11/23/1982 (2)
@
J "
, ,
, ..
. ~. ~ .
,@),
. ~ .1 ~.,:
". l~' <,
.,'
H, .
, .:
..
, ,
,
,"
. "';".':'!:
;" ~~:l<!:':>
, ~ I . .
The City Attorney requested dooumentation showing the before-mentioned "
restr-1otions regarding boat slips be submitted as e:videnoe after the taot.',' ,
'The Hearing Offioer Btated any, proposed finding of faot, , oonolusions
of ,law, and reoommendations should.,be submitted ",ithin 10 days.
The hearing adjourned a~ 1:36 p.m.
,.
" :
"
;1" ,
\ " ,
"
" , .. ':,1
,',
"
,;
, ,
. '
",',.. :.
'j ~ '.
~' I,' .4
L U :.
, ,
" I
, ~)
, "
. ' ....
"
" ,
, "c"
~ .' n.
.,j,'
': '; ',~~ >
, .'
, ... . ~ ...'
,'J,
. ... ,,"
" /f :\~'J~~::~:~ :':. ~
... -"
. ~ I
~. .. .
.. t ' " J' " . ',. ,. ,"':',
, '11\~~......:..' W~
Cl. y..Clerk .',. , '.",
. .)
.' :;
. ';,>
I,
'I
",
'\ ,
,\
,,)
.....
"
, '
I ~. ,
" '
"'. L
".\
,.,
.,~~ L' ~ i
'''''1<
.",....'"';,
., ;""<"
\:- .
,'.~ c t~..':
'.1
".'.1
" .
l . :.,'
:.... ," " .
, ,\
,," ..
','
. .t . ~
,
Q
G
2;+:-':':':
-
~/~Lt-..
STATE OF FLORIDA
1J9tpartmtnt of ~bministration
Division of Administtative Hearings
Oakland Buildingt 2009 Apalachee Parkway
TALLAHASSEE
32301
Sob Graham
, Governor
, Nevln G. Smith
Secretary 01 Administration
Chris H, Bontloy
ou.ctor
November 23,1982
Ms. Luci1le Williams
City Clerk
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, Florida 33518
Re:
The Bel Crest Beach Cabanas & Yacht
club, et al. VB. City of Clearwater
(Case No. 82-1722)
,:Mur:t"l:~i~ b:',~e'il'i "eti:'~L, ': ~s.'- CitY'o~f:?(!
clearwater::' tCase"Uo. ' ,82-1723>., '.,\;1-:;'
.I~".~ c".:" ....~.~_...c~ '1.
Dear Ms. Williams:
e
Enclosed are copies of my Orders in the above- .
: styled cases, along ,with a statement for services rendered
in connection wi 1:h the hearings.
Very truly yours,
1(4] fP.~~
Hearin:Y~~;r
Imc
Enclosures
, xc.:' Pamela Phillips, DOAH
'IECEIVED
"'. .;..\ .1:.. .
HOY 29 1m
..
\' .
. ".1
~ :. l- .
~ .
"I
"
'.
arE"~-l
, .j
:;;)ftJt.~'i}..I"~""1-4;i:.<ilfry~'~1,.~';"~t.."!..I~\I~ ~\, ::. /.. ,.\ ..... .,<.. l'~ "'f'" .. '~r l' f':}' t'. .( . _E. I~....
V.;::"~._~:..'.i.;.;.;.::'a'-":'i.';:"::JI:''..!..'~'':'I'~.,;,; ..'1:'......... ,"" "':, '. ','..,(-'.;,." ,'......~.'I".l.
;.:... ..~.~~~~~.:~~/i~ "I'I"II.-..~..lt)':.~~.~oyer,,~ :;..::'-:.~ '/ .~~';~'::'\':',:J~:L".';~: ::.:;.;: ;'t;(y[
t~~:::~'1:lrt~/f.l";"::...::4:.::"I~/1~';'I~~...:~.1~;:YI?~f,~)iiAr,~ I;t. i;~:.. ~;~,}:~: >>1 1.;4:~:'~it/:.(~t,.:.;r ," .~. ,::\",": i.:-'.::...'';...~ ."""~~:,: :,'::.' ':':)i~'i:; ~~';:,J;~\,:;~":~~l~C:;ct;...
~ "i"'.p.'R~~l' ~.f'-"'''''':~.*;:~';''Y' ......-...tr...'."...F . .,. L.j . . . ..,' I' .....-.. '" .' ..'. ~.. ..:ro. .-.p~.,_~~
;!\:
:~ :'. \~. "
. , :l. '.';:. .~\ ~~\ I >
. ". . ~ . .
, ,
,~ ~
. "
",...,..";~,,,..,
.:~:1 ~:. ~~> .~.
'. ... ~':..'. t' .' ; ,,:..' .
.
..
I
.
.'
"
o
~
,.
,
e
STA'.1'E OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEA!tINGS
.,'
MURRAY O'NEIL, et a1., )
Petitioners, )
VB. ) CASE NO. 82...1723
CITY OF CLEARWATER, )
Respondent. )
ORDER
e
. . . .
Pursuant to notice, ,the Division of Administrative
Hearings, by its duly deBigna~ec:i Hearing Office,K.N~AyerB,
held a public hearing in' the above-styled case'on 25 October
19B2,at Clearwater, Florida.
APPEARANCES
For Petitioner: Neil R. covert, Esq.
Gormin, Georghegan, Covert
& Green, P.A.
1212 South Highland A,renue
Clearwater, Florida 33516
For Respondent:, Thomas A. Bustin, Esq. "
City Attorney
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater, Florida 33518
By letter dated June' 16, 1982, Murray R" O'neil,
et al., Petitioners, appealed the denial. of uheir application
for a special exception to construct a Type A Marina on their
'..- '.
property described as Lots 8, 9 and 10, Block A, Bayside
Subdivision No.5, Clearwater Beach, Florida. In their
application for special exception to the Building and
Zoning Regulations of the City'of Clearwater, Petitioners
seek to construct a boardwalk-like dock extending nine
feet waterward of, the seawall and 183 feet long"with six
,',
'e
,. ,
,7finger ':~piers for boat slips extending' 20 feet 'from" the
. ,'I . < ....
': ',.._, dock,' an~ additional mooring pilings extending 32, feet
, .
The Board: of,
','
.' ',.1." '. ~ "
" '.". ." ,
::~'~;j~:::' ,::~;; '.:'".', ::' " : ";,
~i~\~t~0;j:;!}dL'J:\";,; ::\!;,~ < .." ;,-4- ','" ", : .,,' >" ;>,,;:,:: :', "
I....J~\~" J1:";~(\\j"''\.''''''''' ""\', '\ "', , "J,.... '" '" ' ,.,:.." " ..., ," ,
, ~,~'" ~r*!.~5i.\~;~~I)Fi.~~;i~~~;\f;?~~;!,~;t;i~;'!,~(<,: {:;,,, ,::i:~>: ,~: <; ':",. ;'(";;,~:~:{;:~~~,i 20;t:,i;).;\.~;~,:,~;j~
~;rr;,~tk\}.,.~ l.,..:.l"~\ I../~ "., ~ ~\-ill.~'J:h.)L.:.~...t,:....... ~ '.' \~ .....-'Jt.I(~...;~:~,...~t:.)ll.\...~...~~.../";}.~I'~r.....'I...'?t<t:'..r"'.\'-r1'{-"'~~
~~."Jt.l Ii)).: J);~'~ ~ +! :..;1"''' ~ .....:.:\' ~,..I '1 :):.{. ~~~" ,..e' .\.r~"..I}' " ~t~ .~ ~.. 1 ,,':- ...~ ;~,ft.t~......; :".'/ ...~~.. +.;i-;,flr" I. ./....l": '.:;.::;. i:~ l......~ ,'" ~r :.t.,.;:." '+~l':
~i"", '~~;~l' ',l,~~i1icl'r.~ '~r. 't {;. ~ .~ ; ,I ft, \ '~:~l ~oJ~~;,.. f~I..J'~(t\'$ :::."-9' .:'.; ..-/,. -1 :,...."ir'Ji~;} ~:It~~.t~~J 't\: ';J[:~ ~ ~:. ':1.. "_;~f ~~. :'lli{{ 'j~~'~';' ['f'j ~~~.~ V
~~ fit~~~)~~\;1tfi-r.~~"..r;"H..t,') f::;\t,,~~~(~,,:.,,:;,"'';;;:i.,j~~'i ':t ".~~..~~ .:.,:- 1;~~4f,?" ..1~~\'4~~t~~;":;'f~~~1!>...41;"~~~<~"'J~:.:.~,. .~~lV.,..41"-J,~,~,tl-
. 'ill- .
\,
o
D
.....
, .
"
Petitioners here propose. The SeaGull continues to operate
a. a motel, with multiple ownership of the units, ju.t as
Petitioners propose.
7. Absent Exhibits A, B, C and 0 to Exhibit 2, it
is not possible to tell which boat slip is appurtenant to
which motel unit or that one slip may not be appurtenant to more
than one 'motel unit. Since multiple ownership of a single
unit is contemplated by the developer (Art. 13.2.3, Exhibit 2)
the possibility exists that one of the joint owners could
occupy the motel unit while another occupied the boat slip
appurtenant to the unit.
8. The proposed slips propose no hazard to navi-
gation or interfere with the enjoyment of the waters adjacent
thereto by the general public.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The Division'of Administrative Hearings has juris-
diction over the parties to, and the subject matter ,of,
,
,
these proceedings. Section 13'1. 099,. Clearwater Building
and 'Zoning Regulations, provides that a special exception for
marina facilities is permitted in a CTF-2B district. Section
131.016 contains gu:l.delines to consider in determining whether
to approve any regulated special exception'which include:
(1) Ingress and egress to pr.operty
and proposed structures thereon with
particular reference to automobile,
and pedestrian safety ~ ,1 convenience,
traffic flow and control, and access
in case of fire or catastrophe;
.....
(2) Off-street parking and loading
areas where required, with particular
attention to the items in subsection (1)
above, economic, noise, glare or odor
effects of the special exception on
adjoining p~opertie~ and properties
generally in the district.;
'."J': ..: ..y";
,." ., ''>>.
*
*
*
.
'.
@
-
e
-
. . .
... . . .
. ..
.
m '
1"6:
, '
,
.
, !
"
(i)
(1) ~hat each of the 12 slips be assiqned to a
specific motel unit to be Bold,
(.2) That the Declaration of Condominium, Articles
"
"
of Incorporation and By-Laws of the Beach Moorinqs'Condominium
be modified, if necessary, to provide that the unit owners
and lessees of the units with appurtenant boat slips can use
these slips for their own boats only while in occupancy of
the units, and other boats moored at these slips shall at
all times be under the direction arid control of the occupant
of the motel unit 'at the time the boat j,s moored at the slip
appurtenant to t.he unit; and'
-
(3) The wording of these conditions be modified,'
if necessary, and approved by the City of Clearwater Planning
and, Zoning Board to ensure the construction' arid operatio~'
of this marina will not creat.e', addit'!ona'J: 'parking' problems in
the vicinity of this condominium motel by permitting one
other than the current occupant o~ the motel ,unit to moor a'
.
boat at the slip appurtenant to t}{~t motel unit.
DONE AND ORDERED this ~'Ml day of November, 1982"
at Tallahassee, Florida.
tit
.~?JEa~
Hearing or:.r:l.:r
Division of Administrative Hearings
Oakland Building
2009 Apalachee Parkway
Tallahassee, Florida 32301
904/488-9675
FILED with the Clerk of the Division
of Administrative Hearings this ~:s I\.d..
day of November, 1992.
Copies furnished to:
~/:',',:,:".:.":>. :, ,:~~, .;, ,Thomas A. 'Bustin, Eag.' Neil, R. COVCJ;t, Esq.
:\:';':;'.'.-,"..' , Post' Office Box' 4748 Gorrnin, Georghegan, Covert'
"':::":.' , ' , , <', 'Clearwater, Florida 33516 & Green, P.A. " '
m~',~~.c~)~~:':: "'/"'::",.' , '," " '..,' 1212 South Highland: Avenue' ' . '
;:.~T>. ';,'" ",' :,," Ms. Luoille Williams Clearwater, Florida 33516 ,. ,
~'6i~,\J::;:~,<., ' ' '..'City Clerk ..,' ' .." , ",;' , '; ,
.;",;i~,:-"",."..t..;:."'J':.,Post.:Office,Box 4748 ' " ' ,,' , :,'
.,r..1l,o.\........n!'i.. I.~ . i' l' ida '33 1 I'
i{.::"6~i..,:.';.)'.:.\/',.':.,.,.,C1earwater".F or 5 6 , ", ," ',' ".;....:,.
r~~J;~::;~:;:~~,,~~',;)::'j~/(,<<-:~~.'<t:;.,<,,>.>. '. ....'", ,'.' ".... ',' ,',,: ,.'..:.: ,,' ,',.,:.,.'..:',\.".
~2\-~~i\...)''!1..(.,....,t.....\j-...),~J I ~... .i.,..../ I., . .., oi, \ " ' . ,~....~.
~ )'.~,.~ ,..f...~~t~~l......:'\~(t'.,,',........... l:.~....,:::'\;. .',H <'; ,', " . :,'....~..~,~ ","~'. . . t~1 "'.-":1.. ..', .i',+' .
~ ":. ;/t...~~fl;~t:if~~'~i:i;:,;t.\:{<{~,?i'::.i~',;,'.;; :/;: ...;... .,: 1 :-. ',~,~~i':~t '.'v....~,~' ,,," ," " '." ",:~.\ ~" ;'1: /'J'.!;I'."'; ,': ""~' , /\: ;~'~...': '.'<." "'; /':
t ~ .~' .. t1r ~i\ a ~ ~ ~~l~~~C~~/?!r.~::r~f~: ~~~~.; ~i; '~:J: .-:t~. 'j' . ~:~.~'r>" ;; ~:~. ' ~!:: ~',\~. ~' :' i . .": ;'::..f: :-:k '.1"" \ '. . ,::; . '~:', " ,';' .'; I~~.' ~, ,T ~ :.... .,l, , I .~.::.. :r~ (.~1: ,)~:: .= ~: ~ . t,~_:t . . ,t ~~:;",.~;: ,~?
:~l.r.. ~.~.l'l.t""'" '.r ~I ", ~.;.. . . ~... ,.:to,):. 'r "' f'il" t\. :. \ I' IJ r ." '"1 i Tf' "1." . ,n~ '. \....:...
. ... ~ :~.~ {V. 'J;.J::'i~":'.;" '\~'~'lo~ ;/:....) ~~~}..~, "';:: '.>d i~' :'~/'~I ,lI", , ...~;. .;~,+ \q. t.",', 'L ~\; ," t..r' ~J \.,.. t).. '. ~ ,:" :'~. \<, .' Ji ~ I~: }l ~i I', : .i."" ~<)" ~I:" /. j ,-:....;{ ;~',.f
Z\"t:""'I:t~~. ~',' 1:. ."t';:I.; i~..~ '< > " j~::f~~",~ : ....\I,~\ I !.-I~.: 'U1 rt ~j.:)' ~ -<.. .1 I- .~~... J ':"'1[' t. '.:~ i' ..: : '.I~ ;... .:; ~;' . ~ l :..:. ~ '~-:':4 - Ilr ....l 4.. :'41, '"f":"'n- {..........~' .(.'~-~~:;tj\-.",~r
Jrt'o."'~~l.tj'-r.(:.\...../.':1 "".,..r_J.~ :)1'!"f~"I; ......'~..141t-..~!I,;f~L- )ifI.J.....,r.I~.~ .... ~ I~ ~ ,.,4\''', ,?C. """'i.lt'-['
.' ~,;,t.' ",' " l':-;O- , .~ \.;,..,~f~l~~YG~~~'f;ft~~r;~~~~~;.~lli:~Iwfrk~l};il:~l~J:',~)~f:.,t:,H~~~~~ :{~~~:~,}g~{ifjhtr~~lj:
~I ~~v.;~~;i'Jii~~~:{rii~,~~~~Ji~~;!.~"iJ~~f;.:~R~4r;(~'t1t~;i:~Jl~JW~~
1. ~. d~ ~1~':l,~~.Q~J~; ~IJ~' tr tft ,:lr~"'r~.t'\>"T ~ p;f}}o f' ,. +.-'I'lI... ~"'.f"' ,.t -lIf, I"'~ ..\/ "1~~~T