The URL can be used to link to this page

01/06/1977n � � CITY GOKMI38ION MBETIKC January 6, 19�7 t The Ciky Cotna�i.�sion of the City ort Claarwgenr �aet in reguiar eeesion at the City Kai�.� Thureday, January b� I977. nt i2s30 �►.m., With the folxouing members preeenCs Gabrisl Casereg Joaeph Carwiee � Karleen t�. DeHlaker Karen iiartin Darwfn S. Frank Also present wexe: Picot B.' P'�oyd Thomas A. Bustfn Ceci1 Hender�on Ftank Danie].s Mayor�Commioeioner Coramieaionex Camns�.seioner Co�mieaioner Cotnm�.neianar City Hanager C�Ly At�orn,ey AssigCant City Eng�neer Poiice Chiei The Mayor c�lled the �+eeet,ing to ordar. The invaca�i�n �rae.given by the Reverend David HoiC of Pe�ce Memor�al'Pre�s- bqtierian Church. The P7�edge of A1.].e�iac�ce was l.ed hy �he Mayor. �TEM �3 - IntraducCiaas tts�d Awards. The Mayor pxesent�d Citatiqn� of Appreciat�.on to the Reverettd �hotnas JehnaCon, Pavl HaCcheCt, Dauglae Ort and Dale Pad�n for their d�dicated public eervice. He preaented a- citation and a tYophy to Explorer I'ast No. 97I, aponsnred hy the Data Pxoceeaing Aiv�.eio�. �nd awarded a Certificate af Appointment as Ambassador�-at-Large for the MayoF, to Eagle Scout Paul iinton. ETEi+i �4 -� Minutes af Spec�al Meeting of Aec��ab�r 6, I.476, and Regular Mee�inga af December 9�nd 16. 3976. CommissioneY be}3laker moved �o umend paragraph Chxee of Page 5 of the Deaember ].5, 1975� minates to xead as fa�.�ows: "th8t a1Z employ�ee g�r�.ev�nc�a �.n regard to disciplfnary pr'a- cedurea ox job dtscriminationa shall be heaxd by a hearing officer" a�d to appt�ove the mi�tutes nf �be spec�.al meeting of Dacen�bex 6, ],976, the m3nutQs af ths xegular me�C�.ng af Decem- ber 9, i976, and the u�iautes of December 16, 19y6� as recorded and a� submitted �n �r�,t��n sumsaation by the Clerk to eaah commis- sianer. MoCion t,aas secandeci by Commiseioner Fxank and carried ux�an itaou s ly . ITSM �`5 - Citizans to he Heard re Itams Hot Appeaxing o� Che Agenda. Ra1ph ltichardo� speak��g on beha].� o� tha f3aceoia lnn, �equ�sC�d the C�ty Cammissina Waive A$95a sever costnacCion fce for additiona]. baChroams at the Inn. The Mayor requssted he sead a leCGer to thc Commiesion for cons3de�ation of hie requeet. ' � . Jack Turnbull� arid Jack ShaFt, of Cleart�ater for Youth, . apake of t�ee socc+ar program and requested th� City maW the gras• dn a lot that had been donaCed to them for uae aa.a . socce� field. He aleo,requcated Commiesion incl,ude tihe soccer � program.ln the naxC t�udget. The Mayar agaia recamAe�ded a �� xetter be �writtea. . +�: •„+, - ' � ' . .. . . . i . ` s�i~' ' ' , • • . . ' • , ' .. • ''''7;'�.e'•�r%' . r ' . : . . . . . . . �, , lir�'jil't�^'•'�.r'.''t�.l' ' �xr . . . • . . .. . ` ' . t.'j��L�,',�,}�'.h'�V�'t�^�,'!'!�e?.. •,i.�t�.�.;".'r' :., •' . . .. . . . . ' � .. �, �',f�.`'.''S•T�'�,. �� } a` �,'Yr� �.k' �`� y � , Q��.j�i,'4�'E.ajF':.` '��.:r:. � ' � .. . ' 1�:. • , ' . � " �� . . i1�V�II '_ ,_...� �+ dlnlf2,� _.� �.�k,:.;;��: F : , , }'i'.r � . . ' _�__ __ ___ ��'� ^�r' �� ;.i'i,ti. :.i: �.p�a: ':''r:��,��r:;;:.,,.lo�,�'a}; -t•�t:S1�•d:� ,i:Jy� �e' �'. 1.��,li [�yi �: �vr��. ��• 1f:�A � - Jyl �.F' �` • :ti f !. ',�+�'�•'�e�,. , : i�:�`�Z�t't.'�'r�i ;,;-,��. ,Y� , :� � � t , � � �'�f Bonnin ilardZng requ�ste�d the Commle��.an take aaCton tc get tha Co�eC Cu�►rd sCntion located oa Sand Key. public Heexfe e � ITEh[ A6 - A Public Hearing on Lot Mot�ing Resolutian �76-158. The Ciey Attorney expl.ained tha pu�poen of ta�s pnblic �earing astd requnatad City Inepector Wi1].ard Stewart to re� port on the atatue of 1at claaring actione. Mr. SteWesrt re- ported Zo�s remstning ta be claeced canetiCutad s�snace to pu��ic health, eafety and we]�are. Commiesion discuesed the clearing of Metes and Bounda Parce3 3X in Section 18-29-1G, and Cnmm�.esionex Ma�ti.n moved to delete this item from the reaolution. Cammiesivner Prank eecot�ded Che motion Which carried unanimoueiy. A written recosataendnti,on from the �nvironmentai Planner and the City Forester on Chis property wi.I,X be �orthcoming ahor�l.y. There were ho ai��.aen commenCs. Camm�.seioner Maxtin moved that Resolu��vn �i7b-158. passed on Uecemb�r 9,'1976� ae amended, be confirmed and made effec- tive as �o all persans and paxcels lisCad ti�exean, except for thoae whose lote hAve been verifi�d as being cZeaxed and thoBe whv have paid the City for th� clear�.ng, and that Che proper City offic�.als and,emplayees be directed ta proceed in accord- ance with the ].aw to see t�aC the lots are c].eared. Commis- eio�er Prank asconded �he mati.on which c�xri.ed una�itqously. ITEM �7 � A Fuhiic Hearing to Cons3c�er the Radesignation of State Road bQ and R�solution #76-}.47. (Continued fram December 9, 1976). Re��l�tio� �76-1G7 requeeta xhe Florida DeparC�ment of Tr�nsportation remove 5tate Route 60 from Cleveland Strea� as�d join the City in pl.anr�ing a ro�ste for State Road" 60 which WiI]. be compa�ible with the local land use ob�ectfves. The City H�naB�tr repox'�eci a m�eting had been h�l.d SetWeen the Downtown aad Eastern CaYrfdor property ownera. The di�£er- encea were resolved and language accep�able to ni7. but one party was approved. r Tha Comraias�,on conseneus was in support of the dual des- fgna�iot� of S�ate Road 60, but concern was expreseed r�bnut Che coats af acquisit�.on af right-of-ways and augges�ion wr�rs �aade �a cl�a�ge �he wording in the resal.ut3on. Keith Crnwfurd, Txaffic Engineer, auggeated the conx��cCor rouCe ba piaced close to Baat Avenue. Commiesioaer Caxwise maved ta amend Paragraph 3 of Resolu- tion �976-147 to read� "�he Staxa of Florida �AeparCment of Traaspartation commence acc�uisit�.an of right-of-w�y �or, and construction of, � new road +cthi.ch i+'ouxd co�aecx C�.eve�,ar�d St�ree� Co DreW SCreet, euch coanect�on Co be made east oE East Avenue in C1earWaCer, l�loYida," Commf.ssioaer Marti.n aeconded the mation which carried nnan�.snous�y. Char,�es Finton aac! Joht� Re�kin spoke �.n opposiCi.an �a the co�nactor. route. , � Tom Brown� Cliairman of the State, Road f�0 Cammi[tee� aad , _ ba�m Miaotti� Ch�i�maa pf �h� Task Sorce, epuke �a favor'of � ; tha reaolukioa. : , �: - . , . . _�,.� ' ..� ?:�'�� .��, i` '�" . . . , , . . ' . �{Sa��.r i.,•_�; , tv '' : ' . . , �� F .'4;; �r. s4k��. -'�; ��' ��TM.'i�':l'�1��'.'{:�.`i�;�;��, s..« �, a,' ., .: .ti, . " .�i�ii:w�.1r-i/ f�Le4'�-j�. kl.:-rT,•:_,`..:_ .�ti��=� L`'.', . . � :� . �; '��/�•�,`t` '7�li�f:+��t`I ' ' ' t' . ' ' l i.,k��%if4:v.�..�..�i.��:w�]�ll �°r ' "� ' . ..... i ,'� � , . € t • . Z• � � ,�y � �'4 �� •:i3 3��'(�.�� ' N w ti�.�k� 1,_ y�1�. �; y'. `.,'� �{.. ' Y� � �1!ri��v:•5iji},.��1"3.,4,=.�,,: ;�f�:.a. t �e; r;�� : ,,° . �. ? � .�:s' ;,; �.. �'�{�';'!'�� 2��"�ro.�`� :;k3: -�� 1 3Sa�'��f/�,;�: ;}•• �;.; •��.. �3E.r4 ✓. k��';,'A.yi � � '.��. n.• _ `e f..': ' i i�;Ft-�,_ . ; r:,. .: TM';�>iQ.`jA�t: �::�`�. „'.` �F;lt� � � �,� ; . : : ',, �;t, . , ....'t�':` " .?�..:-••r'�•f ? '!. `�� :i• •�;°�: ..,^ ,�` �,�kvM,�,t��,� �'�;� � �~ `'r��: rti'.��"�:• j � �t' �4f4 y�� y i,.l4r�.ti �t ;..« ..,^�: j, t �!'.t!'f.,�.,. �;•r+...�� ..�>1� '.'; 9.�i�� r.. ,.ir',�.iY e ,; 1:�..y:�... '��lr�. ..'�' �k � �,� 1 ..�� a , �� Coamiasionar Martin sov�d tio�p�� end adopt R��aluCian /7G�1G7, as a��n�ad� and Chat th• appxopriata o��ctal■ b• authorised to exactite •ama. Ca�d3�eionar Fr�nk ■�condad Chi aation whtah carried un�ai�au�ly. ITEM �8 � A�ublic Hearing on Rnquesta for Resoningt a. Change �a�s 12, 13 sad lk� Black F, Fairburn Addition �ro� RM�Z2 (duplex-a��rtmant) Cn ISP (in�titiutional eemi-public). Sverybody's �abeYnacle. (City). , This pxapertq ia located �n the wee� eide of Nor�h Betty Lann beCween LaSalla and Cedar Street�. T�e main church building and parking lot arn lqoated on t�ese�lote. The Planning arid Zaning Boaxd and the Actiag Planniag Director concur in the xecommendatian to razan� Co ISF. Warre� Renanda� Actiag Planaing DirQctor, r�ported thaC Che property oirn�d t�y the ChurcH is located in two dif€er�t�t zones. �he original advextiaing included all of the Churclt property buti it hae now t�eea aplit, The City Attorney quot�d Ord�.nance 111638 whici� a�.lot�r� a e�ange of zanin,g w�.Cf�out �ddf- tiona� adverti��.ng as long as the density i.s being redceced. Thie rezoning is in acaordancs wit� City poi�.cy to xoaa prrap- erty ta ite actaal use and to con�orm to t6e Comprahensive I.and [ise Plan. Commission requestad to cona�der i��me 8�a and S,i coi.-- l�ctively. ' i. Ch�nge LoC� 2 and 3, BZock F, Fairbc�rn Addi- tion, fra�a RM-28 (h�.gh densitq �ac�3ti-f�mi].y) � to TSP (instit�etiona7. semi--public) . ' Lvery- bodq'e Tabernacle. (City). The Church o�ficee and park�,r�g Iot are located on th3s proper�y on th� east side of Fairburn Aveaue betwee�, LaSs1],e and Cedar Streete. The Planning and xoning Board and the Acting Planning Directar concur in this recommenda�i.on. �'here were no enmmet�te fxp� citi�ens on either i�em 8-a or 8-i. Com�aissioner Frank moved to approve rezoning to 7SP (in- sCi.tutional. semi-public) �or IGems 8--a and S�i� and to ins�re�cG the City Att�arney to fncluda th�.e in aa amendme�t �a th� Zoning QYdinance Co be hcoughC back to the Cammiseian ior approvgl as eoon as poesible. Commissianer Carwiee seconded ths motion Which carried unani.mously. b. I,ots FI, 9, 10 and 11, B�oak F, Fairbu�a • Additian. Evexyb�ciq�s xabernaele. (City): j. Lot� ]., 4„ 5, 6 and 7� B1ock F, F�irbnxn Ad-- dit�on. Everybody'e Tsbernacle. (Ci�q). Coar�iss#.oner Martict raovea thsG Ageada ICems 8-b and �-j be deletsd and readvertiaed �pr a di�feret�t zoning. Com�ais- eion�r Fraqk aeconded the motion wHich caxri�d unanimoualq. c. Lots 12, �3, 14 19, 2U and 2I, Block B, Green- r+�od Park;.and Lo�e 12, 13, 14� 19 and 20, 81ock�C, GreenWood Fark �2. C. Wal[cer, et al. (C3ty}. '� ;�.:�.Thesa propertiee�.�ara locat�d eaet of North GreenWood :Y•.1 Av�nue beCweea Gra►nt and Tangerinc Street■ aad axe currentlq .�� . • � • , •. . ,-��.:_: `"��_;: ;: '': • . '� � . , ; t � , , �! �tR,�''4 t V' *;r':• 3.�;:� ��._ �„� ,�.�•. � • � � .: ., � � . , ` ' . . . 'f . , . . r � : 1`' t . t7:::''' .' .(� �' .. % . , t . . • L�� f �tbi�:�..,�;�?��;.�r:i_ .•'.''�'„ ' . �`� ; . : . . . . . . ��.r��1��':,'�h �x�'� tl;� 5'YR.{�yti: i:: ✓. ,�5,,.s;'.•� . : y�� +,I�' , � , '� " ' , �} ��{�. ,}.ri?+' : yj•": ; .: '�;�e ; .t'' ,' ; `�'. ' , . , � . .. . . : �, . ., f3�3e�� ;}hF��,.{e'•..�rfi�tif�y�'!��: •�i�.\l��+3�� ' . 1+1..� _��_�_.._...,._,•�� ' . � ' ��V�77' . . . :� .;`j�''.r'.�1 {;k. ..s.r�; > r,r�i'd . 5 .�'..t.. �+ � �sC C+,=•Y'..vlSiie� y'.'r.a'.:1,:!("' '�1iq. � �.'Y'i+ . Y . . > S� �iK± . ` �� . � � �.�. �.,�yiv.:� =1Sr+",�:s�jS.� �.�� .. y r.��er E�"�� .�� y��.. 1l�i gr. T'� �� a:iii � i.�. y,-4;. :�4� �3�., 7 � ! � 't a r ��`S.•�. Er. � R4��:i�'�i� �'�•:�-1.:.��,d iN"�[��tt:t•4'iT'�� 1'nrR�.yp�i=;r? ��.'� (t " � •,�.'�(} '.. :��'.. . �'f .L"4_', ��`.:''.: .��1y�.i�.a'I ��'�'� 5�� w{� �1��1Y ��i � �. '� H� �1� � , �ylt! s ' fY.a.;��.,F� :��1'{t. .�`��Y.a-�{i",'��=��f•�:�i�'� � `My..•'N`..'�;% ,�'e'L;:�:'i, 'ifi:� � o..f.Y��;�i''�, .i .d' �� `��', � . . ':4'. • �'1#"i:' r,i� j,�;' `��„A' 4r'.. ' i, , . , j ` ..`� � � ��` sonad RH-78 (high danaity d�it�.-tamily} buC hava d�v��op�d �a ■in�A� larily, d�upl�x reaid�ntial n�ighbaxhoads,ae • d�nsity •quivaiene tio RH-S (singla faeily, dnplax �part��nt). R�san- ing to RM-$ xoukd pres�rve th� •x��ting raaidaat�a],.value �nd charace�r and �1so conform to tha Cow�prah�nsiv• Land U�� Pl�en. Th• proparty oMnara objact to,ehi� ahangA ia sonir�g ci��- ai�ic�tian and ar• conceraad xith thr CiCy's long �ange pian. Thn Actia� Pl�n�ing Di�ectotc.■tated th�t an e�ctensive �tudq wiZi ba m�,d• for khs radevalopm�nt vf thir communley aad they thnrefore recammend a conti.nuanca. Commiaeioner Martin moved ta conGinve Itsra 8-c to Jun� 16, l977, and to readvartise it. Cota�aia�ioner Prank secoaded thn motton which carried unaaimoualy. Talmadge itutledge, repreeen�i.ng soma of t�n groperty ownere� guggesC�d all of rhe re].ated �.tema 6e dtecuesed at one time. He stated changee are necsseary but that more Ci[n� ie needed to xesolve the iseues. The City Attorney reported that a continuance cannot exceed a period of thxee {3? monthe and recommended the Com� miseion reecind their prior actiott. Commiesioner M�rtfs� maved to xesaiqd the action taken on I�em 8-c. Ca�nmisginner Frank secnnded the motion whic�s car- ried unanimousl,y. � Commt�sionex Matti.n maved to continue item 8-c for three (3) monthe. Commisefoner Frank seconded the mat�an xhich cax'-- ried uaanimouely. d. Lots 39 and 40, Block D, Greenwaod Park I�2� Ca� be changed fram RM-28 (high d�anity nulti- famil.y) to I5P (inatitutioAa� setai-pu6lic}. Lily White Security Aenefit Aseocfation, I,odge 43. (c�.cy) . This property �acated on the aorth eide of Engma� Street eseC of Greeawood is zoned Rt�l-28 and ie owned by ait organ�.xa- tion of non--pxefit nature Whic� �rould qualify it foY ISP zoning. T�� Planni.ng and Zonfug Hoar� and the Acting Planning Dir- ectar recommend r�zoning to ISP. xhere were no cit�,zen cosaments. Commtesioner Carwiee tnoved to apprave rezoning of Y�em S-d to ISP (�.nstit�t.iona� sem�-�uk�31c), and to inatruct the Ci,ty Attorney to fnc��de this i.n an amendment to the Zaning OYdinaace to he brought bac�C to the Commise�on fox appxnval as soon ae poeeible. Cammissia�er '�e�lak�r secand�d the ma- tian which caxxied unanimout�]y. e. Rexone I,ot 9, B3.ack A, Pine Ridga 5ui�ciivi�i.oa frasa RM-12 {dup].ex-apaxtment} to RM�S (single famiiy duplex-apartment). - �. Carelock. , (Cfty). This property located at the eoutheast curnex Betty Lane and Fei,rmont Street is zoned RMW12 and ' as a duplex raeideatiaZ ares. Ghauge of zo�ting Go �. match the Comprcheneive Land Uee P�an.� � of North �.s developed •itM-8 taould '. . The Plaaning and Zoning �oard and the Acting �lanninA � Director concur Wi.th thla recommendation. �here Wexe ao.cit- izen comAente. � ' � �� .� ;., � Co�misaionar Ca�wise movad to approve resoning o€ Item •$-e tfl°RM-8 {eingle famlly dup�.ex-apartment}� aad to �.nstruct ��''�.�� : . , tha Cfty. Atto�ney to i�clude'� th�s in •an ancnda�enti to �he 2on- �� . " �. ing . Ordiaance �to be •b�aught tack. ta. the Conoaiseion for appraval � �°;�'`��'�`•' �`a�:��oon :as .posai.ble. ' Com�i.�sianer DeBleker seconded.,rhe, aation' � �� ;�."•�s,:-':":3:`��'�`;'` .which''ca�rr�ed'`uniniiously. � . ' . . � �. .' �� . . , ~!f�.7C=, .Se^',��+5 •j:i.• � '��Z:i. . . �. ; , � 't � �r • , . ,- 1 +Yi.••r��.�.Y: �".� ��, ,�j'. �;�:A� � � � ..�' I � . . . ' . ' � . � . . . . . . � 1 „ . R �t•J L(y(. -•�,..''1Y�J5a'E ' "' '.iv:``'S ::_ + . . i� � . ��1 i.y::".� "'�r`i :�: � SC��-�;�:�v�;�`1,�+�if.i4l��k��:`�_;' .�.,�r,;s,c.�' '.',�'. '.ils� ' ' �, ? , �� y ti�� , � �� ' .i�6�%% i�, C�3��. 1,� i ''' ;:Lfs;". `i;.:'r• ;. �1 ,• . , r ' � .'�. �� h �'�.,��.,. '.}s':�,:` ;.]cq'♦ '.�' 1 . �� t� .7;' .. �.1� . . ,.' ' ,{.; 3 . �'I�`�l1.��'�' {• 1:.� _ _ _ f� _ _ .. ,�q:. �.��.lf �'. . r i • . . . . � I i � ♦ • . � � ... � .. , r�•. . t _ �� . �.�rv .... • .... � . ' . . ' � . . .• � � • . . . . .� . 'i�,Yt.' � '. (.�. C.:.l. .'�..x ,fii':rL�Yf•�'�hi.�iiR 7Fi...f-s;ii•ti+^r u�rti.'ia„�S[::ja't��f!`.l::•i�Y .i''i�`.#.�j; P)i yF t"�`t!: � . .�. i°�. :� ;�:',�:�{.x.y':."�',. �'':•;.�.�°.:;7.�:.�'..=! .�'.._�.:ri�:,��a�t�3�`��'.`_ , !i' : . � ..i iw� -.n. �-�`4^ =.�i+: xs.oe:a �4,�� '"' i�.`�.'If� L"'�'��a�'d{;`•';:;'+�+Y?'�sd. ;.��•�:;�kv i�' {,.�'y� i,;f: '�'P.��4t!• :r,J•„n��•fj,..r'4,+y �t": F.,I:. �i�4��y��^•di�j � 3l ° ��' �`"Ps I�'�,�, 1 r' f i��.� �� ', i. .� � E I� ri.i.i�"J'�<i:�i;f4'{ati"i�' y ii �: �.�.,��,, ti a��iY 'y'S ' J^ I e° r t,. '� ,4''� :r �j�i.�` � �{.' ��t '`� •.AI?;.�a°�,�tr a�,�','y.(:�r•;'•S 1,.,.'�c' '�Ci�'s,,1'. ' 1'��`;' ' � . ''�r:, ._ �� ti , � �:i� h�, � 'SSt'�`r �ir -.� r7�1 .,`.� 5¢r �+ �" � r.. .-l�; c J s �.. �L •b 31i� '. `l��..� _. �i� �;:�1..C. m �� :�s : �. Lot 13 (L�a� th• 8outh 6 l�i�t �atr S�r�e�t) aad I,ot Z4� Biock 1�� psi�gti�ld Subdivt�ton /�, to ba cha�ged fram P9 (prof��ional •�rvi.na�) to AM-S (�iag�� laeaily dupia�c-�paxtm�n�). - D. Larkia�. (City}. rhi�� prop�Ytq �ocated on th�, norCh sida ot Pain�eeto Str�at betw��n Wast and Medison Av�nue• is c+trrantiy sonad PS, r+h�ch w�s asC�blish�d to permit relocatl.on and sxp�nsion o� Ldrkine' Funaral Home. Hovever, con�tructton haa ba�n�� delayed by eha cuxrant economic sieuetiian. The aetorn�y for th�n ownex haa asked £or racons�.deraCl.an i� this mattnr aince the site was approved and resoned to per- mit tha uae intended. xhe Planniag and xoni�g Board and the Acting Planning DireaCor recammend withdrawai of�thi,e reqeseeti without prejudice. Comaisaioner Maxti,n maved Chat Yte�c 6-f be withdra�tn withoat prejudica. Camm3��sioner CarW�.se aeconded Che motian which ca�xi,ed �nanimously. . � g. Lot� 1 to 12 �s�c3ueir�e, Hl�ak G, Fairburn Adciition, to be.ctiabged £xom RM-28 (high •dcriaity wulti-fam�ly) to R5-5b (aingle fami�.y) Zas�ing. - Multigie owners. A. Godwin at,c�l. {Citiy). i'his block is locat�d at tha northwest corner of the in- ° tereection of Palmetta Stxeet aad North Betty Lane. It 1e cuxrently zoned RM--28 buC fa develop�d as siagle fam�ly o� duplex re�tdenCial. a� a density of 7.1 unixa per acre. �The zaning chan$e to RS-50 wnu}.d coarply.writh �he Comprehenaive %and �lse Pl.an. The Planning and Zoning aoard and �he Actiag Plsnni.ng Directox x�commend R��SQ zoning. Axthonia Godwin and. Talmadg� Rutiedge spoke in opQosition ta Che change of zaniu,g. , ' Commisaion�sr Fxank mov�d to appruve the razoaing of I�am 8�g to RS-30 (eingle £am3ly reaideatia�), �t�d to inatruct the C�tp Attorneq to incZude thia in an ameadmes�C Co Ghe 2oAiag Ordi�nance to be broagh� back to the Commissian £or approvaZ se ssaan as poesibl�. Commfssioner Martin eeconded �he moCion. iTpon the voC� being taken, Cou�miaeionere DeBla�cax, Martin and Frank voted �'Aye"; Cotani�,�sioner Carwise and the Mayox voted ��Nay«'� Motioa carried, h. Lots I to b Ynclust�►e, B�ock D; LoCs �. Cn 7 Yncluaive'� Block E; and �.o�e i to 6 Inal,usive, . B1ock H and VacaCed Streeta, Fa�.rb�ra Adaftion. to be chuaged �rom RH-28 (high denafty multi- family) to �il�i-8 (single �asui�q-duplex apar�tuant). C. Pugh eC a].. (CiCy}, ' ' Thi,s pxoperty located dn ChQ w�st side of Fai.rbn�n Avenue . � bet�eep Palmetto ,��d �ng�sa�n Strec�s is son�d iiM-x$ be�t dcveloped , � as .a aingle family/de�piex residential neighborhood xiti► a den- • ...� si�y aquiva].ent of an RM�S di,eCrict. . If re�one+�., i� will con- •. ;',, form ta Ehe Compr�hensive ••I,and [1�e Plan aad wauXd Isave' no ; . dnvelopnd property;non-conformiag. � , . . , � . , , . ;;;.. �, ;. � .�� Tha Plaaning aad Zoaing �Board and the Ac�ing Flanning' '�;•��,: r �' Director 'concur ia Che retoni�ag to �tHwB. �. :{i*�••: e : � ,i ..:e, �. ti , , ;•`ri�.r. '�:��. ��i. t�; . : ' . "�rrt�.�' i, `�, ^'• .1. 'r,r' •''� ,5 . . . . � � . ' � ' � , . ' . ��2"R11=yY,Yi:�'�,tr��I`�•..}. �,�va � � � ; .'� . . . . � ' . ." y.FTj�`.��i}';,�c,•.i-' ¢y�f��`_`�l,,r;"�,,�fl'%i��.:: ,: ,Fi, , , • . , /} . t t � . ' i :�`f�`��.''l��f.•'S`;..�� :•, ,f•,;..�:.:ti•• : , ': .. . � � .r_ . v } ^TL' ., f.l� � � t;%y :;' 1,'.•;.:4�;,;f: . . ' a� � -, . , . , ��?.�'�.� 1� ii'ii�'�,' 'r"" 'r.,. i, r��:�: ' 1 � r �y,rs u�}r� r �. �wy;�/r�� r�: [�:..; :. S �: ' "�' . . � �',� ' , , . ' � � , , " , Y' ;y�'�`��k,��.:. �` �'�;��/:}�:,�"� J,' "J - . . . �. . _ ` _-- � isf!'+:,�'?f.��.:4}�.1�{'.��," ..,', .'r�'r;;� ••i.' 'y.� ' 4 .1�Y 7� .. _ ..tr.•. . . _,_, _ - __ ,.�, �... „ :..•fi<;; x�l} 7.• : ,. ��,�:•«..-::`.' :�,.: • ��Ir�l' i , ' " �r`w_ �, `ti��3; Y�.f� . 'N•-.�"S'•��*'ffiY!;j]'�7i�., 'ij: ,� (' y �•.,y, �.�.� �', '�i;f'�li;�rx �' ., y ,o- ,��'�� f3 i_ a. ';�.,5 . �:�.�SE�1f;.',f"'. . _,� ; i',.'Zj r° :v � i.; q•,� A � '� .tiu . • �'.- •.�<." .tJ a: �„ r �-�s1S�^�.�� i.a.�..=�j t��,4,�•iti�w..,�,�f.S�' �'� xv�,',P,t'.tie.��'�''�+��Y:i�w:�,�f��'1 �1� .,;• '�}��F,3*'}{"'S�. � . �} � € T � ` •\' � � �� Talnadga Rutlsdga� r�presanttng tMo pro�,��cty c+Ks��r�, spok• in oppos�tio� end raqueated a coatifnu�nca. QueeCion eros• �boue th� suix af a�e proparCy ownex in Ch� area arid tha City Aetoraey raportad Cha coaxt had t�rken no �ction a�nd a matian har baen filed by tha City Attor�ay ta h�vn kh• is�ua dismisend. Catami.aeioner Carwi,en moved ko app�ove RM-8 (singZe fatal.lq duplex aparta�a�t) zoning tor Ienm 8�h, �nd to inatruct th• City�lttorney to includn this in an amendment Co thn Zoning Ordinance to be brnUghti hack to the Commi.sefon �or approval ee soon ae paaeib�e. Commieaio�er DaBlaker aeco�ded thn motion. Ugon the vote bg�,ng taken� Comm�.seio�sra DeB�e►kex� Fraak, Martin and Carwise vated "Aye"; Che Mayor voted "Nay.'� Mot�.on carried. Iteme 08-i and 8-j have previauely been aated vpon. k. Lot� 15 ta 1,8 Incl.usive, alock B, G�ceen�raod park Subdivi.sion� Co be chaagad fram CG (gen- eral buein�as} Cp RM-8 (s�,ngie faiaily duplex- apartment). M. Val�ntine. (City). These lots lacnted an t�e east side of Npxth Greenttood Aven�e between Grant and Cax�Con Stree�e are zoned CG. Haa- evex, tHere ie an exieting barber ehop lacate� an Lot 2.8. The inte�t of the rcquest was to establie�s a h�sffer betweea the echool property on the narth aide o� GYant 5tre�t and �he etrip buainess area loc�tted to the south along�NorCh Green- wood Avenue. � 'The citS.xans revemled �r�at conc�rt� a� th� Planniag, and Zoni�g meeting that the CiCy was taking away potentiaZ businesa development from the b1Ack community. ' The cuxrenk zanin� ia in accordance Witln �he Lsnd Us� Plan. The Planni.ng and �oning Board aad Che Act�.ng P3anaing Directar recomniend withdra�ral ot th�s tequest ui.thaut prejudice. Commissi.oner tiartim m�ved Ct�at Item S-k be withdrawn withant prejudice. Comwise�.aner AeBlaker aeconded the mnt�,on whfch carr�ed uu�nimously. 1. :tezoning Property �n the CounCryside Ar�a, d�scribed ae: 220 ft. M.p.t. Uy 550 fe. M.O.L. tr�angle Hortheaaterly of U.S. 19 ia the NL� of S��S of t�� (M6� 2) v� Section 31-28-16. to be changed fr�m CP (p�rkway husiness) ta RM-15 (medium density multi-farnily). - U,S. Hame of Greenbriar. Inc. (City). TheYe were na citizen commenta on thia property i�l�icI� . ie locaCed on xhe �ast side of U.5. 19 sbout one usi�.e f�ou�h of 5tat� Road 58Q. The Compxehensive L�nd Use Plan showe this area as medium dansfty.re��.dential but the curranC zon- � ing is CP and shauld be changed Co RM-1G. • A IeCCer from ttte oWner's atCarney requ�sted a continu- '' ance of this item.. � � . ��i.. �= ��. , The P],enning snd Zon�ng, Board and the Act3ng Piax�niag ,-�,;:�,. ' ., Airector recouimeud RM-I6 zoning. The Acting PZartn�.ng Diractor ��:':�%;:;:� '.4, .�■tated the pXopoeed xaning � would a].le�r a tuo eCory t�re].�a-unit l�;: ;.: .. apartnent complex. . � ' �y,��S � �f';� . .''. ' . " . ' ' � . � '�' #"'d�'i�v��;.'e{». ."x_�;,�'�� :��'�� ' � , • �:f �,� �'.��', : • °+" '' '. :- ; '' ' . . _ . . ' . � . � ' � � , i��1� LM1r�I.?�:��• �S:rE; ��1��;�' �... � � . 1 , ,� . .;Fr�'�VS ;•Ys.L�..;:',�f`-xF#4�^'.f��;E°•';�:j{';,.: . .i , ` . . , , - ' � � .�a.��;f��ir;:�',��;%`,:��;�:;..�,,,�,'.,,i<�� :� : .. . , � 6. . � � . � � 1-6-77 � „t �Yl�};Y>�yi�,� 's�ty:.; `r:..;�.4,��' .. , �' , • ;, . , '. . . � , , . '' r '� �,.?;Y �± � �S: � �_ , . . � �. �..-� - �---._.. �.�— � ----- - '� - - - ��i`�i��. �Y1i� ..i'✓.."i`lY.t .'1�: � � l�� ...__ �.�'�.IrT�t��rJu�`".Ft..f��..::��ltia�`��SIJ��:.'.•:�'(�e:. �.: .�:�irw!�s._ ��.I..i%t:'ww^I.J.r.....r.'�it t. aZJ.�.��s.'�.�'�i'i�i��1 .':i:��:: ','�iC_,:'7ar^�'r^�^+:C�';��.u:`ix.� . . . '-�,�',:yJ'��, ,J�:,��:,I.p±st' • > ' }• . r m � m �� The i�iva i� Cha �xl.akanca af camtnerc�at propexty aauth af th� powar li.ne. Kay p�anning h�■ titti�mptad eo li�rit ali com�earciai snnfng �n U.S. 19 erid ta preserve the anviron- marikai quallty a! th• eraa. Con�taiasioner �a8laker �sovnd to apptiove RH-16 (�edium dansl.ty tn�lti-femtiy) �oning far Itet� 8-1, and Lo 3t��ru�t th• City Ateorney ta includa this in aa amaadment to Che Zon- ing ardinanca to be hrought back Co tha Cototsissi.an for ap- ' proval a� saon ne pos�i.ble. Commiseianer Frink seconded th• motion wh3ch carried u�aai�ouily. m. Changc. the 5outh 300.78 F't. of Lot 9, B�ock B, Unit 5 Replet of Manda3.ay Subdivie�.on ��ro�d . CTP {commercial tauriet faci3.itiea} tv CG (general bueiness). - MBT Corporation. This proporty is locaGeci an Poinaettia Avenue betwees� Juanita and Royal Way, an Cleatwater Beach. �The-aw�nexa h$ve req�est�d a change ta CG zoniug. � • �he City Coaimi,ssion accepted an offer in Dsc�mber of '76 from George Ma].lvey, a partner in the MBT Corparation, to purchase Chi� pruperty as Pnrt of a proposed Ci.�y Park. TH� recammendatioa is to.eonC�.nue tttie item un�i1 Jan- uury 20, 1977, to allow suffic�ent time for campletiari af ti�e purchaae agreement. i'he Pianning and 7•an�.ng Baaxd gnd the Acting P1ann�ng Dixector concur with the recomdiendat�fan. Commissionet DeBlaker moved to continue Item �18-m to January 20, 1977, at ]2:3D p.m, Camm�.�sioner CaYwiee eecond- ed the moCian which carried e�nan�.mausly. ' ITEM �9 - A Publi.c Hearing an 4rdinance #1636,- Am�nding the, Zoning Atlas af the Cit�. (Alao ae� xtem �i28) ., There �aere sto citixen comments and the Commissi.on pro- ceeded to Che nexC item. ITEM li10 - A i�ublic Heaxing to Caneider Amendt�ents tn 5ection 17.04 af the Zoning Ordinance. (CTF Zoning). Th�s item had aat been adv�rtiaed and the City ACtaYney . euggeat�d the eitizens pres�:nt be heard as the pccrpos� oE the publi.c hearittg is te r�as�ve infnrm�tior�; and that Che 3tem be advertie�d. The AcCing Flanning Airector repo�ted 5ectian 17.0�+ (8) af �he Zon�Rg Ordinancc estab].�.ahes � m�xim�m height.of 80 fe$t Eor any structure i.n a CTF {comtaerci.al Ca�rtsC facilities) ciietrict. He and the Plsnning nnd,Zoning �oard recommead that elfgibility �equ�rementa be establiahed in ordeX to aesure th�t desirable space, lighC and view relationehipa wilX be maintained i� futuze development o£ areas designated ae CTP. The props�aed requixementa are.ae fa�lowa: a maximam heighC aF.80 feet� pxovf.ded p�aparty ie greater than 200 feet in average ds�iCh �easured perpendicular to Che praQexty Zine along the stree�; 30 feet max�mnm he�ght fox pxo�exti��•lese , thaa 200 feet in depth as detex�iaed above; and �0 feet max- � . imum•haight When more�Chan 75X of Ch� grad�,floor level. 1s , ' ... used for parking. , ' , ''' . ... " � . � ' � � - ;��. ' �- •. � ,'4,`IiC.� .�� • li�t�F!'''�ti?•�.1.' 1i�' •,�-�' �� • , �� }� '• 1 ,��tA.+:'' �/'x;..Y`<��y'4( ,' . .•� � , 'f ��`r �`C�'x�JM' C r �:tr?..�, _y;' :':� t, � , . '�� . .. . . � , . . ��'',�Y,�,�, y`rN�:r i ;�:: �'i�.— ' S.� r ' . . . j!'tjer- Si � `ak;l 'rt'��4'' '� •� , ,-� ��t � % � . YA4~'�'��`.,S��Y'.t:�.� 4.y1•iti,' '.1.,•'i� _t.�i`�•�•' ' � : , . " ' . ' ' . : � `i� �t,�'.'�v:'}.,s„ ' l � �!��i�,i'}��,FP `' �.�.��t t * � E, ��" - ��" .�. �r�' �„rtj';? •'z�ls�s"ly��;Y�Pi�i.'.�'�.�,�',�E•.'Y.w`•: � �'` r`=� fy��M1�� .s�p: � , F. <. , ";ti , _ .. c.�t_'� .':? r. y _ t.t ltr7r�,�,� r:;. '�r .:r � �;:'r.� .,. . � • � .. , . . ' �, :�� '. '. �1 �f ; - 3 � `'1-6=-77. . � 1 ,.5� �# "' . � , •• . ..1,;�t�,�`u: . � �S' • .r�. . ' :A ';�•r.;;;,'.f ' � t' . ,> .i. :a~�.'�'. ': q�;�(,�, :�,. . . ., - � . . . . . -�: �'��:s.� ;4}F:� :�;��:��y�..�..�{5i; y'`�t�txir�"::,:. ..�� •:i��,,.1:�';s:�•,:`��< i1`�l�ti�a�y��3,1it�tN�;`�1�i+�iTS;��i� k3�' �lr.,l,!'�� '�i;�'�: }.'[,y:s�:'.'�`'it'L',V �:•S�ay'.,.-�c t ��ii#�,'rF,\i�'�r �� j.��C' '� r-{�, t y� i�;�,� 'L�.iF r� � k+4i" �.'�„fo�':k"�Y �t.�;��"I-N� ��7 • '.1' ;4+'�Y!!�. �i� Ha aleo reporCad a new CTF �ontng W�.eh ewo categorina is bein� considar�d. One Wou1d requtre tl�e 20D �eet depth and thn othe� Kou].d have atap requiremeate and have 24 units pex acre. Don Si�epson, pre�ident a� thn C1e�srWaCetc Beach Aaevcia- tion� snd Joht� Ras�kin epolce in oppaeition to h�.gh-rise buildinqs. Co�ami.asi.oner DeB�aker moved ta avChorize en ordinarice incorparati.ng theas as�ggeetiona CTF zoniag category and to advextiee eame for Commisefaner Frank eeco�dad the motion Which mouely. City Manager Repor�_s praparation of in the axi.atl.ng publia hearing. carried una�i- ITEM i1�I � O�fer to Se11 Property to City� 1151-1169 Clev�land SCreeC� Bee Realty, Tampa. Lota 14 �hrough 18, 26 through 29. and 34 thxaugi� 37, C�earwa�er Heights Subdivisio�. {Continued from 1}ecemb�r 16, �976j. � The City Manager asked that xh� itam b� w�.xhdrawn as he wae esnable to respand to the Cosnmissioners'.requcaCe at �ha brie£ing seg�i.ari. The ayner or h3.s representaCive was iiat presesft. Commiss3oner Martin moved to continue this iCe� until the City Man�ger can prepare the data requested by the Co�a- tn�.ssion and con�act the owner or his repre�entative. Commie- ei.oaex Franic aeconded the motion Which carried unanfmously. IrEM 1112 - Prel.�suinary General Obligat�an Bdnd Project List. The City Manager presented the preZiminary liet of Gea- eral Obligation Bond pYojects to the Cosamise3on for cor�ai.der�- ation arid stated tHat the Public Worka Act o£ 1976 did not a11ow for the acqaiaiCion o£ property. HaWever, if that lim- ita�ion applies �o futuxe pxopos�d �eg��slaGios�� eevera3 of the i.teme �i.sted would not qual�fy, The projecte on �h� �.i�t includ�d a ci.vic cent�r, l�.bxc�xies, iire statton and traiaing faci3ity� streets, sCorm dxainage, s�.dewalks� par[cs acguief- tion� recreation centcers� pasa�.ve park devel.opment and down- town tennie =CAOVRt�UA. The Genernl Obligation Bond �ssne req�cires a Zong drawn ouC raferendum procees which cun be stopped aC any t�me be- iore the ssle of the boAda if a iuture Publi.c Worke Act is proposed. He recammended the Commisaioa pre�are ta final�.ze Ghe schedul.e by laGe March of ].977. Commission discussed the vaxiaua i��me on zhe list and requested Staff equate the conatruction--aaquisi.tion caets and tl�e operational co$ts to Che mi�.],age to support each i.tem and a pxo�ecCed grass r�venue budget nn an�icipated revenue Che City will receive aver Che aext �ive yeaxe in ad valorem taa�s. Cam�aiesion discuas�d Che tim� �rame, and millage Yequired, aad euggested paring coste on the vario�s projects. They also recommended acquieition af land €or ind�etria7, park purposes. Comsnissianer Mart�.n moved thmt Sta�f prepare a recommen- datiion. set a prioriCy of iteme, the mil.].�ge rQqvired, a time irame and slt�raate fandf.ng ta bQ prase�nted at the February 3� 1977, meetiag. Commissioner Fraak secoaded Ch� i�o�ion which �arried aaanimotisly. � :, `� � ' r. :�•5,,;i . � . . J . 1 � . ��t.�� r . . ... • er . N��{r`J''' ',il;t., • ' . ' � ' ' . ' . .1�: j�� r?RF��`N�:r;'l•� _. � i,' , . .'fi�{�.'+'� ��it,iG i�..��.� : ��3•.��:�' , ^ '' ' • • , yti , �. • ��' }.i;:��l, �":r + : '.7�:,ryi,` .; , ., . � 'i� , . f:= , '. '. .:. s •: '. ; 6 »t�,�'�i(�;;��'a<'R.f`��'j :S'E:;; :�>�::"fr', : ` , 7 y . ;F/t?3�'E�;!l'irtl.i`��}F��\.�'fZh,y:�-. ti ,� �`I':�}`'': , •�F.�' , ; e � . , : �� ,;,�«�'� , j'1ti�A�� 4,�f1.I� "S �•i^'F31 J�1��.i ��X��,.��f.i��l' ��y,�4'yS��l'��.��'"'''` ",�f;%'A?�':i�s�{r ��`��„i'�'�3u ?F!� (T.� ! .�M'..�} ;��4'�.{ti• � cF�?s Nd � f�l 1i:.iyS •�,:�1.; s•I.�.� k�.'..�' '' il.� ;. •+rT��YS!t^!T.;. `.S�"i +SYi�w... tr�''i;t�''�::�,,:. ,,;'Fr. . , .�i�_`�! °; � ' ,i.,y .`�.�. •a�, �r.1..�i � � .�� 'if^; pY�'^ 'S�i �. +`:.,.s:��,,.'.• •,�.�,�;s': N�":`��'k'`4�� •:� I'� } �• Y . , . , 4:: F«%�n: -,� �; �'�,u?t l'r {; ITEM �13 - DoWnCoWc� �Aedav�,�opp�+�n� �lnn. Th• Gity Comr�ins:lan has be�a n�ked to pxovi,da cas��a�rta to a�si�t tn th� daveiopment of a mor� acc�pta6l.e �r�I�[n�fnary p].at�. � Commie��onar 'Frenk questianad the propos�d populatian groxth �a etatad in the raport and sUgga�tad �uc� Wau].a hav to bn done to re�t DovntoWn apace for $6 per squt�rn �oat. At the preeenC Cime it ia rent�ng for half t�nt f�.gyre. Commisaioner Martin asked i# tha concept for aa �mphi- t�tee�tre at tha bn�e of City HaXi had been chnriged to Coachtnan Park by th� Taak Farce. Aom Minatti� Cha�rsan of the Task Foxce, raporGed the �ttotion f�iled. Commissioner DeBlaker expressed apprnval of the plan but euggasted they hold to their professional recammendatioas on State Road 60, making alterna�te suggestione £ox the revita�.i- zation in case State Road 60 is ttot re�,ocated £rom Aawtttown. She recotarnended thsy cax�eult wit� Maae Brothere and othex property awners on the plan: • Commia�ion requested they xeceive xhe prel.iminary plan for review in advance of the meeting ee� for Janvary 26� �977. ITEM 014 - Prelisainary 51re i'].an . of Iraperial Cove Condo- miaium �10, in SW'� of 5ectian 20-29»�,6. - U.S. Hon�� of l�laxida� Inc. AnChony Ba�Caglia, Attorney� representing thg oWcter� r�rae present and stated that the properLy ie Ioc�ted eset of the B-storp I�igh-rise cortdor�irtit�m (Imperial Cove, Unit �9}. T�e original plan for this property ca�Z�d �or CG (general bugi- aese) soning with a planned densi�y o� 34 unita p�x acre. In H�rcti of '7S� Ordi.n�nce �1556 rexoned th� property ea RM- 28 (high dan�siCy mv1Ci�-family) and theq have now submitted a new site plan �ax low--rise air.gle story condpmiaiuA coristxuc- Cian of 30 dwel��ng uni�a at a deneity o£ 9.58 un�Cs per acr�. The area under discu�sion co�sieCs of 3.13I acrea on wttich they Will construc� S sepaxaCe 1-stoxy buil.dings witK G units in each. Robert �+rei�ag, Vice--President, U.S. Hotae RaCirement Division, pxeseated ar► art�.st's renderis�g of the plan. A revieed ovexa].1 utix�ties plan ha� baen aubraitteci to the Uti].ities D�parl•meat. Comminsioner Maxtin moved tn approve Che pr�liminary ei�e plan fnx xmper�.a1 Cove Condomi�tiym i�i0 as submitted, eubj�c� to agproval of the revised overa].1 uti.lities pian by the UC�.lities Department, and that the appropri.ate ofFicfals be auCh�rized to execute sa�e. Commi�si.one� Frastk a�coaded the motion. The Acting �ianning Dixactar stated far the recard t�at if the concept meete witi� public approvai., U.S. Hoine wiil ba amenabls ta acceptfng rezoain� to actual dens�.tq. Upon the vo�e beit►g' taken, motiot� carri�d unanimou�sly. Y�EM 1�15 - .Condon Gaxdens. A nymber a� fasucs have been raised concext�ing Cnndon ,. ; GA�detts. Joseph McPatcs� Aousing Coordinatox, replied to tho�e • . issuee bq vemo of Decesabex 4, 197fi, und W�e preseat. He dis- ... cussed a March, i.97k, copy o� n punah liet af ftem� to be ;• repairsd. The arc�itact, �i�nca th�t tioe, �as'•made xWa inspec- '"�. t.��. . tions � a�, the prajecC �ad eom� de�ficianciee have re�adie�. The i��;.�� :�' �'. Maqor' sxpreased � coace,`rn A�out the l.�xitiy o� thcs contractor �y:r..��::�_ `,:� �." �.; � ov�r :a , ariod og thr�ne . �yr,.,z, ,:., p y�are. Diecuasian eneued on 'who j,��t7.�w'yI •.7��' t•':� � ,. . . � ' . � . . . �,'"•'��4�',,},T' 'i;,'ti:•::._:::�,�s�.<1�. � • � ., i : � . • .. . . . ,��:�,i;��€'�3 p:x+�.�}�`��'`+�.��':.�.':.Y•,_'I^ ' .!�' ',f�� .. � .'(� . • • y . . . � 'i�c �.. ��., I'.�'C��:'' •', ' ,� . . ' ,,• :�i'- ' r� ri��!` � + ,•- ' ' l j'�1[.1 /�,,T' � lii A� .t�. . �'i iF.:, ' �`��.a '. . �' Q .. 7 17 � "71' � ;,+L',n�';f5i:>:�Y.'�tY;ni�'rl:��'I'.t�s�i::.",.`'F:� ,'., ``, } .. . � e+'• , . '•i . 4�. rc'�', • �.i�6�I ! � . s ��lbr+�'' i�i:: ,�='• �, � ;r`.-` � �, i =ti. � ' �� . .. • '�F' _ M•�f � � �i'• .'�` ' i. ,,3,' `5.... y�, �'`?.i�'. i t,L�� .,,�.r��.ePY.b' , ��'j .�.Fi��... . .. . ..'r �.�1 '7' �v.r-, i�'��3 ��'�� kE�' - Y �lw. � 1 j • wS�_�,�i.. � ..� ,��-� � ' . `.:t�' . � m � �� xa� r��po��ibia for ��rint�nenca and Che.,��cxow moa«r �rhich h�d ba�n didtribut�d in �rror. Th• C�tq Attornfy rMpare�d ■uik Mili ba brought tn recovar th• eacra�r mon�y. Whan zl�a �unda ar� availabl�, �th�y w�l! cover rapair�. , Coa�a�,��onar Martln r�ovad that kha C�.earWae�r Ho,u�ing A�tihorl,ey be invlted eo maet w�th th� Caa�raission a�d di�cu�s Cha itam. Coaatiraionar Prank secanded tha ntotian whiah ��r- riad unaniaou�ly. - John Rankin p�e��nted �`liat of unaa�wared q�esk�.ons. �TEM �iJ.6 - Chesepeake Vi17.aa 5tistue Report. . ' r. • j . Zn Apxi1 af 1976� the Gitq Commissioa decZfned to fur- � nish addit�anal func}i�g ior th3.s praject. �here nre pr�senCZy ' ��. �leven uni.ta occupied, s�.x by owners aad five by Cenante. : C�earWaCer 235, Inc., is a dummy corparation that was � ' set up to ba reapaneihle far the pxoject and to protect the City�s interests� The units have been subjected to,vandali�sm. ' The City has af�ered to conv�y the prop�rty t� HUD �n Iieu of � forecloaure but nn s�newer has beea received. . Commissioner Carwis� moved to secare tl�a units at Cheea- peake Villae. Comraissioner DeB�.ak�x aecanded the motion vhich car�ied ccnanimouslq. IT�M �17 - LEAA Graat �- Victim Ass�sCancs Program. (76�A�-23-AGO1) �he CiCy Manager Was suChor�zed by Reso�.ution D76-Z09 . to apply for a Law Enforcement Assis��nce Ad�niniatration (LL�AA) gr�t�t for Cha purpose nf conducting a victim aseistance program in CXearwaCer. A granC tota� of $37,228 hae i�ee� aWaxded to the C�ty, Matching �unds Cotalling $4,13,6 are shaYed equally between the State af FXorida attd �he City o� Clearwater. Cpmm3.ssianex Martin moved to accep� the grant offer in the amount of $37,228 an� tl�at th� nppxapriate off�cia].s be su�horized tv execvte eame. Cor�miasioner Cat�wtse eeconded the �uotion which carried unanimously. ITEM �18 - Apgraval of Poll 4torkers and �hei.r Companea- tion. There is aa �.ncrease ia the numbex af paii workers this year resulting from changes in the e],ec�ion ].aws nnd increasad popu�aCion. Commissioner Garwis� mo�ved ta approv� the ].ist of poll workers� with compeneatfon ot .$40, QO fo�r Clerks and $30.OU f�x Ynspectors. Com�nissioner DeSlaker seconded the motioa which caxtfed unarimous7.q. ITEM lf39 - Autl�orizatia� for New Positions. a. Aesistant Zoning �niorcement Officer - BuiZdiag Departmgnt. � . ,The Bui�.ding Director, Ed B1�nton� r�queated thfs pae�.- •. ,, tion dcse ea the h�avy workload and the precise� accurste in- F��' � formation rsquired for the public. '��`�� ' Commis�iancs� Da8lak�ar moved to a ,., . , , ppxove the position o� ''" � ' � � A�ris�ent �oning : �nforceu��nt Oif icar. Coa�missiaaar Carwiee �;' �::•: - . . ''�{;�._�.�;;,::�.- �,, �'��cond�d tha r�otian.wh3ch carried unaninausly. F ��.F,;�z,�r';: ° �, �. . . . , . �"��'S='.<}.. �,r: ,,' • . . �' � . ' � , . . . � . . . ;�%1?Y;S�'��'i�7;i�;'�t�: � •� ,�� ' �'' 'i' . � ��. ln��c .rj •'•�.'t•.,• i,'�f':,.� �,.�j;'i' ' � tr��{. , . . ' � . . . �•� �xs:r�� ;.yrtfa�3a,� � 'l��.• , :f.. s�'. �' � . .. . � ; � , ' . . �{4 ,i�'t„�,•� .d .i� ♦{rt1 ��.k; ", .4. �'� .,;. �" _i.� ��., :'t,', ��"�'�� t� t r�;•si-f�r• , i ;,�,l;i;µ,j��F` {(>'ti0.��:,'E . ^!':•i'�„ ;'�'��3`.>:,- . , . �-��,��''.:1. . . - .":i , ' . . � — -- ..�Q. _-- , _ ' y �L:.T_7�.�� f.' `01. �. ;`!1� .��.L .5.�� t�o� i�.r��5il..�` e'��.,f� . •�1 � :'-�_.. ��,� .,F� •� _;. '; ... : , �_�. ' - ��'.. ; ��j y '�:�,rf . �43 �.r�r �•rR�rMM`.. . ��` F� f;��rt1 `.tl:� Ah'iir�'F:., �;•� #�'3.� ��.�ir ; y.Y�` '�'3.ti}� `��a�'[�:c �'�r.�'r�y:.,.'r�,A;,6'YJt{�`l..iYR��J S W=.,�,.._. �i#:) �L{=„'7 CWyI�, ti1'��.�,� �.'y,.i'.'�. �ji�`. "'j" i,� �''�'y v'�"%jFY( � 1: '.?�;�.3��' 4k ,:ii�.'ci., ,'}t., "V'5.1�..,.^�w ! "Ei'"� ' �i�.�nAii � y -c ��h"a;�F•'..�,: _� � .�a ai � ' � � l. 's ' . � ' �' : � b. Libreiry Aepnrtmane ' ' �� l� Chiidran's Lfbrax�,�n 1 EtaEax�ence I�ibrarian 2 Cl�rk Typiata i, 1 far PublinaCions aed Mat�ris�a Seceinn and 1�or the Circui�ti.oas Baction. , Justiflcation for theee four poeitions wae taade. The�� Actiing Librarr Director citnd the grovth and increuee in eha t�umbar of patrone requeskin� ]��.brary earvgcee. Coraat�.eeioner Martin moved to approve the pceition of Reference Libraxf,an. Comm�ssioner Frank secoaded the motion. Commieeioner Frank requestad a review nf Che fiae eystem. He a�eo aeked why t� library wae ne�ded on Clearwater Beach. Upon th� vote being ta[ce�� motinn catxied unan�mously. c. Water 5upply Operator fox Uti��.ties Aep�rtmant. 'The Acting�iltilitiee D�.rec�or justified thia position by memo af December�22, 1976, due to an increaaed Warkload and the requ�xetn�n�� of tI�e Environmerital �xotectiose Agency. Commissioner T�raak moved to approve ti�� asitioa of Wa- ' ter Supply OpeYator in the UtiXi�i.�s T}epartment. Commiesion-- er Carwise secended the m,otion which c�rried unaaimoue�y. d. Meter 8eader I, Ut�.�.i�i.es D�partment. This poeition �aas jue�i£�ed by the Acting [)tilitiee Director by memo of D�cember 21, i976� Which etaGed the addi- ' tion qf one m��ex reader Would a�,d �he work flow of the Util� �.�iea Office and the scheduling of billiag at the 3uniar Col- lege compntor. Cammissioner Car�rise moved tv approve the position of Meter Reader I in the Util�,ties Department. Commiesionex AnB�akex seconded the motian which carried unanimoasly. ITEM �20 - AQpointment of Adrrisory Hoard Mambera. a. Libra�y Banrd. Commiesin�,er Martia moved to reappoint Walter Krick and Rita Garvey Ca the Librr�ry Board. Com�aise�.on�r Frank seconded the moti,on which carried un�a3.tnoualy. ' Co�nmissi.oner Mai�in moved that the C�ty Attarney prepara an amendment to the ordinance, limii�i.nE Che Cexm for Library Board saembers to tvo conaecuCive Cexms (6 years). Commission- er DeBZeker second�d tihe motion which carried unanimoUsly. b. Beautificatian Committee. Commiasianer Martin moved to reappoi�t J. I,eater Di,cue to the $eanti�ication Committee. Commiseioner DeB3.�ker �ec- onded tha motion which carried unanimougly. c. Civil Service Board. ;.. Paul Hatchetti hna ree3gQed in ordar ta xun £o� the Com-' , ,.�,mi�aion. Com�iaaioner Martin movad ta continue this item. .�, ��Ca�amisaioner Frank sacanded the motion Which carriad anaai- .. � � �ouuly. �`� � j ' d. Planning and zoning Baard. :�<� . , ;��Y` -��'�,.;�.�� •��oward Crotii'bar �Al�o res�.gned to run for the. Caua�tssioa. E �:,��,t{�%�.�F�;'�,'1�;., '� Cowmia�sio�ri�r �Ma�rtin'��[ovad� to continua, this f.taa. G��i��,an�r .� �- .k�,S,t',ji�w��.r�r1'�;��..s',. {�'�. `;' t:ir:C�r;,fai,r�..:�. ,' ' ' . ; . . � . ' . . , � , . �� `i�y ,�'i�.�: ,IT :ilu''A'_iri;:�' �l' �..�.,�=ri; '�s'.if . �• . ' ,�a� . . . • ' . ' ' � - • � , , •' '�� ' 1�1.�_'j�: ,! r_'. ' . .x.6dw't �.ii '4 ='r,� ��;:�' � .i :i.: '4. • �,� . . � i ,! 3�; S�F. iJ :�r��. Fr• •,; . � .. � . • � • , , �: T. . . . t� ;�,.;.;,c •�`�{;t i.b1i �Tj�ir,.�.�,�.t:+�;�'•a'' '},'t.: . � � ��• ' •� � ., � .��'.',6�l�•� ', .�:=,"::? . r �: � , - t �i4'J��`/�, %V✓��.�`a�.° ii�f.; :•�' , . . . � ��:• . . . .. .' ..arl:� ' :{ �F��l:•'i'i(A[�11y,. , i+i��, �e�'.�` ,�� , ;r:i` �jr.li'•�t, ::•'*.;�:'�'4�;.'.•";:;'�.�'; • .:Y�' �:�� °e«an..ry��(f1;�.bs,.i:, °�'••c".;!'ii��..:�144'''';,�i�:e'�'�':?1! .'"'+7'i � �i•n l � '�.1.'J � � . � ,' � . � , '. , _ _ ��.•.. , , �te 4 ' „ r ' i f . . r �'rank •�car�d�d the aotion xhich a4rried;uaKniaou�ly� � Can�uission�r P'xank n4t�d for 'the r�cord that so�r� n:n- b�xs a! eh• S�auti�ic�►tion Commi.ttan ��re noC att�ading �r��C� 3�g■ r�gular�y and �ugg�read tho�o appo�,nt�ranxs b� texmi.r�t�d upon expiratl.on ci kheix tarms Co ful£ill the �tCriCion clau■e iri R�rolution �76�1G1. ITLM �21 - Changa Orderst " a. �]. to Pav1 Giuli.r�nl. Co. F Xrc. contxact ior Natcth Fort �erri�on Se�n�tA�y SeWer R�plAcen�ent. ($QOO.00j „ xhe prapoaed chang� is in th� intereaC of good pWblic �elations at no coeC Ca Che City, but �rill all.�vinre a tra��- f ic pxQbleta. ' Commissionex M�rtin mov�d,,ta approve Change Ordex I�i �ax the North For� Harz�.son Sanitary Sewex E�eplacement project by Paul Giuliani Co., Inc., at no additional cosC to Ghe City, for a preeseaC contract a� $69.482.00, and that the appropri- ate offi.cials b4 �uchorizwd to execute same. Cammi.es�oner Carwfe� eaconded Chc motio� which c�rried unanimausly. b. ��. to Sur� Coa�t Painting, Inc., contraat for .iacic Kussell S�adinm Pxeasure Cleaning t�nd Spraq 3'ain�ing. ($�M2, $75.Oq) R�moval of the roof of the stadi.�cm ha� revea�,ed �oneid- erabZe additional rusCing and.�cale of the etructura] steel system which wae nat epecified in the o�f.g�.nal contract. It is xecommended that the spat priming�of sgecified ryst areas be deieted an� tl��st the camplete s�ructure be prfiner coaCed. Commission�r F�ank moved to approva Change Order 0� to the Sun Coaet Paiating, Iac., contract far Jack R�ese].1 S�a- dium Press�sre C].eaning e�nd Spray i'ainting, ta add $2.875.00 far a tatal pr��ent contract of $12,849.00 aad Chat tf�e ap- prapriate officiala be aathari.zed to ex�cute eume. Commie- sioner Carw�.se gecouded the motiors which carried unanimoualy. ITEM �22 - Bids. By uaanimoae conaenG ti�e Commiseian agreed to canaider Bid Items 22-a, b a�d c ca�lec�ivel.y. a. Purcitase of fi compact cara nnd 4 compac� pick-•up trucka, 3eBs trade-ins, 5 bida {I in- compl�t� b�d) low bid, Kari Flammex Foxd� Tarpon Springs: �$3b,083.�.6. b. P�srchase o�' 2 fullwvision vnag, �,ess tracfe-in, G bids, law b3d„ Kenyon Dadge, CLearwnt�r: ' $8,987.10. � c. Puxch�se of trucke, 2 partial and 2 ful]. bide. . ICem 1-� Cnmpact pick-up truck, Karl Flammer � � Ford, Taxpon Spr3ngs: $�,518.31. . Item 2- 2 hal.f-�an pick�up trucka, Kenyan .. . Dodge, Clear�ater: $7,897.38. _ �otal: $�1.415.69. ,. � � Coamissioner DnS],aker movad upon the racammendsti.on of �"`� ��- ��the C�,Cp Manager aad the Carag� Supe�in�kendeat, Ci�at canCractE � �. � - � ��"�=� ��" �� ,� for , tha abava ita�s ba awardnd zo the biddera in the aaoesaks +�I,j:�� ,t ' . ' . � . � , . . �iy} �t:��.. , .'i;`�' '��, ;� . ' . � . . .r+l�'...t�a,,...�c ,. .. . , �s�Z� ��,,I;.j: :1,.., ` �� , . , � �y�� 4S'��.:..€, �� .tr..: ,• •. , . , ' • i, r"y5`•' .�q3 eti.':�,;j,i5:ls�r.�.i'. '.y..,i . . �`�k��-� �"}`F''l"�'1i'::•.'.':r��'�'`.�y:.': ..;,�,'<.. ' ,. � , . , � � . � � �'• '. . �� . Q��i'� f�lfl.M1;�'�= '1`L'%.'; ' .:y�.' ..: . .. 1] . ' . . � . � � �i p�q} _�-',�,f�:•...,j�'.'}� �,:.'^; t �2. �1-6-7% r} K� {�1�k�.��+��tA •�l� .�i-' "I.S� . . ..t+e�„��f��!`�°ht� /��::;"rdF^. ��1;�'r.f'_1 � . . .. . . , • , �° '�i , ° . ' . . ... Y' .l��itr` i`{`.'��` r ( ��''.,'.', � S '-:.-:.e t.. °l'� ' .1i , "' `; � ' ��S � ' ;y':�::ir,.�:_.., �, tli:,.,:°�>�. .,.':?+:F^.[trs�„';7^.S"Z;�;�i.;. 1q{ 't,>" .,4�'+,�*a;' �r� �..�,: :6:�'r 1.4'Si �l � . �4 •�Il�, , .t��i�r� €��. �j.�, � Y.I '�... . ��.. � " 3ndic�tad above, Wh�.ch are Che �oNOsC and best reapon�ib].a bid�� and th�t the appropr3,akr of��,cials of the Cily be au- thorix�ud to execute said contracta which eha11 be in sccord- a�ca wi.kh the p��n�� spacifications nnd bi.d�. Comais�ioear Hartin eecand�d tl�a motio� �hich earri�d uoa�nimau�ly. ' Conmissionax Martin xequ�etad foreign vehiclne be cor- sider�d in future bida. IT�M �23 - Other 8t�gineerfng Mattere. The City Manager reported the CiCy had received e�utihor- iz�rion �o dri13 a test hole in nanjunction with our deap We�,I inj�ctian program. ITEM #24 - Ver�al Eieparts and Other Pesidiag MaCCere. None. ITEM �i25 -- O�her Coram�s�iort Actiorz. Camm�,as�,onex DeBlaker svggeateci Che Mayor con�acC the chairmen of xhe var�.ous sdvisoxy boards on atCcndaxtce o� membera and mny recammendat�on Citey may have, C�.t Attaxne Re orte ITEM f�2b - Authorization for S��tleme�t of Y.itig�tion. Properties known as Clesrwater Sand Key Club Ko. 1 (a coadom�n�um}; 137Q GuYf Sou�,evard� AKA Ga�.le�q Re�taurant, M&B 1w5 {a reetaurant}; and M&B i-9 {a �enr►is court) � 5ect�,on 19�-�9-15. The City Attorney stated he had a a�ttiemenC pxopusal in a loag-standing �itigation item �uiC fi�ec3 by Mr. Rebholz a- gaiast the City and ot�er seeking a writ oF inanda�uus to com- pel the C�ty Co eafor�e i�e codes. The case was init��liy dismissed, wen� to Lakeland� and was reiQstate� ta be triea. Since ti�at taLme the pa�Gies have mex on repeated occasi.one to fvr�ulete some method Co mnat the �oints r,�hi,ch were brought up in the litigaCi.�n. Jokn Blaicely� AttoYney, represe�Cing the Sand K�p Yacht and Tenn�.s C�nb and �l.so author�.zed by Che truateea to speak �ot Cuardian MorCgage'Investment Company, stated the suit of Hr, Rebholz #.nd�.ca�es tha� the 25-story taasdnry hui.],d3.rig of the Sa�d Key 'iower {Bullard, deve].apex) ie in v�.olatiqn nf the setback, parkiag and dengity requiremen�e., 'The Bullgrd Carpor- at�,on eold off eome of Che pxoperty as �thoWn in the eurv�y presented by Mr. BLak�l.y, and this sale created the viola�ion of"zoning ordinance requiremen�s. A�.1 adjoini.ng l.aad or�ners �ave agxeed to �his propoaal. by conveyance of various parcels, the g�ranting of easementa and th� e�cecuCion and d�livery of a parking lease �n vaid the parking viqlgtion. �he proposal. allowe approximately 7 fe�t fox an easement fox the C�ty for beach accees. Dennis Saunders, representative of Gnardian Mortgage (an inveetrae�t Gompany) � stated [hey would grsnt act ac�diCianal . eaeem�pC aubject to the rights of Che fi.rst mortgaga ho�.der . {U.S. Stee1.) for a tota]. of 3U feteC. A cogq of xhe,survey was preaented to the Glerk far �he � record. �'41 .� . �a.� . . , . . , . ♦� . i� f,a�t>.r��; � - . , . , o ls,t`i�. t ��. ;�; , . �y��s `l`'1`.��.: ��5:' �'��," . . � ' . . . � v y ir„ �wtli�.�� ' . . . ��;�i��'�Sfl' `` . . . . • .. , . � , � `� ' •'f, ` . ��,.;;'�+�: i , ' � , . Z3. � . 1-6-» . � . , , ., - - � . :r<' .. q�#1t�s..�:� ;�tify7f C. Y!"�SIii�FFa.�.;m.�.:.}y,�. rti�}rEt,:':s7:.:•' .�iy:...c,��°-�'�ipal,�j�r;"�:;.��r'-. i��, . ; ' . f.� i i . ; �i�, �+ . �J.� ."� , . ' r ,^ YM Sv ��FJ;� 4ys.. . tC ,r, �, ~ ,x� .`i 'A,r.� �'li7.� �SC'''w �fr..�i.�. ��': ' �y.'t'�+"y� ' �- :i,". i� �'��y�{� rs' ••I' fr:• !�i 6. �.; � .rKriV:�C:''�.(,.�rY��...x"•� k �:��,`�� t�i� ��fi�•�i \�. F�'�}"� �� r •r. ,i +,�. �, Y �t..�'� .s",,...�1t�- �:e �,^.; •.�,t�+,�i , -�. ,,� :,' -'.S"ilr: .�j ' - 1,; ' . . '�� "` '�.. ' A 4�,K i�•} F �Y.�::y`/iii• ' w;lrvm�•�., ��..� s,y�' .'�'S4"' :a�"4!��w}urlL�j :...%�i': w?1:';z,;(:�Ir� .f'�'�, tw, y� i�_ ,';'T,'^..�.. ;`,, �,. ,"+f,:��:;s•y; :�r{t�.:'4�}' '(�'rm�'I t ��i��(��.,�3`�':iV"`<l e�'�i.:•1� .�i ��',i'•eC�•' f ,* t lr r "yY'�:�.' 1�' "�,.,,":a;i.',l� �`�. ��'�i'°<<;�`��T�i? i',;,t' .t�'4t,�.t.if�.,5., ,i� :�`. � � •t;,� ...��.'•;F ;li+�` ..k• �'�;It� I: 1°''J'�, i' . •' ��`. 5 , ,.�•, c ,. .�� . : ,'•�:.,y;>:��t��r,i ,:.: r'. i t'.�.. .,:;si,� ,. :t;:•, �` '+-'^r� s=^ �ri.:,,:H f�� ;y.,.�• :! ��:'•.?�h� ,.�a'.' •�Y.,a :, :� 3 �N� i'. ° . f . . .. � � ,. Randy Scoatins� Attotrr�ay� r�pras�nein� Top�k� L�std Cor�p�ny Mho 3� int�ra�tad��•in +�ac�uix�,n� tih� propaYey� rsqu��d th�r• ba no stipulation th�t th� �+telats�n� "b• •ubN4�tt�d to eha court or u��lis�d." The City Attorn�y •t�t�d Ch� s�ttl�- d�nt i� •xp�et�d to t�ra�inat� the litigattan• Conmissioner Marein mov�d to acc�pt the t�rn�� a! eh• saktl�n��nt a■ sCatiad in leetar� d�ted Janu�ry S� 1977� eo �� ar�d �tMy,Yacht and Tenni� Ciub� Inc., •nd ta Firsk F�d�ral Snving� end I.oe�n A�soaiati.an o! Largo, whic� raeltion would , likaxi.ee indiaate th�t if the taresa ar� it�pla�anC�d aa can� tain�d in the�e lette�s, that the perCina Wilf ba in ao�pli- ance wfCh boCh tha z�ni�ag and eny other codr• invotv�id� and the City Cammieeion approvne �pacificelly thaC tha rrsetaurant facilities Will ment the �oning requl.ramente and that� ia Addition, partiea agrea to dedicete �o the City an �nse�aenk of tcn {10) feet in character, five (5) feet acros� the northerr�portion of Guardian Inveetor�e property and five (5) fe�t norCh a� that� es�bject to concurreace by llaited Statee Steel (the first moxtgage haldex) (Eaaement °H'� and f�,ve feet diractiy to the aarth per�lel7.ing it �32 th� Way uuC to'the beach). Commiasioner Frank seconded the taotion. .HoCion �ar- ri�d unanimou�ly. ITEhI �27 - Second Reading, Urdf.nancn ALb28 � Aanex�ng propertiee� redefining boundary ].�En�s of th� City to inc�.ude aa�d properti�ts� and establishing.the,Pire Disrrict� �laseifi-- catiion for aai.d pxopexties� ae-iol3ns�s: {Apnroved 8/.5/76� First Reading �.1/].$/76) Lot 2D, Citrus Heighta M�nox lst Addi�ian,�wixh Fire Distr3ct �t2. - P. Gianfilippa. I►ots 7 and 8 and Norrh 75 feet of %at 6„ Uakmount Subd�v�.eion, w�.th F�xe Dietrict #2. - �. .Cehrrs. Lot 10' Block C� Virginia Grove rarrace 5�h Addi,- tion, �al,th Fire Diet�ict #2., W A. Hane. Lots 2, 7, 2S and North 9 feet of Lot 24, Suban�e Subdivision. wi.th Fire Di$Lxict �2. - H. Braakama at al. The Gity Attorney presented Ordinance #1628 for second r�ading anc3 eCaCed h� wouxd read by title only unleea there was a requ�ati to reAd i� iCs ent�.rety. �he City Attoraey read Drdinance &1628 by ti�le only. Co�rtm�sei.oner DeBlaker moved to pass and adapt Ordinance li1628 on s�cond readi.ng. and that the appxoprtate officials be authorized to exacutie i�. � Commiasio�ter Maf Cin seconded the matf.on arhich carried uaanimously. IT�M �28 � Secand Reading, drdinance l�1b36 - Amend�.ag zoaing AC�as., (Annexed pxoperty in Ordinance �1628 - I�em 27} Approved 8/5/76, Public ii�ariag and lst Reading fl/18/76. (Aleo, see Publf.c Hearing Item !i9). The Citq At�orney pr��ented Ordinance 01636 and sCated he wou2d read by title only unXess thera was a requeat to read in i�e en�ireCy. The City Attorney read Ordinaace 01636 by ti�le only. Commiesioner Fxatnk raoved tn paes and adopt Ordinance �1635 on second raading, and ti�aC the appropxia�e, officia�.s be authoxized to execute �a�e. Cvmmi.ssioner Martin s�conded the motion whfch ca�rfed u�animously. �1,�, . . � �. � .. ' , �� . �� t ,• �.� I �•'t.�y� . � , . ' • ' ' ��i�p..a" aS :.�/ ��r'4i�i.. �' r . �I ; �. • . ' �'lf �y�?'; ` ji�' .�� • ;.� ' ^'sre..Y � ' . , ��.{��•,jd:�'�? �;�[S`a�'•J-;;�•'S,�i�,r.�s•,,'•'•?i'Y,�' � e . • • f . . �F.^l,. . � F iei r1��t",fr ;�; � ':v�.�'�4.. $ : . ri ; i. '� `.;.,.,.�', f . �'�('(�3;1A'�i4�$�'<.r��f.�iy�i�f�'�JS�Y�;'�r�a�'�'�t'�r .}.lwy � • Y � � .1' , sR � m � � ' • ' ' '.. . ' .•�. 14• ' �.. ' ,I' '�'.�'� ' �""�}�'�7 , • ., , ' � � , � � ' • . �.F ; .•�'' . , '' �. � � �� 4€� i��'i1+' i:� s ; f. !, ��'v�� / "� �•��4 • � ' ��{4 :M1 1� ..� M :�. '�' '�e ac:� �. s �{I��' T*�1, �7' ir,� t. ��t:.�� s j�� fy�.�r� �}� yi.; �.i`1�,"�:�.f;,�i�''�,•'��1�"�`d ' �f,4i �+'�� ' �' �'� �.'�'`S,'•e ,tr..'4��t �4'':F «:ld [,,-.n„ �--E� i�':•. ,�, .S�U '�a +F ,+i..• ��ii� - `� � n�.• �,::;e: � �'' :�; � ��: 1�, { � , . �.- , t��1• , i,V �r.ril �fsl� f^ y. �'Fira'•.4yi= e �1,'i1 i if [' y:�;.� ` : � 4 2�:': ^� : t ? � `:1.�::^..; . IL� �"l.�l. ' ' i" .1.� .j::-�.l��is;i� ��'.S,'::``'..c':.�. t' 3 : �411 j.f:'si'✓l�,'• t.;s 3S: '�h:;'•M' ;'�;r� q*w�• ^i;Y�"'�-�,��'�r�1 '»'.�.��S.j��fGSf�t�¢ � ' 1 r�µ� i y ;�� „'� � R ?s «fiy `a i;_ir. �"�' � .�_'t� ..t-iW�::t: riaL, j .i�;'.t! ��. �i'�.��•� ;e..',!i :.�' �R�. r' ..,�c 1V� .�wti�f��riA.� ,��r r.r. yzA'�:Lac�-..,1.;.�� f•.•��+��'v. ;.•.�:'tiar;.:v�x r rh rit,-�....� t, �„ ..�� :' .:4;r��f'� ?lx,�•'',�'r.R�'.�-"►^, ,r,',I�l,•,�, l�'� °. 'J7ert;� ;�:�"l.i.,' zr':wyR?�,�^ ' s.Yr. .. � . :�':��'��n�l`.r'.' 'i4'a;� , , �°r�i:�°!�.'��i;:..�4�,,0 ,��' '�-��f?,•. �;��•. ;�a,,,- m ��3 IT�M �129 - Chapter x1133, Civil Sarvice. �.2/lb/76). , S�caed Raading, Oxdine�nce �1b43 - Amanding 8p�ci� �,aWs of T+lorida� I9�i�, Releting to (Puh11c ilaaringa 12/9 6 i6/i6, lne R�adin� The City AtCorney etaeed a11 mmendmenta to the oz�finance sl�ould be coaeidared at �his t3me. Th� City Mariager reporCed receat diecuaefon� �ith the rep�eeentatives of the nmployee or�anisations and p�opoeed add��.ona1 �hae�Qa Which ihey 'had agrced upon. ise racammende thaC Chn pre-�i.i.ed bi11 au6mitted ta the StaCe Legislatfve Dcl.egatian be Withdra�n if the naw Ci.vil S�rvfce Oxdinaace is approved by the vaters at th� Fabruaxy referendum. His snesao of Decembex 30, 1976, Suhjectt "Unclaseffied Per�sonnel in Naw Civil Service Ordinance," liste gositions that are cvr- rently cZapgified and would become uaclaeaif�.ed. Horrever� incumbents in theac� poeiCione Wou].d be grandpareritad pex 5�c- �i.on 2-43 {a) in the pxapos�d Civil Service Ardinance. He recommended the prnpoe�ed amend�enCe b� inc3.ud�d in the pre- filed bil� �,f the osdinance doee not pase. He aXao recnmmended to add �.nta Section 2-43 (a) the foXlowing word�, "r�►nd shal�. en�ay uXl righLs and privil.eg�s heraia." This would also be added at the end o£ the garagraph where it refers to pol�ce afficers and fire fightexs. Commissioner DeBlakex naovad to remave a17. xeference to �i�e woxd "Advieorq" 3,n the title "Civil Service Soard." Cam- miesioner Marti.n seconded the motion which carri�d unanimous- iy, � Commiseioner DeB.La[cex moved to �mend Section 2-35 (a) (5) to d�lete after the woxd "na�ure" in the firsG 3ine. tl�e Wozds "Econfi.derie3.a1 anci/or key pq].icy-determinittg)." Com- miseioner i�rank aeconded the moti.an. Cvma�3.Bsioner Marti.n requested deletion oF �he word "a�so" in the same eentence. Commissioners DeBlaker and Frank acc�pted the change, Upun ti�e vote be�.ng taken, rao�ior� �arried unan�mously. Commissioner De&laker moved ta amend S�ct�on 2-3fi as followe: To amend Sub--Section {b) to read as �oll.owe, '�The di�ector c,f personnel st�all,be experienced fn the management aad adminia�xa�ion of p��:sonnel and sha13 be appointed 6y, sad Berve at the pleasure of the Ci.ty Manager.« Commi�sioner Fr�nk eeconded the motf,an. TY�e City Manager asked that the recorda show that his agreeme�lt with the emp3oyee represent- at�,vee re�iected t�e language befara Che proposed ameadmenC by Mxs. DeBlak�r. Upan the vata be�,ng takea, Cammissioner Ae8laker voted 'rAye"; Co�missioneYs Carwiee, Maxxin and Frank and the Mayar voted "Nay." Motion failed. Commiesionesr DeBlaker moved ta amend Secti.oa 2-36 {�) (4) to add aC tf�e end of the paragraph the follawf.ng, "and/or Civil Service Board." Commiseioner Martin seconded the motion which carried u�ani.mous3y. Commleaioner De83.aicer moved to aa�ead Sactiost 2-3Cs (c) (6) to insert after �He worde "City Mana�er," Che following "and to the C1vil Sexvice Boaxd." Commieeioner Martin aeconded the mo�ian Which carxied unanisaously. . Com�aissioaer DeBlaker moved to.,a�aend Section 2-36 (d) (7} ; to add aC the �nd of the paragraph the fol�lowing, "eacept for �• initial appoiataent of police officere and fire fightera fox ' r+hoa the prabatiaaerq �ez�iod sha11 be ons (1) year." Cammie- aianer Ma�tin seconded t�e motion which carriQd unanimous�y, �;' '; •. � � . � . �`;; , � . ' 'l�,�rf�a�:;�; , �� :. � fr'�! � r 1;.H �'t. . ��' , • :,-; �l�: ��Izi:=��:_ .��:��.. .. � . , .. �5. ., ��V�17 � � Y-r�w"'�.. .? �.��: Y�` , y� `S� {��Ri�c . �rli,' i ��1�- .' fY.s: -f t "1 F• r5Y': `R� �.....t .�:•�� ' ., lry' :' ;.. 'C • t �`n 1 ,t ,5��. ,.5, . �d �'i,': `4.i:' :i'"..;��." , lls.��,� � . ,�� i e"''� "�:', :.� �c�� i t 5�.. , .4c�},1.,. �'s ; „Y', ' ' 1..'.. � ;•Y.i.::.; :'.7�Hr,Gi:.��!e��l?:,'.��y�i�'.�f itl=:iYi�'"t `� , .,, � .. ..�,�� , .. .�' A' , . .._ �.."�,'i�i,��`,��.il'�,y;� •��'��:t%•.:-�� .i:�',: ',, ':.,t; �.; �,.• ..i' � ,3i . ' ' � .r w;ir^a'. ,}fi. S° Y, 'iS',�y i`a i,.�`K'.`'. �4�.. . _ _• . .��.. . i, t 5" .:'r�i '�~�t��;}�i�l�(��'4�. ',�y� �:lrV "i��..' . ' ' ar� . . �'Si'�.n:'it��: '�t��i��•i!�i.i;r�.,.l �`. Tf,,��}` rr� .. .'�� 5(t i.� �.�y. � J ?^ �• ' __ _' lY . ' _. ♦ _ . Con�ml��ionar DeB�ak�r s�ov�d to xm�nd Sactian 2-37. � Civil 3�rvice Aonrd.� to �dd �,n t�r� •l�van�h lin� alt�r'�eh� rroxd "ad�ninietrr►Ciori," th� �DLiOM�tljs� "'Thti:a a��mb�rN oi the bo�rd �ha�]. const�,tuta a quornm and �aah year �h• board shal�. ei�ct ona nf tes m�a�b�tc• as chafrman." Coriais�ioner �'rank sacondad eha moCion which carr�.ad un�n�.mou�ly. Co�n�al,ss�orier beslaker moved Co a�aend Section 2�37 by •dding th� Eollowing n� khe end of tha fir�t paragraphs "end i�ar tha reaseinder of the appi�cable term." Commissioner Carxiea secor�ded ths raotion rrhich carried unanitnoue3y. Comtn�ssi.oner DaSlaker moved to edd ehe �ai],awing to tt�e eame paxagraphr "�ar the initial appo�ntment ta the board� one of the membere appointed by thc City Mnnager and one of ths members elec�ed by the municipal �empiayee� aha11 b� for a term af three (3) yeara; oae snembsr �ppointed by tha City Manager and one member. e].ected by the mnnicipal emplay�es ehall be for e� texm oi• two (2) y��ra, arid the member aelecCed by �he four (k} membere a�all be appoinCed for a te�rm of one (�.} pear. �AG11 appoiritment to run from the time of the ap- pointment and until their successars are appoinced and qnalified«" Comm#.eaion�r Carwise aeconded tihe moCios� �►hich carried unani.mously. � Commiasioner DeBlakar moved to add in line 7 of the aecond paragraph of Sectiari 2-37 after tha word "gr�.evances�" the following new seutence� "Upon requcst hy the C�.vi�. Service Board, tHe City Commis$ion may i,n tts diecretion provide said board indepsndent legal counael.'� Cammiestoner Martin s�c- ondad Che mation. Upon the vote beis�g taken, Commisaionere UeBlaker, Martin and �rank and the Mayor voCed "Aye"; Commis- sioner Carvriee voted "Nay.�� Kotian carried. Gom�aissianer DeBlaker niovud ta amend Section 2-38, H�aring af£i.c�r, �.n the fourth naragrap�t af the section to delete the sentence afCer the wards "I�larida Statutes�' and aleo to de�ete th� �hf.rd paragraph fa its �nC�xety and ineert the fol�owing: "The hearing offi,cer shall then tranam�.0 the proposed order compoeed af findings of fact and concXnsions to the Civil Service Baard. The Civil Service Board may adopt the recommended order pxepaxed by the hearing of£icer ae i�s oxder and order a pena].Cy conai,stent therewith. In ite order the Civil Service Hoard may reject or modifq the cancluaiana oF law and intergretations of adm�nistrat3ve ru3es contained in the proposed order af the hearing o£��.cer, but may not reject or modify the find�,nga of fact unZese Gha Civil Service �osrd determines fram a'raview of the camplet� record and �tr�ter� with �articularity that the findinge of fact aer� not based upon campeteat subst�ntial evidence� or that the proreedings npon which the findings wexe based did not comply with the essential requi.rements o£ �.a4r. The 1an- guage of this paragraph shal.� nat he construed to graat or otherwise germit the Ci.vi1. Service Board �o reapen any hear� ing or ta commence taking nr retaiciag any �vidence or testi- mony. Thereupon, within Cen {ZO) daya, Che Civ11 Sesvice Board u�i,�i.zing Che proQosed order sha�l traaemit Cogethex wiCh a copy of the proposed order ite detexmination,,includfng a determiaatioa of penalty�,to the City Manager; provided, however� tha� the afarementioned penalty eha11 be consiatent rr�,th the facCuaX £indie�ge of tt�e hear�.ng officer, a�d such detexmi.�ation t�rill. a�.ao eanform with Che requiremenCs �ax suc� ordere set oruC in 5eation 120.57 (8} of the Florida Statutes.", and to deZcte the fifth paragraph ia ite entirety aad to ineert� "I�ollowing receipt of the order prepared as pravided in Section 120.57 (8) af the I+lorida 3taCutes, and the peaaleq, such ardGr and penaZty ehel� be conaidcred a fival�order and the City Manager shali be bound to accept tihe i � � , , � : ;i'' y.•��' `i.�T`�1 � . •• [ • . �'� �� /,, ' .1..� ::f.. . j //j' �i�ji,r} 'i.., �i.":•',i� •li'� ;. /.'�'bt1','��t,w�^ ••�t.'i �:r1i.iE•' n . .. F � .!) , , f . . 1 • • .'t'�' .'.' '.. � 16. � . . � � .. 1-b-77' . �#:'aC�4 �'.��W isR';�t:�� •� � r... �;jt�z��„��i�'Fsi,LYY �i',� `lY�'�h1•�'i p�. Y. i `�P.� Q<"li .]� �4,'. ., . p ��.�.�':=,- .� �.:� i�� r... F �. ' ' lY �f��•%,� 4 . /�! . n t�� .1� �. � � � 7'��•.��1 1t,t Y�. •.1�'.J�. , . C�:' t+ ��.� �=,��x4:tY.lh..i ,t , �„' • . `��`� • .tl','..?'.�.�.'.+':i. ;��'1�.� �a1i� .9'S' . { �G�k'.� .M.i�-s��, �� , '.i�. 'L'.,i:y'.. �;t:� r - 4y,� s� ��flrC" �...,�. F `!� .j'.. w .e.. �E.v ... �'i' � �. 'f��.5'�.fr��r�.� �f.Tikti.��.IZ:E.��£i `_'•�; ;�, :�`_ '_ ' . . . , :#_ �� +'f�.+..��i.+a+woyr ' r .,v"y �;' .l .�; -- , ' ��F%� 1i �'�'� �''�'�,?:;•, ,+ ��,'w;,,,sM1 '.��: .;ti :. ,. '��t'. :, ,'}' 1=�-, '•:; ?;;. 1 �"i?��j��, ;�:.1'�;!`'yF.i�'+, 1'.A "w.y`l'.r " ''.:� . '��.. .'e, .s�s�r�.'�`"��..r:r`�a..:'y!i �ii.�'}.1�� .5�.,.��i{l��i•'. �s�<.. .. ' ' �S� . .,1. ,:" .7 �. �.��'�' l� 1!' . •'t - • �.-, �.t��. � [r� �1 . - • '. ' ' �� . i s ��. .� 1^� : 7.S � ' 1 n.S �'�.+v;i� � .. �1 •, f : f.. . ,i .../ • ' f. . ' r_ I�. .—• '1 � " pensity� u�lnas wikhing fi.ve (�) daye, t3�a CiLy Mrn�g�x ■ha11 eeek�further judic�al raview sa set ou� har*in." Co�a�i��ion� ar Fxank eeaonded the n�otian which cerriad vnania�ou�ly. Commisaianer Da9Zaker moved �a amand S�c�ior 2-39 (c) by deleting "privatel,y" in thn th�.rd line ■ft�r tiha aoxd "�xpr�as�" and addfng at the end of tha peragray�h th� �ollowingt "Pro- vid�d� that no empxoyee in the cexeer enrvic� shsll rapr�sant hie oPinion aa polikical sub�ncte or c�ndidattis to be tha opinion of or eadoxenntent by the City oi C1edrWaGer." Com- mieeioner Carw�ea enconded th� raotion whiah c$rriad une�ni.moua- xy. Commiseioner DeBlaker moved to amend SecCion 2�42 (a) to delate itt the �econd lina th� words ��at of tite policies,�� Cam�iseinner Mart�r� seconded rhe s�ation �rhich carr3ed unan�- �ouely. Commiesioner DeBlaker tnoved ta am+�ud SecCion 2-43 (a) to revise the firer tWo Hent�nces of Ghe �ec�i.on Co xead ae �al- lows: "Emplaycses ho].�ing gaei.C�ona iri th� career s�rvice �ot eix (6) monthd ox more �.snmediAtely prior to the adoption of th�,s or8�naaca eha11 be continued in their respective poei� tione wfthout furChex examination, and aha].�, be gov�rned by this ardinance and ehall enjoy a13. righte and pxivilegea herein unCi.l esparated tram their pnaitions a� provided by l.a�t. Certified po3.ice a�d fire personn�X w�iv ��ave h�.Id po- eitione ae golice officer and fire fighter far.twelve (I2) months or more immediaLely pxiaz �o tlie adoption of thie ordinance eha1X be cont�nued in tl�eir respec�ive paeitiane without fvz�thex examfn�xi.on, assd shall he governed by this axdinance and ehail enjoy a11 rights at�d privil.egee hcrai� �ntil separated frotn the�r poeitiona as provided by law." Commiseionex Prank seconded the motion which carried unani- monely. , Commissioner Maxtin maved tv amend Qrdf.nance 1i3.6G3 to �n�- cX�de a Section 3 Worded in the fol.l.owing mannet, and that Che preaer�t Seation 3 and Sec�ion 4 be renumbered ta Sectiatt 4 and 5; "The Cizy Commission ahal� have conCi.nnons p�t�ex to aruertd thia ord�.nr�rtce; however, na such ame�dm�r�x shnl� become effec�ive until and unle�s it is rmCl.iied by a majarity of tite qual3tied eiectors a£ the City voting ei�her in s general election or in a apec�.a1. election called and heZd fax the pttrpose of ratif�.cativn oi Che amendmen�." Cammise�onex DeB�aker seconded t�e motion. Upon �tte votc being taken, Com�sissioners DeBlaker, Carwisa, Frank and Marxin voted "Aye`�; the Mayor voted "Nay." Motion carried. Marcia Warden, repreaenGative of the Communi.cation Fiorkers of America and e�peaking for the City Employees' A8- sociatiott� aC�ted the emgloyees vrouid l.ike to keep the Civ11 Servi,ce Act as i� is. Hnwever, if the oxdinance cannot be de].ay�d £ar a per�.od n£ �ime scr t;hat they could consi.der �.t, they will auppart the lat�guag� currently recnmiaended by Che Ci.�y Managsr and the amendmenta Chnt hava been approv�d. She urged passage of the compromi.�e but with the proviso of a � writ�en at�pu].a�ian that ti�e pre-f1led b�[X1 will be withdrawn ' if the oxdiaanc� paeses ti�e ref�rendum. She stated the cur- � xenC law can be,imptowed ost and diacuased aeveral i�ems that " . � wexe not in th�s best interesCe o� �th� emP].oyees. 5he a18o ,� reporCed t�tat .tElera �rere soate advant�ges in Che new ordinar�ce for the emg�oqees, `;�,�� ,.. Dfck Howard, iraternal Urder of th� Po],ice� stated his . . . � ,�argere3zaCion csn suppart the ordi�anc�, it�til,��!' � •5.i;� i Fil �r�v'��.•;:��'ti: �,�'. . ��;�.�,.� ,•. •;4}�+'�. '��.f�r��t:'•t:,ti -,:iY.� j.�' :�. ' ' , � . ::�-' . , 1.{,'.•;.�/i'.i; 7 .�,,� . . ``� �:i..n��'�.r:_,. ' .. . . , , • , � , 17. '`4�..9'�,. :9 :�' '!�F '��f1,�'�,��,'`rY' �C�s:e;:� .f__ ,-., � . 1•»6-��'. , . ;. � r �4, ' � k ��.. d ..- a. ,Tl �� s� ��.iri.j CS � .It� t�� ;F��.�x'.4,..-�� i�k:f�T�T,'�� r �'• ."t?� �L��.�.�i;;.i�: �r, �"��: '. F��.'ri�.;�,�,'� j4� �j �e t3 f.'.'�,Y �S'� i�a:+v t �, �r : -L . V. � i , � � !�r ' �' �,{c j..' Y ... � �� .s; ib r• s.;:�,: w�if.-�s�•. -'! 7},i�`� '..?i.�1V�';i�.. �;�„��,.45�+�f:�';)�f ' .t'. `< �'r '�'i .3.}' yF.i��- �\i..-�y: .��jf�. .�"�"�',•,tiT�S?�a '�,R;.s.�'�::ES•,F.'1��i : tY'��f��.'xt5��,;"; : s1�i, ��'�i.��.`•.�n. , r '�.:.;.�'Ky Vi?��/,-".; .. ��:':T:. ' . .� •, . �=�J'1'fs'a r'•a � '� l _'d �'.� �a.. �, 3�; v, ','4"� '{ .��.. , "'�;.� i"_ty:� ,. '.i�� -rif.1 �t; �€' 1,' "F�, ��M;',�;J1'��:?�"�� .. .f.�4' .��:tR�:` =A , ,'�'.. �?:<<"�.� -j.: .,E�r. '„�•t! Caaai�sioncr Fra�k ■t�tnd he was gl�d Chat manag�m�ne aad labor had coa�a ta e� agr��nane. Comaisaion�r De8lik�r �ovad that dxdiaaec�e 11643, •��ond xaading� be �c��d by tl.t?.a anly by urianiroous con��nt of th� coa�ata�ion. Commi��ioner l�rank secandad tihe raotion Nhich carri�d unat�i�oue�y. The City Aktornay read Ordinanc� N1643 bq titla oniy. Commieaioner DaHlaker mov�d to p�s# aad �'dopt Ordinance /1643� as am�nded� on second reading und that tha appropriate ofE�,c�als be suthoxiaad tin axecuC• a�sm�. Commis- ■i.oner �'�enk aecaridad the motion. Upon tihe vate bning takan. Commissionere DnBlnkar. Caruiea, Frank end Mnrtin voted "Aye"; the Mayar voted "Nay." Motion carried. For tE�e record, ti�e Mayax stated i��.a concern wae for the 46 paaitione thaC Were removed fzor� Cha carecx sexvicd, w�3ch xaa],d paseibly �1.i.ra�.naCe gramo�ions a£ emploqece to thuse higher paei.ti.o�ne. The Ci�y Attorneq proposed.the foliowiag q�estion for tihe referendum: "Sha�l Chapter 21153� Specia�, Lava of F3.orida. 1941, ae amendefl, be fur�her amanaed by Ordinaace No. 1643 to craate a new c�.vi], saxvice sya�em dealfng r�iCb the falinWiag: Removal of de�artme�nt, division and agettcy lteads from tht civil aervice; mainGa3niug a civ31 scrvice board; including a heariag officer to-conduct emp].oyee diecipliaaxy a�d griev- aace heariAgs; permiasible political acCiv�tiee o� civil eerv- ice enployeea;, allawing civil gervice emplaqeeg ta �oin sad pax�icipa�e i.n employee oxgani.xati.nns; continuing the cfvtl service ete�tue o£ pres�nt employeee; and a reEereadum r�qu�.�e- menC on �13�future changee beyond Ordinance No. 1643?" Com= missioner Carwise moved thet the proposed queation be placed oa the bailot. Commiaeioner DeBlaker secanded the motf.on which carried nnanimo�ely. � ITEM �i30 - 5ec�nd Reading� Ordinanca �1b48 - Ameuding Chapter 232I4� Special Laws of F�orida, 1945, Relating to Penaion Fund for Employecs. (P�blic Hesriags 12/9 � 16/76; lst Reading, 12/16/7b}. The Citp Att'orney again requested that amend�aents to the ordinance be coneidered. � The Coramieaion discus�ed th� additianal coats of increased beaefits relating to the millage. Gersld Weimer, Assiatant City Maaager, reported it wae conceivable that it wonld take an inerease in taxea. Ray Karai.nskae, o£ the Pension Advisory Hoard� r�poxted oa a etudy he tiad mad� �hat moet of Che citias ir� tha Srate have a 2�x bcaefit plan and some have 3�. He also noted Chat at tha preeeat time thc City ie f�sndi,ng a cte�ic:lencq vhich wil]. eventually be paid up and tiite City�� costs �C that time shauld decre�se. Comaissian diecueeed the woYdiag far' the referendam bal- lot and the Peasion Advieary Baard requeated a tvo-part ques- t3on. Charlee Fi.nCon auggasted tihe employees hava the right tia voCe aa �.ncseaeing their deductioa from b ta 8S aad ae the grawth patticr�:.of the City hae deaZined, he euggested kenping the benefit at 2x. Fiost of growth xevnnue pay� fox additianal r�quired servicea. ; 3~�� . . j: . � • .;, ;�;:.: . t: � . � iFt�.k,��`'.��',�e,,;;�� ' � • � � �} =Jyr : . =� . . , '%, . �� ,S.{:��e� `'��. � , .� :" . �' � ` ;:�a"•�;.��•� '�`' ,�.`; �.-' , !': , _. � ti l^y i,; _ . . y i . -. . . . _..: � . •�+�;� •c.�.'1.�.�,;f,:,... :•�,,��..:•.,� ..: � , 4 .� ,� �(:.'R�� ' S� • . . . 'S , . , �,� �4'! �: . �[`'.�.r1',?r.•: ;'r;'.��;.' . '�"y: �^V' 7 �' ��Y "r�:;; .f� , , . . , . �'ig`�;i��:�x�r, `��'. �:'.'.;i��:.�':' , .=,• 1""�1�%% � f ' �'.,ti: "'-�! .'a�.. ..• '.ns-•..r,7=�1� .r_ �P�:ys:...+'y1��'c'[� y'��}N 4i �•r,'''��l �f�"i,E: .1�' :. �h�t_.�.,.�,:"t _�.�� . ..''f�i��Z�� -� •' tea' ".i.�:'•��s �,�i.��.�r?1'��.' +`;'�.;,� ':••frin,��,.:��`: ,.y,4.a;.�Lr'��E�r S�y,S,j'!'3 r�•i •;.e�• ;'.,'.i,4J z' . :S�C.�,;�.��A;. .'I'. 't- � : s'��`r'_��u.,��ifji> ts'n.a� , .'•' . �: '"�,' r. ' � Y�)ii+si �iY' �. �,1, • �� '�1' ' . ' , .S...i': '.,�. .''� ., i . -�,�;� • .�-.�-•.s. � " ,;�, �,*� 4, ; • y'.�^••�L,�.j�Li ,.;t��ti�. s",'[,.._....��1� �.. , :i�`t�� `:.'....��k� i:'�1.+(['��r::� !�'':t;�d �.r.., ..�L',p, ;?F�� 'r.. . 'i;i 't '�!�.:�_�:.ji'a nj:�44GT:: ��.4'�'�: EitYl .\ � ' �.� . :..��/�...�..�:t.r L:7r.'. �'• .: 4r�ttct 'L ) . �1'..� , �l _ `p!,` ' � ^-�" �4 '�N 'li . . .i.' '�r ' F- �.�' �; r ,��j:; �ld�u: � ' � F1, , • �' �', �`+ . � . �4�. : .. �i � . 'li � ,`Fi�` Ray Ka�in�k�• •C�r�d tha Pa�aicn Advisory noard had b��n working on eh• plan fox � y�ar-and-a-i��lf and ali a�p�oy�� group� �ad ba�n aont�ct�d arid th�ir r«praaantativra•�� ia appxcv�A. �h• Doard had con�ulted aA ��d�pendant actu�ry �or advic• in xriting th�ir raque�te. Conmi��ionar M�xt�n �ov�d to a�end S�ction 2-46 by chansxng the m�e�ing d�tQ r�quir�ment� i� t�e lest �aragraph to r�ad as �ollawss "On or b�iore th� fir�e regu��rly scheduled City Co�ni�sion meeting in Juae o! a�ch yeer herna�tier b�ginning With eha firsti such aa�ting in Junn ai 1977." eec. Com��asioa- er DeSlaker eecandad t�• motian xhfch cerr�ad un�nimouslp. Com�iseio�ex KArtiin mavnd Co amend gection 2-47 to raad: "3neta1lat�on of truste�a ahaxx occur at tha firet regular Comm�seion meeCing held in March foltowin� the general muai� cipnl e�ectiiona." Commlaeioner DeSlaker sccn�ded th� �oCion Which carried unanimouely,, Commissionex AnAlaker �ovad to add "or older" to 5ect3oa 2�44, fire� paragxaph� after "who on the date of employmeat axe For�q-f�va (45) yeArs of age" etc. Comm�esioner Mart�n seconded the mot�on which ca�xied unanimously. �he City ACtorneq pr�sented Qrdina�ce ��b48 and stated he would read bp �i�1e only unlese�thare wae.a requaet to read it in i�a enCiretq. �he City Attorneq read Ordfnance ��6k8 bp title oaiy. Commiseiot�er MarCin �aved Ca pao,e a�d adopC OYdinance �1648� as.a�a�dad� on secoAd reading and that the appropriate of�icia�s b� authorized to execute same. Com- miseioner DeBlaker seconded the motion, Upon the vote being taken, Cv��issionprs M�rtin and DeBlakex and ehe Mayor voted t'Aye".; Camt�i.ssion�re Carwise aad Frank voted "Nay." Motion carried. Commiasiari diecuased e�e wording oi the referendum qu�e- tion and can�ensue vaa to have t�ro separate queations, one covering the adtnini.s�raL•ive porCian and Che second to cover the coets. � The Commiesi.on requeetec� T{r. Weimer and the PeAaion Advisory Bosrd retire to the conferenne room to formuZate a set af quesCi.ar�s and t�mporaxi.ly x�cesaed thio item. ITEM i31 - Second ReadiAg� Ordinaace �1649 - Amez�d�.t�g the City Qta�ter, Chapter 97�a, Special Lawe of Ploridu, �.423. Commi�sianer I}eBlaker moved to amend Section 1.01 (c) to read: '�Ths powers of the City under this CharCer ehal}. be conetrued iiberaZly ia iavox of the City. The City �►il�. be empowered to do t+ha�ever i.s neceseary and proper for �he saf�- ty� hea7.�h, cnnveaience and tha g�neral �reliare nf ite iahab�- taats. The speciFic meaCion of particular por�rexs of the CharCer shall aot he caastrued as Iimiting ia aay Way the general poWer etAt�d in CHi.s eectio� of A�cticle L." Conmie- ei.oner Hartia snconded the motioa which carried uaanimoueZy. � � Cammiseioner De�lnker moved to amend Section 2,0]. (c) (4), �� first aenteace o� garagxaph two to read: "iadustrial park � property may be �.eaaed up to thirty (30) yeara with an affirra- � � .. , aCive vota of 4/5th af the City Corap�l.ealon after a duly adver- ., tfsed public hearfng and may ba �.eaead for a pariod of tit�e �� ezcending Chirty (30) yaars if apgraved at a publl.c ref�ran- . , dua�." Con�iseioner Martin aeconded the notioa: The Cltiy � Kanager re�d into the rQcord a etatemant by Aaran Bilgore, e ;`. �a�bnr of Ecaaattic Davelopment Comoittee. supporCive o� �nng �' �' � i.aaaes. ilpon �f�e vote� being' talc�n, Cossiss�.onar� DeBlaker� �, ;.. • � "��` •�� • ' .� Prank and Hartin �ad Ghe Hayor voCed "Aye"; Coa�risaio�er ' �-:: _. . . ;�;;,;;,';;v' � � . .Carwis�� vot�d "Nsy." Hotioa c�tri�d. ' . . a;,�� . , � � . , � , • . , , M.�.�; � ��l'- . � . . , ' , qki�••1� '' 're;�.., � . . ,. , . , . . . ` ' ii�, �1�• .. � , . ' e� ' , . �Srv':�. ;`* �`�� *,' ',��•• �' �.. . , . hl ��}Yy'( Mr•��. . .{ , . �'�'; Y.�Si�`h'•�yi-',�:� � �i��l .�� .. . ' a%i . . . ' .�w��f • :wi"�}�� _�E�� f.ry,1��i��.•ti, .s'.1 t•~'i•,t. ' r..�� . ' ' ' ' � ' � ' . ' � �. � . . ' , . r. a �n�r.�'.1' � �.'. 'ir;.. � . ;�`,��. t f �,�1,� . �'.1.�. ��{:;��1�.IIi+t:�,FF7„?1l��?i1F�^.1:,','�^"+` .�, q5: fi � J�l•. ,��r: �x�.r.�.4: ji`•i�`�)*iYy.it.7. l�tA�`tXn�.[ 4F� t'.-E\,�h1" t� �.i''? •(. .�.'.Z,f�G�. 'r.ff � li` j�"�If�� . T � '.irvfl� �,' y` �i'i' � t =.,: �14 �, �, �� 1t<.' 49,rL , ^�" � +��,f. : f�i�:43.;� �.i .. p �E�'� z:: �'g:'-:3�';'.'��r,:',�i- •'•wfi`•`,. 'r., �'�•?.'.i"�=��,t� ;y:� �°��a� , E �� . . . ' . ' .f �'t ', . � . I .� � �.' y � . I. � w.�ew'.r.�.'1"'. w . � i � ` � ' • rr^)y ��.L: ��t' �•�;toi:;.�rf�.%..1.'�.� • ��' � ��,` � ;'i. �.1.,��.1, S�! � .t't�.i�� -t�t:at`4•' �.l'"1•�� -�.e�','4' ��'" � :��`��:a`:i'�..p,'. ' ,: ;t �:�t : j,�z; , .�:� F�•, •�'' ','b` :;r��'.�4�: :�!h:r;� ;��i ":�..,; ��,T� r•�.'i7�';$'�i��' ��t . s ' . ,�,... : ,� • � � ' . ' ° � �. '�I .. '� � �T�: � .i •1'ti • �;r.�:�.'; � � � :^y� ;�,�;�'r �.,�a� i � ' ti � .e �' i �Y ' i }Y.,}.'}.yti�'�..�,,4,i�E�f.Y '�� a ��.7;' .�,rttg:'yJke�il3 £k} ;'��,��:::��i' +�:��'4' Fr' .'� .��i: .,�. ::�.^• ..P '�,:�y�.c-. '�`�r.'. }^.j.�.I�F��.'.c.' }�. _�..��,.�;�t• h'7! � �`: � f �'S� � 4 �. , . ��` , . � Co�sias.toa�r A�Biak�r moved to a�and SscCion b:08 (b) by ., d�l�ting in tha ��cnnd li�a thi Ward� 'tthirty (30)" and xa- ■�xtiaa th• word� ��Qi,n�ty (90) �" and d�l�ting in th• ehird . lin� th� Moxd• "��.xty (b0}ff and ins�rting th• Mard� "oaa hun- dr�d and tv��tty (120). " Com�i��iori�� Marti� sacoed�d tha �otion xhich carried uaanimaasly. Coua��.�eion�r DeBlak�r a�ovad to am�nd BacCian 8.04 d�Iet�.ng the followiag �ent��c• fn the elav�nth lin�s i�cumbeat Mayor-Cor�minr�ioner may seak a Coamia�ion seat an�incumbenti Commissianar may eeak ihe of#ica oi Hsyor- Cammis�ioner." Commieaioaer t+�ank eecand�d tha tnotian carried ananimously. by uAri or Wl�ich Commisetoaer DeBlaket xequeett�d aa addition to Article� IX� canta�.ning � pravisian requiring rnvennn bond pro�scte be put to publia refeYendum. The City Managex x�ported�.th� public is protected by the offica of the 5tiate ACtor�teq Mho chalZeagee tha validitq of ba�d i.saues. Coam�.s�ian�r Martia moved to add a prav3eioa to Article IX at C�e end of �h� paragraph. to read ae followe: "Such ordinance sha11. in addition contain a provi.si.an xequiring thaC rttvenuc� bonds for projacCe in exc�se of ane ta�113on dol- lare�($1,000��00) be put �o publ.ic refereudum with the e:cep- eiaa of xevenue bo�rde �or public health, safety or indtiat�i.a�. develapmeat and reveuue bonds for refunding." Co�pmiaeioper Aelllaker e�canded the motioa. Gh�rles Fintoa spoke in oppoaitiaet ta revenue bo�de for iudustrial dev�lopment. Upon the vote being taken� Commfse�oaare A�Blak�r� Carwise. Fraak and Martin voted "Aye"; the Mayar voted �'Nay." Motion ca�xied. �omtaiseianex A�Bl�ker, Ldward Winslow, Charles Fiaton and Robert Bickerstaffe diecussed the woxdi,ug in ArCicle IV tihat relatea to the epQointme�t of tHe City Clerk. The conenneus vaa to Isave the wo�ding as is and Che City Maaager appoint the Citq CJ.axk. Sdward Winelot� and Frank Morrow d�.acuesed long-term �esees and suggeeted safcguardls. � The CammiseiaA took their suggestion� under coneideraC�.on. The Citq Atxorney preseneed Ordinance �1649 and etated he would rnad by title anly, nniees tf�ere wae a reqaest tio read ia its entirety. The City A�Gorn�y xe�d Ordinance �1549 by title on�.y, Comsaissioaer Maxtin maved to pase aad adapt on secaad reading Ordinance �1I649, se ameuded and thati the appro- priaCe offietal4 be su�harixed ta airecute� it. Commisaioner Fxaak neca�ded thQ motion Which carried tiaaaimausly. Co�rais�xauer Martin movad to propose tha fo�loW�x�g ques- tiow �ar lthe referanduo: "S�al� Chapter. 97�.0, Special Lar�e a� Blorida� i923� as aoended, be fccrthex araendnd by Ordinence Ha. 1649 to providn a na�r charter �rhich dea3.s xith the foilow- iag: "Graati.ag fu11 recogniCion of home rule government; l�mi- tatione oa Che dxercise�of legielative ppver; te�w� o� office of nlectd8 officials; powers af the City Mamag�r; a syetem o� revanue aaaagennaC; a� i�itiutive or ra�.ereadua ordinance}�: procedure;�;ak�racall procedure; �he conduct of muaicipal elec- �tfons; aud refmrendua� raquire�ent oa a3.1 fuCurn ahaagea to , �Cba,charter?" Co�ul.ssionar P'ra�k aaconded the maCion which carriad uaani�ousZy. ,. r „' � . _ ' _ . � ,�- , . !.5 Z '�Y• `f ' ;�c'-;y '_4', t ,`` ,"t4:i'�:p.��3 � ', , :f...�. . ')'�t�:•�{..y..�.Sc...:.{�, '..1.. 20• .it�+.�'#,+}Y';..t.• ; . �� :'i :� �il['.l. _�� i�: _ 4ep.�i w� . . ` �. r '�7��i'-' �,:f��}'�;'«.� i�: �{3'•'i�;.'f � f�;��' i�li .�.•1..:'�_. . >C ,�� j:t=�h�`...;�.7 f� .. c!v�"' ,. � • � �,�6i'77 }��,t., �s�.��;r:,1 .J.�,t'�"�' ` i�nF a"t ti=•�•l'ni,� ji s: .�;t; � SS - i. ' '�.t . �ii ,� . l � :^'Y�'�`, M iy��11�{'"� °� i `"� '•,r;s;': �?~�':f� :.'�li�. ��,'•�f. _: �� _ Y ��, � "� ` ' , , h . �;�.y • � � �i . � ��7�vs � �x: f�nti � ��65� �� 4 ��. � ',»Y�} � '1':�'`yri;�i'�:��l��rt ,� � 'r± '' �i �,4�t:��i�'��' ��.�x ..'�.. . L, ', �_�� c8•�j'ii� -•'€; ![�i'{� t��i�Wj �`�1' �� ]��Y�'drr4.��11'..�YM�F ��:'� : ; i ',� � �. ti .:<: �ty�y ,� : .¢. � , ,�' ,:j"., �f�';}��i.; 'f I� xhe Co�m�ssion re�urned ea Ordinanca �i16�48 aC thi• tin� to discuas tihe wo�cdi.ng for the question ee Che rafar�ndu�. Rayframinaka� preaented the followingt 8�ct�.on A•hall re�d� "3ha].7. Chapker 23214� Specia� I.aws �f F].orida� 29G5� t�� mploqeee Pension Plan, as a�andad� ba �urth�r a��aded br Qrdinance 11648, to p�'ovide a pensioa sqstatx for t�uAi.cip�l emptoqeee dealing Ml.th the folZowiagt� vest3ng of ewploree peneion rights; Cotal rnturn of nmplayee peneion contributions; penaiot� be�nfits for children of deceased enployens; }�drtsian b@aef�t rnquiremeate; truatnes to administe� paaeiva plxn; an employee p�nsiori advisory committea gnd n referendura re- qcsirement os� ali fntu�e changes beyond Ordi.nance �1648?" SecCioa B shall read, "Shall CE�apter 23214, Spacia3. LaWs o� Plorida� I945, the Eraployeeg P�neion P],an� ae amended, be �urther amended bq Ordinance �].6�i8, ta provide for an increaae in pension benefit formu].a fram 2 pex cant to 2.5 per canC per a�aum baeed upon year� of service nnd to provid� for a� in- c�eane in amp7.oyee� contr3,bution frosa G p�r cent to $ per cet�t a� salary7" Camnis�ioner DeB3�ker mov�d to adopC the language oi the pxapased que��ions fox t'�e r�Eerendum aa Oxd�.�aace �Ib4$. Com- mi.aeionex Marti.� seconded the motion. Copnmission diecuesed the wording of S�ction B aad Charles Finton qu�stionad the Oxdi�nas�ce a�ating the benefit provisioa ehall be 2.5 per ceat. If Quest�on B is not paaeed at tefer� andum �he b�nefit wiX�, remain at 2 per cent. �he Co�nmiesinn expx�saed c.Quce�a that the Sectina �1 ward- i,�ng doee not inform the citi�ena af r� poaeibl��iucrease in ml.�.lage and the cost involvcd. UpaA the voCe bei�� aken the Mayor voted "Aye,�' Gommiesion�rs DeBl.aker, Cartt�ge, Frank and Martin va�ed ��Nay." Hotion failed. Commisaioner DeB].aker movad that the language for 5ection A of the queetion be approved. Cammi.seioner Carwise seconded the mation. Ugon �Ch� vote being taken, Comniseionexe DeBlake�� C�rwise, Fxank and Che Mayor voted �'Ay'e�� Commie�ionex Martin vated "Nay." Motion carried. Cosn�issioner Martin moved that Che Citq AtCo�ney be iastruc- tGd tio draw apprapxiaCe Wording �or Sectiori B of the question far the ballot and thax a special Commiasion meeting be I�eld as soon �s posnible. Commie�i.ot��r Frank eeconded �he matian. IIpon the vote beiag taken� Commiseioners DeBiaker, Frank and M�trtin voted "Aye." CommieaioneY Cr�rwriee and the Mayor voted '�Nay." Motiun carried. Com�aissioner DeB3aker movsd that the City Manager be auth� exized tc prov�de: a. fesll and camplete e►dvert�sing fot �hs three Urdinat�aee aub�,�ct ta referendum, b. capi,os of Che pres- et�t and propaoed Uxdinancea �nr pubZic use� c. printing and d�.aCribut�ou of flqera ar brochqxee summarixing the proposed chas�gee, and d. aet an additio�al to�rn m�et��g �or gablic disc�aeion. Cammfseionex Frank seaoaded the motian xhicl� car-- ried unaai�ously. ITEM i32 - Raaolutiox► f76-160 (Canitinued) � Reaffirming Oppoaition tio Metropalltaa Plas�niag Organizatian for Pincllae County. � The City Hanagnr reported S�. Pekarebarg ia oppa�ed to ;�'; . �. , the KPQ �or PiAellaa Caunty. Co�rni�eeion�r Hartin moved ta �';:. . . , ' ��`s�l', tr` .1.. .f' .5.= I • � • .. ' , ' . �ic,��, •i�c :,3 {,�. ,', ,� , . . . ��' � }i��,pt:.i'.f�' "°� ;,.': ,.;,.i.^`;;�.�,', '. 2:r�Y?,yt�:� . .'i,:,t .,..�, i�.- -• � . F,.: :l.R�t�� ...ir •!�, .aT� -LI: . . � , 5 � ; 2�i• ' s 1"'6�77 ' �� •.5 ;5, - � �� Y P �n �\4?�.,�'4\lt:' "'q� �.`• ,.``.�il' �1T.4 F 'i��:��:. ..;1_ ..� ;�.��' ��c.: JT�'!':�'i`}".rtY� yh, N � A'. .iK"'; , '". ;. '�:"Y,�„ _�=,fr':•.,�";''—:d:.�;:. � :��•a•:-<. i�f.`. '� � ,i w '� ,1'�,i '.j 'r..;:'• Kr'a..��"� ��Vi� f� c ; y .._�' p . . , 'l,.' : �.�_t; �G . . . . .i; ..-,,.: � t'<+}�r { .� r r ;� r:: . ' � • • r' : . f F' ' Y'`,}� C C" [�°, y �� ,�i.� `�(!�}.t.}�.v,., :.1'. .� <' . �4'..t'� �5' � i I4e. �R: tEi ('l.'.:°.:., �r'� ��J.�':.Y\i�' l � �l� .. .'i,Y': i" !' •i,: 3, `y.!�"i ,"�_Stii,..i Ki., }. N.�' ��.�. h� �I� ..A " . . .. :�•�'.. .. :�� y� ,i' •� � ,'�i':' ,.1+, �: ._R;` : yiri::.`"Ttv �''.!��,",`�. e..�;su°'�:,:ty:��,�,.:.t:C:.��.�:3.<r"% .. .:i�;� � • ' �`tt': ' � . - , : ; 3 �yt,'��.-i•� �;' x'��' :> ,''„ i � '` ' _ •' ' ' ..,:. � t.: �t i .;.'.f¢ , � t . M!Y"r�, ••r'1��•lL1.!a � ' i:K«.m.SyL1•`•�� ar -w.._1'J� .� . �� :.. ,ttt� �t;l �.1 �,�Y �R l�1 �`1� �i' .(.� I+ .. �1� .�.. . 1��i�f'��i: r�. �4`.j�(.'i: . _ �� _Z�`' .�' . .. ��J a .''��',-" '"r`,i';.j;: �t:- .-`.Ju�:�'��,Y'"., ,a°�,�`1'+t`�4.q•J �.' �� _ :?: J'�.'-o-��'°`> � �s� � ' ; �.sr, , ��.. . » . .'t ' .� :'.�..� � {'• ,, i . '7t:.. ..St C, !i: -,�:��t.:;. . �:; '-'?� � �:.li.'-rLsr?",'.a�.,`i�.��fr'-1!� " �,",lb�. .e. , i .. � ' . �'}�', ji � � ., _ ., • . ��'4, �.� ', � � ,.. �t. !".} .. iT".0 pa�s �nd adopt R��olut�on �i7►G-].60 r�aflixdia� oppo�i,tioa to tha craatien of • n�v Mrtrapo�it�n p��na3ng Or�anisstiou for Pin�llas Gountr �nd tha appropriaCa o�ficiais bs auehorisad to sx�caCs t��x�. Ca��t�stacear Franlc •�coud�d khs �o�to�. Upoa th• vote b�ing taken, CoraisRion�x� bi�lak�r� Caxri�a� Fracek aAd N�eztin vatad "Ara.t' Th• Mayor votsd 'tNay." HQtion carriad. � xTBM �33 M RasoluCian i77-1 w Authorisiag Puy�ent to Briley. W�.7.d - UCi11tq Revenua Certi�ic�tse, Seri�s of 197g. CT 1586. The Ci�y ACtorney presented Rseolution 17�-1. Cossi.�- e�.oner Carwiee eaoved ta pa[sa and adopt Resoiutian 1�77-1 a�utt�- axi�ing the Truatee of the Co�nstrucCian rruat Pund to pay Briley� �1i�.d an� Asaociaties for nnginee�ing servi.cea perforea- ed in Che sum of $4,428.9$ and that the approprie�te officiala be authorixed to execuke asme. Commiseioner M�er�i.n secouded the mation t�hich ca�ried unanimouslq. Y"�SM �34 �- Autharix�ng Exeaution af Note ta Ba�tnett Battk of Clea�water �or Purchase of Laad frosn KBT CoxporaCion a�d Authorixa�i.on �a Lzecutc Cantract to Purchase. {Lote 4�0 8 & Pt. Lot 9, Hlack B, Maadalay RepxaC �f Unit 5}. The Citq ACtarney preean�ed a note fran Barnett �latio�al Bank of Clear�ra�er fn ti�e aum oi $185�000 to pu,rahase prop�rty on CiQarWater Beach, Commies�,aner �arw��G moved to appra�►e the note w3th the B�rnett B�nk ot Clear�*at�r in the as�m af $185,Q04 aAd t��t the appropriate afficials be auChoxised to exccute aame. Comnti�eioa�r Fraak seconded the iaotio� which carried unanin�ouely. The CiCy Attorney pre:sented Agreemeat for Purchaee and Sa�e of Real �state beC�reen MBT Corporatioa and the'C�.tq of ClearWater for Che iollowing dasexibed property: �� La�a 4 through S and the Sau�h 30U.78 feet o£ Lot 9, Bloc�C S, Maadalay Replat of iFnit 5; . . , . for a to�a1 purchaee pri.ce of $250,000. Commiasioner Garw�se rnoved ta approve the Agreement for Parchase and Sale of Aeal Latate and t�sat Che app�opriate oi- ficials be a�th4xiz�d to execute it. Comm�esianer Har�in seconded the mazion which csrried c�R�ni�tac��,q. ITEif �35 -- Autha�ixing Ex�c�tina of 5�nitary Sewer Ease- at�nt Agreeme�C w�.th Fiorida Power Corp. (Countrya�.de) Ttte C:ity I�ttorney preeenCed ChQ Sanitarq SeWer �esement Agreement vhich is f,ri spproved form aad has bean xcviewed by proper departraents. Commisr�ioner Frank moved to apgrove the Saaitary SeWex �aseme�t A$reem�nt betWeea FXarida Power Corp. and the Ci�y of Clear�rater for-a ten foot Wida �aeement in the 1+i�T�C of Che NW�t af Section 20-28-16. Commissianer Carwiee aeconded tha ma�iou. Upon the vat� baing tak�a Cor�miaeioaare DeSiaker, Carwiee� Frank e�nd the M�yor vo�ed "Aqe." Gom�to;i�eione� Ma�rtin voCed "N�y." Hotion carri�d. � iTSM �3b - Authorizing �xecut�on of Agreemant for Tennie Pro£nanios�al �t McHullen Tanx�is Ccmp].ex. f '' � �' ' . . . �.�•. � The City Attorney presaated an Agreement betvean Joha �. � �T�I1�/S�, RAC� thn City� which �,s in proper for�t. Co��ia�foaer ' ' . . , � . .. � t. �� 5;,: � �' : r . . ! ' : . ' �'C . i• � ; � �. . : . '; i �', , , . `"54'�, � ':'�. •� ' 'I�'il:�:j •�.. ��K�..��f ?.�1� �'::.��.'p::f.� '}•,.,^, � . �; : : . �.4 : ,:. , KS'.f • 1' "y" ... y Ei.�,'. i - � F' �,,( �,;'f,4j tt.'i 3tt�'?r;F��±;�5�`4�`'•ir'� •�•'I . _. . �,. . �i-_.'-_._f�_. . �i;' � .. , . i� � ,. . . �f.i• � . . . . • � 1�6�7 ! f �'j ;• J Y '1 t'� " ?: �.' � ';k '..��,_�p� .. t'' 1 y 4 7 � kie .yr�� 1'..�i � ;i �{�'Y��'�fl '�:+'�� f�.i.w. . � �. Y� .��t�-,'.�:?�SEhS� tf.3',�y yx ��nr }'.i:a i'. : .r.ti,,,,�1.-�!.�' �.t'.,.?::.. ..,! ',:sr.`}�.....� ., . �a- s3� r. :i: t'�ry `,,«ir•'�t��:a�.��;;�,.;_i�:�;..�:�;S�r::n-°,.�''i �, 4:��:�F�ta f',��r;�Ffi�. „y. j.7��.}S..'�p31..' • �T' . 7:' '!,f i�Y �� ,.'.�.-' .'.:�� ..F,=,} �,:,..-I�t;x. :.,� i �.�... „� . � ,i 4 .� ; , �;YS'.'"'y�'�1;?;�•:i.T;��'4;J°,''i'��?3''��.r ��:�'�:�1'�.i,�`Tki,�.�� {�.��.�;+�rr.;•L�—.�Y,.t.�.k��,isfT�. Y� "��)), ''4f.�t �� S3"v;x: :��•s:�S:;'�,�ai'� • :� ',,k�!v� ':•i�•:.. .rw "'.e<';i�",e � �?'�j �. �.�:1�}S,(u.'ft _ ^•'' i,_ �r . . � �� • =.# e � + '; i,. *� ;. �� I� . t � � 'ari.y„ �-�g'1� :.t . �j�.'r:'.�r ,�� ,�tfs" -��"4' �` f..� . ��f: Y'}^y��ir•' '.ti:�r� _ : �r �l_ .sis'4 ' �;' '.s' .�� z' .t.� � �'r�-'� °'; i,' 0 L' i�: i ��. �t�, �, ::�i: h�ii- =:;i,L i �.r.4, �;�`'��; ��:`�...� "? l•�'':�` i�'� : ?�c f �,�a` i��+`��li{ y ,. • A.tj��1y�� faai� `', � • .�`� ;;jf,l�r � n 'j � !4 r. , __ ..�j �$� 61 . , r'I'•; r', �iti: Da82ak�r moved ta approva tha Agr��m�at aad�th�t �h� �►ppxopr!- atr ai��.cial� b• authoxi:ad to axacute ss��. Candi�ston�r lrank �acond�d �he morian wh�.ch c�rriad unanisou�ly. � ITBH �3i � Lot Morring R�aoluC�tin �77-2 (Li�t �14). Co�r�is�3onex CarMi�� woved ta pa�a and adop� R�solution �77-2 aa� ehat th• app�copriat� oflici.als b� autho'Yisad to ' ax�cute sana. Co��i�sionar D�Blakar s�cond�d th� �otl.an rrhich carri�d un�nison�ly. ITEM i3$ - Acceptance a� tanemdnt. The City Attorneq presented an easea�ent £rom Hnrold F. Haye� et al for a right-o£-way aased�o�t �n the SE� of SE� of $ECCfOi1 3-29-15. Ti�e AseiaCaat C�.tq Eagineer reparted that thie sasement ie needed in the construction of Sandy Laa�. Commi.asianar C�r��sa csvved �hat t3�e above in�trument bn sc-- cGpted and the City Clerk be directed to recotcd aame fn the Public Records of Pi.nellas Coun�y, Florid�. Motivn waa sec- oaded bq Commissio�.er Martin �nd carr�ad unaaimously. Meeting �an adjourned at 10:10 p.a�. , ITEM #40 - True�ees a� Employe�a� i'ension �und. The Commisaion reeumed as Trusteea of the Peas3.on Pund. A peneion for the widoW of Aenry Paeco was to be aonsidered ia the amour�t oF $2k9.$4 par maath retronctive ta �he daCe of Mr, Paeco's death on Jaauary 4, i973. The Penaion Advisory Committee revieved the peasion cZain� and reco�qmead� ti�at �C be gxantad. Commiesianer Martin �oved �o approve the pena�,op in the sam of $249.84 par moath. retroactive� to Janaary 4, 1973, ta Hrs. Cora Y.ee Paaco. Commiesioner Carwise e�scunded the rnotian which carti�d unanimaueiy. The raeetiing adjourn�d at 1U:12 p.m. At�ast: .��. Mayo r-Gotnmia s �.a . ' C y Clerk �'��,• • � ' . . � ��.:;: ,; � � ' . ��,i� f•'� ' . ' . . � �� }�, �1 !`�. :,�.t /: �� '' . ! . . , �R'�:! � �''`1��<� '..� ,;� . . � t��i�,¢:�,';A.}.,��.�;;`�• ,� . . ' � , f �':l,: X ��iL�'�� :�`. . � • ' •. • . ,�i �� *'- Y'� ,1: , , `' � � � ' � I, t ':1 , : . �. '�?M' ,��'�'21's'`. ` A' '�1; �::4��iY,,• �� r:.�„�c��y.'•'��t.�:�a�, J,�r,,�,:, 'l�r . ��. � _i�. J'y=' ti. �;� .: . .. . . •y3 "^('�:� 1: � Ir � . . . �. ,Z J • ' . J�� `� � ]i� j3J �.'� :vM1�.�'�_�(r�f:.�t .w." t.i .; l":'� li[ � • . . �y� ��j'��,'�' � (;'6'��,. �:.i�`) � f'.. ;•. �f ' ' .. +!�.'�� °: 'o� '. "`{a-�. : '� '�s� 5.y] k �4;��kt,i_ tly\i;�:;V.f.1`• •i�f�"�x'.' �vf�-�e�r�,�a�'A-�.'�F�+�.�r�i, i�{F.�ry�.�� • t!P°�. "1 .'i� . fi .-t'i: �'L , ,, �.`E. (y. .l, 1`. . ' ': J�'. „',E.'.in ., .� ......r.»-.�s^:• , }� p" � :t r't.��+,ft�,. :(�,:'J"„�/.' .`.� ,��'t...! 't, �st.t'�� '.:j�: ?3`i4�?��. .lr- :��k., �i ,f• �f��:':' '�.: � � �. �` 1: . .��,-..• :�,. F.r `, :s �r6.'4. •rY.%1�: +:'e'Y': � � •i:' :v� :._' , .+.. ,,�'; 6Fr:� ::r'. .�} .�: Sti�:.- ';. ; ��t.e w «6LL',�t•�. � 4 :: � -r; .:-,x rF-n I . .....Y " �1 t..bt's-PIY.�Y�wL=- � �. . �. ' �r FINAi. AG�NDA - CI'1'Y COM�Y33IOti HEETlHO - �anuary a� 197T �'P�1S ACTS 1. InvoaatSca 4. P1Ed=� o! Ail*tfMna� 3. Intraduction• � Auards 4. Hl.nut�� at Pr�caeir Spsaiai Ka�Cfng o! G�armb�r 6, 147d �Coat�u�d), nnd R��ular M��tin�• a! D�cemb�r 9 and 16� ig76 5. Ci�iz�n■ to be t3�ard r� it■ms Hat App�arinq an Aa�nda Pttblia H�nz+i,n�s_ , . 6. Lot tioul,n¢ R��oiut�on /76-158 7. s.roiurion /78-147 - Rad�sfgtsation of �tate Ro�d 60 (Continurd7 8. Requ�eta for R�zan��t ;:,•� � ' . .,-:•_' . - . � a. Lota 22f 13 and 14 glac4c F� Fairbu.^n Additian to ISP (C�.ty7 b. Lats e throu�h 11, 81ock F� Fe�irburrs Additian to RH-� (City} • c. Partions of Gre�nsaood Par!c to R`!-8 (City? d. Lots 39 dnd 40, Grnanwqcd Park Na. 2 to I3P fCity) e. Lot 9� Block A, Pirt• R�dge Subdiviaioa to I RNI-Q �Cityi t. Lat 13 (1,eas 5outh 8 fC. for ntx��t) rutd Lnt 14� 5pring�finxd Su�. No. ], ta RM-9 (City) {to be ufthdrawrs) �. Stock G, Fai�clsura Addit�on to �tS-50 (City) h. 8locka D. E and i{, Fairburn AddfCion to i • RIi-B (City) � i. Lots 2 aad 3, Slocle F, Fairburn Add�tion , to Z5P (City) I j. Lot� I tnd 4 throu�h 7, Sloek F� Fnirburn Add.ition to RtS-e CGity) ' k. Lots ].5� 7.6, ].7 and 18, Bloek S, Green- wood Park Sub. ra R,"i-8 (City) (to he wi�Tidr+�um ) 1. Praperey ia caunrrysiae area, Mt8 2 in' 3�etiott 3I-28-15 to Rl1-16 (C3.ty) m. South 800.768 ft. of Lot 9, �Iocfc Fi, Uait No. S R�plat, :iandalay Su6. to CG ihlBx Corp.) (to be conttnued) 9. drdinanca No. I636 - Amending Zoning AtZaa o! tha �ity � 10. Amend:u�rit o!' Seczirsrs 2T.Qu of Lhe 2oni.ng brd�,nance . Citv Manar�er Reoarrs l�. Ofter to SaII. Preperiy to the City - 1257.-11.69 Clavaland Stracst � Bao Rna�ty, Tax�pa 12. Pr�iialinary G88 Prnjaat� 1�. Darmraun Redavelapment Piari� 14. Prs3.lminary Sit• P1ast 15. Condon Gnrdana 16. Ch�qap�aka Vi11aa 5tatu� Report 17. 4EAA Grant - Viotita Asnfatanca i8. Approval af Poll F7or:cars and Their Camp�naatian , 14. Authorf.xation Fcr Hew Poeicfona; I a. Aesiatant Zaning Eneare�ement 0liicer , b. Librsry � I e. Elriliri�6 Daparta�nnt - Watar 5upp1;� ' Oparator • d. lJtilir�es Dnpt►raaertt - Me�Car Raader I *3. . , .r , +. . • ' 1Z�30 P.K. ON �.. Rev� David Holt-P�ac� M��sorial Pre�byt�rian Churrh 2, Lad by th• M�ya1r 3. * (See beioW) 4. Minutea approv�d w�th car- r�cCioa Co 12/16/76. 5. Rs1ph Richards�wa�.vr 8950 � a�eMnr,cannection �ea-Oic�ola � inn resCirament Hoa�a. Jack Turnbull and Jack 3heW xep- resentatives of Clearvater - for Ynuth reque�tnd Parks 6 Rec. morr eoccar field as�d � Commigaioa con��.der aoccer progrem ia neat budget. Bonni.e �Hardi.ng � Actian to get Coaat Gnard S�ati.an for Claarwater. 6. i,ot Mot�ting R7fi-158-DeZete MbB (31) Sec 1.8-29-16 praperty Confirmed balance af R76-].56. 7. Appxovad R76-147 as amanded 8. a. Re�a�ted I5P b. Readv,ertise c. ConCinue for 3 montF�s , d. Ttezone ISP e. Rnzone RM-8 f. W�.thdraWa wit�aut prejudice g. Rexone R3�50 � h. ltezane RM�B i. Rezon� ISP j. Readverti3ee ic. Withdra�tn Withaut prejudice 1. Rexone RM-16 ' m. Gontinne to 1/.20/�7 4. No citizen cottmeats L0. Authorized adver,�tiaing L1. Caatinued - Repxesentative aat pr+�seaC. • L2. Staff pxepare recota�qendatioas L3, Commission coamentad oq plan l4. .5. �6. L7. L8. L9. Approved sub�ect to Uti.litieay Dept. agprovai (Imperi��. Cove) Meeting planned with Clear- watsr iiouaing A�Choxity Approved secyring buildinga Accepted $37,228 Grant Approved a.Approved b. Agproved Refex�nce T.ibrax- ian c. Approved d. Approved Maqor preseated -.cf.tatianr� iox Se�vice to Board Membere Rev. .�ohnaton, Paul Hatchett, Dongla� O�t aad Dale Paqd�n. Ci�atfa� and traphy to �xplorer �roop i971 - sponeored by Dar� Procees3ag Diviaioa. Certi#icate af Appxeciation - Paul I�intoa - Esgle.5caut. ;,. ��f'..s: , . '�!`llttii,' �I�'.+i ' . s " + � ' . ., � � : �4.'t.yi?�,�#1:�e;, q;` :�t;: 4;• •„�,,�• .lSr , A • •- . . �;7��.�� ( ��''S:r,�, i.:.�,r ��'.`.'f% ^�,�.';t:-�t;=, •'i.• . � ' ��' .ii��"�S'_Z��s�z�.��i��:��;' '-1�'�.i�. , , .� . '�:'n��! I ��. . �.. ; s�, r r•. 'ryi ..r. ' � � . r• . . • ' ... Jinuarr 6. 1977 . , '`, --- - ---- � ' . -• . ��.' - ;`'' :�, .�i . - I ':'1 ..��.� ��.)'y:��:.... � ;�:: ' 4.� 4'_:. '�_� s�ty�iE. � sF t•.?`' .s3.:iE� �1:.. . ;}`:",,.tr,.. , , .,y „ ,,e �k�.a.� '� � ��t:t�'a.,,N�;i , �..w', - _ �i' • - ` �r:'i•,�:E�.'a.: � F�a,I Vr� •`•<.;�fi • ,.z� r �, er.�t�¢� '°ti�. ��. . . •s �,i��,�i`f�-•:��..t;i':"�?�"L: . r""��s 9��ti:.t.,si'.4�.,^ •;` .`}.• .. � i��^�. . . . ': '�<' > L' F��t.4•y�: '1�. ' 1�. , . . , . ,'it '.i''''. .'i- 4. ', .°,.: � ,�.: • '-� � �. . . . � , � . . .- .. . . � ' � _.�.......�...... �;. . u S"' ` �y.,�,yyii�,'riR��'�� 'i.. . W• '� � q . � � • � : � : i • .'t, . , ''.it a r.' �?i;� ��ti'3•,�',� 'i'.:i�i',';f:r, �; ... ' ' = ,;i ' , .. ,l... , ' •f''ire' ' �i. '*.�' .` y.. . . . � . . ,��•• �r .�a1 i I� � r . •, .a�r,i�l; .� �If�AL AG�NDA - C2TL COMliXs3I0H l�ETxNli - Jantta�'y d, I977 lai� 2 �� 20. Appoxntsrnt of Advi�cry �aa�rd Hrmb�rtir � •. Lib�arY b. a�autiticatiore a. civii J.rviaa eoua d. Plaz�ss3.r: ane Zonin� Eoard Z1. Chan�• ard•rs� ' a. fi North �'oM Kar�itan sanitary S�u�r, �l� Q�tIZS�S1� CO• XAC• sa.00 b. !1 - Jack Ruassi� Srsd�usn� Pras�ura Ciunin= and SQr�y Pa�atin;. Sun Coa�t Paint3ni�. Sna. ltZ,�?5.00 22. 6idtt . a. Ftti'Ch4R� a! �ix (a! eompaat cars urfd lour (4) coatpact p�cic-up txucks, 5 bids, (1 ineovpl�C� bid) lou bid, Karl Flamm�r Ford, Tas�pan Sprin�s, �3d,t183.3,a �. Pureha�• af t�•ro (2} lull vistoa lan�, 4 bid�, low bid, Kaayon badRai 38�497.I4 ' c. purcha�R of on� tl} campact pick-ug aad tuo tZ} k tott pick-ups, 2 pazt�a]. and 2 texl� bids. lov bid, 1Cwnyon podq�, . s�.,sxs.ss 13. Other �n�is�e�ristig :iat ;�ra , Zu. Y�rb�l Rsports and 4cher Pandi.sti� tistt■rs 2S. Other Cortt�iaaiaR Aation Ciri„httarr�wy Renorts_ 26. �lutharizatiart !ar Stt':3.amsat a:E Litigat3on 27. S�cond R�tdins -�rdi�asic� Ko. I629 - Atuiexirtg Lot Z0, Ci;t� li�ights Hanor 1st Add•n. (Giantilippo�� i,at� 7 C 8 6 K T5 !Z. a� Lot 5� oa4aaour►e sub. cc.hr�); [.ot ln� sl.oex c, vir_ �inia Gra+rs Tarrace Sth Addn. tl3ass�} and Lots 2, 7, 2S i!1 4 fti. a! Lot 2u, 5u6us'e 5uta. �$s�akama, aC ali (Approved 9/5/7s - Ist R�;d3rt� ZZ/!.8/76) 2a. Saaortd R�adiA� - oratmm�a+ .�o. �.aae _ a�.nasa� Znn� Atias o� eh• Ci`y (Apprnvad 8/5/76 �, lsr lisadin� 1.1/la/76) . 29. Sac�ad ReaQin� - Ordiaanca Na. i8v3 - 11rn�nding Chapt�r 2Z15�3 Sp�c�al. Lasrs o� �3.qrida� i94i, Rrl:tin� ta C�vi� S�x+vic• 3b. 3�cnnd Rwadisti� •• Crdisu�nce No. 18Y8 - Amanc3ing ChaptRr 23724� Spac�a], Laus ot F3,o:ida 1°4S, :ist�xiss� ta Psnaion Fu�ed !cr F.�g�ayees 31. S�annd ��udits� - Ordinanae No. I64S - A�anding Chapta: 4710r SQaaitl LtWs af F1o�ids, l.923, Aal�a�ia� to Chart�r tor City ot Gienrwatrr 32. A�aclut�on Ka. 76-3.60 CCon�tis�u�d) - R:a!lirming Oppo��tiaa to htatropaiitan P],anair�g Organiza- rion !or P�ellas County 33. Rrsaiutian - Au�harizing 1'ayrR�nt so Bri].ey, uiid � Ut3.3ity Ravanu� Certii'i.catas, S�rirs of 19T5 34, Authorizin� Executfon of Mota io Sarn+a� Bank v! C1ear+ra�Crr !ar Purchasa oi� Lsnd froaa tSBT Cax�p. arid Author�::�3,on to �xacutn Contract to Fuxchaoa 3d. Autliorizing�Ex�cution o! SanitA.*�y saw�r �aae- w+a= A�r�un�at uith f'lorida Pouar Corp. (Countryaid�) 3a. Aur:tarizi.n� $x�aq,iort a� Agr�+meat !ar T�nnis p:of�asfana�l at Mc."tul.l�n T�nnis Compl�x 37. [.ot Howis� Rasolurtian � �� '�~ 38. Aac�pxancQ a! �as�man�� S9. Adjqurnm�nt • ya. Trustesa o! Employaaa' P�nsian i'uad vl. Adjavsnm�nt ti �. � , . i . ' ' . ��. � � � � . � . - . ' , , � • ' . � �':, ;�. i�i:.':i' � � . ' � � .. . • ' . � . � V € `'!}' ,5r^i. � ,�'.H 1 .`+J. . ; r .0 : . . � . '} . . 5 . , . . ' ; �rY��,� �;N r:V�i;; �.,-,: ;Ls�.:.,.` : • . .. : „ .. . . �x.s; ; ;;•a:•'�. '�'' . . . Se�u�r��if,�°��L7ii.:�'�i� - s� • , ' ' � . � , � �x� so r.rt. �� 20. a. Reappaint�d Waltar Krick and Rita Carvey. C�ty Attora�y ta p,rapara �ma�dm�nt� li�x�tin� ' te=a�e. . b. Reappo�nted Lasker Dicus C• r,qP�t�ttlRQl'� d, Continued 21, a. Approved b. Approved zz, sias. 8'/ b. Approved coZl�etivaly c. 23. Citq receiv�d autihority to dril3. tee�t well for decp wel.�. inject�.ot�. � � 24. Np�e 25. Ctimmiasione� AaBlaker euggest� Mayor ch�ck with Committee citairmen're attcadance of nembere, etc. 26. Appraved se�t�etneat aubject to grantiag 10 foo� eaee�eaC, � 27. Ord. i�62$ - Paesed aad adopte 28. Uz�d. �i].63b - Paase� aAd adapCe 29. Oxd. ��fi43 ae araanded - P�Baed and ado�ted. - 30. Drd. }i1G48 �s amanded � Pasaed as�d adopted. • 31. Ord. �1649 as atnended -- Pasend and adapted. City Managctr Co prepare £lyers foF public on 3 referendnt4 it�ine aad have cap3,es of o�dinances available for pc�blic. 32. R76-1G0 app�ovad 33. R77-1 app�oved� 3G. $1Fi5�Oq Barne�t t�ote approved � Re�l EsCate Agre�ment MBT gpproved. 35. Appxaved 36. Appraved 3'7. I.ot Mawing R77-2 appraved 38. AccePted ROW eaaeaent fram Heqe.and Ahodas 39. Adjourreed i4:1Q g.m. -G0. Approved Pasco Widow Per�sion $249.84 41. AdjaUrned 10:12 p.ra. ' . 1 � Jar�usry !,. � x97;7 0 ` ' �.� ' `;jr,.,,,''S'�,f `�. '�° c g:?�� '- :Y.(�r'S��*-d.:) ",.: , y� F�,�,.. '1v�;*;+ s��f'V'�'itiil' ¢'�i ,iL `# �t,� i�� I ��' ,;i " . :.f,.�'.�;ty` �•j., _�•,, ,,,, �:� k �=.r°1;31nM� �G 54ri0?� �•Kti..p,', t' r-� •�i:,� : 'ri��. �1� 9 .j. ';Z�l� 3 �'w�`�'"�i,a!::,..fa ;rtA�:�<,t'�r�`t: ,._r "s=�' ;-,�, '. �._ . ,•' . .'" , .� :•:4y, �, -��y��L�. �`,, '�i': .:+.°i.. 4s: .;„ ='�•''��.1� .�'',�;.' .'.k,. ��ts':.•'i�' . ,.9;=:t'��2t`fS�l %*�i� �1.: � 1 . ... .E'. � . � . � t, �� ' • `•5.�. . `1''. .. ��Ai�:��Y..t{:�r�'y�Yi. !'l� ? •f Y°�$'��65�: ��e��..�, �+ak,w��.-, '�� . ' , ,. e� • , . . ..,..,,,..:..M-. i,=q:;��, r��,$,u :� r �• •'s•_ •.�: ,t. ';�"."�',' ..4'• � ' ;i' � -��j `'s'/ ',�.v. r��1:=i£ ��'j.l�� . �I•` ' .�>L.'� e . . . � '..`,t.�. • . r!tr444.1�', . 1. t 4l}.'I+� �•�3' �''aL �� "• i �.`F� C�. i . •� .'�', � . 1•Y. . • Z ' -� �. • � . '�. , � ��c`; .'i, i - � '�� i- .. .,..,.r ;•Err � f�w�L: �i�I ;�, r : 4p; '�� •. I �