Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
07/26/1976
� 1' � .. , . i i � ', . CxxX COMMISSIO�i MUL'TII�(i t. � July Z5� 1976 i �ia Cizy Cammis�ia� oi tha City o! Cia�rx�k�x enaC ict apacial eesstan ati the Citiy Hali, Mandaq� .1uly x6� 1476� ati 9 t 3Q a.m, . ai.th th� follawing �aanbars pre��rit t � �abriel Caaara■ .Ioeaph Caraisa Kar�.ean F. DeBlaker K�ran Martin Darwin 8, Frank A1.so #�reaent W�xe: Ptcot H. Flayd Thomae A. Bus�in Majar �rnest Wichelns Msyor�Cot�mirsiot�ar Co�a�iRsion�r Comais■ioa�r Cotamissioner Commiseionnr Citq Ha�ager City AtCorn�y Rapraeenting Police Chtef The Mayar n��led the meeting to order. The i�vncation w�s g�van by Coramf�se�.aaer CarWise and the Pladge c�f A1.leg�.aace wag �ad by tha Mayar. '�he City Pias�ager bnnouaced that he he8 a ZJsiver of Notice for tha Coma��seion Co s3gn. The Gity Ma;nager xead propoeed Resolution �r7b-8� au�hor-- izing the City Attorney to appeal tha caae of the Citg of CAear�atex�et al ve I�iax G. Battla fram the decieioa af tha i'1nellas County Circuit Couxt� Ga�� }�76-151.�i-14� to tha 5econd District Court of Appeal� ia Lakeland. The Ci.ty Attoxn�y then read a mQmorandum he had prapar�d for �he Me�yox aaci mea�bexa of ti�e City Comrnise�on giving the reasone why the dec�s�.on v� the Cixcu�� Coax� shouLd be appeaxed Co Che Die�trict Caux� in Lake- 1ar�d. Ti�e C�ty Attart�ey etated if the AppeaX wae �ot appxnved that the ca�e mexa].y e�ope where it.i.s and aZea, in anewer �o a queation of thc Mayor'a, he stated tha� the majoa� cost for h�,s office for the C3rccs�.� Co�srC Appeax wa� approxi�mately $4�00o fox the tranecript of the Civi�. Service Boaxd Hear�.ng uad that it would coat in tl�e neighborhood af $3D0 Co go to I,ek�land. Commiseioner Carwiae asked the City Attorney if the R�do- IuCion wae abao�.cstel.y neceesary ae he hae al.ready been instrnc� ted �o appaaX tha case by the i�ianager. The City At�oxneq epok� of the a�b�gu�.t�.es in Section 22 ef the Civi]. ServiGe Law� but 5ecCi.on 3�, u� tha Charter requires him ta aek for a resolution aad appxaval af Che Com�siaeion tp proceed. Comm�.saianex Martin said the At�orney has preeented reasoae tq appea�,, but ehe w�nted to know what Che argut�erita miIIht he noC to appea].. Cninmisaioner Aealaker asked Che C�,ty A�.torne3r Why the appe�l Hae made CQ the Circuit Caurt on pracedure raCher than i.n accordaace wittt SecC3on 22 of the Civil Service Law whexe tiad�.ngs c+�n be appea�ed and tried de novo. xha C3ty Attnraey stated tha� Sec�ion 22 of tHe Civ��. Service I.aW pe���ts appeal �o the Cfrcuit Ca�sre ot� a de novo ba�is, hut the aeW Conetitu- Gion repea].Ed �ha� SecC�.ott ar�d. therefore, a petion tnuet be made.�or � writ n£ certiorari. Comm3.seioaer Fr�nk aske�l the City Manager whaC beneEit a favorable d�cfeinn by the C�rcait Court wau].d have b�en for Che City and tihe citizene of Clearwa�er. 'ihc C�,ty Maaager stgted �� ths� i.t �rauld upho�.d �tha iutegrity of �hc Ci.ty Gov�rnme�t, �].ar- iEy po�nC� xaised'aud a11ow fox it to proceed �rith an affect3ve �� ogeYatio�. He aleo fa�.t that aome af the probiamg could ba cor- , racted through pae�ega �f ardinanc�s, Camaies�.onex Fraait axprns� j.: 13.,..j,;;_. � .� se� tihn �opinioii t�ti�ti hG cauld x�at saa, anq ams�Leri,a�. bnnnfi.0 ta • '�::��: ;'.. • ,.�• th� ..C�itq ar �citixtn� di they canCinua thn aoure ceea wad he ''�y����"` h�li�v�s �� tihae autharia�tioa ta a eal, shouid be dnnied aad to :'�`"�;Y'�`�' .,��.� :;,�, ' :g�oc�ad�.Kith tt�e businnss of. ChepCieq. . � . ��ca�,�,���,�� �.� ;�: :': .• . . r:,;,�1�':��:..�._;ou'�� ,'� w. .,.. .s.. n'�:�16 �.i,+,'i•!'.;. ,:..'T.'�`. ,���i,:r's �� , . ^ i� t��:�.t:y .}�,���,.',Sv�;'�� ,p.:,'�t:•.' ��� .. : - .� ' • , ' . ,' t� , �� ~:i'feE ;Z'' ;s'�r, 5: T��r.y.�� .'`, ��. .� i " •,�-r . .. . .S �y�, i�,�:,.�:�� t':i . �^;.;• �r. � i4 : • . - ' .� . � ' iE 'r kk��11: ,�;.t:.• .:a�M' ;' �.`t.:�r � �'jt �/�� ���•��� ^:���i:%F��FyL•: fr.�W , �'�.�t . AA� "i` f .. . . ', ... � . . "'Ly�Y ��'iy (�1 � y ..'r '�'; :r:.s. � r,: �� ,.'; . . /�c 7t • , � ~� A"���y�;��s^Yf�.` L•' . �. ��J� :, .. • 'IF ' . � � . . . . „ � �I,y�(' ,�b F: .. 1 . • ; '�/�. -7�iV�l.V: , _ � .P��.: � k . . . . � . 5 � � _ ` _ . . _ __ . _ '`tp ik��� .,�.�:''R••�`,s�;t�� f�����_�E,r +�wtw�r.f'^,�'�, . ��t�.... .S . ....�,�:fi:�� � .w � `.i :tik f::ilt.`�r.' • .` ; �,:.� !�C'.i, .:,-5� ,'.�. �....a�: � :'Y �SG��,�s .�.�'4";;tf34::;e',.�T.Tni:.;'�� :+�� �,' • � �•S� � - , ii ' .«...r.;..s:-r..-.�»; +r- t+ � • rti a:.�,3�,t;:��. i,y� ?' y�'�, ' �si���.' Yi2.,�}:.��. . � F �'�i�. � � � � -�ry,]••���fr �r��f'�����r„'w�4��� �iS � � - i � � / � �{ � ij. !:: ...�,'e f �.-���`t� � �•' � ^1.C5;w , . '�a:7 , '•3: l : '•5� � : 4' ). `.�� . � Z . �.�'�� r:��.Yi � ' � •�4.�'��r rs, ��.: . � _ �i � . . _ . . .�.}1.� .-- - .�.._ tv:, The City Mana�ar brteily outlin�d th� pa�t hi�tory o� eh• cere and both ha and Che CiCy Attoxney raco��and an app�ax. Hs�. Anthony 8atkag��a, Attaxnny� rapra�rnt3ng Mr. B�ttl�� •t�ted that hn could underetand why both tha citi��as a�d tha Ca��i�eian Ar.e canEused With the publicitq and noto�ieCy givan tha csea. They �ee t�e char�es aga�net Hr. �attl• and th• Board dee�rminad thet ehera is nat �uat cau�e far dismis- sal. 1in cailed attenkion to tlie fact �hat the Bo�rd voted ��va to nothing or �aur to one an all iCe�r.• Ha al�a at�t�d tha� thn axpense� in tha caee did not only �mouat eo th• ca�t a� the cranecrtpt of $G000, buc �here Was the Prica Wat�rhovse bil� in tiha neig�burhaod of $17,000, nad therer�nra alsa ather axperts i�ired to testify�i� add�k�an. Mr. Battle'e beck pnp s� t�ie time is very cloee to $30�000 �or daing ttoChtng buti sitting homn and if the �atter �e �ppeaZed iti wi11 probably be at �east 2 y�axs befor� it i� reeolved with an additioaal $60�000 acr.u�uleCing iri back pay before a f�nal decleion te raached. Mr. Battaglia r�ad Cha Einding of the ccurt �n Which 3� staced thati �he decisione of the Board ae to �hc alleged vio- laCions are Aupparted by subseantial avideaca aad that the deci�ion o£ tihe $oard un each chaxge wae by majority vote at Iea�t� aad £�nda that th�re was no baeie for it to d�sCuxb the f3ndinge end conclusions of the $oard. Commiss�oner PfarC�a �Cated that ehe did not eee in Che meao from Che Ci�y Attorney aaything that an appee� wou�d question Wh�Lher or not aa employee Would tak� a�ifti. Ia �aswgx�ng a�u�stion of Cammisa�oner Martin�e the Clty Attox- neq etated that pracedura� queeCioas caa be corrected �� t�e fuCUre. The CiCy H3A�g�L thaught that past issues ehauld be resolved. �he Maypx aeked the queation hoW fe�r back this iesue ehould go a�td we should accept eomeone�s decision that has heard.both aidea. Commiasionex DeBlakex ask�d iE an ordinance could be wrifiteu th�G, if the dacisioa of the CiviZ Service Baard ie not acceptab].e by eiCher gaxty theq have a rj,gHt to a hearing in circuit courr on the Eacta. The G�Cy Attorney replied Chat he wau7.d have to reaearch �he Conetitution aad �.t tt►aq be aeceasarq t4 take action through the State Legislature. Cqmiainsioaer Martin moved tha� if �here is aaq contribut-- ing �,nformatiCon to be suhmitted hy anyone in the audieace Ch�y he ncki�owledged. Comwigeion�r DeBlaker eeconded the matioa which carxi�d ananimously. Charles Fi,n��n admiCs coneiderable coaC has be�q.involved, buC the Commi���.on jusC approved $I00�00� for a srudy and ail that wtt� gatCen out of it was that we should have a new ltbra�y do�atown and change the aame of Sta�e Route 60. He stated thaC at �eas� one member, of the Civil Service Baard wae bl.ased ia f�vor af Mr. Ha�tXe. Mxs. Gruver made the commenC as to what the tirsxpaycra w311 xhink i.f tha Commise3,os� vo�es against tlie ralin�s by the Civil Service Board and �he Circuit'Court. , Nor.mats Bo�rlee comnaended Che type of citizen on the Civil '" , Service Soaxd aad etat�d Chere s�as ao evi8e�ce o£ bian. Aa . '�• also.commented that if prospectiv� nr pseseat emploqees are . • gaing ta be put through�thi.� �ppe of hasale, they axe goiag •� , to seek jobe elsewhere, raCher thaa wiC�'Ctt4 Gity governmen�, � ' � aud the C�.Cy Wil�, losa compeCent peap�e ia doiAg sa. .���' ,. � Robart �ickereC�ffe cnmmented that th4 repre�autation on •,'. �, the Civi.l Snrvice Board ie very fair pith t�o being appoiated � ,�.. . by the Co��ais�ion� txo ba�ng elect�d by Che employeeQ and the , :s-�: �. � �- �': .fiiLh member ci�oaan by tho�n four. He also co�nnna�ed Mrs. '• �"' �. ',! vtB1�'aker had arit�ci�ad thae tihe Board cau�$. aot bn removnd ,� ;�.:��. ; � �,; :. ; " �: ,,r:by �,��e' appaiatiag• authorieiss aad he thought rhat was good . '�':,:.-.- �:�� ; .,.� � " •�� bescau��, tha ai^e �Chcsrn to ra ra�ent ��a ••.��,�?:," ' �.� ., . � Y P ptaple af Cl.earWatetc • �'��':r�?' '�' ' ' '''}�� �:and�•'iioC :.�or�l�r'�po3,itic�� apg'alAtse�. � , . � . . S�{ f ..:}�.e's�.l:�i:'�j;: ., f � , �f�f� •'. 'J. • " � . '�� �: }�. . , , . . � ; ' ' ' � . . ;,'*',-,�, �4s'+-`,S {�'t?:4,"� '� .�' , � i f, . . • r.� ��� •�rtr•• ;1.. ;i:';" . • �, {� + K��''+�;.';��: t,,� '.' � � k� s�h�T1.��•;y.'f�uf.�� f� � �F;: �i.'.`r �, ; , . . . � � . � Y��"q+ilEyly,, ��i�»;:'�i��.•� ". ." ;!T. ,;i,. '`:,-,., . . • . , . .,�' `.,.:. •"�t �#�rk:3;•.Ci�'`:E;{ ; �Ar����; ���� Y� �'c � . • , , , .., � ,i 1��'.��.����`"�%��r-. �„•�.:s�, �:A,�': ,E;,;`,�';,..' . •`,: . , �.Z� . . . . . , ; . ,7-2b-76 ; �:� ec�.��=��_, .i�J+! 'T�'E k . � _ t._._ _ . . _ � , ... 7," .. :4 . . . ��s"'-`:. . , •r �{•�� '•i.9li�.'!� �y.F�,:R;•�=Yt.���;�.�;s��/;,��.'�,��i.�:. �.i."�i.- `�, !.:L �i. i i'y ' 'l •� ' u �r` � r�.'�++;'� :9�A�E3.. .fSi�.4 Yet:`�il.iyh,��' �F�t:�, Y t1 1�. �,.��'�I"''J=��L, ' ,�r,.x.,�c:�h; .1::�I:l.�. ._�.1�• ..,� . ..,'�.4.. ��� 1�� ��•':!.'''�r.. � � r ,.� �1.�'�t. �w+, .: ... ... . .f. - . :'j�;'':;,n<,-. '.,�4st'''��: '�':; t �a. . .� ' � ' ' "__'_"' ,i- -�S '.e•'! L4., ':r^f -.r ' •'.. •t . •,�7., '}� ' , •1 ' . , . "" , �.t�.' ., ' •r" .�' ,(; .'�. .� , , . � �. . . .. ' � . . � - ,� � �• � E ,F' ' "s ' � ` ,;�� f ', E • ' � � . tc . . , . � . ,ef ,4 •�r'� , . ' I . , ' . - . � � '. Comcn�.eetorinr Carwi�se movad thaC prapoeed Resniv�ion 07b-81 " �. `� b� �daleutiad. Commiesianer l�r�nlc eecanded the moGion. Upon tha . �� . vota ���n� takan Cammieaicnere Car�i�a, Mertiri, I�rnnk and the ��. � Mayqr voted "AyB." Co�ami�einner TfeRlaker.voted "Hay." Mation , � . ; ci'srried, . � . ���z = ,. ��• Thern beirig no furtt�ex bueinens� the meetinn adjaurned '�� ' at 10:5q a.m. , - � , . - � , � . ,:r . • ,. ` . ,, , � Mayor-Cammieeioaer �" . , � . . . ;, .. �� ., . Att��t; � � . . . . , �. , � ' � : � . ' � . . . � � � , . ��. � � � . ' � 't :� .. ' � . - �, C�,ark � . , . .. � , . , . . . . .. � .. .. . . , .. . .. �. ' , � . . � , �; • � � .'..: , � , ' � ' ` , . , . . � . ..:� : it`: v� . • � . ", : , ' • . .' }. . ' . I. � ` ' ' . ' . . • . , ' � " � . , f. . . . . . � . . � . .. . . . , . !. � � f . . � : . � . � • . � � � ' , . � _ • � , . � . � , z - ` i , . . � . ' . . , ' , • � ' . � � � � � . . �. . ' ' . . . . .{' ' ' . . ' , � � � , . ' ,. . � .�� � ' ' . . ; ' � , , - ' . . , " , : ', .� � ' , � . ' . . . � . . .. . � � � ' ` . � '4, .. � �' � . � . . , , . ' , _ , r ' , { . � ' �'" :I�' . ' ' � ' , , . - � . � � • ���. •', � ' .. � .1 ' , t . . 'i � ! �. . ,. ' ' . . , . , ' . . , . ' . .. ��i.. Y 1. _ � � '�f ' f. '� . � ' i.. . . . � ' �. �, . . � . : � � . . . :L•; �;` ' �;?� • , ' i -. ' . ' . . . ' �. - .i' ,iS,. , t� . :���, ' "�� , • , ' , ' ' ' - , , N. 0�\ ` . . � . . . , ' . . I ff � . . f" �. . . . . . . � . . . e•l . . .. t � . ,{.' I . . . . . . \�. • � '� � ' .. r . . 1 ' . ' ' . . ' . A . . E . r . . . . ` �. . . ., . N � . . ..�'ii ' .F .i : ,,. . � ' t � t�5. � .� < . F � , � . . . ' F'�. :F:'rl'�`•.�1" "`�r 4 • , �4:: .: . �, � t � , ' . . , ' .. ' ' , � . . . ' . � � . . 'fy•:rj((;iff� .��:1 ' �j`: �' , . :7 [. . ' t i . . '.. ��. • . � , ' '� _{.5-' "y!',•^ �4 :. ,�� ..r . . •i� " . . _ � . � . . . . ' . . � ' . �' � � i�i- � Er�,.i,: i ' � "� � ,' �'7 ; r , fF� ' ' � . � , ' � t.� . . . r , . . . ; . ���c`i;����• 1i�r �,`r: �l`.,yi, ,,' �j: �'_� ' 'r�. 'i. . . . � - .. ,. , i . .. ,�-��•�!il,Si.• �'�ji•,%..r'. r�?.f:rl; �1;` ,1���,!.%��. . . - � , . . � . : . ' . • . . �').y;�), t��: ':�`e,.,"_'��4•. �s::�i 'J�..` fi.,�: , . , . , . ,� � . ��: .. '.s , . 'trr��K .^"t--�r �'�` • , s �s; .{�t ' '';�''1' '�':,i•• .,:�. � .. . . , �±�: . ; :� �i.5.t�� -r'.:tiCy _ '.��i%.i. �,��; '�a, ;-?�; •':yN str',�. 'q'i••'" er . � . . •. • - . . '.�,, %: t ��y��: : .��,,;' t •7 :),z? `..i' . j �� .:t l : Y: �?�, ` i k� . �S • . 3 . . . . �1?�:i ..E,, ��i if 'r• `,f-i. � .^' •?`''!: -�1: �,i. . •:4.;���� .�) ��t, d. ^'.E�'j-`,(1 .�X:•i�, 3� •��•' �.'+�'', a, , ��. Ey,�. _ )Y� -;,,,..+ [�,�;' ��t :��;�;:,� >:.,, :t =-'�? i� ,�: ��� . � . i 'S'1 / �'�ii.Y •�.iY�� .!H�1._rw..�� T>�I.h� :,�� �+ 7p1� . ' ��', '�Y �� �L� z i,:.�� .,�,.,i+�w �",�1,<,tt!5 . ��; ,ti. . �, . y. 1 �fj:� �fJl .p�t� ;.� , i f �.t. ..�i {� -, t' j:: ' ,'� �� q ��. yY�.{�f .��..�i '� IY �'!i- +'I �I�! '`1+` ^l', L. {r. isa.w �i P . •.�it �.Aa t`�r�f. t:'•%� � "�Y.��41. Yi.�.''� � ' 6'��'r � , i !h . ��.�.�, ' �4�'i. '��; 4 .4'; (r �.l �� ' r � , �' ��,'o' � . � � •^.v' : �3;�t�f'�CC:•r�'.�i s i?t.� �rr:r,t-:i"' �'�� .« `� •�f' ;,t�5 r„' 9��f,��,I� •_�«•ty. � . ,is' .�v.�; •'.��,;� r�, f •U{��„ !.Y a ,,31.•:i�"=.R�+ e :.:SJ�.�l7' �,y r,'� f'�a S x ...�' i1? +%t:^ 'R�.� . ,. ' •�.``�6• J i''�K, d (.�" ;R �, r. ' �: 4 �.1�?... . • �� . .. : �:1�•[':;:i.z' s � 5�4��'.•vtie+,l��'}�� :rr{'".;i. +�1'•�t� :nh'•.k' `r,J�'�:. ::.r.:? `i' � �,'. .:f£'. '��', i...i ':i: ,�o 'Y3i 1���� i +e � ��5� �.r�:2��'?M'�;:±� ;'( r1E:�i. � 4i.G: .d'P;�.' r •"r,.�� .'l�i.,:1 �.1'•°r�:. � 5 ��'Tt �,��1. Y,�-11� }�„ •.�,,, hty' E .'�ciFc',;"' ..� %�,� �'�i.�1v, '�c;�� ,t,' . . �L'-`. . �L ,r • �' �, , ++� 6"'�;��'.�,•}i�'4� ."�ra�Y'n'�' � r� � :E�;'�.'j.� • :r; .'i; 1 �7'.� ',�:,1��... �E, .,l:i.:•. ° r���' � � 7 �'�Y� �yl"_�::ft,.� �;� .�F.�i, i ���'��>:r ���-:� �r4 � .�`A' �!'� _�'�.' '•l,� . `�E•� "7k� •f- ,+�,�i"" -��r� Ri' .r� ';tr ,ai ,A:`�j; ,t: rE" :,l^l..,i: •f;•.._� •"i:.� :_n�' ':?� %a�.r� 't��`'��r �;�} �r�' �:��F, §�-ri�� ,;ii';n��., „;J'e•}..�,�`>i�: �.�.i s�'S;,�..�;� .�����7.6.;',".. "i)�tii� � ,�•�' w r,�`��i'! "":,� '.;'5��,��'i h`i�$.�`�s '��:�''��r�y �}�� .s: ;��' .t.` ' �J'�„��i:'1�I'jr�`':,�i.e '+ .'�'S .,,... e�5 ��� "�r:,'� 1,;<�y,�4:� ;7�°a !4'��w�[���4 �... ��'i; 'Y'' �� �+: . ;;';,.. , f.:.. •'r: ,.: . r. r.1 ,�� r .�� -:ti •Ns ._� wli• ,._'). ;:l..,. .. . . ,�:��ec:i�;�.. ;�' t a3,� ''�;•";,�,�.�:,y: �,•��'� �,; r� _ . . _ . .. . . <Yi .W�.,:til�, �.� �eGrt7r.!.'�,. �s> 5�:::Ft... .�.'..5ti.�.' ' ' � la �ieor ■. FLOYd eirr MANAO[II Q ID C I T Y O F C L� A R. W A'� E R �orr crRics •ox �r4s � CL�[ARWATt11. RI.ORl�A "J3!ll�, . Tha Meraber� o£ the� City Cammission o£ the City o£ Clearwat�r: Mayor-Commiss�.oner Gabrie� Cazares Commiss�.aner 3aseph Carwis� � Commissioner Karleen De Blakar Gammissioner Karcn M�rtin Camraissionar Darwi.n Frank at �he�r usual pla�es o� residence, Ciearwa�ar, Floric�a July 7.�, �97b , , . .. � � : - , � . , - " . NOTICE OF SP�CIAL M��TING ' .� - ' ' ��� I,adies and Gr�nt],cmen: � � Pursuant to Article 2, Sec�ion 18 oi the Char�er of the City � o� C7.earwaxer, a Specia�. Meeting is hereby caZled an Manday, J'u1y 26, �976, at 9:30 a.m. in the City Cammiss3.on.Chambers, City Ha7.1, � for the puxpose of cons �.dering a resolutian author�.x3ng an a►ppQal of a Circuit Court order in �he Max� " Bat�le C�se. �/ � � , . icot S. loyd - � � . � , . City.Manag�r • . , , ,. f � . ;' . , - . �- , , ,. . , , . , � , : . . . , ,. . , .�. ' , ..� � � ' ' , . ' . . . ' -'. � � ��.�..� � � . � , ' • , . �} , ' .' ', s� : : ' , . .. ` l� ,, �,�..,-�: . . . ; . , y : . , : , • . . . . • ,' ' - . +'r ��;y �'.. ;. ` 7'14. . .`lY: ' .1. � . . � �� . . ..I , . . • ' ' . . . , , . . ' ' ' . •. •i.�`F r,.: ' ..'. ,. I�' ' 4 '. \ � . . ;�r�)i,�{`s �,'> ;` Vl'' :�.l�.:i .li"�ft�, , ;i ,S• �° :��. . i .. . . . , � . ' . , �. .' � .. , . . , }�ti � � ��.}�� ' �F� �{ �,1�, . . � . . � . . . � . . . ,`��{} 2�'�y''�' ?:'i?�i �':(�'�;; �.iJ 'C,y.. z �i..� A}_ i � 1. •.�'. �!� �•'�~''iY�{;�S"r •f�.'J'�a 'f> •.�A3��.. �t�.��'i �'r�, ' ''-1=, .. . r,'�� • . . .. � i � 1�� ' '. , , .+'3•��:''x'•�ti'�IS: :�S.t�f;,, �i'��'ri.'t: r1:; ,1, . . . ` ' . . ' � • ' . , , �. � ' . �..� ,.C�+s,�,:+-. �.; = � 1 ;,,C : . �. ,,,,;.«.+�..�.v.��....�..+.r�.n.......�.-.......-�,..._. � . ...._.,.................... . .. _ .�...._.... . .. . -._.�........ Y�f, �.5.: d� � . . 5.` .'f' �>. �,c-•.... ,''� :�. ,^.-Yu .,+_.�., �i''t'��},�S�.y:d���',i��: �r� i,`Z, •��%I.�S'� ' Y'1��+ .'F' • �� �' � � �' • 4 ' ' . ' ". � � .. � � . . .. , . �»:�i�'=�',t5�� ! R�� . 'a>. �:�i,_ �,f , 1�� , s': i' �' � ' �'. � . , � . ti , � w' F � \�.�r,:,•�vyj��•" ,.'�•y.: ;. fi;�4:.:'�!i�1 „f�'.., a�' � :i,i. . � � . � . . . , . . ' � . . ' � . �S�=. �i �F'�,.� „�'. �':� '•s'�.� s'; '•• ..'�ril }�}� i.�'- � : }!� .�:., _,•.:{..� . . . . . . . ' . . ' , � � . � �yy(qr a'�l i ��. ; i=3 �'r�:.f.lf�i-�V..i�^ .� ,,:``.}��r°;��1`��. i,�, } ' '�. .t . ' . . `t: ',F .�' SF �"t�. �' .I i•c:�� 4Y. irt.)'f,7w!'�1w� ��:;.�� i�`,,.. �� 1. �!_: . ' i� • . ' � . _ ' ' ,i ''L � , ��S:i. f'� T� 1 � �5%�:?r.`�� � �;ii�/ i�;•,�r.�' , � .t, �' . ���..';L�'�'•+�S�.r'{• ,y ' ��� � F r:' u,.�x�ti;r.Sr x;'',1 .v,t'�S �'? >: c35i1: �..t, �S. ' t,t' �s,r •'4 _ .I � v > ! :,�6!!� %,�,•'�_';', .,� S�� �:;�j �i... .����:T`?`'�9`�'�4�Pr�� ;��ti;t.t, :t-i'S�i��{.,.,.•.�:s'.... ' . . ' t,.t < •:,��,:. , ..'�;��,;.��aif , �.. . .�;-;?�'.t::�,•:�•i�:..-:. , .... . �:':•;'�;� ...1� ir. a � r R'. .i tii�� (yS ;[:1 •:s.,,��,....�7!•.. . .. . >s�c��K.l� 'r%` ff;" ,.. ��: ..:.>:L Q .�... t,=.r. �',.h. �i'i.i.�,- � ,(;k . : ^.S'� y; ;• .'�. . . i'[v^ ' d.. •,�,',�•�Y,y' ' '+ • � � �-�t, e ,•. ,t.. f., , s ,y :�., �E 'tr!-s� ..��> "� p j 3 ��•l..:�u n��+S;..�q� ii�. g�'.."F is.a�i.� is�;.i�zFZ '� �-t' 7 ��'' � w � � r' �'�� ;:4�'�''•;�:��..�';��^�.�»:..��•„?�K ` "^ a; �3�"� r �,� �,t{'�l � �P`)�c,�:�.�i .i:rit rA�* y� �i4� � �.; �,:' .f•�.��i�s'j� a Ts{ ,V ��`'�r �j,". �y�r��F`�"!l�'�nC� }'' } , � •���`.�..�:1��i1i'���`!�'�'�i' 'i �+?%a3'.tY�,,:S�e��l�'r . �"y�E .Il� � � � 4 a `t, �, . - �� � �