07/25/1986
,. .....,'.. "'Ar,~!:~ffi/",.",,,lm~:~0~rJ!'(S!~~;:}~.;-t(~~;i~,;'W,(r>'~::;~~~J~;i;fffJ;~~"-!i..~:;~.p:.,.i:f"~~'::::!~J~~~~>~~;~:~';;:.e~:~~e~lt
"
39
. .
.
\. -
ST^TE OF FLORI01\
DIVISION OF ADMINISTRl\TIVE HE1\RINGS
PHILIP HITCHCOCI<; )
peti~ioner; )
) , ....I
)
vs. ) CASE NO. 86-1723
)
CITY' OF CLEARWATER; )
)
Respondent. )
)
FINAL ORDER
Pursuant to notice; a final hearing was held in this
case on July 25; 1986 in Clearwater~ Florida; before Donald D.
Conn; a duly designated Hearing Officer of the Division of
Administrative Hearings. The parties were represented as
follows:
Petitioner:
Timo~lY C. Schuler; Esquire
Glendale Federal Building
11290 78th Avenue; North
Seminole; Florida 33542
Respondent:
M. A. Galbraith; Jr.
City Attorney
Post Office Box 4748
Clearwater; Florida 33518
At the hearing; Philip Hitchcock; Petitioner~ called
Richard Tobias; appraiser; and Denise Williams; leasing agent;
and introduced one exhibit. The City of Clearwater; Respondent;
called no witnesses and introduced one exhibit. Two public
witnesses testified against petitioner's conditional use
application; and one composite public exhibit was received. No
transcript of the hearing or proposed recommended orders have
been filed.
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. On or about March 13; 1986; Petitioner applied to
Respondent for a conditional use permit to allow the package sale
of alcohol~c beverages in a convenience store at 410 through 422
North Belcher Road; Clearwater; Florida. The property is located
"
}>
in a general 'commercial district.
./--1' '1llrtJ~I'\~5.J!;,~r;;~\.~:Y1'l.J.~~.t:; :l~~T~~{[/.-::;'~,.~~t~~":;~ .r :\l..~....t.,lt.T~;<:';: n(:~l"'~ J:.:'l~.:v{~.r;:.'.';L\~ '.; ~+".'~'.o'!.;'f.;~~\j~! (I'; ; fl:~{d: .~Lt'r -.
.. ,Ie. ,I", ,'t....'~y ,;J;:U~f"'"";\t,,~e.,,'~,,~, "" "'.~ "'>/' ^.."'...'h'l.'.C-,.ilhn.'.' .<.;'j..,"tz.:<>LJJ\." ~Jl,',>:<"",~ ".3t 'r';J:''':~~
~I~ ~~, ~ ~,,:r; i<;r.,':f:!f:~~f.i<~. .r.ti~~~~~ ~~' ~~'~~~:~~~~;';~~'~7~:--,~~~\,~"~~,,",~~,,,,~'U~1~.~~t~~:1. f.1.'~
";trl-~ t~~~~~l"' :';..{~';'L;'~ ~":.I~~'1'1~.T~:;'j; ~.Jxt~J' ~~~';JJ;V-,; ..:~:-~~-t""t:Y~lr.~ij:.:":/~{.",:,;: .;-~"':~ ~~.ti-q':';{~~.!f~';i~'~1",~ a;'.::'j. .;'\,.'~+{~;.;..l",~ ~l",<J""~~ ft, "~:. "~p? ~
>'" t ~....;' , T l\!'f'~;i"'" T~~ I:'~~":{ '" ..1 ..t:-t~t.;J l:,'\,...:::t I' ~.j'r'~.c'!J-::t' :~\ ;.~~-i!:\.I~~;."il";,:;.. '~f{"~/:~~1 ....~~ ..~"'".,: "~"~,l....h.,, -: .'~'" < ':':\+~. .:; <', ~.~."t.->.r-~.; ~;..\, V:.,- ; .l::--1"f-.:--''''r(q.1.- 1.
.~'l:,:'iL .~) ~; . ~'r:'~, ':: ,/ ~~e:~"""''"' IL~ .~ u:~\ \~.I '"-t(:"'~ r,.. .'I~~..t: ~. ~L' ~':'~': }! -:. :.;" ':.' <5..~~: ~: '~~...~:/';~ :'.. ;:f~~:~? ~: ."~~ - :ic ',.t' ':i~c:~'.i~ :>:\\~~~t.~:'/ :.:~;" :;,~t: .~\~~, .~. ~ :. .~~ ~~> '.. .:~ .".: ~' .:~. .~. : :~<. : . .. \,~.f.:';~: h' ;J.~.~( ;/_;':..~~':":t'..~~f'<~.~~~./(;~~':r~~~~{~{\:~ :~~t
, ..'i,\~J ~;~.1 -, ~~;~ ~ 1.!;lt~-,,,,'=;"'~:~"T~~' '!::'::'~~:~'}';~~,. ~~<~.\~.;. ,:,;l. ,; ~ ,~;::.t~:-~ :~:'.f~~ .:.v'.~. ~.': ~ ...~~<:~ ~::...-... . .c~~~ ~::: ~ . . ~.~:"I' I.~.: 'X-:.""<:'~"'. F ;~':U ~ >.'.'i 4..~:f.':.:~:.Jj~~; Hj \;p~'~~;~.; "'c(~~'-.\1~\$.t....
!!..l~-:J:.jT:8""t.;.~'T>""~ /- '" . ~:.\. ;:.;t..... ."~~~~~"'21.:t:l,'~~"".~ ;"':1; "'/ (t ft I.~.....-~~ "l.....;:. ~ " "",- ~~~~~ 't' >'.~ (r'-:'; ~..J J.~' .'.,,1:)~ ~ ~.~. / . -'.~~..I~k,. t~~J.1....~ :"'>.1 ~+"~... ; ~'\-'"'j;;:Y'{\::''' ~," t~;~-:~tt.,:~"~.9':j~