11/23/1987
.~;: A~ l~~:i~~:' 0i~4+".:!,';.""~i'l::~,:'~~,~/~'i.:.~~';;:~~i .;,;~t<~J~T~,,\;::""r..~::~r~' ;'''', . ~~: ,\'/....~.~':...-::'r~..:: . ~-:; :.~~,. ";.: '~t'~ .~: , ~;~ . ; '.~' ~<~' ":/,"r~:; . _ : *'~;'": :, " ~..>i~>c::' >.,:~ <~ ;. ~ \~. 3-.:.~.~"'i .~rh-.~'",,~, f'r..,Lt-
!):-4ii-,,~~Jt, I~~ \1t~i ';t~.." ~~~. .I;~"\."(, ~',l . '" ..'i- '.'... r-iT":;\(r' 1\'./,0101 ,1..1::c,u i.',. -..,~ ';' '. J ~ 1EO'~;'" "j. ,~, . +,. ,~, < r'~;'T >.. ~ l.. ~.. " ~"""". 'l'. ~ .-['.,. ~ ~ ~ , : 'l~' i'l~ T T}..' i',~. ~. .". .,.~. ...\~ ~.~~,..J~ii~fl":.~J
.'.fl;';;ii?1!4i!:;~~:')~I~~;~:~V't'~5:f:\Y~~':':;~ijtt!;1:r~;:;'..t~;i:~ij'7~t:'nr; ~,i/;t:Tr}; 'T';~"~'0'~'s":~r(~J'~;};~1f'~~'~~~f&~L ~~.t
o:,::~}'.:/~,<:~?'~,:/L;, '~~,-<~~ ~~ I:~:~:.~:~,:~:..'i:':,,:.,
" :!.~... ".~ .~ '. "+.J
'J""....' I ~ ~
':;~, '!~;~:;~~;;:ij;~ ':
.')'" l:~o~
.: J.~:::.r<../,(~~"
~
v
1';'\
v
~
w
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The Division of Administrative Hearings has
jurisdiction over the parties and subject matter in this cause.
Section l20.65, Florida statutes, and Section 137.0l3, Clearwater
Land Development Code.
sections l36.024(a) and (b) of the Land Development
Code clearly provide that provisions of the Code dealing with the
sale of alcoholic beverages are lIintended to supplement and
function in tandem with the requirements contained in Chapter 72
of the Code of Ordinances,1I and also that conditional use
applicants who seek to sell alcoholic beverages m~~t comply with
Chapter 72.
Section 72.05(b)(4) of the Code of Ordinances
states:
No alcoholic beveraae establishment
shall be establishe within a five-
hundred-foot radius of a church,
school, residential area or other
alcoholic beverage establishment.
(Emphasis supplied.) .
Although this section is captioned IIguidelineslt, it must be
applied and read in tandem with the conditional use standards set
forth at Section l36.025 of the Land Development Code.
Specifically, Section 136.025(c)(l) authorizes
alcoholic beverage sales within a general commercial district if
the use is "sufficiently distant from churches, schools,
hospitals, residences and like uses so as to not adversely affect
the use, enjoyment or value of such properties."
Section 136.025
itself does not define the term t1sufficiently distanttl but this
must be read in pari materia with Section 72.05, as required by
Section l36.024. Thus, it is clear that a conditional use permit
3
~
. ~: :..::.....;.~:.'.,X.;~'t}~':~};t@P,!1~l~~
, . , . .~ I 1'.IJ~J ; F.,,'~\.'f:
. 'C' ,~~?n:~~\~'.;. ~~~"'..
. ~ f't' '.,.' ". .. .... '0<.' ":, ~''''.-.
":;.
'It,
, :.' ;'-, ..,.;; :!: ~~~ ~'~1",:'.;::~:~~}/:~;,::,~Ii~~1; .~
" . , .' .,..,." '\" :,\, ,\., ,/"',1 ,
~ T4. -]:. I : + I~ I ;j~'/~::if~:1 ::.>.:~~
. . " .' ~.' , -, 't;~~~..~:tt{J:'
. f "-~-'Io't;-'t..4 ~ ~
..... ,.1
~
~
,
J
-F, l,.. ~"~""qu ",- ~~. ~ ......
" ~, .....+ ,. . < '-; '> ,:. .
~'.~ ,~'.:',:i:~<"\':.~.,~~:i~~.~~.r;~~y~~: ':"c.: : --~~ -_... c' -~ ~I :. : .._..~...
d" .'t'T
"
: ,":':,:: "\\,;;);!s~:iif:f~~~~\
., .' 1'-'.;" , ~:;.. J
'~.~.'~ ',,;:-'>.i:~~~~;~~}>i~:~
II... ".
~ " }~l'.t. .....~Lq./..-...~~~.:l" l~~'"It~\'I,J..\~ :'f.::r~+~ir',.?h"'!.ir:.~,~~:~' > . 'no . . ~.
i- ~'~J.r' "t' ...,t';J~Ji. t.,,' t l...~" '1i;:;.~,:J(.rL... V;.,.V:h-,,'~.;~JI;~P-h: .. ~'.r'\\'1'
~v d\"4~~~~(~~~--4:~~.~l~:'5tit-r I.
t';r~~fi:':::r{ .w,~~"'iill.".',, i.N.fit,... \'''~~,~:f*';''P' :""'!'}~f -".'$ .
"~~'~',i',,:~'l\~ f:~~l-~::"". ,.d+ t....,"'t:~~ ,....~~'\~~ t, 1"~1'':~%.. ~(':\~~ i",.,;,.':'.-1:. .
" ,1. -....~ J. """ .~tp~~i-'l.;ti\\" .1'i1!.;f of ,.,.:"\<-.;~' ..r .'J:'~ h.... "~i..:.~'.h'" ~"~'ifJ.lco:;,,,t~
~.....l' \ ~ :'<~~,;J;~ ..1,~' . :t '>'" "~~ ";'~;",!:~ f\:-:' ~ ,~.,.' r~.' ~ . ~ ~ f' \' :.'~ ': ~ '\ i:," ~ ;\ :T,~:>" :~J~~,,~l~ ~::) .t-~,J~ ~~. '~..';,