03/11/1987
.. .
I ".. _.......,_..,'. ~ .~. ..... ' ...,...~_
r~ + . ~ 1. C _T..... .,~ .h.... . <1-. _...... r j.,--<..--~ ~
.~ . \
. ~._" .
.>"'../<:+!:~,~L:'~!: .~ ~ c P 'L'"
'<~,"-ci" '-":~;*~g~,;;
.,',
,~~ ",' ;;'.' i .);~T.r, . .~".C."""~.'":._; " .~~ ~ L' .~ ~.'~ .1.:. ,,\J :.....:..: "i." I' .... ':--. . ,.~+" " ~
:-~~\I~" .~,~~J-dr-::("".}'t:~ ;:,r+~~.t.'~~ (~~~T'L'tt.. ~,7~.c:,~ );. t.~.:.~)~ ..&.~~"?;..f c~.~ -..>....~ \t(,;,,-~: ~~"'<'tfl,~Tf'.~~;i ~~\1<~.~, Jdft.;rt-:;~.~\~$"f;"!lt,.~,~~::~.:\.[.~~~{..l".,+~l
'~~ !ri ! ~~~. :it~~~1!4t}.;.U'~sr~~~~~. ,T~?~h':'~)~~,~~';~i . cJ ~~1~;~~::~:;:..~t.;2~.::~~~:~~~Z~,..t~ ~~~':~j;~.r.~~~'{.-:;;rii;~ t'.:'~~;~iiJ~J
a;"'-l"Jt.\~,~(< -,. I 'c .,t.~;, -;:..~:h.i-llS-;..t;,t.~..~ 1.~l'h"''''''''''''J;;r.w:..~ry:.t.~.......'o;1,}'' "', ~ .L.i,.~'!1;\T ,~"'.~"" ",. ,,,~,""'y.',,. 0; I ~.",' .:..... ~/'~;~.. ~ ~or:-~~.r-r~..:;~(.~q./;,lr-1j--M'~
'c :{:~; .~ "~~::'~/' ,,~ ,:~: ;j":~~:::': (:~.~}ji'[:~~y{t?; {r~~~~~~~~r?~':s:;~~y::;~~~~t~?:,"i:~~t"? ;~(?~~;~f~;~;:i;5,i.i' ;~'~',';~j,,~<,O >,~~,.: ;;\~ .~~ YI:'~:,~;':~~++~}f:~1'::~~Zf~~~;r~~6~qf: :}}"\~'~f~.
; ~." ~., :, :<;v_;~. :':;;~~_L: ~ :~"~~~~~.~;':;Y~S~:;~~~~:~i~:iL'~li::j/t~~][~i' ~1lii:,'
+. I I, ~ ,+, , . .....;. . ., I : (td"~' (j...,..... \;."'}\t ~~r,,~. \\..~~.
, ,,".:.. ;.'..:' "....::,.':,.., "::;';'~';";'~'~";:\~i.,~~~~~~r:~
..' '.
6. The property for' which conditional use approval is
@
'.~J'
requested in this case is within a five-hundred foot radius of a
residential area, Hillcrest Villas Apartments.
7. No adverse reports or comments were received from
'0
the City's traffic or police departments.
8. Petitioner's application, if approved, would not
change the parking 'or traffic patterns in.the existing shopping
center, Hillcrest Center, nor would it in any way change the set-
backs, open spaces or hours of operation in the shopping center.
It would, however, increase traffic to the shopping center and
thereby could reasonably be expected to result in an increase in
debris and litter, headlight glare, and noise associated with
deliveries to the store as well as customers arriving at, and
leaving, the premises.
9. On December 16, 1986, the Planning and Zoning Board
denied Petitioner's application, and a timely appeal was taken.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The Division of Administrative Hearings has jurisdiction
over the parties and subject matter in this case.
Section
120.65, Florida Statutes;
Development Code.
sections 136.024{a} and (b) of the Land Development Code
Section 137.013, Clearwater Land
clearly provide that provisions of the Code dealing with the sale
of alcoholic beverages are "intended to supplement and function
in tand~~ with the requirements contained in Chapter 72 of the
Code of Ordinances,tI and also that conditional use applicants who
~ seek to sell alcoholic beverages must comply with Chapter 72.
Section 72.05(b)(4) of the Code of Ordinances states:
No alcoholic beverage establishment
511all be establishec within a five-
hundred-foot radius of a church,
school, residential area or other
alcoholic beverage establishment.
(Emphasis supplied.)
Although this section is captioned t1guidelines", it must be
applied and read in tandem with the conditional use standards set
forth at Section l36.025 of the Land Development Code.
.: ..-....
3
,,"- ~
.. ...~. " . ,'c .; T' ,,'.,,' ,c~ .~ ;~,.:"t.'.,'''.......7.:. .-t,'~,,?t~i1lv.rrr:4V~ /.;';-0\:.
, e ~ '....; " . >, <. ,", i,. ,. . ',,'n .(".!.' 'd'- "-1~'1:>i\ :J;~\~"
,'.~; ::.:.....~:'-i:.~'<:i;. :;~~::: : ;;;::.L:;"~;':':.";',.~:D;}~~;::'i;e~~~~1~' t~~~
I"n ~,\.T+ " '..;"~\1f""l~t-"~~).
,i - ~. ~ .I,:-.....J;~ ..t.T}.~l" ...
~. .
"" " . ' ....
/'
-
Filed with the Clerk of the
Division of Administrative
Hearings this ~ day of
March, 1987.
Copies furnished:
Donald o. McFarland, Esq.
311 South Missouri Avenue
Clearwater, Fl 33516
M. A. Galbraith, Jr., Esq.
City Attorney
P. O. Box 4748
. clearwater, Fl 33518
City Clerk
P. O. Box 4748
Clearwater, Fl 33518
"J
.,
:e 'i
.'
J J ./~;.,
'r
,.
. ~
e I '
,
.1
"
"
"
. "<.\"
"~. . .". " .
". . : i
:\ '
'j.
.. j
, .
--
I
.'
t ". .',
it'
5
,l