01/10/1991 (2)
~' " ':':'. .
.:.. ' .. J'~. , . ,.
.~ . I .~, ';,', . ' ,
~ '. \.
. :' . . ~
"
. ,,~ .
,....;.
;
; "
" , " ;
"
shall
months
subject to the
that (1) the
requisite occupational license
be obtained wi thin six
from the date of this
public hearing, (2) the
landscaped areas on the north,
east and south sides of the site
shall be improved through the
installation of additional
landscape material as well as
an irrigation system to ensure
the survivability of any
landscaping installed; the
proposed landscape plan shall
be approved by the Planning and
Development Db:'ector and the
Environmental Group Manager; all
required landscaping and
associated irrigation shall be
installed within three months
of the date of this public
hearing, (3) a 30 inch fence or
wall shall be installed as a
barrier to separate the outdoor
seating area from the sidewalk
and the driveway; this fence
or wall shall be installed
within three months of the date
of this public hearing, (4) the
applicant shall obtain the
:t'equired conditional use permit
from the Planning and Zoning
Board and (5) the applicant
shall obtain the required
alcoholic beverage separation
distance variance from the City
Commission.
'C
3. Julie F. Tiernan (Seafood
and Sunsets at Julie'S) for a
variance of five parking spaces
to allow expansion of existing
restaurant with zero additional
parking spaces provided at 351
S. Gulfview Blvd., Lloyd-White-
Skinner Sub, Lot 70, zoned CR-
28 (resort commercial). V 91-
03
3. Granted
conditions
"
II.
Board Comments
II.
III. Minutes of November 29, 1990
and December 13, 1990
III.
Approved as submitted.
IV.
Adjourronent
IV.
3:55 p.m.
DCAB Agenda
2
01/10/91
, ;~" ' ~~jl~t:~\r51;,:1;~~~;~~f:7:~,;~i~~f,i{~',;;:',:;<'::;>~?f\:-'~~"j,!~:(;?14jih~;~:~rh.t\l.;7i:::;~~~:' .': ;:: '),~:;f:~~~:<':'~'7.~i:.~:;:,:;J;"::/ J?~~?'~~~'~-;'~::';{~~~::; t ~:,,,,., ,.4'tJ
~ft~~'fifr~.~~'! ~~';T '.':~(~ ~. ;', ~~:~[.'it:I;~~ {". ;->~ ~;~~;~.'I ~.t~x "'> ~rl/!""; ~~J\~~J..'i>,>\t~~~/~~.t-,:;, .'\:",,/t \.';';:::'i,~l,:::r.l~ .( '," ~~, ~ 'T-..:;\ 'fc~' '~\<~. '~~l; ~. if ,'~.. .~,..; j;....., ~r'.r~(\iu..:;.:~./: \i~, ,..~E J. ..~/\~,r;~{~~(9A~,fJr~~~Jt~W;,,~~.
tII"'''' ,"""t'... ;"",;:-;\f" "'l.';~ .t,','" "t/"""_~'''''',,.l\...,'.......,'''....~r<l'''--!''''..t'. ......"'" ....r...'4.:J> ~:f.,.,~J~~~JI~,.~.'.... \-\ .'.,. ~Y'~H~1 J.....".',~...,'~~"'...~ 'f'l.~\~"'J;\-['~",: ..
t,.~.1 :tf'~Jl ~'t.J.(",.t;~~\:'"J\f/ .:;'t.-t{/,. ;..t:;'V:. ~r,1"'~ .'\ ~; \~:. \:.~~"~~~~~."...' ....~ :.~.~>; f. ~j;"~... .i;:''''''l~!\.-.. 'f.:f~~'l: ~ ...~/~ ":,~:,":.r ~ "~.\'ir~ :,'~:<;. ..,.' f~: ~;th' 0" ~ ~),.....' ( ~ :'::: ~'f ...;.., I.~\'. ;'1/.:\):. .,~.. ',': :'~"~~~l-' ~~,j.:.~1!t J\ ''fl ~J~i~tJ'~;-~'~~ ". ;"
~u ... t)<.,-:J" ~r>-..-q~-11rif"~~'"~ -f' '~l~.:':'.-'(~ ~ <.' ',.~-'\"'~ '..lor .....' ..,.,~~'tJ,)) ,~~... '~"-"""."""'.'r ',- _T..,......~ "11" .1'<'.,. 4.0 ~'",1. .;;\ ......"~I"i-...~'?t,,,.....!
ij "~fo'~J<'''f.i't'"ij..j~'\ ,-,I f'f~":\' ~':":'-""~"''''''i'41/1f ~, ,L ~'_.I, .,.:;,~,'I'i~''''\''''.~''':: '''''JiJ-''"'/.J&''fI.\.:'~'''''''~'''f\.,...~"....~.,:,~~~jL. ~,.J,' .-F' ,>""~~; ~'r...,~'l....y,,~.~.'if>";.tt)o-..,i'i-n~'l~+:"',:"~ ~
i!""Jt~:'J:~:!: ...~~?.r:~:~~~;') .~.~1J'!J. ~'t~;\';~'~l,~''''~f~~: aLl ~: ~ :.:'.'. .:/~. l~ ~ t. '.h~;. 'Y~~\'.~ii{~,~:" :," ~::\: :.~ ;- '~.lP;\~";:I/\~':~:" l~\ ~,~~.:,_.;.::>: ;>";:.., \:'~'t :.: '} .t't~ ;.) ';'~r~!L \l:.;..:t/(~~ ~ 1~~.~1~_t~:'\~~.11~:rt)~\i
:k.i,;. ~t'~'Ll .~" ~.~. ~I,/,-f.: .~ '~'~ 1\1.~~~: \.~:t".: l~ ,'" D~ ~ ,r. .' I~ \ ..... I \ ,of J';\1:~;'" ....c.\ ~~~<"~{iF~.. :t~ ~ :.: \ < ~~~"~J. ' ~\~~"',,>:~}'~ .,:- ~:"':'(; (~,o....t" j.'.. "~'~' ~~ :~~... i:~,;,t:~~L~'lEtQ~~-'l\~.I ~'.;i blh..}Y,JJ'rf.
,'~,;' ,;'::" '~'0'~"ft ,; ;?!~;,:1~'~:lM~ti;:',;','" ,",::'~~:{;;i ;" :, .,','.: ,:'.:' .":"s~i;{jJ"1{>~:;L:,~:?;:i~t,;,):);;;'<:j,,;t~~y:':>;'~\\;~;j~~~J:~~~~~~~t~i~t~,
...... ~ ,.' ........-or-
,~ '~1r-::t.1~:7:).,~~'.~~1..~~,~~~:,t.-:....:~,. . 1 . . "~ . . ,\', . ~ ". "\!~'. ~
,,1, ,1\ "f' "". 7',~' ," "/;'" ' ,. ,\l?'~
""ifi"".'I".;-,:::..i:\~!...1'i":l'1~~'~'/.Jn"'I!;P.1t'~ : ,',', +~". .\ ''''"'I~_f~''' >, , I '~'.' ~~, > .' .'; .'\.,..,...."..' -:. "j' :"fi,.b;.,'}',:;~
f.'~~IIJ'l!"lI'" ,',f," "~';";'; 1.'....',.<",..'.,. ",^' " "/""",,,," \\ "...,p..,lt", ,. """"'l"'-'~~"/I--'f"~~ltI.~
I,:;~~: . '. ",' t:
~ " :-..,. ~s;{~
~.i"').I'U~:'~'\~""",~:jjJ,'-.i~U~~~;~_"'~~J.~\~,~.....,...~~i....V\i'~~"'" ..,I,:j"'~i ~ ~"',,~ ,/r,..~/....,""...... .:,',,~ .. ,~~ 't.,' '. '~l" <0'1';.,.1... "','~'J . ~r!"':'I~'. ..,-",<...~l...:t, '.:,';.:,1.;.. L' ~,',' \"J.~fjJ.lIVi\:;I"'}\I-~,~~t>:1
~ ,," ". !
. .' .: ~q . . ~. ..!.
, \
..1 '
'.)'. '
, ~ 114' J .
'.,'1'
.;! '. 1" (\'.. . ,T~ . . ,
'.1 '" ~ ~ ,L. : I, . . .' I < . . , " , , I Jo . " . " " ~,
l:t 'I,'
" ,
t
""~~~ 'I' H ~I:; ..t" .~
T . .;..~) " '- < ,'. :,:'.'
" ,
t. ": ./"..
. -.. . . . i ' I . , .' . . . . '. I~' .
..
, .
", .
.' L""'-i1'\."'" ~';>,'.:,'~:',",. . ,-,1 '. '" .: i ',; ".,\1.,'",~",4i."jtt,'f.J;i'
DEVELOPMENT CODE ADJUSTMENT BOARD
..' ,'I".'14"'t.t.."J1"". ~ ,"'''' .1,. " J hUH Ch i ,'", "', c'.,''! "j" {'1'" .
t\~/q:.t:~~r~tJ~}~:::~,:~~~;f~;}\.:::~,.~?~:~+-.:~~~/ 0 n n. orner t a rman ~"..r;~,': 0+: ~'.> ':::.~f:~lf::~~l~!;~~:"~i;.
~~" ~~:;'~'::j'":";}t~;;r,' ,~..~..~.:-:.-JI'''';!~.;' t..~,:,....} ,: Kemper Merriam .' r4:"~' ."~0~~ .,......~~..-;...~ ~.~1.1,..J ',"' :'i
j,.....) 'P.".l>.....~~~..~~..'. ....~.I'... .' '.I~-"I:~ .1.i...~\V.\....,....~.4':'~ +"",,-r, >
..,~1.~.J~'6:~.\;~~;.1)i"~~t~~\..'..~:.~.,' .(~~~ A lex P 1 i sko i, <~ ..:..tI~/. .:::i~t;I~~1J~,~}~:~i~t ~'~~l~f~\
f.~~!fM~i1.~4g~#~1#~:"i~~~'~{:~;: Ell11Ia C. Wh i tney (.;' ,/~:~~~~T.:~W~'~~~~ J ,~~. N~;
!>"~....~I,;1'-...: ~...>.,~"-i,.t.r..,}: ":-'"~ . ">".:I~.J~",~~,,~~"/~h,,,'~~:;";J.~J I\;t a.~:-:
'.f? ~:;~~lf i't;~'~?~''''''i ~:" 'I'<;~~~!.~~.;,\: << >'~~1'ls "! ",:-"'1;~",' ~;~r.\,:t.. ,tril~~;;'" ~;1 +.:l~~
if:rt !I.~"!. "?fooj.b":.'.J~'~~': !:t.n~'; f~~'~::;': ;~). i-~.I' Members absent: ":'I~:~<~~/,i,~;r':~d' :~~1""~ t':b'!~~':":~~ ~~..;( :'ifl\I>c.
~':'';~:;;1;Tht;:;J~:~f.::/';; ;~;,:~,j;;'h\;~;;~ : :;'~~ :yr~A1~i(,::t~~,V f;~~V?,..!jf,)\.1~', '1
~. . .t~i1~,,;.1t""I~ t~J~-: \,.:~,-:-~.1~~;": ...l~.;/;~ ~,;:. "j ..~ i:.~".j; 4 /l.;:"~~: ".:I."";~"lJ ;1.~.'~~.
,{~....:..t),~,'':(r~\''''~.'';~i,'~':''li,' ~~-I,:~, Thomas J. Graham (excused) ".i::"'-;;J.,,,.-I, .r.l',{I"lIS'
'i. ~'~i~'1~ttoJl';" .;::,:\.(.~.,,'r"<" ~ ~ ....t'..1,......~ Jo ,; "'i7'!~joo",.;';,{.:'"".;~~. -. f'"':'t'$fo,;'"
:..". '''1t-..J<''/;1?'-"';J ~N'""~~:,,,...I-: "..'If-~"~' ...:~.., i'~~~~"l-.;~LJ"-.,,:,,,Io... ~~(.
)..1;. '~~.. J"-;'F~~~.{~r(~~t~~,(\t:]~~:~ ,~~~. 1 ~'~';'::...(..~~.;jr...;:).:t/~H .'~\{
~. i' ~'\"Vft:i->:,~~~t:.. ,;',i;.i, A 1 so present: ~~if.\'j;;,~~',~~,:~~:\'.{k ;' ~r. .
',' . OJ' '1_1"'(Q " ",., - 'eLf,., v'\ 'x'''''( "',"
:':\ ~::'-"t,\~/'o''to~~:;~ '-"~"';';" '.j t ':r-;l';f'~)tt:)..;r""",,,~,~~,,,t-. r"~
t': ~~~: {2':~ri:~:~ :,.~ h f d 1 . ;I~~"'~' ~i:r. '>~?~~""(Y,..'~J~~1~'\t; "~~rL
~ :fJ~~:i!l~h"~ ,;1" Scott S u or I P annlng Manager ,",. -:',k~I"T'}/"~~~ .,M'" !~r~
l't ~~~'.ll~'~,,;.r'.r~.~~ Sandy G1atthorn P1anni g Official "".........,~..:,..j.;iI~...1'~ .'t.~'."i.:11:-j...... "-r' ..
~ ~g.'i(i,;V:~~!J,l , n "'r"~,~f..r...f:;ro1~r~~~: 'Jt':!~\~' t
C:i '~"'I':,"i>',," Mi les A Lance Ass1stant C1ty Attorney 0, ::, - 'J.,>.,i;JI,i;,~.,t"?-),:,(~v.S'l
(' ..., "','1f',{i" . ,. . ,:';'t,'.t:,;;!";',>~,'~l":I'~~ "'~l~.!, 1.
l." ;'f.~Yi'1< Susan Stephenson I Deputy City Clerk 1,:~;,,~~:,t'),~tJ::~t~l1f!~:~i;'
~ . ~s.~~,t-b'.' I'~ ~/ :"~:I;~<:t~} ~:;~~Jv~.:i :~~~~/:Vi~
:'l,~, Th ti 11 d t d b th Ch' t 1 00 . th ..;~>-'l.~i'....j..\~:.'~.r.t~~~"\!".Ja.
~':: e mee ng was ca e 0 or er y e a1rman a : p.m. 1n e \,'~"'::i(::',~ti)"''';'\/fl.>t~',,/
.\~;: COlTll1i ss ion Chambers in City Hall. He out lined the procedures and advi sed that ,:~ ('.:;,~;'t~",.~Wl'1~~'tl{<!'~'
'f.~~" anyone adversely affected by any decision of the Development Code Ad,'ustment ~;;~'^,?i~tl{'0';,~!iB:;~\{nf~~
,.l3p;' Board may appeal the dechion to an Appeal Hearing Officer within two (2 weeks. ,., .'r;;.,'iC",~"'X~.~~;~\'!~1h
~~;.'k lli;:~-:;. ~~~J~;/i~.~~ii~~~:J,~.ti(k;:
. i; ~ He noted that Florida law requires any applicant appealing a decision of this ~,';~\:~',:":':;J(,t!~~<::~'~';~:'"
~ Board to have a record of the proceedings to support the appeal. r:>...J:!,,;':~. "'~'c"rt,y.'~, '
r:; :-{ ';.';.~!~~,V~'.;,;,'i('},~")~}t!~
<"~,""J' r)l~" ...~~ 31.' ~. t. t~,!~..,t"N:1
....-... ....i':. ~~'IU":'~""'\",' 1...\:ld~",;.~;;;j'~"';<': ~:. ~~'k
~ f: ~~ ':~:;~:~ ~'< :.~:t .~~:1'J?.,i;~.,:....~t~r ~;~:tk
"~P"'. ~,4'~ -:\5"'-\:..p...?f......T~;1J:?",~~l(J ....,,~'n.
~"--=-,~.:~ ~"'/. ."I....~~...r.~ ~l.r....,: i.J."~~.-i;~'.;"81 n
,:,::'~ ...\:L:~:-(.~~. .~.I;..!,i;il't,f;..1iJ1..:~.d'
. . ;.{:~ /~~;.L.:;{~~~~~~?l~~\~'/{. ~~~i~~!:.f:l'
: !\....'~L~.,!;,rr...: ~l...\~:):A l~;L.w~~?,'f:.<~~
, ,';;'.1ri:~ '~t;' " ~\~"tt ,tf:t~.i~~8{l~+.~ t~~l~~
.'~ .... '~".J4"" -.;.. . .~_. "
~."'f.,..~:rt ...~ ",':I"j.' "'-4' J\ I"\.":':~~'"
I ,';'";:t' ";.1[': .l~":':l.' :;:1...-.:(1, :..h..j\-t-y"'~J/.f...
I 1-"- ~j: r' ,; ~.~., ,"., -~r.~ ~ .....~.f..~,~:(~~.
~. ~> ,;~. I~; 'J:lo,t~~J'.t t .(r(~~~/:7r.~~;.~l-~~
',:' ';,r..~r5~.~.".\~~,,:~t.~_~~~~ 1fi;~."'1';~;:,jt\',
~".;" ~ J:>~ " ~.~. ~'+-::'.~ .,.t~ f'I': ~""t:\.;h";4(~:~~\)~
~~.:. ;:~~J:'t.~.,':o,' \t'~ipH~ ',I~..~..;.-rlJ.i-~~~
,~t;:':~H~~:?~Q~ ~k~?~f~*-h~;~~~..
\J~,i''' :f'"j ~ ",:--;f h.",~,..l,~l/.~~"t?,..t'.i~~..~~
~";~:.' r~~J,\~~~v~~~{t~3~~f~;:.~l>> ' .
'. ,"~~..\..' :.~""'."'..~~.i:-.jl'" / ?~N~i,.;L:11
: '; ..:~~ :~.; :'./,~~ 1~~:~~~..ii/\\.:1.:i~:;il~
. i '-.'. > ".~!~~,(~: :!tJ ......d}fft;~~.\...,.r;/f
~:: ~;~.:;.:f(~~~';!i~~~~f0}fj~7f;. '.~.~ .
.,~F . ~:.;"~'~~.., "-:(~.';'\,....:.L~~;<f~rL,~
:~ ""'~. (;J.(,N..-';."'-!"':"'.(.4~~~t~"I:".""
~"--.~ cjx~',,'~~"'~ ~J11-:'-~~11~...1-"~4.'i.)
I . .. :. .' ~..' 'toot }J-'-1 .';.~ ~'{(.'':-.1'1~:..
~.\, .1:",,,,., I. ~.\t"'I"4'" r,. ,'IT
;~:~;z;H1~>:~~~~1~~siK~f ~
'~'f'{. .;:i"i:{ll'-;'~~~. L~~~',r.;.i'" '"1:"
;.-5:.7 ~~"~-:,:; ~~~,.~ ~~ ~~~~1:~r~~~~~ 4~'~;J' ~)~.. ~l~ ~
~}'- u I "r{ .~~...'r~r",; f,~.,~':t.':.'~ ....'fJ"'~ro\.~..:1...J
":':~~~L v....:' '<~~I:(l:.'.~~.';':i ;S~~~fr~"r~,~f"~
" ..,::', ,,,\,'.f ~J.:L'";.:".n.t."{,I!ll:-:;t{ -=--.tl~ J....~~f1r
:,t<I~i~\1~Ji'l
'_~':,:::.Y 'i'~::G 'f,~'~:~~1A'?'~!ff
'. ~'t~: ,:~~} , ",~t<:! i,~~~~\i:*~!~~
'.. r
. ,,' '. .": .~,'
".;..
o
January 10.
1991
Members present:
In order to provide continuity, the items will be listed in agenda order
although not necessarily discussed in that order.
1.
Public Hearings
Item A - (Continued from 09/27/90 and 10/11/90)
Kazimiera Budzinski (Britt1s Restaurant) V 90-123
Stanislaw and
The applicant requested this item be continued for a period not to exceed
ninety days.
George
continuance.
Greer,
attorney
for
the
app 11 cant,
requested
a
sixty
day
The Planning Manager explained that the conditional use request was denied
and the applicant cannot proceed with the variance request until the conditional
use has been approved. The Hearing Officer appeal of the conditional use denial
was heard on January 9, 1991. They are requesting continuation of the variance
request until they receive the Hearing Officer's decision.
Mr. Merriam moved to continue the request for sixty days.
duly seconded and carried unanimously. Request Qranted.
The motion was
o
OCAB
1
01/10/91
"
." . " J ~ '
. ~'::".....".,
}}. "L'~'
. '...(; ~ .,'
'.
"
,
.
,.."~t~~12~~rT~"'!.,I~r;:j~~~iii1!
.' ,~.~' .' ': 'f, ~.T, ". ,"a:', :;1,~,.1 !~~,!~'A'~l~~fll'
, , ' '.'~." :">:'::'5!J:(~f!i~~t.~
~~\o:~~~:.~: ::~~~'::~::'1 .'~:'~~"~." l..: .
~'.,~ ,"L'~, .....}.: i+ '.\~:~~'::'. ~
\~$)("Hr-o\~~.~,.. ..... Id~u,'.":L~,.t,...I!,. "-.. .",,'r... ,J.- u. ,\
~~.rwJ..:110-F.r~:i;6~....I....'~'~ .' .,...:.......+ ~ \. (/'.,.,\ ~>!, ."t.
u .':"\,~"..rl"'\" ......H.. ~ f . ...~\ '
~ " .,~, . :' . " . ','\" ' , .. . , , .
111 (...... ~~r";.~~.;.t.h' '. .-ro;,.. '." . .
, .
",'" ..""",[I0 '" (,.
,~~'. '">i';'~".\;,;,f:~.;;,:,.;>",>:::,:,.~:.,,;~,,{,~,,':'" .Ie" ' ,.'t., ',:'-'.,j.: '.:.":.~:'
,<," .,... ..,,';;',.,.: ".:
" ,- ,,;',,~::}:' ,\,:::;",:;.,,; ::,' ......
.'r,L' l, " 1 ~/,' ", '" . , ,"1. .
~ ~ \:" . f
~ 'I " t '
.... -I.:. 'f'
: ~ ,'I /. ~', " ~
<~', -,,' ~ "'t~.,!, '~.'.'
'. . "
1'\', j
!J.,,. t
l, .....
,"
,
, ,
:\".
", .\-\ '. -.',
~', ' ..
" :1;',
:' ~ ~ I ~ i'J . ~. .
, "
,',
,.,.,
~ ....
. ::'. :..,
, ,1
, '.
....
." , J ~
c ,:
.....'\..
'. I.;
"~~ :
"
, '. ~
;.... ' :.'"
:r
, ;J " .,". .
'I;,
I".
:'
,\
"
,.'
"
I,
"
..
, ,
, .
, ~. ~
" ,
" ,."
, ,
0,
.. '1'
>',
,I:. .
,,'
';: ':',: ::,:
, r ....'.i.
"
. , ~ '
oj
'./ r'
".
"
.,i'
',j,
"
o
Item B (continued from 11/08/90) City of Clearwater for
variances of 1) 3 ft to permit a 23 ft high pole Sign and 2) 127 sq
ft to permit a surface area of 151 sq ft at Jack Russell Stadium,
801 Phillies Dr, New Country Club Addn, Blk A, Lot 12 and Part of
Blk D, zoned OS/R (open space/recreation). V 90-155
This item was withdrawn by the applicant.
1. City of Clearwater for variances of 1) 4 ft 1.5 inches to permit
height of 29 ft 1.5 inches as measured to midpoint of a sloped roof
and 2) 1 ft 4 inches to permit ridge height 5 ft 4 inches above
midpoint of sloped roof at 951 Gulf Blvd., Sec 17-29-15, M&B 34.01,
zoned OS/R (open space/recreation). V 91-01
The Planning Official explained the request. The variances are needed to
construct the Clearwater Saillng Center. The structure will be used to store
boats and provide meeting rooms. The Sailing Center will benefit the community
and will not have an adverse impact on the area.
Patty Stout, representing the applicant,
bonus when a greater side setback is provided.
currentl~ in place.
stated the code allows a height
The ramps for boat launching are
o
Ream Wilson, Director of Parks and Recreation, stated this will be a City-
operated facility. No sailboats longer than 20 feet will be permitted and all
watercraft are non-motorized. The site has been in use as a sailing center for
one and a half years and they wish to add a building.
Based upon the information furnished by the applicant, Mr. Plisko moved
to grant the variances as requested because the appllcant has substantially met
all of the standards for approval as listed in Section 137.012(d) of the Land
Development Code, more specifically, because the variances arise from a
condition which is unique to the property and was not caused by the applicant
and they are the minimum necessary to overcome the hardship created by the flood
zone and its requirements subject to the conditions that (1) the site plan shall
be modified as now proposed on this application with a minimum 30-foot side yard
on the south side of the proposed building and (2) the building permit shall be
obtained within six months of this date. The motion was duly seconded and
carried unanimously. Request Qranted.
2. Charles E. Knell, as Trustee for variances of 1) 7 ft 11 inches
to permit height of 32 ft 11 inches as measured to midpoint of a
sloped roof, 2) 1 ft 11 inches to permit ridge height 5 ft 11 inches
above midpoint of sloped roof and 3) 33 ft 4 inches to permit house
33 ft 4 inches beyond Coastal Construction Control Line at 1170
Mandalay Point Rd., Mandalay Point Sub, Lots 18, IBA, 19 and 19A,
zoned RS~4 (single-family residential) and OS/R (open
space/recreation). V 91-02
0.,'
- '
The Planning Manager explained the variance requests in detail.
eXisting structure, which is non-conforming, will be demolished.
The
There are
DeAB
2
01/10/91
.~ , ' ~ .
I.I
",
, '
"
.~', t
'.\
. '.'.;
"I;
( ",'
: , :. ,'.'). l' , . , .~": :
" .
" ~.
",
'. J.<,
., v,.'.
",
,[ ''>'
-,
.j':
: ' ~
',:.::: ::.~ ' '
"\
l,
'(~:-:i '
"T/'
.....
,1',
.1,/
,~ ."
.'
, ..
"
'W
,".:)(: '/,
:,
;s2\'~,~f't~~~:C;i;:::':' ., ; .,' ' .
"',_ ,-. {';-r~'\lv.\-~f"-O~ _,". ~ ~".l~~.'~~""""fl'" J, ;. I
;. ,!, "~it~~;~""'.~""""f'"~:'h' "1-.'- ..,\.. 1tl";,~ J.I'\'~.'''' \::,...\ 'J t+.~ I,' !~,h~' "d}j I'.
~:ltt1~1~f:1~~~~.;t{~;:~~j;d:l:::,/,:,,?j;;::i';~;,;:,:0:':":'.'" ".,.;,.".'.:. ,'.',. ,\ : '
J~~''': .......v\t~t'....t.~'~.i......,l 1t'1\t""',,"p..;i ~'~4"", "Ii . > __', y +~~, '.""/' '>; "'
'~'\'~bJ;,l..",~(~...J~:~.""r<...~;:"':I..!Al..'~J~"':.:'~.<.~"t...~"/."';:~']f.' !"lr:'''' ~ ',,~\. '~"" ~~~. r''"t,~,.':
~ ~...~~,l~~:<~t,fl;:...~~':'~rl\$""~~l.....li~ .",,",~, 1~"'1 ',1 ~~,1."'.""'1~' ," ''-, '.
. .I'!;#".~~\.t..:\.'\.t!,,-.:::'I~l'''' ):JI>,'.~-t.k_t1~/..... .j"':>'~ ~';"I'~;J.~:.,.~ I~'~l'. ..'.~..." 'i' '., ,
~ ;J~~"~)~~~~\1-i/!:...'.(':i~?~'~j'; J"t~~..:-;;'1..J.~~ .,~>,~:~.:'~j :~}'-'I ,.. :.....~: ,',' ~. ~ '. /',:.. ~ ~'~ -.',,' " .1
, ';'~':!~'V~\f;.~r:!;t~-"'io\:~"_1.~~~...)J~r.~~, .~f...:~~tJ.\.,I~~ :.",1 . t..1.:: .',~.:~,;;.ri' . 1, ..,': I!': ,.' ,<: .;'\
. "'''''./~'' _t~j/" )1' . r....~. . ~.;t. ..':. ".... I'~ ~; . ~,+" ~. . . ., + '.--', d ~ .',J.. ..01("
.~ ,.f"i:: ;;' ff:j~~ :~. \~';\:~ \ :~/~l~e;.~r .tf ..~r, .. > > ..(~:, ~:~~.. ....: '. t,.. ~~. '.~ '.~. "" ,. ~ I."
~ . 1"'( "'.. ~' ,to " ~' .{ ,,,II' f ,.,: ,,", .. , '~I . .... I ,.,' ~~. '. ~. ..-. .
~'~..'i""i"""'~~ ~t':'~o\l,;"}.Jl~j.-,..:;:..}~,...t' .r;:.:".I)""....~ ,,'. ,.r~ Ii,: ./.
· :;!t~?;~~\~~~~~~~~:r~,;,:"~\,~(+.}I.;:(:~,',... '., ,"..'
. J " . 1t.! .. ',/,. ~:'t ,,", ", m-;" J,.. . " ,,'... >
;c'/.i':;,\'....
. ,,~
','
>..~' , .
.... ,...~\~t}" ':l~"', . i1i. . .J.... . . ,< .J .
i;~i},1~~%g;i~I;);';\1~'~; ;:,!
t"ll).p~i'"'.tJ.::?'.a../.,.\.)~':.., :~', ,',J l._)
1~*~~i;i~i~~t}J,~~:~ti!;;;
,~,~.til~ )~..~.~;=~lJ--;(.~~t~.I.~ (~, r~.I' :\~: ..
'I. !< 1"~ .'t.o";J~ r- ....::(h)".~.:,,~' .... ,.~t.. i~, t"
t " ;,"\?l:i.'~.{+.. ~..-:'rt{,~:...<r;....:~~ :r:;f"''''~i.'''~: J\- ';
f.'~.y.;~~~'I-"-t-~.."~~l:.~~;.~{.~~.~~i"~;'..~'~/~r l'" J'" ',' _
_ t"...."-rit~J.\~<li'j-r"?l.V ~...~\{'t.~.'";;'l"..~ ~ ~'7 ,.
~~~i!~Lay;.;t~j;:~;II. :~<lF ;.~~. rJ!:}t't~".,::~ .5.~ 4;
)j" :1{f ~:~ ;),~'~<;l /' ,~~~. ,. ..~. T~ .:
r ~f:..J"" "'~ '.If 1',(.. ,...,~" .. (: .,(....~.....
~ ~?:: ~J:!l~ ' ~~~~i;:1 ~~~"':'~.f :: ~.~. " -~rt. : '.
'..~1:.1 ~-e~}'f.. of; ;t~. :..f~j~ t....:....,', ,.' !......
\ "'!,;;..."'"',,.~.,k," ,~.,ii k,'<"';'~:' '.'~ . ':"
J1'L,J',~",- ''''.......'\'''.--t''~:I-...."...... f~- .~.. "'''l
;.'00... "'''. .~~:./J;,';.:J~~';,,;\: ~..(/,..>.....r.~.~~i::~~i.';.-:'t
d:.lJi.~ ,i?l!.Y l"~'~'.'~~ i2:, '.; \.: ,:::/,T : ,: .~:;~
f"r.' .1.,;;~J,:<'y;f..-.' , !'.~<.:' '. \.:,. ,',. I
~I~;' ~..t. "[,}!~::t~:.:r ~i_'.1~~:r.~~: ~,i.'0,; .~:;.;:. :::;:. .:~':'
,,'v "~.'oJ..l;;'..r.{t~';>.~',,i~~'^ ,';"
!.,t~.' t-~.r~:~.\..:',~ . ,t.'.:, \ ~:!..
~. J. .1":;1l.,.-l'" . '\-) ~\,.j,\- r ... .,..
~,,~ '.;f!po(;J1~f\,~, ;~ :~:~ ~\;;~~~.'.- ,?
~ ~~i~'tt:~J~J~~ ;.,;~1::r~I~..~....
~'i.~~:\i""";"~~ ..~"...l~~.l,.).
'~ J"'":ii'.t.,+C~ rI\,'):!.....~..\I...r
t\ .;~~~~cl~i~~..ri~ f"~~:";):.{
. . ....~~~~r1\;;1-i:~i'~S::~~
.~ ~~;;..."'tei'''~i.~'~ _: .'"; ~~
.1!f!"~!-";,\~"'~r'-,: /;)
~1-;:::~i/:f~'f: ~ .~~
li~,t+l~~~':
'1~~}~;i'
~ ~~ ~~;J..J~{"'1.fi
,M~~~~\;;;I;:;"r.
:r:~~1~1~~o,:-"':
.~~iQ~.t~l'~~'
~" ,~"",
~t~I{'
:~fli' ~'(
3~~~
.';:~~:':"'~
~~.~~~~{ ~
.;,.........
~1~i..;:
~;'H
. f{'J~;:
(j'l;l~:;j
.'i'''l~l)~'"r~
iJp,'),
'~1~~
;....-:.
i~Jt:
.:.r:~'
.,~~~i
":1"",,"
"it:
.:~~
,';
~~~.
'::r;.1
r;AiB..
,?~~,-
.'J'..i-1.L
~#~~
~~~.
. l:
1'/.....1;., .::
, '
.'~ . t ~ ':1&, l . .:\ I~"
, "
~. .
l..~ I' ~ , . 1 . ~.,.'
, . .,....' \-< ~ 1
J :': w
.r?~., ....
" ;\1':'.
:. :' .
I... ~. >
.. ....
, . . ';. 1 : ~ ,.. ~. '.', ~ >'! ~
(,'
: . ~ .
.,
.., t <-':.: ,....
l.. .
. ",' T} . .'~ : ,~> .
'. ~ I ' ,~ ','
'. Jo',.: . ...._ ; ','N '
~ .. , '
~ .
, :~.' . '~::')'::" ,.,,;.
,. ,\0
" '.
,',
'. ,
" ,
. " .
'., ',: ..
'..'
) "",
" I
, /'..:
.'>
. ~ " ;,
" '
I.~,;. , .
.:;";,
'. ",.
.!:
:.,'.1-
'.'
, '. .
, '
., ....
.. d'i'
"
'. ,
"
, ,
.\' '.
. ~ '. . ~;
.'.....,
o
several existing tall structures in the area which will minimize the impact of
the height of the proposed structure. It will be necessary to obtain approval
from the Florida Department of Natural Resources. The request appears to meet
code requirements for granting variances.
Harry Cline, attorney representing the applicant, stated they wish to
rebuild on the same basic existing footprint. They will meet all setbacks with
the exception of the Coastal Construction Control line. He feels the structure
will nave no adverse impact on the surrounding area. He requested one year to
obtain a building permit due to the need for Department of Natural Resources
approva 1.
Peter Marich, architect, stated the existing house is very large as will
be the proposed hoyse.
Discussion ensued as to whether the house could be moved closer to the
street to decrease the intrusion of the Coastal Construction Control line. It
was felt that the Department of Natural Resources would address the intrusion
of the Coastal Construction Control Line and make the final decision.
o
Based upon the information furnished by the applicant, Mr. Plisko moved
to grant the variances as requested because the appllcant has substantially met
all of the standards for approval as listed in Section 137.012(d) of the Land
Development Code, more specifically, because the variances arise from a
condition which is unique to the property and was not caused by the applicant:
the particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical conditions of the
property involved and the strict application of the provisions of this
development code would result in an unnecessary hardship upon the applicant and
the variances are the minimum necessary to overcome the hardship created by the
lot size and the Coastal Construction Control line in relatlon to the lot,
subject to the conditions that (1) all required florida Department of Natural
Resources permits be obtained and (2) a building permit be obtained uithin
twelve (12) months of this date. The motion was duly seconded and carried
unanimously.
3. Julie F. Tiernan (Seafood and Sunsets at Julie's) for a variance
of five parking spaces to allow expansion of existing restaurant
with zero additional parking spaces provided at 351 S. Gu lfview
Blvd., Lloyd-White-Skinner Sub, Lot 70, zoned CR-28 (resort
commercial). V 91-03
detail and stated that
the
The Planning Manager explained the request and in
the permitting problems encountered previously have been resolved with
appllcant paying triple permit fees for after-the-fact permits. There is still
a case pending before the Code Enforcement Board regarding the outdoor seating.
Should the Board determine the variances are warranted, several conditions are
recommended. He pointed out that the Planning & Zoning Board had a problem with
requiring a Ilwallll for a barrier to separate the outdoor seating from the
sidewalk and driveway and they suggested that a substantial fence would be
sufficient.
@
3
01/10/91
DCAB
'+ejT' .
, ,
'. -
. ".,.., '4"
. , " '..' :r -I:~~.""'~'t.,: 2'"
, .... > '. ~
" ,.:..1:.
,~l. ':. T I .~, . ~ . .;.':'
. ~ J,
"
:- ;
:-1'"
-'
"
. '"
" /.
" +'
'..'
/,\ ';".
. ..',
~ ~Il,....
.~ , . ~ ')~.!~:t~~
, , " j .' , '0 ,.';, , :.,'" ,::,y:~;,:<\~.'~~,:,}:
L:...V...:h..'~ t.<:'....~,j,>:~,.~'-~-.~J~~~~~ ri!, ,;(I....t..~~~,'~ii~5~.!;~',~'*~t1t~. ~
.. ~:: :./,:- .,' ~ :~, :::...} ,.'~.\~4.~. r~~..~~~~~i:~U~~ ~
,',',' ',... ,j.. ,r ,e ,"",,'e-");.........q,
..' . ~" -,' ~',' ... " j~~....i,.......f.';--;.~.;~-'!t'...{/~
> '.. ....... ~ '.., ~ ". .J "~ ~~. ,,' ",. ./;....~\.f::-..r.r'r~n.~~
.' " ~.. \0-. " :.:;.'.." ',':, ~: {:' ~~o ~,.;~.,:'f+~.....,...:..;~'~"i.(\.~.l~
. I . . .' ). . . f' 'j't' .t U. !~t. !,~ .~~..
." :,," ",': · < ,,; " ,;:, IT~;;iJi{
.~ '. " ,: . ~. ". .. ~''-,,; /J ,>~.~l'~. '1~~.1.,1
.' ,"', -' :, '~i' ",,:' '; " ,',' ~ ",' ':, ::.' "<. '::' '.,.,;t:~~<:?}D::::~{
:;,1'~'J,~1!;liJf~):;~~':':~O::,",;;,:' .,,' ,. ~':" ."
. ", '~~'f' .,. 'I ,'. ", ,".., .,.,
. , ...:~.
.'
."..,:"...;..,,',,..'.'.P,':.,,.,
,~~/iiiY; ::> :,:~", I, ,;,:,"', ,','
. .' . ~. .' " ,
,::,':,::~:,:""y,:"):,:, ',.. ,'0 ,";,:, .',""
~',::~,:,:: ,,;:;:': < ;,,:':;.'}, '
, ' '. :::.~,::3~:!/C(::,::,':','
"
,. '.'
t'. <' .
. .j/;',
.- j. 'to
l ~ L . . . .
!...../~ ,..,
"
......J..,
,(
'"
: ,.
"
...,: ..
";' \.t
~". (, "., .,' ~. .J:.
. ,:'~ .....; >1" ':., '." .
.. "... ',_ .....L ..'
,.~~:....:.~;.~..~~...,....: .... ;.~~.l .~....
'. '. ,l ~ .~.'~ : .' . '.
I:' I.
"
,',
.)'
~. .~: ...... .... +: . . .
. ,
1',. "
"
.' ,'. > ,
, ~..... .-' '
.,., ,,,"'"
, r. ~...
".
- ..'
. ,1
,'f '.
. T"
"
! ,
. ,.,
. , ~ :
.... "
'I'
~l-< ,
".f
,I
.) ,
,.'
, , ,
.,. ~. v./
, ' ,
. . 3;' ~
\ t"
..,4....... '
. .,' "
'.t.
~j .
"
",',
, .':.
/" ,.
'~'
~', . I J ,
, ,
, ,
. ':, ~<."'.. .'
,;
, I .. ~
" '.. . ~
. ~ . . ,"
< , . .~' ~ .' .~ . ~.> ~ t ~:.':; ~ . .
" .~. ,",' '.: :,,:.'~r:'.":,:' ~ ::\: ~ ::
.:,.~,:.,.,.:~; ,,'~"~\,'." :+~.~'i
" . ,:.>i
:":. :~.:::'J.,:: ;'; .'
"""" "'~'"..~-,..",..~"<
. .........~.-jl~W........"\'-~..'!>o\"
, " .) .' ~ l' . ~.. . ~.
;. ",: I '~'., t-... .~.;,..~"Il\;:r~'..:I~.:'I/~'",:
, .,'" ~ .~ '"' ,'. ~ ::. ;.-:...;.~d,._~.'!,..1
~+. t ,,'''; '., ~JI' -L:~ ~.~ I fI/}" i~.~~..~.'..,
. ...r' ~ f:~ ~.E+:. ;:~:9 I
~. , .
.1.....; ,
. ~ . : r .
'/
"
.om,,'
,,'
:;;i;,~"F'Xh 'f ',' ?
'.,j,ft~~r{'::;},;\:;5;:: ..' .
o
Discussion ensued regarding whether staff sanctioned the adding of
additional seating without the proper approvals and it was pointed out that this
is not the case. It was brought up that the Police Department had been adamant
against 2COP alcoholic beverage licenses on the Beach last year and questioned
whether their position on this matter had changed.
George Greer, attorney representing the applicant, stated the outdoor
seating has been there for three years. The City Attorney and he have not been
in agreement as to whether or not the seating is legal. The Planning & Zoning
Board approved the outdoor seating unanimously. If the variance is approved,
they must go before the Commission for distance variance approval. He pointed
out that if they did not sell alcoholic beverages or had an SRX license
designation they would only need 9 parking spaces. In a CR-28 zoning district
the Code requires a minimum percentage of food sales which in effect creates an
SRX license requirement even though the license held by the afPlicant is a 2COP.
Continuing operation of this establishment will not negative y impact the area.
Discussion ensued regarding the addition of the outdoor seating being for
financial gain and that there is a self-inflicted hardship.
In response to a question, Mr. Greer stated that seating has increased
from 51 seats to 80 seats.
The Planning Manager stated the code was changed in early 1989 to require
one parking space per 80 squar'e feet instead of one space per 200 square feet.
Mr. Greer pointed out that he was in agreement with the Planning & Zoning
Board1s concern regarding a concrete wall around the outdoor seating and stated
they would be willing to await the findings of the Beach Task Force before
placing this barrier if this is forthcoming within 90 days.
Discussion ensued regarding the large variances that were granted to this
applicant in the beginning and that there has been a 60% increase in size.
Based upon the information furnished by the applicant, Mr. Merriam moved
to grant the variance as requested because the applicant has substantially met
all of the standards for approval as listed in Section 137.012(d) of the Land
Development Code, more specifically, because the variance arises from a
condition in that the building and total parking situation are unique at this
location and there is adequate metered parking if needed, subject to the
conditions that (1) the requisite occupational license shall be obtained within
six months from the date of this public hearing, (2) the landscaped areas on the
north, east and south sides of the site shall be improved through the
installation of additional landscape material as well as an irrigation system
to ensure the survivability of any landscaping installed; the proposed landscape
plan shall be approved by the Planning and Development Director and the
Environmental Group Managerj all required landscaping and associated irrigation
shall be installed within three months of the date of this public hearing, (3)
a 30 inch fence or wall shall be installed as a barrier to separate the outdoor
seating area from the sidewalk and the driveway; this fence or wall shall be
installed within three months of the date of this public hearing, (4) the
. .' , ~
", ..\ .
.: J.'
. ".'..'
.' '0.
o
G
DCAB
4
01/10/91
.......,. .~..T~. ,T
" '
. . ., .
-:' I ~ : ~ I \., :.. . '.
, '. . ~ ,
. . "
,T.',
'.,
" '
"
.. .,' :
, ',' '. ~ '
,. ~' .
, : .
" '.. .,~ l ."
. ..-'.
."l'
....,.
;.,
, III
." I.
~ ,"' ~ -
.,".::.
, . ~. ~ ,
~'d>:,'" /;..
".,' ..
;. z~~ . . . :,
, "
.+ '>'.
" ,
~ ' . ,
"~ 1'.
... ~/ .
o.j .
~ ~ ~ ,
,',. . '" ,. " ." :." . ,'. .' ;,:,,/ :, '~':, ,,~'r.'l '/ 1"~
f "' r . ~ '. , .
,t ....:. "
, "', ' '~.
e.
. .',