08/18/1981
.~...
._~
ie'
MINUTES
THE PLANNING & ZONING BOARD
City of Clearwater, Florida
August 18, 1981 - 1:30 PM
Members present:
Chairman Parks, Mrs. WUlfeck, Nrs. Regulski; Messrs.
Bickerstaffe, Canan, Goodwin, Kuntz, Mazur and Turner;
John D. Richter, Chief Planner/Current
Public hearing was held for the purpose of considering annexation and
zoning items followed by public hearing for the purpose of considering
items to be included in an ordinance amending the Land Use Plan and
Zoning Atlas.
Tapes of public hearings are on file in the Planning Department.
On motion by Mr. Bickerstaffe, seconded by Nr. Kuntz, minutes of
August 4, 1981 were approved as written.
Planning and Zoning Board recommended as follows.
Annexation & Zoning:
1. East 17 ft. of Lot 14, Pinellas Groves Sub., NE 1/4 of Sec.
12-29-15 (Brunet)
Request: Annexation & Zoning, ML, Ligh t ~Ianufacturing
Above property is located on the north side of Range Road, west of Belcher
Road. Subject site consists of .18 acres MOL and is presently planned
industrial.
/"
Applic~nt Norman Brunet requested waiver of the parkland recommendation
dedication.
']
Mr. Richter pointed out that this property is to be: utilized as a parking
area .'for Prec,is ion l'>lanufac tur.ing. The ML zoning is cons is ten t ,'Ii th the
Comprehensive Land Use Plan and with other properties in this area pre-
viously annexed into the City.
"No one appeared in opposition to above request.
Motion was made by Mr. Bickers ta ffe, seconded by ~Irs. WUlfeck, to recom-
mend approval of above request with agreement ~o waive parkland dedication.
2.
Portion of Lots 27 & 28, Clear'ia ter Manor Sub., Sec. 6 - 29 -16.
Request: Annexation & Zoning, RS-60, Single Family Residential
(Abad)
. .
,e
Above property is located on the east side of Belcher Road, west of Nanor
Blvd. Subject site is developed with a singie family residence.
Mr. Richter stated an Agreement to Annex was executed for the property
on October 17, 1979 and the City is now exercising its option to annex.
The requested zoning is consistent with the LO\i Density plan classification
I
.~
~
- -
Minutes of the Planning & Zoning Board - August 18, 1981
Page H2
~.
-
and with other properties within this subdivision previously anriexed
into the City.
No one appeared either in support of or in opposition to above request.
Motion was made by Mr. Mazur, seconded Mr. Goodwin, to recommend approval
of a~ove request. Motion carried unanimously.
3. Lots 5 & 6, ,Palmetto Terr. Sub., Sec. 7-29-16 (Dohrman & Smith)
Request: Annexation & Zoning, RS-60, Single Family Residential
Above property is located west of the intersection of Arlington Place and
Hemerick Place. Subject sites are each developed with a single family
residence.
Nr. Richter stated an Agreement to Annex was executed for the property
on JanuaTY 31, 1977 and the City is now exercising its option to annex.
The requested RS-60 zoning is consistent with the Low Density plan classi-
fication and with the zoning placed on other lots \~ithin this subdivision
previously annexed into the City.
No one appeared either in support of or in opposition to above request.
Motion was made by Mr. Bickerstaffe, seconded by Mr. Canan, to recommend
approval of above request. ~Iotion carried unanimously.
--
4. W 480.78 f~. of SW~ and of NE~ lying S of County Road SO.
Sec. 5-29-16 (Sylvan Abbey United Methodist Church)
Request: Annexation & Zoning, ISP, Institutional Semi-Public
e
.
Above property is located south of County Road SO between U.S. 19 &
lo'cMullen-Booth Rd. Subject site consists of 2.82 acres MOL.
Mr. Mike Oliver, Pastor of Sylvan Abbey United Methodist Church, requested
to have City water and sewer service for subject site. He also requested
waiver of parkland dedication.
~tr. Richter stated that site plans were reviewed by the Resource Develop-
ment Com~ittee on August 13, 1981 and were approved subject to the
'condition that a sidewalk be constructed adjacent to Main Street.
Discussion ensued by Board members concerning the sidewalk. Nr. Bickerstaffe
stated his concern of whether the sidewalk will be used or not. ~~. Richter
stated that if the sidewalk isn't required.as a condition of the annex-
ation, the City will likely no~ have the opportunity again to have the
church guarantee that the sidewalk will be provided. ,
No, one appeared in support of or in opposition to above request.
Motion was made by ~lr. ~Iazur, seconded by Mrs. Wulfeck, to recommend
approval stating that the parkland dedication requirement be waived and
that the applicant be required to install a sidewalk along the right-oE-way
when deemed appropriate by the City of Clearwater. Motion carried unani-
mously.
CD'
e.
~tinutes of the Planning & Zoning Board - August 18. 1981
Page "3
('
Lot 7, Block E, Oak Acres Add., Sec. 23-29-15 (Ashley)
Request: Annexation & Zoning, RS-75, Single Family Residential
Above property is located on the west side of Duncan Ave. S. north of
Lakeview Road. Subject site is developed with a single family residence.
5.
Mr. Richter stated that the applicant desires City sewer service. The
requested RS-75 zoning is consistent with the 'Lo\~ Dens i ty plan classifi-
cation and with the zoning placed on other properties within this sub-
division previously annexed into the City.
The applicant was not present.
No one appeared either in support of or in opposition to above request.
Motion was made by Mr. Mazur, seconded by Mr. Goodwin, to recommend
approval of above request. Motion carried unanimously.
6. Lot 4, Block 8, Highland Pines First Add., Sec. 11-29-15 (Benson)
Request: Annexation & Zoning, RS-SO, Single Family Residential
Above property is located on the south side of Gentry Street, west of Ridge
Avenue. Subject site is vacant and is proposed to be developed with a
single family residence.
The requested
\d th the
~tr. Richter stated that the applicant desires City services.
zoning is consistent with the Comprehensive Land Use plan and
zoning in the immediate area.
The applicant was not present.
No one appeared either in support of or in opposition to. above request.
Motion was made by Mr. Bickerstaffe. seconded by Mr. Kuntz, to recommend
apptova1 of above r~quest. Motion carried unanimously.
........
Annexation & Zoning & Land Use Plan Amendments:
1. Lots 5-10 inclusive. Block 3. Ackers Sub.. Sec. 28-28-16
(Exchange Bank & Trust Co. of Fl.)
a. Annexation & Zonin~:
Request: PS, Professional Services
b. Land Use Plan:
From: Commercial Tourist Facilities
To: Residential/Office
Above property is located west of McMullen-Booth Road abutting Daniel
Street and Charles Avenue. Subj ec t site consis ts 0 f 1. 0 acres ~[OL.
Mr. Richter stated an Agreement to Annex was executed for the property
on December 7, 1978. The property is expected to be eligible for annex-
ation on August 20, 1981 with the adoption of Ordinance 2313 which will
annex the Eckerd Drug property into Clearvater's corporate limits. The
, ' - ", fl.'" ". ,'..' ....'"'''~.,_.'' ~.., '~""'':''1t..,.~. \ ''0:
...~~II. ~ At, i.+.Ji :'::~.r.;~..~"'- ....l~'...\ ~-.~"'Ir"-~' ;~, :.{o; ::'. 1" ". ~. ":-~.;~':."\'"';h~U-" ~~t~~J.-~~.~:~l.~): ~t:l\~,},~.,~ 'r".~ ~... ~\i.?ft.i.tlf..~l+~ ,.''; ~.
:3!t::--.--....,""-.!tt't~.t-:\-~,,~.(... ,,~,,~".1TOJ:~~.,.:, ;." f':. ~ ...... . 'It~ J.t.'t'~~/'l -.~~.r') ~:-r"" ....l.I.\ ~W~.., .
~-~~. J.<;~~~ ,.~ ~ ... \" i'T ~ ..~'.~.,.,,(. J. ~ ~,,!:.f~\1 ~~ ',~ ,_',', ", ~_tJ:~,.-.'.'"._."".r"f.,~, ... ...... ../.,.,,' ","';!:" .....~, /t,.t:c."o.', ~_.-._,',~~. ~> ',t,""'.', ,","-"".
:."::I~;r:".1:" ::f~:;~~""> - ;..;....... '''':.i..'c<.~-~,,:.~~_I,~:: ...:.,.... ~ ~,h'''' ~"n. .. ...... "'~,' ....
Minutes of the Planning & Zoning Board - August 18, 1981
Page /#4
("
0'
applicant is requesting a waiver of the parkla.nd dedication.
T~e applicant was not present.
'Mr. Mazur stated concern over whether there are sidewalks. Nr. Richter
feels that from all indications. there are sidewalks adjacent to NcMullen-
Booth Road. Mr. Bickerstaffe stated if there are no sidewalks, then they
should be installed consistent with city policy.
No one appeared either in support of or in opposition to above request.
Motion was made by Mr. Bickerstaffe, seconded by Mr. ~~zur, to recommend
approval stating that the parkland dedication requirement be \~aived and
that city sidewalks, if they are not already there, be installed at the
expense of the applicant when deemed appropriate by the City.
Land Use Plan & Zoning Atlas Amendments:
1. Portion Block B, Bon Air Sub., Lots 30-33 inclusive, Drew Park
Sub., Sec. 10-29-15 (Allen/Voice of Faith Christian Center, Inc.)
a. Land Use Plan:
From: Commercial Tourist Facilities and
Medium Density Residential
To: Public/Semi-Public
b.
Zoning
From:
Atlas:
CG (General Business) & R~I-12
(Duplex-Apartment Residential)
ISP (Institutional Semi-public
Above property is located on the east side of ~lyrtle Avenue, north of Drew
Street, opposite the County Health Department. Subject property consists
of .68 acres MOL.
To:
e
~lr. Richter stated subject property is surrounded by Single Family Residences
on the east side of Myrtle.
Rev. Maclin Milner, Jr., speaker and pastor of Voice,of Faith Christian
Center, Inc., requested to waive the application fees.
No one appeared in favor of above request.
Motion was made by Mrs. Wulfeck, seconded by Mr. Turner, to recommend
approval of above request. Motion carried unanimously.
Dock Applications:
1. Isle of Sand Key Condos - 1621 Gulf Blvd.
(Cont'd from Planning & Zoning Board meeting of August 4)
Above item was continued to allow sufficient time for subject plans to be
approved by the Harbormaster for presentation to the Board. Request is to
extend the existing marina 65 feet to the east and west, adding four slips
on each end.
"
0"
e,
..
Minutes of the Planning & Zoning Board - August 18, 1981
Page 1#5
Mr. L.M. Conklin, representing the applicant. stated the plans have been
approved by the Harbormaster. Both ~Iills Development and the Isle of Sand
Key will relinquish one boat slip. He stated that ~lills Development would
not sign the agreement until their attorney could look at it. ~Ir. Conklin
requested that the Board approve the plans in spite of the delay to sign
the agreement.
Mr. Pfeil then presented drawings of the new agreement.
Mr. Goodwin stated concern with the prospect that ~lills Development may
not be willing to sign the agreement.
Mrs. Regulski requested that a letter of agreement be signed before the
application is heard by the Board of Adjustment and Appeal on
August 27, 1981.
Mr. Richter stated another suggestion for approval that the slips be
reserved for the exclusive use of the condominium residents and not for
e~ale or lease to anyone other than those residents.
~Iotion was made by Mrs. Regulski, seconded by Nr. Goodwin, to approve the
dock application subject to 'the completion and signing of the letter of
agreement on removal of the tie poles. before the Board of Adjustment
and Appeal meeting on August 27, and with the further provision that the
slips be used for condominium owners only.
Motion carried unanimously.
2. The Harbour - 1591 Gulf Blvd.
(Cont'd from Planning & Zoning Board meeting of August 4)
Above item was continued in order for Mr. Pfeil to make appropriate arrange-
ments with the Department of-Public Works to insure that any dredging done
in conjunction with the construction of these slips, be done in a manner
which would not adversely effect the marine environment of the bay.
Mr. Richter stated he was in possession of a letter from the applicant
which has been reviewed by Mike Kenton. Assistant Director of the Department
of Public Works. The letter establishes five conditions which satisfy
the Public Works Department's concerns if incorporated as conditions of
approval for this application. The five conditions are: (1) Public Works
Department approve the location of all turbidity controls. silt screen,
mesh size and spoil containment area design; (2) no keeled boats of deep
draft boatsj (3) all dredging be done on the incoming or ebb tide; (4) all
monitoring for turbidity be set up on a daily basis at the expense of the
applicant; and (5) make for the public record recognition that this is
indeed a dock application and that Planning and Zoning Board and Public
Works Department stand on record as being opposed that this not to become
a precedent-setting operation that would allo\~ further channel maintenance
or more channels to be constructed to open water from this site.
Mr. Richter suggested one more condition. The slips be used faT the
exclusive use of the condominium residents and not for sale aT lease to
the general public.
No one appeared in opposition to above request.
.
Minutes of the Planning & Zoning Board - August 18, 1981
Page 116
(;
0/
"lotion was made by Hrs. Wulfeck, seconded by ~Ir. Bickerstaffe, to approve
the application subject to all conditions by ",hich Mr. Richter previously
.,s ta ted.
Meeting ',adj ourned at 2: 33 PM.
.' '
.'
l~~.I) e~
John J Rlc~ter, Acting Secretary
Chief Planner/Current
~ ~ .
, "
:.' ~.f.
, ,
. , "
. ",
T-. ,'2,"
.: ~ ,
.< , T.
o :"," 'f . .
, ,
, ,
I ,~ .
I :.~ , T'" .
.~, , . ~
< '~<~~':"'<" '.
" >'
"....
:~.~~:..t:;.:\....";~.. v
'\'1'Jti~\";:": ........ ','
.", . . I'
,. . , ,":. :.
;...~. ..'{~ ~. '. ~. > ,
. " .
.:' ~ ~ 1
~ : " .
," '
'" .
, .
" I .
"
, I
~ ~ f .'"
. ~ !l~'.i: ,.: I" .
,i~~i'{i~'\'?': ...";'
~. .. .l ; .
::~.~;':" < ~ .. .: }'.
T~~~.. <; .
"
" :
:::':e'. : ..:..:" ':.: .
. r~ .'; .' c'...
",>;, . '. T I " . ,
:;.\,1":i~.~:':'~~ '~'.:' '~..t'.':":"1
::":," ;i.'/.~',J<:' ," .
.~ ;:> . .~'::; ~~.I; . .. ',' : ' :
. ,"I' " . .
::. ~. ~'. ",... ~ . '- . .
::''':.. ~: ,. ,1:1.., ",'
.
.'l. .
.\4 .
'/
!'
:j'
" ,
. ~:. '
...... ,>.
, ...
',.', '.-..;;:: ',' ,:", . '"
,.~.,.. .:.':'~I': '
\.' .
. ,-. ".
~. .' ~
. : ,.,', '". ':-',,; ~. . ;",',
, ,~~.", ':, : .: ,
" ,.... :........., ".
."J"." ,<
" ',.:~~,~',' '.',' ',:: .' >. ". ., .. .
. ~~.~.\ or~' :" ,_
.:': ,", c.'; _.~,:. ','~ ~ ',:(:' ,'.'~. " . .. . .' .
, ' . ~.. .:: ".: ~ ", ...'
.".1:' .
,.:" ..:',
...... .
" .
"'. . .
. ". ~ .
:/n!c!: OF PU3LIC H!:A?I::r,
Planning and Zoning Board ~ TuesdAY. Au~ust let 1~3~t at lll~ p.~.
A;tj)
Clearwater City Co~iBsion ~ ~ursdaYt Septeober 3. 1981. at 7130 ~.rn.
Place ~ COMIUSSrO:' m':I:TI:'G ROO:1. CI':'Y HALL. Clea:,",o/At.r. Fl.
To consider request tor annexation into the Cit~ and establish :ono an~
Fir_ District Classification:
1. East 17 ft. ot Lot 14. Pinellas Groves Sub. t m::l~ o!
Sec. 12-29-15. Located on tho :1 side of Rango Road,
S ot SCLRR. and W of Belcher Rd.
Zoning - NL (LiEht :~anu!aeturinl1) And FO H.
(Brunet) Annex 81-22.
2. Portion of Lots 27 & 28. CleaNater Hanor Sub..
Sec. 6~29-16. Located at 1732 W. Manor Ave.
Zoning - RS~60 (SinBle ra~ily Residence) and FD H2.
(Abad) Annex &1~24.
3.a. Lot 5. B1 Bt Paloetto Terr. Sub.. Sec. 7-29~16.
Located at 2240'Heoerick Pl. (Dohrman)
b. Lot 6. B1 B. Palmetto Terr. Sub.. Sec. 7-29-16.
Located at 2249 Hemerick Pl. (Smith)
~oning - RS-60 (Single Family Residence) and FD '2.
Annex 81-26.
4. portion of S~/. of :IE~ of Sec. S~29-l6. Located S o!
County Rd. SO between U.S. 19 S McMullen-Booth Rd.
Zoning - ISP (Institutional Semi~Pub1ic) and FD fl.
(Sylvan Abby United Methodist Church) Annex al~27.
5. Lot 7. B1 E. Oak Acres Add., Sec. 23-29-15.
Located at 1~12 Duncan Ave. S.
Zoning - RS~7S (Single Family Residence) anc FD #2.
(Ashley~ Annex al-28.
G. Lot 4. B1 8. Hip,hland Pines First Add.. Sec. 11~29-1S.
Located 011: ...... Gen1:ry St. Ulli' .......
Zoning - RS~50 (Single Family Residence) and FD ~2.
(Benson) Annex 91-29. .
To consider reQuest for Annexation into the City, estab~ish Zone ~nc
Fire District Classification, and to amend the Co~p~ehenoive Land Usa
Plan of tn_ City of Clearwater:
1. Lots S~10 inclusive. Bl 3. Ac~ers Sub.. Sec. 28-26-16.
Located on the ,W side of McMullen-Booth Rd. abu~tinB
Daniel St. S Charles Ave.
LUP Amendment from Cocme~cial Tourist Facilities to
Rcsidential/Office.
Zone - PS (Professional Services) and FD fll.
(Exc?ange Bank & Trust Co. of Fl.) Anne~ 81-25 LUP 31-~5.
70 consider request ~or aoendrnents to the Comprehensive Land Cse ?lan
and the Zoning Atlas ot tile City of Clea~,o/ater:
2. Portion Bl B. BonAir Sub. and Lots 30-33 inclusive.
Drew Parle Sub., Sec. 10-29-15. Loca.ted a't 30 3 ~r :~yrtle
Ave.
LUP AmendCent frem Commercial 70urist Facilities and
Medium D4nsi~J Resicential to Public/Seoi Public.
Zone - from CG (General Business) S :m-12 (Dul)lex~
hpartment Residential) to IS? (Institutional 5eoi-
Public). '
(Allen/Voice of Faith Christian Center, Inc.) : 81-46 LU? a1-~4.
Flori~a Statute ~36.0105 states:' Any a~plicAnt apnealing a cecisian o!
,this coar~ ~ust have a verbatio record o! the ~roce~cinr.s to sUp~crt
such an atlpeal.
7hose City Land Use Plan A~enc~ents sub~ec~ ~c A?:roval ~~ the ~inellas
?lanninrr Council will ~e !orwarded to the ?rC !or ?ub~ic ~earinr.
, :,uubsequent to public ~earini anc action ~y t~e ~i'='l CC::Io':\issbn.
',Ci~i=en$ =~y appear to be heard or !ile wri,=~en notice a! a~~roval or
0~1 ection with the ?1anninG Director or C!:::t C:eri: ;:1rior ';0 a~oro~ri"..:e'
, ,?Ublic Hear!.n!;.
. .....,
, '.' CitY o! Clear.'la-:er. fj,.
, ,.'.. Da";id iiub:t. Plann!.n", ::!.rec'tor :".:~!.l:'e ~':i:':'ia~s, Ci '=:' C:e':'~
< A?plicant or represen'tative must ~e ~rosen,; ~o a~~rcss t~e re~ueste~
<." &r.:ene:ent:1 a't both public heari:'J.Ss 4
, '
yOU A.~ BEI:fG Sr::l't '::;:::S lfO'I':C!: IF '!,:r A?':: 'r":!::: A??!..ICA:I'.:' Oil o:m ?~OP:::P.'Z"!
\~~~Ia 200 FT. OF ':Hi: APPLICA:I,:t S ??,oPt?!"!.
Acv. a/S/H
'.
':1
..
.\;
. .'1
,\" '
'\', I II
ct
AGENDA ~
PLANNING & ZONING BOARD
August 18, 1981
1:30 PM
-
ITEM
-
ACTION
A '. Approva~ 'of minu~es of August 4, '1981
B . Annexation & Zoning:
1. Property located on the N'side of Range
Road, S of SCL,RR, and W of Belcher Rd.
(Brunet)
Request: Annexation & Zoning, ML
(Light Manufacturing)
2. Property located at 1732 W. Manor Ave.
(Abad)
Request: Annexation & Zoning RS-60
(Single family Residence)
3.
located at 2240 Hemerick Pl.
& Smi th)
Annexation & Zoning RS-60
(Single Family Residence) .
4. Property located S of County Rd. 50 between
u.s. 19 & McMullen-Booth Rd. (Sylvan Abbey
United Methodist Church)
Request: Annexation & Zoning, IsP
(Institutional Semi-Public)
Property
(Dohrman
Request:
5. Property located at. 1212 Duncan Ave. S (Ashley)
Request: Annexation & Zoning RS-75
(sing~e Family Residence)
6. Property located at 1613 Gentry St. (Benson)
Request: Annexat~on & Zoning Rs-50
" (Single Family ReSidence)
C - Annexation & Zoning & Land Use Plan::Amendments:
1., Property' located on the W side of McMullen-Booth
Rd. abutting Daniel St. & Charles Ave. (Exchange
Bank & Trust Co. of Fl.) Sec. 10-29~lS
a . Annexation & Zoning,:,
Request: PS,Professional Services
. '
- '
b. Land Use Plan:
From: Commercial Tourist Facilities
To: Res~dential/Office
D - Land Use Plan & Zoning Atlas Amendments:
.. , 1.
Property located at 303 N Myrtle Ave.
(Allen/Voice of Faith Christian Center, Inc.)
Sec. ,10 - 2 9 -1 5
a. Land Use Plan: '.
From: Commercial Tourist Facilities and
Medium Density Residential
To: Public/Semi-Public
:";e
, -~
b. Zoning Atlas:
H" , From:, CG (General Business) & RM-IZ
;~ \;:.,',. (Duplex-Apartment Residential)
1ti;;,-::"E' '':OCk APp:::a tio::: (Ins tl tu tional Sem1-Public]
~;;~'/\'>\,.' :~. 10 I s Ie 0 f Sand Key Condo s 1621 Gul f Blvd.
~::"_ ',' , (Cont' d from Planning & Zoning Board meeting of August 4)
~~ ) - ,'. .. .":
. ~. "
, 2.
The Harbour - 1591 Gulf Blvd.
(Cont'd from Planning & Zoning Board meeting of August 4)
>~.: . . <' ~ . .' ,
,\ I ~.;. .> n
~ :~:( +" '.
. .. ~ ,
'i{,;:;:;:..."F.
~}i~;;.~..... . .', G ~
~,Chairmanls Items
Director's Items
HBoard& Staff Comments