The URL can be used to link to this page

01/24/1994 - Special '! v < .r. " I'; .' " '" ,'I: ':.0 j,'" ,I .-' 'I' , , " , , , . .' " , " , , : \ .'1.1 + '.'~ i, ,; ..' .'.. " ',' I ..1 . , \ 'I " . . I ' :~: ~: ~ i, ~ .~.}l ::~ ~ ,; > . . . .' ,.:~ ':,;, >: ~,~;, ;\ ~:,.:. : .'~ ~,::! ::. "," i;, :, . : , ~' . .' , ~. '" i ,', r: j. " .' ! ~ f ~. : , ct... ~. , > .'~ .' I + ~, > l '. !FY'~\""j ",1 r',"',\ , I,; ',' } .. '. l", ;"! f~" ",!" '<!~~,.' ; , ': >,:_.,:'>;..: t~,..., "~,~1' ; ,~',,~\"';'}~l;'. .t," .: L .t r:. c . c ~ '.. ~ . .. ~ ~. '\ , " \1', I ,: ~. I " ; , .: !' . " ~., .'1' , '~ 'c. " ! ' .,',1 .'.. ,./ ;,c ,I, , " " , . ;' - ~ " . j' ~ '.' ~.t , ~', " , . ~ I ' ',I ,'I "I, :' ~, ' , I"" y,: ~ . 'I >. . "'> - . ,'~.( " , . L't.. " '~ (:,. i, " , ,.", ... .',' " : ; \' f I' ," ~ I ~ ~ (. j" , .," 'E · (I " ./, ' ~\.),l.:::~<.:':. .,'~ ..~.::..,~.....' " , .'"l,,'>', , " >" ' " c ~ " ;, .', ", 'I". " j " ~ ," ': i.: " " t ,.1::' 1''\ l . L: , '.~ '; :: '.t J' '~ ... , , , " . ~ 1. > ~ , ~.l~ .,.'L \,. . , , :':.:0; 'l,'''~1 ,:'. .'10".. t..... < . ~A, " J '. 1 , ,. ~ i L .: , " , ~. " ~ c_ '.\' ',I c" ,'.t." I, ~ .. , : " " " ,. \' , , , , c ~.,} j:" , ' · ;l' . t f, , ' ~ ." < . , . :../ ,,' _, f " .,' ;, .."\ .;. ~ . ',:) , " , ' ,'/ ;..c " , 'c ,I"~ ....,1' : , " " :'" ,:' ~ , " . ,,\ . ",,! i J <~ < ~ , " . ~. j., . ~ 1. J i ';- -I. " , ' , " . ~ \, , , , . " ( ~. \ .r. . i. i: .~. :) >,' ~, 'y . ,~ .t .. , ',. ", " . >. ~ , I , I .. ,', ',' "l-t ,-' ',i ,1.' t , " '(J- . ',' ;, ~ . .' ~. " , , , , " . , ',1' " S.i, ',' ,', t, " .: , J.' "f , , , , " ..... t ,. , ' ~ . ~ ' I ~. " " '" , ' I,: .1'1. 1'. ~ " " .' ~::. : ~" . " '" , l ~ ,. ~, )... t ". , , . ',/.: I...t ;. .1 + '. , , ' , ' " , " 'I,.',' ' '.' i~ : \1 : ~ " l' , " :AG'ENDA, .o-+~. " ~, ; " :' I. :.. , " ..i.'i" ., ')' , , ;, " " '1..." ',' f>, " .-, " >"." ,\' ", " ,'I 'j . , . , " )~ , IT" :":~'::?l:\-':'I,,,. : , .' ': :' <, f " " , , \ . J' 1- ',' " ;'" ,. ,I' " ' '" ,.'1; c,...., ~ ',;~~r.,~ . : ~ . " \, " , , ' " . " , .~ " .,., " ~ . ~ r ',\ . 1 " '" ~..... . + .'" , . ~. ',. . '.'~.':; ~ < I.'... ' /:' ~ ~~, ': t 1: l' ,. ~~,' ~ f , . , : ~ ,. , " 'l' DATE " .:lJ} - 91/ " , "~ I " " .' ' '.C "L .. ~, ~l :(~ .. " " " " \:' " 37 ............. g~31 " " , , '1 I';." ',.(,,1 " , , , " ~ . ) ,I " /., \' " ',' .' '.. ,. " ;, I , ,~ 1 /' .,:., , , .' ~, " \ , ',' " .,,<. " , .' " i. ~: . " ,', ,. ~ . 1 " , "'.,1 . " " '.. " I', ; ~ ; 'I 1. I " ' " ," " I . > ~; , , , , ~ , , , ' " i I,: .'\( 1 " " , ..1 " " " " , ' i,L " ... ~" . ,r " I'"~ 1c', : ' ., '.' I " ". , , ': ~:' , \ " '.1, ", .\ : ,\ ;"., . '.,1 .l;J .' ; l " , " , I' " . . ~ ... , .,. }>>~i ;'~"<,(,::.<t~,' , . . , ' " '.t.c , 'I t '. \ ..il i' ~ . ~ . . ' };",;'i:" ..~:> \, ,", : ~:;, ~.:.'~:: F:: !' y ", ,J: I' >; ] : , I ,.( i' ..:.'l'. .c' ' \:';!+ .",' ", f' , ,~ c ~ . , , " 'C'.'. . t >, , , '., .J , .., ,~; . " ,,');, " t:}'.,,, ..: ~ . ;.l;~' ___~ ). l.E. :\~;:. ~,'I:\~\.: .' ,.:' ,. ~ l' ~. ,. ~ ..':~ I '~, .'1 T.. '.j ,t.; . ~ . t:i;': ,,':;:~ 1,;i;\,~;:';' t7" ,)';' ~'J~,j'~'\'i;:'~ ~h:~~,:"'-'.~;':, H'\' ':I," " 'i>"'i,,-;;,,,;,:,-,:;,,I ~'{-:';~~ ::';' :",' ,:..":~;' ',I, ,.\ ,\ ;,:' . ',":::'::, ~; / ,:,: " '.' . ~ -I J- ~ I \ ~J', '. , , . t c..' l .~~ ~ ~ \ .1' ,~, . . . . . . , ,. ,<.. \ .-.. ~ . f. \: ,,' '. " .'c/~.~:~: " :'1 , .' I, " ~ , 1 , ; '. .l;. .' ~ >~ < . ! . ..~' I '~ t.'.~~ ., "- ~. .; > t. ~ . , , .. " . ;". ~ I ~~ ... , . ~ -1/". ',IL. , ,'. 'I , .., ~; , " t.. '/' " .~ ". f " 'I' i"I'; " ' ~ ':. ~" ., , " " ~ I " ~ ~. ,. " <t. . j '. >' . ~, ~. - ~. . ~ ~ ~ . t'", .::'1 .'. ". . '~ ~' . ~ ' " ' .; .; 1 . ~ ~ . , . . ~ ~ , , I '..} ", i I ..{>~I/",. ':::~. , .~. '! '<' . J ~ . , ' I ' J. ~ . ~~ ~ .~. \"1 ...1". 'l. ....0'....1._. , \ ., : "" ~..: .!..."--,.. ~ _\ c ~ ~:. .., , ( , ., , ,. t, , " " ;.t, . ",.... , ; " , ,I , ' c , .' I' I' " , " " , " , . t, ,'; CITY:' cotvfMISS'ION; SPECIAL, MEETIN . . , :;).Lt elLl G. ,,' ,; " ,> I :ji " "'l ,) ,'. , . ('c .t: ,-- ~. .., , , ", . ~ ~ . ' ~." " . ~ . ~ '. i , 1-' ~"' ole'. ~ : ' ,/,:,:'", " .~~-:</.<.;-.l..~:",. ~ ..'< .( r ." f. ,~ . 1 fivt};,:;).'~~;:, ;' }....,. ;:'.';'~ r':<':"i, ~ " "qr~ , ,\ " " , " ,.' .' '. I' ,j ,1'-' , , I . ~ . . " ~' T " ~.' r 'I' . i ~ I . h ,I" , " .. t. ..~, ," I _'I / ., . > 1 ~/ '+. '. c " " ' ,. \ .,' , " , '" ; ,c ;. ,. '~r. . . .'/ ~T' , i . ~.~ " ';"i ,I' Lf'l "'l'. r , ~ . : ~ ~ ~ .,. . ~i. , , I' .~. .: j " , ' .. , c(: ,l <. ...... 't I,' .. f: J " I .' , ',I' " ',. ~ " :';' . ;,:,';,;,:,,:, ',...,;',>", /'" I': , ,'. ! ',' . " ' " ; " f.'.'~. .' ~' "i ~ . .t' . ' .' ;.~;' ':;\I~' d :,~'~Si.....:'.; T;!..:t,:': .~ '1< " ~'. . ~ c." .. i;, ;' '.. >' rh (t.:~,:';( . :'; i ' i,.. t, ' ". , " l~ ~. i '.+ {' . '.\ I >. ~ ~ t '.1' ,: .: I .' i.L ')1 ~ .. . c' ; . I :,' ~ , '," _.':c" , " .. I I c !. ~ . . ... , . \. ~ I ;. t, , I : I ; ~ ,,' " ,~~ . I ~ :t " ", ,. ',I ". , i' ...,;. :.1 " , " ': : ~. '< 1 I ,'f \ , I ~: t, '1 I,". '. \. c J. '\ :', .',..' ~ I'. \ . f . t ~ . . j, .. . ,,", I, " ,.l . ~.' 0' !, ,.';-1 .' .' , :~ ~ ( " 'II' . ~,. ,.., .-> .', '.. ~ I . '1' " " . ) {(. .. '.\ ,. ~l' . i , " , ,~ ... '. , ! , :~ I ,Ic";. I c ~ ~ , t '. " "'" '. . ,>, ~. / : i ~ ~ 't'c.':<: ,.,/ . . '/,' "I < I' ~ ,. ,I' \ ' i < ~ ( :....:. ';-. ,.. .. ,;'.:' ~! . ~> ~': .-1' ~ .t, >.. . ~ ' ~"1.'::,:.,j" ~~< t~ ; ; " ',' ,I " . j.. .\ '" ;>, I ! r. . I ,I, ~, If , >) <'; ,.t' , , .. , ' i j. i.: .:;....:.:::...Jc I- ;,. " :J :)': , " . ~ ,~: . :L " ~ . ~ ... '0 , ,~. I' , I, ,\ " '.' , " '1. I, ',. , j , ," , ., I,. ,<tf , , ',\ "',\ , .;.. :'f<:. " ,i' ", " ; , ." '~:'. f l . c. '. : .: \. ". " ;, " I' " ',I, ~ '.. ~, f ": .... '" cJ ',!' ; "" ~ ~, ."'" , : , ;, '" ~ : '" . .. " I . . c, ~ t . c. f. t' .1>.::' , , I 'I ! I \, ','J . ".' " , , , , ; " ", : I~ .} ;, , ,:i, . .\ , '<. , . " " +., ,. , " " . ' " ',I," r '" ,'. , i .. , , ' ,> .' ,;J.. ." : ' , 1 ,I, , , I" " .c, ' '" " ,I I j I i ,- " '; '" f" ') I, " . ",) . '..l' " , \.,' ; ,'( " " '. . T . ~ I' ,\ " }.., ...... .:. , ~. ~ '" " .\ I. .', '" ~ ," ~ 1. . c..' , ' , . ~ . '. . I " I' . " ,'. 'j' " '. ~ . I, t, ACTION AGENDA City Commission Special Meeting Sign Variance Requests Januar,y 24, 1994 - 9:00 a.m. IT~M A - (cont frpm 10-29-93) Addise, Inc (Monaco Motel) for variances of (1) to permit two above roof signs; (2) of 45 sq it to permit a total of 101 sq ft of attached signage; and (3) 42.5 in to permit a freestanding sign to be positioned 17.5 in setback from street to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 648 Poinsettia Ave, Mandalay Unit No 5 Replatf Blk 84A, Lots 16-20, zoned CR 24 (Resort Commercial). SV 92-48 ~ withdrawn. ITEM B - (cont from 11-9-93) Espana Business Center for variances (1) of 96 sq ft to allow 160 sq ft of signage area; and (21 3.33 ft in height to permit a 23.33 ft freestanding sign to permit nonconforming signage to remain after expiration of 7 year amortization period at 1674 ~ 1688 Belcher Rd N, Clearwater Industrial Park, part of Lot 14, zoned IL (Limited Industrial). SV 92-78 - continued 10 2/7/94. ITEM C - lcont from 11-9-93) Steven N. Eiseman, TRE (Alternative Auto) for a variance of 5 ft to permit a freestanding sign 0 ft from property line to permit nonconforming signage to , remain at 1902 Drew $t, Marymont Sub, Blk 24fLot 24 and half vacated street, zoned CG (General Commercial). SV 93-08 - approved subject to the condition the applicant or future owners shall bear all expenses incurred for removal or relocation of sign if required by ',Depart'ment of Transportation for Drew Street widening project.' ' ITEM 0,- (cont from 11-9-93) Florida Family Investors, inc/Baxter & Rinard (Kenyon Dodge) for variances (1) of 122 sq ft to permit a freestanding sign of 234 sq ft in area; (2) 16.75 ft in height to permit a 36.75 ft freestanding sign; and (3) 5 ft to permit a sign 0 ft from street right-of~way to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 19400 US Hwy 19 S, See 19.29- 16, M&B '14.0 1 less road, zoned CH (Commercial Highway), SV 93-34 ~ (1), (2) and [31 denied. , I , 1 . William D. & Kathryn A. McKnight (Seven Oaks BPI for a variance to permit 2 freestanding signs in a zone where such signs are not permitted at 706 Drew St, Property of E.H. Coachman, Blk 8, Lots 1 & 2 less street. Lots 3 & 4, and part of Lots 10, 11, A, and all of Lot 14. zoned UC,(C) (Urban Center (Core). SV 92-18 - approved. 2. Natt C. Smith, Jr. & Betty l. Smith (Accurate Automotive Repair) for variances of (1) 49.5 sq ft to permit a freestanding sign of 73.5 sq ft; (2) 17.2 ft in height to permit a freestanding sign of 25.2 ft in height; (3) 4.4 ft in distance to permit a freestanding sign .6 ft from property line; and (4) ,1 message panel to permit a freestanding sign with 3 message panels to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 1266 Court St, Hibiscus Gardens, Blk 0, part of Lot 21, Lots 22-27 and part of Lot 28, zoned OL (Limited Office). SV 92-30 - (1) approved an area variance of 1 sq ft to allow a 25 sq ft sign 'where 24 sq ft is permitted; (2) approved a height variance of 3.9 ft to allow a sign height of 11.9 ft where 8 ft is permitted; (3) approved a setback variance as requested; and (4) ilpplicant withdrew request for one messnge panel. 1/24/94 1 " j 3. Pauline Rophie (Alec Center) for a variance of 4 ft to permit a freestanding sign with a 1 ft street setback to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 2416 G ulf-to-Bay Blvd, See 18-29-16, M&B 13.02 & 13.03, zoned CG (General Commercial). SV 92-45 . approved subject to the conditions {1] the freestanding sign at the southeast corner of the property shall be removed within 60 days of the date of this public hearing and (2) the subject sign shall, comply with all height and area requirements within 60 days of the date of this public hearing. 4. Affiliated Agencies, Ine (C-21 Condon-Meek, Inc} for a variance of 5 ft to allow a freestanding sign 0 ft from property line to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 1211 Court St, Hibiscus G'ardens, Blk R, Lots 11-16, zoned CG (General Commercial). SV 92-69 - approved. 5. lakeview Oaks Condo for a variance of 11.6 sq ft to allow a freestanding sign of 75.6 sq ft to permit nonconforming signage to remain after expiration of 7 year amortization period at 600, 610 & 620 lakeview Rd, lakeview Oaks Condo, zoned IL (Limited Industrial). SV 92-79 - approved subject to the condition the landscaping in front of the sign be continuously maintained. 6. Ernest R. &. Lydia J. Malke (Ritz Resort Motel) for variances of( 1) 4.5 ft setback to allow a freestanding sign 0.5 ft from street right-of.way (5. Gultview 'Blvd); (2) 5 ft setback to allow a freestanding sign 0 ft from street right-of-way (Fifth 5t); and (3) 4 sq ft to allow a freestanding sign of 54 sq ft to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 355 S. Gulfview Blvd, L1oyd-White-Skinner Sub, lots 71 & 120, zoned CR 28 (Resort Commercial). SV 92-84- (1), (2) and (3) approved subject to the conditions (1) neither sign shall be permitted to increase in area and (2) the small restaurant sign on Coronado Dr shall be removed immediately. 7. Barger Interests (Peaches) for variances of (1) 1 3.2 sq ft to permit a total of 163.2 sq ft attached area slgnage (Enterprise Rd frontage); (2) 1 attached sign to permit 6 attached signs and of 3 wall signs to permit the 6 signs to be of the same type (US 19 frontage); and (3) 91.2 sq ft to permit 233.7 sq ft attached area signage (US '19 frontage) to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 26034 US Hwy 19, Darryl's Sub, Unplatted Lot 1, less road right-of-way, zoned CH (Highway Commercial). SV 92-94 - withdrawn. 8, Chevron USA, Ine (Chevron & Dunkin Donuts) for variances of (1) 1 freestanding sign to permit a total of 3 such signs; (2) 86.25 sq ft freestanding sign area to permit a total of 263.9 sq ft of such sign area; and (3) 6 ft in height to permit a 26 ft high freestanding sign to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 23988 US Hwy 19 N, Blackburnfs Sub, part of Lot 1, and part of vacated Barrett Rd. zoned CH (Highway Commercial), SV 92-95 - (1) approved as requested; (2) approved an area variance of 64 square feet to allow a total of 176 square feet where 112 sq ft is permitted; and (3) denied. ' 9, Ruth A. Davis, TRE/First National Bank CW, TR (Chain Wheel Drive, Inc) for a variance of 5 ft to permit a freestanding sign to be located 0 ft from side property line at 1805 Drew St, Skycrest Sub Unit No.4, Blk F, part of lot 3 and all of Lot 4, zoned CG (General Commercial). SV 92-96 - approved. . ., 1/24/94 2 ) f 10. John & Christina Stathas (Sandpiper Motel) for variances (1) of 12.5 sq ft to permit a total of 62.5 sq, ft freestanding signage area; {2~ of 5 ft to permit a freestanding sign to remain 0 ft from street right-of-way; (3) to permit a freestanding sign in Beach Commercial Zone without 15ft minimum building setback; (4) of 1 6 sq ft of attached sign area to permit a totol of 64 sq ft; and (5) to permit a roof mounted sign to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 400 East Shore Dr, Barbour-Morrow Sub, Blk B, Lots 12-14, zoned CB (Beach Commercial). SV 92-100 - (1), (4) and (5) denied; (2) and (3) approved as requested subject to the conditions (1) all signage shall be brought into compliance and the encroachment into the Poinsettia Ave right-of-way shall be eliminated within 15 months of the date of this public hearing. 11. Thomas E. & Barbara E. Soares (El Capitan Restaurant & Lounge, lnc) for variances of (1) .5 ft to permit a freestanding sign 4.5 ft from property line; and (2) 227.2 sq ft to permit , 291.2 sq ft in area of attached signage to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 2525 Gulf-to-Bay, Blvd, See 18-29-16, M&B 41 :04, zoned CG (General Commercial). SV 93-05 - (1) approved; (2) continued to 2/7/94. ' 12. lakeview Professional Village Condo Assn, Inc for a va'riance of two directory information' signs to permit two nonconforming signs to remain at 516 lakeview Rd, Lakeview Professional Village Condo. zoned IL (Limited Industrial). SV 93-28 - approved subject to the condition the signs shall be positioned in accordance with the site plan that accompanies the variance application. '13.. Burdines Real Estate Inc/Federated Dept Stores for variances of (1) 185 sq ft of attached signage to permit 335 sq ft of such signage on east building face; and (2)' 185 sq ft to permit 335 sq ft of attached signage on south building face to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 20505 US Hwy 19, 17.29-16, M&B 31.02, zoned CC (Commercial Center). SV 93 37 - (1) and (2) denied, 14. Wonderful Family USA, Inc (Forbidden City Restaurant) for variances of (1) 12ft in height to' permit a freestanding sign of 32 ft; (2~ 78 sq ft to permit a freestanding sign of 190 sq ft; (3) 2.3 sq ft to permit a directional sign of 6.3 sq ft; (4) 4 ft in distance to permit a freestanding sign 1 ft from south and east property lines; and (5) permit a directional sign with a logo/name that occupies more than 25% of sign area (1 sq ft) to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 25778 US Hwy 19 N, See 31-28~16, M&B 14.05, zoned CH (Highw'ay Commercial). SV 93-41 - (1), (2) and (4) continued to 2/7/94; (3) and (5) denied (entrance, sign). 15, Great Lakes Property, lnc (Cambridge Apartments) for variances of (1) 65.25 sq ftto permit 89.25 ft of freestanding signage area; (2) 18 ft in height to permit a 24 ft high sign; and' (3) 5 ft to permit a freestanding sign 0 ft from street right-of-way to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 21227 US Hwy 19 N, See 17-29-16, M&B 22.02: zoned , RM-24 (Multi-Family Residential). SV 93-61 - (1) approved; (2) approved 14 ft in height to allow a 20 ft high sign; (3) approved as requested subject to the conditions (1) a sign permit to modify the sign be obtained within 45 days of the date of this public hearing and (2) the sign be completed In accordance with the variances granted within 3 months of the date the sign permit is obtained. 1/24/94 3 , ' , , ,16. Fusco Corp & John S. Taylor, III (Sunshine Mall) for a variance of 4 ft in height to pennit a 24 ft freestanding sign to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 1200 S. Missouri Avo, , See 15-29-15, M&B 34.01 together with Sec 22-29-15, M&B 21.01,21.02 & 21.12f zoned' CC (Commercial Center). SV 93-62 - ,approved. 17. M. H. Corson, Jr. TRE {Howard Johnson) for variances of (1) 430.5 sq ft to permit a freestanding sign of 542.5 sq ft; (2) 28 ft in height to permit a freestanding sign of 48.5 ft in height; (3) 1 message panel to permit 3 message panels; (4) 4 ft in height to allow a freestanding sign of 24 ft; and (5) 15,26 sq ft to permit a freestanding' sign of 127.26 sq ft to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 20788 US Hwy 19 N, See 18-29-16, M&B 14.12 & 14,121 , zoned CH (Highway Commercial) SV 93-64 - (1) approved an area variance of 30 sq ft to permit a freestanding sign of 142 sq ft for the purpose of allowing two business names'to appear on the sign and subject to the condition the signs be brought into compliance within 90 days of the date of this public hearing: (2), (3), (4) and (5) denied, , " 18. Vlasta Stahle (Val's Fine Foods) for variances of (1) 37.2 sq ft to permit 101.2 sq ft of attached signage to remain; and (2) 3 attached signs to allow a total of 6 attached signs to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 1736 Drew St, Drew Terrace Sub, Lot 43, zoned CG (General Commercial) SV 93-76 - continued to 2/7/94~ 19. U-Haul Co West Coast Florida, Inc (U-HAUL) for variances of (1) 96.8 sq ft in area to permit a freestandin'g sign of 160.8 sq ft; (2) 11 ft in height to permit a freestandjng sign of 31 ft in height; (3) 5 message panels to permit 7 message panels; and (4) 21.4 sq ft in area , to 'permit 85.4 sq ft in area of attached signage to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 201 S. Missouri Ave, Hibiscus Gardens, Blk L, Lots 1-6, part of Lots 7, 11 & 12, zoned CG (General Commercial). SV 93-77 - continued to 2/7/94. , , ] " 20. First Florida Bank, N.A. (Barnett Bank) for variances of (1) 43.5 sq ft to permit a total of 67.5 sq ft of attached signage on the west elevation; and (2) 49,5 'sq ft to permit a total of 73.5' sq ft of attached signage on the east elevation to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 1499 Gulf-to-Bay Blvd, Boulevard Heights. Blk J. Lots 9-17 less road & Lots 21-23/ zoned OL (Limited Office), SV 93-96 - (1) and (2) approved subject to the condition no additional freestanding signs (other than directional signs) be erected on the property. 21 . Mas One Ltd Partnership lBarnett Bank) for variances of (1) 1 61 sq ft to permit a total of 270 sq ft of attached signage; and (2) .24 sq ft per ft of building width to permit a ratio of 1 .74 sq ft per ft of building width to permit nonconforming signage to remain at 600 Cleveland St, Clearwater Tower, Lots 1 & 2, zoned UC(C) (Urban Center lCore). SV 93-116- continued to 3/7/94. 22. Direction ra: reconsideration of Sign Variance cases SV 93-25 . Grandy's and SV 93.31 - Work America, Inc. - approved requests for reconsideration; scheduled for 317/94. 23. Agreement for renovation of Ice House (630 Drew Street) - accepted with changes. 24. Adjournment - 3:59 p.m. 1/24/94 4 t' " , , :", '. ' .. <' , , ' , , ; , , , "i, ,> ' r '. . / ~ i:/', 'It..'.' ,~ . : ~ ;. \ ...' "," l1V:!lIdl.! 1 tl:' ~a 'Zr&1J ill; I;l:!UU II:\HP~R ,l{\':-;ES QlUU:!i1102 , , HARPER, KYNESf GELLER, WATSON & BUFORDf P.A. 0 A MrOI1NEVSArCAw , f\ e.. -:. , ,~ CHAnLuA.8uFQno' , JACK J. GEllER" CLARK H. OnlitN1.E"""" J, BnUCEH~Pliq' ' C, A!..u!H KVllliS.Jr\. DumlSA. Pli)jJ.(IUON Ou-lNlllJ. W"lWIt AI.fflED E. F'l':m- O~ COUNSEl 'toMDUIlT,'IIID , CIY'-lJlIAl.LAW'l'11I .tl.LSO~'tO , I'W::T1ClIN toffll Ofll< .- AUlO AllUfTln)lD ~'IHCAlJ/>OIWA 2560 GULf To SA'!' DOUI.I:"VARU Suru 300 CI.EJ\RWAiER. FLORIDA :J4625 (613) 709.4840 T Ndfl^ DIRE.CT: 855-4058 . ,TELECOPlim: 797.6206 . . ~ ' OUR FILE (I , ' 4345/10756: , Janu6t'y 20, 1994 " " " SENT BY FACSIMILE 462.6486 Arm REGUUR U, S. HAIL , , , , . ' , , Clearwa~er City Commi~sion c/o , City Clerk O~PQrtmgnt P. q': Box 4748 Clenrwa7er, FL J46l0.4748 ,: '.. RE: HO~ACO MOTtt. VA~IANCE REOUEST (SV92.l...B) ',' Gentlemen: .-- Pursuant ,to my conversation with' Staff Assistant Holly Husan1o, this let~er is to withdraw the Monaco Mot~lvarianeG request numbQr SV92R4S. The original variance request was lnade,by'Ad.diso, Inc., the fox.-mer O\Yncrn of the Monsco Notal. Hy clients. the p1;liI$liInt o\~nor!i. Oi Domb,io. 1M, (ilk/a. PWDD Company) i recently ,cook title to chill propgrcy pursuant CD a foracloGuro Qction initiated ,by them ngains t the fo:r:mgr 0Wl10 rs; Addiso, Inc. ' . , Please withdraw thg v~riancD request and removo from the City' of Cl[lQrHa.co~. City Commission Public HlilOl.ring Agan<lD, this matter vhich was scheduled for January 24, ~9~4, begin~ing at 9:00 a.m. Thank you for your attention to chis ma~tcr. ,Very ~ruly yours, HARPER, ~YNES, GELLER, , WATSON & BUFORD, P.A. : (];1J1JJ.u' a. ;j JJ j!JUt ChOl.rlo~ A. Buford ~~ ~~~ Dictatad, by Mr. aufocd Slgi1ed In his absenco , to avoid deiay. , , ! ,I ! cc: Mr. John Di Domizio GAB:jnun pwdd.c756.d ., r~.~I~:>~':~ ,'.. l': ; , ~:.:...,.; I~:-i' \i. ;~ ~~ '.~':~: " .. " Clearwater ~ity Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item fI Meet Ing Dote: A . (h4(l{~ SUBJECT: ' Variance to the Sign Regulations; 648 Poinsettia Avenue; Addise, Inc./Monaco Motel (Owner! Applicant); Adrian Berrell (Representative). (SV 92-48) RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: (1) Approve a variance to permit only one of the two existing above roof signs to remain where above roof signs are prohibited, and approve the requested setback variance of 3.54 feet from the five foot setback requir'ement to allow a freestanding sign to be setback 1.46 feet from the Royal Way right-of- way on property identified as Sec. 05-29-15, Lots 16-20, inclusive of Blk. 84-A of Mandalay Unit #5 Replat for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approvall items (1) through (8l subject to the following' , conditions: 1) Only one of the two above roof signs shall be permitted to remain; 2) One above roof sign shaH be removed within 60 days from the date of this public hearing; 3) The remaining above roof sign shall meet the area requirements of the Land Development Code for attached signs; 4) the freestanding sign on Royal Way shaIl not be modified to increase the height or area of the existing sign; and 5) There shall be no freestanding signs permitted along the Poinsettia Avenue frontage of this property. (2) Deny the area variance of 45 square feet from 'the permitted 56 square feet to permit a total area of 101 square feet of attached signage on property identified as Sec. 05-29-15, Lots 16-20, inclusive of Blk. 84-A of Mandalay Unit #5 Replat for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(3), (5), (6L and (8). [J and that the appropriate offIcials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: This item was continued from the March Commission sign variance meeting to allow staff time to work with the applicant. The recommendation has been revised to reflect this review. The applicant is requesting the following variances: 1) A variance to permit two above roof signs where roof and above roof signs are prohibited; 2) An area variance of 45 square feet from the permitted 56 square feet to permit a total area of 101 square feet of attached signage'; and 3) A setback variance of 3.54 feet from the five foot'setback requirement to allow a freestanding sign to be setback 1.46 feet from the Royal Way right-ot-way. Jlnllwed by: Legal Budget Purchasing Risk Hgmt. CIS ACM Other N/A N/A N/A N/A ~f... tJ/A Origlnlllng Dlpt: CENTRAL PERMITTING 5 COil.: Total Commiulon Action: o Approved o Approved w/conditions o Denied o Continued to: u.., Dapl: Current fiscal Yr. Ad verlfud; Date: Poper:TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Requi red AIf~tlld Plnl.. o Noti fied o Nor Requi reel Funding SDuru: o Capitol Ill'(>. o Operllr i n9 o Other A lIac hlnanl.: APPLICATION VARIANCE YORKSHEET MAPS o None s"'mlll",~f tc~ City Hnnager App,oprla\ion Cod.: .-. ~~ Printed on recycled pnpcr SV 92-48 Page 2 The property is the site of the Monaco Motel which has two existing nonconforming above roof signs and an existing freestanding sign that does not meet setback requirements. The above-roof signs, attached to the structural walls, are unique to the architecture of the building. A nonconforming freestanding sign is located on the south property line along the Royal Way street frontage. The subject property is located on the west side of Poinsettia Avenue, north of Royal Way. The property is in the Resort Commercial "Twenty Four" (CR 24) zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. Sign,' I 'Sign 2 Information Existing Permitted , Existing Permitted Attached Yes Attached Yes Type of Sign ---------------------- ---------------- ---_.--------------- ------------- Above roof No Above roof No Area 51 square feet 56 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. *0 sq. ft. Setback Not applicable for Not Not applicable Not attached signs applicable Applicable Height Not applicable Not Not applicable Not applicable Applicable *The total square footage permitted for attached signage is 56 square feet. The permitted total square footage of attached signage is represented in the "Permitted" column under sign 1. Above roof signs are no longer permitted. I Sign 3 l Information I Existing Permitted I Type of Sign Freestanding Yes Location{orientation of sign Royal Way Yes Area 35 square feet 50 square feet Setback 1.46 feet 5 feet Height 1 2 feet 20 feet Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: The now sign ordinance is being uniformly applied to all signs in this zoning district. Whilo the sign aosthetics aro in character with the surrounding area, the total area nnd number of above roof signs is extreme and not considered minimal. Signs are permittod to be attnched to pampet walls rind mansards, but a parapet wall or mansards is an integral part of tho structure facado, as opposed to an above roof sign which extends nbove tho level of tho roof and is not part of tho focado. SV 92-48 Page 3 The applicant has provided evidence of hardship created for the Royal Way freestanding sign due to the limited area between the existing right-of-way and the structure. SURROUNDING lAND USES Direction ~ Existing land Uses North South East West Residential Apartments GTE Exchange Residential Apartments Vacant lots The existence of two above roof signs with a total area of 101 square feet is not in character with the signage permitted for the surrounding commercial areas. Because of the unique nature of the structure design and the area of the attached signage, staff considers allowing one of the above roof signs acceptable. Applicable Variance Standards To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's requests for the area variance of attached signage meets only two of the standards. In particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully met: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of tho provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. ' (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital" 2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. ,(6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (H) The granting of tho variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this , development code. o c , , , ' I, ~ , ., 0 , ' . i " , .. . ',. t ~ , ' " o c f'~l' : .' : .~. ~. . .. ",', , , ' '.. . SV 92.48 , Pago,4 . Relevant Previous Decisions bY,the Commission:' None pertaining to roof signs. . . CASE #, ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING DATE REQUESTED/ ACTI ON Setback t5 0 11/21/91 ft) 1 A roved Setback (3.75 2/09/93 ft.) I Approved .0 SV 91-22- 1874 Gulf-to-Bay Blvd. SV 92-71 351 Gulfview Blvd. SV 92~88 1 000 S. Myrtle Capt. John's Hairst les Julie's ,Seafood & Sunsets Rain Thatch Setback' (2.5 ft)/A roved 2/23/93 , . , I f\1I of the variances cases cited abov,e had demonstrated physical, topographical conditions creating a hardship. This case (SV 92-48) has not demonstrated any such hardship. , , . ' , , ,0 I' " ) , , , , . ' , , ,0 . ~ ~ ~ ~ c.::l U Z < ~ ;> '. ' y: Z is z Ii: It < !r. ': .. .;1!c, ,~ .: :; I ;; ~'.. ~ kt of: .: UIJ':! .s -= :: ~ E .: ~ ~, : .- ~lJ~ 't !! e.i II. I~ n ~ i._, ,~ ~ ::: 1f..[I. it fi';~ .: is -= i= ] ~ ~ ~. -::I: C .s'" . n1:: 7. .. - ""] ~ "..:: ~ :; .~ 't C E n ~ <:: '5'~ ~ ~ E g :1 r:: ... U .. t." ] .~ ! 1r ~ f, . .. . ~ .. ~] ~ 1~ r: c c::: .[L 8 .. !! ~-5 ~ ~ ~ - - e J:I=. ~ /~ 0..... ':; !f II .~ ~ .. 1 u !i ;; oJ < > c ~ tl ~ " < > l( e ,I:. 'i , 'r: .. ... \0 C 0 R.~~~ ~ ~.~ ~ ; -5 ~~u;~ !' _5 ~ k W Ii 1: .-- a g. ~ ~ ': .~ 'j! .. ~ e ~ ::I .J:: U t U~ ":ttl",,: UIII' - .b A ,.:.. '-3 c ,!f:= 1'0. /;l - .en-a;> J .r t.:: t' eE:; n~ _ n a 'c '::\ l ~, ..., I: ;. 0: I' ~,!i ... i.ll C !. - &.f n ~ E ~..c !5~t_ ~ t-~a nJ:1': .,. .C .C ~ ." - II tl = !:! 'E tS 'i g. E - ... n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ::... ..., '"" n L"::: .. ... "E. -- ~ = ""' - " r; i1 .-. "C 'S ii ~ ii, to .. - F= L - ~ g -a ii: < c Z < ~ .: ':! n n 'c 'C &E l! .. 1'1 ::. t .... ~ ~.~ B t~ ~ i'i .. t.i..: E.';' ft ~ =- ""'-: i ~~' 'g~ "le .~ ~j ,~ ~ ~ ,6 i jf.~ ~E,g .~n ~ f~ E ?113 '~~Ii ~Ji~ OJ ,!e 'c ~ ~ i ,2 -t - t g ":: u ,~ riO::: ,~ '0 ..." , E,.i ,a It 't- -e. ~ e _ .. r.. n a IJ '" l' ..: .; .ff'a == .", a'~ ... '- ~ n 11I;- ~~3 = c: c - n n ~t:' ~ .g :;- n c.. t ,~ .:; ~==- ;.: :.~ .. ... 41:" .g ~ i_ t: E _ It.: i. .. ~; .. ,~ ~ ::; ~.: - a = ..I; n ,~ .: 11 '" .5 ] t.. ~ = n ~ ~ E' li ~ ~ t'.: _ ~ 'E 1= :..._5::_ ~ . :: ~ :~_:_' ~.~ to f "2 -= t ;: ." ;::~ C C ... ... ..:; I~ .~ ~ \. c t ~ .~ III[E c c ~ '" .g E ,~ E "" ;; '- rw c: ... c = '- " e ;j .,1_ t.i ... :; = .:: oS ',g ! ~ ~:: '" " .. -= C I: i: ~ : ! ~i~~ ,~~ ~ :,g ~ : ~ ~ tJ ~ ~ J ~ ~ .~ :::'c ~ B OJ .~= ~~ .. .. Jl ;; l:'.!! :Jon ~ g ~ E " .. ;; Ob ~'7 -: -1'1 .= 5~ t ~ ~ t a !: - ~ l:'" n t ;: ~~ = I .., , ] :~ 'g ~ .E ~ L .. ~ ~, ~ " 'I: .- .. .. - ~"E 1= t: ~ otj n .. c ~ n c.. !f ?, 'C n .. L. ~ ~ i! ., ~ :< ;., 1:. = ii .. ~ ~ ~ ;; ~ f' ..' OJ r- ii .\1 ~ ;; .! '- c. ... ,= r'.i ~ ~ )roo h rei g c '[: E. '; .s .. 1! ~ - E .~ .. 0; !f .. .~ :a ".= '" :; :tE ~ ~ ~ ~ c:;: .. ,., OJ .. 1= g :!:- .. !: t c .- ~~. S _ r.. s -:: E ~,\ .f li - ; c. r: t_ ; "C ~ ~ 'E ~ _ ~ t c en:: - c"......~ ~ ".~..::. ~ .:.~ ~ E C ~ n 1.. u. = E a ., E n ~ - .= - -... ..~ ~ ~ ~ ;:: ..: '" .~ -; ~ c .~ - .: ~ E "~ ~~~.. .... ... = :g j ~~ 2 e_ " ~.!: "I'~ ...- ;... '.... ~.;t.a~ OJ .., ~ .; ~ :: € \. - g t~ ~.~ :: 1bf:5: F .g ~)'c .. ~ =. , ~a; co - :!: ~ - ,~ .. :-, ;: !t co E. n ~ IE ~ .E - - ~I~ C;"';' 'C . ~ ~ "S ~i .- - ~. - :t , .~ OJ .. ... = - "C ,- . :: ""- .. ~ ~ " '~ e I'~ t ~~ C l'~ :. . r= t: r- ? G ~ l .. '-- .g S !: f ~ r: .. ,_ n ~ ~=:_= ~ t 5 t ~ .~ n ..." c: &J.s ... <:: ~ '" ;: '; ~ t - ;:; t; C if n .: ... !; os ~ .. .:: ~ ?"- r:. ." ~~ "~ r: r; ~ ~ ~ ~ ;. c r: '~i ~ i_= ~::-cc t.: t ~ ~cr:~ s.~ E ~ ~~ :; ~ ~ r; :: ....... ... w i ~ .!_5__ ~ ~ r; !: ...."'C &,/u ~ Ii ,_ '- - .. .. .. .. 1::- "" .6,= e C"a ~ ~ _ :: CI. "- g - ,,'f'! '- C "C c..: o LJ I!.I a J.o.o'" ..... .. =-- - .... Q ;-'c~-= :; u 5.~ !i ~ := t::: ~ E '-:' Jl ..., r. w: - " !i Ii ...: ~~] ~ .. ~ ~-', 'F. _ ~ a ~= .;:: ~ ~ :: _ : t> - f! ,E . :: ~ g' ~ ,to ~ - a ~ ~ ii 'C i:. c '- :: E \,I';.. __~ r:.~ ~ - ... ...... ;..." -=~~~_:~ ~g~ "': r:.: 5.. a a = .. u ~ r:~ ~ t OJ i'~ ;: = ~~ 00'; t ;. .1 .: ~ ;; 'C " .. .. -= ~ a ~ .S ]: c .. s .., .. " ~ " III~ n ~ ;; .~ ~ \0 ... i:: c >. ~ ... ~ ;: ] ~ c.. ~. = h' ~ -a .... - r:; = .... = ;; - ~ 5 .. OJ ..!:...= n~ OJ - .. " ... :: ~ T :: i:: e .~ :.0 ~ OJ :L =: E .a 'C .; " .. .. :: ... " ',:: t t- g ~ .... n +!_ t f ~ .= .. ~ ~ =- ;: n ~ .E ,~ i_ 1: \: . "; '~.:__' t a ~ ~-! ~ g - "".C c; ... .r: : Ii.i'; n ~..,gt~ 'C t ~ " ~ ~ .v, r; .!:' ~ L~ LJ=~ ; ~ III "..: .. --~ ... f :. '= 0':: .~' ~ ~':~.s .;- t '=_ ~ ~.~ ! =a:;c ~~;;~ ~ CI Q. ::. -= .... ~ tlt~ ~"B -E ~ ~.ECa .. :: o'C &l' \0 r. _ \0, c.. ~ '- .. .~ ;; 'C ... 1! =- ;: to( .a <J ~ '" ,,.. ~ E 'i OJ !:1 a '!: ;: 0. ~ '= c ~l ~ r. _ u.;; c.. ~ t=~ ., €'.,g " r: ': -t s .. .. '., g ;'\ "" . '" ... " , ' " L" . , " . , I ReceiDt I: '_'""- -:.-:--. -::: C-J ...,.., :,.- - <t rs-, R€'Al)Y'. ;t> S-.:= - or PROPERTY OWNER'S) NAME &. ADDRESS: VAHIANCr. f,"r'Ur':f,TIDr-t \'~ " I lU;pnCSrPiTATTVEISIIH nnyl NAME &. ADDRESS: -A'~1l'0~ ~Gr~... (p~ I beJVT ") (-:.Ci5 ~C.\("'...}O=rr,~, !k:Jc CLe.t1Gw~l WGAC-H, Ft.. ;1, 4. b?;, 0 , - ' " T 'I' ' ..... "\ - II!" 1/....1 Iibb/6e. 0c:... .~ij:I!''''- bc:....i1.d.:'-1, 1 l,t:"/lr. I,: u,Lo- <3 4)01'.) ~C'l'l{ PI Hue. . :~ CLef'orl\.W A T2nL- De fY:-H F t- ':!:, 4-b ~ 0 TELEPHONE: 151')} 44';' b~~~ I TELEPHONE: rc?G I L.'J i ,ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: b u. S ZONtNG DISTRICT: i ::L.... J I' ~ .' 9.' 1'" LAND USE CLASSIACATSON: L\\"':'" LAND AREA:2.b16SG~ III . ii 'C:>wc...lf ~ Lr ,r ( f1J\.JbPrL A)! J.6 '-C,;; OF THoLJ ,::.,l\..uJ . . LEGAL OESCRlmON OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: P~MSI" VN1\ /Vr:>,> S - 6GG SHt::cT' PARCEl NUMBER: I i I I I is available irom your tax receiPt or contact PincllDs Co, PropertY Appraiser's Office, at, 462-3207, parcel number. anach B % x " Inch sheet! IThis informlJtio' If more than on " DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF rflOPERTY: North: ~rD5'\J'1 A-L A-PPT ~ South: G---;z3" E 'KCnI!,NC.,;. Eust: l2.esloe:^_iTlPtL. ~P'rS. ~ UtkAAJi L-o"6 r R/H'L. non....-rc. I West: VARlANCE(S) REOUEST: Poa... To -( vU 0 t::::... k.s I ~J\l AJ (- f2.e/Vj A IV S/r.-IJ c..., e,~:. ~-oCl::;' , ,/-:"1 dl.l~ . , , \. \\ \:~ I'j,_ .. , \~ \ " Ce. \~J' ~17/7tA ~A. , I J ( 1f1t?f' S.JA/?cll'; 'I SIC, AI ~ < '. ' _3) }I ClI~lIq 11 cy_ (\ '1-; . ~' 12 UTe) pc y I}0-T J' ~'- u ~ ')p .;. bLC Ie -f':ec.0 ~~ PI1Jpel....Jl{ II~ ,~. S c ~ A.I'-AC.I-I~' D /16 , . REASON FOR REQUESTING VAIUANCF.ISI: mufer to Swndard!.l for Approval. next pVyc) I.) Vn (I(Af) Ceo.{. 2. o_bDlk (eJ (".)-1- (, . ~. . I ~ t ~ . ~ 4..... ., :~> ....... -::. o oj .5 -~ .- --r'::- or- /1 A '-.~ -'Ji. -''-- c.:..c . ~t:_ r:"C roO ~'\ ,- :'J ...'~.... L ' _ _ .1...-.:........___._,~ .. '- .- ~._____~_'t" __...._L......___..~1'__...~ ___..___,........._.____ ,....., ~~..."'~~l~...~1.. ...___... v-- __t...."'... ............__'11+.._ _.-'....~~1'7 ...--.__.__...-..-_ ....____.....-...._........._.....~.i.....'~ >- - "'................,.~~.........____._-...___ , I r.cwmww ml n!:vt:llr.;~ &101: .' ST~NDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance shall 'not be granted by the De\lelopment.Code' Adjuument 'Board unless the IlP~licatjon and evidence presented clearly support the following conclusion,: , ' 11 I The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property In 'Question end is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by bn bction or IIcHons of the property owner. predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made In the execution of II building permit or work performed withciut the benefit of 0 permit sholl not be considered to be sltuetions whiCh support the orllOting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shope or topographical conditions of the property involved zmd the strict application of the provisions o~ this development code would result in ,m unnecessery hardship upon the applicant. 13) The vnriance is the minimum necessary to uvercome the unnecessary hard.hlp referred to In preceding recital PZ" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land, '(41 The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure D greater financial return from the prope rty. IS) The Oranting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or Improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. 161 The grantIng of the variance will not imp;!ir ;:m adcquotc supply of liQht or ventilation to adjilccnt property,' detract from the, appearance of the community, substantIally increase the congestion In the public streets~ increase the danger of fire. endanger the public safety it. any way. or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. ' , 171 The variance desired will not adversely aHeet the public henlth, safetY, order convenience, oroeneral welfare of the community, (81 The granting of the variance desired will not violate the oeneral spirit and intent o'f this development code. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): 'l /, ;VJ...{J2F " I , ' f Before m~, the undersipned authority, personally appeared =-. deposes and states the matters and facts set out above are true and correct to the best of his~her knowledge end belief.. - (D5^-T liODISE ()...)C AQ(..o. '"' Da.~J:r\ \ Sworn to and subscribed before me this '/ " /11 T?-!- day of C )C W (sC-y( : A.D., 19 q7 , _...~ \ A CS ('""', r c--- ""_ c:::_~- . .._~t-4,- . Notary Public ' lQ1AAr Jll1BLlC ST~n: cr rLORm1. tN C'CHfISSltni EX? Atxi.17.l!l!l5 torDtO nliW Gt!1I:1W. INS. 111>1:. I' ' RI'Y, 12/91 ,\" 1 \ ': I ': ~ , , " " } I.', ,I .~. ~. , 1.1', " \ . lIt. " I' " , < .~ , ' " , . " .' :,~ , , " ~ ~ ....~.1.t.~'~,..~: '.".... , . ..1. " : i.:~ . .r/" " :.' I ~ , " . :'i' , ! " ,'t-1 :' ~. ! . ,. " .. , ,A D D' I I I 0 ,../ I~ L , ~ .. .. . VA.r2II~ r-.J,'-G ;'e~~J\-/'~1 T " \ , I " , , 7 " " . ., . ~,' " .... ,~ '! ,'!.... I 5 " , \ 'J " '. I, " , 't t' , ' 'i .. ',' . ~ ~ . . , ,.. '. . 'J j" .. " .,' .. " . . . ~ ~ ,j ,I ,". ' ,,'PU.'5 · " : '.. " "'OiL ,:)1 " 8 ,I _ ...___-t.._.........-..._~.___I.... . . '> c,' ;~_.. " . ...,..........__a___a___ Ro'fp t-, '~'f " ',' J: ., k 101_?,,'/-:z.Y )>., ,'- ~-pg6P- ~- , L-INc! I' ' T.! '. T',,", _______ _ __.~ ......p I. ~ '6.t("Ji_.L~,?tl.~1.0~_~eL~ T I L.> ~ T6 SOU"f L.{.. ? eo l' \ L I tj 5 " I "'"'---:---- -.- -- -..... -- -- , .... ------- ',' " " ,.' '$ , -_.-A_YAf,!.'A-r-I~_O r-:._l..1_Z_I.'S-,-_ T.o___f'C::::~p'_' r _." H,_I_~.tl_.._,_'..~_, 17. s II Ft'-otA-. S;flLoS~r. .. . . ',- ' .......,-...-- ,.-.,.v-".__~__.".' . ..........__., _ ..a_~ ___..~ ~;i>;-c~-;: . '.----------. " , , , _.. .'-'4.__._ .__.._________.__.________.~ ___~--- .._.____ .~.- -;-. _w'_ a -<. -. _. _ _. __"._~.. -~..l-~.... 4.... _'..~................ l' : + ~ . -i7" , " " '. ,. - I , I . I , \ c' ., " ,'-'J. I.' " ., . . , ,', , , . I~. ~. " ' " " , , C !" .' " " .~- . . . . I r; Ii! . , " Of'.... 1'1 . J(:t,p. ","~ ',' .1:;1, '?Z' '1" ":<, ..'..,:"."1;\ r. :t'~r;jj ~.>>\'>>, 'I . . "~ ,',..."'..<\1'1'; !il'I.;lij :."..'.::'...."":.., "j' >,' . '~l ", . I .; ..": -..,>... ...~............' '., ~ "'. ~ " , II, ,.." 'f"""~ ,............. I . I , " '. ';", 'l ;:' It 1\ '.'" "'.!". ,,' . "\ '.... " ...,,, \.: ';:' I j' " . .>; ",', I I . .. 1".0 "\,,. ... ~... I....~. I - . .... :, = I ; :: t I '. . ~', " .... ", , I', ...... '/~' " .." '" ..... I ~..' ..'.. '. J':'" ;!'~~.""'."....' ", 'I 'L" , . ' ," .1/.. ..jl' . .,., 'J \ ..~........ '" + <.... . ..' , .:...- -'.-:. - I . I:: ;;'::-' .' "~'.s;:, I . ."j:1 \.~t~t:t"n.. .. . .' . h;~r ~'L1H.~.~ilim'lw: . 'II. "c.. ,....:.--.----- -' - -'. · :... -- -~ - - ---\ ., 0. ,'. ..., t'\ .,....--1-. ..~. "", "...$ t. ". ....,;r t..., ~ I ..." " '~' . ",' , 111" " '...." '" .1 t~, '~<\,,: ".:-< "'~'<l'.! '\:......, .....:.~.. ...., '...'....... > ,~.......: "", '\. "...... .... I'''''' '.. .... ~ 'I- . 'II,.., '" ~ ,': ':'," ..,.',>...:-- "..(... ....... '... .\~ ',"',', '... ',~ ., ." t,." ", .... '11' ..... '. '" ...',',,,...... '.. '- '.'~ ...... I . 10. '", "..~ "'~, ' ....., ~~ .... "" ~, .. ,..... .... ...., PI'. ., '" ..... '", ~ . "'..... " , . "' " .... '. ~." . "' . . '\ HrIHfrm!II'I!I:li'!!illjl'lihiltL~i~'it!;!.:~:~I'I>d;10I'1~ ;-' 'il,:I: WI ':" ~,~!U ,- -1.l-1.:~!!b~' ~~tD I \ 'i'l'll'\ 1'/1" : ;'1 ":.,... ". ,~. ~ . tr'. t' .. ~_ ___0.... ',"Ht, ~ ~ I". \ .. I~~. I - J 'I ",I " 'I ' " , I & l~I'i';~I';Jt!i~ill"" , ' ~ -;: :'~tl!:il-i++l;,.L- ~. '.' '\ .- ..:€ \ ~ L' "\'l"';"II' "11' .10' ~ ~ I tf . , " II ' ':. ' Q I !l'~\:.lld;: '1, OJ ~ ~ ~ I I ~.:.: j; U . t: [' ~j t.... I .. ~ ." II ..,~ Iq,:. 11;-,\ '; I,' ~ . " , rH' ':...p.'" 11 ~ I" tl..; ~. 1;!'1E~:::\11~! ijl.j.,...f I ' Ii I'';].' :1,11' : '!:b.' , . ~ ' .rll~in!hm') ;1,1: ~i;.l-Id;'!i;.-I'J i;':l'~l; ~:~i;l~!:~lrD#'s. ~ ,I I:'I';!I i.1 : ! I iill:;"II: 11'I~r !:! .:[,:;,!!: It, '1 ~ ~ll:~T,l 1:\ :d;' il! !jil-Y:I ~dh,:;'P:!IHtli:!: :'1: I. ~~::'t . ~IJE: ,~:; ,!' Lq: . ! ~ .:tl'.t~ f t )~~;'jt ~', ~. ~ Ii t!ll : t1,.. Cfl~"d' ,. -;1.1 .dt ..~j ",~" i ~l';.s . 'll \t :! I !. t t p II: !! \ .' l.' 1 :. ; t I ,\ 1 ~ j, ~ i ~ I ~ 5' 11 f. ... I ~ . - -1.1'1.:..:.:. '~l' ,..),,1--'1':";' ".......1,1.. ",,: J-1 - , ~..~r.r: .tilll > !. ,'; ':;~:." ~ 1'1 ,:~t . 't . . I -' ." - , .. " " '~I' ' ,1-,., ' '':;~'' I ~,. I '"" . c "" "" <,.,'......, .... .. ',.,:,'\....., '.",: II '. '..........~.., .......,., l.>,....>.':..:'~:,.."....~".... 'ill;\: .'.....'.L"~' "', '\.": ". I"..... '.....' " . . II " '.... ".''''l' I'll'. ..'. ". ", ..'....... 21'11'[" ", ':. ~ ", '.... ~l ", .. ., '., [.. ....,1......,., . "'It" .......... ~. ...... ~ . .. . . ,'" ,', ........... 't' .'"> \.... ~I :. 'fL ..... ,.' .....~. "\. \. . ,,' . .' l.1. I' ... . ~ I .' .. - __.u_=-:. ~"---:-::.. .H'_. ... I' ..,.. .... ' 'I' r- -.-;-- ;, .:. ';~':;'.';-:. . r.::: - - -1 . r..!. ....... ~ : " ,'-1 .. - ., 1'....1 ~' .il ~ t\'-=-=-'-=-'-.J, 'I' ,I. 'J ; "7 r . ';.:'" , -U' ~ fl. I 1" ,1: . . :1- · i" ~, , '. ~ I" . ': t~; f: ,:r 11 . ]; ~ . <,I :, ......:;. l:>,,~..~><.!:t~-r':-" ':~I' ~< ,~l,"" \1) "h"'l. , ",", 1 ' :':., ;. I" "','. ~ '. ','.~ ~I t ,<' "", ~ ,::. .,~t .:.:,. '.i~'" :.~~< :} ~l~"'.'\.J Ie' I' '!. ~, , /. ' ' ,~'t\. u'1/ ~ ,{ :1 ,..~ l"'" ~.oJ t1S ',t'OI I , ,/.~.' ~ ~''';1-' . 'j' . .J. "I ~ ~ .~...: . ' ! ..... '.... ,l';~~ - . --'-, I ,I I I I l I' ,,' , '" , , " l' , ,1. . ... . ...... . ~ ~ ,<.. __r ~ . I I 1 I 1 --"l '. '1 , I '1 I I . , I ' ~: , ' '/~ .~ : ;Ii " " , ,)., ';'1 ; c, , , . I , ' I" " ., I. .' _I , " 1 '1./ . '. ..'- -I~ . ~ .... ( <I) {).:1 '':~'' , , t l.<o)"U' ':<31 'i . I I I I , \ '1 . ,:::;::J " ':J .j' --.--- . , ' " _II ~rl ""q1" "'... & - ~~ f' I 'f ""' ~ , i ;1 I I I . j I I ~~ll ,-L '+. 'J -;- .. -.0 '..J i , ' ~ ;:. ,~:v, " , IJ-. l-J) . '1.. . ' e:"j. .~ ') '.j. :1 :;, ~ l"j Ij"'J~ ' v) ~ - I ~ 'I ~, :1 ~. J II I 1.:1:t: ? j~ , l.V .1 ~ :::;:. .... ... I. ' ~ '.!:J ..... .... .... . . IU v-.I,J) J.. oX 'j e -~ ,1 4: 'u 1 ~ -:. ~~. ~ ,~ 1'~ \..bJ \ ~J V)J:?- t, u) "~ ! <:> I .~ ~L , 11 , Q ~ ~I '! I I I I , "r, I "'~JJ . ,)..... ......... ( t - , \ J \ ,... . .....-:-:: ~ I' f "I . , , , " I .l. I' I . '. . " . '. " " , .~ ',', .' : ' , ,'.. '. :",,'; ". J." '. , .' ~e4O!tt . '. ,. . !~ . " ". ..1i.r:' . '~.. t ' :> ',}. , .". ?~:.t.: ~~:~, . ;';'''r" ".t... . . "::~.; <'~". I, ~~; ~ ~ ~ J ::.; . .. ~ ,~ , ,~"'" '." . ,I. ~~~"'{~"'J'r'.~' . ... t. ,,~.. ~" " .' ~ 1 ~'.. . .' , ' .. ,,;. I '" ,. ,.. ,~. .I.J' . t :' :.: !'~~':V . . I ~ ~ i .'! l .1 1 < ': ".':' " ADRIAN & DENISE BERRELL The Pearl of the Friendly Mote/lApis, 648 Poinsettia Ave., Clearwater Beach, Florida 34630 Heated Pool · Phone In Rooms · Color Cable TV All Rooms Have Heal and Air CondItioning Phone (813) 443-6954 · Fax (813) 442.5304 ., . r ' . '.~" ~ct~be~ 14 ;99:' " , . ~l~~') .i.'-c:\'~ilm ic)!" !;.,l~lli '.'i1,'J.:W(:!:' i Or' ,.jun .lIe c;l 1'1,:; 4,; !;,.: ~ 642 r:oir'l~C't'..i,;:. (\~.~ :::' J f..i.....\..,;;,. t~q" D/:;.',;;\cll' r ~ ::JI' i d ~\ ~:A,,::,(' , . . ." ~ I . ..". :,:. . r, . . ~'.1'.; ~ :;' ~ <I: ~.'~': , , . . .:: :::i':~' I I ' , , ...' . t~~:;, , '7I1Q'!,,\c-t.u~1 fib'Llr~t\,tt"'" tl";r.d, 1:hi? r-,;i.r;ll1=: ~l1""0 ~rl. ..,,"'e' t'lbt:N~' 1'(,10,;)'( . 1 e,,/~'l !\ 110 h ,~\.... ,? th?H:ri r~, i. rH.,(! t f-: e p I~C:'P ~'I" i:y' \ :,;-,~. b:"I i 1 '\; i 1'1 '1955. Th~t'E.' NL~fi, LH..'f,m rt' t:.19'1 em' tl-,an f;,lrll::'" tilE!.' e.::;I']y' r?CI(1 '=-~ L r. .nlJl;~f:Fr,clI:'wJI8n thl.? o,.'t:>Pl?j'l:y \'J,-:\E L"uilt.I..t"-? 'I'~el I;Ju:lt if th~ S',it;lns hcd '!;r.. l.UIlIE.: c'~'f 1:hj:;;''=:~''::'c\,i.II''C:' n; ....'~'u.ld'l')cJK ~;::l;rr.i,t:ly 811 d;: :;1; i c I;, ~IU I', 1.i!:. ~:. So :Sl,r e Lh 1~";IJ.:i. '; :: I.'~:;r~:.' J. ' I , , , , !>Ie hcl....... on J'y t;.\l,ll'lerJ t I 18 t"IOI'~CO' f oi- 1 n IIICHlt/\!: and h.=,v't:.. str-uggl'ed' sQVerely f"nl.V'lc\~l,ly -dur-lr,,;. t!"::.'Yo tinltl.' H~ i:.\;\ e,c.rort. " lo' rr;t'd h la\ 1,\ ,ti Ii!.' up kG:!::;) .i\nd "IPPE ::'l("tlln (e of th~..' propt:'t'ty. t!.ruJ 'rE, 'have .SltCCG'e~ed, ...,.:.. '('I' Urd Qf" tlCna'\ e.l y we aY'e Iii:'..: UlliJl:'\:' t h \";:;':\-1;. o'f -;' i.Jr:;~c 1 C1~\..tr'~ 1>v. "'c ....,e. f8~1,we hbve groun~~ for compl~{nt ~ealn~t the p~evio~~ (:\wn~r'':'i '~~ith 1~~'Qo:\\"d '1: \:1 '/'i';;'lwm'::.; ~r,d F.\:~t!' i': ;ch'~in~' ou~ 1\';,\)1 'through j t, Hope fl.t 1 t,y lMe ,stud I C:OII!Q. .tt"'l'f'O'ugh t\'1 [s 5\.AC ce5'sf u lly ahd;proceGd ve~y wel~ l~to the f~1ure. " ' If!.... WG- havC!- .1:0 rQlTlOve t.he 61gns '-'Ie 'ShAl J J\l5'~ b lelld 'i,,~oi.h~ pdvqte. dwell i.ngf3 around us AL1d V\O-OI1Q dl"l.lIilOca V.f1, Poit'l$'e~t.iA. A V e.. '" i ] I, r ea.1 n:.:-€.:- t n Z\ 1. I.il.e. n f"e a. Hot e 1 . ' \J e. feQ 1 'th a-t: t}.e. ~ I QI1 S' Q roe.. r1lT~ a L: ,I c:. 'i::::~r1 ~ I b,' .1. .;,Il'i d 5:t.:. :::\::' 1-" :'1['1 d .;,',:'S" ir:'Jc:c~r o.,rl' Q,,;rem:e~>, p,of.....'I.I\,.- p,ho1.o "'~jecf; W',Hh nves{s . IJ C 5t6l:)d \>enSQt~ thel/'oo\ 10 '.sh~ '~.ieock '11 bad: horae l' " . .,( .;4;; : " r > " " ,. ,j' . " , i ,., . " , f., . , . . .' I .'''';''' It',. I. I. . :~ \ "i - -1- _,_ _ _ =1= =:~- -;=:::=::::::::' , -,- -1 1_'_'_"_._.__ -.- _I........ _:_t_l_t_I_:_I~. . :F= ~ '-, =~=l=~=.[=;=~=:~ . ~1~~-... ;~'-l-\.:':",J- -,-:_>'\' "~=I=~ :=!=J='=I=I=I=j'~ ""'; .~;; ~ '_:~J.~j~l;;~:~;~:; :~ =1= ::: 1=;=:=1=\=1=!=1:~ {it .. =L-:' -. ='='=~=~=~=i=l':'.:t -= I ~I =+ ::=i=~=~=~ =r:(.. _I_l_~~_' -'-1-1-- -1-" -t-'_I_. -.-1- -.-~_ =:=~=\=:=~ _:=~=~=I-l =i'::~=I:. ::;.:~ = =1 r" ~.. I ~ ~ . I . " ~: I " "..1 ~'..." ~..,.-, _. I .... "' ~"!. " , , -\ ) ...~:.~"~~:,~~~~.;)::.,:':~:~.:...,, . ,'<.'.;'- ..'. ...;~-:-:~... _c_ .T.._.....__, .' _ , . ........ ~ :.' .":-I"~'.. .. ....: '~'.'_-:::: :::~::: :::~.~::!:::<<:~ :~._',....~~a.'t'.~;'''~ -"o'.,,: C": ~ .',"':: '~.::7=-:;.~;:.:: . ..~ < U. -........ ~...... 1"'_~ /'~::-:~~;':~!i'.';,~ ....:>:.: ' .. ....' ~:~\~;..::c::..::.;<'f~7:;:'~:i~~-;';:'.:~~~;~i~i::;' :7:'~~~'~~1'"'::::~\~.~",: r.. U._", I~: > :'\':~'r:-:.~".:" ~~ ....r. 10~7' ~~:::-:;;;':::~~_.:-;~~~ . . ~~~;~i~;..~0~~;~~:;'. . ~'. -..! .~. .:..:~~.~~~~:;:~~;; ~.~ . ~ ~ .~., ~. : ~:~ ~~~-T~:~JI~t~ ",' .,....... '." . c . __ __ "h... . .~~::.~::.::.:::..:-~.. ~ - ..~~:f~ ~.:'!~..: . ;. ._>..' .~::t~-"J ..... ........ .::'...a:..:'~~;.~~~j.~..;;.".:' ...._....::...: ~...~~?::.~_'~" ..._... I ..~. ": ~'...~:..: - . .~, .. :::. , '. , ' _t...-. J \ ' \ '! , ~i. ~- '..:.:..,; , (,"'-.,.1 ~ Q ~ ...-:....., ~.- ~' ~-<... '--- ~ I~~'.'..,~ ~ . ~>~~ 4[ f~ ,"T ~JSl .... IT- .. _ _T' , _. . _i \....1 l_ I .C) " \;~ '( - ..:. \ ~ ~! '-~ . > , '. ' J ;'". . . . . . , I ./--.-.....'.. --:..-.;-- --- . ' 0::- > ~' r::.. ;-, , ')J' \ r-.~ [ i /;.1'" ;;,' r' ~,'- ,. ,"II" \ \ 4-- ~, I i I" I . ~" , ~ ' ;1 ~_,-r y~// I ".~:~~ I ~ I 0 r . . r' '" I I II ,:/1 ~'I--' ----~ ---~d-'5h:"~~~\'- :\ j7,-~,' . I\'".'~'l ~r--~-- I ,----'.------: \ ~~ ( ~o ~J n:pUl'l ). L::. [" ' ~ ,I, ~ it ~ ,<..,( .".,,,~.,. .- ~"'n.1 I ' \ ~ ' 0 lL- n ' _.~.-.-- ~ ,c t - .----- B]~ ,:::::::;:-, I:; I ~ , c .. r----::: ... .., --= D '" ... .. .. ) 0 ~ % \0 :l V I I L CJ ( , -1\1 ~ ~t' '-I - .. It) . < , \ J~ If ~~ .-= .. ..... 'en = . <>: VJ '";j ,IT. .~~q~T~.~ I mi. I ,i ~}o 0 t \ D '" ;;::: Q ~ '... ...... / _/ , \ , , " '. " " ' , ; , ; ,J j ~>" " I{, .i:,,":',', , , . 'F \. ,c . '.~'. . " 617 POl ,'JAN 21 .'~~ 10:30 " ' . SUNUS ~ CORPORATION, -------- B. , January 21. 1994 " ~ tt t \''Jt'\1 'r) \ \~t)~ " \1-\\\ to ' · ~ O~~1. c.\1'l c.\.~R . " Cynthia E. Goudeau, CMC City Clerk City of Clon~wato~ ' P. ,0. Dox 4748, Clearwater, FL 34618-4748 \ Dear Cyndiel In rcfc~cnce to Case No. SV92-78 of tbo City Commi~sion Public Hearings, I will need to llak for tl continunncc on thin iasue due to the fact that my attorney ~i11,bQ in court that dato'(1/24/94)., ' I'need to' get at least two wooks notice on this !ssuc so 'he can put this on his schedule. I received this notice 'le~B 'than one week prior to the date of the moeting., Attorneys cannot react this fast. Again, please continue this varianco hea~ing to ehe neKt meeting. Thank. you Lor you-r aasistnncc. ,', " , 1. : 'j ", , " " . \ Sinceroly, 0~\~ . Valerie J. liiak (j President of SunUB Corporation, . Prope't'ty Hnnagcr for . VJU:jj Espana Business Center " ~~py via FAX 1/21/94 - '.62-6488 I ' REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT & MANAGEMENT 2170 Sunnydule BouloYllrd .. SUlt,D VI · Cloarwator. FlorIda 34625 . Tultlphono fl13/447.7fiOO, . Fax 013/401-4084 , ........ '" _~I._...r_~'"' ..._.,U........... .,. ..'........ .., .. . .........._..... . ..__.. ~ ............ .. jI ...,..__......,.. .....~.. .'. .....""" .. _... _;....... .."'" ........ ~ ~ ' , ' i' ,'I ,:;. \ ,J' \ 1 I' , .;','./;' ;'.1.'", " ' , '.' ;.1,," , .', " " ".' ,',I;'.' , '" , ' , . , ,. " .\ J.:~ .'. ,.::.:~:!: \',' .~t".\ . "~"",, , ", "" ' ' ',,' ,," 'j.,', ',: " " , , '... ".."" , " ,,' ".. ': ',C' " t~f"F} ,''',j~j\::,,';;~.: >;;;C;:~;';:)""". ~ ..: .::," ,,: ::" '~: ;:".;,' \:. ,," ... ::'~" ': ','t,~.\>.;,."",,~: ,:;:',:,. \:' '::; ", ,<,:,:' ),:..,.'~;. , ','I .\, to "..,' I ".. " " ,," "}'/,\;' "". ' ., 'i >::,:::":,,,',~,",,~,/:":..:,;, :\', , , ":' '1!";;I,;',:',~:,;I:;:.,j~~U~"~t':;'i~,:.~::i:'::~~'I; :!;':'i'~;.L:,~,>:;i' .: ,,: "", "", ".' ,> ;):: ;;.'}' ',';;'"O':" .. ' " " " ," ,', ,"" ,,'" ,.:, " , ,,' ~~'" ;""'. .: ," ,:' " :i::, :' :~:,('., ~' i/ ,:~\~J." :";,;'L;~;,, ,'., ",.: ,,' ' I . " .. ,. . e ;" . " . '.. ,. " . . ,; e I , . ' . ,,' I," ',: .', " ' . " I' ,'} .: , ",i' '.1 '. '.. :'. ",," .,..... ".{ ',; "..~,':':.,~,',e:..',.l! \,'::: 'I, " '::,;',. do'. , .. ," ,;... ". "', < " ,.'. I> ." ..' .. "~I . :.. I". " ' " , ; ,I" ' . , . ~ ~ I !;J': . , ; \. ~ \ , : ,.. , " " , ,..,~,.;'~ . ':, !,.. ~' ~ ~ I ~ ~' ,.:: ~ I , 'I.,', L:O' ~./ : '. ......'/l ~ ,', I' ~. ~ ., 1 ~ . .', " ':, , .!" ;I:';": ;, t.. .' ~ I, , 'i """I~~'.' .'Q' u ';' . :' ht ~0t-J ' ''l. .', . ~~:','" ~ ',' .'. , t .' c.tC ~ .' l , ~ ~ " t ' . 'f . '. . l,.'.. . J t . ~ . .<<.,. : !'\ c ~; ~ .., , , . ,', !: . .. ~ ~. ~ .I~. i<~.~.:.~.-"''r; , : I. . :t~ .: .,':.: ,r .' .;'1 ;~: > . '. ;'. ,'. " j.' ',' . .,' ~, ~ .' . ,.... '.t ~ c.'; r, ;....t. ~<;.:'~, ~... _4. ~ ~. \, ." ; 'c'r.;'i- .o.,~l \~."/:.,};~ '/. ; '.' ..'. "J "t.' '.J"; '. ~" ,i'.:{':':,;::</:: ,'.. '.". ~; '~" ,:. ~ :), .f . ",' ..I j \' , " ?,.. , .:';/~'JI::i '~'~~}:.'C-., .~ ";l'~; ~I, ~<:.~:~.,' .'. '1 I' . :.j' ,: '. ,'. , t . {', " '. .,. , ; '"" " " . e. ' ".! ( " ., .. r ,. :.: c'.r . ~'. '.: ;. ~" ' ....,., :': ,. '+ " . ,.,., '<. '\~:'~" ~ c ,,! ;- . ....~ "'~'>lt";~~'..~ " \., .;:. ~.~' ,.. .. I .. c .~ " . !.'~ .:', ,":. . :-.~.::'~:~,:>:\",":< ".'..,: " , ". " ".' ,',e:':'::,e:..',.'.'..,(:., .,' \.:....:4'.. . c' '.' ," ..; .1, ~ .'" ,~: ...., . ' ~ c .. I '.." {. ,~l \ t c.'.~.,.:..~~"..'."..~;~.:...,',:".'.,I...... r': ',' '''':' . ',,;, ":'"i' f'.:.,.....,...,:...,..::\',I~,~.~'.:..; ~, .,": '.>..,.."...', ,...,' "'~e: .),':' ~l."'''''''';''' "~:::':..f'::;,':';;' ":,.',. · ',Y:..)';;' "::':'i:"!"\"~:"::':l"""'!~:'::>;:~;':'~.~';'::>:'" ',.';~::-' !. .;,:'," "~,,.: :"'.;;' :.:~I"::,i'.';.~,'.;""'::":;" " .. ,.'1" .'. ., ,':' .\",' ",' .,,' .:, "'j,:'!':'" '. .. .,! i: ;., ,"", ,.... .1' "-:,.~'" .:t' ,,:"..::,e'" ".:~,t'~::';"': " " .. " ' ." .';,.:.:.:>:;,'....:,:'.! .'. : \>,1, " .'::....'/; 'i"'''' ,1.;." :>" r:' ,",,',', i [; :;~\:?;i!!.',~.:'.'~.;\";':,:;':r",, ,", ;:;~:.?~})'~,Ht:S'i,;:~;'~/:.,' ';" ';: ' ;.'. ., ,I "'I:.,:~,,.l", ,,;' ~.: :lc'Jt' ': ~:,:I etcl-. ~~ ~.., ". , . ,-,." ..:,; ,;" ' ,", ..:,.' ' . " ,'. ,.' , , . " ",."., " >C. "h ",'" .;:', .', ,;:.:' :":""'e"<'}\ ,. . ,I. . r ':, ': ';.' "", ~. . . . . '1' .' .. i . c .. ""!,' :,' '.' ,,;;~,~,,~>-:'.":r:;,~:: i :t "~:r.~'~ .l: .,~ . '~Jl.I'.J::"Lj . ..97 \~ ; ~ . ; ~, ,~ . " '" >1-.-, '. ..~'~'i .,' . .'. .. . I . ';.. ~ ". ,:',:' .' ':, "'::~I . .." . ' ..( ,~ . . ~.\ . .\,", . ~, , . ' . 1" , , . l.': ,:~ ~ ...' .' " . . l~' :'.: I .'~ '. . ;.\ ;. . :. I' . ' . ,l I ' ;-:.. , . I' .: I. " \ ~ ~, :, , ';1 . ... '~ .... ,,. t ~'~~:~'.,.d ',' ..\.:,' .. 'I. ~ '. ':. ~.. ~ i j 'c .1 ~ ; ~ I I :~ ~. ' , '". ,e , 1- ~', ., ..; :.,:> '\:',;:.':" '. ;.. . ~. \ I c..: ~ l q' " , ~ /. ;.. ';".\ ~ , '. 'I ~: I': I , , ..... ~. ~ ~~ ~ ~>/i . ~L: '~: .' ,~: .: ,:;: ~~ ~ :.,:' I'. .. :- \..,:' , <, .; ~l . ,. .: ~;: j'. ;c. .' ' . ' , ~ :1 ,I ,:... . , ,tc' .,f'.l 1'1 ,..... " , : 1 ~.~ .c I:. . .'L. . " .. . " f ~. . ,., t. . .'. ~ ~ ,:.' c,. + ~... .,.. .;"c' , .:"! ".. ') ... .1 C. L'.:,'. ~.~ c " . ~ \, ". r . .~ 't" ;: . , ' i ~ . ~ . < . . < . II n ~. '~ ~ ., i '. ~ ."P Y : I '.' . -\ 'C' . ., . , .: "" \ ., ,~ . / '..' , '1'1. .~.' : ,.;. . I;, : .J , . ,I. " " ~,.. . \ . ., ~ ~: I" , 1 ~ ~ ;. , " " ~ ., 1 ' ',' ~. . l. : '.f , \ ~ :) , \:.:~. ~r ~'t~':. ,L I L: '" '., ,~. <;'1. ,t: ,.:; f.lu';" : " " l' ,.. \ . .1: '~>. 't, I' ,< e . \' ~.' ~ . , : 4'-.\ : J ,l " " , r..' " , ':.' +\,..". \ ~ ~'.: '.'. ,;\";'". ~ ;f. , f q' " t-,' . ~ ' " i. .::. . I'.. ';t ~ ; c . '. ,-' '..' ~ ~, ~ .\, l \. . .',\ ..';...., .......c "lo- \ '. . ',. ') ," '. <;. ~ ~. ,. ',I .~ ,~: tl ~ ,(. ~ . ~:~,t~~,;:l~l."! .:.L .,..,. 'i ~;',;.,: i{ ..! ". ,. ..\ .5' "~ ' t ~ . ~ :' c . ~,-:,,',"~>'~' ; . '~. ~ \ ' ' , :.;"':;' c' ; . .l,' ,. ,. J. ). "".' ; , , 'c'f 1 : \ '.' ,.:, ~ " .J '\' . to; .~ ~ '_1 .. ~~. ., " . ~ " . .... , ' 'f :, \. '. , ~.'" c. ~ 'Ii. ~ . ,'.">[''- ." . l',' :: .1 i ~ c1.' .. =,' '. .} ',' .; 1.1 .' , , ' " , .1 J..:.:t. '. I ~ j' ", I ,.;.< :1 ,.,<.t .' . , '.1 ~. I .-' "1/ < './. ",:' ...' ',' f: < I,r ~ , '" '.;.!! " ,~. :.' >. " , , .1 , ' ! ~ " '. i, '/ ,: . : ~ . .-:.' "'J .,." '.,: \ ' j' .;, .; ; \, . . ~ I \ . . "1 .1.'.', " " " . .. ~'.: .~ : .., ~ ;'., , ., j. , ~ . , ; j. ; F1.. ., "ll " " e( . i. 'J ~ '. ' . \,> . .. . . l-/.:~ ,. .t' , 1 ',\' " , ;. C!~ l.'.. . " , ~. ~ .' / " ;, "J .' , ~, " " ." .J ':. ~ l. "~ ~ . '1. .' ,. ',;, " , " " .' , ~( -: r ;.' ,. :\ '; \ I ~ ~ .,' . ~ '. . '.. ~ f,' _ I. ~ p", , 'c. " e I 'c;. , " ',\ ,. ~ " '( f. ., 't\." ~: ,.1, ; " , ' ,. " '.' ' e, : :':1 :,. " '1 ,.' , , " ,I . . ~ .-, '.' ~ : I . " .' . -t . '.~ I',. 'r." ,s. . ) ~~ \0-.' . , '.. .~; . " -'r i. ,,~ ; . ': ~ , ~ ',' , " 'i.. ' , " " ". " ':\;' ,:, ,.f , .' " '. , ,j' 1..' ..' , , . .'1 , ~ ' ~. " , ." : ~ . i ., . i , l ::, ~+ " '!. ,', I, c,,)_ .', ,', ~ , " . .\, ' , " : ':i . t ~ ' . ~ I.' .l'.. ~' c~. . " ..: " ..' ~ \- . ,j ~:. , , }: .; ~ . '1.. ~ ,i c . ~ ( " ,. '. :;' ..'~' I " . 'e . , .1 r S...J,ljf I" .' 'j. '. ~. If' ' , .. . f .~ \ I ~ .~;. " \ \ " " t . . ,. I ~ . .". " ....... . . Clearwater City' Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum . Itr!m # Meeting Date: _______ ____ c. 1/) 'I/N SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 1902 Drew Street; Steve Eiseman/Alternative Auto Inc. (Owner/Applicant); Steve Eiseman (Representativel. (SV 93-08) RECOMM EN DA TION/MOTION: Deny the variance to allow nonconforming signage to remain on property identified as Lot 24, Blk. 24 and half.of vac. street on W. of Marymont Sub, for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(3), (5), (6), and (8). [] and that the appropriate officials be authorized to r!xecute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a setback variance of five feet from the five foot setback requirement to allow an existing freestanding sign zero feet from the Drew Street right-at-way. The subject property is located on Drew Street approximately 300 feet west of Corona Avenue and is in the General Commercial zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. information Existing Freestanding Drew Street 64 square feet o feet 1 5 feet Permitted Type of Sign Location/orientation of sign Area Yes Yes Setback Height 64 square feet 5 feet 20 feet Rlvlaw.d by: leglll Budgr!t purchllsing R hk HglI'tt. CIS ACM Other N/A N/A N/A H/A NfA .{t.~f':'" N/A Origln.llng Oepl: CENTR It;ERMITTING Cnl': Total Cllmml..lon A~llon: [] Approved [] Approved w/conditions o Den! ed D Continued to: Uur Dopl: Current Fiscal Yr. Allvll\iud: Dntl;!: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUIlE D Not ReqLJi red AII,clell Pall I.. ~ Notified o Not Requi red Funding SOUlet: o Capi till Imp. o Opl;!rM\ng o Olher Atl8C!lIlllUU: APPLICATION VARIANCE WORKSHEET MAPS D None Apllfoprl.t1on Cocl,: -0 n recycled ptlpcr SV 93r08 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: The new sign ordinance is being uniformly applied to all signs in this zoning district. The recen~ erection of a security fence, 25 feet from the street right-of-w~y, caused the loss of some of the vehicle display area. The applicant contends the relocation of the sign to meet the setback requirements will cause loss of more vehicle display area. The applicant also states he intends to erect a new sign on the site. Although the location of the security fence 25 feet from the right-of-way and the vehicle display area may make relocation of the sign difficult, .the applicant has not provided any evidence that this variance request arises from any conditions unique to this property. A new sign can be erected to a maximum height of 20 feet, five feet higher than tile existing sign. This would enable the sign to be seen above vehicles parked in the display area. Staff review indicates there are no particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions involved creating a hardship for this property. On May 14, 1991, the Planning and Zoning Board granted Conditional Use #91-29 with 15 conditions allowing automobile sales. Condition # 1 0 required all s;gnage to conform to city code. The survey provided shows the sign encroaches into the right-of-way 0.8 feet. Drew Street is owned and maintained by the Florida Department of Transportation. Tho Public Works Department has commented that if this street was the City of Clearwater rightrof-way, the Department would not allow the sign to encroach. The applicant ,has changed this sign by repainting the sign. This was done without a permit and is a violation of Section 44.55. This variance request is extreme with regard to the permitted setback .of a freestanding sign and cannot be considered a minimal request. I I Direction ~ SURROUNDING LAND USES Existing Land Uses North South East West Single family residential Star Centre (strip shopping center across Drew Street) Professional offices Strip shopping center , ' The existence and/or proposed construction of a freestanding sign zero feet from the street right-of-way is not in character with the signage permitted for the surrounding commercial areas and not consistent with those land uses. The granting of this variance will detract from the surrounding businesses that have conforming signage as well as negatively affecting tho overall appearance of the community. , ' SV 93~08 Page 3 Applicable Variance Standards To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's request meets only two of the standards. 'In particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully met: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made, in the execution of a building permit or work 'performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. ' (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. , (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcame the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the p~rpose of making reasonable use of the land. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) The granting of tIle variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase, the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the pubHe safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (8)' The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this, development code" Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 92-43 1 24 Brightwater Viking Motel Freestanding area 3/25/93 Dr. (3.4 7 addl)/Approved Setback (5 ftJ/Denied SV 92-49 657 Mandalay North Beach Permit freestanding 3/25/93 Ave. Motel sign/Denied Setback' (5 ft. )/Denied SV 92-71 351 S~ Gulfview Julie's Setback {3.75 2/9/93 Blvd. Seafood & ft)/Approved Sunsets SV 92-98 675 Mundalay Sea Gull Apts. Hei~ht (.25 2/23/93 ft.) Approved Setback (5 ft)/Aooroved j ,\, ' QlO <9 ~ ~ I ~ -..a ::I N d C' ... II: 'a :a~-= - 'i' ~ !'J ,9 ,E: ~ "g ct C. t_ tI 'C: CI.:8 ,if "" <1 CI .....=~- =-..=,. <15"'::--' Q ~ - a -.:::'3 1: lP~ !! :a...:a.E Co '" ... ~...... Ei ~ .!:> ~ 'r;; 'c E .E 1: ~ c - - :!i ~ ~~ = a'C CI g g- ~ '3 ~ ] ~ ~ s ,~ oS 1: 'C ~'Q~:; ~g~:a ~ '.;j 5- .~ ~ ~~ c-eoS Si41 ~ ,~.g ~ ::! "" C ill .. !l: oft '" "l:I :., "" ::I :--. 'I: 1:: C c..!'l ~ ~ "" .","c, , F: ~:€ ~' [ .a. ::E t! ~ 'oS r:I "l:I :a::1! 51 1 ;: ~i~ 11 ~ Cl.j = r: C ,Sf I:t <1 '" &.YI:t~ - C '" .::; tt ';: rI' a. 'Q:j .=:i C II: itI :., 8.~.,i .iL( ..s :a ~." j ~ a-E'-: :.a OJ t.CI s Co,.:: ~ =~:M'~ ~:3ia ."._,... ~ e ~ ~ ~ ':;; ~ l:::a ......= . ~ -a2 11 Z "" c "'"' ... ..Hr:lCC e.c:i .- r:I = lil 1:: I:t - t a 's oft ... C ~'!) ~ Cll:"c-= f:: y e :: "'1l::lc .. .. 5 tt ~ -= '~'l:i: .= ;: :: '" j-o ,5 e -s ~ "l:I j e .:~ C Ei tl g, c c ~-= ~ ~ t ~"l:I ~~!!i -;;-s ~': Ego: "L'= a !..~ .~ 'se1 \0 Co 0; c ~ '" ~ oS;: .a '".: C '" ~ &. . ::: ::I ~ '.g ,::- .~ t."l ..:::: S~-E =;-::: E-- ~ os ~I G ~ ~ .~ -= i: .='"CI a ~,; ::I ~1:a B.:: c t€ ~": a,s '3 ., .., t - 1: 1= ~:E - ::I E.!~II: ,~ :8 C c y 1i :a g, i: OL 8. .s "" c ~ .a ... ~~ :.a~ 6 E - Co ~:a or, _ ]~ .~ c. .:::B ~'E .;.a ,. 'f ~ a,5 ~~ f:: ... "'1 ~,-E F: .5 .a. g,,,c '::! - - ... "2 ~ .a ~ to~ ~] ~ ~ 2 \0 ;: OL ~~ ; r: C 5 ::... E C OJ '" ;; ~ S ::I to; rl"c ... - t) \0 ~,,: C . _ "I CI . ~] :rg ~ eL _ C ;~ '; ~ l: Co 0; C 'I:, .~ r: ;.. - 9:'1 1= t: . .."C -- CI ot.!l oJ y a 's i: \0 .E -g ... ~ ... ~ ';- b ~ C y !: ~ g, 0; C .S ;:; y ~ Co ;- ... '::Z 1= C r: .!:l -a. g, r: .~ oS ': :!: .~ "CI .. -= C ~ =--." :ct: rl ~ 'E ~ g,., ~-s l:j 5 ~~l C E ,~ ::z '" 0; ... \0 a-;; .5.g :. ;:; ~tS ~ t ~1i _ \0 - :L r,-; ~ ~ .: ::z !- ~ '" ;;: ~- 11 ~ ~ 100 ... ! u il ;; ~ ... ~ "c ~ C C ;.~ .5f --= WI'; U ,~ ,5 "?S II: _, .E E -a _ -= .w=; =~ ~.: OJ :0 ~ ~ '1: ';;; r: -; :3-= ~] :f';: .: 0;' ';::' !:s: e~ :tT .,,Z F'~ \0 ~ .s :;i .C ~ C ~ :~~ "" ;..., c 1:: -;;~ ~ E 6 Po 'Sj .. - "CIo<:: ........ ~:a 'E: II: ~.5 !!"'C:I C :: ~.e 'O.& Co<:: _ tt :;: ~!: ::r: c '" ... y - a: 'I: - ~ i; ... !: -= ~ t.c :: ~t: ..5 1::. _ 5 f!'~ tt- :: t' 1= it 0& , = .;- ,.., ....,...: ;.~ '~ ,~ 1: ~ ~ .~ -= c'= a e I:: :' ,5 ; ~ .E' ,.3 tL ~ f~ 0<:: I:t ,5 ~ ., 2 :!:! ~ ..s '= C C ' c ~ ~ ~ , :a ~ .. c ~ :--.l! 'a C.!1_= ~~.g~ 6' ., :!l e ::=..c loll il'::Di/ - e.5 -, c:;:l'Ci ~ c.c 4.l ~ ~ ~ ~ !; .. ~ t: -= ,5 e ! g]E!;- u - ~ ~ ~ ~ ,:;r.~~ ? ~ s :: ~'5 ~ ~ 1::.... - ;-~uti ... CI S a F e .a .E ... " = '" ~ \0 ~ .:::~ ... ~ - ~ :;.'8 ;: :1.1 - = =.,.-= .:: _ tl ~ J:L ~ g.s ,::-::::c. :. ~ ~ Ji - - - "" ~~ ~ :: - :: ~- '" ., t::.s ~ ~ ~.- g B ~-: ,5 ro;tj"CI -= ~ t ..:;. : ~ ~] ~ ~.~ ~ l;~] = :; ~ ~ ~~ ~ .s ~ ~ ~.5 ..:, - ;'l ';- ~,~ ::r: ~ .,:, i ~~ ,~ ~ g = .. - - oj- i: f ~ :::. --~ :..: ~ C ; 0 ~, ... ~ ~ ... 1:: :: ~ :.. ~ ~ i:!:.;.t:'E = ."8. :.5 ; 5- r: .-: :5. -= :gf :L E I;: 1.. ~ ;io. ... - a. :: t:,'g a E:';:! _jl-SE s ~ ~ f ~ =.1 i:l a 'C r:I .. \0 ..s "E <'l "CI a -:;; .~ -s -= ,,.. II: .!:> Co e c y .s ~ ~ g: .~ :; ,!:l -a. Co .~ ~ \0 .. 1: ::: ,;, ~ :;. j i Jl - . .. .... ~ ~";:: t; E :.. E ,::;,01' ~ e il' ... ~.; -, ... c - i:: n=s ::r: '" ";! j:: ,E 11 !i .. "CI ii OJ :t 5 \0 'C ~ O'l ... ~,~ ~ Ii ~ Er; , ' ... -= :: ; tL ~ ,5 S ii - ,E,L - e ~ ~ :L "c e '" - 'M .= :;~j-o 'a ... , ~ ~ ~ s't:~ c='" Y OJ 6 t:.;~ = tt "!:: ~ ,5 a , ~j ~ ~ .~ ii ~ i; "c 'c; .'" :a -= - i:'': .. ~.- Q ~ C ~ = g '~ ,oS .~ "..c....!1 ~ ~ :.'~ U-_" ... 'I::; <1 o ~ == o1J ~~C'IIC .-= I: f,.I C: U 8,'-- = t j t ;: : 'ii ~ Q\.t=1:l.t 8;~: .- .. t,I 'E5oLij '" - 1$ iC a]~!! ~ ~ [:g c- C ~ .5 ~ 'C '6, or, r:: ~ I:t .s ~ ;. - = ';' "L .. 'il "CI OJ .... = r: 'E: ..: .. OJ -=~ ~ c - .... tt_ ,5 !i 'E c c ? :,(~ ~ t 1=..., "' €:s ~ :.e ~ '" ::r: ;.. '" ~ o ~ ~ ~ llC e ; ~ ,6 ~ 1:: :., \0 E 8- i~.s'€ ~ E ,Y 100 It or, Cl.Sc.:t'5 .,,~ .; :; :a -s ;:;: ~ ~ oS.!:; 5 ~ ~ ~ .~ ~~ ..8 g.NQCr:I '1'1 ~ !!I E: E a '= ~ to.:;; ,~s ";l ~1 '5 '" l::: ,il - :a:C c::~ ~ II:~ t.Et = CI. F O'l '" 15 E- ~ -C :s :a :--. :., C jg e-t:cC 8 E ~'= ~ ::.ECt-= 6 'c a ~ c e ::I., = -l;;:=1j ~ ~,'E;~ C:C .- 'r: 2 ~ ~ '~ ~ ~.= :; I: , _~g5t.e !1;:"j'0;!ii 2.1 ~ .:: 'c; 'C t"i ="~ - ~ :u ~.13 e ~ ~ ~,~ ~ W E '= 'c..., a -t:.': ; ~ a ;. . ~ .~ "g:;ij:5 ~ ,_ ~ '" '" c . 1f g:;; .a u =: & u ~ 'i .s , , 1. . }\ , ' " I ' , ) " , . , " ,', ~,. . ~; '.' , , " ; , "Control # 910029 Conditional Use ; . 1 ", CU91~29 05/14/91 Request 1. Outdoor Retail Sales, Displays and/or storage (Automobile Sales) and 2. Vehicle Service Approyed with the following conditions: 1) 'the requisite building permit shall be procured within 6 months from~he date of this meeting; 2) a certificate of occupancy shall be obtained within 12 months from the'date of this public hearing;' 3) a landscape plan shall be submitted to the Department of pUblic Works/Environmental Management for review and approval prior to ,the issuance of any building permit to include protection of the large deciduous tree. Therefore the angled parking in the front 'may have to be relocated,; 4) the outdoor, display, sales and/or storage areas shall be,clearly delineated on the site to assist in code enforcemnt. Parking or display of, vehicles shall be prohibited within any required open space/yard areas or street' ROW; 5) no repairs. or detailing shall occur between the hours of, 6:00 pm and,9:00 am, Monday through Saturday and all day on sunday; 6) there 'shall be no outdoor speakers;~7) all permitted vehicle service shall be indoors; 8)' all parts shall be stored . indoors; 9) all lighting shall be oriented away from the , residential areas and street ROW; 10) all signage shall conform' to city code; 11) all vehicular display ~nd access areas shall' be paved according to City code; 12) Only one garage unit shall' be used for vehicular service; 13) repairs shall be limited to minor repairs not requiring removal of engines or transmission; only cars to be sold shall be permitted to be repaired; 14) customer parking for vehicular sales and service operations shall' be ,cle~rly marked; and, 15) the legal requirements pertaining to the public easement to the we~t of the prop~rty 'shall not be violated. , ' " " ' " , ' , , , , '/, , . " ~" ~ ~ . . I '. ~ ........'..1: ". " .... ..' , . '..~ t . '.~ ~, . . ~r.:~:... ..... . ' .. CITY OF CLEARWATER ,.~." SIGI~ VARlANCE APPLICATION , s:v# 9;).08 Receiot #62 '2,.. 7-/'2..(, (-,~..:>' 'SO,GO PROPERTY OWNERlS) NAME & ADDRESS: REPRESENTA11VE(S) (if MY) NAME &. ADDRESS: 5 te",Q., N.b~,(".1\ ~ '] ~ L.~v"h\"" v~v-t. (~c>( Cl,~- 11'1 . ~~ 7 ~ , )Ybl~ 5;1'-' ~,~ ~'I\;~ A~ l.1\t". Sft~lH. 6 )tMCA , ql)1- () r~vJ ~, . ~ ~ '> ( I( b"\,IJCA. W \ .fC\ 1 ~ b 2.S"" ~:1 . C::l\l""'t!' ~ re. f. , .)h..vt 6 ~M~'\ TELEPHONE: ( s.n I lj ~ 1-(, ~ .lr TELEPHONE: ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: f '10 L Dr-tw .sf- (I vJ tC1 ') "'f',LeS f\ !t.U"'\.o'h\i'C... A-v'~ 1,,<- f I "t'l.SO (I 17 I~) LAND AREA: -w? ~ ~).IZ."'i~ " . L oj 2'1. t5LueJr... 2.L/ Mf+r..~"""QtJ\ 50RC\\" IS/~,J --:. 1...rlST ,,~ ft(l t.f.f-(j ,.oJ ? Lr'l 11 tJ JK. J ~ , ~.)BI,.It. ~tro(l.(\~ Ot= 1'-'t:Lt.I\-~ (lhlloJ'1"'-\ I' {, '~-\1.." PARCEL NUMBER: f 2.. / 2...9 /, f ')'Sl (17.- / D 21../ I D2- t.J (j {This information is available from your tax receipt or contnct Pin ell as Co, Property Appraiser's Office at 462-3207. If more than one parcel number. attach 8Yz x 11 Inch sheet! NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPLICABLE): ZONING DISTRICT: (6- LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: 5't'l~4 Jh;r{ fCI.....,f-i a~"~5 South: s l-.p ('~ ,\'ki (Pj,..tl '2.c. ) East: West: (H~.~~ i5\J.1 I~ I ~ Strl ~ (t",W (~ ll;l.J:.') VARIANCEIS) REQUEST (If Variance to 7 year Dmortizntion requirement. refer to Sec. 134.0151: A l' Cl II ~ " Ul c t S- I h cd Ie \I-l 0. ;. I ~.'\ 0 I {~..... oJ l "t. r . 'i ,w--'h-t REASON FOR REQUESTING VARIANCEIS): IRefer to Standards for Approval. next pagel 1\..",- (t It.rt.~h~'.'" .' f.. M. ), fA. L-' c...1 ~ ~u I .....,,,a,, k.. c., ~ f'^~~~.~ c\' i"U. Utl"'\'l.....' O. Splt:!j l~rl', - f31.(.......\~ c,..c. +4 F.\- IN t ..+- At. Kr.,t.'(h...;.;. .......l;'- {-'if Q. C 4~ ~\...:... I ,..... ,'\AJ... t \ y....... ( cc-t ~ .1 t. \- t?1 ( I L..J, ..... t I ~ : i- "\ I:.i r ~1)~lll"-t .;:~ h 4.. \ tI.....:o -h~ ~ \-- j ~ d~/k h":"l --...dl~ -' .\ ~ t;"" 1 . .(.. ~ ~ .- rL;1\ ~\lV''\ I '" "- (. I.." t" rl - )w,'\(Irf"\ If. Vv...... "{.~1": \- i\f'-\'.......<:! +~ Ie il Cl"u"""''''~ ~ . l ....:.~ t"Wo.:. I ~ 1"_ ~ l. ........J, t ......., l"yrn .. tl1 1'\..1........ \<0 .... r:t f- fUt s,lnt+ I' ~:y~ q.l...i- ,j.~ ~';.~e., !,oll...... rdr' I" (1-:.\....'1~__ ~ l.v{ i " I ktd y-e i '\/h.,I--S ~ r ~ foe... t.l, 0 Jr 1'.Jfjt."~ f( +~ d.. -to..:... .( ..1,}... oj. vt v.\\ \.l d,Y'~ l{{'... ~~ .....1 "" . CONTINUED ON REVERSE SIDE ......,. . It.;...........u : :''';I.;.;..i.~':..'.' . ...J.~.. . "l. ". .. ';.,. 'I". ' ,t..T.,"';';..;...... . STANDARDS ~R APPROVAL: A varianc~ shall not ,be granted by the City Commission unless the opplicotlon ond' evidence presented cleorly support the following conclusions: 11) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique 10 the property in question and is neither ordlnorlly or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor craoted by on action or actions of the property owner, predl\CBssor in title, or the opplicllnt. Any mistake mode In the execution of a building permit or work performed whhout the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of 8 vorionce. (2) The par'1icular physical surroundings, shope or, topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in on unn,ecessnry hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is tho minimum necessary to ovorcome the unnecessary hardship reforfed to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of makil)g reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is not ba!led primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greoter financial return from the property. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious t'o other property or jmpr~vements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6l The granting of the variance will not impair on edeQuate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detro,ct from the appearance of the .community, SUbstantially increase'the congestion in ;the public streets. Increflse 1ho danger of fire. endanger the public safety in any way. or slltlstantially dil11inish or impair the value' of surrounl.1ilo.g property. '17i The variance desired will not adversely affect the public bcaJth. safety, c.rder convenience. or general welfare o f the commur.ity. . 18) The granting of the vari.mce desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): YL Before me, the undersigned outhority, personally appeared 3 ~~ IV. ~\Str""'^t\J deposes and states the matters and facts set out above arc true nnd correct to the best of his/her knowledge and belief. , Sworn to and subscribed before me this 07.')-~b- ~ . , - . t ....~;1.q'. ",.;;~... /" ~;.~\~. ~..)t .~ : .{-.:.,....?.1 'i : .. \ I '.V' 0"10 " .... .':j,:,>j.~.::~ ::'~/ . ' , OFFICIAL SEAC ' JAMES J. LOW: III My Commission Expires Jan. 24. 1996 ""J:"m. No. CC 174734 A.D., 19 9,3 NOTE: PROPERTY OWNER OR REPRESENTATIVE MUST AlTEND HEARING. Fluv. 1 :!I!} 1 ' . , , , " , > ~. .' I ~" l '~.' 'l .' ~. " , .1 ',' ,'.' , , . ! ~. ,/- . I , " .. '. ~' . ~ " , , t , , " , , I, " ..' .J'_'I "~ . ~~ J' 1'..:' ~. , I C" 'l',' I, \ " ......"un"f'I.; DI.JO \,.n",. tt)--'~ , "11.,.1,;0 IQn~ .' '1'.'11I" t" .'jMIuU ..11I' ....rt 'H." I ".'.,.... "",-'fir.. , ' fl." . ",,,,.,.t' );".+.t: 1!930l0037 ' . ' r,orlr"1 "rrl.I..,. r,,~.1 1".ntrrJ~.II." IFollal Uumbllhl: ," '" .' ,,(j.~nttehl G.S; "hI: , N'~~ ~""'~ fIn lJI'[ ron ",oxntl'-:a lJo\U ,'. , H~ \0 ;::1i s I :~ v. ~ :~ E '~ S , . ~ ,~ .' g ;: v;.ct 'l~ n..!J 1..11. 'on tIlCDU"IQ tlATA " " , , ' GJl)hi !t1unu1l1u 1ilce~' Madt'the 25th ,dllY '!i' ~!I FEDRUARY' A.V. t9 93 " PA11HCrA C, lolERNER, a lMt"dcd womnn f/k/n P,C. WEIt.MID Elnd PATnICIA C, HEn.IIUD, . individually llnd flS Trustee under that certoin Trust Ar.reemcnt dated l/B/al ;her~illl\1lcl' culled tht grllfltOl', to ,,' STEVEN N, EISEt-tAU, 1I sinuIe innn " whOle pnd offiee I1IM,.e.. i! i I . I '. " '! 'hc,.ehil\flcr called ,'hc, ;,.alllec: . , C p....nh..t ....,.. ,,,-,.4... Ui. -...... "'........... .IWI "1"1\....' ......1-1.. .. 1)." r...tl;tt t. ~$. ''liIIl~,11l'Nul ....., Y.. ~ luFr., ....,.. ,.,.t..,,,....u,.. .." .t~'JJI' II hll.h'hl..1,. IU" ..... ..Ut....,. ,_4 ....'IJI. ..., ,.........u..... " lattu'tl1.Bttlf: "hat.lhe gnllltO,.. /01' alld in cOPlsidcraliilll 'o/the !um of I 10.00 ': amIothc,. valllable eonsidernliolls, TtCeipt whereofi! hcrcbv ocknowledgefl, hel'ebv 91'111I IS, l'lIr~aill~(.t1!~$, nliens, remiscs, releoses, '01l1lc1ls ond GOll(il'7l1! 111I10 the grllntee all that eerlain In1ll1 situate 111 IN!:.. " COUPlIJI, Slole n/ non1DA ': 1Ii=:, " " . ' , , , .. , , , Lot 24,' Block' 24, NARYl-IONT sUnDIVI~ION: according to the PInt thereof, DS recorded' 'in PInt ,Dook 1~, Pane 39 of the Public Records of PlNELr.AS County, Floridn; and ''IOGIrrlIER with the Easterly 112 of nrlJ~",\~, now vacated, lldjoininp, said 'Lot on Hest Side. ~~~71-.. PATRICIA 5'.5. NUMDER =--~.- ..:: 9 6 1C,'O '77'7<: STEVEN S. s. ' mn-mER , ,1 0'(".. ~ ~ e1\, )1 PARCEL No. 12/29/15/55782/024/0240 SUBJECT property is not the hqmastcnd of the J1'untor she in f/let resides nt: / b..:::i71 ~W7tA.1.......----I cJ-:i . '. ',Dt.f-vt-U~' r~" '5 /,//. /f, " I, '. , ' " .1.' 0"' " , , ,f j 1 I. " 'I C' , ~,Cl't U,tth.u/l tln~ 11""J~I..th. Ju:tl".I,tlliJh'Nh dJ;" 1I'1,IHJ'lfllI,Uff... li.ft111! "lillil'IIII~/1I1 ~Ii UHlJW('I~' ,'llly. > \!It! JIIIUl 'lIlIll III 11111b. the .ame '" f~t .illlP/c fillcl'cr, 1\1I1l1/;c !lllrulllt' hCI'e/'lI C(Il:ClIllllls with 'II'" gruutee Ihllt tllc grnlltrll' i'/II1.if1llly scill'l/ ,oj 5ui,/11I1Il1 illfi',! simrlr; lhlll the grnllfur hIli gcxlll righl nnrl1awjltl alltho/ily 10 .cll 11I111 cUIlI'cl/.ui,1 Irllul, ..lid IIC"I'!lII'UlTrllll~ ille lil/'llfl."rid Irlllll ami wiU drflllllllllc lame nDn"n~t Ihe hlwf\ll tlnillu .oJull J)e+:~",u lL1hml1~t1"I"ll'; IIll,lllulI will II/III/ i~ ,/;"'1; ,if IIIl r.IlCllt't/wrlllr.C~. CTr.cJ,t II/%c. IIc(.ruillll ~lIl'3C'/IIC/lt III Ikct:II1II1'I' .fI, 19 92, subject to Clwcments Dnd restrictions of record ) (f,a)i",,~ /10'1 tfless III /J ,6QY .l 1<-. [!G ~ " . . 't w-~".... trl.1ool Ill....... fh-n~' .~U~~~~ un )7;:6_:-1 r.;rea.. ,,_ I!G PATRICIA C. WEILAND, indi\fidllally rd.l>.i 1Ilr.au. ,..b......3-ipi.'I6,.. STATE o/-' COU1I1'Y Of , IllE::Itt;'u\' CE::Jl.1U'V u.ot 011 ~h\..Lay, hob.. mo, on alllcor ""lyou~horl..u In Uulleot. .lor...U on..! 10 Ih, Co"nly .r.."..IJ 10 I.~. K~nowll,ICln'nu, 1,<.00noIl1 ol~"'o'oU PATRICIA C. I.;E!U;'ER, tl married ""Orlal\ f/kln p.e. ~lEILI"ND rnd PATRICIA C'. l.'ErLAND, individually and as Trustee under that certnln Trust AGreement ntad 1/8/81, \,'ho produced DS identification and took /lnd oath . " .., \1'll\o.lr.n..W\l to Lo Ih're.."... J..tllb.J In 0011 who .."""I..llI,. 10"1i"ln( Inll"'mlol '011 SI1~""nowl..J~o.l bol~.. mo Ih.~ ., Ie uewl..ll "!\I:il .....11111;11/1 m~ hom' .nl! ol/lelol ...t In Ih. Coonly and ~l.\. 1"1'lo.e"li~th day 01 II Any . .\,Il, 1~93, " ,if:;-, /. n,-,~-. ""1.61]' lrNlwrt RONALD E. SOMERS .~hl", ,3.~hlft ....Jc.........~...I.'l..I". H1*lPls Sl::..ll. 81'A TI: OF COllIn\' 01' RONALD E, ,SONI1:RS IJotary l)u\Jhc. Slul....: oC t. .-.,LrIJ~, ,~. comm. CXI"ft" No\', 7. I!!'~ , COlmll. 1;0, Fe OU2HU I 't'1'/ , I I II: IlIm V CEI\11ff Ih.t on \I,ll .toy, b.lo"IM, On olfku J.\y oulhor\1...lllllh. lll.l. "0,...1.1 .",1 In I),. Cou"ly .,fu....IJ I. td.. ..,kh~..I"Jll'h.nh, l'.r.,n.Uy on~'.r<J . tu mt "110.,." to 1... till' ,,",uQn dUtuLC'~ In and ......IIeJ uerol~l U.. lOUlntr\C ll'\tlrulf\tnt "'$'II! .;e\.nu..-h.."h5 hdlJ-TI 1l1. '~l"\ . lfutuh:J ChI ulnr. \'lllflt;SS "'y /,.,,1 "",I nU.dol 0.0.1 In II,. C<>unly ..".] 1l1.1. !.o1 .,..,....~J U,I. '~'l' .r ....n, III ' ' J{'t~'\I' a-,.""'h1" .'.;1:.',1/. r;T;r(,n~~*",. )4, l~",~J..j... l'I"u- . ," - J 'I t.! I ll~i~.(C!~:J \\'/:F1I)': t. · I t . ,IUl 2 2 19\)1 --- I }tft ~ ~~\ f r I " , , ,. , . " .. " 't " , '\ , ',f '" , t . 'I. ~\. t " . , I,> . ( "; "~ " . .'... ~ " I I, " ~., I l.~ 'I I ' '. te. .;. " ,I' . . . . ~ c . .: 1-' , " , . . r,. ~ I ,,' ~ , , " 1 , ~, .....',1-...."... , ' , .., ,':' ,',I . (Jt " ' " ..... ..:i ~ b ~""".I . ~.' . ~ /.; , ~ , . '". ". .", :.' '" . "<' \." " " , , , ' " " P ,?-t)\,~ J Ell , , ,.r6;s , s , r.rl " \ " ,~(w , ,5H...rJ ~/, ~ l f) fJ) , $''/ ~\"'L 't.' -It "'T\,..oJ'\:) ,~ ' ((' .s) It lJ ,'.'~\n\ 4- ~ I G-t-\'l ' I:l.f' I ~ ( . t:~H. ~ IOe: 0';:: ~, ' ~ 16--J.I ' , , , ' r..f ~' x ~[ M 4r-- l~(&(rj-" ' ~ rr " I .. ~\\J-; vllTt) .4 IS .~ < /; ,. .:. 'T'~ J.') c;...f'l \J-ll LI... fJ~ .L() 'V1IDt '6 .\ " " , " ,- , . , " ~ .1;'0 .~ " l...J l a III '" ',g " I , \ ,5 '.1 , , ' , ' I' " 1'" .f. , ' . ~ .' " .. ~ '. , , , r: , ' , , ~ ... , , , " , " " ?\~lo.~ ... . ~'. , , j~~ : , ~,;.- . , '~\j"" , " )1\' (. .....J ?17,1..\ ,~~ t~R'1 f. l~+-j~ ~J'O",v"'\ 1\) .s I \, ~ \.>0 ~t~, f\.ll........,J C)~ ' c1~ f ~r \J.Q-.'1. ' t.V\d." ~ t.c....J r~ tt... , , '~\.O-.. ~ 0- s.& .}:- ~~.sl;vt. , , . r ~ l~-:.s " , " " " f'" Cfv1 Lt. ~ ~v .s .~-. ' '\3-12-~~ ,,' .' , " ", '\ . I "". . '. \. , ~.. " .d' :. .' '., " -...OQbL.... ..10.... 1'2.0'''' ""C.H\ .....; ~l- .....,. I ......,.. '2 ',,11-, I ,~.. E.'A~"" 0)":>.00 ,~-: "..;..... . . ;: -n,.,.,~ uvll!._ ItI ....~ ...... ';} ... .....,.... "'\...,.... U" i~...1~ ....,c"U t::It-"'t'.....\... .- . "1.0' r '0 · O. ~ d IJI -- " "''',/, .......... co. .. "-^Cl. c.... ...'t:aj.. , .. , .... ~ ......... . ".... ~"~..1>4.........., ..,.'.... a;:p.",'l.1II. "1..0,0. - LOT 2.4 @ / 24 1-,0"- ...!> ). ,\..,- 1. '1 ~ 11',," "c . 0 , ..~ . o. . DWDO IIl"'r/ .. J 0 II ( .I D'., illl il 0 J ~ '0 J ui ~ 1. o \II J t.~......,. .'t, ....^C..-...,Le:. -,ouJ .,.,ir, ,... ~ ' ~ .. ~ ' ~ 'r: 4 .. )0 . oJ I, b {b- ':f7 .,;~.4:.. .. ' ....Q~ ,,,.,' ~ :. . I e~..... Flt...... f .. "'''I0~ 4 "PI.-. '3 I IfI 'N> ;; '0 I o 'r ~ C . .. - c : '0 .. "..~. i ~iIj, -II , , 3 -c . <;" . ~--/ ~ 1 3 .. ~ ~ .... '9 DO! :i ~ 1../'..... .... ....t. ............ ~'b...,....... ( . '. . . lfi.' .... ........ . "". '7::' :\' E .. "'1- .' I . o '.' , LP, III It'a...~.~ a!J; f!l,1l-..... \... """"-'~...IIW'\..D t::I R.. e... '"'" ...~. l40.'lo' I>......C.D) \00 ~ I-...J , , ~ " LANGTON SURVEYING, INC. LAND SURVEYORS 6285 PARK BOULEVARD, PINELLAS PARK, FL 34665 545 - 5900 . 545.5:196 . FAX: 545 - ~~1 CERTIFIED TO: S Lcven E 1 !>cmiln .', Jail Ht!. c,~\OCj .:l. E.. C,.tE Of flELO WORK 'l.-\c;.. ""1'10 SEC. 11. rwp. "Z"l ,So RGE. 1"0 A BOUNDARY SURVEY OF:' It,lt 211, Ulo~)." 2'f and the: Eil$L 1/2 of the v.u;atcd Hn:t:t on llw West MAR'l't10IlT .:J!o rccordl!d In P I ill' tio,," If, P,lgc 39 of thl.! Pub lie Rl!coros of Pinl!llQ!> County, Florida. Accolthng 10 mnp~ PII)Pll'ull by (111) U,S. Dupnnrn..nl or Hou5mg IInd Ufbu" Oovulopmunl, 11115 PfQPu"y nppumo 10 b.. IOClIlu(j ,n ,Flood ZQnll(s) X. Comm, punol NQ, 12 ~0~6 0016 D. /.IIlP OlllO 6/19/91. Baso Flood Ell/V, PIA fOR ltt.[ tlL.'"tU~"'l1J.s.r: Of 1M-t U(J-tfO~' tll.....lb tJ-,uu, (It'l tf.t" CIJf\-4!.NT OWhC'I.lOT lttC -fJROI1.J1h'. ..,.D AL::.o TuO:lir "~10 "'JIHC..A,~[. UOBTOA.llr 011 [lU...Iu".rr:L tu( 1'11Lf tl1UI[ to "'HISJ~Q fUOU.Io '1l4....S,4ChO... ~hvot. ~~HQ, 't.~ cuhUl Nt 'OfJ""('l W11t"'~ ~IC' UOlth1::111l01,11 rMl! [}41f hfo'" D+. A-LitO ~"'~Slotl-t.'u.t fOllll_t, ~ { H,IHOI\lO~~\1tU ht~ ,u'm~,1 htllUr C[AWi lOnuCl:~'''CY II JCf~! SUCH L1SfUI"!~, ,. MI', "..1 "A' ~f LOCAUO "'LOW W( S"I.r.CE {J,'lHt l,L~lIS, Ol\ ON HiE $UArA(:( Of 'Jlt ......I1-D$.-.I.O HO' lI1SJUlU AJiU tU4f 1t'lt \u""VCY RrPfl(,NNHDHUt(()f.t UHfS '~Il. WIlU'Ul.Illi f1lQIMUL.I('1rSOE Ct14pn'~ 2" ti,.. H{hll' A/III,HISIIIlIl'o'r COOl 10 lilt !lalOO' LAY .HD'nltl).)t .hP lItuU !t.g lWtIrty ....IIU" 00..[ "'''lOlI! r." Ut~.... 11tVll."""r CV"~~lt sr""cIl S~"'U NOI VAUO IJHlU~ llllK>UIIlI'I"" &IJlIVI'o'IlOU """. ?..(.:'~ . '-C- '1l1.fl~IIH(NooK'REIW.IOOOlI'U>I.\lOolUIQh'm""'1 toOll\} . ___~~_ ~ r e...,. ~ U,...i.....U ~... '1..' .",.., ..~... "'.....'...00 "~II' ,,'OUJttl~'''J .. ~ ,,!, ~tO' 1.i1lOo.,\1-.::, ...41" _......~"" j ..... r~""'" /' of C 11II .. ''''''''"0(:01+:;111 U """",,"*'''' ... "'r. "I . POi...' tit 1.......'C'&).til hili .. 'Iu.., .C _ ....::11 {)lie..... "'~""\I."",~..:ro.)]:rn)'" t...t;HUII.lIL ."u.-I'UoilI.{Ji.I.."...CL,IN_.......J ........IIII...~IlI...... .., U",tu".~..I"T ~~.~I'.:r.:.D~-""-ltJ ~or~~Jo~t~ ~"f ~:.S~~:::..c:..U/..rJ(;\rt4....,lJItt ~;.~;::t"fP(b-"",.r :... =.~'::~t;:,"at.' / ., "-'''D~.''IH...::t ~"oII! .....u.;t'1 LV....... II' ~. O.........O"'-MI~....t f.... hJo. '_'.....Uht...""'t,..,,'....... ,.. .~.'IIIiI.t..""....Lft tL;"'i:lo\.AlIIiI1.....,l~. r',....lItlOl".....~11~. .....I:!'liI...I..ettU"............, w.,1'IoI-""L\""fl, _-.:__----..-..-.................. c......... ..t""........., . ~ ...I"DiIlI..~_..,.I.t ;.. 1II'~'lllj)""~'"'' ~. ..".....1......." _......__---_............_>_ 0 E' .3 ~ 2 -e 4 < ~1 ... 0' ~ 10 t ~ ~ fOO 32 0 "'CKINLEY '" 3,3 It) ~ E 31Z 316 10 IIIl ~ ... :}4, 8 7 6 5 8 35 J6 '1- 37 ~ 10 IIIl '" ~ ~ 30' 51 0 HARDING ID It) '" It) Z1Z zrl :g :g ~ ~ ~ 8 6 5 8 < tS ~ a IIIl eo ~ DREW DREW T 17 16 ~ \; - ~ e----- '2 ... ... i ~ 18 il ;:;jll ~~ ... "l 11\ ~!~..!:~ l!! ~ STREET ~~l:t=;; '" ~ zoa .., ... 11\ 11\ 11\ CIo 11\ l!! ~ ... - .... ... - 8 9 10 11 12 17 16 15 3 ~ = a 10 11\ CIo : ... - - - [~ ID fA t ~~ 80 [ ~ 1!!!~::J ~ r.,~~;;:~t;g: 60 ~~~ ~ acr.. o.lOtIO!DJ ... --"""j-_..... lD Lf1'~ o 0 I 0 " .......,,::::- N N N "'1t...., ~~r @ >- Q:: <( I- I tiS J . W 1109 4 ::::l. Z I 5 ~ i 105 , l'D' 6 I ; t;:'F' ~.:J 19 7 114 J 5 J '108 ~ 109 Z 4 I ~ 104 -< 105 100 jf.) 5 11'-- rG~S 103 '-' I ' 6 18 I Q 1,9 i j I 16, ~ , 15 10' I:! , 8 10 j ~ ' 9 :3 112 115 2 W 2 108 ::::l 109 ~ J .3 1041 -< 105 2 4 2 112 115 110 \ ~ 109 .3 ~, \ Z I ~ OJ: 106 I -< 105 4 C\J, \ (J 101 5 I 6 -:;:-..., 100 ,D, \ ,Sr--11S F, I 7 20 19 6 \ e ,,\ ~ I" 7 ~_: 7 12 I ~ I Z, 9 \. 9 8 ~ :>~~~\ :n' 2 114 tiS 2 4 ...J ~ wO o I t-U l/) Gl u..! n::: u >- .::,:: . ~ 6 5 \ Z 5 I 9 8 t03 4 I E ~ I 19 5 1 7 l- 1'5 1:'- \ w! 6 . :::!: ' , o : E-< I '0; U I It 7 ,..... i .. .~ z, ::J' 178' \~ I I Ii .::... W :2 w 5 C\J L CO C\J 7 6 B 7 ." NAME: C.\~IY\O-f\ II~-l-ky(\c\*'.t,~ Aum \r\L. I SV#.q~-(~)p,. PUBLIC HEARING DATE: ATLAS PAGE: 2y{)A SEe: J G TWP: '2.c1 S. RGE: Is E. ~~_CLEARWATER: ~'ITY COMMISSION~ , ' ~ ~ \ <'f. ~ ~ 1 .w I ~ ~~ ..Ul 15 -..", <:> - . ill:! :{.tllU:pUlq ;;. 6\ . S '11 0 <Q on =- 0: VI o <J tPo '" > ..... I gj I >- I '"l cD I , I 0 , ... I , I .... ... I :.:l I ~ . ;,,\,! ~~ln:l.t~H -::i ..; /7 '" D'. I c> '"1 .~ I - ::l I .. \0 :. Q I " ... , ~ u '" \ \ co . ~^''' 0I:t1l1. '..- '''^\' PUl:T1i3iii \ , ... I Ul 1 ..; ... L Vl .. I ]: 0 I .u u I ... <-. t I \ , .., D:: 3 U ... 1-0 ::l ~ .... '^, ..<:: ... 1-0. o ;G, o r::::J . PI! o / I --- -------...-- ./ I ' Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Itllm tI Hlletlng Dote: ___ 1-"" > ':D. Ih'lh1 , SUBJECT: Variances to the Sign Regulations; 19400 U,S. 19; Florida Family Investors, Inc./Kenyon Dodge (Owner/Applicant); Joshua Magidson (Representative). (SV 93-34) RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: Deny variances to permit nonconforming slgnage to remain on property identified as Sec. 19-29-16, M & B 14.01 for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 H3), (5), (6), and (8). o and that the appropriate officia\s be authorlted to execute some. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to permit an existing freestanding sign to re~ain: 1) An area variance of 122 square feet from the permitted 112 square feet to allow a total of 234 square feet; 2) A height variance of 16.9 .feet from the 'permitted 20 feet to aI/ow a total height of 36.9 feet; and 3) A ,setback variance of five feet from the five foot setback requirement to allow a freestanding seign zero feet from the right-of-way. The subject property is located on the west side of U.S. 19 approximately 270 feet north of Ham Blvd. and is in the Highway Commercial (CH) zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the' following table. Information Existing Permitted Type of Sign Freestanding Yes location/orientation of sign U.S. 19 Yes Area 234 square feet 112 square feet Setbacl< o feet 5 feet Height 36.9 feet 20 feet Revlowed by: Legal ' Iludgl!t Purchasing Risk Hgmt. CIS ACM Other NIA Il/A ilIA , NfA ~fi~ ~' HIA OriginalillD DAJII:~ D PLANNING ~~L,PMIIF Cosls: Total Commlnion Actlon: o Approved o Approved IIfcondi t ions o Denied o Continued to: Uur DDJII: Current Fiscal Yr. "'''''7{' ~ City ~l~ ' AdvIlllud: Oil te: 09/1B/93 Pilp~r: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not ReCl\J ired Alfa~IBll PlIrlins r:l Notified o Ilot RNluired FundillD Source: o Cilpi tal Imp. o Ope rat i n9 o Other Allichm.nll: APPLI CA T I ON VARIANCE ~ORKSHEET HAPS o None AllllIOJllialioll Code: o I',. fltcd on r'ccyct cd P,lfHH' " SV 93-34 . PAGE 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: The new sign ordinance is being uniformly applied to all signs in this zoning district. The applicant contends this property is unique in that it is located on U.S. 19 south of Clearwater Mall, one of the busiest stretches of highway in Clearwater, and requires signage which would allow proper notice to motor vehicle operators. However, this is not the only business in the vicinity and cannot be considered a unique property for this reason. The applicant has not provided any evidence that these variance requ,ests arise from any conditions unique to this property . These variance requests are extreme with regard to the permitted area, height, and 'setback of a freestanding sign and cannot be considered minimal requests. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction II Existing Land Uses North South East West Kenyon boat dealership Sunset GMC auto dealership Arbor Shoreline professional office park Florida Power right-of-way, single family residential Automobile and boat dealerships exist on the properties to the north and south of the subject property. A professional office park is located directly across U.S. 19. The existence of this 234 square foot, 36 foot high, freestanding sign with a zero foot setback is not in character with the signage permitted for the commercial businesses in the area. The granting of these varitJnces will detract from the commercial businesses that have conforming signage, permit an unfair advertising advantage to tile tJpplicant over the surrounding businesses, and negatively impact the overall appearance of the community. .8..gplicable Variance Standards To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review tJnd analysis of tile information contained in the application, staff finds that, the petitioner's request meets only two of the standards. In particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully met: (1) The' varinnco requested arises from n condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither orcJinmily or uniformly applictlble to the zoning district nor created by an action or nct;ons of tho property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistuke mude in the execution of tl building permit or work performed without the beno,fit of u permit shull not be considered to be situations whicl1 support the granting of a vmiance, ' (2) Tho pmticulm physicul surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involvod und tllo strict nppHcntion of tho provisions of this developmont code would result in nn unnecossmy hmdship uPI:;ln tho npplicunt. , , , . , , , , SV 93-34 PAGE 3 , \ (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the 'unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital u2u for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property. is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the commu'lity, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, ~r substantially diminis~ or impair the value of s~rrounding property. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE ,. SV 91-02 25191 U.S, 19 Dimmitt 1) Freestanding sign 3/21/91 Cadillac height (1 6.5 sq. ft. addl)lDenied 2) Freestanding sign , area (17.3 sq. ft. addD/Denied SV 91-15 25191 U.S. 19 Dimmitt Freestanding sign 8/1 5/91 Cadillac height (16.5 addl)/Approved SV 92-27 2085 Gulf.to-Bay Carlisle 1) Freestanding area 12/3/92 Blvd. Lincoln (9 sq. ft. addl)1 Mercury Approved 21 Freestanding height (5.7 ft. addl)/Denied 3) Auxiliary height (2,6 ft addl)/Denied 4) Two directional signs to remain (32 sq. ft. addl)/Denied 5) Attached sign area , (98 sq. f1. addll/Denied '" " .q M I M en > en a:: w aJ ~ ::) 2 w en <t C,,) f- w w :J: en ~ a:: o s: w C,,) z :$ a: <( > III "0 z o z [l: \.I" 1.1. ~ .'0 J2 t) ~ ':J::C.!l~>- u......1::.I; c ~ g :w.... . to .11 III tT .: t e "U en ~ ~ " 2 ~.... "0 II Q. lit- 'i:w5 ~ [,; ~:i'::Z:...= .!1c;.;j! ~~!gsg - ~ CJ f:.., tr' ~BUt."O~ .2'.2co~to ... _ u 0 ....11 >.!!:Ii! c lit ... IJ J:! It ~ o-=~~;ii ..CS'c.>u> ~'5~04J1l ~c....._~~ a:";oeo; IS ;:I :J ..... ~ ; ,.,g.cO.,-s ESS..l,l jJ2~.g1~ _>,"0.,1:; 5t:;:~:;> ~~-= 8.:5 =.. .-2:1o.!:!>ou .8a...ca.:-cg. .~:E.sl~~a ,,:-o~~~,!! U"O IQ ";-= ~~~~=2o ~~~;~~: QU= ::I~& E.E~~.tlIll'i: ft B ~,~ -E 2 : ~'a.iilaEI: "0.~8.l3.2 CG....c....~:S AI 1.1 : c ... c. I: ~f-u.~l! g-B .. c .2 ,t: 't2 I: o 1,1 "3 :co 0. ~ c> a 0. .2 .. a to Q. a J:: .. ti;>. ~; 't2 Po. I: <) ~ a t:.!l :lJ:: .. .. ~i i. ,e- J::.I: 0.1; =; =; :iJ:: of :. " I: Q.~ g ~ to 1,1 ii] to > Ijo ~ ',s to 't2 o U to .. '5 ti - E o Po. .. a co; .g ~ i:i't2 I:J:! B'5 "i_ u a :c .. ~~E c,:Ii 3 R~2: 2 n. c ~ " OJ OJ::,l:; " - .. 0. - I: .. 0 a -;~g. .. -; .~ ~.S:! ~ :.0 Q."E c a. a :I ".s:. f .. > ~ 'S ~ WI ,.. ~ "3" " '" tS ~ >- '0 r: .<: I: I: a. a :I .i "H i a ~.S: ';;:' ~ ~ CI .s 11'I a.>", " t: ~ t: 8.~ - 0 0 ~ ii. J '0 I: " .: J:: ~.; ..:: 0; .; .. .. g. ; ~ '0 .=E: ] ,5 ;; E o.'t2 .. .. J:: .. .. .. s~ 1! li " 1,1 g'.8 oS '0 'i Z ..,3 E"O ~ <:: .. " ~ g, !! .~ a Cl :! .5 ..'t2 " c :I a r~ .. ::! 1,1- I: a -!- a 0 >jl .. u .. .. ...tl ~ ~ " Co .: :c: .:; 0 ~ :: .<: :I . ?: u :~ .. .. 8 g .. .. ~ g :I ;;, " I: .s:i a E ~ Bo ;; " > .. o &. s ;; >0. ~ " ..'5 .. ~.e " ~~ e] .c 'u 'E ::! " go ;S'6 .~ ~ " " g a J/. ,Ii ~ 0 > - ,,'0 J:: ::! ,.. ;; 't:i - - c !l::!.s "i > o ii. Co " .. 1,1 c .s ~ > .. ..!! 'E .. '0 I: a 0; .11 ;S ;S 'i > Q. E o 1,1 S .. ;; " Co 0. CI - .. " :I tT ::! to ... e .!l ;; > J:! ..:: ,.. ~ 0 ~ :! ;; o 2 aI uE~ce :E:=a :3 8 ~ 5 ~E~g 't:I - ;> j 3'S n '" Q ~ ~ ~~~~E :a Iii C i~+i! ::1:; ~ ~ ~ ~ ... "'D' IIa U ... '0 -& :: .~ :c],,,'i .."Q.- g ~;g 8 ;tD6~ci t'l ~ ~ " eo .:.2tM>1;I o ... iU 0 E: J!~g:~ ,,-oS':c> !.t::;>"c ~~ oE ~!:Qo ~~.s~c ~~_;3 ~!! CJ 0 ~ = oS "fi ~ 0 Cl oJ:.E~: tJ ... :! . ~ ggtnc" ::! ~ D :i : .~.:&' ~ ~ = J( U I CJ. '" 1.1 ~ .; CI 5 ~ii:~!; I- " :;J ... ..a .. .5 :J '5Ct ~; ~~!~~~ :ill! !!0i1l 0 0'" 11:1 U n . .. .tl :!i 1,1 "0 ~ II] ~ 5 i;~~E; €~~~E& l!~].~Bg- .!~~~.s~ ~ ~ oS ;S "e > ;;"gS2: .R"tJ;:;;;:-S t:: U I) II" U .... ui~.t;~~ g.g-E"o. ii.-:.rt~.s u....s!Ia.= >- ,<:jl.c..~o; ~;~W:-! 00.<) C u ~g;~c~ .!! :;: .. oS " :o~j ~~ ,,-o...:.c .e-~-S=:::G !~ ~"i.! ~ ..!i .. c .. .... G :~ ~no~ -a - '1"1 4a CI): III ~:~t~'f ~>-.II.5c.o ~t'5oti-= ag.o~.:g> ~D.t:J!,;=-E ~~5~"~~ ~~'~i~~ ~ c .e II" ~~i~ ~.;! ~ 5 .. C # 0 o ., "0 ... ..iitiS .c .D .. g ~ .~o o>::~ >-~ a- n' 5 t ~ g.E 01" .. E i;S ;3-:i g.l! '5 ~ U ... tJ .- "D.... 11I'I ... " .0 " 0 i8tii ... ; .s Ji i ~ ....s iE~~-:' :; C ::: = c .. ~ .! J:: 1,1 C s:: .. ,_ ~ 'i E :g .. CI 0 a...~ ~: ~ ; ,~ ~ ... (; : ~.~ ~ -5 >.'';: l Qt::~ Dl8.g''' ,Ii !! B .S ~ a. 1,) ~ ~C-S~ tJ'I" u tj ,;. "' ~ .. .. 1: ~1lg~~ !. !! ~, Q. Q. '. 'ii > o ii. Q. 1;1 " ... C ,S C > o - 't:I ;; 'U C " .. II .!! ;S -= 'i >- Q. E o 1,1 o .. 'Uo C Cl ".5 5.1:1: '><:!! " .. E'c, .. e .. -s~,C . > ,.. > e -= W IJ CeO. ~ II 3 E :i ~ Blj r..."U a 01 I: .. 1: " f U It ~ a ; ; s ~ -2 ~ .!i ii " .. .!! -:0-:'';; ~~-Bo ;.s]j S:m"- a'5-.s .Y :'.2 U3S: o I: ~ t) >'gtT.D B ~ ~ S ~ f is Ii _ D. M IJ -o~::B: c III a CI .2~;S8 ~ ~ ~ j ~;';~ u.!l 0 > ~ 6, LII S ~ Ci..; ~ I ~ ~ "0 .. .Ii OJ :5 >- "E ~ i.~-5~ ~ 2t)o~"5 c.~ ~..:.::E ~,;~O~ ..'g~~.. (I :tn c: ... c .-c-O.2 CJ "2 0 .~ ; &2:ea 1:u~lJft :J...c: CJ Go I) .::t;'ODI.D ~ ... ~ .5 a ..!:!oYo.;g= .&. ..c ..: ~ ... lB~.Dt c'a.~,=:2 .9:",aa~ ~:'?:c::o :iE[,g~ cJ _ 0 EI .D ~ a to. '" .. e:a:-~g .g~;~"ii o.......~ ... > 0 VI ! r.; " .5 _ .ii.2~.~ ~ ~ U E IJ c.i ; 0 ~ ~ : g ~ ::; 0 ~ '0 "! c,"5 = .. .... Q !"it.e,~C;> Bci>~.= c.!lee,8a .!~Iol~,,(II. III " > ,J::.6 >c~E:c ~.!~~g& _ ~ ~ ~E v =trUII~-6 ,s .. C B <= a. Co .. "' .: .. o ::! ;; " '0 " ;S C a Q. :I ~ ~ >- ._ t: a~ "0 0 ::: Co " " .tl.: .. .. g! .!!! c " 5 ~ ~ ,!! - ;; .!l > 1,1 c ~ !~ ; ! .. a :I " ~Ot .. ~ " ... a :r ~ .. " .: o s~ .. " :I 'ij .2 u 5.2 :5' .!! Q ~ Ii " e go .. ii. .!i " t-5 "OJ: >.!:! =..c .~ ~ <; e ~] " 0 .tl..c .. 0 0.0 1:,c '" 'i '~ " " ~ -s .~ .E .. > ,1:1 ;S .. E " E - " a ~ 01 ~ ,!! r c' II .. r 0 ~~ i5 8- ~ ~ !! II " Co a. " - .. " :I I:T ! .. .. r: ,[!! a > .r! ~ .. " 't:I o i- J!. " .. o .. C " .5 't2 C .. .. -;: Q. .. Ii ;; e " DO " ;S .. .s o ';_'0 e e ~ "0 ::! '0; " 't2 " 1,1 c .N OJ > .. Ii '5't:1 - 3 l) .. tile .s ~ e 0. ~ .5/ DO " ~ t ,..'0 !!~ ~ ., t'l .., ~ ~ ) .. c:: It ~ ~ .<: .. "i " .: 1,1 <= .tl :I a. " '5~ U .2 " :I :: E " E .?o " .. !! .. ".: > .. '0 " - a o " I: ..! SO; ~ ~ ]Ii '; ~ " " '0 DO " .. 1,1 0 e . .! 8 II C : ~ t: ~ e is 8 , , ~ .. , .:j.5'O 5"(1 :,h~ · PROPERTX OWNER(S) NAME & ADDRESS: REPRESENTATIVEIS) (H ony) NAME & ADDRESS: I I I i ,1 j I I I I .. R OOlnA FM1l1 V ltNFSTms~ Hr.. 19400 U.S. 19 North ' :': Clearwater. FL 34624 , " JOSHJA Ml\GI[)S(tol, ESQ. Baynard, Harrell, Miscara, OstcM,& Ulr~ch. P.A. 20050 u.s. 19 N, Suite 501 Clearwater, FL 34621 ,TELEPHONE: I &'13) ~3'_ ?L/L/'I TELEPHONE: (R1~) 796-2525 . ,ADDRESS OF S~BJECT PROPERTY: 19400 u.s. 19 N., Clearwater, FL 34624 NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPLlCABLEI: Kenyoo CtO;Je ZONING DISTRICT: CH LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: ClF-LUP LAND AREA: LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: See attached deed PARCEC NUMBER: 19 I 29 I 16 I CXXXX) I 140 I 0100 (This information is available from your tox roceipt or contact Pinellos Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462.3207. If more than olle parcel number, attach 8 % x 11 inch sheet) DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: ,r Car dealership r.ar dealershin North: South: East: West: HiglMaY Residential .- ~~.. w VARIANCE(S) REQUEST (If Variance 10 7 year amortization requirement. refer to Sec. 134.0151: " 1) M3xirrun height - rEquest for variance to allCM an acklitiooal 16 feet 9 1/2 inches of height - Code Sec. 44_!l1 (4)( f)1.r. I .v-". ~~ ~). ~ I~nun area -. all"" an additiooal ~ sq;~ of REASON FOR REOUESTING v ARlANCE(S): lRefer to Stnndards for Approval. next page) 1hi~ variance is Y'eQLJested because the prq;erty in c:uesti01 is unique in th'at it is located 011 U.S. 19 5ouU, of tM r.lPi'lrwrltpr I1Rll ~ich is a1e of the Cusiest stretches of Highway in Clearwater and reqUires sfgnage ""i1ich -W:lU1d.-al.lo.Yrf1"r ;m')I1!1t nf mtice....:to.JID.tor:.yeb~rs. In addi tion. the site is near COU1ty pro- . D?rty \'t1ich is oot under the city sign cede am has less restrictive sign regulations. , \ \ CONTINUED ON REVERSE SIDE " , ., , , STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance shall not be granted by the City Commission unless the application Dnd evIdence presented c10erly support the following conClusion's:' ' (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property In question and is neither ,l?rdinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an ,/lction or actions 01 the property owner, predecessor in title. or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building pernlit or worl( performed without the benofit o1'a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance, 121 The particular physicol surroundings. shape or topographical conditions 01 the property involved ond the strict opplication of tho provisions of this development code would result in all unnecessary hardship upari the applicant. (31 The variance is the minimum necessary to ovorcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recitel "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land, I 141 The request for a variance Is not bosed primarily upon tho desire of the applicant to secure /l greoter financial : return frem the property, ' I 151. The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improve!nents' in the neighborhood in which the property is located, 161 The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property. detract from thel appearance of the comrnunity. s'ubstontially increase the congestion in the public streets. increase the dangor of fi~c. endanger the public safety in any way. or subs.tantially diminish or impair the value of, surrounding property, . 171 The~a~iaiice '(Jbsircd will not adversely offect the public health, safety. order convenience. or general welfore of the community, (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code, ~/~ Before me. the undersigned authority. personally oppeored Joshua M3gidsoo deposes and stoles the motters and facts set out above ore true ond correct to the best of his/her Imowledge ond belief, SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER lOR REPRESENTATIVE): S\\rorn to and subscribed Rt>>o~~.~~e t~l' .......~f\ A. l "1 , ~~>9"\ .....nh..(Jo P, . .. ~ .' , < :~~ ...~ 0 T.4 f:/ ~"'~ , : ! Mr ColTlm. !;1pI11'11 '..:n ~ : : I Nuv.?Il. 19(1.1 t , -; : Nil, cr..oo1617 : -: ~ ~ Ra...h\t......., : : I, tJl ", 'AlWcu..lor...O'" '~ ft, :;. ", lJ B L \ .,' ","r: ! ..,.... " " "c."" " 'it:' ......iI'...O~ _-~ . ",', ()F f'~ ....- NOTE: PROPERTY OWNER 'OR REPRESENTATIVE MUS" A1TEND HEARING, A,D,. 19 q1. ") / otary Public Sardra A. L€Clai r ReV. 1 Z/9 1 " :: .., '" , 0: 0-.... " , I ~ " .', I I . ' . ,. ".1 .;~:' I . " , .~ I ' ~,':.}\:;:.,'i~~',":."." ~~ .fi.,': " '{ .1. .. ,1 .T I' . t .\.' !.t';~~':. ,: !:..,~. " . , ., , ' +)' ~ /4. ~..t.. /I " ,. " . ~ ~1'J ..-.9 t ~ . . i' ...__0 _,:""~H. . . ..If' o ~ ,,' " .. '1, 'J .' '1' .' " '-..: " ., ,. ..... " ,; \ .c . I 1 . ~ c, , " ,l " , " " i " . '.\'+ T\ ....."..cl' : \' , I' " ' ;,". ...':. " ,<I, . ,\: , " .<:." \.~ i" .. ~ ' ,~ " " " I' " ". oJ ~ .., I' )~. ,. I.' ~. . ~ ,,' .,. ;\" , : . . .. ~ " r .' I " " : ,; , " ... ~ ~ ~ . ,\ ~ . 1.', ,'. "~"~ ,.;-- J",:' ::-' , t';?'" ' ~ ,'", l~~:':f:":: :', ,'. 'c', , " ,: , " ,,' ", l'.l . .l ~ " 1.:<' ,I , . ,<' !. ',' " , .. ',0 t ", I' '. '... J f 1:/. 't"' '.: .~ ~'.' ~ > .:. I' , '::. ;:" ~ ;' ~'."~ , , .. '. " .1,' ", ;-, ~' I c, .', ", ,I , "'1'.,' . .'.j..!", '," ~('i :,~ ,,:..-i !l;<';~.' ;,; :'" t:. '1 ~~ , ,. " , ., " .. , . .:'" ~ i ..' * , " o ~ \, '. ",. ~ ~ . I . "~ .,". l'" , , ',,"'!.'f . . ~ ,:.. I ,.. " , , , , ," ~. 1- " ." ',' HI ,I, i~.- I r;OT c ',. , , cl ',1 '0, , , , " J.. I,:" , ' ~~\Qv\H9~H~g..:Ff---4t~~..,-, - r-- . , .:' 1 " 'I' ". ..! " , ____....... ......,~ .... _ 4'" ._~,..._..__. ..._. , ' l' . ; t !, . of. " " , , ,J,I'.'" ':"1' ,J'l .h".' !' \. I ;,",1 ( .' ~:~~~~ )', . ,. , J':!' ! ?- . ~ " '0. 2~ I ",. " '/ " , " ,: I ~f:I~ ~Or'U ~ ~ I _.,t.. ,,' " ~ .: ~. J' , c' -.J :r :J ~, ,'" i' ''1<. , L ~ f .' ',I' .. I,~ .,' , " " ., ..i, ,I " 1: >;1, ,> , ,< ,I J ',' ,! ': ,~ ... ih ',01 , :j, '''B 41, ,~ " " " ",:.: t:, ~. '";- ~;'~ '.. , " " ',: " , ." '., ".. " " . " " " '. L'; > .~" I : 1 " , 1 .' " ... I!) .e g "5 IP ')- ,~ " ~, -'I: i, '. .. . ,", "". i-: :.L' f ," f , " ", '- " " '" , " ". " ", ,'- ; \ ;,' ", 1-;. ',' .f ,I , , ", " :. ~ '" '.'" ., " , , " " "'1. - ..~. c~~ " ''-i , ..... -> " " " " .f ... t I' , . ' ... z ;j " , ,t ' l . , t \oJ ~ I. , ' " '. . .~ " ',. t ,I" I,. " ... '. ">I . '., .' " ,I 'f ,/ J.', " ,. '. " \, " .. " " I, ,. , t '/ , ' , i, '. c' " ,I' ~ 'I; 'l ... 2 :, "2"":'~1';' , , ' . f l' ", , , , , i' . ~" '., !. +' ,\ ''','1. I'. , " ,~ .J ,I . . , " , ) "i 4~ '. t , \ . ,OIi:C '0 " , <~ " , 'l , , ,,> . , >- -d.: 3: I u_ o ..!- ::c o n:: , 4/01 /ryl./o ISO ~ en I.IJ 10 I I;';,.,', l.lJb J..hf' I li611 ---- ~ 127S 200- 18 1271' B 11 12 5 1272 ~ 1270 17 0 1279 4 17 12 ~ 11 6 Z1S 0:: 1277 '276 ~ 1276 C 0 1285 0:: 1285'6 16 13 10 7 :J '2835 '204 t28t m It) '288 '2115 15 IZIl, !l0 ~ ~ GO ~ 1289 DRIVE 6 CIII rJ ~ .... ... 'OlI ~ ... ~ ~ ::J 18 1/04 '6 15 14 1J 8 7 12 II arr OlWlED 79 PROPERrt 11/061 a: vi 11/06 KENYON DODGE 92- 59 "'l~~~"""~~~~'~'~'~'~""""''''''-'''''' '200' C H , ,I 0) - 14/0J '320 /'13'20 n:: W Cl 3; ... 0 vi D- ::) CTI l-E I 14/04 '330 ~ f9:l'fG '" a @] MORNINGS IDE l E 'T 1340 8 I I<fZoe. ~ ~ Q)RM28 F II 14/05 li 14/05 ci 8 0 5 79 4- <:> ... ~ ... ... ~ ~ ~ HARt-! ~-~~_~~fI6 n 1II nl~ VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS , .... , . . BLVD. o U) I I I I I I I g I 7 I ,""6 ... I ~f . I ~I '" " ~ !:: :1 ,sao 19119 .~lIn N A ME: . F LO~\DA ~II-Y 1'-.\{c~TO Ie. S. k'€'I-l YOIJ t)ocx::r E: SV#..:J3-.~Y- PUBLIC HEARING DATE: ATLAS P A G E:..Q93-fi SE C: I q _ TWP: 2C( S. RGE: ~ CLEARWATER crrv COMMISSION I I C, E. ~~ " ~l~ la c--::::: " ' ) ,'. , I <1 < " r " . 1 ,,' , :c,' .', " ". ". , . ~~' : .'t"! . ,t':' ,': ':L,' Jl I, " ~ti:,,",,':?, "~;;. :, ,l "C':". _ l. J>O, 'J '.~)..:",. ''';:''~~:.'c'..:~, ,'~~., f' \," " :.~'<' ~ . I > ;}, .,:t' ,"',,'. ~.,"..,;,; :;,::' ~:, /~>,~ :/~ ~";':1 /r; ~'.,::,,:;,\ i~' ~~, , . }. t ~..; , +' I ~ c'\ ' l,t' :j I ~ >1.:. , , , I , , .' , , , " " ',:.', ;, .:' :' "c ~' .' "'1, c" ~. ., .' r: .. I"~, : c c~... ' . ~ ~. " I' -', '" ',I' .'," .' ci';:;.c .' . '.' ~ > , " cl. ,,, '. \ . ", >. , , , .i,'C 'f ".:.:.( ..' .t"' ~ ~ I :,1' :',',:, ' I. . ~;~ ~ :" !'" " ", ~ ! " " .. j .~..' '~'. 'j ! ~ ....P. -"(". 'j ~. \ ;.: , , , " , .....+ - ..~. I' '.t . .. ..' ~ 'r, l.. \' " . '. l. ".i ~ k. t . ~,. '1 ~.t ',_ .. j , ,~. . ".'L':"h:). ~ . " l f.~ ,-; ,~. .' ~...:.:,'~?o,;"" ...~.'.,~::.~..:t'~.. :'~~ t: ':: ~\ ,~:. '1-; I ';.' ., .;, ,,~' ." -:- ~ .' . :- " 1'- " . \, tit t, ,; ," , , ... .'\ ~. .r . ~,! j ).. , . : - " " " .. " .. .1 ,', ,j .:, " I c, , j, ~ I. ' :/,i '} . '. ~~. . . : " 'T',> ". . , , .' I': " .' J" .',' " ~'" ,> ,;. + < , , " " \. " ~ ~ " " :' . I ~:. , " , " '. . " , . ,~ ' ~. ' , , , ,', ..p- "l". " -t, ~ ' , . , , , " ~ . ,,;' . J.t. c, " 'i c' ';,' , " ,\ ,. ;1 .... " or i' . I ~ . \ , { '; ':\ : .,1. ',' )" ... ! ~ . . . , , ' i, i . '~ ,. " , ',' -4 ' . t . ~ " ll, ~ " ~ ", , " .t.... , I , .~ ~ . I AGENDA , , ') >1' . ~ ~, . ". " ';1 ::'}:,~:":. ,.' " ",,':. . .. ," , , ,,<' . ~ I ~ 1'-,,' . ~} L , " )' .j .' ~; ,1 . ~ \ c'. .~ \ 0 : .. ~ . .) !. ',' l ' ~ " , " F;,~ ,,:: f '~ ~ ~;'; 0, \. . '. !., '" ' !.':;::;'I~ ,: " - 'c ,I Ct.. '. " , " '.,H " , " , ' ,: ,CC{. f' ~ <~ <, ' ','. , , '" " .e , ' ~~_'91j l\ ~ '; ~ ....c...' ~ i: ~ :t,' .. 'i " .:"'1 c".- ~1 'D'ATE.-;j <, ~. ,I,C - 4 ".~.. - , 'c , ) \~:'. , /. ~,' \ ~ " . , . , , " , , ~ ~ > : , ' , " , ~ ~ ~ " . ..! :',' " iF 'le , ' ,iTEM' /I-l " > ,~ ; , , ,. [' , I " ' ,>, ,1 >' !." I', ,. ,> ./ I ~ ~ .~ ~ ". C 1 \. 'I 'l- ,. , , , ' " , ' " " I'\. :., .',1 , ' . ~ ~ . I. ';'1 < . . ~, . . ," r, c)' '0' I, " ;( ,', ;/, C I ~ ~ ~', c , ; ~ .) n 'r , " , " ' , ' " .' I' .,"}!J ,,' J;,c . \ ~ l' , " ." " '. .' , ", Ii!'. ,\ " , 'cl ,I q f.' .,' , i .' .'\ c' ,: " . .~ >, , , , ':t' cot I .'; i ~ ': . . ' j: " , , . '. ~' 'J " ,. .' " j, ,f , - ,',,-1: '-1.\ H, , ' " I .' 1.1. ", '.,'" " .', , . -:' .,,1 , " I t' " ';" J-.c ' " , .It, '0 , ,I " " . ' .,.t; "IL' " , I, " Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item # Meeting Dote: I . i /~41?'I SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 706 Drew St.; William D. & Kathryn A. McKnight/Seven Oaks BP (Owner/Applicant); Bill Hardee (Representative). (SV 92-18) RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: Approve the variance to parmit two freestanding signs, 19 feet in height, 64 square feet in area, and setback five feet from the property line on property identified as Lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 11, 12, A, & 14 of Blk. 8, E. H. Coachman Sub., less the North 70 ft. of lots' 0 and 1', and less the North 20 ft. of lot A, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 H8). o and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a variance to permit two freestanding signs, 19 feet in height, 64 square feet in area, and setback five feet. The subject property is located on the northwest corner of Drew St. and Myrtle Ave., and is in the Urban Center (Core) zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the table below. Sign 1 I Sign.2 I Information Proposed Permitted Proposed Permitted Type of sign Freestanding No Freestanding No Location/orientation of sign Drew St. No Myrtle Ave. No Area 64 sq. ft. None 64 sq. ft. None Setbacl( 5 ft. None 5 ft. None Height 19 ft. None 19 ft. None Ihvtowod by: legaL Budget Purchasing Risk Mgrnt. CIS ACM Other ilIA ilIA ilIA N/A ~L /A Ortglnating Dopt: CENTRAL PERMITTING S~ COlli: Totol CommlulDn ActtDn: (J Approved (J Approved w/condltlons o Oenicd o Cont i nued to: Usar Dopt: ' Current Fiscal ~r. City Advlursod: Date; Popcr: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Requi red ^"octaLl Paulos ~ Notified o !lot Rcqui red Funding SourcI: o CnpltnL Imp. o Opernting o Other AUecll1ll611111, APPlI CA T ION VARIANCE YCRKStlEET HflPS o None Submiuod by: AI11llolulatlon elld.. o Printed on recycled paper SV 92r' 8 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: This property is developed with the Seven Oaks BP service station. Under the Urban Center (Core) zoning assigned to the property, no freestanding sign is allowed. Presently, there exists, a 45 foot high sign that has an areo of 64 square feet. The applicant proposes to replace the existing sign with the two lower signs previously described. One sign will be placed at the northeast corner of the property oriented to Myrtle Ave. The other sign will be placed on the south side of the property oriented to Drew St. Unlike most properties in this zoning district, the building is setback substantially from the right of way. Because the building is setback, the applicant would be disadvantaged and face a hardship if no sign is allowed in proximity to the right of way. Further, because the property fronts two maior thoroughfares, it would be appropriate for the property to be identified from both of the thoroughfares. ' SURROUNDING lAND USES Direction II Existing Land Uses North South East West Produce warehouse Electrical co. Architect Dry cleaners Properties located ,on the east side of Myrtle Ave. are zoned Urban Center (Eastern ,Corridor), Properties within this zone are permitted freestanding signs with an area of 64 square feet. Therefore, the signs proposed for the Seven Oaks BP service station would be in keeping with other signs allowed on nearby properties. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner' 5 request meets all of, the standards. In particular, the following standards do appear to be fully met: ' (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in Question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development codo would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The varianco is the minimum necessary to overcome tho unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recitnl112" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon tho desire of tl10 applicant to socure a groater financial roturn from the property. , .. . ' , , , \ l . I ~ .' , , } . I :' ~ , ' Ie, , ' :", ," l: '"I !'c ~ ~ 1 c I' , , I II, .1. \", , 't I' ":'. . t " . . ~ ' " '. 1) } '.." )' , ' , , '; '": ! ~c' . .. . , , ' . ~ \". '4. \.,' ',< o" (5) SV 92-18 Page 3 ' The granting' of the va'riance ,wili not be m'aterially detrimental or injurious to oth'er' " property or Improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. " (7) .' '.' I 'The granting of the variance will not impair 'an a'dequa'te supply of light or ventilation to , adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public ' safety In any way, or su~sta~tially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. The, variance desired will not' adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the,community. , The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and'intent of this' , development code. ' , ' , '. (6) (8) . ~ ;' Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: , There"have been no similar variance requests considered by the City Commission. . . . .' . ) , . " . ' t 'l " I I" I, ' '. . -I. 'I' " ,c , . , ' >, , , , " , . , ) " : , ," , \ . I. , . 1 . , : , , I, , " "t , , '. , . , . I ~. I " , , " , \ 'l , " .. . ;," ,I' J . ) . ,l VARIANCE WORKSHEET - CASE NUMBER SV 92-18 L STANDARDs FOR VARIANCE API'ROVAL 111 Tna variance raquaeted arl.u from a condlllon whlllh II unIque tll the property In qUllltkm end II neither ordinarily Ilr uniformly appllcabla to tha lllnlng dlltrlct nor Ilrutad by an alltlon or lIotlonl of tha prllperty owner. predecellor In tllIa, or thallppllcllnt, Any mlltlllte made In the uecutlon of II buildIng permit or work performed wllhout the benefit of II permit Ihall nllt be coneldere~ to be Iltuatlonl Which IUpport the granting of a varIance, 12.\ The palth::ulllf phYllcallurroundlng., shape or topogrllphlcal oondltlonl of the property Involved and tha Itrlct application of the provlll(lnl of thle development code would reluft In IIn unnecellllry hardlhlp uplln the applicant. 13\ The vlIrlance 'I the mInImum neoellory to ovarcoma the unnecnaary hnrd.hlp rllferrlld to In pracedlng recital ~2~ for the purpolD of milking reDloneble Ule of thaland. , 14' The rllqunt for a variance I. not billed prlmllrl1y upon tho do.II. of the applIcant to lacure II greater 11nanclal rClturn lor .thll proparty, ' 161 The granting of thl, verlance will not be materially detrlmanta' or InJurloul to other property Dr Improvamllntlln the nelghbOlhood In whIch the ptopeny Is IClcated, loj ,The grentlng of tha varlancll w11f not ImpaIr an adllqUllte .upply of light or vantllatlon to adJaoant proparty. dlltrllet hClm tho appillllance of the community, .ub.tantlally InereDla the eongeltlon In the public Itlaot., InCtall1ll tha dllngl!l' 01 flra, IIndangar thll publle IDfety In eny way. or sub.tantllllly dlmlnl.h Dr lmpnlr tha valull of lurroundlng propany. 17' The varlanca dulrad wl:1 not IIdvereely ,,!feet the public haallh, .afaty. order. convanlanoa. or genllllll welfare of the community, ISI Tho granting of the varlllnee dcslrad will not vlolalll the genarol .plrh llnd Intllnt of thl. davelopmClnt eode. I , STAFF RNDINOS Thl. proparty II unlqua boeaulIl, unlike other propartlCII In thl. lone, the building II letbllc:k from tha right of way. The applicant would fa 011 0 hard.hlp If tha property eould not ba Identllled with a .Ign In proximity to the right of WIlV. It would ba appropriate for thll property to be Idantlflad with I[gnl on MV1le Ava. and Drew St,; bClth of whlllh arCl mllJor thoroughfar... Tha varlonea eppllors to bll raquaeted prlmllrllv for the purpolll of llllowlng tha property to ba Idantlllad frllm thll adjoIning thoroughfarel. Propartln' locnted on tha oppo.lta slda of Mynla Ave. 'would be tI\lowed frellltandlng Ilgn. 04 square ftlet In araa, 20 faet hIgh. The, requested variance, uU,flu thl. oondltlon. ThCl reqUalted varlanca will not adverllllv affact thll health. IIIfely, wolfala, gl"en thll hardlhlp Identl1led In 112. ebovo., Boeoula the variance utl,flcs 1111 of tho preceding .tllndard., It will not vlolatll thelplrlt end Intllnt of the ooda. ' , , " , ' L:11 >( UI. L.L,.;j\I\'I'O\ i ~:~ "~.CCcipt '# I~~&l(bl i5@tS) SIGN VARIANCE APPLICATION S,,#-ClZ-"M"--' )ROPERTY OWNER(S) NAME & ADDRESS: REPRESENTATIVEIS) Iif allY) NAME & ADDRESS: Will(am D. & Kathryn A. McKnight PO Box 1110 Brandon, Florida 33509-1110 Bill Hardee 1201' Oakfield Drive Brandon, Florida 33511 rELEPHONE: ( 813) 681-4279 TELEPHONE: [813 681-4279 '~RESS OF SUBJECT PROPERrf: 706 Drew Street ,.1E OF BUSINESS (IF APPUCABLE): Seven Oaks BP :ONING DISTRICT: UC (C ) LAND USE CLASSIRCATION: Convenience Store LAND AREA: 84 -EGAl DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: FO ff50212-O; Plat CC6 Coachran, E H.. Prop of Blk 8, Lots 1 and 2 Less Street and all of Lots 3 & 4D 63 ft.' of Lots 10 & 11 Etc., as ~r tax roll. :JARCEL NUMBER: 09 I 29 I 15, I 16812 I 008 I 0010 (This information S llvoilable from your tax receipt or contact PineJlas Co. Proporty Appmiscr.s Office <It 462-3207. If more thon one Jarcel number. attach 8% x 11 inch sheet) I JESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: . ' North: South: Electrical Company Produce Warehouse East: Dry Cleaner West: House . \RIANCr:(S) REQUEST: Remove present sign. Install a 64'sQuare foot sign on Drew Street and install a 64 square foot slgn on Myrtle Street as indicated on the attached drawing meeting proper height and setback reauirements as per General Commercial Zoning District. Our facility is one of only two service ,station facilities that are located in the urban center district. ".:tEASON FOR REQUESTlNG VARIANCEIS}: (Ref Of' to SlDndords for Approval. nextpllg'c) Removal of this siqn would cause a financial hardship for the present dealer and APEC without being replaced by our request. The visibility of the signs is the lifeline for this location. Competition in this area dictates that we have appropriate signage to advise customers of th,e name of our brand. and the selli~g price of each grade of gasoline, which is important to our credit card business., .Our request isoto be given permission to'install the two signs as indicated on the site plan. CONTINUED orl nEVERSI! ~IOE r' I . , , . STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance sholl not be grnntlld by. tho City Commission unless tl10 application and 'JvidenCD pre~"ntod cloarly support tho following, conclusions: ' ' ", (11 The vllriance requested arises from (I condition which is uniquo to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicablo to tho zoning district nor croatod by on Jodon or octlons of tho property ,owner, predecessor in title. or tho applic:mt. Any mistake made in tho execution of 3 building oermlt or work performed without the benefit of 0 permit shnll not bo considered to bo situotions which support the granting of a varianco. , (2) ':he particulor physicol surroundings, shape or topogrophicol conditions of tho property involved :md the strict application of tho provisions of this development code would result in Dn unnecoss;u'f hardship upon the applicant. ' (3) The variance is tho minimum necessary to overcomo tho unnocessary hardship referred to in procedinlJ recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of tho land. !41 The request for a variance is, not based primarily upon the desire of the opplicnnt to secure i1 greater finnncial return, from tho property. ' . (51 The granting of the varianco will not be materially detrimentlll or injurious to other proporty or improvements in tho neighborhood in which the property is located. 161 The gninting of the varinnce will not impair an adoquate supply 0 f li~ht or ventilntion to adjacent prop'erty. detract from tho oppoaranco of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of firo, endanger tho public safety in any way, or substontially diminish or impair the vnlue of surrounding property. 17) The varianco desired will not adversely aHect tho public hoalth. safoty. order convenience, or general welfare of the community. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTI OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): Subscribed .nd swam ta lar .ffirme I belare me .his Iff!!:'v ~f ',.; v The granting 01 tho varianco dosired will not violate tho general spirit ond intent of this deve/apment code. , / .' /} , , . / I ~,. . / (~ ;I .. i ~/' ..j/ t I. ... . !1 ( . ( " I ..... - J '-;. ' / r, j1A.., (8) A.D. .192li by , who is pCr!;onally ---------.... , !mown to me and/ar has produced ----- (Typ. of id.nl"i~ 'ml STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF -- ;)s idcntificntion. m:ffyl'iiblic. Commission No. JOANNE C. JOHNScw,,' . COUUG.FJOH-I-f.G-tOOG1dllMfW of Notor'l t'/ped, prlntod or 5tOlnpedl ApI II 2, 1996 ' IlINDlO lIfIU "1IJ~, r~l~ IHSlJf\l./lCf ,1f.C , :. " , , . , . , " I ,::: ' " ' '~:. I ~ "' I ' ,~. " \' " " , . .,' " . t' ' I ~J j' " , , . '\ , " t " '\ , " 'j " , , ~ , " , , " ' ., , ' 1201 Oaktleld Drive ,p. O. ,Box 1110 Brandon, Fl. 33509.1110 , (813) 681.4279 , " . , >, f ',' .1 . , v~ c . . ~ ....' ~; . ..... \ :: '", I . ~','. ' ;' 1 r j . ' .;,'.. (. ;. l! I ... ,:., '. ',t' ~ ,I . . ~ ' .~ ' ;,' ' . : :,,:;,> : ' i~;;.': , . .'," t " , I' .!" \ .". c . ~. . c \0 i... ,. -l-.'. , ," . " ~ ,I APEC , ' " , " .,' , j " October 28. 1993 , , , , ~ ", < .' ,', " .' , , " ' " , ~ I . . . c' ,.1 ' " . 1,. . , > . ~ . , , CITY' OF CLEARWATER t L ". , " (<' , ' ': . . ~ :. , I, . ' ~" . J I. William D. HcKnight. give authorization ,tolBill Hardee 'to represent APEC .. ; " ,in sign variance application' filed' for70G Drew Street., ' , , I, ' , , " Sincerely, " ; , ','1 . jo' , ~ WY)1lJ) . . William D. , , ',1 L " , ' " .;": ! .. , , '. , .' / ' , . " , ' , , STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY Of HILLS BOROUGH .' . I, , ' I, . , , , Sworn to' and subscribed before me on 'this 28th day of October., 1993., persomllly, appeared \~illiam' D. HcKnight \'1ho' is known to me and who has signed \ t 'abov' ent. //~l~ itL& (_~ ~-L.--- C. J~" ' "~lr?Yrt~ : JOANNE C, JOHNSON ' ' [.{ ':.) MY COM"'~SSlorU cc t9Qlj7G EXPIRES \~. :f'~'i1.. Apr112, 1996 "~.r.f: ,\~l("., BONlI(O llllU 1110\' lAIN INSWHCt,I/,C. " " , t," ~ I , , 'e \' c 'I 't , , \ \ , ~ -~ \, " , I I l. " , ' , ' , , :., ~wo. ".1.11 """It-dot! ..I...~~~~ 0, " ......J I. .~ f I ~ I . . r fl", I ~. 0 11 ' I ;1 ' ." II 1 .' ~ r _J -1 1--2~=:- ....~ ..~J~!.d~:~'.,~ ' i:TT~t'~ "'~!~'lllll, ... ...,.. ," . . '. I . I ~."''' 0\ ..... . I "."ofI ....'f .'il~'."'t'~t"'. .t : ". 1 .... i '~'" . I. -,": ., r: .."I~B~.f.~~!:.t.l~ "'~'t..I.:J.., ,...-... \- .. ....I.' '_01 t' '" , ~".., 1,:\'(';, ~lJ'}'i',:.: '/-:>,'llJ'!'I'; ..tri\..", l~.'r ~: I '.,.. I C- . j ~'" "!~ ".....t.. , , l ,/II , , .. " J.-u.. . .!-f.~ .~-'4t,0.1 , ----llU.,~ .' I il I, H II ~ ""IY\~ .1 ~t....-:--"::~c ~~=~:'~-1. , . t ." r:, f t t-....~ I I Ie' ) ~ . I' (, - r ~ r, I . ( ('.H t i"n . ., ~ . " , , f '. ~ " , , , " fI:.' 'I, ',' . , . " .. '/\ I , 1'" h Y'l ;;mn=l1\'v .3 ~ a : ') ! , \ , " " ,. . /.!..rf ' . 0:;' t) u: vi Uj- ~'-!J J J \~ '> 0 ... t '7. 'J '2 ~ 1: ~. VI 1< -( ~ ~ \ij"t; . .91>1 T ~. ~ ~. . r :l ~~ . Ul ~ '6 ~~ r; ~* , -, I" I "', "'__I · -''t i~':; - , , -;.:\ , -a I, I ., " i, \ ~ , .~~ , oJ II ~ ~ ~ <1\ ~ :_,~,l\____:_._~: ~!~!~ . rr'\. PIS P . I ~~fl ~~;~J 'R4t11 ~ ~03 12 J "1' " ' , 3547402 -,-- I ,/' ....' ( ~J~." 9~04 411:'>; --.-- )11.. i 400 / ' "t 9 1 0 ~oo I;) / . ". t. S t7 / : '1 JS1/1 04(lZ 1;) ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~g -"'HART'" I '1 ,.klJ... \ ','. '-/ / -, --~~~.j ,_'.' jF~, JE~ 40< ,"',.. '" g '" (II "'JAr. \ , .... ' / STREET ~ eN.. R t\j I 2 ; Sl.:;S :il __3!!- 309 g 5 ~1~ ;10 j r,~~b t1!i ',--\ "\'J':o;' " "-z' _.~ ~~-- !l~_~;i~!~ 1~.3'0 fW ~ 308 ~08', I)~ , . 9 8 'J 6 _ _0 34 1~ 3~1i ~~~ f 14 , Rp~\r)cl i il--l 4 306 ' \ ~ Por~I"9 - . 310 ~ 8' \~;19j2h~;'~;; , Of} 2 PIS ~ ~ I (@) (~~1 i!: 0 ~~'~tr~,- - __H.... \JJ 12! t! 1~: JDNES ; % 60 i )rl'jt' ~ ~~ ...:--~!-~ ..1.~.~~~ ~ 3l!3: g~;;:g~~~ ;'!~~ ~ [J 1621..'::' JOe 17300 ,101 ~ -~~~.'.?~~,"'... .. ..,. .. 'CN~~~"--"---'" -,[ J / STREET - :ii -:~~-~--_. -., ;;~ 1 :g ..;.,r...-..ht"lI;.;....O'";,,,"" o~:g" .['2;;: I ~ hi ~ 9_ _18__ '" ~ ,,::J~f;l f;l~:2 to;Z;Z~ "E"I"H::! ~Ofj 5. 8 2071 t. --~..- I 604 < 1920tl 20 19 ,I 50 8 9 r~" -., ~ -- 1---" '''---. "h,. 8 7 I' ,~U i \~~ 7 tOll~ ]'tf{LtN FXI I l~~ ;; 2020G _... _..J, -;~7J-:.-.-:.' I . _ "1__.- -= ----I,~I I ~~ ~ 206 :) 212M 20; , I .~:. ~- r- - - -- ,,4 J 11, jO ! ~ ~.:.~ -- -- ---- 1 2, t 2 3 4 6.l 1:>_ 56 2 11. 67 I 25 ~ ~3 22 ~.. "'lU<:>C\J.."""" f:l"''' I;) ~;C\J .~ '" ~<:>,..!~I Ilj?~ ~ ~ g ~ I ,~.... "'...."'''' "'", '" "'.... ~o <:> <:> I(; I <:> ~ I- "~J 40 <ll ~ 40 '" '" ..,'" ...,"".,,,,,"''''''' "",,,,. I. " -- - _ 'f} ... . Q '" 7SrRFFT ,.,. -! ~.I n ._ 1:>-0 :: u. :~~' 'h ,.. ~ ' g ''-'" ij--~ _. ~_ _____' gl' :G ~ :l ~ t:; ~ 5b ~ .30 0 ll;) ~ ~ ;2: ~ 0 ~ 1.,1'" 133 1 '" '" '" '" '" '" 'n.::;:; 1 1 ~ <l) lU - '" '" 1" 6 1098717403).".7 '09IB7654J2] 30 22./03' 2 I~ ~ W 15 I ~~ rtw 22/04 2/03 ----. l- ID ~ 5 Jli ~. 11/01 NAll t~~~~~~'~~'-;.;; ~~~7 u ~2C~~OII,~: 1 6 ~ I. 0-:;- -< I;'.) I::: b II tj I;} '-' . "- ~ -< 1-...... . J <"\ 2 ~ "5 4 II MORTONSON I 9 ( ~(ntIlr ,;,~ -< ~ 6 H UGJ E'Yi12 1 [ ~ < 5 I \... 0 GROVE STREET ,,' ti ...5 ",4 J. I;) ... ~ ~ ~:~:ICKS ~ ~~; 11/02 0 -, 8 @ ~ ~~l}~lliJ~ ~~ r1~ l~ ~~ ~.~ :~.~ ~:: ' ~D~ ~ i5~~~ "'O(.rr::rl:r:~ tB~I'r f:~r~,' 'f;l i ~. -' s~~ " 35 -<VL ~6 01 2 "l( <:>.1 6~.. & G (4) - ;:- ~~ ~ f5 -,~ ~ T~_; ",~'O~J ~_.. ~ q ,__. G,~ ~_. 0''-'''' _ _",____ _...~",.~. . 6'1 ~ I- ~ co '......, ~i LAURA STREET ~ 0(' LAURA ~6-r~-l'~r:r~T~"l r~l~'lf~l-:-r:--1 ~ [---T--'M~MUWN .-I~~ r I VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS ~ 306 131-. ':: 30~ I-- - 4 5 soo ....,'" o"l.. "l......... l>)l>)l>) "l"l'" "'''l''' ._;-- -JONES S:J& aaa Ul 7 6UO U m \ !!~ I-!!P.. - - rL-m 4 5 :a~ :a~ to' IOD !~ ~ ~ ~! !>o ~_l>)~ ;-:~_~u ;;; 'J" J ~I;)I;)Q I;) -- E: "'''''''... '" '" '" r<' 6 .. 8 7 -- :::- "r) 15' '}- ~~ i!:-l(6~. 1m Q: :..r:..=; o II' 1 2 . to" Z Itl ,} :~ 4 I- 8 2 IO~ 11I6 S! ~ ~ ~ ~~ .. ~ tfU 10'''':''' .. ...... ;;"'101 6[1 STREET B 7 60 9 2 7 N A ME:. \-\ A )t \) ~ E I Me- K tJ l G H T , SV-#,S1-18 PUBLIC HEARING DATE: ATLAS PAGE: ,2.776 SEe: oq TWP: 2<<1 S. RGE: 15"' E. ~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION ~ . I ... "---- " . . ~4~' ~ . .-t ~I~ 1~ , / -~----- ..-- -.. .-......-. . f Clc31water City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item II Meettng Dote: Q, 11~l/ /''-1 SUBJECT: Vari,ances to the Sign Regulations; 1266 Cour.t Street; Natt C. and Betty Smith/Accurate Auto Service (Owner/Applicant); John J. McCormick (Representative). (SV 92-30) RECOMMENDATIONJMOTION: Deny variances to allow nonconforming signage to remain on property identified as Sec. 15-29-15, Hibiscus Gardens, Block 0, Lots 22-27, the west 17.5 feet of Lot 28, and the east 1/2 of Lot 21, for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8). o and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same, BACKGROUND: ,The applicant is requesting the following four variances to permit an existing freestanding sign to remain: (1) an area variance of 49.5 square feet from the maximum permitted 24 square feet to allow a total of 73.5 square feet of freestanding sign area, (2) a height variance of 17.2 feet from the permitted eight foot maximum .to permit a freestanding sign with a height of 25.2 feet, (3) a setback variance of 4.4 feet from the five foot minimum required to permit a freestanding sign 0.6 foot from the Court Street right-of-way, and (4) a variance of one message panel from the maximum permitted two message panels to permit a total of three message panels. The subject property is located on th'e north side of Court St., east of Lincoln Ave., and is in the Limited Office zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. Information Existing Freestanding Court Street 73.5 square feet 0.6 feet 25.2 feet Permitted . I Type of sign Location/orientation of sign Area Setback Height Yes Yes 24 square feet 5 feet 8 feet !\n\IIWDd by: Legal Budget Purchasing Risk Mgmt. CIS ACM Other Total Commlnlon Acllon: o Approved o Approved w/condi t ions o Dent ed o Continued to: IliA N/A N/A N/A ~ N/A Drlglnllting D.pt: CENTRAL PERMITTING COIU: Unr DIllt: Current Fiscal Yr. ("'. i A~Vltll.ad: Dote: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Required Alllclld Plrll.. ~ Notified o Not Requi red Funding S~urCl: o Cap; tol Imp. o Opcrllt lng o Other A tlllchmlnll: , APPlI CA T lOll VARIANCE \lORKSflEET MAPS o None Submlned by: Cit;2u~ A"",allllllian Cadi: o Pr;nfl~d on recycled popel' , , SV 92r30 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: The Accurate Auto Repair shop is a lawful nonconforming use of this property. The applicant contends that because the use is commercial, the existing sign should be permitted to remain. At very least, the applicant contends, the sign requirements applicable to this property should be the General Commercial sign standards. (The General Commercial standards allow a 64 square foot sign, 20 feet in height.) Staff finds that all properties in this block of Court St., on both the no'rth and south side, are zoned Limited Office. Consequently, it would confer a special privilege on this property owner to disregard the zoning on this property and allow larger, higher signs than other surrounding properties are allowed. Other signs in this zone are limited to an area of 24 square feet and a height of eight feet. It is staff's position that the variance request is not minimal, and would detract from properties having signs of conforming area and height. Section 42.21 (1) of the Development Code addresses nonconformities as follows: "It is the purpose of this section, where there exist within the city lots, buildings, structures, uses, density and other features of land or development, excluding signs, which were lawful at the time of their creation, but subsequently made nonconforming as a result of a rezoning or code amendment. to permit such legal nonconformities to continue until they are removed, but not to encourage their survival or replacement." [Emphasis added.] Nonconforming signs are to be brought into compliance or removed, and to encourage the continuation of nonconforming signs would be in direct contradiction to the intent of the code. The applicant states the auto repair shop has a paved area totally surrounding the building and the sign poles are embedded within the parking area causing the relocation to be extremely difficult. Staff concurs. In the event the applicant revises the variance application to propose placing a conforming sign on the existing sign poles, staff would look favorably upon such a request. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction 11 Existing Land Uses North South East West Multiple family residential Bay area Prosthetics (across Court Street) Paragon Home Care, Stewart Title Court Street Stamp The existence of this freestanding sign with 3 message panels, 73.5 square feet of area, 25.2 feet in height, and located 0.6 foot from the property line is not in character with the signage permitted for the surrounding businesses and diverts attention from those land useS. The granting of these variances will detract from the businesses that have conforming signage and negatively impact the overall appearance of the community. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet 011 eight standards for varianco aPfroval. ' Based upon reviow and analysis of the information containod in the application, staf finds that t;... t1 'J " , . , ' ,', " SV 92-30 Page 3 . the petitioner's variance requests do not meet the standards. 18 particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully'met: . , (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly, applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner. predecessor in title. or the applicant:' Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considerod to be situations which support the granting of a variance." ' (2) ,The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. . ' , , (4) The request for a' variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to ; secure a greater financial return for the property. ' , c (5) . The grantin~ of the variance will not be materially detriment~1 or injurious to other , property or Improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located., . ,\ ' , ' , (6)' The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding proper~y. (7) 'The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order conveniencet or general welfare of the community. , . (8) The granting of ,the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. , . " , . SV 92-30 Page 4 Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: FREESTANDING SIGN AREA CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 91-02 25191 U.S. , Dimmitt Cadillac 12.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 3/21/91 ' 19 129.3 sa. ft./Denied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. Village at 124 sq. ft. add'l to allow 1/2/92 19 Countrvside 280 sa. ft./Denied SV 92-03' 2301 Sunset Great Western 42.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 1/1 6/92 Point Rd. Sank 66.3 SQ. ft./Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S. Public Storage 32 sq. ft. add'l to allow 3/25/93 19 144 sa. ft./Denied SV 92-05 20162 U.S. Suncoast Inn 38 sq. ft. add'] to allow 5/7/92 19 150 sa. ft./Aooroved SV 93-06 1621-1627 Connell's Plaza 144 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 Gulf to Bay 208 sq. ft./Denied Blvd. SV 92-40 1528 Orthopaedic 32.4 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 lakeview Rd. Surgery Center of 56.4 sq. ft./Approved Clearwater SV 92-41 26508 U.S. Ramada Inn 55 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 19 1 05 sa. ft./ Aooroved SV 92-46 1824 N. Ft. Clearwater Bay 30 sq. ft. add'l to allow 80 9/28/93 Harrison Motel SQ. ft./Approved FREESTANDING SIGN HEIGHT CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 91-02 25191 U.S. 19 Dimmitt Cadillac 16.5 ft, add'l to allow 3/21/91 36.5 ft./Denied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. 19 Village at 12.3 ft. add'l to allow 1/2/92 Countrvside 36.3 ft./Denied SV 92-03 2301 Sunset Point Great Western 6 ft. add'l to allow 12 1/16/92 Rd. Bank ft.lAooroved SV 92-28 1290, 92, 94 Stewart Titlo 2 ft. add'l to allow 10 12/17/92 Court St. ft,/Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S, 19 Public Storage 15,1 ft. add'l to allow 3/25/93 35.1 ft./Aooroved SV 92-05 20162 U.S. 19 Suncoast Inn 1 ft. add'J to allow 25 517/92 ft./Denied " ~ ~ ~ I ~ -Q>'" g~,Q~ ~ ,Ec.. '5 ~ t'i .c:r ~ to s::. 1: ! E . g '" ~'9 ... a.-s CI oS 'il ... .. o:9~:!l1l CI ~ OJ = ,Q ""tI- = - '!:l CI ... g i':t J'oS~ll tI'J QI c - 1:: ~ "l:I :.. ::,S....c 8=aa1l ... ~ ~ ,9 CI ..::-.- E ~~~~ ,Q"=~ CI C '" :g ~ ~... < 0 i .B a3 : tt;, .K! E .Ii 'C io :..f: 'E 1l 1:: '!l Q,:::: !\..c. ~:5[1 ~ ~ ~ ; ~ t:( rz g ! .5 1 1:: ~.... 1::8. i~Jlof~ E.j:; .. a.c. Q, o~u oS~.gli~ o ~'~ .. VI - ';3.5 0 2 ~ 0 .... tot;:.::z :: N <:> ;: n ,~... ~ I: :: :I oS ~ a'~ .~ ~ ';l :.1:.8 .c. ... t:.9 c :3:a ~;g - !I;~ i.&'t E~~~~ :~ :s C 'C .~ ~ :-, "'l = 0 e ] i'g " "~E~~ 5SCol<o= ow... ~ '::;oS~j ~.::-'c;W'I 'r~~ E ~ 'ij "2' 'EnC. -c~sat !i\o!:s,..ns .= QJ - .... .c F.c. = Q OJ 'ti c.=:i - .. ~ c Ie a ~ ~ ~.!!I n ;., i! ... 'j: "1:1 ~ ~ .c. ;, e ; oS ...: .s .5 ~ ,g ] ,~ g ~ :!i~-a..<:l 2 & E ;- 'i .s . E E ~.!i g" .: 5- 8 .:;; ~ \0 ~~ n :0 .. '~ ~ '5 .s:€ c.8. .:: c. - Q 'E .. l! ~ '" c; ... ....c. ~i u ,~ ... CI .a e - n '2- .!: .c Q - ,5. :a g .~ ~ 2 s:a "- o = 'C._ e.~ n 1: e a ~ E ~ c. .. "l:I .a e .:ij Q e ~ c. .,8 -i ~ t 1;>"l:I ,...~ noS :a'C [,~ ~ 8.'~ ~ .sE& ..c.n ::: ~ ~ ~ -s: ]1;= '" = 8- ~ I;> :: ~.~ .Eo- .5 " .<:l ~:.= ., 3 &~ e'::] ;:l,j:; i::' '" ... 11 "i\! '" i;; '" .. ~ ':;Ii >5 ~ .E' '0 = c. 8 ; \0 ]] ,~ t= ;: - B...5 ;1 1< ;., c: ~t:_ ~i & So ; i" ~ '~ a ..... .s ,~ :ii = e '" \0 e I:>, :.a -E .a C = ,':!:i e: .. oS "l:I 8 ~ ~ '" 1l '" e: " :l :0 :: t ~ '" = ,2 . ~] ~ [ ~ ~ .. c..: :a.: ~ ; l! :g i:'~ , 2 1I ::: ~ ~ ~ tt .. = -:5~ .. E e... - 1;1 ~ ~ ... '" ~ ~ ::: t.~ ....Q ~ ;: ~~ = . E~ ~1! :~ 'g ~ if -= '- ~t .~ ~ ~ c. ,2,$ " Q .. ... "'1: ~ t: . .."1:1 -.... r; ot::.:i :!i E ~ = '~ 11 ~1 -51.:: ~ t ~~ ii tt, _ n ._~ ~ ~ ::I 1:: ~ ~'" . E S 1:>,- ... 8 .<:l .. "':::1 C C. - C. .. " ::I is; '=t'.c .~ .: o ~ e .3 .~ :j3't2 S " ... = a 8. c. ::I '.Sza' -E"t' ~,~ a ;.,Cl.~ a 1l i1; -aofl ~ .c 8 :5 e: e, ~.... C1.... ~ .!t ~ ;' '" -= ... ::: ~ 'ij 't2 .. -:5 '" 8- = . ,.::. 1:;:'-' 'I: " ~ '2 [ Cl... 1:-:1 \!J 8 .c E ;:;... = - ~ s .~ 'i: U \0 a"i\! 'C ,- " l:! ;0 ": ~.s &S ~ 1i <'l _ t:: - " E<'l :. i: ~ C' ;: z:; ii B ';:I 2 ~... ~- a ~ . t: ~"l:I ~1 :: ~ ~ .~ ~ " ii t:... ,Q 0 ' . ~ r;) ,l'l;I 1: 5 ~ g C.5 w CL !l ... ~ I:: o~.: '" '" "l:l . C .V; = ~ i!'~ ~ :::~] = i::! - ~E-5 oS Cl. S ~ ~ ~.s" aell 'e:! C1 - ~- = C'. , CI III ] ~'f 'Ii '" ~ !: ~" CI .: 71 6- ::; ~ '" -tw>5 .. '" .c. Q - ~~ tE ~ ,= 1 .5' .\a \0 ;., 1;1 1: 1! !. t E IS c. 'C :!: ~~ "l:l.c. ~':E 'C ;1; ~ ~5 615 ~~ - C C.c =.::: ::a ,if ;1; = ~ '" ~oS '1: '" r; ''; u S -= i= ... .. I;> E Sfc. '€ ,5 e !:: :t- ~ 'ill ~i @& . .. ~ ~ -S g . <'l -S -; ,j:' ,=.~ '" a - ~ Q Q,; :i "f,\ooS~E J:~Bll'B et!~!ie g.a=-=~ C""'c"'- '" ",,~ ...... Il)'" .: ~ 0 ..... .... ~ !l 4.1 '"'" 8 ~,~ l!! -i .~~ ~.& ~ 9 iJ ~ ~ i5. 1i:3 :a -S Cl. ~ t's " ~~~~:a ~E:Ci~ Eig"l1t.:,c M 1.11:'" .g Jl .S "l:I = ..... a = u lJ e.c '" a .~ ~ . ~ :c ,Ej ...-:.a~:.. .~.2 ~. 1! 'tl ~ e .:/ ~=ii1:~ '!I'2",~= tiil-SoS'l:I -(5\0"':; ~ -:~ C QJ ...i1l.I~ Q... - 50 ~ oil .@ e':;; !l.e ~ ::.~ .~ i .. ~ E ~....... c .. "1 fI ~ 'a ~ :Q .~ ~ e '= ~ ;; ~~ ~ "", ~~.... Q4i;:! ..... 4.l -:3W'= fte:~ ::g~l c " '" E ~. ~ -s .~ c. _ Q,I c c.... ~ ~o"1 ~ .. \0 '5 ... e'" ~, C1 ,_ E :1 ....._ .g~~~ n c. c: .:a art'"' ': .\0 oS ~ ~ ae8.~ e E '" a +i ': oS E = u = ... i;l e.;; ~ lJ 1: - J "l:t.:::: e~i6' S1::.t~ 'c ~ 5.5 r; 2 ~ :., Q> c..c ,] -s-;~;:... ...t"'~u1: eo '"' :.:::I ~t~ .c ~ 'S n.s is. [ 5c;r,~tt e--~= ua:3';::a ~ .~ ... .. c ,::: .!i li u :: I""',~ - !:l E -E..o~ ~ '" ~ D ~ ~ ~ 1: CI .s '6. e :a "Cl 1 , 1; .~ ~ ~ ~ ~e ]~ .. ~ \0:::1 l'Cio _~ e :a C "1:1 u ~.~ '" '" t''};. .9 .- ~r; t10S ~'S ~i 'l;I ... .:=l ~lS' '':S e C>"l:I ~ :; \0 '" 1: .. ~ ~ ~ .s 11 ,<:l .~ :a, ft ... =. . .. .... ~ '2 t::: :: :'6 ~ ~ ~~ "1:1... ...... .. ::: g t: a~ ; 1l, 1] '!1j ... 'tI D ,j ~: 1'1 .. ;. f ... 'ij I:! ~ -= t:. e . ... -S c ....:.... O"3l~ ~. ~ i 'fl 05 Q, C" '0 " . gfi"" 'e ~,~ ~ 'f : -S ~~ f [... ''is 0 !,J ...:~ c OJ u ij-;l", = ~~ 4~ e >. oS=-E .J:! e Q .....= 'ji \0 Q 1:-ell: '5,Ql Q .S il 1i K ~t:: .: eB~! ~ ii 'C .S ~j:e:g .g "Cl"-a ... ~ ~ ~ c ~~"Z.~ "foS,g n ~ 'S .~ ,- '^ :; ~>o ~ .S ~5].! ... C i ,6 "CI 8 'C '6, '" e ~ !i u ... oS ~ '" -= 'S: C; = ~ ~ 'il "1:1 .. .. a 'C ... .. :!I . ::~ C u u_ 's ~ e ~ =ti ... .. ~~ €~ , i " I ' .p'lo::.r iItU(cJ Cl? ~\(~d PROPERTY OWNER(S) NAME & ADDRESS: NfJ 1': tJ., ~ 1J~J15/ S'IlJItJ; ,:i\-1l/f(' /1ld";>OIJJ {.if.Hy -tt;;;1/'lI..l4TkR EL.' ?Jt/t)3 CITY OF CLEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPLICATION .JiY!f.] Z' .~,' ~ REPRESENTATIVEIS. (it ony) NAME & ADDRESS: ,~ I ,,- ., , /l -J ()(# "J -', III (. c.. d /?~I , (.. K: /..~2&? ,/lO\/~';- rrt?e~'1 [I t.{"fl!?(u.4 ;t:'& h~ "/Pc 21,(1- 3 ~ /,< ~ TELEPHONE: (<n 31 '70."1,.. . 376' 5"' .' () ./ ' -:J TElEPHONE:.J ,'1'/ ~ i, t: / - 5 3 _:) c. ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: ,j..;J /c: A,,,, ,(I; 97;e~c i'- NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPLlCABlE):_.,4 f11! if P.41C: ZONING DISTRICT: 1k.A?/~ LAN~ AREA: /t15oo I~r: - /1.7 r :..1. /t. . ....L...CS7 ., ... ...> :r-' PARCEL N'UMBER: / .b I /J q I J ~ 1:3 &'.5 77'; t>!..~ I cP~;JO (This information Is avnilnble from your tax receipt or contnct Pinellns Co. Property Appraiser's Office ot 462.3207. If more thnn one porcel number. ottnch 8~ x 11 inch sheotl oL LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: L clC-k' C' DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: A . , 'North: fPt/C 1/1lE: t~c.,..hf';';:;;' C- . Ab 1 , South:~b~"e: .r /ul)l/}h{~f..~1t1 L Enst: West: /)/;:/26- C: /;:tr' .c'>~~ 1- /k111l/.I.k~~""::'4-:"" VARlANCEIS) REQUEST: ) rJ) i) \l.AQ\JmC~, 0 F ~. 6 e"~. FT. oj AtlTA: T() AI W'vJ ~ F2.Egf:;.JANJ)IIJ~\ ~I Y N of ~ 'I '3, ':) ~.~ I~~ ~. .1 t I I r/J, '2 ~},J.H.J$L. of ILl /1..1 Ne:ltj!11lf) NlCyJ. A H2.~1MJ~ ~y~J,~ 26..,2 '. U::!.. ue.14 oJ ,... I\t~ \~M'f>N((; t;r .tf~~! PI~~(:f... TO .AU.-ov..! A. PIle&S7A1JDilJ<1 7'.J1t.,N ~~~ I fl20M . pn.~l\> ~IAJe; \~\,'\ AI \JA~.JAAt-e Or ON~ )..l~:JiC~t, PMlt:L. 'n; ALL~If..1 '?> M.e..S~UAWeL,?,. REASON FOR REOUESTING VARlANCEIS): !Rcfcr to Stnndords for Approvlll'. ncxt pnge) " I. ~7eJ:E,. exH I ~ I A corn Ifwm ON IlI;VEnSE SIDE ~ , I. STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A vnriance shall not be gumtod by tho City Commission unless the opplicotion and evidence presented cleorly support tho following conclusions: (11 The varionce roquosted arises from 0 condition which is unique to' tho property in question ond is neither ordinarily or uniformly llPplicable to the zoning district nor creoted by on action or octlons of the property owner, prodecessor in title. or tho applicant. Any mistake mode in tho ollecution of e building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shull not be considered to bo situations which support the granting 'of n voriance. (2) The particulor physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of tho property involved end the strict application of the provisions of this development codo would rosult in nn unnecessory hordship upon tho applicant; 131 The varian co Is tho minimum necessory to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recitol "2" for tho purpose of moking reasonoble use of the land. 141 The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure 0 greoter'finnnclal return from the property. (5) The granting 01 tho variance will not bo materially detrimental or injurious to other property or Improvements in the neighborhood in which tho property is located. (6) Tho granting of the variance will not impair on adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property. detract from tho oppearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion In the public streets, increase the danger of fire. endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially dimInish or Impair the value of surrounding property. ' (7) The vorionce desired will not adversely affect the public health. safety, ordor convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8), The grnntirm of the variance desired will not violate the general s~!rit :/ intont of thl~ development c,~~:' : SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNE~ (OR REPRESENTATIVEI: ...:~'./$~ C~ ~~:-.-...- , ,,- Subscribed and sworn to lor offirmed) beforo me this fa.1:; . dav of ~"c~ 1"'" lu.,.,), A.O. 19' c)3 by 3e\'\ N '3'.' \l't. (,() '(' \'Y'\ n ~J~ . who Is personally . rnllr7V.,U_IIIlCfud. fHJ~"'o" .'I~'UlnJe a~"*tl.llyn' liPP7ii:Tili1i1 . . \ l~ 1 VI).\J_).~\A-u,,,,~,.r:J,\.'J,~.::..~:J ......l..c."-l-...L-- known to mo and/or has producod'f\\ \\ 113 ,,\ tl '1 <)II , 0 C]l~ f?:) os Identification. , . (Typ. of idM:ific.tionJ C'1. r~l t~ 00 B ("j J 1.)./ S 3 STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF rJ..~~.~tC1~) ~-\J......:2.(l-..,) C . ~ (} C\<1.9~otary Public, COllll1lis~iOn No. (Si~,.. "n/ , \3ts- , S,)\) So R I.J C: .S'f\ {' Q. '( S I 1 of Notary typod. printed or stomped) :'.~~.~-f~'. SUSAN, JAOGERS'~ f.t :& ',~) . MY COMMISSION' CC ,6538e \;,~:S .~J, ' EXPIRES: J"IUo\ry 26, I D97 ":,JJ:~t' _~1~~ ,/!JIIIY PW.1e_~t<<\l,~~~_ --....... - , ' . " , , '. ,l , In response, to the ,va r ianc~ request and reasons fo r requesting va t:" iances, the' appl icant states as follows. 'The subject property is located at. 1266 Cou~t Street, Clearwater, Florida, which is a divided 8astwest road, lying and beinq on the'Southeast portion of downtown Clearwater. The subject property has been utilized as a garage for approximately twenty years and because of a later zoning change by the 'City of Clearwater, the use or the property has been grand fathered and 'is an allowable use for a garage and auto repair shop. The property as it has been utilized for some twenty year~, is an auto repair shop which suits'the needs of the neighbor.ing community surrounding it. To the north, south, east and west are commercial and professional uses of 'property, and those uses have existed for many, many years. The property as.it is being utilized as an auto repair shop has a paved area totally surrounding the building., The present ,location of the signs have them embedded within a, parking lot which. creates extreme difficulty in mov ing and' replacing the signs. " , , The configuration of the road in front of the building which is a,divid~d high~ay, which allows high speed traffic, requires that a merchant along'this road have a more visible sign' to provide information for its customers. The property from' a signage point of ~iew is unique in the sense that there is no space on the property within which to ,change or move or replace the sian and in that sense, the physical surroundings, shape and topigra~hical 'conditions of the property and the strict applications of the provisions of the Development Code would, result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant, , to wit; there is no preferrable place on a very limited frontage of this property within which to change the sign. The variance request is miriimal in that the changes required by the sign ordinance. mean only that the ~ign ~ould be moved some two'to three feet and. reduced a minimum amount in size. The request of this variance is not based upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return for the " property but only to be,~ble to do business in a minimum way and to advertise and enhance the property for its uses as every other business owner in the community. , . ( . :..,....--- r:-'/ Ii /q I I A "/-)/1121 .; , " " .). , .' i , , , . . . ,c, " , ,J ::1 .' I I 4. " 1:, - , " " , r.'.. I ... ~ \t } -:. ~.. . . ' , . I , " The granting of this variance will hot '~~ materially detrimental o~ injurous to any other property owner in the ne ighborhood' in which the property is located in that. all of the .other properties are similarly used and located as is this 'property.. " '. , . , I ~ . , The granting of this variance-will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation' to the adjacent properties or detract fro~ ariyappearance or substantially increase the ' congestion in any public streets or areas in that we are applying for 'a v~riance of the l~cation and size of the ,sign and no 'other ' request 'and :the var iance requested is, minimal at best 'and does not aff~~~ any other factors such as fire, public safety~ or,the,value :of surr?unding property. , ' ' .;. " , The variance ~equested will in no way' adversely affect the public health, safety or qeneral welfare of the community nor 'will,the grantinq of. this variance since it is so minimal violat~ any,spirit or intent of the Development Code. This request for variance is to allow the property owner to keep and maintain the existing' sign at its present location or in the ~lternative to conform only to th~ requirements'of the sign ordinance 5257-92 as it relates to a General Commercial Zone. , 'It is noted that while it appears that this request is made f6r a variance from ,the requirements of a Limited Office Zone, iri reality, it is being made from a General Commerci~l Zone,' which is and has been allowed use and therefore, any variance from. General Com~ercial r~quirements is minimal. . , . , , ,', , I " c" , " ',' " , " '. EXIIIBI'r "A" fh,f r ,)_. '. , , " J. :. I t ~ c i ,\ , I !. 1" " , , " , c I." ~ \ :" ,<.- :. , ~. :.: ,I'c c, \ 'j, . I " ., '.: j ~ f ( I, .... ' '.. I .\ ','1-'". ! " ;L 't",', ,</' ,. ~ . I' , I' , .' r . . j ;; ." k.L><,, ,:/ ,,' >'::,'j :.:>:'," t~(~',J.~;;i';.j".l-~ :":..il..~\ ~..,~. ~ ~"t\':'.'~ ~~":}' :;.c.;.;..~< ,~tc..<...,",~~',~i~\ .'~ ~ ,I I":,' 1:1. ~ " :a ~ 'i.' i . ~.' ,I " \ . ~,~, I.. ~ .' '< ~ ,. ,J ';t , I' , ; , I ',. r: .1 ~ .!". ~. . ',' , \ ", I, ".'.. ~ . t~ '. ~ . , !II' ,~ ,', >~ ., I :+~. t ~ ~ i. ! '. .': \' ~; I. \, .1 '. , . '" ,.,. ., , ,', '. 'c November, )0, 1993 ~ I '. . <', r' ~: , , " , ; , . , 'I' ", , " " " ",I" c ,{r,. " , : '," j" t' (, ", " .:' " Dear'Sirl . , .~ . " ,~ <. : , , , , ." 'r " , Ihearby author1z'e John J. ,McCormlc,k of - '. . . . . 1 ..' . ~ R~pa~~ to take wha~7ver steps neccessary to or' p'er~ltsperlainlng .to my 'building, , obtain loea ted, at . i. . Accurate' Automotive Auto a variance arxl' 1266 Court'street~ ~' . < " , ~. / , ' , ~ " " , ' 'I , \ . ~ I, ~. t. I, " ~ '- , . '"I ~<:*.. .'~ " .f I,,, \;C ') Ie , , " ~ \:,': ,', ~ . i, ,> ,lc ',I I ~! , , , , I ~. i ' (l " " " I ' srnc~~e1y. <t', , c-':' ': ) .' " " . ,I' " " " ! y " 'Natt C'" Smith, Jr. , /~;fYK~~, f))l-1J-~."30~)'3 '3 ~fI,~ s: ',~~t2U~'C~1,~( (~clL'-:, _ /I- ptJ- lf3 '" " 'I, ", ~ ~ 1 j ~ ~ ' ,', " c, . .. ~ I:. :<' ",<l .( ~. " . , ,(pd bit /11 ') h '., '1 . ,Ct' " I , . ", ., , -." , , , l' " " I /;:,!~:y:~~ ,0. Me CoR1liACK~ {;{ f.1 MY COMr.4iS91O/I He 202114 \j;'oJ' ,~1J EA'i'IIlES: July N, te97 "~,,::ik,." Bc~ThnlI'My NIle ~ , I , f, , ': t ~ . ~' I. 1 ..~.: ' . " .. " , , ,', ,', T . ~ ~ j, '. I, " " , , " ! " ,H " , '," . ' "i. " " , } ,~ "I , ' , , . . 'J , ... ~ ~. ;l, . j l,' ,: ' , \ . ..", " " ~ . . " ,!;.) ,.' .' " , , ' I \ ";.'} ..' ,~,' , .elf,.. '. . ". ('{/~tffi/6nt!Jo;:prS~ . . ,'. ., . " . . _~ I /'. .4u1'<>rl1"II6'/L..' .. .--:....--- ,_~_ I fL- .' ./ C'~' " . , ,,,.'.,. " '/ C/~ '" I i / ../iG URI1TE~' :._, ; \ --'. . '. V ' .t'l ~,,' ....__~..~~ U_" i .-~~~u--',_: ~'_>~~ (~~.3,))O' ," :'=-"::~~-- -,-_:.~-' -~--'~-~- , , " , ' ;, ~ . ~ . r '."'- . .-.-~---_.~._.--_. ..- . '. " ..' , ' i' h"'_'___._ t ' -_._-~--.....- I I , " . f- \ ~T____' _._ _ ~_ L., L .... ~ I . t .' 1 '.1 '. ' ", I i .--...,.- ... "'I " , .. . -. ._~. -'<" -.......-..-.-.-.......... , 7,6~/" I" 'I' t ' , \ ' . ~ I' . l , I I" -----.~--- .... j" .., , ' ' , ' ' ,I I I l. , I I ' " j 1', , I -..-...........,,-----..'.... .; I -. !.. : ....... .~_'"":...____~. '_r .. - I " I !' I ' ,/,/,r-"-" ' , I _' L --:..-J . ~ ,..... , \ " j' ' '-. , I \ . . , ( ) ' . rO ..... _.., ....... --:--.~---_. ~ ' l . ~ .!J ''j I' I: - . I : ; I' " , , , , ; I /~ './ .,:: ," ..i ,.11' ,"" _ I'" I.". i-.o" .._.. . ~ ~' ,1 I , , . ~. ... . ""':'-..~.... ~ .. ~.. ~ . " " ." .... ."..----....~ - . .' , ' .-. .;......-. .~--_......_.~~ .....-......--.... " ,j -:. ~.. j" ~ , " I w~, I' " :"" )' .\. .. ", , , ", I' , , , " ~ '., '" < i' I :, ,I~' I , , ,:' . " " ~, . , j ~ ,I 0.....;1: . t:. ;'r .... . , lor ~.~ . '.J 'II, " ,0' JI' "\. ~! .t ,) " , ) ,j " , ." ~'" "....0 , >~ ....., ~ c ...-.... .... ---~._.~~--:--..... --- ,. -j' ,', ,,' VI' " r~ ,~ /'1'( ~, ,~ ,/ " " , ,. . ~ , ,) ~, \,tj, .' , ~ .~ " I~ , , , , ,', 'c ...... " .:(? (j , , , , " : ~ , . 'c ~ . , " " '., " ! ~ ; c I ' " , ,\!) G ~.' ' , . , I " , t. , " I, t l ; l~ ~: II ~, :\1") '. ..... , "< \....... ~. .~ ~, ,\:) , ,"J )' ." , , , , I " " ~~ I~ ,t V) I." k \.~ ('(, ,'-'J ,~ '~~ ,,' '!. " " " c, , t '" " , . '. ,oor , , -J, " " ,,' , I' , , . . ~ , > " " ,', ..~ . , . c, ~ .: 'j c,c " ~ ! I ' II-~ . ~r "rf '1r' .. ...~ r~' ... ~ '~" 'j' ~ t... ":J.. _I,t 4 .;;.. .. ~.c 1. .. .;. . ~ ~t">r., "I. 7.f.,J' . .. . ZP~ I ;... 7t'!. I. ~o; V ~;\\J ~\ '. ,\ '~ ;r" . \'. .....('- '1r~ L -~rt ;l., ~.'1 ~ . ;!It, y.. , il. - P\lT",~\.. ~CG', ~ ,I ~ ~ ~ w 2r.-r ~..: .(, '- (]I '~~~ ~ (~'/--J-!f . ~ ~,L'\."2!Jf1' ~ -<. ~I' .a.,:~ ..-"~ v'1. ~:- , _ ~~a . .IN ~ ;'~ ~. ~ p 1. ~ *,V ~c\ -?' ',;." (!:-tt ~, PI S P OL STREET-.J . - I, ~ .. I o,~, .;. .. ..J \I '-.o-J \ \ ~ '; C ' \.> " , ~ - ~z " 0. 20" ~_ '. J. ~ ~ , :,,,- < " 9 2/:> I .. ~ co ~~ t~ ~ .' ,l~- ~_'4;~1 1>. '''J " ~f 21.~ '. ~ H 21~ f ~ ';;'p . U ,- lO.' , , (., ~-' I :. ,'"\ .r..~ ~.~:~ f~ , .,. r LOft'" .' 2('~ t 4 4 ~ ) :J ....y 22:- 0-. ~ t:l ' " , \\ C A / / 10 5 . ~ /-.:.......... 'f' :' ! 'Y+</-1--y~\~~\:~""' d !. , ~ oC'<?s 3 U 1/1 ~ ~ . '<~oC'" :z. ." :If)' :J , :........ 1 :';'~I 0\ ;4 C \tr~ 1'l.1':! -G ~:l 0 f ~' _ R ...' S""1v 'V:' . /"'l . (, ,'" ,~ 2/' .I:'... ,'l. C . .....4 '\,'=: 21r. ---rl\tk; . " 211.... V", Nf, I') 'c . ~o_ ~- 0 ~-',: " 1 I.. J. " . ,'l ; 7i'" " F ( ~<~ w.sf>.: ~ co 11~ ~ t' jI :"1 i 2'. . r " ' ~ J ".i ct ~ ~ . ~ , - I:? .. '" ... I '\.";~{"l :.\ . :..r~f\. ;.:. ..."':1 ~ :'( '=' o ,. u .:,.~ ~I :!O/l ~,pj. '.\ c >- ..J Q: ~ 2?? ~ ';'11: ... .- .. ,~ ~ , ~ ;:>, .. I I,:' . .i!r<t rRAt~KLlN R M I 6 STREET ,~' '" Jon 2:".~' " '!: u '"' ~ .~ .J 11. f .1'12 0' < ,qar .. ~ C 11'1,1 ~ ~~ ~ ... ~r- > -c ,1()O!; ~ , '"' or. r: ~ ~ - , ~ .~29' ). '" <: ::; o{ ~ ~ i' ~ ltJ ,...,;,' ,~~/, " 0 ,../ IT/'!IttJ 0/ / ~' (, I'ti:" \~~~/ :~ ";':'/ "iJ.;', (J' . (), .\ .. .q(ll .. . C)'t , . ";>"-' .103 ~ t... l~tP~1- ~1n~ .., .10':' 9 ,:~ I I .101/ 1', 2<\ 'T r ro!; I' , 1 14 'f - ." ..1;!' .lSANTA .1TH .,nn r ~ . ~1'n, . rl ,t . "T .,. ~ /,,~ . .. ...... . ,1''''' '" / 19 J (- 1 :) .;/~, . 7 ~i'.Ioi' ." <: , S' ' "1-1- -. G r J. ...P)'.. '''r ... ,[r~ \l.{ ~ .... .11' J ROSA '~ DR1'vt I " T'?, ,~ " lP .'" - II !' 13 -1 -r-" T OL OR, , I~ , I II /1 DAWlD / d~\ ~ / C It, t.,4hl;l' " f .. ~ VJ .m 'i ., F- S l ','r'P\, r" I "1 M'" ttJ;IIJ .,UbOl;l'9tJII aJD't ~1:I'..tli U 11:1'0.,.......".,. ~ :'!! -lOA ~ '<\I . I niT - t I I -I '~J :'3~'l"~';'~ &;,.1.;. ~!:.:}.~.....~ ~4 .:, ). I 1 r, :-, ," r -I I .l( 'T .- <I - I "1'1 ,~ 4.". "'."''''''1 .. '" ',"" I ~/ 02.. r, .. .. 'j. )R f,JI1- ;t:l~; } 5TREl c ~ ' ~"~!~~\;I~'1~'~61--:-~-'j:l-\~I~ ~!rj~r-. I 511 'l~ N .r~'l , " I ~ '~.'" "'I"f.:!' ~ j~ ~ ~:&;~I~_~]~4'::t~~;'~~I't~~ 5;':;1;:1, ~ 30~ ~ 512 ~ 513 "jQO~ 29 28 27 26' 2~ 2~ 12 Sr' :7 ii~,31!:~. 6 i ~!:! ,~;; re 2;:516' >Il 517310"'1'. I'" '" 1 I'"" '" "< S,H, .;, " ~ ~. .~, ~- ..,.. -",,-, o~, -="'P/SP ~ QGERS ~ - .:~~ .J; ll' 6 ~ ~~~~~ ~'3;jI2b r.!" . ,,;;.':l <( ':'- :;~r~}1':T I;:' ~GQVQ~4.' t:b~./\' , _ ~-4Aj_'_,_r_ oj __~<, 5l.~~. <J; o '" ~:J' ,,/'," (J!! IJ' '}J r r .. I f' .. 501 J.. ~~ ~8 14 0'" ~... ~~ 4//0 I ~ , Of\'P ~~G 6\C['1? G(}l b":) " . \ ~~ 01, ~ .. Ii.! w :z' .~_.,i . -VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS ~~ - N A ME: 0M I TI-\ /-A c.c u'i2.A Tf2_l /vi G C"vw..{ \Ck..____ SV#CJ},:?O PUBLIC HEARING DATE:___ ATLAS PAGE:{t?7l?-, SEC:.-l5_ TWP:-2C-l S. RGE: I? E. ~ GLEAR~~~!~~~~.-~.ITY COMMISSI9N ~ ... ... ,~ ~h '" n: U 12 :0 /). 61 . 5 'II () ~ = . "'^\' I I I I f;ll n:>J;11l ,'/ r 0' I I ..; > ... '" :., rt '" I 0 .. , ... ... '.:I l-' " 'f) ." to: 'U ~ ~1 '.. .-. ;, .' .. \,0 r.:l ... ... u Q '" Do-.. 'U fl~ .. ~J ,,. ... _, .r. rr. C ~-~ ... ~ " ...' o CJ <:> .., '" o n: -:J co: t)', I ~U~"':i u " n. o " Of) r: >:J '0< r: :' . (I^\, ..~r,l t ... -"' I. ~ ...-------- .. ~ ./ " , , '.'~~ ~~:<' .~. ,":<!J'! " . . rl~':. '1' '> I.' I' ...... r;. ., . :.~ ";:",' '.! i:" .'1' ,f, i.. ~~ , 'c ," " " , ," , ' c" i.,' " ,,\ .,1 <, y j, . J 3t. > :. . ~ } ~ , . , ..- ~ ~~:~'. . " .. r ~. .:' ." , ) , , ," . i ..t' , ,I' ", ,I I f '/ , , ~. < .' ~ ; '. / , " ' ,.. : l: .~. :,' , " cl' , ), ~ ~ .... 4 . ' " \ ,'. ~' ',\' . I ,I T ~ 't. . ; .. .'J . ' 'j II t~) :'j. ,\. j,' ~';. , I., i> , 'c l ~ ~ ~ . j ",,' '. \ , '. I 1 ~ \ ,,": " '\.- " I' , .' ; .,: ~ .... . ,to !.\ l' . ll" ,; 'f . < . ',~ ; . . ~ \. '~ .~ ~ c, ~>.:.... .: . i. , " . ~~ I ',' "', l r ~ " ' ( ., ~ " ~ " ., , ..~ :' <': I; . i , t . ~ ~>-' '.:, . ,~. '. 'f 1 '.: ~. i ~~ t . I! r , " : 1 " " . ,c. ni', ,. ~J' . ':.',' . I ~ \ } ',~ . !' . '(n' . :. l' > , l' . ~ ':.L." . It ;'.. . ~} ~ . ~.' : ~ . t . ~ . \ -r" , " ~,,:: ).~ ~~~:~;;:. .~~\~I'T~~'~:.:J:~:::.l,f'~~/~}:.:r :>:'p: j ; I ~. : t' ,. 1 " , ' j, '0 }". " , .~. , ..', "' :.1,' .,.. .1,:: (.> t- ' , ;1.: j".\. ,", ~. :. ~ . I (?:"" ~;;" ,'. ~;/:;:",;', ' f::..<'::~~~.; / .". ~:.:>,,~ i;:~.:~ :~~ ~:,.~~{r::' ~ \ '. ....,>. . ~.c: ~ ' t . f. . ',~ ~. I,','" "" ".f ".. '.' , ,:,,',., ';, ~ " , i '':' r :4'~ t: . . I,' ;1.-,1. , ,. ,H".~~ '. ~ ,-..",' ,.1,-, :;-. .. ", :. ;'., '1 l": , ,\ ' . " ., " . ~ . 'I . .... I J i .r' '" " " "0" , '. , , ~ . . . , ' " . ~ .: . .' . " .' '~ ., I ' "ii. 1 " I, , , '.~ ".' ",I: , '. . ; ~ ~ ~. , , -'"f , , " : I ~; " ,~. ~ . 'e .", I> " " , . ~ . ,I' '. ~ { I . , I , , ," '. " I., .: . ,.'. ~ ~ , 'j.. 'j " :' " . ~. < ,'. .:: ',... ", '!: 'f " ~ . ,; ! j .,' L ~ .,~ '; . .' ,',\ 'f :1' " ".'. .Ir-.... " I' .) .i. \ .: . i ..~ ., Cfi/:'- " ,,' . ".1 " ' f . ~t . .; I .. \' ,~ 1 ~ . , , " " .', . ~ >' ~ I " . .~. :' j > -. ~ ':AGENDA '" " ...:! ,t ':'-:"\ ,I , " ," .~ . ..'" ' :., " I".' " p.l ::! . 'r. , ' Ie"" ",,' " ~~ , , , ~ . > . ,. 1,. ~ " .; ( , " , " " ) " 'r " " . - . I' ,II ,I '. , , , 'i '. , , -;l .-t' 9f ". . ,", .;, ~' ..! ' DATE. .I ~Ij ,. . ~ . . ,,' ;' '( - .... I ~ ~} , ' , 'I- 'Ie ,.1 '" ITEM#~. . J I ~ " ., . ; , .' ;. . . ":.) ".il :' '\ ,. t, 1c "II' '., ',' ;, '. '\ , , ",."; .) .' : , I I ~ c .' . I' " , . 'i , i " " ':i J' '. ' co, I, " " I' ,. '\' " 1 ; ~ . j" . " ,j , I, I , . . ~ ~ I , , " \ ' ~.. I. . J' , , , " :"-. \ , ; , .,11 .' !(t .. I, .' ' " ,', Of"~ . , , " ". ' , " " , I. " Ie ,. ~.r . '\ ,) , , - I", ,I , , 'I' ~ .' ' , I, , r " , , , , " I' " .' \, " '\ '.1 ~. ' , \.: L I' ~ .L " \'. .,. ,.'e :1,' ( , t. " " , . . . ~ . ; , .' '., . I' "J , , Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum 3. Item # Meet Ing Date: I I /:J.4!C/,-/ SUBJECT: Variance(s) to the Sign Regulations; 2416 Gulf"to-Bay Boulevard; Pauline Rophie/ALCO Center ' (Owner/Applicant); Frank Sewell (Representative). (SV 92-45) RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: Approve the setback variance of four feet to permit a freestanding sign one foot from the west side 'property line on property identified as Sec. 18~29"16, M & B 13.02 and 13.0,3, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 H8), subject to the following conditions: (1) the freestanding sign at the southeast corner of the property shall be removed within 60 days of the date of this public hearing, and (2) the subject sign shall comply with all height and area requirements within 60 days of the date of this public hearing. o and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a setback varian'ce of four feet from the five foot setback requirement to allow a freestanding sign one foot from the west side property line. The subject property is located on the north side of Gulf to Bay Blvd., west of Kilmer Ave., and is in the General Commercial zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following , table. Rlvlll'i'ild by: Legal Budget Purchasing Risk Mgrnt. CIS ACM Other Total Commllllon Action: o Approved o Approved w/conditions o Denied o Continued to: lilA' iliA iliA iliA ilIA '""I~ ilIA ' Orlglnallng Dapt: CENTRAL PERMITTIIIG ~ CO,I.: v Current fiscal Yr. Unr Dop\: SubmiUld by: City nllge~~ AdvUllud: Dote: '~" Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Requi red AlIocUd Parlin ~ Notified o Not Requi red funding Sourc.: o copi tal Imp. o Operat in9 o Other Attacllment\: APPLICATION VARIANCE ~ORKSHEET HAPS D llano A"",ol'.lallon Code: .-. ld ....,. Pr inted on reeye e pUp~1' SV 92-45 Page 2 Information Proposed Freestanding Gulf-to-Bay Blvd. 60 square feet 1 foot 18 feet Permitted Type of sign Location/orientation of sign Area Setback from west side property line Height Yes Yes 64 square feet 5 feet 20 feet Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: There are currently two freestanding signs on this property. The sign at the southeast corner of the property is proposed to be removed. The other sign, located at the southwest corner of the property, which is larger than allowed by code, is proposed to be reconstructed utilizing the existing poles. The existing poles, however, do not meet the setback requirement. The poles are located one foot from the west side property line. The setback requirement is five feet. The property is developed with a parking lot in the front, accessible from Gulf to Bay Blvd. The lot contains twelve spaces. In the event the sign setback requirement is strictly applied, the sign would be relocated to the east by four feet, causing it to be placed in the parking lot and creating the loss of a parking space. The removal of a parking space would cause a hardship to the property owner. Further, the building is constructed with no setback from the west side property line, which causes the lack of a setback for the sign to be inconsequential. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction 11 Existing land Uses North South East West Single family residential Twin lakes Mobile Home Park Automobile leasing Sweetwaters Restaurant A sign having a conforming area one foot from the side property line appears to be in character with the signage permitted for the nearby commercial businesses. The granting of this variance will not detract from the businesses and properties that have conforming signage and will not negatively impact the appearanco of the community. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that tho petitioner's requost meets 011 of the standards. In particular, tho following standards do appear to be fully mot: SV92-45 Page 3 ~., . , , , (1)' The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to, the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owne'r, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the ' benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a varianco. . , (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development cade would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance ,is the minimum necessary ta overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "211 for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. , , (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return from the property.. , , (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious taother property ar improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) ,The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value, of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. ' . , " , ... ;' t.. . ....: . I i , , , , , ' , SV 92r45 Page 4 Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: SETBACK ' '. CASE, # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING DATE REQUESTEDI ACTION SV91-11 1550 S. Highland Jordon Hills 5 ft./Approved 6/20/91 ' Ave. Professional, Center . SV 91-22 1874 Gulf to Bay Capt. John's 5 ft./ Approved 11/21/91 Blvd. Hairstyles SV 92-01 2226 Druid Rd. Clearwater 1.5 ft./Approved 1/2/92 Dental Assoc. SV 92r21 447 Mandalay Heilman's 5 ft./ Approved 10/15/92 Ave. Beachcomber S\I 92-24 2000 Drew St. Shell Gas 5 ft./Approved 1115/92 Station SV 92-71 35'1 S. Gulfview Julie's Seafood 5 ft./ Approved 2/9/93 Blvd. Sunsets SV 93-06 1621-1627 Gulf Connell's Plaza 5 ft./Approved 9/28/93 ' to Bay Blvd. , brew Plaza' 5 ft./ Approved SV 92-31 1880 Drew St. 9/28/93 SV 92-46 1824 N. Ft. Clearwater Bay 5 ft./Approved 9128/93 Harrison Ave. Motel , ' t.n lid' I N m > UJ CC W co ~ ::> 2 w en <C U .- w w J: en ~ a:: o ~ w U 2 <C C2 c:x: > I ~ ... "0 0 t 1li .s.:: ~.5 u ell ~ .Ii ~, "" ~ e..; ~ ~ 1l-!' . a 0 Ift~ IJ:I : Ii i i ~ ~.2~ i g ~ 8 .:=! l:Z .. tI > 'E 11. t: ;:I it ..I&.... a. 0 , [j~ .. c q .. .. E ; 6- ~ .8 : ~ ..g.. I: u ! 0.5 '5 1: c l1' ; .2' e u ":5! .2 11 ;:I .!! : ; CQ~tD ,g.lol.5 '5 ~ 7.i! .Q;S1l .! ~ ~ I- it of: .!i. .s;, .. 'lI ~ ~ it .. ii .. li 31 ::l D f: .. 8 it 11. .. Ql c ~ ., 11. l:D c ~ .!! IC to > C .. ... o Ii ,. o E e .. ~ Ii u c .!l ~ ,. ., ... o 1:1I .E C it eo .. '5 to 'lI o U .sc ... ~ o 11. ".2 c .. .g ~ ::;;'lI :5~ u _ ]'0 .~ lII..: 11. C C e .2 B go -e '[ S[t o~~ .. .. .. Q,'" C .. 0 D -;I:g. ;; .8 .e. DlB.c ~ ~i c 11. .. ;:I .. ~ ~.!i ~ ;: ; a B~8 M - I) ,.. '1:1 I: .c I: I: 11. it ;:I wi] ~ l!i.; i!= D..>: to .. ~ ~ 8. ~ . _ 0 a !! li f: C .2 '3 .Il. .!! -:: ,; CI .S .il IC u I> .. .. .. Jl o Q, r. 3' .. to -:: to .. ;:I Ii to .Q ] :5 e .!I to U C ~ .. ,. I> ~ .. ~-5 .;'0 .. .. ] !l ~.. ::0 ~ ~ U 0 ~ :; ~ : DI .. C -s:; E .. E 0'" U 0 Ii to ,. .. o lL S :i ~~ :'5 .. ~.2 .. r: . Ef" e! :s '2 E .. .. ~ ~::;; .!! 8 B a .~ .5 ! S 1>'1:1 .s;, e t-;;.u 1!]j .... ,. o i .. .. u c .!I ;; JO .. .!!. " ;; "Cl 0:: II ; .!l .s:: .. &. .:: J :?:' 11. E 8 c:i5 o :I: ='1:1 .2'r: .. it I> -5 .g ~ 'lI r: :J .. .!! '5 .. ~ .11 ii II C D ~ B .sz I: 3' .. to .s;, I- c .2 .. ~_.. -::.. t:o <:~...g ?H! g' ~ "'- c CI CI o:J~t: .E 1l .. il :? ~ .= '; '0 >.: ~ .?:~O"ii a. ; h ;. ~ E ~ II "e~-s ~8"Di ~ tI .. 11. lf~'5.s "'D '" ell '" .. 0 :; .., c .. to.s;, Q 0 a .!J 'il' ~ ~ ~ c. CII " S s :u; 'tI ..- ~! ~ ~D;;~ =.r. u c 'i "e :5 :J ;:I .. 8; ~ D...c c..~~ .~ ~ .., Q o ... .E : ~ c: ~ '5>..gJ "'0 t: :: > toDlI: Dllrli ~ ~ c.U~ I:: H iU ... ! c: .z:; ti 0>1>"-; , -UU~.> .s;,~:lu; ~Clg:5a. !oS.s aa " -0 ~ 'c c :J .. Jl '5 .. .2 :s CI .. .. .. to ;:I l1' e OJ " C ~ Cl ,. OJ ..c: .. .; '" o .0 .. N .. ,; 'c .2 :;: C I> 31 11. :c .. 1! .. .s;, OJ '5 g .. ;:I Q i .. 'lI C .. .. .. ..!l '5 >- :i ; 1ft .9 r! CI 8- 11. .. OJ U C .~ .. ,. '1:1 OJ .. .. I> ;:I l1' e .. ~ ~ I ~ i 'lit: S elL ~"IIOa. 8.g'5,,;;~ 2001"5 Q.~ .~:c ~i-!o;l .... "U ';: t: II .9]'.; oj ~a~~; 'E: fl'~ ~ :J-=~ :] ~:!~:6g UJ! :E.D':~] ~ ~ ~ ~ Ii <: 11. J ... :!l -B a.. 0 0 .. ::;; a ,.. c ; c,..t:,2u 0'E8.-.. uIooOG'- G~~:~ E r: I> .. C 2 ~ .I: U I:: ..o:;s~ II >- 0 . .;=".5_ ~ ~j-8l '1:1 ::;; u !II I> ~ 0 CI.. t: 11. It.. U C U II o.:Jt. ... &:ecSo ! 1J..2.!t;: I: u e I> II II .. >- c c~cs.8 .!i C .. ... .. i; 13 >- .I: ::i~~5 ~;!...~o IJ Q.; ... 6-5 iri S !l .. 8. 0- Il ;; II g. e >. t: a 8- I: [ .9: '3] .sz: OJ 0 -s~ iI' U I: f! >= .. ~'5 8- 'c oi D 8.,€ c...2 " .. .. 0- : :; e J'lI 11. I> .. iI .c iI .;::.....c .:: :E ; o :I: S -Z ~ " i.i] ~~f DI 8 li .S .11_ ~ D ~ .&~e .s'S= .. lr-8 ~ ii.ll B Jl ... ~'5g .. I> "CI o >. .. iI "i .. a .. c .. .. S '1:1 C 'CI a:: e I :I c .!I ;; :. .!l ~ s .. c :l 1:: 0. 0. .. OJ '5 ... o e .. .. '1:1 OJ .s;, .. c &. ;:I !: j~ ax. 'lI 0 ~ Q. iI '.. -e-s o .. I:~ .!I c ~ S c e !:s ,. ~ a II ~~ .. I> :; Ii ;:I I> l1'o. e .. I> .. ~ :i u ~ : .. I> .c ii 2'ti .. OJ ~ B ;:1.2 :E,!I Q ~ Oi I> E g. ~ : ...s;, I> .. 'I:I.c ~:E ~ ~ :I.s: E"CI o I> 0 .Q-C ... :0 t;l .0 CJ;:. .2' I> c tI '5 is f: :J c .~ ~S ~ II C .11 !/ '5 E ... .. D ~ Dlii. ~ E c .- II .. tiJ:' I> t: ~ 8- ~~ -5 Ci .. .s;, .!! ::ri ;:I Q, OJ '5 >- ..,t: u c ~ ;:I "i E ,..E "i) 8 r! OJ I>.s;, ,. .. "CI... .. 0 a: !! c~ Sa J J ]Oi .. ti .. r: 'c & B 0 I: -! :r ;! c u .~ t: ~ c E 8 - .. 1i. II Ii ;; I: .. DI t;l ;S OJ j .9 > .. o c is J 'c ~ 0; .. 'lI 8 c -! .. ,. u.'; .c'll .. 0 ... u o .. DlI: ~ E c a. e .2 001> .. ,. ~{l _.15 ~;: .: ,1.:...p~ceiD1 1/ ~ 7 (,; '-I I lclu{q~, 50,dO PROPERTY OWNERlS) NAME & ADDRESS: 'PAul-lA/if. 2;1,1, , /~1'-J.-,) /11/ M.t.J .f)-<. ()/E~.-fuJ;fP~, /~/.4r J',r(,?c,I .- .l&b tJ ~ crTY OF ClEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPUCATION . . I VII '~)"1!, J REPRESENTATIVElS) Of any) NAME & ADDRESS: F:1ZIhVK- Se/~t5L-L ...z-v ::3 0 iV A s: 1-1 s;: T 7 Cf ~ e s- Cu.tv' p~ - 797. r; t,c / r; ~. TELEPHONE: 'Iff.? I s''?/..?,79/ TELEPHONE: 1;:/.3) '79?... 64116 ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: .2# to tJ..t/1r: .Tp ::? /! ~ J? / c/ ..t? I' NAME OF nUSINESS (IF APPUCABLEI: 1/ t 0. 0 e IF I'd r- E < ~. ' , ZONING DlSTRICT:I(. ~ eEl' LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: c~;r~ , ' , c.J :;J ~ '4"-' LAND AREA: .r? --r.r Or-IV PARCEL NUMBER: / I I :2 9 I I b I ~ 0 (')" 0 I /.?-o I 0'00 IThis Information Is nvaililble from your tax receipt or contilct PinellilS Co. Property Appmiser's Office at 462.3207, If more than one parcel number, attnch B% x , 1 inch sheet) . , DESCRIBE SUnnOUNDING USES OF pnOPERTY: North: ' South: C () AI.., '''- e,' .-f.( c..", n('" ?~ Ilf-I East: West: t! Q,.v,4( /; /I- ~.. r!- / (l() ~ A( I' A. (! I' 'd- / VARlANCE(S) REQUEST (If Varinnce to 7 year nmortization requirement, refer to Sec. 134.015): .~ WI/I Nf?eo /v J~ t;;~. 4 ~). . I .---- .... Ae.+...~ d . ;JJic Fg""t ~ ' p t:.1'.rr I roI ? .. ~ - '~. /, t ~:~l~} ~" E CJ.,<' </' fa r> ..tr-,,;;;;;' , Q11.Ll L' ,5.edb~('~k '(71LijD:f::M /.' :5J(!~lCI~ A RrAs''/I/YD/N<'5 IL. . U-), LoU!..' REASON FOR REOUESTING VAnlANCE(S): (Refer to Stondards for Approval, next page) .-;; A-(" ~ e .f4 ~h,{)~/O HL I'~.<'/.../, /(1' .L. T C,uoC/k -71e /J 11.1 7' /J-~ .() --r-;; .8//",,, ;:J/J'~/("'~7' 11.<#1,; (~oJl/lp ~ """"-1/ K~ u/' -ro /11 r/O'I /4;1,-<' , 'p &; ./ /.-{tC ---..f , I 5'/C;jr tV/L-L )/Gtir ,4/-L OLifE~ S!'4A/ c~.pe t< Eif:j7J/J. ~ 1--1 B ~;-5 , t=i'1 $' ~~t.. CONTINUCD Oil nEVl:Fl5E SIDE ,j ,\ " , . . STANDARDS Fon APPROVAl: A varlllnce shall not be granted by the Development Code Adjustment Board unlasr, the, application and Ilvldence presented clearly support the following conclusions: (1) The varianco roquested arises from a condition which Is unique to the property in quastlon and Is neither , ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by en nction or Dctlons of the property owner, predecessor In title. or the applicant, Any mistake made In the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of D permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. ,(21 ,The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development tode would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. , , 131 The variance is the minimum necessary to overcame the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. 141 The request for D variance Is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater flnanclDI retLlrn from the property. (5) The granting of the variance will not be mnterlally detrimental or Injurious to, other property or Improvements In the neighborhood in which the property Is located, .' 161 The granting of the variance will not impair Dn adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the Dppearance of the community, substantially increDse the congestion in the public streets, Increase the danger of fire, endDnger the public safety in any Wily, or substilntiDlly diminish or impair the value of surrounding property, (7) ,The varionce desired will not adversely DUect the public heillth, safety, order convenience, or generDi welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desir~d will not '\Iiolate the genernl spirit and intent of this development code. . ~ SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER lOR REPRESENTATIVE): Sworn to nnd subscribed before me this J ?'r!2 day of rf) c..C-O(;c.-J A.'D., 19..92:.... by _&AA1v;tL 1?~/~ who is/are , pe~sonally known to me or has /have produc,cd ~ti , ' identification personally appeared deposed Dnd stated the matters and facts set out herein are true and correct t6 the best of his/her,knowledge and belief. Notnry Public, CommissIon No. ,,';';'J.~'r%~, OFFICIAL SEAL :' \R~.0r \ Marc A, [), SlIvormlln ~ ,~~tJz~;{!. i My Commlulon Explrol ....~. <.'I.J;;\\....,.: I MIIY 4, 1996 ..~',dl\lf'r;.. Comm; No. CC 194164 oft...,._ (}iL (}t()" . " '/?1/( ... ~\."VV~Vn,a-l-- (pm" nf T'I' "f...1U m......~ Ilfgr...rm.l NOTE: PROPErrfV OWNEIl on ru~rm;sENTAT)VE ~l!ST ATfEND lIE^RlNG. . Ru\'. B/92 :II ...- I " ' ., , .. t f' . ~. '.'; t. ~ q, .. -I] I, e "- \ \ ", '" I , . ~ , . . -i " " I , .., . , ~~ . . ~ .. .........., .. 'I.. , ... If , - ~ ,~' - ' I . l,'i'rJ~~'II'l'I''''":"",, 1'1 ... ,. .''''' .~..l' t,. . , :~.!,:' . , . '1 : "".\.; ~.~;X f'.1t {:1il' ':~, ' l"d . , ~~~f- ~~.'~ ~I.~~~~ >.')11 I" I I I ! kj, jv'l"NR. ..........1:.2. t ~:,!.).i' ". . t I I I J ,} , : : ~ ' l":'~ -. .. .....J.. ....J.... .j. . I., . . " ',. 'I 1 I I ; lfl 1~.~I:.'~~~g;:"r. .::O~ ~~~ 'If::~~i --- -'4.G?'j"""i' ,Of 2.; '. : .~~ -':-1-:----j"--r-!-+ . j{~ ~;-I!'i..2'C'3'1',"~'):-"" -; : " n'J~ . -;;.tF"\' i. (iCl.3',) :..... '=; 7. 7 q.- 'L -~-rT:-'f--t-... r" .-; ...... .., . I . ,it:il ~~,: I ~-~l' ,X.!!JSPH~~:' 8.:'rI.S'. ""I (-?{~f:; , ~'u, I ,I" . ..... '.~.;\ oi'!',' c.~ I@' LL.~. : ) - iJ ~ 'r~ ,....''1' r'~:' ~ 5-:: ./:({2' ;-: "L ~ ,'"~ ~~I-._.-I'"-'-'l"'-"'"'~''''''r''''' . ....- '2.1,.' j -;:1 . I II J ... . ') N~ '-f--' ._.~.~L~.TJ~.(:.: ...~.. eI..."J.,/.V\/1 p~ 5"~ z.. St>I.~ ~..:) .,....., I I I : . . " t~~ r<;?u.~.l?j A:..;L,..I.O.,,:-..J., ..' .;.. ~:U~ -.)El'.,. ;'-="";?"I{-.,....,:..h, "..~~:_f~.' ,; .5\ ';:. 2 II;. \.':": t. D ,'~' .5.' p:~ .;. 'I I . I,,~ij .: '~. ~F-'"' -i'b7'!--~:::;--rt-:.;, .......~ ~:d.: . 1 i") n?~ '; t3':' t1 <. 2. --:J ('I V ! -to .~ ~ (,., , , 1-. . iH~l';"':-:' -~.: "'~l"~ I I I : S :D -.:.,' .---.- Wr: '. . ~: ~"\--- ",--,,1--+. '-']-" ; r :..... [; ':~-i . . ; . t t ~ I ~ 'l~i .';' :: ,:~Ji~): --tX'-'~~i~;"'" ~~. ~ '"i ,'-:, t-'.j- 3 J.~? " C] 1"0 l;~~{ '. ".....1 '"'~...:.:- , ., "'j . '., It. 1'-1. ':r, 'D c. C p . 't~\. '.. I " . I" . ; .~r.f . 'i, ~::'. I : I!. I .".'" I .. -r...........'"'......_."I......_....".........~...__........_.... .'P .... ...... : :-d~.f..;.l;.. ";., II I . ~ I ~i'F'>;l.:~1 :... :'.-1\.' 1 i i : I ' .t.'i.I~f....:.:,: _....-t-'~.I-....~_...,.._..1. ,.... ' . . -,~ :s,,' . - . I I I" I ',:1 ~:.; '.. .:.:. t \: . :~';t~~':.:':: ' ;-I---;~.-"f-..~' ,-_.~ -..:... .,........, ,. , , l'k.~ '." --_...._.j....l-.' -;,.. ~ ,.... "''''1 I I I ~ .' . '.IJ'~ l' I ~~',)j r I ! ,~.~:~p. --'.l~""'" .......k;.. ~"; /'.l!~' , .' ! : c,I,......!. -'-l-""" ...... ~~';1~ .. I . "r"~~ I ,l,~t ' -, - ..."...... j... I .r.t. ' I ' ~.~Itt\ c .. " I' l:; ~', ,.. J", t i . . 1~~J:i. : ~~...r...,'..;',...:'.":.. 1~~::1::~ ~_.L,~..:.... .... ,... .." ,. ~\~,~{~i> { II'--'-~"--r-'-~';' ':--~.,.". ,.', ~"'r:"'''':'". t~.." " ~\~:.!,:,,~:, ;-:--, --["--;"-'"-1''' ,.. . -t\ow, ;',"',. , '; ;' 1"~'~""" ...:.......j:.......!., ......... h, U. ' : ~j:'''. ~iT~;-L ...... . :tg . , -':"'.i--'; " . :f~ . .. i 1 1. ; '1-1:1.:,: :. -,l.rt:.. .-:-.. . '..., ' I . p , _..........t.+u........'T.. ~~. I"... i I i ~ 'I...... :,,:.:, . I '. , .~?':;~ "-..... ---1--1' .-........ lr:-f': . '.' 1': I l~< '.,' " \ , . . A Le.O C. ~ ...jn:::I~ ~oJU.___.--_.-_ ,'...l~-l.'......;i... . <:::2 LlQ\ll~Ati~ '. SILCOX ENGINEERING, INC., 5409 Nebraska Avenue" TAMPA, FLORIDA 33604 Phono (813) 230.9755 I' . GHt'Cl tlO,,__ _____..:- OF , '.' . '(.,' . .\~l,?~![.,=~ C('I.CUL,I\'(CO 11'( l?:SS o ^ u: ..' .....',~~1. I c:> - 7-: :r7,.Z'i~, ~tllCt;ED 0'( ...:. Co\TI! :'~i~\;.cr:~.:, I:~[ti:\"~',-t..~ ~\;~~~~~7~~ heAl.!; '. I t9 1- 0:' : -,f" : ! I ~';;~'I'~~&' -.--- _..,.' "-'-rC-'.-i-- . < : . ~ ~-.;. '.~ ~.: . .. ~ ..,:::~:. ~ -- ....... ..\.- ...~ , 1~'t .-:.... '-L' .~.. ~:;:~ ~~: ...J ... ..,_~~:;.~.. - I '.:: ,....~'r , ~ ~..;. ~wr. .. ~~ i ,,,' l~' .:~ Iwj ~ · !:'.). t:f1'U .....,--,-- d;:rr I - ,,' . .h'~ I '. :\;j,t' ... .. ...- I". ...,-- ..... .-- j .j..!., 1 ~ "', ~~"'. . .., ,_.. -'".....-.-,. -..:...;.;.; 1 I I .. .;:: . ' I 1 N' '.'." ..t.., ., ""'r'--l'''' - -:-- 1 i. . '::;.' '''..~.;i.. ill'''''' ,....; ~~, -1'-' --j- . ?fl I ~ I' . ~I1'" : -, F!~ ' -~i--11 ~1~Q1Xf.~' , . \ . I, ., I~. ~~J:"... ': ' .. ..,.. ~'''''i ......1'.., I :". ~.':}' I . I ~'I': . ~.l~~(," . ~ t J . ,,";'t, . ..... .;_..... :..... I.." 'l"j'C:O"TIi;t"~~Ti';;~ ~ ~ .:... .:.....~." ..... ~_ ....\1............-'-- :.. ~ t . ~ . : ~1 ~ ~ ~ !,~.. ."~~U; ..: ,.... "', ,..; ,.....:, "..l. . B.. ,,---1'--"'I-"..'.L..- ' ';!::' ~T~~'; I ,i; ~ i ! I . ~ I .i.~~. '~~r : ! I I I '.i~~.. -:;~nt ....., ,..........,.,,, ,. ......,.. '.'" . II...'.. "11 --....11-, -".-l-.....--I -_. ,.,." .. .~.>. ~~~;: I : i : j I l ..... I.~... r . r.......... "'j"- :.....:. ".':"......i..--;'..--I"- -:-17 .--:"lr ~. ,..', ,~...~.~. m...;...h.....;.._......._.....~...._-~~.. I . . I ,,' i-I ! I .' ~;..~~ , ';,.... ... '""""j-'" ," " ......1..--..1-'-l--.\..- -- ~,;:~. t I. I 't;"~ :;;~; .., . ,-,....,.... . ..:..._.,..I..."'..-l..-.-,.......]---y~~.~~ ~ ._,'" ....,.. , "....._,....:-...."_..:...-_~..._..ll,.--l. ,....;;"[~ , ,! ~ .~~~..,.t~.'. '.. " ; ~ .'.:.. ... L.H ..~ ~""'l"~' ..' );.~, :lL~ I I : I ...... ~l;f d:" ._.... ....-.. ...:..:. . +;.:~ I . : ""~ ~:~~. ... .,.~.,...;.~-_..t-- .to'., . .... ~11,o1'i ~ l,'~' "'~ ....,j,1 .,_.-j~--:i ,>:~ I ." "~. "'-. .......1 .,;:~ ~ '.'. ,. ..~:" ...."'-r--.:-~ I .~' "-~~i' i r' .' 1,~: -" .-... . '~T--' _.. ~ I I I/':\'~ - 1, I" , .. ...,......., ...~.._...:---r-I;:- : ~ l' . '.. j . . ,....'...-r.-r~ : I':' '~i. ....~.:~........ f'----- , . .~. 'J "I P61~' ....f.... /I () . '/./Ip)-! .1' 'I p, >', I" /,' ;2J'S. : jL J{ l\. \ I ,. '17, C(', ~. " ~ . . " . - e'/.: ~ 't: co . :) 5~ It? .8/~ ,. \. + '1. 1 '::)16> .:; f-.. ' '~" 7 t .. 'L.IO - .." ! . , ~. '{-/ . /04 - 1/ I t7 .- , ' ,. , J " ,,, I '.. .~ .....~~ ... ,..,....._._~ , . . : ,-., '..'~ . 1 I.r ....... . '. -: . -~--,~.<~,: ~ 1 \-'/,.. ""1' , '.~T_>"''' ~Ii~ .;,r.r..; I "4 +..;]"'. ; I' ':<'::: :~1~ ....- ._--_...-.._._.~--------,_.. .. , " ,\ -.... . ; .,.. ," \, "1 ... ~ ...... k---- I , '.' ..;.._r~,:;:f~ ". "'t" "'~";O::;it~'If!'T" I . '1 ~:~i..t1~.~~t~~~1.t.. .~> ,~~',i~~>:' ~;;:I'. !~. <r. \ ~"j · ::i It 1 1 ~'''O' . ( \ I<_L 7! i<- '11 ~ O,lil _ .v /'~ ;":, ";'-;" :':-::,';, ~, I' - 0" . '. .-"-. .,. " ..., ~ . ~::-:::-:~7:~-:':::~. :;~:"~-::'7=-. _'':'':'::'~. _..-:~_:::.===- : . " 1 ..'t'.:'" ;. ~ . ~ .'. :,- .-.1"... '--;i~ . /; .,,: I ....":. .). . ". ", ....... L. I \ i , ,1 I '. '1 , I . ;1 .., !\ . ,,' ':'''.1': ". II ~ "l ~ j ;:" I, q : 'i ~ ,.:; . ,fj H '1 f j, I .f, f t 'f ' . , " IL:' I[ fr \ I ' " I' 'j , 1. \ . . ~.~ J' I . / / / '~/"" 't~. ...,// , j . .." t ~ I . ~ '11I1 . .....I.......~ I' '. 'I. . ~ .:t;~~.:l~ll7ii;..".., iH; .r. /'!.:.'i'::I"1""" ..,.....;.,8.1:.'.! "''\ n~;.r?f~:'~,~~~~:-:-:~~,,-~, 3___.~ 'I:t~~~ ;.Al~':r:':itE: ;\.,."._.. -. . 2t"(..;lli\')~..l.~" '-I~" ...~~(:"~~~f...i.. ...... f.~.' . ~?W~:;\~ ,;, : :: ' .",,1.4.... 1'\':" . ~ ~~~ . ;'. . :! , ' ;::~::~ t.. i..... '1' ~ ~ ;.~ .' "; ~ t ' W;~l;;~N ere (1 ~ e I A : i\-'- (uiltJ.ii::ff.~"esr-: IlO Mp.Ll ;;: ~~l&g~~~.:A~:3.. ~R-..6,., j! f~ b'c~'~'::', I:?::.t.' sri ~G.-: ....... ,: .{~'I!'''''~~~~~':'A:'' '7..'roo P,51!' ;; U-;;.~I:~.,..,.. .. ,'" i: 1;1..1 -:'\I~..1&- FO{)11~~S ~1~'~;:\~~.~~1" .. I. :'. p~;.I'~;;~. ':,' .... f ' 1 . " ... ~ . ~I . . '.., \.. . ., ,:!,:':c.~',~.." , ""'ii.. '"", '" . t oI",:_~....t ~'."",' ~-..- '''' _...--':.___..:....__~_:,_____.._.._'_.....__.._. f...... : '~,;7;::' .... ~ " r ("' , r' It.. ~i-:7:.':.-;: ",'. ,.:. '.. .. I ,,-'~ f l~;-'::~~..:~:":,"I f' '1 ,.' ,"t;\Z: . l~ ~ ! 'e ," .l~ .:.:.;......l , i~~;,,:; .f.:s.'~' .' ~ . .' , :1 'j I ,I 'I " .\ 2tO.~ H:.f, '0(:-'.. >. : ' I' v ._~-_. ! :;: ., '2 '0" " . i l..._._._.~...., _ __...~.~.._..~~._'_ _.~~_.~.~ .,..__ '; __1':.1,1.__ ... ~~-_.... '-i\"'~-"-~'-_.''''-" ......... r..-'" .......---:...--.'.--........--.,:, I..... ..- ! I , ;' 'II:, . . .- 'Ill:! '2.tl ~ 0 · .;:,;,' , ~ 1'~\~'T" :___.l..-.._._._._._....._ Lt.. .........._._: .._'::'::'~:':_'. ,........ -__-:-..i ___ "/.::.} ....1.-':- .....,t't,...,'t..,..~~ .T.. '.1 "'., .... .... ":" +~.'.~ ,.... .::~. ;::,:,";.:::..~.....~;. "-r 1 .. -. . + , . I . . ~-:..-;..:-~~_.!~.~...:;~":' ~:.;~l:;;~.,~r~...:.-:!:.:;. ,,~:7:-7-"""'" : ~ . 7.."~ . .."",," """"""~~~~_...,--_.......- ..........,......,.PO.....~..'I!__,.,..;;:,;;...__........ .t. ~ .. .... -~\. 7'~...'-~t~.J.,.,;J:- ..~i....+?;...~..~.......4,.l.. Ii' IJ _... '. ".' ..... _ , .-... . . " e,:.,"" ~ ~ " ..0::.""'1, . ,~ . q. ........ "'"''.''''''' '!'!~ L . [1'1'...0 , . . fit e .'~t: . o. -.-...." "-"--.'- --... .~, l' - .. . I ':':"":~""'" . < .\ tl . ~ 'I ~ j ". /' "$J.1H~!';: ~ I _I ..r "I if: ::~~ ; t"V r . '2:':, ,. t.. !' J , ,'}~:'.;;.Ik~~~ l ~.' j~~."~:'~i~,,~ ~ 11 E~I STI,-",N,;:,;~; I:: \ IS II ::)' '0 J A , ", " :,~" .~ I.:'....... ST~l:L f'H:;>C: ',~.'~, ,I t \",;t: r,.i'l e XI S" ~ 6- ';~:~ It' A '0"0" D U\. .~ ~;:p !,;: l"~ S"f~L r?1 pe~; ,~':.~>~ p " . ::\: " .. , '. ',~ ' '.~":'~ ", .....'., J . .' . . ",.., , . .e.'.._.:....__......____.._.... ...._..~, ... '~": ':~~:' '1,..".] I' ".:\' :,?;~tr..T~J.~..,l:.-;..~. ~:. ~,,-___~:::'=-.. ... .. .:: .:: _:~.+.. . ::: ;;. ':-;..~ . .. , . , ; , .~ '; ~ " ~' ~ I. ~ :r. .\ ~l .; , , , ~ ~' p ~, '.. '" -.~..I t: ,"... -.. -1-.., .. ::, },J D '. " i:; ~ :.. ~:. ~f : j:\ t: ~: ." ':1 VI; 1 . " i..' .... I { . I . / . {, .' .J '.. ..... I !' ~":..".." I ... . .<, " ,J. '. ~j y( ~9:~i.. ~t;J I, ~ 1.-:-':,.:):, \ ,,1/-~ l~~.:~~.~..~:.' IJ1' I" Y'" V I ~F.~f'.q .~" ~.: :~~\~~.~'-t .: I .. j ,I I .. / \ ~ , , ! .I , I , r' .... , , . ~ -. ..... -.. . . .......-----.--..- ~ CER 7l{lF.a 70: .- SEe, 1 B TlJP. 295 RGE.16E :S.Lon;'. (;7<4,F TOSA" ACRoS. I~Acl.L, 324.50' NB9'41 \8 W 294.50 ~ ~ ?;: , I"') i:i p 5 III "" - '''l I a d CQ N I I 'j I f J i 8 d CQ N ;to K w . co !'I p e .... ..,........, LPQ!! I.Ul I' F..."u.... l- I ,.J~E'n:,~1 i~ SlClI POST TO BE / REMOvtO . II' OIA. POST ILl , CQ !'l EXlS ntlO I 5 TY COS 124111 TO #24211 _EXlsnIlO Slotl (SEE DEtAIL) ~ ;0'42'23' ( I ~f" ' ~,,' rCM 3D' ~ -~ P 5 ~ . 19'O ' 0~r-10'55"E =' IV, 200.00' ("otUJ. #J E V4- 5GC. If:,-z.'lt;.-''-e I I~ I 0P,o.B, 11B9'~0 55 W 294.57 '~ -9ULF-TO-8AY BOULEVARD L SB9'40'SS"E 324,57' n r. c: i~ 1 V I~ : ~ r:'ln !lIW; I'rrr. m j.rr::rr u+p,'IIIIITl="n llllO 10: . '~\bk: 1 3 1992 SUBJECT TO NIY AODIT10llAL 'EASEMEmS OR RE5lRICnOllS Ot RECORD l' Uolc: Copies of Ihl, Survey nol , volld u"le~~ emboued ~:!., .19nln9 SUfVe)'G'" oeol. , i -I I ., , l ,; 110 IF.: 1111S SURVEY WAS I'El1FORMED FOR nit PURPOSE or lDEllnFYlIIO nlE LOCA,!!Otl Ot TIlE EXISntlO SIOIlS nlD, . rounD Sl"l( . sa P.I<. 14M. n~ - tOlJlID 11I011 ROO 'Ol . rOUHD CQIClltTt 1I00N\1Oll nro wr 'x" . rOVIID CUT ~ ' g;C . Sl:cnaJ '!'lIP . TO~~lF ~llt - ~""'c( II - IoIUSJnto p '- I'I.).f !ZM_ stT IIlDlI ~1lO .. eN' 'I I BASIS or [lEARltIOS: !-EOAl.. AS PROVIDED BY OWlIER , . , LEGAL OESCRlPTIOtl: mOM TIlt SOU nl WEST CO/HIER or mE NORlHE^ST 1\" OF SECI10tl 1 B. TO\',USIiIP 29S, RANCE 1GE, RUt~ SDUlH 80'40'55" EAST,ALOIIG THE EASr-....'EST CEIITtIlUIIE OF SAIO SECrlOIl 18, 200 fEET rOR THE poun or IlE:CIIl/ll/lc; THEIICE COtlllHUE ALOIlG THE EAST-WEST CEtlTEIlLlIlE or SA'D SECTION 18, 32".57 FEET TO THE CEtlTtRUNE'OF KILMER AVE., TlIEtlCE NORTH 1'01'28. EAST, ALONG THE CEIlTERLlIlE or KILMER AVE.. 3~O,OJ FEET TO THE SOUTH Ur~E or 'CULr-TO-BAY ACRES f'IRST ADDIl10W AS IlECOROEO III Pl.AT BOOK 52, PACE 55 OF TlIE PUBLIC RECORDS OF PIIIElLAS COUIlTY, nOR IDA: TIlEPlCE tlDRTIl 89'''1'1 B' "','E5T, ALOIm lllE SOUTH UtlE OF SAID .CULF TO BAY nRST ADomoll', 324,5 FEET: THEIlCE SOUlll 1'02'13' WEST. 330.02 FEET. TO THE POINT OF BEGIWlINC, LESS THE SOUTIl 50 FEET AllO T1lE EAST 30 FEET FOR ROAD RIGHT or WAY, I do further cerUfy that the 9urvey represented hereon meets '172.027 Chapter 21HH-6, FlorIda Administrative Code. the requIrements of the Florida Statutes '4~~~ Ronald L. HU9t~ P.L.S. No. 3747 ~~o~erstone .... ~ . ENGINEERS V'SUITX C r -#38 CULl" PH, Engi.'n,eerin.g & S'U,rveying, Inc. . SURVEYORS LAND PLANNERS , - TO - DAY POULEV.ARD, CLEAR 1f'.A TXlf, I"LDR.l.DA 34t11tS (If ra) 4-#7- 1 703 OR 0148-4384 U^ lE.: 10\06\1992 DRM{1l 8Y: RLH UN, 1m: -- SPECIAL PURPOSE SURVEY ~p''''''' l . -...... ,.", d il lj d ~"l' J ~ 1 ~pjjl 531, 5-'2 :333 534 535 74~ ^-.:;: ,!~ - " v 153~ 53t 53i lOt lOl 10~ 99 .... 'lI;l -. 1: -. QQ) ~ ~ ~ ij ~ ~ n 216 c.~C\\1 el( , :, STREET g ~-':-a ~~: ~~~-. ~ 563~ 564 tsG5:J . ':J~' 1J3:J 134 I " SOO ~ sm:uzy SIIl:u.EY '::::l .. GARDEns... GARDEllS II) 135 ~ n CO~_J'l'IT ! n cr~~ ~ :uo 2ft 9 5 laD I I 22 II: r. 20'- _~ _ IJ ~ d~~~ lotI ~ III.~~~,~ 6 ROlf ' --- }~ 1-~---- 20 'I I tot! 0 I E {/ 7 lit -.E-t ~--~I ~- ~ 1,;9 'J~ I \) B m ~ -~ 7-rli - -'t .16 9 1t7 L -L\~ t,8 17 ~ I J 30'_ ~;._I_-'j -=--- ~ -f;y .!04 16 - I 1 0 3.Q~ _ ~ . 1 po~ 52 :; ~ ~ tal ~ ~ ~ 1 2 J 4 5 -- -- - --I-{B 22 21 20 19 18 17 11 ~ ~ ~ el :; tl' t; ~ ~ ~ ~ . g CHAUCER sf ~ S E -- --;:-~. ...,'" I ... '" - 30', .. .. "'11\'" .., '" , ~ ~ ~~~ ~ 6;:<; 7 ..--!' 2 .3 I .. I' 5 36- 6: _::... r-oJ'- - 22 '20 19 '.811) 17-.1'1 ~ -. .... .., iii .. .... .. .. "" ~ ~ .... ~I t; t ~ Ii ~ SHElLEY GARDENS COND?_~~rr 2 STREET -:ill a 5971596 595 594 8 ( 0- 35 ~ z ~ a 216 . ---- ~ 71 _:.3.o.!.. B I J..) '61 if\21~ ~ 224 ~ ~ '"i01 .I~ 9 1tO ,1.' ' 10"00 S!= ~.J 4 '~-.!:. ~ I 2 I '1~o(J 3~ 6 20i .W .3 I g 15 eo ~ l-3 14 J.a13 tiJ~ ~~ I? .!,o 110 SHEllEY ---- 24/05 24/06 \J~ I"- ~ -t N 13/01 1 J/O~ CG 13/06 I"- o ...... r") ..-- ~ ~ \:~.~ !') .:!:~~::~::mi:::::r::~j: eo ~ ~ ~ . - . \ tiJ "". ,t' s, I . eo ~- . ~ (.1 '.--.- .... ..1"....-'-----.. ;-r 3i1:zlR M H, :'1'\ I! ., ~ ' ;.3n4, : JI/Ol ! 'jOJ - 'UJ Ill" ILl I, !:~ ~?2 ... .'~I:' OJ .l(1(\ ," I '~'IC' 1 I .. II) (:';)0 101;>1 '1 F'-..jO~I~.31'15 I I'~~I ~U7H '\~/Ufj 1 .,-;;:;' 'Tl'~ l.l-.4..l.1- ~G~-(~ ..,- 106 - iu~ ;.u~ I ._- I J\O ,J01 ,lUll J I. I I ' t \-' .,. ,- _..,- . l' ' - ",, 'J, Ion IU :lUU N ,JOII Lllo .. 1 ~~!~' \Ill'! I k~ -d MJ!/ . lOil 111) h , . () :'If JII 112.oJ I - j .1 . . 1I2 ," V' , I ~, r:~'" _..~~ H' R M ~ :'0711011 [ 10/ 1 114 ~II :'12 '~:j (\, " ' Iii'-- nath. 1.0: >- ~. L " _ . I MI M.' ., 11(1 113 71~. ;i~ V , B1i-'..,r ~.1 ~81 ~~. ,f.. 1UD"n 1111} I M(j ~15 . I IIi . 115 2111 " ~ , ~ - - - . .Si.r I . ,7' ,~.r :1 ....~il. - 11:,", :'1'1 tI\ ....'" ':::r l ,-,. 1.........~' : P1Uh" -~I:"'" "',", :~: 1~I;hJi m'R .,~ .;.:~ ~j,l, 'ft~ II,;B/I M7 ~\ 110 111 1'" 7" 0..J ... .,1 ~ :':l ~ ro ~ 31.' .J roi~ ii-lli'". "'I' ", .... 'p',:f '~~ 1 ~":) illtJ .~rfl In nj "'1 i"'1 .. "'1"; ffi I I;; lim ",(,~ ~ 8ii ;.,. tiC! ~;:.:, ,;.',:-:;, ,>:l!, : li:l~ ,!. ~ ::,0$':;' "t\v.HI 174 119 11'0 22!i 4:' ,lot: U' fl .... '" ~''>l.)' Jl..> r;: I. I., ':'u.ll'L9: ~ o.\J ; .:.J\I 8 t.:: llf"'~ ~l:.. .,.- J I 0\ ~7-; ~ J ~)i ~: :;jJ ~I wi i - '; i. ~;~,j 'flil'.J.;;;;,I, ." I. , 1;-. " ,Ui ,1. :II '.iIl,,' ~ A 'h~ .: :1'~{lB~ {,:!:!:.f) 1 ;.,. Il!l... nit'" 7~~1 '.J'O; ~ ~'iW., ',7fti .;;m ,1j~, '. It! :;:r.l1Q~I~ ,~. " ! ~~ J~~ ~ I 1.\7 '''1 II I .. I 11' . ',I ~J ~\. ,";;' ,. :-J"""'- r... 1W~:701 :' 'II ~,;; ~Q ',il'I1',~I,~~ 1" ,'01;,.. '~~I I ...~ ~ '1, I .~: :;1, {;~ :;{ ~ ~l' 131:,1 !!i-I~'~:j,~'~[H-, li}~' ~,u.;::.:~"'(~r.R\7i $.1fJ'ltll"hr,l: "jJlil tit" 1.\4 11\ '1}4 'JJ ... ~ ..., -~ I - ~ I, 'li104 IIM,!1 ~ 'i:t:;1 t '101 'II:.:Q':';~ j~I~11 '~I'(;~' ,w/I ~ t. Il'l :"'5, · N, of' !t: :OJ'~ 'I Jl" ....~ d ,I(i :i;,' ~I ol. ,\il ,~li'\ " I I. ~"'Ft-,,,g, i :---..;:, I' '1 l}~, "1f "J7 ~ ~'l N' n N ,) .. ~- I'" ",,-c. 2.0" P"I 7l.' g :... ~ I :J I '1111'. 1411 I' -I <:il 10 !O! 101 '" '" -"-' ~!~'... .. ;:..c ~ Ii: ~ ;'1'., ,Ii;, Ii"~ . :O:''''l 't'f,:!'1 ~ ',. I ~ ' ?J!) --' "..,.. , :' .?o ~t' . )~, 1n.1) If . j ifll ',' -2 ~ ..,./ ' ;c::21. b'i. : ~ p ~:;:I: ~ I';P;'" lAt ~ 1~/ nu. 1 ~ 1 ;11 ~) r-I ;"1 ;;; ..i'~ ~~, ' : " ( . ~ ',.I,"ti.,:'I~IN ~ll.:,-:,:;;:; ,,< "If':" OJ',;" l 1H . 1 I 211 :!:>J' .rij ""- 0<.1, ., '" ~ :'~ 1-';'1""" , 'J~~il); ~l' \. uHli,,,, . .. ',,', :J'\ "I ,,,,: ~""I \"'" 1. .~:l..:q "~^ ) . ~ ~~, . (to 1 A', 1 Hj4\',n I I' , - :O....,.,.",'..'i..m..".:..";.."il;>.,...,.."1o ~ ", ',' ,1,\oi'''.1 ~TI"~~" ", '2J ~~ ,'n~if ~ 'U I /1 1 " I/I"\' 0 114', 2?_~ r A\-~ ~l~,:t4 f:m-~~ :,:~~~ ~\Iflf~ " ~~ ,1 ~ '~; if~' . ~1fF ':;.nW,.'f, ,i~f ti~ !. ~~ f r.t~ I Ii", . ..~ - ( .- \ ) .4." I 2J7 1, I~\~f.l ~~iMa h~,~:" h{~~qlltg.T: '" ~,i" II. ,jr, LII_t_. ~lllt. -Io:-f, I 1,)' ~ ~'", ,: ." . ',', li~ ~ II I III I l r Il~" i I .-- t J~:~:lr;lf' ;:fl'{~ 1jmlt'~w.4~ !;t~~ l'lh~'I;li;_:l=;~;M~ 1f. :" :P\~I~l! I./~~ "';~f \i:{t!;')':~i;:i-,,;t'7r.f, l"liJ ~ r::'; :l 1\1 11AIl If' ,Z4/, . ...229 . l~ ~ !'~:~\ '~.;.I ~~J. ~1~.f ~ ~r: :L:h\ '~,~ I It ~ .' ~ ,,~ ';',~;:ot! 'I'~ .. -r" \ 1\ po I I ~~9 __'_' ..''<:'11 'fH"'''7ItI' ,'it.'.., '~' -., ( " ~,' I ': I ~~ 11'~0}!f.~Jt" ,1f.Jlj':~;;r-,~~, !\r," ~t: G.~31Ll ~~~ ' I VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS A J ~ NAME: ~(J,,:')-a-\\ /f~ \C.C.~_c.~J\\~~ - I S V :#: .r;J... - /.f-5 PUB Lie H EAR IN G D ATE: A TLA SPA G E :.;,110-:6 SEe :..-Lt_.. _ TWP: J(j S. RGE: /~, E. ~~ CLEARWATEB CITY COMMISSION ~~~~~~ ~.......M-...._~.' 1 ~ bull .J-o--=l2trV _ .." 0101 eo 2~ o ... ~ CG ! ,. 31,04 J .,.' Mi. " ". ,,1: . .I~ . .. : I.~ ;, ,-. ":,~ " , III 'U '.. III ~~ 'fi I., ~-~~ ... I. :s u o o '" '" ~ n: . III 'Pll IlU~D:-I '0 f"f 10: )' \lIlV .Oll011 ,~. 111I .. I~ 1.-: Q llo.. o pllOU HI ~- .. ". .. . .' 'j. :l. ../ 4 ~ I ..' " ~ , ~ ~ .. .... ~. : .. 'j' , 0 lit , " .. ~~ . r, ,. . ;t'1 . , \ , 1 . ~ . - , I ~ , Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum I tern # Heeting Date: L{- . I/:NI'f~ SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 1211 Court St.; Affiliated Agencies/C-21 Condon Meek (Owner/Applicant); Meek (Representative). ("" Q?~q) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve a setback variance of five feet to permit a setback of zero feet on property identified as Hibiscus Gardens, Blk. R, Lots 11-16. for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8). o and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a setback variance of five feet from the property line abutting Court St. to permit the existing freestanding sign to remain in its present location. The subject property is located on the south side of Court St. east of Lincoln Ave. and is in the General Commercial zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the table below. Information ,I Existing Freestanding Court St. 63.8 sq. ft. Oft. 19 ft. Permitted Type of Sign Location/orientation of sign Area Setback Height Yes Yes 64 sq. ft. 5 ft. 20 ft. Reviewed by: Legill Budget Purchasing Risk Hgmt. CIS ACM Other ilIA N/A N/A N/A N~L N/A Origlnatin" Dopt: CENTRAL PERMITTING 7 CO.tl: TotDl CommIssIon ActIon: o Approved o Approved wleonditlons o Denied o Continued to: U 11Ir D'pt: Current Fiscal ~r, t~).' Adverliled: Date: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Requi red AUeend Parll.. ~ Notified o Not Requi red Funding Souru: o Capital I~. o Operating o Other A ltlltlllll_ntl: APPLICATION VARIANCE ~ORKSHEET MAPS o None SubmItted by: City Appropriation Cod,: ~ Printed on recycled pnper SV 92-69 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: This sign complies with the size and height requirements of the sign code. The lone nonconformity is the setback. In order to meet the setback, it would be necessary to reposition the sign to the south where a driveway currently exists. To relocate the sign in the driveway would obstruct and disrupt the vehicular circulation on the property. Also, it would cause an unnecessary hardship on the applicant. It is noteworthy that a second freestanding sign (a billboard) exists on this property in violation of the code. Jhis violation will be handled separately from this variance application. The'surrounding uses are shown in the table below. I L Direction, ~ Existing Land Uses '1 I SURROUNDING LAND USES North South East West Offices Retail-Amusement Reta ii-Signs/Automotive Retail-Strip Stores The granting of this variance will not detract or adversely affect nearby uses that have conforming signs. nor will it adversely impact the overall appearance of the City. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's request meets all of the standards. In particular, the following standards do appear to be fully met: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital" 2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return from the property. I , SV 92-69 Page 3 (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety I order convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decisions by the' Commission: CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETI NG DATE REQUESTED/ACTION SV91-11 1550 S. Highland Jordon Hills 5 ft./ Approved 6/20/91 Ave Professional Center SV 91-22 1874 G-T-B Capt. John's 5 ft./ Approved 1 1/21/91 Hairstyles SV 92-01 2226 Druid Rd. Clearwater 1 .5 ft./ Approved 1/2/92 Dental Assoc. SV 92-21 447 Mandalay Heilman's 5 ft./ Approved 10/15/92 Ave. ' Beachcomber SV 92r24 2000 Drew St. Shell Gas 5 ft./Approved, 11/5/92 Station SV 92-71 351 S. Gulfview Julie's Seafood 5 ft./ Approved 2/9/93 ' Blvd. Sunsets SV 93-06 1621-1627 Gulf Connell's Plaza 5 ft./ Approved 9/28/93 to Bay Blvd. SV 92-31 1880 Drew St. Drew Plaza 5 ft./Approved 9/28/93 SV 92-46 1824 N. Ft. Clearwater Bay 5 ft,/Approved 9/28/93 Harrison Ave. Motel I' " ~ . " .., , " VARIANCE WORKSHEET - CASE NUMBER SV 92-69 , ' I , . STANDARDS FOR VARIANCE APPROVAL I STAfF ANDlNOS I 111 The VlIrlllnce requelted arlllll from a condlllon which II The ulltonco of II drive WilY mllkel It Imprllctlclllto rllloellte unlqulI to the property In quutJon and Is neither ordInarily 01 the 11gn, uniformly IIppllCllble to the %onlng dl.lrlct nor clelltlld by IIn 1I0tlon or eotlonl of the propllrty owner, pledecellor In title. , or the epplloent. Any mllteke mede In thll uecutlon 0' a building permit or work perf aImed Without the benefit 0' II , pllrmlt Ihell not be oonlldllred to, be sltulltlonl which sUppoft I the grllntlng of II vllrlllnce. 121 Thll Pllrtlcular phYllcllI surroundlngl. skepe or To IIllmlnllle or obltruot the IIldltlng driveway for the purpolO topogrllphlclIl condltlonl of the property Involved and the of relooatlng the Ilgn would pOlO II hard. hIp on the property ,Itrlct appllclltlon of the provl,lonl of thIs dllvolopment code owner. would rlllult In an unnllouury hllrd.hlp upon thll eppltcllnt. 131 The Vllrlencell the minimum neQUlDry to overcomll the Thll lion In Itl prlllent location abuts the drlvllwey and unnllcelnlY hllrdlhlp rllferrlld to In prllcedlng recltel "2" for caUl.. the varian 011 to blithe minImum nllcellluy to thll purpole of milking realonllb!e ule of thelllnd. OVtlICOme the hllrd.hlp. \ 141 The requlllt 'or a vllrlence Is not bued prlmllrlly upon thll The granting of the vllrlanoe wlll not CIlUtD a greeter flnencllll dlllllO 0' the applicant to lecure a grllater flnanell1l return for return flam the property, the property. ,161 The orllntln'g of this variance wlll not bll materlelly The eXisting location of the .Ion II not detrlmentlll or InJurloul detrimental or InJurloul to other propllrty or Improvementl In to other propertlel or Improvemen1l In the neighborhood. the neIghborhood In which the propelty Is loceled, 161 The grentlng of the \/Iulance will nOllmplllr en adequllte The Ilgn meet. thl. stendllld In It. ourrent [oclI.tton. lupply of Ught or ventilation to edJacllnt property, detrllct from the appearence of lhe community. lub.tllntllllly Increelll the! congntlon In the publlo ,treetl. Incrllalll the denger of fire, endanoer the public safety In IIny WilY. or lubltentllllly dlmlnl.h or Impelr the vlllue of lurroundlng property. 171 The verlence dulred will not IIdvellely IIffectlhe public Thll Ilgn dou notadvellely affect the hllllllh, lelely. helllth. lafety, order. convenience. or generel welfare of the ccnvenlllnce or wellllre In Itl current lace lion. community, ' ISl The grentlng 01 the vllrlllnce dellred will not vlolele the Olven the herdlhlp In\lolvlld If the I Ill". wllre to bll relocated, general Iplrlt and Intent of thl. devlllopment code. th,grantlng of thll verlenee will not vlolllte the Iplrlt Ilnd , Intent of thll code. j' " , ' \ , i' ~ ~ ~ oj : nYrr~)r~i1iCo'Z..e~= , Bo.~o PltOPErlrY OWNl::nIS) NI\MI: (to. ^1>U1U;~;S: CI' Y or- CI.E1\ItW/\'l EIt SIGN Vl\rlII\NC,r: I\PPIJCI\'1I0N 'SVii q_~r,~ nEPUESENTl\lIVE(S) (if nny) NAME & I\DDReSS: ^ f fjJJ.g .t~JLAg.~ n.~.i ,e s , . I.n c .'. _~_. 1211' Court Street -Cl earwa ter, ~ L ::i4'6To--' TElEPIIONE:_t8...l3) 446 - 5.ll.5.L_ TElEPJ lONE: ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPEnTY: ' 1211 Court Street NAMEOr-8lJSINESS(lFAPPlIG^m.r:): C21 Condon-Meek, Inc'./Condon-Meek. [nc. ZONING OISTI1lCT:_ ~f:::\__,_.._,_. I.AND USE C1J\SSlnCATION:C.TF LAND AnEJ\: "l't) Al..Q.C~ LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PltOI'El1TY: Hi b i s c u s Gar den S B 1 k R Lot s 11. 1 2. 1 3 I 1 4 -L5-+:--1 fi ___ __, . . PArteR NUMIJEn: ---1..5__ I _.__.29_ I -.J..5_ I -3.B.5LL I _Q1 B ' I 01 11 0 {This informotion Is lIv'nilnhln from your tnx rocoill I or t:llllloct Pinollns Co. r'ropllI ty ^pprnlsor's 0 rrico 01 tl62~3207. II moro Ihon onn r;orcclnullIucr. nUneh 0% x 11 itll:h slmoO DEscmOE SUHlIOUNDlNG USES ur: PItOPl:ltrv: North:--O f f i c e_s_ ._.....___~ SOllth: Reta i 1 -Amusement Enst: West: Ret~~~~~mnt;v~ Retail-Strip Store v AItIANCE(S} IlI;OUEST: Variance of 51 in Distance to allow a 0' Setback. .. BEASON r:on nEQUES1'ING V^I1IANGEIS): (Bcrnr tn Slnudmds rur ^JJlllov,lI, (Ioxt Imue) Sign was constructed prior to 1985 ~ ..--.---.. S i g n was con 5 t r1!S:...t~cL tow i t h s t (l n d 1 50...ill.R h \<J i n d s Sign should last 25 yrs minimum (except possible facing) --.- --. --_.- Signs (actually two J~osi tioned tO~Lethe.r.Lidenti fy t W 0 bus i n e..s-s.QS__.:.: .-.C2:L_Re..nL.Eli,ul.e.Ll.o.slIJ:u,n.c.c . C21 fr a n chi se JJQ_G',.~ r:t,~.,~._QJ.lO\'/..:s..9..mP i n_q1ion___.___.__~_ ~C,o.sJ:_o.f-1:emo_vj,ng ....J,n d . r.cco n s.t.r.tJc.LLn Q_,..s..i..g n~,_~_...$L._n.o(). - ...----- wh i ell crea L~?,.~ r..i,n.~!~~i ~l_l\.~I~~.?_~lR'''_''''_'_':___'''''__''__''''_'.''''_d~._r_..___ t., 0 v i n 9 s i 9 n b a c k \'/ n lJ 1 d III 0 C kin com i n g d r i v 0 . t:Ofll mum or~ nr:vEIl!ir: GIl>l: s r^NIJ^JtUS ron ^PJ1JtOV^I.: ^ vnli/IIIl:O sl1nlln()t 1m grnlllod hy Iho City COllllllission unloss the npplicotion lInd evidence prosontod dondy 511111HlII tllll fullowing conclusiolls: (11 1'110 vmlonce rCl)lJor.lcd ndrom; horn n condilion whil:h is lltliqllfl to tho proporty in fllJo!ltion nntl ill noithor urdillmily or unirorlllty IlIJJlliI:/Ihlo to tllo zoning district nul' monted by on rIl:tion or Dctions of tho nropmty oWller. rnodocossor in tillo, or the npplicnnt. ^"y llllstnl<o mnde in tho oxecution of 0 hullding permit or worl< perforlllod witllou I tho hone Iii u r II perlllil shnllnut ho considorod to be situntiuns which Sllr)port lho granting of 0 vnriollco, t21 Tho I)niticulor 1)lIysicnl SIIJJOlIJuli.1U::. shoJlo or tupoyrnphicnl conditions of tho property involved and tho strict ollplicotlon of the provisions or lhis devolupllllHlt codo would rosult in nn Ut1110cossnry hordship urlon tho npplicnnt. IJ) Tho vnrinnco Is tho llIinilllullllloeossnry to overcomo tho Utmocossory hordshiJl rolorrod'to in precoding rocitol "2~' for tho purposo 01 moiling rensonnblo uso of tho loud. 141 The requo5t for n vminnce is nol hosed primnrily upon tho desire or the npplicont to Sllcure n gronter finoncial rotUl n from tho propClly. WI Tho granting or tll(l vntlnnc:o will not lJo IlIntoriDlly tlotrimontnl or il1jlJlloU9 to othor proporty or hlllJ1'ovolllonla in the l1eiyhlJOrhood in which tho property is 10cotlld, (6) Tho gronting uf the Villilllll~1l will J10t itnpnir un ndll({llnto 5Ul'Illy or light or ventilotion to ndjneent property, dotrnct frolll tho IlllllOOlnnCfl ur Iho COl1l1llUllily, !luhstnl1tinlly illcrenso tllo congostiol1 in the public strools. illcrcnso tho donger uf rim, Iltlllllllgm the puhlic sofoty in ony wny, or sllhstnnlinlly diminish or impair tho vnlue or surrounding Inopcr ty. c' " 171 Tho vnrinnco desired wi,lInol mlvorsoly nUoet tho Iwblic hOlllth. sorety, order convenienco. or gonornl welforo of tho cOllll1lunity. 181 Tho' gronting 0 I, tho voriOI1CO t1esilod will 110 t violoto tho gone~ol spirit ond int'on t of this dovelopmont codo. SIGNJ\TUnE OF pnOPEnTV OWNEn (On IlEPnESENTJ\TIVEI,~_L~_ Subscribod nnd sworn to lor nf lillllmll hMorn mo this 27 t hlny 0 r ~ t e m b e r ,^.O, 19...9...3. hy ..;j~ ~,J ~,M &ms.n~ ~!::,~eiu..i1~;'-'.--r -"v...,... -~rTiiI ,-,,It 1Vinh. ",.~ Ur,,' 114-U It" JIIIllI ,,"',.....,t 110'''/11." tr .JIJ'''':If'' f'I . who is IJCrsonolly Imown to mo and/or hos plolllll:ud ,______. ""I'" "f iII~"(i(j""tio,,J os idontilicnt;on. " ST^:rE Or: FLORl~A, COUNTY Or: _~_I,j t. l~(....A .J: ~.. ...,,\. ' ~~ ' ., . '~-~-'---4 ___ Notnry Pllhli(:, COllll11is!iioll No._ < . I--a.,("""", '6 L-fi=- ,<".1 J~8i,oJ,.;b- (NnlllU ur Nolmy typod. printod or slompodl " , , , , i/ ,,' , , ~ .:,.j I ': p.' .) . , , " ! , ,l. , , , " L . ': ~ , " , , u' , , . I" . ~ . .:.t . ~ ~ ' ... ,i- c' , ,I... '\' ..' , "J ,;,,1 ~ ...... ;" , I ~~~r,..~.~. . , '0;.':' " . , ' "i " " " " ; .". " ~ ". .." .':!.c " ':<,:F~~ "t'. . ~. , , 'I " , , , ' i, :-t<', , .~. , . ~. I 1,\ . .. . " '. '1 : /j I \,' ~: . I " ~':: 'I: ',; v' ~' ' 'ii, ',' ' :iY'/,t,,/:" " " :' " : ' < " : , ;. ,I ;,,~;:~~~!):;~">'~~:.,o,',' ,;:,~.:. I , _ :' " J . I' ' , ' 1\ {', '. " I .~ . :.: ~ l' !", . " . ~ ,~ , " ~. : , ' , . ~ I, , ; .", 'c ,.: , . , ,,' " , , ' ',' 1.' ," . ~ . t " ' .. " I . , , " (' )1, < .. ,<, " 1 " \', ~ I .i,: '\'.' ' " ".< .., ;,'; , ( ,"i". ;, ,~. ' ,', ,"! 0,1.,. ',. I ~ . . ! ~.' ' ~ ~ . '(b." ',' /;:. . l~ ~ , ''; ".' ~ ' . ..k," ";",;" ,I , , , f, t. ". 1:">.1; " . ~ l ~ ~ j- , J i.. ',' t ",>" .i ; , , . ~: . ~ < \ , . '. ~, . ,., ~ ' " .~ . , .~ ~ 1 J -. I , , / ~-t " " f- I ~ I r~~ . " , , , ~ ,,; r('~ ! ~ ~ ~; ,~' ;;:,:,:' '; i ~ .' f :: . . ~ (": \. ,'.' . \ 1. i . f ~ ~:J~' ".", .: .. ~ "' r.:' ,",' t,: , ' ,,' ' . t , . i.~;:i ..!.' . . / :p.. i: I. / ~ ~, . ' i, .. ':"' ,'I'f' ~:l"~~~~:<~":' ~, , :r; .. >'~ .,;. ;r.{':-:'" ,~ '>;" \ :'.', ~". ., : ' . ~ ~ " , " >',. " :t'. " \, .' ,I', ',' :.c..'~ {. C6iA1(}r.u4/-~' , . , . 1,4IC.~ fljv}~ &~ ' " " " t c ~.( ,'c ,c , " , .' , , ~ ,.,' ','>. , , "~ ' '\ J i: ':.: t "\ ,', ,:" \ I, ','! " , , ~ ' ,J .... C- - ,', ,,",' . ;.~ 'I . -: .. ~. I ,1 ' ~. '. ~ " ~ "., r I ~'. " ',1;' j . ..Jf',,' " ~ I . . ,- r' . ~ .~' '~,,:.g it III ~ ;>> " "c ,.. ....' , J.,~ . ' c"' ," ,I u ,1 ) ~ .:, 'I ~ I .m .~. I : c ~' . I " , ~ )c, " \' . , ~ ~ ," .' I; 1. )' : " :~, " ~, . . ~ ~ " .,< ( ~ I < " ,~ \1. 't ' ~ ," " ) ,I,y I ... J ,~ ,j " ' " '/r .t< . ~ "~I ~ "', .l ~ ., ., . ! ~ " ~ 1".1;' r" "t ".' y " ..',' '-I.J' / t' ~ . c ~ ' , ~ ; . ' . , , I, ., 1,.- I' , '. " .. " . . ,~, ;: ~ , '! ,: " " " i " " ,,' , " ':l . ' .', " " ,.1~/:1/9 'l.. :,r0\'f).. f/" '\ I " /l ~:I:'l -X ~t...~/ ,! (J ' ~- . ~ ~ , " , " ~ . " " I, J.'\ " ," , " -" . 'I " I' . c : ~.' I c.l . I : '1 +>\' ',< " , " ""," . , . , ,. "J " ' " '0 ') ': -" ~' " , ' , , f' '<\ " ~ I " I' " , ' '.: .\ ~ /" i ~ . , , ' ., ~. '\ ," " , ,i " j' ;,/ " :i i ", <I" , ' , " " ,I ". II " , i . . " ," ,1 ) , " " I,.:c~' \. ) " .. ~ ' ; r ,~ ," ~ , .t. I': r ~.' ", ,. '.' , ' ;, ,) '\ , .,' " " : ~ .: \ : c "I- '" " 'e j;'.' .. 1. ' " . ~ i. I ~ I: , , c..t ,> , , ',c ., \q ", " ~ ." I ~ [. " " ..f , . ;.' :' ,f " j y~ ~ -..... .".~...- " " " ):. ,./ .1 . ~M^I_L ~AN61_~ 'TO, , fT oJeD ,"EE'" 1t..EN\ , , \[V' \, \ \ - ,{\ ' " I, ,\' " c ......, t, '1to, '! . !;~ , " , I f. '.' , , . . . j ~ , , " '" ;: I " I " ,', " i i t. I' ", " . iI, ", ~; ).'.... " ,\ " / . , " ,1ft' , " " , " >"1 \, , I , " .' '" I . ~ . , I c. j . " '" ,l, " , 'f'\ \ ., .', " <' ''I , , c, ,0 , ' .,,' " '. II , c' " . t, , ' "I >. , ,j j't , , " I ~ . '~ . ~ ".!:: '. . 1,r'::~'~~~('J'~ " /. "';.~ . ~, ': '" ": . . ;. '~l. ". f ,;. ,', ~. .. . ~ ~. t. . )...0'15< Illi'';1.,I~, 1'-/, ,.;~, I~ I-/-' "i; sc ~'~'" C~,." ~I/ I) ;t~IU ~ ~ . t I IjI.GCt,oI,' y'~ , ,l. J t ' , " " . (' ~ uA1"" , , <;'"'7'1 ; , - I . I \ \'. 7 ,. ." ~'---;-'Il-'- '--.T..-~:~.._r~~'-~'-~-'I .- '_ ,I I . )'" ;';'~"l. ,~ " '~, : ~. ' i. ;' -'--~~. L~J ! . \. . " I -_....__....~ , ) , I I I, I ,1 1 I " ), '< I, . "-"'- , 'l ........... ( (C . i, : ~ ]. .1 ,I, I --- ".1 I, " I , , ,'" ! , , ..' f ..I " /. ,0- I I I ~ , , ,I I , , I I : ' " '. .. , I 16 1 IJ 5 . I, ] 4, f, ' 13 I, '12 ! ill ,. j I I I , I ' " ; I , I , , ' I, j' , 1 ,! , , I , , ", I '........ " '! L j ,. I' , I ,. " . " 1____ .... , I ~,c . , , , ' " ,Jo diU 1-1, lV, \.::'\:1,", 'e; 1(, .. (I~ ,}Y\\ \,\tV \~ . \,'~ . ,-{ \ V )d./ .Qr s, Go; tV 1{r=-16:ff'T } ' 3 TCJ ,.9CJ 1"1 rJ ...v\ .I <1' ,(cJ IO'P i. ",C, " '/VoIJTrt '. " / II =- ~C ' " " t. ' " , , , I , I 1 " '~ ' " Ll1?, l"" -, I ;,.: 1 B i . , '" I '. ., ~ 0. ) -. - ':" >' p / S P " . ":~ ~~~~~,:l - ~~:~ . ~.'~!~LdJ u ~~~.~ -_,~__.I ,~I t; C;:;"I'f"j ~ _,~~ ~, (~;) 22~),,: ~ FRANKUN R M 16 smEET " , ~ ~ I ' ' ~ . \, 'A,'p\ y' Vv C A /// /~~r . .- :~~,'-'--=-i' 300 ~ l;g~ ~~~. ~' E J~ ' ....., \4 S " ..,', ." / /I~ 5 / OJ, ~ Z - _ ~ - - I -h~ I I I I ~,'" I r" '1-,.L.'< ".-' c.\5-,~ '\ 22/" W '" 5 ~ 01 '-;-.' 2 I r ! ')<tAl 'I" 'I' I.; ""f '.., .'<..:...., / r.:.\~ ,"~ I r <J> 6 30.2 0( 30~ 0 '11" t 9 -I 7 6 5 4j j; 2:Pa: If' /", q.......... / .' ~~<e 300 ~ ~7 I!iO 1~:'''' -- -- "~ii~ ' II'J l~, I '. ' .. ~ I I' t d~5 ~j , -1' >". V <:t;.'J 3 ,p \ / U '01 B "'1> ~\.r,o~ 22 21 " ... 'I I ~ I:, ~ ~ ~ "t:, .~, I '. "'4 ~ ~:~ ~i 111"" 3/' 4' /,( "';.j'~---.... 2)<'0' '5 M3 ..,l'j - - 0';<.., . -'_-,.~J I'" '-- - - - 1- 1 1 j - '" , ' '.... . -- . .:;:, 2':>- 20 "....7 .;; L ,~-I~ ~... .,,_':.C' - "., ......:ti::l.,~ 1J '.I(t.! -- '<:!1 4' 305 9 1 .) '~"'" SmEET vII, ~218',1O,!4 ',"', S r ,n C,..l, - \1.\9 '- -------'K\- ~q?- 25;' " 19 'r~1 'I"" 1;'11'" l.;,t:ll<)rb.~\~~\'Il.~I\~g-'n"" Ii '\1~ ~ 'f'C' 5. 'U.108 .1,.0,11,10 24' _' 1......a......."..1l' ; ~~ ::;~ :~:;!~, ~.J~'~;~ r Cl q":!"~ 0 -G ~Q ,~'~-; "-~.-'Jtl-l 7 ~-, ~I;~ ~-- 13 \4 '15~- ~6 17 .r'd' /. ,1:(:', 11: 1B[191ilJ fl.~h;:,:23\24i2~F :;: '......, I) .......... ~ m g J,:; ~i~ ,/ ~...f.,// 16 I ~! ,,'1, I i ~tj " S-1,v "'~. _ "--__'----., 121 12 ~ ~. ~ ~l>I. ':- ~ Ih I IlJ ~ I l' I, . ,:\' I ! ~!2, \ Vl Vl 4tl5......, ,..", ROSA DR' 0 L ;,------ _I~ ...- ~ :r:l;;J 9 ' B' l G/;, 5 41 J L 21 ,fV7.,i., -"'_ -,- '- - '-'. '_ ~ "'SANTA i--- ROSA .,;.... ~ 'fl., : 11 r.(U:G1i~J Ij)P(SF :', \ ; -!" j~~. 'I ._~ Vl ~;;'-l'-'-~'~ ~~~.~~ ~!~I~~ ... ~, 41 '''''<:I,... i",,)ll '(11<l)~'~ ..ii,' ,/ I I - -- -- - ,\. 43 .."'- /, l'g~i~~ ~,_~ ,J.;~F.JH;.'L .,I,',~: ,,,)~ 8 7_ fi 5 ~4 j 2 1 5 4 J 2 1 ~5 r.4~1 i SffiEET', r. _ .,- ..':'~- .," ,,,:t; - I':' . ""..1 - ',- - -,..- ,- l-~OJ ' G ~ET'-ij~t-':~",~r..l,l.. I';,:ll~ I "L:>o~, ~." ~\'b<>Irt+r'~~ .j, M~llo. " ..' '''' n"... I '~Miu~ .~I.u ~:n!>o B ~~i..7;Rl P:l';~~i)3 !ll:211;~r:t '~l.-~ 0 rl ~ 4~1 ~ ~. ~ : It:.' I'.!? I ' 5' I 1_.. .3'1 lB - - 1n - - rP21 ' ,(. -.,' D 0 Z "IN Oil H28-f;11 F~ 51,.1')-5111 \ COURT I :- .~:'~r.1~'~~ ~::: ;:~o:,:::f~1\ CR].~o~r\ ~f~~;_~66 ,.' : '~'\~-3 '-7]'!rIH'~ L. - - ~~o':;~- - ~~~ ~ t: tJ.11::i 1-:3 t\i ., ; J J JJ~ rr- 7 , 11 1 1 .. - .r' 1 601, I'HOnmmlW.:.... J)'j ~ j J 2 - ~ M ~ I 1rt.rt:t4 ~~ ~ Ei i 4 j ~ f ). ffi 4 ;~ I 9 /l 76 !i 4 JI211 p.,:;! clJlTm . ~103 :I 4 J 3- 0 9 ~ll~ 1 U r.: v,I.C I f':; L JO~~ -. ':i]IJ" r--~ [ - - 512 ~ 8 ~ D ,-Q ,'-I ~ I "'.----.'- '211 '28 27 26 2524 22 5/4 .. B 14 I::' 217 III 19 20 21 31/03 ~I~~ L ~ ~~~jiJ1g.. 11).... <>.. ~-;SiG ? ~ 8 C)... 1 ~ ~ I,." :g.. ~_~_ 1ll ::.~_!; 31/01 ~ sy13j~,~ ~ ~ ~~ _~, J ~P7Z't ~'-_ ~ ~ ~ ~ ,I ~ "... 2 0 %: rJ a f oems / 0 LSTAEET Pil U -- .. ,-, - , .. l~ -".a1> O'j ~ to. '" ~..,.., to. '" - r:; ~ ~ j ~-'-iib- ::1 .Mr""'~~ ,.~~;~~~~~~~~~.~~~'~! IT 2 'A~5_ 164 B 5 6 B. 528 I ~ :-,-~~E 10 ~ 6 . .::,Q.~ o~ ~ 3 ') 1 211 bS!l ~~\)~ 22 II ft: 6j2" -( 6,~ 'H~ - T - 1- ' oif #..~bc"'..... u g " ,\::/ -oVJ.r;!lFc ~ 7 I - "'jSO' 15 16 17 ~C .....o<l ~ ;Z; t&; C' 9 10 11 ,12 1'3 14 rj;": - .. : ~\I 'L::';;~ V' ~~ ~ ~ ~;:] 0 ' ~ ~ ~ ~fl ~ ~ ~ ~ I~ ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~t~ C G ~ p".__U 'G-, - -- '1URNER ~ ... ,-( STAEE. T ill~~~~\ . '" _ ... 'n ~ '" .., ~ '" ~ "'..- '" .., r- ~. b I "'("'/'l"r.,j'.(;;"\,!~ ~ ~i~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~M s n~..-.: ii: J 4:.;~ . !-H~ ~~ ~-;-i~ ~~~ g H ~ ~ ii ~~ ~ ~.; ~i' i 19 18 17 l6 15 14 \3 12 11 n 10-- ,0.1 10 a , [:1'/1\ 4 J i 604 70 ,05 6 -4 J 2 I;'T!, '< 2 J . ~ G 7 6 9 '~~, ~: .:~_'" 42/01,"""" '~09 '~i 10 _ 11,_ ~D ,.' ': .::<':.' ~ .. ""'6~i!1-'~~'~ ~t 3' Yi ~ " 16'::6~ 1 -4*V ;"''''' ~ ~ ~ ~ ' . :.- < 'I~',' ::,'~I:\;,"~~ir!l\ .~., ..J__, VArr.',^~ fi'S 4?/02 -v: ~_'9__L-' " . ;-r'IHO :~Ir '<:1 ORJ~~.I-J:i9 "l~~~,~~!I~~1~~'6.~ -,-~:;'~'~;--ll, B ~~( _----~':I R M' 20 ~ 'i.~2~'~'. ~ UI: ~.; VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS NAME: ,~\~~(\ ffiQ..Q..l~{) Ir ~,\ to<,t\Of\- N\Cl'_Y"" $\C /(CX'f-\0(\,N\~e...t\ \(\~ , I 1 SV #qd--Iu~1 PUB Lie HEARING DATE: ATLAS PAGE:J!(c.b SEe: v:':;' TWP: :)q S. RGE: \!,:) E. :~ ~~~~.,~.,~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION :~~~~~~~ ~~ ~: ,"l I o J(j ~J t!wPUJ:'1 /)> ~h Is .. I I I I . 't;! ~ -' m >, III m , " ~ , .... -' :j 1..' " 1'1 'tl n: 't.t ~ -' .. :> .. .... u -- ,o\Oc '11I ~ 'c , Ie. ~ ~ ", , ' ", ,; , , " ,', i! - " , \ "~~ ' . ~ I. \ . , , " " I' ~ " " I ,\ , J I' I. ~;\' . ~ , >. ,c :~:) ~{," \' , ,I " " . I " " I,' ~/ , ' . '" " , . ' c' J l'> " }..C .{.'. 'i.:' o. + . .' , ~ . ",-: ~: ,t ':, ~, ) ... +, . I,' ,I J LT. "'~f ~ .,".~' ~{:.~ ' ,~:'. ~.~./,1~1:!!:~~~$.ff\.~-~' c '/}. i :'~ ,'. J,'. , , " " rl'" or .;, 'I, '~' ';'c i. .' +'.. ~ .. " '; 1, {~, I . ~. .' I' . ,', . ".'" " , , I, , ,': " , T , . ~ " " . +~,{ , ,I , , i < ~ : ,. "I ; ~ ;: ~ : I " ,. ,J' ,'r " I ~ . t ", \ ' ,\ J.~. _ ~ . '. " " , \~ t. . ~ Ij.", :. . ., . , r.. " ~~ . " ,J 'I [1: ..; " , , ,I, '" . }. , .:: ,,' . ~ ~. 1.. ~ ~ J ',' " 1 R. 'j ( ( '1 ~ ~ ,~ ~ ,', ,f. :1-' . L .i, . ..; ~.'~'. " , i '. J . ~ ~' ,,' 'p' . \, '.4, .' L: ,I' , " , el'. ,~ ' ,; " , , , c " . ~. ~ I ,.r.' '" " ~. I . >. , \, c\ ;, . '(~ ,.' " ~ ~ .' ~ " :', '"...c " ," \ ..'' , ~ ~' ~ \ ~.," ",7,\', -t; I' . ':.. ' '~. ;".':.,." .!" ~::;:::.: .' , " :,01 , ' <, I, " ~ , . " , AGENDA , i " \ , . '. ~ ~ " "J" '. ::1.' ,,' . <~, " 'f .J I ,; ~ ,) ~ '. .}". ,,' :, ,', " ~. . I, , ' 'I' ,-, ' ,,' ~ ~.~ ',f:' t.. ~.. ; ~" r.> /~~ I' i~" i,;~" '" :;.:,:;'i. ?:\" , ' t", 1 " , ,', " " , " ',' ,", " I '. ~.<.~ <' ...../. , 'J . ' 'J I, ,j. : , .,' DATE ,J .~.'t.. 94 , ' , i ~ 1 " ,,' - 'I >, +l ,I ~ , ,; , , " ...t". . :' " . , ~ I, " ,; l.., . . ITEM #~ ," " .' " ',' ., .' ,', J, :~ .~ ,,' " , ' , , , " " , " " : ./ 1 , " .~ ~:: . , , " c/ :1. . ~ ( . .' I, . ~, . r ,', , ,I . ' , ) ," ,,\ ,I .' , , '" , " " .. '" , " .I. " ..I .:.i, '. , '; ,', ,1 , " , , , .' " t " " ! . .' " "c ,l . t J~. ... : ~ '" '; " I' " , : " " c' >, ' '. , , , .. 1 " , ' 'l' - i ~c::.\I O?7Q} Clcmwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item # Maetlng OMe: 5. IId.il?~ SUBJECT: Variance to the' Sign Regulations; 600, 610 and 620 Lakeview Rd.; Lakeview Oaks Condo (Owner/Applicant); J. Warren Hughes (Representative). RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve an area variance of 11.6 square feet to permit an area of 75.6 square feet on property identified as Sec. 21-29.15, Lakeview Oaks Condo, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8), subject to the condition the landscaping in front of the sign be continuously maintained. o and that the appropriate officials be outhorlzed to execute soma. BACKGROUND: ,The applicant is requesting an area variance of 11.6 square feet from the 64 square foot maximum to permit the continuation of a freestanding sign .with an overall area of 75.6 square feet. The subject property is located on the north side of Lakeview Rd. east of S. Ft. Harrison and is in the Limited Industrial zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the table below. Information J Existing Permitted Type of Sign location/orientation of sign Area Setbacl( Height Freestanding lakeview Rd. 75.6 sq. ft. 5 ft. 11.5 ft: Yes Yes 64 sq. ft. 5 ft. 20 ft. RavlDWDd Ily: Lagal Budget Purchasing Risk M9!\\t. CIS ACH Other Totol Commlulon Acrlon: o Approvl:d o Approvad w/conditions o Ol:nicd o Cont Inved to: ilIA ilIA ilIA ilIA !(~ ilIA Orlg1natfng Dopt: CENTRAL PERMITTING C-,~ CDIIS: Unr Dopl: Current FlscDI Yr. {. . ,1, AdVllrllnd: Dote: Paper: TAHPA TRIBUNE [J Not Required AII.clod Pall!QI ~ Notified [J Not Required Fundlnll SDurcD: ' [J Copi tal Imp. [J OperDt Ins o Other AUQthl1l1111\l: 'APPLICATION VARIANCE \/ORKSHEET MAPS o None Aj1lllajuialian Calla: ~ Printed on recycled pnpcr " SV 92-79 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: This sign complies with height and setback requirements of the sign code. Howover, tho sign face, as defined by code, does not conform to the size limitation. Sign face is dofined as lithe part of the sign that is or can be used to identify, display, advertise, communicate information, or for visual representation which attracts or intends to attract the attention of tho public for any purpose." [Emphasis added.} In this particular case, applying the definition to the existing sign, the sign face is 8.4 feet vertically and 9 feet horizontally. However, not all of the sign face is currently being used for advertising purposes, nor would it be particularly desirable to use all of the face for advertising. This is because the lower portion of the sign face is in close proximity to the ground and the existing landscaping obstructs the visibility of this portion of the sign from the Lakeview Rd. right of way. Further, this being the case, it would cause an unnecessary hardship on the property owner to require that the sign be altered to conform to . code. The surrounding uses are shown in the table below. Direction ~ Existing Land Uses I J SURROUNDING LAND USES North South East West Office Office o ffice/Warehouse Office The granting of this variance will not detract or adversely affect nearby uses that have conforming signs, nor will it adversely impact the overall appearance of the City. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. ' Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's request meets all of the standards. In particular, the following standards do appear to be fully met: (1 ) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or action,s of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The pmticular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnocessary hardship upon the applicant. The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in precoding recital "2" for tho purposo of making reasonable use of the land. (3) SV 92-79 Page 3 (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure u greater financial return from the property. . (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located'. (6) The granting of the variance' will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase . the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of,the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ ACTION DATE SV 91-02 25191 U.S. Dimmitt Cadillac 12.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 3/21/91 19 129.3 s . ft./Denied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. Village at 124 sq. ft. add'l to allow' 1/2/92 19 Countr side 280 s . ft./Denied SV 92-03 '2301 Sunset Great Western 42.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 1/16/92 Point Rd. Bank 66.3 s . ft./Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S. Public Storage 32 sq. ft. add'l to allow 3/25/93 19 144 s . ft./Denied SV 92-05 20162 U.S. Suncoast Inn 38 sq. ft. add'l to allow 5/7/92 19 150 s . ft./A roved SV 93.06 1621-1627 Connell's Plaza 144 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 Gulf to Bay 208 sq. ft./Denied Blvd.' SV 92-40 1528 Orthopaedic 32.4 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 Lakeview Rd. Surgery Center of 56.4 sq. ft./Approved Clearwater SV 92-41 '26508 U.S. Ramada Inn 55 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 19 105 s . ft./ A roved SV 92-46 1824 N. Ft. Cloarwater Bay 30 sq. ft. add'l to allow 80 9/28/93 Harrison Motel sq, ft./Approved , ." ; . I' ;. '" VARIANCE WORKSHEET - CASE NUMBER SV 92-79 I STANDARDs FOR VARIANCE APfIftOVAL I ST~ ANDlNOS I 111 The yerlance requlllted IIrlle. from e condItion which I. The lower portion of the .Ign face I, loclltlld In ctoUl unlqulI to the property In qUlIItlon end I. neither ordlnllrllv or prolllmlly to the ground end 1. ob.ttuoted from view from the unlfolmly eppllcllb\e to the tonIng dl.trlct nor crellted by en Lekevlew Rd. right of WilY by lend.ceplng. 1I0tlon or 1I0tlon. of thll property owner. predeceuor In title, ' , or the IIppllcent. Any mlltllkelllllde In theuecutlon of II building permit or work performed wllhout the benefit of II pllrmll .hell not be con.ldered to lie .ltuatlon. which .upport the Illllntlng 01 II Yllllance. 121 The plmlouler phy.lcel .urroundlng.. .hepe or To requIre removal of II portion of the .Ign fece whIch I. topogrllphlcet condition. I)f the property Involvlld IInd the elb.tructed helm view would cllu.e IIn unneceullry hard.hlp .trlct IIppllcetlon of the provl.lon. of thl. dllvelopment code eln the owner of the property. would 'llIult In an unnlllleuary hard.hlp upon the IIppllcllnt. 131 Thll vllrlllnc. I. the mInimum neclllury to overcome the The variance I. the mlnlmlmum to overoome the herd.hlp unneceullry hard.hlp re1erred to In preceding recltlll :'2~ for Identllled In 112 IIbove, the purpolII of meklng relllonebte u.e of the lend. , 141 The r.que.t for II vllrlllnoe I. not billed primarily upon the The grllntlno 01 the verlllnoe will not CIlUIII II gruter flnenclal dllllle of the IIppllcllnt to IIIcurll II grlllltllr financial return for return from the property. the prop.ny. 161 The grentlng of thl. V11ll11nce witt not be metlllllllly Thll ul.tlng sign Is not dll\llmllnta\ or \rllurloul to other detrJme!ltel or Injurious to other property or Improvement. In plopertle. or Improvement. In the neIghborhood: the neighborhood In which the property I. !oclI.ed, '81 The grentlng of \he vllrlance will not Impair IIn adequnte The nl.tlng .Ian IlItl.flea thl, condition. .upply of light or ventlletlon to adjacent plopcuty. det!act horn the eppearence of the commu~lty, ,ub.tantlelly Increa,e the conge.tlon In the publlo .treet., Incrllue the denger of fire, eudenger the public IlIfety In eny w~y. or .ub.tantlally dlmlnl.h or Imp"lr the value of ,urroundlng propeny. 17J The varlanca dllll,ed will not IIdvllrlllly effllllt the public The .Ign doe. not adverllllY IIUacl the health, .afety, helllth. IlIfllty, order. convenience, or general welfarD of the convenience or welfare 81 It currentty e"I.~.. community. ,al The grentlng of the variance dulllid will no. violate the Olven the unnecll.llIry herd.hlp Involved If the .I,;!" Wele genllrel .plrlt end Intent of thl. development code, required to be altered. the granting of the variance will not vlolete thll .plrh and Intent of th'e code. >, " I, ,. , . ^' .' . .----........-.-.--.--...-.. ..... 0 ..... lO 0"1 CD lJ1 t\. 1.." CD ' o-l C\J , (\J C\J , 0'1 t\. M 0 C\J M t\. ..-l Q" 1Il I'\. ..-l LIl LIl , I-r . . . . . . . . . . . C\J ..-l V ..-l lJ1 en lJ1 M CO (\J .-I CO ..-l ..-l , :Z:' I'\. en , M trI C\J 0 0 0 0 l'\J CD .......-i I'\. ..... X~ lC .-l ..... I'\. LIl CD LD l.O C\J o::r lJ'I LIllll l'\J OJ ct@i - . - . - - . . . . . lD ..... M M ..-l ..... C\l ..... (\J (\J .-I NC\J V a:t NN , , W W to ~g:: a:. 0.. 1-: x ~ :x: x x x x x x x X X...J , z: :z: :z: :z: :z: :z: :z: :z: z :z: :Z:I- , t.oW 0 cto' ?- M -10 ~ 3 3: 3: 3: 3: 3: :3: 5 3: 3: en -IU: U U LJ U U U U U U u en , .... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a a 0 0 0 0 Q: 1-' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a: :z:: 0 v lD I'\. I'\. N t\. N lJ1 N M LIl \JJ ::I :;)' . . - . . . - . . . . > -10 o::r .-l co I'\. I'\. V' LD ..... t\. I'\. C to a: EO I'\. V M I'\. lD C\J N t\. 01 0 I'\. Ol :>0:: .-l ... - ..... en 0 . . . , , , wen: w 3~: ::I a:-J; x x ~ x x x x x x x x xxx :z: ::)(.,)0 Z Z z :z: :z:. :z: :z: :z: :z: z :x::z:w w oui :> w ...Jg: N .-I o-l (\J N N 0: WO 0 CU: , ::z: 1: .' ,0 ..... (\J M Q' \n U3 I'\. CD 0'1 0 a:. wO M rr'l ('0') M M M M' M M M q ...-1 t- :Z:' I'\. (\. I'\. I'\. I'\. I'\. I'\. I'\. t\. I'\. (\. ..-i (J) >-l: 1.O La 1.O 1.O l.O to to l.O LO lD W W 0 l,/j La 1.O 1.0 to to ' l,/j l.O 1.0 U) U) 0 ::l 0 -1 0 , a:. , III :::> . N I.L. :>-: 0 0 W 1-' f- I- 0:: 1 l- X a: u..r. l1.. :::J I- a.., v .-I 0 CJ C/l 0' N 0 0 CJ 0 0 0 . 01 0 0, 0 0 U W 0:: 0 Cl 0 c::l 0 C c::l(\. ON 0 0 0 Cl a..: z z :z: x ::z: :z:...... z :z: :z: :z: :z: ..J , (!) 0 0 0 0 0 0 O't- 0 0 0 0 a: u..' 0- U U U U U UW U>-l U U U U 0 W 0 :z: :z: 0 N 0: . tI) CIl 00 (f} C/l en (f}::I (J) , en U'I (J) . :z:: :>.<:: :>.<:: ~ :>.<:: :>.<:: :>'<::0 :>.<:: ~ ~ :>.<:: :.L root 0' III 0: a:. ,0: a: a::z: a:1.L a: a: 0: ~ U1 0 0 0 0 0 Oa: 00 0 0 0 0 't-' 0 0..: 3:<1: 3:et:l 3:U 3: a: 3:CC 3:UO 3:'t- 3:W 3a: 3:m :l:LJ -I :t .-.: ~ 4J 1 WI. WI WI WI WI I WI.L. WI WI WI WI 0 0:, o:l .......... ~.-l ..... .-I .....N HN HNN Ho::r H(\J .....M HM .....M .. U' ::> :> ~ => => => ::I. => => ::I :::> I-- ([ en: I- I...U- WI- WI- WI- WI- WI-I- wen WI- WI- WI- ' WI- en I: ~ a: ~H ~H :>,<::H ~..... ~H :>'<::HH :..<: ~H :"<:H :>'<::H llL..... <II: ...J a::z: <I::Z: a::z: a::z: a::z: a:.:z::z: a: 3: a::z: a::z: a:Z <r::z: <r: 0 . 0- -1::1 -I=> ...J::> ..J::I ..J::I -1::>::> ..JCIl -1::1 ..J:::J -I::> -I;::l I.. , Z , X ...J ... , lO U3 l!l to .-I ..... ... .... .... .-I .... a: (f): M M M Ul to OJ CD OJ co co CD I- -I <II: 00' M M M N N (\J C\J C\J C\J N C\J W W M M M N 0 0 Cl 0 0 0 0 I- W ;C oc: I I I I r I I I I I I 0: I-- 0 O. to 1.0 LD m I'\. I'\. "- I'\. (\. I'\. I'\. ...J 0 :z: c: ..-l ..... ..... C'l ..-l o-l ..... o-l ..... .... .-I u.. Q 0:: to 1.0 LD . lD I.D LD 1.0 to W lD lD root H :z:: 0 Q" <;1' Q' 1-11-<;1" o;;r V Q' 00 q <;T <;1' <;!' II; d c M M M UM M M M ~ M M M M '0, 0.. > :Z:' :z: . . Z Z I-- 0:: (;) 0:0 0:0 0:::0 O:W W 0 << , t.J O:..J 0:::-1 a:-I -1t.o ..J ..J -I E: ..J U ...J U ...J U ...J w W U) I.L. CIl u.. t3~1.L 00 (J) I.L. U l.r.. in l.L.. ~ u..' Z l.r.. :z: u.. :z: 4- do "- 4- 0 ;E' U'I W3 W3: ZH ~ :z:. :>.<:: U'I H. H H <II: 0:: ~ E:W . E:W . ;EW. O:...J <r:..... . H.-t . a:...... . Wo4 _ ..... . ..... . ..... . r-f 0 lI. :z:: a: 0: .... 0:: a:HO: o:-a:: . aJl.L.. OCOa:: ma: ClCDa: ::!COo: otnc: oroo: oroa:: , 0 ~:::>41 -':::>W -,=>W :z:a: N4I ONW NW :Z:C\JW UI\lW WNW WNW 0 0 ... . ' WI- WI- W~ I-:::l. 3: ~ U I- 3: I- ..... I- r-I ~ H I- H ~ 0 0 en: ~ . llL a: .:>.<:: a:. .:>.<:: 0: HI-:Z: WXa:. HXa: WXa: Xo: ooxer OOXa: U'lXa: lJ1 Q >- :z:: a::' W >-0:3: >0:3: :>-0:3: EC/lH H03: (/)03: .....03: ~03: W03: W03: W03 . 0 W - W-IO: W...JOC W-1Cl: U'J Q =>0::10:: W~o: ::I~O: Uet:lOC O:aJO: a::a:la: o:m~ 1.0 "- I- 00 :Z;' :::> a: a: 0: <r: 0: <r: Clo::rW W <r: 0: <r: W 0: W <r: <r: a: 01 I-- 3.: l.JJ 3:0W 3:0W 3.0W -1U1Z :.LOW ow :>.<::041 O:OW' OOOW U'lOW enOl.JJ ID root :z: lI. 0: ~ Oo-l-1 0.....-1 O.......J OM:::> <r: -1 00 ..J <r: -1 H -I -I ..J ...J .. u , a: _.H.O U ..JU) U ..J\DU t!l.....O ..In.U :::lO-U -1o..U Cn.U ::lO-U ::lo..U ::Io.W ,.., ::I u 0: , -1 , 00;]" III , orn 00'1 om 0..... OUl 00'1 OU'l OCO cco oeo 0 0 w ~' ....NO N C\J Cl MC\JO ' .-tOO C\JNO M.-tO ~NO U1CXlO ....U10 NIIlO MUlO Q 0.: 000 000 000 ONO ONO OMO ONO 000 0040 0.-10 0.....0 0\ U " aJ I ' 0.....0 Oo4q 0.....\.0 0<-11'\. 001'. O.-t(\J 001'\. CON O.....\fI O....C\J O..-lM :>.<::: , , . , , . " . , , . " . " . , , . , , . , , . " . , , . \1' .. 1:~ .....U1q .....U'l..... .-IlIHD C\J0l"- (\JC\Jf',. C\JNV C\I(\JtO NOo-l MIOI'\. MU)t\. MWO w , 001'\. 00"," OOM o l.O "- oo::rtO o ('IJ (IJ OQ'N ON!'... 01'\.0'1 0""0 0"-"- "- u ::If5] ov Ov..... 0<;1'<-1 c:.. N 0..... 0"-0-1 00-1 00 OU) ow..... OlD W Q ,1.0 'lO 'LD '\fI 'lJ'I 'Ill '\fI 'lO 'Ul 'U1 'Ul ::l Q III ([ :z: : ..... .-I ..... .... - 04 ..... - 0-1 04 o-l ..... -1 , M M M M ,., M IV) M, M M M M a:: root . 0' 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 => u -I I.L.: en m en 01 0'1 en m m rn m 01 0'1 "- w , <:T q W Q" W Q" W q, W v w v W Q" W Q' W V W o;;r W v W t- ;1', w: :J , ::l , :::l , ::l , :::l , ::l , ::I , :::> , :::l , 0 , ;::l , :J <n 0'\ <;:' 0 C)' U'o U'\Q"-1 \fI q ..J tJ'IV..J \J\<;T..J \fI7...J U'lq..J lJ1<;!,...J IIlq-1 l.f'I'I1'-I LrI<;T-l LtlQ"'-l ::l <;T ua:: ..... _Ma: .....Ma: ....M<r: ....Ma: .....M<r: ..-lMa: o-lMa:: .....Me: ....Mer .....Ma: o-lMa; -, N a: ... u)' 'N::;' 'C\J:=> ,ru=> 'N::I 'N::I 'ru::;. 'N::> 'N::I 'N=> 'N::I 'C\J:::> 0- 0 0::::>: en en 01 01 en rn C'l en ' C'l m m en I "- a: w a:.u: N C\J ~ (\J .- N l- N l- N l- N l- N l- N ~ C\J ~ C\J l- N 1- 0: J: , U) , 00 , en , U) , U'l , en , Ul , Ul , tJ'l , tI) , U'l OJ f""'I 0- q (I)' ..... ..... ::l ..... :::l .... :::l 04 ::l ..... ::l o-l ::l ..... ::l ..., :::l .... ::I ..-l ::l ..... ::l ::l <r: z w: N C\J ~ N .., !\.I .., !'IJ .., (\/ .., C\J .., !\.I .., ru .., {\J .., {\J .., C'J .., U1 N [CITY OF CLEARWATER , L.B!'~ # ~'~c')~o I SIGN VARiANCE APPUCATlON .'. {.-'5 -0 · . PROPERTY OWNER(S) NAME & ADDRESS: REPRESENTATlVE(S) (if any) NAME & ADDRESS: 1 VIt9,:>-,C\] lfiflfV/P-/J tltfs. A atilt). ,-:-. J. AJAflll/:N ~~ ' t I, d.,c :J..f'1 efrlNt r<M,{,... , IZ 3 {f' /7 . "Ji'", oft . If. ~ t.J~ 6}- ~ It) LA&-T,I~.4l C~((Jl.J.... ~ ~t;'tt' TELEPHONE: (&(~ 1 #1-~f07 TELEPHONE: ( g /3 I '/-""/- 2 fs'o 7 ZONING DISTRICT: :r:.L LttjQV/~ 1(" , J/l.' dilll6!.. Il. /a14~ ,/ T LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: c:::rf LAND AREA: ;(, /'1 t4e.u.,. ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: boo... (.. (0 - b.2.0 NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPUCADLE): l"kCJ4~ aKJ LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: a:t/a "U PARCEL NUMBER: Z I I 29 I I rs I -4 ~ ~o I I O?S I 02.1 (This Information Is available born your tax receipt or contact Pinellas Co. Property Appraiser' 5 Offlce at 462-3207. If more than one parcel number. a11ach 8% x 11 Inch sheet) DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: South: O,f/'C6 {)ft:,CN" East: tJ./.{(~jr - .tt!d!td'.h~pS~ West: tJlhrer VARLANCEISI REOUEST [If Variance to 7 yeilr amortization requirement, refer to Sec. 134.0151: ~t2lkri f}f' II. b Sf' If, ~ ~~I!t6(j i-- ~t5r1 e'rT 7.r. 6 o .f 6.. (Fa dtfloJ D ;.~ S-t. S "'If-,r E REASON FOR REOUESTING VARlANCE\Sl: (Reier to Standards for Approval. next poge) ~/{.v ;!fr.J tft:W /p (p1tC.E rC/L / / '/E/lItS". ~bJ C "f1~ or PES,' '7 o1J S /5 d l:.r -tt-af. 7'/;f...J .~ ./ II' ' L .;oJ, C" ,.. fV~ 1€.c~ttliSr vtll1 I' tf,.}(J ew r.l~"'I'/fi,.Y " Jrj.v ':.J ;f(g~1} r, t' tL r -rtf. .,t;?tJ-. r'Y'~'lt7 //-V:r, .'_'__ . Dr, 6.JtdtlL? INS 2. S/;9UI ~.t.. G1c~ or /f,j fJPPEIt./7fO.vS E~' ~~J~ .5't')A'r4 A 4,zJj("-- 1~ ;;'1- -/r bl<--r hT~~-~~ 2!~~ ,daEd.!. ~ T -Ad"'! J:L;,v"",tr S&.",.JL J~d~ LJ /A- C~"'~~, ,0:rv ;(11'1 YO A!JI/tfItJ~ ,I;;c.r ()tI..J A.v'N!#~ i ____ I' ~ l? Et:tfqJ~' VSH,1/ . 77f~ or s- CotHINUI:O ON IlEVERSE SlOE \ ( STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance shilll not be granted by' the Development Code Adjustment Board unless the bPpllctltlon end evidence prosented cleDrly support the following conclusions: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which Is unique to the property In questlon and Is neither ordinarily or, uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by Dn actIon or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mista.ke made In the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of B, variance. (21 The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result In an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (31 The variance Is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital ",2" for the purpose of making reasonoble use of the land. (4) The request for n variance Is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return from the property. ' , (51 , The granting of the variance will not be materlnlly detrimentnl or Injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. CGI The grnnting of the'variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detroct from the appearance of the community, substantially Increase the congestion in the public'st/eets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any, way, or substantially diminish or Impair the value of surrounding property. {7: T~c \';]rin.",? d(l!;h''!'o \'.'111 !~.,t ~:!\':': r ~I~I~' aHLct the ,(:l.Ib!k hn.:tlth, ::o!c t'l. cr~cr ccnvcniar.cc. or g~l1crc! '.'JClf3r~ of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. ,SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): Sworn to and subscribed before' me this A /,;) day of @~ ~A.D.. 19 7'-) by --J4ukl'l':rE:A'//tI tf-f~:; who 1.1_ , ~al1Y known ~r has Ihave produced as Clyp. of 1.0,) identification personally appeared dcposad and stated ehe m'Dtters and facts set out ~ere' are true D?d _corre~ t~ best of his/her knowledge and belleL ~ //?CC::> c/~~ - ,.~ .O//J // '41, EYE' A-;S:dL~ \f.~j,;;., ~I t)1~... ,....,... ~, "'QY"'.\\)'''~ N~.Ilih'y Public, Commission No. r/OTARY PUUl.tC STATE 01' n ORrDA 1!~15S:0r; DI', ~1f\Y 9 191'!J BONDED nfHll GrljERr.t INS. 'UI/O: NOTE: rnOPEI1'rY OvmE~ Oill~I::pnESENTATIVE MUST ATIENO HEARING. , Ro.... 8/92 " I, " " ~ I " , " , ~ . ~~ . .\:,,",1:. I ~( ,,' .' ."k " I ~ I \, " I'" ',- , U "0 ,,", , , ~OOco .Ip LA1<EYIE~~ RO'AO ... - ~ ',0'" .\() ; --_...._-_..~ , ,___ _. ,. _. ..,~ w____ - -~, . ill ~ q' } 7?~, ct .' , I ''\ . ...... . oI.~.:.- .- ~ ~ I l' ,t I : ~ 'p.l i\ /, r I~ ., U' I, . : II i: Ii n , , . '. i .... I ~ . " " . I ", '. . I '..~ ':.' ','. . " . ~ .. ...... ..... .:. " . .., .. . .. ~: . ~ . ..... .. ~ ... . . . 01. ~. J..... I .,J.. II . I'.. __. ~,_.....~_. . "~" ~ c' ...___ ........... ,.....___.. . , , , I ~ . ' i 1/' II r - c \:.7L.. ~' 126';Ai.I p.; .,'J ffi 12/17 :I: "66 4 $If ___. ~ '" <D Vi I 1257 5"- B'-' I 1261 -- '260 7 }-. --t- 55 :H03-61 @ 3 68 P/SP 11/0.3 I CJ' 9 \0 , 1 12 11/05 I '0/ , 0 mEO-a_ ~' '" JJ J J '30$ ISOO 17 m 'A' 14/01 I ~ 2 J ~ I 4'314 ISIS 5 !lIT 11 ISI8 14/02 0 OL ID 132D 1324 hl9 101'1 It' 1JJ@4::ll g~~:g~2~~ ~ ....f~ _ 50 r.. r.. r.. r.. r.. r.. to. r.. r.. h, ~ ~ .!. . I IlB~(f ~ ruSK^W1lLA~ ^~NUE' 0 '" HE. 0 's B 7 6 5 4 3 2 11 ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ '(l\l)<n\l) 'Q<n "l'O 6 7 8 9 o '" . ~A' I _ I STREET r... ~ 1~rr:-.;r;!i'~I~ :; I 54JO..1911 ~I--r---. VAC, V ARJANCE REQUEST: SIGNS 1><1>0 NAME: SV#.9Z.71 PUBLIC HEARING DATE: ATLAS PAGE:3o:58SEC: 21 ~ CLEARW'ATER CITY COMMISSION i-A KE.\J I e.'v\J ~A.,J (:>() / t -\ V L, \.\ E:.~/ TWP: '2'~1 s. R G E: I'? E. ~ " ~I~ . 15 i I I I "t] cc :l " ... ... :J U o <:> .., .n r::=::> ...; t1l I 1 I ."'.. .. ~ ./ ':. Cleanvater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum ~. Item II Meetflig Date: I:<L//~r SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 355 S. Gulfview Blvd.; Ernest R. & Lydia J. Malke/Ritz Motel (Owner/Applicant); Same (Representative). (~\1 Ci?_Rl1) RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: Approve a setback variance of 4.5 feet to allow a sign 0.5 foot from the S. Gulfview Blvd. property. line, a setback variance of 5 feet to allow a sign 0 feet from the Fifth'St. property line; and an area variance of 4 sq. ft. to allow a sign of 54 square feet; to permit existing signage to remain on property identified as Sec. 7-29-15, L1oyd-White-Skinner Sub.; Lots 71 and 120; for meeting Sec. 45.24. Standards for Approval; items (1 )-(8); subject to the condition that neither sign shall be permitted to increase in area. D ond thot the oppropriate officiaLs be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to permit existing freestanding signage to remain: (1) a setback variance of 4.5 feet 'to aI/ow a sign 0.5 foot from the S. Gulfview Blvd. property line, (2) a setback variance of 5 feet to allow a sign 0 feet from the Fifth'St. property line, and (3) an area variance of 4 sq. ft. to allow a sign of 54 square feet along S. Gulfview Blvd. The subject property is located on the north side of Fifth St. bounded by S. Gulfview Blvd. on the west and Coronado Dr. on the east. The property is in the Resort Commercial "Twenty-eight" zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the table below. RavloWlld by: Leglll Bud(lat Purchasing Risk: Hgmt. CIS ACM Othar "fA "IA "IA iliA 1!t fl-. IjfA Orlglniltlng Dupt: CENTRAL PERMITTING 'S ~. COlli: Totol Commlnlon ActIon: o Approved D Approved ~/condltlons o Denied D Cont Inwed to: Unr Dupl: Curr~nt Fiscal Yr. Submlllud by: Advunlled: Dote:. Pnpcr: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not R~qwlred Alhcl.d Plrtlol r;] Notlfl~d D Not Requl rN.I Funding Source: o Ct1pi tnl Imp. D Oparating o Othel- Allochm.nu: APPLI CAT/Otl VARIANCE \.IORKStlEET HAPS o N ono Allpro[lIlatloJl Codl: o Printed on recycled pnper Information SV 92-84 Page 2 Sign 1 I Sign 2 l Existing Permitted Existing Permitted Freestanding Yes Freestanding Yes S. Gultview Yes Coronado Yes Blvd. Dr. 54 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. 43 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. 0.5 ft. 5 ft. Oft. 5 ft. 16 ft. 20 ft. 11 ft.; 9 in. 20 ft.' Type of Sign Location/orientation of sign Area Setback Height Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: If the signs were relocated to meet the setback standards, it would be necessary to remove two parking spaces (one for each sign). It would be possible to relocate the Coronado Dr. sign back approximately two feet without affecting the parking and thereby coming closer to meeting the City's setback standards; but the positive effect to the public would be marginal in comparison to the cost incurred by the private property owner to accomplish this. Given that the sign on Coronado Dr. is undersized by seven square feet, staff regards the request for an additional four square feet on the S. Gulfview Blvd. sign to be reasonable as well as minimal. I. I Direction ~ SURROUNDING LAND USES Existing Land Uses North South Restaurant East Retail Motel Parking Lot I West The granting of this variance will not detract from the surrounding businesses that have conforming signago nor will it negatively affect the overall appearance of the community. Applicable Variance Standards : To be eligible for a variance, a request must moot all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application; staff finds that the petitioner's request meets all of the standards. In particular; tho following standards do appear to be fully mot: . (1) The varianco roquestod arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinurily or uniformly applicablo to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of tho proporty owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the oxecution of D building pormit or work porformod without the benefit of D permit shall not bo considerod to be situations which support the granting of a variance. SV 92~84 Page 3 (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an ,unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The. variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital II 2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to socure a greater financial return from the property. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. " (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety; order convenience; or general welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: SETBACK VARIANCES CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING DATE REQUESTED/ACTION SV91-11 1550 S. Highland Jordon Hills 5 ft./ Approved 6/20/91 Ave Professional Center 8V 91-22 1874 G-T-B Capt. John;s 5 ft.! Approved 11/21/91 Hairstvles SV 92-01 2226 Druid Rd. Clearwater 1.5 ft./Approved 1/2/92 Dental Assoc. SV 92-21 447 Mandalay Ave. Heilman's 5 f1./Approved 10/15/92 Beachcomber SV 92-24 2000 Drew 81. Shell Gas 5 ft.! Approved 11/5/92 Station SV 92-71 351 S. Gulfviow Julio's Seafood 5 ft.l Approved 2/9/93 Blvd. Sunsots , SV 93-06 1 621-1 627 Gul f to Connoll's Plaza 5 ft./ Approved 9/28/93 Bay Blvd. SV 92-31 1880 Draw St. Drow Plaza 5 ft./Approved 9/28/93 SV 92-46 1824 N. Ft. Clearwater Bay 5 ft./Approved 9/28/93 Harrison AVe. Motol " . t \" . "" SV 92-84 Page 4 AREA VARIANCES FOR FREEST ANDING SIGNS CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 91-02 25191 U.S. 19 Dimmitt Cadillac 12.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 3/21/91 129.3 Sq. ft./Denied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. 19 Village at 124 SQ. ft. add'l to allow 280 1/2/92 Countryside sq. ft./Denied SV 92-03 2301 Sunset Great Western 42.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 1/16/92 " , Point Rd. Bank 66.3 sq. ft./Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S. 19 Public Storage 32 sq. ft. add'l to' allow 144 3/25/93 sa. ft./Denied SV 92-05 20162 U.S." 19 Suncoast Inn 38 sq. ft. add'lto allow 150 5/7/92 sa. ft./Approved , I SV 93-06 1621-1627 Connell's Plaza 144 sq. ft. add'l to allow 208 9/28/93 Gulf to Bay sq. ft./Denied Blvd. SV92-40 1 528 Lakeview Orthopaedic 32.4 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 Rd. Surgery Center of 56.4 ,sq. ft./Approved Clearwater SV 92-41 26508 U.S. 19 Ramada Inn 55 sq. ft. add'l to allow 105 9/28/93 sa. ft./Approved SV 92~46 1824 N. Ft. Clearwater Bay I 30 sq. ft. add'l to allow 80 9/28/93 " Harrison Motel SQ. ft./Aporoved l , '. VARIANCE WORKSHEET STANDARDS FOR VARiANCE APPROVAL . 111 The variance requelted ",Ises from a condition which Is unique to the property In question end II nellher ordlnerlly or unllormly applicable to tha ~onlng dlslrlct nor craated by In llctlon or actloOI of the property owner, predecenor In tille, 0' the llppllcllnt. Any mlsteke made In the uecullon of a bulldll1g permIt or work performed wllhout the benem of a permit Ihall not ba considered to ba IltUlltlonl whIch IUPPOrt the granting of a varlllnce. 121 Tha plutlcurar phYllcal lurroundlngl, Ihapa or topog'raphlcllI conditions of the property Involved end the atrlct llppllclltlon of thll provisions of thll devlllopment code would ralult In an unnacalllllY herds hip upon the appllcent. [31 The varJrmce II the minimum necellllry to oVllrcome the unnacalla,y hll,dshlp referred to In preceding recltel "2" 'or the purpolll o. makIng relllonable' use of the Illnd. 141 The raqualt for a variance II not baud prlmerlly uJlon lhe del Ire of the eppllcant to lecure a greate, IInancllll return for thll property_ 16J'The grenllng a. this varlllnce will not be materlelly dlltrlmentel or Injurious to other property or Improvementl In the neighborhood In which the property Is located. [61 The granting a. the varlence will not Impelr an edequllle lupply o. light or venUlatlon to adjacent property. danact from the appearance of the community. lubstantlally Increale tha congaltlon In the pullllc It,eetl. Increese the denger of fl'll: Ilndenglll the public nlety In any way. or lIubstllntlally diminish 0' Impair thll value a. lurroundlng property. . 171 The varlllnce daslrlld will not adve,sely affeot the publlc health. lafety. order. convenience. 0' genoral welfare a. tho communIty. . . IBI The granting of tha VlIrlence doslrod will not violate the general Iplrlt end Intont of thIs developmont code., CASE NUMBER SV 92-84 I I STAFF RNDlNGS I' The proporty II boul1dod on three Ildes by roads: One hellltandlng sign Is 10 square 'eat undersized. while the othe, II 4 Iqua,e feet overslzad. Reloclltlon of the signs would require removal of perking .pacal. An unnaCalury herds hIp would be Impond upon the p,operty owner II parking IpaCel we,e removed. Additionally. the ,emoval 0' a 64 Iquare foot 11gn 'or the purpole a. replecemont with II 60 Iqullre 'oot Ilgn would 11110 Impale a hardship In light of tho marglnel public bene'lt cllu.ed by luch action. No Imallor varlllnco. would overcome the above.ldentlfled hards hip ~ ' , The varlllnce rllquelt appearl to erlse from phYllcal conditions more then flnll~clel ccnlllquonclII. . \ j I I I , The .Ignl 81 thoy currently axlst are not detrlmentel or Injurious to other properties or Improvementl In the neighborhood. The Ilgnl mllat this .landlUd In their current locallon. The Ilgns as thllY currllntly axlst do not adversely nffeot the hoalth. safety. convonlenco or wolfere. GIven tho hord,hlp Involved If the .Igns were rllloclltlld or replaced. granting the vllrlllnclll will not vlolalll the spIrit and Inlent of tho code. 1\ I ~ /.. ""L.. ReceiDt # '" 10.3 1 50- PROPERTY OWNERCS) NAME &. ADDRESS: Ernest R. ~ Lydia ~. Malke CITY OF ClEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPUCA nON . . . I V II ~ v "\ 2..~ I REPRESENTATIVElS) (if any) NAME & ADDRESS: 165 Devon Drive CIQilrl"il tor BQ~""". Pl ("'I\"'" id~ 1.1161.0_ TELEPHONE: 18131 461-5763 .:t-"U.cI';:;IO') TELEPHONE: ( ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 355 Sou th <;:i4lfview Blvd., Clearwater Beach , NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPUCABLE): Ri tz Resort Motel. ZONING DISTRICT:-':.R 2. g LAND USE CLASSIACATlON: C,:-r; p; LAND AREA: LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: Lots 71 and 120 of LLOYD-HillE-SKINNER SUBDIVISION accordinq to the map or plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 13, pages 12 and 13. , , PARCEL NUMBER: 07 I 29 I 15 I 52380 I 000 I 0710 {This information is available from your tax receIpt or contact pjn~lJas Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462-3207. If more than one parcel number, attach 8YJ x 11 inch sheetl DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: . North: Julie I s Restaurant South: 5th Street East: West: Coronado Drive Gulfview 86uJevard VARIANCE(S) REQUEST (If Variance to 7 year amortization requirement. refer to Sec. 134.015): 1 ) A requested variance of 4~ feet for the location of the siqn located on Lot 71 . - 2) A requested variance of 4 square feet in size of the sign located on . I~ot 71 . 3) A requested variance of 5 feet for the location of the sign located on Lot 120. REASON FOR REOUESTlNG VARlANCE(St: (Refer to Standards for Approval. next page) Please see attached. "';1 CONTHWCO ON IIlNriR!l( f:IOf, . STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL~ A variDnce sh2lil not be granted by the De....elopment Code Adjustment Board unlesS! ;",: the application and e....ldence presented clearly .upport the following conclusions: ~.:J~ (1) The verlllnce requested arises from &l condition which Is unique 10 the property In question end Is neither ordinarily or unlformly eppllceble to the zoning district nor created by en action or ectlons of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the lIpplicant. Any mistake made In the execution of 8 building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2\ . The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict I . epplic!ltlon of the provisions of this development tode would result In an unnecessary hardship upon the eppllcant... " (31 The variance Is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship rcferre"d to In preceding recital -2" f~r the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. 14) The request for e vDrlance Is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure e greater financial return from the property. . (5l The grant\ng of the variance will not be materially detrimental or Injurious to other property or improvements In the neighborhood in which the property Is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not Impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract horn the Ilppearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets. Increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. , (7) The variance desired will not t1dversely effect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfi'lr~ of the community. ISI The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. fl. , "Zt.I-~~L )f" /;/{J!lfe '.....hld. ,,, p<>ooI~unll\,",l (\ ~ II . .., .....o/")1 UL.€ J~~ 1"'C>-J2--""",-, ' I .- I Sworn to and subscribed before me this S day of 7L~e...t.-~"- ~../ A.D., 19 ft"2 by Ee.1J rEST V< MAL~er..-.J Ly'fJ 1/1 )./ A$;Ir;t~DH: ~ - .-...... SIGNATlJRE OF PROPERlY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): ' personally known to me or has Ihave ~P"IiiIC.Cd- liS I..,.,.. ull.D,1 Identification personally appeared deposed and stated the matters and facts set out herein are true zmd correct to the best oi his/her knowiedge and b!.:\iei. ....I~ rtU :$ ,0ler1 r.:~t::. S:..:: ";,f n;:l;!:l t~J (c.I1.;nh~kn b:_:.:~ l:~:. lI, \~?S NOTE: pnOPEfiTY OWNER on REPRESENTATIVE ~ ATTEND HEARING..... , l.n".o.Ilhru "'rf~il\'I"M~I\"ln" ,;,:'. n~v. BlgZ .. . ". '- . ~~ R~ Re404t ~oieJ ~. Overlooking The Gulf Of Mexico · 355 South Gulfvlew Boulevard Clearwater Beacht Florida 34630 . '. (813) 44.1~9905 FAX: (813)461~2199 " '.'. . " . ., Dear Sirs: )"" ;In;!;??.~esting a variance to the. Clea.rwater Sign Ordinance, we would. like you to take into consideration.tq~ following po~nts: 1) Moving the sign structure located on lot 71 .at 355 S. Gulfview Blvd. back five feet from the front property .1ine (which would necessitate II'Dving the center pole 8! feet from the current lcx::a.tion) would place it in a position of not being seen by tn::ltorists and pedestrians proceeding south on Gulfview Blvd., which would .damage IlWalk_in" business to our. establishment, .and would also cause confusion for people not familiar with Clearwater Beach. There is also the. potential of additional automobile accidents as cars make abrupt turns onto 5th street when they come up to .: the building. 2) Moving the. sign on. Lot 71 back frOJl the front property line \"ill eliminate two parking spaces on the property. Moving the si.gn structure Ion Lot 120 back five feet from the side property line will .also cause a . loss of two additional parking spaces. . With parking so scarce on the beach as .it is, this would only contribute to a. growing. problem. Not having enough parking for guests of .the motel would create "ill will" from the guest1s perspective to the'property arid ~learwater Beach as a whole. . 3) The cost of moving each sign has been estimated by Ray Davis of Davis Signs as being $1776.20 each (a Copy of the bid is attached.) 'l'his is' a total amount of $3552.40. In a small business, as you are aware, this is a very substantial sum and would needlessly create a severe financial hardship upon the owners and operators of the motel. 4) The signs in question do not abut any other property line or .building (as you can see by the attached site survey), so they don't cause 'any detriment to any. other property holder or business on the Beach. 5) By granting this variance no harm will cx::cur to the public health', ,safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the conununity. As a matter of fact, not granting the ,variance would damage the conmuni ty as we noted in item 1.' . 6) He do not.:. believe that the spirit ana .i:ntent of the developnent code was to create unnecessary financial burdens),: nor add to a g1'O\...in9 problem (parking) on Clearwater Deach, so granting the requested variance . will not in any way haun the cOlllllluni ty. \'Je appreciate your considering these i.tems, and yo~r consideration of the requested variance. I .J , ' , . ~ ~. f. , ~ . , ,. .. . , , . ': , , , ,. . I, . 'f ", b t/ . I " , , ..... .. I~..'t"., ll~". ' . .. ~ . I \. .:.:~~~,l/ ", , ! _ I.: f > . , 1 f " , . ~. ~ . ~ ,,' "', r ~. ,:' .' ..' RITZ RESORT MOTEL :jss South Gulfview Bouiev~rd, Clearwater Beach, Florida 34630 , " 't. , Sign'~2 located at the S6utheast end of the the Ritz Motel on'Coronado Street. " \ ... . . ) ; I L. Lo'r 1,120 '. , ..! ~ T I.' . \1 . I. >~ . ." y .... .. ,~~.... ....... -- I \ .' t I I 10'0" 'j> .J' ,.. , i ,I.. .j'-t i, . , . RITZ' MOTEL " '. ., ..', \ ~~ , .: . ~ <' ~. >.t , ,. " I .() '! :1': I " ,( " I I I. T J " " I. 1+,_ " : '~I I( i l , I ~ .1 q . I' f'\ I i '1"' I. i 1 ,. !' NO VACANCY . ~ . ... .. , .IT ., . - !. ';) l"" Al<~' l~..'IC.\ r,:J.lo:"..:::l, - .1 t'l51' .t...r.IC&t . FRor/\ f"t.::.t.\C€" 01,1 (.:'or~' :.1r \,:., t:.() '-to POL&:; ,'Ct j j' Ii.- \ ,., L:d:;;I/-,!iC;::; .r} dt', H-:ll~t:., L-..id , , . I ~ :,':. ;! 'I r., 'I () \',)[ i';' . r;.' 3'" \, f. , i I I / .' ',' ~1v I. Y' I ~L-:'-'-----' .....:;' l ;..--.. --- '. 'I , j , ' ., , I II \ lO~, " . ,. I r: J \',1 ,.~ ~.........~_...", .,,1 , , ) ,. . \ ,. , " " '., . ,.. " ~ . ~ . . ' ;~ . I >~ ~. ., . . , 1 . c . I.' .' >" t . ~ f' . .. (. ,. ~ . .J: ': ..,. '. ~ S... .~.,"" '.... I' ". '1 \ c'.j. .....'.. . ,+;",' ,I i 'j J , , {> I, c: 't J. '. .' , . ,", ' , . . ' :\ I, '. " .. , . '\ . , . >t. 1.' f.! . 'I " ," , . l'" "l " , , , .' I RITZ 'RESORT 'MOTEL 355 South Gulfview Boulevard Clearwater .Beach,'Flo~ida 34630 ., . ,. . , Sign "1 located at the Southwest side of the Ritz Motel on South, Gulfview'Boulevard. ., I. LOT 171 " ,..... j{ t. 9 II ._': ,:~~-t ':.+- . .~ '. 1.. , " " . , , . :. . :1 ~. . . I ~ ~ .' ,+:,' '.' " .' .... :: I ()~ - I, ...s>! --: " I I . \ ',4. !' I , I \ ., I, I, ,..\ .\ j. c' (, I, .,1 . , ,. ~" , '. I. t- .\ ' " ... .. " .. No ',VAcANCY' " ,.' i. \. ... \:) R/rz' -1'1a/,EL ., ., " , . 0, ," I, 'I' I \ \ I. 1. . ;:; .\,1 ., \'l, 'WtE Leo f\A S' '0 .\- " J ..-r I' -, I 0 II I 1" t I. I , \. : R~LE: 1"6"<:.1 " . . I . , OI::Jr/~/,lcG. f';:'ur ,t"'(Il.L..' i.' 't-ill/f.: ~.: -:. !" ; ~ .. .. 'J '. ". '-..t I !')r: . ~\,.\ I .'.,"'oJ (n, .01 , , " ~ ,,' " " " I' I " .' '. I I 1 i I I' ~.., .. ' I A~~)\ (l :: . I. ,.1 II, JI ., ... . I ., . I .' ~ . ,,' ..------~.._--~- . - , . ' t'/'~ I (c-;" ..-----.. . . ! I. ,I ,., " , ' ., '. ., , . j_. '._ l (:J /.':. flection 8 ~ ~ . A':'7.'5. 29 'ro.VNSIlIP SOUl'll IU\NGB 15 BM'f 1-: 11 j~.o.'78' , .1"(>, I, ~~ 0,10 Z'1 ,J" I , t}la4. liS B.Zo') pO';. SPECIAf. PURPOSE SURVEY , showing the location of the existing sign Stlppol:tn on Lots 71 and 120", 'l'HE I.I.OYD-mJI'!'E-SKINNER SUULn VISION as recorded in Plat'Book , 13, pages 12 .and 13, public records of Pinellas County, Florida; . i'j;+" /1<7 .10+. /2'0 AIm .ROCWt:1 AS , The Ritz Resort Motel 355 GuHview Blvd. So. C.leanlator " . . . LO-/-. - , .'. '70 . L'ol- 71 , ' .' " ,. .~ l'';J, S/t!d Ib,f 1 o fO,B/P 'i(!9' BASIS OF BEARINGS: " BAS~S OF ELEVATIONS: LEGEND ' I. A.: IRON nOD. I.P:: IRON PIPE C.M.: CONC. tlilONUMENT N.D.: NAIL &. OISI< P.C,P.: PERMANENT CONTROL POINT P.: PLAT A.: RECORD M.: MEASURED C.: CALCULATED tlOTE NOT VALID WITHOUT AN EMOOSSr:D SURVEYOR'S SflAL 9cA.....~OZ 3 (813) fl.17.205.'5 I hC/oby CCIII''f Ill'll lh'C sur~I!'f rcprIlSl,!nll'<J t,l,!'cUII mll,!I~ II,,: ' 'CQUHQIIHIl\11:q!, CllaplIll 3.11~,IY/7A(OIl(\" ^lln\II\I~\I~'h'IIJ Co,h, . /9 "-'/l:a-:~~/// ~ ,"0'~' 92 ~~--.?~-~?i "../::.~/::. ~-~:,......-- ..----:...~-.::.=-!!.... -:.-.- . t. (. C. Ooyd AII...n \)illt~ FlollUII IlrgUloled Surn'fur 110, J9J:i' ALU~N l..AND S.Ufil.VEYlNG c: noytJ AlIm, P,I..S -- -----...- 1 J'.'"ililln ,\tIJn'.,; P.O. BUX.1232, '('.upnn SprlllIJS, Fl. .l,16f18.J2n JH I.c.,fw~>u,II~n.\\l. T.\l p,m Sl'rillg~, 1'1, Clol,!CkcrJ 01' ,. , !F" I I, \ ., " " . eel " ;~ :' .\ , "f"'.\ ~ I. 1 : ' , ,. , I \n~ ~ ;, ID III f:2., ~~ .' .1Il 0 . - . q:W I:r' ~! m~~ ;i ~~. jge. ~~o glll~ ~ I. ~'~ ;:0 a: I 15 f( t In ZOO ~ Ww I' I. i'ugJq: ~ , ~g~ ::l::ea: ., lIlWll. " 61 ~ $1'0 E"8 l: 0 2iL ;~ .eX 'i X. E.N OJ .. '" Q> I!!- 0.0. I!!.:! f~ :J ~ .. .. l: Z .! ~, r:! 0 : e Q> ~. ~ III ,- 8 u .l: :J en_ -w -' u. ,5 Ii! VI , U. ~ ,5 'c . 0 t 0 ~ E .e \t<l W g!QlJi. !2 "" -..: .c. 0:( - - ll. 0 ~ ' I - ~ .....('01 CD .t::. Cl -c tl.N J, i ,:>. aloe 1:,J, :l.,o V) !l " ~ ~ ff ~ 1 ~ i, - - fl' e: l! ::J .. .E ~ e: III ,.:, .~ 1 . '~ ~ ~'5 E ::l 1lI_ :3 :it . ~s c: if Ii Q'i ~.l: ;~ . E .2 2 .. .,~ i a ll. Z .~ ~~ 8 iL'" . 0- CM a 11'" .0 .. '5 Ii Ill... "tl, :a .. -g .. ;a o QlotJ cB' ~:c 1!~ ' {fez>.... C ~8. :s ~ .! i '2 ::to 1ft :3 n j'~p f:"8'" ~ It~ .. ::t. OJ ~~a I-a:... ,....."... ''''"'"''-->> 1J"..,........t"~~ ._" II: \' ~t ,- -.I -...:.... OJ \1 ",.., ~ I j~"'L" -~' . . "+"'" N I ()..-4.U ~~~r: ~... g \:l5~~ ui ,1 '" .. ~\~';,1i' . Pol'. ti ~f. .8 , .1.., H ~I rJ , :i,loa . , ~'41 I'l '!:!' .~ ," IJ " ... r' . ~ .. ~ B ii. 'd .~~~:~~ &}~nl! .1 ,!'i Ii ~ . ~;"'N OJ u. o .t t; iJ .n:!' .. 2.'i ' ;j\~ NI>l ~~ -/- , ',p "' Cl7l"1A~.,nc:::.Cd. " , .. I . ~~~gl . . . :t , .0 ~ I ~l l..L -1 ~ .. d.J:d~\ C t5? men . 1/J(l 9 E! ~!l. _ . -,1('2 ~ jB~ .,-~b; ':to/; - .......-J .. ,'(II .1fI.9 3nn ~I ',\ 09 .111 f,.... ~ .Y(J.~ -10;0 " ~ ii o .' '/. :c . :'~ . f : ~ ~A ~ " ~ ~ <": , s:: "'.. :::~ :! ~ ~A --..- ~ .: 3 .. .. .. :; '..,- . '" .~ :! ~ 'V A'RIANCE--REQUEST: SIGNS NAME: .- SV#. CfZ-Bt. PUBLIC HEA.RING DATE: ATLAS PAGE:Z7c;,)~ SEe: ~ CLEARWATER M.6. \.. 't<-\Z ! 'R \ \L..MOT-EL TWP:.LLS. ~ __ h CITY COMMISSION { RGE: 11S E. ~ ~l~ I ~ Wl< l~' ;- '" . tJ '" ';:'li ':'llll:lPR I I ! Ii '\ ~/" .... .- ...... ~ " .. '" "1:1 C -I - .. :. "I::l to: .. ... j~Q :. I I . ~.'.,! :>'t'l:1 .. ! ~ -n ;- . . I \..1-1 l' I I. -:l.\~.IJ"onll;1 1 _.J-- l q _ _, I ;-' - ! .. nc-. 0; .- :J ... Q ... ... -J ': ,"' , ," t.,. \ f' }) > J . .. <. I, ". ,. -.,.'.~_.,..~ ..>>( ,i ,v,i.'\::.,:..::/:, '.,.: .".. l"'h~f"'"".". ~",,".{.f.l..,~ .._." '< '.;.~.., ..', ~~,.?~:.\:~ ;",.~."."..:<,~,;"">'...,,~, .'.-. " .,:.:. ., ",1 ,'. . .> . ,,', . . ~. . 'j':. .::~ : t. . .~, .~ t : I l' .' .j' '. ;..,' ~. ! . 1 ,,,..~. ~ ' . .1. : , i~,:'!!~:r.': ,; '~f .: . ~ 'L ~.... . ~~':,.. :-- ~..'\\..::I.'.;: : I, ~: \.>':~ '.., .'t'; . ~.' . . I .:;... ~ ~ -,' r .,; . .: ~ ~ i.~,~/:L,;. :".::'(' ;. J.~ .~ "1- ',',. :'-;~;:\I':. .\' (i{,'~ ..'i;,'i, .....F. "'0;) "'~ " >~ . ~ +~ . ,""j , " .// ,. .~ , , I. . r" ," , ". ' ~:: /. . . ~ ". . ~ I . '. .~ I. . .1:. '. :;:: .j. r. :.i ~. . ",. . "" v ~., . , , ~ .' I ,. . ~ t. . ' ~ ;. ::~')' , , , . t..', ; ,'.. -(. .\ . f. . ~ / :,.", ... ~. .. " ., ~ '.' \ ,/ .\ ,,1/. , t'!" '. " ',: t". t.< ", >..J, , , .; 1, > ' " "-I. .. . , !, ,.;,';./.... '.~.. ~ 1>' '~ , , :.'<'>:':~\.:.> , ( "\.1 I ,; . .. I. . ~ + ~ ~. . i. ,!.. . , '~. l' " .., ,-. I ~ f , .' , " ~ '. ,.. . \. . , ~ . ' '.' , It. . "t'. , , .' ~ , . ': , .. . ~ . ,. I. '{', ' ., t"\ ~ I . , ;~:. .1 I r;.' :,', . t}- /. .", .. 1:~' ,~ " ~ ~ ; . '", I ~ .:: .' .1 '" :, , , , ,:." i';, . ',~ ., :t' , ." , j'o .' , ..1 " . ,. .': '\' t ',,~ 'f' .,. . '<.~ ... , " .,. ~~ ' ' . 1. ' , ; ". ~ .. i- J:' . " , d .,1, I. '., I , ,'\ ~ ' , t :,: I I > ',~' " .! '.~ ~c, F . ~t . t: ~ :"", I."'. ~ _ ' j". ",: " >:. :" . .~ . to 1. . . '" ~! ,.. " .' 'I. o I ~'., ;b(';'~':'.'~' ;~'l /,,~.; '? ;.....'"';. ..,~; i ~ ,. , , .,........ .\ ; ~ _'w j' I 'It i' '~ .d"i~ '; > .. . :1,"':' I. ~. > '.. \, , \ ~ ' .. t,., '\~, ~' , " . .., .1 .j. , .. ':. }, ". 'I". ,. t:. !, ':r , , ~," .' < IC,t '"I', ~, ' .1. " ~ ~ ". ,. _ t.. 1"C .,'C , .j <'t ." ....it"/. .; " .' " . , t ,~ ',. ,~l" " :' 'J' ,. '. , ~ '. " I. ., .. '~ :I, ~.... , ~ ' .1 ~... . Y' '.' :.' .,~ ~,' /t '.. ~f t ,~ . ': ~ i. ... ~, ;. .; I" ., .','. ." C."t>' ;.:'t. ':l ....t. fj. >.'.1 ! , ,'T:. . I' ,.-, ' : l . t. .', :'. '.. C {; , C . ~ ',: \.<' OT '., ~ . '. . '.,. (" " '. .:. ~ ~ . ~ '. I I.... ~ .. . ~ - ,:; >, " . ,. ~ " ~. '. . ',' . , ' '. .j " ., 'I' ~J. ..J .. ., . , , .. , ,,' 'T T,.:"~ ~ j.~ l ~ ., .. ~;': ~. ,f. ~ ~ C ~ I .' : I . , '. . ..' '.. ., i +,' ,i ~ " ~ . .'. 'L t.. 1-1' . .' , . , . ~ ;. ~.J":'~\' : ... .. ~ , ~ .j. " " ., ,., " , .j ~,' . . , .'. ~ ." ~ .. . '.. , . ',t ;P . '" . '. ! ~ ", . ., ',: ,. , ., ~,- ~ ~ .: I. . ~.: l.. c' !, 0 'h., \, . ~ c' ~. . :,. , ,. 'c' '~ ' .' '.).' '. '. >"i' . ~: ~'~ ". . .. " "',c ,: ,..\,,\ . [ :'. ~ r" .. '....t. " ." , ., T ~~. \. ". .' " :,' ,t>j'.;" ." ..t"j. , ,. ., . .', ,.' .'" . I, c.,. t ~, ~. ,. ~ ' " :AGENDA :, ,~:... \ . , . ~ (I" , ' ~ ~ , ,\, ., " !, .j. .;, , : .' , . '~ ...:. . \'1., ~ ~ . t. ...' . .;/ , ~ , ' ~ " ,- .J ~,. . , I ~, .. ~ J -: :' ~ ,'" ,," " ;. ..\ . ., : , ~} , . ~.' ., \. '.!. , " , ,. ~ .' " ..1 . ~ ,. .' " , I . , ' ,,; \. oj. ~J ~ . . ," ,~ '.c i~' " ,t- i l '. ". , ~ :. i l c, ~ , ,'; '>.: l, 'i I: , , '" , , . , ,f ., !. . ' " ~ , I; , '. .' ,'- .-DATE f..-' a.,* ~. 9# 'I :,'1 . '~ " r ., i. "it .' , .. "I ,. ',. " * <' " ... I , . ,ITE:'~ '#d .. . ) l . ~ ., , I. , .,. , , '. 'l ! .\ 1 , .f' .,', " .-;; .1. "f ., . ..' 1. . , 'I', ~ L I ~ j ,. I, I.' " .' !',' , l' . ~ . ~ ~. : ~ . j. .; ;t 0",. . :, , ,t ~ . ~', ,. C. ~ " ,. " \ . . . ,';. ',1 .,. .' I :.-1 1, , .' , , ~ , , . ... . " . , 1':',1 ., {, .f , , .. >toO ' ,. " t. .1". , : ,.. ~ '. '," .'.' , r , 1 .. .' ' " '.! ~ I , , \ ,"' , .' :, ,; , ';, \ , , .1 ' ,., " .j .j 'j . I: ~ " : ' " '. . , ;. \.' " -,' '. '. \. , , ... I.' ....:~ . '. "C, ,. ~ '\ . . I . It , ! 'I' "' , , .' ,. , . . '. , , . , . ,/ . .~. . ~ '.'. . L ~ \. . . ,. , . , I ' .~ ..,. -~1;2U;U~ li:2~ 'U'H3 ..~Dll UU!-I POWELL' CAR.\"EY 1itJOO:"U02 . , I " POWELL. CAnN~Y, MOORE, Hucx'~ & OLSON. ~A. -# 7. AT'I'ORNI!:VS A,T lJ,W 'J7..i. :. ,U..,nNET1' 'rOWER ONE PROGRE99 ,.lJ,ZA . aUln: 1210 ST. f>ETEnSBU"G. rL.OAIO^ ~370' ,. MARY JO CARN!:V , Dft'^N T. l"IT2.0~"ALO ..I0EL R;GlL.&:1l JOHN CURTIG Hur:l<~ o\NNI: 5. MASON' 6, 1-1&:1...,.., MOORE STIi:WA,RT O. OLSON ' JAMES N. P9WE:U. " DON OOUGL.Al.l R^MG^Y 5U!lANNA 5. !U1P:A .1b1)~.G ec III fI.'U 0 e:.'....L 'fII~.;i,. u'"'"u. ,. . MAII.ING ADDRE.!lS: P.O. DOX.\GOt ST. PEn:nSQUna, f'L.Onlc,", 3:;l73\.ltBO "F'CL.CPUONE 1l13.f!9&.PO I I I"^CSIMlI.E 8 1.:l.99Q'!>>OI 4 January 20, 1994 Cynthia E.. Goudeau, City Clerk . City of Clearwater P.O. Box 4748 Clearwater. FL 34618-4748 Re: Public Heating on Sign Variance Application ~ SV 92-94 . , VIA TELECOPY AND U,S. ~~ Dear Ms. Goudeau: .'This office represents Barger Interests (peacl:les) with respect to the sign variance application referenced above. The pUIpose of this letter is to withdraw the variance applitrntion and to request that the item be removed from the Public Hearing Agenda for January 24, 1994. . . Thank, you very much, if. you need any additional information, or have any questions, please let me know. Sincerely, . , POWE~ CARNEY, MOORE, , HUCKS Be OLSON, P.A.. .~ . ,- 1s~ on >, SOD/pink \....~u.~~:I1, . . cc: Mr. Scott Shuford (via tclecopy) Mr. Steve Doherty (via tclccopy) , , RECEIVED, , .IAN 21 1994 CITY'CLERK DEPt ClealWatcr City Commission . Agenda Cover Memorandum . Item # Meat Ing Date: 1. I/.~(dq,/ SUBJECT: Variance{s) to the Sign Regulations; 26034 U.S. 19; Barger Realty/Peaches (Owner/Applicant); James ,N. Powell (Representative). (SV 92-94) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Deny variances to permit nonconforming signage to remain on property identified as Sec. 31 ~28-1 6, Darryl's Subdivision, Unplatted Lot 1 ,less road right-of-way, for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(3), (5), (6), and (81. D and that the appropriate officlols be authorized to execute sama. BACKGROUND: The applicant is roquesting the following variances to allow the existing attached signage to remain: 1) An area variance of 13.2 square feet from the permitted 150 square feet to allow a total of 163.2 squ'are feet of attached signage on the Enterprise Road frontage; 2) A variance of on.e attached sign from the permitted maximum of five attached signs to allow a total of six attached signs on the U.S. 19 frontage and of three wall signs from the permitted maximum of three signs of the same type to allow a total six attached wall signs; and 3) An area variance of 91.2 square feet from the permitted 142.5 square feet to allow a total of 233.7 square feet of attached signage on the U.S. 19 frontage. The ~ubject property is located at the southwest corner of U.S. 19 and Enterprise Road and is in the Highway Commercial (CH) zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. / ROl/lawed by: L{!gol Budget Purchasing R hit Mgmt. CIS ACM Other N/A N/A N/A N/A tt fl_____ IA Origlnatlnll D.p!: CENTRAL PERMITTING r; S CoIU: Total Comminlon Action: o Approv{!d D Approv{!d w/condi t ions o Denied D Coot inued to: UlDr Dept: CUrrent Fiscol Yr. { .- \ . Adv.rthlld: Date: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE o lIot Ilequi red ^ lI.cled Palllu [:] Notified o Not Rcqui red Funding SllUJCo: o Copital Imp. el Opcrat l ng o Other A ltllchm onU: APPLl CA T 1011 VARIMCE IJORKSIlEET HAPS D Ilone Subltllllad by: Cltyf:/t~ .-. I l ,~ pr ntcd on recyc cd pnper Apl1Jllprlalion Clldu: SV 92-94 Page 2 Sign 1 I Sign 2 . Information . Existing Permitted Existing Permitted Type of Signs Location/orientation of sign Area Attached U.S. 19 Yes Yes Attached Enterprise Rd. Yes Yes Number of attached signs , ~ Total J,.....____....IIiI...___.... I ~ Sign of the , ~ same type 233.7 sq. ft. 6 142.5 sq. ft. 5 163.2 sq. ft. 3 150 sq. ft. 5 ~__M____M___~~___~N_ 6 3 3 3 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: The applicant contends that the signs are building murals designed after a music type and are not meant to be used as an advertisement for their products. Each "mural" is a replication of a cover from a music release such as an album jacket or compact disc cover and it is the staff interpretation that the code definition of "signs" clearly identifies these as signs. The applicant has not provided any evidence that these variance requests arise from any conditions unique to this property. These variance requests are extreme with regard to the permitted area and number of attached signs and cannot be c~nsidered minimal requests. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing Land Uses North Sou th East West Cas a Guillardo Restaurant Strip commercial shopping center Cypress Point Shopping Center Professional offices Commercial and office uses surround the subject property. The existence of these attached signs with a greater area and more-than-permltted number of attached wall signs is not in character with tho signago permitted for tho surrounding commercial uses. The granting of these variances will detract from the commercial businosses that have conforming sign age, permit an unfair advertising advantago to tho applicnnt, nnd nogutivoly impact the overall appoaranco of the community. Ap-plica ble y"Qli{l,n c~_$_w_n d ards: To be oUOiblo for n vnrinnco, n roquost must meet all oight stnndards for varianco approval. Based upon roviow und ulltJlysls of tl10 information contained in tl10 npplication, staff finds that the potitioner's roquost moots only two of tll0 standords. In pmticulnr, tho following standards do not appoar to bo fully mot: S V 92~94 Page 3 (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or . actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution .of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in' an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding rec.ital "211 for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which. the property is located. (6) The granting of the variance .will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: ATTACHED SIGN AREA CASE # ADDRESS NAME V ARlANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 91-01 2000 Drew St. Shell Oil 2/7/91 SV91~16 601 Cleveland St. Sun Bank roved 8/1 5/91 , . SV 92-19' 27001 U.S. 19 J.C. Penney, 329 sq. ft./ Denied 10/15/92 . Co. SV 92-42 714 Cleveland St. Trickel 70 sq. ft.1 Approved 2/9/93 Jewelers ~ O'J I N O'J > f/) a:: w co ~ ~ 2: w (JJ eX (.) I- w w :c en :::.::: a: o ~ w U 2: eX - CI: c:t > I a II .g !~ ~ j ""u:i"a..~ .a ~ .E ~ ~ .g a>E.co.='ii ~ II .~ g g; li Q .. UIi -U 1:1 U N~ tao.~>- .11 II .!l ~ I- i 'S"'rJU o5":JJl.;E J: "C U J: 0 "g2.!l,g':: j:lo.E"c ,,"O.!r.:SOlJl z:::J1~~l:Ia G G ... G :: II o~~i.!;t .... E -- .. ... ~ ~ c1: ~ " tJ" J!.E~.c.5!~ g;;&.. g:S 8 II :J..!I 01 I: ~.ot:II!.lj s:: Ct u" ... ;c~J~: ~ .. G " CI u ~ji.2ll:: ~11..~C-S .E1;l II eS" .8::~a5.s Jl ~ ~ E ~ 8 .. oe- 8{lJi':::li>. igSo=:2t: c......>.....t&. 1!1:;~aS>2 o g:: 01 J: r:I. J:"E.="IIJl ~C..Q-S".J:: ..Bot:"D~"" ~'a<:s;~S ::~i~!j ~':;f8g5 .. J: .g 'ti I: o ... B :;: 0. ! tiI o tI. 2 i:i II 0. II .c .. .. >- Clt: ~ 8- c 0 ~ a =.!! :S.c .. .. ]-2 i.~ .c.c r:I.~ .i ii :J.c U II t! co ~~ g ~ &I U iill &I > tio .c '" 1-05 II "C o ... &I .. .; c ... E ' o 0. " 0 ]] .~ I.t "C"O 811 B~ :;: .. c.cE ~ .2 :l g'.e '[ sag. o~~ &I .. .. c.... J: .. <) Q ~'Cg- ..2 0. :l.li:;: ~ L[ ~ J: 0. .. :J II .c ~ tt ~ :J '1: .. .. .. " - .. " :I 1! 8 ].; ~ -a i :) .i]i B ~.Ii 'f ~ '3 1I.1i .. 0.>&1 .. t, ~ ~ &. ~ E K) - o .. &I .Q E :;I J: -g oj "' &I ii "C M g II :'! 0. .. II " oS g. s~ 1 E 1l':E ~ E E"C !; t &I 3! E " ! ij. M: ... &I " &1.0 ~ 0 " I: ; ~ ~ ... O""C .. r: .. II :: ~ j~ ii "'D :0 " ...c " u II .. ..c ::: I- 01 .. a..c :;: .. ':;0 ;; : .c ::I ~.!! 01.1:) .. II .. I: 8 ~ ~ : I: .. :;I Cl II J: '5:;' E E 80 t :: ~ &. g :i >a. ii II .. -5 .. ~~ .. c · E~ :J"i ~ii E ! .. .; CI .li "C Jl ::I 8 a .; .Ii ii 0 > .. II "C .c ~ to .. "C il]] "i '" o D- a. II II c .!l ii > " e .~ .g E '0 ci~J: oS iJ 1.1 ~ C C'.I"l:I i: ., ~ 5 ;I -5.5!'JJ:. .. 1'1 '" G ~1I8~E II oS c .. -.c.!l .. ~J:: ;; ~ -g~:-g .. t " Cl 1:1 ti u 0 !!~-Sg- CI ~... :E: :;]0,S!' 5'~ r: ~ '; E t~ ~ 8 ~ ~ -S.!lt)~ i :1 j!: 3 .:1-a'..tI~ .2'_ " ;; ] II Ii ~&ii. ll~]O;g. "ff1l....s11 II off ii .. oS :t!~5S :;~a.G& 'S~Ir~:! 'O.8'ii~:i II ESE-li ... :J 0" II C::'::::C:D) :!~:s;gc If! ~ Wi .... :i ..c _ IJ ;, 1: .. E -5 .. II ~ ... ... ., ::II .. x..,!!.;1l II ~ .. II J: ij.c: ii~ :;g ~! oS~ ~lt o it- C'.l E CI .,,~.Eo'i Ut:l~U,. c ,g l: II &I ue:>.c> .i E g E ~ :"U~..o-5 .:: A lL~ .. ti l-e_~3. ,:..ii,s::e t:a."'D-::~ x..!ua~ a5~~ii b'58.8~ f'ii8.j~ ~=!j5 .s:~::r "C c .. &I C I:.,~;g ::s III ... ill 2.~:EctrJ :iiiJCl.E .. t ~ ~ E It ... ! I:; 0 :~~!~ ~ ~:; ~ g ~;'5~~ ~j.;..;! >- i~g~]~ -Cl.1!_..e .!l 'ii .. ..!l .. E 2't3 C -t]i :: Q E1!f~t~ e ~- E~-5 c3~;B]o c .2 " ,i .s Cl .5 E~8:"C ~ .!l c: S 1: ct 0 :; ~"g ~ 1: j IJ ~ g;!o .-o>::~ .?;o.t:O"i c. .3 ... > g-e8... " E ; oS :l8't;1~ ~ t.I V a. C",c oS .E ~: : .. II Q 11,0 C '1.1 t.I .r: ~ g ti .11 _ II oS .E ~;';.5 .5 8,"&;" a....,.. g : ; ~ _ ..c U c 'I': .... t::: CII !;E.I:)" II c [ll g.:: I) ~ .S u'5 ... i ~ .s ~ u ~ C iii -5 >. ,g ~ ~i~i .s a 8 .5 ! i: ~ ~ ~8::~ ~~:.gi iii:t1.g2 _...ia.Q. a > o D- a. 01 " U C ~ .. > o .... '2 II 'D C II .. Jl ~ ..c J: J :& l>. E o .. o .. ii II Q. "- II ;; .. 6- !:! B l: .!I OJ > .. .. .. .:: I- ... " 0 c a> .. c ';: j.E~ " ~ 0. to C II -seF >'; ~ i ci c c 0. E A ~ e .. " o :J 'tI u1;l] 1:: .. 'D o Q I:; .; ill t: tJ c: ! u .. IJ CI ; ; S DI..c:: !! Jl c c .. .::: ]~:: .. 0,>0 ij~~ ! .. .. oS! 11-50 > .!!.c>1I ~"i'i.8 :." ;.s ~ ! u .. U ~ ';= ~ l!!!&' .. Do... Q. o !! ~ : = iU Ib I) oS! ~ -5 g ~ ::! lJ> {l J: c.s II g-.= ..., :- u.sQu U ::::J t ft "blOC,) oS !! a.; I ~ i = fl I " t: oS e&. ~""~QQ. 8,g-s't:i E b j; 8."fi a.. ~ ..JII!:C Gji~oJ: '5 "tI -;: t: W\ Sl.5~j ~ 6 i ~. ~ f:=;i .:I ~ ~ Q. IJ ..l!""'Dco.o a !.6 0 ].J!a.~" .c:.c.:~"3 !;~~,gt J:'a~::2 .ga.oo:1 -0>1:0 l!,..t:2U 3 E &,'s .0"' - 0 u G~D.~o e ~ " u c ,g...tS.;!'i : :'';.5~ .1I'El!l ~ iisll.2-8e ". ti!iP &I . ~]1It:Q.8 ~~o':~.s ij.:€ c :! 0 ii ! 11.2 .Il .E > SC'UEIIIII J: II .. ,.. j '0 .!] ~ ~ &I tlI ~ 1I~,.;oS'S II C "'D C .. J: 'c.B"JII:J:! I-t'iii~1;1I =ij.ii~l-5 - ~ " ii " c S .. J! -5 -5 i ,.. 'ii E o U S .. II " a. r:I. .. .. ; .. :J 0" ~ " U J: ..!l ii > .. .. II .c I- s .. I: .. .. c , a. a. II " -5 - o ! 'ii " "0 " -5 t .c .. o s,; .. " ~ B :oJ! 5.!! > 1:: " "- o C. " oS o a E ~ ... ".c ,..u =:;: ~ l: :l I: E~ o II 0 .o.l: ~j C.l: a .~ I c 8~ J: .. ~ .Ii > .11 -5 .: II ~ o ~ II 'fi .. .J1. ~ III U ,& .. "C... .. 0 ~ .. c ;; a::: ~ J 1~ &I " "Q tiI 8 ~ J: .!l 8 ;; c > JI II I: .l: " \00 1: E3 ... o E u .E ~ J: 01 .;: 'ii " 1! u e u tiI u .l: .. U .; oS! > o c a ~ 'tI ~ 'ii &I ~ 3 C .! II > &I .; -S -g .. " o. .. tile .,!! ~ c D. :! J! 1;11 " ~ ~ . to> "C _ .11 e.'5 U ~ of aJ N en " ~ > .. c o 0. :s > 'E E .;. ._ 1:: Q.~ "tJ 0 ::: ii. II .. .o.c .. .. o .. c.,!! .J! J: 8 a c ! .9 Q > II ~ c ~ 0, ~ o 01- 'S ~ 1:' .. - c.: " t :: &. c '!la. ] U C III A~ ;; ! u II ::I u [6> II ~ ! _ il :! :: 'I'-:~.lt_'"'" ~.. I -' .J~~,I. ~1\.,'1I w ,,"UANCE AJ"'U~J\ I II.},. . 50.00 Z.'1~'1.3' . PROPERTY OWNER(SJ NAME &.ADDRESS: REPRESENTATIVEIS) (if MY) NAME & ADDRESS: BarQer Realty Y James N. Powell 3839 Fourth Street ,St. PetersburQ. FL 33703 I V It q~ " I .,..J Powell, Carney, ~Ioore. lIucks & Olson. r.A. P.O. Box 1689 St. Petersburg, FL 33731-1689 lCLErl-IONE: 1813) 894-6500 TELEPHONE: I 81 J I 898-9011 ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 26034 N. US 19 NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPUCADLE): PEACHES .. . , ZONING DISTRICT~ ell . . LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: CTS .. ,(~r LAND AR~ ~.O moL<!9res I LEG^LDESCRIPT10NOFSUBJECTPROPERTY~--L)arrylts Subdivision. tJnplated Lot 1. Less RD R/W Plat Book.84, Page 78-79 . DESC.RIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: PARCEL NUMBER: 31 I 28 I 16 I 20345 I 000 I 0010 (This Information Is available horn your tax receipt or contact Pinellas Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462.3207. If more than one parcel number, attach 8Y~ x " Inch sheet) .' 'j':,:.:1 , . '"\ . r,,! , OJ ~.... I.. I> . t ,:t i I :~\ ...."jl it i; l~d~ I ~;: I ", lilt; B . B . $.' '(":'.\,1 North: USlness East: USlness ,'...r-i:l"q'. South: Business West: Business .. ':I;.l~;"-. J, '. .' t.l.', ". . I t ,r~; ,Ii:. '.1, VAR~NCE(S) REQUEST (If Variance to 7 year amortization requirement. refer to Sec. 134.0~~?;~i>5~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~ii~~~'m~~i'miiim~~m,'mtmr~~~ A variance( s) to permit nonconforming signage to remain: (1) Variance of iJ.}.2~sq... it. to permit a' I:ol:al o[ /63.2sq. [t. lll:l:ached al"(~a slgnage (J::nt:erpdH~ 1\(1. frontage) (f,):;,:t~r~iance 01 I . ~"{ ,I. ,..1\/' ,,>{ .,: , n t tac C slgn to perml tat tac le S 19ns nn o. ,...a slgns to pc rml t .81gn8', O' a 5 tgnage '. $ "!.!"~ '. . type (u.~. 'l~ trontllge) (j) Vanal\ce ot91.2~_ It. to permlt,..:n7sq. tt.:,a~t,acl1ed area . ( . \ ......., ~. I \l.;.,~\. 'l;i EllgnBgc \U.S. 19 frontage;. ~",\~ -<f>. 'J' .. - .> t' ">:' )./:.:Kt.: . 11.'1'11" ::. ~f ~,~l(~," . I. ~\ ) ~ I: 1-: ": ,',', '/ . < '.1. il. .11, I i.'.~'~:,~~:' ~: . :. 1 ~. ,. :,' . .. REASON FOR REQUESTING VARtANCE(S): (Refcr to Standmds for Approval, next page) Peaches feels strong1"y that the building murals used at all properties are an al-t form which s~ts the mood for their b~siness. All murals a~e desiQned after a music type and a'~e not meant to be used as an advert i sement for a product. Peaches has used mural decor throuqhout the United States for over 20 ITars vdth the understandinq from municipalities that'murals are an art form. We see no difference between bell towers, prototype structures ie Taco [Jell and murals as an architectural feature for a QiVen business property. corn UW[D ON IlCVF.I\SE GIP!: . . STANDARDS Fon APPROVAL: A varhmce sholl not be granted by the City Commission unless the application and evidence presented clearly support the following conclusions: ' f 1) The varlonce requested erlses from a condition which Is uniQue to the property in Question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly IIpplicbble to the zoning district nor created by an action' or lictlons of the property owner, predecessor In title, or the !lppHcant. Any mistake made In the execution of 1I bullding permit or work performed without the benefit of Ii permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a varhmce. . 121 The pertlculllr physico! $urroundlngs, shape or topographical conditions of the property Involved and the strict eppllcatlon of the provisions of this development-code would result in on unnecessary hllrdship upon the appUcent. 131 . The ~~r1once Is the minimum necessory to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to In preceding recital "2" for the pUrpose of making reasonable use of the land, (41 The request fOI" 1I valiance Is ",01 based primarily upon the desire of the nppllcont to secure II greater financial return from the IHOPt'rty. (51 The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or Improvements In the neighborhood in which the property is located. 161 The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation 10 adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community. substantially Increase the congestion in the public streets, : increase the danger of fire, endanger the public salety in any way, or substantinlly diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. 17) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health. safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. IB) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and Intent of this development code. (SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVEI: '" L. h - . 'f Before me. the undersigned authority. personally appeared ,Jrj Jl\J'.5 flI, (}~v.Q1 J deposes and states the matters and facts set out above are true and correct to the bes.L I his/her knowledge and belief. '{ SWOlll lo lllU.! sulJscriIJed beft.lre me this ;:?liJ._ d~.,. of MJle,ll1ky ,._--.:..A,~., 19 92. .' X'- ~ C(}/2 ( ~~~arygpi~ ' '. NOTE: pnOPEn~ OWNER OR nErnESENT^TIVE MUST ATTEND tlEJ\J1ING. ~,..~.,. P{j~ OPll1CIAI. NOTARY SEA\.' o ('.. I.INDA C JOHNSON ~ ~7f ~ CO....ISSION Nu...eE" ~ ''\CIT /1:, 'I(' CC166825 7{<. . o,f MY CO.....ISSION uP, OF F\.. JAN.~ 21 1996 Rev, 12/91 ., " BUILDERS · DEVELOPERS · John W. · John Wm. · Michael E. AUgust 28, 1992 Mr. Bill Henn Peaches Music store 26034 U. S. Highway 19 North Clearwater, FL 34623 Dear Bill: ~RLrt'~ Mlchael .E. Barger Partner Re: Sign variance Application Peaches Entertainment corporation 26034 U. s. Highway 19 North,. Clearwater, Florida , . ~ I with regard to the variance application referenced above, lpiease be advised that Barger Interests, property o~ner, her~by i~l~ . authorizes Peaches Entertainment corporation to make thei;~~uest fo: variance. Please let me know 'if you need anything e,~~~~[1 thls regard ~ . . tJ/(~l!Jb~'.~' J( \1X,',t ~~, Ji ~ ~:fi'j' ~~:iJi "'!i'lifll ;;!I~.'. : '.l~,:. '!t- ~! ~ \1 .t\l L~ l, r" ': .;.1~~"JI1"\'! , t1tt'll n ,L'l ,,':.'*I.,f, '~;: ,:, 'i,.r.tl/IJ;,: \' ~ ~;~'J J:A(t,. , '~~pl~V'''!' J" ;~.\~If' ~\,l},f-:tl'.': '," !. ~ iJ 1\1'1' . . ~ r J~ 'i,,!~d( . .t, r.. 'I il~l I . "Ill': ~ t< I. ~ f I:, . {V ;~f' .'~1;,~:I~ : r ~"..l I~, 'Ir.l~ , '.:;~I~ ~[;':.; 1. .,,~:\:h d~'Irn1~. Jt .~I't ,It I" I' . . ~~r~ r,'1 .'i~. ""N'~l'. ,',. The, foregoing instrument was acknowledged befo~e me thi~ .V1i~H{' , day of August, 19~2, by Michael E. Bar~er" as Partner of, :~~~~er Interests, a Flor~da general partnersh~p, on behalf of the,l::" partnership. He is personally known to me. sincerely yours, BARGER INTERESTS, a Florida general partnership MEB/jks STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF PINELLAS NOTARY PUBLIC: lu;,Ll , y K .#t~fanlck . Nol;uy Public, SI~le or FlOlid~ ~l Large . Com&is~:don Exp~res: My Commi5sfcn EXlJlrC5 APR, ?, 19G3 Barger Investments, Inc. · Barger h~terests · Mid County, Inc. . ' 300 First Avenue Soulh, Suite 500 · P.O. Box 2244 · Sl. Pelersburg, Florida 33731.2244 1813)821-5421 · Fnx 1813} 822-526,2 . ' , . , . JB)tai1f~<e 1I' REALTY a PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COMPANY The Second Floor 3839 Fourth Street North St. retenburg, Florida 33703 . I r.o. Dux 7697 St. Pelmbu% FllirlJ:I 33734 (813) 894.6500 FAX 822-7141 AugUSt: 24, i992 Mr. Bill Schwalback Federal Sign 125 North 120th Street Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53226 \ . RE: Peaches .Entertainment Corporation, US 19' and Enterprise Clearwater, Florida , . , ,. BY: To Whom I t May Concern: , "I H.'lc Federal Si~n is authorized to repres~nt the property owne~,~a~~~r Interests J.n regards to the Peaches sign var i.ance for the t"a.BlJve referenced property.. . i~~V)tlHW~~.~' : ~ J~"l.!l\~'\ 1 , Please call if you, have questions ~ 1"1 ~!\ I-I" . "~~~ ~ ~JI: sJ.' ncere 1y, , ~Ht; ~'~i.:;V:', ~n.f1.":f. ,.~,-F ~ J \,"";'!,l',~ 1(: t" , : 4':.(~~ ~ g; lP MANAGEMENT COMPANY ~\~f1f,liffh'(',~: I {)~!ift~~\il~; . 1"W9,U~R't~.~t .'rUl~~i~~~~:~1 !{l; '~'" !fur ~ UI ' " !~~~~f;~~;~:r(:~.j , :?Md'I~ :~. ~ t "'f;rt~: '\\.(1). , "I('~1 .\~j\,,:,., . 1 .~! .. ~~ \...\ ': ,~l~r~; :'ra,I~.~('t.: ." +~'J 'I :tr.~ ;'I:.\~~' ~': ,. r" '.:-k'~ ('.,' . ' }'~;rl~.~M\', ~ . ',t.;' 'lE~.j~~ ~n' !, ' I. f~.. ~~ h r.t '. ';' ,.~ty.1r : " :',:f.,., .' President . . " . '~ ' i;",,:!. /l~,~ , , : ~ ' .:'1:. , , Acknowledged: BARGER INTERESTS, A FLOHJDA GENERAL PARTNERSHIP BY: ?z~fY1~ - Mi&hael E. Bar~~=Genera 1. Partner GCP/1m I', . .. " \ , " I .' .' I '. , I'. i"~>'''-'':' c:~".~~.;.. ~. , ,'. POWELL. CARNEY, MOOREt HUCKS &. OLSON, EA. .1 \ I ATTORNEYS AT LAW BARNETT TOWER ONE PROGRESS PLAZA SUITE 1210 ST. PETERSBURG, FLORIDA 33701 MARY JO CARNEY BR'IAN T. FITZGERALD JOEL B. GILES . JOHN CURTIS HUCKS ANNE S. MASON s. HELEN MOORE STEWART O. OLSON . . JAMES N. POWELL DON DOUGLAS RAMSAY MAILING ADDRESS: ' P.O. BOX 16B9 ST. PETERSBURG, FLORIDA 33731:1689 November 24, 1992 TELEPHONE 8Ia.898.9011 FACSIMILE 813.898.9014 , ' CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT Mr. Earl Dussault . Zoning Technician Planning & Development City of Clearwater P.O. Box 4748. . Clealwater, FL 34618-4748' I . . I I ,1\;: ',:ji!t~,. . . . , ' -.'11" '/ . . . · r. ~ It. ;.~ ) , , . ~If I;f.\(ri~ ~"!i~(i\:'\" ':'l.,f,~'~r:-' , Dear Mr. Dussault: I '~[{)~'1"[~:( . ~tr". " . ., " ~J,r..h~!( . . As we dlscussed, [ represent Peaches Entertainment Corporation with resp~.~f~~ "an application for variance with respect to the murals on their building. Please 'flnchllie , con:pleted si~ed applicatio?, as well as the $50.00 application fee. Also et:lcl~~~~j'.~r~ a certIfied copy of the deed to the property, a notarized ~etter from the owner auill~1J~~hg "Peachesu to make the application, a letler authorizing Federal Sign to r~present t~~\.~Wl!er, and an elevation sketch shown the sign locations. If you need any additional infqFlti~tlon or if I can give any help in 'processing this application, I would appreciate itif y,dM~Wp~ld let me know. ' ' . 'jt\i~~{r~~l:\ ,~ ~~ ~J!;7~1~" ~; ~ . ;1~!).'~ \.';I';I;!'. " .",... . c~i.l T 1. ~I ,L < ' "~/f;.'~""~ ~~>" . "~ ),1.1, I ,,. '; > I .'i' t ~I.... it:);- r \'. ';~.!' "'~?'~: <i Re: Peache~. - Sign Variance Application I' Thanks very much. [look fonvard to hearing from you. . Sincerely, . POWELL, CARNEY, MOORE, I-lUCKS & OLSONt P.A. , , '10, A7 Stew.art O. Olson SOO/kb Enclosures ' pcahC!l\duSUUl t.1 .,. I. J-:' ~~I~ g ~ d w t:i 2 w ~ w ex ~ ~ffiaF= I I. i 1"i1 ~. ~ t~ '=I ~ ~~ ~ ~ ------ ffi1t o ~ c::r d w w 2 ... ~ .r5 ~ t13 ~ 3 ..j - ~ ...a .r.. ~! . ~t ~'I ~~. ~ I % ii: It :n .!~ R I I I I -- I. I ~ (- \_- C ~ ~ ' i ~; ~ ~ i~ a i~ L. ~P=J . ~pc:d, . I (-- C ~ .._.~- 1\ :. 11~\1.t1 ~ ;\ ! !I : ~' ..', .~ i tt .' .... 1 11 f -:;;; =-- L ~ , 'f"1~ :1 [) !;; ~ I '; ;'~ ~ a: 2 w IX ....., 0 IX W \" - ~ U) ~ ~ o fa 2 :::I liigEB ::JcWu u ex c cl 'h or- o m 'f" ..~t. "1- !!.... ~ }I -14-t'-'" - .ll ." C o "P ~ o e- o tJ iii c 01 U5 'I " i -z {) ti ~ ~ ~ '...., ~ 2 in ~l"l ~ii~~ ..J ~ ex "0 0:: ~ W2 l5 Q,,, "in w~:~ u.cno . ~',!,i . 'l ~ ~~r.. 0: UJ I 2 w ~ ... au W (3 a. c UJ ~ t; it ). ). "en t- f- a u is <r - .j\ ~ ~ en . . . .... . ,... . ..... .,. , . . f~ :: ~: ~ E,I (j ~; ,; . . ::1 'I; " ,. ~ "\... ... ,.. ...., "", ~ , ~'" -#.~'". ..."\r -'" ~............. ......'"\.-1.1. ~~~1... ~~~ ~- . .1 ~ ~. . . .. ~ \\()() ~ ' !'i . ",(j"'i~ , ~, " .. ':oJ'\l ~ ,~ ,~ ' )'r: ~,~ ~~ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ It' ~ ~ ' IJ ~~~ ~ \; ~ h~ .., . ~ ti ~ & '''\,.'1 ~. ~ " l\{ ~,,\ l \I 'j .t.J ~ \,'~ ~\I \ .S-s.....,.,. ---.....,.....,.. <~ ". . '.. , l:l \:I. .\ 0; ~" .r ~ ~. r... . \ \~ ,\ .......,.~~ . . . LI:,,~ ..:J--........,....._ --"" \ V,'lIA-EtE" iT' C'cu"~'1 'lo' ii -pArGet. 4- . ~e-pL,6.'- c~ SQUARE 92-07 ~o\ ",,'0 'j,.tt'o "\ - RoAd . I~ . ~t\l rncc RMI6 ~rL ~~ e-;co Z 'Ja "0 /H '--1 \J A ME: "6 A~e (""" \......... e AL.TLj I e PC ,'\ r S ,/ \--0 '-' H~: ~ \ 3 V:#: S2._c~. PUB Lie H EA R IN G D ATE: ATLAS PAGE:.2.s?cSEC: S~_ TWP: :2-.B_S. RGE: \ Co E. ~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION ~ , ,. r-. ... - .., o '.0., ""Ii' , -_/ ---;?_. ~r~ la tY. U ~ > -. In =- .,,""! I I I I fOl\l1:-lOlfl ,'7 I 0 I . I 1 , , , ......- >. ., m . U ... . ,.. .... ." .' .. 0 '':/ .J: ., <Yo .. ~ 0 ;; ... - ... :J 1..' o .., ,~ u '" ~ ;: .1 .... t, :. ..., ..: . ." 'TJ .~ -'rlf :J:l;>;l~ I;) .' 0- (::\.0 " .... 'J :l l:;, 0:0 IIc:-. 'U 0: , :.t.'! ":11:1 .... .. ''l 0 '" c ., f) .. " Q '-' I " '-, ',.. J .. '--- / Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum cz. Item # Haetlng Date: J/1V/1t( SUBJECT: Variance(s) to the Sign Regulations; 23988 U.S. 19; (Owner/Applicant); Earl A. Wesson (Representative). , Chevron U.S.A. Inc./Chevron & Dunkin Donuts (SV 92-95) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Deny the height variance of six feet from the 20 feet permitted to allow a freestanding sign with a height of 26 feet for the "Dunkin Donuts" sign on property identified as Blackburn's Subdivision, east 180 feet of Lot 1. and part of vacated Barrett Road, for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 H8). Approve the following variances: (1) a variance of one freestanding sign from the permitted two freestanding signs to allow a total of three such signs, and (2) an area variance of 64.7 square feet from the permitted 112 square feet to allow a total of 176.7 square feet of freestanding sign area on U.S. 19, on property identified as Blackburn's Subdivision, east 180 feet of Lot 1, and part of vacated Barrett Road, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8). o ond that the appropriate officials ba authorized to execute soma. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to permit the "Dunkin Donuts" freestanding sign to remain: (1) a variance of one freestanding sign from the permitted two freestanding signs to allow a total of three such signs, (2) an area variance of 64.7 square feet from the permitted 112 square feet to allow a total of 176.7 square feet of freestanding sign area on U.S. 19, and (3) a height variance of six feet from the permitted 20 feet to allow a freestanding sign with a height of 26 feet. It should be noted that the applicant's request is for an area variance of 86.25 square feet; however, staff finds that the actual variance should be 64.7 square feet (90.45 square feet + 86.25 square feet - 112 square feet). The subject property is located on the southwest corner of U.S. 19 and Sunset Point Road and is in the Highway Commercial zoning district. There are two freestanding business establishments on this N/A ilIA N/A IliA ~7l-:- ilIA Orlol"ntrllD Dellt: CENTRAL PERM I T 'ING j;S CDltl: Ruvlow.d by: Legal Budget Purchosin9 Risk Hgmt. CIS ACH Other Totol CDmmlnion Aclion: o Approved o Approved w/conditlons o DenIed o Continued to: Usor 00111: Current Fisca\ Yr. Ci AdvQrllud: Dntc: pop~r: TAMPA TRIBUNE [] Not R~quired AII.clQd Purlin e Not i fi ~d [] Not Required Funding SQurcQ: o Copl till Imp. [] Operating [] Other Anllchmenll: APPLI CA T I ON VARIAIlCE IJORKSflEET MAPS [] None A\IIIIII\lIlal;lIn Clldu: o Pdnted on recycled papel' SV 92-95 Pago 2 property: a Chevron sorvice station, and a Dunkin Donuts restaurant. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. . U.S. 19 SIGNS Sign 1/Chevron Sign 2/Dunldn Donuts Information Existing/Proposed Permitted Existing Permitted Type of Sign Freestanding Yes Freestanding *No Orientation of sign U.S. 19 Yes U.S. 19 Yes (if permitted) Area 99 sq. ft.l90.45 112 sq. ft. 86.25 sq. ft. 112ft. (if sq. ft permitted) Setbacl{ Not givenl7. 5 ft. 5 ft. 9 ft. 5 ft. (if permitted) Height 40 ft. + /20 ft. 20 ft. 26 ft. 20 ft. (if permitted) ""'Only one freestanding sign is permitted for each lot. SUNSET POINT RD. SIGN \. . Information Proposed Permitted Type of Sign location/orientation of sign Area Freestanding Sunset Point Rd. 82.75 square feet 5 feet 20 feet. Yes Yes 112 square feet 5 feet 20 feet Setbaclc Height ' Staff .Comments/Proposed Conditions: The property is owned by Chevron U.S.A. and a portion of the property is leased to Dunkin Donuts. Since the property has frontage on two major thoroughfares, the code allows two freestanding signs - one on eachthoroughfare. However, because there arc two freestanding businesses fronting on U;S. 19, the applicant is requesting that each be permitted a sign for U.S. 19. Two new signs are proposed for tho Chevron station, which is the corner busiriess. One will be placed along Sunset Point Rd. and will meet all code requirements. The other will be placed along U.S. 19, and will replace the existing I,igh-riso sign. However, before the Chevron sign can be replaced, the Dunkin Donut sign would need to be romoved, or a variance granted. The property is unique because these businesses function as two sepnrnte entities with soparate buildings and parking. It would paso on extremo hardship for either business to lose an idontification sign nlong U.S. 19. Howevor, there doos not appoar to bo grounds for SV 92-95 Page 3 allowing tho Dunkin Donuts sign to bo higher than other signs in the area or in the City. The applicant contends tho sign will cause a traffic hazard if lowerod to meet the City's height limitation. In the event the sign is lowered, a portion of the sign panel would be positioned ten feet ovor a paved portion of parking lot. The City Traffic Engineer indicates that fourteen fee't is the appropriate minimum clearance and recomm~nds that, if the sign is lowered to ten feet over grade, the traffic island below the sign be extended either by painting and placing flex posts, or curbing. City staff will include this as a condition of approval for the requisite sign permit. (It is not included as a condition of this variance because staff recommends denial of , the height variance.) SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing Land Uses North South East West Shell gas station (across Sunset Point Rd.) Burger King Spur gas station Fortune Bank While the existence of the Dunkin Donuts sign is in character with the signage permitted for the surrounding commercial uses, the additional height of this sign is not in character with other freestanding signs. The granting of the height variance will detract from the surrounding businesses that have signage conforming to the height requirements, permit an unfair advertising advantage to this establishment, and negatively impact the overall appearance of the community. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's request for a height variance daDS not meet the standards. In particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully met: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title,. or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without tho benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations Wllich support ,tho granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, sllape or topographical conditions of tho property involved and tho strict application of tho provisions of this development code would result in an unnocassary hardship upon tho applicant. (3) The varianco is the minimum necessury to overcomo tho unnocessary hmdship reforred to in preceding rocital "2" for tho purpose of making reasonablo usa or tho land. SV 92-95 Page 4 (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return for the property. '(5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the .public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order, convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance dosired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this developm,ent code. ' , Relevant Previous Decisions by the Com.mission; FREESTANDING SIGN HEIGHT . CASE /I ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES .MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION. DATE SV 91-02 251.91 U.S. 19 Dimmi tt Cadillac 16.5 ft. add'l to allow 3/21/91 36.5 ft.IDenied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. 19 Village at 12.3 ft. add'l to allow 1/2/92 Countryside 36.3 ft./Denied SV 92-03 2301 Sunset Point Great Western 6 ft. add'l to allow 12 1/16/92 Rd. Bank ft./ Approved SV 92-28 1290, 92, 94 Stewart Title 2 ft. add'l to allow 10 12/17/92 Court St. ft./Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S. 19 Public Storage 15.1 ft. add'l to allow 3/25/93 35.1 ft./Approved SV 92~O5 20162 U.S. 19 Suncoast Inn 1 ft. add'l to allow 25 ' 517/92 ft./Denied Ln en I N en > en c.r: w co ~ ::) Z w tJ) <t (.) ..... W w :J: en ~ c.r: o :: w (.) 2: <( - a: <( > I ~ ... c WI.... a. ' llg R G,,2 .5 8 "" ..~~.. ~ c 8.~ CJ! c....~ Q]~ 0"O.2'5"O!! :i~~: a.". ~ c . =:s C U .. cJl811:,il: ~.c JI CF~]"! lie:: E.2' jn .;-"'::=~~E~ :;~..~~~g~:2~a ~t: ...c"U-n:;:i...i c:~~~ ~~ !~':-: s- 2g.~ 8.1: 3li:~4tl: =~~2B.5I""CiX.2 tH~c~I:..lI!!::"t:8: o c g.. Q~ ~ ~ m M _ ~ .c.l:l..1: CilJi.c.cil "';cBu~!!J)J::='5 .i; ..sa-=.I: -a ~); S I) I:c~~.!!J!j..5lIl"" .2'11 0: I:illl]~]-'; ..:J1rl:g"'-a"-I:;'" lIo~C1,..ft::C...ti=-Ci "~I: 'l:l ..I) >.~ ~1i.2...!:;ceSt:D ct..~e.;g~.2!!.C; iiu;E"c~~~1)1: ~!!I:"F~.Ea.:a.g t: CI,J: tJ'tj CI 0 .. ~ctg.~;;-gl-S~ t)g.r;::~.2lC;c""'-S !!.o~u~:~"'~ .cJl ...c.c.c ~-., iI ecn :Ft:-rl;';;IIl~..": 1-D.;~E~~~g~~ 1)11 Ol.cI) 3 RI)_:J- > 0 CJ .... - u..5!" "U Oli .liIl:C"cSCll">"':c E: ....si Ii~:: 3..2 ~~ ~~:~~~~ij .r.= u I: >.2-cn >"C~..... 8:~:0;::"~ ~ c;.o.c..... Q,::I_II:C...J:;ClUiCO .'lllll:;~.c..~~:;~ ~; !B"i]-s~.:.: ~ ~ .g 11'6 oS c !! B "J! ~t: iC'i "C.- " . :::1Il i~ Ii II :c g g ~ ~ g ~: .. .. II .c : 5 ~ " .. .c .E ; II j-go .. X. ii ; ~ ~ ~.JI a a. n. :: ii ~ tilfi.s c .. ~ > (; :g~8: o n. :J ~ 2 .. .. a.. 'S '0 J! .: gi~ ..- iJ!.~ >t.c> " .. " II 1! 3: .c iI 0 I-.c.c .. "0 o .. 01 .. '5 .: - E o n. .. D Cii .8 t "5'l:l ; ~!! u oS 3'0 2 " ~CE !. ~ ~ 8.~]: oS a.. ~ ~ .. " D.c.c .. .. .. g. 0 ~ .ccn. ".S! ::I r:ii~ c .Y " tij D.."E c n. II ::I Il .c 2 '0 >- ~ 0;: ~ !. -= : OIl " .. .2.s~ f'g g 11. OIl ::I .5 ~ ; ]~Ji ~.s~ 11.>"' 01 t: ~ t: x.~ ~ a ~ ll..a .. "' "'''lJ ~ c ..5l ~ .8 = I: II ~ t c 3: ~.~ " .. .c II -.c II - .. .. :I "' 3 ~ 01 :J .D"C -'c ,g:i .5 t.I E; g ~ J!~ - .. i~ ,,1! .c II ~ = ...c ~ u J!: .. OIl .. :J ~ II C"Dl !! .~ II .. U "' J:: U ~.. OIl ::I > 0 OlE ~ ~ II ~-5 .. - "l! 0 II " ..: S ~.!! Il..c :. ~ 8 ~ ~ = c ~ ::I III .s~ .. OIl E E g Q ~ ~ ~ 8- s :; >0. ~ " . '5 ~ (; ~ - C I E f'I 'e '5 c .u 'E ~ ill g' -5:g ill U ill a Ji g J! u u .: .!l ~ > u ~ ~ II 1:1 a~] " .11'5 oS.. ,J:: .. .= 8 l [ > ~ a..l; Eg B 1! I) C f .~ Il .. X--s g-:; .. - c ~ ~i _"C : 'j ~ !! G ~ OIl .. "C "lJ I) C i c 8 tJlJl ~!!.c 01 .. .c > :0"- C II .!I .! ~ : ... 3 .. III 01 I) .5..c c ~ i ~ 0> 0 ill .. "C ; ~ 8 8::1:] ] "C Ii Q ~ > >'U.E ,,1:.2' .c: :3 iU I- .. .c o .. .. C .. U I:: n. 11. .. 01 .c .. ... D 01 ~ .. 01 "C u oS .: D 11. :J ... 'E II >- .5 t: ax. 'l:l 0 ~ D.. .. .. .l:l.c .. .. I) .. c:,s .!I I: 3 ~ c ~ .!l ;; "'ij > '0 iI ~ .e~ .. .. ~ c; :J .. [tv II 01 " t: ~ _ a or u - .. .Il '5 c I) .. tIO Jt z a. 'l:l C II OIl III II ~ ao R"~ " .c .2' ".2'. ; ~ CI .c .. Ji ~'5E ~ - I) .. 1)- :! at C U Ji B ~ 1: = . f! CI Uao.c :E t) ... ;~.s l: .. ~~. 5 f ~ ~ ~ E 'it.E"]~ J! - U III :: 11 " N .. ~.c C : E':: ~~ E ~ g'] 8 ~ =; :s ...11 ; C U 01 .. .. E n. : !l 0 Q,. II I: ... a !:! E - II) "'"80-5 GtJSt; o-5]G 8~wa. c,sr.;.E :! "C ~ ~ .!! ~ 8 ~ IlC .... c- :~~g, ..c U II iU I-a.>c "lJ C II .. .. " ~ ;; "lJ (; .. .c ... .. a. 2 .Il "lJ ~ Ii D .. ~ 0. "C D U a .E .. E ~ x.~ i ~ .c I) .. u ]j. ,21" .c " II '> =0 II "' .c.c .. .. ..... c I) !l'> .. U CIt; C .. -.!I 1 .. ,g &: '" 8 e. .. .2 .a ....t= s ~ ~ tJ ; g g ~.!!.!l ~ oS G II .. > ::!l: oS!' =:~ .. II .c I: U .. ,g]:\ ~ C ~ II > :I ~.s:c - . III 1:"lJ- [81! :J 0 c llc~ " .. II 8.~.s .E.g(; .8;; ~ t~.g s ~ "l! '6 l ~ ] g ;.p.u ..r:: ,,__.!! ,io':-S .ccu:€ i ~ ~ s A]'5~ ~ci.!!!! .. ~ > .. "' .. ~ .l:lE l g .:!: 0 U oE::I:.E ~ ~ I 1:1 t: oS &.I 0 ~ .. II ~ 8: :tg-S~ ~ 2uo8.-5 D.~ .,jt:C ~,i-!oJ ...-a~J:., 21~o~ m c: 0 .... c; ]-2t;]i! s1!~8.: J!~"CDO~ .E: ... ~ Ji ~ .2 JI g,;g 'ifi ~j~ c~l:;2 .S!n.DO~ ~:'~0:8 5"E"'!!.. Q..g.a~ 1I~a.~C; Ec.."c 2:;S~1i ~oo-5~ ~~...!i.. .~ L~ ~ ~ "'D .- ..... !Z CJ .,1!UI::c...; -;; Q G II) 1:1 g 1.1 II.. Q ~ ~.scSo~ e'i;.g~=> cuE .. .. t II c. > c: ... c' cello .S 1! II '" " c ti Ii >- J:;.5 >c.a~:c ".ll "lJ III ;:J II ,c....~uo::;. t- m=[.z:...... ~!a.t:til !:UUClJ:; ~ II ~ " II .. -E ~ B ~ 0; .. J~ ]os .. l!. .. II ~'-S D I) c g .Ii.!! ~.a S~ Q II 1! = .. .. ~ g :J! .c" ~S .c ~ - II II C c 1 .g tl ~~ II .. " c. ~ a ~ u .c Q 2..a !; ; .g u :J.5I :?J1 ~ ~ S 8. .: 0 ~ a .S ~ 01 .. 'g.c >u =2 ~ l u .: ~~ " 0 .a-e .. I) g ~ R .i ~ ~.s .!l,5 Ii > .Il '5 c .2 01 ';. '5 tD .~~ ~:6 ;~ g'S ..... II:; II Q o <: ~ >~ 0"; a.~t;> n. E III II ;Ei'5 ; 3 ~ i ::I tJ .c n.. [oS ;.s 'i-S-:o ; ~ a i to. ;.E.s ii.. . E a.i;'ii lig,,,> i:~:; F.i-s.g~ l E .l:l .. " D il..1: ~-:~ ~ ..! u t"'" .... ~ Il 0 ~ ; ,E >- &I "tI C C -<: ..2 l :>-;>- o ~ g, .: oc.1:11 .!:O 2 8 ,5 c' ~ tJ ~ !t:;.! ~~~=~ ~ :.c : ,9 t) ., ....:ii c.. 22.s[~ ~ II 'E! D ~ ..':! a .. Ji .::: " u .c .!! :c :J n. u =a- ~ 'e = E Il E ~D " u I! " ~'5 1"0 :; 01 C a j::::t: J ~ ]] ;; " .. c '1:1 ~ 1.l 0 I: .9 ~ i; c :0 oS! u c F ~ c E 8 ... o 'E u .E "C C 01 ;: 1i. II ] .. l: " DO .. '5 " .i .S! > '0 c c J "0 .~ .. " "lJ B J: .!l i; > .. 01 is-g ,- u I) .. m c .g E 0: n. .. I) 0.;; .. > F{l _.!l e!-S lC fi! ~ ~ .. .. .: E ... u o ~ g-a ';: E c .- II ~ ~ I) lll> U t: t:x. @[ ." . , I Rec~bt II t..e..f::k-4 I '.5"0 CITY OF CLEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPUCAT10N . I VII Q:;;).-9s-j PROPERTY OWNER(S) NAME & ADDRESS: REPRESENTAT1VE{SI (if any) NAME &. ADDRESS: Chevron U.S.A. Inc. P.O. Box 1706 Atlanta; Ga. 30301 End 1\. '~(!sson 299 9 St. N. St. Petersburg, FL 33731-0683 TELEPHONE: {404 1984-3050 .~ ... TELEPHONE: (813 .1822-4715 ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 23988 U.S. 19 N: Clearwater, F1 NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPUCABLE): Chevron &. Dunkin Donuts ZONING DISTRICT: CH LAND. USE CLASSIFJCAT10N: t-rF" LAND AREA: 40 t 740 Sq. Ft. LEGAL DESCRlPTJON OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: Blackburn's Sub. E. 180' of Lot 1 &. Part Vacated St. T",,,,c: I1rl PARCEL NUMBER: -0.6..._ J '}Q J T (, I nqn77 J __OD..O..-. I 01 nn (This Information is available from your tax receipt or contact Pinellas Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462-3207. If more th an one parcel number, attach 8~ x 11 inch sheet) DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: r,:1.'~ ~t:ntinn F. Or-hpr r.nmm'l 1T~~s South:Shopping Center East:.Jia,.s Sr-:'l.tinn F. Other COmln I] tJses West: Shopping Center VARIANCE(S) REQUEST (If Variance to 7 year amortization requirement, refer to Sec. 134.015): REQUEST REFERS TO TilE DUNKIN DONUTS FREESTANDING SIGN - .~ ~~~~-~_._. . _....""-~..... ........- . . .. . ..-.---- . ~ . .. REASON FOR REOUESTlNG VARIANCE(S): (Refer to Standards for Approval. next page) SEE ATTACIIED .. I;"" CONTINUED ON REVEnSE GIOE " . , , , , 1 ' . , ","\ :' , ~. } l . " , .. . .' ~ " , -" , . . , , I. I ;. < , . ~: -> J ". ., " , : '. t' "t . ., . ~. L, . . ., ' I .. , , ~ I ..1 ~..... , . . f~:~t .'(.; I ;' '+~: l' . . ~ . .' . i. >, ~ ~.. ~ . E. 299 Ninlh SlrcCI North 51. P'3\!',1I5burg. Florida 33131 ..ce83 . (8131822047\ ~. . 'i . , i~~"::~~~~;~,;:~O~'~~~;'~;S. ]NC. . L'.CEr ISEO PoEAL ~ST ME BHOKE.R Aile DE'IE\.CPER IB _ICiI", . '. September 7, 1993 ,: l . Mr. Hark Hively. city of Clearwater Planning services Division P~O. Box' 4148 Clearwate~, FL 34618-4748 Re': S\792'-95 l I , '. ,I. , . Dear. Hark, I am amendin.g the rec,ommendation. .. . I above referel1ced variance _ request. ..per your -1 !: Vari~nce of' orie (1) freestanding ~igd 'to. allow three (3) . free.standing signs on the. ,property" . Variance of six .(6) feet~in sign height to allow an over~ll sign height 'of twenty six" feet for one freestanding sign, the. Dunkin Donuts sign. -This. wil'l allow the' Dunkin. Donuts sign to remain as is. . . ' variance .of 86.25 square feet in free~tanding sign area to allow the.Dunkin Donuts sign to remain as is.' Sinc.ereiy, CORTEK.PRqPERTIES, nie. '.. ~?24~. E~rl A. Wesson , Vice.Presid~nt/Br6ker ~ . , , .' ., ., . 'I ].. , j. , " I." " ,. .1 ".\ \ \, ,.. STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance shall not be granted by the Development .Code Adjustment Board unless the application and evidence presented clearly support the following conclusions: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property In question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, prodecessor In title. or the llpplicant. Any mistake made in the execution of 8 building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting . ~ of a variance. ,.,,:, .. (2) The particular physical surroundings. shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant, ' (3) . The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital .. 2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. 141 The request for a variance Is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a Qreater financial return from the property. 151 The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood In which the property is located. 161 The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property. detract from the appearance of the community. substantially Increase the congestion In the public streets. increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way. or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. 171 The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health. safety. order convenience. or Qeneral welfare of the community. 181 The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit an.d intent of this development code. t ...' -. t . , . .' '" r I J "'" .' -..,~ . SIGNATURE OF PROP~RV,9~N~~.(Q~ R~~ry:SENj~T1~E~: f~ ~,:"".,~~'nT1I!J. r' 0 ,.~.. "'..I:. j....,," .:~ ',th.s-d~4-: ~7 -'. . "J .., !};;b L/\ 6.../ I A } Sworn to and. subscribed before me this -;.;; day of +.~lC:'.-';'I.....',<.(JL/ _A.D.. 1 9q .?, by /-If=l/.?.IL L-f J, nl-) V 15 I -,J ./2, who is/are , . personally known to me or has /have produced as Iryp. ~t I.D.I ~ ~ identificDtion personally appeared deposed and stated the matters and factn set out herein are true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge and belief. (~~.)J /_('/)..C((.~. fl' ___ /C4u A..-J h.l".H D' ...~ ....n. Uf..~.......'Of'lll-Clifl. Notary Public, Commission No. NOTE:: PROPERTY OWNER 011 REPRESENTATIVE MLLS.I AlTEND HEARING. Rllv. a/92 , . . , , t . : ' , .. , . REASONS FOR REQUESTING VARIANCES. The current situation is as follows: There are two separate and distinct businesses ,located on the above referenced platted 'lot, a Chevron service station and a Dunkin Donuts restaurant! Th'is. lot .has 208' frontage on U. S. 19 and l80' -l frontage on Sunset Point Rd. Each business is located in its own separate. freestanding building with a 75' separation between the buildings. ' The lot is owned by Chevron U.S.A. Inc. and a portion is ground leased to Dunkin Donuts. The ,lease was executed'in January, 1974 and will expire in January, 1994. There are no provisions in the lease addressing signage as the lease was based on the permitting process in existence in 1974. Each business.has its own freestanding sign facing U.S. 19, both are non.conforming to the new sign ordinance. The signs are 66' apart. The Chevron. sign is a high rise type, size and height are inconsequential since it will be replaced. The Dunkin Donuts sign is comprised of two message panels ( a logo panel and a.changeable message panel) totalling'approximately 87 sq. Ft. including the 6" space between. the panels. The sign is 26' high and part of it extends over the driveway into Dunkin. Donuts. The bottom of the lower panel is 16 I above the driveway so it does meet minimum height requirements above a vehicular access area. 'Proposal: To allow the Dunkin Donuts sign to remain as it currently is. This creates the request for the variances to ,the minimum street 'frontage required for an auxiliary sign as well as the request for variances to the maximum height and area for an auxiliary sign. Chevron will replace its existing high rise sign with a new sign comprising 90.45 sq. ft. at a maximum height. of 20', thus c"onforrning to the new ordinance. .The sign will be installed at the same location. This triggers the request for a'variance of . 244' to the minimum separation from an auxiliary sign. Additionally, Chevron will erect a new sign identical to the,one just described at the northwest 'corner of the lot, facing. punset Point Rd. This triggers the request for a variance of 80' 'to the minimum separation from an auxiliary sign. since this lot fronts on two arterial or collector streets two freestanding signs are permitted. ' . .. , ' I ., . , , REASONS WHY THESE VARIANCES SHOULD BE GRANTED. The existence of. these two buildings on one platted lot creates a unique situation in regards to .the new sign ordinance. If this lot were to be replatted into two lots, which could be accomplished by obtaining a variance to minimum lot size, each business would be allowed a freestanding sign on U.S. 19. However, I do not believe it is the intent of ~he' sign ordinance to require a business to undergo such extreme financial and time consuming measures that a variance to minimum lot size and. subsequent replat wo~ld require. Each business depends on U.S. 19 as the major source of business and to deny each business a freestanding sign facing U.S~ 19 would put the respective business at a competitive disadvantage and possibly out of business. I am sure 'that. this is not the intent of the ordinance. There is no possibility to erect the Chevron freestanding sign that is permitted for the Sunset Point Road frontage to address U.S 19, even if a variance to allow this were granted, as the right of way acquisition in May 1992 has taken all potential land at the corner. ~ sign would have to be located in a driveway to achieve this and .that certainly creates a traffic hazard. To require Dunkin Donuts to alter their sign would create a severe hardship as that sign extends over a vehicular access.area and must remain at the present height or close to it to maintain adequate ground clearance., Even a new replacement sign still maintains the same configuration. To compel Dunkin Donuts to lower the sign would create the necessity of changing the entire driveway and parking lot configuration since lowering .the sign will bring it below the minimum ground clearances. To request that both Chevron and Dunkin Donuts' share the same freestanding pole is an impossibility as the prefabricated signs that Chevron utilizes are certain sizes and the one to be erected along U. S. 19 only allows 3 f lO" ground clearance~ The addition of another sign on that pole would violate the maximum, area permitted as well as place the additional sign on the ground. Even more importantly, the aesthetics would be abhorrent. Therefore, the variances requested are the minimum necessary to allow each business to operate. at its, current level, not to increase business. Aesthetically along U. S. 19 the pr'operty will be improved as Chevron will be removing the old. high rise sign and replacing it with.a new conforming sign. The Dunkin ,Donuts sign will remain as it is, therefore not changing the aesthetics nor valuation of the properties in the area. The Dunkin Donuts sign exceeds ~inimum setback as well as minimum clearance above a vehicular access area requirements, therefore posing no threat to the safety of the community. (2) " . . , , "- ~ 'I ~ . .' . , " " , . , ' , , , ' ~ J ~ , \ \. " fT." ". ? :'.. :. ~. ,~ '1 C 1 ,., . '.' : ,,1 '. t, .... ~L , , ) . c,:' " , ,. I. .. This . variance will have' a.. limited life as the. 'Fla. . Dept. of Transportation I s right-of-way plans will have such a drastic impact on this site that neither business will continue to ope'rate.. At the , very least, these freestanding signs on u.s.. .19 will not survive.' Please refer to the\~ight of Way map enclosed. The right of way 'taking is scheduled for~fiscal year 1996-1997 so the variance will most likely only have a life of five years. I believe th~t this re'quest for variances is based on a unique set of circumstances and to deny it would place an unnecessary hardShip on the .business in question. This property has been severely impacted by one right of way taking already and is destined to be rendered inoperable by t~e,Fla. Dept. of Transportation in fiscal year 1996-1997 due to an additional major right of way taking. This reqUest in noway. viol~tes the spirit or intent of the development code but merely. enables each business to ~tay in business. I therefore' ask that' these variances be granted. , .\ , , ; I > I \ . . , ,~ ,. < (. l. ,. ~ , c , " " ,. " 1 ' ., .. , I'C' " ' . , .' .; . ., , I I , , . , . , i I . , , , r,''''Ii:' , ,. , . " '. " :' . , (3) 'i " .' . , .. ,. . ~ . , ,,' \ . .1 , \ " , , " , j . ~1 . .' , , .. ,I .', .,, I.' .' . '. ~ ; ~ :,l: . . ".. ;\' \ .,: ,. .j , 'e " .. " , I ' i I I. ,. .DUNKIN DONUTS SIGN c.o T"" , . ,. i. ..r . \ /, .' " o'{., ' t....,. ., . , , " .\ ..1 ". 'I , , TOTAL AREA B6.25 sa.FT. I I 'I ,. '. , ' " ..' 1 ' ~ , .i' .' '.t:'l; ,,. ~. .' .1-4 ,08 ~l ....{ N 1 .11 . - UJ -J . UJ .. " :r: /I c . .. .,' CJ " Q ~ .. , .. .. " . u u , ll. .. l Q " > .. ~ Q I. .... a. ... en 0 a - I " 2: .. . c:C I -.7'G:, en u :i .J . Co .. " 0 C \., C'.I ~ " .. , . u . .. a /I II . .. .. .;; :: ::0 II , , .. Q ! .. " :> a .. -rn- :to ... :I Z O. c z ~ .. r,'.', Z ::l C en 0 ... ... ::l C Z W c 0 .. 11I " C <C . a Z W wi .. ..J c ~ u >- .. z. Q ... " ::l c c. c: .. UJ Q. 0 0: D. , T" ,I,' , . I rOUHDA nON SIZES ._~_ .t.. ~GH mJE OJ.' 'B' 'c' . C-60' 4'-0' 6'-0'. 11'-0' CHEVRON SIGN 8' 5'-r 3/1&' /'mum Pt'tYCAABCI'lAI"E FAct - O/.RK GREY or MUE row ~ B ACKCIlOUHO FActS TInS SOE IIING:D Foo !8l. VICE. 5 roo U1JI.IINA ltD IVJ.llI An~ (2) 5/8', BOlTS - rtP. 2 PI.J.ctS CH IWlJIJ.RX NID IPS SlCN BOXES (2) 3/8'" BOlTS - Nl'. J PV.ct:S AT OO"/HECOON BITiUH SIGH eon::s l/B' rcm./ED Pet YcMDct/A tE FAa: - DAAK CREY OP,l.OOE BAO:CROJIO (2) 3/8'" BOlTS 'MIlt mAtISlUCDH CIWlI c:s - fYf'. RED m#lSlUCDlT . CRmICS - rtP. 3/16' ,mum P<1YCAABctIArt FAa: - BLUE lYACU( BAo:cnanm Cash Stll S,rn 84;0 9 9 190 1 .1 4 fo Open 21 Hours 15-12 lC B )f 1/4 (C-'5) TS-16 x 8 x 5/16 (C-6D) 15-12 l( 20 )f 5/16 (C-78) CO\.lJI.IH {omt: CPE(}~ I, 1I II 11 II 11 II II J "-4' ~AL nmlG AtID ACCESS FlIlISlHD GRAOC f7 0 12 E.W., T. AHD B. RIG() n.ECmIOL lXI'jDUlT "'" D"IDIIIC~ tll I" I" II) ----::;:I- ---- I I L.__.J b ~. .00l1I Q)~ ...r:: c:::I u::e C-&o Q '0 ~ co ~ I V ..... .1 ... J)) ~ tfN ..!.. . .... .1 ... ... 5 Z !E Cl <...') is en a :.. S Z ~ j! ~ 0::: -0: :z U'l <( .0 w 2 a N ~ u.. -1 Ul <( Q.. f'. I v 0 '..0 I u . ... ..!. . c:> I ~ ~ ., C"l 010: ~o .u~ vj9~c( '":10 ....... ::oroz g~zii ~ ",,3=0 c:::::j uo"z eJ Vl ~w 9 ~ 1 g ~ "..; u <( " Z ~ .... :u o u.. TYPICAL SIGN INSTALLATION DETAIL ,vitl"1 SPH.EAD FpOTING ~o. .... 'i"~ . . Sl: ~ .- C'..\ \,\. .. ~t .~ ',.-"'......~ .' ',' . - 1 I';' . ~~~w~~~~~~t '. . --- "..... \/ I .p ~~~' ~ . n~ It' I ~ , I I (!. ,. ~ 2: - f!'" LJJ (f G Z "0", O. o J: (J) ~ ~ ::- (}J f r '-. 1..- l:! -. ! " '- () ~ n .( , :::: It.J (/) ......... ..:::- :~ ) (1\ ~' . III 1,1 (I. I .1 ,'h 302 201 01 ROAD C H. g ~ II .~:::::~:~.::?::~~:~;:~8~: .::~~:~~~:~:: VAc...rro BARRETT RD. 1898 41/01 too 2 ?if:/ ai{' ~ ...~ 1- w 2 2.41/. -t II '987 . ~ I~ .1 -Z 'm ..... ~ ~\~~~\'!-J\@ ~~ \%\%~ vl :i . 10 00 .... ;j ;:; .., Iil ,.. N ... ... on ~ .... ",...01"""',,,.. ......"''''''''''O'l''' 2?~~~~~~':- ~ ~'.~C ~ ' N; /05 , . HARBO~ SQUARE SHOPPING CENTER 1926 1923 1923). 'llfoB7 vl ::i ~4107 1929 1927 41/02 2"3837 .32/01 1885 t H 674 SUNSET 19 S H 0 P..P. .U:UL..C _E_ tL T E R - T + ~--- 1 _.. V'J.\RfANCE--REQu EST : SIGNS v ., ...: u @h l~ -.... _ t.. '" 'r~ q~ooE ~.ttnK:K ... I). r, t '!i 'II . I'll ~:J~~:! i ~ 0.. ~ ..; ~ ~. ... !o. ., '" . 0 .~ ... - '~ , , " .' .., "'l1 ." "t1 C .... ., .~ - :l It .. ~ Q '\I ... '.J Q / .; V' " .. :l 0 1..' . r'i .: ~ It: t "R .., 0 '" ~ ;,; :: - , . I D-L ~ -"JS] ... ,f,\ 0 : '-"I~ C] ~v^':' I I I , r,~lt1/ r c:;o I . . I. I I \ \ " ...- .. n c:>- . .., rY, o .., r-: o . ;>',\f i':jc1 , > .. .. .., ... ~ ';>Nt' puq4~~H \ \ I . I ... Iv. I :. I ~ I ,~ I .,( .\ "-- J ~ ~. '. .,. ,.- . ". I' . . ." I,,, . ; ~..'! , " , ~. " l,t , ;'.~ 't '<. , ' .., ,~ ~. ~ I : ! " II ;' Y; : " {.> , ... J 1 " , {, , " I ~. r ~ . .,, ., ., , , . , , .' " " '.. ,~> F,~" ,. :' , ~f >. r . ~.X; !.::.'~, (.i,.,' .,'</.<."'~~--; . . , " ':. 1 , .', . . .. , : ~.~ J. . '. I '.,.... " ...... ..i.' " .' ~ I ~ .') I : ~-.. .. " , , \Y t,.;'....'... : ~...' " , " I.' .;, . , ., ., . , , . ,~. " " \ , " ~ .. , . ../ , , ~" :i ',' .,. ,. , . .. , ~ I. . ~ " " ~ ' ,. . j l' ., . . .' ,. I , ~ . . .: f' ~ ," " '~ I . " . ., .' . f .11 ' . :1 I. , ,.. , . ., .,- '.ll. ;'. , . . AGENDA .i " , , ~ \ t .,' :/ . , ,., .\ .' . '. .j , < .,. 'f , ;' .1 '+jC ., i I :. ,. ..j .. \ .' . , , ,. ',C I I' I '. ~ : " ~ . I ... \., ; .1 DATE - vi- 'Qi ,. ,.-' :i' ..f E~ ,I 1 - I , ., , ., , ., '.. '. " .i ;. . , It ITEM #3 ., .. . ; " ":t' ',' . , ,.' ,I tl I, . '. " ..' /' ., .' .', .. ,I ,I II. " ,.. 'I f' , I' ., .' ,. I ,. . i ,. . , ", r". <,1. . ' \.. '. :.' '. i' ~; r I II " ':, '.. . , , . , . , I " . ,~~..,............ .. ,.. . , } : .11 . : ~ ., ,.1 '. , .,. ., " 'I . ., " ..' (SV 92-96) Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item fI Mel!ttng DatI!: q. ,/;"'iL9tf SUBJECT: Variance(s) to the Sign Regulations; 1805 Drew Street; Ruth A. Davis/Chainwheel Drive (Owner/Applicant); Thomas Jessup (Representative). RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Approve the variance of five feet from the required five foot setback to allow a new freestanding sign zero feet from the side property line .on property identified as Skye rest Subdivision, Unit 4, Block ItF", Lot 3 less the east 20 feet thereof, together with all of Lot 4, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1) through (81. o nnd that the appropriate officials bl! authoritl!d to e~ecute saml!. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a variance of five feet from the five foot setback requirement to allow a new freestanding sign zero feet from the east side property line. The new sign will replace an existing freestanding sign that exceeds the height, area, and setback requirements. The subject property is located on the southeast corner of Drew Street and Venus Avenue and is in the General Commercial zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. Information Existing/Proposed Permitted Type of sign Location/orientation of sign Area Freestanding Drew Street Yes Yes Setback Height 67.32/45 sq. ft. o feet 20 feet 64 sq. ft. 5 feet 20 feet Ravlllwed by: Legal' Budget Purchasing Risk Mgmt. CIS ACM Other Total Comllllnion Al:llolI: D Approved [J Approved w/condition~ D Denied o Continued to: N/A N/A N/A N/A "!In IL NfA Olilllnltlnll Oopt: CENTRAL PERMITTING '5'::> COlh: U.er Depl: Current Fiscal Yr. i;;j :.1; . Advartll8d: Date: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE D Not Requf red AlIlctld Pllllu ~ Notified o Not' Rl!qu; red FundIng Soulce: o Capi tal Imp. o Operoting o Othar A uBchrnlnll: APPL\CATlOtl VARIANr.E ~ORKSHEET HAPS D None Subrnluld by: APP10lllilllon Code: .-.. d ..... Print cd Oil recyc II! pnpc I" SV 92-96 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: There is very little available space in the front of this store to place a freestanding sign. Most of the frontage is used for parking. Only a small area at the east end of the store is available to accomodate a sign without causing the removal of a parking space. It is noteworthy that the parking spaces are nonconforming because they are "back out" spaces and because they are partially located within the Drew St. right of way. Removal of any of the parking spaces would have a negative effect on the business. The area at the east end of the store where there are no parking spaces is where the existing sign is located. The existing sign is located on the east property line with no setback, and the new sign is also proposed to be located on the east property without a setback. . SURROUNDING LAND USES c I I Direction II Existing Land Uses North South East West Commercial Single family Commercial Commercial The building is located on the east property line. The lack of a setback for the sign is inconsequential given the location of the building. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's request meets all of the standards. In particularf the following standards do appear to be fully met: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to th.e property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. . . . . (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would' result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of tho applicant to secure a greater financial roturn from the property. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. '. ~, '. . . SV 92-96 Page 3 (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The' varIance desired will not adversely affect the pUblic health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: SETBACK CASE /I ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING DATE REQUESTED/ ACTION SV91-11 1550 S: Highland Jordon Hills 5 ft./ Approved 6/20/91 Avo Professional Center SV 91 H22 1874 G- T-B Capt. John's 5 ft./ Approved 11/21/91 Halrstvles SV 92-01 2226 Druid Rd. Clearwater 1.5 ft./Approved 1/2/92 Dental Assoc. SV 92-21 447 Mandalay Heilman's 5 ft.! Approved 10/15/92 Avo. Beachcomber SV 92-24 2000 Drow St. Shell Gas 5 ft./Approved 11/5/92 Station' SV 92-71 351 S. Gulfview Julie's Seafood 5 ft./Approved 2/9/93 Blvd. Sunsets SV 93-06 .1621.1627 Gulf Connell' 5 Plaza 5 ft.! Approved 9/28/93 to Bay Blvd. SV 92-31 1880 Drew St. Drew Plaza 5 ft./Approved 9/28/93 I SV 92-46 11824 N. Ft. I Clearwater Bay 5 ft./Approved 9/28/93 I I Harrison Ave. Motel ~ . , to en I N en > en a: w a:l :E ::I '2 w en c( u I- w w :r: en ~ a: o $' w .(.) :2: ~ a: c( > I. I ~ ~ ..... III III il~ .!l ~ u'" '5'; III u oS ~ ""'~ ~ ~ ..Jl il u 01 I: 1;-5' .. " ., oS 8 ; S a ,g3a- .:: .2 01 J III .s IJ ...~ I: . 01 g t tL ~~ ~ :t.t 0 III c; c.-=- > ...!l 2 ; c= E .., tJ ~ " & u -S~-S I: I: " CI g 3 "D I: C" u - u H~i III .. :J :il!; .. E:sg' ~:;;;:g ::J u "5 .c 01 .a u.c ~~.s , - 1:. B l: Q. Q. 01 CI -= I: III .9- .c .. "D lj .c II ! 01 .. l; Jl :J o 3: .. " U .. Q. .. CI ~ ;; Po. 01 .Ii ,; .. " > I: il " '" E ~ {!. u "D II u .. -S c 'O[ ~~ .2 '" .t: .., "D"D I:.!! 8 ..c; .. ]'0 ..c; .. a. C:. C ~~ .~ 8.~c. ~Ci.~ ~ CI " 1Il..c;..I: u.... P." I: il III 0 "';i I: P. ..2 ~ ~B:C I: - .. ~a.1! l: P. .. :J .. ..c:: g ~ ~ ::. .. 01 ~ II' = 8 .! II 1.; ~ -a ij ::. ~ "B i :J>.s ~D t= > .::= .. .Ii il P.>" .. 1:: ~ ~ K. ~ f! a j 01 ~ u u J:. .. o .. 01 'l ~ ~~ l:"D .~ !:! .!Iii -5 ~ :;: 8 J .J! it 01 I: 12l.!l .e ; .. '" 11 01 01; CI . .c .. .. - l2lC ~ ~ .!I !:! 0.'5 " U" .i ; .. !:! g .. ~~ 0." 01 _ ~]. .. " B~ .5 .2' III .. " .9-;: .c.... il 0 ~ :: .c :3 > " =:i:a .. 01 e ; u .. g f :J tII " I: -s~ U E E.... 8 0 t; ~ ~ &. 2 :; >P. - U 1I.c .. ... ~ 0 U .. U ~ ~ e! :s 'il E ~ U tII -s~ .n B 8 i ].5: i S .. f. "D !! :;,j' -- I: !:!~.!l C; '" e P. P. II .. .. C .!l ;; '" .. ~ 1! .11 "D C :1 .. .II -= -= "i >- c. E 8 S f II .. P. Q. III B C .5 ;; '" "D .. - .. " :J U" !:! " (: s ... I: u .!:! C. Q. U .. -= '0 !:! 'ii " "D " -s c o P. ;2 >- 0;; ~ >- _ 1:: ii.8. "D l! :: P. II .. .a.c .. ... g~ Jl E U :J g e ~:s '" u 01 5 c;:! .. ~ .. " .. O' " .. ::. " ~D II U " f. ~ ~ :: ~ " ..c; o S'ti .. " ~B :J.2 :5Jl o t , 8- I: 0 ~ g, 'l:; " &;'5 "D..c:: >.2 =.c ~ ~ ~.c e:g D 0 , .a ..c:: O' :s 0..<:1 C..c:: =-i !: C u .. Us: c .. -2.5: .. '" Jl -s C o I: ~ II III .c II -.lI "t: o .. C Q. .2 0 B ~ .:2.s .s 0 o li; Jj :3 >.2 1:: :; l:E o ~ g,o O''ij :; c " .. uS -5:= ~{l 01,8 .5 O' ~ g :J .ae " J ; III c~ C > .gi B 0 sa.. .s ~ I: ~ 1:! 0.. i oil "D C ~ iii Jl -= .. .f :s 01 .. I: .s! B oS! c !l' .. "D II .. o 0. c; Do 11 ... " ~ .. "D I: II .. .. J! .c .. .. .lI :s D .. O' .. .. :J U" !:! ., -e. D "D C II - .. Jl .c .. '> :; - D .. S f II 11 a- Q. D ~ ~ ~ I "DO' '; ~ [ 1:: 0'" tI .. D.. 8.c;{~ eti 0 8.'fi a.'C ..)1.:2 DM~;;J -5 ~ ... l II S~5oj IJ C o.t=.- :J 0 .. E 8 ,!it N tt ... ..t::: 5~Bx.1I {l 01.8 J:! ; v c .c: .... ,.....- 0 .!!.!'P.3!- ~.a~:&l ~ ,g s " " .2 P..._:2 .t:g.oQ~ 1!.?:~lig BeX.;.8 t;II 0 2 ~ .... E~:-;g o:l.cv= ':=o:-5~ :~:.5= '~ a ~ " E "'U .s .... 'i C:; ~]~EC.~ IlII .. &I a c: ~&j~~o'! r:eJj!.r~ ~ ~U E-- II,) ;E; 'Ii U II U .. 01 >- C e.u =: c.8o .~]..<("D =~,:..:-s.5 u ..... ." C ..... E ,c~:lB~~ .... ... IJ == .c _ IJ t.l a..t: u ::ij.ll~~-5 .. E U E ... U III ~ Cl~ ~.E 1:- !! 0 Ill,.. Jq; I-Q. @:a c .g " ~ -5g' ~~~=; ~ -!! g> 5 .. C -0 0 ~;-gs .&:..a CJ " g;: fa '0 ::-:: ~ >= 0 "'i 0.;...> ... E ~ .. ; E 5; ; 3-:1; 50l -= E u..... Q- 1"0 :; Q c 11 ~ ~ Il g !:! '!!C ..!::1lI..::r:_ :tg';~~ .Eg;g~ g : ; ~ .c u E :~i~ u':: .- CD.. ~li;:a G ~ oS > (; c >- u't1l 0 II -S >. 'i: ~ ..t:u~ ::'x'g'1I -523.5 cu"tJ:':' !E'S~ Q 8 iJ "; >- " Il .. .. t: F 'ij.. ~ .2 t.I _ ling. '~S.5 aCi. B I: ~ Il' '" " -= &i '" III .a Il N .. .E "tI f c " :2 Q. :2 .. -0 0; ..c::. " ; I: " ~ o B l: .!l 0; '" "tI ., ; " :J U" !! u .c t- rt: R ~ ~ ~ " "D ;; >- 0; .. .. .. oS 'ij " .c u l: ~ :J Do .u -=::- u~ D :3 :::: E Il E 2:0 .. u f! " ".c ,. ... -0.. 01 0 ;; " c ;; -- ="; ~ 3: ~'ij M ~ .. " "D 01 t! ;; c -! 8 Il I: "',!! U l: ..c:: .. t- '" I: E8 ... o O' c " - .s "D c 11 ... ~ a. .. 'ij :; l: " Cl CI -= D ] oS! '" o c e J "D ~ 'ii u .-0 u U c ~ II '" D .; S:"D ", 0 .. U o .. OlC C " ... E C ... ~~ .. '" j!:{l _Jl ~= ~ . I . Receiot , 5"S'ly , 'To.06 PROPERTY OWNER(SI NAME to. ADDRESS: P. uik A 1) d u: ~ --..-R R t- L, H t'r '.{li1( \-\'1 \\ 5 C Cl r b b t, do 1 t I -::t: L ~;J. Ci ~ I CITY OF ClEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPUCATlON . IVII q2..9~1 REPRESENTATlVE(SI (if any) NAME & ADDRESS: ---;-h QfY\tl~ ':JC:;:.s. Ur :l'=&'J.lo Snbc(' 1Jr~v( C l ('QrlU(~,.. J F L, 3'1 (n ICJ TELEPHONE: (ld~1 S~ If I~ '& S- TELEPHONE: ( 'bl3 I 44 I ;:l 444 ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY:-' t(1 ~ s D r -e \...)J s. + ( r ~ i NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPUCABLE): C h ct ~ ~ lJ.J ~\ eel p r ~ \J C \ '::(. ~ c.. . . C' C 115/:.1- u..A.r L,,1 ZONlNG DISTRICT: G lAND USE CLASSIRCATION: T F LAND AREA: ISr/;).~'~'"Lr I./.'I- LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: ~e.:UJ I TLu f' d.er S ) R.AI~ IS Ii --1o-t ?, I {~~ '1'nr {u ~ + 'J ~ -t' Cl-1' 0", J 0 \\ ocr \ \) -\- 4 I h\ \ M l r== l' Un ~ ~ Y h1= .sk, (r{s+ $"bd~\J ~ I' ~\\. PARCa NUMBER: --L2--'. :1 9 , --'.5 , ~,Otllo , ~ (This information. is available from your tax receipt or contClct Pinellas Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462-3207. If more than one parcel number. attach B~ x 11 inch sheet) East:----A~ -k. <;'O\,"oJ',l..l . West:-R-Mn\\ '> \.U~t.l('s.r:-l-( r"'~I\+ -;:..:-(e..\ VARIANCE{S) REQUEST (If Variance to 7 year amortization reQuirement, refer to Sec. 134.015): E A S I ,\. ~Ii . he.. SC:l\J -t . yo REASON FOR REQUESTING VARIANCE{SI: CRefer to Standards for Approval, next page) y.w..\Jl. a. 2(l~ Sc . -.-: ~_.._-........;.,.._~~~- #" ,. . STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A veri8nce shall not be granted by the Development Cede Adjustment Board unless the eppliclltlon end Ilvldence presented clearly support the following CDr"!,:,!~.;..ms: I' ) The vDriance raquested arises from a condition which is unique to the property In question and is neither ' ordinerlly or uniformly eppllcable to the zoning district nor craDted by en lIction or lIcdons of the property owner, predaceuor In title, or the nppllcant. Any mistake made In the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of II variance. . (21 The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property Involved and the strict application of the proviSions of this development code would result in nn unnecessary hardship upon the eppllcant. . . . , I (31 The variance Is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to In preceding recital .. 2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for 8 variance Is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure 8 greater financhit return from the property. (5) The grzmtlng of the verlance will not be materially detrimental or Injurious to other property or Improvements In the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (71 The variance desired witt not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. l81 The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): --cf~:) C\, ~ -(""~ 1- . .~~.._._( Sworn to and subscribed before me this ~ - . day of lJ:;:.~~- , A.D., 19 1 A by rlfv,l~ J7.-.ir?1V-.-,o who(j)are personally known to me or has {have produced as Ily~ ,,'I.D.) identification personally appeared deposed and stated the matters and facts set out herein are true and correct to the best oQer knowledge and belief. , ~ ..g~u.:,,q:Q. ... rnJ ~'lI1'Y Pubfit, Sill" or not1d" Notary Public, COll1mlssl.on No.:;J[;U O~..5 L!J.,O My Com::.l:1lon bplm tloY. 2,1994 h.d.d t~l~ troy ',,1. .!nManu In'. NOTE: PROPERTY OWNER OR REPRESENTATIVE MUST ATTEND HEARING. Rev. 8/92 . . ~ . , ,. " , ' .' \ I. , ;, > ,. .j' I I ,. .' '.' '. . . / ~ c, '~ ~. \. . ,. '" . :: ~ 'l" ~:.' .:.I' ,..f I'. .;....,:.. I J, I' " ., ,I - ,. I . ~. f . , l. c, , .' , I , " '. . , . , I" '. , . .j" .' , I I. : ;., . I , . " j,. '., .., 1 . , . . ~ ~ ~ ' ,< ,'. ~. L , ~'.' ~: . ~ , ~ "f' , .. j J '. .\ \ ., \',. ,.~~ ~ ; ': .! I' '1"< !~ , ' .h I , .. ':. ., ," t , , ,.., , ~i',.':'/; ::.':.,'; :'\~~Sf',i{::./:;'::J.....;:'.' ". " .' '. .,. \. ., ' ..'~ . 'r-'~.~'t~ ;~,>'~'~.'t.-;'.>.(:~:,,~ .,.J " I. : . ~ . ~, : : '\ " ...., .' .", Jy ',: , " ,'" l-<'.. ...',~(< ., . ;' . "..~._-~, C I .. ,. ., , . \ ..' ..\ ., , \: ~ ,. ... ; , ,. . , ~' . J ,i , ' , .' .: ~ . " I ',. '. , C i:' ~. , < ., . , 'I' ". " ': (, ,: ',. .1 ,! .. .t ; . if, ~ I' .,'. ~ , " .,''',.. \ ~ '( " l' . I .:, " ' " , , ,. ,.. , , '., , . i. " . ! ' .As ownerl trustee of the subject property, " . la05 D~ew,sireet, ., ;1 >'0 ~ . I:' t t 'i ~ .: .' '~ ,. t, 1, ., I . , .,.1, , ~.. pres em t,l y kno~1n as. Cha'i i1whee 1 Dri ve , 1. do here authorize my -tenant " .\. ;' . .....:.-. Tom ,Jessup 'to request a. sign. variance, for my property. at. laos Drevl.: , , , . '. ' ~ .. ~ . , ~ '~. . ,. (\.:;... " , ' ,. I.. "~. "1; ,.1,: . ;l' '! . S i g.ned. , , . . ,/) ~. . . f/ . J /1..~.".',!., . . 0 . '" - . . . . C,j '. (, ,',c ;;. " " '....1. . f., :,I!. " ,. Ruth ^.~ Davis " ,., ~ , ., ." " : t: ;~.' ~' .,. : . \ . ~ .,(. , '. .,\ .\ " . I , I " ," ., " State of. 'Illi ~o:is' .; " .~~ ~ , ., Coun~,y" of Jackson' . ,~ . ....... .. ~ ' ,by. f2 I..L t./ I\.- 'A. ackn~v]edged befo~e Ot{ U ,"S rre on Oc:toh~ . . ~ 3,~. , I. q -9 .;l. . .' This i nstr.urrent was :;'",. . . " .:.+,', ., .> "OFFICIAL SEAL" , AMY J. SMITH. 'NOTARY PUBLlO. STAlE OF ILLINOIS MY COMMISSION EXPIRES ,9/1B/96 't .' .; " ..~ ~, ~~~/,- l\my SlJlI t , otary. .Publ.ic . \ . ;. I '. " " . , ,. '. ,. " ,., " .'.' ;. . :. f ~ . , J. . . , ,. .. .: .r , t ,. ,f j. :1' .'. '.. . ,. '. r~ I '. , , 'l) " .' , , -., " .. ! ; ... ., , " .; 1 ...j. I: . ~ ~ \ ' ,I , \ , ' ,. ,. . I.' i"C , , " , ' ..' , , !. ' ~. ... I, ! ~ : ~" , , , , l . , ., . " .\ ;' .' , " ~.~ . ; " '. ., .., ., . ~ '; ~. ~ ~. .,. , .. ': I \, >.i , . ,~ : ,~" . , ~c. : , ,. , , " >, ,., "0 , i ;' ,., . , , ,. j' . ~ .;'. 1..'j . .i ,; I' ..1 '.. ..J . i .r d , , '. \1." " ., . ., .{-: .. 'Ice .. .~,,:. t., (. :".: < 1. '.' ~, ,: ,. . ," " ., ,> .' '.' ,'. " " , I '. ) ,. I ,t. , , I' o , o . ~.~..........t~~ \. I' .1 .1 ,I I~' .. 'c '. " .. -'"I' . ",.. .' .' ,. " . 0...: " '. I .. ..r , ~ .' d. '- , I I'.. "' , 't..f+ ':. .' I '. L l " ,. , , f I i' I . ~ I :.. , I , " ,',c r;, I i ';. i " , I ,. '...... .' " j" . ;'c~: ! ! ~ .' " .' . .. " 0 ., '.;. ,.1 ,. . , .> t\ ~. o~,) c..~ f \.\. \ ^ ~....-~ .S,t.( Y u{.. ed~^ (~'" ~.) ,..) :. \J i '^ j . . .' ~. , ,. I .' . I' " .f, l:"' " :1. .' . .' ,. ' ., ., ;, '. ., ,. " . , " \ !. ). :>.. , I .'j'.' . , , I. "'-on" ._,__.__.......... ". --.............. ..~ :-- ________ Or . _...... . ; " .1, . , ." .., '.' I' ~. . ., .l' . \ " " ., I' , , ::,.!: ~ 't.) \ '" I r. " I ,. i i I , .j , 1 I. I ,1 " ., ,! . . .s 1"'~ '~ , f,U 1(' l.U \) .~ \ l~~: b~ ..l -\ c> d ;j( , ,L~; ecr..::\.;b:...... l:O, ( -~ \"( I:.~...\i~.. ~r (_1"..11,,\.. 0 ()l. r.~,'r,-l"ll . . , , . J' :j:' '.- ij'j f 'd. l~~ , . . ., '.. ,.' " :~ ly tJ..~~ (' ol~~~, . :11,\ . X~it) \PO ) "-. ~. , 'I . 'r :J;t'~ :- . ....--r- t II,~U' : ij ,h f . , . -!. ,..,~...~.... ':,) \ ~"""j;~fl) , . .. ......,.... . l , I . .. I I I \ . '" 1 .~_i_ + ...... . . "2.'f.l i · ~ 'I' jt ..:~~.. . '.~~ -i . ~ ~.;;. .'. '~~~>~::l~~'" '. ; 1\"' "-J . .. ':d ,:.j -, t:J :~.~ ,'" -7t;" : ': "',( :'!'.":~ . J, li~ -- '/ - "'LI ~ . I~, . .1 ,. .' ~ OJ . . ~ r-. , 'l~'~' ~ '~ ~(j }.... D ~ 1.1 "1) . \ Q . . . . - -. . .. ., -- . ,.,,_ .- - :d .~ ~ ~ . .. I -\ .. ~ ~j '. , .... 1,-.; " . '\ .. , .'. :;':.:1..~;' ...' ' '. . ',: I ,.' , . ",' . " '''\" .', I"... ~,:. '.... J:, " " 'i:',. "', .' '.. ~-vl . ,,' :,. '" "", ' ,. '. " ,: " ., ,- . '" ,'.., , I.~ . ", I', '. "J' .1' '~"".\I "..,1" .'. '". ,.",. 'leI . I '. ,'1l'"~I.,.,;.tJ~'''' 1 ,1 .'. . . " . ',.. .;. . '~. \', .,', ,01_' ,. "". , ,: ',.' " '.," " .' . . ,L.."" '. f",' " ,.'. ", \ \_ ".. ' , ,'," ' ' :. )...... '..f.~ "l: ,i ,,,' ;'P'n'.. "" I"','''''''~'' I .. "',N','" ' '" ' .'..' .tt:,;: ~'~fr-.' ..; . d.":l'"t.~'1."o;s~r' ~ ...; I..r }.:~ J.i. "', I'd' ~~. ", or..C1Z. 11.' . '" · .. , ,,- ". , , >'. J'", .. ' . .' 1 ","'~. I t'4 11.......~..i\>\.. .".'...1...... .. ".".'''''1.'''';.'' ',. ,,' '. , '..,. ,,' .'. ,". ,.. .... ',"'/-", ...' . ',". " " ",' " ." C" 1,,; ,,' . " "" ""', ;, , l' '. .... " ", { ,'. ,\:: '" ,'" . :,.'<' "', "" '.' "',w. ,,'. " ""1' ..n ,,' ' . '., ".' ", ( " >".:'" " '. .. . '. . t' . I'll '.. , I' " ' . ~ c' \ . , .'/. 1 . : 'Ii ',. ':'~.'J!.. '; _.~" , . . ........;1."." ,\....:~..:J :.,," .; r:';;,' ~;;. . -~ri .\:.\ ...., I'..,i. ,:..,.~. . \'~ ~t'\:... :., , ~',\.;j~~...,.~, ,~( , :,,'... .1.., I'~' ";1.1 .J...\; I. r:'. . .: '.I,....~, 1;.'~;':'i":."'f.:I::,':' . . . "j '('0\' .....;...,~~fr:lI,~.!'.~.,~~,,'. "t' ',. "". . " ~ ....~ hr...,,- . "'j ~. '-\.',:.. ~)'I"iI-, .: !' !If,,,., 'j;'~I" :', ~ . . ~ ..I;~.'. I. l~'';' ..',,'.1.1 ',~:': .";,' .. 4', (....: ~.. . . . ~\""" ,::.,;,\~t':!~.,'-: \.... l~. '. I'~~" ...'''- ...., '. :\1 'P . ,. . II , . 'II ' . . '. ..~ I I J 'J, . . ,.....,~ "., '" · \1'\ 1,\.. \ '. ' ., . '~:',:';~.\'>~: : .;':"I~\.; ~~.::'.' .... .,.. . "',,, ."" ")'1 \.; ~ c...,. _", '.', -:.......-.....,+. -t:~:/,\.I'; . >' - ... , . I... .. :.~ . . \. " . . " ',' I '. .1 . , I ..,~ ._..........._~ .:.- ~. ....... ......-.- , I.. I I.. ~ I I .\' . . ~~. ~':";;:~ /~.:., ~L ,'''S" "-C~~ ~tV' t()(fJf! ~::1t 1~49 v BLOCK F oV ~ ,I Ii ,I ?, -......--....... ....- " ~~ ,. .,.., 1.f.ll' " .,.' ....,.. . ..........'/. " . , . --.':.'. 'r-~"-- - -r9:-R-G-W----.5-T-:--f-.S.O.:....J:L.f. )-' \\ r .... "~~"'-b ~.' '". >./ , '. '. , , , ~ ---. "N~'. "."...;.#( I , I ~l ~I ~i , ~ I ~:.. <t'- ..-\. I ~ ,.., '\ v-'-l: ! ~~ ' ~ I 'j , I I~ ~; ~ ~: ,'IJ I "" ~I l>J ~ I \ , ~ '8 NJ ~ Jr,~Y, .-,....... J,,~v~/, ~Nld3.,~ , -L' .sr..,ofY'! , ""..J.......".l'" , ,ot 'I(~""/ I , . ,I f .' 1 ~1~1.t ti !)~,."L IJJ. .l: ~~.TiU 1lI11l1111 I ~ . ~ ..t /'d#"'l .JI' .I"..-J,J..........-r.l... . ~ ' 13 (J~' Il.JtJ(v~. WI"'.()~~ 'uJ~~ . ~ 51&tJ-:? ~ I , ~ ,: "I , ~ II) r !II ~ "' ., . I:l ~ : ------. ---~ .-..-- . ';"'--'1;1 . ~o _...._~_ 'j .ve:il -.:z ~- '~-..I" ",-\/ .1 ",.~. ALLdy' \ t "I. -'I " I r~ SUHVEY OF LOT J .10BS Lho End, 20 feoL llnd .:111 of LOT if utn'I' /~ OF GKYCHF.ST SUUDlVJSION SEer: /.,' rW~.e D~, /?tW;, ',IoSE, ,0 1 " IV :~ \" \ NiaJ.;'" . 1 q't{ci~:' /; S/(,~. 'j fl . I' ~ ~ ~' '\ n \I I .') , ft"y. (.S 1 ir'(" \. \' f'(LvJ I,tll.l llt;.\ . fU:l\l~"'.~V t I n:;, .recorded in Plat. Dook 28, P1r.e 23, accord:; of Pinc.llan Co\mLy, Floddn Clcnli.mtor, Flod.da I C~,.I;Ii~d a/,b ')Uf\'tp .G['OtfGE f." YOUNG, IM.~ Survey for SL. Pol:.en'.bul'c, F'edo:""l .r;,.P'lL. t\5sn. y-....., , Nnmo.: A:'J30C. ~1omf'n Invc!i lara, !nc.( / -d.---..:.... 4:j ~ ;7'""- Oct.ober 9, ~9~2 L,<<~(;-{G.,~dt..jt',L,.(.~..> (fo rWUlii!l!L.H..J.h'OIIlPs01ll'.......... Order No. 9illhl Florida ~\U"V'c.'iorlr. nOf~'ll Ho. 1)61 n"'/r/..,,n,...,...$'orj.{}'n."...."3. ,I. , 1/ \ ' rtl,,.;.J,.,Cn'i"'n,.).f~'l'n".r181r. . " " '. :' ..... I ' .I ~,~ J I ~#t:( --'~I 32 320 .... 310 JoJ 31f! 34 Sf.( ~fi 310 35 J08 306 36 304 "7302 J 300 "8 220 oJ 22( .39 222 220 218 40 2111 41 2U 212 :10 lOti 42 ~~ 110% 100 :c~..~ ~t: t~ J. 4 5 C\1 B _. le} -: ~ ........ ~ Z 9 ::J 10 11 IUb ~ ,.J .us-- r.x:l---EG .W 11:::a J2f .m -0 0 24 ~~~ z E!- C\Z 0 3/8 ~ 316 gT E 25 m ~ ~CO. F.!:......-.J.U 111 311 ~ 312 3011 .~ 26 IJlO 307 308 305 7 "aT 303- 27 ~~~ 301 6 "00 227 220 226 5 28 2t/! 223 2~ 22t <I 222 29 220 2111 2/0 ZI7 3 216 2/6 2 30 214 213 212 Ii( ~" 101 ZOll m'1 Ie 31 lOti ZOoS 104 m" ZOJ! ZOI ZOO .... tl.:l::\ ~:::! .. .. ~ 60 t t; t: t: l: l: l: t; t t SlREET ,-, ~ t ... ~ l '.., CIG " . '.. . . ..1. 325 323 8~ jrJ I- ll) 3/7 7tD :/'5 ~ 313 ~ ;:[ 3n 309 6 ~" 307 309 306 :107 -'03 5 .f06 301 .10.1 229 30' U7 4 U6 226 12.1 1 B 223 7~ 221 3 tiP 19 "'9 2'7 20 ~ ZI7 ttS 2t6 2 213 Jrlf 10' .s 1 " / ~ ~ ~f ~ 60 ----...-.---- - ".....-- -:<-,~ w _~_~3 330 ~ 326 33 ~ E .., .. .. ... 42 3.24 3/9 34 t- B 7 41 3/8 3t.1 35 0 312 30736 2 C)\A. 1\ 308 50 37 .., .., ~ JB 300 30t ~ S;; 0 ... .., ... .. ~ ~ B J.3/05 33/04 CG 2 ... ... .., to ~ !;!! DREW 60 h~^.c . .L.. :r ~.~ J ~lj5": 2 II. W I II.~ J :;, , ~ r J WHJ I -\ , IO.? 0'( , I , '1 I.Il4 \ \. ~O~ ~ ,- If):' I /0.1 fi ;) ; - 10). . Ie . ! .. C'tJ . f. IY ., w() I , ., r 11 f:-l ,. ,.~ I VI 1 Cl: ........ b I <( 9 III :J. I !J z .1 I . . ;:J 9 ,; ~ z l ,S 1(. , -l 10 ' :r ; 1 .... .. '<1 .., 0 ~ I .. .. .. ." t t, ~ t. ~ I.. R r _ "'l i 'I'] f... ..". ..., .....l ""1 ~ It:. t ~ 11 II 01 (.1- '" ,. -. I 5 6 7 W II.~ 1 II' :;, --' ~ . ~ lOR ; 0'( III ro, . In;" ~ .. . i I, 100 I I 11I1 r. .JD, ~n . 17 7 ,,, Z I.~ A 0:: - , ?- .-. .( II 9 ,;;' V1 II . 2- I 0' t R~ L . _ j " I , , . ..i _ P/sP 5 104 I -- .--- - ....-i G ., tOO I (E '. .1 ',,-.J . I 108 ..j W I:J I l -. .. ..... . --.. '_/~!~: ~ . "03' 100 . : B 4 ~ i ta, -- '::'L J i ~ .-J.~) "..{.~J" ~ '9 9 5:!0 ~ 0" ~ ' j -,.' f'\ 'I ;t ./5 L-'.. _ ... _ ~.,. 14 -1 Z w' E-o 0 >1: 1~.._.ll__Z 7 ~ I' ..... "1 ...... z L CLEvELAND \.. . If)' 1.!J n: . ) ):. :..<: Jj 0~f } >- .:.r: .;( t- If) .~ w :> uJ '.d .., 20 : . ....! 8 '" , I I 9 12 -j E-i l-i Z :::> 1() 0, -,. 12 ~Il 5 , 11 ; fin t ~ 13 .. .,., ~ I ," t~ --, ~ 8 I .. ....._.......up. _ ..... 9 Q ~ VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS .-- NAME': -DA~IS /tIlAINvJflEEL D'2JU~ "LJbS.sUP sV#. Cf2.QC, PUBLic HEARING DATE: A t LAS p AGE: 28Q.4.. SEe: I 3 T W P : 2 4 S. R G E : I -S- E . ~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION ~ I l' ,I' . ~. ,J> Ii I . S 'II () t?o .., "" ,~ .. .c: ... .. ~~ o I I D I ~ "'"Js] ." .-r"\ ..: \.-./ on , I '\.. ' QQI' ,/ o , ';l^'.' f;lln/='JlIH , r . ;]. I I c> t~~r- ~ .. .. ~ =- " I " ,~ " ~ I .....1 ... I~~ :l / ~ '-- ., Clemwatcr City Commission Agenda. Cover Memorandum Itcm II Meeting Data; ID. Ila Yl q1 SUBJECT: Variances to the Sign Regulations; 400 East Shore Drive; John and Christine Stathas/Sandpiper Motel (Owner/Applicant); Konstantine Stathas (Representative). (SV 92-100) RECOMM ENDA TION/MOTI ON: Deny the following variances: (1) an area variance of 16 square feet from the 48 square feet permitted to allow an attached sign with a total area of 64 square feet, and (2) an area variance of 12.5 square feet from the 50 square feet permitted for a freestanding sign to allow a total area of 62.5 square feet, on property identified as Sec. 08-29~ 15, Lots 12, 13, and 14, Block S, Barbour Morrow Subdivision, for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8). Approve the following variances: (1) a variance to allow a roof mounted sign where such signs are prohibited, (2) a setback variance of five feet from the required five foot setback to all~w a freestanding sign zero'feet from the Poinsettia Ave. right of way, and (3) a variance to allow a freestanding sign in the Beach Commercial zone on a property where the buildings do not have a 15 foot setback from the right of way, on property identified as Sec. 08-29~15, Lots 12, 13, and 14., Block S, Barbour Morrow Subdivision, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8), subject to the following condition: The sign attached to the roof of the north building shall be removed within 60 days of this public hearing. [J and ~hat the opproprlate officials b~ authorized to e~ecute sam~. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to permit the continuation of an attached roof mounted sign and a froestand.ing sign: (1) an area variance of 16 square feet from the 48 square feet permitted to allow an attached sign with a total area of 64 square feet, (2) a variance to allow a roof mounted sign where such signs are prohibited, (3) an area variance of 12.5 square feet from the 50 square feet permitted for a freestanding sign to allow a total area of 62.5 square feet. (41 a setback variance of five feet from the required five foot setback to allow a freestanding sign zero feet from the Poinsettia Ave. right of way, and (5) a variance to nllow a freestanding sign in the Beach Commercial zone on a property where the buildings do not have a 15 foot setback from the right of 'Revl,wod hy: Legnl . Budget purchasir,g Risk Mgmt. CIS ACH Other Totnl CammlnlGn Ac\iGn: . 0 Approved [J Approved w/cooditlons o Denicd o tont inued to: N/A N/A N/A ----HIA Nf' :bit.. N(A Q r il1[nalinl1 D GIlt: CENTRAL PERMITTING 5s Calb: UIO' DellI: Currcnt fiscal Yr. Suhmlltad hy: Advorllsod: OMc: t:. . I Paper: T AHPA TR I GUIlE o Not Rcqui reel AUlclod Partial o Ilotified o Not Required fundirlQ SOU'tD: o Capi tol In1p. o Operating o Other Altachmenu: P.PPLlCAT10Il VARIANCE ~ORKSHEET HAPS o None AjlllloprlllliDII Codl: ~ printed on recycled pap~r SV 92.100 Page 2 way. A third sign, attached to tho roof of the north building, is not part of this variance application and must be removed to comply with the sign regulations. The subject property is located on tho north sido of Marianne St. between East Shore Drive and Poinsettia Ave., and is in the Beach Commercial zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. I Sign 1 I Sign 2 I Information Existing. Permitted Existing Permitted Type of sign Freestanding *No. Attached **No above roof Location/orientation of sign Poinsettia Ave. Yes Marianne St. Yes (if permitted) (if permitted) Area 62.5 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. 64 sq. ft. 48 sq. ft. (if permitted) (if permitted) Setback Oft. 5 ft. (,.S: ~<Lr"'~l\"a) Not applicable Not applicable Height 20 ft. 20 ft. Not applicable Not applicable (if permitted) * Freestanding signs are allowed in the Beach Commercial zone only on properties with all buildings positioned a minimum of 15 feet from the right of way. Above roof signs are prohibited in all zoning districts. ** Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: . . Two of the variances requested, #'s (1) and (2), regard the roof sign that identifies the motel to the one way westbound traffic entering Clearwater Beach. Because of tho windows, the architectural design of the building prohibits the placement of an attached wall sign on the east facade. Also, because the buildings are not fully back fifteen feet from Marianne St. and East Shore Drive, a freestanding sign cannot be placed at this corner without a variance. Staff recognizes the importance and need for an identification sign oriented to the westbound traffic on Marianne Street. The architectural design and existing setbacks combine to create a unique condition for the placement of a sign at this location. However, this is not justification for an additional area variance of 16 square feet and consequently, it is staff's position that it is appropriate to downsize this sign. As the applicant considers ways to downsize the sign to conform, staff encourages the applicant to consider some alternatives to placement of the sign on the roof, specifically, locating the sign over the canopy at the main entrance, or requesting a variance to allow a freestanding sign of conforming area and height at the corner of Marianne St. and Eust Shore Drive. The other three variances, d's (3), (4) and (5), rcgurd tile freestanding sign oriented to Poinsettia Ave. Staff observes there is difficulty placing a sign oriented to Poinsottia Ave. Both tile southern building and tho middle building are less than one foot from tile right of way, leaving Iittlo room for the placement of a viewable sign. Also, the mchitecturnl design of the building leuves little opportunity for the placemont of an attached wall sign. While these factors combine to create a unique condition for tho placoment of a freestanding sign zero feot from tile Poinsettia Avo. right of , , '. ' . I SV 92-100 Page 3 way, these factors are not justification for granting 12.5 square feet of additional area. Furthermore, drawings which accompany the variance application show this freestanding sign extends 4.5 feet into the Poinsettia Ave. right of way. The City Engineer has directed staff to not allow any portion of a sign to'overhang into city right of way. If this sign is permitted to be placed on this property with a zero foot setback, ,it should be reduced in size to 50 square feet arid removed from the right of way. . . SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing Land Uses North South East West Motel Public Parking, Marina . Motel Retail Commercial and motel uses surround the subject property. These signs as proposed are not in character with the signage permitted for the surrounding commercial uses. However, if the freestanding sign is moved out of the right of way and the area of both signs is reduced to the permitted amount, the signs will, in general, be in character with signage in the area. Applicable Variance .Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application. staff finds that the petitioner's request for variances to allow a freestanding sign with a zero foot setback and a roof sign meets all of the standards. Further, staff finds that the petitioner'S request for area variances of both signs does not meet any of the standards. In particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully met: . (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. . (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3~ The variance is tho minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for tho purpose of making roasonable use of tho land. (4) The requost for a variunco is not based primnrily upon tl10 desire of tho applicant to socure a greator financial return for tho property. .' .' I , , , ' .; ," ~ " . SV 92-100 Page 4 ' (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. . (6). The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the. appearance of-the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the. community. (8) The granting of the variance desired wiJi not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. . , , Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission:' ATTACHED SIGN AREA CASE # . ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING \ . REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 91-01 2000 Drew St. Shell Oil 84.8 5 . ft./Denied 2/7/91 SV 91-16 601 Cleveland St. Sun Bank 43 s . ft./A roved 8/1 5/91 SV 92-19 27001 U.S. 19 J.C. Penney 329 sq. ft./ Denied 10/15/92 Co. SV 92-42 714 Cleveland St. Trickel 70 sq. ft./Approved . 2/9/93 Jewelers 5 ~\ . . .r ., . , 1 ., " , ' " ". , , > J., ' '1 .. " . SV 92-100 Page 6 SETBACK CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING DATE REQUESTED/ACTION SV 91 -11 1550 S. Highland Jordon Hills 5 ft./ Approved 6/20/91 Ave Professional Center SV 91-22 1874 Gulf to Bay Capt. John's 5 ft./Approved .11121/91 Blvd. Hairst les , SV 92-01 2226 Druid Rd. Clearwater 1.5 ft./Approved 1/2/92 Dental Assoc. SV 92-21 447 Mandalay Ave. Heilman/s 5 ft./Approved 10/15/92 . Beachcomber SV92-'24 2000 Drew St. Shell Gas 5 ft./ Approved ,11/5/92 Station .SV92-71 351 S. Gulfview Julie's Seafood 5 ft./Approved 2/9/93 Blvd. Sunsets . SV 93-06 1621-1 627 Gulf to Con neW s Plaza 5,ft./Approved 9/28/93 Sa Blvd. SV 92-31 1880 Drew St. . Drew Plaza ' 5 ft./A roved 9/28/93 SV 92-46 1824 N. Ft. Clearwater Bay 5 ft./ Approved 9/28/93 Harrison Ave. Motel . . , " o o 'C- , ("'oJ 0') > (IJ a: w r:c ~ :) 2 w en <( (.) .... w w :I: CIJ ~ r:x: o ~ w U 2: <t - a: <t > I ~ .. - OJ III a ~. "i.,.- ~1i ~ ;...'0 tI .. oS U 0 ~.;QQ. CI'eft JI~lll:~~~ ~-aliiiuG !!~C"I.I.!> -:: ~ c ~.c; ,,"" .."B'U"',,~ .,ijc~:w-51J :Eftg.:iIi..fi 21;-g!-cO~ g,;g.EIli1Q"D CD ;J "D u ~ ';: ." ~.Qig~]1I s.!:c..5!ofi ~~~;mu... IU :: .:: D..:: ~ ~ ,siiQ5;r:rc ~~.;"~~~ ~.D2;=.,.~ gQ~Q=]u= .:;.!1U~"'Ci; "tl<tog,]~.a l.;~gguo s~.!-e;c: ~:i~:::~c.11 :E':'U:!~:iSJ! u;r::ClJvEoS i:~.;=8~ ~GtDgS]t ~-St)G"DU~ ;:;g]E"ti!~ o c 4! II ';; .. , ]~~:;OClg ~'iiEol:.E... ~1o_f=~.iB "':"~ 'ic;.2 ..-Cw .2""D..!'.!" ~.fi]~i~~] !;~;8!5g.:!1I BII_~ I:-C: "c ~~::,S!'g. a3C1;:_~"aM'" ~ ~ ~ I ~ .. .. .u ~ 0 c a. .2 .:i ~ -8 2::_0., g,.!!';;I:E! .!:.E~ii ....S~-~ ~~:~o ~ N t,1 I) - s.~~a."n _ ..c " t;n ! 5"~.5~ J!g~;gi .c~I:t..Qo ~ ~ i .. ~ ~~oQ~ cc.>co ..2 iQ t: 0 I: .~ Z ~"5 iE2~] g~~~:ti 1l5-Sl'Eu _~~o"O .. i.~ ~~.5m=r ~ ~ .2 ~ 1; : ~t .5 u E .~ - G]~~ii~ ~ ... 0 ~ ~ c: ~ .s ~~ ; ~ "E ;.uu.E'5& " co>.... u ;.!!;~~-S ~,-g>,.;=.. '~.i]3~~ Ut~~~~ ~ :. u II. ~ ~ _1T"'\J"'c C.5 g -S 8. l = i i ~ ~ E u ~ -=-!m .gi;cu(; ~~.E"...&.gtl..... .,. "'ao.gnlQ'c~- m=u"Ln,~""";~ Gc.:J.:!ONa..>u '5':-:., t.. o.:-~]..:.. oS..!!"cftN",:t:U;._ o ....tJlI:.5u....SnG lI3 ~"O-5~E t: o.E; J 15.~ G4!~tnQO ~ '".c ~ C, Ct, Ci ~ - <'0==:::0... :Jo~l:~ 2~ .!~"D t:J!1'; ii ~~ J!1I;C::!C">>... ., i,j....:itn:.g>'CtoCl.i: ~&J..M!!;i.!!gE :f=;~';EE;esg S_~~II.~Q;; B].~~':: 'C ....u....=.~.fc8.: ~~.s~~i-5~~aE J:!1I0~~!!:E;.~.!1~ ~~.!! ~i::.5 0;; 011:<<'_ tJ 0 01.. Q,1: i "iiA .o:....s~>o... ~~e.~ !~1t-;1~ ga:~~~u~\t!~~" 'o..ll.!! ~ c:: .;";;.Qa.;; i~;~~-S o"g=..8 i ~~c~~~o>~:!gSc ;,.- >,s:, u;~: O"tiLn O~CI~ t:c':~() =.3-:; ~";&. m-.t:.... lij.Q~",2".. ~:!E~ .!!~ ~~~jc ~M ii., !:gE~c"'!:!;:;!~.6 ~ E I)':: &111 ClC: U.-" _ ~ ~ 0 ; < e = ,~ & ~ 1I='ii.~~ cCJ"g-:J u"'Cllou-!.ge":~ ~ ..c"O...:a-C1--... 1I~...,..t=...II~~.t:'5~ M ..- ~1):2'" .D -g ~.:: -: ,; I~ ~ ~ :: :: :::;!jE~.t:lEll...~.E>~ G."" 0.., C1aoCDCliO cn.E2.!!3-s~-;Lti~-; .. u u c .!l tJ ~ .; : '0 ~ = : E -S u > -u~ i~ .. ,- ~ 0 o.C ~.g ~ .~ -: .i ;; ~ .. .. U tJ .. 01 ~ u M ::: u tJ -5'5 '0 t ~ ; .; I~ I) ~ ;;%.2' U .. a ~ : ~~~ -5 .. .., ~ao '0'2..r: >~ 0 ":C.Q 11. " .. g'g>~ .'; :s ~ .~. ~ ; ~ '; ~ tJ " :J t:~~ ~ ~ '0 [ WI a C"ii .8 i; 'C"CI ii .k1 u';E '8 C ~ :CM~ o.co. " a ... ... .- oIJ ~~; !! g.2-= .. ... I: .. tJ 0 O.cg, u..:J ~o ~ .c C .. WI 0 'U fIJ-.~ is m~J: ~~~ 5 g. :l g ,~ ~ ~ t; ~ .: u :. ;; c .. .5 " .... 'Wi , :- "CI ..: c Q, " ~~~ "'5 :. 1ft 'e g ~_~ .. .~ :> 11.>0 l t: ~ I-- ~-8 N [3 r: .S!' .. ~ c 'ij I: ~ WI u ~ u -S .. ~ f. In N 'U C II C 0> .; .... o e tJ -S ] "$. M M ... . ;t; 'U .E ... I: i 'E ::J .. 1:1'0 u C .. " : ~ u .. I: U .s u ~ t: > ,!! " <l ! ;:... .. :l u u .c ..: ...... u .. -5 8 E .i ,g ;; c :> :; II .. ~ ~ ...3 -:: g ... .. ~~ WI :i ii ;- .. u ""ii. i., .t: u :; ~u u u 0. .. o a ~ .. "".. u c ~ .2 CIa. .. 0. ... II. &! <: ~ ::J - .. 0 <: ... .s~ =g~ " II () c o 8- ,g.:> ..: >- - == ." ~ Oi E ;. 'i ~ 1l >.- .. WI t: <: .. u .. .Q 11. II u 0 '" OJ Q. 0. :E ~o ~ : .c :J ~" :~ u 0: ... 0 u WI C .. C u :. ;, u c '5:ia ., .. E E g'O ~ : ~ 8- 2. =- >11. ~ ... ~; .. ~ ~ .2 C' l:f"I :; - E ~ 'E .y 'E ~ u g' ~~ .~ ~ " a .E ... .r;. .. Q u '.. oJ ." ~ ~ c u o 0. 0. a ;::l a >" t::"L: 1 i a"; II a .. tJ III ~ .P;; ~ .u c; c .. .: ~ g ~ ,~ .. Oi tJ ~ 0. il " ! ~ u ~ :: g.s e ., u c .! ~ S -D u "CI C ~ ~ .s I-- ;; " a'!-5 E " ., ~,g ;;g; - .. .. ~ - o '1: ~ B.E .s t:"c.!P... E~i;~ .... ... 1:: ..J::; .8.::~""~ C)U~O.2' ~S~~.. &-8'ii 0:: 'ft == c "2 ] u"j::J>.. -S~~Ec -SB.~J:t~ 'ijEcl:; t ~ ~~ ~ ... :- "CI 01 .., !~5~&,E .. ... u 'U E ~-SQ1ij~ .5o~~:- ... c:n - CJ -5 a ~.5:'~ ~ J!i:.S]SC) 'U!e..'U..: 1.1 Q:t 0: :: B ... .~.. 1I:J.5 &.~E:~'"'CItJ E't-3~f~ 11... "I:J!C III ~ :> 0 " 9 Cl ~ 11:E: c .. ~-c....2'-S .SP~'5e~"i "~IIBC;,,- ., E: I:l':: .D = E:; ~- u -S 0 IJ ~ (I ! ..U.5l2i11" o~;-S;'5 8:u.Qo".s ;~g':-S] .i2~~~~ ~ :; ;, ~ c ~ u~~~:~ ~~;:1l1:~ o .. ~J! .2 >- :; t: :5' 8- .. " o 0. ;; " E-5 " .5 ] :>..: .g $ >.5 j~ !] Ej u": .Q.g> o ~ c:~ 'i .5 ~ :l ~ t:: .. E > ~ .~ 0 -so. '05 0>0 .g ~ .: ~ ~ 8- 0>0 u 0. 'l:i ~ ~ :! _.z:. B !!lo.9 ~.u :i gg' .. :I It I: c- ,t:;.!P .2'-a~ 0" ..... .. ., l..,g..c .s:;....::~.s:;.> .. :'2'Oi wo'5Ef; ~uIIE~u o a iU 0 Cl Cl 8.S : u..c i; 5~~~;-5 -~M""i.s .S~.s-o>c III ;I m tlI ., .D " .. I: u ~ ~~:g!ol >.:;;:..-; ....... --c..j D i~~t,-.s 0'" !! ~! = a ] ';: ~ .: Pi uuE~~~ ..!!..Q,.e~;J.2' -g&:-Son 1ft G U ... '"'0 ~j.~~~~ .;:~ ~EoS ;-se>..tt""' o.s:;.~Oic5 ;;.j ~-3~E' : .. ~ ~ tft a .."oS ".!i'U ~~;~]~ -';i:i~] ~ ~ ~ ~] ~ "CI__CCt.c ig~~-S~ :!i.!!-Bg'=:;. ;]~'~~~~ E ~ 1:D D I,) "CI ~ Eg."c~~oS 8 Q.~ 3:c.!!.G - " >.0'; g'Eu'= ..:JEg'~ .s:;. .. E o>E'U'- ::: 3 ~ 0 o ....: ~~U~ Q.. ~ : .S goo tJ .5 " ... U 'C ~~~~ :J~:!.! tr CJ iU .. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a.. -.; 0; i :~.g .s:;. .0 .. ... - ;:, ..... lEn-a .5 .,g ~ >. .... .... ... ; o u ,s r; ~ C ~ .; " -a III ~ "C " .5 U>."> CJ t: 011.... - c;'v~.!~ 4! 0. LI " " iG '2 ~ " a.. > 11.'<: U !:! IJ-.....~c. -S;~:JQ 'O~~~~ ~:Cll.c c c: CI c ..... :J 'E!.;.te f c = ~:i 1ll,2 ..!l .. .. U ..... C ~.o ~t!:~u en u.2 ~~~;~ I '9 .. .s:;. ~ .. '0 u C ~ o ~ 1i o .s III .E 01 C 01 .<: ;; > o c ~ .. CI C 'ij I: .. ';; tJ ! 1l'ti I: ~ ~ ... o III >-.c 'B~ ~ :J ';; 11. ;~ .. .. - .. o g, 8 t:l C .. tJ u .. .. ~g, u > ;: ; - _ 0 o c 01,2 Cl.li" :~] 0'" > ~;.G ""II,! ~ oS 0 'U" "i I: l! :. II 01 .~ .; 8. II t: 0. .c " 01 .. 11. tJ DI 0 u -5 Ci.] ;o~ .c .. > 5~~ ~i~ C"Cl !t;.s .5 U t: iI ~ ! ; a. 0 .s:;. 0 " 'i~~ 'O'U>.- ~ D E g..sg 1 8. 8 tJ ~ tJ U " -a 1:] ~ ~oS~ ,2'Uo ,ii,; &.~$ !! f S ~ ji\B! .. ." .2 .!i tJ>..Jl ~fi-S-5 - u "D o ~ " ;; .. 'U C II ~ a. .. "i ~ C ., III tJ .s:;. .. " .. oS a 'i .. o c oS 'ii u .s:;. .!! = .. 1'0 ';; " f: ! i::-"ii I: ~ ]~ P;; U " I: 'Ug, !l 0 ]: ~ : g u ~ ~ ~ c E 9 'i 'U ~ .. u 'U " .; u 'U C 0 ..!l u ~ .. > c: u E .s:;. 11. :..2 o ~ III u C'Q ~ ,II !!! -5 00_ u 0 ~E " S.5 , [R;c~iD1. '14031 I . \1.\U\Q ~ 50.00 PROPERTY OWNER(SJ NAME & ADDRESS: ctTY OF ClEAHWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPLJCATION . I VII q,.2.IDa I ~. .JO\-\N (5) CHR\~nrJE. .s\p.il-flT~ LlOD ~I S\-\O~ b~vE.. c.L.E,{'I- Pow A~EfL BfN:\-t -f"t.. ~'+b 50 REPRESENTATIVE(SJ (if any) NAME & ADDRESS: ~ONS;t~"'TlrJE S'rA-1'\-\A-~ Lbo 'CA-::'"T S.ri 0 ~ P (U \l E. Cl-E.A~ f1'r\lE.~ B ~ FL 'R (.\ 600 TELEPHONE: ( ~ \:>) L.\ t..\ b .Q 3 b 8 TELEPHONE: (~\ ~ 1 l'.\-4. b 2..3 6 f? NAME OF BUSINESS \IF APPUCABLE): ltoo 1:"'5"\ 5\-\O~E 'b1t\\lF-.. CLE.f\RuJP..rEIL bEl\<H ~~(,.~O , , 5t\~t:l?~ ~E~ kO\"tL ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: . . ZONING DISTRICT: C B LAND use CLASSIACATION: C.1:F. LAND AREA:~R_ LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: Lo,.-:, \~, \ ~ I AJJD ,'4- \ BLoC~ B kcoR.f)/tJG- 10 ~T ot: t\~9-8ou.R-J..\o~uJ ".::iQ~b\"\S\o~ / pu.-r Rea\"::" 23, 1='",,1;. 4~5. PARca NUMBER: 0 'i? ,. Q ~ ,\ '5 I 0.l.59'2../ C!J 02.. I (!:) I~Q (This Information Is available from your tax receipt or contact Plnella& Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462-3207. If more than one percel number. attach By" x '1 Inch sheet! DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: Mor G 1- South: ~IA l)L\.c. YA-R\I..(tJ6- 1M A-Rl (lJA East: MDTE L West:_RE1'''' \L VARIANCE(S) REQUEST (If Variance to 7 year amortization requirement. refer to Sec. 134.0151: \. ~ ~~r:h-Nc...'i.. ~o~_.----k-No'N---CotJ f'Q~,r..t \ t-l Cr _~ooF 'S\G- N LocA-"'~{) O~ \""'~ SDLl\EA-~\ ~~rJE~ 6~ "n.\C '50tJ.'t\-\ ~u\Lbl~C-" :2 . \J ~ ~ \ P't l'J c..E. ~~ ?- A tJ ON c,:) N of" 0 t' (U. \ f\) c;.. t=b \... E S" Gr rJ Lo Co'" \ .f. D eN T,",\;.. \J..\E5T s\t)t.. of \'\-\E. l-OT RF-\wEEN 1'r\~ t.E..i',H:~"L.. AtJ~ \1--\ ~ SQuT~ ~l..Ud~1 tJG--) No '\ ~E-c:n ~ tr ,\r\ E ~'S ~e.e:..T &~T6t\ c..k.. O.f ,\'l€ 'BL.4.\LPH.J(,. "QLllRE.,u,E. ~\ . f"'_ ~<.: (J, .~ ..,,-(ur ~.- I"") f{cQ \ --' ,.. -. (. . r '1) '-1"'.r- 1-\ 0:-- I "") REASON FOR REQUESTING VARlANCE(SI: (Refer to Standiuds for Approval, next pagel ~ t":. E. ~ "IT A C ~ \:. \) pA-&e s . . CONTINUED ON ItEVEHSE SIDE .1 . o 0 ,. . STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A veriance shllll not be granted by the Development CGUD Adjustment Board unleu the application and evidence presented clearly support the following cO''':'!~~:ulll:. . 0( , , 11) The vltrlance requested IIrises from a condition which Is unique to the property in questIon and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made In the llXecutlon of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit sholl not be con&ldered to be situlltlons which support the granting of a variance. ; (21 The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property Involved and the strict applic!ltlon of the provisions of this development code would result In an unnecessary hardship upon the !lppllcant. . . . f : (31 The variance 1& the minimum neceS!lary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the hmd. , . (4) The request for a verionce is not based 'primarily upon the desire of the npplicant to secure a greater financial return from',the property. , (5) The granting. of the variance will not be materially detrimental or Injurious to other property or Improvements In the neighborhood In which the property Is located. 16) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of ,the community, substantially increase the congestion In the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or Impair the value of surrounding property. ' ' . (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience. or general welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and Intent of this dcve,lopment code. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENT~T1VE): C/~l,~t/...'7 _ t-.t;;f/r.aLf. "I . . . ' , " PA~SPPA.Tlif'ld~:;;Z;3J t, (G-~Ek-ClE.) , '. ~ Sworn to end subscribed before me this /J - day of /fI" p E"' n BFA. A.D., 19 9;2.. by C2./1 RJST/NA ...s rlJ rH AS . who Islate' pef5onally-kncwrrnnne-cr-ho9 Ihave produced P A ..:s...s ) ~ t.? P. 'r / hy"" "",D ,I as identlflca~lon per.sonally appeared deposed and stated the ,matters and facts set out heretn are true and correct to thl! best of ,hfso/her knowledge and belief. .ect~ / . kl'~ -TE~ N ~I"'~""p' -"lP-T"k _ No sry Public, Commlss on No. 7 tJ J'.P ~ ~ NDtUY Public. Shill 01 nOlida My CDmrniuion ExpilCl Sept 12. i993 NOTE: ,PROPERTY OWNER on REPReSENTAT1VE MUST JtTrrNO'HE.AR~NC~".c, Rllv. 8/92 " i .' , ..: , .. REASONS FOR. REQUESTING THE VARIANCE. ~ ~ c, The vital role, our signs have, to the inflow of tourists .in our .bussiness, and also the lack of an effective alternative solution, if removal take~ place, are our two strongest reasons .for, requesting the variance. Both of the signs are located in sites that are very im~ortant fqr the survivability of our bussiness. The root'. sign, located at the southeast, side of our lot, ide~- tifies our motel to all the tourists that come from'hiway 60, , which is the main artery visitors use to come to Clearwater .1' 1'1 I Beach. This signa1so plays a serious role in attracting prospective guests to all the motels located on East Shore drive. It gives a clear signal to visitors that there is an area on the north side .of the Causeway where they can find acommodations. Removing the roof sign will'have very negatIve effects not only to 'our bussiness but also to the other motels on East ;, Shore drive. The pole sign, located at the west 6f the lot , also plays. vital role in attracting visitors from poinsetta avenue and the beaches. Without this sign our motel will be'completely r . unidentifiable from the west. . . The second and most significant reason for for ~equesting the variances, is the absense of an al terna ti ve option if removP<+s takes place. Our buildings are constructed in such a way that there is no wall space to be used for wall sign. The existence of the I many windows on. the buildings, on both the firs t a.nd second .1 .' j I l ", .1 .," >. .' , , , ' \"", , ~ ' ; I ~ .: '. \' .-. (, I. ~, ~ ., . . u ....'. \. l i j' ~ (.~; i I' ~, .'. .:'~.' ~ '~l- ..~\:! > 1.: 1\ : "~, ", ; / , ' 'j..' I. < .~ : ., , 1 . .'~ : '. : .J \ . ~ t ). , ~ \' r '<'.' ~ . ! ' ~ ; ~l: .,: < ": ' ~',~ \ ,~': ;..~,': < .~l. I ~. r 1< ", -; \ 1 j".... . \1,. ~ : ....t " II II. I.' 1';::~!,!;~;:;':k"tL~~: ....;, hi." :',;' ji"""";' '. ;, ,'. ., 'd ,.. ., ' .. . i" .~ t.' . ~ . ,. .,1 t ~. { ~;. . ., , .1. , 1 I' , , t. '1 ,. , , .. ..'" .. . " ';.r \ . ~ i . '. '. ; ',: ~ . " .' J ~. . I"" l: . ',I. ".' \ , .~., .,....." > /' .'. . . ,. .,. ,1. .. . ~, . l' . I: ., .I; .~ I . r, <. ',1' <,.- . , ..,. ," , .' I,. ! :, . I " \'. \. . <. "", ,., , , ';. , .: ; t:' (., ' .....: ,,'::/ j',>"< ~,'t ,.l..> 1__ "\ ,\:1 ,i ....., .1 ",,:,,' ;. . \,' "<~')1"~:'1'>' t."t ).:l,:..~.+j~... ~ ~~J':""""""'~'ojM,.t_~.. ...._~ .............>~... . :;,~~ -........--:. ~.<.. , , .' I'~ . , ~'" ~..-t...... _...,,-.. ._...__............. ,"~_.... "--- ..... ,~ ..' ~ ~ " . '. . 1......._...._"'-'.. ..' ..._....~- .' ,. " . .,''4- : . .,. , " r>, .t'. r " ., . " :"J I' l ! I , . ' "t -, L C . ill ,. floo;r" . does .' I nQt, ailowfor 'adequate wall space for '. signs ., . to be .,. , .1 ,~ \." made. ., Removal of the. existing, signs would l~aveus .with three. I.. . ~ ' ,II ,.' 'I " buildin:gs of unindentifiable ., . use and it would cause devastati:ng:'-' ~:~ results \- to our bussiness~ .' ". i.. t). ., I'" . ~~, . , !,:l. ' ~ L: , :.i '. " " r . ~ : .., ..; ., ,. ,l~ :, . ,., 'I;) ,. .",:1: I :. ~ . : ~ ~. ,. , Il,1 _ , ,. " .,. .'. ., , . ~. t : , ~ ;.' ' , , I. ,. , ,. ',.: " . . I.' ,. \ :' ~ .t,.' do" : : ~,' :'c'):'., . \ I . . " ~.' , " ~ , . >' I.' . c,.., ~ :.t ~ ' ;>' ... '. ~. I , . :. . . .. , ~ , , ... ':, , , .." , , .~' ., '. . \.; : ~ . :. ~ e :' .-to ... ., c:': " ;".". , ": 1',. i" ~h . 1.: ,., ,t,'J \ : ~'. " f " ~ " ~ '.< '< . : 'I. ,.. , I ,~. -. d ~I\ , \"0, ~:.:. ,f ,. ;-.+ " :~.";I L\ c I. .," ;, . : t , '" ' I' 't., , ~:' ~ .. :r; 'l i'" . ~.' " ;',! >. "\ , . ",' j:: . I, : + > i ~ ",.,' . . f ~:, ,: , , ' .. 1'-" ',' :.~' . ~ ~ ' .,. ..!,. ., ' , ,. , . , . '(II, d' , ~.~ . "' .,.~; J._' ~,. j 'f '. ~." t. . ~ , . ' .' ~ ., ..:. . .": \""'." ,. 1'\: : .. . !', ~ ' , ., .' . \ ::. , .. .., , . '. "' "1 l,' j' I " . ~ .' ~, , .. ,. '. ~l i " .' =,., \ f' '.. . I '.. I' , " t ,. ., .1. " , . ., " 1-', :. '~ ..; '. ',., . . ~ .' . Ii ,.' .;, . t ,. , ,. ,. , , 1:" t . ~ . ;." , . , ~ T ' .! , . , .'. ., , , . \ " ' , '. '. ,\ ,. ~. F , .. ' ., <.1 :.... , ., , , t :, , < ... ( ,. .1' I' , , .' " "., ,. , " '~ ! . ' , \. ., , ",. ,. , ,'~ , ..,'" . , .' . , , ~ " ~, , '. ;" r " : ~, ,.! , . , " .,< " , . . , c. !.. .,. ~' , : I ~ c , ' ~ ~ " ~, :. ,. , . ~ ~ I .. . ~ !' .L'!" '" ,. :, .,: I, 'i' ': ' :' , . , " , , t' ,\ ., " ' ,'. , .', r "c /~ . . ~. ~ '. ,'. j. 'I': t " t. " i .. I . - ~ . ". . ~ . ct: i' .' , . .,' .., \. . i.. ., . ,t \ .,'. . ,Il ; , , . ~' .01 I'). ." .'l' .; ~ " .i .,' '. t ~. " , , , .' I; '. .'J ',>1 , ~: ,. . r ,~ ( '.' ,. .J I ..' , , L' .... \ , , , . ,.. , . '. . , .. 'r \ , . : I ;:( t\ ~ :"":, r . . ,. . .1 .', , ' , .' " ~ ft. , ',' . , . ., ,.< ; Jt L ... . t I, ,; , ) ~,t ' , I . l i. ' '; c , . I . . .'111 .<'"~~_... . , r, I, . . I ~ 0\1\ N .as owner of the property described as 1 i , i i I I ! I j I . LOT '5 l2 , I 3 I .p.-rJ \ 4 13 kco(2. D I ~ 0- oPrRC\nw fI.{~~~I:" uJ. St15i)'.J \ ~;QtJ It\...AT '000)::: 2. ~. fME tf S . ,I ~ n t-J ~"\f\. tJ'\ \ tJ ~ '5-c1><\ \-\ ^ S to nppear before \he: '1D pU\.,. O~ do hereby authorize . r---l L-J DcvcJopmcnt Code Adjustment &anJ '(Variance) .. r-1 L-J. Planning &. Zoning Board (Conditional Use) ~ L:-...J City Co,mmission (Alcoholic ~verage Distance Variance, Sign Variances) j ,I ! . I , I to .requ~t approval of \} Q.'1..l 'Q..\J\ c -e ~& . ' . "'~u.) n : 'u.\J$1)V\f S2...LuI~ ..s16V\.-~ SUbsc~it~ and sworn to (or affinned) bCfo;e me thi~sL of J)eflem be R I A.D. 19 (}I.Q by 2x)~ ~' S~a.. \ hq So , who is personally known to ~e and hIlS produced , tfA<'~ ,..,1111.... d.od .....' oj t"'"f"V'Y IJ df'rUtdb", \=1D~1 'i) r-t $,.. IlJf ~ I. I C en S e as identification. (l)Tt oJ lM~Il},..II,,") STATE OF FLORIDA . COUNTY OF ~~'h(J.l\q ~ ~r-;'- )114t1(J.~ [~1- ..i zW~ -:p~e:~..rYl'uhlic. ,CommiS5i~n No. C Clk 'i q 7 t . . ~,I?1fl(). Jl!1- 6iJmlk2,tNnmcnf N"'aT~ .ypcd, prlOlcd or ".m~) NOl'.\1C \' runl Ie s . ~I\' C:lHl,ur:t:ilmi i..{'gr~WJ" !'f.Il/IIIM, .rdVI,au ICltWw ll1rw Nor,'II'i' !'/Jur"! ":-c:, 11:, ,~~." .It 11:>:11, ,'1\\ nil 1.",1. , i I' ".,1." " I. 1; .." ,\ . I ..} . L:,I':,,' :\:< ~ ., . , " \. ~: (. ,;, :, ~ . ~. . ., ,. 6. ' i"', ~ ' , 1. <"i, ." ,- o < " : ~... ~. '. ~ t . c ' > . < ..! .. : ; ,. _ ~ ~."" . . Ij-t-i'''I'~'''' i . ','~".'o"""H. r',,,,',. . i~\:":'L~::!'~ .. 'r+;\~:~<~~.}~:~'(~>~. ;~,:, ,. I. .. i.' ,.. ;! ....1. ,', . .~ t '. . ~ " . \. . , I ,.. ,If . ., .. . :: /" '. . ~ I . . " ':' ~:r ",' '.\: ~< .';; ...," ,I ,U/... ""'J' ~ r" > '+ '. > l .' " c . ~~ t < T ~ 'I- ., . ,. .. .', oJ '., .,' h '.' o{\ S/'tV\ f Ck.-" -'r-. ':' o V\ S6CA~ J'-i-l V..(J .~~ i~dlti~ .,. ., t .,. )RD~:. . 0 . .' ',. \..; ....', n ~ ~ '.'._l~,> .' ~ t I. o ~. ~ , , '<+,>." . A[i~~ -= . l.-:) t.{- ~..r. . J ;.' .' 'I " .1 , j I. : ,Ii ., . , I.: .' " : .}' . .'" ,l " ., 'Y ~ ,> . I, . " >, , . /1.1. '.';1 j-, . J. :' .1 .' ~ . J\ ". . ~ . ~' " ,I ..1; .\ , ~ " l.. '. " .r , . '~ ~ . .,. . ~ ~ . , " , i . ~': (G 'f'~'., f' ~"-,..- ~-~'-'-~_ ~~' ., .",......._........_......~_....__._..._..- --...-........ \ .- ..l:;:::::.. =:Ja_."j--A ~L:.n.; . '~ :-~'~~.. ,~. ,. ,. . <3 " .~ :''0' ' lJ'\\..-' . ,., :." t" . , . I \~. , ,. ~. ~. " ' . , .\ , . , . I~ I <of '.l {.' ., ,. ., . yf~. , , .;;t , . .' I " I. " (. i, ,. , -...-_.-_--~ _._- ......- ~.--- ~ ,. , 'J. , '. " ., .t ~ ,7 ,I; " 1, .' . , ': , , >l .1 .' ,. , , .' ,. --:;TP_ , .'. ; . : ---~ ...~~.._.....__...__.,J. ..___---.....~ C f ~. .r I, . , '. " , , , , ~ r , ., ., .. ., ! .' !, .C._ , " .1 " I,. , ,. .. , . ., {' " , , , ., , , " , , . .' '\ ". ., " '\ ',- ., i. 1. : c~ ~ . , , ..C 1. .,. ,', II , ,. " ., I, 'l \: > .' .,' ,~ I . ',', , , d .f , , ~.I . ~..:' ;r~: . ''',~' ~ . ,. , '. "1'- ~'_ ~ : ,;. '~. { , .' (, ,,:. . " t ~ , ~~ I.' ",1 . ~".:.' ... \ ...............--. oi_ ................. .__ _ ~_.~~ I' .J .pD Ct:- ',S \ G-tJ .. C0N po "N SE:.T.ri~\. sr .. . .' ! !. I. , .. , ' " ,. .' ,; " .~ .,j\ (2.. E .j\ I 1 ~. '. . '. G)'2. s' ..Fi- "'2- .-:v +-:, ''S.'JLi ~~ f. " I. I' " 'I' " ,. .. '. f' t , ;'. '.,) .; ~ . I,. >,1 " ., , ' :1 .'t. I,' . 'I ; . " (,.1. 'I' . I I ;. 'I ,. ., . .' :., . - ._'-'-'~-:--:-"l. ~. . ,. ~ : I" . . ~ I. . . , . "G...~? ~,r, '. ~. '''~I. " ..1 .,' .!' . , . '5.:1:? f + , I I. .. i ., ,. .. I . , '/.' .' ~ fo ft ., ----:-::t}:;~ ~s ~ + , ....- --.~. r' . r ~-:~ff,~ , .' . I I I I I. .. , I . , T"[' I , , . :\ I. .1 ., J.-() rA- '. . I . .. '\I .,/ I , I I .1, I ~ tT. .', I I , . " i ~T .', " j , I." ., . " , ~ . , .' I. , .. ' ~,:.i ' \ '/.-.------. Pa~:edll ' :" ll(~. . .. , _i, ,,' ., ,. ;,'" ,i , ,. ,., I \, .' . f !' , , .1 .' , , ' l' I , '. '.' , . .' ,. ,.. . " , , ' .f' ." Of ,. ". .., " . , ',. ~ '4' ",:1. . ',' ~, ~ I ~ ,,' ,". t: + .;~ ~. I , .~ 'to: .. I J "! . . 'j. " ." ,,(I . . , I<~~ ".. ~; '. . .'\. ~ ~'t;" .,:',;,., . . ," ~~.~ ~;j :~'., ~ :~~.' ,\ ~. ",." . :r{:~' .' .~ . , I, \ ,: ,. "'~'i1 . "~' , i I .', ",t' [;:'--.. :' ;,.:r; :~ ,.', _:, ..'J T . ~~__~ti. . ,4: :~~~ ~ '. l:'~ . .r.: (. , , , . , r .i F: :. , . , , ., I ,,;.-' ~>' , :', 't . ' . ;. . .~~ T" . , .<.' ", }~. ~. i .'. ' . ~', :',1 ..... , . . i':. ,," ,.' ..,'.... 1'. , . .:,1. " . ! 'J. ' " ~ ;U.: , I' . f . i~' . .' Zf I .~?~, 4'. " , ' . ~'. ,: 0' J, II.t,' :' --::.~.;: . . \It . ~ 1,,1 ,I.> ::".;!;' ;:~J . :~/:.:j ~ \':i~d ;-Jul .;..1.; , '/~1"': :'l~\'i . .:'l,J::., . . t, \~, ' \\~)" t' .' . \ '1,1'.. . . l\.~~'j '. I , J'} . " ,. ~. ~~ r ,'.(f" ~' ;t;-:'<' . ~.~::! ,- I, :: .i t~ . ,~i, ., ~I. ~ ,t.L . . " ~ ~ ;: Lt. ! c ;- ~i:," .H . th 'L.... ' ,.J( ,. \.l;; . 4 y.,... ")J , ,. l. I ~, ; ~.. ." ., . 7\~~"I'" ( ;> I,. I . ~ ~. ~ L' I 1- . .",t> . ,~ ~ r;., , ; .':~, ,. ..," I , .-t .", " ',. .,j , :;;: . :" :" .... . :~ < 1', t' I, , . .\ . ,./ '. . . ~ f '. .~~\~~~ ~. ' " ..~;~ . ,. , '. " ,t"' .;:1 , .' , ' ".',~ '. ,. ' , \ " ., :l' '., ,. , !. : . ~ . ., " " '. . , .; ,"; . \ I .~ I, , , ':, .....--. 'f ... . , ~~', ~.t" , .-:""', i 'j .. t' '.. i I ~ , , , ! . ~ ',. .til . , , ., . ,: :\:;y ': \!. . .~~;. " .' . \' "~~1' .~.::~ " ",> . ft... I. +. . ...:' .' (. ' r I ~. .ft~".'~'j ..... . .~ ....1 I . t: ~ f.! ,.. t. ' ,'.). ., ' ." ! "." " r.., . , .~ i. :~4 1;';" t' ~ : ~~f . . r ~"'\.. +.J. 'r~. .1, . , >~ ,'J' > ". ;>"".~~;~.;r : ..t ". I:.:. . .~: '. i:..>~ . ~ ~ " ., " , i I, I '. ! ~.. r - -... . .," .'. '. 1'1" '\ .~ . .~ J .. .. ~ , . ;." .' . :t; . ., .. .4 I ~! . I.'t : .I:.~',,} I. " . " . , .' (" . y .., ~ '. ,I " ;. .... .. " 'I, . ....... ::' .;.:~~ '1' , , I' ,.' , . . ~ " . '~.. .' ,: J'I.." . :. " . ~. ~ /. ~ .~ t.~ .' ~~:.", .~ t ' . . . ~L !. . ,. I .':.\ I' < .' "L 11:;,.,."...". . ;';wi,;,. I):....,. i t;,.jJtf , . )1'1.\ i~N". '-t:.....~.,~. ti>,~.; , . r:~~):: \' .~ ;;~\' : " ..l~.. "I'};. . :...' '!. ,:~i\ ... . ~ . sl~f':: ",', ~ . ..p ~ ' , , I . , . . ..~'!...,.. . ':~, . . ~,I';; . ",: '1' . . ~ .,1.'1 . JI~;' -~ ,~~.. ~.... '1\' ' .. tf'J' ~ ::f' 'r ,J. ~ ,.' .I,~.~~~~/..'.. '",:. ',j'!. . '.j </;!;:, . , . }J( . '" t . ~{' . ~ . .,'. t : I;.~r:": I. ',.' '''''"J . :. " ':.! ;~,~;~ . .t .,. , , ." ~~> ,. . , ., . 'i', . ~ ' ., ~ L. ,__~_k"""," ., . ,. ) ,. "." I , . ::,1. ". ~ . ~ :'.~ ': , ;. ,l , , ,. .,1", ':':~; .,.f .; ... "t' . ~ ,,' c ~:~ ::< . '>.~i :\ ~ ., ., , :. I~ , , " " .' , . f: i..T.. .J '1r.~. I ~:~;: . ~ fl ~t~ ,-- I . ':;\, jJ t,(I. It t ' .{ ../ ;, 'IN .;> . li3 : o. (j o lJ ". . , I . d -I" \ ,; I '. , ., .f .t;. 't+1:. , . I" " .., ... ~ ~ .' , 'I . .. ,I I>~'. . . ~ l . , ~.'fI",~'>" ~ . :.: ~. 1, " .,' , \ !' ", ,. \ . " , , , " " . '. " 10' ,. , ' . ,.~c I o. '.' " ., . . "i' I" . \~ ,I .. [. 'I. jt. I . .t. . . '~fr ./ : '\ ' ~~.. :-.' :\:.". u - !. '! ~'l ", ."!. . . r:.I.'i:..~"',.. , .. ".': . i::~ ..... . ,.. ,/.. tL" . < ..!~" #. ~.' . " ~. .' ~.: . F (J'&,' ,tilDe c. S. WA 1.L. / .(HIl16~,T'" ~~!~~~) --1\-"'.;)"714'-; tn.. ,.. t : : _\.~.~',. ~," .. .. . >" , . I .... .. 1 l . ~ '. .' (' ~ ,",: :" t ~ '.~ ',i, . ... t , : ,. . ':', ~ " , ~. ~ ,~I .' ,. .~. . .'r'o ;! ' ~ c :. . . '. ',' . ~~ -..1 .... .' . . 4~L... .' .,f"' r- .J I'<>\,JJ.JD o~t-1 PH"C ... , ! ,~. I, ,. .Y l. rr:JVND . !. r ere.... 'V'll' .11 ! ':, I,. 1./ I., o' I', I .:t ,] )'~ U. 0<0' ~. .. ~ f" .f" "I .i~-'-<., .r~ 011 . '.- . c ~. i .,". : ~... J. .. .' ? ,:'~ \""p: *; ~-;- . in--.1.,.......\!'> -.- ,--_._, ,-...- . I \~ ..:: :.~ ~\:""'~~Itr: '~t . .~... .... ......; : ..' . ""," ~. ,=,t 01' ~,. " .. . "': ~ '", '.: . J ~. " '/ . ~~... o.,~ .. , . .. . '!f ..,...,i.2' " ... r . . , . , . I.l, ! : n ( ;< ~ q J ,. , iPt ~s~;. Ii. ; if 'I, t. .'. 0 ~ s,; ~~~~:.( ~ :'IfI'S it J -.. ,~..1'~ lldo';''/'!>f' 11/1 ~ II ~ f4- :- ~.t. ..! ",' ... ~ P.>\J\I_J::l\~~ Z. r. ...."'ic:a~~ ...'I-.:"i.>c-M..... i.:" , A, ,. i ".; ....'" tfJ I' . I .... ~ ,~,..# ..llo ~' ,. V, J . J t ., ..,' .; , 1/ /" ~}';:' . ! ...F . ;<,11000 ..\' P::. ~ ""- 1t'I.... , , , III , , 1:1\ " , I'. I "1.......,. o-..'l..t '\4"'; ~....:.,'_...:::..~(,;,1'1t , ~ ....\"0."'" ....,,,~....,.~..... II~ .c..co EI\SrSHOJH! Pn, , ,', ,"0' '.' 'f.' , r ?~~~~:' I ./ 1 '\0 ~ .' ~,\~,-:~ 40' wno:'1." "..".. ...r,', .' . '..... 1 .:' "; ...')i'.~ '~l I'.. ,..' , . ~l: . L :-1..'":' ,.......: ' , . ~ , .', >' --..:-_~ -. ...- --t" ~.';'~ ~~...... ~ ~~~~1:~~J' '. . t r . ~'. . . . , , , . .' J. , ' 'c'l, ,.. , " l. ,', MARIANNE STREET :, .. '.' ... .. ....... ,0_ ,... ~._ ... ~ ..._ _ _........_.__ -.... - ~.-:---/- " .. , ' ~~ . .' , -_. ...~. ~...:..~,' _.._~ .. 't.~- .1;. . ,.:.~ . ('bl:>' RO'N, .\0" h,."~''''''~'oI'''''\'',\ . . . .. " '." . ~o ,. , ,) .1 '., '. . ".. ~. '" " i , '.~. >:~. '. :'.. ...,.-,' . 1 ~ ' .1,1 , ~: .. '. \.. . , " '.. ~. ' .. .... . 'ft I:'~', ., \\. . t' ~ I" 'f . , t .. '. ,:'1. " ,(~ , ':\, :;p: . ,'\:. :" .\\~ ..- " ~..1 . I,' . r ..,' L " . ~l- I 'rl,' . , ~ ~ . ,~l:: ~-.~. ,.. ~\,. ~ .........._"t...'\. , 1~_:~~~:4... , \ ... I,~: ,j' ,i;" .::' " I ~ ': '::~., .T....~) ,. .... f I r: . . ~ I ~ . '. .;'>,:. .... :.~);o. . . , :;\ ,Ot:'I. r" '.' ", .' \." ,I .~. .' , I I . .' . o ifq . "'':-'0 tt ~"'i , !)-. ~.' Ii" " \iL. . I' ....;..:, , ':.,' ,t . ~ ~L : . ';~..~ .'~' 1 ....----..,,'.j': . ,,"I .. . :. ~ l. .. .() ., t,;, ~ '.... . ";,.. , '. . .',' t . . :.~.~, . . . .' " . i:! " '77 "!!J /13 '/1 /1~ ifI to pj' HI !!~ .:.!!! ".Jll~- "If" .73 fr' lIfE fj;<l1I !1'~D1ZJ 'U" ~\C.f .s~ 7~ .n;Pi 1J:i..n "'~tt llr-;;- ~-188 l!&. lU.:!lff · "1 !!!..:....f" 1Ir "U, -n - Mf-~~ "'-" ,. ',r ~ .. .80 '1 fiJ """--- .l': ~- In;;'''OJ .. '8ft W II iUUg -m ~ m-m !![?t:t .t:~$! !!!~fU ..'''~ ..J 'SO .~a !ff~~ 5.:';!! --;:'ii n,.;;f:J .51,<1 g-;;tJ. " uo I, l! W.II 10- gO o .... ::1. ...... '7$ · C\J ;;;--;-"1' "'""4 -/'C'--"I 7'V:V , WI -~l:l ~. . iii -=~- ." tn ,n .. >-1 .n--- ill~~ In " u. 0.. Q; r'1 r.., ~ .!t: ~ ~ ~ '4 t.> CR 28 AL/C 5H'-212ft S J 9 3" '. :13/01 .ltp 00 J 9-3Dt It Oil J950- )- 4 1;1 917 .:s 0 '< 5 c Q zoo J >1 ~ ~ II: 0 eo u I ~o _---...- P/SP ~._- II 7 ~ B C"USEW^'f c;-,,~ ~;~~-. 12 $ ~ N ' -'11 .' ,u' ~~ ~ -\ 'V Ii " .. <.l ~ . 0 Q >t ~ ~ N u AL/C fOS/ R i t i tc I! ~- .. 1 ~ or W^ Itrl lCl r oti \ y ~a VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS . A MOTI2'.L. NAME: 7A.~DPIPE:.R SV#.qZ-IOQ PUBLIC HEARING ATLAS PAGE:RlO1A SEe: 6 ~ CLEARWATER CITY DATE: TWP: .2~ RGE:~~ E. COMMISSION ~ s. ~ Q; "\ .~ '~h la . I I I I .., r.: ) .. -0 ... :l U III .c .. ... o ;..0; o <:> 10 .n = " ''l r: o .~ c ~ I I I a I , ~' ... '-- / . \ ", \t.. . SV#92-100 CITY OF CLEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE TRANSMITTAL TRANSMIT TO: Cvrhhla Goudeau, .Clty Clerk Phil Charnock, Earl Dussault, Stephen Sarnoff: ZonIng Review Stephen Doherty, Zoning Soctlon Supervisor Case Assignee MEETING DATE: . CASE II: SV# 92-100 lEGALfAODRESS/LOCA TION/SIZE: Sec. 06-29-15, Lots 12, ~ 3, . and 14, elk B, Barbour . Morrow Sub.l400 East Shore Or./0.39 acres M.O.L. OWNER/APPLICANT IBUSINESS)/REPRESENTA TIVE: Stathas/Sandpiper Motel/Stathas . VARIAN~E(S) REQUESTED: Variancels) to permit nonconforming signage to remain: 1) Variance of 12.5 sq. ft: to permit a total. of 62.5 sq. ft. freestanding signage area 21 Variance of five feet to permit' a freestanding sign to extend 4 ft. 6 in. beyond the street rIght of way Hne 31 VarianCE! to permit a freestanding sign in CB Zone without lS'mlnlmum bldg. setback. 4~ Variance of 16 sq. ft. of attached sign area to allow total of 64 sq. ft. 51 Variance to allow a roof mounted sign to remain. CODE CITATION (Chapter, Section, Para.graphl: 1) 44:51 (4)th) l.b 2) 44:51 (4)1h) l.d 31.44: 51 (4 I(hl1.a 41 44:51 (4)(hI2.a 5) 44:51 (4)1h}2.b DEVELOPMENT CODE REOUIREMENT(S): 1) Maximum area: 50 square feet 2) Minimum setback from properly line: 5 feet 3) Minimum structural bldg. setback: 15' 4) Maximum area: 48 sq. ft. 5) Prohibited signs: Roof and above-roof signs. ZONING/LAND USE PLAN OESIGNA liON: CB IBeach Commercial)/CTF sunROUNOING LAND USES: IPloase refor to attachod map for 2:oning/LUP dosignation of surrounding properties) NORTH: SOUTH: EAST: WEST: Motel Public Parking/Marina Motel Rota,1I ,........ + CITY QFFICIAlS WISHING TO COMMENT MAY DO SO IN TUE SPACE PROVIDED BELOW (COMMENTS SHOULD BE RETURNED TO THE CITY CLERK AT lEAST fOURTEEN DAYS PRIOR TO THE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING). ., k . . ~ . ,. . -' (:.J::...... 'La.......... -.:,,10../\ ..4-r~ \ . ~.A.. u...~~----- ~f'-<-~~. c,'~ J~ ~_..};,- L...:t... ~ 0 .'-J . \ I , CI.? ~. W\cv~ .:g'1. -'. ~ / '1 ~ · FOR PUBUC HEARING BY THE CITY COMMISSlON ~t.Jl ~.~ ~- -4'; ~~ I ;l,.- TRANSMITTED BY: ~ark A. Hively DATE: August 9, 1993 wp/svt92100.scs ,.. . fO..: . . ~r . ....:... " ., " ' .~ '/. .> ,. ., . " , ~~I, ~ , :t .i.:::' ~ .' 'j r. ~~, !. I ; " ~~ < ~ ,/ ~. r' ,,)' '.', ,\[:i \. ;, 1 ~ ~< -f~", I + ~ . , '.' H, .. ..,::. . ,,' ", ' , " t' .. t.....,~. . .'.' .' . ' . ' ,. t.:....,.....' .C., . '!'. , . . . . ,! w.'. .~.',i .;; ;.'.,., '. ': ',' . ,.. .,..,.. ,'. ,.',. -! ,.. ..', ,: .;. ,". '. ~ .. ';" ".",. ;'" ." . ..... .' lnF:':", '~',i{{'X;.;: (:>,: . ", .:':.. ". " ':' ,:" ."'.~ l. J ....: /' / ,. t';"" , ..' ::"".'.:-,,.. ,~.~.~\..,':'.:~'.'."..:'.\",...",.~ ;< .~,{>'''', . ...', ...,; .",., j .' ....::<.-:;:: ". 1~;,;;,i';':~i!ji'I~;ii~;j;,~';,.{.t,:,f.:i.\;!i~:;i.L.;.;.::,;i;i, .:Vi,;",'",;,,;:'!',. .' ,:;", ".:;: .~.' ". ;.':'....' ~,;:'. .... . . '::<:: k"i. "I I. " ". .>1:- '.:.. "...../.;.':.:<.;~.~:..,\!,... ',.,. 1, ,.. , '1"' ,'l u,-" ,I 1 ,:1 <l . . ., . ) ..} . , +. ~ . ~ i, . ~' I '".'" ',.. :; \', ," " . .. ).' .' ,. . .' ;", + ~ : ' .,' !.;.~., ...f ....'"... . .)./~ .,. . . t" f., :"..l~ ~,. ~,~' ,', ;"\ :: ..;<)..; .... ' ~;; I' f.;'."..' .. ., '.. .:;,. '.\.<':. '..,,:' :.. ..' ~. 'I,. '...:/ ;;,', ' ..,' , . :,'.' :,. ,. " ,..' ,. :.",~."~I,,;;~::. ,".;.,;:: ',.:.' ,....'. .1 " 1.' '~';I : l \ ~ ;' }. c . ~ ~ \ ~. I . i , ':.. i' . ;.: .:::.' ," ,:- .~ >"", ': '; +. :,,," !,:, > :.~:);',: .;: '.'., ~.~; . J ":::'"~,~~~ ...~. .'\: ., J" . . ~/1 ~'l-. :~~ .... ., < ~ \ 1" , .1 ; , :./ ~. ,. , , I" . "c' . \ .; ~,} ~ , .. ~: ).. '" ~", . ~ !.' \': . ',";.' " .1." .;!....r.~\:' "t.. \ . "t'.;: .' i'~l', ..'. \' ':t' It " 'i... ,. ',~ ~'". . '/: . .j, .. ., " " ,'t,' .,' It." "i. f ,.,' .... " '{:! .~~~,', ~'f: ".'. .. ~. '..\ .. ..' ,l '.. "':, ~u' ' .j. . .. 'c .; . ,.. .; 1 L .'/' c' c ,. , ,.. ,.. " ,. ~.i . . /:: I {. . ,,~ t , ;, '...f: .....,~,.,.,...:,.". II ,.1"' '. ~ . ~ ., ~ ~ "..,. '.....M'.. .' '. ~ . ~ ~' : I . .; . ,.ft t\ , ' .,' ,. '! l'~ ~ ,," ,~',," ,:\ ", 'I :1',. ...~.... 4' '. ~ . . . . T.r ,~: .\ ~~ . r ~ . .' .,; ~. t'; ;_. ~ r ' .' ........\+:t .' ~ . ~ . , , , I ! , ,',.. ,./. ..~t' C.<, .'"l ,. , , I , , . :....~,' ~ : ~ .., ',. ~ ~ . ~r1 'I' . )q:f.r" ., ~ " ,'.: ~ ".:~': \ -,' ...: .1': . . .. .1 ,., ,. t. i.!.+.c ",', . . i' t: ~ ! ' .', . ;. ' '.. s.' '." \:. ." ..'''(~.~~.~Q..,,':~ :,' ;.'.::. r:~ ,'. :,:' ;." .." . : ;,} ...' " .,. 'I: ~ : / ' : _ ~ T '.' _ : . ,', ~ .i I .' ' '. ,. .,., j'{. ':,'" " ....' ~. . .. '. :i:. , ' ' ......' .' ,. ;1 :~ ( '. :'. \ I:~' ..',., ~ ,'. ~ ~ .; , '. ~ >,- ': '.: " .' " t':... \.~ : t ~ , , ). ;.... <' .. . ~ . . ~ f' ,\.,t, >:' .:;L'" ,;.:;>:. .,....:. .'.J',.. .,1 . ' ,." ' " i' f ; :' .. ."., .. .', :. . ..... '." .' "., ", ' .. .'" " . ,.. ",. .. . '.'" .....,...;/.. ." ......, . ..,...... '." .... .... . '. '. ,'., ..' .., .' .' .,' <: , ,,' ,',: ...... ." ..1.j , .......' ,,: . " .:..," ,:/i'.i". '.. ., ,', <.C : :', n.\:,;'~-;i .::~~.~.. . .....:< ',. <. '. ,.',~ ':",,::/' ,'. ...: :,':,;:;: .., '~'i I .: .;:, .', .' ", ,.' .:. '.. . ,":. :i',:,:(,. .,. ".'(!., .:':', .<.:'" ..;.;';'.. .>:-;'.:: . . !:.;:..,':':,~.;:'i..',',":") 1,\ !"'..;.':r.; .,.. ,'" '. ", .' . ' . ,,' ....; ,..,' .' " ,"~'i r.. ...,.~.}_..,< ';..,i',".~"->l ....l.I\..:.:~~., ~. .,~;,.'.,.,l',...,"...'. . " , : " ~ :. ' .,.'.T ::.':.,.' ..," . '. . ..'.:.',. ..:.:,.:> .', ,. :'.:; ,... .'.,.'. ,j.I,... .. ~/...:,. ',.'. I .'..:...'.... .:,.... ." .. .:. ,..... . . .; '. ," .' . .' . ..., . , .. ...... ..,':,. '.,'" ' . ,:';\>:",,:. "Y.)C..;" ,.<;,\ .. /"';. . ,'. .;/:. ..:.... . ". '..' ",." .' '.' .",,, ... :-.;-, ,.:,.. :;.. ;.,... . .,.".;.... ':. ....'i.... .....,.::\..; '''..''.'.~' '..' .'.; ':' '.' ,";,..>.:, . ':;'. ::.':,... . ," . ,-..... '. : ,"',' "', '.' .. ,.,.... ..j'.. .;::. '. .:;' ." . .." '. '. .., . ,.' :. .' ....'. .' .,... " .. '. ..' Il ,,\,.,.J.'~~'" .;. ,~...,.,..\.'~ ," f', ',,~ '.'.,'t'.. '" .. '. ,; '.: ,'. ..(: , ;, -'. .,. , . .;' ' ." ' ..i' .,'. ' . ." ..' ",' . '. ..' "." . . ,....''''.,,'' .. '.;:,: >:::/t,'::'." i", .... , :, . ,,:,'.' , ;. :,,;; · \. ... :.. :. . .,.. " . . :; . . ,', .l ..,' , ~, .".; C. . ,-,-",: ,; . ,..,. ;':\. .,." , ,.. . .,:, . , . ' " " ,.;.:,. : , 1" ,,:L .. . ,,:;. . ,. , ..';. ~>>:f>/',. .,;"' ,. ~ '.;~ . ~ T > . ..," .,.'. .... , , . " ., : .' ;.'. ~ ,.,: , "., . " :::~;')(:'~:::.: ; ~ ", .... . 'L,.':.i,': :\.', .d . i.' .., .rT.... .... <. ,',:- \ ,.. ~ :~ ',., ,', . ~.~ L: ;\",;:)~f: :...:V.:::.; ..}... .. f I ~ . . ." '..,,' I' _J!'. 'I '.' ". Ii t' .~,' , ~ ~ ~ .. '''. ' .1; \..' , 1:'\ .' ,. . i' . ," ,; .:, .. ,. ~,.':~:~:: ::/::.r.r:.:t .. .~'. . \ ~ ~ . ' , . . ~ . ~ ", , ' ,. ,. ,.. . ~1 t' J.' f" . . : ~ . . '.,. .:. ~': ... "'.' ~ t . > :; ... I. ,. ~ ,,' ;'. '\.f .', ":.H'.~ . :..', ; .. ,. i,..::.. ~ ..... < > ~ .~ : . :1 ," ., ..' . ~ ': <." \. 'I:"..'. I :.: .~~ .'~.. " ' .:'T~ , ..;f.' ! ' I:~ Ir~ ~:{.:: c . , ,. ; jo ~ ~..( I . .,:>' r l, ~ :l ;. ~. J', ',. .,' I t '.:~' '.i:i .'1'''':: .' . , ., ; .., ..', . .,. ~ \. ;,. , . ~ i .' ',." 11 ; .'. ..' ';. ," ,. .," .J. , : :t. . . ~ I ; ! ~ - . . , .J, .' ., \, . .-. ,..) .\ . . , I. . ~j . ,. .. :.0 . ., , .; . ~ 3.. " ;'j!CC ;... .. . , . , ,. . , . , ...., ;...... , ,. ".' . " . ~ ~ . ,,"~';;y; '.,~:., , .;, ...t: ',:,(' . . l,'. ;" J, , I" }, -\ '. ~' , r ./. ,.j' , ~.. { ., . cl,. 'j . " , ....c. i..: I ~. +.t, ~> .l . ,.,' ... . p '~ I :, . .; ~ . .~ ~.. L I . ~ ; I"~ f .:"1, .'J ;. ..\ ,'~ . ~ ' , ~ " ',I :.~ f :..; \ . , . ,~ .,' ;." !' ., .\,'" .1 i':" :v ~ '; ~ , .1,.. .,.~, ' ., . ',:'" . , .! ....~ '~ ' . .: l'~' I ~ . " ..,:0.' .1' ~.~ ;...:.:; .':' l :1." .:).' H : ..:'::?i:~:\.' 1" ", L " '. 1.< ; ~... :' ~ ,.,; ~ ~. -I . ," .." ..1: . I' .' ~, ,., "Tt "., ,'F ~"\~t: ;: . .1 !---:.~: :~.l: " :.~~'~ (~:'}</c" I,. ;, . '.'...' ,I" .,. .~T " .! .'; . ~ i':~ > ,. .!...:r' ;, :'. " . . i: ; . ~ ~, . ;.;"1 , ~} , . ,~ ., , 1.'- ,: " ". T f.:' ~ r t ' . ~ ' : ~:, ., ~'I .. , c , ~ ~ } .. } . ., , , ' ., f, '~~~" ; \. \. .:". 'i \ , , I. ;) .' 1 "\:0:' ,. :\ . ~~): /: .', ;', '.'1 . . :.i f.' I; :':, .". ,. .' '~ ,-,' , > ..' . .' .:' . ." .. , , : i:.-, ~. .,: . ~ ~ ~ . )'.,. .: J " l~.' I :i, .~ r . " : J~' ~ ; '. . .' \. '. /.~ : .~. .. -0" : .~ ~ t.;~. ). .... , ' ~; j .'" (<L'.', " ~ : f . I; .: .. ~J.; . '.) . ~ .,'. .... , .c,;: ,1 !~ . ,~ ' ' }. . , . ",:'. I . + ~ : ~ ," . '." .~. ., I' .' .'.', f :. :/ , ~ . " t..+. ;':' ~. . . ' >c,';.\ '.';' .1... . . I . I, t ~ , , ,... < . .~. ; I > .,' f'I>:: ,>. .. ~.'! f /~ T T ',. .,,,' ~ ~ t:. ~'t ~ l'~ c.~ ...,\ i i '. . ~ .' I.' .j. t: ~.. , '>', .: '" 1 . ~ ., , . 'J ~ ': ~'-\.~ '1' ,. ~', ",'. ~I +:t. , . ,., '.. ;:..', '.:.~: :. > . ': (~. ,.' :. ~ . ' ,., . r:.. .,. . " '.j : 1 .\. '..J. : . ..' ~ .1"" .' '. 'I I, " d " ... .1. .', . \ '.' t 1- I' ... .':> . . .'0 , . i '. ~ .-: \' ,. ~ ~ ~.: ~ ;L '. ~(I :. . t ~ ; ./) . ~ t ., ~ < ~ . " ". . t'i \ , . . +~, \ ' . , : ' , , .1 , ,.f i.;., . ~~, . ~ ~ <. ~; . .:t. " ~.... . , ' ,. . .\. ,'. .:','1 .,' . I I. .\ . \. .' ~ . ; ~! c . ~ . I" .:. c ,. It' .., t'..o '....: !. ..;f , ' " .I : ......:d. ',. ~ '. ,/ , , '.' :.. "1 .'. ~ ( f.1. ... ". ~ ." , . ;~ ....,L.' " Ii' "..<, ;". ",r' :~, ~ . I ',,-. " "'!c 'I'. ~ \. .',"// :~i: d .l. \' t!i~Ji,.'..:~,. , ~.,:~'~~~>:i. ./ ft", ' . . ~ . ~I..., .: : ~. .I> 1.<' LJ;;l:~~~~ ~,;!; . I" " . ',. ~ /0;. .L~ ! ; ,. ~. i. t"' . t: " J" . l. !" ,'. it:; ",... l:-~J' ~~ '. :'/ J .. I ' ~, . :- ~ ::.i' c. F~~:, ft,:::.<. ~. .. ~ .' i' ~ ,:1 ~. <r . E ; ~ .': : 1 ~ ;, ~ ,~...,'" i ,l' r .,',. ~J . , , . ., .'d. \1.'" .1 ..c. . ~:"'" ..j .j. "\ '. ,. . , . " ~ : . , ".'.'. .:. ./ .'. ,. l,t. , , .; ., i.!.' \. ./: ::l; ~ . I,. ': ., '. ~ /- t. i . . , ~ : ' t ~ . , . '. " c :\ I ,; . :; ./ :..{. .. . ,'. " ;..' . <' ;. ,.oj . ., ..' , ,:, .l . ,~. I , ..1." .. , . ! ~ J, ...... T .' , . ~. '. " \ :l 'l I ,. . , :/ ,. " 'I , <I: f:' ., <c,. ,.. ..,'~ C'I' I . :. .' . ~ ~ ;'l'r: ,.. ~ .t t + ,:: .:. i ~, !~" '"~ \.'. i. ,.' " ,.' ) " . ,. ,'.\',," , .., . '" . , '.! . ., ~ . ., .', :1 't,' . .' . , . .,','.. '} t. :...~...C\ {,\.. t'\- ,I. .... '.! ':.." t , ~ . I.: . .\ it.>::.,:~,;,,;~\: 'c;,~~ ;'}'.',~' t: ,:.:-:. .'.': ';'(;.,,( , ~ I ., ,.. T .\! : , J', " .j" .,\' .. .,. .'. 't , .,. . . .\, 'l~: 'to '< '." ,," "- p. .~. : '\.': .( ,I" .... ,. . ,. . ~. I ,'\<,:" ~ ~~'.~~' , .,.~,;'II...\ :..~ ~ ,J , " ~ ~.. 'p ;, .\. '.j. !. ....-.: ... ~.u' , "..,'=-,1, , " .: "'i..~ '(r,(' .\ .. ~ ..... :'1. .4, . :,', .,;. 1, :'t. c.l. ... '. , , "" ..' .' . ",I .,. ,\' , .... . ". ,.t. ., , ., :." , " ! . .:.'ft' .~ . C P . . . '{. ; ~ .j. ~. ! l , ., ., , "" .... .1' ;' ,., , '. ~ . ' ,. !" . " i. .. , .,t. " . . . ~ C 'J . ~ !.. . r , ' ,.. \ .' ;.t ..1..... . .,' . ~ ,. .'. r. ,. '. . ~ .'. '.. C ~. .; '.. i ., i .' . '. ~ )' . < . ~ ,,' .' '. ' l.i . E _ ~ .... " ..'\. ;" " ."0.\." . I .. ~'. ."t . ~ I .. t ~ '.' l. .\" ., . , . \ '. 'i! ; ; r '/:.' ~ . IJ , '!. . 'r ( . : ~'_ ,l- .j '! 1; .:. ; ., . ;~ ~ ". .): I .1 " ~. " .'. .'1'.: '.H ". \ ,. , , r .,. , . I ~, "' ~ , , , ., . ..~ ., j< . t.. I..' '. . ..'f . :.~ 1 h~ '.. : , ~~ < ." , . . C " ~ " , ~ . ,. . ,. j' , ,. , .'.J (~ ,. ,., . \. ',. ., . ~ C ' , . ~. .~ i:, . " .~ . ,t,. .,. .....,r.. ." ',. ..1 ; ~. " \ . , ;. " " ,.' Ii. ." \. ., , .',;' .'-+:::1. t ~ . :AGEN,DA,' 'I .: ~ . '\ .,~ ~ ',1' " ". ,. ./. /- ~ t "',' '. ..l, . \ ,., " .<, . .I'j. . .! I. \t t, : 'I .....' ; , .j It.:'; ., ., " , '" ,'. , i .; :: pc' ... .:' , .Ic J.. , ' . " .J ,., . ' ,', . , , i , ' , .' '. ' '. .. 'I ~ , . ., '2~ , . 94- ,>. , ' \ . :';A~~~:. ... .'-; ~ ;" ,: 't<,' '. i. " '<' '. ,. . , , ., , I #~2 " , .' /\. ITEM . . ~ \." ., t'l; '\ .' . , .. -.. , , .,\,. l' ;, '. ., , .,t " \ I,'J 'J . , ; . , , .. , . , . . , . .' " _,1 ; i. , I.. " . \. .' , ... ,I , , . '.;\. . ' . .' " , '. :, ., , . .~ !' ..t ,. 'I' . i~: ,\ , . ,: .J.,I" ';. ., j. ',.,1.. \.:.. ,. I ,. .', .1 ,. " ',: . ~' , 't<., .'1 " " ,. t .J: '", '.. .,. ~ " . . > .: .> '. ': .l ;. .' .' ." ". .:) \ '. , , .\1. '1 I',': 1<'. . ., , , ,...1 .: ., . . >.,~ .,... ~..... I.~, . r..' j~, \. ~ ~ , '. "'..... , . , " ,. '"/ l ~. 1/~!j11~ Clearwater City Commission. Agenda Cover Memorandum Item # Meeting Dote: SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 516 Lakeview Rd.; Lakeview Professional Village, Ass'n. Inc. (Owner/Applicant); David F. Kern (Representative). (SV 93-28) . RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: Approve the variance to permit two directory information signs on property identified as Sec. 21-29- 15, Lakeview Professional Village, A Condominium according to Plat recorded in Condo Plat Book , 22, Page 111, Pinellas County, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 t-(8). subject to the following condition: The signs shall be positioned in accordance with the site plan that accompanies the variance application. [J and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a ,variance to permit two directory information signs. Because the property contains less than 25,000 square feet of floor area, no directory information signs would be allowed without the variance. ' The subject property is located on the north side of Lakeview Rd. east of S. Fort Harrison Ave., and is in the Limited Industrial zoni~g district. The variance is requested to allow the replacement of two directory signs, one of which presently stands on the north side of the complex and one which stood on the south side of the complex prior to destruction caused by a vehicle. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. Rnlaw.d by: Legs l Budgat Purchasing R I s\t.: Hgmt. CIS ACM Other 'total Cllmrnl..loJ\ ActloJ\: [J Approved D Approved w/condltlons D Denied D Continued to: N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A -4/- ';tt... NlA orlgin.lIng o.pl: CEH'tRAL PERMI'tT\HG /' , '-")'::::~ / COlli : Ullr Dlpl: Current Fiscal Yr. Submhud by: IldVlni"d: Onte: Pnpcr: TAMPA TRIBUNE D Not Requl red Allul.d hili.. A NOlified o Not Rl!qui "cd fundinll SIlUIC4I: D Capital 11fIP. o Operat In9 D Other AlllCllm.nu; APPll CA Tl 011 VARIANCE UORKSlIEEr MAPS [J lIone Approprllltinl1 Code: o Printed on recycled p/Jpcr SV 93~28 Page 2 Information Proposed Permitted Directory/information No (Yes, if 25,000 sq. ft. of floor area exists) Type of Sign Number of Signs Location/orientation of Signs Area 2 0 Interior to the development Yes (;~ r.... ~.-t\4tj) 20 sq. ft. 20 sq. ft. (,"f 1....T~\.\\~d) 60 ft. minimum 20 ft. (If:.. ~,.n:.;t\"..~) 7 fl., 9 in. Not regulated Setback Height Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: Subject property is developed with a one-story office complex containing approximately 12,000 square feet of floor area. The property is accessible from either Lakeview Rd. or S. Fort Harrison Ave. According to the site plan accompanying the application, both proposed . signs will be located away from public streets and will .be oriented toward drives internal to the development. It is clear from the site plan that the signs will be placed to direct people located on-site, not to attract the attention of or otherwise advertise to those located off-site. . SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction II Existing Land Uses North South East West Office/Industrial Office/Industrial Office/l ndustrial Auto Sales Each sign is 20 square feet in area and will be in scale and proportion to the development on this site and other properties in the neighborhood. .8.Jmlicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a requost must meet all eight standards for variance approval. BDsed upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's request meets all of the standards. In particular, the following standards do appear to be fully met: (1) Tho variDnco requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicDblo to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor ill title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of n building parmit or work performod without tho benefit of n permit shnll not be considerod to be situations which support the grunting of a variance. ., , , . ] . , , I , . SV 93-28 . Page 3 (2) The particular physical.surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property Involved and the. strict application of the provisions of this development code would re~ult in an unnecessary hardship upon the. applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to .overcome the unnecessary hardship referr~d to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose o,f making reasonable use of the land. .(4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicantto secure a greater financial return from the property. (5) The granting of the. variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the. property is located. , . . (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to , adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase . . the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the, community. .' (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. . . Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: . No similar variances have been requested. 1 :; . , '. . I., ; , . '" .' ,,' .' " VARIANCE WORKSHEET - CASE NUMBER SV 93-28 .L STANDARDS FOR VARlANCI: APfROVAL 111 Tha variance reque.ted arl'llI from a condition which I. unlqua to tha property In qUllltlon and I. neither ordinarily or unllormly applIcable to the zonIng dl.trlot nor creeted by an aotlon or action, of the prQperty owner. predeceuor In title, or thllllpplh::llnt. Any ml.takll made In thellltecutlon Qf a building permit Qr wo,k pe,formed without the benefft Qf a permit .hall not be cQn.ldered to be .ltuetlon. which ,uPPQrt the grantlng 01 a ve,lance. 121 The pllrtlculer phy.loal surrQundlngs. shpll or . topographIcal condition. 01 the property Involvad'end the strict eppl1catlon of the provl.lons of thl. development cQda would re.ult In an unnece..a,y hard.hlp upon the appllOllnt. 131 The verlance I. the mInimum neceuary to overoome the unneceuary hard, hip refclled to In preceding reoltlll ~2~ for the purpose of meklng rn.onable uu of the IlInd. , 141 The raqllelt for II vellanoe I. not bllled primarily upon the dulrll of the eppl10ant to secure a grltater ftnanclal return for' tha proparty. . " lGI The 'illentlng of thl. va,lance wilt not bo mate,lally detrimental or In)urlou" to other property or Improvements In the nelghbo'hood In which the p,operty I. locllted. 101 The granting Qf the varlllnce will nQt Impair an adaquete supply Qf light or \lentllatlon to adjacent propeiw. detrect from the appearance of the community, .ubstllntllllly Inornle thll congntlon In the publlo straet.; Increllle tha danger of flra. Ilndangllr tha public lafety In IIny way, 0' sub.tantllll1y dlmlnl.h or Impair the Vlllue Qf surrounding propertY. 171 Thll vllrlance dnlrad will not IIdvllllely effect tha public health. .afaty. Qrder, convenience, or genllral welfnre of tha community. lBI.The grllntln'il of the vn,lance desl,ed will nQt vlolata the general .plrh and Intant Qf thl. devalopmant cQde. .STAFF RHO/NOS r The property Is unique becau.., uPQn entering the property. It I, not clllllr whare tQ go. The property Is developed with se~erot aUlce bulldlllgs containing n tQtal of nino occupllnolu. . Without dlrecto,y InlormllUon. II given occLlpllncy may not be ellllly looeted. The requalted vrl'lllncall~pIlllII.to.lntlsfY thIs standerd. The purpon of tha verlnncol. to dl'llct people who are on . thll p,operty. It I. not to' ncure a graate, flnanclel relUrn. .The .\gnl. III plopond. wlll nOlllffeot olher propenlell. ,The .Igns will bo In SCII'e with the developmant on thl. plopelty l'llld other PIOpeftle.ln the efell. Tha .Ign. will hllve no affect on rhll community other than to anlU IInd direct pllopla lllrolldy loontlld on thl. proparty. The \lnrlancll, IlS propolOd. ntl.fllII thIs ullndnrd. j. .' .' ., . , ' . ., , . , . ,. . ..' ..," I' I ,. J ',le>I', .< ! '. . .. .0 . . ...B~<:;.t~tQt J: ~~ L' \.J' ~ I;; ~. f<=-> .~ ~~-- . ~. -' , eln' OF CLEARWA TEF: , .SIGN VARI.,\NCE APPLICATION SV I: (.. ,::. - ., I.. ... ...... .PHOPERTY O~'NEFHSl NAME l.. ADDRESS: REPRESENTATIVE{Sl 1;1 anyl NAME l. ADDR~SS: ... L,lK('vic\:'l'ro[usf.iQn" 1 \,11 i:I~" :,,-,,. I n.-1.nt, 5 I 0 1. a K (' \' it' \,., Ro a cl , . b 1 d 1.:, "3 Clcar~~tcr, FL 346lb f).J\, i (! r, I~" rn. l'n>~ i dl'nt . 5Rme .Jf; 0\0'111:' r; - - . . ---- LAND USE CLASStFICATION:~"'n if"; n, m':' 1 LANDAR!:.A: :; .:J~n!t. 1 j 1 1 I I \ '.! i I TELEp.HON~: ( 81 J 4('1~:!OOO TELEPHONE: I c;, " I , ~, '. (01 - :WO(J ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: ~llb L...d((!vil'~: Road. CleLlr~o1rul'. FL )461t. N,I\r~<lE OF BUSINESS (IF A~PUCABLE): LJkl!\'ic.... Professional Vill<lJ..:~~.!~.f;r.oci.1t ion. 1m.' ZONING DISTRICT: unkno\om ., U;GAL DESCI1'PTJ 0": OF SUCJECT PRO PERTY:. ....J....:Ik.C.\:.~l~t:O.(~s..i:c.n...L-l!-i-J-i....g\o' r-~~Hld(lHH-fH~n, . according to PILlt. recorded in Condo Plal..Book :!::. l'il[!.C' Ill,' l'inl;11il!' c"OImt \.. .i ~\ PARCEL NUMBER: nl II ',~ C.\. i:. 'lw';ilablt: trom your to).,. rl:Ceip1 or conHlc~ nmccl numbfH. i1n,lch 8/: ). , i inch 5h~Cl: \ S- 4(\(A. \ ,: C'(,,~. cc: ('.; C: !This In!Ormmi'.'fl Pirwlln:,. Co, Proptmy Apprniner'!, OUiet" (J~ 4G2.3207, I! morl:. than onl- , . DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: , . North: South: .Prof~s"i'';T1r-l Cornrnc for ;.,,, 1 Offif'pc Eas~: 1''-(1 f('~E inl1,~ 1 o,~ri cp<' ! '1 I ! West: ComHI":: rei t~ 1 v ARIANCEIS) REQUEST: To allo\.-l the inf=:t.1ll':l"inn 'nO. r\.'n .r'll ;""fn"''':"l'.~o.,~l/.-llr~.o.c':::('lr~' r.1L:nc OIl t1J_ pOpe. !..: 'ut:signating the occupants of each. office. in the co.mule}:: to t'cp"lace. 'c:.:U;dn;' f'if'nc on the propcrtv. oil(: of which i<: "ti 1 i 'It'M,ri;,..,~. :mrl onc' nf '~hich ',:.35 tl~+!+slll':(~ b) a \'chic1c. . ' i , , I .REASON FOP. REQUESTING VARIANCElS): !Refer to Suindards tor AllnrovLl!, flext napel Tilt. v.:tri.nl1cl.: l'~'oll~sted vi 11 allO\, ~h~. continlll'cj U~l' 0' di.::.'.:.cr,,",..!i"W~~~~h_~', :.JCUiC;lll. pi!til:ntl- lociiL:nr thL" bll.~l{ji.nv :.h(:\' an Bl!l';:t:n;. 1: if, ~!i:.::.ctdr .for n.:.~.iL'nU ane. ,,,-, ,.0 U I:'j 1.1..",. \..."1. .t)\'l'. ,., 11""\""1'.' ')~rj\'" ,..\. , ...., ,. I c"t ..\. '11 '1 ". J 4.... ~...... "":> ,"- L.... ........t~. -I- ...... ..., :.~. :'--L...... ...4........ I -t- .I.......~. .~t.+, .....l ...4 t'l _l t. ....1(. J IJ (......1.[. It.o.~~.U._~~4~J~-~~h...~~u-t--.---1~H:.~"'i-l-!-~tl...J.. .l"~_U""it."-:ln: .. ...I...'~~-:'nJrrc~'-r~nli.'. O\.-.'l1t,;:: ~~rlc \-' j 1 J 'n (I t . !; ( d II t I"i me n t '" 1 () rill i lid o~IJ:...:..LS:2U;:'-,.:..:..h.c...:.'~ ;, (' ,,,. : ~~UIH.!..i.':Y~l~"+U."'.I~~--mHh--H \.:i.li not, .:Id\'L'r5t;1.1' Jfil:C~. IlId.!l ~c.he;11th, t'roer,. COn\'I!.njl'~cc, ~~clJ(:nll \,',:If.'\!'l, ~Ir ::hl'.Mli1'~' 'iyr::'l11tcnt. 0: !.Ii\' c!C'\.'l.jopmL'nt C(lcil:'"O~City 01 Cl1.Nln:,;te:-',l!l(; ~d11 .-.llt)\'. ;;-;;nttntWd,llIlC! ~_'_' ~_~~_i__'n.l:1--'11'+"'-:' I>...~ . .~.--' ~., ........ __ __...__........_~ 1___..- ..................-or-'. .-.0,--'-' _-r.-r.." . ,. _-rn-:-... _~. t"". . 1 " L __C_~___"'T-"-__________'''- __----.,..___....._--;...-.-..._..__......,....:--:--___..............._____...--;--.____-:--_.._.__W. 'I ' . -----_..--...--- ............---__..._...._~..~._....~_.....__..........~--.___ ~ _~c_..---.._....... __........_--'----.....--..--:--~__ ! .' ;.~lr,'ilft'.LJrL. :U. nr\'T~i~.:. ~J~:-! " . ., .\ . I:. . T~ I q ,. J' , . 1" " ,> , .' . , . " J.~ . , . , .~ < f.. ::~ .:< .: . '. 'J' . J -', ..;~~:~/ .:j ,. . : .~.'.. . .. . . ~ . "'. '. , . '. ,e' . !:TANDAr.Df. FOR .,..PPRO\'AL': ;... \llHllHIC~' ~lIbli IICI\ lit, prUtltt:c; tJ~ T:I~ Crh ~(u;lnU~!-..rnr; lInl~!i~ ttH bpphcn1icln lltHl -" 1(ltlrlCh lHeSblU cd clearlY surmon till:: tolloWln0 co.ncIUl>IOnt: . i . ... (';; TIlt: Vl.1rhmc!:: r ~Ulll::S1l::r: arr!;!:! from ,,'. conditim, '....hich n urliout" 1t! tIlt: pror?epy in ou~s ticm und I~ ntdthe~ nrditlllrily n', unitormly o:JolH:abl(, HI th~ lrming (lIstrlct no' c,ontecl hv fin ElCHOIl Clt IJc1io'n~ of 1111:: propurt~ I' (lwn p.~. pr 1l(IeCe5S0~ m tltll.., 0: trll, [JpphCW1~. A rIV Illlr.1I1k~ 11 HI (I!, ,ltl till" IHuCutiol1 of ... bllilClrn~ PIHnllt or WO;'I nfjdnrrnE:c~ witll(Ju~ tilt: hfl'ltdJ: (If l. r1errill\ !:Iwl, not l)f: cunr.lclered 10 1)1: !".l\Uj\:IUI~: wl1ir.h 'Ht:!'rltlrt tilt. onm1111~' CI ~ 'I vnnnnCl. I. ~ 'f . .. Tilt: pn.rti CUI~H n tlY!> i cw surt(}undmgs. :;hllJH~ m ttJno~HilfllllCfll..cClnrllllOI1:. . ilPpliciltlon ('~ 1111: prClVi::innt C1~ tlU!, clevniopmnrll CtICl!- \'.'0 II lcl rr:sLJ11 IlPpHcum. , , 01 tIll: lHoocrty II.wolved tltHl 1111: r.tr IC~ In /In \Jrlnl.:C!~r.~ ll" Iwt o!ihir. LJP(JI' ttl' '., The vUlinllce if. ,tIll: minim,l1n) neccssorr to' overcome the UllneCl::SlWrV hur tl!ihrp rei l:rr~d 1(, in pr ecudin{l r udwi .': p. ~{";- ':h(. ~t;.;:: :...i:t. c f rnul~:hr, r e&~annt,~t. Uf;t,4. c 1 'the: 'dnd. , . '0 I Thl:: rUQue!>, iOI t' vl'l\lmC\' I!. Iloi btl!:>et! PTlflllllily Ullt1l1 till' tll:~\llt~ 01 11H' appltcillH 1t, ~tl;;Utt.. I' prenwI iHlUflCIH' 'rC1Urn from Ull.:, ~rot.lerty, .'. (pi ." , , " 171 TI1f: .prontinp ot the vnriiltlCt will.not b~ nlDtcrittll" dctrlmenwl'ol. injuriou: 10 .otht:r piopcnyol, imDrOVCrTH:nt~ in ,ht; nciohborl1ood .in wlllCh till' property i~ IOGutt:cl, .. I 1 I I nl.: prnntmr; ot thc: Wltloncl.: will not impair iln adeCluOlt:. sllPnl~' 0; Iiph1 or 'J cnli'lation w adjnccm propeny, cictrac~ trom thc.ilPPl.:arEl~cl:.of the communiw, substamially increa!ie ,th~ conge~tion in tl.{t; public sttceu.. increilsc: tin. danger of flrt;. endangur thc public safe1Y ill an" \!'Ju\" or substnntiDlIy 'diminish .or impair thE: \'nluc: .. of surrounding pro pert".,' , .il1a v;Jri;lnC(1 desirf:d will no~ adversely aft.eet the public health. safety, orch:r cnnvenjenc~,. or general "';eltmf:' of trlt: community. ,'. ' .. ' , .', tpc: genernr spi:i~ Llnd intent of this dcv'elopnicn~ code. ~\ ~~., .~............. , ....\'.i..~~ .-" ~ "",. "',"",-"I -~- David F. Kern, President of Association ". (8) , The, granting of the. variance desired will no~ violma 51GNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVEI~ .\ --:.... ~, " ~i~tJ~crinf:d ~rc .S~..":r.'''~~ t;; ~Di ....~~"firrr.'t..d., bt~~l.;rt rnc tl1i:.,. II~l 'de v of il..t)f i 1 . ':~,t;.' 1 ~23 '. .. I u.1\'ic:: F., I(err. I 17t7/fr 4","'m"~II~":'~u,Jf ;~~,:'.['~'" (IIf,'.",; ""'111f ,., :;ufnlu.n, ~r ":.J~i".~"b.t \'.'h(, j!.. personnlly I . , ". ~,Cl \'.' r. 1:' 111(: an C1! .:, J'! I"": ~nf~''':'''' ,.n .....,.. ,..; "".' .. :... ,... .. ,. .. .. .... .. .... .... ,... .... .." ..... ,. -" ~l. 'I t:m(i(~:oon..1 '" . T. .)...........~ .a.{H~...,t1."..._................................~~. ..'-.lLL&-L~li....,~......~.N-H." . ".... . "7".,~~ r.t iaf-"tlllC;ilt~~n ;-;"7E. OF FLOR!r::it~.. cour':~'!' C'F ~)lTl{'l1(J~~ , ~ . I . ~ . . , ~ ~. ... , , . T~oWr\ r'ur)l,::;. :ornmir.,br, tv, " : > ~ l'... .......-..:-- .~ f11"'~", , .' ., " , i' J ,. H':wllI: of Nown'. lyp!:(1. 'bqntl:u or t.tlHlIDhd '. :-----:--.... ....-... .-'--" " ., ' I. e' . " .f .' , ; ,;' ~ .' . ., i' .. '. ,. ",J. . ' . . ., 1. ! ~ to,': \.\ ~~ '" , ' .. " '.' \,' I' , .', . t.'.. ..'~ f.o " . , , '..\>' , ' 'J oJ: ~ .. . ~ ... . , , 1\;:;,.",;. ... "}~\}';;~f:\ l..~ <~~. ."L .:.'.' .. .." ': )1. . 1',. 'i' .... "f . .J:~t:;';;,/~::\;:\:. . .f " 1 .: ~ '.:~Y :1,. i. ., . l' \r ." ",", ; 'J' ~ h ~ -9' ,". >,,,1.... .\ , ,d T ". '." ~ ; . '. . ~ ,.) :., '.j ;. 'i .,. ". I I. .', ., . , , , ~.J .il " , , .' ,. '( I /- -; Il, 4> /,0 i. -; .1 ,. ~ ; '. . .' " ._/ .' .;, J.., Ii . . , r ~; ~ (., . "--;--;;(- , I. f , ,/;',; 0 . I~ , ,fJ"~ !E\Y. J '~-.A;7 . . ~ ~ .ll @ ~. .....J , " " I . ~: ',. ~ ' ,.,. . '-, 8;' -:::: .~: \~. ~ '\ (;;::;. .-. '., ..-.. . .'1 " .j .:~..,..;::...._ .==L.8 ~..~. 1-. i. ;.. -;--:- \".'." > - ;":"::-.:-_.-:-\" . ~ ~ 1 :..::.. .(;"0 --- ~ i ,-r :' , ...1 ' . ... . {j ~ I " , . .1 ... ., .> '. ~. It< " I I " ; . . ~. , , , ' f ., ' \ '. ., ; , .. " , ", ., " " . t:?~Yk11 Di:.t .' " t..kf:J!: V !'6:r.j ~'-rrL(1Nc.6 ?f6fN :.; I~' LAf(6VI~~ J.:~J~ "PI Y>1:tN $IOJ....$ , ~.P r~~IO}Jrv.... VI~ ( , ~y, CU;Af..WA"1c.R.. " .,. , :VRJ>:'Y.JI~ !' -' f?tJ L,' . ,n""f~ YP.:1f,. . ~,'i/'1'; , . ,.' I:, 'i, .1 .,. ., ,. , , ." I. 1. >, .. , 'j ~ . .. j > c. l . ~ .' , .,' , " . " " ,. , , (, ; 1.\4. , .' .':' '. ~:I ", ~. ..': '.: '\ ~ ,l . ..: . ~ . , ., " , . .::< ,. , ';. r--. I ., .r--- I' t< ., , .-5.0~.: I. . 1666 ft. >1 .. I , LAKEVHW PROFESSIONA1~ Vll.I.AGE ASSOCIATION I , ., , , SlGN AREA ,i , ' ~'. ?f2' I' . 4J \4.l ,~~ SCALE:' I.51r = 11 .t. '\ :, .' .' .\'. ,. \1 . ' , ' ., . ' . . {;, 'J,. -., '1. I , .1 ., ./1._X_!tI~ Ponls - ~ N .""'" ':0, , ! '..... '. '.. ..1 ,. .f. " .' , . ) , . . .' ~... . ' . .' , ..' ~ .' " , I , :' " I . :'{'.' . .' " " . . ' , '.. .'f ~;': . / , 1." " . . ..}., . ~ I . I' ~ '. . I , ,. i . J' . J . ',., \". . , ., .='<.'1 . ~ .. .:0 . : ' .: "f.:,. \:. :~. . . , :). i/". .,. .:. .i . ..., '.'. , , . . . / . ~ /.ft, to .~ .' .. ~ I Vrtl I ~ ;. .. ~ I. . ','. ,.'. ,. --------...... , .."- , ~'" ' :-'. 10'1.\, 1/. rr \'L"ll""i:!-(', \L' " . , ,! Jl (.\\It, I V k. ' . _ ~./_ ... . Y 'I if ',::m':l1j:\I~JLI ~ ("I! r I ",";' ; , ' ~ ....,\I2JJ!'lLIV~.,V 1'11~' -, .; . "o/rr\LiLA~l\~'1 '. ~- · "I" f; 11 (I p,,:; .... ' : ~~. , /,. "J r or' ~ \)' . . .!I ---..:... ~L"', -' .... \. ~ ,\.... ..:...~ -_.~' '.' -:_ ;J · H I r',';" '-".::,. .",.,. j f ............ I . ... .~. ~ \ . --:- FH~ ~;j,l:,;,!. ,>--- '. ....--.- , ' :.. ~ . ~ . i .. :-.j ; iI. II J./. u: 11 tFi- .' Yll/tO (.tJlt.' ,. , ' I. i,: II : I I l! ifill' j ('f.' U, ~';.r..=-::o.'''; ~..,~ , [D. l' W.' r "!:'J L I:) '. . > I ...,~~ ;f: . .._..._.1' . r 'V '.l.~l'. L - , ,1. i:~~\irJr'\Y"i~', >,. t'--'~;:;~~'.:.l. ~'''II~lr~ .. -:.. r--:-.. -- --. -- .. -. ---..., : UFo tJ'lllu,^rl'j ~rr.IISC:t~: ;0. ......-- , . -t-UI~. :~l x'j,... ~:, ! ~.fi.~ V C,',: . ~N. r.l ( F'~ 04~~ If ~ . . I ~ I t . " ,I t~ If,:.e 11t:n. ,,;. ,1 Atlr ;'~i~~e:,.!;; .... If ~I r..t'Tt,u-t t "( I. .1 '! I. , I. r---': ...' , "4/ c t L_~ , I. .. , I' ~ ...--.. --;- ... ~. , /1. . 1 ('" .:, _ , ,-;- ".. r.; I . '.. "~~ ""' :. r . ...----. ~ ..-... - -~--"'-----:---' . I .> ~1t:':I\h?r . " ~, I I I I ) I. i I I _" ..... :I.._~ .... ))'6)11' ,~\nw'; m:lt~:~ i~; '" r---.~- --- - ----- -:-:.._.,: , I , , :--... '.- . ..- .( t!':'\V.ll'l.\f"~ lil/';' f;"ll'., 1.\11-.. \i1 l.i ,It. ~Jr.I~ nl!.If. 5 I 1]. '" 3 lff{l:U I ! p-LF6 l.lC~, '., . ~.:r::t.{~ hl-:i.; CfPICe-;. ~ r"'^tr7kTio,~ y.'\1r:'~ . ..,. ! .1 Jl.'0r.: ~11'"'' ..\..~. . ,- \~.~r\ Q:.'lf Ii p.", ~ '1.10' 41 .... (r: . mill rr. 'r . .j,i .Irl\ur.\.. I ] M J?.11 j,Uf:. ! : ' t. ~ ___OW," ....-. --.,~"",-..- I ~.. ._--, 'I .t.-.';" . ........,- . . IY.~" H, Lt. fiti;':; A~;. f4 t~,41e'.e' r..$ II N t:- . p/~'fH t.\'t..v... . I I. '1 f';,:J I VI VI-v ~'~~l~' , ; ~~ - :. J ?'Cf' . tl'lJ?: f~ "I.'~"". Ii.d .... .t,.....I . '!;-,d..f . --. ~-r r{'lfr'r , . I... \ , , . I ., . t - . ;='1(,1-: Fla AK'V ~ r~.1';' ! ' .' M/j ~ J e'-c,.l ~,i~-r: ":r ,. ~ , . ,. , , , , .;' -tI' ,,, .' . " , '",/\.,... . .' c ~...... ,- ,ll ....:"'~""""'~. ~ ... ... \ , /It , i r- .'", ,- I.> I \' ,.... ~ ~ . t,;;..~. · ~Weto:::.Jnl.f.S ~-w,( -Yrp. ~!/.-:,.I i1 > ' ~'. t'. " ., , . , . " " , , , " , 0 , t! , ..< , , , ~. t . I .i: ., !\ \-IV I \J LI V ,I CLEARWATER, PINELLAS ,( SllNC t. ?OP ~ lor, (,f 5EC t 10'- ?l, 1 0"'0. .~r U'&..il ~~~('".,./P.rh c'd.r~ /t! rQ.Rr1J/~';" /;: ~((X'..r /~ : ~ '. . I , J.;-. tl1' I I ~,J , , . , ,1 , ,... / 1 i " (;()r~ / r""A'dV~.I.' &.. "N~ (i:1;"",:f /~ ,r,J/AVVO',v"',i. ~'or~'...~ ...".'....".. -"({tf"r ..",(;'$, AH,P r:'~.f /,#~,T ~~~/' ~...... cc/,;r /. /.1: AA".P .:-C; .t/,//1 ~/ rN'~ ~t:1~ d~ /d..r.NE.A"t!r .r~"",/W "N"" <f.r'/~'/" t""d.....f.r ..r,.,/.!,.n:r",P. c~/' 6 , /dtk'",TM!"~ H"//"# /"A-U/ /A'1f'T ~.... :tJ' :f"rA'EE'./ rJ('",;,r/ U,.IffP ,N"E/#"'~ /~, ~t:rrl"' /..-' ('1;:tJ..';/.,-.....rdP'~~ rd FA1:'" A~dr'" "'.,;IC ,ff.I,r O. .&fltr..i/,/' ..l,f ","CC~.P.r,p ,.,.' ,PtA,P BdIc1K ,~ /'A.:fE ,'I<'. l,r~d;f'/A./, ,,/ ~A:"'" /'/H4!".!,(A,J" t"~#/'r ",.."'.#' /drt'-';'EA'.'," ,..' .A.'A',~ ,J"'f ~j 1;1.. ~ BY. ~,t.!".r I. ~t!;J.~ 0(: ., t;, r ~ j , /....., - _.'- ).. I ,'" \;) .\l ... ."-l ~ tl ..~I-:--.. , i' tt, I! ... , \ . ~ i . , ,... ~~..-=:_=-.,-- ..~..-l . I l' ! . . , , I . ! .... 1 . ~ : l' I ,.l I, ,~/ 1; ~ , .. ,>..7 d "'" '.r~ ' tI. ,y..... L ~ ~ ~ bl. '- . .~ .f' \t. .. , ,,' ! . &J .. IT'':'" - {f/," tJ..r: . .,., ~, -'....., , ~:-~..,T"' ~ I \.. ; rI. ~~~ ..... I '\} I :: i ::: : I., ~ $"~~'!~ ' '\} 1 "':, ~ ~ t", ~ 1,...1 11"J':'," I ~, 'j r; . t ",~ :1// 5"]- '1 {.::'l ~~ ~. '.... -:{... h u t, . ,'" I . ~ . ; ~r~''::l' '-'" \1 '~"". /'~ ~ " ! J I ... - I..... t i ~ :'<l! rr fJC~:nON'/I~: ! I@~. .:. ~I "-~""'.... J ' . ',.. .. ~r'- .~J". -. "'1 \. _.~; , J \- \ :.' '.,.. ... I ...... Oij I *\l:' t" ~ .~.J"'~"OHJ.-""') t., I~.~ ~ '1tJ - I '. I '.t .,. , /':, t. !t I:' ift:Sll io- . . -;...-" -;" '. -. ~ii'~ I .. t___ I....-I-i/ ~ ~,L___ ,.yr,.j-,~~P" ",,,-~. -- \1\ I ' ' ... _~_" ..,u~ ~~~' _ ~:~~.:~~'~ .~- "..~!~~:I~~.~_~ ~ r~!:.:-" T -~)-:' ~.~. --:-..... -... - -........- ~I~l I, ,.1' .J....../f'o ,i'~ ' I :-.. ~': ~ t- /..... ~'.tI.1 ---:-.~- : I I . I ,'" I I ' \ ,~_.:__~__l_.._.._.._.~_.,_ .._~I I . I LllCA1101-t. . . I... 5161N f., . .;-.'-:1' ~..__._._-_._..._.-ii : > ~ ." -:-- ~~I/Ntf.~ ' .' . \ 1 . ~ - I ...... r"-':""'l " -. I r : n :1:- 'in - .. j w: I I - !' ,i I: I . ;, I '4 "- . ~" 4 ~ L.._....J' : L.._...J .. .. ~ , . , , ~, ,,, \l' ;"1 ~I ..., ~ Ii' I ~ ~\l ''i ~ ~ ~ 'f.) ~'" . \: '~ .. ! , .. f., :',,~ c' ~ ,. $" ...~.C ,;(1~ .".' .~ .~ 1\ i1 :t j J (t:::'~:,:.:'::~. \~. ~ I ~\ . , . I .. ., I ~I ~I ~ .'-:1 "I ~..~ Iz: 1': "" ...~ ~ . ~ . <,(or I f /;' r PA/~ , I'~/'J( .!(/'t" ""1",.1..- ,.:01", ...."..~P/,#i:: .1/:'[ ~ LC....-..:J: ~ l~"':" ;: '/('/',.I( ~,.I"'.f"/A-'~ JA'I",.I ,- >.. _."-.:~"'.!!'-.!. r '<".I, .:M-rl"!"".,,. "~C,, ,. ' ~);~ " It'./,J/ PN~..(' ..1,/,., . ,.',:. .-.!J2E.r ...-l!'7 oJ' f/~.I"" .,lAY", . .,.:., . U','.J, /,....-..1. ';,I'I".r~' A,'('C"'. _ ' . . , ~. ~L..!!::' r ....~f.',/ ",~.r ".J".'.... /." ,1/ . '"If ~..~, ..,":' ,,.."',!,':..f, "II l J : /-,,,11> , ,.~~ ~ .J i'. .. -:-.tt-'! .r ':', l A~ , .=-- I'o'oft! or i'/J.4~.i r ,'1//,.1 = :~.!~~~ .~(' int,1 r:: " ,r /.,',..1 ~"!, ~'" of , --- 1/., 4 I 1:~ , ''It l,.J ~T la' :fJlJ.': "'j',,. ~ . ......" ., C' I ~ r ..;.!.~,+~~~- r.:'LA~~ ,,"'t' 9.. ,,;:-. . .1".:'-, .." ,.~ ..1';...... " . . .. '. , ' , . I .... ~ ",'001 "jr' yi: . .' .'," .\ . ., ....,..'. . , ~i'.",.:,.,;::::: ; ; l' '. .. i. . , ". . . W 19 <C' ...::J ..~ - > <: ~ 9 :; ex: .,' 0" .J.. .r ~ ,:P, " ~ <C Z o .- Cf).~ (f).O WO 'LL Z :: o 0 ;i:. ~ 0::: . U. 0=' ., rI ~ L..1... .f '<( :; .~ :J Z., ,..-~ ,t-' 11- Z ,j'. :;j ." 0..1 U :~ ~ ~ :! w $ w > w ............. -- c: ...t -, I.U' r -oJ '..I. <( --.J ' -- '\ . .j . ' 'i .~ .. \. ~ ' \:\.\.~\ ..,' ~ ~ . ~ ;~ ~ .-;~ "- ~ ,.'('. "". "\ L'~ 'to ,~ ~ ~ 1~\4 ~ . . ~ :l " .:11 .~ ..... . ~ . ~ ~ ~\\\';.~~~~ .' '\ ~ ~ ~~ ~ '\ \: ~\~~~.~~ ~ ~ .~ 'i'" . ~ 'at.. ~"'.. .~: I~ ~4 \i ~ ~....t ~ ,~ "... '( l~~~~~~. ,~.-';~""~ ,~c::"':'''~~ ,~d~"l~~ ,,~ ... ...... ~~ ... ~'i!'" ~.. \~~. ~ ~~...~.~~~.... \\" ,I !\. . ,~~.. ~~~...~'~ "~~~~~~~~ "~lL'~>:'.' ...t\"t:~~~ ~~:~.;~.\~ ;, ~ "I ~;: ~ :~..,\,~\:~ ~ ~., o;!o.... '~. :~ ~ ~ "l \~ ....: ~'.'.; ~ ' ~ ~ ~1" ....... ~...,~~~'t " ~ " ~ ~ .. '" 'l,~~;;\'''l,i: hI.. :>...~ .~ ~, \ ') ~: ~ ~ :~ ~ .{ ~.1~ . l ~~: \ ..~ \ ~. I,. . '" ~.'. ~ _'. ...:-: ,'I ~ ... " ..,: l \ .:~ \. ~.~ ~,' ~ .:: ~ '! \, ~ ~., .::.; :w- 1 ~ ~ .~ .:;: L~ :: ~ t"..t ~ : ; ~ ~ 'J ~.. " ~ : ~ ':: ~ 1~~" .t;~ ':t '," '\ ''; ~" . ;.' :~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~i ::. .-~ ~ ;!"\ .n:'i ( ;., , / ';", ~ ,~. ,:.,1, ' '. ..." f t t ~. f. ~ \,..:. . ~f, ~ 'I ~ i ; :: ~ ~~ ~ , '. I:, !J ...,) ~'1 ~.I ;~~ ~:j " .; '. ... , , .. :. . ,. " ~ I ' , , . .. . " ,. , , ., ,. . I I'. " I. . " . , ,'.. .' .'.l" 'I . . .~'. I , ... \f' "II ",. ',.., .!ll I ~I ~'\. :- .~ .." '\ ." , .:. (' :~~ :' t. ,..~ ,~~,. 1 >;" . ~ ,,~.. :. " 'i ~ ~ ') ~ ~ ~::(~,.,..~~~""'l\ 1.:;:- . \I _ ~...',.;. 1.... ~.,.~ .:~,,~ >; ~ t; t\.~' ~,~~,," + ~ ~~ .... "':. , ';. c ~ : ':~;.'~':~'V"" ' ~..: !l"t\, ,.. t\ ~ \. ........ :0:'.... \;~ .., :1 :(, ~t.c ~\ . ~ ~ ..:-.,,()o,;c f\! 1 ~ ..,h~V~~~ .. ,,,~ ~ ~ . ~ t ~ ~ ~ . ~ ....'-.....,'\.. '~ ~~~~t:h!'i~~. ~ " '. .. ~ ... ~ ... ,. ,\:.' ':\ :-r...;".........".I\ '~ ~ ~~~,,~:i~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~.. ~ " 1;"." ,." .... \',.......:..."...'..t ~ ~H~~~\;~~ ,Ii \:. ., ~" Ii .' .~ '" \.'~ 'l. ~ :. II. ~ '; oj ~ =-> \: "'..~~...~,,~ :::~ "!..'!\~~~~~\ ~..lul'';~~<';"~ " !'l ~ ... 'I ~ "'~ ~ " ~~ .~~~,~. \'!\ .,,0.;\"'.... "'; - '{...:i~..."'~t:~~~ . ,~.. . 'li~ >;: '1,\:\" ~!o~'i~~ ...,~' i..i!";;;~ -t ~,,,, ,:< ~s; :11\ ,~~~.~ ~ ~.~ ., ..., \i ~ "u. ~ ~.... "'jn'-:"l~~t: .. '. ." , - '. .,~J ~; .. ., . ....-\: .: \ '.~ :0;," ~':;i ~:~,'~..: ~""1:; ~~I;:~'} ~. 'J:"~\.i ~~~.:."\~~ ,... t'-1 ',. . ~,~:; n,- 5~ _ ''; ~;$ ;'..1,",: h i ~ .. \"~ ...~ " " ,'l .' ,~ ~ ~ 4. ~ ~~~..~ ~ t'~ ~~C';:;\. , ~, .:,,';;,~. ,,~~:'I.....:~'l" ~ti~~:'r.::q ~ '\... '\ ~"'.,.. ';;!o>ll't" ...,,~ +;:'\."'':''... ~ ,\~'i~ ;.,"'~'l ~ . ~..... 't ,..~~h~....... ~ :1,- .~~~ " :' .~ ~'..~~' ~" !t -- ~~!\~ \ ". ~ ~ :- ~ 'J .... !t; .s~"it,,'l ~;;~),. ~~.... ..,.. ~.. ,\:,\, . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '.} c ~ ~. I . '; ~~ ~, ...;. ~' . .. 3 j': ~ .:;'. l ~ ~J ~ ~ ~ .~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ : .~ 'z 5 ~ .. ... .. 1 ~ " .., . ~ .. .., , . ~ . .~ " ~ .~;..~ \: .' .,: ;I ,~ " .~ >: '. ..I ; ~ ~i 6;11 'I ' ~: f ,.: 1 :. ' ~ ..' ... t ~ '1 ~ ' <, ~. ~ " ~ .~~ ~ ~ t, , ":' El n H .. ~ ;": .. l ;!.~' :: 31 .'.... .. . =~ ~: ::~ ~I ~.: ~i ~, ~I , ~ ,~ ': ~ ~ .... " ". ..: t .;: ...i.. \. ~ ! i .~ ~, " tl ~ .. ~ ? :( .,: ~ .,:: ~'~ . :: ~< t · .~ l' ~ .~ ~ ~: ~ ,. ~. ~, ~ ~ ~ .~ .. .. '.~ :l ~ i , ;;, '. ~~ ~ '~ .. ' ~: :: .~ ~.. .: ... i .,. ...'~ .. .. ~I ~4 I ~ .~' ." , I , , i I ,I '~I . _:"'_._', _~."o."".,j;$ 't-'.' . ~ _._--:: .:::::;-- ._h_ . *'.. ",'~ c:i'-'- ! j "1 r, " f. Z ......',:--0.... /! .....--. .--- - ". ........' ':::::~~ . , : 'j ~.. .;-;... ,. '..... ..~,...... . ~. _. ...... <~.....~ ......__ '", ;o-~ "' ... ,_ I' . ' r:-, " , ,'/' ....:::./.. " ..~,. . : if ' .. clD.~~\l ' "~. ....~I:--.... " .~ ~ (. I. ~..... "'-~ II!II..... ~ ". '~ 'J \; .. I - " .....:'..... ' t . ,: '-. ,. x . ~"E"-"'" ......:~:~:... -:-. ... ----::'-~L-...;,..,o, f'.! ~.~ I :.::. "1. ^ ,.,~: .1 ; .-;r-=::i.::' ~ r~. " ., . .;; i ,1''';:,'):['".) ;:,,,,i:i.:: '," .. -:-:'1: 7Jj . . \ . \, '. i .t,": . I ~'l '1; . .,' ..- :' -. ~ , "',.~,,~ _. . _.... .:..;:::-1. .' - ~.. ....~:.~;.'IU. ' .,;-.. I ":" , ,," .j . ;,.:' :,: ,""-:1. rr;:. t ':.. . ,: L 'I ,...~..~ ':'" .,. I," ,......,_ .~.._.. ....~ I '~ 'OJ ~ CT .:::.-:i "k "'!: . ~:,:~-"~'HL i' !l ""., ," " .. ,. . .\'1 . .... .' " .... .~:. jo. ~ . ....' .,J~' .,' ." , ., ......~.. ~".t ,.,.,,0. .1 .~,,:,__~_'f'., ,;- ., :::l ~ ~~ ...:'3.:t":!~'!~~J'" :.: I . . ..."., ;~" ,. . I ., .->> ' " .1 " ~ . . . Z , , ::1' ..-: .- ,. -", ~ .. ~ . i t ~ . _.~ .U. . ,I . l..o : I. ~. .~ :;;: . I , .~~ c '.e . ... -I , , . ! i'~. -;;-;t;'i~;~ :;:*.....r-- ..,., ~~ ,I ~ ., ~: . , .. '.... ~. '. ", ... " :~ :: ;~ ~"~:! :. '~: ~ ,~, .. '. ~ ~ : ' ~t 'l ~j . L,l:~ ~ ~--.._...... l ~ I ~. --;;;;.~ N .' ~ ,"~ '-, -. .... t.. ~ll~. ., t".,.,~,,;,.~-- . . ~ ~ ::i '. :~ . ~, ~ ... '~ . " :.j ~r ;.j ~f .. " ~. ~ .. ~ :~ ..~,.~,,~... ,t ' ... .. .... >... ~ . ": : ~ ~ .. ~ ,~l: ; : ~ : :~~l~V~ .~ ' .; ; ,',". ~ +~ . ," . :. ~~ .. i f -, ...' " '\ '! ~ ' , ~ , ;. " ~ .~ .,...........1-1... \ .Il". I. , . 'I ~ ~ \ ~l , , . .: "" .f '<If t ~, /_ .., ,~ , :r. 12M .:. c:::. . . 12s;~""" _ 12r.~ t f .j \ ... -_......_-~_.-- --..........----- ;..........- t ... p..' J . .. . .g~I~~.~C.f ; ~C ~~ l~ I h ~ t ,--- nJSKA'MLLAJ. /' H:E. TOOlG /25(' -----,...-- . ~ 4~...~ 5~ 12Ct . 12tU PETZI'lLD L. ------~~- 126~ 126 P GULF':. VIE1" : ..:....'_~t;. ... . ~- .. :... E ;-. ,k. e:T' oo"l::.ei -------;----- '. '::7~ 12?~ ~2'7! -:: 5-38 .: 3-68 .. ..i' , -- If:: .:. 1:: \ 3 ,.__J~__....:.~~ ;':~~"'-o':.-~ ... .- .~. ,... v o , .L lr .- , , . \~ ( .- ., . ... _. . \ ' -' ..(.~Qt"- ,,"'.. ../.,tj, \. .+ ;:::._...... l~ LAKEVlEW ROAD ~ ---, ~ - I,S"1 I ~ ::, ~ It:' :~ I'" .....Ie!> - I ~~M'1'1'I1 ;:; 1'3"77, t...., )~~ ) ~,~ ~ ~::l' i {5::.lIfi: ~Ig;;;:'b~ ~ .. 113"5 '1!r,An!5' /'. .' 5:l.::12':::!: ?!\ Sot:- 8 m.tar, :' /1.!.'3 OF:. i I I BELlJAIR "':' ~. 1 - ~"";- - ' '....J...... ,., ':..J :J' J ~ I 135' I .. ~l5 ,I ~: 1"I.::~110 15'J8~,' u;;'1 - , I 11'i' f. t ~:> 11 119 10 J <f / ! 1 4! ,~ : t 6 : 17 i < . ',i '0' I l:,:;;l'~ 9.59 'I I / i J t. I I' , . ; 6 ' 7 ; E. ; 9; 'lJ' " ,/ /1 ~~~~ ~~1~~: ; I I . I.,',."", ...,,,,1"''''' ..,..." ....---/ t -0- SlREET ~4::l~'-'9" YA:, 1.!67 j. '1"';:'''''''1'''0,'-'''''' \"'-- ~--__ IS6~1, I S;~I~~ ~:O:;~~,~ ~~ r --..,.."....,. r3uF l' . ..'1 C ~ '. - ,~ t- _t, < t .... 13." E. ',<,<:,'::: ",l~.-"- .', ,- r- . ~; ~ : ...... iSf.;....Z~...L...l.. .. ~ .~,' Sl ~ ,-{16 - --: ~.......;. .. { 9 \ 1 i;"~" .r. "~ '4~'. :I IIS7fl"r.:;.' ....,..l~. 'e, ;:".,,-, ~,' ''';''''1'- < -!:. I I .....-'i ('0 -< H1-+ 10 5 1,.' :J: : '~i S , c: n' 1 2 . u 1Q;)C;j..........II.QQ:.lC"""...~ICtlO IOC\jI...,~ ,~~. ~~ .~<~":~~!~~~iP"l'~. It:'~IO'l''"- ~~ .-- '::;., \ I '-- ,-.. !: r" ~..: r ,- :.- ~ \ ~.. VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS - --... l~ A ME: L-../"..:.. ~~ .... ' ~. "....:' ~-;;: - ~-f~<' ':c..:;' , - ..-. -- \ S V .:'- ':l~ .. :.:: PUB Lie H EAR I N G A T LAS P AGE : ~_;:. S.::: SEe: -=- .... ~: c ~ ::: ~. R \\' L, ~ ~ p ':' - '" , 1,"'-,.;::: . :~::.:~~ ~ .....'-1.......4 D ATE: ___. __~-----_..- 7\Afp' ~ '=', s 'R~c. . y , .. ._~ ~ . , '-' I-.. .. \ s- E. - ...... I 'I "-- ~....... rvd\~ I S S ! C' N ',' .' " :, '~ '. '. '., ,.. \' , . ~ f c ., " ,; .'. ." i. . ). : .;. " ~ ~ . '(. -. . ,. ,.,"; I ,. . I ~: " I '-t ____ J -- 1 " :\, I I I I /' ~.~ __ r \~-. ......... < . :'"~~- _f'-...._. - .~)".... . '" "', . --: ..~:' ., ~~ J~.--=: ~ ~,;. rl. -' "\l ,.~,~ .;n ,. ,.. ' J ... _._ ___....-..______.---__-r-- - -. j .. c. . --......\ "" ,. ,- ~ .,.J' .....- '": "". '> " . . ,,--::... ..--:' ~; ~~ " - ",-'" ..--->......-. -e--" -~ ,,-.; -,' ',.... .:~~:-":.,, ..,-~~ .. . , \., ,\ ,- ,- .-:- / ,. " .~~::.;:, ~ _.. .; ~- .. . l. ~ c::- ~ -.- .' ., " _. .. --~ . , , ~ ( L l ,'---.." I:. .~ , ' ,-- , . i r I ,-' I - 1~jt~;'~1 '"' I ~......: f ~~ \ J >, r ('. ;-.J. [ f. .[ , . --- I .~' ~ ".l~/ .~ 1 ' =1 .j ",_ .1\ ;;!~ru I LI1 , . ~;-f -I i" [ ~t .~. , ' ---"- ,.- ./ r ' ,', I j 0' f , --- ,- v, ,. " r' (-=:,. 1, ..... " '/ "l. . '--.... ",,--, , . '-, ~: " . , ,.~~~~~' ~ ." . , ,- " . .. J .~ ~ .. :. ;. ~ ,. - :6 .,1'- , . i- ...... , I I .~t.. ..-....---_......-~.....-. . . ~_..!-. (~ ------:l ~;..I -' ;- [ .cj I ~nl ___.i;;;;. -'. ----- . ," ,'-v. ......-, . " .. c' .;:. ... . .1 ~ '_: :"'-.. C: , , : . ; --~ = . ;., , ...~~ c?~ CO "1 1 i 21 r .,! " k ...' ..., ..:::._; I " '_: I ':1: ~< :"ltr~\...~~;.: ! \.: I . I :~ f .~ I l ' . \ c L~'" ~;,o.~ ~ .'\ .....~~:.~~.: ~~~'.,.:'~': .~~ :.".-~...:~ rr" :'..., I .~I \, /' I ~ -..- \ 1 " ,'. I - .~=--.. r....... ~.... =. I t :;.r'~ ..~-.......... t::?a~/ \'",- ....._'. . I . ~ , ~ r' . ."~~ ~ -.. , ,'\..- ----=-=--:~..:~-- - ----~----.._.......ll/..I, .,. ~~~ ~ i / ~:'; j ':' . ' . L~=i~7''"::'_ i, I~ [ r. ' ----.:..:... '~.. . ". I . ~~..:.._.'~." '~""'. [ '., J~.."---' ,..:., _ .. ~ -;..- -. ... I . "-.~~ ~. [ ([~, '?-' I ~~ /:. " .-. _ r.. ~s::::- I;" ..,..... r:..~ .:----.\~/___,--;..". ~'""2\~ ...,~s/.P ~..--.... r or ~~,"".,-;" !Ii". .~~, :::.;....~".., ~.\.........r'.;/",.://' ) I r:'- ...... -....~ ~ I,. ..1'. 'I . -,-~. " . ,---;;;" /~--:"".'(~:;, 1) IUl'!>; ,~:'~. 'I ~~rr:= r .....~~~. -- _.f;~...'. ...".. _--.... :-"';L'.. i-,-, < .......~:.~-.~.- / ........... ..>....... t .........~f ko,.....i., ....,.:..'_ .1 c, ....:.:: ~'::--.. it ~~" 0:: .. ...... ". ,~ ,. , .... I r I .. ,'" c. .. . -.;..... ...:,. . ~ .' .~' I . : ....,: ~.....:J j..:".lot . ....;.. ~~ ....lr--__ I~ I [ ~.. .. . ----.:.-.. 10 ! '\ I ! ! ;. . j " ": i " ,...1 ;'::1' I;; 1':- , '-" , -, ~ l a i I , o ,I. alj I '-- .. t.~ ;:''.:.;'.:1~ " .. (e> . tl c;;:;:-I~ I ~. -:::; , (J . :. ..~ ,:' v.~:": . / '; , , .1 I I. I , .J ~ ~. -, i , '. ", - ,'. .--?- . ~ i r .- ---=.. ':" ~ ,'. --.. ....... ~J"-,__. . , {' Ii; ~~l [ ( . ( , -.-...-----:;.~--.-- -.--.-.----...-t-.---.--- ..c __,. ..,+.~..~ ;.. -, 1 _ \ . ': Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum \3.. Item # Heeting Date: /I'j,~(q~ SUBJECT: Variances to the Sign Regulations; 20505 U.S. 19; Burdines: CT Corporation/Burdines (Owner/Applicant); Harry B. Bahner and Mark S. Schaefer (Representatives). (SV 93-37) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Deny variances to permit nonconforming signage to remain on property identified as Sec. 17-29-16, M & B 31.02, for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8). o and thot tha appropriate officials ba authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to permit two existing attached signs to remain: (1) an area variance of 185 square feet from the permitted 150 square feet to allow a total area of 335 square feet attached to the ea.st wall, and (2) an area variance of 185 square feet from the permitted 150 square feet to allow a total area of 335 square feet attached to the south wall. The subject property is located on the southeast corner of U.S. 19 and Gulf to Bay Blvd. in the Clearwater Mall, and is in the Commercial Center zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. : Sign 1 I Sign 2 . .1 Information Existing Permitted . Existing Permitted Type of sign Attached Yes Attached Yes Location/orientation of sign East wall Yes South wall Yes Area 335 sq. ft. 150 sq. ft. 335 sq. ft. 150 sq. ft. RQvlQwed by: legal Budget purchosing Risk MgRit. CIS ACM Other N/A N/A N/A NfA N/A ~M. NfA DrlglnlltiflU Dept: CENTRAL PE MITTING COIU: Total CommiSlllll1 ACllon: D Approved o Approved II/ c ond it; ons o Denied D continued to: U .ar Dep I: Current Fiscal Yr. I ,;,' J " AdVQrtlled; Dilte: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE D Not Required A lIeelml PallJOI S Notified D Not Requlr'cd Fundlnu Soulce: o Capi tal Imp. o operating o Other A u~ ellln' ntl: APPUCAT ION VARIANCE WORr.SHEET HAPS o None Allpleprlallon CO~G; Ci o Printed on rccycled pnp~'r . , . " SV 93-37 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: The applicant contends that due to the physical layout of the building, the size of these signs is essential for proper identification of the business. However, those signs are directed to the interior of the parking lot and the maximum size of 150 square feet will adequately identify the building entrance. There are other major tenants within this mall and other malls, and staff regards Burdines to be similarly situated to the others. The applicant has not provided any evidence that these variance requests arise from conditions unique to this property. Furthermore, staff does not regard the request to be minimal. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing Land Uses '. North South . East West Bombay Bicycle Club Restaurant Seville Condominiums Sky Harbor Estates residential Sam's Club (across U.S. 19) Clearwater Mall consists of retail stores. The existence of these two 335 square foot wall signs is not in character with the signs permitted for the other stores in this mall. The granting of these variances will detract from the commercial businesses that have conforming signage, permit an unfair advertising advantage to the applicant, and negatively impact the appearance of the community. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's variance requests do not moet the standards. In particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully met: t 1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome tho unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) Tho roquest for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return for the property. (5) Tho granting of the variance will not be mnterinlly detrimontal or injurious to other property or improvoments in tho neighborhood in which the proporty is located. I, I. , , I 1- ~ '. . ~ J , ' SV 93-37 Page 3 (6) The granting of. tho val'iance will not impair an adequate supply at" light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the, value of surrounding property. . , , , (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8) The' granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decision~ by the Commission: A TT ACHED SIGN AREA C'ASE# .,ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES. MEETING' REQUESTED/ACTION DATE , 'sv 91 ~O1 2000 Drew St.. Shell Oil ' 84.8 s . ft./Denied 2/7/91 SV91-16 601 Cleveland St. Sun Bank 43 s . ft./A roved 8/15/91 SV 92-19 27001 U.S. 19 J.C. Penney 329 sq. ft.1 Denied 10/15/~2 Co. SV 92-42 714 Cleveland St. Trickel 70 sq. ft./Approved , 2/9/93 Jewelers '. , . " ,. , j. , . , : . ,. . , ,.... M I M en > en a: w co 2 =' z w en <( o tu w :c (J) .~ 0: o ~ w (.) Z c:t - a: <( > I It ~ ~ ;;; 11!;!:t ~E : tg ; ~.. .c.." _~ o 'WI ~ 0 ~ ;. ~'.S ~ IJ .., -" :; .; '5 -! ,,~g.'i : = ... .. It s.... ~;Soc"O~ OJ..ltIc~= C "'" ... I: CJ 0" :2~...:!2f! .S CJ 0 ~" tJ ~~llt~g "5:l:"I:J:~ _ .E"E-Cl 0"=11_> ..,.UE-5t1" g.~.~:.xj > ::s E ..... 0 ... .soD a....... !~!c~j~ .E" 0 G :i g Q.c..tiIllU .ll.g..2g,,~> "fiI;DCl1!"t: SS:~~~~:i IJ E=:;ll ~ G 0 :J U .Q. I:D _ ." Q. ~ ~ ~'~ '3 :Ii .!t .:! Cot ... '5 " "> -5 ;~o.D~as -.:Ja.....iUCJ...U ~...g"5Jio:J "c-S:u>-J:;,g -c=::Snc 8-!";5':~~ c~-5:s1J!E:j J~e-ta~=5 !tJl];]!t5 "1I't'Ug.~G~ tj C U .... c::: U > ,c,2>.t:..,!i!.cc 1-"'lJIlCI-Cl " c .g '6 c o u B :<: a- G. a, o Q. S o " Q. G .c " "> . m t: ~x. c 0 g Co .t: .!! :J.c .. .. "B.e ~,g. .c.c Q.-:l .i ~ :J.c u a. 'EI;D G C ~.:::: g ~ u u all u > uD ~~ " u C ,~ ... > .. Il 'C o U u .. .c c .. E '0 Q. ~~ .g ! '6'" CJI 8"5 'ii- u 0 :.c iii a. C E s.~ B o :.. :a. 2l~ .. U " O.c.c u.... n.- c a 0 0 .ccQ. .. 0 :J . -::: 0. g..~ i 'g1:] :J~.c g ~ ~ ! .. :: 8 .! ~ 'f.; g .-E. ~ :J .s~; a ~ .s ~~~ ~5 ~ u ~ ~ F K. ~ _ 0 0 !::! li.:t >0 .Q "1:1 U :t .2 Ii .. Cl '5 .!I .Q :J o .., C Il -5 u .; o ; E ~ II a' " !! ~] Cl - I;D .5 .E E i~ ~ :2 JP~ .. 0 .e~ o C " i; .. " " Il :l IT !! ~ i; .. U U C .s i; > .'C " " ; ~ ~~ ~ wi u .., ~ 8 " no.c :E" ,,- 'lJ Q <1 ~ E 80 ~ ::: ~ &. s :; ?;~ = '5 .. u 0 ~- c' Ef"l eQ '2 '~ E .. ~ E' ...'C JI ~ " !! u Q. .~ .E ii 0 >. " u 'C F !! ::- ~ ~ ., ~..! .. ~ g c ..~ a = ! ,,] .c u " c ; Cl -s:S l! t Cl OJ 8." i"c .1:: : .;. :; t: u U Il Q." o 0 a.: ~ ~ .. u '" o Q. .. Q. u .. kll C .. :J " c o :E 'lJ C 8 '0 u ~ ~ 'C II C .. 0 o Q. ,g.:l .c > . .... 1= > 'lJ .. t: i; E " .c ';; t >oQ... ~ 11 ~ .. WI ,c C a .. ]~E ct Q ~ S " c 3 '" Q. Q. II " -5 ... o !! 'n " .., t> .;: C o n. ;, ~ E >. ,_ t: D.8. ] 2 .. Q. II ... ~-S o .. cJ.! JI C u :; u ~ 0: U .!i! :. ~ .!! > u Cl ~ .2~ .. u g ; ::l U tTl;, !! .. 1! ... I- :; ~ ~ ~ -5 .. -5 :: 'E "i ... OJ .... '5 Q. IJ....." . U 0 C ~ g' : ~ ~~ g .5 ! ~ ... oW; ~ ~ ~ Jll-e ~ ~! ~g6 _ u Ii oS u ~ ~ ~ ~ "e.ct; g E OJ B ";3'5~ =:; D1 ., Q. g..~ :: a ~-g:.! In::lS''' f1 D .. 0 M ... ::::J .... g:;.cu :t .. E 'il' "1!_2E ".. G ~ Ii. ..... :. ... 0 u .., -S;~~ O=~.5 See.!! C u ~ ~ .i a.Mi; M ~ 8 ~ :~jii .cg~c I- .. > ;, .. " .c o S-a .. ... ~ B ;;.2 ]'Jl .. > o t: 'ii ... " Q. 0: 0 .~ ~ U -5 'lJ.c >oJ! =.c ~ :t ~.s E~ u Cl .Q,c .. 0 O,c C,c E~ ~ C U t> ~-s 'is > .!l .-5 :l c E ... t> o ~ g'li. ":: E c- ! 0 0>> C> t: ~ 8. @:[ C CI ,!l ""5 i; :J.E :.; t ~ ~S~ M .. .. o t ~ >- != '2 "~!!~E :1..t: ... -s:~a '0 .2 .~ CJ ~~J:I-;: g.;~c; ,; E E 8' 2 ~~ S ~~g8. .;g;g- !! : ~ .8 0...1::=" " ~ s. ... -5 .. ~ =-00- :! :t g ] ! t ~ > CI ; ;: ;J .. CI > ,~ ;~~; M- tJI D 11:11 C E: -s ~ 8-:...'C =- 0 0 C II C I;D Cl ==J1iil! ! " c UI crli':!.;; ! 'M ~ ]' J!'ilFE u ~ ~ .,..c~ ~.2 E 3 "1:1 .c <<I. .. WI C> Ji OJ 'tI o " -5 a. ::l ~ '6 ~ E o .. ~, a, . 'U e u Q. E II E ~ K~ ~ ~ '5 u .. C ;~ ,!l .. ~ '> ~B CI ~ .c.c .. .. Ol- e Cl ~~ 0> ~ c .. "i.; .5! c <C 3 ~ -5 'O:g,s ~ .i::t II ]~l IT.., < t: .. -58.> I;D Cl.!1 is a. '5 u__ 0: 0 0 11 u I;D c.::! .5 Ii ~ C '0 > IJ ~ ~ C E:;: 1.1 c>...c .s~"" u 0: >- "5 Co E :E s g :t t 8 'tI'lJ " ! 0 "E g.SE i 8..~ ~ !! 3 0 " u",i] ~ ~ ;;.!t ~ .5! S ;: .g~B'" ,!l1l.20 ij.; I.I.~ ~~oS.s &~o~ ti.." fn ~ C,t >- c_ ~ii].8 . U 'lJ o >- 0; 'ii .. oS 'ii u .c u '=' ,c :J Q, U .c :i u c J! '" 'i ~ ~B !!. " ...,c ,. .. 'tI < .E "t;I e < " -5 " ..i .2 > " o c ~ ~ c( ~ ,I II: ~ i G .E 1l'fi > E Q. t:-uoc.. 8. g"5 'I: ;: 2uo8.-5 a.. -::: ...i(:C l!.ii~ii:t ... ~.... J: WI S .~~ (;] ~go.~; gN:Ea c:: c 8 " Wi "'"5uQ." Jl 0 "t;I I;D.Q .:: ... ~ oS; I) .!.!.!I,:;g; il~~~ g Q.~...3! -C.Oo" :ii II > C g c>t:ou 3]~~.8 a 0 ..... u .. e=E:::! o .::I ..I: .. := ~""".c~ ~. :. '0 .s ~ ~!! :: ~ ,1:: ~~.2~E 'tI 'ij U !i! C> !oot:D. 1'1 .... <c... j'Cc~.8o i;~::.~.~ ;10 c J:II - ...- C ".Il1l~:i1l ~5;i.sii ::g.o~'i.a c .g II oS ;; g' 'g ~ t :s ~-2g'g o 5 ~ e . ,E".i 5 ~ ~ ~ ~ Q '0 >.: g >.1:: 0 'ii 1i.~~> !r E ~ C> WI E c -5 ~ B ~ .. ~i)vi c-.c'5e ~:CJ- ~ 0 ; Q cUU.c CI u t;: ~ ~II ~.E -= Q. CI . E .5 8.;'6 Q. " >0 i:~~ =..c:uE "i "E:ii :! ::l .. CJ: a a...D g .:: ~ ~ .!lU"lj ; :! t:: > .. - .;.. ti ~ C CJ '5>..g:t ..... t: :1 ~ ::'8.g'Cl .s [ 3 .E ! E ~ ~ tv lot ~ ";; ::- ... u ... .. t: ~ :S- : .2 ,- II .. :a go ~S.5a~ ... o o t> c~ r::"'ij :t :t ]ii - OJ .. C OJ ... .., 0> B 0 .~ ti Ii g >,!! u C ~ ~ c E 8 'i 'C !! 0; OJ "1:1 B c .!! i; > " ti .;:'C '0 ~ I;D C C " ";: E c ... ~~ ~ t 1-"1:1 .. iil:E - .. " . Rec'ei~t II .~ ~ \ . 51,2.~f'1.3 .f. ~(::) PROPERTY OWNERIS) NAME & ADDRESS: . 'BU..l2-D uJf5'S '. c..T COa..p '5 '-I ~ r .12. A, I 'UJo p, tJe; 'J:$L.~N b \2-0 ~ , . -12.1... fr~ 'J f).. "\ I 0 tJ I t=:L. "?J ~ "3), l{ ~, I I \Jt '-..1-1'......... I ..,. SIGN VARIANCE APPLICATION sVII'l3-37 TELEPHONE: [ '3o~ S-1j - I '} :3 ~ REPRESENTATIVE(S) (H ony) NAME & ADDRESS: l--\~l2-t2'1 ~,~f\.I-trJcn.' l4f:7l."t H 4 to \'1\ R-'lL. \L s". -.Sr. \-\ Ae r::e-)L ~ ~ e Ji. ,H- ~ ~o -~ -;"'7-O{p" I \ ~ .p~ {=L l '3 3"'~7- TELEPHONE: ~--o(;l) '2-rPl.(.... 3!L~ L/ 85S A ~11.-5 I ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 7..05'0 5" \.1 S' \ q NAME OF BUSINESS lIF APPLICABLE): lS c.\..\'2 D1 fVE""S I ZONING DISTRICT: LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: C-I F LAND AREA': WI 34 (\u?t;""S ,! I LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY, $1'- e f\-in)-U-\f. b - 1M t Tt:S !>. 'b.ov", DS 3/- 0 ~ i PARCEL NUMBER: J I I ~ I 1 b I (J~ 000 () I 3 I 0 I 02-tJ (This informotion ' is available frorn your tox receipt or contact Pinellas Co. Property Appraisor's Office at 462-3207. If more than one parcel number. attnch ayz x 11 inch sheet) . Gc.- DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: p fHt...~ rlAl-<-Y- South: S tV \ t..Le:- East: West: 'f2.ts ~~'HV n S 11- \.o'Y) S C..,\,..\-L ~ . V ARIANCErS) REQUEST: .0 V'f+1'l..l,vy..\<.(G of \8-S' SQ PI TO f\-\.L.b~\1 3'35'5~ Fr ()-F f\-i1F\c..tteD 9 lfTN A-~e- . f\-'l.(;t:\- W)-\.lt.\.' \ 'S" A-.S50 c, f\..nll W l-r\-\ rt BUSINeSS ~..t..j\~ u..FrN<.-t J N b T V vc;w f\-J3I.,.~ '8!--IH'\t\ 5TI2€{ I (Lllr H' r- 0 f- WT)-\.! I . I -\..! frf. T S 1 ]) l5"" -) (jJ \J 1\41..\ J7-N c..e S\q..N ~ ~.A _W tJ '\ V ,l;W 1\.YbL~ os;:. \ E?:t ~'& F'f \0 A-~L,{.? tv '335' S(J r::r or: ~~J> vJ\..\-\(....t-\ \ s &~ ~Oc.l')t. rE 1> (,.tJ 1;-1* f't 'Bu..( I tJe5.J" tlJ~a:- ~l'LQY\f\ )mc~. r (l.H:r H r ol=" w ~ ,( cgou:i-\.~ ~ (Dt: 1 REASON FOR REQUESTING VARlANCErS): (Refer to Stnodlll'lls for Approvnl. next pngc) t. ~-u-\2-D f ~ '- C \\.f\+l~- 7.. _,_U ()... q _Llll.,\OtAT _p.JhQI:~ Y2-. .'5t ~t-J f\-ttt:t HA-S .:[f..fS\-2:D . pJ?- \ 0 (L lu Co D E:" A-tl b -rtk' (~l{ t ,C71--L \ S' C s s ~ J,.J1-1 p,..L t=.O 12- ... -\0 ~\-\-E :5 L(..pJ Lv 01+-1-1 0 rJ .s Q f" T\"\€ 0L D C.---=r:t\-l S (-z...C \ \'"X ~ TIC ~.~ LO ~ OJ~ f.) t.L.r ,i..H'. f S> .. . I . . < . corHlrwCD au m:vrn5[ SIDE . . . , ANDAROS FOR APPROVAL: A vorionce sholl not be grented by the City Commission unless the application Dnd ' ,dence presented ~Iearly support the following conclusions: 111 The voriance requested arises from a condition which is uniquc to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly npplicable to,the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the npplicont. Any mistoke mode in the execution of a building permit or ,work performed without the benefit of a permit shell not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. .(2) The particular physical surroundings. shnpe or topogrnphicol conditions of the property involved ond the strict opplicotion of the 'provisions of this development code would result in an unnocessory hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecossary hardship referred to in preceding recital .. 2" for the purpose of making reesonoble use of thc land. (41 The request for a variance ,is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financiol return from the property. I Hi) The granting of the variance will not be motarially detrimental or injurious 10 other proporty or improvemcnts in the neighborhood in which the propcrty is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequotc supply of light or ventilation to adjacent propcrty. detract from the appearance o"f the community, substantially incroase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in ony way. or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property, 171 The variance desir~d will not adversely affect tile public health, sofety, order convenience. or gcneral welfare of the community. 18) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the generol spirit Qnd intent of this development code. ~NATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER lOR REPRESENTA TIVEI,j ClA_^'1 ~. &-p<AA,t'--:- , :v-- Jbscribed and sworn to lor affirmed) before me this ~Sdoy of ~1111,J~ u .. pO~1 JDII.n n..lth' D COIJl/'..IIY 'f .ppllc#lIJJlrt' ! -:!;S(,O - 3&~. 3~-o8~-D lawn to me and/or has produced B. )).e; aJel2-'j L iccMSd (T~.p.. "f id"nlifi... li",,1 .~ I'1tfJ<j- , A,O. 19t]p , who is personally C)C~ 3j(,/9t as idcntificatlon. -ATE OF FLORIDA. COUNTY OF /~;NG'LLIf "5 ~ L<<.A~L,A J.--1 .~r~" ""'" "m ..- lwe,.. . /rt 7JftL'''Notory Public. Conunission~~:"~I1H;JlI" IX', M~. 7,1'.4 , I V,.. II...., ,Jl ,ctr"1Vll1\::lIh"".r.i. J";. '-. , 'ANET S McMAHAN ~ . , IN.:Il1le :JI Notory tYJJUd. printed or stumped) .. ' \ ~. ~ I' .1 " .' . \ I . '. . " '.' . j':',' " . ,'~. ~ >'" .... " '. ,/ "I.~' l.~ .:I. ..... ~. :. -......---...---.. , . , . ,'.~. .~-......... '" " [!!JBurdlnes " , I May 12, 1993 city Of Clearwater , ' Department of Planning & 'Development Post Office Box 4748 Clearwater, FL 34618~4J48' Attn: charles Zetterberg , I Code Enforcement Inspector ! , I .1 I i I ! . \, " . Dear Mr. Zetterberg: Burdines'authorizes Heath and company to act as our agent to apply for a signage variance at the above referenced project. We' have enclosed a site plan for, your. review as, well as pr90f of Burdines Ownership. . . . , , I, . ,," If you have any questions 'regarding the above, please do not hesitate to contact me at (305) 577-1932. Cordially, wdLn~ ;f 4 William R. Lyon operating vice President. Director of Construction - '. ' WRL:,cf enclosure Si~,H1alum u~Uc... State a! Florida __'._ Jb So t L. Jj}// L /f . Print TYPf: or Slamp Name of Notary PublIC ~J)r:;onnnv known 10 me, or U l:Jr.)(11 !.::nd Identification: o OlD 11lltO an oath , Type of J.D. o DID NOT Take an oath I , ! .' 1 ", E OFFJ A NOTARY S 'A JOSH AVILA NOTARY I'UBI.JC STNTF. OF FI.ORIDA COMMISSION NO. CC22OB27 MY tOM~i.!~~I.cw.~>f!\SEI'T 1.1996 , f , I ,I I , " . " , , ,', ......~ -__4.. ~...:;:;..~..~ :._ .... "'..._.. -~-,-~.. ,', " .. AFFIDAVIT I, Gary' J:.., ~ of ~s ,Real Estate, Inc. . as owner of the property described as, (",C(lid. paM/on IJnd tl/lmtl of comp,ny " IIppflc"bltJl , Burdines Department store, ,250 CIE!ar\oTater Mall, Clearwater I Florida 33516 do hereby authorize HEA Tit & COMPAN Y (Mark Schaefer) ((lam I If '._/....n r. ~v.1 to appear before the: ,---, L-..-J Davolopment Code AdJustmant Board' (Variance) r-J L-J Plttnnlng & Zoning Boord (Conditional Use) , . [X I City Commission (A'eO~~L Beverage Dlsl0nOO Vorioneo. Sign VArlAncesl " ' I, t I . to request approval of: Leaving exi~ilng Butdlneulgmsg:e..>>s i" at r.ln~I'W;tte" i I.", Mall Burdlnes. (f 1 " t S{~nu.... .f P.'>'I> M~ 11I, A ,.v /I '/<14"1 ,..IJ/~" fll" ,,""'. of ,~m,..n ~ if ap,.~~abl~1 Ti tle 1 YioQ PresIdent Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) before me this /s"f day' of Gary' ~ naY. Vioe President Print N.mtJ (includ, pDIJition tJnd~ntJm/J al comp,my if 6ppflr./lbltll I known to me and/or has produoed ,J; ~t.hO ~ f'?"Yt-t2- I. c !r1':--- !'If t1f(1I!1i~.t;~".' , ,,/ ~ " OF ,I /-I/Jmlt.. T<J N ~{.L/ I' , '("ho Is personally , p..1J . A.D, 19~ toy 8S identlflc8tlo~. OF " , . /~a.n""'Notory Public, CommissIon No, ~ ~ .............. G ,'" ", .,. ~ 0 ~ .... , "1 t; r ...... 11'111/11111,1 , , .'dvt,icl (Name of Notary tYped, printod or stornpod) i 'I " I' 11 ' '(')1:::\ :! \::..10 ~gl~@ ~e r;:=J ~ l. ~ III I Oc==J 10, I ~d toe.i ~" . I "'-'_ , t ._~ 2)0' i ! ~ "\MI'11 :=====~ . t>' , '~.-.,- ",.,~ ....:.....::- - ,- -. ~~Q j~'_r:;-; r9-':'::::"::: .~. :,,'~ - !.._..~ ._~.- .-- .:.- .... -'-:!-"~Ef.::;, .--- : -.. -::., ,-.:...:=.:-. ---r-~. -. -:"'.1 ~~ ;:-: .': :. :-:, '. . ir ' ',-. ,,,.. . .... 6 ~\. ~l.7:.."':;-: ~-.:.::.~ , _ ~l~' .~~:~ ~~. ~., =- ;~. i I: .~ " -"-' I . .. -'" \- 1 t ~ 1 'I ! ~:::-:-:-:.:.~ -::- -~,,- - ~ ~ = ....::~:'.:- " ~~-'-- ll~r~ I ,I~ ~~-\I"r'-. ' 1,.<'1 ,,~ ~ 'E ~ -..... ~:::":"7 ,I "I ~ ~~ ~7=.=:;:=. -:....:.;.::2~~:= }.,p . I .u . ~t ..___r- '.'......" r... I ,.' 1:::== :-~' :'-::--':I=-=- ...- I l",. \" i .:-:---~t~= ,i1., ~.!. '1"":'!-r=". " 1 .. , , . m ~ Y" .-::t"'",o= - --. - I'l---"-"C:. ., ,'..."= -", "-1'" , -..-,., ,-:1 ~~~"~:E F~.. :.::.1=~":~:~ :+ .~. . .:'~~ :"'i".~ '=-r.o~ I=-_::l~~ r ,." u.:.:..:l I ~1E~:'; 1:1':_::J::.~:ti .I__.! . '0. :::~ I~;~:'::':-";': .: l' ~,-~-l'" m'A'~ 1;;=.'::':":' r.~. . ,J... ." I ~i~::':':~f~'~':::"=::-:" ),1-,: I. ('~ ~(-~ ~--J"77lI~'1 \ " . , , , " F~/:,:,l,.::, :,:' " "'j " ,',', , ' , \ -.... ...--.. ...-.-....... ~t " " ~!;:.I " , c ,....,. <' ~ . t-I"'J. ) "t \ t' ! , \ ,. , ~,;r .'~__., . ~ ,,1. 11.._ , . __"'_-.e~. t (!:). .0-_: .:~_. J' , , ~'1 .. 'P ~~ " ~'I' . , ., . ,I " ~ . r,' Q_..'-:'_ ':~'h' vv " i 111' -."1 I I I , :8 I , I I ....1 I ~. I . I .-.~ . I ..... I 1 :-., I '. t I t+. .If I .:/ . e ~4' . ' -tr- " ',' ~- e... o . ''';'1 I"" , . , _...1 \, .' I. ,> ,I ( " 'I 0~"-" . . ' .... '~--:-:~ ~ ',1 " , , ..,.., e -- ,.... ._" .. , .~ " 0, , , ': , , , , ~~--_--. . ~il ~ I... " , ' W', .. .. i~ II h f' '.1~ P I.~ :,0 ~1 I., l~ 'flt I -r---'r t~; ~ "I I -.:_-= 1- " 'J _-.1...__.1 I I (eJ >, ..I " . ," " ~ j : > . ' , i .!, ", ,~~ '.1~ Jl "t, : U ( , , -- 0,,', .I_____JL_~_, _~~ :.,' j " h ~J Q ~~ .-l 11\1 'I 1 ~.. ,; - :"1< !.. .._ .... N. , ' It.: )1 15' . , ," 'I ~I' \j, ' , ...Ir~ IIJ'~ " I , , , J , . , I, I \ I ,1, \ ",.' " , G ~ h' ~~ '111 " " j, ~ ~. I ~ ~ 1 ;~i } I ~ij ~l'/l:J~ "" Jlt\llliF 'f (^t~'i, , . j ..I { ,f ' ': Ii! I ,I.~ ., l ,.. ~~,~ ~4l'1 (ill :19 ..~ ~, -,- ~ " ..' ! ~ Ii- " ,!l " , l...~ ..)~ ". ....,,-'. l' ... 'i, ...,r\"). ' 'V: t 'I 'I ~ ~ 'I ; . '\ G , , , ..... <E " ; , , , ~ ,~: 'or t '/. \.l T' . : t ~ ,~~ ,i ,,'. , , , . \ , j',.' I,' ....,. , , j, "..,,, , , ~~ :-.=:n.--:--:;i .:..t:_ .: ~ . """;%'. _1 ,-,r:.:':::'~ ~ t:...;~~ "... --- . - " ~., " T~~:: ~ o ~ ~ ]@J?), L:.@J' ',r~~:@ . Oc:::;J 1,I!l- O~.: {\"l l ' h',' lei, ~ ' "~''ii>l'' " :'~"::'I -=.:::.::l " "\I'O! --~-~ -=- t> -,.'.., .1 ~~ .~- ," ::-.=. c..::.=.....::. ,,' ~\ .~I ~~'Q'f' ::J' ._~~ F.~~r~' ',. _ ~_::.~,r ~.:;;:'w:..l~. -~~a=-:-. ~:\....::~ ~ ~~j~~~ F- - ::~- --. ~~i-:' . ..~:: '-~.E:fi ~I~-J-- --::I ii I?I~~~~~I!~A~. "~...a" _ ~,-:-~ L':-'::'-I~"-..I"':"". .Il...,.l'--:: ~ .. 1 " . ' " " , Gr:-.:'-" ." . ... ~~--=-:: ~.=r-~ - ~~~~ ..:::;.:::.~ I. .,-.:-~ ~ ~:t:~~ ~ --L t~~' ""=-----:= , I..::.... -:.=- ... 0) , . ,--- l ,11 --"-. i~r ~ ,.,_.ii'! ~..~.7'E.~ ..l;.n'l:~.. I :-r~.:.:-~+ ':":''1!~. }}f;;E:~ . ~~; ~;r ::l.1.ii>1 ~:~tf t,:>f. ;~~l' ...-..."". . ~7i: ...~. ~ ~:s:- .;/~~ :~;;i.:=Jt : :~~~~: ....!::.~ ...i::::::;~ :.1:.~_-'::'. ~~~. ~. .~.. ! ;~~ ',t" , ,,' .. , . , . , , .:: ::-:.f::';: t . .i:":;-j , ::'I:~r "..J , , " , , I: ':. " ."', , " , . . ., I. i' , :'J:.' L ..- ,', '. " : ': " " ( '." "I', ., " '\','," .:'1. . .~ .' .. .', <[)-.- '. :~~.:~ . . 1tl " ".:'.c ;.' . ,.' " \ (U)~. 'I' . ~.- " ' c ~ , " , " ' ~~', .', '.' @-.~ " " \' . . I ~ e " h}' 1 I 1- "'1 I I I I. (j) I :8 , t I I I ' ~ ~ I: .( ~ ~\. Ul ~ . ..-,...... LL., , . . :t ~ I. ~~ o J 5 R G)~. .~_.:. . -.- -. ~. ";I => = -- ~ ~ --:l ..-- -, - .. . .,' , ' ~ , , ~ ,~ ~ <II , . ...t, .., ~~ ~n In ..~ ~r ~. ~ . 'J! ~ ..~ e ~l ~ ',0., ~" " . 'I " , ' , ' , ' ' . ,,' . , ' " , . ' ~ , I . ~ '. l . 1 \ . \ ',' .., " < If , ' , \ " c ' , ,. " " , " ' , ' . > ' 1 , ' , " " ' ' ' , " ' , ' . :.' ' , . 'I',' c,' " . . ,,'" ' " ' : .-,;...; - -:~~_.,.: -'-: _---:.--- - . .:. ...--.-.... ..- ' ' . , , ~ '. 1 . ~ , . , , I +': , , . . c ~ . ~ ' ~ '. . 'I " , ' \ . ~".... ~.. . ,,' , CLEARWATER '-' - , , ", G~r~ " , 1, -. TO - MY IlOULl:V^iiil C---.J t . . ' c n!l..!.LR~ M(0) , . . 'c , . , , ' , . ' I " . >..' ' . . " . , ' ~...... ::. ' .. , l .' , " , , l ' " ' I, . ~' . ~ . J , "J 1 l . Ie. " " ' , I . I , ' ., I.' . c . l NAME: SV.#-~3Q3f PUBLIC HEARING DATE: A-TLAS PAGE:3c:oA SEe: ~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION flD , l.,l., '", .') 11 , ~ 2J/l1 J.J. MUGGS 91- 4 0 ~ ~ . ... ~ ;I I ,. ~ . ~ . .. I: I u..:)) : 2Jjl0 1 Q) "::~ II ~ ~~ II Jlf);41....'.. S TO H/~2 '4;1.1 CG CG I ,- I ~ :E ~ 1I ~ 241r~ 'l ,'- .. ~ UU-In BAY BLVD 2 i. $,R. eo s.'....'n ~ ~ .... .... JI/OI :ll!f tt - "oJ ~ ~ i'!ll_ 1 c ~~ I//"'~~ ;" ^'."' =w ~H' V AR.IANCE REQUEST: SIGNS FED~T\::.-o /f?U'i2-DtNe",:::> 11-\EA-l1-\ 11 TW P: '2..'1 s. RGE:.l-Co E. ~ <) ~h la i I I I , i . ;J^": I I I I r:ll"~~ PH ,'/ I 0> I I I I .0.- \ \ , .... - ...; > r' at >- ... m , C> ... , ... ... :) " .. . ''1 "t:/ rr. "t:/ 5 .., ... ::l it .. :. Q 0 . 'U Uc-- "t:/ ... IT. U Q '~Il't! l'1'C1 t II VI I. i!. ..; '" .. .. ::l 0 l..' -- -- .., roo: :I .. ... .. ~ U VI ..<: .. .. o :,.; o , , I': III 'OJ ,., ~:J;lO:1 o .. Do ..; . ,,/IV pm:tll~lIl 0' "'I \ , c C> I I .. , Vl I :J I II I I. n I -- ------ ....... ~ , ' , ., \ II\- t~, r . ~ ,:.~: t ~. ~: ~ .' . it," I " I ~U:";:.:: .,."" , . ' ",. ,....,;.,:...,,}t'..:..,' ..'" . " ..'. .i:; " ,.'- \ ;~.'. ,." " " ',' , , ,'! ' LF:':;\:\~::iV,;': :":,,:,' ',";; , ' ,'., " "." "', ',,: f;;, ","...i.'.- ;.+s,r~",t,.~:.,~,;.~ '.,",:,.:~),'''"..,;.~,,',,',~.,~'',:.: ,":, :~ >, ';">~ ':, ~!.:, '. ,'.' ~,' :,', ":.:'~';: . 'It.~,:'.;,' .':,:. <'<:,':' ,> ",."", :,,' :1 '. :',::> " . ", ;,: ..' ' , , "i<" :" ", " ,~:, '. ", '.' . ," ,"__'..~,;.','."::";\',I".',:. ",.;".'~.;~,..;,;,:;,\i;','.:'.>~:,..""!,".,. r'- >,,: ,~. :;""'; '.", ,:'" '....:. ..: ,:,:\/:'.., " ,: .,,' '. .; , "'" -' ,. , ,," '.>' i,' ',' l':::,~ ': ":' (,:: ":',,'\n-:',::"';:'~~"~; " ,,':'" ,':; ,::i;:~;.:C:'i":;:"'; ;,;,\:'::,( ::';'::1'<~;!',~';:~ ":;:~ ;;;~:.":,;.;\~.:; ,,',';,~,;{,;: :':Lt ',,;:, " " ': , "',,. . ,,' . ,'. ' . y'''_,\ , ' ..' . ' ,....' . ,.., .. . i,..., ., ' , " . ' , .; . ' ",' ' ! '. ; ,"" , ,;' ,'. ': : ~:' .' ",":;::";~." ,,' ':, , .'. ',' .. I ~;"".,\" .. t L f:}"' t'~ ,'j' f'"., ..~ I ''I'' '\' , '. "r ,..." " "," , :.'.I,i"" .!, .,' ; ..,',; . ~ ~ '. I. . t . I ., :.t " "..' t:':', \' .....t. .,.1 ". ~ ' . ~. : i;' r, ~ ~ '. c' "' \, , : ',t. f....c. ;, " ~;,(: 1-. , .,>. ~. . ". ..:' , ',I, . I 'J.: {r'. ,. " ':1. . j.'c' .t~' f ~; c ;. .~:, ...:~ -:: TC i ,~,~,::\:~,:":'. '~."'" ,', ,':: ". . :... , . \ ... ~ :,i~,:::,~,~",':~,':,~ '::~/,,":'.;~) ":' ',:::'.' /:,': ,': : ,;:~'{;': '",' \'. . ~. '; \, ~.~ I.:: ,.. . ~'.\ L c~:. ~:., . , T' '~'. ~ I , '(", . l ~ ,. c ~ ".:.1 :' lJ, ..r. J,. .,: 'f " , " <, ... . ~ ~ . 11 . '. ,I, I ~ I . ~ ~ . , .' .< '. :,1 ,,' :: > ~: '~' ":~.~,,"~v0: ", "" , \, .":, 'lY;' .', ,. .', , ,< .... ,'c,. ) ,.' ~~: < .'," , ' ,'> ~ t : ! \:.' . 1 ~ ~ :, , , , . ' . , ~. ~. ~. (. . ,1. . '.,' 'I '. , I': "." ' .. .: ':." :.' ' ~ :,.' ':: J I" ,~ /.1\ , . -, 'I,. , ,:/' I, ~ . ~ . '." .... } .' " "i' ", ", " ... ~ :" " ,.T '.t; ,~~\Jgd " , ": , ." :,T c.:',. " '~" ' ", . . .' . t. ~ + . , '" ,~I;.:'::'.'>; .~'~: ~~"J ,'i"', ....: "",' <, . ~ . '.' - " ,'. . .".~: : T , 1 .". ~ ~. t: ~' , , 1.": ~. \' ,. .',,: ...... .... ,> , I' '; ~ c. .~~ .\ .. :. .~ t! < ,,>',' ";:~. "" r)}<':'\~ ':,', :;,',.~., :t,"" .~i:.;: \"~~ f . f · ~'{<;'.~r;,', \'., i:t/::-~::;: ' .~ ~~. f:." I,;.. ~ .. .f0~~\; s" ~ i .). I" :,,, .> ;":";::: ' ::,:,\.: ~'",":- , , " , '~: ' . ~. :. ,jl;.. , i ~ ~. . ;: !' " \./ " . ........, " , ) \ . T .~~.; ~;.,: ';~J; " :..',.,' :0."( " " .. \' " i, , , '.~' I, r.. }, .. ~ '. 1'/,'> , " : ~ " L~::L;'c' ~.'<':' ." i I. .: i'..c\' " :,r. .. , . ~ j.. : j. .1 l. ., ',. ~ " , ' . i " ", 'I .', c/ . . ,\.' 'I ' I.,. ., '. : ~ -. ~ ' " ' :' .' r ~, ~ ~ " ..;!. . " ..... ,.' I. ~ I. .: ~ c : : ~ . 'i , c '\. I 5+~t... ~ r' ,I , . ~,\ . ' ~ " .1,; ./.. " , , .~ , ,'., ',' '-: I' , " ., , CC ~ ',< : 'I. . . :'~ V''. t.t ....:.. .,' ~ I',' /- ' , ' " " ':. " \ ' ~ 1< i. . ;. f \',' " I . ~ ~ ~ . ,i ';of ,'. \ r . ~ j '::. ~;.. f . ~ < c ,'. ~ .i.~.. .'} '~\:..( (, T~ " , ~,' L '.:.-'1 I > " ~ f ( :/1' 1,.' ~ . ... i,':.,-: ':": , , . '~ :": >~ :1: t, . " I: I ~ 1 .' ' :'J/i)':i::,.:. , '.', 'J'. , " " :. I". ,,' ., .....: ..~. . .~. " '. \ i: '1,.. , f, I. t.; j. . .,,'.~),.', : ., , , t t.: " ,. '! {:.. "J ,.' ,. I' . , .' +1 ~T. Of. . , t. ~ ',' " ~ : .' :.f I ./. , ," " ' .1 ,I " 1,. . \ ^ ~T" '~I<, ~~ 1, :' ;/::.~' ..' , .j.. " , '. I,' :f i 1 l. ';,' ~ " " , "<' ." ~,' , ~ ~ . .' ' , , ,. f. . . ~ ~ < , i '.: f, . \, . .h 1,; _: ~ . , '~'.. .... \. '.,.,' ".e . ~ , <.> ;- ~ ' : t '{. , , ...: t . ," 10 '. ~" , , <'I. i , ,\ " . : ~: ~ >I . r : ~ ~.. . t . ~ , " I ".' 'I,' .' ~i , , " ;.' .', 1.' '. .:. :\',> L , : ~ '. -:' ,I'- " . ~ c ~ ~. " .1' (. . c;' t - ~ , " 'c:.l 0:), \ ',~ ,,' .:1 " I" 1., , ~ 1 . \ ~ , , . , .t. ;? .' ~ ~ ,,' 1-:' .' ' ~ ' , . ,i' '" ':'. >, . ,.' " . c ~ . T ~ ~ ," :, ii ", ,', . 'i'i t> i, .J '" , , "" ~j> : ~. , '.'i ., ..~, "~'I{' , ~:: t :. ..}"\ . , , ,n ,c t.. ;1., '. ~ c:. :. l ~ . ' $, ',;' , " .', ::'/t:/: .' '.. '!: .,.cI :.;. "J l ; ~ ."..\ ':.:', t , .' ,: , : \ , ~ ," , , " , ,\, . ;\ ~: :'/ ,- .~, ,'l i:" < ,;' '. ) ~ t. :t " , '. ~ ", " I .. '~. , .,.':.' , " ~' ,1 " " '",J ..'; !'./rr i, ~ ~ ~ .\,: Ij:' . J' ~ t' , . ~. ,I . " .'.:'. t. , : .' , , ), " , '.' . , 'r .,, ; , > c < ~ I. ~ ,.' ' . . , ~,'. c ~, . , : ~.:, " c'l( - .. ; ~ \ . . ;::t ~ ~ i <' ~ ~ ',' " < ~. . .' ~ ,l, ; ';'" '! i' '.. ..' q ~. " .).' " .' , (: il i ~. , . " ~ ~ . , ~ c>~. i i'" " , i,,1.{c' " ' i ~, , '~ t \ , I l -:-;. I,. ~ " . . ' ~ ~~ . c. '\', ~ .L " '." ~. \ .' " t ..'t'" . l j: . ~ Ii " " \ .: " ~ .">" L :\ ., ;'.' I. ~ II '.:' < c, " " , , . ~ t~ f " . " " , , , o \ :.." '. ~ . ~,' I, ': .\ ," . ~. ~ ',j , ' " ,..j.,' t f- ~ . iii .' C." '\ ~ ' .: '\,. : t : . ~.~ l ~W;." "'. i : : '. ~.;/. ,'; . .l." l' " j. , , ,', , \, " , " ,I, .' " : "f i . ~~ f "} '.', ,t. '" " . ~ ~.: r . , (' \' , ~ c ~ :: j..' " ~. '. , (: ,:'.~' ~ ; . . '.,.." :', ~ ,j. . ..' . r C ~. : ~ . "~ .",. ,'. >- "~:. .;\ \. f~ ~'.i~,t:,V'.~ ~.<~> >4' \J.r:~'~~ ,.' , , ,i,T'1 J"". \.'.j ". . ,.' ~ . . ;. ~ ,I. . . . ~ '" '\' ,", . ;,K. ",. , ".'l , ' " , . , . ~ ~,' .3. . .'.t. ,/, ...'. ~\. \.." , " ",: I /~l ". :! . , ,-; ,. ., ~~. l:. < , c"' ~.' ,'. ~.:.., . f ,I '" ,,' " , , r. .. . ' ~. '," ~, \ ;1' ';}'.~ +'c'~"""_;-:'T.;.~I :,. ,..,.. ~. " I: \. T';" +, .';. "( ~ C," " , ',t' t. ", " , , ' t":1 .. , ~. I' l ' . ~ I .~ . '/ ,;. .... .. ". I ~ . " , ..' , ., '" ,( , ' .1 "1, ~ . t:. \' \. f' ,,' ,', 'I. t',," , I, ,.,- .+ ,. , ,',," I c. . ~. ." " "," . . ~ ~ , ~ , . I i'.,": , ; I" " ' " ,.,.' c, ....., . : ~ . . \ ,;.. .' .~~ ;' , " '< , " .) ,,' \, . . , " , ."{ ,.' . " ~ ',' ~ " ' ~. : j" " "~ .:' + " , " , , ./ ;>" ". ;, ',' " " , , ,I , , " " " ,,' ,t " , , ~.'" f. " ,/ , ~. " 1,lp. " ;..' \/':,.. ", \ --; ., " < t ,'; ,:. , ", ,AGEN'DA, '. ' '. , 1 , >, . ~ ... ,: l '. ,\ " ' " ' ,; 'It. . .~ ~ : ~'~"J . , , .', Ii' ~: I 'l~ :! , '.' " ,<. .~t_:. " " ,I" " '.' \. l.' i:,tc !.}/,'::', , ~. f';= L .. , " ',' " ' . .' ~ ! ~ ~ ' >. , : ~ ,. '~ .t" t i' ..... .l 'c . r !" " , ' \ ~ : . I , ~. ~ . ~ ..i. " " " " , . c" .. , . ~ ." ( ;>:i';~ ~" ;: !~ :, : .' "; to.. I., " ~, 1. I, ~. i ' : 'i I " " , ';?' :DAT~~ , ~"- .' 9#- " , , ';'/ .. . /" t " .1 , , ,'1< ; , ~ : , , , . j ~ " , \c~' . , , l' 1 ~ ITEM" #-15 ; ~ .. " J 'JI" : . " ." ;> ~'. >.' ': , '\ , , ; Jr ;'" 1', , " " . ,. ", ! ' " ., . ,! J, \' , " ; , " ~~.' . .. , " .' , ~t . " .' ~' \' ,', '" " :;: ".}t 'j " , : '\ I ~ J , :'~ I.., .' f, '" , , , . , ~ ; '" " ., ~. \. " ,,' t'C , , , , ~\ . " , \ I I : . " l' ;:',',,'. , ,"t " ;, , ' , . i .(": ~~ . I " . ~": '. I, i, Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum 15 It~m tJ He~tin!l Oilt~: 11;)~/q~ SUBJECT: Variance(s) to the Sign Regulations; 21227 U,S. 19; NSI Venture Fund VI . Cambridge Apartments Limited Partnership/Cambridge Apartments (Owner/Applicant); Rick Hardwick (Representative). . ISV 93- 61 ) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Deny variances to permit nonconforming signage to remain on property identified as See, 17-29-16, M & B 22.02 for fajlure to meet Sec. 45,24 Standards for Approval, items 11)-13). (5). (6), and (8), o and that th~ appropriate officials be authorited to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to permit an existing freestanding sign to remain: , 1) An area variance of ' the 65.25 square feet from the permitted 24 square feet to allow a freestanding sign with a total area 89.25 square feet; 2) A height variance of.18 feet from the , ,permitted six feet to allow a freestanding sign with a height of 24 feet; and 3) A setback variance of fjve feet from the required five foot setback to permit a freestanding sign zero feet from the U,S. .19 right-of-way. The subject property is located on the east side of U,S. 19 between Drew Street and Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard and is in the Multiple Family "Twenty Four" (RM 241 zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. Information ' I Existing Permitted Type of Sign Freestanding Yes location/orientation of sign U.S. 19 Yes Area 89.25 square feet 24 square feet Setback o feet 5 feet Height 24 feet 6 feet Rev i cwed by: Legal ' Budget purchasing Risk Mgmt. CIS ACM Oth~r lotnl COIlrnilad 011 Ac t i 011: o Appro~ed o Approved "/concJll1Cm~ o Ocnll:cl D Cont lnuccJ to: __.....__ NIA N/A NIA IUA ~r ~Yft6 = Originating Ocpt: . CENTRAL PERMITTING C Costs: User Ocpt: Current fiscal Yr. ..... .. , Advert iSL'tI: DiltC: Paper: TAH~A TRIBUNE o Not Requt red Arfected Pnrtieli r;J Notified o No! Rcqui rcd h~din!l Source: D CflpitM Inlp, o Operilt Ing o Other At tllc:tUIICfI!S: APPL! CA II Utl VAR1ANC~ WORK51lEfl ~A~S D NOIW SLbnh ted by: Apfll'opri II t i 011 Cude: o Printed on recycled pnpel' SV 93-61 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: , , The new sign ordinance is being uniformly applied to all signs in t/1is zoning district. The applicant contends that the frontage road providing access to the site causes an additional setback from U.S. 19, Furthermore, the commercial zoning of the surrounding properties allows larger signs. Although the frontage road does cause the sign to be setback further from U.S. 19, this is not the only property located on the frontage road and this location does not constitute a unique condition to this property. <In support of the height variance, the applicant contends the future 'overpass at Drew Street will allow the existing sign height. Initial plans for this overpass are not scheduled untlllate 1995. The height bonus provisions do not include future construction. There are no physical surroundings that prohibit placing the sign out of the required setback. The applicant has not provided any evidence that these variance requests arise from any conditions unique to this property. These variance requests are extreme with regard to the permitted area, setback, and height 'of a freestanding sign and cannot be considered minimal requests for the RM 24 zoning district. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing Land Uses North Drew 19 Shopping Center South, City of Clearwater soccer field East Vacant land West Mazda Village Auto Dealership, Lenny's Restaurant (across U,S. 19) To the north and across U.S. 19 are commercial uses, To the south is a public soccer field and motel. The existence of this 89.25 square foot, 24 foot high sign wi,th a zero foot setback is not in character with the signage permitted for the RM 24 zoning district. The granting of these variances will permit a sign that is larger than is permitted in any residential zoning district and some commercial districts. This is not consistent with s;gnage permitted for otller multiple family developments on U.S. 19. and would permit an unfair advertising advantage lO this property. Also, this sign detracts from the surrounding commercial businesses that ,have' conforming signage for their zoning districts and wW negatively impact the overall appearance of the community. Applicable Variance Standards To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application. staff limJs tllel! the petitioner's request meets only two of the standards. In particular. the following slamlards do not appear to be fully met:, ' ( 1 ) The variance requested arises from a condition which IS unique to the property In question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor crealuu by an action or actions of the property owner I predecessor in title 1 or tile applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit sllall not be considerod to bo situations whicl1 support tllU granting 01 a variance, ' SV 93.61 Page 3 . , The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property Involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would resul~ in an unneces~ary hardship upon the applicant. The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. The grantin9 of the va'riance 'will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or Improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property, The granting of , the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. " , , , , . , . " c , ' (2) (3) (5) , c , (6) (8) Relevant Previous, Decisions by the Commission: CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES REQUESTED/ACTION SV 92-05 '20162,U,S.19 Suncoast Inn 1) Freestanding sign area (95 sq. f1. addD/Denied but Approved 38 sq, ft, addl), ' 2) Height (15 ft. addll/Denied but Approved 5 f1. add!. , 3) Setbacl< - 5 f1. variance to allow 0 ft./A roved 1) 4 subdivision sign height (2,84 ft. each) 1 Approved 2) Subdivision sign area (2,24 sq. f1. addr.total for all signsl/Approved . 3) Separation subdivision signs to each other (125 ft.) IApproved ' 4) Number of subdivisio'n si ns (2 addll/A roved SV 92-17 2225 Nursery Rd. Oakbrook . condominium I, , [ I i J , ! c, I MEETING DATE 517/92 10/1 5192 ..- c.c I M O'J > en c:c w to ~ ::J Z w en c:::t C,) I- w w ::I: en ~ a: o ~ w U 2 <t - a:: c:( > I ~ U ~ ~: i~& ~; B;~ a fl U " 'tI .!l c .z:; CI CI is ]~i~]s .!lUCOa;>oC oS .S 2 t: ,g -SS%Q!..:a ~..~2'e; =::~EQ.u -a'gi~-r~ ~ ~E~~f S:23.c~a "C>~gb! ~e...oc= 8::-.j:€~-5 a~~ct.!l~ >"EM'53 eUtlc '.. ...o~..ccmo _ t: ";; ""'" c: .~eLf~vi~ ~'; ~~.g S.c~.!IEc .8: .:~.2 .. ~ ....... .!loS;,:8t:l u"E".c~ U'tI ..t:.11 55~-E.a-S ~ g~ ~~"!J QuJEJi C-1oli-tL'C.'"O Ji!' g :: CI .. :: ..u_.S.... l'a.~'tI~.. ..n...!l8SCl ~::5!!cE ~~11~~~ l u C ~ a .. : g !! CI IJ ;! t~.E > " u o ; -g G f!-y :; ~ .!: ~ 0 ~ ., ,II g oS '5 0 {l~~ ~ ~ j C..!!l ,Il 8 CL ~ ~:Sa. a.t:: " ,g.52 n. . 0 ~.!: ~ ..Ji!'E -S~-r 8j~ j :. ~ c.5: >-ui ...!lm .c"'m ClU... ij " IJ ~;- ~ loS : g ~ C' 001;, t:!:'tI.g 8. ~ .!! :..u Q.... ::::J ___ ;I It ~ ... " ~ .t: c .5 ci) ~ 8 'tI II !! ; .5 ~ 0"0" ~ ~ ~ !l _ c o.!l .. ;; :J ... o U I: " -r~ .. ~ .c a ...c Cl~ -n II oS ~ ~ ~ ;. ;e U t .c>a. o C 0 - a .. a. 'tI n. ~~~ ~ ;10 ~ II 0 0 gta.: ~gj 2 : 5 ~ -: ~ _co2 flJ!:ij l."li.; .c ~ u 0...> g ~ ; U E ~ ~ 2 u g "; i;~ .... .. a ..; c. :lil~ uj=l ::j ~-: E C tlI 2 !! .5 ... II i ; U G "@ ;; n ,:!t:] .11J!. .2 u ;>0 0 Jl~~ : ! ~ .. a.. ,\I .Q .!l .t: soS1! C Q B tIl~_ ft c ~ ~~:c ..'Un. :: 5 :! ;J u ~ fl g g- .. 0"" g ~ ~ 'tI > 1,1 "0 I:: a. ., a ~ e tJ It & a .. c.,w ~ E ~ ] >- .gg;lt: CI ... 2 '" -sg$g. z;..~a ~.gJ!::! .c.!l ~ ~ ~; ~! U "g 8 ~c i ~ .. 0 r~ ~ U "tJ"O ~.!l "'5 ]0 .c .. c.. c E II 0 fl o.:i= 8.~8: ~ ~ a .. " .. O.c.c u ~ .. a. - C 0100 ~ ~ g- :;'fl~ :E:.- !WI ~]:1i ::0 II .c 2.. ... ~ ~ ~ ., .. ; :: ] ~ ~ OJ .: >'tI I:: -a ~ ::2 .i] i ;, ;10 S ~l.!:: C .5 ; ~t~ r:8.~ N a' ~ 'It N 1!:=: a D: ~ " u.c a ~ .Q .. ~ 0 u'" .. :! ti .. u u ;; 6- ] ~ ,E] E_ -S 8.E ""0 '5 ! g~ "E ~ II 0 au ~.8 oJ: 'ji ~ B ~'U : i ! ll. ~Oj ;! U'tl ::0 C 0"11 .. ... - II " ...~ .: ~ .~ .!I II ... : 'O:ij IJ.... c :g~ ~ ~ 2 .. n..c :E'" ..... 'tI 0 :; ~ .c ;, ~~ =iI .. C g ~ ~ :J C _ ::0 a u C '"5:;2 E E 8'0 :i ~ ~ 8. oS ~ >a. .. " ::'5 ~ ~ " - I:: . E~ ~Ci "E1l - u E .. ~.~ ~'tl ,!! tl ., !! ~ ~ .! - ~ S: u'tl .c !! I- :; -ci - - C !'2f.s 'ii > o C. 0. a u U C -! II > ~ 'C :; 'CI C :l .. ~ ... s:. ,':: ,J -a ,E 8 o ..., ~ II ., a. a. II 5 ~ IT f tl c: .!I ;; :- ~ l- 01 .!l c .o:E] ~ ! ~ ..a Q t:II m ';j ,,;g C . ..c ... :a .. .... ... ! c .Y.. o >::0 .2ti l: 2,; o -:: a 5 "'C u.i.5"o ""O'tI".s "g'=;; ii1: 'E E .. :;[~~ .ll' N.II ti :;; ~:;;~... ClD:..c"8, :Ea""'Cc "';I5:;~g ~ ... ~ ~ " ~;~ull' .~..'5E g].s4l~ ';;iil::581:: .. a. g U au" ... &J g.2'IIE~ ~j,~ ~-: C\f " t U .t:..a m~ a.!! ta_=t::; ~ :€ '~ ~ :: :3:ti-gE o t c ., ~ 8o.:!j!.a ~S:i:S .i1i""TJ~ :: I: ~ ~ ~ u-=!i'~E ~go~g .. 2 g~ oci.e>. ocr c.....ctJI-E :.sc .!!ui~W;:l .S.!l.!l::j"g,E .g~~;~l:~Oj~ aa.,2J'It 5 ...0" tIl U .!I = N ~ ~ ~ c.5 a _ ~Ul:.!lEoS .c~~e'::Ec(O'" -=.c's;,Ila..'Co o ol.!l'U~ >0 8 .. 0 ~ .. 1i ., t: U I: .s~~.s t~ ~= ~ o .'UI:: E>a..c 8. ....o~,2Je=.!I'iin. oX:"oE.c.ca ~-El3u.!",,,,! ., ! u J:: E tJ 3 :l II ;J~a..Eg].u=> :5 O"&""X: CI.. 0 u ., a a.. "D :J ~.E a "1D1:=cEc"oS E:t-f.i~!~~b 5co II lJ.g.. 1I.!l 8. u~'5gi~f~~ ~-5=.!i"'CI~:i~> 1I_'i;;CI'tIt:Eu alO :o.5u"o.i! ~g!~~~i:'i :i! ~.c:9.. ~.t:j;! J!": Q.~"g"O ';:"50~~56~ ti.!~.r~~~S:3 lI....oc~.2't:...!:! "g . C ~ >-" 'E ... :: c _ .!! QI. c .z: .....c .!! m.!"JtulQ..t:'lJI-"tI .cou.cc3:a.Eoo ;EII....:O'C:22.s !:: "C .g ...; G II ::1:.... E; .!i ::u1:.i~tj~ "';2(;"SE~~~i ~:!~,g 8..8 i~o5 C ,2 u .i -Stll .E~~=6 ~ -! ll' ~ ~ II: ID 0 0:!1!l:: .E]U; g; ~a o ~: ~ -a-E~~ a. ~ ~ " ;l E i-S a 0 "U ... '; IJ o.ii :.1 ~ ...I:: a. g-!i;.5 ~ 0: :; C; c: &I ......c CI ~ ti.n .. ~ E:: c: i;; ~:~ .5 & ';j 'tI A.!? g : ;;] -5~~ 'ie.g; 8.g :-~ c .. -of: ... .! ~ ..- (; ~=.s> u -8 e II .c "Sl 3: +J~~> ~ l ~ i ,S e B.5 ~a..IJ~ ~c;:.! ~8~:> t:~~,Mi iQ~t1.go _ ~ .!i Q. Q. Cj > o C. 0. a .. U I: ~ II ;10 ;; - 'U ;; "0 r. :l .. ,It -S -S 'i ;>0 1i. E o u o .. ::! II " a. a. II ~ .. .. ;:r fT ~ u U I:: ~ II :0 .!l t: ... 'tI 0 C Co a .5 ~cE it E ~ 1! ; " ~~~ >~ .t: CJ .; ~ ~ 0. eE -!! ~ ;:r"g 8~j t:~'tI o Co c ! .~ : ~ II i ';j ~ tD.c~'" ~ ~ ; ~ -:0.:'5 ~i5o ;.s.!j 3:1'::'; j~:.-s ~ii" :." g..8 .t: ~ u a U &;,.. ~~'5~ .wQ.MiiU 'O!:~ c I:l a 'D .2 lo5 fj -a~~~ g.s-; i; u.!I 0 > ~g,~Jl .5!n.'5 ~ ~ ~ i 'tI t: ;. ~ 8.a. t: .. .. &.g-S-:: ~ 2ti::i2tii ;~~l! e E-: Q j IJ r:: o.t:: -:; ~ ~ :: E.g 'e Ib 8' u II' :J'5t,)Q.C). .!l 'tI, 0l.Q .cS~.~a '!:!.J2D.;g- -,=.c':~~ 3:ll~~t I::'aS~:s1 ..!lQ.OO" :5a;>oc~ c~t:.2u gE~aJ .,..2 ... IJ' .... E'E:-~~ o ::lI.c u -;0:';] u~Cl.5: .!! ~ ~ II C ,Sl .::] ~'DuE8....; ~ g <c... c CI::.8o .'l1!act"o> a iQ >- ..c.5 >.:.Qc"E u.Sl] fl :; II ~;;:a~D _ ~ II t:: ~ C 0" !l ~ '3: oS e ~ c B >== a- a- Il tI -5 '0 CI .!< .. tI 'U ~ .. C o 0. ;, ". .! ~ c.n. " 0 :: c. tl .. ~-S o M I:,::! .Il I: 8 a C ~ '5 :5 > g a a ~~ ~ " : 0 ::0 u ITa. !! a 1,1 u ~ - _ e :! :: - .. .c :; g'li .. " ] B 5..2 :E.!l o t Cj .. E g. .~ ~ uo5 'tI.c ;>oJ:! =.: ~ l " c ii u 0 ,:2.c ~ ;; Q .Q C.c Ji!' u .: to -S 5 3: " U c ~S ~ .. .!l E oS ~ ... " o ~ COc. .s E 1:- a - - 0 Cl~ ~ '5 .... 0. @:a M .. '!:! o >. ] II .. ~ Ci u .c u :0 ::0 a. .. '"5 >- U-E ~ :J ;; E ;>oE Ci 8 E ti :0 = 11'0 0: !! C:!, =1i 3: 3: ]] .Wi g .. c "g ~ .. .. U 0 I: .!l ~ ;; C ;10 J! " c .c u .... ~ S 8 '- o .. I:: " :s " I: a .. - 'Q. .. ~ u C u i;D " 5 " i o '> .. o I:: = R I 'j 'n !! ';; to "0 u u c .l!! II :0 u .; ;::'CI ... B o .., CI c .s ~ C 0. ::!..2 01 .. ] ~ ....'tI - ,!! 1Il.c - ~ U ~ <- CO l') 111 .. > l " *""".-I~'~~ :: 4110 .; { ~ 1'1"3 I' So pF:oper:rv OWNERISl NAME & ADDRESS:' ;.:......r. 'w AKI;"t.~~ l~r'''''...I_;''1 h.Jt. ~3- Co\ REPRESENTATIVEISI In lIOyl NAME (. ADDRESS: , , NSI Venture Fund VI - Cambridge Apartments Limited Partnership c/o NSI Management Inc. l4lU Enterprise ,Road Clearwater, FL 34623 TELEPHONE: 1813) 7.25-9537 Rick Hardwick,. General Partner c/o Tidewater Enterprises, Inc. 19321 U.S. Hwy. 19 No., suite 500 Clearwater, FL .34624 TELEPHONE: [ 8131530-9700 ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 21227 No. U.S. Hwy 19 No., Clearwater. FL NAME OF BUSINESS lIF APPUCABLE): . Cambridge Apartments ZONING DISTRICT: RM-24 LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: H.D.R. LAND AREA: 13.02 acn LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: Sec. 17-29-16, M&B 22-02 PARCEL NUMBER: 17 I 29 / 16 I' 00000 I 220 I 0200 (This information is available from your tox receipt or contact Pi;'ellas Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462.3207. If more than one parcel numb er. attach 8 ~ .x 1 1 inch shee t) DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North:. Retail Shop'ping Center South; Ci ty Land, then Motel East: Vacant Office Land West: Retail, Motel, Car Dealers , ~' q~ Of VARIANCE(S) REQUEST Of Variance to 7 year amortization requircment. rcfcr ITu.-Scc. 134.015): , tI <...' Bq I- Variance of ~.25 feet. to allow ~ sign ~rPR of~ ?~ ~~ f~ wh~r~ 24 Sq. f~J is allowed. .. ~_ d.VJ- Variance of ~ feet, to allo\o,' 1'1 sign hpighr of~r whprp lift ; c:: ;,11owen Variance of 5 feet, to allow a sign setback' of 0 feet where 5 ft. is required. Tf possible. a variance of existing si90 variances until overpass is completed for reasons outlined below. REASON FOR REQUES11NG VARtANCEISI: (Refer tD Stand;yds for Approval. nen pugc) Area zone RM..24 and the surrounding properties ,are CH. Setback, property is on a service'road thus increasing the distance from U.S. HWy. 19. D.O.T. plans to construe t an overpass over Drew Street .in the future .-which w0l11 r1 :-Ill ("'lW a si~n to be 10 feet over the crown of the overpass (which is an unknown h~ht) . It I s likely' the height allowed would be the same as current1 y. in place or even higher. ' , . ' COI\!~.t\L:::D Ol'~ F'..EV::?,S:': S I~::: " I " j, , I .,.1 '" , " ..1 : , ' STANDAR.DS FOR. APPROVAL: ;.. vananct- snail no~ be granted 0\' tne Cit~, CommISSion unleB' rne 'aophc.:?tlC:ttl ,mc eVloence presented, clearly support tne lollowlno, conc'u~lons: , ' \ 1 1 'The variance reQuested BUses from a condition which is uniQue to ,thE: ,property in Question <lnc is nelthel ,ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the %.onm9 district nor created by a~ action or actions, of toe prOO!!rly owner, I:lredecessor in title. or the applicant. ,Any mistake made in the execution of e building permit or \'\Ior~ performed without the benefil of a permit shall no't be considered 'to be situations which SUPDort the QramlnC; of a variance. 121 The perticulcr physical surroundings. shape'o~ topographicnl'condltions of the property involved and the sui", applicntiory of the provisions of this cevelopme,nt code would result in 'an unnecessary hardship u'pon th. applicant. !31 ihe v,ariancc is the mi,nimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship relerred to in preceding recit,: "Z" tor the purpose 01 making reasonable use of the land. l~l The request for 8 vDrian~e is nOt based, primarily upon the desire o( the applicant to se'cure 0" greater (jnanci.. return from the propert)'. , 151 ,The granting of the vDriance will not be materially detrimental or irijurious to other property or improvement!. in the ne;'ghbolrhood in which the property is located, , ' , . ' 151 'The granting,of the var,iance will not impair an adequate supply o( light or ventilation to adiacent praperq'. detract from the appearance of the community, SUbstuntially increase the congestion in 'the public streets, ' increase ,the danger af fire, endi)nger the public safety in any way. or substantially diminish or Impair the valur: , ~f surrounding property. . . (71 The variance desired will not adversely afiect tlie public health. safew. order c,onvenience. or general welfart: of the community. . ' tSl The gronting of the variance desired wm not violate the general spirit and intent of this deveiopment code. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE1: -;::e,,~~ @~.~J-r Rick Hardwick , . Before me. the undersigned authority. personally appeared deposes and state~ . the matters and facts set out above are true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge and belief. I Sworn 'to and subscribed belore me this q.J? day Of~':,L ike,tdl (1-R J r Notary Public ' A.D.. 19~. NOTE: PROPERTY OWNER OR REPRESa1TAllVE ~ ATrt:.ND HEARING. "." DANA C. roRO " , MY COMM [XP: 4/05/96 . aOND[O BY SERVICE INS. NO, CCr927J9 nt\', ':I~ ,. ,', , , i _'0 , " I, , " ,I, " " .1 " . ~ . , ,I , ,1 '. rl:; ',' : ~; I 'I. " I" t ~: f I. >. ~ ',I .1\ > t', c. ,I ~ ' '.. i ! " ,1,,\., " .... .......... >, ,; ,. ...... I~ '#. . , ,I , , 5ft. " ~~~~~ A/?;JlfiAi {)/is , , 3,,5~, < ", ;?-fA=: , h,~~' , .. I' ; , ~ . T '. 5". 5.f+. '.i " ,t " " " " , , " " ' i\ , , ,t, ': , , , ., t' o k~: (\ .1 ,Jv-o I.-r\ ffD r~~ /;.~ , ' , ~. c . . ~ I, ,I 1" .-, ~ - . r ~) \ I ,.., I' I. ~ f \' >~ \: , , , , , '. , . , 'I '. ' " ( ;td~"'-~ 'C;p,tJ/1j \ , ' I . , '~ , '. " " " . t '. '. , ' , , , ",I, . I~ 124-126, I ,I 128-130 CAMBRIDGE CIRCLE 125-'27 J, I . , , j. ': W ...J U a: U w t!) o a: m 2 23 1'09-' , 1 I } , , (C1ll1 ~, ~}e. lkc,,'th~V\ b. ~'r1 . /iJ Cll nO/) ~~, l!J 1103-1011: U,S, 19 NORTH , '. .' I ,32-,341 1138~' 36\ w '....J u a: u w C) Cl CI:' co Z <C o I~ CU,W\ 6 r\ ~()-l.. <"' , s ,.). q .'"\ J ,- d 00 t 0 Co. ~ ., _ ' +~' Nor~ '~ oP +\-u- s~, 'b\'\~, Mo.' () ~ D {\-, 4'-\.u.. ,tA. S'. , . t q ~. e...n/l c.e.... )(0 ex c\. ... . " { // ,!# ~~ I~. ~~P?,1J,. 1144-1461 115001481 W ...J U a: u w (!) o a: m 2 <( u L' '; , . . . , ,. Ie . ,. O':! ~ ' . ~ '1 ., :..' ,,;' 0- ,. '. . - ~. I ~.I .: 1 . " . , ':,'. , . ~.' 6!.' " CIi. : . '- :,\'':' .'~: ;.. . .. . ~: ".'.. >t . " " ','.0<' ., '''. - lOt o on 3377-782 ~ ~ DREW "'5'\, REsmlcnONS 438-4-33/1 2/40q f81 '- /I-U S 1311 - . cfl . :) Nom AU. ADDRESSES NlE OfT U.S.19 4374 -331 22/01 ACREEMEIH 4207-1273 cc ~ M5 , 2/W! In~ 0- ~~ ~~ m Ok;;' {ft '- h~ - ;; ~ ~ (0.1 .,: ~ t)o N M ~ 1'f'Il;'n ... ;; N N to '0 ... to. - - l)... 3= ... t"'f 2\ /00 , . 06 . , ROt 211 33 22/03 CITY O~ED ~<:) . ~-/ P/sP ~ 210fJ7 C R 2J/02 C ~ 3811 z~ 10\ VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS NAME: tlSIjfENlURE ::h,,,,d pm'o..-,dS<= Ar. / \--\A..-clVJ\CK SV#~~-Co\ PUBLIC HEARING DATE: ATLAS PAGE:Z:B.JA.SEC: \7 TWP: 29 S. RGE: \(0 E. ~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION ~ .., ,..., o ~ .. , - .. ::I L' c::> ", '" - - '.. ~h I:> ... ~ u 1~ 'n . 'rll I I I> I I ~l . S 'II () ,po. ).. .. m , 0 OJ I . ... I .... 0 I :3 I . , .~^~ r~tn:OJ"H . .. .,; ..; ,'7 ,,, ." ....' 'tl · 0 ~ ... '.. I :> 'I'll :I:U:lj I .. .. I;) :. CI 0) .,; I .. 00-- ... <:::l-"' .... 0: Q. , U \ > , Q . :It.or ":t-e1 .. '-- u ., 'i1^Y pU-er'l~tH .. ... \ ? ,,, \ ..; <: 0 , V" '.. I <: .. .. ;> I VI .. I :> , 0 I U Lt I t. -~ .., -- t M on o 1 .. ''"-- ~ .' , , ClealWater City Commission Agenda Cover f\1:cmorandum (G. Item # Hcatlng DotQ: IlaqLqcf SUBJECT: ,Variance to the Sign Regulations; 1200 S. Missouri Ave.; Fusco Management Company/Sunshine Mall (Owner/Applicant); Kay Vega (Representative). (SV 93-62) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: ' Approve the height variance of four feet to permit a freestanding sign 24 feet high on property identified as Sec. 15-29-15, M & B 34-01; together with Sec. 22-29-15, M & B 21 ~01" 21-02, and 21-12, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8). ' ,0 ond that tha opproprlota offlciols ba outhorlzQd to eXQcute some. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting a height variance of four feat to permit a freestanding sign 24 feet high. The subject property is located on the w,est side ,of Missouri Ave., south of Druid rid., and is in the Commercial Center zoning district. The variance is requested to permit the reconstruction of the ex'isting freestanding sign which is substantially nonconforming to height and area requirements. Pertinent summary information is listed in the table below. I : ' " Information Proposed Permitted Type of sign, Location/orientation of sign Area Setbacl< Height Freestanding S. Missouri Ave. Yes Yes 150 sq. ft. 5 ft. 24 ft. 150 sq. ft. 5 ft. 20 ft. Ravlllwld by: Legol Budget Purchasing Risk Hgmt. en; ACH Other ----lY. A NIA NIA NIA N!AtL N/A Drlglnallng Dept: , CENTRAL PERMITTING 55 Co Ill: Totol Comll1lufon Aellon: o Approved o Approvcd w/conditions D O!!nied D Continued to: Ullr Depl: Current Fiscal Yr. Ci Advorti.ed: Date: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Raqui red A IIBelad Parlin Cf.l Notified o Not Requi red funding Suurce; o Cap I tal Imp. D Oparat in!! o Other Allachmonu: APPLI CA TI ON VARIANCE ~ORKSHEET HAPS o Nono S ubrn IItld by: Al11lloprlalfon Code: - , ~;I prlntod on rocycl!!d pilpcr SV 93-62 Page 2 Staff Comments}Proposed Conditions: Sunshine Mall is located on approximately 40 acres of land.'. According to the application, the Mall has the capacity to house 86 businesses. Because the property is located in the Commercial Center zoning district, the Mall is allowed a 150 square foot freestanding sign, the largest freestanding sign size allowed in the City. According to the sign diagram accompanying the application, the steel beams that support the existing sign are proposed to be used to support the new sign. The diagram shows the beams separated by ten feet. In effect, this sets the sign width at ten feet. Giyen the ten foot width, in order to take advantage of the 150 square foot size entitlement, the sign must measure fifteen feet vertically. If the twenty foot height limit were to be strictly observed, the sign would stand clear of the ground by only five feet. City staff contends that it would be out 'of scale to place a sign of this size with only five feet of clearance over grade. It is staff's position that the nine feet of clearance proposed is more appropriate for this ten foot horizontal, fifteen foot vertical sign. , Nine feet of clearance would improve sight visibility for vehicular traffic as well. I I , ,I I SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing land Uses North South East West Multiple Family Residential, Restaurant/Bar Restaurant/Commercial Fast Food Restaurants, Searstown Shopping Center Office/Residential Because the Sunshine Mall property is approximately 40 acres in size with almost 2,000 feet of frontage along Missouri Ave., the additional four feet of sign height will be in scale with the Sunshine Mall property, and will not adversely affect other properties in the area. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all oight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that the petitioner's request meets all of the standards. In particular, the following standards do appear to be fully met: (1 ) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in' an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. ' j' .' SV 93-62 Page 3 , (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2t! for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return from the property. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) The granting of the variance wil/ not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. ~ Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: FREESTANDING SIGN HEIGHT CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 91-02 25191 U.S. 19 Dimmitt Cadillac 16.5 ft. add'l to allow 3/21/91 36.5 ft./Denied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. 19 Village at 12.3 ft. add'l to allow 1/2/92 Countryside 36.3 ft./Denied SV 92-03 2301 Sunset Point Great Western 6 ft. add'l to allow 12 1/16/92 Rd. Bank ft./ Approved SV 92~28 1290, 92, 94 Stewart Title 2 ft. add" to allow 10 12/17/92 Court St. ft./Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S. 19 Public Storage 15,1 ft. add'l to allow 3/25/93 35.1 ft./Approved SV 92-05 20162 U.S. 19 Suncoast Inn 1 ft. add'l to allow 25 517/92 ft./Denied t:, STAFF ANDlNOS VARIANCE WORKSHEET - CASE NUMBER SV 93-62 STANDARDs FOR VARIANCE APmOVAL III The variance requeued arlllll horn a condition which II unIque to the proparty 'n queatlon and I. nalther ordInarily or unllormlv appllcablo to tho 'lonlng d~tllct nor crftatlld by en 1I0tlon or actlonl of the property owner. predacallor In tllllI, or the eppllcent. Any mlltake mede In the uecutlon of II buildIng permit or work performed without the benefll of a permit .hllll not be con.ldered to be .lIuellons which luppon the glllntlng of a vallance. 121 Thll p~rtJcular phy.lcellurroundlngl, Ihape or tOPQgHlphllal conditIon. ot the property Involved end tht!l Itrlct IIppllclltlon of the prolll.lon. of thll dallelopment code would rlllurt In IIn unneeenary herdlhlp upon the appHcent. 131 The lIarlence I. the minimum necenllry to ollercomll thll unnecenary htud.hlp tefeued to In preceding recltlll ~Z~ tOl the purpo", of meklng ,ellloneble Ulll of the land. 141 The requell for e IIllrhlnce I. not billed primarily upon the dulre of the llppllcent to ncure e greater flnenclal return tor the property. 161 The grllntlng of thll lIerlance will not be materially detrlmentel or InJurloul to other property or Improvementl In the neighborhood In whIch the property Is located. 101 The grentlng of the variance will not Impelr en lldequete .upply 0111gM or ventlllltlon to adjacent property. detrllct trom thllllppellrence of the community. lubltllnthllly Increllte the congeltlon In the publfo .treet.. Increllle the danger of fire, Ilndanger the public safety In any WilY, or 'Ub.tantlally dimInish or Impair the lIelue of .urroundlng property. 17J The vllrlllnce dellred wUl not advellely nffect the publlo heelth, IIlfety, ordllr, convenience, Dr genllrlll welfare of the community. IBI Thll granting of tho \/Illle.nce dllllled ~m not \/Iolft\e the generel.plrlt end Intent of thl. development code. , . The Ilppllcant detlrlll tel ule 1hllul.tlng .tllel beeml to .uppon the new .1gn, The bum. ere Illperllted by ten feet, Thl.. In eUect, Umlt. thll width of the new sign to ten tllllt, It the applicant II to utl1Jle the 160' .quare feet of "rllll ellowable, the .Ign mUlt mea.ure 16 fllot vertlcelly, Con.equently, II mulmum height of 20 feet would CIlUIII the lIlgn to be po.ltloned only five feet over grede. It I. CllV IteU'. po.ltlon that the addItional tour tee1 01 heIght, which In turn would enllble the .Ign to be placed nIne tllet over grade, would caulII more epproprle1e Ipetlal relatlonlhlpl. To '1rlctly epply 1he height requirement to thl. .Ign would CIlUlll the plllcemllnt of 1I .Ign with generelly undll.lteble spatlel rele'lonlhlp.. A nine foot cleerance over grllde I. mlnlmel for e ,Ign of Ihl. ,1111. It eppallll that the varlllnce I. reque.ted primarily for the, purpo.e of allowing tha ulstlng .teel bllllml to be reu.ed for the new .Ign, The SunshIne Mall property II llpproxlmetely 40 acrlllln .Ize wl1l1elmost 2,000 feet of hontage en Mlnourl Ave. Tho addItional four feet of height will be In .cele with thll property. . Due to the ,1111 of the property end de.lgn of the Ilgn, 1he verlllnce reque.t IIltl.flIII1h!. condl.lon. Becllu.e the .lgn wl1J be In ,cllle with the properly, the public hllelth. 'lIfety, and weltere will not be edvllrsely Ilffected. The .Ign adhern to good delllgn .t'lndl!lrdl, thereby meeting thll .plrlt lInd Intent of the delll!llopmllnt code, , , " " , . _ neceint /I 418~ ~ '0-0 7/1/"'1 ~ , PROPERTY OWNER{S) NAME & AOD.R~SS: CITY OF ClEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPLlCATlON SVII q:; - ,Co..:t REPRESENTATIVE(S} HI bUY) NAME & ADDRESS: " . Paul Strecker-: . .. c/o Fusco Ma~~~~m@n~'~nmpnny # 9 Sunsh loe 1-1a 11 Clearwater"FL 34616 Kay Vega Fusco Management Company #9 Sunshine Mall' Clearwater, FL 34616 TELEPHONE: ( 81 3) 44 1- 2 8 45 TELEPHONE: (at3) tl tll- 2 0 tl5 L I .' ,~ .' , 1200 South Missouri Ave. 'Sunshlne Mall ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPLICABLE): , ZONING DISTRICT: ',. CC ',LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: C'l'P,. LAND AREA: 40. 36 1\C LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: See Attached PARCEL NUMBER: ,22 / 29 I 15' / 00000 1 _21 0 1 0 100 lThis information' is available from your tax receIpt or contact Plnellas Co. Proporty Apprllisor's Offlco lit 462.3207. If more than one parcel number, attach 8% x 11 inch sheet) , DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: South: Commercial Commercial Enst: Wost: Commcrclal Rcsidontial & Professional VARIANCE{S) REQUEST:, '1\ v~r1ance 6f.1 feet to allo~ a 24 foot hi~h freestanding siqn. REAS~N FOR REQUESTING VARIANCE(S): !Refer to SuxuJul'ds for Approval. next puge) Sunshine Mall' was built in 1967 a9 the EirRt 8n~losed ~nll' in the , . 'c i ty and, th~.uriJ:..y_. Rec.cllLr:lHlnlJQfLi1LQJ..l~QlJ1.l.!illJ1 i ty have impacted Oil r success. We reqw;.sJ:-':.hL~_.'liltiillJ~~~tha s i q n code t6 ,he Ip improve the readibility of th~adcr board section. ~. mall of our size wi th a potentia 1 fo.L,.o~ids inQ1L9cs needs as much cons ideration as possible'. , Q~\l: si.C1jLI~tl_tlJQ 5. toot rn!.nimulIl setback requirement and' will be redesigned as a t~~~-f~~O square root sign. COtl1lNUr;o ON IIEVl:nr.r: SlOt: " STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance sholl ,not be granted by the City Commission unless the application and evidenco prosontod CloDrlV support tho following conclusions: ' , (11 Tho vorlancc roquested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordlnorllv or uniformly applicable to th!'l zoning district nor created by an action or nctions of the property owner, predecessor In title, or tho applicant. Any mistake mode in the execution of e bUilding permit or work porformad without 1he benefit of a permit sholl not be considered to be situations which support the granting 0' n variance. (21 The partiCUlar physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict appllcDtI~~ of the provisions of this developrnent code would rosult in on. unnecessary hardship upon the appllcnnt'. ' (3) The varinnca Is the minimum nocessary to overcome the unnecessnry herdship referred to in precoding rocital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a vnrlance is not based primnrily upon the desire of the applicnnt to secure 0 greater financial return from tho property, (5) Tho grnnting of the vnriance will not be materinlly detrimentnl or injurious to othor property or irnprovements In the neighborhood In which the property is located, ! I I ,[ I I (6) Tho granting of the vnriance will not impair nn ndequnte supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community. substentially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase tho dnngor of firo, endanger tho public safety in any 'way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public hoalth, snfety, order convenience, or general welfnre of the community. ' , , (8), Tho grontlng of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit ond intent of this development code. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): ~~4~ Subscribed and sworn to (or effirmed) before me this ~ day of JulV , A.D. 19 93 'by K~ Vega . l'ifiir1tT.,n"Tiiffilurt. po.,l1Dn .nll IUI m. 0' CfJlnp.n Y II .pp~rc;;ljl"" , who is personally known 'to me and/or has produced , ITyp. of Id.ntifi_tion} as identification, STATE OF. FLORIDA, COUNTY OF pinellas d~?,1dl/l^1 q'/~fL~7(..~t.'Notary Public, Commission No. CC262625 ~~. lS.fI~f~.V J; 7 , SANDRA I. SZCZEPKOWSKl ' '?\-MV'OOMMISSIOtlHG~526'EXPl~511ne of Notary typed. printed or stamped) ",,1, FabNiIY 10, 1!)91 , ' . JOIIl)(D T1fl1J tROY ,,lJN lIISlJIWlCf,Irt:. , , " " ! <; t. . ' IV ~ll~kU f'.02 " , , ' AFF'DAVIT I, Paul'Sl;.I:&cklu' (hiiJw. ,.tuJrI.,J" ",j;}";;:i;;;;o7Ccii;;;;:;i,'r ;/ (}ppl:Cub/~1 , as owner of tho property described as, _!ll!n~h toe ~\d 11 '" du hlJruby uuthorlzo 'K,~ Ve9a~ , '11...... at "",..tfI...i../ ~ to appear before the: " ' ,---, L-J OuvulCJpmont CClde' AdJuStlllent Board (Varlancel "-I 1--.1 " , Pltumlng & Zonh'G OOQrd (Conditional Use) r-::-t LX...J ' City CommIssion (/\lcoholic Beverage Oisumcu Variance, Sign'Variances) . 1 to rt\qufJ~t opproval 01 ---9_ I'; i(ln 'Jar iance /} .u..~~A? \$~c'~P - .:;G~,? '~/#~~~'t.; :; ~nd". ., 1\0,.... M.~'"" ",,,,,,..i. I/ncLJmV ,....ili"" ."" lI.m. ~I ~am.Hllr ,f .ppr,.,,,,,,, .' . /. . w /~' / . .... -AY--~ ~.,1'..:!/~r.r . ~. I " ' . , 1h -.J I i - Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) bufore mc lhis ~ day {)f , d V ' , A,D. 19 S hy ftt,d &, ST nE..(..)((.r.i..II:(c'fres'~X~,'J ~.[. Fl'Ui.!LJ\\r{1'1Cd '1;&:~WhO Is pers.:mal1y ",,,/ N~"''' (In{'.J,ld. PQ'~' o!nd 'Ntm~ ",1 ,omp,),,'I' if applicablel . , , 'known to n1o. un%r hus produced ~..LL"\ ~ e..I: l~ I: <. r n.J C. , , (Type of i,[,mfification/ , (> 1I1\(:<l'(.,lT t STATE OF fL"t)I'\IDA, COUNTY OF It~lU III Vr., ~s Idcntific&tlQn. , )J}f.l ( ~~~lLtl)' '~JI~, , (j I S{;L""".1 ' , ~rll.1~LwJfIJ II) ~'(, {' NCltary Public, Currllnlss[on'NO":"'l:x.I.I; r-c S ' g/?I Ie; J' , . . , -r . ~. . L INamtJ 01 NattilY typed. ,prihttld or stamped) , , .,u~,..c. , ' " , , , ~ ~, , , , ; , . . ; , , , I J ' . , , ,/0 .. '.' , J. - ~ ~ " ' ~ I' " , , ' . ~. . " , , , " '~ "~ :',' :,P .,~ ,\i)~ ~~' '9 ' ':", ~ ~~ "~~ ", ' , ~~ / \j ~() ~V) , "-_. , !tj~ '~~ ' ' . >-. ~~ \S S~~ ~~~, W~ ,~ ~~~, ~&~' ~' "~~ ~~k:' ~.,~.. , ' , ' . ~~~ \1 ~ ' ~ '-J ~.. ~~'~' ~~ , 1 ~. ~~~ ~~~ '~~ ~ ,~ ~, ,~R,~ ~~ ' ~~ ~\ ,~\S' ~ ~ ~ ( \ I , I ' d I )~ ! i"::: ,\ I ....... I ~ ~u ! ~ ~I I (l ~, '~ ~ I ,~;, , \.l, - ---.- ~' 'j' I , l I' ~' ~ , ~ '" ',~~ I' . , ~, .. ... \ ~I " I , 1:-" I ' I , I "'lJ" " 'l. . , ~, - , , UU R ~? . ,~ i~ , ;:JJI .I e>; q . .I c:::' i Lt. " . . " c::/j 6 ..........~______.____________ ..__....____.... 'l__~.. . , , ' I , , ,I' '\' " , \, . . ~ t, /-.: :.,f' ", , ; .r . ~ . ,~: '~ ' I, ,,,( ',' " .~. \ 'I ;~ , .' ; , , " (,: , , ~; '. ! , \" ' . l ~ . . ; ";,,~. , " Jl . ~ . , ~ < J \ ; ~ .: , ' .' t ~ L k.' .,';' \' ;,:,,:, . .' 1 ~,),r':::Ce ;;::,:"'-:; ;,~"", '{',- ; :i.;, ; l ( ..' :} . <: ) ~ .0" f.... . ~ ~ . . ;'. .j ~ .' ~ .'~"" (!.' . Ao L;~;,;i!!;,:: j ~,,~/;:: ,J: :;;,:,/;; ~. I T , ' '.' \, ,". :..'. , J , , '. \" '. ;.: , . ~. : ~.l ' " ' ~ : ... 'j} , t ., ~ 'r' " 1.' . " i '" " '. .. ';. " .'1 '.. :.. ~ ~ ., ! . ; ~'.' , " ," .;:. -' . >~. ~ :., I," . '. {'\,." ~" ~~.' (~'.'. .~> , I ' ' , ~ , ,~" j .' .' ,i", I ~ I . . < ~ . ~. '1 J. q. .'. e I; ! ," " 1 ' " , '\' .,~ I I I,:/r t'T" -1.1; ~ " .j.. " ,(, i;, .>' " I ",r . ',,!, ',",:",,',,', " " '" ' . . !~:.~.<\.r.~Hq., ;,1 '<." '..;:Lt.. _, .:" < " " ',,' "\, , .' ~ ,,~~.' j' ~ ~' .:'~... i . .l'~'l; } _I' /. . (~ 'j ,.~~O.:/:P. ,,:~J; .\ '. )-t. ~ {': I ...~ i.~~ , r . L j ~ . ~ f' :,' ...r., .., . . " t~. '. .. ":': , .. .~ ,',- ~ : ~. :,1,' ". I, I, " " ' " ' 'I !! '! " p. , " " , , , ,c. . \-" . './ ,,' .'141' . It/' r " \ , , " , , " t' 10.' .. .' ., , J' , ~ .,' " : ! " ,l '; . . '.'. ',"i ','" . .. " , l' P; ... ...: ,'. . ( ~' " " j, f. l . ; " " ~;::'" ~ ~ ~ .0 . l . ..~. ~ L J,~. I ~ ..,... . ~. ~.; - I,' ':';' ,'e: ,',' ',' ~ c; '..' 1 1.... '.. }~ . ~. t. I 1,,;'::':';'., . i.. l" ," " oj, / , , " ,)e' , e " " :. :' .. '.' '" ," " , "." , \. . ~; '. .~:. j, . I '~ , ~~ ., , ".' ", r:l., '\"'\'. .,' ,j T;" " 'I: e, ' ,e, " " '. .~.l- .' . ". ~ I,; ,.~ " I'. '" " '.1- 'J". ~~ ) .~. . . ~., '. ,;.:}+ . , " \ I . ' 1 ~ <'.t" , e .,.'." :, , ' , , .. ',' ,. , \, " ,; 1 " " , '~ : ~ '. , i I' L .~ . !'..... " " i .l " ,,\ ,', ,. b.. C '. , ' ",I' , \' ',,'f !. , . .. ~: ~ '" j' ". ~ . . I' ., \ ~ .... I , 1 , \ " . 'l ,'I ", .1' l .11t ',. ,r" ,~: '~-I ! ~ 1.',' ,e I, '; ~~: " I ~ c , , \ ~. . ':.'.. ':;', J el' .; . .. ", '.' '''," " 'c J" , ' ,,' ,\ .' . ~., . \:' .' ,. ,.' c, I ; .,;!' .:t ", ,', , ~' ~> " " .~ i " . , ". ' '"I" e.'," . , '<'/ t' : '.j . "T \, ' " " " ,', I ": \., , " , , fl' c. "," ~. '. . . ~ t a ,] " , ~ ..... , 'f ," ~ . ~ , .. , " ',I '., , . >'t ,"t' , ' , , :,1 ~ :. e" :. ,', '.' I , ,,' '. '., " e.' \' " , ; ./ ' , , . ~~. . ;, " ; " j~,. ~", ! '. . ~ ( . ~i c' " , ~t' :.~::,~='-~-=- :'---~""~~-11' ~ " , . ~ l . t . , , . , . I ~ . . ' '.l ',' ' I "=-..:J:r~ -~.~.:..'"~.=~"'~" ~..'~:~~,",..,._v.~,l ,- ~ "', " " " ,j' ',l .' ~ '" I' L ~ , ' , " ",',. , ' <=~.-;p)~..~?e~q~___ : ' : !SCALe ~.(..-,:,(,!:?" . '. .' ~> . '~ ' ; ~/ . , ., ,', . , . ~: i ~ I, A ,__. ,,;-. :..~ " " " ~ . .', I , " ;~;~ ' \.". , e, ' " ~.. L" ", ~' ~l~ " ":: ' \ ,J i ~.' .' t.', '., " . i . ~\ . I ", '." I. ',' ,.' , I .... " , , '. 'I.. '1'1 >, ;. i, " " ,I 'l '; , I. '.'" ',( ',' ~ . \," \,: '! :, .Lc " ',I ,I , ...,' I, , . '\ I" l' ~ ' ,'e " I, I, i': ' }..r ,:t " '" I"~ , , .' '.-F. 'I I, , ' , ; I, ! ' I ' ,. . . " , ,i " , .. , , ,. --. ,- - .... . IIl1l1i;~ 0111I1111I0"" ..~. ...., ~ii ~I i HUl ~fHHIHWH. ~ _\ ~~I '51 , '& mHH~IM ~ JJ~: ~i , U;MIH lion '. ~ e' . ',' j' ;~;;~:;::~;j !; ~ / r aflH/fHHHHfHHHJfH ~ I ' .....;'-" 'Jt.iHtI ~) , . ,~mHf!HItHftmHfU I; ,;:;/ j' p~ I I ~ ..~ '/ ~ l: " ,1 multi "flH.~~li~t~ /' '/ i. ~ ::1_ ~ . ',- . ~ g / =E:-:i ~ . _,r;n:;;TfT~ ~' ' ,.--, /' ::::- .:::, '!rf~~ ,..,,] ~~: J '};f;mHfHttl'~.~;iH /' . ; :J~ ~ .. W., ! ~'- ,I lNmH,IHltftr;~~Hi~~ 3/:' ':0 It:~:":' -. '. .. . -. .. == :i? -h I . ,I J J; , 'lr~ f~ ,:t H~ ~~ , . - ~ ' ."; ~ r~ ! 1.tllil..~:t,xf; ....i~.!..1 I ;o~ '::;F' ..'3, ;J '~"" '!. r; ;_'i.) II 'd'" =1 U:.l'.,r~::."., ::.t~!i 'T]'t==i\ g '-l-J!l. j' I . r~~-:-:'":'",-- ~t,. I 1\ "'1;;11.1,+ :l ,1 .Iw.. ~ ~t -~.~... .: , ' i /',.. -, " " t. ., /, S -I ,'..".. ....... ..........., ..; i .,,[. -=. - ;11!'riirjlli;""'~~,~.",J' ~: '/ ,'.' ,. . . J -'"'=fQh_.- r..nt.,'...."" ; ~ I <C!:'~I 41:h..-~.:.....-.,..i?'..;:~: 1; .~~..,a. 'I" ~:' . c~ ~_....._-'-'3! llei t::! ' ' . ~ '-__. 1 8 ~. ~,-,~,~~..,"!1; -;:Il liimrrnr,TT1fiT!,iJ;rlt'il I! 1 13: ~,r-:I ..-'.....,..-..............'.ii11', z' . . ~'~ -...... .. ._.n........ ...- -'! !MlWllIllfHH,;:iifN ! f ' ), ,.......I.t;f......,...'t':. . . " -..,.................-,.I....~'!' " ,JmflfitHHHjrr~I,~~.~ ~ i ~. L -- .n,,.. """-iff, ,,: ~ ~'0 HfI"iII O!II I'-j &rIllmmlllllffiH ~ ii' . r ' : : .:!.., ~I ~1;;'~;H~::,!f~ fRlHII lit I I LHU, t ~ · i, :;1 'il,...."...."' : ;", ,-':C; i~'~;. ~;:~.,,~~:I~~", 113i..:. . .l:l..!.:..~.~ ~ _ .' E ' ~......_~ 'F~T_-:._~"",.j '\ "'Otll: . Ii........ \1 1 . ,. '. ~. tr. ,. I 'I : ' ; ~'J,;.I;~. '}H...........,:. II ~' ~" J I : " ... ~ I; ~J '.t '. I J I '}l""'I'~ x; I ~ : ;: riU . i I,h ;,~,,,:,' ([J' n.~;:: i ij :,1 t I ~";"I;" ~ ~. ~d -. , . . I ,'/ ..' . ,1 'I ~ I .n;..,..., rH....;.......... J' . ~..,. . L " " r.J -- - -11"7":',-;-:".~"\- - -.... _ ~I '~~~i , ) u u '5 ~ ... > ... ,- . c' .. '. , '. , , , l..J . u' ~( 0... VI .. , ., " o .., " , ...."--- '- -, I ~ ...-...... . \,' ~ Q: -( a. I -J .c U , n :,l. ~ It " , ' L ..-.--_-~-_....-.. ..., . -"--. - V ARJANCE REQUEST: SIGNS NAME: Fuse,., l1CitJ:lT. /SunSI-l "10'" /V\A II / V,;-6. A , (, , SV-#,'3=S-(d...PUBLIC HEARING DATE: A'TLAS PAGE:2clfo~~,_SEC: IS TWP:2.cl S. RGE: 1 S- E. ~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION ~ cc "'l ~ \! '~'.,., - ..tim w .' . 'I U ill .... .- ~ -- IS i 11 ,I: ~!..:1OE ! Cil .. ~ ~~~l, .PL= .." )1f:-- _ ;' - ~: ""2- ......... ~- H ' ., : - & ....-;;;, ~; : :.. ; ",:; ,"; i R M 2 8 - ~ ~ r-;;;L -riif.1~ ~[ '~=~:~ _u__. ::IB"- .. .. -~\- _u =.11_ n' U )'/01 ' ~ 11 ~ ... ., )0 a\ ~:t1ilii % cc -l ..J <I: ::s ,,,,. -.J , cc w ~ 21/01 X VI Z ::J VI: 1--- I":@- ", I UJ' s.o i i.. r 11>-t.6 21/05 : ~~....~,..~,......",..o,; .~ , - , ;; 5 't\..~J' P/S"ra . 6 ! .\:'tn -. 1 un' II E?/:l.llf A I S?. r::: l.E....', ~ !- 9 1~1. '. . I. >0 !', . 1- "j ... . i ~ ; !. to 'J ~ ~ 1,\. '.G , I . ' ,... I I i "5- Ii' '. ~ ' ,,6 ~ In_r II q MI II .. 1(1.: -,. i ~ f t'J ...~''') .oI;l',jt~ 'lu' ~ '~." . I -', t . I 1\ I:' I 1~ II ,!I ,~"'" t. t ,.!.i,l I' I , ---L TilE .,," 11 ..",I... I t 1- .:f1, 1- M f r . P"~T t 11. ".. IC,(. '1/1< r;;- ...~ !.: tt) o '1/15 .. :::; .:~~~- .:'f~r.';.. . ,_ _-. .~r:__ C<3 ~l~ l~ . I I I I , 'll^,! I I I I f:ll n:lJ oH ,"'/ I 0 I I I I , \ . .....- ~ "lJ > ~, In >, ... m , (> .. . ... .... :) l~ " .,j trl r-: "<1 ~ .., -I '.. ... =' c. o.. :. Q ~ .,:i " lie>- .. ... 17, 'J Q . :If,,! "'1'll1 t- o. '" o.. ~ .., n: ;Jo o. - .. ::s u o I:) .., ... M .., l"': In . PI! ll:J:I:I:I t:I .- "" o 1- _ - .. -1 I I I a: ~; . ',' ~ '-- ./ Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item # Meeting Dote: (1. 112iJ1~ SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 20788 U.S. 19 N.; Corson/Howard Johnson (Owner/Applicant); Richard Grist (Representative). (SV 93-64) RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: Deny variances to permit nonconforming signage to remain on property identified as Sec. 18-29-16, M & B 14-121 and 14-12 for failure'to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(B). o and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to permit two nonconforming freestanding signs ,to remain: (1) a variance of 430.5 square feet to allow a freestanding sign of 542.5 square feet, (2) a variance of 28 feet in height to allow a freestanding sign of 48.5 feet in height, (3) a variance of one message panel to allow three message panels, (4) a variance of 4 feet in height to allow a freestanding,sign of 24 feet in height"and (5) a variance of 15.26 square feet to allow a freestanding sign of 127.26 square feet. The subject property is located at the northwest corner of Gulf to Bay Blvd. an'd U.S. Hwy. 19 and is , in the Highway Commercial zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. Ravlllwad bV: legal Budget' Purchasing Risk, Mgmt. CIS ACH Other N/A IVA ilIA ilIA ~ IlIA Orlginlltlno Dlpl: CENTRAL PE MITT1NG ~ CuI.: Total, CGmmlulGn Action: o Approved o Approved w/condltions o Denied o Continued to: UIOf Dalll: Current fiscal Yr. ,i\" ) Advlrlbld: Date: PDp~r; TAMPA TRlnU~~ o Ilot Requi red A If,clld Pll r Ilea ti] Notified o !lot Rl:q\Ji rl:d funding SGU/ce: , o Copl tol I~. o operating o Other Allachmlnll: APPllCATIOfI VARIANCE IIORKSIlEET HAPS o None , SU~n1IIl,d bV: C Apll/oprrallGn CGde: .-. ld ~w Printed on reeyc c paper " SV 93-64 Page 2 Sign .1 I Sign 2 Information Existing Permitted Type of Sign Freestanding Yes Location/orientation of sign U.S. Hwy. 19 Yes Area 542.5 sq. ft. 112 sq. ft. Setback Height ' 16 ft. 48 ft., 6 in. 5 ft. 30 ft., 6 in. (10ft. above overpass) 2 panels Existing Permitted Freestanding Yes Gulf to Bay Yes 127.26 sq. 11 2 sq. ft. ft. 5 ft. 5 ft. .?. 4 ft. 20 ft, Number of message panels 3 panels 2 panels 2 panels Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: The applicant has not provided any evidence that these variance requests arise from any conditions unique to this property which are not already accounted for in the sign regulations. The existence of the U.S. Hwy. 19 overpass to the east of this property is unique, but the sign regulations recognize and account for this circumstance. Specifically, the regulations allow a sign height of ten feet above the crown of the roadway. [See Sec. 44.54{2)). In addition, the applicant offers no evidence of any unique conditions or hardship that would give rise to granting variances for the sign size or the number of message panels. , These variance requests are extreme and cannot be considered minimal requests. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing land Uses North South East West Restaurant/Hotel Sam's Club Restaurant/Storage Office Bldg. The existence of these oversized signs is not in character with the signage permitted for the surrounding commercial areas and diverts attention from those land uses. The granting of this variance will detract from tho surrounding businesses that have conforming signage as well as negatively affect the overall appearance of the community. ,,' SV 93-64 ,Page 3 Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the Information contained in the application, staff finds that the . petitioner's request meets none of the.standards. In particular, the following standards do not appear to be fully met:' ' , (1 ) (2) (3) (4) (5) , (6) (7)' (8) , , The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in titlet or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. , The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in' preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonabl~ use of the land. ' The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a ' greater financial return from the property, ' The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply' of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appea'rance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. " SV 93-64 Page 4 Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission: FREESTANDING SIGN AREA CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION DATE SV 91-02 25191 U.S. 19 Dimmitt Cadillac 12.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 3/21191 129.3 sq. ft./Denied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. 19 Village at '24 sq. ft. add'] to allow 280 , /2/92 Countryside sq. ft./Denied SV 92-03 2301 Sunset Great Western 42.3 sq. ft. add'l to allow 1/16/92 Point Rd. Bank 66.3 sq. ft./Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S. 19 Public Storage 32 sq. ft. add'l to allow 144 3/25/93 sq. ft./Denied SV 92-05 20162 U.S. 19 Suncoast Inn 38 sq. ft. add'l to allow 150 517/92 sq. ft./Approved SV 93-06 1621-1627 Connell's Plaza 144 sq. ft. add'l to allow 208 9/28/93 Gulf to Bay sq. ft./Denied Blvd. SV 92-40 1528 lakeview Orthopaedic 32.4 sq. ft. add'l to allow 9/28/93 Rd. Surgery Center of 56.4 sq. ft./Approved ' Clearwater SV 92-41 26508 U.S. 19 Ramada Inn 55 sq. ft. add'/ to allow 105 9/28/93 SQ. ft./ Approved SV 92-46 1824 N. Ft. Clearwater Bay 30 sq. ft. add'l to allow 80 9/28/93 Harrison Motel sq. ft./Approved FREESTANDING SIGN HEIGHT CAS E # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ ACTION DATE SV 91 ~02 25191 U.S. 19 Dimmitt Cadillac 16.5 ft. add'l to allow 3/21/91 36.5 ft./Denied SV 92-02 26210 U.S. 19 Village at 12.3 ft. add'l to allow 1/2/92 Countryside 36.3 ft./Denied SV 92-03 2301 Sunset Point Great Western 6 ft. add'l to allow 12 1116/92 Rd. Bank ft./Approved SV 92-28 1290, 92, 94 Court Stewart Title 2 ft. add'\ to allow 10 1 2/1 7/92 St. ft. /Denied SV 92-87 20865 U.S. 19 Public Storage 15.1 ft. add'l to allow 3/25/93 35.1 ft./Approved SV 92-05 20162 U.S. 19 Suncoast Inn 1 ft. add'l to allow 25 517/92 ft./Denied , , V ARIANCEWORKSHEET CASE NUMBER SV 93-64 STANDARDS FOR VARIANCE APPROVAL STAFF ANDCNQB 111 The verlenc:e ,equelted arl~e~ from a oondltlon which I~ Thera Is no oondlllon unique to thl. properlV thet I~ not unlqua to the property In qUeltlon and I~ nelth.r ordll18rUy or elready accounted for In the .Ign ragullltlon~. An overpau unIformly appllcebla to the lonlng dl~tllct nOI cIuted by an tllI.l~ts to the eut, but the .Ign rellullll\lon. allow for addltlon/ll IIc:tlon or IIctlon. of the property owner. pledeclluor In title. height In order for the .Ign to be nen horn the overpau, or the appllcllnt. Any mlttake made In the llIlecutlon of Il building permit or work performed without the benefit of a plllmlt shalt not be con.ldllrad to be ~Ituatlons which .upport the gran ling of lll/artehl:ll. 121 The particular phv_lcel surrounding., thapll or The .urroundlng~ end condition of the property dOel not topogrllphlcel condlllont of thll propllrty Involved and the , CIIUtD a hard.hlp. .trlctappllcatlon of the provl.lon. of thl. dovelopment coda would rnult In an unneeeuary hlud~hlp upon the apptlcent. ., 131 Tha variance I~ the mInimum nllcllnllry to overcome the The varlanclI I. not minimal becDuse there llIll.ts no hllrd.hlp. unneceuary hard.hlp raferrad to In preceding racltlll P2" for Thll vllrlllnclll are not neclluarv to adaquetaly ldllntlly tha the purpose of makIng ree~onable uu of tha land, property. 141 The requnt for a verlllnca I~ not billed prlmllrlly upon the Tha grentlng 01 theu vatlanclll wilt give thl. propllrty graetar dlltlre of thaeppllcant to .ecurll II grntar f1nllnc:lal r!llturn for lIXpo.ure and a eompetltlvll edge over other property owner. the property. In the .1Ime lona. Thl. In turn wilt Cllu.e Il gruter financial retUrn from thlll property. 161 The grllntlng of thl. varlancll will not be matllrllllly The granting of the.a varlllnclll prolong' thll exl.tence of .Ign. detrlmentel or InJurlou. to other propllrty or Improvement. In that are out of .calll with the elllstlng development In the the neighborhood In which the property l~ 10oll1ed. IIrea, 101 Thll granting of the varIance will not Impelr nn adllquate The existing aVllr.IZlld .Ign. detrllct from the IIppellranc:e of .upply of light or ventlllltlon to ad/llcent property, detrllct the community. from the IIppllllrllnee of the community, .ub.tnntllltly IncrellSll the congutlon In thll publlo .trellt..lnereau the dllngllr of fire. endllnger the publlo .lIfety In IIny WilY, or sub.tllntlelly dlmlnl.h or Impair the value of .urroundlng property. 17! The variance dulred will not /ldverulV aHllet the public The orllntlng of thau varlllncu will perplltuate the exl~tence henlth, .nfety. order. conl/enlence. or genernl welfare of the IIf ovalllzad .10n., therebv dl~ruptlng 'he orderllneas of 'he community. City'. IIlgn eompllance program, 1111 Thll grenllng ot the vllrlllnee dllllred will not vlol/lte' the The .Ign regulation. were ndopted with the Intllnt of gllnerlll .plrlt and Intent of thl. development code. enhancing the visual qUllllty of the City's st,feeta IInd Innd,cllpe In order to prolllot the value of propettlea end 'he wIIII.belng of the locnl 'ourl~to()rlented economy. The oranllng of thl. vllrlllnce appear. to be In vlollltlon of thl. Intent. " , , 1.1\ _Roceint #...5:..QSh:] ~~'Jq ~ 7''';-0 PROPERTY OWNERfS) NAME & ADDRESS: CITY OF CLEARWATER SIGN VARIANCE APPUCATION SV# q~ . --------c:a4. RF.PRESENTATIVEIS) (ir ooy) NAME & ADDRESS: tDll.To~ H. ~~.l:L-;:rlS. , .f;fib~_l:i~~.nu.~~ ~\:-. \) ~&...__3"?? 70 I f('C.~An.b &""ST Qghl.LN5.\.U.8_2__S1nbl_CQ_~ j \~CO \ 41\*'. ~n:..q..\- ~.d:b. a~~_a_'2L4:kA.a I TElEPI-IONE:~....,l;,,~:t.2..:' II r I TEl.EPHONE:-!6J.~) %3...3. - 3,0 ":?- c... ::1.0"1 '=t;"l( ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: \4 ~~~N~(;)oN , ~U~I..)~~ NOCl;TI.l. c..LE~~ NAME OF BUSINESS ifF APPLICABLE): H.o\,.;)~ ":S'O\4NSOi'J ZONING DISTRICT: Cl-\- LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: C,<= LAND AREA: Lr:GAl DE~CRlPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: p~q,,_c;..~ G::Nu..oS ~~L~~~~.._-.ON_~~_Le..r.:t~_ \'0 '1..q (;:, - 00000 - \40 - 1'1.,.0 PARCel NUMBER: \ ~ - / ~ 9 + \ b -t ..o9(j 0 c I ,l+o +.l'l.'tl ~_ (This information is nvnileble from your tax receipt or contnct Pinellas Co. Property Apprniser's Officc at 462-3207. If morc than one parcel number, nttach 8Ya x 11 inch sheot) DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: Qt;;s.TAV~tJ"r \ \...l,Q"T€L . South: fY\~~lH.B~~~ I East: Hc:::r"l:'~L ~ STo(lJ$".,.\:,- West:~T~ 'Pt::::"Tl;? "M~(. "!A.MPA -rRJ60N{; VARIANCEIS) REQUEST: ~.:.l:Y Pot-~ Slbr--J s;lN p~O~€~ \N ~(nc='~-r CJ::,.,""-O' ~"-! 0..... ~ I;) ~ Q. - 6 - 9 ~ - l ~ "'::.\....(,'\"" ~:~~',:::; ~-:.~.~.~~;+ '" ,~ ,~ ' ~~~\ ., G-J U/'r'Yt-.: r.-.............c. ~ ~f=. Z.8. Co \' .......' "'e"sY'."i' "'\";U v2.e.~A': '" A AN~ ~~G 'fub~Au"E'- \ - ..s. ~ 1 ':' . J "::. 48 .~;:!:. r.:. S. "=- \ ~ 1..J 1lJi;g;~" CD \ ) A r < p.. v"\(' P Qf \ -.:.......~fl, N~<2. 1) VbI-161J(,.~~/tV f-rr. "'0 <?~.......e.c... '""0 vC."',A:'^-. "2.. V'0.CSSAc)12.. ~A-"""'~\s.. . AU-ow' A f;(E;:51AtVO}NY-'6-/~~o~ 2. iI/IV r/&It;.ett..DE REASON FOR REQUESTING VARIANCE(S): !Rcfcr to Stnndl)(ds for Approval, next page) ~~~le.)--Lf: \\-l!L-.--~LS."-1~~_\':: ON \,1,.1(; Pftt:)~lt--~E" Slc",N C!.N SW~E'r ~b::9..3. -':LS:.~EE:"T ~~. 14BS. (3.ol"Lr,..\-i..-r INTO~""F'll(lM.A.Nc...; " !:. SA I'T. ^A I-:I\T,-\ \-I !;.ll:l,~~ o~ ~SLt.r_...J.I.........-~_~""~_~5:l "(" e~ $1.tICtt...t- F'Qo""i. 11..lt= CVt=e........~$. ~.,..o . -'='~~I~~_.c.B~t;;:;:__~~U~~.s_(}A~~~ ""'n-(~_~I.J~.,'Q"-'\.l:-CW ~\;l.~!-NS:.~ ~6..'t_Wl:;lu.....-b_~O~!4-_1:I::!~.!.~._gc:;:~G.~lTl".... f"Q.()........ ~~_~~__~-n~r--~ ~ SOI,/'f....J _W 1'1' LL.Jl!E{]2'l.,,,,"I.',I~:_...:r_~~~_s.\.!:._~_() 'W___~ \J LL'U;l__~A':L..J)g,,~..:r\~_~~.1:!i :..LLStrL3,13-.A~"~"-8L~_, ,J~r.U:'f L~l.'l_1\l)'J"V')!.~.~l. _Tb ._Kk~U.l_.'A.1.:1..G.-_._,____,_________. <<:N ~J,...R!:._~..~____.__,PJ.1~'I$i_.~ .__ ~...._ _ CONTINUED ON flEVEfl!i( SIDr ..... " , I ,I " ~" '....~. STAl.&DARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance shall not be' granted by the City Commission unless the application omt evidence presented clearly support the following conclusions: (1) The variance requested arises from n condition which is unique to tho property in question ond is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicablo to tho zoning district nor created by on action or actions of ,the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake mode in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the bonefit of 0 permit sholl not he considerod to be situations which support the granting of I) variance. ' . (2) Thll particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this dovelopment code would result in on unnecessary hordship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is tho mirlimum necessary to overcome the unnccessory hordship referred to in pn:cedin9 recitnl ': 2" for the purpose of Illnkin9 roasonable use of tho land. (4) Tho request for Il variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicDnt to s ecur(s a greuter financial return from the propertY. . , (5) The granting of the vnrionce will not bo motoriolly 'detrimentel or injurious to'other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which tha property is locllted. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an odequ'ate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appeerance of the community, substantiallv increase the congestion in the public streets. increase the dongor of fire, endonger the public sofety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The voriance desired will not odversely affect the public health, safety, order convcnience, or gencrLl,l wclfnre of th~ community. 18) ,The granting of thc varionce desired will not violote the gcner II spirit and intcnt of this development code. ~c;!\l\ N~,^\..~C. <,;, G ..,;L- SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): , Cl SubscrI~ed ond sworn to (or nffirmedl beforc me this ~ day of #1 ' f.,(..y-, ,A.D. 19L.a- t! by lite;;"'?If'!) J GRls r ('P-eJ:1IN~uLA 12 .s/~IJ'(~..) ,who IS.-Qcrsonlllly rf,nf F".,n_ruu:luafl po..(,Qn .na 1'Uj1". 01 cOlnp.nv 11 "pprtc..lJ/eJ . known to me arid/or hDs produced - ' fTyp. 01 id.."lilj".tjuII/ os identification. STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF 'P/.(/ELI.,,'),'S. ---..~w':~. " l.~'i"'- '~rf[t-"" . . . . :,.~ J~.~j . "~~ ~.' -./1 Qt ,,p'- ..- .... jI..- " . , , " , "I j II Ii" . , , .' < i , ) " ' 1 , " ~. . I . , " '.1 'I ", " ~q " " '" , ~ . j i. ~ ~~,..;. '.' " 'o' ! , I, , I ~ ';" q ~ " , " , , .'" . . '. ~ i ~ . 1 l " L . ~ 1- . ., .. " ," , . . , ,.. , ., t, '. " . , , " " ,~ ADDENDUM,' A' , , ~ . I ~. '. I, SV # 93-64: MILTON CORSON/ ,PENINSULAR ~IG~, ;. " 'I' ,1) VARIANCE OF 430.5 SQ. FT'. ' , ALLOH-A FREES'l'ANDING SIGN ' , TO OF. " " 542.5 SQ. 'FT. 5) VARIANCE OF 15.26 SQ. FT. TO ALLO\'l A FREESTANDING SIGN OF' 127.26 SQ. FT. , , L " , i' ~ : ~~~3 -'7.S-0~t,!l-3ol ~ Q' ',' t::.I'P: r/J.JI98 .; SIGNATURE' " SWORN TO AND ,SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS 'jl?!b DAY OF _ Nol1e"7"8C/~ A .'D., 1993 BY RICHARD GRIST WHO HAS PRODUCED,' FL.1).eiJa'S U~, AS IDENTI FICAT'ION, PERSONALLY AP'PEARED, DEPOSED AND STATED THE I1ATTE~S AND, FACTS SET OUT HEREIN ARE TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF HIS KNO\'lLEDGE AND BELIEF , .. , ~ iL Jklw--.J ARY UBLIC I COMMISSION, NO.' ' . ~ ~ANET $, McMAHAN ':"~' :~~~;t~' :~~ ' \ . , 1\ ....0 n.aU C&1lr.uJ..,' 1":. .,. , , 'I~: ;' . + , ' I~: > l' \1> " , , , , ' , I . ' , '< '., , ' .. " " i, , , I' ,I " " " I . I 'I ,t ), " ' , , I.. . , , , , , \' , , " , " \ , " ' .. ,\ " : 1.. :.' I . I " .1 ,". I , ; , " r. ' , . , '. , \ . ' , , . , " ,', I. , , I ~ . , . , ' , ,', ~ : I ',,:, ',: t....' I..' x/ !~p~~i, ,( ,- . ~'>'.~,~ :1, ,....i , ' , , ,: " '. ; , , . \ " ! .; I .~ ..' , . ; I( . .' ! , I ' , , I ' ) I " : . { , I , AUTHORIZATION FOR VARIANCE REPRESENTATION BY ,PENINSuLAR SIGN COMPANY , .' ,I J. \. , . '. , ' I, Milton H.-Corsor!, ,Jr:. as Trustee. the owner of the prope'rty described by the follo~ing ta'x' parcel numbers: 18.29-16-00000-140-,1270 and 18~29~16-00000-140-1200, ,authorizes Peninsular Sign Company or its representatives 'to 'appiy for and ,process an ' Application for Variance to'the City of Clearwater in regard to signs located on the above parcels. . , , . tl1~~~:~ ~ .1, .. , I ~ .. " , > _ ' I .>- . ,., \"", ' .;, ~ '. . ~L. ! .: t: ,. :. ,~\Iton'H, corso~7 . .. :. ~ I, ' 'I' , I '. tt , ' " , " , ' '.. ::,.t......I... It . r' ~ . . . ~ . , ' I, _,,'IT, " ,Slale of Florida , Coul)ty of Pinellas, " " I ,TI;e for'egolng instrument' was acknow,ledged beFore ,me this 24th Day of June" ' 1993;'by Milton H. Corson, Jr., Trustee, who 1s personally known to me and who did not take 'an oath. .' , '. , , ' ., ~~ ' t1, , t iJp~L ~ ~ -it' &dL-- Christine-Anrte'- ach:? ,,' , 'Notary Public; IICC170899, , " . i .. , " NOTARV PUnt.le. 5Th -rn' OF Fto~m.\.~ ~ M\' COMMISSION EXI'IItES: Dee. 2', 1995. DONUJ':O ,'unu NOl'AnY I'VDLle t1tlIlERWRITElti,' I, , , ;.t :,. ',1 J \ ;: . L ; I'" .' , . , , . I, , . " +'.cl . j ;'. " " \ , ", " ".; ,. " I , > 1 ,,' I , '. , , ~ . ,I " ", I. , , T. . ~ .. 1.j 'j , , ' , , , , . I .'. '-;" . " ,,' ", ;) , ~ , , , .. " <, " , ' /' . '/ t , .. t I ~ . " ' ~ ~ENINSULAR SIG'N CO.~ . ' . .' . \, 1'0 1l0lC 2<10, f'IN~llA!l l'"nKI tL ~46M'O;>2D TO WHOM IT, MANY CONCErrN~r:rEnSOUnG (DtJI m,J07fi 1.[oo0167?J076 " ' , " rill( 101J) 5n,41l1r, I, the undersigned, authorize th~ following named person to purchase,sign permits for Peninsular Sign ,Company, Pinellas parr., E',lorida fro,m tl)e City' or Coul'"Jty Governmental Agency ,to whom this letter is'pre5ent~d, ' j'. . , ' ~ , , S IGNlI.'l'~ 'I, 1 'j ',RICHARO'J.'GRIST " '. ~ , , B€fore me personally appeared ,gephan ,P. Ginn, ,to me \....e11 knO\07J1 and known to me as the oe r: son descr ibed in and who executed ,t'j1e'-' forr:goirig instrument, arid- acknowledged to' and before me that. he eXe6ute~ said instrument for the purpose he~ein expresge~. ~;i I:ness my, hand .;.nd oEficial seal this ..JjiJ1l. day of ,~~____ AD 199 3 " ' " '" ,-----) , " i' " . (, , '" I .... '7 ~ .' ( ) }ltI'..1:t~{..; C1-', 0~~'~1f4Il~'Ar:'-0' Notary PY~lC., " U. St- te of Florida at Large · ., , , , ' , , Mi; commission expri~s , ..;f'J,;'~~~" OFFICIAL SEAL, , ... '11'\<:- n.. '. Ilo!'l"'rla J, Slocksl;lflcr . f )~;~n~J } My Commission Expires ,'. ,~u,lti '1''' : May 29. 199G , ";";"tr \1\;-'\",0:.- Coml11, No. CC 205796 ~'i~:."t.. 1 . " ~ "~ I h 1.A(',~'f/l .' 1135) fQnTY N1N-r~1 S"fnEF.i 1'101\111 ~~:~ .lo',uw.rur,mc. Mw~~..~Vt,n~'. ..., \,' , . , . " ' :i 1. ,., , ' " , " -,-.' .....~.- ".1'.' h;oft... "'''UUif'''') ---->'//,rx1;rr~I;.'.:-... -.-~. h, ~~:~.~~[===::. / ~ ~o . / /. /' i, ~ /' . / './' ~ ~ ///A1'~/ ~ ,'/.~' ' , '~ ~ , r, .' /' /' " r:::: ij. I, ~~t. r lJ Il I J~,. 9 -----,.~~------ I I, , ' ',' I 1-.'.~.~ .'!n'j" ~:~~, .,.. '" , ., ,..."... (~ '.111 1- ~ ~ -:-L I , \' I: , ,I =<O(J,tJd J i I~ -€I I Ie.: If, .tl -: l~ ~ j, - \.'_ J E', ~-_..__. .._-~ . --.... -~-~ '. . I.$~.,,,,I .= .)J 7 l~_ >~~~_-:::::--- -------~_. :;'50."", . " !.. ~ ~ , , ,. -r= I~ I!, p., ,;, n .. " I, ~ ;:\ I " ,L. ~~~.~.~----.....................-. ~...-- ............-... ~i\?4." ' , , ..~~-,_\...' 1II1"111IO_'.lfIlllUII ='L; :~I ::'..l';l~'t'~-=~,~~r,-r~':ll~INf::::: ~=':AD~C:-::l",='h~~r:I,~I:..: .:::~':~~ ~'Q1~N".....i ~;...,..,)IIj"'I,.....nIl';"tl-QI ,....J,t pt..... 1(1....'l)h( 1'111'11I;. tilj""'III......'...U..01' ,,,.~C~.....uU-UIW 011I 1100CU n:::i~' ~~~-:-~ .. ~ '......n 'il) 1..... " ~....I'OtO ...aWl" __ 00 e, , H -12- ulI'I-~'il PE.NINSUUl.R SIGN CO. - ..., ., I . -I' .. '. I.. ,,~ JI.......M1I41,J J~lL1JIj;".J ",.Cl1lDn UJ/ ,,, ':'O/ILF 1i"I~" ~L/~l..:'.".'Jl.:' "'''''''0' C ,4('JI r .....Ut O' 3 -t-o _do ._~':/ ,./ ' , t. --"t. I I -',' r} ,., /G.~ '" ~';> - ! ,'" , '.!l 1\. I I" ; :.r '! c) ,\ \ 0, - II " \) . . <, II '. I~ :). 'J I \\ 0 , .. f'l, 'j t '-j " " \15,'t 1:/", f o~r:a. "I; ~'Clll\1 f). -I ~" ":t- :ZIt! //' l ..1 " .) 121--,11 ;. - , li\ U 11 ~ ,I ':) II , , (:\.\ '1.' ~ i t..~.,,, 1 @- 'FRcIH \IIC\J ::>t.,. bId!: \ '/11" ~ 11 -0" ~'tRt~=t~ll~i:1~=~ri!in~~i~~~ill.r~ :':~~.~::M ~= :\~::. ~-J~~~tt.::,::r ;~~~ 'D ""''fc'.t rJ'''~ ~""'_LU~U. ~ .O....lWP..""11.. ~I.,J 1.'" 1~=n~f~r,J,~'::; , .......-...,.,~ ,.-I: tlM .~U ..."i...... hO ((. '7l- t 1- POt/G._I/. H Z [~ " , , L J .!_nll~ULAA ;~N. CO, "llguJt~I. ~...IIIJ.sOt I U~ " .. ClUI.1'" ,.) IH..I ~~I p,t WtI.'1 r. L '=1_ UAAQnCli " umnllOh I: {,~,~ T I' " , , ,\ t " . 'r \ ," f'---'- U~ 1'1 OIJr:tl ~..~ H ,'.1 --. () .. I ... N 0' 7~J' ! .. ,F..ILsl-l1~, ' t . V t " I , , , ".-. ~ 'II" ( ) , , - " , ,I \: i\ , :--..= - '-"- ~ ---~ 'fl [=J t1 ~.. , ~ /, . ,/V\' , --~,. ., ,?) - -.- [J ( ? .. , '1 .' H l ( ~ , ') ,\ ~/'<J ... . ..tf1 ~' fA - ,- , & ',z.1l - - , , "1 .:::. ~ . I ~ I, , ~ -.l) ... tr- , , l^) n' ,} t.l T \ It r-_v.J -:.:L^lf. : l?'lf'::. I' _n" . , PEN,INSULAR SIGN CO. ....".-o..~., IIb\JJ~{U ..l..lI",,'fJ U:'",' 1 ~l l (;",JU ,., 1"""( , ,1.0,1., WI. 1...r. , I. ..I"".... r.. c..1Z.~1' " '~_II[ .- "... - - . tn .I " : I, '. 'il I II . , , " "1.: l.1t . IL .... c..n- '! '"111 .' lIlr,.,~.... . ",."U, ,""''\t H "'01' ....,.., It"""""" "110I,11I1"" ".........".. ""\lfCI)UfUfI toN>'''' 1....."'1"1,JI,'(HI_~N-~11.......1(If IIJt~in"ll .""1 ~ It:':t:~t11,~~J'~~1.c~~tN'l \~,~ 'm:m~:.. 'V..1I111t-..J.lllt~.;.{"..... ~UI'"''''~I'''._MU"""hl...D' .~'-t.''''''i If 110.....'..... t-"./III ,..~,,' ~.).u. iDlI ....... t(,M,ll'I'" ~ .... !'.Ai hili' h'lrrt '.jlt.oot'.......... ....q'.... ....41" h. """"" 1............llW..... V'''''I!4.'lclAIl1.''';'-\''' ~ , " 3 , 'i '" ...!!. 'Err I: ., .. 11 IDD ---m , 12 ! .. :ET SI ! ~. .. I) \1 1 12 ~ ~ .. hD EO S = ~ '" .. 11 ! 12 .. ~'o r_ :i .a, 3/09l' ri~ ~oo U J/l0 I ~ ~ . I I ,oj J ~ 21087 .. CC ~ 23/02 ~ ", 1.1051 2J/03 !U .. .. 210'2./ .. I .. 23/04 :i nt I' .at I ~ 20967 , 2J/05 ~ " e ,L. :i lI'l I ,e II. ~ o n. ttltth..- .",.t,,. JDI !., .00 .08 :::$ ~ ~ ..... ..... GULF nLW BLW THEcc GENe SUB 85-18 CH 2J/06 "t 20865" . ~ J. 2J/01 2J/01I 2J/OII 11 s: .. .. ..,. i '" -I' 11 II II II. 1471-7IJ ~,,-~. , "/11I-7 U .)4,.-",.. GULF I ---.-.------- 2 JHe-Ul .. - :: .. .. II II 11 2Cl cc ---,..; CH 2 101 I c I S ~ \.oJ I: ~I' ,Iq .....' ~ "" .\:) :t:, \00 0\ '" ~ ~ '" (::) "'-I.. ::z::" ......~ ......~ t\:::' ~, f'... ::t: 4J ~ .oJ ~ ....,. ,.,,.: 1 .. ;;:- H/Ol <C C a:: o G! 14/04 32/02 '~'V ARJANCE REQUEST: OL :lJO;lO ..~:. 14/0' , .' 21 02.8 " , '. 'nn-nun" nn '"rn,,"""" lJ_ItI'UUIU'UII..'U'U. nUU'UItUUU lo1.tUn.UluuUUUtUU tlU,....u...., ~Jt IUUtlUIHUHU'U'U IU'UUU'"'''' .. ...IIUI.........U....1I fH.."'~\-'1I\'" "/U.U..UIUIIUUUIU,, .... It' 11("1 fU I 1'............"...UI'..' UI........U~ ..II....- ..,...~~ --"-' UtI...'U..UIJlUUU....H HUe'" 11 I .....-- ~ y "..IIUUlu.nlll.......U till.,. II ..,nIUIU,u.nn""""1 + .. UIU u,,, In u, Uu UUu UlUU UI UU ..~ l~' .Uln.tI.IU'UI'UIU4U'UfIU.U.I.UIUII ,'t~:~~:,T""N"...'"",'.'''N.''',V...',',t.'.','.'N''N.'.',.,t::1 '4"H .,.. "1 ""."";<<J UUlnIlUI._lIlt II Utl'tltl"'''''''I'''' 11l1"U'....UtUI,U ................'1.11.. IU''''III,..'t".tI'l ..........'IN,'..,.....,...N.....'N,tN..,..V..,.,'....,.......N"I'II,t.~ ..1....IIIU'f......tU'Utll.I..'U 'U'WI.'I t ...I.III..~...'..IU.I..Ju..nl..tu.'...I.. -' '....',..unu1.u'nuu~nl.....>>'~'''Y/..U... 1""1""1II111U~1~" m Ob' tlIHItUIUU,nUI f, .. t... R"u 1......V....,I.......I..I.:..I'..'t. · .', H 'NJ.iNN!J}J.',- _IUI ntl tI. u. U'I U'I" "'I....~.....Tr,Y.. II It U.ItUIUUII" I.',.,I.'I.....II:..I...........N..:.'. ...... f '~I nu'........... ~..n....lu...I...... ~ 'I .. ItIl'UIUItUII ~"IIIt'''''''I''UH' ~r I "{"y,iUIt....1 .............HIII... ...... . Q .t""''' ~ IQ)H~'U 1I1...........UH "- ... Ip;fU. II t "tI .. '....IIUIUII'" >_.. '"{ ~ .".. "UIUIU. .H IUIU'IHH't -....;J HII. ......I..'.. ""ltI~I"II" ~ _Sl_ I I J .... . ""ii6WUlr- J~~L_ 11/05 , .a. PIS " ;J.. ..... ',. . .. '... . I .: " ;. ." ... '-- '.... .... l .~.... j,. t ::.: :'. . . ',r:H/05 ~' . '-,";" j..... , _.:' . -.. '~.' ~" ~ r STUDEBAKER' 2" :. 92~39, .' : ~ ..... . 1~~~. .~ ~ ,.,...., . CG :. ~:~ . ,; ~ P/SR . " :'~'. I~r 1! .$.... '.' ~, \ JI ; a. :. 10 BAY r M ~ ,. ~ .. " l~ Sl 5 an 11'o\O/(11 41/05 P/SP .CG "'/01 "1jl'\)4 '2055"0 ,'" .. ; ~ 20569 ." 41/03 [Q S'~ /lZ' UO CH 1.0,,"011 ~ NAME: c.. ~Rr~1'J / HO\NA'RD I .:JOHf'J~1 PEN IN.e:.;;>0LAi2... I - SV#,Cf3.w'l PUBLIC HEARING A'TLA S P AGE:.290BSEC ~ \B DATE' TWP SIGNS s. RGE:-1(P E. ~ CLEARWATER CrTY COMMJSSfON , , " "'\ I I I,' 1 . u: . ~ 1.J r,/ 1\.: I ~ :.': l ~...~ ,.W .-...:.....,...' '- I : 0 1 r. ~- , <"I /11' ~,' ,\ I I I , I n~l. I '~J =. '. .. JLL -;I m I () "" , I I . " :y , 1 II ,I II I \~, I ~~ ~L7 o . '~~ I I ! I,. , " i " 1\ Y',.t~'~ . cf: . ' " " " ',} " ., , lit: ( " , " " " lJ '. ; .~ , , ',I, )". ',' r ,\ .. . '1~~"\ , ,:I::',,:~ \ ,~"'.:" '~y~~ !L>C':"~':"~' ~ ~ . ~ ~ . < .; 'c , , :,; ~ ~ \. ... 'i,' ! . .," ,.~, .1 . " , " , .. '\ . :., .(r.. J t;": . < ~ '. . .... , I 11 ~ '. i'. :1,: ~ ." ~ : . i > . ~ '/ '':' \. . > . " 't".' ':~,;; ,;' '. ~ .f ~ 'L i . .' ,,' . ." ~ ;-:'. ,\j." . '. . . ~ ~ . ~J~ .~. 1 . : L . ~ " ~ .... .< " . ~' '., 't .~ 11'~. .\.\ .~~. {''''.-J~, .f '."' ".+ '.",1 " t1 ~. ..: ... . .."of ,:' ir ' ' t. , , ~. c~ ",'...'" ,. . ". :'\~. ~ :' ': ! .-:,<;'~::,::', '. ' ..' , ,,' 'I, '.'(' . , . ~ I". . " , (: :, ':1, .f ", :,.' \+ . .~. \'. ' . . ~ ...;~ " , "';TC .:,.".... i... . ", i . <, ; ., ;:,,:.,.,:;/ :':\:~'~\':~<'''';' , I'.~" .>. . ., i I . :i ,:"1"", ,: ";'.~ ~: 1>..'. . ., ~ I ", .: ~ . + ~ ,.";' ~,',". ; .:~.~ :.~;: .~,. 'l . ':" '; .' ':' '.1 , ,co ".:. "oJ" >.: 'l:' . .':~ b." , I . ';~',:.'>.~ ~:,:..;.:., ;~: . I ..' . ;': ':;: >',\,>:': ,~ . ,~' . . ,f. I .. ~ ~,' " ' '}~'"L."'dol:. '~,i>~" .,.. " ',~' o:'~. "!\ I ~'" J .', ',I \'jl'" ' "fr.:.~..:' ~, ., " . ~'~I ',~;II' l +', <' '. I , ~ .:~. ;," h / ~ I :' ~ . ~ ;' ,-, r " .' tb~:;,;"'",'>,,i,:l'/ ;', .;,'.!:I ;::,: , ~ ~ ~ t I" "l '." > < . I .. ;.;.1;.,.....<'.~:r~L '"c~ " .1 "~~.' '~.~'. . ......~: 1 ~~ ), ," . ~.', . ~. t ^' , I ., ~ ' I',', .:'1" , .; '/ .: 'f~f n ". I '.'. ~ . ' '. I, ~ .,' ~ ~ a' '/1 .~. \ .' ~ I'. .L:',': . " .. ~ ..1 1- :" ..1 . .'. ".'~ ., ' C! '.. '~~ 'f . I.>. ' I., . '-..c " c;,...c ',r .1.",; .' ,>i~'~.~d~~ " . r " . + ..' ~ : , ,... } ;' :-"'.~:1" r">.',:;, : ; , ::'.} , ~ <>:- :.. . "~I }.f' ~ w, . j'~ ' .1~;X\i~:; ~. ~;:/ ' , ,.,:'. ,l.~ ;, ';,;:'i/: .',~'~,t.1 ~". ",,"',' ' ,,[' i ."t' ,. '. F', ",: ;, '" ! , ': ,:~,: ,,? .!:: .,; . I . 'J' .~ ,'> :,)tc' ,c .; \,<,', ,,:',;: ,: i-' \', , I .' I, t ~ "l<..c I', , . '~~ \,.'~;;'~~ c ~ ;', f., ;1 . I; ':+ : . ~' : (. . ( ~ ":, \ ,', \ ~" -,:" ' I:dt e . :J.~ ~ ~ c , ,I j' ',' It' , . : . ~ I, ' J: I " c) :. 'I' ; : . ~' ' : " : ,~ ',~'} ~ c ~... . '\.1 c C\t. " J . ' , ' . , '. , ~. ,i '..':;' .i'. 'I ( ..1:,' i' " , I . ~< 'i, '. , '. .) . c f. ,,\t' . , . ~. ',. , ,il... :'.',1":.1'/.':: " . .. ~. ~ :, . \ , ~. '. ," .. ' ,i, 1, , I I. . fiT': " i' ,~ " ....~ ~. i ~~';'.:.:'/ ~ ~~ . . ~ : ,:.'~'.,':..;:>: ,: '1~'" ,"l:'~ .. ,(, ' . ," t:: I~',' . . f\ ~: '; . ".I. ". 'n \' ,.' "t' , ,~/., : : ~ ...~ 1 . ~ " " , l' ~', . <t , 'I.:., ',.i , I' ." ~ '\<' /' c; ~', " , ,: .. ". ..c " , ... ~::. I ':," '~ ~ i' c -r" ~ :: .: < " ".; ~ '" , ~', . l ~ l , : ~ " cl; ! " . ,cc <' '~~ <0,. : ,',' I . ~ I ~; . 1 1 ~~ '. I ~ , c, ~ \ ~) .; I ".1 'll'. fl . .".'n o . ~,':.' ':," ;, , .. ~ ,', :, ; , " , . ~: 1 ,. ::~ : ~. 3 ': \ . ~' ,t . ~ .,.l1, " l.'" ,,' .j ,:', \ ~ ,'" \ '; ~,,~~+',;Yc . l ~ ., 1 ~ .~ ~:,,' \,,>,,\ 1 ' ~ , . t, " ,', :,. ",(, .. ,:0' , : }' t, . ~ ,\..7 ,,~. t ,'. '. i~~ s', ~,; .,: ' . , , t,- '~. ..' "", i: .', .'., ,.. . , ' : ,.''-,,:,:, ' " ," ~ 'f ., It.. '" .' : '~'>', 1 ..' . ,'., ',' t " .)'. : :'), , , ": l , I 't- .'". .: c:";j":':( :..... , .. '+ ~ . ., . ,;,: ~ ~., .:....: . ~: \' ':' ' ': r~. :,:.}i' f " c ~ ~ . q, " I' 1 .l ,', ','\:': ~~. ~. ~. d 1 ,,). l '. .~ : ~. ~ 'l," '," ". '. .. ,. ,.~, !. 'j" I ' , ~ ..~ .'. " , ' !. ~ , ~. ,.. ~ ~. " , , ~. . . ~ . j':' i ~: ,:, ';,/, , :, ,'-'?' .' !.~ '.>.< '1',.' ~ " " . ~: I, " ',:, !,~ . ~.. .. I' . \ I~ ' 'd ~ . ,> I . ! I' .'. .:" ,c "~: 1 ~' .::.~ ": d, . \ ~. ; I' : ~ ~', \ I .: ' ,; '.~.l \ ..' ,'. :' t : , .' " i/.:,~'~:'; ,,' }~,:,: " ,;1 .. ", ~ 1- > < i, ~ ,,:' '. i , , '.- ! " i:'.~ ~ , , .' ~ :" '1 " .'c. ..1,.... , ~ . ~> -> . .', ~ , .' . ; i.:, ~; '~1 '1 '.. . I."">' ,; ; ~"T ." " '" '., . . I '~, I l ~ ... ,.I' . . ~. . .., .. ' :,' '. >.> , ~ J . I . ) '. '. ~ j " ., . :. j,. , , ~. .~: ; , , c ~c .1': ~ _ ~ > ,Ic: t c i ..~ ., ,i -..;'-: ~:h'-~\ ,c. " , ,~,; i . ;:" <; c ~. f. ,c : . . ..'. .11< . .1" t ~ > . . I. ~ " l. >. . ~,' .\, . " .c' \ I " ,'j ; _II. ~ cj ',' ., 1..;. " !.' .'(1" ',\', , , " . " :' ~ :.. ,,~; " ./.'{i , , r, ') " . . ~ l ,i . .:.f, . : '~} 'Y :{c<.'" y.:',\,. ' .. ~,';. ,c<~:: " , ; ~ I:." "-'- '.' -;., ~'.' ~ '...: . ~ :,~ < ~ I ~I .: .:, 1(, . \ l ~ 'J \, , , ~ . i ~ ';~ ... ' ,c:' t ;i .; ~. I.' ;' ~: \. .' . ., ~" (. l' ~ . . c, .,: l' '~l ':;' < ~ ',. ~ +..... , " , i . '. ~ l , " , l/~. 1 ". ;, ," , ./ . , " : , \.. ~ ,,- ,-, , " ,'j " : " " t t . ~ .. ' ! . 'c.1. ,~: ~ i " , , 'L", . " ' ~: " l .' ..' \ " ." , ,.1,: .'<\ , I , ~j. ,'/< \' ~: j',:, '" I' .; , ; \' ~ ' . c .':'-1 ~ " ~ ~ '., ":);, 'OJ't, , " )' ... _~' ~ -I 1 't; . 'It"!. / c , .\', .1,:; \, '. " ), 'I' 'j "f" '" ' .' , i-, "/ ,I .' ,. ,,,,.'t " ..1'\ '; , , " " , I, 'I '. ' 'I" , \ " ,t '. I >: , , , . ," ':) '.l '.\ " ',' ,I' ,. !. i I.. ,I .. ... ~ ~.' '" . ~. ' .'. :f' '. ~ " ',!' ;1 , : ~. t ' p 1""'" 1 ~ ' .. ., ",'J. :ci L. '"c" ,', " :';',l " 'r; I , ,\;-t . : ~ ' . " , .. . ~ 1',1 " . I' " , . ' , ., " :. (. . . , " , ~ ;. ;; ..,; " , " " :..,./ " ,1'11..1- 1 '\. '. " , , ~ '.; . ,,' ,I, .' '1" , , " > J,' .(" ".: ., ... n, " q::",?<\, V'-~,' ,,,;,,:,;:;;,,;"',"..,:.,;... ,~ ",": .c;. 1<:.' .tl' q' " c.:; ., \.1' ' ~ " ~ ) , ~.', . ,i d ~ c i.: ',' ,I :.' . , ~, <' , ~ 1- , , .l,;., ;i{:': ,! .. :.' ""'," '^ '" <l \(V(o\1: (. ': .,. . ',- \', " Y' .. " . i'. ; , :'\ " r ~. . f .~' " I' , : i.~ I .\~.. I " , ,~ . "..: lc ~:~ '~( .; ~ 'j",:c, J :/'.1' . t o . ~ ..,' ~ l " :.'~' . I "J~j1~,~'cJ.., ~'~: :,:'r.'J:;:~~T,;'.T.c, :.~ :,,\, +.I~,'" : t ,~". <.>'~.,c.'~ _.".' -.': I , ~. \ > ". " ~, ~ \ ;i?'i,,;,.,"::: \ . ,I ", ';' \', ,<' , ' ;,\!;;;f,, 1 "I .. '" ~ . (T.,\: ~ ' , :: ~ :'1';:::::: : .: : I :. I.. ' : ... ~ ,,:,: : ~:i,.' ">;;'::: c'. ." .; !,;. r' ~: ,I. . ;. { " , '.J , ~ I: " "";' ";' . ~." . , ~ <, ~ I ','., + . .' I ~. .,.'t. . .~ ,": . + " L .\ ".'f;' /, " .~, !;- : . 'I " , ! .,' " I ; ;' <"l<~ ~,;J':,:j" :,'''':.:' ~ " I -,. ,', . t >':' ,', " i ~ )' '. c < .,<. ' '. ~'I>. .. - !. ,"-t ' !" :."!J;' ' ~' ), ':t ." 'c' ,\ ,t ,'~ ,'. ,f, " ~.' . ~.I . , " , ' ,', I c'. ,1 '\ '1' ., ~ ~ . ' ..' " . ~/ ..'t .' ~ ~, , ~, ~.! . ., + ,. .' : ..t, . 'i , ~') , , :' ,', ..., ',' ; , " ~ ~'" ~: f " , ' ..' ~ L 1 :': t \. ':,',.'1 ,', .~ ' T, 'c ~ ~ i :J, , ~ i : ~ '~ ," ,,' " ;. i ',. I' , i n , " (c' I.' '[ '.! .", ,- ..../ :" ~ . l . .." ' :..:. ~' - :. '., c ~'. . ~. ,,' ,', ~'. ~ '; . ' . ., : I. !,':It',.,.. : ~ i .~, '~ .'. \' ;:'. ", , . : Ii" .' ~ "1. , " ,1 d ~ t '. /"".. ,. ..' , ~~,. , ~. ,h ". I" " , ~ d.,; ~, . ~ . , ' , " ,. .' ~ , '. , :b,: .., . t t<, " :" .' ,\' ,I " , ~ I .< ' " " I:, ,;. c \'}" . 1 .', ~. , " r,., , I' ~. i- "-, . . In". \ " .',\' . . ~ ' f> , " .' ..;! ;,' '. ", ;' . , ' :, /: ': '" '1, '~ , ,i -F, .. ',c~ . , ~ ';; : ~ /' ,', c '.' , ~'. \ ~ ~ . t l 'J' ," I." , " " " " ~! I' ~ \'. ,"',_>. . c t , . . " . \ ~ . ..' , 'Ij' ' , ,', '. . Ii.'. ;.1.,r ,'/, " : ~::. . -;'.' . c. ,'c ~..' .',. ," ..1" : I I. ~. , , ~c<, .) . ," " , " I' '. , I t ~ , .; 'J~ ! ; : ; c(. < ~ ,'+ ~ . ~ ,\".", '.:l' '. ~ . >~ l ~ ., r .'.' ...... .: , \,' T) ,c\. ',., \'~: ~ ,\ ::1' 1+ c.i .!c .j'?.. t' ..!: .. ,', " , \. " ;.J ~. ~ < , c: ,\ " " 0/,' : , \ , ", ,', .;, l' , . ,'1' / '\ ,> , . ~ i _ ,H ',' c, ,\'1 .. ~ ~ .,' .. q'}' '.' .,~... ~, 1 ,.'- ~ ~ :; : . , ,I' . . >", ,; " . " ,. I , . , ", > :"J ' .. ~ ~ . . ~ " " . I',. ~ ! : .~ ':. ,r, 'c, . /" ~< 'f i" '" , , ., .,' ~ I. ,', .\ . ,'. , , ,l' ..,' '., ~~ ~ , ", '. . ~ I' ; ~ !. . 1 '1 :. ,:. . \1., ... . . C. T< g.;{~:/t;,/;: ';:, , , '.,. ,( " ;, . 'c ~ . : ~' ~;: l .,~. . ,f, . ~ :.:: \, '.' ," I .J ~' 1 . .r. ;; c. , . .,1. ," I: ~ ~ I, . . . ,I . l' ~ , ; .~ -. .' ,1 I, .I ." ':1, . ' " ,,\ , "I " , j , .' ! :',.' ~~. . . ..~ \' " " , ' { ~'" '~ 1 " ,r " , , " " ,I. :, \, , . l' <.... " l ," . I' "\ ,--; , }! ..... ~ . , t, I;' I'. '{ ,,', > ", I {: \'" r I ~ . . J~~~':'~>:: " .j " .~ ~ , ' I, I' .:. ~ : 1 . ,< , , ' '. ' ~ ,. , .. 'jl \, , '., '., \ . ~ .,. I, . ,:'" '. , .... , , " ' , l , ., .f ~. :. . " " ~, l' .'c , , . '~ '. '. . ..,. \, .' .:.)."~1/ 1; <\~~: ','I- ~ :>.<~> . . i, . . , ' :. ". '~. \. ".,'h \' .." . ,- , ; \ , ~ ~ '. t . .~ ; :- J.... ,,':'0 ~,.' " I, , I ,Ct" " c.-': ;.. ", : ~ . ',I " , I' ' ; . ~ ',' .'," 1',t, , ) .t. } " ., I. t; " ,\, ~: c , ~ ",. , I , . " , , . I ~ .,' t . ~ . -; t }<~:: ,', '" ~ ~. ,:. ", I , }:.,:, , 1 " ,.. " {:':" 'i' " ~ ; , l'l' , ~. :.: . .' \.- i",". .. ~ t " " I -0,:' ,~ '. :l . '. ~. . " , , " , , ,". i .',:. ." '.... . " " . ,', )'.. .' ~ .~ , ' ",J, 1./' '.>' , I \1,- ,'. AGENDA. '";, 'I:'t 1 . .' )' ,\, ,\ " ". :, ',\ " " ,", , " ~ I : ';' . " . , " .' I ." c ~ 'J ", + i ,; '. ',~' ... ~ ' I. ;. " '"'. " '1 ,;DATE-1' .. ~ Jj~ 911' '. 'l . , , .' . f::, > . \' ITEM #~ . " ,'> . . ~ " " , .( '" , \' '" . ~. It " , , " . ~ . , '. ,; c, " .I' ,I )', " ~ '\.' , " , , '.' ','1 ", .. " ,'I. '\' , '., , , , ' ',I " , ~ 'I ,~ ~ " ,,' l, . ~ , " iY " " " , ,I ; Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item # Meeting Date: ;)0. 1/;) ~l{L{ SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 1499 Gulf to Bay Blvd.; Barnett Bank of Pinellas County/James C. Clark, Barnett Technologies, Inc. (Ow'ner/Applicant); James N. Powell (Representative). (SV 93-96) RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION: Approve the following variances: (1) an area variance of 43.5 square feet from the permitted 24 square feet to allow attached signs with a total area of 67.5 square feet on the west elevation, and (2) an area variance of 49.5 square feet from the permitted 24 square feet to allow a total area of 73.5 square feet on the east elevation, on property identified as Lots 9-17 and Lots 21, 22 and 23, Block J, Boulevard Heights, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8), subject to the conditIon that no freestanding signs (other than directional signs), be erected on the property. o nnd that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same. BACKGROUND:' The applicant is requesting the following variances to enable replacement of attached signs: (1) an area variance of 43.5 square feet from the permitted 24 square feet to allow attached signs with a total area of 67.5 square feet on the west elevation, and (2) an area variance of 49.5 square feet from the permitted 24 square feet to allow a total area of 73.5 square feet on the east elevation. The subject property is bounded on northeast by Gulf to Bay Blvd. and the south by Court St., west of Highland Ave., and is in the Limited Office zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table. ilIA ilIA ilIA NIA Nfst II A /" OrigInating 00,,1: ';-' ~ CENTRAL PERMITTING CUll: Reviuwud by: Legal Budget Purchasing Risk Mgmt. CIS ACH , Other Totol Commruion Action: o Approved o Approved wleondl t loml o Denied o Continued to: U .or DOIII: Current Fiscal Yr. ,../ll Adv. r lind: Dnte: rnper: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Requl red AIIIClod Palli.. c;} Notified o /lot Requln'd Funding Soum: o capitul I",p. o Opefut i 09 o Other Allnchmlnt.: APPll CA T lotI VARIAIlCE ~ORKSHEEf MA"S o Ilone Subllllnld by: AJlllIOlulltlOIl Cod.: <) Pl'tntcd Oil rt'cyclcd p[lJlcr' SV 93~96 Page 2 Sign 1 _,I Sign 2 Information Proposed/Existing Permitted Proposed/Existing Permitted Type of sign Attached Yes Attached Yes Location/orientation Court St. Yes Gulf to Bay Blvd. Yes of sign Area 67.5 sq. ft./24 sq. 24 sq. ft. 73.5 sq. ft./24 sq, 24 sq. ft. ft. ft. Staff Comments/Proposed 'Conditions: Subject property is located at the five-way intersection of Gulf to Bay Blvd., Highland Aveq and Court St. It is developed with a four story office building. The property is zoned for office use, however, within Limited Office zones, typically small single story buildings are found, not multi-story buildings. Also, other properties to the east and northwest on Gulf to Bay Blvd. are developed with smaller buildings on smaller properties, but are allowed more attached sign area (64 square feet). Staff feels that these conditions combine to make the property unique. In addition, staff review of this variance application included an inspection of the property, and it was found that the existing 24 square foot signs are small in relation to the scale of the building. It is staff's position that the requested variance is in keeping with the scale of the building, and is minimal given the location of the property, subject to the condition that no freestanding signs be erected on this property. SURROUNDING LAND USES Direction ~ Existing land Uses North South East West Rio Motel Texaco station, Budget Inn Factory T-Shirt Pesticide co. office The requested 67.5 and 73.5 square foot signs will be in character with signs permitted for other properties fronting on Gulf to Bay Blvd. The granting of these variances will not detract from the surrounding businesses that have conforming signs, nor will thoy negatively affoct the uppoaranco of the community. Applicable Variance Standards: To be eligible for LI vmiance, a requost must moet all oight standards for vurianco opproval. Based upon review and nnalysis of tho informntion containod in tho applicntion, staff finds that tllo petitioner's requost moots all of tho standards. In particular, tho following stundards do appoDr to bo fully met: SV 93-96 Page 3 (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is uniquo to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor croated by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or tho applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in , an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is I,ot based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a greater financial return from the property. (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located., ' (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property. detract from the appearance of the community, substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. (8)' The granting of the variance desirod will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission:, ATTACHED SIGN AREA CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING' REQUESTEDI ACTION DATE SV 91-01 2000 Drew St. . Shell Oil 84.8 s . ft./Denied 2/7/91 SV91-16 601 Cleveland St. Sun Bank roved 8/15/91 SV 92-19 27001 U.S. 19 J.C. Penney 10/15/92 Co. SV 92-42 714 Cleveland 81. Trickel 70 sq. ft./f\pprovod 2/9/93 Jewelers " , ' .~ ~ ,l> I . . VARIANCE WORKSHEET CASE NUMBER SV 93~96 I STANDARDS FOR VAIUANCE APf'ROVAL I STAFF RNDINGS I 111 The verlance requested IIrlles from II condlllon Which II Sub/ect property II 10Cllledllt the five-wilY Interlectlon of unique to the properly In queltlon IInd II nellher ordlnllrlly or Gulf to BIlY Blvd,. Hlghlllnd Ave.. IIRd Court St, It II uniformly IIppllcllbte to the xonlng dl.lrlcl nor crellted by an developed with II four Itory olllce building, The property II IIctlon or IIctlons of thll property OWner, predecenor In title. xoned for olllee un, however, withIn L1mlled OIlJce ~onel. 'or the IIppllcllnt. Any ml.tllke mtlde In Ihe lIIlecullon of II typlclllly smllll lingle 110/'1' bulldlngl lire found. not multl-Itory building pllrmll or work perlormed Wllhout the benefit of tI bulldlngl. Allo, other propllrtllll to the ellst IInd northwest pllrmll shllll not be consIdered to be .Itullllons which support em Qulf to BIlY IIlvd. lire developed with smaller buildings on tl1l1 grllntlng of II variance. .mllller propertIes. bUIII/e IIlIowed mo" IIttached IIlgn IIrell 104 Iqullre feet!, 121 ,The pllltlculllr phYllcel lurroundlngl, shepe or If thll property owner I. not given the IIImll opportunlly to topogrllphlcal conditions of the property Involved IInd the place sIgn. II' other properllel which hont on Gulf to lIay. II IUtCt IIppllCtlllon of the provlllonl of this development code herdshlp would be crellled, would result In IIn unnecenllry hllrdshlp upon Ihe IIppllcant. 131 The vllrlllncell Ihe minimum neceuary to overcome Ihe, The existing 24 Iquare foot Ilgns lire smllllln relllllon to the unnecellury hllrdlhlp relerred to In preceding reclllll ~2M for ,cllte of lhll building. The requested VllrlllnCellI/e In keeping the purpose o! milking /elIlonable 1.1111 of thll IlInd, wllh the Icale of thel bulle/lng, Ilnd lire mlnlmlll given the loclltlon of thll property. ' 141 The rllquest for a variance I. not billed prlmarlly upon 'the The varlenCelappeer to be requelled p/lmllrlly due to the daslte of the IIpplleant to secure a greater I1nencl111 relurn for unique conditions IIppllCllble to this property, the property. 161 The grenllng of this varhmcc will not be materllllly The requlllted 07.5 and 73.6 square fo.llt signs will be In deulmental or Inlurlou. to Olher property or Improvement. In chllrllcler With stgns pllrmltted,for other propertlel fronllng on tlla nalgllbolhood In which the plopeUY I. locatad, Gull to Bay Blvd, Tha grllnllflg o.f thlllll vllrlllnCII8 will not detrllct from the surrounding bUslnellcl Ihat havlI conformIng stgnl, nor will they negatively affect the , IIppellrllnce of the community. \6\ The tlflln\lng ot 'he Vllllllnee will not Impair IIn lIdequate Slime IIn 115 IIbove. lupply of IIghl or ventlllltlon to adJecent property, detrllct , fram Ihe appeerance af the communllY, .ubltllntllllly Increllse Ihll conge/lllon In Ihe public Iftellls.lncreasethe danger of fJrll, endllnger the publlo lICfety In any way, or Dubslllntlalfy dimInish Of Impair 'he value of lIurroundlng property. 171 The vnrlance dllllted will not IIdvernly nffect Ihe public The requtllted vllrlances appear to salisfy this condition. health, IlIlely; Ilrder, convenience, or general wlllfllre af the communllY, 181 The grllnlln{l of the vllrlance desired will not vlolllte the The slgl1 regulllllonl were edopllld with the'lntenl 0.1 genereJ Iplrlt IInd tntenl af this developmllnl cadll, enhancing Ihe vlsuel quellty af Ihll City'. Itreell IInd Inndscllpeln order 10 prolect Ihe value or properties and the ,well.belng af the locllltourlst orlenled economy. The glllntlng ot thll.e "Inlanclls IIppellll 10 be consistent w1th thl. Inlllnl. , I , t'l \'. . __ .'-', . <":11 ~ UI- <..:Ll.:AIIWAIl.:H R:ecelpl#~lo.5 ~ 04\1 SIGN VARIANCE APPLICATION. A.MENDED SV# q ~ 1.'('1(n PROPERTY QWNER(S) NAME & ADDRESS: REPRESENTATIVE(S) (If any) NAME & ADDRESS:, Barnelt Bank of Plnellas County (or Barnell Banks, Inc.) James N. Powell Successor bv merQer to First FlorIda Bank, N,A. which in Pow en, Carney, Mooro. Hucks & Olson, P.A. turn Is successor bv meraer to Sl. Petersbura Bank & Trust Barnelt Tower, Suile 1210 Company One Promess Plaza % James C. Clark. Barnett TechnoloQies, Inc. Sl. Petersburg, FL 33701 Post cmce Box 30318. Tampa, FL 33630 TELEPHONE: (B13} 224-B839 TELEPHONE: (B13) 898-9011 ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 1499 Gulf to Bav Boulevard, Clearwater. Florida NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPLICABLE): Barnett Bank ZONING DISTRICT: OL _ LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: Resldential/Omee LAND AREA:M /It: P. f.f:7 LEGAL OESCRIPT)ON OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: Lots 9-17 and Lots 21.22 and 23, Block J, BOULEVARD HEIGHTS, Plat Book, 7, PaQe 54, Pinellas County. Florida PARCEL NUMBER: 14 I 29 / 15 / 10476 / 009 / 0090 (This Il1formatlon is available from your tax receiptor contact Pinallas Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462-3207. If more than one parcel number, attach 81fz x 11 Inch sheet) DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: Rio Molel & small office complex South: Texaco Gas Station & BudQet Inn East: Factorv T-Shirt Warehouse relall outlet West: Pesticide co. offices/professional offices VARIANCE(S) REQUEST: 1. A variance of 43.5 square feet of aUached siqnaQe to allow a 101~1.I of 67,5 square feet on west elevation. 2. A variance of 49.5 square feet of attached siQnaqe 10 allow a total of 73,5 square feel on east elevation. REASON FOR REQUESTING VARIANCE(S): (Refer to Standards for Approval, next page) 1. The permitted sionaqe size results in an unreadable sian which causes a compalltlon disadvantaoe to Ihe Appllcanl. ,2. The property borders Qonem\ commercial zonina on two sides and the T.Shirt slore across the street Is permitted the .siQnaqe denied to the bank, The variance requesled arises from the height of the buildinQ, a unique characteristic to the property, The disparale trealment of ttm surroundinn property resulls In an unnecessary hardship on the Applicant. 3. Tho variance requestod Is the mInimum necessarY 10 allow tile sinn to be readable. The lotterinQ would be 2 feet In heinht. 4. The ornnltno 01 the variance will not lrnpacJ dotrimonl~ anv othoLQrollortv in the neIghborhood. It will not Impair , adiaconl proportlos' light and venlilalion. II will not dolmel fromlho aJ2p'omanco of tho eOl1lmunilv of impair the value of (lnv surroundin9-illQUQrtv, 5. Tho roquC3slecJ vmlrlrlCO wllll)QI violi]o t11iU]Q!.]Q@!Jipilil or Intont of 1110 slqn ordff}lH1CO (No. 5257-92). A".M'I'lll A 111 IN 1111 fill CON T INUED ON neVEnSE SlOE :~. r I, , STANDARDS FOR APPRO'VAL: A variance shall not be granted by the City Commission unless the application and evidence presented clearly support the following conclusions: '(1) The variance requested arises from a condition which Is unique to the property In question and Is neIther ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actIons of the property owner, predecessor In title, or the appllcant. Any mistake made.!n the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations whIch support the granting of a variance. (2) . The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property Involved and tile strict appllcalion of the provisions of I~is development code would result in an unnecessary har~shlp upon the appllcant. ,(3) The variance Is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital .2' for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance Is not based primarily upon the desire or the appllcant to secure a greater financial return from the property. (5), The grantlng of the variance will not be materially detrimental or Injurious to other property or Improvements In the neighborhood In which the property Is located, (6), The granllng of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventUalfon to adjacent property. detract from the appearance of Ihe communily, substantially Increase Ills conge5110n In the public 5treels, Increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safely in any way, or subslantiaUy diminish or ImpaIr the value of surrounding property. " (7) , The variance desIred will not adversely affect the public health, safely, order convenience, or general welfare of the communIty. (8) The granting of.'he,v,arlance described will not violate the gee~~l spirit anp)ntent of Ihis dovelopment code. SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): ~.. _. ~ ~ -.-.. , . . Subscribed and sworn to (or affirmed) berore me this L ~..J!J.. day of I 'aI>' b, A.D. 1993 ./ ' by James N. Powell, Attorney for Property Owner PrlnlNamc(lncludcposillomndnameol compan'i' applicable) , who Is personally ,known to me and/or has produced as identification, (fypmlldenllllcnUon) INELLAS Notary Public, Commission No. (Slgnlllurc) , LturA ~ /"1S~'~. (Name of Notary typed, printed or stamped) , , K~\lV Plio' O;'Fll:jA(",NOT'^h~~~'n.) ...0. ....'0 LINDA C JOIIPI00'4 ~ '1W~\i. ,. COMMIG!lIO~4 HUMDtn 7 ~~'~.' ~ CC16li025 ~ u;. ;\.o<t MY COUMmSION fiXf'. . --~--- --.:.!1!!:~...~.L.l.!!B!..,~.. A:\API'IJt:A IION,..II 0,1) " " "j /' " " ! T . , " " p' 02 .' " " " .' " ,01 t ; , . F-~-- /. , ~ I, " . " .1 .' r' ......,...... ~ ,j ! )1 \Yl '-~ . I, ! i ...............-..- ,I, I ~ ~ [ I I , --~.._[!..- -.. ~~..,'... :"-'-':,' I ' ! '1 ' , , I I . I .. 'I" j I . "~ i___. . --. .......,..- !, i I, . -$ ~ 1i~ 0- .. l ~~ '~ 1 .' , , . " I, I. I' '. \ . I ,\ . (, ), " , , r~l .r;;~ .~. ~..> . ~ , ' . tl 'I " ~- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ., t\. ~ ~ :..._- , " f o. oj, " ' , , " , , , \ I, . " . , " , Iii 111 !B 'lti- ...J_......~_ -~,...... -..+---. ~_.... "'I'''~'_.'''. , ' :1 ' ~ I I ~ ,,~ .._~.......-.. , -U\ 'l1\ , , ----..- - .-...... ............ .~ ,t-t - ,e:: I . I .. - -~ I 1I(~lrtmiWx.:'I1\~tt..\. .,~Ct~>~(~K~"ilro.~n(r\r.~f"'i rn) ;rlt~r)O~~ :~'~fi."('~''''4' ~~.. \ 'r ,&U' ,\ I'.~)'~'.,\ ,\'t.:! " ~,~;, ,"'Y~~I>-: J(k':~,;:, "":i:-)IV~lr,; ,;t\ ~;)~N~ ::i:r~):" > ?'~..j 'h{1~ '. ~~" ....... '_..~""" " ,^ \j'" \"'1' "10-' ,'''' "t'" . ,/ ,. C,' ,"" '''l'.~ "" ' ~(l:i,i~f~." ~'tr: ~}r" \.': ~I' ,~hl\. '.:,{" \ ti ~,ii-,:: "'e:'}I<') '(, ,'?!'t '~~,~ ,\ ''', :..: i'4 .... t ~~. . 1". ~,' ).,.. '.~' 'i'~I~~..~. .~,. .~~. ....1. .1:. ....~~l Ct. "ll,.\' k~ ,.~;, (~>~ ~h""~I' J... ~l...... .~ .....'.. lt~ 1',\. ";~'" ~,,'I :1" I' ....(..'IXy. . t.".;.( '''f ';~l~~.;.\,. ~.;~. {~t.: " ~. 't."t "~"~~'..:;.1.. ,.4... "i~~. V~'I""'~~..' ~~~, ~l~, 1~"'..:'11~llt-~~ ~ '.' "1 ''''1.' ,..,.~..,.. .....".. ,..,.t........ 'or "h,1..J, ~.;.~. "'. '~''''t .'1.... ~,1.L~~.\'~.lll :.~~:,~ 1.' . .~ ~l'....,. ::~~P.I ~.\ \~;... ~: ~~. ;. \....: :: :'q ~~" \~ '.':t ~ tl ~ ~~ h ~ ~~~~: ~,~; /,'~.;~ t ~.~~~l t'~, ..;. ~;~~ \ C h 'I .'1' '~' " 'I' '<r.' '. '1""'(' ',q .'.'(1 ~~'1.'. ~" I,'i .....f' .,t. .n,!, ,il", . ~"'" ".~'. 1'~".. . ~~ .....l~.. \. /~ .,t. .',,\. i' .... 't,~ '\)';' .1,'. \,~(.I:'~ '. It.ill, l'li ,I,,~\. I' ,," '." ',,' ""\ ti}". ,1..". , ''''\'''~. "'I '>'1' Ill, .~Ij '~'j'~'~ "~+~' l l~. l..':.;"t; . !''l~' .'h.........~i'1.... ~ ,I ~ ..:'t'.....- .l}.,,,::~ I; -l':hf I+:'~J" ;,,:,, :~J:-.\ :);:- .:-t;l\.r, ~ ... .' II \,',~II.~'AI....., ""'''... t,~ :.hr,:\''\' ....~. l:'l"r\"l.,~''''''' t,)"-""'Ii,.I'\~.~'i}t'~~~~I..~/,~.....",I~~~n~.; ~..t, "). ." .... {' '~"'I\'" "} "''1 .....~\. .".1 "":'i.'~ .. ....... i". ....."1 H,..,'~Jt. ...\-......... .~~~~ .:~~, I ~ i ':t ~7 ... .:'~ .'...... ~~"".~':: ,. ~~.. .'.~ ~ ~.~:~.; I. ~~ l~1~~..~:.I: .:f} .~ ;i,;~...,t1 ~~)\ '~tJ:' :;~~:~~ll ~~.. ,I, '. '\"" .,~, :,jl, ',,, ..It' ',.\,", ,,"(, ,.Ite.l..., Ill, ,. ,hh'('I',!L'rl . ,I.,.......... {l,t r) .,. ''i,'', "( 'j.":' :~....{.v .~~ .~,~ ...:( ':'v-' i.' ;l~. ..., \.,...';1 ~\~~t~ "~""":>\('t ./...l,J"~h( ~~tt~". '.'~L: \:... ~;~ .1:~:.v (;..~ ;a:~,";.~bl~IJ.. ,'t.hi{~,}~.t;'f w~ ,~\:.. ~r'~ ~:t. }'~;..~.i.ft... "'>:,:~\:".\' .l~. :.d, "r,t.J-/,,\,,;,~!,""'t~'~~~~j't"~.._! :l'l'~'~' iB,1. ~)",_, 'II,'" 1('/, ,',":",:, II! !,I, .,''^ '.,'h ,'1;( ~t!. ,~t!,);,I\"';'J" l 'c~'~ '~! 11"~tlg <"~I'l\\~ .,',.'...' '..~, 'f'/';, ,..,...:<'l"",",.,,"-.!",. .,~\.."',~~,'~'\ R! '~t, \, ~~(r; "'II ~>YH'; .{~i"': '<:,~;, ~ILi.t~~,.; .ll';,U'~(':.~T, ':',' ?'.'~''',~\'\H'' .~, '. ,~I~~ (~l~'l~t , "~}' "t~", """C ..,,, ..... ;j,,~,~., ., " "".', '. 1 h, r<t\~.~)\" Illi ,1('IIo\(l':"'f," , " l ','")", .,,, '\/ ", " '''' "" '" ( <. I' .. ". "\,1 , :~~:. "'li :...;....... .~t,h....~. h.~..---.I(..~, . ~'t~~r ....". "~h l'\....l>:lt~~\...i/J.:~.~O..f.~~. ,);..~ .;~~' ( i" ~ iCJ.t ~~ ..~~~ '~lttX. ~.~ ~}")j 1.)~~:'S~1~;' >' I.;. .' ~),. ~. \ t': ~ji' : f;... !;jtl ~5h,; '/.I\~~'...4jHt,tJ/1 \ Ql' ,VI,. "~. ,.cO,. I~, ," .... ..I... 1\. ..< ',n. ~"..Ql, t.\~ ,'V,' , rn~,_ ~. "', r..'l."> .,.... '"\', ~,. ~".~ '11' ':l' 'lit\..{.',. '."'f"'" ~.,~ L J..I' '-~l)'""",. :~~"~'." ":'i.. "'i,,' ~.ri:'{IF'\ "l' .,',\, ,)," ~l', '<1.., ~l~ 1~~l\;.Q...', l;/j'.'.""" ,111. 'Ii,'" '" ",~."",' .~,:;;,..:~.. ".:,' 'I ", '1),/" 1~..t'~1 r:~r .Ih~,,..!.' lJ"'\t,~. 'J, 'h.,' "'i,~ hh' """;"'''''' gl;"'il, 1~1('~~~f" I\.,:r,,~<:"r "';" . . '1":1 '\~. {".l,.. I ' ..~ I :. ,~~ .\,..:.,.... ~.~,~ 1'~..;~.ttIJ (." .,.,( 'J ~.~. .'1 dg.,.\l" '11:.i "1~:' ~",+~,,:, 1,\ !~~l!' \\.~,',\.'.m..~~~( ~"'~~,,'f,~~lf4!r ~:(~)V~':~~~~ ;";~l ~ 'h~,:{~.~' ~.. ~.~~;:.:~:<.,.\...::~l~~ I.~~:it:" ;~:"~~'" Qf~;tl~~\...i~;~}..~~~.ll,." 'm \'~I ,,;," ',:j . '~l' "I" ,.,", ", t' "("~ "'\'1- '~"( :'" !1.,'d1' ,\~"\1t,' ~ J. ~I .~~~l~: . '~;~~),< ~ r...! ..~~~t :;~\.~ ~ I': ;". ";: ~~.l~"'~iCf~~I;l'~~{ ;'itJ(' " \ ,.~ "~~~ '~.: ~':" ~.! , . '1' "\I/\/, ""'\'i 1((V':'\<'tf . "...., "t"\'(>"'~(''''l'' "'~S 1(, )~!;(~I;l, ~~"~fiWC']~(l(~:'~[III~I,l!Ph'(<l:'('" ':"~hl.l'~lf'"J'~ -t:~(L~l\(ltl'. ~_tH~I' !Nf'~ \ ~~~/' '~F,t)\'J" I, t q'li~~l\'~:",h,\! "'."'" \"':-;'\,',. rl l"l..~r\ ~fll' f ,nt11~l' ..tK' ,~QS\11 bhfr~~:',\l, ;'.:"l~rd!l~r:~g ':,"~~l<..I~f~[ljlt~;, ")I}i ..~\fi~:i~iJl'~ " "'~IJJ;cl: I' '. ")(1 ,< ,lIt: ,. .~" ",,~ l\ r, ~ ~ '''0' ,,,_lll'):;.I! t.~ IIJ~t\II' t:~~(: I, ", ' J( ~ H.~ ..L~~!'~ '~h:~ ,'~h I"I~' i~(r'tf(~ 1~/~r~FI~~t'. ~~., . I ~ /~. ' "',...~~~~~,~ ~1"i1!th ~Jl t "iJI;~I""'l\'''' "h~" ,'.'1 :\I)':."~'" , "'(l,;'..,dl' , l~h df.{~h.,,~, ~~'~l ,~.~:v~~,...~t,o) I- ~.O 1.... ........0;(,;..... .~\~(,~)';t...}!),l,.;~~'~1h.~ ;!b\A"i:~t~f' ",tJ'''t1:~II..,\~lot'''.'.1.~~ 114,)..I.'t)~\' ...)~..~ ''I'' '~' '. '~"'1' '. 'H 'l('~I.I''''~c..f~ .~...... " ti~;''')M'c' t~:l' ,I,r, ',I,;, ,;',," ~l'j "'1'/, /,I{,l';, :;),. "!il\'t,, )l'~ll , ':l' '0 \(\r1 ~ _""of ".,. Ii d.n r .\n~ '/.' <,l' . ..-. ." .U'.l.lI,. \,( ~'[ il1r' .. 'i'1~ :'\~~f,!, .~.:'~. :"~L.' ,.~~j 'o;~\1 -.:.'" '~X~J, '~r.'. I ll,~~,,~t VI. ::)'i (:" x}~t.. i:'.f: :'~h\..I~i .., .. '. j . .1 .r. " d'tr .'. ~..[;!o t. ,t ...)..-. ( /'. ~ ~ .~ 'p\ Il"I'!'" ", ,"'. "'.1 "" I ..', "','" tl, "",1.( 1..t., '\"\lIJ~, .'.,1, .,1~.. t..,," (~'I';:~';::~j,j '(1;:,,, ),il"~; '\, ~\,,')f,~. ,&, ~\(, 1!i~:,1 :11-, .":.':; ~ .,,\i' '.... }...... > ..~,t .. ~,..,. '~!. : hfo., ~y~ .~..i.. H' . ~ - ,''', '. I fr"'Wt..,,/(, ,;f:" ;"j )" ,):'i ..~" ...ll) !lW .5J., .ill'., .) ,.".~, '", 1 . '0/,' ~-r.': -'\~'. ~,.. ~;~ \~.;.' ';,1- ,'(.' ~f~ t.. 'j~,,:' ..;.. t.(( .,f.~ ~.,.. \'~'r:"'''' .'1/" ~;... 11.,,1'11'1' !r'-;'l \.,:\;,. (!'l',' Ti'\ "'~:'~f<(..'!'.', ""'!\~ . > .' r" "'... ..1 1 . >. i. . , . I.... \...... ( . f.~ . ~..' . ...\ ,.. . . ~~I kl'~r, >:'-,.... ",~ " 'C't O/f ' ',', ..'.. '''l' '.'j" "'I" ....' H' . .", "r""'" ...,... ;" '" ~mt"f' .:.'~.. ..l,~ '\~,,!" 'J:;-. i.~!::":~;l tr;~,..''t~~\ .~~~ J~\' ~.f~1 .1;.' . ~:-l):, ;f:'~'~' "..~:~:I:~.U "" ,. 'J~'" ,. '\ ',r' "r'l "( .~ ",..I(r( "q ")(" "d'! <.( 1 )1"\,,, "'i' '1'" :5 ll1&.l~'" :;,")k:' r~~:llil\~ :-: ",~l~'; f1i~'I~\\'I'~'\5I':""(I' :::i:\i ',,~~hl,.t~(,il ~ ~~';'Ii\~~/if(in~d ~R~~ t1'1"U ~~ ::1 ,'," '. )<<:' 'J~\\ "'''J~ II' 'r:l!' In~. (H,la.1 \ '"lr'::' II '. .... m . i lA-\! .LlJ, !" ,d t ~ F lit ,~ ,,~ 111 \ii ~. ~ \~ ~ . ~ 1~ \11 ~ ~ \J~ ~ , , , , c I: , , " . I , ' :,' ~. :" ~ " "I P'. laO, , ~ ,'tre ," ~i ~ ~~ ~!jil ~i ~I .., I , ,) " , . I" ,I -.-.. I -1 ," , , ~ - ----.. ._--~, ' I I ... --- - -.-- tttQ ,I, ----~. ...-- - .' 0.1' II . ~. -_....- ..- --_--.:...-. ~ " ... ~ , . \t\ -t , ! _~_---=--'. . , - ~ ~ ~ ~ q ~ ~ , :~ tL" IIJ'~ . W~ ~ ii lI) .' t; j , I I' ; , I I rl't:;I', ',\t 1l'X~'0(~I'tr";1"'~/" ....'/: tllT('I!,'.' "~' 'V"C\" J\ '\';: ':'H\"" a In,~.... ,\,~,/"I' "....l'~"'~~.TI" ''It ",It. j~ ".1 "~,,;J ,.' ,,' ,", ',.l, "l' 'I "''-It .1,' i" ,,__,.:,1, Ii '~l, ii,~ll"'''' ,.:.~~r..i"';'\"'IJ~",; ";')t:'I\~'.~.~1.JJl:\..11' .\-J,. "J,..~~(,q,'I";, ~ .., .'..'., . ',.l ")' "'C.., (. " w '1".... ", , ~ 'I "X ,,' ,"'t ' , " ..,', '~-'l ''''I:I'';'I~'''l'' ~'~"..,'?"" '1") ....,. ;t Xi ("I' 'f1: ~;'" \ ""',' , 'n" 'l' '11.' ,;~:~"~,,, ~\' t. ".,~ l, ~"'" (( '\ ,~, \ '. '.( .'po r' , 'i ':;, (. " ;.' '..~ ',J.() .1>(,.: (,>:'; ;'i' t", '':I., !.' '\ h~, 'i~" At . '\ ~"C~ .!(, .~I' ',., (\' \, 'i\ II' ,'.:, ,.' .l(;. ;~) :,1; r.~~~i.~..[~\ ~......~ \t'~~11;'~i, ~t I~..~'~'~,~:,~~: L i:'~$:: ',~\~ ~))''(,:\.,~ "~::. :, "(: ~. -~~t'lj <~:/l, ",'.. n' ',' ~ I , t.,!". '~, I ~"~ ,,!, '1/ ,I' , l ,'" , "'fi ~'.:!l ~ .~\ .1.. :/ ~ ~ 'r 1 .r.,' ..~: 't I. :1 .:I-:~ ':~ ~.: :: : ~ ~. t". "~I .~:~ .~~}t;~ \~.,() \/ r, ~J l... ~ .. "1 .. 1....\ t, 1;., , I'l .... ...~.. \" ". I ." .......0 ) r '.~. \t ~./.,rL, ".t ''I; ., 1. '\ f '~."~.~ ~. ". ~. '1, ..... .'. ..~ 'f 'I '. I. :'..~!"J..- "!~~~\.it','.lt. It ...~.~" ,.... <~ ,"'L. ...i, .. "\ ~L" ... l...iI .. L I' ,," : ~.ti\.~"'I.l,~: .'~: ~'.. .'~ ~... :.:' .>. ~ j;~ ~:' '\ .....l..~~~, .:....', I:~..". ",' <' '." '] 4, "I \ 1),'\""'''\ ", ,," " '" I'. ',' \,' ',< I,.., " e " "")j ~.,.~ 'ttJ -.Ii.. '.....of oI'\,,~.. ;to~. "'~I:" 4'''' 1". i ,,. t. '"'\ ',' ", -'. "~'. '),tt..'1 ,\,it"~r "'~;l:t "'~ .'~.. "\ . f. .',;il... j; .'..~...... i. '\ . \; ,',~..: ~ ,'" ~;,' " ,'\~IJ~ ~." ./\~~~~~:~!;';:<:: ,~:~"" t'~" ...~, "';~'~'~"': ,.,' J:' ':: 'i;i: ~~,:"": : I'~:i ~ ;'~';~:'~; ,:.,,', :.:....~:~~{.~~:..;, '1~J ,i.....~ h .~:;~ t '. .~ '\. ~~ 'i~" ~.'.f '.~ ~""'~)'1 ~~~l ;'., .. I; J,'.~~' ; ''if r~;.4A~~t.;. ~"l '\. . ~ ~1 \, .. .., ....'., I "', ,..", 'i,\~, .....L~l ~> .'. ~o'\ .,..t ,,~~, . "~l' It' ,~. .... .... ',.". .\.:. ' 10. ~'" .....,.,... _II' I....~..... ';t:~ 1.<.' l :';:' ".) ". ".' l~J z."~ 't'~ )"'" .,L,.t. l~ ~.~ .. 'l .~I "." .., ..... '. .' ..' I . .--il ,}...r. ~i'.~~!'~'~/,'i~ r~."~ \r.; 'j.~ .~( '~.. }~. J. tt"\~'(" f.(~~~~.f..t~'jt 4.~ :f.tl; t ~(f:... c~~~~"J~~ )"t~'~'~l. l' : I~..'(, :\-" ',," ? 1. ':h..~~ ",-"!(}'fff1:', It.'b:>.1 J',','..I'\...,~t\.'t ~~'r,~' 'c!~: .~ :I,;:~ I~: 1~!:,.1~~"~: ':i",' ~~;:~t~.?i~ ~L,,$/~ ;1-''l~:: ft,:'.\~f~. {J.~', '~IJ"'i)""''':!~J,r.~\I('''''x),'~-'';''''.'~' /':":"1" ~\.:.,. ~l ' .',\-..., ,lfl.(..,;".~tlH," ~~hi'l\l;:~ ::':j '-l,,:'ci; - \jl' of :;t"'" ~',' :~; :I;,"i " j"!'tl'..,.;i ',,' ; ~:'~ i ,:: ,,:, ~u:tl" ~ , n ,., ,.'t~,"..,+"...~.;. ;;",..' .:l. ~t.,.... y!: ,lL.r., ~1' "I, K~ :{;, /.i\; "J'i";/i ;!. ~r (it"1 :;~i.~)'l~n'\'~ :~'1itH' ~ ~:t;~U~i(Rtt!~1!~\:i\~t:j~l~dR: . ("t '~,: i~ ~':~i;::'::t:1~~tf;~~ ~H~!~ ('" t ,.i, I.. .... I. Li~~.... "oil'" ...'. ......"".. j~ I~', li~' . ..I ... '1;,1. , ilit% 1,1~l::..1l..7iJlt~~i! !l~~,I~;;;;~;tii::a!t1;!-h~~mUU{i!mU.~I.iU},~ :~\:~i.$t:~~~ " ' er ., ~ I : .. Ie " , . I .1 , ' " ' ,'. ,. , P _ m 1 , " , ' .~ ~~ ql:i. , I , I.' . , .' " I, ,', , , . I' , !f \' ~ ~ ... ~~ ~ ~ ~ " .../ .... 'I~ c,' c' (j... , ' , " , ,',' ,1 " , ~ m~~ I -iJ' ~<IJI ,!-..r/D'v , ~.;J.' K" ' 1'-. \.1 __~~jJ ',' ~. rr' 'l-~__2._..~~~::1rJ< , . \ ' , " , '.,' . , " . P_01' ~ ~I, " ~ ~ - ,~~ fl ~ ~. ~.qy , fD'7 '1,.Q' .~.;J: Ii <J 11 ~!i 11 jfi~ ~w.~ I~ m~ p "$ " '2 'llll I' J ~' ~~ tJl% 1.~ljJ . , --" ----- , -- (~, ,rr: , , . -".::= ~,' ': J ' . ,,'1t-.~-. ,~:.. ...~~~:J~ ---. .. ...~.........~I(..~.._',~ ~~...:-l , I I . ! " , ".' , I. i -" '.. . , " ., /{L,n.',/,,: ',::,~ ':' ': , : ' ' " . ".'. .. :'1 ~:'.' , , ' ' .. l' T :T ,,' , " , " I . l ~ t1 . \ . , .~. 'I t '; ~ ' ,~1H , ~;.)- \.J L ,;, F H^W~Utl ~ L~I'> H ,!j ~j:? :';; 'Ii rj~' I l'j'\" l~" 1 fi '" ~ ..c/. \ l"'" ' ,t1 I :~" ' . r.J \ G 1 \ \ \;I I; ;1 (~ :.' 1 .., , . ,\~l 17 'rU~ . F., I , , (" 1 I \ l' II 1l ;,' ,., r, I I ~.'t~'I~?! ~~:,;', ~~ ~ ., I" ., . ... I. ... . '- 0, -. -, ~ J"' " I I , I R S51~1.r' 8" \ ~'I \ .,~ 'I) '.:r::'", .' , - ~, '\ s1. , .., ~H:.I ~ ~ B? r"j" "l:' - ~..... .. ~1;> ;"1' 2~} . , t , .9 R ;- ':;'~.Q) c:r r-, 'It I'" ..". N r, O'J-o, ~ ~I~I~ ~ ~ ~J:! V1 12 :J ~J j1j ~,~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I' 0 .:!f ~F~:!.~~~h::!: ~ iD I ,.,.,.., ~ ' UJ I t. I..J, ,J "I.-i , H}, j ; "1'5 I '15 "I,} ;:, \-1'" L... "'" ",..,1 '" ... ~ tv t; .., f-J t'-JD'J ... ~ l"j " [" " " .. '" . r.- r .... .... - - .... .!l1I :'1' :' ~, .. /rlfl ,I,,^ ,/I , ;. (j ,""'" " -., .ufo 0,' ,1/7 ~ :1,5 1111 r ;'.\ .1:.1 .1..'/1 .1~.~ I B 1 J Eo- , :~ / U) .1:1 H U1 ", ,;/1 ~ U . .i.i2 9 . , - ,1;/,1 :'0 ,I. ,l,H 1:J 19 I fir) II 111 108 I? ~ ::'G IJ 15 '" '" 't! " .... ~ CG 1~~ s mEE T ;, ~l 0> ~~ '=\1 ~ , I In (~,1 J '11 " ,,1Ci, "l "t. I~) . " ,,'t- \' <; :'.1 ? J().l #Ulj ,t:'". , JUAN .t-1 f;:' I ;., '" ''''I "", "'''' .. ~ : J ~ ~ /d 711 n S l I _ u. _, '-i ~l' __.....,5, I ~. ~ 2. ,,, .v ... , 0 I .0( \,,11../ ,~1 -- ~~ V1frilli' - ST. --.J/ .=~~~~;~~ ~ \: " ,~:=;~~==::. '- 11 . '-'E'-'~'---E.-------'-' .0 . ~ 7~ IRlmmgl~~;U-I~'!fimirb} ,-', ..,'1- ;;~~~; ;- ;; ::~;:IS~::;:=:} ~ ' -.. . -. .r~=E! =; =; E;:=:==:=:;:=::~ t,.} 1 9 10 :-::- :- -:=-:~-~€:-:-=. ' r.o ~~ "'lli1~~~~~Et~~ H:~;~?~;~=~~g;~~y ::!. :. ~ ::; ;:;I:;::I;;:~!=;;~~;~=~Ei=) - -:- -:--=-:~:~.==-:-:-==~:-: ~= s.n. 651 - .- - ~7t~1.-I~~I~' , . _.'_4 ~ .... _._ SR 651 " ... :. ~~ .. ~ - .. o , t-o, It} It} ~~ ;;: :" ... t- ::!. '" t;) ~ r; !) ;1 MO 4 .HI 5 5111 (i --.- ..--- 520 ' 7 522 . W [1 ::J - -..-. . - ... z 9 !i.~[) ~ t <( " I 5.1:' I I i I i 1 () ft,'ll 1 J11 1 9 }{J t", I ~ I., '~ i :! i ::!. RS 15 11. 12 '" '~ .. '.. ;!, 8 :; 'I :. 6 1( I 18 t;) " .... r... ~ .. STREET 'J I) ,~~I 15 .~,'!,~ 14 lIJ ".11 IJ :.> ~ ~ t;.u .( It l~ I I 2 'q I T - - ,t'; I.. ,- I ~ .. J ~~ ~:! 6 5 ~ <0) I~.U ~ I:!. '" _~ : 2 I 111'191 )() ~ i ~ 'r? ~ .... ... '" .. .. ~~ ~ ~: :!. 8 7 , W !::J " ~ 0'( n _ 'I 13 II" <:J i "'.. I:! . ~~ I 19 1.0 . ... I OJ 1:.' 'I:.' 1 15 i Hi :~~ 1 ~~ '" '"'-.. ........ ~ III 12 I ~ '~ I:" .. 17 VARIANCE REQUEST: N A ME: ~A'RJJ em- &~ll<', / Po \^..I eLL r sv#0,?L"10 PUBLIC HEARING DATE: ATLAS PAGE:zek?A SEC:J1 TWP:-1cl ~ CLEARWA,!ER CITY , '11. ~ I....; :,'l I ,lit HI:: 111rl,' II o o o ;t i:i ..J II vi r,',' I , GUlF GULF TO TO BAY BLVD. I~ :~ ~ ,~ ,It} It} 119:-2U~21 ! ....J.___ _ _ ' , (ill . .30 1\, BAY 1If' '" .., 'It) !~22 I ,5f1~ .5011 2J 5f,~ 37 fjf,'! "4 .51" 25 .~1? ;16 .$:>' 27 28 fi.10 I- I.m , J6 t-; 21 ' . - .. 1- J5.!:J... S,., !iiJ~ L... ..~~o r 1':,1' 3J I {i,;!. : _ 31.. '_.j~" J~ : :'i,1,~ I ~ , I In .~3~ 29 , " SIGNS s. RGE: IQ E. COMMISSION ~ . ~li 1J r 11:1' 11 ("1 i ' " ~, '- ':- --------1-" ,,'"' ~ .- \' ,~' ~ '0 L.s?..L1C] L:' ,~ i." ",,,., 'i?~1 ~ ~ , '. Jj,.i 0 -.." .::'/='Plt :~"'; : I ~, :~ C~I L~ " ~ r" ';; . \..' 0 . I "'" _, t'~' . ,= ff.' 1 <('0 ;J , "'!i -; ~ 0 \: ,,, :::.. l t , ~. '-~ .; '3 -:i J: f] Ii C'PI ~~~":l , I ~ ~' Dc-. '" 'I ' · 0 · C>> G , _j ;! ' I ~ ~"- - C- =1l"_' ~ ~-rt- n *-:::? , L'.Y )[ C ;:~q~:"" I < ,< ,--i 1 _ ' I ..'. \':';""~111 <.lUI.! ~ .,. . I '_. 'I '0 . , , '---, ~f-~L ~ ' "- '~~ 1 : ':\ .,~-~~U"""'" I L _ _._ _ ' if0q-'-~~-~~~~-j----r~l:c_ : ",' '=t~~~J;~1 ' 'l~f " v:,-,=Jk~J' ~l~J'~I~'_-~"~JHjll~l7-~---~r- , I u- ___ '...... / . m, , _________"-, ~_____ :~ ' , , , I , ' ," I ''-. ' ./,,- ~, ,'" "Q~~~)'~-____."'Y'l~' ~ </v1,.. _' lUJ. / h'I,>:o I ' ,~ ~ --~----..::!l '"" " , ' r - , -, Ut ~, I " , I~ 1'1 I c I, .--- "t , n r. -' ... " , ~ ~ , ' . . , " t. ' " "--- \ ' \ ! , , I' " JlJ -=-* 'd.. \ ' PO\VELL~ CARNEY, MOORE, BUCKS'& OLSON, P.A. , 4T'J'OnNEVS AT l.AW MARY JO CARNEY IlA"NtTf TOWUI DRIAN 7. ATZGERALO ONE PROCRESS PLAV,., SUITE. 1210 , JOEL B. GILES ST. PETEASRURG, FLORIDA 33701 JOHN CURTIS HUCKS , S. HELEN MOORE STEWART O. OLSON JAMES N. roWeLL ,DON DOUGLAS fUMSAV SUSANNA S. SHEA ' TEL!PHONE: 18131 B9D-901 1 MAIUNG ADDRESS, . POST OIll'1CI!. SOX lau ST. PETERSBURG. F1.0RIDA 33731-' &89 : FACSIMILE: 1013) 99Y-9014 January 20, 1994 VIA PACSTMTl.'R ONl.Y - 462-6488 Ms. Cynthia E. Goudeau, City Clerk City of Clearwater Rc: ' Request for Continuance of Sign Variance Hearing Agenda Item No. 21, MAS One Ltd. Partnership (Barnett B2nk), SV 9~-116, from January :24, 1994 until March 7, 1994 Dear Ms. Goudeau: This letter is to reque.~ that the hearing on the above referenced sign variance application for the Barnett Bank location at 600 Cleveland Street be continued from January 24, 1994 until March 7, 1994 as we have just received the Staff Report and Recommendation rega:rding our variance requcst. ,We need addItional time to exam1ne the issues ,set forth in the Staff Report and re-evalu,,'\te OUI request. , , Please do not hesitate to contact 'us if you have questions or need additional infommtion. " Very trUly YOUI"S, POWELL, CARNEY t MOORE, RUCKS & OLSON, P .A. , -- "- \ ---. ---: Ja nes N. Powell , JNP Jlj pc: Mr. Scott Shuford. Centrnl Permitting Director (via FAX . 462-(476) Mr. James C. Clark : Barnell Technologies CI\~I\ll'I,TtCU\III,n;aUIII(11 ' RECEIVED I ~,N 2.t' 1994 , I ;::OO/~O(' [f.J .\3.-.:m'.J 1'13.\IOd I'TOO G'llfi CTfi.\7, on:~T to;o~~Tn Clearwater City Commission Agenda Cover Memorandum Item # Heetlng Dote: :J \. II dlf/~L( SUBJECT: Variance to the Sign Regulations; 600 Cleveland St.; MAS One Ltd Partnership (Owner/Applicant); James N. Powell (Representative). (SV 93-116) RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Deny va~iances on property identified as Clearwater Tower, Lots 1 & 2, for failure to meet Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval, items (1 )-(8). o and that the npproprtate officials be authorized to execute some. BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting the following variances to allow the placement of an attached sign on the east face of the Barnett Bank office building just below the raofline: (1) an.area variance of 161 square feet from the permitted 109 square feet to allow an attached sign with a total area of 270 square feet, and (2) a ratio variance of .24 square feet per foot of building width from the permitted 1.5 square feet per foot of building width to allow a ratio of 1,74 square feet per foot of building width. The subject property is located at the northeast corner of Cleveland St. and N. Garden Ave., and is in the Urban Center (Core) zoning district. Pertinent summary information is listed in the table below. Information Proposed I Existing Permitted Type of sign Location/orientation of sign Area Ratio Attached Cleveland St. 270 sq. ft. I 80 sq. ft. 1.74/0.52 Yes Yes 109 sq. ft. 1.5 iliA iliA ilIA ilIA ~L ilIA Orlolnntino 00111: CENTRAL PER TING Co sls: Rovlawod by: Legal Budget Purchasing Risk Hgmt. CIS ACt-! Other Total Commission ActIon: o Approved o Approved w/condl t Ions, o Dellled o Continued to: UlOr DlI\lt: Current Fiscal Yr. Submllled by: Clt onnY Advertised: Dote: Paper: TAMPA TRIBUNE o Not Requ; red Alleclail Partin fa llotH;ed o /lot Requi red FUl1dinO Sour co: , 0 Copi till Imp. o Operating o Other ^ lIa elunonu: APPLICATIOil VARIANCE \.IORKSIIEET MAPS o Ilone Al11lroll,letlun Coda: ~ Printed on re~ycled roper SV 93-,116 Page 2 Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions: Subject property is developed with the Barnett Bank office building. The variance application regards the sign on the east face of the building just below the roofline. The applicant proposes to remove the existing 80 square foot sign, and replace it with a 270 square foot sign. The existing sign is a "can;" the proposed sign will be channel letters. According to code, using the sign area bonus for the exceptional sign height, a 109 square foot sign is allowed. ' The applicant contends that the permitted sign size of 109 square feet results in an unreadable sign and that the letters comprising the sign must be a minimum of five feet in height to be readable at the ground level. However, staff review indicates this is not the case. The sign on the west face of the building measures 100 square feet, and is easily read from a minimum of a quarter mila away. Further, the sign on the Sun Bank building located directly across the street from this building is 92 square feet, and is also easily read at a distance of a quarter mile. To allow a sign for Barnett Bank that is three times the size of the Sun Bank would clearly confer a privilege upon this applicant that is not available to others in the downtown. I r Direction North South SURROUNDING LAND USES ij Existing Land Uses Office building Sun Bank office 'building Parking lot Retail complex and parking garage East West The placement of a 270 square foot sign is not in character with the signage permitted for the downtown core and will detract from the architecture of the building and aesthetics of the community and Clearwater's downtown. Applicable' Variance Standards: To be eligible for a variance, a request must meet all eight standards for variance approval. Based upon review and analysis of the information contained in the application, staff finds that . the petitioner's request does not meet the standards. In particular, the following standards do not appear to be'fully met: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicablo to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performod without the benefit of a permit shall not be considored to bo situations which support the ,granting of a variance. , , . " \ , SV 93-116 Page 3 (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of ' the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in preceding recital "211 for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the applicant to secure a groater financial return from the property. , (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to oth,er property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the property is located. (6) The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community; substantially increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the value of surrounding property. (7) The variance desired will not adversely affect the public health, safety, order convenience, or general welfare of the community. . . ' (8) The granting of the variance desired will not violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. ' ~ Relevant Previous Decision's' by the Commission: ATTACHED SIGN AREA CASE ,# ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING REQUESTED/ACTION, DATE SV 91-01 2000 Drew St, Shell Oil 84.8 s . ft./Denied 217/91 SV 91-16 601 Cleveland St. Sun Bank 43 sq. ft./ Approved 8/15/91 SV 92-19 27001 U.S. 19 J.G. Penney 329 sq. ft.1 Denied 10/15/92 Co. SV 92-42 ' 714 Cleveland St. Trickol 70 sq. ft./Approved 2/9/93 Jewelers '. , \ ',' r . VARIANCE WORKSHEET CASE NUMBER SV 93-116 I STA,..OARDS FOR VARIANCE APmOVAL '- STAFF F1NDINGS I 111 The vtlllance raquested IIrlns from e condlllon which II Thll property I. Itmll/lrly slluated to other muhl..tory unIque to the propelty In quutlon and II nellher ordlnflrlly or bulldlng. In Ihe downlown cora. unlformty IIppllcable to the toning dlllrlct nor ccrellted by IIn action or actlonl of the property owner, pradecessor In tItle, Ilr thl< IIppllcant. Any ml.take made In the execution of a building parmlt or work performed wllhout the benefllafa , pllrmlt .hall not bll canlldllred to be s1luallonl whIch IUpport ' , the granllng of a vllrlance. 121 The partlculllt phYllcelsurroundlngl. shape or Tharels no hllrtllhlp applloable to tha petitioner. In the event topographlclIl condltlonl of tha property Involved and the Ihe VIlrlancas ale approved. tha Barnel1 Bank would be sulct applicatIon of the plovlllons at thll development code eUthollzed a .Ign threll Urnes tha Ilze ,of tha Sun Bank sign would Inuit tn an Unnecellary htud.hlp upon tha app1fcant. directly acroll the Itreet. 131 The varhlnc~ II the mInimum necellary to overcoma the The vllllance requestlllllrll lubstllntlal, lInd thera II no unnecellllry hardshIp referred to In preclldlng racllal "2" fOI hardlhlp or unlqua condlllonl to wltrrnnt approval. , the pUlpole at meklng leasonllble u.e at the land. 141 The requalt tor a varl/l'nca II not baud prl';'arlly upon the, Abunt any haldshlp or condlllons unIque to tha property, II dellre of the applicant to ucura a graater financial return for eppears that the variances are baud primarily upon a de lite the property. of the eppllcant to IOcure a grent,er IInllnclal relurn from th? ' proparly. 16! The granting 0' thIs variance will nol be mllte.lall., The grllntlng of thlllO variance. will relult In a Ilgn tor the detrlmeJ'llal or InJurlou. to other property or Improvementl In Barnatt Blink that I. three tlmes the Ilza of tha Sun Bank the neighborhood In which the property 11 located. Illln. The result would be IIlpaclal prll/Ilege conferred upon this appllcant. 10} The granting at the verlance will not Impair an adequate The placement of a 270 .quAro 'oat Ilgn I. not In' character .upply of light or ventilation 10 adJacont proparty, detract with other .lgnl perm1tted In the downtown and will delrnct tram tha appenrllnca of the community, lub.tantllllly Increasa 'rom the archllecture of the bulldlna and the ae.thetlcs at the the conllestlon In the public lIueat"clncreale the denger 01 oommunl\y ftnd Clearwater', downtown. t1ra, IIndang.,r the public lafety In any wIJY. or lubslamlall., diminIsh OJ' Implllr thll value of surroundIng property. ' , 171 The vnrlenc/l dellred will not Adversel., afflict the publlc Allowing a larger sign for this property than Is allowod other health. lafety. order, conllOttlence, or gllnatal welfote 01 tho downtown propeUlu would dlSlupt tho crdelllnellS ftnd equity community. at the City's Ilgn compll/lnca progrllnl. 191 The grantrng of the verlllnce desired will not violate the The .Ign regullltronl werll lldopted with the Intent of ganerllt Ipl/It and Intent of thl1 davelopment code. enhanclna tha vlsuat quality at tha City'. IlIeet. IInd landscapa In orda! to P!oto<:t the value of propeUle. IInd the well.belng of 1he 10cIII tourIst orIented aconomy. Tha grllntlng of thl. vllrlnnce appears to ba In vlolatlon at thl. Intllnt. " c" " . , r:o,OO :;l-- CITY OF CLEARWATER Receipt #rJJJ(n'h SIGN VARIANCE APPLICATION. AMENDED SV# '1"1, ,I IllLL PROPERTY OWNER(S) NAME & ADDRESS: REPRESENTATIVE(S) (If any) NAME & ADDRESS: Mas One Ltd Partnership, an Ohio limited partnership Barnett Bank of Plnellas County (or Barnett Banks, Inc.) % Mas Property Oorp. % James N. Powell. Powell, Carney. Moore. Hucks & Olson, 600 Cleveland Street P.A. Clearwater. Florida Barnelt Tower, Suite 1210, One Proqress Plaza St. Petersburo. FL 33701 TELEPHONE: (813) 441-3131 TELEPHONE: (813) 898-9011 ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 600 Cleveland Street, Clearwater, FlorIda NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPLICABLE): Barnett Bank ZONING DISTRICT: UCC LAND USE CLASSIFICATION: ODD LAND AREA: loS~~MoL LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: See attached le~al descriptIon PARCEL NUMBER: 16 I 29 I 15 I 16528 / 000 I 0010 (This Information Is available from your tax receipt or contact Plnelloo Co. Property Appraiser's Oftlce at 462-3207. Ir more than one porcel number, attach B'/a x 11 Inch sheet) DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY: North: Barnett Bank drive thru facilities & office South: Sun Bank/Office Bulldlna East: ParkinQ lot and office complex West: Relall & Garden Ave publlx parklnq QaraQe VARIANCE(S) REQUEST: 1. A variance of 161 square feel of altached siQnaae to allow a total of 270 square feel. 2. A variance of .24 square feet per foot or burrdlnQ width to allow a mtlo of 1.74. REASON FOR REQUESTING VARIANCE(S): (Refer to Standards for Approval, noxt page) 1. The permltted SIQnaQB size results In an unreadable sian which causes a competitive dlsadvantaQe to the appUcam. 2, The property is located In the downlown urban core and the heiQht of Ihe buildlnQ is such that any identification siQnaQe . placed at the top or the bulldlnq needs to be at loast five (5) feet in helQht to be readable at Ihe Qround level. 3. The variance requested Is the minimum necessary to allow the slQn 10 be readable. 4. The orantlnQ or tho variance will not hnpact delrlmentallv anv other Propertv In the neiollhorhood. nor will it Impair adtncenl property's 1I0ht and vonlilation, It will nOl dotract from the appoarance 01 tho communIty or Impair the valuo 01 anv surroundlnq properly. 5. The reC1uostod varlanco will nol violato !l18 (Ioneral spirit and Intonl of tho slon ordinanco (#5257-92). . 't.j. 'I ., '. ('nnn/II IF/) nil nnwn~r r.ll1r .~ I , 'I ~ , STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance shall not be granted by tho City CommissIon unless the application and evldenco presented clearly support the following conclusions: (1) The variance requested arises from a condition which Is unique to the property In questIon and Is netther ordinarily or unIformly applicable to the zoning district nor crealed by an acllon or actions of the property owner, predece~sor In tille, or the applicant. Any mistake made In the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permtt shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance. , (2) The particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property Involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result In an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant. (3) The variance Is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to In preceding recital "2" for the purpose of making reasonable use of the land. ' (4) The request for a variance is not based primarily upon the de'slre of the applicant to secure a greater ffnanclal return from the property, ' ' (5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrfme'ntal or InjurIous to other property or Improvements In the neighborhood in which the property Is localed. ' (6) The granting of the variance will not Impair an'adequate supply or light or venUlatfon to adjacent property, detract from the appearance ot the community, substantially Increase the congestion In the public streets, Increase the danger of fIre, endanger the public sarety in any way, or. substanllally diminish or Impair tile value of surrounding property . (7) The variance desIred will not adversely affect the public health, satety, order convenIence, or general welfare of the community. ' , "" ,/---"'\ \ . \ (8) !he, granting of the variance described wlll not violate the roneral SPJlt and Inten~,r,~,~I~ ~ment code, SIGNATURE OF PROPERTY OWNER (OR REPRESENTATIVE): - ..~./ - '-.:... ' SUbscribed and sworn to (or artlrmed) before me thIs 1. 7 th day of [)ecernbeJ~Ap..1gg~ by Dennis E. Dean, Partner MAS Properties, Cor~. Print Namo (Includo pas/lion and llama of company if appffcablo) , who Is personally known to me and/or has produced nersol1i'111y (Typo of /donlillcaliorrJ as Identification. STATE OF FL IDA, COUNTY OF PINELlJI.S 1 ,I ~ i! ('I, t li/(111 '-, -(S1p Il/Uro) .~ 'd- , ~ --1 (1)~1I J . i l.I (' tt;) L I . 'iJwyr;..... RODiN t~1. TUCKER No ~i~~~ikk;:~:' (Name of Notary typed, printed or stamped) \ ' A:\AI'I'lJCA lION 1l00l (jdl " ' :" c ~ . / ~ >' . .. . ' , , , I' , I, ! . , rr1 L ~ .U -.J 6 EC' 0= I ~ I I , .tj Ri ffi '~ ~ l ~' -z 75 ' ~ "mgr g <:)' l ' ~ ~ . <r fu ~ ~- ~ ~. .~ .t ~ \\ \S) :z: . G '2 5 "':::l, L) 'Z"Z .~ ~~ ~s . ~ "~i w ~~ u ~ ~~ ~ ~&~t " I I I , . In' .', I~" it' ' ..;t &' . ~ . .~ - ,z "-"', ~, 1< ~ .~ ~ '.' ~ cS!:=..- ~ N Hi ~' ~. Us::5 ill ~~:? -..1- -z N W. ~ '4~ 7 ~ in 3 < ',Ul ' ~ ~ i ~lli ~ ~ ~. ~~. ~~ ~ .~. ~ ~~' ~. &lffi .~ . ~ L ., '.~~ ~ ~~~' 'Ii ~ o ~~. ~~:i i Q ~~m J [E I ~~. ~ i~ ~'; ~.~ ;n E ~ m lJ\~ ~ Ii). ~ 3. :t ~~ Q ~ 3 u ~ J ~ fli ~~, '-J ~ ':J ::J ;: frI"Z ...' ~ ~ '& ~~ '~~ ,~~ _fD ?: v Q~ ~ ~:t: ~ 'x :J~ .9 ~ \7'\ t()!S -z~ 3 , ~~ ~ ~!:'J~ll) ~m ~~'l' o:~ . ~ ~ ~ &~~ ~~ ~~ ~"ill;1.l ~ 15 ~~ :I: _1 (J\ II 1'\ 1ll ' \J ~ ~ 8S 3:.J 11 ~':JI,\) Il~, \11 ~ ~ ~i ~Rl li) ~.a~ ~~~ ~~~~'ith1 ~~ ~~~~ 8~~\~ ~\ ~ ---w ~ .. ~D ~~\~ '(J 'C) .. p ~ ~ 5!~~ ~31i ~~~0 51 ~' ~~~,~.I :~. l~~l;~i ~ ~~ ' .' , , , , . . , , , ~ . ~ . " , , , ., , " . . ' . I\-. . , , , , , . . I ' f \ . ~ . ii '. '" . i: ,:',' i ',' ',', ' ... , ' " . . ' " " <, ,', . \'. , .. ~ l: '~ ~l . ,." : .' ~~, tL , ~~ . ~ , .. , i(iaf!" 8. , , , ',' ' ~:-:. ;.ft- ___. _ ,__'_' ...,____._____~.___:_..;__.;.____ '__.___.. I ", , ~__-~~] ~;. ill g ~ ~ 8'.~ ~'~ 6t ' ~, " ',' -F, ~. ~. ~ ~I' ~ .-.:.. ~ ~ ~' ~ ~ >C , .' I -- - - .- - -- - - - [U~, " , ',' , '. ,: -- -- --, - - - - :- n. 'u~ ~ . ", ' ,I . - = = = ' -- .- = = ~ Sf II ':"'" ',' , ' '" ~: I~' ~~' ~ ~. .~~' t~ ~. ~" ~'t; ~ ~1~J . I, ~l,' __ _. ._ '_,'_ _. __ _ _ ~ ~() l' <.. 10}. ~~~ I, - (Q~ - "r \l \\M -- - - - - -- --, - --;4 ~ . - '.~ G ' --, '[j @ [3 13 I~ ~ EJ [j [3 R .. 2 -'I ~ , .El~ 1=1 EJI=J 313 EJ B[~P~~ aLl ~ ~ ' :. ,I ~ g ~ ~. ~ g ~ ~ ~ - ' i i~ , " ,- . ,I . . . I I , . ~ ...o~e~~ ) , . '. , , , , . , , . . ' + I' " , . .' ~ , . , , ' \ ,c .. . . ~ . , ".J' " ' ,', . j ~ j " ' , ' I .' '.;. , ' . '. l' " 1 ' , , ;- , , , , ' I ", ,I ~ . I : " +. .; ~ .. '.' I , . I .. .i' ~ ; '" ~ I " . , ~ ". '~ 1'. , 1;' ,.f', ':. . c . , t ( . . t , , . ) . , I . . I " ~ j c ~ . 1 . t . . ',,:. ,Jr:.: ': .;.' . . ~ .,.... .: ; I ~ : ':. ~ . , I >., I .' I r I . .1, .. 1 . " ", ~I / . . , . 4" , ~ . , " I. " , ' " , I . . . -1"." \ . " , , , , . , l , " I ' I + . . ~ ." . . . " r :t. " > ~ , " " , , ' ,) , . I < ~ . , ' , , " " " '.< "I. I , . . .:.. .." .~,~. , " , " " , ... ~. . :. " <'. I . ~... . . , " . ' . . ~t (, . . .' .' , : ~ . , " ;. 1 . c, . , I ' > ' , ... ,~() "0 -~ '-~ I 'ot I " ; . '~ ~' ~ ~- '~ ~. ~. ~ ....- -- -- - '- - - - -...... ->- - - - - , ' , I ~ < : 'I ~ rj III , ' ~ N . PrG' t"!J =....-lIO;-"'~.E.,1 r '. ,.' l~j " . j 0-15;' \ . II I , " . "I '. 1 . . , " < ~ 'I>" C . it' ~ . , ' i. , \ ., ,; . ., \ . ~ ,\" . '1\ ' 'ill' 'C-: :F . " ' r.: l 'fz ' ~" . ;:r ;Z' , I'U, ~H~: 'q . . l\~ ~..: K'\\(.\ , ~I.IJ\ -:; I ' ~~~, '(" 6) z '6 ~2 g r- Jl ' -J ,~~'~ ' ~~'m 1- i ~ ~ ~ : \[. .~ t" t , . . , ' ;: , ::~ '~1d ?~ i~~I: ,f.1l~~~ ' -~ ,~ +\ " ,\ -'--.c-' ''"' " " -- . -. .. , , , l::J. nq 17.-,. . " I , ~ :1' .. 'Z ' .. ~ U) '.. I ~ , . ; , ~ " ,. . , " " ' , I , ' . It. ,.. , "." , ' :.':.11' ,I " ; , : ~ . . . ',' " i , t. . ~. , , , !; .' . . , t . . '" >"< 't, , ' . . ,. . .~ !. ,. i." ,.... '.1 4t.. . r' . ' I" ~., f : i, . , , . , ., " ' , " , . . ' I _ . ' . \ ~ I . . v" . , ' , l ; , , ." , . . \, " . " . " " , .. . . '. .l i. . " L:.. ' . " " ffi-r , :,' ., . \' . . . ," .. I 1 :. ' -l ., . ~ , ":;> , ....... .~. . , 3la \ ::lo . ..~~,' ;' ,tn~' , mp. ,"'----... ".~ , , , , , . , , . . : ~ ~ 1 . , , ] @ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- '~ --- .' , , 11 ~,~[~_., II -'I-~-- ." . t.. , , ' , - - , , . , " "S (,' yGf)\3\ . . " t '! L i .. , , ., , , ~ .... -. . , I , , ' } ;. d, ',' j. , " , . ~ ~" .. ~ .. ,; 'f \ -i$..L... ~ '. .... . .f " " ' .- .L I >, " " !, , <.: t ~. : ~. ., t ," . ~ " :. , , " , , .; , , , , ,I' -,', " . . " ,,\ , . . . ,. ~ " l n, " ....::.:~r:......~.. " ,< \. , ' N.EuMIat.'S .S'.r;f!C,{;" r /O() 'J . , ~- " " " I I I I I' . ' . , .f " ., ~ I I' I I + ~ 1- - -,- gtP .' . , I ~ ti 7> - h 'i ~T\ i~r a ~w ~' 1____ ::; .' (frJ & 'd r - q: .' 6' 0 " ' , Z.I r , , :'~ ~~ ~ ~t i~ z.. , \"-111 )r ~~}. d~ li~ ~0 (i! ~V, ('" ..- I 'r ~guJ J~ ,~dt 1m 'a~l '~~I ,~~ I. 'z.\l! I I /. " ,. 1 J. , ' . I _ '---- ' :( , ~ " .-! W2~1 ~~~I Z:ll$ " ~r cJl ~ ~'T__~T_~""""'''''''_._~__'''':''''''''__ ;}~~'~",!-~.'~''''f ..~~., h.. +~ .... "----'... " ". ~==,::,=:::::,::";::,;",:~::;:,.=:",-",,,,,",,..:~.',;=j-' ..'..,... .,.~ .'.-~""IT'" ~. -~~):;-'.. . " C' t I.. j , j: I. ,o1.',~J ,',',('1: it,.' " " ", ", 'l I, " ' ., " , ~,t , " " , , , .' " i , '. '. 1\ , ' , " .f '., , " 0\ .' ' " ." ie,. \ .~.. ~ . .~ , " l, , . ~ ~I , .1,' . " " , 1 I.. . '. :.1 " , , ~H"'I ,..~.....-.: ;:":.~'i_~l~.)\."" \"(~I,;,,!:<. , c " " , " :., '. ~ . . 0 / t~ ; " " , t l~ ,~~' l !t ~1l ',~ffi2 ' ,.I~~~ l,mam ..'.: . 'I ./~.7,1:/S ClA'lJ7:7.19.1::> , ' ~"'~, -- -,,-:,"",:....~~,..,.,~ .~;-..,..~'i ,,4'-- -, ==------:---:-:-~----: ~ - -~ ~< " . ,', " -. ..__.--:---,.,-~_.!..:~_~______..:.:..-:..-"':'__~,.. H. ':" " co , .~, ' .~,~~ ,-" ;,:, ~ rt" . (,) f:~ I'-In ~ilJ Llp' j~ , r fil -\, _~-z~' < lb - z , ~' '~ii1 "-,.- '. , J. " " .'l I I .1 r " l {>c I. ."; ft' :. ,: <~ t'e i'~:i > -, ,. :~~ l~~ I~~,. ,d , " ,', . r ," " " <' (I. " ,', , c t ~ , " JJ '"i, <I. ~ m~ t I., 1 ;ih ;,~p l~}?~ ~~~ (, I' 2 ~ ~~ q1i ,} e, .' ;,\, ,.e ',' :?1 - - Sf ~ 'ro t , 1? o/l I , f f,' .. -- -:-1 - __I )i ;( '~ : ~ I ~ , ' I, I I Ie, I I t 1 .,. ,. r, "()~, " -' "':7;Y~S S'~y;; /iJ'I7/r .7"/'1' , '. "\ . :~'f~ . '. ( 'e " .\ 2116 II./l)'} C (C )/'2/02 fG I 16 a . .- 1rJ' 1 7 ~ J 5 30 ~~ .... '.. .!~ lL ',URA SffiEf.T = t ~'rj _.. .~~~j' , 'A' E' .n · ":t II~ !I 10 11 A' I j ~.: ~':t: -~' .~. '~ :. .'.,', 'I']!I ::.:.. ... .:?,~ ~~;'. ~ ~ ~.~ "I "'I~ ...... .." ~ ::l~J Itl Cl. EVELAtW r J I-r'''rl 6' I - ~!I I ~ ~ ~ ;~j 8 . '" ..... ..,. .. IV I !J 11,1 J "l 1 "" J I. 12 ~' .~ w ll~ Yll 'II 2J ,_;~.rn E ..... ...-..... ._-~ 22 ~~ 9 10 :'1 )J~i ' \ I,. :.!(J , 1/ 5 VI ,,0 0: lY. n .( J: SI9P.. 10 j I: :fl.~r'~'.. .,,\~, 'f f'4' f"H't~J\.I1 "'1 ('I~ ~ \n In Inl.t1'.o'I. 1.('\ to 10 _. - ,\ j lJ'~' ...1"',... u..... "... ~ n .JII1~ .1) .... ~ . .~ ! I r.~l' l f', ) ,~{ _.... ...,J. tJ ~ ~.III J 1 9 1 I (J c, ,I J ' I li'~ ' I CJ ~. hI 15 ' I ~ ;:J '., <1 IV w. ~ 1 1 1 I I J' I I ?:' 'I ;:J~ < 19 (lI ~ .. - -. . . - . ~ GROVE STREET [''1 I J ':? I · _ ~ C], t, ,. ,. ' " I~~ . " In _I . 115 , J II. :. -~' l5"" ~" 1~ J; 'J.,I~ G"- ;:lIt' & I I C; ~ [() to ~ ~ ~ ;: ;:. StREET ~ . ~~ '1 ~ ' 5 '1" 1 t. .1 F!: 23 z .. "0' '.~n.f''-t~t. r. \"P1 ef' ...~ f1') 'n - .:~, 'i'o '<1 ~__~ II ~ (\~) oj }:.! 1 NAJ.J, MOHTONSON " '" r~ ~u ." 1- ~ (~ 4) hI '~ ~6 2_ld~ !J iO DJ ... ;: , ~ t t /III I ,', ". l7 ~ B I VI ~- 41 lY. H '-.. 0 372 l.. H-' , 'j \ 1~ J ,'II ~:! 'I 'tJ, l7, ;:~ '!.. z . 0 (3) Vl f- m ZI Ii ~ 0( z I ~ ~u - ;.: r + ::!! ~ t. Ot t.. ~ ,.. r-~ I'- ;:;: 5 I" J :.! ~ :- ~-Q[~ ~fi . ~ 1 . 15.~. ~ SlHEE T 'WI" . ;~,:! 'tY 0l. ~l I 10.' Ill...V "1 'J I ~a;' ; . - '1.J 'I~'~~ . l .'" 11 11 .. 1/5 ;: p'"'~"(' 5) '10 11Z y :_ '. . ~ c~ , I I; J II /111 c; ". '- Q ... " '1 ,/ ;C. ;1 ., J " ' ~ ~ " 6 1 Itl I' (',} ,0 ) (6) (5) .. i() cr ~ 0( 1 \ I IITu~ \ t~ ! ,. 11 10 4 Iii " '" .. ,. ,', on L ( " ~ ( fi ) 11/01 VARIANCE REQUEST: SIGNS N A ME:, MA?7 01J fZ / rbb.\ZAl e:rr L po y.J el.,L SV#.96"-'i1& PUBLIC HEARING DATE: ATLAS PAGE:le0e)SEC:~ TWP:-Z'1 S. RGE: I'? E. ~ CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION ~ G , t~ u (0 ) <> ", 1.1 oQB), 17 IH '" ~. /lJiI ~, ~ r c-, ... ~' '> l.AllI A .. ~ -, .~ :I. ( ~) . 2 (5 15 ~ II - Q 3 90 1\ t.{'. ,1 1'1 1 II 1J I~ '0 ~.') (C) 10 II 1\1 C) t',l - .... '-11 V'J'''' ....) ~~~ 01 f'.C\II~ "ll.()lr) ... ~~ ~ i..., r-.,,..,,,. r'-rr) '0 U) 1(1 If) '.1 'II H. 60) '" ~~a .. -r"' ._ 2j ~11 ~. .." "i . '... (4)~G '0 ~ i,- . 1'\ (j 'j' I \';:'; 00( ""--1 .(.. uu L -ti'" "' tu ({.,l v'" "UJ 0 " ~r_..5 L~, . ~~.~ ." :;: ~*q; -" ""j~' ~' ~,.- ..,1' . '..;,' f;i;jO to 4~fJ) ~ "'~ ~~~I ~ ~ .nt.l~w: / [} ,', , J '2 1 .. . .I, . ._. ~ld) 1~-;1 u ~ .: ~, ~,n 10 11 1 1.,11 .... a ... -Ji ~ ~ J. ~. ~'I Ii:', 117r'" . , E! !J .. ;;; ~:. ". PAHK , , /0' -, I 1 , I / ~I \ ~ , j 1 , "t : . l. , , I ' , ' ... -- ~_.-. -...,. I .-/ . . .~ ~ J > . " -.' ';~: ..'! . ~.. ~ . .' c ',c + i. j:;..'\o'~/ ., L 1 ( I..,,~, ~ : t~.:'\' \ri'::.':.~'.r ~.':'~ :. f>':' .~;i .~::.~:, .. ) ~ ":. !'C. :..~: ~ .;, .. . ~ , i . J . . ,. ~ ~."', . . \. ',,:~.:,h.:'>,~~~':;:,:',<, :1" '.'.,,' k <.: :' t . ~ ,.. ". ". ~ ~,I' " >:. "t:.~! ~.(.'. ;i:.o'+J..'),,:~ :~",,~: '.: "" ~ ~ 0 '. c '.1; . I \~ r"o;' ,T, ~ <.'. _'; .-: ~ I IJ . .' .', \ ..' ".1" J<; ;", ,,:,::;Z~;,:':,> i> ,:' ;",' ('::\': !,,:'~ .r ,I J:,I,",J." " fi.L~ 3;.1 ij. O!' c 'L'. fe,'" " !,'~,:;.,:~,':.~",,: >, ' ~ ; ::c j..; . . !;{:.,:?f'!':~.:."'.; ':" ,';: '". c:; t~,'t:i::::"': .,'. ", :",,', ','., '.' /:" , \ " ',,' , ~~':;,:c.:'~.'~" ':~! ., ~ ~ . . (:... .; . ~ ;',", i... f , . l " ~~ I c ~ 1 ~ I.': ,':' . ; \. ' ~~:2"~ J ~ ":,"/ "I. . ~ :' <.~ i ! ; :.. , , " j. t.:\ :~<. ~t ,. t. i:',. ~ ' t > .~~::~:'.':~ . 1/; ~, '.... 1: i.' !'. r"":,' ~") ; ~. ~ ."' " .,,' '. ., ~ :'~L:~'!'.. ct . ... tC .' ' ..," . t,',' :, : i~c' ~ . t, , ~: ~:~ <. ~" J ~~"... ',I , .! ~ j" ~ : ,~' ~ I ~.~ ,', I" : L: /~.~ ;.' ,,!-. ... i: i', ',' ,', I : \~!, ~ C ,: : ~ ." tt . '.. (~ 'I, .l' cic" .'.. r. ~\ \:~ [;}::," E, ~(/' :':.' ,l:' 1 ", ~ ..' ,< 1, , ~ ~ \, oj. " .~ ',< ,~ . : ',;':,/,' ~ ~ ; , , ,~ ",, :- ~ ;', c \ .' " ,:. u~..... I .~O~ ., , ! , . " " " ;', ..'.,:' )1 I , , ,. : :11 .' .' I , , ,:J " . " ' "..i.'. ,; ., . f" , . ", " ,-, ", 'fi, " , , , r .: r , I , I /. 0 t ~: . " I .... <, ,,' " '>.J , " . ..' ':\ " ' .,l j ':> i ~." " . t: '. , ~ .1 , \ ;, '.:. ...' ,j' ;1 \' ;f\ , . . :~ I.', !' ..f.,-,,- r' j..", ." ,~~~ ' ; ,: '. " : i, ". c. > t ~, '\;, : ~ , " ,'" ~. ~ I '; I,. ... l. " .... 1..~ ' ,','.':t " { , . }~> ~ '. I.' ~' . .~}\. " ":J . C ., " ';'..:: . "fr' . ~ I ' , ',. , ~.. + ~ :,' " , , 't, . ( . ~. " .,: . , ~ " , .t", . ~ ~ ~ .,: . t';. . . t ,~' ! '!.' , ' ,'~ t. j", . .. ~.. :':'.1+ , , " , ! ", '. , ,'t~, , ,. ;- < ~.:/'~ ~~.~..!. i ~ .. ,"'..- "i': ,': .~. . I" t....: ' : .,l" ',r "~' .,;., u., !.:J( : "If" t. ~'.: '"0\ ,1.I'i; L :' '. 4.... ~ ~.~: . .',. . ~ ! '.,'; Ii'.... , .... '~ " , " , ' ~; ~ : I,": , " , ,', .' ~ .....' ", 'I " .\ ," . , ,'. . . ; r ~ 'I ~ " .:.>1 'I '" 'i,: '..; ~.. ",;' , " .~. " ',I , ' I' :/: ., . ' .' ',' \ . . ". : i~ '." .,~ > ~ : ~ ...:.". " ,)', '" ,:1 '. ." .",1', ,,' , ' , . : r , , ,.} ~ .' , , " i, , , ./ :' ,,:.1,,1 . , " 1,: _, I "..' C ~ , , .. ,,;., ., 'J: ,,' . :. ~I " ,1 '..i . ~ : 1 .;} ,:r 1 ~ " ~ \ : ~. : ~ \i ; > .' ,,' " ." ': ~ . . .:' d ': ..... .. ,I' '.. ...... .t,5. I' . ~ . . , ~"' , .1'. ." " ~ . , . " '1" ,\. '! " .' .:l I: ,~ ," r ~):.. . ". '" " '" f: ,~ :- ' . .'\ ' '" , . , '. , ~, 1 . ""1., '/},' " ., ,', i I' , , :1: .1: , I 1 ~ '\ C f. I;;. 'v " , .",' ~. ." \ ,', . ,~,' ;', > I.', .. ,\, '" . ~ : I',t. '. .,1 " 'Ic' t. . , . . ~ ~ i ,~ . .: I " '" ,<, , / .. T '."""" ' . '..' . '. .~ ,.;': ~!. :' \ ~ p ~ ~, ~ . , .' , , . : . .~, ' ..,-' , ' , " ,r' ': > " ,. . , , ., . ' .:.: ~ ~ ::\~::" ' " . 1, ,I " .. 1 < " Ic, / " . ,. '.' '. , ' .' ,. ~. , :~ ': ' " '; . . f' " , " ,', .' , ' .\ +';' ~:'AGENDA' j'.:f. ;, ,I.:,: " i :" " '. . : ,\ . ~ \ , :' ,1"' " ". :;. :'1' ~ l" . i " I, \1 " " .: ., ,I ~, "l" L >, .':' .: " ,,\ :, ,I " '1' " ' . 1.' , " , " " ,i , " , . I \~ ! .J t'" :"1' . L , , " .': ,i '; I' I' Cf4, ! '. 2~ :,' i,. 'DATE .,1 -- .,'j " l' - , , , , :1 '" , . " I, , ' , " " " ITEM # -1 " " ; ~ " " , II . , I ,. " Ii , " ;' , " , " .~, ' < I, , ,f , . < ~ " " ,.' \, '" \ ! , .' f , \' " ,', , J . II. 'J ~ " , , " " :,.; ,I. , . ~.' .", "}. '1.' " !' .' , ~.l . T: \..~ I ~ I" "1.' , ," ~ " " ' ", ,1 .t.c ., ll. . ~> -: .', . .r I ':Ii' ',1 '.' ':\1... ,). ,!.:' " '" .', I, ., " ..1', .1 '" " i ": I '.) c . ~ .' " ! j '~, ': f', f, '" 'c {, " ,; i"' :.) . " , t \. . ~ ~ . t ,,' :' ' ~. . ~ ~ ., , 'I',' , ! . . ,~ . " " " ' t' " ~. .. ',' ., ), ,') . . " \, , ~ , ~ " , ' , , . " .to>. " " ~ ~. : I .:. " , ~ ,0 ~ . .~, . ,~ ~ ~ {, I" , ' , , , , , -I t , . }',:'/, ,:', " ; , .', > I . ~{ " , " J, , ' I. .. , r I ' '; ,... " , ) !' I ". . l . ....~ < d < +, ~. ~.' > .' .." 1-' . ~.; '. . i \. . .,'T" , , , " . ~ . ~ b' i. . . 4F;;A~ . 'la~/CfLf , ., , . CITY OF. C LEA R W ATE R lriterdepartrnental'correspondence " J . TO: ci~Y,Commission' . SUBJECT: Mary K.., (Sue) Dial1a, Assistant City Clerk Z7t.J-- f ' ' Reconsideration 'of' Sign Variances" SV, 93-25 Grandy's SV 93-31'Work America, Inc. FROM: , . DATE: January 10, ~994' ,The 1 above refer'enced requests' for sign variances were denied 'on October 29, 1993. Neither the applicant n9r the repr8sen~ative of the applicant was present for either,case. .( " 1 l L In ca~e SV-25 (Grandy's) the applicant and the repr~sentative"Todd , I, Pressman, were s.ant notice of the, l:1ear ing on october .18th ~' A let~er was received from the applicant'~ representative on November 23, 1993, informing us that he 'had recently relocated his office; ',' I hot.,ever, did not specify the :exact date of thE?; cr.<1nge. . ,In case SV-93-:31 '(\'lark America, rnc,') the 'applicant was s,enta notice of the hearing on,octbber 16th; however, the representa~ive, carlt9n'Ward, ,inadvertently, did not rec~ive notice., . , , , , Both representatives in, the above ca'ses are asking that their requests for a variance be reconsidered. I am attaching a copy of the correspondence we have received from Mr~ Pressman and Mr. ~lard , along with a copy of the minutes reflecting ihe action~ taken at~ ,'the October 29, 1993 ~ign variance~meeting. I have scheduled: discussion of these requests for reconsideration for the January 24, 1994. , IE you decide to reconsider the requests, they will be agendaed for the sign varia~ce meeting' of March 7, 1994. " . ' .d " Attachs. , , co: Betty Deptula, Interim City Manager M. A. Galbraith, jr., city Attorney Scott Shuford, certral Permitting Jeff Kronschnabl, Community 'Response .,. . " I": " , , ,.I . . , " '. , ' " ' , , , , 'I , " i 'j' , "J " ,,1 , , , , . . " , . ' '. ' " ,: I t, f;,>::~ ::, , . , ! '.'.. " , " " , , ",~ ,,' . -'I'PRESSM.AN I, Govornmental Affairs and Public Relallons 'S'o~;)' '..,.- & ASSOC.IATES 5VC;3-:J,s U R G E N T M E H 0 TO:' Jim Polatty Steve Dougherty Charlie' Ze~terberg FROM; Todd Pr~ssman tv,. DATE: 11/12/9'3 ,t.Y . J~ (, ': RE: No Notification of Variance Heeting!, .. . ~, I am'listed on the application as the representative. , I would hope' that the review can be re-schedtiled. ' , ...~ .' .... Thank you. \ ' , L. ~ .,.,.,. . " .. " Cr'1 ,--- J .. ~" "..... .. . ., ' ... .\,; u. .j 0 !i(....\ "" , , l:. ,\ \ .' ,) J ~ , , ../ \ " , . . ~ ~' 0 .... , , . , , . " .....-... " I " \ .' " , ' ,) .. , :.' ' .. ., z 2B810 us HlghwaV l!). N, · SUllo IIJOO · CrOi1fWalor. FI!2!.!oa .34621 , Phone a 13. 726.VOTE '86B:I) . Fax 813.706.3975 · OlgllDIPagll, B 13.253.641 a " , " I '. .. ~ , " " , ' < ' " j '.." I . ." ;: , j ,C , . \ ~ I ,'. < ~. > ; , ,,' ~. > -, , '. :pl' ':". ~ .' '. I ..I.~. ~ T' C J , 'I ", ~ " I , I , C PRESSMAN & ASSOCIATES . .' I . ~v q 3-~:J' RECEIVED N 0 V 2 9 1993 CITY CLElX,DEPT. , , C Governmental Affairs and Public Relations' Cyndie Goudeau . . Ci ty Clerk, ,City of Clearwater " , P.O. Box 4748 Clearwater, FL 34618 November 23, 1993' I , ' Dear Mrs~ Goudea: " , . ' . , I I . , This letter is to, ,make you aWl?re that I have recently , ,that s.everal pending petitions before ,the ,City can be , , " 0c:..;...,Il,"'I,.i, The, 'following. petitions, -SV793-2-51 SV ,93-65, SV92-99, SV 93":'48 '" with my' former address, on Hillsborough Aven~e~ in Ta~pa. ", changed my address, and my hope, corrected 'with the proper, address. , , , , arid 93-89 are all listed l' rec"e~ tly got smar t and changed my office to Clearwa t~r I , One, of my cards is enclosed., your attentipn. , ' , ' ~ ,~ , , , , ' , , , , ',' \ . ".' , PRESSMAN;& ASSOCIATES I Governmenral Altalrs and Publl R r ' 2BB ' " C e allons ....70 us Hfghway 19 N Sl' 'I Ph. 81:!.726.'JOTE 18M:!)'. O~'1'300. Clur'Walof. FL ~2t Fu 813.796.3975 Q t,al Po1QOf 25J.6~18 . , , '.. . TOdd Pressman Presidont , I , , , , '28870 US HIghway 19, N. . Suilo .300 . Cloarwator. Floridn 34621 Phono a 13.726.VOTE (8683) . Fax 813.796.3975 · Digital Pagor B 1:).253.641 B . , . .,', . . . ,', ,- - , , ' 'a_........ ~ c~JJ " R"'I.PH RICk...ROS l,all;!..illao\ .JOkN C. "1'1'1: .JO,",N 1:, GI.....I.lCHTCR. .JR. E.M". G~ PRATE-SI R. CARI..TON ........RO CYNTH'... I. RICI: MAAM. C, TiMME-So ,l..........O,.,.ICl:!!> RICHARDS: GILKEY, FITE:, SLAUGHTER, P,RATE:'SI & WARD, P.A. RlCH...FlO$ DUIl.C1ING 'IlS:! ~:",RK STRr;:I:T CI..CAI'IWATER, 1"1..0RICA 34616 , 'V9'3-3/ '- Tel..: lell:J) .'4:J.:JllD' ,......: (D':J)....e::J7'\1 WII.I.I"'" W,Gll."!:'I' Wfl.l.l...'" "'. .,....C"I:"Zre 0" COUNSel. Jl'ORT RtCHr;,Y' O""'CC 0..... !lIU,. OYORN'" fO_J04 U.S. t. . ,unit ~O:l iI'O"" _'C-HItT, ''''0''''0. ~...8 November 8, 1993, "l.'(~I:lI..:l".:l:l '...{..:)) .oa~e".3e Mr. Stephen L. ,Doher~y., Department ,of Planning and, Development Post Office Box 4748 Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748 Re: 3196 Gulf to' Bay sign ~a~iance A~piication Dear ,steve: : I ' filed' a sign Variance. Application on behalf of. property located at the 'above address on May ~17, 1993. On May 18th, I, received a confirmation letter from your office for receipt. of the application which letter also indicated that "we will in~orm you of the, city commission meeting date as soon as it is assigned". , ' I ha~e just received today from the pr9perty owner a copy of a,letter sent ,to them 'on November 5, 1993, from ,Charles Zetterberg indlcatingthat action was taken on our variance Application by the Ci ty Commission on October 29, 1993. A copy of this letter is enclosed for your reference. As the property owner I s representative, I ',.,ras not sent a notice nor did I receive notice of the hearing and the property owner was apparently mailed a notice but it was never received.' I 'arnthereforerequesting at this time that the action taken by ,the city Commission on October 29, 1993, be rescinded and that" we be notified of a future hearing date at which time we are afforded the opportunity to appear before the City commission and' present our case. In the meantime, by copy of this letter to Mr. Zetterberg, I am requesting that any ,action to 'enforce, the ,sign code with respect to this property be abated until we, are afforded a hearing pefore the city commission., , v~ou~s. ~ Carlton Ward RCW:sp Enclosure cc: Mr. Frank Mano , Mr. William wilkins Mr.,'F.B. Lauer , Mr.' Charles Zetterberg Milton Alvin Galbraith, \Jr., ,Esq. Ms. Gwen Legters ~ '" RECEIVED NO V '1 0 1993 CITY CLERK ~. , , . ' , , ' " , . ~ . ,I " 1 " " . ,'t I "\ I I, .J' , ' , , " t, ./'.; 'Ie. " ; , " I , I 'applicable to the zoning district nor created by an 'action or actions of the property owner, . predecessor in title, or the applicant. t;>.ny mistake made in the execution of a building , permit or work performed without the benefit of a 'permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting of a variance; 2) The particular physical 'surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant; 3) The variance is the minimum ,necessary ta overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in #2 for the pu'rpos'e of making reasonable use of the land; 41 The request for' a variance is not based primarily upon the desire of the' applicant to secure a greater financial return from the property; 5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious ta other property or improvements in the neigh'borhood 'in which the property is located; 61 The granting of the variance will not im'pair an adequate supply of. light or ventilation to adjacent, property, detract from the ,appearance of the community, substantially increase the conge'stionin the public streets, increase the danger of fire~ endanger the public safety 'in any way, or substantially diminish , or impair the value of surrounding prope,rty:' and 8) The granting of the variance desired, will not violate th~ general spirit and intent of this development code. '. ~ , . , ,Kevin Gordon, representing the applicant, stated that it would be a financial hardship to replace'the sign. There is a I,arge tree in front of the stare that blocks the sign, He has been working with ,the Traffic Engineer to get signage indicating Gulf-to~Bay goes, off to the right rather than calling it 60 West. They are willing to paint over the 56 square 'foot sign that is painted on the building: , ' " C'ommissioner Thomas inquired as to whether or not one ,of the four foot panels could be removed. , The Mayor suggested the applicant continue to work with staff and come back with an alternative proposal. ' , Discussion ensued regarding what would be Clcceptable to the Commissioners. It was determined the applicant, should work fu~ther 'with staff and corne' back with a proposal. , Commissioner Berfield moved ta continue the request. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously. The'City Manager stated staff had met witl;1 DOT regarding on-street parking on Cleveland Street and the City will be redesigning the signage at the intersection where Court and Gulf-to-Say 'split within 90 days. ' '" , The applicant is requesting ,the following variances to permit the existing freestanding sign, attached sign and directional sign to remain: 1) an area variance of " 86:6 square feet from the permitted 64 square Feet to allow a total freestanding sign area ' " 'minsp 1 Ob,93 10/29/93 18 " , , , I , \" t '-, ,I " " " " , r " , ( , .' c, ~ J , I " , . , , t , \ :.,: : , , ' 'i , .' " of ,150.6 square feet'; 21 a height varian~e ,of 1 2.75 feet from' the perrT;litted 20 fo~t height tq allow a freestanding sign 32.75 feet in height; 31 a setback .variance of 3 feet from the 5 foot setback requirement to allow,a !freestanding sign 2 feet from the street right~of~ , ,way; 4) a variance of two message panels from the permitted two 'message panels to allow a freestanding sign with a total of four message 'panels; 5} an area variance of 27 square ,feet from the permitted 64 square feet to, allow an attached sign with a total area of 91 square feet; and 6) an area variance of 0.95 square feet from the permitted 4 square , feet to allow an on-site directional sign with a total of 4.95 square feet. . , ~ , The subject prt;lperty is located on:the northwest corner of Gulf~to~8ay Boulevard' and South Duncan Avenue and is in the 'General Commercial (CG) zoning district. , " " The new sign ordinance isbeing uniformly applied to all signs in this zoning district, The 'applicant is requesting 4 variances to' permit the existi.ng freestanding sign to remain.' These variances are for height, area, setback and additional panels. The applicant has not , provided any evidence these variance requests arise from any conditions unique to this , property. '. The'applicant is requesting one variance for additional attached signage ar,ea. There are two existing' attached signs with one sign oriented toward each street. The applicant contends Grandy's is voluntarily removing "an all important wall sign" thereby reducing the amo'unt of total square footage below City allowances: This contention is not consistent in ,the applica~ion of the sign regulations or with' the variance being requested. The applicant further contends that installation of ,significant landscaping is "probably very , unique to G'ulf-to-Bay".' However. the landscaping of the front of the property does not constitute a unique condition for justification of additional signage. The applicant ha's not provided any evidence this variance request arises from any conditions unique to this property. , " , , The applicant is requesting one variance to allow four on-site directional signs to be 0,95 square feet over the four square foot signage permitted, This appears to be 'a ' minimal variance, however, the code clearly states business logos on these signs shall not : exceed 25 percent of the sign are~. The logo's on these signs occupy approximately 60 percent of the sign area. The applicant has no't provided any evidence that this request arises from any Gonditi?ns unique to this prC?perty. ' These variance requests are extreme with regard to the setback. height. number of message paneh and' area. The magnitude and number of variances requested cannot be considered minimal requests. I ' .i Surrounding land uses are: to the. north. professional office; to the south ~ Georgio's Restaurant, Shoppilig Center; to the east - Carfinders, Inc. (used car sales); and to the west ~ Spinal Health Center, C~iropractic' Service,S (medical offices). " , , These signs are located on Gulf.to-Bay Boulevard. a very high exposure corridor with a high volume of tourist traffic. The combination of height, setback. number of panels and area,of these reQue~ts 'create signs that are riot in character wit~ the signa~e minsp10b;93 , , ) 0/29/,93 19 , , , , ' ,c' . . ". ~ ': .: '; , , , :' , permitted for the surrounding co~mercial areas and diverts attentio~ from those land uses. The granting of these 'variances will detract from' the commercial businesses that have :conforming signage,and negatively impact the overall appearance of the community. , , Staff finds that of the eight standards which ,must be met for variance approval, the applicant's request does not meet the following: 1) The variance requested'arises from a condition which is unique to the property in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applicable to the zoning district nor created by an action or actions of the property owner, C predecessor in title. or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution of a building permit or work performed without the benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be, situations which support the granting of a variance; 2) The particular physical' surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant; 3) The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in 112 for the purpose of making re'asonable use of the , land; 5) The granting of the variance will not be materially detrimental or injurious to other' property or improvements in the neighborhood ,in which the property is located; 6) The granting of the variance will not impair an' adequate' supply of'light or ventilation to adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, SUbstantially increase. the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety in any way, or substantially diminish or impair the valUE:;! of surrounding, property; and 8) , The granting of the variance desired will not' violate the general spirit and intent of this development code. . No one representing the applicant was present. .' Commissioner Thomas noted this used to be the site of a Steak N Shake and has been rebuilt. He asked staff if the square footage was based on the outer frame or the letters. Mr. Shuford stated they measured the entire sign at t~e top of the pole. Discussion ensued regarding which way a sign should be measured.. If the sign is painted. on the side of a building it is acceptable to measure just the letters but if the ,backgr~und is diffe~ent from the rest of the building, the entire sign would be used to calculate the area. Commissioner. Berfield moved to deny the requested. variances for the subject property for failure ,to meet Sec. 45.24, Standards for Approval. items "-3, 5,'6 and 8. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously. ITEM #8 Variances to Si n Re ulations for prOperty (Work America, Inc.) located at 3196 Gu .eo-Bav Blvd., See, 16-29-'6, M&B 24.081 (Wilkins, Lauer, Jacobsen) SV93.31 The, applicant is requesting the following variances to permit an existing freestanding sign to remain: 1}, an area 'variance of 191 square feet from the 64 square feet permitted to allow a tota' 'of 255 square feet: and 2) a setback variance of 2.5 feet from the required five foot setback to allow a freastand'ing sign 2.5 feet from the Gulf-to- , . Say Boulevard right-of-way~ '. , , I . minsp' Ob.93 10/29/93 20 , ' , , ., i.. ~ < (I' , I ;-1 > . . , . I ., I I " " 1.1 " 1'1. , " , " , , . I' , I The subject propertY is located ,of) the northeast corner of Gulf-to-SayBoulevard and Bayshore Boulevard and is in the ~eneral Commercial (CG) zoning district. The new sign ordinance is being uniformly applied to all signs in this zoning district, The'applicant contends the sign's location on the' propertY with respect to existing. ' . landscaping and the existing building minimizes the impact of the excessive size. However, there remains sufficient area on the site to place a sign th'3t conforms to setback and, area ~equirements of. the code, 'The applicant has not provided any evidence that these variance requests 'arise from any conditions unique to, this property. These variance requests a're extreme with regard to the permitted area of a freestanding sign and cannot be considered minimal requests. , , Surrounding land uses are: to the north. Eunice Little, Inc. (Realtors Exchangors); to the south - Tampa Sa y {across Gulf-to-Say}; to the east - FDOT office; and to the west'. vacant lot, ' ' " ' A vacant lot exists to the west and FDOT offices are to the east, No businesses are located to the south across Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard. Th~ existence of this 255 square' foot freestanding sign is not in character with the signage permitted for commercial .j , businesses in this' zoning district. The granting of these variance requests will detract from 'the,appearanc,e of the community. ' ' Staff finds that of the eight standards whiCh must be met for variance approval, the ~'pplicant's request does not meet the followin'g: 1) The variance requested arises .fr,orn a, condition which is unique to the propert'l in question and is neither ordinarily or uniformly applica'ble to the zoning di'strict nor created by an action or aptions of the,property owner, predecessor in title, or the applicant. Any mistake made in the execution' of a building permit or work performed without th'e benefit of a permit shall not be considered to be situations which support the granting' of a variance; 2) The particular physical 'surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the property involved and the strict, application ,of the provisions of this development code' would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant: 31 The variance is the minimum necessary to overcome the unnecessary hardship referred to in ;t2for the purpose of making reasonable. use of the , land: 5) The granting of the variance will not be ,materially ,detrimental or injurious to other property or improvements in the neighborhood in which the' property is located; 6} The granting of the variance will not impair an adequate supply of light or ventilation to 'adjacent property, detract from the appearance of the community, substantially,increase .' the congestion in, the public streets, increase. the danger of fire, 'endanger the public saf,etY f , in ~ny way, or substantially diminish 'or impair rhe value of surrol,mding property;, and 8)' . The granting of. the variance desired will not'violate the general spirit and intent of this development code, Two lette~s of support were received. No one representing the applicant was present. " " Commissioner Berfield moved to deny the requested variances for the subject property' for failure to meet Sec. 45.24, Standards for Approval, items '-3,5,6 and 8., The motIon was,duly seconded and carried unanimou,sly. 'VI, " . . \ .. , c , Dear Moyor: This letter is in regard to SV-9325, ,which is a request for the City Commission to' re-hear a,sig~,varian6e for Grandy's restaurants. Thc:sole reason 'for this action, is that the City failed to notifv me in'uny fasnion that the request was scheduled, 'before you. r have been notifi'edin this instance, for the re-hearing, only two ~business days prior 'to the meeting, by phonei by the City Cle~kls office. ' . , , " .' l . ~.) " ~~ , , '. 1 ~ ,; . I PRESSMAN & ASSOCIATES' I ' i"'7' c~ -_', *" ,'1 'I Governmental Afla Irs and Public Relallons ./ ~ ~ of...... The Honorable Rita Garvey, Hayor, City of Clearwater P.O. Box 47~B ' Clearwater, FL 34618 January 19, ,1994 , I am scheduled to b~ on vacation next w~ek and will not be pre~eni ~n'the 24th...unless' you want to conference call into Hawaii! , , , I '\dll look forward to the opportunity of presenting to you the facts that support vuriancc~'for Grandy's, at the date you choose.. . " ". . . " Clerk , , , ,e , I RECEIVED. J~N 2 1 199~ CITY CLERK DEPT. " , ' 28870 US Hlghw'ny Hl, N. · Sullo H3UQ · Cllll\fV/l\\(lr I FlorId:\. 3.\G'l' Phona B 13.720NOTE (0003)".'Fnx U 13.790.3075 · Di';lltnl Paoar 0'3.253.0410 , I, .. .. " , I . ' " ' , ' , ,. ' " , ,; . " ,'.,i-< I . ~, ~ " ~ C it' 't " , I ' " , ' , ' '" , ," 'I ' . ~ l ~\.~: \ : ",'.;~{" :', ., , .' , i . ~.~ .' ", .. ' , .: I i .c , L -I- c' I, . , . , '. 'j. ere ~ . . . ,. . ~ " . . j. 'I , ~' , , ,I . n 'n'- ~3 't.:UPIE~ m:~, r..J ~ ' - C01VIlV/fSSION , PRESS , Date ',IAN '24 j9S,1 , , , I"' , Th~ Honorable ~1ayor. 'and Members of the City, Commi ss,bhY GlfI1i\, ,M~ A. Galbraith,' Jr., City Attorn,ey~, ",' Ice House "c , , " '" , ' , , " 'M,E M 0 R A N'D U H '.' " .TO: : ", , FROM: . . RE:. DATE: January 24, 1994 \, './ The enclosed 'redraft of the agreement relating to the Ice ,House came in late 'Friday, too late for me to distribute it to you in advance of ~his morning~s meeting. , . I have compared ,it aga i,nst my tWQ 'sets of proposeci changes and the notes from . your meeting last Thursday evening, and I believe thi~ incorporates the changes ~e,agree to. .i L .' " ' " ',' , , MAG: a ' .c "; . . .' ,. :, Enc.1osure ., ' ~ . I t . ., ,.Copies:, Betty Deptula, 'Interim City Manager, , Kathy S, Rice, Deputy City Manager " Scott S~uford, Director, Central Permitting " VictorC. Chodora, Assistant Director, Central Permitting' " . Timothy A~ Johnson, Jr" Esquire ' ,"I " '.J. ., . ; " .. . ~, , . , t <", I . , . ' . , . . . " , ' ': <' > ~, I ~ . I 'I J . t, , , , , " ' , . . I , I . ;' ~ ' . I \ , , , , I~ . ~ " c " I . , ~. q.: I " , \ . U1/21/94 17:09' 1J813 ~~1 8U17 JOUNSON BLAKE1.Y 1aI 002/006, ~' AGREEMENT THJS' AGREEMENT is made on January ~1 1994. between ROBERT SCHOELLER and CYNTHIA DANIEL ("0wne~') and the City of Clearwater) Florida, a municipal Corporation C'Cltt). RECITALS A, Owner owns the real property' described on Exhibit nAil altached hereto and' incorporated herein, which real property is commonly known as the "Old lee House" and the street address of which is 630 Drew Street, Clearwater, Florida. 8. The Old Ice House Is in a state of disrepair as the result of a fire. I~r.k of maintenance." and exposure to the elemeots. C. The City Is Interested In seeIng that the Old lee House Is in a timely manner either renovated or demolished. The City has initiated steps to demolish the Old Ice House. ' D. House. Owner wishes the City, to abandon its effort to demolish the Old Ice , E. Subject to compliance bv the Owner withBa5e~poA the terms and I ,conditions set forth below, the City will abandon its effort to demolish the Old Ice House. NOW1 THEREFORE, in consideration of the mulual promIses hereinafter contained, Owner and the City agree 8S follows: 1. Recitals. The, foregoing recitals are true and correct and are Incorporated hereIn by reference, ' , '2. Desion and Construction Timetable: Owner agrees to comply with the following timetable for desIgn and construction of the renovations to the Old Ice House: a. On or before .January 28. 1994. Owner will secure the east and south sides of U19 property 8Qalnst entry bv unauthorized persons, Ol/2.1ill 17:09 'a6l:l Hi 6617 ,JOHNSON BLAKELY lai 003/006 b.a:. On or' before April 15. 1994. Owner will' submit to the City a complete and acceptable application for a buildlna permit and aoollcable plan review fee. accomoanled by construction drawlnQs to renovate the bulldino envelope of the Old Ice House inclUding. without limitation, renovalion, repair. replacement, or construction, as apJ)ropriate. of the roof, wIndows. and front of building, lthe IIDesianed , Imcrovements"). Such construction drawinqs shall be drawn by or under the seal of a Florida reoistered archltecl or enclnaer and shall provide such details end specifications as are customarllv required by the Standard Buildlna Code and the Cltv for buildina permit applications. C.' The building permit application shall also be accompanied bv a site Qlan and an application for sIte clan approval. and evidence of compliance wlth.1ill other reQulreme(1ls of the City which are applicable to slmllarlv situated prQQerties in the City of Clearwater and whioh may applY to the Old tee House, including but not necessarilv limited to reQuirements relatinQ to the submissIon of a site plan for the property, designation of Intended uses. crovlsion of on-sile parking, provision of on~slte stormwater retention, h:,!ndscaDlnQ, provision of water and sewer service. concurrency requirements. the life safety codes, and the payment of any fees not PAid bv the time of issuance of the bulldlnQ permit. The Owner shall complY with such other requirements to the extent they are applicable to the property as a condition precedent to obtalninQ 8 certificate of occupancl{ from the ell\{, 1 . a~ Gn-oF-befGr&-ApriJ-..4.5;.-4894;-GwAeF-W1II-submU--to-the-Glty seR6tfUGtio~fflwiAg!HG-fanoval&-tAa-bujlding-aAlJelopa..of-IAe-Gld-IGe-HGuSEHAchJdiAgj w4tAeuHi~tieFr.-reFtaVatioA;-fe~fT-f6placemeAl;-Gf-OOAS'rUGlloA,a5-appfOprjatar-ef the-fGGfr,viRdow&;-and..ffORl~uildiRgrltRa "QeslgAed.lrnpFGlJameAts!!p !L.1:r. The Owner shall Dav all applicable l;Iermlt fees and Impact fees at the time of issuance of the building permit. Assuming a reasonable period for review by the City of the submiUed construction drawings, and upon Issuance of the building oermitl Owner will commence construction of the DesIgned Improvements on or before, May 31, 1994. The south wall and the temporary sllorinq of the south wall shall be reinscected bv a Florida registered e'nflineer not later than May 21 , 1994, and either the wall shall be repaired or the shoring shall be reDlaced as may be necessary so that the south wall shall be certified bv Ihe enQlneer. not later than Mav 23. 1994, to be structurally safe, ' 2 01l2!(.~,:L.!.1.!J..IL "U8i:! Hi 81H 7 JOHNSON BLAKELY Tal oo.ai 006 ~~ Except In the event of force majeure, construction of the DesIgned Improvements Will be substantially completed 1'1. the opinion of the Owners architect on or before January 161 1995, and a certlficale of occupancy shall be issued on or before APril 17. 1995. Owner's contract with the general contractor performing the construction work will contain a penalty clause providing that a $100.00 per day penaltv, payable to the CUYI will be paid by the contractor for each day after January 16; 1995, that the Designed Improvements are not substantially completed:'"" 9fld a like sum for each day after April 17 , 1995, that the certificate of occupancy has not been issued. 3. Suspension of Demolition Effort. ProvIded that Owner complies with the provisIons of_paragraph..2.~.... ~~. above.af\d-b~V6; the City will suspenda9aRGaA its effort to demolish the Old Ice House. \ 4, Escrow. Within three (3) business days following the execution of this Agreement by bo\h parties, Owner shall deposit in an interest bearing escrow account with Johnsonl Blakely, Pope, Bokor. Ruppel & Bums, P,A, ("Escrow Agentll), the sum of . , $15,221.00 (the IIDeposJtlI). Failure by Owner to so deposit the funds with Escrow Agent automatically terminates this Agreement. If Owner fails timely to gpptv for a buildina permit. submit construclion drawings to the City, aPDIIJ for site plan approvall or to commence construction, then, promptly upon receipt by Escrow Agent of an affidavit to that effect executed by an appropriate official of the City, Escrow Agent shalf pay..over the Deposit, less accrued Interest. which Deposit shall be used by the City solely for the purpose of paying, In whole or in part, the costs of demolishing the Old Ice HOlJse in accordance with law. A copy of the affidavit Shall simultaneously be furnished by the City to Owner. Owner waives any defense Owner may have to dernollUon of the Old Ice House and consents to such demolition providing the City complies with the tenns of this Agreement. Any excess, funds remaining after any legally authorized demolition of the Old Ice House Shall be retumed by the City to 'Owner. If the Deposit Is Insufficient to pay the costs of demolition, Owner shall be liable for the shortfall as may be provided by law. The Deposit. Including accrued interest, shall be retumed to Owner by Escrow Agent in the event Owner tlmelv commences construction of the Designed Improvements. Notice of such commencement of construction shall be in the form of an affidavit executed by Owner and delivered to Escrow Agent. with a copy simultaneously furnished to the City. However. the relurn of tho Deposit to OWl\sr shall not relieve tt1e Owner from the oblloalion to substanliallv complete'the construction of the DesIgned Improvements on , or before JanuarY. 16. 1995, or to obtain a certificate of occupancy on or before April 17, 1995. The waiver by the Owner of any defonse the Owner may have to demolition 3 01121/94 17:q_ "li'813 HI 8tl17 JOHNSON BLAKELY QJ 005/006 , .' \ ... /}4 ..., ~ -s.tJ.- ;,.; J J.-C.. j'}<.>A ...0,]0 lj 5. Escrow AQent. , a,^,=, The duties of Escrow Agent are only such as are herein specifically provided. beIng purely ministerial in nature, and that Escrow Agent shall Incur no liability whatever except for willful misconduct or gross negligence 50 long as Escrow Agent has acted in good faith. The Seller and Buyer release Escrow Agent from any act done or omitted to be done by Escrow Agent In good faith In the performance of Escrow Agent's duties hereunder. ' , , , 'b.B.- Escrow Agent shall be under no responsibility with raspect to any Deposit placed with ,It other than faithfully to follow the Instructions herein contained. Escrow Agent may consult with counsel and shall be fully protected in any actions taken in good faith, in accordance with counsel's advice. Escrow Agent shall not be required to defend any legal proceedings which may be Instituted against Escrow Agent In respect to the subject matter of these Instructions unless requested to do so by Seller and Buyer and indemnified to the satisfacUon of Escrow Agent against the cost and expenSe of such defense. Escrow Agent shall not be required to institute legal proceedings of any kind. Escrow Agent shall have no responsIbility for the genuineness or validity of any document or othor item depos1ted wlth Escrow Agent, 'and shall be fully protected in acting In accordance with any written instructions given to Escrow Agent hereunder and believed by Escrow Agent to have been signed by the proper parties. , c.G:- Escrow Agent assumes no liability hereunder except that of a ' I stakeholder. If there Is any dispute as to whether Escrow Agent is obligated to deliver the Deposit, or as to whom the Deposit is to be delivered, Escrow Agent will not be obligated to make any delivery of the Deposit. but In such event may hold the Deposit until receipt by Escrow Agent of an authorization in writing signed by all of the persons having an interest In such' dIspute, directing the dispositlon of the sum, or in the absence of such authorization, Escrow Agent may hold the Deposit until the final determination of lhe rights of the partIes in an appropriate proceeding. If such written authorization is not given, or proceedings for such determlnatlon are not begun and diligently continued, Escrow Agent may, but is not required, to bring an appropriate action or proceeding for leave to place the Deposit with the court, pendIng such determination. Once Escrow Agent has tendered into the registry or custody of any court af competent jurisdiction all money andlor property in its possession under this Agreement, or has made delivery of the Deposit in any other manner provided for herein, Escrow Agent shall be discharged from all duties and shall have no further liability hereunder as Escrow Agent Escrow Agent shall be entitled to represent Owner in any and all such proceedings. The CUy acknowledges that Escrow Agent is the law 4 l l 1. 1,1 , , ' , , . " , ' , , " ,,. 1 ,"..: ' ." , , ,. , , , 1 'I : ":t i' ..~ :',' .' ", , , .. ,,>. L . ,~ . . i , , : >' I 01/21/94 11.L!1 "n'813 4 U~1.L. JOHNSON BLAKELY' ..~..~ .. -. ~ lilI 006/006 , , , . I I , . finn which has represented Owner in connection with this transaction and the City 'consents to such continued representation. including representation of Owner in any , , dIspute which may arise in connection with this' Agreement, the transaction ' 'J ' contemplated herepy" or matters rel~ted to ~ny of the foregoIng. ' .. , IN WITNESS WHEREOF; Owner and City have executed this .A.gre~ment on this ,dale. . . , > OWNER: "c " ' , . ,\ 'I ' " By: , , CYNTHIA DANIEL CITY OF CLEARWATER, a municipal corporation , '\ , . !' "f " ' '. '" . By: Mayor " . ~ Attest: ' Approved as to form: City Clerk " ,,' + !, ~ " , ~Ity Attorney , ' The undersigned agree,s to a~t as Escrow Agent tl'ereunder. JOHNSON, 'SLAKEL Y, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, p.A. " I ' '.\ . 2M361mma ~ By: ' ~I " . . 5 " ' , , \ . , , , t. I 01/21/94 17:08 ' '5'813 441 8~~ JOHNSON DLAKELY ~ 001/006 ' JOHNSON, BLAKELY, POPE, BOKOR, RUPPEL & BURNS; P.A. 911 Chestnut Street. P,Q. Box 1366 Clearwater' FL 34617~13e8 Telephone: (613) 461-1818 Fax: (813) 441-8617 y- Facsimile Cover Sheet To: AI Galbraith, Jr.. Esq. Company: City of Clearwater Phone: 462-6760 Fax: 462-6426 From: Tim Johnson. Jr.. Esq. , Client Name: Schoeller/Ice House Client/Mattcr Number: 34642 90298 " Dutc: January 21, '1994 , Pages including tbis ,:over page: 6 .' Comments: 1hc WDIlmIla,u:<lIlloIintllln lllit lWl>mlulan m.y too: olI<lm~ltllon'.J:ffl\l..tIl W \ll.l;It!... ~tlIl!idcn~Jl ThU WlOVlillon illlllCllda.l On/y r....!be It/. alll'", irIl/iv14lWllf CllIhYllUlwd tbov. llUl:,~ ot'lll'- Il\t1I.ojjC II nDIl1.c W~ rulplrlll. YQ\lIU btrtu,.lIOlir"d lllIl "Il)' oIWomln.ull<\, otatrib.f.tIll\ \lI' "'1'1 r.flhl. CClllVIll<<llulion b ..muy p<<>IIib\\tAi Ifyw norM \hi. nnuNul(l/llll_mr llt It'rtlllll~''''' Ill' u..!..,;;!lUI or eWI) ~ -"<Iv" \he '''''''pC otrh4lt~nn III\ll1 iIlltJlllml III lIIII 00q , n~ \l.'Ii"" ~ ""';1'1'0 1lI.Omt)'1rJlrnl CI' athc/WiJ4. [fyau b.VI t-'~'~lh\o. C=ur.>a.rillll In ""!W', pl<NC lI<>ll!y iii br whphcm, D:l1I~ &nd /ll1</1l1ho ari~ nlW&ao IG 1M otl/lC ~.<Sdrao \'1. U,:t. POIIll :ieM~, Vol/will ~ ,cimb...,~rOi..rypo.lI\jjC (rvrJolhar c.cpcD>e U6<<i.I<dYtilhth~ Itllrilo/"\lIIo ~1lt"IIll'-'I~ ~ , tag " ' AMOUNT: $ 34642.9029a 01/21/94 , ' RECEIVED, JAN 24 1993 CITY ATTORNEY " , '