Loading...
10/03/1989 .- .. .~._.--.-.-....~---- ,: P&Z PLANNING & ZONING BOARD DATE I~~/a:' 1- vi( CUr-ru. () s 01 t " ,I: ,t ,I , ~ 1 t ~~ r I I '. , '> . ".J .: --i ' ~ , ,'~~ J. ~ .~...l . f!~ , ~} , \~ ' ,] ,/>'\ .Jlij . .....-..--....-.-..... ".. ()'\i".!;'.:. .;: PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE INVOCATION ITEM ACTION REVISED AGENDA PLANNING & ZONING BOARD MEETING TUESDAY, OCTOBER 3, 1989 - 1:30 PM A. Approval of minutes of September 5, 1989 CONDIDONAL USES: ALL TESTIMONY IS GIVEN UNDER OATH. The Board follows the procedures outlined below: 1. The Chairman reads from the Public Hearing Notice each item as it is presented. 2. The Planning Director advises the Board of any pertinent background information. 3. The applicant or his representative presents his case. 4. Persons who support the application speak. 5. The Planning Director presents any supporting written documents. 6. Persons who oppose the application speak. 7. The Planning Director presents any opposing written documents. 8. Persons supporting the application (other than applicant) may speak in rebuttal. 9. Persons opposing may speak in rebuttal. 10. The applicant has an opportunity for final rebuttal. 11. The Board makes a decision. FLORIDA STATUTE 286.0105 STATES: ANY PERSON APPEALING A DECISION OF TIllS BOARD MUST HA VB A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS, TO SUPPORT SUCH APPEAL. (~;''': . .;,.. B. Conditional Uses: 1. (CONTINUED FROM 915/89 & 9/19189) Lots 2 & 3, Miner's Replat (7 Rockaway Street) Charles and Ypapanti Alexiou CU 89-67 Request - Rental of and Instruction for Non.Motorized Watercraft AND Rental of Parasailing and Wave Runner Equipment Operating Seaward of Designated Swimming Area in AL/C (Aquatic Lands/Coastal) Zone Zoned - CR-28 (Resort Commercial) 2. Lot 1, South Oaks Fashion Square (1500 McMullen-Booth Road, Units 13 & 13) Booth Marketplace, Inc. (Legends Sports Pub )/Bruce TurnerlPeter DiMaria CU 89-71 i , \ '. Request - 2-COP (On-Premise Consumption AND Package Sales of Beer and Wine) (NEW liCENSE) Zoned - IPD (Industrial Planned Development) P & Z AGENDA 1 10/03/89 ~d Use Plan: FROM: Public/Semi-Public TO: Low Density Residential " 3. M&B 32.03, Sec. 07-29S-16E (2235 NE Coachman Road) Trinity Baptist Church/David McClamma CU 89-72 r', { \ Request - To Allow Security Trailer Zoned - P/SP (Public/Semi-Public) 4. Lots 57 through 63 & Part Lot 64, Clearwater Beach Park (Units 1 to 3, 490 Mandalay Avenue) Mary G. Realty (Fritz's Market)/Nick Gionis CD 89-73 Request - 2-APS (Package Sales of Beer and Wine) (WCATION CHANGE) zoned - CB (Beach Commercial) 5. Lots 57 through 63 & Part Lot 64, Clearwater Beach Park (Suites 5 and 6, 490 Mandalay Avenue) Mary G. Realty (Chubby's Cafe)lBetty Reid CU 89-74 Request - 2-COP (On-Premise Consumption of Beer and Wine) (NEW LICENSE) Zoned - CB (Beach Commercial) (,T.:...... ~. ,'. ' . 'I 4:':. I ANNEXATION. ZONING. LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENTS. AND LOCAL PIANNlNG AGEN~ REVIEW: (1) Statement of case by applicant - 5 minutes (2) Presentation by staff - 5 minutes (3) Comments from public in support/opposition: individual- 3 minutes spokesperson for group - 10 minutes (4) Public Hearings are closed (5) Discussion/Action by Board C. Annexation. Zoning. Land Use PIan Amendments. and Local PI~nnin~ As!encv Review: 1. Lots 25 through 28, Blk. B, Belmont 2nd Addition (Located on the north side of Howard Street between Scranton and Tilley Avenues) (Belmont Park Methodist Church) LOP 89-11 Z 89-13 I ( , "'-' ' Zoning Atlas: FROM: P/SP (Public/Semi-Public) TO: RM -8 (Multiple Family Residential "Eight") P & Z AGENDA 2 10/03/89 2. Lot 3, Blk. B, Bdenville Sub. (Located on east side of Edenville Avenue, approximately 325 feet south of Gulf-to- Bay Boulevard, at 517 Bdenville Avenue) (Alley, Rehbaum and Capes, Inc.) Z 89-14 Zoning Atlas: FROM: RS-8 (Single Family Residential"Eight") TO: RM -8 (Multiple Family Residentia1"Eight") r." " .t 3. Chapter 135, Section 135.099, relating to the sale of gasoline at convenience foodstores in Neighborhood Commercial Districts. IDCA 89-10 D. Chairman's Items E. Director's Items 1. DISCUSSION ITEM - RE: Comprehensive Plan - Objectives, Comments, and Recommendations received from State of Florida, Department of Community Affairs F; Board and Staff Comments A",l_ € ~"::--' , C... P & Z AGENDA 3 10/03/89 I r j ! MINUTES PLANNING & ZONING BOARD TUESDAY, OcrOBER 3, 1989 - 1:30 PM Members Present: Chairman Johnson, Ms. Nixon, Messrs. Ferrell, Green, Hamilton, Mazur, and Schwob (""", A. Motion was made by Mr. Schwob, seconded by Mr. Hamilton, to approve the minutes of the September 5, 1989 meeting as written. Motion carried unanimously (7 to 0). Chairman Johnson outlined the procedures for conditional uses and advised that anyone adversely affected by a decision of the Planning and Zoning Board, with regard to conditional uses, has two weeks from this date in which to file an appeal through the City Clerk's Office. Florida Law requires any party appealing a decision of this Board to have a record of the proceedings to support the appeal. ITEMS ARE liSTED IN AGENDA ORDER THOUGH NOT NECESSARILY DISCUSSED IN THAT ORDER. B. Conditional Uses: 1. (CONTINUED FROM 915/89 & 9119189) Lots 2 & 3, Miller's Replat (7 Rockaway Street) Charles and Ypapanti Alexiou CU 89-67 Request - Rental of and Instruction for Non-Motorized Watercraft AND Rental of Paras ailing and Wave Runner Equipment Operating Seaward of Designated Swimming Area in ALIC (Aquatic Lands/Coastal) Zone Zoned - CR-28 (Resort Commercial) Mr. Hanillton declared a possible conflict of interest (see form attached) and advised he will not participate in the discussion or vote on the above request. \:. ;:~, . Mr. Hilton gave the background of the case and submitted, in writing, the staff recommendation. Mr. Mark Robinson, applicant, in response to staff recommendation, advised the number of watercraft proposed is 5 catamarans, 1 sunfish, 8 windsurfers, and 4 aquabikes, He stated the catamarans allows for better instrllction and special catamarans have been purchased. He stated the Harbormaster has reviewed the request since the last meeting. After questioning by Mr. Mazur, Mr. Robinson stated the sailboards are a different size and easier to train on. He further stated it is rare that all equipment is in operation at the same time. After questioning by Mr. Johnson, Mr. Robinson advised it may not be possible to operate at his previous location. ~~ Mr. William C. HelcL Harbormaster. Citv of Clearwater. stated he met with the applicant and knows the applicant. He stated the applicant ran a good operation at the previous location. He stated applicant agreed to operate 5 catamarans, 1 sunfish, 8 sailboards, and 4 aquabikes. Mr. Held advise he would like to change his previous recommendation and endorse the application. He felt this number of watercraft could be monitored by the Harbormaster staff. He advised these boat operation are watched carefully and unsafe activities are noted and enforced. He stated that, based on knowledge of the operation and of Mr. Robinson, he endorsed the changes that applicant stated. After questioning by Mr. Schwob, Mr. Held agreed that catamarans are more stable than sunfish. After questioning by Mr. Green, Mr. Held stated the north end of the property is where the public heach starts and he felt it would make no difference where on the properly the use was located. In fmal rebuttal, Mr. Robinson stated his business has always been run by trained employees. He stated he does not intend to sell the corporation but he is not at the site all the time. He stated the building is proposed to be positioned where it is because the properly owner requested it be positioned at the north end of the property. He also stated he wants to create the appearance of an attractive use. He felt the boats should be lannched from In opposition to the above request, the following person appeared to give his comments: Attv. Harry Cline. reoresentative of Clearwater Beach Hotel stated the Clearwater Beach Hotel strongly objects to the location of the use, He stated his client requests the operation be relocated. He requested that, if approved, the use be solely for Mr. Robinson and he expressed concern if the operation changes owners, He also requested that the channel into the water be toward the north end of the property and he advised the sllbject lot is 85 feet wide, P & Z MINUTES 1 10/03/89 the middle of the property. He stated if the launch is located on the north end of the property the watercraft must be launched to the northwest or southwest. After questioning by Mr. Schwob, Mr. Polatty advised he does not think the applicant would need to come back J'-' to this Board if there was a change of business ownership, Mr, :Hilton stated the Code is not specific regarding ( change of business ownership. Mr. Schwob stated he would have no object to applicant running the business but he would be uncomfortable with an unknown corporation running the business. Mr. Schwob felt the Harbormaster has a lot of experience and he appears satisfied with the request. Ms. Nixon stated she would be concerned about approving the request if motorized vehicles were used. She also stated she is familiar with the operation and the instructors seem very capable and careful. After questioning by Mr. Green, Mr. Robinson stated he would not mind the operation being located on the north end of the property but it may possibly block the view of diners of the Penguin Palace. He clarified that the Penguin Palace requested the watercraft be launched from the south end of it property. He stated he intended to place the building approximately 6 to 8 feet from the Clearwater Beach Hotel property line. Atty. Cline felt the building will be intruding on the Clearwater Beach Hotel and felt the property requesting the use should be the property affected. Mr. Schwob felt the building was part of the beach atmospltere. Mr. Polatty clarified that the Board could condition the approval on being only for the present owner of the corporation. ( " Motion was made by Mr. Schwob, seconded by Ms. Nixon, to approve the above request subject to the following: 1) That the use is restricted to 5 16-18 foot catamarans, 1 sunfish, 8 windsurfers, and 4 aquabikes; 2) That there be no 27-foot catamaran; 3) That the City Manager or his auth.orized designee make final decision to allow a waiver of City Ordinance 114.76, which describes the parameters for establishing and managing a marked corridor from the shoreline to the western extremity of the 300-foot restricted area; 4) That the occupational license be obtained within 6 months; and S) That this conditional use approval applies only to the corporation making this application. Motion carried (5 to 1) with Chairman Johnson voting "nay." 2. Lot 1, South Oaks Fashion Square (1500 McMu11en-Eooth Road, Units 13 & 13) Booth Marketplace, Inc. (Legends Sports Pub )/Bruce TurnerlPeter DiMaria CU 89-71 Request - 2-COP (On-Premise Consumption AND Package Sales of Beer and Wine) (NEW LICENSE) Zoned - IPD (Industrial Planned Development) Mr. Mazur declared a possible conflict of interest (see form attached) and advised he will not participate in the discussion or vote on the above request Mr. Hilton gave the background of the case and submitted, in writing, the staff recommendation, Mr. Bruce Turner, applicant, stated he wants to open a sports pub/restaurant and is requesting approval of on- premise consumption and package sales of alcoholic beverages. After questioning by Mr. Schwob, Mr. Turner advised there will be large televisions at the establishment, there will be no entertainment and no wet T-shirt contests at the establishment, and there will a jukebox at the establishment. After questioning by Ms. Nixon, Mr. Turner stated he would like to have approval of package sales but it is not a necessity. In support of the above request, the following person appeared to give his comments: Peter DiMaria. renresentative of landlord, stated the landlord is in support of the tenant's request for conditional use approval and the operation of a sports bar. He also stated the landlord has seen and approved the tenant's plans and all liquor license requirements have been met. ; r ,-, Mr. Schwob agreed that there should be no package sales when there is not a strong reason for package sales. Motion was made by Mr. Schwob, seconded by Ms. Nixon, to approve the above request subject to the following: 1) That approval is granted for on-premise consumption only; and 2) That the occupational license be obtained within six months. Ms. Nixon stated she would prefer not to see people drinking and then leave the premises with packages of alcoholic beverages. Mr. Hamilton felt on-premise consumption and package sales under one license P & Z MINUTES 2 10/03/89 '/ i:1j.i~;~:t.~:J.::r. Request - Zoned - To Allow Secllrity Trailer P /SP (Pub lic/S emi- Public) ! is a State liquor license problem but he has no objection to it. He felt the Board should discuss this subject and felt the Board tends to take away a business' opportunity. Mr. Green stated just because the Board doesn't like both uses at the same place doesn't mean it isn't right, Mr. Schwob felt, since applicant doesn't mind not having package sales, he would rather be conservative because applicant did not establish good arguments for approval of package sales. Ms. Nixon stated the Planning and Zoning Board has frequently approved on-premise consumption only. Mr. Hamilton felt there may be a technical problem and but felt there is no problem with package sales at this location. Motion carried (6 to 0). 3. M&B 32.03, Sec. 07-29S-16E (2235 NE Coachman Road) Trinity Baptist Church!David McClamma CU 89-72 Mr. Hilton gave the background of the case and submitted, in writing, the staff recommendation, After questioning by Ms. Nixon, Mr. Hilton stated the applicant is asking for approval for 6 to 12 months aod according to the Code 3D-day permits are allowed concurrent to 300 days. Mr. Lacy M. Evans, member of Trinity Baptist Church, stated the travel trailer belongs to a missiol1ary who is here temporarily and the Church is asking for 6 to 12 months to keep the trailer at the location. He clarified the trailer would be at the location closer to 6 months. He advised the Church has had some recent break-ins and other problems. He also advised the Church is ill the process of moving the trailer to have it correctly placed. After qllestioning by Board members, Mr, Evans advised as follows: A married couple have been living in the trailer and the man checks the grouod for security purposes; there have been instances where people have wandered on the property; the Church is not paying the couple to stay at the site; the man gets paid only for cutting grass; the trailer is hooked up to tbe Church's electrical system; there is outdoor water but it is unknown about sewer; and there are facilities for the outdoor people at the Church. Mr. Hilton advised that two letters of objection were received from neighbors. In opposition to the above request, the following persons appeared to give their comments: Mr. Theodore Machler. 2268 Sharkey Road. stated he objects to the method of application and stated many things have been done at the property for which approval was obtained after the fact. He stated the Church did oot seek approval for the trailer until he objected. He expressed concern about uncollected trash which adds to the unsightly nature of the street. He stated the froot of the Church is attractive but the back is unsightly. He advised the trailer has a Florida license and the Church maintains apartments for its missionaries. Ms. Karin Scolt. 416 Acorn Court. stated she owns and occupies a duplex in the area. She expressed concern about setting a precedent if the request was approved. She stated that, in regard to security,' the people in the trailer were gone during regular business hours and the trailer is closed and quiet at night. After questioning by Mr. Schwob, Ms. Scott stated she would be opposed to the request even knowing the trailer would be on the property for only a specific amount of time. Mr. Bill Schenkel expressed concern about consistency, about the Church, and about the trashy things behind the Church. He stated there are also trucks parked on the property for paper collection as well as a buses. He also advised there is a loud speaker thal can be heard for blocks. He further advised that a change in parking has also created flooding problems. In rebuttal, Mr. Evans stated there aloe big newspaper trailers whieh collect newspapers in support of the Church's senior citizen activities. He stated the trucks go out daily and pick up newspapers. He stated t:l1e Church is constantly after its workers to keep the back area clean. He stated a new minister is taking over t~e Church. He also stated the man is present in case there are any problems or noise. He advised the speaker system is a call system from the Church to 2 other building and the speaker system is not on at night. He stated tIle Church is doing all it can to take care of problems. After questioning by Mr. Mazur, Mr. Evans stated tl1ere is an apartment in the administration building for visiting missionaries and dignitaries. He stated the apartment is currently occupied for a few days and the Church intends use of the apartment for only 2 to 3 days at a time. ( '~. ..... After questioning by Mr. Ferrell, Mr. Hilton stated the health department should have been notified and the Church should have been required to make proper sewer hookup, Mr. Polatty clarified there should be an approved hookup and if there is not, the request is moot. P & Z MINUTES 3 10/03/89 J :.,; -' > _ n:.'~' ',; ",/: , .';','.:.:.:' .!~;\ Ms. Nixon stated she is not in favor of the request und expressed concern about seUing a precedent. Mr. Hamilton felt a temporary building use such us this was not the intent of tile Land Development Code and he is not in favor of the request. /' I Motion was made by Ms. Nixon, seconded by Mr. Schwd)t to deny the above request. Motion carried unanimously (7 to 0). 4. Lots 57 through 63 & Part Lot 64, Clearwater Bench PlIrk (Units 1 to 3, 490 Mandalay Avenue) Mary G. Realty (Fritz's Market)/Nick Gionis CD 89-73 Request - zoned - 2-APS (Package Sales of Beer an,i Wine) (U)CATION CHANGE) CB (Beach Commercial) Mr. Hilton gave the background of the case and submitted, in writing, the staff recommendation. Mr. Nick Gionis, applicant, statcd he is just moving from one location to anoUIer because his lease has expired and also because he owns the building to Wllich he want to relocate. After questioning by Mr, Schwob, Mr. Gionis stated he has sold alcoholic beverages in his currcnt location for 14 years. In opposition to the above request, the following person appeared to give his comments: Mr. John Brandenbumh. 499 1/2 Mandalav Avenue. submitted a listing of the nearby alcoholic beverage establishments (see attached) and submitted affidavits of surrounding neighbors in opposition to the subject request (see attached). He stated he is opposed because there arc 15 alC<lholic beverage establishments within a one-block area. He stated he is directly across the street from thc proposed establishment. He also stated the parking lot fills will young people frequently and it is probably the noisiest corner on Clearwater Beach. After questioning by Mr. Ferrell, Mr. Brandenburgh stated he owns a walk-in clinic on Baymont Street. In tinal rebuttal, Mr. Gionis stated hc intends to close his business at 10:00 PM every night. After questioning by Mr. Schwob, Mr. Gionis stated he mainly sells meat, delicatessen mcat, soda, produce, and other groceries. lIe stated he rWIS a mini supermarket. ( r " Mr. Schwab stated the applicant has been operating for 14 years nearby and the location change should not add new problems to the bach area. He also felt an operation that will close at 10:00 PM docs not appear to be one of those places that causes problems. Mr. Hamilton statcd he has no problem with a person putting his own business on his on property. He stated his only concern is that there will be another request at the previous location. He felt the size of the new location lUay be smaller overall than the current location, Ms, Nixon stated she is not in favor of new license but a location change is different. Mr. Green stated parking and late-night noise should not be a problem, Motion was made by Mr. Mazur, seconded by Mr. Hamilton, to approve the above request subject to the following: 1) That a variance to the separation distance requirement be approved by the City Commission. Motion carried unanimously (7 to 0). 5. Lots 57 through 63 & Part Lot 64, Cleanvater Beach Park (Suites 5 and 6, 490 Mandalay Avenue) Mary G. Realty (Chubby's Cafe)/Bctty Reid CD 89-74 Request - Zoned - 2-COP (On-Premise Consumption of Beer and Wine) (NEW liCENSE) CB (Beach Commercial) Mr. Hilton gave thc background of the case and submitted, in writing, tile staff recommendation. ~. M.'i. Patricia Muscarella, representative of applicant, stated this is a new establishment, which opened about two weeks ago, that is family-owned and run by the mother, son, and daughter_She stated the establishment is a sub shop/pizza place that is open for breakfast. She also stated the current hours of operation are from 7:00 AM to 10:00 PM but the applicant wants to stay open until 11:00 PM if there is business until that time. She further stated there will be no off-premise consumption. Ms. Muscarella advised tbat Binor's Liquors, a request recently P & Z MINUTES 4 10/03/89 -:. .'.... \' . ~ ~ ~'~<~~";'" ..I.,~:.~~.>H:.\,:, .:; ':.\.::J:;'1~;:~~;,i;~K;-;':'~, , . Ms. Nixon stated she is opposed to any additional licenses on the beach. approved for package sales of alcoholic beverages, was a business proposed for the shopping centcr. She also advised the deal with Binor's Liquors fell through and that business will not opcn, In opposition to the above request, the following persons appeared to give their comments: " , ( Frank Palombo. 644 Pierce Street. stated he is opposed to the request and the Police Department's position is the same as it has beell, that being that the Police Department opposes any new alcoholic beverage requests. He advised there are almost 60 alcoholic beverage establishments on the beach and the Police Department felt there are enough alcoholic beverage places on the beach. Mter questioning by Mr. Schwob, Lt. Palombo identified specific problems as follows: 1) The image of Clearwater Beach is a family/tourist-oriented area and, though tlle subject establishment may not detract from a family-oriented image, with almost 60 alcoholic beverage places, it is taking on a different atmosphere; 2) He felt 26 parking spaces were not designated for the establishment but was for the entire plaza; and, 3) Places where alcoholic beverages can be located on the beach is within approximately 11/4 miles, After questioning by Mr. Mazur, Lt Palombo advised that package sales also impacts on traffic considerations and the neighborhood, the Police Department cannot justify keeping increasing alcoholic beverage sales, and problems will be compounded by the increasing numbers of alcoholic beverage sales, After questioning by Mr. Hamilton, Lt. Palombo advised the Police Department can police parking lots but tenants can say they will police patrons, He added that once the shopping center is closed the owner of the plaza has given the Police Department the okay to police the parking lot. He added it is difficult for the Police De partment to distinguish between patrons of establishment and pcople hanging out in the parking lot. Mr. John H. Brandenburfdl. 499 1{l. Mandalav Avenue. submitted affidavits from people in objection for the same reasons as the previous case (see attached). He stated that additionally the affidavits include that, for the health, welfare, and safety of the neighborhood it is imperative that this request be denied. He stated it is well known that the parking lot in this area is a late-night hangout for gangs with loud radios, screaming people, and screeching tires. He also stated the local police do patrol the area but the police are hamstrung to do anything about it. He felt this request must be denied if the area is to be cleared of gangs and hoodlums that plague tbe area of Mandalay Avenue and Baymont Street. t ": In final rebuttal, Ms. Muscarella stated the proposed business is for the family-oriented and tourist trade and to serve people walking along the beach. She stated the request is for on-premise consumption of beer and wine. She stated that parking may need to be dealt with another Board, She clarified that the operation is a family operation and one of the family members is always on the premises. She stated the family would call police immediately if they saw trouble, She felt this is one of those establishments that would promote the tourist- oriented area, After questioning by Mr. Mazur, Ms. Muscarelht stated the family has operated the establishment for about two weeks without alcoholic beverage sales and she is not sure what the lease agreement is contingent upon getting approval of alcoholic beverage sales. Mr. Hamilton stated the subject establishment is a nice little operation. He stated that originally the shopping center was to cater strictly to the beach residents and now there is a variety of stores in the shopping center. He stated the parking requirements are different for a restaurant and a retail use and there is a parking problem at the location. He agreed that there is a possibility of proliferation of alcoholic beverage uses on the beach though he felt, depending on parking, that there may be an instance where it would be appropriate to approve a new license. He stated this establishment has about 14 seats and a Walk-~lp counter and he felt there was DO need for it. After questioning by Mr. Mazur, Ms. Muscarella stated she thought there were some variances obtained for parking that were previously obtained, Mr. Perrell stated the drawing shows the shopping center is about 6,000 square feel. Mr, Hamilton thought the market was part of the original proposal but the rest.aurant is not consistent with the reason the parking variances were originally requested. Ms, Muscarella felt consumption on premise is better than package sales. She stated tIle restaurant is more in tune to a family-style restaurant. She added the applicant would not object to a limitation of hours. Mr, Green stated he does not have as much of a problem with on-premise consumption. He agreed with the staff recommendation of approval. I '\.~". Mr. Ferrell stated he understands the Police Department's concerns but the establishment appears to be. a family. run business and felt beer with a pizza is not out of the ordinary. F & Z MINUTES 5 10/03/89 Ms. Nixon expressed concern about parkin.g, particularly with the recently approved Fritz's market. She stated she has a problem with increasing the alcoholic beverage sales on the beach, especially with. the traffic on the beach. (W Motion was made by Ms. Nixon, seconded by Mr, Mazur, to deny the above request Motion carried (5 to 2) with Messrs. Ferrell and Green voting "nay." 1, Lots 25 through 28, Elk. B, Belmont 2nd Addition (Located on the north side of Howard Street bc~een Scranton and Tilley Avenues) (Belmont Park MetlIodist Church) LOP 89-11 Z 89-13 Lmd Use Plan: FR..OM: Public/Semi-Public T<>: Low Density Residential Zo:ni1lS! Atlas: FR...OM: P/SP (Public/Semi-Public) T<>: RM~8 (Multiple Family Residential "Eight") The above property is located on the north. side of Howard Street between Scranton and Tilley Avenues. Ms. 13arbara Willi;uns, representative of the Church, stated the property previously was ilie Church parsonage. She stated the Church recently bought a new parsonage and the subject property needs to be rezoned in order for it to be sold_ He also stated the Church lIas a buyer for the property as soon as it is rezoned. Mr, Polatty gave the bacl<ground of the case and submitted, ill writing, the staff recommendation. No persons appeared in support af or in opposition to the above request. i I <'" . Motion was made by Mr. Schwab, seconded by Mr. GreeD, to recommend approval af the reqllest for Land Use Plan amendmeIlt from Public/Semi-Public to Low Density Residential and a Zoning Atla~ amendment from P/SP (Public/Semi-Public) to RM-8 (Multiple Family Residential "Eight"). Motion carried unanimously (7 to 0). 2. Lot 3, Blk. E, Edenville Sub. (Located on east side of Edenville Avenue, approximately 325 feet sOlLth of Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard, at 517 Edenville Avenue) (Alley, Rehbaum and Capes, Inc.) Z 89-14 ZoIli~ Atlas: FR()M: RS-8 (Single Family Residential"Eight") T(): RM-8 (Multiple Family Residential "Eightll) The above property is located 011 east side of Edenville Avenue, approximately 325 feet sotIth of Gulf.to-Bay Boulevard, at 517 Edenville Avenue. Mr..rIm Helinger, Jr., representative of applicant, stated the reason for the request is to allow the applicant in the future to aslc for approval for a parking lot because the number of its employees has increased. He advised the parking lot is located immediately to the north. He advised the only intended llse of the property is to be a parking lot and tIle applicant would agree to any type of screeningllandscaping that would be required. He stated there is a building on the lot that 'Will be removed. After questioning by Mr. Johnson, Mr. Helinger stated the office building is on the southeast corner of Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard and Edenville Avenue, Ee felt th.e llM-8 zoning would be the least offensive and appears to be a suitable transition from the commercial property. He felt the lot is particularly suited for a parking lot and he is not aware of any problems on the parking lot currently being used. After questioning by Mr. Mazur, Mr. Helinger stated he is not sure if the house on the snbject lot is occupied. Mr. Johnson clarified that he visited the subject site and the house is not occupied at this tilDe. Mr. Polatty gave the background of the ease and submitted, in writing, the staff recommendation. ~. In opposition to the above request, the following persons appeared to give their comments: ,-, Mr. Gregory Britt 721 Edenville Avenue, stated he represented approximately 30 residents on Edenville Avenue. P & Z MINUTES 6 10/03/89 He advised there are problems with parking. He fell the rezoning and use of the propcrty as a parking lot will lower the taxes due on the properly. Hc statcd many people need homes in Clearwater. Ms. Dixie Walker Duncan. 900 Edenvillc Avenue, expressed concern about affordable housing. She stated Edenville Avenue is a unique street in a unique area of Clearwater and is a very pedestrian-oriented street. She stated parking is a problem. She felt multiple family zoning on the property would not be an advantage to the residents. ("" Mr. Schwob felt rezoning this property did not qualify as being in the public interest of the City. Motion was made by Mr. Schwob, seconded by Mr. Mazur, to recommend denial of the zoning atlas amendment from RS-8 (Single.Family Residential "Eight") to RM-8 (Multiple-Family Residential "Eight"). Mr. Hamilton felt the logical place for the parking lot would be adjacent to the office building. Motion carried unanimously (7 to 0), 3. Chapter 135, Section 135,099, relating to the sale of gasoline at convenience foodstores in Neighborhood Commercial Districts. LDCA. 89-10 Mr. Polatty explained the background of the proposed amendment and he advised staff recommended approval of Land Development Code Text Amendment 89-10. In support of the above amendment, the following person appeared to give her comments: Patricia Muscarella. stated lot size will a determining factor as to 110w many fueling sites could be accommodated on a property. She stated this change will recognize a change in the industry where one fueling dispenser may now have three hoses attached to it. After questioning by Mr. Sch\vob, Ms. Muscarella stated the proposed amendment will requires that the fueling spaces be outlined in yellow. After questioning by Mr. Hamilton, f\Ar. Polatty stated because there had been such a delay in wording the amendment correctly tlle amendment went for first ordinance reading before the City Commission first. Ms. Muscarella stated the Development Code Adjustment Board recommended approval of the text amendment last week. ,/ (, Motion was made by Mr. Hamilton, seconded by Mr, Grcen, to recommend approval of Land Development Text Amendment 89-10. Motion carried unanimously (7 to 0). E, Director's Items 1. DISCUSSION ITEM - RE: Comprehensive Plan - Objectives, Comments, and Recommendations received from State of Florida, Department of Community Affairs Mr. Polatty advised the purpose of this discllssion session is to address any items the Board cares to and at a later date a revised Comprehensive Plan will be distributed for use at the public hearing. Discussion followed regarding coastal zone densities and rebuilding allowability, both in the case of voluntary rebuilding and after a disaster_ Ms. Papandreas advised that the Level of Service portion of the Traffic Circulation Element will be redrafted in order to make it easier to llse. Mr. Mazur left at 4:05 PM. Discussion followed regarding 'Whether to have the public hearing on the Comprehensive Plan during a regularly scheduled Planning and Zoning Board meeting or at a special meeting, The Board generally agreed to have a public hearing after the regularly scheduled Planning and Zoning Board meeting on October 31, 1989 and to start the meeting at 1:00 PM. F. Board and Staff Comments \ ......- Mr. Hamilton stated he would like to see a general rule established regarding 2-COP alcoholic beverage licenses where the State allows on-premise consumption and package sales of alcoholic beverages and, in some cases, this Board restricts its approval to on-premise consumption. Ms. Nixon stated this Board does not approve a license but approves the zoning for the license. Discussion followed regarding specific reasons being given for not P & Z MINUTES 7 10/03/89 . .' , ... I,~' ~. . ',:-,!.: \ ~'".'".., ,;.~:.,,;, :.<,,', :, ",;.J';" <-~:~'~;.?~'![";:('f~,V;~Y.~ t),;.,~'~,,/,:;:.. . Polatty, Jr., , Director and Development Department , ,.; f.:': (-""\ approving package sales of alcoholic beverages under a 2-COP license. Mr. Schwob suggested a discussion item be set up with staff and the City Attorney to set if there are other legal questions and/or possible problems with appeals. Mr. Perrell advised he would not be able to attend the Planning and Zoning Board meeting of October 17, 1989. After questioning by Ms. N"'IXon, Mr. Potatty stated the trailers parked at the Church would appropriately be addressed through an amendment to the Land Development Code. Meeting adjourned at 4:22 PM. (..0,..., . \ .;.l;:-t..... ~ , C,. P & Z MINUTES 8 10/03/89 \ , - \0 ., . '\.' ...~ '1 .'~ '. '.~ ..... . 1(' ,,', ". '.,.... ,..j.....' ..:'. ;,':, : ,.' . ;,': . I"..'.... "" :'. .~: ~. , ": .' .,':" ". ',':,~ ......;. ... ~.l..: :', .. ,.' ......' ,~. LAst' N^Mf-r1 KS r NAME-MIOIILl: f'M~1 E iJ a ,-t''l ;- i I~, /1 I I!.(,~"I/ I ~/) " f- / J ,,{ J(i AI>UR ESS . .' a. L' '-jf Ii It I/(;lf, C 7// (l /Ic((~l (~..: FORM 88 MEMORANDUM OF VOTIN<7 CONFLICT FOR COUNTY, MUNICIPAL, AND OTHEIl LOCAL PUBLIC OFFICERS N^Ml:O/' nOAR!>. COllNCII., ("OMMISSION. AUIHORITY, OR COMt-'l1 TEE ~-,,') ~ ...--;- ,- . 1"--((/ " "',' v ...1- C._6"j~-}'/"/.c: ., .' II I · I<L . 11 Ii: 1I0ARO. COUNCIl (p;:j;:,,(ssrON. AU r I/ORI fY, OR C Mt-ur, EE ON \\' 'IICII t SF RVE IS ^ U Nil or: ~' I Y I ' ('OU NJ Y , ! Olllt.:.1l I OCA I ^liENCY N^~tt.: Dr 1'011 fll AI. SlJlll )IVISION: {'... , ('IT\' ("( HI N I Y //~I . ( / . ,/ { ,'1 f< ( Cl,::-:- ~t Y "OS-1I10N IS: i: HECllVE )( Al'rOINl tVE WHO MUST FILE FORM 88 Tllis rorlll is ror IISC br allY pcrsoll sCfvillg at rhe cOHnl)', cilY, or olltcr Iorallen" of govclIl/llcnl 011.111 appoinled or clecled board, council, cOl1ll1lis~ioll, authority, or Clll1ll1litlec, II ~lpplies equally 10 IllCll1hcrs of advisolY ;111<.1 nOll,advisory bodies who me presented wifh a vOling cOllfliel of illlc!'CSIIJllcJCI Seel iOIl 112..110, Florid" SUI( Illes. 'I he rcquirelllcnts of this law arc mandatory; altho\lgh the lJ~r of this parlicular form is nol rcq\liJ(~d hy la\\', YOll arc cncouraged 10 \Jse it \11 tllnking llle disclo~\Ire required by I a\\'. Yom rcsponsibiJil ies tlllder the la\'" whcll faced wil h .\ n1C:lSUIC in which YOll ha\'c a con Iliel of intcr csl will vm y great Iy depending 011 whelher you hold a IJ elcctive (l. a J1poillti \Ie position. For th is reilson, pI case pay close a t1ClIlionl 0 I he insll \Icliolls on l his form beforc completing lhc le\'cJ.~e side and filing the I' orin. f}! .' INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLIANCE WITH SEC1ION 112.3143, FLORIDA STATUTES 'L'~,ECTI':I) OFnCEI~S: ^ pcrSOl1 holding. ekcI il'l: COIIIII Y, Inlll1kipa 1,01 ot her 10c;11 pl1hli<.: 011 ire..' !\'IUS r ABSTAIN from \'olillg Or! n fllcaSlIlC \\'hich inure~ (0 his spt:cial prh'ale gai/l, Each 10c;11 officer aho is prohibilCd //0111 k Ilcl\dngly \oling Oil .1 measllre which inures to Ihc spccial gain of n principal (olhel than a gC.1Il'rJlI1lCIlI agcl1cy) by whol1l he is IclaillccI, In eilher C<!SC, YO\l should discl()~e the conrticl: PRIOR TO rI IE VOTE BEINC; IAK EN by puhlicly slalilJg 10 rhl' asselllbly rhe Jl;11urc 01 your JnlCleSI III Ihc measure 011 which )'011 arc Clbslainil1g froll1 voting; (Jnd t 1 \\'ITH IN 15 U^YS ^FTER TII E VOTE OCCU HS by completing a ml liling Ihis f01111 \\'ilh the perSOIl rcsponsible for recording the minules of Ihe meeting, who shollld incorporate Ihe form in th~ minutes, APPOINTED OFFICEHS: ^ persoil holditlg appointive COllllly, 11l11l1icip"l, or other Im:al public or/ire fv1lJST ABSTAIN from vOling on Cllllcasure which inures 10 his spccial privillc gain, E<lcl1loc,,1 ofliccl a 1m is rHohibil cd /rolll knowil1gly vOling all a measure which inures to the special gain of a I)rindpal (othcr lhan a gO\'CI IImenl :Jgcncr) by \\'holll he is relained, ^ persOIl holding all appointive k)(<11 office otherwisc l1Iay parlll."Jpale ill a Illnllcr in which hc Ila~ a conflicl of illleresl, hur lIlllsl disclo5c the nallll c of the con f1ict hefolc 111 ak ing any a(lcl1I pI to in f1uCIlce the decision br oral 0 r \\.'ri II CIJ communication, whether made hy the officcr or at his'dir-cCfion, .... "1 :. 1 4 :{ .: IF YOU INTEND '10 f\1AK E ^ NY AI'I r:~ 11' r 10 I NrUJENCE -IIIL:. DEelSI ON PRIOR TO 'II IE f\1 EETINCi 1\I' WH ICH TI-IE VOrE WILL BE TAKEN: .;; , 'all should completc and file I his 10/111 (hefolc Illnking ~\IlY atll'1l1pt 10 infltlencc I hc decision) wilh I hc pClson responsible for \, ,ccording Ihe minutes of Ihe 'Ill'cling, \""ho \\'ill incorporate the IOllll in Ihe rllinulcs. ~ ., · ^ copy of Ihe form should be rHo\'idcd i'lIIl1edialely In thc olher Illclllbcrs of the agency. · The lorlll shollld be rcad publici>, at Ihc IJH'cling pr iOI 10 considcrar iC)fl of lhc matler in which YOll have a conflict or illleresl. 111'""111.11 It\~f\ ({?veA) rA(iE 1 : .l~:/,~,'i.i :"~'!i';;.~} '~:l;~'~i !~~:}:~"~:.l!;.' ";",~j.~~~'~ "j;':" :, IF YOU f\JAKE NO ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE TilE DECISION EXCEPT BY DISCUSSION AT TilE MEETING: · YOll should disclose orally the 1I<11mc or your cOllrticl ill the measure hefore parlicipaling. . VOll should complcle Ihe reiI'm and file it within 15 days after Ihe vote occu:s with the person responsible for recording the minutes or t he meet ing, who should illcorpol ale I he form in the minutes. ('" I. D'i:lOSURE OF LOCAL OFFICER'S INl EREST JLUYVlr:..f-il {-, lL~}t:~~" hereby disclose Ih.1 011 _____ L C/; A Illeasure came or will cOllie bcrore my agcllcy which (check one) C'57 ,19 ~ : ~ __ illured to Ill)' sJJecial priv<1tt' gain; or ~ _ inured 10 the ~pecial gain of ___________._____________,__ . by whom 1 am retaillCd, The measure berolc Ill)' agency .\IId lite ltalurc or my illlcICSI in the llIeasure is as follows: ( //) ! ~ .- L/_ ~'?. c:;: .-I~ t" ' ""1 / -A'1C, I '-~ I ('.-'.'" Tt/ #1'1 +fL<2-- ;//6P-- -r~- ,- .......-. J ,.... ,,II ~ . ) C\.,. i/ C~ '/; "1 L-C l"" ! ? r Jlk~' A l' c:-{ 1 &!.- i7 e..! c/ e-il-y , ~H~!~;g4d-~r - Slgnat ure .--.-./ tP /2/-<61-,. ------- .-------. - ate hied T-- , OTICE: UNOER I'HOV/S/ONS OF FLORIIJA STATUTES ~112.317 (I985), ^ FAILURE TO MAKE ANY REQUIRED ISCLOSURE CONSTITUTES GKOUNlJS FOR AND f\IA Y BE PUNISHED BY ONE OR "lORE OF l HE FOLLOWING: 1PEACHMENT. RErv10VAL OR SUSPENSION FROM OFFICE OR Et--tPLOYtvtENT, DEMOTION. REDUCTION IN , \. HY. REPRIMAND, OR ^ CIVIL PENALTY NOT TO EXCEED $5,000. ...~ ". "., .' ., ""'.. .n u. FORM8B' MEMORANDUM--Oi:-YOTING CONFLICT FOR COUNTY, MUNICIPAL, AND OTHER LOCAL PUBLIC ~OFFICERS - NA~lI~ 0" nOAR 0, COUNCIl., COMM ISSION, All IIIOR I n', OR CO",,,'" 1 EE lR. -_J?~~rt' __L2o (1 ,''' ~_3 17 ~.){"d_~ . ,-- lilt: 1I0ARO, cour.t 11 . CO".1MISSION, AU i1iORII ,,"', OR ('UMMlllEE ON \\,lIlnl' Sf:ltvl' IS I.Nlt or: l"~' NAMI'-r1RS r NA"'E-,.t-.!/I)/)U: NAME J'~~~LUR ) t-.( >/(l ADUlt LSS " CJ Ce n-terVJCI,J /JA iER- U^ 1 E ON "'"KII VOl 1: OCCUlt IlH> . : . '.~.; . '" \'. ..,.... ,,' '.. . .:' ,', ". ',\" ',". .:' .,' 1"'.":' ~ "" . :.. . . :. ,'w,'. I" 4' ".:~ '!'. ~'.{. ,'. l.., )",.:" '. .... J'" " ED J/t! A (2.)) C-r tv_ ( (lUN , \' Fn ~( I~ '5 vt'"v I ' n II) N 1\' , ! OlliE\{ I orAl ^nr:NCY NAME OJ' PULl lie AI. Sl/III>IVI SION: / C '1-1 ~ C / eA\ -/-v ~-,e.{' MY POSll ON IS: J AI,n(ll N11\'E' ;: EI.EC:IIVE ^' _ WHO MUST FilE FORM BB ( ~ ~~ ":. :! This forl11 is for u~c by allY perSOll ~crving nllhe COli III y, cilY, or olher local Ic\'c1 of govCrllllIClI1 on;\II appoirllcd 01 clectcd bomd, council, cOlllmission, authority, or coml1littee, II npplies equally 10 lIIembers of advisory and non-advisory bodics who alc prt'sentcd with it voting connicl of in/crest ulIdel Scctioll 112,314.1, Floridn SI;lIlIlC5, Thc Icquirtl/lenls of this law are lllilndntOlY; although the me of this pallicular form is not requilcd hy la\\', YOll are encouraged to lISC il ill Illak.ing Ihe disclosure Icq\lired by law, " '~ If .~. Your rcsl'ollSibililics IIllder the law when faced with a 11lcaSUlC ill which )'Oll Il<l\'c a conniel 0 f illtclesl will var y greatly depending on whether you hold an elective or appoint ive POSilioll. For this IcaSOll, plcnsc pay close attenlion to the instl lIctions on t his form before completing lhe rc\'else side alld riling the fOIl11, .' f l::d~:CTLI) OFn CERS: INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 112.3143, FLORIDA STATUTES 1 '. , j ~ , 11 ~ , ! ^ per$OJl holding ekcI ivc COUll! y, ll1ullicipal, 01 nl hel I(leal public (Ill ict' ~'I UST ^BSTA IN Ir 0111 \'ot ing Oil allle<lSIII (' which il1\11es to his special pr;\'ClIC gClill. EllcIIloCClI o"'k~r a 1.\0 is plO!Jibilcd Irolll knowingl)' \Ol;ng on a IIlCaSlHC which inures 10 the special gain 0 f a principal (01 hcr than n gn\'(~rlllllr.nl agency) by \\"holll he is reI ail1t:d. '" eilhcr t'''sc, YOII should disclose Ihc collflict: PRIOR 10 filE VO I'E BEING TAf<EN by publicly sl,llillg 10 /he ~ISSClllblr rhe nature 01 your illlClcsl ill (he measure on which YOll alc abstaining frolll vOlillg; and \\-TfI,tlN 15 D^YS ^FTER TilE VOTE OCCURS hy cOlnplcling and filing Ihis 101111 with Ihe persoll resronsible for recording tile millutcs of Ihe rnceling, who should incorporale lhe form in the millutes, ., ., J: APPOINTEO OFfJCEHS: ^ persoi\ holding appoinlivc coullly, ll1ullicipClI, or other \O<.:al Pllblic olTice f\.IUST ABSTAIN from vOling on a mcasure which inures 10 his spccial privalc gain. Each local officel also is prohibiled Irom kllowingly vOlillg 011 a measure which inures 10 the special gain of a lirincipal (othcr Ihan :1 gO\'ellllllcnt "gclley) by \\'hol1l lie i~ retained. .~ :-i. ~: :~ ~ .~ '-, < . :s1 ;1 ^ persoll holding all appoinlivc local office o!helwise may pallicipale in a mattcr in ",hich lie "<IS <I cOI1f1icl of ir1\CreSI, bull11l1sl disclose the natllre of the conflicl beforc Illnking nny allelJ1plto influcllce the dccisioll by omlor writtcll COIIlI11 lInicalioll , \\'helher made 11y the officer or al his 'direction, I F YO U INTEND TO f\'IAK E ^ NY AI'I Ef\ IPI' TO INFLUENCE 'III E DECISION PR lOR TO -1 liE 1\ IEETI NG t\r \VH lell TH E \'OlE WI LL BE TAl( EN: I \ ~"'~. .'11 ~houltl complele Clnd filc Ihis form (bclorc Illaking <lny altcmpt 10 inrJucnCf! I Ill' decision) wjlh thc pCI5011 respolIsiblc for .:cordillg Ihe l11inules of the Ill('ctillg, 'who will incorporate Ihe lorm in the minules, ~ ~ · ^ copy of the form should bt: provided inl1llcdinlely 10 Ihe olllcr Illembels of Ihe agcncy. · The form should be rend publicly at the 1l1eclillg prior 10 consideration of thc rmllter in which you have a conflict of inlcrest. , ION" 0(1\ Ifill', Co VISJ~) r^GF I '. IF YOU ~JAKE NO ATTEt>,'ll'r '10 INFLUENCE TIlE DECISION EXCEPT UY DISCUSSION AT THE MEETING: · YOII .~ho\lld disclose otally Iltl: IHtl\tlC of your conlliel in Ihe measure hcJ'orc p:lJticipating. · YOIl should COl11plCle fhe f(lrlll 11 lid rile if wilhin 15 dnys I\rlcr Ihe vole OCCllf S wilh the person responsible r or recording the minutes or Ihe IIlectillg. who sl10llld i/l\:orpOI "Ie Ihe fornt ill Ihe Illinlllcs. DISCLOSURE OF LOCAL OFFICER'S INTEREST JiE'JJ// ~ r- j IV}, tll---. .:Jr:, he, eI,y d i,c1osc I hal Oil _. I (:J ! :s , '9ll: (a) 1\ 1l1l':lSllrc came or will corlle berO! e IllY tlgcnq' which (check one) __ j/lUl'ccJ 10 Ill}' !'pcdal privale gain; or V in", cd \0 I he ,pecial gni n or ____13e>-'2::11,,_. f'/JEt -r:W-.plczc c. ~~___, b)' ". ho III I .m rel.i "cd, , he "tcosmc berOlC illY agclIcy tllld Ihe nalure of my interest in thc tJlC<1SUIC is ns follows: Bt7~ 0a/V~ ~, ~ ) lA-k~~) {}- ~f 1J [,"'j [;1'0(7'''1' ee:-n,,) A JchoC . ~) ~ r~~~ ~rr~ __'W u --~~!tf...__.__._---_.- cHI cd Signal mc TICE: UNDER PROVISIONS OF FLORIDA STATUTES ~JI2.317 (1985), ^ FAILURE TO tv1^KE ANY REQUIRED CLOSURE CONSrlTUTES GHOUNDS FOR ANO MA" UE PUNISHED BY ONE OR f\10RE OF 'tilE FOllOWING: 'EACHMENT, REMOVAL OH SUSPENSION FHOM OFFICE OR E~lPLOYMENT, ()EMOTION, REDUCTION IN \ In', REPRIMAND. OR ^ CI \IlL PENALTY NOT TO EXCEED $5.000. ( t \, i \. \, ,,' <'.;, .. . . \,0-" H" ,u I~\ , ",' ", '. ,,' ' , "':"', : ',' ,/: ". " " " " .:' """~,., ( I. ." ( ~ . 1",1_ ,:1 \." ; ,,"-,,;-, To: Planning and Zoning Eoard City of Clearwater Pinella.s County From: Eric and Karin Scott 416 Acot-n Court Pinellas County Clearwater, Fl. 34625 October 3, 1989 Dear Sirs, This is a -Formal objection "to the placement o-F a "Security" tt-ailer at the property o-F Trinity Eap"tist Church, 2235 NE Coachman Rd. We object -For the -Following reasons: -Permission was not requested BEFORE placing the tll""ailer on the property. We are assuming "the request ~or permit is a result or our complain1: calls. -The trailer already on site is vacant for most business hours. We have observed that Nonday thru Friday ( 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.) the residents o-f the trailer are usually gone:, indicat.ing "Security" is a secondary job to them. The trailer has continuously been occupied serving as a residence for ground maintenance man and Tamily. The "security'. issue is merely a guise to c~.r.~nt established r~sidentail zoning requirements. ~ -We are concerned with the precedence a ~avorable ruling might establish. During Christmas holidays (1988), there were 5 travel trailers parked and occupied next to the gymnasium. I~ one trailer is permitted now, what~s to say others won~t be permitted later? We don~t want to live near a Trailer Park. Trailers decrease the value o~ surrounding residential properties. -The visiting trailers had ex1:ension cords to the church for electricity and hoses hooked up to the church ~or water. The trailer presently on the site has a similar set-up. Additionally, a makeshi~t sewer line o~ PVC-type pipe runs approximatly 1Q feet across the ground and into a hole next to the church. Is this legal ? -We own the duplex directly across ~rom the trailer. We occupy one side o~ the duplex and rent 'the other side (legitimatly). We are concerned since the asthetic quality is depreciated and renters may be discouraged because o~ the trailer. We cannot a~~ord 1:0 loose income due to an unsightly trailer immediatly adjacent to our property. -Our last reason for objecting is purely personal...Our property was purchased primarily because o~ it~s location. It~s a little bit o~ woods still le~t in the city. We enjoy living on a dead end dirt road, we pre~er it~s seclusion to a busy, paved street. It is bad enough to have to stare at the side or a gymnasium while sitting on your porch, but a trailer in our ~ront yard is unacceptable. Encroaching civilization is inevitable, we will stop the unreasonable i~ it's in our po~er to do so. Thank you Tor your consideration concerning this matter. RECEIVED Sincerel ~r- ~C ~it- Eric and Karin Scott OCT 3 lES9 C;.lTY C~ERI( I . ,', . ',. " .' '.', ' '.', . ,I .' . ' , . ~ ", i' , . ' eLL ~q-7~ () .. iV .---..,- "----.--.------~ ..'1- t:wL-& ~~- ~, '..., r.. ,... -:- -d- /. .I - . -t -' /-- . ,-.-:.-------------,--------J~- _____ ,_,a:-::.~_ ~./ . -------~c-VA~,JL~'I(,!:€-"' =:~:-~:ia.=~ -~._=~=_~~:~::~__:~-~:__. .:',:n _ >>~:=J.-M--a,--22v~,-,--------.!-E.~~-I~~f).... -. lid 'IY/ilI:/77f ~ .,.------.- --.------5 E,P 26.1989_ ,,-- ~ fi)d /} /. _ _ ) - p-~ d... ~ /../ /~ / Y OlAUNn~G ~JJR,B~~ H__' ---~-~~.----' ,:..K-~-+-~ JJ::L___,.____ ~~~lOP-MENTbEPT. , .--- ftt;;--:r:~~==-- . - ----- -.----=~='~~.:::-.-.:---. , a~--u-A.~~~.~~,~~,-,---... ------...- .... " ~~--~-6IV-Jl'-f~~~>-----' . ~~-a1-~~. .-~------- :-{,:......~r--~-2.3-.s;:JJ-,.e.~11 %9'.uv /d-,---. ! "'''"' ' I . ,'. ."'.' ~,:.. ' ,;' "'". ". .: I . j . '.~, ' ' . '. ,': ' . .', ". " ,. . .. ' '.. '.' .: . . ' RE c'u 89- -1 ~ r"', .' j "'--, " tt O-V ; Y1, "v.J (\ e~\ p r'"' f.2V ~ GL olj 0.. c:..e '^-'t- h, ~ Tv-{ h~ ~ Bo..p h:si ~hW\cL-.. ::: ro-W"'u..\ ~ tk (JC4..-':lt- to ~~cvr.),) lo bj2..t..t i-o a.. c.a,^~'h<CIV'\.o-\u.~e- " IlIM'I "'^" ~ J"..- 0- _ " s'" c.cU' i ~ +r ~ \~ <" .f.v tk h, llaw: 1. r<!'< ''''-\0. : I,.. Q 'f hc...\'ler/\ dOc.s hot r("ov-iJe. s.e~'+l' It- .~\"'ue> tt../) es.. rVlj~u.., :, If- 0.. .s..e. C,v\x L ~ 'I UCu" cl i.> ~\N. r Lo J -( cl +" r o...+r-O I a.J kr eta/(" k.) he. olo~ ~ . not t\.e2c\ "" rLu.~ -H sl.e(f' 'rhe{..e. )S CllNlfle.. 4('sh:~ SfClte. cU,)~l~~ k -to s..e. 'flJ fZ- a. 5 ~:. oth. '- e... l c)., 0 ~ S,EC,.uj~(...*1 ep\-io ,1~ ) s~h. lA/} '^ ']'v\.LJ\d ) cou...tJ k ccm.~~dvte(;.~ '~f'S+, 3, ,-tiu. i( s..e L.wu'1 +r(;t~ l~\..l/ i ~ be.~J rA.V)L,V\it.:.t LVv\ClMkls~ r,;'("e..tzV'd~ # It~; . ~ '^""'^~)~~ ~wr ~t' ; s (,\,lA1lLt.~; Y\ P \~a ; V\ J~" ta...t~~ oJ L(JcJ Cf;,,\uA ~J... svuf-P./J l\.-.s, (I.J!.J:) j'~u fvr ~ cl~ ~/W.. ~Y'o~ lur.,e.AJ ,\ -\- o\<>~ .M-~ tt.~ ~ -tivJ- -t-f.W II cJ.'lt~...\ch I, hoL(.l S 1w,J~ (}.../) (;-. v ~ ~tu.~. q. ~ S\{.~st~J +-ret.~leY \'5 ~Dt ~~l~~ ~ (;- ~~laAct lv\. ~ r i, ,~~ d-u. f' V,) )C~c..Q/.l RdjCtc.t.\^.-f +0 ~r, .It V, tLlt\ bj-e .>ore a..dttt J .,*" thJ2. r ~ '1 c I ~ v'j .Jy.cv~ Le. r > tL V\. vt o-t~v j '^'~ (c.... Eo +-r (t W y\ '^- y- 0 ~ J ~.e.- ,$odb\l\ ..e 'Ly b[ -rru -r;l'~~ r:,~f h'~ t f-ro r-4 r .. ~ I tle... 1"r\' ~~ ??u..pI-lJf C~c.,~ h.M f\-Df o.~t;J (' U:. r()y\...~~ to 1'1 o-y CliPr'KJ-rA: eLV ,-\, w " ~ ,,\ sib N.l1 "'be ("') ; VI. au. i''''" 5 t" 0. ",J d OL) n,,,t' vVeLlr r ..."J- j ,Sp.R.~t.t.l CD\^..5) ~~() I\. f)-Y vlt~:s~so..:tz:o A fro~ ~L$t-;. h., ~dt...5, ,Sr~\1:C~ I ttv. 'lC.kUAcl-t'1 hM ~c..-c.-tf"Q4 Y"'O r..e.dr~l 'o~l.L~ ~ r'.Q..F ~ 9to "c~, d.a.e.. h~.s GO f\..S>hrL.lC..:tCo"" ~A(fa..u; ~ ) :,lw.. rtA-~k't- o-,~ ~(f~ ~ 4. c..on.S~ h,oj5L r~ ~ ,.CvV\M.,~ ()..,u..~ <te..{1..VU.- ~ c~~S \.5 d..tl4'W.eA h, b~LA ~ U V :RECEIVED ':' tM -tr'\.l. MoJ.~\,(,. O-Vw... . j I i~:l.~" ,!:~~ M... Sck~~ LO - 2. - g:7 OCT. S 1989 CiTY CLERK , .,',.., " " ". ,.. ,..' , \ ',,' '.' '^ ' . '" . , , ." , ' ' /, : ! ('~'" ,r!. (- 70 THe 2ol't//;I/& T PLjf"u,A/I/f/G 73ol'?/LO ,;-- .\ , I : ,. ,. .:.' , . - " . ..... .,' ,.- , I '. ,_ ...,... 1'" rE!3L Tl-tI,5 SJ7U.J9T/O,U WlrM' PRIlKIf.16 rtl~ Ttzl9/t.cf< 13E#/MO THe ,'." .77R/tV/ry BfTPTlsr CHuR.Ut IS rtlV EYE SOI'1/G To rH E, ,Ale 16~/JiJt1. I-{(Joo, THIS ,!1I2ErJ /5 11 13€rJt..J/IPVL. woo~)O AR.€/;,. jJt:J r ,q r;e,t;/ L..E/l.. PI7Rk: I i r..s 73i'9-D c/VocJGH tJITJ-I filE V'(/).)fC!... B€uIAJ~ /1-1"6 C'~U/lC;(~ .T F'EEL- IF Tf'lE7 AilE f1LCJc)o 70 P812K. . TH€ TRAII-EIZ. IHG'a..e, rART rulE V~t..tV€ OF m y J..{Ol7Je;:::::>e PI2Gc::./~re. ...rHPl/e j:::Dlwle ,. .,9 '- ~ ~ 0 F' r<cm~uP1,-e;-tJ {..V 0 (2. K. ro m Y /-fo m e - I ,TD 131l1~ UP THe V'19L.c./~ J IHI7D IMe : ~12.6T jr.I/tJC, ,yoo s~c 1J-I!-IfE'"1tl yea Com€ . /0 my M()(.)~~ . wE wOuLO ,APPRr:=c::.II9Te R . DeNlflL FOa. rHE R tC<u~~TeO 'ZOI-//iVG. ,. .f \, '- ~ i i' r "", '.i: . . ~~, f' , , ... ! :. . . -....:.. .' _\~..: ~.'!'':l. ...;:.", ..._~',' '.~' ~~ ~f2~ ( .... d"_''';- Ii E eEl V E D ly'08 RCC!JR/V GT I .~.. "'_'_,,... ___......_ .~._...__.... _ _........._,. .....~.. .. n...._ .......___....._,..._...~, _'" ~. . . , I.' :t:';.~~' r L " :.;: '. '"'V.:..~....~1 t ,..1 ~. ," ..... .......... ~ ,~~.., i 1 i ~ l. .... ,- '''''-T ...OCT 3 lSa9 -- '. . ",,,"::, , . \..., ~ l,. , . , -- -' ; CITY C'- '='~~. ,",. .. ..... LL.~ ,-, _ .' ' '. J -".' ~ -', \...,..-..--,.......... ,..-..L".,---, ...-....--.... .. ,--. --....., , '. \ , I '\ ,.. . ii:'_.-, .~:...h.,.....~ ,., ,~.......-.:..:'--:.~..:.....:, .. l.. .-..., .~.;.. . ~_, ,.1', ..' . . j ,~.."':' . .,: ' .....-. ,'~k:~~; j,-I~:!t\~::'-;; We wish to object to the request for conditional use of a "security trailer" by Trinity Babtist Church. This exception (" or va r i e nee v i 0 1 ate s the use pIa n pre vi 0 u sly f i 1 e d . Add i t ion a 11 y , it detracts from and lowers the value of adjacent residential LOla:;:s~ .:~:r~~l~l~~ 2~~ ~ ~~~ ~ '-, , !c/Z./l'l $~ #( ~ Z2!:} 5 $~lCety RA. loh/8f ~ -::/ ~ "1-J? Al~/... c..r. '012(91' \)~ -W~ 4\2. C>>-\;,M.oVJ~\ l(a., ~. /, . -::k ~ hI' {,tf. 7 (}~r~ IA'. . · JO/2/'" f n~ d~ / D /2- /8 7 17~ ?;Ut.n/L.:- '1" ~ ~ LIJ. ,')/:2./gq ~ r;)~~)AJl, /ptJ:J.. ~!:JJ&,JO;(. .~. ... to It./ 8'1 ~U-~~ c::'t 4- ~ ~ t." ;:(0!! ;;;~~~. ~~ tftqt-~+q~ /0/,(/'1'7 ~ /:; fj-)~ F't7t"~J-/ 6-1,(,fl lid. / d/:J/ 17 r. /T 1 d. .. !,~/?-/8'.q CJ> ~/ - e;, DIlrl !" 7' r (J it!- /L t/t at::::r~;:t --L ;1 Y0 ;- it?f:(:?Y U }.e.-A:I /vv,.. 10/t/'17 tv" ~~. .,ts.r hltr.ff~.t.. ;f'~- /0'" &-'0'1 (j'VV\ QJ~ I:'~ Far:-si-~/{;)V\ 1(&, /;O.,?,-:f1 ~ CdU 2:lH~ f~'trtar ~ /t)-d,- fer (1-. -~\ .JJ. /V~ ~~CoS -JJ~ ~ /RECEIVED~ i L/.. . " ,;, OCT; 3 1989 CITY CLERK ...., ", ,j ':\. . \ \. '. . . .' . . , ' . \ \,' ", ',', '. ". t .: . {...' ~ " We wish to object to the request for conditional use of a "security trailer" by Trinity Babtist Church. This exception or varience violates the use plan previously filed. Additionally, it detracts from and lowers the value of adjacent residential areas. /J /O/A/ L//t r-lcQrfl ~- \':n. SdVv1~ c,f. i CJ lJ.. / Ii 9 c2~~S S~ Rc4 .. ~~" '- j 0 I J-./ rs f 2-7--Js ~~' ~C ~1t- d lo/z/8~ t.!-lb ~\G- (~M.t) OtYl-O ~ l3-Q.oJv- I Dj-Z-/ 9; '-I- loA e O,vJ Cf- 0~f2 ~ /~/Fr L/og fJcoe# C T t'{:~ Xlv IffJ~/('~ --'7f! 0 I1nl'd 17 -.; \i;:~,' RECEIVED OCT, 3 1989 ( 't. " ,"--,- CITY CLERK , ,., .,. " , .....,.,..:. . .'" .. ",." , ." " " . \ " '. " . . . " . . , . . <. yo (-fvJ f) (Lr...---.c0 ~ ~ S ~ !;' ~ . \A)t:)t-y\ i*'" c.. L{ ~ I C "'-"'" ( , : "', with reference to: ,; Pu~lic Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, FI October 3, 1989 Meeting, Agenda #3 and #4 dated 9/23/89 LIST OF BEER AND WINE OUTLETS WITHIN ONE BLOCK OF THE REQUESTED "CONDITIONAL USE" OF MORE SALES OF BEER AND WINE. ON PREMISES (COP) OFF PREMISES ('-""'" ''',','1''',,'' 'j! ..; .',> J ,'V ~ 1 PELICAN 2 CLEARWATER BEACH HOTEL 3 BEACHCOMBER 4 RAJAN'S 5 HENRY"'S ROOM 6 FRENCHY'S 7 GINO'S 7 ISLAND HOUSE 8 PENGUIN PALACE 9 McD'S 10 BEACH BAR 1 BEACH BAR PACKAGE STORE 2 ECKERDS 3 PELICAN SUPER MKT 4 FRITZ'S 5 FLAVORS AND FAVORS { \ .... ' '-.-,.' . . . . ,', . , " ' , ' .... ' ',' . " ("~' Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. with reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc.(Fritz's Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 ~ part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-73 {", ( \'.,.. In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's business. I ~m sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. f Please deny this request. i\li..~NDALAY SURF & SPORT, INt;, '1JJI t11c/Lf?~--=-- NAME S)., 1- /I'iC1-.dU'e:<) ~ . !9JLESS C'Y7~':~- ~~~ 1h~ ~7 DATE ~ if' '-.'" "'. .;..~:\>.:- '"'~''~r''-At~<:''' .. " .. . .' ,:." '" I . . f . ~', .' . ' : , . , , , ' . . .. . '.' '. '~ : $i' . ... r' \ Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, PI Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. with reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc.(Fritz's Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-73 I (" ~,~.,' In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this ~conditional use". I I j Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. Please deny this request. b ~r /' r:5f-63zJ L/ , " , , .'. , . ' . ~ ~ '.' , , . . . ' ' ,-",) " (' " Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Boar~ Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Pi Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m, With reference to Agenda item ~3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc.(Fritz's Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CU 89-73 {-",' , . 'I -;',^, In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". I : I I ( I Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. Please deny this request. -~ l "'--., :: '.\ ..>~:t~l:)k ,,"1;~.~..!S:."; .2.'''':',v.;~~ 1t'E~:" .,1' .:~ ~:,:~'t':l '....':,;::~~r:~ll 1<, :. :..'"~ .' ; j" ~ " ,,','.. . "f\, .' ",' '<.', ; . ;. "',:l~' '.'.,. ,;.' . "- ~'i\ f, ~ C'" \~"~'I' ' ,~ ~. 1 ~....', ""f'" (-.., . . ".' . j.,,, . I . . '., .,. " Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, FI Tuesday, O~tober 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. ,i I with reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc.(Fritz's Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-73 In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. Please deny this~~sttv ~ ~ r;~p.J)A N!~I3G&[IN 0/28/ R ~ NAME EU teo f' ~11/-11 0 IV ~ DATE ADDRESS I A L/-f4 Y{CilA d tt I ct::J A-ve. I I I ! I....'. ,: ~, :..~;*-"';t~ f'~~~:'; "\"" .~-:..'~i.~;&~.Jt~f- ;...; ; ../..~,... ;';~;H" .~ \; " r. (", l t ... ,- Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. with reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Fritz's Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CU 89-73 In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. Please,d~y, }hisr:jJe est. /./~v'f/ i-'T-'.~/.4 . /"<> i!- N- ~ \+- 7 Ul/L~ NAME 6-/,/p //1,)I/f" (.)/jl; ~ ADDRESS _ / C. 1/" V-J~-lF l- ? Cl v:/ <<'i DATE . . ,'. , .. ", ..~'.~":1.:,:;..: ;.; ::; ',,: '. .~" < t'..:. ., ',". ' .. .' /"-" , . [".,., f ' :tl~',i._ l/ Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Flo,or, 112. S_ Osceola Ave., Clearwater, FI Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. With reference to Agenda item ~3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc.(Fritz~s Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-73 In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one b10ck radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant ~s proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's bus~ness. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal w~th. Pleas,e~deny this request. ~ , ;;./' ::-c- 1-" / t '.5f.r "_ (/) f-I~ ,I,t/<. ? 77' 3'~-, , L { Yl-.- <:'\.... , NAME v' '" / . / ' "r; ,- /1/' (/lVi ~:""r, ~~- ?? (.,;1 APORESS ~, fI' I I ' ~k/ ' , ( . I (" t-,. ~,~ <__ V .c' rr L- Ir/f-ff DATE . . . .:. J"" '., . . .' '. . I ~~ : '. . '. '. , . . . ' . . . . I' .' ..' , -", ...' ., ( ("< ";'d". '.' ~:' ~ .\~~ -,..c;.;>' / \..,.',. ,. ::-1 , Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, FI Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. with reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc.(Fritz~s Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CU 89-73 In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant~s proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day~s business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. Please deny this request. ~ ~ 17 ,- f /.~;'....~, ~ /~~~~ ~. C// ~ I ~L~~:r ADDRESS //f If? - /~/j-~ ,~#';"C-/i, 1 ~f/) ~~c. '7--~~~/ I , l C1l//o/~ DKTE ~ ~. .,;j^\"~'~.~v';'!;lif.'~~,\S "~1: "{;r:..:'.' ':~!"~~ ,~':b '''" " , ,,' ~: .' '.", ' " ' , '.' " , j', : ' . '. . '., '. ~. ". .', I' , '.' .{, (""""., t ., Public Hearing of the Planning ~nd Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater"Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. With reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Fritz's Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CO 89-73 In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". .01 ! ,;1'"... L "1,.,;. ,Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. .,. i Please request. r'C., NAME 9 -rLY-r9 DATE ADDRESS I l,.".,.' . . ~ ..~M::.l-I.\,:.!:..ti.f~H \..~.. . j:/.,..;."; '~. ~~ (", i. .Iif.., ' ~:.. '., '<l>\i,'... l . \. , '-..-.../ '. ." .. Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. with reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Fritz's Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CO 89-73 In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day's business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. Please deny this request. I .7 ' ' ~ ' (~,ia~ L. f.o'l.,,~/C/6,.,J NAM~ /J /. ) A I i4 j .-' . V .I :.J r..h~, ADDREpS / t;-02C'--<Cf DATE . ",' .,:~ .~' ....#;, . ,'. I I . . 'I'".. .....,:. ", '. '{, ~ ' . "...' . '. J, .' . ,. . , . . . ' . '. ,. , . ,'\ ~ Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl, Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p.m. With reference to Agenda item #3 on Notice dated 9/23/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc.(Fritz~s Market) to permit package sales of beer and wine (2-APS), at 490 Mandalay Ave. Units 1-3, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of Lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-73 In as much as there are five such retail outlets of package beer and wine within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this C:,' "conditional use". Further, I am located directly across the street from the applicant's proposed beer and wine sales. Each morning I must clean up the trash from the sidewalk to prepare for the day~s business. I am sure that the closer the beer and wine sales are in our business district the more trash I will have to deal with. Please deny this request. 9-~l~J/' DATE f "-/ ~,: . 'ft' .,;,,.i} 't." '.:.', . . ,.1. . .' .', " . . , . . .., .'.', ' .'. .' . , .- . .", "'.' .'. . '. ~ ru< ., . ~ Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 1:30 p. m. With reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby's Cafe) to permit on~premises consumption of beer and wine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-74 /-",' . i ~- In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this rrconditional use". I I ! ; I I I j I I I I I .....,..; Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhoqd, it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a-late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay ~ve and Baymont Street. R~~lY submitted a 'Le~ z -d-~-'6~ t#: ;&: &~ TE . /T-i/ A'26 ~ ADDRESS " ~ ,Y , f \ '-.".' ':U"). 'w. ~'. {-'fj,,' '''',' I,' . . :').'. .' . '.. . . .' ., . ~.' I' .!. ,: , r~;>\ . , ;. Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Pl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p. m. With reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby's Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and wine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, suites 5 &'6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CU 89-74 {, ~;l." ' In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood, it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave and Baymont Street. ~ Respectfully submitted /1 /.... ft. - t~ ~# t.-?--/ -.1.7 c:;Z:~~ ~A - ;' A J4~~ A 9..}ESS &- ~--- / '~0," ,(b t&C-i; ,0/:;:" r ~ C11/-E ~ r;r DATE \.... " . . , . . ".' . , . , ~ . . r... , ., . ". ' . ~, ".', . ' ,.'. I ' '. . , . . :' , . , ~. ' . I .' " " . .'. '. . . ..,..-., ". t . . Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p. m. with reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby's Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and win2, at 490 Mandalay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CU 89-74 ,>r' ( '1";,:....... In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood, it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to'preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave and Baymont Street. 9 of.. r/-# DATE . Respect lIly submitted ADDRESS l_", . ',' ~. .' . .' , , . '.' . .' . . . . . , . '..'. ,~ " :' ' #, . '. , . ' (""'" ", . , .. Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 s. Osceola Ave., Clearwater,'Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p. m. with reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby~s Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and wine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-74 (" ~, In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood, it is imperative that this request be denied. It has Long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a ;ate-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave and Baymont Street. Respectfully submitted -LL.c<-,u d. N 9-?J ;?" ';q DATE ( \.....,' "1'-; " . . . , ~.' ' '" -:',.'. .' .:., '. . . .' {""";", " '. .. Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, FI Tuesday, October 3, 1989 1:30 p. m. with reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby's Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and wine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CU 89-74 /"""" l' ..,..,.,. ' In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood,-it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Avel' and Baymont Street. Respectfully submitted 9 -)r y- %'7' DATE ., y. b~ c ( ""-,, ,,',.,.W. ',',./iI',... , ;" \;" , . .. .. .. " ,.. ~.. '~.: ""'tt~' '"..' 't1;,> " " , ' .' . . . , ' ., .' .' '. '. . . , ~ . ' 't ..' ~~. " c''., . , ~ Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, FI Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p. m. With reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby;s Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and wine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-74 In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and w~ne for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of " this "conditional use". to Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood, it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a lat~-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. ..... This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave and Baymont Street. Respectfullpj submAt,ted j' (AjAc6'"J I V Cui Ort--- G~4 ? 1V/tf3b&Z-IIV NAME,u?,') --;?7 , 110 I I .. t;:.U"'-A/ ii" ~ r (v ~ ADD~ESS A ~ I It LlKCf {VlCtVtcXe: a"1N..J-( , "-./ qIZR(r-Cl DATE \,,~ I I \..., . , , ' " "', " , '" '..., ' , ' . .' , ,) , " , " " ,,' c",.. . . Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, PI Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p. ffi. With reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby;s Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and wine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CD 89-74 .t':" ' \ In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". , , " I I I Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood,_it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave - and Baymont Street. YJle/j<~7 DATE NA'E ' q-~~ /J14.wf~~,-, ADDRESS . ~ ,.. 1/1/ AJ t- v . I -'~./'1.... . .z .... '.. . . . \. :. . : . . . ~ . ' ~ . .,' " ~, . I . I . '( .' , , . r'< f. ' " . . .. Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting city Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p. m. With reference to Agenda Item *4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 :j' ~ Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby's Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of. beer and, \vine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CO 89-74 " 'i: ~ (''''''" I \"",.:, ' In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood, .it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave, and Baymont Street. ;l Respectfully. snbmitted .J ,.I~ / ,/' , / r ~' / cr-I ,. t/( e:--...)- ;:' /c-t-'")~ , ( I ,-:) .I) (.,~__~ I- Nl\M~ _ -;: ~ . ,'"> " ./ , ...::/f/( /;::,~ (~t~ >v1~~" ,.~/'V,~, <~ . . ,..-,: 1:3) ;"z. I. /I - ':;/ c:?.:-J)' '/' r ;,' /'-".... /~I /' DATE ADDRESS / (",.,,) 't. , ' " ' \ ,.... J '. .' . . ". . . '.. ": ' I . . I. . ~ ' ~~ ~ f " , . , Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 1:30 p. m. With reference to Agenda Item #4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice aated 9/26/89 Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby's Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and ~ine, at 490 Manda1ay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CO 89-74 . ('" " .,~. . ro' ", t. ' ';t"I.:, ' In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises w~thin a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of this "conditional use". Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood,_it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave and Bayrnont Street. Respectfully submitted M:~DALAY SURF & SPORT, INC. fir>> 144 c/~ NAME _(l-l.- ?1'1U-r-.~~ ~~ ~ESS r; ~~ (k~</ ~ I 9/],7 iJ 1 DATE f \ ......~,.' "" ,'. " . ".. . ~.' r' t;;(' . :~:.~~' ,,1(.:), ~ "~.: ~"':".; ~\~. ~~", ':; :<,:r. . I'" .t.. ~, ' , '. ',' . : " . I . " I, , .., ., ." " .' ' . '. , ," . ., ". ( , ,...." .. . ~ ("':; ;: . . Public Hearing of the Planning and Zoning Board Meeting City Hall, 3rd Floor, 112 S. Osceola Ave., Clearwater, Fl Tuesday, October 3, 1989 - 1:30 p. ID. With reference to Agenda Item ~4 on notice dated 9/23/89 and "CORRECTED AD" on notice dated 9/26/89 ,'0- Mary G. Realty, Inc. (Chubby's Cafe) to permit on-premises consumption of beer and wine, at 490 Mandalay Ave, Suites 5 & 6, Clearwater Beach Park, Lots 57-63 & part of lot 64, zoned CB (beach commercial). CO 89-74 In as much as there are ten such bars that sell beer and wine for consumption on premises within a one block radius of this request I respectfully submit my request for denial of (:,':: this "conditional use". Further, for the health, welfare and safety of the people of the surrounding neighborhood, it is imperative that this request be denied. It has long been known that the parking lot in this Plaza is a late-night hang-out for gangs with loud radios, screaming people and screeching tires. The local Police patrol the area occasionally, but they tell us that it is private property and there is nothing they (the Police) can do. This request must be denied if we are to preserve this area from gangs and hoodlums that plague the area of Mandalay Ave and Baymont street. Respectfully submitted " DATE ~, . /]I afr:~ I \ ....._0