Loading...
12/13/1990 ..1 '~ . ~ .', 'I 'T'" . ~ I.. . t ~.._~_ ~ '..., " ~ . "c~'i~~~"~":':'~' : .. .. . - .-......,....... ....c.. ..... ,..- I < ,~. ".' '. .' . ,'. I ._./,~...... ,,~,c_.L." ~ C' e ~ v.. . ~ "'"...~ STATE OF FLORIDA DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS MANUEL KASTRENAKES, ) d/b/a Pinel1as Rent-A-car, ) ) Appellant, ) ) vs. ) CASE NO. 90-5002 ) CITY OF CLEARWATER, ) ) Respondent. ) ) FINAL ORDER Pursuant to notice, a public hearing was held in the above-styled case on November 29, 1990, at Clearwater, Florida. APPEARANCES For Appellant: Esquire , Esquire Road' Louis Bakkalapulo, Thomas G. Hersem 400 Indian Rocks Suite C Belleair Bluffs, FL 34640 For Respondent: M. A. Galbraith, Jr., Esquire Post Office Box 4748 Clearwater, FL 34618 STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Whether the Planning commission deviated from essential requirements of law in denying Appellant's application for a special use permit to operate a car rental agency at 2576 Harn Boulevard, Clearwater, Florida. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT This is an appeal from the action of the City of Clearwater Planning Board in denying the request of Kastrenakes for a special use permit for outdoor retail sales, displays and/or storage to operate a rental car business on property owned by'Appel1ant at 2576 Harn Boulevard, Clearwater, Florida. ':\ ~ ~'". ;";{:'#W::~~~i:,:+c:~::. :'i., ,," :.1'1 .._~..... to. ~ ~ .t:,. 1/.. :,'..". , , .;. ~, . ~ '> " ..:: .' ~ ,:~. ' .:..&~.~II;<it;t-?~ '~I P/:;~ >0,.."1,; 1.11' t;~.., ~':;;~'"I, j..~~ ~~,! :,t~ 7 .{il;'.!;, c:': t~,.j:":r ": :\:1 ';'~.~.. ::'~ :'''.: ., ~':L ~~...: <,' J t.i~~;; ..:... ~'... ~> ~',.<~:.~ .:.:~ .' ~;:~~ ~>~, ~f~ :J~T\-~'T '" ~. ~ ~~ '.>'..\l c.{"'j.?.t-"-\~ 1-<::. J: c...i....~~~~.l~; f 1. ~n ~..:ii:c'1.:.,yL'~t.,} ..~t~ ~n....'t. _ ~ <. l" '~. ,.{ .JI/~~1.~f 't,J-:..;..... "'.. ~. .' LOt Is i :... ~ ~''''I. ~., .of 1-,,;' -"-,' ," ,. .l . ~., \, j , ~~l- "'.I~" "'#3~"~. ~~.r ~. ,',> t:.~l:t;l>t... ..\< tj.~.c\'~~ :\~(:;'f';.~\:tci.\~t~"~f:!f~~.W~.j.fl~t.~~~*.{~~'~~...~,~'': f:t!'~,~';'~:":':l-~-+- ~~'::: '<r.~~...: /;'::~~'-w<~'::'" "' i'~;~tJT~";~;';"'~~:'; ~ "" '"~h::1j..~~.~~...;:~,~T~~ ~\f~.f.L(l"~~~~ I ..... ~i ...j"'.... \~ ;'<I;..(:tj~ ~\~~,:~ \~~}!.fi; ~~ r'\~~:~(.'~~~r~'" ~\.....~..(..(\,..~;::,. ""t....!. ~ ~~t:~;:~..c/~'~;).r. "': <J'~'.:'::' ~'Cl T,~~. '., L-::'tU~ ': -..:.:..: .~ ,~', . :J," ~..(:~~I .~~!f .'"'~ ~.:..I'~<\ i~.C).h.''" ~.:~~~~~ . '>;:\"<i'":?":3~~~'!?~?2"~;:'.J.~:.1~{t;.L',\:~~:,.,::,: _ >:,;\'^<.~:'~;~:::-<::w~r\i~;:~;.:');;lY:~~;~~' .tl;:;~';':' (:';'t- :' ~ '\\.:';,~.~~':"".'~":'" :~'.';.. ' .. 'i., ," ...,~ ::).:.:,...t,:"'~:~V!i~~~'1(~(.]~:~ft~~,. ~~~?'{~~~f~~~~ii1~~~;;~f(;rJ'~)53;~~,.i~{l"1 :(;:~::f~~:~,,~~,t~i'~':';,'~;-\::~~';, ':'~:'~~"~:;)'.-,~':'~;':"';'.. ,..',:" " , :';,: f~'" ,::f,:,; ;/\:5,<", ;,r:'[" ::;i.i~~~~F' '~~J"'i~~~t,)., :t\- <':' ......."'^r.,.~r..........Ir~: ~d;.'" ,', :;r"'.'~L ui..1-IJfiI.,;.. ...~,. ,..-\. {'J" Jip~"':--i' >' ,O>".,....._-;..~~ .. ."",,:~' 11..... ...... , ..~"':.,.............:~ . ""1or4t:;:/.k:l.,. ~ 11~/ >i'~Yjl'~ .J...h..;:................ ~~ oa.~~"'f... ';..' I+- j~L ...... " ~ ~ ~i.~...~.....,~~~':r.rJ,. ~..tl";Lf~t.. h~~".1 ~,.t, . !''\. ~ ";.<r. t~'~;"" .......'l/!"~..~ ~L !. ....o5 ~ I> , ~ l' _ \......, ,)1,.. ~'. [. .' .,' _ ......"'":;..... \.. .. ...,-:--~ ;"\"'~' ~~~U~ ~...t..:.~.,,~J.:;..r, ~ .L...~,.J-\.. ," ,.,nr, , J:.'\" ./' i~.!_.~,...'.. '. "t f.- ...~ ~{... \-.r'i/"~'''\+' (.../ ,"I" .,. ,.'. "'I.~J) \ 3 ... ~t......l'" ~ 1'..!,'\~ "'U~i"ll :~:"...,. i';.~t: ~: " ,', ,',';;,;:;!' ,-' :" ':2; :.,,'.:: ;)(! ',-,"; . ,'" i ,.....:.." .: .. '-, ' ' '; " .',' " ,,' - '.,. >.... '~<J \t:~:~"?/..,:;\"~j:\i:,;,"\h\.S ^", ,,~f'~l~if~W#~W.0~1tp,::~?;B!X';:'~;q;?1y;+;::,;';'~\'i:f~'~<;:H:~,~~\:;:;r~?' ;:: "-';'-'~:,.,'" ~, . " ....'..'.f -: '.)~~~>:~. ~"...''''':'~'~........t.:; ~.......~t:~~J.~J~;- . .~"\4 . " ,', ',~" 0 .'1 t?"." '1" ,(J~~!,;.,.\:~1"'11 ,l),\"f';;~~ '~" ~F;;~":1 ~. -~ 'i. ..\~, .,...1" '.1-.,..__; -"',1:~ to ~,:,V.)..~r:~ ~.~.:lrt,['.r~'~:~ ~~~)1 . E:~' ,>>'fi '" " . 11< .!. ~ '.'r' ',"f' .~~. .:-{'I.....J4l...,";<;;-~J .fI':11 ...." 'It t, '. .,. ~ 'J I' . +'~, \ '..~: t ",~'l 1", ~~} ~" . ,~~},L ~1.'1'k"'..t l'~"'-~ '\~ " ~ ' ~.',.:,'. T} '~:~.~.~L' ..~...:~::,..:.. ~~I~'~~~~~8/$Ki~f;:'~~;' . ~' 'V'r'>''',''''I';>~..... " :l . vL~' ,.-.:- ~ . #-7 . ~ ~'.' ~ ',~ l;:~:' ...~:~.~:'.~" \',' ......~..i"'.~O<~:..~: ';.,' ~",.~~.t,(.l~~I:..t~~'r~~....t..-:.~l.j'",' f'r....I.th'bl'(\J~','!'l..+\H.". ~....,~ ....J'it...,~. . . .. .1" , . t, ~lcl J.'.brlY~ ~~:~'~~ iJ,.~ f.,..". ~l'~ . ., \ ~~ I"~ \""',... '.' L .'. "' ~: c;,"-'li' J" ,>Y'I':;,,;::, A.l,""", T;,lr, ~""r;,!,pl'~' .' ""~",:'''~ I'~~,~T'" ..; "'""".'~"i""';" "',.., "'..,.-..,..... 'i' ~ '. -,....... >- ~...: :~~~~~,.:: ':~~:~~> ",;.~:'1/A:\~;;y,!~'t?,~~~:~'jE;~ii/,':. ~:.<~-{~,i{:\~~? ,;~"'?i'~:';':\'.'::'::' l;;:i,::~, ~ .'../'.".. { " '::~', ::~:~. ....... ~. ;, . .' .". . ._. ::.:...-.)~ _~ .:: '~H_' ~.~...... L", "!"-. c c .. '. ~_ ., , " .~~.:: >'":--:- :.........:~ ;t....-:.,:.,:",,:: . I ~':'..: