'A''i .1 :1.. ! y J• a?? . n' , fir. '} c= Yt '%" ?' ',f r n1.` p ,r 4 'r'>< r r,.": t/rF 11 ] µ x?. 4 { i N '?/ik lfYv.1 r '.C•?'. l!8?'•..H -''yy xT` t[( '- ':tr+:?.'.i?`1., .1f:Y:3? ,r.. ]' ' - .:4n. 1'`1 `.'? '.' I a +I 'ef.;?>' rL ? yet 4:,.,.... . i. Y rMi?' r '•5. k.t bJ.I Gt?.'Y.'u w.n J'?. T rj1,Y'd w, -'?i f S'LS.,'..T I . t A „ , I d ,3 f., ' f'f , ... F , .'? .. J 1 ,1 I 'F. , r ,?? ' r.S , ot f ` I .I' .r s'Ip,` - ? ' ... o- °AI,k '., •p ,S• F I, r 'r }. ''. , A• i 'r r. .L•. 'yam [ j,.,,,,• y J I[I. 1: 11. p4n w , a ?0. " ? 4 ..Q - I - ` :I - ? I , - - , ? . . " . I . , - " ?Zi? e i i, is )tt ! , , .,s r f ,. , J " ,.du 41 ih:,'4'/. :',.... ".i .-...r' ._ :.'..... ..,-" .-.:. :f :? ` _ ... r - . ,`'. .` -I'.. " ., , "' ° .. .. .. - { e r. n.... , ._ . .. ' 1'I::. - ° 21 ,, r 5","i. - Lr ?w'ir`i;`rJ"r • 7. -, S • • , . - ".e '-. a 3:. =+•i:" . i 5.ccct.,,,3??? `a .iq.; r I 1's ,r :I c. 'e' r" ?: d, ywa •Wsf , T - O'. . ?,r d .3i I .I. '1' '.'. ,,: x•,t' .r..,,.. i.; .4r L.4. _ '.T: ,Y ', "f' . ,... ,,`.. , ,l. .r -. 1 .r•.. y'. .4..'. ,. .f.,,, -4. •I" .t S ;rr,.'--_"t i' r.. , r;l r 1F- it E' l' '/ r .,,? t•.!' r" 54- I ?, «'•°•:i. ' J ? . . 4 r ''tt I.7' 1': "7. T :: A' "' .Ir {f' -s" P' , , ?. etfP,1t;'d.•F`1. '.i .1?•,3 r•p:,. :f' ,r, fa" .3%.:I...i r j S'..: .I. -- ra7 :.'' i' ,. . (: , ' :.'i .1 ? r. : r :o S4,-r, a ' '.r t" s1 :.i I t' e, s° y.' •.F'?.1`I - t Y• J ' '1 • It a' Cii ir.'i,' ,x• 1.', (" i r' i. :'• •r ° : . y. 9 •*• e f. l °i : / 'r.' • So f r : t A r 5,` ,, r, r?? .r r ` i : n ?' ' ,1 ° • f , ! r.y . f r' f { •rJ t f •,} , ?r : i'I it 1' 1 ae ,'r' , , r' A 7 t' I. f J. 3' '•'1 3: - 1 r i I e Y' 1 i " ye .r. 'r' '3'! [ ,4 f? ' f ? r. r • ,? _ Y' ?v x t 'i' .: d?Tt i'1' 1.;, .•k. g , Y ., E Iaf?: '.? , -. s i, r• f/`.• li n •I? .. •r'r , .ir ,' ,i, , s .{ r;i r r' r :l 5' _ r•'. !. :far'' ': 2l - ! '/ '? s,i{ °i. .'f'r t_; 'Ss l' r '`::. :'7. .7t £,w J, it -i- j; r`. - ??i, i.;- ,. a .,.1. -, , !I •L .J,, ;f. .r f,... M"5r',' ',#rS ,.YS' _ 1 I, , 1 ,. ' . ?y `r: :L/ . „ i'-T !L _'?` _ 'h °f. , •'f,' .1 Fi :rte _ r ?" '31 , j! ,,. 3 ?j ;, I:. Ir •i.F.'S., r.+ ''I ,!' 1aT', it ,,, .r - ,i '.. + L . ,J .. - J t fr:' v ,r1: Y '. •.rJi°T'v r!. 'l'. -'y. .!',,. "1•.'I '`J.? r f'r r :I,j` 'f rj?,&. ti'?`.'s :t•,-E :iL: r' j'-fix. Y'!" ,mod ,. Y: 'J , r,F - 4 I' - . ,J . ?'? ?'?'! 1 ... 9 P n which ,I ,'• Rr:, ri g'' '''' '3 •'' ; 1 : ' :J - EXHIBIT A'•is a lare: set o-f blue ri is 5 f '? _ 'J' ' '' rI I ?', ' are on- file', with 'the 'original a reamewi i 1 J ','.. 1., the city Clerk 'pe artment. r' :A•`.: •. L.a.' . r .. • }', ?tt.` ,t' t+' .•t", 1t '? ` • I,. :#., 1•ert} - II' .i 'E :'r l'I l : L'. f r - I , ., - , .. ,' rr •r` r 'r,? f, SLY' i , t t );Ez.T f. P ' iX•al•; :I .. °1 r , IF - ` ?' J. . %er° z 't:y. 5, ':,:4'F 'i t C +}]'7.9: e - ' r'. : F t s ix 1 •T' 'T •? . .11 3' . r• :!' 'i4 eS2 •I }' : ' _^' ¦ ")gz,^,:: i.':, .°,r. ^ t .`.•:..,,=.:•. w ' -.!?:t!4. .,'<,r, r-i'a ,:' 1,',? ?,5 . '}.".5.. y : `. ?•4y. a1 d„ A ,5 .'`'s •' .t :r° ''f .,S'`'`1 X1,4,'} :rs? r 'ti :, r fr,. ,. , , , ex • . :I:. r?';i:'. ' sf % Y ;y. ..i r: :' a UY'r. .r.'.` %. :`' i ' F'tp, F,¢:, .. `, ; A' ? . V hAY 85 190 Cr3l!S P.2 AIMCIZZ OF ACHEEMENT WHEREAS, on June.18, I087, the C:leh"wa ter City Commission approved a Site ? •. - Plan Amendment to the final site plan for TMIMM CIIE1'ROLET, INC., (Phaso IV of the Matter Site Plan - PSI', 83-60) relating to ccr in reai property in the City of Clearwater which Is owned by LAWRENCE ;:. I!n MITT, III and leased to Dl,%I5tITT CHEVROLET, INC.I and - - WHEREAS, the approval of the Site Plan Amendment was conditioned upon an 5 agreement to be approved by the City Comailsslon providing for the Improvement of 3rd Avenue, Lake Chautauqua Subdl4lslon, if and when the Improvement is needed; NOW, THEREFORE, tar $10.00 and other good a valuable consideration, ij. i recelpt-of which !s acknowledged by LAti1'RSNGE tV. IhiMITT, III and DI1Ih11TT CHEVROLET,' INC., the parties mutually agree ns followss 1. DIMbIITT CHEVROLET, INC., t?'Iil construct a ttva-lane toed for 3rd Avenue between U.S. 19 •and'Atain Street, Lake Chautauqua Subdivision, or a portion ihereo[, at such time as a determination Is made by tho City of Clearwatee that the aforementioned improvement Is necessary. The angineering and design of said road shell be 1hs obligation of DIMMITT Ct1EVR )LET, INC. The road shall by constructed 1 In accordance with the applicable Lily of'Clcarwnicr engineering standards for roads ! to be dedicated to the City of Clearwater, and such stormwater detention requirements aS may be imposed by other governmental agencles es a result or the road construction. 3.. Until such time a5 the road is constructed, access wlU'be permitted bstwaen the LARRY DIMI;TT CADILLAC and MINIM= CHEVROLET dealerships across'3rd Avenuel however, there will be no access to U.S. ID or to btaln Street from 3rd Avenue - by any of the dealerships operating at this location. 3. This agreement shall be a cotenant running with the land and shall bo enforceable against the heirs, successors and assigns of the property described In Exhibit "A." l-p r,? f'irKtf?.•f3? ? ' Executed this 17 {7 day of Auger, 1987. Countersigned: CITY OF?:L1:ARWATE ,t?I?CDTtI>a? ftr s ener ° ? ?-- C Fly/5 laneger Approved an to form Altssen and corraatnas C ty ttOnsa Ctty Clor" }, , • M(1II131 V' "B" w J. "'. C.. - ;.•'. to % F.' ! ?'• , r1iY 2? '9p 4356 P.3 LAIVRENCE ff.. DIAIMITT III •' Gntitir.nee A, mmitt I . ' ' . DIMMITT CHEVROLET, INC., n Florlda corporation y y/-..?• ! Lawrence 1, President _ STATE OF FLORIDA ) COUNTY OF PINELLAS BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Rita Garvey, / Anchony L. Shaen,akar. Cynthi a E. Goudeau, and M. J1. Calbra c , r. , the 518p6r- ornm s9 oner, City ,tlanaper, City C er un y Attorney, respective Y, of the City of Clearwater, Florida, to, me Viell known to be the persons who cxacutad - - -- the foregoin' agreement, and they severally acknotyledged ilia execution thereof to be their free act And decd for the use and purpose herein set forth. ' WITNESS my•and and official seal this 9th day of'.991 °um ,e1987. f r.e. a7/ Z{rGx4e1a1y Commission nxpiresi r Notary b r. i t__ - h.,..,,l.. tar r.v.ra.... .,•, ' STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PINELLAS BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared LAItiRENCE A:H' • ' DII+ AITT, III, w•ha, after being duly sworn, t}eposas and says that he Js the person described in the foregoing agreement and he_s slgnad said agreement freely and voluntarily, this 17,0% day of Aujuia, 1W. , (l1 i 1 1 t-?. My Commission Expires... Notary Pub c e t' 'STATE OF FLORIDA ) . COUNTY OF PINELLAS ) 13EFOR£ AIE, the undersigned outhorlty, pcrsanaDy appeared LAWRENCE !i. DIWIITT, III, as President of DMIA1177 CHEVROLET, INC., a Florlda"corporatIon, who, after being duly sworn, deposes and YRys that ha 1s the person described in the foregoing agreement and hits signed said hrroariont freely and voluntarily, this ? ' day of sN.?198f' 3. 1a... 1 r 1 . ' rr11^?1u - ns?r .?. My Cc+::tirlleslon Expltast T +9 . !tiz'?" ' a ary Public % % f r ' • 1 r[ ' I t J Y i 1 .' ' ' ? X11 r??•'J'' • ` . • ' , ' !b; , . THE NORTH 5.07 FEET OF LOTS 27 THROUGH 72 TOGETHER WITH ALL OF LOTS 7 AND 26, TOGETHER WITH THE EAST 15.00 FEET OF LOTS 6 AIID 27, ALL nuor. ill BLACK 36, UNIT 1, _ SECTION A, CHAUTAUQUA 10011 THE LAKE" AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 9, PAGE 52 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF PINELLAS COUNTY, FLOnXOh. 5C.&LE t 1"* 50' '2C)4 4T CM) r() rn Q f ` 'd' •?1 fJ O 10 r- Y J C 51 r2 5 .v3' - J Q 0 d 'SILL. ILCYD .01 1C349t; {M? m Si 'PREPA7MD BY: KIHG ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES, INC. TWIb 5V-E:rcw O??S Lk.)l' Q 3:ZL FER.RANS, PLS C.7t '51ITUM a-5ur<vh: FY-N. REG. HO. 3885 KING ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES, INC. axis U.S. 19 Norlh Engineers. • Planners • Surveyors Gesr Florida ]]575 (813) (E1]) 791.3??1 F C1,441JTA000A. "CLI TWE- LMa Z" d&MM by pro l n a tM [ kdi.d try LO C A l 01-.1 _. W» C TG 4 ;W ? ? l fl lo 5 RIGHT-aF- VJ&V I J .. EXHIBIT "C" ' ' r J, . ' r ,'ta .R '1`• •i.y?J;LttiJ.lf r ? • .1' ayxye K'•b': ... ,s.'l... ., . {r a i. ( .'1 e ?w^ d . l MQIL r FI 2 TS02" egyg2' 71" Lp rb,a'a ;p ' ? Q •o w Q o Y t(n 3I w 0 U ` t W44-SS60"W 14J6 I r _ 5ao•oS t r •r r t.9 r`r 3.0 ' s r R 'Loo.O' 51 R 7141'5 SKETGI+! Wn UOT Cout)TITUTE & 5URVEY. KING ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES, INC. 2145 U.S. 14 Nord; Engineers, • Planners ° Surveyors Gearwaltr, Florida 73575 ' ' ' 91.144 1 (417) 7 GHAUTA.UGiL14 'OU r THE Ll%Y-lr' draw. br L4? prp I na ahrrtl dmcktd by LOC WT lou 5V- E-rC14 lot)1-001L o+? flow book no. dal. 5• I.9 DRQIIJAGE et UTILITY t4'bfA'T. 1 EXHIBIT "D" r ? i VVV lS', f. . ? ?? a rw• ?. p'?.•S. tq, ,yrl,?i. ? ? .?? •? ?, jam.. ;r ?. r . • 1 Y I u CM) raoo'c75zh W pa'd' ' . Ib.ao' 5ou•OS'14'1= • , „' . , ,r'•1 }, .r, ; ' .'gib PARED BY: /IHG'ENGINEERXNG ASSOCIATES,-INC. t IE FERRAIIS, PIS SCls Lt??!'+'Sc3' ! FLJ1. REG. NO. 38135 -- - - MAIM 57. :r... r , 100 loo' ) to r to ? (O cD Wig' E]RA,tNA•Gt; EASM'r • .? C-i 1'- 9 • too' taO' ? w O TIIE EAST 25.00 FEET OF LOTS 6 ACID 27, BLOCK 3?,. UNIT NO. 3, SECTION A, CHAUTAUQUA "OH THE LAKE" AS _ ? _ _•. > RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 9, PAGE 146 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF PII;ELLAS COUNTY, FLORID A. i SY-eTG14 ONLY-HOT d SURVEY PREPARED FORT KEnglnearing Aasaolaiaa. Ina. L,'-E" jPGNAUTD.UQUA "ON- THE Clearwater. ' Florida °34423 . (6W) 7o1-N1! PLAM LOUMON 5iCEZCH `. 012A1ND.C3E EASEMENT ' 5CALEt OATEt ORAY44 BYt C90 BY, FB, PO. JOB 140.: SEC. TW. RGE. SHEC7 HD.t t'?5o' J 4- •9c LAg ci l.1(. 'L015A'-OD12 I OF I EXHIBIT "E" +I lei :a ?1.?f ,.i 4 . ., 1 . • , - • y t1 F, R , 1 • ?• 1 , 1 . 5yrr t . . 1: r `y ; • o M' , r FLORID LAwmK cHI S I ?tiYY.ltllofl r. ' • I a DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 604 IA. WAM D istric;t Seven s.rns?Mr M5 7-1200 - Access Management r 11201 N. M%;Kinley Drive Tampa, FL 33612 (813) 93576070 ` Aiigunt: 27, 101:721 CI;R'01 PILD MAIL: P--007-371-076 William Directo city of P. 0. Bo clearwa Re NOTICE OF INTENT TO PERMIT section No. : 15150--000 State Road : 55 (U.S. 19) Mil. post 21.280 Rt. D.O Log No.: 6902, Per it No. 15--799-92-032 P Pro ect Name! 3rd Avenue S. catigory xII YOU ARE HEREB4 ADVISED: ,The Flo ida Dgpart"ment of Transportation has completed its review of the above! referenced connection permit application pending revisio s andIrecei,pt, received'8/5/92 for consistency with Rule Chapter 14-'-99 and ' 1.4--97 F. Al. C. , and hereby' issues this "Notice of Intent o Par itn, subject to the attached conditions and special provisi ns. This notice -of intent to issue a permit will. be valid for one (1) y ar, providing that surrounding conditions have not changed signs - i.cantly. This n tice ?f intent to issue a permit does not' constitute Departm nt permit issuance, nor authorize the connection construction with Department right-of-way, but acknowledges. Department concurrence, of proposed connection subsequent -to issuanc of f1na.1 development approval by the local governmental entity, avi.nglurisdiction over the development. The De rtmen shall issue the formal connection permit after review nd con urrence that the connection complies with the intent to•pcrm t cond•tions and special provisions; that the applicant has receive development approval from the appropriate local govern .mental entity; has complied with, all transportation impact mi.tigat on' conditions specified by said local government entity; has pos ed the performance bond pursuant to. Rule 1.4--96.;006 F. A. C. ; r ' e EXHIBIT B 1 r ;t i r ' r zOd 'L10 DNId33NION3 DN17I' 6050 EGO C19 95: h1 ZO-01-2601 ti. r •. , a r:` r r t C. Baker r of Public Works Clear ater k 47481 Ler, Ff 34618-4748 pit Notice of Intent to Permit AUguat 27, '1992 Page, T o that t e appZic:ant has been issued a Drainage Permit pursuant to Rule C apter; 14-86' F.A.C.; and it dual permitting. is. used, a connection permit has been issued -from the' local permitting author ty pursuant to Rule Chapter 14--96.013 F.A.C. 'Failur by the applicant to' abide by the permit conditions and special provi0ions shall be'sufficient cause for'the Department'. to initiate acti6n to revoke said permit and close the connection cat ' the ex ense o.f the permittee. , -The ap icant, must..request the formal connection permit.in writing, allowi g thirty (30) days. for the Departmentfs review and " concur ense that.said connection' complies with the intent to permit. 'conditions and 'special provisions thereof. ''A shorter time limit , will o illy be considered with proper. r justification and must be agreed upon b the District Permits Engineer. 1 r , , BY: Richar J. aier, P.E. Distric e rmits Engineer- V RJB : bd t cc: B. A. -Benett, P.E. R. J. Ba er, P.E. M. F. Jackson J. S. Op er P. J. Lately Reading i.ie Attachm nts: 'YA" Conditions and Provisions r r • ! r eod 1[0 DN1833N1JN3. JNIN. +GCSC 288 Cie l5:bl:. ?0-0[=?66tr,, ?/(v' 1i?,; (.1• ' ? ,`!.ail' "' ?E?.' i I f ? l ? t f ATTACTEMENT "A" ¦" Condit ons and Provisions Permit no. 15-799-92-0:32 P Mie pr perty 'owner or authorized representative, her;arter called the Am 3,icant;, by providing signature on the connection application and permit document binds and obligates to abide by the access connection provision stated herein. S ecia cond"tions: 1. F gineer of Record is to provide justification for variance of tt a following Florida Department of Transportation cr3,teria: A Three hundred twenty-five feet '(325f) 'right turn deceleration lane required per Roadway and. Traffic Des igrl Standards, Index No. 301. 8 six hundred sixty feet (6601) minimum connection separation per Florida Administration Code, Rule Chapter 14-?97 . na3 , - Genera Provlslo s:• 1. T e app?icant, heirs, assigns' and successors in interest, b nds anz obligates to save and hold the state of Florida, the D partmerht, , it agents and employees harmless froin any and all d mages,iclaims, expense,-or injuries arising out of any act, n glect for. +"O*mxssion by , the applicant, heirs, assigns `and s ccessc?s in interest that may occur by reason 'of this access c nnec:ti1on design, , construction of access connection, m intenance or continuing existence of the access connection f cili_y, except that the, applicantshall not be liable under t is provision 'for damages, claims, expense or injuries a ising rom the sole negligence -of the Department, its agents a d emplii yees. 2. T le app4cant agrees and obligates to perform at own 'expense t e relocation, closing, or alteration of the approved access c nnectipn(s) should noncompliance with provisions hcrowithin b deterpnined at some future date, or should the Department, d terminia that traffic patterns, points of connection, roadway, g ometri?s or traffic control devices are causing safety h zard a the approved access- connection(s). 3.. The app?i.cant shall not commence use of the approved c necti?n(s) prior to a final inspection and certification by a egistered Professional Engineer (contracted by applicant). S id certif i.cation shall be reviewed and concurred with by the D artme t. Page I of 3 ' I bOd L l 0 " ` , f' f ?? i ? ? Y • i I ? : ?I ? •fV ? DNI833NIDN3 DNIA 6CSE E88 E18 A. Y, • t hTTAC1LMENT "A" (continued) Permit No. 15-799-92-032 tP 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. TYa applicant shall notify, 11i writing, all known involved r ght-o --way users (utility) in the Department'c right-of-way a the location of the proposed access connection in ac- c rdanc.e with the Department's "Utility Accommodation Guide" 70-020'001-b. Applicant shall be responcible.for coordi- n Ling all adjustments and resolving any conflicts regarding u ilities. Applicant shall also be solely responsible for any d mages` and/or cost caused by interference with. or damages to e isting permitted utilities. A copy of the approved permit' must he di ,(spayed in a prominent. l cation in the immediate vicinity of the access conneQLiurs. c nstru.Aion.' Failure to display the approved permit may r cult iI n a stop-work order issued by the Department. T e applicant must notify the Department of Transportation -- District Maintenance office 24 hours in advance of starting p opos edi work. Call: Paul J. Lavely Phone Number: (813) 935-6070 Tie applicant agrees to complete the construction 'of the a proved' access connection within 90 days after start of c nstruAion.•.. , Failure to comply with . this' provision may result ih-' 4"-stop-work order' issued by the Department until a m ifiedpermit is reissued. T .e , app scant agrees.., that, access connection (s) will be cons 'truc ed and maintained in accordance with the approved plans aAd this Attachment "A" (Conditions and Provi: ions Permit NP. 5-'9 9-92-032 P and will require adherence to the Highway Administration "Manual on Uniform Traffic Federal Control i?evicessI (MUTCD), F.D.Q.T.. "Roadway and Traffic Design standard and F.D.O.T. "Standard "Specifications for Road and Bridge . 1991.'r T applicant, shall provide a detailed set of construction plans, tp a scale of Z" - 2011 or 1" = 4011, signed and 'oealed b a Professional Engineer registered with the State of ,Florida., ` The detailed plans shall present the proposed" c nectibn and approach improvements including the profiles, w' th, radii,. angles to State Highway, auxiliary pavement, existing, and proposed traffic 'control devices, existing and proposed' drainage devices and easements or other drains i ludinf pipe size, type, existing and'proposed grading, Page 2 of-3 4Lo :, `)NI d33N1 DN3 DN1 N '6ESC a85 C I S 85: b 1 ao--ot_-assi::. i Permit; t I ,F i ' . ATTACHMENT "All (cont;inUdd) tlo. 15{-799-92--032 P c ntouri,ng that affects the natural drainage pattern or, run- e f. impacting the State Highway and the proposed connection, d ainage?ual,culations and other data in accordance with Rule C apter , 14-86 F.A.C,.; the driveway, auxiliary lane and c ossover pavement design, including sub-grade, base, s ructur'al course, friction course; maintenance 'of traffic p an, signal detail plans, signing and pavement markings, m terial? specifications, construction standards, and i specti?on/testings requirements in' accordance with Rule C alter 14-96.0008--5 and shall submit inspection reports and F'nal, asL built plans to the Department. '10, P rmit 6hall"be valid for one (1) calendar'year and shall P ovz.de 'the F.D.O.T. an estimate of all construction phacc a tivities prepared-by a Prof essional. Engineer registered with t: a State of Florida and concurred by the Department. This said Department approval shall be a binding provision of the p mit. 11. A lic.an is responsible for meeting "Rule Chapter 14-86 ( ainag? Permit) by either a permit or a letter of exception f Ira =the District Drainage Engineer or their rdesi.gnated r reseAative. 12. A lican?, shall provide all related legal documents, ire., a ess 'easdments,, joint-use access connections, local government related approval., etc. 13. I A MEp AN OPENING IB.;JNV0tVE0 WITH YOUR PROPERTY'S ACCESS, THEN THE-POLLOWING STATEMENT IS APPLXCADLE: B rece pt of this document, applicant or authorized re resen ati.ve agree and understand that alteration or closure of any edian opening' done in`association with this or any. en ineerng permit' as mitigation for vehicular impacts or any ca se associated with said parcel, and access thereof, or of erwis?, shall not constitute or solidify any entitlement or ri ht of, access or - means of access, but merely 'serve as to porary measure or response to traffic demands at the median op ning:l The Department retains the right-and nothing in this do umentishall forfeit said right, to alter, modify or close an median opening, associated or not directly associated with th proj4ct, within the state right-of-way. I . Page 3 of 3 90d L i'0 • ,t 7 E ey'r ,r .'?y' • 1. ? .. DNI833NIDN3 DN1N GCGC U8 CIS 65? b(. ZO-OE-?6S(: CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION Agenda Cover Memorandum item Mooting Doto• 3/18/93 SUBJECT: PINELLAS TRAIL ROUTE RECOMMENDATIDN MOTION: APPROVE OPTION 1 AS SHOWN ON ATTACHED MAP AS THE PRIMARY PINELLAS TRAIL ROUTE THROUGH CLEARWATER AND OPTION 2 AS THE SECONDARY ROUTE THROUGH CLEARWATER AND FORWARD SAID ROUTES TO PINELLAS COUNTY FOR THEIR CONSIDERATION AND STUDY. and that the appropriate officiets be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: On August 2, 1990, the City Commission approved a Pinellas Trail route through Clearwater that primarily used the east side of East Avenue. However, in a.preliminary engineering report prepared by King Engineering, Inc., said route was deemed unfeasible due to safety, permitability, and costs. These findings were presented to the City Commission on November 2, 1992. Prior to said meeting, City Commissioners and staff toured other optional routes. As of this date, any design and/or development of the Pinellas Trail through Clearwater is on hold. The County has asked that the City provide a new recommended route, or sequence of routes by priority, that can be considered in finalizing the trail. In response, the city Manager appointed a committee of staff from the Parks and Recreation, Planning, Public Works, and Traffic Engineering Departments to review trail options and to prepare recommendations. Maps of four optional routes are attached to this memorandum and primary advantages and disadvantages are listed for each. Staff recommends that the route shown as "Option 1t' be recommended to the County for further study. The City of Clearwater rs Parks and Recreation Board also recommends this option. In the event this route listed as "Option 1" cannot be achieved, staff recommends the route shown as "Option 2. The routes shown as options 3 and 4 are not recommended by staff. Reviewed by: Originating Dep .: Costs: N19 Legal N A Parka & Rtrc ea eta Budget N A Purchasing N A User Dept.: Risk Mgmt. N A Parks & Recr a o urrent Cis A Funding Source: ACM Advertised: _ Capt. Imp. Other IN/A Data: _ Operating P apar: _ Other Submitted y: -Not required Affected partial Appropriation Code: _ Notified City Man g r _ Not required Commission ActioP{aQ,d _ Approved j rAo f fj 1 QtS-?- e _ Approvad w/00fditionstA3 54•?+? _ Denied Continued to : t h G 1 r n a Attachments: Map of original route and traps for four optional routes None r ` L N t l rtocErss iURt1Ers ? Jr rr? ?atl•K Er vit p11 DRUID" JASMINL 0 lotus ,? ? Rnt#U t PLC F? IAJ L__l I L M RICKr,R ? J ??nTxrt#5? wA+t#s ?} co++tJE r r ,__ s t A sr 4 l! I • Lc LAKEVILW D sr - L _E I? st +1h??'?cLLORMAII'AIM4 0 ST ' ?IT[LICV+Ew RD f3ELli;VIEw' 5 1kilRVf0Id13 WAY a Iy1J1NA1t4.Q ???t???? ? 3/10/93 WOODLAWN AVr WCOOLAWN . 1 ri . y: F 1J . DREW sr. g,rs, 591 4 7. 1?4' 0`= u G,,,,r y El W #r; IIEi A I? LAURA a ? ?% f` LAURA _} ? ? I1 i?! a ?m S.R. so er x1 if a PARK sr PIERCE s] 1:C] rRMN-KLIt# ? t L-A 11 a i? COURT 1", S? urn iEr IF] 1 1:0 7AS?fItJC ? _Lotus 5T 1 ' ADVANTAGES ORIGINAL. ROUTE 1. Avoids residential neighborhoods, 2. Proceeds through center of downtown business district. 3. Takes advantage of abandoned railroad right--of-way from Magnolia to Lakeview Road. DISADVANTAGES 1, Large trucks frequenting businesses pose unsafe situations. 2. Active trains could dislodge and throw stones that could be hazardous to trail users. 3. Route crosses the active railroad line two times resulting in risks of bicycle tires, roller blades, etc. becoming lodged in 'track openings, 4, Questionobl+ as whether or not there is sufficient width on the east 'side of the tracks for the placement of the 10' wide bike trail and 2' wide separation curb,. 5. Railroad Indicated they did not want trail within a few feet of their active railroad line and, if they have the opportunity, would possibly not provide a permit to construct in thot portion of ,their right-of-woy. 6. At the southern and of this route, between Lakeview and Belleview Road, it is highly unlikely that the Department of Transportation will issue a permit necessary to construct a portion of the trail within a few feet of the substandard section of Alternate Highway 19, 7. '. Along the southern portion, where stores front on the sidewalk, there is not physically enough room to construct a 10' wide trail given there is a minimum 4' required separation distance between the (rail and the edge of pavement.? .'M _ wnr m== +.+nc+JOr 1= PAT= p ? 1 , . 4 , E . IIART ?z +n JONES S Sl El 1171,0 51 S.R. r!@0 -C !n I= ?an IIEI4I3RICK5 { •r'i ?"1 U m? IrAU{n 1l ; LAURA O Y V _ S.R. G0 ?m tiE ?I?C?C7??? `y! U rc ] Er { PARK -- - ?+' o T ul?-?1 a???------- 1 F- ? PIERCE 5T PIERCE Lsl_ OPTION I t. + ?---} (Recommended) U L_J rrrnrNKarrN St ED u ADVANTAGES - COURT _,_?__s r Q a I? _ y [] count li sT 1. Takes advantage of views of Clearwatcr's boyfron t. El 2, Portion of route on Turner Street could PIESNNUr st be, constructed down the center of the roadway V, `ROC J1 ST ROGERs leaving driveways of adjacent businesses and ?_?U L EIE homes unobstructed. , ^ruRutrt St t 3. Takes advantage of abandoned railroad ? _ ? right-of-way from Magnolia to Lakeview. , sn?rT, rnK t- NAROL t 4. Does not cross rallrood tracks. ._r1 urrPING .-Sr PINE st PINE { 411- 4A ? RDISADVANTAGES lL? n? a 1__ no ,ar<ur E _ D f ! j U Parking will need to be removed, on lurncr Street from Ook Avenue to East Avenue, on Oak JASMINE WAY AsuIr1E 1 WAY L Avenue and through some County erni13layee parking tots. MACNOI L. t OR 2. unless a different route is found to connect Turner Street to Magnolia, this route MUS_ PAIII Earns would also have to parallel the active railroad tracks which could subject trail Jtr OROS s . ?_ users to stones thrown by trains.. I South of Lakeview, this route moy have to >zAraD cErNlRnr fallow Hamlet and Bellevietiv Road which are low r._.._ oE4,n?i'! sAOLE" I I.2 r }1 I?`' volume residential streets. L =7 CE ,,, 4. Railroad. might not Permit trait between ! ! ?L RICKC14 '. _ _ ?_-y __I1 PI? ?5 (I JI ? o Turner and Magnolia. WAINS 3 WAIkIIIS =n tUSIfAWI{,l? Sr ir ff1 r i SI Q LAI, -VIEW -- - X1,1 ?o • 13 51 ? EJ I sr Preferred Route' - . - -- Allernate Route PiNN IrtAIL dog s/ta/9s Eo,•er - OpUrnl - . , , rr!r a r i [_Rn I I? `YALOV900D WAY .1 ! I.' s • h± • 's y s '. _? ?IED DREW r M , M. 1"' I ' N uU1 tn 1 a I U ? I ' PIfRC£ Si x EtE:1 COURT sI I? , J C r UARXL[1 RRR ROOM I si IURNER sI IJ IJ ? ?`orq ntia RIM rnc ? PINE Sr PING u, CI Cretceq A ` 3L __J RD yy gAUll I . JASIA l'IE -WAY MA( kolus PATH ??.._ f1uiJ ?1 5"G?? ? 161 _._. _ C4R[3E 11 ._ st a if U Ll 10 rA S ,! rrArtr 1 U ?J] z 5 Sr c1El «6t a st s,R, 510 LAURA ? ? ?k S.R. 60 P? PARK ?_?WC OPTION 2 L PIERCE St [- ([? ? Er- ADVANTAGES Rn?tKLIN sr 3 1. Proceeds through the center of downtown ` ? which could stimulate' business and promote L caustt D'Li? renovation. 2, . Takes advantage of the abandoned railroad CIFESTNUI sr right-of--way from Magnolia to Lakeview. a 3. Uses the west side of East Avenue which is wider than the east side as in original route. 4. toes not cross railroad. track. . I `{AR01 I PINE _ DISADVANTAGES , 51 1:1 L.__ 1. This route still parallels the active N railroad lines and rocks could be thrown ?L C causing problerns to trail users. ASUINE o WAY 2. Railroad will quite likely continue to j ?a object to the trail sharing the active Q1 A f DR railroad right-of-way. 3, Parking will, need, to be removed from the I oius I°` east side of the Post Office. However, the --- City's new parking lot, may resolve this { ! problem. i oRDS sr 4. Toward the south end'ot East Avenue, L__1K= w large trucks are active and driveways to RAND CENTRAL warehouses and/or commercial businesses are involved, PAELLAS 5. South of Lakeview, this route may have to ?9 _!L follow liamlet and Belleview, which are low 0. IUSKAWILLA volume residential streets. ti. Some parking will have to be removed on si Garden Avenue and Hendricks Street. 7, No traffic lights exist where East Avenue sr Grosses Chestnut Street and Court Street. ao a o?`?p L?JJ UtLOIJAN ;j YAWWOUD = ?A H L WAY !1 rs? + L a.9 wuoDLAKrr nvE trlppnLpy?T, I tC !] 4?h+ - vphan7 l _ .1. 4 S' r: f1 Preferred Route ?r -- -^- -?- -- --- Alternate Route t s ` I'ItRT S1 1C !1 1lART .n JONES ?s 5 - ?IA?? f El 110 5, rT. 590 ?.' d¢? rya ? ? ?' ?il } IrE?IDRrc;ks ??} ' K=n LnuRA '` U i- 1? L W LAURA ri ?3n ? r? I I 6 0 u S.R. G4 ? ? ?m? 'ro PARK o ' a is f? PIERCE St u?--?J m ?? PIERGE S] OPTION .3 ' l ? ?RANkuN sT?. \ cnvitr sr V ? ADVANTAGES u,Deti coURt ii s?. i• Takes advantage of the view of a f Clearwater's boyfront. CIIESINUi ST 2. Could be constructed Inside the medians ?RUGERS'I SI ROGERS of Bay Avenue, between Druid and Jeffards, leaving driveways open'. 13C 3. 3 Does not cross ' the railroad tracks. n n 1? I 4. Is the most direct of all routes. ' f"nc ?ncnxP+rrt ST E E JJAROL DISADVANTAGES Qeftrn PINE Sr PIftE L` o LAN$ 'Cj i, Difficult i getting the route from DRUID RD a Y in `?] f w DRUID RD Turner Street to druid Road along streets that are narrow and which Include residential JnSr.allE ?vA- r [/ -- _ ASAIiNE d yygY' driveways, etc. [=WE 2, Al the south end of lay Avenue,. the trail r.lncrr o Lr n would i t OR n ersecl at Jeffords which is a bus ql L ('-OR ? intersection for emergency facilities of y Lotus OA III Marlon Plant I-fospilal. Lotus 3, A route from Jeffords through the Morton "D,,, ? -? E= JCFfORD Plant Hospitals Campus flan to Corbett Stree# f ?? QRAND Swould require significant dedication of ?property by the hospital for the trail, s CENIRAL 4. Getting from Corbett Street t'o Belleview4 tt}lTrrl„) Cl2f?' ?? •'?-- ?'"? Ll Boulevard will involve the perimeter of the RICK II n ter---] ?--`-1 [--11- PIrtELL golf cause which will require golf course approval? - wAlKtr?s tvntF,rNS ?f coRDE r t oT ? • ' o ST A ST f a LAkEVIE1Y =XE EL Sr 0. 51 DELLt VIEW no Q L 51 z1J ?W r Vol 55005 wnr p[NtRAILd+q rk: dxE L110193 wUDDLAWN AVID tt wOODLAWN `Opllon] ' J. ?u `. ST Of'?te ? ?t^ .i AV, .fart. -? aril w ST? I? t? s rt. _.,? '? t ?_? • Eµ ? ?_._? 1??!____= f. J?[ 1 ) ?_ ?Rl?. 1 - . 6{1 S rr. OPTION 4 (As suggested by resident) TIhit1 V, . 'ADVANTAGES _' f-- .' . ADVANTAGES 'rrli RCC 'S1 1 -- ?--? { -.? _ _ rlr.`RC-C-} st t'? ) II I I r? 1. Trail proceeds through; the downtown r _ tlrnrmthi _ ;,r_ business district. r- I t r:ouRr -sr DISADVANTAGES ctiuR ' sf IJARktrf I, At is questionable os, to whethnr or not u _ST,_ ?--- there is sufficient space for the trail on cl+esnru! RDGLRS, ! S1 ROGEItS ( ... ' East Avenue between Jones and.Louro. -? I?f""! ['1 Lf'' ? - {?TMw? • 2. There is no traffic light at fast Avenue _J 1 ! lwJ 1 I? { and Drew Street, -_rulrtrarR st _ 3. the railroad will more than - likely 'object IJ 2? to the tin}I sharing this mule with active ? Uz 'rr5 hea!1701 - tracks and problems could be encountered by fN? µ. C?Plt1C 51 t'krrC Y rare sr rocks thrown by trains. C+esernI oL?.??1 []?(?a ??, }s route will have to cross the ' DRUID Rn W DRUID RU railroad tracks 'til two locations, once at the / J f _.?-? north and once at the south and. a• Although Prospect Avenue is a straight iAtitr?JL war nSlliirtWAY line from Laura to Lakeview, bicycles will have to share this roadway with traffic and o f ir4ACtrouA DR a? l safely would be a primary concern because of llte numerous driveways and parking lots from 1.01us PATIO bus which vehicles are entering and exiting. ----? ?_•_?___1 ! G. A good portion of route is through JET FORDS ST residential areas. ??;? 7. the use of Lakeview Road from Prospect to crtArrn CENtRAL ` Hamlet is questionable due to very heavy 1 nil ??11 sAntrr+>; traffic on Lakeview and the passibility of riot 1--- PlrrcLLn 4 having sufficient room for the trail on the Rlckr•??- ;r ri hl-ol'--wa "? S. ' As with other rotates, the south end of , WAtKSSrs 1YA ? KY.RrSINS CL IUSKAV (LA this route will use (lie residential road 'of f corrnEri ? I- Fiamlel. sr n T si 9. Trallic lights do not exist at Chestnut,' ~ r- o T Ell) ?r A 5r Court or Cleveland Street. C LAKI YI ((?, -? U 5r' \ ~S I ' MdEIMAN 51 ftCLLCVlLVr RU? ('?` f 111PAIL rr+q - -•' 3/10/D3 tY6UbL{ •ra ? i.l ?• 'Y s r r `,?. .tit f' , • 'r Ste` ~ war?? { waOULAtSrt V A Statement to The Commissioners of the City of Clearwater From the People of First United Methodist Church 411 Turner Street Clearwater, FL 34616 March 16, 1993 Dear Commissioner, Our church members were surprised and concerned to learn; just' this Tuesday, of your intention to adopt a.proposed plan for the Pinellas Trail at the Commission meeting this evening. The members were sufficiently alarmed to call a special, emergency- Administrative Board meeting to consider the plan. By unanimous vote, the Administrative Board adopted.a motion to vigorously oppose the plan. - We do so while acknowledging,the' great benefit to have the Pinellas Trail, but with the reservation that the option recommended by your staff is not the desirable way to link the Pinellas Trail through downtown Clearwater., Our church is located on Turner'Street. For over 100 years, First United Methodist Church has-stood watch over'the city ... meeting its needs ... responding to its problems ... and addressing the concerns of its citizens. The 1,800 people of First United Methodist Church remain very much involved in providing emotional, financial, economic and spiritual support for the citizens of our community. The restriction of the church's ability to continue to effectively minister to the needs of our community, which will happen under,'your.Staff's proposal., is our greatest concern. Maybe your Staff simply does not understand how many of the functions of the church will be negatively.impacted by their recommendation. They never asked. Maybe your Staff forgot to study the positive community outreach_ ' afforded by the people and the programs of the church. They never inquired. We were left to read in the St. Petersburg Times of the recommendation that will forever diminish, perhaps. disastrously affect the way that the church now carries out its ministries. The negative impact affects the Pinellas Trail users as well. Though we have had little time to respond, the obvious problems include: First, our Sunday schedule will cause some problems with those utilizing the Trail. Some of these problems include'... 1. The inability to load and unload in front of the Sanctuary those who attend worship in our mini-bus and van. 2. Insuring enough room between the church-owned parking lot and the Trail to allow ample turning radius for the church's bus to enter and exit. .3.,The constant traffic flow of 650+ cars between the hours of 7:30 a.m.,and 12:30 p.m. for the worship experience. 1 ¦.:. E!r . . r 4. The traffic flow of 45+ cars between the'hours of 3:30 p.m. and 8:30 p.m. for on going adult training classes 5. The traffic flow of 60+'cars between the hours of 4:30 p.m. and 8:30 p.m. for youth activities. 6.1 The need of those who attend the church 'in wheelchairs and motorized chairs to freely access the church facility from the church-owned parking lots without obstructions caused by the Trail. .7. The added liability placed upon the City of Clearwater for injury to church-goers now forced to straddle concrete boundaries and dodge bicyclists, skate-boarders, etc. 8. The additional costs to be incurred by the City-of' Clearwater through active or off.-duty police officers patrolling the church-owned parking lots to insure that they did not become a popular parking area for those seeking to enter and exit the Trail. 9. On account of the numbers'and needs of those in the church, the Trail can in no fashion impede or interfere with the ability of ambulance or fire equipment to respond to property or medical emergencies. Second, our weekday schedule will cause some problems with those utilizing the Trail. Some of these problems include ... 1. Our.Pre-school operates 5 days per week between the, hours of 8:50 a.m. and 2:00 p.m. Approximately 70 children are involved in the program. Restricting the flow of traffic of the 60+ cars on Turner Street.would result in a tremendous back-up of cars'at Ft. Harrison as parents waited their turn to drop-off and pick-up their children. This back--up ... twice a day ... five days each week will no doubt occur. This will only compound the flow of traffic on an already over- crowded road. It should be noted that the`only option to avoid such back-up onto Ft. Harrison in such event is to require the safety hazard of forcing the children to cross Turner Street. 2..'Our weekday evening schedule draws persons to the church on Mondays through Thursday. Whether for committee meetings involving 35+ cars, choral events and rehearsals involving 40+ cars, or our Wednesday dinner and study involving 120+ cars, there is continual use made of-Turner Street by the church. 3. Our large day-time events and meetings, such as the United Methodist Women, The Fellowship Luncheon Club, and the Retired Ministers Groups all utilize Turner Street as a means of access to the church. 4. Our deliveries of educational materials, food and paper goods, office supplies and custodial supplies are' received through our main entrance on Turner Street. Finally, our ability to provide specialized services to the community will cause some problems with those utilizing the 2 f i Trail. Some of these problems include .,. 1. Several weekends each month, we provide weddings for' the people of our community. Florists and caterers will be unable to easily unload the materials which they need into the facility. Brides and grooms will no longer be able to leave the church and get into waiting vehicles to go to their receptions. . The .wedding party will no longer be able to process in their motorcades as well. The excitement of the wedding day will be curtailed by this plan. 2. We often conduct funeral services at the church rather than at the funeral home. We will be unable to allow the funeral director to bring the body to the church, to bring the family to the church in their limousines, or to arrange the processional to the cemetery should this plan be in place. These concerns are the ones which come quickly to mind. No doubt there are more which will come to us as'we have time to study the proposal fully before you. We'cannot understand,the perceived benefits of-the recommendation currently before you regarding the Pinellas Trail. How, or why, did your Staff fail to look at all of the ramifications inherent in this one decision? With all'of the obvious demands placed upon Turner Street by church members and community residents alike, we are puzzled that the Staff conjured up the possibility of flying stones from passing trains, yet failed so completely'to show concern for likely tragedies from traffic demands on Turner ' Street . Please reject this recommendation from Staff to transform Turner Street into the Pinellas Trail. The Pinellas Trail'is a worthy project. Route it in a ,way which makes good sense. We believe the recommendation to be a hastily made and poorly thought through decision. We, and the 1,800 members of First United Methodist Church, will be,watching for your vote on this issue. Attached please find a drawing and some additional notes which speak to our concerns. Thank you. Respectfully submitted . Rev: Paul,E. Van Dine Senior Pastor Mr..George Bouse Chair - Administrative Board E' , t "iI [ rat .? v. e h Mint n Associate Kstor' Mr, Steve Cole Chair -.Board of Trustees 3 E? r? V A o ? W fA IU6 0 Pm 16 Fe 4) M c b 0 i H ?e I S co w aV ?? 4? 52 z0. o ? 116 ci 0 E W Y N Q IL u 0: U ? . d Z P L W ' aV? W c aao asp 10 w U Q a W z 0 W O 4 a a I :E zM II ?a??°?°?ooad MR IU6 y R Z ? ?r = o? Z y ?NVZ N V ?u a O0.o z ?O?`saoao O...1 ? W M U. R z a tiJ z 0 w z W w z :3 m 4 W z 0 W td1 a 0 M IL Nr z a 41 Z O POTENTIAL EFFECT UPON FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH MEMBERS AND VISITORS FROM PROPOSED PINELLAS TRAIL OPTION #1 DOWN CENTER OF TURNER STREET P_REFACE_ANI BACKGROUND: Having been made aware only as late as Tuesday morning's newspaper that there was any remote thought of running the proposed Clearwater section of the Pinellas Trail down Turner Street, with a presumed deadline of City Commission action on Thursday night of the same week, a special session of The Administrative Board was held at 8:00 p.m., Wednesday, March 17, A.D. 1993. The Board, representing the over 1,800 members of First United Methodist Church of Clearwater, UNANIMOUSLY OPPOSES the Turner Street proposal for the Pinellas Trail. We believe there are, not only detrimental effects on both younger and older individuals and families using First UMC facilities, but also that the route Is not the safest for the projected Trail. The Trail in this location offers a disruptive intrusion, hindering access between our parking facilities and our building entrances, while also removing the limited public street parking which is beneficial equally to our church members, county employees, and the public doing business In the area. Moreover, the resulting narrow one way traffic lanes on Turner Street would prohibit the present convenience of stopping and standing to discharge preschoolers, teenagers, or handicapped adults along both sides of the street. Church bus, van, funeral, and wedding parking and waiting arrangements would be denied by the proposal, further hindering the normal safety of discharge and pickup of such persons and the ongoing religious ceremonial uses of the church itself. The anticipated blockage of left-turn access in making entry to our parking lots would GREATLY hinder the overall convenience of our members, visitors, county em- ployees, and others who now use our parking lots on daily and weekend basis! Normally left-turning vehicles both into and out of the parking lots (as functioning safely and adequately for years) would be forced to make right turns both coming and going from these facilities, in most instances going out of the way several extra blocks to accom- modate such a "round-about" and, at the same time, forcing more traffic onto already busy arteries in the area, such as South Fort Harrison Avenue and Chestnut/Court. (It is not to be Ignored that MOST such route adjustments would not only inconvenience the driver, but incur higher rates of left turn and cross-traffic efforts on THOSE arteries, from which long delays In making such turns are already experienced!) The overall negative Impact In this immediate neighborhood would likewise extend to observed existing traffic for such adjacent operations as the local school deliveries, medical offices, etc. Observers note also that much traffic which presently approaches and exits from the nearby Christian Science and Episcopal Churches via Turner Street would also have to cross the proposed Trail (at the proposed Oak Avenue turning point), having probable adverse effect on those church members and certainly adverse vehicle traffic across this proposed section of the Pinellas Trail. Some of the particulars of detrimental impact on First United Methodist Church of Clearwater are elaborated in the following examples. And it is thought that more negative effects will become obvious as more time passes to evaluate the Impact! Page 2 P_ROJ3ABLE_ADV_ERSE EF_FC_T_S OFAN&_TURNER STREET P??I.ELLAS TRAIL PROP4SAlz FOR CHUlTCH.M REM IBEITSAN VAITOR.$,,-RELATED TA OUR-P-RESENT ONGOING P IROGRAMS_AND_MiN1M1ES: (1) Bus and Van Loading and Unloading In Front of Sanctuary and Fellowship Hall would be Impossible as Now Planned. One Way Traffic Lane only about 12 Feet Wide Would Mean Blocking Traffic Too Long for Providing This Close Access to Our Church Doors. (it is to be noted that many persons who use this bus convenience NEED the door-to-door capability for it to be useful, because of age or walking handicap.) City Traffic Engineer (Peter Yauch) has stated verbally to Pastor Van Dine that this MIGHT be accommodated by trail develop- ment authority by "cutting down" a portion of the curb and sidewalk for a bus parking circle. We do not believe such ad- justment would solve the problem conveniently, however; and It would, at the same time, reduce sidewalk safety. (2) Standing Cars, Hearse, Funeral Procession or Wedding Procession Vehicles Would Not Be Allowed Along the One-way Proposed Design. This Size of Group Also Probably Could Not Be Accommodated by Such (possible!) Modi- fications to the Area as the Sidewalk Bus Parking Circle. It Would Hardly Be Able to Handle All Necessary for Funeral and Wedding Processions. (3) Even With Such Accommodation for a Bus Circle, the Narrow One-way Street-Segments, Separated by the 15' Trail Median, Probably Will Affect Our Bus Turning Radius Negatively. The Bus Must Do Considerable Maneu- vering Around the Church Property Each Time of Use for ANY of its Many Purposes, Even With Present Wider Clearance and Turning Radius. (4) Coincidentally, It Has Been Noted That LARGE Delivery Trucks Will Often Access the Public School Property By Wide Turning on the Turner/Palm Intersection, and BACKING Down the (alley-like) Section of Palm Avenue Lying Between the Church Buildings. This Access of Deliveries to BOTH Church AND Public School Properties Will Be Hindered by a Dedicated Center Lane for the Trail. (5) It Is Not Determined at This Time Whether or Not the Proposal, If Devel- oped, Would Call for Elimination of Left Turns from Turner Street onto South Fort Harrison Avenue. If Development Authorities Attempt to Pro- tect Pedestrian and Bicycle Traffic on the Trail by Eliminating Left Turns on that Busy Intersection (where a left turn would turn another vehicle directly across the Trail), Such a Prohibition Would Exceedingly Further Complicate and Greatly Inhibit General Access Both TO and FROM First UMC. (6) Any Prohibition. of Left Turns INTO and OUT OF Our Church Parking Lots on Turner Street Would Force Much More Church Attending Traffic onto Fort Harrison Avenue, In Order to Accommodate Making a Right Turn Into the Church Parking Lots. The Lack of Left Turn Availability in LEAVING the f • Page 3 36 Westernmost Parking Lot (Now Shared with County Parking on Weekdays) Would Force Some of That Traffic to Cross the Trail at Its Oak Avenue Bend and Seek Other Ways to Turn Around in Order to Travel Eastward. ' (7) Deliveries of Many Church and Office Supplies, Including Mail, etc,, Are Re- celved Through Parked Delivery Trucks and Vans on Turner Street Through Our Front Entrances. These Would Block Traffic on the Proposed 12-foot Wide One-way Road, While Making Deliveries. (8) The Loss of Six to Ten Convenient Street Parking Places Directly in Front of the Church or One of the Church's Parking Lots Is Detrimental BOTH to the Church Members AND to the County Employees and the General Public Who Use Those Street Sites Regularly, Yet Are Faced (by the Actual Wording of . the Plan) with a REDUCTION of Official Parking Lot Areas of the County. (9) Re-Design of our Parking Lot Parking Spaces and Traffic Flow Has Been Suggested by the City Traffic Engineer, to Avoid Left Turns Onto and Off of Turner Street by Making the Main Entrances Off of the Narrow Side Street (Palm Avenue). However, That Street Is So Narrow That Its Use Would Probably Hamper the Ordinary Automobile; and It CERTAINLY Would Create Difficulties for our Church Bus, the Mini-Bus, and the Van. (It Is Difficult to Exit onto Palm Avenue at Present-even in a SMALL automobile-Without Blocking Both Lanes of Traffic on Palm Avenue While Swinging With the Most Efficiency Possible Into the Proper Lane on Palm!) (10) IF More Traffic (Due to Left Turn Prevention) Were Forced to Exit Onto Either Court Street or Turner Street to Make Departure from the Church, This Still Places the Same Traffic Across the Proposed Pinellas Trail as Would Be True If Left Turns Were Allowed at Every Parking Lot Exit and Entrance. It Would Simply JAM Up All the Traffic Into One Crossing Point. Moreover, Anyone Presently Exiting from Palm Avenue onto Chestnut/ Court Already Experiences Difficulty of Turning Off Palm at ANY Time or Day of the Week--Particularly When Needing to Cross Traffic Lanes for a Left Turn onto Fort Harrison! A Traffic Light Would Be a Practical Necess- ity With Any Increased Volume of Vehicles Attempting to Exit from Palm at That Point. Yet, Such a Traffic Light Would be Almost Prohibitive as a Solu- tion that Close to Two Other Existing Traffic Signals! These already considered obstructions and damages to the church's work and Its members and visitors' safety, plus our anticipation of more difficulties and disruptions becoming obvious as time to evaluate the detrimental Impact goes on, causes the Ad- ministrative Board of First United Methodist Church of Clearwater to vote UNANIMOUSLY In opposition to the Turner Street proposal for the Pinellas Trail connection. We urge the City of Clearwater to VIGOROUSLY REJECT this proposed routing. WE STAND OPPOSED TO THIS WITH UNIFIED VOICE! y?,fr.;: :.} , :..+ . • ?frd:• "!s o, x ' , ^? , .. C. ,.i.. '.F : -. ? Y`'rp.,'"3 [:"/•' ..t^F° ?'".°" t r f R?? rF t ? E _ ?t'a?i{? ' o', r'S.. •('. .'11-s?5 .: }i.s. ?. i. !' .•'y it , , f + .: R.' r i'?.e:r f?.l j /:Ys ,?:r ,`i^.?L.. •!,t -. -!: ? ] ,. , , it ?fi { ?' „'.r,'Y+: ?, r. y' •t•- .j•sr?9 4'?.,'. 7F, ? .._ ? ? .. • t' tfr (?•R5 'iy¢?',i.. l?r ,?rt7 ..r?. lr• ° !'rY?R . s.F, v?ri?rin' `?,! t. t' i ' ?'.e ' . r i ` 'k'" ,}y"pY}?t E?. ?" rl.. ,rri 1. -?1• `,5i .1. ? ?+''A :i?ri?"` ???:iy?t. :"!1 ?\• ? ? '# r ' .r :', .. '!}r'? _ - r' ?i,??iarj?+?A trf! + f,•t. 1 t i. , +?i ,: V : +' ! r,6.. ' i '.i ? °...<?,t ??.?. dt, :=?3?. ..?'.?.: ?.5 ;,'%?' ?i'+1, ?+` r.n, i?gcys' 'r °? •T.?- ,. ''• .;; -:I _ r. ;.,,'? P??. t''c':e .F rr 'r~ ;.L ( •,e v'r:4• 'rs? . r.j •? '?s'., r. ''t ^q: .: J,• ;•t.£, .3, -.e i. R-? • [? v?r f'!°.-f 'i 5' r- ' "r r - ?: ', 1' ' f'<' i, '",, i j, ?ff :,,?; r . rn e , ;r!' a? •ae .i ' f1.?'3.'• '."r" ri Y::: ? ?? .N.7a" :7 ;f' .,. r?r' •i• _ ir?•' rl >, `•???•+.•-'??i?l..?:f:.r f .. '• . F ,. x?E? ?r.•Y?'a ??``?? ? s?,. , (J - • T ( '.1 ° °I'3:tr ,jl' i •, l.r 1 .. i+ .. ,i , {. •. i ? f??c Pt t7• ,?#s !: ?5'???El,rrl,;Yr,• .T i?' .. 'r. „ ?r•'es .'S? '?? "..:?x•' :i+ °•• P. ..i e' ? '4. f?. .[ }?•n, "-' • i?' ,'1' '-i ? . ! 'r ?' i• <i•csgg trA,}'}e .,. '`z .. _ ;r6-, ie. ,?4r, ,1 'r' r.i ..?•., .ir ?'fit •,?7 iE y'?'c •,r:y '"t=?}r ,;? i? ?rs'C'9 ?'. ."?`3 a'. `a. ??'",? 'f i`'k.? ?' • '?!'_ , [ c ?t`,6?. ??e•sL. _.' •f ;?#. rri ?, /Jn• ?,?s,alft.., ? .. ?i• rr. ?i?.' '??S T:T +J''•Ir .Ir/. ?. tr`*??'a l?.?r,. ?.,r? rf'Y. f,iit. ?''I' ... ° ,r, •?t• 'Lu?Ri{i+rE:9fL°:.t?.'xt?o: "d- .? -r•i. ., >. i?. ..:j?aaf .M1?x.°a?'.i :-.'i"?.[lr 1, ?,t :..-..?'y. iti.p .. .:?° .. , , t .. c• .?,.: -`.`1 .. .. o. .r .? .:.r..»: .'.kj?, ", ji'?'i' ',: „ +' t,r .. ., .; ;'= r °•t ' 1 ? ,? ?', ? ? ?f• ', ? r f .1 - z .!„ it, ?.j: JPA ]DATE 410, I Sr. .. • .1 .'1 ' r ITEIM, 'TT r t ! 1 t' i' .'f yl . i,r??i: le ?, r??n • • ,S I r d F1.. , , iiirr??? //VV// g •?'! ,' ? f• • ')err .i F r I i , •! i1 1; ff"i Yr; `?,r . (f ? •,? f ? • ? ; ? .. ? 5 ' ' , ! ? ... ? t , r ? . I + ti ? .. . . r • .F ' j ,`?? j'r.? •;,? i. - ...?+.. 'r"r r S • . . 'rr .t i +"r. x '',1'. .t.F??j? ' S - ?? r a .:•!? ..r. rF. r :???;}•tr rV??'w?,?.: •. n,iuL?E t-r>f: c? , r y Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum SUBJECT: REQUEST TO CLOSE DRUID ROAD AND BAY AVENUE AT JEFFORDS STREET I3n-e Meetil- ? 3/19/43 RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Deny the request from Harbor Oaks Association to immediately close both Druid Road and Bay Avenue at their intersections with Jeffords Street and advise staff of the Commission's disposition regarding the proposed traffic action plan identified in the attached report. 17 and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The Harbor Oaks Association, a neighborhood homeowner's group, has requested the permanent closure of both Bay Avenue and Druid. Road at their intersections with leffords Street. These closures, the Association reasons, would protect the neighborhood from the pollution and traffic hazards caused by motorists using the neighborhood's street to reach other destinations. Currently, Bay Avenue carries about 1,180 vehicles per day and Druid Road carries about 4,250 vehicles per day. The City's Transportation Group has, in the past, acknowledged 2,000 vehicles per clay as a desirable maximum for local residential street traffic, and Bay Avenue falls well within that threshold. Druid Road, while it traverses a residential area, is classified as a collector street, with a desirable maximum volume of 15,000 vehicles per day and Druid Road likewise falls well within that threshold. The immediate closure of Druid Road would divert a significant amount of traffic to South Fort Harrison Avenue, negatively impacting the level of service and increasing congestion along this heavily travelled roadway. In addition, the Fire Department has expressed their opposition to both closures, citing concerns about access to the neighborhood and to the Morton Plant Hospital complex. However, the Transportation Group and the Fire Department, working together, have developed an implementation plan that reduces traffic through the neighborhood while maintaining emergency access. A key component to this plan is the improvement of capacity along the South Fort Harrison corridor, The Transportation Group,recommends that, should a diversion of traffic away from the Harbor Oaks neighborhood be desired by Commission, the proposed plan as described on Pages 20-25 of the attached report, be adopted. Reviewed by: originating Dept: Costs: S NONE Legat Total Budget N/A _ PW/TRANSPORTATION 9PPUP Purchasing N/A S NONE Risk Mgmt. NZA User Dept: Current Fiscal Yr. Cis N/A ACM N/A 1 Funding Source: other © Capitat Imp. Advertised: 0 operating Date: © other Vr Paper: 00 R i d Not equ re Submitt by- Affected Parties ® Appropriation Coda: Notified City Mona er ®? Not Required n P ted on recycled paper ti Commission Action: SS 41, 13 Approved d' arr.rt 's 11 , Approved w/conditinonL E3 Denied 13 Continued to: Attachments: 1) Memo from Pete Youch dtd 3/04/43 2) TRAFFIC STUUY REPORT is None -:..,I 1 r r ?r . a CITY OF CLEARWATER ` Ilyterdepartmentid Correspondence Sheet t TO: Cynthia Goudeau, City Clerk i FROM: Pete Yauch', Ass't. Dir, of Public Works 1 Transportation ' COPIES: William C. Baker, Director of Public Works SUBJECT: Changes in Agenda Item 'Request To Close Druid Road and Bay Avenue at Jeflbrds Street (for 3118193 Commission Meeting), DATE: March 9, 1993 The agenda item addressing the request of the Harbor Oaks Association has been modified between its original submittal (for the February 18 meeting) and this current version. Changes are as follows: . o The section entitled Proposed Traffic Diversion Plan,% starting on. page 21, was :.;. modified to reflect the use of mountable barriers as the primary means of diversion. The Harbor Oaks Association indicated that this approach, as shown in Figure 12 and described as Plan A, more closely agreed with their. original request, to close both Druid Road and Bay Avenue. The earlier version of the report made it appear that directional closures at both ends of the Bay Avenue parkway section (Plan B) was the preferred plan. o Material provided in Appendix C, concerning the proposed increase in utilization of Myrtle Avenue as a means of improving the level of service along Fort Harrison, . was expanded to discuss possible improvements at the' intersection of Myrtle and North Fort Harrison, near the Atrium Hotel. . o Reference to Bay Avenue as a possible route for the Pinellas Trail was deleted. Field reviews showed that the alignment to the north and south of Harbor Oaks ; presented several technical drawbacks; and` it was felt that the Trail's routing was independent of the Association's request. o The Cover Memo's Recommendation/Motion section was slightly modified to emphasize that the Association's request was to "immediately" close "both" Druid Rozt' and Bay Avenue. r: rS3`,'r ., .1''t 1 ' iI j f. Y i Y ' r r r.?..1.,7_;,e,1.1,,_..-_7. ';+'?it,'?lj', A?°.'i'°.L S:.x'rl1?"?,,4, ..:_,,, .,_j ?,. .y. ,t.... .?a:' - .. 1 - 'rb'. ,r:. . ,0. v,' r•I..?v "J °n s ?, ,,- J;,1 t,'',? .. 2, }.,il;°r. of ewj.,, !_s• 43''?°'..<?.,'?if:'..1r'k,•aF.ys 11 , .i :, °'3. :,?' ^,'s.F, ..a.'4 •'2`' '.1. 'r:. ` _;. ,. t; -;-?: .::,t'r 1"'>v1' ii,'.:I..o. r.,H (f:. tr T: ,` ';, , lit'I ("i' rl' _ . A ., .!_c r f ?ir1 .?,i •,h sY. '`)`,' .'(. rr .. ° - ,} -,.. 'fl". g:; i, t;,, , ? , 4,{S . ",r +? I , •f . P"'.{,r f ;' ,' ,,wi r ^: f f.'+ . F . .,r f u;.A3 :! ,. '. e' a {,. ?.. fr'.' •r' i1',.••' .g .1 .. - i . . f,r ;ifl??.:;,i .-•' ,;.v: i. ,. r , . a I ,. ". }' - .. , .I'. - ,t ,j I ; t •',' „ Yet ? .,,. ,. I, }' + , ..' [5,:%'.L" j'f ,Sr•%t)i 'L'?..{{iir,',st.°"s'r f r .. r'. :el, :(-i` Yom !' ;'; •' ?, y• ,%,, s•,°..,' '._:. .. ./' , 7' r r I r r. ?.? c , j .:° , _'; d, `' ,,?I rI "?` . f;.i . 'o' 1 I . f '-,7 y., s`"s. . t , !4?,,b?,'' ';i'•A- r'';r'={ •,(},,s'Ir,.,, ' .'ry'1r'`.'-, r. r.f {... ?I { ?r ... ':F s ' i !'' 1 . j t ' a.;;' r' r': ' r i 5,i,, e,iti; '!y? -i'L'" j.lo"'a r•,.1, .i• .r,"`.'#:z s r, i}:'? .t '?f' ;,i' ; ';wr ["it'..,' ,{.? .I ,j.,, 'c ?l i,t«-?'?, $s .I ii ! ?, , - . f si 'r' ' i';s; Lt A a i )'r: 9(,` t. , _ ' .i , . 4 i''t•.`?' lis$ .r4 P .!' • ? 'r ° '!I ,i rl'. . axS''"y'.I. r ?} •r f' • .r= i ,1j'< r ?, dN; .{-..i,''.~ t, 4: .`.r=1', ", - r' t, ,".."il 'l: .3-' . .:'r r. .' r '?'.i:,, -? , t r. c fl°'"':.i'1 ?4?7 /' 't li: i;...is t^.'iS' r ,a.. - .. ' r ' 'f' >'?5:. sry`q} tr .rt,'i `t ;`r ,.4 .+'_-,?.:. J'"!' ..ti .,? , : r Y •h,.: i .. ,,L'? :d.:},% 1p6' ?S['y tit`i Tr,: r 'i;.• r t 'r' I` t. •t7' fa'r,+ '(. - '{? i, ' f.•` -i(y J,'si` .3 y,5+.,`1q ''#^,S ..y.` 2' °r ,r i r r.\. Ji ::u. . o, .!. ; aj,: 1 i • e ! C ,.,, -; ,;; , 'I : i -? ° . z. rtj ??,,....,,. +.5 .^I: •'/ 'S:r '., ? .'f'' •.},t ,..I, '.," .'f, '!1,•.1: }°i"< k •,r, .. .'i .q"'.!, j' '•P' •."?,.. CI w: ci• r,, , ?" =S: c:4. f 'L= .. ?: . ' rr. }'A.. i' ,..6., w:? V# , 11 I ?, ,}$,,,;,, rr- ifr ',I:< 4i. 'e'.•?'°:i '?'rr`l3r+.H >"i?" <. •;=r rl.<J: .??,. '7. :,. '•1; t }'? 1. ,1 I:aI... .Y :.+. b ,t .{, b?, i .,r'.• r t ,1. ,lt •? ,. 1 S?'A iC''=fir > h ?x 3°f p r., r i y??''°° 7 6.1- dr. 'tr , i ?` ' 1'• it • .? f l,•r r r i rVl'7., y1a j', .}.,-. ':: ! " :.?'s"^,, , :'4: ,1< rr:' ,'f: '?. <?i • •,r.?1i:1 w.•' rrr: ' -A"'r ''l•. I, ,,, ,,. Z'.1° '1::. i`•''f-' i. ? .'3? 1:.'.3' >Ja.,r I I .•,. " ? i ,.J.- '`.. .:J 3'.7'. !: 's re ,'{;j $ e •' ,•'i r'..` "!.• 1 .11 1 t, Y?. 1 r,^ i `S , t I.9,. .r Y?.,? .`r'c Y a9+? tie L. I:r: 1',, _1,'i1 :. ^`:' , ! :!'r ``" ' /1 _ ! , l ,, ??yy {`'?aa'' .s. Fti , , .'r,F . - C 0,-i4 j Y . ei •3' • tts ? . : ,,t; ?:•: „ .: C. C :#.:' .; M , ' 's'Yt rf.`fa .'l: S.I.-e'A.a+.»:R' .r I , i,' :,i. Lr%.=1'1. 2?'41i ?1 d: i'.?...': A:{`t+,'?. im et(2 :.;.''»i,-...,`, .i.- ' i > {,,;: '.RAFF`. .+7 J1I • .. - o ' ?' ' , . ` , + - 'r,,t , I , ?!-.*° °L -.I, . .r., f' •t r . h e •S •I 5 I ' I rr I ? I. • I , ' -, i• ^ ;5.. . a.! '.j:',L -:r :?:. .'? =I. r ,r ' r'' , . .. i '+ 1 f r ? .. . i .!' ',- , r 1. , . , `S^I,"", r. !lY': r .. . , :,fit Y ,:r ~ Mr L 1. ,;; ' ANALYSIS OF REQUEST FROM L HA"ORr OAKS ASSOCIATION , Are' , ?'r j'' '; :),, . , : r... TO .CLOSE DRUID SROAD AND BAY AVENUE ' ' t ? '' , :: , •; • ' 3 ,A:, ?? , . : ' 'r ' - ? ' ? . . . .. . . I I;. i.,,?!A,J ,' r ' ;ti: P ?(; '...? `f'+i ,''S t .! ,,. 'i ?' ,, r, `I . . `.r .,F' a ... Z?,"'. 4? ,,_ 1 '. .}: ''r ,.,L,..1 A . .Prepared By: J,a'' pt City of Clearwater`. t ''`?? Department of Public. Works i, } < , I"? ;: ,, .,.a. Transportation Group ; a.: ,r r f • : i : ,.r.'.: . . . ' 3 . ? t t ?, ?: f' . - , . . 1I . .'' - 11i . ' , 4 .' r , r .. F' - .r 'A ° r ' ',} r ' "' f I .. „',ail, - , `r °..`. Februar ; 1993 . .. h. } ' . f ' I "l' r : ,. '.C r'4 . z r ; , ?.°, 1, i' , ' _ i ,` ti' r, - .4 .'r ..' I i '' ` F . 1, ? i . r ' r r ,iT Y 1?.!, 'ir r _ ` ,,i . I L ' r • . ' ,f' . ' ' I. _ . r r1, } .1 •Y,/ ,+(jl, f,' It . .. , r . .? ' f S.. ,,, 'r r ?3 (,, !ii •?5 ,' , . 1'' ' `.tl l.. .s '.Sr 4r!!'e'; I.J!r'`ij S' •,- ..? . ?'.'.:i t 1 f 1 { . ? 1 I .. i ? 11 r ? ? f ANALYSIS OF REQUEST FROM HARBOR OAKS ASSOCIATION TO CLOSE DRUID ROAD AND BAY AVENUE INTRODUCITION Clearwater's Harbor Oaks neighborhood is a well established residential area located convenient to downtown Clearwater. It is bounded by the downtown area to the north, the Morton Plant Hospital complex to the south, Fort Harrison Avenue to the east, and Clearwater nay to the west. -A map of the area is shown in Figure 1. The Harbor Oaks Association, a neighborhood homeowners' group represented by their president, Mr. -Cedio Saltarelli, has requested the permanent closure of both Bay Avenue and Druid Road at their intersections with Jeffords Street. These closures, as described by .Mr. Saltarelli's June 2, 1992, letter to Mayor Garvey (Appendix A), would "...protect our single- family residential area from, the pollution'and traffic hazards to our residents and children caused by thousands of motorists daily traversing the Harbor Oaks 'residential area to reach other destinations;" The Harbor Oaks Association has, over the past several years, expressed their concerns about traffic in their neighborhood, particularly as it relates to the operations of the Morton Plant Hospital complex. The expansion of the hospital facilities has pushed its boundaries, toward the perimeter of the neighborhood. Several former, single family residences have been converted to medical offices, and further hospital expansion is anticipated. The Association's concerns have not only been of traffic volume, but also of traffic mix.' A major concern has been the Hunter Blood Center's mobile donation coaches, which were, until recently, parked overnight in a lot at the corner of Bay Avenue and Jeffords. Early each -?' morning, these coaches were started and.warmed up before departing to their collection sites. These vehicles have since beeri relocated, and their storage area has been converted to a doctors' parking lot. Other concerns expressed by the association included ambulances travelling through the neighborhood to reach the hospital's emergency room. During the past three years, the Transportation Group of the Public Works Department has conducted several traffic studies within the'Harbor Oaks neighborhood. In June, 1990, the Association requested a four-way Stop at the intersection of Bay Avenue and Magnolia Drive, in an effort to reduce the amount and speed of traffic along Bay Avenue., At that time, the Transportation Group studied traffic along Bay Avenue and Druid Road; the requested four-way Stop was not installed as nationally-accepted standard volume warrants were not satisfied, but speed limit signs along Bay were installed to emphasize the 25 mph limit. In late 1991 and early 1992, at the request of the Association, the Transportation Group conducted additional studies in the neighborhood, including counts along Jasmine Way, Magnolia Drive, Lotus Path, Jeffords Street,, and Pinellas Street, as well as updated counts along Druid Road and Bay Avenue. Additional counts were conducted during July and August, 1992; and January, 1993, as part of the investigation into this request. ? ifs . ?. .. 1 1 ` r ? y • • r Figure 1 Harbor daks Study Area SPOTTI wOODE CT. - SPOTTIS W000E LA, C17Y LIM 175 paw mm- ..atam;, m---. COE RD. ?, 9! ?.J n FLAMINGO DR. \O y ? r W+! ? ,IOMCa IiT.? v c?u ? HGMGRICki R 10 +aie LUR# O ST. A >1.AUR14 `? Q??b ? ?:ooo [ { SR LO CLEVELAND F N PARK T 0 °.c rIEnCE ST. a PIEVICE iT ` ??'' ? 3 FFRANXLIN ST COURT ST, L?a ?? COURT St ;? d I ra Q W4KLR• ? Q 1 t0 , CHESTNUT 5T-OLRt t ROGER 4 4~1 l?ROG RS ST 0ot t UURNUUEpN 3T o TURNER W f f N ? w { t p x?a? [ ALN 0 aIHE aT. _. r P I N E ST PIN T.' v 1¢ t f LR[SCl/R 0 I]R I [It 0 JASMINE WAY t JASMINC WAY MACH IA DR I MAGNOLIA D11, ?a? LOTUS W PATH w LOTUS W PATH 4 W .d aye ? a=? ? ?? b n JErrOROS sT a F i :s¢ f O W ' ? F-? ..'1 f ? 1 o?z -? an0 CENTRA ST, y r Rlcx<A IHELLAS ST. ??4?W39 a E2 we? TUSKAVe1LLA ? ? T ' 4 CI IL in 7 CO ?^ ST U1 , W ? I a ST. ao. ??{ ? cQ LARE y`? ?c n 0' K !' E ST J AICLENHOHO ST 00 as a ca 0 BELL VIEW R0 BELLEVIEQuI _ ?- Z IrILDWO0p WAY W ? J C7 Y ? WOOpLAWN ? =?M ' U AVE. WOODLAWN 2T. ROES IN Q :?I noesG W W W !? ?? I = J W i .}r ?? o .sue a 31 0 i ?„ ?{?'A 11 '16 . .. - - . , ..a?':. . ! , ' r r , ' '. ........-.'.-..... _.. ... J....o«.'..w+w.1'1 1 The request to close Druid Road and Bay Avenue was originally scheduled for presentation at the October 15, 1992, City Commission meeting. ' A copy' of the Agenda package, which included a staff recommendation to deny the Association's request, was furnished ion the Association for theirreview. Then, at the request of the Association, the package was removed from the Commission's Agenda so that further discussions with City staff could be held. On December 3, 1992, representatives of the Harbor Oaks Association met with City staff members from the Fire Department, Planning and Development Department, Public Works / Utilities Group (Solid Waste), and Public Works / Transportation. During this meeting, the following, points were raised by the Association: o ' The volume of traffic along Druid Road has increased significantly over the past several years. The Association attributes this to the unrestrained growth of the Morton Plant Hospital complex, the County office facilities, and the congestion along South Fort Harrison Avenue: o Speeding is a problem along Druid-Road, and. there has been no visible police traffic enforcement. The Association's representatives pointed out that -there are no good "hiding" places for speed enforcement vehicles along Druid Road, and that Druid Road has a substandard design. . o Trucks frequently use Druid Road to access the hospital, Belleview Mido Hotel, and other points, despite the signed truck restrictions. o Zoning has allowed the hospital (and its supporting facilities) to encroach upon the ieighborhood, with no buffer between ]and uses. o The character of the Harbor Oaks area has changed dramatically, and the residents are concerned about further deterioration of the quality of life in their neighborhood. CURRENT CONDI'T'IONS Link traffic counts collected during the past three years are summarized in Figures 2 (24- hour total), 3 (morning rush hour), 4 (evening rush hour), and 5 (highest hour for, each link). Dates are shown with each 'count, so that comparisons between counts can easily be, made ' (although some acknowledgement of seasonal variations must also be considered). Turning movement counts made at the intersections of Druid Road and Jeffords Street, and South'Fort Harrison Avenue at Druid.Road, Lakeview Road, and Belleview Road, during the morning and evening rush hours, are shown in Figures d through 9. A speed" study on Druid Road, to the north of Jeffords' Street,. shows that the average speed through this section is 25 miles per hour (which is also the posted speed limit) and the -3- a ?7 {? t' .1 ? ••.t ' GOUkT ST 4 C"ESTNUT ST TLlR1JER ST 3397 w 803 5 $rS (h3) N z 1021 (I 1q3) t(1l9?) r. ¢ (. jai) x .?. Z DRUtD Rv - 35 2N;?$g S Z ;? NO SCALF ( (93) (ylRZ . A5HINE WY MAGWUA DR Q J . Of LOTUS PATH y24 2 7qv 1180 s 225 a ;. (2/92') (11,191)-4q3) 3592- ! .19:FrORPS ST 4 f 1-709 81 ) 1405Pital ( ?a?) r o 3976 ' NEL.1-AS ST u ('7190 r =4--. 3703 6?9s' h 0 CITY LIMITS i u CORBE-rT ST a Ccluniry c rab . K?vti?v? R4 ?A Figure 2 a ELLEvIEvJ RD Traffic Counts 24-Hour Totals z ; ISO z d_ -4- •: 11 fl! .•y. fs ' ' ' i ° i p i ? 'f r• , ; r ?? 111 ' . y ' ? .a! . I ? .. ? ? ,1 ? 7 / r I • l' 1 ' ` I 5 iFr ? ? • ? ? l ? s . } 1 I ?1 ! ? ' r ? ? ? 9`7 ? t" v? ? !. e , 1., : .. ? is 7 + l `..+?': .aJ- . .a ti .. 7i ? ? •...-1 ....... -... ..-... ..?.,... .... ..- ..._yu" 1 ? 1 CGUZT ."ST Q C"F-STNUT ST I E' R' ST TURN r ,w 117 c1r93? e 173 ?5o c?w3) M ? so b t ? ? x GIg3) Q ?I?Q3) 1 DRuiD Rv i Z41 (IZ.j91) nb 5CqLE J RSM INF. ICY MAGNOLIA DR ; Q J LOTUS PATH - 71 4q ZZIO NcI {I?R3) (1291) ae i r -C JEFFORDS ST x 87 (719 H oSDito 1 0 (1214+) . Y 281 i F'INELI-AS ST u ?r t t--7 CITY LIMITS V0] cwtBETT ST p ' . re a tLEutiEvJ RU L p? C3EL?LEvIEw RD Figure 3 Traffic Counts Morning Rush Hour ? ? -5-_ 'sir ^f 1J'. q t Lae .' ,,' 1;}' { 1 ', , o- fel ?`7f?Y?,??a; ,' :• •;F .',. • ' ' ' r . f , r '.. f(: .. ,r •3 e7y$ ,x,'99, ' CdURT 5T 4 + CFAE6TNUT ST T ' `' ' • Ilo(1/43? f b? (1 1113) 4.?y TURWER ' ST j 93 N SS ?g a ss ({193) ; 93 c1?43) k ? Gt93) Ago SCAI.C JR5F11NE WY Q MAGNOLIA DA Ick 1 -49 1) W m J H O 3yg( ) f 2 I.0T 5 PA-rH ? '1 3 y//1 19 47(121gr '17?IZfgI) o J5: FFORDS' ST x 98(7raz) NoSpital 2 C z qr} 32? ; 1 PINELI-A5 ST Ale tL ; 2) {71x{ S CITY LIMITS VDi coPBf: rT s- 0: V) J . Coun`?ry G lib , ¢ . . , R ' Figure 4 BELLSVIE W P Traffic Counts ° Evening Rush Hour r - • ? J t. i ? ' ' ' o - „•• Ali '*'? t, .? COURT ST 4 CHESTNUT ST 117 ( 8a? ?( 9 - ? ) -rURWG'R ST • r ?? . ? g Q 75 Z 3p) {12- ?) LI2-3), a } o ? ©RtlID Rv" • -3 C x P NO 5CA LE, z(gI C 1 JRSHINE wY MRGWOA DR ' Q J 4 LoTO5 PATH 362 $I(?-3pM)(1?4? ig ?I-5 P) (12-Ipu) • c?1gx) 120(3-p?)(,?j ? (IL?q ti) 4c JEFrORDS sT Y { t?42) ?$ l (IG-II AA) ('714 L) 4,76 (2-3p) NOspital o (t2jgl} - 324, 'Y 4 IL (5 1 PINEI-C ST -b pm) (7lg2) 380 0 s CITY LIMITS V) ' r COROl+TT 57 ' Ca?l??ry G lub - E R? t? vJ LP% R Figure 5 t3EI-LIEVIEW D . Traffic Counts Highest Hour of Day I`ti?. F.i Si.,, •Is '?-? ;Y.."' 1 i .. .r• ?',?+ r ,?7,ti 3i is;il«,Ltl.'r.. ,'. _ ? r- °,j' ?'f ,. ? r:• -> 1, ? • ?''`'.', i .,? ?'''€t ";', 1§'? 'i r !?. .'L , y.. P.i,?: ..,1a .'x`3.7 :??•J? 4yt? •3F', ii '?( At ? . i. .t, ? .1.• , i a , 1 .. `.(. ? .' , ;t ._'E _iF •?? .i,?Ttrf t a 3 i e•?I r r ` ' a' 1,+ f,•J •? l??w r .' i4,? ?.f-, , r,.", i.... .°f c ? ? F ? . •,'!•. ,,i. or)r 1' .. ' '• I `'7JY lllr ' .iar1:1?1 1.' A .. I 1 a r• 0 4' S ?'}?.'r i??, ? `f??' .:a. b'`,?V t .al,^•.S" '??. 1 }?." I;L A; - S? ? [ i r'I a •IY ..!'{. A•f^'}t ;?i?.i?l.•ir, ,.?.•'i? ;?_.?'' j-'k • ?f•..'??':;?'''. ..4?..;rfa '.,-!,. :t. - .. ,' ea'. ' :ir;?}, .,':/laps: r'y'. - .X ' fl•!'r .'1i ! ]•T 55, / ..1, t, ,.f'•'? ?. I:k?? i!•rF? Il.t?p.r •F'• ;Y:,t'1i+`?=•.F. h?',' '.! < .. ? r ?? 1 ?? '? ? ? S i •1i ?t??°n?"':?r`Y'':r.;"-r' ?'. ,>-f?'r.. a€` '?' -.? a?'?'!?{`•!? '?' .t _ `6 .. :. t :F I,',.• r: ;?rr55•?:i?r F?A1t'`??4•. :,?''t__F-, t 1.9 `.?j' •.'A ?.i.•r. ?,, •,7°0?::`:• - 'r. r,• - ,',, ! 1. r 1' , ? •i?.l. , °? "f?'-??'.7f• •?• '??'?•' i Ir,?q' :i. 'A:: 4`.1tj ..l? „4fi'3.. R. , '/ 'r!' ..L . .l'' .r ?r.a X' •?1+ _' ? .. ? 's?i., °r :!, k:}yrS1 j i,r =, .ra:,.F 'fr J'_ ?.r.?..,:j, p. i•x??n.a•.al?iil ,. ,, l:?#,? ? Y ?. ?1 ' ? i :f'.; ;;1 f7? Jr r •=, F' 4.- •i ?' ./". ! e...y,•..F , sie. ` 'r1 Y . r .. '., . if .. •'!'? ,. ?. `1?? 1 .t' :i al'x '!?w ,b'EE `•2 1?- .l . -I, ? . k' ? 1` .? r I '? a?,r. ?,?Yr ',1?,5 f. ?•?, ?'?; ,.3 °s?.?; ''f.?l1;#?'. ;7i•.-. ?•?' ?+?t'• ,., ", ? ' .,F,' „- .y: "j,r", `t'!} ?it?f i . of ? : PF' yf,)F:' g,?`?'.,€r=:.. ,?F,;?'i6'F.,<{,;'3a' €??' ,._? 'f' . F c a'? ? r • ''? ? {},'? eE' ?1 •G SF, 'i ": ;P (' •(` -•),' s{?1``?'11 %i ?7?`•^,?. a°'f.?% .:.' .?. .`,??? ?..I f .e .;j YJ? R? ?"?, ?, r. r „1:•e'i..e.. ,?{:sl??}t!? F 3 ?'??° r :s ° ? ? .. ? r t• 1 y ` '`" ? ?y j[1 1 i { F.' r ?- t ' s- ? • ? , '.t +, ? ?s; ?'i'4?f.i ,s•?:.p?r?i Y`.^rr; :. :`i'a.v t ... '!° "a.:4;w } t,?;?Y y ??:-•,..,-a.`,i7..',`.xl: .° .. ?. .. ? .. ?. .,a - ..,.. ? .•.., .s: ? yti: >' k•:> '! s :9 ? : . ,may ? ?? -I r 1 C?k•.. ;4 /Lf 19 >, pQa 2 2 app 91 ?L`. J • .. r : ? 1 i f ? ? it Figure 6 ° Turning Movement Counts '• . Druid Road at Jeffords Street :. 'fir<tijs°', ., ?L. ,.. r a - ` • i ' '• r 7jiic '. ?.?.'Y,`*i?ft r?-: % x ?'? •ra u?-' ?r7? .' S.. 2' 'f :I:" ?r , 7 ,e.y .'.l ?; (Y?<a .i: r<t n? '1'ai• -.a•' .is ;s•::?'RF" iv°: '.4"art+'T'ftA. C',.y?,t• .?,J .i: a .. ., r .t•j '' . .4 FII: .t.a5; :'{?, ?•?? ;[•,: j'?;.'??'?.? ,1' ,;;.?' # ?,,.' ,r?i'? ,rr- j. '.L,i ,•T 8', 'fit, •':'?'r y,,..: ??..-i:`fy }'! Viz, '.S(°y"!' 7 ?a t1 ap - r :'' ar - t. •Y,' 13.? !i.' ., ? a :y^???• -..ta .? _ y ria rfl. T a Ir vir?,?f`m?%; l - ,i f .,,t,i • •f` '? {•, :1#3's ,; rl'.-?s?;.;, :3:' ? , prat' ? ?' ' . - r r [ e.?.r ? ? : rJ .t? ?'? {?n? Fe r't,i yaf -l, r ?It ?r"ri ,r? r°.r?.l F,r ;i<`°,i' - ''•`: , .. x? iii `', ff t 3 - ,<,,1 < +• ?,F. •'' ,J}. Z'f,`yt y: 4?, °'VS•.l` '.tr 1. ?1, 1?' a ?'r?l l.l./.?sj. '1}, ? ., ?,' .• ? .jt'.i} ?'' p ?.,?jf ?•: !f? ?. i -'a;, ?'•i' ,`?''+,?•S'1 7 :Sv;' _ .'I r • .• ,)'' :•xt '?{?f Saar 'i .!• .$ : =.3 .. } '. ? . '6:'? 'Y4,? ,.?i ?+? r' (( rji- ?; . •! + .. ' ? ? r .: •<?.. ,a , ??h yn<S IJ/,L 'At' 't ••1; ..4{ t '7 .i ''•Y !/ r?I•r .:f''F(. ((fp'r,?., ?i ry'i??' r' ^,rF t °•!s? ?i vf,.' ? i. r ?r??. ° f,,Wl; ' -S", x:2 i'a i.t '°'i rj, ~y,Y'?' T.?.,.5,- •7, .! •4t '1'.•,• ''# ? i (. _ 1 ?k ?. { ?rpSrn'-}?.n?. j '_?'? ,.Y :r'?. .1,X:' i.?s•,. 'I ,r ? T .'s. - e..i ? -fir :•` $ e ,f `!.?%.. .?. <• 'ri ?7? FA e. a,F Yr? ?i 'i ''i1. •,ar ??r',3 t?a.5 r'J'i. a: 7'?'.• 't" *.. ri^7. 'r? r ? '.. .. ': . , •E' r .j :el }ia...s 'S'',::5; .. •r ;,}',? i?• `=r .t1'y?.t1 f'' .rJ,. V ? tr'x: ?'r' •,t i r.. - .. i '•i 's: ?• to .('}I„1:.%:??` ?_;`. '.f''? te•i .,?i ryir'i ik .i' J i? `S' '?•• •!x", :i? `j-. ". 1. ? 3"ff?, !C: !. ??(.' err :>~9t ,1. ''p F" .1 r' .i!•:{: .:k. ,,' '.1'. .;r - Js' I4 :i3?a?f?i? .Y?ir _ 1.. ,??• f,y', rsl '; 1'S. .R t .i..• '(. '/? r. ?/ ,i •.T rl? Nri?n?! r?, ,. trr '•?i?' ?Yi';=;,'•}`t?x«l.: y?.:C ;(.r?,ri.{..r. .a .i. -j? .f3 r•'I.', "?._ ..??€. '',' •f '1. ?•{?,i. 3•; .1 •?ja ,fit .? ., I, 7.:1'F'` .r ?l.f ,I. 1'!r• r1J..t. v'a??'f 7? ?'!''r?a •Ss' 'ly t 'i: #i?r ?..w ,ri't .S? `d'ta}'' "?i, ,ts ?r wa??. 3'°?.? .r k,?, •,:..?•G•'i: •s '. i' t f =e:. r, '??.t.`. ?a 'a`e a?. '•/!-+''!. '>.f`?aa .j [? '1 a•'?' :>=• it ?1. ???- j,'y(" ,i ', ??y ?: '.?'y?rl;? -A^t. ?. Tts? :!•'s -i:. . ,? ?,?' ' _i' .S r 1. t: '•?:-[,...., +'st?n. !r` .i,'if .?y?, [R r'f??,i,:??s,.•?'? ?? !.9' [. ?:!?i L r '?; i „>Mr ?, I ,'t '.l, ` •F Fri ?? f<r.i+, w.+?,f?f>r I? ...i,. «?r. . i.2'...-.?,. ir.n•<r,C:?':t???,.a .. .r M« , ... .... r ,. .•.,. .. ..,, '?i:.?m . r ...'•".?..:.TaiW!t? 00 1,- • .3, ?t .: ,tom ??F .. ? •?1 5? i - i ',?? t•?•'''r"5 zr4 `. 495 2 330 AM ff X... 5 AEA}. 6b to N 3cllc,,jte&J . -?. N ?3 i fish-. •?: .. t ` ? .. •. r .. , ... '1 ? ? ,.lt. Figure 71, Turning'Moveme'nt Counts'.. 'Fort' Harrison at. Belleview iS?llW'??•. 'r(: a ,?' ?° ', ? :?,' '. '. xF?' ?? J'?', •?i=air'?t'?ky(' . a$i3j?`r;^;ti-'t?+?:, ?'r i-t_ 1;'.n,+.'t J•. ?t- - _ .Y' .?: .,,,..o y f?.e r+? .,a..y ,, •r s •,':r.' ?af': a.:'1,,,}'?., .y' ,c:`, ` :1 i? .. ? ' , "r, - ',.4.?,?, .?wl.ti"7,4-/`t°'4 r :i?'?:y?stl +- ? la,`-?. .?,ii• ;!+' rsr .j.ft •?i,.;;'?:''?"r5 r,'..5?'t?. '`!1 •, ., ,+ '+, J'?I '??' _ 'j?,;+r'a?'?'? ?y='• ,r, »?.?,'+,•, a•, ' '?, :?' !'?=7t 6i;Si :' - .• :i, le e r Mai` S:.f'. ,?5; ,.i _,}: •l? J.. J.1.'1, r'S?¢?y?.':?? r,.?rj•'-.n. , 1'• ,i. •,}? '?', 'i'p??,:lE '.1?:? ,!. .:'e' i. .r? .Stm:',,}a 1'• {? ? + -/ ?r.F ?f1[tr , w'..?// '?F !7`'?'1`t' '•f J?2?'%,.. :q: 7`?.?'}' Pt 41'°_ F `'1' ° .r! „]?61,• .?}7•` 4. .,•y.. `!j_ c6 i a„4r: •s I•.j iyf?]'` .?: .'., ?1 .' .. 'f I? - ?•j'i. '+ 'f syi'° / }! tl. F''"%,? ..L. '; Y.Y,'Y. i?ii? ''f¢i,l,'..i? 1 ?'1. 'l '?!' 1'.•'Y, I¢.' I .r' ?Y iR''?s}? :r?. ?I''- .1?, ,ir.}r• i,2'.f K{: .?'•' ? , [[.?r? _,, :c. `,'"?'Y?S. CR ".f`i? .,F, a/.. '??. ?-5•".:?. ay?1' '°S L. ?',L ). 'I. .,f'?1''+'? .F fi :,t ? ???.. ?.1'.'-l?.h :: i l'. '?F ((, ya'd ,?..o.r w>;a E? ••?` ?'i'- J' f° 'll'•'P. ..ay? °•{ Y' r`Jr ? ?-f'Y , 1, t. `?. r;,l`?x'd :; ?';.• , y. '?'. .Fiala;': r.:.?y frl"!1?,1%;`.J{(•L`.. ,,Ic;?.`- .?' .'?',. •,4?. y rLr {1 e - t., `li' f. •`i ' ,2, .'? (3 4If, :1 . 'r. •!r. ? 'fie/,-? 4•? ?•ao:4': '.l•i Fr 'i'°7, 4."?. t.?w-?YSLI•, f, r'Syd +SY r},? ty• , ri . ?•r, E+'°i-11.? t?'?e?f '? Cr 4 r4,';i; 2'.M?r ?1? .'eI ? .r •.ti?: ,, ?e' ,2 •r;4:,,, ?,i?: f. ••fi, =va .'3/,.'i 's. s. ,4Y:??1`Il}fl/. •''R}.¢?' ? •r'" ,; e: r?•+11 `ix;.i,. :+, -`F.' "?? •?. .} ,71•: i.r '•.s?? ? ';/ i ? -?,' 'as 'r, ? ? '7.1. 'r: o,???s, pw?U',?1i°.Y :r7,. +??`?-•. ?-?:i •ax'ir. ,vp"', rv •? ?.' ?'i•?+ :', ??p- ' ;f' . a r. ".c ?.}' .^'` M.+i'{I,M? wI.T, '`i +.:I ` r} 3 ..• . ,. :S':''::T.?,.f?.o13.r.h?i?'1•i.#5rF'+k1,L R.Y.i-?vP. •, SFr.'t , .. r.. r - .. .. r . ., -•. -j'?}.'l.'n•'. `)`•a . .,, . .<.'>i .I? ., r+'fMii ?' 'I f. ,r 4 •. 1. I. ? j ' •} ' ?+' ?' y?: J r M I } a i .'r 1'.i'Vctf'f in t9 R'^i • + 1', ? .. ..2?: Mtfr ry. IY_ q•fv r ,? r 4 ? - i # rjrri:=. 10 30 3' .. 'PM 32 it PEAK' PEAK - '.; 3?3 ' 2 f I s;. La ke vt' co 0 1- ??`<I? ??5.?. .. _ 1, . •. `. r.l 1.2 `? .. ? ° •; •;., '•3'.1'. I 7 ?f. ?I •??. ,` ,f? ,?! .: ` ' •' ?' ? ' -',' Figure 8 Ms: ' :' ' • r Turning"rMavement Counts 'r.. Fort.Harrison at Lakeview' , ,.y. «...!r.-•+,wi,Y?":.r"`r °';;?t;:rY?!11:•}y,rS,'`1v°:7'Y."T':t. "'•,w'y wnr...••IV,..?t,,,;.??..+.«.... rwr,. , . e .. ¢:.Fr: J r P' ?•. r .i{1 f?:, {.a` ';=i i:. ,.^,r•.I bl'.«?-'? ikr:3,a ? '.r i.'.,?j: .. 1 .. y= ..g. :rf:: ., z..l,. .i•,•fT`.! ?1L rlC..Y)rfl ?;;I,?, :?? `?,«?. ;.t?+ ?3';,',4•'y, j:.5 ?b„' _ ', ? ?,' ? - 1; ?4r J +- .?i';ja;.3§t: a'J1 Fy "r L4g n`:, a ..,' 'i4 .. (; ?4'? ? .s - d t 4, 3• . , )• 'r :?4?, y 11,?Yf.•1 s `M1^! , ¢ ? ° ?"' :''. .l .k:,:.? 5 ,: Sl- ' I ..r r ' ' :.F !'. ?f'.: _ •'?! : rI , a.l.f,i F , Rio. F.. >•1 'J° •6 ? ?•h' !, ,r) •.S ?t?lyh,,r?.Ti `" `i',• f . ..t. ??a - 'f• /f .t-r?i r,': r°1 {?+r?. ?... c?;? y° =t''ti-6" •'?.;i :?•y'y?"i.5''•"+:?' i .3. ., '?„ 'S.' '`, .??•-i,?:ir;'i'lr; f 1, '.? .[s 2'-• - .y`.1•' .l• :, ?s k'. /fi: i `.j?'. ? . " rr `. i • ,?rT - •Si? 3 Fit>.. 4!. ?- ! `) ? J '+?," '!' `l .•'+,i-?.+? r ,y, acy., t i`: "1'' ..,r, ,!r•?4- "•I ?r r`._ . ep'r' ..r b', i'' ? j=;. :.*i r`'}+?'r aS(;,r F?' `i"§'. i' .Y .'T? •,¢^..'re `t 'r, '!" ,f is t• rw a?w1f" .1 "1,• .•t' ilf'. h`':';' ,Ic.' a?..?'i..t.7.. ?' E¢i. ,, ,: 'a ,'?'.1t' .I Sy„!.; - ?i.-f'il. ?t,j,$ ..,prn 'i.t'yy 3r. .D d.?• '_"' s. ?. .• ?l' ,' ,'i,.?.?. ?, 'r'?t'.='•.yff?'. ' ', r-r: i. ?/! 4„ ,f.,'.ct ¢?? 1:,5 y o , ,r ?•')?-?.+ 'v'. yg •yr i''?;?a t?5•j!•'.F' ? -Er' ?:;Fr'r 'L s r .'!. .r !? ,r` .. / r' ',e• T?'r.ir. i.: •4. ?;. ?a r? rS'y ? 4 s?, SaS.r .? :'X t !.•. 'I'~•,s! -r t'. y r ° !. ? .•1'.{! ?r ,. ..i' )r, a?;; 1!', .[': ?/ iii, .dg ..r. 5'k'' '1, ? o ? , •=L .5 ' t •' 1' ?i 9 ,la4?4'brx'' !i. '?'. s>{. '?.,#:. ,t•) _ .. •?. - rr ,1. ?r. ??1?'?-?°'!?'. ,ia,.eer[?.%'sk;,'tr ,, ri.ts ?:, r??!)..i,?? '!- .^,.e.•.rrklr.;.a:d1Ct?..:S`?'?.-. Y.•5''A,??k:'e:.. . ,+- . .. , .t' .-.?. 1 apir??I. r ? .1 1 ,r ? r r ? '. ' ,. ? ' , j ? r I ? !f ' , .. ' i , ?, r, •i` S I y'1,?pj •' -^f ?? ?y, ' ? ,r?. .. .I; i f r / J ,.'.; , r r', ..r . . ., - ? I • F,. 1 ,?f ,, c?•.9f % CO 0 • F. . .. 0 N ai 3 ''? .f'. 57 PM ?.: 49 30 65 7 PEAK , 62 80 PEAK . -` 92 '' ' 2I 53 9 6,9 wtl '? = ? ' . .. . , - • . ? ? ' ?` ' '':'fir % j D rug d ,; ti7 t? tV : z I-D • - .. r ., ,' • ?_ r' , r ? ` .? .S', rte •}`'- ? ? .. _•, / .. ?r .y ? ? ? :SFr Figure 9 ,-: Turning Movement Counts... r r Harrison', at aDruid ????, i ? s' ,,r !r .t1.( f 4 ' , ? '. .. . 3 s . `, , ? '6-•?: .. .ei'a ?4# :4$ •a Y'Y 4' .'!. 7 85th percentile speed (the speed at which 85 percent of the traffic travels at or below) was approximately 33 miles per hour. Traffic accidents reported within the study area during 1991 are plotted in Figure 10. There was np indication of a recurring accident problem within the Harbor Oaks residential area, t. THE SOURCE OF THE TRAFFIC Why do over 4,000 vehicles a day travel along Druid Road through Harbor Oaks? It was originally believed that most of the traffic was generated by the Morton Plant Hospital complex, the Belleview Mido Hotel, and some residential traffic from Belleair. However, observation shows that much of the traffic, at least during peak commute periods, really starts as far south as'Seminole and the Gulf Beaches. Indian Rocks Road starts at Walsingham Road and continues north through Largo, Belleair Bluffs, and Belleair, and ends at a Tee intersection with Belleview Boulevard. A turn to the east on Belleview brings you to South Fort Harrison; a turn to the west connects to Druid .Road. According to the Belleair Police Department, Indian Rocks Road, at a point just north of Ponce De Leon Avenue, carries 21,425 vehicles per day, on a two-lane "residential" roadway. Figure I I demonstrates why the Indian Rocks Road / Druid Road corridor is so popular with commuters. During a typical morning peak period, and assuming a starting point of Indian Rocks Road and West Bay Drive in Belleair Bluffs, there are two primary commuter routes to downtown Clearwater -- east on West Bay, then north on Clearwater-Largo Road (which .becomes Fort Harrison); or north on Indian Rocks Road and Druid Road to Fort Harrison. The first route is 4.1 miles long and passes through eleven traffic signals. The second route is 3.3 miles long and passes through one signal, one four-way stop, and one three-way stop. The attraction is obvious. Most of the Indian Rocks Road commuter traffic chooses to use Belleview Road to reach Fort Harrison Avenue, resulting in significant congestion at the Belleview / Fort Harrison signalized intersection during the peak periods. The remaining traffic follows Belleview to the west, then heading north on Druid Road to the Harbor Oaks area. There, the traffic patterns disperse. Some motorists heading for Clearwater Beach or the County Government complex turn off of Druid onto northbound Orange Avenue; then east'on Turner Street; then north on Oak Avenue to Chestnut or Court Street. Others use northbound Oak Avenue, despite its limited width, the entire length from Druid to Chestnut. Still others, heading for points north or east of downtown, continue east on Druid to Fort Harrison or beyond. During the evening peak, the pattern reverses itself, as traffic accesses Druid Road at several points, to eventually head south to Indian Rocks Road. I? r ~ ? P- f '? a ? li I 1 '? - a ?r ? ? ,? ? ? { ? ? t •r f : i p , ? r . ' . - ?.. . I ? ? )'t? • • 5, if ??if ' ? f'> f{,fir ? ? 'r I" t . f f l F , • ? Y I !t' I ? , r ..??.'i'1','b.,t?l ?(r? r, ? , f . ? ' ,. ? ' ' ! k r r t ,, Druid Road f e,y ?1. Jasmine Way t, ; ,r • T:? .If 1 Magnolia Drive _ c , I E ' { Lotus Path t d S -15 tree Jeffor s Morton Plant Hospital Pinellas Street' f City Li Figure 10 Accidents. Within Study Area Calendar Year 1991 vl? ?wZ It'll a. p.?? E•`. h. h, •. t ? r t ' Figure II r C Comparison of Corridors L ,:nrro` qtr t :i,ueR? (is J! ¦ ?L?M4CIINf+/ pR Y ?? WyR At ar e? .? -rA++lrR? I ,Rr F • ?tfxrri «14- H S w 761 mN III"' r b - :It rr. N' ?1 W ? nr tiu x cr E ?0 W R _N ALT 19 w nr s . r 1 I• ,, .fir : , ' Y ? . . ,' .R.s-._ .,, I .. 'r! ' '.f, t, I. 1.1 .r1?'. 1.. ' i A ' i I 'r ••.f't I HOW MUCH IS TOO MUCH TRAFFIC? The Transportation Group frequently, receives complaints from Clearwater citizens about the amount of traffic being carried by residential streets. It is easy for a traffic engineer to describe the imount of traffic on an arterial or major roadway by comparing the volume'to the roadway's capacity; for example, US 19 carries in excess of 90,000 vehicles per day,-- far above. y its estimated capacity of about 65,000 vehicles per day, and therefore receiving a Level Of' Service rating of "F". On most residential streets, traffic volumes do not come close to the capacity,of the . street. There is no congestion, and generally there is a low (or non-existent) accident history, because of the limited exposure of conflicting traffic movements. The concern is primarily the. environmental quality of life along the local residential streets. During its busiest hour of the day (3:00 - 4:00 PM), Bay Avenue carries about 120 vehicles (total of both directions), or roughly one vehicle every thirty seconds. -,During the evening commuter "rush" hour, it carries about 75 vehicles,'or one vehicle every 48 seconds. Based on a 24-hour total of 1,180 vehicles per day (vpd), the average drops to one vehicle every, 73 seconds. Druid Road carries considerably more traffic. Based on the February, 1992 counts on Druid Road to the north of ]effords Street, about ane vehicle every ten seconds passed the count station during the peak hour of 12:00 - 1:00 PM. The 24-hour total of 4,242 vehicles per day (vpd) reflects an average, of one vehicle every twenty seconds. For comparison purposes, following is a table showing some of the 24-hour, volume counts taken this year: Lantana Avenue, North of Mango 95, vpd Brattle Lane, West of Northridge 425'vpd Beckett Lake Drive, South of Sun Tree 479 vpd Frisco Drive, South of State Road 580 1,027 vpd Bay Avenue, Nortlz of Jeffords 1,180 vpd Stag Run, West of US 19 1;284 vpd Haverhill Drive, East of Peachtree Circle 11465 vpd El Tair Trail, North of Northeast Coachman 1,800 vpd Northridge Drive, South of Sedgef field 2,205 vpd Wildwood Drive, West of Quail Hollow. 2,920 vpd Airport Drive, West of Gilbert 3,950 vpd , Druid Road, North of Jeffords 4,242. vpd Harn Blvd., West of US 19 4,357 vpd Druid Road, West of Myrtle 5,462 vpd Union Street, West of Hercules 6,263 vpd Landmark Drive, South of Bay Meadow Court 7,255 vpd , Countryside Boulevard, North.of Northridge 11,968 vpd Druid Road, West ofHercules 13,076 vpd . I v •' b a .1 The City's Transportation Group has frequently cited 2,000 vehicles per day as the maximum desirable level volume for local streets, based on the Federal Highway Administration's Pesign of Urban Streets roadway classification system. However, the next classification upward from local street. -- collector -- by definition can carry up to 15,000 vehicles periday. A collector street intersects local streets, usually with stop or yield signs on the local streets, and carries traffic to the closest arterial. The roadway characteristics listed in the text would define Bay Avenue as a local street and Druid Road as a collector, consistent with the City's published Functional Classification Plan. IMPACTS OF PROPOSED CLOSURES ON TRANSPORTATION NETWORK The most significant impact on the surrounding transportation network would be related to the displacement of traffic from Druid Road to South Fort Harrison Avenue, as would occur should Druid Road be closed. In` our 1992 counts, South Fort Harrison carried about 27,000 vehicles per day, which approaches a "Level Of Service" (LOS) rating of "D". The closure of. Druid Road would divert at least 3,600 vehicles per day to South Fort Harrison, increasing its daily traffic to approximately 30,600 vehicles per day, and boost the LOS rating to an "E" or higher. The City of Clearwater's Comprehensive Plan, adapted by City Commission on ' November 16, 1989, identifies South Fort Harrison as a "Constrained facility due to 'adjacent development", and has associated a Level Of Service "E" as the desired minimum level of service'. Besides the impacts of additional traffic on the actual traffic flow along South Fort Harrison, the degradation of level of service to the desired minimum also impacts the d)-velopment that-can occur-in the area. As there is no programmed reconstruction of the Alternate 19 corridor within the next'five years, the rea, `.ements of Concurrency would prohibit the addition of more traffic onto South Fort Harrison. This could impact not only the hospital's expansion plans but could also limit any proposed redevelopment downtown or along Fort Harrison. The closure of Bay Avenue, without the closure of Druid Road, would most likely present no significant impact on the surrounding transportation network. IMPACTS OF PROPOSED CLOSURES ON CITY SERVICES' The closure of any street can have an impact on the services provided to the residents 'The Florida Department of Transportation has established Level Of Service "D" as the minimum standard for State Principal Arterials such as South Fort Harrison. However, the: Commission's designation of South Fort Harrison as a Special Transportation Area permits the adoption of Level Of Service "E", • r . f -16- 1. .1 i 1 r, , M 1 r in the neighborhood. The City of Clearwater, through its CPTED (Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design) program, has recognized these impacts and addresses them when evaluating proposed street closures such as those implemented along North Greenwood Avenue. Similar considerations should also be given to closure requests based on factors other than crime prevention. i Therefore, the Transportation Group requested input from the Police and Fire ; Departments as well as the Public Works / Utilities Group, which includes not only solid waste collection but also oversees Emergency Preparedness. Copies of responses are included as Appendix B. In summary, the Police Department indicated that the proposed closures would not have r a, significant impact on the Department's ability to patrol the Harbor Oaks area. Public Works I Utilities also opposed the closures, citing concerns about the maneuverability of solid waste collection vehicles and the servicing' of the area during disaster conditions. However, in subsequent conversations with the Harbor Oaks representatives, the concerns about solid waste collection were resolved through the affected property owners. The Fire Department has expressed two primary areas of concern the limitation of response capabilities to Morton Plant Hospital, and a similar response limitation for the homes in the Harbor Oaks area. The Harbor Oaks Association has expressed an acceptance of longer. response times for emergencies in their area as a trade-off for to the street closures. The Fire Department has tabulated responses to the Harbor Oaks area as well as the Morton Plant Hospital complex. These are,shown in Table 1. r. , Table 1 -- Fire and EMS Responses To Area The Morton Plant Hospital complex is a collection of medical and service buildings (including some older design structures) surrounded by narrow streets. The Fire Department has identified five routes into the hospital area; two of the routes are Druid Road and Bay Avenue through the Harbor Oaks area. Tile Harbor Oaks neighborhood is comprised of large, wood frame, older homes. The Fire Department is concerned about the rapid establishment and potential spread of a stnicture fire in•these older homes; the proposed street closures can not only delay responses but can also -17- `I.,, Year Harbor Oaks EMS Responses Harbor Oaks Fire Responses Morton Plant Total EMS & Fire Responses 1990 8 16 103 1991 19 is 92 1992 11 8 9i t+?. 1 I i . 1 impede fire scene operations. The Fire Marshal has detailed his Department's concerns in two memos that were included in Appendix B.. One area that has yet to be addressed is the potential effect of the closures on the insurability of both the hospital and the individual homes in Harbor Oaks., AIR POLLUTION CONCERNS One of the concerns of the Harbor Oaks Association was the contribution of traffic on Druid Road to air pollution within the neighborhood. ' There are a number of different types of pollutant emissions generated by internal combustion engines -- hydrocarbons (HC), carbon monoxide (CO),'and nitrous oxides (NOx) " are the most prominent. The hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide vehicular emissions are directly related to the speed of the vehicle -- both are significantly higher at idle speed, but drop at running speed. :Stop-and-go cycling of engines also increases the output of HC and CO.' Nitrous oxides remain relatively constant throughout the speed ranges. After consultation with the City's Environmental staff, it appears that the proposed closure of Druid Road Pr Bay Avenue would not cause a significant improvement in the air quality of the Harbor Oaks neighborhood. Vehicular poll utant.emissions are generally dispersed into the atmosphere -- adding to a overall haze and not concentrating along a particular source roadway. Also, the reduction in level of service along South Fort Harrison would result in an increase in the HC and CO emissions due to increased engine cycling. MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL REDEVELOPMENT Morton Plant Hospital is currently in the preliminary planning stages for the redevelopment of their main campus. City staff members met with hospital officials to discuss these plans. Much of the planning is based upon the hospital's proposed acquisition of key properties in the area. The hospital currently envisions a realignment of the campus to -face Fort Harrison instead of its current orientation toward Druid Road. A circular traffic pattern,, with traffic entering the campus from Fort Harrison on Pinellas Street and returning to Fort Harrison on Jeffords Street,, is proposed. Pinellas•Street would be extended to.Druid Road, and Jeffords would be widened. The hospital would ask that Bay Avenue be. vacated between Pinellas and Jeffords Streets; Reynolds Avenue would be upgraded as a replacement interior north-south link for Bay. In an October 16, 1992, letter to Mr. Saltarelli of the Harbor Oaks Association, Morton Plant's President and Chief Executive Officer Frank V. Murphy, III, indicated that the hospital believes that it is in the "...mutual long-range interest of Morton Plant and the Harbor Oaks Association to support the closing of Bay Avenue at Jeffords...". However, he went on to e 1 • ' • ,.Il 4. • 1 x- /, = ; I? Sa ` ' r i t comment that "We would not find that the closing of Druid Road would be beneficial to Morton Plant". SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS The closure of any street results in a loss of transportation and emergency access options. The decision to close a street must weigh the loss of the option versus the gain from the removal' of traffic from the neighborhood. From an engineering standpoint, neither Bay Avenue nor Druid Road possess a uniqueness that demands the elimination of traffic. However, from the neighborhood's viewpoint, the existing traffic conditions present an intolerable situation. The Harbor Oaks Association requested the permanent closure of two city streets -- Bay Avenue and Druid Road. Each street has unique characteristics and therefore should be considered independently. Bay Avenue should undoubtedly be classified a local street. It currently carries about 1,180 vehicles per day, well within the maximum desirable volume count of 2,000 vehicles per day as described by the Federal Highway Administration. The proposed closure of Bay Avenue would shift some traffic to other roadways, but would probably not present a significant impact to existing levels of service. Druid Road appears to fully meet the definition of a collector street (and has been , so classified by the City of Clearwater), and should normally be expected to carry a higher level . of traffic. The existing.volume counts of approximately 4,250 vehicles per day do not seem to be out of line for a collector street, even though it traverses a residential neighborhood. The major drawback of the proposed closure of Druid Road, from a transportation viewpoint, would be the negative effects on the level of service of the primary diversion route, South Fort Harrison Avenue. Most important, however, is that the closure of either Bay Avenue or Druid Road would have a significant negative impact to the Fire Department's capability to respond to emergencies, both in the hospital complex and in the Harbor Oaks neighborhood itself. The Public Works / Utilities group has also expressed strong concerns about debris clearance after a major storm. In summary, the immediate and complete closure of Bay Avenue and Druid Road, as requested by the Harbor Oaks Association, would, significantly and negatively affect public safety, traffic flow, and the potential for-'development in the southern part of downtown and along the Fort Harrison corridor. The key to this last sentence is the phrase hi mediate and complete. If capacity constraints along the South Fort Harrison corridor could be resolved by roadway improvement projects, and if the access concerns of the Fire Department and Emergency Management coordinator could be accommodated, perhaps by partial street closures or mountable barriers, then City staff would have no objections to a plan to reduce traffic within Harbor Oaks. 1 F r a f The Transportation Group, with significant input from the Fire Department, has developed such a plan. The plan has two major components -- the resolution of capacity constraints along South Fort Harrison, and the diversion of traffic, while maintaining emergency access, within the Harbor Oaks area. I Proposed Resolution of Capacity Constraints -- South Foil Harrison The most obvious improvement to roadway capacity would be the widening of South Fort Harrison Avenue. Currently, South Fort Harrison operates with four, ten-foot wide lanes. There are no left turn lanes, and the substandard lanes widths and adjacent utility poles keep speeds lower than desired. Widening of Fort Harrison; with the resultant improvement in the level of service, would help make Fort Harrison a more attractive through route than Druid Road. Unfortunately, the limited right-of-way and adjacent land uses make the widening of this corridor through Clearwater an expensive -- and unlikely -- proposition, In 1973, the average daily traffic along South Fort Harrison was approximately 15,400 vehicles per day; now, twenty years later, that number has increased by about 75 percent. Clearwater has long been interested in improving the capacity of the Fort Harrison / Alternate 19 corridor. Numerous plans have been discussed; the most promising was the extension of -Myrtle Avenue southward to intersect Clearwater-Largo Road in Largo. One early plan was to transfer the .Alternate 19 designation to the extended Myrtle Avenue alignment. Subsequent plans have discussed a one-way pair system, with Fort Harrison running southbound and Myrtle northbound, between the new southern intersection and the northern convergence near the Atrium'Hotel on North Fort Harrison. Unfortunately, the project was put on hold, due to cost, when it was determined that an overpass would be required for the rail crossing near Woodlawn Avenue, The Florida' Department of Transportation has initiated a Project Development and Environmental (PD&E) study for the entire Alternate. 19 corridor from St. Petersburg to north of Tarpon Springs. This project has been on hold for the past year as traffic projections for the Dunedin area were reevaluated, but is scheduled to start up again early this year. Unfortunately, the PD&E process is a long one, and no' projects are programmed for South Fort Harrison in the next five years. it is also possible that the Alternate 19 designation could be removed from the corridor as a result of the PD&E study, as the City of Largo would like to remove it from West Bay Drive. It is in the City's best interest to continue to pursue improvements to South Fort Harrison; such improvements would also benefit the Harbor Oaks Association and Morton Plant Hospital in accomplishing their respective goals. Morton Plant Hospital has proposed and is initiating a "South Fort Harrison Coalition" of property owners with the goal of improving the capacity and the appearance of the Fort Harrison corridor. In addition, the Transportation Group has developed a new, low cost, traffic operational strategy that could relieve the capacity constraints of South Fort Harrison; this will be presented -20- S I S I 1 ? e 1 ?+ I t ! 1 l r r for initial Commission review and comment as part of this agenda item, and is described in Appendix C. A Pinellas County engineering representative has indicated support for a Fort Harrison project, which would also improve traffic conditions around the County 'Courthouse facilities. Proposed Traffic Diversion Plan If capacity concerns can be resolved as described above, the next step would be to develop a system to minimize through traffic without totally restricting emergency vehicle access to eitller Harbor Oaks or the hospital complex. The Transportation Grdup proposes two approaches to providing traffic diversion features; the first plan utilizes mountable barriers, allowing emergency vehicles to cautiously cross the street closures, and is the plan favored by, the Harbor Oaks Association; and the second plan eliminates through traffic from Bay Avenue and cuts Druid Road traffic in half, while maintaining unrestricted access for,emergency vehicles: Plan A - Close both roadways of Bay Avenue, midblock between Lotus Path and Jeffords Street (Figure 12). Tile closures would be implemented using mountable barriers, and a U-turn through the median would be constructed to provide access to the Hunter Blood Center and the alley north of Jeffords. This work could be done immediately. . - After the widening of Jeffords Street, and after (or "if") a means., of improving the level of service along Soulii Fort Harrison is implemented, close Druid Road mid- way between Jeffords Street and Lotus Path (Figure 12). Again, this closure would be constructed with a mountable barrier. Mountable barriers have been used in other cities; they restrict access by making the crossing very "uncomfortable". for most vehicles, but larger 'vehicles can cross at a reduced speed. Enforcement is sometimes an issue, as four-wheel drive sport vehicles can also make the crossing. Maintenance can also be a concern; landscaping is often used to augment the barrier. The Fire Department indicates that their crossing of the.barrier would not be?a frequent event, being needed only when a confirmed emergency occurs at the hospital or within Harbor Oaks. Plan B. Close the southbound roadway. of Bay Avenue south of Druid Road (Figure 13). This would eliminate the southbound through traffic component along Bay Avenue, yet still provide emergency vehicle, access along Bay Avenue. Staff envisions no prerequisites to this closure; it could be done immediately. After the widening _ofJeffords Street, close the northbound roadway of Bay Avenue at the alley north of the hunter Blood Center (Figure 13).. The alley would be -21- ''¦ IV ? ? Y '• ' ' r ??? ? ? ?• , 7 .'f11 ?`5 i r . . J ? r r 4 ' r'':?i ? ? t i ' ' ''- ' • ' ? ?,. ? , . is ? . , ' ,. . ? ' Y k?s?i ? •' 1 4 •? • ? ''•??F'1 ...? ,.F 1 ? t ? ?' t???f .. ? . ? fa ( ? .. ??? f ? ?r T ' 9 s . •r •t 1' ,' ?'r ? ., ? ?? ` " ' ` s . '' 1 J{ ? ie .. t ? , .- r .. ,. 9 r, i?F•} •,}.. Y.rr •r ? ?I EMI '?lt> ?"y?. ? r , .`???'S ' i?Y ?N1'y •Y• 'I ' +?, 9'•.•'Y ? !al ??: f ?.? l ? ? ' ,f i? 1•?' . j {, 1 ' c ''Ir. ' f sV' ? . , v.. . . .- ?. , . ? ,?, .. M ,. . . . , . . - . .. 1 r .. , r W Figure 12. •t Proposed Closures . 7 Using Mountable Barriers ' • r th L t P a o us pa{e.ior Co nstruc? '- 'U-turn t Dw Pv , Kaf bor Q??S fille ?17-Honument -rrnatir,tain ?• }/ 0 .0 BIJ5: DW a H u ntar Gent tl FfO d r -S 'Widerifr%D .r r• r..a? rr? --•• r?+• ry ?-?n?r.? ?r rr r o PTLE-r _22- r 4' •y,°???(N ,. .?.Y' 1t ,`riti tt'`, ''fit, rII •": ., ? .l f' , i(l i dk is•'•. ci.. .., :/+,! , ... -. .. :A! e17.'.' 1 ,,4.?1lT.:+. •?}'a?. ??=1...:{':.v. '.r..?, n. r'. .z ?• - .1' ! .1?r..'` ._ r ?t. ? .., .?F s .,r .:x!!: Figure, . 13 Y . r r Bay Avenue Diverters' Druld Rcf Construct U-turn P Remove pavement { ' • Co nstrtac U -turn 1 Cf O/14-. WO?y Center W den Ing r. Jeffo rds! SJt . z .. i' ,? 4'Si.:• r. t / t ' , . ! a , 1 • + ' l . s 1, ; ?, . , r I r f I . '? , . .1 Al 'S ; 3 , r Y' ' , }ea ,?. ? ad's' • f i . S , 1 - ` • ` ? i , - , S r • ? c , ?, I r 3 f , • ; i ?. ' i :?? ,sl I , ', +r b}. (,:) ,': II..d ? ,1 .1nWalr:l..!'''3 'Y: • ,.. .. -,'' • !. ;;1 .. ... ../ :irl1 ..v I t .a - ... .. .. r ? ' 1 - r ! r I f f - 1 - r I r . ? x '. S.YiJTa?1 • [ . 1 converted' to a one way. eastbound operation. The corner- of Jeffords and -Bay is critical to Fire Department response to Morton Plant Hospital; with Jeffords' existing 20' ' foot wide roadway, truck maneuverability is limited and the option to use the northbound lane of Bay should not be eliminated, After widening of Jeffords, the closure of the .' northbound lane would eliminate the northbound through traffic along Bay Avenue,' yet still provide emergency access to the hospital and residences inHarbor Oaks. ' ' - After the widening of effords_Street, and after (or "if") a means of improving the ' level of service along South i Fort- Harrison. is-implemented, close 'a section of the northbound lane of Druid Road between Lotus Path and Jeffords Street, as shown ' in Figure 14. The resulting short one way southbound secction .would eliminate the . " northbound through traffic component of Druid Road, but still provide emergency access to the hospital. and residences in Harbor Oaks. Recommendations The Public Works / Transportation, Group recommends that, should City Commission agree that traffic' conditions are negatively and severely impacting the' gbality ofd life 'in the . ; z ' Harbor Oaks area and wish to take action to close streets as requested by the Harbor Oaks Association, that the considerations for emergency access, and, capacity of affected roadways, as. described in the previous sections, be, incorporated into the implementation of the closures. it • -' , I • i'1• r ' e - I I /r . ' 1 y'. F -24- ... t ?. • ` , . - - S ' ` + 5 f"' `f: • ' I 1 , - i , r f _ f' i r f ` ! r ` r , ' ° , .7 ' t1;. I rye S? yt};•"k .rr1.f'?. .7?• F rF 4L-?'???y. r. t .• :l?rt .r"t.1??illr?5 .1. 1^ r•? °!?, . •Jl ? ',,Jr' .1 .. ?r , . ''{St' '•1.°,. '#r, f?f', r?' .,' "'?y .• - ?a n'1??:. 1• `1 rIC - ,. ' ? - - `?' girl 'C ! ' 1" •'' !s , , ;' ,. .. a ;.;. d ?it il•' .?° .??/ .. ° , ?! - ?. it •'i ? .1 i??•r' .??' '??4r? [:%9A '}?° il. i .,. ?': .V '! !?•"i ?i:3. f - r .'mac ?I?vjkP>#? `?'' > -i,r ? ? ? a 1.. {' OFF- "A ?, '1. ,i -7 1 `'?. ? ? i ? - ' r, .`i. c r , 1•' r,. . #.•:r . '•Y:. Ix,rt. ',?,r°.. .i- 'I? ::?? ?? '; Ire ?f kl ."r}. ? / r ? ,, x. , .r ,•r''}, < ?1?? 6 :??'t;}1 4k{•??i 't. .cfJ. . ' • f ` r• 1?%)'1.41,1 '••i'l?.Lri rr•,t fr • , 1 ry ?f-F'fsi???1 i hY: •.? ?.F •1 } .. ?' ? ?'t "1sjl=;r7r"?i? 4 i?;hr- aaf.'Z,. ,?., f,??tyi?': 1.: •. J?.. - }? .. ? ..?1? - "t. 'J f" .?+.??" l?Pf;f-1: ??'.3;'s" ? - lk, ,?.ry1'; Gdy r.:'„"'i: .' '•?.`E ?' ? ' f•' -M? t: X1,1 ?'1: ;•1,f. r'. t.?,r,-S: f.: ?Y:r ?r l.Yr .I rT.l '?ir ? r ... ? r ? .I?y +T ,'? IS'x a •1 ? {;; •e. of ,'i,. 'F3,i7?,t?:y;,? ?i', .. Y dli,.',l, i •. ,.?,. «,a;. F<s 1p ,...... ., ^. ?'s ?.,1?,;:.94jn.f y: A'4.: '. ?;'?? ,•+?? e.. .. .. - .. " I•r'; .a ..., r. .. , e ? .r'¢ ' ` Figure 14 . I Druid Road Diverter Lotus Pat Res ti?e? ce D i veir'Te r ' t' DrivQ N'. 1 a bo OQ ks, , 1 •,r t' ;fit Bus A'.4.. : DrWe_ MJLY ` _ wide: nitlcj ; ?'1??,,? ??'• ? •+.. ' ? ? 1 .' - . '' r ,- , / • . ' , ' r I r ` i .. ell ??r' 1 . i i • } -25 4?itr: a'' "r? ?f..:i< .. •:. ,4'! r ..i ' i fr I,.frliii •'l? '?1 ae?r? i°?S"• ? '':r'S?t/i":•:r;r? ,}: '?'-;': }t.s'S :"'t af'.A:' bi4 'h.. ..-' ...Y. 1?l,. rf•tF,. q ..rr 'r •. r?s, t: ,? . ,~ 1!? ,'S 4'`.5; s ! • cPf . , }.. •,i:"":•y : ): d.rr.. '=1.: i '.', j, _ •1 , c'i : b ?,T't ao ?? r•l..'' r'ra: y;- d 'sz}y t} ??,.??, t A. ';Jl ik ! ?'Y. -.J (.- ..?.` i. f;'?:'; ..: .4sx' ' Ft, ?`1? ,?'?st+"S". J?'i'I':•a }?/, •s ?` '.s ,? .:. J:r, '?" c: ,r. ,?;' :?I.:. _ fir.:. C;.-:f '?;?,? ?tf". Y?1 ;,; 'i. 'll;i I,JP. .{, tje'.f:-y3..:. ;,^..r,•r:• iP.:?:' a7•..w-,• i .n r"rJ? 1.,,, : ?yt ? ' Y. , .? ?£ ..? , r' ? ;: ?) ? ' ? i' " j a • r ' !'e.. : ?:'.7'.. , ?: rl,: n;? ? ` : ?:?? ??,?. ???1?• i a.`?. fA:';.ts ''rrlrhy :ts:^?.r,` ?r.?•j, ,J.?, 'J .x} .. ! if sy,. ,'• :C,, v,A?y,r ~'s,r.'?,{1:??'?..r •F>lt,. 'I• •?,i4s;°d• .! _'1' r? ? .;,5, ?' '_!' ,?I'L? •E s. L?'r':?:',af'. F' ;s •r i'r, '.F ?,?:: ee ?;.?,'?., Se,?r•.` ':. .. r .. f•?"i ,. 1?? ff?' '.1 ?[,,. ty,., .. t '.iJ`: E.. r. t'. •a '_.. y .. ,tr .t1° - ,f ;? .4 .i s,, ;t t? ,,, 'ii'. ?%?..r it1 .r.' '`i ,, ?f' t r'S?. .. ' ,J ??•? 46 ?5•??!:ts. 'iy' 1? ;;, tS:S i ?" 6" ,io .,5. .? i, .`.7, :{>,' •??' Y yam' ,i! qAr• •' i`,?r' •.t. 'tY'l1'' .}'+°-;"F 11 •f?. 1... ,'J,. f ' F !. J .?'?'J::'=°•Fw?i .1.q?.1"F'. i . ! 'tc . # y[?.? 11'A t: ti',; ! . f I,'':r t J 7 ? ?'r?. «+f,?' ,i•? ., r,q*' y i'?}l:?.. '}`, rp?' .a.jtr .t' i.tt.G?,"',•r. ,t 1' ,J r''' :L'r• .r9'i.n` `e?'?y,Mf? n],}3 ? r''I' d: ,'j,s .1 ?'' eb :' .Ix, tr.r.',: i. ?f. . 1 . ?7,' 7.-: f6 ..y <: ' '„1••-tl,?R ?a ?? } .?%' .<!. ,':. tom,;. y.. ,t r;?J '' .. >r ..'?.Fr ??r•.;?: j`. '. riJ?1,?q„ 3,+)d' +',}- 1' ''1 `?ti a?. .'?' 't. r. ,t l> °l:..t rijr .,5e'. (:'•' .j ?.`I .! .7•'{? ',. .tJ 4' ?( "t'° >s al.y +"5 5 ?- f... ccJ ab?.,?J• '?' :day •i. ?. ",4 ..:'7, .H"?? 'T!': ?,[,Ji •? .Yi I!$,.L', tF?- 'Sx' .ft, a??, ?. •t}£? !. 'R? .';+. '.1 ;`t =F ?:.! .J r ,?'! ? ,t ?'\'' 'f.. f:i .f ? x l ri. 1.. ,],: '. :" 1 a,l d' ,? yr}r • ,rY =:1?:?3 •: 1rf. p `r„ :Cr .y tr:. ,'?'-t..,,,?}r' '!- .1.3'.', ;'J ,.r,:.' .?F?;''., -?r ?-,..;? ::: .?,. ff1 lrl., •'e'c, y.!! .,' 1" .Y F '.?; :r'.. ?. .<} ? o}t= tr -?t: F[:s< :.C ,. '+??. :'lt? •s.?..l„ :, q:. } ,?t': d^ .r:? '; )J?• '1" ."j':?, e:f ? =+:"i ', , a?F'.• ji' 17' ?,{.ny «L!. 'i.•j.., t fiif"`,?. ,:?; ;' ld •/. v.5 ;?:• w:•: .tl`s=:st„:?`#=?), ':iI': f;'„r^€ .•Ir:?f:], :1 '? ,,F? ?I,` ;r= .a ::T `l e:;[ ,?f l '.r i 1 .i;'. „?. Ss. r•,re U .?iS' `rr7.. i . <? : ?? :,i0. J ?ci', .. i..:',.: _ ,J ? ..i' < r'?': • ti i 'a:?. i ,J? ",i. ?°, I .J a,e ! ..}?.-.sk .>ti°fi.y ?.i ?`'Y{(L! ?s .[' .. ?d .?', :', •'S. ! »ir'+°}r}{q: P, Y'' rf` i ., ? b ' • k Y Y r?F - l ? . L... \ ? d •5 k a 1 - 1.• ''v ' ' F S . ' 4 ? i , f ? ?.. ,c :?< '?• '; i' ?;,h•.?. .%?il- i !'r'f: sA' `fF"?yt. j°:J?:;ier;'!rs-"f'f° .Fri s? :y,.,^ °: ?i y' :l?°(? } e" ga 4•}.. '4w ? ..i, .F f. ., y.. ?<: :i?' ?' °?(.: ., ? '?jt.: ?' e •': t•.'?h •P. ?` ?-'?,^ e'' ?1'x?Y<A?S' Y` 4br `'6 9Y '1 •C,S :57" .1 a'7?, C' ?4':r: :,+; ?.. .e. vl r[? ct' r :i„' ',4• ,1. ,l?eF?. s'.. ]S '.s •t' .,?- :r' .y,:,?? ?k z `?i f?J` t7':.E?S. :l'? •}': t. 'r. ?''7, s1 '•t ?•f?v:-•!b' :t"'' F 1 '?f? i ? r'/. ^5k``. „y.45. J??'.•7, ii?A?` r?•i'°' .%.1: ?'t..• ,f: ra?? it ?a `I,. st, i•, y? ''.fit ' 1':, F'S':<;:': ;? r `• :T.,Y '''i' 'e?`?? ,"•" i it:. i ?Y•e'' rs ri .Y g4id'r§"^; ».".?=.?+., Y?1,' ,'7'fi'- '{'?r t .rl% ,'?:'. `r?i.. s? '`L" '•3< .F"1• ? "'J's 'K,'.' .°t, .. ,l t,1 ^'s,: •.:t. ?.,• J. -?,, (',y},? -L, :x.1.J.?,:?% F:. ,lc ;{?.•r, of.r 'r Fr tx :i, 'J,;' ?'?t ?:i{)?'•t F'".l. •'i•, n'J.°.i r! ?ry: ?-, E' } , f?.. _'y •'. .,S .u•. . t,;y, t ''S.o- ?"?E' •+''' ..Y ' °k ' a ` •,?"E """(. a. :i , 1:, _ "aF' •., . 'ir. ''ia" }.r J .?,.??? 4 , sf:-' .•'? i ,?i''., 'i'..:+? s=''.. ;' •'a?i <.i;:'; ...,Y; i?r'[`f ,.. y:t : •„'°?`r1 P^:'F;?lF!?rti`;j, -?I.:i s.rs:?Y''!,- ''.ipv?a, .,y}?f:f, ,w??r,?°t ..??` '!1. ,,f;.,' it '1},•: ?.,,.,,/i, .i» ?.Y : ?Jf. .f }, .3' h:`.t<? '.,, d: :?:!' ?? !? ri1:-•" ' n" .r e ..'.'?'. .p, ^k?;.•..[' r'!: -Ix •;?' -'I'•?'.., it fr R: .P'J •cJ' !? :i 1,' `Y:J`'i,?': ,.y i 'J'p',' }!x' •l. .'Yr'"'..• ?rJ. Cb I :?',. k;. ?.?•' r'i 1!, !.`jjK?.rp4' {,. .?'a.x: `Yt'+ ?J' ,s' t°,,,. '.t'•i'-•° ?J'•-'.!"S:•..tA9'?. r..L:.?7-k:: er+.ri ix.:,r,:. ... ?,, ..s. e.i.`Cy°:! ?,..S4 F:"!.';eK?'.?••. r. •. ,`.'?» .'i':' i•a':.f t'F, •fr•'.#' . ... ,• di,i ? n,. r k15+t???. e A ,? ` :,??a'r?. ' Y.k!^. a?P,,ir.?"xdk.?t;.'.' . •• ?.?? ?: ?ri,:1r'? rP,' -rr'. ? r 1 ? ? ? 'r .. s ?'7?[ ... - ?.l rJ ,t 1. `J•. `? r • ? ? SIP ;. i- ' .. f ,?;• ? ., :, •r..• °.?'.'.?l" 't , - f ! r: ' ! r,, rt.:`r, rt,-'-.( ''f.1i ? ::?_; ?"f [ ? . r. . [. .l. s Ji I ... '; ,.`. . Cs. l•.. ?Jw ' i°.' •i i'41 .Lr .11•f. .S :'i i , z[ .7. I•?. E-7 ,J,: y'. ,Fr ?l' ;?', :,.{•sr? . t"[, °.?^ ! ? .fi;, t t i. _ . f. .?! 1 ^d;,' ?)rr• 3 '", Jl';?: •ri I v'1 1• 3 :L! i''s' iJ ` i I' 11y. I , , i? r., ?•Y 'i'i' ?. .?E' . 1:'i .rK3 ,I}r •'ir .1• r' lI Y}J .. '.f, f S°tt', `+' 'I; ? t ?!''i .. .. r .. 1;.y'P t•?l' •, j•. ?'z': rff i,:,, •e° ? ? , i. ? :,?:•"'ems 'fir:: .•5.,. `. Ml•Pr`!, -.(?? 'r- ;,I ..f -' ,. .i •St; r 3.• f 1 ' ? .. ? ' I' , .k ?7? `i y,J. ?-? .Ia ''1•t{?rFi )':+ _ 1. ,' 1 •Iy -??; .'t?: ??`` y'?ts?'.S- •Le.1 ?•1 '. ! , ? ' ` b'. ? 1? ,Ii II'i •'Fr: [,. .: f.?{ lr,3a- ? tt 1 ,r . f , ?, , lrt•r` ML?Y ?,{?I']-'S",' i• I ! .. :l',.' ?{s •,t? `elf 'f?. J• f. ?j^a??,: '.i? .. t Y.; f`,? t.,?'.:f 't' ? ';' t.':r??' ?j _ 'r '(°,°.`• :pi ,f, IJ? -f- [ ' :, ? C r +, : it wT¢'sl'~ ;, °FJ'1' '[f• .=1• 1,f 4,r, S' i•'7/' e!• ... i?: %d`, ,t-`?: 1.. 7%r? '?? ?'? _ ?7.' 'F? - t >1 ? ?c? ? ? 1?' ! •it.: ?,r}'?, ?i?1t???^r. .:, li "i? :?'. fir' ,<?i "t' :'f' .. .:?i, •, ?f ;4.: '1,-';' .:S ri t: ,' ,•F='i. ` „ • J F t a y I?P •fr t i. ''Y'„" ??t<? '€ .. •t t ? n Yu ±y r•+ I. 3 ... c ..t ;>. .;'r v r .e.' .. , s• _ .ln.i7., ,lfFe ?xf'.>JE . "' • '' -.:e - it • r r .' ECEIVE :: H ARR FR D JUN " 8 1992 OAKS TRANSPORTATION , A'.S- s 0 1 AT I O N C L E A R 'W A T E R a F L- O R I D A June 2, 1992 The Honorable Rita Garvey Mayor, City of Clearwater P 'O Box 4748 Clearwater,.FL 34618 Dear Mayor Garvey: Enclosed you will please find the following: 10 Harbor Oaks Association Letter Dated'6/7/90 2. City Traffic Report Dated 7--25-90, .3. City Traffic Engineering Report Dated 2-3.92 4. City Traffic Engineering Report.Dated 2-18-92 .51 Morton Plant Hospital Foundation/Harbor Oaks Association Meeting Minutes Dated 4-29-92 The enclosed infornati.on concerning vehicular traffic generated by the expansion of Morton Plant Hospital facilities and the environmental impact on Harbor Oaks is a matter of considerable,concern to our residents. Throughout the years, historic Harbor Oaks has been one of the most desir,-')le residential areas in the City of Clearwater, and we have,always souc,:.c,.with our neighbors, to maintain and preserve the, unique residential character of this area which through the combined efforts of the residents and the City of Clearwater has been entered in the National Register of Historic Places. This' locale has represented the most convenient of all residential areas to downtown Clearwater. Residences have always been in high demand'with few vacancies, and most owners are long-standing residents in the area. The area is well kept with outstanding pride of ownership evident. Prime residential'areas are essential to the maintenance of all property values in ' the City and the'real'estate tax base of the City of Clearwater. The expansion and growth of Morton Plant Hospital' in an overly congested ?r atea between Harbor Oaks and the* Town of Belleairr' two single-family ., residential areas, thus far has had an adverse environmental impact from ' resulting noise pollution, air pollution and traffic congestion. r D E D I C A T E D ,T O' N E I G H B O R H O O D B, E T T E' R M E N T. ,i ' ?,? a •! ' .. , r . • ...ilia.` Mayor Rita Garvey . Page 2 June 2, 1992, ' Quoting from The Pinellas County Metropolitan Planning Authority 1991 Report, "pinellas county is currently classified as ,a marginal non--attainment,area for the pollutant ozone, and it has'been determined that tailpipe emmissions are the primary sources of this pollutant." Thousands of vehicles. daily, are traversing our residential area to reach other destinations, such as Morton Plant Hospital immediately adjacent to the, south, or points to the north and south such as the Bellevi.ew Mido Hotel or the,Pinellas County Courthouse. A long-range environmental and traffic impact study and how theFexpansion and'growth of'Morton Plant Hospital will affect. Harbor oaks is an absolute necessity as a guide for the long-term preservation of our residential area.' We request the Board of Corrmissionecs of the City of Clearwater to take . immediate positive action to close Druid Road South and Bay Avenue permanently at Jefford Street to protect our single-family residential area from the' pollution and traffic hazards to our residents and children caused by thousands of motorists daily traversing the Harbor. Oaks residential area to reach other destinations. Sincerely, HARBOR OAKS ASSOCIATION Cedio S. Saltarelli _'-),-esident CSS/mmw cc: Commissioner Sue Berfield Harbor Oaks Residents: Commissioner Richard Fitzgerald Commissioner Arthur, Deegan " Mr. Robert Kirn Commissioner 'Lee Regulski Mr. Leslie Conklin Mr•. Harry Jamieson Mr. Michael Wright, City Manager Dr. Robert Mayer Mrs. Jan MacNLitt Ms. Cindy Godeau, City Clerk Mr. Harry Cline Mr.. William Ruggie Fir. Tom Miller Mrs. Candace Martens Asst. Dir. Public Works/Environmental.. Mr. Peter Jones Mr. Harold Heye 'Mr. Peter J. Yauch Mr. Charlie Harris' Traffic Department A2- a i= . y 'It • ?'?•f? ? ' t'I ? ! ' ': ' f „ y , ., rte t` r . J:it•., ?} ';n };S "{i, ?' jr.' } ?` ii'° ' Ji°? g+?.ir::fs,:;l.r .,s•!R-,.,, t • '1• i,., , 'r4' ':fi"",.u:., ` ?s; .1,;.'•.i` t4.,f., Yn? S•y a'S d' __- ...,,ayl7d,:k; •?f. ?t"i=`4'`," al ?r'c;r..:.f?ll?t.l}, ,l?i;lE E'"f°;u;r,3-: ?, 4r.,rr?.=,':.'? J}, `-., 'i i`" ,,?'; :;s i-1'e. .a!`.'?'r?}yr •... F..7 fJ!SLd ?t`?l ?`?U -i •r 't -'' Y 1'^ies ?.::'_" ' - Y r- I i.:.,. {< t, IV:,tid..?r.,, .1.'; 'r: Cja} y. . _ rY `{ , y•r?..'Jif tC4i,r.!,S` J"r 1l '""i„ K- i3 nl1,: / •tc l.l,.' , ::a ` 'r1, r.• :s;•". j, ' ^ S , r r, ;• '.I' ?r?;.tfl, 1+ vJ S. tz ', 1,!'F J,.T/, A 1 Y, ., . its i;k>' ?F . . ;•? w i. , °T !l.l... ,•t: r .,?.S ; } ?i?° 'r .i'ir'" I> `i'? J.).rr '! , i ?t rA tr't: '4'?•'' .r:••, 'TQ° 'y.? d .-s: •'dt N1r' ,s : r „ i ,gq"!. (• na. ' I..k .F''.''l? •1: ..''sCI:„ ,f''i f _ , . • J l'. ' J. ' r' ir. ..,? .i!-: ' ,. r!"l4 yr .'?• :t .?k .k, •b ; . • :, Fi 4- h•.r ti, r 1'. ,- ,f, "{ 'f l 3' ;'' -,1+ ' !J : ., i?.rf1 ,"; !k 1 t? _ °C :? ti ) . , t, .?. ,' .., r,a. ,'t .1, r!' ' 'r- r iM 7 , "!s t,r a ;tv ' ?'. •'r .ar. _ '•i 4 •i' ' J . .'F' »T`L.. J tr'":t- ,•,,'' : '?N. `'' ;S `( 'if'!%. ' ?`l's S ' }'tlS' ',' ,,..,rI 'I'.[ .4.. . `Y! 'i rr 'y' J. I.. y ,, 'r rr.0 .c. ;.v;. ,ttt,• I: -f} + 1,(r.• '. ::A:'.' i'' lF.'' •?. ,'' 'i-: ?'r:•Y .^i,1?J?' ., '3 ,` ?.d.', 1z - t,'•I. iA. 'a: , ''l' .t ",: '7 ri r ' y 'l -. . . . :?i . 3 ,r•' •(,•f a._ i r F, r,c " ,f'1 AY1.,;• .F i:R)' :e."ki'?P I. •'ry•?l' _ !4v 41; '; , , it J , - ,r. t "y?;j '!:'f'''F?: i%,? '?'•'y,X, 'i• ,.1. •P {?.t JP..?l, '., ,ii I;" i'1 ,j t(:er'.`I! `'J1'. -I ,t r .. .'°I'1 rt: .i :.. ';)?,; r r ., `.. °., r, ,r../. `td?', 1:, b'7 s, _t r,Z,, w r,., ,'.?•.. c ?. ,ty rg,'ff,, ?. 3b a •L` •tkdk `'Well r.. ?. }'•j. q,r{ '?fL ,'c i?. '; -.; t, 1 J- .3.' 'f. ,'I',.Y +?'i t'.;• ,S..J :- F.9 .r i ?.r+: :Se '!r • k r'11 ?z (r (, i, a ;?'? ;, ,'t' s,. ? ' , -i / , ?! • , , f, ii:. 'i].. `?J.Y ;. `iJ' , .'P :ta,PF >!bJ 9`., -. '.f ,F' - 'S'• \, V .i ,k;? '•C 1 {[t'.''+J?'.2 .t t", :.(. ?•r•J?J',r„1 .,??: ?;r- A.'- ?I• r'.- I. ,.. a. a? . •' c . , 1. ` It , W `, 4-' ??rf p Yr. `• . ,'.P , tr • rr ..t .f.. , . . r'y..^` 1 . 4 i •'?T• ,(. ?Ya':,'.c` •'d1 y' r' ?lr . `r :1T' .e't. l'?' 4... .,`br. e, 1.' ''y ','t : .1 .1 Ji Dk?- ' i 1: kk e • ?•' • , • ! ' • Y. 1', b . '- lr r. .l?.t r,. t ?•er „?. I- t':,§ _ A. x'4' v=SI ' -, s i.'1 }`e 3 .1', ra' Y i, Y,1''},n l: A ly ',i? '7. y %..i'°'y „ '1-"''.7, `.P"?p i;;S.° j}}? •''" ;•) , -1,4, ,Tr • f: y,' • ai ', '. I ;--rt{6kr'•} ,dt t ` 4 '?i , r ' F, + ' c, •2'; f.1 , k: a ?•' rY:n ••', C , '`r , `n' : ¢' +tii? . ? w r Y.'R. .' r?k4j" . 32 SS t:F , E y .? rr °`'.•..r.F" ?+'.n,,• _ .?f,', .f t ? }I`?, • is II't !ES CC wr. pY? \-,f L=Y f"?y'.'f. ' A : i1?K, ./. l : __ r',?. .? ' {• . he a ' nJa .• t.. j ^ 'SSA. .t, ,, - :ir_ '7 !fn »,?r.''1?, {;%. I,(Iv rl :3: .;'Y 'SsL f- .rA .'1"•S 1°• '«!'J . v.r°. 'i' . t ? r: -°tr `s "?a:= ', f.: r,t` 'i•; •: s• ;i Si• - r. _ i''?,r• ` 1 '? ,t,b , i i••.,'t,%-'•i: E?1 . ''t-N »: 3, ,.?.. t .' '.'s`'',ec (;, -•,,, .tt''? `lr e, y: ?t` r. ! :,, ,yc,.r:k..., ?ti'•J' ,P :+t,6 + 'G ?' t.' 11.. .'q': t .i .t +,;rN1" .3. "i r,'::.i'ir>,' _ i. 'y" '?.: •? it ,qtr r :i:` J. ?5r vc., `',r.? ,,.1. ,r7 r7 +:' r' „w .i ,,: .[' ,t' '4:t 4' :`kr> `r'.'. :d °a y':.g. ii ;e i tf t)r. a b r F' ' C 1 r4 S.• .3, f,, . ,,%l'° -,'a„! r'. ^',L' { ` 'i ':, pC'r'''k" ?• ".f. r11' " -' ; 3r 'i. . ? G. ?- j ?' ?.S r ', . i>. r,a e',' } i. i-7•:, . ,i° , -,il' 3r'tli ° Ar..•^ . s . . ?r ' L', 1 `5 ' ^ . 2 rF:.,, ! •T`.+', !a.,t r `r.. . t. ,+ .1.,y. V°{.;{ 2 `? ?., a.`,J S i rl•??i,•w 'r.JY' '?': 1J %1: .. .'C, :,4 ' 1 ? r: .:L: V. ' Nyr1J ,vj•: i ,.I,. ;t'•,? :P +.Lii',' .;''•.?, .?` 't; I`4y" ;.. { 'Ji:'3 ;,i°,;")i!:?-' ',!a ': r. 'i;'•`1 a :;,`' 'It' 'd 'r1.1?-1 ,k"* '.t.. 'I. .1•P. .iat.. '.^tr ° ?i, ?'l.+i.r 6:?i.P ?, t,; '.rl'' r<S?r '.09):? } ..1,-}:?-,, t ???. °{ !! ,"),{i?->.S. E is f!; 1 M4:- jis " :'T-? '1. ...r•t1 4 ?: ' 1! , t vt.. ' r . , i'.;" •`y",;+}, 4'. '.??;,:"_j e. ,a :,.l. a , a t ,v: t? :.`, 5a!i'- .r?.re: •`?°` l.. f {? h 's'• I I e l,:, ? e` ., ;: 1;:, tj: #,r, .k!.;. '-+i ?1 (.£ , ..s 31• `Y, :S >..,..: .-.. ,F J, p? ? r` ;r:,iJl, :t. ai3 r+: ,w> ``?rt"7•t'/,-: .."s? !J`° rY1,' r• I ','7':. t,r ', :a. „~o.TS '; :i ,rd,`f" k? ?P. P { n4kJ ., (:- i7 t.r. ?o} sfl, E S •S I. 2°, :'•e.a i• ,JA, j `t I.. ' ( .v..•i« •'•,; r r k',' 't?r ,}, "" _ '. ',' " ?y.?. "_ ', .r, •= .-'f: ' ? . r= 1:. r. e c ?' r " ; 1`+ ^ y ,., `ro .r.i : . ' (., "`? 4..r:r„f t t.,+s' -t? , .1,'?%' t :f. - y ..El z , . ;, : `t -`1. l<; ?t.?r4". i9r : " ,AA- ,F. '(',' ' i *° r;r'. •J:• : .;s'J a t;'r ?. '.1,: - ,',1',:' .,.i x?`?.? .r2 rrv,: €.--, 4'. `4.,.. . r:,,)•aJ S: i` , ri '{ ,`fJI , ?,rf{=A '! ¢. .,T! , _ I..S1^'1,:1"! -':• , ,•1,: ,. r" ?.. ?. ,l.r p.e :f: f. .7rPI „. ? ,. rr•? 6 ,,.=_:f..J' 'r, ,, ?` "i` E v'-° ) - 'i°' 1 Jl"at" r f +. rr'Y''ti;:'r{, r:4 rr, ..) S'}, S .el° P: "r .r 6').' rf a rS,} h. ''l .iw 'L.%. Y'.,.3 .. ''t ' f '' > ;.r1 ,[e' ` ' r'r=F, -- ''i ' 1•<'y .r,fin. ,g., p "i,"".< 4'. J r.+' .10 a. a..t^, ? t? ! (> j / , 1. ;c .? r j;@ :5. ",/.: t s, J f i ' ?'. ?' .$ Yi1a i+ ,r t M- :? S itT3.,I)t.. ?s'' '?`'I_"x, •?. . .5,, .? f , a A} it yy.r. . r. . i i J r' + . f/I .,l ? t.d e „ I,. . ' ; S 'e"' , 1.'. , ° : t' ee-. •' t „^+ ,{C.t 5g J ,.R' , t .?r' (, `C' 7 !.w,+I;",•y,.Y, yx;. ?i' J?F rh, .i7r '?f'. ::• 1 _ & ?'.°',? ••?°, Jrr + r 9prr4{ . . :'i,..'::S ,«„ .Ig. '1 .A' =.4i'z `lr: •. . ? gg r;%q f:1' a a t }iy $?!;r.1 ±7! F•r ?:r' E 1' '(' ,:"r r ' r '?'f. r1 Iil1T°" '•4r 4. 1J •1F { i.J -"r• 'tF' .F.e'. f. •' !}'r S a y4 ti F•1.7,` ) ,i.. 3 rr}?+ 1., 7 ?' :, ,'1'" 1.'r• -.., $ •?. o ' T r:. ,, J-1 - ::' c4 r € '•t°;' tr" l;r, `` Y.1'. .:.r.tY?• ?,,g???.**? ,,I,bdtl ,.. .. S , . • • " _ ir„IrH?lt ii" s1r%F••.-;,.A ?.ikj''-I •rl°.._R..}«;i::l F?dir Y?Jkr?J t .7af Jt,v+tl,., 6I :• 7. ' •. 1.5 . ::'6',1;,-,'i't". -, ,.'4''Wrr' • ^'}?s 't.•:• 4 - r-' "-- ;.I , t, . f•1. I ., ?..:....« 1r.'h-?s?i}rt y .F: a'.?,I':r `..ry'.. (. ,:t. a:. :?S FF ,S I J` _: r.,r . . . ' ,,;., 'r t , .I 1 .e,• >I, v!r'', ,,tr ,1 t' 'd. f.1 <I " i, tl?, > t•• '5, t ?- ,t. if::'J'•:^y4 .f1 .t. ,t. I ,! .. a:1 , :h, ,'f .r',r•l'•', „itr`' - ;' ,'i>_M.?."" _'.4 r,i>' . t'. , 'r.. r .< . I tst,: d (.. „ +'/' r 'r , i!1'' J u .f. •f. : ' , Jd: :i' {. 'i ,? .( 'i'ASr'. ?. -I: :c ,. _ - , i-%,.lt'A `r.: -'! ! ^ r / - ' r , `l .I, I`. . 4 . i?- r'kti!„t3r ,..r`J. -. - .. .,J.., i' ,. .. . ... ,... I. . , . . .° ., .. 1 • ?. .. a ,.. v. .. .. .T.. . ?, v5r •. rf'r. :'.t+ 141:',!.: .N. r ., a«. J - , -,I-.,. r n, f,j%n ;, '! '?1 r ii lf+ 1 i• .. .. .j- -%r ,d{r f .1P .f r :r .(:r :f.' ??'-'r k-`,-i y(X,t' •.!" `'i•,) „ •rk'. f 1` -3'' ,`r., s .' 11 t ,? ' (? is'.!Y .,'1; y:1't ? I. r' y' j, y. 3, .,,r`t 11T1' ••1, .S s IJ: -? , t T, - .. .•?,. d),`f J 3'k f' r'?• ' K. k. d'r T _.. . 'I •f ir'. .'r`, / J.. 1;, , 11 p't Yep; . Yom{, .r,!' '.J .r?. Y it _ r •,I - . S"1? s`J.: '4!:Y,P i;' '1 (i '' 'F ,. .. .i'r .j9r N ',, ,?L ?, ., 4? z .- - 'd, „I-. I i , :7 ^' , k' '. J1'1' , , t r ;•C li,.. f, -.1 . 'f.'i',::::J.J r y`t I` r' .r' I :'J 'i" .f• t ,ir `, E'.r" 1 ,,f. '•?r ., i'' ''/,.? jJ:' ::F ,.t , Ql ' Y, `i , l . r . ri' . 1, '.j. . fkva - , .I. '1 'rK, f. '.t. 'r.. . !,': : t I ° . 11 ! y)r r, ' tAb'.'r}f;' ';, • i k r . i . S i ' I ' r !-- - `r4 , }' :''i,:.' If. j,. , 'S' ,F? F '!v Y ;. r ;'?':'.!?I. _' A??i ? B , . 1.?, ? rt '' i i~ X "-,.": ", , ? ? , , . ? '.'.. ?', . ?. ''? ": I ""' i . _ , , . ? Jt°5;fi rT , 'til yf? 1":f',, ,t,'•lf.r. •7 f: - , '1nn r tP. •. -.4'-iv ?' i'Y . ! • o . .. J 'C . ) 1, Y : i;'•;.'3,r$ 'V.I f 'y-?., :C t' L: ,.!° ,. '. I a1? ° :t` '•!.'•„ V. ;iy.??.... .fk'ri,' .. ''1'+' i,'. r ,t . , . .r °'>: , :( k •{•'r!',r`l. r. 1 :I r %; e' • 1' 'r : i' 4" , ,:r? I' ''! } tL: t'' . f -t, 1 'f . S •r , ... f,' ,;j ..i•`:•,;f• } , r (, , . ,, ,,t".f I ,, 'i" , :.1 .'?;r 11 ,'i :r1 Y`- , a r,,i , ? Tr /' , i- .1 r .f j >' r., :3 ',I: .r 'F.,r i;,•,!1f Et,: ,i' 'r" ,1vp, qt ,fl y. .r , 1.,,f.; ..' ,; r..f " J F .,;, .1 . 'r', .1: ,J.'. . t,,Rs it 4r?a." t-,I t1 !,, 5,{` - .J`J ?€ 1~ .i I '4 r. i (: ) r,' J'af ` ' i' , ,{ 1 .. h t 3 .: E i i I r ,.a, ,:,> t,, FI?, r •, i' ° t : " r'' i ~'F-A .T.: .;`.,'-s •iyfr •)r 't- 'S, •,. f4.' 'g Ii " it ,•": iy`. ?. A. •r."'. i, ,' •J tJ.-, ;r f" ,J ,J l'- o' :*; (qi-T J d., rs {.' .i•, r?) i f. r 's f, p?^.r j y'! I f I'. Y, l +'. '(:.C' , , , 'i.. 't: Via'., ,i °,4 ?. ?ti4 !'r .r. i. .',r -t'r 'fir y(r„{,r Vii- %`;; :I; , t' , ,. kiA M•+^,, ,r .t ?d. . . ,r „d'Y: F. .!',': t it .?-i M:n`r.f P', 'I t' 'I. s': ,/'.s ?tq :4.'1.' . {" ' 1 .t 'SSE 't I 'J, S: '.ii 'i..'.`" Y'J' ,r.'• '!rR 1('. '?f„k „w,li? p I {1: ,C -.) .,3 il. 1. ',e S":" re ,''4 l-e. ',, , i iv I . t- 7.. .. `r. ,t) { 6' .. rp- ' fs }"3 S; ' , 'I $, 7-', #, t .'- ,e, . . t:, q , 1: I% , ... , s ?} `: i' t t:lz. ;• , r..Lr'a1r :p: -F'if ir- Irf f4 f°. ,, 1 " E '°I.r' 'F+e'-' 1'!. 3' 1.:4i'i 1.'.I- _ .,'? "rl k, f. { '; i.. ?.•: , ;i, .rr .?; +if :if,. ;}? ,'1' -I, ':ty'r.f :i 1,!( .f ;t .. •df M<, ... I.L .'r',: ,. ', rtr. F ., trtt l • r 7" fir' ' ' Y1A,, ; \ a :1, .d r`3 is 1. ) '.1. ,j.? ,.. ,1 r,?. S+ , t' / " 'l . l 'P J i t , ( E,." K. .is, ,1 i ' 1;;,, ( > ! • , 6.. 'r,;" ` FS'•' Yr' <b'.i i 6 kL?'t, TV :1. ,i ,. Ys r?-+ Y,.. -i'.^y, hl/Y. , \: .i ?s:v ,. r.'? ' , . -1 ,. },':' f .,.?i <Y. '°J ,-Y 1 , ... • d• 1... ::".,s `' ??'.- \ .+' 7:i - . t J i rr•.be)?iti'f A +t .. 1 } •r . s 1+r +.Ir <i .. t+r ` ' r' r 1. r , ' + , .. rl, li TO.' Peter Zauch, Traffic Engine FROM James Goodloe, Fire Mars COPIES Fire Chief Davidson;'Assi Pidala; District Chiefs Of SUBJECT' PROPOSED CLOSURE OF BAY STE DATE April'16, 1992 The Fire Department opposes this closure following reasons: 1. Bay Avenue is a north/south alte Harrison Avenue. 2. Bay Avenue provide an accessible in case of ma j or' fire. . 3. Closure would affect response t1 if Fart Harrison was not availak 4. Bay Avenue is the designed acces Truck 45 and Engine 46 for respc east side of the hospital.' 5., Closure would affect access to t building at 401 Druid•Road. Please contact this office if there is a clarification'or supporting documentatic JEG : vmc -B1 -' ?1.i ?4?.'k ?•, pi ? 'tM'aM1 ?' 4r??.?•' • e 1 • • • • - •111`. ? 1 • i • • . • • C I T Y O F C L E A R W A T E R INTEROFFICE CORRESPONDENCE SHEET EC TO EI'?E TO Peter Yauch, Traffic Engineer FROM 1: James, E. Goodloe, Fire Marshal JUL 2 91992 COPIES Robert Davidson, Fire Chief TRANSPORTATION Joseph Pidala, Asst. Chief SUBJECT Proposed Closure of Druid Road DATE July 28, 1992 The Fire Department continues to oppose the closure of Bay Avenue and Druid Road. The following comments of my April 16 memo are listed herein. In'addition, two added problems will exist with the closure of Druid Road. 1. Druid Road and Bay Avenue are a North/South alternative to Fort-Harrison Avenue. 2. Druid Road and Bay Avenue provide an accessible staging area in the event of a major fire. 3. Closure would negatively affect response times, especially if Fort Harrison was not available. 4.• Druid Road and Bay Avenue are-designated access routes for fire equipment to the West side of the hospital.. 5. Closure of Bay Avenue would severely diminish the Department's ability to access a major water supply.•"al fire hydrant assemblies along Bay Avenue are served by a 12" water main and provide a flow in excess of 1000 gallons per minute. Other hydrants in the area have a f low•rate of 500 to 750 GPM. 6. Most residences within the Harbor Oaks neighborhood are of such site and construction composition that their fire load greatly exceed those of other residential areas. Due to this increased fire load, quick access and quick response from all angles is of.utmost importance. 7. There are only five (5) routes into Morton Plant Hospital and surrounding medical facilities. Each of these routes is a narrow, two--lane road. If this request'is granted, two (2) of these routes would be eliminated. Our ability to perform fire suppression, rescue, or evacuation for any,type emergency would be severely limited. Please contact my office with the exact time.of your presentation -to the Commission. If you have further questions, please call me. Thanks. JEG:crh -'B2 - 1'r 'i ?A • ' , d { l ' + ' r 1' ', ; , . /. • • • • L , " ` ? fit' ;`( , r... .. ' ,'? •y. , <?r1 r. ..'-t[,.r'??..«4'.9' 'r,e??r°?4,t '1 .. ft. •' ... ... , . ., 1 CITY OF CLEARW•ATER IInterdepartment correspondence Sheet e i To: Peter Yauch, City Traffic Engineer ' FROM: Robert M. Brumback, Assistant Director of'Public -Works/Utilities ?. COPIES: William C..Baker, James V. Maglio SUBJECT: PROPOSED CLOSURES ?- DRUID ROAD AND BAY AVENUE DATE:. August 10, 1992 This memo.is in response to your memorandum of July 31, 1992, conveying the desire of the, Harbor oaks Association to close Druid Road and'Bay Avenue from Jeffords Street north.,, Utilities Group would pose vigorous objection to closing of .,' either of these thoroughfares.. The closure of either Druid Road or Bay Avenue would.-impose' unacceptable restrictions on the Solid' ;.' Waste service of the Harbor oaks area. It would put our drivers -in-a' position of having to back out. of some locations in an .. , extremely dangerous way. In, addition, it would pose'problems for debris,clearance and general service during natural disasters within the Harbor Oaks area, It would also deny alternate route 'access to Morton Plant Hospital under disaster conditions. If'you wish to discuss this further, please let ](La know. RMB:deb' ! .S3 - :?'S?iar 3 • 't 7: «? j`1' I FI br s, •;'1 •, f :?a;: '1. •"1 'j. r'• .,3 0 : Jp ?-y' J r :, . ..1?R '1 •i ?'' : i A e 5, , '1 ?r l? :3i?l.?' fsr ::'? .',• ?' ? r'fr.<i ?tf ?'' S ?i f . - '?i. , ?''}` ' }? f r- r . 1 ' r Ft •?'rf,?; , e ? ?d ?'15S"t:; A.es? ?.rs.. r:. .q'et <'?.r, ?',?rr5'fI' .-t.:?i.'Er.,:ia?:.'. {,'... 1.'1!•i."? , tc ?? ?. ,.. .. a ..f' .. r..-. ..i.?i-f,5? CITY. OF, CLEA WATER . :. Inteedepartme.nt' Correspondence Sheet f ' R ECEYVE TO: Peter Yauch, City Traffic Engineer AUE 2 f..?2 FROM: Sid Klein, Chief of Police . ' TRANSPORTATION COPIES: Deputy Chief Eastridge SUBJECT,: Proposed Closures - Druid Road and 'Ba y Avenue DATE: August' 12, 1992 . r " Regarding the above=-referenced subject, Z have requested'input ' `F from 'my staff and it is the Police Department's the ' position that closure of Druid Road and Bay Avenue would not have a'sign`ificant impact:'on the.ability of the Clearwater Police Department' to, •'., patrol the area. SRK'i J5 , -.{ } • • . ,r - ? A f ` , li .. I t 1 t-,!. . ! I if f i ` . ' S• '?1 t f ` . . < ffffff c + ' r ? 4', ' Z F ''q't R, ?si';r fi;F.::..1 i?',}•i f'{.i't 7•:it;Iwr:: i - '.?;?? ..Sr. ?:..1I. •j':. .:t .r kid T. fr.,+' #?:.htir'---- ,r!:J i'`.. + xt 'ro-r::ra..'. ? n ' ,,. .:1--y •,. IS.`?'?: I St.r'," ,r.,}., r:' ' :?.' -+'- _-r . -0 :1'" „i,.. ^r t+, ?' ??. :4 .t.f•?! LS,; .f?s...tl:•?'.f' '+r `3 ,+.;lh t:}: •i' <3."f ,, S.*?... 'r.f ."Irt :.fir:', '1: .r..F!-.. J., ?y ?:t 't'sl,`s<: 'y.6 [f:.Y, R1;;.. : ,ry:: s:'"t,",-?', r R't?.,;'. h'! .?i 3" ,i , 6 "}° +1:, t'r+. 'I I F,. . :IT . .., ,, • • + , R • Y.' I I }... ..t •'.},, i : 3,• `} p4l1 '. ,i 1t r.ii ,t,. Vin . .{. : ri-t. "J d; `, `j : Fr?tr ' '. , rF - ,' '' ii- . [v., kr ly I , S?i ,Ilk ''T :1, . , 'f • . y^1. fai^ Si., _r:. Ira v. ?-' iff ,. ,ti`r r _ ' t. ''j` ' 1; ' _-;p 4 ?Ja •Yr^ F r •t. ! !4°, ''• `•s 1",'1'Y `. P f, {?.+',R? Y ',4. , ,f I, ;,a,. Es', e''j! _ ?, E . I . d'.• , t.1' Sif` ?1 ,'a, 'r a. -` ¢. };" 'f}:+?. r, Ir II'. r. :E .'i. ..i ,i., .s3_•ir5•ry}IrgYr.t?;lt I t? .4 Js`. .4i :l. ,.. .f?l: tt' fY'. 5 S , ' . I ., f ,F ., ?i:q E;? F;rs?t.'-' Vii- ' ll..si",b`3'" 'r4. 1'rJ ,l( >•,?R. .1Y ??,..6,.t' 'i,., ? .. ' °r - ' a ".1`?!%'s .,s I^'?'5?1. 4 fr 104. 0.i: y'i', 1 G :ry'" ,f . i° i I-`. ?; ,F E1 . r ': ', `tf, -.' 0: e4'''`.' ,, c: M"`t t .r: I .. 1'j' r :?,+:(.'ri,t,;`{, ' 05 1:'r'a ? L «:. '.i , J 9 +`'h F 10,4) -, r'I; . . , i' R. . ry2 f ice, ..:.; 9 s ' '1' T +' 0.r la" a :I:.,?Y,r,. ia.€ 3; ion .t . "I 1 1 , x , :iC' Y..: s°.li F .. • i', , ?.1 . . '. J 1W,.,1.i,?' I . r Y <'r`• ^i,t., . ..6,, . r .r ,'ykS;#,i1•.. ~ t , ..F, \`. ?' ?' j 3 ?.. i"? l.,kl` i:l '{e r.1 [ of k .f q ?S.f: ,wr: °a a, ,?' . 1 ,i, .,i' aj= : i, 3 1'1,31'•: }? !} j, I I. `'t. '„' !•. ,.:J; .f` - 'f:T.,• t` 'r,«] '1' 1 a' '1,. ,',,. . :4 F: `A C° a Tq?r yJ ' 4 't? 1 u Y+i tsi a' ' Y''^ r", f?• r i "a .,'at•,. r .2• . .;7iZ" ..1°y€.' "I, I .Ys.i j 3': I., i},.(t?,y sJ?:1? 'i 'xr` 'i '?:` 7: °}^ '.e?A-'.? •Llrr. i,c' ?' <,Ti S`p f I? 1, K f.xf? S: !'s.s,.?.i.2 ^11„G, .'l' :t.+ (TT t j ?, „t ,l (( it Y. •-} •i `If rll:, _ 'f7 r- ^s' !ytY1M" e. y$ k..14 •! a y `?i- "" f 'I`•' A? ,f?x ?-t ?.Ir1 H ; . t' ;y:: :{•..: :J,Y'?? "" f.4ta ,9 . ?`: .i^_Y' .If ,'i 11 -r in EC ?'. € :' •• )' .,°.': •!' ' E .ik" f . ,3, iA ,`41,:1 : r' ?,?'+ t?li::• .a v1, "1. x ,, a' `. ;fir ,F t l 7' qqji 1 i° 'v i' °f:..Fl, .,3?. > ,: .1-.'f_ r,'. °.. •:? »y. k r. rt .3 ..?"L"j j?' ,k}•. - ,0: B.- ' i of •/°"'r',,i :010 i 1.. ,l, A ? ,t 1..,•, ! w,.' `, J;' ,°b...41:l? tY, IT ,?^ 4' (( .';:'Jw ,?' ! • .,3 _ F1:? ??'. 1, .:a' .lii:: 'r:.-' `r..k, '7 ".i ry . ?.? ':4:1 -' .a:-. Fi ' .fl:G '.t' .} . i? .', r. ^ !f.'' ,.'r. . , t, .•, ., ?.d ,f- J: 5',l, ,i Syi >?,? ,1` ?l ii'. ' ,1:.,,a^,f#11 ` 1, " ,0., !' t. i .i• .1'1 s'7},1 f 9i T .;' Yiry ?:. l !r• #.i°r ,,., ,":' 'f ''; :r:... . .:•=? 's:".cs i .1., . i ii a il. .t: •»;., ?t , r : F. r •61 Cr''3"4'1 d'` ta:'.S. ri?i •r °•.R?."N3:? t 1'4i7y i`.r:I :'1°. :r t r r: "ii d " y ," 11 03,01I ''.1E..,C, a ;':. r. .e:, R'?'•! 1..,E e, ,'+,j,',a1, ( f. 'tk v.l.'? .:. n„%j .Ji ''.1:`' 11I .?,° ' a Ytv .t, J. .. 'N',+,? ,?• :,} .1 •.S 'r: ,.1:':t," ,lT,''?. °S.; Rte b .. 111 51 -+: ,7„.,t. '"/' r' s, r 1„ t ''?'i: ql'y ;: io. ,t;. " r..'4. -e'."15T,.-,-,I-,- .3o." ,r .r.. {>:. f,. .r,s .'i?.,1,r'i r r " ' , t• ', ", :, •1. .? ?4i , ,a;. i,y , j '•is ,r!'.. r 1',.,:,? '.'E ~ .'•r: . I:. + T.._?,. esj.. F.1 + <r' -1"':. a " ?1 .?'.`i ' ,Y 1 . 4} s. :i `! - ry ',i s;r'' t'r<:j. t fad, J'° TWIT""", '". ,, : 5; ;' ' ':t ;?; .•t .. 4:Pr. 5:; `'>.'- .Si ,;ij', i• itc.: qw a' J•3,rr., :i.-}+y:;' .11'' -'•F1 . '1., .'v •,i '", i:? r• a. Er:?l:?rf 7 .?fl e'S l 11,41 '. M j !:. R,, S.` €,, `,2 `''. ` 'j k. •J" 4. yry1: aS. .'F ,;y. }, :: ?I.o :f.:' t: 'l A• IS..R ? it ??r,-, -, , "'A:t? •; : ?I'1,:; IN Y !';4 :T•:v •V ?„ E;•!• :M . (. t:•. .L-I,. r 1S:'tl - :,'f`..: ?"$,f.,,, r,4, r'1'-;'- .'..1, .n ,). ii'.1...:? 'I yxaR," .•,:.`(')'O 'iL• jt, it'r')r' f ?1. t r:;r?; . ,\ ':;'.`j `1`.r;.f':. .I-,.€, 1. Tj+t??: f' =:,i.ri a ?i r.i,:,; -s.l r I.1 j y i ,I • _ sr , ,. , .1= t: ` ; +4', = ^ t,'a ?'' ? t' 'r ' a^; E.rl ; y•, 'tJ" ??! - t','Y'.d. x, '`,-? J ': ,,,.? -t oily .- n+: „}; .'4;,11.1It11 '4,11d5, t :. i tK..si;r'. i '1 . 1rIM7 y, ` . +^/ . :•,: , I::. 1,; : r.'. , t • r'-,,1p;.^`:!;` •3t ;e'.,r;: r" r•''. 5!V ?" ' 's. •' ' 1 1 7t`r . ! `x'3, t C; >• y. r a )•,'.':r °^I'. '.2 t r, ," y., ';„ • `, i r S 6,14: r'4 . k s 111.1 S. l„ ['it r :a s;} iiii G$Ft:;t [$..;t ;t,t. % :T'IT ,! ?'e' r?.;? Lr } i:F. , ' t x,'.+ : R ,r, v. ?jn s 1' a•t.r• . x, - ,•?.9: :1 R J ,. r., .a,,': f s . R .'i,`: :x 1 •J ? 5. Gi a '? ; ..i::',Ja'1' >•.:1 •r?tl+? k: '.iz4 ;j,l f, .' ?.!'- .r' •l,:•r'* {: :?5i,'i`n ,d•,t3:.• :"t `' °+ 3r'•'I?''°' uf?, ,'1 d i- ;B+S', -1 t'1 ,"t'=s', et f.. .3^ rrr ,4' m.i`1R:: '1;' _ T '.R• r `.. ::-2 {q _i•+f r•ti. •I'+SF•° .IQ ,tr 'a'ria: c'.?p ,".r' ".)k I .s 3 .: "S` "a", '`ls -?•". ,i•. •.. a? i v, ft -: ,.ia•`'? ..f #1:A14 ' ,• i . r, ? ,',i }'? i 3.. ?,' ; .: s•., _ , 3=,rtF • ist,+, w : i- ' ' .6. .Ji """j, s lot V^'i x+rr,, .' tr. ; •:a .! '+ r.,' ,,T: '!f b, (?!, i:.. '':,^ .6 ? .,5... Rif,>t. j.li . ,j. ':1, 't :?•:?si 'Y rw ?f' `i,'' Vii': i;: . . .x, . .:[. n".j, -! ,l` .?'. .i3. Y,Y? .'1 .Is r. a L' (i) 1,;,',P1 1 •fx.r,. 4- y '"rJ' 9?'{ .a-'R ?,' ?'''rf }, Lh.{ , a,v(, .? .'F.,.n?_ ?`?(: ,. F'tot -. t` 'tr ?'<^`F- :'r, r5 f' I14iwIr:S?fTiPA.Fta.ar:..,...,i.r ..:?tt'.at'1x it?-? r....t°t?j?..r'k?+fS1+',ti;tst•ak:r.:>:,: ,:-I S. w: .. I' t!••s',.1.4»:>.°'?i.- k,s3 .1•.5. -r:'' ..r t:a,i,.=,i'"?'o iAr.=11.4.4;,..°°!'vr_ia., ?' `.i'?„ ' fir' :.(. ',?., 1.. i e- r ,. i.i. ..1 ,'r'.: 'b.. ~ z ,i, - As F, ' - ! ° J.!' Fd " .. ,' .' R . i , . 3r 1 Ef'- e f i. ' . t,."?'• ' 1. f . '; i '1, f' ?. ' ge,.i_: I. .". .. ,3. ° jR r!I' .r,' ' i,' rt: I '•4'ts 5 ..rYr. ' ,.,? ? ,? ., ,? ? , I Y. - " " ' ,? . ; . 1 T ? 1? , V? . !x 4 A % - z , - . ? -, , -"'?,?.", , - L? 'r,? i:;; R; . J r. .1r`irr.n^:.r` t?'. 4:'.5>'1 ..r},, r :l•v?.ry -`',? « ," i <1 a ..ys i tJ. x 1...4.. ,` - .l r . „ i w . e.F:., :q:.t 3.-,"i :j ?;':. iC r ;y, , " 1` ,r.f `i- >k?T.a.-1St + • ' 11 'f' , Y' ,e'e. ii .'»1"'"'C. Ft ,Y . R' `..7 /. ' Y . ',t If. ?+ , j+, j,- '?t 1^t?,. ,,,, .t': -'I, ' i 1" LL , I ' , s< ! } 3' ,t a '•f " r t.i:,`.i?•w'1't .1 1. ,,,, •;?; , _ ! ' 'r , - T' ..3. ,f„ r;4 IZ ;6!:.a 5-' r' .1 ,'i. '1' L .'4. :1{e' .?•.'1 ,.Y.~•3 l! M"., fait: :fir .. ," - .:i, `r"', ?',.-,r•„, i:fY' "S` ''"'1. A: 1•° ry r.t: 3. <t - I , ,I ..r; ,r,•- ..f, ': SI.,' i Ems., ? r. 3' , r .. I 'i '1i :l'. 'f' , "t°•t .3:. ,5i, •j;. 41.. r?I%JL r: '"; .,,' `J.:.i. x!:[' .'s, S'.S{r,(,t h. •1 "r: !,. " f , :.r jllY ?' ;' , I'. r f.. ' ` t r•' ?x 1 '?., . 1 r. _ t , r Iry s ,an 'r• ', r,s4 'f 'J., it ,,l`. 1' 'ilr. }`' +--1L -_ 1a' `+?'• fir. " : ,, .?'17f . fir, , , ?. r" r i -t' 'r. - / ( i??t° gf F:; is _ . k j i,+l i!. 'I' 1 1 i ° , , .,I ^.a :{ ° .r., ' . •?, {. r.^ ? ". 'mot ?,,, .?•ll, 'airs 3" `, A'' 7 f .. J •J :`L •. . f."'. „. r: r ' s` tr:: ,,, .i.i r.. I',:, ;3, t. ., tl' :r:.: i:: =fRi:>yF :f iry } 1, ;:c ;.{.;i' `1 ",?•,?,!',i.i R ,f`' t' -` 7Jr? '`.?,t'11, .:f• .:E: ,. !;", -r .'J• '7I' f fi ,4 z• A. end?Y' .C' }r' OAN I? t r.r; €. .L' . .;5•ir.,. fl. !5 1 } F 4 : :'Y I+ S f , '.,, '; .. 3' .}', ,' . ',''':.tr': .!° "i' F' 1-'31 r ?. ,A ,. , '! '.id ,I A. - ,T , ' .r'1 r•Iii .•j 5}::„Y..k'.d .:- : _ r .... .t t t , J ! tr, ?( . t."..Y »i'`;1.:,, rn? d]' '1'"f '3 • .'1 '.F. 1 , ,"R't' ,,I.' ri ?, e°, ,.3 ,=i )?)'j? R y't f - .. i. .. y.5 J4,. <3 Jt j. :,? , 'Y;r'. '?y, a 'S r .'y f t. R . r ` r' i - . 1 0 " ' )' ; r.. ,:'s!'.' "j' 4 1 1 Y }. r .. J: t* ..5.. 1.Y': ^1'`: ')"1 1'1>• t3 13s, - I. y\ i'Y' '' }? q 'E f'3 li -.,'° > 1, rl t ?, k y' ' Yi :... p• , 1,r?. x3. .i. p '.. • ,f ' , j a,''r. • . , s•' _ r,' " ' t r;' ° f ` ?, ' ,? '?, •. ^y'. • I1',,?, 'k.: f. f:%it .,f' : t: . . t \-'. ...r .r It. , ;1: }:. ',f'• ..' ,, ;St sli `JF•- + !.. r I` r x ". :14 s e , i :•" /• Vii- '1 ,J ,3 .. .'cl''i?j?' L. I :.? t 1',', r 1. • .I f +p. '.!.'° 3 (i : i ?'y,. Ii? ,r> bile'}+' - i `rl'l ,'i. .•s.r •'Jr „ti. „Sl•:°,i° i'J. rr° .'i:. i.' '1', r f?.' t :1s,,:. :t„' yt.0 11? .f?"', '.1' !, ., t' , ?it.'r.r ':4 rirlj., i t,. ;, t 'q'? F. .'r •'f` ?' r Y: !. : r :s' ~tR-'i' .S', sx •: i:? ,?'ti''?. er,m (, ?? } '?S•f• I .', 1r.t 1. 6.r `p:• of 1 7; -'r'ai ,k, fit. °1I' i ';Y (L, •lif.: ` t f ,.5 .1 , ,,?,,? .i, ir, ftr, ,'l'yF?'' Kt Y•t ;6 '3 j}?y/?.r •°Ji it r :'(' ry ,3 Vo- ,r. '1? ` ` - , - , r.. -il:'•??.e.,.ti.n t4 " ,?s?i_ti•;,+q :1 ,!. rs r z tr . R+ f = x• ;M? :'S' S f . I: :r._ .i':' 1 ' >il Yk "I I .4°il °,i j f ' t ', ": - :},. 2: ?'S So jay. 5 i. i , ", • , • i.i.K rll 1 1 ` -A-? ` '.5 ?e 'll • 6 ;tr , ' ,.I?r. ., e'• i%. I? -i i'1" t 9 ' f •ROSS •IG." .'ex .1'! :, fi' IY.Lry - ,.- _ Vp•'sfr S ?-JJ• '`'.S%° I . , e' i, .` s, l y'* a. v{, •,d k, '!= t 3 S x. ,39 , r : v. t. S?r? D#IX } « lr e ! I ' Proposed Reconfiguration of Foil Harrison 1 Myrtle Corridor ¦. '. t . For years, the City of Clearwater has looked for a way to improve the traffic flow along the South Fort Harrison corridor. Recognizing the limitations of the existing narrow, four lane roadway, with minimal right of way, and faced with ever increasing traffic, the City's engineers. have long considered Myrtle Avenue as a corridor that could provide some relief. Myrtle is underutilized as a north-south corridor, carrying, between 7,000 and 9,000 vehicles per day. The two corridors have natural connection points -- on the north end of the city, near the Atrium Hotel, and to the-south of the City Limits, where Fort Harrison turns, into Clearwater- Largo Road. Unfortunately, completion of the "missing link" of Myrtle (between Lakeview and Woodlawn) is unlikely, at least as a City of Clearwater project, because of the need to.construct an overpass to cross the active railroad line. In addition, most previous plans have utilized a "one-way pair" configuration, with Fort Harrison running southbound and Myrtle running northbound. One-way pairs provide the optimal capacity for the amount of pavement available, because conflicts with oncoming turning vehicles are eliminated. However, one-way pairs are often unpopular with adjacent business owners, because of limitations on access to their properties. This proposed plan, which is still in the conceptual stage at this time, as capacity analyses are being completed, utilizes an asymmetric lane configuration while maintaining two way flow on both streets. As shown in Figure C-1, Fort Harrison would be predominantly southbound, with two southbound through lanes, a two-way, left turn lane, and a single northbound lane. Myrtle would be the opposite, with one southbound lane; a two-way left turn lane, and two northbound lanes. Traffic signals along' the streets would be timed as if the streets were one- way; with progression southbound on Fort Harrison and northbound on Myrtle. This configuration would extend northward to at least Drew Street, and perhaps to the Atrium area, if capacity analyses so indicate. One key element to this plan is getting northbound traffic from Fort Harrison over to Myrtle. The existing route involves a tight, 90-degree right turn onto Lakeview -- a difficult, capacity constraining maneuver. The proposed plan utilizes a section of the old railroad right-of- way, currently owned by the Florida Department of Transportation but not planned to be occupied by the Pinellas Trail, to provide a free flowing right turn, as shown in Figure C-2. Should the plan continue to the northern end of the corridor, a lane addition -- also within . existing right-of-way, between the area of the Atrium Hotel and the Stevenson's Creek Bridge (Figure C-3), - would allow a free-flowing merge for northbound Myrtle and Fort Harrison traffic. Even without the adoption of the plan, this would be a worthwhile improvement. Initial conversations with the Traffic Operations Group at the Florida Department of Transportation have been positive, and they are looking forward to receiving more information. In addition, Pinellas County Traffic Engineering is also interested in the plan, as it would help i r .r '??,. -or°al-wN.^ 'f, .t.,f ,.ly .,, f 'y. Y - f;.;; :.5'i.0'.I%,?, ..F' '.C :'f'{' , F ?i;'?' y't la' " . !'r::,e.[iT; (i»_ln p-,,i<'7,iwtr,J- .r:e `i;t ";t.".(!'r •:?z`'.`j .,.r.I ?',.- •i' .. , .? -i;'. ''> ?•F, s'. ..,...+- ,,. l..,,.r. .i `1-st. f-S i' ,f+' .r ,. .Ai ', "^" -'S y.},•y ti ",'V ] >',, ,t ail ,''": -L: •i , n °( rl . '1' 'ys . s': .,i, t, r,, r' t I.• . r, t '.I.. Ili' A _ , i. , r. .e ,J t.f. I - ir },C:?''•M:' `. ?• ?+?. S.I r••+? Llr ,f", `t 1, ' ',,. r t, t` c1, j°",d,Sy ,10 , `"1" 'St] n •l, .e v II' 51:. .t r sir 'J. .•? i. ', , 1 'rIY`'.'' `- .i +f'''•.' I' `y i? . ,. ;: `r1 .. r -. j1 F ,';,'', •1'' ?A:{}r1s.,Y.t;l}f4 't:r..i; ',r ,'.'•. '`CS•eea?i'.,p R 4 1 '•). ,! :i .. d fp. , 1 •.1..i ?-..:'.:''ti .-I y'E{J'; `?-.:1.= .J'. '{; `r, .r t ".r .R 'Y: ,TS taw F"`` S,4 .. f '.. :/?" t.r {:•F.f.?. }aJii Lt'{-'t?C!ta-.,1„., "?'?. , Y,rs ?.r,. .r e?1'letf` • r? - ?/1 ' 11.• •3- 'L. F. .i5'r ;,??d"-r a ('S'.."s 'r: , Y 'T'' 1s d: r, '4j .>(: t`; ;',;p,...it .s,??,.fr y` If ,'! `r'' ,t'''' i{'.V Ir, 'Uta r , l f 4 I° ,.,., ,r. 2 f, .''! a. f.+_ I,, s':?;,. ,i, b,,- <( v...t: ,' C" i ,.A, ¢€?s •'1r .v '•; h 'y ,, ?• .', .. J. !r, s'?'l, .J': "'{7':°c°. : ,, pi Y;K `I` .it'.ar `. _rr :?. ,,- ''ii:, ;t11? ?f.. - . . 'i -J::'j .') ?. ,ei,:,' "r, J%" . ,- •-f ,a a S.is i'x /'.' `t , ,?L '• .!'. _ p1r / j" ,'if r'? J.1 , ',"•'' ,r ! } :F• W S 1y l NSA. ' 3<J ,} 1 ' f . .k _ L. } :tit" c?; _ ;/'. •'4 J: Vii'; ! r't AJ? 'I?, :.J r' ,'.y. i'?f,S.l..' 1 i+- ,"J' •.f.': r, •r :f,'' ="f, •• S tY .I, a. t. ' i-" :1. , .,C t,-•r is •r , 1% . i .yI _'?•, ii,ys't''. Y 6'a'. r : s ` s !7ne?'fi 's'' 'a 1'1 "A l ?.. :•'y. .,`s. / ' , `? " y°^'•' r4 I:. {;: ,%!.-- ,}id _ •f ''al;°'!s:., I.",,-, 'O. . ;y,. ,,{ kr. ':}. 'i - ?. ,.y: ,,r.'? ?' {:. , :j ? ,, .•3; ayt s .}. ^ie fir' _ :£'j. ;i t:s' .t. .r,!'.' t}'"i"?`•..t, t5 ?y °s . :'a r , a•. < s: ..V'"?. ?.. ::?., t i,? )•' • .. r " ,'' , ._F•. _ ` -r',r ?, ., .?:'r4!'• `sYde.:' , ,:?, ,t •. i.: .,, Fj?l. t },,="M1. , 11.I ,,.: i?I.'4v '.S , r `/. .. v "'!• :.k a 5 .,1, 1 u' i' , !-f ' d' .K i:1.Y y? .. 3,x EF 1'x,. 'f:,:" ! I," '; h., / +. r ,.tr.It. . t . ?(° ??yc: ,.; g'.i1.:1• .->..T.''" .,.r? sY ,"d: 'I:.. •. y.. .ir, )''d•.S• "<-v 6!.'!' 'rL':,'I,f. l°. 'S.. '• •1,' f.y,.1'r, J , ES t;` °, .a,.'P{ ?'} .*et .¢ C :.i', •.+i. •R:s, : . ).r. -I I ?' .', J.' I}?•,y.f.,, n. '.,'S.: .?- `irk' :St al'',,' t'1 "r.1 , ? V'f ,i, {'';.t. ',t, Itf:".'7r•i•,p- ,,.,,. r': S'.- - r.? , V3 (.'.C'.3i fit{ -9e,?i L ;1- r-'_% . "r°' '•if ;"l. 4, +r.`w ????`?pp,, --f ,g,t J)v; s' S yyI ' .i '' t .c,::•' `rp .,f,' ,," AA'+i1' 4d/', 'k:?:&A,.7- v,€, l t < S ` a r, .' 1 1! J. r ',... ...c'..' ; N..,..,,vl0,,. ,.tiiiYfN,v....•a. •,i,-d4.-.:'. "i.'{ r .,, - . • , - . !, - - ! {I. .l. ?Ri ?/: =ti .'i1 ., b,:• »a 1.s«S; ra;•:,k_.`J+, WtFr:.a•w..:t ti.XlS ° . . , .' ..s, ' ! 1 j , .; ,., t rs. I r i 4' ' r .J.. -f . ,,' - i ,F1,i _ "'v , :. ? traffic flow in and around the downtown county'government complex,., " . ' ' ' t" , , I i? , r . , . .1 ,., _.:., ; : Transportation Group plans to continue its. analysis an this proposal; 'with close -. ;,a t- :.. coordination with the Florida Department 'of Transportation, over•'the-next few weeks,'and.wi11, ` ; :: ??. x:, . be returning. to 'Cominissiowwith a more detailed plan in "the future. ., . ° r ? . °° L. ... " `.t`t (- 1• Y r t. A tf'-`fi'r+•,4 ' , 1 s , , , .. -d ' _r :F. 'i` :` 'f, ;" ?II.,.1 i i t zit,; '.i, ',f ' ., f, . . r" t I :-ti..: :fa:f? - .I t - r ° .s:.l. ,air 'aC ..?-. ' r " 3:' ' 1 ,It f f.. ie. 'r •J','J' Y:t`.,.,; , t :,',d' Lf.," s " ic• Tt1 ' , .J. . '4 , ;.r,. r'f ,5• ',4.!.-H,},i7H'9•l ,'i•` i • i , - .'t'. f i , f , . tl+. , , , .4.r , , ^` , .. .. 1 t,. ;l` 1i'' I , r" t t' : w ', ,. '"fit j' , , ' " . , r. R" ]? 1 f, , j..: k.: , ° , . } , . ., S, f - ' t. ,fl"; JF • "I I ' , • - , r r ' .i . :x:11. .f,"y ` L ... ;' ,tr F. ' (4ui.• < j f- , ,r ;1 I (:_ .1 ; •S : ,,4-'.S'. ti a,' ` i.1. !F, y I Y', .d', - , J. ? - 1 :s...8 "f•,'. -Si ,l .- , e? Y f: ;" . rr: .4 , .I, . . , .t•` 2 ,.,,: , s'?= - = i.• r'r`' r•f', J ..E} . ?r. y)«Yt' - .. .»......?..._.--•----.. ....__.. ..... .. - .. 3' f .. .,`!, ds+.t i..d'.ra,.•itita_ .4icR?.?tr1: r}}}?--, 1.'U`r. 'ri• ,.r.. I 'l f ,- 1J ? •4'i ?1+,".iFi, .,'.t i .' ,• ` i ` •rti COURT 'ST 4 CI-3ESTNUT ST TURNER ST # 1 z ¢ l O ! DRu1v Rv ND 5CALc JRSHINC. WY ORT HAK915MO a Q MaGNOUA DR Q ?. w MYRTLE J to > L . OT ? 5 ' PAIR 1` >- JEFF'ORDS ST x 1405 pl't.Q l Y ? ? 11 PINELLAS ST I CITY LIMITS VI CORBCTT S7 . I J C a L ni,^? G1Ub .. LAKE???'v'? RD , NB Right Turn, Lane BELLEVIEw RD (See Fi9vrs~ C-?) z ? cr za Ffqu?ne 'C_ / f •r ? f • ."?e FjY F?ra''f+'!t!i' ' fyi' l'F ! aAs?• re '4s+'.?''?? `i., l- ..',hie ,•',*`,• '?•. r •. ,11.1• .1'E ?j•. _ ,. y.. , 1 ??', f. Stir i, , ' ? + ? ? { ? ?' ??;'. '?,x•. ?',1! f' i 5 { ? 3 1'f:y -. -'!'. -' ,',J: ? :?. pi J,; iJJ'+ ?r i' ?1 I ., •4, i,i:LSL ei,r.. ti.? f a a } . s •t;.' ,' -'!: . t . r`1. }•,' ' s, r. .. ','. .1 i'•??' .fi);`:) •s,yw a?{' +1. '11 =': +;i`i •, '4 ?,'?, rr .d r S. !' .'r..f.. t" ?F;•'' s?? ?r.: '>" 1..r •: i?j' ,Q .3•; ?`(• E? ' 1•t ''l i ? ? r , -:'S' " .?"l t' .?'?.« 't,•''t.ty r?' .?": r'-.!' f: •f"ly' .i r.l 4''?5'? ' j75j L."fc .,?:+j e: -.f.?7' .! •J t„' Ij???l?,rt?t.tt ,t:i+'!yy µ'eVe~?F.i •14?` ? ?• 'i. :.i?l•ly 4 r'?.-y:t. P' ZY •.f}, ';r,' ?.-?'.??. f. ?,l1 .`i rj•' !',J ?rY'r' F?. 1'° i ?,1 y'? ? 1 .3 ? ? " .. 1 rnfa? a' r;a '•ll'Y? =.11 ?1?. .'?'': .Sl A e.y?^' -?y?¢,'iF `:. Vii., ., r;- ?i .. r .. ?' [rr:• ',•!V{!?}I E 'fit i' ?/.. S ,?.. ? j : i:? : r: t.?•-,1? r,; r.i'' • 6a . ' 4': r ? 3 +? 'rr ?. •,S"" ,?= ;?,`J,.r.i _ ,???: .t!°•, ?,;,_ '•,f dl Ili: 's. .i:" - r ~,: ;? »>:'. Vpf?71}:'d, .f; •,i 'J •'y 'rif "??,r .?`;i .?? °"?' i. ? ` ' r ? r YK yi5i':f1!`i1.r4a[ s .. stl:d", H'4'... s r??., _?."?-.{: 4 41.x, s J SF.,A'r?U.3?J ?• ? ?-`rtt ,t?F ?,•'. r 1 ... . .. . . .:. y. 1 .. ,y?`?, ,.° ;?! 1`:. it ? !?? ?'+ ? ?'• .,. . .. ? + I ' •. rJ•r ei Ldke'uie-w Rd 17 I-E d, ? 1. ' , I ' 1. ? . ,'r". y-?•, ``xt r. ear ? .. , , !' :^s" t?• Y?;Fa 1. If I I. .. . r ' d r, .1 S'x, 1 ?i?u.re C-?.. ,? '?:':?f7`'. ..tr. ?,r" ?? ? '' .,r. r - ?... .?; t?.a r_?..1? ..?1•: G;i t;<<'?a Tt hi -"It 't' .. ,. :'tti :1',?:?.,.?y'• 'r .a ? , 'e ai t..t ^,SSr 'l. •.`r.?.. ;P.,c i' f•?, ter. o' ? t? 5', s ?" - •i' 'jr;:.`!- ? ? ° ? ? ? '• ?:1 ?`•? R•,rr'•ayr " .ftrr. `i: +' y'}'?` 'i 'i'• ii : ? i° ' 'r• ?? n.'^?{•r'?3.? ?.? ; : r i'r - r r.r?i 'J'_ E , : ?' ? ? ' i , ? ?. it j • a . r,o? ??Jy ?{a:,''•; sj ??y 1• ,,(. _ 7. '1 ??f ?'•{,• r ?:?`, l ..?1. ? F r .. ? ?' '1. ? 'Yi' .r?:?.%l ,? tl 'y' ,. •,{1' '+ .''a,? .j i rte. • : r a ? F".' e ?. %?'?yt'?'r?i:r?'., ,>4? :t'i e, ;`ry?.;P?:r s Syr+??'?rr,r?i, r tf'?' . i' • ? ? . , .. 1 ,. rf?r .,r?' 'r+;?.?7."tt? ?rrl{?? ',?P ? 11 ,?? ?!" •otif``; Irjl;'J??.'"t ?3 r3.'•i '?r `?? ?1 .. V ?r ?? ? ? r j, ?'? '?".6?k?irti-:• -s. 'rtr:r.?..: <........., ., :;i"S;l, ,.. i..a':??,:..w>?i?:r'?i?ry,?.>: r'S ,. ... .. .. . „ _ .. ,. .. ?.. -. '... : i._.... <>'". ?• ? I - Loa+ne. c?.ro s a?• ' Sun Set w (2200 ?) 00 I 00 EX4Stly? C-6,r uy ' 1 easo.. 5t 1 . . zz? fe C.-3 . a e S ,.f?'Tt, r`?, se's: •.? `'•f" "?'=1''?:?f? i ".r', "fir •• f ' 4A FRED A. THOMAS P.O. BOX 6025 CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 34618. March 18, 1993 <. Mayor Rita Garvey Clearwater City Commissioners Clearwater City Hall 1,12 So. Osceola Avenue Clearwater, Florida 34616 Subject: Sun Bank Building and New City Hall Dear Mayor Garvey and Commissioners: I'am out'of the area at a previous commitment and.'unable to be at this meeting. I have asked Tim Johnson, my legal representative to read the letter.: Karen Martin and Frank Mudano are in the audience to support my statement. They are available to answer questions about the historic situation of how the Annex was purchased and built. Yesterday, Wednesday morning, I had the opportunity to review the City Hall Annex, the City 'Hall, the North Myrtle Avenue City property, the Gas Building property on Court St. and Turner St.,,and the City Police Department with the City Manager, Mike Wright. Following the review of the City Hall Annex it has been determined that the building is actually a 72,000 sq. ft. structure. Following is an estimate of, totally refurbishing the building. Attached is a list of those estimated costs. The total cost for a beautiful new building on. currently owned property is $1,794,400. Not included are. costs for exterior site. modification to make the property more attractive or termite treatment, as the building appears to have termite infestation. This remodeling can be conducted while City Hall Annex continues to function, using the same concept as the remodeling of pre-existing shopping malls i.e., recently Seminole Mall, Clearwater Mall, and Countryside Mall. A review of Seminole Mall would be in order since Frank Mudano built it originally, and then remodeled it, and there is no . relationship between the aesthetics and functionality of the Mall from the original Mall to today. Yet, the Mall functioned - it had its customers shop there and nobody missed a beat. You can do the same thing at City Hall. Begin at the 10,000 sq. ft. public purpose room,' remodel that south end, and move to the north: As one section is done, people move into it and you do the next section. You will not miss a beat in City Government services. 1, •• ! J 1 , March 18, 1993 Page Two The total campus environment, with all of the City owned property at the corner of Missouri and Cleveland Street, will allow the City, at a future time, to build a daycare center for City Workers. One of the current modern trends for businesses with large numbers or employees is to establish daycare for their workers. In today's economy, the family has both the mother and- father working. Providing additional daycare benefits for our workers would be a major advantage to attracting the highest quality caliber worker possible. This fringe benefit would also allow you to help curtail rising employee wage costs, because of the additional benefits being provided., I am not saying to do this now. I am saying this gives you the opportunity to do it,' and it is something that the City Commission should do down the, road. You can accomplish a massive renovation where you have a brand new City Hall on the property of the City Hall Annex for approximately $1.8 Million. If you wish to liquidate the City Hall Bluff property, you would receive anywhere from $1 Million to $3 Million, depending on the value at time of liquidation. There are buyers, according to the City Manager, wanting the property. Pinellas County has indicated an interest and Calvary Baptist Church has indicated an interest. That is without even going into the public marketplace. You can keep the building and therefore give yourself additional expansion room in the newly remodeled City Hall by using the old building as the Chambers for City business, and making a remodeling job of that building for additional City purpose business - civic meetings, etc.' You have so many options with this proposal. The most important feature of this proposal is that you can have a totally functioning brand new City. Hall for under $2 Million on property you already own. You do not have to remove a piece of property from the Tax Rolls. You do not have to deal with a structure that still has many unknown factors as to its viability as a'City Hall building. Whether the windows were put in wrong or right, the question has not been answered, ,This question is in litigation. There are too many unanswered questions to rush to judgment on the Sun Bank Building. Secondly, there is no reason to waste $6 Million or $8 Million of the taxpayers' money when you can get the entire job done for under $2 Million. City Government has never thoroughly looked at the Annex as a building to totally gut and refurbish. We have been looking in the wrong direction to solve our problems. I totally and unequivocally oppose the purchase of the Sun Bank Building. I do propose the refurbishing of the City Hall Annex into a new combined City Hall. The City Manager has stated that the Gas Building is in outstanding condition. It is not necessary to move the people from that building. That business can be self-functioning in its independent location. 1 F . M . d [.m ra r; ' ? ..., - . - .t,,r,r :S +it•5 1Fa_. ,r•,,.}+uF t 4 A'f!? is-i 'r . i ?i ,. ; ?? •1,' u? r,+; .. Y ,. , ' 1 ', Y'`t5 t f.. +af;+,.,. rrilrY :-' ,.,: 7', 'leA.a.•. .. gt.r.t ..::7.#.'a'?''?. .'s 7?". ,.. .. _P. .. .. . ,, ,• .a. ,'t itYY March 18, 1993 Page Three The original motion made by Commissioner Regulski was "to not buy the Sun Bank Building", That motion passed three to two. By, your own Rules, plus, "Roberts, Rules of Order", the original motion must'be rescinded before any new motion to pursue the Sun Bank Building.' Under your Rule No. 11, Amendment to Rule 119, Section 2' the, Commission's action' may be rescinded by a four/five vote. Any action other than following the Rules of the Commission'' will be vigorously pursued by me using all legal' remedies of law. We all want what is best for our city.- Together let us focus on more services for. less money, r: In this case, more beauty, more user-friendly, and more practicality'. for. less money. The. citizens need a new city hall. This decision should be made in a business-like manner. No ' successful .enterprise .would choose to construct a new, city hall or :purchase the Sun Bank Building over this economically viable proposal. I urge extensive examination of this proposal at best, continuation of this until I am sworn into office on April 19t. ' f. ' Regards; Fred . Thomas ` l6arwater City Commissioner Elect FAT/sr .f'. cc: Clearwater City Clerk , g}?"ti;'•°'' 15i?: xt•, i-; -d: ;4j1i'F', 5.. s, ! •. - _ . ,'r'ye. .+}?{i ',fit'-yS?• t ;; ?? f p j•a , S, ? P4 i l ?k ` . ./1.` e.y - IJe. "' - `'1. .'}I•f I?e4?1?,:I f, ... r '' '' .'. ... . ? ' ... i-i'' r`f-e`?}=??1,jf1p? ' i. l 1'rjl t f .?`?•'r'' . ;,? -l. .t' ? ,' fib: t'•`-<?'•, a ',I ,??>f,. . :.lam f •j' ? ?'^ [ w•:: i [ ' J° r a' '•I.s 5' !fit' I I[ ; 1 ', • I , J I Y •1[rf. f ' ;? _ ??'rr ., •.. - ) ?, ? d',, ?'i fit:.>? ? t? ?..?. ?. a ' ,. s'• -' .f ?? ?a? ?,r$st.4', :r'? , ;°, 'q _ „a??_E•tir.&i:.y,' ..'. "' F•'S}'?.`.t?i r.,r'; J...` ?,.. f. r ? .. r ? ,.-. n r r 1, - • Attachment'. LIST OF REMODELING COSTS " (Including a 10% Overage For Contingencies) ; 1. Interior Demolition $ 48,000 2 Total New Roof 40,000 , . 3.. AlI New Air Conditioning, Using Refurbished Chillers :360,090, 4. Modification of Electrical - Entire Building a 160,000 5, . Totally Modified and Redone Sprinkling System 60,000 6. Totally Modified Plumbing and Restroom Facilities To Comply With' All ADA Standards 60,000 f.. '. , 7: Totally New Exterior Skin Finish 132,000 8. Totally New Insulated Acoustical Ceiling . 100,000' 9. Totally New Floor Covering - Soft or Hard Surface 160,000 10. New Interior Partitioning For Offices in Any ' Configuration Desired 160,000 M 11. All New Interior Doors 30,000 12. Re-designing a New Entrance to The Building With ; Atrium Center - Approximately 42 ft. wide .2 4 4 L Total Cost for a Beautiful New Building on Currently- ; Owned Property $1,794,400 ? t i ? ` • w??i; . J S l. 'f, °.^}? ':rr??+ ?;f Fes , ' • ?S r? : w 'r .e ti t .'• ., ? ' . .? ' ;fi , °f, t a, x2t ty;'••.t.15??1 . ?? 5,'}?4%?'laiZa ? . - , ?x .s •; ??.a'Yt . r r ? 4 M E M O R A N D U, M IZe..c.? 3? 1853 TO: The Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission FROM: M. A. Galbraith, Jr., City Attorney" RE: Necessity for Motion to Rescind DATE: March 18,,1993 I understand that a motion might be made tonight relating to the Sun Bank Building. If the motion is made, the motion would raise, the question of whether a motion to rescind an earlier commission action is required. On June 18, 1992, the city Commission approved a.motion'which is stated in the minutes as follows: "Commissioner Regulski moved to deny the purchase of the sun Bank Building." According to the tape, the motion was, "I'll make a motion to deny the city manager's request to purchase the sun Bank Building." The proposal was to purchase the building for $9.8 million plus closing costs. The motion,, according to the,minutes, is not limited to any particular purchase price. Read literally, the motion would deny purchase of the building for one dollar. But, the motion according to the tape was stated with specific reference to "the city Manager's request." Robert's Rules have not been adopted by the Commission, and you are not generally bound by anyone's concept of the rules of parliamentary procedure except to the extent that such rules are imposed by law, the city charter, or rules you may have adopted for yourself. Your existing rules of procedure do not explain when a motion to rescind is required. Rule 11 of the Commission rules simply states, "Commission action may be rescinded by a 4/5 vote." If Robert's Ruse applied, three votes would be sufficient to adopt a motion to rescind. Taking into consideration the context in which the motion of June 18, 1992, was made and adopted, the fact that the commission membership has changed since that date, and the discussions and motions which you have adopted or failed to adopt since that date, it is not at all clear that a motion to rescind the June 18, 1992, motion is required in'order to authorize the negotiation of the purchase of the building for a lower'price. I am of,the opinion that a motion to rescind the vote taken on June 3.8, 1992, is not required,.primarily because the membership of the commission has changed since that date. Also, the difference in the wording of•the motion as actually made and as recorded in the minutes raises a question as to the intent of the commission at / t i .°t that time, which is relevant to deciding what is the "'action" to be rescinded if a motion to rescind is required. (Was the "action" to deny the purchase of the building for $9.8 million plus closing costs, or was it to deny the purchase of the building for any price, such as one dollar?) Nine months have passed and circumstances have changed. There is a fundamental rule that one city commission cannot tie the hands of a future city commission, unless your rescission of an act impairs vested rights or violates a rule of law or a city ordinance. This concept is not•foreign to Robert's Rules, which apply to a "meeting" or a "session" of an "assembly.." You are a legislative body, not a civic club. One recent Florida'. case discusses the necessity of a governmental body to comply with rules of parliamentary procedure. A city and others challenged the approval of rezoning by a county commission. The initial vote, on a motion to approve the rezoning, was a 2-2 tie; one week later, the rezoning was approved on a 3-2 vote. The initial tie did not'. amount to a binding denial of the application, said the appellate court, because no rule to that effect had been adopted. There 'was no.rule in the county code regarding tie votes, but there was•no obligation on the county's part to follow "generally accepted ruules of.parliamentary procedure." Parliamentary rules not adopted,by the county may be waived or disregarded, said the court, and courts will not enforce their observance. Battaglia Fruit Co. v. City of Maitland, 530 So.2d 940 (Fla. 5th DCA 1988); rev. dism., 537 So.2d 468 (Fla. 1988). I have not reached 'this opinion without some outside help.' I telephoned Joe Brown, the Secretary of the Florida Senate, late this afternoon to determine if he could give me some quick guidance. Before I could tell him what m}• own thoughts were, he suggested to me that a motion to rescind would not be required primarily because of the change in the membership of the city commission. The other side of the coin, of course, is that an action you take tonight may also be subject to revisitation, by the next city commission.' I am prepared to advise the next commission that a properly worded motion to "undo" a'.motion you might adopt tonight on this issue will not require a motion to rescind, for the same reason. Also, if there is any reason to believe that such an eventuality might materialize, I would advise you not to rush into a situation before the end of the month that might leave the city in a breach of contract situation. MAG:a Copy: Michael Wright, city manager Cynthia Goudeau, City Clerk i ? ?1 D omitown Clearwater Bringittg ti rtew view to husittie5s. 1'.0. MIX 4748' Clearwater. Vloridn 3,1618.4748 (813),162-6206 May 28, 1992 Mrs. Sue Berfield, city commissioner Mr. Arthur Deegan, city commissioner Mr. Richard Fitzgerald, City''Commissioner Mr. Lee'Regulski, city commissioner Honorable Mayor Rita Garvey city manager Michael Wright Re: Proposed Downtown Redevelopment Plan ' Dear Commissioners, Mayor Garvey and City Manager Make Wright.:' The Downtown Development Board, at its 'meeting on May 27, 1992, passed a motion to support the City-Manager's complete-downtown' development plan as outlined to you at a recent meeting and as released to the press. While the Downtown Development Board supports the entire plan, the-Board supports, in particular, the., following segments to the plan., 1). Expanded parking facilities providing for the purchase of the Kravas property with Cleveland Street frontage and the parking on -Garden Avenue Garage. 2) The purchase of the Sun Dank'Building allowing for the East End Development and providing for downtown core commitment by moving and consolidating city services to the one location in the Sun Bank Building, Please don't let the opportunity to purchase these two downtown properties, i.e. Sun Bank Building and the Kravas property, pass us by. The purchases make sense economically and will further the economic redevelopment of our downtown that is slowly beginning. We are truly encouraged by the enthusiasm and ideas that are beginning.to unfold. We beg you to approve this very important .plan for the redevelopment of Downtown Clearwater. It will not only benefit the downtown property owners and merchants but will encourage developers and investors to invest In our beautiful city, the- gateway to our beaches.' Very truly your Mary M )/Vaughn Chairperson, Downtown Development.Board , J ??4§r? 'p's?.}!f?k..i;ja; .. ;.a:?, 'rF:t.'r,?'{r }': >;jF, .F :" ':, 'r f: .,. ?.t. i .4, r,i- .s' "e• "?t?"i.' I?: S:•l:w. .a5}5..?>a.i;2v':eGJIS' i ~'i tij .1, l'"T. rN1n'..') !'LF'?Y'f,,l! .?trf. r• /' •.?. ` ., r rr? '.}?!'?::i' 'rl...`?y, .?,li+t I? ' r•''i '',a r p --. ?I'+d? . r . , - ;?`. 'j' ? ;•li?: ?; rs..rd'"f. ?, N'. E:•?!, i J•• .,'i s.' ,` M; } .. .. y ? ? .F ??? .ry?; f?i ?? A?;3'. 1 ``; : r .. -. f.'.??' ' I : r' .y ,, ''1,1..e ;, `sj . ? ? . c 1 • ' i.?.r `. I r' , r• ,?? h+.?:?,? '. , ., r'j> _ r-, .. ' ? •4;'EI j 4 t r ? 1 .,f y?'..,f?,t }`• ?l: P .,1!' .'?A'ri,{{5-0, i,'. '<Y t !. a' , ? .. y -`.:i r 't?yvtj rA'J.•?' S ' 'r l: '.. . N.'-. ; jt`['. ?' v ' - r .. f f '. `? .1' '; ?#Sr. b. py r(.;?f 1"•{,? "1•' ?•?yi; 'i` ? ,'?'r??'t?..?.'ll t. ?'s:`?'.s;{r, ?rjf?5?r: s !'. ?. r y`°. s•, `, i-,.. ?` ?.: re?',F ,S. rat ,,rr-- SP .( •i.' ? -„ '4. ???•..: i? ,'??t .$ "+ , v ?r 1 ' ?'. i'o,? F?P'1 G? .i .sit. f ? . r J fr . .r . y.. , r ? ? ?P ',d ?tl ` 1'n'?;',s°t?? 'al :. :?' .t" r'•',S, ' ':J ?.°r 6.. 4r:` .?i?rfi.., .'}.1. ,'1 - ri - } ,11 ;'? G "YYi "• :.. lif• Yi+=•}fie , ?M';-•lri•' ,?. a es ,., ,f:.. ?'? :t. l..f. '?' '',gf? ?,ss?:,*. :-1?fI ?.?-t`••'i<• t.:{, •?r .1, p?: P. 3Y ') ,]1 •,1; f,. K}?.?r' 4 t' , 't ' - ... ?i' dr•'?+' 1 .Al. , s ?, . k,:. .7. t.{E' 'i . i . y • ilf.. r'1 ? _ '',t°.. .i.l. .1'r. S`"?J. )fit '?!. ?j.f. +1 Y`f: 1,._7,. 7'?''t ?Y` -?14' •r' ?Il?? -. '1-, .. >'"; `?.^'?' q,Y%itYt a; 'r ?,°r ? s'!'' t3' ? e ')„?'Y s,' :!• _ :rl? .. .'..' :•r' ,'i ? •l.,re ?rFt'r2 ?r+/•f1•• ?? :'+ '?•i!y"'rf''?'. ???j??3r C. 'y,?:rjR„['`Si i. t?? ? ? -.i ,9•. ?4 ?7. ?•l?:l? .. '7L ;e1.'rR?4i ji.1?Y: '.4' '?d..y.-?,r :£.., ,•li?f`'i, i• linr;;,,'1" •,? ..iw". .. ,. ,? :t.?r,?'f,?s „? S. -;? •>; t.rr 1. Q, r, ?^ •t.'' :t'f '}{"i.t'? i^ il. y !. .e ' .. Ir r j•' 1? .i• _ i'„?.. ? eta „.,i?? `,1' '1 • 1 : ? t Y ? ?I,•r{,F,, i. ' 4 ?'?f RrS"., ? ,iN IJi'i? 1?j?7•i,?('?it ;??1'i?. ,j, 'I?t•c, ??; '.??'-,fir :i> .: =: .yk i,d? il, .' j.•yr ?''-j, '?t? '.' - ., '+tt "'f 'lr'' '.f- _ ,1 't..??t ?:reb;•'wrl .t<. r. 1>, {rr "y. , Sa.,??.,,xx ???.?x:' ..?v,'•5'`a _ ??"'e?.,ir"},':iy?-,?';!'t' .t1'.?'7 r •' rr, V'+;?"5' ?-?.?,'` ? f• `1 ?{. ?[, ) t.? rti, 1. ., s.7,k *ry_ . r.. ? ?? : , ' ! y - !f^'' .t r,e 'fit'.`' ?f' ??,? }•:z?,?"€` :i:= : ,,. t? %°+.?t.a°. ;r, ..t ;'i- i' a.' : , ; y' a' -! ?" ' ?°. °! ? : ?.' ?*'y',t -?" 'i'isE.- y.•i' k. °:?lr•,,. ?;?`??I,??rt .s}•'j t ?,LaSr ? 3,'??' ?,.t';'' ?? '.. r. St. , 'I.Lt?t; '•? j' .f;F' ! d ';'i°11 .:.r...f. r'.'P•t.!.!i+1!"!^, e3;?iF.:l1.:i1?• ..n'° r ' ,f;. .!` y. y'•'Ir I,i"' ,i4;..'. 4?;d,l.i'?.. i.?A++{?f 'Additional Information was provided with ;this item F SEE = .offic` Records. Re orts/Studies 'r, Vii[ ? :fit ? ? ? _ .. a .. •, ?` 4'... .. :i, ,'. „;.?:r r g?', s`. tit ',r? ?; -. J - I ?r t rik .!' ,. k i .yr' r-t?F•'1 +', .i ? r.'^____ _ - ?i?''.Y.:LL. .' • i• .s 3 ., .. -., n . .. ,,11',i {?tf;f?tk;:#!ty`i?t?F;:: a?:?.i 3 • rr CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION Agenda Cover Memorandum I teM33-1-18-93 SUBJECT: Feasibility Study - New Bridge at state Road 60 and-Inland Waterway RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Confirm the submission of an application for joint City and State participation in a feasibility study for the replacement of the Memorial Causeway State Road 60 drawbridge with a high-level fixed bridge, and pass Resolution No. 93-12 authorizing a cooperative assistance agreement for a feasibility study. ® And that the appropriate official be authorized to execute same, BACKGROUND: The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), through its annual budget process, offers a Local Government Cooperative Assistance Program whereby municipalities are invited to propose joint city-state projects for improvements to the state transportation system. The proposing local government and the state share in the project costs on a 50-50 basis. A relatively small amount of money (less than $1 million) is available for the state's share of approved projects in District 7. While this is not the process whereby a new bridge could be built, the.Local Government Cooperative Systems Program is our best means for instigating the ten- year-long process necessary to complete 'a new bridge at Memorial Causeway. A feasibility study can be performed at a cost of approximately $100,000 ($50,000 City - $50, 000 State) and is necessary to identify the complex. considerations involved with a bridge replacement project. The study most likely will examine Drew Street, Cleveland-street, and Court Street as possible take-off points for a new bridge and the very serious impacts associated with the possible geometry of the on-ramps and off-ramps at each take-off site. We are unaware of any plans of FDOT to independently begin this first step of such a,project at this time. The City of Clearwater's participation, however minor, will, we believe, begin the process and greatly reduce the time frame involved in a bridge replacement project. Because March 1, 1993, was the deadline for the submission of applications, staff has entered an application for a feasibility study in accordance with. DOT's application rules. We now have until March 22nd to follow the application with a resolution by the City Commission. The resolution is attached. The application, also attached, can be withdrawn should the Commission desire. ? Reviewed by: Originating Dept. ? Costs: Commission Action L l Public Works k ? (Current FY) i P es 93-1 ;? rovedf A ega ! pp Budget NA User Dept. Funding source: 1 Approved III ? u/conditions Purchasing NA Capt. Imp. Denied Risk Mgmt. NA 1 Advertised: Operating i Cont?d to l Cis NA Date: other ACM NR Paper: Appropriation Code(s) Attachments: Other Not required x Resolution 93-12 Subm' ted Affected parties F.D.O.T.Locat Govt. Cooperative notified j, Assistance Program Application C1 r Not required X er60brg.agn , J =.t. r , RESOLUTION 93-12 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION 'OF A LOCAL GOVERNMENT COOPERATIVE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT AND JOINT PARTICIPATION AGREEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, FOR THE REPLACEMENT OF THE MEMORIAL CAUSEWAY (STATE ROAD 60) DRAWBRIDGE WITH A HIGH LEVEL BRIDGE; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. rj WHEREAS, the Legislature has created the'Local Government Cooperative Assistance Program, Section 335.20, Florida,Statutes; and, WHEREAS, it. is a policy of the State of Florida to construct and make improvements to the state transportation system in a cooperative partnership; and WHEREAS; such partnership shall be promoted and encouraged through, the joint funding of projects that improve traffic flow and reduce congestion on the. State Highway System; and, WHEREAS; the City of Clearwater desires to receive matching financial assistance for such project; and WHEREAS, the City of Clearwater wishes to make an application for such project, enter into a Memorandum of Agreement•and,''if'the proposed project is selected for funding, enter into a Joint Participation Agreement with the State of Florida Department of Transportation; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section I. The C.ity Manager is hereby authorized to apply for matching funds under the Local Government Cooperative Assistance Program. Section 2. . The City Manager is hereby authorized to enter into a Memorandum of Agreement with the State of Florida Department of Transportation. Section 3. The City Manager is hereby authorized.to enter into a Joint Participation Agreement with the State of'Florida Department of Transportation, if such project 'is selected for funding. Section 4." The City Clerk is hereby directed to send copies of this resolution to the Department of Transportation and all other persons as directed by the City of Clearwater. Section-5. The City Manager certifies that matching funds are available for the joint funding of this project. Section 6. The City of Clearwater certifies that the project is cons,i stent with'the Florida Transportation Plan, the Metropolitan Planning 'Organization Transportation Improvement Program where applicable and The City,of Clearwater,.s comprehensive plan. -JYi'+/'r"° :`tls,a- •:.; '.'M W"`7..l,}«,?.T4;r;.-•.•t. .i.:ra..r ?C.:,,." :4a :- , :Ft ° {t (P,,: ..,....,, r,, . ,t•.v', :,.7 } '1f:,.i?•r" '11'1t•n; lc ?r.'•n:t• , r":) .? i .. 'a '3 _ !^.^'i ' "t "'i:' `!'` '},. _ . [; ..1. :`i' .(.•" .1' 1E. '•f .3,y 't -? , `S. , ? `rt. `'9Yr;15i ''-,.ri;V #7!A;•} ? kir;:r': , .,,.N': .T? •'. e,.lt,' i '>ti:?'S,. ?v, :.W , ' i f?'S`' ,... :I"..1`.,C ..: •p'::', .r :.1'.:{.'?ry, :'a}.. .} ,r ;. i i 3 r ,}k}. ,'!. !r r. , . 't -. 'r; , : ,}." ' _'}..: 4,,yR ?. i ?o` ?; p f- ": , Y" ..y7' .. y }. ' ,:. y r i. ,.. :4,' •-.?f' ,.1 . -Z o, , ?, . 11 ''': ?I , , " s • xr.r e<°?i: i'," 'r 'I'?' rb•' '??, r. 1•;: i(' ' }' ., .{ J, P•.'I.r.;:?'. ,r'S'?+'t+l?v s€jI; '?,9J," ,.•?: ..l `?'. r, . ? , #. .: '? .f?' fe. (tI: ".'ti' ., ':.#??5:'r?A -'8§:-1.`'•?.?' j.°:{F?«l?.?.`':'F?: [1? ?'j• r. r• - •-?i" s_'. .a' •??•.r, •,3"f :}l-t':).,F,!"? ?a! .'1 ,(• j:, li 4 3 ; t r e} f !. }?' (i . b t'':: P}. 1° `,,t " s F' ?' rt-" '> 's'I '4.:'',?LY'a:, i+P,r y 7; 4 ;r` ,'i, ,,,iA.:.,7, ?t ;?,rS tr:.'s, f tr - "s.t, '?'! -tj1•':e , :;,<<•* eeJ ,,•I I (' Ir ,, 'dt? .' . - ',f... 1r,1 ,: .,;r '!'.t;' :tii'r,}???y Y!''wati, '•- iEs• 1'.i •,,• ") ' • • ",?• ,?? ? b +'i,1 ,: ?? > • s; :ia„ C1.,i jr. I ., - .t: ,.. . :u . y - : . t:i ' .1 .s . . , . . ! . s . i >. .I -'r " 'i r . t' rti . .. s• ",i? '.L' I t' 'i: Ala .7. .r e,;ti: ,j, b, :t}' '?,+',"'• '?`lS X. FS: Y,;^ E t;; " a4'}:.d•?.':. f. f, ' ,Jiir r .. 6 ' ' , . IS, ?`7 ,. t'?'',t rl 't,. ,`?`' " Yr- r,.I l?` '1+,.'Y ,+?'` .t itd.•?9.,1':'',, ,,. i.- ` ! _ - _ " Y 1- `,? I r1- •?S.?r, ,•I'.,. ,S.w,J .I i{:. a -'.c f :e: i,' s r' r.t•. '. y-rtII ,_ i " t ,.s: t ; :•t•,: :J? ' ;; i1 }., f., t'.., 't. `?' • >j• :r ' 't^ "l'.''' 'f,: :F. i,r, } a •?'•' .? ,l'-.:'t•?', ,.j,..: S'':v ,,?'%!.}'-F, a.? ., r . i ,' E ?.', i? - f J. I. 'E? „(f. ? .}e -•`• ? . Fr 1s. "F,j.c P ''?. `1• - ',9?' (, "} f . % "? - t4.* _ . f' ire rc`.,: 'S ; ,,r ' :''? f ` n ' ,y: : ''i. J.',r i.?,. ` '> I' s.i , , r ': }r,?,, }': x1.-? . F! ie•.s?r _ .';' ?j' :'{i '' .i! .=r/ ; ,:I r1 ,-;r ,, i `'}•:' I.,% " ", ' ,; .w . ". ,.#. . ,r r - t t.'.. - ' ,? _ jf? F t ". 1.: .;5 . ,t,-,+' at . '' ," '. E ' ,. f.' . E. r- pr' J'?? t: V.; )S, i. .i. '.',"i i .t, ;, .'i1}, .?.. ./•_s, :1„." •i'?' ',+ .?,',i".a-i' .,E - ?j. .. 'x• ., " ?.:,• :r';,:',-yF 11'° ;!'fief ?, ^f_ ?!.{;'L' 'l, fs; a' s, ,, 'F t:0?'3. J'?•`''Zr ' •'f ` ,e. ;i . , . ',%,'..:}'.7'..lj. yy' 1, .v "' . tr'. r ' :;i'• x ,,,tV v7.,t, ? `l1 r;t .; , r e; jx r fr:'; ' r ,- M. l1 ??,,[- J. ..7 1 S D,?w. .if r1l c: H31 ( (S {`aS: {l'j[!• ?• 'd'i,I r r' ' . ,!' ry?l1, i; y } ?f r`'> ? 1, 3 ,!1 •! ''l. :'jws. ..}.? ?.. , Y 5 P'; ',•}`;Y'`.P'?i`,f, ?: k. .i?' 1. rt L'": }?t ,{,'.7 ti-Sf}_ i /. " ;1,.r J, .}'' ,,, :'1, 't.fl, 1? • i, T 'it ,,jP 1 •r,- , :??' ,5 . d",ff ? i., ,' .? ! 'S i]y . fii', .'`'r• yY,; E , , , n , "1 s-'. ' .r,- ?, .Y. ;"'F { ' . ,•.i '.i; ' e i. 'r . fn 0.. "I:'• ?s' •f 'E r:r^ .t, .,-'1/.,s ) :', t "'?` r;. Iv`i' -.. 'a,' t,,,,L: t ,, .,^A, 1. ' :, ; }', ,d q? :d"•_J' *{. 1.'r,.l,' w.•e rr,a rt r L ".;•' ?i.?.a ,'•'.i- "}. .t:F. ;fy`, ''r. hp..:ly, i; lL't S,i ;l{f: 1, ';.;•',. ;,{ {,,`. -sf;1,A .,; l . r, it 'r Yd ''?"" r4r t ( `'rC '? . :tr, . r ^ <, .: •t , f [[ //,?? yF. `•'j''rr, 4r Y.yy {,1 }., . `. Y•• .t ,,. .# d.i S:S& `81. +., ..'e''.!.'a,, t -.lfI: .rt,YG., .L . Z `'?.a'! ., l?''t ..:A• Y:, .r 1., r(?' i •k, r.' .e h t ? ...u F•sr r q';..>, :',.,,a is .r':: ,. i iq :rr. iir,. .;.''rr.a r'.. rl;` -?°•.r, ` ij,, aE a' ) •. ,, t r f • . F'?, ?: .:'.. f Sec}tion' ' 7 Th's resolution shall take e'ff" 't immediately" upon adoption. . ` r: - PASSED AND: ADOPTED th i - day' of ? t , 1993. :;. --,l; . t;'` ,S 'Cynt ?a E. Gou eau • Rita 'Gar.vey. :.'r,1 q fl, City:-C1dr..k : , , • Mayor?Commissioner, ' . ` . ., ,. 3 i' ,{'.,-4C .. . 4ti'- iii e - r / ?; '''': ,j,Lt, :^r , iii i . - ' ' • a . . . ,; ,'(r : ., } (. J 'f. ' '' . , ! e' 1 r 1 . i !'• • .''" I I; I' '_ - - - '. - ' ? ? ? , '_ ' , ? ' ' ' ' .?_ ' ' - ? , 'r . ; , . , , r ? . f , ? " r ? . - ' ? ? , , , ? ? . . ? _ . L. ? , , ? , , . . ; : ? ? L , I ? F ,jA, t7,• - 't" r, , J s- - , • ' ` . ' ° :"j`, }.,' ';i3' ?,,r .,'E;, .'F:Y I E ' . . ', •r ? : , ` ? - , 'lam: j.?}C . , , r ii z 4., iz ?,re. "E Y F';` i • .}! .!` .. . . , }.icy r L. ?'s .}I• •r° ,i•t• f ,1.,~ i .!".:,:"S, r'.', ats{ti: F "!.. •, [ .,? , . . r j• . ^,'; '•., '; :M s r ..._ ... ,. ?.r f,I t''?. f. .. .fi - ?x:i" ` ,',• •f' ''` , • r • •y1 • , .l,. •S ' '' • . $" F , - .. `I. ? .; ,• ,'.' it r.^"1,:- I. I I • .F r • r • , , • ^ p r i f a . 5J ' , T, •. , J. i' fbif [ ' ' 'lV• f • ' '-!}J `' ?r' . . ? S'r :iy.:.... .-- , .. . a [ 1'. •?' ....[.. ,.,{. 11 4: ie , ';} . + .. r . ? . , t f .. . .. . , ... ? , a ; Sa?l i"perir.?' ? $41 Ott t Ica °G1- ?? POST OFFICE BOX 4748 CLEARWATER. FLORIDA 34618.4 748 February 26, 1993 Mr, DbVid A. Twiddy, Jr., P.E. District Director of Planning and Programs 7340 Planning/Mail Station . . 11201 North :McKinley Drive , . ? Tampa, Florida, 33612 `. ; Dear. Mr. Twiddy: , The City of Clearwater, Florida respectfully submits the enclosed application for participation in the Department's "Local Government Cooperative Assistance s'•:. (50/50) Programming" for fiscal year 1993/1994. The project as ro osed b the city is to perform a Feasibilit 1Plannin Stud at a. ' cost of approximately °4 100,000 to replace the functionally obsolete "Clearwater' Draw" bridge with a more efficient structure. Given 'the present life expectancy of the existing structure it seems prudent to now begin the necessary planning to determine the feasibility of replacing the existing structure. Please-do not hesitate to contact me should additional information be required by you or•your staff. ? r ` =f Very truly yours, r, William C. Baker, Director of Public Works YY CB;jI Enclosures i i aft x 1'l e ???? r ' ? ^ ? ` ) %i :.?sf :'.? ?'?,c1.1 •317 }` '``?r? ' ' ' + ' + E ids ' I ' . '. ., i• ' ! , . E FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION LOCAL GOVERNMENT COOPERATIVE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM PROJECT APPLICATION FORM (TO INCLUDE EXHIBITS AND AUTHORIZING RESOLUTION) 1. FUNDING INFORMATION A. Funding for State Fiscal Year July 1, 1993,-'June 30, 1994 B. Department of Transportation District Seven ;. C. District address - 11201 N. Malcolm McKinley_Drive,_Tampa, Florida 33612, D. Application due date - March _1, 1993 H. APPLICANT IDENTIFICATION ' A: Agency: City of Clearwater, Florida B. Contact Person: -Mr. William C. Baker Director of Public Works.' C. Contact Address:, City of Clearwater. Public Works Department P.O._Box 4748, Clearwater, Florida34618-4748 ` D. Telephone: 813 462-6970 E. FAX: (813) 462-6641 F. Agency Federal Employer Identification Number (FEID): 96 - 000289 RP/[orms.d! -E r r 1 Vx} ' •i?' ,j•i z'fC , •?,' ?;',!' ;?, ,•?' .s?. , •'1 •. d .. ? f , ., . ' 'r?' t .l,Y'' y;,J.:..c}F r[sg' ? ,?',r'? i -'R• '? k. ,i. Y+ ! i? , _ ?r 1 r ' 4 'rt•1'1 9•? 'sr..t? ??. •'1: It ?. ?,F'r ?r ! r. ., - ? _ .. F''?, -.Yy ?.1,1j' ..l. ',.?, .' . ,?. Iri, crfl i,r''.. a?S ).•r ?, ' ? r ? ., Ir, ..' r. j' ? •"i -, •`r?? ??r: ,li, .v• ? :a.,' '£' i:1' '?'•? ,:r ? •Jf - f ? ? '? ?a r?''£;??J ,?A •.r' ,r £, ? ? 'i 't .?:?? FE,jr .'rJ,?, i_''r ' .r . ? - -F, I ,fir d <`f.S`. ?t ? ??'.t " ``,*,fl•"y`., 1. .; ' .• •.f.i:•: r.•fr4 > v.}' . •' :° k, .. ,r'. t.Y, . r. ..,: f!- :l',•,i. :y. t ' ..: `F ? i,.1 r? r . , i ,. .. ... .. , ra{4Ck III. PROJECT INFORMATION . ` A): Project Description: Planning and ,Feasibility Study, Bridge Replacement, S.R. 60, Clearwater, Florida. ' 1. Brief Narrative: Perform a feasibility study to determine the potential for replacing- the .:' existing functionally obsolete Clearwater draw bridge'(#15444) Which ':. crosses the Gulf Intercostal Waterway (GIWW) atrmile'p' i 1:508 on.:. , S:R. 60 (Memorial Causeway) with a modern more efficient highrise 1 -structure, • , , . • . ' .. 2. Typical Section,' :. Not applicable at this time. .?. I Work Phases in Application Project: ' Planning and Feasibility Study-(1X).. :`' /1OT1115.d? } R r ass+???? ? ? ? r I ? '? >• ? ? I ? ? ? ? -{ ., ? ,? To? :p?F.?' ":}5.'4!i°s`'`} :ill,.-<??•? w A . ?? r#•£,?'.ey'?X? ??'y'r i?y ail ?: -.•• 3?a F rE= :? - t' lr l,??Sritti r'i±: ... .. ? .. ?l. f !. ., t=? .d.i . •.S ?•r r,ti ' 3 ? ? ''i; f , 4. ,Project Length: A roximatel d miles 1 kil me ers From mile. post,'#.'N A to mile post* NIA., ' From: approximatel 1000 feet west of the wet nd f the rid ' 19) and then east to the intersection of Ft. Harrison Avenue (,Alt. U:S. Cleveland- Street (S,R: 60). (See Exhibit "C" for study area) B), System Identification: 1, Project on the State Highway System? YES X NO " 2.. ° State Road # S.R. 64 County Road # NIA 3. 'Local Road Name Cleveland Street and Memorial Causeway 4. Other description Federal Aid Urban Route k1456 C). Project Schedule:' ' re Estimated date to: , Project f. Project_or_Phase Start Complete Days Planning (1X) August, .1993 April 1, 1994 270 Calendar Days.' D). Project Map(s): See Exhibit "C'' for study area. ; e RP/formsAl I . 3 410W L L ? ? ° ' ? ? , ` ? . ,r ` ' • .. a ,` . , _ ' ,. • , . ' - , . . . . , , ;. , , , , r ?, ? ? ? + a . • . ?` ,. ? ?? ? - . ,' ? r .' ` ? 1 ?' ? ' ;' ' , . ? , c f . , , 1 , . . r, 1 Vii., a' ? • , ?•,t ? - f??? .?w'. Y ? ? ? ? ... ' ? ? ' ?', ?E ?' ' ` . ? ? 'f•? t, r ' I ., ?? ' - • , i .}'pi;.. s:e tl, , .. '! _ , ? °Y f'. .?, {., .- '. ? ? ..- .. Jn 'f?. ? .. .. . .- sr.-r i?iHt IV. PR OM ON SYSTEMS/PLANS ' YES NO A. Application project is included in the current 3. Adopted Work Program? X B. Application project is on the State Highway System?. X , C. Application project f consistent with the. 1. Florida transportation Plan (+ 15 years)? X 2. MPO Transportation Improvement Program?., X• : ; o..;." :.: .'.. , ' 3, Appropriate local government comprehensive p `' L plan? X , WPA Project Identification Number: To be assigned upo project. * * ' Local government ID #: To be assigned upon selection for furidin wi df r the grant assistance program. , , s ? ? ? r• ? ? ? ? 1 , LT?S? . f i r ?' ' ' , , , ?? ' - , z ^ ? - ? a • s? s?. ? t ., , .. .r •? _ y?j. C. ??????' `?1•F"a ,4 ?i,.?, }•h l,.?'i L??Pf??? ... '=.1y .}. v '? ?' ,.i, .y, a 'f° •T'<;f j.. +,':' {yk',!' ^ .. ?z '1 .• `.+ d' .. i. .'r ? ' r , " ? .r l .r ' Y ', i ? ? '? ? ?•.' `J' '' ? 1 I ` 1 ! , l' .. ? ,•?i• ?s3 tyl{. • ? ` - a ' ' .i1 %' '1a ? cr ? ?1r r ' .Lt .?. ?'?tl , , . 3 " ' '-)? rl s '•,?,r , 1 , y .1 ; " ' ' ' • ' r', . ' r Y• R • ' j,.. .F ? r rF .ys 1 1 r. .1 [ 1 a . '?'?t iis' ? ?i t . ?, ^. r , e f " _. 'J, r p r e ''°f .l ? r ? ? . . Y.' ? - -'''_? 4?k" ?' ` ?" ? ??` ? F si t rr}' •i • ; 1?` ;t?J: i i ' < , R ;; : { - ?? ? ? ? r • ,.? , r -41 e ' ? ? ' 'i• , = ' it??• •sa : ?f.` w. '1.:, 'L , ;;r" ?. r .. 'r ?, .. - F? ,,LL11 iF+is ?i<° # ' r + t , ' • [ _ , ?? ?, r y ?..ii. '? .1. d. r` ,. , ri t yrtrF ??? `.f '? ,?,I ,r' , tr, . L"LLr `.r;•'3?r , yI •,..?fr . ?4}: f t i„ `t •(' ' l . f , 'r r , ? ';•?I;??'r 'i Y??• •'l :fflCu j.yr,•,#.,,. ?l= $ ,.J.; :. r. -i• , ., i ,j'. .''. .t',r.J: - •. [[•, ¢ Jr .,4?f?'? •h ll,.?f'',! '?. ?? ' ` $ , _' i. .. ,;y" _ i_F• .l`:i ''. ?',!• •S •..2??,.I ?kx 'rl}^ t I f ' °, `!f • 'c, / s ?'i a ! 4:f 'F • ? ? ? ° , ' t, ',L` et ?!rr J si ,ne?'4'. . , . r•, it.. .?.•.. . 1 r > !. ;.rS.?r?.?: t.? , ., - ,`+< - 1 .! YL ` .-? .? ..-. .I..iJ.e.+.. +D.. ?:" t i ?`i'r '. r. ? ..r r . .. .. • .L:.artft?:iil r V. STATEMENT OF BENEFITS ;. attached ExhibitA , . =:4. • .r:, .. '. VL STATUS OF PROJECT COSTS ft. :... : 3 t..r. In accordance with Section 3 5.20, Florida Statute, Rule Chapter 14-89; P.A.C: and.. Work Program Instructions the proposed project qualifies for articiPation as a Phase P " , ; The resent day. cost estimate for this project is $100,000:' No non- uali "n phases' have been identified at this time nor'are'an donated odds and service antici ated.. I ? ri=q 't r ' ; 7 ., i . 7 ? ..} ! 1 Fy ° ` r , 1 rs , , ` +1 • . 7 d ]? '?i.? . ? 1. , ? ' S ' ` ? 1 i r r • . t , . . S . '' F? . r .. r f '+? r f r ' t?' ? ? 37+, 'r. f ,', r r = ` ' t r • ... . . ': 4# ' RP/fnrms.dI j . ; , 1 • yid[. ? ... , { . r ! ? ? 1 Z ?• ' , ` ?'? ? S l' `S. F ?. t ' ' 1 9 . '? }y '? '? ` .'`ix "w . .? t !: , ?e , l, • .. : . .. t , p ? !• '-?, y, s.. ;( sir ,1 r'? `q::?'' ''1 •.i ( ? y, i i ? f . ? .? ? ? t, a , r 1 =( E r Jr ti. r?;r, I? . . '•aY 1. ' i g ? ` . f?d:'i(ia....ir'., .r. ..._ ,, ,. .. . - r .. ... .. ... ., ... .., a."1 .3 ..x,.•.1. 41,C ..: ut- f, .-, ... .....;a,'rj?` I .VII, ' SCHEDULE OF ANTICIPATED.PROJECT FUNDING a Qualified cost for the proposed planning and•feasibility project is $100,000: the City of Cle'arwatees percentage of the project costs is 50% or $50,000, the percentage ' . share of state funding is anticipated to be 50%a or $50,000. ° VIII,` MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT (MOA) , 1 Kf To be performed upon selection of the proposed project of refunding under the gram ' assistance program. " IX: AUTHORIZING RESOLUTION The "Authorizing Resolution"•'has been scheduled as an action item at the next z, , commission meeting and will be remitted upon 'execution as Exhibit B. •, ? '? 1 l ? ? ? • ' "I • ? ? ' ? 1 r a `1 f'- f . If , r r ? ` 1 , , r ! v ! • 1 ..:' . ar r ai . K / o rins. • a i r - , • ? I' ? - ' ? ? , 't 1 ? ??i' ay? t , ? ' ??,' , , 1 i ? . ?. fir xsF??'.r., .•!if .. ?.ti',., iS ?'??. ,?zF;:t?i:;'?..i;I'N °'9}" i;Pi?,r":i'^'s:i eem3at,. .,?'a'.i- .?,•., r .1, L::ir .' .am?.r'h},,. aa' ", 1;J "{ s, E ;i'- i,•':`,l;:y"r '; ` .C"h. "r*4'1'%+ T... ..4 s?. ?*•' ':St r.? ,''b;`,">:. ?.,j,.:+„ =.t.r'',`•'+;•>'. Ar r''. £'< t{ .f(;? :s::t. "YS, id'. ,i,}:'. .,r _ .1, I--, •9'.r., ?. ?`f C" , ff :).-1'. '`s r$.! 'ir'.•. +C.'.,t.° .-i'., +:3i,`J .,F.. 'J: '°J'°iJ.'Q.• ,i, z .'.". fF'''',. .Y'f '?;• lr 'i J' -? ...-,a... f, ?- :r dP.. ?Jr -d1 ,'x ;lLa°7 ') -?F:? :}.t', i r; - .'t+ - 'Jr .rf. 'y •.,(„' ?.,f:, ';1.:;^`+!..t7a - • i ;, . • ,t .,? , - r ' t.I r }`s=?', ii: =r '1• ' ; A,i i=.I, ,Lt , '' ; iJ , f 'i? y`' , a ,. a r } , .+' ,r °a. 1 .f' - '' . I ', -jam .,''ft7. Y ??..' 1 11 ,. 1 + I' .r,°.' _•`;`.,Cwi) , t >S. r••'. f?yJ4. :?•.',z .', 1,•". ?y v t, .. - ,'. , +, x "A.^ :7,ri7,t4 -n}4> . •'f': S.' h' ?i•. .l,.?l if .S r'1, k , ,I 't t I,I, (. 4i, ,3.'yj,?l:N .'u .Kgv J:.„ i:,, ljY?: i`.4f ?•:'f 1,--,?ig• .v `I ,h-''?Jf , '/ ( .I. ,'I ',?' -+.. .. ;?.•_•,w 1, I . f d' 7 l?ii 6'F; P F:?S .: i' -'' ?d,.% ff.i° ^f,i, 'y t' , . 1' . }r`.: :'z w ik1 ?f$. n' ?" i 1l' t w 3r F i .f 'p' N'• .i .d ,P S'•' •. ? ? .'r,. .yh. 1, ? :'f. J, f'r' i;t:. .,a,„p ' I.. y i a `, "' 1 , Jsor f; i J 4 i 't' ; 1 f °°g. o' ar' 'l+°.F,'.t. r"^•.. "tC:'C { t,*.'?r,r ;1 ,k'," "Y': :1''- 'r}' '7'.' 'a.;. ?3!,'• 'I:JI ?3. .r,-+ ('?p? >tl?g':- ..?,:'.y° ,'k.t,{t f fx .af`• .(; ,if ,'_' 'rjr ,,$t? °t t s. 'sk r7 °i: ,, r. J (di '{ I'' f: ,f:. .1+ -r. ".S. j,''„):, y J ?P::r f''L . '?- ;IJ ., "..' t.. { Ft' 1 >` c a .1; _.d :T`i"s1 1 '1 i ?. '4 ?. 3 R t, ,y.'t i 4 ,l ,,tt-.• ..r.` F' ,? % .E1.1,.;r •.7 '] .g rl'., .r YC i.':I ' ?' ; is '''•t:"•...ti• - i'.. r , ;'' ,'. >, a; H, !1"i, A, 'a': ?.1: . •'I'r ,1: 5' 't' . 1 ;,; '.611 =IS: .?Fe,. r}J :? •x" _ F I'? tr.'',.}?.>:1' ?, :.'??.,. e.tj .i?..1r. t'•'{z< 1C' 4''? .i _ iS'?}'ta. b` ,1'' 'L r{.• '?'.. ??+. •a6 .F a . 'Sa. , r : .-,x+• .; . S,is'.' ?' tia - 1; - •t '1 t . : r. y `.'3', , ,1. 1 .! •'?.' .I, .Ft :) >V' .??I+ f'. 'J' k` Y', 11°. Y: - yt, 'E, .,,. 44 :'.+'v •'ti, ,}; .r:• '.7;.7 ?. `•.ta? ,li.•'l. '.r ` 'C'..t. '{' "k,,.?. `f?•i?:.. ._/,3, .e. „ir. Yt' ???, t. Y .J' T,' `<Y .°f 'f , 'rv 1. k'. ,1': :1 4 •;, y.' :1`1' r', ,V. `:?', A'• ?•3?a .s?T, ;?.. 't,f-. 1' ?t`i4'1 ;j' yE- A.;' 'yJ I: ,J ..r `J• it'1, J' 1 S `Y. 'it.?= S't. •. i iJ'.° •?C' r, a?t ,y a+. ,y ' I , i y . , S try '?,. •r/R, .i'- h: '?z ?' '.f.+ .3: r.•Y iiC! {.:fir: `I",:Y'`Y 'i :',' ,'i. i J .1 'i z'V t: y tv' 11ri?J- Y•: 1,: V, 4":a J S. - 'l`.>', }'JS',?.h: F Y'>' v l • !' Y, ,!.! /-.,7r :il. rt_ ry.Pf 1{ Y? :'1 11'" i [[ :I."y ,'.Y.L 'f, f L'. '1 . T.J? ,;: N?J'`'L. 3 S `' 1 e ` C,? y 'S r'?' f'. • . f. .cY `;`& -+!- i,t, -ra :`e: ''+ }- ..s °.r,. :1'1??r ,f Y -ey ,r:'.l. ''.!•'' ,A. r• :i. ','; 2tL_, r, frs.?„ '1 , 1 ~i•,I '.}.' :i I-. ) 6 Yyl'. ' F. ,'! .1. ''t,. ,Ci --') •L ,•., '+fl yi ? 1. ,!. .•7° .l '`{'%/F .,k ,w, F _ \' F 'PF ,y i 'S7,' L ?si // 1. ~/~? R`l, ?'l? p !+ {? lx 7•tI e:,' tv t.; tS,-.r 'w' :>F. irr ?',, ;! `il: .,. rJ.,. 'j,I:,,," ?1J ?r`?`? x Y?1all ''?, i r,tr •V a ,`9? 'r?? ft 37E*+`aJ.ko.?.'.,,f• ??i,...icl..k+r',r.. .;` .; F.3. if,;t •i +.:>l rl,:w1;1",ftY. .'+r7 ..•'',P:: •+';e .. :v' SDK.. I s,. ' 3, +: f: •`%'.`.a;.'?d s+r.'1.`:.::.:I.. lt%ti ..l.:1----'4r' :..J,'•%.uiv.-;";j iJ+%'i.;. vS.'.:;:a.,+.,??„Iti+ ;e r. I i'i'. 'f 3. s _ - r l I 'I ! •"i `r-.>rr 719' ?--'I +;,' S ,'. ' ,f-, , ° S f ,' . - - kl, ?.1.1.1.', r A-' .i."' ri.?i?• rJ !y'I, f. , . . . ! r ..3<n;. ,I •..-f,.J .. ...t. .. 1 .. - . f. - . , r,.. .,,.,>,_.. . 6. -1,. - .,_ „ {,I •'. rti•a ?,,.. s ,t- _, ''p'•f 11 a ., , . I .. .,, ,a. ':-. r-.n :'•,= ?• .4f:=,,^ EXHIBIT A ., . . f !``,;, ?- , .t . I$s s; °s 'STATEMENTz' OF BE EFITC ;1 ;:t: :;^::. Nf^ ...hi,: •? I N ?/ ' .. ' 4J • ' ;' ..Y ' fr. r."' ) ',"-' a'. 'y. r .j ': .tr.' . r s: ', t _ :. : : J;l' . !V? i:F,• •r.l t. .. r <n- - .('`r, ?,] .td' + •y?p i f,?Y:E?, .-erg ?.:i• i'':et t, -,,. E' - .r ?c !ry -" :??• , #?1;. .' , -: t?l :fit,` , ` ., ,?r• .y: ,' t ' .`t. :.C <1 1. J i . J - t s _ zl'' •:S KPi '?,M ?'.IF+ .F. .. ., a!' .tlr ' ° f., ;,]..' 'f .' 1•'t ts, ¢ l ° m- .•a. _r• r1j ?. Z lei Vtj Jr '€ ,t' :?'.. is Via' }-la r .,1 f'? 4 !. `€., 'I t~' 'C` 1.7?',.!`x 'Ff ',y` =r?'f fi't' j.l; 'F,` t 9 !1,. ?.I -t• ?, 1,,,. :E. J + yt}'Rf;4 q?, A?'1:- .r {`, }° ,l -a;,'• I . . raf, i,` °! a . }.r[' 'r a X i - I;, d,r . k ' ,i' , 1' <' ?'. i5? % ? , .. - -, : i; , r < l?.. ., ?.! _ , c y .. _` s ' to 'si ' I ?j , . ' ' , f': R ,. '?ij - ,f' S M1 ..f ?r f a,1 'k %,r, kI 7, j, S'fr-1 ' f ..11. - ... l . I I .. '4 i .1. „ }; .Its .gip . J # . , '3 .',fi ` ',, '. J • '•, y,. 4 ' .!, - ? A - . , ° I 1 it ' ;,,, 1 .lt. L'?'' •1 { .i ?i _„ ;1. Y. ' ? :kf 'l. o YS ? - ''f ,,1 .yi-. 4 I'=rf,,y' 'R:A„ kt., _ i' I ' . ,'• + I ... .. , ,, !', i •!'?,. •i Lr: .. fit, "r: - • -Y r r , " ar. ; ,I r y5 F j` 5 :I, ,', ?, '.' r ` 'r Yvy. at,e . , °,. :I! ,' . Ifi ;,i ?kr ; ' ?/e :?'?! S?ri[: f'?t J:' a. ., :,I r ,J ,. . ,J, .. , ' i1 ,'{. r . ' -:J,_ ;J,y. ,'1'' ' Y'- .I ` S ' - .. ,J ! '.i =.. aft Fv'ti si' ?; i' i.' 'i. .. ] . ,ia , . , ' csl 4 }+:'•!% C i,- ...f, .. I,. , ,.( ,7, .. . - . J' , , tl. ?' .? -5 .^'' ' ?'F "f, i-t' i:./??1C1116,dI ., 't t.. . ''f ?s' k' ' ??M,? ?y N},?F•''? : Py, t',r, ! 'I; , cF '7 +rt( it ,I ?'i i, .r y '? , arT,?,/ 3 '. .F J sfr t, i J f Ip/J1?i. f r1 ) r. < ,. 1, r i I .' ?1 .J+f l.,.r ..i.!'!. ''i-.\e rJ I J.k ,1' „ .. ... iF' ..1 ks- +•t°?,_. -Y?, '>Ft. ?•?• e F ',Y 'er .1 "' !a q J, :'f: s iti: „' ,.< ?'.r , 5 ' J Jb3r5,f'fl t ..I. r??a,.'. ,';, il'. S 4'? l` '}: f. Tr R:. j. 'S. .t ? 5 ? .. e. .°?I'.-. "i? ? .}'tl°;: S`;?n?.5 rF ? y ?iti ,1 ` ' Y r. y ' eF r , , , r f Y '' ` N ' F r ' a 1 ?? EXHIBIT A i . V. ' STATEMENT OF BENEFITS The existing structure was constructed in 1963 and is considered by the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) to be functionally obsolete. The bridge carries 4 lanes''of traffic, 2 eastbound and 2 westbound. In 1992 the average daily traffic (ADT) was 37,094 vehicles. The Pinellas County MPOs adopted projected ` ADT for this facility in the year 2010 is 52,900 vehicles. The bridge is continually manned by bridge tenders. In. 1991 the tenders performed an average of 502 openings/closing operations per month. The 'average time .to I` complete a full operation is approximately S minutes. Twenty-six (26) accidents were recorded on the bridge by the FDOT in 1991, twenty- '- one (21) were rear-end collisions. -The benefits to be derived by'replacing the functionally obsolete draw bridge with a modern free flowing highrise structure are as follows, '. ! 1. Improve emergency evacuation time for coastal residents. 2. Eliminate the potential for mechanical: breakdown, during emergency operations. Thus allowing for the free flow of both vehicles and maritime traffic. 3. Improve traffic flow, level of service and reduce congestion, 4. Improve air quality. 5., Improve energy efficiency. ' 6. Improve'safety by reducing the potential for rear-ended collisions.' 7. Increase savings by reducing maintenance costs and eliminating operating costs associated with a functionally obsolete draw bridge. RP/rorn,s.dl ' . 8 :. IL t, r 'T_. if i ?, ;r;4,;a {,r is .k' " „F.,I t' --,.1- ., -i''J. •. .E. .. • 1. .,c_, r. s.a. ,r p r= .'I;f h-y 1 ??Y: „t•t i t+.,y. % 'aF .i i.:rdI:f?t,Ir `; :" ,i. ` ;1;:..; !",, . i P ,;ti,a. f.-41-,^„J ..1 ?-,,. .2'',a ! 7499 ??lml,:"•'i7q" ,j.^?"': (>' .a"fi -'ti?}- -ti ,n, .e?'':; r7ir ur• = '?! .1:_'E ' : i, r ? ?: •,-:{: ro •y; '?r :f .(!,??.. yrf..i>?'vn.._., •$rt.w y: J IL'.-.Jr3r '"i,, re: `i'r?:;r. fi Y1;7: t ;p:. 1. t.? ., i' ^'r': ,.?+'h' • . "...+,. _ r.' ..1:?C?e{SFr, .,, .?.,?', ,'a,,a. :as ,.t?:'-, 'r,' ?.?, ? , Y . L .r' ii'li, -i °7. ._f1, i.,1-.('. ' k" X- .L`:f j . f, q ?+[i'y' ,s., i•l . ;, t g?` ?YI(?; . .. .- , t 11 16, `r 'n . f' i . . r . , r, .I ' . i r,.. r.' c r , ,i`, I; '1'r° , ?" `3I. -'4' •i '') L' i r. is. , +iI "i; t :I' ' t:.:a?.{AI t '!? 'J-r ..1` ° rF i`,J° :l ' t. 11 . i. ,' F .. • . 15:`9" °'(?... .. ? , S" ,t. -:Tf I" , f.t, I t ,t. I . ,'F . . . , t - , ` 1', ' ,i t ', ., ' ';-,,, r•; (;, t', ?T t(, F4 "Y. ,,A,' i I}':• -3r.( ?FI I1' ',t . •)' , 3 •'?i :?:k t;. ` i C <.j-, ,ts ?i P+fS'I?." :i'Vie:: Y'+ •• 'c:, :i, .i ;r ,, ' ?' ';= 1; , `,I 'r j; `i; i.}:•a .,':b:tI L • " }, r ,' ^?f: '.r i5,'.,1',': ,L"' k4 i' 'i ? r . r .. r > ,: v a E`,.:: ,k f?,,. Y,?. . ?:i 'b. ,L.-ti',_?r; y I ?, f.-?i";S , . ., 1 ri ,el,`:-R ; ::r. !." ,,v,r ",. r#' `,I.Y` „ .. f 3iw. 3+ ?.;' I Y .', 'J ' - r . r r.. •? , `t •}'!? t•.'f' 'I F-4.. I .' 7.ti'i'- I ffr'E `?" ?t ?J f•L. .` .,b 1i,,':s%. -.,I, ;i,, I .. . , ,•'1' 11 t' iA, j.'",,r,a "' s' ., 1 , `t? _ :'yi ^,q- 1: f ",I '•.'ry'e' .?cC•4 r?`' P6,+' f' fir} .`J. , •;f. .`. 1. •i "?' tr. '?s .•;,.{':` f., J. '•Er:S t:,. t, -!!,,#! ,:,?,'- '-:r. ?. 1 1' 'r ''' ".!:"'•`• t; ,:, .A:I . .:.7 ."''°, `r'•.1, r1•k}t 1. ."4.' `,i , o- i T .1 I `,,, I-+sf•°bJl, .a:. i, 1,,,(i; tia.' I ? •2' .P•, ? 'F? , , , e ) ?- .I. ? , 1? ,S} .1; ' i - ..??' .F °,?r •'r '.`.'?; ,.4: {{ { •,e rp.; L?'$ "7? '15 ,,-F. y?•[• 'irYt i\', 'fF'i'{ i.- '.'•ry' •.? a E' .l'i.' _ •f a - "'? I`t's ,i'r tl 'F` ,!t ' L„Jl,'IJ' Y t : , 4 ' 1 a .I T j 5 r 1a '1 s. .e f ',}'' s `" , ,I L ' {.,. " L }, • yy( >'7: •s. a r^ ,r, r PZF^qE .,,i.° f'; :?' ?s . .. I .,i • 3 r,'E '? / : ^ I , '' ,> 'il ti " K. ?. 1 .,} i 4s , ?S S . }, t ra F y c A C. I Y ::E:,Fl , `'e`.'Ef'-t ,tlJ ;.r ` .i 'i 11 `.? t . •?: ? f- r`f ?: „4?. S', .:1 'e' ". r ??' ;'r.i:l? :;b.f• r>'' . - ,..s.., ii r•9t .c, n, a ",'%. .-i: I. i •Sr? .r. 9 f' t : F?. • -'le.: - t,,; r -r }. .r.i' aa: 1t . ,J •'t.: }< ` iN 'r. ', 'r,'r i ,).- . Y:.• , ' r.i ,?'?> ,,." 'fl"I . fi:4 r? .';ri- " a;! 'E, .E'. t#,c = " t, !;- s, r Kt 1.; _ `'a.' `' "? '? s a-,'S:, ,." ,4'` ?E t, •?t ..l:4, 7f, 1. .Y _ '`Y -'i 1, r., - t .64 ..t .bid"'' _i .r' I. :f-;., .tk y r, ,y `;, '6 ;{;' { i. 'FY itr, 3 '}. .A. ,e t'Y, ,? ,,,,,. Vii,! ,;?: `: I` , , i.'{`;, :It ii.,-4 - r€?, I" vf• s"rr ., t':k '`9- ¢ •a'P .r. i. i, f. .rr4'i t•ir ' ',f; w '..h ft i% •',,1,?h 41, °,ix. .'1.. sr?•/ f as P' .IF^' 1'i I• i- •o' .I' "r' I 'i F -a r'iG; ' . •'.'r .a"'.' ^q•f,' ie ..!'y{{,rs •xia 'r-,"R '', ;? '.1 i r' "'.s ,t.. ":..r(.. y. 'A' 1f-`I$,,- "l.(. '? ,?,`'.'.)" t? ,.i i' ,- E ,r,Fd ?''1'' } 1 ,F, F •f'?, ,t, ;??,11 ',`f' e3-' e.. i /-:, .,'. '.1'^:.t?l.. i t. 'Lr y ..i 1 r • f.. ' r '??'• +7i',--' $?`5, r( :r, ? .11, :I f'f. ,F'r•, • nI-l-i:l:?, D 'c.'c 3r.• ` rt;?. ? q rsa'• :e1:: ss y [[ ,€ t. ...{.' ° .fit '.I r..f,S .,(f5tr { -!:.°lt,1,' .'1i' '.'i` J•r,l _) _ 'v 7 " T R ? .,r r,'Ei '; t• N p'°:1'.` ,ic. : 'S, ?l. )• ';`L ,C d tp.f ,•j r` l : - 'J -: F ^ " 7 t ,I iY ,tl. 'tti tu I '.S fRe, '.i ,`j:'a,,'}?` x'j3,t '4. '} + ,'!r. 1. ' ! .rtr ?r ` -t` ;, °•' ..ti' j W :. ' .;, ..f ,,•? t r- N' Y,! i .1,'? k<?:"r °$ i. •4 •'1.`.° ei _ .t '`t.h .dt w°?i" ,)' .) # 1 1. y 1., r F c» rt` `?'-"i' : 'i• L : :l¢ '}?' {`' • P' r 1 : ?'..i• s .-! E.'?.'..:.i: A i''Y;'.'; ?t .S7t '!,{. !: i TY .',? ?1s i..rl, k y.; X'`' .` { y- ;i. .ti.i f.: `;J-• 'a' :s.`-? s<: „3, 3' y !# si ::j'' ?fr°•.r' I. `J .1.R ,4'.?..r#'.+'- {{ s i' "r-' r: Mo, .?,'r° 3r I.h It ',1, t•: `til f'yF.. Ij'.:j• kn 3' y?")r. `1' i,'r a !' v',, ,? 'a ? nl'. rr. .f`... '?.?? ••L;i,. :t 's• -i•?f, rS'• 'i.. ."{,•,•3A J'` `71 :air, .r.. '!t.':?:r pr f,i :•,, Y'?q ?;p. rTl;. ` :.11 yi _ .r:. ':i.: r ., p -J r>, ' 'S' i, ; . i S 1.1 - J' e I ,:p ,'y'? l S ;I 11 yr r,. '". ,,.,r?' .ft tai .t., !5). .!'. .Ir -,. '3t r•- I,t ,5 ,y t:r,,,I` tft+`,'y ,: I ,i T. 'i? ?G=:?',r'tf*r, au :. : r • `)•' !-?' i - '?; .t>fi e?fL..Aiy?'ar r',raf,+w ,..L.,fti.-.a d+,V... vf_.7r?. .11'' i";c.-,-,..t.. %:4 t.,..'>,ai,.:'.^• ,,! .Y.. .. ,F I:.. ?.. ,.4e.,-e"I' ,;.i,,, ..;[a **f :,..i=''., >,,.,.>.s'? ".. i , . . i : a?:1,4; rl.+.i:.j£ .,'t % .'..?, ? , 1, J: i",Y', • ' It .. .. „ 1 I ,ll. ' !' a,, , .F :t ` T,' r ., • S'. 'i + S : -` ? 11 .:"?. Ov a r, f : is r f }!,° , ( , , T .. l?C. ), 4 , r , J r, J tI . ry'E'. .4.1 ',n t,,a f.: EXHIBIT! C . . ' . ;f tV ,T.fik F?I. '.4- . .'a'r :.. -L:, rl t - .a. JAi•,'li' ,' t.,; - ;r, t:` r ,;, s}; . °;$. ;; - ' °P • STUDY AREA. : ; _dd ?• } '. h r y '?t.i.. •I •'r.• -k, , .. . IL .f r ',!°i {f •F iiatiS..'-1. - .»? - .,'s,. ia' • 4A:,.-. '-%%, .°., - -. .. ., .. .- r ,. ... ... ! '.. .'! v.t ..: 17. , _. ?., ai7? - il>!, f'. t ' ! 1, .,I r ,? f-.l»7'` t:;.7!` ),, ,r ''. .t F`r' , - , r _ - - L'' ' 1- '' tjig! "Z; rl I '? s 1.+ " 1xi:'J'L .f .•i.:;... {i L '?. ', ?" i' rP • r, s: ,>'?' :rf tl" .;n. '.Y. :i3 +)?-,,'. ,,? -L'. :I? .. r , , .,r :!-. `rJ;}• ' 1., a iEr,. f' r; . fl •'.•,', I'- 'r: ' , 'l -T' .. , .t 151.!! .fx, r' •S:? ( , - )' t'' . .r f'„ IF.• 'i r.1' J.. s°Y, is ?>•. + ' • .t L•' k f. :t ,f. .+•.. it qt'y'. i.?:, F;: •r :err § :(, .,, e r 1.. C F ; f° 'i ',:,'. `?i',' )t .,.,I3?'?t ^{ r.' .?, ,re .1 /: i i ),.r,V i I)_^,?i:} ';1:'1)l ri. '.,' - "I t?:' p'.•r. .?: l; `x. ?t,r.•' 1 >'i L, 1 n•f': '.t` F ',fir i R yyv yil' f- I' :.1• r .f. •4.-r. qG -ry +1',1' .f .P S.' I• , ?F ,.`rte,. y(. 'i - 'f ' .. "J I L'I j 1. " r t .;. .,I i ` , '3 ' 'i: r! if ;.e a `? ,.3 I f :3t,„t .L 1, ri - !, a .', i , ,. "e y °e '`41? .f . , I, j. y+a 4 I. F ,? , 1.;, I . y :,f: ('. 4, L''i - ? e ., .J , c .. Ii " ., e't ' .•., ,1', ;,•.1,. 11•` 'Ir .rr' • t+ - - 1'.i • , 1 .. ,i1+( ' .. 1. . . - Q.JI' f( e ,::r;,Yr,i.1t',r'' .. ,l• , '1 t Ir, ,.'., ifl,: 'aI " -i. it is :r. -., ... .:" , !i :fj 't. ,5 1. ;'t', .b t; ,f I,i."t: 1 'i.'. Il . T,' to ,t1, 'L#' "', •I r'Sr- 1 ! > .. ii 999 «f,. .; Y:i,' .tr. -I-}' .. 4 il, 1 '` -):it" .. e . k ''f - , - ' i .. - - ,','."-t C, -, s " s /' j, '.g ,'S '? F 'i ",i:^! ' ', ?:5:. - i- .'s..'-;: l ' I i. i, :k 1. )' t' , ,. .. - it • .,i 1, 4. .t'. bf, 3, ?'j, ,-i Ji'' .IQ ?,,,I k ;, f. ' t .'.i ' ', ( :N `fir` ';.. e. ,- 'i.' .""" .e: p17 +° > S' k l y , S. i t: i,'1?j• . '!`s'fi: {, t-. ,),t 1. 1?tr :,a"r•, ''k'-':.! ,I. 'r?l ''t:; ` iA° - - c'" •` - -- - ??._.__... _ ? .rJr• r .. ,"i'..r:... ... e"FCi': .l1..' i4?,Yr3? $t.f 1 / f ? ,,, f i t Clearwater. City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum • `s ' i t Me 03/18/93 Resolutions Transmitting the Land Use Plan Amendments Associated with the Downtown Development Plan and the North Ft. Harrison/North Myrtle Avenue Zoning Study to the Pinellas Planning,Council for Review. RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Adopt Resolutions 93-15 and 93-16 transmitting Land Use Plan Amendments-to the Pinellas''Planning Council. ? and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: The Pinellas Planning Council (PPC)has recentl.y.'revised-its,transmittal procedures for Land Use Plan amendments. The PPC now'requires the adoption of a resolution by the governing body of the-local government requesting PPC review before it will process Land Use Plan amendments. The attached resolutions transmit the Land Use Plan amendments associated with the Downtown Development Plan and the North Ft. Harrison/North Myrtle Avenue-— '.Zoning Study to the,Pinellas Planning Council for review. Risk N/A C3 d , Approved w/conditions cis RevIewad bq: Odginating Dept: Casts: 1 NIA Commission Action-. Legal Planning 8 Dev lopment Total Approved Budget Purchasi ng sk Mgmt . N/A User Dept: Current Fiscal Yr. El Denied H!A 0 .Continued to: ACM Funding Source: other 0 Capital imp. Advertised: © Operating Attachments: Date: © Other Resolutions No. 93-15, 93-16 Paper: 1@13, ' ' Not Required Submitted by, Affected Parties Appropriation Code; © None ? Notified ' NO Not Required Cit a ger Printed on recycled paper Y, .S , ; ,. r r r • 1 Vi .. r , z ; } r i 71 ! Fez. " r • v ti ' ' •°r , zk• r ! xV' L t r J ! r 1, j'•Lj 1Y?. (?lr . irk ( Y 1'.. .S {. a -?,.«(t' .•1?a• .. r • .. t -'d.? RESOLUTION NO. 93-15 A RESOLUTION APPROVING TRANSMISSION TO 'THE PINELLAS COUNTY PLANNING COUNCIL OF.AN APPLICATION TO AMEND THE COUNTYWIDE FUTURE'LAND USE,PLAN TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY'S FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT AMENDMENTS AS PROPOSED'BY ORDINANCE NUMBERS 5297-92,-5298-92, 5299-92, 5300-92,•AND 5302-92'OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. % WHEREAS, on February 4, 1993, the City of Clearwater has held 1 the requisite public hearing in consideration of a request to amend. the Countywide Future Land Use Plan; and WHEREAS, t'ne City of Clearwater has determined to request the amendments of the Countywide Future Land Use Plan as identified in' Ordinance.Numbers 5297-92, 5298-92, 5299-92, 5300-92, and 5302-92; and ' WHEREAS, on February 4;'1993, the City Commission of the City of Clearwater has considered at public hearing and passed Ordinance , , Numbers 5297-92, 5298792, 5299-92, 5300-92, and 5302-92 on first reading, tentatively approving the corresponding City of Clearwater Future Land Use Element amendments for those parcels'described'in-.' the ordinances; now therefore BE. ITRESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section 1. The Director of Planning and Development is hereby a authorized to transmit to the Pinellas Planning Council an application to amend the Countywide Future Land Use Plan ',as required to maintain consistency between the City and Countywide Plans 'for those proposed changes to the City's Future Land Use .,Element contained in Ordinance Numbers 5297-92,• 5298-92, 5299-92, 5300-92, and 5302-92. Section 2. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of 1992. Rita Garvey Mayor-Commissioner' Attest: Cynthia E. Goudeau City Clerk ; ?r4?• ;rE ir,r f -fir ;="3," '`.ail: .'. •?:. l 1? .j• , i J•?f ,. - . 1. ' -.a'. RESOLUTION NO. 93-16 A RESOLUTION APPROVING TRANSMISSION TO THE PINELLAS. COUNTY PLANNING COUNCIL OF AN.APPLICATION TO AMEND THE COUNTYWIDE FU'T'URE LAND USE PLAN TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY'S FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT-AMENDMENTS AS PROPOSED BY' ORDINANCE NUMBERS 5308-92 AND 5310-92 OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. WHEREAS, on IDecember 17, 1992, the City of Clearwater has held the 'requisite public hearing in consideration of a request to amend i the Countywide Future Land Use Plan; and WHEREAS, the City of•Clearwater has determined to request the amendments of.the Countywide Future Land Use Plan as identified in Ordinance Numbers 5300-92 and 5310-92; and,. WHEREAS,. on December 17, 1992, the City Commission of the City; of Clearwater has considered at public hearing and passed Ordinance Numbers 5308-92 and 5310-92 on first reading, 'tentatively approving. the'' corresponding City of Clearwater' Future Land Use Element amendments for those parcels described in the ordinances; now ` therefore > r r. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF 'THE CITY OF', CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section 1 The Director of Planning and Development is hereby authorized to• transmit to the Pinellas "Planning Council 'an application to amend the Countywide Future Land, Use Plan as required to maintain consistency between the City and Countywide Plans for. those proposed changes to the City's Future Land Use Element contained in Ordinance Numbers 5308-92 and 5310-92. $ection 2 This resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED this day of .1992'. Rita Garvey, Mayor-Commissioner Attest: Cynthia E. Goudeau City Clerk =?a^ , .;? :i• `1: `,rye:. f r i ORDINANCE N0: 5354'-93 r AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, RELATING TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; AMENDING SECTIONS 36.114, 36.118, 36.121, AND 36.125, CODE OF ORDINANCES, RELATING TO DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS; EXTENDING THE MAXIMUM DURATION OF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS FROM FIVE YEARS TO TEN YEARS; REQUIRING THAT COPIES OF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS BE FILED WITH THE STATE LAND PLANNING AGENCY; PROVIDING FOR WRITTEN REPORTS FOLLOWING PERIODIC REVIEW OF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, it is the desire of the City Commission to amend Article V of Chapter 36, Code of Ordinance,•to reflect certain amendments to Florida law as sear forth herein; now,.therefore, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:. Section 1. Sections 36.11.4, 36.118, 36.121, and 36.125, Code of Ordinances,'are amended to read: Sec. 36.114. Development Proposal. Upon a determination by the city commission that it desires to proceed with further negotiations relative to a development agreement, the property owner shall promptly submit a development proposal for the subject property to include the following information: ' ?r 9e k •k ? ! (3) The desired duration of the development agreement-, not to exeee d -4 ye years;, Sec. 36.118.. Minimum terms and conditions. Any development agreement approved under the provisions of 'this article shall contain not less than the following: (2) The duration of the development agreement. The duration shall initially not exceed 10 •f4*e-years and may be extended for- one addi t4enal of -t emee dthree-yew by mutual consent of the city commission and the developer,, subject to the same public hearing-process necessary for the initial approval of the development agreement. Sec. 36.121, Recording. Not later than 14 days after the execution of a' development agreement, the city shall record the agreement in the public records of the county, and a copy of the recorded development agreement shall be ` aSSe psi- ,rv`r f . kA .... .'. F . = i a `,ar.. r r i' (` ,'Y, .l: , .>,I? nYN.. 7. •.? rF ??.•?3. . r ,i .. .,??.? 36 submitted to the state land p 1 ann i ng agency ' within 14 days after the agreement is recorded. A development agreement'shall not be effective until it-is properly :recorded. and until 30 days after having been received by the state land planning agency. Sec. 36,125. Periodic review of property. (1). 'The city manager shall review all properties within the city subject to development agreements at least once every 12 months to determine ifAhere has been demonstrated good faith compliance with the terms of the development agreement. The city manager shall-report his findings to the city commission. For ears 6 through 10 of a development agreement, the review"shall be incorporated into a written report which shall be submitted•to the arties to the agreement and the state land planning agency. (2) A development agreement may be revoked or modified by the city commission upon 30 days' notice to the property owner, as shown on-the-records of the property appraiser for the county, if. the city commission finds, on th'e, basis of substantial competent evidence, that there has. been a failure to comply with the terms of the development agreement. Such termination or amendment shall -be accomplished. only after a public hearing and notice for the adoption of a development agreement. , Section 2, This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption. PASSED ON FIRST READING -,. PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL ' READING.AND ADOPTED r: Rita Garvey' Mayor-Commissioner Attest:, Approved as to form and,correctness:• r Cynthia E. Gou eau M. A. Ga rait , Jr. City Clerk, City Attorney, . '?KfJ ?y j• '?? e lr ? T.f '.,'' d Si f f • s•1 ? a f ? r a t. . 37 Rita Garvey Mayor-Commissioner RESOLUTION NO. 93-11 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY, OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, ASSESSING THE OWNERS OF PROPERTY THE COSTS OF HAVING MOWED OR CLEARED THE OWNERS' LOTS. WHEREAS,- it has been determined by the City Commission of the City of Clearwater that, for the purpose of promoting the health, safety and general welfare of the citizens and residents of the City, real property within the City should be cleared of'weeds, rubbish, debris and other noxious'material; and WIIEREAS,. notice pursuant to former Section 95.07, Code of Ordinances, now Section 20.38, Code of Ordinances, was provided to the owner of each of the lots listed in Exhibit A, and the notice required each property owner to cause.the violation to be remedied or to file a notice of appeal within 10 days after the. date the property was posted; and WHEREAS, the property owners have failed to take remedial action within the time provided and have failedrto file a notice of appeal within the time allowed, or appealed the notice of violation but failed to take remedial action within the time provided by the Code Enforcement Board, and it berame'necessary'for the City to take remedial action; and WHEREAS, the owner of each lot listed-on Exhibit A has been provided with a notice. and opportunity within which to pay the costs and administrative charges set forth on Exhibit A, but no payments have been received; NOW, THEREFORE., BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section 1. The City Commission finds the preamble hereof to be true and correct.' Section 2. The City Commission hereby assesses a lien upon each parcel of real property listed on Exhibit A for the actual costs of mowing or clearing, plus administrative costs, as shown on Exhibit A. Section 3. The City Clerk is hereby directed to.prepare a notice of lien against'each'proper-ty listed on Exhibit A and to record the same in the public records of Pinellas County, Florida. PASSED'AND ADOPTED this day of , 1993. Attest: Cynthia E. Gou eau City Clerk k q - i ' • i .;?` ? • s? ? .?. ta t' ? . . r r :t ' '..f i 1;a 1 >t r ' i f ' r r ' f r f r F::. e . - st r r EXHIBIT A (MARCH) ADMIN. PROPERTY OWNER LEGAL DESCRIPTION COST CHARGE TOTAL , Mamie L Higgins. Avondale Blk D Lt 15 & 16 $ 97.07 $200.00 $297.07',`- Charlie Harris Bidwell's Oak Wood Lot-27 50.00 '200.00 . 250...00 Karen Rohret & Bidwell's Oak Wood Addn 85.15 200.00 2851.15 Thomas Dempsey E 1/2 of Lot,36 Jaime Viera Jurgens Addn Blk D, W 50' 199.98(LC) 200.00 464.98 of Lt 1 & Us 2,314, & 5 65.00(Tow) Ernest W.Bailey Est, Lincoln Place Blk 31 Lt 5 52.12 200.00 252.12 ?,F;: Joseph Johnson & Pennsylvania Sub Lot 12 81.81 200.00 281.81: T. Mason ,James Liddell Pennsylvania Sub-Lot 13 77.94 200,00 277.94 Willie/Wm Turner Pine Crest Blk .2, Lot7 73:53 200'.00 882.53•:: (Waste Removal) 609.00 James/Nancy Erskine Plaza Park B1k'D, Lot 6 148.44 200.00 348.44';! Steven/El'izabeth Plaza Park Blk E, N 50' 93.65, 200.00 293.65 Holland of S 100' of Lots 11 &• 12 Hoke S. Russell Plaza Park Blk G, Lot 9 127.83 200.00 327.83 ,Sun Watch rnc. M & B 31-011 Sec 5/29/15 „ 159.95 200.00 359.95 ` Daoul E.'Debs M & B 32-15 Sec 22/29/15 50.00 200.00 250.00 Mikki Wildstarr Kas Villas of Sunset Grove 50.Oa 200.00 250.00 Lot 13 Ruby L. Clayton Sec 22--29-15, M&B 32/13 865.75 200.00 1065,75 .H & L Clearwater Sec.. 17-29-1.6, M&B 23/08 884.50 200.00. 1084.50 -., Partners Ltd. s •r ? diy=r `.f? I ar ? < I..i .`1' r t ? .. .J 1 , r , ref. Y, ? .•''. ? I ' , I . f TO:, FROM: RE: DATE: MAG a Copies: ,/Cynthia Goudeau City Clerk Michael Wright, City Manager M E M O R A N D U M The Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission M. A..Galbraith, .lr., City Attorney ' tt ?t RECEIVED MAR 11 1993 CITY CLERK DEPY. Commission Rules of Procedure R3 r March 11, 1993 ` In reviewing the proposed revisions to your rules of procedure, which will be on your agenda next week,, you may want to give further thought to the proper disposition of the motion for the previous question. During your last meeting., a motion for the previous question was made. A point was made' that the, motion is not' proper as long as any other member wishes to speak. Rule 14 (to be renumbered as Rule 12) states that,.". ..The Chair cannot close debate as long as any member who has not exhausted his right to debate desires the floor except by an affirmative vote of four (4) members. . Rule 15 (to be renumbered as Rule 13) lists four motions which are not debatable. . One of them is the motion for the previous question. Reading these rules together, and trying to give effect to each, it would appear that the motion is in order even if one other member wishes to speak. Rule 14 limits the power of the Chair to close debate. The rule is consistent with Robert's Rules, which says that the chair can ask, "Are you ready for the question?" but cannot "gavel through" a'measure. Using the terminology of Robert's Rules, the "assembly" '(City Commission) can "order" the closing, of debate by using either of two motions-'-the motion to limit 'debate, or the motion for the. previous question. Neither motion is in'order when another member has the floor, neither is debatable, both require a second, and both require a two- thirds vote for adoption. If you wish to establish a rule that the motion for the previous question is not proper as long as any other member wishes to speak, then you should amend Rule 14 (the new Rule 12) as follows:. The Chair cannot close 'debate and the motion for the previous . Question-shall not be in-order, as long as any member who has not .exhausted his right to debate desires the Floor e*eeptt --by an -a4LW-Etta-t4e-ve , k Y {{ l r t ; k i. C a Y&. - . , n,/1-... jII !" .t' , va?.F, .I?": •'S '1 I.. .. ...1 <, , , ' • '. , •• ,. ` I. .+i`vh RESOLUTION NO. 93-'14 f ' j A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF-'THE CITY-OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE•CITY COMMISSION.RELATING TO THE CONDUCT OF ITS BUSINESS; REORGANIZING THE ORDER. OF 'BUSINESS AT A REGULAR MEETING, AND REVISING THE RULES RELATING TO THE PRESIDING OFFICER, THE READING OF ORDINANCES, THE DISTRIBUTION OF MINUTES OF WORK SESSIONS; TIMES LIMITS UPON PERSONS ADDRESSING THE CITY COMMISSION, MOTIONS TO RECONSIDER AND TO RESCIND, DEPARTURES FROM THE PRESCRIBED AGENDA, THE DISTRIBUTION OF MAIL TO THE CITY 1 COMMISSION,- THE USE OF ROBERT'S RULES OF ORDER, 'AND RELATED MATTERS; PROVIDING'AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the- City 'Commission finds that the rules of procedure for the conduct of its=meetings should be-amended as provided herein in order to promote the. orderly and efficient conduct of business, and to promote the' better , 'understanding of .the rules; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF "- CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: Section 1. The Rules of Procedure of the Clearwater.City Commission are amended to read: `?. SEE'EXHIBIT "A" TO THIS RESOLUTION " Section 2. Thi's resolution shall take effect,immediately upon adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED this day, of March, 1993., ' 'Attest: Cynthia E Gou eau. Rita Garvey City Clerk. Mayor-Commissioner k '! L t ' ? + ? i 1 , + RULES OF,PROCEDURE CITY COMMISSION CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA RULE 1 A quorum for the,transaction of business by the City Commission shall consist of 3 4h-pee (3) Commissioners. The presiding Pfn 4 officer of the City Commission shall be the Mayor-Commissioner. In the absence of the Mayor ease-ef h;.. . ' n,-a--a ee, the Vice Mayor shall assume those responsibilities, and if both are , absent, the senior Commissioner in years of service shall preside. The presiding officer maybe referred to as the "chair." The chair shall preserve order.,744,- may call to order any member of the Commission or other_person who shall violate' any of the rules and -;-,a ?'a; when 4n the--eha p, he shall decide all questions of, ; order, subject to a majority vote on a motion to .appeal., The chair shall recognize all Commissioners who seek. the floor under correct procedure. -m-11- members of the--publie shall be wed te speak, m4nutes ea?Fing--t-aam i-seer All questions shall be stated and put by the chair 44-m, and the chair he shall declare all votes. RULE'2 The City Clerk shall make correct minutes of.the proceedings of each Commission meeting, and shall furnish copies of the. minutes of each regularly scheduled meeting to the Mayor-Commissioner and to each Commissioner at least 24 ?en#-y -few hours, prior to, the next regular meeting. Such minutes shall stand confirmed at the regular meeting of the Commission without the reading"thereof in, open meeting unless some inaccuracy or error be pointed out by some member of ' the-Commission present, and in such event, an appropriate correction shall be made., Upon request,'the City Manager will cause the City Clerk to provide any Commissioner with transcribed excerpts of tapes of City Commission workshops or regular or special meetings. RULE 3 All motions shall be made and seconded before debate. Every ordinance shall be read on atleast 2 separate days -at „ either „a 'regu 1 ar or a. special meeting of 'the ; City Commission eetiAs -before it is passed, except when it Is designated an emergency and receives at least reeeiying a 2/3 vote of the Commission. Such emergency. ordinance shall remain effective for 90 ninety days after the effective date. All resolutions, ordinances and contracts. require 3 -three --(3Taffirmative votes for passage.. RULE 4 A copy of each ordinance when passed shall be furnished by the City,Clerk to the heads of all City departments concerned, EXHIBIT "A" 1 ° rl . i , 5 RULE 5 (rev.-2-20-86; 5-1-86; 1-1-93) (1) The-City-Commission shall meet on'the first and third Thursdays of each month at 6:00 p.m. in its chamber. Special meetings may be held on call of the Mayor-Commissioner, City Manager,or any two of the members and, whenever possible, upon no less than 24 twenty fG'•"' ,rM4 hours public notice. (2) ' Except as may be rescheduled from time to time. when necessary due to conflict, a work session shall be held at 9:00 a.m. on the first working day of the Commission meeting week. 'Minutes shall be taken by the City Clerk, but not distr,ibuted_unless _r_equuested_by the City Commission., Work sessions are primarily' designed for information gathering and guidance, and no formal' Commission decision approving or disapproving an agenda item or items scheduled for-public hearing may be made. Only staff members shall be included in the work session discussion unless prior arrangements are made through the City Manager, except with the approval of a- ma.ority of the members of the City Commission in attendance. (3) Except for items advertised for public hearing, items may be removed from the agenda and 'additional items may be added. The agenda may be reordered. ken a d- 4 st-r'i uted byte-Eity Glet&F,-Only staff m6mbers s,a-r --be --nellued 4n the work -s•es?s on-d i s e made through the er. (4) A regular meeting or special meeting shall conclude at'approximately midnight unless. the time of adjournment is extended by the unanimous consent of the members of the Commission in attendance. The Mayor shall adjourn the meeting upon. the conclusion of the item of business which is under discussion at midnight. With the unanimous consent of the members of the Commission in attendance, the meeting may be extended for such tiire as is necessary to discuss and act upon any of the remaining items of business on the agenda as the members may agree. Uncompleted agenda items shall be automatically postponed to the next regular meeting and included on the appropriate agenda unless such items are placed upon the agenda of• a later regular meeting or a special meeting, as a majority of the members in attendance may agree. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the setting of meeting dates, the scheduling of uncompleted agenda items for a regular or special meeting, and a motion to adjourn shall be in order regardless of the time of night. (5) Four (4) regiefi4-rr}eetings "town meetings" shall be scheduled during the year, excluding ,tune, July, August and December. They will be scheduled at City-owned facilities throughout the corporate limits when possible. RULE 6 The City Commission shall appoint all comfflittees and advisory boards asrovided' by ordinance -in aver-dance-rwi-th t# The. City Clerk shall furnish each committee or advisory board with copies of all resolutions or ordinances relating to the activities and duties e^?eerns of said committee or advisory board, which shall be delivered by the most economical, 2 3 1 r . ' . method to the chair c-W-raa* of such committee or advisory board within 4 f4w-1 444 days after the passage of'the same ,or as soon thereafter as possible. . AIIL? r - , -6 20 136) No e Go ' CIGiiTTTT"T1 sro?-rcr-rru^.ra dire v-4-ur=rndi?°£C-t--Pe-1-Sr9'" cial interest, or wh4eh whom he 49 emp4-Dye4--of othp" r reta4ned- He 4. -e of his interest _'.;U0Pn z natur his 4n.te'L's'C-TT7^the-ITT tteT --- T..- _-Form 4--shall be ree'e4yeo by the G4ty Pier! +nGer-Tested ;nt, -nutes of e'-IIiept4g'. , RULE 7 S' The City officials whose regular attendance shall be required during the s4tt4n& of the- Commission meetings_ and work sessions shall be the City Clerk, City Manager and City Attorney or their substitutes, unless excused by the City Commi1sion.-p4m. al I - any ether--off-ieers Other emoioyees of the City shall be beds attend xi" meetings and work sessions upon direction of the City Manager : ,or by special request of any Commissioner to the City Manager. a. RULE g in (rev. 2-20-86; 12-1-88; 12-17-921 The order of business of a regular or special meetina shall ordinarily be: I. Regular meetings Pf czedu-i=e. A. Special recognitions and awards. B. -Minutes of previous meetings. C. 0-x' Public hearings (riot before 6:00 p.") Legislative and administrative matters: ' vdncv-s---pub! -i'E--hearing' duly adyer-tised. 1 -9. Presentation of issues by City staff. . ' .• 2 -3. Statement of case by applicant or representative (5 minutes), 3 4. Statement of case by opposition (5 minutes). 4 §. Commission questions, .5 6. Comments in support and comments in opposition. a. Individual (3 minutes). 3 ' t'• 4 , b. Spokesperson for groups (10 minutes).' ' ?. Commission questions. 7 8. Rebuttal by opposition (5 minutes). 8 .'. Final rebuttal by applicant or representative'(5 minutes). 9 4-9. Commission motion to determine disposition. Variance applications: 1 .9. Staff states its recommendation and briefly summarizes its reasons for the recommendation (2 minutes)' 2 -3. Applicant presents case, including its testimony and exhibits., Witnesses may be cross-examined. (15'minutes). 3'4. Staff presents further evidence. May be cross-examined. (10 minutes). 4 .5. Public comment (3 minutes per speaker). ' 5 6.City Commission discussion,'and may'question any witness. 6 -7-. Applicant may call witnesses in rebuttal (5 minutes).: 7 8. Conclusion by applicant (3 minutes'). S .9. Decision. D. Citizens to be heard regarding items not on agenda-0 minutes er E. City Manager reports.. F. City-Attorney reports. 6. Other Commission action. .1 II. Special meetings. , If an agenda item reguiringa public hearing is -scheduled for a special meet inq,- . therules set forth above for-legislative and administrative matters or variance appjications, as appropriate to the agenda item, shall apply'.. III 4-1-. Speaking. Persons speaking before the City Commission at times ether than publie ' ` shall^be limited to three minutes per speaker except to the extent that a longer time may be •al lowed by this rule durina_public hearings.. No person shall speak more than once on the same subject at the same meeting unless granted permission by the City Commission. RULE 9 11 Any member of the Commission who voted with the prevailing side may move to reconsider not any action of the whale Commission provided that the motion'be made at the same meeting at which the action was taken. A motion to reconsider shall be in order at any time (during the meeting at which the action was taken) except when a motion on some other subject is pending. No motion to reconsider shall be made more than once on any subject or matter at the same meeting. X iz, ??;' 11 '•. ,fr. ?, r.a ? M J ¦ l-?z t ?1 f . [ [ 1 i I r I I I ? 1 1 1. 121 Commission action may be rescinded by a 4/5 vote. The motion to rescind may be made by any Commissioner. RULE 10 1 The City Manager, City Attorney, or any Commissioner may place ege6da an item of business on an agenda. Any citizen may request that an item -a be placed on an agenda enendae , even though staff has assured petitioner that adverse action may result. The Chair a tenet depart from the prescribed agenda with the approval of not less than two other Commissioners bt?t---eta do so by a 4j5 ete or by consensus in respen?e to ,. rlfnnne ?+nn ?r+nnt_?hn G-_-. RULE 12 44 (rev, .1-7-93) v .: These rules, or any of them, with the exception of £#ae? provisions required b the City Charter or Florida law, and the provisions, of Rule 5 relating to .adjournment, may be amended or temporarily suspended at any meeting 'of the 1 Commission by an affirmative vote of 4 44 (4) members thereGf. The provisions ' of Rule 5 relating to adjournment may be temporarily suspended with the unanimous consent of the members of the Commission in attendance, as provided in the,-rule', and may be amended by an affirmative vote of 4 members of the Commission voting upon-a motion to amend the rule which was made,'and seconded not less than 24 hours before the vote upon the motion. These rules are for the efficient and orderly conduct of the business of the Commission only, and no violation of a rule s*O woes shall invalidate any action of the Commission when.approved by the majority vo'tes required by the Charter. RULE 12 -14' Any member of the Commission making a motion ar--sees shall address the chair £hairma-n• and await recognition before speaking. The Chair must recognize any person who seeks the floor while entitled to it. The-person making the motion is entitled to the floor first for debate. No member ep,& is entitled to the floor a second time on the same motion as long as any other member who has not spoken on the issue desires the floor. When a motion has been 4-, made and seconded, the motion 4-t shall be restated mated by, the chair rh o before e" debate shall be in order. Upon-presentation of agenda items, members may ask questions and request additional information prior to making motions. For a member to discuss a matter while no motion is-pending requires permission from the Commission. Motions and any amendments can be withdrawn or modified by the maker at any time'prior to the Chair stating the question on the motion; after that time, the permission of the Commission majority must be obtained. The Chair cannot close debate as long as any member who has not exhausted his right to debate desires-the floor except by an affirmative vote of 4 f-ear---¢4 members. A tie vote shall constitute' a continuance to the next regularly scheduled. meeting. • r . Ir .>t ? i. . l . RULE 13'4& The following motions are not debatable: To adjourn; To lay on-the table; To take, from the table; For the previous question. RULE-" rrr efE cp$ nv^n agenda be 3r`"i r^^ ' . z ??#$?5- a'acrkrc-4n rrr4?ori? rrr-;-4 ems cE'IF15 - shall - v---nr-tee ? to - not 1.,.•? than ?•_I? but not more thaft--MZ'$'1-xwt•es, RULE 14 •7- r t- The Commission shall, at the. direction of the Chair, take a.ten minute break' approximately -every two hours,--and may recess -fer'tnner,--if the members of 4: Gnir Yet- , ' "'-TV'Gr+ RULE 15 •18' (rev. 6-20-85) k: All material prepared by the City Manager for the Commission shall be provided to the press and to the public via a special box in the City Clerk's Department effiGe. Reports shall be-made available. in the. _City Clerk's Department 'si*€ e? for the .public to review. RULE 16 •4 (rev. 6-20-85; 5-1-86; 4-20-89) ' All mail to the City Commission Mayer Gommi arriving at City Hall received pursuant to the law or in connection with the transaction ` of official•business by the City,of Clearwater shall be copied as follows: A. Each Commission member-will receive the original of items addressed to`them and copies of everything will continue to be made for the City Clerk's Department 9f -iee an die-£`}iry-?4ttorne ' 'e the citizens' file, the press file, and the read file. , B.' Anonymous letters will not be distributed: C. Publications and lengthy agenda-materials for other boards upon which'.the Commissioners serve will.not be copied. Only the.agendas will be'' circulated. Items of considerable length (such as- petitions) will not be copied, ,but instead a memo will 'be distributed announcing the availability of the item in•the office. D. Mail with the words similar to "Personal", "Confidential". or' "For the Addressee Only" will be delivered 'unopened to the addressee. J However such words or similar words shall not•cause a document to be deemed exem t from the public records law if.the'docume t would 6 •:j;p ?L, t ??" aJ •Y' l 'fie' `'ii. .ia 1 ,l?t5xt , 1 s s'i ?`Irt ` ' ?• ' .. . I 'r 1 , i f , .. I ' i r ? ' rv?, 3I r I fy??r,'?. _ °• ? ` r , r r rr ?• ' . al ? ? tl `? .; . t F r 3 I ' { : ,. p e . i• - ,r.?! ''l r' If f` I '. ,f f. '1, .. ' p I If p 1 a 1lc ?t?r FS: ;?,1. .. :; •i r r .1 ."?Il r,l t'. 1. 1 '. a .. ? F "? ' [ .,,Y?'•• 7 Y . p I fl ` ? r , . r ? f , rr,?1 < ' ` r ' r ' /r . _., t.,r Ai ' ' J - , , ,,` f s, y?, 1 f? s b . _ i 3. `.1. .• '• 2; 1: .i. ??.; y. i.l - 1 , ` rsf ?.•? •y`1°N 'a' ? 7'++. !S r i r ? 'rr . s ,. r `y.. .`j'?'??k - ? ? 2ib' b ' ' ? - < ` Iy',.: .r! s' .f .`?I: .r ? .' ? - r .. s • ? f ' y ,''1. ?,1? ' ,. , fir. ,i? ? ": ! 'f G1! 'Y!.'an.l•" , JIY' , r aI. j ;??yf p , . i7?''. r ;a. Sre'sf•#'.??,YK?, e. r 'a.`xn'.1:-..,, t, . $F ? ..e.Dnr,. r.i • dir . .`e a .,. . .. .. .. .. :.. , .p`', •r i ,'`ii i.? _ . . , r s..a,..rnv '` . otherwise be subject- to' the public records, law. :E. ` The ""1Aw-G^m«s4-eqie- and Commissioners receiving' individually addressed mail will be responsible for replying, asking the,.`City, Manager or City Attorney to reply, or placing the matter on the . agenda for formal Commission 'consideration.' Co ies of responses will be Placed 'in a 'read file in the office of the City Manager, and. in the citizens' file or press file in the City Clerk's De artment ° for review by Commissioners and the-public "r- F. The'City Manager will'be responsible for seeing that'mail addressed or .to'the Mayor and other City Commissioners is'properly answered t a , placed on the agenda. I v I, F ]} 1 j? ?•vkJ ` -The Gij? Manager- w4 11 an.,- ind iAdual ea pWflt letters-s-, fr l5<<' - W -_l he G7til- ?RY1 ?]/IhN ill disc_1[`s-l.l4th the Mayor m a 14 e TVus-ea*I-r• m RULE 17 ' Exce? t?6?', provided herein, or as maybe requ"ired by Florida lAw the,Cit? Chart er, the rules of the Cit? Commission for,the conduct Of its busihess,-shall: - be as -provided-in the-most recent edition of Robert's Rules of Order.— i l'e , f. x .' .. •r t ,?'X'r? ` f r a •6t ' .. ' 7 1j, j f+r if.?'`:, sit ??E;??t?:'i." f r? ? 2;Z" FI ?t psi :pit'I: :?~ ,+...!" •i'. 'F: :5•' ..? .._3 yf. ir,?J 4'-•';"''"? Ir i?.J .. .. or11 ? 1'. :irA - rat,' `','., • '!. , J, f r . ? f . 1•?t 1 ,_?Y` li" =t f. `? ?? .1. .. rtr?• .1 .+' ` ? ? I . 'ri .,r?^• ..-I. :r;'i'tj1' 7t`•'r '.L-'. ,.1-':'•: i? •7t• ,',: , I ,. , r e ? te. t ?7i „ •?rif Y`'?1 J?. ?%i.F, - ? .' •?'? ;?+rl. ?;:? 4 . 6`''?:.r ', ?t t.lY; ! ?r? I ` r ? ?.. ? t?` ' f ? { ? - .r'?'.IJ r?rlj ?.: fir` .. r?•? 1?ur Zf ?:.' ? :r - I .. , .,. .I/f.,_?3.' t. r jv SP 1.:? i , 4A ?. 3.. gl'i'1' :fI't,?1: 1Z'!: r. ? ?}•:r X54 '`Y r' ,F •!. , .li i1. ?p. .r .Y? ?s 1 '1 ",: ,y't.?tt! •Tdt ?:It ?ai r, tl > _ .r Stcr ^,tJ !'?'ti: "?' r'? fr' •i" $ P' f ,? ?+ ' _ ? ? `.t l'. •l ''it.? ? 'Cit. `.a , :i:•! '!'t t: ,?.,.:i:4'. 1':;Ff ? .. .. J, ri °•r^ ? ` .s' :t.' rr•' '?' ?",. '}} F `?j,3.}r. 1? ,r°..'t? Et•?•? '?,i ?.C' I }. s ? . r a'r• .I^y'. ,`r• ??5?_'`:f.` r? '!` ``y7!?41s`. 'i ?. `a'? .. • t .a' _, .ra,..,,Y;, ?,rr•. ? 9.'I ^r*? 5? ?y ?=f,. ,??l, r'. ; t' t' .',• ? r r ? i ?.ra ., 'r'. _!' •a? };.alf ta`'.3,lr?,Y:4ts _ 1 ?. ;FI J,,}? rP?) '•y .r•'. ?)r • i? .. ? ?• , ?'';.: w,15 .f ?.ri .*-.; re•,{1 I i'.J' 'e ?r `??l'- ;4 t?-? ";l`EJ St i. ' r `' F ?T ? ? P.,', °!:r' ? ? •?, ? ?.? o ?•Ir.:')^:q:, tl,, r?, . ?L .` .. • f r' f ? ?.r ?f.y? ?.ft.??? :r ,.l 'i r: a .K'L. ?'•,',,l ?t'?r!t:p',i J.A?' ,?•' ., `?I .f, - }`??', - '.•r'e. ., ? ,%,f• ':x, _.i f• :(r ?,;. ,?. kt -?i .15• ? ? ?'!i'. - :,}-,. ,',• `f. ?'!7' ?1 ?. ,??f1.1; i-?`?'£ 3• :,+t??l:}`x.r..l,? .,r.?r'?'t. .. ...r's',.i, t'?..?rfL;.??di5?t.?nk:?;:F41:=.-%:r';' _. ,:t? ,T ?1 ?J, •+;"' ,!` ,r• ?. ,. - ... . .......- :?#' `F?i•\r?. I ,.?r ' ` r .l ..`, ? ! - ,i; '! J r ; ' - E? 'j • ,f '.. r J ' ' r r.l??i •?'=;l,tf/ ' r ? ? .? 1 `^ - r " _,?I • • • 1 ? ? I - I ?T `' t !ie ? ? 'FI? 2 r • ? ` ^ • ' ? YES I X" 1 'J r t d!;;x; .' ? it ' ' - ' . ?.', r?•' ? E N ' i 1,7 4 'ITE ?+s ?? , J . . ? ? .. ? I • .7 r I t t ? ? ? t r : , k s e r ? ' ? ,? t ? f !ill .1,4 ?,f I^ ». IS? ? , - -?r t ` • ^'1 ? ? - , ' • ' , .,?. r ' .?',`. ?? .?: r" .ti. ?F•, .: ?l4e? •?r'• ,. fir. '1% .: '. J:..° g n4.F7.1?,. t? ! ,.,;? •?` ?? i rig s C Y? L A W A T 'E R % .•, , ?? POST OFFICE BOX 4748 , CLEA11WAYER,' FLORIDA 34618.4748 Utica at City JUtarnuy } 1813) 162.6760 - 1* Fix (613) 462'6426 March ' 1.5, 1993 Emil C. Marquardt, Jr.,, Esquire McMullen, Everett, Logan, Marquardt & Cline P. O. Box 1669 ;. Clearwater., Florida 34617 Re: Diocese of St.' Petersburg to City of Clearwater Dear Mark: During their work session this morning, one of the Commissioners asked;if the license agreement should have a "recapture" provision allowing for termination if a "paramount public,-purpbse1l- is found for the circular drive site at some later date. I told '.them x • would draft an amendment''to 'include such 'a provision, with 90 days' notice to the Diocese, with the expectation that the-Diocese would find this provision unobjectionable the way I wrote it. . ,I In writing this provision, it appeared that 'the license agreement need some reorganization, and then T decided that some of the other provisions were not as clear as they could be. The result was a rewrite of the agreement, and a.copy is enclosed. .I have underlined the significant'changes,„but,you will find minor changes throughout. I continue to believe that the,Diocese should find all of these changes unobjectionable. If any of them require further improvement. or if any prove to be objectionable, please let me know at your earliest conveni.ence,,because this is scheduled to be brought up 'T'hursday evening for approval. 1 Sincerely, M. A. Galbraith, Jr. , City Attorney ' MAG ; a' Enclosure Copy; Earl Barrett, Real Estate Services,Manager ('?E r)u'. rn?II,Irtymnrlt ,tctrl Allirrni llva'Action Qrnhlc?yur" t - f ' I • r • ' - ' . •?e?e t,• ' - • ' .. e . k ,- ,r .. r • ' ...i •. f I . ir'J . r V r V L I C E N S E A G R E E M E N T THIS LICENSE AGREEMENT is made and entered into this 23d day , , of March, 1993,-by and between the CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, the Licensor, hereinafter called "City", and the'DIOCESE OF ST. *PETERSBURG, FLORIDA, the Licensee, hereinafter called "Diocese'; WHEREAS, the City is.,the.owner of a certain parcel of land. purchased from the Diocese on this 23d day of March, 1993, said parcel being 115 feet in width, more or less, and improved with approximately 300 feet of 4-foot high chain link fencing within ; the easterly boundary thereof, said parcel running southwesterly between properties owned by the Diocese; all as depicted in' EXHIBIT "A" attached,hereto, which property is referred to herein., as the "City Parcel;„ and WHEREAS, the Diocese is the owner of a certain circular driveway, a portion of which encroaches oni-o°the City Parcel a distance?of 4.3 feet at a point approximately 65 feet south of the northwest corner of the City Parcel,,also as depicted'in EXHIBIT "A," the encroaching portion of the driveway being ' referred to herein as the "Circular Drive"; and WHEREAS, the Diocese wishes to retain the full use'of the Circular Drive as it presently exists, without structural r modification or realignment, and the City has no objection to the . continued use of the Circular Drive as it presently exists; and WHEREAS, the City intends to install at a date not yet certain an extension of the Marshall Street South sanitary. sewer , interceptor replacement within the boundaries of the City.Parcel; and WHEREAS, the City may require from the Diocese a ten-foot wide temporary construction easement along,the western boundary :. I of the City Parcel during construction of the sanitary sewer interceptor replacement; and WHEREAS, although proposed improvements to Stevensons Creek, are expocted to be constructed wholly within the boundaries of the City Parcel., it.may become necessary to.relocate the chain link fencing from the City Parcel.; NOW, THEREFORE, the parties do hereby agree: 1. The'City grants to the Diocese a non-exclusive license to use the Circular,Drive as a part of the driveway located upon the adjoining property owned by the Diocese, without modification or alteration by the-Diocese. (a) -The license to use the Circular Drive shall continue for so long as the driveway•located upon the adioininq,property' r 1 ' j r s s 7 r owned by the Diocese shall continue to exist and be used as a drive_way. Provided, however,?that if the city Commission of City should determine that a paramount publid_pu moose exists the use of the portion of the City Parcel which is encumbered the Circular Drive. the Citv shall have the right to remove t, Diocese. (b) The City agrees to repair, replace, reconstruct'and fully restore to its'present, or better, condition, any and every portion of the Circular Drive that may be.-damaged or destroyed during construction of the•sewer interceptor replacement. Otherwise, the-Diocese shall have full.responsibility for all maintenance and repairs to the Circular Drive as may be required during the term of this license agreement. 2. The City grants to the Diocese the full right and authority to remove,'at no cost to the City, the approximately 300 feet of chain link fencing from t:he ` City Parcel within 15 days of receipt by the Diocese of notice from City to relocate the fencing,. If-the fencing is not removed-by the Diocese within 45 days of recei t'b the Diocese of notice from City to relocate th6• fencing', the fencing shall' be deemed abandoned in-place and the City may remove the fencing at cost to the City and use the fencing for City purposes elsewhere. within the City. 3. The Diocese agrees t.o.grant to the City a ten-foot wide temporary construction easement along the western boundary of the, City Parcel, if and when required, for the purposes of constructing the Marshall Street South Sanitary Sewer Interceptor Replacement. The City agrees that'a condition to be imposed by_ the temporary construction easement shall be that the City shall repair, replace', reconstruct and fully restore to its present,.or better, condition; any and.every portion of the circular driveway, within the temporary construction easement that may be damaged or destroyed during construction of the sewer interceptor replacement. 4. The Diocese shall relieve, indemnify, protect and save harmless the City and any and all of its officers, agents and employees from any and all claims and liability; including expenses incurred in defending against any claim and liability, for death of or injury to persons or damage to property that may, in whole or in part, arise from or be caused directly or indirectly by this agreement. 5. The City shall relieve, indemnify, protect and save harmless the Diocese and any and all of its officers', agents and employees from any and all claims and liability, including expenses incurred in defending against any claim and liability, for death of or injury to persons or damage to property that may, in whole or in part, arise from or be caused directly or indirectly by the use of the temporary construction easement.' r.l r ?e ti. . •°• . r` r' 'r` `?1. .,? ,6 f ''Ai '.t • f .?,..• sk 1. FI !i1 i.1r?!_,^'?S?,.r??7 .. I ' ' • .1 ` •. 9^ •'?. ,]1. ,' ? • ? ? s. `spa ,: 7- , . ?{ - • ;s ? ... r, ?" r ? ?i= rt ,[, r ! ' .• { r r •i,; v, r°? ? i: ?;j t ' ly[f ?e}•,, L, , I?', `, ;> >?' - ` ?.' 'if- :?•,1 ' I . 1. , ,- ?. •r'!?{lf ? ', L • . ? ? ` ' ? • ? ? {:? } i : .. , ?. P.. + ,:1 r r 1' .'. w 'lr r r ?' . ?aJ r ` ,.f?Y? • j ' r? ` + . A. -7? '• • + ? y ' ?T r ? ,J. ,I r ? . . ?? M • ;l R,. ? ?. , i-I 1' r ? rt ? ,y, y ' ' , •. A?`i' ., + ?• '. ' I??`.N .! e'n1 i a r , S I ? , , 1 .i. ?°? , R . i' ' ?" ? '? - ' • ? • ?' ` ' r • . '', • ? aI -c j .r ii ?p`<r r•?') ' .. k , • ' , y1r • , • • 1 6 . , 'This license shall 'be binding upon the parties', hereto . and•their successors'and assigns; but this licens e shall not be assigned without the prior written consent of the , City,, _r IN, WITNESS WHEREOF.; the parties-hereto have set their hands`. ? ,-•.,r, . and 'seals the day and year first above written. ' r r ' Countersigned: ; CITY OF CLEARWATER By: ' : -• ,?-, •' Rita Garvey .. Michael J. Wright,- Mayor-- .. , Commissioner ' . City-Manager , 'k Approved as to.form Attest: and Correctness: i M: 'A .. Galbraith, Jr.. Cynthia E. Goudeau r' G= City' Attorney City Clerk y . "` ' •:. DIOCESE OF 'ST., - PETERSBURG r Witnesses , ny Attest: , F.r:i:a irr' ?L' .:r'ii ?:, a;.?;'r.;'y., ;t6: :,5:;.?; a! r.; `• -? .. ., t r. _. '. ? v f-. .. .?. ,. .:fr„a, ?'i. .Na; ;yti: mA:. srt1'?,yr'???.a ••i .5 .'.1 f f . • ' . - ,. : t" ..- X111 a?i,?i".e ''J •1r :+.r ;,' i.' :?/ r,1'•. '? r f , e ? ?'?'i•?-, .tE??i: f;«'`1?1' ;'?ft' ?' •r i":FD?t `s 1? ?? ? + k{:' - 5 .r' ., ? ? ? . - ? .. .' f:'t'!Y -! .roc, v{ 't.• r Y n , }'.' i; .Ytt ..gyp + '''P 1? ?;7;' ;,5fi` r,°?_ '' r .-r,`i:•rs.'? flf I. ,.t, .e ? '. .. ; r 1. ,``1. i?lffl???? 4r. "(7ft}e1(7?? th f, ''?!.', t,r ip. ?' :? rr 't<S t"', j. (r!.4tst. #'.4 `` ?•f' ? •+ '> Y ••i'lsl•;'??;'k ?jy "'q, i••'`k r' r'?a ,-!•.; tl•ii" ?'ri ?'4: ?. ,," r e ,' -' - ' ' :Y .''?;?. r•. :+? •?. J?'?,t,?',y sl ?? •? 1 fs' f , s'r :'rri '!' .,Sn:J ,`" ! i?: 4.•.? }', ;yfi.f ??i4• ''•?' _t .: r.t, "t '. , 1• •, '1 . .rr , { . _ ., l?;t/'R [c '-?r' 3 •' ? 11 tr° ?,5 ,, 5,`{f. td r t ? , i 1 , e J' t-'f) '''Y'om: .•? /? a 3'61 jlr } f' , , •7? •?=??s; ?'t.M1 ?• w:` e?, '??.? ..: t•'.1 ?. ?e ? !. ! •f? " ?31f Ji l1 fY ?•?• ir• 'li4t'i'1i` ry?? ?,, ? r, 'fi`r' '?' ,!' •+'''ks +'?'?t'(4`."gat •,` ?.rt'•,iijrY,?..F?'i 'j'ie?' F ? ,' r , ? :;. rf ??F,1 ?••• r ?•. ,, a , . .eta, ?..., t' .- , ! f ? , - . , r , , . ar , ,• ..•nr.? . .. a -. .. a Ali x f3 S!1'?11J1{ . ,. .(i .'.. , • ? .: ?\I fi •Y..f? r.± i ? aL ? "~'? ?? _s_ ?!, !/? r? ?/' tip.. , 1 .? ,? - • .; : f ; 04 4? , tit l '? T F 'h 4{.rf r+H..ww•t. LyI,Ohllr!.. ?.:?rM- .t:!: • •ISnn•• .. ? ? ? ?- It r 'I Jai .13,..E . 4 i?: ,. .?.?` ?']' rl.:" ? •? ,. /'.+'•. ^'.. /.rte. •' M ? ' •. •.? ? ? ? .. { 5 pp ? 3 ' .' 06 ALI S. %q G oil H .1 4 .' ` Y '' r l l }? ?. ,?, •+ + - • , ' d.t ?? ?'/1,a? . r "r '1'f ?i !'' .F 1 ++. ^ ;'St l _F, t' , r? ajF' 'r'l f e r •i?A x ° 1 p r , .? f '?751't,+',Jf. •. a'?'. '+' ?+.a.•'y??: Y. ?e`aMY,!'*.?:?fr'•. • ,fi - r , .,5+ C` e?,.i+M. CITY OF.CLEARWATER INTEROFFICE CORRESPONDENCE SHEET TO: Mayor and. City Commission FROM: Betty Deptula, Assistant City Manager SUBJECT: Private Property Rights Bill (S1000/HB1437): DATE: March 19, 1993 Commissioner Berfield has requested that a resolution opposing the proposed ".Private Property Rights Act" legislation (S1000 and HB1437) be prepared for your consideration at your meeting tonight. ` . `. 1 In effect, the proposed legislation would require payment by. governmental 'agencies for any regulatory action'that would result in a property value decrease of'40% or more. This would :. severely limit governmental ability to control and manage growth and would impose significant costs. in analyzing the costs of zoning or other regulations. r ' Attached are the analysis prepared by the County 'and the City of St. Petersburg, as well as the.! FLC position paper. The actual billand the legislative staff analysis of the bill are available in the office. Please call if you would like a ,copy. ,'. 1 r If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call. + r'. PRINTED ON REYCLED PAPER 1 Y }`'_`fii!<,i`f.'' r?+i, •',,II. :a' ? i:' :rrrF '34,j1 ? f' ' ' -: Z + ' ? fi • •r f+ •, , S, . ; r.{ ,F: S:. 1, ,%,.. a RESOLUTION NO. 93-19 " A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF'CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, EXPRESSING OPPOSITION TO THE PROPOSED "PRIVATE.PROPERTY , RIGHTS ACT OF FLORIDA;" PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, [louse dill 1437 and Senate Bill 1000, the proposed "Private Property Rights Act of Florida," would expose cities and counties in Florida , to unprecedented liability including attorney's fees, for the diminution of property values due to governinen to l .regu 1 at i on; and WHEREAS, the proposed legislation would expose governmental agencies,to new liability for police power and land use regulations already on the books;' and WHEREAS, the proposed legislation would drastically increase the cost'of' local government by requiring the employment of lawyers and appraisers to evaluate the 'effect of every existing and-proposed regulation on individual' parcels of property; and WHEREAS, the proposed legislation would have the practical effect of ' negating the'ability of cities' and counties to regulate the use of land, ' contrary to the requirements of the Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act and other statutory requirements, and contrary to the hoarse-rule. authority of local government to regulate the-use of land for the protection of the health, safety and welfare of the public; and ;. WHEREAS, current case law provides an adequate remedy for regulations which constitute a "taking" under the Florida and United States Constitutions, and fn fact provide better protection than•was available,ten years ago, now, therefore, " BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA: 1 . Section 1. The City Commission of the City of Clearwater does hereby express its opposition to House Bill 1437 and Senate Bill 1000, the proposed "Private Property Rights Act of Florida." Section 2. Copies of this 'resolution shall be provided to the President of the Florida Senate, the Speaker of the Florida House of Representatives, each member of the Pinellas County Legislative.Delegation, and to the Governor of the State of Florida. Section 3. This resolution shall-take effect immediately upon adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED this 18th day of March; 1993. r Attest: Cynthia E..Gou eau Rita Garvey 'City Clerk i? Mayor-Commissioner C .: 3.i •• 3 • 1 Yyn,t •7 r Ali 'f ! . • - .tr { ? r ?'r r a ' . ,+. M E M 0 R.A N D,U M TO:. Councilmember Connie Kone FROM: Michael S. Davis, City Attorney ' .,DATE: March 51 1993 ' RE: Senate Bill 1060/House Bill '1437 Senate'.Bill 1000 and House Bill 1437 create the "Private Property- Rights-Act of Florida". :This proposed law is a lawyer relief act. I' strongly recommend that the,` City take an official position in opposition to both bills.' The Bi lls would create a cause of action against the City whenever . the -practical use of real property is severely limited by " a City , regulation.. - The 'def inition of ".severely limited" is a reduction of fair market value. by more than 40 percent for the uses permitted at ' , the time the owner acquired title or on July 1, 1985, whichever'is ' later. The, property owner would then have a cause of action to require the .,. :. .City to'condemn the property or pay damages and could also recover attorney's fees and costs. The City could choose not to pay the compensation award,, but 'must, rescind the regulatory program and f would remain liable for attorney's fees, to the property owner as well as damages incurred by the property owner while the regulation . was, in effect. This legislation constitutes a dramatic change in the law and would have severe adverse financial and, practical consequences to the City of St. Petersburg and all other governmental agencies in the State. of Florida. This-legislation may require the City to conduct, real estate appraisals of all property in the City which has been rezoned or subjected to a new municipal regulation after July J., 1985 to determine if the municipal zoning, historic preservation or' , other regulation has severely limited its practical use. Further, -the law could bring growth management, zoning, histoi iQ pre;,-erva-- tion and other traditional municipal land use regulations to a halt. ichael S. Davis bg g: I.! n r . r° ° _n 4 jR SY v t' j ,? t .; ' I d ? I I ' I • t ? ? r ? ?I /r • r :Ertl I ? I ? r i•i r'. ', ? w. ` iii ' I ' , . , ,' • ?l. o F.Sf- ?'? ??.:sac d u ? . A RESOLUTION OPPOSING THE PROPOSED PRIVATE PROPERTY RIGHTS ACT OF FLORIDA [HB 1437/SB 1000]; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the proposed Private Property Rights Act of Florida [HB 1437'/SB 1.000]'exposes all, municipalities and other governmental 'entities in Florida to unprecedented and. unlimited liability, including attorney's fees for limitation of'property values due to"governmental regulations; and WHEREAS, these Bills would, should they become law, expose governmental entities in'Florida to liability beyond that customarily provided by law and require said governmental entities to pay attorney's fees and damages for police power regulations which are well within the authority of local-government to enact, such as zoning, land use and historic preservation;,and WHEREAS, current decisional law provides an adequate remedy for police power regulations. which constitute a "taking" under.the. Florida and United States Constitutions; and [WHEREAS, 'these- proposed' Bills may brinq to a halt municipal zoning, land use, historic preservation and growth management legislation, and- expose governmental agencies to new_ liability'ex post facto'for police power regulations currently on the books, while drastically increasing the cast of local government•by-requiring local government.to employ appraisers Wand lawyers to evaluate the effect of every proposed land regulation. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that this council strongly opposes House Bill 143.7 and Senate Bill 1000 and urges the members of the Florida House and Senate, the Governor and the Florida League of Cities to oppose this proposed legislation. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that copies of this resolution shall be provided to, the Governor, the President of the Florida Senate, the Speaker ,of the Florida' House of Representatives and each member of the Florida. Legislative. Delegation representing Pinellas'County, as well as the Florida•League,of Cities. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution shall become effective immediately,upon adoption. Approved as to form and content:. raity Attorney . i i ,, 1." 7 tY , It I f r e• ``. ,, •ri 1 •' j YY.J. r ..r i ' I=? 1. .. :.`'L'. .U!'fl1?I?uccz:Cl'S lar=li?fs. . T The Honorable Cha?} Members : of the %palo\ Of COUki Commissioners ' FROM:. Fred Marquis s` County Administ? . V /q??l4s `Own., RE. Resolution in Opposition to Proposed Legislation' DATE: March 16, 1993 RECOMMENDATION: It' is recommended. that the Board of County commissioners. adopt. the attached resolution. and forward copies to the. Governor, the ' Speaker of the House and- the President.of the Senate as well as 1 individual. members of our legislative delegation. BACKGROUND' The'attached legislation, Senate Bill 1.000 has a companion House Bill 1437. The legislation essentially requires payment-by counties and the state `(but not municipalities) for any regulatory effort which results in a property value deciease'of 40% or more. The' legal result of this legislation, as reflected in., the attac'hed' resolution, would be to overturn over seventy years', of caselaw regarding' compensable takings of private property:' The practical result of this,legislation, as reflected in the attached resolution, would be to- fiscally prohibit past ' and present regulatory efforts to, control and manage growth and natural resources. I , E ?.?"•. i??, -'?{I' .tr is vp•a.1y uv,: •rr yr .?, ?. .t•1j. a fir' f s:•t JI,' , ? . . ' ? Y l . ' , e '?1?? ?' .r.' :i t`a'xi' tt?-1•.. 'lid ,f :L / li,.. • ' t. f 4<'?{ ? , :, +,Y '. ` .?4 ? , ,l.• ., tit Resolutibn No. `•5's. ' WHEREAS, it is correct that Justice Holmes originated' the concept of a regulatory taking with the following language: "The general rule at least is that while property may be regulated to a certain extent,' if 'regulation goes too far it will be 'recognized•'as a taking." PennsylvaniaCoal _Co. v. Mahon, 43 S.Ct. 158 160 (1922) he also said that: Government hardly could go on if to some extent values incident to property could not be diminished without paying for every such change in the'general law." Pennsylvania Coal at 159; <cited with approval in the. majority opinion 'in Lucas v. South: Carolina Coastal Council, 112 S.C 2886 (1992)>. and WHEREAS, the passage of "Thy: Private Property Rights Act of Florida," <HB '. 1437' and SB 1000> (the Bill) would allow private property owners to receive compensation for. "severe limitations" of the practical, use of their' real t property caused by the implementation of regulatory programs by the state or. any of its political subdivisions; and WHEREAS, the Bill would, apply to the state and county-implementation of the Growth Management Act, environmental laws,' local= zoning, game protection ' laws and regulations, and a vast array of other rules and regulations that affect land use; and WHEREAS, without any apparant rational, the Bill would apply to-the state and. county but not municipal implementation of the foregoing regulations; and WHEREAS, in Four significant ways, the Bill seeks to undermine over seventy (70) years of Florida and federal constitutional jurisprudence underlying the balancing of privvate property rights with community needs in .1 g f' that: 4 ?' ;f??.;rt' Cs c' `y ,t •t. Fri>S r I w t ' k .Ia I 1. The 13111 redefines a regulatory taking as -any regulation 'which acts to "severely limit the practical use of real property". The US'Supreme Court has consistently defined a taking. as a denial of all economically beneficial and productive use of land: Lucas; Keystone., _Bitumi.nousCoal V. DeBenedictis, 107 S.Ct. 1232 (1987); Aging v. Tiburon, 100 S.Ct. 2138 (1980); Penn Central Transportation Co. V.- City of New York, 98 S.Ct. 2646 (1978)'. Florida courts follow that same definition: Glisson v.Alachua Count Z, 558 S6.2d 1030 (Fla. 1st DCA 1990); Lee Count v. Morale:, 557 So.2d 1086 (Fla. 2d DCA 1990); .State of 'Florida Department of Environmental Regulation v. MacKay, 544 S0.2d 1065 (Fla. 3d?DCA 1989); Bensch v. Metropolitan Dade County, 541 So.2d .1321 (Fla. 3d DCA), review denied, 549, So. 2d 1013 (Fla. 1989) ; '.down of _Bay Harbor Islands v. Driggrs, 522 So.2d 912, (Fla. 3d DCA), review denied, 531. So.2d 1352 (Fla. 1988); Fields y. Sarasota-Manatee Airport_ Authority, 512 So.2d' 961 (Fla.' 2d ACA 1987),, review denied, 520 So,2d 584 (Fla, 1988); Florida Audubon Society v. Ratner, 497 So' 2d 672 (Fla. '3d DCA 1986), review denied, 508 So.2d 15 .(Fla. 1987Garden State Properties Inc . v. Dade county, 410 so. 2d 655 (Fla, 3d DCA 1982); State Department of Transportation v. Donahoe, 412 So.2d 400 (Fla. Ist DCA 1982); City of Boca Raton v. Tradewi^nd Hills Inc., 216 So.2d 460 (Fla. DCA 1968); City of Miami v. Zorovich, 195 So. 2d 31 (Fla. 3d DCA); cert. denied, 201 So.2d 554 '(Fla. 1967); Waring v. Peterson, 137 So.2d 268 (Fla. 2d DCA 1962). 2. The Bill creates a presumption of a taking where diminution in value reaches 40'%,. This depart: from the long established rule that a regulatory taking involves investment backed _e? ectations and should be established though case specific ad hoc inquiries in which the extent of diminution in value is only one of a number of factors. The US Supreme Court.has consistently eschewed any such set formula for determining when a taking has occurred: Lucas at 2893; Yeey.City of Escondido, 112 S.Ct. 1522, 1529 (1992); Pennell v. City of San Jose, 108.S.Ct. 849, 856'(1988); tiodel v. Irvin , 107 S.Ct. 2076, 2077 (1987); Keystone Bituminous Coal Association V. DeBenedictis, 107' S.Ct.. 1232, 1254 (1987); MacDonald v. Yolo County,. 106 S.Ct. 2561, 2566 (1986) ; Ruckelhaus v. Monsanto, 104 S.Ct. 2862, 2874 (1984)'; Loretto v. Tele ro ter Manhattan CATV Corn., 102 S.Ct. 1364, 1371 (1982); , Model.v. Vir inia Surface Kinin and Reclamation Assoc., 101 S.Ct. 2352, 2370 (1981); San Diego _Gas and Electric Co. v._ City of San Disgo,, 101 S.Ct. 1287, 1303 (1981); Kaiser Aetna v. U.S., .100 S.Ct. 383, 390 (1979); Penn Central, Florida courts follow that same rule: Valtaiaro v. State Degartment of Environmental Regulation, 601 so-2d 1223,, 1228 (5th DCA 1992);' Glisson at .1034; Florida Department: of Agriculture and „Consumer Services y. Hid-Florida Growers, 521.So.2d -2- z^ 'IY • n i 1 101, 104 (Fla. 1988); City of Boll ood v. Hollywood Inc., 432 So.2d 1332, 1337 (Fla. 4DCA -1983); Pinellas Count _ v._ Brown, 420 So.2d'308, 309 (Fla. 2DCA 1982). 3. The Bill provides that overy'square inch of property is its own "unit ' of analysis" for purposes of determining whether that square inch bas been taken. This departs from the takings rule that: "takings jurisprudence does not divide •a single parcel into discrete segments and attempt to determine whether rights in a particular segment have been entirely abrogated, in deciding whether a particular governmental action has effected a taking, this Court focuses. rather bath on 'the character of the action and on the nature of the interference with rights in the parcel as a whole..:" Penn Central at 2662. The US Supreme Court has consistently followed that rule;- Keyslone at 1248; Penn Central at 2662. as have the courts in Florida. Valtalaro. at 1228; State of Florida Department of Environmental Re4ulation v. Schindler, 604 So.2d 565 (2d DCA 1992); State of Florida Department of Environmental Regulation V. MacKay, 544 S0.2d 1065 (Fla. 3d DCA 1989); Bensch v. Metropolitan. Dade Count, 541 So. 2d 1321 (Fla. 3d DCA 1989); Florida. Audubon. Societyy._ "Ratner, 497 So.2d 672 (Fla. 3d DCA 1986); Fox v. Treasure Coast Regional Planning-Council, 442 So.2d 221, 226 (Fla. 1st DCA 1983)' 4. The Bill may displace all prudential and jurisdictional doctrines which protect against abuses by both the. government and the property owner. Such doctrines under the general term of "ripeness" include the need to apply for a specific use <A ins>, the need to explore options <Penn Central>; <MacDonal_d v_.- Yolo_County> the need to seek variances. and the finality requirefient <Willi.amson County. Reg. Planning Commission v..' . Hami-ltion Bank, 473 U.S. 172 (1985); and '',WHEREAS, the logic of•the.Bill, which ignores the receprocity of benefits associated with good growth management, should also require' that regulatory changes which increase the value in real, property should result in a payment to the-government. for such incidental benefits, in order to offset the massive tax burdens associated with the impacts of the Bill; and , WHEREAS, the,Bill is unworkable in its present' form as the. concepts being addressed are incompletely defined, and -3- :F Y r ". y' E ..i tY l r ?•! t? Y• ^,f r ' r rr ?1 ` #, F • .,1 j`i t ' f i .t`_ ,ter r ' ' I'•i ?•i/ if .t ; ,4-fo '. • ly IS . t ' t Le.,l. ? '.' .. WHEREAS, local governments are ' . presently protecting private property •', , rights by, ordinances which, unlike the `Bill,. are conceptually',based'•on established and evolving takings Jurisprudence; and WHEREAS; the Bill would virtually negate. the ability to' rezone. property for any of the protections such as preservation of community integrity or environmental purposes; and WHEREAS, it would be nearly impossible to 'enforce downzoning Of any piece of property 'as to which, it. could not be' awed that 'a 40 percent diminution of value has occurred and therefore be declared a taking under the Bill. .'.` NOW,'THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Board' 'of County Commissioners of Pinella's County urgently requests the Governor of Florida, the Speaker of the `•?' House and'the President of the'senate to strongly appose the Bill and urge the members of-the Legislature to discontinue consideration of this legislation.'. BE IT FARTHER RESOLVED that the Clerk of the Board of County Commissioners of Pinellas County send a copy of this Resolution to the Governor of Florida, the Speaker of the Florida House, the President of the Florida.Senate and to the. individual members of our legislative delegation. Commissioner offered the foregoing Resolution and moved its adoption, which was seconded by Commissioner and upon roll call, the vote was: "I AYES: NAYS: ABSENT ARID NOT VOTING: 1, 1 rfr'l fem. •. f. t yf. -?' ti:? ,rNa Via;;i'?1.? ? r? t .,4i f 1 " '•i' w .i,7 P.. ??. af'' if • f ix: t ,: rt + r I MAR 17 '93 15:21 FLA LE.AGLE OF CITIES 9@4 2223806 Pr?lde?l Wtl1'ers _ ' Mayor, I3("ntorl R1Vt Vks Presl4ent Ilene Liebarman : Mayar, Lauderhill' 4 Second VW Pm1dant Clarence Anthony Mayor, $outh Say, f , i p,4/il i RoWaleagua:af Iu©s, lna 201 West' aik Avenue ., c Post 6#1ae Box 1757 Tallahassee, FL 32302-1757 Teleph9ne (904) X22-9884 Suncom 278-5391 FAX (904) 222.3806 i LEAGUE OY CITIES OPPOSESIPRIVATE PROPERTY UXGHTS BILL HB 1437 by Rao. Harris, at al. es zoos by en.. Myers et aL. i The, fiSCdl, impact of the bill on municipalities could forea many - sma?1 cities into bankruptcy. Approximately 69% of the cities! in Florida have populations less than 10,000. The total. revenue ' collected in these cities rang s from $4.3 million (Crestview pop. i 9,886) to $15,316 (Lazy La a pop. 33). Payment of just compensation for land use. regulation that limits the use 'of person's property by 40$ would virtually destroy the fiscal stability of these cities and eruely afflact their bond rati,ng$ some snail cities for'the firs time in Florida history would;be l forered i,n>~o bankruptcy. } In ether cities, residents would experience a general deere'ase:in deli,vsry of essential services] f such as police, fire, Wager, sevax e otc. Law enforcement, fare c ntrolt utilities, and solid waste alone account for over 501 of a city's budget. Payment of just , . compensation for land use re lation that limits the use of a '•, pergon's property by 401 soul severely decrease these or avdxi elin;inate these or other munic pal! services. The proposed bill appears tbe a mandate. Although loeeall governments must plan for future growth and preserve our environmental assets pursuant to the Local Government comprehensive Plarming Act and Land Developme t Regulation Act, Part 11, Chapter' 163, Florida Statutes (1991), i he bill fails to provide a revenue source to assist local governm rtes." to sati,Gfy their lia.bil.i.ty gor doing what they are mandated by the growth management act to do. The bill will most likely be hej d unconstitutional when challenged in court requiring unnecessary legal expenses. Federal couxrt4 have held that property values an be reduced by 851 to 90% and;i,f there is still ' some "economically viable use" left to the property, them there is no 11taking.11 For further information, aontae sane Hayman or Nancy stupari.ch : at f the league (222-9684). , Ai•WrRorA194andarPonalas,Cammlict0n00Jo1r0-Dad0 Couniyan Gerald Thompson,Comwaflonor,BrowardCauniy• BarbomShognTodd, ComMWIonot, PlnrlW County o rCongramalonAl01Alders: John Lawson, Aiayar, DoFunlak pd s. Ole nol Dowden, Councllman, Laka Chy * Glvnn Edwordt, Commissloner, Atantic Beach p George 5. Musson, Mgor,NowSmyrrAsoaclh. John >{.L,nndryor,Apopka a WIIIIamCopetand,Counefman,Archer.a Job anico, CouncA Cn:drman, Tampa, a Holland G, Mangum, Mayor, Samlncle a Wlldtm C. dwother, Commisatonlr, Plan Clty • Vacancy • Larry L. Sahuliz, 0="Man, fto,?cladQO • Jahn V/rt ht, Da tY Mayar, Avon Pa+k a Rtcturd Barhaw, ncllman, Fort Mfllrrc a John "Jeff" Koons, Commisslonar, Weal Palm Beach ¦ loan P*arl, L- ds9. John Mi faeruna, Commisslone4 Dania w John Kur n, Vice Mayor, North MIanV Baacls • Joseph J. Gsrdn.r, Counciknan, [3ay harbor is?inds • R, Shlvrr. Commss:onar, Fla: da City • 70l?r?asl Cltlsr E. rnlsn L", CaunrJtparmcn. JadWAVillo • J. L Owumer, Jr„ C 1vTiWGr4r, Mranv •IiandyW, cimrn,Mayor,Trtlnpla0rvldJ.Flaah."ayor,St,Polora *Jullohtartfnox,Mayar,I{ataah*JlmNauafo,Mayor. Fort l?+drndaioeChatdora l?,Wriaon,issior+or,QrWn 0-00ratAylnmsrrCnwa,Comml,sienar, rllahaaaea Mang Glullaril Mayyar,Hollywood a R13nJ.aarwy,i?!?yvr.Ga:rr"W r Prraf Proakiont,1 [o e, 5mllh, Councilman, Jasksamrilo a Glandn Lion ,Mayer. 01WWo * FCCU&I NICh"I J. Robono, Cq Manegoh N40%, orth WwTO poach e TaNr+hnsrsoel Cfrlt +r Raymond C. sin[a, Bxacu Q tareaw a }tarry Worri qn, Jr.; Genortil Counrgl k s '