Loading...
04/14/1969.,. .tr Syr 4r.s• y y s? t' fY et . t, L .S.it a t h /??.?xMy?'?t b f =C'?M^r, .Y+t? ?Wtr 'Ftnv N ':sw C.yt4. ?,?.?,?,_ ttv, ;,,., ,,•e`,• k?!i?;. i'r'?M1;•? ?,, ?? ,n?!?#?'?yy ..5 "!$ e't:S'?`?'3""?,`'?'r'*'tr.". E, 1'"?.?r? r ? ? f •? '!' ?fiR'.i'S`^'? . ? ? r .;y? .?['S?•''t?'? .. 1 •?. '.., ?. "?,,?'':'7" . it r `?`. .? ?r?•';y7.. ,• 7 `f!1?51?`?: . ? S' c.r ? j, ' .'?t•r?'I. t" ?' .' , 4 ?jX •' .. .i 1ti .:? n'? lN.. i:' 5• 1y'? i '?^'''f•'?`'s;::+? `'" °_?':.'f; ?' 'tir ,?..e:??? :4 c•t .?., 'rii??''uti,{;.Y', "J-.1.: .t Frj t? '.l kl.'.a' ..Y?.•. .. „„.j+„ ;`??.?'{.' }, a•,iF.?S l '^}C .+ k t, r? ?l?tx..fx e.?E;:1L;+.$'??1}?:!!? r `? O i CITY COMMISSION MEETING April 14, 1969 F, The City Commission of the City of Clearwater met in special session a•t'the City Hall, Monday, April 14, 1969, at 1:30 P.M. with the following members present: H. Everett Hougen Mayor.-Commissioner Donald S. Williams Commissioner Brooks Carter Commissioner Donald Carlson Commissioner Rick Hall Commissioner Also present were: Merrett R..Stierheim City Manager Herbert M. Brown City Attorney Frank Daniels Police Chief The Mayor called the meeting to order and announced a public hearing to consider items to be included in an ordinance amending the City zoning law and zoning map. The invocation was given by Chief Daniels. ITEM N1 - request of E. H. Holcomb, Jr. for Lots 1 to 14 incl., Brookhill Terrace Sub., to be changed from R-lE (single family) to R-3 (low density multiple dwelling). The Planning 6 Zoning Board recommended approval. Mr. Virgil H. Wintrode, representing the applicant explained the application. Dr. J. B. Rice, 1595 Evergreen Ave. representing about 20 people in the audience stated that a survey of the neighbors showed that 43 were opposed with no one supporting the application. He read 5 reasons for opposing it from a petition with 35 signatures. Reverend-Gary Dewitt, pastor of the Community Reformed Church adjoining subject property on the East representing about 22 people in the audience, the Board of the Church, and the people of the church, spoke in opposition. Mr. John Austin also representing the Community Reformed Church opposed the request. The City Clerk had a telegram and the Mayor had a letter of objection. Mr. Ivan W. Stoll objected as they purchased a lot and are building on the North end of the lake on the basis of the present zoning. Mr. Wintrode agreed to a maximum of two stories. Commissioner Williams moved that the application of Mr. E. H. Holcomb, Jr, to change lots 1-14 Brookhill Terrace Subdivision from R-lE (single family) to R-3 (low density multiple dwelling) be denied. Motion was seconded by Com- missioner Carter and carried unanimously. The City Manager reported on sanitation problems indicating a considerable shortage of employees and stated that he hoped to have a more complete report with recommendations at the next regular meeting. ITEM #2 - request of Paul Hennesen for South 917.92 ft. of East 524.29 ft. of SE 1/4 of NE 1/4, Section 11-29-15, to be changed from R-lE (dingle family) to PUD-R (planned unit development-residential). The Planning 6 Zoning Board recommended approval of the application. Mr. Reid Compton, representative was present. The City Clerk read a letter of objection from Mr. Elmer L. Rowlands, owner of Lot 6, Blk 46, Highland Pines 8th Add. Mr. W. Compton reported that Mr. Hennesen was in South America and therefore it was recommended by the Mayor that action be deferred until May 5, 1969. Commissioner Williams moved that ITEM #2 on the agenda be deferred until the regular meeting of May 5th. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Carter and carried unanimously. ITEM 03 - request of Adeline Cralle Salvage for Lots 1 and 12, Block 9, Pine Crest Sub. to be changed from R-2 (duplex) to B (business). The Planning E Zoning Board recommended disapproval. Mr. Alfred C. Wyllie, representing the applicant stated there was a business all around it and a radiator shop was proposed. There were no objections. Commissioner Carlson moved that the request of Adeline Cralle Salvage for B (business) zoning on Lots 1 and 12, Block 9, Pine Crest Sub. be denied. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Hall and carried unanimously. ITEM #4 - request of James R. Roberts for South 350 ft. of East 290 ft. less road right of way of S. Greenwood Ave. and Woodlawn St. in the NW 1/4 of SW 1/4, Section 22-29-15, to be changed from R-4 (multi-family) to B (business). The Planning E Zoning Board recommended disapproval of the request, with further recommendation that the tract be zoned PUD-C (planned unit development-commercial) and plan should designate 40 ft. (one-half right of way) for Greenwood Ave. and 30 ft. (one-half right of way) for Woodlawn St. Mr. Roberts was present. The City Clerk read a letter of objection from Mr. T. J. Motry. Commissioner Carter moved that the application of Mr. Roberts for B (business) zoning from R-4 (multi-family) on South 350 ft. of East 290 ft. less road right of way of S. Greenwood Ave. and Woodlawn St. in the NW 1/4 of SW 1/4 of Section 22-29-15 be disapproved but the zoning as recommended by the Planning E Zoning Board PUD-C (planned unit development-commercial) be approved with the stipulation that 40 ft. right of way on Greenwood Ave. be dedicated and 30 ft. on Woodlawn St. be con- firmed and the City Attorney be instructed to include this in an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance to be brought back to this Commission for approval as soon as possible. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Carlson and carried unanimously. ' ITEM 45 - request of Capital Homes, Inc. for Lots 10 to 16 incl.-South 5 ft. of Lot 17 and All of Lot 18, Palm Bluff Sub. to be changed from R-2 (duplex) to R-4 (multi-family). The Planning 6 Zoning Board at this time has tabled the ; .;.',.,, .' .:. •, request for change in zoning from R-2 (duplex) to R-4 (multi-family) and with- . . holds any recommendation pending the adoption of an appropriate new zone classi- °` .. fication. Mr. 'James M. Dawson, representative said they cannot wait for an -`•'t. '.7`?{7=???? ?,r•' • U, ter.':, ?. .. ? ? ? i ,,;1=' i `;L? .p... ;1. i ........>r.rr/"rir'.".w+wn.wr s.. t ..?.. w.•-,....wrwr.?.. ... ..•• y' t? i 'e'.l';*l?TS ray ti.ra a., f•?:l ? ? ?rti..: •.)?tl ;?,N .•;. _•• r • _x ,?..-„as! .• Vin... ^rli... n ,L,•,• r . r,r•I S ? ,' •,; ti. .',Yt. r ' -ii, }'...??'h. ?:, 'fie'' ` S; ,.. 1., +,.,a, •?.x. ? ?i}.Y'?+°°'. t •5 N+•;i?1f r 1'.'3'?,??t'N'' ?N'!'E.r Y ?T, j15 '` ?.•*?t„kF?i r.:?'1*'??`', r.?'.:`t?-S ".Z??Z';i'e '•:.?; ??1':, •i?:i ;????;??, r-•''??'ky'?.!?•??•?''s.t'.:ti.",;•,E,?•'??7t'?',?-jx; ".;yi. •',liF'•?. n;;,, .?:v ?_.a?.....?,«.?r•:4's.:G`i:'?{.4:?:.s..:.:..e3:?S,.a_s...::..??1.:.:,s'.??..:.4fi.k:;LSSS?{:..C..,.t?S,r?.T'.._,•!_?',S,a.r.,...?.rut1'x??1.c{•.5.:?i?t'i?..'!! .?''] -2- CITY, COMMISSION MEETING April 14, 1969 'indefinite time and was not aware of the recommendation of the Planning 8 Zoning Board and explained their desire to start immediately. Dr. K. P. Taylor spoke in objection. Mr. James A. Robbins, and Mr. G. P. Davis spoke in approval. Commissioner Williams moved that the request of Capital Homes Inc., for R-4 zoning on Lots 10 to 16 incl., South 5 ft. of Lot 17 and all of Lot 1B Palm Bluff Sub. be changed from R-2 (duplex) to R-4 (multi-family) be denied, but that PUD-R (planned unit development-residential.) be approved and the City Attorney be instructed to include this in an amendment to the zoning ordinance to be brought back to this Commission for approval subject to the right of way nego- tiations with Capital Homes Inc., for 10 additional ft. along Osceola Ave. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Carter and carried unanimously. g ITEM 06 - request of John Araujo et al for Lots 15 to 24 incl., Block 24, Marymont Sub., to be changed from PRS (professional E related services) to B / (business). The Planning F. Zoning Board recommended disapproval of the request- Mr. George A. Routh, attorney for the 6 owners requesting, the change spoke of .? being surrounded by business except to the rear, that a plumbing store was planned by Mr. Araujo and felt it was consistent with the long range plan. Mr. George B. Blume, attorney, representing some of the residential property owners, Dr. Jean Lester Bennett and himself, stated they felt any change would be detrimental to good planning and approximately 147 property owners have signed a petition against the request. The City Clerk read the 5 reasons for objection as listed on the • petition. Commissioner Hall moved that the request of John Araujo et al for B (business) zoning on Lots 15 to 24 incl., Block 24, Marymont Sub. be denied. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Williams. Upon the vote being taken Com- missioners Williams, Hall, and Carlson voted "Aye". Mayor Hougen and Commissioner x...._? ?. Carter voted "No". Motion carried. ITEM # 7 - request of R. J. Hupp Enterprises, Inc., for Lots 1 to 4 incl., Block 4, Milton Park Sub. to be changed from R-4 (multi-family) to B (business). The Planning E Zoning Board recommended approval of B (business) for Lots 1 thru 3 incl. and further recommended that Lot 4 be zoned M (manufacturing) to conform to uses to the West. The proposed usage is for auto tune-up service. Mr. Frank Logan, attorney, representing the applicant stated-this was a franchised tune-up business. Mr. Charles A. Britton, 812 Grand Central, spoke in objection to the tune-up business due to noise and .fumes. Commissioner Williams moved that the request of R. J. Hupp Enterprises, Inc., be approved for the R-4 zoning to be changed to B (business) for Lots 1 to 3 incl., and Lot 4 be zoned M (manufacturing) and the City Attorney be instructed to include this in an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance to be brought back to this Commission for approval as soon as possible. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Carter and carried unanimously. ITEM 08 - request of Metz E White, Inc. for South 18.75 ft. of Lot 3, Block B, Drew Heights Sub. and the North 25 ft. of South 250 ft. of West 148.92 ft. of East 1/2 of West 1/2 of SW 1/4 of SW 1/4 Section 12--29-15 to be changed from R-2 (duplex) to B (business). The Planning E Zoning Board recommended disapproval of the request. Mr. Donald 0. McFarland, attorney, representing the applicant explained the request, and stated the applicant wished to build another row of storage garages identical to those already in the vicinity. 4:20 P.M. (Commissioner ' Rayor Williams assuned the Chair at the request of the Mayor.) 4:30 P.M. (The returned and assume the Chair, Mrs. Newba. 1 whose property adjoins spoke in objection as some o the present garages are not storage but commercial enter- prises, with 3 or 4 trucks operating out of them. Mr. Burdette Beidler, 110 Flamingo Rd. owner of a rented home near the subject property objected to the business request as did Mrs. Beidler. Commissioner Williams moved that the request of Metz E White, Inc., for B (business) zoning on South 18.75 ft. of Lot 3, Block B, Drew Heights Sub., and the North 25 ft. of South 250 ft. of West 148.92 ft. of East 1/2 of West 1/2 of SW 1/4 of SW 1/4, Section 12-29-15 be denied without prejudice. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Hall. Upon the vote being taken Commissioners Carlson, Williams, Hall and Mayor Hougen voted "Aye". Commissioner Carter voted "No". Motion carried. ITEMS 9, 11 and 12 were considered together as they were in the same area and the requests were the same. ITEM # 9 - request of Clyde H. Long, Jr. for Lot 5 and East 10 ft, of Lot 6, Block K, Boulevard Heights Sub., to be changed from R-4 (multi-family) to PRS (pro- fessional E related services). The Planning 6 Zoning Board recommended approval. Mr. Sam Coleman, realtor, was present. ITEM #11 - request of Robert W. Decker for Lots 16 and 17, Block J, Boulevard Heights Sub., to be changed from R-4 (multi-family) to PRS (professional 8 related services). The Planning 6 Zoning Board recommended approval. Mr. Decker was present. ITEM #12 - request of Vito A. Tagarelli for Lots 2 to 7 incl., Block E, Breeze Hill Sub., to be changed from R-4 (multi-family) to PRS (professional S related services). The Planning E Zoning Board recommended approval. Mr. J. E. Satterfield, representative was present. There were no objections. Commissioner Hall moved that ITEMS 9, 11 and 12 be approved with the zoning to be changed from R-4 to PRS and the City Attorney be instructed to include this in an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance to be brought back.to this Commission for approval as soon as possible. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Carter and carried unanimously. r, 4/ ?; ¦ i` V,. CITY COMMISSION MEETING April 14, 1969' ITEM 010 -request of Robert D. Fewox for property described as: Begin at the intersection of North line of Govt. Lot 2 and East right of way line of Bayshore ; Blvd., Section 10-29-16, run East 767.12 ft., South 499.12 ft., Southeasterly .1153.78 ft., West 2283.87 ft. to East right of way line 'of Bayshore Blvd., thence Northeasterly along said East right of way line to P.O.B. to be changed from R-lE. ' (single family) zoning to PUD-R (planned unit development-residential). The, Planning 6 zoning Board recommended approval. Mr. G. Patrick Iley representing the applicant explained the proposal and showed tentative plans and architect's conception of the proposed two-story garden type apartmehta. Mr. Donald McFarland, attorney representing 6 propery owners to the West presented 4 letters of objection and stated that there are no schools or shopping centers in the area for this type of development. In reply to a question from Mr. Charles Hendrix, 1180 Bayshore Blvd. Mr. Iley stated no dredge and fill was proposed. Mr. Steve Benoris, 1254 Bayshore Blvd., Mr. Theodore Meyer, 1290 Bayshore Blvd., Mr. William Daniels, 1116 Bayshore Blvd. and Mrs. Dewey Linton spoke in objection. The City Clerk " reported receipt of 8 letters in favor and 4 letters n objection. Commissioner Carter moved that the application of Mr. Fewox for change of zoning from R-lE (single family) to PUD-R (planned unit development-residential) on property described above be approved and the City Attorney be instructed to include this in an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance to be brought back to this Commission for approval as soon as possible. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Hall Upon the vote being taken Commissioners Carter, Carlson, Hall and Mayor Hougen voted "Aye". Commissioner Williams voted "No". Motion'carried. ITEMS #13 and 14 amendments to the ordinance were considered together as follows: ITEM #13 - request of the Director of Building to Amend Section 26-11'(1) of the Clearwater City Code relating to building and overhang extensions beyond the building setback lines in residential zoned districts to permit greater ex- tensions and overhangs where the building setback line requirement is more than 5 feet. ITEM #14 - request of the Planning.& Zoning Board to amend Section 26-11D of the Clearwater City Code relating to Travel Parks to permit occupancy up to 120 days provided utilities are available and trailer etc. is capable of connecting ' to such utilities. " After some discussion Commissioner Carter moved upon the recommendation of the Mayor and City Manager that these two items be deferred to May 5, 1969. Motion was seconded by Commissioner Carlson and carried unanimously. Commissioner Carlson moved that the meeting be adjo ed at 6:40 P.M. Motion'was seconded by Commissioner Hall and carried ur?f sly./ 7 Attest: Clerk •r Y. • ?j 1?? ??" s4.d f.'?l',Ti..t',,=V`V ??,?,t•??S'•P 'S' •'#' . .. 4.ll,r? .I.i '!!. -jy3 p 4`? "511;, aV•S'?;t. ,"J'-1?'?1,, ;j. a' .•t• _a?i,.r 'r`r. •.?.,. 'ti,.:;a. rr ?t. s. n .30. e' j' _ b. f• .,s' ,a°a::..::?s, -f •Y r.?'S. ' i. ! :,? t l; iYcj' .ty Yi. .>t,` :.+", • t ? ..F ? ,? s t i ? } r.yy'?. ??{ff?'i .,6N.n, '. S.,r 6f, •e .t:: ? ? i ,'ir'f. ? 4c^ ;?Sti, 'r;i'i1•'?i: . i.:;.:.,, , rr;`?-•; ?.' `F'' wtY •"al f:. r-i; rr:'h' ti•'l' 'i,? •5?;. `t` ,'G`t ..,., .A r..s ••f'u'?' r.., .J?.ti. }? hi } 5?' ti ,:x' .' 'til. 'F: •w•' ., •f"' ,r{; w ,.,: ;€?;. r.. :`Z?f Sl?.k at, t}_?: ,li;.i' •i `? •'J'.a'.i`t',? •'z. ?;f`aXs, y.?+?i'^j,!r;:' {r,. t??f+' y +t•. ._ -j' •t^'if c+.. .-.. r.r- .r.. ...,3.?, T?!".4n.nro.?.r,,n.ww7 wniPrw ?+ ..i: •" j' -..a, !.'1•: '. Tw h.?f?K,F c: ? YI'' 1 Y , ... ... rw? _ if nl•3. Jr ?,+ 7r^c ?r?a't dir. ?,?}ta:l •1,3 .i-',l,5. 1'; :ZV. :". '><. ^, :=" :- 1 i' yp1 ,yy> 1 71 r }?„??}•'a?: it=jj ,,,}, \'4? 1 , f'. •, t?.:` ., 1, ''e ..f; ,a''},. ,?{i: 1??"h,::•,`t ?}E. ?"'as y': t: •:Y :"Ix,>,r?,.. ,?t,, it • 'f ? -i. ' r 1 '` • ''`I •f: !" ? j,. ?M. .l .?'; <.?:.i?':` :rrr/.. !`? r •; ?•r'.Cf , . 3', - \ '? a` J °•?<s,!•',1e I°°t'! v}+ ?3?4 i:. ?" q{ ? :5'i' 1' , y - ;J,• 'try' y.,?, '; { E.}?';'Y..}?i ;f, ,1 f. _ 6t''.'t ,1'' ' 3 :J: r,?i ??•. 'KC},itL? CITY COMMISSION MEETING" • y`= ::,:. April .14,.'1969 i 'o t• ?`.r,' wrwwrrrwrr raw r.,r.. rr w w rrr rrrrw --wrwwMwwss riw+rrrrwrrrw.Mwr wr r'wr« w rw r r w r:. ww r r r w r..w April 109 1969 Honorable Mayor and 'Members of City Commission ,' ; ;<.',?z-`•, City of ' Clearwater Clearwater, Florida Gent emen: The City Commission will meet in Special Session on Monday, April .14, 1969„ at 1:30 P.M t, in 'the City Hall Auditorium for the purpose of conducting a public hearing on'zoning ordinance amendments. i Sincerely, i . :?•r.,=; /s/,M. R. Stierheim` City Manager rrwrrrrrrrwrr-rwrrrwrwrrrrrrrrwrrrrrwr-rrrrrwrrwrrwwrrr r.. r- wwrw.rrww.wrwrr r..rw rw ' rt• Y i•.'s .'f: •'I ri- S' •3:.y, Y i - t,t 't' ,.`' r ?jY.'f'??"{.4i1V. ? r :'r: 'r ? r '? r .r. ,t` i, ? •1 ° 'f 1 1 SS r.- .F S: Lr . i . ??' ?l 'w:? ."?(.• ' t` , ? ?j?'.I ? `•t,'? i• r • t' '.,t •. -, } :r•.y, q r 3' . Mfr , . ;' • r': 4 ' { ..i+'°i;'. > ?• !•? -'}": lilt.?' 1• a'. 1' 1.+ , ";i. •°i •j' . s -.}: .!•_ It -', tt, : _ '•?+ r•;t : r 1. , a' , 1 : i '. _ > e' • : t'•' t' x aY• %•. 4 to :[':. f'a :•?,S?z •.f ?,: rr? Y i. P'li F,oE>?.r z tai - i y i.S, '? d •# - s tire. ,'€: (,'„- ^ t^ .;.?,-,:` ,.J y?yy '>?a #'"y? / -'+. L?,: .f'r• i•>;'. ?r....•i :t' • s• :('..•S r.':.t. .'s r l?v t'h Ta„Y.f }-?t;'1'»,•f?; `•.Y.f?. .7•e. J'i.'s3•. .j''• !r:• _•• i°? :n .(-4i's. 5. xl^• y sf{}j I i°a1 't. _ 's.?i"9i'. 'r a, .;rY; ?>) ` t ...j (, "'y.: •.: k',?;: j?'i 's_y,l,: r 'Y ?yW??•}Ly'? ]??I'yV.r?•w'!r?%tti'.-,r Hi'L ?h:t 1. 1i'T:.,? .SJ%'; :t,{ ^'1`.'. t.? FI" .. ?•?: -A?lA, sf l '`Y`,f 1' yl :•S' j31X 1'.-1" r~?1' ? rti i',a;l ,' ••S'' ,?'r• ;"]+.'?,. '.??,r, .! -i,3 ,,.-..t,,?",.. .;?6?;'.` t." L.]i is ?'Y'?1'!-, ?{ }.?f. ( fe. `.I G' '?,' .\': r v: k.". `.J , ..+ ti+• 1. '`{°. .,?, !" 3"..,.?J,....t, ?;??: q , k.Y_ 1i "1, 'M .? tY ?"'I't.T, ? ?. , )..? }. .,Y ,t • t. ?'i i' J? '?"?'' Yom' ',', ' ? {?.,? . 1'.! ? `'.' ,P'•-- /$ + ,? ,s. ?,3f i, `?- ,?•. ,L.:r$t..?7f:. :?t.`?.+ ;?'-'rte ?',z: `x'.V ,'44!.,,,,..?./fJ :;?,?r•e .'1i •y4:tl .!'.,'rt Yt,?' :•'j.? ,f:.• .t '? IT } 1' ?d R.i Y J "! ? ?>'? k.?i a"" ?•s .y`{r?'g.•. .t.?.l, ,v ry ti ?: :ilk .? •. ,f; ?,. .J?:: ;t4''?i,: j?(",i, d, ..?: 77: ?. ?yr5?"r'tiS', }.. "tilt r, e;',?.(?J'i ?• :':??;k;{1•..?.?vS.Yr ??,v"t?•i.', ?f?,• i ? ?, ??^ .??.;3i .11.y t•,., .:.ir. ;.?.•:e3,.,?.?`.','-?;'•+,,}, ••t, :,3°:•.:?. .r'R....?.5,.x• < iS,?:' .T. ,. °:x?=•.! :? '',t' r;.'Yf,r.t?',.s, ?+.y t''{l '•?.r 1..1 75,,,. T r??'i='? t.15??` .?'.,??4.'#ki''? ;;> 3? l ; ,', ', ?, ( .? ??*. .,r, 1'.`t • ?r - ?' I., it Y ,kQe ! ':Y F,' ay , , :i . '', iil re •?" y,S.f a.?kt. `Ci ? -, °'sl"? '- i•-., lS.• 7. t, a, Ali: rS J^:;5 #t ??• S".}k \ .. ?i'h:r ;;:,?: ry t '-<' ' 1(.,,. l; a`: }r,• i i? i' ~' f k y f ; i ! E? t } )-?"???•. f. e ' e?:;.: •`''":+., ? .. .'':t':? ....?.=`7 t.'.;r:!: , e IT,' r y. •+:.,,Y 1? i'( { i'1 ?: ?Iti?f•iL','?L.;'i ? a;.:it .?':'+'?'.x 'S.ta .,"X, (.' a''r! .?k?;i•?=;,i.°? .±.?? .r.,.+rrw,.j?•??•pS:.K,?li.`S':};1..?°??YY:.S? 'i%^A??.a t't ,i Y'