The URL can be used to link to this page

05/14/1997 - Specialr�- �...�� _ _ . � ', . - . . � � - � � ' „ . . �y �. t, . . �. . , �'. , . , i .. , ` , .' �. .5i. ' . . . , . . ; . . ' . ..i �£�.r.. J ' � $�,r��Yl�':' A'1:.�. �5 ;.�,.. . ' .. , . . ' ' ',' . _� I � . � . . ..—�_h .... . , , � �_...:.r.war.v:�',t1.4Wj�.1;�'°°,�i','� Fd . .`�; . . '- � . . . � . ,. , . . - ' , ' . ' . , . I � . � • .�n a. � � , r�.. . 7. ,, . .� . , . . . . . ' . . . E . � � ' . ' . • • •• � . � � . . . :' ' ' ' . . , � , � ' ' � ' '. ' . � � � . . . • . , 1 . . � 1 � � � . � � „ � � . � ' � I � ' / � ' t . . I . . , . . . . . , . . . ' � . � .� . � ' .E . . . . . ' . ' . . . . '• .0 ' 1 • ' . ' . • . . . i 5: � ' .. � . . ' ' . . , . ' , �4`. ',! r� ' � , ,' . � �, . . r, `•.'. ., .. .. � ' , . ` � . p . . ;' . . . � , .; . .. , • • ,.,' . . -, • . .)� � . � . . , � ' . . ' . • . ' �:i'.i A i •. `� "4t�l. �-.k'r. Itl�r . FI � ._' � .. . .. .... . � .,. . � � �Y/i4Th.9.:.'l;�t}�..f:k;°�i.��?�'):F. ; t. ; 1.�"•�45 � ��' .. , f . . � � . . ) � . . � � �� ' 1�S1�I� �. . . � . � . � . e�1�. �� 11� � . � � m�nutes named: mspa5a97 �� . , . , . . .. r � ::- . . - - ., - .., . ,� , � � � ,, . . , , ,. . . . . , ��"��„ . �,.:� . ,. »„,�tx, ;f � � � � MEMORANDUM TO: Honorab�e Mayor and City Commissioners FR�M: Pameia K. Akin, City Attomey p� RE; Appeal of Planning and Zoning Board Decision Case No. CU-97-'�fi Equator, fnc.lTiffaRy Wilder ButlerlBTLS Entertai�ment, l�a (Ptanet Bubba) Change of Business Ownership at 251 fi Gulf to Bay Blvd. Hearing Date: Tuesd�y, May 94, '! 997 - 7:00 p.m. DATE z April 30, 'f 997 Pursuant to Section fi.27 of the Clearwater C�ty Code� when busi�ess�s which ha�e a conditiana! use %r the sale of alcoholic beverages change business ownership, ihey are required #o seek a conditional use approval for a change of business own�rship. The appellant is the new owner of the business and saugh# a conditional use approval for change of business ownership. Foflowing a public 11eari�g, the Planning and Zoning Board den�ed the request. Enclosed is a copy of the record of that hearing pro�ided by the City Clerk. Pursuant to Section 36.065, cor�ditional use decisions regarding the sale of alcoholic bewerages are appea[ed to the City Corpmission. The City Commission must foflawing all provisions and requirements regarding the conduat of the i�earing. Pursuant to tha� sec#ion, the hearing is cortducted as fnl2ows: . The Mayor shail set forth at the outset of the hearing the order of the proceedings and the rules �nder which the hearir�g wi(� be cond�cted. The order of presentation shall be as foflaws: t'� ) (2} (3) (4) {5) (6} �) (B) �„Y..�. .. .��,., ,. .. Receipt of the tapes, minutes and exl�ibifs from the Board Opening statements by the part�es Appeflant's case Respondent`s case Rebuttal by appellant Summation by respondent Summation by appellr�nt Conclusion of the �earing � The Commission has the author€ty ta dete�mine #he applicability and reievance of , ail materiafs,. exhi6its and t�stimony a�d to exclude irreievan#, immaf�riai and repetitious matter. Cross-examir�ation may be permitted. Each side wil! be allowed one hour to presen# their ca�e. �n rendering your decision, yo� m�st consider the record and test�many preser�ted ai the hearing b�fore the Board and the hearing befare you, . relative to the guidel�nes for consideration of canditional uses cor�tained in Sect�or� 41.033, 41.Q52, and 41.053(23). These sectior�s are attached for your reference. The burder� �s Upon the appellar�t to show #na# the decision of the Board cannot be sustained by the evidence before the Board and before you or that the decision of the Board deparis from the essential requirements of [aw, You sha(I be guided by t�e Cify's Comprehensi�e Plan, relevant pvrtions of t�� Code� and established case law. Your determination must include appropriate findings o� fact, conclusions of law, . and decision in the matter o€ the appeal. The Commissior� may affirm or reverse the decision of the Baard and may impose such reasona�te conditians as the Board may ha�e imposed. Specifically you may impose conditions and restrictiona necessary to comply with the standards for appro�a[, "to reduce or mirrimize by poteni�affy rnjur�ous effect of s�tch conditiona� t�se upon otner property in ihe �"� neighborhood and to carry out the general purpose and intent of th[e] development code." While the Commission may allow bath the applicant and #he respondent to submit written findings of €act and conclusions of faw, it is my recammendation ti�at tf�e Commission discuss its conclusions and as appropnate make its findings of f�cts and conclusians o# law. Follow�ng tF�e Commission's oral rendition of #he order, i will reduce fh� order #o writing and bring it to t�e Commission a# tF�e ne�ct Commission meeting for approval by the Commissior►. PKA:jmp Copies to: E�izabeth M. Deptuta, City Manager Scott Shuford, G�n#ra1 Permitting Director E. D. Armstrong IEI, Esquire, Attomey for Appellant �1e� . u . .. � , , , - . , ' �{ . r, , . • �. ' , . - � . ; ' ' . " . �. , : " , . . . . , . . ' . . d ' � ,' .�. ' . . .. . . . . ' ' • � � � ' �, • . - . . . , ' 1NDEX � � .� � 1, City Code Sectio�s 6.2fi and 6.27 re: a�cohoiic beverage � � � � � establishments � '�� .�. �� 2. City Code Sec. 36.Qfi5 re: appea(s ;� . � ;��., � �,� . 3. City Code Sers. 41.031 through 41.035 re: a�plication and review �• .� � . „ � Secs. 4'�.059 t�rough 4�.Q53 re: sfandards � � � . �� , 4. Record � � . . , . �. , . . � . .� . � . . , ,.. , . , ' '+� ' .I � � k . . . ' ' • � .. . � . � . ' • �i'. . . , , � . . . , . , . - ' . r . . �' .. . . ' 1 ' . � , . . . • � � . t • . . 1 ,. . . . . . . . . , . . - . . ' . r ; ' . , � , � . , .. , . . . ' , , � . . ,� . . i ' � � . . � � � ' � . . . ' � i ' � . . . . � � . . f�� ` .: ' • , . „ , , , . , . , . � '. . , '. .�� ' t' ., . � . r ;. ' . . . � . .. . . . - � ' , � �-- � , _r _ _ �Sec �:�G�:;;'' �Appl�cabl�lt.jj;of�condi�ionalnyse"appro�ai�antl;sep�tation�_.reyulrements: � lr� addition #Q the regulations cflntained in this article� he;car'i�i�i�nal�use:ap�roiial� T"TM+�W "�w�'C�'M btiw�+«^1•. "[�s.Ti w.�I . � �irem�nfs � efisepara�ia��eqc��iremen�;set�orkh`�in:artic�e:lil'of�chapte��4`�;�shall�,aPp�Y,° ' Nt Y!w`��lF J'SwR111M4. �c1Y..t".J Sf+.L[..l1.•�N. y"�s4..)��r...vs 1,^ � •: -• .. - 1 �' � r{„q-��,'d��bk�"s.`iTlef��nliiitie'��'ip or� in cases where an existing atcohalic be�erage sales use at a differen# �ocatian is discantinueci, for a new alcohalic i�everage sales use, (2} For the purposes af this section: (aj Approval mea�s a condit�or�al use approvaF for tne saie of aicaholic be�erages within fhe city. Every alcahalic beverage establishment �awful�y in existence within th� city as of January 21, 1988, the date af ada�tion of Ordinar�ce No. 4420, shall be deemed to have such approval, including but not limiteci ta establishmenis which pr�date the adoption of the land deveEopment cade. {b} Convictior� means a verdict of guiliy ar any plea of guilty or nola contendr�, regardless of whefh�r the court sentences the defendant tfl jai�, prabatian or atner s�ntence, {:� and regardf�ss of whether ar not th� court withholds its formal adjudication of gU91t. (c) Holder af the approval and holdsr mean the persan having t�e right to aperate an aicoholic beverage establishment within the city. The ierms shall also inciude ar�y officer, directar ar partner, if th� holder is a corparatifln or partnership, and ar�y �mployee or agent of the holder if t�e employee or agent is canvicked af a crime or fau�d to have �iolated an ordi�ance or condition descr�bed in s�bsection (3} of t�is sectian. {3} An approval sha11 be subject to special condikions, suspension ot revocation as d�scribed in t�is sec#ion i� the f�ofdsr of the approval Fs: (a} Convicted oi any felony as the result of canduct on or off the premises; (b) Convicted of any misdeme�nor violakion of any law rela#ing to assault and loattery, weapons and firearms, prostit�tiaR, lewdness ar indecent expos�re, fraudul�nt prackices, public nuisances, obstructing justice, abscene literature, gambling, drug abuse preventiar� and control, or offenses conceming rackeieeri�g and iliegai debts, fnc�uding any conduct which is unlawFu� pursuant to F.S. chs. 784, 790, 796, 500, 8�7, 823, 843, 847, 849, 893 or 895, as may be amended #ram time to time, incluc�ing but not limited ta . conviction far at#empt or conspiracy to cammlt ar�y of the foregaing, as the result of conduct on the premises; (c} Convicted of a vi�lation of any ordinance of the city relating #o any conduct � on the premises af a kind describet� in subs�ction (3)(b} of this sectian, or relating to the subjects of disarderly canduct or no9se pursuent to sections 20.61, 20.fi2 ar 20.�i1; (d) Found by the code enforcament board of the city to have viaSated any ordinance of the aity ap�lEcable to the alcohofic bev�rag� establishment or the op�ration � tnereof; or (s) Found by the city commission, after a hearing for which ihe hofder has been given �otice and an apportunity to appear and par#icipate, ta ha�e violat�d any ordinance of the city telating to the standards or criteria far canditiortal use ap�rovals, including faut not necessarily iimited to false ar incomplete #nfarmat�on �rovided by the applica�t of a material nat�re, or to ha�e violated any condition impdsed by ordinance or by the planning and � zflning board at ti�e time af conditiona� use appravai, or to have �iotate� any candition prev�ausiy im�osed by the city commission �ursuant to this seCtion, The i�earing describ�d in this subsection sfia41 be combined with the �earing required 5y subsection {4} of th9s sectior�, (4j 1n any case in which a coriviction or viofatian desc�ibed in subsectiaR t3) of this sectiar� is alleged ta ha�e occurred, the city cammission may take one of the foilawing actions upon ti�e conclusian of a hearing #flr which the holder has been give� notice and an oppartunity to ap�ear and partici�a#e: (a) Continus tne approva� su�Jec# to such cortditiot�s as sha�l be deemed reasonabiy �scessary by the city commissian to ensure compliance with app�icabla laws and ordinances; (b} Susp�nd the approva! far a period of time fo be determined by the city commiss�or�, but nat to exceed six months; or � (cj Revoke f�e apptoval, (5) The heari�gs requirad by this section shall be canducted by ttte city camm#ssian d��ir�g any regular me�ting ar spe�i�l m�eting called far such p�rpose, At such hearing, the f�older shall have an opportunity to pr�sent �vidence on his behaif, to cross exam�ne adverse witnesses, to be repres�n#ed by counsel, and ta st�aw cause wny t�e appro�al should not be cantinued subject ta canditions, suspended, or revoked. (6) The decisian af the city commission shall be deemed a fnal administrative agency decis9an, subject ta judicia! review by common law certiorari in the circuit cflurt for the county. �rr� -�,-,--�.- � �-� '�5� eG.�3n:Ofi5�Appeals�;�o�fiea�Ins�officer;or; city .commiss�on. .�..�....�_.�.... . . .._ . .�..�..._. .. � .. . , _. __ ..._ ._ .w��..... ��°"1 {1) Purpose and exception. � "k� (a) it is the purpose ot this sectior� to pro�ide an administrative process for appealing decisior�s rendered on va�iances and conditional uses by the deveiopment code adjustment board and the planning and zoning board, or by #he design review bQard prior #o �ny available recourse in a court of law. In particular, it is intended t�at such administrative relief be pcav�ded in ihe most professional, obiective and equitab[e manner possible through the appointment of a hearing officer to adj�dicate matters as provided in this section. T�e funct�on of the hearing officer shal� be to serve as the second step of a fwo-step admin€stretive pracess relating to �ar�ances and conditional uses and to desig� review. The review of a board decision by a hearing afficer shall not be required if afl affected parties are satisfied with the board decision, but no party s�all be deem�d to have exhausted his administrati�e remedies for the purpose of seeking �udicial re�iew unless the party first obtains review of the board decisian by a hearing officer as provided in this sectior�. (2) Applicability. Any party in interest may appeai a decision rendered by a board on an applicatior� for a vatfar��e or conditional use to the hearing oificer. For the purpose of this section, the term "party in interest" m�ans the property owner, the city manager or any person who will suffer an ad�erse er'ie�� o �n �n#erest �rotected or furthered by the Jand development code. The interest may be shared in common with other members of the city at large but shall exceed in degree the general i�terest sha�ed by all persons. (3} Fifing for appeai. Tl�e procedure #ar filing an appeal shall b� as foi�ows: (a) Appeals shail be commenced by filing a notice of appeal with the city clerk within '{4 days of the decision of the board. (b) The notice af aPp�al shaSl set forth in detail the basis of the appeal. ' {c) At the time the notice of appeal is fited, the city clerk shall require #he :� appellant to pay a fee in accord with ti�e schedule established by the city � commission and set out in appendix A to this Code. �-.... �.. - �!'1 �� (d) In any case w�ere a no#ice of appeai has been filed, #�e decision of the board sha�l be stayed pending the fnai dete�minatian of the case. (4) Administrative responsibilities. Administrative responsibiliiies shafF be as fo1lows: (a} The city clerk sha�C, in concert with t�te hea�ing offcer, estahlish a timeiy dafe and hour far the hearing and shall schedule a�oom at an appropriate (oca#ion within tihe cify for the hearing. Shoutd tMere arise a conflict in the hearing office�'s schedule, the office� shall be empowered to change the established hearing date. (b) The city clerk shali give notice of the hearing in accord with the requirements contained in articl� IV af this chapter, and shall also give such no#ice to the parties of the appeal. (c) The ci#y clerk shall make availab[e to the hearing offcer tf�e tape recording of the proceedings before the board. (d) The city clerk shall tape reco�d the hearing. (e) Following the h�aring, the hea�ing officer shafi prepare the written findings and decision. Copies of the findings and decision shall be mai�ed by the hearing ofFcer tv each party to the appeal and to the city clerK. �5) �or�tl�c#�� ofFicer shalk be as follows: Conduct of the hearing before the hearing (a) The hearing officer shall set torth at the o�tset of tl�e he3ring the order of ihe proceedings and the rules ur�der which the hearing wili be conducted. {b) �he o,,,�,,,�',�"�`"w,,,r�„�t�a�t on��ihe tieanr�g�s a�� b� as laws: �., � � esp��or,�de�;,,s r,.�se ��o �� sion`�df� e� ea �, t'�ha' ea �' o cer: �c) The record of t�e board's hearir�g and decision, lnc�uding a1� ex�ibits, shal) be received and cor�stitute a part of the record. � (d} The hearing officer sf�aiJ have tY�e authority to determine the � applicability a�d relevance of a!� mat�ria�s, exhibits and tes�imony ar�d to exclude irrelevant, immaterial or repetitious ma€�er. (e} The hearir�g offcer 'ss authorized to administer oaths #o witnesses. {6) Decis'son. The decision o# the hearing officer shall be based upon th� following criteria and rendered as follows: (a) ihe hearing office� shall review ti�e record and testimony presented at ��. the hearing before the hoard a�d the h�aring officer relative to the guidefines for ��'� cortside�atron of canditional uses or variances as conta€ned ir� chapte'r 41, article li, or chapter 45, respectively. Although additior�al evidence may be brought before the hearing offccer, the hear�ng s�all no# be deemed a hearing de no�o, ar�d the record be�ore #he board shall be fncor�orated into the record before the hearing officer, supplemented by sc�ch additional e�idence as m�y be brought before the hearing officer. � (b) The hearing officer shall be g�ided by the city comp�ehensive plan, relevant porfions of this Code and es#ablished case iaw. (d} The hearing officer's detemnination shall incSude appropriate findings of fact, conclusions of 1aw and decisian in the matter of tF�e appeal. The f�earing officer may affirm or reverse the decisior� of the board, and may impose such reasonable conditions as the board may F�ave �mposed. (e) The hearing officer sh�11 file his written determinatiort on each appeal � with th� city clerk within 45 days of the date of the appeal hearing. {� The decision of the hearing officer shall be finaf, subject to judicial review. � _ _. �-...___� ,` . ,. , , . , '. ,� • � ' � � . , ' � , �, . � . , , � . = r ' . �, . , . - � ` � (e} The hearing officer shal{ �ile his written determination on each appeai , � with the ci#y clerk within 45 days of the date of the appeal hearing. � � � �'", � (t� The decision of the hear�ng officer shafl be fir�al, subject to judicial re�iew. . � (g) Judicial re�iew of a decisian of a hearing oiticer shati be by common-, . � '� � .� . law certiorari to the circuit court. ln any case where judicial review is sougF�t, fhe � , decislon of the hearing Qffic�r shall be stayed pendi�g the ;ina1 determination of tiie , , case.. . , . � . . , ;. . . . � � . , � . � ' ��, , . . . � ,. , . - � ,�, . . . r �°. - . � . .., , . • , �� ,, . . , l ' .. . : �. . � , � t . � 3 . � � � . ' , ; , . . I ' . � . i s 0 ! S l 0 � i''�Y � DIVI5IQN 2. APPL�CATION AND REVIEW Sec. �41.p3�. Applfcation and submission requirements. (1) . ap,pl Ca o__ for a co�ditiortal use shall be prepared on a rtorm ta be d bv the develapment code administr�tor and ..�`"ia .��`"e�s �n� �bY� e;�awnerzo (2) The apptication shall be filed at t(�e offic� of t�e dev�lopment code administrator iagether wikh an ay�plicatian iee according to the scheduls �stablis�sd by the city commission and set out in appendix A to this Code. (3) Eaci� applicatiflr� shali be accompenied by an acc�rate site pian, drawn to scaie, id�ntifying: (a} Current and propos�d parking, pedestrian access, and �ehicular access on, the site, and ingress and egress to tF�e site; (b) CuRent and proposed locations, setbacks, �ses and gross floar area of �uildings and structures on the site; (c} Current and praposed height of bui�dings and sfructures o� t#�e site; (d) CuRent and proposed fences and landscape buffering, and perimeter and interior �aricing ��ot lar�dscapi�g nn ti�e s�te; (e) Current ar�d prapased site lighting on the site; (f} Type and generai location o# the naturai features on ar�d immediately adjaining fhe site, including significant natural vegetation and areas covered by tree canopy, as well as regulated natural features such as wetlanc�s, wetland bufferslsetbacks, natural drainageways or sireams, waterbodies, mangraves, and designat�d spec�men and historic #rees; t9? (�) AdjoiRing pro�erties and fhe principal use(s) of these properties; and Such otfisr informat�on as the cade administratar may require. Any supplementary information, exhibits, plans or maps which are tn accompany and constitute part of t�e application shal! be submittec3 to ths cod� administrator at the time of �1ing of application. 7wenty copies of ail such documents shall be requ9red for distributional purposes. Any am�ndment to a site plan approved by the planrring and zoning board as part of a conditlonal use �aermit involving increases in the intensity of use {as measured by residential density or nonrssidential floor area ratio), increases in struct�re height, or decr�ases in setbacksF o�sn space, or puffering shall be cor�sidered by the f�oard as a madificatian to the conditiona! use pormit. Other amendments may be considered mir�or amendments and may be approved by the devefopment cade adminisfrafor, unless determined by the code admi�istrat�r to be appro�riate #or baard action. i-�....� ._.. . ...�_.__._� � Sec. 41.�32. Revi�w procedu�es. � (1} The development cade administratar shall, upan determination that a ` condit;onai use application complies witi� aEl applicab�e submission requirements, recei�e the applicatian and instrt�ct the c�ty clerk ta schedule it for pubiic hearing by the plannfing and zaning board and give notice of such h�aring in accord with the requirements contained in art�cle 1V of cl�apter 36. (2} Tha pfanning and zoning board shaff cansider th� application and r�nder a deaision at the conclusian of the public hearing unless the board determines that ac#ion must �e det�rred to sllaw far additiana4 input and review. Sec. 41.033. Standards for approval. A condit�ortal use shall be approved by the baard oniy upan determination that the a�plicatiort and evidence presented cleariy indicate that: (1) The use complies with ihe land use plan. (2) T�e use complies with alE ather appficable pravisions af this development code. (3) Ti�e use complies with the applicabie conditional use standards for the proposed use cantained in division 3 of ihis article. (4) The use shall be consisterit with t�e community welfare and not detract fram {� the public's convenience at fhe specific location. (�) Tt�e us� shaH r�ot ur�dt�ly deerease the value of neighboring property. (6} The use shal! be compatible with the surrounding area and not impase an excessive b�rden or have a substantial negative imp�ct on surrounding or ad�acent uses or on community facilit�es or services. Sec. 41.034. Condltlons and restrictions on approvaf. !n approving a canditiona4 c�se, ihe planning and xoning board may impose conditions and rest�ictions upon the property benefitted by the cnr�ditional �sse as may be necessary to comp(y wi4� the stat�dards set o�t above, to redUCe or minimize any potentially injurious effect of suc� canditional use upon other proAerty in the neighbor�ood, and ta carry out the general purpose a�d intent of tF�is develapment code. Faflure to comply with any such condition or rest�iction imposed by the board shali constitute a viofation of this deveiopment code. For those conditional uses which the planning and zoning board approves subject ta CD�ICI��QiIS, the baard shall specify the t�me allotted to satisfy such conditions. Sec. 4'L.035. Certiflcate of occupancyfuse. Priar to the initfation o! any appraved conditional use, a certificate of occupancyluse shail be procured fram the b�ilding o�cial in �ccord with the pro�isions caRtained in sectlon 36.a61. �a.� In approving any conditional use, the planning and zoning board shall specify the period of t�me for which such certificate may !oe procured. The baard may, upan writ#en requsst, grant ex#enaions to such time allotments not exceeding six months each without notice ar hearing. ,�,�..,,.._..- - _. ._..�._. .... ,� �"� .� DiViSION 3. STANDARDS Sec. 49.Q51. Purpose. It is the pur�ose of this division to establish general and specifc standards for the pfanning arid zoning board to consider wher� evaluating any applicatian far a conditfona( use. The standards ident�fed in this divisian shall function in tandem with the review procedures for variances contained in section 45.Q�. � , idb7 enera! s �nda ,a The standards in this sec#ion shall appiy to all uses which are identified in this development cade as conditianal uses. �5�"`Si`�,�.�"s.e�..-.use°s'�v"�' c icomp'Tysw`�"��'"a"f_�n L_: essta' n�'��,co��""'ec (1) The use shafl comply with the fand use pfan ar�cf ait applicable terms contained in this de�etopment cod�, the building cade, ar�d this Cade of Ordinances. (2} Acceptat�le ingress #a and egress from the site shall be provided in a manner and locatian wi�ich ensure optimum vehicle man�uverability and vehicular and pedestrian safety. The n�mb�r of ingress and egress drives sha11 be #he minimum necessary to provide reaso�able access to the site. {3} Naise generated fram the use shall not unreasonably diminis� the use, enjoyment or value af surraunding properties. (4} The directian and glare of lights from both motar vehicfes and illuminating fixtures an the site shall not adversely aff�ct the us�, enjoymenk or value of surrounding �roperties. (5) Sufficie�t landscaping ar�d screening shall be pfovided to diminish noise, r�duce glare and buffer high activity areas and a�jectionabie views, including but not limited to trash disposal faciiities, such that the use w�lf not adverseiy aff�ct the use, enjaymer�t or �alue of surrounding properties. (B) Sufftcter�t area shall be a€iard�� for parkirrg in accord with section 42.34. �a} Whether the use is compatible with the sucro�tnding natural environment; (d) INt�ether the tra�c generated by the use is of � type or volume similar to tra�c generated by tf�e surroundfr�g uses. �-,...... , .__ .... , _... � �c .Q�i�upplementary s��aintlar�s�bY�,cate8o_ry�o� use�! T�e staiidards in this asckion which apply ta the ider�ti�ied ca#egory of use shail aupplement the generaf stancfards of use tdentified in section 44.OS2. No cond�tiana� uss shall be authorized unless determined to meet all of the standards applicable thereto. (19} Nightclubs, tavems and i�ars may be allawed within #he North Greenwood cammercial, beach commerciai, resort cammercial, general cammercial, downtownlmixed uss, infill commerc;al, t�ighway commercial, commercial center, urban center (bayfront), urban center (core), urban center (eastem carridor), ar�d limite� industriai zoniRg d9stric#s subject to all of ths ia�lowing: (s) The use camplies with a�l the generai standarcis for conditionaf use approval I�sted in sectior�s 44.a33 ana 4�.052; and (b) The use daes not cantribute to an inap�ropriate cancentration af such facilities as �udged �y the number of similar facilities witi�in 5DQ feet af tl�e propose� use, the potentiai effect of t[�e proposed use on public safety, and the poter�tial effect of the proposed use on residential, church, school and park uses withir� 50fl #eet. For the purposes of this sectson, this measurem�nt shail be from t�te praperty line of th� property contair�ing the alcoholic he�erage use fo fF�e closest Property line of each of the lis#ed uses; and (c) T#�e use is: ;in� 1. �acated on a passenger vesse! licensed by the state to self aico�olic iaeverages on which atcaholic bsverages are serv�d on�y after the �ess�l is underway, or is not located within �Op feet of a conforming church, schaol ar park ' c�se, residential zane, or similar alcoholic beverage use; or 2. Lacated within 5�� feet af a conforming church, school or park use, residential zorte, or similar a�co�olic �everage use but is located in ihe Urbar� G�nter District or is separated from these uses by a right-of-way of 1Q0 or more fe�t in wtdth; or 9. Structure des�gn - entrances, windows, exterior service windaws and loading entrances shall be ariented so as #o minimize impacts on adjacent properties. �L.`Y�Y�IeM+��I/f�1�1iMM'��'�"I+:'.ri•.�w^�e�se..T.ww'R'tT�`e1K.'/^T�Ptrva3!^f11" . w'+�T'��•'��w�LT.i�M�lt.ar.�M��:i�YlyrR1 � ,. �..� .. .. . .. .... . . .:........ . .. . .... . ', 3. Provision of buffers - perimeter Iandscaping shall meet or exceed the � � stan�ards o# sectior� 42.27 to the extent aliawed by site des#gn. � 4, Site desigr� - the a��licant shali specificaliy demonstrate that the site desigr�, as detertnined by s�ch fac#ors a� buiiding orientation. outdaar seating � autdonr loudspeakers, parking lacation, buffers, site lighting, and access and Coading area design and [oca#ian, is compatible with surroundir�g uses. (e) All occupational license approval standards, including the pofice department bac�Cground check of the applicant, shall be met prior ta the issuar�ce of an occupational iicense far the use; and � - (� tn the beach commercial snd resvrt cammercia! districts, nightcl�abs, tavems � and bars shaU only be permitted in delicatessens, or in shopping ce�ters ar hotelslmotels cansistent with #he pro�isions of section 41.07i except that expansion af alcoholic be�erage �,. s2les area and changes of b�as�ness ownership for existir�g noncanfom�iing nightclub, tavem � and bar uses may he,car�sidered; and (g) I� the North Greenwoad commerciaf d#strict, no new nightciub, ta�em and bar uses shali be aliowsd, but expansian of alcoholic 6everage sales area and c�anges of business awnership for exist�ng nightclub, tavem and bar uses may be cansidered. �� , 51 EI � � • l�rrrrr .lyu�Y1 'ww'rMM�a-✓-Y�+-M'�...-..r ' ` _ . �� . .. . , �� .,... �E. D. AItMSi'RqN(3 tIl '� DRUC� W. BARNE�S JOl�J 7. HI,AKF,LY IIRUCE H. $dKOR 0[N M.HURN5 MPCffAFL T. CRpMN DUANE A. DAIiCER i1.IZA88TFI ]. bANfFJ. S � JoHrrsoN, BLAKEI�Y, POPE, SC7KOR, RUPPEL &$URNS, P.A. ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELL4RS AT I.AW LlSA B. dOACiE MARIaN iiALE JAMES W. ENMANN SCOTT �, i1.I3ENFRI'� FRATlK R ]AKES 7IM07'!iY A. lOHN50?�. IR. SHARON E. KRICK EtOQER A. LAR90N HAND DELIj(�,Y City of Ciearvvater c�ty c�e�c ��l2 South Oso�o1� Avenue C1e�rwater� FL 34B18 JOHN R. LRWSON. IR.• CHARl.ES A. SrtRtAFtK05 MiCFiAEi. G. LT'f'rLE IOHN A. SCHAEFER MICHAEL C. MARlC}iAM PHfI.iP M. SF3ASiEENt STFp}�AMS'I. MARQUARDT CH/►RLES M. TA'[ELF3AUM . dAVID J. 077'INOEit lOAN M. VECCHIOLI F. VVALLACE PC3PE. JR. AlNEiHR WILLIAMS DARRYL R. RiCli/litb5 JLJLIUS 3. 7SCHAU DLNNlS d. RUPFEL' •QF CpUNSEL PL.EASE R�Fi,Y TO Cl.&AfiWATEA FILE NO. Ap�ii 9,1997 �' �'. �; �?o� � � � �; �' �-� � � � i991 "�! � i� t_'.�.��'�{ E�W � � Re,: Not�ce of Appeal of a becision of the Planning �nd Zoning Board Case Number: CU-97-16 Hearing Date: April '� , � 997 Dear Cler�c: Enclosed are the following: 'i. Notice of Appeal of a Decision of the Planning and Zoning Baard. 2. This firm's check in the ama�nt of $50.OQ payable to ti�e City of C(aarwater as the filing fee for an appea� of t�e Plar�ning aRd Zorting Board's decis�on to the Ci�► Cammisslon. Fina�ly, ! wfll not be availabie for an appeal hearing between May 1 and May 11. On behalf of my client's, I fespectfully requesk the appeai haaring before the City Commission be schedt�led for May �t5, 1997. EDAIar Enclosures cc: Ms. Tiffany Wilde� Butler Thamas G. Butler, Esq, . ; 04 25526.09 CL�1lWATLR OFFICfl 9� 1 � S fR�ET rf1S7 qFFICB SOX 136i ,�.:: ]�c�Rw�c'r�rr. t�orun� a�ai�.��aa � 7'H18TNQM8 (�I7j�61.i��r lACS1I�Q18 (I il] 41 f •id17 : Ve miq yours, .. � ,�'�� E : Armstrong !fl � TAl�A pFF7CE 100 NORTFi TAMtA SSAEBY SUIiB 160D rnsr o�sca nox i ioa TAMPA, FIARiUA ]]601,1100 TEl.Et11qNEl117} 21S.2S00 FACSIMfILB {tl3)12]•T11/ Q� e.� , i' APPEAL OF A DECl510N OF THE pLANN1NG AND Z�NING BOARD f,.,� CITY QF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA ; 1N RE: APpLICATI4N OF EQUATOR, INC.IT[FFANY WILDER BUTLERI BTLS ENTERTAINMENT, ING„ CASE NUMBER: 97-'l6 ,,• + � r � �� r . � 1 ► ► 1 1 � � ► A � � :. ► � Equator, tnc., Trffany Wirder Butler, and BTLS Entertair�ment, Ir�c., by the�r undersign�� attomeys, here5y appeal the dacision of the City of Clearwater Piannir�g and Zoning Board {the "Board") on April 1, '�997, whic� decisifln denied the Conditional Use Permit to allow the change in ownership of an ��coholic beverage [icense and t�e operation of a nfghtclub and restaurant in Case Number 97-9fi. The bases for tfi�fs appeal are as follows: �i. Appellants awn reai property and propose to op�rate a nighfcf�b and restaurant, includ�ng the sale of alcoholic be�erages, at 2516 Gulf to Bay Blvd., Clea�water, Florida. They will suffer an adve�se effect to an ir�terest protected ar fct�f�ered by #t�e l.aRd Develapment Code whrch exceeds in degree the ger�era� inkerest shared by all persons. Their property value is adversely affected by the �ecision of the ��'y� 3 Board. � . "�"� 2. Tl�ere was no su5skantial competent evidence to sup�ort or sustain t�e Baard's decisian. 3. Tfa� decision of #h� Board deparis from the esser�tfiat reqcifrements of taw. JOHNSON, BLAKELY, POPE, B�KOR, RUPPEL & BURNS, P.A. .�� • '" ) � �� •� � , f�� , l ,i� E.D. ARMSTRO �S .; Post ��ice Bax '� 368 Clsarwater, F�. 34S3D Dated; Aprii 9, 1997 '� 0925532.01 x'"i „r � CiTY OF CLEARWATER NOTICE 4F PLANNING Ai�ID ZpNING BQAR�1 PUBLIC HEARINGS Thc Planntag and Zoning $oacd af thc Ciry of Clearwater� Flarida, will h�1d pub[ic heazin$s on Tuesday, April 1� 1997, bcginn'sng ac 2:00 Q.m., in the Harborvicw Ceater, 300 Clevcland St, Clcarwatcr, Florida, to cansider the ioilawing rcquests iar coaditional uses: 1 � (Happy Foods) ta permit pa�lcege sal�s af becr and wine (ch8nge of busintss ownership) $t � Sec 02-29-15, M&B 21.05, zaacd CN (Ncighbor�c�od Commercial}. CU 9'I-15 2�. F�uator. Ync.l'CYffapy Wifder Sutl�rlBTI,�S Fnte��L,,,i�e. (p�antt Bubba) to pcnmit nightclubs, taveras, and bars {ci►�ngc of busincss ownershipj at , Studcbakcr's Sub, Lat 2, raac� CG {Geatral Commercial)- �I„�'1:1� 3. A.P. Mar Corn. (Portvuc Matel/Rccl Easy) to permit Marina facilities (charter boat) at C}ry Park Suh, Pari of Wat�r Lat 1, zoned CR 28 {Rcsort Cammercial) & P(Prescrvauoaj. �iT �_t7 � Interesud parties may appear and be hcard ai tha hearings nr f�1e written natice af approval or obscctian with the Centraf Permitting Dixector or Ciry Clerk prior to the heariags. Any person who decides ta appeal any dccision made tay tha Board or Commission, with respect to any matter considered at such hcarings, wisi necd a record of ibe proceaiiu�gs �nd. far such gtuposc, may nscd to enstue that a vrrhatim record of the proceediags is made, which re�ord inciudes the testiusany and evidencc upon which the appca] is to bc basad per Flarida 5tatute 286.O1OS. A,u individua2s speakiag oc� gublic hearing items will be aworn in. Fivc d�ys prior to thc mectiQg, scaff r�eports and recou�eudations an the above requests will be availabic for reviaw by intcrested parties betwcen the haurs af 8:30 a.m. and 4.30 p.m., weekdays� at thc Ciry of Cleacwater� CcntraF Pcrmitting Department. 100 S. Myrtle A�c, Ctcarwater, FL 34616, or ca11562�4567, Scott 5huford Ccntra! Pcrmitting Ciry af Clearwater P.O. Box 4748, Clearwatcr, FL 34b18-4748 h10T�: Applicaat or �rtprese�t�tivo must bc prs.sent ar thc hcariz►g. Cynthia E. Gotuieau, CMC Ciry Cletk « . � l 1 i• i� � ! .i • " :aY �i / • ► �i�� i � • � ► 1.1 a� • �• �S '�•' i r :«��i`�a�� : i �.i7�; �:� .r�[��: ; i. r:i �� ; . � � : u � �a�: f . .��. . � ; � i rr ; � s�; it r . : c f ��r►, � r : M � . �� * : � a�: c� ' ; � �� y i. r:i �,� ��i. ; � � � �:i rr �+: . � � .�rr: r.i �; ; � � ti � . , •, ,,. Ad: 31ZZ197 � CiTY QF CREARWATER CONDITlONAI. USE TRANSMiTTAL ' TRANSMiT TD: Cynthia Gaudeau, City Clerk ;�om Miller, Environmental Mana�ement on Meeriang, 7raffic Enpineer Stephen Doherty, Zoninp Sectio� Supervisar Dussault, Samoff and Melone; Zoninp Section Review Deputy C�isf, Asu! Mas�t, Polics D�pt. i.t. Jeff Kronschr�abl, Community Responsa Team Case A�sip�ee MEETlNG bATE: CASE �: Apr '�, '�987 CU 97-Z 6 �:��g��] I�i�Fr 0 � ��gT �r��K o,�Pr CU 97-'{ B 1-EGQUADDRESSl��CATiONlSiZ�: Sfiudebaker's Suhdivistan, tot 21267fi G��# To bay 8Jvd1200 ieet Fast �t Q!d Conchman Rd.12.70 acrea OWNERIAPPUCANT tBUS1N�SS1IREPRESENTATIVE; Equator, 1nc./Planet Buhba! Tiffany Wilder Butl�r CQN�I7'SONA[. USEtS! R�QUESTED: N�Qhtciut�a, tavem� and bars COD� �ITATtON ICh��ter. Section, Pnraprbph}: Sec 40.424(1) ALCOHOi.iC 8�1/�RAG�SITYP€ OF ACTIDN: Changa af business awnership �LOREDA LIC�NSE DESIGNATION: 4 CQP SR ZONINGILAND USE PLAN D�SIGNATIOAI: CG �Gener$I Commercial DistrictjlCG � EXESTtN� FUTUaE LAND USE, Z�NING AND ACTUAL USE OF APPLICANT'S AND SURR�UNDiNG PR�PERTIES �UTURE LAND US� LOCATIQN PLAN CAT�GORY Z�NING ACTUAI. USE SubJact ProA��Y Commercial General CG vacant buildinp Nortti lnstitutional � PISP churah Soutt� Comm Gen CG & CH mixed cammercial ��t Camm Gen CH mixett cammercial �e�� Institutionat P/SP � P C- R t3 W CITY QF�ICIAL,S WISHING TQ COMMENT MAY DQ SO IN TH� SPACE PROVIDED BELOW iC01VIMENTS SHOULD BE HEfUHN�D TO TH� P1ANNING MANAGER AT L.�AST F�FT�EN DAYS PRIOR TO THE SCH�DULED PU8l.{C H�AFiING�. TRANSMI'iTED BY: Earl Dussault DAT�: Feb 27, 1957 `FDR PUBL.IC HEARING BY TH� PEANNING AND ZaNING BOARD �{cuab9716ed Q�� I, � CxTY C�F CLEARWAfiER �``� ��3 s 41 `°—` CENT�tAL FERMITTYNG DEPARTMENT �Gg `�' / 1 � 7 ,� 100 SO. MYRTLE AVE.� 2�"a FLOQR 1 CLEARWATER, FIA1tIDA 34616 �i'� �'� � `�' f �or� (sa3)-ss�as6� r.� { �'� T G— ,.,,, FAX (813) 552-4576 G� �/ r•� t CONDITiONAL USE APPLICATIt7N - ALCDHQLIC BEV�RAGE SALES (Please prir�i or Type, Black lnk On1y} tV�lYl��vc.w v�• ��..n� ��r�vtij �� ,' � .� ., �ar� � TYPE �F R�QUEBT (Check Applicable Box or 8oxes�: L7 Hrw l.ksns* 0 Addr�� Ch�ny �8u:in�t:Own�rshl�► Gh�nq� ❑ Llc�nsa Ds:lynatiory Ctun�• ❑ E�c{san�iot� ...- ';�:::::,.�wrr�.:��::� rc.wrc�rtar�{r�+�r.rl,; ::�:;:rsuwnu . ..... . . ... . . � . .... . �xlttl : ��latln � ! 2Z2 �� ZCYe � Ptopos�d: �'ropased: �.7,ZZ'Z Proxso�ed: �G HOl1RS OF OpERAT10N: Ysleekd�pys �� : � Al.i.OWABLE CAPACITY (D�termi�ed by �Ire Marshalq: •r,a��',�j Ez�suny: ►. i'�,593 Fropos�d: Weakends � �� l�door� Qc�tdoar Si�l�A7lfRE OF FIR� MARSHALL ORM T QN 1N SUi'POR �� RE U�ST• I, the underaigned, acknowledge the fo1lowi�g; TH� PROPER'�'Y OWN�R OR DL1LY A�THORIZED R��RE5�N7AilYE MU3T ATTEl�D HPARINO. !» order to represent the appllcant At tha hearin� befnre the Pka�ninfl a�d ZaninB Baard, a writtQn authortzation letter from the prop@rty owner or bueiness ownar r�am3r�Q a aertain vther pe�son as representntive MUSi HAVE BEEN FILED AT THE C�NTRAI. PERMITI"INO D�i�AR7MENT PRIOR YO TNE HEARIiVO. OTHERWISE� THZ5 CAS� WiLL NOT BE HEARD AS SCH�DUiEp, r ` _. . ' �.1 �� L �,� �l �� //.( r ; ��j,' !�� {• SlC�1+tAfiUR� OF: PROPER�If OWNER (OR REpQES�NTA'iIV�} STAT� OF F1.ORIDA CQUNTY OF PINELLAS SWorn to and n �� \ tni � a�y p�od�ced _ "'� ,,,^,,, „ . ,�_ aa identiTia M,.»� � -- srwnpa L. arw� ,f �. IAY I:ObA�E�5810H I CC a7Ei9E E7(Pl?�F.S: Auqu�t 7,1990 Ba�did �Iv. r:a,tuy PubYc �� , �� wha is ,a.o..�s��.�y a�ty icn n to me urrcllor haa �. NOTARY P�JB�lC MY COMMlSS10N EXi'IRES; FOR O��ICIA�. USE OM�Y REG�IVED VARIANCES R�4UIR�4 C1TY CQMMiSSION �.C.A.B. THIS �S INr�I�D�p TO �� Q 2-SIdED L�OAL DOCLIM�N�'. NOl'ARY ff�FORMATI�N CQNiAfN�D QN TNIS pAO� MUST B� ON 7HE REV�RSE SID� �F A COMPLETED APPLICATION FOR APPLIGATION TO �� ACC�P7ABLE, 81Form • Candfifan�i Ute, Atc 8cv • ��ott-9d• f�1��o0DT �t..� ��a...... . . .e... . . . ..__�.�__.e . �J�� BARNETT, LESIfL J. 6ARHGTT GRAIp E. 6EHRENFELD � ROBERT S. �01.T CkARL[S A. C�tRL9CN �iNO� N. ouruis LESLIE WA6tq HUqOCIt PETER T, 141RltWOOp OAVIC L. MOCHE JAYWC M. LAiA6[AT VALCRIE 570KCfi LIT6CF4QI TNOiAAS 8. LON6 MICHAEL D. MILLER AIC11AR6 W. I7AGKE 9COT'T O. STI6AL4 � B�LT, KIRKWOOD �3 LONG A7'TOqh�YS At LAW s��rE �ao 601 �AYSFiORE BOULEVARD TAMPA, FLORIDN 3360fi �,�'� E� �� c;� �� — 16 TELEPHDNEs i�l]1 86,•tp�0 TELCCOPfER: IDEJI �p1�E711 ��A� 11 199T MAl1.tN 6 ADDREbS: POST OFFIGE gOX 32BT March 6, 1997 a��j� �iE-�� GPT. r""��^.�L°R!°ns3sor Mr. Eaxl Du�sa�t Permitting Specialists City of Clearwater 100 South Myrtle, Central Permitting Clearwater, Florida 3�46�.6 `' Re: Dear Mr. Ta,ffan H�atler/� ua�or �nc. Dussalt: This. letter follows up our telephone �onversation ot this date, wherein I in�ormed you �hat �his �aw firm represents Tiffany Butler and BTLS Enter�ainment, �nc. ("BTLB"), in connection wi�h Ms. But�er's appl.ication for an Alcohol and Beverage License. Please be advi.sed that BTLS is a valid leassee of Equator, Inc. ("Equatvr"'j , which is the owner af the prop��ty descr�,bEd as 25�.6 Gu�.f to Bay Boulevaxd; Lot 2 of Studebak�r Subdivis9.on . . Ms. Butl.er is authorized by Equator and BTLS to pursue an A�.coho� and Beverag� App�.ication and Li,cense for the suhject proper�y. Further, Ms. But3.er is authorized to seek a condi�ional permit fpr sucn aicoho�. use. Tf you have any questions re�garding the matter, p�.ease ].et m� knew. TGL.tms f cc: Ms. Tiffany Butler Equ�torr Inc Very tru].y yours, BARNETT, �� Thomas G. ,.. 80LT, KIRKWOOD & LONG �.i', �� `�, .� � � . � �--- -.� -. .. �� ,. •. , � . ��, � �_ �� 10 �� ''►.� � .!w � �,�.��.�.� r. -. . . _ . , . . _,.�+��?"' .�$7 ��tier"APP '� �, Long IM""*� "� . CITY 4� CLEARWATER � " CENTRAL PERM�TTING DEPARTMENT �= 10U 5Q. MYRTLE AVE. � 2''`° Fi00R ,.-1 CLEARWATER, FLUKIDA 3�616 ' PHONE (8I3)-562-45b7 �AX (813) 552-4576 APPLICATICIN SUPPLEMENT FOR ALCOHOl.1C BEVERAGE USES CONSUMPTiCEN C3N-PREMiSES PROPOS�NG ENTERTAINMENT INSTRUCTIO{VS PI,EASE COMPLETE THE FOLi.OWfNG 1NFORMATION i� YOUR REQUEST FOR A CONDITIONAI. USE PERMIT F4R CONSUMPTIQN ON-PREMlSES ALCOHOLIC B�VERAG� SALES INVOi.VES � FORM OF EN'iERTAINMENT OR lF THERE IS THE POSSIBLITY THAT YOUR Op�RATION MAY INCLUD� ENTERTAfNMENT IN iH� FUT�JRE. FAILURE To SPECIFY THIS INFORMATION MAY RE&ULT IN ADD1TlONAL BOAR� APR4VAL BEING NECESSARY TO INITIATE ENTERTAINMENT ACTIVITIES. 1) PR4FqSED PRtiVIARY USE OF THE PROPERTY (PLEASE CH�CK ALL THAT APPI�Y}: �CS?� RESTAURANT NIGHTCl.UB, TAVERN �R BAR ❑ HOTEUMOT�L ❑ OTHER {PL�ASE SPECIFYj: � 2} PROP EDlP0551BLE ENTERTAINMEt�17 ACTIViTlES (Pl.EASE CH�CK A�.L THAT APPLY): t� JUKEBOX, TApED MUSIC, BACKGROUND MUSIC ❑ �.lVE MUSiC {SPECIFY TYPE, WHETHER AMPLICt�CATION WILL BE USED, ETC.): ❑ ADULT USES (SE� SEC. � OF CITY CODE) {PI,EAS� SPECIF�: � DANCI�3G {SP�CIFYy; ❑ D�NNER 7HEAT�R OR Q7HER LIVE ENTERTAINMENT (SPECIF'Y): � �.,� O C?TH�R (SPECIFY): �� S/Form • Condilional Us�, Alc Bav • 44ct•96 -1400-0007 C�� 25�.� GuIF to Bay B�vd. �''o�l Si�e Front Yard {25' SB) Open Area Required (50%} �x�sting 4pen Are� � �ui�d�r�g Area (Se;-vice ,Area) �.20,543 i�,?60 5,384 �,385 1?,222 Parking �equired . 172 I�/1Q0� sf �xist�n� Spaces 205 This inc�udes 7 ��C spaces There are also � 6U spaces pQx deed at the ']Campa Tribune B�dg. E�cistin� Use : Restaurant-Night C��b �'roposed Us� : Same , Management ; Uwner ��erated �. ` �i�� 2�ib8 C(1Lf i� B�Y BLtIQ SU� Z20 C1.�ARWA'fER, FL B�FbI� � �19 746-�774 ��o �. �: � . � � .� � � � .w.. �,�.�_ �.. � ..,. -,. I • = t��h � . � L� . X� .. �/�J i L0 l�t�� r0 �/1�^`�t' 4rr+ l%�) /i � � � � 6v�-� k � �y�c?�. r�' . 1'��' -- — � , � � S '.� y►•' .�r ,, � • - � �' Y 1 'a l..l y {r�. • 1, � t , , t � ti�' ' . � -� ''� � ' � A �`�� . R �g �- 4� �-'=�-�:t� p , r 4. a . i , , , f '� ! I . ' . h� 171�' ! l. .r � � � �� V �� ,.�� r. . � . r `"� � � ; `,d1 � , r . :��•.P � � t r' -- - � �- a . '' � , � � , � �; ` • ! 1 O —�' � � . � � ,; � . �,' i� � �� m m '�� . �� . . . -* �• 1 Y , � 1 � ' �4 11► i �• � � 1 � .�: � V; �. i.. ' � , � � .�. �i, rt S. " . � i � , � �� . , � . i � _ � f I: + ... ....._ . - --�----� - -�i ... .. � .�..' � �.. _; �t:._r�.. _..� »,r ,, � _ � a ,l ....,,� + ;' �:— .. , �� '� ,, _ ,. � . ; �� ' ,. ~ i .� . �w ., ��M�r. r� � (�` �i i •��-}1 . � K •'t� N _ _.p- ` : � . _ .��--... . . .--�i , , �' ' � +, '�,� f �r: � . . . �.�'^',�: . + _�' �• � • o �' • ` ^�..} ~~ o, i ' _ � • . � , i , �.7I, •�� J �� • ` ! . , � � ` � � � G o q � � } -� P'` � ' :. — w.- �}' �� ,�, •� � ,�I , h = , •. ' w � J �. .� v i � r � , � � �+1� • , �•--••r•' � `,•• �" • � �.�� r t�' , � � c �! � �` r n �_ �� . . \I w� �.�. .i r � � � � ,.,�� " "� , . • '!� :'� ' � q --�1i' il �A� •J^� -F V '� � N 4]'� � ; . . �A � • � � �-� �! �+ 4` � t � ......__ ' _� '� . i � . .� �� I� �� . r . , . —�" .�� , j' 1 � , .. . _ . ' w "_" "� . . . .-..-.� o �' i . o j . .. �, * , ` .�.. wi � � .1�_� . . �� , • • _ . ~.r�_ F I , 1� I ` � � •--�^—� .� .� ...� .�� • � ' ' i � -r� � � • �l —'i ., ,' � �' ' ;' 1'23' 17'�.W, . ' 279 �l� .• - �. � . �' ... .. , _. - �i� � CY C�L � Td �.�'F' i�? �i✓i�. �„� � � � � I r ��-1 ' � i. .... � . . . • .. , . . . .... ...,...�.... _,. _ . . � . '� A~�t� � 9 "' 10� !1 r...—_� , �� 1 � . ........ _ .. 1 , � ut I •+�� ry 1•,+� t4 � 13 I: � 4 / h� h � � � � .i � � .� � ti w .. ":.�'T.._.; � x�` . •�� 'a ti � '� �9 to �� j. .� .�.._. I ; 1`.• r '., 13 + '' � � � : � � M n tto I� .a �. . _ �w � � �Af�T � � � ' T—� r r 4 JJ� r 1� . ;: .`r a � � � -s3 B �+ sa �� __ _ »/os 1.._,....... � . t.�`" :u .: • ; 1� 1 'a.� 13 1; �..��. _ 10/ � � � � �.' �� w � . ., � �� w ��n STiZFET . ..... _��.� �..__,_r i ►� , 13/0:�� ,�' I � � , . � , ,,, �'""r.!°`_'ic3 I ia;o4 ' F ti3/t0 I { � � �' � ry � �h� � . _ .��..�� ..— , ��. �� F � Y M N �:,o, _,�,� .4�� . . ... ...._...... ... .t � , € � NAM�: �:�U # 97 'i 6 � - — ATLAS PAG�: 2908 ST[JDEBAKER'S 2 �z--39 � 4 � �o� � P � � � a .�,o� c� .�io. 0 � CU a �xo d � L1scn � � wA �h w 1�/01 li !. I� I. ;'°'°r � i 1 I ! LO1 2 j 1,.,.,. 1 �/11 ,o�t• 1 �/12 �a� �� t g,��o � + w � � – — - R R SR. QO w � � � w � 41/0 m �...........� ..............�............ . � �, f I � � . � � r � � � �I I CONDITIONAL US� REQUEST EquatorlPlar�et Bubba/Butler PUBLIC HEARiNG DATE Apr 1, 1997 SEC: 18 TWP: 29 S RGE: 1 fi E CL�ApWAT�R .PE.ANNING AND� ZONING BOA�iD . :. . � , . . �� r1... .....:_....�w. . .. . . .. ._. _. � i � �.� -';. -`�i''�i �-w. _ ,,.,;.. , � . , .. . ...... . .... 0 . . ., - , M�ETfNG DATE: ,�"� ��ASE l�: Apr 1 � 1357 CU 97-i 6 e CfTY OF CLE�lRWA7ER CONDiT�QNAL USE REQUEST � LEGAVADDR�SSlLOCAT[ONI5IZE: Studebaker's 5ubdivision. Lr�t 21251G Gulf To Bay BI�d12d0 feet East of Ofd Caachman Rd.JZ.7Q acrea OWNER/ApPl.ICANT (BUSIN�SS)IAEPR�SENTATiVE: �quator, inc.IPlanet Bubba/ Tiffany Wilder Butler CONDITi�NAL USE�S1 REnUESTED: Ni�htclubs, tavems and bars CODE CiTAT[QN {Chapter. Sectian, Par��r�ph1: Sec 40.424(i1 ALCDHQLj� B�V�RAGESITYPE O� ACTI�N: Change of business ownership FI.ORIDA I.ICENSE DESIGNA710N: 4 COP SR ZDNINGlI..AND USE PLAN D�SiGNA'i[QN: CG {General Commercia) DistrictilCG EXISTING FUTVRE LAND USE, XQNING AND ACTUAl. USE OF APPLICANT'S AND SURROLINDING PROPERTIES FUTURE lAND U5� L�CATION PLAN CATEGO�RY ZONING ACTUAL US� Subjact Property Commercial Generaf CG �acant �uilding North lnstitutiortai PISP ct�urc� � �outh Comm Gen CG & CH mixed commercial East Cornm Gen CH mixed commercial Weat Institutional P/SP F P C- R O W COMPATI�ILiTY WITH SURRDUND[NG PROAERTtES The praposed nightciub property atauts a church to the narth �to the rearl. The site has had a long history of short lived nightciub uses under several different names� over the years. Nightclub usage is a compatible use pravided certai� performance requirements are met as conditioned by approval (please see t�e recammended conditions below). PR�VIDU� RF�.ATE� BOAAD ACTlONS ihe Pl�rtninfl �nd ZoninQ Bo�rc! last appraved a conditional use for a ni�htclub, tavern and bar callad Jam'z N Java on Au�u�t 29. 9995. Attached is � copy af ti�e minutes tor thst appro�al. OTH�R DEPARTMENTICITI2�NIOUTSlDE AG�NCY COMMENTS See attached comments. StMiIA�iLY l.ICENSED ALCOHOLiC BEVERAG� USES WITHIN 600 FEET OF SUB.lECT PROP�RTY Perscna�ity's - 2086fi U.S. '19 �arttiatsles - 2557 Gu[f Ta-Bay Boulevard STANDAROS F�R APi'ROVAI.lCOMPL.lANCE �ple�s� refer to Sec.41.052 far General Stsnd�rds and Section 41,053 Suppiementary Standards for Appro�ai) Propasal ap�ears tn camply with Star�dards for Approval, � � -�-� . S7AFF C4MMENTS: m ,^. Th�s is a request #or cor�ditiona� use approvat for a n�ghiclub, #av�rn and bar wiih dancing and pre- recorded music. The Plannir�g and Zoning Board last approved, foc this site, a conditianal use for a nightclub, tavern and bar called "Jam'z N Java" on August 29, 1995. City records indicate the Occupationat License for the properry expired September 30, 1995. Ti�e new propos�l does not m�et the parking requirement for a nightclub, tavern and bar. The cade requires 1 parking space p�r 44 square feet of gross floar area or 431 parking spaces for t�e '� 7,222 square #oot building. The applicat�on �ndicates 9 72 parkir�g spaces on the property and fi0 parking spaces per dsed af the Tampa Tribune Buiidi�g #or a totat of 206 spaces. Previaus�y, the parking requirement was to be met by securing an agre�ment with Florida Power Corporatinn for use of the Florida Power right-of-way �or the required additional parking. The parking requirement must be met by such an agreement or the a�p�icant must obtain a variance prior tio the issuance of the occupational license. � This request seems appropriate for th� property and should not negatively impact surrounding properties if the following conditions of appro�al �re met. SUGGESTED COND1TtONS O� APP�t�VAL: � �� t•.... 1. The appEicant shall obtain th� requisite building permit, certi�icate af occupancy and occupational license within 6 months of the date of this public hearing, 2. The appliaant shail neitF�er promote nor permit an tF�e premises any i#ve entertainment� competitions, contests, or any oth�r activities that violate the public nudity or aduit use regulation ordinances {Section 2'! .13, Code of Ordinances, and Section 47 .6Q1, Code . of Ordinances, respeGtively), in parti�uiar, the appiicant shal� r�either promote nor permit "wei T- shirt co�t�sts" or simi�ar activities on the premises. 3, There shail be no autdoor entertainment. 4. The sale of alcoholic beverages shas� be limited to consumption an premises wlth no package sa�es. 5. A landsc�pe plan for all parkin� lots shalf be submitted to En�ironmentaf Managerment far approvaZ and the required landscaping s4�all �e lnstalled priar to the issuance af the requisite occupatlanaE license. �. fi. Prior to ihe issuance of the requisite occupational license and opening of the business, th� applicgnt sh�11 maet the parking requiremsnt or obtain a variance. ....t.: .�-r a � , �. ' ' � �...�..... . . � ----..- _ . � � . y � . � . �. r - . �, , , � r � `7. A m�nimum of two security pe�so�neS shaif be provided to police the parkir�g tat between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 3;�0 a.m. on Friday and Saturday ni�hts. 8. This approv�l sF�a(f be for a nine month triai periad fram t�e date of issuance of tY�e occupaiio�al �� license, after which the application will be re�iewed for compliance with the established co�ditions of approva�. '.. NO'TE: . THiS REPOR7 {S A STAFF RECDMMENDATION T� THE SOARD M�MBERS AND DOES NOT REi�SEiVT A�1�A� DEC�S�QN aF THIS CASF. A FJNAL DEC1510N 1NlLL 8E MAD� BY THE B�AAD .' AT THE PUB�IC H�ARLNG �N THE �ATE LISTED A80V�, Q1RErORT.� � , ' '� , • ' . . ` ' . . � . . - �i . � • `� • ' . , � � 1 r � _Y . � CiTY 0� CLEAAWATER COND�TtQNAi US� TAANSiNiTTAL 7RAN5MIT T�: Cyntht� Goudeau, City Cisrk Tom Milier, En�ironmenul Man�gement n Meerians, Tr�ffic En�ineer .. e�hen Daherty, Zor�inQ Section S�penriacr Dussault, Sernaff and Melone, Zoninp Section Review D�puty Chlef, Paul Maser, Police De�t. Lt. Jeff Kranschnabl� Cammu�ity iiesponse Tearn C$se Asai�noe MEEiiNG DATE: �AS� i: A�r i, '1997 CU �7-1 B � V r �/ i � .,�i...�ir�R�%�+�' ��fr. �; � 5 7�9� (�ITY �L�R{� DE�T. L�GQUADDRE5S1tOCATfONlSIZE: 5tvdebaker's Sethdivision, lot ?J25 � 6 Gulf To Bny RIvd1200 feet E��ct of QJd Caachman Rd.12.70 �cres OWNERIAPPLICANT iBUSlNESSilRFPRESENTATiVE: �quatar. Inc.lF'ianec Buhbal Tiffany Wilder Butler CONDITIONAL USEISI R�nU�STED: Niflhtcluba. ta�erns and b�ra CQDE ClTATION IChapter, Saation, Parapraphl: Sec a0.424�1) ALCOHOLiC BEVERAG�SITY�� 0� ACTiON: Chanpe of business ownership �r1.OR1DA LiCENSE DESlGNATION: 4 COP SR ZDNfNGILAND USE PLAN D�SIGNATIpN: CG �General Cammercial District)ICG tOCAT�ON Sub�ect Property North South East West � EXISTING FUTURE f.AND USE, ZONING AND ACTUAL USE OF APPLICANT'S AND SURROUNDING PROPfcRTtES FUTURE iAND US� PLAN CATEGORY Commercial Generai Institutional Camm Gen Comm Gen +nstitutronai ZONING CG PISP CG & CH CH P/SP ACTUA[. USE vacant buildinp church mixed commercial mixed cflmmer�iai ��c-�ow CtTY OFFICIALS WISHING TD COMMENT MAY DD SD IN THE SpAC� PROVIDED BELOW �COMMEN�S SHOULD B� RETUFiN�D TO TH� PiANNING MANAGER AT L�AST �IFTEEN DAYS PRIDR TO TH� SCH��UI.�D PUBUC TRANSMtTTED BY: Earl Dussault DA�'E: Feb 27, i997 � �;, cuab97lBsd ia�4^awlJi..�.1La.: , n ..:1"; . �... _� "FOH PIJBLIC HEARING BY TH� PLANNING AND �D�VING gOARD ♦ � �� ;� � ,"' � r Pettt�a�t In Op�wgitiott ta Uperc�tin�� of Nl�[itci�blRcMst,sur,uit . �Y � � f WE; tl�e iiadersi�ltd, as I�iembers of tli� Corsvnunity and Parisluon��rs of Hal,y Tri�yit}� Greek Orthadus Church located at 449 Old Coaelvncuti Rc�d! Cteaswastr Florida a� iierrt�y ex�ress uur unif �d voice in oppcysition to the praposed gar�t oia�s appiiva#iun for a chondit�onA1 use farthe c�sration oFa nightclub/rectaurant facility s�n�ing alenitiolia lkveragcr prese�illy clated tu b� eul�sd "Plunet Bubt�a," at a looation thni is adj�cznt to tltie Ci�urclti taeilities. 4ur oppc�si�ivn is bas�d oi: in��y grouada r�hich includr: a} Tltat tl�a praposcd eatabtis�unrnt ��i11 s�rva a�c�oltoliJ bac�crages; b) That t� propo�ed estab[i�itmr��t �riit t� aHitiated v� �th A4r. CJ�ITI� A�SO �1701{'1i A5 ��Bubt�A the Lovc 5ponge," and vr�ho hgs �ncaura�cd acta ofrnoral decadcnce for �liich otli�r ect��►li�hmeizts in the Cin� of Clcaru�atcr a$'�liated �vith i�im hat�e auffcred eonseyutnots; a} Tiiat llin priar optrakion af si�nilnr estahlisluncrits resultcd 'ni ritiiculc of aiyut�i> >nembers during i'r� Is10i]5 8t71�1�CSr . dj T��t tl�c chttr�c� faaility also acn;es as a aQhoo! facllity for Fevcral f�e�ndred Sundav Sc�tuui Childrrn and studc�s of tha C}resk Languege, w�hich �clivitiss aocur dur�ng tiic carly c�cniiig hours ncar ihc timc oFtraditionai happy Hours, giving risc to substantiut �afcty concccns. � a ao�enrnunity wa stanci tugcthcr in eppositiotti to ihe ganting of tlie prc�tnt Nprlioulion and �nskc our voicc �io»�n t0 Cll1,'I1 Q��1C JCfC1t1�7CYS Of i11C A.$C114`y CE1dC8C[I W1lI� tCVIC�V Of �11C APPIl08i1J1] �OC CQ11L�I11Q11A) ll$C. • Printed Na�rra Siu��kurc R�Sident af Clzsr+vater � � V � V� i�- Church A�iamb�r ✓ _� � V ��rd� Q�+� C�,�. q � -1 � � ✓ L�, � Cle�nvnter Business Ov��ner � Q�`�� -/� �q 7 P� ,�.�. ----- � � �"'�' . � � . . �. � �,,��,� s �w� � � N r� _� - �-� �. � .� � -.-�.- �'�� ! �!�_, �� .. � G � � No c _!si L.�� , �� s � � ��. -- - �/_N'a.S _ ` �-�1 _N-�-x- � 1.% . c.� � _v ' � � � � � t% v . ✓ v' . i/' `_' L/ �. " � . -y . �. � � ,� .� ,. _ .� : . � �� X . � . �G�d iCv��+ �; r1 �` —•—�� .w��.a� ��r...��..��ww�i -�=.+ r / . / I � � /� � i�/ I .i/S � �+ � I 11 .��!► � '' ; . ��L� - / i . �� - , �� , : � ��:li! .� � ..�. - - � � w . �� S lY1Q. �C"� � � �7VIQ! ,._..� �� V�s�`�iS �I�RY f�a�/�� ` �� r �TE"J , 1. �,nl� i � �� '�,c.�a . . ' 4�� r� � � petitloti [n Op��o�itlo�� to Upertitlo�� o�'Ni�l�trlublRrat��uru»t ��1't1LE.��S4I]S?��IlPS�.A4��cc��t 1e� Cl�u�� • �v s� WE,1lir undersi�zd, as Alemhers �t`tl�� Cortununsty{ a�id Parisluontyrs af Ho1V Trinit}' Gr�r�: Orthodux Cliun:l� locatad at 4UJ QId Cuaclunan R�d} Clturwater Florida du l�cr�1�� cxpress uur unified vc�ict in a�pc�sitian to ihe propc�sed g�rant of aui a�plivalion for a�ronditional use iar ti�e operatioi� oia nigl�tclub/reciaurunt facilit�� sen�ing alcnl�olic bcverages presaeytly slAied til be.:ulied "Pianet Bubha," at a louatias� tlint is adjacznt to �he Churcl� f�cilities. Q�Er oppasition is i�as�ci ott msury grou»d6 v�•liic�t includc: a) Tl�at tUe propnscd emtabiisivrnnt ��fll szrva al�ahalio bz��eragzs; b) That the prn�sed tstnblis�una�t u�i�l be aHiliattd with I�Sr. Cicm, nl�o l:noa�ti as "BuUba thc Lo�c Sporige," and who Uss �ncouragcd �cts oimoral decndence for whicli aUi�r ��tablistun��its in tho Cit}� oFCtcar��ater uSiliated with hun hn�•a suffcrtd cons�quata�s; a) Tlu�t tltc prinr operution o�similar estsblislunrnts R•esultcd 'u� ridiaulc �fa��ur�l� �ncmbrrs dvring rcligious scrviccs; � d) That thc church faaility also szn�cs as a schaal facilitp fnr scti�crAl hundred Sunday Scl:uui Chiidren and studcnis ofthc C�rcek i.�nguage� which aciivities occur cluring tlic cArly cveniiig houes near ilic time aftrad�tional happy hours, grvin}� riac to substanlial safct�� conocrns. i4s a�co�rununity wc ata�jd tagcthcr iii appositior� tu tltc �rmiting ofl��c present nnplioalion and mske aur vaice l:na�� to ea��ly ofthc mc�nbcs��oftlte Agrncy cliargcd widi rc��ic�v oFt�ia applioatio» for c:onditios�a) usc. ri--��---' -�F � Churclt A4einb�r y� �.� � � � ✓ � � Cjesn►�ater Buseness ��►ner -�l�c� , .� � d� �� , � u �� -�-��/ . �� _..._... �,�s�J �� a�� 4 ��H �.r� � �� r��►r . � 1 Y �1 I � � � � S �� ~ � i _v� wia � � �P d� . ,�G 1!�L.;� � ' - �r " , i.�� /,� : � r �Y• � p L. .�c�5 � �1— � C�. i�, �`[ , � � � ��t � C� � �� . . .•i . i � � � � �/ �.3�� • � M � �� . / �. i / � � r „�,� � � � , Y �� - . � � L' %' � ... ��.4 - ��, ' 1 �// / / � � � � � r i �►. . � � � A f � � �'//f.�� I + � � � f / � / . ► ■�� t �...1 s • . ►/ � �/ • � , ... _ ■ � _ �. / � ' � + � � 1 � , s� •��ti � � � �� t� � � �tv�� N��' � � � �� i . � GT/� .. .. ,� . „ S �D� . � �_ � � � � � � � .� .� � ✓ . �✓ � � � � ---�1�� . V V � Y . � i;.. . , I . tl -1� � ✓ � � �� % . ./ ✓ . � � � - �� ✓ � , � V � V V -�"b� n ^--H---- ++....�:v.. �. !..•ia..�.� / �. .L ... � t �.�1... ., � i I / � 1 a � � �+ . . _ Li . . 1 _ . �, ��.� � � - , ,_ ��Ir �� ,� ,�wr�.�,�� _ � - � � ��,�i-�� . •- . � � r...J , � �.l Y .` � ' // �� G w 1 Q � C�� ` ri I ' � � �r/'� � � �' t m � • �'ttitiati tn Op�o�itioi� to U�cy�ntin�� of Ni�iitclu�IRcst��«r�u�t r�II:111L }i 1+s.�}�YS�'$E�'s Acli�crnl !o Cl��t�rl� rzsrns�� WE, tl�r ��dersign�d, as 1�Semb�.�rs of tl3a Comanunit}� und Parisluon4�rs of Holy Triuit}� Grc�k �rthaciu� Cl�urch locatcd at d�9 qid Cuacjnnan ILc�d. Cleanvater 3�loridn do Isere4�y esrress uur unifitd vaice in oppc�sitia� to ,...� thc proposed grunt uf eus Appliantioz� For a ronc�itionpl usc i'or t�ic c�+tratioz� of n nightctublr�ctaarant CACitity seR•ing alcoltioiio baverages preseniiy riated to b� w�t�d "Ptanet Bubha," �t A locatiot: tl:at is ad,��e:ent to tf�e Chur�•I� fi��ilitier, Q�xr oppositioxi is based o�: muny gae�nds �]�iolt includr: a) Th#ttli� proposed est�Ujislunrnt �t�i11 sarvo a14o1�aliJ bt�>eruges; b) Thnt the proposed cstablis[une��t �cili be a�'ifialed wi�t ASr, Ctcm, Aisa kno�� as "Bt�t�t�a the i.avc S�songc," aryd who has a�couragcd acts ai'moral d�cadcrn:c for �vhial� otl��r estpbli�hmc»ts ir� ihc Cin� nPClceru�atcr afliliated wiil� hu� har� ruffer�d canszqua�c�s; o) Tltat tSic grior operalion af sunilnr esta�lisl�rntnts resultcd is� ridiaulc nf ahurc!> >n►:mbers duririg 1�C�1�[O119 S�.'I'V1CC3; d) Thai tha ohc�rch facility also r�rn•cs as $ schc�ot faaility Cor srz�rral hun�red Sunciay Sc1�uu1 Chaldren and studarlis of thG Cireck Ianguagt, vyfii�h activitics axur during ttic: eAriy avrning hours ncar tl�c timc of tradilional happy �ours, giving risc to s�bsiaminl sai'cty conocros. As e aornit�unity wc siand togcfl�cr in e�gosiiiqr� t4 tl�c granting of ff�c prescnt ��p�li+;�tion anc� rnakc our � oice l:stiot�� to eacti a!'ti� members aft#�c Agcn��}� ai��rgcd witii re��ic�v oftl�c �pp�i�ati�n fur canditianr�l e�c. Prir�ted Name �V� ��n� �ess/ � �iQ,v��f �.-�--� � -��..�� Ari�� r�� Rraidt��t of Churcii CIERi'1YfttC1' A•iembzr � � Cleanratcr Business 01ti'f��C � �s . . , _..�� _._._._.� ✓ �� r� �� DS Ca.�,7�7�I'S ��s� 7�� . � �° � nr � s �C � � v � � � � �J .� 0 � . � �� - � 1 � �, � � ' ` � � �� S �4� ,� R � � N� � , . �l � �� !� � / c� � 4. y /�/.S � ��"�"'� --� --.� --- ' ' � � � � � 'J "� . � �'N 0 ��-t.�]'� 4 f ,, w ,�. , , � • �% . /f-�l= -�f�� !�t'� t !��- V ' .t/. ♦ �� ' � ,, . . ----� � � . ✓ ✓ 'If • � .. � . � � � K � , �J � �'1 . � • . � � u,gL l�:s; � � � ✓ ✓ V '' V . r � V � . � � . � .c-� . /1_ -. 0 �/ �/A-.cl A�� fiF��l� o � !��/ :.!� ,� ,,_ • / � a 1 `� 1 � � � / :, � i �� . L � � �l, , � I � l •�y �/� � ' •' � , � � �.i.. � � � r �'..r G� J'< � /� � ,� � r�n �?S / ! � .+ i .�i �. ,r...i�� r..:... �-J � � � �. u � u c � '�s; i � V`�, .' - ,^ � � � � �� C� �� R N �`� r�„� r w... ,,,,, .,f "' , /` 7 �'r�5 � �� — L� � ..� � n.,� �-, � � �� 1��.�,�'lzS�,r� �� *-'��l..L-.Ai� �----• ��+' • r . � � � _ . � � � � V � /"/ V � � � � . � � � 1./ t •� � �!' � �% � � . . � ' 1�� ' �/ . ✓ ""�_..�� Z--�� ' . Ii/ �/ r r[ I � , �.1 � � + � � � � � � ��f� I I!i r � w r'. r'. �/ ��- / J _ 1 � -'�! i• _ i��._� _ 1 � �t� V V �'+' � �� J o '�� _. �� ■ � ,i � Plilklbll Ifl O�1j7b:1��I011 t0 Oj1M'�t�011 O{`;v��i�C�U�1iKC9tI1Llt'1�11f 5crri��c.c��zQt�oji.��Re�1�►c�nt tu e.�t�tsu.��x � WE, tlie ��ndersigned, As A�cmh�re ofttit Com:nunity� and Parisluoners oTHoly Tri:�it}' Grctk Ort4i�dux `,� Clwrch loaa�cd at 409 nld Cc��elunan Rnud, Cltsuwuter Flarida do litrc:by ex�tiress uur uni��d vnicz in nppersition ko � the prapc�scd grn�t of ast upplivaiio�i for a ronditional use for t��e o�ernt�on of a nightc�ub/restaurant Facility sen�ing �lcol�olio t�veragas preacntly elatcd t� 6e wl[�d "�lanet Subba�" a# a loeation th�t is adjoc�nt ta t��e Ci�ur�li #�ci�ities. Ch�r oppaeition ie baeeci a�► rnnny gr�unds v��ict� include: `�...� �f a) Tl�at tl�e propc>sed establislimcs�t ��ill serv� nluoho!'sa bzvcrAgas; b) That ihe prapu�ed establisl�me�it 14i11 bn �liated with I►4r. Clcm, ulso �:r�a«n as "gubf�n the I„ove Sponge," � u,ho has Zc�couraged acts ofimoral dtr.adcncc for tvt�icli otiiar estublis�unentc in ttse Cite� oFClcnrt�atcr �liated tvit�t hitn ttn�c cvi�er�d caonseqt�e��cr.s; a) Tltat tlta prior operation af xi�nilur esta6lis4tmetsts rc�vltcd 'ui ridiculc of oiiurci> >n�mUCrs during TCilgloU3 SCNICCB; ct) That thc chur�h facility also scnncs as a schoa� facitity fcrr ari��r�tl hunclrcd Sur�t�y 5cf�uul Ch�tdrrn srsd studcnts ofthc Circck Languagr. K��ich aci�vEtits ocacur diuing tl�c carly c��rni�z� hnurs ncar ilzc timc oits�difianal happy haurs, giwing riae to s�cbstantial safctv cos�cerns. As a aoinntunity we atand tagc�hcr in appositiori to thc gr:u�ting oftho gnscnt ��pFli�nts4n and ma4:c our voicc �:no�tir to cacli ofihe me�nbers af tl�e Agcncy clYargec# wit�t revicw of t�ie applioatian fur canditionni usc. Printed Name , � Yc �c, �'t��„�� .. Signsture _ ��7� �_ � •, � • . Residesll nf Gleanvatcr t� v L� �� ✓ _ v/ v Ciear��aicr C�urch Business �tztnbar ��tiner C�— c�.� G,�. 4,r � � C� �i/ � � _ C% ._�..L �.____ �. �� ..- �� ,�- � PrtiGion ln Oppo�ltlnn tn Uprratiu�� of N1�I�trlublltcste�w�u�t ,. , � i � ' =*' �� WE, tliz �mdc:rs's�n�d, as 1�IettiUers of the Commu�it}� and Pariskuan4�rs ai'Hol1� Trinit}� Gireck Ottli4dux Church [oeated at a49 Otd Coac4unan iLcxtd, C�earva�ata Florida do ltiere�y ex�sress uur unified voic� in appnsitiatt tc� ,.�, t�c propoeed grant of an applivatioii far A c•onci�tivnsl use for t��e crperAtion of � nightel�b/re�tarar�nt fa�ilin� s�ers�ing ' ' alonlyo�ic bzverages preseittly sla�ed to be �;:�1lcd "Plnnat Buhi�a," �t g 4ocatios� tli�t is adjRa�nt to the Chur�h t�cilit'res. Our o�position is baecd oiti maiiv p�au�ds w�l�ich include: , a) That t�e propused eslablisl�rnznt a�ill scrve alca�ofi� be��erag�s; . �j TilAt Q1C �]iOpOGCG� t�i8�l�3S�tiitG[I� tt�i21 be ; trfieLed with I+'Ir. Clcm, a�so lrnat}7� as "Bubba the Ln�,�c Spor:gc " and who has �ricc�uragesl acts of'rza�ral decadenee i'or whicls otlzzr establistunants in the Ciri� af Cfearr��atcr u�iliatcd �vith him ha��e su�'ered cons�yur�ices: c} 'Tlt�tt thc prior op�ation af su�xil�ur establisluncros resultcd vi ridiculc nf oiyur�l� inLmbrrs during rcligic�us acrviccs; d) T�at ti�c ohur,ch faoili�y also scn cs as a schaol faoilsty far sc��cral hundred 5unda� Solzc�al Children and studcnts of thc Oreck Languagc, tivtt'sch activities oocur during t1�e cnrly cvcning houss near t��a time of traditional ha�spy hours, givin� rise ta substantial safety cancerns, As e� communsty wc staud togethcr in eppogiiion to fhc grwuing of the prescnt ap�lic�tion and inake our raicc 1:noKn to eac�i of ihc nscinbers nf t,he A,geney cteargcd with re�tiew af t�ia applinatioi: tor conditiona3 ease, Printod Na�ne a � : �,�: � Sigs�alurc . ri It,, i� � "�� i / � � �,� � r. , � % � � _ _. Rc�idcut aF CSean ater V �lfiK� fY/�e.�LdodL,� � �� .,�, � _ `�C. , , _ � ✓ J�.c✓ � � � � Church ��tz�,�v �/ Clcar�+vntcr Busincss o�� . l� ✓ G�.�. � �, � � � �i � �.ti Pctldou ]n Op�soyHiou tn Opei'N�IUII Of i�I�sl�tclul�IRcshtut'wti 1N�, tlie i�ndersi&��d, as hlemb::rs uf tlia Corr�nunity �nd Parislunn�rs of Ho4,y Tri»it}� Grc�k Octhadux Chunh tocated at qU9 C3id C�acEunan Rc�d, C�eas-waler Florida do iti�rehy cx�ress ucsr uni�td voicz in opposiiion tn th� propoced g�t of a�i appii�atio� for A oonditeonal usc for the c�eratio�� af a nigl�tclub/restaarnnt fa�.itity ran•ing �1colwlic txvzrages prese�itly clated tu i�e �u31ed "Pla�set IItibisa," at � looatiou tltnt is adj�c�nt io tltie Cl�ur�[� tnuilities. Chir oppogition is b�4rd an mpui,y grouuds wbicl� inafu8e: a) T1int t�yt propc�r+�d cstablislnnrnt ��i116�rve a�4nl�oli� ba��cragzs; b} That t1�e pra�oced establisiunc�st �4�i11 t� �HiiiRied wiih ��r. C��ll?� Sl�50 �C)7D11Y) AS "Eitl�bu th�: L,o��e S�nge;' ar�d wha has aneourAgcd acts of moral�dtcudence for ��hicli othzr esta�lishmc�titc in ilie Cit}� tif Clcar►��atcr aSitiated �vith him hac� suRered cons�c�ues�czs; c} 'fE�nt tl�c prior o�cmtion of similar establislunents resu(tcd "ui ridicule ufafsurclt �natnbers dur�ng rctigious acrviccs; d) That thc c#�urch faciiity a�so scrLCS as a school facility far c�c��trul hur�dred Sunday Schuul Children nnd studerrts afthz C#rca�: Language, w�liich activities aoc�r ch�ring tlic carly cvcning hours near tfu timc vfiraditioeza! ha�py haurs, givirr� rise !o substanti�l sa#'ctv cvnocrns. . As a aarnmunity we stAnd sagclhcc in ��positivn 1a t�c gr�jting of �Zie pr�scr�t it��Hcution ac�d rn�kv our voic�c };noi�ri to cAC1� a�ilia me�nbers oftlic Agen�y� cli�rgcd witli re�iew oftl�� Applicatiou far conditiona� usc. Priritcd Nam� Signature � n Clean��atrr Rexident aF Church $usines4 Cleanvaier A�izmbcr O�ti�ner [i' y � � �� ✓ �' � �.,_.-� � y— � � � ✓ �r� � �..�� / ��.� . �-�� E�-�� rr r E tiLC-. � .. �. � �� . I•.eYr ' i�%/�lcaT I�l . S'ri`Ffi '�c-cn c� ✓ � z.�- � � � � ✓ 6� Q'r � f � '''I • �.. Petldon In Op�►arltlort tv V�cr�:tivu o!';V��l:tclublRcstNUr,u�1 �P.iY1ilE_E�ls�lsll3� ��vernQCS Inrcnt tn C't�urrlt Pro�r��v WE, t11e i�ndcrsigned, ns �1cmb�rs uf th� Comtnt�nii�� Ai�d PQribluonL-rs of �Io1y Tri�iit?• Grt�k c3rt#iadux Churcli tocutcd a1409 Old Cuaclunnn Roudr Cl�anvater Florida cia ��crc��y cxnress ux�r �ssifsed vc�ice in a�spusi�io�i ta ,.�. tht propoaec! gr�nt ni'su� u�pZinalias� Por a ronciitional usc for tlae oprrAtios� uf a nightc�vblrettaur�ni �pcilisy c.�ning � �lco�3olia b�everagcs prese:�tly aiatrd tu br caltad "PJanel Bubf�a," �t a�ocasion that 'ss adjac4nt to the Chur�li t�cilities, Our appasilion i� based ort rnas�y g�ounda u•hicl� ity�luda; a) T1tat tlu proposcd cstabiizlvnrnt w�ill acrve aloohoSi� bzvcrag�; �} '�int thc propared estabtislss�tes�t �cisl bt �1i�ted with I+4r. Clem, alro knos��i as "F3ubbb � Lot�e . Spange," ar�d who ha� rncaurage� acis ofmoraf d�cadcnce for a�hicl� nth�r c�tAblisluna�jts in tha Cit�� oFCleara�atcr afliiiatcd wiih him ha�� sufferrd oo�nscquences; a) Tiiat t��c prior opc�ation of eimilar esta6liskuncsits resu��cd 'ui ridiQUfc of c[wrcl� in�.txtbcra durir�g rrlsgioue acrviccs; � d) Tl�ai 1hc ohur�h fac�lily alao bcrvcs as rt sohool faci�ity for scti�craS hundred Su�day ScE:aul Children and studerrt� of ihc Qreck Languagc, �t�ich activities aocur diuing tlic carly avcni�i� �ours ncar tl�c time of tradiiior�a! l�appy houts, givirig rise to substantial safcty concerns. :�s a cvmmunity we standtogc�hcr iti eppoaitiarE to thc �snnting aPthe prescnt xp�r�iatttion anc� cnskc oter voicr Mos�� to cacli of the m��bera af t��c Agcnc.•y r�iargcd will: rcti�ic�v oft]�c applioation fi�- coridilios�nl c�e. Prin#od Na�nc a �/ , ■ ■ _ i J A � � . .. .... R � I / / � �[ . � Signaturc � ' � �� / � � � �� r /.I � I A �. � S� �' 4 'I, ! � �� SS • � �a�iL�11�[ ��4:''tii �l3=:'�,DFS.V. .,t. .,. . .. . .... .. .. . . .., . . Clean��atrr Re�ident oF Churctt Business Ctear-�vater A•t�mbar Qis�ner .�._ � .�'' � ✓ �� [,.✓ �� Y �� C�_ � � � � _.t:__ �� v � � `�� f'eEidoi� in Opy�►onitiot� to U�crKti�t� aCNl�litci�bl�cst��u��wtt Set�;�i�'F coitellr_$ever �,.A<�,f3��L1�►..i fL�tt�cl� Pro� Y WL� tlu und�rsi�cd, ns h�tmb4te oftlya Comst�unit}� aiid Parisluoii�.-rs of Holy Thuit�� Grc�k �rthod�x � Clturclt �oaatcd At A09 (�!d Cuaclunan Rn�d� Clrarwattr Floridu du h�rt4�� prese our unsed voiae in o�position to the propased gani of an t�gplicatirn� for a conditionAt uca for tlia t�peratiut� of a nightclublrertat�runt Faeitity r,zre•ing atcofioiic tx�erages pr�sel�ify stated to i�e aaiied "P�anct But�ha," at a�oeatio:� i�i�tt is a�,��t to t1�e Chi�rol� t�oilities, Qar op�or;ition is bc�eed a� many grouncis whic}� inuludc: ,� a) That tlu propased establislunznt v�n11 scrve at�ohaliu beverAgzs; h) That thc prdpored establislunnit ��iti bc aBiliat�d with I�•ir. Clem, Also l:nn�� as "Bubl�n she Lavc Sponge," assd v� Ezo has ��tcouragcd ncts of mara} c3ecscd�r�:e for whicli othar estab#ish�ne�tis �n l��c Cit�' ofClcan�•uter �liaicd svitl� hirn hav� sut�cred a��ser�uaiozs; a) Tlint tl�e priar aperatian ofaiinilftr establishrnents resultcd i�i ridicula oPohur+cl> >ntmbers duru�g rrligious acrviccs; d} That ihc church fac�lity a�so scrti�cs $s a sc�tool #'aoility for strcra� hundred Sur�d�v Sc}iuu4 Children �nd atuc�crrts of tha C}reek Lar:guagc, w��ich activitics oocur thuing thc aarl}� cvrr�i�ig �ours ncar tlie timc of traditional happy �ours, �kYffl� flBC 10 SU�BtAllllii� 88FC1Y CU11CtCI15. A�{ ll q4111I11L1111tY WO 61R[lCl tOgCi��C1' 1!1 �]7]�81t10n tp Ij1C b'P811�tt1�' V�i�1C jli'C5Ct11 Hn}?il�u�{011 A11(I Z11A�{C OUT �'O1CC ]+iiOtiC11 tn ea�iti oft�c mccnbeis affl�e Agenoy ct�arged wit�i rcricw oftli� applioati��i for conditio::al usc. Printod Ns�ne Signaturs C4�ar��atcr Resida�t �f �hurcl� Busine�s C�e�nvster 14einber O��ner �r .�a�ri�r•c�r�r�� . .... . � t � � ► . � �� . . r �� n �'�a ? ca, � � -� � �1 � v�° � � � --�.! y �� V ✓ ✓ � �D .� �'� /L !� FY � � / � �'�� -�-1� � �� ,��/��► '� �� ✓ .�.! . , d� �� t� � Pctition In Oppas[tto�t tn Upet•,ittu�i nf NiwtttciublRc�ti�ut�t1 �CiYI1L.-��4L��ic �.�Y��pESa dcllnccnt t� �ft�t�rl� Prunrrlv �,• .� W�, tlie unct�rsigncd, As 1�icmULss uf tl�e Communit}' a»d Parislvon�'rs of �to1,y Tcii�it}� Gr��k Orthodu� Chureh loeatad at 401 Q1d Cuee3unan Raacl, Cl�arwater Florid� du lierel�y cxpr�re our uni��d �oic� in o�pusitiou to ,..-.� t3�c proposed grant af an npplic�at�rni for a conditionwl uee for the csperation uf a nia�itclubhestaur�nt fAai[it�� s�R•ir�g alcol�olic beva�ges presenlSy slated ta be �ut�ed "Planet But�ha�" at a�oaatsatt tltat ss adjACent ta thc Cl��r��l� ti�ailitie�s. eh►r oppogition is bused o�t m�uiy grounas ��liio2� inc�udr: a) 'Tl�at t��e propnscd cst�bli5lut�rnt un11 strvc alao��ofi� l+avcrages; b) That tUc prnpo�d tstablisEunent wilf bc aSiliatcd with i+Tr. Ctem, ulso l:na��ti us "Btj�bu t�u: i,ovc Sponge," and who has t�icouragcd act9 ofmorat circadrn..°e for whie�� otl:�r est�b�is3nnrn�s in iht Ciir ofC�csrtir�ter ��iatc� wid� h:m huL�� suff'cr�d cans�qua�c�s; a) `fl�at ti�a priar uperation oF6imilnr tstablislunc»ss resulted v� riclio►►le nf ci�u�1� inLm6ers c3uring rrli�ious acrviccs; dS That tho churoh i'aciiily a�sa scrtes as a sckool Fucilily fnr scvaal f�undrrci SuncWv Sc��c�u1 Cliildren arx! studcrrts of thc Qr+cck Languagr, which a�ivif ics oocur during tlic car]y ct=rniu� �ours ncar tlu time of tr$dilional happy hours, giving rign to substantial safcty convcrns. As a community wc ataiid togethcr in upposition to thc grut�ting af lfie presrnt appsi�ut ion and m�i:e our voic� �:notis� to cacfi ofthe mc�nbers aft��e Agcn��y� c��argcd w�th rcview of dsC a�pli�sti�cr fvr �or�ditioczal usc. Frintod Nsme � �A �4 u� �% ' , -� r�'� - f�ri� � �h��5 Rc�idtnl af Churc4� Clennvaicr A4zmbtr � � A � 4 � / � '1�� _ f� �_ -_ .__ __- ._ _ .. _ _ _ __ , __��-v v � � b� �s2.�f fv � � � .� ✓� . ,��1k��s-�o� . '_"�h r ---b� � _� Cl�arn�ntcr Husi[tc�s Q�izter � ✓ t/ � ,� Pctitio�� ln Oppo:��tion to Oper,ltldn of Ni�l�tclublRc�tnur,utt � WE� die iindersigntd, as hfcrnb4rs nftha Cornmun'st3' attd Parisltioners af Nofy Trittit�� Grazk Orthodox Church Ea:ated At d09 (7ld Cuaclunan Rnuc�, Clenrwatcr FlaridA du l��r�i�,y �xpress uur unified voicc in orposition td the proposed grant af a,� applivatian for a oonditiorial usc for t�tc �perp�io» of a nightclub/rertaurant f�oility rrn�ing �lenl�oiiv bevaagcs �resently cZated ta b� os►lled "F�ane! Bubha�" at a locntion t�»t is adj�cent to tf�e Chun:l� ti�cilitees, Our opposition is bas�d o�t marty grouuds v�l�ich inal�de: A} T1�at t�ie prapnsed estsblislim�nt r��ill srrve Aloohali� b��crAgts; b) Tliat tl�e propoccd ectablishma�t �t�ili hc �1i�ted with I►�r. Clem, �lso 1:no��n as "BuUbA th� LuWz Spor�gr," and uho h�a ��couragcd acts ofmoral d�cader�.:c for �vhicli nthar ctt�blisluneiits in tl�e Cit}� of Cicarw�ater �linted �vidi 6un tent�� st�crcd �oi�srquaicts: o) That t.he priar o�xsntion af similar establisturic��ts resullcd is� ridiaulc ofcit�nc�� in�rribcrs during srligious �crviccs; . d) Tha11�e church !'acility alsu scn'rs +�s a�cl�ool faciJity for scraal hundred Sunc�ay Solir�ul Childrrn and studcnta of thc Orer�; LanguAgc, v+iiich activitics occur �luring tSic earjy evrning hours ncar 11�c time of tradi�ioru�l ir�rppy haurs, givin� risc to ��6stan�inl sufet�� cvnccrns. As n caarmiunity wc stand tagctl�cr in o}�pasition to thc granting aFQic prrscnt xp�►liaatior� and �naiCG our voicc 1:no��ri to e�ch afthc membcrs nftiic Agenuy cl�argcd with re�'icw oft3i� applioati�n i'or eonditioc�al ase. Resicicni nf � Printrd Name Si�ufurc C1�nn��ater �� . I.G� `�? �' � � - �=. n � a '1 �•'c x7� � ��_t.��'i� , �� ,C � � �'� r� �.,�.'��' �`��-,,�� —� -�.— � ,r � �? .� � �—C�1� f_�. , „��c.. C �..:�...r�z��-, .-�.. �"11�� Cv ��1/ G �� =�w ,�� D �V.� � f�/.1 � , � r � / � u�/11' � ":11Ca�/0. l�id 1 Ci CNY+.� � �, . �� . � �� i ��,��.. �5 - - 4•_,�1''�.. ' ��ltLS� �{ f1%t � �I �j��(�j � �%%.t��/�,�t .i� � � � �n .��;�I,Z�s ;��.�` � �� , � � � � � � �,� .�- ��_ /� _�,,� ,�f . r� Clsuroli 11�1�mb{r � � � ,.�` , � � � �i� � � � �� . � ��c� ��. S "� ,�7 �� 1r.�� •.s�� ,,��; �� Ciear�v�ter $usin�ss �sz�er � �J ��C �i � ., i,' �'etido�► ln OpY►owillon ia Uperuttn�� o!' Ni�l►trlul�lRc�atiiursutt Scrti_i�y� dj�co��o�,��_I3e�srn�cs A41,j�c�y$.,t�Cl��!t�cii Proncrlv VVE, tlic uad�rsignzd, �s hlembLrs uf tli� Cosrununit}' and Parisluont•rs oFHaIY Tri»it}� Grcek drthodos CE�tt�ch lo.:�ted �tt 409 Old Coac�a�An Rnad, Cltbrws�ser F7orids� du htrehy ex��ress uur unified vuice in oppasition ta ,r the proposed gra�nt of an �pplivation for a�-ondi�ional use for U�a o�eratio�i of a stightclub/rectaurunt fncility s,.n�ing � ' alca��vlic beverages prrse�uly stated to be calfed "Pianet Btibha," nt a locntian thAt is �djar�nt to the Churcl� f�oilitier. 4ur oppoaition is Uaccd on many grounds w•hici� in�lude: n) Tiiat tS�e prop�sed establ'ss�un{nt u711 servc uicaholia hevcrnges; b) Tha! thc propo�ed c�tabtis�unrnt n�i11 bc afi'sliaLcd with I�4r. C1em, u3so kno��tii as "BubL�a th�: Love Spange," and wlta hss �i�couragrc� acts oFmoral ckeacies�ce For w•hicl► otlier establisluntnis in il�e Cit�� ofClean��ta �Iiatcd wisl� hiun hns� suf�'ered 4onszyut��c�s; o} T1wt d�c prioc ��xxatiaR aFsi�nilar esta6�isl�r�terrts resultcd �t� ridiculc nfcl�uncl� intmbers duru�g nligia�s strviccs; d) That thc churc� facilily also scncs as a s,choal facilit}� FcTr sc�'rral hundtcd 5unduv Schuol Chi�drrn snd studctzts of the Grcek l.a�guagc, r�fiich aclivit:es accc�r during tEie eariy ct�rnin� ho�rs ncar tlio timo af traditional happy haurs, givin� risc to substantiAl snfcly concrrns. . Aar a canununity we st�c:d lagct�:er in cpposiiion to thc srunti�� af thr ptcs�ryt aJ�:+liontion anc# �nskG our vaic+c 1sso�ti�n �o ea,cli aft3�e mctn�sers ofllte Agcn��}� ciiargcd witl� rcvicw oFt3i� applioatiou fcx cor�ditionnl use. Residtttt uf Chureh Printed Na�nc Signatuca Clesnvatrr �1�i�mh�r � . ��/ � • � � � n S`�'Q.�rc e, Je�^�^s� 5 � � t'� �� . �- `�� -�-� �Y�_�� '`'�� 1� �. .. � "�� 1 I •.r. �, V � ✓ V V V V � � � � �� Cl�an��ater Husiness O�tiner ,� � � , . �\�{` � ` . .1� .1 ' V • ,F , ' � . , . � . �, � ��,� . . „ . � � ��E . � , . . �� . � �. -s � �� rs .. �- . . f L � y o ��2 s� �rz.�e� s � � , � e �� "� r� ..�,' , �S , . � ��--�-- � � � .� � •� �,{,,,,`' 5 � �� .1, l� .�. : �' � : �G� ;� �v � � �{ �r. � /�/'�9� � � . �. . � . i�� , � . . � �...,�._ � � yc s �� : �� '. � � �(� � 7�- �,� ... —�' • ..� - . � . �- . . • �� ' :i • C;' ' _�.' ,, �� , .. �� • ., � . � � •��... • ,.. .'. � - . . • � • • d-..�L-.. . • , �� i � 1.. ' 1 L �_ . �� . � ' ' � y � . �� ...`��. . .4 • . •, . ' '' �,. � �� ....v, r ...,�:� �. �.:. . a . r, /� i• y I , :� �� .� �,..�'. .,.� av � �� • . . � !� E' �% yI S . d✓v „�'s �J-k �,�t _f�?�r�Ir� � rv� �a n� � 1�Lr1�.�� s' ,��,..�.., ls •�,� �1 � �'� S p Jf1� cI fiL�'T� ?�.s„�-�ctl �. � . ...�� s' , r�c �,� � � � �,F��, ._._.� + '+ � �o _.�O�d�l�� C � � �.. '-" / e �.Ls�. � 1�'5��3' �' 1� fi ti!(�+� c�� `Y .��1—" . _ : ._S� . � I'�"^�' � . �b � Np 0 i � , �. 1 � � � i M �..�.'� . �f � � � I : L L � �l .. �/ r � � . L'Lr , � J � � � �� . � � _ ,�� ' � �r � 1 � ' �` :� . L'�► � �� , ,�.,:...,,,, � ... . . ,��. ��. e�" . � � � . �s � �'�=s . � �.� . � s .� � . �Z � , �P �� ' --r,� � � � � ✓" •� � � � �I..�.�. ✓ ' : � � . . . • ' s, �� i"b-� . �—.� , ,� � • L . ! • � ' � r i . � , • . Ci • • . � • � � � . � �. . • .-�--� ---�- . � � N�� . � . ,� � d� orcL �l h�J 0 O, � � � a N n �rd �J, S M� r�T o� � � ��X�'1 r_�,�� l D r1'' . .� a � _ - - - � -��_ �...� � �l�s�� ,�. _ . � .� � � os �oln�c{��1�� ,� � �r �S �, �Q ` ��..�..,�. � �? .� Yl., . � l� �I , 7'��s ,8, �Y��,� � , • K # ��,�,,.. � ,, . �� ✓� r �' -� �.t,�`'"°u� � r � R . � ..•�' `+ r wH � � ' �.�_ � . ---- -�� . ' �� i'etitloit ln Op�wrtitlo�i tn Operntint� of Ni�hlclublRc�t��ur,t�it Scr��t ,�ca�o��.,a�rne�,�, �cs��.,�o �f�u�rh_71;or�rrl� �i i . • . _� � WE� ih� ►mci�rsi�ted, as I�iembcr� c�ftjtie Corsununity� nrid Paris�ucsi3��rs o1'Hofy Trinity- Gr��k Orthodax ' Ctwreh loeated at Q09 Old Cuaclunan R�d, Clcarwater Florida do itier�i�,y cxpress uur teniF�d voicz ia oppositiost to the propastd gaat of'�ri appli�Rtioz� foc a 4ronditionn3 use for t4ze o�erntia�t of a��iglitctublrectaurunt Cacility seR•ing alcolsalio brcer�gr,� prese�stly slAted tu be culled "Planet nub4sa," ut A locbtio» tl�at is adja�ent to the Church t�cilities. �hu opposition is iras�d on many grounds wl�ich includc: � � a) That t1�a praposed establisivnent r��ill scrvz alcoi�o3ic bat�rrnges; b) Tltal t�zc prnpo�eci r�teblisEuncsit �►�il1 bc �li�lcd v��ith A�r. Clom, also 1;na�«i As "&iti�4�a the L.ove Spange}" urid w•ho has ��icouraged acts ofmarel d�cadance for t�hic2: otlser eswb2isluz,ents in il�e Cit�� of Ctearu•atcr afl"�listed witl� hun hat� �uffcred aosiscqua�czs; a) iliat tl�c prior optration af sirailnr esteblistunc:�ts r�esultcc! i�i ridiculc nFclit��l: �rnmbers during rcligious scrviacs; d) 'I'k�a1 thc church !'acility �lso scrr�cs as a schoal faoilily fc�r :�c��rral hundred Sunduv Schuul Chi�dren �nd �tu@cr�ta oFthc Qreck Language, K�hich aclivities ocxur during tl�� early evrni��g hours ncar tlac � timc of tradiiionai happy hours, givins risc la su6stantial safet�� conccrns. A� a conutiunity we stasid iogatltcr in ap�osition io the p-a�:t'sng otihc prrscr�t ap�+liuution and mak� our voic�e l:nv�i�n to ca��i ofthc mcmbrrs oftltc Agcn�y cltiargcd wiih rc��ic�v oflll� �ppiicatian for conditsonal usc. •� , i r � � � � � i� �� r � �� ..,I� Rcsidtnt oF Cf�urot� Gleanvatcr \�izm6�r �� Cieantiaur Busipcss O��er ... . o�� . �� n �' ' � � �i � � � , , � ' � • � ; . , . ', ' � . . � . ; �. . . � ��`6 '. �� ,�, � Nh • � l � • . � - � , ' , ' f /•_w 4 � � '.� �'_.�:G� ' � _ �• � <�ROn� r 7i �,_„ � � . � � �� . , :-�- � � ' � -.� �- ' � . . .. _ . . . � � � . � _.,,�C'' v. ✓ 1�_� . a µ. ti !�: .r � � . � : . � . . ' � . � j.r�! t_ 'vrr �4— r�,1_ St�-N �r9,� � �i�, ��r.,.r,� _ � I�c1� . . . � � —�--- - . ;: , � ^ , •. • , . �. . • ., . . '. �" , • ' • ' rQ • � V , � • �� ' . ' . � y , . . . , � � . �•. . . —�� . . •• • , . ' � • � ' •M � . t • 1' • • . �� .� � . t/.. . � ..��r '��• . . . _]�._ .. ; . • : , Y � M . .. • . • � � . •' . '� . , •. . _!� ', r.......,_ �. / : E/ .,. i � 1. �.�s'1 i� i � .; _.+ � - �is� . : �� .% w � �` � : � 1 ► i. � � �. �� '�! �%� � �.:L��f�`7�' � � � -� ..(�� ,�'��.�f'�..,. � ` �...�� -� �i�a�.1��1�� - �.��.�.. , � OCn,CIr/i1S �77i2! S ' . , — � � � ' � �0 v j.� �/��i�h n' � ' ,� �1++� .� En�► � s : , . . r , .. � � ` � • A , �r� , � .. ' � ,r f � � , L �.,....1 � _ �. � . � ' « � ' • '`'� �:. . F.1 . .' , �. � ' . . � ` ,1 '.. � • , 1�� .... .� . ..• . . � . �� ,,� ,� � � ., � N . ,. � �� .' .•�� S � i11 . � . � � � . � y � ` .,. . . . J . , , � . . . . .....� �, � � . �� . � . � t � � � �:� , ' � � �� J � . . � � � � . _..1�� - . �� ' , . � ' � ' �,•, � � i , � , � N . , . ,..i ✓ • ,.� . . . . �. . . � � �,�—� I . . ., � • . � . , �• . / • I / .r� , , • . �/ - '� � , ' � r;� . / , � ' ' � t./ � ..�r��. • � � . ' � , , y t ... �/ . ' �• . . 1 , ' 4 ' � . � .� • . � . � � � �l a��G ut [� . ` �, , . ' ', I� . e ►�� o � S' •,: ; • , ' �.�._ • ; --�']r �' • � • �•� • . � .. . � ' `% :;.:' `' ` .. • ` . '. � - � . �--� , ' = I � ---1f�--�^� . , . . � �. �. . : �.. : , .� � ' /{f � • � �' •, ,f •, . 'f • I V , � � � �: �/ � �• � � . `.. ' '� .\.'� � � . � � .. �• .. :'p' � ' ' .F• '`' � + '�•*� � � , . . ., � � � ' � . � . .Q.�f �9� r� '�•� c.,J � !.. � OJ2� 0 m , �� . , ,� � ' ,', 'S 1• •,.... «'L'r.J r •.` , . .. : , ' ' . .., � , ! . . ` �' , ; �1,�'� � � � . 5 1�" . , . �, �. . • + � � , ' ;`;� . . • i. ' ` 1 N�i�` . , . ; . ' . , • • : '�� ' . . . • � • , . . .r� ? . ` , ��` , , ' : .r � �'e � � A � . � � . � � , ' �� =a�. . G'DG/7�� : . . • , :" •, ' . � �� , � � � � ' � * . . > � '.~ •�'i �� 51�iS._ , r, . ' �.� � V , � � � E r�N�-[- �r r��L .I C I� 2 I� 13EL� � �fl,�,� �� . � �. , ' : ' . • . . � ; ; � • �-.7- ;r- . . ' ' ' � . 4 � ' , . • � ' a ' � . . . . . • � . . ' � � ' � ' • � � � . ' . . � . � _ . . � ! . . � , . . 4 ' ' 1 ; ' • �. � •� � �= ' ' , �+�+� � • 1 � � � r . • . � � � . � . � . , _ ,' r . � . . ' . � ' . • • • ~, • � �, . .i'A. . • . , . � � . ' � f� . • �� 1 • . ' . . ' . ' �� • ti . • . .. � . -�: . • . '• � ' t . .. —� – — - ... . • .�. • " • •. ' �•• , ' . • � ' • . �•• � . � , . . • •i• � ' � • ,� • ' ' � .• ,. . ' � a��r ' ' S� , � . • • � ' r �� — — � � � . . .. . • , • ". . ; , : - � • - . r � 1� �– �w . ' . , � : . • 1 ! • . ' � ..• . " L i � . . , . , . .. . .. ,. ,: r � .� ' , . . . . . ,. , L - � � � . . ..S . . • . 1 . . ' . „ , ..� ' :� � � • ��,� ' , � � �� • r� — . . .. ' �''' • , . .�' '� �ti; : . � r :.� - • , , � , . 1. ' � 7.. � �.f. . .. . . : . _ _- _ . ' ' . , , . �1,'N y 4 ! �� ''.� . 4'J. , �. �• ; . , '. • . � . .) �. . . . .y . a , ��/7 • ' • � �rr • • ....�� , - ' ' . , , , �., � • , , �, ' .. �i ' .., � '��''' � : . ' ' . ''�� R . ► � �•' , ��N��'`� . . ; . � � 4� � f � ' . � � C %i f 1 . � � ,^' � � . � �� { r (� /� � .l . .,�� T/��.L�- L� : , �--1. .3. _. x � . . . � ' .�.�..�: � . '�f . . � ' '. :�- . � ' � � . . , � , . . i . . � � ' ' . ' �. i .� � , . �1' . � , • . . —�— �. . � � � ,r^�'� . � � , , � . �i . . . � . . . . �, .; �, � . - . .. ; �, • ; � �, , , ; .� .,. , , r, . .� . � .s - ,� . ; .�. ' . , : . � :. ..�� ,�� , . . i'.. � L� ' •�• . - . � • ! �, ;. . ' � . � , i • � , � � . . .! ' . ', 1� , ; � : • • ' • ' � : ,� ��``• �i,, �,�' ' ',, •. `. •`';. :y�'`'' � �.. � ! • ` . .. � � :f, � '� . ' . :?' s. , ' �� i •• e r , '.r• , , . f�� '�• ''� • � � � . • ' � • .' , j� � . , , �. � , r�� • . • '. ' •. � • � , • , ,', ' � � � . ' . � . :1. ' , • , � . � 1 , �+,' �, +.+..�:+r..`', • � • t V �' � . . . � . :, � , �. .• , ' • / , � � � t� • � � � ,�.J , � _'�1_ �n�� A � � ,� � � �� n � ,�• ,. . � ....... � �r� . / �� !� •.J , . �� l � . '� � � . . ,� . ,� �! ��¢ c y��,-,� � C��v ,��--iz �,1� t� �1 L 4 J� ,� t�e'� n ` - �. � • , � f• • ��i �" /��.� s•� ��c ,�,� �� r.4.�f c�l�- �%, G'rL t-'1�1 �,1 c��, f ��'� � . '� . � ._.... ,�''''',;p,.n�,.�,,,i�` �� R�� E � �� .� � ' � �� , �11N�a�� rL�;�r��c.,_ ' � � � � '� �� _� �X �• � �� .� � �� ..-- , � �� 1 -' _ .. �' . � � � � �� ., ��- .� � X � T �_ � � 1, , � �' '1 x � ,�� --�— � � � � �� . _ ,j,�,/►,� � ' 5{ �,,, �V � '"r , �, � �. -- r t� r �. r ;�- r -`"' - ��,:i �,t �- r� 17 •� � c� � r F? 5 ;�-1..,.. �•�i I�i''-,�,'��:�t,�'ur �' � ��i: ��,,,� ��l�'�� %% C � ,r1 Cc.� ��' c � ; ,: ,� �r � J � r. .._.�1 , . , � 1 � 1 � �C..J �� J.��' r�J 't ► S' �-�"'�'�'/T � _w� �� Z/ > 1 f�� L /t/J� %�� /- � � " '� �� L � -1 .� ,.��C� � 1�� y , `��.� /f i/i-� -� �%� ��:�v� � 7"� --� 1/1 � Y/� s f� ��:�r�� G � C�_,�#.P � . � .�� . ��•�i >�: �+.�� c ��1. 1°��?f�1L—i-5: � � �� 7.c'� ��S ' Cv�� . G�. � �_ �►,K �� t r.r� ', a�r.�� k- - L ' S ��-� � � � l GU ' L�..— _ 7`�i i� �� r/�S.r�rr. _ �'�'� . �f��f.c....�.-- � y�c�s'��.5 � '� S ..rC7� � � � ,� r f � : T�- K� %�,�1�1��vL,� ,��,�GG��3�,/1. ,_ r'''C ��.c'/L. . , �� i1 rv� �l. S?� ��- f n s�"�,. ti��-l� � � �Jr �., � c �'"� � 0 � 0 � � �� N ��`� ✓ � � � � � � x � �� _�... � � � .��` � r . � � . . � � �- �` , � � �. - . � ' ! � � �' � .� .� .� .� �� ,� �1 1 • � _ j,,�,l� r ✓ S 1�„ d��T�- � �r 5 f.7�s��ti�.,� /�7, �� ;�-� ,�. � � '� r: , 1 , !r � • C � r .i�, � J.�.il � �� r �J�- - - i i _ _ • t .. l -'•� • .�. �.. � �, s. �1�l��1�--s1��_ , � u � � � `:� L �, J � !. —�'�"��R�y�'..LS.— � 1 ��.�,r� � � �, �. �� = ; �: 5 �Ni�1� f �R��,�� r`if(' �� j�1� �S ol?ll;r-> C� �- r l� i�-rc��y11�� ± �� J , �� -c�. rJ _ �"��,��is i �h'€ C/a'?i�� .�.� � �` � z �, �� .� 5i=�-�Cy � _./",r��'iL�J iLC+ i1�� = �.��."� - �i,� `�'�' , �� 1��.,, J i-�l< <''�-��- i� �, �� . t?Lcr,�/ (�,j-�!'-� ;. ►'��L �..�t.�yZ,�,7� � C��.��r'. z lG�j-� ,�; ,�l l«�. �----- �� , �c7 '`� I /-1 /�' :% �� '�11- ��.� ,��[�+..rL� _'�T.. �" � �- � �' �tlt.� � �1 ��c►r1k � : ..a ��4�LL,t ' ' � 1� 9� �t � �� U 7�'1 s � �� .�f�-� �Y � k � �; � �� u,�� ( -�. � r ____ h'�'1 U �� ,�,1� �i r�� f% �� . G� C �� '�" � ,; . , , . : . . . . . . ��L.e,►�- . � � � � � �� r� � N�� , � --.�Y� �� .. �- � r� � , Z� ..�.,,t..� ` .. � �� i< �. C -� � � � � �� .%'C � � � �._ � � � � ,\,� �� ' � � � � � � � ?u � � � . _ ,j,u/►,U ,r� � -7 ,��,,, �v� � /�/ � J I S ��jLQ_�c''�tte'iC ± t .�. �� / = �r �/� %' I �� °'`�" � �r= "�.�' � C' lC~'� ��7/r.� 1�/ .f � --- —�� IIQ C� �1c'r.'��'%!`--� �I(�� 4��''.c�. �a ,_..�... ��T`�' �- � f-� � 1-f�� ,� ` � �.�: ►,r t .� """'� ' ,� �..�.,.� , �, � �ls.�t �'--=--�- �� E' � ;�(�._ _ _,---=--.�. c. . � [� �., �!'%1�rla..�r +�r(Z� :61 :JI��'/;fi� L!" r,t..r.r. �C ______ ��' Lr ,r? �,,��_!,' �� !' C'�s � /.� � � / - ___��_, �� G P �„� f � � ! �/�'i? 1.5 J � � ! � � rr p / �� ,•- �� /' , G fj��L.c�r; f ['r[�r�. f � i s . l � [. �j�-�+ �e �(.� /✓-r,._ _�� i� �n� rrr .. _��_sdc'��: t I'�»?--� % �1� ��h � �' � J�A %.5�� S/' C' ��'u 4fr. �.K,eti.. ,��' �� -�-�-�CS��1'11S �.�4�- c.c�% '"�� 1S�L �t� j S��o�tl��s � �c v� , �, � ��P�7� �� R- /��l�i��z�i/%S ��C �'� �ct � % ^ _ � , �!/ItGr �I`� � � �-(? � ��[�� ,� �,I fy r� ///± �} � �Q��'� ` ��lF✓ ��'l. '�tLf� .'i � 1.��/ Y�L��, � � ' �S . �/ [i�e} "'ti �� . � , . �� r �l�i� � M.e � .rt�s2'.�C ��R6 . � � � f � �.��c,.��.1�r.1'�i,G,�S �� i��-�.� ��z��,�%ti��C�s w � � �.� �X� n}�� I I�� c/�16�r%C 43�r .7�/ � �:;� -�� ,��%�.� lc� G�'�L� .. • � , .�! � . -. � . � ' �� . . ' � t� �� .. ..�„� V � . � ; • r� � • � � ; � � '� .� ' ; � �� • � r .��.,��..✓ ;.,,� ,. .. . � V ; ;�� : .. , v . . . - . , ' �� . .� .;y. �, ' S V � .� • " • � � .i • . . • �` . ''i• + � . � ,' . , '�`. .`, ' . , '�:�,.� ' � . '• �. . � .� � r� � . �!' . , � � : � .� .. .. � . �• t . . � � ' .T�' ' • � . ��... . . � � • • , • ' , j y • � . . • F . . • '�„� �. . . � ,�:.; ' . . �' . '��'.� � • � �1• , ' I� . . , � • �. • ' •� . r . � ,i �._ , . 1 . I ' . ' . , . . . . • � �� I. ' • " • ' ' � � � � � .. /J R1��.w�i . '' ' ' F . 5 �� r t/�L �� r'I�1N�A.� _ � �1�.� � ` �_� r� .. A f1�id � 1�t � UI 0 � l� n� b n n(1� A i��f �e � o � ��► �L� f i r � � � � . i � 1 � . � �... -.� � � � 1 • �� I► �. . �I� r � r . �'��.� _ � f ►��r�; ��. ~.•~ I;a .�I _+� �'J ♦� � / . � � �A,� � �/ � �� . � •-- �- — -- i - - � %. � ,. V -� /�:� �w ;a.� ��/ � � I ' �� , . . . , � . �� 9 � , • , , . • � 1 1 ` � , .� � ' ' � .A . . . ,��,�,^�`' � � . � . , � ��,,E S . � � �� . � � � �� .� .' �. � �� ✓ , � � . � . '�"_"� :� :r;' � '• '. ' � �+ �: � • F�'•�,.''+:3' �.f1 �... ��:, � .`.- �, • 'r ; • . ; : , •� .; . . . . , ' . ' ' �" , V� . . ,. . (/ � .. �. . � ::;. :�.. �': ,. •�: . i� .� ✓ � ; � � � � � , . : ��;t'�� .,, ��- . .. � .. � �� . � �r. � . . � . _ :F��_.:.� . . . , . _ �: �L.�� . : �v� � . �.. � ��„ � � . � �; , < i: � .-�--:. . .... ., .. . � � � � � , , -..�,..� . . ,;• , , .., ,_ . . . . • �• , j? .,l.! : ,�-'' .•; •;:�r : . . . . ' • ' i • , � . � � .•, . • •,Ji� , ' � �..r.rr � � � . � � •� �� ,'�� .� ;';. ,. �� .� . ♦ • • �� . `/ . f! _..�L��.. ,��'•,,��1f ' •� 1/ ""�'�"' � � �VUyS14J�211�i4i.hii.�:, s' t .ra.art • . . . . _ C�r� c� 1�-[�C� c�.u� �,�.�'� e. --. _ �_ . , �ICI�L_,� ..� . _%7'� C r a i'� _ -- ,� - ��qC. i a v... ... �±�rs C1 � � ..Q,.� � � � K _ � P�.�r� s �. - �- n v� � - P�- � 15 � �'1, - � � �� c � . f ,�'�[1?2 � �- _ , _ _. _�1 l , �.� -�� E ' - �-•—..�.. • �'l1 �.. A�w1 � . � l• ' � � ..:_. ��r��-.� .S ��., �� . : �. �; . ' * . �t.�t z l�'� IU S � 1 t ��'�%' .C�=Y�-�' .. ., • . ,�. .., _,. _ _,.� � � + �� '�� . . ' .. � .�. CL' � �� d�-: . .l �X �'�..,r -t-�-�_.��d'yY'LYf l.t,�'. _ . . ' • . ��% C,�-�C,'7`�:� �-�'-�"'C- l7��.'�, , , r ' ' . � !� li � }.'u (,'�.-� � / . . � , A• � s .+ � . swi► P� ,� � , 1 ��. �.s.��s / �' r . •': i � � � 0 a , ,. * � � i �' , . ' • . ' . . � ' �� ✓ . �/ ....� � R►��'�,� N �' � �� . . '`�� ✓ -�/�/�ci,��b�%� � � � • �-.''� . ��,�� a..��.,,�. - . ' ' ,; � �o�"J �•`�� ,� . . ; ; +/� V ''" I 1� Qa u -c zU� �+� s � , � V V 1v 1�PT, i'�o �U �a k}S ;� �CNf4�L ��(CJGr4 �� C � ' .. . • �/ � � �� ✓ . �.T �� P,�� s , .�. • �: � � .� L' p�" ��s � _:; .. ,/ - � �� ...c...�S � ' ✓-� � ✓/ �° i �S 4 r!1 . J. `, , � � : : � ,�/ �:_ S �r� �. � , ' i. ' . . ! . �r ,1 �. • . � . • • • ' � • ' � � ' • 1 ' V � • � � � � � � : � � � ✓ � � � ti�rfs �n, . . . �. .� . .�/ �.. �,. � . ;� � ��cA�-��2� � �• . '; � �rr►�► Z � �rn� s � � ��. �� L �. . .' : . . ...,, /`.� :�� , � 57� N�) � �L�! f� �� ,S , � ' � � � ,/'' . � � ,.j' C � � i_ S � � � ✓ � � � �C� , � ...�.' . 1 �, 1 4 ., W' :�.J � ��1 � �-�i�T �C-��L � . • �J-�� / l� � Pet�tion In 4��oalt�an #a Oprrs�tlon aT Ni�Iftcli�blRcstuur��tit SNt��tnQ :�cohoiic Be��e es ,�}j�,�hnt ta (:1� • ' r ti�' WE, ilte uadcrsigtt�d, �s ��icmb�rs ofthc Communit,y and Yaris}i'saners of Elol}� 1'ri�iit�� Vrr��: Urthc�du� �,,,s Church located ut 409 41d Coacfunan Raad, Cl�anvat�r Florida do lt�rzba� express uur �ulifiLd �•�i�� iil uppusili�� tha prapos�d grAnt ofan applic�tion for a condiiiona! �tsc for th� op�ration of� ��igl�tclub.�r�slau,•=►»� t�cslit�� scn�i��; alcaholic bevcrag�s presently s4at�d to b� called "PIA11Ct B4lU�?8,�� iL A iOCAtIOri t�ltii l5 tlC�fBCZllt �U lll� Church faciliti�s. Our oppositioci is bascd on many graunc[s whi�li inolud�: a} '�t the propost.ci cstmblishm�i3t will serv� alcoholio bev�r�ges; b) That thc proposcd establis�un�nt wi16 bc affliatcd with h�ir, Clem, also l;��o«m as "Bul�l�F� th� Loti�� Sponge," and who has encourag�d a��ts ofmorul decadence for H�hich at4i�r �st�lilisl�n�iits isi th� Cit�� of C1Carwat�r �iiatac� with him hai�� sufftred cansec}uen��s; o) That th� prior operation a�'similar tsEablishmenis resutt�d i�t ridicut� af �;hur�h m�mb�rs during religious sarvic�s; d) That thc church facility also srrves as $�cttool f�cility for scvcra� hundre� 5ut�dA}• S�}�c�c�l Gl�i�dr�� and stud�nts o�tho Creek Languag�, ��hich activities occur during tlz� �arly avcuing ho�srs ��ear tls� timc oftcaditional happy hours, giving rise to substantial s�'�t�• ca�aerns. As a community we sta�td togethcr in opposition to the gtat�ting ofthe presznt applicAt'san und ma�:r our �•oice l�fo�� z to eacla a�tha m�mbcrs ofth� A.gcncy chargad witis review oftha ugp�ication far conditionRt� us�, Printed Namc � ► �'� / i / ' . � .�. :r ._ �...... �1�• r � ' . _. �► il/ I i: l� �' U ^ � �! L1 /L � %1 � . . ..,1 � t� � .� , � � ,, / • ir ,. Itcsid�nt af Cl�us-c:l� Clearwat�r i�i�mb�r � � : %'TO �S � � �J � �� _ � vt5 r�-- � J'l.l.�.. "Y F•S Na C' � /� � -r`�`'`�. � . �_ � /�U L`!-�.�- �� o C`lrur►r�it�r kiusi�y�ss U�rtt�r .. ��i--. /�� _L..�L..f �S _L''f2. ��L NU -�`�- � �� Pctilio�i ln Oppos�ilon to Opc:�ntlon of Ni�i�tclu�lRrstnuraiit �,�� A1co[�oiir Qcver�ge� �jnccni io Cftu��ctt Pt�Q�t� r*� WL� tlie undersignad, As I�4tmb�rs of th� Cnmmunit}' und Psrisluon�rs of Ha[y Tri��it�� Gr�ck Ortl�odus ' 1 Cltiurclti located at 409 Ofd Conclunart Rr�ud, Clcarwater Florida do I:ertby cxpress uur un�ed voicc in oppc�sitiot� to the proposed grant of a�i �pplitatirn� for a��onditional usc for tl�e ��cration oi`a nightclublrcctaurnnt fucility cen ing alcalwlic treverages prese�it]y slated to br wl1�d "Planct Bi�hl�," at a location thnt is ad,�acrnl to thc Ci�urali tnoilitieg. 4ur appasitia� is based un mar�y graunds u•hia�� inuluds: � �� n) 'Tltat tlte propusad ��tebli�h�ntnt v��i11 scrvc s�lcoltoli� bat�tragts; b) Thai the propoted ,establisluna�t �viE1 bc a�iiiliated with A�r. Clem, ulso krio«�r As "Buht�n the Lovc 5pangra" anci w�tio has ancauragcci act� of moral c�rcadenct 1'or which othzr r.�tnbi�swntnts in ihc Cit}� oFClean;ater agiliated with him hat�c gufferc� cons�quaic�s; . o} TI�t the prior o��lion oFaimilar estublis�tmcnts resultcd in ridicule of ahurch tn�mbcrs dusing rtligious acrviccs; . d) Tha# thc ohUrch �'aciiity aiso srrvcs as a school faoility for sr�•cral hundred Sund�v Scliuul Gheldren s�d studrrds of ihc Cireek Laaguagc, which activitics oxur during thc c�r1s� c:�rriing hvurs near t�re time af tradi�ional hapgy hours, giving rise to auhsiantial sufcty conccrns. .4s a oanmunity wc atnnd togcther in oppoaiiion 10 the granting aitho presertt.rp�+ficsssan arid rnakc our �oicc l:no�ti�n to eacli oft4� mc�nbcrs oft3ic Agency charged wi11i reti�icw ofllia appliaatio�� for conditionn! use. Prisited Nama Signature Cltanv�ter Rtside�ji �#' �hure4� Business Cl�nrrvater A4e�nber �iner �[-� � � ✓ V � _.� ' _�! � - � � � � � � v G�� i �- � s�� 1 � Prt�iio�� in Oppogltlpn to Opci•��tioi� ofNigiitclu�/Rcst�:t�r�ii �n��ttg r9l�al(r_Bevrr��cs,�,��lt�rrnl #Q_Cl��rr�i��t�,l�L'L 'r' WE, th� i�nd�rsigned, us hicmi��rs �ftli� Corrununity And QarisEuoncrs of Holy Tritsit}' Groek 4rthodux Ciiurch looattd ut 409 (71d Conclunan R�d, CLearwAtcr Florida do h�rtl�y cx�ress uur ur�ificd vnicc in oppositio�t to ,.—� 1he proposcd grant of an applivatirni for A ��andition�i usc for t��t c�pesucion of a nightctut�/rertaur�nt Faci2ity ctn�iRg °' n�ao�tolia bever�ges prceently FtAted to be �a11ed "F�anct Bt�btui," at a locntiot: i�i�t is ac�jas�s�t to thc Cl}ur�:h liscilities. O�ir oppo�iiion is baseci on matty gra�nds w•l�ic�� 3i�elude: a) Tlsat tlse propused cglablislun�nl u`fII StfVC A�I:O�IO�I�I tld\'Cfil8t5� b) That thc proposcd c�tahlisiuna�t ti�iil i�c aHiiiated ��iih I►4r. Clcm, Atso knoc��n as'Bistat►� the Lot�c Spange," and u•iio hns �ncouraged �cts ofmora� d�c�dcrn:e for wiiiol� othtr ertnbl�si�nen�s in the Cit}� ofClcsru�uta �Iiatad �vitl� hi» hn�� suffcred oonst4up3c�s: o) 'I'I�atthe prior operation of simil�r esta�lisluncnts resultcd 'ut riciiaulc afolturcl� �n�mbcrs during rcligiouq ecn►iccs; d j Th�t thc church faci2ity also scn•cs as a school facifi�y fur �sc��cr�! hundrrd S�ndav Sclioo] Children snd studcnta of#he C�rr.rk Langu�g�, vr�hich a�livitics nceur during tlie early evrnazg ho�rs near tiu iimc of trnditional hAp}sy hours, givin� risc to substami�l safcty concerns. As a aonununity we staiid 1ogclher in opposition to thc granting af thc Qrescnt :�p�+iic�lio� and �t�e�Ce o�r �biee Rnotii�n to cacii afihe mc�nbcrs o: t3u Agcr�c.�y� ct�arged wit�t ret7ctv oft��a app�iQalini� f'vr co�clitiont�l ust. � - ,�. ��a /%e Cf<arn�eter Reyidczli of Chusah Business Clc�nvater A1amt�er O�vrier � ✓ �� . _. __._1..�' 1.�.�� 1.��/ ,__. ..�._../ ..� -., �. --� ,�r -�. � �� ._ ✓ ✓- �• . � --{�- `..�.. �L,,.. t�' _,�G. fi� �..r�' a �SUGGESTED CONDiTXOI�IS OF APPRO�AL (should the Commission choos�e to approve the request}; 1, Th� applicant shall obtain the requisite occupational license within t�n days o#' d�e date of this a}�peat hearing. 2. The app�i�ant shall neither pramote nor pemut on the prcmises any live �nter�aixament, Compebitions, contest�, or any other actiwities that violate �he public nudity or adult use regularion ordinance� {Se�tion 21.�3, Code o� O�dinatices, and Section 41.GC?�, Cod� of Q�edinances, respect+ve�y}. In particula:; the applicant shall neither promote nor pemiit `�vet T-shut contests," b�ini contesl� or male/fem�le revsews in violation of the public nudity or adult use ordinances, or sim�ar activities on the premis�s. 3. There shall be no outdoor entertainment, including temporary outdoox enterta�nme�t 4. The sale of alcoholic beverages shall be limitied to consumption on premises with no package sales. 5. A landscape p�an for all parking lots shall be submitkcd to Environmental Man�g+ement for approval. and any required landscaping shall be installed prioz to the issuance pf the requisite �'occupational license. G. Prior m the issuance o� the requisite occupational license and openulg of the �]U51t1055� the applicant shall provide overflow parking generally sufhcient to meet the tot�l parking required under current City parking requirements through a long term agreement wi�h F�orida Power or other sim�lar arrangament suitable to the City. 7. A minimum of two security personnel shall be provided to police th� pazking lot between the hours of �0:00 p.m. and 3:00 am. on Friday and. Sa�urciaay nights. S. 'This appmval shall be for a nine month trial period from the date of issuance of the occupationai license, after which the application w� be reviewed fo� compliance with t�� established conciitions ofapproval. C1TY COMMISS[ON SPEC[Al. MEETING CITY O� CL�ARWAT�R May 14, 1997 Present: Rita Garvey • J. B. Johnson Robert Clark �d hiooper Karen See) �lizabeth M. Deptula Bab Keller Pamela K. Akin Scatt Shuford Sendy G�atthorn Steve Doherty � .. Patricia O. Sullivan MayorlCommissioner Vice-MayorlCommissioner Commissioner Commissioner Commissioner City Manager Assistant City Manager City Attorr�ey Central Permitting Director Central Permitting Manager Central Permitting Super�isor Board Rsporter The Mayar called the meeting ta arder at 7:00 p.m. at City Hall. ITEM #1 - Ap�eaf of Pfannina & Zoninq Board Decisian Case No. CU-97�1 fi Equator. inc. Tiffan Witdar Butter BTLS �ntertainment Inc. Planei Bubba CF�ange af Business ., Ownsrship at 2516 Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard Dn Augusi 29, '1995, the Planning & Znr��ng Board approved far this site at 251 fi Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard, a conditional usd fo� a nigY�tclub� tavern, or �ar called Jam'x N Java. City records indicate the Occupati�nal License ior the property expired 5eptember 30, 1995. On April 1, 1997, t�e Plannin� & Zoning Board denied the request for a conditianal use appro�al far a nightclub, ta�ern, and bar with dancing and pre-recorded music for �quator, I�c./Pianet Bublia. Centra! Permftting Qirector Scott 5hutord indicated the sits tradit�anally has 3�ad a nightclub use. Many nightclubs aperated on the subject property during the (ast decade. Ths use is non-confarming due to parking requirements. The site has 206 parking spaces on site and r�nts 60 spaces from the abutting Tampa Tribune praperty. Staff recomrnends approva! based on 8 conditions. Mr. Shuford said the use shauld nat impact negatively on surrounding praperty. Tonight's hearing is an appeal of the P�anning & Zaning Baard's April 1, 1997, decision to deny the change of business owr�ershi�. Th� City Attorney recei�ed the tap�s and mi�utes of the Apri# 1, 1997, meeting iExhibit 't ). �d Armstrong, representative for the applicant� said the Pianning & Zoning Baard's decisior� was noi based on evidencs, departed from the requirements of iaw, and reflsctad a#�ersonal bi�s against Todd Clem iradio personaltty, Bubbaj. Under questionifig by Mr. Armst�or�g � Mr. Shufard said staff's recommendatian for approval was based on the site's locatian, a review af surrounding propartias, and previaus an-site activities. Staff currently is drafting revisions to the code. He said staff's recommendatian to amend the cade and permit the transfer of ownership af businesses serving alcahoiic beverages withaut requiring a conditional use was based an aRly 2 denials of 40 requests since '� 994. The msp05a97 i �a114/97 � -..,.. . ... .. _. .- --- - . , � _ . .. . _ �. . ... .. . . . .. ather denial was a�pealed to the City Commission and reversed, He sa�d this code requirement is unusual. Ciridy Hard�n su�rnitted her resuma (Exhibit 2) out�ining hsr 1 fi years as a practicing piar�ner. The City Attorney verified Ms Harden had worked for the City of Tampa and, is an expert. Ms. Harden presented an aerial view of the US 19NIGul#-to-Bay Boulevard intersectian, statirtg it is one of Pir�eflas Courtty's most �;�mmercfa� ir�tersections. The subject praperty is in the intsrsectian's Northwest quadrant. 5he nntec� abutting and nearby properties have intense commercial uses and the area serves more than its immediate neighborhaod. She said the subject propsrty's proposed use compiies with the standards of approv$I and potential impacts are mitigated by ti�e property's design which orients the huilding to Gul#-io-Bay Baulevard. She said patrons cannat access the abutting chu�ch property ta the Narth from tF�e nightcicab's park�ng lot. The business' operating hours arid Conditians will 6e the same as the previous 5 uses since February 1988. Mr. Armstrong submitted minutes from the October 16, 1990, Fabruary 5, 1991, May 3� 1994, and Aug�st 29, 1995, Planning & Zoning Board meetings reporting appro�als of changes of bus�r�ess ownsrship far the subjeci pro�erty and previous lack of opposiiior� {camposite Exhibit 3j, in response to a ques#ion, Ms. Harden said th� previous f��siness� Jam`z N Java, had an agreement to use the West side of Florida Power's easement for parking. Mr. Armstrong submitted: 1}�'ss April 25, 1997, letter ta Rev�r�nd Father James Rousakis� pastor of the Holy Trinity Greek Orthodox Church, 409 Old Coachman r�aad, requesting a meeting #o respond ta Church abJections (Exhibit 4); 2y t�e April 30,�'1997� reply from the Church's legal adviser, Michael �. Bautzoulcas, indicating fundamental differences "are near impossibte to overcame" (Exhi6it 5j; and 3) Mr. A�mstror►g's firm's M�y 8, i 997, r�ply to Mr. Boutzoukas requesting a meeting with fihe Church Parish Council to discuss issues such as hours of aperation, security, etc. {�xhibit fij, Mr. Armstrong said the Church was ur�respansive to the May 8, 1997, letter. He said the applicant has tried ta work in gooci faith as a neighbor. Ths applicant, Todd Clem, AKA Bubba, said his raciio persanality is no� w�o he is. He gave his "'word" the business would maintain the praposed conditions. He said the area Resds a nightc��b to serve those 2� years-ald and oldex. The business will feature happy hour, a restaurant, cigar room, and dance fioar. Mr. Armstr.�ng submitted the May B, � 997, letter from Michael Meidel, Florida Power North Pinellas Area Manager, indicating Florida Power was processing th� Application for Rig�t-nf-Way Utifizatior� for use af a portian of the transmissian carridor for parking (�xhibit 7]. In response ta a ques#ion� Mr. Armstcong said hetween 130 and 150 �ehicles can park ir� the easement. Mr. Shuford will verify the number of park+ng spaces required far the proposed use. Mr. Armstrang said his client has the right to request a parking variance. In respanse to a questian, Mr. Shu#ord said previous uses have had noise violations. ln response ta a question, Mr. Armstrong said the property was in foreclosure when Maurice Wilder of �quator, Inc. purchased it in 1990. Since then, varinus tenants have operated nigf�tciubs on this site. It was noted the porch had been snclosed since the bu�lding's previous use as a restaurant. msp05a97 2 05/14/97 Mr. Shuford stated police reports indic�te Mr. Clem was the disc jockey at .lamminz' on Cfearwater besch when patrans were cited for violating the public nudity ordinar�ce. Mr. Clem said he made those appearanc�s while under con#ract with a radia statian and was directeci by the business' owr�er regardir�g the contests. Although several wamen were cited for exposure� he said he never was charged with inciting those actions. He said his club will not have those types af contests nr that type of atmosphere. ln res�onse ta a ques#ion, applicant Tif#any Wilder Butler said inappropriate activities will k�e banned, In res�onse to a question, Mr. 5huford will re�ort when Tattletales opened on the site of the former Hardees. Mr. Ba�stzaukas submitted: 1} the May 'i , 1997, tetter to the City from Thomas Lor�g, representatfve of BTLS, Inc., indicating BTLS was assigned the autharity to resume the Jam'z N Ja�a business operatian fln G�If-ta-Bay BQUlevard {�xi�ibit 8y; 2j the License Agreement betwean Florida Power and the Greek Orthodox C�urch of tY�e Hofy Trinity� Inc. regarding use of the right-af-way for o�erflow parking and sttrub fencing CExhibit 9); 3� the Macch 2E, 1997, letter to Mark Lagos, Parish Counci! President, from Patrick Frankie, Ptanat Bubba General Manager, indicating the club pians ta hast calendar girl cor�tests, and affering to r9pair t�e fence separating the properties ar�d to discuss cl�sing the club during the Church's annual evening Easter celebration (Exhihit 10j and 4� the Church's May 4, 9 997, Gen8r�1 Assembly Meeting minuiss indicating op�osition to the nightc�ub {�xhibit 9'11. He said a petitian signecf by 700 Church members �pposing the nightclub was submitted to the April 1, 1997, Planning & Zoning Baard meeting. Sam Marcop4los submitted photographs of damage to the fence between the properties, �ars from the nightclub parked in the Church's lot, and empty beer bottlss, cans, and trash in #he Church's parking lot (composite Exhibit 12j. debarah Aowal, Ed Santiago� Laurie Dacey, Peter Wilsey, Steve Del Sota, Mike Schaffer, Heather Habora, David Doherty, Craig Cursteen, Jeff Zerin, and Ron Kateze spoke in support of the application stating the Church located next ta this site, the Gulf-ta- Bay BoulevardlU.S. 19N interseation is h9ghEy commercial, the pro�osed use is consistent with the praper`Ey's cammercial zoning, the tax i�ase r�eeds expansion, the rights of free enterprise, churches anci businesses shoulci wark tagether, the law will 6e abeyeci, the nightclub senc#s intoxiaafsd patrons home in taxis, Mr. Ctems's radio persanaiity is an act, and an offer to clean up resulting trash. Reverend Father James Rousakis, Mr. Boutzaukas, Dan Andriso, Mike Masteridis, Sam Marcopalos� Jaan Camboros, ar�d Bill Katseknpdis spoke in opposition to the application stating moral principals are at stake, social consequences will occur, the nightclub misrepresented its agreement ta park on Florida Power's right-of-way, parking conditions ha�e not been met, the Church and school will be r�egati�ely impacted, tF�e nightclub endangers parish children and is a bad influence an teen parishianers, the nightolub's lacatian is �nsuitat�le, and inappropriate nightclub patron behaviar includes jeering parishianers, droppir�g trash, ctimbrr�g on and ruir�tng the Ch�rch's tence, ar�d wanderin�# through the Churah's parking 1ot. msp05a97 �'+y�.� ..'1'.;.-l•w..a...i. ., ,. , ... . . .. . .,. .-.. . " 3 05!'� 4197 Neighbors Russ Hunt and Joseph Ryan requested the City monitor the nightclub for noise violations and patrol at closing to discourage patrons from drop�ing trast� in nearby neighbarhoads. The Commission recessed from 8:52 to 9:�6 p.m. Mr. Frankie� F'lanet Bubt�a General Manager, said he had pro�ided his telephone and beeper numbers to the Church. He submitted and showed a video of Church members parking in the nightclub's lot durir�g Sunday servic�s {Exhibit 13). Mr. Frankie, Rick Silva, Wilfis Reese, and Tina Meadar spr�ke in sup�ort af the application, stating most patrons arri�e after Church activitiss, bums are responsible for trash, patrons cannot be con#ralled, ar�d entertainment in Cle�rwater is needed. Nick Anton, George Manzeras, Jeannie Antan, Aphrodite Merimac, Canstantine Milerades, and Peter Caf#entzis spoke in oppositian ta the application sta#ing the Church must abtain a liquar perrnit each time it serves afcohol, abscen�ties from nightclt�b patrons embarrass families, laws should protect citizens, past retaliation against Church members occurred after illegally parked rrei�icles were towed, and Clearwater L�each and Morningside nightclubs, determined to 3�e nuisances, were clased. In response ta a question, Mr. Shufard said legal staff can confirm the Florida Power agreeme�rt with the nightclub far parking is long t�rm. He recommanded a reporting requirement be instituted to assure the club adheres to the agreement �or tY�e iife of the business. The business can seek other ways to address #he parking requirement. The City Attorney said t�te Iiquor license can be revaked if the business fails ta meet the parking c�ndit�ons. Mr. Shuford indicated previaus nightclubs probably did n�t meet the parking requirement. It was i�dicated the Church's agreement for use of the Florida Power right-of- way for ingress is separate from the right-of-way agreement for parking. Overfl�w parking lots are not required #o b� paved. Concern was expressed minutes from previaus Pianning & Zoning Board meetings subrr�itted (composite Exhibit 3) do not reflect oppositian to previous applications. Church members indicatad they had spoken against the nightciub at past Plannir�g & Zoning 8oard meetings but were unsure of the dates. Ir� response ta a qusstian, Mr. Shuford did not know how many cars can be parked on the right-af-way. Mr. Armstrong said the previous nightclubs l�ad agreements with Flar'sda Pawer for averfiow parking on the right-af-way. Ir� response to a questian, Mr. Bautzoukas d4d nat know if ti�e assessed value of the Church praperty had changed since the nightc�ubs began operatian. It was noted police reports i�dicate violatians occurred at previous nightclub b�sir�esses operated by Ms. Butler since 1990. It was noteci a restaurant operated an the subject property when Church constrUCtian began in 1888. The c�trrent liquor license has been in effect since May 2D, 1965. Mr. Armstrong said the Church constr�ct�d improvements and additinns in 1967 and 1990, after the property's cf�ange to a nightclub. He expressed concern a Planning & msp05a97 4 05/14/97 �� Zoning Board member t�ad stated opposition to Mr. Clem as an individual. He said the Planning & Zor�ing Board previously had appraved nightclub uses for this site 5 times. In response to a question, t�e City Attorney indicated the City Commission must consider this request as a transfer of ownership and not as a new use. She noted no expert testimony was presented that addressed praperty values. It was recommenrfed the nightclub keep the prQperty clean. The police shauld handle vioiatians. The City Attorney said the liquor ficense can be revoked for non compliance with the conditians. ln response to a question, Mr. Cfem reiterated his promise to camply with the conditions. Concern was expre�sed regarding legal issues related to allegatians of prejudicial comments made by a Planning & Zoning Board member. Staff was encouraged ta be vigilant regarding the nightclub's campliance to canditians ar�d ta enfarce irregularities immediately. It was haped the nightclUb and Church reach an amicabie agreement regarding Greek hfllidays. It was r�ated the Ci�y Commission cannot set new standards tonight as Lhis meeting is quasi-judicial and not legisEative. Concern was expressed previaus minutes do not refer ta citizen oppositian or approval of items. It was felt the police report provided the Commissinn contained insufficient detail. Commissioner Ciark moved to �pprove the change of �usiness nwnership at 251 fi Gulf-#o-Bay Baulevard subject to t�e following conditions: 1 i applicar�t shall obtain requisite occupational licer�se wii�in 10 ciays of date of this appeal hearing; 2j applica�t shall neither promote nor permit on the premises any live entertainment, competitians, can#ests, ar any oiher actEVities that �iolate th� public nudity or adult use regulatiort �rdinances {Section 21.13, Cade of �tdinances, and Sectior� 4� .fi01, Code af Orclinances, respectively}. !n particular, applicant shall neither pramote nor permii "wet T-shirt cantests," bikini contests, or malelfem�le re�iews in violation o# the public n�dity or adult use ardinances, or similar acti�ities or� the premises; 3j t�ere shall be no outdoor entertainment, including temparary outdoor entertainment; 4i the sale af alcohafic be�erages shail be limited to cansUmption on premises with na package sales; 5j a landscape �lar� for a!I parking lots shall be submitted to �nvir�nmenial Management far approval and any required landscaping shall be installed prior to issuance of the requisite flccupational license; 6) prior ta issuance of requisite occupational license and o�ening of the business, ap�licant shall provide o�erflow parking generaliy sufficient ta meet the total parking required under current City parking requirements through a long term agreement with Florida Power or other similar arrangeme�t suita�l� to the City; 7} a minimum af two security personnel shall be provide� to polfce the parking iot between 3 0:00 p.m. and 3:00 a.m. on Friday and 5aturday nights; and 81 approval shali be for 9-month trial period from date of issuance af occupatianal license, after wi�ich applicatian will be reviewed for campliance witf� estabiisl�ed conditior�s of approval. The motian was duly seconded and carried unanimousiy. ITEM #2 -_Ad,jaurnment The meeting adjaurned at 10:25 p.m. msp05a97 5 05/14/97 � �� s�� r � �-f,� c ` s�"` r � ,�S Cynthia Hardin, AICP Cynthia Hardin has sixtean years of �xp�rie�ce as a practicing planner. Her work �istory includes a wide rang� af projects, ranging from zoning and land uss studies to histaric preserriation efforts a# the State iev�l. Ms. Hardin routi�e�y handies rezoning cases on behalf of property owners. Her eminent damain experience includes work an the S�ncoast Parkway, Polk Parkway and numerous local road projects for th� �Iorida Dspartment of Transpartation and local gavemments. Her wark for local gavemment, non-prafit ar�d private sector business orgariizations gives her the ability to �nderstand and integrate pub�ic and private sector perspectives while arri�in� at soiuti�ns to plannir�g issues. Ms. Hardin #�as extensiv� successful experience in presentations to a wide �arse#y of a�diences including city counciis, county commissions, go�emmental land use advisory bodies, regional and statewide agencies and business and neighborhood groups. PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE Principal, Engelhardt, Hammer & Assaciates, lr�c.� Tampa, Fiorida-- Current and recant projects include site feasibility studies, variance req�ests, rezonings, apprais�l support, DRI amendments and annual reports, '' � eminent domain representation and �xper# witness services far a variety of public and private ciients. Executive Directar, �'lorida Trust for Hlstoric Preservation, Tallahassee, F�oridawDirect aIl activiiies of 2,000 member� stat�wi�e non-profit preservatian advocacy assaciation including fund�aising, legislative advocacy and educational programs. Planner. Taub & WilEiams� P.d,� Tampa, F[arida--Coordinate and direct develapment plans of private seckar clients including rezoning, site plans and Developments of Regional lmpact. Assistan# IVlanager, Land De�elopment Caordlr�ation Division, Housing a�d De�elopment Coordinatio�ti �spartment, City of Tampa, Flor[da-- Supervise staff of s�ven praFessianal �lanners; responsible far all staff anaSyses and �resentakions ta City Cour�ciF, principal autho� of al� zoning regulatians. Asso��ate Pfanner, Planning & Zotting �]ivision, C�ty of Pinelias Park, Flortda--Responsible far presentation ta City Councii of staff revfews for land use plan amendm�nts, rezorting, site plan review, plarirted unit develapment master plans and subdivisions. Principal author of r�e�v subdivision co�e. s.� �� Cynfhia Hardin, AICP (page 2j Assistant Pianner, Current Planning Section, Planning artd Dev�lopment Department, f�Aa�atae County� Flarida—Respansible for infarmation regarding �II aspects of the comprei�ensive p1a� and iis im�lemenking regulatians ta the gen�ral public, developers and design�rs, � „ ReQresentative Proiects •� Tampa Bay Paric of Cammerce, (Rezar�inglDRl}, 0ldsmar, F�arida • Suncoast Parkway, (Muitiple Em€nent Oomairi Planning Ana�yses), Hillsborough, Pasco and Hemando Counfies ° • Citn.is Park Mali Roac�, Improvement Project, {Multipl� Eminent Damain Planning Sf�di�s), Tampa, �'lorida • Northem Trust Bank, (Rezor�ing), Tampa, Flor�da • Ybor Ciiy Historic District, (Plaroning Study), Tampa, F�orida • Cify � of Tampa Historic pr�servation Ordinance, (Ordinance �raftirtg and Adop#ion), Tampa, Florida Pro%ssiana! Credits Florida State University Master o€ Science �n Urban a�d Regiona! Pl�nning, 9 992 Rscipient of ihe Department's McClure Award for Academic Achievemenf Research Paper Topic; The J4elationship 6etween Nisforrc Dlstricf Designafion and Ge�trifrcation: A Case Sfudy of Tampa, Flarida Clemson University Bachelor oi Arts, May � 98� � PoliEical Science Majar, Sacioiogy Minor Ctemson C�apter Blue Key Suncoast 5�ctian af the American Planning Assticiation: Chairman, 1992. Vice-Chairman, '1991. Secretary, 1990. � Awards Program Chairman, Z 989-199� Ftorida Chapter oi the American Planning Associatlon; � Awards Program Chairman, 199�-�992. ,�uror, Awards Prog�am, 199a, Prngram Chairmar�, � 988 Annual State Conventior�, St. Petersburg Uice Chairman, Florida's Natinnal Register Review 6oard, 1991 - current. i i i 1 i � t i F � � �- �:a::� � a: J.aYI•i r ' .�• - � rr�u��i ..�.�..,..-•ti � �� _ . .� � � , � ...� .� � .., .....,._. .., , ... 4. Lc+tn g5 thrvugh 8A 5� 31 tl�r��ubh 13i Li�yd-•�ita 5ki�:n.�r Sub. (455 Cutfvee++ Itoui�>varc!) Cc�ntury 'Cec'fI Co,, inc. cU sa�15 f � �� .� f y�� [ta�uase � Buainass/PreEt�yien.:l n{Eicea � (Rr�� Ert6n[c Sus�Of�f.C�) Zun��S - C1t-23 (Rc�urt Cnma��r�iH� "iv.:�tLy-Eibht"} ��,� �� v K�. �4arv�y a�vis�J a� Ceilow�: 'Mi� is :c r�quc�t Eor bu��n�ss/proFessionai of�ic�R ir� thc Ra�¢ort� 8o�a.�rc►nt "'Ct►rncy-�ig�t" xar�in�; di.ytrict; chc g�svc:nino sec�i,ane oF tt�e �..-�r:d Dev�►io�sac•nt Cod�� nr� S�rc�iona l�6.�125Eb? ,znd (a)i5?; tbr. rsqueaC ia to havc: � rast cfitat� ufEice :n an �:xi�tin� mut�1; end. �thc "irn[�ic Fa��fa�ae aommet�ted thar� ma� be a ne�� for nde�i�ianat ps=k:ng W��ieh ►rould br d�=erra�n.:d When �ny pKraei�t� �: an ocrupx�iaan; iic�nac iS ap�s�i+:d :oe. Ys. Iiarvav ��vi,acd ��s�if r�comm��s�c� a�prova'1 �ub js�ct Lo th� Eol:awin�: i) 'Ft�at th�e Oc;uPatLqnc: Lic�nsc be prncur�cl viti►in s:x aon�ha o£ apprv�ut �E �he cvnditios��'L ua�; �nd �) 'ThaC Gl�e park�ng b�: r6vivu.zd by che TrYEri� Engeneer Eor detrraireutxqn tt��t tycr- ia s�ffi,eErnt- p�r<frtj nr u v�riane� 5c ab�air�rd. Atty. Uon 2L�E►stiand= repr�a�at�;.ivr o` npplica�rt. s[at:.i th+� r�qs�.;sC wilt nat ca�s.se [hc c�r�t� eQ bc ovcr-bur3�r.ud. �ie ndda�i th�t tis��c ki; t be n3 n�u eanstrrsction bt�� r parCiti�orr �.i�: S�t �r�sksi�ed Lo c:zhibaat� tR.: sou«��ra po:�io�T O� Che n.Eit`d �r?� 8s 3 QsrL C�r,i� rr.3�: �:sCa�+� a�{1LC�:. !+o p�rsonu �tpp�•n;yd ir� �vQpa:k af •ar in app�sf.�nR tr� t�a abt►v? r.3qu�•si. �:�4r:oh vss �,e3r. i�} yr. Sct��rah. s�cnn.led by `�r. ttanil[or�T ce �p�ro�t• C14.► �ty�a�v ` rQqu�3t sL�j,�ct t� �h� fe;iaering: i3 'i'tta[ eha �ceupae_onai i,ic�erts� t�r pe��u:« �i�:�ir. +ir esnn�hs �sf �ppro�at �.` .h� c�ndicianul ��c; and 2� �hat tht pur;ci;�g b� rr�vi�w4�! by sh� ►rnffic Enoi�zrr Ear detarni��Lion thtiC eh��rc iy s��:Fic:,:r�� Q.-r:�in� a; a•rax�s�c.s bK obts:rced. `Stitio� csrY�Nd unr3Ai�l�uiij C7 to 0}. � S. i.at �. 5cud�b�ksrs Sub. Cx5t[5 Ccls-C�s-Bay 3ou�evard} V�i4 ►tii�'%L:rj:i �il::sc (P',tc,:r.r+�rc's) iE.estis; F[al��s�/2:i��ioa r� U(y�: ~ r� � 4,,,. Kn�t�v,.eC - .�S��CDi'"-SZ?C ;t?�t �r�.-aFa� G4RSeL�p.�Dn Of s��CV�tO1lC Bcvar�gas; �oncd - CC Cv�n�*.rai W@a�rtial) Ys. �srvty adv'sstd �s fv.lavs: 77,is reqt�rh� is [o: on pr+oi�s conesirp.:pa of x:caholie be��ragrrn ».`rr C+-nMral Canaerc;ui zvains c�iatrice; C�r �ov�rn:n;; xec�ions n[ che L�se4 ?,rv�lopotnr Codc �re� 5�ct�ons t36.OZ5(D} and th� tactas of OrdLn�ncc 4420�-8T; tti� rrc�uss� is ap�c e tic�e! 1�� toe a rhangc oE b�sain�xss oun•:rship and is ehr only ct�an$c intr.nded: zhis par�icular 4-CpP-S�{ lic��se doe� �uC hnv� �h+: 3�; Eoa3 rrquirt*acne ��d �rtually funcCions ns � 3-COP; ch�• =r�i':tc �s+�:nc�r cora�ent� ch�G t4c "ncv Cadc requ�rr,s 365 par�cfRg �paces :ur 730 uccnppnca" are �ruc but da nat applx ta Chi�e ea=�L��shrcne b.�cau�c thaae �cqui-+:,zcnts �r�e Cor 7sCat,]Eshnent� elosee Cv x r.esidonte�L srca �ha� �rfiat aa �.cMbii��d by G>dc and thia appltc�snt sxct�Ss this ru�uire�rnfi; and. th� Fni�c� �cp$rt+aent a;�v na rsasoq to dcnx li�caxc to nppticn�t. I�s. Harvay .1dV�ard nt*t: rcrrs�wa�+ndod approrr=L VE the abuv+; r�quss[. F �� z ��.,�-- ..... , az�:b�as •1 1 L1 1 � m 1 u::.J I rJ i:.1JI' 1�I � �:� � f '�.• [1 i1'SUI•1 �.1.��'41ne-�� .��.��. � � r�...� ...�� .r..�. »�.... �X I� 3 Atty. �d ArNSirc�q$. r�:pr�+x��ni:ttivu uf i.i t�• 5:n•�i�rti� ti.�s►'r. �n�! r�i��t:.�et purrltuser, $l.nrkpapl Palncr i,imit��d, it�t�!�1 ci�.� r.�q�i��K: e+ :ur .� rtti.�r.hr� ,3: ownarryl�ip ��f tl�e ar�b�urk ]icr:»�e :��d c�p�li►•.�nt mti�.�Gc r�:qtei;.��n.•ttit�: .r:' it►f• �:��d�•. !�C ad��t t1��C� «�ttaorLnh;n in�r��x,s/cgc�� rst tl��• suti;rct t�+r��;i.rn ai�f� 2,1i p,�rking SpaCt)S p�o�rided tiJ�7wYC �S7 �1st�;Sin� ltp.tl'+!.i :1['�t r��ruis•5��. ��• �:3iKtr :tL:1[•d�� era usa i.s roupatibte yitlz sesrrr+un�ins vs,�s. �1f4�•r nu�•it ivain�; h� `lr. Sra�u•�h, `!r. Ars¢xLrptt}; SC�ti�ei Ch�` }��'�+pux�.l u�+� rxG i�re ui !: :��• k t� i:.tr L�► �ioe• �'urr•�rz[ oparnG ion, tllare vi ll h�� n ly v�e�: �s[abl iKhr.,��nl .yt t'�� st�tt j�r��_ Inc•3; i��n. �,:�f �;�V UQdrs1L RVn w�; I bti :t n►�11tc iab �y�r�: u�� t.iL i.►U. Lr� aupport of thc sbov� raqurx�. t1r. �iit Alrxaadn.r, Arckiirc[. �t.ic.•�1 :�� M'1!� Y�.�C73Lt1C� �l]/ �..��N $�'1V��1j�1C 8snk �..� {�C�j>.=:•: C�1�' F��12ir•:t� VLtYyr.tr r�:C4T qu�Ktianstl� by ?�ls. Vix►sn, Mr. +li��xt��!� ��t.�tnd :. �.I3r1ri n� �i !:'a�• ::::::��k h�i: ch� Eootprzn[. Yilt not �S� thanfi��- iSot ion ��s�' �sadN by `tr. iiag:+n. �res>�t��d b�• !�c. ;rttu�,�. C�� •rpprar�• �ct�� .z�j��•• rcqucst sub�ect to thr u4r t:.+r�t`s: h,:ir.g }+r,rcurr� u::4�in �i� �a:+i�?�s. :Sttiaa r�rri�d uea�ir�ouuly (7 to 4}- � Il�c meP[in� rcc:al��3 :�: 3:�: ^:: I:d :.:�o:s�an�d tiC -+:UU !'�. C. Anrsex�tiao �,ad Zooio : 1. �arccl �: t.��t� : :�rnu�h by. �lyRiet� 5uh_ . . Parrc% z: Lots l �hrqush 24, Ch� lsca '�aa�:r. Sub. . P�rc�el. 3: i.�ta I r.wr.,ugri ?�. CE+e isZ� ',�oo�z . ?hnnt : i !lrcr��:c: CaS; oL th•+ :��-�iaus a{ S�sic itLa �� nn: ch o. .'�i�'n .*.: �:.�•c• (i��s��:�\��C�r.,: � � sa--� �-rqut:Ki - ,:11�•x�t t•):c and ;G7�in, Pa�rcl I; RS-5 (Sxn;,l++ rsrcet 2: �5-6 cSingt•_ P�rca! 3- RS-� '�:n�lti• �. � - r.�..�ti i :� '��:�:iii•.1� i.l: 11:(�� mi :, Ft��SL.t.•n::s: "S:x'�; �arai ly s.+a:; •�r.z::e: ": e�ur") i�:i t{.ti'.�)Y'' ?YC�1�:i.l.t•1 :i:�• T�►i.ly�:t� al1�X .7. Ctli: C�:ir'il�ll!£� �i: i.l:l�: r:i.F:l: :.5;:� � i: �:i bf E.rplh:s S;rr,.�t. s ` ' : "4 : � • � r.,,,==,,st iK :•a: :t�;.�•x.,ii�•st ':S. I+�r1�;Y zdri:�,:�! �5 .7. n1�: ►� is LiCy—Loi s.l.�.e. s ynd ;tS-fi lSirsai4 esr�:�y �!s:3N.z�i�. "S'sx"1 z,�:tiny; �s:: Pa�rcal t.�r.� P�rccl � a:�� znnrxa: IOR nnd RS-4 f${R,7��! iat'tt(f �s•+:CtZr::LRt ��f�<+l.•:i�� tcS�itit� cTi; P�rr'CI �: lhe� '�?riDF?Cr�1t� 1Y�• .3jll�i7�� '�i.1C�.:.i �'a.3�tl'L� UF1 i.�4�'�� 6�y`,��1':L'�l<1=I;• R!� sl{�171�. subj�eta a_ .�I;,lr.�hn�:nt� t� rinn.•x: .tlt :•:�•x s:� du� �}• ��`�tvmbHr "s0. S95$ �Rc! ��y fa�� na: p�i�' br ir�d:vido:it prorKr.; ovn�rc u'siF b�: r,ls•: rcarun;ih:lit� a: cf�c d��topar. v�ict� Ic.:x :src: spc•iFir:�lt;r tar�,r:rc! �a ch,� pur�:irase �: �r.nperCj Sae��h nr Lakr, Gh,�tzue�ui; City uatCC, Sh+:�c cthe; ni;:s: t� b.i� ar.� seua:lrrbt+� e� .�:t �rr�,�-ti.•s; :nd. thc di[[�rc�t ��ning� nr� r+�g.�.•�.�d �•vern t4otsgt� al: pruq•:e�irc ea.r�•t ZS-4 �Cvrtin� �� Ce� 4aE ,iz.� .znd e!�•nSit}•. bu� P�re�l t:�tr�! Parcr.l � hs,ti�.� bccn r.►•r.••d RS+S ia Or.1.;r ;h�t th� ��zi<tiny: s�.y:�cks ni: `r•. nn�y4r.►t.•nrr.�i��;. `!s. F4�rticy ��lY:a<<i t�t�sf! r�•�•ocn.•n•lc� �ppr7va: ��i i.ltr znnr�ti�irn an�l Rti-!� !'Sio�l� r+1:y: 3y .�+�•s:danti tii "5ix"i r.an:ny; qn Parcrt l �ni ParGni x in: .1M1!!��1:�'►:1�1�1 .1S1ii :Z5"w iStR+�t�! �:1�1;�} {iAySt��11C::il ��L�tfC�l\ n�J:l�:�f� �►11 �QI'CLZ �� P.�c x *lin�.e.�e 8 o2ri�ir:�;e 1 ��' i C]— 1:J� / .3 :.'��F'i�l 1" liui �i i..L' i r� n.,._ r �..r�i �� a r F a � v.a �.+ i...� ..�..... �...... ..... �. . • . . ,I• �� 0 2, t,oc ll 3 F.,rc ��s ta. Z;, i3 GtCy P�r�c Suh. (25 Caus�uay Bout�vard) �'"`' City o� Ct,,•xrvatcr ' CU 88�14 Kequaut - Msria� (Cocl�Gruci �oa �� Tun botk:�1 ?e.i4•.�. •• ?I SF : P�ib : i: fS•r+ui -?�cr4 � i c } ALr'C (A4u�tic i.andx/CD:tKC3:i 1. Lota � th:aug� ll� Co Lttmbia Sutr. �� t1.M5 il�cac[k'n ►�Tivu} Se.s Stonc, I.Lct. CJ $$-FS �l!QU�s:t � M�rin7 lCOn3C:uZttAri �+C ;ulditicna: �icr) ��nad - GR�28 (Resor� Co�e��rciat "'�c,�nc}-�i�hL") i�i.ir. i?si�udZir :.3:iGiS%LC►�75t.�Si1 4. �ts 85 [tzrough $8 S 33� -:�~rLgr i 35 F.iayd=,dh ite Sk:nr.e: Sub. ;�+55 Cui.vi4.• 5�►�Ltv�:d: :..sntury Toet Co.. Inc. CJ 88-L6 ' Qcqu�.st - 5�ss{negsf?roEaxs'sonal d�:ic�:s r • �g�ai �sL�� Sub-OEEic�rJ '•� Zvn�:d - C�t-28 (Raso:� :or�erci.�i "T�sca.;.�riLi-.."� 5. �..7e ,^,. S.ud,sbxk�rs Sub. r?5i5 Gutf-c�-82y Bou:�ca:3) � :.i f� S�� in�R �,t:�k ( F'aCC.��r�'�! { �euisliic lati6) i K�wpto�l C�i S3�Z'r R�:quRst - 4-CO?-�� (On premis►r Consu.zpc.on oE ALcah�tic �evcr.sg�s� Zone� - GC (�ar.ral Comaerciall AMiaA�1QR b �7AlixloG tr L,�!(p5 US� PI.AN Ai(E:IDi�.�?iTS: Ii) StaCe�a�nc �f aaxe by appiiea�C � S�tavtcs (2I Pre�Rncac�en by xtsf� » � �in�tes {�} ;,amczz�cs Erocs public �n suppartlapp3s�cian: . indivtdu�I - 3 nr�nutes . ' a,?okcapevson for grnup - tfl sinu�Qs (r�? Pubtic :{car:ng4 aK�: tlo��d (gj Uiacu�ssianTAcrio� by 8aa:� 1.. . ._ �.... • A b Z �t�Cr.n�u � � :32l�6/89 . .. - �' � ,� �viembcrs �'rescnt: �ViC1Ili7�CrS g?CGUSCd: n�nv�ur�s . PLANNING � ZONIN(3 BQARD TU�,SDAY, UCTO$� 1 d,1990 �� - � s � � Chairman Jatwao�a, Ms. Nixors�, Mcsserx. �errcll, Mazar, Schwob awd Hau�ilton Mr. Gans Also i�xson�: ]arnes M. Po�etty� Dltrcwr ofPiannit�g arid Dcveiagmcnt Scot# Shufard, Plawn'rag Menagcr C�a�r�crson lot�on outlined the pcaned�rrs for conditional uscs �nd advised that anyanc advcrsely �ectcd by a dee#�1aa af the Planning ar�d Zoni�g �oa�ci� with rcgard to canditianal c�scs� �as two wecks � this da� in which to �le m� appcsil tfuougt� tha City Claic's Office. Florida Law rcquu+es amy party �ppcalis�g s dxis[on aftttis Board to bave a record af the proccedings ta support thc agpsa�. TI'E1V,[S A,RE L[STE�I IN AC�NDA QRA�R TNUUGH NOT N,�G�'SSARILY D�SCUSSED IN THAT d�DER A. Ai'1'�iOVAL pF NIINUTES Motion was madn by Mr. Harnflton, and secondcd by Mr. Scf�►vob, w�prove tho miiwt�s of tine ma#��s of Sepiember+l, 1990 as wriuw and 5eptembcr a8,1g90 as ames�dsd. Motton cazri.ed wnanimovsiy {b w 0). B. 1. �QUESi� F4R EXTENSYON, IIEFERRED AND CONT�I�P[JED X'�'�MS: 1,at 1 and part af Lai 2, $lk B-1, Maryland Sub.► 3ocated an the rast side of S. G�wood Ave, appt�ximately 175 fat sotrth of Turncr St (Jaquter Investmcnt� �nc.), Z 9b-07, LUP 90-16 USE PLAN: FROM: HIgh 17rns11ty Residrntial TO: ResidentiaUOfi�cc �4Ni1VC ATLAS: FRQM: RM-28 (Muiti-Famiiy Residesit#al 'Y'Q:O�, {Lirs:ited O�SC�) Mr. Shuford gnve the background ofti�c case mad se�bmittcd, in writia�, the st�ffrcodmrn�ndation. Aonald J. Sykes-Fre�,1715 Woadridge Dr., archikrt rept�esenti�g the applic.ant, stated that Lltmug� a naaricet study of the arca, it wns determincd there is a great need for child day car+e end t�e prescn�t xa,ain� dc�cs nflt permtt that uso. � Mr. Schwob stnir.� th�t the proposai child c�rc usc would be a conditia� use a�plication and shou�d not be consider�esi for tlsis r�zoning ttiquest� Mr, Shvford statad t�c reqvesbec� zaning is the least intcnse thai wnuld a11aw child day care as u conditian�sl uSC. No p�rsons a�pcared in aupport of or iti oppnsltian to thc abovo request. Matian was mado by Mr. Sehwob, and sc�qndcd by Mr. Femll� tc� approvo t3�c atwve request 1►+totion carricd unanimausly (6 la 0). C. �Ol�i��'�'�UNAL �TSES: 1. Lot 2, SNdCbi+kat's 5ub. (25I6 Gulf-to-9ay Sl�d.}, Lifa St�vis�gs BanSc/Aaron R Fodimut (alackpool palace l.td. Fla. lac,), CU 90-b5 � Roquest - To pem�it on premiac cnnsumpdon of beer, wine and liquor Zon�d - CG (Genual Commercial) �'� Ms. Nixan stated due to A�mfl�ct of #nteJrst she wiU not participate in �iscussian or vote in this matGer. Mr. Shuford gave tha bac;cground of thc case ar►d subrinitted, in writiag� che staff' rccammendatian. Mr. Shufnrd provided a seating pl.an submittcd by ti�c $pplicsnt for the Boand's cutsory rcview and advised that staff E�as noi had thc oppottisnity to reviow it as yct. Tham�s Manel�, �892 Deer Ruo� Soa#h, A�iatstnt Sccretgry tn Wilder Corp. of Dtlaware, stntcd ho is r�epresenting the appl�c�unt and wauld unsw�x guestlons far t�a Board memtxrs, P& Z h1�NUT�S 1 101ifi194 __.�.. . s-�w�a��..:�atn.�w,�..°,.,.r�...�u,...». ..... . , . . ... .� . .. . _ _ , � �_... . . . . ... .. _. -�x I� � .. ', ��7Lacu�,«ar� e��ua! r�gard�ng �he avaflabillry of the app�lcant, Ms. Ti,f�any W#1der, ta be prases�t to answer dotr,�ite� qve5tions, Mr. Iv�errell stat� Ms. Wilder is in a meeting with tne Division of Alcoholio Ekveira�os and Tobaccco und thercfare could not atte�d this mxti��. � Mr. Mc.�reil stared ti�at fhey plan to op�n she busine�s r�efr,.n�ed ta as Thc Eqt�atar. lt will be nper�t� as u restavr�nt 8c nightclub, He stated slicn: wilt �ot bc wct T shin contests ar "tcddy" wntcsts. Thcre wiil bc bikzni contests und thin� of that natuta occaainnully for specia� proraodans. Mr. MetrC11 said that thcy desirc to �un a cic�an respectablc busiricxs as�d be a goad nol�,hbur gnd wi11 havt sccu�ry and wi�l poiice ihe property daily. tn response to questions by the �oard, Mr. Merrell stated Tif�y Wi2dar, 21, will bo aperating tho busin�ss in coqjunction wlth tbe gentleman who managed thc club wheQ it w� Studcbakcrs �d t�at he will bc on-site durir�� n�ating haurs; th� booths have b�n rcir�stallcd artd d�cy hdpe to maintai,a a SO% £crad/Sa'/o alcoholtc bcvcr�c salts; and thet waitr�ss �od bartcAdorx wijl as9i�t patrons in obtain�ng a taxi when neccssary should thay apQcar to bc intvxic,atcd. Diseus�ion ensued wittz tha Board mcmbc�a cx�ccasin,� cont�rns includ'mg the �'oilowfng: pmbl�ms with this loeatfon wbcn it was Mako's and Scudebakers; tt�o lan�th af tlme for a trial periad and to obtain occ:upationa� liccnsc; and the seAti�gpfatt �sxsCnted No �nns app�carpc! �n sUpport of or in opposiHon W the abovo rcquest. Mat#on was �nadc by Mr. Sahwob, �d sacoadcd by Mr. Ferr�elJ, to eppmve th� above rtqucst subject to tha fa��o�ing oo�lciitions: 1) 'I�e applic,�t successfill�y tratLSftr the d-CO�»SRX Florida S�aco desigr�azcd alcoholic beveragc ticcns�; 2) Tha appsicant obtain rCquisisc nccupat�vnal Iicenso wtihin two (2} rnot,tiis of ti�e date of this pubtic hearing; 3} 7he sale of �I�ahofic �vet�es s�,ll be �tstrl�ted to consarnption an pt�emiscs with no packa�c sa�es; 4) Thc applfcant shall pmvide prooFto tize City of Clcarwater �f an �recment with Florida Aaw�r Corporatian to u�sa the �iarid� �awar right- af-way for vvert3ow parkinb, as welt es tht agrermcnt/easerua�t for the Republic Hank par3cing; ti�cse a�reemcntslc:asem�ts must t�e satisfac#ary to tho Ciry Atwmey prior to i�uana of the occupational �icen�c; 5) Thc applicant shall pmvi�: thc planning twd DeVelopt�d�t Dtpartrncnt with a scating plan which meets thc siandasds c�escribcd in tha ArchitccWrnl CiraAhic Standartds man�a2, A�ccican Tnstituse of Architects, �'a�r tahle sizes and aisle widths; this se� p�an shall be adh�d to et �II ttmcs by �c menagemcnt oF the propascd nigtuclub; 6) 'The rcquimna�nu of tlic 4COP-SRX 1ir.�nse shall bo �dhrred W at ali times by ihc rraanagomeni of thn proposCd nightclub, and a copy o�'this �icense st�a4l ba provided to the Plauaing and Devalopment D�pa�tnner�t; and 7) 'fftis canditivnal uso }xrmlt sha11 ba far a nine (9) mat� tri�! period from tht datc nf issuance of the occupational liccnse in order tar the sppiicnnt's conn�liAnce witi� the Cft�s 1aw enforcemont c.�des durir�g thls period tc, t� observec� and av�luated. Mation carried ur�an3mously {5 to 4}. 2. Purt of �ots l4 8� 15, 5x, 12-29-�5, Pinelias Gmves/Northwest carner of BeIcher end Ra�n�e RoadslWtaver L`nrcrpriscs, lnc.. (�1ori� Rca�ty �cutd Two, i,ui.y, CU 90-56 Request -'Y'o petmic vehlde inspectian statibn Zor��d -1L (Litnited Industrial) Mr. 5huford gava the backgrovnd of tho casa and submittcd, in writin�, the �aff recommcndation. Mr. Shufonl statad thflt stafihad �reivcd a traffic impaci study an� have not hsd the apportunity to evaluate it an8 rccommcnded this item bc cantinvcd, ' G�arge Dealcir�, 2240 Helleat[r Raadr 4T T�rnpa Bxy E�tgl�eeriag, Y�c., stated ne condUCted tha tra�ispart�fon a�a4ysis submiucd tn a�tnff end ti�ait he has si�dts to pt�esrct to tt�e �oard. Discussion cnsuad rogarding the rcview af t3�is report by Mr. Crawford end Mr. Mt7riana of t�c '�raffic Enginaring Di�ision and whGthar they could be calIed for tf�eEr commenss. Mr. Polatry feit tbat the study siiouid go chratigi� the nnrmai rcvicw proccss allowing the affcctcd dcpartmcnts ta rcviaw it and pt+nvidc their cosnmcnts in writing and would therafo�e recnmmendcd that thc Board coutLsuc this stcsn. lvtotfan w�.s mada by Mr� Sehwob� arrd xcc�ndr.cE by Arfc. Haml�toa, to CoiltlnttC t�C abDVC �qur.�t SubjeCt to iha OCtDbe!' 3(1, 1994 mceting. MQtion caniod unanimously (6 ta A). 3, Lot 7, A.B. extd scnnie Cates Suh., a07 N. Ozcoola Avcnue, Salvadon Army, CU 9D-67 Requcst - To �tt �5i�ori�� i�� n�j�r Zoncd - RM-28 (Mnlci-namfly Rcsidcntial) Mr. Shuforti g��o tho backgro�nd of the casa and �ubmittod, #n wrjti,�g, the staff rocom�mcndatian, end adviscd that onc Icac:r in �uppnrt And one lctter vf objoctlot� had bcct� roceivtd. O. Stephc�e 'X'h�rker, Attorncy. rtpresenting the Salvatinn Army, staicd daey have no obscction to �taii's P& Z M1NU'TE,S 2 lO/1b/9� . �. _ ;r u 6 • .. , ..._ . .. ...�, , � , . ..... , .._. . . ._ _ - . _ _ . . L-~� �/', � rtich�rd Bailhe, 1390 Guif Bl�d, #l�OS, stated that this requ�st wnuld benefit qnly thQ renters af th� equipment at t�e exper�se af the neigh�orin� aommuni�ty who �ra in abj�ctinn to thls business ar�cf asked the 8aard denY this request. I� r�butt�l, Mr. Kahle sxated th�t from a enviror�mental aspect they do aare �nd wi�l insure there wllt be no 8estructian af ihe sea oats in th� grea. There will �a � survc�iilance boat tn prntect the safe�y of swimmers and people on flotation de�ices, Ha added therp is nnt a naise pollution wlth these wateroraft. Discussian er�sued regarding the method o� bringing th� watercraft in and out with�ut violating the protected sea aats areas, Mr. Kahie stated #hey can work around that by (auna�ing them elsawhere and towing th�m in. �n response to q�estfo�s by the Bflard, Mr. Ka�rle stated h� has previously operated � similar business in Arlingtan, Te7cas. He sta#ed both he and �1s p�Cfier will be p�esent et all times, o�� for survelllance and one nn the beach. The vehicles wilf be placed away from the public walk area tawards the rest�urant. Me. Kahle stated their trai�er is 1 fi ft. and tiuiiy enclased and has the business name on it and th�t woufd be used In lieu of � sign. Board discus�lon et�sued with tlte members �xpressing Cohcerns including the foliowing: safety, pratection af the environment, and th� beach nvt being wide ennugh at this Iocation tor #his type operatian. Mation was made by Mr. Hamiltanl and seco�d�d by Mr. Jahnson, to deny the abo�e r�qu�st as it does not appear to support the followitlg StandBrds for Approval of Land Development Cotte Section � 37.017 �d}; {4) The use shall be consls#erlt with tF�e community welf�re and not detract from the �ublio's con�enience at the specific loc�tian; artd ifi) The use sh�ll be camp�#i�ale whh the surroundir�g area and not impose ar� excessive b�rden or have � s�,�bst�ntial negative impact on surrounding or adjacent us�s or ar� community facilities nr servic�s. Mot�o� carried ur�animously (8 to 0). 't0. l.ot 2, Studebaker's Sub. (2�i16 Gc�lf to Bay B�vd.) Equator, IRa. �Calypso Bay Cafej, CU 9 � -'� 3 Request - 7o permit on premise consumption of beer, wine and liquor Zoned - CG {G�nera) �ammerciall Mr. Shuford gave the backgr�e�nd af t#�e case and submitted, in writin�, the staff recommendation. Gearg@ Greer, 60a Cleveland 5t. #885, �pplicant's reprosentative, stated his cltent Is I sa�isfied that parking is suffic�ent �nd exceeds code �'equirements. Remodeling is undsrway to canvert thls Iocatlon back to a restaurant. Mr. Greer stated this will fae s#rictiy a restauraRt with some entertainment gs �ecessary to meet custorner's needs. The hours a# o�eration Will be 17 :00 a.m. far lunch daiiy and would (ilte to remain open u�til 2:OCi a.m. !n respans� to questfons by the Board, Mr. Shuford stated #his SRX license 1s grandfathered ar�d daes not require 51 `Yo faod sel�s. Mr. Green r�viec! that this I€cer�se req�ires th� business #a be bon�fida restaurgnt meets�g a11 requifemer�ts other thar� the 519'o faad salss. In response to questions by t�a Board, Mr. Gr�er stated there will b� a cover charg� after '10:00 p.m.; v�l�at parktng wiU be available; and t�at entertai�ment w111 consist of music for dining t�ofore �p:d0 p.m. at�d music for dancing after '10:Q4 p.m, �nd wiil be tataliy inside ti�e P& z MINUT�S 14 42/�5/91 r i .. . ....r � v �..�..�I 1 � � 1 �1.J� � e.�� . �� .,' . .. �.. �. . .. � ..� � � • �� ' restaurant. No persans appeared in support of or in oppasitiar� to t�e above reauesf. Discussion �nsued reg�rding wheth�r ta impose � trial period. Motlor� was made by Mr. Hamiltnn, and s�annciec� by Mr. Jahnson, to �pprove the above request subject to the foilowing conditians: 1) 7he ap�licant suca�ss#��ly tra�sfer the 4CQP- SRX �iarida State designated �icoholic beverage lice�se; 2f T�e applic�nt vbta�n re4�isite occuqational Hcense within twa (2) manths of the date of this �u1�1ic hear�ng; 3i The sale of alcahplic bev�rage� sheli be reWtricted tn consurnp#inn an premises wlt� no package sales; 4} T'i�e applicar�t shali provide prnof ta the City o� Clearwat�r of ar� �greement wit� the Republic Bank far ov�rflow parkirrg, this agreemer�tl�gsements must bs satisfactory fa -the City Attorney prior to issusnce a# the occt�pationa� ilcense; 6) The applicant shal! provide the Planr�ir�g ar�d Q�velopment Department with � seat'sn� �lan which meets tf�e standards described in the Arai��tectut�al �ra�hic �tand�rds trian�a�, American Ir�stitute of Archit�cts, for teble slxes and aisle widths; this seatir�g p�an shall be adhered to at alf timQS hy the managament of the ro osed ni htclut�; 'Bj 7he requirements ot Xhe 4-GQP-SRX licensa sh�ll #�e adh�red to at ap times by the management of the p o ased ni htciub, �nd a copy of this ilcense shall b� p�QVided to thQ Plannfing and Development Department; and 71 No autdaar speakers or o�tdoor er►tertainment s�,all be permitted. Mvtion Garried unanimously 1B to 0). D. A►Nl1iE3CATt�iliS, zQNING, LAND USE PLAN AMIENDMENTS, LAND �?EVEI.OPNJENT CODE TE3CT AIVtE�11UMENTS, AND LOCA�. PLQNNING AGENCY REVIEWS: 'f. Parts of Lo#s '� and 2, Sec. '�-29-75, Pineilas Gro�ss S�b., L,ncated an the south side af S�nset Pa�nt Raad, appraximately 3S0 ft. west ot Hercu3es Ave. tK.D. 5auder, Trustee} A 90-'� 3, LUP 90�18 . LUP - Frorn unclasssfted ta Cornm�rci��/Taurist I�ac�lit�es Zt]NE - CN �Neigt�harhoad Cammercial} Mr. Shu#ord gave the background of the case and s�bmittsd, in wr�tir�g, the staff recommendation. Mr. Shuford noted that ihe praperty has been developed g�nerally in conformance wit� City devetopmer�t standards, Hawever, t#�e developrne�t daes not meet the perirr��ter larid�c�p�ng requirements, and has � slight deficit in interior I�ndscaping and tataf open space. The City Cvmmisslon decided to ai�ow the develapmsr�t to occ+�r with the above mentioned deficlencies. James Baxt�r, applir�.ant's rspresentative, state� that the deficiencies were �xpiained �n full ta the City Cammission befnre the Annexat�an Agreement was executed. AII obligati�ns reqU�red by the City on the developer have been fulfilled. Matian was made by Mr. Harniiton, �nd seconcfed by Mr. Gans, to approve the a�ove request. Mation carri�d unanirnnusly (6 #0 0}. 2. Part af Lots 1�& 12, E. A. Marshall's Sub. as origin�lly platted and P�rt of Lot � B iocated on #i�� nprcheast corner of State St. ar�d Betty Lane (City of Clearwaterj A 90- � 4, LUP 90-zo LUP - From unclass��ed to Recreation ZQNE - U51R (Open S�aaCelRecreation} P & Z MINUT�S 11 02/05/91 � [l•- � ti— 1`J' 'r.� I.5 :� � r'a•� P►tui•� �.C�v 1 htt+� r 4.ni•�� i aivu u i.r �u._ -..� ,... � x� � Member Mazur declared a conflict of inter�st with regard to this appiicatior�. Emii C. Marquardt, Jr., attorney cepresenting the �pplicar�t, stated he reque5ted a 30-day cantinua�ce aE the August 15 m��tsng. Cdnser�5us was to contin�se tl�is item to th� meetir�� of September 7 9, � 995. C. �anditional Uses 7. aMR Cor d b a�ue1 M [nc to permit outdoor retail sa��s, di5plays andlor storage of vehicies at 1345 S. Ft. Harr�son Av�, Belle�ir, Blfc 15, Lots 7& 8, znned IL (�imited Industrial), CU 95-53 Mr. 5huford gave t�e t�ackgrour�d at t�� case� a�d presented, in writing, the st�ff recommendation. He stated staff recommends appraval subject to sever� conditions. !n response to a qt�estlon, Mr. Shuford stated no �ccupatian�l license for outdoor sales has Ever 6een obtained fe�r this prop�rty, so that use was r�ever formaily established. David Hutche,on, r�pre5enting the app[icant, questior�ed if the location of req�fred parking spaces may be altered on the plan. Consens�s was to san�t�on administrative aut�ority for stafF ta r�lacate the requisite parking spaces as needed. Cia,rificatian w�s requested regarding the names of the property owner, business and lessee. Staff is ta re�iew th� uaperwork for consistency. , Member Maz�r mo�ed to approve ltem C.'i subj�ct to the following �onditions: 1) Appraved ac��ss from S. Ft. Harrisan Averru� and �akevi�w Road and parking shall be provided in accordanc� with the requirements of City staff regardir�g parking location anly; 2� Landscaping shall be provided on t�e property in ac�ordance with the plan submitted by the applicant, and i� no case shall there be less than ar� average af five feet of fandsc�ping provided adjacent ta all street rights-of-way, exclusive of a'ssles; 3) There shalf f�e r�a storage or display of vehicles in any street right-of-way or re�uired I�r�dscaped area; 4) A� Building �ermit 5hall be obtained within b4 days fro� the date of this public hearing, w�ic� s�all be drawn to seai�, clearly indicate vel�ic�e display areas, parki»g space and v�hlcular access dimensions, and IandscapEng for review by ail affect�d clepartments for code compliance. Applicar�t's automvk�ife saies vperation shall not deviate from the pl�n, once approved; 5} Thece shall be no vehicle service co�ducted on site, as deffned by �and Dev�lopment Code. Sertion 35.71; b) Any excavation on th� site shall b� limit�d to pavement and base �emoval �s may be necessary to provide landscaping; 7) The required certificat� of occ�pan�y and city occ�pational license sha�! be obtained within 12 months of the �ate vf t�is public hearir�g; aRd 8� Sit� lighting sha�l be screened wit� 90 degree cc�toff mechanisms, directed downward and away from adjainin$ properties ar�d street rigfits-of�way. The motion was duly se�onded and carried e�nan;mousiy. 2. � ua or ln�/Bos vn Inve t�n� t Grau Inc dlhla amz-N- ava to permit �zightclubs, taverns and bars {change of business vwnershiP} at 25'tfi Cu�f ta Bay Bl�d, Studebaker's S�,b, Lot 2, zoned CG {General Comm�rcial). CU 95-54 mpzQ8c.95 Page 2 of 6 08/29/95 4-^ 1 t�� 1 Jy /..� s� I F"��1 r rc��•+ ►,.�i+� i r�r� r�rii•�l � i livu o i.a -,uc. •.•..�, � ._ .y . .,. . �� Mr. Shuford gave the hackg�ound of the case and pres�nted, ir� writin�, the staff recammendation. He stated staff is piQased to see the applicant resolving some of ti�e prob�ematic issues associated with t�is �ang-standin& restaurandn�ghtclu�. Improvements to the exterior of the building irtclude removing the neon pa4m trees of the former Ca�ypso �ay �ight�lub. Concarr� was expressed with a suggested. condition prohib�ting outdoor activiti�s, includtng temporary events. Tttis was not felt to be fair because an ad'acerit church is allowed to have outc�oor evenu wit� appropriate p�rmits. Mr. Shuford exp�ained the City has expsrie�nced compiications with o�tciQOr events in the past be�cause temporary events ar� not reg�riated by tk�e code. Also, staff wis�ed tv pretlude the possil�ility of ciist�rbing th� neigh6oring church anti residential prop�rties with outdaor r�oise. Cansen5us of the $oard was tt�e applirant should be a�lowed th� same privilege er�joyed by oth�rs and should not be restricted from requesting permits for ot�tdoor Uses, if they desire. qr�e memkrer did not agree with a suggested cor�dition requiring valet pa,rking. It was indicated that conciitian was inclt�ded at the suggestion of the app�icant. Cc�nsensus was to strik� that cor�dition. Cheryl A. �z�opoyan, Generai Ma�ager of the subject bu5iness, stated whil� the bUSiness is primarily a restaurant, it will sel!„alcoholic be�erages. She requested a copy of the propased cor�ditions ac�d discussion ensued. in respnnse to questions, Ms, 4zgopoyan stated they pro�os� to provide parking tot security from 7 0:00 p.m. to 3.Q0 a.m. A copy oF the polIce report was r�guested and reviewed by the . Board. While t�e rompiaint� reflected in the report related to previous businesses, it was noted the majority oF the calls occurred around i 1:00 p.m. The 10:00 p.m. start t+me was felt to be adequate. . One member requested a conditia� relating to outdoor site lighting. In r�sponse ta question5, Ms. Ozgapoyan stated ti�ey proposed to open for business or� September 8 and she i�as a v�rbai agr�err�ent with Flarida Power to lease part of their right-af- way for additioRal p�rking. She felt she wo�ld receive the paperwnrk �sutliniRg the terms by the end of next week. She said they will be alEowed to use the entir� right-of-way with the exception of 15 feet fram tha o�! pipeline. There is to !oe nv Charge for parkir�g. One mer�b�r expressed cancern with allowing t�te busir�ess to open withaut sufficient parking in place and suggested, �ither a�arking varian�e, or tying the par€cing fease into tl�e oper�ing date. Ms. Ozgopoy�n did nat feel that woulti allow �nflug� iime and requested 30 days to ha�e written proof of the lease. Dis�ussion erisued regarding parkin$ calculations for the proposal, Mr, SF�uford explained the lacic of parking for a nightclub on this s�te has be�n aecepied for same tim� dt�e to the art'angement with Florida Power. He did riot �eel there would b� a parking prQblem due ta the , new b�si�ess operating as more of a restaurant than a nightclub. He indicated th� or� site parking was more than sufficier�t for a r�staurant and the overflow arrangement was simply a formality to af fow a c#�ange of owr�ership c�f th� o!d A-CO�-SR license. H� suggested al lowing the appiicants 30 d�ys to secur� the IeaSe agreement so they wil� not be held up past their projected openi�g d�te. Mr. Shufard indipte�, if the lease is not obtained, ti�e alternat�ves were fvr him to se�k administrative authority to grant a waiver ta th� rode r�quirement, or for the applicant to request a parking varianc�. mpz08c.95 Page 3 0{ 6 08/24/45 ; •� . L x �, � Disc�ssion ensued regarding m�nagem�nt of the new operation. Ms. Ozgopoyan stated this is an entirely new entity at th�s laration and has nathing to do wich Calypso Bay, In response ta a questior,, she �ndicated Calypso Bay did t�ot have art active parking agreerrient with Florida �'ower at the time they sold the pro�rerty, st was not knawn if a previous agreeme�t had expired, vf if iher� n��er was an agreement. 7he ��piicants were informed an affirmative vaie from a�l fotar memt�ers was required' for a��roval. Ms. �zgopayan responded to questions concerning the cov�r charge, va�et parking c�arge and the Top 40 music. She indicated there is no in#entivn for outdoor s�ating at pr�sent. The ovtdoor latti+ce awning is b�ing re�la�ed with a more permanent awning for weather protection. Ray Balfou, rep�esenting Equator, lnc. �pvke in support of the app�ication anc� �xplained the relatior�ship nf the business anc4 praperty owners. He did not f��l tF�ere would �e a problem with the parkir�g, as it was just a matter of getting th� paperwc,rk signed. Ms. Qzgapoyan stated this is a total�y new concept in the Cl�arwater area and ei�ht more un�ts are anticipated once this one is perfect. 5he stat�d they get along very well in Gearwater. Discusston �r�sued regardir�g new conditions and amendments to the suggested conditions vf approval, MembQr Mazur moved to a�prpve subject to the followi�g conditions: 7} The sale of alcQhaiic beverages shall be limited to consumption on prem�ses on(y, with no package sale�; 2) The apptir,�r�t st�ail s�cure aR agreement with Flaricla power Carporatior� fvr use of the Florida Power ri�ht-of-way for the required additional paricing within �ne manth frpm th� date of this public hearin�; 3) A minimt�m of two secur�ry personne� shall be provided to police the parkin� loc be�rn+een the �o�,rs of 70:�D p.m. and 3:04 a.m. Fr�day and Saturday nights; 4) This approval shafl be far a ni�e mvnth trial period from the dat� of issuance of the occupationa) (i�ense, aker which the �ppfication will b� reviewsd for compliance with ihe establish�cl canditians of �pproval; 5y Site Itghting s�ta�� be screen�d wit�r 90 degre� cc�tof{ mecl�anisms, diretted downwa�d and away from ad#oining properties and street rights-of-way and s4�ail be installed w�thin three months from t�te date of this public hearlr�g; and G) prior to th� issuance af the certificate vf occupancy, the applicarit sha�l submit a site laiids�a�ing plarr tu Environmental Management for review. The �-�lotion was du�y secor�ded and carried unanimously. D. Annex�tiont Zoning, l.ar�d Use Pla� Amer�dmer�t, I..and Development Code Text Amendm�nt and Rocal Plar�ning Agency Review Mr. 5huford gave the background of cases D.1 through D.4 arid pre5ented, €n writing, ihe staff recommendat€ons. lt was noted the �taff rep�rts c�o not contair, the stre�t addresses of the requ�5t�d ann�xation5. Staff is to am�nd the r�ports for inclusion wit� the City Commission ager�da pack�ts. 't. 'i304 Parkwood St, Pir�e Ridge Sub, Blk A, I�ot y 1(Mary J. Koger). A 95-20;�UP 95-23 [.UP: Res�der�tia� [,ow ZONE: RS 8 {Srng�e �amily Residential) Member M�zUr moveci to endarsQ lt�m D.7 ta the City Commission. The motion was du�y seconded and carried unanimousiy. mpx�Bc.9S t� f'a�a 4 of 6 Q8/29/95 u` f O� 1: 1.:J 1 J..JWr �•i i 7lui � ..a..a � � f t�.� � rt1r� A 1 1� I V�7 u �.� .d�ra. �.� � v �� 3 There were no persons presen� to speak in favor or in opposiC�.on �o �his request, Mo�fon was,made by Mr. iCeyes, and seconded by Mr. Mer�iam, £or approvaZ of tha.s reques� sub3ec� �o the €o�.�owing cond�.�ians: 1jThe applicant sha11 revise �.he final si�e pl.�n and �ecert�.xy the final site plan wi�hin �s.ix months from ��e date of this pub3.ic hearing; 2) The applicant shall meet all Developmen� Review Commi ��ee ( DRC ) comm�:n�s for si.te pl.an apprav� i; �) The app�..�can� shall mee�, the perimeter landscaping :�eguixem�nts, Section 42.27 of the I,�nd ' De�cr�:iopment Code; 4) There sha�.l be no new ou�daor speakers �ssocit�ted with this use; 5} There shall be no OU�C;00�' storage of any kind; and �) A].1. repair ac�ivity shall be candu�ted indoozs. Mo�ion carra.ed unanimou5ly (� to 0). 2. Equatcr, Ino (Calypso Bay Ca�e, xnc) tv permit on--premise consump�inn of beer, wine and liquor (busi.ness owners�p change) at 25�.6 Gu].�-�o-Ba� BZvd, Studebaker's �ub, Lot 2, �oned �G (Genera Commercial � 94-33 Mrs. Glattharn gave �he background of the case and presented, in writing, th� staff recommendation. Applicant, Grant Saund�xs, 6147. Sahia De� Mar Bivd. �232, S�. �ete; was p�e�ent.• Hs s�aCed the�e would be no changes in the operation of the busi.ness, and thexe axe �uture p�ans , zn r�modeling. Discussion regarding th� Police repor�s ensued. Questions.regarding securi�y ouC,s�de and S.nside and th� pa�roll�.ng of the parking lat. J� Cr�aar, Genexal� Managexr 748 Cocktail Court, St. Petexsbuzg, was presant. Questions were asked about hoW they intend to contro], situations when someone has had �oo much to drink. Mr. C�amex stated that the employees are requir�d to take �he res�ons�ble vendo� caurse. He wou�d �ike �he op��on far liue entiertaa.nmen� in the futuxe, even though the appli.cation states otherwa.se. ' Discussion on neon signing ensued. There were no persans present to s�aeak in favor or a.n opposa.tion to this request. Mot�.on w�s made by M�. Keyes, and seconded by Ms. NS,xon, to appxv�re th�s request subject t�o the fall.owing conditi.ans: 1} The app��.cant sha]..� obta�n an occ�pa��ona� liaense within �wo months from the date o� this public heazing; 2) The sales o�' alcohoiic beverages 9haX� be �estr�.cted 'to on premise consumption with no package sa3es; 3� The app3..ieant sha�l submit a copy of �,he parking agreement with Repu,bl..�c $ank �or overf�ow parking; 4 j No outdoor �.vud�peakers sha�.�. be permiCted; S} There sYiall be no outdoor en�ertafnment, i.ncludi.ng temporary events ot any kind; and �} Signage requiremen�s o� �he Ci�y Cad� shall be observed at a1� tim�s. Motion carried unanimously {4 �a 0}. p & Z Minutcs � 5/3194 � i;. p. A1tM51'RQNa !Il f1AUC� W. flAIt1�GS JOHi�I T. bLAKLLY DRUCE H. ItOK�R Af.fiX15 P. [3ROOK5 t3UY M. ElURNS MICHAEL T. CRONIT! DUANE A. UAIKEit .lOftNSON, BLAKELY, POP�, BOKOR, RUPPEL P� BURNS, P.A. ATTORN�YS ANU GOUNSIiI.LaRS AT LAW CL17�\IlETrt11. pAN1ElS LISA El. DO�OC MARIpN EiAL� REIIECCA A. HBNSQN IAM�S W, NUMANN SCO7T C. ItG�fiIl'Z FitANK R. JAlCES 7'IMOTHY A. �OIIN50N, JR. 5}lARdN C. KItICK JQIIN 1L I.AW50N,JR.• M�CItABL G. I,1iTLC 1�![GHA�L C. MARKHAhS STEPiiANIE'I: MARQUAiiDT DAVIU 1. OTI'tNGBR F. WAL4ACE POpE, JFt DARRYL R. RICHARDS Ap�il 25, '� 997 Reverend Father James Rousakis Greek Orthodox Church Of The Holy Trinity 409 Old Caachman Road Clearwater� FL 34625 Re: Conditional Use Application Dear Re�erer�d Father Ror�sakis ��-� .�/r y �y 7 C C, DCNNIS G. RUI'�'EL• , � � CiiARLGS A. SAMAiiK�S �7� JOliNA.5CFIA�FL'R �� [3E�'�iAhIP1 SClIAR�R PHZLIf' M. 5NA57EEN � CFiARLFS M. TAI'�LBAIJM IOAN M. VECCHIOLI ANTFiONY P. ZR+ICifi 1ULIU51. 7SCi{AU •OF COUNSEL PLEASE iIGPLY TO C[.�ARWATER fl�eko. 384fi7.97071 Please be advised that ti�is firm represents the property owners and the business owners aTfiliated with "Pianet 8ubba." Please be advised also that these owners have asked #he City of Clearwa#er City Commission to consider the City's Planning and Zoning Board's decisian to denied the owners' conditiona� use application. The �dministrative appeaS hearsng �s scheduled to take place on We�nesday, May 14, at 7 PM. 'I am uncertain whether you were aware of this proceeding� ar�d helieved that the Church should be informed. Please und�rstand that this firm is new io the matter. We were no# in�olved in #he preparation of the application or the Planr�ing and Zor�ir�g Board hear�ng. We have, hawever, re�iewed the a�plication, the Clty of Gleaswates sta#i report, and tha tape recording of #fte April 9 PlannEng and Zoning Board public �earing, ar�d under$tand that the Church strongly opposed the application. On behalf of the owners� and #heir recent administrative hearing request, i would appfeciate an opportunity �o meet witi� you� or a representative groUp of the Church� to discuss the application, #he Church's objections, and possib3e altematives to respond to the Ghurch's object�ons. E believe �uch a meetir�g would be more productive if it were limited in sizu. However, to ensure that we not exclude any interested member of the CLQAltWAiER OFFICti TA�iM OFFICG q� �� IDO NOR7l1 TAMrA 5iRE8T r45SOFF1Cg�17i 136i SUIT�' IIpO CLLARWATER, �i.(iA1DA J151T•IJ68 rOSTOFFiC[31lOX II00 TL4ErfiON� ¢Il)�61•Itl� TAMI'A, F40RIDA 33G01-1104 TCI.[Cp►IER(111]j1�1•[417 ' TELtlIII�NQ(�Iljl7l.2300 71!I.fCOrIBR [t 1!] 277•TI !: , r . .» , , �� 30HNSQN, BLAKELY, POPE, BOFCOR, Rur��t, & But�NS, P.A. AiTORNCYS AND COUN5ELLOFtS A'C I.AW Greek nrthodox Ch�rch 4f Th� Holy Trinity . April 25, '1997 Page 2 congregation, we will make oursel�es a�ailable for a second larger meeting, for any � church member or surrounding property owner. � . The owners have also iRdicated a willingness #o participate in one or both of � these meetings. The owners.desire to be responsible and cooperat�ve neighbors; and would appreciate an opportunity to engage in dialogue with fhe Churc� to attempt resolution of the objectians t�at are felt by th� Chufch's congregation. Please cal[ me direcfly at 461-'�818 #o disc�ss this request and #o coordinate meeting arrartgements. 1f [ am not avai�able, ( will ask my partner� who is equally ' familiar with the application; to participate in t�e meeting. I will also gladly coordinaie �he meeting aRangements with the owners. � ! took forward to heari�g from you. ' Very t yours, - , �. � v • � E. D. Armstrong II1 EDAIar � � cc: . Ms. T�ffany Wilder Butler � Mr. Todd Clem Oi27187.Ot ■ , �: � � � � ��K� ti� 3"�� `� 7 � �_c ` �.r l�c��y '�r�r��r ��r��l� C�r��+ad�x ��urc�� ` . � dd9 QLD GCiAChMAN �C�Ad � CLEARVIrA`i'�R, F'E-OH[DA 3a�s � � :- 7�LEPHONE �813) 78�8-484� � FAX (8�3} 795-8173 _ Q1ot�e ot A!lsr� Her,v. Fr. �� pq�s�ltls ��k�h0l1@: 79! •F�47 .i , � , ; • E.D..Atmntron,g, &.sq. � johllacni, �y� et �1, � 93 � L�ratnut St�rec�t ; - G'lc�rwatcr. ��. 34bI b-5b43 Aev. Fr. Eg�11oa Act�ppie� A�p�I3o, ts9? �s�t Yta T�t,�tcr 7'0 4�1-8��i 7 Resicter�oe P�orw: 7�5-27 sa R� C"ondit.�onal Use,�pp�iGat�+m of Pcaperty and �vai.nes� Owncrs A�Filiatecl wir�► "�'lan�t Bubba' i3�a�r M�r. AYmstt'ong; Ttu Presldcn� af our Church Pati,sh Coundl, IVS�rk Ysgos, and R�vcs+n�d �'�t�Z' R4t��,s, who both jaln in the rx�cctdon of � lettex, £anvarded y�our �ctu,r o�A�pri125 ta � for r�rirw arid reaponsG 'Thott�h th� Chtmc%► rcprcacr�tasivcs have no objoction ta a�nccting, wc bc�ev� thac t.hr fundamiental diffcrcnces that eYist u�e ne�r iaigos�� tb av�nG �e c�tuch �lts►s opp�s�d the a�nining use as a nighcclub in the pa�t. �nd �1 crntttiulv�e to do s6 on t.�u hm�lamcniai br�c� t.�utt A ni b ia � a�ntitht� of a and the�ar� an iac��tib� ad#oinln� use fn t�e oantext of th� �d zonin� f�v�t. . '1Ai�c i� L� tha� tha�� w�w spoke in �ppasit�on � thc iirs� � epcF�s�s:d>,; • �tunzacou� reaccmc �ox thtix �3tians, the unt�crlyinng t�trmr wxs, and r�utai�, the � �metual d�Ferences that a elnwc�ch and nightclub cannat vvecname. Should "Planec '�ubb�" v�h to o�t�t�nuc as a r�estgurant, aa �t h� t�te right ta da, we do nat, and wpu�d ' lnat e�q�Oress obj�Ctions� unitss th�ir c0�tduc� ix� the op�ra#ion 4� t�c yt+cst�ur�nt v�rirAt�ted � �me sak�an. "C�ef C�urle�s" op�atxd � a�stau�runt xt thst locaticm ive y�t�s w�t�out . uttyr typc a� i�ctipa�t a� w�r t+ellg�aus acrr►icxs� edwcatia�nal pxogr�nn6 anci cultu�ral �nta. . I aai �c that yocu partncr, N�r. 5amarkas� aa a member of thc governing bo�rri at St � ��o1a� �huirh in `�hr� Sp�ga would ag�e tk�at, �tt � Gretk cammunity, the church = dnvitan�en�i►t is gcued t.o�ward the at,ability vf tht �a�ani�y', ��nemost th�ou�t �igion but ': aXao t#uro�t�g,h ather xe�atec� edu�cat�oa►� u►d cu�wxx�l gxog,rama, � ; .� � I L1A ' �hHr� �avi�ng eet �'o�th our pasition, vv� w�lrnrne yowr feedback ndvidng o� the n�turc N�-�nn� f1 I f1M �H��N t.� i.�n�� R R: G1 T J F. G1 G' ?� .! W ,, • � . _ 0 A � Apr�134, � 99? Pa�e 2 ��►1 of th� "poa�ible altcmatlr►ca" �o�d i�n your lectcr so th�t wc can evaIe�au whcther a m�ecting couid bc p�vdurtEvC. Hvw�vr.r, wr �nd it ri�icuZt ta crxv�s�a� � pia,n th�►t wvuld pr�dcvo thc go�ls v� ova' chtu�, +�nd allaw the Parlsh Counc� to �ll �ts respon�bil�ties tA the mcmbcra a� our chmnc �caunu�ty. A� s flnal noce, shoc�d. you � tv d�s this matter further, you may di�ct yovt �Fondcnc� w my vf8ce, as icgal uh�sor aad ootiu�srl to �Toty T�xn�ttjr Chuu�h gt � G�Td b'� Itcr�i� � F.A. 7� Wc.r� Ba,p Str�at Tampa, � 336�Ni �x. rra 8xs,2s�aa�r �a Faar No. Sx3 ��-UlS�6). A�t�ennatJ�vdy yva an�y xdd;�ess y+aur corn�spondcnae tiQ xv�ir. L�g�as �s Presld�nt of the �axia�t� Counci2 at thc Chwrch atrcct gd.c3ress� with a�py t.o rne {I w�ould aot roneidcr it a�t ethiral v�nfadan fa�r yrau tQ c�omn�ut�c�ttc dfrrct�y wlth ZVk. I�gas, b�t �+rs�tvz the rig,llt ta ra�ui� oonununics}tiaats ttu+oug� my o�i`xce in the tuturc, if nearas��ryj. AI�o, t�u ope:�i� stnsc�un c� ot►r churCh plaaa thc obligation. Co amduct th� busin�ss nF the chu�rii on the Pariah Caur�il. 'Th� prlest dc►es not h�v� the autha�ity zo bind t�u cht�rch 3n admY�trat3v� rr�tr�, tttus the xeasan far redirxeng fu�rc arrmmunicattons to �my�df vT Mr. I�g�. Ifyou �'iu[rni�h � Y�our Propoaod "�itd�t�a�itvts" so that the �t may ba dis�cd by th� Chtur�t a�Qdrs. � wil� be keappy to d�vsx the aam�e w�th }►��. � .� // .� n � ' �� . 200'3Jdd ' —»..�EK�.u.�,:r�..y.;.,s,: �-:s,,.....,. �............ �!�i; �. ►� r�1 •s�+a_ �U�Y Y��, NS-AdO� alnb shS��Nid w0a� � � 60 � 0 i LB �@E adti i � E. D. ARMSTRONG IIi pRUCE W.RARNFS �afw r. g��a.Y �Rl10E H. HOK�R GUY M, BIJRNS MICHA�I. T. CAON�J DUAN& A. UAiKER a,I7aifk it[ J. DAN�? _c � 5' \.� �OHNSON, BLAKELY, PQPE, BOKOR, RUPP�L & BURNS, ATiORNEYS AKA COUNSELLpRS AT S.AW / : : .1I� I r + 11SA U. WDGE MAItlON 11ALE JAMFS W. NllhtANN 5C0'['I' C.ILGEN�IiI'Z FRAT[K R.lAK�S TIMOTEiY A. !O#�150N, !R. SWSiON E. !{RICK ROGER 11. [.AR50N Michae! E. �c��;:��,, �squire Gold & Resnick, P.A. 704 West Bay Street Tampa� Fl� 33606 10iiH R. [11WSQN, JR.' MiG13AF.L G. LTi'iZ.E MlCiiAF.L C. MAAK}{AM STEP}lAN1E T. MARQUAItDT UA�IID I.OI`TR�tQ£R F. WALLJICE PQPE, JR. UA3lRY1. R. RICFGIRDS DENNlS �. RifPP�I.• May 8, '� 997 � �� P.A. s�t�� CFIARI.�S A. SAMARKO� G 10iiN A. SCFiA�R PHlLIP M.5HA5TF•EN CFiARLF.S M. TA7'ELUAUM 20AN M. VECCiilOW A?v�3ER WII.l.IAMS lULIUS J. 7SCfUU •OF COUN5F1. ��. �� ,� L y !� � �.i PLFJI3E RF1'LY TO CLF11li �.E�.3e s7.s7o7� Re: Conditiona! Use Application of Property and Business Owners Affiliated with "Pianet Bubba" Dear Michael: This letter is in response to your correspondence to Mr. Armstrong dated Apri1 30� '1997. Mr. Armstrong, as mentioned in correspondence to Reverend Father RousaKis, is out-of-town for the nex# week and asked me to respond to your correspondence. Ou� c[ients' request for a meeting with the Church Parish Council stems ftom a desire to see if we can address some of the concems ra�sed by those who spoke in opposition to my clients' appliaation a# the first hearing. My clients also want to establish a dialogue with the Church Parish Council in order to show their good taith efforts to become good neighbor� with �he Church and i#s parishioners. The issues my clients would propose discussing with #he Ch�rch Parish Council, ine{ude patentia� buffers between the Church and my clients' b�asiness, discussion of hours of operation, issues regarding security guards andlor other sec�rity arnangements, as well as any other anangemer�ts that may be brougttt to my cCients' attentions regardsng altema#iv�s that may mitigate !he impact of the operation of my clients' b�siness on #he Church. Ci�ARWAl'� OfT10E f l I Q�.'S7'NIJC Si�tF�T tosr o�c� sox u� c�►�w��, Fr.o�� ubt t-: sar il�J.flF1ol�IE: i� u) �a l•S �i � fACSO�ID.Y (�Il) N1�817 TA1yPA O�ICE iD0 NORT:1 T�1�4A 571tELT surse i�oo rosr qrF�c� aox s ioa TAMPA, FI,ORIUA 31602•5143 TF�.frH6TiE (� I!} 223.IS00 FACSIINIL� (tl]) 2T7.711t � E i��lj� nT��:•i;'�i�'��e,:y+r" e, ' �' � y+a�� 1�.,,. 5' �if, � y.s,�'!� t yy � �f�� f �� ''i'a R6 �� , � -S,�e'!� ��t,y� � yy��1'�++SSfy�� .�i� 'iS�iit',ar'i�,"`� -�'s� . � �'�� ' � � � ��>�`',: �"`i. ti:, �j. .��„ id `�htKd:''� 14�yj`. f7�{* �[ ��`�*+4��.YK �j�c' �h;�i'� (F: h�Er�3 .J �J" �i''.'�i"�w'FL � % ��i`?1.:� . . .. 'x � � sr � yFa�t it'� rx e�E�rYS�. tir �e i" �! ��t� ^t�1 i' v:,r;^�'"'� F" �'� t'' !',','. .G��'?�Y °� �i �.'..',:p ^ c.jY, < :� . �� 7P'��. ��1�':r�j 'A, ♦ .rJ��':�3�d��.{i r.��.,=�::; r. - �j�Stn;��r�.s\.Y"4'�.�r��-1"li�.i�`�+�t:i.f;7:� �.,� � y �i%. ;; "4 � � 42,N t �;...��sbt i l. T�.. 1$ .:>� .:r ( <�;� +, y1� F� r� $I �..5; l i'�� 1`� '�'.i',.;=,''' �� "� � . ,��j..;i�' . ]�� s ' � �yz�,v... s F, s`�' �a:, ti, „�.;}.•�,� t,ol.� ?-�t' �11"z.�f� Pi�E� � ' ;1C :ft ��CiR..i. P YR !i{.� j��n�5 f. � �k^, � l ,�yJ� � �i'' • ° ,;�!• .�'�t?�3 � • ,s �;.'i. zr =;� ! ' c:'?',: i � .l�,,�,t �„�� e•'� �' !•:�t, < . 1:t4��,��3.' Iv u.t<: `�4z .J.:�i . .,..1',..i�: �=.,'-'�i�t:��j'd� i-yl��`•'ti��:,F ��.�. '�.f ��i��: .t . tir#.-_',�`� if i ,'.i .�� .'T,�'"� ��- ''.`:s.� :F;'... . �zl�k:r,::�.y�_.,.� ...rt�y:�i '%��,"�;e�^`� }�;�� `-'.�-,",�.�':.. ;�' r.t; K.:d� E: jr'«f`e%Gv�}v;'r. a;�:�, °�7;': . j ..ttr,�t. e �..j }�,:i." ,�'�' r'ti�S �4+;� S�rFp :�. . Y,S, , .•y.a 'i (>Y� :��. .�15.� :�1?��"r1��'.�.�. � .t.�gi�� f.�jF' �i 1�f �.i.i�.�'..r�',�s). '�Fr�� .. ,��.,,, . is �.'i:; Yi' �{: �d. .,��`,�,�1� ` ' ' " i •r,: !j.—lz�.:i�.!'..;.C» i '% .1' s�,. �, Y;��..`�'..'.�,'..{��:�'�':'S�•r„-', ' }'93 e'!iS ' C�� ;,i�J � �( s�",+• S.'yi`. rli i-��+. 4x;•-x t.J , �F! �ei:�;'4;a'i'.. ,TSZ�� '�,d�L '1 rC �'', :ip i.k. .;.: ;:�, :c. '. . �.f..j_r��'� t�..,rt `,f.�:,•.�. alr . �:''4: ii, if : �f•'rtt1 '�i6�� " �: A' l:Y.�;��..°,�Y•1 1i� �.�4 • - . .. '.. .f�'.t`,. .��.' �.. �i• �,. p'rs+:: .{ 'E�::'�.J: �: ,.�?< <,y..,� s�1tT �;_,, ,�,Fr�e .�iv�k'F�•1:< "�:�. .,�:r. "kM/ �.�`.� 3.1r,,.�';" 1•' r'' �. ' ii>� �1�1'd;`y.,'i ^p ... ,. :�°. ��o' . '.5`•�`, f� U�•i d . `�'�� `''� •�! 7i:f S.'R;s�J 1,�i3,}F`'�F�. ' ''�{, o ..y ' °. ':�'; "r� . �;, ��:_ 4.,fi . „�'F" i �St� �s ��i S?1''''�' �" �'F. +�"• ' , . i . s��a�*: ��: +�y .i?�5� _,�;, g•�..r'� . �ti;;: .r�r. '1:�.'.: `,,'�S'•�':..:`:...,,,r,'rn :iys,i �� '4��'(a.�.`.':1':.±;_ �r` r:o�..�'. . `f, •�s� �'j,:.a� .li' � � •'s` (,i�' .`:y; �•ti: `'?�h��l�".1�'1��'i�a»i.".y��{�F,�,�,. ;�"rj� o •.r'"�..�'i�; s��. ,'}�.;�.tiy�J" ,�.�E� jf, ,`� ,.�•'��4:jy�.y?�i�}•�r zi't��l�i�1�:..'q�.E ,•�l��i�`3�;_��i..r'�j1.' . { S•` i;".�" 3 ..,��^.:,C' � � i c,,, � .1t`''``1� :.s r;, ,'' �s j�.: ..�'C.:,a...�r �.Ss.r S"�{at��K7 :r^�xCii;;. e.� .7:�' p�� J �I �t.�.i_ ��` , `��`� f � '�' : .F j i^� :'a � i••�•.� � ! ° ;� � : . ','r. .' � k:i��:'� v r.�v�,. � . r,. t . �e;ip � . . . � '!', ��.'��f!`• , . .��5 ' ': ;�t:'�: ��51'�.i�',�U;J}�ie�l��.:',f�.'iti�' . t. . . . :l,t . � k'ti' j .' ."�:1�`'.... � . . o ' , '�•�' y�. '�1r' . .�i . .t .. �'i' C� ,t', F � t � �Gf'�•'��!'��: � [ ..!•� F ' . � . . ..:�. tr.' ?z,t'. ., .z:� �.. , �3:'� ;�.,. � �1�''� ,) r Ii�r .�3.'��'�•i•.;r.;�'�:i „Mf�' �•. . . . ti �r�,:;�A�.'•�,:l��i Pi�'�� ..E',�..• ' ,i;; ,� ' , . .. j :�. � �:� :_f:, .�:.�.i° �, 3v��n•.i..�. �;� .ti'�; � ,i "Y ; Ei �jj �.,, ��„ 4 ' . ? ''i''�w.),` , "\i`�•�1.•� 5:��. � ��•t,- �' it. � ' V � � . . .'7.�',;' �f�.;�� 6 �` .�*��' •�. , t .� =�`,?�. t i : � e ' � . ' ... .�.t�. �i.€: ..1i.1.�' � � . � . :I - . ' . . . .�� '�5`fi�,.,� .';�� . I . , , , � ' . , ' � . . , • . • . L.yF � ' wd: f � '', .! •. � . • ' ' . . . ' . . . :��'1i` i�t. �4:, ,� . . . . ' , . .S` �t °�� ' � ' � V - , . ' .. , ' �. - ' , - � ' �i� • . ' . . . � . . � . � � � ....�.a..M'��MT+S� Rbh'MY.�'�S71�IS�FrMM+i�..�rwrw..--....w-.w..,....r . . . .. � . . . .... .......�.-w+w+rwl��NA''1yTN1tw...,, � . . . . ..... -�. c-- � �x� � .IOHNSON, B�.AKELY, POPE, BOKQR, RUPPEL & BLIRNS, P.A. AY'iORt��YS ANO CQU1�I5�iL[,ORS Ax LAVI � Michael E. BoutzauKas, Esquire May 8, 1997 Page 2 As a follow-up ta flur recent telephone con�ersation, ! want #o reiteraie that after re�iewing the file, i could not locate any agreement with Florida Power regarding parking a�angements. f do � want to be accused of misrepresenting any#hing to your or the church. I value my reputation in this community and iherefore am advising you once again that I do not have any p�rsonal knowledge of any agreement between my clients and Florida Power regarding a parking easement. Attomey Tom Long, in correspondence to the City of Clearwater, has represer�ted tF�at such an agreement exists, however, I do not have any agreement in my file. � would reqcaest that you respond directly #o me in Mr. Armstrong's absence. Thank you for your attention in ti�is matter. CAS:kme ot�TSSa.o� Sincereiy, (� G�-�. f.r� �' . ��,C.. Charles A: Samarkos � �� f . e��1�°v F��C'�C�c"� � � � ��oo� �vwer .pv,,. May �, �997 Mr. E. I�. Armstrong III 7ohnson, Blakely, Poge, � Bakor, Ruppel & Burns, P.A. 911 Chestnut Stre�t Clearwater, FL 34616 Dear Mr. Armstrong: • Y'"'-`� � � . l i� 1 a�� , {�t•. .,�., l�.�� t��- . , �,. y �j.7 Florida Power Corporation's Real Fstate Department has received your client's Application for Right-of-Way Utilix.ation for use af a portion of our transmission comdor near G�lf to Bay and Old Caachman Road, The application will now proce�d through our �orma� approval proc�ss which includes research by Real Estate Department staff, and review by a committee made up of representatives from aII affected azeas of the company. As you know, Florida Power has a long-standing agreement with the Holy Trinity Greek Orthvdox Church for use of the same property for overflow pazking. Any agr�ment with yauc cli�nt must not conflict with our existing agreement with the churc�. 'I'his should not present a roa�black in the approval process, since the previous business operator at yor�r client's location, Jams n' 7ava� a3so �ad ari agreement for use of the property in question. Usage was granted subject ta certain sp�cified candidons set by Florida Power. This previous docume.�t expired when payment was not received in Qctob�r of 199b. Florida Power must honor its agre�ment with the church; however, this need not prevent a second agreemen� for use of the same property by your client. 1"�ie process will simply requ�re a little cooperation amang the affected parties. Sincerely, . A Michaef G. Meidel North PinelIas Area Manager cc: George Townsend Tom Long COMMIlfVITY R�LATlDN5: 908 ClBVela�d Street • Clearwater, FL 34616 •(8131 662•5739 • FAX i8i31442•6275 A Florida Propress Campsn y oaio�iu� zo;zs �ts�it �. �w�Mrn cM�lO �, errmrM�C�p nQpc�lt i. 00�.4 C11Ap1�+►. W1i.�Ofi LIM[SA N. DYIWIK i.riLlC WAGLI! HIJODCI� fi�* T. KIKitM�OpD Dwv3D 6� K4ex� durxc N. uwK[pT v,.�,��c sswcew urse►sa TMOKAI 0. LONO ?l1RHAtL O. M��Cf1 rt��D re. R�,p�[ acorr a. er�a�. ''�4d1861i �ARNETT, r JO@1SOf3-$LAKI.EI' Bo�.T, Kr�xwoo� ATTORN�Yi A'Y LAW �u�r� �oo 8f3i �l+�YSHGRE Bqt1l.�VARL1 ��r��. �e.o�ta� a�aoe� May 1, 199'7 S�ave Dvherty Central permitting ��ge�rtmant Poat Office Sax a7�i8 Ci�arwater, F3,orl.da 39618-gT48 Ra: BTLS Enter�ainment �x_nc. DQar �teve: � r� LoNc lma02 �sr"! � ��,�b�`-� �S C [. � �.�`'f�J SII�[R� � {, � �T.L��t�t t�l.i1 ��J•�C10 � a�s� esi.r�u �u11�1fG /�DDAL'S'Sr fC1�i OFF1C[ 60X J �67 i/Ulr.�„ FZ.ORl�A � 7Q0) Via Hand Delifery: ` This 1,awfirm represents STLS Enter�a3rfinent� Znc. Th�.s lettc�r confirms �h�t STLS En�er�ainment, xnc., nas besn assigned �he authority �o resume th� Jams and Java business operation at 2a16 Gulf ta BAy Boul�vard, Cloarwater., Florida. BTLS �nterta3.n��nfi.r Inc. agree$ �o be bound by �11 vf th� terms and conditidns r�f �ams and Java's conda.tion��, use perm3.t, and agrees �a a�rial period of ope�sa��.on. HTLS Enterta�,x�ment agre�� tc� aubmit f�r an immad3.at� �ri.al review, whi�ch tria]. vperstian wi].1 b� r�viewed a� rhe May 20, 3997 P3,anning ar�d Zon.�ng Board me��inq, a� which time the Planning and 2oning Board shal� dete=mi.ne whethex the appraved u�� has sufficientXy campll.ed wi�h the� estaialished canditivns vf appxov�l �or Jams and Java. However, in the int�r�.m, 4TLS, xnc. will also proce,�d on fti� own conditianal use application. � B��B Enter�ninmen� agre�e� Co provide two �ecurity pexsonnel to poSies the parki:ng lot be�wec�n �lie hour� o� 14:00 p.m. and 3:00 a.m., Friday and Saturday n,�gh�s. TiffanX Sut�,e►r and Todd CZem, as joint owners ct 8'�LS, znc. are authoriZed by the owner c� the sub�ect property to make all appl�ca�i,on� nea�s�ary to reeaice�bYish the Jams �nd Java bu�i.ness . Eurther, the �pp�i.cant ha� an agreement with Floxida Power to use tihe ad�acent zight at way a� addixional �aarkir►g. Very t�uly youxs, BARNETT, BOLT, KzRKW00D � I.ONG �.----. r� Thomas G. Ld "�- -.�.•..:s'.�.#.'...._t`tF: �..v !i" roH.v...+-.r . .. �, '� �� cUZZ� �r�a� REw:ji� �i�.�� e�aS��b�L�T ��,;�f ��9,� . �� RIGINAL � 1 � 7 f � s TNES LZMITED LiCENSE �RIVlLE�E AaREEMENT� Made �nd catered in�o this 24TH day or ��Q , 1942, by snd bctwecn �T.ORIDA POWER CORPURATION, � F�o�ida ao�paratlon� 'L�CENSOR' hcrcin, and GREEK ORTHODOX CHURCH OF THE HOLY TRINITY. 1N�, a Florfda nat-lor-pro[�t oarporaE[o�� A09 Old Coschman Rnad� Ctearwatcr, Flo�lda 34625, 'LiCENSEE' hcreln; WITNESSETH: WHEREAS� LICENS�R I� 1he'owner of the i'ee simple �[t!e to (amang other lands) an ctcctric trattsmission tine right-o[ w�y strlp huvtng nn averagG wldth o� �pprozimstely 248 fx� and generally oampr(stng thc rvcsieriy 2A8 fee! nE thc E 1R oi NE 1/4 0[ Sec��on 18, Taamshtp 29 SoWh. Range �6 East, Pinellas C.ounty, Florida (sub�ect to mad right-ni-way oi dnlf-to•Bay Bouteva�d� Otc� Coachman Road snd Arew Str�et)� wi�it �he scgmcnt af sald s[rip extending nnrthward from �he nnni� ctght-u�-w�y llnc a[ Guif-to-Bay �oulevard fo� a�proxlmaidy SSU leet ind ending ��J�raximatcly 25 feet sauthward of the sautherly Icgs at L[CENS�R's palre;d transmisston towers HD-35 and NC•Sp being herefnaRer referred ta as thc "Lianse Arta' Snd with 1he localion a�d etttent of said Lianse Area being substantlaliy as depEctcd on pr�nt of sketch at�ached heroto as Exhibit "A' and by thi� referenx �nmrporated hercin and madc s p�n hcreof; and WHER�AS, LIC�NSE� �S dcsirous of acqu[ring irom LZCENS�R �he I�mited privilcge and Itanse tv ocxupy and u�E11u tht Uat3se Area far over�nw vehlc+slar parking an the naiural grass or turf surfaoe sRd fendngfiedgir�g of the ptr�meler and INHEREAS, LICENSOR ��ri[ling to grant �o LICENSEE thc dcstscd ttmlied priviscge and l�cense for such oocei�rancy and nl[Ei=ation, subject tn artain terms and oonditlor� � slipulatcd below aTa�g with srecitic rcqutrements as shown nn ntt�chr.d Exhibit 'B' nnd by �hls roferr,nac YnoorparatGd hcrctn aad ma�e a part hereof. NOW, THEREFOttE, IT 15 MU'I'UALLY ACiREED AS FOLLOWS: A. That LICENSOR hercby �rsnts �o LICENSEE, ana LICENSEE htreby axepts from LICENSOR. the [imitcd prlvllege and llanse la oecupy and utiltze the Ltcense Arca for the sale purpose at avetAow vehicular �arktng on the nalu�al �ass or turf surfaoc and fencing/'hcdging of Ihe perimeter �ogethcr wi�h such ather ltmtted privilege and 1laense u may bc reasonably r�eassary ar convcnient for the full enJaymcnt of #he Llcxnae Area fa� thc a�nve purpose onty. � • 6. That fnr end �n oonsideratiar. a[ the lo�egotng timited pt;rilege and licensa. ��ie LICENa"EE hcreby cavcnants to pay to LZCENS�R � ycarly fee, in an amaunt equal t� �ha pro ra�a port�on oC tach year's actaa! ad vafarc�t rea� estate Eax+as attribatablc to thc Ltcettse Area. {For gu�pases hereof. snch tax smount sha1E mean thc ne� amount piyable �[!cr dcAuc![ng the maxlmum d[soount al�o�wable by law for prampt payment.) LlCENS�R shaft, upon teai}�! ot e�c6 ycar's �:uc bill, mall a billing �nvolce to L�CENSEE far paymcnt. LiCENSEE's yearly ttc checks shall bc madc paysb�c to FLORIDA P�WER CQRPORATiON and maltcd to LiCENSO�t. � • G It is cxprcss[y stipuEa�cd by thc said L10EN50R and LiCENSEE that thls Llansc Agrccmcm Is a licensc f�r permissive �tse anly and Ih#t !he plac�ng af �ny �mprovement upan the ptaptrty pursuant to th[s Agrament shall not opera�e la crcate or vest any praperty rlght la said LiCENSEE D. It is eupressfy stt�ulatcd by thc sa[d L�CEN50R and LICENSEE that thc privitegcs prorridcd herein create na perpe�ual rtghls but �eterminable privikgcs deptnding solcly oa thc oondi�ton� in tt�� Agrexmcnt a�d mt no t�mc s1�a!! ihis Lianse Agrccment be rnr�.s�rucd as � Llcxnse ooUplcd wlth an fnteres�. ll�t7 l. !NI �I ....,�... ^w____ _ �� _. Tha� L[CENSUR's coritta! to LiCENS�E's use of thc prnperty dcsctibcd hcreln (S Ilmitcd. Such oana��ianat and ics�rictcd c�onscnt creat�s pri�ileges !� �he LICENSEE ta use the land oniy insoCar as aamptiancc wiil� thc c��diNc�ns hcre�rt i� oantlnued. F. That LiC�NSOR �xpreufy rcservcs un�o I�scff, Its suc�ssnrs, �rssccs �nd assigns, �hc ron�inutd tight lo occupy and ui�ifxc the cnttrc Llocnse Arsa and to grant to Qthcr parlirs such �ar�vilegcs affccling !hc l..�anse Area as �ra not inaor�s[sient with privileges �ercin granted. C3. That LlCENS�R agrta ta in[arm LtCEHSEE Ihirty (3U) days bet'ore oonstruclfng addlHona! electrlr�l iaciHties vv�t�in Ihe L.foensa Art� so that �.tCENSEE ran fetocate or remove the utiifratlon desctlbed herotn shnufd LlC�NSQR dctetminc tt�at sUCh ultfixattan wou[d interfert with LiCENSOR's [ac��itfes or use oi said arra. H. "�'hai upon LIC�NSEE's breach oi any oovenant ar cnnditian contained herein, thts Llcense Agrtement alter wrl�tcn notiRration by LZCENSOR b LiCENSEE o[ such brcach and upon faCfvra a!' L�CENSEE �o remcdy or rem�ve such breach wlthln a periad ot tive (S) wa�king days a[ttr receipt of snch wrltten rtotifieattoa. sha» ccas� aad tcrminatc snd shall bccomc null and void aod Ihc prlvifege and �icense herctn graRtcd sha�] thcrcu�on �mmtdla�cly revcrt �o tnc LlCENSOR !n absalute, howcvcr� LICENSOR expressty dves �ot waive any rights ot rrcourse L10EN5�R may have againsl LlCENSE� (ar damages sustained by LiCE�ISOR as a resutt of such brcach. . �. 'i7iat LtCENSOR heteby earpressty reservcs It�c t�gt�t �o r�voke thEs Lictnse Agrccment at will by giving LfCENsEE tt�irty (30) clays' written nottoe, $r�d �.ICEI�SEE sha1� h�ve �o rig�! ro aorr��nsa!!on inr any acpendttur+�s by LICENSEE upon revacatinn oC this Lianse Agrecment. 3, That ar�y oosts. a�to�ncy's fecs or expcnscs incurrcd by LICENSUR ir� wnstruit�g or enrarcing ihls Liccnse Agreeme�t �ha11 be borne by the L�CENSEE. K. That Ihis privilege and ItcenSC is pcnonal ro LlCENSEF and sha[I nat b� assigried �r traRS[erred in wholc or in part wi�l�out Ihc express prior writtcn conscnt of LZCENSOR, 'which ca�scnt af LICENSOR shal! be solely at LICENSOR's disc�etion. L. 'rhat �hc valfdi�y c�[ �t�is Agreemeni is cnntingent upon LiCENSE� lirst obtaining propet zoning, aut�ority, approva� andlor �ermlt from the a�pro�riatc governmental body or public agency having jurisdiction t�vcr snrh util�ration at this lac�tlon, lf suc� zo�ing, authority, ��provat andlar permlt is tlat stcured, thls Agrecment wiH bc ca�siderc� nul! ur�d void. M, That L[C�NSOR shati not be liablc idt any ctamages �o UCENSEE's util[z.attan howsoever resulttng fram LtCENS�R's oonlit�ued use and ocru�aRty o! the Lfce�sd 1�sa; L�CFNSOR, however, sha1� �ot will[u11y causc un�ut damagc Io LiCENSEE's e�liiization. N. `Rtat LICENSOR's Transmissiot� Righ�s-or-way t�,SP��tn� �i.c., Mr. Jasc�rh G. Brnwn, Jr. or his designatcd aiternata, �elephone 8131 866•SlQ9. St. Petersburgj sE►a1t be nntificd by LiCENSEE at leasi lor�y- elght (48) hours prlar to LiCENSEE's rnmmencing inftial ac�[vi�ics wi�htn the Liccnse Area. O. Thai LICENSEE shafl be res�ronsiblc for clean ap of any and a1l sptils �hat may occur w�thin the Llsxr�se Arr.�, Such apills must be rcnortcd to LlCENSOR �mmcdiately, P. 'Ii�at a�ree �ttd easl�y �asS�ble �wr��y loo� (ZIl') widc ac�e55way be retnined Alang th� lenglh a[ thc Ltansc Area and to a�� transmisslort slrucl�rrs for usc by LICENSOR �ar cm�rgcnry acccss at�d tor normal matntenanoe and pa�rol purposcs. Q. That I.ICE�IS�E shail not use a dragt�nc or cabtc typc crar�e wirhin the Llcensc Arca. !l'�I S +f��. � � ��t �, ��" �' �� r��r � Page 2 af 4 Pages �. . . R. 'Iliat LtCENSEE ah�i[ udhcrc to prnvisi�ns in NE5C regarding rlearanocs �nd �leclric rondu�lors. Gro�nd c�cvation must nal be Incrcascd morc than two fcet (2'), �X�, � bciwccn ground Icvci S. That �f Ihe utillzatint� arta ls [cnccd LiCENSEE a3�a11 lns�all a stxtecn foot (I�i'} widt gatc In the feooe tnaldn� that pariion n! thc Llanse Area accessible. Gate shou[d �ave a�ack inslal[ed by LiCENSC3R. T. 'i7iat LICENSEE shall assumc 1hc snlc du�y. res�nsibiiity and obtigatlon at mvwing and otherwise main�aining �ha su�facx of the portion o[ �he Ltcense Area upon and across 1hc land �avoived t� a oonditi�n campatibic wi�h the surrounding area. U. That the entire dtsturbed area withiri Ihe Llccnsc Area inc�uding LICENSOR's patrol road, Shal! be restored by I.ICENSEE �o a condltlo� at lcast as good as Ihat which exisstd priar to conslructian. W, 'mat utson corr�p�elio� af opetatEoas. LlCENSFE shal! nntify LICENSOR'� Transmisslon Rights- o� Way Itupector hereto�orc menitnntd in abavc Paragra�h "N" for Inspectlnn o[ 1he Llr.cnse Area. W. That LlCENSEE xhall �urnlsh LlCENSOR with a set of as-built drawings within thirty (30) days af tinal mnStruction. X. 'Tijat LIC�NSEE harcby expressly understands. aovenanis and agrces (a} thai nothing cantaincd fn Ihls Agrcemen� or cantemplalcd �S intended �o or shafl lncrease UCENSOR's iiab�lity Cor personal inJury ot dealh nr tor any property damagc, (ty) that LiCENS�R dncs nat assumt any such additinnal Itabiliry� (cj that ltabilisy artsing qut of tbe Utilizatio� snd accupanry a[ LZCENSOR's Liocnsc Arta by LICENSEE and LICENSEE's employees�agc�ts. cantractors, Invi�ees ar any represeniat[ve, Is hereby assumed by LICENSEE and sna11 bc at !he sQle and axclusivc risk nf LICENSEE. (d) that LICENSEE shall answer and SatisFy ta L10EN50R's satisfac�ioR ar�y and ali complaints rNativc to LICENSEE's utt{izalian o! UCENSOR's Ltansc Arca (c) tl�a� LICENSEE sl�all pralcct. defcnd; hold harm[ess and indcmnify LlCENSOR from and agatnst any and a1l acEions, claims, damages at�d/or toss, inciudtag msts and atro�ney's fees, ocrasionW by or growing ant of any actetai or claime� u3age vr cor�ditian or LICENS�R's Uccr�se Ar� arising in any ma�ner whatsaever, direct�y or Indirec��y, by rrason o[ th[s Agrcemcnt fo� LtCENSEE's utiliratinn ther�of� and {� that LrCENSEE covenarits not �o intcrfeta with LiCENSOR`s t�cisting and [uturc hig� vostagc ctulrtc transmisslort Iines and re�lcd (acilities in any rnanner whatsoever and shaq ful{y indemni�y LtCENSOR irom afny and all loucs as in 5cctina '(ej` abovc Tesvlling �fom Surh iniccfcrcnce. Y. '!i►a� L[CENSEE's opera�tans, activitics an�1 cqui�mcn� used wi�hin the License ,4rca beneattt or in ptaximity ta any o[ LTCENS�DR's eieclric Facifitics shall, a1 a11 times, he tn strict mmplianre with ap�licable provisions of the National Elcctrical Saftly Cade {NI�SC) and lhc Qrcupa�iona[ Safety and Hea[tSi Act o[ 197! (OS1�A). LICENSEE ls fur�her notiT�ed an� herc�y �grecs �a sa notlfy any of LICENSEE'a er��loyees� agen�s, rnntractors, representatives or other perxnn5 cngaging 1n L{CENSEE's activi�Ees upon said License Area with LlCENSEE's knowledgc andvndcr L�CENSEE's suncrvi5inn or cantrol, �hat cxtr�me caution is n�cessary arnur�d a!I af LiCENSOR's dcctrIql [aeiiftics, surporling 51ruc�nres, andtior guys ar relatcd a�purttnaaces� �nd !n the tver�t ot any damages or lnjuries, LICENSEE shall immedialety report thc r�atura and cxient thereof to LICENSOR's ncarest lacaf a[fict, 'Z That as a safegnard io res�cct ta Patagraph 'X' abave, LICENSEE will carry po{Icies of insurance exeptabie lo LiCENSOR wi[h respect to ac�erai LtabHity with 8adi�y l�)ury 1[mits not lrss than S2D0,000 each pe�son and S500�000 each accurrrnce and with Froper�y Damagc limlts n�t less than SSQ,UOU each occurrcnoe and 5100.C)00 aggrcgatc. L[GENSEE wltl havc.the ir�surancc �aticies mentianed cr�dursea by thcir fnsurance catricr �o provide blanket mn�racluat covcragc txpressly with respect to Paragraph "X' a6ove, ta Ihe full llm�ts nf and for Ihc Ilabqitics lnsurcd nndcr said paSicies; and pr(or to rnmmcnring initial construc�ion �ctEvities rvithin �he Liccnse Area� LECENSEE wil! furnish LlCENS�R with a com�te�ed certificate, in dupilcate. nR the attached Moditted Form 9U8 a04 (S) evldcnc{ng insu�ance aoverago o[ tha Ilabiliry assumed Undcr smid Paragraph "X". � ITIAl. I 1� Iq�k Pagc 3 of 4 Pagcs C. � � � �� . . _ � . . ... .... ... ... _.. _. _. ... . � � . , �, .�� 1N WlTNESS WHERE�F, thc sat�I LiC[�NSOR and LICENSEE hAVC caused thcsc prescnls lo b d 1 h i I i h d c cxccute n t eir respect vc cor�raratc names by ��c r prarcr o[Tice�s t ercunto u1y authorizcd.. a�'d �he�r.,, respecttvc carporate seals �v �� hcreu�to atRxcd and a�lcs�ed. all as a! the day and year tirst abovc ' Q��i��„r,, , ,�, •:,. � Signcd. scaled and dclivcrcd FLORiDA P��NER C�RPORA `:�� •``� ,� �,,�•.:�' �' En the resence of: as L10EN �'''' r' !' r�� : � P { , ) � i ; ; : ;i �, � � .� : � . . ,: �'� �..,, . -. � .. � ,• ' .. t:� C.► J • Cr '•�.,. �, • �y �: •• ,°... '�•: ' V� P csidcnl � �' � . �'.,,,,., r 1 i . . pOW� ,.,,.,,.. •� oA R c► Attcsl• 5igncd� xcatcd and dell�crcd in the presensx af: �' . 3�.�.. , , t�11TIAL INl L, � ' . . e � o � LECn� nErr. � � APPROV�D l ��1� � 1�. \ �Y i 0 0 GREEK ORTHODOX CHURCH Ot= THE HOLY TRINZTY, iNC. {as LICENSEE) By� - �' � �� Costas Panagintopovlos� residcnt ATi'EST: Secrc�ary , 0 Page � o! 4 Pages . ew�..r��n� �n. r� u� er e�c� �o�o .--..#...... F.P.C. F�E-0WN�D Fi/W �i--�—� F.h.C. iFtANS. C�N'��RLl�lE UC�H�� AFiEA (QRA83 PARI(iNi�5F3RUB3) � ._...�. . piN�«AS couNnr S�C.18� T-29-S, R-1 &E �r� rs rar�r �► sv�+�,..,, srr� sx� oktn � � � � � �, ��i„ ._...._..�.._.._..�..�...�...�.._.._ iOAD No. 60 (GULF TO 8AY BI.VD,) c� .. , � �� ,- ��r EXHIBIT "A" F�orida t'ower GREEK ORTHODQX CHURCH OF �-�-e2 CL-�2� Cor�v�ation THE NOLY 1'RINETY, INC, DRAwN BY:m. ��0#1 /� �T %►j.� � r� r � �. ,�r . 1. ! 2 � x �, � SP��I�EI� L�4vi8CLN�NTs [nr shru6 fcncing and avcr[�ow �atking Tlta� alhcr Ihan LICENSOR's facilit[cs, nn at•rrhend wires, �►oies, light slundards, dum�sters, sfgns� irees, butldings, struc�ures or obstacles sha11 be Iara�cd, cansiructr.� or installed within trie Llcense Arca with��t wrlt�tn a�proval by LiCENSOR. Tha� any shrubbcry planted by LICENSEE wl�hin the License Arca shalt be af a variety not exoeul(ng lwclvc fecE (!2') I� hclgh! at maturt�y. 3. 'ii�at any srrinklirig syslem w��ct� may be Installtd by LICENSEE wtthin the L[cense Arca shal� spray no closer than twenty-five teet (25') fram the ncaresl edge �( LZCENSOR's struclures or guyiog and to a rr�aximum height oC ten feet (14'j. 4. That any and aIl p(ping andlor culverts ins�t�tled 6y LICENSEE within ti►e Licenu A.rea shalf have sufflrirnt earth covcr lo prevcnt breakagc due to the o�cration oC LiCENSOR's vchicics aad heavy equipment within �he right-o[ way. S. 6. 7. That no bclow ground grada drair�ag� or faci[ities be installcd by LICENSEE withi� �he Liccnse Area wtlhout LICENS�R's review �nd written appro�al. That LICENSEE agrees that no refuciing operations t�kc plaa wilhin tht right-nf a�ay. That aIl parked vs�ic2es w�tfiir� thc Licxnsc Ares shal! bc molar v�hicles of an o�craltve and traasient ttasure; mobilc ho�es� or(iae Irailcrs or carricrs at cxplosi�c rnaterials arc proi�ibiacd. 8, That LICENSEE ahall notify L[CENS4R's Suptrvisor of Transml5sian Undcrgraund (l.�.. Charles A. N�llall or his drsignated alttrnate. tctephonc 81318bb-57Z9, St. Pclersburg) at �east for�y-elgh� (48) hours priar to LtCENSEE's ptrfotm�ng eny excavation with�n the Licxnsa Area !n order that LZCENS�R m�y arrange for an anthor{zcd represcn�ative to 6c on si�e to assist �n tstabltshing the existing lacation o! FYCs c�ndergtaund 'fuel olI �ipelinc and �o ob5erve a!f expvatlon activ�ties in praximity to said pipc�inc wlthtn thc Liocnse Area {nclUding planting af schrubs. 9. That LECENSEE shall make s�ccial no�c af Guidclines invol�tng L1C6NSOR's oil pipeline altached as Pages 2 of 3 arid 3 oi 3 a! Exhib[� 'B'. by this r�fercnct �ncnrpotattci herein and madc a part hcrenf. and AQPLtCANT ahall comply [�lly wllh said Gnidclines. EXHIBIT B" Pagc 1 0[ 3 Pagcs ItJIT'1111. , INtTI � f • �', 1 f��f,� .� ,, �x� � Gu�da1ln�� [oc tcnrtructlo� cror�lnR aE th�_�srte++-to-Anctote,,,011 LIn• ihe �lorlda Povtr Corparatla� S�rto++�ta-Antlatw th:rn�ii ln�ul�trd oll trrn�patt l�n• h�� b�en 1n�tsll�d �nd is ap�raird In compllanc� vlth Tltl� ;4-�aeC l93 red�cal D.O.T. - �r�n�port�tton at Liquld� br Pip�iln�. � �. llurl�d �trutturas - Crossln Sltuatloa� Th� �nlnl�ure tlearanees r�qulr�d toY aro��ln� �Etuatton� o� th� d/A 0!1 Iin� and propoa�d othec 1lne� oc lktuctuc�s follou�� o. Halnta�n 12 lntha� ot cl��ranc• b�tvfen !ha oll lfn• and oth�r plp�t or ■ttuctt�res b�ln� burl�d and crossln; the ilnc. b. �hen 1I lncfie� oi e1��r�nt• i• noR praetleal� prori��anr c�n 6f n��otl�t�d vlth tlorld• Pow�r Corp. ior a subrtltutlon e[ tfi• aoll barrlar �rlth �n �pprcr�d bsr:l�r. I. �nln+�.Soll Cov_sr av�r nl�,o,il 1lns th� Mle�l� �oL! cor�e r�qulrimrnt■ �t �ny loeatlo� •Ion� tht� ��lov �to—Aneiot� 0!1 plpa 1Lns h�� b�en •stabtish�d to b• i1 �ncfi��. ss roi.r�ncid [io� top oi th• pip• ta'�raund lsvrl, road bed, tlrar botto�� dc��n dlteh bqtto�n� �te. JVn� rsrlanc� tn thi�. wtn�rnw� protrctlra soli cor�r �uit b� n�Rvtlat�d rlth th• florlda towrr Corp. [or Rub�tiluk�, prot�ctlr�� sqviv�i�nt approv�� can- CliL• l�iUCtyie �[�Mi11` iA'�'3;'�'�. 3. �ar�ll�fin1 • Sucl«d �ttuctuRas Tfirr• ato l�+e atandacds oi saospt�billtr [cc parall�iln� •lEu�- tlon�� a. Tlocld� Poxar Corp. �IW, •ape�n�nts •� olh�r contso�l�d �r��. t. Atl ��r�liailn� o� bur��d «tructur�� nd otfi�r ptpar !o th� �IA a!1 11n• �v�t R�lntain ��lniww o[ thrw� t3) test �ur[ae• ta sutt�ca elsarsnc�. b. 1111 p�c�ll�iln= �[tu�tlonr out�ld� th• ccnttol of tfi• tloridr � Tvw�r Cvrp. •hvvld t�qu�st thr ��nl�nn thr�s (3} [i�t �urt�ca . to •urtaer el��r�nc�. Hlnf�w� �cc�qt*bl� i� on� {L) [oot �ur- t�c� to •nrlsc�� ptarldln� rd�qu�t� ptovl�ions sr• r+ad� ior co=toelan eontroi. ;. oa�v� !losd�ay�ararth• oll pip�llna �uat be e��d ond e�ntad lron� R-4-It lin• to �t-O-1f 1ln�. Driv�var� ahlch can b� elo�sd to �11ov [or �+slnR�n�nc� an th• pip�linr �l11 no! not.allr b� r�qulr�d ta pra- rldw carin�� 5ut �ill ba r*qaic�d to coa►plr v�th it�n� 2 sbor�. Hat�� 1lctual ca�ln� r�qu�t��ntr ++1�1 b. d.r•:�tn.d by condltion� �t locstlan si th� croseln�. C. A. Huttsli /y391tt1-� , � INITIA IN �xHIBIT "8" �'� � Page 2 oi 3 Pages , / • ,�. r' . `, � ...� , �c�r atno,t ". �� °� i .._. ti .... . . � • M-Ib�� . • � I° L.R.N.'. • �C�it[: /��r iaa 1 • • •� . f . • �'Ir ._ z r A�� 'C � u a�o , 4"� u.�E 0� N�1lr �o;/o sUC � + �" ��rs �+[! �t'�t rr� rAc�+,��y . � �f� . .. . t�ou�. ' . . r . -+� _ �. . ro'-o•, • , . , • R 8p � �L � vA :7� � 4 �1I � po��: ti � • ., .fC/ILB: �� Z "Q� 1�� C� � 1l��1! �� wlk ��ri��14 �1 l00� IIl.1 � t, ��► fr �11� �H� �rrl� �0� �. C��1. ��fll �� /�1� �� fM�11 Mfi�� I��I.� ' 11 S 6►JC�i . +. Ml�. t' �f��. Hr�� fl ��s1. � � � ��`�,, ' �' �� 1��.1 , M41L111�1 L11T /011 tJ�CN ILAA �J � , . ...l�. � ' RONC�[it � �. �f �1� • . t !1[INIpi1C111� UtLit � . ED6Fo� �_ � �- �rr. ��r� �f t'-�' t 1�is� �i��r��1 � 1�� , o. .• � ( 11� 11�./ ♦�f� �1 ��r1�i1N�1 1��I�f�) • t�� ,• �• M�.1 1��1 •f 1�' i1N�l fNl�� i� •�` � ! � 11�.� I�i� �1 t•1� Il�t�l t�N»�� !' • 4' . � D� rA�G '�4" �.. � �.�• �.�.t ��.�1 r�f,.j. 1i��, �. . �..... ,f f�1 Ll !'� w � �• D" • r • COotlC�PET� P11"�'t 1NE ' CO �ER SLA�BS " '�'�' . . _�.._..... , �•��.rt ,00c• �,�i��a� �,�� ►M� pROJECT ��C'TOI�'-,dNCtOr� P/PE�lN�' � � u� �Q � I�LOl1i17A PDW�R Ca�rORAT10M No, o�i �cr��ow or sK. �r� •�..trr�rrr�• •..��.. ��tt�.��? ��c��t_�l.�t�__�r .f�_caj}�r��!F dRAWIN� N0, r4-S34 -A� 1 INITI�IL 1 i1 . � �xH�BYi "8" �� Pa�• 3 of 3 Pa�a■ � �,� 7 � �.,,, , L � � � �� M� � �9g� s/�Y�g� � LL � �nh 2s, Dear Mr. Lagos: Pleasc aliow me to introducs myself. My namc is Patrick rt�nkie, and I have been acc�u3.r� �s the General Man�ger of the new Planet Bubba. I have twelve years prior experience in the fields of both restaurant and nightclub man�gement. I would first of all like to express ta bath you and your pazishioners, that I wou.�d nat p�rticipato iR an cr�eration that was not entirrely first class. As my references were being checkeci, I was doing a little research of my own. This facility has been the homc af nightclubs since the eariy Eighties, Some mare successful than others, but nightc3ubs none the les�. Upon acceptance of my posi�ion as General Manager of this project, i rari an Extensive backgtound check an Bubb�a's current nightclub in Ybar G`ity. Upon ehecldr►g with the city of Tampa records, X was able to find not even one viajarion. This mcludes city and aounty ordinances, anci most unpartanUy; under age consumption. �e Ybor City location has been in operation for aver a Y�• � Please let me explain my intsntions as General Mar�ager of Bubba's ncwest Nightclub and Restaurat�t facility. Unu�r no circumstance will we be hc�shng any ty�pe of theme ntght or contest featurir�g naked women whatsoever. We will be hasting calendar girl contests, with Clearwater Beech sppmved swun wear only. (No T-Backs) In addition to our calenciar contests, we will aLso feature a mr�e review: also cIac� in beACh approved swim wenr. We are also going to great lengths to provide a top quality restawrant. We lzave hired not onc, b�t two of the area's best culinary t.alents. �The food will be inventive and tasty, appcaling to everyone because of xt's measure of good fl�vor. This is why it is so ir�portsnt to us to devclop a booming lunch and c�inncr clientele. And as an added accent to ouur theme, we will feature on of the tnily finest Cigar Rooms in Tampa Hay. This part of our faaility will cater to our upscalc cuscomers, wha enjoy finc cigats, as well as fine wines and spirits. Bubba is also ciu�rently n�gotiating with his oid fricnd Bob L�s.�iter, of WFLA. radio, to da a live broadcast fram our cigar room. This ides as to solidify our standing with the older radio listening community. in closing, I would like to imp��ess upon you with assuranee, how import�nt it is for me, as well as Bubba, to maint�in and strengthen our "goai neig,hhor" rapport. We would like to clean and repait the fenc� that separates aur two properties. In addition to this, we are williag to install a locking gate, that can be�ocked ar unlocked by either of us. Zhis would allc�w yau and yOUT PBTIS�i1011CI'S t0 SCCCSS OIIT �Ykil'i� lOt RS 11CCL�CC� C�[iTl]ig yOl1T S�tV1CCS. This gate would retnain lockcd duting houts of oper�tion, and re-opened by you as needed. Lastly, we understand that in thc past your parishinners have been heckled by patrons during you annual night Easter celebration. Wc ar� willing to do scveral things ta assure that this will not occwr in the firture. You and I can discuss possibilities as the time draws nearer. I advised your Vice President, that in A"worse case scenario" we wou�d shut dawn aperations for that night. I am very much looking forward to entering into a warking, as wcll as a neighbarly relationship with you and yaur church. I feel that the key to eliminating a lot of p�tcntial pmblems is to kcep an open line af crnnmunicadon between one anothsr. Please feel free to contact me anytime, to discuss any mstter. With Regarc�s, Patti k Ftankie �� i� c � s� �y.� $ULY TItINiTY GREEK ORTSUDOX CFiUACH 5��q � 409 OLD COACHMAN ROAD j CLEARWATER, Fi � 346Z5 GENERAL ASSEMBLY MEETING MINUTES MAY �, �997 Pr�sident Mark Lagos called the meeting to order at 12.a9pm, Father 3ames delivered the Invacation. President Lagos opened t�e floor #'or nominations for Chairpersan for the meeting. Michael Kastrenakes naminated Louie Bakkalapu[o. Nick Prokos moved to close nominations. 5ecanded by Zisimos Zarv�las. Passed unanimausly. Louie Baklcalapuia appointed Michael Boutzoukas, Pari'samentarian, George Papageorge, Sergeant of Arms and Kath�rine Papastavrou, Secretary. Katherine Papastavrou read the msnutes af the last General Assembly meeting M held on November 24, ] 996, James Kaklamanos mo�e� to accept the minutes as corrected, Second� by Kittie Ladakakos. Passed unanimously. � Michael Bautzoukas spoke about the urgent need to correct an easement descriptian.Tt�is easement, oc the right to use someone else's property for a specific purposc, �xtsnds from the south bosder of tS�e church property to Gulf to Bay. The purpose of easement, when created, was to provide for surface water drainage from the ch�rch across this property, to the street. We have been advised by the mortgage holder oithe pro�erty that this easement actuatly goes thro�gh, a.nd has aIways gvt�e througl�, t�e bui[ding next door. After review, it appears #hat the ciescription of the easemeat was incarrectly typ�d ar�d a correction to this typagrap�ical error must be made to carrect the title grablem ihis current d�scrip�ion creates. Micheal Boutzoukas said that since this invalves an interest in real property, a change would require approva! thraugh a 2/3rds vote of the General Assembly. He motioned that the P�ish Council be given the avtl�ority by the General Assembly to make this carrection ta th� easement description on the candition that the adjoinirtg ias�d owner prepare the doe�tments and incurc the costs of recording arid correeking the easement description, Seconded by Sonia Stephani�is. Pttssed unanirnously. President Mark Lagos reparted to tl�e members of Holy Trinily that the City Commissioners had s�nt a letter inviting us to a special m�eting on May I4,1997 at City Hati at 7.00pm where we would be given the appostun'sty to sPeak in oppositian to the aper�ing of � nightclub called Pianet Subba immediate3y adjacent to our churah, On April lst, 1997, a request ta aperate this nightcSub was denicd t�y the Zvting Borird a��f iE was a�lowecf to apen or�y as a restaurant. The nightcSub is appealing tl�e decision ofth� Zonin� Board at this s�ecial meeting. r."�w.r�...-.�:;.�.�.,.,t,,...<,....,.... . .w._ ... -� x�, i � However, Planet Bubba is legally operating as a nightctub under the .�amming Ja�a ]�.� license untel May 20, l 99�Mark La�os motioned that we, the members oF Haly Trinity Greek Qrthadox Churcfi, as x united er�deavor oppose the opening of any nightclub next �oor to our Church, Church School and Greek School that our children attend dai[y. Secanded by A�ex Alexander. Passed unanimousiy. � �?i Michael Boutzoukas presenked the 1996 General Fund Statements of Cash i�eceipts and Disbursements for the period ended December 3 X, �996. See attache�. Alex Alexander who is on the Audit Cammittee took exception to the figure far toiat cash receigts which should read $417,708.50 not $42�,176.28 �nd the figure for net cash (dsf�cit) ta read ($11,�487.12) not ($7,719.12}. Mr. Alexander reported that an audit had been conducted and that all cheques had prap�r documentation. He fett �hat this repart f�rm�y represents the income and expenses of ihis church. He did recommend, hawever, that receipts be issued ta mave maney from one acco�nt to lhe other thus registering all t�ansactions. He recommended that in the future, actual amounts for the last three years be included in the financials, Alex Alexander thanked Fifi Molinaro, James Kak4amanos,Manny Kastreriakes and Costas Panagiatopoulos for serving on tl:e Audit Committee and ti�e Of�ice Staff, the Treasurer an� Jvhn Tsagaris for their service a1so.Manny Kastrenak�s moved for th� npprov� of the 199b Report of Income and Expenses as acijusted by the Audrt Committee, and present a seconciled statement with three years aat�als at the next meeting. Secanded by Michael Boutzoukas. Passed unanimausly. Tt�e 199& Papadi Trust Fund Statement of Cash Rec�ipts and Disbucsements were presented by Michael Boutzoukas. Mark Lagos moved to approve the Papadi Trust Financials for I996. Seconded by 5andy Mastori�es, Passed unanimously. Father �ames announced that there were three vacancies on the Board of E�ections. Chris Prokos nominated Saridy Mastvrides, Gus Afendaulis nominated Mary M Prinos, Anna Poulos nominated Sevi Lagos. Deno Kril[ies moved to close nominatians. Seconded by Ivlichael Kastrenalces. Passed unanimously. Gaad ofthe Church Father James reparted that h� would attend the upcoming C[erg7+-La�ty conference in Boca Raton but would return ta Cleaswat�r on May 1�,3997 to attend ti�e importgnt meeting at City Hall where memhers af Holy Trinity wili un'ste in opposition t� tE�e apening of a nightc�ub adjacent to tiie Churet� and rejoin tha Cter�y-Laity th� folfowing marning. . Bill Catsikopoulas repacted that the Re-beautification af the Church Cam�n�tte has met and is worlcing on getting bids for new carpeting and pews. Also the Papadi roof a�p�a�•s to be tealc�.ng �d will require repairs. Manny Kastrenakes� thanked the Parish Council for performing an excellent jot� ir� their service to the Church. Mark Lagos thanked the PTO for providir�� baby-sitting services which enabled • . , � � � � � �. , '. ' � _. Aw.w+r...ry..�., t»r.�•ya............. .. -. � . - ' .., . ,,>: ., . . . .... . . . i. .e�W ii .. ,. . . . parishioners to attend the Ge�eral Assembly meeting, � � � Meeting adjourned at 1.35pm. . . Res e l!y submitted, , . � , , . . a nn apastavrou ' , , , , Secretary � . . - . : � �'� .� . . . '�\ �rA M/,i \ . . . � . . � 1 �.+ �,a � . ., . , ,. , :. r� f r, rS ' �" , :.. �, ' . ' i��•� ' . . . . .� r '� . '. . , , , . � '{ '% , , �, . ; " , , . , . .. � , � �� , , . . . . , . .., �a� . � � ' � ' ; �� `�'�'Y� "��¢� ' . ' , ' . � - � � K.. t . ', ,. . _ � . � ' , � . . ' ' / . • �w ' . . , i�,. ' . . .� . . ' .. , � � ' . .5 3 . . . ; � � . . i . , (. . i � , i I. � ' � ' ' . . . �r . ' . .. • . . ■'��Z�kt�+�"^'.»«..•. � , . . . . ..:.�... .. . . .. . ... .. .. . ... � i � ! \ � 4 / 4 4 -_ —__ . .. , . .. , . , I . . . , , - • � 7 . � . ' ' ' . �� ' ' . , ,'i!� ' - ' � �� . . . � ' ', ..i. , n,� ' �i.+ � ��ti: ��[��.: ' ,f•' .. . . ... . �' ::r1'.`�;, . . ,. , I • . ' ; , • ' ',.. �, e ` : , �, �, : <' . , ,, , " ' . .. :,; , :1, ..�� ,�,� ,::�' ,��.� .�, � �.� ;r;y , ' '``' . ;�L%i'; �' ` ':1_; `i. . tn . : ,• . :.. " , . ., • � . �f1�'.1` '�.i_... t�.. .,�y' .'�I� � ' ''l� .i�! �'��'� � �� • � � �'. , ..� . . � � , ; �1' '� �r' i. ��r .; .�.��' , f' .', ... �t . . , � � � �.:r,� � ' ' . ' . ;�.;�:.'{.., , ' y'. .�" � '�.'. , , . . � . - � , • ,i.: . � 'i: �iA �'�:; i�' ;r,<; ,'ti' , 'F,r`'' , , . � • • . ;,� � ';� r ,.{•� �`�,' ',.i:•�,,`t;; ..'`,,,,; . l .-?.. , �' ' 1'� _ ,,� : ' ', . ;'� �,�- . `ti,,; :'.° � �?�. �� ;j,�,':�.�� r,��,.ir�` ��,, .. � .. `l��;� rs�' - „ ..;'� '•'':,,�f '•�`�::':. t ��;: „ , ��;., , .i74 � �:1��. • '}.: .x.•.:` �'v � >�1 �t� ,'' �'lr�.. • ' ' ''+.` ' . � �''�� i K �',S'.. .. � ��YY.��.'.'f•L�r..� '•,'�l � �,'� ' . !.�!�� `1: '•.tt��i"'!',t:R':.^RYs}'.`1:: ��'ti.�P_:':.•(:':MY.If^.:»�-w :';:tMTt:��.'.?.�'�'"t�:%.:,�:.:y':r:°'Y:^.^i:r?:rv.t;...y.�._�...�...7:..«�fr:: �:••+�«a�<-�••-� . ' �y:••.1: J./'� , pl.'�;._.y�;:...`t�; .�.'�' i�ti...��.' � • �. _t . 1 . , , ;' a+:`:t :`L..�� ,' '�' ! ��: ' `t �`�':. ` ,�� . ;^i.� :;.'". ,1i"ti• '�`:'. :1 t'��: ,d't::�� 'r„ ' ',�' . y•? � ,f ' y :, '�''' ��'� 'i' � 1 u; �'i��.i'� „� � � ; j'�. '„� ,. . �. ,#�.:' i5 � .1.1"'.t. .. ',� �:. � � '. �.y„ � . ��.. ; i . S ..1: � .("'�i�: ' r � .. :..I' y�'r i. . . . ' • � �.M "i �+ ,��5',I>'� ��,`�,' .•'1:t'�'.•`''.�.t�c',`�'.�:`. ,�; :,7" �Fi'o ;r�;4'` t��' . ' �" ,.�,i �� .�,`.'��• , .. �• , . ' �� . .;4� � . '�! . . � . ' �. . � r. 'i.� .�i, t.;�� • , r�:" , �.+:..' :f' �i'o .'"' ' 'u'='!!` �.�' �, '.� il� 'y. .��' '��. � l. . ',�.'i; �{\�..�� ! � � � �.�, •� ., ;� . . , i�. :t' ^�r' .fi ,g'r' .� ,'e. ��,:;'.. . .v . . . 'tl: .., . =�i `. l� 'r' .1. 11 . 1� . i„ �,"i ' . 14.�. �!''• • �,: ' , ��';: . �.'s�: '� �.. , ��y =�,.��.: . - � ..3' '�I� .y' ` ' .. . . .�. I�'1•, � . J 1`.y;:�F �� ..i'� •�E•,'= ,'S' �; , :��ri.' . . � �.f.. . �+ ,�'i,' � r ..1�.�;t , . • l � ��'` •�1�if:� �•',��i13��0' �;\�• �•1. �', � . .1+' t .' '1' � � I 7.. �li+P.,� •�' •:i:[ '�:...'..'�.,�'. � i.. ,�' ��. .� . ' •�1�` ' li' .y.� , � �R ��4 �.. • ✓ • � , �. .I:.,.,�.:L r�1�.11�1,fi.�Ist': �'rilt�'ll�.i:f:.� , ��:, �� '(� � rf1 .��iC �:��.� . 11 . ��`'� i�i�' ��..�:� . r,l �. '�+ �` . .'i.' '1• • .�.'r' �f,1 •fE�.. ...3�` ' ' ' '�r ' � ; 1 , .. 1 1 � �_ . .ti.�,�l�, ' :��';IF.�, �.�; •i�,�� . . , • ' , .t �1 . . . ' �!' t: . ��" ,'i�•'��, . . . . . � . . .� . �. 5 , , s., �.Y� . . . . .. .. . . � . .. . . . . . . i. . �1 . .. � �.., ... , IJ.+ ��I��•i•� . ,�i._1 �L,�.,7 ' ��• •`�! (•'w'T� i!1 ' r{� R�� y ,,�. ..�..� ' �1� i�. �� i�� ii�if �i i f . .. j �Ia ��:� 1 ,:r'• �•��''i I•��t'�� .' `�•�'1.� `r�:� �'44,,'•�{S�` 4 1 � 'y, , ��•.��'- '!`'� '•'t�?�',:�� as�.�:a. ` �. r � :,. •,( J`� '� %� ,�.,i {ti`�� •, �wf.� ..�� _i �`,�_A,fI � �'�;I. ' � � ''l,�., t � : ��.? '�'�;°.'�,1, .`��ir�i.��,k.�.�;fa��,'} ,r'� f`�•i�� {S� �}i��f7;� �_�J(/� I..�'�l�}`r��vlt� �1 Y�i.,i'�L,�; ' . �'; 1; � f'}� .;'SGr � `�;, •fS�t�� . ,2,�- ' � ;'al , ,,`.� ,�.�� I.t �;.. . L ' {.r�� ' � �� -?�.,. , :��:. i, ;i��l:iijll� � i;��4;�1.��jtj .,� i :'�ir��i�'�`,k � � ' ''. ��li�l� ��l�� ,�� '��j� � �.,, R' �'' '��Y'{ ��ir � '' � : .`r; �� i,'ir:�:f :; �,,;:7r... 4��,� �.r.f, � : � ; � ' 1: `t>.. �r{ � .� + �>�� _�,.� ;,,�:Y,�„},ir�j 'l'�r ,'�:1 _" ' � `,�,i �•,t; .:E;•'1�'�;�� '','„ri��`�I��l `t„��,1 ' `,i"�?ff y{�f' •r��'i�T�� ;� ; ��, f�, rrr�f . �� `�fT , t� � i� `; 1<�. .�. :.; .. . r I' � k r�ff��,�`'..►.r �t#�`�'�� ,'' �' �: �� . �...r,:: � , , -, <,�,�„�rr ' rj�+,. l �1 �,.'` .�s. A.i ,.:`�s: � •.,L:.-;''f� ��► � �r,,,�. 'C' ' � ��' � �� e ,,��s'•��fti± �I r��' ��`f �/Q; ' :.��-�S�jft,�� 'r� ►; r� �'r1..1�5� �'' f` \ S�, �� a r �� r�� Z � � ' ? �S, :�� I k� �� ' � � '� � I I . �. ' � '' '`•+, •r: ''ti ••'•f, '' +l �'' ,ti'.�`�..�`:i:t.r+r.r}' ,��`, `1;,�� '�,J':' �;.�:�'+.rl,�,.'�.:•{��il , , Y.:'•, s' "�'1�;�� a�l t�i N!1 •�r v+:��y _r�r �1 � �� i�.� �.�.�1��,' � �.�i ,� � .�, � �!��. ,�w'1 ��.��' � `��)f. �•T ��t �~"_ r;� ;�F f� �?��i� �3w,�.,� rr�� i��` C��ilr �� ' y•�•� �i '�y j)i;lili[' , .J,+.�"; ir!: ,'�'', .T �+�. . ''��i''^•.. ' l��f� ~� r� 1 , . � . � � : . . �� 1 �i":.. ��'�'-''., � M•i1 �~• •;a4'.� . ,. ,. ,. �. � 1' ,,�. � � � �' ' �� +1,'' I�.n' ' ' ' � ,�.�.r� �fy �+ W.;'�,t� � . , .�;�',:'•,; °�;,'�• s � '. `,}�,, %�,��*r"�� ,�,�� •�'►=+'�:,.. �� i �r� .. ,1�, {' r� .1:� a=•�`'j '.,• .•' ��}`� ' `�,�,�.. ` ��'_� ,'; i�'.I'• `,�'y �� ` . T-•� � �r.� .l.' ��f. '• „+'•+`, :� +,:, , `�' , ,,/� ,l �'G'r.: ,, ;,� .�'��"';' � t t �'t�� ' 1� i i f- , ��.�I!'M1,��'�, ''n �`l�• ! �' C'4 . � '4�,��i,�1��'J�.��i�l, ��A., !� :r;' � �. .'i�,:'� ��5.. ::: ,•. . , , . ��;'. . .�'''.E3"i �r � 1� ��j��';� 4 � �.�� °� �:.,�Tr�;;'-�;;'" ��- ;,; y...' ... r...;;, , ��f� �;��,1/ ��, • , �', j�,� ��<<;', �;"..... �!.:, �'..,�� r. . �7 i• {�•�� • r- .� �r.::ir ;::i��;ai?`.J':-r.:�:a:�t.x M: ; .:..ax��s'>,� i }.. ` ' �� I�'�,'..� f . . i.-; ,� ",�'., ,` •� ' , l.� � �J*+�, +yl �!�'.��:-»�`' c . � r• .. 'T r�•�' A �,•T �� ' '�',•��' f. '•'i'�'1•'�' j'i\'� 1•, 1 � r �.�.�j�. .:t�' ', .:: .�'.c ' 'i e��'�1�1�) �f , .�,,. . y �`�';�`' �.. L ' t+ � i•: r� � . � �7! ��/ , • ' I, ,<,� ;{r '1r',�.i� '�i .• ''f 1�ii �` 'F� �. �,S'��+ l� i��l��'�;'+I � � ,�� •j1 � ..•�:� ` �t�{ ,�Y' ��'�`�,�;7�w`!ti� . ��,:. `I'�'��: �,� ;�,'.Y �,�;�1,;� i {;.�.t.7� M'�'.:riJZ� i_ :n' ; .. t:N{�J�•�. , . ��,��=,� ,'��1M'�� `:r�•�. ''r,. ; �:. � t+ ' ;� ,, ',�y ''L � �a •� ` , . :�j' �� ' '��, �1�,+,�'u �' ;��. . s/.�' ".'Si�1� •�1�, :� � 1 ,�'i' L. r: .�� ' y'.'S"/,I � ,� . :" '�S ,J. 't. � .� I� ., � �� "4# ;.�„- .� r � �..;,: •., ; , � .1 �,,- , . ,�', :�;; ' ",, � ; . � � �i y,i� , . R� � •'1:»... . ,?',. '. ; .� . ! , ' i .� ';r„� .: �, �.�°r��.�� ;��L� '��.t�ii /;15'. r• :� i� :,.,�'.�'�'t °' . S. .i��!',`��l'S:`��+Is. .; '.�rl:�:�'�.� ar'�• ��f / � �l�„I. 3i't��t�+�'';�.��:: ��wL � 'I� ,�'� y f•�I�'�•�t�{:`• ��.. ;� ��:��'j��' .3�'��.' �;�:�� "� '�� i�' '.�« �Y;!r��.Y:`;,;'J�r'4�a��.'�, ` rj,,J:: �:'. 11,� ''� ►)1'.'��: �� tid..�. � ji., 1 r. 's+�,�' '•�� \f/�•'� �s tlw,<��`i�+1�.r.�,'1�,��.�,�. � - ��.'�. i1'•� � �]r�,. ' ' 1;�t �`+t��,��t.'! sr1j. ��7-� = ^','r t � � � `•'��'� �' .» � / L � � ti� j '� •«�)]j��y��4� +', ii�'��. �- `. � �..`'��1� '„' ��r�'S,iY�+��i f[t. �' �� .'-+ : y ''f� ' f f � ' t �r� � � . 1 r q��bi,�Jr'' l�:�i� ��'u.. `:h'. i�i,�r t�y^� Z � �';�iK� t f�viy'.:.� r �l�'�'�:i'f:�i��i.' �' ._ . _ . �'i. .. f ,y 7. . �� 1� n � `� .;�;�� G�r",� � Ib'��ii .�. •' '�T f1�CtY�. .- ; ...rs..'K.�"�r•:'�`:�:.•';�l Ra'S.r' "�'+�.�•�, '�i_ �:.' ',f, �;�� ' � T t -� s � � �. �' •J' ��' � �► �.,`.�� .:� �r'e� ' ;�r.Y;- .'.": �.� .1��> f� , �s'. i.:• ��, ;�, E, ��,fv�yti . 4� � �A(i � � ' \' ��. fl='-'• :' �'.`, •,� : . . '. r�� ,Ea�;i•y'-"� 1�'-' :�.'` ;a"� �1.; rr � � �� ','��'' � '. ,� , . �' 1 � � \�'�.4;r? .�' .�w�' �: 'i.�,�1 . ''r�' •.�� 'y..�.�'' „''. ..��. 1 � f,��,�"�� .` .�. �:b.�. ': . +� .y. �' ' '• r � . �' ..��r, :e, • �'?'s:.r. _,t'! ��; i., ��. .4 �:' � �' .r'.� . t'r .;r.. • � t � i •��i ra ��.�� i i > � ,,,�. .�� `�� ..' ( � ,��• `' 'r':: ��' .r � �u.rf: °.� � ij:I ' y 1 •y��{ f: r � �, .' • .�'y �• F. •',,^ { i • ��' .�[` �' 1 ' �'!�, '�' 7�'.. �.L" �,'� F., 4 � }� 1 � !iI ��'i��.�r��1.''-S'�` '1�,•• �l�� 4.rP� 't . .�..i t. � f �• � :: 'y, 'r �, �Y`'} .r� ��,� '�.s� t�,� ,' f s f + �� .;, r� � �i• �'�: • .ti:;; -�. aly;_� r � , -.� ''' , Y� ♦ � �j` � � . .. ..a � � ;,. �1.• 1 � �� . � ly:�iy�t �,�F�1�� ti"��.' �!1� f�j.�..... >. ��,',}�,�� •��..' . r��.. � 1 • � 7db '•ij� �'•r�j�r r} " .� :: ,�'�,�: �,..y�.x' • .� rt :,„` � • '` r...:,-.. '�-}� ��,�' ' '�}�' �i' '+J�/If�{;�':�� 'a'��•�� , �,ly�;',.; .7;i�: ;st' ..y � `� � 'j ! .td.=::. �•1 ' �� '�''' :". .� � � ;'. . �. , ,�, , , , ►� , , ....� -,__.. �:,.�:m � ..� � ��'�;., �j• •�i . , r; uK !'�' , ' ' :�: ��r ' :: , �'�� r � � , �x;, .�, �.;', 'i. � � � ; � ,,,,,,,;,'1si+h4. � ��+ t� ' . � � ' � t�'� r h• . �.�.�� . � ,_+ � 1 ! � 1� •y�� y ��, ,. • ,:i `;'� . " C.L`F '� � r� • : ; .:..�s�e—.�;:;� • .� � t � � �`twl �� V'� :�� :y. .1«,:• ;�L�,��r.�;�.�1'. �,�, �'��,rr�„�``!:♦ ��"'�'yMY, � � � � :� � sa .:i� .f�t`��'�j'�%��i•'!if"��:'.��r�,».,d� !i��;� ''��,.�'�,� �-�� t,.� .� { _� ! � j . � , �.i'{ r� :f'. �, � 1 .i' % f�. �.� '; ,�., �,.� ..'.. � ' � �t 'i 1 � � �� j '�fi;Y.j;� . � ; . t• f �i , y,. , a: '�,,; , y„+,:�,`.ti':F r., -' . � ��_.�,. �t�=.�f#`+.• �� .�, jj4�.�,�y�� }5� : rt _ ;Y; �•��'•,�� < ,w �. � � ,.i % �: � ,I� �.. �� i'� (�,�•,;i� i • �°,= .. ::'�'''.'tix:,�.:'`;�r � �-i • .�� }' }, `�7 � ; �,•. �i'' '1 r. - � ��- ��,�' '.f�• .�t�� y...r..�,�r. ,r,j7s'�.�"F'�!• ,'' -:.��'..`�'. i'-�,7�.;" ••��,}'�'F� • ':f' ., A�!� .r ' �' � {� T1 � � y'�4.,�� +.�� ..� :, :' i `�ti'�SC+r`.`��i•r+l��; + .. �i�... �.laf�... �f.�= ��"j•�'� •' yt��;'.1, .'• •��r''a;icJ.S:.��R�:'F�...�9!�•�.� � � . .1�� .�' , : li;,. . �+., ��'{ �y. } �.. � �.''�' �.� '�t�r`�. ! +� . .z. � �,ti�? . ti � � i ,.I:�� \ °�,:: �.r .F„ ' r � : � �;`y�lt ; :. _ ! i �;:r 4.��_= �;...il:.. , fN.. �,. .i! •y', t�f]�°:. .�'V.;� ' �;'.S.i'"• y1 f t`.'i :. •'�r, ; �}.$'..; �: ' ' �; F . ' .� �., �,'.. C 'r 1', . ��+t;�. � �`�' � �.7� • -; � � �.: ~ ' � � 1 ri . r�� ':.��n..r�� ' `'',t. ;. .'�::;'.7�.:��s�.:. �;' •';f;'' .r.,�� :�� .. .�,li'.i's. 1' � t�': •.�:. � :y,• „�`r . Ky..f�� r�+r r'w�r.�l' �r � , �} �`i:'�:(.7�.u.'^•a.Y�=��f:rsl,� wi,r.�'.f'r��T.�..�+-ii, '�,��r�•9. '�4 �{,,� t ..+ � :. : v � . �., � ;'� M. r..f �� :; r � �. i,, :•�, .,., . t .{ r�ti.y�, s1,� i �•,•��r�� . ��'.'. v� ,<<4';: ti� i�.P:' �.� �� j�� li..; t� i:�. r�. ��4:.�' ,+ti�-- �: 4,r-.r. --�� -ry`• �,.,.�:�, +'� �� v�. ��i ; p '.�:� r,� . '. 7 "� ��^�''•/k� 1`�'� wl1� �' ��, ( +. �. ��ui�.t� �,�... ��1t.+.��.}j : ��, :�"�! r .k.:'-��Jt.:.;C.�. Zi��s�;^f''I{/,��,. ��`� `F ' � }.t,�:'_t.�'„r `:. �� r 1� ; ��,: ,::, �ru% L.'!�� f,:i:• {�?i.:�,F+rl +' ,`�^'j+ ---,�� -�`"a•,_,�•_ �� ''�i �:; } •a 'i� � �, �� ['4 � s' .� t' `� ?;t."' � �'.�,• �"'' r".'r+H; �N' �.k'�` r r �� 1)��' �f1.1 �►�: t. �;� �].�,:�'r*� `�f1��.�Cy' .iR -�: �. ,;,~_{, ,•. ,y 1 �, 1' ' �r�f •P t� � , s, ► r • �� y, �. ' c,, , r � '�rw.,4 � � �''�+�C; ,P��.py�l�{%�r?�j";r ��$i�i ��;.' lM� �r�'��s ��: ,�Nj��t'1^t'�..rti+.5�'• � �.��f �tw�f!'.��' �. } ;�4 ,s• .,. � ,� �rrl�� ; - � ,:.� ��v, � �.��:��r;�''�L�; . • n,� �w �. �,��"'L.��' ��I,.1� ��ry� riry��l�+��4e . p�./`'�' {7'if;iti^� \i .;� � / �� i'`T ?' � � ' 1 � f � � �'�,�,...�'� ,� "b ` �"; �. � � : �,} z •� ►�. y,.—� , .. =�.'t� �� 'eT r:�y� � .%�Z,�r..li:��. i�''��:.�w:M+fi��i'K'��i:�t1i�..��1�� F,t•�K:�'�'►tR��j�;�.�L'• , � � � . � � , � ' ,. � � � . .. �i ' . 4 � ' ' . .1 '�. 3 , ' �1 . � , .f . . . � � , � � . . . �� . � . ' . . • ' . . .�. .. " " _ " " . . •� � . . , t . _ . . . .. . .. ' ' . , . �.' . . ' + ' � � ' 1 � . � r��. � '�d' �.'.'.. . � '� . , . . . . , .. • . ' . ' �F r'�.i�.'��`�•'�� r�� 'y'.�T i -sk.+ �, •� .1 + ;."�� ' '. + .F,:r '11.�' ��-' i �' '' `� . ' ' ' ' . V '9r�'R• � + ' • , : � ��i, .�t � ~�� • /�r, r�. .�� r ' r 1'r' �, '� � ; � .�'r .�''�'� y ti I �ti.��4.,a�•, ti `.�'y'., �"T�.��?!*,• � •'�� . ��' � 7.. � �r,h�!�,�'.•,r� ��v •�. Yl�"�. �,�, . ,�y" �� .b:�, ►.� :.y,� '�� 9,�Y,` � �.,/••��' �'` '`, , 15'! `•�..rrt:+,Ii�FI�, ., �`"� : .�ji� � �l`t.•�•; ' ;'.• � '^.'v�7, ' ' 'F .. . •..t• k` .•'; .� t„ � �:<<,�, ` •'' i; +, '' ' "` ��'•'.� �.," � {��'r .. � ' .; �_ � 'f��• �=+' �` `�'�� +� T��i� l: �i.��^l. : •i�. ,�'l � �L� 1 '' .�1 I1 '{,S �l i� yt �a` ,�'� *. {�..',�: ;.c':r; ; , 3 •' �`, . •., ,. � ' �� '1 r'� •r t � , �' £, ,, ;; t L•;�;` 4 �,., ':,�',c,� �j �. •.. ��r�i • �} � i.� . ,u.' ,�w 1 '., 'X � • � . ' � t •.' ;�,� 1 � � � . . � , .` f , 1 � _L ��J�' ., 4 ' ;� '��' �� ,:,` �,Y� �.`�y+� r �y� ��T; , l;y,:.t, r, � '7� �.,<��` :,�;��.�'� .,�. �'�. r.:;'.�.�1�,:,:- ��s�.; .. r. �k f� �`. ,.:.: ".�� :�.,,,. �, , -: � ��±' '.♦ :� ..�I l]��'1/��.►4 ; 'i�� ; 7PY�' �:j, i „�1 '� . . �� ,E i, ' �i.r�,� .' ( ,�t'l�+..�: �.i�!�.i.�� r' 'l � '``� f �.'' � T.I . i`:i � . �'i. '' . ,�,' � '•�� • . . ''�,� �' � ' a��• 'l� r�.��u� � � ;� ih� <. ., ��r�•�. ' ' V��• 1%: fi ti H '�'; ,.�`''�� ij`''� Y: '•,� •'�,,i.• .�.�:,:,: �,� � ��'�+.•�:. '�a��'. ' �'t� • j� �i1i 1 � r: .. ' S. �. M� � R �7�.. ;..y q7�.;�. 1 •y., nr . .rf•+�.> '•� :I :•',> .� i � v :i},r;-sx.� .,;......r.. �E ' �E ! 5:��r,� :.:.�:� ��j h t�j.�. " �. ,� .�� ,G '1��f': ��/�'�/��1.'.�131�1��t1r7,�'�.�4�i�•�+`..�� •� �' i..��~ �} i." .f; . 5� � � •►,,/� ,: f�,� '. �}l1i,� Sti.. Y ... ,F � ♦ � � �' � +rti�r., ��i"l'��a; � '}.;.�f� ��y� •A�j;ViY•,'```+•t . „ ..er� - . " :,;'�;�.,;. i`' . � .� i�'k 71 � � '•��;�.�'�LS�' �t`"111�1 �j,�l. M � � ' �• ' ,. � '''"i,;,,F.�,!�' �, s� .,�,' ��,�j�r� •�� 4j�.,�� ,�s��':�}i�� r'��'�''� ` i1.� r� ■ .. ' ,.. � .,�:.�sF+r�� :�u.»�� a i i � � l!l ��k' N' ti� 1 .rr 1� r : , ''1',., ,�'� • �., . � ., i, ,s ��. ; ��,+�� i��, , t�:,:, ,, ;�, ;.. .. � �: ,. �;:a �•,;�.:', 't` � .� �:-�i�l�.'rt i �1,.: .�� .�v ��, �r. .. �t,' ',�4�;j'•,''►.',�: ��'. �.�,:. ,,, ;' .�[ � . i �r ' �< ' . i' `ti, �'' .!tr'`t �'� . t•��.�+•� ��1�� .�:f! r�•.=� .i .u�� a �,� �.r.� �� ` �' . ..� �.'�.i'' . . '�' ! • �'I �: lR�i�'~.i�!- �:��:�'��:wr �S`��;F' ;�' ,� . �� t'i,. ,� '��., . .': .��'�... t,�� '.�',�,il+,�.�Ij a,.:i• ,�•ri. .i � ��•�'�ii, ,, �� .� '''`'' '� y`": .� �31.i ;1��*I�:�IE�' f�:;e:.y)+��'�.�4��i�t.',ti ;l'•, .�?�� `,�, ��. '�I� ; �r�,�(�r��,,+N�i,_^ •��,,� .•�it'�f:�;�.� �',�: f...�rF'�1r'.1'�,•�'�'��i`� ' �� . '. � � . �� .; , •;� ;ya.,µY,r.:�.. .sr :� '��;�� :' �j.� �• ';.5��vi1�..1{�K�;, : ,� r1�!'.i:• ,' !`s• �+�• !y+q;�w �;��r}��!"'-� 'y�!"'+; ` �'�; '1 '•i'a: ; �, 4•� `'��.:T :iL�'a' � . i�! !.',� �'�,' ,`;, * '`,.•� 4. ��,.�•;�...,'"�.i "•' . , �� :. �. � t� r ';r',• �� :,5��„«!+�'�, �r�.'��1�..r �4l..�r ..-{1°._•, •'t.' �.i ,'�+�'.j,•. ��,1 '.�.��1�:�.�1�:..5�`?��.r 5 ... 'a:;1J^...�r ; u 't� " � 't�� ir I • �%A y , �. r� ,; 7'': . .TR: `, . ' ' s t / J., 1d'�,�Y� �.i.. * i ,t • , f s , •'�1...%'�� . ; . ►S, �: y.:��.• .,t—, ; • � ., `wf!'•' �'L�:T�i.�`� ' �,' • • - .'jlr,� ,;+ ' . r Jn , �C '�t �' ,'r:r.. � ,� ,•y' , �,. "� � w„ 'N�.. •'.� � { '`' :S'1�, +(��il�'�r;�...�7 ' +�; - „ '�� ,.�`h� � '�-��.iZ'�.i�. a�. .�r1.�ii •;'i ,-'i S.y � � . . • �{.' :, � " � °'� '� ! �� r .�tY rr � ,fiJri�}... "•t i }+� �. !•. 4� 1:ie'�1;1'•.�.,' :�:�L'�,:;i.' , �:, �:.•:. ±C�r' .. d'�rr�F:�'f�:"��ii ��,.i.'~i r ,��' �'�'t( •�'' ��,7r.�:� `�,.�' •'s ' `TSt1, ,kl�': .�'��ir! ��VS� f` it �r �r' � iS.�y".• ��,'t'�57�1��ti '�. f~ ,��- ��.� ..'.�� .,� r,:��' �'-\�•Y �� "r��+r ' ' ^.f.� �'' ' •�� i � � 5��6•y' !.'.�1" ��' r • : f VI�' ��~!r��S1`'` r ��T�� C ti;,� :. �.:� ,...� � ��.f,,,�:��:,. kj.,;.,:.. : ��,; •�►, -��: �,r•a �. � ` �:�� s. � ' . . r. +'a �:• V ��Y w` � . '�:� y ' /fl�;��t''"'r I� ':1.' _�;�,.r. t�r .!f' •L'l.;S�:�a Mw ft,:wt�•• ry � �y��t.� �.' � : i . �� .)(�"��' ki .s'' �.5�"r� , �.•� � i h�:':� .�'T�"� i.ri',�'� �-"`L'x ' �' �• � r'��i,'. �.�� . � 1ry:f�. ,.�V�i.Y�. �'�h,�.�,'. � [�.•''� `Ri� . !4 la! ,T1:.-5;��`-�: r � � ! i•. �,,. � ,�.` � � l� -`v _t! ,y�/ r� �..., � ,�v �. �'. . � . r - - �.� i �'t{„��' '� �, ., :r ' •1'+ ,' . � " �'�.�.:i � •�' ��y y.• , I�+ � '{ �' . `.`+'. i�.•.i� i: . �ii:'' � v e_,Y,` :f� ��h� �t��: ..l;'/. � %'Yitr-.� �a..�, ., � .j C4`, •'�� i'i' 1r��J��• ��' 'yit~' v� i�1 . ' . � .r' ' � k~ � � �� f''. �r' , ,+.i� •.� '•�' � i` '; r't:, P["' , �' r�i �'��.�y��'. R.1. ,� �� .�� \'� � :M. '' • �i: . � ��« ,�� ' '� f+-' �, . a ,i; � � l��_.. �• �� ., . .1', ,.• ;t�, �.nl.;�� n ;+ �:��.,� : :� �.�. �• .��;. :i,.?, �y :;. , ' ' ' � , ; ,, , -, �, <<,, • u y �,,=�� r�} ,'�.` ',.,,,.''��, i, ;� �i� .:` ,•..1,, cr;: �. � '�� t`r�' a�•rr.r� \.'' ' ' "��'..� r�j�. f. .,� �; :;f,�,. "Y'y=. � fi ,'�';•�•' ,�+ ��' ,.r ._�` .1C, '" � ��.{•`��' �''f:•'3, • r � • ;��,�. „ :�. ,�, , -�. :�,:��"•"r :�} ;�,.i . . +�,' r '�' .j 'ri; •j� � .°,: �: t �` ,��'' '.' ''' �'•� ��'+i:� � ! 1 � . � �.' I ��iY� 1 ; � �.�1 . ��,�• •J . , � ��~�: L�L� . . 1 '�r / ��'�`� �.`. ��r��l� � {Y'31�1 ' .!i 'y�.7��?r�� s��•• * '�,' � !��'_ .'��t�y s�ti�,,. t � ' , ir� 4 � � .� l;'": i.;' f''�';� + `): � � � �� r ��r �i+ ' ti ,,f, .'\'ti''' .'�,. "��' �� S 1 1 ! � t t�t ;�t�r� ;�>��•�� t:'.��;- �::�s , ;��,. � �;t•. ..� ..,.. .. � ►j{ �- ,�, � ii1,d, �` ; �f'' '' '': ,:'t� c .r%�` � - r ' 1�� 11�1 ��}}; ��"iti�;i��:�'�'��':. � � � .� . :; ti�,�►�. :�� .. �,�� r i 1 � ��,. ., � `�` � ^ �:1, �� i,I ��j�t,,':y'l. 'FI �` 'r'�r.t'?.L'� ,"��" „!''w1'!la.,..._ ' — i. � •» + `��j�t+t e,j r ��' _ s ; ,; . +S� y' t �. .. . . � , . • � '+1 �• r) . ;' �. s �t ''^ :-:t.�. • I , ' � � v,�..f ir.i � �` .;�;. �}�• �: � � . * r� ��,.: .i;;,� w� �� y.. ��:,°,• •� '"•''�` �'f � � }�� Y._.;. �,�'��` :,s,z,��.t �1.,. :3.. 1. ! � , ;�;' `!. �i,. ?. •'��la.� . 1 i� `�I� r �D� ��i i�}. ��•i ; ��• � �: ,' „� �•; .; , ' �. ': ' {� i. r' ' '{.i�,': .'' S •'; � ;: , "'. I ' :%��, ir ;�r,ii1}'; .� � ' •:�.± � . ,�� : . .;� �, .�� Ll-�%" ,i',1 I 1 +�r�:,, ,�'%.,� . '•_,.�:."f;; ��!... ,..�., ;;w� ,r� , Y` 5,�. �J • � f�r+{ � ��a,. i . , �„'�1 ��:.��;':y_ •,�.5-'� � /. ,. .I�t�.r�, i�l�� Si+ �:,. •t',.,� '.,;'. '•:::.• ,:.,.�z.z. ::`�t,;-;�. '� , �,. �''- ,' A�+ � . ij, !��+. �. , ' 1.;�", ��„ �t' . " ., � .� a�'�'�.+,;�+: '�� ^y.E ' , . {y,R� r,�� 1�..., }�'�.�•i:i;�� +;�-:�;+..�. �:.1' I �:1 � .'r �' :1� ��•{'� , �1,��: wi , ;r' °': •• .`,�� ::_ � �:i�.��' *ti., :.',�: ,3, �� 1�.. �:v :� ; f^� � ,, ,'?`� •l .� 4;, ..,.�;��• ��'riR�� .��.t,•:.' �•„'' .� �.. .��. �� '� 's ."�`� f..'�•.l'., ..�•� .''t. ;'��; 4 .'a�r+,•:+3,�-�'��'t''L'k_�5�;;'� .:{:�:: ;�' �.��.� ;�� 1 S. � (� i.:.��;.. 'l'r i^�<st��-., :\�� '.,b.�.i •�;Lr�''r.sk��+��•, ,`�T`,��+� ,��' � . ��", �i•�":� .'•, -. �y��t ti:.� rw► r�ir:�ri :r�i�`�' � � � �'.'��.1+<' i:`y��el. �.a i' .�':r1T'TS�:�['a� �s __ �`,fu'.��'��..��"�,�%1ti•.�SIJ: " �a ;'f'. �•�,;:1 •� 1: :,,� �;'F,�' Fr" _ �,�. �r� '��fZ 'e"'Mi:J�it,�'': i�':ti��j.t,'-tif%►�� 1l�: ';•; . �; `� ;Ji '�� 'i; .i.'� �l,Yl . .. .�/C� �u"' r��f�f�i�i�S.• .,•r.[,;,.1 Ir'��, .{�r.�1,,� %; : <<ii�� ii; „ , „ , . . • . , � I - - ,. . . • . .. ; , r ti: . ' ' , . ; . . � : . , , , • , � �; • . ' +. ' , _ ' , �..... ' � . ' � .,_ � • � • i„°F~ .�' �1 ` i s • �:'1 �. � ��, y,, � �r_ {�: ,.�, . , , ��ti. , .. .. - � ':.� ,!. , • � �•' ' , ; . . . . . - , • � ' .i�.,;��. , , � - `�. . . �i ` ` . � . �� . , ' . �,�'�,'`'' . ,. , ' . � : '.. ' � � �� .�. . L r , . .� ,1 .*; .. .! , i ��.,S�t'�' � . '' . • ..9~• e ,' � ' f . �.' 1. i : . �'. . i � ' . ��1 �� , . � ��rl'. ' � � , � � �,� . �� . . . �',l�' . ' , j `� • . ,' , �i. + ;�� ,,;�'�� ` �J�d.-��;� �.. .i',ni. � .,� ' 4 - , . :�.� ' ?: '".' j'f " . ,. •� - ° ur..�' ,i ',�� {' �,. if' ',r.1. .t • 1. . . I� .I ,.• . , . "' ;�� , l. � I �N, !i� .. .1 • ' '� . . . . � , � � ..i 6 � . ' • . .1+ `il�+'1l� '`� �y,' 3 71` . . . � . ' �, . . , i;<,�. .�... r,� . ' ��, .. . .�i'::�x.�. ..��.';.rtd.',.j.,..,« _:,;rpy-�w;w.;.+�..-..�yr:.•c.,.r.-» .:r:t:-'^.-r:;x:,�,.._��..;..;.�.,r:��.�:�r: >?:�,i:::::.:•�,�aris��.::�!:::�,a::,:�ri:;:•r,e��r: •,� .t' .i�' .�..,.,....,�� -.,'..: '•'. , ", • . :;�i ir:�� • � , � " ' . �� . �i�Ss�. ;�... r 'a" ', �: � .•, .,� ��;,�' �.i: ,��,;� �'� ;�..', , '..y� �� 4,. . , '•� :.j; 'r .. . . , � t rt��. '�� , ,' ` � , . . ' . � ' .�L. � . �-11 i t . `I � � ��{� ' '.' � . /��' � 1 � :�'I'� � � . . ' . � ' i ' ��r ' ' ' � . , 1•��,� , i " ' �'. .• . tiY' f!'P�...f�.i' ' �i ' �� . . .. s�' • � ' �. +� .1 � � i I � ' � ' � . i i � �. . . ' . i� L� .��.i'. . �:i�� ,f,�- '.'1�'r: � ' ,. ' �.��' .i• ' ' .. ' �;,. . . ,.. . '�'. . , � '�: J ' ,. ' �.I , .. • i...,� �'ti� , . . . . ." ,. . . .. _ _ i j �' • � ..�� .I.s.'� ' � . . 1�•' 1 :•� ''. , . , ,' , , a1,; . ' ' � � '�'r.� . . .��i ... . , � � i�� .o .3'', . � . . 't :�. . + `.�...� ;!. y'' � . • ' � . , , . . , , k • .� ' ' , � . ' . ' � ' , , ��:`r,' , ;ti; •., ,i '�' r+;• t ; . }, , , �� 'r' ' , ' 1' ��i`� , . . . � • �;^ . . , , �. . � ��1.� �Y. Ci �� .. � ' -' Y ��i.. . i • ' r, ' '. . ' y��:',.` , ;'i.;' i . -.4,. :,� ,. 'i,1'„�.�" ' ':„��: '•(, �t: .��., .. .. � ..� 'i i• ' ' .. ..iiti.' �'� ..., ..'�I � :F•�.. ��+ , . ' . . r . .'''`. . �,� , • . � ,�i� 'i��. . •q' 1S� �,. !:f�.`ri.'. `"r, '. .. .. ' . ' ' , , ., i . . � ... �'�, � . `,f" ��,, .. � ,. . � ., . . ..,. ......, ..,.. .j� .�.�'! ..... .. . .. .. . . . . .. � . . , .. �..k.. . _ . • �r, , . l. ' .:r: •' ' ' . � . • — t €r.�.. .. . "' .;.,�; � � ,i �.� ,� .,}�.'c�?'.. . . � .. . '�.`' j� � � '�-i /{•.� .. . . �5.'�f' • ' .�. ��. .� �''1 .l. � �� . ' . ''�� ii'• �� i`fi�r, � /.w .i . r�L! , .,ry. »'*�,� f�� "� '.1'.�. 'I'�. . �7� � � 1 .. � ',., �* y.�• y��, r l.,t., � � i . '� ".�� '7�' .� '' . . • . �{��r� s�`�, �� '� '�l ��_." . ��, .. ' I '; �� `: ' !�� . _s : �'+' ��i ' �L: �.�'.� �, . . . �� ~�� t •Y4� � ��..'' ."�i . • :t' .r.�i�,�.:,t �, .`�`.',y'.[�. :f'. ✓�' . . . . � , �, '��f•,ry�' S� �� '�FI ,�f,''�'•� , . ' �l.l�ff'i��r! ,�'. .�, '}',� /� .. '� i i{? '1 ,�� 'j• , ' . . ati f:�� }. ). . . �' .. ,•T�r �. •�:'ti 1.' , �' :f+!, .Y . �, ` �� ;. '':. . . ,`,' .i ,'ti '7' F , �' ,I ` .i,. , � /. :�� ;[� 'I .�x . ... .'�ky� ,�x,.�. ;,.;;; '�;._ , ., .��: �,%, . ..+' :°' �!�" � �''�: �. , . � . :� � , ',', . . � �' . i�.� � (i •.; e' �• �,:C .�. . i �•,,:., �1,r..' .�� 1�� i ��,: .� �iy' . �r ',{ •. •,y�' . . - � �.i.. , i�g,c �• . t, � �, �', � . . �y', . �'�'• ' 1i` , % k;�`� � '�o��.,�- ��t�.�i .'I'. ��' ,9y, . ,_' . , . � .i�' * /f . � i ' si�. . . n' :��.fi�',/:,�.";1'.��'�k �r _ ' 1�..�1.�� '�� ',�' ,. ' " " .{ .....f.-..-��--.. �.�....�,'. , r�'��., 1'�. L�� ''i .. '�" it.: :+.. ,-:t �5 , . � . .��• ,�� 1 ,.��,.�I: �. .'; ' :h• . ' . 'A'" . .��'� �; . . � '• '�l'1 ' ' �I' �! .� <t+ r� �'1 � �F��if� rr . ,.✓.' . :4. �f' �.1� �• rl.,Y »i�� ,�, E�', �'. �'f• ' �,/t� �� .`1'. � ' � . ' ` ��,��'-.., '��/'� • � r `.t�:� � �1''�.. � .1�}.� � �, ��^ �+� 'S� S' . ��4 .! }" T�y Y�;l �i` � .. `�! ,�.� � � e.r.' !, '1�. I ��'� • ' , . "� :a;:' •'�1.� . . i .r 'w��. ��a.. '�. :�i:. .�.''' I� . . .,. 'p„�,. `�� . . �k pF:., .:r; :�, 'i�r'� `.i"'' � ,. 't,� . i , . ' , �� r,�;'` .i" !. ',r.�':��±' � . ' � :i. ;j.; ' ' ' . M1' ,.��. 'Y .• ' . , ' 1, ;y, ..�� '�� -� � :+� , .. � '��.t' , �.� � , • . , ,. . , �K, ' �" t� . � , ' ' . � � `�1'�j1 �" , � ..,'�;• y, f , ' ' �_, : 'r, ;,^ f 3 , , � ";, �� r'' :�i.,�..�. , � •�::,�;,�. . ... ?r• . .. . i � - i', , +.� • • j�. . � . �.1• .�i�� .•I,� . . � � , .j�� . �'�: ;:r: ";., , . , . . �'� t ', . .+.; � ''.� �4 ; -.P��` . . ��. !�,.� .�.� . '�': ,� , r• ��;.'�. �.i�ti•il.,�� . . ;;�•� ; .��'. .4� :��- �,3 ; . . . .a ��' ��' � �'.'L'�...�i � � . ��4_._�.��F .�. . 's• �;.. .�. �';;l� �n.�, ;,F�. ::ri _i' 'i� ' � ar�� 7 Ir.` y ,�j �'/''' ��' . ��. ;1,., • . ''t�� .� . '. R�,.; � �� . �f, _ii�i �• .:.. . � � ,� ', �.�.. . z 't ,.r#• � :: . £ . w�. � ; �:', :�' : , �1.; '. �. � ,..^, ' i .�t.{�l ��w•,,��, � , ,�.: _;,• �� `,�i.. , ., �f�r�'','`��, ..•• , �� .'�`� `14�" 1�: :��-,:•_r' ,. . . , ;� • .�". , . r ._ • . ., :� . .. ... . . � _ � . . ..:i�� .. . _ �'lstr •'r . . _"<:: , . , �w�. � . � 4 � •�, . . ' , ' , ' � ' . `, . .� ,, •.i. � , . ^-• � � }:.v • � � .. • . . , ., �'�. . , ' ., j. ,}�.�. . . � � �� .� ..� �J:.�.. � �t ..��' • . . � � • • ` d �1C� �, o �-e l�,q►� d � � � � � � ��, � � n 1 �l � Z � pQ Q h P � �� I�i � la-�- �C` 5� �-� �' -� � �, � �c� � �R� � �c� . � �� a S'`�� :.�'^�"'� ; �� E✓r.. , � - . . � � .� � ..� . r ,�..�..,.�--� � �{�r,�,r :`��f�� . ..1`� �:'4. +'�'i r,.:pr, ; ,I.. �+r' j', %' I ��, "..�:.• . --i , ,�- ..;` ' ; r .: ,�;,�;,�.; `: . ;1'a``; r. :. , ..;i . ��; �.,� i,. i+. . , a, . . 'i.. � �. , j �� rw�.wrlr_ ��(,' .,•i : , . :`k .:� �i,� . +.' � r� 1 � `� �1 �. ��* �', �J.•� . ..�.�.ni�,.. .•�: �,��;'��'�-:�r;:�"�� '.� ;� � ��'' �� _ . �. ._\'il�rn• !i�y� '1 _ ' S l: � iR'�iM�'i�`.�i�« I ,� ; � �: ' i � , �.5 - ' �i'�i. . ^ ; f�; �� 1: . ',e' ,'�� y.. ,= x ., { , '� �►• '1:._ .'i�� •,1}.,',a3,f�r`1; '.1� �� V ` � +,� ;+i i.� . _ «i :: r� �-�.�._��• . 1�� - : �';,;^i�::;:�:;� `� •''Y�5' :" •'•'�--�� r � �C +•.r p �`': '. ' � " 'h�' �.r. ��i.`P��Jtj!Y .�1 Jse ,•�.�'�:.'r.•.�: �-�`•i,':' i.,• �S1 },� iiJC�.«:�j,�4�` ��. •...: � .�`' �-' � � • �� tiY,i'�;�.''��j� � •' i,; .. „ _�. �� I._. „'.t.� •J. _ �� . w�i � • �''rr':� ,� `t :,i�t� s•� iI� .''r.• �::%L. �' ' ��-�J -?��Y;r.,i ti�i�3�': '= • ',�' ..:.:;. �• t. �u �.e �,�•'w�•,�sr�f ��,� r,-` i � c.'., ;. .'_,r �X4s`� �S: t, r.�+�•t..'��1i .r_r_...� • � `: •�•.. • -.-.. .� - �,,... �..�t � ' .:. ,:,��,.`� ;�,:_t:�'i rY i �!'�'.� yi: ''+'.� `+� i� .:+' ' i� • ��1 � '7' +�'!iR yt: . i : 'f. i . . ` �'. • •,;`a14. .✓�J,i!��1��1��i�L� !r',� ;�'�'�r ..t�, ;;'�::�!•� �^' i'�='��`-� ; ',�h`.''.;��hi:r.`.�T.�. p't' : 1 �'�i'` + tr'i. -_ '} . . . .�:. `.k•;'. ; ,ti�°;,:,s.�i;r., •�ri.",,�''�;�te' +'. ;�,�`.; � ' _'�.: �1.. .,,A's'"'t=1 ...'.�.' .,r:�:,�_1 .� . � � ��, 'sa 1 �� .i ti � w'.}'�i�•� � ��' �f: , �.i±- `' 'YtiC 1�� r�� ,•�, i,l-`•�.':: :}':'�'�i�'• •� :; . C , ,� ti:"4Y:�ik � �•t��',� :;i'}�y;.�i,;�',.'=1':.�I'��i•'�`.'" 'e�4.� �'� .Z `•�fE� �-j '. y: ' Y:2:u�1, ir;';�'. ;.; i*�•'. ��r_ "'".�'E. : S '.1 ��'�1 y:. �ij"_i�•✓ �� " ��3�1'•:i.� . .�f:?��,!: ._ �,`'' ��, ^S•�:.��` :• �'.v:;;+t�t�:.:r'�i «•ti'i�'':'.Zs, �:u;;;; �': i � F�:: �1.�=�.k��,�rt.��, i�t,;•��,�d. '.�1,..�:,; �.;'�;� .;;; ��i:. ` , � •..:- ;�i;;`� .'•An�r'..4„ .. .r `:;�:�.i�;�'•t,�:i;`rtt.:'i,�4' �'=n�� 5,i',,.�r�;;��.,:?SL^ _.��:-.i�._.�=_IySC. ':E.�. . �_3i" �5��' '•_�•:' �'_•i.12•r?w� ��:`;.`� '•_� �.};';f � '~ y� +4Rr'� ti✓�' w . .',?'yk: �. .•� A�"•�, �1,:� •��i`�'+=�r• • y'S-i t ��.5 `'[��,a�y-'�L� • yV'', }�: -i%:i>>:�,:; • �-^:' :},jii-. ;'i�'..'Y':.. y"��^�,�'. �'J`•�'.ai'. �e%�h�l �ir 1!}if'�J1� .. .T• i; ti, �J „:'r'', ��+;;�. .` ��;4;�tir1;�Y,rrC' •;} ._'�"..,.�_..r'�',�:�i ,. .. ..'.�,,.:, :. ,. (.'f°:'�� f{Ir�':�4 �;'e`.''�~. �� '. �`�"f--.�';� ' �r;•: �I ,�.,, • .� �.Ji•'�t. 4' h•`i •.'t;;i� fs„ �..,� { . �r. '��rjS; 1}.. . i. � " t��y) �� f• ��:}.�' i :`{� �., ,s t' i �'i'�..... ;��= , r. : i�� i•'}'1t.... ��'�... , t`° , , y',. `!!' • „��: '`� tit`�4�'ys:i�i� .i1`.1iS�.1� .,'•E'.•' '�' �/ �'r,� �f•�•.�.:� '� r� �!'' ,. ,.. �' ' ��rirj'��.. i •..1:. �� f: '1' • � � � {� i . Y•.:.� �y .�:,.', :, . � ( ,l: �...,,�, �� , :� :� �,, «.� 4��'.'.�;;' �' • ��::;.:.. ,��• . �` �' t'7; tr. rA'ii,�•,:.j•• �;� � �� 'F. . �� . [y�l� + 11� I '.'�: ' '.,.:' �: �� `• .'r/ti�,:' � ;:;�",.l.;,,"r _ 'r�" .: �;�'�1'��J`•" t'; t .';,� *y,i,iY '.:��f�:. : ,, ` . 1, y�r` �. � .,. , . � ;. � � �i '��; �,�'y-,ry�i:.:t' t �• .,��'0�'� '�i�Il ��?C:�. !r;; �'y:; :r '�', �,. � �; �F. iI 1 ••'•`� i �.,� •� �� . i i� f' ��' +/..�. ��.i . ', x �� '1:, i .. ,l..�. . 11 �..� 1�},', r; �..::s.��. ri^"^'�� 'as. � �I�..1... � � ��.£' �' `�''. . •�� '7��,rt4• :i�'C , � .{:�� ,:�i..��, �..ii.��t `�u 1„�.. ,I�.i,�.`�.. i.:�•.'r• � • . i� `', r�'�,. y,• i_�}�1�'�.7p;i�v;,' �� r�: �i�r' ��,r;��,,�i�; ��3:.,t r� `�� ,� ��/ .:i,.../7;°,. �• ��..��.,,� "^ ��' ��i"4j�%•�: ;��<�;r.:{;.r,l�,i..`��4:��•� � i1�ti��. ..�� .t�`.:.• :�,�'f��1.' �,;�.. ��. ' .. ; •'�:,.� . . � ,1:y.E:J•;i.r �ya�. , ti .�.k�r'' :."'' :,�.. ..�,. ;�';,,1� ;,�"��,�.:, . �s�.i . •:'.�`. -• '. �,. , ��-, .� � .z'� .'��, � �\."� iy:��'.s ; •�.� i:'r•�l`f �;.i� ��L.4.` �'i:� �i � .:I,, 7.,'+`. f ��" ..4C �' ; +� •' .�' F,F ' ,.. � �I' , ' � ��w.'.-> �;:1�,.� ��.��,�..i. - ' �< <�.'-;i.�,. �r:, .,`��:�yi, t.., ,�-•�[';:`:,�,y .� '`�..c'y %�, ' � '94'!~ ��• i .S'�� .{t!3',..,}'�"'.`''i �';'' ..,"i..'�.� �`, *.,;''. '�.i. -� ! :�..i.� : t�.,..., .5��.... 1�.- : .� ti'..�.�i.`.. wt. "►aY^::�i...�.1� e ",V��I.�rt •� �, ..t�;� ' F. e'. �`;i'" , .,.....`-�•r. . ; j •.:,` �: �,, . � '. r t }'l1` �� .�Y'.: F:: ' .r�Ji ' ��`� � < <N�' � �l rl � p� {' r:'i �' ','f•'� ' w. .. �� e � . •':. '1'; .�. j'' ��i:.�' �;,'.e�j ��'�� '�; .�5'~,��,r i� y�j�� ;r' �}::.;�Y ,.{,}t ;r.:�--. !:. "r" cf.�'�..''•:- �:,� . :. � ��. �. . .�.. �.4•�,f' .,'!t •� . .r _ ,: �� ` 4 +��ji y::;`Q';.,F?:�.. .�� o ?'<.,.,� I.'�. :�':! �'; `r. .'•;.�:'��. • y ' ,r� E :' ' � ., ' ' l.�,y � � ..� � �` � r ��'i ::-Y;'rr!,w +•��, y�• ,y.,�''~ �,ay!e1:�'� .yr t� .,�,.�' q�,',' / �,, �1 + 4 � q ." ' . ' � t�'`•(, " 1•'•�'� ,' � : '�-T•r^,y � ��:'�f, �. �t<' '�.i/., ityT ;- , E �� y.a�,4r,. (f�w l'� �l7r�, .i+,�� %tr ;.E � �i� .}._ ni!�.r�-.: M. . i� ,�.; C; �':r'. ',. . .,'�j i ` ,�' �.T_,•;':r`f � �� "� .Li!�i1`�.�^�''.,}' ;��, �l.'J`y� : R11^, �i:',s+.�.,',�,11.�'�.�{�k� �,l/� (� �i ;�:� � � :'(;t.," ';' 1. {�~�.t�')',, �f; �� `'�F�'�'+ • ,la ...iJ�'�' y �1 %:� st:�., s � .' ., r."., -,' `; : ti4� ' '�� rr�.! '�, 'r: � •'� � . .. ,4 y� � ; .��; �'�. !: i ` : :;:� •.. .':'f: • � ,F a; 1 i � �`i:' �` ;,L"z.' +`t �. . �; ~ ti•�[ ' � �• � . f � � i. . r r�. ti €�r� „'r,?� � (. ' (��_',�,�. " _ �� c' �;y"��'� �'j,!�,: �,1� 'r � ;. �=r ..t• , . �, � . ' .;,:�.s`," ��i : , ',i.��,. t,� . -,r,�, `�, � �.. ', .t, ;,�, �., , .� ,� w/ `�!' � ��.��. :�s, � . . ��. ., � r . `.3.� �. ,5 /■j 1� ��: � 1 .,�i � % '� .' "', `� �..ati.. . q f��!:.��,, ! � �' . � �'`� �', � '� i''•��.`..`, �.;'-��.; `•' '".�� `��',+ s�'ti' � .�;' "' j '' ; ' ' Y: ' ' �°� � ;, i� L,��,.1 ... � .,�^ '..r'! �.�� a,'. °�-=,°;'7: . J • •�•:'.i`'�. �.• ' { ^r'.' � .+�. ��' +.. '.. �. '� . �.�: . r ��',�,�' �' .v''+;: '�aa* ti . 1!'%•0'''��.': ��'.1'� 'r�irn{�x��i'�'l,`.` .�� . �y,Y... '.�. , 1 ,,; : �` .. f E•;',� �.• ;'' .. ,, :�. i . ,•,.r. 3, < • . : s' .f.'y•. (�Y, r , i "ti �� ♦ .7 � a �'`�'" � � 'L`�� ` 'R ,s .�M1: it .�r];,s'„ �''�, ;� ,,i , i,° ,pr �i�.,.` +�, •1"','a'.:.� • �..�� ,c „ � � . . :' �i•it � �'�*:.i•.;.�: '?'''.•�.'�►•{t:''` �� '7 . O>}� . . ., � � . '(� �, '� r.--.r�� "�''I `\#:�.�t .; .. � ' �.n�.i, ..,�li�� a`! ;. ,�',��...,�.,.�.:./' �T--y:'.' �'�j':,�`.'� Y ' !' 7.P�`,l'i �'f'��,i�l'�l 1 ,f ° � �, #�.1� ,'.�e1'� .�.�:.i;; � ,'.�� t��.R•. r:±f ;�'.'• � ,-� :� �: _ . y`.�. � s l�..' •! 'S ��• fr }�' .� ��'f ,f. �F• �1 . .,'�� ,��,.� ��.r�.'.'' �'1��•�' �.rr'� �". '� ,r i��' ; /� i'• (�\�'.` ~ �',�; �� = • , -'. �: � : . �::; � ,� ��; , • � T.'�. �' w', r ��. �. d�,, '� < ".c :.r:;:',,. �. '}.''::�: '�,�' �J �i' 'i..' �''.4' , i . �'� �'�'.. 1��' � ��r� i . ��;LEF� . ;:�. .,� . •`,�M �:o. '`: �V'!l;� �,��y'�,L ',.' �'�=r�I*�s �w'l`:*�, y i,. ' � ^'j ,r h'.t �,r �.� '.:�� ..: ;�.:.,D. 1`Y' �h ;,�. r:� ►�,.y: w'',`1,�' �'��`�,�c; �i � .(•i'�k';",' ''w.'l,'�•4 .L�. I..f � . ,�,�.. �,4., y','';•. Y -.. �/r 'p}, ' `�'.". 'ir.� '�1 ��+rr C..�j�.. y .��:' „fia.�, „':,' ��6',�• ``�.��i'Y+�_� 'I ;•1•�'„�7�� ' . :.1� • •• :'� �* i��' '.'1� � f ' � '•�� ti�r 5. `i�1�� ' ' _ �"f' • 1:l"�Y f �� r� � �r!ti f • � �,I' � 1N� ` �_'��_,�n�^�':i.. k�• 1f\'.. 'f.� i �,. .:X '�il:Yi�.��:"•i�fr':."A''�e�.w .�_�Jt~� . A�s�:1 .�i`'/\�+t;�:''�;•�.i' . � .• f�•; �1./:R�. 1• +'' �' -i.,.�11 e''�� r. � ?, ,�",i•..� .�c''; Jsti "`,,. . , ''�1 .�... � � ,� ' ..��.�,�, r� r' ' ' �:.��:. �q±'• y�'1� +� �''i.�i. ��1'�,�f°,'• , �r'�y,L`� •� r'! }T �. ' '' ,,' .�,'yj+1,. '11 • �� 4,11�,, `r�:tF',I; .''!� .^.�r.'*�' � .. ..�..3 , � ; ��:'r;�::. Y..,..;. ��.�,'.,.s' � .,•.' •�..' z' , '�1.. .; `i" :'i. -�/r'. "�.: .�, �`it. r i�i, '�, .. .i.L,`:`1_�'`F fe��'..r`�1��.'�fr�.��, , . i. �.1�.. .I , .. . , � 1' . �: ; ., , � :'^' "..4., " . �y ��' �a ••. � •, f � ' =s` .r �`' '�'. rfr,� f ;� ' o , i . ' f.'' 'r.'.!i,. � �� '. , i r . , .'i" � ,• ?;;' � '?� �g ..r.. ' '` . , . .�.n� , ''. ' .•., 'r .;4' ',t ,�'r�a-r' r '• s : .;.:�' T' �:`r`L* , 4;�! i,,� u�; �.�7�`t+,•. , r -.L�., t,' � .,. y�'.. �.. .... ' . a � . •�,�,,�.,,- -s ,. ,1 , . � 1 j 5' r �� { �r �':�1 �' r '' � f l�y� .f,A ' ,, ,�� .�:�; ,�'�.�'•�'1� ` yfr' �. 1• •��j� * � �+�� i i�G"� � � �'f �" r J� � ' � • r ,Is.y� : �.::..� •r�f s', , : � ', � , ' �• . i T . „ �L�e '_� � , ��'� �� ' ��``;�.4��.+ ; �� ' l ,t. ' { �,%*.,.. , . � ; '.., ► . � t � �� i; ;'�, ''� �{ r �c � +`�ti,7 ;b ' �, ` ��:� 3.�.' r .\', „ � `��" ; �. � �� , .� ( � 1� .,. � � � M . \�,/.�:-�c, . �. . ~;4�� y�,.y ��f� ` ; i � �'� ;' �,�:� � '?';��?� %'�Ir' � i � j r�j ' '.�s' =a '� � :� , �..�►� �'� ' `�'i J_ ♦ � ` µ�. � r i M � 'i r1 � � ^ ,,` : h ►!+� ...s . . BI , , � - �; , �.�, i a►7�,•':'+►,• . '.ri.. 1 � `;�,j,r,+l � 1 •� 1 . .�1. . .''' ��:��,�` w . . � R. � � � . � �;+�1,� • �*, ��'��;,1 ,,� : � q . . � � � . �.' � ' ,�.. 1 � � . �, , _•. ' ,!'',. ^'�� . • ,��1� il �• �i 'r�,.�. r.�4 ' r'T„��'`�' �iyi 1 , ,r7�.� � ``E • '.r� • Il.c',� ��' IfY��. . �J. E�,��''� . '`: �� * � f,. " , r��. �.'�T�' ""'� .�r�r� .i. '+��,,�, �.: ' ..r4;' ,'�`�j,`�'".'t.' � � '�i- ...�.:�.. ,:i..-.,�'ray•s.� �.i;7��ritrl;.�'�ti::�:- � ' � �r .. .��;, '�.{ � ::: �, � i .{G�, ',w' t. ; r�� . ,,. ry�,�:. '}', ' ' k: '�.�„4�� _�,��'� i"+�. ' � '�' ' lr.:;{,�'�.�'��`:i�'f. ,j,. ; �'1.�, ��1 'r,�,�` �,� �r1 .y• i . f� `� y1,•��: .} �,,i�5� �./` .Y � t t ••' � . Mh�' 'M�',' .., , � �,;. ' '7• 11j �,I , . . 1 � . � _�� i . . S•" �� , �' y1,ty'� �' ' � � ' • �11� .. y.•J: M'F. !• •..�'�Y �. ' ' Y , i!{� �' '. ti �, . '�1 • .. �� l�,' ��'�. 1 �l � �nV� � r �� • ��1 A I 'fi i, ,'h. 'r 11 i., . � .}fi�� ' �' �� , • , ��•' ti/ Y.J .',�• i .�r�y�.•i .,�'�✓i;'�+:;!'.�, �:,�,', i�.�; �,.� �.;�';�5. '."• .w`,,:� tI. ��'j��r � ..t� �."�/'.. .t . k! ��! ' . ..'�t ... F� y S ��VG� �i �ll. 3 � l. �';�� k�. �,' `� k\ �� `,� ' . .. . li JI•� � �ti ��,4 � . �� . � � i ,..,y' �..y,� t ,.r� ,y',,.��i �,�, �'"fn �.•_:�+1?. 1, .:t: �-.::^:. :•.t�S�s�;t'�w1��4 �� . i.sY ��. .. X :� ..:�:-.� w �'n ' �� '��: '' , � `�� f�. }5:n ,'i '� ,�. � r�,., �., •�y `7� ��~.�r'1 � i•l. • i �'�' '� .. ' . ' � '� r '+, �- � �' r�� !�'� r., , . , ,��,`.�, ...si�,�*� 1..' � ♦�� w' ,C . 'tiM, '� .� : '{'� •, "% r ;.r,,� , � ��. ~�' •.�• ;',;;:` �' ... , �'. `rt. .��y�;r,�,E .`t �'y��',; .�yYr. ;r J�• .' _: ' : � . ,J � � T ' {r �� ri � ��j, '�. � � • S,i�` �! �i'�,'��rp , `�,r �' . • -� ��X •��t.4'." „ /'� i�,�, :i� � '� •n, ��;•E, ,�,4 {.f ��. 'i i/� � 'ri�'�,` f.. ��..r. �; ' .;Q`:`� : . �, ,,, P E � • •�,. �, 5�1...� "l�...,`;'+ r ?;�;ti_ ..... . ��:, •'�:, �. :F;., {; .� ��„ �a 5,� �_.,.�.�.�:..,'r�` .�r;R �+•'. .�•'*`. ':`� .i.',4 , �,'�. . f_ti, �� .. ,j . �. i � � `�:.i�ff^�"�!A' •,•."' '.7'E• ?,� 'i; �..�� ! � .,�,�' �, X �3.`': ' .'� '•;:„:, � N � +�ar � �.;;v��,��,,�;.y�.yt^�,��:1�'t. °��, „�� lj.':: �i��' j , }�. , � 4+ �t � � ; � �r�� ;-c�,,., ,,.;�. . . �� ,: .°�� '�,:`f �� '" . . : ,. �,' �:� :��, ; ;,�• :- •' y4, �).:' ". �,i'�, ,'�;, , • !�' °r� . . ! ' : ?' , �,i�r ,' �'. ?46' ,a��, �rr. t t,, ` '�' . �'�� . , .� ; • . �'t'.:17%,e±,\' `;i\: NJ`'1�'.(�.,..'�'�1 `'i"'� 'F~� 1��+ / LJ� �i`,[�-/_ ,. ., . :; '.. ,1 'p'�� ' . . %�. �� 1`' � j,? 11 n • ; +' ,� 'f 1'� , �V. i.: <.'Nr , t 1 'l. i �,i : ; .) ',�' � '� •r, �,,' .t��.•�. ,1,'"' , ' �/•.,: - ; .t. ��y! 4. �'.`. ` .�c �.,� .'�, � .��;,� . � ;z.. �\�,"1� �� tt, ' � • '� Li; `�' y•y ;.e. 'n; �,f �,`�"' i: . .✓ . .�� r��' `�� t i , y}`.Y.f i..yy �y� l. l ,( 1 • 1'�W+� �' ' ��/ ,4�� '�'+f �ti ` `p±�. .� . . ` 4 :'. �;.�,',,�'•'�;F, 1 �'� . +. _ �: ;:. . .•1 :4i" Y� <; .' � '.� +1.Y�.• .�i .1a, P'.t �`. 1 ' `,` ,,.. ,(w� � !, _�, � . :. t .. , �'... :�.� ' .iw. . •r.. . ;�h�'�� ,G` , . , , ,Y .�. '{'...."' ; . , -=�_,,,,, L,�, "'tY ��1 � .�'' '�, �;,.t�� r �';r�---'r ri;'+i:':". : �� r`.- .•.��,,; '�; ,, ,' �.I'.. � :i. y 'p' . .��T.l' 4 �� ,� �� / �.1`� if' � , f � �'�:. `',. '�� 'y k r�•t, t �' �K �� • � � �� . � � .'i �.��'� � .. . ♦ �•. . .� � �, f: " ,..;y.�=:�_�� ' ' .� � ',. � i r � �a ' I" ::'; � , • ','•1';.',, ` � n JL�'` : i. ��. ,..� �'��•!•. ,`:��' �`,-'�,..`: t�..••,'.:r�� :�;'i.�-��', --- . , . . , . . . . , , . . _ . i::.' � . , , �� .�.� .• • , .. . „ . : .. , ,. . , - � `�. . . • . , ., , , \,, , , , • , . , . , . , . � ,.�. . �,. .�,4 . , , ,��a . �r � ... � . ' , . `. • � . ' , . , } . . � i� . , , ' . . ' � . • , ' .. . . .. 9 . ' 1 , . .�` , . , • . , ' � .. . . . . " . . � � ' . � � � ' ' . ' 1� � � . ^ � � ' . i . ' ' ' . c, ' ti:sl• , ' ' • . � 1 . . . �:1.. '.fi. .. .C. . ." h'i � .. . .. , — . .. . .. ^ . ... ... . � . ' ,�1 .• • .. , , ' ' , . � � �, " ~', ;��' ^, i , . � ' ,I ` '. .. �. f��, ' . �. 1..'• •, f�. . ' � , .�,I . . �.. � �.. ; . . • ' ;' ' .. . : 1 � ' , ��. . + 4. • ' .. 4 ' , . �' � , . i •�' � • . � ', . . � '• ' . � • ' . , � . . ' . ' � ' �i�� ' , !:. . ' . . Y . .. � �. . ' � � . . ' ,'�': }'' ' ' '' , .. ? ' ' "' . � � j , .. . �, 1 ' ., . . ' ' ' ' ti' � , . ' , • , • . , � � • � ' • i , . . . . � ' , ' � t ', ' . �. � '�. �'�� .i' , . ' , . � i ' � , . •��. �' '� I�' � � .� . . � ' . , . .. . . . � � ., *,'' ,�, , �'? / • ' 1. . ` �� ' .. . ' ,� ? � �. , .. _ �r`''{:•.��1,'/r� t�, ' N•r'" .''t• .•f15 .• ' ' . . �� '� ', 't• r •'' '� ' .;l ( , I, ;.,:'',` ... ��, . "`, - , ., • �.+� f `.. � t i . : •�1 -r��. '.. -'ti. � - .�. . �'. � . � ' �r"� " � ,,' • .. ' (��1,'. 3 `� '.1`' `{c . .., � . � • - .�,' �, . � . ,t • .:ut �.'r,_. -:r• . . . ' s �'' ;�' ' , � - `+' `' . # - �4" Yr r . '�� i.',,r,'_ - . � �' ° . �f; �a; �i ` ��- : 1. ti i'i�.. � � • '� ` -? . � j �, , . , '. n �i �' ^� . • ,:y• �"� }':._. •. . / � 'i�;• "F , .! �, , ._ f , � y , � f:. „�~ '� ' .. '.�; ' + ;. '�� ' ' �`. '� , ' ` � � � � � •''�v � 't.� �) - ,; ~ % i. i . '�. _�. �f,,, �y�' ::`.:;:.�r,;t � �_�.. � . ',.. � �t��;;: ' V�� :4 , '�i�, i�'''' ��.+ t.. �,.•. °� '•��; ' ,-tii,� '5�:. ' • '. ''T� � �:,,�,�r' '.�,`;.,�/.l`•1��; ,f�!,. � ~ ' ";r' ' •` �-�, •,��''• �� , ' .'s- , : : � , . � ,, . n , '�t.' � ! .� � ,'' fi "' 'E.�� '.•' . '\- � i'� . . . ' �C � . � �r�� -'-�- � �r' . - :,' ��r . ,� _ ,'�, `"..{ '' . `. ,.�,•.1��•.- ,C:�;� , a � �� ' }' . ,... t.�,. � µ k'�,` �'-:� '.✓,'� `,E'i. • ; � � � • ', �� r � �.�,�',f� t� �,. �~'i