08/17/1995
,
k;,. -
. ,. .
~ \
',/
, , .
"
p
"
;. . ~.~;:~ . ..t";'; ....'h;: ~ '.' ...~.
"
.~ '
.~. '" . .,.... ~ ....,. ~ . "
AG'ENDA
DA;E_8 .. d.. 93
.' ,......
'!
F )Ljl/t'
.~._......_.....~ + . .-.
~1:
"
i
i
\
I
~
.
i
i
'j
l
,
.
i
I
i
1
: I
I
I
i
,~- '
"! '
. ,'.
, ,
: ~'
,:~.;,. '
1f;~r:::f;;;\';\.,r"~'i~:"~"\'; .J~'>' "," ";:,
I .',
... .
..
,I" I
'.
,"
. ,',
. ~~ . ': '
CITY COMMISSION MEETING
~
~5
Note: 'l /1'1 It{ 5 Preliminary (Wot'ksession) agenda and pnpC1....,Ol:K that was
in package initially but then not continued onto 'l'hursday I s agenda
is at the back of this agenda pnck~
F JL/Lf;
\
I
;
\
l '
t '
i
l~
I
L
! '
!
!
\t
\
\
I
!
I
. . ~ .""
ACTION AGENDA - CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION MEETING
Thursday, August 17, 1995 - 6:00 P.M. . Chambors
Welcome. Wo oro glad to have you loin us. If you wish to speak plooso wait to be recognized, then
state your ill!.!illl and address. Persons speaking before tho City Commission on other than Public
Hearing Items shall be I1mitad to 3 minutes. No person shall speak more than once on the same
sublect unless granted permission by the City Commission. ANY PERSON WITH A DISABILITY
REQUIRING REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING,
SHOULD CALL 813/462-6684,
1 . Invocation
2. Pledge of Allogiance
3. ServIce Awards
4. Introductions and Awards
5. Presentations
6. Approval of Minutes - Regular Meeting
8/3/95 & 2 attorneylclient special meetings
of 7/31/95
7. Citizens to be heard re Items not on the
Agenda (maximum of 30 minutes)
1. William C. Baker, Assistant City Manager.
2, Mayor.
3. Five
4. Nono.
5. None.
6. Approved as submitted.
7. Glen Johnson presented a letter and
drawing re proposal to develop shops,
restaurant and lighthouse/observation tower
on current Clearwater Pass Bridge.
l
I
~
':i
Ii
~
;l
.J
~
"
~
~
David Camobell thanked staff for efforts to
keep Builder Square truck traffic off Druid
Rd. He requested police patrol for
compliance.
'^
,
j.
.
Rev. Floyd Erwin expressed concern re
bubble bath causing severe rashes on
children following excessive use.
Barbara Steo requested identifying signage
be removed from neighborhood ACLF.
- -------prrerrCHEARNGS
All Individuals speaking on public hearing items will be sworn-in,
Not Before 6:00 P.M.
Varlanco & Rezoning public hearings:
Staff states and summarizos reasons for recommendation (2 minutes).
Applicant presents case. Witness may be cross-examined (15 minutes).
Staff presents further evidence. May be cross-examined (10 minutes).
Public comment (3 minutes per speaker),
CIty Commission discussion, and may question any witness.
Applicllnt may call witnosses in rebuttal (5 minutes).
Conclusion by [lppllcllnt 13 minutes).
Decision.
08/17/95
1
,,' .
8. (Cant. from 7/20/95) Public Hearing & First
Reading Ords, #5741-95 & #5742-95-
land Use Plan Amendment to Commercial
General for property located at 509
Bayview Ave, and 508 Meadow lark lane,
Town of Bay View a/k/a McMullen Bayview
Sub., Blk.. 3, part of lots 1 & 2, and S 1/2
of vacated street abutting N side of lots;
and CPO Zoning for property located at 509
Bayview Ave., 508 Meadow lark lane, and
3009 Gulf to Bay Blvd" McMullen Bayvlew
Sub., Blk. 3, part of Lots 1 & 2 and
Bayview City Sub., lot A, and vacated
street r-o-w between lot A and lots 1 & 2
of McMullen Bayview Sub.; LUP 0.70 acres
m.o.I., Rezoning 1.02 acres m.o.l. (R. Roy
Meador, lUP93-43, Z93-54)
9. (Cant, from 7/20/95) Variance(s~ to Sign
Regulations for property located at 387 1/2
Mandalay Ave., Barbour-Morrow Sub., Blk.
A, Lots 23-25 (Homer Realty, Inc. /
Wedgwood House Estate Jewelers, SV95-
31 )
10, Variance(s) to Sign Regulations for property
located at 2632 Enterprise Rd. (Europa of
Countryside, A Condominium, SV95-33)
8. Approved. Ords. #5741-95 & #5742-95
passed 1 st reading.
9. Approved 11 .5 sq. ft. area variance to allow
attached signs with a total area of 34 sq. ft.,
a ratio variance of 0.77 sq.ft. of attached
sign area per foot of building width to allow
2.27 sq,ft. of attached sign area per foot of
width, a variance of 2 window signs to
allow 5 window signs, and a variance of 2
attached signs to allow a total of 7 attached
signs.
10. Cont. to 09/07/95
Administrative public hearings:
Presentation of issues by City staff.
Statement of case by applicant or representative (5 minutes).
Commission questions.
Comments in support and in opposition (3 minutes per speakerl.
Commission questions.
Final rebuttal by applicant or representative (5 minutes).
Commission disposition
11. Public Hearing - Vacating a portion of
North/South alley north of Pierce St.,
between Ft. Harrison Ave. & Osceola Ave,.
platted as Division Street in Blk. B, John R,
Davey Sub. (Peace Memorial Presbyterian
Church, V95-10) (EN)
12. Public Hearing - Res. #95-65 - Approving a
new Community Redevelopment Plan for
08/17/95
11. Denied.
12. Approved Res. #95-65 adopted.
2
the Community Redevelopment area located
In the downtown area of the City (eM)
13, Public Hearing & First Reading Ord. #5820~ 13. Approved. Ord. #5820-95 passed 15t
95. Amending Sec. 42.34 - LOCA re reading.
parking space formulae {LOCA 94-281
Public Hearing - Second Reading Ordinances
14. (Cont, from 8/3/95) Ord, #5861-95- 14. Ord. #5861-95 adopted.
Annexation for property located at 1528
Stevensons Dr., Stevenson's Heights, Blk.
A, Lot 20 (Rowe, A95-1 2)
15. (Cant. from 8/3/95) Ord, #5862-95 - Land 15. Ord. #5862-95 adopted.
Use Plan Amendment to Residential Low for
property located at 1528 Stevensons Dr.,
Stevenson's Heights, Blk, A, Lot 20 IRowe,
lUP95-14)
16, ICont. from 8/3/95) Ord. #5863-95 - RS-8 16. Ord. #5863-95 adopted.
Zoning for property located at 1528 n
Stevenson5 Dr., Stevenson's Heights, Blk. .
"
A, Lot 20 (Rowe, A95-12) ,:
~
f
17. Ord, #5869-95 - Amending Sec. 2.60(3), 17, Ord. #5869-95 adopted. i
.
relating to term of members of the t
Environmental Advisory Board 18. Ord. #5870-95 adopted. }
18. Ord. #5870-96 - Annexation for property ~
~
located at 109 Meadow lark Lane B, ,
Bayview City Sub" Blk. 2, lots 1 & 2 and I
abutting alley to' South (Kadlec, A95-14)
19. Ord. #5871-95 - Land Use Plan Amendment 19, Ord. #5871-95 adopted. J
to Residential Urban for property located at
109 Meadow lark lane B, Bayview City
Sub., Blk. 2, Lots 1 & 2 and abutting alley
to South (Kadlec, LUP95-16) 20. Ord. #5872-95 adopted.
20. Ord. #5872-95 - RS-8 Zoning for property
located at 109 Meadow lark lane B,
Bayview City Sub., Blk. 2, Lots 1 & 2 and
abutting alley to South (Kadlec, A95-14) 21. Ord, #5873-95 adopted.
21. Ord. #5873-95 - CG Zoning for property
located at 1969 Sunset Point Rd., Pinellas
Groves Sub., SW 1/4, part of Lots 1 & 2
(Sauder, Z95~03) 22. Ord. #5874-95 adopted.
22. Ord. #5874-95 - CPO Zoning for property
located at 705, 707, 709 & 711 Jasmine
Way, Magnolia Park. Btk. 31 . Lots 2-5
(Smolensky / Kornreich / Shaughnessy,
295-04)
08/17/95
3
. > '. ~J
I
(
I
I
I
j
I
r '
1
23, Ord, #5878-95 - Annexation for property 23, Ord. #5878-95 adopted. :
located at 412 Oakmount Rd" Oakmount
Sub., Lot 2 and abutting r-o-w (Clark, Jr.
and Warren, A95-17)
24. Ord. #5879-95 - Land Use Plan Amendment 24. Ord. 115879-95 adopted.
to Residential Low for property located at
412 Oakmount Rd" Oakmount Sub., lot 2
and abutting r-o-w (Clark, Jr, and Warren,
LUP95-19)
25. Ord. #5880-95 - RS-6 Zoning far property 25. Ord. #5880-95 adopted.
located at 412 Oakmount Rd., Oakmount I
Sub., Lot 2 and abutting r-o-w (Clark, Jr. I
and Warren, A95-17)
26. Ord. #5881-95 - Annexation for property 26. Ord. #5881-95 adopted. t
located at 1236 I{apok Circle, Kapok ~
,
,
Forest, Lot 14 (Sario and Hassell, A95-18)
27. Ord. #5882-95 - land Use Plan Amendment 27. Ord. #5882-95 adopted,
to Residential Low for property located at
1236 Kapok Circle, Kapok Forest, Lot 14
(Sarlo and Hassell, LUP95-20) )
28. Ord. #5883-95 - RS-6 Zoning for property 28. Ord, #5883-95 adopted, ~
located at 1236 Kapok Circle, Kapok
Forest, Lot 14 (Sario and Hassell, A95-181 i
.
29. Ord. #5884-95 - Annexation far property 29. Ord. #5884-95 adopted. I
1
located at 1238 Brookside Dr., Meadow i
Creek Sub., Blk. C, Lot 10 (Coulter, A95- I
.
I
19) ~
30. Ord. #5885-95 - Land Use Plan Amendment 30. Ord. #5885-95 adopted. ~
to Residential Low for property located at J
1238 Brookside Dr" Meadow Creek Sub., I
Blk. C, lot 10 (Coulter, lUP95-21)
31. Ord. #5886-95 - RS-4 Zoning far property 31. Ord. #5886-95 adopted. I
I
located at 1238 Brookside Dr" Meadow I
Creek Sub., Blk. C, Lot 10 (Coulter, A95-
19)
32. Ord. #5887-95 - Relating to Utilities; 32. Ord. #5887-95 adopted.
amending Appendix A - Schedule of Fees,
Rates & Charges to provide new Gas Rates
& Service Charges for the Clearwater Gas
System
33, Ord, #5888-95 - Relating to the Community 33. Ord. #5888-95 adopted,
Redevelopment Agency; providing for repeal
of Ords. #2576-81 & #3021-83, which
adopted and amended the redevelopment
plan for downtown Clearwater; providing
for proper notice
08/17/95
4
41
34.
Special Items of widespread publlc interest
a)
Memorial Causeway Bridge Feasibility Study
a)
Cant. to 09/07/95,
35.
Citizens to be heard re items not on the Agenda ~ None.
CITY MANAGER REPORTS
CONSENT AGENDA (Items #36-45) - Approved as submitted.
The following items require no formal public hearing and are subject to being approved in a single
motion. However, any City Commissioner or the City Manager may remove an item from the Consent
Agenda to allow discussion and voting on the item individually.
36. Contract extension for audit services with Coopers & Lybrand, for FY ending 9/30/95, for a total
fee not to exceed $93,300 (FN)
37. Contract extension for purchase of Black 3408 polyethylene pipe with M. T. Deason Co., Inc.,
Birmingham, AL, for the period 12/14/95-12/13/96, at an est. $1,018,375 (GAS)
38, Contract renewal for Unisys A-4 & A-6 computer software licenses to Unisys Corp., Tampa, FL,
for the period 10/1195-9/30/96, for $52,681 (1M)
39. Contract renewal for hardware maintenance/operating system support on the Utilities & Finance
VAX 4000-300 computers to Digital Equipment Corp., Tampa, FL, for the period 10/1/95-
9/30/96, for $45,310.44 (1M)
40. Purchase of 2 high speed laser printers & instalJation for Utility Building to Dynamic Solutions
International, Englewood, CO, for $39,380; authorize lease/purchase through city agreement
with Barnett Bank (1M)
41. Contract for hardware maintenance of the Unisys A-4 & A-6 mainframe computers to Digital
Equipment Corp., Tampa, FL, for the period 10/1/95-9/30/96, for $33,987.96 (Consent)
42, Contract extension for subscription services for library materials with Ebsco Subscription
Services, Birmingham, AL, for the period 10/1/95-9/30/96, at an est. $65,000 (LIB)
43. Contract for 1995 Gunite Restoration to Infrastructure Services, lnc.! 151 Operating Corp.,
Franklin, TN, for $323,711 (EN)
44. Contract for Hampton Road Widening (Gulf to Bay Blvd. to Drew St.) to R. E. Purcell
Construction Co.. Inc.. Odessa, FL, for $588,473.97 (EN)
45. Receipt/Referral. LDCA to modify restrictions on vending machine signage (LDCA 95~17) (CP)
!
1
I
,
~
!
i
!
1
~
I,
~
~
~
I
<
OTHER ITEMS ON CITY MANAGER REPORT
46. First Reading Ord, #5890-95. Amending
the provisions of Div. 3 of Art. 5 of the
City's Code of Ordinances, adopting a
revised Employees' Pension Plan, providing
for a referendum election relating to the
pension plan (CM)
47. Confirm City Manager's decision to increase
domestic and lawn water rates approx.
12.53% effective 10/1/95, such increased
46. Approved Ord. #5890-95 passed 1 st
reading as amended.
47. Confirmed.
08/17/95
5
rates ta be used for 1 st full billing cycle
beginning an ar after 1011/95 (FN)
48. Other Pending Matters
al Consideration of Beach Tower proposal
CITY ATTORNEY REPORTS
I'
49. Other City Attorney Items
a) Res. #95-66 - Authorizing execution 'of
Pinellas County Interlocal Mutual Aid
Assistance Agreement for police services
b) Res. #95-67 - Authorizing execution of
Tampa Bay Multi-Agency Gang Task Force
Mutual Aid Agreement
c) First Reading Ord. #5894-95 - Relating to
Franchise Agreement with Time Warner
Ente rta i nm e nt-Adva nc elN ew ho use
Partnership, to amend the agreement to
extend the term of the franchise for a
period of 3 months, ending an 1111/95;
amending Ord. #2085 increasing the
franchise fee paid ta the City to 5 %
48. Approved clements to be included in
beach tower contract.,
49. al Res. #95-66 adapted.
bl Res. #95-67 adopted,
cl Ord, #5894-95 passed 1 st reading.
50. City Manager Verbal Reports
51 , Other Commission Action
08/17/95 6
___...~.....~_.....__..c _..~, ,y....~. .TO,.'. .~.~ ..
50. Internet demonstration to be scheduled in
, September at Main Library.
eM reported funding application for new
product development was submitted to
eVB.
CM noted Central Permitting innovations
commended in recent national planning
magazine.
51 . Thomas reported he submitted a grant to
the State for matching funds to purchase
Camp Soule,
Berfield referred to scheduled Pinellas
Legislative Delegation Hearings. City will
address legislative package by second
hearing. Letter to be sent expressing
concerns regarding need to control illegal
fireworks sale
"
I,
52. Adjournment
08/17/95
:. ;.
Berfield questioned if memo re
Morningside had been addressed. It was
indicated the Police Chief will respond.
Johnson noted Commission 'salaries had not
been increased since 1980 and felt the
issue should be addressed again.
The Commission approved a salary increase
to $15,000 for Commissioners and
$18,000 for the Mayor, A first reading
was scheduled for 08/28/95 at 9:00 a,m.
Garvev noted Nagano correspondence has
not been copied to the Commissioners,
CopIes will be provided from now on
'52. 2:09 a.m. - 08/18/95
"
~
7
-;.......
-t,. "
, ,
TO:
I.
FROM:
SUBJECT:
COPIES:
'{.
DATE:
, 'jo;t......~
C I T Y OF C LEA R W ATE R
Interdepartmental Correspondence
1
I
i
I,
I
,
,
, ,
.i
"/
1
Mayor Garvey
Sally Thomas; AgendD Clerk
Invocation
Cynthia Goudeau, City Clerk
August 17, 1995
No minister will be present this evening.
~
t
I
t.
~
I
I
,
{
,
I
\,
"-.-. .
CLEARWATER CITY COMMISS10N
Agenda Cover M~morandum
, '.~
Itom #
Meeting Date: 8/14/95
8/17/95
SERVICE AWARDS
Subject
The following employees be presented with service awards for their length of service in the
employment of the City of Clearwater.
o and that the appropriate olticlals be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND:
UJt!J.!Ji.=
Karl D. Pople
Roland C. Martens
James Nungester
Betsy K. Clement
Recomme ndat ion/Motion:
Police
Engineering
Solid Waste
In fo rmati 0 n
Mgmt.
James O. Pyan. Jr.
Thomas H. Miller
William F. Jaruszek
Sean Schlcsman (PPT)
10 Years;.
Joseph N. Zag one
William Farias
Gregory J. Bickel
John R. Diebel
Konrad McCree
Arnold G. Abramson
Barbara L. Taggart
Rene Colmenares (PPT)
Po lice
Police
Police
Police
Police
Marine
Public Works
Parks & Recreation
Benjamin F. McBride
Joseph J. Rinaldi
Edna G. Lee
Carla S. Collins
Anthony Holloway
Stephen Doherty
Patricia Meri
15 Years:
Jerry L. Williams
Dennis F. Brown
Joseph V. Caple
Solid Waste
Solid Wastc
Gencral Services
Sam Brown, Jr.
George R. Miller
20 Yea r s :
James R. McGee
Public Works
Thomas M, Grow
25 Yea r s :
Donald W. Andrus
Engincering
30 Yen r s:
Clarence L. Fails
Police
Engineering
Information Mgmt.
Parks & Recreation
Police
Police
Police
Police
Police
Central Permitting
Finance
I
Solid Waste
Solid Waste
Gas
Solid Waste
Reviewed by: Originating Dept: Costs: CommissIon Action:
Human Resources Total
Legal D Approved
Budget 0 Approved w/condllions
Purchasing User Dept.: Current FY 0 DenIed
Risk Mgmt. 0 Continued to:
CIS Funding Source:
ACM AdvertIsed: 0 Cap!. Imp.
Other Date: 0 Operating
Paper: 0 Other Attachments:
o Not required
Submitted by: Affected parties Appropriation Code:
D Notified
o Not required D None
Cllv Manager
,\
m~~.
TO: Mayor Rita Garvey
FROM: Betty J. Blunt, Confidential Clerk Receptionist
COPIES: city Commissioners, Betty Deptula, Cyndie Goudeau
SUBJECT: Presentation at the August 17, 1995 Work Session
DATE: August 17, 1995
The following presentation will be made at the August 17, 1995 city
commission meeting.
,s years
vlarl pople
city seal)
Police' Department (letter of appreciation, pin with
,
i
1
I
I
. I
i
SERVICE AWARDS
\'.
10 years
~egory Bickel - Police (letter of appreciation, wall clock)
~nold Abramson- Marine (letter of appreciation, wall clock)
ears
am Brown, Jr. - Solid Waste (letter of appreciation, plaque)
eorge Miller - Solid Waste (letter of appreciation, plaque)
30 years
v61arence Fails - solid Waste (letter of appreciation, ring)
R. c: : 'I MEETING DA TE 'f5-t-l..r:rf'1 .s
Persons wishing to speak before the Conlmission at the beginning of
the nleeting under "Citizens to be Heard regarding ftems"not on the
Agenda" nlust pre*register with the City Clerk Departnlent prior to
6 : 00 p, nl, 0 nth e d [J Y 0 f the rn e e tin 9 . A m a x i nl u nl 0 f ten p e 0 pie (3
minutes per person) will be heard at this time in the order in which
they register. Those persons wishing to pre-register PLEASE PRINT
your narl1e and address below:
, ;
I
Ii
I
t
I
NAME
ADDRESS _
124rtfJ{) lJ;EJ.c,f/&'K KiJl!4~1ZI--
pJ16E 42.1 ~ pHI tPlluS-2.f-/777
, ?-:, /..s:> /'4 , ~ AI ~o.Co A ~>>
C L \.N 1>-+" t..:.;c
1, G)EA/ ~#)-J)/$&1lI
\AV{ ~6eCL.
2. F7
3.
4.
, 5,
. 6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Persons who are not pre-registered and wish to speak before the Commission
may do so after the public hearings.
"
Glen Johnsol1
~~:... ~
(l" '., -r_n",",
, -'-lii
~lJ
.. ........~ ~
'n, nn_........ __ ..oJ-
and Associates
!
...
August 17. 1995
f<e
'7
Mayor Rita Garvey
City of Clearwatel' Commissioners
Pinellas County Commissioners
City of Clearwater residents
Residents of the Tampa Bay area
1'0 all concerned,
As a resident of Pine lias County since 1957. I have watched and participated in it's
growth over the last thirty eight years. I was proud to learn yesterday that of the lop three-
hundred cities rated (as to Ulere suitability for living in Ule United States) the Tampa/Sl.
Petersburg area was rated in U~e top ten (regretfully Clea.rwater was omitted), The source
Florida's dominance as leading Ule nation in economic growUl and stability. As a cit..i:l.cn and
property owner I have been blessed with the opportunity to have done over a half billion dollars
of business, mainly in construction I'elated projects over the past twenty two years, My resume
includes and specializes in architectural and structural design, construction and development
of beach front properties. To my knowledge no other person has built more gulf front projects
on the Pinellas County beaches.
I mention this for the specific reason that I have adequate credentials and experience to
develop a project as I am about to ul'iefiy detail, After a month of thought and research I
propose an alternative to Ule demolition of the existing Clearwater pass bridge and in lieu of
constructing the "proposed tower".
Clearwater Left Bank shall consist of a high end shopping village ftlled with unique
premium retail stores, boutiques, galleries, cafes, specialty shops and fine dinning, all
overlooking Clearwater pass and the sunsets of the Gulf of Mexico. This community project will
be consu'ucted by redeveloping Ule existing Clearwater pass bridge, Located over "the new
channel area", vertical structural columns will raise you to a cross over area at point higher that
the seventy foot new bridge. On top of this cross over area, an observatory level and a revolving
fine dinning establishment (similar to that atop ofTarnpa International Airpol"t) wiU be perched
120 feet above the center of Clearwater pass. This aren (dinning/obseIVation level) will serve as
a base for one of, if not Ule. worlds tallest lighthouse.
This structure will selves as 1I0t only a world wide recognizable city landmarlc and site
seeing facility, but will also selve as a welcome navigational Bid to our beautiful harbor.
I have provided copies of this conceptual idea in the form of an elevation sketch as the
project would appear fl'om Ule gulf side of Clearwater pass,
I believe ill the conceptual project that I have proposed above and 1 am prepared to
expand on a more prospective. detailed elevation, I feel tills project is a more Ulan viable option
to the proposed demolition and removal of the existing bridge and tile cost Ulat shall be
incurred. '
I respectfully request bOUl the demolition of Ule existing bridge and the procet:ding of Ule
proposed towers be put on hold for a brief period of time until the ftnancial. legal and practical
matters can be addressed and a formal association can be formed to present a proposal that will
honor such a pJ'Oject.
I
Res pec tInlly,
diJljp- --',
Glen 9Z::~
J 2600 Belcher Road · Suite 102J · Largo. FI... 34643 · (813) 524-1777 · Fax (H 13) 524-1077
I
"
, 4
," ,
"I,.
I
!'
CTb~
'?J/7 CL
@
Fine Dining
..s-(R~VOIVing)
.~
BaLV'EW
BILTMORE
\
i
, '
I
I
I
I
t
,
I
,
____ Lighthou5e,(height to be determined) N:r.S.
~ Observation Platform
ISLE of SAND KEY
~
. .
-'
~."'.,~~
'.: . · ,f
'. '.' .'~) .KEY
. ~~t . PAR;)
""--- - ~ .
. '-....1\.... \....
~0
~
SAND
___ 1.-. ........--
4_ _~
TRANCE RloM tJ.vl../=
EVATlON
1.. EF=T
~ANK.
, -"'\
-~~-
CLEARWATER
COUNTY t FLA.
....
[S] SOFARe.~hl'ATE8 :
A.QhU.o'~'. a 0..',," a ....nnltlp
. . . Malloa ,. _&III\U A A.l.A.
, .
GLEN JOHNSON a ASS,OCIATES
o
" .'
',-
!
1
~^
..J
. .
"
.
j : ~\
'~r
I'
I
"
l';
'~
:\
. ~
: ~
~'~
:,
,7
.
h
"
i
~
'~
,
'i
\
CLEARWATER
BEACH
/
City of :;W;/kYUnO
1\ ~ r~
Hilton
~ EJrl"j~ PalSl
Drawbr/{J."
-1\_........_
-.--... ..... -
--
--
--
CUARWAT€R PA~" Eil
It- WEST 61
-CLEARWA iE.~
- .---'" - --
-- --------
~ ~.
-
CITY OF
PlNElLAS
PrtpQred By:
GLEN JOHNSON a ASSOCIATES
'12800 Belcher Road
Sufte 102 J
L argo. Fla. 34643 Ph. (813) 1524..1177
,
I
CARL A. POSTl
A.I.A. .RCHITECT
Architecture - PI.nner - Interlo
~-'
. . """"
I ...
, ,
. , .
~. .. <
. ," . .
.'
. ..i
~ ~. ..
DATE
, .
..
, ~.
..,
,;;--::". .
. ~i"
-.
f~;"
,I"
,:(J' '
(",..
. ~\..~.
F .JYb5~
AGENDA
l- .l~ 95
ITEM # 'i
c-P1-
Clearwater City Conunission
Agenda Cover Memorandum
ftClnIJ-9-
Meeting Date: ~
g'. J 7 . 9.5
SUBJECT:
Application for Future Land Use Plan Amendment and Zoning Atlas Amendment for 509 Bayview Avenue
and 508 Meadowlark Lane; and Zoning Atlas Amendment for 509 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark
lane, and 3009 Gulf~to~Bay Boulevard; Ownor: R. Roy Meador, Trustee; Representative: Harry S. Cline;
land Use Plan Amendment: 0.70 acres m.o.I., Rezoning: 1.02 acres m.o.1. (Z 93-54 & LUP 93-43)
RECOMM EN DA TION/MOTION:
Approve Application for Future Land Use Plan Amendment to Commercial General and Zoning Atlas
Amendment to Commercial Planned Development for Part of Lots 1 and 2, Block 3, Town of Bay View
a/k/a McMullen Bayview Subdivision, Lot A, Bayview City Subdivision and the vacated street right-of-
way between Lot A and Lots 1 and 2/509 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane, and 3009 Gulf to
Bay Boulevard/South side of Gulf~to-Bay Boulevard between Bayview Avenue and Meadowlark Lane,
and pass Ordinances No, 5741 ~95 and 5742~95 on first reading.
[] and that the approprlote officials be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND:
The subject property is located approximately 1250 feet west of McMullen-Booth Road. The City
Commission on May 4, 1995 referred the proposed Zoning Atlas and Future Land Use Plan Amendments
and accompanying site plan back to the Planning and Zoning Board to consider the most recent changes
in the site plan that have been made. The revised site plan will only change the land use and zoning
on the northern portion of Lots 1 & 2, Town of Bayview, keeping the southern portion of the lots with
a Future Land Use of Residential Urban and zoning of Single~Family Residential Six. The revised site plan
proposes to utilizlJ part of the remaining residential property for a retention pond, Retention ponds (utility
facilities) are a conditional use in the Single~Family Residential Six District,
j~
i
I'
;',
PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD RECOMMENDATION. The requests for rezoning, land use plan
amendment and conditional use were heard by the Planning and Zoning Board on July 18, 1995 with
the rezoning and land use plan amendment endorsed by a vote of 4-3, and the retention pond conditional
use permit approved by a vote of 5~2 (minutes are attached). Previously, on May,3, 1994, the Planning
and Zoning Board held public hearings on the applicant's original request for Commercial General land
use with General Commercial zoning for Lots 1 and 2. The Board recommended against this proposal
by a vote of 4-1. The applicant revised his original request for Zoning Atlas Amendment to a
Commercial Planned Development for the entire site. On February 28, 1995, the Board recommended
against that first CPO plan by a vote of 5-2.
'"
J
:!
Rcvi ewcd by: Originating Dept: Costs: $ N/A C~ission Action:
Legal N/A CENTRAL PERMITTING Total 0 Approved
Budget N/A ;;;5 0 Approved w/conditlons
Purchasing NIA $
Risk Mgmt. N/A Current Fiscal Yr. 0 Denied
CIS N/~_ User Ocpt: 0 Continued to:
ACH Flrding Source:
Other N/A 0 Copt tal I~.
Advertised: 0 Operating AttUCtuacnt8:
>
Dote: 0 Other ORDINANCES NO. 5741-95 &
ftr."\ Poper: TAMPA TRIBUNE 5742-95
, I 0 Not Requi red LOCATION MAP
Sl.J:ai tted by: Affected Parties PZB r-Hnutcs
Cltyfi~ lllI Notified Appropriation Code: 0 None
0 Not Requi rcd
~ Printed on recycled paper
Z 95-54 & LUP 93-43
Pago 2
CURRENT REQUEST. The applicant now proposes to change the land use classification only on the
northern portion of Lots 1 and 2 to Commercial General and combine this property with the existing FINA
site, This site is proposed to have a zoning of Commercial Planned Development. The southprn portion
of the two lots will be combined to form a single residential lot, This new lot will retain its Future Land
Use Classification of Residential Urban and zoning of Single~Family Residential Six. The new lot will
meet the dimensional requirements for this zoning district. The property proposed for CPO zoning is less
than the four acre minimum recommended for such a CPO zoning, but the City Commission can allow
a reduced area if deemed to be in the public interest; the attached Ordinance No. 5742-95 contains this
provision. CPO zoning can provide greater assurance that the proposed development will not adversely
affect the residential character of the neighborhood to the south, and is the zoning classification
recommended by staff if the commercial area is expanded. The applicant's intent remains the same as
in his original application - to use part of the two residential lots to expand the existing FINA gas station
presently on Lot A.
Both Lots 1 and 2 had single family houses on them, The house on Lot 2 (509 Bayview Avenue) was
cited by the City's building department as being unsafe, and the owner was advised to correct
the situation. The owner has demolished this structure rather than repair it. This house was noted as
being "one of three oldest in Bayview and might be the oldest" per an Historical Survey on the area
prepared in 1980, The house on Lot 1 (3015 Gulf-to-Bay) is also mentioned in the report. It was built
prior to 1940. The report indicates no historical significance for this structure,
The Development Review Committee met with the applicant on June 15, 1995t to review the latest site
plan for the property, The DRC noted that their earlier comments had been addressed, and that the site
plan was acceptable if the following changes were made:
1) The location of the dumpster will be shifted to assure adequate overhead clearance; and
2) The following notes need to be added to the site plan:
1 . A site pollution clean-up plan must be approved by the City, commencement of the
approved clean-up plan must occur prior to the issuance of a building permit, and the
clean up program must be continuously pursued in accordance with the schedule and
conditions in the approved plan.
2. All site lighting shall be equipped with 90 degree cut off mechanisms, and all site
lighting must be directed downward and away from adjoining residential properties
and street right-ot-ways prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy,
3. The retention pond, if on residentially zoned property, must have a conditional use
approved by the Planning and Zoning Board.
4. Signage shall conform to the requirements ot the General Commercial zoning district,
with no freestanding sign oriented to Bayview Avenue.
I' The site plan accompanying this report reflects these concerns of the DRC. The ORC was aware of the
neighbor's desire that a block or masonry wall be constructed along the dividing line of the commercial
and residential properties. ORC deferred consideration of the type and height of any wall or fence to the
Planning and Zoning Board. Regardless of material of construction, staff recommends that the
wall/fence be continued up to the unimproved right.of-way of Meadow lark Road on the east, On the
Bayview Avenue side, staff feels that the fence or wall should not be extended to the right~of-way, as
there is likely to be a driveway along the north side of the new residential lot; a fence in this location
could limit the sight distance for vehicular traffic. Options consist of stepping down
the height of the wall and/or terminating the wall approximately ten feat before the right-ot-way.
OTHER REVIEWING BOARD COMMENTS. The Environmental Advisory Board considered this proposal
on February 15, 1995. Concern was expressed about contamination on the site, Statf believes that
the note requested by the ORC adequately addresses the environmental concerns raised by the
Environmontal Advisory Board, residents, and staff during the review of this project,
.
Z 93-64 & LUP 93.43
Pago 3
Due to the historical significance of tho Old Town of Bay\{lew as one of the oldest sottlements In Plnellas
County, and of the previous house at 509 Bayvlew Avenuo, the Hi~torlcal Society and the Coalition of
Clearwater Homeowners Association have both written the City opposing the proposod rezoning. There
is concern about further encroachment into this historical area. There was also concern regarding the
possible destruction of one of the older homes in Bayvlew. This latter Issue is moot now that the house
has been demolished. However, it should be noted that the applicant had offered to donate both houses
for preservation to any entity who had an Interest in saving them. No Individual or organization came
forward to take this offer.
The Historic Preservation Board reviewed this rezoning proposal at its January 17, 1995, meeting, The
board voted unanimously to recommend against the proposed rezoning. However, this current request
Is less intrusive, and the house the board was interested in seeing saved has since been demolished.
FINAL STAFF COMMENTS. There are concerns about this action being regarded as precedential for
other nearby properties. Staff wants to clearly Indicate that it supports this particular change only
because it resolves a difficult site design problem emanating from the existing zoning line and structure
location. Consequently, we are supporting this as a solution to a very site specific problem.
We feel that the proposal represents an excellent compromise between the need of the property owner
to reasonably use his property and the need to protect the residential character of the Bayview
neighborhood. The improvements to the site will: (1) Establish an expedited pollution cleanup program;
(2) Protect much of the existing significant tree canopy beyond the requirements of our Tree Protection
Ordinance; (3) Buffer the adjoining residential property with landscaping, fencing, directional site lighting
dumpster screening and signage location; (4) Establish a stormwater retention facility that exceeds
minimum City code requirements; (5) Significantly improve the safety of the driveways serving the site;
and (6) Improve the potential for more successful business operation at this location.
$a sfid':ari~na'(tre.vla:WJaHtGiiial""'sl~ro f :intHhfolffiiiUortE8dtiiifiiiiJf(the:a"""',.. Hoiti6if\lhajjiriWiii:P.'drmIHfh ""
sit! ff"."GCbmmends:a ~'~~;traVal ''Of;:t'h.i "'fo ". os6H~z6fflh~i"~Aiiij'iaiHa '11ijncf U:se!Gi~WAm'HdmoHi~?iIS':ihe'; 'fa n ,," ea~
'"" '.. . " r", ,',' ,..',....,'..".'...,', """",P"C,(", ,'..,w'. "... ,.. '.. ,P..",.. p, , '...., ..','"..,','" ..<.,9",., ..""'..j{'f. ,'.. ..,..', ,,' '....",'......'. ...'.',..d',......, '.', .....' ....,.,...'.,..,.. ,^" v.. "...., ..'.',.....",.. .", .."1, ,PP..,....;:~
t(),;.'bti::sU' '.. "'oded';6 ")'aU\ofthfijkt8hdards]or,',:a"'."..'fbVaCo r';diiid'iOevel6' "m'ehrCod(:f';sectlons,,~,g6~066 ': ana
~9,~'~? ~:~~ p',;t,,,,,,,,... .,o~,(~,^"Y~.,,*,s: ",,,,L; ".." ,;"'",,,.. ,'.,;:.,...., ,,, , ,:;. ,',<',,; "~',"""" RP.:., x. ,~'w."',""',,"~\,"'w, "". ''''<'' """" ""'''';<'.' ,,;,,; ,P,..;: ,'..,' ,. "<,'" ;;'."':: ,..,~".<';<w~,' ,'.~, "',.',',,.',.....,:, :.: ,.; ,'...... .::,','" ,: ;'..' ,;:'. >,:.
Pertinent information concerning the request Is summarized in the table(s) below and on page 4,
EXISTING ZONING AND FUTURE LAND USE OF
APPLICANT'S AND SURROUNDING PROPERTIES
LOCATION CITY OR FUTURE LAND USE
COUNTY PLAN CATEGORY ZONING ACTUAL USE
Subject City Residential Urban RS-6 Single family residential
Property City Commercial General CG FI NA gas station
North City Commercial General CG Office building, club, and
restaurant
South City Residential Urban RS-6 Single family residential
East City Residential Medium RMH Bayview Trailer Park
West City Residential Urban RS-6 Single family residential
Commercial General CG Food mart/bait shop
ABBREVIA TIONS:
CG
CPO
RMH
General Commercial (City) RS-6 Single~Family Residential "Six" (City)
Commercial Plannod Development (City)
Mobile Home Park (City) u.p.a. Residential units per acre
Z 93~54 & LUP 93-43
Page 4
ZONING RESTRICTIONS
DESCRI PTION RS-6 CG :'r{paq'liQ~$~pxi;p:e:~fi~ EXISTING
REQUIREMENTS REQUIREMENTS );FREaUIAEMENTs~~r (Lots 1 & 2)
.~. . . ~ :~~
Density 5. 5 u .p. a . max . 28 u. p , a . max. :~i~!.;;;~~:r:r~tim::N1.A\~:~iij~;:;:;l:j:;::r:~;~: 3 ,4 u.p.a .
Lot Area 7 ,000 sq , ft. 1 0,000 sq , ft. ~1~fjlif~1~~ 1 3,462 sq , ft.
min. min ,
Lot Width 70 ft. min 1 00 ft. min. ,::t~;~;:t;p:;/:,;1:;~'tt:;::;!j/pr'i'jf::i;[,t:;t;;j: 1 29. 2 ft.
. "'..,.. Jut. e",.." an,..,..,..",
Depth 8 5 ft. min 1 00 ft. min. \~~:;i~:;p:1'j;iJ~Ti~<i:PI:/}~::t;;MS 1 04. 2 ft.
. ,,','....,'.^ ,or", te,::.. an..:."",..:
Floor Area N/A O. 4 max . ~.~If:tt!('~i~~~~..IIIJ!~~fJ~~~'~~;: N/A
Ratio
Bldg. 40 % max. 40% max , ri41It~~lfl Less than 40 %
Coverage
Open Space 11111
Lot 45 % min . 1 5 % min. - Greater than
Front Yard 50% min , 50 % min. 1 5 %
- Greater than
50 %
OTHER REQUIRED REVIEWS
AGENCY YES NO
Pinellas Planning Council/Countywide Planning Authority X*
Florida Department of Community Affairs X
*
The combined area of the portion of the two residential lots having their land use changed to
Commercial General is under an acre. This is a subthreshold PPC amendment.
z9354.cc
ORDINANCE NO. 5741.95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PLAN ELEMENT OF THE
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF THE CITY. TO CHANGE THE LAND USE
DESIGNATION FOR CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED SOUTH OF
GULF TO BAY BOULEVARD BETWEEN BAYVIEW AVENUE AND
MEADOWLARK LANE WEST OF McMULLEN.BOOTH ROAD. CONSISTING
OF PART OF LOTS 1 AND 2, BLOCK 3, TOWN OF BAY VIEW A/K/A
McMULLEN'S BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION. AND THE SOUTH 1/2 OF THE
VACATED STREET ABUTTING THE NORTH SIDE OF THE LOTS,
WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESSES ARE 509 BAYVIEW AVENUE AND
508 MEADOWLARK LANE, FROM RESIDENTIAL URBAN TO
COMMERCIAL GENERAL; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS. the amendment to the future 1 and use plan element 0 f the
comprehensive plan of the City as set forth in this ordinance is found to be
reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is consistent with the City's
Comprehensive Plan; now. therefore,
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The future land use plan element of the Comprehensive Plan of
the City of Clearwater is amended by designating the land use category for the
hereinafter described property as follows:
Prooert'(
Land Use Cateqory
From: Residential Urban
To: Commercial General
Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption,
subject to the approval of the land use designation by the Pinellas County Board
of County Commi ssioners and subject to a determination by the state 1 and pl anning
agency or the Administrative Commission of the State of Florida. as appropriate.
of compliance with the applicable requirements of the Local Government
Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act. pursuant to
~163.3189. Florida Statutes. The Director of Central Permitting is authorized
to transmit to the Pinellas County Planning Council an application to amend the
Countywide Plan in order to achieve consistency with the Future Land Use Plan
Element of the City's Comprehensive Plan as amended by this ordinance.
See Exhibit A attached.
(lUP93-43)
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
Rita Garvey. Mayor.Commlssioner
Attest:
Approved as to form and
legal suffiCiency:
pa1:~~~in. City Attorney
Cynthia E. Goudeau. City Clerk
~~},.:~' "
" '
',~: .
> '
,,'
'. '
!~ "
",
~. .
"
.I.....,
"
1tI_-...
, "
.
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3, Town of Bay View Subdivision a/k/a McMullen's
Bay View Subdivision, except for that portion of said Lots 1 and 2
South of the following described line: Beginning at a point on the
East right-of-way line of Bayview Avenue lying 75 feet Northerly of
the Southwest corner of said Lot 2 and going Easterly to a point on
the West right-of-way line of Meadowlark Lane. said point lying 50
feet Northerly of the Southeast corner of said Lot 1. together with
the Southerly 1/2 of the unnamed vacated right-of-way lying to the
North of and adjacent to said Lots 1 and 2. according to the plat
thereof. as recorded in Plat Book 6, Page 23. public records of
Hillsborough County, Florida, of which Pinellas County was formerly
, a part.
I
! '
I"
j,
I:'
'.
iI'
1
I . ~. .
I
i' .
,
I',
i,
I '
EXHIBIT A
ORDINANCE NO. 5742~95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY REZONING
CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED SOUTH OF GULF TO BAY BOULEVARD
BEnJEEN BAYVIEW AVENUE AND MEADOWlARK LANE WEST OF
McMULLEN-BOOTH ROAD. CONSISTING OF PART OF LOTS 1 AND 2.
BLOCK 3, TOWN OF BAY VIEW A/K/A McMULLEN BAYVIEW
SUBDIVISION, AND LOT A. BAY VIEW CITY SUBDIVISION, AND
THE VACATED RIGHT-OF-WAY LYING BETWEEN LOT A. BAY VIEW
CITY SUBDIVISION, AND LOTS 1 AND 2. TOWN OF BAYVIEW
SUBDIVISION, WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESSES ARE 509 BAYVIEW
AVENUE, 508 MEADOWLARK LANE. AND 3009 GULF TO BAY
BOULEVARD, FROM GENERAL COMMERCIAL AND SINGLE. FAMILY
RESIDENTIAL 6 TO COMMERCIAL PLANNED DEVELOPMENT;
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE,
WHEREAS. the amendment to the zoning atlas 0 f the City as set forth in thi s
ordinance is found to be reasonable. proper and appropriate, and is consistent
with the City's Comprehensive Plan: and
WHEREAS. the City Commission has determined that it ;s in the public
interest that a Commercial Planned Development zoning designation is appropriate
for the subject property even though the property contains a lesser area than
four acres: now, therefore,
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
I
"
I
I
~
,:
I
l
,
1
!
i
t
;
(
~
~
1
,
,
~
j
!
I
j
I
, ;
Section 1. The following described property in Clearwater, Florida. is
hereby rezoned. and the zoning atlas of the City is amended as follows:
Property
Zoninq District
From: (CG) General Commercial and
(RS-6) Single-Family Residential
To: (CPO) Commercial Planned Development
Secti on 2. The Central Permi tti ng Di rector is di rected to revi se the
zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment.
See Exhibit A attached.
(Z93.54)
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
contingent upon and subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5741.95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
Approved as to form
and legal sufficiency:
pakh ~.~kin. City Attorney
Rita Garvey. Mayor-Commissioner
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau. City Clerk
:- \ . .,
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3, Town of Bay View Subdivision a/k/a McMullen's
Bay View Subdivision. except for that portion of, said Lots 1 and 2
South of the following described line: Beginning at a point on the
East right-of-way line of Bayview Avenue lying 75 feet Northerly of
the Southwest corner of said Lot 2 and going Easterly to a point on
the West right-of-way line of Meadowlark Lane, said point lying 50
feet Northerly of the Southeast corner of said Lot 1, together with
the Southerly 1/2 of the unnamed vacated right-of-way lying to the
North of and adjacent to said Lots 1 and 2, according to the plat
thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 6, Page 23, public records of
Hil1sborough County, Florida, of which Pinel1as County was formerly
a part:
TOGETHER WITH:
. I
I
Lot A, Bay View City Subdivision, as recorded in Plat Book 9, Page
43, of the public records of Pinellas County, Florida. and
TOGETHER WITH:
A
The unnamed vacated right-of-way lying, between said Lot...2": Bay View
City Subdivision, and said lots 1 and 2, Town of Bayview
Subdivision.
_.1
I. I J,LI_I_LJ.LLLI
I
_J
14101
...cnu 04C~l1
~. 44-~'"
, ~;~t:::l.:.L;."'~:';:':'~'. '.a;:.:.:..t=.:,
.0
~1JJ!J1~:' ~ ~ ~~ili~.li~iIJi~i ;~l ~!~.~.~~~~4:~.~~. i~~
1i2) 9'~ i~t6 J~ a~ ~~ r";\ ,~
I( -12 II 'o;~;'f 1l;~ 7 ;~;~ ~ It) ~ 23 '27' 21 '20 ' 19' 1/3
8 a. ~ .QD...' .~t1 T '1. I f.~dl,91 A! -It ~-r.' en . K~PCK
~ V ~ ~~ ,:li ~ ~ ~~.; ~ r.., \ 't X jfJ .... ...
- .'/11... ...~ .. fO..., ........,........ ~ ....
CARe UNA AVENUE
dl ;;'. ;:, R~~T~;Mf..JO ::;
1(1 Zr.l If; IZ~~ i:w ,I.xl: I.
a, 12Z 32( ../ 12~ 124 '2'27 1:27 7.ln
,__ u'---";. '- __
. 20 15 2/ 1'27- /' 129 2.\0
~ a:J ,.J2~ '$ 323 / '"- 216
;.. 21 ,,;.., '4 1~~ 129 _ 21q
as 3:!~ ,'!..~L / ~ no ,./"
t;J n 75:r IJ '=~ lJI - j)'
;~ -t:n 3:0 ,7~~ / -
7J 7< 12 I}O lJJ no .../
1)7 I 2.\11
i>irN.~,lf'9 __~'if l:) 3Z9 01 ~~j Cd) 2JJ -'.::... ~
~ ~ .iI ~ ill-13 ~, IH 2<2
I! II [10 'I 11,_ t-.___
N
U1
o
......
-t
""
~
I
..1
1.\/053
Acn[[IJEtlT
5."-1101
~CG~
'1~ 11)
GULF
,b
14/06
.vo
o
...
s. R. 80
~ l-~ ~ ~
,~. ,,' ....~ \()~
/.. 1"/ ",0''' ./.:.'? ~
.it v....., "''/' .'\.~ ,or,
/., I"} 1:," .....::".;;:;:
,~ V<:>".;/, .....~ ,~
~ >..:; / ./.. --- ~
~ :.:}(~ ~ ~
y V /_ X \''1.
~:-/ y;( ....-.;.. ~
~:"" / X'''' /<:>;;.:--
../ /., ....'/ \'"
/ '/ ," /...
,:-.. -(.,:&: -v-....
,. "\.
....
~
J
'J01-17~'
.....-----
~
,J,J ..,
I
:;: -If7 8:;; :;::.., l>- '" I;j
r. g ~ g g ~ ~ g g
~\ 2 J 456
:~ 9 -43 =--.
\ ~ R
~ /~~12 11109 87
." If~l ~... ttl
tl> / ~\4' 0 <:) -
,~" -JO~ :::l ~ :=l
rJ1.> p..1.( !12,c..V.D ft:lrJQ' 10 "" ,,~- ,'r.>
un
..
TRA VEL <-
TRAILER C
23/02
PARK
Q
~
..,
1.{/07
1 2 ,j ,i 5
SJB
V~ t
~ ~ '" ~ ~ 7 6 ,~
(,0 2~ '" '''.;; jM( :!o;;
J>.1...., ..... .. :f7~;~' ..
rvdl/ S. R. \60 ~ g GULF
- . '-:-;-;ij.i~ - ,. v' \- GUlf
Q~, 'JJ.~"~;II:~.l \~ ,VI >. -'"b,\
....~~ . .1'..',;);."'..... ... BfJM LlL". \' 1\.0,
;../" r.' .." /1" '11Ilt90!-;.: "2.~'" 1\ f..l......., \?i
^ rd. ~I I..! .~i/!t!ll,ol!/.~'Z~:~. ~ ~.-" l,..' ~ ~, ~
~'/i:'::~/~"l")f:':~()WN 1. ~. I':"fI I~ \.;
5\0 'Y!l~.!f..91l,;"I' I oJ "-ALI'''' 1,.\ '1 \ 10,10,
~ 2 J ~ ^'..- q \'Ojis ~~ ) ~a.':>
...-- OOF ? ~1;.S\ 1.~ )..--~) p~ R
~ __---- 611 3 4 ;: ,. m\\1.~ ); ~7J [\
~ ~() BAY 'b 6?i...l.\~ -\\':... ).. \1.'1'
. -8 c-' ~ 7"""~" '~ll"::"" A"'~ ' - "'W 1.~ "Q 1. ""
I ~., ., r - ".,' J.' ~~~~~", 1,'.,..'.x: ,.,.', ,'... ~ a "" ",J'
"1f:'~ ". "/' . ","' ~.- ..eo '" . " 0 ~ \ ., ... \ ' .
'I .... ,., ,._, -- J ~,' 'il' .1"..,. .0 I '''It'' , . "r~ J.. I,-()~
_..:..;.Jo~t~.::.;' J, ~';.r,-...... ~ ,.,,',!- ;",' .,!.~..'" ,I' 't.,' '-~2.r' :.. 1 ~ ~;:,..J ~ r
0;;' .", ..l'.,';.~i:n,;.~~'" /".~':J.. J:,., .5, ';1 ,to \ - ~.t''::\''l' ,r'l
.-~" W" ~ .... ....r,.....;.I.c. . ".of\r'? .. .~ t,...t
(\o"~H r: J..U t.n:". tl~~."j .;: ~,J,..t..;. \ .a..r,:.tt. .,,-t-f' ~ 'Iol~;
':l ~~ ;~. ..,!.,.,..~...'. ~.~. ';.):~~'.: ,..\>?~F~:....O:~ .:,..'.~f,~....t
,..n ' f. '.1 6 ';.' ..;v.,.... J, .....'~'1!.::"'e' .~':. ,':':,'./'
~I- r. _ I,:l . ;'~,,: .~. '~i.:, :"(i:..::~~".~rt',:ri~~ .-:rt._ V;;{~':>'L~
'~'{.''''' 1 4..() ',.,',~'t\~~ .-. H~rll:...,1 ~ ~\
... ,....., ~ 0 u v . ....~..., " ut~.,tJ" ~"j "..t ~'1.'1 iJ
7\ ,:..';:t.'4:~. ~ l\,j '3. .<t.:,,-.' , )"~'~[1'~:\~'~'~"NI~'\!;;"!
...-:.J .::.-{: . e;.J~~~l' ~ C1 4~' I~~ ~-:\I.i~1~\I., ~~'I '.fl.. i-'~ I'
..,d,.,.: .,::' l~i""i'("'" R \\J;,;.4 r:!j; III!'; ~iY..t:r.>~\: ~'T;.'l' ....t: '.'. ;/
'... ......:....6 ~I'" "11 \I~t..~..'i,;.., '"
. ;'.. ~:,Jr2'.I.'O.I.....:r:....ijo . ~ \'!~-' "~ i,:C..,..~~.'.. :t:-
.'~.', ..:. . '; L'~,... . .., - ;;Ip.a; )'I.~ ~~f. ',.~^.~.J... l'f'I.,.f'~
,,' ',.., .....'/-., ,., ~L: . . '~""'."'..: ~~r.
, ': ';' : ';',!~:;:.)Y 'f, ... \ '1 ,:~...'~m.... ("~")Yi:-;1!'';:~Ii:,'~
. "," '.' /' ~. \ ..,' ~"', ; .'":(' ;~'dk~:~R
",;;..../' 101 2 '?' , :. ~1\~?1.:,x' ;,':';):Z~.l
I .."" t6'. .... ~. ~~'. ..."...... ,"
,,;' ;g...' ~. :" .; t.
107 It. ~ ;. ~h~~..:. i
../ 0 Q~' ,,~'i ,~'" \. ,.~'~,~
100 J 'A ../../ ~,\~,,'1... ': ;'S ';. " ':'~~-i
i.? .;/1.,...\..V.
~ ~ 'b I ~j:':;' .~;~.t
t.
.
Q
.,
TO
101 ib 2
10J ~u
10~ ~\
101 200
109 2tO
I II 212
--
II:! 214
117 210
119 211!
, 20 220
121 211
m\:
JIG 2J2
lJJ 182J.
--
IJ5 2}r,
32/p I
PROPOSED REZONING
\'Ze-v L SEQ Ot..{ 11..\ q S-
Q I~
z q 3~ 54
OWH~R
APPLICANT ME AO 6"Z. 1 R
I
ZON1NG
FROM' CG ~ Q S - 6
TO C. () 0
-
P L ~ H t~ I tl r. /I n.1 Z 0 H I Nan 0 A R 0
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
. PAR. T L oi'S l ~ ~ , e l. ~ "3
M c fYl V I..c6 tJ B A, Y V ( E vJ .; lJ e,
t. Of AI
6A"vIEW c...lTY
A fJ 0 VAC.A'TI:l) CS-r-R- EEl
~€TvJEc[\J 0.73 ACnEg
'C.
CITY t:OloAM13510N
'r 0 w H 5 HI P 1.g
-1.
n ..dl 0 F. \ 6 E
5r~CTI()N \10
--------
s
ATLAg PAGE
30\ A.
-
,~
I
I
';!r ..
I
J
-:r--
AI--
,,'/ I",
, --,~...
\;;0 t l"I,=-li
,
@l~
13
I
I
I
I
..1 ,. 1'~:l'lIr'l
... I'r' ~ I. \1,,"t>;I
~ I :-:I
\., \ 4 I
: ,c-----l
,.~
'"'
l~
..
,.
.:
,.,
I>
C) r-[ "':I
I ~ r:
--
· pa ~~;>ll:t
.UAV
I
I
I
I
r.., n='J llll
,'/
I 0
I
I
I
I ~
\
..
'...-
!
I
-, i
I
.., I
:-
~, !
Dl
; I
.. j
m
.
..
...
.
...
~,
~
.,
.
..
'ii 't'
r,:
'0
f;j ."
...
.... ;'I
I. \.
:. 1:1 " .
.. Uc-.. ..,
..... n:
u
G
" , . ~ 'II .
()
!Po
:SJ
\
.I
\
~
,
0 '.
\
<:>
."
,n
c:::=>
..~
,
It,
Cl
-... ..
",
...
...
:.! [i
t.
~.-~~
..
..
.,
..'
o
Q
t'
" 0.
o
. "^\' Pllqlj1l111
\
\
I
I ..
IVI
I :II
. I t.
I l:lo
.
. .
I
I-
I
a I
~ .,."
#
..4- ~~.:~~
I
I
I
./
1,
L. q 3 - 5'LI
L <1 '3 - l{ 3
.
Paul Hall, representing the child care center Board o{ Directors, outlined the changes to the
proposal. He staled the play area will be fenced with chain link, tlw drive widened and perin1ctN
landscaping provided. He agreed with staff recommendations.
Vangie Mosich, President of the Board of Directors and Pastor David Charles Smith spoke in
support of the application.
The applicants were commended for coming back with such an excellent pIt'll').
Member BickerstaHc moved to approve Item B1 subject to the (ollowing conditions: 1) The
requisite building and parking lot permits shall be obtained prior to installation of the modular
building and no later than six months after the date of this public hearing; and 2) the perimeter
landscaping requirements of Sec. 42.27 shall be provided prior lO the issuance of a certificate of
occupancy/use. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
B2. (cont. from 5/04195) 509 Bayvicw Ave and 508 Mcadow lark lane, McMullen
Bayview Sub, Tract A, Blk 3, Lots 1 & 2 and south 1/2 of right-of-way to the north (R. Roy
Meador) Z 93-54; lUP 93-43
1
I
,
t
t
!
I
~
!
i
~
1
i
~
~
!
>,
I
~
I
i
f
f
i
I
Ms, Glatthorn gave the background of the case regarding previous hearings, site plan changes and
conditions. She enumerated the Development Review Committee's (DRC) recommended sill"
plan changes and presented, in writing, staff recommendations.
Member Mazur expressed concern with having alcoholic beverages available where gasoline is
sold. It was indicated the beer and wine sales portion of thi~ application is a part of the site plan,
because it is a planned development, not a separate condftional use. For clarification, it was
indicated a conditional use for the retention pond was requested as a separate item due to the
pond extending into the residential lot to the south.
Harry Cline, attorney representing the applicant, displayed a map of the site. He described how
each of the previously expressed concerns has been addressed. He displayed a second map o{
the site as it would appear under a Commercial Planned Development (CPO) zoning.. He stated
they worked extensively with the City forester regarding the location of the retention pond, and
19 of the 20 trees on the site will be saved. landscape buffering is to exceed the requirements.
Mr. Cline said the estimate for building the requested eight foot masonry wall along the southerly
boundary was over $14,000 and was not feasible. He staled a six foot wooden fence will be built
instead. Other concerns addressed were reconfiguration of the gas pump islands, narrowing the
driveway and relocating a dumpster.
Discussion ensued regarding location of the retention pond. In response tD a question regarding
the exact placement of the pond, it was indicated the legal description is on the site plan.
Two citizens spoke in support of the application as follows:
William S. Connally, owner of the adjacent property to the east, felt the applicant has done
everything asked of him and should be allowed 10 improve his properly,
mpz07a.95
Page 2 of B
07/10/95
Robert Roy Meador, Jr., the owner/applicant, stated the subject properly hils been in his family
for 50 years. He said no one accepted his offer to donate the house on the southerly lot and he
had it demolished. He wishes to be able to improve the property and reviewed his efforts 10
satisfy neighbors' concerns.
Eleven citizens spoke in opposition to the application as follows:
Breck Parker, areil resident, expressed environmental and historical concerns. He stated a $7,000
estimate for a masonry wall was faxed to the applicant. He gave a brief history of the houses and
property owners in the vicinity Jnd Commission action regarding the site.
Sherry Collins, area resident, expressed concern with neighborhood safety for her daughter. She
stated she has worked with her neighbors 10 reduce the number of transients llnd drug and alcohol
related problems in the area.
I
I
i
I
~
I
~
.
t
~
t
~
i
~
~
~
~
'I
~
1-
:,
l'
~
t
"
~
i
~
i
I
I
I
Charles Martin, 20 year area resident, distributed copies of a historic resources survey prepared
by Howard Hansen. Mr. Martin indicated the neighborhood has declined.
Jack Alvord, area resident, spoke regarding property ownership ilnd responsibility of government
to observe its own laws. He listed other applications granted against the wishes of. Bayview
residents. He complained his water well was cut off when the old McMullen house was
demolished.
Terry Dopking read a letter from Brian P. Mullen, who could not attend. Mr. MlJllen requested
these hearings be held at night. He felt a bigger gas station was not needed, would 'not create jobs
and would encourage more transients. Ms. Dopking expressed concerns regarding rezoning,
alcohol sales and the safety of her children.
Mary Alvord referred to a chronology of the gas station she said was contained in the case file.
She opposed the rezoning, naming numerous groups which havp. spoken and petitioned in
opposition. She cited specific standards for approval she felt were being violated.
Barbara Sartor, Dunedin resident, stated her mother ;s an adjacent property owner to the south.
She indicated there are strong memories of the area and they did not want to see it degenerate,
Mary B. McMullenl adjacent property owner, opposed the rezoning because of the proximity to
her back yard. She wished for a better plan that would enable her to better enjoy her h,ome.
Dennis. Grinstead, adjacent business owner, opposed the Land Use Plan amendment, indicating
the proposal was not appropriate for the property. He expressed concern the proposal would put
his small grocery store out of business.
In response to questions, Mr, Grinstead stated he carries a full line of groceries and convenience
items. He said his prices are competitive with those in convenience stores llnd all of his business
comes from the neighborhood.
rnp/.07i1,95
Pilge 3 or B
07/10/95
Early McMullen Sorenson, area resident. stated he hopes to live here all his life. Reading from
the Code, he expressed concerns the rezoning is not compatible with the area. He diclnot feel
the IJroximity of the two residential lots to Gulf to Bay Boulevard poses a hardship for the
applicant. He cited examples of how other similarly situated residential properties hllve dealt with
the matter. Mr. Sorenson described conditions existing on the surrounding properties and how
the proposal affects them.
Allan Stowell, Clearwater resident, expressed concern the application violiltes the City1s
Comprehensive land Use Plan. Reading from the Code, he stated the standards for npproval arc
not being met. He read from a letter written by Attorney John Hubbard concerning violation of
the zoning standards. Mr. Stowell displayed a map highlighting the proposed rezoning, stating
it is not in the publk interest and is incompatible with surrounding uses.
In response to queslions Mr. Cline pointed out the land into which the pond extends belongs to
the applicant. He expressed the view that zoning is intended to be transitional and should change
slightly as goals change over time. Concerning the historical nature of the neighborhood, Mr.
Cline pOinted out the Fina station has been there for 50 years and the owners are entitled to some
ability to maintain it. He stated the remaining residential lot to the south, though irregularly
shaped, has single family zoning and meets code. In response to a question, Mr. Cline stated this
project is site specific and any other construction would be subject to Board approval.
I
l
I
I
,
i
i
!
I
l
I
i
'c
Mr. Hubbard's leller was submitted for the record at the request of the Board.
In closing, Mr. Cline responded to the concerns of the opposition, reiterating how each is to be
addressed. He displayed a map of the Gulf to Bay Boulevard corridor, demonstrating the
application is in line with zoning in the area. Cbncerning placement of the proposal in a more
northerly location, Mr. Cline indicated setbacks cannot be met and again recounted Mr.
Mayberry's extensive review of the site.
ij
~
}
Concern was expressed this seems to be a massive project for the small number of pumps
involved. Clarification was requested.
Jim Smith, President of the Co-op Oil Company, responded to questions. He stated Rich Baier,
the City Engineer. advocated the proposed configuration to avoid traffic stacking up into the right~
of-way. He said there will be three pumping units with three hoses on each side. for a total of 18
hoses. The diesel pump was eliminated due to environmental concerns associated with use of
the fuel. He estimated 15 percent of his revenue comes from alcoholic beverage sales. While
he agreed drinking while driving is a problem. he felt the ability to sell alcohol was necessary for
the business to remain viable.
Board members in support of the request felt the applicant could not have done more to mitigate
any impact to the surrounding properties. The plan to improve, not expand the existing business
was felt to be common sense. Vvhile it was agreed a gas station is not the best use in a residential
area, it was indicated that use exists in many places and should not be required to move out to
accommodate the neighbors. Jt was noted the applicant has done everything asked of him to
protect the neighborhood <lnd the environment. No reason was found for the project not to
proceed.
mpz07a.95
P.lflC .1 of U
o7/lB/95
While not rejecting the proposal as a whole. members not in support of the request expressed
their reservations. Opposition to selling one or two cans of beer to drivers was voiced. It was felt
the projcct does not align with the Comprehensive land Use Plan. Concerns were expressed the
application does not support the standards for approval. The impact of a commercial property
encroaching into a residential area was protested.. Concern was cxpressed with splitting the lots.
It \Vas felt approving the application would compromise the Board's commitment to serve the
publ ic i1f1d set an unwanted preccdent.
Member Carass<ls moved, concerning Item B2, to endorse the Future land Use Plan amendment
to Commercial General and Zoning Atlns amendment to Commercial Planned Development as
requested. The motion was duly seconded and. upon the vote being taken. Members Keyes,
,Nixon. Carassas, and Baron voted "Aye"; Members Merriam, Mazur, and Bickerstaffe voted "Nay.1I
Motion carried.
83. (cont. from 6/27/95) R. Roy Meador, Trustee of the R. Roy Meador Revocable living
Trust to permit utility facilities; detention pond at 509 Bayview Ave & 508 Meadowlark
lane, Town of Bayview Sub a/k/a MCMullen's Bay View Sub, Blk 3. part of Lots 1 & 2,
zoned RS 6 (Single Family Residential). CU 95-45
Member Carassas moved, concerning Item B3, to approve it conditional use for a retent,ion pond
(utility facility) on Lots 1 and 2, Town of Bayview, subject to the adoption of thc requested Future
land Use Plan Amendment to Commercial General and Zoning Alias Amendment to Commercial
planned Development. The motion was duly seconded and, upon the vote being taken, Members
Keyes, Mazur. Nixon, Carassas. and Baron votcd "Aye"; Members Merriam and Bickerstaffe voted
"Nay.1I Motion carried.'
B4. (cont. from 6/27/95) 1221 & 1256 Bay Ave, 317, 323'& 325 Pinel/as 5t, and 1225
Reynolds Ave, Westover Sub, Blk B. lots 1-2 & 17, C. Perry Snell's Bluff View Courl,
lots 22-24, and S.J. Reynolds Sub, lot 8 (Morton plant Hospital AS5ociation and
Evmorphia M. Kralis) Z 95-02; lUP 95-13
LUP: From Residential/Office General to Institutional
ZONE: From Ol (Limited Office) to MPD (Master Planned Development)
Member Mazur declared a conflict of interest with regard to this case.
In a lettcr dated July 17, 1995. Emil Marquardt, requested a 3D-day continuance to allow time to
clarify certain aspects of the Morton Plant Master Plan.
Member Keyes moved to continue hem 84 to the meeting of August 15, 1995. The motion was
duly seconded and upon the vote being taken, Members Merriam, Keyes, Nixon. Carassas, Baron
and Bickerstaffe voted "Aye"~ Member Mazur abstained. Motion carried.
C. Conditional Use Applications
Cl. luVcrne M. loken, TRE to permit congregate care at 2780 Drew 51. See 08-29-16/
portion of M&B 34.041 zoncd RM 16 (Residential Multiple Fllmily). CU 95-4(.
mpl07a.95
P.lge!> of U
07/111/95
AUG 1 G 1995
c21f I Sf /fj'i ;-
1'.+,. ,
<'. \ '
/l1at;!.~ !(U.., :kP.1.~..{
/),J ,(
C:!:tt.{ C~2-7?7l,/l~('-::6
-fJP.: ~<"2 R1.--yrv-~.
cyop,b~.a.LLrr' lfrt 1?cu.j1-~
P"'-o/l"/I~' .
~ ~ .? 0 .
I~ /rJ;t..,Jr f~ (..u:;'i ~'~~., ..{7l.(/:'{K.(f'"AVJ )
.. I
J 2~ ".....~ tv rJJ.J t, r~o'1'"\ r;/ ;fAlj../..-(. C.lr./j/1-r:tj'
/,,-t-v{,~ A~~ t~~ J ?..va..,~ L, fa ~- /'..t.PAYl~~ /' rAJ:j.~/ t:Ld
.c0417 OPl'c0~ C/~ /U -) o-~ rJ~~..:t ~ i(o--l if ~
~ 1il e P j) 3 ~ c;:b./l~~ 5~ '3 UV F~4 ~~
a..-f e~ (j~ O~A'~ Cbv'.L{- fo.8c<-<j 8~~.
I . .
{h, fA. j.;'" {,.--:A-;)..V> 7 t~ lM. lw p~ J,.Pvt>. /...u..... TIv /~..-u
h ~-d ~ /3~ w~ . 04 ~-1 p~.2u~ / 1:/\/ /0. 2 pza-~ 1
~ IJ cro-t.1.- /C/-~ (jN'~ r:Uf~ IN r~.fl, /,-v>~.
a tk-, ~ ~ c;(.&., -h..-U'/. ::zv .g~ ~ k-" ~J
7J ..' . t
~. ~J't~ (~~ c~~d' Jx- 0 vr..deZQn~~)
cd tl~ ~.2 (:V/~ {J...<M {).A2 ~;to f~ v2-->-bzO'~
. r1 . I' - {/ \
/Urrr.o/~ ~ ~ D.. ~L---~ ~p.~. !~~>>b!! ti
0'-:9 fJ~f,. W-./i/!k:2A~ ~ j?t-h"v~ {~~ i.1A.. M~.h-.
~ () tI ,cI I
()..-., .eltf,n.;t --cevJ w..d {lv-, ~. . :
.-JI i'--" i?"1 {o..UU! u.~ (.< 1~.",.-r..v.A/~.J (Lv.-A~-r.' v" '
(;f....J-.> (V..R~'>:. (p.J./ IdfJ. ,.Clw2r ,0.,../"Ci/.;!- tlv J~-,1:,. ;' {Iv WI.(
, i
COPIES TO: Q. e... ::: '8'
COMMISSION
PRESS
CLE.RK / ATTORNEY
i
-
........~....... ,.. .;... .
i '
:.
"
\ '
. '''.
~
()v'~ th /'.~ (L.r:~ w).~ IY..l b/;~ 1/..-.' ~~ ~""- I
lJv.~ ~Js oh ti.-1t{i....~~ ~ dw-u",. Co-n>--rA.iM'..<...J "'.p _ j
') C~ . i<~ . cJ.f-lh, .t.:/",. o!~:t ..&, /''-'Jrr:ML'1 g .1
cfLo-.d:, 'Z .! ~ al~7 (] Cl7-"~ t;:, {l"" GJ a-..t
C/jtV>.::t -.-to ~-'v~ .JZ;I~ tf.JIu, ~u:2Z'7 tl... U/l.lR... .
J 1--wJ ~ {.~ .J?~ -t/v ./2~;t- rX~k:>~,,, IJ
. {,f,y Ov'''''I,u<>>t' ('7 ;-~.:t'J- a~ ~7 &... /r.t~<:,.r .
, ~
r'!f,~ 7I~ ~~ tpUA ~~~ l~''''/I'-U
/I'lt;~ -
I
,
!
I
(f;A~~ I
11/1 ()roNr;.eV,'.ef/J A~
. 34d/S I
.
<;~.; ,
-
,,<
, ,I
R~::3
COPIEs TO'
COMMISSION
.' Re: MEADOR/BAVVJEW REZONING/LAND USE CHANGE
Date: hand-delivered August 16, 199~
AUG 1 7 1995
APPLICATION
PRESS
CLERK I ATTORNEY
to: Mayor and City Commissioners:
We are enclosing a copy oi City Ordinance 40.675, which
eleven requirements for any Zoning Change. 40.675 says
City of Clearwater is not legally allowed to change
unless the application meets all eleven requirements.
list the
that the
the Zoning
Please carefully review these eleven criteria before the hearing
of August 17. It is our 1irm belief that the facts will show
that few or probably none 01 these eleven requirements are met by
the MEADOR/BAYVIEW APPLICATION.
Bayview Residents'
81r7 --!
~.~
cJ,-
Jr-,
. .
. .
-
.~" .
Sec. 40.675 The following standards shall serve as the
to evaluate any requested amendment to the zoning atlan~,
amendment shall approved unless it complies with all
enumerated standards.
basis
and no
of the
1. The available uses to which the property
appropriate to the property in que~tion and
existing and planned uses in the area_
may be put are
compatible with
2. The numerical and dimensional development requirement$
contained in chapter 40 which govern the development of the
property will sufficiently safeguard the integrity and character
of the area.
7. The amendment will not adversely burden public facilities,
including traffic-carrying capacities of streets, in an
unreasonable or disproportionate manner.
I
I
I
I
1
r
~
f
~
I
i
I
i
3. The amendment will not constitute a grant of special
privileges to the owner.
4. The amendment will not conflict with the needs of the
neighborhood or the city.
5. The amendment will not adversely or unreasonably affect the
use of other property in the area.
6. The amendment will not defer the improvement or development
of other property in accord with existing zoning and development
regulations.
8. The district boundaries are appropriatelY"drawn with due
regard to locations and classifications of streets, ownership
lines, existing improvements and the natural environment.
9. The amendment will result in enhancing the health,
and welfare of the citizens of the city.
safety,
10. The amendment will, further the expressed purposes of the
land development code.
11. The amendment will be consistent with the comprehensive
plan.
')\
/~'~
I
i~~ ~~, .
I~
MEMORANDUM
TO: The Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission
FROM:
RE:
DA TE:
Pamela K. Akin, City Attorney
\
Rezoning Hearings - Quasi-Judicial Procedures
AUgU6~995
Based on the discussion at the work session of August 14, 1995 the procedure outlined
below will be followed by the Commission for the upcoming Rezoning hearing. I will
prepare a resolution at a later date.
1. Staff states its recommendation and summarizes its reasons for the
recommendation.
2. Applicant presents case including its testimony and exhibits.(20 min.)
3. Witnesses may be questioned. Questioning may be done by the
commission, by staff, or by interested parties. Applicant may also question
staff as to the basis of the recommendation. (each question not to exceed
1 min. answer not to exceed 3 min.) .
4. Proponents of the application may speak (3 min. per speaker).
5. Interested party representatives 'may present case including testimony,
exhibits and witnesses. Interested parties in opposition will have equal
time to the applicant. Time will be divided amongst all interested parties
in opposition.(20 min.)
6.
Public commant in opposition.(3 min. per speaker)
Applicant may call witnesses in rebuttal.(5 min. per witness)
i I
7.
8.
Rebuttal witnesses may be questioned.(each ques~ion not to exceed 1 min.
answer not to exceed 3 min.)
, '
: i
. I
9. Conclusion by opposition.(5 min)
10. Conclusion by opposition.(5 min)
11. Discussion and Decision by Commission.
';~~; , ":'
.,', I
.,
.f;. ".
~.t'.:.-""~h~. . ~ '
I
I
. . -..
"
,,'
Commission may ask questions during any portion of the presentation and of any
witness or speaker. It is my recommendation that for the purposes of this procedure.
.an interested party be considered anyone who is required to be directly noticed of th~
'pending action.
PKA:ln
'.
, ,
\
I,
I
,...~,...~...-..-. .
.~
.....
~.ll
~
~
"
,;
')
l---bAA LL-~' r2f-ULi!.
P O. G~ I fLJ&;c;
~~ ~lVL J FL 3sfG, I 7
16/?Q/16/0000Q/320!OlOO
ALVORD, JACK N.
ALVORD, MARY J.
606 8AYVIEW AVE
CLEARWATER, FL
,
34619
16/29/16/052~='008/0030
WILDER CORP DELAWARE
6TH FLOOF
3000 GULF TO BAY 8LVD
CLEARWATER, FL
)
34619
16/29/16/05292/008/0080
NGUYEN, THANH PHUOC
NGUYEN, KIMTRUC THI
2223 HARN BLVD
CLEARWATER, FL
.'
34624
16/29/!6/47a2~:C02/CC30
SCHMITCHEN, FRIEDRICH W.
SCHMITCHEN, JUNE
520 8AYVIEW AVE
CLEARWATER, FL
-l
34619
16/29/16/53892/005/0030
CONNOLLY, LAURA N. TRE
317 N HILLCREST DR
CLEARWATER, FL
""'
34615
~
'.
K-e - g'
z Cf3 -Stf CC ~. f7-9s
'f-UP q3- y 3 \
I I (0 I rei -e- F j
16/29/16/05292/007/0020
SOUTH MAIN ENTRP X lTD
SUITE 204
2420 ENTERPRISE RD
CLEARWATER, FL
34623
16/29/16/05292/008/0070
NORTHLAND PLAZA
5120 W POE AVE
TAMPA, FL
33629
16/29/16/05292/008/0180
MEADOR, R. ROY TRE
3843 PICCIOLA RO
FRUITLAND PARK, FL
~
/
34731
!6/'29~'!6J'538~=/DC3IJO~'7()
I
I
t
Me MULLEN, MARY 8.
517 8AYV!EW AVE
CLEARWATER, FL
34619
16/29/16/53892/006/0010
MULLIN, SRIAN P.
603 BAYVIEW AVE
CLEARWATER, FL
34619
'I
I
. . '! I
.......T.
.c I T Y 0 F C lEA R W ATE R
IntllfdllJ!nttmllnt CortllJporidllnce
. f\-e,;. <6
TO:
FROM:
Betty Deptuln, City Manager
Scott Shuford, Central Permitting Directo~ ~
SUBJECT:
Bayview Neighborhood - Update
COPIES:
Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager
Bill Baker, Assistant City Manager
Lou Hilton, Senior Planner
t(Q)f1
DATE:
March 23. 1995
Given Commission interest in the Bayview neighborhood. ] am providing Ule first of an anticipated series of
updates with regard to staff activities in this area.
First, the proposed expansion of the FINA station at the corner of Gulf to Bay and Bayview will be coming to
the City Commission on April 20. 1995.
Second, as you know, one of my departmental ~goals for this year is to prepare a neighborhood zoning study.
] plan on using the Bayview area as the subject of that zoning study. As we have discussed, the Bayview area
is "ripe" for such a study since there are a number of potential development issues coming up in the near future
that may affect this neighborhood. The FJNA station is one of these issues. but the likely conversion of the
mobile home park adjoining the neighborhood on the east to anoUler land use may have more significant
potential effect'>. There are other properties in the immediate vicinity of the neighborhood that have
development potential which could also hnve some effect on this neighborhood. Consequently, we will take a
comprehensive look at this area as part of our regularly scheduled planning efforts.
Please call if YOll have questions or comments.
I
I
~
i
t
f
(
,
r
I
Finally, lhe Historic Preservation Board hilS requested City participation in a project to allow state certification
of the Bayview area as an historic neighborhood. We anticipate being able to assist in lhis effort through the
hiring of a lemporary employee using existing funds in my department. We will keep you advised of this effort.
SS/db
J/lyYJp,w',lt$
...._",,-_1-
E:-.-::~ ':j
1:-4E
- ~
((... '8')1/)1J
fb FIr
RA.~DALL C. KRA..~JEC, AICP
"LANNING MANAGER
.'€Dt:CATIO!':
tvlliP. Master of Urban Planningt Cniversity ofWisconsin-MHwaukee, School
of Architecture: and Urban Planning, 1982
BA. Marquette University, College of Arts and Science, 1976
PROFESSIONAL REGISTRA TIO~.
American Institute of Certified Planners, 1987
PROFESSIONAL AFFILL<\TIO~S OR ACTIVITIES:
American Planning Association
Florida Chapter
RECENT EMPLOYMEST mSTORY:
1995 . Present
1990 - 1995
1987 - 1:J90
Tampa Ba)' Engineering, Inc.
HiI\sborough County Planning Commission/IvIPO
Post, Buckley, Schuh & Jernigan, Inc.
TOTAL YEARS EXPERIENCE: 12
KEY PROJECT EXPERIE:"lCE:
. Project Manager for Tampa Port Authority Surface Transportation Plan. Served as tcc1mical
project manng~r for the Hiltsborough MPO on behalf of the Tampa Pore Authority.
. Project Manager for the University Center Research and Development Park, a Developmcflt
of Regional Impact in Tampa, Florida for VRS Realty Services.
. Project Manager for nle Pavilion, a Development of Regional Impact in Tampa, Florida for
Fol~on Tr.ve~tment) Inc.
. Project Manager for 1-75 Corridor Study) a planning and market analysis of the 1-75 corridor
in Hillsborough County) Florida for TECO Properties, Inc.
. Projcct Manap;er for Hillsborough County MetropoUtan Planning Organization Congestion
,Management Systems Plannlng.
. Project Ma~agerfor Hillsborough County Metropolitap Planning OrganJution Pedestrian PJan.
. Planning Commission Liaison. HilJsborough County Livable ~oadw~y PlQ~..
" ..-....:.. '.- ,. rll;~P=::::",~~~:':::;~' :..', .' .
. Project Manager for City of New Port Richey Evaluation and Appraisal-aepO'rt for City's
Comprehensive Plan, '
TAMPA BAY ENGINI:SERING. INC.
0M1 EngInHrlng · ~n$pon't1on · Envtronm~ntlJ1. P~nQ
16167 U.S. 19 North, Suite 550 creaIWater. Florida 34624 a13-531-3505 FAX 6131539.1294
..
,.
Cu r/'?!9)
#?@
-
0:....... -,,_"'--.
. ~ -;r" -. .
.~ ."- p "-=:&';':'~ -::
~~ ~iv~
\~.,., -~
~"'" ~.....~ ~ =~:::. ~ '..
.', ~~..... "..
C I T Y
OF
CLEARWATER
POST OFFIce BOX 4748
C'LEARv.'ATER, FLORIDA 34618-4748
DEPARTMENT OF CEl"4'TRAL PERMITTING
Telephone (813) 462-6567
August 9. 1995
Allan J. Stowell
2973 Thornton Road
Clearwater, FL 34619
Dear Mr. Stowell:
In response to your hand delivered letter of August 8. 1995. I am providing the following infonnation.
You have requested a copy of the Historical Structure Form Florida Site File for the structures reviewed
by Mr. Howard Hansen as part of his contract with the Central Permitting Department to perform an
Historic Resources Survey of the Bayview neighborhood. These forms consist, for each project, of a
multi-page inventory providing information such as location and identification of the structure. site
description, historical information. surveyor's evaluation, photographs of the site and other similar
information including maps. This information is available for the following structures in the Bayview
neighborhood:
~ Bethel Presbyterian Church
.. Meador House
... McMullen House
~ Early McMullen House
~ 520 Bayview Avenue
.. Hampton - Harphan House
... Alvord House
~ 725 Bayview Avenue
.. 3015 Gulf-To-Bay Boulevard
In your letter. you questioned why staff omitted this information from the bound copies of Mr. Hansen's
report. We did not include this information because it consists of highly technical appendix type
information of limited interest to the casual reade'r of the summary report. We also did not include this
information in the bound report due to the length and technical n'trure of the material. Each of the
structures listed above has approximately six pages worth of material in the file form and includes black
and white photographs of each structure.
Per your request. I have had all this material copied for you. There are additional copying fees due to
the fact that the material had to be carefully disassembled by a City staff member and the photographs
had to be carefully copied to allow them to be legible. Consequently, there was an additional handling
charge to cover City staff time spent in copying the files. We were able to doublc4side copy much of
the material thereby providing you with some cost savings.
In response to your other request. due to the length of the material to be copied and its relatively limited
usefulness in evaluating the pending zoning proposal for the FIN A Station. I do not Intend to provide
@
- Equal Employmont and Afflrmatlvo Action Employor-
Stowell - 08/09/95
Page 2
individual copies for Commissioners or the City Manager. This material is available in my office for any
interested party to review.
With regard to the proposed study for the Bayview area and environs, I plan on developing a scope of
work and signing a contract with the Florida Center for Community Design and Research out of the
University of South Florida. This non-profit group has prepared studies for the City in the recent past
and I am confident they will be able to do a good job in analyzing this area. As you request, I will
advise you when a contract is signed.
As I mentioned to you, staff is pursuing a contract with this group because of limited resources in-house
to perform this study and because of the extensive controversy associated with the Bayview neighborhood
involving the FINA Station rezoning request. It is my professional judgement that, due to the highly
emotional setting involving the FINA zoning proposal, City staff should not be directly involved in an
analysis of this area at the present time. I want to clarify this because I am not sure from your letter that
you understood fully the reasons why the neighborhood zoning study is not being done by City staff.
Due to summer vacations, my Department is considerably understaffed the remainder of this week and
next week. In fact, I will be on vacation all next week. Other Central Permitting staff, including some
planners, will also be out. I am consequently asking you to minimize the frequent and extensive research
requests by you and your associates during this period of time of limited staffing. I ask you to consider
carefully whether the material you request is needed for your preparation for the FINA Station rezoning
request public hearing. I also ask you to consider whether you (or others) need to get similar information
from more than one person. If, in your considerations, you find that further extc:lSive research material
is necessary or that more than one person needs to be asked the same question, I ask you to work through
Assistant Central Permitting Director Vie Chodora who will attempt to comply with your request in a
reasonable and timely manner. Mr. Chodora will determine the best and most efficient way of complying
with your request. However, I again ask you to respect our limited staffing during this vacation season.
Thank you in advance for your cooperation concerning my request for consideration due to limited
staffing. As noted above, I will advise you upon the execution of any contract with the Florida Center
for Community Design and Research.
Should you have questions or comments, please contact me.
Sincerely, ~
s~~t~!iltJ~ ~
nirector of Central Permitting
cc: Elizabeth Deptula, City Manager
Vie Chodora, Asst. Director/Central Permitting
John Richter, Senior Planner
Lou Hilton, Senior Planner
Steve Doherty, Central Permitting Supervisor
Etim Udoh, Associate Planner
SS/Ib ,u\a&aMD...
.po,. c..
'.. .. ~ ";
· FOOT PLAN
TEL:S13-975-6443
Aug 11,9S
11:05 No.OOS P.01
!
I
,
I
I
I
t
I
i
I
i
I
#p
~~ FI?IIT
FAX TRANSMISSION /f5
FDOT PLANNmG DIsTRIcr SEWN
II ~Ol N. MCKIlllEf P"IW;
TA~""'" F'L :):3&.1 2
o I 3'970-o~44
FAX: 8 J :)'Q'15e~43
I
TO!
Early Sorenson
744-6090
Date:
Pages:
August 1]. 1995
3t ;nchlding thjg cover sheet
Fax #:
Froms Don Scott
Subjects Level-or-Service
COMMENT&("--~'"''
oJ \ 0 0
'I \ . \ 0 0
Here III the Ve1-or-Servicc(L9S) for SR 60 from US 1910 McMullen BooLh Rond from the
Plnellas M USing generalized I~S tablcs(circlcd on the spreadsheet. LOS P). MZlp is in color
but also sho It as LOS P betwdcm those points. Cull me lit 975-6444 if you have any questions.
o i
I t
I.
.
. FOOT PLAN
TEL:813-97S-64~3
Au 9 11.95
11:0S No.OOS P.02
~~~~~~~&~9SS$e~e~~~~aaN~NN~~~~@~~~QS9a~~3QS~N~~M~~~~~~~~oo
....... ,I; ... Qt ClC 0( n Iii
.- It u ~ iLi B
t:: ",':'CJ~~51.. 't)"O ,.. i ~,., -g 'U_"CI~"'''''~ ,t! ~ "D" 'tI_" >>1 50 .. 1
~ ~~ fg ~ClC ~.... I ~ ~~~ ~~~ - ~~~ ~~~ ~~~! w
"l:I ~.... .... ~ "D .. Go 1!. 'a ~ - ... '" Lo 1! 0 .. .. -g.." :II .. "Q'" .-
It;;~I~e2]jl ~~~~~~_~~su~~~<<J~~~~~~~!~~~ "l~iM~~~~~il :t ~~
t~....~t~.~e-~ ~~aDuZ611.e~~tja~t~~~~aJ~s~H~~~~ti-~j~~~ui ~u-~.~~
- ~i~~!! ~~ut2- t!~2~ bc~~~-i~ ~ -~~ 2~ ~~ ..~~~-_ .t~N~i~
~ A~.~UU ~~~~M~~ Q~~D~ ~Q~~~U~a. = ~aU~Q~ ~a~i~u~~~z~~~~~~
~!:5 a: Ci lW . ~ '1;J
U 0 "......,.. ~'O.. ,_...
~ "O_~~_o.. "D >. ~~ ~"D~ "Q_ ~ ....~" ~ "0_ "D_~ ~~ ..,,,
ClC~O~~~Q ~m 0( 4 ~~~.u ~- .~ ~-- ~<.... M
'tl ,,~ 'a ~..~ i. .-g ClC 0 ..~o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~i -
~~~lWZ~!~~2~ ~~ClC>-~ ....GO~t~oClC~~ulu~l~ ....... ~~~ N~~~~~~b n3~t~
M_ ~- ~~-t ~- .c ~~-~ -~~ _~"_~~U ~~~- ~~ -~- ~~g -~ ~
!U~,~ ~~~ ~~ ~i6 ~~~!~L~t. ~IH S . E~~;U~"Qt ~t~i~~~~ s
~~~t!$~~:~~~i~j!>EJ.!wa~~la~!i~~~ij5!i~u~~5i~~~Sla3;~.~3~~Q
a ~
I ~
._.-.......~..,.......~.-
gw.~~..m. -
~~~~~-;~~~~~f~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ i~i>>iii~&~a
11111~Jiiil~siil]!!~!J~J~~1]~~~~~]~M~~~~~~a~~~~J~~!!!JMtMJ!MJ
B~ 2i~~~~~~~~~~~ e~ij eeo ii~iiiiii! t ~~u~tjjj]j
~S ~~aaaaaaaaaaaj~~~Jtl~I~~~~~m..~j!Ji~JJJJ~!3~3~~~~~~ I
~~~~!~~~~~~m~i~~m~lamm~~i~li!~~~~~~!~i~mmi~~imil~mli~!mIl!
"-..:.w.
,f!
I'
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
(
I
ill. ,__ ...~..
N
3
-'
mu_~' ~~~~Da.._UD~CDeeo_~__u_ UUUUUUUUgOUUU~U~Q'
QgOQCD~O ii\~~~~~~~~~~~Og~~~~~aO~~~~QgOgNNNNOOOQQQ~~~~~OQOO
~ ~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~ ~~~~~
...... ~ ~ .,...~........
~ j .'
=U~~O~~L~~WOL~OUUOOM~~UWL~~~OM ~m.QUUUVOOY.~UU~Q
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
:::::::::c::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
~~~~~~~_________~~___~~~~~~~~Nre~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
o~c~o;;=;~;~;:~:;;;;:~~~;:~:;;~~~;~gQgg;;;;m~e~~~;~~~;~~OQ
o-!~ ~~~~~~~~~Ce_DOD&~~M~~~~~~ ~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~ ~~~~~~~~NN~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~N ~
g~eep~~m~~~5~~~~~e~~~~~reg~E~g~g~g2~~~2e2Rg~~222~~RE~~~~ppp
"!-~ "1 ~~~.., II! 1I1~1IJ iI1~1I1 U-:~~"1~~ ~~~U}"l~il'1 ~"''''''J~u) "lU] liiti!L1LiU)"1~~ u~~~u: , ,":V:"1V-:~"1~ ~ ~
QOOOOOOOgQOQQQQQQOOaaOccooo~ooaooooOCOOCOOQ~OOOOOOO.~O0000
~
It
~
I)
...
..
II
..
(jl
~
n-
01
~
Ih
OJ
'S
'"
U
IR
....
01
S!
...
..
~~~~~iei~~e3~i~gg~~sg~~~~Es~si~~~iJ~s~sBB~B~~g~si~~i~~~~~~
dddddddQOOOCOCOQQQOdddddddOdOOQOQCOQCoooocidaacQoooOOOO0000
r:III
"i1.
i
:;
~
.J
U
....
.
l"I
..
L-
'W
~~~~~Qg-~g~N~NN~O~~~~rQOg~~a~~~~N~rQQO-~~~~-_Q~~~~~~~--QOa
~N~g~N~~~~NaO~N~NO~~~~N~~~N~~~~rr_~8N~~~NO~~_C~ON~~~~~N~~~
~~N~~~Q~NNCO~~~N~~~-~N~.~N~~N-M~o~~ ~~~N~~NN~~N~~N~N~~~~~_~
,. It.. t.. III.... "'.... t t",. 1:11..,..... ....1...... t.....,..........,..
OOOO~N~QCQ~-~gOgog-gggaQQQggQgag-ao~QOOgQaOOOQOOOQaCOONO~O
~~~~~~~~MWMM~nn~~n~M~~~~~MM~MMM~~~~gOOOM~M~~~~~~..~~nMMM~aO
o
...
~
...
...
"',
&
~
a
't;I
-
1. ",I, . .1' . .... .._
",,-"""j~lr' ~_"!I,_ _ I1Ifl \,aml ~~m.... ~:.r
...',.---~~.~
.... ____JIIJ . --
..
FOOT PLAN
TEL:B13-975-6443
Rug 11.95
11:06 No.005 P.03
.
.. w'
,
.':;.
".1:" .
~ f ~l.
't.' 1<, '.
',"
. "
IG';':
-IJ\~:, .'
I:.
: ~ .:,~ ~
. ,"~P"
'!rt't
, '
~
'.......-----.
~. ~.
'/'
"1' .
. ',I
r. ~
.:' ~
....
..It" ,
, ,
. "
Pinellas County
'" 'MPo I!'
1994 Levels of Service
". ;. .
Existing Oonditions
FIGURE TWO
'Level of Service A, B. C
Level of Service D
Level of Service E
- Level of Service F
Using Generalized Tables
N
A
. " Milo.
- . I
.' ',. 0 . 2 4', .~:.: I,': '
, I' J'I!~"1' ", .,'.. "{,'71~"
l'Jef>e red IIJ 1M PI...... c.u~1y MPO . :. ~.: . ,r. r. '
,1
. f
....:" " I
:."..'~~.',.". ... I" "t ......,..',......,.'....... ......~... ,. .
'. ,"1 ....~.I..-:~;........i .. ~dl......~;.l.... ,-
.4. ....'.. ........... I. .........,.... ..I.._...,""'o/l;'n.r~.tT...~~~~~t.::;.l":.....~...f.".T'If.'J'1......~.\:,~~";:1~.";~'~'.;'t\.-::..I~"" ..:---:.-..-.._;..."''i'y_~t''_..~~..~~..".~......FIo.rt.!.....f.~//.q...
,If..... ,,~!. *. ~. ~ / ~r~/;"t": : f. :.'::\ '1.j'lI ~~!~.':~l"i ~t~t n\j.:.'fw"i:~? ,4 ~; .~tA'~':l~ltr',".w~ ~,~~:;~~~~~,~~~f~......; \ :.: I. )\'. .~'.~'Aj. ......: P.: ll.11~..,.\I'J,.~ .:~~ I .
.. .. ... J . ". ..." '., '.,.. ,..' .t,f;"" .IA.... "'l".~ .'r."S'.I" . '~." ':.\I~,WI'H'~~' . !:;IiI. 'i ". . ~'::.,.. t.., ." . .." .~. ..~.l.i'( .'f.r :'I~...T .'O..d:fl,
FOOT PLAN
TEL:813-975-6443
Auq 11.95
10:18 No.OOl P.Ol
-...,.
Hour -0 tVt OAIIS
Endkln ~ we E8 WD
01:00...... 437 !i6{J 3M S34
02:00 M4 29' 590 276 o./lD
03:00AM 203 :21)7 11>> 219
04:00 JJ.l 141 210 110 184
~DOMt 1~ 1M 14D HO
06;00 AM 1I:l0 1112 418 t~
07:00 AM 1431 753 1382: 878
00;00 AM 2#1 '.....0 2f;01 .D7D
09:00 A.Vl 2173 1532 2061 '503
to:oo AM 2020 1402 lB7Q 1820
11:ooAM 2122 1820 1(l39 1707
12:00 PM 2257 ~ 2233 1~
01:00PM ~" 2203 21Ul 2"2
02;00 PM 1040 ~T tUG 2128
03:00 PM 1910 200Il 2081 2070
04:00PM 202G 2100 ' 1l041S 2104
05:00 PM ~ao ~1 2100 241..
06:00 PM 2373 2WS 2230 2!576
O'7:00~ UH6 ~M tlloa 21""
08;00 PM 1040 1714 1DtlO 1 GeT
~;oo F'fIl ,,60 1458 HOC HI7Cl
10:00 PM ,106lJ 138'1 tOll? 1919
11:00PM ?i!} 571 ooz 1009
t 2:00 AM 660 764 elD ' Il92
Tetall: 33879 3273Cl 32V1l0 ;)2028
.
AIJI r""!l TwO-WIlY Haur
IZD we Tata! I:nclnu
1402: 1162 953 om:lO ~
:105 370 6e$ 02:00AM
1~ 2~ 04:)0 M:oo AM
1211 181 3,D 04:00 AM
147 1~ Sl!l~ 05:00AM
0423 107 ClIO OO;OOM4
1.40T 715 2.121 01:00 AM
2,471 1,4OD '.8&0 . 08:00AM
Z,12:T 1,IUD 0.04' Oi:oo AM
t,IlS0 1.508 3,.4tiO '0:00 AM
C,OS1 1,784 G,7M t1:0Cl AM
2.245 2,014 "',211~ 12:00 PM
U2S 2.165 ""SM 01:00 PM
2,031 2"Oe ",100 o~OO PM
1:.000 2,039 ""Q:!IfI 03;00 PM
2.033 2,10~ 4.1305 04~OO PM
e,uB tMl7D ",eo5 05;00 PM
2.302 2,540 ",042 (10:00 PM
i,7&1 2.2i4 9.070 01:00 PM
i,4!111 MGl S,tiO 011:00 PM
1,133 1,417 2,~50 1)9;00 PM
1,078 1.350 2.428 10:00 PM
7;; 000 1,18Q 11100 PM
6~ O:!ll> , '120 12:00 AM
33,431:1 ~z.(,\Oz 65:617 AD.T. ,,-
LOO TruO\( Factor
1,17 61lUOntd Rtc\Of
M.253'Eltfrrllstad MOT
Av'U\gs TraJIa CtI1U80t0rlatlCll:
P:D Ra\io:
D r=aa:
PHp.
7.S7lll.
o.~
OJlT1
8.7~
o.lJl:r
O.9n
I
I
i
P01l1.W Fax Note
To
Phon.. I
Fl&l<1I
\...,
ol~.
0.:011 I\M O)UMN
W.OQ Not
U.tlO 1)4
IWlI.Illo~1 d ~'1
__ AnI Dlncllc)Q _ Olbu~~
___J
~.90AW
__ TDl&l Volll/ll.
"-- Illotl(.t."'~I~'oITnmPJrtall.:1~
~-Ollttl.n4,wgc\A1I1, 1M. 1m
........"ll........';.J-- -
. ~ " ,J n'.. '. .,. .... .....
~
... ~: ~ ~
Chod<od~y; 'tr#
(Canlultanl)
~pt.dby:
(Florld4 ~l)
.
0'100"'
.
OMQ ru
UW~
1-....--1
.&..
OOWTM
":i~~~.~.~~~
~ FOOT PLr:\H
TEL~B13-975-6~~3
Aug 11.95
10:19 No.OOl P.02
~ n iiiifierf .
lDeatlOlU Gulf to Bay, btwn U!J HI & Malllintl'aneo Bo~ DIY of WMk: Wid
Ollrntncvy DviJn Da": ~1D4 OQuntM Numbw(.)l <4GOO" 04G1lO
E1urnmaJy fl.I"n TIma: D1:oo PM Holt oonngurallon: 2
~r DcI. i 0.2 Ho\.lr
BICln PV/LT Ml:l He row PVILT Mia -Hell Total Enlln
OIIOOMt DTI a 2'1 toot 88t ; 14 000 OtlOOAM
02:00AM 130D 4 1U ~I eoo 10 11) OM 02:00AM
03;00 AM 457 IS 25 4QO M2 5 15 382 03:00AM
04:00AM m 12 10 ~1 2&9 t 15 274 04:00 ,',M
05:00AM 2117 11 10 ZTfJ 2lU 12 '" ilia o~;oo IW.
OG:OO AM 5G6 14 32 812 568 1; 21 80S 06:00AM
07:00 AM 2056 6t 7B :UV4 1044 6-4 60 2058 07:00AM
Q{l:OOMA ~;)2 01 M :)IlC 1 ::)12D OP D1 COlg 00:00 AM
~:OQAM 8M2 81 Q2 &705 8434 71 70 !M4 ~:OOAM
10:00 AM S3-40 70 03 $51::1 ~~..~ 76 82 SSOQ 10:00m
11:00 AM ~7D2 Of ,~ ~ ;,~ 110 DO M4D f 1:00AM
12:UO PM 4~ eo 82 013!11 4007 64 (15 4188 12:00 PM
o t:oo Pr.A 4~ 45 iOO '<<86 01118 ~ 100 ~l)() 01:00 PM
OZ.OO PM ~1 f/,) \la <40:>> '\()4'i1 ~ tl)!) 4243 ot:DOPM
03:00 PM 8798 68 70 MM 398$1 44 ita 4161 03:00 PM
().4:OO PIA SQ10 e2 Uti 41~ GO'7u -10 1~O 4110 04100 PM
O!J;O(I PM 4004 152 71 of037 441:1 -12 1t8 "~4 011:00 PM
Da:OO PM 4763 46 80 4878 4828 41 138 4805 04:00 PM
07:00 PU 9072 4& Il2 "000 97$10 ~ OQ ~1 01:tlO PM
00:00 PM ~104 ~7 ~ ~2~ 200T Z~ ~ ttT~ 00;00 I'M
oa:oo PM 2557 20 41 2618 2Sl1S 21 74 2482 00:00 PM
1~:OO PM 2407 10 S5 124" 11320 t:s 87 .20400 10:00 PM
11:00 PM 173<4 H 21 17ee 1705 IS 40 UU1, 11:00f'M
12:00 AM 1306 5 19 1330 1478 9 31 1~ 0 2:00 AM
Total.: 64.203 000 1.422 88,8115 02.457 8D1 1.700 0!1.018
-
V
v
ChlC:ktdby.
lConN\Antl
ADo.pted by:
(flOrlCIA Del)
--................
'. .,~;;.:~".;...H~~ltvfo~
. ~ :. .~4I~L,", j.~;~lf..tllHi
.
t.~l .
. ,.'
.'
11 ~ ebl!7 letS-
CU 4::::'$
er CL~ARnATER
rnterdep~=tmental Co:=espondence Sheet
TO:
Tom Miller, As~istant
Engineering/Environmental.
of
Director
Copies:
Scott Shuford, Director/Central Permitting
FROM,:
Dick Hull, Assistant city Attorney
RE:
Environmental Advisory Board
DATE:
February 22, 1995
! have reviewed the provisions of S3i6.317, F.S.(1993), and
believe that t:.hose statutory p::ovisions provide that state la-...r
supersedes local law ~ith regard to the ~egulation of underground
pe't.=oleUI:l. p=oduct s'to:::'age tanks. I have also reviewed the
provisions o~ S32.3S4 and S43.24, Code of ordinances of the Ci~y of.
Clearwater, and believe that they do not pertain to underground
petroleum sto=age tanks and, that even if they did, they would be
su~e=seded bv the Florida Statutes.
~ .
~
1
I
~
~
j
I
!
I
Consequently, ! do not believe that you have the au~hc=ity to
~ake the action sought by ~he Envi~onan~al Advisory 3oar~ a~ ~hei=
~eeting 0: :eb=ua=-y ~5, 1995. (See !-:inu'tes, :p. 6). P.ot...ever,!
ag=ee vi~h you ~ha~ ~he owne: should be enccu=aged ~o cle~~ ~~ ~he
si~e as soo~ as ?ossible usi~S =ede=al ~oney while it is availa=le.
~~ -.:. .:.~ --.:: .~~ I ~ -.-
ill -ll i l:= l~~ I:; ! i \.! ... ~ I i'11 ';"
I : Ir------- ~ II '
. p' . II- ..
:1 n'O\. ., u':~
}I I t~AO 0 ,:. 100~ ~ Ill'
iUL!j '1'.\ .. .....- (L::Jj
· - 1 ~
~~:-:,......~-:~::-- :
\"0.1 ~ L..t" l..:"::Ji"..r...::'n, ..
: ?:~.r~r:-:i,*!'~;~~~.I. r:t".~'t:1~~ .
..._...._.___ u .....,'._.
'-.
~ -. -: ~ r..~ P: n:
: . .. . .; :.. I ~ Ii
I . t!
"'.~;. :; - 13::-'5 Il'i
;
,
!t :"
I .
. 01
~ l '
.--
. . :...... ~:,
~ . '.... - . ...... .
:.;~ '0' t: ':" :~.:,::.JTtl;t:.
~\.....
Itf
e~ f/!7!9J.
petro8.9
August 9, 1995
~/
AFFIDAVIT ~6
Enrly M. Sorenson
I met today with NaJ1c~r Evans, Nanager, Tanks Program, Florida
Departllleut of Environmental Protection, SouU1\vest District Office)
3804 Coconut Palm Drive, 813-744-6100 extension 414.
I showed Ns. Evans the .July 7, 1995 Meador SITE PI.JAN. \'1e discussed
the Meado r /FINA!Cuop 01.1. pn L I.'OJ eUIlI-con Lumi.na ted Hi to (II the MHadol'
BiLe"), Florida AdminlsLrati.ve Code ("FAC") 62-770 (the St.ate code
governing petl"OltHll11 cleanups), und the Hendor SITE PIJAN, i.n
t' e 1 a L ion tot Ii e pot e nl: j a.l i. III IJ act 0 r L heN e ado l' sit e [) II Ill: H ,'b.y
pl~ivaLe w(dlst City \o/ells, and Tampa Ba~l.
Ns, . EVClIIH explained the folluwing:
1.. FAC 62-770 esLu..bl ishes the lega.lly-auLhol'lzed pJ'()(;I~dure~ fOJ'
pctr\)ll;~\llll c]eanupH i.n t.he staLe of Florida.
'J
... .
FAC 62-770' 1:> procedures fOI' petro lculIl clcanups are a:-:; follow:;:
f-t. The oWlle L' suhllli ts u CAR (Con tumi nn t. 1011 ASS(3SSmen t Repor L )
Lo FDEI'. The CAR defines tile extent HIIU s~:ver.i.t~r of the
contamination.
1J, FDEP rev i.cws Lhe CAR and
As~esslllen t Repo r t Approval Ot'de I',
lssues a ContaminaLion
e. The 0\\'110.1.' submiLl::i a RAP (Hemedial Action Plun) to FDEP,
The HAP tells hO\... till;.-' uppl i call t pluns Lo cleanup Lhe si te,
d. FDEP r-ev lewH the RAP and issues a Remedial Ac t ion Order.
e. 'l'he owner Implements the RAP pursuant to the Remctllal
Action Order, submitting reports to FDEP as Lhe RAP progresscs.
f. mIen RAP is success fully oom1'1e t.ed (the Hi te lIIee ts S ta te
La ['get cleanup levels j nd iell Ling LhH L the con tuminl:l Lion t.hr-ea L to
the environment is mInimized), Lhe owner submiLs an SHCR (Site
RehllldliLntion CompJetiotl Hepar!.) to FDEP.
S.' FDEP rev i.eh's the SRea and issues lA 81 Lc RehalJil i LaU 011
Completi.on Order.
3. FDEP's Site Rehubj]..i.l.ution Gornpletjon OJ'der' .iH the only
dOCUUl<Hll. which muy legally be f'cpr'esonl.ed as llcknowlt1dgj ng Lhu.t. l.lU1
s i L(~ is cleaned up and LII(, anv j r'onllmnt pJ'~ tec I.od.
}~!">.". .
4. The City of Clearwater has no jurisdiction to issue any of the
above Orders, or any other legal representation that a sit~ is
cleaned up and the environment protected.
5. SITE PLAN Note 15 'employs language (11SlLe Pollution Clean-up
Plan") not in FAC 62-770. Such language does not invoke FAC 62-
770, the relevant, enforceable State code. There fore, legally,
No Le 15' s language is mean lngJ. ess . No Le 1.5 does not, in fuc t,
require a clea~p. J"~-'~"'''~~-...-._-''--_.-.....,-.--r---r-l
Note 15 could very well end up being interpreted to lIIean thut
cleanup of the Meador site will be delayed until such tillle that
the Heador site moves up the StaLe list, to ,n point at which the
site could be cleaned up by the S La Le wi thou t any expense to
Neador. .There is no way l~o tell when the Neador s1 te would reach
that point. It could take nW,llY ~'ea.l's. In the meo.nt.ime, the
possibili ty. is very !'ceLl tllu t Headol" H petroleum contamination
CQuld po ison his ne i ghbo rs' \o/e J 1 s am.\ endange t' othc l' envi l'onmen ta 1
resoll t'ces.
. . r---/'-
....-""'\ ...),..
_.-~ "--...- .
--",-
------
7 . Wo ['k on the ~leado t. s j Le, Htlch HH so i 1 eXCHva t iOll, s tormWll ter
pond construction, -installation of underground utilities,
dewatel'ingt Hnd (;HoploymenL or hCHV.Y equipmeJlt ovel' the contaminoted
11111)' spread t.h~" COil tam j tlH L i 011 La p l'ev iously I/neOI1 Lami na ted
.i.ncllld j Ill{ Ilea I'b~' ,,,re 1 J s.
'.1
t..... ..
..
t
y.,~
~Oo
~-\1.
~
i:1 ~ r~
-, [ II
hllll) !
JhL 11 I
j I "iiJ
1 .; I) .. :', ..:..
'"
i !.
~I H
~: ij
G:r ];
~ ~ i;
A 1 J
t I! '
~ I
e
'I
11 i
H l
u
I
J~
~'If.t II
1 JIB
lihi ,
ii~. i
oM fl
I
II
J
I
i
J
I
i
i
t !
I 1 lit
II & l.r!!
11~lt 1111
Sd] JI iliilll
IIIHi il~t
t: J!~!~ ~~fl
!i !::y81 ~f.sd
~ flitt liel
~ '-II~~ Fll.
!la
I. .) Ii
I) It!!
t . ~ J
It 1:1
~i Ill'
tl .. i
!ll !MR
r' . .
i I ]
,. t J.
i f~
! ii JJ
~ I. 11!
I i" :I.t
II KG II!
~ it jj~
Jl ,,1 l~
! .I" ~I
I
i
t
.1 ~
~I
i~
Ii
..:1
]
i I!
f I
.1' 'Il
: i~
hi!-
I!tid
il.r~l
l! . n :
. ..
..
i
. 5
i ~ I
I j1
~ It
it! ,
it" .-1
l f
J i l!
· I I I 1
I ! -I i[ Ii i f
i i It ~ Ji~ ~l~ Ji;IM s ~j
i J ~ fi I!'~ 101 I!! i to
.l~ II ~ ll~ 'lH lr~ 11
J J i ! l!iJ II~ 11 1:}
li1 1~ 1 tlJ Ii t~~ I j}
"'-t.:....: ...0:: ..~.:: "t!..1 ",s
I
i
E
i
II
6
.Ii
~
..
1
j
f
u
i
o
1-
1
..
~
o
~
...
<
j!;
..
"
z
~
:t:
Ii;
i
g
:s:
8
:t:
0-
III II i I i I
Mj! .~R t t~ ,I
1!:j" i!e ~J j.t fq I"
IJ' 111l5iK~ -I 111 ~~
~ i~ t : l~ . !;
H 1 nhil llll Ii I"
lt~i iUF! II! It! l~t
11II IJJJlt IIi Jlltll
j ~. s=
~j~ ~
11 i i
.., ~ Jl
ja] ~
'I}- I
if I ~
.1;..
f1f
I
pI
~ &i
~ .. I
0'1 ~ ~
i ~ ~ i
! z x,~
..
!:i
"'2 ..
~s II
o ~i f..
;I of. d'
! ~2 I!
~ t;;~ tJI
!; ~~ 11:
~ I~ ~ ~ ~ !
It
II
f c
, -8
II
! I
'iii
!
::
.'1....
l><>
*
'"
t
...
.... .~:.
.. ...; ~ ". ~
. ... .....'
"
f .E'.
, ~ i
t
. ',' .,..:. j., .
~.;~ \. .. ~ .., ,
~li
~..
~!
j
I
~
..
o
>:
~
..
~
(]
;;t
..
to
!(
~
..
!l
~
It
i
x
8
x
-
..
~;J
~~~ s~
!(~tl It
~!~ !;
~~J !:1I
oil II
~w! II
i=> I
! l~ ~ ~
"
. .
. >, ,.<j J- .,.,.
,.
i
. .' ',... l
> ...... ~'! 1
J i~ ~ t
~ f: f i
! ~ I J i
!
1 .
: ,,; I.'. : ':;',~,'" :.;>,: .;\~':'~:~"::. ~.{::b;~~~j:;,:.~./:: :!~"~:'. . .
".;: ''-,'::~:''.':..:::,.:!,. .:' . ....-:.~.. ,~,::~:'.;?':':~??\r\~?~}f>:~::~~l;;r.
. '" .. h. t,;~f.}~I".',.~;
: iJ' '.... .:"f':'!~<~~ ," ",".
! " '. .'.' .. ~ :..... .1! .... ~. : ~ .~.. :;.. ~ :i..(.r.~.~.{~.:.;.~,'.~:,::.. ". .
i ~. ::::",'. ;,; .':.,:. e ~ 'd.: .'~. -
'1.. ~ I ~B ", '. . !; ~.:'. . .:. .
'2 '1! ; : '. .,. i L~'
i t I ~ :. i ~ '..'
I i ~ ~
n . ..' \i.,o" ;,.. ,I ..;':...... ~
~
:;;
'2
i !E
i -
~ ~ ~> ~
~ ~ {; I .. ~~ ti
I L II 'si H ~
~ H l] ! ~[ ; I ~ii ~
~ I J ! ~ I..,' 1 ~ ~ i E
~ il~{lr ii IiI H 111 ~i~1 !
II & gl ,II I ~t'i~~i~
I ~i it! !JI ~3bi~~
I ~ j! ), iJ~jQJ mH~
~ ~ ~ ~~~i~9
.8 I I' 9~ I It III n · 9il9i~1
1J ! i..f ~i 1 { !~ 11t f~ i ~a~~i~
]~ ~ I ~ ! al 'i if It I i~icg~
II ! It! l'l~ I!Pl~tf Itii Ii ~ H 'hUl
t II ill~; Ii ~i 131 i1 ~ i8 ~
i !I ~i= ~~~,Il ; 3~ ~ tN j ~ ~iJ
[, --U.J:L.. ~_fi.,L.Jt.i... ____'t..t, ~~b._ Q_L
~
.&
!
..
I
"
~"-" -
\."
'(/I1I'/~ @
(!)ec
Re: MEADOR/BAVVIEW REZONING/LAND USE CHANGE APPLICATION
Date: August 16t 1995
DESIGNATION of REPRESENTATIVE/SPOKESPERSON for INTERESTED PARTY
.to: Mayor and City Commissioners:
I, JuneSchmitchen, who resides at 520 Bayview Avenuet
Clearwater, Florida, am an "intereste~ parties" in this. action,
as defined by the City of Clearwater. I do hereby designate M~
Breck Parkert of 716 Bayview Avenue, Clearwater, Florida, to be
mMepresentative/spokesperson .in this action.
Yours truly,
8)/0/9;
9~
June 5c hmi tc: hen
-
. -
.
. ~ 'to... '\
( fin /C;S-
RICHARD K. DUITBR, AICP
DlRBCInR OF PLANNING
SUMMARY OF
EXPERIENCE
Mr. Dutter has more than 20 years of experience as a Land Planner,
Landscape Architect and Urban De.'\igner. He joined King Engineer-
ing As..;ociates (KRA) in June, 1987 with a broad experience base In
both the public and private seetOI1i. Mr. Dutter's areas of expertise
include land use planning, land development regulations and zoning
ordinance preparation. growth management plW1 preparation. urban
design/redevelopment studies, historic preservation planning, and
Site/subdivision design. Other area." he has extensive experience In
include landscape architecture, parks and recreation planning and
design. and waterfront planning.
Prior to joining Kfl~ Mr. Dutter served for four years.as Regional
Planning Manager for a major regional engineering firm where he
was responsible for planning and landscape architecture. Mr. Dutter
acquired his public sector experience while serving as Planning
Division Director and Zoning Administrator for the Township of East
BrunswIck, New Jersey. In addition, he selVcd for three years as an
adjunct professor in environmental design at Rutgers University
where he taught courses in land use planning, urban design. and
landscape architecture.
RELEVANT
BXPBRmNCE
Mr. Dutter has served as Project Director/Manager for numerous
planning projects. Key projects include:
City of Clearwater - Miscellaneous Parks }lrQjecls - Project Director
for planning, landscape architectural and engineering services for
several new parks and park renovations within the City of Clearwater,
ranging from a nature park with interpretative/educational trails to
active recreational community park facilities.
r.lncllas }llannini Coulls;il ~ Scenic Corridor Stud)' . Project Director
for developing criteria to determine scenic qualities and for
developing land use. access and design objectives for scenic corridors.
HilIsbaroUih County NciihbQrl100d j>>arks (17) - Project Director for
master planning. site design and engineering of existing and new
nclgl1borllOOlI paI~. Included urchitecture fOJ Icclcatlon centers,
restrooms and picnic shelter.
Tierra Vcrdc_Marinc_C.cnw: ~ Development of Regional Impact
application for a 110 wet slip, 384 dry slip marina on the island of
'l'icrra Venle in riI1Cni\~ County, l'loridn.
.
p
.'
EDUCATION
MEMBERSHIP IN
PROFESSIONAL
ORGANIZA'nONs
--
0"'''',
....''','1<.
,
~ i
R1C1IARD Ie. DUITBR, AICP
-2-
SerenovCl - Development of RegIonal Impact application, land use
. pInn. Master PUD rezoning, landscape architecture and site/subdivi-
sion design for a 7,OQO..acre, 6,50~unit, 8 million sf commercial, office
and industrial new city in Pasco County, Florida.
New Riv(~T - Development or Regional Impact application, master
plan and Master PUD rezoning for a 1,800-acre, 4,800-unit, 700,000
sf planned residential community in south central PWiCO County,
Florida.
Wyndtree - Land use plan, Master PUD rewning and'Development
of Regional Impact application, for a 452-acre, 3,OOO-unit, 400,O()(}.sf
office/commercial planned community in southwestern Pasco County,
Florida.
River Club - Inventory/analysis, hmd use plan, rezoning, master
drainage and utilities plans, and site design for a l,3DO-acre, 1,000-
unit. 1.1 million-sf office/commercial/industrial planned community
in Manatee County, Florida.
Rive;: RWit: - Muster Plan/Master PUD rezoning and Development
Order amendments. master bikeway /pedestrinn plan. subdivision and
site design for a 1,900-acrc, S,80o..unit, 920,OOO-sf commercial/office,
new community in Pasco County, Florida.
ijeacon Woods East M Mu~tcr planning MPUD/DRI amendment.
residential village design and landscape architecture for a l,25Q-acre,
4,SOO-unit, nO,aDO-sf, commercial/office, planned community in
northwestern Pasco County, Florida.
Master of City & Regional Planning. Rutgers University, 1982
BS, Landscape Architecture. Rutgers Univcniity, 1974
American Planning Association
American Institute of Certified Planners
American Society of Landscape Architect"i
-
',I,
, "
~...,' ~.
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z' 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
:
i
I:
I
j
\
~
"
.
~
1
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MAnKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
~
~
'"
~;
~~
"
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT HE REPLACED~ .
destroy another
MARKET to obtain
f,-'esh frui ts and
Ii
Y
,.
~.
1\
,I
f
j-
,.
~
NAM€~): ADDRESS. I.,Q d':tObc..ew
___ ___1__ I. ~ ______dqQ~_-~J:~-1!?-~ I ___ I . ,;
~ ',~ , ~ ~~L.4/~) ,
r:;:::.. . '1.t!2!~_ ~-- -- - - ___t.9..29-__ (s;~(f.......t!E _:. Jt.)./i.'Y-lit-- 'I d.~&'e ~
~~f!\~+__01nN'L_~__6qiJ_~__Q~:tb__i~__~i_____Y_ ~~ f ~
- -. _lc bs -.(1 -1f~l.ft\A.'- .-- 2'1 ~_1. _ _~"Jf:.hJ1~_~l..~t~l2? 1:
~~_E::?~-____-_llLl~$-d~_~{Jd:;{JL1~~____- ':
-~ - -- -~. -- _n.__JdJ./~-uJ-'J-k&&~
..Cd ~.1{1tt:C' ~[,_.:5..rJ/2,,-W217LC'~__~::1~
- - ILl:: ~ .?c -7D !Jf!fl!:e!.l.-.. 312.1 gz - /L~/J lflL.lbjc-,.d.,fLU
7~I1(!fg~--- - __.2.8fl:L_.~Cjl*:7tZL&.f:,1~~Z-"
\ ~Z--::=... _ _ ..... _ _...z. .L(c:LLJelJ..'<2 /. _ rjL _~Ja.. C/4-L-:l:-
,..,n O_J_~':5 . _1:-1 ~t:~.dfL~~1.(~. -_. d_1j)=-- -I__7~~~~:'JjJ'_l,v~:.('.d._Pf..:. - -~jv-J7 _L_Cu
G I ;t2 l - 1C2-- I .rt.- .n.
- ., ". -'<.:; ....... '\ . .? . . " (' r ''") t. . ;t'
-- J. LC .,. .G't (~r....__. -.-. - Jt.l/{'f!r.f.(~ar.tl. ..1..1/:..- -1-(-_._ -_ _..:0.;..'1-(;1./--. __ _ - _._ __ _ - ___ _ __
~~,b~~_.._-_.._-~~-~---~--
(;
i
, I
!
1
I
PETITION
to Mayor. Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Cle~rwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
7. 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 8ayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
,
I
I
i
t
t
\
I
~
~
~
~
,
q
'1
.
We are customers of. the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACEDp
~
=
i.
)
!;
~
ADDRESS
- ---------------~-~--~
--{,<",i=-~---________d::L'ic:LL']!:1y.b"'".J..Q.o-d---j)L- t/J'1 I<
/---....t>r /." f ( '7 / D /1 /J J S-\-.r E' r.fJ--:/ J'') 7
~Mr~~----a.JD-t{.~- _r..c=L__ _::-__.5&[..::.:.1__/./ r~
13JJJ3_ _ D- ~ :LJ0.o_::-'VlCL~~Ci5~L Ct-t_fCiCb_f1,-t2.C~J$.,JJ ,'0- roI
_Cl_Gl_C\l_!:l_L(l_rC~L1;..EJ_Q~~~__Ii31JJ~LL~1LQJ::d~gfA J' ., el()()
(LL_, f.~f) _____.2.~~JL6,L~,L~_L1~LL.: ~i
- r___ ___L:-.___ _~~&S-JE~____,._'Cb..(~~tb-J:l_L~\l.DC '
, -----. '-- . (j) 16 .-.-tP ;},j ,ct-
~-_..- - . - _.kl. -_._.._,_ ~D.{/;);+f-:=_J_]J-t~t- -,fZ_-!__.%~
~.t ~" /} V? _.....:iI.../ ~ ...
:: '9 ~"7J;r-<!'~-"'::b. - - -- - - - -- - _;::<<~.ij;X-! 72l ~'- - ff},'-UL,d%tccsIL<r:.Z. 2-
c71.~ JJ~____,. ___ --..__._.j~J..Ui'sLoJe.~~,v_~_Q.t 0s_..+.. 3(f~ 19;
----/ .) // '-;? I I / /:1'
- _o/,,;;L2L:. _-ff;2_"-J;>~(.:'_- ---- ___v_QR___ y JJ:g.LL'2.L'3-~__J_'l:~___~LI'.$...L_39c;'/r
- .~~ JllltlJli_JdJ/.4LA ~ - - -.. - - .J..CZo s-- {;.J-dL {{'2~:i~v- - JY.J2/10!&'.:.fU - j.?;?,J. -' 3 Y 6..( r
~
;
.J ~ ....
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey ~ City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
. ,
We are.customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition 01 a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop_
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
destroy another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
"
I,
.t
.j
NAME ADDRESS
~1iJ_~~Jlu5c~~_____________Lq~19_J2il~1~J~~{l~~___________
,
_~--.c~LL\\'lL-J---------J~.l.:1O-~"J,\-st"'-~~T'--------7 .
t~~~- -f:zQJ.:do_o____ - - -- - - _21 - ~C -_5?r_:-[;:i2t.:.(C L-~_~L' .
__ ;rl1.tt. {fL (ll..ai.!'.a J' ... _ - __f ~12(.'_ .itli/':!...lkj;, -./d.~.f!LCf!:C;-Cc {' ~d.di,
-- S i1l.J?jLjL~~____ ---- - LZ ~~ r ~.!:!f!.J~c..:!(j'l.L./R.f(/ .e-I <f"
-- \ ,LLJJ_~-C~ff't--V:.'-+--LI{,\6fl~[l[ '~.
- -CL 'VLJ----_1J1L14v;.__..LLIo..O_L.___LL_'_:-:t~--m. . - ~57k~
-r ~~-- _QI~E --~-::----___J.;:A-1Jt"'Gls._::-~-_b1~4~~--~
. 1 r~ ~..J. I- _ u. . I (
?'f\~<-!,J~7)(/~p~------- m ---,---?!~~c!tiJ!S;/.~-C.t..~:~ w....J:..... ·
..fA JjJ ..i-J~-i'l;~ - - - m --.. m.. ..- - ../J'5../1 (l. sbJl..CL. _, '\ !'2~M.,U. t., f rJ..... )
I, ). A . J?._G:J(,___ __ _m_ _d!iL'.f.J.J~jJQJ~~ct."'(.tipJ..l!1:3jbr 5
e4??!-&"~ (!:'..r."d-v:.I.t.'4;t. cj<!d/.:/?r.r.Ze<-- r /
':
':
.1
:1
"
!t:. ..~ .
. 10(./
c.O t..
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey ~ City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAVVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTe to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop_
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED~
the area to replace the
destroy an e~isting use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED_
,;
~
t,
~
y
,
~
I
,
~
I
I
I
I
~_(~C______:::::::J.:~~ZL0L~{Q.~__~LH:'~
~~2?@:U~~=~~~~~~~~~~~~6~:~:t~~~~~~
L~~~~___h~\)l~\(--(~S~_iL-}_-"____________
, ~- -- -- ----------------------------~--------------~~-----
, I
-----------------------------------------------
..-fi~~lffj~~~--------.----------(~I~-~ ~ ~~-~:.~---------;~~:;l
I)l;~- - - 'Z.....--- -~-=t- - -- - -. -.- -- - - - - - ..J.-- Z::t- _~.1_ - - _d L2h._ -fl..tL -- ----
._.. J .~fr:.f!$--Lcc:!..0:.~ _ _ _ ____ ____ f~~~ ~~__cl ~(:&_"5_t_AJ!:~f~{~r.t
~ ........
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey ~ City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
-,
. .
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in the area to replace the
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would destroy an existing use,
our- use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain fishing-bait
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would
existi~g use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegeta les, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. '
destroy another
MARKET to obtain
f....esh fruits and
f
1
t
1
t
C
,I
I'
~ ~
O :
i ~DDRESS ~
- d-r-l2- . ~---ZdI1:l:r;~~ - /2-,qf'\
, i'r;rr /u~J- / /J 1 !~
- - -- --- - ------- -~J---{)l~~~-~-~J~J-- ~
+:' r , g, , D ~~ 1
_~u... _L.L _ \-cJIJlY'~~j_____ (L~____ ----c..iJ..Q,.C.~11:tJ{\ .
___b0-,,-_ _ ~~~~las_:t~C______~~l____fi2Ll@l_L; .
-~ry~-------------2:-~L~b--~.4I-;L~,-~Dt'J..Q ,
--~~-_I..JL~--------------AS-.l-S--~~~~-w~d
__~l:;.y... ~c- _ktDtC:1" __ 3Q~? fqs:'i!.xr.d. J)~I~LVJ ~5.lJ.~ L 1- _LoJdl:tz 3- L-
-- r<7~~~:~0------~~~~a-CW~~flI~fft-:-\C;r6 1
-----~--~"--~--J~-~---------~I--{----~L~~-------~~-p
. . Po"'" \ t?':l-._ - 5_}~y~:: - -- - -.. - - - - 21Y1 - ~.:Iii."'"-'fr- W.ao.d. _.DR c<t:: t'_ ..M
.- .wi.U; "'- -~I.aJi~m - - - -. - -. - - - - - - ~\j.L~_ - -J9Hflr --'lcxd-P..f1::L~/~.-~ ~~t
- ~~'5:2~~=-_ ____ _______ -_-2~3L_~LI.i.~_~_~_L'>-..-
n,.
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.'
the area to replace the
destroy an e~isting use,
to obtain fishing-bait
l
I
1
I
l
t
,
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves 85 the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED_ '
destroy another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
~
,
I
~
~
~
~
i
t:0
\\:J
~
:~_____________:::::::~-l~Ct~~,~~~~~
~_'-o,_'Jj]~~':!':5::'s1__ _ ilX}~_L.:1t~_<-::!:f'2)_'L_71d:..J:!t"-i!-Y!c.'!!if:~"~.Jlt;. 0 '/ {" IJ .
~_ ~(~ _______JtQ_fi_r~~ELL.~~~'!..cLa-IJ-Ii.--~G_~1 eLIAJ F?/~
~ - ---;.~ . v' I ;
~~~ _~ __' ,_ -2.!. Z_~.L?_/.f!.!;'Ld.t-!.<< ______ -__;-_____ :
~-- -f.1..1J<-cg,&- __1 L D_":.. tL J21 L1{J le-W.aiJSL bh- -L1J<5f, C./(Jjr~
u--c;;- ,. __.ad.o.=:1.~___ - '~'::2 _~~~_~ C'-~~~
, A , 0 ' '. V () .t - l .?}-l CD ILl
~ ___if~ - .rk/;;:):2trCM_I2i---llis:i7':!; :i'~JS-C:
, -LjSI~~- '!Ill!1jJi-.<r:LJ//s,-;JL~---1jJ&-;:( ~St(P'
~ . ~~L ~2~~___2_6_ _(;([__,~.x~JJ.!.__SJ:__-eL_t.trt.1,.j.eiZ-_3CL(:.P~
_ ~<!-_""o!..<.l.3d-k:!.1.K ~,2 ~ 2'.L 11: .6.<,tz?~(;i-.J::3.L'1t._t2._t"GL1".L;"M <: LfCu.%;': t /. ~
IT~~_LQ5!;LE~:::_~_:_,-~:_:::~:~i;.-_!?~~Iq-'b'fg
__ _'.R~_h~'!'h_- _ _'Zf!zl!.JfJ/'f.-~q!./!!:__f)1Cj;Jk-:j3lf t;( c;:
__ _ ~J~;}{ ~'_ __dl] ~:'4Y:Cjj_ _ _ _" L{!.!_L~_ ;5_~ _Cf!?~L~ ,-<-!.z:.~If?-I- _f!:_ s C;C I~-
'f"
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Blo~k 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WI~L NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
(
!
t
I
1
,
\
!
T
,
~
~
~
~
!'
j
~
~
. ~
\
i
I
I
I
,
i
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. .
~ ADDRESS
- --7Y~y-- _______jL"2(2.j;;~__SJL__ ?A~~ __P..~___
~_Jl.S..-!~ _ __ __ __ JLi{__ Cf.!M..L f?1!.__f&J~1!#:.Jf~Lt
l lQ ----_______J-~~9_\i~.a.~~l.~~! ?~':1a~~~.A_7J(il
/ /' &-"{O'"\ L<---,\J- ~ ~~ ~Iv..)~
- ----------- - - ----_.._------~-----------------------------
~ -~ --~-----~- -----------~!~~~~~-~~----~~-----
G -,2-~_ ---____________i!.Q:!LI:.h~\IJi<;L>nfJ-.--~<>y2L-
- -- n!.-1iJV -----------n-----?~--!2~F-"R~~~L!':u;<.,~{-
_!_- _ - .:L_~~ _ _ _)_ e>_Q._____a~Lb___Q_~_~S;?_~~_0J~-
- J ------- -----------5q:J~~~------------------J1
- () ---=--- -.--------------JL~~(-(J)~-.lfE~_gc;:l-
-1.'!I.frlJiAT-!:0!~-----------8'f70~(ttj{.I1lt.KCA+
g,J:.ti.d~:-------.------~fb..c;-~....--~-WtJ.fJej:.4/J;j{
"
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
i
I
I
]
l
~
~
We are customers of the CLEARWATER, FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will, endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
'.
:;
.~
;!
J
A~qRl R ~Rn~~n~~n~~ q~Rr~ ~t th~ FINA would
existing use, our use of the CU::ARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store su~p~i~s: incJudiMg
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
destroy another
MARKET to obt~in
.,....",..~~ i'ru:!. ~~ a~d
::
~(
1
'j
~
'1
-,
Ii
i"
~
~
II
h
'r
,-
.,
'J
1\
)
1;
;
,I
',1
:1
,L
~J
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an eKisting use,
to obtain fishing-bait
I,
'--"
;~_____..u..___: _?~\\ ~~: -\-0\)-<.",-,-\ l~
':"~_.._-~._~,......_q'-'-~r"'"'' .... .. ....... .c...o~,~~.
"
_ ~. I Ir
.U~..~-r.....
v
,
"'" .... ...~..~,. '~"~'.' ,-. .........~..,
. ....__.H... . .......... .... .H.H_h....... .....__._.j
,
" ........ ... ..... ....".1
\
.' . ....,.... .. ,.. ........ i
!
,
.... ...... " " .",..".;
I
\
... ........ -P.......... .--1
,
i
. . ~~.... H . .. ._01 c . .
i.
. ,
~~."''''_''''_~'..,r' ............_.......~..;.:~ ........._..
. )e.-\-;~",^- l' To. .~. .\.LM...l . .V-;',<L .. CJM.,.l..v.cl-~1-':_-----
. c~\:'\ .. '.. '. .., . . _" ~..................,,~..__.._._
:~_c.._....~__........___.c....~~~,o<"''''..-L'._'.~''''' .... .~~ .. ''''",., .... .~.'
'. ,
~ ~
17-. . . '. . . ."..n'._n_ ..dO ..~
...... ----Wo :i "-. /fi~;'r- ~~t; '//-. ..~~ ." .. ~;'jq ..__m--mu-_,
- '. .-.-GAi~~Ru"& m....mC{. . C<. ec~/& ......q-.--..-.-.--
:'. ~L.~;~~~fU*;J. . flm%_./.lm .....-..... _mq ...m____._____;
L-.__1.2..,:~:i0~ . jJ\<'~ .!!l .. -adrv.'l~ ~ 0 (" I . .fL' - _. . m'.. . .._.. . q - .-._... ...--_1
~~..._._,-yJ...._iL~~ ...t " . _. r~.: (ls.~IJk.~f. .r~~_.. . . , .. ,_.'-. ." 'n .,..... ""~_"'"'' "'_.'__'.
: -- -~~_.Jt~.~ &--~mm_.f/"'/"t'~h .. qm.qu ._.uh......___.u_
~--_..~-~~"._~:.)~~..~~..~.~..,......."' ..~(~./~:?:>,- .... .q...............~ ...... ........... .....-.....---.j
;'. 1/ fA '.j .. .
~t! "'.....:t_~~_...i..............~...._..,...~..~... '.T....b........__H~...'..h.'..._~...~, ',r. "'_'_n. ...,.... ... .....". 0'" "_~ ".'-,. ..... .. ......".-0.-..,.". .c'w . .c_....'...'.,~.. ....~.~_..~....'.....T."~................__ ,_..+
r.: . 1 J'J... ; J . .
t.. ,., -_:1_1-rt~.~..... .' -...... ...... -".,~ .. ,.. . ... .. .."." ..'. . .... ..,...... ......" .............. ...... ...N.... ........ " ....... ....... . --....... - . . -,.... .... -...-... ..-,..... ..".....~.._. _..~.!
~__...?1_g_JL_.............. ....."'_'" ..' "". ...', ..........'.. '_',,_ . ..... ......... .... ., ..... ......... ....- , _," ...... .. .... ........ .... ,. .,.... ..... ..,.... "'-"'H_-_" .........,,-~.._. _..~_...,
';..:. ___Lf_7jl....._____......~......__.___..~..........__. ............ ..._.. ,.. ..... .......... .................. ..... ......". ....__...'_.;..m..__..~_....\
<:;... [ :
i..JV i'
. .......4~_........~.~.,.llI-___'_,...e.'.r~......... ~.............>o.._~... ~..,.. e ..'. ~.~d .
.
.:..~~,,~ ,.~2L. !; ..h .............~ ....._........
Sol:;
_______r'~ .........,.......<.........4. ~.~., .' .'" .~_.~, ....4_.~ ..~... ~,
~,~._..~. 5 3-~; ........_..... .._".,.... ....... n .... h".n... .
.. .54'::
_____._.~"".4......4.~_.............4."'''...h.....---'''... ..~''''' ..,. ..~. ." ,......... ._...~ .... ~.. .~ " .... ._, ...e
. 55:!
---..5~.:;.., -..... ..... ..-....".... -........
'rp. _...."........,____.~.~ :.-1.....~....,.". ,~,e,"" _,.. _"T., ..,.. ,...... ",..
: <"7; .
__"'_T4_~.~...f- ':~T' ..; ~,.T F_., U, _. ~_ _re.., .,'~ ... . .
5<6<;
__..-...,.~.......,>"......---f; ..""',....
~_~.~'..H_ ..5~ ~~. .... .
~--~.-_._. &P. ~;-...
~~.._ ... Ce.f ~: .
1.-.).. ..i.. . ..' .
.....__..>rd~., ' W
&:? ;;
. .... ..... ,..... ........ ". ....... .._". - " ......---..-,.' .....". ..... -.---."..l
,
.., - . ... .. '.... .. ..... ...... .... ...... ........,._.,,~_............ i
1
... . ...... . ... ..... .. .... .... . ..... .... ''''''''1
: \
.'~"
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commis$ioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
j
\
I
l
(
i
I
1
\
~
~
1
~
~
Ii
~
~
(
~
~
"
"
.
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
n~ighborhood grocery stqre supplies, including fresh fruits and
vege~ables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED~ .
, '
NAME ADDRESS
___~~J(__~~~2_~~~L_______~~{E__~Lt~_~~--__~_(~~L~5_~---
___~h~___~~~_____________~2f2___J2~~'~e~'_12(___C~J_~--
f!.4t.D.L.Jr::J-,,}f.iJy-~_---:- _____L&...:L~" fJ illf}.JI./hl d f~~t'...r..l-f.;,y-
_J2Jj"bge~--1iJdi.:cft:s-----#i,ll-jl&{f:I.L/i1t7/i~1T/
__ ;r~:ff___ (-\ 1{C:-!1 ~~____ __ -,~s. ___4= v_I!~::~_iLl!~_h-l!!!L4
~.....-: ?' r"
9Z''--?- ------t1-2-(LJ)JfiL~:.IJ!i.:.Erl--f!I='- Ie '
(CM~ ______s:27i2_JeuLk__J2i&d--_CifQ~~ r
_ .s~~~_3_~~"1..~________-~:?_~J___~.!_.._~~e_~~_"_!.~€<.::_'__9g.~. (~\~
_ -R4T0. -'t--~'"-tJ.t. i.: ~'-.f.C - -- - - - -.i.5:!!e. -- - h 1JL ~tI.~ Pi -T,,-1B./!.5:. - --
~ -lo0;!>k-----------d5.QlC,-k~~hj.k?~(fJL-J-~-----
_. . _ _ ____________~_____~1.Q~____.2D.J:)vk'__~_~1b---
_ _ __________!lp-L___~_J)~~z_-B-J~-C--
if ~... -. .rT i It. t\
_______________~__~_q____3_~_____~~J~jV~---~;?~ y
~.
!" I.
~
,)
'!
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
"
~..
K
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
l 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAVVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
,.
;
I,
j'
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
,
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next doo~ to the
FtNA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. .
. ADDRESS., /I {I
-- -- -m---~~~&fh!:-12~!-~-;t;f,!-/L.~-0 ,
, --~-----Lt;!~L-(QlL'?::.~-!2!.'-'-~-7V--(~~b'!.o1
iJ?6~- --tP::.<d----Qt2J2-.BJ-~lr.!L<.I?J-'-~---~~ 3 tf- b I '1
--~tz -- _..____dJ'-Q::_5:~fShgLL__1!0.:L~S:..rOfW.t'~Y/I'>r ,
t{{L :.. (i----mm.2.ri7-5!i.l..-,SiL.A.,L.Jgj)o/dty;/xy J:/t.llS i
_}._~~b-_--__--_-~J~-~~t:i_l_l.;!0~:J--~J:.--~~ell~]~/~ \ ~
-- _~~----~_--___:Fj05~-C.YJLb.f{~'=-f,-----C.L.e.f,~!:CJ.J2
~ .:!f:~~~::k'___0Xll. __ =-~q-J~~~..~~.:.L::.___-___
/1'1 ___ ~ - n 7 (.'") e;:fi.../
v,t...-c::::'""c:"'L.&'c..'\.O'l ;. 'Zc-- ?' l /t.;" 1-
-------- - - -------------------------------------------
-"[7 ! ----- -.J~~'-cb4AJ::k-h..h.--:;;fti-~--Y-l61 '7
--'t--~ /lL -- -?.d-l':fgr;,-~l4clL__ci{d1LrtZ1.--
~ _ _ ___ _ _ _L~ r.:~ _ _ F...~~ _1q~ __ (!!?:.. ___t;;(..ff.kC:. _ Jrt /'0
.......
-.l ~ " '
'"
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93~94. LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 01 vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARkET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in the area to replace the
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would destroy an existing use,
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARkET to obtain fishing-bait
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
~
,
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existIng use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vege~ables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. "
"
~r
"
;1
j
'1
i
\
"
--l 2& ADDRESS ,.-
I.. ,,' rG/~/'.. :'>>'3 /v ~ 7~c-r Y't.rg /?/ ~..-; #~.I 7
';Ix.. 7- TL-:1!-- ___L>L --___- ~-Z! -!!!!----l--- ---&1<-:;:; It 7
~-)llLl.Lt1W.kl-55--Gt--JLlJ1~ €.lct1v:i4,
fi;Jt6~_~---j:I!/d.N;@:J).QL--fkiL--J!;x:-f7.-~&61
, · 9d<LLl<.+ ~~ L~ _QD.!"Ue",LiH.9LCJ .u.Js~Jl--_,:-:S~LJ.,~ l.{
W'0-SP>1iL<t::____3Ct'l9___c..~2ep.eiK(:!--Cjw~-tiiL~-:}qf:,/q
_ --~-t4----_Jil...DU~JlLvl~t-tkL---W:ti----\CLt----
__iU~MJ_.iii11~emClti_-Jeg:B-JZia:rlflJJ)lli-m~.10--
_d~~. ~~~-~~-t_-\.(-~~~Q~.-_-h0
r:- .{) / L-r.-'.- /;.... t d--. ()"-t: W-e.~ - u( tA-v )J\ e ~ vU ~ I...( ~,t\:"
t5~~-^-- :3i~::-r--7_i5!-----r-75!j--~;;C-1_7/~D/7rkbo"l FJ..
n_____ ~-l). - , -~P--(lJJ-----Ck---n'--------...-----L9jl.:L .
.// /' . ~./. /4 1/1 /~{,#z,'.,,{. c:r _ ~ /' /'/? "d -A, ....../'/ X . /t;? ,
O~~ ~~---~~~-a42t"~~_~<.(---[d~&.cC6~(......-~ .:. V~// '
:1
~
'I
{I
~
'l
~
~
"\
~
:~
------------------------------------------------~~---------------
----------------~------------------------------------------------
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop_
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait'
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. .
I
,
I
.
\
1
I
)
,
i
I
r.
1
I
~
,
~
~
;
~
~
i
~
~
J
~
,
l
~
r2
t.,o", .
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAVVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
I
i
I
1
I
1
4
1
~
"
~
~
11
J.
'!
~
Y
.;
~
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop. .
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED_ .
NAME ADDRESS
__~~~~~___e!i~~~~_____________________________~!~___E~_________
__(2~V.:!?.[L-h~,fl-~--LO-L~Ll)J5.~PEirU.jl~-t;'J~-El8-----~---
-:LL~.LL':1'I1~{Xt_)&jL-JJlf?-LOLf:.--'-r<-.-&.s--d0f1 ~
_~~__~--L^,J~~~':::---2:c2\.l:l---0-~L'Q.\:U~~~-~~SL~k ~\
-.,L7.:{JA-::W-z.d?__- -- gMP_QJl_~:~~~_,,_~~_~~________~~_____
_:m~__~-{~1~~~--------~L~L~L:..L--3-(::!!~j~----------
&Z=.Lf~ -6 -~'-t-- --- /~ tf2.c__ e? j.L2:- ~.1_ -- -- -- --- - - - -. - -- --
-i&L~C .L__.d._ -!XLBy- ___ _~ '12.- ~_ __It.~ L[~ _;f!2 _ _ t>~*" _ LL~'YY.J2~ - - --
__~0~~~~-Y.sL---g9J~Q--(Q0-~~.>S.tJJ.- /._aL~_:= ---
~::J'i!!L _LL....-t~:. _ _ _ _ _ _ 6'_ {J~_ _~3:.<:._ (~~i'2i ~!:.~(J!;:.L 1l-- -- -- -'-
.OO~~\-~~_e.._~~JL-rl.L- ..Jll\a___~~ffi:ilL-auL----
~.dr~L---~~--0:'-(Av-J2LI... /-!.bL4!!1lY.2J2~,/~.H.J.z
77--;:?,~t-~r--~~~~/..2:.;.,;<-./.u.~...d:.&4d-7~ 1-/'7'-
\
~\.
..
~. "''': .
I'
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94-, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We bQlieve that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT DE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an eHisting use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. .
destroy another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
NAME ADDRESS
QD-~J~~)~'S:::~J.2i.~~_______lD_~~Qo:\D~\Q.Qh__l..ll_______
~19.1l'i__;ff..g~_LQJ:fl.~~_'=.~f.9gL_~_1~L_______
jfl~t1__11M'{L~E_~_____ __J_<iQ~_r;g_(L!.~~l'__~j~ct.. ~CjI~:E-~~
~-~~ - k_ _ _____ ~~.~~{1~_ __ L=~~~~~::;~~~~
.' _::,_JgP5::'~.M !~~lilj:."!!.:i9!i '-_ J-fJ.Lf)::.-:?f:if.Lf/ '
-~~h--~_,/_jjA.cf!-~t: -- -----~':.<:./L_lE -- - _tt3i_I:~r_1i ?.~_
~I~-~--------_--~?l~~-~~~~~r!~f_--___----
~.l~12 t ~ __ - _;Q 2<e._ _c;.q~_~i..~_. _ _c:. !r~r: '"Y~~!: I-E~__~~_~ ~S=
~~-~ ,. .
1- - - .!JJ-~ Hj__ __ __ 2.. yj{_ _C:.~fj1!!Qt..:.~{:!_ jZ~_ _ _ __<; ~ !.':!.'!'::'J:./13 J._ _~2~~ Y
- - _Cl.. t~--- __J_1..Q(Q_~ M!:"i1_'h. _Cl -- -- -- - --- .c:J._-!i!5'!f!.;8J...'k -3 !fl.".;! II
jQaflnI_~---lQlfci-----._------------------____-J:l_~,~__'~J--____
-i~,iJ 6i I .tSo~1 C (VJ ~ {
----------------------------------------------------------------
(
\
I
j
!
I
I
;
I
j
~
I
~
~
~
,I
J
1
~
I:
i
,:
,~
:~
"
5
;
~
i
i
--
,.t... ,
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
.,
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the abov~ REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait shOp in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
~~~~~ ~ ~Rny,~n~~n~~ qt~r~ ~t th~ FINA would d~~trov another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
~~~ ADDRESS
Wj)~______-:2i-2P-_J:jC_t1_tl~_lJZ1Y._JlfJdIJj~AQji:J2--
&d;.JiL---------Zf.L~!----~~~~--~_l/!~,-~---------
_~4.pL~-(Jd'L-'~--_----lYL-ta/tLj}~m:J./J1---IL'~~-------------
~~I---~~~f/ktf4lJM!.4-'-~----~--------
~-'f{!fi5-J;:;fkc?~(---~~2./':--~~.u..>-6':aJd.c;-~--
_~~~~~~--~~~~---~-5{-~-L-Z~----------------
~L2.J-~1r..2. __ ___J?f.ff.~~.MLa~0.? _~L :::&R,-_C&4.::~1rr€- PC ·
_ A~~t-St4\~~\i!~L---!.QtueflClOL.A1WtJ.(l"---1-.9:lt- ~~10
_~jlh<1Sf2~l-YJ-ie~Al.---- _lq~_?_51_(1~li~lLtJ1..:.----- ------
~ ~ ~. ,_ ~
~~ _ _ ~_'5"('.l~~~---- -- __l~S_~_.rl~~.l.t~ _j?JS~_t.J__:..-29fi1-bl1:p..J!.Qe.._ j:t,
/ ~/ '? ~ A . i "I (I ;J
, . .'1-f"'///) e..(}'Y -/ /" -r-.4?. ,;1,,-, -" l-::>.J~
.' r/;lv......v '-' I :!').tA..iI'~ (.."lr.- ~.~ <~ l,~..~. _. 11..,
----~-r- -~~-~-------------ry-------~-------~---------------
_.......: -It.. '-Z-~C.k CV t:. d-. . '." rJZ1~
. /~.., ./,.. _u.__... .
_ . __ _ ~ tL______.:~ L~:.L.:t..t.. ...1 -------'7-----------
1/) ,r . /! ( /,) ;;' .
f:,.t'2(:L-1Llf~d'-~}----~(l?/!{}!2-'--L1d.{2----------------
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
i
I
I
\
I
I
~
I
,
l
,
I
!
'.
.
~
1
1
J
~
i
N~M~ ~ ADDRESS I.
~/. 11.:-) /, / ;. ~ 0 0 I (j L A- g,f ti" 8 cu{r.:I=J 0 'I (1 tl.... ), 1-;--, l xl ~.J 6 /' c~
~r::( - 1 (!~~-~-::~L---7"~f!; --'-7T(r;;;;;;0~~~:r'trt<V 1M 7 7!
~ ~----- ~~~~~~__~l_______l~L~____________~~___~__ .
-~u:._ __~~&;'~_R<L.~3_t~~:1~~_'!.~_c.!.~~~!k.~('__~=-CP-d?_~_ ;
-4 ' ,C,-i1"J~~~('_:A.~2-S__&<!L\::1.R.iL~J~~L!!.lS:19:__~~3L~9__ '
/ ~ lL~l~QJLt".__ /J2..::-~~!l':.<:E$r;:Ls._!!.(;L_~!h::;T------
--t -' L'-' ./ ~c-
:7 _~_C__~j~ ~~______.LX?.L___~6j_1'k2.<?Le--1- ,h,4 '} ""
/JII""'/ (-- :-.':. . /,,/ ./
_ ~~~~ __ ~~~______~~c~lY~~J~__________________ '
~~-)~ ---~----------------------------------------
_' '~~L~Z~\9_;'_(2dth'~J::::';:j-______________
_ ___~Ih:W::i:':~~______lbJ~i.@!:r!-!!!!)J:lLJ&L_r;,__________
1-k~---~~*7J-j_':'~~~_5-~~~"-:rL-_9J-~- J:.:______________
,"/,1 t-'~ <.: J -I ~ ,l-'- Ii ~ I .~_/
--I-)4Jutft---" - ~---_1.r;(:..-_->'L-I/3.j.J()f..c:J{J2a::L-LJD----
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition 01 a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
stare and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our,use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an eKisting use,
to obtain fishing-bait
A~~R\ R ~Rny,~n~~n~~ ~iAr~ Ri th~ FINA would dS6troy another
eKisting use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
.~. .. '..
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners. City of Clearwater. Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94. LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, SOB Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
A~~R~ A ~Rnv.~n~~nF~ qt~r~ Rt th~ FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
d~strQY another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
I
.
,
~
)
f
;
t
1
~
A E /7/ /) , ADDRESS
(fif--K.-,-j~ C-: _________3JjD.tL_Ck_'*-_yj.:._fle.q~drL'_~~_(~ ~1? /<1
--- -~..: ______32:B__~\J_z~<&\::.I\...A~L__Qll_f_.L3StJbI J
~' -.J. ----_____d2.(L~Cj_ku..f:...I!._Ub:y__c'i~~_FJ__f.<:tt.~Lcr- f
, '~f.,:. 'e~-- 1-12 ,_________d2Z_~1:!:..e'i..r:0:L;:.v.LS..!'..A;--Lc:;./.:L_+-10~ J~I" c /7!
- t.__ ~--------- ___L12.1_:::'Q _~~-+,-Pl- i:!.CJ__ -~~.!'.:.fP-- _"{ ~.t!J j
.;.J:Y.YJ__:1ztIJL~i~ __________!2Y-~_ __ 0!.J._11(}~_e_ __.[C1~.e~L-_} J!:!2 :
&( _~~~ ~_~~'_I_ ___ ___ !LtJ }:?~ _~~'_ ~_~~~~ _~!-~ :~_f!:1_€- t.:~~~c~.}fVb:?;
~Q ~~~fd,~~'f~l _____________~~~~~~~?~____L~~~~r~_______________
v r I) // " y;,' /J 10 ~~'"
, ,):r. ':::.L.~~-------4-t{s..-'i"-~-'f1.G."'2.~~4-:!..t;;J../L--/J.:!:f~------=:'-!7.-
~4 _.!-J~f.~l______!Q..L!.2:i~.Y.1!{j~,,-~~__------f:f-~?-l---
aw:!.~--f1!.~r:_)JIa- --- -- - -Z.R_kL-~ ~~W _jj____~ 2~i. -- ___
~J~)~J__l1j~;~----_- _:?_~_~_~_.:__9_:___S_q~fU!_~.cLd_.Qg~N~ _'t;Yttl7h
Wi-~kt{1-_ __(bQ '[I].yj~!:___ __ __ LY_l__ tn.IJ.h.Lr:kL'2JL._!.l!(~~ -~I:YJ4-?)--
i
~
l
i
~ ..
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commi5sione~s, City ot Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z Q3-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers ot the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA . station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town ot 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing~bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
I
,
I
(
i
I
I
I
I
(
!
Rl~R\ A ~Rn~~n~~n~~ ~~Qr~ A~ th~ F1NA would d~GtrQY another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, inCluding fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ADDRESS
-~___~_____________l'J1~~_~~l~c__:{~~~:_~_________
~ L (j-\~-; -~- $r'.[I/,.'
. ~ t ~f "'?' ", ~ -a"'-
..:- - --.:__ ____________ _ :.e'O;~~~J..~ . ~L":'_' ~_-_~________
-7~"", '1',,/' -?/tuk/~ /j /1...",.;/4:\ .<<? '7../,..;. /~, .
"LUc..'-&,~ - ./-~----- --------- --- -<=Zt.~- - - ---;rr::t..'~c~-<.:r.u. _.. - --~ ----
-~Q~~_~_ltl0J~~~-~-------i:L~~~~~~~--~~?---!JC~!..~:-------- l
__;a:42~c.?4r_~~~_______d~et--':;2.d-__Z:~__~1~~LE__~~~L.eld Q p~ ~
r~\\. "GLQ. /l/)(x CfuU_ (-J Q Clv""\J.,.\r) 1 el~ J'-:'j 0 :~.,l.j (0 (tf'
-~ ~--_____:::t..~__ljT_________~_ ___-_____J__ -s- - ____~J----
--- --tv;1~dL= -- -- - --- J~Jr~'_iJMcit ~ i - - t-:. L_ _:;.:j.Et/J_ - --
~/~----~----------------~J.1~,~J?4--C:C~~-----~----------
-..#!1t:f.::~2:Sff4'~'1-------- ___(!(~.q~q;.fJ_1.-J(.':..(~.:__ fr:-i.:. _ _ ..~Y.. "_ ~ c~ J
.k' L ~ 47..~~;~" ., /J OJ/" 'I r , j ~ ('"';0 /. / 94
/l/tc,- ) r. ~l ,,') "Ci I )(tI~J(lt,,-.:r.t''t,c/C/... ~. C./lft'.
---~2"- '--- Z---------..I-------~----------- -----::1-0.- ./ ::.t..
L/'"I ,.. ~ ..--. ;...- '. ") (.-~2 <'..'/~ J/.4! r-'" ~?,.A1
. '" . ? ./ (_.>( . ' ...;.,-1......- .. ."., . }
..;-~_t:::;..,:;- ~/::t'.d::t..._____....----- 1-------.......-.......-l--~-'7l,.r----~-
. /1 d ..
..- _ -:?p " 1 '(1" 'H,\ ) "... "~I (' ., .//"",/ 1'"'11'0'
__~tJ_~_J~~ __~________~_2~c__J~J~_.______________________
-u;:; .....
____~~L~0~~0~C~~__~:_-__________________________________
PETITION
too M.:lyor G.:~I~vey'131 City Cr)HHn.i.G!',;ionllt-!3~ Ci.ty nf L'Jul.\n'ktf.~,II"~ F.1ny-ldd
"
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT 'and RtzoNrNG REQUEs'r
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
LDts 1 C\nd :2, Block .:;:, ,'~nd J./:';~ 01" VI:\l:i.:-.tr;!c.1 ~Jt:n:1I?l
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501' BayvimoJ Avc}nul.? ~ ~.i08 Mf:~,;II:Ir:H'" 1 a 1"1<. Li~nC?
We petition you to VOTE to DENY thf.;! above FiCOUnn.
We are custome....s of thj;~ CLEf-1F<ltJATI2:F< FOOD l'lARI<I.::T, Ill?)( t doot~ to thl?
FINA station. We !..H?lil?vP the.\t thl,", <~ddition (rf B CONVENI~NCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET~ which
serves .::.s the Historic Town r:)"t' Bi.\yvie~oJ'~; neighborhood groc:ery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no othel' f:i.~'illino-'br.\i t ~..tlt1p.in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the ~r~~ to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Pll so, a conven :u?nCf~ !'-:i \.01" (:.' 'i;1 t 1.I'11'.' r~'l 1"1(.\ ,..m1.11 rI destroy another
e~isting use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACEO.
[~ {.iDDHES~; ~ ~ t
_ .J~. >:.- '~_~:~~~~q~~:~~~~~~~c~
_~m.: ... .~;; tf.d~~liit.'<;<<l?~--~:----
~7t~a'&../ -... 6/c -2... _0~.bA.. 4fl-f-V~ '
_--~.../ c.~-.(~~..~tL_-
. ."4~_(.__._ .. _nO. ./1/1 ,,~~ d&.1/fv.e- -c (g,;.c-h-
.... -.- .. . .. . J.-2;?Y/?:;c>:-.5& (;(--- SZ:-::2~1f:-/7
. .----- .-.- ~W c~~f0.g~t1&f
. .._OL ._ _, '~~c&~(~:'L.. ... ..~X~~2M..C.hQ:~IO"/:RCLtJ.t._,sf~ .....q~~J-!- L
Jl.ill - u..--i- C:6\1.fuQ.. -\\LoO~ .t\'C..\=-">l.Q..\N~I3:-~ . \\-.
J~~~~))\...:~~'~~j;~1:;~~~~~
NAME
~H.
,
_u6....
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey Sf City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94~ LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Dayview Avenue, ~08 Meadowlark Lane
We peti ticn you to VOTE to DENY the ahove r~EQl.JEST.
We are customers of the CLEARliJATER FOOD r1AHI<ET ~ n1?:< t door to the
FINA station. We believe th",t the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood.grocery
store and OUr neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is.no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including -fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
N~ME ADDRESS
__ _tJ.b_e..!...l__.&tJJ>_~_____._. __._ _ _ .__ J:J..f.:~.._~_~sA~J?_- _L"-.._!tOLJ1/- _g..:_~ f.{~C:; 6
__B~~..__. -~_. -._.____._10_LL_~1{!t:tk _UdQL:t:L_'Ur::.J3:L_~ tq
-_.]~M-,/-,._PP.<ri~-tI:b'- --3_!Qj~,.i(~~.f\Y-~-,-A(?-'L.:3~-1A...J s'"I~!l
':fl~~C~(r-"-J.~;:~i~;~,~,~~~~~.t'~'3~~ I ~
:~:~~~~~~~~:--'~~J~Ij~~~~~9~~i;]~P.L:3!I69S-
.~&.~~!.~_~~__...aL~_L~.~~_s-___-:8__"~-f2-d.-c:.12-
__Em..(}lL~_ ._._.~gl.~~(}.~.__._._.~Cj.~Q___S:B:~{dr;g,l~f?_~_1.~
_' bff4::n ~.4Ir-.!:-C~S~';}."H':-~iL~~_..tJt;~------ ---..
. n n. h~(J{.~~.mnn.~._- Jo_--.T~YUt\le~ . ---..~.
~_,.. . --Q6-0....-.~.~L'1:J.t.nb+-_._~___.S-_.~ . !
H'" ....._ .. .~_...__~.).~..r....__.~~een~_kA('d._.f\U2:._ro SJ p~
- ......n'SS,,~..:Y~~-\a~-~OR.~ ~
;'
PETITION
to 11ayor Garvey I!( CJty COITlIll,i(i;~,j:irJrH'1r-!:;;~ C.1.Ly of Cleal"'watc~r~ Flol-Jdi.\
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94~ LUP 93-q3
Lots 1 and 2, Bloc]': :: and 1/2 or vdcat.ucJ !:,ill"wo-t
Mcl'lULLEN ElAYVIEW SUBDIV!STON
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 M8ddowla~k Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the ahov!".' REUlJEST.
We are customer-s of the> CLEAFMATEr~ r:.OOD l'1AI:-':V:ET, nt?::t door to th~
FINA station. l'-!e believe? that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
Th~re is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MAR~ET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
(-\ODHESS
_~~ U\.;_W~\_t~()~\~__.Q_~!.!::L~..:-~~~)ll(2,~~_~9(} .
~t...l.~...._..~c.:~Jl).~-~_~~~~lQ..~L\@_~~ 0J .
_ j~_~_q.~_~~2<O_.__T~l'>lqt~Ll~t~LQIL-&
._._ _ '_P__~.._._.!_b~L,:\_,_.____~_L6~_~_~._~._.._~.t M
.. · vD-.---.~9.-~.\.---G...lV&M.a~.-~~-~ ~ ~
~ ......... _ ~--,-B..~.Oh.. _.:\l:~~~L_;?f:~.N.~__6 /- 9~
.r.\'- .. r.m._V:M_eL_:'~~~I~----~-lo.:.:2b---JJ:j^J9~--~--~ .~~
,~ _ __ _ _ . --\1U~,~---\t\..__._.._~~-~.,^_."J-------~-- I- t -~
}?t::r~-~&-- -, - ---~-l.-------h?~!-ecO~t-~ll-"~~ //.
--V.~AfC---:-- - OtH------ ---.------L?.5.A;-?h~rZZd--cc-..----ittflf"'r
____iJl.lll.Ar:J__ ,_ _.. HIIL.-....- _ _... .....~"--_dq.ltj__.:..Kel.-e~-"_- ---.. __. fY\ t:ft'(;~
-JtrJ..- JJ14j{ly;t1._ .-... -- -- --.' .... 'm_ ..- -_.~ ..M {J(I1~-et,.... --() !c/2tJ~
~~g.-..Lhwur1~..... ...-91--- __w/~d~~4!..(!i-.t?/~
~,~
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City CommissiDners~ City oi' Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA. station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKE"r. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ADDRESS
J.~~_1~~~~'~_____ _J.?~Z.if _L~:!:!:!.~~.~~.:::J._r;::-':.~!f_~~~r..J.____,3_y'!:-_7_L-
. ","~~fLJ~Yl4-4..IT~___ 2L~_z'L.12/Q~11y'I;.L _JA'kt{2d____ ,__~~}_0.:..1. ~____
- ~~~.:t-L- _"j~I"Q~~8.~~-C;;r~'".--.(~~ :!-::r-.cL~.!,J:L-:s ,,(.L~I
/i1!..&:._--C_A!:~- - -- - _ _ _. _Js:.~ I. ___. _..__~r:.t{.r:lr:(S;.t::. _ .Oth .f!j~U 1_ _'.l:7.l'CCt,0 _~/.:!_ 2t:& L( (
~b,"","'" ..r-:I~i~~ ?A~ C.4USe'IV4-/ IlJfIIl j) ,Ir:-'^ r,d 3fJ408
- p:i;-I'I~~-~~-4: JJ?=d._.L.pa.~_.__.a.J._.._-.-:.Y-J'.p:.r._e~4::..__. _~.#'~,t.2.UL..c:_--",,~. r:., .
\~l-,$( : _' /1..," __J2"'lQi._~I.L?t-dA.~A<<;-'f~tjJ.!:2C-ct~'-L:::J21:-)( kl (
--J).ft-",,-,=,(j.!c-t4~-- ___A;ii!:L___~<,:~_jLdj__1.ffL{n,.~J;~L.l:.::~ ,) 'f 6 1'1'
-~l..JIZ~}JlJ?t;/d--_@.r.:-x$L'!L.Aj1:,.t,~Qd!!::Wd:?fC__;:dO I J.
~d4tftlff~-t:(f:Z:-- --!-3!i~ -'""-'~[~;;!:?JiL~-'t6Ic;'
_41;/~/ / r,:{(.._.-_ C____.._ ._-_.tf(- _:{}f!I}~~___.;;!J:: _..itXL:-_~_0.~:L.~_)ft.!:d I~
7),1-:1/' "p!!" ?-- ,.I(~'f t&~t7JJL~r?J5;;-xJl~' CL~~J17t f1' h./~k~
t- ...~" .:r-_ ,- _. -- - - _..- - -. _ _' _ _ - ,_. -- - -. -- - --- - - _.- - _ - _._ -- -- --.- - -- - - - - - - - ~ - - - --
dJ'..--""-
,. . C /> :.:tf.. L .
.._ -_~ ;t,...- _.k~~.~~~r__.__.._._.J3.?:LI._6_ILLF--,:i!}_'._~1.~v.__!LJ.:;"!dQ.!3.._----------
- P/ {[> - -- d L ; 1 '?'&;' C
:C(~~y.~..~~:-::-:. ,____ .__ ~_. :5Lk.J ~ q~!~9Q._ _ .J.\L.._ _ ___H.C _{gf:~~.lr",~_~~_._ ~ _(Q L.t._
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City ot CleArwRter, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94. LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue~ 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
,..
I
I
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, neMt door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD .MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop_
I
I
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MAR~ET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
AIso~ a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ADDRESS
~~.0.! 2e__~l-_&~;~~__..5-:?22~=tfi~~.!~Lr;!_dd7-~d.;z_~41/4:~'" co
. P:tc~ ~L/ he ~_.. -I ,.' .:.1../ #' .:;.1 t;/l
. - . . ~..2~~~::.:.__..._r:.l!J~s.:_..IJ!1!#t!..~-:I~.k..)K_s:..:..'_/~._~_______
- _.-,J')ir.,Ij~~--._-.21.Q--~<{',*,jL-'S.J5.:Lr-J.k,:l'''-t:L~_:?!./L
.ftr.-J:.tLJ&1i.~~t!i~:J,t::-.b.__... ---22-7L2--- /2CJ.v~~(VP.cd_...5.~____C_!!.tIJ{~Zi2?..)~
A} (/ tJ .I-: r. ~ J:;.' f I f
-~_~'FLJL.- .-- _.__.l. :t....-'J _..k!'ts.lt's:.;r__JL.____iE.ir.. r'..j:>;;A~~ c: '..
JJt.i.1!l~ ;-I:::'1!!L.-c::"-". - ... -- .-. ..sa <f. .ft _ _G.t.~\S.S):. \. ~-Q~--- - -. ._T~~j-t .9..:c\_~i'.c!)i J:L;> :; 'I c; ~
~._.E..tf7-- _~~k::~. -' ._.:......._.,j~j_~"~:__o...~&...IJ_)-;;...~_:_ t1l_ -.. ._.ZL"t~?L-f<.,....-__:..a.....~ ~?" / I
___ ..14- ~~-_._~---'i 2f.:.. .Y.._....5./!._"'.~::.~ / .__.__~~l,;:~::~ __cl,-.[!~_ ~Ur
.J.' .. . )VII. 1/' I. /J J I I -
"'_ ;~t..{.~i--'::.<-J.};:fJy:.~. ..._ .0__'_.'. . ..( ~/.;.2..&~.I;!1l. !..1.-?{.u.c..lrz:((j,!:{~,- _._"__ _._ _______.___
.:..j.r:r/::Yl.__.? C!..d~I 1-:lf.. ...... _ __ .no 2._~!_'l~~___..L:)~(j:.tL...:/j c _It.1L.{./.tLsL ..__.._t; j-Lv/.::..3.fI cl I<i
\~~~~'...t;'.._._~~~.~~4-.. ;"'.--..--... ....~.~!t..__i3~.~~.0::.:~~~~.~~2.- ._~ \~::S.':l..~l.!.>~'L.:3~~_.__~~(J \ ('\
Ci'~S,~ - Y'1' ) ". ... - "7 IJ J::'~ t-". C~A-' 0 <;.... ) 5 1-; f=-t I
. /.... I ,".) ~ \ .- , < j l- .
.- ~. .-{4...- - c. -t...:~~~ ' . -.-.......-...--..... ....~...,;,. -~_.... . ........ ...oJ -;;;Cfl---..._'i..~ "..... ..c...:::-:__.._.!......__J l
1...> --, (t-; &l{;; /,.:~ /" "'.',7':''; )/.)..../.
c~.. , ,'.- ~-:._.- ~\-~':'~ _J:.!(!.~.(2.-,-- ........ .__..~~~J:.:.r::~~(:...__(~:.(~:;-)<__. _~_.::-~~_._!_L__:.. -. --"__
."
I,
'1->...
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners. City of C18arwater, Florida
, "
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBUIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET~ newt door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience storm at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAt<l- ~ s€= ADDRESS
'-- ~~ ')') 0 '7 C v-L fr-- 7U ;j ;Z"2'-(Yc_
-. . 0--- --,,--- -____,,----_C,_________._______._____ ~~_~-_ ____
- __1~__._ ~--~-------_.----.-.-.--.fb---CUL~-M--.~--.E~~
...--..- -' - -".--./ 1.312()~-~,.~J!,.-~~~~~.__~q.r.s.4-._ __._._
-~t;.---37,:>$~r------.--~'!!~--~~~4~L'>.".:!:::-"""-g~~"i>(:j~1:'
~~_..-....,~.l-lf!..--llctJ..~~t~IY1--$!L.-.J:J:~~---
~ . ----~~----~'ftt9.-~LIf?.:tL61J_J3I<<d.-J:r_!Ps:-
-' ~..Z227 .. - ~-..--.--.-....~OS:..".~~J..0&_~--.c..\~,
-- ...---. -~.:&..._.-. !1<!52Z!2g9__l-l1J~a!Y.dQW-Ji!l (1{._.IN.__:?1.~__~/~ F'/
,- . ~J-l.tlt[~ -.... ".........-...,.... .__l.fOO.I__1t~.~~._~_...:ti!.~.~_._.__...._._..__...._... ...._ __'_'_"
- "--.----"-.." .~0(,-g:,:;~G~-~-~- _H_ -.
_ -. -.- .4!;;/I:::::-:~:.....j31iJ~~~:i;;;f~::~
. :IX;l",hiAI\c-~~ ~ .. .. Hj C() :SG:llfl\1o .\t.J ,,-ic..()" J~ \ uC\ h'. __ __
{
. I
t.
~ '.' ~ '
PETITION
to Mayol- Garvey I!~ Ci ty Commissionen5, Ci ty Of~'\:~tr.?r. ~
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT an d RE Z ON I NG... Rr:G1UEST
Z 97.-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Blpck 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
Florida
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET~ newt door to the
FINA station. We believe. that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET~ which
~erv~s as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
AIso~ ~ con~enience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ADDRESS .
~.!?E-__.A~,,-<JgLd!r___ __..__ _..__ __lt1.9____,1{C_~~L~L_?_l(.'~!,~. 'II r L,
~__ _.._ ~_._______.~_.~-..J\1J~\.QC'<1~Lht-~.-.0uJ\v
.~ . _. _ ....___.~ ",_'_'" ..n__.___.~_~_Q_~.____J~!:':~ __!!.1l~ __ _. _~._._
. .C~_ ___~~..._......___j(~~.~ .__ Lt!:.~!:5::.--!2~:..__.__~{~. f.l;lll; {t..
- .. __:::__..__.~_ _'H _. .... ...... ........... _._~0.(S=_ Jl1Ltt-.:;llJrnt?lC_____..__
. __ . '~'_ ~_ ... .... .-.-___,.._._.____.....__~~_~5~.~Q~_Lqk:.K.J.:~~!?_'C_._~L.eg~VC~t't;/ P L
t' ! ') ';J, ifJ .--' f _..' -? ' ...-- r-;;.........
/.l,f/j!( c0.~:.-C--..-. ......_ ...._!!:J..':~.~.( ._~y_~;;~_~{jSJ5.L<:;L.cc;'_._.;:~?S?()
{JmtM#L{Pd;....---.....52~2..j?lJ.c1JUJc.;cjJa.e..-c1LLlMJI/j-~/0
. __ _ . _.. _ _...::3:0... ..N.. f~ ~ ;'.f\ (j b!.\!.' .~~ JS.c&f5
_::W'__',~'~'" Il f I
. :... . \ c ..~..~ ,.r::. (glee. ..AYet1.(..eijrrF ui'cd-4?.
_ ." ..:... _.".....w..... ........,. ..L2......... .._.... . __._.__._..,~...._._ _..___._._... _..._.__. _._._....._....__._._.~
~1~_D~:1 ~.f1: I.. ...m T. nn... J:3~ ~I.. ~ ~ ~".! ~~! .~':' ~f. .S! 'c-~ .~:.~.~,_" :.~~ :.L.....E ~ ..~ <I" I "
yB:1~~:~~~J.. ....f~tr~t:) {t":~!_tijiud/..lJIt..J.,...CI.::..__.EL.._~~~al
{... J
I.
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAVVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, SOB Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Al~A~ R ~An~~n~~n~~ q~~r~ ~t th~ FINA would daatrQV another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
I
i
i
,I
1
. {
NAM . y../ I' ~ ADDRESS ...,
_ rULl:Xo.r.,.4:!{ - -_-<2.:QL~.!-q{-.~fflff-- ---- i~eof&j..Y..4-.Q.::!-,_tr__
- _ . ___J~=_..:~!!!1QJlL:i.I__J][L_______~Sflfll!:f_ll~!!-~_
Ii 'J
Cd'. 1f.J:!:.rJ~_ f?i'!!:.~L-J.!:.Z-.}g0.f5J~1?~~'"lll~ P:.:.. -7?7~~~lq-----------
~ . . ~., .., ~ ~:' '-Z-_.- ~ .. ./:)... /[, .,1
it" J.e . '/ /. .:It.... ..;~. t. .X.-f.(:. "-~ /().'.cx L ~ ,., I /<-./ \..
.t!f --2-_ ~____fi kJ~'J..--.-- - --- __cd. "'-C--r~7--".J/7T ---4-,:-- ---- ---
'l I ~ J~",? /.?"'" l/J.~ /1 04 (I"
/.&:'-.u:.j,L'If::S,-!?~~t:::~~ ~_-_ ~-::.~ 7-",-~"'I:J:!-Y-'!::'~? ':'c.-" ___L!:.:.LA..:_ ____
" ~J~~I i..t/,1~-,~ l' <( L \ - v'\ 0...;",.. l(-T-1 / ..1.'/)/f / 1?... '"l .;.:.,
:=I~(~~l:ii~!-/ ~.1.__~_ _______.L~____-,__,---'-.-- J'-.....-~----7---
CJ ~:-!.:,'")_:,~, ~ .~? __.l2.1J\q~-:~~J~J:!:~___Ql~,-__~_ __ ___
~ ~ r U .1..... (j)
/"1 / 1/ (1 .--.. IJ -(". - ?
-9L~J'::' ,~L " --_~X~~f!2dtlL'1-i3fJ~'!.~['--~~~-_L_~ -~-~----
i~~~"'.....~ ? C k.7 //'" 1.,.,\ .",,'L/.) .'J.~. ~_.",.,"/ L-:1f (/>:: 'j>
L.J...~_ ~..>.: _'__L ~ .;.,__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ --1"_ Z ..:lo;.;J../-,,-,'_ .:.. __ ~-.,;;..'rZ'" \.. _ ':.f:""..! __ _'_ __ _ _-.;.. J;:.. _ _ -_
... V' .,'~"') ~/ " 4 "\
__ _f2;:' ~i:L2':{~Q~_1z_rJ..~~~l_ef~::'~_~~T-=-_~~:~_L~~_-:?~!!:?~_C;:.
~~ / .4 ...
/ ",,'. /),,? r.'1 .., /..' 1."/ .. r'";1 ~ " " '7
_ __ ,.' / I. I) .J'j I. / J ,:, ...,/ I - .{..I"y .::J ~).:;... (~I' ".t.o, ' ...l ,(.1.,',./ ;.-
.... ;u:::l~~, ~01:-W~~;~---;;-~;C~9~~';;:-7c~;;:?t~1%~, :~J~~~t.~-:-,;/l
. //Z~.. ',' /.. ~ c L~ _ I( .-'/ YO. .._ ,_ /
z:--.- ....- ---- -' - ------------o;.::'--------------.~,.l,o. --....- --
,=-~-~~--Ii:tiM < < r.~~t.-~--f:l~~!.1:"~?~L1.~~c(~/-4%:.:.:2~~!'9
/~' ,. Y -... ---'r-- ,I, - .,"~ '"" , ,..---..' /7..... ;;t-
/ /" .. ............. ~i . / ) L / / J_~ ~ c
(~ -" 0 ~'. ,~'-7/}t~/t((( r:.2~ /-5 /)f/-~/?J!...{I."/ 1 /:(If!lII(//f;..('E-tI,c; I't
./ 7 '9'9 - 3 StJ-c" :9>~-J 6/ 9
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z.93-94, LUP 93-43 .
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
I
I
I
I
I
i
1
i
i
\
!
A~~R\ A ~Rn~~n~~n~~ qt~r~ At th~ FINA would deatroy another 1
(
eMisting use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain ~
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and ~
vegetables:?WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. !
C~-~~---.~--~:~~~~?-:?~~--!!:2~~/-LJtI/!f/:=-~ i
). a7l:Ji:tr'----L-!;,;:~~~-:;.,';-~~;;;:~~~.i5~~~~;~=.-@~~~~' , . !
- ~-~~:-'~~;;--------L~------------------~?---~-----4------~ /1
-):f; ~ _L~C'&.".?:~~~_ --LC2LG:.2Ud.:!1!U.i-_-____J-e_Cfdl-:t:t(..!:6'.::t~~~b r-
~/ . {Y' , . . I I
/-- ~t!2~ ,..: -?/)~, , If'" , f? /!e ,. . ~..L.../ ~r) 17
.-- ::;r:...8:l.t---""~:..-:.:..L:... ~..k~_ - - - --- -- -- - -- - --- - ------ ~:!_'A:t~J.cdd..e._!:: -t- ~a../
?5-( . t/ -)
(:: J2:~:.~ -_ - J-tc;;~~..:~.---~Z'~~~ .c€..!:;~!.!~(:'Y~~:._ __ __~t.'~i::.~L:~_CZ~,
. - I ~ ~
.~/! !jtl~-~-r;L?ktt~~- ~~t~lQ~~hcl~~~;-lUL1-,;7-- ~1J.;.lli1---'jl~1- ill1fJ? ( 9
~ ~'t?~ t/. ..,- (.' /' <. -' // ,,/ ~ U"..; /c;
~r!:fp-TI- ---... ~__..:.7':_ ~2'2~ddf.:.::-:..CL~ttYL--c:.z;a~__:..LL .LeL.:::~_
!lB~:.L{l~~ . -J3.i.6.- _l~(J!.j'.P.!'__ U.1!Lfb::.~~V!j___ fiU:'<:.'L_d!!.!: ,'r
--~ro~-CU~~~-!J;Lt2-~,~~9~~L~C~~-~-'!l-~C:-3.1S-----
-4!itJ.l(:kl.-'i. --d..i!)LI.~ jjd,1zz-L_~:~s71f=J._.c!.LlL.E-L 2/1:;:,; "
-fl1. )~>r)~.1I-J{~'t---j~-~~,~~~~ur1:-1!1--1'L[(.--rt---~-;.-
_\ :~A}:1.!.. _ ~ _ (,-_ _ J.tl{JJ,c...:- ~-_ ~ _..:uL:-I- _ _ _ d 3::\!: _i~::"'1 i.X..L _'L _:!L _ _ _,~ _ -:!~,~_ _ _ ~ ~:I1
"X;:/J' ~'--IJ')" ~ J' ~ 7 ,~. L. ) tJ't_ ~ ) P /21 (:..' L \
" ~(.4>. I (,,.\., t >\{.',r- II"
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other .fishing-ba~t shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an eMisting use,
to obtain fiShing-bait
f~
(-/
I';,
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAVVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
A~~R\ R ~Rn~~n~~n~~ qtqr~ Rt th~ FJNA would de6tray anothar
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME I .-? AD~SS . '/ -;y . '
,--f-d2f'cCt---g__dtlL/..~_-_-',1a.-.l--::kd4jELC'~-..M4C?------'Z".b.? /-G
~o.ch--t\..J,=/iQ{ G.::",__~______ :L'f:!~~__L L-:::'_ !H~_",SQ.~__ '1/- R1.-
I5IY13/Jdib--~J-!1-----__---I!J2l._.L-8!!:..~Z;j}j:/2r;:fi._~ {~ !
-(~!.f.:~l1.~"J:-';<ULW .Y.l-l-------- _2,]':/L-.zgn.<;l&.._h!P~iiiCf'.f..Lw!J-~';(' fl flcy :
-. - --~~J~+~:p~r-----1I~L~.=:L~I~;lJ~gQLC~-~cl h, :
1~. - - ..G7-t- (g-:tt.;J-~&~" ----~9-2~--{]lflt---Q-C\fiL---1-){vd-
~~ J ,{ .---.. ~ ~"
, " 'V /}' . <' ,. '0." v" ,
- ;?2 '- . ~~ -_-- .:.:___~~L_..I..(U..tt~.z'2~~- _c.d___ ~.c...___
~'" ,.J' ,''-/ " .,~ G l' I
~ h.--T ~.... ......"". r? _ .' ~..
, 'I, 4~c~ ~,,, ~ --; . ;/.'""~' '" 'tJ c:~..~..., -c?o~ / /';1-?~
---.: o!J:e:. / ~'I12-&.----------Ir.~-Ja(Jif-/f~edd!L1~~L&.4J/f -,
.-I4::~~='~------___-__2CZa2._--0?:~.!~-LQ--k,-?~14--
~L J _p/~,.PJ 1. "7') "I') ~._. ~.. -"
_7:Ct~1e._1~_'~4~_____________L(;'~.!:!?){_c.~?[t.___(~ti@J[~~_t-?f~//
/J;",,-~~&:~"3ce:. --- - - --.. ___o...L geL.!!./.... -1!1aJ..I-.l-V..;&._..1..'l UJ
~ . \ ~ ,
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, .Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petitiQn you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an e~isting use.
to obtain fishing-bait
A~~R~ A FRn~~n~~nF~ ~tQr~ ~t th~ -FINA would
eKisting use. our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies. including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
destroy another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
NAME, ADDRESS ~
...Jak~J--~~\Ir.f'+____JD.:!?_..GtffL~~~__2~pg;e_ H., r .
~--.q~T4:.--LL~fL2.~-2J-".=;~~_'l-.e-~~.-I~
, --Lf;lli~~L::"',"-_';:IJ..if.!,t~-=::::::::L.-'11j:u'::~dhll.:'2--.!.'1. B...!-A=,,(;~(g.~~. -/, I
-.tflc~'t:!:!:!:~-::-::..~--_ ______ll~f!~__ Jz.~':~ _f/.:: ;.~B.v.!f~_./!.i:~-= ___ I
~ 1 . I
_'d~_ W\;g_ ~~-- - I ..::----fl~Ct.--.A1c:..a{f.a..f:!.r:--Tf;1:J,.---a/~ :r-'i "
. .~.... ~. / 2- " Y / If (. ,~;tJ --r c) 1-:;;;:2 L /.p-
-- -4!_ ~ -- -----------~-----;Z~----:LjT----~-~- --- ,
_i1.!4#I-,.:- ' W&.~-- - --- ~.PsJ2-_--E'f2I.-tPC-z2'c:.e::H:'Z(q
J(lJ!I1t!.~--- . Ydt______,;j9E.!!..J!1.r~1"q~f_~qL_~~_1!.~~!:l:.C~2_'1"'/C;
-crs~- jf~~-~-=~--l1(l!.:.- ~.ud.t J~_ ~~-::---.::;---- --- - ---- I
--~J~d_-- LJ..Clh_ -~- ~czf_ --bJ.1-U _m ~Ll..o-_.l1_~.aQ__CL~lvrX~
:::J:ff~:ff::C_=~~S:=-'-'=i!-----------~-S.ls--'i~:l=ot\.L~'l'-~L~dL~J ~Q~
_~~~t;J~~~_____________!!~:J__~~__~~1~_(~____________ ~ ~
rlg"t.;:!:LcJJ:.1:h':!!k:l--------k-.j2----.L-4..!J!!...-f.!.J~.-___
,.:.....,
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of.Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of. the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an eMisting use,
to obtain fishing-bait
A~~~\ R ~~nv~n~~n~~ qt~r~ Rt th~ FINA would dastroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
~ME ADDRESS
-3::~-..t-r- f\_'tt~lL__:!.___~~~\.~_~~_~_~~_~l~~'.:-~~fL D.J I:
r41~~- . 7::._~~___0___tk(!!.J~_::..__':!::.Y~..:~~__JI-/1T.rt 5,;;?"
l~~ .'~.1~{f~__m__?:.t..::L_{L<LG_':!../)~~?f~fL_ 52-771 !
--=pJg.AIJ....."s'-'):-.1.L-ltk9:::1.';)_ ___..a.q.e,:L::._::L1.tl..1"ijJ::!Lut.'-^.D.L ~(. ~J~. I. 3</;;'19 I
.~ ~ ~/J - 2 q 2/ 01' ~ C ,C ~.o_. J [j/J} ,/) "?tf/.)o \
--/~--~ - -- --- ----- _1.~_____!~.N..___ L"li<.LS-__.J.5.J..J.C-._ _J/ Tf\ :> T~ ;
. , I
~~~..-'_~....~------____~~~9_~_\~_:..~~~IM-!~~<1~ _l_;;3.sgl}- 3
~'-~::lQj...Q.fZ~~~i_______,~t~\.!JSL__~live._&LS1_ 2!?.iJi-._lJ '3370 S-.
t.~~~~1~~!- IT~~_____?~-~~-i3.___S.~~_&~_~.J-~'~-:_+~~~::5:-~ . 3 s'-( Q \.
z;::dketJ2:~ ~~~ 1;:{Q __ -.Z,)_i t-.-._ !}t.~(2i~t{-:.( ~:5~~--0.~(-71 ~~~6 3)Z-
, ~~4 -
-_f;f!;;<6';dl!.~f::-___- _LZE2__L.'kLl..JLiir:'"J.JJE~.!....s._./LJ;;;f c---:;' /- ~
--'-~--;:;1.t&=-::------ L~.;l:'71.&!:/1::!-:::.!''::''~LQL{!!:::J~ 5<7 (.) s I
_~'11..~~-__ __ ______Lf!. ___i:di~_ ~~(.r;_ _It.::-~ -(~e-::__?i~_ /)~
. -->-. ~ . r-- - ' f.'. /.? J
- :. :--&---'~~-.::::.---~~~c:..~:...{!:z::'J:.6~~_(2~~__~!i_1
(.~ {.J~-rr--/~A:'-r../-'~-r
I
1,-, ..
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the abOVe REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
~\~~\ A ~~ny.~n~~n~~ ~~~r~ R~ the FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
dastrQY anQther
MARKET ~o obtain
fresh fruits and
I
1
~
~
t
!
!
i
l
r
\
I
!
,
~E ADDRESS
ift;T--1kir.ji&?J.-i)"--:.---l---- .d~~ 'L__G.Y1CI1L~--?J.!:d-'--{..2-C!..L
~~~~f~:-:f~~~~-~~~-~-?f/;rjfi\~il!.!~jt:~~- ~h
:ti!:~iZ?{rJl;;;t5LG1h~15::Z;~ ~ '"
~~~~~~--~~-'------------------------------~
-~~7~~~~~~~---~~~~~L1:~-------------------------
- ,-
}r:2fj~~-----E;:~Y~--:--y~'!.'2.~----'t!:J!.~---=I-:X~.----------
~~5;;:;~=:~~~~f-'~1--fi~--:1=.-~~r
------------7-----------------------~-t-~----------~----------
.tL"}/1 ~~.. 9 () I / ..~ ;..~'") C-' /. ", ,; .' .: f
11."r /'-....A' .l')j, ( /CJ ,C"J. t....:.~ 1 ..) /. I (, _~ I" ,.-,'" i / ". L-
-- -:----1~~- ----: ---~---------- ______4._~---~---~~-~- -
_~~--LL-J.JC--,L~YL.6~Jjgq.~~:I.1!w----------
e n 17o~~~' -- \/ ,--J.!- 'F) ." .
------~t7-[(~~~~&~;t--LiJ?~~~1(~J~C~!~~~~-~J:~---------------~
.=.-J..i.kf>.h..~~j~~k~ll.'_,_\J___ll.]_J~~~\_!..'.i.;:)-l~.:!..-~-!..;::iC.l:.'\2.~..s:~f__t- (, -'\ $'-.\ l: ~ t,
'"
t...I-"1.1_. I
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
(
\
j
1
I
i
,
I
I
I
~
I
I
i
,
I
!
NAME ADDRESS I
-.f~21r~~h QeL___J:gC_rL__ __Lr?:.'J__ _ _1]_~S~~..!~!:.::''.1_t__I2:..~__C Lr.[rC.~((. fe v-.... I
_0~~~______!!::~~:@~~___i!.tf?j2___Q_~~c-_~__!I~.:~____~_~!.,.y; !
:IM€-------.t...flLl3-'~-- ----2~L1?-1E:-'""2q~I..':J.-Jlj~.fL-.:.fJ}f2~qkr>
-------------------;}-----51t'J-~~L~-~~LJ.,...r.;t.,L.~2.v;.~
. % I .'. #J.AJ...f:-!f---.La~fdJQWb.lldl!:L1!J)~--f!...A-r
-- - -'~ -------:..-- ---$l-';,-_5.Jf.<2..!'S:k-dZ_C7-J!.!:::..r:~-
-- ~-- --~--r--~.PL~0~~--C)/b.-{>;,-Tt.J.~~.:~5
- ",-~-===J~~----qJ..'i2-~JA:~k~L:L&:~__s.:::._
-,r---:S-;;{j[Z(ii#1b~vf 4 D '7 /~ ~'flj t:")~ L-tl:> yf- L-~ . C!~ rj
1?&~=G:~?t-;LZ~~]~ZQ!i~t2~Z~2C~~~~~5lt~ tL
/"1/ ~ ,f/' / j/';; . J 0, 7711/
L-(.;;t:...z:4<::::&~ -7<';2.::m- -- - - _..!_Z~:'-d_ _ ./~~.tf{!i.:'_~2;;(Ji~'i~ __ _"~_ _~~~__ _ "
~\_\i.n.~'~.L.J_40d:..-g-t-_-'D.L:.tj__~n['~dJ.Q_l~:x:d_llt._E._
T~~~J:.Jl!_0.:.__D.6l\:15__lfjl:_f_l';:~,9Ll.1-'1~L~~'C(:cj_fJ.c-2:
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town 01 Sayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Al~~; R FRn~~n~~nF~ ~tQr~ ~t th~ FINA would deatrov another
existing use, cur use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENToand REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We pe~i~ion you to VOTE to DENY the above REOUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop_
There is no other fishing-bait Shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
AlqRl R ~Rn~~n~~n~~ ~~Qr~ A~ ~he FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
deQtroy another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
j
I
I
j
I
,
~
i
i
l
~
1
i
!
1
!
I
I
J
1
I
1
!
NAME ADDRESS
9fk1L~~L:-3.V'X l_____---~~1.s1..l-~:L~~~-1CLY1~ti~~DL
~ ~2 ,/ / /2:l..~ .
" c--. ~././ ;\ ( r:: ) --e'"" ' - 0
_.Jo-~---- ,_~""--;ro_~r_-~-- 0 _____~..L..!-...-€:-f'+-........-c~:l----
7p L~ ? ~"' c:. ') '?(J ~
,,--;r~ ~~;~~__~~_____!~~~~_____~~~6t~~?_~_~_____~~.
~h~.- I)\...--- ~ ,3} CAt '"~ ,'014=D 1 :s1:f:.
G - -;;1- -~ -- ---- -_...39fL_0.Ld.;,.j.<>...f!t11f~ /;;JjyJLJ:!lm:t.t-,
JJ-_P.--!.-.:.~[2 t4 ~___ ____ _2._C_t!-1_ __4~1.!.._:tiLk.:.1:.k'I-_=.::.~ ---
O-~~ (J J~ (
'~//.~ --._~~_ #' ~"_ o~.;:. o' ce'}':; c:.~;O?~;>, -, -:.r-.-e.r A..-o~_ .- 7.....
~m~~;[(~~~~~:21-{~~:~:;=::~d~~O~~~;~:fd~rll?". k-
. ~-7~ -:e::Y~~---~.-----_--Z5b2_-_f0.!.Jf7J-__~f~,-5:::L~_-~1'g~r
/" .i -r;,;) 0-; S/r 0, / o""Co .~ .
07----01.- .-...," 5/v /...:..,j /("'/.v<ir.,.' ;;'-I/";,:';-.-..o:>7':'-='
lih----------------------- ---------------------------7~------~/
_ _____~~~~ ~__________~61~~~-?~~~~---------~----------
" ~T /
_~~l:~~ ~~---------------------------------~---------
hX~ -) .- C) r- R n
LLt _:..~::6~ _ _ 0 A...~:J~!I.r;:;:-~:::: ____z:_'~ Qq _ _ f5J .YJ..S:_ _C v.. _ __ _4.:Ll2Ljlj)
~~- "-.\ .
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissione~s, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowla~k Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believ@ that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing uso.
to obtain fishing-bait
Al~R1 R ~Rn~~n~~nF~ ~t~r~ Rt th~ FINA would daQtroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including tresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ADDRESS
_~Cd_,-_~_-2~g~-I_________:iL~__l~~jJ~L~f__q~~_____________
~ :J........ is J " j ~ t.te ':2 :i
,I I~ f.1 ;... 1 ::; "7 . - . , ,,' \ , ,. "., '..;::l
uiD____ _chlf1!:E..u______....r..;;_2._~___ \.l. ___ S'___ ~_..~----u- ------
-J-e.J:5_5..! ~l . ,_ _<2..1'':'''L~.1.J.____/~ 'Z _~-!..2_L':!_2.:/l:"?3~Jll~_!:L<K__ _ _ ___
~ ~ ) 0 ''). Cl c-:- 9:\i]-- -.~ ';:< ~ \ C
C ~~ a.~~~_ - '_-::- ~dil-::.___-1~~~LJs1.__"G!!.7_ --J..~~-~-0:-.j,~-------
. '-~( I <~ '1 .-") q c-.J I! f) Cj/l~~ 1/ 1./
'lkZ Y----,-,~~tA=~--~-~--~~2S(i. ~L~--~~---~--~------
,.'. ,.....? I tl. /7"'- /"
- '.(,~il.1~.J::::t%Ji- ~-::::------ ~.?-.;-~- _J~:.h~i~:--!__5::~__5__(I.:.::,_':.:l__
~ ~ A. ~ ~ ", '~)II'! d /!,/ 1-) ~!.4c r? I I /J-_.)
V - 7t~S.-:.tI.. ,"'--------L---,;:J------&--';7~-:;-Lr<:-/-L...Lr-,/
- ;..(J;l2::~11!-~=---------?::~{:-!.---':f1(.l{L1~tJ[-::-::---'~
lJ!fHL/:4:,- k::,j___... ---- ----- .LJ2.:t.2 t___.I.2!{- _-i~L!!.t!~!!-- fLl_
~_.:;'SiLll~ _~'cj_~______________~~L~____!2,_~~__QJfs..._-b.b1.1:L.--l(JfS:fLJ~L. 3l-J G4()
~ '/J JJ {) (I' . , (t ,'[? , :1/( I a
.'tl.!.:.li:;.t.H--~tlS~L.. :.____ __ _ _ ____~~~=J5. __Ll..J~!.. ~:.(:'lLf~..,~:}_~-___(~,~(~~~_ <. (' 7
4Lf::;:.#" ., I ,I
.... ,...Jr.J;~!..--<.;.-~~.:::.~T.~~-----------2-L9-1--tJc.:.d.!-:.-:L(..~-./)s~'-lCL~~:- ..3 4 ~ f ~)
j .~ ) :J t/ r- J j. ___1 IV .tY-H
--~ ~d~~~-f---~------------~~~~~-~;~~1~UiL~Q~-~.~~--------
'-.r-.
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City 01 Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 01 vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition ot a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD HARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town 01 Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
I
I
I
I
!
I
I
1
I
I
j
l
I
I
~
1
1
I
1
~
I
A\~R\ A ~Rn~~n~~n~~ qt~r~ At th~ FINA would d~6trQV anQther
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ADDRESS
N.\;fJ]_W_\J_i2~-'lI:~~----- _..-3.:i?Y..__G: yIt____'"i_c:_!?:t:!.:L_6::~20G)
~1--D1:1id.];_~__________.l.2_CJIJ.9__ ( ~u.Lt=J:.J2__'?:j<JX~(~_2Q_cJ
. I
J2.Q.t1L-[)~LS_____-_~Ss.'2_EnJ_t}3.o-!Y'.L_~r;;L*~~"-~l) t I ~
r ~ { ... () (:\ ;:.:. if... -1- \) (1) I f'.. -}
.!.::E-D.r~;:::.._ ___12r,;._ ___ - ~1_t.Ltl__~_2~'-U___ lLJ.2.GJ.f----::f- VJ__L
. F-i~Y'Y-Z?-P..Jjh~llC:.--- ____~QJL(L ~~d::'-('L :L{''-.~-~---~~~~ '- ____
j:ba_~'k._'_\;c)~l.c:.?--__ "'-/ .:L3LLIaAl.!"lk_':::-~:.~~L_Dl2-.____
~l~~ ___;0_~_(~__ -<;''-j,-I~-'1L.t:'1l:~.5''::::(... -- -~;71 ~-~~ c~_ _~J._'::_ -_ ___
- ~_~1.____~~7d-__C!!i!l~MlfLfi&;__r;;_~~_____
-~S-:C"J~~___~t__ffi~o~~l~__~~__j:;-~J.\td_____~l!.Wldl/C
~ ~~-'7~ ~J~ 7:.9/ ..O,~L<--e. C~ ~;-w....~
. ~-~~~ ._~~~-----------------~~-~--------------------
~ L - //1'/ ,;;; a~
_ __-~~ ::J''-- ~,'1:_.:'--_______...z:.Z'2L'_./;':./~L.t___~___!!I______________
y~ . c' ~ ~
L~ ~ --.-:.-------------~~----{V?:&Y.5::!:f/_--~----'.::::H".~~~tf
__~ttl~~11t~j~____j~5_~~~1~1(~~~-----------------
~), ~.".
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET~ next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of . a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town 01 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in. the area to replace the
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would destroy an existing use,
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain fishing-bait
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
A~~R~ ~ ~Rn~~n~~n~~ qt~r~ Rt th~ FINA would deatroy another
existing Use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
N~E ADDRESS
,c:.ffrf:~.G/f.:!iJlh'l.. -----__d~_C#..P'..?d~."tflYP...-/J;#f.i2JP-.3 $!.~9..8'
--~~~-------~]Q---fr~~~L-~--------~J~~:----~~~~~----
:J'J~~J.------'J3EJ--~~tI.-d:--~/~rz=~'9S---- .
~~t----~;-;---~---------~-----------------
~ - -~~-- --___~___1_tC~1~C~:--G;~-----------
~-- --~:1.:L-----2Y.::q'-~-G.~~~>:'?'_'.fr-~~~:2------
--4~~~--~JJl~~)_____L~~~t___~~'~o~____~~~__~__~B__________
.::IW-~J:l~:~-_-,=::-- L LJo.-l h?~'~.:::::z.-- -.;z..~:tl.O- -C3b2bf:-:Io.~ 'L _ _ .
&d2 '/' --.; 6 '; 1] ~ .--" /? :iks- ~ 6 '>-
-------- -~~~~;-:::--~<;;...~5 -----.e=:.:----~6-.;...l..~Li:~~.i;!~----~-:~ :?-
, ~ -~V!* '
.~ - L'; - ;],(d;~~~~~~5~;~G.:7~~J~~~~;-;);~~~=~
'l~~U~~~~~~~---::~------~-~-~-----;--~~~~:.;;t~~~::,~-~
/T.--------------~--~------~--tL---c:~--------------------
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Cle~rwater, Florida
Re~ LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We bel ieve that the addi"tion of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
i
\
"\
I
!
\
I
NAME r . I' ADDRESS . " \
~~~~-~ ~~-------~--------------~---------- I
1] -!Z:~ -- -::??-~~~~~~aL-;~~~~~q~~ ,I
~~l..- . ~ ~'l /l1 bJ ~f,\ I f' _ ~- \
-~~- -~ ----------t~-----~~~~ ~~ ~
~ _____________~_~JLL_~~~~[~---~- _ .
- C~ -___~~------~~-ti--~Q!!?-G-~--OLWmGLa-"'-<J..il~
.~__~-- ___ ___ _ ___ ____~Q3LO----[~J2~-~-~~~~-~
--<j.>,,{fi- -- ----- - .f,;___J~~2_4C!J,,~~:::,-CklR.J '_ ·
illV-\-C4?~~---------j;-Rt:~L~1~~1~~~o~
~~----------l---------------~~~~---~~
___~_L_ .----------Lfn~-d:----E!.$i=.=/A1,<..JIJv-t;:;;;
bZ~___{dL-~1i2_-----------~----~:-----~:---------------_~_
" .-- .
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
A~qR~ A ~RnV~n~~n~~ q~Ar~ At th~ FINA would dastrov annthar
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Bleck 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait $hop. in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
j
!
I
I
t
I
I
.(
1
\
!
l
l
I
!
1
f
I
j
,
~~~~\ A ~~n~~n~~n~~ qt~r~ At th~ FINA WQuld daatray another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ADDRESS
/l .. . J J . CUI"
1J:~U~~~~~!];iilfij;;~~Z~~fl~~7'
~___ _ ~________~fJ.qg_Q-fe~~k(._____~
. ~ _' Jb:.;2~~______-.2-0_9_2..___j:k~.D~.L-DYL--~
" ~ ~ ;)yt)c; -2: Z; \'h :. .
S . (~~__.._..L0_V~~~~~__~ll___~~__..__.._.._....
__ _ ~'1.~L_~tf!;}!:L.L-(} .I.!LL _z.~:g(L_<i!{0{!!!.<.I.j;;,- L
:l^"L~'!2_~ -.:: _.. ___J !.:.~'i_ _@.... ~~_1l ~__(t~~ ..~~ ~ ~.. L J
- .. .. . ':~:J:S ...._..__2j~-"--..f~v..'=.t.J.L1:.~'LJ2L'.JJL_____
~. _-.. X..\\~---__-20SfL6df:._:fJE~t___---m--
/2/. .... ..1..,. K"/ _ . v'7 C7 /J <> /.;'1- (j (.. /':/'; .l;;~. A V )......, ) /) ~
~G~f~~fd-------~t:V_~---~--------;-7-~~~-_-~-LJ-~
~~7~~.._______..2:72(it0_5;-~]l-;t_~.LJ_~------
i
.
I'
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 8ayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Al~~~ A ~RnV~n~~n~~ q~Ar~ A~ th~ FINA would
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
de6troy another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
NAME I ~ ADD~~~ \ r1J ~ }." '1 h
~ ~~ \ 0 -YYJ-.Q.(~U\.v~.)Y\.. ~v ~
Z-: --~--~-----r:~---~~J---;-:; ----------,---~-~-~/=- ---Z.--
~~-~---~---------_____~___L2~_&1~~-------J-~--
~-frW:ev.~---------/DJ-JjJ..1-C6t1c-ilt!Jtt(JL--(-~fA1F-C.
-~1rLTr_-~o-(b~-Q.ll~----tbZj-~t31---@!!i11--E:~----
--/V-dJJO---YiaLLCL_________1/2J:. __k!.{~I;:??__tJJ::.6____~~.
- ___~~tJ!{ __ -B..8)g.l)__ ____ __ ___L Db __bJ'j!J2ER-__1l:.J!};i_:'LL..
, .Ae- - - - -- - - - _66 E.. !1u:.LIl.atJC..Lfr.l1E::lt;.DfL _ LL _ f! ~_t
/ t!:".,? ,f / -I. J
------___________l5Z-L./_./~~,~...._./L2l'_,.:S~-------- 'I
-- :J~1--------------;J'3->1(..:LI~/&L;j:p-dn-~~~---
- 'riil7:ff'-~~-----------QtjQ-Cj-G.~j{~-6.~)iqy--'ljJg---8.~}:Jc.;
--'t-F~;-': 'It!tr-------$GLLMeSf;{l:-4t--1Jn--etta-It.
oA-~-f'8 - {~- A1:1#-~__ - - _-Z_?-~_Ct h~L<-:J-f1'U-k5-L_-~-~- ---
p1l1j'---4y---- ---- _____j~L'(!l_ rLl!.'=-E-i(L.&f-,ffMl~-~1!1
"
,P.'I.
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
~
l.
"
>
'.
.'
.}
~
~
~
,
.~
1
~
~
ri
.1
'.
11
I(
,I
"
.,
:,
i.i
"
I<'
d
I'
,.
'!
;':
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey ~ City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the'
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARkET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARkET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
t
F
t
~
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. .
.-
,
~.
I'
t
~
t'~
I;
I:
F
~
f
1,
.~- _ '_~____~~l~:~~:A~cg~~__~-LtC._$-,____Ef~L
~ / ,I I
~ / -
?.0 - -_ ;:, _ _ __2.!t._ 5'~J-h:.~d_cJ.~.J:...S._.J4.I.Lt........_C. L~t."t..i.J-_,t:lf.........\
#:.7!~~~j---LtJ2-+d-g-'-*#I.id~-1~ -
_~~._~4X~LL-_ ___ __ _6.~L_ 61E-!'CF: _~L:___~~IE.t!.l..l{J4J ~~ __EtA..
j)gtMr.;J..B~t~-.L 'jJ ]lr/~~:1Jtf~-f.J:.- - --,:i~il&Lfr - :jjjL~-
V~/V I Cj .) r Tf>V GtQc. Sf. OlE&;(r~rk? (fL_,
a~~~=~ -~ -~~;;~~ -- -- -~~;~~; --- ~ ~,-.-~~~- -- -~-;;~ -- -i;;~~:~~~-l~~
sf/0 -- \f-s.:L~::!~- -_\. - - -- - - .-- - -- Jj__ % -~- -- -~ _&-- ---- - -- - - -_ - c
-mJr-(!AaL -cd.-----(!!-/JJ------i~r;tl1.da,-------------
-iLdff:ff - ---/tf/i 1.J:t.l!f:.. - -- - ____ L -~ -- _ _ ___._ _ ./..1_ _ _ _ _ _ ___ __ ____ _____
. -C,,-jz~fJ2~--- .0 Z----71a~-~~~-(Y~~~)1~!:~.;:I--jl~~~-~?cj.01h----
IJ] , '~/L .,~ G-":-' . 1. c' /'!1) FL-
. ,.../ ' ,- ..".:J ....:; ~.: Ie 0ol" (" ~ .....
. . ~ ~ ~._,- ~-- ----... _k -,-~. ~co:...'l_*_d-L__ '-~.----- -EO,..) )
)~- 1 ~ /).. ),. , ~ / ) , ? ( .!. . /
....," I _ ..t:. I "". I,' l,' ( ". "': (l,/ ". / .... t r) II. /.< '. ~> /__ (. :;.,
- ;r/~, J.~.-t-f f...__/ .:::1..'/-'._'---_,1.1... i~-,-!-....-~~~t!---- ./~-:.-:-----' .') V.o-->/
';J >>/ / /,~ ... E ..-"l ) U./ ( ) ,./ /p/::! -' /1-/
~. ~ _ _ !15- . _ _ _:/U1. . _ ..! - - - L L:::-S. - - ~&t.v.jcrti!:cL _ _ -/.'dLtI.r: _ r.... _ .J-'_ _ _ _ __
i:
t.
I
I,
I
i
I
I'
I:
,.
,',
"
I
\'
}~:> .
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
(
I
I
.
I
~
1
:\
f,
'{
d
J
;J
:;
~
;l
)1
~
11
I
iJ
i~
~
l;
(~
}~
,I
:;
;'
~.
.,
,.
re
t:
'{
'I
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station" We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
~ :.
re.:
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
I:-
(e
~;
if
~'.
r.
~~.
t.
~ ~
f
I::
t..
~
n
II
,.
:\
I'.
~".
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. .
NAME r / ADDRE~~ .. ~
-~~/<V~"'---~~-"---~~T~-L-------------
(-?}'14h~~-~~~~-------~~~---~---Z~---------------
'~-L~1~6~___.___~W___E I t1-2::/:L6.L6----------
/,1 /~i K ~A;-/ _
-~7~ft~~:L. .----~~~~~--~Fc---~r,1;;1/--~-~---
---~- -~~~~- ~--; --------~------------------------------
; ..a/' ..- /l (;. r-z-=-/-:""'- "s lL/ .~.
--v --~~-' ______.____~e~~---~_-----L~-C~---------
_ _ ZiLtiJ;.Jl__ _B ~~__ _ _ __ _ _~ _!:LZ."-__'2~ _..:. 0 [}_~ _ ./1.J. -=_ _C ~~ LC _}!L ~ I ~
. Q.k.~~{._-:_-: ~$'=& ~Q.c_l._________~~____'~____~____~~_____1~_____1~__
. f' (" t7:;r;;) f) -it. () '1/)4' }..5
_ ~iA.1.1J- ~/ _.:::.'J ."_____m_~~~-[(Ll~.r'Ea~I1Jl.e-~;----l:/!-~()..) (9
.LJ:)!;!~!:iL -.,L~fff.!.F - _. - ~ r '2 ~.t3 _ _ _I:. c:Lt!;;;~{..!:.{L.;.,~!:(~ _ _~ Z5~_ -E1.~ _ .3 Y. "'!.~(-- ;.:
/. - ..:.;,,: /. - . ..:::? -..J -D. jl)' r J I 5f- ~~P? -- _.,.v~. S5
. - e. ~~~~ --'P.C!<.l1-- -..: ./_)./..2 -- -._~ j~~ f.eJO---- - - - - t. I;.. - - -F=~-:?-
--~ Jl~~7~~1~r::~- ---~Q\.!~~~I~J0-~~-?r.:t-1~I1$.L-d~9j:;J
- -~A.f::f. Il..!Y:A:J':4-- - -17 JL i tiIL>:.7. i'.. - !/J.::~- -- -/:51~ZL{[!I.L_? '/V I f
,.
r.
i'
t'
,
"
~ ';
"
t
,.
I:
,
t
,:
!'
"I
,
~
~~::"'( .~ ,
. - "~Y
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey ~ City Commissioners, City 0'( Clearwater, Florida
-!
I
'1
'(
~.
~j
"
;i
i:
;
i\
;\
~:'
j}
~.
1\
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94. LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
"
,
,.
1.
'.
~.
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
}.
~,
I;
~.
"
~
\,
.'
l:
I.
t-
,.
I
.~'
r-
~
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD HARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's naighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
. ,.
"
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
~.
lj
[:
",
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
eKisting use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
v~getables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. .
NAME . J /~ ADDRESS
/.'") ,- { ';-,. /1' ..J" , ....) ! . -'. , "
L.. /" / L } I. -.; T"i -/. ,of .' i... ~ I /... I J ,
t_;,I.?.,}.JI"'~ /c-c.nt.".....[ iV(~'/' ~. /. ,.(':-:'fi.{,~"7..j~(,/ ..C'1'/.:l.1-{
----~Lr----- - ------;--~--------C-~-~----~--------------------
~'!t::Z:2 -~~ql~~~~~L~~~;:..E~~~~~~~~
,~,<'aLd; flJ--- ------:--s:!.A-:aWa..""2tL7-f2--_____.,-_____
- {U.'t;f;7;:fka-dJ.-----------('i~&-cJ.<d!~==---~-\~-------
~~~~~~-~~f----~~---~~~~~~---------------------
_-:r~~-h ~ /jAA ,",./1 ____CLLL1:r__~!ct.___.._____.___.__
___ ~t~. ~---~~-~~~-;2?~!~--------
n&-~-___---GJff!n4 5i?;61S-_____.
~ -.~ j'l}. n . _ I ~/
--- -G..~---------- _'Of2_7_JJ~:&;.:t=_k~W rl
....-->- I ~ . /;Y"../ 0 ;/ .
" ~..-.c. ~:?: ,"2--7..../~. --:'>--- '") L/~;" //~/:/Y~'...-:1 .. . .?:/ ;) /Ieee:-!
. _,;:._._:...._ _ _ .=.....~~ L:"--~C..oi","o!.:-::._..l-=-_ __ __ ___ __....)- __ __ __'-'_ _ _.:l.-/....;:: _ _ _'-.:::' _ _ ':,.-_ .
b ~i,-<.r- - 4e'f; ~& - - - - _~~_1117.L te!.1fI_/JYL_ $ALfJa.<L_ -<:7/'1-
~.JJ} N ~ ~/ .It L(~'d: ';;\1. i I [~'=' _1 c(
..:. >---.-.---------'ciAr---------c..~--.... .1.... I..::-r- f-<..fi..-_.1:"'_ ..:.---------
...... ./
<..
~
"
"
f:
~
,I
~
f.
I'
t.
V
r
i,
t:
I::
,;
i
fi
,
,
~:
I
!
,.
(:
~:.:
,
,
i;
'\
, :~
:~, '.
:(
i:
i
.'
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
~
~
,
~;
f
~
(:
~
r
i
f
"
~:.
'.
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, SOB Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
i.
~!
"
,
E
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop_
"
~~
'.
,.
,.
"
I
r
I.
t.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
~~
r
f
"
,
~
~
(
I.
t
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegeta.bles, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. '
..
t:
,
r
tl
f
NAM. " ADDRESS
"~______Ld?!.-?&U/Lg~-:!!?!:c:::~~_______
-"- <: -------QfCt!;3~.dt:;r.d~--~~'ITr~<!!C--L:L--
1~-~-~~--------------!!-~~~-S-~\~~~JlJV_~_____~~____~___---
q~__~~___,LI-~1- -,1)8-~_11;i::.L).:tt2.- __cPibUIa!.1f:Z-; _:;Z_L__
'-- ~A~i1--- ___LZ~i- _j--,~tY..",= __'2::r:-_ - --"- -'=-_'1tIJS-_~,--- -----
-?F-~ _/}1(~_ - - ------ -- ----- - ----- --- ---~ /AJ.JJ:lw----
t,:---r /J .;' / ~ d- ~ ~)
C ,,;::~~~:r<<L - -- - -- -- -- --- -- - - - -- -- - - ------ ---- - -{! ~""---ta"'~~:--..7rf- r
. - -~'-l'_~~-~V--------------__-U2_.cl~_k-;- .'
, ~ D At? /iJ/} _. ~ -1?
h _~<L --./ .h:L-_ .o;f--et J:L<::-: -- ___ -- - - - -- --- - - __ __ ~"" -.t<'--.....-~_ _ ___ ~_
-- '\1~ti.Ju--h~ih.YQ----- ---------~-"-~~<"~;~,--~-----
--~(Af!~f!--T/~-.-----------!lfi---cl:h!:-d~j'~
.
!
r
n
~,
~~.
;,
t,
i
.'
,1" ~:' ~
PETITION
to Mayo~ Ga~vey & City Commi5sione~s, City 01 Clearwater, Florida
1-
!
~
.t
;j
~
r;
t)
'"
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated st~eet
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowla~~ Lane
I:
~~
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
"
i
1\
I,
tt!
it
~
We a~e custome~s of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next doo~ to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town 01 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
f
~
"
r.
(,
~
~
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fiShing-bait
i'
?
.,
,.
~.
.'
(,
r
,
"
1;
,.
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another j
I:'
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain L
neighbor od grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and '.
:::e~abIeg) WHICH WILL NOT BE ~;~:::D. ~ f
~'.\.-/ ------ti---P:;-- fW;/J.---------. ---~"*v' !
- - - ---- ,&--tJ-- 'dQ,dt:f.J2.Y-ft .....-~ ;,
X~ ."',~~L~~2-~;~7tec~---~~-'$$6
--~-r---------~~~----_~~~~-~~\ilL-~l~~~{~L~-
'.f1f~=-----CGeel;t{/4;bL.;2s..=---l&-l72iJ#;:.
-- ~L)-_---~--13JJ-B~J!:Mb-5-'L-~tJ!1~g--~-
-:-, 1 /7;;. .
(/ . '"
-- ~ -' _ :t~~-_------__----------------------------
. · ( S
t'> I ,_.-- ,--- D I)(f / /3:1:- ~ r...'.z L <:' ~ ..--;:-.,
- {4;. _,-L.2:!:s,c :.l ___ _ _ j.!.-2--9J--SJiLyttc ~_ _ 13. k:J:fL _}(
. /"---------/~--~~--'~-~1~
~__ ___________~1__JSf~_~~_6t~-_~.~~___
---- - - -- -- - - :f2cqJS .5.@~ffi~&.f_;.:i. iC.I S'
,
l'
(
-
~\ .
~;~.tf .
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
l
i
i
~
~
)
!
j
i
I
~
~
..
iJ
l!
,j
~
\;
~
:i
~
~>
r.
,J
j
q,
.i
t
~i
Ii
!{
:~
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: (LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, 8lock 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of 8ayview's neighborhood grocery
store and cur neighborhood fishing-bait shop,
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would
exist.ing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED. '
NAMt{' I~' ADDREGt . a. d /r
-::;!if#JJj&~!fj~--__----j~f@'-Ju~!!j{_--e~fL:l?lJ:rli'-
lJ,Jr1-~-~-----------_Lz~~--41C::!!:~E::::-------.&;1t.t!ll::;f13/(' [I;
/~ ~,) J /?'....~) /.: 7/ Ik=: ytr::-f"i ':J (i' D u"'-.-,;(-(') \ L-,
~~~ ~5t~~:r~~~~-~~~~~~~~:::~~~:~~~~c:~~::~~~~~~~~~~:=~::~~~ .
.... ~ -- -- p'
, r, r)
. _:-__~__'" _~_~-".':'__ - . - - __.:.____ _,:!!~<!!:'.~,:!_~!~__.__qj~!!~ ~ ___m__ .
. fI? G--~,.-'--'~:-------- (~!f-~--4Jti-:..-1}:11S:$:.g.S~Lfl-U; .
"--<'J-V'VI..~ -- . ~'2,.~.";:-;.':/~'_-_u. ,')-;,'/"2,/ L-::J'LI..Jc./,.:..!.~~ lC:c-r::. L/c"J J i
~- ~~~~~~C/:~:~j1i2~f,t3-~?~;~~~516/.ri
rtt'./. :; ./. ~. '~. ,'~ ":/ 177+') ~ I
f Ii ., ~.'V . .01.. / '" ") " ::- JI. < J ',' &;-. (T ,."..., If ~ (. ,t., \
--/~ . -::'\,:)- -~7- r--:-.-------' -L/ir~ ~_../~:~LW-C1-_----1---- .K-:_~ ":c./ '5f/;;':J'() !
-. ;)-rr /;,~~.5~ i.--==~:'::'_--___-7_f:.._~e~(:l:"~1~l:~_-__..cj.!.--sj_C_.tl-::.._~ &<~ \
/ ~~'~ C ;t t ,'1[Z; 11.r ,i.."./~"",: Qp,,- ('2a~_.. /t-c.. .:ii'-,4{'/~/ ~
)" ~ 7 ~dJ' - (1 --- - -- - - - - - --.. -:'1- :r.r ~I;,- -(/i!....-. --l- ~,;- -. - - - - -- :)0-;- ~ - -:-
~. ., --~, IL / ~/ -^ IVt.::::::' ::J ,,) ? ,:/J.(./ ,..<....t;tn: . /.~ V\l.L ~-.'i , L ~ )
rt;:;:77-(('7------------:~=f:~-/fZ--;,- t-~:}}05 -;:--1- ,
; fr-J~~[ .. - "::j /.i-r::.--:':'::~_,- _ _ - - - _lJ ~;;: _-"2__ _ -.!. ~(~ll. _1.9_ _ _....-q_.::._ _ __ __ __;: ~~'~ ~ 0
c- J L
destroy another
MARKET to obtain
fresh fruits and
~,
,;
r.
~
.'
;~
\
~;
q
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
~
II
~:
I'
!;
'..
11
~
~'
~
:'
"I
~.
~
~
~
.,
:':".1. ' '..
[,
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 ~ayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
I
~
~
'i
?
~
~
r
~
ij
'I
~
~~
1
t
~i
,~.
"
I'
;
!
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
t
~
iI
"
li
"
V
~l
t,
\
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
"
:.j
.,
j
.
~ ~
j:
:;
j\
"
~}
~
~
t,
~
~
\.
'\
~~j
'.
[1
!~
"
[i
1) ADDRESS, \;
-- ~<1LtdCe ---------Llfb-L()--b2-~~.::--.LA,a.CZCr3.:.S46 () 1
.' /1 / t r.... 'I I
~-~--S~~~~~~~~t~~~f-l[~~~-CC\~;:~~~33,f:.( C. J ;
. -~4~~~~y~~-:~I2-:(JI'-'-u +\"'-=Y!-----,--:-H-'L~, 't<", If _.
~.?t:.cU:lJY_'UtA]J_Q:~~ 2j,2_2.(~~~~U:1:l~~~_~~~(Q-!9 ;.~,/(.j ? J'
MaL-:{l~. -- ~fA:::/.~ __ _ -(~2~~),-_U1{../1.~"iiJiLi.1!~~~(~_~~~ ~l/6 {}
~~. ~ '-1:t1 ~n 6-.1 ---. "."
-'. /J (U,-,.,. f-/~ /~I!.;Lc C(7 . '-L' 0::7 (/. ~.' ""5 ..... ',)
,- (' t'-~ ~L\&~.':;' , -----LA~ll ) ;i.d--____-:~;-_I----.!..:._..1-(:.----'=-.::--..--
I - ~-- - ------~-t . '-----~~.~----------------------
;' ... r ~ G /,;.: ~. ../.',' -/
~ lr q: '; .':'/&" /' ..,' d./ \ -- ./ ~ l\ .J7 ~ ./-L)
~< "'~ -~~~~' -~-~/~;2~--'-~-"- . ~'_.._-.. -:-~~____________:_L_______~_~.
" -1 (.; v j' I l< f' { '. f./' (
-- . /rn L'~_ .t~-:- ~------~f.~V-'~--=--"----------=;--~7(J---------
- --flj- ~S~tt-r:,~-JJ---.------ ,--..------
-('/ ..--~~~:..-!:2e.K(J/~~"-:_------------- J.Sit--------
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to ob~ain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
:-. ~ ,
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN 8AYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
j
!
I
1
I
I
I
!
I
,
1
i
I
I
I
\
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, ne~t door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop~
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an e~isting use,
to obtain fiShing-bait
A~~A~ q ~An~~n~~n~~ ~tRr~ At th~ FINA would destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies~ including fresh fruiLs and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
AuDRESS f
- ________~~_~~Mf-~C~--~l~>L"1-'-U--k. ~l:ct(f.,l'i 1
___________21f!.7)jlLJJIuL.d1::!1~~:.rzffdd.t~ljl-i'idn. i
- -~ - - ____2-_~fll~tL:b1:!.!!:.~-_,_(}~a31./' /f ?l
-/ia..:LL-,(,~(2M ~ ___'____tl2._'1__0 -a-}i-ld..!-'<..f-A -LL__sJ IL._t:. ~__l!l ~2.r
_4!~~~_______J_~_~.t!.Af_rJ~~~-/lL__C-)_iL.J2..__.J:.Y ~ .<~-
----------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------~---------------------------_.~------
----------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------
-
.,
l~.:" .
'Ih')
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fishing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
A~~R\ ~ ~~n~~n~~n~~ ~t~r~ Rt th~ FINA WQulct destroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
NAME ~ ADDRESS
__1-l:...~ ~_~___________ ___2:...~I2::__&Y1..l._:m_J3lJ~_l:.u:.~"J.l~__
- - - --'7<::1-~C!2~-________2P.L.I/e!~ri!..<Ld:..-!.-<L~2Ld~
---. ~LIJj'1~)1:;'(L-------2.e~KEa.'-:!i!-tt;;J!./2_-4I/~
-_Ui!f2_~1j~~________~JJ!__!J:.tLjflf.C!!~J}Jt!. - .j;
-_st~!?~_4_w...!J-Je.c ____________~:?J2__~ ~~~~--~:-~hl'~- '!:!._IL ~M~'
~...!Ct!.i.:U.__Jv.J--<..c./.#LL------- ___~~_:LJ __.t..2. ::::4r!e:M..__-Z~--r/J~J'.k:-
/!I4'<-,diltij#------------ __r{Qd(;__o::!!!:.~1i21i.~.L_SDl/;;: . aJ:
--U~i2.!';?kle-----------.,,2/..3-.{La:L.ezl~-WA!f6..1 f-, ~"<l
--~-------------------------------------------------------------
-
"
I
./.'........
(~~.~~~/;~vD '-\Y)" L~
~c~~.~...... ..
------
I
y
~
~
!
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey & City Commissioners, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Slock 3 and 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
501 Bayview Avenue, 508 Meadowlark Lane
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serves as the Historic Town of Sayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fiShing-bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fishing-bait
~\~~~ A ~~n~~n~~n~~ ~~~r~ Rt th~ FINA would d~stroy another
existing use, our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obt.ain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
~,.~~~~~l~ 4 ~, AI?DR:.:~~:~: i ~.;2 )
/~~Z4:':rt:L__( !.5-A5J.Z'-dz1_____f2L;..LL~~q~iJ.L'?/ltLtZ?-o~"'.:. CC..:. r1
~-,_ ry-)-:. ' .-- IZ:~ ~. j
zL/_Je4.~.;;.-~:..J/;;::.t{{LLj[2.:L::~--Xqt#/2.1,/j[Jt2ji 2-d {"_
'. / /.;zq:, ,; ,~/ .1'"'1 /' /'~'.. / ,# .'
/' ....J9'"""v ~'/ , /" / I' /'~'./. r7./7l.. -- /'
. .:.:...../:......,.--//~"'~...~ ,. ./,;,.,-/",,,.;;:-' ... " /,:' : ,",/<.-;'/'! ." r-<.- .'--. /",-
~___________~__________________________________l___ ------------
~ '-7 .' . "
;-: ;':., "<'.. .:/ ,/;::,. ~, "'7 ~I r:;';.> c:: /' 1,' -;> /' .'- 1.--;"1 ,1 /. .... ~ . .
.. ,r, . _ ~.r .:./'. to/ " . . ',.",. L- / _ / ." (.", L/t, ~ t..,. I "/~
__~____~----~---__--1----------------- ______~ ____ ______-c
7t!,~~-~!~LjL---_---1~ie\~-t:9s::<;t8-.0ji~~-~--
~~__ _______ _________6.-?:tZ!:LJd;~(jj'-.Ei-::.&~U.!.4!;?4T .cYz.
~l~ 4~J\s' -,.. .~-6L~~~S~(lA~s\il-\::L---\:Li~V------------
- . ~ dC/I/! . A -
--j-::~ . ~'_ ~:r~~ '~~~~~~~Qa~(~~;k06L\l(S~C~~, \
~~~.~-/ --~~~~---------------------------------
(--~~~~ -- -- ~----------------------------------
.," ) b.t, ..' ~.~/. C;, G If rJ P:r
,-//.:" }t1--- _' __~j_______________k.2I-Z-5::~~~{~R~~
"
:j\~..,+ "." .
We petition you to VOTE to DENY the above REQUEST.
I
\
I
~
J
f!
.,
!
j
~
1
\
.
r
I
t
Ii
1
1
i
PETITION
to Mayor Garvey ~ City Commissiorler9, City of Clearwater, Florida
Re: LAND USE AMENDMENT and REZONING REQUEST
Z 93-94, LUP 93-43
Lots 1 and 2, Block 3 nnd 1/2 of vacated street
McMULLEN BAYVIEW SUBDIVISION
~Ol 8ayview Avenue, ~OB Meadowlark Lane
We are customers of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET~ next door to the
FINA station. We believe that the addition of a CONVENIENCE
STORE at the FINA will endanger the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET, which
serVes as the Historic Town of Bayview's neighborhood grocery
store and our neighborhood fishing-bait shop.
There is no other fiShing-bait shop in
CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET. Approval would
our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET
supplies, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
the area to replace the
destroy an existing use,
to obtain fiShing-bait
Also, a convenience store at the FINA would destroy another
existing uses our use of the CLEARWATER FOOD MARKET to obtain
neighborhood grocery store supplies, including fresh fruits and
vegetables, WHICH WILL NOT BE REPLACED.
ADDRESS
~-~~-~~~~~--~~~---~-----~--~-------
_ '~--z~c. l"h 'Hr...V.'.rG-S;~ Pre.. ~ Ct W. pG.-
--,~---;-- ---- -------------------------------:::::--------
_~.. ,. ______L~3~-S~-~--~---~~-------
~ rt Jj;is~~~~~~:~--1::tJ/:;~~7~;:;~~~~~~=~
-j~L~KP..:_1J..J.iaIb.- ~.:L-~ (:L J:.I2j-Lc:t,l('RL 01:- LmK-- - ---- --- .
_. _~ ~ -_6.1 __ __ ___ _ _ ?:1Y:.~ _ t!!:.: ~S!.._ _'2 ~.~ ~_~:.l~_::,,=- _~ _-J!..:. ~ l:.._ ~~~_'"::~~_ "> '1<.. <: '-'
~~-)'""J 5 -~. ~]g7()
'---r:(:(~_'-t. d_._ _ _ (G~..: _'_ _ ~~~~~--:. _ 0:~'=._) i:.:.J:" ':.' l. _ (:~ _ -.-~ _ - _ ~ - - _ - - --
!~~(].d.tj.--.Jl1QM..~ .5.. _.~.. ......-.---', ...-.----.---.- --.. --..---.--.---.-- -----
1tM...- ._JCE~~ ~~::/ ..__t~'(J__.rfU.}:~\iLryf2JJ::~"_Y_f__r'_L?:.:L~I~L..!J.:2Qj__.__ -
\ ) ( . fl . ~ c', . ~((,
~<..s..... la -A-' . ....u <I L',:'(" ' C, C (. :) t...( c~ r; C ! vCI ~'- cd "i r
...--']..-. Ya- ~ \.--.' ._____.__~.;J- ~.Si. -~.~.-_-(L_~---"7Z- __u____t::.J_L__
~!J.,J . I I~ \ \ . / /' /1 .~
_ X~C;~YA _z:!-ft?:__ ___L", - XL:!~_~8~_.:"::: --------------
~I llG,b .~L\\j,,'_ UJ,-JYbs~.s.. _ - ... ,-5 t)~: /) _ ji''fj.llJ.. d:ij/1Slt J[L t-Jfij:J ~ - )~( (~ L()
...
-
'!i'~ ..
CITY OF CLEARWATER
Interdepartment Correspondence Sheet
TO:
Mayor and City Commissioners
COPIES TO:
COMMISSION
THROUGH:
Elizabeth M. Deptula. City Manager . ,\ ~
i ard J. Baier, City Engineer fir
om Miller. Asst. Director of ENG/En\liQ~ental
{
. PREsS
CLERK I ATTORNEY
FROM:
AUG 0 9 1995
COPIES:
Pam Akin. City Attorney
Scott Shuford. Central Permining Director
Environmental Advisory Board
Mike Quillen, Water Resource Engineer
SUBJECT:
509 Bayview Avenue House Demolitionl Coop Oil
DATE:
August 9. 1995
The Coop Oil Company FINA station is located at 3009 Gulf to Bay Boulevard. The owner has filed
a "Discharge Notification" with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP~. the agency
which regulates the discharge of petroleum contamination in the state of Florida, indicating that
contamination of soil andlor groundwater has occurred. As a result of this notification. Coop Oil
Company is eligible for state funding through the Early Detection Incentive Program and is not required
by the state to affect any remediation until funding is available through the State Inland Protection
Trust Fund. The site was assigned a low rank of 7.221 out of 10,381 sites. To date.
Engineering/Environmental Management has received no indication that an aerial assessment of the
extent of contamination has begun. Furthermore, there is no date requirement imposed by the state
to initiate remedial action.
\
,
i
\
1
\
!
,
This memorandum will address the concerns raised by Mr. Jack Alvord in correspondence dated
August 1. 1995 related to the subject house demolition (Attached).
, . Contamination Assessment Report (CAR) Requirement:
CitY staff does not have the authority to supersede the DE? with regard to remediation of petroleum
contaminated sites, including initiation of a CAR, Attached is a copy of Section 376.317, F. S. and a
memorandum from Assistant City Attorney Richard Hull which forms the basis for this position.
Through the site plan review process, staff conditioned approval of the FINA gas station expansion to
that allowed by law. yet remains consistent with the intent of EAB motions. as follows:
riA site pollution clean.up plan must be approved by the City. Commencement of the approved clean-
up pIon must occur prior to the issuance of a building permit, and the Clean-up program must be
continuously pursued in accordance with the schedule and conditions in the approved plan ".
This issue has been considered by the Environmental Advisory Board IEAB) since February. While it
has been the EAB's desire to expedite groundwater and soli contamination crean-up through site plan
approvals conditioned with the development of a CAR, state law and City legal opinion denies the EAB
the authority and City staff the ability to seek such a requirement through the site plan review process,
However, staft are continuing to work with the EA8 to formulate a similar requirement before issuance
of a building permit, pending legal office approval. This matter is anticipated for EAB review again in
September. No "resolution" has ever been submitted by the EAB to prohibit any construction related
activity on a contaminated site until a CAR was completed and analyzed by the OEP, referred to in Mr.
Alvord's correspondence.
[0 V.eI?J
-
l'
Memorandum to Mayor and Commissioners
509 Bayview Avenue House Demolition/ Coop Oil
August 9. 1995
Page 2
2. Earth movement on a contaminated site:
Central Permitting issued a demolition permit for the subject house on June 19. 1995. As is typical
with a house demolition, some disturbance of the ground is to be expected, This is necessary to
remove the foundation and to disconnect plumbing services. This limited disturbance should not have
been of sufficient depth to encounter any potentially contaminated soils. However, even if it had been.
it is not against state law to move earth on a contaminated site as long as the soil remains on site, as
was the case with this demolition. Attached is an "Interim Guidance Memorandum" issued by the
Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP~, appropriately highlighted, which confirms this.
3. Uncapped potable water well:
City staff has investigated the possible existence of an uncapped well on this site. The attached
correspondence of July 28, 1995 to Mr. Alvord summarizes our, actions and findings. The City does
not have legal provisions to regulate private water wells. This responsibility is administered by the
Pinellas County Public Health Unit through the Water Oualitv Assurance Trust Fund ISection 376.307,
F.S.l for the DEP in accordance with state law (Chapter 376.302(1 )(a), F.S.l. However, had Mr.
Alvord's claims been substantiated, City Engineering/Environmental Management staff were prepared
to be very proactive to the extent allowed by law and take appropriate action to obtain Pinellas County
Health Department immediate action.
4. City erect warning signs and excavate and cap 'the well:
The City does not have the authority to trespass and erect this type of sign on private property. The
DEP has the authority to place warning signs on certain contaminated sites. The City also does not
have the authority to enter onto private property to search for a well and then cap it.
City staff has spent considerable time assisting Mr. Alvord to overcome his concerns with this property
issue, in spite of the fact that the appropriate regulatory agencies to address .these concerns are the
DE? and the Pinellas County Public Health Unit. At no time has Engineering/Environmental
Management staff ever been "blithe." "reckless," or otherwise "negligent" in the exercise of their
public responsibilities in this matter and we are personally offended by Mr. Alvord's presumptuous
claim to the contrary. Staff have been extremely sensitive to Mr. Alvord's concerns, even to the extent
that they have attempted to have this issue incorporated into the regional planning process as an
emerging environmental issue of regional and significant pUblic health and water quality concern. Mr.
Miller has personally discussed this issue with both the Pinellas County Assistant Administrator and
the Regional Office Director of the DEP. He has also worked to incorporate this issue into the
Comprehensive Conservation and Management Plan for Tampa Bay to force regulatory changes among
supporting agencies. Funhermore, Engineering/Environmental Management Staff were responsible for
the most recent round of potable well water Quality testing afforded to Mr. Alvord to ensure the QualitY
of his water meets appropriate safe drinking water levels, According to our information provided by
the Pinellas County Public Health Unit to date, there have been no maximum contamination level
exceedences for any purgeable organic contaminants related to petroleum contamination. Finally,
throughout this process, Mr. Baier has repeatedly spoken to concerned parties in order to resolve this
issue, including receiving telephone calls to his personal residence after normal business hours.
Engineering/Environmental Management Staff will continue to support the need to resolve this
important environmental issue. Please let us know if additional information is required at this time.
',.: h,',
"
F
L L,; ;Yv......)
.~
fjP,
-
PRESS
. CLERK I ATTORNE
-,
/ ;;r~
COPIES TO'
COMMISSION
....
, ,.-----........
// , \
( August 1, }995
~~d""
Hayor en CommlSSloners
~ y of Clearwater
POBox 4748
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
AUG 0 3 1995
Re: Demolition of the historic Booth house at 509 Bayv
Possible Dangers to Children and to Drinking Water
Hayor and Commissioners,
\l{ ~
I
~ @ l~ 0 w1f
AIJG G B 1995
~ll~=::!'~'':''c.~
ell n. .. ...n
. Ef1.~ . .t:...e.t. M4,N.~Ge.~F
~--
On June 25, 1995, CITY STAFF of the City of Clear~ater issued a
demol i tion permit for the 1 OO-year-old, historic Booth house t . at
509 Bayview Avenue (on the Meador property) in the Historic Town of
BaJ'view.
POSSIBLE DANGER TO CHILDREN
On JulJor 17, 1995, a demolition crew from Sonny Glasbrenner,
demolition contractor, arrived at and clemo~ished the Booth house.
THE CREW HOVED SOME OF THE EARTH BENEATH' THE HOUSE. This was
necessary to remove the house1s foundation and plumbing.
My neighbor, Early.Sorenson, of 517 Bayview Avenue, watched some of
the demolition work, including some of the earthmoving, and took
photographs of it. I also ~atched some of the demolition work, and
saw the crew moving earth. And I talked with the Glasbrenner crew.
r understand from conversations with DEP that the adjacent Coop Oil
Company ~ s FINA sta.tion (also on the Heador property) is an EDI
site. I understand from DEP that this means there is a plume of
contaminated earth and groundwater underneath the FINA and.
extending an as-yet undetermined distance downhill from it. The
300th house is downhill from and less than 100 feet from the F!NA.
I understand from DE? that the only way to determine the extent and
strength or the plume is to do a DE? Contamination Assessment
Report (a CAR). I have asked' CITY STAFF to re~uire tha~ a CAR be
cone on the Heador property, but CITY STAFF has not requested a
CAR, and Mr. Meador and H~.' Smith (Coop Oil Company owner) have not
clone a CAR. Lacking a CAR, there is no way to know whether earth
beneath the Booth ho~se is contaminated. But there is certainly ~
reason to suspect it may be.
~ understand from .the Florida Department of Environmental
?:-otection (DE?) that IT IS AGAINST STATE LAW TO HOVE EARTH
CONTAMINATED BY AN EDI SITE.
Besides being against State la~, the ea:-thmoving at the Booth house
~ay have resul ted in an ongoing endangerment to the heal th of
children. Some of the cii:-t beneath the house was necessaril:-+
brought up ~o the su:-face, ~ith the foundation, and is now exposed.
This earth, if contaminated, may endanger any children who happen
to venture onto the site. ! therefore request that t.he Cit:-"
(Oi/IJ'f?)
Commission dir~ct CITY STAFF to place signs on the site warning
children a\Jay. After a CAR is done, perhaps the ..signs could be
removed.
By~copy of this letter. 1 am warning my fellow Bayvlew neighbors so
that they may warn their children. But other children come down
Bayvlew and may find their way onto the Heador property.
POSSIBLE DANGER TO DRINKING WATER WELLS
As I stated above. on July 17 I talked with the Glasbrenner crew.
! asked them whether they had located the Booth house's old well.
They showed me a four- or five-foot-deep hole behind where the rear
(east) edge of the house had stood. One of the crew told me HE HAD
SEEN THE WELL, AND IT WAS NOW COVERED UP AT THE BOTTOH OF THE HOLE.
I asked the foreman if the well had been capped. He said HE DID
NOT KNOW, AND CAPPING WOULD BE THE WORK OF THE PLUMBER. NOT OF HIS
CREW. No plumber was there, and the crew filled- the hole, scraped
the site level, and left.
.
I talked with the Cityts Hike Quillen on July;25. Hike said he had
called the people at Glasb~enner, and was surprised that they had
admitted seeing the ",'ell. . Mike also reported that he unde::stood
that THE CITY WAS PLANNING TO WAIT UNTIL COMMENCEMENT OF
CONSTRUCTION ON THE NEW FINA STATION, TO LOCATE THE OLD BOOTH HOUSE
WELL.
I talked with Tom Hiller on July 26. Tom said he knew nothing
cbout the uncapped ~ell preblem, and called Mike Quillen into his
office to talk-about it. Tom then assured me that THE WELL SHOULD
NOT HAVE BEEN BURIED ~TITHOUT BEING CAPPED FIRST. Tom said HE
UNDERSTOOD THIS WAS A DANGEROUS SITUATION and HE WOULD SEE TO IT
THAT THE WELL WAS CAPPED BEFORE IT CONTAMINATED MY WELL.
(Perhaps what the Glasbrenner crew member saw was not, but only
looked like, the Booth house's old well. But the City and I need
to know for sure.)
Nayor and Commissioners, I have ~~itten you and appeared before you
and CITY STAFF many times this year to explain this danger.
The Town' of Historic Bayviet... contains many old wells. . In the
1800's and early 1900's, vi~tual1: eve~: house in 'Bayview had its
own deep well drilled into the Florida Aquifer, to oqtain drinking
wa~er. Today, noone knows where all these old wells,are. Any old
well that is uncapped presents a direct connection from the su=face
groundwater (where FINA's contamination is) down ~o the Florida
Aquifer (where our drinking wat.er is) J a direct opportunit~. fo:-
FINA's cont.aminat.ed ground",'ater t.o enter, mix with, ,and poison eu::-
d:inkins wate~. This is why the only way to protect our drinking
water is t.o do a CAR on che FINA site, determine ~he extent. and
s&reng~h of the plume, anc then clean it up (I believe DEP calls
the clean-up a RAP). Right now we are in the rainy se~son. Since
July 17. Bayview has received over 6 inches of rain. This rain
crea~es g~oundwate~ pressure ~hich COllld have fo~ced a lot of the
~.'..~~. ..
F e \,)1' U a r J' G, 1 9 9 5
Mr. Williurn C. naknr
Assistant City Mana~er
Ci.ty of Cln>>rwntcr
Post Offine Rux 414R
Clcnrwntcr, Flurida 34618-4748
"rhan~ you for your January 24, 1995 letter concel"ninc- my appearance
under "Citizens 10 be Hcardh at the Janunry 19, ]995 Clearwater City
Co mm i s s ion M e e tin go . The rei saw e a 1 tho r 1 n r 0 r mati 0 nth a t [ "C: 0 U 1 d not
~ 1ut. rt~. ,~i I h you i nth nth r en In i n u 1 e s 1 W il sol lowed . The ref () r ~, 1 W 0 U ] d
like to share that information with you at this time, but will keep it
as brief and :dmplc as pos::dble. To nccomplish this, J wil] sunlluari7.e
my reply in this letter and reter you to a.list of enclofied, numbered
,. e f c r en c: Po s s h 0 U 1 d J~ 0 u b (~ i n t ere::; t e u i n l:l. m () )' e d e t nil Po d ex pIn n a t j 0 n .
(see refel'enc:e #1)
] don~t feel that anyone individual or group of individuals is
i n ten t ion all y try i n g t 0 h arm rn e 0 r rn y pot a b 1 e wa t e r . w e 1 J. Nor am I'
acousing anyone of doing so. Perhaps it is all a mntter of ignorance~
la.ck of understanding, 'incomplete records, incomprehensible laws,
incompetence, loyolty to, or fear of others in the governing process,
ora com bin a t ion 0 r n 1 lor the a b 0 v e . W hat I am sur e 0 r, h 0 \II eve r, i s
that my well is in dancer of contaminn1ion from the Fina plumfl and no
one is certain that my well is safe or the Health Department wouldn't
be testing it for gasoline c:ontamin~t~s. J want an immediate c]flanup
of that site. My well was here long before the gasoline station and
they didn't take th~ pr~cnutjons nec~~sary to protect my we]] when
they were permitted to build a station on its present"Bayvlew Avenue
and Gulf to Ba~' BouJ~vard site. In ~'Ollr let1er you gave no valid
Ii S sur an c e t hat you l~ 0 u 1 d 0 r W 0 u 1 d p I. 0 tee tan y 0 r 0 u r B a ~. vie \II W e 1 Cs .
(see rCrt~rC'lIc~r-: ;:2 b: '#3)
As late as July 13~ Jn9~!
had non compli~nc0 ltnms.
th:.:; time.
( ~ ~' {' ,. ('" r ~ (' e n f: f' ~ 2 )
1 h e F j n n s tat j 0 n r ~ f '= f' r co d t (I i n ~r (J U r J ~ t t Po r
There is no lo~ or r~cord of compliance at
111 .rOll:- ! t~t I ('!' ~'(Il1 t'(d'~"l'r~<.l 10 the Heal th Department':, long r.tunding
ex per tis e i n w ell man age men tan d p I' 0 lee 1 inn . M .r e x p e ,. i en c ~ i n die a t. e s
t h a 'l m Cl n .r W (l I' kin C" ;:I n d :l h and 0 rll~ d W p. 1 ] ~ <l r e tot nIl ~~ .. un k TI 0 w n tot h e
H c a 1 t h D ~ p n .. t men t. W h ~ n world n bon In~' S t r e r. '\: H ~ a 1 t h D Po par t men t
l'"(lt"J.:CI':; arn forr.~rl to ask IDt! \\'hel'c othr.r' B1-I~'vj ew we]] oS ore] ocatcd.
the .Y C' 0 IJ ] d rI . t ~ v en r i Tl d ;i W ~ I 1 tit i:i t II: asp 0 U r i n ~ d i r t::.", nil y run 0 f r
\\' n l ~ J' i n I (l 1 h f' a qui (e run l ill W n J\u~ d 1 II t 11 e w td 1 s j l c wit h l. hem. I
o.nl ~nrr~' hili \ don' t a~l'e(:' wi tll ,your as~;e.<:;sment (Jf the management and
pn,'tt.'l:tion .'''Ol~ olltl illt>d.
('S~~. f'r.ft.;.'I'n.IIC~ :q'
<EveR)
FINA-contaminated goundwater down through the old Booth well into
the Florida-Aquifer. Every rainfall contributes to the danger.
-
I explained this potential danger to the City Commission on January
29. I wrote Hr. Baker about it (letter attached) on 'February 26.
I appeared before the City's Commission, Planning and Zoning Board,
and Environmental Advisory Board (EAB), to explain it. The EAB
acted on the danger, submitting to you a Resolution that the City
permit no activity which might require any construction (including
earthmoving) on a contaminated site, until a CAR were done and
analyzed by DEP.
Yet CITY STAFF did not request a CAR on this site. Instead, CITY
STAFF PERMITTED A DEMOLITION WHICH NOT ONLY IGNORES THE EAB
RESOLUTION, BUT HAY VERY WELL BE CAUSING POISONING OF THE CITY'S
WELLS AND MINE.
1 am incred~lous at CITY STAFF's blithe and reckless ignorance of
the EAB resolution, and its permitting of an activity which may be
enda.ngering our ""ells. It seems to me that if the City has any
du ty to its res iden ts lit is t.o ensure t-.pa tits drinking \.'ater
wells are safet and if the City has any responsibility to others,
it is to not poison their wells.
".
I request that the Ci ty Corumision have CITY STAFF follow up
IMMEDIATELY, digging back the hole, locating the old well, capping
it, and having SIYF~MD inspect ~nd approve the cap before covering
it up again. Then, I recommend the City Commission reconsider how
CITY STA~F is impl~~enting the EAB Resolution.
AUGUST 17, 1995 VOTE ON MEADOR REZONING/LAND USE AMENDMENT REQUEST
I since~ely hope the City Commission will not allow CITY STAFF to
use its negligent behavior on this matter as another excuse fo~
postponing the Commission's long-overdue August 17 vote on the
Meador Rezoning/Land Use Amendment request. I and my Ba~-view
neighbors have been waiting since March, as you know. we need the
Commission to make up its mind~ on August 17f so we can get back to
ou~ lives, families, and other duties.
Thank you.
Sincerel:" yours I
J(j/.Ac..,$~vt~
~/Ja.ck Alvord .,,-...r.....:.
~~606 Bayview Avenue
Cleerwate~, Florida 34619
\
:
I
I
,
I
i
,
:
cc: John Hubba~c
Bayview residents
Chai~man anc Members I Clea~wa~er Environmental Board
Nancy Evans, DE?
South~est Florida Water Management Dis~~ict
-
~\""~t
1.IST OF REFERf.Nr.r:S
Rl::FF.P.ENCF. #1
1. Plcn~e t1ndp.rslllnd that al 1 Pinel 13$ Count~1 and Clearwater
~itlzens and tourists are dependent upon safe ground water
:; 1I P P 1 j c s. J t s pro tee 1 ion n ~ u j n s t con t n m i n a t j 0 Tl n n rl ~ a J 1 - w a 1 e r
i n t r u s i 0 Il i s 0 f u t m 0 s t i III P 0 r 1 an c e. I n p pea l' e d b e rOt. e t h P.
Commi5siun Dol only on my own behalf, but on behalf of all pc~p)e
dependent upon clean, safe potable water. In the event of a
d i s a s t c r sue has l h eon e i n w hie h h lJ r r i CD n e And r e \II d P. S L J' 0 V P. d
H 0 m e ~ tea <.1, F 1 0 l' i d a, po r tab 1 Po &' en era t 0 I' S co U 1 d b P. h 00 ked L ~ 1 h t!
Jllnny w.:llt-:. in our ilrcn to :-lUPP}Y snfr. drinking water.
REFERENCE #2
.
\
2. In your letter you ~tated that the Florida Department of
,Environmental Protection snid lhat the station operation at Gu\f
to Bay Boulevard was in violation of no rule or regulntion
requiring action on its parL. How do they know this? On July 13,
1994, Richard W. Pugh of the Pollutant Storage Tank Program wro1e
a letter to Jim Smith of the Co-Op Oil Company and outlined a
number of ~on-Compliancc items for Facility ID# 528515207 Fina
3009 Gulf To Bay Blvd. Mr. Pugh required a written response
detailin~ the intended course of action by July 30: J994. When J
ph 0 n e d MI'. P u ~ 1'1 at 2: 50 PM 0 n J an u i:l r .Y 2 i' t 1 995, and ask e d him for
copies of other ~on-Compliance items nnd the rnsponse to his' .Jul~'
1 ::), 1 9 9 4 1 e t t e f', h e a cl vis e d t h a. the did not k e e p the s ern cor d s as
h r: did n 't h a v e spa c: e j n h j ~ f i1 t':-; . When J ask e d him for a. cop:r 0 r
hi:; log 1 i s li n~' Non - Camp li an c e j t ems nn d the co u r sea f act ion
cor r c c tin ~ the ~ e j t P. m z, h r. s aid t II .It h e did n '1. k e P. pal 0 g . H e
oS a 1 d t 11 a 1 M:'. S m i t h had 4' 0 the r s L a t ion 5 wit h pet rot e um s p i 11
p:-ohlt.lU:-: ;;nn 1h;,1 he r:nuldn't rr.llIp.mber \I'ha1 hnppened with the
\'on-Comp! i nnc~ i 1 ('!nl~ 01' .,lIl1~' t:J! 199~. r r ~tr. ru~'h do~sf\' t kl~ep
rncordn .d' !~H':~f' ~":CHI-CnUlplinnc(~ ilem~ or 11'1e df:tniled ;Jction tu
t: Cl f' J' C C t t It e S E' i t em~. h 0 \\' <: any 0 u ~ Mr. W j' a, t t. Tom Mille f' 0 f' an;y 0 n e
~lsc ~(,!JJ me that m~: well i::; snfc from thr: p.x1rp.m~1~r high levels
o f R e n 7. en C. E t h~' 1 b e 1\ 'L C T\t! t l' 0 1 u e n e! X.y 1 e Il e::;! L t: a d t e t r... 0 U t1 i II fl d
!n 'lhr 'rllOl'ntol\ tntH":"nlo"ln~ lctttH. d0l1r.tl Ma,y 14, 1987? For
f'urthel' inJ'ol'l\H".1 inn :,~e LC:lboruLol',y Numbel' 660636. Pl'ojec~t ~o.
-:0-01' n(l~.
{f.-,v;:RJ
-
:.,
Page 2.
l
~
Your stutesnent tb"1. the Fina still ion i~ rcltf$1 creer"wi th tlse FOEP "nnd
i::; in violation of 110 rule or regulation requiring' action does not
t ran 5 1 a 1. t! to" you r \4' ell i s ~ arc {r 0 m ~ 0 n t Ulll i n a t ion II " 1 n 1. r u 1 h 1 the
Fin a con t anti n a t ion co u 1 d bel' em 0 v e d a t n 0 cooS t Joe i the r' the c i t Y 0 r
stntion owner. A city government ll']way~ has the power to protect its
citizens and J believe it is in a position to require that the
pollution he removed regardless of whether' the Fina 5tat10n'$
ap~licalion for Land Use and Zoning changes is approved or not.
(see ref~rcncc #5)
There is n way to re~ove the contamination at the Fina station wi.thaut
cost to the city or stati~n owner. Why can't we start the process
immediately? .
(see reference #6)
Very truly yours,
Jack N. Alvord
606 Bayview Avenue
Clearwater, Florida 34619-4213
cc: ~~ayor and,Ci t.)' Commission
Betty Deptula, City Manager
Tom.MiJ]~rr Assistant Di~ec1~r of En~ine~rin~/Environmental
Wayne Wyatt. Pinellas County Health Department~ Engineering
S~ction
"leI.<> .~"" ~_..
'.'
P.a"'I' :\
, ..
Rr.F'tRt::O-:Ct .t
( ,. D rd , )
pol hl1 n n t ~ i I) t n \ h t~ c: i t ~. 's r (' ~ t~ /' V C' U r IHd H 1J I (~ w;1I lU' . 1 r you ~ ~ n
pl'OV~ me \Vl'un~ un tlais nssuOlptiultt (alld 1 sinct~reb' hopt!' ,you c3n)
ple::lsc furnish mr. with n m;,p 01' l~)liHt or pl'ivnlc C)eDrwI11~f' wells.
the i I' S t 3. t us C\ n d w bet her t h Po Y ;s I' to' 0 I' n r c not a 1 h I' eat 1 0 (\ U I'
ground wuter Nupply.
REFF.REr\CE # 5
5 . 0 n ,p a ~. c 1] 8 0 f the C i t Y 0 r elf: tl r w n t r. reo m p rt~ hen s i v e P 1 a n Ado p t e c1
No v c~ m her 1 6, 1. 9 8 9 ~ \. i t~' 0 w n e d an rl m a i n t a i 11 e d pol a b 1 n well s ~ r ~
covt~f'cd under Conservation. 1 seriously doub1 till-d. (:it~' uwncd
pot a b 1 e \\' ell s are m u c h 0 rap I' 0 b 1 em. The cd 1 ~t m u s tho" can
:nventor:,.' of l.hC'! wells it owns which makns them co:;r 10 monitor,
The wells that .concern me al'C the PI.'ivute wells ~hich !'emaill
unlist.edt unmupped .nnd ignored. Whcre arp. these inr.1uded in the
Comprehensive Plan? Will the next Compreh~nsive Plan includ~
them? Will the next Comprehensive Plan include a plari of actibn to
inform tourists and those planning to mo~e into the Tampa Bay Area
of our ~ritical water shortage? Will they be told that even thos~
'with their own wells have no guarantees of moderately priced, safp.
water? No mention was made in your letter as to who' would pay for
my water if my well is polluted by the Fina station plume. If the
~i ty cannot protect my well) will my city water he furnished free
of cha.r~e if: and when,.m:>-'...well.water..is .poisoned.b:". t.h.e Fina
s'~tion? Who wi]] p~y for it? You didn't mnk~ this clear in your
letter.
P.r.FERF.'>;CE ~6
C. 1 am n(d an ntto;-ne:-" and urn unqualifi.~d to givp, ll~p:nl ad"ic:c in
11I..\ t t c r ::; c n n c c: r n i n b the 1 a \01,' " Howe vel' Tea n I' e a d wit h com pre h Po n s ion
.nbov.p, ;,,,e:'n&:'~~. 1 t:an r~nd nothing in Florida Sli)1utp. ~7? whit~h
\I." 0 U 1 d p (' ~ v ~ n t t h t-! rem 0 val 0 f (: 0 n tam i n a t ion a t l h ~ F i fl::l ~~ i 1 e ,
I lI~:ncl ~hr: ~'l~l low paj;e:; 1'11' :hE: 1cJeplHJrlf~ hook alli! found
Envlronmt:!lltal and EcolQ~'ical Sel'vices \hut arc in the bu:dnes:; (If
cl~aninb ~itcs such us thl~ one foun!l at the Fina ~tatjon, J
c:ontr\c:t.ec..l managers of thesF. businczse~ and War: lold lhC:l.t un
i mm e diD t Po C I fl D n u p co u 1 U h ~ s tar t e d w II i c h w 0 U 1 d c 0 ~ t t 11 c ci 1 Y n n d
~!itc owner nothin~, Sll ....\1.,t.;; the linldup? Is there 0. problem
\'; H h 1 h i $ ';' Has fI 'f ~ n ~' \,) n t'" 1I I tile c j l~. tl :' t: c u n I ~. :~ t a f f 1 e" ':: !
': h f" (: I~ t' cJ 0 fl 1 h j :.: ',\ ~' r' 0 ClI \1' h n ~ ! C lln 1 t' a I' ll, the l' e h a ~ \t e en :i 0 m e
tli'ol::'.'m:- with 11H' con1r..H'~ nnrl hi,l..lin~ l'l'(l(:!,,~::- u:ill. ~:ompllnil!$
want irl~ to c:1 CHIl ':p :i 1:: :illd county ~t1.Il:ami1\at inn, SonH: (.\f thll:~t.
\I' b !1 :.~ ... ~ i r1 ~ h ~ hi, 1 tl i TI ~ P r ('l c ~ S f f: 0 III P 1 ; I ; :: p ~ c ~ h r in;; ;~ 'J n i :.;) led
r(", l'.'lll'.I..):..,\.... '~lo""( 1'110'" l'f' fl"\' ." 'I';" j.: "'11' :.",l }"III1'"
..... ; ... t... . c- ' .. I . '. . ... . ~. tr. .. . ~ I . ,. . t . till'" "
:;l-:lrill., -,~ "'11,' ."'lu1~~ !tar-r~!Jf'r.. !I,"';r'\'::"'!'. :;!' I,' :nH~" 1 h,',~
i ~ w i r! ~) 0 't t. 1:..; ~.1 H :. t .. . t II~' pI' !If" '= ::. \. f (! '.:! ani n;; up t h:' r j 11;1
',~': n 1,1\1\; : '.;, ! i \Il~ ,
(ovlflV
Page 2
REFERENCE "#3
3. In your .January 26,3995 letter you referred to the expansion of
the Fina StalioJl at the corner of Bayview Ave. and Gulf to Bay
Doulevard and said that no il] ~ffect would occur at my site if
allowed to expand under their current status. Does this slatement
ru~nn that 1 will not be grant~d the snma.Kurety if the station is
1I0t allowed to expand? I donlt recall mentioning anything about
the Finn Station expansion during the three minut~s 1 was allowed
before the City Commission Meeting. However, since you seem to
jndicat~ that you are tying the surety that no ili effect will
occur at my site if the Finn Station is allowed to expand into
the Bayview rftsidential area, it nppears thot my well will not be
pro t e c t e d. '1' her e h n v ~ bee n a n u m bet' 0 r It Fin a 1" 5 i t e PIa n s for the
Finn St.ation and all of these plans-, including the, latest, are
filled with errors and omissions. I am sure that the people who
drafted the application and site plans n~ver intended to make
these errors and omissions. However, such mistakes could be made.
to tailor an application to the specifications required for
approval~ I understand that once approved for Land Use and Zoninb
changes, there is a simple procedure available to accomplish the
real and originally intended goals of the applicant. I feel
certain that this is not what is happening in the case of the Finn
station. On the other hand, however, what if I am wrong? Would
you still fet,:l it.wise .to tie, t.he.safety of-,wy.well to the
approval or disapproval of the Fina station application?
REFERENCE #4
4. 1 have been trying to find a chart or map of wells that have been
dug or drilled in the Clearwater area. When people from the
Health Departmen1 monitor my well, they of tun ask if there are
other wells in the al'(~<l. I show them the w~lls I can recall: hut
T am sure that there [He more. 1 kno\l.' of another well at Fred
McMullen's old house und a dug well at the end of the street that
1 forgot ta point' out. It took mor~ than a month before the Health
De par t lU e n' t was a b let 0 cap a 4" we lIt hat r t old the m a h 0 u t. I t
h~d been open far severa] years after Dr. Fred McMullen's old
house war, demolished. \\'h~n the people working on a church parkin{;
] 0 1 ~ :: 1 the we 1] pip e 0 f r he low g r 0 U n d ) eve] and s t n r t e c1
bullcio?,ing' dirt over it, : hecam~ concerned. Dirt~' runoff water'
~I'as pouring' into the aquil'er th3t supplins my well. ,1 am !:ure
t h n t m n n ~' 0 the r v a cat cd. 1.1 n cap p e d. 0 pen \1' el1.!l ex i s tin t h (! c i t~. .
r.;)(~h 1illll' ~n olrlc/' hous(;' t~: lorn down 01' conn\!c1~ to c:it~' ",fllcr'. n
In!!! t.3 itll,'olved. \'.'hat happens to thC\1 well over th~ followinb
~ - c a I' s i z ~ 0 t :1l 1 run k n 0 \1,: n. To day m;,,,,:o' u f 1 II e :0; ewe 1 1 s are p 0 U 1'i n b
, . .
.'
~~~(-t 'iI' ~'.
('
(~'.
., . I
..
CITY OF CLEARWATER
Interdepartmental correspondence Sheet
,
,
. ~
TO:
Tom Miller,' Assistant
Engineering/Environmental
Director
of
Copies:
Scott Shuford, Director/Central Permitting
Dick HUll, Assistant city Attorney
Environmental Advisory Board
FROM:
RE:
DATE:
February 28, 1995
I have reviewed the provisions of 5376.317, F.S.(1993), and
believe that those statutory provisions provide that state la-,.,
supersedes local law with regard to the regulation of underground
petroleum product storage tanks. -I have also reviewed the
provisions of 532.394 and 543.24, Code of ordinances of the city of.
Clearwater, and believe that they do not pertain to underground
petroleum storage tanks and, that even if they did, they would be
superseded by the Florida statutes.
Consequently, I do not believe that you have the authority to
take the action sought by the Environental Advisory Boare at their
l"Jeeting of Februa::-y 15, 1995. (See Hinutes, p. 6). However, I
agree with you that the owner should be encouraged.~o clean ~p ~ha
si~e as soon as possible using fede::-al money while it is available.
. . .. . :';"'~'I';" 7 ~,
:':~'.I' t'; '.~; ~~t. f':;/lt/~ ~:.
-inl -. ._r. ~:-;l-:'~!~'~.:-:w-:='
t I J == :...J ::: I ';: ; ::; I...'
.,'1 ~I t:= lJ:., I::: II \.!: l.; Ill' j,
. J~_.--"'-"'--"--l I
. '~', , J
"1'1'" tilll
. ilJ Ui t.~AR 0 2 1995 iUD.
I . I
. ~i.;'Y (:; ~~J;~:-;::tIT~--
} E:~"::-~~.'~'~,:~.:.: ;~!...~"'~?~~
....._-..~..,___- ~I .'_,"__ ,..
1-, "
t .
I t ~4 I
, ~
, n.
- - h_ - fn) I
:' ::!' ': ! ~ ,I
': _ IQ("'::: t r I I
'-' ==.J _ !
I
I; ': M6~
,--
(pv,E'fO
Ch, 376
POLLUTANT DISCHARGE PREVENTION AND REMOVAL
,'" · '.'.' ",":i::,',', ,'; "'. ,'.', ::." .';X"{'?:( .,',~5{;,.'.:,~;',/e:,'.. {:.::' ;;j,i"\.) :":i:;':,;:~',';", ;'..'.'!.':',' ,,:;,,:,,,\,'i/";" ';:)C.::.........':'
buled 10 a particular der!;!ndant or defendants. each
delendant is liable only lor the costs associated wIth hiS
damages. The burden shall be on the defendant to dern.
onslrale Ihe divisibility of damage!:.
(5) Nolhing herein shan be construed to allect
cleanup program eligibllily under ss, 376.305(7).
376.3071. and 376.3072.
HIIIOI')',-I.~.~. 6)-310.1. 11. c/'I. &4-33e. I. 18. ctJ fl6..159 1 10. c/'I 92.~
376.309 FaclllUes, flnanclo.l responslbility.-
(1) Each owner or a facility i~ required !o. establish
and maintain evidence 01 finanCial responSibIlity, Such
evidence of financial responsibililY shall be the only evi.
dence required by the department that such owner ha:!
the ability to meet the liabilities which may be incurred
under SS. 376.30-376.319.
(2) Any claim brought pursuant 10 ss. 376.30-
376.319 may be brought directly against the bond. the
insurer, or any other person providing a lacility with e...j.
dence of financial responsibilily.
(3) Each owner of a facility subject to ~he provisions
of ss. 376.30-376.319 shall designale a person in lhe
slate as his legal agent for service of process under S5.
376.30-376,319, and slJch designation shall be filed with
the Department of Slale, In the absence 01 such deslg'
nalion, the Secrelary of Stale shall be Ihe designated
agent for purposes 01 service of process under 55.
376,30-376.319.
H..IOf)',-I. e..., 1:-". 1I:l-:)\O. I. \9. ~ll. &&-159.
376.311 Penalties lor a discharge.-
(1) The penalty proviSions af this section do not
apply to any discharge promptly reported and. where
applicable. removed by an operator in accordance with
the rules and orders 01 the department when the site has
been determined eligible for participation in a program
described in s. 376.305(7), s. 376.3071, or s. 376.3072.
(2) Penalties assessed herein for a discharge shall
be in accordance wllh the provisions administered by
the department In chapter 403.
HIIIC>IJ.-I. &<I. tfl. 8.3-310. I \1, ~ll 92-30.
376.313 Nonexclu:siveness of remedIes and indl.
vidual cause of action for damages under ss. 376.30-
376.319,-
(1) The remedies in ss. 376.30-376.319 shall be
deemed to be cumulallve and nOI exclusive. .
(2) Nothing In ss. 376.30-376.319 requires the pur.
suit or any claim against the Water Quality Assurance
Trust Fund or the Inland Proteclion Trust Fl1nd as a con.
dition precedent to any other remedy.
(3) Nolwithstandlng any other provision 01 law, nolh.
ing contained in 55. 376.30-376.319 prohibits any per-
son from bnnoing a cause 01 action in a court of compe.
tent jurisdiction for all damages resulting Irom a dis,
Charge or other condition of pollution co....ered by. 55.
376.30-376.319. NOlhlng in this chapler shall prOhibit or
diminiSh a pany's fight to contribution from olher parties
Jointly or severally liable for a prOhibited dlSct'large ot pol-
:utants or hazardous substances or other pollullon con.
jillons. Except as otnerwlse provided in subsechon (4),
'n any such surt, II IS no: necessary lor SUCh person \0
olead or prove negligence In any form or manner. SUC!]
oerson need only plead and prove the lact 01 the prohlb.
ited dIscharge or olher poilu live condition and Ihalll:"
occurred. The only defenses 10 such cause 01 a
shall be those specified in s. 376.308. 1
'(4) In any civil aclion brought aller July 1, 1
against the owner or operator 01 a pelroleum 5t
system for damages arising from a petroleum Slor
system discharge, Ihe provisions of subsection (3)
not apply \1 it can be proven thai, atlhe lime of lhe di'
charge: .
(a) The alleged damages resulted solely Irom a cfi'
charge 1rom a petroleum storage system Which 'fI"at
installed, replaced, or retrofilled. and maintained. ;0
manner consistenl with the construction. ope rail .
repair, and maintenance standards established for s
systems under chapter 17-61. Florida Administrative
Code, as Ihat Chapter may hereafter be amended, ThG
requirement of consistency with such slandards maYbe
satisfied only by befng in compliance with the standards
atlhe time ollhe discharge, regardless of the lime spe.
Wed for compliance under the schedule provided II) sa)d
chapler. '".
(b) A leak detection syslem or systems or a monilor-
ing well or wells were installed and operating in a manne.r'
consistent with technical requirements of chaplor'
17 -61, Florida Administrative Coae. as that chapter may';
hereafter be amended; and -i
(c) All inventory, recordkeepin.g, and ~epollj.ng'
requirements of chapter 17-61. FlOrida Admlnlslrallv~
Code. as that chapter may herealler be amended, have
been and Bre being complied with. ~
..
Any person bringing such an a=tion must prove negti:;
oence to recover damages unoer this subsection. For.:
ihe purposes 01 thIS subsection. noncompliance with ~
Ihis act, or any of the rules promulgated pursuant
heteto, as the same may herealter be amended. shall~'
prima facie evidence 01 negligence. . "
(5) The court, in issuing an~' linal judgment In any,
such action, may award costs of litigation (including rea~
sonable allorney's and expert witness fees) to a~y
party, whenever the court determines such an award l~~ '
in the public interest. . .,.
Hla."..,.-I.,sA CI1 BJ-310" I. I~. cll. ~.3J6; n. 20. :'1. CII. BIH!i9. I 12. ~.
9~X. J
'''',,'."-E'~''~I Oclobo' 1. ltl9ll. o"'lu.~llo I. 21, ctJ. 86-159..na 'I IfMO"Wd.
101 t....... or III. L.O'"lltu" 'ou''''[l 1M 199Il 'PIlI/I" "g'II",.. ulS.""
'slon, or munic
ad thereunder. l~
"eon1rol, excepl a
t Except as pro\
pts the regulall:
utanl discharge:
-- (1) which has
~ ing 40,000 gall
;v A county gov.
rYwide ordinance.
"tanks. as describ
same as or marc
o"law or rule regul;
a)~ The original ore
- ce belare Septer;
(bf The ordinance
ensive local prograr
,suant to subsectk
6traIes to Ihe departm,
'Cd Ihe stale law or .
filing a petition for
ich has sough I app'
'departmenl prior'
'uired to demonstra"
'red the state progra.
(4) The depart mer
~ove a request to con
"prOgram aulhorized p..
oays atter receipt 0
!1Pproved, Ihe deparlr
.:e local government I;
ance and enforeemer
376,3073. The dcparlrr
callan due to Ihe pOpL
celegate compliance
. .t!:iose local governmt:
as~ate's program jointly.
. d51 The departmen:
. , .rmil any county gOY
ancewith s. 403.182, a
siorage tanks. which pr
SIVa than Ihat establisr.
~~n9 underground stor _
ilPprove or deny a req~
in ordinance establishl"
;ljJ.,.the procedures and t\m~
~in-g Ihe rules, the depar:
Ions Ihal warrant such r
t~tj?n of underground $'
a!~mrled 10. the proximity:
lit source aquller. the pOlo
~SUPPIY because 01 the~'
tanks 10 pUblic wells or ~
petlO1eum products in ;:
(6) A county goverr
regulaling undergrounc
~ as any slate law or rL-
Ea approval by lhe departr
;: 1i11l"'l._1 tJ. Cll. fW-3:>e. I ~.
E. I 6 en BO-JJ1. I 7. en &~.I8E ,
,.,.
i I 376,319 Response
1'",100,-
376.315 Construction of 55. 376.30-376.319,-SeC"":".
tions 376.30-376.319. being necessary for the general"
welfare and the pUblic health and salety of the state and
its inhabitanls, shall be hberally construed to effeclthe
purposes sel forth under ss. 376,30-376.3H! and the
Federal Water Pollution Control Act. as amended.
"II.,OI}.-'. (1./.. ell 83-310. I" ::Z. en fl6..15~
316.317 Superseded laws: state precmplion,-
(1) It any provision 01 ss. 376,30-376.319 .or 01 Ih~
rules developed pursuanlto ~uc~ sections, wnlch proVl,
slon pertains 10 a faCIlity matntalned lor the purpose 0
lhe unClerground storage of petroleum products tor use
as fuel in vehicles, including, but not Ilmiled 10. lhOS~
vehicles used on and 011 roads, illrcrall. watercraft. an
mil. IS In conHiel WIth any olher pro....lslon, hmllallofl. Of
reslriclion WhiCh is now in cllect under any law ot ttllS
state or any ordlnarlCc or a local government, politIcal
1434
F.S. 1993
F.S. 1993
POLLUTANT DtSCHARGE PREVENTION AND REMOVAL
Ch. 376
and that it has
ause 01 action
subdivision. or municipality, or any rule or regulation
adopted thereunder,lhe provision of ss. 376.30-376.319
shall control, excepl as provided in subsection (3).
(2) Except as provided in subsection (3). the state
preempts the regulation of the prevention and removal
of pollutant discharges Irom a lacility described in sub-
section (1) which has no single tan~ having a capacity
exceeding 40.000 gallons at any time.
(3) A county government Is authorized to adopt
countywide ordinances that regulale underground stor-
age tanks, as described herein, which ordinances are
the same as or more stringent or extensive than any
slale law or rule regulating such tanks, provided:
(a) The original ordinance was legally adopted and
in force before September 1, 1984; or
(b) The ordinance establishing a more stringent or
extensive local program is approved by the department
pursuant to subsection (5) alter the county demon.
strates to the department that It has effectively adminis.
tered the state law or rules for a period of 2 years prior
to filing a petition for approval, However, any county
which has sought approval of a local tank program from
Ihe department prior to January 1, 1988, shall not be
required to demonstrate thatll has effectively adminis-
lered the state program for any minimum period.
(4) The department shall either approve or disap.
prove a requeslto contract for a compliance verification
program authorized pursuant 10 s. 376.3073 within 90
days after recerpt of the complete application, Ii
approved, the department shall provide full funding to
Ihe local government to carry OUl the contracted compli-
ance and enforc-ament responsibilities pursuant to s.
376.3073. The department may not disapprove an appli.
cation due to the population size 01 a counly and may
delegate compliance verification and enforcemenf to
Ihose local governmenls who agree to enforce the
slale's program joinUy,
(5) The department is authorized to adopt rules that
permit any county government to eslablish. in accord-
ance with s. 403.182, a program regulaling underground
storage tanks. which program is more stringent or exten-
sive than that established by any state law or rule regu-
lating underground storage tanks, The department shall
approve or deny a request by a county for approval of
an ordinance establishing such a program according to
~he procedures and time limits of s. 120.60. When adopt-
Ing the rules, the department shall consider local condi-
lions that warrant such more stringent or extensive regu-
l~ti?n of underground storage tanks, including, but not
hrmte~ to, the proximity of the county to a sole or slngle-
SOurce aquiler, Ihe potentiallhreat to the public water
Supply because of the proximity of underground storage
tanks to public wells or groundwater, or the detection of
pelroleum products in public or private water supplles,
; (6) A county government may adoot an ordinance
f regulating underground storage tanks that is the same
"' as any state law or rule regulating such lanks upon
t approval by the department of a completed application,
* ~1.1""Y.-I. IJ. CII s..-3J.'l; s. 2':1. ~".Il6-I~'l. i. 5. e".l!7.3h:.. 18. c!1.ll&-l&\.
. . I;ll l!&-3Jl;.. 7. ~h. ~IM.. 13. r.". gZ-;lO
July 1. 1986.
'oleum slorage
.oleum storage
;ection (3) shall
:ime of the dis.
Jely Irom a dis.
~m which was
~aintained. in a
on, operation,
;lished for such
Administrative
amended, The
ndards may be
~ the standards
, Ihe time spec.
rovided in said
,s or a monitor.
.ng in a manner
ts of chapter
at chapter may
and reporting
Administrative
lmended, have
376.319.-SeC- ..
.or tne genera1 :
~f the slate ant{
d to effect th~
. 6,319 and thl!
~mended. :
.J'
emption.- ;...
5.319 or of th~
- s which pro"'"
~he purpose of
'oducts for use
.,ited to. thOse
....atercraft, an4 .
1. limitation, ~
Slny law 01 thi'
"menl, political:
Response actton contractors; Indemnifi.
(DflliR)
(1) The department may agree to hold harmless and
indemnify a response action contractor who has a writ.
ten contract with the department or who has a wrillen
contract with a local governmenl which has contracted
with the department 10 admlnisler a program pursuant
to Chapter 86-159. Laws 01 Florida, for any civil dam-
ages to third parties:
(a) That result Irom Ihe acls or omissions of the
response acllon contractor in carrying oul a response
action; and
(b) That arc caused by a discharge or release of a
nazardous substance, pollutant, or other contaminant
from a site upon which the response action is being car.
ried 01.11,
(2) The department, in determining whether or not
to enter Inlo hold-harmless and indemnification agree-
ments. shall consider:
(a) The availability of cost-effective insurance;
(b) The Immediate need for the response action;
(c) The availability of qualified response action con.
tractors: and
(d) Restriclfng the appiicability of such agreemenls
to exclude gross m~gligence or Intentional conduct.
(3) Any payment or cost, Including the cost of
delending such aclions. which is incurred as a result of
an agreemenl by the department to hold harmless or
indemnify shall be payable from the Waler Quality Assur-
nnee Trusl Fund or the Inland Protection Trust Fund,
whichever Is appropriate. based upon the nature of the
discharge or release.
(4) No state employee or employee of a political sub.
division who provides services relating to a response
action while acting within the scope 01 his authority as
a governmental employee shall be personally liable lor
any actions undertaken by the department, Ihe political
subdivision, or a respons!) aclion contractor pursuant to
this acl. However, nothing In this section shall affect the
liabilily of any other person,
(5) This snctlon Is repealed eHective October 1,
1997, and s11all be reviewed by the Legislature during
the 1997 regular t.=gislative session.
lilotory.-s. ?, r.II.1l6-15~; .. 7, tIl. ea-3Jl,
376.320 Appllcablllty.- The prOVISions of ss.
376.320-376.326 apply only to specified mineral acids
when stored in aboveground tanks. The purpose of 55.
376,320-376.326 rs to prevent the release 01 specified
mineral acids Irom aboveground tanks and to register
Ihe aboveground lanks in which specified mineral acids
are slored, .....
lilolory.-I. 1. a'l. !lO-!09: .. 10. en. 92-30
376.321 Oeflnltlons.-As used in ss. 376,320-
376.326, the lerm:
(1) 'Aboveground. means Ihat more than 90 percent
or a lank volume is not buried below the ground surlace,
An aboveground tank may either be in contact with the
ground or elevated above it.
(2) 'Conlainment and integrity plan. or .CIP' means
a documenl designed, created. and maintained at a
facility, which shall be considered a public record and
made available pursuant to the provisions of chapter
119, and which sets forlh the procedures for the Inspee,
tion and maintenance program for aboveground tanks
1435
'~
I '
. '
. .\"\~ n:~E:1':;(
~-
~'!-- .~
......-: !lp..-~
- , '-
...
FlORTOA
----~ ~- -....
~ -
Department of
Environmental Protection
12.....ton Chiles
Goyernor
Twin Towers Office Building
2600 Blair Stone Road
Tallahassee. Florida 32399-2400
Virgini;a B. Wetherell
Secreury
. - STATE OF FLORIDA
PETROLEUM CONTAMINATION CLEANUP PROGRAM
NOTICE TO INTERESTED PARTIES
"TRANSITION FROM REIMBURSEMENT TO PRE-APPROVED PRIORITY' CLEANUP"
PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 95-2, LAWS OF FLORIDA
Legislative amendments to Chapter 376, F.S., were filed with the
Secretary of State on March 29, 1995 which direct the Department
of Environmental Protection to:
· Discontinue the Petroleum Cleanup Reimbursement Program on
March 29, 1995 with limited exceptions for active priority
sites.
· Reimburse reasonable, allowable, and documented costs for
partially completed p=ogram tasks through March 28, 1995.
· Implement a prioritized Petroleum Cleanup Program based on
pre-approved scope of work and cost, within available budget.
· Provide for pre-approval of necessary free product recove~y
for eligible new discharges as a reimbursable expense.
The Bureau of Waste Cleanup has received many questions
pertaining to the transition. Responses to common questions and
Department guidance based on the provisions of Chapter 95-2,
L.C.F., are p=ese~ted in t~e following pages by the topics listed
below:
1. Sunset of reimbursable activities and criteria for
exceptions;
2. Priority scoring procedures pursuant to Rule 62-771, F.A.C.;
3. Reimbursement for partially completed program tasks and
e~igibility for limited post-sunset activities;
4. Non-reimbursable voluntary cleanup;
5. Pre-aonroval recruests and orooosals;
6. Respon;ible party contractor qualifica~ions;
7. State of Florida pre-approval agreements;
S. Reimbursable free product recovery for eligible new
discharges; and
9. FY 95/96 budget.
"Protect. Conserve cnd Manage Florldo'$ Environment end Nawral Resource$"
Pnnlect on recycled poper.
.
.
--
~ .
,
. .
Page 2
Additional guidance and information regarding the Florida
Petroleum Contamination Cleanup Program will be"posted on the DEP ("
Ecosystem Management & Environmental Education Bulletin Board
Service at 904/922-9334. Please contact Jim Lewis at 904/488-
9334 with questions regarding the BBS. This guidance will also
be posted on the Internet as follows:
Gopher Connection
Address: gop.d€p.state.fl.us
Directory: waste_management
FTP Connection
Address:
Directory:
ftp.dep.state.fl.us
waste_management
If you have further questions regarding reimbursement issues or
pre-approved priority cleanup, please contact staff in the
Petroleum Cleanup Reimbursement or Petroleum Cleanup Sections,
respectively, at 904/487-3299.
1. Sunset of Reimbursable Activities and Criteria for Exception
On March 29, Senate Bill 1290 was signed into law (Chapter 95-2,
L.O.F.). This law provides for cessation of the Petroleum
Contamination Reimbursement Program for new work at all sites ( .
eligible for assistance through the Inland Protection Trust Fund
with the following exceptions:
a. Sites with a priority score of 26 to 49 points that had
initiated the IRA, CA or RAP program tasks as of the
effective date of the law (March 29, 1995) are authorized to
continue until the completion of that one program task. A
single reimbursement claim may then be submitted for the
entire task. Completion of the RP. program task is not
authorized as a reimbursable expense;
b. sites with a priority score of 50 or more 'points are
authorized to complete an active IRA, CA. or RAP program task
like the group above. In addition, these sites may continue
with the Remedial Action program task if implementation of
the aooroved RAP had been initiated as of March 29, 1995.
The pr~visions of Rule 62-773.700, F.A.C., allow interim
reimbursement claims -to be submitted no more frequently than
once every six months during approved remedial action; and
c. Sites with priority ranking scores less than 50 points which
are subject to the following may seek prior approval from the
Department to conduct site rehabilitation and thereafter
submit an application tor reimbursement:
\.~
(ov,.fJ{)
1\'1 f~m ora n dum
Florida Department of
Environmental Protection
'FROM:
Interested part~~
Douglas A. Jone~~hief
Bureau of Waste Cleanup
TO:
DATE:
June 7, 1995
. ~" .
. ,
"
!
SUBJECT: Interim Guidance for Identification of Reasonable
Scope of Free Product ~covery Efforts
'c
section 820 of Chapter 62-761, F.A.C., "Underground
Storage Tank Systems" and Chapter 62-762, F.A.C.,
"Aboveground Storage Tank Systemsll require that the owner or
operator of a facility with a n'ew discharge II immediately
undertake to contain, remove, and abate the discharge"_ In
accordance with this rule, free product recovery must be
initiated immediately upon it's detection as a new release
from a petroleum storage system..
Chapter 95-2, Laws of Florida, requires that, at sites
eligible for state funding assistance, no new petroleum
contamination cleanup tasks be initiated without prior
approval of scope of work and costs. This guidance
describes what will be considered reasonable for free .
product recovery associated with new releases. A proposal
for free product recovery that is consistent with this
guideline may be submitted to a DEP district office or the
appropriate contracted local program for petroleum
contamination site cleanup or compliance verification
activities for authorization to begin product recovery.
Free product recovery proposals that exceed this scope must
be submitted to the Engineering Support section of ,the
Bureau of Waste Cleanup in Tallahassee with a site specific
evaluation of free product recovery alternatives along with
cost analysis and technical and cost justification for
selection of the recommended alternative.
! I
1. A local program tank compliance inspector shall verify
the existence of measurable free product and verify the
need for initiation of product recovery. Evidence of
this verification shall be attached to the free product
recovery proposal.
2. Acceptable free product recovery techniques are manual
bailing, portable low-rate product recovery pumps, and
absorbent materials placed in monitor wells.
1\'>."'. .--..,
MEMORANDUM
June 7# 1995
Page Two
( :- .
3. Initial site visits may be as often as daily. Onc~
product recovery rates drop to less than 1 gallon per
site visit, the frequency shall be reduced to weekly..
Once product recovery rates drop to less than 1 gallon
per weekly event, the site visit frequency shall be
reduced to once every two weeks. Once product recovery
rates drop to less than 1 gallon per two week.event,
the site visit frequency shall be reduced to monthly.
Records of the volume of product recovered from each
monitor well per site visit and document~tion of proper
disposal of recovered product shall be maintained. If.
the recovery rate from each well on site is less than
.1 gallons/well/month or the free product recovery.
operation has been conducted for a period of 6 months,
a report shall be submitted to the DEP district office
or local program office with a recommendation to
continue or cease product recovery operations. Product
recovery may continue if authorized by the district
office or local program office.
Reimbursement shall be limited to reasonable rates for
a field technician at one hour per well per visit plus
local mobilization and demobilization and reasonable
rates for: a vehicle, the initial cost of a disposable
bailer (must be dedicated to the site), the absorbent
material, rental for a portable pump and an oil/water .
interface probe, rubber gloves, tyvec suit, and proper
disposal of the product recovered. Local response
action contractors shall be used for routine site
visits to the maximum extent practical.
4.
DAJ/tc
(0 VJil~)
," .
..
(;..
(:..
..
I .
. /
.
A cou~t order in existence on March 29, 1995 requiring site
rehabilitation; or
A confirmed plan for reorganization in bankruptcy in existence
on March 29, 1995, which was not objected to by the
Department, the financial terms of which incorporate or are
dependent on the Reimbursement Program. .
l
I
I
I
i
r
I
!
1
f
'j
f
I
I
Page 3
.
Questions & Answers
Q What constitutes the beginning of a program task?
A The law stipulates that a site rehabilitation program task
shall be considered to be initiated when actual on-site work
or engineering design, pursuant to Chapter 62-770, F.A.C.,
integral to that task has begun. Contract negotiation and
execution, site research, and project planning are
specifically excluded from consideration.
"Engineering design" is limited to actual design activities
for Remedial Action Plans. Activities such as bidding of
equipment and services, review of proposals, record drawings,
file review, and site reconnaissance, though necessary, are
not considered engineering design. Therefore, these activities
alone do not constitute initiation of a program task with
regard to authorization to complete a task under the
reimbursement program without pre-approval. However,
reasonable costs for such non-design activities performed
prior to March 29, 1995 may be claimed for reimbursement in a
partial program task application.
Initiation of the Remedial Action program task is limited to on-
site activities necessary to implement the approved RAP and shall
not include any activity prior to the date of RAP approval.
Q If my site has a high enough priority score and I. elect to
continue site rehabilitation activities beyond March 28, do I
have to complete tha~ program task before submitting a
reimbursement claim?
A A partially complete task application can still be submitted.
However, eXDenses incurred after March 28 will not be
reimbursable unless the program task has been completed,
except interim claims during approved remedial action which
are authorized by rule.
o Can I submit a partial claim now for activities through March
28 at my high priority site and then submit another clai~
later af~er completing the task?
A Rule 62-773.700 (11), F.A.C., allows only one reimbursement
aoolicatio~ oer orocram task or increment of the RP. task.
A~surn~ng the~e was no change:in priority score, a second
-
I-
, .
. .
.. .
.
Page 4
,
application for the same task (or RA increment) would not be
accepted by the Department. See section three.for-additional (~'
guidanf::e. .
Q How do I obtain prior approval to continue site rehabilitation
for sites with priority ranking scores less than 50 that are-
subject to a court order requiring site rehabilitation, -or a-
confirmed plan for reorganization in bankruptcy?
A The responsible party must submit its request for prior
approval in writing to the Petroleum Cleanup Reimbursement
Section along with documentation that the site meets the,
criteria listed in Chapter 95-2, L.O.F. Persons responsible
for sites subject to a court order requiring site .
rehabilitation should sUbmit a copy of the court order along
with evidence that the site is eligible for the use of IPTF
funds. Persons responsible for sites subject to a confirmed
plan for reorganization in bankruptcy should submit the
following: a copy of the bankruptcy court order confirming the
plan for reorganization; copies of the disclosure statement
and plan for reorganization that were confirmed by the
bankruptcy court order; the docket number of the bankruptcy
court case; an indication of how DEP was listed in the case;
and an indication of where in the confirmed plan for
reorganization the reimbursement program is referenced.
Questions regarding the applicability of this provision to a
particular site should be directed to the storage tank
attorneys in the Office of General Council.
C.,
.~.'::'.A
c.:,. .
2. Priority Scoring Procedures Pursuant to Chapter 62-771,
F .A. C.
,
Site prioritization is established pursuant to Chapter 62-771,
F.A.C., based on the threat to human health and the environment.
Each site is assigned a priority score following determination of
eligibility using information available at the time of
inspection. In the event new information becomes available as
in-depth site investigations are undertaken, a request for re-
determination of a site's priority score may be submitted to the
Petroleum Cleanup Section of the Bureau of Waste Cleanup. It is
suggested that d~cumentation be included with all such requests
to support the specific criteria listed in the priority ranking
rule.
Questions & Answers
Q How long will it take to score or re-score my site?
A At this time there are nearly 800 eligible sites for which a
priority score has not been assigned. In addition, over 100 (
=eauests for re-scoring of sites have been received.
Additional resources are being assigned to assist in site
LOVEf{)
I"
, .:
Page 5
scoring. Delays for i~itial sco=ing and re-scoring may run
from several weeks to several months. A written determination
will be is~ued upon ini:ial scoring or requested re-scoring.
Q Do I have to wait until my site is scored or re-scored to
proceed beyond the cut-off date of March 28 as a reimbursable
expense?
i
f
!
I
I
I
I
i
1
\
,
i
f
!
(
!
1
A Costs incurred for site rehabilitation ~ctiviti~s performed
beyond the cut-off date are not authorized pursuant to Chapter
95-2, L.O.F. The official site priority score as determined
by the Department will be th~ criterion for reimbursement.
However, if the site priority score or re-score has been
determined as of the date of reimbursement application
submittal and 'the score would otherwise have justified
continuation of the program task based on conditions that
existed on March 29, 1995, the activities will be reimbursed
in accordance with Chapter 62-773, F.A.C.
3. Reimbursement for Partially Completed Program Tasks and
Eligibility for Limited Post-Sunset Activities
Reimbursement is authorized for partially completed program task
work performed through March 28, 1995 at sites eligible for
petroleum contamination cleanup funding from the Inland
Protection Trust fund.
Reimbu~sable post-sunset activities shall be limited to the
following unless pre-approved in w~iting by the Department or
exempt from the sunset pursuant to Chapter 95-2, L.O.F.:
a.
Reasonable, necessary and documented activities and expenses
to restore an eligible site to its o~iginal condition prior
to initiation 0: site rehabilitation. Such activities
include: Decommissioning of remediation systems; proper
disposal of recovered product, stockpiled or drummed
excessively contaminated soil and site investigation derived
wastes that were generated prior to March 29, 1995; repairs
to asphalt, concrete, sod, and utility conduits disturbed
during site rehabilitation activities;
b.
Reasonable expenses incurred to preserve the integrity and
security of subsur:ace monitoring wells, recovery wells,
galleri~s, equipment vaults, and buried piping. However, the
Decartment will not reimburse any exoense to remove or
De~anentlv abandon such assets unless the site has achieved
~o furthe=~action or site rehabilitation completion statusi
c.
Reasonable exoenses, not to exceed eiaht hours of
orofessional staff time or 5500, whichever is less for
~reoara t ion of a II S\l."i\I't\ary of ~lork" document to accompany
=ei~ursemen~ applications sU~mitted for partially comple~ed
program tasks. The applicant must summarize all work
performed, provide a chronology of events, and attach copies
....':" ~:~f '
I.
Page 6
of site maps with sample locations, field and analytical data
tables, well and boring logs, etc. Though partially .~,
completed task applications are authorized, complete \
documentation of all activities and expenses is required to
justify reimbursement; and '
d. Reasonable costs for reimbursement application preparation
and review by a Florida Certified Public Accountant.
Questions , Answers
Q Is the Department going to reimburse the full purchase price
of capital expense equipment that can no longer be used at a
site due to its low priority score?
Q Will the Department reimburse re-stocking fees or minimum
. lease terms for .capital expense equipment?
A There is no statutory authority to reimburse capital expenses,
either purchased 'or leased, in any other manner than that
which is outlined in Rule 62-773.600, F.A.C. Therefore,
purchased capital equipment will be prorated at 1/30 of the
purchase price and leased capital equipment will be allowed a
reasonable rate for each month of actual documented and
approved use at the site. Similarly, re-stocking fees and
minimum lease terms beyond the time actually used are not
authorized for reimbursement.
@....
..t ...~
'~~:.::"
Q If site rehabilitation activities were suspended as of March
29, 1995 due to a low priority score (or no score) and a
reimbursement application has already been submitted for ,the
partially completed program task, can a second reimbursement
application be sUbmitted for the same program task if the
score is changed to a higher priority and completion of the
task is authorized?
A Under these circumstances a second application would be
accepted. However, as with interim remedial action task
applications, no overlap of time periods is allowed. It is
suggested that these special circumstances be highlighted at
the time of claim submit~al. .
A. Non-Reimbursable Voluntary Cleanup
The provisions of Chapter 95-2, L.O.F., do not prevent the
responsible party from proceeding voluntarily with site
rehabilitation activities prior to formal pre-approval of the
scope of work and cost in priority order. However, all such
activities must be performed in accordance with all Department
rules governing petroleum cleanup and the expenses incurred will (
not be reimbursable. ~.
lD ve~)
"4
\
.1
Page 7
Questions ~ Answer.s
Q Will my technical report be reviewed and approved even though
I have a low priority score?
A Technical reports'will continue to be reviewed in the order in
which they are received, regardless of priority score, and
approvals or comments provided in writing.
Q If I .encounter contaminated or excessively contaminated soil
during tank or construction activities at my site, am I
reqii:i..'red "to '~rein'ove "'and properly dispose of this material 'at my
" ....: C?,~..:.~~peIl;~.e.~ ::: :':: ~..-: . . ., ".' .
A No, provided the contaminated soil is associateq with the
eligible discharge at the site, it may be returned to the
excavation untreated and will be addressed at the time of
priority cleanup. Unless pre-approved in priority order, the
costs incurred to voluntarily remove and dispose of such
contaminated media will not be reimbursable.
5. Pre-Approval Requests and Prioritization
Selection of eligible sites for pre-approved site rehabilitation
will be from a statewide priority list. The highest priority
will be eligible sites with priority scores of 70 or more points
which have approved Remedial Action Plans, The next priority
will be all other eligible sites arranged by current score.
If the next site on the list for which funds are available is a
State Cleanup site which is not already active, then the state
will conduct the cleanup.
If the next site is a reimbursement site, the Department will
notify the responsible party, advise them of their priority
status, and request a proposal for scope of work and cost from
their designated contractor. Failure to respond to this request
within 60 days will result in the Department assigning a state-
cleanup contractor to conduct site rehabilitation. If the
selected contractor fails to meet the minimum qualifications or
if the selected contractor fails to reach agreement with the
Department on the terms of a cleanup agreement, the Department
will request that the responsible party select an alternate
con'tractor.
!f a request for pre-approval has already been SUbmitted by an
agent of the responsible party, they will be sent a cou=tesy copy
of the notice to the responsible party.
-
I,
~
4
Page 8
Questions & Answers
Q Should I submit a request for pre-approval?
A No, it is not necessary to submit a request for pre-approval.
When it is determined that funds are available the Department
will contact the responsible party, usually the entity t6 . '
which the eligibility order was issued, and request a proposal
in a 'standardized format. '''Unsolicited .requests fer pre-
approval will not be reviewed until that sites priority
ranking score is reached.
Q What happens if I have continued Remedial Action un~er the
Reimbursement Program at my high priority site and that site.
is next on the priority list for pre-approval?
A A request for a site rehabilitation proposal will be sent to
the responsible party. Upon execution of a pre-approval
agreement, all s~b~equent work will be subject to the
provisions of the agreement, including prompt payment of
invoices. Expenses incurred through the date of execution of
the pre-approved agreement may then be claimed in the final
,reimbursement application for the Remedial Action program
task. .
Q If a ~~p has not yet been approved for my site with 70 or more
points, will my site be included in the highest priority
category when my RAP is approved?
A Yes, following issuance of a RAP approval order, the Department
will request a proposal for pre-approved site rehabilitation
from the responsible party.
Q Will the contracted local programs be involved with pre-
approved priority cleanup oversight?
A It is anticipated that this responsibility will be assigned to
contracted local programs. Such oversight will include the'
solicitation and review of site rehabilitation proposals,
.negotiation of pre-approval agreements, revie~ of technical
plans and reports, and approval of all invoices for payment.
6. Responsible Party Contractor Qualifications
All Contractors selected by responsible parties to submit pre'-
approval proposals and negotiate site rehabilitation agreements
with the Deoartment must meet the following qualifications:
~ -
a. Possession of all applicable certification and licenses
required by law;
b. Possession of an Approved Comprehensive Quality Assurance
Plan prepared under Department rules; and
(O'l$^'
(~
~,...
':.........
I .~:;...
(
...
Page 9
c. Ce=tificatlon to the Depa:tment that:
· It complies with applicable OSHA regulations;
· It maintains Workers' Compensation Insurance for all,
employees as required by the Florida Workers'
Compensation Law;
· It maintains Comprehensive General Liability and
Comprehensive Automobile Liability Insurance with minimum
limits of at ,least $1 .million.per.occurrence and $1
million annual aggregate, as shall protect it from claims
for damage for personal injury, including accidental
death, as well as claims for property damage which may
arise from performance of work under the program
designating the state as an additional insured party;
· It maintains Professional Liability Insurance of at least
$1 million per occurrence and $1 million annual
aggregate; and
· It has completed and submitted a sworn statement under
s. 287.133(3) (a), on Public Entity Crimes;
Questions , Answers
Q Do I have to be pre-qualified as a contractor before
submitting a detailed proposal for cleanup?
A No, qualifications will be verified as the proposals are
reviewed. Once a contractor has demonstrated its
qualifications, it will be added to a list of qualified
contractors and this information will not be required fo:
subsequent proposals if the contractor certifies that there
has not been a change in its status.
7. State Of Florida Pre-Approval Agreements
Pre-approval for p:iority cleanup will be in the form of a
written agreement with the qualified contractor. Funds will be
encumbered upon execution of the pre-approval agreement and
invoices submitted in accordance with the terms of the agreement
will be subj'ect to prompt payment pursuant to s. 215.422, F.S.
Questions & Answers
Q Is all pre-approved work subject to prompt payment?
A All cleanup work subject to priority order within budget will
be paid in accordance with a formal agreement and funding
encumb:ances. However, two kinds of activities requiring
prior approval a=e specifically designated as reimbursable
expenses in Chapter 95-2, L.O.F.: court order/bankruptcy
cases; and inspector-directed f=ee product recovery for new
......
'{' f. ~
t .
Page 10
charges. Both of these are addressed elsewhere in this .
notice. These expenses must be claimed for reimbursement", in'
first corne-first served order behind all other previously
received reimbursement claims.
8. Reimbursable Free Product Recovery For New Eligible
Discharges
In accordance.with Cbapter ~5-2~ .L.D.E.~.compliance inspectors of
the Department and contracted local county programs will be
authorized to direct limited scope free product recovery as a
reimbursable expense at eligible sites with a ~ discharge,
subject to the conditions outlined in the attached memorandum.
Such pre-approval by the inspectors will not have to wait for an
incident specific eligibility determination. However, written
notice of eligibility for the specific incident must be received
prior to submittal of a reimbursement claim.
Questions & Answers
Q What type of limitations are there on this free product
recovery'?
A Pursuant to the attached guidance memo, only portable
selective product pumps, bailing, and absorbe~t materials can
be authorized by the on-site inspector for limited frequency
and duration. Reimbursement for more complicated recovery
systems and methods requiring design consideration must be
pre-approved by the Engineering Support Section of the Bureau
of Waste Cleanup.
Q What is considered a "new" discharge?
A One that was first discovered after March 28, 1995, the
effective date of this statutory provision.
9. FY 95/96 Petroleum Cleanup Eudget
Allocation of t~e $152 million 1995 legislatIve budget for the
Inland Protection Trust Fund, exclusive of staff salaries, .is
approximately $100 million for reimbursement of backlogged claims
and $52 million for administration, compliance and enforcement,
local program contracts, reimbursement application review
contracts, state conducted cleanup, and pre-approveq priority
cleanup. .
As the soecific amounts required for each component of the $52
million allocation are established, this information will be
posted on the bulletin board service and internet addresses
listed a~ the beginning of this notice.
C9~EfV
.
..
(~
..;
C;"...
. .'
~ .
C I T Y
,0 F
C LEA R \V ATE R
POST OFFICE BOX 4748
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA 34618-04748
RECi02-02-0e-03
Environmental Management
July 28, 1995
Mr. Jack Alvord
6a6 Bayview Avenue
Clearwater, FL 34619-4213
Re:
509 Bayview Avenue
....
.1
I
!
Dear Mr. Alvord:
This letter is to follow up on our conversations regarding demolition of the
structure and the potential existence of an improperly abandoned potable water
well at the subject address.
The City Building Inspector assigned to this demolition project has no knowledge
of a well on the property and, at my request, reinspected the site on July 26,
1995, but could not find any evidence of a well.
The plumbing contractor for the demolition, R&R Plumbing, confirmed that they
oisconnected a City potable water connection and a sanitary sewer septic tank
connection, but also found no evidence of a well.
The demolition contractor, So~~y Glassbrenner, stated that he has questioned all
of his personnel involved in this demolition job and none of them :?aw any
. evidence of a well. He also exolained that his standard demolition contract
requires capping 0= any potable water wells found on a site and that none were
found on this site.
Consequently, we have no definitiv~ informc:.tion which would indicate the
existence of an improperly abandoned potable well which would have the potential
to convey contamination into the aquifer.
As you know, regulation of private potable wells falls under the purview of the
Pinellas County public Health Unit. If further substantive information is
available regarding the existence 0: an uncapped or ungrouted well on this
property (e.g. historic sampling records, etc.), we would be happy to pass this
on to the health unit.
.,
Michael D. Quillen, P.E.
Water Resource Engineer
xc: D. Wayne Wyatt, P1nellas County public Health
Richard J. Baie~. City Engineer
Tom Miller, Director of Environmental Management
@
-Equal Employmont and AlIirmotl\lo Action Employer-
Ch. 376
POLLUTANT DISCHARGE PREVENTION AND REMOVAL
Hlol"rr,- S ~1. th OO-~
'N01..-S";11O~ J. th ~2\J. \)ansl."lI<l.~ ....l,ng ~gollulhorllle' Ind leloOOs
01 IN Deport""'''1 01 EnW(JO'1,.,..rtal nogul.ll00'\ o"e lne OoDo""","1 01 ,....lur~1
R.WUOtu 10 ,1\0 ~\ll<l""'nl 01 En..onmotnlll P'<>\.tllQl\.
376.305 Removal of prohibited discharges.-
(1) Any person discharging a pollulanl as prohibited
by ss. 376.30-376.319 sholl immediately underlake to
contain. remove. aod abale lloe discharge \0 the salis-
faction of the departmenl. However, such an undertak-
ing 10 contain, remove, or abale a discharge shall not be
deemed an admission of responsibili\y tor the discharge
by the person laking such aclion. Notwllhstanding lhis
requirement. the department may undertake the
removal of the discharge and may contract and retain
agents who shall operate under the direction of the
department.
(2) Jf the person causing the discharge, or the per-
son in charge of facililies at which the discharge has
taken place, tails to act immediately, the deparlment
may arrange for the removal of Ihe pOllutant; except
I"at, i1 the pollutant was discharged into or upon the
navigable waters of the Un1\ed Stales, thE' departmenl
shall acl in accordance with the national conllngency
plan for removal 01 such pollutant as established pursu-
ant to the Federal Water Pollu\\on Control Act, as
amended, and Ihe costs of removal incurred by the
department shall be paid in accordance wilh the appli-
cable orovisions a! that law. Federal lur'lds provided
under thai acl shall be used 10 the maximum extent pos-
sible prior 10 the expenditure of slale lund~,
(3) No action taken by any person to contain or
remove a discharge, whether such action is laken volun-
tarily or at the request of the department or lis designee,
shall be construed as an admission olliabilily tor tile dis-
charge.
(4) No person who, voluntarily or at Ihe requesl 01
Ihe departme"ll or its designee, renders assistance in
containing or removing any pollutant shall be liable lor
any civil damages to third parties resulting solely from
the acts or omissions of such person in rendering such
assistance, except lor acts or omissions amounting to
gross negligence or willtul misconduct.
(5) Nothmg in ss. 376.30-376.319 shall affecl the
right 01 any person to render assislance in conlaining or
removing any pollutant or any rights which that person
may have against any third parly whose acts or omis.
s'lons in any way have caused or contributed 10 the dis-
charge 01 the pollutanl,
(6) Any person who:
(a) 15 not liable lor a discharge 01 pOllutants under s.
376.302: or
(b) Can establish a defense under s. 376.:308: and
(e) 15 not eligible lor a cleanup program under 5,
376305(7), s. 376.3071, or s. 376.3072,
who renders assistance in containing or removing any
pollutant may be eligible for reimbursement of the cost
01 containment or removal in accordance With applicable
reimbursemenl provisions and rules, provided such
assistance IS conducted in accordance wilh applicable
rules relallng to cleanup and the department grants Pllor
approval 01 reimbursement. The departmont shall not
unreasonably withhOld suctl approval. The department
shall, upon pelition and for good cause shown, lwaivc
Ihe prerequisite for prior approval. The cost sharing and
deductible provisions 01 s, 376,3072(2){e) shall not apply
to a reimbursement request made pursuant 10 this sub-
section.
(7) The Legislalure created the Abandon~d lank
Restoration Program in response to the need to prOVide
linancial assistance lor cleanup of siles thaI have aban. .
doned petroleum storage systems. For purposes of this
subsection the term 'abandoned petrOleum storage sys. "
tem' shall mean any petrOleum storage system that has
nol stored petroleum products for consumption, use. cr-
sale since March 1, 1990. The department shall establish ;.
the Abandoned Tan~ Restora\1on Program 10 facilitate'
the restoration of sites conlaminated by abandoned
pelroleum slorage systems.
(a) To be included in the program: .~.:
1. An application must be submllled to the depart':.
ment by June 30, 1992. certHying that the syslem has
not stored petrOleum products for consumption, use, or'
sale at the facility since March 1, 1990. " ,.
2. The owner or operator or the petroleum Slorage..
system when it was in service decided not to continue'
in business tor consumption, use, or sale of petroleum'
products at that tacilily. . ,
3. The sile is not otherwise eligible for the cleanue
programs pursuant to s. 376,3071 or s. 376.3072. .'~
(b) In order \0 be eligible for the program, petroleum
storage systems Irom Which a discharge occurred mus!
be closed in accordance with department rules prior 10
an eligibllity determination. -1
(c) Slles accepted in the program will be eligible f,
reimbursement of cleanup costs as provided in ~
376,3071(12) unless the owner or operator certifies to
the department in writing that he qualifies as a smaJ
business under s. 288.703(1) or a corporation not;!J
profit under chapter 617. ..,
(d) The following Gites are excluded: ..)
i. Sites on properly of the federal Governmen~
2. Sites contaminaled by pollutants that are,.h
petroleum products; or ,
3. SHcs whele the depal\ment has been denl.
slle access, ;
(e) Participating sites are subjeclto a dedUCtible
determined by rule, not to exceed $25,000. .
HIOlgry.-, &l. en 63-310., 13, eh. 8(,..\~9. s 12. en W-!le. s 13 en.;1
, G ell 9;-30. I'drt~ .
"'NI01..- The 'W'Ord J..........C'. ....u' 'ub.t.tutf"fJ lev Ihl" wOld ......"',' bY' 1M
376.307 Water Quality Assurance Trust Fund.';".
(1) There is created iii the State Treasur; the WaJ,
Qualily Assurance Tru5t Fund, 10 be adminislered~
ttle 'Department 01 Environrnental Regulation.
(2) The Waler Quality Assurance Trust Fund n~~f
used 10 carry out Ihe provisions 01 55. 376.30-37 .
other than the prOVisions 01 5S, 376.3071 and 316.~~
101 the expeditIOus restorallon Of replace~enl o~ p~
water supplies as provided In lj, 376.30(,))(c)1.. a r
the inVestigation, assessment, cleanup, restor~ed
mainlenance. and mOnitoring 01 any slle conlarTI1 ....
WIth;
(a) HazardOUS wastes: (;0111':
(b) 'Hazardous substances' as defmed In lhesahon.
prehensive Environmental Response. Campen .
1422
ov/:""R)
-.--."-----------..-...-.- ": .~.....-..~~.-. >......:"~.. .' :'~.' ".. '\' . "."
F.S.l~
!
:ood cause shown, ~w ....
'oval. The cost Sharing ~
5.3072(2}(e) shall not ap~
'ade pursuanllo this cuS
ed Ihe Abandoned T~
lse to Ihe need to proWl
o of si~es thai have ab~
ems. For purposes oJ Iht
;}d pelrOleum storage s~
1 storage syslem that 1\:..'::
: lor consumpllon, use,-::t
;epartment shall eSlabri(
~Ion Program to facirit~
Imlnaled by abandonid
"~
rogram: . '"1
submilled to Ihe deparl..
n9 that lhe system hit
for consumption. use (}'
',1990. '~
f the petroleum storage"
::!eclded not to contin~'
'e. or sale 01 petroleuni
,..
..eligIble lor the cleanyt
. 1 or s. 376.3072. _if
'he program, pelroleum.
!'charge occurred must
oanmenl rules prior 10
'"t
:lram will be eligible fd'"
'ts as provided In s:~
'r operator certifjes to""'
: qualilies as a small
a corporation nol lor~
~
:Juded: i
3deral Government: ,a
~rJulants that are no!.;.
~
nt has been denJ~~
:t to a deductible a;'
$25,000. 1
2, Ch, ~llll;. 13, CII. 91.XlS.-
~ ....... tJ11~. 110'1011, i
ce Trust Fund.- J
Treasury the Waler t
:)e administered by ,
1cgulalion. i
Trust Fund may De ~
;s.3l6.30-376.319.J
2071 and 376.3073:
acement 01 potable-1
:.20(3)(C)1,; and lor~
anup, re storation,1
sile contaminate~
:hned in the Com':~
,. comp,n,alionj
",5. 1993
r>---
POLLUTANT DISCHARGE PREVENTION AND REMOVAL
Ch.376
and Liabili1y Acl 01 1980, Pub. L. No. 96-510, 94 Sial.
2767; or
(e) Except as otherwise provided lor in ss. 376.3071
afld 376.3073:
.:.., 1. A pollutant;
; 2. A substance which is or is suspected to be carci.
: !logoniC, mutagenic, leratogeniC. or toxic to human
. t>eingS, or acutely toxic 10 indigenous species 01 signifi.
: cance to the biological community alfecled by the haz.
~ ardous wasle or substance; or
~ 3, A substance which poses a serious danger 10 the
~ publiC health, safety. or welfare.
~, (3~ The trust fund shaH be funded as lollows:
~ ~. (a} An annual transfer of Interest lunds from the Flor-
:.lda Coastaf Prolection Trust Fund pursuant to 25,
~ 376.1 1 (4)(f).
:. (b) A monthly transfer of the inlerest Irom the State
::f Water Pollu1ion Control Trust Fund.
;: (c) AU excise laxes levied, collecled, and crediled to
r the Water Ouallly Assurance Trust Fund In accordance
:; with Ihe provisions of ss. 206.9935(2) and
~ 206,9945(1}(b).
:: (d) AU penalties. judgments, recoveries, reimburse.
~. mf!nts, and other lees and charges credited to the
;. Water Quality Assurance Trust Fund in accordance with
.: the provisions 01 subsection (4).
(e) Tl",e fee on the relail sale of lead-acid batteries
credited to the Water Quality Assurance Trust Fund pur.
suant to s, 403.7185.
(4}(a) The trust lund shall be used by the depart.
ment as a non lapsing revolving fund lor carrying out the
purposes of 55. 376.30-376.319, olher than those pur-
poses lor which funds in the Inland Protection Trust
Fund may be used as provided in S5. 376.3071 and
376,3073. To this tund shall be credited all excise lax
revenues levied, collected. and credited pursuant to ss.
206.9935(2} and 206.9945(1~(b) and all penalHes. judg-
ments. and other fees and charges relaled to the imple.
mentation 01 ss. 376.30-376.319, olher than those penar.
ties, judgments, and other lees and charges related to
the implementation of S5. 376.3071 and 376.3073.
Charges against 1he Waler Ouality Assurance Trust
Fund shall be in accordance with this section,
(b} The department shall disburse moneys in the
Waler Quality Assurance Trust Fund lor actIvities as
authorized under subsection (2) according to the follow-
ing priority order;
,. Emergency actions necessary to protect the
PUblic heallh. salely, and welfare.
2, P. evious obligations.
3. Resloralion or replacement 01 contaminated pri-
vale potable wells or waler systems.
4. Response aclions earned oul pursuant to the
Comprehensive Environmental Response. Compensa.
tion, and liability Act (CEACLA).
5. Cther response actions carried out or authOJized
by tne deparlment.
6. Other authorized activities. except 'hal, upon a
determInation by the secretary that sulhClcnl unobli-
sated funds are not available in the trust lund to ade.
qualely lund any activity or acllvltlea under this subpara.
sraph, tile secretilry may elecl 10 dIsburse nvailablc
moneys 10 parlially lund such activity or activities. or to
wllhhold lunding lor such activity or activities.
(c) However, lunds used as provided in Ihis section
shall be expended for waler supply systems or fillers lor
conlaminated potable waler wells only as lolfows:
1. Persons with contaminated potable waler welfs
Ihat were permitted and constructed after January 1,
1989, in accordance with slandards adopled pursuant
to s. 373.309 shall be eligible for:
a. SUbsIdies for connecting to existing water sup.
ply syslems or exlensions thereof, provided that no such
subsidy shall exceed the present worth ollhe 10-year
cost 01 providing and maintaining fillers tor Ihe residents
served by the connections; or
b. Fillers and tilter maintenance to provide treal-
menl for water Irom contaminated wells sulficJent to
assure its potability. However, no filler shall be provided
for a potable water well designed to provide water to a
household that is pari 01 a subdivision or development
of a size that would. according to the departmenl. be
more eltectively served by a water supply system, If
such subdivision or development received its develop-
ment order nIter January 1, 1989.
2. Subsidies 10 persons developing new water sup-
ply systems to be permitted and construcled alter Janu.
ary 1, 1989. In accordance wilh slandards adopted pur.
suant to s. 373.309 because of actual or potential con.
taminatlon 01 potable water wells, provIded that no such
subsidy shall exceed one-half of the present worth of
the 10-year cost of providing and maintaining fillers for
the residenls to be served by said syslem.
3. The mosl cost-ef/eclive remedy. as determined
by the department. for wells drilled prior 10 January "
1989,
(5) Except as otherwise provided by law, the depart-
ment shall recover to the use of the lund from a person
or persons at any lime caUSing or having caused the dis-
charge or Irom the Federal Governmenl, Jointly and sev.
erally. all sums owed or expended Irom the fund, pursu.
ant \0 s. 376.308, ex.cept lhat the deparlment may
decline to pursue such ro::overy II 1\ Iinds the amount
involved too small or the likelihood 01 recovery too uncer-
tain. Sums recovered as a resull of damage due to a dis-
charge of a pollutant or other similar disaster shall be
apportfoned between the fund and the General Revenue
Fund so as to repay the lull costs 10 the General Reve.
nue Fund of any sums disbursed Iherelrom as a resull
01 such disaster, Any requesl for reimbursement to the
fund for such costs, if not paid within 30 days of
demand, shall be turned over to the department lor col-
lection.
(6) Moneys In the lund which are nol needed cur-
rently to meet the obHgalions 01 the departmenl in the
exercitoe 01 its responsibilities under ss. 376.30-376,319
shall be deposited with the Treasurer to Ihe credil 01 the
fund and may be invested in slJch manner as is provided
lor by statute. The interest received on such investment
shall be credited to the lund. Any provisions of law to the
contrary notwithstanding, such interest may be freely
transferred between this trust lund and lhe Inland Pro.
tection lrusl Fund, in the discretion 01 the department.
(7) Except as otherwise provided by law, it ;s the
duty or the depar1menl in adminislering the fund dill.
'423
I
r
\:-
J ; :
I, .
.; . ~
II:
~ ~ '
~ :
~ i .
~ I .
.1 i;
i '
Ii !
I ! \ .
, ;.
ill \ j:
\1 i I :
\1 !
t11 ;1
" '
llil:
tIll:!;
If 1\; :.
~1!.l l.
:!~l; 'll
:~ t
I' !
1,: Ii
'1,1
:i i I
". i~ '
.,.~
;.h I
If.. ~
.~I ~; ;
::; i L:
"'t . ~
1; ! j ,
r I
j It I'll ;
.; if
. (;ll
Iii lj.
, "
1'111.
d!/.~.. .
CIl. 376
POl~~TANT DISCHARGE PREVENTION AND REMOVAL
F.S. 19~
gently to pursue the reimburSement 10 Ihe fund of any
sum expended from tne lund lor cleanup and abatement
in accordance with the prOIJISIOnS 01 thIS section. unless
Ihe department finds the amount inyol....ed too small or
the likelihood 01 recovery too uncertain. For Ihe pur.
poses 01 s. 95.11, the limitation period within which to
inslitule an action 10 recover such sums shall com.
mence on the last date on which any such sums were
expended, and not the dale that the discharge occurred.
HIIIOf)'.-s Il-l. C1l. llJ-:llO. I. 3. en. 8,)-353. I. 10. en. &c-33ll. ... 3. 14, 3-1. e~
00-'59,1 1l2. ell. M-'lIJ,' .. eI'1. M-39J; ..11. cll. ~111;. 12. C1l. 00-331; I.
'I, clI. i',X6; ., 5, th 92-'5.
'Nol..-S~loQ/\3. cJI, 9J..213.1""llt,,~.n 'OIII'ng Iogll'~llIOrllltl and .~II(lI1S
Of 1M 0. PAnmenf 01 En...CInmOnlal Rtgvlal<Q<\ '<'<3 I'" 0.(>&""""1 1)1 tI'\U1.1
~.IOUtCA!' 101M Doa.rtlNnl 01 ErrvvOf'otnIonf.' PtolKhon.
'N01..-S~b.101~le<l by 1M ."donl",. I.I.'ance II) S 376 H15)(0110 ~onfo<m 10
11>1 "numbtr~ M<;tll<l.I.O by.. ~. e. .no 301. t/1. 66- 159.
376,3071 Inland Protection Trust Fundi creation;
purposes; fundlng.-
(1) FJNPINGS.-In addition to the legislalive findings
set forth In s. 376.30. the Legislature 'indS and declares:
(a) That significant Quantitles of petroleum and
petroleum products are being stored in underground
storage systems in this state, which storage is a hazard.
ous undertaking;
(b) That spills, leaks. and other discharges Irom
such storage systems have occurred. are occurring, and
will continue 10 occur and that such discharges pose a
significant threat to the quality 01 the groundwaters and
inland suoaee waters 01 this state;
(c} That, where contamination 01 the ground or sur.
lace water has occurred, remedial measures have alien
been delayed lor long periOdS .....hile determinations as
to liability and the extent 01 liabllily are made and that
SUCh delays result 1n the continuation and intensllicr:.tion
of the threat to the pUblic health, salely, and welfare; in
grealer damage to the environment; and in significanlly
higher costs to contain and remove the conlamination:
and
(d) That adequale financial resources must be read-
ily available to provide lor the expeditious supply 01 safe
and reJJable allernalive sources 01 potable water to
sf/ected persons and to provide a means for investiga.
tion and cleanup of contaminaticn sites withoul delay.
(2) INTENT AND PURPOSE.-Il Js the intent of the
LegIslature to establish the Inland Protection Trust Fund
to serve as a repository for funds which wHl enable the
department 10 respond withoul delay to Incidenls of
Inland contamination related to the storage 01 petrOleum
and petroleum products in order to protect the public
heatlh, safety. and wellare and to minimize environmen.
tal damage.
(3) CAEA TION.- There is hereby created Ihe Inland
Protection Trust Fund, hereinafter referred to as the
Olund: to be administered by the department. This fund
shall be used by the department as a nonlapsing revolv.
ing lund lor carrying out the purposes or this section and
s. 375.3073. To this fund shall be credited all penalties,
judgments, recoveries, reimbursements, Joans, and
other lees and charges related 10 the implementatfon 01
this seclion and s. 376.3073 and the excise tax revenues
levied, collected. and credited pursuant to S5.
206.9935(3) and 206.9945{1 He). Charges against the
fund shall be made In accordance with the provisions of
this section.
{4} USES,-Whencver, in ils determination, inci.
dents 01 Inland contamination related to the storage of
petroleum or pelroleum products may pose a lhroat to
the en....ironment or the public health, satety, or weltall!,
the department shall obligate moneys available in the
lund \0 provide lor;
(a) Prompt investigation and assessment 01 contam.
Ination sites:
(b) Expeditious restoration or replacement 01 pota.
ble water supplies as provided in s. 376.30(3)(C)1.;
(c) Rehabilitation 01 contamination sites, which shall
consisl 01 cleanup 01 sHected soli, groundwaler, and
inland suoace waters, using Ihe most cost-effeCtive
alternative that is technologically leaslble and reliable
and lhat prOvides adequate protection of the pUblic
heallh, safety, and weJlare and minimizes environmental
damage, in accordance with Ihe site selection and
cleanup criteria established by the department under
subsection (5). except that nOlhing herein shall be con.
strued 10 authorize the department to obligate lunds lor
payment of costs which may be associated with, but ale
not Integral 10, site rehabilitation, such as the cost lor
retrolitting or replacing petrOleum storage systems;
(d) Maintenance and monitoring ot contaminalion
siles;
le) Inspection and supervision 01 activities
described in this subsection;
(I) Payment of expenses incurred by the depart,
ment In lis efforts to obtain Irom responsible parties the
payment or recovery 01 reasonable costs resulting from
the aclivilies described In this subsection;
(g) Payment of any other reasonable costs 01 admin.
istration. Jncluding those administrative costs incurred
by Ihe Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services
in providing field and laboratory services, toxicological
risk assessment, and other assistance to the depart.
ment in Ihe investigation 01 drinking water contamination
complainls and costs associated with public information
and education activities;
(h) Establishment and implementation of the compli.
ance verification program as authorized in s.
376,303(1)(a), including contracting with local govern.
ments or state agencies to provide lor the administration
01 such program through locally administered programs, '
to minimize the potenliallor further contamination siles; '.
(i) Funding 01 the provisions of ss. 376.305(7) and _
376.3072; .
U) Activities relaled to removal and replacement of .'
petrOleum storage systems, exclusive 01 costs of any
tank, piping, dispenSing unil, or related hardware,. II
such activities are juslflied in an approved reme~lal :
action plan ior sites at which site restoration is bemg .
completed pursuant to subsection (12}; ..
(k) Activities relaled to reimbursement application .
preparation and activities related to reimbursement.
application examination by a certified public accountanl; .
(I) Reasonable costs 01 restoring property as neart)' -
as practicable to the conditIons which existed pnor to :
activities associated with contamination asst!ssmenl or "
remedial acHon taken under s. 376.303(4); and
(m} The Inland Protection Trust Fund may only be
used 10 fund the activities in 5S. 376.30-376.319.
~
Nothing il
Inland Prl
lion cau!';
deiined il
when th('
wastes, e
of chemic
ucts and
for Ihe sIc
206.01(13
excluded
.assure th!
10 pay re
not utltizt:
conductec
tralive sla~
provisions
menl del\';
bursemen
rate of leSl
and if, afte
mitments
which are
ance of tl"
SSO milllor
. limitation t
, (5) SIT
. (a) Thr
. orltles for
'. tamrnalior.
. need not t
't'. Th,
welfare m.
lion:
~ 2. Thl
contamin~
3. Tht
ler or surf~
the probe
at1et:ling.
known pu ~
. 4. ThE
ment.
r.'_.
M~neys In
cescrlbee
Bccordanc
nothing ;n
~he depart
rehabiHtatil
". (b) Th~
. Jhe purpo~
the rehabl
. rehabilitatli
made In ac
at which a
.lallon pro~
'such site
formed by
OWn perso
tont/acto!:
takes a SIt.
gible and c
~
.,
1
"'
,.
~
1424
evE/V
-
POLLUTANT OISCHARGE PREVENTION AND REMOVAL
and related a
ares thai it Is
rt and comple
','ater Pollution
se provisions r
~ removal ot
Flow-thrOugh process tanks include, but are not
~ied to. seal tanks, vapor recovery unils, surge tanks,
d lanks, feed tanks. check and delay tanks. batch
IDroks oil-water separators, or tanks in which mechani.
. physical, or chemical change 01 a material is accom.
ed.
. 9) .Hazardous substances. means those sub-
.c es defined as hazardous substances in the Com.
. shens;ve EnVironmental Response, CompensaHon
- UabUity Act of 1980, Pub. L. No. 96-510, 94 Stat.
fiT. as amended by the Superfund Amendments and
-"uthorization Act 01 1986.
"10) .Op3rator. means any person operating a facility,
Iher by lease, contract, or other form 01 agreement.
(11) .Owner" means any person owning a facility.
(12) .person' means any individual, partner, joint 'len'
or corporation; any group 01 lhe foregoing. orga.
",' or uniled lor a business purpose: or any govern-
'iltal en Illy ,
131 .Person In charge. means the person on the
ne who is in direct, responsible charge of a facility
. which pollutants are discharged, when Ihe dis.
ge occurs.
(14) 'Person responsible lor conducting site reha.
\.aUon' means the site owner, operator, or the person
ignated by the site owner or operator on the reim.
. ement application. Mortgage holders and trust hold.
.' may be eligible to partiCipate in the reimbursement
.. ram pursuant 10 s. 376.3071(12).
15) .Petroleum' includes:
8) Oil, Including crude petroleum oil and olher
rocarbons. regardless of gravity. which are pro.
. d at the well in liquid lorm by ordinary methods and
't;t\ are not the result 01 condensation 01 gas alter 11
ves the reservoir; and
" ) All natural gas. Including casinghead gas, and all
er hydrocarbons not defined as oil in paragraph (a),
16) 'Petroleum product" means any liquid luel com-
ity made Irom petroleum, including, bul not limited
'!Jlllorms of fuel known or sold as diesel luel, kero-
.e, all forms 01 fuel known or sold as gasoline. and
.Is containing a mixture 01 gasoline and other prod-
".. exclUding liquefied petroleum gas and American
. ety lor Testing and Materials (ASTM) grades no. 5
no. 6 residual oils, bunker C residual oils. intermedi,
lfuel oils (IFO) used for marine bunkering with a vis.
ty 01 30 and higher, asphalt oils, and petrochemical
stocks,
(\.7) .Petroleum slorage system' means a stationary
not covered under lhe provisions 01 chapter 377,
ther with any an site inlegral piping or dispensing
.~rn associaled therewilh, which \s used. or intended
Used, lor the storage or supply 01 any petroleum
. UCI, PetrOleum storage systems may also include
.lJwaler separators, and olher pollution control devices
. led at petroleum product terminals as defined in
~apter and bulk producl lacilities pursuant to, or
Ire(! by, permits or best management practices in
e~ortlO Contlol surtace discharge 01 pollutants. Noth.
rein shall be construed to allow a conllnuing dis-
. ge in vlorallon of department rules,
ad In ss, 376
16.3'9, unless
e term: . ~
substance la
storage tank
hazardous
temperature
: capacity.g"
Ch. 316
(18) 'Pollutants. includes any 'producl' as de/med in
s. 3i7 .19(' 1), peslicides. ammonia, chlorine, and deriva-
tives thereof, excluding llquelied petroleum gas.
(19) 'Pollulion' means the presef'lce on the land or in
lhe walers 01 the stale 01 pOllutants in quantities which
are or may be polentially harmful or injurious 10 human
health or welfare, animal or plant lile, or property or
which may unreasonably inlerfere wi1h the enjoyment 01
lile or properly, including outdoor rec:reation.
(20) .Response action. means any activity, Including
evaluation, planning. design, engineering, construction,
and ancillary services, which Is carrIed out in response
to any discharge, release. or threalened release 01 a haz.
ardous subs lance, pollulant, or other contaminant Irorn
a facility or slle Identified by the departmenl under the
provisions ot ss. 376.30-376.319.
(21) 'Response aclion conlractor' means a person
who IS carrying out any response aclion, including a per-
son retained or hired by such person to provide services
relating to a response action,
(22) 'Secretary. means the secretary 01 the 'Depart'
ment of Environmental Regulation.
(23) 'Storage system' means a stationary tank not
covered under the provisions of chapler 377, togelher
With any ensile inlegral piping or dispensing system
associated therewith, which IS or has been used for the
slorage or supply of any petroleum product, pollutant,
or hazardous substance ao defined herein, and which Is
registered wilh the IDepartment 01 Environmental Regu-
lation under Ihis chapter or any rule adopted pursuant
herelo.
t11'10"",-~ &i.l:!\ e3-3\Q; I 6. en. 54.335: I. 11, Ch &,..,S\).. 2. Ch. tfl-'M,
~ Z2. et1. OO-!>l: s. 9, ell. 9I)-9!l; I. \2. Ch. 91-:m; I. J, ell 9'2.30.
't1~'..-SKI1Cll3. et1. 93.213. tranlt.rrt'd 1""III"'9Ie~lllulht"llot:' lrod Ie lions
01 I". CG~rlmenr ot Enwonrnentl' RfOullloon lrod Ih. O.garltno1nl (II N.tural
R.JOulC.. I~ In. OrPlrlrntnl 01 ErM'onmenll' PI(lrtCllO'l
376,302 Prohibited acts; penalties.-
(1) II shalt be a violation of this chapter and it shall
be prohibited lor any reason:
(a) To discnarge pollutants or hazardous sub-
stances into or upon the surlace or ground walers of the
state or lands, which discharge violates any departmen-
tal 'standard. as defined in s. 403.803(13).
(b) To fall to obtain any permit or regislration
requIred by this 'part or by rule, or to viulate or fail to
comply with any statute, rule, order, permi!, registration.
or cerlHication adopted or issued by the department pur-
suant to lls taw/ul authority.
(c) To \mowingly ma}(e any raise slatement, repre.
sentation, or certification In any application, record,
report, plan, or other documentliled or required to be
maintained under this 'part. or to falsity, tamper with, or
knowingly render inaccurate any monitoring device or
method required 10 be maintained under this 'part or by
any permit. regislration, rule, or order issued under thiS
'p~Ht.
(2) Except as provided in s. 376.311. any person
who commIts a violation specilied in subsec~ion (i) IS lia.
ble to the stale for any damage caused and lor civil pen-
allies as provided In s. 403.141.
(3) Any person who willfully commits a violation
specified in paragraPh (1)(a) or paragraoh (1)(0) snail be
guilty 01 a misdemeanor of the first degree punishable
1419
. .
1,
~
r
"
l'
i ,;i
~ fl
" ,I
I' ;;~
, '
!, ,['J
,.
,.
, I,
:ii
:,
iii
I
f
, IIi
I,
I
i i j !
ii I
I l'
~
,,/
\<-~_ c \ 1./
".f . .~
/L.~
,,;--.
\..... /,..t
i"
I.}
cg', } r; .'1 )
K e c' v
/L~
~
?5'r J r; , v15
I
'l r5
~c\J
.
.AJZ
~
~ (r;.c17
l-
I .
thr@
.' .
_c'" . .
, 4:.:.,
'1
" "
"
.'
, .
" .
'. ," '
"
c... .
. .
.~,. '
, '
. .'
!,'
'.
. .~'tl"';l-.oll.u:1:..I>-<"'h ".:.~,..~~'. .;<( ... ,
, ~ " <
, '
'~ ~ .
, . . ,y.. ~,~ . - , ""'~"'.""-.
I
*?
. I
i
I
I
I
'l
.j
I
i
I
I
,
!
i
SEE AGENDA DRA \\'INGS
Q'11.Q5
.' .
- , . .
','
.. .
, .
,.
. . , . . . .
1 .
!
I'
!
,..
F js-t!
. ' ~/
" ,
,o!; ..
:'.1,", ' .
.:,'.
... ~ ~ .
.., ,
, .
'. ).'t,,""1,..~,,;~,:......, ol." ,J.,_ ." .c
... '. " ',' .
, <" ':;',' '.. ., c' c, ~, ,
.." .
0,
',.. ... ,
" ,.,4 ~ . .
-,' u,. .
I. '. ~ .' ~
:1
"
.... :.'.
AGENDA
DATE
F~ J7~ 95
.,..... .
ITEM # 9
"1
(j.,.""
h' .
~.'
f-~
~.l
'/'
'-~i
~~- .
F /570
'. .
i:tt"',lY " f <,< .
Cf 'd--. C;<'. I '7 . q 5
CITY COMMISSION SIGN VARIANCE CONTINUANCE
SV 95-31
I
THIS ITEM WAS CONTINUED FROM THE CITY COMMISSION SIGN VARIANCE MEETING
OF Julv 20. 1995
WAS THE ITEM DISCUSSED BY THE COMMISSION? rgJ NO
o YES (SEE SUMMARY~
SUMMARY:
WAS THE AGENDA ITEM REVISED? t8I NO
o YES (SEE SUMMARY)
SUMMARY:
OTHER ISSUES/COMMENTS:
~ >. .. , . '.' .
~
,.
'. ,
c~~ ~
Clearwater City Commission
Agenda Cover Memorandum
I tern #I -:--G-
Meeting Dote: ----=-t-
<6 . 1,/ ,cr 5
SUBJECT:
Variance to the Sign Regulations; 387-1/2 Mandalay Ave.; Homer Realty, Inc./Wedgwood House Estate
Jewelers (Owner/Applicant); James K. Fowler and James A. Martin, Jr. (Representative).
(SV 95~31)
RECOMM ENDA TION/MOTION:
Approve the following variances: (1) an area variance of 11.5 square feet from the permitted 22.5
square feet to allow attached signs with a total area of 34 square feet, (2) a ratio variance of 0.77
square feet of attached sign area per foot of building width to allow 2.27 square feet of attached sign
area per foot of width, (3) a variance of two window signs to allow five window signs, and (4) a
variance of two attached signs to allow a total of seven attached signs, on property identified as Lots
23, 24 and 25, Block A, Barbour-Morrow Subdivision, for meeting Sec. 45.24 Standards for Approval,
items (1 )-(4).
o and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND:
The applicant is requesting the following variances: (1) an area variance of 11.5 square feet from the
permitted 22.5 square feet to allow attached signs with a total area of 34 square feet, (2) a ratio.
variance of 0.77 square feet of attached sign area per foot of building width to allow 2.2.7 .square feet
of attached sign area per foot of width, (3) a variance of two window signs to allow five window signs,
and (4) a variance of two attached signs to allow a total of seven attached signs.
The subject property is located on the east side of Mandalay Ave., north of Marianne St., and is in the
Beach Commercial zoning district. The variance is requested to permit the existing signs to remain.
Pertinent summary information is listed in the following table.
Reviewed by: Ori ginating Dl!pt: Costs: $ lUA c~ission Action:
Legal NIA CF.NTRAL PERMITTING Total 0 Approved
Budget N/A 5;' 0 Approved w/conditlons
Purchasing N/A $
Risk Hgrnt. NIA Current Fiscal Yr. 0 Denied
CIS ~ User Dept: 0 Continued to:
ACH Ftnting Source:
CRT 0 Capital 1~.
Advertised: 0 Operating Attochlllents:
Date: 0 Other APPLICATION
,'fl.') Paper: Tampa Tribune VARIANCE YORKSHEET
0 Not Required HAPS
SWai ttcd by: Affected Parties 0 None
i~n~U , ~ Notified Appropriation Code:
0 Not Required
ct ana r
, I
~ Printed on recycled paper
...........
SV 95~31
Page 2
I Information I Existing I - Permitted I
Type of signs Attached Yes
Location/orientation of signs Mandalay Ave. Yes
Area 34 sq. ft. 22.5 sq. ft.
Number of attached signs 7 signs 5 signs
Number of attached signs of same 5 signs (window signs) 3 signs
type
Ratio 2.27 sq. ft./1 ft. of 1.5 sq. ft./1 ft. of
storefront width storefront width
Staff Comments/Proposed Conditions:
This property has four small shops adjacent to the public sidewalk on Mandalay Ave. Each of the
shops has a canopy sign of like color, size and design.
The variances are for the jeweJery shop. A total of 22.5 square feet of attached sign area is
allowed for the jewelery shop. The applicant is requesting variances to allow 34 square feet of
attached signs, or 2.27 square feet of sign area per foot of storefront width. Additionally, the
applicant is requesting variances to allow five window signs instead of the maximum three
permitted by code, and a total of seven attached signs instead of the maximum five permitted by
code.
The appearance of this jewelery store does not detract from the appearance of this business
district. The canopy signs create a motif which reinforces the cohesiveness of this complex. The
signs in the windows of the jewelery store are nonilluminated, low impact signs. Furthermore, the
canopy signs and window signs are serving different purposes. The canopy signs are directed to
motorists on Mandalay Ave. and pedestrians across the street from the jewelery shop. The
window signs are placed primarily for pedestrians on the sidewalk in front of the jewelery shop.
Strict enforcement of the code would not, in this case, enhance the appearance of the beach or
the City.
'~~.' ."
VARIANCE WORKSHEET - CASE NUMBER SV 95-31
STANDARDS FOR VARIANCE APPROVAL
11 J There .ra Ipec'-l cllcumltencu relatad to the parttcular
phV-lcal lurroundtngl. .hlpa or topographical condltlonl
appllclble to the lend or building., and .uch clrculllltanc..
ara peculiar to .uch land or bulldtngl end do not apply
ganerllly to the land or bulldlngl In the appllcabla zontng
dlttrlot.
(21 Tha .trlct application of the prov!.lon. of tha coda would
deprive the IIppltcant of tho rall.onable un of the land or
building..
(3) The verlanca II not be..d exclu.lvely upon tha d..tre for
economlo or other mat.rlal gllln by thll IIppllcant or owner.
(41 The granting of thll vlulllnca wlll bo tn harmony with the
ganaral purpon and Intent of the land dovolopmont coda and
oomprehenltva pian and will not be matarlaUy InJurlouI to
lurroundlng propartlel or other wile detrlmenta' to tho publlo
wolfare.
STAFF F1NDINGS
Thll property hili four ImtllI .hop. IIdJacent to tha publlo
.ldewalk on Mandaley Ave. Each of the Ihop. h.. II ollncpy
"gn of like color, liz, end dulgn.
The varian au Irl for tha jewelery .hop. A totlll of 22.6
Iquarl feet of attlch.d .!gn area It Illowed for tha Jewalery
.hop. Thll applicant II requeltlng varlancel to allow 34
.quar. feat of IUached .!gnl, or 2.27 .quara feet of .\gn
IIru par foot of Itorafront width. Addltlonllly. thaappllclnt
II requa.tlng verlan~1 to lllow flva window Ilgn. Inltead of
the maximum thr.. permlttad by code, IIInd I total of IOven
auachad l!gn. In.taad of tha maxImum flva permItted by
coda,
The eppuranca of thl. JaweJery .tore do.. not detraot from
the appearance of thll bUllne.. dlatrlct. The canopy .Ign.
crllllte II motif Which relnforcet the cohetlvene.. of thll
complex. The .Ignl In thl window. of the Jewelory Itor" are
nontl1umlnated, low Impllot .Ign.. Furthermoro, the clnopy
.\gn. and wIndow Ilgn. are nrvlng dlffer.nt purpo.... The
cllnopy .\gn. are dlractad to motorlat. on Mlndelay Ava. and
pedettrlan. IIcro.. thl Itreet from the jewelatV Ihop. Tha
window .\gn. are plaCid prtmarlly for podlltrlan. on tha
.Idewalk In frcnt of tha jaWlllry .hop. Strlctanforcement of
tha code would not, In thlt clla. enhence the appaarllnce of
tho blllch or the City.
Strict enforcement of tho cod. would not, In thl. Cllle,
enhance the IIppurencll of the bllllch or the City. The
epPollrance of thlt J-welery .tore don not detrllot from the
appeerllnce of thll bu. In... dlltrlct.
The varlanca requalt appearl to latltfv this condition.
The l!gn raDulatlon. were IIdcpted with the Intant of
enhancing the vl.ulIl quality of the CltY'1 Itrntl end
hmdlcepo In ordar to protect the vlltua of propertla. IInd the
well-beIng of thllloclIl tourist oriented economy. The
grllntlng of thl. Vllrlancll appeareto be con.lltent with thl"
Intent.
SV 95-31
Page 4
Relevant Previous Decisions by the Commission:
ATTACHED SIGN AREA
CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING
BEQUESTED/ACTION DATE
SV 92-19 27001 U.S. 19 J.C. Penney 329 sq. ft,/Denied 10/15/92
Co.
SV 92-42 714 Cleveland St. Trickel 70 sq. ft./Approved 2/9/93
Jewelers
SV 93-73 2200 Gulf to Bay Goodyear 136 sq. ft./Denied 11/9/93
Auto
SV 93-37 20505 U.S. 19 Burdines 185/185 sq. ft./Denied 1124/94
SV 93-96 1499 Gulf to Bay Barnett 43.5/49.5 sq. ft./Approved 1/24/94
Bank
SV 93-32 20505 U.S. 19 Poston's 194 sq. ft./Approved 2/7/94
SV 93-49 1420 S. Missouri Good 22.6 sq. ft./Approved 2/7/94
Rentals
SV 93-106 704 Court St. VVorkbench 7.9 sq. ft./Approved 3/21/94
SV 93-39 20505 U.S. 19 Dillard' 5 21.26 sq. ft./Approved 4/19/94
SV 92-90 423 East Shore Olympia 51.6 sq. ft./Denied 4/27/94
Motel
SV 93-65 24791 & 24826 Ken Marks' 128 sq. ft./Approved 6116/94
U.S. 19 Ford
SV 94-26 110 Island Way Island 8.8 sq. ft./Approved 8/4/94
Estates
Realtv
SV 94-35 2907 S.R. 590 Johnny's 8 sq. ft./Approved 11/3/94
Italian
Restaurant
SV 95-14 675 S. Gulfview Continental 10 sq. ft./Approved 3/16/95
Towers
SV 95-20 387 Mandalay Lappert's 4.8 sq. ft./ Approved 4/20/95
Ave. Ice Cream*
SV 95-17 2495 Gulf to Bay Builder's 102.25 sq. ft./Approved 5/4/95
Square
*The ice cream shop is located adjacent to this jewelery store.
" .
SV 95-31
Page 5
RATIO
CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING
REQUESTED/ACTION DATE
SV 92-34 1685 Gulf to Walgreens 2.9 sq. ft./1 ft. width - 9128/93
Bay Denied
SV 93-69 1 645 Gulf to 3D-Minute Coin 0.79 sq. ft./1 ft. width - 11/9/93
Bay Laundry Approved
SV 93-32 20505 U.S. Poston's 1.57 sq. ft./1 ft. width - 2/7/94
19 Denied
0.72 sq. ft./l ft. width-
Approved
SV 92-90 423 East Olympia Motel 1.1 sq. ft./1 ft. width - 4/27/94
Shore Denied
SV 95-09 1520 Musicana Dinner 2.9 sq. fi/1 ft. width - 3/16/95
McMullen Theatre Approved '
Booth
SV 95-20 387 Mandalay Lappert's Ice 0.32 sq. ft./1 ft. width - 4/20/95
Cream* Approved
*The ice cream shop is located adjacent to this jewelery store.
NUMBER OF ATTACHED SIGNS
CASE # ADDRESS NAME VARIANCES MEETING
REQUESTED/ACTION DATE
SV 93-07 801 Phillies Jack Russell 1 wall sign/ Approved 11/9/93
Dr. Stadium
SV 93-78 1 200 Missouri JC Penney 1 wall signl Approved 2/7194
Avo.
SV 93-60 603 Missouri Clearwater 4 attached signslDenied 3/21/94
Ave. Outboard
SV 93-93 2126 Drew Mac's Sports 1 attached signlDenied 4/19/94
St.
SV 93-87 830 Court St. R.J, Automotive 1 wall sign/Denied 4/19/94
SV 95-11 249 Clearwater 2 wall signs/Approved 3/2/95
Windward Marine Science
Passage Cariter
SV 95-09 1520 Musicana Dinner 4 window 3/16/95
McMullen Theatre signs/ Approved
Booth Rd.
SV 95-23 467 Mandalay Eckerd Drugs 2 wall signsl Approved 4/20195
Ave.
VARIANCE WORKSHEET - CASE NUMBER SV 95-31
I STANDARDS FOR VARIANCE API'ROVAL I STAfF FJNDCNGS I
111 Ther. .ra .paclal clrcum.tllncllt ralat.d to the particular Thl. proparty ha. 'our .mall .hop. adjacent to the publlo
phy.ICIII .urroundlng., .hap. or topographical condition. .Idewalk on Mandelay Ava. Each of the .hop. hll. II canopy
appllCllble to the land Of bulldlngl, and .uch cl!cum.tanctlS Ilgn ot Illce color, .Ile and dll81gn.
lira paoullar to .uch land or building. and do not Ilpply
generally to the land or bulldlngl In the applicable ~onlng The variances arll for the Jawe!ery .hop. A totel 0' 22.6
dlstrlot. .quele feet 0' IIttached .Ign arllll 18 allowed tor the Jewelery
shop. The IIppUcant I. requeltlng varlanclII to allow 34
Iquare feet of ettached sign., or 2.27 .quar. fe.t 0' .lon
IIrea per 'oat at .tor.front width. Additionally, the appl1011nt
I. requutlng varlanoe. to allow 'Ive window .IOn. In.taad of
thll maximum thr.. permitted by oode, and a tote I at teven
attached Ilgn. Inltead 0' the mulmum flv. p.rmltted by
oode.
At 'Ir.t blu.h, the verlance rllqull8t .eam. quite Iarg.. The
requll8ted .1gn Iuea It e 61 % departure from thll code.
Howevar, thl. C111oulatlon Includas \ho 'pl!lCII betwoen "Ettatt
Dlamond./ "Cu.tom Design," and "We Buy Diamond. &
Oold." It 111.0 Includll8 the 'pace blltween "14K Oold
Chllln.," "Florida Charm.... and "Expert R.palr on P,.ml...."
If thala vllcant Ipacn ware oxcluded from tha (laloulatlon,
tho sign are II would bll 21.8 'qullrll teet which would
conform to code. It would not b. Incorrect to calculale thll
.Ign elllaln thl. manner: however. It would not negate thll
nelld for verlancu. Inltlllld, It would Inareuo tha varlanc.
requlltt. for the number of window .\g.,. and the numb.r 0'
attachod .Ign. becaUlIII .Ign. which wllre treated.. onll,
would nead to b. traetlld lit thrn.
,. Theeppearanoe 0' thla jewelery store don not datraot from
the eppenrllnce of thl. bualnlll' dl.ulot. The ollnopy .Ign.
oreete e motif whloh "Inforo.. thll oohellv.n... of thla
complex, The .Ign. In the window. 0' the Jew.lery ator. lUll
nonlllumlnated, low Impaot .Ignl whloh Iue viewed prlmerlly
by pedlllltrlan.. Furthermore, the Ilgn IIren vlulancl may not
be quite a. lIIC.trema. a. the numbe" Indloate becau.. the
c.lcullltlon Includllll .ome vaCllnt .paoe. between ""uagel.
Strict enforcamlnt of the code would not, In thl. can,
enhance the appearanclI of the buch or the City.
121 The .trlot application of tha provla[o!\. of the oode would St.lot ento.cement at tha codll would not, In thl. oan,
deprive the appl1cant of the rea.onable u.e of the land or enhance tho appearanc. of the beach or the City, The
buIlding.. eppearanoe ot thla Jewelery ttore dcn not d.trect from the
appellftlnCII of thl. bu.lneu dl.trlct.
131 The variance It. not bued exclu.lvely upon the de.he for The varbmce raqu..t appeDr. to utl.ty this condltlon.
economic or other meterlal gDln by the applicant or owner.
141 The grllntlng of the variance will be In harmony with thD The .Ign reguletlons were adoptld with tha Intent of
general purpou IInd Intllnt of the land development oodellnd enhancing thl vllulIl quellty of the Clty'a .trnt. and
comprtlh.nalv. plen and wlll not be metarlally InJurlou. to lllnd.capeln order to protect the valulI a' propertlllll and the
.urroundlng propertl.. or otherwlle detrlmentlll to the publIc well-being of the IoclIl tourlat orlent.d aoonomy. Th.
welt.rll. grentlng ot thl. vllrl.noe IIppUfI to bit oonllll.nt with thl,
Intent.
'I, .~ j. '. '
5000
~
l '15
ER(S} NAME & ADDRESS:
errv OF CLEARWATER
SIGN VARIANCE APPUCATlON
9 5~ 31
SV#
REPRESENTATlVEIS) Uf nny) NAME & ADDRESS:
Bomer Realty, Inc.
627 Cleveland Street
Clearwater, FL 34615
James K. Fowler and James A. Martin~Jr.
P.o. Box 1669
Clearwater, FL 34617
TELEPHONE: 181'31 461-1000
TELEPHONE: 181 3 ) 4 4 1- 8 9 6 6
ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTV: 387-l.; Mandalay Avenue, Clearwater, FL 34630
NAME OF BUSINESS (IF APPUCABLE): Wedgwood House Estate Jewelers
ZONING DISTRICT: CB
LAND USE CLASSIACATJON: RFH
LAND AREA: 0.2 acres
LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: Barbour-Morrow Subdivision, Block A,
Lots 23, 24, 25.
PARCEL NUMBER: 0 8 I 29 I 15 I 02592 I 001 I 0230 IThis information
is available from your tox receipt or contact Pinellas Co. Property Appraiser's Office at 462-3207. If more thon one
porcel number, attach 8~ x 11 inch sheet}
DESCRIBE SURROUNDING USES OF PROPERTY:
North: Curio shop
South: I ce-cream shop
East: Sportswear Store
West: Parkinq lot
VARlANCE(S) REQUEST:
1- A variance of 11.5 square feet to permit attached signage to remain.
2. A variance of 2.27 square feet per lineal foot of building width.
3. A variance to allow two additional permanent attached signs to remain.
4 . A variance to permit two additional permanent windo\ol signs to remain.
REASON FOR REQUESTING VARIANCE(S): (Ref~ to Standards for Approval. next page)
~. ..~ ~.. .
PLEASE SEE ATTACHED.
CONTINUED ON REVERSE SIDE
.'
"
~~/~~ '.;1.
STANDARDS FOR APPROVAL: A variance shall not be grantod by the City Commission unless tho application and
evidenco presentod clearly support tho following conclusions:
(1) There ore special circumstances related to the particular physical surroundings, shape or topographical
conditions applicable to the land or buildings. and such circumstances ore peculiar to such land or buildings
and do not opply generally to tho land or buildings in tho applicable zoning district.
(2) The strict application of the provisions of tho code would deprive the applicant of the roasonable use of the
land or buildings.
(3) The variance is not based exclusively upon a desire for economic or other material gain by tho applicant or
owner.
(4) The granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of tha land development
codo and comprehensive plan and will not be materially injurious to surrounding properties or otherwise
detrimental to the public welfare.
HOUSE ESTATE
"\
~I/-
-.....c
Jr:~'.J
Sworn to and subscribed before me this ---9J:h
day of
May
A.D., 19 95',
by
James K. Fowler
, who is personally known to me andlor has produced
N/A
as identification.
STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PINELLAS
:J4~~1l, ~4df
Notary Public, Commission No.
Kymrn N. Kidwell
(Name of Notary typed. printed or stamped'
...",0'1' "uo. Ol'FICIAL NOTARY SEAL
o (. K
~ 'n~i rr n YNN N I(IDWl!LL
... ~l. .,',,. COMMI15910N NUMBER
~ ':'.;1:- or CC174047
7"" .:,;' Q
t:' 'oQi- MY COMMISSION EXP.
OF f\. FEB, 14 1996
"
Page 1 of 2
1. The building owner required that the canopy sign be compatible with other canopy
signs. This used 11.9 square feet of the allowable 22.5 square feet. The canopy
sign cannot be seen by pedestrians or traffic proceeding north on Mandalay
A venue since the building has an extensive overhang which protects the ~~dewalk.
The landlord has been non-negotiable in removing the canopy signs or allowing
it to be altered to reduce the amount of square feet used.
2. Since there is no parking in relation to the storet the business relics upon walk-in
customers. The canopy sign is not visible from the sidewalk and does not benefit
the business based on the patrons who frequent the store.
3. The store front is narrow (15 feet) wilh respect to its length (90 feet) which limits
the permitted signage. Were the building obviously located with its greater
dimension being its depth or lengtht the' existing signage would meet code.
4. The additional window signs use a painted back drop to help shield against the sun
in the late afternoon and also to hide the shelving which forms the base of the
window display. Removal of the small painted strips would reqti ire removal of all
of the window casings.
5. Additionally. the landlord has installed a drop ceiling in the building. The
windowst however, extend well above the drop ceiling. The upper painted
portions of the windows shield against the intense sunlight and covers the area
where the ceiling is dropped. Removal of the upper painted portion requires
redesign of the ceiling at the front of the store.
6. The signs have been in existence on the windows in excess of fifteen (15) years.
In an effort to show good faith and to attempt to comply with the sign ordinance,
the business owner has removed additional signs which appeared in the doorway
and entrance way.
7. The strict application of the provisions of the code would deprive the applicant of
the reasonable use of the land or building in that the establishment of a jewelry
store in this area is both unique and rare. The property throughout the business
district is primarily restaurants and wearing apparel shops. Given the extremely
small frontage of the building, the additional signage is the only notice to the
public that such a business is located on the premises and differentiates it from the
other surroundingt more generic business establishments.
n.....~.~~.,...h .~~...
"
Page 2 of 2
8.
The granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general purpose and
intent of the land development code and comprehensive plan and will not be
materially injurious to surrounding properties or otherwise detrimental to the
public welfare. The signs are tasteful (not garish), subdued, and are informative.
Since this is a beach business district, the signs are harmonious with the intent of
the comprehensive plan. To the knowledge of the owner of the business, none of
the surrounding businesses have claimed that the signs of \Vedgwood House Estate
Jewelers are injurious to their surrounding properties or otherwise detrimental.
There has been a concerted effort by the City to upgrade the caliber of business
on Clearwater Beach. A fine jewelry and estate jewelry store clearly fits within
those purposes. To reduce its ability to corhmunicate with the walk-in traffic upon
which it primarily relies would be injurious to the comprehensive scheme for
development espoused by the City.
'. .
, I
II
; I
j I
I
1
II :\DA T A \A lY\JAM\FOWLER\V AlliANCE
. ..
-""""'1_'"
--~...._~~~~
~'IIIiil:\W""I-,",,~
~____.___~ t!:l
iiiilJ--_'-
) "
.'
'"
r
..,
,
(~.,.
(]\~';
I
'. .,..... . G ~ r:
::
-
r-t
>(
::
.....
,
t>.
'.
fJ-.nJl
~.
,;
,
)
I
,
I
>
(
L
L"".--
I ".,.' .. .".~ ...
-
. . ." .
. '
r(
~ \...!j
)... l.:.:{
,
, (2
'-';I
.....
\i)
t: t
~ EO 1
I
.i L-1 .-\ !
~I' 3. .d =t ~
l>< >< X ,>< U
::
t.? : :: .......\.. 1;l1.
I.. 1"1
M I~
...., v-
I
~ ' . 'I, ;v,
..-;.:. Z:? If.
'" '. t j<!,
'-...1 t. l.:j 1":
':l~ ':..t' 'f
~) ~J . ~~
1(,1,
.::.) ~ 'V)
':.j, 1c..l
-l c: .....
C') ; if:
"
c...!.I 1;:.) \:; J ! I~I
~ : <.. . , !d:
. ; /-'
-.:} " : 2;
..:
..... ~, ' I
G..- , I tt I
\(
o,q) . 1.1
-LI
"". I
oJ
,
'.1 I;
1Av' I
d .... ~ I
:!:~
'. <r -\.\ I
-.,":1 -
gt': 'II ~ r-
:} ~
.... ...
"":'a "t. \1 'll l
\it -';";
3~ I
- I
@ i
1
I
, .
.-",.p . -- -
'-;g Z
~
:;: c.!J
<:to t'C
-
C) 0
~
F
VI
;::;.
U
G?)"J:. ::,,;
.i' &
'. ~
"
/",-r\';-"~'..tV\
\
r'
,
\'
~
\
\
(
)
\
\.
t 1
\~ ~.~ .
J ..-..........
,/ '..j
.~ (&?,
) cd]
< ,-
) ) ~:!J
\ c'
\ .,.??
I (,:::::_ >-
{
\
(
(~~
'r<)
Cl ~
,t
~ ~
" ....
~ I
'2..
I:l '.
~ r
lI: r
2;
--.-. --- ...... -- ...__u :'1" _.- .--,
"j
VI
\q
c,
-21
'1 ~ I
~l
~l
~I
~I
-)
-j
I
, >J' ..--.....'
.....-:._ .......c-.
L!J
~-
'. . 2 ~.
.""\ n. 1"1 }~ Vl
,:j ::to ..::t
'<. ~ :.<;, -\... \-
a :;, l"J
l1 h r"') ~..\..
-
clJ
'.lJ
:..
~
^
q;
-~
.:;;
~
<
-$
.:..:
..J..r\
I:'.,
OJ
M
-
\....-)
-..
II
.
-\-=-\,
~
"
1i6~ ....L
t
-..:: 131.1.
~:
PAPAYA
Q
.'
U~ .lWI-~
.! p-,....:..
""
"
..
1
5
- ;",
I' .,rc
112 -;-;;
IIJ~
M ,;;;1
.H7~20 =~..GUHIJ IlJ u
445;;r! IV ~ U 441;/ .t ,.":1H/$
U3l:>U 14 !:' 4U ~
eo u'~y 1~ HZ 1411 1~"44Z
tJg ....,& / __ "" _ /39 .,/n,
C" - ~ STREET
/ ~~ ..., :g: 1 :i: I
432 435 '3~
/33 2 /30
.,31 U8
4 Z9 J 426
4:7 "N
.,:5 4
\ .,
.... \ S'
OR 60:14-1 O~7 . \
~ FOUR SusO S j
I.ANTlIN1S co roo
/ 10 -35 _ - 1
-CO
I
I ('I
L'2"'-:m~ ~
nr-I 400/
, I .23/01 (J
.
..
~
'-le~7
.
, Il2 /437 1
/36 ,
433 J
"3' t
429 ~ "28
.!.E..~ ~'tO -l28
"2.5 7 '"""I 424
.,23 ~ -co JV 4t2
421 V ~ 420
"19 ~ "'8
",,; 11'::: 4'6
"'6 12 -.:j 41./
413 13 J 412
41/ It ( I-. "\ "'0
tOI} I~ :7-"""'''08
407 Ie J.) "-
405 17 Jt "04", ,
403 III 40Z ~I
401 l'j JJ "00 J .~ 10
f 2O:t: --. I 1'\
397 2' ::> 32 \1
2' ') , "
Y9!1'c~..t3':" / 39: 392
3IU.:,~'l!4'.:':" " 39 12390 t;j
I Sinh:. ~.~,. Jll I I ~
ndP/ ~~ ::: :: .L L- /381 :841
OR Z:I)5-6n ~ '92 389 1& 2~ I bO sA/; 14'1111>/60 I
\ ~:E l ~81 JI '''1[;" 7
" /
~, CI1 7 ~_:lOQ ~ OR 7V~-~ I
0: OR ~9W':::-. "- .....
o 927 I ~ _____
~ 5 7
o 200) ~
J N I ~ p~ -8
CAUSEWA Y
-t\ \?
CO ~
12
4'
.....
~
J
S
,,2.3 ~
6
~
-1>J
v
L.s
~
I i) I
7
4
o
I 3 ~
jJ--;:~ E
I r--- 1['
. r
I ~ ~
lIlll 5 I~R t;'; :::p~~
...... · 'f 7' ~
.... , :2~ w
i 1 u. ~ g
~ ~ 0
CI: ..... S!
i ~ ~
> ~
I
BL\ID
0>
o
73 lCDl ~
11
.
"0.. Y'"
'<? r"
~~
~~ I"'{
hlol \ ().
~~c
WATER LOT 1
1::>ee
"..,..,
, --.-......
r
J
:\9 t -Vue. PARK
~ ".16-187~
r
-....
4:'0
45:1 II
/61
I U
119
fI
,
-HI I E!4
2 ri5 j
"ZS J 7
.7
",!?, ~ ,
..
-~-4 .
7
~~
9 1
10
....1
"05 II
L{)
"OS 17 -.;tt
1J I
-..:..
.-
HC\1,
TREET ~ ____ .
.-- ~
8 ~ J~: 9;:Od Co Slol,
~1 z:;; ... 9~~09
,0.. ;:l m 19
'z.;~ I :g e J
D>
o
1
-
~
--1~~
~~
/
/
SIGN VARIANCE. REQUEST
NAME: HOMER REAL TY CO. / WEDGEWOOD HOUSE ESTA TE JEWELERS
SV # 95-31 PUBLIC HEARING DATE: JULY 20, 1995
ATLAS PAGE: 267A SEe: 08 TWP: 29 S RGE: .1Ji E
CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION
......" ,."t"II. ~... ,
..
..
I
------,
I , ~
I', I
I .. S ~ -u_~~" ~ ,
f ~\''';''~~t \ CD -~~,~,~ ~ irOo(l~~"''' ~
I G,lp l; III .
I '\ ~ ~ ~
' ~ ~ I
{J : ~~ I ~;.~ ~I\ {~. ~..">o.o~ C"'O
\ ~ i ~ J
-\_~_.I '$'_--, ,,<F "'--
~~ .~u, ['"~~-l" Q ~ ':'j" "... '-\1-
f ~ I 1
· t I ~. ,~,..~.~ ,
~.o> .9 i U ./ i
Lt~ L_-,,'o..-r '~JJ' I d
... =. J:
bE;. ~
-
~ ~ 5
I ';lAY OI~OlJOc L ")110 ~ O_noCl"" I
I I ..
'3-\' ~.D. "J~ 1-1...'<:),," T ,~..". ~
...... )).~...~,....l- ,..".., _ ".un
1 I
'.}>I. -J- s.-onoo
I
I
. I
~
I."}
I
I
I
I
IJ
01 ~
yV"-t . I ~ ~
'-~~~~;;/2J~~J' ~
~ '-' ~~..J-r' r~~~ ff~ ~
..- "r".'/ u O\~
i :t;:; ---e________________.~o ~"..,.o..." l' .
- D f\: :-CVI'"!C''' .~.'
] ! ~ ~
': ~ ~ .~ /' \.":
~'\.:'D-- " ; ,\ '" ~ ~"
uJ VJ
~
e
lA
!!
c::
g
0::.
~
~
~
i
t:
~
..
s
.
~
E
-<
Vl
~
Q
c
o
o
S'
It
I
~
..
I
,
I
T-' 1 I
I
I
I
J
1
I
I
n ,
.
'0. )~))' '
I I
. ~ 0
" C>
tl! w .t::.
~ :s
~ If
I '..0 )."..,
I .; I
..
I :'f=J I
E' 1
i I
I
I
'J.'t'l' ~tI()UI'"
o
o
o
e
P'--,f:'
o
~
\
~
~ i
.
I
",
"~ .
"<, '
. (., 1'. >
. 1~
tl
I ~
! .'
I' ..
"
.,
~"
.. .
.it'. .
"
~t:t~SH.~1;.~:itd?i,~!.: :",;; :-I;:.",'>
, ~<
~I' '.
.;.,.. .
.. ";." ,,<{"'~"":~'..~:?'~~~:
. :'i-,
"
~.~ .
, :
'I~ .
. .
~ ., .
The paperwork for ltem .#10 moved to lO/5/95 pack
.
I ~ ..
f""
1-"..
, .
\.
.:. ~ '
~: .
C.:'.
: r : ~
"
:J'c
.,'
......
? '.
" .
'\""
(
i ~
,
:.1
.'.~ .
: ~
r )606
...
t
.
0;.'::"\:".
~tJ
~CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION
Agenda Cover Memorandum
{ I
Heeting Dolte 08/1'/95
I tern #I
SUBJECT: Vacation Request 95-10 (Peace Memorial Presbyterian Church)
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Deny the applicants' request to vacate a portion of the
North/South alley north of pierce street between Fort Harrison Avenue and Osceola
Avenue.
~
BACKGROUND: The applicant is requesting to vacate the Southerly 146.58 feet of
the 28 foot paved North/South alley running North off of pierce street between
South Fort Harrison Avenue and Osceola Avenue, platted as Division Street in
Block B, John R. Davey Subdivision. The applicant would like to fence off the
paved alley to prevent vehicular traffic from endangering children that attend
the church's nursery.
The city has,an existing natural gas line and sanitary sewer main located in the
alley. Engineering Services objects to this vacation since the alley is used by
the general pub~ic going to and from the Pinellas County Metropolitan Planning
Organization and utilities Department. The County has a utility bill payment
drop box with access from this alley. It should be pointed out that the drop box
appears to be on Church property. city solid Waste trucks use this alley to gain'
access to a dumpster located between the Church School and the County building.
All other City departments/divisions concerned with this request have reviewed
the petition and concur with the comments made by Engineering Services.
Florida Power and GTE have existing facilities in this alley and will require an
easement be retained. Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse has no
objections.
The City Engineer has reviewed the comments submitted by the reviewing
departments and recommends the applicants' request be denied.
I Reviewed by: I
I I
I Costs: NIA COIlmission Action
I I
I Legal NIA I
I Budget I (Current fY) Appro\ll!d
NIA I
I User Dept. funding Source: Approved
I Purchasing NIA I w/conditions
I Copt. Imp.
I Risk Hgmt. NIA I Denied
I Advertised: Operating
I IS NIA Otl\ I Cont1d to
I ACH I Date: 8/03 8. 811 0/95 Other
1
t ENG. I
~t I Paper: Tnmpl1 Tribune
. I Appropriation Code(s} Attachments:
, OTHER I
I Not required
.\{\'I NIA Appl icotion
\l:. I Affected parties Location Sketch
I S<boit:Jl.~ I notified )(
-4 I
1 Not required
1 CityH er I
I
. J
..,.
, ..
.
Vacation Number 95-10
"Peace Memorial presbyterian Church"
V A CAT ION REO U EST
PRO C E S 8 I N G SHE E T
t
PLEASE REVIEW THIS VACATION IN TERMS OF YOUR PRESENT USE AND FUTURE
NEED FOR THE PROPERTY. INDICATE YOUR COMMENTS BELOW:
REFERENCE ATLAS SHEET NO 286BI G-6 SECTION-!!-TOWNSHIP 298 RANGE lSE
ENGINEERING SERVICES: ~ / /
REV! EWED BY: <IJ6 APPROVED BY: Ue"//L'r-r ~ DATE :6/20/.P.r
COMMENTS: The applicant is reque~ting to V t e Southerly
146.58 of the 28' paved North/South alley runnin or off of pierce
Street between Fort Harrison Avenue and Osceola Avenue, platted. as
Division street in Block B, John R. Davey Subdivision. The applicant
would like to fence off the paved alley to prevent vehicular traffic
from endangering children that attend the church's nursery. The city
has an existing natural gas line and sanitary sewer main located in
the alley. Florida Power and GTE have existing facilities in this
alley and will require an easement be retained. Vision Cable has no
objections. Engineering Services oDjects to this vacation since the
alley is used by the general public going to and from. the pinellas
county Metropolitan Planning Orgnaization and utilities Department.
The County has a utility bill payment drop box with access from this
alley. It should be pointed out that the drop box appears to be on ~.
Church property. City sanitation vehicles use this alley to gain
access to a dumpster located between the Church School and the county
building.
TRANSPORTATION GROUP: t '
REVIEWED BY:~~
COMMENTS: .
~~ W:\..\:"\&,, %~\,.M.~o-~ ~~
1.
2.
3.
4.
D~~fi.;
CENTRAL PERMIT~A~TMENT: ~~f()0V
REVIEWED BY:~. APPROVED BY: ~
COMMENTS:
~ UC(C). fh;, ...."7 I" "'-
; ~f'( I-f ,e)' IJ.r;_- f.." t, -I. "v: <un c.-~) ,-
1L (:p.V'<_ 1Jrec "",f{ 6:Y"'''''~;-IJe"v'',,,,
DATE:
SOLID WASTECEPARTMENT:
REVIEWED BY t
COMMENTS: "
)/0 Ci bd t*'- +,Lln:.s
APPROVED BY:
DATE:
6 /{)~/ 95
t
6 CUMU' V \~
-
:-,,:\!.~....... h
5.
6.
7.
Vacation Number 95-10
"Peace Memorial presbyterian Church"
GAS DEPARTMENT' ,
REVIEWED B,! :tJ..",{~ J. 0 &r~t."'"" APPROVED BY.: 1~ ~ ~
COMMENTS: CO..., e.c.....r w iTh GAo"It\(~""{"'j' .
DATE: a,/ee/'lS
FIRE DEPARTMENT: :iA /1 A/
REVIEWED BY:~. GOod(~1L . APPROVED BY: '(lIfMtt, ~
COMMENTS: 6l?J:jJ7'~c.:r1O,y 7lJ ,clk- j), ,r.umr 4c..t,e<?5
c Hvfi.GI-~ 3:--I-h6L f -:p, G '2Jl..J?CI. . '
DATE: 0(B-
.FoJL:.
POLICE DEPARTMENT:
REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY:
COMMENTS: I
Q C-~,i\oV\-
DATE: 6/u/;r'"
fr~'-r '
CITY ENGINEE~R' ~
REVIEWED BY.: DATE: ,
COMMEN.TS:' (P~/i.r I
:j).;., Co "-"- ~ ~ W-;r- fv-A~ · I
~e ~ -(~~ JJ.f~- ~ 1
~ ~ w-wLf ;"'ud;'-~--I- ~ 'j; ~f-. IJ
~~;;~TE~~~-~-~~~;~ .
8.
PUBLIC HEARING DATE:
08/17/95
COMMISSION ACTION:----APPROVED----CONTINUED----TABLED----DENIED----
ORDINANCE NO.
DATE OF ADOPTION
RECORDED IN O. R. BOOK:
PAGE:
LETTER TO PROPERTY OWNER ADVISING COMPLETION OF VACATION
VACATION CARD FILE:
REVISED 06/95
VACPROC.WJS
,
.
r"
.. ~ t.
1.
I
. . ~ l'.:
V A CAT ION
REO U EST
r
F I L I N G
FORl1
I ~ 'Ie;, - "J 0'-' i (~0
NAME: 6.r.('I.~Cl.L./ T: O'gA'J.;o"",'"'S~,-~ /,.jp~f-4.~;,..~//......-J PHONE: ~(57i{ r- ~CJl..( G-i)
'ADDRESS: cl.'....r.l.. II ().\ I=':.~J- 4d1.~/.\-c.~... , C'/'-".-('{.<.r,T,p4 I--/&." ~ 4& S e'.J
~ ~
HEREBY PETITION THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER FOR THE
. VACATION OF THE FOLLOWING:
c=J
c=J
EASEMENT TYPE:
RIGHT-OF-WAY
mALLEY
c=J
OTHER:
2.
,.
LEGAL DESCRIPTIO~. OF PROPERTY TO BE VACATED:
fJ /5 A-/le...( b;;- 1 i.v~ t>.~ P, ;/tc -t ~ A .uj c'l~ '"~ {C,M c:/
".
3. STREET ADDRESS OR SIMPLE LOCATION:
. II () S. Fl. H.....~I\'I,rc. """ '.
4. PROPOSED USE OF VACATED PROPERTY:
! v pt\~......~:t IJJ,,( vlc...r\ T ,~~ r- ~I' <:.
" v .( c. '/ ,,>(.; ,... 7 tV oJ J< ( .. n y -t c. D, C .
5. ZONING ON ADJOINING PROPERTY:
C (.'.. ^ i-'l ~Jtll<'H~ 7 I",-r-
I
~
'\"";~-;..~;~ >, ~.
.!
6. ATTACHMENTS:
LAND SURVEY' OF PROPERTY IS REQUIRED IF THIS VACATION INVOLVES
EXISTING ENCROACHMENT
'.....- ....
..~... ~., . .
- ~'"'" - ~.:..... - .
..~~~...'-
....M:.. .
x
DRAWING SHOWING PROPOSED USE OF VACATED PROPERTY
(SURVEY, PLOT PLAN, ETC.)
SEE RESOLUTION 82-3 (ATTACHED)
ATTACHED LETTERS OF NO OBJECTION FROM:
..... c: ...
--:...--- ~ ~ .
!~~~ .
.-- ..
; .........
x
FLORIDA POWER CORPORATION
x
GENERAL TELEPHONE COMPANY
x
VISION CABLE
OTHER
7. SIGNATURE OF THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY ABUTTING THAT PROPERTY PROPOSED
TO BE VACATED: (~PPLICANT)
.'.
. NAME
. ilL..... ",I 1: u ~ f3 It\~.. ~ ~
~DDRESS & ZIP CODE
D~TE PROPERTY ACOUIRED
~5 7' FeNJ. f:1= L~A'--<
cl~,(....j..~., F"l~. "5 "t~1.I-I--I/1
I '1:Z ,
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF PINELLAS)
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this
~ l -a \ Cf~
E. c\ \..0 QJ\...c)) '"\ Dr t) ~ \ {> l~
who has produced ~ L
-
by
..)R
, who is personally known to roe or
as i e
"'-;;'~';"'" MARniA GilL
t.'Jf'rSi'li.f;, lAY COMMISSION' CC 291238
\..\~/!i EXPIRES: July 9, 1m
..:~~:~~~" 8tnlod ThrU tllOt)' P\t1IC ~
Notary PUblic, commission No.
and 'who did (did not) take an oath.
--
\..yy[ QA.. ~ 0-
\(\J\ ~ IV+- F't
~
G'I......L
(Name of Notary typed, printed or stamped)
ENG. DEPT. 3/82
REVISED 10/92
VACREQ.DDM
:t,<"""rw.,.
,
..
"
-.....
"- .
l!:,t
b .<ID~ i .
~ .
p ~ ~:\ f~
~~ ~l
:!"d
~l.'l f
u= .~
::<0 f .
. 1
I.
I", ..1
,~~ \i '<r"
: F ~
;. I ;:
.~ ..: l
I .~\
I" I
: I
I . -. 'l
'1 ..L i i, .H \.' \. :
L' I ~,.'''.. .~____-
:~. ~ _.'~ -,--..--------~or;r.l~r_n~::~ ..
- II --.... -..f~' -,. 7'"
~.- /-
I
- - ~~! --- ,
. -r;. .
I ~ ,I 10_1.4.
..' :. ;u
. \ m:;:..
-
.
J
~'
~ I
."
. , l.
.1,1.1
"m;l'~
.., ..
!~i t
I
"
~,
'~II
00 "
wl\Tl 1
.....
m,~
"""
..
....J- ~ ~
, . ~l
"1
oj '''I
\~1
j ,II
II,
, I l'l
Ii,
I I'.
i : :~)
'j ., I~'
. .. . .. . ;""
~.-:.~:.~ ~~~t~-~~-~~~;-~~.::~~~-- I. :..~j
....." ,"'" ~~1Mr''';~~~~ M'"', I ;
19Z I~.O?,J ...., ,_~)....
- I - _a. - . ~~J - ..... ~ -..~ 11.' t'~\
I " ~ , l'
. t JI
t \ 'I ~;
~ ; l ~ ~
I h;: ~:
i 'I . I
, I .,
.. . . I I It
I I .1
I I . I
: -.. ~ -,~
I 1".&'
: '. { r..::
. I I il
: I. .'
:: t1l \ ::
.. I I II
.. I I .1
, ~ I'
~ , . ":rl , .:
~ "': : I
_,' -c ~ I I
1 -J:I ,I
I . ..
.. 1 ; I I'
~ .. I" t
: .'. t:.~:
1 I "
I ,I
I ,I
, ,I
, .,
,I
,I
,I
"
.1
,1
"
,I
,I
I" ,t
. . 1 I
.' ......',
, ,
t. ",,"'.
I .'
, "., , \- ~"
,..... p...
- "',,-:;'
~.:" -I
~,
~ ,-
" I
.. .
_ f.)":"8~ nl
· ~r.'"
: . fi
~. l!
. ~:" t
~~Jtill'
,',t '1 I
'>>:U;l~r ~ !'
'L.~~.~t
~. 'r.
\.~. ~t....."
., ~
,;"}\.. ~
'~:r{~-~
;i~i1IJ,.~1
,ale'II
.t~...l.\~....,.t~
. "~',: 'I': .,..~
'h ~ 'ut~
I "1
~~
,
I
I
;
(
r . L~ _ .
~: " ...
." -,<,
.. ~ ",+~
I
I
,
r
I
i, c!".t
\
,
,
I
>,.... .;
ot'... .
....,...
,
"
~~~1
Ihg
~!~jr
i'~; ~
~I: i
r ~.:
. 'i,'
~1~~'i
"t1ii}" I
llX' t
~ .~~, ~
, i.lls~ -.!
'! : lij]l~ 1~~
I ~jfi: ~~~
~ ~.<1\~ t:a
,.." t1".
~ ~f~.~~' \'1.
.. t ',. ~ .
'," ~
. ~~.f~'
''\ :
\ .
\~
i\."
I
I
"-- .
...
I
I
I
I
l
I
I
I
r
,
1
~Ll
I
'~J
...- .... ~ ~ ~ .1 ..
" I
,
I
1 t
\A~ OJ \
I I
I I
! -
'.
,
,
,
I
,
,
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
"
I '
,
,
,
I
I
I;
>,-1
1
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
)
(lJ I
\
~l I
,',
'.
,II HI +...~ L ~'."'I""
. .1.. h
3nN3^V V103::lS0 HlnOS
,.
. _ c. !.
ro.,
"
I ~~ J
I
1 V
\1
I ~
1.1
1('
I I. I'
.' ~!~! 1 ~ l'
~:, II ~l'~" ~ l. ~j
Ji f I'! : ~.!!f ! i:i :~~~
l' I r 'ItIt!.; ~t'l
j!l! i1 Y;" ;!' ~I
r!phl J,.I)! i .!~ ~
~1,H!1 ~IJlt J .IJ ~
Jllh, """, \ J
.~
I
I~,
JU~+ij;:
I' ~ ell;;
~ ~ Ill!
i:I...u
I
"".'
r
.\
I
. ~"t'
mill
I
.\.\
I
1
tu
UJ
~
W
U
a: '- i '"
~'r
I
I
I
\
l
", ~ ,
l.~
.~
, :
,~
I'~
'~
,
it!
~
,
., ,
,
~
\
.
.
i i
I,
i.
,
'.
,
. .
.\
- ~ T
,
..
,'.
, .
. I
I
,.
*~:lr.:';.~ . > ~ ~
, . <,..'
" , ....., .'
f
". ~ . .... .' <
..
NOTE: This is not a survey!
t' ,
: l :
,.
I
: . l
w J. R. DAVEY
>
<{ G
Hl 87 ...
<( i::::::
..-J G
0
w ~
u.
en "j ~
c. ,-' ~
"
I @ tJ
f- ::::)
~ 14 ~
0
if) ct
15
PIERCE. ST
7/25/95
VAC95-10
"
~~~"'-1~ .
AUG-03-199S 14:34 FROM
TO
6541
P.Ol
C I T Y OF 'C LEA R W ATE R
INTERDEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE SHEET
TO~
FROM:
SUBJECT:
DATE:
COPIES:
Rich ~e~EngineeT
James ~~MagliO' Superintendent
of Solid Waste
Vacation Request - Peace Memorial Presbyterian Church
August 3, 1995
Robert M. Brumback. Director of Solid Waste
. ..... t 41 +,.. .' ~ , ~.. .. . I ,_ t . . .
,
Reference the attached sheet. My comments on item number 4 stating
Itno objection" were made in error. After a physical inspection of
the prope~ty) I find that there are two (2) containers (dumpsters)
that are serviced in the area requesting vacation. One container
serves the Church and one serves Pinellag County. Therefore, the
Solid Waste Department does object to this vacation.
...
If you have any questions, or I can be of further assistance I please
, contact me.
--
JVM:ns
Attachment
ill ~ & ~ till ~irnr
r'A't~' 3 ,I,;.
: oJ J - 1995 ' : ,
L__.. '.. . ,j, :
(17- ., ('. . .. --
r ~. . .. T
t '\\.Il.... L
--.......... ----" r~ ..~.~':~_;.:.. _~~..__r
Ii
[I
co.
oept.
fe)l1P
"'J11l'
-.
b/Zz/9J' \
j
I
,
1
I
AUG-03-1995
14 : 30.1 FROl'l
TO
P.132
/~
6641
... .......-- .....-..
'"
v ~ C ~ T ~ ON R E O.Y-E S T
~ R Q C ~ S SIN G SHE ~ !
PLEASE REVIEW THIS VACATION IN TERMS OF YOUR PRESENT USE AND FUTURE
NEED FOR THE PROPERTX. INDICATE YOUR COMMENTS BELOW~
REFERENCE ATLAS SHl!ET NO_2J,lGDI G-6 SECTIONJ.!LTOWNSHIP_~RANGE :LSE
,
ENGINEERING SERVICES: ~ _ / ~ '
REVIEWED BY: <f!U" APPROVED 131: :lM'.4!f"'( ~ DATE :6/,u,./~
COMMENTS: The applicant is requesting to v t e Southerly
146.58 of the 28' paved North/South alley runnin' or off of Pierce
Street petween Fort Harrison Avenue. and osceola Avenue, platted as
Division Street in Block B, John R. Davey subdivision. The.applicant
would like to fence off the paved alley to.prevent vehicular traffic
from endangQring. children that atten~ the churchts nursery. The City
.has an existinQ natural gas line and sanitary sewer main located in
the alley. . Florida POWQr and GTE have existing facilities in this
alley and will require. an easement be retained. Vision cable has no
objections. Engineering services o~jects to this vacation since the
alley is used by the general public going to and from the Pinellas
county Metropolit~n Planning Orgnaization and utilities Depart~ent.
The County has a utility bill payment drop box with access from this
alley. It should be pointed out that the drop box appears to be on ~,
Church property. city sanitation vehicles use this alley to gain
access to a dumpster located between the church School and the County
building.
16
2.
TRANSPORTATION GROUP: \
REVIEWED B'i:~~ DA'fT~~f~
COMMENTS: 6 w, ,~
~~ ~o:...~ "'8.~,-"-o..Q--~ ~~ "',
3.
CENTAAL J?ERMIT~A~TM'EN'l': ;fi~f()'0V
REVIEWED B~:S. APPROVED BY: v
COMMENTS: '
~ UC(C ). . !h'J 1M"? J,< ,:.-
,. ....f' ,/-{ rJ. l}r; - -- f...l:, ~ I. ". ": ~UrJ v 7 r '-
iL- j:-fi.,r~- 15,e-c ".f{ E.<-Y"'~(~;-f Je~",/~rl
DATE:
4.
SOLID WASTE IEPARTl-mNT:
REVIEWED BYr ( APPROVED BY:
COMMENTS:' v
N" G bel"~ +,.,,:.s. '3 C1.)I\\.Ul \.r \~
DATE:
~ /~YJ/ 95
. ~. .. " .' ~ .. ~ . .
\ t~" . '....:..."". u, t.......f ,_ -:_ _.~I~:.: J',"'II. 110.._ .. II" ..., ill :.".. ,.
,'.
..........
TOTAL P.82
; .
. "
.,
" .:
'.
,.
\,
,
-..>""...... ,
,~ . I ~ .
'.
. .
~,. .
DATE
~..
..,
i-tr
~.i'
-.
;'t:
'..r<
:~
...
r:;'
~'
F/C:,J/&
. . .
. . .
AGENDA
. ...._.;......__T~-- "
l_ d- 95
ITEM # L~
'!":'" .
'~":'\U.'''C-''
I~ ~:I':~'
~ ..i1. c
~ -~ ~
· 7r.. ,..,
~~
~-i1EQ..~",
~#".~
CLEARW A TER CITY COMMISSION
C f',\ ~ Agenda Cover Memorandum
110m II
Mealil1{l Dnlo: _8/11/95_
1;;(
Subject:
Approval of the Coml1\unity Hudcveloplllenl: l\CJcncy's Downto\oJJl Plan
I' Aecommenda\ion/Mo\lon:
'1'0 uppt'ove the COlllmunity "ed'~velopment Agency's Downtown P.l.an' and
adopt Resolution 95-65
'1'110 TratU tiolla1 'foun Cen tur - " .:Imilll .:IC" It:. pl ac~ tha t
mel.lt!l the needs of Clearwater as the YOVOJ:tllllollt conter,
with suppot:t COl1\l\\crcial and totai 1 llSO; all unl;orl;aimnent
di-'trict, C\ new ce~identi;.,l locus ilnd <lll ill1H!nity sttuctUI:C
built around Coachman Park and iI lIOW int;erior. lllke and pill"~.
'i
I
!
.j
\
I
[
I
I
I
I
I
(
'I
i
r
,
I
J
I
i
!
1
o and lhal Ihe appropriato olllcials bo authorizod 10 oxocute smilO,
BACl<GROUND:
, On October 17, 1994, the Commulli ty Hedeve I opml.!llL: ^CJllIICY HilS illltlHH" i Zl'!d to contract \.Ii th 1I1\11:son
Taylor 8e1lomo lIerbe~.t to prepare a llownto"'llI Plan.
,t Tl\e 1najos: e'npha:)i~ en1ployed in preparJng thl:! pliLl1 "till:! 1:0 U!Jc :Jignlflcilllt public jnput~ To do
thi:s, th re e \lnl que Ilu.!chan i SIIl:S we ra app I i 'HI:
Public Is:sucs Work:shop:s - Two centrally held \.Iorkshop5 were both publicly advertised and
invitations were :sent to aVec 60 potential participant3
Vi:lual Preference Survey (Vrs) - 'rho IHimary vi:lioH <'Illd COll~HHl~U:J tuchnique w"':! the VI'S, and it
wa:s admini:stered in live ~p.:s:don!i, a:J WfJ]) i"\:J tl.!levi:llJd.
From these highlY vi:dbLe effort:!, thu pi 1111 ha~ ~l\\t'rl.)cd with a cllHlr vl:sion for clOI/lltown.
In:stcad of compotillg in an uphill battle, dOUlIl:')HII rln!Jiu~:) to htl:
On June 14, 1995 at a ::Ipeclal CIlJ\ meeting held at Peact! BUlllod.al Pro:.Jbyt;cl:ian Church, the CM
Board ot Trusteu:! ul\animou:lly approved lilt.! plllll Hlth tHo i.\\\\lllldment:s:
'1). 'l'l\\\t th~ location of th~ l-\ulI\ociill C<lU:It.!\.h1y ndrh).~ C.II1 be eillH!l" Drew
or the COLlrt/riurce/Chl.!::Itllut lItn!ut optiull!l i\nrl;
"
21 That whilt i!l cli\:J:liflcd a!l COIIllI\Ul.cii\\/Uutt!l"\:O\ll\ll\l:nt on Cleveland <lllLl
Hi:!l:!lOllr.i Struul::1 (1\I<A the t::il:lt I::ud Jta:ol'{!rt;yl wi 11 he rJe:.d ';!uilted 11:1 a
mtKcd-u:Je ~l:(H\ to allow [01: the bllildi'l!) and zonllllJ of. rU:Jid~"tlal,
cOllune,l;ciil] ilnd t.:ntcrtainlllcnt IHojucUI.
On .July lU. 1!)9S, thu dO\lntown ruduvuloPllU!llt plan "'''\3 :J\lumitted to the l'lannilHJ to Zoning Doard
for review and wa.::l Counel to be con:si.!Itullt with 1:11(: ,::itY':J cOlllpcehen:dvc plan. Thl:! dountown plan
\.1<\:3 unal\imoll!lly t:"dor~ud by tho l~lLlnnllllJ '" Zoning Huard.
Revlcwed by:
Legal--1~\ ____
Budget __!!!~. _,_
,Purchuslng _ .HI A _
RIsk Mgml._.~_
DIS __!!.!lL__
ACM -"'~-a' ~- -.- "-'-
Olher ~L t:?i .,~,-
Submtlt~t'6v.:
'?~'
City Nnnogel"
Originating Dept.:
CRA
Costs:
U/A
101nl
Commission Action:
[] Approvod
I.J Approved w/condlllons
[] Donlod
rJ Con\lnuoll 10:
U!lor Dept.;
Curt enl FY
Funding Sowell:
Advertlscd: [.1 Capl. Imp.
Dalo: e /7/95 l.~ I Opowllng
Pupor:'l'ampa 'l'rih/Gazu .tel J 01111;)(_____
fJ Not roqulrod
Alloc;lod partlns Appropriallon Codo:
X Notlflod
1:1 Hol ruq"irod
Allnchmcnls~
1'1annl11CJ , Zoning I.loard
'1/ 1 U/9~ 1111 nut (HI
Reso. 95-65
i
-
"
-'ik:~
JI.A." -28~ 1995 1 S: .12
CLE~Il;,'".JA rEI~ .: I r I' (U::~:"
813 <152 6.188 P.DLJUOOl
O. Annexation, Zoning, LancJ Use PI.." Amendment, l.uHJ Development Codo Tuxt Am nomenl
and local Planning Agency Review
1. Down\own Redevelopm~n\ plan ~ Pete Gozza, eRA b:ecutive Direc\or.
The City Community Redevelopment Agency (eRAI retained a consulting group to p epare a
Downtown Redevelopment Plan. Copies of the proposed plan were submitted for Board review.
It was Indicated such a plan must be reviewed for consistency wlrh the City's Compr henslve
Plan.
Mr. Gozza outlined the key points and displayed a map highlighting details of the propos d pl.ln.
He stressed the plan is $till in the conceptual stage and is open to changes and suggesti 05.
. ,.~
Mr. Cozza responded to questions regarding street layout, parking access and use ensllY.
Additional que!)tions were raised regarding means of accessing the propos~d bridgel Har orview
Center and the Pinella.s Tra.il. Mr. GOlza indicated this Is a conceptual land LIse plan land the
traffic patterns have not yet been addressed. !
Discussion ensued regarding placement of the Pinellas Trail, developing a Cocoa Walk sl~i1a.1' to
the one In Ybor City and building a holel on the waterfront. Mr. Cozza stated in res onse to
questions, lhey are considering condominiums and office buildings, with Ihetallest bing 15
stories.
,
I'
Discussion ensued reg~rding development of a downtown lake and development of the
surrounding property. A suggestion was made for the City Comn"lissiol1 to first Gonslder
developing the lake and leWng the market forces take over th~ commercial develoPIT\~nt. In
response to a question, Mr. Gozza stated thi5 is the last time the plan will be presenter to the
Planning and Zoning Board before it goes before the Commission. '
Mr. Gozza indicated the consultants will prepare an executive summary of the plan and I rovide
a camera ready copy to the City. He stated stil{f has rcvlcwlld the plan for consistency tlth the
Comprehensive plan and recommended endorsement to the City Commission. I
I
Member Keyes moved to endorse the Downtown Redevelopment Plan to the City Com~ission.
The motion was duly seconded and carried unanImously. I
02. 1Q9 Meadow lark lane 8, Bayview City Sub, Blk 2, lots 1 & 2 and abutting al~leY
to the South (Lisa A. Kadlec) A 95~14~ LUP 95.16
LUP: Residential Urban ZONE: RS 8 (Single t:amily Residential!
i
I
I
I
~
i
.1
03. 1531 Stevenson Drive, Stevenson's Heights Sub, Blk 6, LOI 7 (ThomaS' L B9qth)
A 95-15; llJP 95~17 1
lUP: Residen\iallow ZON1:: RS 8 (Single Family ResidentIal) 1
I
04. 412 OaklTlount Road, Oakmaunt Sub, Lot 2 and abutting rlght.o(~way (Fred O.
Clark, Jr & Valerie I'. Warren) A 95.17; tup 95-19
mpz07a.95
Pilg\! ., 0' 0
07ll11/9S
~
tOTAL P.OCH
-
.,}...., " . ,"
RESOLUTION NO. 95-65
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CLEARWATER APPROVING A NEW COMMUNITY
REDEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR THE COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT
AREA LOCATED IN THE DOWNTOWN AREA OF THE CITY
OF CLEARWATER; MAKING FINDINGS; RESERVING RIGHTS
AND PREROGATIVES; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 81-67 adopted by the City
commission of the City of Clearwater on August 6, 1981,
determined that a certain area in the downtown area of the City
of Clearwater was in need of redevelopment and so designated
that area as being a "community redevelopment area" within the
meaning of Section 163.340(10), Florida Statues, and the'
boundaries for such area were corrected by Resolution No. 94-26
adopted on April 7, 1994 (the "Redevelopment Area"); and
.i
WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 2576-81, enacted on December 17,
1981, adopted a community redevelopment plan for the
Redevelopment Area, and Ordinance No. 3021-83, enacted on
February 28, 1983, amended such plan (the plan as amended is
hereinafter referred to as the "Original Plan"); and
,
,
i
i
I
I
I
.1
I
1
i
. '
WHEREAS, in accordance with and pursuant to the procedures
and authorizations set forth in Part III, Chapter 163, Florida
statutes (the "Redevelopment Act"), the Community Redevelopment
Agency of the City of Clearwater, Florida (the \\CRA") has
prepared and approved a community redevelopment plan for the
Redevelopment Area 'which will supersede and replace the Original
Plan and has recommended such plan to the City Comnission (the
"Proposed Plan"); and
WHEREAS, the Proposed Plan was reviewed by the Planning
and Zoning Board, which is the land planning agency for the city
of Clearwater for purposes of the Local Government Comprehensive
Planning and Land Development Regulation Act, and the Planning
and Zoning Board found the Proposed Plan to be consistent with
the comprehensive Plan of the City of Clearwater and;
I
,
WHEREAS, the City Comnission has received the
recommendation of the CRA to adopt the Proposed Plan and has
caused a public notice to be published and a notice mailed to
each taxing authority as required by Section 163.346, Florida
Statues, and a public hearing to be noticed, scheduled and held
as required by Section 163.361(2), Florida Statues;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF
THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA duly assembled this
17th day of August 1995,
Section 1. Findings Based on information presented to
it, the City Co"~ission does hereby find:
(a) The recitals set forth above (including the
definitions) are hereby adopted and incorporated
....
f,'(.":,.... .
herein to the full extent a5 if set forth in the text
of this Resolution.
. .
(b)
The public hearing required by section 163.361(2},
Florida Statues, has been held and closed.
. '
(c) A feasible method exists for the location of families
who will be displaced from the Redevelopment Area in'
decent, safe, and sanitary dwelling accommodations
within their means and without undue hardship to such
families.
(d) The Proposed plan conforms to the general plan of the
City of Clearwater as a whole.
t
. ,
(e)
The Proposed Plan gives due consideration to the
provision of adequate park and recreational areas and
facilities that may be desirable for neighborhood
improvement, with special consideration for the
health, safety, and welfare of children residing in
the general vicinity of the site covered by the plan.
.'
Cf) The Proposed Plan will afford maximum opportunity,
consistent with the sound needs of the city as a
whole, for the rehabilitation or redevelopment of the
Redevelopment Area by private enterprise.
(9) The Redevelopment Area consists of an area of open
land to be acquired by the City or the eRA, and such
area will not be acquired unless;
.' ,
1.
In the event the area is to be developed for .
residential uses, the City Commission determines
that:
A. A shortage of housing of sound standards
and design which is decent, safe,
affordable to residents of low or moderate
income, including the elderly, and
sanitary exists in the City;
B. 'I'he need for housing acconunodations has
increased in the area;
c. The conditions of blight in the area or
the shortage of decent, safe, affordable,
and sanitary housing cause or contribute
to an increase in and spread of disease
and crime or constitute a menace to the
public health, safety, morals, or welf~re;
and
D. The acqui.s i tion 'of the area for
residential uses is an integral part of
and is essential to the program of the
Ci.ty.
.. ~
-
..
Ii'
~~'.f.
2. In the event the area is to be dev~loped for
nonresidential uses, the City commission
determines that:
A.
Such nonresidential uses are necessary and
appropriate to facilitate the proper
growth and development of the community in
accordance with sound planning standards
and local community objectives; and
I.
B.
Acquisition may require the eKercise of
governmental action, as provided in he
Redevelopment Act, because of~
(ix)
Defective or unusual conditions
of, title or diversity of
ownership which prevents the
free alienability of such land;
Tax delinquency;
Improper subdivisions;
Outmoded street patterns;
Deterioration of site;
Economic disuse;
Unsuitable topography or faulty
lot layouts;
Lack of correlation of the area
with other areas of the city by
streets and modern traffic
requirements; or
Any combination of such factors
or other conditions which retard
development of the area.
I
;
1
r
'I
I
\
'I
1
!
!
I
\
. '
{i}
,
t ,
(ii)
(iii)
{iv)
( v)
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
(g) The public hearing was held after public notice
thereof by publication in a newspaper having a
general circulation in the City and the notice
described the time, date, place, and purpose of the
hearing, identified generally the Redevelopment Area,
and outlined the general scope of the Proposed Plan.
(h)
The Original Plan will be replaced, superseded, and
amended by the Proposed Plan effective upon the
adoption of this Resolution.
I
i
.\
(i) The Proposed plan conforms to and complies with the
requirements of the Redevelopment Act.
II
'i
'.'
Section 2. Adoption of P1an. The Proposed plan is hereby
adopted and shall henceforth be and constitute the
community redevelopment plan for the Redevelopment Area.
section 3. Reservation of Rights and Preroqatives.
Notwithstanding its approval of the Proposed Plan, the
City Commission reserves all rights and prerogatives of
the city Commission with respect to the independent review
of and action on any matter that would otherwise come.
before the city commission in the normal cour-se of its
.;'."
. ", !,
.>
'.'
,
... ~ I
'.'
\ '.
~""""" .,...~'. , .
.to:'
.' ,
: I'
i;
i':
i:",'
I:',
'.
I::. ,
,'. .'
i
t,',
! :'\ ~~'
I:'. .
,.
I .l ~
I'
If:
I.-
I,
I;:" .
:1.
I
_1"'.,~,Jr.. "U'+~J"''''''~~'' .
... ... ~,~...
.,." ., ','
j ~.-.' ;., -:" ,. .
"'" . : .......
t.,
....;.\'- I , " ....
.' . <\
responsibilities and jurisdiction within the Redevelopment
Area.
Section 4. Effective Date. This resolution shall become
effective immediately upon its adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this
day of
, 1995.
.1
j
I
t
Rita ,Garvey, Mayor-Commissioner
ATTEST:
I
(
]
I
'j,
,
t.
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
.1
i
\~
I
I
l
. I
1
I
r
!
!
. ~J~.1-~ .. ,
J.:Xcalt!ve Commlllce
Ann M. Wilkin.
CAlIinMII 01 IN BOMrl
Sl.rpbrn R. Fa.lcr
CAllir'1fttJftoEI.d
Chnl" D. R1av. m
VC EcoflOmi.cJ
Bwwss D.~tlopIfWllI
Janke n. Cue
VC Gov,,,,,,,,,"1Dl NJairZ!
EducalwlI DntlO/'f1U1Il
Grq:orJ Broslu.
VC Tow",
Daniel T. Mann
VCM.".bmJoip
Jud1MIlehcll
VC P/IliIii: Re/adi1M
SINr:iJJ1E~,"u
John r. Conne1l1
Treasurer
Phil M. Jlendmon
I_dial. Pall CMirmo.ll
Jullw J. lICk I U
. UI,uCow.v.1
reler Woodham
Pr':fidcllt, CEO
BOllrd or D1rcdOC'S
Davill J. ^"cl.m
DlI\icl I>t Andri..,
I!. D. Annslm<l! III
Ourla It IIdlr
Alan C. lImnilein
Ray Bouchanl
1&0:4 Drown
Robed A.lIurwc1l
Roben W. lIynl
SLeVCl II. C1upnpn
LaN)' COlOpcr
Haberl N. 'I'ctcl" era..rotd DOS
Sam A. OavU, II
Mary A. Devine
J!dward C. Droole
Oary S. Gny
Kcnncih O. ) lamUlm
Roy G. lIamill. Jr,
Robert n. Heilman, Jr.
William IlcUer
Guy Jumin
Gonion lohNm
Albed N. JulUcc
l'du W. Krauigct
J, II. MeCUt\.lin, Jr.
ArUtidt.ll Miliolel:
Prank V. Murphy,lU
Julle F. Nichula
Kathy Soon R.bu,
TalmaJ,lc Rullcdac
DU)'I 1. SCllOn
Dun I. St.lIlorI
Ronald W. Sl\1ln
David P. Stille
lLCul.t~Wanl
Oouilu J. William.
TAMPA BAY
~ /'~:f!lf.n;.
. f ftJJ.l~d;!
.
.~
COPIES TO:
COMMISSION
\'d-
GREATER CLEARWATER_
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
AUG 1 7 1995
PHf:SS
CLERK I ATTORNEY
t20 N. OKEOLAAVE. P.O. DOX 24~7. ClEARWATER. fl 04617. 6iO/46H)0l1 . FAX 61"/449.2609
RESOLUTION
DOWNTOWN REDEVELOPMENT
Whereas, the revitalization of downtown Clearwater is vital
to the community as a whole, and;
Whereas, redevelopment is an essential element to ensure
Clearwater's downtown has a healthy business climate and to
prevent further deterioration, and;
Whereas, a plan has been written to revitalize downtown, and;
Whereas, the city of Clearwater could benefit economically
from job creation, building refurbishing, and generation of
interest in downtown projects and activities, and;
Whereas, the Greater Clearwater Chamber of Commerce supports
renewed opportunities for private sector investment to
increase the Clearwater tax base.
Therefore Be It Resolved:
The Greater Clearwater Chamber of Commerce supports the
concept of downtown as a town center and commends the
community Redevelopment Agency for its efforts in that arena
and supports issues such as increased mixed use development
to accomplish this task.
Be It Further Resolved:
The Greater Clearwater Chamber of Commerce suggests that the
plan allow that flexibility in the land uses prescribed
therein. The Greater Clearwater Chamber of Commerce
encourages the City Commission to take the appropriate steps
to ensure there is an aggressive pUblic education campaign
which markets a redevelopment plan to the business and
residential communities of Clearwater. The Chamber also
suggests this be done as a function of the Downtown
partnership.
The Greater clearwater Chamber of Commerce would also offer
assistance and guidance to the Partnership in this endeavor
to make redevelopment of downtown a success.
Passed and Adopted This
/6
. .
/;--
day of (litO./--
, 1995
/' .... II
o , /1 I/,~- (;
./ It.l(l; ;, ..,.u/-tl.l,-""
steve FOWler
Chairman-Elect
ry :;,..
I~
08/16/95 15:15
'5'449 2880
CL\ITR CHAMBER
COPIES TO,
COMMISSION
Iai 001
AUG 1 7 1995
PRESS
CLERK I ATTORNEY
DOWNTOWN DEVfiLOPMENT BOARD
. Auguse 15, 1995
Mayor Rita Garvey~ Qou~
City of Clearwater
via fax #462-6720
Dear Mayor:
0.. l.&iltt
a..u,.-.
I understand the City Commission is considering adopting a
resolution (# 95~65) on Thursday, August l7th regarding ehe
new community redevelopment plan. I am sorry I cannot
attend, ~~t will be out of' town. I wou~d like to ask you to
share my comments with the Commissioners.
David Slooa
\.W.Q.up.,.,..".
Overall, I believe this i6 a fine plan, and a posi~ive seep
mu.ww~ forward for the City and downtown. I was particularly glad
T~
to see Sectio~ 1 '(f} citing your intention to a!ford maximum
opportunity for redevelopment of the area by private
enterprise. This is consistent with my belief that the'
A1Bl~1l City I S role is to stimulate private investment I not: to own
and develop property itself.
Kala Mr;CuJIou,h
. , ,
~~M.Waroo It continues to concern me that the plan does not address
in~entives .the City is willing to offer. Stop for a moment
Ll1lillllTricul and consider. " . what is likely to make an investor \I..'illing to
spend $10 million here, rather than in St. Pete or Tampa or
JlldlHadeI1 along US" l~ I in order to implement these proj ects? What is
the City willing and able to do to make these projects
attrac~iye to investors?
Co/Ullluu I
The plan would .be enhanced, in my op:l.l~,l.on, if it included a
9.iscussion 'of the eypes ,of incent:.:ves, the Ci,ty is willing to
offer .the development community. Use' examples of things you
I j . '
ha~e done in the paGt'~f you' denlt wah~ to make s~ecific
commi~~mcnt5 in advance -' any good developer' will find' these
th:l.i1gs' out, so you I re not giving 'a\.iay' secrets. Clearwater
has. so many residents and business people, who are wi~ling to
help 'make~his work. They have.experience in development,
. ' . l
. '.
.. . I
I
j.
~' .:
'''"I.I'FI~'. .
08/10/05 15:16
'l3'440 2880
Cl~1"R CHAMBER
IaJ002
I
and professional reputations and contacts that spread
nationally, even internationally. If you will reach out to
the expertise already here and ask for help in selling the
plan, you will be likely to have more Batis~ying resulC8.
I am also concerned about Section 1 (9) which addresses the
City or eRA acquiring land for residential use. Thewording
of the resolution makes it appear to me that the type of
housing to be built, if the Ci~y acquires the land, is
lIaffordable.1I He need to make sure there is a full range of
middle-income and upscale choices in our residential mix to
support the costs of development and the new retail areas,
planned. There is plenty o! room for all types of housing
i11 the plan - don.' t restrict yourselves to only llaffordable
housing" projects. If that was not your intent, please
revise ~he wording.
Finally, I feel we all need to make a commitment to build
enthusiasm for downtown revitalization among the citizens of
Clearwacer in order for this or any other plan to be
successful. The Downtown Development Board has offered to
spend both its time and resources in this regard. We need
the City to work in cooperation with us in this effort - it
will take all of us.
sincerely,
------:--J /.:"
~~t:/~6
David Stone, Vice-Chairperson
cc: DD3 members
: I
~ I
.'
" .'~
'.. .
"". .'. ,
, ' ,",.
. ." .
"" .', .. ,.. . "t'~
..... : '
17:'"
.,"'
.1."
~> '.. .
.. " ~ .
".: < > "
:..1 .
~F':',.,
'"
,,~ ."
,-
.j.:~>. '.
:: : .
~~'::(~('~'~f~' J:~?+~:r~:~'f'~'~: ~I~~l'" ,t..~." ~oq'~' ."; ../,.." ~ .
.. ;,' 0 l,...., ~...., ~' . '
, ~ .... , < ~ "
Additional Information was provided with this
item
SEE - Official Records Reports/Studies
-=fF/d.-
"
~.J7. (S'
1 :
,.
"1
I
F / ft;:! /0
I
.
CfL\
Clearwater City Commission
-Agt'JlcW. C.mcet:.Memoraudnm..
Item fI ~
...tln, Dot.. I ....-l
o. , rr ' cl 5
SUBJECT:
land Development Code amendment revising parking space formulae. (LDCA 94-28)
RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION:
Approve Land Development Code amendment concerning parking space formulae and pass on first
reading Ordinanco No. 5820-95.
[] and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND:
A recent survey conducted by the Agency for Bay Management indicated local zoning ordinances in the
Tampa Bay area require more parking for large commercial developments than is necessary. In response,
planning staff reviewed suggested parking space formulae from several credible sources (see attachment)
and recommends some adjustments to the City's parking space requirements. The adjustments pertain
to a wide range of uses, including multiple-family residential, office. commercial, and industriaL
The proposed parking space revisions will have little or no effect on parking space requirements in the
downtown core, where substantial reductions and flexibility already exist. Certain uses are regarded as
"preferred" uses in downtown because they contribute the most to the vitality of the downtown area.
Those uses - retail sales, offices, personal services, residential. restaurant and entertainment uses - all
have lower parking requirements in the downtown area. Other uses, such as community services,
assembly uses, manufacturing and warehouses have the standard parking requirements. Additionally,
aU downtown uses may, with the approval of the City, rely upon public parking spaces to fulfill parking
needs.
t.
i
7
,
"
"
,
1
~
j
1
:,
,
t
The Development Code Adjustment Board reviewed this ordinance on May 25, 1995 and unanimously
recommended its adoption with several changes proposed by staff, including clarification of how the
ordinance is applied, revision to the grass surfacing requirement, and increases to the proposed parking
for general and medical offices. These changes have been included in the attached ordinance.
~!
1
\
,
,
;
Reviewed by:
legal
Budget
Purchasing
Risk Hgmt.
CIS
ACH
Engineerlng
Originating Dept:
CENTRAL PERHITTING
Costs: S N/A
Total
IA
N/A
N/A
~
. 'J
,
User Dept:
S
Current Fiscal Yr.
C~jssion Action:
o Approved
o Approved w/conditions
o Denied
o Continued to:
stbai tt t'd by:
City ~~J.. .
.... l d
~w Printed on recyc e pop~r
Advertised:
Dote:
.Jf\'t Paper:
a Not Requt red
Affected Parties
o Notified
~ Not Requi red
fl..nding Source:
o Capi tal 11lll.
o OperDting
o Other
Attochments:
ORDINANCE NO. 5820-95
PARKING COMPARISON TABLE
o None
Appropriation Code:
.>r .
mj.J~'.: . " '.::
" ;"'0
LDCA 94-28
Page 2
The Planning and Zoning Board reviewed this ordinance on June 13, 1995 and unanimously endorsed
. its adoption. The Board did request that staff look into several issues involving warehouse store
reduction, marina parking, grass parking for offices, clarification of the wording for multi-family, and the
legality of the elderly and low income parking proposed.
Staff has examined those issues and recommends that some changes be made to the ordinance received
and referred by the Commission to reduce the floor area of office uses having grass parking options and
revising the wording for the section on multi-family parking. These changes have been incorporated into
the attached ordinance.
PI
.."
ORDINANCE NO. 5820-95 '
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA,
RELATING TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; AMENDING
SECTION 42.34. CODE OF ORDINANCES, TO REQUIRE AN AISLE
WIDTH OF FIFTEEN FEET WITHIN PARKING LOTS THAT HAVE
PARKING SPACES AT AN ANGLE OF 50 DEGREES, TO CAP THE
NUMBER OF PAVED PARKING SPACES WITHIN A PARKING LOT
AT 12S PERCENT OF THE CODE REQUlREMENT, TO ALLOW
GRASS PARKING FOR WAREHOUSE STORES, TO ESTABLISH NEW
OFFSTREET PARKING SPACE REQUIREMENTS FOR THREE
FAMILY DWELLINGS, ACCESSORY DWELLINGS, MOBILE HOMES.
MULTIPLE FAMILY DWELLINGS, ELDERLY AND LOW INCOME
DWELLINGS, RETAIL SALES AND SHOPPING CENTERS, VEHICLE
SERVICE USES, PERSONAL SERVICE USES, OFFICES, PRIVATE
CLUBS, LODGES AND OTHER FRATERNAL, CIVIC, UNION-
RELATED, AND RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATIONS, BOAT SLIPS WITH
LIVE-ABOARD VESSELS, AND FABRICATING, PROCESSING, AND
MANUFACTURING USES, AND TO REQUIRE CONFORMANCE TO
THE UNIFORM SYSTEM OF TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES;
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section I. Section 42.34, Code of Ordinances, is amended to read:
Scc.42.34. Parking.
>II
of<
of<
'"
'"
(3) Applicability.
(a) In general. All parking lots, parking spaces and loading spaces provided after October 13,
1 985, whether such spaces are required under the temlS of this Code or not, shall be
constructed consistent with the standards contained in this section. Any existing unimproved
parking lot which is to be paved and any existing paved parking lot which is to be either
restoped in a manner different from that previously approved, resurfaced or resealed shall
be subject to all standards contained in this section, unless such standards are determined to
be impractical and specifically waived by the city tfftffie engincerr.tl1ifmgufMj9tf:'~liii~FhQJ
i"iic.hig~)~lri1:ij'~i~~~rt~~f'l~ii:~~~~pnif~~~"D~~t~f;Q(~&g~n:::~f:;~7...... .... .... .... .. ..... ....... .
(b) Parking lots serving a new or expanded use. Any parking lot which is to serve a new use of
land, including the buildings or structures thereon, shall conform to all parking lot design
standards, l~"'~~9'ijptp.i;:s.t~ft"tja~~'i surfacing standards, and parking space and loading space
standards con'tRined in this' section n'ri$fifi::~~'tiQiC:~~'i":n. Furthermore, if any modification,
addition, enlargement, extension o'j:"'itltc'rniio'fi of" a building, structure, feature or activity,
through the application of the schedules set forth in subsections (6) and (7) of this sectiont
results in a requirement for additional parking or loading spaces, then the resulting additional
parking and loading spaces shall be providedi2iilctr:tt~drtiij:nU.l ::.~p{l'ii4f:shnlr;~'2h(Q"tnf:1iffI,'~
re~ll:i.~iji~'~tf~(h9tJ~:'ll't(~e9.tiQ'ri:nij'Q :~e.6tio'~:"42:n. . . ... .. .
(c) Parking lots serving a changed use. If any parking lot is to serve a changed use of land,
including the buildings or structures thereon, where, through the application of the schedules
set forth in subsections (6) and (7) of this section, such changed use has an increased parking
or loading spnce requirement, then nll suchIHlslHIQ(i~l required spaces for the changed use
shnll be provided:'Slich' riddilionatSJjnccll shnll'coofQr.lll jo tlH;:;i~ID!ireluent6' Q( bQth:'thi~
section"AIJd 's#'tiqll 42.27. . . .
(d) Existing parking lots to be redeveloped. ~h~n'n uroperty]!! io ~:'jjde~eJ9~:'i!ltb'~if~ew,
struCt,'iri"oi u!ie":thnt"~ jit~~ii~es." th~' 'gross: fl9Qt. 'ut#u': l}g~lc"("ll'se:'~ren:'pf.;thedh'Opertyi :;u~
ypplicahlo;' by :.'2S:per',:eent .':or"m9(~;:::' tb~ ::entl(c ::'prope'rty:' ~tiall':m~t::'1b'f: ~q"H-erii~riW th,~
~tion' ~rid '~~\12~' :4.2 .7,7 . 'i ~tio\t1d': ip~.m~Qti1r::r~~'v'~l2Riii~ut':9(-tb~';.:.t?i9p~ttY: 'q~!J:fQy~r-: ~
Derio~ 'of ,wQ :'YM"o ~: !~3~~: riij.Q S'II cbiio~r~in~r.i"taf. red~v~loQroc6t 'cu.tth}l~llv~ly:iil~&a:s~~")M
grosiJfJk9r"ai~' gi)dI9~' ti!ie::'~~"of 't)l~'propel1Y.~;!fUpplj~Jl1~'~:: by:::2rrik:geitfol.<fuQ"i.~;:::tb~
~ttti~ 'l1rQvertY's~riU:rit~t tP~:regti it~trients"9ftJii$ .'if~ctl!2n' ~ijd . iJ~'j igtr4:?'/~1'~?: lf1U)'y.:pRit;:~(
it'. Iirkinglel "Whi~ro . 0'9&110' b~{..edetjdo~~~UtkHn""~r::ilfnicture.':whete:-tlle
~o':t'Of fi~tiE,ft:"~iife~'ee&t'3:O""relhl~~:~ilh;~ifti~~~~~:~)~ij~:'::;:~'::f'e":':rt'\
as ':,~~te.r.~~~"::~)~ :~~~'aty:;: p~,tliY.';~pp#ft.1~e:t:~:':6t.:)~~::ti:r~;e':;'.a.pPii~~~~::)i()~I;:";JJ?::~~~
. 'Ui'lte'bijjl~ia . ~Jl\\f . iUkih ' h)nft.itti:eri\ir~;:"Bhi\U:\Je."i~: uired ]o".:li>:nf&nu. to
i~~~ii~:l~t.~~~i~~1~~"~ii~~i
Haeea"joe;n wred:tt): ser;'if'an'. 'ient"iliiii' '"tinehitri"" ed ti~Hh~jre'"'' '~'ci1riftafbe.n"favrded
~~t~~~S~t~Z.~1:~i~~i~w~~t~~~
(4) Design standards. All parking lots shnll be designed to meet the following standards:
(~) Offstrect parking spaces, including aisles, shan be designed in accordance with the standards
identified in the following table. Any adjustment of the standards contnined in the table shall
require the approvnl of the city lftlfHe engineer. Furthermore, larger spaces may be required
by the cily tffiffie engineer where columns~ at' walls, or other site conditions impede
maneuverability or vision.
'"
'"
'"
'"
'"
(5) Surfacing.
..
'"
'"
Ij<
'"
(b) Grass surfuce.
h:: :..." : :::':.'~~' '~tl~fi\C~ . required':::: 'llie"' 'hl~l~itil\"IPi"~ riitQlper:Bf Rir~iahen(.Y;' '3urrn~~':'~it~iDg':~ gp~ei@
. .... ., ....~yjUJI((~ prirJ...ii1g:"]o~:' ~t,a1J' 09f:'exc<<d:tli~ ':'totql ~'il.tilnb~{:9($'paQes::reaui~9::pj:t~'i~'j'~JrgQ
i riciC{ified' b~'.J.?: ~'I:s~uj~' ~~C~Df fQ(: ';iili~i vi> h2:t~::"~~"6:,ri~':fferi~n,1 ~d fQ ~~f~9d :riW~ Icij'::'9.fti~
wi, loh'. shill) .' \l~>t ~~~'~id': tQ'ei{ititftiil in b$i'on~~~e.~' regUhyd:'by'jbfs ':~ec'don':.'rl9iij:3eij: bY:4(}
p~tS;ent j:"' Au:. spa~~:nridlll!i>>l (lenntrl' ~b}~"jij~~~e~ij :'Qf tbi~"(iatnh~n h~'v~:g; ~gi:i\if~ihin~~~Qt
OIhe'~ ~rm~1l?'~'lfli(ft\~~ i\iJd~\I~tlhe' flibi~ctfo'tli~'~VDt2~ti}lqnh~.~iti'~h~in~ti:' . .....
2. Grass surface optionnl. Parking lots which serve the following uses may hnve ~fflYided
with a turf block or other grass parking sllrface consistenl with the teons contuined in this
section. Unless otherwise specified in this seclion, Ihis surfacing technique may be utilized
only on parking spaces, not on the nisles which give access to the spaces. All such spaces
shall be remotely locuted with respect to the use they serve, shall be maintained so as to
2
n....
~.
s3-.
g4.
"
I
!
~.
f6.
g+.
present a neat nnd healthy nppe.,rance~ and shall be subject to the approval of the city
engineer ftfld--lreffie-en.g~.
Multiple-family development. Parking lots which serve a mu1tiple~family development
containing more than 100 dwelUng units may have ~tft up to tcn percent of the
required parking spaces in a turf block or olher grass parking Burface.
Offices. Parking lots which serve an office development containing more than ~~~
square feet of gross leasable floor area may have be provided witlt up to 30 perceii....~'fale
required parking spaces in n turf block or olher grass parking surface.
Retail and service uses. Parking lots which serve retail and service uses not in ether than
these located-wilhifl shopping centers which have more than 25 reauired spaces may have fl
required ~eefl ill excess sf 25 may be provided '.\lith up to 20 percent of such
required parking spaces in a turf block or other grass parking surface. However, furniture
and appliance showrooms. and wnrehouse stores. may ~ be-p1'6'Yffied-wtth up to 50 percent
of the required spaces in a turf block or other grass parking surface irrcapeeti';ei sf the
ftUmbet-of.sptle~ required. Access aisles servin!! such spaces may. with the approval of the
city engineer. also have a similar "unpaved surface.
Shopping centers. Parking lots which serve shopping centers may have ~lt an
amount of unpaved parking spaces as follows:
ilia-: Shopping centers having a gross leasable floor area of 25 ,000 square feet to 400,000
square feet may have he-pr-ovided witlt up to 20 percent of the required parking
spaces in a turf block or olher grass parking surface.
!!.I.}lr. Shopping centers having a gross leasable floor area of 400,000 square feet to
600,000 square feet may ~ be-;mwitled witlt up to ]5 percent of the required
parking spaces in a turf block or other grass parking surface.
~ Shopping centers having a gross leasable floor a~ea of 600,000 square feet or more
may lmY..!: ~llt up to ten percent of the required parking spaces in a turf
block or other grass parking surface.
Churches. Church parking lots which receive infrequent use may have be-pteY-ided \'(ilk up
to 85 percent of the required parking spaces in a turf block or other grass parking surface.
Access aisles serving sllch spaces may. with the approval of the city engineer ftfld lraffie
engtneer, also have be provided with n similar nonpaved surface.
Industrial establishments. Parking lots which serve industrial establishments and which,
through the application of the parking schedule set forth in subsection (6) of this section, have
more than 25 reQuired spaces may have a required number ef epaeee-in eXeeRf:I of 25 lJIoy-be
provided 'NHlt up to 20 percent of such required parking spaces in a turf block or other grass
surface parking surface. Access aisles serving: such spaces may. with the approval of the city
eng:ineer. also have a similar non paved surface.
Public parks. Parking lots which serve public parks may have be-prtwitJed-witlt up to 100
percent of the required parking spaces in a turf block or other grass parking surface. Access
aisles serving such spaces may, with the approval of the city engineer atttI-the-lfttffie
~flgifleet. also lillYS be provided with n similar nonpaved surface.
3
(6) Offstrect parking spaces.
'"
'"
...
oil
.
(d) Schedule. The following shall be the minimum number of offstrect parking spaces required
for ench land use, activity. building or structure permitted by this development code. When the determination
of the number of required offstrcct parking spaces results in n requirement of a fractional space, any fraction
less than one-half space shall be rounded down to the nearest whole number and any fraction of one-half space
or more shall be rounded up. Parking spaces required on the basis of building floor area shaU apply to gross
floor area unless otherwise specified. Parking spaces required for employees shall be based on the maximum
number of employees on duty or residing, or both, on the premises at anyone time, which would include any
overlap of employees at a change of shift.
I. Residential and lodging uses.
...
>It
'"
...
...
b. ll1ree-family dwellings, multiple-family dwellings, accessory dwellings and mobile homes:
Two gfte-ftfl~ parking spaces per ench dwelling unit for three-family dwelHngs.
accessory dwe1l\nJ!.s and mobile homes. One nnd one-half parkin!! spaces per each dwelling:
unit for multiple-family dwellin!!s havin!! no more than one bedroom. and two parkin!! spaces
per ench dwelling: unit for multiple-family dwellim!s having two or more bedrooms.
...
...
.,.
.,.
If<
L. Alde'tJ ~t:aq$t ;:JQw:. i n&ilil4':~ W:etuii:g('~9'~~iijfctedWi!~J)iiid.i'iiNv.i~~t,bOWglflb~i Jii~G' niij~na
ijQU~'O-g-'ij(lthH~ti<'the'Gitl ~o'n2iiij~: 9~vil!ipm~uttSl$ni\tlhliiijt?~~~fu1lt~ftoliW:i~mW ..~
,lj~~'~ijY:ai'::'ifip'mvAd~fQf'~151~r.ly.';''O'ft9\iq~49bi~:~J}iiij'nrVgll1Qb'~'~PGkktij"g'tiiii6~?P~~::i4~t~M
~roflQtfd~t~bti~tm'n2je:f~m.ibt::"\Wii~f~'mll~/~tElh~t&nmifd.'~liHig~'/}~~A~h~l~~\ff9~pijj
tla'rk:~ij"~::'~pn~:: ijef9~~lli~~ :p'nl~ J~(Wid,iVl~~f.~@iJW~)Y~11i:ij.((
2. Retail sales and service uses.
R. Individual retail sales and retail complexes eefflers with less than 25,000 square feet of gross
floor area: Parking or storage spaces for all vehicles used directly in the conduct of such
business, plus five ttHt parking spaces per 1,000 square feet of gross floor area.
b. Shoppillg, centers, relail complexes. or individual retail sates with more than 25,000 square
feet of gross leasable floor area: FOllr and one-half FtYe parking spaces per 1,000 square
feet of gross leasable floor area.
.,.
'"
.,.
...
...
g. Vehicle service: Parking or storage space for all vehicles used directly in the conduct of the
business, plus four spaces for each service bay or similar facility or area, plus one space per
two persons employed on the premises. Ench service bay shall be permitted to count as one
space.
...
..
II<
...
'"
j. Personal service establishments not otherwise specified: rive SHE parking spaces per 1,000
square feet of gross floor nrea.
4
,.
.' .......> .
04<
...
...
...
'"
~,r:.:')::;':\;::':PfP.~~:~::i~~~:~~:'~,~~::~~(p,~~~i.i!~~~:~t;:r~:~~l'~~~~:t{~(~:tg~~:~'~:J~~!~:.:~~~~~
ftl':.'<:\'..~:~::2Qelf~'mF~tflceii:";"/: Foufnrid'Qpe~l)l\)t'pni~n~'('~pace';v~'c;;1:9P~r~'Q"lli\"m";'feei'jQrgiQ'ss'~le[,~j1?l~
. ,d ".., 'tJo.9.~'~~~/ .... ... . . .. ... . .. .. .... .... ....... ... ........ ... . .' .. ..... ...... ....... ........ . ...............,... .
!4:;::X~/~<~edjc~L'~ffic~~:<$~i:::p'~r~jn2' np9:#~.P~:r .'f~(Xxr$'iU~r~:.U;~t: o(lib~ii. 'wiib~~::t1~9.i~ijr~:;'
04<
...
'"
...
'"
S. Miscellaneous publicfsemipublic uses.
of<
+
...
'"
...
b. Private clubs, lodges or other organizations of a fraternal, civic, union-related, religious or
similar nature: One parking space per 30.SQ square feet used for assembly, dining, meetings
or other specific use of the club fa~iliticsr-Plua one additienaJ parlcing--spaee per t'/16 petsOfJfl
regularly employed on the premises. Tlte-fHll'k-iRg 9paCeti required OR the booiB of fleer Mea
are fer the purpose of pre vi ding pntktng f-or members and l15fmfHe6 that o8e-9paee will suffice
to meet the parking need per fallr members. If-the facility is te be eeeupied by more than
four persona pcr pMlft.ng-spaee bll500 upon a grootef-eeeapaney-eaUfll-ftHowed under the
~~en one additional parking apaee-per-rour additien&l--eeeupttnts
shall 00 required.
c. Commercial marinas: One-half parking space per slip. except slips with live-aboard vessels
which shall be reauired one parkin!! space per slip.
'"
'"
olo
'"
olo
6. Industrial establishments. ~flg-spnee per employee, ph:l&-aft additional ten perecnt
ef..feqttired~fllployee parJti.ng [BY '/isitors; or, if-greater, .1lle followifl"gt
a. Warehousing: One space per 1,500 square feet of gross floor area.:.t-flHtI
b. Fabricating, processing, and manufacturing: One space per 400 square feet of gross floor
area or six-tenths space per employee. whichever is greater.
+
'"
oj<
olo
oj<
il1l Confonnance to uniform system of parkin~ lot design and traffic control devices.
Non!!overnmental entities to which the public is invited to travel shall meet or exceed the parkin!! lot design
standards of rule 14-110. Florida Administrative Code. Such entities shall also install and maintain uniform
traffic control devices at appropriate locations pursuant to the standards set forth in the Manual on Uniform
Traffic Control Devices as adopted by the Department of Transportation under rule 14-15.010. Florida
Administrative Code. Businesses with pnrkinf! lots that do not provide intersecting lanes of traffic and
businesses having: fewer than 25 parkin!! spaces are exempt from the provisions of this section.
Section 2. The provisions of this ordinance are found and determined to be consistent with the City
of Clearwater Comprehensive Plan.
Section 3. 111is ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
5
1 '.
".
"
;
. " . . .
" "0
,
\'
;} .'
.,
~'.
"
~,;.;..,",.,..,,.o.
, .. ~
;.
,
j':
..
'",
.~ .
;'
.. .
..i.
, ,~,".
. .d,... ..
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
~.--r-~.-
'" , ' ."
,
,.', ," ~,'~' "~'.~"".,~~';.'~
. .,.m. ...,."__._\
I
. !
!.
I
I
,
(
Rita Garvey ~ Mayor-Commissioner
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau~ City Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Pamela K. Akin, City Attorney
6
1
~,.., ." .
W
-I
m
~
Z
o
en
a:
c:t
a.
~
o
(.)
CJ
z
52
a:
<I:
a.
-c '- ;::-
IU
"0 ~m
C Q)CIJ_
eO) tJ c-
eo-
E C) ca '(ii c'
O C C .- .-.
'-.- >.::t.
UC"Oo'"
Q) 0 0'" ... ca
CCN a..a.
N
(X)
-cC>>
c=.
co CD
..J.....
C :)
co .~
.DCIJ
... c
::J_
-cN
c:'"
.to CJ)
-
a, en-;;
c: .5 u::
.- .:.c Ij..;
c: ... to
o co 1-'"
No..
'C
e
ca
c .:t
o c: 0
'en to 0 _'
's; a: .c m
.- 'C co
.cCDCm
:::l .1::. ~ ~
wen..&.._
c: ~
o .....
.- c:
... Q)
~"OE
oca.
0.(00-
I,I)...J-oo
c: . CD D:)
ca"O>O)
...cQ),....
I-tOCl_
"Q
c:
ta.....
...Jc
... 0)
$ E
ltl a.
:=.Q
.... Q) Q)
ta>-c
~Q)O
UCU
CD
II)
::l
.
:J
.
'C
-
Co
U)
-
,...
en
E
o
o
...
'C
Q)
.0'
N~
.
:J
.
"C
-
.
a.
U)
N
.
::l
"0
-
.
a.
<n
N
?
'E
~
Q)
C)
.5
en
..
U)
E
o
o
...
'C
Q)
.c.
0.
o;t II)
I
MN
M
in
E
o
o
...
"C
W
.c .
LOg.
d.
en
LO
N
,...
o .
"C ::l
::l .
....."0
11)_
.
::l
.
-c
-
.
a.
en
,...
.
:)
.
"C
-
.
a.
en
N
.
a.
<n
,...
..
>-
u
c:
Q) .
.0 ::l
:t:-ci
Q)-
.
::l
.
'C
-
.
a.
en
l.O
,...
):
'E
oS
~
c.
',p
"'5
~
10
,
,...
E
o .
o ~
-0"0
w-
.c .
a.
,... en
. .
U) .
E ::l
o .
o"C
... -
"C .
Q) c..
.c en
NLO
I .
,... .....
.
::l
it)-c
E-
o .
o a.
.t; <n
Q)lO
.0'"
N~
("oJ
..
(/)
E
o .
o ~
.0"'0
0)-
.a.
('l')g.
N
(/)
E
o .
o ~
-0"0
(1)-
.0 .
Co
('l') en
E
o
o
...
-01
.c
a.._
en a.
LOG.>
.CD
aUi
.~
c:
:J
-
.
a.
en
,...
E
o
o
...
-
.
a.
U)
LO
N
,...
.....
'c
:J
-
,
c.
II)
,...
CD
...
o
E
-
Q)
...
o
::r:
o
o
o
,...
-
.
a.
u),..:
LOu)
o
o
o
..
,...
-
.
c.
(I)"':
LOu)
a
o
o
,...
-
.
a.
1/)"':
(Cui
I/) ,
(I)'+-:
~ I/)
..0
(/)0
~o
ca ..
U)l.O
:=N
co c:
..... ro
Q).c
0:.....
'I~ ," ~",.. . .
~ .... ;::-
CD oeo
"0 . If- 0)
5i (I)(,/),-
E gg-
E OJ ro'in ~
O c: c:.-.-
J_.._ >...:::.::
o c:"O 0 10.0
CD 0.... 10.00 ro
a:NOa..a..
<'i
00
"00)
c:~
ro CD
...J....
c: ::J.
....
co',p
,o(,/)
... c
::J_
-
-eN
C,....
roO)
,-
0;0';;
c .5 u::
.- ..:-:: 0+;;
C '- m
o . n:I 1-'-
Na..
"0
c:
co
C ~
o c: 0
:'en m 0_
:~ 0:: :g m
,DCDCm
~.~ co ,...
cncnJ:-
c:
o ...;
',p c:
C'tI (I)
~"C E
oco.
0.1;00-
UJ..J-co
C-o ~CX)
Ec:CDC1)
1-1;00::'
"C
C
co....
...I C
... CD
$E
coo.
3:..9
... CD 0)
C'tI>'O
ECDO
UCU
G)
I/)
=>
-...:
d.ui
1/)0
LOa
coo
. ~
N-
o::t....:
.: ui
'+-
uiO
toO
ooq
00""
o ~-
.0
10 0 .
C'J o::t 5}
o
a
q
,...
-
.
a.
In"':
10ui
o::t,..:
. . .
....: In
'0
fl)o
'00
o 0 ~
00-
o ~-
~O .
10 0 0.
No::tln
o:;t.
.....
. . .
....: In
'0
1/)0
'00
o 0 ~
oaT""
o ~-
.0 .
10 0 C.
No::tl/)
o
o
o
,...
-
.
a.
(,/)....:
.
Lf)1I)
..:
CD
....
c:
CD .
() '+-:
C)cl/)
.E -E 0
8:CDO
0,-0
.cOlli
mEN
o
..0
~q
. l/)..-
00-
00 .
000.
~ _ In
001.0....:
00 .
o::ttOq-ui
o
..0
"':0
. ~
I en'_
00-
g g ci.
~ ~ In
00lt')....:
00 .
o::tCOqoen
o
..0
"':0
. .
I l/),...
00-
00 .
000.
~ ~ en
00Lt)...:
00 .
.qco..t'ui
o
0-
o .
~c."':
o en .
o f/)
tOLOo
... ..0
CD '0
> ~ ~
ocn-
o
0-
o.
~c."':
Oll)'
o I/)
coLOO
.....0
CD '0
> '+-: ~
ocn-
o
0-
o.
~o."':
all) .
o lI)
coLf)o
.....0
CD '0
> '+-: ~
01.1)-
II)
.....
co
CD
lI)
.q
-
a.
U)
,...
en
.....
co
CD
1.1)
(V')
-
-
.
0.
enen
. = ,...
C.
0...11)
o '- .....
.c~co
en c: ~
c: CD
._ tJ o::t
.
0.
III
,...
....
co
(1)
lJ)
-
.
a.
en
(V')
.
o
lJ)
....
co
m N en
-0)
(V') . 0)
_0.>
. U) 0
0._ a.
en E
""+0)
en
'-
0)
.....
C'tI
Q.}
~
-...:
ciui
eno
100
000
N~
U)
.....
co
CD
en
~
-
.
c.
U)
,...
en
.....
1tI
Q)
U)
M
-
.
a.
III
r-
o
o
o
~
..-
-
.
0.
en
0"":
C"II (I)
-..:
en
o
o
..-
-
.
0.
en
..-
en
.....
C
co
...
::J
1\1
....
en
Q)
a:
....;
f/)
o
M
-
.
0.
en
,...
o
o
o
.
-
-
.
c.
f/)
M"";
T"" lI)
~
"Cc:
o co
o '-
..... ::J
.... 1tI
f/).....
1tI U)
u.. ~
o
o
N
-
.
0.
(I)"";
-en
o
o
o
r-
-
ci.
en...:
.
tOf/)
CD
(.)
.~
CD
U)
1tI
C
o
en
...
Q)
a..
L
~ '- ;:-
CD 0 ex)
'0 ....0)
~ CDen~
E gg-
E C) l'O'ii) ~
O c: e.-.-
.- .- >.~
oe"Oo~
m o.~ ~ ra
a:NOa..a..
.N:
ex)
"co)
c::'
CO Q)
-J....
e:a
ra.,f:l
.een
~ c
=>-
"ON
e!"
. ra CJ)
'. t""
--
.. .. 0)
. cO) c: e .
.- u::
'2~'~.
o co'E
Na..1-
."
'0
C
ctI
c: ~
Oc 0
'ii) co' 0 _
'S; ii: .c (1)
',- "C co
..QmCOl
~;l:.rat""
cncnJ:-
C ..
o ....
.+:;; C
~ 'C E
oco.
0.(00-
CI)-I-CO
c"O~CX)
ECCDO)
I-caC~
-c
c
ca....
...J C
~ OJ
~ E
1'0 0.
3:..9
~ (I) CD
C'O>'C
~CDO
ucu
Cl)
en
::>
C'J
-
,-
I/)
....
en l'O
.em
::J CI)
... c:; M
..(1)...._
l!?.....c
ctI m .~ ci.
.e en c CI)
,
0-
U)
t""
~
U)
o
q-
-
.
C.
en
t""
en
'0.0
c..::!
ra "
....
~.c
m .9'
aJ C
o
o
N
-
.
a.
u)....:
t"" ui
M en
-c
'0
c.~
en....
m
t""c.
m
.- C
~ 0
0> .-
Eta
E ~
o (J
uf:!
.. in 0
en 0>0
~ UO
I.':: ...1.':..
~....... .~.-
o . ~ 0_
- c.en"iti .
~enO(Ja.
Q) <.0 0'- U) ,
~c:oo-gr-.....:
0) N ,.: E lri rn
. .
c. c.
U) en
~ Ii... .....
~ ....:
-.'ui-ro.'ui
ra en (J U)
ffi Q) 0.- Q) 0
a1Eg~E~~
0)0_ 0_
0-
Oci.
OU).
OLO'+-:
LO . en
~q-o
~..o
C ~o..
::JU).-
....:
U)
o
o
o
..
t""
-
.
C.
en
('I')
o
o
o
t""
-
.
c.
I/)
LO .
.....
q- u;
Q)
(.)
:e
o
oQ" .
.. "":
....: en
'0
eno
'00
00 ..
oo~
o ..-
..0 .
000-
LO'-U)
U) en
.... ....
ro ro
0> 0>
en CI)
q- o;t
- -
. ci.
0.
en en
t"" t""
0",: en
....
0 0. 1tI
Q)
o en . U)
OLO'+-: ('I')
o . en
,-('1')0 -
.
~ ..0 C.
m '0 U)
> '+-: ..
0 U)'- t""
....:
.
en
o
LO
-
$ r0-
m .... ~.~
~ 0 ro ~
.........: >Q)
....... . - >
_II).oQ)~
'0 E.c.e
c. ('I') ~.~ ro
en cn.c~
,... 0. ro ;: C)
.
c.
II)
,-
"'0
C
ro
(I)
.c
::J
c:;
Q) en
.... 0>
~ C)
.- 'C
0:..9
.c
(.)
...
::J
.c
U
\:,
I.
"0 -
CD 1.,."'"
"0 ~co
C 0')
CD men,....
E. u c-
co....
E en co'- ....
C C UJ C
O._~_'S :i2
uc"OO....
.Q) 0.... .... co
a:NOa..Q.
I'
I.
I
-
C\I
co
"00')
c::'
co m
..J...
c ::l
co'S
.eUJ
.... c:
:J_
"ON
c: ~..
co v,
,....
~-
I~O; ~. U
. '.5 '::2!E
c ... ....
Q' co ~',
.N'Q.f-
. "0
c.
eg
c: .)/.
o c 0
.- co 0
UJ-.c-
'S; Q. 0')
.- "0 00
.amcO)
::;) .t: :em -
wen. ~
c ..
o ~
.~ c
~"O E
oco.
o.mO-
UJ..J-CO
c"O~oo
EcmO>
l-egO~
"C
C
ctI~
-I C
.... m
e.E
me.
3=..2
.... f1) m
C'O>'C
'OS? f1) 0
oou
or-
.....
UJ
N~
->
.0
e.o.
UJ E
. .... m
o
o
q
LD
-
.
c.
UJ~
.....(1)
(I)
C'\l~
->
.0
0. a.
(I) E
..... Q)
....:
<Ii
o
o
co
-
.
0.
(I)
.....
- Q)
Q)
.>
0.0
(1)-
to 0.
. E
0 Q)
....:
0 <Ii
0 0
LO
~ 0
.... oo:;t
- -
. .
c. Co
U)....: (I)
..... UJ .....
en
- c
Q) 'c
UJ i3
(I) :J U
0 Q) ~
"0 .J::. C)
0 Q) 10 ::J
m .c I.,. .... c
U) U co 0 co
~ ... :2
::> en U)
.
Co
1-. C/'J I- lot ..
:>- h mo
~ (1).....0)0
~ W >.c U)
c >a;.Quoo:;tt:
Q) 0_ c.UJ m
e-o."OEJ::-"O
2 ci E :E m .~ c.. E
Q)UJwE_J::(I)U)
...., E ci
..... 0 (I) .
~~~E~ E
"'(1)....00_
.... m OJ:: 0
C - .. '- U . 0
mU~(I)rna.....
E-"O(I) (l)rn
"C m.c ,'" rn
(l) c.'- u 0).... ttI
Q;rnE_:ENo
"0 .. E........ 0)
c:.!Q N
egO 0..0)
~,g + e ~ ~
ttlU O)~oa.-e
...rn Q)coJ::E'o
cw->-uuQ)c.o
0)- 0 (I) (I)...
E"O c..'E.-.c-oq ~
Q)"O(I)E'O)' co
- 'e- c..- c. + -
Q) - Q) (I).c tI) U
j'~' .
ORDINANCE NO. 5861-95
y'
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
ANNEXING CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED WEST OF BETTY
LANE ON THE NORTH SIDE OF STEVENSON CREEK. CONSISTING OF
LOT 20. BLOCK A. STEVENSON'S HEIGHTS, WHOSE POST OFFICE
ADDRESS IS 1528 STEVENSON DRIVE. INTO THE CORPORATE
LIMITS OF THE CITY, AND REDEFINING THE BOUNDARY LINES OF
THE CITY TO INCLUDE SAID ADDITION: PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE. .
WHEREAS. the owner of the real property described herein and depicted on
the map attached hereto as Exhibit A has petitioned the City of Clearwater to
annex the property into the City pursuant to Section 171.044, Florida Statut~s,
~nd the City has complied with all applicable requirements or ~lorida law in
connection with this ordinance; now, therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following.described property is hereby annexed into the
City of Clearwater and the boundary 1 ines of the City are redefir.ed accordingly:
Lot 20. Block A. Stevenson's Heights, according to the
map or plat thereof as recorded in Book 34, Page 13. of
the public records of Pinellas County, Florida. (A95-12)
Sect ion 2. The provi si ons of thi s ordi nance are found and determi ned 1:0
be consistent with the City of Clearwater Comprehensive Plan. The. City
Commission hereby accepts the dedication of all easements. parks, rights.of-w~y
and other dedi cat ions to the pub 1 i c whi ch have heretofore been made by plat. deed
or user within the annexed property. The City Engineer. the City Clerk and tho
Centra 1 Permi tti ng Di rector are di rected to i ncl ude and show the propel'ty
described herein upon the official maps and records of the City.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
The City Clerk shall file certified copies of this ordinance. including the map
attached hereto, with the C1 erk of the Ci rcuit Court and with the Count.v
Administrator of Pinellas County, Florida, within 7 days after adoption. and
shall file a certified copy with the Florida Department of State within 30 (J~ys
after adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
'\
7-20-95 .
Ri ta Garvey, Mayor.Cammi SS1 oner'
Attest:
orney
Cynthia E. Goudeau. City Clerk
.. -
.'
t I'\,,~ M'- !.!.:..
'615 ~ '1;
t2 ~
9 8
7
I
f;i
1.3
~
!l
::;~ aJ,B ~ . g ~
9 1t}1 ~ 7 6
ftt ..~. :::@
10; 11:: I~e lJ
,
"0"
0('
12/02
OSI
o B ':lO~- '~:l
p,'e)
1
1
USE
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
PLAN CLASSIFICATIoN
A q 5'- 1'1..
)..
~
I- H'3
/01
l!J 10
cO ,.,09 OQ
<:I
,.,07 ::!
.
2. ... ., .., t- O> I....
a <:l a a a 5
'.:! '.:! '.:! '.:! '.:!
9 B 7
'3'5 e
1311
-
S
"""... ~,..".
--
DB un-'.)Q
III")
O<l
It>
...
~I.i
:;..1
PHILLIP JONES
FIELD
o
..
RUSSELL
STREET
!lO .'11;'-101
CII'I' I)l'Itl({1
HoLT YOUTH
CEltT(R
o B.l~I~-IlO
13/0:::
..
1
;;
13/01
..
<>
H(lll
It>
19
"'C)
~ I~
LAND
and
ZONINC;
.---. .
LqS-.IY
OWHEA
... I' P Ll C ^ II T
j 0 \-\ N 5 0 tJ I
R A ~j R.o w E I A Po
PflOI'EnTY DI!SCHIPTIOII
COil U T Y R C:-Sl D E'lJi I ALL. ow
R-3
Lo, '20 I 6\... k A
C; \" r;.vE ~s 010 HT~
O. \ B "C II 1. ~.
'LAND USE PLAN
ZONING
C I r y
Q t ~ ( 0 E.1J"t"{ A L LV W
RS -8
IeIGIIT OF.WAY
A.CIIL~
J
PLAtllll/lG bod Z.OIlII/O DOAnO
!_.--
.
.
CITY COMI.tI551011
'26Q B-
Sc:.CTIOIl
\0
TOWIlSIIIP 2't Z (tAIIOE \S- E
- ---... .-... .......-.. - .--- - -.....- ------- ----.
A II AS" A 0 E
EXHIBIT A
"
1
.I
. .'
~f,~,,; ".. ~, .
. '.,. n . ~
. '. .,T" T':"' t..
.~. -.. .
ORDINANCE NO. 5862.95
\5
I.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE' CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PLAN ELEMENT OF THE
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF THE CITY, TO DESIGNATE THE LAND
USE FOR CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED WEST OF BETTY LANE
ON THE NORTH SIDE OF STEVENSON'S HEIGHTS. CONSISTING OF
LOT 20. BLOCK A. STEVENSON'S HEIGHTS. WHOSE POST OFFICE
ADDRESS IS 1528 STEVENSON DRIVE. AS RESIDENTIAL LOW:
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS. the amendment to the future 1 and use plan element of the
comprehens i ve plan of the City a s set fortll in this ordi nance is found to be
reasonable. proper and appropriate, and is consistent with the City's
comprehensive.plan: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The future land use plan element of the comprehensive plan of
the City of C1 earwater is amended by des ignati ng the 1 and use category fOI' the
herei naftel' descri bed property as follows:
i
Prooertv
Lot 20. Block A. Stevenson's Heights.
according to the map or plat thereof
as recorded in Book 34~ 'Page 13. of
the public records of Pinellas County.
FL. (LUP95-14)
Land Use Cateaorv
Residential Low
Section 2. Tl1is ordinance sllall take effect immediately upon adoption.
contingent upon and subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5861-95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
7-20-95
"
Approv~ as to form and
leg~~iCienCY:
k.4
Parne a . k H1
City Attorney
Rlta Garvey
Mayor-Comnissioner
Attest:
Cyn till a E. Goudea 1I
City C1 erk
: I
! I
;
,
,
,
i
\
L
-
t 1'1,1"\ MI.!.!.:..
.1115 ... I; r
(:I
!:! !.:! .
I
9 B 7 f.i
~ 1.1
10 13
\ '"
,:~ ~ ..
1519 a
!, ~.
.i . II .,.
0 pAR . .....
~ . ... . ~ ... ill' . . ,..
'616 III .:t;; '"
'613 a~i' t!. ~ ' :?
9 1!'\ ~ 7 6
@ ..c ~@
~
..
~
10 ~
).
'50' ~
1l~'1~= 13
"" -
ti ~~ ~@~
~ ~~:: ::
or
j)~
..
(j
-
c
12/02
OSI
D.' 120~-'~1
1"'81
)
~
CIlY O'M-I({I
HOt. 1 YOU Itl
C(II1(R
O.B.I~I~-OO
13/0:
..
..
). I.J/OI
~
..
o
)...
l- I
I- '413
1411 1\ 1 '
UJ 10 ~-
cO '409 Cli ~l~
Q
I~O" ~ ::!~
o OVERLEA
. '"
2. - '" ... "" '" ...
Q a a a a 5
~ ~ t! ::! ::!
9 B 7
13/5 f
'''"
-
, S
DII.U"-<)O
l"'~l
Il)
...
...
gvj
::...s
PHILLIP JONES
FIELD
Cl
..
RUSSELL
STREET
\0
!lO 2 . It'- )'1
HC'l1
'"
~
">a
I~ I':
LAND
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
USE PLAN CLASSIFICATIoN
A q15'- \"1..
and
ZONINC;
----. .
LqS-.ll-l
OW HER
,., ,. P Lie A If T
J 0 \-\ N 5 0 t.J J R A ~i
Row E I A P.
pf\OPEnTY DEscnlPTIOH
COIItITY R~5IUE"l-.fTIAL L-OW
l{-3
Lo\' '2..0 I B\..... \<' A
~\s.VE 10<; o~\) H-rS
o I \ 8 /. C II I. ~,
'LAND USE PLAN
Z 0 N I l"J G
CITY
~ E" 5 I D EtJ"\1 fl L LV W
RS .8
lllrillT OF. WAY
kC Ill': ~
J
PLAlIlll/lG and ZOI/IIlO BCAnO
!_--
! Sl!CTIOll lO TOWIISIIIP
C 11 '( COM UI S S lOtI
2C-( s
FIAt/Of
l5"' E
All A 5 f' ^ 0 I:
'2.C;q B
_ .__..._.._......_.. _.___.__.....~___4______..._ ._. ,.-.---- ..-_ --. -.
.
-
..to~Tn 1" '.
T '. .,;~. ,
ORDINANCE NO. 5863.95
\~
,.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY ZONING CERTAIN
REAL PROPERTY LOCATED WEST OF BETTY LANE ON' THE NORTH
SIDE OF STEVENSON CREEK. CONSISTING OF LOT 20. BLOCK A.
STEVENSON'S HEIGHTS. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 1528
STEVENSON DRIVE. UPON ANNEXATION INTO THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, AS SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 8 (RS-8):
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE,
WHEREAS. the assignment of a zoning district classification as set forth
in this ordinance is found to be reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is
consistent with ttle City's comprehensive plan: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following described property located in Pinellas County,
Florida. is hereby zoned as indicated upon annexation into the City of
Clearwater, and the zoning atlas of the City 'is amended. as follows:
Fropertv Zonina District
Lot 20. Block A, Stevenson's Heights. RS-8 - Single-Family Residential 8
accordihg to the map or plat thereof
as recorded in Book.34. Page 13. of the
public records of Pinellas County, FL.
(.A95-12)
Section 2. The Central Permitting Director is directed to revise the
zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment, ..
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption,
contingent upon and subject to tile adoption of Ordinance No. 5861-95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
7-20-95
Rlta Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Attest:
~
Approved as to form and
1 egal SllffiCiej:
pan&: ~ Atrl
City Attorney
Cyn tt1 i a E. Goudea u
City Cl erk
III 111
'"
o
!:!
~ I'IIf~Ml.h ,
I;
~
9
B
7
,
f)
I
1.1 I
~:
!:l
HilS "';t;!l: ~ r-
'51! ~:tJ! ~ ' :?
9 :1' n ~ 7 6
~ '9 t. .. Ii'
\lS' ~ ~. "" ~
10;; 1 t:: 1:- E 13
. ,.. -
)..... ~ co J. tn,.....
,,0"0 ..&-
140' ~ ~ ~ ~ = ::
or
..
t
~
G
C
'P7
RUSSEll
)-
~ 111."
I- /03
/4/1 I \
ill 10
t1l '409 III
0 or'
'<107 ~ 6~
cOVERL.E.A
-Z ...
- ... .... l-- 0'1 ....
o 0 b 0 0 ~
!.1 ~ ::! ~ ~
9 B 7
13'11 E
'311
-
" 5
l'l Cb I:>
:!l "Il~
LAND
USE
-
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
PLAN CLASSIFICATION and
A q~-l'1..
ZONlNC;
-_. .
LqS-. 'l..(
OWHEn
....,. p Lie A 1fT
j 0 \-\ N So t-j I 1Z ~ ~i Ro WE, A P.
"
Pflop!:.nry DEscnlPTIOII
CO tI U T Y RC:-Sl D cl...fT I A L L-ou.J
R-3
LOT '20 I B\.....k Po
.:; T 6. V E ~ ~ (] ~\.J I-fT S-
0, \ 8 A C II I. ~,
'LAND USE PLA~~
ZONING
C IT Y
Q E' 5 ( 0 E.1-J"1"( n L LV W
RS -8
IIIGIIT OF W^Y
l.Clll!.i
I
I'LAlltlllla 1ll\U lOlllllG IlOAJlO
1-.--
l St:.CTIOIl \ 0 TOWIISIIJP
CITY COMW5SIOII
'2..6Q B
2'-i z
flAHOE
\5"' E
A II ,,:; I' A 0 E
I
-
-----LL
'.
.'
...,,~.~..._<~. . .~1' .".
) ~<' :. ~ t
.' .:-~:;...~;;~.
.'.... ....... ~. .
JA ~!...,,, . ':
. ~~t::;.~~.
;,. ' . >' " ,.:.... . ~ .
.'" ......' .,:=:'
\. . "' :.',
,.
.' .
... ...
.. 'c .
DATE
." ...,
. .
P~'.'" ..
~;.. '
~!.. .
-~'.
~
.,~. . .
~~~,
...
P'o:-' ,
F-!(pc;S-
o' , . I. ~ . '..". '
AGENDA
1_11_ 95
ITEM # /1
','
.,.
'"".'17 '......,..
,\
ORDINANCE NO. 5869-9~
\1
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER,
-FLORIDA, AMENDING SECTION 2.60 (3), CODE OF
ORDINANCES, RELATING.TO TERM OF MEMBERS OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE; PROVIDING AN
EFF'ECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, Section 2.160 (3) provides in part that if a
Board membe~ resigns creating a vacancy, a new member is appointed
for the unexpired term; and
WHEREAS, this provision is inconsistent with commission
Policy BD-4 which provides that a person appointed to fill a
vacancy created by resignation shall be appointed for a full term;
NOW THEREFORE:
BE IT ORDAINED ."BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. That Section 2.160(3) Code of Ordinances is hereby
amended to read as follows:
Sec. 2.160. Creation; Membership.
(1) There is hereby created the Environmental Advisory Board
of the City of Clearwater.
(2) The board shall consist of seven members who are
residents of the city. Members shall be appointed by the city
commission.
(3) Appointments shall. be for a term of four years. A
member, . including a member initially appoInted for a term 'of' less
than four years, .may be reappointed for not more than one
additional term. I~ ~ v~cancy occur~, ~ ~c~: appoi~tmc~t ohall be
mae.c by the c:..ty commiooion =or the unc)cpi::ed term. Members shall
serve without pay.
Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon
adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
8-3-95
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
"
Rita Garvey, Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Attest:
fvL k-
Pamela K. Akin, City Attorney
Cynthia 8. Goudeau, City Clerk
p
"
,
.'
Jt:\':e"~' '. ',"
, .'
. .
ORDINANCE NO. 5870-95
. AN ORDINANCE Of THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
ANNEXING CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF BAYVIEi~
AVENUE AND WEST" OF MC~IULLEN BOOTH ROAD. CONSISTING OF
LOTS 1 AND 2. BLOCK 2. BAY VIEW CITY SUBDIVISION, WHOSE
POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS MEADOW LARK LANE. l09A AND 109B.
INTO THE CORPORATE LI~IITS OF THE CITY. AND REDEFINING
THE BOUNDARY LINES OF THE CITY TO INCLUDE SAID ADDITION:
. TOGETHER WITH THE ABUTTING ALLEY TO THE SOUTH: PROVIDING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
\<6
,:
i'
WHEREAS. the owner of the real property described herein and depicted on
the map attached hereto as Exhibit A has petitioned the City of Clearwater to
annex the property into the City pursuant to Section 171.044. Florida Statutes.
and the City has complied with all applicable requirements of Florida law in
connectiqn with this ordinance: now. therefore,
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISS ION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following-described property is hereby annexed into tIle
City of Cl earwater and the boundary 1 i nes of the City are r'edefi ned accordi ~gly:
Lots 1 and 2. Block 2. Bay View City Subdivision, ac~ording to
the map or plat ther'eof as recorded in Plat Book 9. Page 43.
. of the pub 1 i c records of Pi ne 11 as County. FL. together wi tl1
the abutting alley to the south. (A95-14) .
Section 2. The provisions of this orelinance are found and determined to
be consistent with the Ci ty of C1 earwater Comprehens i ve Pl an. ,The City
Corl1nission hereby accepts the dedication of all easemen.ts. parks. rigllts-of-way
and other dedi cati ons to tile publ i c w}ri cl1 llave heretofore been made by plat. deed
or user' within the annexed property. The City Engineer. the City Clel'k and the
Central Permitting Director' are dir'ectecl to include. and SllOW the property
described herein UPOIl the offi~ial maps anel records of the City.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect inunediately upon adoption.
The Ci ty C1 erk sl1a 11 fi 1 e cert i fi ed copi es of tll is oreli na nce. i nc 1 ud i ng the map
attached hereto. with the Clerk of the Circuit Court and with the County
Admi ni stratal' of Pinell as County. Flori da, with; n 7 days after adopt; on. and
shall file a certified copy with the Florida Depar'Unent of State within 30 days
after adopti 011.
I'
I
!
I.
I
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
~
8-3-95
Appl'ovecl ilS to forlll dnd
legal suffiCiency:
parn~II~I. C1 ty Attol'rley
Hitil Gdl'vey
MilYOI' . COIIVlll S 5 i On81'
Attest:
CYIl tl1 hI E. GOIl(/etllJ, VI ty C1 erk
I " f I 'U I "j I'~ i ~;
,:) ,." f" ,.)
't -1 .; 'J ~ :;
~ ~~_. --.
1- ;'1 ' -, rntJ,m.
o 0" " ,
., . r ~
._,..~ I.J._
;tLl~11' FtJ g~ ~ ~
t.. ":JI of ~." N
. t ~ _ _ _ C".
,., ""'. ,~ f'~ ,..,
1:-lo:J~1 OF;-- -]@I
."l ~ - 0'"' _ 'lIl - _ ..
~ . -C" 11:' ... .. - - f"" N
/'1 ~ ~I~' ':' ~.~~'[:~.. ~;;::
.-. R"I ,E1f
"'-'"':;:;!m' ". 10
'1:~lJ" (." - ,.,~' .; O>:~~
. l. 0 - - - - ('I
. ,,' /.t:~:~ H.~Nc.. -
tR
, ~ f ~ ";', Hr'
~ ~ ,f.~ I. . ",
, ') ~\ .1 5 6
ii) ( 1 lI1l'"
JI:. ':'\;7:;' u. . ---
~tlf~; ~ l.~~ ~T~.'
I.. I.E,I\~t":;F~"1
!.. -- rRE~~~~~
:1,;;; -'J~;- T:<, I )'. toO
~ Ii.." ~"
I 'l 3 J~ ..:.'1,'~~).:::
(" J' ,5,111..
~ .'J 1 ,', :.' ~r~
~IIl1~T! ~
, ~ " : tl ltj\
0' :. ,*
!!:f :....:..:... '. ..~: l~
~ j I ..~.. "":'; j\f:
1!~r.Ut;~~~ ~
j~l.l53) ~1 D6 3
I 9.:$::i
1 ~ 11 HI :.,"; 7
,/ "
o .,. "" . ~"~ Q)
g 8 - ,J E; (;
i, __... ~ ",~'..~4 I'"J
5
:>
.,
l~^n()1 IN A
..
(}) em 0'''''1;0 62J~'::",/ ..;..: /~ hi' . ..,HU,~"~"
r'MII( 217 I"~-'\o.' '\"p:,I."~"
> :. : "4,1,. ~. \ t~ ," i . ,'.' ..,
. :,. < I ~ I;. h \;. ~ \ T -:1t
7.1./07 n/I;~ 22/JG~ );.': ~"~I.' "'.':':;' '"
_ ...1.o.U".J.'K. _ _ R ':';~~ 11; ~...:~, t~ ~'~"'> \, ~ I
=..J1l'1::JJ;; .,'i'\:'1i.-'" rr r:,~, .. .;]iiJ' :~, '~~~l ~.::'J)l,,~' '.~: '0
~.;i.:.l~i~.... ::.... f; _ "i ,_~." iiOo-124~!.. J~ ..1lrl' ," ~ -I:..:. f b' '2.P'I"I# l, .: .p: ,.' . :
l~""il''1~ (>o~Yl1l-~'r~ ,,011 ",0 I'1N lC"'~. N'd'i' :: f\.',..~J:I.....i;.;"}'1'1'..
ti. ..., , ,I ~. .c:o 1'1 "'" .. _ ... ('I "4') N ....1 'C) n .11.. l~' .)0'" L~ . d~ .~:l t .' f~ I I
!~~"rr:\.. pg 22/lJ~~""" ~....... 0...... ",-0 ':oJ ?<d~'': .4)".... ':~c!,.r.:.':: ,~..; d'
.;l,~I,/::I'l.., ..... (', C'l'" N N"'!:"!. .~'l ...\ ~ '" ~"~''';l '}:., ~'/
,~~, {J~: 'I \"'I S B f"l N N 11:!:';!l. S'.'!~" ,Ir ' ~.::i n. .'. '~'j' , ... I'. :,'oJ:;;" .
''''.',;.'.t... '"~ - - -f- 0 -. ;'~"I"'"~'-.Jr':I~"" -~t""""l
,.,:],jl~,1.. .., 0'1 :J on I sg, . -,~ OJ; "I l \, .. . '!'l ,Q ~ l ~ '3 "\", . ~
;?.,;/rl', ;I'~l ......~.....::::.,.. Q~ :'~1.. {Q.i ~i .J_:'H.!;.~' ~J,1.t,r ;~~t!l\f\\.'~l.
. ~/' ~ N'" ~ c--.f C"'1 '" ::e C" l(i~ i, ~ ':~J I ~ .~} 4 I'..~) '~~,.: ,... .,. .
,~~~~;r:;~ ~I h1~ ';:; <:''l'; ~kt <:'I ~ ~ N I ~ . ;it..n t :rh'1: 1~ "R !(-il!.lW})"';
:r.1.ji";'\J~ 'f111 "a ].)0>0. ,<,> ~IJ ""'....~. ,I t.t".f'TIfn .':iH'~')' J":I' ;: 'l.thz10
:~, '\';;:! ., - - .:' ~~ 01 t '~I .. ";,' ." \fl n ;:.,~ liP'I'" r~ I J' ~ fl(; ;f $'~{':'('i.I;
'.: ~';':lt.J..~..~LNIS:v.r.1r.-;- '~,,;~\;~ 22/18 .;h~~\l.l~~ ~'~l"~';~ ~~ ~,~. ;,!.r~(r/' 1~l~'~ :!".~~ ~A'~'~'
H'1~~' ~MI-'~n I \1 A)'" " .~~1. ~; ~W'l.: ~ ,'I:i 1:'4'" I .:.'l!lt~.., ....~ .J.ii.jt.V':'V:
l.~~ci ~~~ld~~~ g ~~~.,,1~~. t'J~ .... \:~~~,~:~,~;..i:}~~.~,~t~~:';~l~~::l J;,f~~:.:: ' :;~~ ,':t~l~lrijl~
, :'~: l-'~' ~~~,~Jl\~h~' }'~' "'.lf1 ~}:1-;~f..i:~.l~'~;t":: :~' F.\)'Y..:i ;t~: 'r~m' ..I!~ ,
if:; ?.'; ::'.1 ~ tl.t ~{'I~~.~.t::\~!t.~!r ~',~;.U~J:[{~;\~:h~'~f' 1:~~;.N~'~"ir/;' ~~H~\.~JI/~'~rr~t1fu'{t ..~Mj:J~'';'
1,'.1.'''2. ~;-: ~,~. fi . 't . "-r':;~:'i~ . ~', ,~lt~~I!~'I"'~b 1M,. ;~'}J"t:~:fl! 1t'.' '(l fc-l 1'\' " / ~""
.11\ ~.. b.t"}.~3 ,'., ~, ;.'!'m';,\~~ ,. ~~t\!i~'~ld~'\~;t!l~~?'r~I'l'J'I!j;~'i? tj~~'!7\hA;'; g ~ G ~.
21, ...:....:.. ....-r ' "I' ':.~. Nlr';5J~I-'ih{'~~~;~I!1{, '~J~~J 1'1:?e"~!r}~\\lf;!,\. ,9 ; . l-:; ~r I' t 123 ;,;
W . i! f'(ltt'f.l' "~'ll\.'~~15J{.\i! {" J;;('1;;\rj:~'II~I~/:' \1 ~:;l';[.: 'q Q .
j to Q 8 7 6 J ".i.,.,..J,'-'.'lrit ".:.j~~t;. ""'f.I"I\-:"'~ '," i:'\!"'" !Q"
- .>" OJ;\',J 1" ~\t,";I. ~ ''''l.E "'\i"\'f~ .f..f/..J~"';! ~ :i,: :1. i./' 'Q"
... ~ . . :,i~,r,tt~'(.J.i,. .'Il!' ~~. ~~J~1 ..h',I,.,.; ;.1.'1 :~...!h/i Ij',; .n"":,I': '.
.... N ','l'F..~.tUi'l '~~':i~H1 l-'i~'ff"~"i~1Y1'r\;:":~\ ''')'~'Y.\''I\''~ \ -;,\,;..\
~ g ~~, 'f'~i;!~~~ ;:ir~;~~r;~ I~K~iT {d~~t~ ;i:i{~.u.~~~ :,:,,1 "i;":.~~ l'~:: \'?. \~ \
- - ....-1;:;r .' ':'II,U~fl/'~'f!:i::JJli;~!;'>;~:~~~~:' 'i~ji'iI~':;:':"~"J;h;j:L:.!:n!.; If) ~"~~k ?ltH
~J~~~~'- -~;"~I:I~ljf)l 2....~~(~, ;;j{;!' /l'l!I,'.ni'r~"!b'[i-&iJ :uVftafJ/f
~.~~~ a ~:~
! p~l\i . ,,I ,'...
t 2 J ,1 5 I 2 j . A 5 6 7 8 9 ~ R ,~t. ~t" ' I'
R,I>P5U7: --;Z~51J : Y 7tE W 1: .... _,~2 ~JN ~ :,~;~~?~~.'~:~
~f~ 9 ~ 2J ?2 21 20 - 18 _! 7 ~,'.6 15 ~~~~ ~ tYR~ :H)~~
---- 19 0" A u Mf'li'-'I,..I
T ~R E .\\'.~"l~ (: :..1.<.:
::7 Cl( nW^ En 2"
..'.,,\ 00"",... 'j'" ,. "^,"IJ~M' l'~~ -~ ~7
; 'f:',\'."'lr::.,:I',"~'" ':., ,.......... ~." .,. ,; " n,:. 'V
~t~~~t':'~:!\:id.;W}l::\~i.~:.. ~.I ":It. J:~:.:(illl.~ ~,t;i~.:~~~ ~~I;;l ~
~g~ ;~"':i '1:.:. tl': .t.,. t' ':'i:; ~y.lt',: .'?~;.; ",~'I'; ![. ". :.'.ji (7"\ ,10"
lr ., .tft"l J Ii: 'r, ,'~" "'. :f": .:'jf' /1111 ;': ,;.'1 '.: ,~.i,t 0 ~
~.~ I i',,~.~ttl .~II.. ';{ ,Ii> ~t~riut" ~ !o!.'.rl. \3)7 8 g~'
;'''' , ... :t. ~'\'i ., :...~,ti ,~, .~ ~~~ :hi" l
i.if,:O ! :~ . ~:,. .' !. lLIoN:.1 ;::: ,~~ 1.,1;1,. if 13:~ 3 ;;.
.;f\ .: 1.:. ." . . do .r., '., ~,~.~, \, .~... ~'.'~I'~', ". 1 ... VI 'Ill
~f~; w~~T~'~~":~:::~'I:':~>;'ltf1~gt ~ '"
'J~l"I'.::~ IJ ~ 7 ~~ .. k}P~CI< .. 37-0~
, ,'~,J ~ _ ~ ,. l- I. ':. ,,;. I :,:.1 I
A \/1:"1..11 Ie' v",.,. ,,'1(0_ M~ I
:1/1
'19
R
b1
I:';+;
,; ,~,~~., ,~; ~~.~
. ':';i,l;('1:.!O'l ;;.
. ~.:f1'r.'~I~:;'~
, ,'1' ::f\"\~F (ri\' th
nn r
LA~JD
P80rOSEb ANNEXATION
c LAS S I Fie A T I 0 f"-J a n cJ
^ '1 5 - I LI
zoNING
USE P L A ~J
-...--.-----
t<J\ D L E. c..
l)Wllcn
.t,PI'IIr.^11 r
L I 51\.
~
L ^ ~J D USE
rL^~J
I
Z 0 t,ll ~J G
I
(.l" - ~
t> II 0 tl 1:.11 l Y 0 l: S C III r TI 0 II
C
~~o T ::, \ '-1
e,AY V1evV
A 1111 nil II rrl1 tI
E-, L Y..... . 2-
S LI E-,
2.)
C\f'(
tl fl~,l~ .\ tV
COIIIII'"
(1, c_ Sit,) E. N r I 1\ L
...---..--.-.........- -.- - .................--------------..
Q. 2.. g
^Clll;S
U. r.f, f\ rJ
P....s 8
(: I I ','
{, F. r, I r"l E....J r I ,\ \..
IlIGHT or w^)'
"CIlE!;
-..-..- _.. -- ... ---....--.............
I' I ~ I,".' ~ I~~r~ ~:: ~~,!~_~~I~_,f~~~~~,~. - ,"~;I~"~~~ _~_~= J.=.__~ 'c 0 M IA 1 S ~~~~~ ~=~=----=--=~_
',I " r 10" \ G T fl '0'111 r; 111" 7_ <1 -; n ^ /10 r: 1 to E A 1l A 5 1'1\ (1 E 2. 9 2. A
.....'J':...
ORDINANCE NO. 5871-95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PLAN ELEMENT 'OF THE
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF THE CITY. TO DESIGNATE THE LAND
USE FOR CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF BAYVIEW
AVENUE AND WEST OF MCMULLEN BOOTH ROAD. CONSISTING OF
LOTS 1 AND 2. BLOCK 2. BAY VIEW CITY SUBDIVISION. \mOSE
POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 109 MEADOW LARK LANES. AS
RESIDENTIAL URBAN; TOGETHER WITH THE ABUTTING ALLEY TO
THE SOUTH; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS. the amendment to the future 1 and use pl an el ement of the
comprehensive plan of the City as set forth in this ordinance is found to be
reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is consistent with the City's
comprehensive plan; now. therefore.
\9
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The future land use plan element of the comprehensive plan of
the City of Clearwater is amended by designatlng the land use category for the
hereinafter described property as follows:
Property
Lots 1 and 2. Block 2. Bay View City
Subdivision. according to the map
or plat thereof as recorded in Plat
Book 9. Page 43. of the public records
of Pinellas County. FL. together with,
abutting alley to the south. (LUP95.16)
Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
contingent upon and subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5870-95. '
Land Use Cateqory
Residential Urban
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
Rita Garvey
Mayor.Commissioner
Approved as to form and
legal SUff~nCY:
iL~A~
Pame 1 a K. 1 n
City Attorney
Attest:
"i
I
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
I' ..
I:? J~~ I:~ :I~ l:i IS!' dl CitY 0...."0) &2)'- ./ ,';'..; ,', \1, i' . 'l'ti 'il,.,
~ I~t D.' ~ ~'V "!. ,:! _. -~ I'Am< n~ -/ 1\ qr; L '~;'I~ t:, ~; ..,
.>1\' . _....v, _ 2" /07 22/1,j ",. ~,:'i': ~'l~ \; ,. :;:
10 'd ' M' m:' ,.t. . " 22/J5- '~'. ~ ~\" ",,' ~ :. -
., ". :' =-'0 ~/'!t.~ & '-:;';:;;;-1 r' ~,',:~"~ i:l,',', oJl
.. ...... I,) ,_ ~~.:;-' ... - .'1;Oi.- :l rl :r: ..' .... :~: .;~ ~:t',.j ~I}" ': !;;
U~-'1'-- -- -0-- ~,&.l.1~,~",,:""'6 ~,-~~.." i;:;';~ ~. ........;.;J-IoI~. 'j.:.:.' ",' .t:..~"~, h"l:tJ'iif}il. "\?' , .
\') ~L 'tiN:;;:;' ~ ~ :....}./!ji\~ _::;~JIl.-:11r., toll) ~2 foj!::I' .0"; ~., N.,: '~'a; R,';:u;/.';,";I';'1'r:r., .'
_ _ ~ _.... _ _.-.. _ .......,{,.,\. VtJ Q ..., '" - .....--. 'Q ~ t'!"'''1 n~.: '_1 - \\~ .:,...,,.~.;..;; . I P, .
U: Q . 't>"'''' ';t :!l"" 0 P> 22/1J ~ ~....... ~........ ~" ......~ '\1..1 -;;-<.: \~ .: ~.! ..: ..';~ !'-'. ".~: :..; ,
t.... _ _ _,.~ .;t2'jJoitl.".......... C"'I ('I f"'1 N .I::'!:'" ~l -~ = .\1 J..... I "z,.. ..c,/d
. J' 11'i"1:'::: N ,. CO,.. :1/~c':'!:::: _ -5--8- ~ 1'1 N ;';'I,';'!t.<;, ,!,.. I{"~ ~ol ,r!':;.~:'!;l'J.' ';."~1;"~ . .
Il~I,I~fl~I~J:~;.[~:f2JN :"'~'I~~!1:.." ='~~l 2/1:b ~~ ~~ S~ ~% !.~~.1 ~~Q~ ,~d!.~~~'~lkYillwlliji~i.Ai.\\~~i,~
~ 00 .' -V ,;'.';r"t:C~; t::....~ .~ N~ ~C'I N Sl ~N ' , ~t ~ 'iN~:~ -A}~',. 1\~i ~i!t-}~;T'\"~'
.-. R ~ I E if '0 ~::;d( '~1 -:;:~ 3jt!,L ,~-ml=m ...-."........ ,,.., ....-.....,' 1'1 I i thit ~t :~i~ ,~:!. li1:\ ;;'r \V.' d
.. J,@ m f-.'~" ~~~ :~t\:;.I~ . I~ "WI!' .:s...q:.1'i -OlEw "":"' I .,~l "':.("" "'Fl ~'1f lh'~/\' (;'I1-~Uk ;r i!it.:.;.~i"
"[\':~l .. ':::.:: J' ,;~ ,., ,:, ~;'t\[,\. ''.P;~. i?ii:'O'<"-ll""l"7 )=":~';:;~ 22/18 ;h!~~.~: ~t~I':1'f. ~t11 ~"~' gf~,.{. i~ll'.ll :"f':A.1 ..~ :~.
t. ,... . _ _ ("'a.I ~2Z0!1 ,~"".~~n ~ .)...~.. .~~K~ l' J -tr_) ~ ..i:j ~~'C: ...:'-.t~C. .....~!J 1 %J/v~v.
, '/~r:hv INIA - \.~ifJ..tcl. A~;'EJ.Jd~/;1l ~ ~,~~.J;1\ (G) \Mi!:J~\~ .H.f,~8i :1~~ t1;'!~ ~tf~~'t i.~r.'1 ,..~J111~~;tJ
,~ . --"7 -1;l S! H :";1'"'\~'~l'.'!~lH'i'~'X'1~tl-~~;''''1Il'''~:''/'1''!'''\1:1'~1 \:,1 ,h nl;': ';,H, !rllt',~~4/()~
l"'ft. ,-..;:- Itl .t. ~t ..~,.... ,"~ ~'f' '~1'il(l ti-l..."'.j.......... ...fIt"" . 1"1\0'\.217 U' I'\:JI. '''t~ \ . . p. '_.
~ <:; Q..., . riP no :!3'" .., ... .~,~...: ':^1,: ..I}" l1(1, t, (II Ir. t,[....r\l'.'~..f~.. '. "(I ~, '1' :..! ~r.'~' 'fl")' I .'\"
~ ~ ~'~ 't. . '.'; . '1Ji. ~;: i.R ~ :,~ ~/; :'i'.J;l)l:il~ri;.:.~!~!JI~I~~ ~ "~:'rn,,~'i~ i,~~ltii:\;IJ~~{!; ~i'~f:F{:{\~\~}Jr.r~ t.! l.~. ::l!~~;,:,..i :.1.:
I , , ., 5 6 V, ..!, .'J .\ 1: :~~ ~h';W\f'~t~' 1\\IYil~;1j. III'.~ r~{.~J,:q'~'IlI'~' i! .::l~, '!P I . ~.,.\. ,{1dl,Il!t!!.:,
-' . it~~,iiL .oJy:~ C) A ,"'r"~l.~,~ ;{....;-ltN ',~~h. tl.;~".,::,.tL'J.o" , !~, 1'\" ;-
J~.. ~~t ~.~}-, @ II' ii~. ':\,-tXf3. ;'.. .J.' ;;~ ~;,~r.~~~ ,. }~~>i.~~A~1~'~\~~~~I~\~'{~\'rt~~;~~i~ ~l~t.\'~t ii~ ~ ' ~ G I ~
j,--., l~"'~, r ) ..' J'''~':'l'~ ".l""~lt 'I..'~ 1JI'l.~<.r,).~~I"11"" I ,....ILI 1 '23
W 'i .'I'.~r. ..lL"\'.;!..,., ',.. F......it.! (4,' ,.t" ...-:. .".
It~l."'" 10 9 13 7 6 j' I: ~~,11 )~Il;';""lll''il . .j,j t'" ;t.~t~fi.~.\'I~'.';' II :':'1::'.'1 ~" Q .
1..1..,......,0' 8 7 5 .:- '!Ji\'U~~-Vri ~:;l'l~r,~t~'l~~ "\'1\(.~~ 'J'J'/!'~'~H)I ;';!.:~;'i. i:;" ""...........
~ k I-.:J <n ' . "\'p{ '(..t.,n. ',,1 ~'iA~:.>r.-UI'h'l .t.. .1.' .Cr ",v 'J" \~t"'I" I
I,:r ~11 N OJ . ;. ~;jt~.~t'~\'l 'i';l'~'~.~ \'.~iJr >i."\4IS" t:h,:.~:;:( ~. ~~,L\'l;' :~ \ ~~:.:\.
_ __ _l.E" ~"l ~ $I ~ IJ ;.\~':,~:.:~~:~ ':,i!41.:f'ft. ~~r {d;;:ll.ti,.t~J~ ~ :'::'.iT'~\~~ I'~ ': \~ ~ \
4~V~H~.~.~. '- -- -Z :.~~_r;"I4.~':" ~..,~ .... ,T. .I.~-f~... ~~ f 1'\", ..~". t 1~'I'_.\ '..',
l KtHiutkY:t~ ,,~~ n/ .:..:.. :.,.:;lh'r('~s.;~.U(I)lI'W~':1~'~~ ~~iiil;'.:i'~fi";.I!!Jl.:~Ld:~ ;N j,.:,: \"fj't 1 ~(f
-- -'Mt .. ...' '.' , ~-510' .~.f, ~,f)l .;o'C4 ~ 'Yt~.i1i~): !'!! ',..n'n~'l ~~'7i'i'.1f:~.1.J t"\ I-( . '!l'i
.",\ l: l.i,' ":l ~~ I cLiil.i'iw i(H .....-. !ib.lh~~lfi~ i~\!t
~. ~".l"':".~" :!II Ii! ,..
~7 i r Hf: .:r.l::: ll! '..' "'~:
_ . 5. Ilk ,..."t I 5 1 2 J .~ 5 6 7 #..!~,h' ,>
W 1 I j ", !lTIl: ., F. ..J ' lJ3_~ rtE W ~2 r-tI ~ ~"::"ift.:;, ::1.
. ~ ~.. ,.:;:! '~l..; ~
:2 !i 10 9' ~\ ~'L ~~~ _ VI 2J 22 21 20 ': 18 17 16 15'" o! JB.~ :.~i~'l
. :: '.' I .1.,. 11.1.i] 'r tRI "JA ~E u J11f.~i. "'l~ ':.1,
:: ~ _~ \.~ 1--'. ~"'I:,,"'~~ (: .,1,.,.
3~ ~ ~ ..' ..:: l~ 2::7 Clt RW^ ER 211
-4 ,':' "';}'(l I "i"1i~'ir':'\;';'i'l;.~P ,',: ,. COUNJ)':~<':',".P~f~" ~".
, '.: ,It': I~JF SEE., ;,.J\U.., ~'~';.l;:/o:'~~'I:f;t;,,~!1.''1;'''i'\':' ~!..: j:l~! 'l~lj:li) ~j'I;:~~~" ..I~.~ 0
~._ .~~_;.....J ".. . '.. ," ~ ' .. -ii.., 11J, ".'7"" ..." ~'~f .t>
~C7. \'. .. . '''!' ':(. ; "; '. "1'" ';2" .'f' I:' :.:.
i'.~~~ t..,. 1 . .. .... " '~'I\':.:.,.,. ~. :~ ,'" \ . ~. .....,11
~~ ;I'~~ .~I~,;r~.II~;_I:~,..v9.~ ~ '~i~~~ ,th'''' l~ji: ~I,!, "1: :'. ~r"; :~t ~'~1 :~l'i :&:,. .~.p CD "(H1 :s
1 .:If l ;;0- "":" .' . j-" ~:L,; ./;- i;' ~ ,..t:.!~i~lJ. ,if, ,:~!,'.tl. J)7 8 9
III f,,) )r" 5 0 ('.'; ..; ~r :4'\ 5 ., .':....Hll~~if.; ,\::; ;':~ :,~. 1'~ 3" 4
L J 1'''; q ":h"'::tl:..:,;:.,\r':~ 'r:, ..', r'.\._." ~Rj:'_~ Kid.!i;l~; .~...-) ~ ~ 110
,_ ~ - ~ ~~.~ . ..;..:...'..:...:..J-:...~~~.-:.~~;;::'....l.:... .... ....
I ;I'~' r~, ~ .f' Vlt/l 6119-2"OJ ~
,,- ,;_.:;; 9 t.J D:s: "t):W: it \..~ ~I'.. >- 23 ''22'' 21"20" 19' 10" MAJOR'S ~ 115
,/ <:) .. ~ . <~ ~ .~ rgt. R, 8ti ~ :} 1.0 I MANOR
RI._....~g' ~....!...i..I_'..J., ~ :J~ '; f:'~ 8 ~ 7_" ~ K p... 1\ .I .1 _ 37-01 OJ
'1''': If'. --, . ':' j...... lr .. /. I.~ I
~. IINA 0\\.1:"),1111:" Vnr..7i\M-lIn1'o - I
w
~
'11)
cui
~;,{,~...!,..\",..~
,~~I;ll' 1~04 ;:..
. j,;N"1 'l1.t;, .:t
l . \.oj :\. J ..
, 't'\ ,~~ ".t .<'1
nF1 I
OWtlrll
....l'l'l ICAII r
USE P L A ~~
-------.---
K^DLE.c..
PriOPOSEb ANNEXA1-ION
CLASsIFICATioN and
^ 9 5 - I LI
L^~JD
zo N I N G
L I Sf\.
~\"
~r)II~ll),
t",~. SID E tJ r 1 /\ L
LI p..., I:' " tJ
I
Z 0 t.) I ~'J G
I
P, - :?,
I) fl 0 It l: 11 't Y 0 Ese nIl" T 1011 111111 nil II 1 11111
LOT ~ \ ~ 2. I ~., L K. . 2-
v I E. \,IV C I r Y S L{ p.")
~AY
l_ ^ ~.~ D USE r L ^ ~J
0,2. q
^C"r:.~
P. F:. ,r, I h F......} r , 1\ \...,
U r,. f'> f\. ,..)
r: I , Y
P... ~ 8
II I r. II TOr- WilY
kel\!::. 5
I' t. ~ '~ ~;~ ;~~~ :~.'t'~ ~.!~.~!! l'~ (~~.~~ ~~~'~~. .. _~.u _ ,- . .~~=~~= .1= ~=~~~~~~j";;;- ~__
'01 ': r I () tl I G T n 'oY /I :. IIII' 2 '1 ~ n ^ II (\ r: \ G E A 1l AS" Hl E
2. 9 2. A
'j~r" .
-
ORDINANCE NO. 5872-95
~o
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY ZONING CERTAIN
REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF BAYVIEW AVENUE AND WEST OF
MCMULLEN BOOTH ROAD. CONSISTING OF LOTS.l AND 2.
BLOCK 2. BAY VIEW CITY SUBDIVISION, WHOSE POST OFFICE
ADDRESS, IS 109 MEADOW LARK LANE B. UPON ANNEXATION INTO
THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. AS SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 8
(RS-8): TOGETHER WITH THE ABUTTING ALLEY TO THE SOUTH:
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the assignment of a zoning district classification as set forth
in this,ordinance is found to be reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is
consistent with the City's comprehensive plan: now. therefore. .
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following described property located in Pinellas County.
Florida. is hereby zoned as indicated up6n annexation into the City of
Clearwater. and the zoning atlas of the City is amended, as follows:
Pro~crty Zonina District
Lots 1 and 2. Block 2. Bay View RS-8 - Single.Family Residential 8
City Subdivision. according to the
map or plat thereof as recorded in
Plat Book 9. Page 43. of the public
records of Pinellas County. FL. together
with the abutting alley to the south.
(A95.14) ,
Section 2. The Central Permitting Director is directed to revise the
zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5870-95.'
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
\
Rita Garvey
Mayor.Commissioner
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
1,1 I I''') hj I'''; [ ~j
1'\ ,... " I)
.; ; .; . :-; :;
I~ ;~)Mtl
:tU~~^l YitJ~~~~ ~ f.{
u...r:J of ~ ., ,,~
'.._ _ _ ... r-I
:. ;J~':'I o'n.:-=... '~f ';:.":.. ~
r ~ c: ~ :: - ~ ';: f:i r.
i;, ,1~r;J' " F~;, _r~ OJrm
~ 1010 I~: [ -V"
.. ..::..,:..., ~~I...E-{ /0
f':'l J " tyj .:. "!~' .: O'l~fl~
. t. ~~ .-- - - - C'~
.' , I~f 'j :v ;~;;, -
8
~
~
'1
g:
<:)
.,
I~ ;~;. (H'
~ ,", '"
I , ~\ ,I 5 6
iilr"\ @ m
J~~ =.1~7 ~~... .
tflfrSn l,~~b;,
.. __I - w ".~'. '.
! [;"tH1Uti<):.H:N.
1~~~ ~-'J~""'lr-;,",":~~' ;~O
~ I. *. . c~. ) .
. ~'. h "''': rl ~ ~
I 7 J J r ~....(:..J~.
_ . 5,lI'v
<>> ." I :~ ;.~ ~r",'
.- - ~;tT~ ~
21' i '~r m~' J;:-~} ~
,2:1 t ~ . .. ~':IJl"
- '. Jt ItJF "sit :,~~;i:n
, . : ~ ,;,':l :1~:lf""
~- 110- "~l'f~ 1 N
~ ~I ~ '17'~~~"}~ yg ~
I I · KrIfl" ~ 0
I,-~;'J:;;I-J~.J D ~
<:) "'9' & 0:1
g 8!9. So
., ..... :>~. !. ~~ ...
- .:-.:.....:
(~^J1 II~J ^
C~) 1;11'( 0""'(1) G2J~:/ .'~f /~:~ t '.":i~ ~~2)"
l'~nl( 11' l\~t..... "'II~II!'
.'< ti :~.': ~. ~.~ \ I .~'. It}
1.1./01 22/1,1 n/J6 ;:,,: ...~~~; ~ ~~ ,~. ~
_ ~~.~/"Y'i!.. _ ____i_ -::;-.....~.~l " W ~ ;"jiR ~;~I;'~> ;, ~ I
~1.:lJ"~ ..".....IJ..., (""1 ~ ..i .41'0 I.t; H~. ~ ;""'.)"r. . \. .0...1.
JO~&:'l~l~"" =- {I _ ~ r_~-~=.iir \hi~~ J~-!J~ J~ J.lri' ,,~. "I:.:.. ,} ~.. ltf."ii1i .,..f:-': ,\ ,. .' . .
".,'j'"tl ~ :;o;~m~~~If'" '" on ",0 "1 N '(I "'~' N.,: '~. .: .';.~'J'I'" 'i~ /i'I;'~':' .
"'~=:'".Ir'~_~' ro (;) ... .... - .., ('~ .., f"f ('I'" f n I~.. '.1" ,t;' ".t~...~ .'~~ ....> .
;t.:l,/:Oui ~..., 2?!lJ!?, ~;:, !.1-;:' ~ ~ .......g 'N'\ ~ .~~ .: U1.! a :'.~.~~.'~ .~~ :", -<'id'
::.;~ ~: '; ~I S B ("", N ~ 1_~~1" G""ti " ,u'" ~ ~ \ (1. ......t..l:..l~~ l.i '..1;..~~; ~ ~ .
'.A ~~""." t..: ... ". - - - --~ - - ..... ....i rt+ ....:>.1~.~.. .A:'. :t~.J ...... .f .
'i']"~~i1.i'. 01 ,...., In ,(,0,,% :....."': ~;: m:,\'..:,,:!II.....J"~;.,.~.;..~....,l
'~,}.'tr. ,r;;,~l ............., ~~ C)~ :'~. ~Q~ ~\L!!!:'~).:';}!~l?"'. :~lj!M~..f\'...l.
..i+P , .. ~/I~ N" ....C"~ C'I ~ :i! N ~- I~ ','l\j, ~!i~.'~iJ't" a~bJ,.J t1....'h..
,;\il"t,f.. "5<,t...~ ''9 Nl'l ~C"j N.., &'iN I.f...]. ',~,n" .-~" td~.:.l!~}t'fj.1...,'.
1J3:;rt\ "tt '.:g ~.,~ ...e:S.'1l ..,.,..... . " t 'i WHi1' ~, \ \':~:l 7.j:i:i' i; '!!l\Y.\ 0
:~, t,'.:'~ h ~.- - - .;::. ~ 'Olu<J1 I~t '..I .. T.,. .', '" h ';.17- l!tU':-i~ t~ [iht'-V ,I 8:l"j,':;,~ i.'
b: .,;;t,!I\' 1~~,LNI~v=!lr;- ",./':;~ n/18 .:h~~)i;'~: nl~l'~'r. ~~ ~"~" ~'t\l!!(ti- ~Jlt,~ :-:~*,J:l/~~~'
1~'Ol\ \ ~'-1~2;i-l-;~"":;ij'~' .~~~ 1~ ~~'j ~ ..t>1l."'li'" .:,.l!-.ft~... ;-..,~ .Il-it !":ur::v.
\'\O"'1kcl t..Jt:~ILL~~ J .1,'1\ (G) \~i'~l1 h .;IT,.(,tlf :.~~~ f.:~i!~: 't~~j~~:;:' .!~~~ :~U1r.l~~;tl
-;:;' ~ 0' -, \..,:J'~.S.2i.}''''''II. .~"...'\tl"}~'~-4tl~t.'.L'~.~..~...\t\'tt ,:.. '\1\;.. .1,", !i!.l~'~4/0~
'''':lI''~:I.'~I''J \'\l:j,l,l1."\'l'iWJ~l..HI,,:,.jv)'~I;' ,lrl,':'\.~17;'~' ~'ll-' ..1~\,:... I'
no !1 ~ ~..~ '~.~..l.~;~~I~l-~I'jSl.1:. tiJ,Vf~U)lJ,lr l.r.nrH...\1~+ '~"~~_tt 14 d.~ \.~\' '~\;)I f .\t.
Iff. ?"i .:jl ; ;5'~ ).:; ~O~'i;~~;~i:\!r~;r l}:tW{~~til~r'~:~rn':~}'{i'l.l~j~ft~~.:~r{ r:~\1~\f,~~~}iTr"n\&J.~J.t;~1'~J'~
1..1' oJ2 .J:(:~m) \~. "'l~ 1(, /.... 1M,...%\l; "~~1'~1 \.' ".l"'I.T..l..'" ' ~" ,\.. '
"'11: ""i'.i I fl. - I. 't...~.;I t, ,~ ~ t I .t;....... '... ~
n '1 \';..J. IJ ,'" L ,.'! '.\l';, ~ " l.~'.;-H '. I"~ {~~';" ~'~~.l~;~;. t,"I';r''l,t iJ litfi~,t .(.~. ~ :::: /G ~ '
,':'~ ~' .} "'': !..tr.....~. ..;i~'f.Ul~ !~[~':lifr:lJ\':.:!:.!~\1 ilr,~ h~o .,~:~.;' ~'j,i... ~ ~
J -- ". !'l"l"t'p,'" ::'i :iljg:,~! ' l,cl jl:P.:.....t;~. i!~: ~'- ~ ;;;'i1~,;.'. ..), /2.1 ~
jw 10 9 8 7 6 j' .'.: !'~.tr'r!~~ :~.,!\:~iT.~t ~~d~!f,. J~~;~~.,~W~.U,\'::~ .'1'1 :;:(,j:;:: ~ ....... OS
;, "J'\"lt<1.~ Int";j'j!;',' ~!:~~"\~1\;.'" ,/.r,'.:.::'l\j! ~':,,:l:J\JI;r """"'-.:
.. :!l . , ~ ;\.j;r\"Cfjl.r. .'1\! ~Jr~P..t,~,"lIl~ ,0\': :.I,'J ,~...\w: .:1"; ,Il!....\.: 'I
'" :':'j~:"~'~' h'l.t':i!'l;:~'" ...t)~nWil~m"t::~.~.:,tl ,..I~'.i:'\l';""i ~o~::.\'
~ ~ :.\, :,'~';'I (Srtl':i~'~:'~ ...h ~;;;:~.t!"'~~l':;'- .iiJ.jJL ;...~\.iT;.\:;II'~ ': .... ~ \
_ .--. _~ .. ...t:.:....1~_1"'............. ,.'~I........~I.... t:..."'.....:-...\.. ~1~;.'LI...\ ...~i
ft.~'P. ;~.'
.~ '.'
t'Ei ..J ....p~:
.' ~ 7.~) ~I -~!T ~ ~ "~ rtJE W ~ 6 r.:. 8 J ~ fD p~ Fa R.~~rfN.: ~,' ~~
:J;t6:.:/ ~ 1.......;./.- -, -~~, ~~R:i:! P: ~'~
10 9 FJ 7 6 f-' I ,~~ n: b ~ '; \ 1;'.
_ _ _ _ Vl 2J ?2 21 20 19 16 17 16 15 U liJt1" ,\~(il
T ~R RAtE ,A\"""~ <: _.k:
:':/1
Z;;. Clt nw... tn
r---
(:p.,.~iJ:~\;.:'1 !~,\H .~.: '''. Cl)IJNrtr~';i.\I~;:~~,I\<, n".
1~::1... '\' .....',. ~ '\." ,I f"'~'A!" .~b,}' .t~1 Ih~.. 0
~~'\~'~:~:::~:I:I.:#IJ. :'~J,,::,~' :':. l'i\.:.':tCiVi!,'W.I'~'{~:;,~~ '; ~.!~ ....
;g~ ,',.1\: t~:;. i:'l": ~~.~. r ':.;: ~ji~~: 't.1:': "'~'\l !'~' .... :;'~i ri'\1 300
[(" ":~"l "'1; '....,., "Ir"; ."}!"'F '."j1 r'~ '; i .: ...j,1 '..:I
._1',- .:.;'J I.. . . . t I ,. '. ~ . > . . . ;~ t l ~ ... '(oL.
-'::~'y~!' , I'.,'~: l,,' 'I; ;: \ "~f!i" 'm .' I.: ~'" 3 7 8 9
;,: ':J j '; .~ "~~'. ,5 . ,"rh,r~.; ; ~ ;~3 ~..~: 1(~ 13
',. .:"'. ,,;. .,1::. . (,/ " ~..t..,. ,\. '., ' ":'.:"~' ,. ~. ,1~'.) ~ "
+ ,~ , :..:..:. ,. '.....:J:.. ..1' '~1~r~-c." ,-" -
'/)f!;~'j,~; R~.. ~ l:!l ~ 23" 22" 2 J 20.1. I g' lB' '~iJ~gr
't1~".\'::. "11 7 ". . kAprl<:. 37-0.{
. ":,,':, ~ . ., \'. ~'-' ..I .~ A
",'.,h'. - ,.:. .. /; ... ,. I- .. ..
21/
\!l
llit
CerA
~;' ~t~\~.. .'1\' fA
. ~~'!11 ,\~04:~
: oi,~11,t.' \ ~\;: ;~
. f;, =nl~! (~\' 1;1
'--
2'9
,...
~
~ ~
on
...
~
<Q
'II
;;
I~
2'9
<"S
nfl r
A\~~III!:'
Vt1f"': '''' ,10_ nflf'.
._--~.
Pl"iOPOSEb ANNEXA1-ION
L ^ N D U S ~ P L ^ ~J C LAS S I Fie A T IoN and Z 0 N I N G
L1S/\ )<./\DI_E..C
-'
L ^ t'H) USE P L ^ ~ J
I O......II{"I\
, .r., r' I' I I r. ^ II r
I
'e [) I J ~ I 1 Y
^ q 5 - I Ll
I' /l 0 t> Ell 't Y n Ese III r T I 0 II 1I111t11I11UIIHI
La T :;, l t 2. I e., L k... 2-
1:> A Y V I E. W C \ r Y S L/ f..,
!.l P,., ,'1., ~ N
1__-
Z 0 t.J I ~1 G
I
rZ-1
0.2..'1
^r.:Il[:~
I',~. ~:, I l':l ~ tJ r I ,\ L
""___.......___~_____,c_. ...~_........_....--..__a_____
l.l r , r) ^ rJ
p, So 13
11 J nil r 0 r w ^ )'
(: I I '{
r' F'" I t) 1: ,..) r' J 1\ '-
'.J C, I lot'
Iv
1'1 AIIlI'tH~ "lid 7..('llrl~'n nOJ..rto
IflWI'';lllf'
^CI1I:~
., '~'~."~~=_= I~~~.._~-;~- Y_.~-OI~~1_5~1~~'_-,===----~~ _....._ _,
21'1-; r1^l/n[: 16 Ii ^'lJ,')r'/loE 2.92. A
i-'t).{..,...~ ,",
I
i'
ORDINANCE NO. 5873~95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY REZONING
CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED WEST OF NORTH HERCULES AVENUE
AND NORTH OF CALUMET STREET. CONSISTING OF PART OF LOTS
1 AND 2. PINELLAS GROVES SUBDIVISION. SW 1/4. WHOSE POST
OFFICE- ADDRESS IS 1969 SIJNSET POINT ROAD. FROM
NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL TO GENERAL COMMERCIAL: PROVIDING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
~\
WHEREAS. the amendment to the zoning atlas of the City as set forth in this
ordinance is found to be reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is consistent
with the City's Comprehensive Plan: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Sect; on 1. The foll owi ng descri bed property in Cl earwater.. Fl or; da. is
hereby rezoned. and the zoning atlas of the Oity is amended as follows:
Property
See Exhibit A attached.
(Z95~03)
Zon;nQ District
From: Neighborhood Commercial
To: General Commercial
"
Sect; on 2. The Central Permitti ng Di rector is di rected to revi se the
zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment.
Section 3. This ordjnance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
(PUT IN COUNTY INFORMATION IF NEEDED)
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to form and legal
SUf~1;rk
Panfe a K. A In
City Attorney
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
,.
~"J~lI,. ~ 'I' I.~
I'
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
A portion of Lot One (1) and Lot Two (2) of Pinellas Groves
. Subdi,vis;on, being in the Southwest Quarter. (SW/4) of Section One
(1). Township Twenty.nine (29) South, Range Fifteen (15) East, as
recorded in Plat Book 3, Page 15, of the public records of Pinellas
County. Florida: and being more particularly described as follows:
Commence at the Northeast corner of the Northeast Quarter (NE/4) of
the Southwest quarter (SW/4) of said Section One (1): thence South
. 00017'47" East along the North.South center line of said Section,
also being the center line of' Hercules Avenue, for 270.00 feet; ,
thence North 89006' 54" West, for 50.00 feet to the West ri ght ~ of . way
line of Hercules Avenue: thence continue North 89006'54" West for
287.56 feet for Point of Beginning; thence continue North 89006'54"
West for 337.54 feet: thence North 00015' OB" West for 220,00 feet to
a point on the South right-of.way of. Sunset Road: the.nce South
89006'54" East along said right~of.way for 337.41 feet: thence South
00016'32" East, for 220.00 feet to the Point of Beginning.
EXHIBIT A
~
~
t'
Z.
ii:
n::
~
[t]
c.
U)
c:v
30
'9#3
31
'937
V1
'9JO Cl 32
z IP"
1=
19U ~ ,))
:::: '9Z.5
1918
J 7 '912
GO
6 '90~
DI<I \- t.. I~. ,
'"
... ... '0 .. - .... ... ..,
.., ... to to. '"'" '" ... -
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :: ~ ~ ......
~ ...
- -
l09 106 107 \06 105 \04 lO~ W2 101
0\,)
", '930
ill
SUNSET
OAKS
40'9V
OL
,gol'
"ELL M66-
89- 01 /93.1
:'0
~o
2
ClE.AAWA TER
~ir OOUt-lTY~,"'''';
(, f~',:,:li.U-!.::';~~ -::.1
1;)~i--':"'~t4..~:::...~ .
~~':~~''1~.~~W:1 .
':: ..t.~."2'A ':ln2' -\'
.. ....,.,. :;s~~ '"J
'1 .,......... ;~I:,J <4 r:--
}., ~ . ...~.i:~ ~....,
.:S:.;;,:'.- "~.':"'~~' .l.<f,
_,'l -J;:lI'- _.
,~":.i"'" ...~~.~ ~.
~~4~~.",.~..~,,;~
'909
HAS'TlNG'5 0 g u'NE
'"
... "'-
co -'"
... ~~
J ~ 2
60
-,.....
~OINT
POINT
...
-
...
...
Oil
13/02
co
..,
~
~
Q)
~
1903
(7-EI.&VE/'I)
o
..,
-~
~ ~
'J
~
W ,liS'
"3
I-
@:- ill
i:::
~
\
:t:
18.90
,ass
L..
~ ...
I I
& 2
~
:p
.r~
...
I
E
PROPOSED REZONING
OWH~"
,",PPLlCAHT
SAuDER
\( D."TR
z q 5-03
PROPERTY DESCRIPTIOH
ZON1NG
?AR\ L.o'TS
PIt-> El-LA <
\ CG.. "2... 1
G}Qove';'
'5 W \/ f..{
'\
c..t-.J
FROM'
10
C&
1. GIS ACRES
PLAHNING find !OHING BOAnO
CITY '=0l.4MI5510H
SE.CTIOH
D\
10WH$HIP 'lq s
RANOE \1;" E
).Tl),S PA.GE '262.. A
,.
~."'.\~ 'I' .
1 .".
ORDINANCE NO. 5874.95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY REZONING
CERTAIN PROPERTY LOCATED NORTH OF MAGNOLIA DRIVE.
.CONSISTING OF LOTS 2. 3. 4 AND S. BLOCK 31. MAGNOLIA
PARK. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 705. 707. 709. AND
711 JASMINE WAY. _FROM NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL TO
COMMERCIAL PLANNED DEVELOPMENT; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
MIT. .
WHEREAS. the amendment to the zoning atlas of the City as set forth in this
ordinance is found to be reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is consistent
with the City's Comprehensive Plan; and
.~~
I
I
I
I
!
"
I
I
!
,
,
I
r
, !
I
WHEREAS. the City Commi s s i on has determi ned that it is in the pub 1 i c
interest that a Commercial Planned Development zoning designation is appropriate
for the subject property even though the property contains a lesser area than
four acres; now. therefore,
i
. I
,
.
BE . IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY CO~lMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following described property in Clearwater. Florida, is
hereby rezoned. and the zoning atlas of the City is amended as follows:
,.
I
i
,
.'
Prooertv
Lots 2. 3. 4 & S. Block 31, Magnolia Park.
according to the map or plat thereof as
recorded in Plat Book 1. Page 70. public
records 6f Pinellas County. Florida. -
(Z95.04)
Zoninq District
From: Neighborhood Commercial
To: Commercial Planned
Deve 1 opment .
i
I
1
1
. 1
Sect; on 2. The Central Permi tti ng Di rector is di rected to revi se the
zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
. PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
~.
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to form and legal
SUffiCi[CY: ~
~, t
_4..... V
ame a . kin. City Attorney
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau. City Clerk
5
10 9 " 1 2
...,.
..,. 6-
.1 N '1::::::"
-
I 8 0 24 2.3
"
...,.
1 ...,. Q ...
Q eo
00 '0
i~~l t ~
) J1
a 2
& '0
RUID
IG
~
10 ~
7 8
....
l& ..
'0 9
7
Q
. .~
. .
"---
-- -- ".
.".
.....
o
N
-
H. :s
:J:)TO~
~, PROP',
flll....U \
of
a: ,"",01 V Jy: lLJJ.:o ,
~ ~.:.' l~J {( ~~ 5
~ if
;0.. ~ 10"
6 15
A 61613704
I " LJ~ ~
~\
~ I
10 18 7 6
9
~fI I
8 ... I" ~ III
Q ~ ~
.... ....
~ ~
j
~ 1 - ~
I ~~
10 \9 B 7
I
; I ~ ~
"'7
t4 1J 12 11
106
10 9
...
...
'CI
<f'
'12
i ~ ~
&0
~
~
la
o RVID ROAD
~~U...~1l
"
w
JHUIU
0.
Q
Q;)
o
'"
I~
~( 0
&0
.,
o
<0
...
Q
10
2
. ~
:~1 2 :3 4 5
;: "'..J,~~
,.tJ;(Y B ~( 6
I. . L "-I' ..........,,~ 7
~ r:!. 1 0 '"" B 5 I~ It 'Z J . IS I'
e 7 6 f ~ ~ ..~
~:J ~ / \ ~ ~.~
WI<.~ / ,., {!o~ I) I 5 P JASMINE
~
...
...
ro
1 2 A
~ ~ DRUHILL .V
:::: 24 23 /
() LPROFESSIONAL ;j
515 -lg2
~Io.TtD
:3
..
5
,,-...,
......,
8
10 9
CENTER
. ~ i~;~ i{~;:!I';;Oi~. .rli;w
~.;.+:o '~$.:.b"'" ~~~:~ "'(~"~f
'~'.."" C" ." '.> . '~^(1! ..
~~~~;\' . ~,;'rJ:N ~ ..
1 )if )>,~~. ;,,. '<~;f: ~:n :10, ,. 11 ,t ,. .., ".. , .. ,. J . J Z I
I.~' w'e...., ,,,,,.,. ~t~V.:. I r':O..... "{ t: 1"\ '
~ r.....-' ~5~:...:'f-::~ ~....;(:.."l.~ . "'-'01:'::::
......., ~ ['.: I t:P- ,. fi
~ 7. ~: nuz' ~ Z ,~;oJ ,",1~~IJ JO 7 U
8 ~ '; g~l~RJt6 ~ J "Il
MAGNOUA.
-
~
A
CONDO
65-121
\
Q
f1 ~
[
[il
MAC lo.JOl-( I+-
~IVE 0
...
~ . -
~ ~ 0::. Q l;: '" ....
'" ...
2 .3
A B 1 .36 .. 5
Jo
Z7
21
:to
/
1QDi" u
...~~ ; ~ ~~~'I ~ ~
~Io-' ~ iil S. ..<1:1<021 ._
~ ...~ J Q;
~. U 21 to 2 <l:l . 100Z ti
u ~ I. I., UJ
~ . ~
o
c:::
a.
8
\ 1 2 :3 4 5 6 7 a 9 10:
\ MAG N 0 L I ~ (t;'
\ ~~ I x
~ 22 2' 20 19 18 171'i 1514vj
____~~ I ...__ 0.
I ,~~~
-.
~.~.., e::: ::: ~ I ~ ~
.. ~ _ _ CI;)
~ '" <l:l _ l 1I0~
~ Q; J
n I. It >> :II 22 . 1104
r4, t
'I . .."" ._
".~
~I~
I
;lO
~I
PAR K
o C 10 9 B 7 5 S:
(~ It.. -l;~w ~ ~
~ I~ 1G./, ~ ~
- ~ - - _ _ _ ._- _ . --I _ ~ "I
~2-IJ~ I '!'I'Il't'J""'"
I 0::. Q 0::.
:! OJ'r Q;) Q;) <0
2 '" f l~ 110.9
A 8 1 .3.. 5 :;):1. ,
:\7. [I 1105 ^
.~ "'"
1006
11 U 'J I. " I. 17
l. l{' f'\, ( 'T,
~ ~ ~
I~ to to
.u
~
!-orus
2
:3
7
..,
6
4 5
8
&
\ .
3 --< 413
11
PROPOSED REZONING
S 1\1 0 L E tv 5 KY
z q 5 -04
ow}ot~,.
APPLICANT
q k'O R N t\ C.'H
? ROPER1'Y 0 E SC R\PTIOH
'.
ZONING
~LK =3l)
PA&<'K.
LO\,S 2-S1
VV1~G.~OL-lQ
FROM'
c..N
1'0
c. p 0
0.66 ACRES
PL....NNIHG bnd ZONING BOARD
CITY ~O"'MISSION
SECTION
\6
RANGE 15" E
A TLAS PAGE 2 q 5' '8
TOWNSHIP 2q s
~..~.'~ c
ORDINANCE NO. 5878-95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
ANNEXING CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF BELCHER
ROAD AND SOUTH OF SHARKEY ROAD. CONSISTING OF LOT 2.
OAKMOUNT SUBDIVISION. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 412
OAKMOUNT ROAD. INTO THE CORPORATE LIMITS OF THE CITY.
AND REDEFINING THE BOUNDARY LINES OF THE CITY TO INCLUDE
SAID ADDITION; TOGETHER WITH THE ABUTTING RIGHT OF WAY
OF OAKMOUNT ROAD LYING BETWEEN LOT 2 AND LOT 9 OF SAID
OAKMOUNT SUBDIVISION; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. '.
~~
WHEREAS. the owner of the real property described herein and depicted on
the map attached hereto as Exhibit A has petitioned the City of Clearwater to
annex the property into the City pursuant to Section 171.044. Florida Statutes.
and the City has complied with all applicable requirements of Florida law in
connection with this ordinance; now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following.described property is hereby annexed into the
City of Clearwater and the boundary lines of the City are redefined accordingly:
Lot 2. Oakmount Subdivision. according to the map or plat thereof as
recorded in Book 45. Page 43. public records of Pinellas County.
Florida. together with the abutting right of way of Oakmount Road
lying between Lot 2 and Lot 9 of said Oakmount Subdivision.
(A95-17)
Section 2. The provisions of this ordinance are found and determined to
be consistent with the City of Clearwater Comprehensive Plan. The City
Commission hereby accepts the dedication of all easements. parks. rights-of-way
and other dedications to the public which have heretofore been made by plat. deed
or user within the annexed property. The City Engineer. the City Clerk and the
Centr a 1 Permi tt i ng Di rector are di rected to i nc 1 ude and show the property
described herein upon the official 'maps and records of the City.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
The City Clerk shall file certified copies of this ordinance. including the map
attached hereto. wi th the Cl er k 0 f the Ci rcui t Court and wi th the Collnty
Administrator of Pinellas County. Florida. within 7 days after adoption. and
shall file a certified copy with the Florida Department of State within 30 days
after adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
'\
8-3-95
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~L l
_ !J
-,/ 'L ,I.
am la K. ~Tty Attorney
Rita Garvey. Mayor.Commissioner
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau, City Clerk
I
J2/0J
, '. '\,. ., ,,'. .
1-',/ ~ I-'
32/03"
50
32/04 a
a
~
',.; ~
,~
. .
. "'110' C5
..:t\', ~ :'. . '. d
; f;':.:,:)'~ E-i
It- . 4-,
....~J"!:'r;.=:"..".l. r ~"i,..":i'W.."'-~_')"I~',~ ,.., "t J.:,"~~'~',,~';.ft.:;;I:':.""~ .l..":'!i....!:'....'-: ;"
. ..../1 ~l; SJ-lARKIf;f. ;i~J~D 0' .~'...' '.'. 'I.~\' .",.'1', 'V'~~ ~..,I: ~'
~.l~\;'~.~.I;.r\i1.": ",.:.tr~~"',l. t. ......1 ;..~:.~.~...";,4".~/;;~f',.::;{1\:.~ ~.~~.
::,:[1' '-::r" .,-
_II. ,...". .,.,.1.1
':., ,,,," !' .'O~
o
r:I.
~.~ r1t~ :~~~r~h~!'~:~t,~~t..._.~
. "f.""r.~J~~~ ~"'..1' :.:~:~, .~~.+...:
,. '~ "'0' ~r.~1t I: ,,<:., r' ,d.; ,t;,;:
,I":' " ,"".i.-. "~~:'rt '~;~'..Jc'frr'
... . ..,......... ~':'r.,.~ J. -:..-.....
_~. ",.-'__ ;)101o......:-.... ,.. '!~: "".
~ .~~":'Jr..: ~~.~['.~.;..~~~:!~
':', ,;",r.\Ji;:'''\3(08~ ;~~.;.~.
\:0:: _.:.........-'!:I. . ..~.~.~..~.( I
,./. or J.;,........ \.\l.......t~j
1_..... . ,.......I,l .,1., '. 'lo:' ..
. ~1~~I.\'.)Cl.",~~:.. ":j"~'t.',
~'.e. A'~:I\.r.~"':;~ ~f:. ;1~~~
-.,q....l :Ji~'~fQY.:~ ""'"j' ,.. 'J:;'/-.,~
.: 'l.hlJ,~.-u..... ~t- l,~....~i""
,-:It!,,,~,,,,,",J;:-'r',~,.r 'l Ll.u-jl~'
.- ~.'....~., . J: '.(,.., ~rr'
M~:,'..r. P.l'Ir,... . ."~,,,.....,~:I~
. .....-1 (';. ~"'l .tI.' '~f~ ~
~.\t.;iI~~~I; ,.It::~~\''_.~ld~ u.
1J.33/l0
P/SP
33/11
'1ill Co.';. - '- a' 'I',';.'~'~; ~i,'.,.-,';,
;~. ';.;"0. A:. . : 01 ~~;~:' ~ ..~': ~:~::~1~~'.?1~
.... ~. . "3 /' ........,.. j
. ,:.." .. ....'~~ 3 0... -f."it;~
:. -.- ~ .. ~.:.:::I~~.\.~ r"j- A~~ ~~:.. 1
"3/'P5' "".,I~. '-'il. ''1:'.''.:,..
..J .. . ~ ~:~l.U~~ '.~ ; ~ ..:;..:S.:.....I:
it~ .~, . ..., ':O:\.J..~1"'I.~:..:"_:~J..~: J-;: ......1
t:t~ I. ",i -~:." '. :~.1..:~;~:~~..fi !~.~~ . . .~. ''0
~~~q~:,.'. ',' ~.).' ~ i~:"',,' i-1'~ ..1 ,', 2l
..~IO. ...1 ~f..~jrr~:)! .:...(!. ~~!'~ ~;:n
>~4/9?\.:: .r:~?(,~3.;.~. t::!~(~r' .~", "t. .
~o.ll'... .' ~:...-:~.:7..i.;.: I:~;-::'. !.:.~:. .~.. .j7"'.
';. 'I 508
~8 $00
.. JS
.. ': ;.. .1/0
-
7J!
.~
" ~
~. .......
'"
611
i~ '.
, .
~n
l4.
dlS
. ,.".
, "
~p .sa.!
~ 'I
n.
~ ,.!.J3el
a . nl
s
60 ,
, .
'lO.3
w
:J
~ 82 ~
< ..
<
~
'. .... 'to . . . . . .. , ." ...
f~;~: '~~,f'~ t1:f'N '~~'E ~~!"~ "':a :~:~~. ~n~ ~R' ~I"':'~i' ~~Tt "'~:: ~r~ 1Fs r-:;':k '-', ~ P,.t~'r:.
.;~t:-~ :....;'!'t .:~.~ ~~~ :.:~ ~ "S'f1 ~'. &~~RI~ ~,~J. lO'~ ~;r1R 'ik'~ ;3~ ~1':~H:i5~ .i'6=t :~lji:: ...J....
.... 'Q'" .~..' .I\.~' .11:.,' ....;. ..:' t. i~" '-.:'"q,:. '. . "d,' :...: t, ...; ....~.:).. -' " . _
!, '.: . P'.' ., s, "'-! ..... 4 _ '. ,... ~. !-r'" _'"""\ +, ~ '"t. ,. 1'r7t . 'f . I'. L: ~'.t" 'r It" ~ t~. '-. .1'0
:..;IIII.......~ .:'."'" I:~:. ''-'''''i.~ :~!.1:~ ':--.. ....1'1~ Ir1..:~,B .':'. .~. ~.;:"":.,... "'"4......". I"':' ''';'' ~4... 4,:.';; :." ..;:.,
.;: );M '.{J~ ~ia" :l.r~'i ~~Oft' .~9a :~ft ';:i;:a~ 't~~' :~~!" ..~,4~' 2.38' ~ F2!' ff.f :}~ 1~9 JP.,-' " ti: ,." ~J:}}: ':;' 11 100
~~ .!O(':: ,~. ., :; F".' .: _', ~"t' .~/",:""" .... ".' ': :,.' h'l;, ,," t': , ~'.~ ~ -.,.. ;". ~
" , .' . .... , ..' N r .."'" ... . .2':t" .:
';; :'-;,:"'... :'.';~;.J~ \1'1':,..~7~.$ . It :.:.,;,.ui~t:{"!!'~"'''''''''I' .... "',:'~' ,..! I. ~ "':':"'i"'~'" ,p. ,. :.., f". ....1. S'OI . :.: -1:2
',' ! ~~)~.. ".h t!'~19..~r::R.1trJ"'J:14 ~"'.1..:~,:..';"~t""'~-!',.:,:, : ~t ~\&':; '.,.~":"": -.. '. '+, "'. '0 310
.' I .... .....-..... ......",...:....,-.7i''!:'~/~' ::.. 1', ".j;-. ,:t.I."l...;.. j- ~ ~}'": ~..l rol,)1 r PI. ~ .. J' .L:'ID ',' . 1,0.;25 '.!
.' . , ...Il'.,"- _' f.. _ I ... ~.., ..... .. .'~, _. ..... ~ ..':'r... ..... ~ . ..i.:.:_...' '+: ~ ,,'!;,. i: "
.L rEi: ~~~ }!i.D t~l ~B ::,tD ;~:a :(n ~*.i ~~{~ ':i,ij~ ~~~!~ ~\fi :~Ol ~~~ 'r~~,::~' ~~~ : <;~; :J.;~6::~' '~'~~?30~
.~'t .~: n~lt ~~:i .~~.? .:l\:, ':~ .~. l~~ :~;'Z;. ';.~.:': io{~<. ,1~~ ~'J.. ,l[dl~ '~fiL ~1~ 16' 'Ufl<' .::~} 'i.li-~;{~
Ir~ :.~. :~-:-t.: +~'r .~~:';,::. ..t'~f' ~':.1"~ nJoo..;or.t ~.,~. r:lt.~ 0 .-:i' .,- .,. :,""A' ,n ; ""~~.. .f;J. '"..i .....c~. .~.. ~;:"'2jr'.4'
.\." ~ r~~t ~.~; '11~ ~i}~: .~t9~ ~~; ,*~J .r~ ~?~e; ~:~~~l :',~t ,~~:~. t~ ,ilk. :}~ ..1 ~ ..J t, ~':~J~' .~. . ~ -; ,
'. c :~..,,-, .'" ~ .I'.n ~,tt ~'. H r~IN ~.t~1J -.4. i'..,rt c..'~Ji ~;a .:: Ja ::::..,. ....,~ t;..: ti ~:...!....._ :;~,...,,; ;',Io:.::28',::y \'~>.-45
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
LAND USE PLAN CLASSIFICATION and ZONING
J
f.:~ '~TI ,~:"
.; . 4'ci
.- ",. 408
. , '
. r':,:~ to
.\~
. ;':::\4 ~ao
OWHER
^PPLlCAHT
wAR.Re~
-;,
,
'LAND USE PLAN
~ 'CL.A R.K
,
ZONING
COUNTY RESIDEIJTIAL L.Ou.)
R-3
C IT Y R6'5 I D 6 klT ( A c... I.- 0 W
~s b
A'lS-1l
PROPE.RTY DESCRIPTIOIl
L 01 'l.. I
OAI<tv\Ot--l1 suB
o.1...0;.cnES
nIGHT OF.WAY
.l,cn L::';
PL,J..HNltlG lInd zonwo aOARO
J
C I T Y COM 1,\ I S 5 IOU
SI!CTIOH
07
TOWtlSlllP "'2.q s
nAt~OE \6 E
EXHIBIT A
All .l, 5 I' A 0 E 2. 8 I A.
81
6C
~
59
~
z
~ .41 ~
l
~
--
.~. .~. ,... > '
,.
." ~
.:..c
,. .
~. :
~~f~~l___....".....,.. e'..'. , c.., + .."
. ~- ~ ..
...,. .
~.... ;..... ~ ..
... ...,
'I.::t/ >
..
......
" p.
. , ~..
'. ..
"
,
DATE
...' }.'
, .
'~7..~..
~:r~': .
~\.; .
~,
~.
~.~:-
~
1',"
g.. .
. .'
....
F./fct~ 0
.......-".. ..~~-_....-.......
'.
AGENDA
1- Lt. 95
ITEM #
'".
-
.,
\:\
I'
, . ~
tyt"~1 ~
II
ORDINANCE NO. 5879-95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PLAN ELEMENT OF THE
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF THE CITY, TO DESIGNATE THE LAND
USE FOR CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF BELCHER
ROAD AND. SOUTH OF SHARKEY ROAD. CONSISTING OF LOT 2.
OAKMOUNT SUBDIVISION. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 412
OAKMOUNT ROAD. AS RESIDENTIAL LOW: TOGETHER WITH THE
ABUTTING RIGHT OF WAY OF OAKMOUNT ROAD LYING BEnJEEN LOT
2 AND LOT 9 OF SAID OAKMOUNT SUBDIVISION: PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
~~
. I
. I
!
WHEREAS. the amendment to the future 1 and use plan element 0 f the
comprehensive plan of the City as set forth in this ordinance is found to be
reasonable. proper and appropriate, and is consistent with the City's
comprehensive plan: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The future land use plan element of the comprehensive plan of
the City of Clearwater is amended by designating the land use category for the
hereinafter described property as fol19ws:
Property Land Use CateQory
Lot 2. Oakmount Subdivision. according
to the map or plat thereof as recorded
in Book 45. Page 43. public records of
Pinellas County. Florida. together with
the abutting right of way of Oakmount
Road lying between Lot 2 and Lot 9 of
said Oakmount Subdivision. (LUP95.19)
Residential Low
Section'2. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
contingent upon and subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5878-95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED '
8-3-95
'.
Rita Garvey
Mayor.Commissioner
Att~st:
Approved as to form and
l~su/z~encY:
P ela K. ln
City Attorney
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Cl erk
J.' ~~I::
~3~ ,:r-
~ "~,'?/O i5 ~
.~~"\~. ~ ~. a~ C; .: ~
; t;,~.:,:)'! E-1 .' ,. "
. , ". ;;"; '"
I". r;r ~
,~i; :5': 0:: i~:' . -..
i: ~' ;~~' ~ ";~i'
-
RS26!ij Lt.. ..'
,;,~
:.:--.:r.1' .:~:;.'. ":"". .....,,, ,
~:~p~:r..;...f'; '. t~
. CLEARWATER '~',M::- .1~PI 60 "OJ
-. }.,i""~ t:.~ ~~.~~. y ~I. ......:;!ar....- ,. , ,,}.'cC4JtiTr ";".~ ~~:,. !;.,; t;,:~:'. ~1"""""","'J': .... ,&oW ,.,~. ~
. _ _ \ _ ;, ;Flk!~~~K.~:.~W:.f.t9i:>~;:'"". \d.~;Ur{~;(;li;~~f./;~~:;'~'Z f~:.. ::, :
~ ~ 1"-1:-" \I) ~ ~'il:tt_::~:,,'~w';I:l','.:~j,'''':~l/~''': '/tU ...,.;.....: ~; B....\.....f.:..~~; .:F-:~~.;,;. ..~.~ 01'1
~ ci I I"'" ..... ...... . ~....i&'.,..-~.'I'I ~.~. 1: "wo!"'.. ts~,..t ,'" * .~.: '. ...~ '1 ,.'i" .....+..:ut:-r ~ --: ~ .'-., ..',: .. ;;.. . I,
c-. 1 0: 8 ::t7 ';"'~'~O,~r;'1, :r'.;/-i'~U..;'!'j\;: :."\:3/,0+' '. .:t';,'~;r'''~''~I~''!'~' .. ~,,' 1
uS 1 . ;".'::.:':f.t'-,h,'(;.:"r:~'~:{~ i~,' 1".' I., '.'. .'."..,I~~P703 ~,.,~.~~, .... '.....~~.. '34 ~ ,,332:
!:--4 rn ..... .. ~_:J.:.........4.""~;':".t.I"" 1., _,. ....-I~p'.._r....oIklA:......> . ....~.. .' Q ~ . n.
a 40~ ' ".:~'~"j~.~,~t'.;,''-:)'~~'::,Ii 'tJ/pS' :....,t-;.I',;.::..."J:._J~:.':;\I.: ~o.P. .0 ~
P ';. 9 :..l-'~" r 'r."f.~~,.., ~ ,"f; .;" ,'.,..' '.' '.', ., '. "'~J~'" . P .
'~:fJ~ - '''~::'J:..!.:~3(~R':<'::7-,~'~<~1 .i9" ". '~""~"':'''''~.';...:.,,~!. ':.;," ,,?r 0
1 '_ 2' ~ ~ b.,,) ,..". "..' .~.. . trI.. ....:,:.. 7t'T.... ,-"",,y\:,'>-'~I'" ,-' .... .,~.. I .A
~ ,....~.. ~....~ 401"-' ,..:...~~:-:-::.'t~"'.tr.~.Io~''l:.:.'1!.;:J. _. ,....~. .~;..._,...~..t't....I..:....:~:-.. .. "
p::; t:: 'I:".;:' ',~::,;-"" _ ":b~'\.\"I''C'''.":~,,, :,Jo.I~~it.: 0: r '0' '..: 'S;I'.;~,-.., il"i'~'f' .....;. ~,'..,..~
~ PI S P . ~..: '.';4;;;~ l. . :-0.:. ' :...w.~..~ '.::,J,\.~~ .;J~/. 6', ',7': '~:"~' N:;: . ". ~ .~ :....:.' 60
:r: . ~ I.r :tIO.. ,'r,..'t!:., · :!~.. , -.,p:".l" t?f'l!.;._"t,.~,~']H:,~ ':':.110'.' '~'.,,.. '.: ~'''~~;'' .:: (' . . J ,; " l'-"6 ,... ,
u ~ ,.t; .'''''"'. ... =:r't........ ..,....nJ..~:r...4~..X:.l:.-ot-.~~~ A- ,.~ ,".w~:'.. :J'~~' ...;.rC".f".. .+..t 11.. 'SI"
G:i ,7 33/11 .!:<l :t~;.. ';..;-JfJ ;i"'~\r~d~ ~ '-~~'1r.:r(i" 'f'J~'~.~(~~' :ai: >3'4/'"'11"~ ?";.3'/62~~, b~/ol;'.~' .'~ .' .
I a1 O.z.,... It..".......;.1 ~ c.1J .:r,,~'r:"t.IIi!:,.I ..(,,-u'Jr..~~" "':j'~ ;--.. r'... ,.:.._'.~.,"...."i";. -..-.""... ~~.,,-.
~ ~-\.. ""'::'L:~ : .\:'j!~-;',:~, :;: "'tS)y,;.. ~''i~~~~1;;r,.l!i:~:i~..~'~!~~' ~~ ~~S'~ .~. ~. .~::'~':r~I~~...fi! .:;~:::.'~~~r ~~~"d7.' .....
. . i- 0 ~ co r.'~'!Ji' ~ ME CEJ1 ~}1.~ '-:JR'F;' ~;;,'f.' ~~ 1.':'r. ';J~Jr :,:~':!,: .~.s~: '~~f' ~: i~ "';' tr:'~. :'. I' ;t ?"~.' :..... ~'I 608
, -Z \ ~.:s~.;17.... g:;;'~"'~ :z.:;;.:.'~ .:Q:~ Jq'~':, U"~I" l~::;' i;;If[;'l~~ !~..;: 16S" 11;';'~ \~.~ jftP~" "8
s i3lS t:':'t;..., ."'~~.' ~ ;-''2 ; '-i!;;: r 'J ~'.. , . :IJ :,.. ll: .~;o; ~ ..:11:1. '. .,..:i~: 911 ~. ~4 .': ~ SOU
- J-."H ("-- ....' . .. ,-iJj .:~.: 1.:,.... .~=- ~t"". ) "'l ,,:-:"ij ;.. .N ',:"!i '. . ~..~. '" . ... '~1-1.= ..;.. ---
.., ... ",...~~ .:..:..... .'~~ .."';;:';:1'" .., ..... ~i~.P...l.~I.:&.I.....:;I '''51-'' L'.' !';....:;.~ ~ ;. ....\' 'l+.;~.." '.:-:", '.', '.' ..... .;',',': . .,,\120: . .,
.. r~"t-:r... ..,.........,.. .~.. A ,.,. ..~,...._~J_,,...l,ilo;r.~~l-1!o1': .-.. ~ -J!..1..........' .14.,.. ~.. ..... ''''.' ~~".' ... .11".
, .. ,'",~ I; ::...' . ~ .: H""~' ....~~.;:;n:-I?R CE .'..1'/:' ":W", -~r.:-:w," t-=:'!,:':'.\:.- :'gftl\JC';,~.~....\ ,.; I; ,:.::~c' ,;~ H; . .. \.:: "~ " :,!,.;~..: .~., ,.; ~" 039
l"" .i,' ..~. - 'r <t ..-... ~..L't":;:'.;1.1 . t>....-. .tlh:.....iO.J".'Ij~-1 ..'J. ..... 'I L .............. "I....... ,.~.......:~ .~
_ .. ..:.:........ tof',~ ~..~.-. J... ...'":..........::~.....:-:-~ :',...,........,)t -",:-..'''.''~'WJ~-:.~...........rr.: ........: .~. -, ..~",:"tt:.~.::'...:~,...... ........1... ,. .":,,/,,,~'''~.]=1...~4 .....~ ...~ ;:. I.a
::. ;':.~ f~~ "1<f~'" ~'l:;04 .t;~" ...... 'i:i -:..... 'n.F~ ~!\~ ~"'i.Q ~:,l-':':" ~i~' ;', , r ~...~ :1~>':'" :9"'.~~ .......'" ~p-"..,.,~; . ..:~!~. '. r.;s'; ~Fi' ,-:.. "', .:;::-
'I.,'.. ,..:...::.~ .tv ~.~!i:f": .It'C :,'.R ~ .~ :~~ ~J.~ ir-;:)l ;~i, "j ',' .:~' ~:..t't ~:.,~ .t;:j :n':. :~~:. .$IS" :""~'-
;' '.' ?~. ;;.r:;? -1l!3 .,4 i :'~ III Ii r-;. 7~ :'R'lJ nL. 10n .1' :1'! 13 'ftH ..t5~ .l'.6~ "17"~ '.7'> .':;1 ;: "-10 .'
. .... 'QQ'~ ,1;", !':.~ .;10,\, ,:.;.'...." ' f~'" '.l-.;." , ,I.., .~, t., .....! I.. ..'... .. .,~.: ,?~, ...~ ~~
!.. .... ., ...,~ .~.., _ .... -. '.!! :'t." 'l"'r. I" ,t:' ~,',,"'." . .f' .- J/O .' '.f .sQ# ....:~
.,.. :............~ L ....'11 r:~a, I"",~': .~~.....~ . t..- 1d1~ 1.,~-t_,B :';.... ..... ,.. ...;..ot-~lf' "".:..~ ...: -, ., ,'t,., :,:; ...... '.. .."~'
. '!~ .";..a:t':33 :l~t ''3n.30 29 '.2\':'27 ',7e- 25'. ,?)" 23' :22'.~~1; :fO 'l'g '-1~" "~' ;,:.1'23'~: '.~;'4'1"
, ' '.,' 1.1;.: :f ~ : 1ft' ;;~ .~~ n ~ a .. ',It. C) "I!.. 'f"~ ~Ift n i! ;::.'. ' .... ~ ',.t.': . iDs ,.;.' ",: ~. 400
3!1. ~'1:' .;s.:.. .,4 ;:... . ~. .....:s-..!...; ',~. .:.~. '+ ~ 1'1-.
. ,:i 30/:. '.' .., ;J ;... ".' "'" ~,dL.::':~" ~; . '''. ~;'t..: ", p;\ . r,oo ,; '~~';2"(:~ ;:"
. i '.. "':t~~....... ..~.J:u.\t:."~""..'.1 ~.. rO. ~l'~ ."U..~~~III .CI.': ,_."~. ..~.... j . ~~,.....\.....~ '~." f.,. A..' SOt '. ; ~2
l, 'i.~::';"~' ' ~I::~..~:~r;~. ,..J:"Q' $';;:.~':';'I'~:"':'~';';~~."":~. r. "r'."~' . .,:.. :'~i':i' , .. . .' J 'c'" 310
I ...-:~.--:,A.. 4 t. ....~.... ~, . I \ '. -*'__! iI !~.:"l..';"~. . =--l; ~'l .r.-'l~'.l oJ' "I I J" ,':'1oQ ,. L .. -1 r,
..... .; .... :".":". -~?-.:...t.7'~" I.. _.,. . ~'li-.. '..:"",". ......., .:.,....! 1:rr . '. ....~ . 'l...j,:~:_ ~. .: '.0:" 'r: '!? t ".-?5~. "
~'I'ij"" ~f' ..1.1 .{!;ij :~..~~ f~B '.;'-!;~ .f.:ij,' ;':\1 :1f.~~ 'if"Rl"J :.~li, )';i~ .,~,~.",; i:rn 7~.~~'r "l: :, ~'I';',;jUP : :t~'~i. :J.~~ ;. .:..'o\~
.-'t', ~~: ~ .'R"~' ,tj q..~rJ ,'~j\H 4!-4 r.. R ..'f "., ..~1. .~'~;~~Iij ~t ."[I: .~..~ .~:.;:J ~.- "3-:!Lt.~ .~:. '..:26.~~ '!",",;' .30iJ
.:t. .. I: t~ ~ \~&li '~{.?-l~t~"' ':,~ t i~ ~' 'i.Z;. ':~ ~\ ~~< '~~.~'I"~';l~.'. J".: ,:1~'ct ~1~ ~g' ~~'ry :U!t.: .'~~'~~~ ~~~-..'!::
.r"'~ ....J ;;:-::t:tttLr '~~~~::: "~""~ ',..../JI~ ,.~r-'~~ :.\....~ ;":"1'1.. 0 I ,:~r .,- -Ii .t"~' ." : ...~..'...'. .f.... If.'' ~ ", '"t ~""4 ~ ~.~ 27n...
'; 7 f'Jf i?~' '~2;' :~p ~pl ;Z~',. ,~~:; ~?':lG~ :J~5".~t, .p::p ;~J :7~ 19 J~,.. 12; ~3~' "
";', H ,.:7,":;' ..t~~ ~~f~ :-~. ~ ;.~fra 'lr~ ~:.~III ::~~ ::"<;,~ .....~ 9. P.J~ .;, R 1';t;.; J.~' e, t: " ., 9: :",' I~' ..~ "}':"8:::-~~ .l~; I '
..... ..fil .p .1i.'oI- tJ . N. (\U .._ ._:pll .. 1I_.!l.JI ..~ ~ ........H ......);} ,.. '" ;.s ~''''..._.' I~. "'''_.4. "'.' ',::.45
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
LAND USE PLAN CLASSIFICATION and ZONING
I' .
1..1 ~ 5
I", .'
IT]
J2/0.}
r . .... '~'';: .t ..
:.0
o
c/.
OJ,..
~^
I ~
I3J.}j10 I ~"\
l""'l -
'}2~a
~o
. ~.~.z:- "
. \":..
, ',:.:~ -\ 300
OWHER
.I,.PPLICAtlT
A9'S-1l
wARQ.Et-J ~ 'cc..Af<,.K
~ .
~
'LAND USE PLAN ZONING
PRO PER T 'Y 0 E 5 C RIP T I 0 II
L 0'1 "l.. I
OAKrvtO~T SU~
.
COUNTY r:\E''51 ()EJJTl AL- l.- 0 u.J
CIT.Y R6s I D GUT (Ii L. LOW
;
: P L A t/ n I ~i G Dnd Z:ONIHG BOARD
I
, SECT10H 07 TOWHS\lIP -z.q :;
.
R-3
~s lC.
I niGHT OF. WAY
I
,",Cf1E:;
o,'2..0.:.cnE:5
.J
C I T '( COM 1.\ I 5 S I 0 H
RJ.t10E \6 E
A1Ll,S PAGE 2.81 A
-
~/S
-
.' . '~OJ
w
:I
~ 82 .
-< ,
51
81
-:--
5C
;
-'
~
-.
59
< ----:-::--
'Z '.
~ .p
-
~
--
. . J
~~t"\~1
. ..~ ".'
t"' .
~s
ORDINANCE NO. 5880-95
-
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS. OF THE CITY BY ZONING CERTAIN
REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF BELCHER ROAD AND SOUTH OF
SHARKEY ROAD. CONSISTING OF LOT 2. OAKMOUNT SUBDIVISION,
WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 412 OAKMOUNT ROAD..UPON
ANNEXATION INTO THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. AS SINGLE- FAMIL V
RESIDENTIAL 6 (RS-6); TOGETHER WITH THE ABUTTING RIGHT
OF WAY OF OAKMdUNT ROAD LYING BETWEEN LOT 2 AND LOT 9 OF
SAID OAKMOUNT SUBDIVISION: PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS. the assignment of a zoning district classification as set forth
in thi s ordi nance .i s found to be reasonable. proper and appropri ate. and is
consistent with the City's comprehensive plan; now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITV COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The fOllowing described property located in Pinellas County,
Florida. is hereby zoned as indicated upon annexation into the City of
Clearwater. and the zoning atlas of the City is amended. as follows:
Prooerty ZoninQ District
Lot 2. Oakmount Subdivision. according RS.6. Single. Family Residential 6
to the map or plat thereof as recorded
in Plat Book 45. Page 43. pUblic records
of Pinellas County. Florida. together
with the abutting right of way of Oakmount
Road lying between Lot 2 and Lot 9 of said
Oakmount Subdivision. (A95.17)
Section 2. The Central Permitting Director is directed to revise the
zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment.
Section 3: This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5878-95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
Rita Garvey
Mayor.Commissioner
"
Approved as' to form and
le~a\ SUf~CienCY:
fl.te", IL
P ame 1 a K. I Ak i n
City Attorney
Attest:
Cyntnia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
~
..
P/SP
~...~ ~ 5
!..- ~;
. ' ,
;,~
~
73t
.32/0J
, .
.: . ;',' '{IO
,::\\~. d :. :
j If':.;::;'} ~.
'" I ..~ -=--r
ffi '.
G I,
. ,.
.~
,,,
II
.....
, "
."
~.n
32/03
S'I #15
~o
ct(ARwA 11:R
~ .!". ......:" ... .
, .'
:;d1' ,;':/' :..
'~, ~.,. .t...'t.J I
'::.~V'::-'pP~ GO
. ..
-+;J'
50
32/04 a
40J
o
r;J
1.13J/lO
~. : ~::~ (,':: "'~_l"'''' "'K"fft.' ....:~.~. "'"'O"~".': ":9OU11 y ,t:;~. :'-::' :-:-:;,; ~:':'fi,l; "~'1~"~' .::: ;" ..
~ . t t, AR lf~rt":R. .'tl.: "I' .l''''\'' '.' J. \! ~'.. ~"''''''.' .J'" ) I
~ I'" !'p~...'.~~ .l1-.,,.~ ~." I :.tf~~.~. ...: J: -, t ,. .~. I, ~ i':..t."-..t[l :' :1~"~.;:"F/:~.:!1:": i~ ..r., :'. I' ",;.. I
~'ir~:.-:..,~:",~4~~"'.;J;;'~:F[.'. 'Ii' ..~;... ",.. "..'" I' ""I"~~.:. ~ .-:;,....J.-:.:..
.....~,...._~j..~ ~;;. ~.*:...!,r~.('i~;~ ..~: ',e.... ~~.-'1 ':" ;-:.~.,~~~..
';:\;'~r~~;.J, :r:;{t"~n~:'i1i; :,\3/'04'" '~I~~":l'l\i'O' ~"r.:'~'~"~!;
. .... .......~. ...",'...,.~ ,~.~ ~..~~ ;r:., :...t t. ....; .rJ.,j "" ~,..~.--:;.
i~" :/......:.':~~!..;.~~~:.:..,;t:'; :., ~, -... :.~ ,.:':.~~'~...r:::....:r..:.h~~'.~'.'f
. t""'. "; t. io.., t~ '.:,.r~ It ""~~ ....1.6 I 5 . . '''I''' ..l,...., ~-... i~I.~~f
, " ,~.....:..' ..., . I! '/"c. """ 33 P ,.,' ..'. I:"'.. ,'. ..
..~:::.~r~~l~;,(QR!ti.~..~.:-.,J)I. . . ~ 'Ii :.. ,~,,:'H''''t': )''; "";.:~I~.~'.'''''
.....~ . "." .,.~~. .rrt:l'.'~" ':to .0/(;... . -\.~'^""\r .t-~""'i'"'''' "'.....
";.:.'...l:.~,~,"~'~r.":;;:'" 1~~ ~~....~ "'r ,..,... '., L':~.' .:-t.:.~ ~:..t'o-..~~?~.,~..:,:: I .
::1!.1~h}~::e;.;.r.;.~ 'I:~~'~;l' ';~"l1.06'" :.J,.1"..~l.:".~, il!:~ . ,.'''''
1I<("....;.~~..~'..~f. "r~..t..i;' ~""c"'.;. ..~.)f+J1.:t'.,.c.~'. J.O!J
:):~jltllft'~J!~:.M;~ :"'m;'~.:i' :-~'r;' ,W'.:J~.t. ,...1 \; ;; n
'-~~1~~ri.~~~~'J~~It~~"=~i; . >;J4'/Q71"" "V~iI92.]" ~i~/6i'
" :~~t:'r~ .I..,.;l".. 1':' ~ri.', i;J, ..,., . " '. ~:~. , ;~.l"~" · ~.-... ...,
~\:.;w"~~I~~j~t'""~'!:~;:\~~~!~~ ts-: -40.11'" .~. : ~:':,.:r~~..f~ .~;;-:~:"':.~~~'
'!;! 'I
..,'"
:g ,!.J3el
t1 a '~'
~
60
.'
,
,
. '103
. :~..~ ~.l *, ~
'::--;ii"
':. 'I 608
L.J
:::l
~
0(
82 ~
..
,
~8 500
~
. ,..
! "
. , ,. .
.:W.j~ "t:~ ,::;:;~ .._'~ ;'~~r. . ,...., '~~ .~!\- ~I-:!:':i.' ~:.!1":" ,. ~rn ,,]: ' r:~~ r~--" ~:~ ~..'. !1,t;'~; .
..~. " ~:ij '"
lit n ... ..!' ~ ,.~'~ ~. r';t. ~~, ij -'.#1.~ 'r'. ... ..'~
:f,~ ..,. l' ~ l""'~ HII ' " '.. ~. .. "~
"2'1 '. I,. .
; ."lr~ ~.#. . '.,' l~ ".' " Jt.. p~ ~j5~ 16~ '17::.'"
.!~ .. :'I~ . .. J.... ..' I :}p:. ,if; iti
21 '.f\'~ :-;t.
t1QP :- .,'... ','~I '. :;-!.....' ".
tt .1 . .; . ,..... . 'l' I' .... .r.- l!'....:. , ., . -, ). .",,' JIO
~...~.J'. ~ .,,','4 ':....;-'t I....'&~ ..."" '1:\ . ,.- t 11~ If14.:~,B ~~,:." ." ....~ 1'~'( <. ,. , ,...~ . ';" ..~....
. ",~t -":33 !~i.' -:IH :'jo' 29 ' 2fl . ,27 "i.6" 25', t( 23 . : 22' :70 '19 1 ~.~'
;t' ~ ;;,! "1' n .'
-{.. . ',~ a .. ! ..\ Q 'i '... f' ~ n ~! .~. . ' ....
: .'i-~' , 'a :.; .. .1,1, a ~;.I... :.! I ;';' :\:~ n .~ ,..I .
3tl('; ;,p :J ~4t :oj>: ~ : ' . " ,:'
" .... .. j".' ,', ..., "': ..... . r .100
'. .- ',1 .... .~ ~ . ..'~ :,1 .. .\ ,= ~ . ..u _ l... " ~"" , . ,t..' I." ..
, .)9
-'f: ," no
. j .~
< j.: :."
. . .
. "
~. : ~
~.'~~ ..~.~ 4 -;.~
.....,'...2 :..' ,.: '40 ...
4 ,. .=~ 406
~:f ':...~ , .' .,.,'
81
'~"
.: Ji")"'i"':".~~"''''~}/"''' ,..... ::;...II....,~~t.H...t:...~,.:'. "-,... .... ,..I..;.....~...].1-4 , .;'. "'l
.' ~ ..:..~...~.. ;. t,l r.:.......,.nRl~rJ:g ......=.t~'.I'.,~....c.'1:~.~I.:. '. ~r~f'\AIv.= I.:..'l.....;rl~....~.. . ~ .
,.. I ... ~ ~.~:.. .~ '. :')0':'" t.. ~~~ l~t :~"j~'.' :.:~~:. ;./r~: ':.:: ~ i i:,~ ~1 ~r: ~.. ~ !{.!+:!I~! ~../.\! 'f;.: ~ . f. ~ '. ',; ~ t~J.'?5 r.!
: I;"~ ...:;, 'c(a" ':";~Iq i'.lt'B':".'D i:ij' "l'ft ~.~~ ..:t'~ "ij :!i:!~ ,.... "!-~~:;.~.:..~ :,~ ..~JUO .:J;; ...g, ,..,....~
~. . ~'\ ..... :Ji3;i r\:"" .~-:. ,...; '( '.~ ;':';.' ..~ . '.-;1 '~;'" "I.. ('., ~ ~"i' 'to,' -1-;' t. ,..,
':~~' '~I r@~~ '~.~:i :~~! ~~t\~ :;~',:. '~~ ~i tl~. :;~',~i ~~~:J" ,'~ ~ ;)':. Jr: W~'q ~~_ t," . 16'{I~!.'. >~>~ '~~~r~_:~; .!'...j. .30~
.~;~ ,.~ Wj1= ~3T :j~~: ".:;j-:i '~b'i 7~:: z~:..; ~,o't.~r ~:25\';~t, '23; ~'ir ';ij :70' 1'9 'J~'~' ~: ~~;7'i;,
-':'; p. ,.,:::; .~.~~:Q t..i; :!r'2 .Jf:B ,;r~ :..~~ .:;:~ ~,~;; ~'is: i?.J!t :" R" {'i!:.'; .f.i:~, ,;::!!, '. 2 ;.: /~, ..~ 'l.''''a:::;, .l_, I
..Ii':,., .... ',..... ~ ..~J.p "'1 tI ~... tI _ N :.~ ,......l.f "'Tot: M ~f_; n .... ,. JI ...:.~:U ':,' R ;-~_" ."" ~ h lw ~ ......._....., ...."!'...,... "J." .:. ~.;.5
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
LAND USE PLAN CLASSIFICATION and ZONING
:':>nJ'~:"
:~ ~ ~ .. .....
~6 ."
;";2'(~'"
301 ."
r.,. ....'
'. <" 41 '.
-~ -, -100
6C
.;.: h
s;:
42
.1tO
59
~c. ..... .
. - .'. - .
.'\-::" ,
. :,.'H 300
-<
Z
~
,47
~
OWHER
APPLICAHT
wARREt-J
~
\
'LAND USE PLAN
~ 'C L A R. \<. .
.
AQS-Il
ZONING
PROPERTY DESCAIPTIQtl
L 0\ '1.. I
oA\< MOl--J\ suB
c 0 U ~l T Y (2. E'5 I 0 E IJT I At... L.. 0 uJ
R-3
o.'l.O.:.cnES
CITY R65lD6klT(At... L.oW
t:< s 10
nlGItT OF. WAY
....cnE:.;
J
PLANNING ~nd ZQHltiQ BOARD
CITY COMMISSIOU
SEeTIOH
07
TOWtlSlllP -z.q:5
RAUOE \6 E
Allk.S "AOE 2.61'A.
-
~V".i~ l ,-" -. H .
ORDINANCE NO. 5881495
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA,
ANNEXING CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED WEST OF MCMULLEN
BOOTH ROAD AND EAST OF LANDMARK DRIVE'. CONSISTING OF LOT
14. KAPOK FOREST. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 1236
KAPOK CIRCLE. INTO THE CORPORATE LIMITS OF THE CITY. AND
REDEFINING THE BOUNDARY LINES OF THE CITY TO INCLUDE
SAID ADDITION: PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
~G
WHEREAS. the owner of the real property described herein and depicted on
the map attached hereto as Exhibit A has petitioned the City of Clearwater to
annex the property into the City pursuant to Section 171.044. Florida Statutes.
and the City has complied with all applicable requirements of Florida law in
connection with this ordinance: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following-described property is hereby annexed into the
City of Clearwater and the boundary lines of the City are redefined accordingly:
Lot 14. Kapok Forest. according to th~ map or plat as recorded in
Plat Book 47. Page 47, pUblic records of Pinellas County. Florida.
(A95 -18) .
Section 2. The provisions of this ordinance are found and determined to
be consi stent with the City of Clearwater Comprehensi ve Pl an. The City
Commission hereby accepts the dedication of all easements. parks. rights-of.way
and other dedi cati ons to the. pub 1 i C \'ihi ch have heretofore been made by plat. deed
or user within the annexed property. The City Engineer. the City Clerk and the
Central Permitti ng Di rector are di rected to i ncl ude and show the property
described herein upon the official maps and records of the City.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
The City Clerk shall fi.le certified copies of this ordinance. including the map
attached hereto. with the Cl erk of the Ci rcuit Court and with the County
Administrator of Pinellas County, Florida, within 7 days after adoption. and
shall file a certified copy with the Florida Department of State within 30 days
after adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
"'
Approved as to form and
legal sUfficiency:
pa~~K.~dt'
City Attorney
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
t_.J ~.
,-
4
- "
.' ""-
\
'.
f
\
I
'--- ~
6
0
tt
~
8
to
1
z:
3' ~
~
lo'l :::E
)t u
oJ)
'''fJ .\
'''''' q
,-",r ')
I ..
,n,
rl7J ,~
fbl7 <J\ '60
1m' '7
'U~ LG
'9
:.0 ID
~I
. . 0:
..
~ U
3'
~
~
AcnE5
LAND
USE
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
C LAS S IF J CAT ION a.n d
^ q5- IE3
P L A ~~
ZONING
OWHEIl
A P PLle A. Iii
5~,R I
0)
w.
\.0.,
LAND USE rL^~J
Z 0 N I 1'J G
p n 0 PEn T Y 0 Ese n J r T I 0 ~l
LoT ILl
\<. A ~ 0 K
poRE:ST
cOunTY RESIDENTIAL
LO u.J
~~3
0.'23 AcnES
CIT Y
Rc-:~ (O"f;;; kJ11,\L
LOLU
RS b
!llGIIT OF,WhY
f'L .l " 111 "G "n II 1. ('1111 "a no AnD
!....-----
, ~ E. C Tin II 0 q rOw,,!; III P 2 ~ s
I
n ^ IH.1 E \ 6
C I T '( COM 1.11 S 5 I 0 14
E ATl....S "AGE
?_7~ A
f
I~XIIInl'l' A
-
~~8,~'":'.', ":. .
. ," .
..
II
ORDINANCE NO. 5882-95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PLAN ELEMENT OF THE
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF THE CITY, TO DESIGNATE THE LAND
USE FOR CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED WEST OF MCMULLEN
BOOTH ROAD AND EAST OF LANDMARK DRIVE. CONSISTING OF LOT
14. KAPOK FOREST. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 1236
KAPOK CIRCLE. AS RESIDENTIAL LOW: PROVIDING AN'EFFECTIVE
DATE.
WHEREAS. the amendment to the future 1 and use pl an el ement of the
comprehensive plan of the City as set forth in this ordinance is found to be
reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is consistent with the City's
comprehensive plan: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The future land use plan el~ment of the comprehensive plan of
the City of Clearwater is amended by designating' the land use category for the
hereinafter described property as follows:
Property
Lot 14. Kapok Forest. according to the
map or plat as recorded in Plat Book 47.
Page 47; public records of Pinellas County.
Florida. (LUP95-20)
Land Use CateQory
Residential Low
,
I
;
I
I
I
I
I
I
, ,
Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
contingent upon and subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5881.95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
. Approved as to form and
, legal sUfficiency:
~f' ~ .
.[ It- .
Parf1e a K. in
. Ci ty. Attorney
Attest:
Cynthi a E. Goudeau I
City Clerk
-
_ "'" / 1510 ~ ~~~:...-'
"" "-.....-J ~ _ .......-:'5.~~60
'- ~ ~~/ v--.'\.
~ ,?-<f,'2
) -,.-:'" ~. . t-~~ _M~S ~ \
-.. '. 1'-'"' :'t--Y" . c.. ..
/~~' ._' ii.i~" l.' Cpo o..~ l,'?-~()......<::,g
... ,-,,, ~ ~/ y.... V 'Z-...J ....'
',--_ ~ _ _ _ ..-"" ._~~~~_ - . r ~ ........ ./
" ~"" ,_ l /...............~
,.;. "..~V ............, _d:............~....~..."f.....~.. L~j ...""'f
~.~z.' ,..;...-':;;.~f.,.; \ L .,.......;X, ~r;/ ./
...;.~,~ ...:J.!:.."-:~.::.:.:t;" _...;;.....-\;-'."t.;.:.~y ~ ~
.. -...;;- ~":.,."......;,........ ~ ..'....",a., .$~~.................... /'
.~,~'- _.t:"_"~,.::..r 2 ,/0\ ''':'9'' "<.::~-'...... ...... ~
:..+~ - .~E'.'" .:.: - :;.;S-~-::.-. !~;...JI""" , .--
.,..)~c ;o:r" ""-= q--I.....~.. t - 't-~"Y-,... -- ~8
:~.l.~ ,~.~-!'~:'~~ ,/." -=;~;-'. '-",:J';;;- . // .J I
:..~E. ~~/...ok~ ~.:-:'.:5:X<~.i:ttr .... /l"Q', (m.-...../ . /" /:' ./.1011
~~t.~;~~'~t~:~. r ~:~o~_.. ........f' ~~'i ~ ~ ~
~1.::,~.! ~~;..~-:#~7-" :.tr"~~. ..... 'h"'~~:: -/ 0..- '
~~~ .h.i;.t~-: t;:;;..r~' ~,,(~"7 9~_..-'- .. Q -. ~
--:.:.t5' ~.., ,-=~~ ">/""./, -" - ~.. ~ =\::.
l';:-;.,,; :,.- ~ .:[~~" , :ry ......... ~ 1: - - - -
:ltil f'.~ ~~r. 23/03 m - ;:3/0 r)"H \ ~PVT.
?<.,ti".a ,~-:.; .~. 2~ 0 R ~ J' 'SJr1/
;"jl:~Z';';;/~ _ .~&jl . - ~ .... :,.:) F!ul ,""""
..~, :..i....~ ~.....:oJ"; _...J.O ~~._'~ C. "
~.:-. ,-::':.-- ~T~" ..:~.~ .~,..- ./" ~~ J' 11 '311 -< d.12, ~
F" ,...;~;. ~h}L'''':'~~~'''''''' ----- Jr' ''?~':.!. .~. 13 ~ ~ ,:":,,,I~tl rw:.J",.u )f
',"l~~'..:.;no-:~' i=---::J . .r~8!"L" ClTYO"oljI:O ~.. 2'-;;;:;;:~"" ."
.,...- .~ ~.:~~ , . '--~'i};
.err" ....~..,.~/. ."i,:; _ ':'il'!'>""'~,,;'~1I PIlCP'::R 1"Y.r:;- . = I 'JT' "
:!.!;'C\i;1::-:<'I"" of';', -0il'J-1' d'-~.' '..~..., ~~}.c.: IZ37 \b. -.. 1~ I$DC' 1:C1 '1
.. ".,r,,~ ,~.....,... '" ~""'1\.~ '~~'-'~ O.f.: ..:;o;j~f' ~
..~.Il. ~~:'r. -""O::.:~re- .'1' ~~~...":'" ..-';..T...~:r~........ ~~~ Cd;;...... 2~, I-"','l
d~l" -;. ';",;::A 7=__ .~ .,J;;fJ.: -.11", ~i8:':?'~~~~~~':';':'~'"-r.>W; 123'12 ) l' 'M. ~
....... ...z.., '."" -''''''''0; ...;:~~~,. r'!l;r.;., ':..1.. "='~~ 2' _'"
;- >~. -:~z.:. :'=. .;.:: ~....: ,;~'11 ',-..;, l:~.r.~!"t"~ .~ ,-IT,,' .:-"t'~:S:;';;' M Q tt r/) ~I /."
:~~,,~... ~7'-';; ~;; -:.:;-.~~. :i::::-'::-- "'. '~~.;~~." .. ~aBi;r~li'1 ~ ...... CO':'; I!"H ,..,.. 117J .~
......1.~~J-~ ~ ~ i"3 -~~.. . ......~~. . ~ ...u.:..,~..t.... ~~~!'~ ~..
.;.:.,:..::t';'.~i' ~~~ ,~~~~ ~j:!~1'J:l:I,;.;'; -.~ -;-~~'h~.f.-...~..,;::?.;;p ":.~=:11 LO 11 ,h!ld........ t~1 ~
_.... '..I.: ..-.~ __ ..- ........ ,",: ...j..I..;'\.... . ~ ~.~ . ~ - ~ ..,
....:-.,q;.. U:J :J:........ .,...,.. ~- r-. ..c.,1t.-.....:...::..c.:: ...~ .~. . .. ~ ~ -. ~ ........ -ra!'P 1. - ~
I::~~ ..2f !:t~l'i; ~. r:~ ~~~~~~ ~"~';"l"'....---~Z~~?~... ,- --0 l~ ,%..< IUj
':?::"I'~" ~',,"_.~~":IJ.':~~,:.{.;:'~",..~~f~~'" .~~~;cro.l2: . OdJ'auu l IIi' ..
.=..:.:. '~f:,.,":,,'~~:;;~~~~~:' . ' '~'--::7' " _.;;;u I
... ..,....---... ..........-., . .....i _""'~~~. '.' ~ '" ..~ ....lI;-....., ~ 1 a:: ~
,'.!.:;- '!:e."",'bffli:;:F!,~!:'t~ ":~I...;W~.~.',z;.,.._ ':-r(j.Jffi _ =-~~~~-ftl. -< I 'L~ 'Lr.
4-;?;;.:'::7,;~e~~ '~~;.i& ~ ~. :~~;:, - i:~ .;:4f~~~~~ .n ~~.:. ~ ~if~E. :> I~ r~ :;;;~ ::
'-'~!=-)';i.~hI -'l'~!::.. ~-::h~ ~...... :,... :r~. ~ _~_TT>""" . ...L. _' '~ l~ ,~tj\
~~i~ _!:.t: .,~~.. ':::-...~-;.:' ~ ~~:: ~~ .1~~'ir'~,,~I' .16:'~'~~~' '-', :.:-=~ _;:;...;:n ~ ,. rm! ,IT, 3J
~~_.;~.~.~: ~.;.Jr: ::,t._.:.. :~ .\=:,I,.:"~~~ ~.. :~..::~a..: ~l:!~:-. _ . ~::;...~ -< ') INri ill I~' ~,
~~-..-' ~'~-:f::.~~ ~:-2'5=-;It);r,; ~~~~~ :e~~k~~~:~~ ~~"'-~ j.~~ ~::r: u .""". rlU~ ~
-.:.~.~:'1.;,C ~~~"".7... t':": .._"~~,, -.,-. ~~;.. ::ct~-:-=--.~~ '''':".~_ ~,~~~ ~ ~~w...., .. I~ IIC' ~
~;.~.r~~~~J: ~1i~ ~ .~~ ~~~ ~~":'~~;:~~E ~ ~~ ABBEY Ci (PVT.
..::':!:?~ i::m7~~~-:::' ~ ~ ~~:';jI~ ~~~ ~~ .-..?:;;~- ~~ ~ ....~~J.'''''''^'i .~..,.- .~. ~ ~ ~ :;;1 ~ .. : : ;; I"
'~::;~I J~:.-::;.~~=;.I~~~)") ~~ ~i,,~ j~ i'rB'':!~ ~~,..-.. , - .. l ~ 1"':; .."Or
.' I:":"'i:'",' ~:r::' ~~:- .2W;>,....;,~.......:. ,;~ ~ ~jl+"~ . . ~~~~. ~ ~~.,
..-~~gi..g;I....~/:<~~fJ~ -~~~~ ~ t"e", \ ~~~~~~ ~1 %fi~' ,0' ~ 7 ! ~:;~ '... --.,~~
_~~r-;~"}.~.- .... ~~~~~ ~~ .... ~ " ..~' ,- _.... '... rr:. - '" . .._.~ ~'",,","'.i+.=:~.J'~. ~~a:
..:~,..;;3.~:'i~<(;;':' .~5U~~~::<,;;~~,~",~:i;l~~~0Q'; .71i:~'" .. _,' . ,.,,~~.~.~~~_..:'-.t~~~~,. ~
.... ;-.:-7";;:.;Ioo'f.,~: .t:::;7~~~~~-'T(j; ~tl.~ t~r-:;-:- . _ :Q;.n-.. ~ ....~ ~ ..~...-...; . ~. ~ 1%1l~ ~~ '_~r.l<~~ ~
--...~~.1 ?'.~~ "'=;C'~~ ~ ~~ ..~ 11 _t_ Y\: .;~_.. '. J-'6. =- "-".~ ~ ,~.~ ;~~. ~
~~~ ~ ~ =-~._. !ffi-s.-~ ~- ~g.' - , . .. .... - 1!:llI .
~;,::-;'~W:i1~~:~r.' -- -..>,':-:" . - .'. . . . -. . ,,~.~ '-<-...;,~: ~
,f~_~.._ ...n:.,'. ~e'~&~l:~~ ~~~ ' ..' i<'" "II"'" .... ....~ ,... ;;:l:: ~~
.~.~Q~~ ~~~ i..~:"~~~ r'"",;;;,,-r...; ms,~ k'~5";t"..n - o.~ 2:~- ~I" - ~~, ~ --. i1i;' - --- . , " ~1
:;~;;.t;:~~j~.~.~:: ;:ii~.~ r",;J~~~" ~~~'i{~:;t .P. ..~li.~ ~l~~ ~'" .,~~... ~ . ~~~~ ~~ It>E .~J
;-T...:-.,J-'"1 -../,IJ.,,"-:,~. .~-=-:&r."".( "" ....;r-;.;..,.... .~ d~~~D-""__t..~~__...~......~""""'~~.~..................,..~~.......~ u-:.Jr"'"":tCr4~~I~............~U"ti:-
L-J L.-:..'
,,----
f
\
J
~.
. .
....
..-
....
...
,
)
.-
'"
LAND
PROPOSED ANNEXAtION
P LAN C LAS S I Fie A T ION a,n d
A. q 5 - I B
ZONiNG
USE
OWHER
AF'PLlC^HT
5~.R I 0 '.
w .
\..u ..
pnOPEnTY OESCtllPTIOH
LoT I L(
\< A -Po~
L ^ N D USE P L ^ ~J
ZONING
poRE:ST
COlnIT)' ReSIDENTIAL L.Ou.)
~-3
RS b
0.23
C I T Y R E'-;: I 0 E IV II" L L 0 LV
n I G II TOr-. W ^ Y
rLAlllIllIG ...nd lOl/lllO I)QARO
!._- ----
.1
C Ii Y COM M I 5 S I 0 ~l
I:;. ~ i\:--{.
I '
"
..
I ~
1 :
F
~
::;.
~:
~~
~-'~.
a
ct.
16D
<0
c::
u
ACRES
.a.cnES
~...:
6.
~
8
CJ
~
::I
~
~
5f:C 11nll
oq
TnWIlt,lIIP 2C1 s
ATl"'$ PAGe '27L~ A
n ^ ~I r.l E \ 6 E
"
~,h.\r""" ",
,
., >. ... ,
. . . .
. c ": ':....', n'. ...
ORDINANCE NO. 5883-95
a'6
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY ZONING CERTAIN
REAL PROPERTY LOCATED WEST OF MCMULLEN BOOTH ROAD AND
EAST OF LANDMARK DRIVE. CONSISTING OF. LOT 14, KAPOK
FOREST, WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 1236 KAPOK CIRCLE.
UPON. ANNEXATION INTO THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, AS SINGLE.
FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 6 (RS-6): PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
WHEREAS, the assignment of a zoning district classification as set forth
in thi s ordi nance ; s found to be reasonable. proper and appropri ate. and is
consistent with the City's co~prehensive plan: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following described property located in Pinellas County,
Florida, ;s hereby zoned- as indicated upon annexation into the City of
Clearwater. and the zoning atlas of the City is amended. as follows:
I' .
I
Property
Lot 14, Kapok Forest. according to
the map or plat as recorded in Plat
Book 47, Page 47. public records of
Pinellas County, FL. (A95.18)
Zonina District
RS.6 - Single.Family Residential 6
I.
'.
Sect; on 2. The Central Permi tt i ng Oi rector is di rected to revi se the
zoning atlas of the City in accordance ~'/ith the fOI'egoing amendment.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption,
subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5881.95. .
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
'\
Rita Garvey
Mayor.Commissioner
Attest:
Approved as to form and
leg~tf;: ~ncY:
Pamela K. A In
City Attorney
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City C1 erk
!--.J L...:.-
~-1-
.,---
I
I
\
...>.......
"
I
'--
.
6,
0
tl
j;
8
a)
J' ~
='
~ :l
)t U
~
r.tlJ ..
J.xlJ '1
'~I 'J
.)
.... 16
.,
4.0
..
=>0 1.0
I )1
I'UA ~. a::
,. '''' ~ U
I' :i ill Ir.l )'
12 I Ilrl:
11,
.-
--- "
)
,/
---"
L A ~J D
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
P L A ~~ C LAS S I Fie A T IoN a.n d
Aq5-1B
:ZONING
USE
OWHF. It
Af'I'LIC ^ II"T
S~,R
o
Lv '
lL?, .'
PROPERTY DEscnlP1IOU
LoT \ L( )
\< A -p 0 ~
L.^t-JD
USE
rL^tJ
ZONING
COIJ~11'(
l=oREST
0.23
Re511)S NT I AL
LO u.J
~-3
C IT)'
1:(.(::>-;:; 10 E J.J'rIl\,L
RS b
RIGH10F,WAY
L,:Jt.u
AcnES
" n II Z 0" I II 0 (\,., ^ n u
CITY COMMISSION
,l,CRES
f
'27 Lj A
rL.llIlIHIC
! ~-_._-
..r.ellC"'''
() (l
\6
2q
lOWIIS"IP
E
ATl.a.s PAOE
nA/laE
:)
t
I"'.~. '. ~ .
ORDINANCE NO. 5884.95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
ANNEXING CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF KEENE
ROAD AND SOUTH OF MEADOW LANE. CONSISTING OF LOT 10.
BLOCK C. MEADOW CREEK SUBDIVISION, WHOSE POST OFFICE
ADDRESS IS 1238 BROOKSIDE DRIVE. INTO THE CORPORATE
LIMITS OF THE CITY. AND REDEFINING THE BOUNDARY LINES OF
THE CITY TO INCLUDE SAID ADDITION: PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
~9
WHEREAS. the owner of the real property described herein and depicted on
the map attached hereto as Exhibit A has petitioned the City of Clearwater to
annex the property into the City pursuant to Section 171.044. Florida Statutes.
and the City has complied with all applicable requirements of Florida law in
connection with this ordinance: now. therefore.
BE IT: ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following-described property is hereby annexed into the
City of Clearwater and the boundar'y lines of the City are redefined accordingly:
Lot 10. Block C. Neadow Creek as recorded in Plat Book 36. Page 26.
public records of Pinellas County. Florida. (A95.19)
Section 2. The proviSions of this ordinance are found and determined to
be consistent with the City of Clearwater Comprehensive Plan. The City
Commission hereby accepts the dedication of all easements. parks.. rights-of-way
and other dedications to the public which have heretofore been made by plat. deed
or user within the annexed property. The City Engineer, the City Clerk and the
Central Permitting Director are directed to include and show the property
described herein upon the official maps and records of the City.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
. The City Clerk shall file certified copies of this ordinance. including the map
attached hereto. with the Clerk of the Circuit Court and with the County
Administrator of Pinellas County. Florida, within 7 days after adoption. and
shall file a certified copy with the Florida Department of State within 30 days
after adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND.FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
'\
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Attest:
P Nl tLvt
Pamela K. Akin
City Attorney
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
-
n__
., .....
BEVERLY
ORCLE
':/~
110
1::18
111
1::24
112'230
113
'::"6
1\4 :z
'242 :=
t::
~
115
rU8 ~
IjC
1::00
\1)
"'2.
rd
v
-
~ MEADOW
~~u-,~....). .!.."l =:t~
~:"t ..= co
!i"' ~.. of ".;~
.~.~
- \t@! ~. t ....~
.;.~---: ~~::;:.:
t23t~~~ ~"~-:~'~":.~'c-.!
.3
f'J }.;:-,.~ ~ ~~ ~~-(
S ..~ 1ct1r'~'"
.:~4.~ ~S. .
......,.. ~1 ""!;:(.S'"
.':::'.~ .(::;! ~11'..
. ~ -,""'" --:-. ...,~~.......
1ft
,
RS
15
~
~
4
15
14
to
C
~
'"
@
7.:
,"1202
'. _. . ~
-.~~ ~~; Y~,~~~:f ~~ '~~2r:'~~ ,,'''>.~:'~;i; .-
,.,.. ':.l..... _! . . . ""!,....-.. .. Q.A:.4t ..........~ ...... ~ ..~......:~I:.... or. .
:)~ :..l....~~l.. '1. ... .-. . '. .... .....~.. ..... __4.. - .
'~:I' ,-r.'
- "":.:r.'10 ~ .....- I,. \lAC
1ij:'11 ,. ...
-10-....;
.""i-} :..:::. :2~ .i~. '.;~';:'"
. . ;-::-, .,:,;-;. . 1255 ~
...:.::. g':.;.~';:~- -;..'~..- .: . :
'.' -......"'~. f........L
,~ ':~r-\~~':~.'~ SRENlWOOO
1 0 ..' -1,.. L ~" ," ,..... .... .
..-- - ;...~,...:.'...::: \\) -
','2r~ .:...., _.-::. : ,.:,'_i ,_ ~p)' . ,': .'.,'....
, . ,...... "'10'" :..., ....-
,.,," ,:;,:;;'~:L ,'";:....~~ "\'8 " ' ~ ;'12'.;,
.~.;~ "~~Jf.~ '1~:~ " 11.,. ..~~~
.,.:, ',~'C' r::?f.. -~: ..... ,., .'.' '.':14 f: ~....'
,~:~7~, -:;':7-~ "~r \;~~\,:, :~..:i2 ." " '15;.:. :~.;..~ .:1.~.~::
4 8 .. -C' ...... ~...~ ~""'.h1.1./ 00.... ~ .":.. ~'... ~ -:;:~ o. ....". lG-~~ ~,~." _
:,:~:::, ;fg :jE:;,~;~~:;;~:~; ;:, ' ,~'.~c;:::;;::~ :~:~:2-:~,,;; , : ~\ I "
. "'. -8 ." ~ I - -" 8 ", '-'.~.... . - .. -.. ,', '-"'"'l...:AJ<E't1EW ,'.. .. . -.. ',-""" I
.:?;-:~f~~~"2i~t:ri~~~E~;";:~~.:~:;~~;i.:T:{::::'.?~: :.t~ ~;'.. ,. ~:;-;,-~~~'.:: :,;7~', ::",;,: ,";~~~:7"': ,
-1"'/0<4-' ..:::~.:,";.i:~. :6'O~ '- ..., . - '~'6'O" -
._'.~ ~_-._', ~...'_, .II.." ;1. ,- :_'f"".~_OO\":.".['._..:,.' ~. :,..,:~~..'.:...,.s.,.. ~.....~.'<"'\. ,.;.~,~ .. .._~ - ...... "'~'..:":;;~ .~='. '1; ....&-.-J.... -...... _ ....4..
w,. ~ -, ~ . " -'-. 001 -. ~:r!..-:-:-;::,::.<. ;~~; ,:g~ .:"::'~.;:.:.:
,,J.. '1.:106 "'f' ":":' ~f,~~,~:.;:'~.:,'~'~.~~~.~..:: ,~",~,",'_'2';iO:-,:'}.,.~~ ~. .~, ~-=:.;':':';F~ ~':'-;:S2:::~ ~- :~'~1~:~ >;.26. ~ ..", "o1-.'[t. ,!:'~""~.1...,,..
- -. ~ "~:'7 :~., ,::~.",,:.i300' ....so ,,:,:: .:~';.
: ~~\,[,~:, -,""
,1, 4/01, .~~...:., '~""" f3tJ'" .. '.~' :;300 . ~',--:. ':2'.:.; _ 31 ::::' .....~_~'_',=-_. '.i_' . ~:::'.~':'_';-.'::.~:'.~ "~.~: ~~~~.f'?.)~i::'i
.... .' . ".~. ~-- . '-- --.. :'~:: ~ -- ...
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
USE PLAN CL'ASSIFICATION
A '15'-\Q
6- :__'~
.. '.20"
., ,,wI;
5 ..-."
'~"1~'1~:;.'
:~l;;:J~
." ;;:--:".
"-.' .
.,<:>~;.t..~
~ . ~ ..~
;'-~-..~'" ..
-...:. ~....:.-:..~.
..-.......t...
.~~~,?~
. ......_...~...
~ -/"4 .
..... ..
~-. -
to
""
~
1~5-l
o
<0
;::7_:N,i.o ...: ~_.....r
,:~~:::::,:':g'~~,:'~
.~::t~.:~ i~~t.:;
r:~~:n ..l.
:::l;~~,~~
.;},~,~~..;:
" ~":2
..h' ~
,,!:"'.1~ .c-;-: .: o..:l{')
~~'.~,:? ':':~"".
, N,Qf.'" c-.I'\o
,." ',:'" :, <"'I IQ
.,.'.....r....~ ~ . '22.
~~::~~~\:
~', 'N .',1:)
.~ "N,r J;;
'-
~ c~: ,,' :;.:;
~:~.~~
"'N.'~
~t :~~~~~
1" !:,ARWATE"
COUHTY~
. .. -<0.
:-26"'h:'~
. .
-:T". .
;::: 7\ .:.:...~:-:::-:=:~
t""-" ,/l,. t. .-:J'...'+i.,.....,.--:-.......
;' '.:' -.~',~-:.::J:.i
."60'" 1S01~':-:;.~,'~~
tot:' !~..5_>~;:~;
:-:::..:,.:.~~ i60
'~~!?~j ',,;;~
'-'.:~' .I-~..
'.~!:~~ ~~~
.ro-.....,...~^' 1"1i'_"
'" :.. .'.;<:-,
LAND
and
ZONING
OWHER
... P P LJ C A H T
..ft.OULIER)
R
K
~
G
\<
PROPERTY DESCRJP1'IOH
BL~
La\'
lOI
m €t:l.~ CJ u.J
c
I
sv~
'LAND
USE
PLAN
ZONING
C.fLt:'E"f<..
C 0 U ~l T Y
R.E5\OE~Ttl\L-
Law
R
....,
::;.
O.'2.lOt.CRES
CITY
Q ec; l D cS N Tl Po L-
lr 0 u.)
RS L(
RIGHT OF Wt.Y
ACRE.:>
]
.~ Cl T Y
! 5'" E
CO)'\I~15SI0~
GE -::'o8A
ATLA,$ PA -'
.=~.~=
P,-AIIN1HG
tI n d :: 0 N 1 .. C 9 0 ^ f1 0
~; t: C t I U 'I
'2.'-'
TOWHSIIIP '2. q
..
~
Rt.'WE
!::XII In 1'1' A
--
:",'H c.i',.... . .
"
.
.
ORDINANCE NO. 5885-95 ~ (:)
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE PLAN ELEMENT OF THE
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN OF THE CITY, TO DESIGNATE THE LAND
USE FOR CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF KEENE ROAD
AND SOUTH OF MEADOW LANE, CONSISTING OF LOT 10, BLOCK C.
MEADOW CREEK SUBDIVISION. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS
1238 BROOKSIDE DRIVE. .AS RESIDENTIAL LOW: PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS. the amendment to the future 1 and use pl an el ement of the
comprehensive plan of the City as set forth in this ordinance is found to be
reasonable. proper and appropriate. and is consistent with the City's
comprehensive plan: now. therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY. THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
f
I
ii
i!
I
I
i
I
Section 1. The future land use plan element of the comprehensive plan of
the City of Clearwater is amended by designating the land use category for the
hereinafter descr'ibed property as follows: ·
Prooerty
Lot 10. Block C. Meadow Creek as
recorded in Plat Book 36. Page 26,
public records of Pinellas County,
Flori da. (LUP95- 21)
Land Use Cateqo~.
Residential Low
Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
contingent upon and subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5884.95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to form and
~r:UffiCienCY: .
ame a I. Akin
City Attorney
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
1200
-,?I"'~ ,~~:,,,\f::
~4;"": l."""". ~~..._<li
-........ ~.........
~i~ :~~~~.
~_""x ~~..,.-..
.......-...----.. ~.." ..,~~
t231~' ~"~:'~I;;.1
lj1-V
'239
LAND
OWHER
.... P P LIe ANT
"\G... 0 U L I" E R )
LAND
PLAN
USE
COUNTY
R. E 5 \ D E ~T { l\ L..
c ''';" y
(~ e:s l D cS N Tl A L...
r L .... H ~Il ~l G II n d :. 0 H I H '::. 8 0 AnD
S[ClI0~1
"2L/
TQWtlSlllP
R
lOW
lr 0 L.U
1-9
K
~
G
\<
ZONING
,.
.:J
R
-)
~
RS
l{
_J
R A ~w E.
c
:;-..;:... :i~ i&C
.:::',~11.?A~ '::!.
n .-t I ...~. 4;r'~.
. .~:;:~:1300
..'.
~:i~.~:J.: ....t;
<I"""~~~-~."~
and
ZONING
PROPERTY DEscnlPTIOH
BL\.(.
IS-
LO"-(
\ 0 I
("Y\ c: JJ, tl 0 u..J
1
I
RIGHT
OF
Vi ;., y
c..tZ..t:'E'K-
I
suR
O.'2.(QACRES
CI T Y
c 0 ~ )~ 1 S 5 I 0 ~~
,l..Ht$ PII.GE "308A
E
....CRE~
-
T
t.i: ~ "', I'~.", .
ORDINANCE NO. 5886-95
3t
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. FLORIDA.
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS OF THE CITY BY ZONING CERTAIN
REAL PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF KEENE ROAD AND SOUTH OF
MEADOW LANE. CONSISTING OF LOT 10. BLOCK C. MEADOW CREEK
SUBDIVISION. WHOSE POST OFFICE ADDRESS IS 1238 BROOKSIDE
DRIVE. UPON ANNEXATION INTO THE CITY OF CLEARWATER. AS
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 4 (RS.4); PROVIDING AN
. EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS. the assignment of a zoning district classification as set forth
in this ordinance is found to be reasonable, proper and appropriate. and is
consistent with the City's comprehensive plan: now, therefore.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
Section 1. The following described property located in Pinellas County,
Florida. is hereby zoned as indicated upon annexation into the City of
Clearwater. and the zoning atlas of the City is amended. as follows:
Prooerty
Lot 10. Block C. Meadow Creek as
recorded in Plat Book 36, Page 26.
pUblic records of Pinellas County.
Flori da. (A95 -19)
Zoninq District
RS-4 - Single-Family Residential 4
Secti on 2. The Central Permi tti ng Di rector is di rected to revi se the!
zoning atlas of the City in accordance with the foregoing amendment.
Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
subject to the adoption of Ordinance No. 5884-95.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
8-3-95
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Attest:
.:..
Approved as to form and
1 egg S{fz4nCY:
pame1a . Akln
City Attorney
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
.
1\1
tIIl1
..;~.', ~"i'.1- ~ ....1. i:~ ''';.'''-,l'" "'!'u 'YfOo-' n '1/ .a:.:~~ n 8j '.
IOJ.;i~ffif.liI..:1':;ml- ti,"2"i~{ ~~.~~ .;:i~~ ~~.~~ ~.~';'A ='~I~" ~~~ ~10-z: :;~J~;;'r;~~ ~l:~~ / ..--
:~"J1>' .!':'l!'!~Ite:tr~ ~~ ~~"." .ttt.~ ..' 5~ ~rr~'~ ~~~.... ~ 'C);II~ ;P:i'~;;;-O;:;~ J:Wr.j '~~&~"""'~h 108
~~~ '~Ji'~,~,.~~:~~.:5.~~~~ ;~~ .;:~~ ~~1~ :~~~~ ~~~ ~;t~~ :it~ ~~~~~~:W~Z~ 1l{)~.
\ %2~ .~~ ~~~~4f~DAu..~~tX~~~",*"!f;!J~';;~i.~1Zi.I~~~l~1t~S-}?'~~~1' ~~~~;,~ ' 09 ~
.tto~ ~~';.: ~O\;. ~5.~~~ ~I-JT.tt'" ~~~~ :~~2! .~'~i;'~ ';:';\:";,",::; +~ t;; .~~~"lI ".......~.... .It:I ~"l~' ]mil...../~ ..~~&~ . V~ ,~ '21:
-- :~:-lC~ ~J.'Z,~ ti~;~:.~ ..~l:...:t ;.d5t~ :~~.;~ :.;;~~ ~.~~ ,~~~ ::g:.~~~: ~.~~-<:, ':I~~M-::-'., '.;.";; ..:-::i
I ,. ....... ...---~(.* ~,.,.............. .,........,."""'~ ...... ,,''"'''..J, .' .~~... ...........~ ..~~.....C'l. .-.I:""~...A< ~~. ol .,.&..If^,~ .~ .~-
-';"1~'" l:....',,';\~ 7"'''''t.';''''' Mjl'4:-' . 6"'!."'~ . ,.<,". ':':~o:E r-....;r. ~t"O"";"''-':O, :~"y.~::'J' ..'" r,:""",,,, 110
.:':;j 1I"'1""l:. ~.1.'jI- .~:...':"' ....~ ~"". ~.'.:...~.'" ...,... 'I'~.~",~,,;, 1:::" . ~ ':' -..JJ' ~ ."~dn: .. '.::1! ~'::r~'
....Ili.'~ ~~....~.t~ ."J'l"I".~"'" ...t::c;..{~ '. .-.. . ....~..4~B" ~L"':~'-~<'~;.:t .... ~.' ,....... :fi:.1Vj-'- I :+-~~It'J~" t'l~~~". ,:!I8
I C t:'\-~""~.. -""''ilr:t ~'r .... --~., ..II;-.......t. '.,.~~~....,.." :.I!f~~ ~m._....;.. I~~. ~;\'"'!?:oIi. -'J.,.r. r~ ..
< ~:.("~.:tO.' ,........ "u,' .. - 'l:il............:; ~e:;~.l u.;....71';.;;:- 'j~ ~.<'-'~~...;,~ "',.<J.:,. ':s-~""!S"' f.,'> ,- ~~.
I 0 ~~~;~6 ;r;~~ ~,?.:;;r i!'-!~. ';r.,'t...~ ~....~.~;-ti.. .......-.~ ~t~~~ ~1:i-:i!!,;f=.(lt'.,duj ~~ A;~'. .:~~:-~~!;~. 11'
c:: iu,;.~'*":; ~'),,:...._~ ....~~'..~~ .~ ~ '"J. ~'~~\'. ~:s;l;-;Y :oo~~.. '''.1. .. -<e~!J;."q:,~. w' "ri"~'::R:i ~.~~~~'.!t 1224
.... I:::l.,~ G)l:~ft1Ir~ .i'ii-f~:t~ ~~.~~..- ."~.CQ tt):::'~ :Q3..r~ .N.........=<. tZl)...-... . ....~ ..' -D. ~.I J: ~2 .~~..~
~. r'''~ ...-.......,.......,c: ~- ..t'...t.". !..... .:t:OOHrt+':.'t--.. r;::~,~.! ......-:...)...... ::..::~"...,'...' .......~~.,.. . :.... .';~:..'- H J. <....., .........~....':"1~~
'.'-J!:.5''''v''~'''' ~ ~~ ...r.~~l.~"",
\1) ~ MEADOW CltARWA TtR A,. LANE ~ ~f!t~I:~ . '~h~~"':.1l~~ 112'~30
"2. .~.;.;.... .,.,_~. .., "'-WCl'Io ~ r:-' //_':'l~::oI-fJ;. ';.{1-i;~ - ~ r"'.6..."'\'\~.":" ~~~.~~~;...~.../~
~; ~_" _.~,. ...:~~':-_" ::_ ~.... ..... 'a.I.~~;" ;:e"41;; .-. "-~~l!. ~:.::,... .~,.,.;"';::,- ~~~,.. -:::.;!:'I.~':'.':
~ ...~~~J..a:,.o;...).~_ ~ ..~ iD';t:Q/~-"';a :e.....,~.~ .~ '~'a" e~,r;.-.r- ..~::)'.Q '- - . I:.",-.t~~'" . . 113
'. -~";::,i ':'''':'''2~_.t: .. '~'1,':t- ';-"'S ~.... .~.~. .~~l~ fr~';;':1I-' . -~ ~::"'!'p~-clYA~-'~R-rr.i 12-6
V -';"~....-;: ~""':.., oJ .... ,,-; .1"'. '~.:;;"'1 ~ '. ~1t. I'"K!'.,~" '.';" .:~:.;:. . .::J.'1.:.J~~~J];), _,,~ "
- .~'-"'. ..:!<..~. ..~:=~ r:,,=t;5:~ .t~"~<i.~~o;..:t~i~~-'~'''.;~;f:;:~~ I'/.(k' ~ft::. .....,o;,-.:".?'~:;i$
I tZ3f~~~ ~~;'':'':i:;~ . ,-.;... '~"~3~~'26~ ;~' ..........". ..:"~~fz~~~~.~..~.rY ""-j:.il~~~;~' 114'242
Vl fJ9 R S 4 1 . ~'~:; -C' I,':f.} ~1~ :;;r..f'..~., .~& ..~~~ .;.- ,...;~ ];~'-..4?i.D"~*~J"
I ... :;'=;141 ~~ ~':'I~'2-. ~~. , '''':H)5 ;;~'~.\..- ~.:. ~'.;"::: ..~~ :~..""'~"
, 7 ~ 16 ~ 15 Q3 ::2.7- ~ l~ ..c;iif:~ ~~.' ~ .'),,~': ;~ ~A.t:~ ; t":!:';:~ }' .~... ;rJ~\r. _ ~;:~ 115
~ ~ ~ .'r~~ ;. ~~~.7~,...3" ~~~~ W'~~ ~336!l~~"'[1 :.~'f ~,..~ ~~~!..~ti~~ 12~8
. ..:\{ "I;,; tl7 i . ~~.,,:..,.
...., ">l ":~.':":. 0 BEVERLY N ~ ~~'.1t;:":".'';::-(''''':'-,' ,'!t "~"'l"~'-'~'';. .w.-......' 't';o.;:...~...,.
.~... - - lI'l OR"" ~ ~......-..:.,~, "-:i ....~o ........>\.~... ....p.- ........ "')'
-~ -- ........:. ,.. ~"'Pw...t<'..' .....,>~...:.rk.~ .';".u;>........; - ~<" .' - ,..;....r:. ~,
. . :.11. ;; "30. \.~................'"t~...;.".."t' .,:.J...I.;..... -. ~r-....' ~~(j"...... ~..' '.~ ....'" 1 1 6
7', . ....,;: "-::'::'I'( ........., " '.. ... --=--:-:K..II.I\J"'I~.;; I-o...;~...:.-<tl. ','r.~.";ay'" . ~1~"'" .-..... ltl:!~-' ':t'i.,:~,:;-..,,:::. ...5A1
.J'p .....,. ...... ,_.. " ....... ....... . ,.- .~ -Cl) f:r). .....~" ~ .-"-221 ,...... .rt-....,;r'" ._....~ If,l
'12!J2 -"t.... ~.~...; ..'::,..,:;:lP..I.....;..:;.,-.~.. -i.,p 'r-""-"';';' -:,' ~~~..:::_~~ -.v rN6 124'3 " , "-,!f"':' :~.n,')..,',"I' .:;;...;..~:
:';' ~ .:~~~ , ~~.:.:'.;::;;J~a~..Cl.....:~...:>:.~.....u.a. :'=~";':.' ~':'), .. ~;;':':"'I" .: .. . -:.:.. . .~- ;;.:... ~~'~.:~,~:.~~T~~~t.~ 0
... .. .......:t........, ~ -.....,.."j ........ ,...~.."'..- t_,."J... .1;41_..;.0;-:.,oiiii ....;:. LU .'-.t'ffil-t-f'~:'" -, +. -.....;ry..-...-.....~.-:--- ,'26
6 ." "';'1'.".;. ~ :. ~:'l'.-J,.r. ..,:-~r'".3.... Cl ;i".. ...,'; ~'- -....,.~.;...... 117
'._' T('i' "'-.; . .' .I.::;.:J >.2"'"'- . .\. f~ -f.>;: .'..'_. . );&8r_-:;
"~"l'~'" . .~-..,. 'lAC .. .... .._~. ~.. .. ..'-'- ".-. ...... ..,... ~ 7>:~~;7,'!..-'...,...~. ..'-. ....- ..,,, "S.:~
:~~::%~~.:;~~ >::......~.- H~ 'a .~~.;~~.:~.; .;~~t~:1. .~:-t7~i d. '; ':"':;>'1 ~: ~ :J;i~.;'.:..i<i:p.. <~~:.j:'~ .<O:~.~~ ~ '-
'. ...- ~ ~-~~ .:.~. '.:.:.. ;-':.-11' . ~.- ~.. ;:",9- >... ..~.~ ~:.. . -~;:~ ~~~J~::/- ..,., 0:: ''''~~_ "';:'.:' :: ~ 0::::' .;~........._~ ~~ .~~" o.:.:~:~ .:;:~~
5 ..... ,:.... -,l ......ll.- J 12 c.- ,." . ..' ,..... 5 4. CD ....,.,.-...... ..'.N~.. "'('-01' ", -:".'. ."r--.:I;.
,.', --=:.:. ..)'':-- '::I.~':' .:.~ :t,.;. .... "r.-..:-..~ ~....~-:... ....":r~. c;'~,::o.-;;': ".",.. .;.~~o~".'-:: :~..N:"~1.. ..N .:":.~ ~.."N~:-:i ~~;.p~:
~.,..:'''''':--:':y.::'rf ~;.:~~'L r~ t.o'" ....'- ... ...M...-:....I!j\ .... 4..~~.L' ...,......~~ ;', .~.'...\:N :.~::.-.r,i-.............
, ~. ...~.~~ M~ .':, ~ .l\ Ii' 0 ~;:;.o.I...~ ~. ~<.: :. .....-~ ..'~ :;!~c;;t\.:!l ~ ;;::-N.~I'f..o >'::. :.:.::~ .::.:~. '.'1;1:) .t:~:.;.. .:..'4,. O-!N:.;.
. . .:-. -'f' '1.255 0 - -...;, Q) '..' ';!:! Qj .. -.. 'Qj " I....:.. (~ Q3 12501 ......:N;tl.o.." <n ... ..... ....~.to ..,. N.....
. :~.~.~r~~~~~1~.:~:,~~~ - -~REN~.. .. ~(- - :;::~:~~.}....:~:.: :~:. ..~:~~:~~:~::o:~~~ot.-ii2~:
..~, .: n"r'~ ....~ 0 11IJ.\....,..._._,.."..-~DRIVE>..,.. ',,,.to ;...~..
10 ':-.:. ";:-',1 f-,~ . ..:-~ ,.. <00 .:. ..~.. . ~".' -. '.. .. '.:~:> 2.
. . .;!:"....~. .;::'....::.'Je.fito ..- ..."'.~ . -.. ~'" ;;:; !:::.-"" '-. - L:;::':~N'~..,.-:_ "...c.l:;; ";'0l;.\Q. Cl'Io......;-;;;,:
. ..121Z ~"J foC I> -It.... -......~~. ""'" q] ; .:~"~.'....'.; - - ~ In \S>,y r "M': - l..~"-"""\o ....:....r- ~ .......... -CQ - o-~t'-. Ql. 0"""" ."..
....:... ":'l' ::"to" ~ - .- ....-..... Rs-e ...:!.......... Q) .. -...,:~ ~ ....,.....- .,.~ :2 "~.:'.
.;.... ,...... ~\. "" .... R e" B -:7' ~'~.;6',~,' 10 . . - ;'12'''';' ""';"~N'- ''':''('-01.- -'('-01'-' N -. I..'..,.
:g'-.':;. :~,.; :~~ ~t~~ \., 9 M~..' . _.. ~k. . 11 12S2 .<~'.~:~...~:: : .;.~. ~ . '.' N' ~ ~..',,' ~.~'~;;
..."tZ16 ~:'~ ~f-~~ ;Z7i,~;.=- :.~' /'~'{5 .'~iJ': .-:. . ':~!~!h .::\.~.. ; ~':14'" '~'"1:r..l!. .....,.' "'f'. . ,'" "'A r-- .....
4. ........ -:~.~~.' :.g.. ...;.:,'. -...~'::::'-', _.....:.: ......'.:,-..... "_" .... . .....
.~~12::O -.~.~.~~......~:-.. ~.:~. .....e. .-4~, .5 ~ '15" ".:..' 13.. ~. ......- .._.... - .....r ~~;~~~t;~;;.~~~
~~;~ -r~ ~:;~:~~~<;; .... ~ ..~-.~ .-:;::;"'~,-_t;'\ ~~~~- :;~: I ,,'i.'\~~ : .~~.~ .., ~ . ~ -~:~i~ -:~~;:~
......8....1--..8 .... .~,,\.. ....... ..t.....GA.KEVlEW ... ~..~ .......1
.'.:?~~=':-;'~~,:.'..-.~::.;:~~~.~.~:.~_F..'/~..-...~.~~~~~.~l~~.f':2;::.':~~'.:-,~'::'E.~..:,~.~;.:.. . .'~.'':: : ~:~:- .: .. ,. .:-;:, .i:: ~.~.~~: ...~~: :.~. ~~~:.': I
!4(~0<l-. _ _~. ~j ,," ..-:..... 1_' .~ ''',;' .':'~" ..60. ...; "~":'.'~I"''' ~:"'\:; '~ii~';' .... ~~~,,:' i.~".'~'.:~.:,: ".., ,::;:
... ~ ......rf'1~...~... ....1-:,. ...... ...... ...r..,~ :;'.. .~...~. . : .I.^.....t.~.~ Q,f ClIt .,"'l2 .... ..... _._............~ ~.7=:--..-;.:......"M~._. J.'~:~....
'-~'.306 1..'P"ll ~:--:.! ~)....:...~.~...to'."J"" '....-....:;...":"..' "":...... :;-t............~r..~ ~\o'''.J :;., ....._1. ...~':;"."':.'~" - r- _.,.-
~ 1.... ..-. ....... i. .............. ........... ....\.,1.. ~..~~:26:::'~."',.I'~~J;?-
~:1\;b~ ','::.,~ ':i: -:j>I'_~':;;2:~~~ '~'- .. .,-2....... L _"_":1;1 -:-..:' ::i~ '-~~~... '.~': ~~~:~~.~~ ~~~:;~ tMl..~.< ..- - ._
;,.. . . . fC' ..tv"", ...>_ .,..~ .. _.~[: I:> ........_.A..' _,._ .....~ t"'-.- -:...::I-:..~....c........... . ...a......:.. I,aii
1200
:z
~
C
;:
~
6C
C' [.IoRWATtR
-
.~:.:.;;:~t~r ~':f~~. ~:.=.:~ .:~i~+4~~.:~~:~
",.' ~ 'C.:~ '~26 ._;.~ ~". "-; ~~>-::-'~;"~,
,.~:::~~:-:\:' .:..... '\~." l~~G:'~~'~f~
_4
s.~~.~;;:;;; +i60~ ;
."'~""~;u$ t,:,~: l
!:;;.:.1:r....:' .1,5'..... ,
. ~~~:.~~ ':S~
t~O! "\~J>:, ~":'-~_~:". ~.1JJ
.. ._ _., ...."1..:. ~_t Jlf4"J#... ..,.c>
LAND
USE
PROPOSED ANNEXATION
CLASSIFICATION and
A q5'-,q
PLAN
ZONING
OWHER
.... P P L1 C A H T
~OUL-rER)
'LAND USE PLAN
R
K
~
G
\<
PROPEFHY DESCRIPTIOH
SL-K.
Lo'"'r
lO I
fY) e::.o. tl c UJ
c
/
sv~
ZONING
c.1tE.:'EK-
COU~lTY
r<.. E 5' \ D E WT t 4 L.
LOW
R
...,
::.
o ,'2. CO I. C RES
CITY
f.< ES l D cS rJ Tl A L.
{"... 0 u.J
RS L{
n I G II T 0 F w;... y
.....CRE~
r L All N III G n n d Z. 0 II , H G 8 0 A no
C I T 'Y COM IA I 5 :; I 0 IJ
:. I: ClIO 14
'2L/
lOW/ISlIIP '2.. 9
~
FlAHGE
! S- E
E~o8A
ATLAS PtoO .-'
.
" ,
.tfo).~!~"!~,c....~ ~ .._
'\.
~. ~ . ," ,.
.. '.
, ,jIIo'
. ;.;;~~:;.:..<~ ~
4h.... 'i ~ .~.
"
'.. T
.. '~. ~,~.
, .,
., ,4
DATE
'Y' .
~"
'PO:
.::t:t'-
~. '
~.'
~~.
'.'\
'IT-
.,.
~' .
Firo1? .
...--...- ~...- .....
\,
. .4" .
. . c ,
, 0'. '.' :.,' . . .
.AGENDA
"
<j - /1_~6
\
I
I
ITEM # ......3:l
(t
-
I
ORDINANCE NO. 5887-95
3'd--
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER,
FLORIDA, RELATING TO UTILITIES; AMENDING
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND
CHARGES OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY
OF CLEARWATER TO PROVIDE NEW GAS. RATES AND
SERVICE CHARGES FOR THE CLEARWATER GAS SYSTEM;
AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the current base gas rates and service charges of the
Clearwater Gas System have been effective for ten (10 ) years; and
WHEREAS, inflation has increased the cost of providing overall
gas service and competition in the energy field has necessitated a
review of the gas rate structure; and:
WHEREAS, the accounting firm of coopers & Lybrand L.L.P. was
~
J
I
I
~
t
i
t
t
~
~
"
:j
~
I;
'I
~
:;)
'i
;
11
,.
retained by th~ City to study these gas rates'and service charges
and to propose a more modern structure of rates which recovers from
each customer class the appropriate cost to serve that class; and
WHEREAS, it is determined to be fair and reasonable to adopt
the recommendations of Coopers & Lybrand and the Clearwater Gas
System to establish gas rates and service charges based on the cost
to serve the various classes of customers;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
"
;~
~
'j
section 1.
That Appendix A - Schedule of Fees, Rates and
"
,;
Charges of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Clearwater is
hereby amended as shown in Attachment 1 to make changes throughout.
-:.. ,
Sectlon 2. That Appendix A - Schedule of Fees, Rates and
Charges of the Code of Ordinances of the city of Clearwater is
hereby amended as shown in Attachment 2 to include a new section
XXVI. Clearwater Gas System Fees, Rates and Charges.
;i
'.
ti......rf'l.'.... ,"
section 3.
Should any se~.tion, paragraph, sentence or word
of this ordinance be declared for any reason to be invalid, the
same shall not affect the validity of the ordinance as a whole, or
any part thereof other than.the.part declared to.be invalid.
section 4.
All ordinances or parts of ordinances in
conflict herewith are to the extent of such conflict hereby
repealed.
section 5.
This ordinance shall become effective upon
adoption and shall be applicable for all gas bills and services
rendered on or after October 1, 1995.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
8- 3- 9 5
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
'READING AND ADOPTED
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
%
lJk4
Pamela K. Akin
city Attorney
.....l.' ~~ ..
L.
.IL..
ilL.
n:.
Y..:-
, YL..
VII.
VIII.
IX.
&
XI.
XI.L..
XIII.
XIV.
XY.:.
XVI.
XVII.
XVIII.
XIX.
XX.
XXI.
XXII.
XXIII.
XXIV.
XXV.
XXVI.
XXVII.
XXVIII.
APPENDIX A
ATTACHMENT.l
SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES.
Adul t Uses .. . . . .. . . . . . .. . .. . . . .
Amusements . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Anima ls . .. .... . .. .. . .. .. . . . .. .
Bathhouses and Massage Establishments . . .
Buildings and Building Regulations . . . . . .
Cemeteries . . . . . . . . . . .. ..
Erosion and siltation Control . . . . . . . . .
Land Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Fire Department Training Facility .....
Library . . . .. . . . . . . . .. .,.. '" 'II' .
Parks, Beaches, Recreation . . ! . . . . . . .
Peddlers, Solicitors and Canvassers . . . . . .
Police Department . . . . . . . .. ....
Public Transportation Carriers . . . .
R7creation and Open Land Space Dedication . . .
S ~ gn s . . . . . . . . . . . . " . . " . . . . .
site Plans, SUbdivision Plats, Land Use Plan and
Zoning Atlas Amendments, Conditional Uses, Variances,
and Certain Continuances . . . . . . . . . . .
Special Land Uses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
streets, Sidewalks, other PUblic Places
Taxation and other Fees . . . . . . . . . . . .
Traffic and Motor Vehicles . . . . . . . . . .
Transportation Impact Fee . . . . . . . . . . .
Tree Protection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Utilities - General Information & Deposits . .
Public Works utility Fees. Rates and Charqes
Clearwater Gas System Fees. Rates and Charqes
Waterways and Vessels . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Occupational License Fees . . .. .....
(
i
OLD-NEW . .
CDA:3 2
CDA:3 - 2.
CDA: 3 - 2
CDA: 3 - 2
CDA:3 3
CDA;B - 9
COA: 9 - 9
CDA:9 - 9
CDA:l1 - 12
CDA:l1 12
CDA:l1 - 12
CDA:14 - 15
CDA:14 - 15
CDA:15 - 16
CDA:15 - 16
CDA:15 - 17
CDA:15 - 17
CDA:17 - 19
CDA:17 - 19
CDA: 18 ;.. 2..0
CDA:18 - 20
CDA:19 - 21
CDA:19 - 21
CDA:19 - 22
CDA:?? - 24
CDA:?? - 47
CDA:40 - 47
CDA:?? - ??
.Editor's note -- The schedule in this appendix contains all of the
fees, rates~and charges, except for taxes, which are required in this Code of
Ordinances and/or by resolution.
Cross reference -- Occupational license fee schedule, .~ 29.58.
-1-
.1
tl~-::,~! 1 I '\
I'
.
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A.SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
Amount
','
'.
. 1.. ADULT USES:
(1)
Application fee for certificate of compliance or provisional certificate of compliance
$ 50.00
(2) Application fee for adult us~ license:
(a) Nonrefundable fee; if approved, 'fee will be credited to annual adult use license fee 100.00
(b) Fee for each additional adult use classification; if.approved, fee will be credited to annual
adult use license fee' 25.00
(c) Investigation fee for each individual listed in the application pursuant to Section
41.522(2)(11), City Code 25.00
(3) AMual adult use license fee:
(a) Adult theaters ($175.00 of. fee payable to Pinellas County Public Health Unit
(b) Other adult use classifications
(c) Each additional adult use classification
(Res. No. 93.74, ~ I, 11-18-93) -
11. AMUSEMENTS:
475,00
. 300.00
50.00
Coin-operated amusement devices:
Storage and hauling charge for seizure, per machine .(~ 7.26)
S 10.00
(1)
(2)
Permit fee, per location (~ 7.42)
10,00
ill. ANIMALS:
Beekeeping:
(1)
(2)
Permit fee (~ 8.61)
Renewal fee (~ 8.62)
5.00
2.00
IV, BATHHOUSES AND MASSAGE ESTABLISHMENTS:
Bathhouses: "
(1) Establishment permit fee (~ 9.32)
10.00
(2)
Bath technician permit fee (~ 9.37)
25.00
-2-
~\lt". ".
-
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
r
I
i
I:
I
I
f
Subject
Amount
y.... BUILDINGS AND BUILDING REGULATIONS (~ 47.087):
Permit fees and charges:
(1) Permits andfees. in general; exceptions:
(a)
~}
.~. \'
(c)
(d)
(e)
Permits are not required for carpeting. painting, wallpapering. tile, paneling over existing,walls..
and floor tile, nor where the valuation of labor. materiaJs, and all other items does not exceed
$500.00 and the work or operation is of casual, minor. inconsequential nature, and does not
violate any city codes or ordinances, or is exempt pursuant to Chapter 75-489, Laws of Florida
(Special Acts). Section 25: ,
Valuations for new construction and additions shaJI be based on the current Southern Building
Code Congress International's valuation tables. Other permits shall be based on contract value.
The building official may request a copy of signed contract if the value presented does not appear
to be in line with other permits of like work.
Where no fee is stated, the same shall not be interpreted as an intention to waive any requirement
for a permit that may be stated elsewhere in the'city's Code of Ordinances.
Demolition permits shall be issued at the fee set forth in this fee schedule. However, no fee shall
be required when the building or structure has been declared a hazard to public safety or welfare
by the building official. .
Prior to statting any electrical, gas, plumbing, mechanical, roofing or other work under a
combination permit, the contractor or the subcontractor engaged to do the work shall file with
the building services division a form showing the name and certification number of the
subcontractor doing the work, the subcontractor's Clearwater license number or occupational
license registration number, ,the number of the combination permit, the address where the work
is to be done, and oilier related information as may be required by the building services division.
Failure to file such form or provide such infonnation shalI be just cause for the refusal or'
inspection services, the issuance of a correction notice, and the assessment of the appropriate fee~
,
(2) Fee schedule. In the case of reviews, inspections and similar activities associated with building and related
codes not requiring a combination permit, the following schedule of fees shaH apply:
(a) Plan review fees: .
1.
2.
Building permit fee estimate
Consultation or special service fee. per hour
25.00
50.00
(b) Plans examination fee:
.~
1.
~
Multifamily and commercial. valuation:
a. $50,000.00 or less
Plus, per $ I ,000,00 of value or fractio thereof
12.50
3.00
b. Greater than $50.000.00, but not exceeding $250,000.00
Plus, per $ 1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof
in excess of S50,000.00
162,50
2.50
-3-
~;t ~ ~l-.l ,~ ..
ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
Suhjt!r:t
C. Greater than $250.000.00, but not exceeding $500,000.00
Plus, per $ 1 ,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in excess of $250.000.00
d. Greater than 5500,000.00. but not exceeding $750,000.00
Plus, per $ 1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in excess of
$500,000.00
e. ' $750,000.00 or greater ' .
Plus, per .$1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in excess of
$750,000.00
2.
3.
One- or two-family residential building, per building
For multiple identical single-family or two-family buildings in the same
project:
a.
b.
. First building
Each additional building
4.
Zoning plan review for new one- and two-family; additions, remodeling,
or new multifamily or commercial structures, per application
Flood. zone review, for structures located in flood zones A or Y, per
application
Threshold structures, per structure
5.
6.
(c) Plan amendments:
1.
Change to permitted planS. per hour
Minimum fee
Duplicate permit placards, each
Change of contractor, per contractor
2.
3.
(d) Certificates of occupancy:
1.
'.,
...
3.
4.
One- or two-family dwelling, per unit
Multifamily and commercial, per application
Conditional certificate of occupancy, per condition
Replacement or additional copy, except one- or two-family dwelling
(e) Special inspections:
1.
~
(t)
Refunds:
I
Change of use or HRS inspections. per trade
Maximum fee
After hours, weekends, per hour, per inspection
Minimum fee, per inspection
1.
Permits under $30,00, unless issued in error by city
-4-
Amount
662.50
2.00
1,162.50
1.50
1.537.50
1.00
75.00
75.00.
25.00
25.00
25.00
50.00
50.00
50.00
25.00
25.00
10.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
30.00
60.00
50.00
100.00
No refund
- 1
f
I.
t
I
J
!
i
I
r
I
!
> ~
'~~f'Io.~ .,' '"..,
"
.'
I '
A IT ACHMENT 1 .
APPENDIX A-SCHEDUL~ OF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES -
Subject
2.
3.
Amount
Work has commenced. or permit is over 90 days old No refund
All other pennits Refund of fee paid, less $30.00 or one-
half the fee. whichever is greater, to be
retained by the city
(g)
Permit fees:
1.
Per structure valuation:
a. $50,000.00 or less
Plus, per S 1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof
b. Greater than $50,000.00, but not exceeding 5250,000.00
Plus, per $ 1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in excess of
S50,OOO.00
C. Greater than $250,000.00, but not exceeding S500,OOO.00
Plus, per $ 1 ,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in excess of
S250,000.00
d. Greater than $500,000.00, but not exceeding
$750,000.00
Plus, per $ 1 ,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in excess of
$500,000.00
e. S750,000,00 or greater
Plus, per S 1 ,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in excess of
S750,OOO.00
!
I
I
II
: !
. 25.00
6.00
.1
j
I
f
I
I
325.00
5.00
1,325.00
4.00
2,325.00
3.00
3,075.00
2.00
This fee applies to the following types of permits, with additional costs of $30.00 per
trade as noted. Combination permits, subtrades (involve at least two of the following:
building, electric, plumbing, mechanical, roofing and gas):
2.
Building only
Electrical only
- Mechanical (may require electrical)
Gas only
\ Roof only
Aluminum structures (may require electrical)
Aboveground fuel tanks
Asbestos abatemtlnt
-5-
~': .. c .
,,:J,
.,
~.,,), ~"'<L,''''~
SubjeC1
.
'.
'1.
.1 '
I."" . ."".
,.' \ . ~,. .....:.,.
~, .-f.',:
.. ....,. ':~. \" .
I." . u . .." ,.
. ATIACHMENT 1 ' I
APPENDIX A~SCHEDULE OF FEESt RATES AND CHARGES J
Carports
Davits (may require electrical)
Decks
Docks (may require ele~trical)
Driveways
Plust for right-of~way permit
Fire alarms
Fire suppress~on systems
Fireplace
Fences
Hoods
lnground swimming pools (also require electrical and plumbing)
-6~
Amount
5.00
;........---.'i. ~'., ~I'. '\"..
. ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES. RATES AND CHAROES
Subjut
Amount
Underground fuel tanks (removal. replacement or new installation)
Walls (privacy and retaining)
(h) Miscellaneous permits:
1. Mobile home, mobile office, construction trailer, sales trailer, etc.
a.
Building pennit (tiedown and site placement)
Electrical permit
Gas permit
Plumbing permit
Mechanical permit
30.00
30.00
30.00
30.00
30.00
b.
c.
d.
e.
2.
3.
4.
Temporary power pole, not in conjunction with combination permit
Tent permit (may require electrical)
Demolition permit "
Plus, per square foot in excess of 1,000 square feet
(No fee charged when demolition is ordered by city)
30.00
30.00
50.00
0.05'
. i
. 5. House move:
a.
Application
Preinspection
Plus, per mile outside city
, Remodeling permit, for setting house on lot, per vio~ation:
40.00
50.00
0.30
b.
, c.
(i) 550,000.00 or less
Plus, per $1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof
25.00
6.00
(ii) Greater than 550,000.00, but not exceeding
$250,000.00
Plus. per S 1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in
excess of 550,000,00
325.00
5.00
(iii) Greater than S250,Ooo.oo, but not exceeding
$500,000.00 .
Plus. per S 1 ,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in
excess of 5250,000.00
1,325.00
4.00
\
(iv) Greater than $500,000.00, but not exceeding
$750,000.00
Plus, per $ 1,000.00 or value or fraction. thereof in
excess of $500,000.00
2,325.00
3.00
(v) .$750,000.00 or greater
Plus, per S 1,000.00 of value or fraction thereof in
excess of $750,000.00
3,075.00
2.00
-7-
Amount
1
I
,
1
i
I
I
1
I,
i
I:
j I
i
!
I
, ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES; RATES AND CHARGES
Subjt!Ct
6.
7.
Swimming pool permit, aboveground pool
Recertification of electrical service
(i)
Special fees:
1. Work not ready for inspection (reinspection fee):
a,
b.
First occurrence
Second or subsequent occurrence
2. . Followup on permit:
a.
b.
Failure to request inspections
Minimum fee
50 % of permit fee
, 30.00
3. After-the~fact permit:
a.
First occurrence
Second or subsequent occurrence by same contractor,
any job site in city
30.00
30.00
25.00
60.00
Triple permit fee
b.
10 times permit fee
(3) As used in these fee schedules, "combination permit" means a permit for construction
privileges, conditions and restrictions of a building permit, electrical permit, gas permit,
plumbing permit, mechanical permit, and roof permit (or some combination thereot), for
which proper approval has' been granted by the city and for which proper fees have been
paid.
FUingfeesfor appeals, Any application for an appeal to the construction/tlood board of adjustment and
. appeals, the city manager, or the city commission as provided for in chapter 47 shall be filed with the
building official, accompanied by a filing fee as follows:
(1)
Appeal to the construction/flood board of adjustment and appeals
(2) AppeaJ to L'1e city manager
(3) AppeaJ to the city commission
Developmen( impact fees: -
, ,-
(1) For all new buildings and structures, the applicant shaJl at the time the building permit
is issued pay a development impact fee as follows:
,
~( ) N .ct 'aJ . I . 'I d ,.
a ew rest enU structures, slOg e-taml y, apartment, con ommmrn or
mobile home, per unit
(b) New commerciaJ structures, for each 2,500 square feet of noor area or
fraction thereof
(c) New industrial structures, for each 5,000 square feet of Iloor area or
fraction thereof
-8-
125.00
50.00
t
!
!
I
l
I
~
I
125.00
250.00
I
i
I
I
!
i
1
.
I
,
I
I
;
j
1
J
,
250,00
250,00
;
!
,
l
- i
.'I!:
I'
I: '
~:~>
ATtACHMENT 1
APPENDIX ~~SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
1 ~
Subject
-
(d) New hotel or motel facilities:
I
!
I
I...
, '
,
Per unit
Commercial area other than units, for each 2,500 square
feet,of floor area or fraction thereof
1.
2.
; .
I'
I..
. (2) The funds derived from these fees shall be deposited in a special acc,ount to be used
exclusively for the construction of roads, public transit facilities and stonn drainage in
the~city, including actual construction costs, acquisition of right-of-way, the construction
of sidewalks, curbs, drainage structures and signal installations.,
(Ord. N.o. 5120, 9 3, 8-15~91)
.YL. CEMETERIES:
Purchase and conveyance of lots (~ 11.02):
(1)
Prices:
(a)
(b)
(c)
Infant space
Adult space
Urn space
I- -
! -
,
I'
i
(2)
Fees:
(a)
Staking fee: .
1. Weekdays
2. Saturdays, Sundays, leg,,:! holidays
oj
Amount
250.00
250.00
125.00
500.00
125.00
30.00
50.00
(b)
Consent to transfer of ownership, plus recording fee
(c) Recording fee, deed or consent to transfer
25.00
As provided by law
Y!L. EROSION AND SILT AnON CONTROL:
Fees for land clearing and grubbing permits are as follows (~ 50.21):
(1)
(2)
Land clearing and grubbing pennit
Reinspection fee; per additional inspection
I"
, .
~
(3) Speci~nspection fee
These fees shall be paid prior to the issuance of permits, and such fees shcll be nonrefundable.
(Res. No. 86~9, ~~ I, 2, 2-6-86)
VITI, LAND DEVELOPMENT:
-9-
10.00
25.00
25.00
'\
;,.........- ~.~,. .
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES.
SubjC!ct
AmoLlnt
There is hereby esmbl ished the following fees and charges relating to review and processing of site pians~
land use plan and zoning atlas amendments and subdivision plats, conditional uses. variances. appeals,
continuances, concurrency reviews and concurrency reviews, and development agreement reviews:
I
I
I'
Site plqn review (99 43.21-43.25):
(1)
Base charge for each site plan
Plus for each acre or fraction thereof
..
790.00
55.00
Revalidation of a certified site plan
150.00
(2)
(3)
Site plan amendment after certification (9 43.51)
150.00
(4) Transfer of development rights (9 42.06):
\.
(a)
(b)
With fonnal site plan review
Without fonnal site plan review
1.50.00
350.00
Subdivision plat review (99 46.31-46.38):
(1)
Base charge for each preliminary subdivision plat
Plus for each lot included on the plan
890.00
30.00
Revalidation if a certified preliminary subdivision plat
55.00
(2)
(3)
(4)
Subdivision plat amendment after certification. prior to recording
55.00
Administrative lot division
150.00
Anne.talion (937.05) and initial zoning and land use requests:
No. charge
(1)
Development agreement review
365.00
Land Use Plan (~ 36,066) and zoning arias (9 40.673) amendment requests:
(1) Base charge for each application for amendment of the zoning atlas 475.00
Plus for each county land use plan amendment 200.00
(2) Base charge for a zoning amendment and city land use plan amendment on the same property 685.00
(a) Plus for each county land use plan amendment
(b) ~lus for each property three acres or greater in size requiring state approval
Variance or conditional use applications:
100.00
200.00
(1) Variances:
1
J
!
,i
I
,
(a) Sign variances involving existing legal but nonconforming sign (9 44.09) (see also
-10-
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subjtct
Amount
There is hereby established the following fees and charges relating to review and processing of site plans,
land use plan and zoning atlas amendments and subdivision pl3:ts, conditional uses, variances, appeals,
continuances, concurrency reviews and concurrency reviews, and development agreement reviews:
Site plan review (99 43.21-41.25):
(1)
(2)
(3)
Base charge for each site plan
Plus for each acre or fraction thereof
790.00
55.00
Revalidation of a certified site plan
150.00
Site plan amendment after certification (9 43.51)
150.00
(4) Transfer of development rights (9 42.06):
(a)
(b)
With formal site plan review
Without formal site plan review
.
.
150.00
350.00
Subdivision plat review (99 46.31-46.38):
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Base charge for each preliminary subdivision plat
Plus for each lot included on the plan
890.00
30.00
Revalidation if a certified preliminary subdivision plat
55.00
Subdivision plat amendment after certification, prior to recording
55.00
Administrative lot division
150.00
Annexation (9 37.05) and initial zoning aiulland use requests:
(1)
No charge
Development agreement review
365.00
Land Use Plan (9 36.066) and zoning atlas (9' 40.673) amendment requests:
(1)
(2)
Base charge for each application for amendment of the zoning atlas
Plus for each county land use plan amendment
475.00
200.00
Base charge for a zoning amendment and city land use plan amendment on the same property
685.00
(a) . Plus for each county land use plan amendment '
(b) 'Plus for ea'ch property three acres or greater in size requiring state approval
100,00
200.00
Variance or conditional use applications:
(1) Variances:
(a) Sign variances involving ~xisting legal but nonconforming sign (9 44.09) (see also
-10-
-.
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
Amount
SIGNS)
50:00
For variance requests for which a continuance is required at the request of the applicant
or due to the applicanes failure to provide sufficient information for consideration of the
variar.cet an additional fee of $50.00 for each continuance shall be required.
(b)
(c)
Other variances for residentially zoned properties (9 4?22)
Other variances for nonresidentially zoned properties.(q 45.22):
200.00
. 1. Single variance request
2. Any additional request for variance with respect to the same property or
contiguous properties by the same owner
475.00
55.00
(2)
Conditional use (9 41.031)
475.00
(a)
Plus any additional request for conditio'nat use with respect to the same property or
contiguous properties by the same owner
, Plus for alcoholic beverage sales requests
55.00
210.00
(b)
1:xception A: Requests involving transfers of business ownership for which a conditional use permit has
previously been issued 350,00
-Exception B: Requests involving package sales of alcoholic beverages for indoor retail sales uses selling
alcoholic beverages 'as an accessory use and which either: (a) contain a minimum of 25,000 square feet
of gross floor area; or (b) sell alcoholic beverages only as part of a gift set in which the value of the
alcoholic beverages in the set is less than 50 percent of the value of the total set 100.00
(3)
Rehearings of variance or conditional use requests for which a trial period has been established by an
official city board or by the city commission None
(4) Variance or conditional use permits for construction that has been initiated or a use that has been
established prior to obtaining a required conditional use or variance approval double the
required fee
(from above)
. Appeal from planning and zoning board or development code adjusTment board to
hearing officer (~ 36.065) 365.00
(1)
(2)
Requests for a continuance of any review or other process which would result in additional advenising
. (~ 36.084) 55.00
. .
Concurrency ~view (9 36.148) 55,00
Plus for traffic impact study
55.00
Plus for vested rights determination
210.00
(Res. No. 92-38,9 I, 64~92; Res. No. 92-59, ~ 1,9-17-92; Res. No. 92-65,9 1, 11-5-92; Res. No. 92-77, ~
-11-
-
!
,
t
J
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
,......,.:..(.~~" ,",. . ~~~ -'.
ATI ACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF' FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
Amount
1, 12-17-92)
OC FIRE DEPARTMENT TRAINING FACILITY: .
Fee amount derennined Uy 'use agreement.
x... LIBRARY:
.
Fees for the use of the ciry library !Jy nonresidents are as follows (9 18.04):
(1) . Aruma! nonresident
100.00
A nonresident card may be used by any member of the immediate household of the person to whom the
card is issued.
(Res. No. 8842, S 2, 11-3-88; Res. No. 92.51~ !i 1, 8-13-92; Res. No. 94-34~ 7-21-94)
, \
XL. PARKS, BEACHES~ RECREATION:
Rental fees for parks and recreation facilities (ch. 22):
(1) User groups. There is hereby established the following categories of user groups upon which rental fees
. will be based for parks and recreation rental facilities, including public buildings (Martin Luther King
Center~ 'City Hall Annex, Memorial Civic Center, Sailing Center), the bandsheIl, swimming pools and
athletic fields: .
City related group:
No charge
.1
(a)
Cb>"
Cosponsored group:
1.00
(c) Outside group:
1. Public/civic/church. 'Hourly charges (Clearwater based only; non-
Clearwater based groups treated as private),
2. Private.. Basic rental charge, hourly charges, and equipment charges.
3. Commercial. Basic rental charges, hourly charges, equipment charges,
and ten percent of gross.
(2) Amounts of fees and charges. There is hereby established the following fees and charges relating to the
renlal of public buildings, the bandshell, athletic fields and swimming pools:
~ .
(a) 'Public buildings (Martin Luther King Ce~ter, Memorial Civic Center, City Hall Annex~
Sailing Center) and the bandshell: - ~
1.
Basic rental fees:
a. Sailing Center, per use times number of Jays
b. Other public buildings, per use times times number of days
c. Boat storage, per month plus tax
200.00
70.00
30.00
-12-
;~........; .... .
.
'(6)
, ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
Amount
d.
Dance floor rental, per use plus tax
90.00
2.
Hourly charge:
a. Utilities
b. Personnel, per employee:
i. Straight time
ii. Overtime
iii. City rate for off-duty police officer, (if necessary).
10.00 '
15.00
.10.00
3. Equipment charge for each piece of equipment used, per day (including
. but not limited to, piano, P .A. system, and spotlights) .
5.00
. I
, i
I
I
9.00 !
!
11.50
17.25
6.00
(b) Athletic fields:
1. Hourly charge:
a, Utilities
b. Personnel, per employer:
i. Straight time
ii. Overtime
c. Reservation fee, per hour (2 hour minimum)
(c) Swimming pools:
1.
2.
Basic rental fee, per use
Hourly charge:
a. Utilities
b. Personnel, per employee
60.00
8.00
7.50
I
!
;
,
,1
1
;
,
j
I
;
,
~
(3)
A cleaning deposit in the amount of 550.00 shall be paid in advance for the rental of the Sailing Center
to assure that the premises and equipment are returned in a clean and undamaged condition, as detennined
by the city.
The fees and charges established herein shall be paid to the City of Clearwater and shall be credited to
the parks and recreation department, except that fees for the Sailing Center shall be credited to the Marine
Department.
(4)
(5)
When applicable, a deposit of 530.00 shall be required to reserve any building (other than the Sailing
Center), bandshell or poot or S50.00 to reserve the Sailing Center, and S 12.00 to reserve an athletic
field. Said deposits shaH be submitted with the application and will be refunded only if the application
is not approved.
Thoseibrganizations or agencies which' have current separate facility agreements with the City of
Clearwater shall be exempt from this resolution.
,
:,
~
~
!
Use of facUlries by nonresidenrs (ch. 22):
(1) Effective January I, 1994, nonresidents who wish to use city recreation facilities or programs may do
so by paying one or more of the following fees:
-13-
-
.~IY.'";:
... !
1.
2.
Annual individual fee, valid from January 1 through December 31
Annual f~ily fee, valid from January 1 through D~cember 31
Note: An individual card may be used only by the person to whom it is
issued. The family fee provides a card for each family member residing
at the household.
56.00'
140.00
II
I,
I
I
~
!
I
I
I
_ A 'IT ACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A.SCHEDULE OF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
Subjt!ct
Amount
(a)
Card options:
(b) Options in lieu of nonresident card purchase:
1.
2.
Daily guest fee at all tennis facilities
Admission fees for open swim programs only at all city swimming pools:
3.00-
a. Children 17 years of age and under:
L Wimer
ii. Summer'
2.00
1.50
b. Adults 18 years of age and over:
i. Winter
iLSummer
3.50
2.50
r
3. Class/program fee plus 50 percent additional for activities offered on a
session basis.
4. Single season fee for adult athl~tic leagues, per person
5. .... S~ngle admission fee (exception. 'city pools) plus an additional 25 percent.
6. . Participant fees for activities/programs conducted by the recreation
deparnnent staff that are free to residents: .
33.00
Where practicable, fees may be charged to nonresident panicipants.
7.
In co-sponsoring programs where leadership is provided by noncity
employees:
a. Participants .of youth programs, per activity
b. Family participants of youth programs, 3 or more
c. Participants of adult programs, per activity
10.00
25.00
20.00
j
I
i
i
i
~
\ 8. Lawnbowls, shuffleboard and horseshoe clubs:
"\
Per year for each Chlb; due January 1st of each _year
100.00
(2) The criteria which establish the class of city residentS for the purpose of the fees above and Resolution
No. 88-43 are:
(a) Permanent residence within the incorporated boundaries of the city;
-14-
.1
.'
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE.oF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subjtct
Amount
(b) Ownership of real property within the incorporated boundaries of the city, as evidenced by the
official tax rolls maintained by the county;
(c) Tourists and guests- temporarily residing at properties within the incorporated boundaries of the
city; or , '
(d) Persons who are employees of the city, their spouses and children who live at home.
(3) In programs where rentals are charged, or where enforcement is impractical, or a majority of the facilities
used by a program 'are provided in a municipality other than. Clearwater, the nonresident fee is not
required.
(Res. No. 88-43, ~~ 2-4, 11.3-88; Res. No. 90-49, ~~ 1-5,.12-20.90; Res. No. 91-46, ~ 1, 12-19-91;
Res. No. 91-47, 9 1, 12-19-91; Res. No. 93-61,. 9 1, 10-18-93; Res. No. 93-71, 9 1, 11-29-93)
XI!.. PEDDLERS, SOLICITORS AND CANVASSERS:
Peddlers applicationfee (~ 23.33(5))
(1)
(2)
25.00
Charitable organization registration fee (9 23.81)
10.00
ZIIL. POLICE DEPARTMENT:
Fees for pennits and repon requests processed by the police deparrment:
(1) Solicitor permits (~ 23.81)
(2) Ta:d permits (~ 25.071) (see aJso PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION CARRIERS)
10.00
10.00
(3) Vehicle for hire permits (925.171)
10.00
(4) Taxicab/public conveyance vehicle permit sticker
2.00
(5) Handbill distribution permits (9 3.41)
10.00
(6) Street artist I.D.
10.00
(7) Amusement machine permits (99 7.26, 7,42)
10.00
(8) . Cabaret cards
5.00
(9) Letters of good conduct
,
(10) Bank e~ployee I.D. processing
(11) Fingerprinting:
3.00
5.00
(a)
(b)
One card
Additional cards, ~3ch
3.00
1.00
-15.
ft....,.....,... _ _, .
_ ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEESJ RATES AND CHARGES
Subjut
(12) *Auto accident report copies
(13) *Event report copies
(14) *Other report copies
(15) Record checks by mail
(16) Black and white ph~tographs:
(a) Four by five
(b) Five by seven
(c) Eight by ten
(17) Color photographs:
(a)
(b)
(c)
Four by five
Five by seven
Eight by ten
.Up to six pages; additional pages, per page .
(Res. No. 84-1, ~ 2, 1*19-84; Res. No. 85-42, ~ I, 6~-8S)
XIV, PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION CARRIERS:
Taxicab operators pennitfee (~.25.082) (see also J'OLICE DEPARTMENT)
..
I
XV. RECREATION AND OPEN SPACE LAND DEDICATION:
(1)
Recreation facilities impact fee, per dwelling unit (9 54.23)
(2) Open space impacr fee:
(a) All new development and annexation, if applicable, shall be assessed an open space land
impact fee equal to four percent of the net land area of the project or an amount of
money equal to four percent of the land value.
(b) For the expansion of existing projects, the open space I.and impac;t fee'shall be computed
as follows:
\1.
~
For nonresidential uses the assessment shall equal two percent of the net
land are~ of the entire project or an amount of money equal to two
percent of,the land value.
2. For, residential uses the assessment shall equal four percent of the net
land area attributable to the expanded number of units or an amount of
money equal to four percent of the land value.
-16-
L..-
Amount
2.00
2.00
2.00
2.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
3.00
4.00
6.00
0.25
25.00
200.00
...,., '-" , .
.1. ..
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subj~ct
(Code 1980. 99 116.43t 116.49)
XYL. SIGNS:
Application fees for sign permits are. as follows (9 44.31):
(1)
Per square foot of sign faceage
Amount
0.40
(a) Minimumt per sign 20.00
(b) If sign is electrified, additional per sign 20.00
(c) If the sign has been located. placedt erected, constructed. altered or extended without a
sign permit having been obtained for such work, except as provided in subsection
44.31 (1). and if such work otherwise complies with the sign regulations of the city. the
applicant shaH pay,treble the amount of the permit fee for such work. in addition to such
other penalties as may be imposed.
(See also LAND DEVELOPMENT for sign variance applicatio'n fee)
(Res. No. 86-66, 9 I, 10-16-86)
XY.IL. SITE PLANS, SUBDIVISION PLATS, LAND USE PLAN AND ZONING ATLAS
AMENDMENTS, CONDITIONAL USES. VARIANCES. AND CERTAIN CONTINUANCES:
(1) Site plan review:
(a)
Base charg~ for each site plan
Plus
1. For each -acre. or fraction thereof
.:"
(b) Revalidation of a cenified site plan
(c) Site plan amendment (after certification)
(d). Transfer of development rights:
1. With fonnal site plan review
2. Without formal site plan review
(2) Subdivision plat review:
(a) Base charge for each preliminary subdivision plat
Plus
1. For each lot included on the plan
. (b) ~ Revalidation if a cenified preliminary subdivision pl:u
~ .
(c) Subaivision plat amendment (after certification. prior to recording)
(d) Administrative lot division
(3) Annexation and initial zoning and land use requests:
(a) Base charge for each application for an agreement to annex or annexation and initial
zoning designation (including an individual existing or proposed single-family dwelling
-17-
I
250.00
50.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
350.00
250'.00
25.00
50.00 '
50.00
150'.00
r" '~H .
i.
(4)
I ~
I.
'.
I
(6)
(7)
(8)
_ ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE.QF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
Amount
unit)
No Charge
lAnd use plan and zoning alias amendment requests:
(a) Base charge for each application for amendment of the zoning atlas 250.00
(b) Base charge for :;l zoning amendment and city land use plan amendment on the same
property 250.00
Plus
1. For each amendment. requiring state approval . 100.00
(5) Variance or conditional use requests;
(a)
Variances: . .
1. Sign variances involving existing nonconforming sign age
2. Other variances for residentially zoned properties
3. Other variances for nonresidentiaJly zoned properties:
Single variance request
Plus- ..
4. ' Any additional request for variance with respect to the same property or
contiguous properties by the same owner
50.00
50.00
100.00
200.00
(b)
200.00*
Conditional use
Plus
L Any additional request for conditional use with respect to the same
property or contiguous properties by the same owner
2. For alcoholic beverage sales requests
*Exception A: Requests involving transfers of business ownership for
. which a conditional use permit has previously been issued
*Exception B: Requests involving package saleS of alcoholic beverages
for indoor retail sales uses selling alcoholic beverages as an accessory
use and which either: (a) contain a minimum of 25,000 sq. ft. of gross
floor area; or (b) sell alcoholic beverages only as part of a "gift set" in
which the value of the alcoholic beverage(s) in the set is less: than 50%
of the value of the total set
50.00
200.00
350.00
100.00
(c) Rehearings of variance or conditional use requests for which a "trial period" has been
established by an official city board or by the city commission None
(a) Appeal from planning and zoning board or development code adjustment board to hearing
officer 365.00
(b) Appeal from planning and zoning board to city commission 50.00
\.
Requests for a_ continuance of any review or other process which would result in additional
advenising 50.00
Concurrency review
50,00
Plus
(1) For traffic imp3ct study
50.00
-18-
,~:n~. .' ... , .
ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Ii
Subject
Amount
(2)
For vested rights determination
200.00
(9)
Development agreemenr review
365.00
(Res. No. 94-28, 9 1, 5-19-94; Res. No. 94-52, 9 1, .10-6-94; 'Res. No. 95-14, 9 1, 1-19-95)
-
XVlll, SPECIAL LAND USES:
Alcoholic beverage establislunenrs:
Fee for application for variance from separation requirements (9 41.091)
125.00
(Res. No. 88-4, 9 1, 1-21-88)
XI;h STREETS, SIDEWALKS, OTHER PUBLIC PLACES:
Fees for services provided by the depanment of public works (ch. 28):.
(1) Petition to vacate street 200.00
(2) Petition to vacate alley 200.00
(3) Petition to vacate pedestrian walkway 175.00
(4). Petition to vacate easement 150.00
(5) Petition to vacate other 150.00
(6) Street name change 200.00
(7) Address (house number) change 100.00
(8) Utility permit/other uses of ROW/driveway pennit:
This fee schedule shall not apply to action initiated unless required by the city commission.
~ '
Penniifee to conduct race utilizing public rights-aI-way, per panicipanr
0.25
!
I
I
j
J
:\
I
I
I
!
J
1
(a) No inspection required
(b) Inspection required
(c) - Failure to obtain ROW permit before starting work
0.00
,20.00
Double fee
(9) Final subdivision inspection and reinspection
50.00
(1) The city manager may require the applicant to pay the charge as a deposit based upon the estimated
number of participants and may deny the permit if the applicant refuses to pay such d~posit.
(2) TIle charge shall be remitted by the applicant within two weeks following the race evenr. if a deposit has
-19-
.
n....'...T1 ,..
-
Amount
!
}
I
!
~
_ . ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject '
not been required. If a deposit has been required, any underpayment shaH be remitted or any overpayment
shall be returned to the applicant within ten days after receipt of the affidavit provided for in subsection
(3) below. .
All applicants for spechil event pennirs to conduct a race shalt provide in affidavit form at the time of
payment of the charges or a request for refund of overpayment, a statement identifying the event and the
number of persons that participated in the event.
(3)
(Res. No. 82-3, 9 1, I-~4-82; Res. No. 84-72, 8-1.6-84)
X& TAXATION AND OTHER FEES:
(1)
Occupational license tax:
(a) Registration fee for persons not maintaining a permanent business (9 29.30(3))
(b) Duplicate license' fee (9 29.33)
(c) Transfer fee (9 29.38(1), (2))
(2)
Interim proprietary and general services fee. per unit, per month, initially (9 29.95)
XAL. TRAFFIC AND MOTOR V1;HICLES:
(1) Impoundment of vehicles (9 30.080):
I'
(a)
Charges for towing:
(b)
Anywhere within the city between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.:
a. __ Regular wrecker pickup
b. If dolly required . .
Anywhere within the city between the hours of 5:00 'p.m. and 8:00 a.m.:
a. Regular wrecker pickup
b. If dolly required
Towtruck: at scene over one hour, each addition;1.l hour
More than one wrecker or toWtrUck at scene:
a. Each additional wrecker or towtruck during daylight hours
b. Each additional wrecker or towtruck during hours of darkness
Storage charges:
1.
"
-. ,
3.
4.
, .
1. Outside storage, per 2~hour period or fraction thereof
2. Inside storage, per 24-hour period or fraction thereof
(2) aea~ater Pass Bridge (9 30.161):
- ,
(3). The following toll rates are hereby ildopted for the use of Clearwater Pass Bridge:
1. Two-axle vehicles, including motorcycles and mopeds
2. Two-axle vehicle, including mOlOrcycles. mopeds and buses, public
agency; token system, two tokens for
3. 111ree-axle vehicles
, -20-
25.00
10.00
3.00
25.00
40.00
25.00
50.00
25.00
35.00
35.00
35.00
?
8.00 - Ij
~}
10.00
,1
l
J
1:
,
"
0.75
0,25
1.00
~~.;t({'~: .,,~ ..~ .
, A IT ACHMENT 1
AJ.>PENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
f
I:
I
Subject .,
4. Four-axle vehicles
5. Five-axle vehicles
6. Each additional axle
7. Buses, private
8. . PSTA buses
9. . . Jolley Trolley
10. Pedestrians
, 11. Employees of city on official business
12. County park employees on official business
13. Emergency vehicles on emergency calls
14. Employees of the Florida Department of Transportation working on the
Clearwater Pass bridge replacement project
(b) The rate schedule established in this section shall not be revised except in the manner
provided by section 15E of Ordinance No. 3932 of tile city.
(c) . The city manager or, in his absence, the chief of police is hereby authorized to waive !he
tolls established in this section when in the exercise of his discretion it is determined that
such waiver is necessary because of emerg'ency conditions.
,COrd. No. 5664-94, 9 1, 9-1-94)
Amount
1.25
1.50
0.25
1.75
0.10
0.10
Exempt
Exempt
Exempt
Exempt
Exempt
XXIL. TRANSPORTATION IMPACT FEE: Pinellas County Ordinance No. 86-43, administered by the city,
assesses a
. fee on new land development or a change in land use. This fee is based upon the increase in vehicular
traffic generated by new development or land use.' .
xxm. TREE PROTECTION:
Removal:
(1) Permit fee (9 52.32):
(2)
(3)
(4)
For removal of 1-5 trees
Per tree over 5
Fee tor appeal following denial of permit (9 52.34)
Reinspectiori fee, per additional inspection
Special~nspection fee
These fees shall be paid prior to the issuance of permits, and such fees shall be nonrefundable.
(Res. No. 86-9, 99 1, 2, 2-6~86; R~. No. 93~32, !i 1, 8-30-93) .
-21-
15.00
I
I
j
I
!
I
I
!
I
j
I
i
l
i
,
~I
j
i
I
l
I
!
J
,
I
i
3.00
25.00
25.00
25.00
;.
-;'1.",
, , AITACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subjt!Ct ..
Amount
XXIV. UTILITIES - General & DeDosits:
Deposits and 'lenera/ utility infonnation, fees, charges s.wi T-dU: schcd-u!-cs (9 32.068):
(1) General/y. The" public works department will furnish and install water and gas service connections and
tap the mains. as well as provide solid waste. wastewater collection and stormwater management services,
for residential, commercial, business and other purposes. The city will charge for such service
connections and installation according to a schedule of fees to be established by ordinance, in the form
of an amendment to this appendix. The Clearwater Gas System (CaS) will furnish and install natural anq
12ro9ane rLP) eas service for residential. g-eneral service (tyVicalIy commerciall business). interruotible
(typically industrial), street liehting. gas air conditioninl? gas vehicles and other t)urooposes. CGS will
urovide !!:as service connections and tap I!as mains. to serve customers/'Dotential customers where it is
determined by CGS management as being- feasible. Gas" service fees shall be uniformlv administered not
only within the City of Clearwater but also throughout cas's extended service territorY in northern
Pinellas County and Southwestern Pasco County accordine: to a schedule of fees established by City of
Clearwater ordinance as approved bv the Clearwater City Commission. in the form of an amendment to
this appendix. All charges to the premises shall be madt! and shall be payable according to the schedule
at the time application is made, whether or not an amending ordinance has been 'codified in this appendix
at the time of the application.
(2) Deposits for service:
(a) Water:
1. Domestic water service. Each meter service shall be secured by a minimum deposit of
$30.00 or three times the minimum monthly charge or three times the average monthly
-bill for domestic water service, whichever is greatest.
2.
Lawn water service. Each lawn meter service shall be secured by a minimum deposit
of $30.00 or three times the minimum monthly charge or three times the average monthly.
bill for lawn water service, whichever is greatest.
~
,
,
I
,
"
\
~J
3.
Temporary potable service. Temporary potable service shall be secured by a deposit
according to the following table:
:;
.~:
Less than 1" meter 80.00
1" meter 160;00
~
500.00 .,
1 112" meter .,
'c
~
\ 2" meter 900.00 ,
3" meter 1,250.00
4-" meter 2,500.00
4, T~mporary nonpotable service.. Temporary nonpotable water or "hydrant meter" service
~22~
.
ATTACHMENT t
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subjl!ct
Amount
shaH b~ secured by a minimum deposit of 5500.00 plus an amount sufficient to cover the
cost of water consumed and any other charges incurred. Such service will be provided
by a temporary meter on a fire hydrant. Charges will be at the same rate as for a two-
inch lawn meter. The final bill shall be for a sum equal to the minimum charge, the cost
of water consumed, and a service charge of 525.00.
5. Domestic water service, one week ma.ximum. Domestic water service for not more than
seven,consecutive days, upon application by prc;>perty owner 01' the owner's agent, shall
be secured by a deposit of S65.oo.
6. Dome:stic water service, three-day maximum. Domestic water service for not more than
three consecutive days, upon application by propeny owner or the owner's agent, shall
be secured by a deposit of 540.00.
(b) Gas. Each meter serviee account/9rernise served bv ga'i shaH be secured by a minimum deposit
of S20.OO or three times the average monthly bill for gas service, whichever is greater. Initial
sine:le- family residential deposits with no prior consumption historY shall be set at 550.00.
InitiaJ non-residential or multi-family residential '.cIeoosits shall be set at three times the average
monthlv bill as proiected bv the Gas Sales Representative based on the customer's equipment and
the planned use of this eauipment. The initial deposit mav be set at less than the normal three
month level upon demonstratiQ!1 of being in business for two vears or more or otherwise
providing satisfactory credit worthiness and by executing a special deoosit/9ayment agreement
approved bv the City Manae:er which orovides for a more raoid oayment schedule than normal.
(c) Solid waste. Each customer shall be secured by a minimum. deposit of three times the minimum
monthly charge for solid waste collection service.
Cd) Wastewater collection. Each customer shall be secured by a minimum deposit of three times the
minimum monthly charge or three times the average monthly bill for wastewater collection
service, whichever is greater.
(e) Deposits of cash equivalents to guarantee payment of bills. Commercial depo-sits in excess of
51,000.00 may be made by a surety bond. written by an insurance company authorized to do
business in the state, or through furnishing a letter of credit from a bank, by making an
assignment to the city of a savings and loan investment certificate or passbook, or a commercial
bank savings or time deposit certificate, the fonn for which shall be approved by the city
attorney.
(t) Housing authorities. A housing authority created pursuant to F.S. ch. 421 may fulfill deposit
requirements for the agency or tenants of the agency by letter of agreement to be financially
responsible for the required deposit or portion thereof.
(g) Determin3tion of average monthly bill. For the purpose of determining the amount of any
deposit based upon the average monthly bill, the average monthly bill shall be detennined
according to actual consumption at the premises, regardless of changes in ownership or
occupancy of the premises. during the preceding 12 months of actual consumption. For new
. premises without a prior service history, the deposit for each service shaJl initially be the specific
~.amount required above or three times the minimum monthly charge, whichever is greater. At
the end of the tirst six months of service, an average monthly bill for aJI services shaH be
determined according to consumption at the premises during the first six months of service and
the deposit shaJI be recalculated. If the recalculated deposit is less than 90 percent of the deposit
paid by the customer, the difference between the deposit paid and the recalculated deposit shaJI
be credited to the aCt:ount; provided, however, that the total deposit retained by the city shull be
not less than the sum of the specitic amounts required above or three times the minimum monthly
-23-
'F
, ATfACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subj~ct
Amoulll
charges, whichever is greater, for each service. If the recalculated deposit is greater than 110
percent of the deposit paid by the customer, the difference between the deposit paid and the
recalculated deposit shall be charged against the account:
(h) Re~alculation of deposits.
.'
1. The amount of a required deposit may be reviewed and adjusted based upon actual
consumption at the end of the customer's initial six months of service' or most recent 12
months of service, upon request of the customer.
2. The city may incrense the deposit requirement on any account to three times the current
monthly average bill at any time should that account be in arrears, or if the customer has
presented a subsequently,dishonored check for payment or has had more than two past
due reminders in any consecutive 12-montb period.
(i) Refund of deposits. The deposit for a residential or community service organization account"with
an individual meter shall be returned after two continuous years of good account experience. For
the purpose of this paragraph and for subsection m below, "good account experience" means not
more than two past-due reminders in any twelve-month period, no disconnection of service for
nonpayment, no dishonored checks,. no evidence of meter tampering, and no evidence of
fraudulent use of the utilities system.
(j) Deposit requirement exemption. Except for temporary service, an applicant for service to a
residential or community service organization account with an individual meter shaH be exempt
from the deposit requirement if the applicant presentS written verification from a public utility
that the applicant has had good account experience during the most recent 12-month period, or
the last 12~month period of service by the public utility if occurring within the preceding 24
months. However, if the account should at any time be in arrears, or if the customer should
receive more than two. past-due reminders in any 12-month period or present a subsequently
dishonored check, or in the event of meter tampering or fraudulent use of the utilities system by
-the customer, the city may require a deposit in the amount required for a new account.
(k) Interest on deposits. Interest on deposits held by the city shall accrue beginning as of October
I, 1992. The interest rate shall be an index rate established as of October I each year, and the
index rate shall remain in effect through the next September 30, The index rate shall be the
three-month average of two-year Treasury security yields for the period from July 1 through
September 30 immediately preceding the fiscal year in which the index rate is applicable. Interest
accruing from October I, 1992, through September 3D, 1993, shall be the three-month average
of two~year Treasury security yields for the period from July 1 through September 30, 1992.
Thereafter, the index rate shall be annually recalculated and effective from October 1 through the
following September 30. Annual payment wilt occur as a credit posted to the customer's account
commencing with the first bill rendered on or after October I, 1993, and each October 1
thereafter, A customer who posts a deposit after October 1, 1992, will receive interest calculated
from the deposit date and credited to the account on each October 1 for as long as the city retains
the deposit. A customer who terminates service, or whose service is terminated, will receive a
~pro.rated interest credit to the termination date on the tinal bill. A customer who qualifies for
"i a deposit refund will receive a pro.rated interest credit to the refund date. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, an interest payment or deposit refund i"n an amount less than $1.00 may be paid in
cash but shall not be mailed.
XXV, PUBLIC WORKS. FEES, RATES AND CHARGES (~jj ,\I~~ ')
f.JJffilmpacr fees:
J
"
.'
"1
-24-
I
~I'" il'"
. A IT ACHMENT 1
A~PENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES ".
j:
Subj~r:t
AmOUIll
(3) Water. There is hereby imposed a water impact fee, based on the capital portion of the cost of
financing the extension of the city's water system, on the single-family residential unit or
equivalent single-family residential unit, or equivalent living unit, which is re.~ponsible for
creating the need for additional water system financing. The obligation for payment of the fee
shall occur at ~e tim,e the first building or plumbing permit is issued. The water impact fee shall
be payable at the building division at the time the flfst building or' plumbing permit is issued, as
follows:
1. Residential accounts.
. Single-family, duplex, and multifamily residential,' regardless of the form of ownership,
and mobile homes, per unit 480.00
2. Each nonresidential account will, for the purpose of establishing the water impact fee,
be considered to comprise 3 number of equivalent living units based upon the size of
water meter required to serve the account. The water impact fee shall be 5480.00 for
each equivalent living unit. Equivalent Iivi.ng units and fees shall be determined according
to the following table:
Meter Size Equivalent Living Water Impact
(inches) Unit Fee
Less than 1 1 S 480.00
1 2.5 1,200.00
1 1/2 5 2,400.00
2 8 3,840.00
3 Compound 15 7,200.00
4 Compound 25 12,000.00
6 Compound 50 24,000.00
3 Turbo 17.5 8,400.00
4 Turbo 50 24,000.00
6 Turbo 100 48,000.00
3.
Each additional unit or equivalent living unit occasioned by changes in property usage
subsequent to April 1, 1990, shall be subject to a water impact fee computed in
accordance with subsection (3)(a) 1. or (3)(a)2., above, whichever is applic<tble. If a
building pennit is issued for an existing connection which will increase water demand,
the total number of units or equivalent living units for the old and new parts of the
structure shall be computed in accordance with subsection (3)(a)1. or (3)(a)2. above. The
number of new units or equivalent living units shall be determined by subtracting the
number of old units or equivalent living. units in the entire structure from the total
number of units or equivalent living units. ,The water impact fee will be assessed on the
remaining number of new units or equivalent living units.
II
~
4. Whenever any work for which an impact fee required by this subsection has been
commenced without tirst paying such fee, then such fee shall be tripled.
5. New lawn meters shaH be assessed by meter size as follows:
-25-
:.'+'-' '.1' ~ "1 ..
_ _ A TIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
AmoUnt
Meter Size
(inches)
Water Impact
Fee
Less than 1
1
2-1 in manifold
1 1/2
2
3 compound
4 compound
6 compound
3 turbo
4 turbo
6 turbo
5 70.00
175.00
. 350.00
350.00
560.00
1,050.00
1,750.00
3,500.00
1,225.00
3,500.00
7,000.00
, (b)
Storm drainage. See the building code adop~ed in chapter 47.
(c) Wastewater impact fees. Payable at the building division at the time the tirst building or plumbing
p~rmit is issued:
1. Residential accounts.
Single-family, duplex, and multifamily residential (regardless of the form
of ownership), and mobile homes, per unit
900.00
. 2.
Each nonresidential account wiJI, for the purpose of establishing the
wastewater impact fee, be considered to comprise a number of equivalent
single-family residential UIlits or equivalent living units based upon the
size of the water meter or meters required to serve the account. The
wastewater impact fee shall be 5900.00 for each equivalent living unit.
Equivalent living units and 'fees shall be determined according to the
following table:
.
"
Meter Size Equivalent Living Units Wastewater
(inches) Impact Fee
Less than 1 1 $ 900.00
1 2.5 2,250.00
~ 1 1/2 5 4,500.00
~ 2 8 7,200.00
I " 3 Compound 15 13,500.00
I
4 Compound 25 22,500.00
6 Compound 50 45,000.00
3 Turbo 17.5 15,750.00
4 Turbo 50 45,000.00
6 Turbo 100 90,000,00
-26-
...
-
.':'J'"T'" '. ~~.
ATIACHMENT I
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Ii
I
I
I
I
Subject Amount .
3. Each additional unit or equivalent living unit or part thereof, occasioned by changes in.
property usage subsequent to April 1, 1990. shaH be subject to a wastewater impact fee
computed in accordance with the rates set forth in subsection (3)(c) 1. or (3)(c)2. above.
whichever is applicable. If a,building permit is issued for an existing connection which
wiJI increase wastewater collection demand, the total number of units or equivalent Hving
units for the old and new partS of the facility shall be computed according to subsection
(3)(c)1. or (3)(c)2. above. The number of new units or equivalent Hying units shall be
detei'mined by subtracting the number of old units or equivalent living units in the entire
facility from the total number of units or equivalent living units. The wastewater impact
fee will be assessed on the remaining number of new units or equivalent living units. -
~Connection charges. fees and taps on mains. The following charges and fees shaH be payable to the city
upon application: .
(a) Water meter connection charges and fees for taps on water mains, backtlowprevention device
installations, and fire taps on water mains; fire hydrant installation charges:
.
Water Meter Connection Charges
Less than I" meter with 3/4" service line
S 210.00
1" meter with I" service line
280.00
1 1/2" meter with 1 1/2" service line
530.00
2" meter with 2" service line
700.00
3" meter on 6" main (4" tap)
2,950.00
3" meter on S" main (4" tap)
2,965.00
3" meter on 10" main (4" tap)
2,985.00
3.035.00
3.085.00
3,130.00
3" meter on 12" main (4" tap)
3" meter on 16" main (4" tap)
3" meter on 20" main (4" tap)
!
I.
~4" meter on 6" main
~
4" meter on 8't main
3.255.00
3.270.00
4" meter on 10" main
3,290.00
4" meter on 12" main
3,340.00
-27-
.....,' .
~N"'ri""", ,
,. -/I. ~, ,.,
.'. ".
_ Arr ACHMENT I
~PEND[X A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES '
Subject
Amount
4" meter on 16" main
3,390.00
4" meter on 20" main
3J435.00
I.:arger meters and taps shall be charged at cost.
All charges for services, pipe and meters outside the city limits shall be.25 percent additi?nal.
Taps an Water Mains
2" tap on 2" main 260.00
. 2" tnp on 4" main 315.00
2" tap on 6" main 330.00
2" tap on 8" main 335.00
2" tap on 10" main 390.00
2" tap on 12" main 390.00
2" tap on'16" main 470.00
2" tap.on 20" maill 470.00
"'4" tap on 4" main . . 920.00
4" tap on 6" main 935.00
4" tap on 8" main 955.00 1
I
1
4" tap on 10" main 1.070.00
,
4" tap on 12" main 1,125.00
I
4" tap on 16" main 1.275.00
(
t
J
4" 'tap on 20" main 1,325.00 i
\
, f
\" tap on 6" main 1,130.00
~
6" tap on 8" main 1,195.00 i
i
i
6" t:Jp on 10" main 1,255.00 !
1
6" tap on 12" main 1,355.00
.28-
..
~~~:j.~. "_H.~,
J ",
u"
1
1
I
, ATIACHMENr- 1
A,PPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
. <
Subject Amount
6" tap on 16" main 1,455.00
6" tap on 20" main 1,670.00
8" tap on 8" main 1,270.00
8" tap on 10," main 1,41~.OO
8" tap on 12" main 1-,475.00
8" tap on 16" main 1,555.00
8" tap on 20" main ' 1,770.00
12" tap on 12" main 2,060.00
,
12" tap on 16" main , 2,205.00
12" tap on 20" main 2,365.00
-.
.'
. '
All charges for services, pipe and meters outside the city limits shaH be 25 percent additional.
Backjlow Prevention Device Instal/ation
Charges for furnishing and installing reduced-pressure (RP) or double-check (DC) backtlow
prevention devices, when required by city ordinance, are as follows:'
'.~
,.
Size
(inches)
New Customers
Single Parallel
DC DC
Single
RP
Parallel
RP
3/4
S 210.00
S 355.00
$ 260.00
$ 460.00
3/4 (below ground, in box:
required with lawn meter)
1
320.00
N/A
N/A
N/A
225.00
385.00
285.00
500.00
1
..
1 (belowground, in box:
required' with lawn meter)
1~
2
335.00
N/A
N/A
N/A
320.00
595.00
420.00
785.00
395.00
770.00
495.00
975.00
3
1,280.00
1,710.00
2,560.00
3,165.00
1,485.00
1,960.00
2.970.00
4
3,700.00
.29-
~ <. :
1~"b ~>- '".
I'
',.'
_ . ATfACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A~SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES.
-[
I
I
I
I
Subject Amount
6 2.345.00 4.560.00 2,655.00 5,180.00
8 3.910.00 7,650.00 4,755.00 9.335.00
Standard installation is above ground.
Existing Customers
Size' Single Parallel Single Parallel
(inches) DC DC RP RP
3/4: s 100.00 S 200.00 S 140.00 S 280.00
3/4 (belowground, in box 210.00 N/A N/A N/A
required'with lawn meter)
1 105.00 210,00 145.00 290.00
1 (belowground. in box 215.00 N/A N/A N/A
required with lawn meter)
1 1/2 235.00 470.00 315.00 630.00
2 285.00 570.00 365.00 730.00
3 1,140.00 2.280,00 1.370.00 2,740.00
4 1,255.00 2.510.00 1.560.00 3.120.00
6 1.775.00 3.550,00 2,305.00 4,610.00
8 2,975.00 5,950.00 3,680.00 7,360.00
Standard installation is aboveground.
'I
I:
I
I
:'
)
I
\,
Additional Fees for Detector Check and Double Detector Check
Installation on Fire Lines, exclusive of any required tap
and charge for such tap
,
New eustoniers
2" single detector check with 5/8" bypass meter
4" double detector check with 5/8" bypass meter
6" double detector check with 5/8" bypass meter
8" double detector check with I" bypass meter
S 900.00
2.150.00
2,680.00
3,730.00
-30-
.~":-..:; 0, .
ATr ACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subjt!a
Amount
Existing Customers
2" single detector check with 5/8" bypass meter 835.00
4" double detector check with 5/8" bypass meter 1,490.00
6" double detector check wilh 5/8" bypass meter 2.025.00
8" double detector check with I" bypass meter 3,075.00
Detector check installations not included in above 'table will be charged to customers on a
time and materials' basis. . .
All charges for services, pipe and meters outside the city limits shall be 25 percent additional.
Fire HydranJ Installation
I
ji
,I
I
I
t
I
I
I
I
I
Charge for furnishing and installing one fire hydrant exclusive of the required tap and charge
for such tap $ 775.00
Charges for any hydrants that are not adjacent to the main or that require additional piping,
restoration. mateLials or labor shall be increased by actual material and labor costs, plus
overhead. .
(6) Gas pennit and inspection fzcs. .\A1 and all fees provided for iR this seetion shall be payabl~
and eollte-eted at the building division ef the zity.
1. .\ basie fee of S 1.50 phiS SO.50 for zaeR outlet shall be ehargoo for each gas house
piping permit. sl:H:a fae to eover ORe iRSl'leetioR. .\R additioFlal fee of SZ.OO s1-mIl be
ehaFged for zach additional iflspeetion required to obtain final approval of the work
...t I 1..' A .. . ...t {! . . ~11' , .
uue to war ( ...elR~ uone In sectIOns or to Improper or uthCCtlVe IflStdJ atlOFlS reql:1lnn~
replacement or eorrectioR.
2, Where ORe or mor~ ~as appliances are to b~ installed, a fze of SO.50 shall be paid fOf
the inspe.ction ef the tirst appliance and $0,~5 for each appliance iR e:teess of OBe.
The fee for a water heater shall ineIude the inspe..:tion of both the gas and water
eonneetioas. Where additional appliance inspeetions are required due to improper or
defective installations a f~e of S 1.00 shall be ,har~ed for each sueh inspection.
3. '.V1tere aRC or more existin;; appliances are to be replaced, a permit shall be required
and a fee of SO.50 paid for the first sueh replacement and a fet) of $0,50 paid for each
replacemeRt in excess of one when done at the same time. The minimum fee for the
correction of J violation shall be S0.50.
1.
If [}flY person fails to pay any or all fees speeificd above wheA due, the building
official shall refuse to ~ive final approval to the "'lode until all fees have been paid.
. . . I' ft ' . . 00
One permit document may be used to eover all Items fDr '1' lie a permit IS requlr
~plied for at EIRe time.
..
I
,5.
!h1W Reclaimed water system connection fee:
1. Standard connection assembly (tap, service line. valve, meter when required. and
backflow prevention device when required, installed at the property line), to be
furnished and installed by the city: Actual cost of materials and labor.
-31-
.
ft!}.......4. ....
~
& !
. ~!
>,1
_ . ATfACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES.
Subject
Amount
.,
2. Nonstandard connection assembly: Ac'tual cost of materials and labor.
3. When bacldlow prevention device on potable water supply is required: Actual cost of
materials.
Rates:
October 1,
1992
I
I
,
I
I
I
!
r
I '
j
I
!
(a) Water rates. Water rates for all water furnished by the city shaH be as follows:
1. Domestic' water rates shall. be the following based on monthly consumption and, will
take effect on February 1, 1992, and October 1, 1992, as shown in the following
table, and shall remain in effect thereafter unless amended:
Meter Size
, February 1,
1992
Under l~inch:
Minimum charge with usage
up to 400 cubic feet
,Plus, from 401 to 1,200 cubic
feet, per 100 cubic feet,
Plus, from .1,201 cubic feet
up, per 100 cubic feet
i-inch:
S 5.88
1.78
2.11
,Minimum charge with usage
up to 900 cubic feet
Plus, from 901 to 5,400 cubic
feet, per 100 cubic feet, per
100 cubic feet
Plus, from 5,401 cubic feet
up, per 100 cubic feet
1 1/2-inch:
13.23
1.78
2.11
Minimum charge with usage
up to 13.400 cubic feet
~ Plus, from 13,401 to 18,700
cubic feet, per 100 cubic' feet
Plus, from 18,101 cubic feet
up, per 100 cubic feet
196.98
1.78
2.11
2-inch:
-32-
S 6.12
1.86
2.20
13.76
1.86
2.20
204.86
1.86
2,20
"
,.
ft';"!l':,J.,.I h,. .1.,. . . ,. . ., ,
.0
- 1
,
- .c A TIACHMENT 1 !
. APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subj~ct Amount
Meter Size February 1, October I,
1992 1992
Minimum charge with usag~ 457.17 475.46
up to 31,100 cubic feet
. Plus, from 31,101 to 45,800 1.78 1.86
cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 45,801 cubic feet, 2.11 2.20
per 100 cubic feet
3-inch or 2-inch in -manifold:
! Minimum charge with' usage 705,60 733.83
. .
up to 48,000 cubic feet
Plus, from 48,001 to 63,400 1.78 . 1.86
cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 63,401 cubic feet 2.11 2.20
up, per 100 cubic feet
4-inch:
Minimum charge with usage 1,358.28 1,412.62 1
up to 92,400. cubic feet
Plus, from 92,401 to 130,900 1.78 1.86 .j
cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 130,901 cubic feet 2.11 2.20 I
up, per 100 cubic feet
6-inch:
.
I
Minimum charge with usage 3,488.31 3,627.85 J
up to 237,300 cubic feet
Plus, from 237,301 to 1.78 1.86 l
t
270,700 cubic feet, per 100 ~
cubic feet f
, Plus, from 270,701 cubic feet 2.11 2.20 i
I
'\ up, per 100 cubic feet .
.
I
8-inch: , I
Minimum charge with usage 5,880.00 6,115.20 ,
up to 400,000 cubic feet
-33-
...
;rr,'{-...'......h~. .
_ ATfACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
Amount
Meter Size
':
Plus, from 400,001 to
"456,300 cubic feet, per 100
cubic feet
February 1,
1992
1.78
October I,
1992
1.86
. .
Plus, from 456,301 cubic feet
up, per 100 cubic feet
2.11
2.20
r
I
I
I
!
I
I
r
I
r
I
I
I
$ . 2.18 j
1.98
2.73
6.54-
1.98
2.73
32.70
1.98
2.73
91.56
1.98
2.73
180.94
1.98
2.73
348.80
1.98
2.73
1,052.94
1.98
2.73
2. Lawn water meters. Lawn water rates shaH be as follows:
Lawn meter size.
.,
~
Under I-inch:
Base charge, with no water allowance
Plus. up to 200 cubic feet, per roo cubic feet
Plus. from 201 cubic feet up. per 100. cubic.feet
I-inch:
Base charge, with no water allowance
Plus. up to 900 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 901 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
1 II2-inch:
Base charge, with no water allowance
Plus" up to 1,200 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 1,201 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
. . 2-inch:
Base charge. with no water allowance
Plus, up to 5,400 cubic feet. per 100 cubic feet
Plus. from 5,401 cubic feet up. per 100 cubic feet
3-inch or two 2-inch in manifold:
Base charge, with no water allowance
Plus. up to 13.400 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 13,401 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
4-inch:
Base charge, with no water allowance
Plus, up to 31,100 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 31,10 1 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
6-inch:
Base charge.' with no water allowance
Plus, up to 48,000 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
Plus, from 48,001 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
"
3. Standby and other charges for fire protection systems. For fire hydrants and fire
protection systems on private property connected to the city water system, the
customer shall pay a monthly standby charge as set forth in the following table:
Faciliry
lHonrhly
-34-
~.
~ -:-. , ~ '
ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subj~cr
Fire hydrants. per hydrant
Fire protection systems, based on tire line size, per building:
6 inches or less '
8 inches-
10 inches
12 inches or larger
" Amount
Charge
S 5.00
5.00
9.00
14.00
20.00
Water drawn from a fire line and used for purposes other than firefighting' will be charged at the lawn
meter rate if the water does not enter the sewer system, or the domestic rate if the water enters the
'sewer system. Such charges shall be in addition to the monthly standby charges.
4. Service out of municipal limits. Accounts outside of ,the corporate limits of the city
shaH be subject to a surcharge equal to 25 percent of the monthly charges,
5. A charge of the monthly minimum for a 1 l/2-inch water meter is required for a
deduct meter for air conditioning cooling water and similar purposes, but not for lawn
irrigation purposes. This charge shall be required only where a separate irrigation
meter cannot be set in the right-of-way or easement and the meter reader must
physically read and deduct consumption for billing purposes.
6. The water rates shall be adjusted periodically to recover any increased cost to supply
water due to changes in the wholesale rate the city pays for water. Any such
adjustment shall be a proportionate increase based upon the ratio of water the city
buys wholesale to total system water. Such rate adjustment shall be recommended by
the public works director and approved by the city manager, and a copy shall be fLIed
with the city clerk following approva1. ,
7. Dormant accounts. The monthly charge for a dormant lawn water account shall be at
'the applicable water lawn base charge for the size of meter at the premises.
.~
(b)
Gas service rates. The follow in; rates shalt apply to users of gas providzd by the ~ity:
1. General service rate, natural gas eoAtainiFl;; flat less than 1,000 BUt's per zubie foot.
a. ~Ionthly eharges for open account with gas meter OR during the month.
.\CCOUAt :harge
1.00
-
First 3 therms or less llsed
3.00
~
'\
Eaeh additional ilium us~d
'1'
or pnw31 mg rate
0,69436
M-intmum monthly biJI
1.00
a. ~.fonthly eharge for opeR aeeount with gas meter off,
or tor dormant lllilities account, zaeh full month.
Monthly fixoo eharge
1.00
-35-
....
.
.'!"",
. ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
!
~ I
il
jl
!
i
!
!
t
,
j
,
t
I
I
I
I
Subj~ct Amount
2. Interruptible seryiee rate, l:msetl OR sale of "aN eel ~a') at reducoo rate in exchange f-of
fighH~terrupt g85 supply to high ,'olume-user fla.'/ing elterna.tiv0 source. Rate tel be
agreoo upon by eustomer and eity, The contraet shllll include minimum monthly
eonsumption levels, alternative fuel supply eapacity, right to interrupt supply a.ml
eonditioFl3 for supply interruptions, and other terms deemed neeessary, The--eity
maAa~er is authorized to negotiate the terms of such .zORtraets.
3, Franchise fees shall be levied by. the dty on ~'/~ry. purchase of narural ~as provided by
the dty, at the ratc paid by the city to the municipality where the- service is delivered,
except as may be otherv;ise provided in the franchise agreement.
,t, .\11 areas noith of State Road 580 and ell areas east of McMullen Booth Road served
BY ~as mains or ~enncetiens meae after Oetober 1, 1983, are subject to a surcharge of
SO.035 per therm unless sueh a sl:Irehargc is. prevented ~ a franchise agreement with
the eity.
5. Standby ~enerators fueled by natural gas:
a, }.{onthl)' ..:hargcs for open account v:ith gas meter on dl:lrin~ th~ month:
.\ceOUnE eharge
1.00
First 75 therms or less Idsea
60.00
Each additional therm used
or pre....ailifl~ rate
0,69'136
Minimum monthly sill
61.00
13,
"fonthly .:harge for open accol:lnt with gas meter off, or for dormant utilities
account, ~ach full month:
Monthly fixed' charge
1.00 !
. ~
0,9733
1.: 133
6. Liquid propane.
I,
CuFRffi_creial, per gallon used
o'r prey'ailing rate
. \11 other, f3er ~a:lloR used
'I'
&i'-preyal mg rate
~. Preyailing rates. The monthly gas ~hargcs are sul>jcet to an adjustment per therm or
per ~a110n for increases or deereases in the supplier's rate for pl:Irchased gas in
aeeo~danee with the proYisioRS of the supplier's tariff as reeommcnd.:L1 by the publie
wodes L1ireetor and approved by the ~ity manager. Upon approval of any such rate
atijustment. a ,:oPY shall be filed with the dry ;:lerk,
8.
a.
8. Diseounteu gas service rates, The monthly gas service rates may be JiseouFltco p~f
-36.
"
:}IJ..
SubjeC1
, _ ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES'
AmoUnt
therm €Ir 13fr gallOR by .,'..fitteR service agreement as recommended by the gas system
mllflagiRg director ;md approved by the dty' manager. The di5couRt -shall Rot exceed
ORe third of the othef\'Jise applicable gas service rate, uR:less approves by the ~ity
eommission. Upon approval of any sueh discouRt, Ii oaop)'--of the serviee a~ree~
sha:11 be filed with the fit)' derk.
!l2ltej Wastewater collection utility rates.
1.
There is hereby established a uniform schedule' of rates and charges for the use or
availability of use of the wastewater collection system. The wastewater collection
utility rate shall be a monthly fee consisting of a minimum charge for an assigned
volume of domestic water associated with each 'water meter size, shown as the basic
allowance in the following table, plus a charge per 100 c.ubic feet for water consumed .
above the assigned volume. Such rates shaH take effect on February I, 1992, and
October 1; 1992, as shown in the following table, and .shaH remain in effect thereafter
unless amended:
Base Monthly alarge With or Without Consumption
February I, October 1. Basic Allowance
Size of Meter 1992 1992 (cubic feet)
Under I-inch $ 8.88 S 9.44 400 or less
1- inch 19.98 21.24 900 or less
1 1/2-inch 297.48 316.24 13;400 or less
2-inch 690.42 733.96 31,100 or less
3-incti or 2 2-inch manifold 1,065.60 1,132.80 48,000 or less
I 4-inch 2,051.28 2,180.64 92;400 or less
~ 6-inch 5,268.06 5,600.28 237.'300 or less
8-inch \ 8.880.00 9,440.00 400,000 or less
Charge per 100 cubic feet of
water used over the basic
allowance 2.22 2.36
. 3.
~
4.
2.
Service outside of the municipal limits. Accounts outside the corporate limits of the
city shall be suqject to a surcharge equal to 25 percent of the monthly wastewater
collection utility charges. .
The wastewater collection utility rate schedule shaH be reviewed by the city
commission as a part of the annual fiscal budget preparation to ensure that adequate
revenues are generated to pay the costs of operation, maintenance and outstanding
bond service requirements. .
The wastewater collection charges provided in this section shall not apply to sprinkler
irrigation systems separately metered or deduct meters.
Basis where water is unrnetered. For accoums existing as of the effective date of this
article. at premises which have a source of water other than city water system. where
the spent or used water from which goes imo the wastewater collection system; the
customer shall pay a charge according to the schedule providell in this section, based
5.
-37-
.,...:1.....,. .,.
I
, ATTACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-~CHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
J
r
i
I
ji
Ii
I
I
Subject Amount
upon an estimate of the amount of water going into the wastewater . collection- system.
In the event of a disagreement as to the amount of such water reaching the wastewater
collection system, then a metering device or devices shall be installed at the
customer's expense to determine that amount. For accounts established after the
effective date of this article, the customer shall install at the customer's expense_a
water meter on the water service line, which meter shaH be accessible to city .
employees for the purpose of reading the meter. Water consumption measured by such
meter shall be the basis for the wastewater conection charges for the premises.
6. Donnant accounts. The monthly charge for a donnant account shatl be at the
applicable sanitary sewer base monthly charge for the size of meter at that premises.
~Ed1 Solid waste collecth;m rates.
..
1. Monthly charges for twice weekly collection of solid waste in prescribed containers.
a. Single-family and multiple-family dwellings.
(i) Curbside pickup: S16.30 minimum for each living unit
with no limit on the number of containers per unit on
manual pickups. One 90-gallon container will be
provided for automated service. Additional 90-gallon
containers will be provided at the discretion of the
director of public works at the'rate of S 16.30 per
container. Where routes are automated, automated
service shall be the only option.
(ii) Side or rear building collection: S32.60 minimum for
e:lch .living unit. Manual pickup has a limit of two
containers. each. having a capacity no larger than 32
gallons per unit. A fee of S 11.37 each will be charged
for each additional 32-gallon or smaller container for
rear yard pickup. A fee of S32.60 will be charged for
side or rear building collection of each 90-gallon
container.
(iii) . Base charge: S5.42 for each account. The base charge
will be included in the monthly charge for active
accounts. Dormant accounts will be assessed the base
charge.
b.
Motels, apartment motels, or apartments renting by day or week; aJl
containers serving the premises shall be centrally located at one collection
point.
(i) ,
~
\
Curbside pickup: .
First living unit, minimum
All additional living units,' per unit
Side or rear building collection:
First living unit, minimum
All additional living units, per unit
32.60
16.30
16.30
8.53
(ii)' ,
-38-
-39-
'l,r"'" ,.. , '.. . . ::"; 1'1
'I
An ACHMENT 1 t
APPENO(X A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES ANI? CHARGES
.. Subj~ct Amount
Size Times per Week Pickup
(cubic
yard)
1 2 3 4 5 . .6
1 S 41. 82 S 75.85 S108.86 S 150.37 $ 198.78 288.64
2 75.90 138.66 201.41 277.33 369.18 543.06
3 98.19 179.40 260,60 358.85 477.71 702.72
4 117.94 217.60 317.26 437.83 583.70 859.85
.
5 118.12 236.23 354.35 497.24 670.13 997.40
6 159.50 296.07 432.64 597.87 797.76 1,176.17
8 201.38 374.91 548.44 758.38 1,012.37 1,217.64
No new one-yard commercial cont.ainers shall be
provided after January 3, 1991.
(ii) Compacted commerc:la/:
Size Times per Week Pickup
(cubic
yard)
1 2 3 4 5 6
1 S 88.82 S 177,65 S _266.47 S 373.94 S 503.95 $ 750.06
2 151.86 303.71 455.57 639.29 861.56 1,282.32
3 \ 214.89 429.78 644.66 904.64 1,219.17 1,814.58
4 277 .97 , 555,94 833.91 1,170.21 1,577 ,07 2,347.28
5 340.95 681.90 1,022.85 1,435.34 1,934.39 2,879.09
-40-
"
P""'"
Subjtct
Amount
i
I
I
J1
J
j
I
I
I
, _ ATfACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A.SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHA,RGES
Size.
(cubic
yard)
TImes per Week Pickup
1
2
3
4
5
6,
6
403.98
807.96
1,211.95
1,700.69
2,291.99
3,411.35
8,
530.04
1,060.09
1,590.13
2,231.40
3,007.21
3,616.95 '
3. The charge for the collection of loose trash or garbage shall be 5149.50 per hour or
52.49 per minute for time on site with a minimum charge of 525.00.
4. The charges set forth above shall be subject to adjustment for increases or decreaSes
in the dump' fee. Uniform increases or decreases shaH be recommended by the public
works director and approved by the city manager, and a copy of the adjusted charges
shall be filed with the city clerk. Other Increases or decreases shall be subject to
approval by the adoption of an ordinance by the city commission, upon the
recommendation of the city manager.
.unw Recycling.
1.
2.
Recovered materials dealer annual application fee
Curbside recycling:
S50.oo
a. Monthly charges for curbside service for once-weekly collection for each unit:
Calendar Year
1994
1995
1996 1997 1998
S 1.99
2.05
2.12 2.05 ,1.99
b.
Charge for additional curbside recycling bins or replacement of bins lost or
damaged due' to negligence shall be: Cost plus 51.00 handling charge per bin
(one-time charge per delivery). _
Charge for a curbside recycling bin toter shall be: Cost plus S.t.OO handling
charge. .
Special collection of recyclables where City services a bin at the residence or
carries bin to curb: ,without physician's certification of medical necessity, shall
be: Twice the curbside recycling charge.
c.
,
d.
3. Monthly charges for muhifamily collection of prescribed service:
a. Service with semi-automated carts:
41-
., .
.\ ".
I
,
"
\ .
it'JI\".~"'" , '.. ' .
, .
. . J
ATf ACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE O~ FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
. Subject AmOUnt
" -
Calendar Year 1
j
1994 1998 I
1995-97 ,
I
I
Cluster of 1, 2 or 3 Carts I
Time(s) per Week Pickup [
1 554.48 556.00 557.52 I
2x 98.31 101.09 103.86 J
I
3 x 142.14 146.17 150.20 I
I
.'
l
4x 196.64 202.18 .207.73 \
,.
5 x 264.04 271.42 278.80
"
6x 397.88 . 408.74 419.60
Cluster of 4 or $ Carts
" Time(~) per Week Pickup
1 $61.48 - S63.00 564.52
2x 112.31 115.09 117.86
3 x 1~3.14 167.17 171.20 t
224.64 230.18 235.73
4:t I
1
Sx 299.04 306.42 313. SO I
I
6'x 439.88 450.74 461.60 . 1
1
\ I
1
Each Additional Cart over 5 f
Time(s) per Week Pickup j
,
,
1 57.00 57.25 $7.50 ". !
1
-42-
I' ,
~,.".~...~. ,.,... .
. . ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A.SCHEDULE OF'FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
i
I
.1
i
!
I
. Subj~ct Amount
Calendar Year
1994 1995.97 1998
,.
2x 14.00 14.50 15.00
3x 21.00 21.75 22.50
4x 28.00 29.00 30.00
5x 35.00 36.25 37.50
6x 42.00 43.50 " 45.00
b. Service with non-compacted commercial container:
Times Per Week Pickup
Dumpster 1 2 3 4 5 6
Size
(cubic
yard)
2 S44.02 S80.42 S118.82 S160.85 S214.12 $314.97
3 56.95 104.05 151.15 207.84 277.07 407.58
4 68.41 126.21 184.01 253.94 338.55 498.71
6 92.51 171. 72 250.93 346.76 462.70 682.18
.
8 116.80 217.45 318.10 439.86 587.17 706.23
~ . .
~
Multifamily complexes serviced with one compartmentalized container cluster of four
equates to one three cubic-yard dumpster.
4. Monthly charges for commercial collection represents the target level of commercial
recycling from which the solid waste division will flex up or down to b~ competitive
with certified recovered materials dealers (private recycling companies) operating
.4.3.
II. '..
.
,
v'l," Jc'.' "
ATfACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
Subject
Amount
I
i
I
.
I
I
I
I
Ii
.1
I
I
!
!
I
I
I
I
I
!
I
within Clearwater.
a. The target .level charge for service with semi-automated carts shall be charged
on the same basis as rates included in 3.a.
b. The target level charge for service with non-compacted commercial containers
shall be the same as rates included in 3.b. above.
ffi~
Stormwater management utility rates. The storinwater l,l1anagement utility rates shall be based
upon the revenue requirements for the construction, administratio'n, management, engineering,
operation and maintenance of the stormwater management system, and the adopted capital .
improvement program funding needs of the system. For the purposes of these rates, the terms
shall have the meanings set forth in section 32.242 or, if not defined in section 32.242, in
sectioris 32.002 or 1.02.
1. Basic rate. The rate for one equivalent residential unit or ERU shall be established at
S3.00 per ERU per month.
2. Residential property fees. The monthly fee for each residential property shall be:
\,
Single-family
Duplex units
Condominium units .
Apartments
Mobile homes
1 ERU/dwelling unit
1 ERU/dwelling unit
1 ERU/dwelling unit
1 ERU/dwelIing unit
1 ERU/dwelling unit
3. .Nonresidential property fees. Nonresidential property shall he charged on the basis of
the impervious area of the property in accordance with the following formula:
Impervious area (sq. ft.) divided by 1,830 sq. ft. = Number of ERU's. A minimum
value of 1.0 ERU shall be assigned to each nonresidential property. The impervious
area of each nonresidential property shall be as determined by the city engineer.
ERU's shall be rounded to the nearest one-tenth of a unit,
4. Undeveloped property.. Stormwater management utility fees shall not be levied against
undeveloped property pursuant to this article.
IDfgt Reclaimed water rates. The uniform rate for the use or availability of use of the reclaimed
water system -shall be S 13.77 per month per acre of pervious area tor all reclaimed water
system customers. "Pervious area" means as de tined in Section 32.352. This rate shaH be
reviewed annually and revised as nec~sary to recover the operating and maintenance costs of
the recl,aimed water system in a fair and equitable manner.
)
ffit6t Mlscel!lJneous additional charges: .
',.
(3) Applicabl~ during normal working hours:
1. Tum-on ~'5-WHellight up only, does nef....tnclutW-aAy sefVice):
-44-
.
,J"..
'" ATIACHMENT 1
APPENDIX AMSCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND "CHARGES
Subjut AmOUtlt
Ii. Ges meter, per meter 20.00
b. Water meter, per meter 20.00
2. Special reading 15.00 !
.' 3. Collector fee (for each collection attempt) 5.00
.4. Check reading (if correct reading has been made) 15.00 .1
5. Turn on gas pilot 15.00 I
~e. Read for change of account 15.00
7, Reset meter Gas 50,00
28. Reset meter-Water 50.00
19. Water meter test if meter is correct:
a. Less than or equal to 2-inch' size 50.00
b. Greater than 2-inch size 100.00
~-lQ. Dishonored check service fee. See section 2.528
11. Gl.15 meter testing (in shop) if meter is ei3rre.:t
12. Return eatl Customer AGt ~resent at first eaII as arranged
2.+;. Tum-Qff, ga5-&f water
11. Inspections:
:!5 , 00
15,00
N/C
a.
B.
First hookup ar Bflplia:nee
Eaeh addieienIH hookup or applianee
3.00
1.00
.lQ-l-:S. Lawn meter removed
11+6. Duplicate bill preparation for payments (mailed in or customer walk in)
11++. Water meter downsize or upsize (no new lap needed):
70.00
N/C
. .~
,.."
a.. . From I-inch meter or to I-inch meter
b. From 1 112-inch meter or to 1 112-inch meter
c. From 2-inch meter or to 2-inch meter
d. From 3-inch meter or to 3-inch meter
e. From 4-inch meter or to 4-inch meter
f. From 6-inch meter or to 6-inch meter
Any combination of downsizing and subsequent upsizing or upsizing
and subsequent downsizing for the same service, per meter, will not
be allowed more than once every three years.
60.00
110.00
160.00
330.00
'385.00
400.00
11-1-8. Leaks, ga5-* water
N/C
(b)
, The charges in the preceding table will be doubled for services between 4:30 p. m., and 8:00
'\ a.m. on workdays and aU day during holidays and weekends. ; 1
Domestie serviee ..:hW'ge. 111irteefl dollars per employeo per ooo-baJf hour Y/i!.h a $:6.00
minimum.
(e)
(d)
Commereial insta-.llatiofl,
-45M.
r
"l"' ~ -"v,
,\ )
ATTACHMENT 1
. APPE~IX A-SCHEDULE OF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
Subject Amounr
-
1. Thirteea dollars per employee per one half hour for one employee and a truck, witft-.a.
~O minimum..
2. Twenty six. dellars per one--half Rour f-or tVlO employees and a truelc, with a S26.00
minimum fur delivery ar a $39.00 minimum far repair and insta11aOOfi.:.
(~) Mileage t:l1ar~e. "A mileage eharge of $0.50 per mile \ViII be added to .a11 service calls outside
the original gas service area, unless p,rohibited by a gas system franchise. The ariginal gas
service area is bounded OR the sauth by DlmeetoR Road, on the west by the Gulf of Mexico,
OR the BOrth by Curlew Road and OR me east by Tampa Bay and the Lalce TarpOR Canal. .
(f) Special seasonal gaS turn OR. The city manager is autHortzeel tel reaue-a the gas turn on charge
by not more tHaft 50 percent during a period beginning not earlier than September 1 and
caGing ROt later than November 30, as reeommended by the publie works director, in order to
enCOl:lrage zarly t'1:Ira an and to reduce the ','1orkJoad at the be;iflflin; of the heating seas&fr.
!.lli11
Other miscellaneous charges:
(a) Water:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
(b) Gas:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
{.
~:
8.
Unauthorized water system use: For any use of water, unauthorized,
per occurrence
Bypass: Ten percent of average monthly bill for each day since last
reading. .
Broken stop locks on water meters ,
Repair or replace tampered or damaged meter or any other part of the
water system: S20.OO plus labor and material. To relocate water
meter: Time and material.
Unauthorized use of fire hydrants
100.00
20.00
200.00 '
Broken stop locks on gas
Reactivate gas meter charge: A charge of S50.00 for meter reset if
service is restored where it has been cut and capped if heat only.
Where two or more gas appliances are to be used where the service line has been cut
and capped, there will be a charge of $25.00 to restore the meter.
To reactivate meter on rental apartment units where service has not been cut, a charge
of $15.00 will be required for meter reset.
A minimum charge of S50.00 pe"r month is required on gas service for any other
standby purposes, in addition to the account charge. Consumption will be billed at the
general service rate.
To relocate a gas meter
Unauthorized gas system cOMection, for removal
Bypass: Ten percent of the average monthly bill for each day since last reading.
10.00
60.00
25.00
f!2l Solid waste roll-off container service:
.L.€+1 Permit fee to place or service containers (9 32.292(3))
50.00
-46-
1 I
, ,
I
!
I
I
1
I
!
I
I
I
I
,
,
i
!
I
i
I
I
!
i
I
I
!
j
,;E
~~...~... .
~ ATfACHMENT 1
APPENDIX A~SCHEDULE OF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
SubJl!ct Amount
l.&.~ Monthly fee of 15 percent of the gross revenue billed by permit holder from the
installation or servicing of roll-off containers within the city for the preceding month,
including roll-off containers installed permanently and temporarily (9 32.293(~)(b)).
(Code'1980, U 50.05, 54.21, 54.22; Ord. Np. 5058, 9 5, 12~20~90; Ord. No. 5062, 9 I. 1-3-91;
Ord. No. 5080. ~ 1; 3~7~91; Ord~ No. 5102, ~ '1, 6~20~91; Ord. No. 5162, 99 1-3, 1~2~92; Ord. No.
5219, 9 I, 9-17~92; Ord. No. 5258, 9 1, 8-13-92; Ord. No. 5284, 9 I, 10-1-92; Oed.' No. 5314-92,
9 I, 12~3~92; Ord. N~. 53#-93, 9 1, 2-18~93; Oed. No. 5454:-93, 9 I, 9-16-93; Ord. No. 5325-93,
9 I, 3-17-94; Ord. No. 5506-94, 9 4, 1-20~94; Ord. No. 5700-94, 9- I, 11-3-94)
XXVI. CLEARWATER GAS SYSTEM FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
. 01
i . . This is a newly created section. See Attachment 2 for this s~on in its entirety.
i .
XXVII. WATERWAYS AND VESSELS:
Temporary pennirfor live-aboard vessels, .not to exceed (9 33.054(2))
I
15.00
\
-47~
-i '.' "".i} .~
AITACHMENT 2 .
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
xxvx. CLEARWATER GAS SYSTEM FEES, RATES AND CHARGES:
Rate schedules, ~ees and charges (5 32.068):
(1) Natural Gas Service Rates. The following monthly rates shall
apply to all customers who are pr9vid~d the availability of
natural .gas service by the Clearwater Gas System, based on
their applicable class of service: . "
(a) Residential Natural Gas Service (Rate RS): Firm natural
gas service for domestic uses in all residences of three
(3) units or less.
Monthly Customer Charge ................. $ 5.00
Non-Fuel Energy Charge .,................ $ 0.480 per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill.................. $ 5.00
Effective 10/1/96
Monthly Customer Charg~................ $ 6.00
Non-Fuel Energy Charge. '. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. $ 0.530 per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill................... $ 6.00
(b) Small Natural Gas General Service (Rate SGS): Firm
natural gas service for all commercial, industrial, and
other applications where no other rate is applicable and
the customer's annual consumption at the premise is 0 -
17,999 therms.
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $15.00
Non-Fuel Energy Charge ....... ~ . . . . . . .. $ 0.430 per therm
~inimum Monthly Bill ..........~....... $15.00
Effective 10/1/96
Non-Fuel Energy Charge. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. $ 0.400 per therm
(c) Medium Natural Gas General Service (Rate MGS): Firm
natural gas service for all.commercial, industrial, and
other applications where no other rate is applicable and
the customer's annual consumption at the premise is
18,000 - 99,999 therms.
\
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $20.00
Non-Fuel Energy Charge ....."........... $ 0.380 per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill.................. $20.00
Effective 10/1/96
Non-Fuel Energy Charge... ~............. $ 0.350 per therm
1
I
.
q
ATfACHMENT 2
i
[
"
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
/:
j:
"
(d) LarCle Natural Gas General Service (Rate LGS): Firm
natural gas service for all commercial, industrial, and
other applications where no other rate is applicable and
the customer's annual consumption at the premise is
100,000 the~ms or more.
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $50.00
Non-Fuel Energy Charge ................. $ O. JJO per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill.................. $50.00
Effective ~O/1/96
Non-Fuel Energy Charge. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. $ o. J 00 per therm
(e) Interruptible Natural Gas service (Rate IS):
Interruptible natural gas service available under a
standard agreement for typically industrial applications
where the customer I s annual consumption at the premise is
100,000 therms or more;. the customer agrees contractually
to purchase a minimum of 250 'therms/day (excluding
curtailment days)'; and where the customer has either
installed' alternative fuel capability and/or
contractually agrees to curtail service at the request of
the Clearwater Gas System, subject to penalties for
failure to comply. '
( f)
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $100.00
Non-Fuel Energy Charge ................ $ 0.260 per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill......... ...... ... $100.00 plus the
Non-Fuel Therm Rate for the minimum number of
contract therms per day
Contract Natural Gas Service (Rate CNS): Contract
natural gas service for special applications and
conditions approved by the city Manager. This rate is
typically applicable where competitive fuel sources are
confirmed to be available to the customer and a special
rate with special conditions are required to obtain/
retain the customer. This rate may be used to construct
a special standby rate where the customer requires
capability to serve, but normally uses an alternative
energy source. Such service mu~t fall within the normal
construction feasibility formula to insure a profitable
payback to the city.
Monthly customer Charge .... As Established by Contract
(typically the same as the normally
Applicable Service Class)
Non-Fuel Energy Charge .... Per Therm as Established by
contract
Minimum Monthly Bill ... ... Monthly Customer Charge
Plus the Non-Fuel Therrn Rate for a
Contract Level of Monthly Consumption
~
2
~lr""",~ '.
I
I'
i
ATTACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A . SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
(g) Residential NaturaL Gas Air Conditioning service (Rate
RACl : Firm natural gas service for domestic gas air
conditioning in all residences of three (3) units or less
where the gas air conditioning load is separately
metered.
-
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $ 5.00 only if
this is not already being billed on another metered
account at the premise on a firm rate schedule
Non-Fuel Energy Charge ................ $ 0.200 per therm .
Minimum Monthly Bill.................... $ 5.00 at the
premise on a firm rate schedule
Effec~ive 10/1/96
Monthly ,Customer Charge................. $6.00 only if
this is not already being billed on another metered
account at the premise on a firm rate schedule
Minimum Monthly Bill..................... $6.00 at the
· premise on a firm rate schedule
(h) General Natural Gas Air Conditionino service (Rate GAel:
Firm natural gas air conditioning service for all
commercial, industrial, and other non-residential
applications where the installed gas air conditioning
capacity is 0 - 149 tons and the gas air conditioning
load is separately metered.
Monthly customer charge ............ ... $15.00 only if
this is not already being billed on another metered
a~count at the premise on a firm.rate schedule
Non-Fuel Energy charge ................ $ 0.150 per therrn
Minimum Monthly Bill ...........~...... $15.00 at the
premise on a firm rate schedule
(i)
Laroe Natural Gas Air Conditioninq service (Rate LAC):
Firm natural gas air conditioning service fo~ all
commercial, industrial, and other non-residential
applications where the installed gas air conditioning
capacity is 150 tons or more and the gas air conditioning
load is separately metered.
Monthly Customer charge .... ......~.... $20.00 only if
this is not already being billed on another metered
account at the premise on a firm rate schedule
Non-Fuel Energy charge ................ $ 0.100 per therrn
Minimum Monthly Bill......... ......... $20~OO at the
premise on a firm ra,te schedule
~
3
AITACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A. SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
(j) Natural Gas street Liqhtinq Service (Rate SL): Natural
gas service for lighting of public areas and ways.
Service may be metered or estimated at the discretion of
the gas system. When the gas system' provides poles,
fixtures, piping, and/or installation labor beyond the
service connection point, Facilities Contract Charges may
be assessed.
'i
"'\
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $15.00
Non-Fuel Energy Charge................ $ 0.200 per them
Normal Maintenance & Relighting
. Labor Service Charge ............. $ 0.100 per therm
plus any required equipment/parts
Minimum Monthly Bill .....~............. $15.00 plus any
, applicable Facilities Contract Charges
(k) Contract Natural Gas Transportation Service (Rate CTSl:
Service fortransporta~ion of someone else's natural gas
through the Clearwater. Gas System for supply to another
gas system or an individual customer. This is handled
like a Contract Natural Gas Service and must be approved
by the City Manager. Provision of this service must fall
within the normal construction feasibility formula to
insure a profitable payback to the City.
Monthly Customer Charge ... As Established by contract
(typically the same as the normally
Applicable Service Class)
~on-Fuel Energy Charge .... Per Therm as Established by
Contract (typically the same as the
normally applicable'service rate)
Minimum Monthly Bill...... Monthly Customer Charge
Plus the Non-Fuel Therm Rate for a
Contracted Level of Minimum Monthly
Flow as well as any Facilities
Contract . Charges for special
Facilities and Metering Required to
Provide th~s Transportation Service
Natural Gas Vehicle service (Rate NGV): Natural gas
service for fleet vehicle fueling. Thi~ ia a contract
rate approved by the city Manager~ provision of this
service must fall within the normal construction
feasibility formula to insure a profitable payback to the
city.
(I)
Monthly
Customer Charge .. .... $ 5.00 for Residential or
$15.00 for General service applications
only if a Customer Charge is not already
being billed on another metered account
at the premise on a firm rate schedule
Energy Charge .... ... $ 0.100 per therm plus any
Non-Fuel
4
rO>;.l'"
A IT ACH MENT 2
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE Or-FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
applicable customer-specific or pUblic
Fill Station per therm Facilities Charges
Required to Provide this service
Minimum Monthly Bill......... Monthly Customer Charge,
if appl~cable, ~lus any monthly
Facilities Contract Charges for Special'
Facilities, Metering or Fleet Conversion
Costs Required to Provide this service
Effective 10/1/96
Monthly Customer charge....... $6.00 for Residential or
$15.00 for General service applications
only if a Customer Charge is not already
being billed ~n, another metered account
at the premise on a firm rate schedule
The total energy charges for this service
including al~ adjustments, facilities charges,
taxes, etc. -may be expressed as a rate "per
gallon equivalent of gasoline."
(m) Natural Gas Emerqencv Generator or Other StandbY Service
(Rate NSS): Natural gas service to a metered account,
separately established for back-up service, where no
substantial gas service is used for year round purposes.
Note:
,
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $25.00
Non-Fuel Energy charge ................ $ 0.430 per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill.................. $25.00 plus any
Facilities Contract Charges for the Facilities
and Metering Required to Serve This Account.
Effective 10/1/96
Non-Fuel Energy charge.... ... ... ....... $0.400 per therm
(2) propane (LP) Gas Service Rates. The following monthly rates
shall apply to all customers who are provided the availability
of propane eLP) gas service by the Clearwater Gas System,
based on their applicable class of service:
(a)
Residential Propane Gas Service (Rate RLP): .Metered or
bulk delivered LP service for all domestic uses in all
residences of three (3) units or less.
. Monthly Customer charge ........... $ 5.00
~ Non-Fuel Energy Charge ............ $ 0.650 per gallon
= $ 0.710 per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill ............. $ 5.00
Effective 10/1/96
Monthly customer Charge. ... .... ... $ 6.00
Minimum Monthly B i 11. . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 6.00
5
L
"I';-.~ :t'" .
ATTACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A ~ SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
.
! <
(b) General Propane Gas Service (Rate GLP1: Metered or bulk
delivered LP service for all commercial, industrial, and
other applications where no other rate is applicable and
the annual consumption at the premise is 0 - 2,499
gallc;ms.
I
I
1
I
Minimum Monthly
Bill .............
$15.00
$ 0.350
= $ 0.383
$15.00
per gallon
per therm
Monthly Customer Charge ..........
Non-Fuel Energy Charge ...........
Ef~ective 10/1/96
.Non-Fuel Energy charge.~.:...~.... $ 0.320 per gallon
= $ 0.350 per therm
(c) Larqe Propane Gas Service (Rate LLP1: Metered or bulk
delivered LP service for all commercial, industrial, and
other applications whe~e no other rate is applicable and
the annual consumption at the premise is 2,500 gallons or
more.
Minimum Monthly Bill.............
$20.00
$ 0.290
= $ 0.317
$20.00
per gallon
per therm
Monthly customer Charge ..........
Non-Fuel Energy Charge ...........
Effective. 10/1/96
Non-Fuel Energy Charge............ $ 0.260 per gallon
= $ 0.284 per therm
(d) Contract Propane Gas Service (CLP): Contract metered or
bulk delivered LP gas service for special applications
and conditions approved by the city Manager. This rate
is typically applicable where competitive fuel sources
are confirmed to be available to the customer and a
special rate with special conditions are required to
obtain/retain the customer. Such service must fall
within the normal construction feasibility formula to
insure a profitable payback to the city.
Monthly Customer Charge ... As Established by_Contract
(typically the same as the normally
applicab~e service class)
Non-Fuel Margin Rate ...... Per Gallon as Established
~ by Contract
~ Minimum Monthly Bill ...... Monthly customer charge
Plus the Non-Fuel Usage Rate for a Contracted
Level of Monthly Consumption
6
ATTACHMENT 2 -
APPENDlX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
(e) Propane (LP) Gas Vehicle service (Rate LPV): Propane gas
service for fleet vehicle fueling. This is a contract
rate approved by the City Manager. provision of this
service must fall within the normal construction
feasibility formula to insure a profitable payback tci the
city. ' '
Monthly Customer
Charge ....... $ 5.00 for Residential or
$15.00 for General Service
applications only if a. Customer
Charge is not already being billed
on another metered account at the
premise on a firm rate schedule
Charge ........ $ 0.100 per gallon
= $ 0.109 per therm plus
any applicable customer-
specific or Public Fill
station Facilities
Charges Required to
Provide this service
Bill.......... Monthly Customer Charge
plus any applicable monthly
Facilities Contract Charges for
special Facilities, Metering or
Fleet Conversion Costs Required to
Provide this Service
Non-Fuel Energy
"
Minimum Monthly
Effective 10/1/96
110nthly Customer Charge. . . . . . .. $ 6.00 for Residential or
$15.00 for General Service
applications only if a Customer
Charge is not already being billed
on another metered account at the
premise on a firm rate schedule
~
The total energy charges for .this service
including all adjustments, facilities charges,
taxes, etc. may be expressed as a rate "per
gallon equivalent of gasoline."
(f) Propane Gas Emerqency Generator or other StandbY Service
(Rate LPS): LP gas service to an account separately
established for back-up service, either metered or bulk
delivered, where no other substantial gas service is used
for year round purposes.
Note:
Monthly Customer Charge ............... $25.00
Non-Fuel Energy charge ................ $0.350 per 'gallon
= $ 0.383 per therm
Minimum Monthly Bill.................. $25.00
Ini tial Usage Charge ................. A one-time charge
7
ATIACHMENT 2
; i
! I
;
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEESt RATES AND CHARGES
for the number of gallons required to
initially fill the LP tank (size as requested
by the customer)
Effective 10/1/96
Non-Fuel Energy Charge. .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. $ 0.320 per gallon
= $ 0.350 per therm
(3) other Gas Charges. The following charges and fees may also be
applied to customers of the Clearwater Gas System served under
an applicable natural gas or propane (LP) gas service rate:
(a) Facilities Contract Charae (Rider FCC): A rider
applicable. to any of the above rates to cover
installation of facilities beyond those typically
provided to other customers of the class or beyond the
costs incorporated into the applicable gas rate.
on-Going FCC Charges .:............... A monthly charge
calculated to cover the on-going estimated
maintenance costs associated with the special or
additional facilities. These charges will be
contractual and subject to annual revisions upward
based on the cpr index or based on a revised cost
calculation at the discretion of the City Manager.
Time-limited FCC Charges .............. A monthly charge
calculated to cover the costs associated with
additional facilities as requested by ,the customer,
excess main and service construction costs which do
not'meet the. Construction Feasibility formula, or
appliance/equipment sales costs. The interest rate
will be established contractually at the currently
applicable cost of marginal funds to the gas system
(gas revenue bonds or other financing instruments).
The interest rate will be set by contract and
,approved by the city 'Manager based on a review of
the currently applicable financing rates available
to the gas system and may be revised from time-to-
time.
Public Fill station Facilities Charge ..... A natural
gas per therm or propane (LP) p~r gallon -charge
calculated to recover th~ com~on facilities costs
to provide such service. This will be, calculated
and may be updated from time-to-time by the gas
\ system and approved by the city Manager.
(b) Purchased Gas Adjustment (Rider PGA): A rider applicable
to all natural gas therm rates and propane (LP) gallon
ra tes to recover the cost of the CGS I 5 purchased gas
supply, including losses and use by gas system
faclli ties/ equipment. The currently calculated PGA rates
8
(c)
,.
AITACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
for all rate schedules, unless specifically broken out by
contract, are:
Natural Gas Firm Standard
Rate Schedule PGA . . . . . . . . . . . $ 0.300 per therm
Natural Gas Interruptible and
Contract (Non-Standard)
Rate Schedule PGA . . . . . . . . . . . $ 0.230 per therm
Propane (LP) Gas
Rate Schedule PGA ........... $ 0.480 per gallon
= $ 0.525 per therm
.
The above PGA rates are based on 12 months ending April,
1995 actual Weighted Average Cost of Gas (WACOG). These
PGA Rates will normally be adjusted semi-annually in
April and October and may be adjusted upward or downward
from time-to-time with the approval of the City Manager
based on actual and projected supply costs and projected
consumption levels in order to recover the total cost of
the gas system's supply plus all costs attributable to
the acquisition of system supply gas. The over or under
recovery of these PGA costs will be computed monthly and
an adjustment in the PGA rate will be made' at the
discretion of the city Manager; however, the PGA rate
will be adjusted anytime the over or under recovery for
either natural or propane (LP) supply gas exceeds or is
projected to exceed $100,000. The differential between
the Natural Gas Firm Standard Rate Schedule FGA and the
Natural Gas Interruptible and Contract (Non-standard)
Rate Schedule FGA will be computed for each semi-annual
period based on the available records for the most recent
twelve (12) months by dividing the transmission pipeline
"Reservation Charges" component of the WACOG by the
therms sold to all of the Natural Gas Firm Standard Rate
Schedules. The Gas system may also segment specific gas
purchases for specific targeted customer (5) based on
contract.
\
Enerqv Conservation Adjustment (Rider ECA): A rider
applicable to all firm standard natural gas therm rates and
standard. propane (LP) gallon rates to recover the cost of
energy conservation programs undertaken by the Clearwater Gas
System and approved by the city Manager. The ECA will not be
applied to interruptible natural gas or contract rates. The
currently calculated ECA rates are:
Natural Gas Rate Schedule ECA .... $ 0.023 per therm
Propane (LP) Gas
Rate Schedule ECA ........ ... $ 0.021 per gallon
= $ 0.023 per therm
The above ECA rates are based on twelve (12) months
9
~ ...... ">
AITACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
ending actual expense levels. These ECA rates will
normally be reviewed semi-annually in April and october
and may be adjusted upward or downward from time-to-time
with the approval of the city Manager based on actual and
projected energy conservation program costs and projected
consumption levels in order to recover the total cost of
applicable gas system programs as approved by the City
Manager since March 1, 1995, including energy
conservation incentive payments as well as the labor ~nd
other costs attributable to such energy conservation
programs: The over or under recovery of these ECA costs
will be computed'and an adjustment in the ECA rate will
be made at the discretion of the city Manager; however,
the ECA rate will be adjusted anytime the 9ver or under
recovery exceeds or is projected to exceed $100,000.
(d) Environmental Imposition Adiustment (Rider ErA): A rider
applicable to all firm. standard natural gas therm rates
and standard propane (LP) gallon rates to recover the
cost of environmental programs imposed on the Clearwater
Gas System by Federal, state and Local regulatory
agencies. The EIA will not be applied to interruptible
natural gas or contract rates. The currently calculated
EIA rates are:
Natural Gas Rate Schedule EIA .... $ 0.005 per therm
Propane (LP) Gas
Rate Schedule EIA ........... $ 0.005 per gallon
= $ 0.005 per therm
The above EIA rates are based on twelve (12) months
ending actual expense levels. These EIA rates will
normally be reviewed semi-annually in April and October
and may be adjusted upward or downward from time-to-tirne
with the approval of the city Manager based on actual and
projected environmental project costs and projected
consumption levels in order to recover the total cost of
gas system environmental cost impositions as approved by
the city Manager since February 1, 1993, as well as the
labor and other costs attributable to such environmental
projects. The over or ,under recovery of these EIA costs
will be computed and an adjustment in the EIA rate may be
made at the discretion of the city Manager; however, the
EIA rate will be adjusted anytime the over recovery
, exceeds or is projected to exceed the plan by $100,000.
~ These EIA costs may be recovered over an extended time
period as approved by the City Manager.
(e) Weather Normalization Adiustment (Rider WNA): A rider
applicable to all firm standard natural gas therm rates
and standard propane (LP) gallon rates to recover loss of
revenues to the Clearwater Gas system due to unusually
10
.
\
, ;\
AITACHMENT 2
i
i
il
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
warm winter weather or to return excess revenues to the
customers due to unusually cold winter weather. The WNA
will. not be applied to interruptible natural gas or
contract rates. The WNA rate will initially be set at:
Natural Gas Rate Schedule WNA ..
Propane eLP) Gas
Rate Schedule WNA .........
$ 0.000 per therm
$ 0.000 per ,gallon
The WNA rates will be reviewed at the end of each winter
season and may be implemented based on actual heating
degree day data, the gas system I s projections of the
impact of this weather on revenues, and projected
consumption levels. The implementation of the WNA will
be at the sole discretion of the city Manager only if the
heating degree day data for the winter season exceeds at
least a 10% variation from the ten (10) year historical
average and the city Manager determines that this has
created a material impact on the earnings of the
Clearwater Gas system for the year warranting the WNA
implementation. Any over or under recovery or
distribution may be credited or debited to the PGA at the
discretion of the city Manager upon discontinuance of the
charge/credit from the previous winter season.
(f) Franchise and other ci tv ICountv Fees Recoverv Clause
(Rate FFR): A charge levied by the Clearwater Gas System
on every purchase of gas within a municipality or county
area to recover the costs assessed by governmental
entities in accordance with the franchise agreement in
force between the city of Clearwater and that other"
governmental entity and including any other otherwise
unrecoverable fees, special taxes, payments in lieu of
taxes, or other impositions by any governmental entity
(including the city of Clearwater) on the services of the
Clearwater Gas System sold within such municipality or
county area. The fees collected within each governmental
jurisdiction shall be used exclusively to pay the
franchise fees and other governmental feesr taxes, and
other impositions levied on services within that
governmental jurisdiction. within the city of Clearwater
where a franchise agreement is not in force, the city of
Clearwater will levy a 6% Payment in Lieu of Taxes on all
gross natural gas sales excluding interruptible and
contract services and the Clearwater Gas system will bill
this in the same manner as if it were a franchise fee.
Tax Clause (TAX Various) : All taxes due the
appropriate governmental entities (such as but not
limited to state of Florida gross receipts tax, state of
Florida sales tax, county sales tax, municipal utility
tax, and others which may be legally levied from time to
(g)
11
ATTACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A' ~ SCHEDULE OF FEES; RATES AND CHARGES
time on the purchase of ga~) will be billed to the
customer receiving such service and rendered to the
governmental entity in accordance with the applicable
statute, ordinance, or other legally enforceable rule.'
(h) other Miscellaneous Gas Charqes: The following charges
are applicable whenever applicable gas services are
rendered the customer:
"\
Meter turn-on residential (per account for new
customers, seasonal reconnects, and after
nonpayment disconnect including turn-on
of pilot. l~ghts) ........................... $25.00
Meter turn-on commercial/industrial (per
account for new customers, seasonal
reconnects, and after nonpayment
d~sconnect including turn-on of pilot
1 ~ 9 h t 5 ) iii.................................... $50. 00
Meter Read for account'change (no meter
turn-on required but may include turn-on
of gas pilot light) ........................ $25.00
Meter turn-on surcharge - same day service (per
0, account as requested by the customer) ...... $25.00
Replace broken stop locks on meter .............. $30.00
Relocate gas meter... ...... ........... Time & Materials
Turn-on gas pilot lights only (per account) ..... $20.00
Turn-off gas pilot lights only (per account) .... $~.OO
Repair or installation work
- 1 person crew time on-site .......... $40.00/hour
- 2 person crew time on-site .......... $72.00/hour
overtime surcharge (as requested by the
customer) ..... ........ ..... .... Double normal rate
Special meter reading (per account at
customer request) ........ ....... ........... $15.00
Gas meter test - if results are within limits
(per meter at customer request) ........... $25.00
Reset gas meter after customer requests
removal (per meter) ............. .......... $50.00
Unauthorized meter bypass or hookup .'. Time & Materials
other services not normally provided .. Time & Materials
Collector fee ......~....... ..... ...... See Appendix A-
Public Works utility Tariffs, section (4) (a) 3
Dishonored check service fee ... See Code af Ordinances,
section 2.528
Missed appointment - Customer
not present at as arranged ... ..... ......... $15.00
Leak inspection .........-..........,.......... No Charge
Special seasonal gas turn-on... .... The city Manager is
authorized to reduce or eliminate the normal gas
turn-on charge during a period beginning not
earlier than August 15th and extending through not
later than November 15th to attempt to levelize the
I
i
i
i
.
j
12
\.. .
ATTACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A - ~CHEDULE OF FEES . RATES AND CHARGES
1-
,
workload at the beginning of the heating season.
(4) Gas Contract and Rate Application Policies: The following
represent policies of the city of Clearwater as applied by the
Clearwater Gas system:
(a) . Uniformity of Rate and Service Application: To the
extent that the customer requests a review of his/her
rate account, all rates, charges and contract provisions
are intended to be consistently and uniformly applied to
all customers of the same type with the same usage
characteristics, fuel options, and equipment
capabili ties. Any customer who feels that they have been
treated unjustly and is unable to resolve the dispute
with Clearwater Gas System personnel and management has
full access to the normal City of Clearwater utilities
dispute resolution process as defined in the city Code of
Ordinances (S 32) inc-luding appeal rights to the Gas
System Managing Director. If the customer remains
dissatisfied after attempting to resolve the problem with
the Gas system Managing Director, they may register a
formal complaint by directing their concern in writing to
the city Manager who will schedule a meeting with the
customer to determine the facts and make a final ruling
on the resolution of the dispute.
(b) Contract Rate Level Determination: It is the policy of
Clearwater Gas System to offer a customer or potential
customer who currently uses or has access to an alternate
energy source and has the capability to use this
alternate energy source, a rate level which is 5% below
that, alternative, provided that such a rate application
will provide a reasonable profit margin to the Clearwater
Gas System and the extension of any capital investment to
serve such a customer falls within the normal gas system
construction feasibility formula. Where the capability
to use such alternative energy source will require an
initial additional capital outlay by the customer, the 5%
lower level may be based on a net present value
calculation over the expected life of the facility.
(c) Rate Schedule Reductions: The city Manager is authorized
to reduce the billing charge(s) for any rate schedule(s)
towards achieving the "cost of service based rates" as
recommended in the most recent rate study done for the
Clearwater Gas System.
"
i
.~
(d) Ma in and Service' Extens ion Construction Feas ibi 1 i tv:
Whenever a perspective customer requests a new gas
service, the Clearwater Gas System will extend service to
the prospective customer under the following conditions:
13
.t~. ~.
AITACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES. RATES AND CHARGES
1. Design considerations The extension of gas
service to the perspecti ve customer can be
reasonably accomplished within good engineering
design, access can be secured though easements or
right-of-way, and the service will not jeopardize
the quality of gas service to existing customers.
2. Main Line Extension- Construction Feasibility - The
maximum capital investment -which will be made by
the Clearwater Gas system to extend main lines and
services to serve a new customer(s) shall be seven
(7) times the estimated annual gas revenue to be
derived from the facilities less the cost of ,gas
and the cost of monthly. meter reading, customer
accounting and billing. The formula shall be:
Non-fuel Energy Rate
X Estimated Annual Therms/Gallons
Estimated Annual Gas Non-Fuel Revenues
X 7 Years
Maximum Investment for Construction Feasibili ty
Note:
The Monthly Customer Charge is assumed to
cover the cost of meter reading, customer
accounting and billing.
3. Service Line Extensions - The Clearwater Gas System
will install gas service lines off of the main line
at no charge to the customer under the following
circumstances:
o A year round customer has installed gas
equipment with an estimated minimum annual
consumption of two (2) therms per foot of
service line required, or
'\
The cost of such service line extension meets
the Maximum Investment for Construction
Feasibility (as defined "b.1I above).
Customers who do not meet the criteria for
service extensions as set forth above will
either be charged the estimated construction
cost per foot for the exces~ footage or pay a
CIAC to cover the. deficiency amount from the
above Construction Feasibility formula or
enter into a Facilities Charge contract
sufficient to cover this deficiency plus
interest within a period of seven (7) years.
4.. Customer Contribution Required - If the capital
o
,
I
- !
o
14
I
.......... .
ATTACHMENT 2
APPENDIX A - SCHEDULE OF FEES, RATES AND CHARGES
5.
construction costs to extend the main exceed the
Maximum Investment for Construction Feasibility,
the developer/customer(s) will be .required to
either provide a contribution ~n Aid of
construction. (CIAC) to cover the excess investment
amount or satisfy this deficiency by entering into
a Facilities Charge contract sufficient to cover
~his deficiency plus interest within a period of
seven (7) years. Such Facilities contract Charges
may be reduced or potentially discontinued entirely
to the extent that other customer (5) are added
beyond the initial customer(s), the facilities
covered by the Facilities Contract Charges are used
to serve these additional.customer(s); and to the'
extent that there are calculated excess dollars
above the additional customer(s) Maximum Investment
for Construction Feasibility minus the capital
construction cost.s for the mains to serve these
additional customer(s).
Conversion of Equipment to Natural Gas The
Clearwater Gas System will convert the customer's
existing orifice(s) to accept natural gas at no
cost to the customer, provided that for Commercial
and Industrial customers the use is year round; the
customer enters into a five (5) 'year contract to
exclusively use the natural gas service of the
Clearwater Gas System; and this amount, when added
to the other cost to serve amounts, is still
renders the project feasible.
I'
I
I'.
I
, ,
6. Relocation of Gas Service Facilities When
alterations or additions to structures or
improvements on customer's premises require the
Clearwater Gas System to relocate metering, service
line, or main line, or when such relocation is
requested by the customer for whatever reason, the
customer may be required to reimburse' the
clearwater Gas System for all or any part of the
costs incurred to accomplish such relocation of gas
system facilities.
\
15
'J'c
r,~,\"", ~{, .! ,.. .
..", ,
t ~..
".0' .
~ .c <:~.. ...
'1-)". .'
, ,
; , , ~-," ," .
"
DATE
, "
.'=~~' .
*i,'~. .
~\~
-.
~~r.,:
. ',11
~\:..
:.r-
:,,-:
~' .
,"
F I1V3
"
.... Il' -' .
.. ..', M. .
~ " .' .
AGENDA
~- L1-~~ u
ITEM #~~~_
~~\ 1-+ .. c
ORDINANCE NO. 5BBBR95
33
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWA TERt
FLORIDA, RELATING TO THE COMMUNITY
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY; PROVIDING FOR THE
REPEAL OF ORDINANCES NO. 2576-81 AND ORDINANCE
NO. 3021-83t WHICH ADOPTED AND AMENDED THE
REDEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR DOWNTOWN
CLEARWATER; PROVIDING FOR PROPER NOTICE; AND
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Commission of the City of Clearwater adopted Ordinance No.
2576-81, on December 17, 1981 t as amended by Ordinance No. 3021-83, adopted on
February 28t 1983. which comprise the Community Redevelopment Plan for Downtown
Clearwater, which area is described in Resolution 81-67) adopted by the City
Commission on August 6, 1981; and
,
WHEREASt the Community Redevelopment Agency has developed a revised
Community Redevelopment Plan; and
\
WHEREASt the City Commission of the City of Clearwater has reviewed the
revised Community Redevelopment Plan and believes it to be in the best interest of the
City of Clearwater to approve the new Community Redevelopment Plan; nOWt therefore, '
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CLEARWATERt FLORIDA:
Section 1. Ordinance No. 2576~81, and Ordinance No. 3021-83) comprising the
Community Redevelopment Plan for Downtown Clearwater are hereby repealed.
Section 2, This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
8-3-95
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
'-:
CITY OF CLEARWATER1 FLORIDA
By:
Rita Garvey, Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
t, L.1-1
Pamela K. Akin, City Attorney
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau, City Clerk
',.
1,
~(1~<~~1{)'~~;':; 'u;'!'::<C';;::':<'<<" ,',! ',:.'.,'
", ..<:..\::~..I;<c.~::.~'..
. J.
'. ':':'~",,(}..,:;~~::,>,:.,l';: :.,'..; . (:":
. . ";' ..' "
,.
t.."
..'
::'.c
.~i'
I'
The paperwork for Item #34a moved to 9/7/95 pack
"
F /1tJ,s-
.. ''',
J'
" \ . .
,\~,.
.'~ .
. /'1'
,,"-
:. ';~;>/":~\:~~~:~~7:;i(~'& '.~
. .. ...~:!:.tr>
" .
< \. .';..
I
i
~
,
,i
1
:1
C l-QrK
:3 q (l",-
Gr\EATER CLEA~W ATER
CHAMBEr\ OF COMMERCE
Executive CommltlJ:t:
AIIII M. WilkIn.
CMintttut of /Jw BOGTJi
SleyJhfll P.. Fowler
Chtzinnm&,Ellcf
Charla D, RI",- nJ
VC EaJ,.."tIUd
BIUUtus DI~tklptMroJ
J.nlee B. Cut
VC GtrHf7llM1IUJ1 Nfairtl
Edu&4Ii411 DnlloptMlIf
GrqoI'J BrOllu.
vcrol<l'im
Dwtl T. Mann
vC M.mb6nJlip
JudyMllchll
VC P~ic Rdr:liorul
SptcWE..lIl1
John P. CGnntlly
Trtamru
Phil M. IItndmon
l_djQ,. PfUl CMir1Mll
Jullus J, Zsch.u
l.6,dl CO!MU1l
Ptkr Woodham
PruidorroJ, CEO
Board or Directors
~.vld J. Abd.sm
Df.l\l.d M. Art.driao
E. 0, Annatroni m
OIule:s E. Ddu
Alan C.lJomncin
Ray Boocham
J u-ed Drown
Robert A. Bunocll
Robert W, B)'1d
Sl.evc:n D, ChlptlUll
).all)' Coo~
Robert N, .Pac. Cnwrard DDS
S.m A. DaoN. U
Muy A. Dcv\ne
Edward C. Dro6\e
Guy S. Gt'I)'
KCMeth 0, IWniltal
Roy O,lbrrcll, Ir,
Robc:lt E. Hcilnun, Jr.
WilllamHcllcr
Guy Iumin
Oonhxdoluutn
Albert N. Iustice
PclQ W. KmWgel'
I,lL McCUlUin,Ir.
Aziaidca Millol.cl
Frank V. MUlphy,lU
Iulie F. Nicho~
Kalhy Short Rabm
Talmadge Rullcdgc
Ouyl I, Seaton
Don 1.. SUIOO
Ronald W. Swart
D.vld p, Slme
R. Carlli'll War4
Douglu I. Williun.
TAMPA BAY
C{~-a;
1fii;.,<!t1v,I
128 N. OSCEOLA AV[. P,O. DOl( 2451, CllAP.WATtP.. Fl J461,. 61:l/46HXll1. FAX 81:1/449,2889
August 15, 1995
COPIES TO:
COMMISSIO~
The Honorable Rita Garvey and
Commissioners
City of Clearwater
P.o. Box 4748
Clearwater, FL 34617
AUG 1 7 1995
PHl:SS.
CLERK 1 ATTORN!::Y
Dear Mayor and Commissioners:
The Memorial Causeway Bridge is a recognized regional
arterial which not only links the Clearwater Beach to the
Mainland, but also carries tens of thousands daily through
our city from other areas of pinellas and Hillsborough
counties.
The bridge, in its present form, is functionally obsolete.
The proposed new Memorial Causeway Bridge will be of great
benefit to the community and the region, by increasing the
capacity and traffic flow onto and off Clearwater Beach.
The cost for a bridge such as this is a great expense for an
individual community to bear. Completing a SEIR study
severely limits city funding options for this tremendous
project and places the burden on Clearwater residents. Your
chamber encourages you to accept the recommendation of city
staff to move forward with a PO & E study. By completing
this type of study, the city would ensure the widest possible
funding options would be available for funding of the new
high span bridge.
Thank you for your consideration of this important project
and we hope to work with you to make this crucial project a
success.
Sincerely, t
,l/li.- I(Ul</~:> f{~rI-"tl /....)
Ann Wilkins Duncan
Chairman of the Board
cc: clearwater City Commission
city Manager
city Engineer
I
I
! '
r- rJ J..
Clearwater City Commission
Agenda Cover Memorandum
3~
I tern M
Heottng Date: ____
rg./7,C(S
SUBJECT:
Audit services contract for fiscal year ending September 30, 1995
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION:
Extend the contract with Coopers & Lybrand to perform audit services for the
fiscal year ending September. 30, 1995 for a total fee not to exceed $93,300
~ a'~ that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some.
BACKGROUND:
In 1991, as required by City Charter, the city undertook an RFP for external
auditors, and selected Coopers & Lybrand. Coopers & Lybrand have completed their
fourth audit and copies of the completed financial statements and audit reports
have been distributed to you. The initial contract anticipated extension for a
total of fiv~ years, based upon mutual consent of both parties.
The proposed fee of $93,300 for the required financial and compliance audits is
increased by 3.3% over the contract fee of $90,000 for fiscal year 1994. The
increase of 3.3% this contract period reflects the increased cost of services to
the Auditor since FY 1994 and is lower than the 1994 Consumer Price-Index increase
of 3.74%. The current proposed fee is acceptable to staff.
Coopers and Lybrand have met all conditions and service requirements of their
previous contract providing accurate responsive service.
The expense for this contract will be divided among the city, the Community
Redevelopment Agency (CRA), the Downtown Development Board (DDB), and Grant
funding based upon a breakdown which will be provided by Coopers and Lybrand.
Fees for the DOB portion will be paid by the City with reimbursement to be
received from the DDB. The breakdown for the $90,000 fee last year amounted to
$1,000 paid from the CRA, $1,000 from the DDB, and $88,000 paid from the City.
Payment from grant funding was not used last year due to grant funding budget
constraints. Funds for the city's portion of this contract have been included in
the Finance Department's 1995/96 Operating Budget.
Rwl ewed by: ~ orfginoting llopt: Costa: $ 93.300 Commission Action:
Legal Finance Total 0 Approved
Budget ''"'"l'YlA 0 Approved wtconditlons
Purchasing $
Risk Hgt N/~ Current Fiscal Yr. 0 Denied
CIS HI" User Dopt: 0 Continued to:
A04 r.JJ) FLnding Source:
Other 0 Capl tal I~.
Adv'crt.ised: ~ Operating ^ttacl1/llcots:
Dote: 0 Other Extension Contract
. ,'-\ Paper:
~ Hot Requl red
W.I tted by: Affected Parties 0 None
Apprqprlation Code:
CHtL1rg;;- 0 Notified 010-09821-530100-513-000
fii1 Not Requl red
~>o, ~ .
I
A G R E E MEN T
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this 17th day of August,
1995 by and between the CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, a municipal
corporation, hereinafter referred to as "ci ty, II and Coopers &
Lybrand L.L.P., a firm of certified PUblic Accountants, located at
101 E. Kennedy Boulevard, suite 1500, Tampa, Florida 33602-5194,
hereinafter referred to as "Contractor;"
WITNESSETH
WHEREAS, the City is required by Article II, section
2.01(c) (3) of the city Charter to provide for an annual audit of
its financial accounts; and
WHEREAS, the city participates in Community Development Block
Grant and other Federal, state and County Assistance programs which
require independent financial and compliance audits in accordance
with-rules established by the u.s. Department of Housing and Urban
Development and other agencies; and
WHEREAS, the Contractor is in the
accounting, is fully qualified to meet
applicable city, state and Federal law, and
\
I
!
!
.
I
\
business of public
the requirements of
desires to perform the
i
I
I
I
\
. I
i
necessary services:
NOW, THEREFORE, the parties agree as follows:
1. This agreement relates specifically to the city's fiscal
year ending September 30, 1995.
2. The Contractor shall audit the books and records of the
City, including the community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) and
Downtown Development Board (DOE), included as part of the City1s
Comprehensive Annual Financial Report. The Contractor shall read
the city's Comprehensive Annual Financial Report for compliance
with GAAP and the applicable requirements of the Certificate of
Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting program of the
Government Finance Officers Association and assist the city in
complying with new or existing requirements. The Contractor shall
express an opinion on the fair presentation of the City's general
I
.1
1
1
COOPERS & LYBRAND L.L.P.
~"~N- ~ 't
purpose financial statements in conformity with generally accepted
accounting principles, for the f isca 1 year ended September 30,
1995. The Contractor shall also express an opinion on the fair
presentation of the city's combining and individual fund and
account group financial statements and schedules in conformity with
generally accepted accounting principles. The contractor is not
required to audit the supporting schedules contained in the
comprehensive annual financial report, however, the contractor
shall provide an "in-relation-to" report on the supporting
schedules based on the audit procedures applied during the audit of
the general purpose financial statements and the combining and
individual fund financial statements and schedules. The Contractor
is not required to audit the statistical section of the report.
The Contractor shall also perform the required financial and
compliance audits associated with the Community Development Block
Grant and other Federal, state, and County Assistance programs in
accordance with the 'Single Audit Act of 1984 (PL 98-502) and rules
of other agencies.
3. In performing the services described in #4 above, the
Contractor shall comply with the following:
. generally accepted auditing standards
. the standards set forth for financial audits in the U.s.
General Accounting Office I s (GAD) Government Auditing
standards (1988),
. the provisions of the federal Single Audit Act of 1984,
and
.
j
I
I
\
J
j
1
j
"
. u.S. Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Circular A-
128, Audits of state and Local Governments,
. section 11.45 Florida statutes,
. regulations of the state Department of Banking and
Finance,
. Rules adopted by the state of Florida Auditor General for
form and content of governmental unit audits,
. Audits of state and Local Governmental units (Revised) -
AICPA
2
COOPERS', LYBRAND L.L.P.
,<
I..",. ,..
. Chapter 7j-600 of the Florida statutes referring to Fire
District Audit requirements, and
. Rules adopted by the state of Florida Auditor General for
audits of state grant and aid appropriations.
As part of the audit, the contractor will consider the city's
internal control structure, as required by generally accepted
auditing standards and Government AUditinq Standards.
4. Following the completion of the audit, the contractor
shall issue the following reports:
. A report on the fair presentation of the financial
statements in conformity with generally accepted
accounting principles.
. A report on the internal control structure based on
the audi tor' 5 understanding of the control
structure and assessment of control risk.
I
.I
I
!
I
. A report on compliance with applicable laws and
regulations, including those relating to funds
received from a State of Florida grants and aid
appropriation pursuant to a grant or contract.
. A report on the internal control structure used in
administering federal assistance programs.
. A report on compliance with laws and regulations
related to major and non major federal financial
assistance programs.
. A supplementary management letter if required to
comply with the regulations of the state of Florida
Auditor General.
. A report on compliance with general compliance
requirements as required by the Single Audit Act of
1984 and OMB Circular A-128.
5. The Contractor shall retain all working papers for a
minimum of three (3) years, unless notified in writing by the city
of the need to extend the retention period. The contractor shall
make working papers available, upon request, to the following
parties or their designees:
. city of Clearwater
. u.s. Department of Housing and Urban Development
;
I
1
\
!
{
~ ,
!i
I
I
!
3
COOPERS & LYBRAND L.L.P.
I,
~ o. ,+
. u.s. General Accounting Office (GAO)
. Parties designated by the federal or state governments or
by the city of Clearwater as part of an audit quality
review process
. Auditors of entities of which the city of Clearwater is
subrecipient of grant funds
In addition, the Contractor shall respond to the reasonable
inquiries of successor auditors and allow successor auditors to
review working papers relating to matters of continuing accounting
significance.
6.' The Contractor shall assist the City in scheduling the
Comprehensive Annual Financial Report to be completed and issued no
later than February 1, 1996. Contractor/city meetings will be held
at least once per month until completion of this contract. Weekly
status meetings shall be held while the Contractor is working at
the city..
The Contractor shall complete performance under this contract
by March 30, 1996.
10. The Contractor shall bill the city and the City shall pay
the Contractor for the performance of the services under this
contract on the basis of the Contractor I s normal and customary
charges for such services, plus ordinary out-of-pocket expenses
customarily stated separately the Contractor in his general
practice, the same to be separately stated and itemized. The total
amount of this contract including out-of-pocket expenses shall not
exceed $93,300. The city may, by amendment of this agreement,
increase this maximum fee and/or extend the completion date upon
the Contractor I s showing evidence of conditions which require
substantially more time than would generally be required to perform
the prescribed services. Progress payments will be made
periodically for work completed to date bqsed on invoices submitted
by the Contractor. The sum of such progress payments shall not
exceed 90% of the maximum specified above. The final payment will
be made within 30 days of receipt of the final audit reports.
,
.!
\
I
\
!
)
p~
4
COOPERS & LYBRAND L.L.P.
'.
, <c
t11~""" "
I'
I
I
. ~., " ~ c .
>j. .,'
. " <;': .
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this
agreement to be executed the day and year first above written:
Countersigned:
Approved as to form
, legal sufficiency:
Pamela K. Akin
city Attorney
Witnesses:
~a,~
l3~4 dd-
File: COP9SAUD
CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA
,
,
By:
Attest:
Cynthia E. GOUdeau
City' Clerk
,',
Coopers & Lybrand L.L.P.
By:
Q \,{ {'{A1./l...e f}; Ul4
(
Attest:
5
COOPERS & LYBRAND L.L.P.
, "" '"'..~ -'...
,
i
,
.1
I
'.~" >
~C\s 1-
Clearwater City Commission
Agenda Cover Memorandum
3''1
\:
Item fI
Heetlng Oate:
~~. \ rC3.5
SUBJECT:
PURCHASE OF BLACK 3408 POLYETHYLENE PIPE
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION:
Extend the original contract for a period of one year from 12/14/95 to 12/13/96
to purchase the estimated requirement for Black 3408 polyethylene pipe from
M.T. Deason Company Inc., of Birmingham, AL, at an estimated cost of
$1,018,375.00
mI and that the appl'oprfllte officials be authorized to execute salTlC.
BACKGROUND:
This represents Clearwater Gas System's (CGS) estimated annual requirement for
black 3408 polyethylene pipe. The black pipe, used for the construction of gas
mains and services, is required to meet new customer requests in the high
pressure North area which is designed for 100 lbs. of gas pressure. This area
is generally north of Curlew Road and also includes our Pasco Expansion
requirements.
We have had a purchase order open for (2) years to M.T.Deason Company Inc.,
which cumulatively totalled $2,150,048.70. As a result of the delays to the
Pasco County Main Extension project, we have only ordered $235,000 or about 11%
of the orginal estimated quantities during the last year and a half.
M.T. Deason Company has agreed to extend their bid prices for black pipe from
their original contract for another year as they have a considerable inventory
of pipe committed for our Pasco Extension which we are just now beginning.
During our recent annual bid for our low pressure yellow 2406 polyethylene pipe
bid of June, 1995, all of the vendors included an escalation clause in their
bid. As a result, the value of M.T. Deason's company holding their prices for
Reviewed by:
legal
Budget
Purchllsfng
R fsk Mgmt.
CIS
ACM
Other
~
~
N/A2JcJ~
Originating Ocpt: ~
Clearwater Gns system,~
Costs:
S 1.018.375
10ta\
Commission Action:
D Approved
o Approved w/condftlons
o Denied
o Continued to:
User Dept:
Clearwater Gas System
S 0
Current Fiscal Yr.
SlbIi tted by:
~
e\t aOll vf
Advertised:
Dote:
Paper:
~ Hot Requl red
Affected Parties
o Notified
~ Not Requt red
flrtding Source:
~ Capital 11Tl>.
o Operot Ing
o Other
Attochllents:
Vendor Letter
o None
AWoprlotion Code:
. 423,00000,141120-000-000
~ Printed on recycled paper
.
.
"
. '. ~.~ ~ .. J
. '.0 '~.'..c~> . ~ ~ :.:\
. jO. ~. .. . . . : ~ c . \ if
" ~~,'
~~~r!J:.c~ <.'.. .
.." ,<
- 2 -
another year without any escalation costs is a significant benefit.
Therefore, the Manager of Gas Operations recommends awarding the following
quantities from the original bid 07-94 opened October 29, 1993:
f
\
~
~
I
Group 1, Items 1-6 to M.T. Deason company at cost of $1,018,375.00
These materials will be received to the inventory code 423-00000-141120-000-000
and charged to the appropriate code when issued from the warehouse.
A Pasco county Gas System Expansion Bond issue will fund this project. The
Pasco bonds are now projected to be sold in the third quarter of FY 95/96.
The transfer of Gas Revenues for this project is, in effect, a loan from the
City's cash pool, and is anticipated to be an interim solution as these monies
will be reimbursed to the Gas Fund once the new monies are available and the
Gas System Bond Funds established. Budget transfers will only be required for
Fiscal Year 1996 to project 315-96320, Pasco Expansion New Mains and Services.
Budget transfers in Fiscal Year 1996 will be addressed on an as needed basis
for this project.
I
I
il
~
f
io!
~:
~
~
~
i
~
tl
-!
l
I
J
f
1
\-'''1"c.. c
M. T. Deason Company Inc.
JUN 1 5 1995
Clc,:lI'wnter Gas System
June 13, 1995
P.O, BOX 101807 · BIRMINGHAM. ALA. 35210
(205) 956~2266 · FAX (205) 956.1911
Mr. C.S. "Chuck'! Warrington, Jr.
Managing Director & Executive Officer
Clearwater Natural Gas System
P.O. Box 4748
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
SUBJECT: 3408 POLYETHYLENE PIPE AND FITTINGS-PURCHASE ORDER #6440
.. ,
Dear Mr. Warrington:
We, M.T. Deason Company, Inc., want to thank you for Purchase Order #7910,
dated June 15, 1995. 'This purchase order covers PE 2406 yellow pipe for the
period 6/15/95 through 6/14/96. Please note, due to the substantial increase in
construction in the gas distribution industry, polyethylene resin prices have
continued to escalate in 1995. We, M. T. Deason Company, Inc. (and your other
pip.e suppliers). for the first time, had to bid an escalation clause based on the
unstable resin market. These increases will be documented by letters from resin
suppliers to Poly Pipe Industries, Inc.
At the present time we are shipping PE 3408 black polyethylene pipe and fittings
on your purchase order #6440, issued to us December 13, 1994. The following
quantities were listed on your bid:
'1
~,
Item 1.
Item 2.
Item 3.
Item 4.
Item 5.
Item 6.
QTY.
10,000'
175,000'
25,000'
125,000'
50,000'
50,000
DESCRIPTION
811 3408 Black Polyethylene Pipe
6" 3408 Black Polyethylene Pipe
411 3408 Black Polyethylene Pipe
2" 3408 Black Polyethylene Pipe
1" 3408 Black Polyethylene Pipe
1/2" 3408 Black Polyethylene Pipe
Our total bid on the above listed pipe was $1,018,375.00. The Clearwater
Natural Gas System, by allowing Poly Pipe Industries and M, T. Deason Company
to test our pipe as an equal to our competitor, saved $409,000.00 on this bid,
All testing, as documented to the City, was done by an independent testing
laboratory recommended by your natural gas division.
To provide excellent service and timely deliveries, Poly Pipe Industries purchased a
substantial amount of PE 3408 resin to avoid any price increases from suppliers.
Based on these commitments, and the fact that we still have substantial
inventories of PE 3408 resin at a competitive price, we are willing to extend your
purchase order through December 13. 1996.
.. () 1.
-.J pr'da U::,"'Uj ,""
(!ill;,') 1-~.()(I"clJ ..
\ .
\ ',,'
..............~.~ .
, ~. J " . .
. '? ~ ~ 4
Mr. C.S. tlChuck" Warrington
June 13, 1995
Page Two
We respectfully request an answer from the Clearwater Natural Gas System
regarding the extension of this purchase order by August 31, 1995. This will
allow us substantial time to allocate this resin to other commitments if your Gas
System elects not to extend this purchase order.
I want to thank you in advance for any consideration given us on our proposal.
We will continue giving you excellent service and timely deliveries on your
polyethylene pipe requirements.
With warmest personal regards, I remain,
Yours truly,
M.T. DEASON COMPANY, INC.
. \,\.
MTD:af
Enclosures
cc: Chuck Gagnon, Clearwater Natural Gas System
Jeff Shunk-M.T. Deason Company, Inc.
. :j
~
l
I
r
\
I
I
I
\
l
~ (V\ /l
-~
Clearwater City Commission 3 Q
Agenda Cover Memorandum ()
I t em II
Heating DntCI
~'Jr/.cr5
SUBJECT: Renewal of annual software license for Unisys A-4 and A-6 mainframe
computers
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Renew a contract for unisys A-4 and A-6 computer
software licenses to Unisys Corporation of Tampa, Florida, at an amount of
$52,681.00 for the period of october 1, 1995 through September 30, 1996 in
accordance with Code section 2.564(1) (b), sole source
N Dtld thot the tJpproprlntc offlclDls be authorized to cxacutc snroo.
B~CKGROUND: This license gives the city of Clearwater authority to use the
proprietary unisys corporation operating system software that is required in
order to run the Unisys A-4 and A-6 mainframe computer systems. The software
was leased for a five (5) year term when the mainframes were purchased in 1988,
and the city has been paying for the license on a month to month basis since
that lease expired on June 30, 1993. Due to the city's migration away from the
mainframe environment, it is deemed most beneficial to the city to avoid long
term commitments to Unisys. The monthly lease program will allow the city to
terminate the lease for either or both computers with 30 days advance notice.
The A-4 is used primarily for running payroll. Two other smaller applications
also run on the system - Occupational Licenses and Inventory. All of these
systems are slated for replacement, if approved by th~ Commission, in the next
year as the city migrates away from mainframe computing. Information Management
plans to sell the A-4 on the used market when it is no longer needed. There are
no plans to move this system to the new Municipal services building, primarily
due to the expense associated with preparing a computer room to match the
environmental requirements of a mainframe system.
The A-6 computer is utilized by the Police Department for Computer Aided
Dispatch (CAD). The Police are actively involved in implementing a new police
Information system. Once the CAD portion of the new system is running live, the
A-6 will no longer be needed by the city. The Police may be able to trade in
the A-6 for a credit on their new hardware, or it will be sold on the used
market. It will not be moved to the new Police Headquarters.
The proposed 1995/96 Information Management and Police Department budg~ts
include sufficient funds for this contract.
Reviewed by:
Legnl
Budget
Purchasing
RI~1i: Hgmt.
IS
ACH
Other
N/A
~/
~
~J;
-1 ,L.
v
originating Dept:
Informlltlon MnnJn9'~~,
l ; ,:-r
U~cr Dcpt: / ,
Informntlon Mgmt.jPollce
Costs:
S 52,681.00
Totlll
Commission Aetior.:
o Approved
o Approved w/';ono\ t Ions
o Denied
o Continued tu:
S 000.00
Current fisenl Yr,
\~ ~\>
Advertised:
Dntel
Paper:
C'l Not Requi red
Affected Pnrtles
o Notified
~ Not Required
flmlng Source:
o Cnpl tnl hll'_
~ operntlng
o Other
Attachments:
N/A
SlOni t too by: . b
(..~u:; ie
City <allnllgcr '
~ None
Appropriation Code:
. 555-09862-546200-590-000
010-01144.530300-521-000
.~. I d
~~ Printed on reeye e pnpcr
. .,
r) Clearwater City Commission
--:LJV\ r.:::;j...., Agenda Cover Memorandum
39
It em #
Meeting Dote:
1'1'7.95
SUBJECT: Yearly maintenance contract for Digital computers
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Renew a contract to Digital Equipment corporation of
Tampa, FL in the amount of $45,310.44 for hardware maintenance/operating system
support on the utilities and Finance VAX 4000-300 computers, from
October 1, 1995 through September 30, 1996, in accordance with Code Sec.
2.564(1) (b), sole source
~ and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND: The city utilizes two (2) Digital Equipment corporation (DEC) VAX
computers to run the utility billing and financial systems. Together, these
systems support 166 daily users. In order to maintain these computers in the
best possible operating condition, a yearly service contract with the hardware
vendor is recommended. Only DEC can provide both on-site hardware repair and 24
hour, seven day a week operating system dial up support and hardware diagnostic
services.
The utility billing computer is used nine (9) hours per day to directly support
utility customers. Due to the customer/citizen oriented nature of this systemr
the hardware and operating system support contract provides four (4) hour/sarna
day response five (5) days per week, from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. with continuous
effort service. The Finance system maintenance contract provides 5 day, 9 hour
per day coverage with next day response. This is a less costly service option
which has been in place for the past three years with no significant
operational problems.
Due to the City'S daily reliance on both these computers, this year's
maintenance agreements for both systems also include a service called
Recover-All. Recover-All places the city on a high priority list for
replacement of equipment in the event of a localized or regional disaster. The
cost to cover both computers systems is $2,432.64/year.
The price for one (1) year of service on the utilities system is $26,106.72,
and on the Finance system is $19,203.72. The prices are based upon a three (3)
year multi-year service agreement executed by the City on July 1, 1993 which
Reviewed by: Originating Dept: . Costs: $ 45.310.44 COIR1\i S8 ion Ac t ion:
legal ~ Information Ml1nagel1)en~/' Total 0 Approved
/1\,
Budget ' , 0
Purchasing $ 00.00 Approved w/conditions
Risk Hgmt. ~-' / I r Current Fiscal Yr. 0 Denied
User Dept:
IS J'~ Information Management 0 Continued to:
ACH fU"lding Source:
Other No/A 0 tapi till Imp.
Advertised: ~ OperPtlng A tt achlllC!flt s:
Date: 0 Other Multi'year service add~ndum
,< , Paper: Service agreement
'1 , ,
~ Hot Required
Slbnitted by: Affected Parties 0 None
Appropri at ion Code:
Cltyt!tu ~ 0 Notified 555'09862-546200-519-000
~ Not Requi red
~ Printed on recycled paper
"!<: '
:'.j
"/.~I.~I'(""",.:,c. ',,<' t{ '0;.' <,.
Ie . , . ,~,'. '.',
,~ ',', .
::r' .
.<-'.. '
":.,. '.'r....,;l'~
- 2 -
places a cap on hardware maintenance cost increases of 7% per year for all city
owned DEC computers, and allows a 5% discount on contracted maintenance
services. This agreement onlY guarantees a price discount for service
~" contracts. The service contracts still have to be renewed every year. Service
will be billed on a monthly basis with a 180 day cancellation clause.
The cost of the maintenance contracts for the two VAX computers is $3,311..76
less than the FY94/95 contract. The reason for this apparent decrease is that
Digital sold one of its software products (called ROB) to Oracle Corporation.
Oracle is developing a new pricing structure for support and will be invoicing
the city for ROB support for FY95/96, hence it is no longer included in the
Digital support contract.
I' The proposed 1995/96 Information Management Operating budget includes
sufficient funds for this contract.
I..
!
,
i'
\"",.
. .
MULTI-YEAR SERVICE ADDENDUM
BETWEEN ,
CITY OF CLEARWATER
AND
DIGITAL EQUIPMENT CORPORATION
Preamble
The purpose of this service Addendum is to provide Purchaser with special
pricing for services. The following ter.ms and conditions are in addition
to Digital's U.S. standard Terms and Conditions and any applicable
Service Description(s). In the event of conflict, thase special Terms
and Conditions shall prevail.
1. Scope of Addendum
This addendum applies only to maintenance services currently provided by
Digital to Purchaser on its existing hardware products. This addendum
does not 'apply to any other services including, but not limited to:
services currently offered by Digital but not provided to Purchaser, new
services that may be offered in the future by Digital, and like services
on different products. Such services, at Digital's option, may be
included herein if requested by Purchaser.
2. rerm
This Addendum is effective 01 JULY 1993 (Commencement Datell) and shall
continue for a period of THREE Years from the Commencement Date.
3. Maintenance
Digital shall maintain purchaser's Eligible Equipment [as defined in the
applicable Service Description(s)] for the Term of this Addendum, subject
to any and all qualifications set forth therein.
4. Charges:
Hardware maintenance charges for equipment covered by this Addendum shall
not increase by more than SEVEN percent (7%) annually. for year TWO (2)
and SEVEN peroent (7%) annually for year THREE (3) (other than for
incremental charges due to configuration changes) for the Term of this
Addendum. .
Also, hardware and software maintenance charges shall receive a price
reduction of FIVE peroent (5%) for the Term of this Addendum. This
discount will not pertain to products unannounced at the inception of
this agreement.
Page 1 of 3
~
MULTI-YEAa SERVICE ADDENDUM
BETWEEN
C7TY OF CLEARWATER
AND
DIGITAL EQUIPMENT CORPORATION
Software maintenance charges for equipment covered by this Addendum shall
not increase by more than SEVEN peroent (7%) annually for year THO (2)
and SEVEN percent. (7%) annually for year TH.!Ul:E (3) (other than for
incremental charges due to configuration changes) for the Term of this
Addendum. .
5. Termination for Cause
Either party may terminate services for cause if, after giving the party
in default thirty (30) days written notice, such party does not cure the
alleged default.
6. Te~ination for Convenienoe
Termination is 180 day written notice without penalty charge.
7. Obsolete Equipment./Software Ret.irement
Notwithstanding paragraphs 5 and 6 above, Digital shall have the option,
after one hundred and eighty days (180) prior written notice, to provide
on a time and materials basis, hardware services for those products that
have not been manufactured in volume by Digital for a period greater than
five (5) years. Also, Digital may withdraw from service individual
software products which have been discontinued or reclassified as
"Cust\Jmer Supported" upon one hundred and eighty days (180) prior written
notice (such notice shall not be issued prior to the end of the first
year of service) .
8. Termination ~or Fiscal Non-Funding:
In the event sufficient budgeted funds are not available for a new
fiscal period, the City shall notify the vendor of such occurrence
and contract shall terminate on the last day of the current fiscal period
without penalty or expense to the City.
pag8 2 of 3
.
j::~~
~LM~d1~t~4
Da~/~/R3
.; ./
Signat:ur88
..
Ii.
........
. .,.... .~.., ~
I,
..t . '" '.' ~
. .("("'.~'"
j
, r
MULTI-YEAR SERVICE ADDENDUM
BS1'WEEN
CITY OF CLEARWATER
AND
DIGITAL EQUIPMENT CORPORATION
!
I
,)
!
War Digital Equipment: Corp.:
/JJwtt ~k-
Name
~ii~~~1
&- 2t}~q3 . !
Date
Page 3 of 3
. .,f
--= ::J/....~~~
~ ..:.I ,~I'
N ! ~ l '~.
5 ~ ~ ~
.. ~~.
~ ~~~;fS
~ g I: i J 1
i~!~J.
· IJlli]
t~
UiUa;UHUUH! . j
J:
....i111
.J~
:~3
',:U;,
~~"_MM_~_~_~"__~~_ I
.-.;
...,
..,
~ < ',~il
~ b ~~
.. ,.. ~,l
M_gt_tLlLlUIl_CIt..lll.JltJt...1IL1lIIo CII Ai tit ... . "
.1..aa......I...~~ ~,'
...I.........I..~~ ~
ccccc~tS~sc'ss~c~~ ,~
~l~
jjj H I
!!!jjjjjjjjjjjijJ! ~
..,"';
'rt!
'x'
At
~~~~~~ss~~~~~~~~~~ ~
C~~'~.CW~~.5s~S~.~ ~
'i-
g
.~~
i
~
.~
.,
::\
.~t
." ,
:~:-
'.t~
."
I
J
"i~
~ ~
_....____.n....,',..... u_!
1~~I~;ii~i~i~~lill I
!!!!!!!!535555!!~~ f
t~ -~~:
~ i<~
~J, ~
;': .. :
:~, ~
;~ I~
-,.... ~..,.....
..... c
~
I i
~ ~
t; S2
"'" Q
~
A ~A f
~ --'--"-~--f~-a'n-~ ~ ~-~ ~ ~ m ~ ~ ! ~ ~ ~
~
I J J: 1
~ ) j
.
i
I
: '" i~
: ~ ~. ai
I ~ B! ~
~ e i ~a J ~I ~t
~ . d I! h l .,
~ .Ka~af u~~ ~I'
" i~U~ ~i j~iu~ ~
,hS6 ~~ }d~ ~u ~
~
'i
1 ~ I ~
I I f s~
I ;; ) . ~~
~~
am
"
e i
~ r;
j ~ !~
j ~ U
.
}~;~~~i~~' :-~~~~.~ }.~~:lf.~~.~::\:~:.~ ~ t~I~~ ~..?~ f
."" ... '.""'" 'IY~-"'l">' ..l...,tl~,
):::~f~:~II}.:' . .~\tl'5~.:,I~I"\ll
i~'i.-l~Ji: :;;;1 11~..~ ~ ;U~l
. , '''I..... 'I.... . ,1.',
'.' ........r: . !4-W . .. ",.
'J.s:'::::~;(1 .!" ':!'!f:' ,I ,~'~~l
~..,:t-~;~~( ~:t :\t. 1 ::' ~. ~I
i . . .o,., J~' . · ....
.I, t- '", 1. ..... ~'
< '..J::;' ,I t .. . I ~ o'
'I ""'I.... ~;.,. '.' ... rt".....,
~ ........... .fU-. c.. ......"
;1" '~~ ;1J~tl :: !~'I;.~,~ S
, \., -.." ...t. ~
.1-+ ,........ "O;'~ ...1'-"-"'"
;:)" .:.'~)~ :Mil' :. = , .; pq
oJ.' th:~~ :-...: .' : ,. ~ 'tS;-.;.
~ :!.. ,. .-.. '. .1... , '''l
~ ~~ ,~~. ~4 \. ':, . i ;< ~;' "'1
:a- ;1 ""V--:.,..~ ~ .. ~. ~.; ~.
~ I ~(~ ~~i~:; ~~ '~~:J~j~l
I ! ~~I' "t!r' ,. ' .r. r )~ : t, .
~; ;",!~";JriJ~' ~ ~~ :e~' ~ P ~
Iol U . J (.l~'.' " ,,;Z;
.. z: t .......~..~ : .. ; ,. . lL. ','
too I ,"; :, ";'~~~l:~~'a' t..~ ~1: M~J.~\ l
;.- -.~_I'~: ,u~ ,! I~ :
..... ~ " .,' '-I>':" };', 'I ""': ~,
...... .}:::J'j" .J,to.'... ... j ,.; .1
.".... ,....,. .,.. ,. 1-r
-It', ,". ,.., . ., -.
~!IIt. :~.tt, ~ t .\' 't ~
JI J j ,.~., :,~J : :, ~' ~ "~'1r: n
'l~ I~ &~: :',: '.. ~'.' ., : ~ 1~~ ~J5
u .. _ ~ 'MI' .
F ' ." :.~ ,t '.' .. .
eO'd
]
j
~
:II
~ ~ ~I t~
~~~!~~~~i ~~~i~~
~~~II!~ ~~;ID~ ;i~
11t~~~~,.. ~3Ioi:Jm~ lis
s~i!~,i~~~~~a~f~~~
~O:lf SSG1-GI-LO
I'
,
I
~
:...;,
~_.
-
~ I (iC
II!; ~ 5 i i ;i ~~
~~~
f .. Q " 'I
-- ... ..-
~ 1~=~ I
:!II.:
~ ',;;
...
, ..
i
8 ...-...... . I
:~
............ ~ ~
t t;Jt:J~p
:t;
~,,~~ :IS i
~ ~~~;c ;c
~ ~~~~ ;II; :1
- '"
b
r
'~
I..~.
!Jl~ "j
] JII! i
j AJ~! -i
,"
un ~ '~
~~
~ ~1
".
! ;;~; ~ ; ;
~ ij ~
Viii 'IS C lil
ill ill -.--........--.
\!
:illj
.... \'J'
i
':
I ~ !
~ ' ! ~~ -;'1
j Id
i lam hili; .
'i ~ ~~ ~
l I&I~ I ~.
'",\(
, fi!! ! n I
, Inn,
I I illi
a!. ~ i~ I
I~i~ Sf I iU i I
~ i:
i 'd'
it
I
- :f~:
:2 ~n~ .. .
: ~
J ~ 00
!;~! j
i:
~
' '
J !!!! ~ I
~
t., ,
:;. ,
,
.,...
.,
t
E0'd
SO:TT S56l-6T-LO
z .... .' i~ ~
~ .:.: :.f; ."'-......,~ i~a!IJI;I;I;;;;
~
tl ~ ~! ~};
; " ~ r..-! :~ ! f
,. ,
:J ~ t
~ ~ J: !: a::
"". ...
.,:. ~ .! f~l f!rr~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . 0-
.f. -.
~ ~ :'; ~ I ~
.'" '
,r~ 'L'"
. .
S ~..: ; 11 ~
! I j f ]~ ..." .
:-.. .... ,~......
i ........I........c
....-.......
~ B ...........fIII........M....MI........,....
~
l ! j. . ~ I I ! -<
) I~ ~
I -~' ...,.,...MllI;;' llINMllIII1II1III 11II ....---
IJ11lJ j ........I.....~~~~ ' ,
I .11.......8..1~~~~
~ lL ~ &CCCt'~SIS~Ct~~~~~
~ j
=- J
] }
J I
Q
n !
oC ~~~~~~s~sss;ij~~~~;
". ~
9 !!
~ ~ li1 = il ;: I; .. ii ;l 11 . . II = $ ;l Ii: I ~ .~n
i
s lu j & i ~~ 'I
c
~ d J =
~ r ~!~i F i ~
to g ) ~
~ I)ij rU~I~~U
~UI I I- J1J I J Dli
l) "'~
is w.
1m E s!! j . ~~
j ~~ !i~~!!11 II gi~~~
~ ti .
. ~~
1t"&'''">I'rH'~ . ~ilgBIB~i~iH~y~=e~
t.. ...'1r"'....C";.... ~~.... ".1"_ .......~.. ~.
..... ~~.~ .~ ~e~ ..~ ~.~~.~5~~
<~l'!'il'f'" ,. · "'1".' ,
.~..,'- ,.. Ii' ~ ~'. ~~ ;~ ~~~II~;~~~;~~~~
,,".::;~,'~t',i ..,~, .. ;t ~ ~~~.
~~t~J~~~t. .~~ = ^ ! rJ ;:~
"'~''''';:-,~' . o. ~tf:., . ,::.; 0,
..~ ..<r......." . .,' :.e. ~ ' ...,....
r;rg;y,JI,' I ,!~~~ ~i~~3a ~m ~m~ ~QQQ
I . "" ~ .... ~ M. ~w ~"~ ~!!I
... "\- ~ ~...., I....'.
1~~'''''ir
:' nl;.~'. '" "i '~:.'~~
>. P..i.... 1 1: ..,,::.. : :.~....:I. e I
i; ~iJ.:llf ;lit i
' "i r '1,,'1'
:i "1 ""+ " I .' , ~d;:,..
, ",. ..' > ~.
.:1- ~..::t..~ ~t.. .. ': I, ~ ..,
.. ' . ".... ....... .. ~ ~ >
€ ~ h ! ~ ~:):'( ~ , ~. : ,.. ~,
1 ~{t; l'II~ll[ ~ iiii~lli!illliflii '-
~ t;'~ ~ ~.' r~; j ~~ , .:~ .~ ~ ;. :.
I~ ~! ~ j ~ '11;::~1 :d1:l1 j
B e : : };;;I: i. t ; :. ;:,.;' ;
~ ....', -to, . ~ '" " : :,t
z; ~.~?f:~ j : : : I ; i
. j 5 I~ d 1 j ~, [~ :. ~. ,I.~ J !!!!!!!!55!~g!5!55
; I I~": , , r! ( ~ ,.' f
i;~ ,~i:~. ::a:~: I~} ~
. f.J . . ,
"'\
1.0
:)
...
t1
j
~
1l0'd
SO:TT S5GT-6T-LO
. .~
r.::
i.!
J:"~
. ..
"
-.
-H
:!~"':
- ,
1ii:
..J<
tl,r.
t';:;
~
-::
I
"'r~"
;.l.~
I
~oH
~
l.~
;5
'a
i
,...
~
;l,
v
.~
I
~
i!;
;":;'
(..i
~~
,...
..,
"',
i
J
~
~
a
'!'
, ,
.~:;;.
r,:
i
~
~l
Ii
; a ~ III i a i II ii ! ' ~
., I
1..
J
lit
. ~== ~; -. :1
,;0" ~
~ i:-1f · :...t
~ ! ~::"'i
......
.100.>..... '1
~ I
j ~ .....~ .....
(: S
~ .
..
:,. ~ ~ :: ,
~ oJ !
... m__. ~ 1
_III I 1
~ ..~ ~ ..
.- lite ;1l I' I
~ cc~ :$ ~,
j , 1;1
~
I
IU
"'I' j
1 S
11 !
i
...~ I
~~ l
~ ~~l ~ ~~ I i
, 1 ~
..~9~ ! I
I
. III. ; ..
ial
t I ~
... N 1'1 I
~ E ~
~ ~i II!u~ ~ i~ I h ~ e I
. .
~
.. ;si"~1 : !
uhl .l".
~ ~!& ~ r '~!
I ~ fj, .
...
,,"
i- hlnl i ..
*~ ~ ,
211! II liU* s r I
! I! In~
InU li!n~ia ;
18 ,In' ~~ J '.
h nl Q I in
I I ~2
@
~
' I
~~~ ~ '="'1"
:J:
:1< i
i~~ g~
; Is ~ ' ,
I ~
~ !!! ! !I 1
-
SO'd
90:T1 S66T-61-LO
"'"""l
,.
~ """'c ~.... .,
. . ., ~
5
~ I ..F:
Ii ' .
f ;
;
,-, ~ .... ..- -.--
~ ~
~ ......
.r.t
1.a
~
... -_..
8
~
I i
~
-1 .,
~ -.- ~!
~
] I
j
1 8
~
ai
! ~
~ ,
~
; ~
i!
ij
! I
:..
.! ~
~
'.
.~ ~
II ,~
, ~
~i!
a ~~
,
I ~I ,
~
. I
Sf
,....
a :i
i ~a
I
I,
,. ,"
- - .. . " ,
~ ..
..;.
~.l
I ...
I
" '
J ~ :
!
I
I
t
I
f
I
r
(
I
,
'\
~
:>
~ ~
,
,
"
>
~
"0
.
,
- .
I . A
,
W
~
~
~ ~.
..
""'
~~
tIJ. 't
"
~ .....
.,'
9
'" ~
-..
~!i.;
l;I') ......u
......~
OO'd
....
LO:IT 566l-6J-LO
I .
~ ~ ~.
~'i",""""
11;:':'1>" ..1 _, _.~ _ ". . ,
'<)
c'> .; .'
".,., .
... ~... ~. 4
,. "I'
...~~ 'f... ,
. ,
iii. ,'.
AGENDA
DATE
~~ /1_ ~Jj
"
',,:! '
ITEM #
~.,.' <
;.c, ...~
g.",
.;.~
-II;'.
":J'
'.1.
. ":i
!:^
.-
PO",;' .
F.I?fC g'
\
\
I
1
\
,
I
!
-rM3
CleaJwatcr City Commission
Agenda Cover Memorandum
It cm #
11cetlng Dote:
-0
'6-17.9'5
SUBJECT:
High Speed Laser Printers for utility Billing
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION:
Award a purchase of two (2) high speed laser printers and installation, to
Dynamic Solutions International of Englewood, CO at a cost of $39,380.00 being
the lowest and most responsive bidder in accordance with specifications, and
authorize lease/purchase through city agreement with Barnett Bank
~ and thDt the appropriDte officials be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND:
The city of Clearwater utility Customer Service Division of the Finance
Department works with the Information Management Department to produce
approximately 45,000 utility bills and reminder notice per month. These bills
are currently being printed on two (2) r 300 line per minute printers, which
were installed in July, 1990, and were predicted to have a five (5) year useful
life span. Bill printing takes approximately three hours per day. These same
printers are also used to print all utility Billing system reports each day.
Line printers are highly mechanical devices, which are prone to more frequent
breakdown as they age. Although we receive excellent maintenance on these
printers, utilities is experiencing increasing frequent problems with the
printers, resulting in an interruption in bill production. The printers were
the most cost effective technology when they were purchased, however, they
cannot print the post net bar code. Although the bills are sorted with zip+4
zip codes, the city is unabl~ to take advantage of the. post net bar code
discount, which would reduce our mailing costs from .274/pieces to .254/piece,
resulting in a postage savings of $860/month.
The new laser printers are capable of printing the post net bar code. They will
handle 8-1/2 by 11, cut sheet paper stock (instead of continuous feed paper,
which is currently used). This will allow utilities to reduce its dependance on
preprinted bill information, and allow the city to customize bills more easily.
The printers will also support duplex (two sided) printing - another feature
that may be advantageous as postage rates continue to rise. The laser printers
Revi l!'Wed by:
legal
Budget
Purchasing
Risk Hgmt.
IS
ACM
Other/FinDnce
N/A
~
~
Originating Dept:
Informntion Manag
Cos ts: ....!..12.. 380.00
Totol
User Dept:
Finance/Information Management
$ 000.00
Current Fiscal Yr.
Coomissioo Action:
o Approved
o Approved w/conditions
o Denied
o continued to:
r\ ..',
Advertised:
DDtC: 06-16-95/06-09-95
Paper: PlnellDs County Review/
T lIulla T r i bune
o lIot Requl red
AffL~ted Parties
~ 1I0t I f I cd
o 1I0t Rcqu! red
Funding Source:
~ Capi tDl Imp.
o operating
o Othr:r
Attachments:
Bid Tob
Printer Options PriCing
o None
Suml tted by:
cIgt~
.-.
~w Printed on recycled paper
Appropr I a ti on CodQ:
315-94731'564000-519-000
, '
~(t!/Fh.;> ..~.". ,~.
\ w
- 2 -
will be able to print bills in approximately one hour (including handling
time), a reduction of two hours per day. The Training Technician will spend
those two hours on staff training and support of the Enterprise Network. Two
printers are recommended for both production speed and redundancy, due to the
critical importance of bill production.
Once the printers are added to the network in the Municipal Services building,
they will be available to all users of the Enterprise Network and can be used
for any large volume reports, including those containing charts and graphs. To
support enhanced printing for both the bills and reports, some additions (above
and beyond the bid configuration), are being added to the printers, including
2,000 sheet paper input bins (to minimize operator intervention), and
additional memory and disk to handle charts and graphics. Even with the
addition of these items, the Olympus Pageplex 32 printer is still less
expensive than the printers bid by other vendors.
Other costs relating to the printers include yearly maintenance with four
(4) hour, same day response (estimated at $2,208/year/printer with a 7%
maintenance increase cap per'year), paper and consumable supplies. The city
will continue to utilize at least one of the two existing line printers, for
the printing of utilities reports requiring wide continuous form paper. The
utilities Customer service staff prints approximately one box of wide paper per
day. Information Services is working with the line printer vendor and with
utilities Customer service to determine the most cost effective and reliable
way to continue providing this print capability to the utilities area.
Capital Improvement project 315-94731 utility printer replacement includes
funding for the lease purchase of these printers. Annual debt service costs of
approximately $8,968.00 are included in the Finance Department/utility customer
service Program FY95/96 recommended Operating budget.
,;
"
~,~l~":".
~
. -r~' ~.
~
:>!
Po
gj
~
~
g
lj
t1
It!
III
III
"
.
.,
,.,
2
~ ~
~: :
I 0
~ :l:: ~ "
" .. jlII
e ~ a ~
U III III Po
~ ~ e
e g s
'"
... .,
""
2 % 2
~ ~ j
Po II:
~ t:: 0
Po
~ ~ e
e ~ 3
'"
.. ..
...
~ 8 ~
> :z: ;J
0. II:
g t:: c
a.
~.~
8 S
M 8
...
!(l
o
~
o
~ 9 8
... a, ~
~ l>l ..:l
~ ~ ~
Cl a, to.1
~ ~ ~
... ~ S
~ ~ 8
o I"l
Ul 0
U ~ 8
~ a, ~
~ ~ ~
;;'! tJl
~ i
~ ~l
~ ~I
'" i:ll
B il
~ ~I
~ ~I
~ tl
~ i
~ ~1
~
~ gl
')1
, .
o 0 a Q
Q '" fl '" .,
., ., g ., .,
~ ~ ~ ~
r4 ~ ~ a;
...
.,
'" fl fl fl ~ S ~ fl fl fl S fl
~ ~ a a~ a 5 ~ a ~ ~ a
~ z Z ~ H ~ M = ~ z z ~
~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ H
Po Po
g fl fl fl % fl ~ fl.fl fl fl fl g g fl g g
~ ~ a a ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ., ~ a : :
~ ~ 5 ~ 5 S = a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
o 0 0 c
o 0 fa 0 0
co ~ ~ ~ ~
~::D)tD
...
..
: fl fl fl fl ~ ~ fl fl fl fl fl
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ G 5 ~ ~ a ~ a
v z ~ ~ ~ ... ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ H ~ H ~ ~ ~ ~ M M H
Po Po
g fl fl fl fl ~ ~ fl fl fl fl 0 g g 0 g g
= ~ a a ~ ~ g ~ a ~ ~ ~ ., ~ ~ ~ ~
~ = z ~ z z z ~ z z z ~ ~
~ ~ ~ H ~ M ~ H ~ ~ ~
'" .,..
~ Ii! fl 0 [;J 0
~ ~ ~ : ~ !
~ "'"' H Ll-t
.. .. '"
., &l fl '" fl ..
~ ~ ~ : B g
o;:z ZN"-
... ..... M H
fl ~ ~ fl
~ E5 l!l a
z", ~
H ~ U) .....
&: hl
a 0( ~ fl
~ g ~ ~
~ ;.:
.. ...
'" .,
"'ge'"
~ a a ~
... ~ ~ ...
N ... ...
., .,
o fl 0 .,
: ~ ~ :
... ... ...
fl ~ fl ~ ~ fl
a ~ a G l!l a
:;;::; ..... Z H Z
... ..:l ... ~ Ul ...
Po Po f-<
Po Po II:
g 0< fl 0( & lil
!3Bg!;~g
d ~ tl ~ Ul tl
%. %. %.
...... ...
<:' "'.. .,
; 5 ~ ~ 0 ~
.., [Il 0 v ~ '"
N Q ...i ... % ..,
~ ...
<:' I>: ., '" ., fl
r;I & Q '" fl .. ~
~ ~ * ~ g a 0
... N'~";~
... Z
iO ace
<:::I ~ .. '" tl ..
~ 8 g ~ a ~
1'1. Q ,.; M Z ,.;
~ ...
00::" ..
o & Q '" fa
III P, 0 ... g
~ fij ~ ::l tl
~ 1"'4 Z
...
~ ~
5 is
... ...
~ ..:l
Po Po
~ ~
~ g
~ ~
is 5
... ...
..:l ..:l
Po Po
% ~
~ ~
~ ~
f5 f5
... ...
~ ..:l
Po a,
~ ~
!; !;
Z %
~ el
i5 is
... ...
.:l ~
~ Po '"
g g ~ ~
a 0 ~ ~
..; ~
~
N N N N N 1'1 N N N N 1'1 N N N N N N N N
~ ::!
_ !;: '" to}
~ ~ 2 ~
... ~ g., ..,
'" ... Ul m ~ ~
~ ~ : ; ~ ~ ~ ~ w
~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ Ul ~ M ~
~ = N ~ M ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.
ffi ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ la ~ ~ 6 0
~ ... ~ ~ ~ ... z z ~ PI 0 m ...
... ~ ... t'~ re 8 8 0 ~ ~ ~ g
~ ~, ~ ffi ~ ~ g ~ ! ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ B ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~
~
00 >-
~ ~
tl ~
~ ~
::: Ij
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ PI
1:l ~ ~ ~ i ~
~ >- >- to.1 ~
"it: ~ !E. ~ ~ :;;
g ~ N M E e
'1' ~ g ::1
5
t
...
!J
~
Q
1>1
U
~
tl
o ~ N ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ N M . ~ ~ ~ m m ~ ~ ~4 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
tI1
is
~
tl
~
til
PI
~
u;
a
...
Ii:
~
gJ
~
. t,', rl"\
t:
E
~
~
o
..
M
!;;
z
Ii:
...
tl
kI
P:
%
~
o
."
...
~
~
i3
."
M
~
..
...
~
."
I"l
~
c
,.,
~
Q
I
.'
~f?~,<. " , , , .
'."
,)
;
11oo
=
3
~
~
13
~
III
C>l
C>l
~
..
1"1
~
B ~
I 15
d :R
I
... C>l
o ..
a ~
1"4
r>
a N
Iol
l=l a :.l
III III Po
~ i:3
a 9 ~
~ 8 ~
~ ~ ~
~ 8 ri
~ e 5
~ i
8 ~
~ ~ ~
l; = ~
.. 0
I'l ;;;
~ ~
~ ~ ~
0:
l>: ~ .0:
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
..
~ g 1>':
; 8 ~
11oo !;j
B ~ ~
~ E :2
t z ~
.. ~
I>l iE
i ~ ~
!i! In
11oo
8 ~ ~
~ ~ ~
~ ~ iE
~ ~ ~
~ ~I
~ ~I
~ ~l
~ ~I
~ tl/
l:: ...
t:: g:
i ~I
~ ~I
~ ~I
~ tl[
g re
~ ~I
~
~ gl
o ..
.. ~ wee e e e e e e e e ..
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ M ~ H M ~ ~ M M ~ ~
"" 11oo
g ~ ~ e e
:G 15 ~ El El
~ :::: Z d d
'IIf' ~ =
tot .. ..
..
~ ffi fl !S ~ a e
~ a a G G a a
.,. ~ == ..... r,..I z :z
..,. ..... '"'" .....:, ~ M Jo-t
11oo 11oo
co 11oo 11oo
co e B .0: .0:
~~a2g
,.. z z .
tot .... ....
fl fl f.l e e a e e
~ ~ 6 e e ~ e ~
rz =. ';t z Z =. z ~
'H- H ,.... ..... fI-t .... .... H
Q Q Q
~ ~ ~
:z: :z: ;;;
... ... ...
..
a !;l ffi Ii! fl c:
a 6 a a ~ ~
;;; Z ;;; ;;; z
..... .... H Il-4 H
.. ..
.. w w ewe e B e fl co
~ ~ ~ a ~ a @ a a ~ ~
~ ... HZ" ;;; ;;; z z ;;; ~
. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H M ..... M
"" 11oo 11oo
.. "" 11oo 11oo co
Q < ~ e .0: e a a a e ..
~ g g ~ ~ a ~ a a ~ ~
1"1 Z;;; z z ;;; z
N ~ ~ ~ ..... ~ H
.. ..
~ e e ~ e ~ a fl fl e ~
~ ~ ~ G a 6 e ~ a e ~
~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ a ~ a a ~
11oo 11oo
co 11oo 11oo ..
.. e B .0: Q < a e e e ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a e ~ a ~
~ ~ ~ S E ~ a ~
..
.. ~ w B e I>l e e e e
~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~
Po 11oo 11oo
C 11oo 11oo 11oo co
co < .0: e e .0: e e B e ~
~ g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a a a ~
z z z z z Z
H M H..... M .....
III
~
c> co
c> t;l &l ~ e
~ e a'~ a
~ Z Z ~ :z:
..... ...
.. co
., B ffi <3
~ ~ ~ ~
..; z z ,.;
.. ....
e e !j
~ ~ ~
: ~ U ~ !
J ~ l:i l5 ~ z
... :z: ;;; ...
! I
z Z
H ...
fl lol
6 ~
z ~
Hili:
s g ~ s
..
Q &l <3
! ~ ~
:z: :z: ..;
... ...
tl a
a ~
z z
... H
e fl 00
g El iit
u tl 0
Z ;;; ~
g ~ ~ ~ ; ~
~ e 0 0 ~ g
z l:; l5 z
... z z ...
e fa
a ~
Z Z
... ...
co
co fl
~ B
..; z
...
Q Q
I>l W
a 0
z z
H ...
c
~ ~
::\ ~
C!3 11oo
g Q ~ l:i fl ~
l!l ~ 8 g g l:;
m ~ 15 l:i ~ z
... z z ...
c Cl
~ ~
Z ~
H ...
lil
!
; ~ U
~ l5 15
.... z z
lil I>l
~ ~
z ..
... ~
11oo
'"
C <
g l:i
d z.
z.
...
,.. M N N N N ,.. N N ,.. N N N N N N N ,.. N
~
~
H
;;;
o
t:
'5
~
Q
'"
l&l
~
tl jg
tl ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Cl !.;. ... @ ~ t;
!;: ..... tl .... ~ "'"'
... U ... ~'Ao g:,
;n~B
~
t 1-0 ~ ~ ~
2 I>: 8 0
~ i : tJ ~
: : I ~ i ~ 0 ! ;_
: : ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~
~ : ~ ~ 8 ~ S ~ i
goo f) w _ ~ a
9 ~ ~ j ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
00' ~ 1-0 ~ ~ 0 ~
~ ~ ~ g ~ ~ ~ : ~
00
~
tI
I w
~ ~ ... Ie
>- ~ ;! r"
Z.
@ Ii! ~ In
N <'l ~ 8
o ...
I/) ~
roI M
o P"'4 ,... "'" ... .....
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r. ~ ~
\D I'-
,.; roI
;1
'.-'.-' ~ ~~ ...... ~".'l.
~
00
00
~
o
N
~
<'l
!;'l
C1
co
1"1
...
~
,
r-
~
~
o
M
...
~
,
r-
~
I/)
;;:
c
1
: I
I
I
!
,
co
1"1
...
roI
,
r-
~
I/)
><
~
co
M
...
...
.
r-
~
!
1
I
f
I
!I
~
iii
Q
~
~~J~":'''HU c
, .
".'
,;" ,-,
,
. .' ':. ';''':~~.~:,~
, ,
,.
Pageplex 32 Printers Costs/Optional Enhanccnlcnts
LMY
Clearwater City Commission
Agenda Cover Memorandum
~l
Item fI
Meeting Date:
'j '/7. cr,s
SUBJECT: Hardware maintenance agreement for Unisys A-4 and A-6 mainframe
computers
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Award a contract to Digital Equipment Corporation of
Tampa, FL, for the hardware maintenance of the Unisys A-4 and A-6 mainframe
computers for the period of October 1, 1995 through September 30, 1996 at a
cost of $33,987.96, being the lowest and most responsive bid in accordance with
specifications
~ and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some.
B~CKGROUNO: This contract will provide hardware repair and preventive
maintenance for the city's A-4 and A-6 mainframe computers. The city utilizes
the A-4 to run Payroll, Inventory, and occupational Licenses. These systems are
all slated for replacement during the 1995/96 fiscal year, if approved by the
Commission. The A-6 computer is used for Computer Aided Dispatch in the Police
Department. The Police are actively implementing a new Police Information
System, which will render the A-6 computer as surplus in the coming year.
i
l
)
j
~
lJ
'J
j
"
.\
1
~
Effective last fiscal year, since the City is migrating away from the
mainframe, Information Services no longer deemed it necessary to continue
paying for operating system upgrades and support on these computers. since the
operating system was no longer a consideration, Information Services bid this
service, instead of purchasing maintenance from Unisys, the computer
manufacturer. Digital Equipment Corporation is the recommended vendor for the
second consecutive year. The City has received excellent service from Digital
during the past year. The service agreement for FY95j96 reflects a 6.35%
increase over the current contract.
~
1
Maintenance coverage for the A-4 is Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. until 5:00
p.m., with four (4) hour contact and eight (8) hour on-site response. The A-6
will be covered Sunday through Saturday, 24 hours per day with two (2) hour
contract and four (4) hour response, due to the public safety nature of the
Police application. The contract will be billed monthly and can be canceled at
Reviewed by: Originating Dept: Costs: $ 33.987.96 commission Action:
Legal N/A Information M~c~~;;t Totol 0 Approved
Budget ~/ 0 Approved w/conditions
Purchasing to 000.00
Risk Mgmt. User Dept: ~,/! Current Fiscal Yr. 0 Denied
IS rl 15~ Information M mt./Police 0 continued to:
ACH Flrding Source:
Other 0 Capi tol Imp.
Advertised: ~ Operating A ttnchmcnts:
Dnte: 07-14-95/07-21-95 0 Other Bid tabulotion
Z:{ '; I Poper:Pinellas County Review/
Tampll Tribune
0 Hot Rcqu; red 0 None
Stbnl tted by: Affected Parties Appropriation Code:
City ~fP/ ~ Notified 555-09862-546200-590'000
010-01144-530300'521-000
0 Not Requi red
~ Printed on recycled paper
"":1 "'~.." .
.~.. ..
.,
'f .
" ".
"' L. "
"
; .
.' .
.,
~-r~"''''iL-'': H.I\~L""'~:
r "~... .. "'; I . "
'",... "')I~~:;. .",~J~:~: '\ 1
h . :. , t". ~ _:\'~ " "I.
.. ", ~. <: ... !., .","~ ,,,\. I
. . '::' ~/. "
- 2 -
any time with 30 days notice. This monthly billing will allow the city to
terminate any portion of the contract if a computer is no longer used by city
applications in the coming year.
The proposed 1995/96 Information Management and Police operating budgets
include sufficient funds for this contract.
, ,
,I'.
I.:'
I
I_......~. "W
4 ~. ~ ~ .~. .-
'"
;
.. ",:" .....~~.' --;Ir~~:.~~..-
[.
I
I
r
I
~
l~ I; .
;.
m\>. ~'\ . . .
ml1>HY~~~,,', "
#~"'~"i'" V ~\":i:~~...}~ t
~ J-.' ~ < ~ ~
~,~"...~.., , ..1, .................-"~~r
p;... "\ . <'" ~ ."
"
,.
'.
"
.i,
CITY OF CLnRMATD
DID 133~95 . OPINED ~y 29, 1995
DID TAD
~ :1"
ITEM
NO.
DESCRIPTION
I
...
1 tmISYS RARDlfARX MAINTJDWl'Cll A- 4
2 maSYS ID.JWKAJUl HAINTllHANCll A~'
I.
START DATI: I
TlUUlSl
SUMKAaY OF DID 133-95
,
., .
BIOS SOLICITED I
BIOS RECEIVED:
NO RESPONSE:
NO-BID RESPONSEt
".
,t
SUMMARY OF NO DIDS NIA
::
,'l' ,
, l " ~ ", ~...,
....: 1',
, .
~ ' ,~". "+.' .;. < .... t
mnsys HAJU>>fARll KAINTSNANCB
1<1
2.
12
UNISYS CORPORATION DIGITAL EQUIPMENT
TI\MPA. F!pll1D1\ TAAP7\, FLOll:lDh
MONTHLY ANNUAL MONTHLY ANNUAL
!'.!U..Qg ~ ~ f1llg
1,743.00 20.916.00 954.08 10,249.96
2. 726 ,00 32.712.00 1,978.25 23,739.00
53.628.00 33,987.96
........... ...........
30 DAYS
30 DAYS
MON1'lIL'l
NET 30
j.~
" of" ,'(if;"]
~
f
!
.I~:.\ \'-,
., .
L\0 :L
Clearwater City Commission
Agenda cO'7'cr Memorandum
Item N
Lt ~ ^ ",.tin, D.'"
\ g. Iry. cr5
SUBJECT:
Subscription services for Library Materials
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION:
Extend the contract with Ebsco Subscription Services, Birmingham, AL, for the
period 10/1/95 through 9/30/96, in the estimated amount of $65,000, tor
periodical subscriptions and serial standing orders in accordance with Sec.
2.564 (d) (Other governmental bid)
~ and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute some.
BACKGROUND:
The City employs Ebsco Subscription Services to maintain the Library System's
600 periodical subscriptions and 275 annual and semi-annual reference serials.
Estimated..expenditures for FY 95/96 are $65,000. Expenditures equal
publishers' subscription charges plus Ebsco's 4.9% service charge. The total
varies each year with publisher price fluctuations and subscription additions
or cancellations initiated by the Library Department.
The Service includes all interactions that normally transpire between publisher
and subscriber; i.e. orders, renewals, payments, problem solving, and reports
on subscription lapses and other changes. Ebsco Subscription services contacts
individual publishers and negotiates the best available prices. The City of
Clearwater payments are distributed by Ebsco to many publishers, eliminating
the necessity for the Library and Finance Departments to process approximately
300 additional purchase orders and associated invoices which result from direct
transactions with publishers.
Ebseo Subscription services is included on the current State of Florida Library
Materials Contract.
Sufficient funds have been requested in the Library's Books and Publications
capital improvement project for FY 95/96.
Reviewed by: ~g Oept: Costs: e~. s 65.000 Commission Action:
Legal ~ _ . library Total 0 Approved
Budget 0 Approved w/condltlons
Purchasing S
R hk. Hgmt. NJ Current FiscaL Yr. 0 Denied
CIS ilIA J>tk User Pept: 0 Continued to:
ACH Funding Source:
Other ~ Copl ta I Imp.
Advertised: 0 Operot Ing Attachments:
Dote: 0 Other
r," Paper:
\ \\ ~ Not Requl red ~ None
,
Submitted by: Affected Parties Appropriation Code:
fU 0 Notified
City ~Qr ~ 315.93510.564400-571.000
Not Required
~ Printed on recycled paper
(
1.
r.', .
~.;;' ~
;., "
~ : .
Item II
~rJ 1-
CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION
Agenda Cover Memorandum
43
Meeting Dote
SUBJECT: 1995 Gunite Restoration Contract (95-11)
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Award a contract for the 1995 Gunite Restoration contract
(95-11) to INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES, INC./ISI OPERATING CORPORATION of FRANKLIN,
TENNESSEE for the sum of $323,711.00, which is the lowest responsible bid
received in accordance with the plans and specifications,
uu and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND: The purpose of this contract is to provide for the structural repair
of deteriorated storm sewers at various locations. Existing storm sewer systems
within the city are inspected periodically for structural damage, corrosion,
failing joints, etc., by storrnwater Personnel. A list of storm sewers in need
of repair is then prepared by the storrnwater Division (Department of Public
Works) and submitted to the Engineering Department for the yearly storm sewer
restoration contract. The methods used for this repair work will be the
application of pneumatically applied reinforced concrete commonly referred to as
"gunite" and the pressure injection of grout to fill voids at defective pipe
joints. Gunite will be applied on the inside surface of the pipe either at the
joints or along the entire length of the pipe depending on the condition and
material of the pipe being repaired. These procedures will not require
excavation for storm pipes being repaired nor will there be a need for extensive
property restoration.
Construction sites are at the following locations: (a) Palmetto street and the
c.s.x. Railroad (b) Franklin street between Garden Avenue and Myrtle Avenue (e)
King's Highway between North Hibiscus street and pinebrook Drive (d) Chestnut
Street between South Myrtle Avenue and Prospect Avenue (e) Union street and
Beecher Road Intersection (f) st. Thomas Drive and Hillcrest Avenue Intersection
(g) Jeffords street and Norwood Avenue Intersection (h) south Myrtle Avenue
between Lotus Path and Druid Road (i) David Avenue at Gulf-to-Bay Blvd. (S.R. 60)
(j) Hillcreek Circle East between Hillcreek Circle South and Hillcreek Circle
North.
This project will start on or about September 15, 1995 and is scheduled to be
completed within 150 calendar days.
The available balance in the Storm Drainage Renewal and Replacement capital
improvement project is sufficient to provide funds for this contract.
Eo<
tJ
~
Eo<
Z
o
tJ
Z
o
H
f<
~
c::
o
Eo<
1Il
M
c::
M
Eo<
H
~
Cl
III
Q>
0\
O'l
..
c::
o
c..
III
c:l
H
,tQ
c..
o
z
o
H
~
~
E-<
.~==-= ~----"-----------'I- q" '
, -- t-.--. -- --- -..-- ...---..... . .. ...-,
wiij ~ a ~ ~ & ~ ~ ~
a: r:: ,1'1 to '<t N <0 NO...
::Ju.... N... 0 0 r-. r-. r-. 0
............ c..:! .... _ ... _ _
U.... 0...
:J -."t= .
a:VlZ.f.~
.....w1=lI:;:j
~H<1~:.t'
a:ii:ffia::i
~~:S8fE
~5 ~
z ~ .
:;)u Z
1.:1:;) '0
o~~t;
~~-~~
zoo:>
:JUU!!:
.J
o <1
U vi
Z .....
o <1
1= 0
U J:
:;) Vl
za: ~
Slii U
~~u~
lIluf;::
III
Q>
0\
....
o
>- u..,j
<t ....
alwa: .
.z.....O
a:-VlCl
wc:zu:
~~8j
....
....
Eo<
u:I
P
Cl
P
~
w
!::z
~Q =i
Clt; .
Z:;) .9
oa::uw
~lii~rt
:I: z ~w
oOO:I:
,UUVl
>-
O'l:
Q
1Il
c::
=
:r:
E-<
lIJ .
!::z~
ZOo
:;)--
.... ..... a:
....Ual
.....:J~
<ta:<t
liiliiu
~5cici
uuu:E
rol
E-l
O'l:
o
o
~
1;
.....
Z
<1
:J
o
III
Q>
en
....
0\
....
>-
H
t:l
t-,
><
O'l:
o
1Il
r.l
Z
Q
M
Ik
z
Q
.....
Q.
El
1II
W
o
..
Cl
Z
H
;z;
W
P<
o
o
H
IQ
...
wci
!::z
8
r-:
III
...
8
tti
l")
...
8
ci
or
...
8
tti
l")
...
8
ci
or
...
~
ot
N
...
l-
S a a
c:i M l")
M ... .-
... ... ...
~
co
N
...
a 8
,..:
to
...
m
o
q
M
...
...
o
o
to
In
8
r-:
LO
...
8
t.ci
N
N
-f-----------
00
,..
...
III
...
o
Ul
N
N
...
o
o
ci
<0
...
,,:
.J
o
N
N
W
Q.
il.
.....
<1
III
::
a
w
I-
ot
Cl
:J
a:
a:
o
U
.
o
<0
a:
w
Z
;:j
w
I-
.2
;J
Cl
.
M
en
a,:
":t
,...
...
a
OJ
...
...
o
o
ci
,...
...
u.:
.J
In
N
...
o
w
.....
<t
CI
:J
a::
a:
o
u
,
on
<0
X
o
'<t
a:w
wl1.
z-
:Jl1.
w~
.....;:,
z~
:J">
Cl!J
. .....
1"1 .t
N M
of
<0
,..:
rl
...
o
ll!
,...
...
...
8
o
<0
...
u.:
.J
ID
r;O
N
.....
-.(
III
~
o
w
...
<t
C)
:J
a:
a:
o
U
.
<0
lD
X
.
lD
M
It:
W
z
:J
w
!::
z
:J
CluJ
. Q.
Mil.
'll
o
.,;
M
...
a
N
o
...
o
o
o
":t
...
u.:
.J
<0
OJ
...
W
Q.
il.
.....
<[
...
w
~
o
W
I-
<t
Cl
:J
a:
a:
o
u
N
>t
a:
w
Z
:J
w
!::
z
:J
Cl
.
M
,f
-...,
r-.
'"?
,...
o
q
...
o
...
8
o
N
u.:
.J
o
to
N
W
Q.
il.
.....
<[
f-
w
::i
a
w
.....
<t
Cl
:J
a:
a:
o
u
,
III
M
a:
w
z
:J
w
I-
2
:J
Cl
.
N
Iri
-t
o
,..:
m
o
Ul
'<t
en
o
o
o
o
...
u:
.J
o
l")
0')
W
Q.
n:
.....
<t
III
::
o
w
I-
et
Cl
:J
a:
a:
o
u
,
o
M
a:
w
z
:J
w
I-
2
:J
Cl
I
;--~
ui
o
q
...
N
o
on
or
m
o
o
ci
N
...
u.:
.J
IJ'I
Cll
w
t;";
a:
u
z
o
lJ
CI
w
lJ
a:
o
u..
2:
Ul
a:
.
o
<"l
a::
w
Z
:::;
w
!=
z
:;)
l;l
, Ul
;k.~
-0.
,..:
of
m
III
Cll
N
o
o
.n
N
...
o
o
o
":t
N
J:
U
et
w
N
to
w
t;j
a:
u
z
o
u
o
UI
u
a:
o
...
z
W
a:
..
o
M
a:.
::t
Q.
w
a:
...
:z
6
.,
. w
;:5:
ro
:3
,..:
~
8
oj
r..
...
8
oi
o
N
N
o
,...:
OJ
N
o
~
to
N
...
a
o
co
N
J:
U
<t
w
o
m
N
w
I;:;
a:.
u
z
o
u
o
w
u
a:.
o
u.
Z
W
a:
U,
M
a:.
=t
0..
w
a:
~
o
""1
. w
~&:
.,;
a
N
..
...
8
to
OJ
...
8
N
N
N
co
N
....
co
N
o
o
ci
N
...
o
o
g
1")
J:
U
<t
W
N
+t
w
II..
Q.
.J
et
I;:;
~
o
I.JJ
f-
et
Cl
::I
a:
a:
o
U
I
N
,t
!f
<t
n.
UI
cr:
I-
~
o
.,
,
".
~-
..
o
...
8 ~
g N
... ..
8
ci
N
N
8
N
N
N
o
1-;
...
...
M
o
o
o
N
...
8
ci
N
M
:z:
lJ
<t
JLI
o
N
UJ
tu
a:
u
z
o
lJ
o
UJ
lJ
a:
o
u..
Z
Uj
0::
.
co
't
a:
~
0...
W
ct:
I-
Z
(5
~)
. '.11
;,(:Q.
-n:
-
...
8
ci
or
N
o
q
on
00
...
N
on
co
en
N
o
o
ci
N
8
o
Lll
<"l
J:
U
<t
w
o
,...
w
t;j
a:
u
2:
o
U
o
w
U
u:
o
u..
Z
W
a:
.
+t
III
a:
;'(
0..
w
a:
!z
(5
.,
, w
~o...
:"0:
N
..
8
LO
s:
,...:
~
...
...
o
..
Ici
Ul
N
.,;
o
o
o
...
u:
t.i
o
&
M
u
I;:;
vi
o
6
:>
.....
~
...
...
::l
a
a:
C1
o
UI
...
U
W
,
E::
w
a:
:J
VI
VI
UI
a:
n.
M
..
o
o
.;
M
III
8 g
& ~
8 ~
ci on
Ol Ul
CX!. N
...
8
g
1I1
...
...
o
o
g
U)
t..:'
o
o
g
o
ci
...
vi
..,j
.....
o
a:
...
z
o
u
;z
o
i=
~
lr
,f
~
OJ
8
o
LO
...
~
..
...
'"
M
N
M
<It
8
iii
m
M
en
co
'<1'
...
8
0)
OJ
":
...
co
M
<It
a
Ul
,...
III
OJ
III
,...:
...
Ul
.;
N
Ul
<It
g
g
..
o
ll)
-i
..
o
oi'
o
~
...
o
o
o
o
Ul
o
o
o
M
l't
on
'<1'
III
'"
:I:
U
<1
w
N
.....
<t
f-
a
f-
If)
a:
W
o
Q
al
W
..J
III
~
a:
o
~
oen
z-
<1{3
ziil
QI-
.....u
:3~
;tg
"'0...
~IJ..
_0
z~
Ow
i=:E
<tw
~~
II..~
W.,;
IE:!:
iii
...
:1, ,<"
, "
.,' .,.
, "
<:'
!:'
.~ ".
1"',jtltiJ.;.."" '
< ~\...l ~ .,t-' " ,<, ,l .J'
?t.:..H..: ::. . ':" .:\"-':O":~~".,~,.",
, ,
" ,
.. "\
, ,
""':I;.-:.:.:!',/:~!,"..... , .
.. .},,:, ',': .. ~"<~,,,/:,;,:,::.~(t:A~~:,0.Y
1995 GUNITE RESTORATION CONTRACT (95.11)
BID SUMMARY
I"
I',
BIDS SOLICITED. 12
, CONTRACTORS PICKING UP PLANS & SPECS - 9
CONTRACTORS SUBMITTING BIDS . 6
NO RESPONSE. 131
SIEG & SONS, INC.
PNEUMATIC CONCRETE COMPANY, INC.
PALMETTO GUNITE CONSTRUCTION CO., INC.
nClUN,\TE.n.Q
, ~
I
I
I
~
I
,
I
I
;') .',
I
. ,
"
ftr~'!;~i, .'..~ .~"
. ,.:,'
. '~,' I ..
" " ~; :.;.. .".
, . .',
. ~' . ~
: ,;" '\: . ," ': :// ,';:' , <~':,:,;; >>:"'~7~F
<1.".:.1'.ll-' -
1
I,
1995 Gunite Restoration Contraot (95-11)
,
!
,
i
I",
BIDS SOLICITED - 12
Beacon Construction co., Inc.
P.O. Box 2426
Muscle Shoals, Alabama 25661
Sieg & Sons, Inc.
1731 Langley Avenue
DeLand, Florida 32724
Coastal Gunite Construction Co.
16 Washington Street
(P.o. Box 977)
Cambridge, MD. 21613
united Gunite Construction, Inc.
102 Welland Avenue
Irvington, New Jersey 07111
I
I
Coastal Marine Construction, Inc.
625 N. Tamiami Trail
Venice, Florida 34292
Johnson Gunite Construction Co.
2801 E. Second street
P.o. Drawer "C"
Sheffield, Alabama 35660
.}
Inducon Corporation
2632 NW 43rd street, suite F-8
. Gainesville, FL. 32606-7438
904 377-4148 $225K
Infrastruture Services,
Operating corporation
112 Alpha Drive
P.O. Box 680699
Franklin, TN 37068-0699
Inc./ISI
~
i
~
I
f
1
Inter-Bay Marine Construction Co.
7950 118th Avenue North
Largo, Florida 34643
Palmetto Gunite Constr. Co., Inc.
P.o. Box 388
Ravenel, So. Carolina 29470-0338
Pneumatic concrete co., Inc.
Attn: Mr. John I. Simmons .
3412-B Lorna Lane
Birmingham, Alabama 35216
Preservation Services, Inc.
2609 East Broadway Avenue
Tampa, Florida 33605
i W
l-
e(
i:u..;:
-00:
o <(
W
-I
o
~
.... N t') ~ to
t
t
J
i
I
I
~
,
~
,
"
~
~
I
~
~
"
I
I
f
;
I
!
[
1
I
!
,
(f)
-J
<(
U
G:
Ll...
o
..... .......... ..... .....
o 0 0 0 0
V It> Q) IV Q)
(J1(f)(f)(f)(J1
I I I I
l- '- \,.. \. l-
V IV IV IV Q.l
cccCO't
,Q ,2 ,2 ,2 0
II) 1I) 1I) III C
,~ ,!Q .~ .!!! 0
'-EEEE~
g,EEEE>.
00000:-=
:::EUUUUU
,-
,-
I
10
en
~ 0
"'? -
:J
IV ......
U lJ) uca.
.......- 0 IV
0.........
E Q3 (Il (I) 0
_ :J C
/>.ot:...,.g~
.-/ ~~~c3"'?.c
o. '.....
0<(<iEQ)~
..... oco
O'-'V:'=..cN
~~:J-=o:::
Ct::Ll...(f)3::"'?w
I
\l
J
~
"0
>. lLl
d >
CD 0
Z I-
'"0 0.
ci V 0..
> <(
Z 0
'- 11)
.0 0.. .....
0 a. 0
"'? <( 0
il
I-z
11:0
4:-
a.1-
We(
ea::
"e
Ztn
-
II:
W
W
~~~'~aro
"Z (\
Z:)
W ~c;?
o j j 0
:t · J
--;...,' . -.---.ffj--.----....'..-.ml lIJJ -" '......
___.~~~-.~:' "1-... , .,.,<::~::*\._ ]'~:. ___, . u_ ~~~~.: ONV~~~;.I_~y~! I~zr -.--
-_..... l'-.. i.""', \ \--.--.____-- _./{I'::\"-'u_-
" , "/.. ''<'' '\'" ( ,,~.'_.~. '_, "_._..._ ..._-, /I) k
. ~...." ~ ~" ' . -'.... 1<'1
. ,'- .," I
-........ -..J "'~_'. r'~
.......... "-.... .....'\....,
"'.. "'-: """ "J 'l~-" Il'l.' -
, ,- ". ~..._~
..... "',( ,,~.,
~".. ,.......... I .",
'-"... .....
", "'~/'"
..... ~ '. , '\
'-, .....:--. "-
", " '-..I
y'..t "
....,. >. "
v:1.;~ m....
". 'd.> '...
~ ~ ~., X "
$' I ~~ ',~ \.- '-,
" /.( ",\ . '-. \,
". (- ,.~ . ',\ >~ "-
'-., ~..... '\. "V"
....~ "-"f . ~ . ,
'.... .1:(" ;> ~ \. " "
.........:~ ) I.J .r '. \.J" ...
.....:'. ,- t.. ~ \, "', \,
" () ", .x '.
, '-' \. . \ '"
" ~ \" ~~ ",
1. ~! " "( '-,
in g '-, ,: .',-, ""
('J .J ' ..
...'\.~~' '...
-,F , ...
" :.1 ,
"'\\. \,
..... - .......c{.' >< "
.'" \ ... "
IX \. -:<. \."
J ..... " \ \,
.... 7 "... i ">( "
:.::1 '''''' . ;y, \....,
",-, \, ,
(,.1 " .x "
I .> ....~.,' \'" "'.
. '\ ~ ,
, 'r '.
) ), ,
y), \, \,
... ., '"
" ..
\. \<
'\ '\
"\.
.......
~.~.:." .~
..' ,,>
"':'l ___1~ ,r;
-,~JI"'II"~!)- .-. ,.:
...;
...
1-'
1.1
W
t~
I-
V}
r
'-'~'-' --- '-'--' --..... 0
r'''' ..
'-t.
_ 1'1
.' ---
'I,..... ,.-..--
...-----.-.- ......--
0:.:
~
Z
o
(.Il
-~
~i'/" "-'" l
Db'lj -~....
n
~
~-
lLl
'-'
."T'
...J
.1:
O.
t
1'1
"I'
pi
.......\-
'-
., -'--'"
,;-.] I>- ~ .1>' ''',
.' _"_ 0;741 .....
,.. '. ", >( '0''''
f
'-_.'-\
.......
~1') ........,
"". f...-J .....
I ,,,,, ,
..... ~,~
'....
......
....
~.-
l~J
L..J
(Y.
!-o-
W
~
oJ ~
.!a
~~'"'I
~...
Q~
.:~ !i
=~C!i
J> 1.
Qttto)
l~.
~
~~
["1..........--...... )T
'Plll.1C11f ..' :,;
II)
l,,)
~
~
~
'f.f {"
'/:" ,
I. i!
, -~ 1
i:: '
I' ".1
... I
I:
.if
.'
: rn~
: It!
(1')
:)
(.)
tfl
(lJ
:I:
,..:
111
, I
o
1=
1.>J
. ,
"'<:
:J
'.1'
fL
-
:5~'
r:t~
<(
Ld
... .J
C)
\
"'---
A -_
i
1~ :: :
~1O ~ ~
.-
Z
LLI
c(~
g~
O:::~ 0
~~ ; ~
~ ~~~i
~ 3j~Q
13 ~~l~
w Ii; 0
Ii. '""s'"
oe.!) g ...
z 8 "
~~ on I
-w Ql Q.
U LLI !!!
Z
(5
z Iii ~ la
LLI I~ I~ I~
I
I
I
I
r
!
I
!
,
~
~
~
Q
~
,[
!
CD
'.-J
...J
Cl
':'(i';'~ "
.'
,I. ~ ....___--.__ _.u.
_ _n ...__ \-' , [~-~"-:~ .. :.': m__ ',:" I,op _~ _un _ n_ __h___ ,/ (, 00
___nO ,,".f ::. ... ..~~ =_ ~::"!: '.: ::: . .. =. .... . ;,< I. / ~ ____. __~: ,,'.: '~_____.___ :/ !;; --
b ~ 1
t:;
w
f=
VI
1-
hI
0, .0 m td
~
1-
Ifl
ti
w
0:.
1-
VI
0- f:J _____.._____ _.____.___.__._,_
---...... -_ur -.'- -( \'-'---".C'I m 7..)
..J-m. _00....1 .__+.u_._+.__.. ~"""l'-'- -/'dl.
..., .._~.. .-- . . ~ )or -- --. . -- ....-. .'-". .......... ..... ,...
" ,
~
1.0
I"l
':H
o
,.,
,.,
.,-
0.:.
-,
(;
c.
\.
t
CL
. U
-fhL,
101.0
('I'"
. ~ .........-., .-... ~.--.
....-...-
"..._......_~
1.01
U
0::
w
II:
... 3rln:MV ~
~ u"_'" __'_H' ~~ __n!
n~ i_
10. C!J "Ill:
....rm
/
f
[I;
.--'?-7ri" i, -_ ,..
-
l>
i ::
~ .::
aID ~ -
... 0
Z N
lLf
<::::E
01-
-0::: ~
O:::-ct
~~ ~
.0 SJ~
~
~ SdlS ~
0::: I ~ 2 ~
'"'
W
..J .G i 0\
u i!!
l&..C)
Oz
l:iE ~
-w
Uw at
-
z i
C) t ~ t
z ~
l.LI 10 I~ I
:> U I
~ai ~ II:: !
j
~ ~
I
I
,
I
~
Cl
~ !
r
I
I
r13JtJ"Q
,I
~':/,"'~
.....,.....~ i
~n
l
":,,-..--.. -,--~
i... ..
I!l - ..
...
all) ~ 0
to- '"
Z
w
<:2:
Q~ I-
<:1:<( u
~~ ~ ~ r;
.0 !1
~ g~j
~ 011I: loW
!i~~ '!
~ i
l .. C7I
lJ..C) i s. j I
0% G ~ ~
?:~ '" z
-w CIl I
Uw 2!
~
C) t t ;
z ;
w I~ ~~! : t
I
al ~I- It: ,
t t
i
I
~
I
~
a
~
,.,., ......, I
l_.________~.l l____
--.. --.~li --.--.---...---
Qa e C!J
~~~
t:t..s;::;
~~~
_u,_.__._..~__..",. .__._..._" .....'......_" ..._.__.,...1
lJ]~I1S
V]"IM.lt\lJ
:::: ~":'~:'::<~"':..~:::.~=-== :::::.
j
~
t:)
, ~~
i 7.:
.. ....---........-- ,..-,.-.-......
.:..... ::::.:. .~::7: :.:~: + '; ::.::'.... - '.. T~:-_-::~'.:'::
q
.
mO
'j t')
., '!.., ._ _u_.._. ....yr\
-,..._..;~;~~_...... -""-:;~O~.~3N~~;._.:- ~ nJ~ \~
Ll: ~,I.'
-. --.---.... -..-.---.------~li -.-----.. "]
-.J)'
.-~
~.s;::;
~rt~
...._u_..........__.... ..........__.._~.... ...._..___~._......~ ...._...._.
3^,>JO ~mO~03U1d
,---._.....-~~.~" --... ...... --.-----., ~.._--- ~........._-
~
01 &..: .s
-.\!--- -- . 1 ....
-.--.-..--.-----.....-.--.-..--.......-..----..---. .--.... . ..C}--_.,- ....
. 3tNl lV~IY/{jV "'liP' ~"t:>>li
-'.' .......-.-----.... _,_.........u.......___. ---,-_.., rj..lJ( :.... .:..tJ_....___ ~!i:
...~~
=.s;::;
~~~
.
o
t')
HOSQOOM
j., ~" :~\: 4J. ._ _ _ "_..., ~nJS~~~~~_ ..__ ._...__.~HJ~~~..._.__
II ' "':1 ' i ""';0 ,--.---.-----...-....-.-.--... . ...---..-.-:--..-..-'.--
-.. _.~..- .-....---.... .. ...-...-.....- _....,._......t.. :-... -- \j", , ( II' r l
~ r ! i / " :.. t.
..........._., ._._.....~~J,:~~~~~~,._._"........,.._...._. :~.',la~~.~H.. t;,:il \. [~ ........._,_.... __..-'_-'''- __.__.__,__--.-_.._.
\1\f. H"q hi -'" . .m;~~~~~~~;~H....__...-... ,_.~-- .-..,~~~~~.-- -...-
, .. ---........ .. ." ...-.... -'..' ,..~,_. ..... -..,--...J.,...-..,........_,
:
Ll: ~
.J :!
~l)
tQ~~
-.~.
~.\i~
~~~
Vl
o
....
~.
\4\
. ~1\",,;.} '-- , .-
"
M"_ ....._ /.\
_.._._.... 1:..... ["'''n ___.... r"
. . ......" '
1Nt S '-"",) .....-.... ,.---.- ..-.... 1"
\ .. [_ nn 1,1" '-...- . ..-..---
_ __.. / ., ......__ ..... .... uo ..., . .,.t V -........--..
..... ......_.__.. J '., __ __...... . .... .._~.... .. . -....... -,,-1 { . 311M"" -- .-......-..-------...
.', ...., i . _._~____..___ IHnos
-. ..-.---
--..-..---...-
, _~tlIMJ
;7 /'
./ /"
. ~ J'
.,,~ "~.,../
~..',/ /"
r "
, ,
...
()
--.~~~...__. ~,~
"
.,
..
"
...
.,~:,
.,..;;~-
'?' .
.-
"
~
"
'.
'.
"
"
r'
.'
I 'JF'I
no.{}[ ~
\X'I'\: . '"
: ' -J
.\ 'I'
,. /()"u"" ~,(
/ ~'\
/ \,' ,/,'
I .. .
Ii,'
f j"
(/ - .I!'
_ n-- ..~~l~::i ) ~ t~
. .--....- --,--, . ::~:=-~:~.. ~
__.._ _,,_.._ n,.... {'I ({J --- '5'-" ... .._, . -----.,.--. "-- ~
,._ .,_...~__. 'l~ ,/'~ 3^V 0_0__""-
__._ .'_ ' .._._ .1~1 l'l .......-
......__ -r'" \, _.~:::::"::'.:: ::."" _. ....- .. '. :.--",!;-..~ .::. j:t . .. ;;;:;; m~;:;:;'i~ --
['H'" ..., "'-"-'-jl~7 \t~=,?E~~E=.-:.:'--=- --' ....---
~ . _._---- _..- --.
t. E .
~ ::j u ~"
. b ll~
~ ~ __.... n
~ '- ':: . -..---......
tQ-"" ....
...~~
e..;.
...~,
,,~~
:s'+;;:~
u~~
,,'
/,Hn
"-lJIl.-'
I-
n:
;:)
(j
u
"J
I
I
I;
,I
p
i!
t,
~ !
I
,
\
l-
Z
~
<::IE
0.....
D:: ~ I-
0< (,)
,~~ ~ ~
.0 ~ I ~
~ ~Ci:l
~ I=mvli
~ I~H
~~ ~ if
OW 81 vl
w -
Z
(3
ztl'iili
W i~ ~j I
gal ....:
D::
"
~
I
'I
~
~
I
~
~
-j f--' 'i'... '.. '--'
, ~~.........'.. _ .._.'-. ..,..+ .._~l....::~'+...':~:l~:,.,'-~'\ ~._," I ,.,..... J ..-..--......... ....-..-.....-.,. I
_.. . _ .. ....," .,.. .. ... "r . ...." , ' " I fa' .. - . ·
. ...... .. . ..... _'''_ ...".,,__ _..._. .......1..-1 ","- ----1-,..--.-..
:H1t1j^ v..... .........__ _' .. I . .......-.--..... ~- .- ...-+-.-+- I -.'
JS\'J-'-' - .....-.-.... -- --
.-.... -...-- ...-----.. .--
,1'
\'1
~ ~ '1
~ \
~'bl )
:ge~
..~..
\ l.s~
~.!,!.
\ '" I
_ ._.>=.~.. .~~~:~ dd /. __.n .n! !
I"l
.1;...'.
~: ,
/
.- . '.~'
""
'-,
.....
'.
f
,
;
~"
"
O'a'O~
II Jfl.:'JJlI
I pi......'\. ;...........- ...... ......,.. - _._""'0 .......... ....,1,.
,.II" ..~.-.. ,..,\
" .
! \
)
\
~
'IJ
,tj
~ ~
~'b""
~..
\O;~;::
...~f3
=liC!i
~~~
~
f
1\'
'1
~ l
~'b""
""'...
~~~
""~'S
...~I
..'1;_
t::,s""
.~...
.....Q;;~
"i ....'. "-' ,,-- _h' . '..-..
r- ~{..._ _._~~~~o_, ,__.....__,_., ___' .._~~'~: .....__._____.___h..____
~ t~~" '
1! I),:' 11
,,~, I.
I:i ~ l' j;'
~;, t, U' .
,I ,~1,
~9r ~ I rll'~: 1 ~.... ''1 t~ '\
, I 'l; ~ I ,J \
,-
'.,. .
W:)
"
.......-...
,. .
........~ ....r
"
;1
"__ ......~.. i _' ~'
. .
IJ W)'i
.'
I_~- '_" .._.. '_"__'__'_ .....
'II J.'1M
()UtlJVI1
,,\IS
tI
A'IM
Vmlt'l
VtlOl
r: 'I ..
:MlI;jO
$\'1'101
$0"
....,"-. .............-. -...--'"......- ------..,.." .._--.-
~..._... .-....--------..-
,.
"'
.
'.
r:
':
t.l hJ
~ :>0-
n; iE
.::I Q
Z 0'(
~ t.l
Z
~) 0
::f
7
0
:r
.;J
.-- -- ...........-.-.. -,-.-
'"
.,w,
".-.-.
.....-
. . .......
I ~.,.. ,
-. ,
-
\'
,
I
~ !
po
~ ~ i
f- ~tllI (Il ."
Z
w
<:I:
glX
0::< ~ z
~~ ~ I
.0 ~ J i
~ gc!~
~ 0( t g i
~ !i!i
o III 1 01
~" i lit:
~~ ~ i
-w ClO llI:
Ow ~
z
C3
z
w
~ ~ :;
ZC ~-i 11Il
jIl:> tJ tJ
~rd ...,: oi
~
I
~
~
.1,
."........,
31131:1
....... ,..._............. . '. ,_ . ... _ .4.... ..._..._...... .._..... ....__~_
~t..~~!~ .'~ ! I
>Hfv d
I.i
,,"0 . 0-'
____./:I. ~~'1"".- '...
-..~1R'f' ~'.
\
'( .../
\ ~.., .,.-/
,./ ./'
" //"
\\ .....,...
/ .
/ "
\ \~~<'
~_., ~\\ ~ \,
.-' .... ,/,., \ \ '\ ,/
..' \ \, ,,/ ..
-: II / /" '. \ 'C, \/ /
-l" /'_. \ \ 0,.
~ "r ',e "
;;.. ......- '. \'.\ .
~D .~. ;,..." ) \\C" .. 6\('
" ,/ .'l-,A'"
"."", "..- ." \
,/ r.... r'}
,/ /~'\' \
" /' \\ \
' ..- \ u>;\. \ ..-
/ \"1:.\ /
" \\, '1> \ .1,.....-'
" \\,. , .,
'~'r1~ \ //' /::~
\' <.- V' .. ._
\ .. ,"
'\ /;..."
- -
/.... '\ .. '\' <.-:....
" \. "/:..'\-.' (\
\. '." ....
/' ~~; \('.,:,
"J". ~~. r....
,......' .........../\
CJ
.:(
o
CY-
1? \
\\\~ \
~. \
\\ \".,. " ,/",
\.
\
...J ...1~
,.... ~,.;;'
'';-:'
~?'.
.'
...
/ ,,' ...Si.
. ... ~ eft.-
..... lJ ...
,.'- ..-., \ \\ \. ,/"
- ~'..
.-
,..,.,....
-
--~... .~....
"..-'"
.-
"
..
.*-~
-
"
."'T...__.....--
,/
........~........
.-
..
"
,~~
"
.' / :'\'\
// ~x..\"
....'?-G ....
.,/"/ ~>It ' /..,.."..
~...
.............-
_..."..
-
-
-'
.....
"
~
),NNns
I
J
, I
, ,
, !
I
I
.
I-
Vl
~
~ \ //..
\/
I
I
I
,
-
.'
.....
..-;
-
-
..
/
./
~.
...-
....
.F
/
..,
.'"
/'
.,/ \)~
-..1~~
~ ...'.
/'
/'
..'.
......
.'
../'
...'
/'
....
....
...
..-
,..'
,/ '0~
to- -..\ C(., ~ /..
,,-
.......
....-
..'
.....-
../
..
"
,......'
....
f~:~ ."
',-
--.-- ........ ..--q-----..___ ..... -.... __H_..... '.,_ ~~ L _. ,.._......
ta:: '"
,. ~ ~
'--.,1 ."'~"',,- ~;~ ...~r.f~!"!\--~~- ~+
- t! .Jmn --
=~.g .H.. ,_ '~{
a~~ II
"'_'___ ....",... 1",_.__- ~ ,~~
~........... - .. u . - -..,.. ,..,.......__u__.-.__..__ ....-- ......1"-......-.
3N01SA3~ ~
! 1
--................."~..~._.. ..", .., ..- -....... .. ...,-~...., - ---....,.,. ----............ .....--..-' .....--...-....-----......- ....--
I , ~
" ~Q.
~g
'l., '4v~nno
',:-,::::-:,:::,::,:P___m ___ '_. . ..._..._.,
~,
r.
,.
r'
IL'
..,
'~( . -. O'~'
......
.....
.. .
..., I~
0. ".~ '....
. . "
~ ~/ ''',
, ... ~;~.~;~:; -'~~:ryl . .......~.- J
......,~.
.... -.-.-'"\ ,/u)) (., .
, ~ / '. ,
'..... .,-'
--......
........._ _................ H .._.._...._....
JNt
--..-......................
~
U
l-iJ
:z
o
1-
tt')
I.,
:5 .\)
l..
,
.
-.
........
1/)
~...-.l.~J.._.....- t--:
;~
\
\
r..
,
If; ;(1
'.
..---........-. ....._~.._-
. t. '._ 'P'._.
".
....-.....
-..--.....
-....,... --.... ~-..- .'." -.... --...
-
. '<< '.
i ~
1~ = ~
-
~~ ~ a
... to-
Z
I.&J
<:E
gli: U
0:<(
On. g
Iiw
.0 u~w
~
~ i I ~ D
~ vlJ!~
i I ~
l&..C)i~x:
Oz a. ~
~ii ~
OW m
W - I
Z I
(3 ,
Zttri I
w J ~ Ij ril ~
gld ~ ~~ I
~ !
~ f
I
! I
~
~
~
t
O}J
,-
I-
W
1,1
Q;
l-
I/I
I . H 'I:~-.. .. i;I-:'~l-._. . l:!n___j,,,",,'".'j' --".f!I1r".'.' ..,...-.--... "-".--'---'-'-
.' ... . .' ---, 'WJ 'V10')Snl
" 1.. ,._____..__.. n....__......~.
o
I:
,I.
,Ii
; qr
; ,11~
; r n
1":(
Q.i: iI'
o'
IY. '
..:>
...
I..
W
",
,.,u..' ........,. .__~"___'" .' " ._"'.,..._..~._ .,'n_
Hlf10:] :>JVO J^1'1 JI.." ..,')
..... ....- - -" - __u,_ _'h." h_'__.__, --- ,-- ..... f
.J .'IVl
1-
l,J
u.'
n:
,fo.
1;)
3nNJI\'"
'. .~...
-'.-,---..
- ----.....-.--..,." .... ...---.
..........-._~-.-...........-....
c
~
2
lJ..
hI
"")
'...-.------,..,..-...-.
JnN3^"
aoow.JotJ
, C
I ~.. ,
gy , ~q
"I
~
.,
If ., I ..
.1 ~ t
.l' ., j
jo, 1, 4 ~
~ ... ... I
r.: .,
, '"
'1: : I
" I (:
,
o
-{
o
IY.
'- --" - ,. ...-
3nNJNI
Cl
-1:
o
0::
,'J,
:!
~~
~~
QI~
~ ~)_H_ ___________________
. - ..-..-..-.--.---..- -.. .....'- .. -'----j:t 1;1': JtlH'IS-rr
ml '.I'Lr1iL- _00_.'_'_'" ,...~..u_.._____.____.... __ __,
..... - -, .... '-'" .,..- n___., 1:1-,.,. r!
..... ..u__~ ..~_. ._._-. _.,
3
:! t....
~~ ~
~'"i I
~~~
~.,~...:.<,
,
r ~ ~r1
!\ 1-
l"
-
,1:/llIl..;: j'
;M d') 1,,'.11'
- -.. "'T N" .~.... ~-.o,.. __.
'flH
)f'1 "t ;- t
I. 'I \ I"'~ I' . ."
. ~ \ .J
, . ..'_ '" ..'" ..,.. _...l:?,
--:: - _.. -...
n.
'1-
-
ri[
f.":... (~;...\... --...... .,.. _..... ._.__..~ .. '...h...........~_...__ . ......___.
/n (lIn >JO
?! '''./1.. ..__ _........ _ ._....__..,..,.., _. __,___ ..,__. '............
,
..Ir+t
.1'
~ I
0-
E
V
~
<tt'
\.II
='
~.
w
>
"It
to-
Z
LrJ
<:~
01-
-0::
0:::-<(
00..
~LrJ
.0
~
~
~
...."
Oz
~ a:: :g
u~ ~
z
C)
Z
I.&J
-..., -.. .- ~'-'-""""''''_.._____._.__n _... ___.,
'HO
\ ..........., ..... -_._~ .. .....----~-_.. .. - ....-.--.----..
o '-_...-.. -
~(~. 1 ~,! VI10NDVVl __...
" l;l .. _____.....__
.. 1;1 _.. / r'" ," ..----- ....- ,. - ,,'h. --... ---- ..
I i~
U:' ..
..",~
U)
~I
I
I ...'
....-.....-....... .._--_.._-~.,~,...
..' --. -. . ..... ..
...
t'1
t"l
/
1.11
-.
,-
0:
;-
'.:!
0-
U
....
t
o
t"l
I
:1:
,..
:;.)
o
If)
'l.\ __......._ __......._....._._, ___ ._..............___
,'~\~F-----~lVd ~~~J_l~l_____.._ _
l,j.._/f.'I :.....,...-....<,..-...--..-,--.-..-.-- J,
:!
~.s
~~
~~
,
-j
, I
I~- ::
I!!!(l -
~~ .h 0
010 01 co
:
f ,
. ,
. ,
I
t;
g
~ i =Ii
! Q.
ac!ll~
~~ I .s Q
~ .s ~
< 'tl 01
. a::
~~:v
~:E8
-j
: I
J
:.J
~ ,ti t
fCl~'" ~v
~~ ~~ ~~
~
~
l
l
I
!
I
I
,
1
I
\
I
i
i
I
~
..
~
l
w
:;,
:To
w
>
~
....
u
w
n.
VI
o
0:
0..
?!"~". ."
__ _., __... __._..__.. J l
__" _....................._~ _.... .... u.r \
.,-....... .... ,....__..~-,
_. ...-........... ""
-...-......,. .....-.--. ~
lJi
"-:o-!r~~).~' ,..
'.
<,
1...,_._ ,.,.,_,. __.___..._J' on'. -- ,-'.. ,.--- - ..-..
_._ .._ .~_~_,. ____ __ _._ ._~~13~~~~,:~~ ._~. _~~,-, _~.~~]
o
w
0:
v;
\
\
\
\
\
~\ 1
"1:\ ! if
\ t;..:
--.,.-,.--- - - .----- \ 8 -
)m~;'~~---'--"""'~,~" _.u _..~~ f. ___ ..._.. __d~: ~I.Q~_.__ :11 , .'
. -----....."... ---..- ---- ----, ....-..,.,. "'" . .... ~:-~r:' 01 ^ va ..t;!~l 7~'~.-=t,
_..._.... ._..__ '___ '__"'_~_' ......d......__......._,
~ ~
;la~
loi;..
~e~
...,eiS
~.s~
r~ .'
",tto)
,,_..._ ......._.._ .._-.._._1""-" '-"-'-'- ... ......- ---' .--..-,.-- .-- ,-. -...- ____,...r'
nvou ~NOld~VH: I
'.'_"' ..,___n __.._ _..____ '!;. ';. .. . : rl,
.. -.--..... -. . -_.. -. u__ "r'~'-'''';' ..,-t+.....,_...l.L._--..-.
; ;' 'f :': I ;\ "I
I"
I . ~ I . t tt
I I r II;
. , .
, I'
\ '
II'" ,
~
co
o
I-
~
:::l
~
I.
OAla
"
~
~~ ~ -
-
.
t- o
Z en
W
<~
at-
a:ei t; i
On. -<
liw ; 0
.0 ....
~ a ~ ~
~ -< 0
'~ m c
~ 0: ~ ~
J!!l
lo.Cl - t
O2 a-<
~iE g:~
iJW
W -
Z
~ &; &i I~
W dl !
I:> -i1~!V
gni ~ !~
,
~ I
~
t
I I
i
, !
~ I
!
a I
~
,
I
.
I
I
,
),
:O:~'f i.
I
r
'~ vi
,.:
r
3Al1F.R
(
\
(
\
.~. 'rl"t'HL")
8
:j
III
I-
n-
::5
n
I...~
'.d
l.)
...
i,'s
II:
....,
t..
,I
)-
Z
W ' '
l.I~ o(::::E
:. oI- I
;;: ii: ~ t; !,
I..' o.ct
~.,..... . . ~~ ~ I b
~ a ~ 1
~ rOll
~ w:r: c
~ .: ~
~ .. ~
u-C) ~ I a
Oz ~ 1
~ii: ~ :r: iii
OW 01 :r:
W ~
Z I
C)
z t t S ~
w i~ ~~! ' f
ga:l ~ a: I
I
~ i
)
I
i I
I
I
!
i
,
~ t
I
Q I
I
I
I
t
I
j
I
I
I
I
I !II L" !'t"EI' . ,.' ~':' ,
. _ H.. .' em. II \
.... ...' .... -, . \ \
... I ~ ,.
\
['l
,.
!I)
...,
.,1
c.
u
'-
,
)
.
..t-
III
19
III
:!
~Ji
ii:~
:::5:::::
~~
l.1
..J
( ,
ry:
1..'
N
o
N
11--0
)
::.-:
"II
lo!
tr.
(,,)
_I
-.
:r.
Yo
CI"
<i
::r
'-)
z
:.~
c.
u
....
.
1.0
,..,
I
Ol
~
~
~r1 ]H.') r Uti
1
.. I
" ,
l.' ':.
. ,
,
I r'
c
o
:i:j
o
:;:)
\..
\..
o
U
4-
o
Q)
u
o
lL.
.....
o
U)
u
o
lL.
\..
Q)
C;
C
c
o
:;:;
o
01
:J
\..
\..
o
U
~
(1)
......
:J
o
<( ---
N
........
.-
......
C
lJ.l
E
w......
t: ai
.2 E
c: Q)
'w ~
0:::,2
...c .5
tIl Q)
lJ.l0::
E...c
w VI
~ ,Ill .D Q)
oEi.i:E
- 'Q) ~
'N.o: w
-' :_ N ..0
",' u.. ........ i.i:
..-
"'0
c:
o
II
N.....
'-.,c
I- v
_ E
: III
t") U
II ~
f-..E
c
~ .-
W v
010::::
'-
O.L:
..J fn
......
c .
Q)Q)
E ,9-
:00.
v '-
VlV u;
= ~ ~
0(1) g
>..
lV E
...... '- 0
vO
c.-V; ......
E 5
oE \..
o 0 en
vJ:: ~
> V :J
0_ (I)
E..o tIl
v..o ~
0:: 2 a.
<(
I U1
<( ::E
-.J IJJ
<( l-
I- ~
W
0 0:::
0
~
l.1..
0
-.J
~
W
a
,.... N
c,
. :J
, : <..?
: \-, -:--'-'
~
'3:
o
"
o
, ....
I
:
t")
.x
to
(I) :
vN :
.9- II II Ii
0.1-1-1-
\
'- t :: ~
~~g~
\ ' ,
I- -
z ~ ~ -
Wa i ~
~ II) ::
0:(0::
0:::: ~<(
oo.w
~ ~Wa:
.o~a: I
W a:: III W !
~ w z
(f) 0:::1 1
~ ~ Q. ~
a:: ffi 1
0:::: <( u a:
0 ~ 0: U j
I- u ~ ~ 1
tf) <..?ZU !
u..ziil
0_0::
a.. ~ffi
-w
~ U z liidlD )-
lD
, ~ i~1 I~
u
z
0
I- ~ 1
u
w
tf) '1
I I
I
!
~ !
c I
Q
~
-ti
"'0 Q) iii
Q) ,~
Vl ..-.. :J C
:::I (I) 0- 0
(I) Q) '-'-
Q).....
Q) Q) \.. cO
~-: VI c01
0 .- ::I
o 0 l-
E ~'-
v III III 0
.......9- '- >0
Q) 0
C 0. C l..
.Q) Q) -IV
~E$ ...... -.......
VI v:;:)
Q): 0 {io
~o -
001"") "'0 ~.8
,......... Q)
.........5 l.. ..... ~<;:
OlVO 0
l..- :;:)
...... ...... <..?"'O
I ~~ 0
0 . C
: ;Q 00
~ to
t'1 lL. ..... Q) I"") VI
_x 0 0 ~ c
;"~v 0 .....0
a. 0'-
:J......
-.c 0 ::1: ,-0
0...... 0 .....01
U;~a. 0' 1Il:J
..... c\..
c(/) C VI 0'-
_""",-",,t_ C uS
tr}
~
ui
. I'"
. " ,"
" .'
, '
, .
., '
.. ,-
.N> :-:,.
, '_'. ('J , .
. . : < 1-: : I-~ :
L ,. "
, , '
.:.:: :.~ .:': ::
, ' , : .'~ ',::,:-:
, ~' .
, ' '
v '> '
, ...... '
.- ..
~"-'., "
,"~' "
FrJ3
CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION
Agenda Cover Memorandum
l.t L.j- ::::1:. D.t.
~./7. 1'5
TO DREW STREET (95-19)
SUBJECT:
HAMPTON ROAD WIDENING - GULF-TO-BAY BLVD.
RECOMMENDATION/HOTION: Award a contract for the HAMPTON ROAD WIDENING (GULF-TO-
BAY BLVD. TO DREW STREET) (95-19) to R.E. PURCELL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. of
ODESSA, FLORIDA for the sum of $588,473.97, which is the lowest responsible bid
received in accordance with the plans and specifications,
DO and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same.
BACKGROUND: This project proposes the widening of Hampton Road to a standard
three lane urban section with connections to GUlf-to-Bay Bvld. (state Road 60)
and Drew street. The existing roadway is a narrow two lane facility. The
roadway is being widened in conformance with the provisions of the Development
Order for the Development of Park Place. The project includes construction of
a stormwater collection system, replacement of the existing 1211 water main and
construction of a stormwater treatment facility on the former Seabolt property.
Funding for the project is from impact fees paid by the Park Place developers.
This project will start in September 1995, and is scheduled to be completed
within 150 calendar days.
The available balance (obtained from Park Place developer) in the Hampton Road
Widening capital improvement project is sufficient to provide funds for this
contract.
T _u "H__. .. -.,.
I Reviewed by: I
, Originating Dcpt_
I Legal N/A! /.1 I
' - I; Engineering Oepl1r h t
Budgct ~"uJ~!i U D t . .1
.t,/ . 'I scr ~ - I
Purchasing . ~4/1... I: " / I
' ~ I, na ,
II Risk Hgmt. N/A I _
" AdvertIsed: I
IS N/A lj
1 ACM ~ Qc.l\ !lOl1te: 06/24/95 & 06/30/95 11
ENG~ A" fl.- . !IPl1per:st. Petcrsburg Times
: I ! ,!] Not required
I OlllER ,,'. II
r ("\'1 Affcctcdpnrttes
SUbmltte~/4~ ',' 11 notifted
! City HlI7fler 7.,.. If Not rcqui red
(Current FY)
I
I
I
t
J
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1 Bid tabulation and summary
I Typical cross-Section Sheets
I
I
Appro...cd
Costs: $588,473.97
commission Action
Funding Source:
Approved
w/conditlons _____
Capt. Imp. X
Operating
Other
Denicd
Cont'd tc
Appropriation Code(s)
315-92143-563700-541-000
Attachments:
x
ItAMf'lUN AON
'...'
T....U\.AT~ 0' 1101 lOll, H~"'''O!'f~O~D MOlHlOID IQlII.I,TO I~V TO O~IW ITIIU.lD'
'10 0"1""'0 wt O"fI 0" V JUU n Uu
"W""DO"U, ltIllI!I II" " "UGUST II '~n
IH"" OU<:~I'TIOH llU"HTny KI""""NS -.AMMltmA &. lllrIAST~IlT ""'M l\ I. 'U~t Itl
NO CONlnACTmo Con' ~OllOYOIIS. '''C, 'AVlliO CO, COH'nACTO~S,lIjC COlil TnUC1.011
fA....,..., FL, G~A"O nA'IOS. MI IAnllo,n 'II.IUAI 'Ano, H CO""AII', l..c,
DOUIA, 'I,
I. CUAnlOO a. Ql\UI..NQ.AIMllV"L.O'VOUL, ALL IXC"VATlllH5 IlnOSIOH Cll..TnOl I L S, n,soo 00 15000 DO ",4JO 00 a,OOll 00 ".'".n
I"SIOl nlW.IO/CIVOI"O "'MOVAL 0' AU "DAD MAHnIAlS'" A"UnuH....CU.
.00tw...~.S,"'U. nnUCTvnu,nc t.."nOXI......J!lT 4 )0 At!
2 ,nOVlOI & !'l..CI co"""...cno no...ow.., riLL rrnue. "'IAlunu SUO C,Y 600 500 1150 r.n 6,11
l co"srnucT non", WAun 'ONO CO""UH I L 5 n.ooo 00 4' 000 00 1 I, '1)0 00 10,000 00 JO,)I.II
4 lIun IO'UI"D O' CHAIN IINO 'I..CI Il S 1,100 00 1,00000 001 I 000 00 '5'..1.
S COHSUUCT 4" COliC~HlllOfW~lK .CITY IHOH 'lOti 1t,OOO,5 I, 1.71 1'0 let I.,. I,U
.. CO"ST~UCT '" COItC~11I Onllrlw", on 1I0IW"l.. J,OOOI', l JI llS 2'0 , os lU
7 COHST ~VCl C OHcnt u tun. I,OOOL " 725 '00 .10 .45 'QS
1 CONST~UCT l" n,t I'C l AS'HAL1'C COHCAlU 'OOOG.... 000 170 ] IS 415 000
I CONSI~UCT I" C~USHIO ~ICYClf CONC~UI "'51 1,000 , , 1,:1 , 00 "' 110 1,]4
10 cOHn~ucr U. ItAB'UflD SUB C:II"OI TO l . n AO 10 000 , T l as '00 110 US UI
11, INST..IL I" UNDI~0~A'''1S0n lll. CIlIr IHDIX "DS 4,71)0 L I 1100 1000 11.75 IUS 1054
12, INIT All I' HOH 'InIOU no UHDlADRAllnSOR 711 '00 L I , 100 11.00 105 1000 ."
U IIjnAll UNDfRonAIN CUANOIJl 10 fACl1 ~OO 00 IJ500 16000 noo 111 ..
I~ CONST~UCT S S' x 3~. STORU """HHOll TY'1 J H , ucu 3,$1)0 00 2,00000 2,Or:o 00 1.15000 I. lA4 01
11001 I"OU , 2001
II COIfnRUCT I TORM M"NHO~' ICIT ~ IHOU n021 o I..C,l J.OOO 00 1,000 00 1,Inoo 1,7UOO l,lU,6S
II. CONnnUCT "'1 "., SINC:U \\IIIjG Imll .tllY INCI~ UIO. \\11TH IITtlIR ~ on 0' AI"CU 2,JOO 00 1.600 00 2,01000 2, lOll 00 1,A3I,SI
WlNGI
17, COtlSTRUCr TY" A,l COVBI! \\ImG INlH ,CITY I"OU '2101 4 IACIl 2,100 00 2,000,00 J.U5,OO l.250 DO 1,111 U
II. COHnRUCT CfoNfnOl URUCTVAl WITH AlUMINUM 5.I....MI~ I',TY II.DfX '2l5 II..CII l.OOO 00 A,OOO 00 2,015 00 %.100,00 S.151.55
Mool"IOI
II. IH!.TALlll" RIIHIonCfO CONCRIH "~I 1.IOOl f H,OO 3100 11,10 11,71 n."
lO. IHIUlLl~" nf.NlORCID CONCRUf Plrt: $SOLI. 2100 .. 00 1:',25 H,IO 21,14
11, eOIlSTRUCT H" IL..1II0 'NO IleT'OH .,oor INOI~ ,HOI I I"'''' '00 00 100 00 125 00 475,00 111,10
lJ, ~ACR a. 10nl ITlIl CASINO co....,. WITH ..lL ""UIIITlH"NCls 1ST 'fTlRuunO 20 I I .noo 600 00 5" 00 11000 U4,n
W"'UIII"""""
u, "OJU" VAlIII covIn TO """'TCH nOAOW"" CIl"OI , lAC.' US 00 usoo 1500 1100 nUl
H. ~IMOIII .. nl,...ACI UNSUllAIll ""'U~IAl "~UC' ""'''SURU SOD C,~. A 511 1100 11 es 110 1100
21. TIIAHIe CONTnOl I l I, 25,000 00 1'.000 00 51.000 00 II ,000 00 U.n5,n
U, 'IIItrAIIUION,IHSTAU"TlON.. U"NAC''''''HT 0' ~nOJICT SlONS I' IIXUI SHUj" , lACH AIO 00 500 00 AOO 00 ISO,OO 215.15
11, IHHAll SOD 70,000 S,I, 0,15 0,25 011 o.n 0.10
u. '"UHl UIITINO ll11n 11I0011 21)0 l r, 2 so 11)0 2 AS Us lU
21. INIT"'LllIoor l..nRII~ 100 L.f, 100 500 ,n 400 121
20, fURHISH.. IH""ll U' oucn'.( IROH W...UR .......tH 1,60' L f, l5,~5 AS 00 lO,O;O 11,65 1I,1~_
l1. 'UlIll1SH.. ,0.1" All CO"',ACT bUCTllllnOIl W"II~ MAU. FlTTlNOS ~ (0" ~.SOO 00 ~,700 00 I, '10 00 16,000,00 A.S It D.
U. ,VRUlII. .. INS Ull U. wA un "',,". VAl"'l 2 l..ell 1.000 00 1.200 00 1,11500 l.l15 00 1,014 so
n, 'UnNlSII.. IHnAU u... U' U''''''O SlUlrl .. V"lVI 2lACII l'OOO 00 J.200 00 2,1UlIO 1,000 00 J.nl,n
It ,unWSH.. .N""U'. OUCIIII'''O'' WAU" "'AlP' 100 L/, uoo J200 U '0 2000 n AI
21, ,UIll....H.. IN.T"UI. W..u" """'N .....lV' 11..Ct< HOllO 600 00 700 00 A5000 IIIU
21, IvnN'"I" 'N"AlL I. OUClIlll"ON wAlIn MAIN 100 L f 1000 " 00 1100 1100 nOA
n. 'UllNI.H I.NIT AU .. WAlI~ MAIN V"L v, I fACIi SSO 00 100 00 '6000 US 1)0 AOO 11
21, ,URNI.1l & INnALlU. MIlR.."nn O.S~" JO ,''C,. 11500 lOll DO to 00 n5DO lUll
n 'U"NIIU" .~IT"LL ,. P'U1P11AINEI\G4'liIft 4 fACII .000 6000 SlllU 100 00 10101
. -.--. -.---------
00 'U~IlISH" ItlllAU .. nl5r~A'NIA c"Son .. t.A'U noo ~o D<> 4A 00 liS 00 t4 .,
0" INST"ll SlnvlCf "nl..CiI 'fn S1RVICI l"" ,""".GS rAOVlOlO B~ C"~I . .f.ACU 15000 70 O<l 11000 100 D<> SlOll
41, ru~NIIH .. INST...n '" $I ~YICI ""1 200 II SOO A 00 5 so SOO 511
AS, ru~NISN "NST"U J. ,vC I:A51"<1 ~oo L I S51I 500 LO~ SIlO ISO
OA, ,vntjllH .. l'llTAU fI~1 ll'O~"NT ..UI....aL' 11"CII 1 100 00 1.700 00 I,USOO 1 000 DO .."S11
~., 'URNISH.. 'NSTAU l. 1I......0U~' IlOWllH lIACl1 500 00 _00 00 HOOD 5WOO usn
~1DOlll'5 10UL U,....I'I~ 00 lIuonoo nto OU" .n5,1I500 'UI,4H ..
!
!
j
1
l
I
1
.
I
I
I
,
I
i
I
!
aID SUMMARY
UIDS SOLICITED - 29
CONTRAc'rons PICKING UP PI~NS & SPECS
CON'l'RJ\C'l'ORS SUUMl'l~l'ING IUUS
9
,.
:7
NO RESPONSE
.,
n" COUU CONS'l'HUC'l'ION COMPANY
CONE CONSTRUCTORS, INC.
KEAUNEY DEVELOPMEN'l' COHl'ANY, I NC "
ALL AMERICAN CONCRE'rE, INC.
-,I
tf!.i.\t'.--:'..'.',.~~,"',~... ~
, ....'40
~ t.~ " '. ", 1<
lL~TON ROAD WIDENING (GULF-TO-BAY BLVD. TO DREW STREET)
BIDS'SOLtCITED - 29
'.
, ,
; !
~
. '
,\11 Am..dclI" ('''HIt'I.'ll'. Ill.
...... :11]00 ~ l!it.h AV['IUlf' NOI'! It
51.. r..I"I"MIHlI"!{, 1'1" ,:1:171 t
....
t ,
ell I "d..." I ",'H!' t.!'lIe' It'll ,'".
1\720 t Hit II ,\". {" Ill". , 1-/..,., h
',"I":". Frul~'dn ;f ~fi '~1
II. C'"hlo ,'oIlR1I'''''l I "II, Ill".
'!l \ nn '~.~ll) I\ve t.. ~:i.J.. \ir~~J;\'~ ',lo
1.11 I'!:", rt.. ~ III 1:1
rh" (;"11[' e""I'ol'''' lOll
1'.0. l\l'~ :\1111l;7
TlIIlIl'tl. FI"I'\IIt1 ;1:!t:lI11
11"11,,,< J eo"".,. A Ill..'.. 'III".
1'.0. !lo... zmll)!i/l
T.'ml,l<:, "'ITllcn, FJ.. :1:lrllli
GIll.....'. !'j"1I1 JI['nl r:"I'J'(lt'Jlll"/1
Gin r]lI~1I Ill'.. :;1111.' 27.J!';
['"II"..:,' rlll'''. lit'''I>:i" ,IO:Jt~l
1111"11","01 .:mllOtrll.... ."" l'''n1I'H''~'
I'.n. lJo~, :; 11211
('1']111101". Flu :1~llr,I-7217
r".ttru(.) ll,"" ~ Ctl... [n<: \
11"21 ~Jnl'llll 1.111 It"" l\lll!t lIlt'd., ".
1'11"'I'Il. f'I,. ,1:11\10
1\ IllInllu' 1'''1\1.1'11\'[ i I\\( (:,,,.\,.
1!i0 I ::'11,1 ," ""11~
I <Illll'H, II., :I:tlHli,
ll\.I-!;lnlp I'''\'\II~ I',,'nl'''''~'' Ill<'.
:Inll IIIlI"lId"," I/nn"
,\,.IJ'I.,wl., ] [~, Fl.. J;:ll2;'
n\.-,r~t J'f.,.t P;''\.lJIH '.ulllpllll~'
J 'HCl nOhfl':~lU !ll)nd
I.,...,"" , 1'1" :111111
PI'III{"[' ("U!I t J.~tl:- t I u~ ("('I. I I Uf.O.
1i.111 Ii \ J II Ii It,)",'
I'I1In"'I.,,, 1'1., :1 I:';: I
1/",,1,1;" 111.111'.., II,,: ,
1!j.J Ilr, f'; II" II l dl\" nun,1
l'u!'l !1)'PI"I, !II" :J:l!lH!l
H ~ F \''''11 '1111..,." "IC',
Hr,': I ~ flllt h .,\\.....\ ~",'I 11
t.rl~H..h"t..~'.. FL, :t ~r;~~O-::H!lrJ
J.\tllb' Ilnl"'!1I COIIHII'lIcI,1011 ro.
.11113 31 \.11 5trcol, !'lort.1I
HI.. 1'('1 ""!4hurjf, 1:1" 3311-1
C.,Hh COIIIlI.I'lIel.Jflll 1:llInl'll.U'
2112 ^~~ln"toll Drl\'1;'
H,ll1u'. rh~ttt'~ln ;lOin:.
f.f1fl" C'''l~~ t ~'.Je lo}'r:;:, J UC" 4
1'./). n,,~ :!~Ilj;f)
I "'"Ilfl, 1'1" J:!!i22- 21!!i!}
'1'.,\. t.'lInrmll1~" [;OIlHI"IIr.l.lflll ('''I'!,.
2~ I hi,...,...! It,,11~ rlnnd
Tnn'oll !;I'I'l'"tR I Flo/"Jcln 3'Ili/l9
~Jllr' III t,:, ~;h)' Cum.I.". Cu" Jllr..
I'. n. 11,,\ :JOUn:!!}
1'''''11 1'/1I'1~, Flo,'Jd" :J27Jfl
(95-19)
,
lilt' ""1'<111"" l' C'o'"I"\IIr I'
1'.0. n".'. 2 !)Olll ;
1''''111'11, l.'\ol'ldn :\:\I\ll1
1~/l'"lt\ 1111\11 & ""0\1-'01' t t\, 1111:.
1'.0. llllx ;llO:l!JG
1'1\1\1\,1', l'\ol'1~11\ 33GB!}
~o~Mln"~ K~rnvnLnr~1 I"~.
.171 ~"I1I'II'11 noul""II"tl
O\lhntl,l', \', "J'I [In :I,IIi77
'11"1 ".Hll ral.'lrll''I, IlIc.
1'.11, 11..-, IlHifl:l
~ I. 1',,1,1' I....'" r~. Ft.. :l:l7 -I J
II/,d II 1\',>] ,t.... ('on~ """l'tI Oil eo.
;!IR;, .\11"1'11111 ,. III
I'll 1m 1It1I'l",,', Fl.. :l Hi I!;I
1'1'111"1.. COIlRI.,"UC II "" Co., I tit'.
",0, 110.'; 12!J
l'oll,l'Ilr, 1".> :I~IHiR-OI::!1
/I.F.. I'll IT"1 1 r'O'Il<tllwl.l,," C..,I'II".
1', n, ll<l~ R:17
11.,.. "!l 11 , FI,. 3:!/i[jr,
n",,'1 nil", I III''']'"",'nl ,,11
t',\lf,;, 11\2.,,1 ^VI.')t1I', tlol" h
I'III,.IIII!l J'nr'll. l'l,. ;llflf\f1
Slnl.'I)' "oul tlld,lt'li, lul'.
71)7 1;1l1h SI. 1'1., I'lIf.l, lillll t. r:
JI"IIII"III0Il, n,. ;121011
1.""11 I'll 1.''''1'<1'11\'1 I"" ("11'1'"1'111,1'''1
", n. 1111\ '11'1
I"tln,,'! III, Fl. :\.12211-111'1
\
i
r
I
,
\ :
I'
!
.:.PA......._..j
I
l
i
I
1
,1
I
'.'
I
,
l
1
!
j
I
\
I
\
I
I
\
I
i.
~ i
:J't .', '
3Nn NU lSYJ
::INn M!tJ .lSV3
3Nn M/tJ .l5]1,\
~
~
5 mr--
p
~
z
o
u
~
..l.
oll
~ ~
8
~
+
-lit-
~....
~~
..,
~~
~g
...
....g
~~
~~
.~g
gi!
~~
&i5
0:.
110.10
w
~
~~
olli
&1~
Bo
.
00
g
~~~
~.o: 8
::!~~
~~ J;
~~ g
0=8 ~
~~ IE
it
g
in 'in
wi
;., ~ .
00
'"
in
.,;
~I
""
:l!:
m
m
5
oll
""
~
'in
..;
8
ui
00
+ ...
:2 z
l:S
~ 110.
w ~\
t~ ~ ~
0= 5
i:J~ 6
,..
+ cr
00 C1.~1-
g
:J: '"
0
IE ~ ~
.
10
in
~
~;
"'l~
~~
~ Bo
~
.:r ~~
if ~ ;
M ~
-~-~
e
1!1 h
B
B
:I
ii~i ~ 8
i ~~ III
~ ~~
1!
3NI1 '3SV3 . dl'Ol .lS~
... ,~ ',",
:i
3 2!
:i
~~ S
;:)0:
8~....cr
~la!9
w 00
5~~'"
~m~~
~i:~,",
:clj:::lr:li!
He o~-
4/'eJlO:J.!
ai-~~
~5!l;;!
.
~~ ~
~ I i
~ g
~ i I
~ ~ ~
i g
~ ~
e:
"
~r..... ;.;...:..
, .
,I
::i
3Hn ltol'l3SY3 51 :i
-- bl8 !i
12:- ~
B~,..Q:
3Nn MIH lSV3 I~!~
aJ~~
-
!oJ w ~I=~~
0 CI ~
~ <<
~ ~~ % :::E~
+ ino In ~ 0 -
~ ~~ a ~\ 8V1::l..L
uti Gi-~
~ ~ ~ ~c 75~1i)~
i!: :.l ...... ....
g ~ m?: .
:::E ""'10 N
..
Q:g . 00
00
'" .
('oleo
eo
+ N
~
..t.
...
VI
~ in
~' ~ ~ ~I i 8
~ ~ ~' I
~
e.w- ~ g
~ in i
cl f2
:z:
0 8
u
~ r ~ :8
" ~ ~
z +
~ :;;! Oil
-
+ .... ~ g
~ z
l5 ~
~ n.
~ w ~l ~
CI 'io ~ I:
%
~ ~ ~ 12:
CI
~ 8
:1 :S
J;
-
g .- ~~
a N
e: ~ ~ ~r-- Gj'j
~o
z
~~
in 00
-
:3 Nn M/'d lS311\ I ~ ~ 8
.~ III
! ~e
;INn ':3SV3 'dl'llJ. lS3't\
crs
Clearwater City Commission
Agenda Cover Memorandum
4S
8' .)'7.'15
Stem 11
Meet fng Dote:
SUBJECT:
Proposed Land Development Code Amendment - Vending Machine Signage.
(LDCA 95-17)
RECOMMENDA TION/MOTION:
Receive Land Development Code Amendment modifying restrictions on vending machine signage and
refer the ordinance to the City Clerk for advertising for public hearings.
[] and that the approprfate offfcfals be authorfzed to execute some.
BACKGROUND:
In order to resolve a significant code enforcement issue in the most expeditious manner, the City
Commission, at its July 31, 1995 work session, directed staff to prepare a land Development Code
amendment which would exempt vending machines from City sign code regulations.
The current ordinance treating vending machines as attached signage was part of a comprehensive
approach to regulating the appearance issues involving vending machines. However, this particular
provision has greatly complicated code enforcement efforts, and .could create the situation where a
number of existing properties in the City would face "double jeopardy" with regard to the ongoing sign
amortization program. Many properties have been brought into compliance with 1992 City sign code
requirements; however, some of these properties would become out of compliance if required to adhere
to the vending machine signage requirements adopted in 1993.
The attached ordinance would exempt vending machines from signage requirements, but would continue
to require them to adhere to the setback and other placement requirements as provided in Section
28.10(4) of the City Code (attached).
This ordinance will need to be reviewed by the Planning and Zoning and Development Code Adjustment
Boards.
Reviewed by:
Legal
Budget
Purchasing
Rfsk Hgmt.
CIS
ACM
CRT
iJt-
W/A
NIA
~
Originating Dept:
CENTRAL PERMITTING
Costs: S N/A
Total
User Dcpt:
$
Current Fiscal Yr.
Camaission Action:
o Approved
{] Approved w/cond\tions
{] Denfed
{] Continued to:
;:~'J
Advertised:
Date:
Paper:
1m Not Rcquf red
Affected Parties
o Notiffed
I!i:I Not Requfred
FLIlding Source:
o Capitol I~.
o Operatfng
{] Other
Attachlllents:
DRAFT ORDINANCE
VENDING MACHINE REQUIREMENTS
Appropriation Code:
o None
City
o Printed on recycled paper
;"'>:"',
ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA.
RELATING TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; AMENDING
SECTIONS 28.10 AND 44.08. CODE OF ORDINANCES. TO
DELETE THE REQUIREMENT THAT SIGNS ON VENDING
MACHINES BE REGULATED AS WALL SIGNS; PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
CLEARWATER. FLORIDA:
11
..
11
11
11
11
}
I
I
f
~
I
\
!
Section 1. Section 28.10, Code of Ordinances. is amended to read:
Sec. 28.10. Newsracks and vending machines.
(4) Vending machines on public and private property. Vending machines installed on
public and private property shall comply with the requirements of this subsection.
11
11
*
*
11
11
(b) Vending machines shall be placed only on properties for which there exists a
building serving a principal use. Vending machines shall be placed within a building, or may
, be placed outside a building if the following conditions are satisfied:
.
11
*
11
11
11
8. An', sign upon tho 'landing mooRine whioh is \'isible from off the premisos sholl
bo-deomocl a "'Noll sign," nOt'l'ithstanding that suoh sign is not Dttaehed
direetly to the building, and shall be sl:lbjoct to tho requirements and regulations
of ohapter-41. A sign permit shall be required for eaeh sueh sign effeetive ao
days following tho offeoti..,o dato of Ordiruif\oo 6482 92, nOhvithstanding that
the '/ending maehine may ha'/o beaR installed prior to the effeotive data of the
ordinance. In on ootion to enforce tho requiromonts of this subparagraph, the
sign and not the '..ending maehine shall bo deemed to be in neAeomplionee if I)
sign permit has not been isst:/Od for the sign.
.
*
*
.
.
*
Section 2. Section 44.08, Code of Ordinances, is amended to read:
Sec. 44.08. Exempt signs.
The following types of signs are exempt frem the permitting requirements of this
chapter, provided that number. area, and other limitations set forth in this sectien are
1
it."'::'"
~, ^
. ' , ' ~ ,
'...
satisfied. The area of exempt signs shall not be included in determining compliance with
maximum allowable sign area requirements. Exempt signs are allowed in addition to signs for
which permits are required. An otherwise exempt sign which exceeds the limitations of this
section shall require a permit.
.
*
.
.
*
*
(12) Machinery signs. Examples are signs on newsracks, gasoline pumps, and publio
telephone booths. Signs on newsracks shall be subject to regulation as provided in section
28.10. ^ sign on 0 '..ending maohine sholl bc subject to ragulotioR under this ohopter os a
"~Nall Gign" if tho-sign is '/isiBlo frORl eff the promisos, not withstanding that suoh sign is not
attached dirootly to tho building, and 0 sign parmit shall be reqwred for each suoh aiftA
effectivo thirty days following the effeetivo dote of Ordinanoo 6482 02, notwithstanding that
tho vonding maohino may have beon installed prior to tho offooti'lo dato of tho ordinanoo. In
on aetion to enforoo tho requirements of this subseotien, tho sign aAd net the 'JonEffi::t{t
machino shall bo doomed te bo in nonoomplianoe if a Gign parmit has not boon issued for tho
~
*
*
*
It
*
*
Sectio~. The provisions of this ordinance are found and determined to be consistent
with the City of Clearwater Comprehensive Plan.
Section 4. This ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND
FINAL READING AND ADOPTED
Rita Garvey
Mayor~Commissioner
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Attest:
;
; I
,1/J
Pamela Akin
City Attorney
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
2
~ 28.10
CLEARWATlm CODE
removal in the same manner DR is provided
herein for newsrncks in violation oCthe pro.
-A. visions of this section.
(4) Vending machines on public and priuate
property. Vending machines installed on public and
private property shall comply with the require~
menta of this subsection.
(a) No vending machine shall be installed or
maintuined within any part of a public
right-of.way.
(b) Vending machines shall be placed only on
properties for which there exists n building
serving a principal use. Vending machines '
Rhall be placed within n building. or may be
placed outside a building if the full owing
conditions are satisfied:
1. The vending machine shall be under a
roof adequate to protect the vending
machine against rain.
2. The vending machine shall not be
placed upon the ground, but shall be
placed upon flooring adequate in Rize
and strength to support the vending
machine;
3. The vending machine shall be placed
flush against the building;
4. The vending machine shall nut be lo-
cated within n required setback, open
space, view corridor, or landscaping
nrea, or within a parking spnce or trav.
el aisle within a parking lot:
5. The vending machine shall not be lo-
cated where the vending machine im-
pairs n motor vehicle operator's view of
motor vehicles, bicycles, or pedestrians
upon, entering, or exiting a right.of-
way;
6. 1'he vending machine shnll not be ID-
eated at a place where such vending
machine unreasonably obstructs the
flow of pedestrian traffic or vehicular
traffic;
7. Electric service to the vending n111chinc
shall comply with the edition of the No.
tional Electrical Code currently in ef.
fcct; and
SUPI), No. B
8. Any sign upnn the vending machine
which is visible from off the premises
shall he deemed a "wall sign." notwith-
standing that such sign is not attached
directly to the building. nnd shall be
subject to the requirements and regu-
lations of chapter 44. A sign permit
shall be required for each such sign ef-
fective 30 days following the effective
date of Ordinance 5482-93, notwith-
standing that the vending machine may
hove been installed prior to the effec-
tive dnte of the ordinance. In an nction
to enforce the requirements of this Bub-
pllragraph, the sign nnd not the vend-
ing machine shull be deemed to be in
noncompliance if a sign permit has not
been issued for the sign.
(5) Enforcement; removal.
(a) Upon detennination by the city manager
that a newsrack or vending machine has
been installed. used, or maintained in vio-
lation of the provisions of this Bcction; the
distributor shaH be notified by telephone
that a violation has been observed and shall
be given an opportunity to correct the vio-
lation. In addition, a copy of a written no-
tice of violation shall be posted on the news-
rack or vending machine.
(b) A notice of violation shall specifically de-
scribe the nature of the violation, and sholl
specify n reasonable time in which correc-
tive action may be taken. A written notice
of violation Sl1011 include the date and time
when issued and posted on the newarnck or
vending machine.
(e) Tho distributor may request. an informal
hearing pertaining to the violation. Any
such request shall be made by telephone or
in writing to the city numnger within the
time specified in the notice for corrective
action to be taken. Any such request shRIl
stay the time given to cure the violation
until the hearing hRa been conducted, the
issues raised during the hearing have been
decided, nnd the decision has been commu.
nicntcd to the distributor orally at the con-
clusion of the henring or by telephone or in
OD28:8
T1>
-&~ I
)aE1fD !
r.
1
l
...~....: ";
',....
-~~
C IT Y
OF CLEARWATER r:JJ
InlordepllIrtmllnt Corrllpondencll 1 ~. fl
~ CC r.j
L/~
TO:
Betty Deptula, City Manager
John D. Richter, Senior Planner Cf4
b'l{.
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Vending Machines
COPIES:
Pam Akin, City Attorney
Kathy S. Rice, Deputy City Manager
Bill Baker, Assistant City Manager
Scott Shuford, Central Pcnnitting Director
Cyndie Goudeau, City Clerk
DATE:
August 15, 1995
Yesterday the City Commission inquired whether the code restricts the location of vending
machines.
Yes, to a limited extent it does. The code specifies that vending machines be placed flush
.. against buildings. It further requires that machines not be located in a required setback, open
space, view corridor, landscape area, or parking space. A copy of the applicable code section
is attached for your ease of reference.
Upon review of the code, however, it may not provide the degree of protection desired. For
example, it does not preclude a lengthy line of vending machines in a prominently visible
location against the waU of a building, if the machines are not located in a setback or other
restricted area.
J
,
I
!
\
I
1
I
1
Unless Scott or I hear back from you to the contrary, we will review alternative options to
ensure that the placement of vending machines does not unduly impact the City's aesthetic
interests, and we will present our findings to you.
jmbdvend,ing
RECEIVED
~UG 1 5 i995
CiT" ClERK OEPT.
.
t 28.10
CLEARWAnm CODE
romoval in tho Barno manncr 8a ia provided,
heroin for newsrocka in violation oHhe pro-
vi9ione of this section.
(4) endill machines on public and private
prope y. en In moc 11 es installed on public and
private property shall comply with the require-
ments of this Bubsection.
(n) No vending machine shall be installed or
maintained wit.hin any part of a public
righ t-of-w ay.
(b) Vending machines ahall he placed only on
propertics for which there exists a building
serving a principal use. Vending machines
shall be placed within a building, or may be
placed outside a building if the following
conditions ore satisfied:
1. The vending machine shall he under a
roof adequate to protect the vending
machine against rain:
2. The vending machine shall not be
placed upon the ground, but shall be
placed upon flooring adequate in size
and strength to support the vending
machine;
3. The vending machine ohaU be placed
flush againBt the building:
4. The vending machine shall not be 10-
cnted within a required setback, open
spoce, view corridor, or landscaping
oren, or within n parking spnce or trav-
el aisle within a parking lot;
6. 1'ho vending machine shall not be 10-
cnted where the vending machine im-
pairs 0 motor vehicle operator's view of
motor vehicles, bicycles, or pedcstrions
upon, entering, or exiting 0 right-of~
wnYi
6. 1'he vending mnchine sholl not be 10-
cnted at a place where such vending
mAchine unreasonably obstructs the
now of pedestrian traffic or vehicular
traffic;
7. Eledric BCl"Vice to lhe vending machine
sholl comply with the edition oHhe NA-
tional Electrical Code currently in ef-
fect; and
Bupp. No.8
.
0028:8
...
B. Any sign upon tho vending machine
which fa vlslblo from off the premises
shnll bo doemed n uwnll sign," notwith-
standing that auch sign i8 nol attached
directly to the building, and ahntl be
subject to the requiroments and regu-
lotiona of chnpter 44. A sign permit
aholl be required for eoch such sign ef-
fective 30 dRYS following the effective
dote of Ordinnnce 6482-93, notwith-
standing thot the vending machine may
hove been installed prior to the effec-
tive date of the ordinRnce. In nn action
to enforce the requirements of this 8ub~
paragraph, the sign and not the vend-
ing mochine shRlI be deemed to be in
noncompliance if n sign permit has not
been issued for the sign.
(5) Enforcement; removal.
(0) Upon determination by the city mAnager
that 0 nowsrack or vending machine has
been installed, usod, or maintained in vio-
lation of the proviaions of this Bection, the
distdbutor shall be notified by telephone
that a violation hos been observed and shall
be given an opportunity to correct the vio-
lotion. In nddition, n copy of a written no-
tico ofviolotion shall be posted on tho news-
rack or vending machine.
(b) A notice of violotion shall specifically de-
Dcribe the nature of tho violntion, Dnd aholl
specify A reAsonable time in which correc-
tive nction may be tnkcm. A written notice
of violation shall include the dote and time
when issued ond posted on the newsrDck or
vending machine.
(e) The distributor may request an informal
heoring pertaining to the violation. Any
such request sholl be mnde by telephone or
in writing to the city mnnager within the
time specified in the notice for corrective
action to be taken. Any such request sholl
atoy the time given to cure the violotion
until the hearing hns been conducted, the
iosues raised during tho hearing have been
decided, Bnd tho deciRion has been commu-
nicnted to the distributor orally at the con-
clusion of tho hearing or by telephono or in
"
4t
"
" ,
" . . ~ < .'.
~~r.~(..L..:,,~~. !~~. ~.. ',> :,+ . "
F./ f;o-s-
"
........ ...
'r, ~ J... " .
...t It, ,
, , . .~:~.~H.,"..:".
'.'.
'. .
. '. ,"
AGENDA'
,'" I.~ ..-,t
DATE
~. /1-' CfJJ
';';;"
,4-'" .
~l'"
~,yi
.....
<<~;
!(I
.'~"
::i
.,
1:"'-:-' .
ITEM #
___...... u"__ .
CI1t1~
CLEARWATER CITY COMMISSION
Agenda Cover Memorandum
!lem 11
Meeling Date:
~
Subject:
AmendmCIll of Division 3 of Article 5 of the City Code (Employees' Pension Plan)
R ecomm e nd allan/Motion:
...
Pass Ordinance 5890-95 on First Reading amcndi ng Oi vision 3 of Article 5 of the City Code;
providing for repeal 'of the existing Employees' Pension Plan; establishing a restated City of
Clearwater Employees' Pension Plan cffectivc January I. 1996; calling for a Special Election () n
October 24. 1995; und establishing the bullol question for the Special Election,
o and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same,
BACKGROUND:
During the collective bargaining negotintions earlier this year. City representatives met with
representatives of a coalition of the fmlr unions for the purpose of jointly ncgotiuting Pension
Plan changcs in concept. More than twenty changes were agreed to in concept with the actual
language of the Plan to be developed. submitted to the City Commission for upprovul as a n
ordinance revision, and thcn submitted to the electorute in a rcferendum,
Major changes include establishing the Plan as IRS qualified to allow for cmployee contributions
to the Plan to bc made on a pre-tux basis~ increasing the employec contribution from 6% to 8%~
establishing the City contribution at a minimum contribution of 770 of covered employee salaJ'i es;
increasing the bencfit computation formula from 2.5% for each year of covered service to 2.75%
for each year; decreasing the minimum job-connected disability from 75% to 66 2/3% of the
employcc's average snlary for thc last five years of service~ establishing a process for
reassignment of employees who are disabled to the point they cannot perform their job but who
can perform useful, mcaningful and availablc work in another position within the City (including
a tier system for police und fire personnel); changing thc Pension Advisory Committee from a
three-person el11p'oyee-e~ccteu Commiucc to a seven~person Committee comprised of threc
employee-elected members, three City COlllmissioners or Commission appointees, and a scventh
non-employee l11embel' selected by the other six Committee mcmbers; providing that the Pension
Trustecs arc the City Commission and providing for finul approval authority by thc Trustees;
providing an early retirement provision for employees with ten years of covered service who
reach 65 years of age; providing cmployecs wilh optional bcnefit methods on an actuarially
equivalcnt basis; and eliminuling the $300 minimum pension.
Reviewed by: Originating Cept: Costs: S Commission Action:
Legar~ Human Rosourcesl,t.i.. Total
/' 0
...,f71' Approved
Budget ~ 0 Approved w/condllions
Purchasing NA User Dept.: Current FY 0 DenIed
RIsk Mgmt. NA 0 Continued to:
CIS NA Funding Source:
ACM Advertised: o Capl. Imp.
Other NA Dato: o Operating
Paper: D Othor Attachments:
o Not requlrod Proposed Plan
Submitted by: Affected partios Appropriation Codo: Urd. iJ.5890-95
~q~~~ o NotlfJed
o Not requlrod o Nono
Cltv Manager
iL.~:, .. ,. ,
" " , . .'~r;"'"
'"
Pension Plan Agenda Item
Page 2
August 17, 1995
Subsequent to llpproval of the four collective bargaining agreements, the City engaged the
services of the firm of Kalish & Ward to assist in preparing the draft of the amended Plan. An
initial draft was developed and provided to representatives of the City's four, unions on June 23,
1995. On that date, representatives of the City, including DeputyCily Manager Kathy Ricc, City
Attorney Pam Akin, Human Resollrces Director Michael Laursen, Roger Rovel1 (attorney wi th
Kulish & Ward) and actuary Steve Mctz (of Coopers & Lybrand) met with representatives of the
Union coalition group, including their attorney Lee Dehner, to receive input as to the language of
the amended Plan. A second meeting was held with the Union coalition on June 29, 1995, where
further input was recei ved from the Union coalition group. (At this meeting, the Union conli ti 0 n
spokesperson indicated that the Union's perspective was that the Unions and, City were still in
negotiations as to the Plan language; the City's perspective was that negotiations had been
completed and that mutual discussion was directed at ensuring that all concepts agreed to were
included in the amended Plan.) A draft of the amended Plan was completed on Friday, July 7, 1995.
copies of which were distributed to representatives of the City unions on Monday, July 10th. City
staff subsequently met with the Union coalition on July 28. 1995. to receive further input and. as a
result of that meeting, made seycrnl modifications to the draft proposal.
The proposed Plan was provided to the City's actuary for an actuarial review to be done to project
the funding impact and actuarial soundness. A copy of that report wus previously provided to the
Commission.
Subsequent to adoption as nn ordinance, the amended Plan will be submitted to the voters at a
referendum 011 October 24, 1995. The proposed ballot question for that referendum is attached.
If the referendum is approved. the costs associated with City contributions to the Plan will be based
on the annual actuarial analysis nnd will be included in subsequent budgets.
,.,
~ '
I
!
i
;J:. "
" "
}'
:~, ~( :
~ .:
, "
):.:
, "
~. ,
'~~~n.,~." \.~, r-o'- ~
. X. 4.. '., r, I, ..-! "
'" ~'~., .' . >, ,
'f..
"
I,
~~}
~',. :
I
!', .'
Ii;,
;~., ,
I::: '
i
, "
I! ~'
,J.
It,
~".~
.~ ..
, -",:.
! J,'
1'/';',', .'
:. ,
I:;
!;,
I:::
, ,
" ',.. '~ .
.',
~ ;
" ...'
,~. -,...'
:.' " ;:"~' ..;~.~'"'1'It:'
,~ ,
, !
CITY OF CLEARWATER
EMPLOYEES' PENSION FUND
AMENDED AND RESTATED
AS OF JANUARY 1, 1996
I
~
~~T\,' ,
\ ".. . o'
Section
2.391
.. 2.392
2.393
2.394
2.395
2.396
2.397
2.398
2.399
2.400
2.401
. , ....f'-.. ~ ~'I
CITY OF CLEARWATER EMPLOYEES' PENSION FUND
AMENDED AND RESTATED
AS OF JANUARV 1, 1996
Table of Contents
Title
Page
Amendment and Restatement.. ...... ....................... ..,... 1
Purpose of the Plan and the Trust............................. 2
Def I n It I 0 n s............................ ............................... ~...................... 3
P Ian Ad mi n istration.. ""., ..e..........;........I...... .................... 10
F? a rt I c I pat i 0 n.................."............,........................... ....... 14
Contributions to the Plan......................................... 15
Benefits Under the PIan................................,................... 17
Time and Manner of Benefit Payments......................... 29
Establishment and Operation of Pension Fund.......... 33
Amen dment and Term inatIon... ............... ..................... 38
M Isce II aneous...... .......... I.......... I............ I.e.......................... .'. 41
1,', "
'. .,'
, "I
, \'
"
,
, '
.. ','
~;-J'~:~:"'-:""':"'''';'l'''<''.''"''
I.
; :,
;,
,',
I'
, ;, ~ .:. T :;"<,
, ' ,
,; , .' j .
"'<,' :"',:',
,','~ ,.~,. ~:~~
A pension plan Is hereby amended and restated in accordance with the terms
hereof and shall be known as the "CITY OF CLEARWATER EMPLOYEES' PENSION
FUND.II
.'
,1
, . ~
~, : ,.
"','
i ,
.. -'-<-'.r .
CITY OF CLEARWATER
EMPLOYEES' PENSION FUND
Section 2.391
Amendment and Restatement mu;LName of 1h!LE..Utn
1
, "'.t<'h::':'01t;~~
':
r
l
I
f
f.;.1:"n'.....;. '.n
. ... ..""~
"
Section 2.392
Purpose of tlliLPJan ~the Trust
(a) Exclusive Benefit.
(1 ) This Plan is created for the sole purpose of providing benefits to
the Participants. Except as otherwise permitted by law (including payment of
expenses as set forth in paragraph (I) of Section 2.399), In no event shall any
part of the principal or income of the Pension Fund be paid to or reinvested in
the Employer or be used for or diverted to any purpose whatsoever other than
for the exclusive benefit of the Participants and their beneficIaries.
(2) Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of subparagraph (1),
any contribution made by the Employer to this Plan bY"a mistake of fact may
be returned to the Employer within one year after the payment of the
contribution. The cIrcumstances as to whether a mistake of fact has occurred
shall be reviewed by the Committee, which shall submit a written
recommendation to the Trustees. Notwithstanding the Committee's
recommendation, the Trustees shall have final authority as to the detormlnatlon
of a mistake of fact.
(b) Partlcipantsl Rights. The establishment of this Plan shall not be
considered as giving any Employee, or any other person, any legal or equitable right
against the Employer, the Trustees, the Committee or the principal or the income of
the Pension Fund, except to the extent otherwise provided by law. The establishment
of this Plan shall not be considered as giving any Employee, or any other person, the
right to be retained in the employ of the Employer.
(c) QuaUfled Plan. ThIs Plan and the assets comprisIng the PensIon Fund
are intended to qualify under the Internal Revenue Code as a tax~free employeesl plan
and trust, and the provisions of this Plan should be interpreted accordingly.
2
.'
~'il ~'i, '
Rcv.O/4/95
Section 2.393
Definitions
(a) 11 Accrued Be nefltl1 shall mean, as of a specified time, the Normal
Retirement Benefit as set forth In Section 2.397.
I:
r
!
I
f
l
.
r
~
~
(b) IIActuarlal Equivalent'l shall mean a benefit of equivalent current value
to the benefit that would otherwise have been provided to the Participant, determined
in accordance with the rules established by the Employer and on the basis of
appropriate actuarial methods and the following actuarial assumptions:
(1) Mortality: 1983 Group Annuity Mortality Table (Unisex).
(2) Interest: 7% per annum, compounded annually.
(c) "Annual Additions" shall mean for Limitation Years beginning on or
after December 31. '1986. the sum of:
,
f31W the amount of Employer contributions allocated to the
Participant during any Limitation Year under any defined contribution plan
maintained by an Employer;
f4i!.Rl the amount of the Employee's contributions (other than rollover
contributions, If any) to any contributory defined contribution plan maintained
by an Employer or an Afffliate; -
,
,
,
I
-I
~
~ any forfeitures allocated to the Participant under any defined
contribution plan maintained by an Employer or an Affiliate; or
~ amounts allocated to an individual medical account, as defined In
Section 415(1)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code that is part of a pension or
annuity plan maintained by an Employer or :an .^.ffilbto and amounts derived
from contributions that are attributable to post-retirement medical benefits
allocated to the separate account of a key employee (as defined in Section
419A(d)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code) under a welfare benefit plan (as
defined in Section 419(e) of the Internal Revenue Code) maintained by an
Employer or an Affiliate; provided, however. the percentage limitation set forth
in Section 415 (c)(1 )(B) of the Internal Revenue Code shall not apply to: (A)
any contribution for medical benefits (within the meaning of Section 419A(f)(2)
of the Internal Revenue Code) after separation from service which is otherwise
3
I,
t~. . ','
treated as 'an IlAnnual Additlon,ll or (2) any amount otherwise treated as an
"Annual Addltlonll under Section 415(1)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(d) IIAverage Monthly Compensatlon'l shall mean the monthly
Compensation of a Participant averaged over his last 5 consecutive Years of Credited
Service. If a Participant has less than 5 consecutive Years of Credited Service, his
Average Monthly Compensation will be based on his monthly Compensation during his
months of service beginning with the date he commences participation In the Plan to
his date of termination of employment. For purposes of determining a Participant's
maximum beneflt,as required by Section 415 of the Internal Revenue Code, a
Participant's IIAverage Monthly Compensation'! shall mean the Section 415
CompensatIon received by a Participant during the three (3) consecutive Limitation
Years with respect to which the Participant receives the highest Sectlon 415 .
Compensation, divided by 36 (or, if less, the aggregate number of his months of
employment).
(e) IlCommitteell shall mean the pension advisory committee described in
Section 2.394.
(f) (1) IICompensationll shall mean the regular salaries, wages,
overtime pay, leave pay (except when paid a lump sum upon retirement
benefit), bonuses paid by the Employer (provided the Employee contribution
rate is applied thereto), Employee contributions designated as Employer
contributions under Section 414(h) of the Internal Revenue Code, and employee
salary reduction contributions made pursuant to an arrangement described In
Section 125 of the Internal Revenue Code, compensation deferred under Section
457(b) of the Internal Revenue Code, indemnity benefits received pursuant to
the Workers' Compensation Law, incentive pay for police and firefighters,
assignment pay, acting pay, and shift differential pay but shall not include
clothing, car or meal allowances, disability payments, lump sum payments of
accrued sick leave paid upon retirement, relocation expense payments, benefits
under this Plan, any amount contributed to any pension, employee welfare, life
Insurance or health insurance plan or arrangement, or any other fringe beneffts,
welfare beneffts or Employer paid deferred compensation.
(2) (A) I n addition to other applicable Um Itatlons set forth In the
Plan, and notwithstanding any other provision of the Plan to the
contrary, for Plan Years beginning on or after January 1, 1996, the
annual CompensatIon of each Employee taken Into account under the
Plan shall not exceed the OBRA '93 annual Compensation limit. The OBRA
'93 annual Compensation limit Is $150,000, as adjusted by the
,I
4
Hov. 8/4/95
Commissioner for Increases In the cost of living In accordance with
Section 401 (a)(17)(B) of the Internal Revenu'e Code. The cost~bf-lIvlng
adjustment In effect for a calendar year applies to any periodt not
exceeding 12 months, over which Compensation is determined
(determination period) beginning in such calendar year. If a
determtnatlon period consists of fewer than 12 months, the 08RA '93
annual Compensation limit will be multiplied by a fraction, the numerator
of which is the number of months in the determination period, and the
denominator of which Is 12.
(B) For Plan Years beginning on or after January 1, 1996, any
reference in this Plan to the limitation under Section 401 (a)(17) of the
Internal Revenue Code shall mean the OBRA 193 annual Compensation
limit set forth in this provision.
!
!
~
i
(C) The limitation on Compensation for an "eligible" employee
shall not be less than the amount which was allowed to be taken into
account hereunder as In effect on July 1, 1993. "Eligible Employee" is an
Individual who was a participant before the first Plan Year beginning
a-J.t.e.f. December 31, 1995.
(3) For purposes of determining whether Compensation exceeds the
dollar limit under Section 401 (a)(17) of the Internal Revenue Code, if any
Employee Is a Family Member of a Highly Compensated Employee who is one of
the ten Highly Compensated Employees paid the greatest amount of
Compensation during the Plan Year, then such Family Member shall not be con-
sidered as a separate Employee and any Compensation paid to such Family
Member shall be treated as if it were paid to or on behalf of the related Highly
Compensated Employee.
1
I
1
i
I
I
,
(g) "Early Retirement Date" shall mean the date on which a Participant
has reached the age of 65 years and completed 10 Years of Credited Service.
(h) "Effective Datell of this amendment and restatement shall mean
January 1, 1996.
(i) (1) "Employee" shall mean any person employed by the Employer as
a full-time permanent employee other than
(A) individuals who have failed a comprehensive physical exam
and by reason of such fact have not been recommended 'for acceptance
Into the Plan by the Committee or approved by the Trustees,
5
L
,~ ,'.'.,
(B)
persons hired on a contractual basis, and
(C) employees exempt from the Employer's civil service
classified service system (unclassified employees) for. whom an
Employment Agreement Letter establishes conditions of employment;
provided, however, if a person was a Participant in the Plan prior to
being employed in a position described In this subparagraph (C), he shall
continue to participate in the Plan.
(2) The Trustees shall have the right to determine from time to time
which persons are full~time permanent employees for purposes of, the Plan;
provided,' however, that all persons covered by the civil service ordinance of the
Employer who are employed on a full-time basis shall be considered full-time
permanent employees for purposes of the Plan.
(3) Permanent part-time, emergency. seasonal and provisional
employees shall not be UEmployees" eligible to participate in the Plan.
(j) "Employer" shall mean the City of Clearwater.
(k) "Family Member" of a Highly Compensated Employee shall mean such
Employee's spouse, lineal descendant or ascendant, or the spouse of his lineal
descendant or ascendant; provided, however, that for purposes of determining the
limit on a Highly Compensated Employee's Compensation under Section 401 (a)(17) of
the Internal Revenue Code, the term UFamily Memberu shall Include only the Employee's
spouse and his lineal descendants who have not attained age 19 before the close of
the Plan Year.
(I) (1) UHighly Compensated EmployeeU shall mean any Employee
during the Plan Year or the immediately preceding Plan Year
(A) whose Section 415 Compensation was more than $75,000
(adjusted under such regulations as may be issued by the Secretary of
the Treasury); or
(B) whose Section 415 Compensation was more than $50,000
(adjusted under such regulations as may be Issued by the Secretary of
the Treasury), and who was a member of the "top paid groupU;
provided, that as used herein, "top paid group" shall mean all Employees
who are in the top 20% of the Employer's work force on the basis of
6
~~",,;-...,, .
Section 415 Compensation paid during the year; provided, further, that
for purposes of determining the number of Employees In the top paid
group, Employees described In Section 414(q)(8) of the Internal Revenue
Code shall be excluded.
1
I
1
I
I
I
\
(C) In determining who is a Highly Compensated Employee,
Employees who are nonresident aliens and who receive no earned income
(within the meaning of Section 911 (d)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code)
from the Employer constituting United States source Income (within the
meanIng of Section 861 (a)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code) shall not be
treated as Employees.
( D) For purposes of this paragraph, the determination of
Section 415 Compensation shall be based only on Section 415
Compensation that is actually paid and shall be made by including
elective or salary reduction contributions to a plan described In Section
125 of the Internal Revenue Code, a plan described in Section 401 (k) of
the Internal Revenue Code or a plan described in Section 403(b) of the
Internal Revenue Code.
'.
I
(E) The term UHlghly Compensated EmployeeU shall also mean
any former Employee who separated from service (or was deemed to
have separated from service) prior to the Plan Year, performs no
service for the Employer during the Plan Year. and was an actively
employed Highly Compensated Employee In the separation year or any
Plan Year endIng on or after the date the Employee attaIned age 55.
(F) For purposes of determining whether an Employee is a
Highly Compensated Employee, If any Employee Is a Family Member of a
Hlgtlly Compensated Employee who is one of the ten Highly Compensated
Employees paid the greatest amount of Compensation during the Plan
Year, then such Family Member shall not be considered as a separate
Employee and any Compensation paid to such Family Member (and any
applicable benefit or contribution on behalf of such Family Member) shall
be treated as If it were paid to or on behalf of the related Highly
Compensated Employee.
: I
; I
,
(m) "Internal Revenue Codett shall mean the Internal Revenue Code of
1986 as amended or any successor statute. Reference to a specific sect/on of the
Internal Revenue Code shall Include a reference to any successor provision.
7
..
"
:(~ :.:II.J.' ~ T.
, ",6"lf:
(n) "Limitation Year" shall mean the Plan Year.
(0) "Normal Retirement Benefit" shall mean the monthly income payable
to a retired Participant pursuant to the provisIons of Section 2.397 of this Plan.
(p) "Normal Retirement Date" shall mean
(1 ) the earlier of:
(A) the date on which a Participant has reached the age of 55
years and completed 20 Years of Credited Service,
(B) the date on which a Participant has completed 30 Years of
Credited Service regardless of age, or
(C) the date on which a Participant has completed 20 Years of
Credited Service, which service is of a character or type of employment
that is described below as "hazardous duty'1 or that the Trustees have
designated as hazardous duty.
(2) For this purpose, a Participant's service shall be deemed.
"hazardous duty" if the Participant Is a full-time sworn police officer certified In
accordance with Section 943.1395, Florida Statutes, or a full~tlme firefighter
certified in accordance with Section 633.35, Florida Statutes, and he Is
employed In police or fire positions as established by the Employer.
'!
I
I
i
(q) "Participant" shall mean any eligible Employee of the Employer who 11as
commenced participation and is contributing under the Plan.
(r) "Plan'1 shall mean the pension plan as herein set forth and as it may be
amended from time to time.
(s) "Plan Year" shall mean the 12-month period ending on December 31.
I
"
(t) "Sectlon 415 Compensation" shall mean all compensation as
described In Section 1.415~2(d)(2) and Section 1.415-2(d)(3) of the Income Tax
Regulations.
(u) "Trustee" or "Trustees II shall mean the Individual or Individuals, as the
context requires, designated as trustee pursuant to Section 2.394.
8
;.,
'.'
,\
, . ';i'
,.t; 1.. 'd " '. ,'. ' ,
~'~'. ,~~"~~:,,,~-":j'r>~'~
~~":"'~"::"'"' ",' ',. '~'.,
i
\'
"
~.~,
(v) M~enslon EY.n.d" shall mean the pension fund established pursuant to
Section 2.399.
I"
'"
(w) "Years Qf..Credited Service" shall mean the total number of years
and fractional parts of years of service credited as an Employee of the Employer
, durIng periods of 'partlclpatlon In the Plan, omitting Intervening years or fractional
parts of years when an Employee Is not employed by the Employer or not
participating In the Plan (except as may otherwise be provided In rules established by
the Committee and approved by the Trustees).
;,
f.
'.
<,
\'
" "
.',
"
,
',", I
I
'" ,
" I
,; "
!
r' '.~ '. \
:~
I
",
'. 1
!
9
I
l
L
:t"~~J, ?
"
Section 2.394
Plan Administration
(a) Administration of the Plan. The Trustees shall control and manage.
In conjunction with the Committee, the operation and administration of the Plan
(b) Trustees.
(1) The members of the City Commission of the Employer, whether
elected or appointed, shall serve as the Trustees. The term of office of each
Trustee shall be consistent with his term of office as a member of the City
Commission.
(2) The Finance Director of the Employer shall be the treasurer for the
Trustees and shall provide such bond as may be prescribed by the Trustees.
(3) Each Trustee shall be entitled to one vote. Three affirmative
votes shall be necessary for any decision by the Trustees at a meeting of the
Trustees. A Trustee shall have the right to recuse himself from voting as the
result of a conflict of interest provided that the Trustee states in writing the
nature of the conflict.
( 4 ) The Trustees shall not receive any compensation for service as a
Trustee. but may be reimbursed expenses as provided by law; provided,
however. that the Trustees may receive compensation for services as a
member of the City Commission.
(c) Powers and Duties of Trustees. The Trustees shall have final
authority and control over the administration of the Plan herein embodied. with all
powers necessary to enable them to carry out their duties In that respect. Not in
limitation, but in amplification of the foregoing, the Trustees shall have the power and
discretion to Interpret or construe this Plan and to determine all questions that may
arise as to the status and rights of the Participants and others hereunder.
(d) Pension Advisory Committee.
( 1 ) (A) There shall be a pension advisory committee comprised of
seven persons. Three members of the CommUtee shall be Employees
who are active Employees and Participants In the Plan; three members
shall be City Commissioners or appointees of the City Commission; and
10
j-:~':' " '
the seventh member, who shall be a resident of the City of Clearwater,
shall be appointed by the other six members.
(B) Except as provided In subparagraph (3) below, terms of
members shall be for two years.
(2) Committee members representing the Employees shall be elected
by a majority of the active Employees who are Participants In the Plan.
Committee members representing the City Commission shall be appointed by a
majority vote of the City Commission. The seventh member shall be appointed
by a majority vote of the other six members of the Committee.
(3) Terms of office of Employee elected Committee members shall
overlap, with two of the members to be Initially elected for two years and the
third member to be Initially elected for one year. Terms of office o,f City
Commission appointed members shall overlap, with two of the members to be
Initially appointed for two years and the third member to be initially appointed
for one year.
(4) (A) The first election of Committee members representing the
Employees shall be held within 45 days of approval of the amended and
restated Plan. Thereafter, not less than 60 days before each
subsequent election of an Employee elected Committee member, the
existing Employee elected Committee members shall select and appoint a
nominee group composed of five persons from Employees participating
in the Plan to conduct the election process. The Department of the City
Clerk shall provide necessary assistance to the Employees for the
administration of elections.
(B) Members of the Committee last elected by Employees on
the date of adoption of this amended and restated Plan shall continue to
serve as the Employee elected Committee members until the first election
under this amended and restated Plan has been held.
(5) Any vacancy on the Committee, whether Employee elected, City
Commission appoInted, or the Committee appointed seventh member, shall be
filled for the remainder of the term and in the same manner as the original
Committee member who vacated the position.
1 1
:~.r:'. ';" '
~ ~ I ::.
I
I
(6) Members of the Committee shall serv,e without compensation
additional to that earned in their respective capacities as regular Employees or
elected City Commissioners.
I . '
(7) Each Committee member shall be entitled to one vote. Four
affirmative votes shall be necessary for any decisIon by the Committee at any
meeting. A Committee member shall have the right to recuse himself from
voting as a result of a conflict of interest provided that the Committee member
states in writing the nature of the conflict.
I'
Ii
(e) Powers and Duties of Committee.
(1) The Committee shall have authority to:
(A) Arrange for the necessary physicians to pass upon all
medical examinations required under this Plan. Such physicians shall
report In writing to the Committee their conclusions and
recommendations. The Committee shall revIew such physicians' reports
and prepare its recommendations as to the acceptance or denial of
Employees as Participants and forward same to the Trustees.
(8) In conjunction with the Employer and medical consultants,
establish the scope of the medical examlnatlons to be used for benefit
eligibility and medical standards to be used for benefit eligibility and to
guide the examining physicians In reaching their conclusions and
recommendations. Such medical standards shall give due consideratlon
to the nature of the job classifIcatIon In whIch Participants are to be
placed.
(C) Investigate and recommend to the Trustees, in conjunction
with the actuaries, such mortality/service and other tables as shall be
deemed necessary for the operation of the Plan.
(D) Make recommendatlons to the Trustees for improvements
or changes In the Plan.
(E) Receive all applications for benefits under this Plan and
determine all facts that are necessary to establish the right of an
applicant to benefits under the Plan.
12
{;~
~v! j,
Rev. 8/4/95
LFJ. Prepare and distribute to the participants information
relating to the Plan,
(2) The Committee shall, from time to time as It deems appropriate,
submit recommendations to the Trustees as to rules, procedures, forms and
general administrative procedures relating to the responsibilities of the
Committee.
(3) No benefits or relief shall be provided to any Participant under the
Plan unless the same has been r&vlewed by the Oommlttee and a
recommendation proVided to the Trustees.
(f) Conflict In Terms. In the event of any contlict between the terms of
this Plan and any explanatory booklet, this Plan shall control.
(g) Nondlscrim inatlon. The Trustees shall not take any action or direct
,the Committee to take any action whatsoever that would result in unfairly benefiting
one Participant or group of Participants at the expense of another or in discriminating
between Participants slmllarly situated or In the application of different rules to
substantially similar sets of faCts.
(h) Procedures and Records.
( 1 ) The Trustees and, subject to the approval of the Trustees, the
Committee, may establish rules and procedures as are necessary to administer
the Plan, which rules and procedures shall be applied in an uniform and
nondiscriminatory manner.
(2) The Trustees and the Committee shall keep a complete record of
all their proceedings and all data necessary for the administration of the Plan.
All of the foregoing records and data shall be located at the principal office of
the Employer.
i
I
i
! I
(I) Final Authority. Except to the extent otherwise required by law or by
this Plan, the decision of the Trustees in matters within their jurisdiction shall be final,
binding and conclusive upon the Employer, the Committee, each Employee and
beneficiary, and every other Interested or concerned person or party.
(j) Appointment of Advisors. The Trustees may appoint such
actuaries, accountants, professional Investment counsel, legal counsel, specialists,
third party pension administrators, and other persons that they deem necessary and
1 3
\:.., '
~i. - .:,
.; :
t1t'irlt.'~>!}.... ,~,
'i~HJ~I::" '~ :""""l ~ ~~:
Y',
, ....
. ,
:'~'. '
'j.: '
..
;. ..
"1,
,
~ '
"
I't.
,',
\, "
'e,' .
",'
..
, .
, 'I,'
'. ',..'
. ~;" ., .
',11
. ' ~ .
. ,"",' ,.,.,<" :.'.
desIrable In connectlon with the admlnlstratron of this Plan or to assist them In the
performance of their duties as Trustees. The Trustees are authorized to pay for
such services from the Pension Fund.
14
. ',"J
, , ',: ->-' \.,. . ,II ~ ~ ~:l'~":~~
t"'!::" t:~.,
:.'.....'
";
Section 2.395
Participation
(a) Participation.
(1 ) Unless otherwise provided hereIn. all Employees of the Employer
shall be required to make the contrIbutions specified In Section 2.396 and shall
be required to participate In the Plan.
(2) Any Employee who Is a PartIcipant and who by reason of
appointment has or may become an official of the Employer shall be eligible to
continue particIpate in the Plan in the same manner as any other Employee.
(b) Reemployment.
( 1 ) If a PartIcipant terminates employmen,t with the Employer and is
subsequently reemployed withIn the 5 year period following his termination of
employment. the former Participant shall again be eligible to participate In the
Plan and his credited service shall be based on all perIods of employment.
provided he
(A) again satisfies the defInition of IIEmployeell set forth In
Section 2.393 (IncludIng passing the comprehensive physical
examination). and
, (B) repays the amount of any Employee contrIbutions he
received In accordance with paragraph (d)(4) of Section 2.397.
(2) Notwithstanding the foregoing. an Employee who Is reemployed
after his benefits have commenced under the Plan (other than disability benefits
pursuant to paragraph (c) of Section 2.397) shall not be eligible to particIpate
In the Plan upon his subsequent reemployment.
15
~~~.~ ,'~ ..,~ ,
. '.''''ll
,.
Section 2.396
Contributions to the P I a n
(a) Employee Contributions.
(1) For each Plan Year, an Employee required to participate In the Plan
shall make regular contributions to the Plan In the amount of 8% of his
CompensatIon. Employee contrIbutions wllhheld by the Employer on behalf at
the Employee shall be deposited with the Trustees at least monthly.
(2) The contributions made by each Employee under the Plan shall be
designated as Employer contributions pursuant to Section 414(h) of the
Internal Revenue Code. Such desIgnation is contingent upon the contributions
beIng excluded from the Employees' gross Income for federal Income tax
purpose's. For all other purposes of the Plan, such contributions shall be
considered Employee contributions.
,
~
~
~
,
I
I
I
f
i
I
(b) Employer Contributions.
(1) For each Plan Year, the Employer shall make contrIbutions to the
Plan in an amount equal to
(A) 7% of the Compensation of all Employees participating In
the Plan; provided, however, that for the Plan Year beginning January 1.
1996, the Employer contribution to the Plan may be less than 7% (but in
no event less than 6%) of the Compensation of all Employees
partIcipating in the Plan; plus
(B) such additional amounts as may be required to satisfy the
Plan's funding requirements for the Plan Year and the cost of
administering the Plan, as determined by the actuary employed by the
Trustees.
(2) The amount described In subparagraph (1 )(B) above may be
reduced by any available credit balance in accordance with applicable Florida
Statutes.
(c) Form iUllL Timing of Contributions. Payments on account of the
contributions due from the Employer for any Plan Year shall be made In cash. Such
16
---
,,'
I,
~~~,\t~::,:!\1,:...,...:'..,........ >.
, . . ~,. , " ',., ,. .
;kt H
.". .'
". ',. I.., ::~'U
I'; :
"
payments ,may be made by the Employer In accordance with the requirements of
applicable Florida Statutes.
'. ,
"
)~ ' .
'(d) Forfeitures. Any amount fonslted pursuant to the provIsions of this
Plan shall be used In aC90rdance with Section 1.401 ~7(a) of the Income Tax '
Regulations.
\, '
. ~ ' ,
,,"
.~ '.
.~' ,
\'
, ~
':'
I,
t,
17
I
-
.,,:' ,
Section 2.397
Benefits Under the P I an
(a) Normal Retirement Benefit.
( 1 ) A Participant shall be entitled to retire from the employ of his
Employer upon such Participant's Normal Retirement Date.
(2) Upon reaching hIs Normal Retirement Date, a Participant shall be
fully vested in his Accrued Benefit and shall be entitled to receive, at the time
and In the manner described in Article Viii, his Normal Retirement Benefit.
Subject to the provisions of paragraph (e) of this Section 2.397:
(A) The Normal Retirement Benefit shall be a monthly Income,
paid In accordance with the normal form of benefit described below, that
is equal to the product of:
\',
(i) 2.5% of the PartIcipant's Average Monthly
Compensation, multiplied by
",
(il) the Participant's Years of Credited Service.
(B) Effective for Plan Years beginning on or after January 1,
1996, In the case of Employees who are performing actlve service on
behalf of the Employer on January 1, 1996, "2.75%,1l shall be substituted
for 112.5%" in subparagraph (A) above. An Employee will be deemed to
be performIng active service If he is actlvely employed by the Employer
(workIng on a contlnuous basis), inclusive of light duty assignments made
by the Employer and the use of sick leave, vacation leave, military leave,
family medical leave, or other approved leaves of absence from which
the Employee is anticipated to return to regular duty. This
subparagraph (B) shall not apply to Employees who, as of January 1,
1996, no longer perform active service for the Employer but who remain
on the Employer's payroll and are compensated for a given period on
the basis of vacation time, sick leave, severance benefits or any other
type of leave of absence and whose employment with the Employer Is
expected to terminate followIng such compensated period.
( 3) (A) The normal form of benefit shall be an annuity paid monthly
for the life of tile Participant, with a 100% survivor annuity paId monthly
18
for a period of five years following the death of tl1e PartIcipant to the
beneficIary or beneficIaries described in paragraph (e) of this Section
2.397; provided, further, that following such five year period the survivor
annuity shall be reduced to 50% of the original survivor annuity amount.
(I) the last day of the month In which occurs the
designated beneficiary's death or remarriage, If such designated
beneficiary is the Participant's spouse, or
I
t
I
i
~
l
1
I
l
I
(B) The survivor annuity paid to the Participant's beneficiary or
beneficiaries In accordance with subparagraph (3)(A) above shall cease
following
(ii) the last day of the month In which occurs the
designated beneficlaryls death or attainment 01 age 18, If the
designated beneficiary Is the Participant's child or children.
( 4 ) In the event that a Participant does not begin to receive his
Normal Retirement Benefit at his Normal Retirement Date, such Participant shall
be entitled to the benefit he was entitled to receive at his Normal Retirement
Date, adjusted to take into account his Average Monthly Compensation and
Years of Credited Service as of his actual retirement date.
..
(b) Early Retirement Benefit.
J
I
( 1 ) A Participant shall be entitled to retire from the employ of his
Employer upon such Participant's Early Retirement Date.
(2) Upon reaching his Early Retirement Date, the Participant shall be
fully vested In his Accrued BenefIt and shall be entitled to receIve, at the time
and In the manner described in Section 2.398, his early retirement benefit.
( 3) A ParticIpant's early retirement benefit shall be determined in
accordance with the provisions of paragraph (a) above, and the amount of
such benefit shall be reduced to the Actuarial Equivalent of the benefit
otherwise payable under paragraph (a) above.
(4) If a Participant separates from service before satisfying the age
requirement for early retirement, but has satisfied the service requirement, the
Participant will be entitled to an early retirement benefit upon satisfaction of
such age requIrement.
1 9
:;tr' ....
(c)
Disability Be neflt.
(1 ) (A) A Participant who is vested in his Accrued Benefit and who
terminates employment by reason of his disability shall be entitled to
receIve, at the time and In the manner descrIbed in Article VIII, a disability
benefit equal to his Accrued Benefit as of the date of termination of his
employment.
(8) A PartIcipant who is deemed by the Committee and the
Trustees to be disabled by reason of an Injury suffered or an illness
contracted in the line of duty need not satisfy the vesting requirement
set forth in subparagraph (1)(A) above; provided, further, that the
monthly amount of the disability benefit payable to a Participant
described in this subparagraph (1 )(8) shall not be less than 66-2/3% of
such Participantts Average Monthly Compensation.
(C) The provisions of this paragraph (c) shall apply to
PartIcipants who are determined by the Committee and Trustees to be
disabled on or after January 1, 1996.
(2) A Participant shall be consIdered dIsabled for purposes of the Plan
if, In the opinion of the Committee and the Trustees, the Participant is disabled
due to sickness or injury, such disability is likely to be continuous and permanent
from a cause other than specified In subparagraph (3) below, and such
disability renders the Participant unable to perform any useful, meaningful and
necessary work for the Employer in an available position for which the
Pa~icipant Is reasonably qualified or for which the Participant may be
reasonable trained to perform, subject to the limitations below.
i
1
I
I
(A) If a Participant employed as a sworn and state certified (In
accordance with Section 943.1395, Florida Statutes) pollee officer
(Police Recruit, Pollee Officer, Police Sergeant, Police Lieutenant, Police
Captain, Assistant or Deputy Chief or comparable sworn and state
certified positions) or a state certified (In accordance with Section
633.35, Florida Statutes) firefighter (Firefighter, Fire Lieutenant, District
Fire Chief, Assistant or Deputy ChIef or comparable state certified
positions) is disabled to the extent that he cannot reasonably continue
to perform the functions of his specific position, but remains capable of
pertormlng useful, meanIngful and necessary work. he may be assigned
to an alternate position with the Employer as described below In lieu of
receiving disability benefits under the Plan.
20
'"
"
\ '
I
(i) If an available equal level position Is available In the
pollee or fire department respectively, the Participant may be
assigned to such position within the respective department. such
assignment to be with no loss of base pay (as described below);
or
! '
(Il) If no equal level position Is available in the police or
fire department respectively. as referred to in subparagraph (I)
above, the Participant may be assigned to another sworn and/or
state certiffed position in the respective department, If such
position is available, such assignment to be with no loss of base
pay regardless of whether the assignment Is to an equal or lower
level position; or
I,
I,
I
(Iii) If a position is not available pursuant to
subparagraph (I} or (ii) above, the Participant may be assigned,
to a non-sworn and/or non-state certlfled position within the
respective department, if such position is available. with such
assignment to be with no loss of base pay regardless of whether
the assignment Is to a non-sworn and/or non-state certified
position of equal or lower level; or
;
I '
i'
~
I
i
I'
(iv) If an assignment cannot be made pursuant to
subparagraph (I), (II) or (III) above, the Participant may be
assigned to any other position with the Employer that Is available
for which the Participant has the skill and knowledge to perform
or for which the Participant can reasonably be trained to perform,
such assignment to be with no loss of base pay regardless of
whether the assignment to such position Is at an equal or lower
level.
I
,
"
(B) If a Participant employed in a position other than as a
sworn and state certified pollee officer or a state certified firefighter is
disabled to the extent that he can not reasonably continue to perform
the functions of his specific position, but remains capable of performing
useful, meaningful and necessary work, he may be assigned to an
alternate position with the Employer In lieu of receiving disablllty benefits
under the Plan. For this purpose, the Participant may be assigned to any
other position with the Employer that Is available for which the
Participant has the skill and knowledge to perform or for which the
21
>~}~'~" T
Hev, 8/4/95
Participant can reasonably be trained to perform, such assignment to be
with no loss of base pay regardless of whether the assignment to such
position Is at an equal, or lower level.
(C), For purposes of this paragraph (c)(2), the term "base
pay" shall be deftned as compensatIon at the rate prescribed for the
particular job class in the Employerts pay schedule.
till Any hazardous duty designated Plan Participant who is
assigned to an alternate position in !leu of receiving disability benefits
under the Plan pursuant to provisions of paragraph (c) (2) (A) of
Section 2.397 of this Plan shall continue to be designated as a
h?zardous duty employee regardless of the nature or location of tbe
alternate assignment. Such Participant shall remain eligible for
retirement as a hazardous duty employee.
ill The Trustees of the Plan shall make the determination in
each Instance if a Participant who has been found disabled pursuant' to
paragraph (c) (2) above may be assigned to an alternate position with
the Employer as provided in (c) (2) (A) and (8) hereof.
(3) (A) Each Participant who is claiming dIsability beneflts shall
establish, to the satisfaction of the Committee, that such disability was
not occasioned primarily by:
(j) excessive or habitual use of any drugs, intoxicants,
or alcohol;
~
I
I
!
(II) injury or disease sustained while willfully and Illegally
participating in fights, riots or civil Insurrections;
(iii) Injury or disease sustained while committing a crIme;
(Iv) injury or disease sustained while servIng in any
branch of the Armed Forces;
(v) injury or disease sustained after his employment as
an Employee with the Employer shal!\ have terminated;
(vi) wlllful, wanton or gross negligence of the Participant;
, :
or
22
ill
"
.,',
(vii) Injury or disease sustained by the Participant while
working for anyone other than the Employer and arising out of
such employment.
(8) No Participant shall be entitled to a disability benefit,
whether in Hne of duty or not In line of duty I because of or due to the
aggravation of a speciftc Injury, impairment or other medical condition
pre-existing the Employee's participation in the Plan; provided, however,
that such pre~exlsting condition and its relationship to a later Injury,
Impairment or other medical condition Is established by competent
substantial evidence. Nothing herein shall be construed to preclude a
dlsablllty benefit for a Participant whol after commencing participation in
the Plan suffers an Injury, Impairment or other medical condition different
from some other Injury, Impairment, or other medical condition existing
at or prior to participation in the Plan.
" ,
( 4 ) (A) A Participant shall not become elfglble for disability benefits
until and unless he undergoes a physical examination by a qualified
physician or physicians, who shall be selected by the Committee for that
purpose.
(8) (I)' Any former ParticIpant receiving disability benefits
under provisions of this Plan may be periodically re-examined by a
qualffled physician or physicians who shall be selected by the
Committee to determine if such disability has ceased to exist or if
the former Participant may be employed In an available position
for which the Participant Is reasonably qualified In accordance with
the provisions in paragraph (c)(2) above. If the Committee finds
that the former Participant Is no longer disabled or is capable of
performing service for the Employer in accordance with the
provIsions of subparagraph (2) above, the Committee may
request the former Participant to return to tile employ of the
Employer. If the former Participant returns to the performance of
duty as an Employee, he shall again be eligible to participate In the
Plan. In the event a former Participant is no longer disabled or Is
deemed capable of returning to employment with the Employer In
accordance with the provisions of subparagraph (2) above, and
he does not return to employment with the Employer pursuant to
the Commlttee's request, he shall forfeit the right to his disability
benefit; provided further, that if an Employee accepts employment
with another employer In an occupation or line of work similar to
23
~~\..,: .
the occupation or line of work that resulted In the Employee being
eligible for a disability benefit hereunder, he shall forfeit the right
to his disability benefit.
I
I
I,
(Ii) A Participant who returns to employment with the
Employer and recommences participation in the Plan shall not
receive credited service for the period during which he received
disability benefits under the Plan.
(C) The cost of the physical examination and/or re-examination
of the Employee claiming and/or receiving disability benefits shall be
borne by the Plan. All other reasonable costs as determined by the
Committee incident to the physical examination, such as, but not limited
to, transportation and meals, shall be borne by the Plan.
(0) The Committee may establish such other rules and
procedures as It deems necessary to implement the provisions of this
paragraph (c).
(5) A Participant whose employment is terminated by reason of his
death In the line of duty shall, for purposes of the Plan, be deemed to have been
disabled in the line of duty, and the Participanes beneficiary shall be entitled to
receive a disability benefit as described In paragraph (c)(1) above.
(6) If a Participant receives a dlsabllity benefit under the Plan and
workers' compensation benef1ts pursuant to Florida Statute Chapter 440 for
the same disability, and the total monthly benefits received from both exceed
100% of the Participant's average monthly wage, as defined In Chapter 440,
Florida Statutes, excluding overtime, the disability benefit shall be reduced so
that the total monthly amount received by the Participant dos not exceed
100% of such wage. The amount of any lump sum workers' compensation
payment shall be converted to an equivalent monthly benefit payable for ten
years certain by dividing the lump sum amount by 83.9692.
(d) Termination of Employment Benefit.
(1) In the event a Participant's employment with his Employer Is
terminated for reasons other than retirement, dlsabillty or death, such
Participant shall be entitled to receive, at the time and in the manner described
In Section 2.398, a termination of employment benefit that Is equal to the
24
.;:.. ~:
Participant's vested Interest in his Accrued Benefit as of the date of his
termination of employment.
(2) (A) A Participant's vested interest in his Accrued Benefit shall
be the following percentage of his Accrued Benefit, based upon such
Participant's full Years of Credited Service as of the date of his
termination of employment:
TOTAL NUMBER OF FULL
YEARS OF CREDITED SERVICE
VESTED
~
Less than 10 Years of Credited Service
10 years or more
0%
100%
(B) Notwithstanding the foregoing schedule, a Participant shall be
fully vested in his Accrued Beneiit upon attaining his Early Retirement
Date or his Normal Retirement Date.
(3) A Participant who terminates employment with the Employer prior
to his Early Retirement Date or his ,Normal Retirement Date may elect to
receive the total contributions he has made to the Plan, together with 5%
simple interest on such contributions. Upon making such election, the
Participant's interest In his Accrued Benefit shall be forfeit~d.
(4) If a Participant terminates employment prior to his Early
Retirement Date or his Normal Retirement Date and receives a distribution of
his contributions (plus interest thereon) and Is subsequently reemployed and
again becomes a Participant in this Plan, his credited service for purposes of
vesting and benefit accruals shall not include any periods of employment prior
to his reemployment date unless he repays to the Pension Fund the greater of
(I) the full amount previously distributed to him plus interest at the rate of 5%
per annum from the date of distribution to the date of repayment or (II) the
actuarial present value of the Accrued Benefit previously forfeited. Such
repayment must be made no later than the second anniversary of the
Participanes reemployment. If a Participant repays the foregoing amount to
the Pension Fund within the prescribed time period, the Interest of the
Participant in his Accrued Benefit previously forfeited under subparagraph (3),
above shall be restored In full and the Participant's credited service shall be
based on all periods of employment.
(e) Death Benefit.
25
11:,""1', '.'
(1) (A) (I) In the event of the death of a Participant who Is
vested In his Accrued Beneilt prior to his termination of
employment, his beneficIary (as described below) shall be entitled
to receive a death benefit at the time and in the manner described
in Section 2.398. Said death benefit shall be in an amount equal
to the Accrued Benefit of such Participant as of the date of his
death.
(ii) The Participant's benefIciary may elect to receive, in
lieu of the death benefit under the Plan, the total contributions
made by the Participant to the Plan, together with 5% simple
Interest on such contributions. Upon making such election, the
Participant's beneficiary shall forfeit any right to a death benefit
under the Plan.
(iii) If the PartIcipant does not have a beneficiary, the
total contributions made by the ParticIpant to the Plan, together
with 5% simple Inlerest on such contributions, shall be paid to the
Partlclpanes estate.
(B) In the event of the death of a Participant who is not vested
In his Accrued Benefit prior to his termination of employment, his
beneficiary (or, if there Is no beneficiary, his estate) shall be entitled to
receive the tota'l contributions made by the Participant to the Plan,
together with 5% simple Interest on such contributions.
'\
!
(2) A Participant whose employment is terminated by reason of his
death In the line of duty shall be deemed, for purposes of the Plan, to have been
disabled In the line of duty and his benefit shall be deter~lned In accordance
with paragraph (c)(5) of thIs Section 2.397.
( 3) The Participant's surviving spouse shall be deemed to be the
beneficiary designated to receive tile death benefit payable under the Plan, and
If nons, his children under the age of 18 who are the Partlclpanfs dependents
(within the meaning of Section 152 of the Internal Revenue Code) at the time of
his death.
(4) If the total contributions made by the Participant to the Plan,
together with 5% s!mple Interest on such contributions, exceed the value of the
death benefit paid under the Plan, the amount by which such contributions
26
:~:i': ~ ",
(Including Interest thereon) exceed the value of the death benefit paid under the
Plan shall be paid to the Participant's estate.
(f) Limitations on Amount of Ben eflts.
(1 ) (A) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Section 2.397
to the contrary, the projected benefit for a Participant (under this Plan
and under all other defined benefit plans maintained by the Employer,
whether or not terminated) when expressed as a benefit payable
annually in the form of a straight life annuity without regard to the death
benefit or any other ancillary benefit, shall not at any time within the
Limitation Year exceed the lesser of
(I) $90,000 (adjusted under such regulations as may be
Issued by the Secretary of Treasury); or
~
,
t
>
l
I
I
,
\
,
I
j
(i1) 100% of the Participant's Average Monthly
Compensation.
(B) Notwithstanding the foregoing, the benefit payable with
respect to a Participant shall be deemed not to exceed the limitations
set forth in subparagraph (1) if the benefit payable with respect to such
Participant under this Plan and under all other defined benefit pension
plans to which the Employer contributes, does not exceed $10,000 for
the applicable Plan Year and for any Plan Year and the Employer has not
at any time maintained a defined contribution plan in which the
Participant participated.
(C) The limitations In subparagraphs (1 )(A)(i), (1 )(A)(II) and
(1 )(6) above, shall be multiplied by a fraction (not in excess of one), the
numerator of which is the number of the Participant's years of
participation In the Plan (in the case of the dollar limitation set forth in
subparagraph (1 )(A)(l)) or the number of the Participant's Years of
Credited Service (in the case of the limitation set forth in (1 )(A)(ii) and
(1 )(B) ) and the denominator of which, In either case, is 10.
(D) As of January 1 of each calendar year, the $90,000
limitation set forth in subparagraph (1 )(A)(I) above, shall be adjusted as
and if permitted by the Secretary of the Treasury, and any such
adjusted limitation shall become effective as the maximum dollar limita-
tion under the Plan for that calendar year. The maximum dollar limitation
27
~-,." 1 '0 , .
for a calendar year, as so adjusted, shall apply to Limitation Years
ending with or within such calendar year.
(E) (I) a. In the event the ParticIpant's retirement
benefits become payable before age 62, the $90,000
limitation set forth In subparagraph (1)(A)(i) above shall
be reduced in accordance with regulations Issued by the
Secretary of the Treasury, but not below $75,000.
b. In the event the Participant's retirement
benefits become payable before age 55, the $90,000
limitation set forth In subparagraph (1)(A)(i) above shall
be reduced in accordance with regulations issued by the
Secretary of the Treasury, but not below the actuarial
equivalent of $75,000 at age 55.
I
I
I
I
t
I
,
I
I
~
~
r
i
f
:
!
r
1
1
I
, ,
c. In no event shall the limitation set forth in
subparagraph (1 )(A)(i) above be reduced to an amount
less than $50,000 (Indexed In accordance with the Internal
Revenue Code) In the case of police or firefighters who are
qualified participants as defIned in Section 415(b)(2)(H), of
the Internal Revenue Code.
(Ii) If the Participant's retirement benefit becomes
payable after age 65, for purposes of determining whether the
benefit meets the $90,000 limitation set forth In subparagraph
(1 )(A)(ii) above, such benefit shall be adjusted so that it Is
actuarlally equivalent to the benefit beginning at age 65. This
adjustment shall be made using an assumed Interest rate of fIve
percent (5%) and shall be made in accordance with regulations
promulgated by the Secretary of the Treasury.
(F) (I) In the event that any ParticIpant partIcipates in both
a defined benefit plan and a defined contribution plan maintained
by his Employer or an Affiliate thereof, then the sum of the Defined
Benefit Plan Fraction (as defined In Section 415(e) of the Internal
Revenue Code) and the Defined ContributIon Plan Fraction (as
defined in Section 415(e) of the Internal Revenue Code) for any
LImitation Year shall not exceed 1.0.
28
~~..,.... ~ ,.
(i1) In the event that the sum of the Defined Benefit
Plan Fraction and the Defined Contribution Plan Fraction exceeds
1.0, then the Plan Administrator shall take such actions, applied In
a uniform and nondiscriminatory manner. as will keep the benefits
and Annual Additions for such Participants from exceeding these
limits. Adjustments shall be made to this Plan before any
adjustments shall be required to any other plans.
I
i
I
l
~
~
.
\
~
~
r
f
I
!
I
I
j
(2) This subparagraph (2) shall apply to the amount of Benefit (as
such term is described below) under this Plan for any Participant who Is
considered a Restricted Participant (as such term is described below). Such
Benefit shall be limited to an amount equal to the payments that would have
been made on behalf of the Restricted Participant under a life annuity form of
payment that Is the Actuarial Equivalent of the Restricted Participant's Accrued
Benefit under the Plan.
(A) For purposes of this subparagraph (2), the term IIBeneflt"
shall include retirement Income provided by the Plan, plus loans in excess
of the amounts set forth in Section 72(p)(2)(A) of the Internal Revenue
Code, any periodic income, any withdrawal values payable to a living
Participant and any death benefits not provided for by insurance on the
Participant's life.
(8) For purposes of this subparagraph (2). the term
"Restricted Participant II shall mean all Highly Compensated Employees. In
anyone Plan Year, the total number of Participants whose benefits are
subject to restriction under this subparagraph (2) shall be limited by the
Plan to a group of not less than 25 Highly Compensated Employees with
the greatest Compensation.
(C) Notwithstanding the foregoing. the Iimitatlons set forth in
this subparagraph (2) shall not restrict the current payment of the full
amount of retirement Income provided by the Plan If:
(I) after payment to a Restricted Participant of all of
the Benefit described above, the value of Plan assets equals or
exceeds 1001% of the value of current liabilities, as defined In
Section 412(1 )(7) of the Internal Revenue Code, or
([I) the value of the Benefit described above for a
Restricted Participant Is less than 1 % of the value of current
29
.
: ~). ; , :' ,. ~,
, ::~'j'.~:'"
~. '"
, 'I,'
','.f'
~ ; ,
_~f':~.r:~L ~t,~'~l\~ ...,'....'. .~._. '
I ~",7"
"
'." ,.
"'ii, ..
,,'
,,>,
,.,
" ,
~',:, . '
;.~: , .
"
~,' , '
'. '
~]: ' .
r':,.',
.:-1.,\
.. ..'
j, ~
}:,
.... ...
~:' '.: '
\:;.'\
~ q
. .... ~ ,
..
.,
','
./ 'I'.
't.I' ,
\.., ,
.\;
.,
'I:
~1. '
~.: :
"
~L
!,:
t:
"
'".,
I. . ~. ,',,'
" .
'I
:' I
liabilities, as defIned In Section 412( 1 )(7) of the Internal Revenue
Code.
30
~ . : ~
. ' ~ ~.
(.
,.' 1,"
.' ,'tf":'111:";.,
'I
I
i\
']
,;
'I" "
Section 2.398
Time and Manner 9LBenefit E'ayments
(a) Time for Distribution of Benefits.
(1 ) Except as otherwIse provided under this Article VIII:
(A)(I) The amount of the Normal Retirement Benefit to which a
Participant is entitled under paragraph (a) of Section 2.397 shall
commence as of the end of the month that next follows the month in
which the Participant terminates employment on or after his Normal
Retirement Date, continuing as of the last day of each month thereafter
during his lifetime and the lifetime of his beneficiary, if any; (If) No
payment shall be made with respect to the month In which Participant
terminates employment on or after his Normal Retirement Date;
provided, however. that a full monthly payment will be made for the
month In which the Participant or his beneficiary dies.
,
1
j
~
t
i
1
,
I
!
,
\
!
(B}(i) The amount of the early retirement benefit to which a
Participant is entitled under paragraph (b) ot Section 2.397 shall
commence as of the end of the month that next follows the month In
which the Participant terminates employment on or after his Early
Retirement Date and elects to receive an early retirement benefit,
continuing as of the last day at each month thereafter durtng his Ufetime
and the lifetime of his beneficiary, If any; (ii) No payment shall be made
with respect to the month in which the Participant terminates ,
employment on or after has Early Retirement Date; provided, however,
that a full monthly payment will be made for the month in the Participant,
or his beneficiary dies.
.
.
!
(C)(i) The amount of the disability benefft to which a Participant is
entItled under paragraph (c) of Section 2.397 shall commence as of the
end of the month that next follows the later of (1) the month in which a
determination Is made as to the Participant's disability or (2) the month
in which the Participant terminates employment, continuing as of the last
day of each month thereafter during his lifetime and the lifetime of his
beneficiary, If any; (i1) No payment shall be made with respect to the
month in which a determination is made as to the Participant's disability
or the, month In which the ParticIpant terminates employment; provIded,
, ,
; i
31
'.
.....' .,.
however, that a full monthly payment will be made for the month in which
the Participant or his beneficiary dies.
(0) The amount of the termination of employment benefit to
which a Participant is entitled under paragraph (d) of Section 2.397 shall
commence as of the earlier of (1) the end of the month that next follows
the month in which the Participant attains his Early Retirement Date (or
would have attained his Early Retirement Date If he had continued in the
employ of the Employer until his Early Retirement Date) or (2) the end of
the month that next follows the month in which the Participant attains
his Normal Retirement Date (or would have attained his Normal
Retlrement Date If he had continued In the employ of the Employer until
his Normal Retirement Date), continuing as of the 'last day of each
month thereafter during his Iifetlme and the lifetime of his beneficiary, if
any; (i1) No payment shall be made with respect to the month In which
the Participant attains his Early Retirement (or would have attained his
. Early Retirement Date if he had continued in the employ of the Employer
until his Early Retirement Date) or his Normal Retirement Date (or would
have attained his Normal Retirement Date if he had continued In the
employ of the Employer until his Normal Retirement Date); provided,
however, that a full monthly payment will be made for the month In which
the Participant or his beneficiary dies.
(E) The death be'nefit payable to a Participant's beneficiary
under paragraph (e) of Section 2.397 shall commence as of the end of
the month that next follows the month in which the Participant dies,
continuing as of the last day of each month thereafter during the lifetime
of his beneficiary; (Ii) No payment shall be made with respect to the
month In which the Participant dies; provided, however, that a full
monthly payment will be made for the month in which the beneficiary
dies.
'1
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained herein to the contrary, any
distribution paid to a Participant (or, in the case of a death benefit, to his
beneficiary or beneficiaries) pursuant to subparagraph (1) shall commence not
later than the last to occur of:
(A) April 1 of the year following the calendar year in which the
Participant retires on or after his Early Retirement Date or his Normal
Retirement Date; or
32
;:-~-},
(B) April 1 of the year Immediately following the calendar year
In which the Participant reaches age 70-1/2.
(b) Manner of Paymenj.
(2) (A) In lieu of the normal form of payment described In
subparagraph (1 )(A) above, a Participant's retirement, disability or
termination of employment benefit may be paid In one of the following
optional forms as elected by the Participant. The optfonal forms, which
shall be the Actuarial Equivalent of the benefit that would otherwise be
paid to the Participant, are as follows: '
l
f
t
I
I
~
i
I
(1) (A) The manner of payment of a Partlcipant's retfrement.
disability or termlnatfon of employment beneflt shall be the normal form
of payment described In paragraph (a)(3) of Section 2.397.
(B) The manner of payment of a Partlclpant's death benefit
shall be the normal form of survivor annuity payment described in
paragraph (a)(3) of Section 2.397.
(i) Monthly Income payments for the life of the
Participant.
(il) Monthly income payments for a 10 years certain and
life thereafter, under whIch the Participant receives payments
during his lifetime and, if he dies after he has begun to receive
payments but before he has received 120 payments. the
remaining payments shall be made to his designated beneficiary;
provided. further, that If the designated beneficiary predeceases
the Participant, the Participant may designate a new beneficiary
to receive any payments due after his death. If the Participant
does not designate a new beneficiary, the payments required
under this option following the Participant's death shall be paid to
the Participanes estate. If the designated beneficiary begins to
receive payments under this optfon and such designated
beneficiary dies before the end of the 10-year period, the
remaining payments shall be paid to the designated benaflciaris
asta te.
1
I
33
.( ~:.
(l1l) Monthly Income payments for the life of the
Participant and, after his death~ a survivor annuity payable for the
Itfe of the Participant's designated beneffciary equal to 100%, 75%
or 50% of the amount payable to the Participant.
(B) Each Participant shall have the right to designate a
beneficiary for purposes of the optional forms of benefit payment
described In this paragraph and to revoke any such designation. Each
designation or revocation shall be evidenced by written instrument filed
with the Committee and shall be effective upon filing with the Committee.
;
J
!
,
1
I
I
j
I
!
J
(3) In the case of a retirementt disability or termination of
employment benefit, In no event shall payment extend beyond the life or life
expectancy of the Participant or the joint lives or life expectancies of the Par~
tlcipant and his designated beneficiary. If the Participant dies before receiving
the entire amount payable ,to him, the balance shall be distributed to his desig-
nated beneficiary at least as rapidly as under the method beIng used prior to
the Participant's death.
(4) In the case of a death benefit, payment
(A) to the designated beneficiary shall begin within one year
following the Participant's death (unless the designated beneficiary Is the
Participant's spouse, in which case such benefit shall begin no later than
the date the Participant would have reached 70~ 1/2) and shall not. in
any event, extend beyond the life or life expectancy of the designated
beneficiary; or
1
1
!
J
(B) to any other beneficiary shall be totally distrIbuted within
five years from the date of the Participant's death.
(5) The Participant (or his spouse) shall not be permitted to elect
whether life expectancies will be recalculated for purposes of distributions
hereunder.
(6) Notwithstanding the foregoing, payments under any of the
options described in this paragraph shall satisfy the Incidental death benefit
requirements and all other applicable provisions of SectIon 401 (a)(9) of the
Internal Revenue Codsl the regulations Issued thereunder (including Prop. Reg.
34
. ';, .
" ,
'.H,'
Rev. 8/ 4/95
Section 1.401 (a)(9)~2), and such other rules thereunder as may be prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury.
(7) The Committee may purchase and distribute a nontransferable
and nonrefundable annuity contract to provide any benefit under the Plan paid
in the form of an annuity.
(c) lump Sum Payment. Notwithstanding anything contained In this Plan
to the contrary, any benefit payable under the Plan, the actuarial lump sum present
value of which is not more than $3,500, shall be paid in a lump sum as soon as
practicable following the Participant's termination of employment.
(d) No Payment Unless Sufficient Funds. No benefits shall be paid
under this Plan unless at the time of such benefit payment the PensIon Fund has
sufficient assets to pay such benefits; provided, that in the event the assets In the
Pension Fund are not sufficient to pay the benefit amounts due under the Plan, the
Employer shall make additional contributlons to the Plan pursuant to paragraph (b) of
Section 2.396.
W DfrecL Rollovers.
ill Notwithstanding any provisions of the Plan to the 'contrary that
would otherwise limit a distributee's (as defined below) electlon under this
paragraph. a distributee may elect. at the time and in the manner prescribed
by the Committee. to have any portion of an eligible rollover dlstributlon (as
defined below) paid directly to an eligible retirement plan (as defined below)
specified by the distributee in a direct rollover (as defined below).
ill For purposes of this paragraph. the following terms shall have the
following meanings:
LA.>. 8n llellgible rollover distributlonU Is any distribution of all or
any portion of the balance to the credit of the distrIbutee. except that
an eligible rollover distribution does not include: any distribution that is
one of a series of substantially equal periodIc payments (not less
frequently than annually) made for the life (or life expectancy) of the
distributee or the ioint I1ves (or 10lnt life expectancIes) of the distributee
and the distributee's designated beneficiary. or for a specified period of
ten years or more: any distribution to the extent such distribution is
requIred under Internal Revenue Code Section 401 (a)(9), and the portion
of any distribution that is not includible in gross Income (determined
35
1-~;":~ ,,' , 00 ,~'" ...
Rev. 8/ 4/95
Yilthout regard to the exclusion for net unrealized appreciation with
respect to employer securities).
LID An "eligible retirement plan" Is an Individual retirement
account described In Internal Revenue Code Section 408(a). an Individual
retirement annuity described In 1nternal Revenue Code Section 408(b). an
annuity plan described In Internal Revenue Code Section 403(a). or a
Qualified trust described In Internal Revenue Code Section 401 (a). that
accepts the distributee's eligible rollover distribution. However. In the
case of an eligible rollover distribution to the surviving spouse. an eligible
retirement plan Is an Individual retirement account or Individual retirement
annuity.
i
\
!.Ql A "distributee" Includes an Employee or former Empioyee.
In addition. the Employee's or former Employee's surviving spouse and
the Employee's or former Employee's spouse or former spouse who Is
the alternate payee under a qualified domestic relations order. as defined
in Internal Revenue Code Section 414(p). are distrlbutees with regard to
the interest of the spouse or former spouse.
l
I
I
,
!
,
'I
u;u A "direct rollover" Is a payment by the Plan to the eligible
retirement plan specified by the distributee.
'.
36
I'
~""" ,
'.' '-'!
Section 2.399
I
"
I
Establ1shment and Oaeratlon of Pension Fun d
I
I,
(a) Establishment of Fu n d.
( 1 ) As part of the Plan, there is hereby established the Pension Fund,
Into which shall be deposited all of the contributions and assets whatsoever
attributable to the Plan.
(3) The assets of the Pension Fund may be deposited by the Trustees
with an official designated by the Employer, acting in a ministerial capacity only,
who shall be !lable in the same manner and to the same extent as he Is liable
for the safekeeping of funds for the Employer. However. any a~sets so
deposited with the designated official of the Employer shall be kept in a
separate fund or clearly identified as assets of the Pension Fund. In lieu thereof,
the Trustees may deposit the funds of the Pension Fund in a qualified public
depository as defined in Section 280.02, Florida Statutes. Which depository with
regard to such assets shall conform to and be bound by all of the provisions of
Chapter 280, Florida Statutes. '
I
I
i
I
I
i
,
i
'I
(2) The Pension Fund shall be held in trust by the Trustees and the
Trustees shall be vested with full legal title to the Pension Fund; provided,
further, that the actual custody and supervision of the Pension Fund shall be
vested In the Trustees.
(b) Raco rd s. All assets attributable to the Plan may be comm [ngled in the
Pension Fund. provided that accurate records are maintained at all times reflecting
the financial composition of the Pension Fund. Including accurate current accounts and
entries as regards the following:
( 1 ) current amounts of accumulated contributions of Employees on an
individual account basis;
(2) receipts and disbursements;
(3), benefit payments;
(4) all Interest. dividends and gains (or losses); and
37
~;i".. "
(5) such other entries as may be properly required so as to reflect a
clear and complete financial report of the Pension Fund.
I:,
(2) Invest and reinvest the assets of the Pension Fund in:
j
I
I
I
1
1
~
i
.
J
j
I
I
(c) Powers and Duties of Trustees. The Trustees may:
(1) Invest and reinvest the assets of the Pension Fund in annuity
(including group annuity contracts of the pension investment type) and life
insurance contracts of legal reserve Ilfe insurance companies licensed to do
business in the State of Florida, in amounts sufficient to provide; in whole or in
part, benefits to which all of the Participants shall be or become entitled under
the provisions of the Plan, and pay the initlal and subsequent premiums thereon.
(A) Time or savings accounts of a national bank, a state bank, :;)
or a savings; building and loan association insured by the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation.
(B) Obligations of the United States Treasury and agencies
allied with or related to the United States Treasury.
(C) County bonds containing a pledge of the full faith and credit
of the county Involved, bonds of the Florida development commission, or
of any other state agency, which have been approved as to legal and
fiscal sufficiency by the state board of administration.
,/
, \
(D) Obligations of any municipal, authority issued pursuant to
the laws of this state; provided, however, that for each of the five years
next preceding the date of Investment, the income of such authority
available for fixed charges shall have been not less than one and one-half
(1-1/2) times its average annual fixed charge requirements over the life
of its obligations.
(E) Common stocks, preferred stocks and bonds and other
evidence of indebtedness Issued or guaranteed by a corporation
organized under the laws of the United States, any state; or organized
territory of the United States or the District of Columbia or any
corporation International in character engaged In international business
and trade, provided:
38
I,'.
(I) the corporation is'lIsted on anyone or more of the
recognized national stock exchanges;
(iI) all corporate bonds shall carry a AA rating as
established either by Standard & Poor's, Moody's or Fitch; and
(iii) not more than three percent (3%) of the assets of
the Pension Fund shall be invested in the common stock or capital
stock of anyone Issuing company nor shall the aggregate
Investment anyone issuing company exceed one per cent (1 %) of
the outstanding capital stock of that company; nor shall the
aggregate of the Investments under this subparagraph at cost
exceed fifty percent (50%) of the Pension Fund's assets.
..
~~
~
~
j
{
I
1
J
I
I
1
( 3) Cause any Pension Fund investment In securities to be registered In
or transferred Into its name as Trustee or into the name of such nominee as it
may direct, or it may retain them unregistered and In form permitting
transferability, but the books and records shall at all times show that all
Investments are part of the Pension Fund.
(4) Vote upon any stocks, bonds, or securities of any corporation,
association, or trust and give general or specific proxies or powers of attorney
with or Y'lthout power of substitution; participate in mergers, reorganizations,
recapitalizations, consolidations, and similar transactions with respect to such
securities; deposit such stock or other securities in any voting trust or any
protective or like committee with the Trustees or with depositories designated
thereby; amortize or fail to amortize any part or all of the premium or
discount resulting from the acquisition or disposition of assets; and generally
exercise any of the powers of an owner with respect to stocks, bonds, or
other Investments comprising the Pension Fund which it may deem to be to the
best Interest of the Pension Fund to exercise.
(5) Retain in cash and keep unproductive of Income such amount of
the Pension Fund as it may deem advisable, having regard for the cash
requirements of the Plan.
( 6 ) Retain the services of a custodian bank, an Investment advisor
..
registered under Investment Advisors Act of 1940 or otherwise exempt from
such required registration, an insurance company, or a combination of these,
for the purposes of Investment decisions and management. Such Investment
39
..,..,'....
manager shall have discretion, subject to any guidelines as prescribed by the
Trustees, in the Investment of all Pension Fund assets.
(d) Prudent Man Rule. The Trustees of this Plan and all other persons
occupying a fiduciary position under this Plan in the administration of this Plan and in
Investing and reinvesting assets of the Pension Fund shall utillze and be governed by
the prudent man rule.
(e) Receipt of Information. Where any action which the Trustees are
required to take or any duty or function which they are required to perform either
under the terms herein or under the general law applicable to the Trustees under this
Plan can reasonably be taken or performed only atter receipt by the Trustees from a
Participant, the Employer, or any other entity, of specific information, certification,
direction or Instructions, the Trustees shall be free of liability in falling to take such
action or perform such duty or function until such information, certification, direction
or instruction has been received by it..
(f) Overpayments and Underpayments. Any overpayments or
underpayments from the Pension Fund to a Participant or beneficiary caused by
errors of computation shall be adjusted with interest at a rate per annum approved
by the Trustees. Overpayment shall be charged against payments next succeeding
the correction. Underpayments shall be made up from the Pension Fund.
(g) Appointment of Agents. Any of the foregoing powers and functions
reposed in the Trustees may be performed or carried out by the Trustees through
duly authorized agents, provided that the Trustees at all times maintain continuous
supervision over the acts of any such agent; provided further, that legal title to the
Pension Fund shall always remain in the Trustees.
(h) Independent Audit. An Indppendent audlt shall be performed annually
by a certified public accountant for the most recent fiscal year of the Employer. Such
report shall reflect Items normally Included in a certified audit.
(i) Expenses of Administration.
( 1 ) (A) The assets of the Pension Fund may be used to pay all
expenses of the administration of the Plan and the Pension Fund, Including
the compensation of any Investment manager, the expense Incurred by
the Trustees or the Committee In discharging Its duties, all income or
other taxes of any kind whatsoever that may be levied or assessed
under existing or future laws upon or in respect of the Pension Fund, and
40
~~'"~/"'~ f.' ." '
.. 0:. ....~"h'
any Interest that may be payable on money borrowed by the Trustees
for the purpose of the Pension Fundt as well as any settlements or
judgments entered with respect to the Plan.
I:
I,: . '
(B) The Employer may pay the expenses of the Plan and the
Pension Fund. Any such payment by the Employer shall not be deemed a
contribution to this Plan.
I'
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained herein to the contrary I no
excise tax or other liability Imposed upon the Trustees or any other person for
failure to comply with the provisions of any federal law shall be subject to
payment or reimbursement from the assets of the Pension Fund.
(3) No indIvidual Trustee or Committee member shall be entitled to
compensation from the Trust (except for the reimbursement of expenses
properly and actually Incurred).
I
I
I
:1
i
41
I
v
~;"f':-': ,~'.. ,
Rev. 8/ 4/95
Section 2.400
Amendment and Termination
, I
~ i
( a) Amend ment of P I a n. The City Commission of tile Employe r shall have
continuous power to amend this Plan In whole or in part; provided, however, that no
such amendment, except as permitted by law:
( 1 ) shall become effective until and unless It Is ratified by a majority of
the qualified electors of the City of Clearwater voting either In a general election
or in a special election called and held for the purpose of ratification or
rejection of the amendment; provided, however, that such ratification shall not
be required If the amendment is necessary to comply with applicable state or
federal law.
(2) shall have the effect of vesting in the Employer, directly or
indirectly any interest, ownership or control in any of the present or subsequent
assets held in the Pension Fund;
(3) shall cause or permit any property held subject to the terms of
the Pension Fund to be diverted faT purposes other than the exclusive benefit of
the Participants and their beneficiaries; or
( 4) shall reduce the then vested Accrued Benefit of any Participant.
(5) reduce or eliminate any benefit in pay status prior to the Effective
Date of the Plan, except as otherwise provided under the terms of the Plan, prior to
the Effective Date of thIs amendment and restatement.
(b) Termination of Plan: Discontinuance of Contrib utloos.
( 1 ) This Plan may be termin'ated in whole or in part at any time by the
Employert". provided. however. that termination shall not become effective until
and unless the decision to terminate is ratified by a malority of the qualified
electors of the City of Clearwater voting either In a general or a special election
called and held for the purpose of ratification or rejection of Plan termination.
(2) If this Plan Is terminated, or If contributions to the Plan are
discontinued, the Trustees shall continue to administer the Pian in accordance
with the provisions of the Plan , for the sole benefit of lhe Participants and their
beneficiaries. In the event of terminatfon, or if contributions to the Plan are
42
~ ','~
discontinued, there shall be full vesting of benefits accrued to the date of
termination and the assets of the Plan shall be allocated In an equitable manner
to provide benefits on a proportionate basis to the persons so entitled In
accordance with the provisions thereof.
(3) The following shall be the order of priority for purposes of
allocating the assets of the Plan as of the date of termination or the
discontinuance of contributions, with the date of such discontinuance being
determined by the Trustees.
(A) Apportionment shall first be made with respect to each
Employee receiving a benefit hereunder on such date, each person
receiving a benefit on such date on account of a deceased Employee,
and each Employee who has, by such date. become eligible for a normal
retirement benefit but has not yet retired, in an amount which is the
actuarial equivalent of such benefit, based upon the actuarial
assumptions in use for purposes of the most recent actuarial valuation,
provided that, if such asset value Is less than the aggregate of such
amounts. such amounts shall be proportionately reduced so that the
aggregate of such reduced amounts will be equal to such asset value.
(B) If there is any asset value remaining after the
apportionment under subparagraph (3)(A) , apportionment shall next be
made with respect to each Employee in the service of the Employer on
such date who has completed at least ten Years of Credited Service and
who Is not entitled to an apportionment under subparagraph (3)(A) , in
the amount required to provide the actuarial equivalent, as described in
subparagraph (3)(A) above, of the accrued Normal Retirement Benefit.
based on the credited service and Average Monthly Compensation as of
such date, and each vested former Participant then entitled to a
deferred benefit who has not, by such date. begun receiving benefit
payments, [n the amount required to provide said actuarial equIvalent of
the accrued Normal Retirement Benefit, provided that, if such remaining
asset value is less than the aggregate of the amounts apportioned
hereunder, such latter amounts shall be proportionately reduced so that
the aggregate of such reduced amounts will be equal to such remaining
asset value.
(C) If there is any asset value after the apportionments under
subparagraphs (3)(A) and (3)(BL apportionment shall be made with
respect to each Employee in the service of the Employer on such date
43
-
"
r......~ ..~. ~,
i
who is not entitled to an apportionment under subparagraphs (3){A)
and (3){B) in an amount equal to Particlpant's accumulated
contributions, provided that, It such remaining asset value is less than
the aggregate of the amounts apportioned hereunder such latter
amount shall be proportionately reduced so that the aggregate of such
reduced amounts wHl be equal to such remaining asset value.
,
i
I
I
I
I
~
~i
.
J
I
,
r
i
i
\
I
!
(0) If there is any asset value remaining after the
apportionments under subparagraphs (3)(A) , (3)(8), and (3)(e),
apportionment shall lastly be made with respect of each Employee
included in subparagraph (3)(e) above to the extent of the actuarial
equivalent, as descrlbed in subparagraph (3)(A) above, of the accrued
Normal Retirement Benefit, less the amount apPol1loned in
subparagraph (3)(eL based on the credited service and Average
Monthly Compensation as of such date, provided that, If such remaining
asset value is less than the aggregate of the amounts apportioned
hereunder, such a'mounts shall be reduced so that the aggregate of such
reduced amounts will be equal to such remaining asset value.
(E) In the event there is asset value remaining after the full
apportionment specified In subparagraphs (3)(A) , (3)(B), (3He) and
(3)(0), such excess shall be returned to the Employer.
(4) The allocation provided in subparagraph (3) above may, as
decided by the Trustees, be carried out through the purchase of Insurance
company contracts to provide the benefits determIned in accordance with this
subparagraph (3). The Pension Fund may be distributed in one sum to the
persons entitled to said benefits or the distribution may be carried out in such
other equitable manner as the Trustees may direct. The Pension Fund may be
continued In existence for purposes of subsequent distributions.
I
( 5) After all the vested Accrued Benefits provided hereunder have
been paid and after all other liabilities have been satisfied, then and only then
shall any remaining amounts of the Pension Fund revert to the Employer.
44
\'-.." '
Section 2.401
Miscellaneous
(a) Alienation. No Participant or beneffciary of a Participant shall have any
right to assign. transfer, appropriate, encumber, commute, anticipate or otherwise
alienate his Interest in this Plan or the Pension Fund or any payments to be made
thereunder; no benefits, payments, rights or interests of a Participant or beneficiary
of a Participant of any kind or nature shall be In any way subject to legal process to
levy upon, garnish or attach the same for payment of any claim against the
Participant or beneficiary; and no Participant or beneficiary of a Participant shall have
any right of any kind whatsoever with respect to the Pension Fund, or any estate or
interest therein, or with respect to any other property or right, other than the right
to receive such distributions as are lawfully made out of the Pension Fund, as and
when the same respectively are due and payable under the terms of this Plan.
I
J
I
I
j
,
(b) Effect on Other Plans. Nothing In this Plan shall be construed so as
to abridge, alter or in any way affect any 01 the rights or liabilities of an Employee of
the Employer under any other retirement plan In effect as of the Effective Date of this
Plan.
(c) Forfeiture of Benefits for Certain Offenses.
(1 ) Any Employee who is convicted of any 01 the following specified
offenses committed prior to retirement, or whose employment Is terminated by
reason of his admitted commission, aid or abetment of any of the following
specified offenses, shall foneit all rights and benefits under this Pension Fund,
except for the return of his accumulated contributions as of the date of
termination.
(2) The specified offenses are as follows:
(A) The committingj aiding or abetting of an embezzlement of
public funds;
(B) The committing, aiding or abetting of any theft by a public
officer or Employee from the Employer; ,
,
,
(C) Bribery In connection with the, employment of a public
offlcer or Employee;
45
,or.1 ~,""
(D) Any felony specified in Florida Statutes, Chapter 838
(except 9838.15 and 9838.16);
(E) The committing of an impeachable offense; and
,
I
I
i
1
i
,
i
~
j
I
I
I
!
(F) The commIttIng of any felony by a public officer or
Employee who willfully and with Intent to defraud the public or the public
agency, for which he, acts or In which he is employed, of the right to
receive the faIthful performance of his duty as a public officer or
Employee, realizes or obtains! or attempts to obtain, a profit, gain! or
advantage for himself or for some other person through the use or
attempted use of the power! rights, privileges! duties or position of his
public office or employment position.
(3) For purposes of thIs paragraph! Ilconvictionll shall be defined as
an adjudication of guilt by a court of competent jurisdiction; a plea of guilty or
a nolo contendere; a jury verdict of guilty when adjudication of guilt is withheld
and the accused is placed on probation; or a conviction by the Senate of an
impeachable offense. For this purpose, "court" shall be defined as any state or
federal court of competent jurisdiction which is exercising its jurisdiction to
consIder a proceeding involving the alleged commission of a specified offense.
, (4) Prior to forfeiture, the Trustees shall hold a hearing In accordance
with FlorIda Statutes, Chapter 120 on which notice shall be given to the
Participant whose benefits are being considered for forfeiture.
(5) If a Participant whose benefits are forfeited pursuant to this
paragraph has received benefits from the Plan in excess of his contributions
without interest, such Participant shall be required to pay back to the Pension
Fund the amount of the benefits received in excess of hIs contributions without
Interest. The Trustees may implement all legal action necessary to recover
such funds.
(d) Indemnification.
( 1 ) To the extent not covered by Insurance contracts in force from
time to time, the Employer shall indemnify and hold harmless the Trustees and
the members of the Committee from all personal liability for damages and
costs, IncludIng court costs and attorneys' fees, arisIng out of claims, suits.
litigatIon, or threat of same. herein referred to as "claims", against these
individuals because of acts or circumstances connected with or arising out of
46
"
;"~,~r'~;,'-' . ",
I
their official duty as Trustees or members of the Committee. The Employer
, reserves the right, In Its sole discretion, to selUe or not settle the claim at any
time, and to apreal or to not appeal from any adverse ludgment or ruling) and
In either event wlll Indemnify and hold harmless any, Trustees or members of the
Committee from the judgment, execution, or levy thereon.
(2) This paragraph shall not be construed so as to relieve any
insurance company or other entity liable to defend the claim or liable for
, payment of the judgment or claim, from any lIabllity, nor does this paragraph
waive any provision of law affording the Employer Immunity from any suit In
whole or part, or waive any other substantive or procedural rights the
Employer may have.
I
t
~
6
( 3) This paragraph shall not apply nor shall the Employer be
responsible In any manner to defend or pay for claims arising out of acts or
omissions of the Trustees or members of the Committee which constitute
felonies or gross malfeasance or gross misfeasance In office.
(e) Uniformed Service.
(1) An Employee shall be credited with service for purposes of vesting
and beneflt accruals for his service in the uniformed service (as defined in the
,Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994 [the
II Ace']) upon being granted leave by the Employer for such uniformed service
and termination from employment as an Employee with the Employer, provided
that:
(A) the Participant must return to his employment as an
Employee with the Employer within the time periods prescribed by the
Act; and
(B) the Employee complies with the Employee contribution
requirements prescribed by Act.
(2) The maximum service credit for uniformed service shall be 5 years
or such other time period as may be prescribed by the Act.
47
'" . ' '
':'1.1
ORDINANCE NO. 5890~95
C M 1- =#Lf;
~,)ll. 95
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATERt
FLORIDA. AMENDING THE PROVISIONS OF DIVISION 3
OF ARTICLE 5 OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER CODE OF
ORDINANCES. ADOPTING A REVISED EMPLOYEES'
PENSION PLAN; PROVIDING FOR A REFERENDUM
ELECTION RELATING TO THE PENSION PLAN;
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City of Clearwater has previously adopted the City of Clearwater,
Employees' Pension Plan, which has been amended from time to time and codified as
Division 3 of Article 5 of the City of Clearwater Code. and
WHEREAS, the City is authorized and empowered to amend the Plan and
subsequently submit the same to the voters of the City of Clearwater at a Referendum,
and
WHEREAS, the City negotiated Plan changes in concept with employee unions
and now deems it is necessary and in the best interest of the Plan participants and -the
City to adopt an amended Plan, now, therefore,
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. Sections 2.391 thru 2.411 of Division 3 of Article 5 of the City of
Clearwater Code are hereby repealed effective January 1 t 1996.
Section 2. Division 3 of Article 5 of the City of Clearwater Code of Ordinances
is hereby amended, revised and restated by adopting sections 2.391 thru 2.401 effective
as of January 1. 1996, to read as follows:
Section 2.391 Amendment and Restatement and Name of the Plan
A pension plan is hereby amended and restated in accordance with the terms
hereof and shall be known as the "CITY OF CLEARWATER EMPLOYEES' PENSION
FUND. '\ ,
,":"If:~ l , I', '.'
Section 2.392 Purpose of the Plan and the Trust
A. Exclusive Benefit.
1. This Plan is created for the sole purpose of providing benefits to the
Participants. Exc,ept as otherwise permitted by law (including payment of
expenses as set forth in paragraph (i) of Section 2.399), In no event shall any part
of the principal or income of the Pension Fund be paid to or reinvested in the
Employer or be used for or diverted to any purpose whatsoever other than for the
exclusive benefit of the, Participants and their beneficiaries.
2. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of subparagraph (1), any
contribution' made by the Employer to this' Plan by a mistake of fact may be
returned to the Employor within one year after the payment of the contribution.
The circumstances as to whether a mistake of fact has occurred shall be reviewed
by the Committee, which shall submit a written recommendation to the Trustees.
Notwithstanding the Committee's recommendation, the Trustees shall have final
authority as to the determination of a mistake of fact.
-I
J
B. Participants' Rights. The establishment of this Plan shall not be
considered as giving any. Employee, or any other person, any legal or equitable right
against the Employer, the Trustees, the Committee or the principat or the income of the
Pension Fund, except to the extent otherwise provided by law. The establishment of this
Plan shall not be considered as giving any Employee, or any other person, the right to
be retained in the employ of the Employer.
, ,
C. Qualified Plan. This Plan and the assets comprising the Pension Fund are
intended to qualify under the Internal Revenue Code as a tax-free employees' plan and
trust, and the provisions of this Plan should be interpreted accordingly.
~
2
..
Section 2.393 Definitions
(a) "Accrued Benefit" shall mean, as of a specified timet the Normal
Retirement Benefit as set forth in Section 2.397.
(b) IIActuarial Equivalent" shall mean a benefit of equivalent current value
to the benefit that would otherwise have been provided to the Participant, determined
in accordance with the rules established by the Employer and on the basis of
appropriate actuarial'methods and the following actuarial assumptions:
1. Mortality: 1983 Group Annuity Mortality Table (Unisex).
2. Interest: ' 7% per annum, compounded annually.
(c) "Annual Additions" sliall mean for Limitation Years beginning on or
after December 31, 1986, the sum of:
(1) the amount of Employer con'tributions allocated to the
Participant during any Limitation Year under any defined contribution plan
maintained by an Employer;
j
1
"
I
}
!
I
I
I
I
i
I
(2) the amount of the Employee's contributions (other than rollover
contributions, if any) to any contributory defined contribution plan maintained
by an Employer or an Affiliate;
(3) any forfeitures allocated to the Participant under any defined
contribution plan maintained by an Employer or an Affiliate; or
(4) amounts allocated to an individual medical account, as defined
in Section 415(1)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code that is part of a pension or
annuity plan maintained by an Employer and amounts derived from
contributions that are attributable to post~retirement medical benefits allocated
to the separate account of a key employee (as defined in Section 419A(d)(3) of
the Internal Revenue Code) under a welfare benefit plan (as defined in Section
419(e) of the Internal Revenue Code) maintained by ,an Employer or an
- Affiliate; provided, however, the percentage limitation set forth in Section 415
(c)(1)(8) of the Internal Revenue Code shall not apply to: (A) any contribution
for medical benefits (within the meaning of Section 419A(f)(2) of the Internal
Revenue Code) after separation from service which is otherwise treated as an
"~nnual Addition, II or (2) any amount otherwise treated as an "Annual Additiontl
under Section 415(1)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code.
D. IIAveraqe Monthly Compensation" shall mean the monthly
Compensation of a Participant averaged over his last 5 consecutive Years of Credited
3
I'
<,
Service. If a Participant has less than 5 consecutive Years of Credited Service, his
Average Monthly Compensation will be based on his monthly Compensation during
his months of service beginning with the date he commences participation in the Plan
to his date of termination of employment. For purposes of determining a Participant's
maximum benefit as required by Section 415 of the tnternal Revenue Code, a '
Participant's "Average Monthly Compensation" shall mean the Section 415
Compensation received by a Participant during the three (3) consecutive Limitation
Years with respect to which the Participant receives the highest Section 415
Compensation. divided by 36 (or, if less, the aggregate number of his months of
employment).
E. "Committee" shall mean the pension advisory committee described in
Section 2.394.
F. 1. "Compensation" shall mean the regular salaries, wages,
overtime pay. leave pay (except when paid a lump sum upon retirement
benefit), bonuses paid by the Employer (provided the Employee contribution
rate is applied thereto). Employee contributions designated as Employer
contributions under Section 414(h) of the Internal Revenue Code, and
employee salary reduction contributions made pursuant to an arrangement
described in Section 125 of the Internal Revenue Code, compensation deferred
under Section 457(b) of the Internal Revenue Code, indemnity benefits
received pursuant to the Workers' Compensation Law, incentive pay for police
and firefighters, assignment pay, acting pay, and shift differential pay but shall
not include clothing, car or meal allowances, disability payments, lump sum
payments of accrued sick leave paid upon retiremeflt, relocation expense
payments, benefits under this Plan. any amount contributed to any pension,
employee welfare, life insurance, or health insurance plan or arrangement, or
any other fringe benefits; welfare benefits or Employer paid deferred
compensation.
\
2. a. In addition to other applicable limitations set forth in the
Plan, and notwithstanding any other provision of the Plan to the
contrary, for Plan Years beginning on or after January 1, 1996. the
annual Compensation of each Employee taken into account under the
Plan shall not exceed the OBRA '93 annual Compensation limit. The
OBRA '93 annual Compensation limit is $150,000, as adJusted by the
Commissioner for increases in the cost of living in accordance with
Section 401 (a)(17)(8) of the Internal Revenue Code. The cost-of-Iiving
adjustment in effect for a calendar year applies to any period, not
exceeding 12 months, over which Compensation is determined
(determination period) beginning in such calendar year. If a
determination period consists of fewer than 12 months, the OBRA '93
annual Compensation limit will be multiplied by a fraction, the numerator
4
-
~):,............. . .
of which is the number of months in the determination period, and the
denominator of which is 12.
b. For Plan Years beginning on or after .January 1" 1996, any
reference in this Plan to the limitation under Section 401 (a)(17) of the
Internal Revenue Code shall mean the OBRA '93 annual Compensation
limit set forth in this provision.
. c. The limitation on Compensation for an neligible" employee
shall not be less than the amount which was allowed to be taken into
account hereunder as in effect on July 1, 1993. "Eligible Employee" is '
an individual who was a participant before the first Plan Year beginning
December 31, 1995.
3. For purposes of determining whether Compensation exceeds the
dollar limit under Section 401 (a)(17) of the Internal Revenue Code, if any
Employee is a Family Member of a Highly Compensated Employee who is one
of the ten Highly Compensated Employees'paid the greatest amount of
Compensation during the Plan Year. then such Family Member shall not be
considered as a separate Employee and any Compensation paid to such
Family Member shall be treated as if it were paid to or on behalf of the related
Highly Compensated Employee.
G. "Earlv Retirement Datell shall mean the date on which a Participant has
reached the age of 65 years and completed 10 Years of Credited Service.
H. IIEffective Datell of this amendment and restatement shall mean
January 1, 1996.
I. 1. IIEmplovee" shall mean any person employed by the Employer as
a full-time permanent employee other than
a. individuals who have failed a comprehensive physical
exam and by reason of such fact have not been recommended for
acceptance into the Plan by the Committee or approved by the
Trustees,
b. persons hired on a contractual basis, and
\
c. employees exempt from the Employer's civil service
classified service system (unclassified employees) for whom 'an
Employment Agreement Letter establishes conditions of employment;
provided, however, if a person was a Participant in the Plan prior to
being employed in a position described in this subparagraph (C), he
shall continue to participate in the Plan.,
5
2. The Trustees shall have the right to determine from time to time
which persons are full~time permanent employees for purposes of the Plan;
provided, however, that all persons covered by the civil service ordinance of
the Employer who are employed on a full~time basis shall be considered full-
time permanent employees for purposes of the Plan.
3. Permanent part-time, emergency, seasonal and provisional
employees shall not be "Employees" eligible to participate in the Plan.
J. ~'Emplove"" shall mean the City of Clearwater.
I
!
I
I
I
I'
I
i
!
K. "Family Member' of a Highly Compensated Employee shalt mean such
Employee's spouse, lineal descendant or ascendant, or the spouse of his lineal
descendant or ascendant; provided, however, that for purposes of determining the
limit on a Highly Compensated Employee's Compensation under Section.401(a){17)
of the Internal Revenue Code, the term "Family Member" shall include only the
Employee's spouse and his lineal d~scendants wh'o have not attained age 19 before
the close of the Plan Year.
L. 1. ,"Hiqhlv Compensated Emplovee" shall mean any Employee
during the Plan Year or the immediately preceding Plan Year
a. whose Section 415 Compensation was more than $75,000
(adjusted under such regulations as may be issued by the Secretary of
the Treasury); or
,. b. whose Section 415 Compensation was more than $50,000
(adjusted under such regulations as may be issued by the Secretary of
the Treasury), and who was a member of the "top paid group"; provided,
that as used herein, "top paid group" shall mean all Employees who are
in the top 20% of the Employer's work force on the basis of Section 415
Compensation paid during the year; provided, further, that for purposes
of determining the number of Employees in the top paid group,
Employees described in Section 414(q)(8) of the Internal Revenue Code
shall be excluded.
\
c. In determining who is a Highly Compensated Employee,
Employe,es who are nonresident aliens and who receive no earned
income (within the meaning of Section 911 (d)(2) of the Internal Revenue
Code) from the Employer constituting United States source income
(within the meaning of Section 861 (a)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code)
shall not be treated as Employees.
6
d. for purposes of this paragraph. the determination of
Section 415 Compensation shall be based only on Section 415
Compensation that is actually paid and shall be made by including
elective or salary reduction contributions to a plan described in Section
125 of the Internal Revenue Code. a plan described in Section 401 (k) of
the Internal Revenue Code or a plan described in Section 403(b) of the
Internal Revenue Code.
e. The term ItHighly Compensated Employee" shall also mean
any former Employee who separated from service (or was deemed to
have separated from service) prior to the Plan Year; performs no service
for the Employer during the Plan Year, and was an actively employed
Highly Compensated Employee in the separation year or any Plan Vear
ending on or after the date the Employee attained age 55.
f. For purposes of determining whether an Employee is a
Highly Compensated Employee, if any Employee is a Family Member of
a Highly Compensated Employee wHo is one of the ten Highly
Compensated Employees paid the greatest amount of Compensation
during the Plan Year, then such Family Member shall not be considered
as a separate Employee and any Compensation paid to s'uch Family
Member (and any applicable benefit or contribution on behalf of such
Family Member) shall be treated as if it were paid to or on behalf of the
related Highly Compensated Employee.
M. "Internal Revenue Code" shall mean the Internal Revenue Code of
1986 r.lS amended or any successor statute. Reference to a specific section of the
Internal Revenue Code shall include a reference to any successor provision.
(n) "Limitation Year" shall mean the Plan Year.
(0) "Normal Retirement Benefitt1 shall mean the monthly income payable
to a retired Participant pursuant to the provisions of Section 2.397 of this Plan.
I
(p)
t1Normal Retirement Datelt shall mean
1. the earlier of:
a. the ~ate on which a Participant has reached the age of 55
years and completed 20 Years of Credited Servicel
\
b. the date on which a Participant has completed 30 Years of
Credited Service regardless of age, or
7
"'i'll" ~ '.
, c. the date on which a Participant has completed 20 Years of
Credited Service, which service is of a character or type of employment
that is described below as IIhazardous dutyll Of that the Trustees have
designated as hazardous duty.
2. For this purpose, a Participanfs service shall be deemed
Uhazardous dUtyll if the Participant is a full-time sworn pollee officer certified in
accordance with Section 943.1395, Florida Statutes. or a full-time firefighter
certified in accordance with Section 633.35, Florida Statutes, and he is
employed in police or fire positions as established by the Employer.
(q) "Participanttl shall mean any eligible Employee of the Employer who
has commenced participation and is .contributing under the Plan.
(r) UPlan" shall mean the pension plan as herein set forth and as it may be
amended from time to time.
(s) "Plan Year' s~all mean the 12-month period ending on December 31.
_ (t) "Section 415 Compensationtl shall mean all compensation as
described in Section 1.415-2(d)(2) and Section 1.415-2(d)(3) of the income Tax
Regulations'.
(u) ttTrustee" or "Trustees" shall mean the individual or individuals. as the
context requires, designated as trustee pursuant to Section 2.394.
(v) "Pension Fundll shall mean the pension fund established pursuant to
Section 2.399.
(w) "Years of Credited Servicetl shall mean the total number of years and
fractional parts of years of service credited as an Employee of the Employer during
periods of participation in the Plan. omitting intervening years or fractional parts of
years when an Employee is not employed by the Employer or not participating in the
Plan (except as may otherwise be provided in rules established by the Committee
and approved by the Trustees).
\
8
.....~ ,.., ...
Section 2.394 Plan Administration
(a) Administration of the Plan. The Trustees shall control and manage, in
conjunction with the Committeet the operation and administration of the Plan
(b) Trustees.
(1) The members of the City Commission of the Employer, whether
elected or appointed, shall serve as the Trustees. The term of office of each
Trustee shall be consistent with his term of office as a member of the City
Commission.
1
I,
{3} Each Trustee shall be entitled to one vote. Three affirmative
votes shall be necessary for any decision tiy the Trustees at a meeting of the
Trustees. A Trustee shall have the right to recuse himself from voting as the
result of a conflict of interest provided that the Trustee s~ates in writing the
nature of the conflict.
I
i
I
~
i
I
I
\
I
l
i
I
[
{2} The Finance Director of the Employer shall be the treasurer for
the Trustees and shall provide such bond as may be prescribed by the
Trustees.
(4) The Trustees shall not receive any compensation for service as a
Trustee, but may be reimbursed expenses as provided by law; provided,
however, that the Trustees may receive compensation for services as a
member of the City Commission.
(c) Powers and Duties of Trustees. The Trustees shall have final
authority and control over the administration of the Plan herein embodied, with all
powers necessary to enable them to carry out their duties in that respect. Not in
limitation, but in amplification of the foregoing, the Trustees shall have the power and
discretion to interpret or construe this Plan and to determine all questions that may
arise as to the status and rights of the Participants and others hereunder.
{d}
Pension Advisorv Committee.
~
(1) (A) There shall be a pension advisory committee comprised of
seven persons. Three members of the Committee shall be Employees
who are active Employees and Participants in the Plan; three members
shall be City Commissioners or appointees of the City Commission; and
the seventh member, who shall be a resident of the City of Clearwater,
shall be appointed by the other six members.
(B) Except as provided In subparagraph (3) below. terms of
9
1.
....~ ~ . '
members shall be for two years.
(2) Committee members representing the Employees shall be elected
by a majority of the active Employees who are Participants in the Plan.
Committee members representing the City Commission shall be appointed by
a majority vote of the City Commission. The seventh member shall be
appointed by a majority vote of the other six members of the Committee.
(3) Terms of office of Employee elected Committee members shall
overlap, with two of the members to be initially elected fer two years and the
third member to be initially elected for one year. Terms of office of City
Commission appointed members shall overlap, with two of tne members to be
initially appointed for two years and the third member to be initially appointed
for one year. .
(4) (A) The first election of Committee members representing the
Employees shall be held within 45 days of approval of the amended and
restated Plan. Thereafter, not less than 60 days before each
subsequent election of an Employee elected Committee member, the,
existing Employee elected Committee members shall select and appoint
a nominee group composed of five persons from Employees
participating in the Plan to conduct the election process. The
Department of the City Clerk shall provide necessary assistance to the
Employees for the administration of elections.
(8) Members of the Committee last elected by Employees on
the date of adoption of this amended and restated Plan shall continue to
serve as the Employee elected Committee members until the first
election under this amended and restated Plan has been held.
(5) Any vacancy on the Committee, whether Employee elected, City
Commission appointed, or the Committee appointed seventh member, shall be
filled for the remainder of the term and in the same manner as the original
Committee member who vacated the position.
(6) Members of the Committee shall serve without compensation
additional to that earned in their respective capacities as regular Employees or
elected City Commissioners.
(7) Each Committee member shall be entitled to one vote. Four
a~rmative votes shall be necessary for any decision by the Committee at any
meeting. A Committee member shall have the right to recuse himself from
voting as a result of a conflict of interest provided that the Committee member
states in writing the nature of the conflict.
10
.'
(e) Powers and Duties of Committee.
(1) The Committee shalt have authority to:
(A) Arrange for the necessary physicians to pass upon all
medical examinations required under this Plan. Such physicians shall
report in writing to the Committee their conclusions and
recommendations. The Committee shall review such physicians' reports
and prepare its recommendations as to the acceptance or denial of '
Employees as Participants and forward same to the Trustees.
,
I
I
I
i
I
\
t
J
\
I
I
(8) In conjunction with the Employer and medical consultants,
establish the scope of the medical examinations to be used for benefit
eligibility and medical standards to be used for benefit eligibility and to
guide the examining physicians in reaching their conclusions and
recommendations. Such medical standards shall give due consideration
to the nature of the job classification, in which Participants are to be
placed.
(C) Investigate and recommend to the Trustees, in conjunction
with the actuaries, such mortality/service and other tables as shall be
deemed necessary for the operation of the Plan.
(0) Make recommendations to the Trustees for improvements
or changes in the Plan.
(E) Receive all applications for benefits under this Plan and
determine all facts that are necessary to establish the right of an
applicant to benefits under the Plan.
!El Prepare and distribute to the participants information
relating to the Plan.
(2) The Committee shall, from time to time as it deems appropriate,
submit recommendations to the Trustees as to rules, procedures, forms and
general administrative procedures relating to the responsibilities of the
Committee.
(3) No benefits or relief shall be provided to any Participant under the
P,Ian unless the same has been reviewed by the Committee and a
r~commendation provided to the Trustees.
(f) Conflict in Terms. In the event of any conflict between the terms of
,this Plan and any explanatory booklet, this Plan 'shall control.
11
,\
~...".. .
(g) Nondiscrimination. The Trustees shall not take any action or direct the
Committee to take any action whatsoever that would result in unfairly benefiting one,
Participant or group of Participants at the expense of another or in discriminating
between Participants similarly situated or in the application of different rules to
sUbstantially similar sets of facts.
(h) Procedures and Records.
(1) The Trustees and, subject to the approval of the Trustees, the
Committee, may establish rules and procedures as are necessary to' administer
the Plan, which rules and procedures shall be applied in an uniform and
nondiscriminCltory manner.
(2) The Trustees and the Committee shall keep a complete record of
all their proceedings and aU data necessary for the administration of the Plan.
All of the foregoing records and data shall be located at the principal office of
the Employer.
(i) Final Authority. Except to the extent otherwise required by law or by
'I this Plan, the decision of the Trustees in matters within their jurisdiction shall be final,
binding and conclusive upon the Employer, the Committee, each Employee and
beneficiary, and every other interested or concerned person or party.
m Appointment of Advisors. The Trustees may appoint such actuaries,
accountants, professional investment counsel, legal counsel, specialists, third party
pension administrators, and other persons that they deem necessary and desirable in
connection with the administration of this Plan or to assist them in the performance of
their duties as. Trustees. The Trustees are authorized to pay for such services from
the Pension Fund.
\
12
;:t~ "-\: I~ ..., , +
Section 2.395 Participation
(a) Participation.
(1) Unless otherNise provided herein, all Em'ployees of the Employer
shall be required to make the contributions specified in Section 2.396 and shall
be required to participate in the Plan.
(2) Any Employee who is a Participant and who by reason of
appointment has or may become an official of the Employer shall be eligible to
continue participate in the Plan in the same manner as any other Employee.
(b) Reemployment.
(1) If a Participant terminates employment with the Employer and is
subsequently reemployed within the 5 year period following his termination of
employment, the former Participant shall again be eligible to participate in the
Plan and his credited service shall be base"d on all periods of employment,
provided he
(A) again satisfies the definition" of "Employee" set forth in
Section 2.393 (including passing the comprehensive physical
examination), and
(B) repays the amount of any Employee contributions he
received in accordance with paragraph (d)(4) of Section 2.397.
(2) Notwithstanding the foregoing, an Employee .who is reemployed
after his benefits have commenced under the Plan (other than disability
benefits pursuant to paragraph (c) of Section 2.397) shall not be eligible to
participate in the Plan upon his subsequent reemployment.
\
13
Section 2.396 Contributions to the Plan
(a) Emplovee Contributions.
(1) For each Plan Year, an Employee required to participate in the
Plan shall make regular contributions to the Plan in the amount of 8% of his
Compensation. Employee contributions withheld by the Employer on behalf of
the Employee shall be deposited with the Trustees at least monthly.
(2) The contributions made by each Employee under the Plan shall
be designated as Employer contributions pursuant to Section 414(h) of the
Internal Revenue Code. Such designation is contingent upon the contributions
being excluded from the Employees' gross income for federal income tax
purposes. For all other purposes of the Plan, such contributions shall be
considered Employee contributions.
I
!'
(b)
Employer Contributions.
(1) For each Plan Year, the Employer shall make contributions to the
Plan in an amount equal to
(A) 7% of the Compensation of all Employees participating in
the Plan; provided, however, that for the Plan Year beginning January 1,
1996, the Employer contribution to the Plan may be less than 7% (but in
no event less than 6%) of the Compensation of all Employees
participating in the Plan; plus
- (8) such additional amounts as may be required to satisfy the
Plan's funding requirements for the Plan Year and the cost of
administering the Plan, as determined by the actuary employed by the
Trustees.
(2) The amount described in subparagraph (1)(8) above may be
reduced by any available credit balance in accordance with applicable Florida
Statutes.
(c) Form and Timing of Contributions. Payments on account of the
contributions due from the Employer for any Plan Year shall be made in cash. Such
payments may be made by the Employer in accordance with the requirements of
applicable Florida Statutes.
'\
(d) Forfeitures. Any amount forfeited pursuant to the provisions of this
Plan shall be used In accordance with Section 1.401-7(a) of the Income Tax
, Regulations.
14
"-
~j,,~, '.
Section 2.397 Benefits Under the Plan
(a) Normal Retirement Benefit.
(1) A Participant shall be entitled to retire from the employ of his
Employer upon such Participant's Normal Retirement Date.
, ,
(2) Upon reaching his Normal Retirement Date, a Participant shall be
fully vested in his Accrued Benefit and shall be entitled to receive, at the time
and in the manner described in Article VillI his Normal Retirement Benefit.
Subject to the provisions of paragraph (e) of this Section 2.397:
(A) The Normal Retirement Benefit shall be a monthly income.
paid in accordance with the normal form of benefit described below, that'
is equal to the product of:
(i) 2.5% of the Participant's Average Monthly
Compensation, multiplied by .
(ii) the Participant's Years of Credited Service.
(B) Effective for Plan Years beginning on or after January 1.
1996, in the case of Employees who are performing active service on
behalf of the Employer on January 1. 1996, "2.75%" shall be substituted
for "2.5%" in subparagraph (A) above. An Employee will be deemed to
be performing active service if he is actively employed by the Employer
(working on a continuous basis), inclusive of light duty assignments
made by the Employer and the use of sick leave, vacation leave, military
leavet family medical leave, or other approved leaves of absence from
which the Employee is anticipated to return to regular duty. This
subparagraph (B) shall not apply to Employees who, as of January 1,
1996. no longer perform active service for the Employer but who remain
on the Employer's payroll and are compensated for a given period on
the basis of vacation time. sick leave. severance benefits or any other
type of leave of absence and whose employment with the Employer is
expected to terminate following such compensated period.
~
(3) (A) The normal form of benefit shall be an annuity paid
monthly for the life of the Participant. with a 100c/o survivor annuity paid
monthly for a period of five years following the death of the Participant
to the beneficiary or beneficiaries described in paragraph (e) of this
Section 2.397; provided, further. that following such five year period the
survivor annuity shall be reduced to 50% of the original survivor annuity
amount.
15
;',\
(B) The survivor annuity paid to the Participant's beneficiary or
beneficiaries in accordance with subparagraph (3)(A) above shall cease
following
(i) the last day of the mOl1th in which occurs the
designated beneficiary's death or remarriage, if such designated
beneficiary is the Participant's spouse, or
(ii) the last day of the month in which occurs the
designated beneficiary's death or attainment of age 18, if the
designated beneficiary is the Participant's child or children.
(4) In the event that a Participant does not begin to receive his
Normal Retirem-ent Benefit at his Normal Retirement Date, such Participant
shall be entitled to the benefit he was entitled to receive at his Normal
Retirement Date, adjusted to take into account his Average Monthly
Compensation and Years of Credited Service as of his actual retirement date.
t
(b) Earlv Retirement Benefit.
(1) A Participant shall be entitled to retire from the employ of his
Employer upon such Participant's Early Retirement Date.
(2) Upon reaching his Early Retirement Date, the Participant shall be
fully vested in his Accrued Benefit and shall be entitled to receive, at the time
and in the manner described in Section 2.398, his early retirement benefit.
(3) A Participant's early retirement benefit shall be determined in
accordance with the provisions of paragraph (a) above, and the amount of
such benefit shall be reduced to the Actuarial Equivalent of the benefit
otherwise payable under paragraph (a) above.
(4) If a Participant separates from service before satisfying the age
requirement for early retirement, but has satisfied the service requirement, the
Participant will be entitled to an early retirement benefit upon satisfaction of
such age requirement.
(0)
Disability Benefit.
\
(1) (A) A Participant who is vested in his Accrued Benefit and who
terminates employment by reason of his disability shall be entitled to
receive, at the time and in the manner described in Article VIII, a
disability benefit equal to his Accrued Benefit as of the date of
termination of his employment.
16
..
,\
(B) A Participant who is deemed by the C~mmittee and the
. Trustees to be disabled by reason of an injury suffered or an illness
contracted in the line of duty need not satisfy the vesting requirement
set forth in subparagraph (1)(A) above; providedt further, that the
monthly amount of the disability benefit payable to a Participant
described in this subparagraph (1 )(B) shall not be less than 66~2/3% of
such 'Participant's Average Monthly Compensation.
(C) The provisions of this paragraph (c) shall apply to
Participants who are determined by the Committee and Trustees to be
disabled on or after January 1, 1996.
j
I
I
.
~
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
(2) A Participant shall be considered disabled for purposes of the
Plan ift in the opinion of the Committee and the Trusteest the Participant is
disabled due to sickness or injury, such disability is likely to be continuous and
permanent from a cause other than specified in subparagraph (3) below, and
such disability renders the Participant unable to perform any useful, meaningful
and necessary work for the Employer in an' available position for which the
Participant is reasonably qualified or for which the Participant may be
reasonable trained to perform, subject t9 the limitations below.
(A) If a Participant employed as a sworn and state certified (in
accordance with Section 943.1395, Florida Statutes) police officer
(Police Recruit, Police Officer, Police Sergeant, Police Lieutenant, Police
Captain, Assistant or Deputy Chief or comparable sworn and state
certified positions) or a state certified (in accordance with Section
633.35, Florida Statutes) firefighter (Firefighter, Fire Lieutenant, District
Fire Chief, Assistant or Deputy Chief or comparable state certified
positions) is disabled to the extent that he cannot reasonably continue to
perform the functions of his specific position, but remains capable of
performing useful, meaningful and necessary work, he may be assigned
to an alternate position with the Employer as described below in lieu of
receiving disability benefits under the Plan.
(i) If an available equal level position is available in the
police or fire department respectively, the Participant may be
assigned to such position within the respective department, such
assignment to be with no loss of base pay (as described below);
or
'\
(ii) If no equal level position is available in the police or
fire department respectively, as referred to in subparagraph (i)
above, the Participa'nt may be assigned to another sworn and/or
state certified position in the respective department, if such
17
-
-
"I
position is available, such assignment to be with no loss of base
pay regardless of whether the assignment is to an equal or lower
level position; or
(iii) If a position is not available pursuant to
subparagraph (i) or (ii) above, the Participant may be assigned to
a non.sworn and/or non.state certified position within the
respective department, if such position is available, with such
assignment to be with no loss of base pay regardless of whether
the assignment is to a non.sworn and/or non.state certified
position of equal or lower level; or
"I
I
(iv) If an assignment cannot be made pursuant to
subparagraph (i). (ii) or (Hi) above, the Participant may be
assigned to any other position with the Employer that is available
for which the Participant has the skill and knowledge to perform
or for which the Participant can reasonably be trained to perform,
such assignment to be with n6 loss of base pay regardless of
whether the assignment to such position is at an equal or lower
level.
(B) If a Participant employed in a position other than as a
sworn and state certified police officer or a state certified firefighter is
disabled to the extent that he can not reasonably continue to perform
the functions of his specific position, but remains capable of performing
useful, meaningful and necessary work, he may be assigned to an
alternate position with the Employer in lieu of receiving disability benefits
under the Pla'n. For this purpose, the Participant may be assigned to
any other position with the Employer that is available for which the
Participant has the skill and knowledge to perform or for which the
Participant can reasonably be trained to perform, such assignment to be
with no loss of base pay regardless of whether the assignment to such
position is at an equal or lower level.
(C) For purposes of this paragraph (c)(2). the term "base pay"
shall be defined as compensation at the rate prescribed for the
particular: job class in -the Employer's pay schedule.
'\
!.Q1 Any hazardous duty desiQnated Plan Participant who is
assigned to an alternate position in lieu of receivinQ disability benefits
under the Plan pursuant to provisions of paragraph (c) (2) (A) of
Section 2.397 of this Plan shall continue to be designated as a
hazardous duty employee regardless of the nature or location of the
alternate assiQnment. Such Participant shall remain eliqible for
18
l" -, ~.I.
retirement as a hazardous duty emplovee.
!.El The Trustees of the Plan shall make the determination in
each instance if a Participant who has been found disabled pursuant to
paragraph (c) (2) above may be assiQned to an alternate position with
the Employer as provided in (c) (2) (A) and (8) hereof,
(3) (A) Each Participant who is claiming disability benefits shall
establish, to the satisfaction of the Committee. that such disability was
not occasioned primarily by:
(i) excessive or habitual use of any drugs. intoxicants,
or alcohol;
(Ii) injury or disease sustained while willfully and
illegally participating in fights. riots or civil insurrections;
(iii) injury or disease' sustained while committing a crime;
(iv) injury or disease sustained while selVing in any
branch of the Armed Forces; _
(v) injury or disease sustained after his employment as
an Employee with the Employef shall have terminated;
(vi) willful, wanton or gross negligence of the Participant;
or
(vii) injury or disease sustained by the Participant while
working for anyone other than the Employer and arising out of
such employment.
'\
(8) No Participant shall be entitled to a disability benefit,
whether in line of duty or not in line of duty, because of or due to the
aggravation of a specific injury, impairment or other medical condition
pre-existing the Employee's participation in the Plan; provided, however.
that such pre-existing condition and its relationship to a latei injury.
impairment or other medical condition is established by competent
substantial evidence. Nothing herein shall be construed to preclude a
disability benefit for a Participant who, after commenci,ng participation in
the Plan suffers an injury, impairment or other medical condition
different from some other injury, impairment, or other medical condition
existing at or prior to participation in the Plan.
(4) (A) A Participant shall not become eligible fOf disability benefits
19
until and unless he undergoes a physical examination by a qualified
physician or physicians, who shall be selected by the Committee "for that
purpose.
(B) (i) Any former Participant receiving disability benefits
under provisions of this Plan may be periodically re.examined by
a qualified physician or physicians who shall be selected- by the
Committee to determine if such disability has ceased to exist or if
the former Participant may be employed in an available position
for which the Participant is reasonably qualified in accordance
with the provisions in paragraph (c)(2) above. If the Committee
finds that the former Participant is no longer disabled or is
capable of performing service for the Employer in accordance
with the provisions of subparagraph (2) above, the Committee
may request the former Participant to return to the employ of the
Employer. (f the former Participant returns to the performance of
duty as an Employee. he shall again be eligible to participate in
the Plan. In the event a former Participant is no longer disabled
or is deemed capable of returning to employment with the
Employer in accordance with the provisions of subparagraph (2)
aboveJ and he does not return to employment with the Employer
pursuant to the CommitteeJs request, he shall forfeit the right to
his disability benefit; provided further, that if an Employee accepts
employment with another employer in an occupation or line of
work similar to the occupation or line of work that resulted in the
Employee being eligible for a disability benefit hereunder, he shall
forfeit the right to his disability benefit.
(ii) A Participant who returns to employment with the
Employer and recommences participation in the Plan shall not
receive credited service for the period during which he received
disability benefits under the Plan.
~
(C) The cost of the physical examination and/or re-examination
of the Employee claiming and/or receiving disability benefits shall be
borne by the Pial). All other reasonable costs as determined by the
Committee incident to the physical examination, such as. but not limited
to, transportation and mealst shall be borne by the Plan.
(D) The Committee may establish such other rules and
procedures as it deems necessary to implement the provisions of this
paragraph (c).
(5) A Participant whose employment is terminated by reason of his
20
-
"\...... ,.,.
"
death in the line of duty shallt for purposes of the Plant be deemed to have
been disabled in the line of duty, and the Participant's beneficiary shall be
entitled to receive a disability benefit as described in paragraph (c){1) above.
(6) If a Participant receives a disability benefit under the Plan and
.workers' compensation benefits pursuant to Florida Statute Chapter 440 for the
same disability t and the total monthly benefits received from both exceed
100% of the Participant's average monthly waget as defined in Chapter 440,
Florida Statutes, excluding overtimet the disability benefit shall be reduced so
that the total monthly amount received by the Participant dos not exceed 100%
of such wage. The amount of any lump sum workers' compensation payment
shall be converted to an equivalent monthly benefit payable for ten years
certain by dividing the lump sum amount by 83.9692.
(d) Termination of Employment Benefit.
(1) In the event a Participant's employment with his Employer is
terminated for reasons other than retirement, disability or death, such
Participant shall be entitled to receive. at the time and in the manner described
in Section 2.398, a termination of employment benefit that is equal to the
Participant's vested interest in his Accrued Benefit as of the date of his
termination of employment.
. (2) (A) A Participant's vested interest in his Accrued Benefit shall
be the following percentage of his Accrued Benefit, based upon such
Participant's full Years of Credited Service as of the date of his
termination of employment:
TOTAL NUMBER OF FULL
YEARS OF CREDITED SERVICE
VESTED
INTEREST
Less than 10 Years of Credited Service
10 years or more
0%
100%
(B) Notwithstanding the foregoing schedule, a Participant shall be
fully vested in his Accrued Benefit upon attaining his Early Retirement Date or his
Normal Retirement Date.
(3) A Participant who terminates employment with the Employer prior
tq his Early Retirement Date or his Normal Retirement Date may elect to
rsceive the total contributions he has made to the Plant together with 5%
simple interest .on such contributions. Upon making such election, the
Participant's interest in his Accrued Benefit shall be forfeited.
21
~~'. . .... , ~
(4) If a Participant terminates employment prior to his Early
Retirement Date or his Normal Retirement Date and receives a "distribution of
his contributions (plus interest thereon) and is sUbsequently reemployed and
again becomes a Participant in this Plan, his credited service for purposes of
vesting and benefit accruals shall not include any periods of employment prior
to his reemployment date unless he repays to the Pension Fund the greater of
(i) the full amount previously distributed to him plus interest at the rate of 5%
per annum from the date of distribution to the date of repayment or (ii) the
actuarial present value" of the Accrued Benefit previously forfeited. Such
repayment must be made no later than the second anniversary of the
Participant's reemployment. If a Participant repays the foregoing amount to
the Pension Fund within the prescribed time period, the interest of the
Participant in his Accrued Benefit previously forfeited under subparagraph (3)
above shall be restored in full and the Participant's credited service shall be
based on all periods of employment.
(e) Death Benefit.
(1) (A) (i) In the event of the death of a Participant who is
vested in his Accrued Benefit prior to his termination of
employment, his beneficiary (as described below) shall be entitled
to receive a death benefit at the time and in the manner
described in Section 2.398. Said death benefit shall be in an
amount equal to the Accrued Benefit of such Participant as of the
date of his death.
(ii) The Participant's beneficiary may elect to receive, in
lieu of the death benefit under the Plan, the total contributions
made by the Participant to the Plan, together with 5% simple
interest on such contributions. Upon making such election, the
Participant's beneficiary shall forfeit any right to a death benefit
under the Plan.
(iii) If the Participant does not have a beneficiary. the
total contributions made by the Participant to the Plan, together
wittl 5% simple interest on such contributions, shall be paid to the
Participant's estate.
\
(8) In the event of the death of a Participant who is not vested
in his Accrued Benefit prior to his termination of employment, his
beneficiary (or, ifthere is no beneficiary, his estate) shall be entitled to
receive the total contributions made by the Participant to the Plan,
together with 5% simple interest on such contributions.
22
(2) A Participant whose employment is terminated by reason of his
death in the line of duty shall be deemed. for purposes of the Plan, to have
been disabled in the line of duty and his benefit shall be determined in
accordance with paragraph (c)(5) of this Section 2.397.
(3) The Participant's surviving spouse shall be deemed to be the
beneficiary designated to receive the death benefit payable under the Plan,
and if none, his children under the age of 18 who are the Participant's
dependents (within the meaning of Section 152 of the Internal Revenue Code)
at the time of his death.
i"
(4) If the total contributions made by the Participant to the Plan,
together with 5% simple interest on such contributions, exceed the value of the
death benefit paid under the Plan, the amount by which such contributions
(inclUding interest thereon) exceed the value of the death benefit paid under
the Plan shall be paid to the Participant's estate.
(1) (A) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Section 2.397 to
the contrary, the projected benefit for a Participant (under this Plan and
under all other defined benefit plans maintained by the Employer,
whether or not terminated) when expressed as a benefit payable
annually in the form of a straight life annuity without regard to the death
benefit or any other ancillary benefit, shall not at any time within the
Limitation Year exceed the lesser of
I
~
,
t
I
:
J
\
j
I
j
1
,
(f) Limitations on Amount of Benefits.
(i) $90,000 (adjusted under such regulations as may be
issued by the Secretary of Treasury): or
(ii) 100% of the Participant's Average Monthly
Compensation.
(8) Notwithstanding the foregoing, the benefit payable with
respect to a Participant shall be deemed not to exceed the limitations
set forth in subparagraph (1) if the benefit payable with respect to such
Participant under this Plan and under all other defined benefit pension
plans to which the Employer contributes, does not exceed $10,000 for
the applicable Plan Year and for any Plan Year and the Employer has
not at any time maintained a defined contribution plan in which the
Participant participated.
\
(C) The limitations in subparagraphs (1)(A)(i), (1)(A)(ii) and
(1 )(B) above, shall be multiplied by a fraction (not in excess of one). the
23
.~
.
numerator of which is the m.imber of the Participant's years of
participation in the Plan (in the case of the dollar limitation set forth in
subparagraph (1 ) (A)(i)) or the number of the Participant's Years of
Credited Service (in the case of the limitation set forth in (1)(A)(ii) and
(1)(B) ) and the denominator of which, in either case. is 10.
(0) As of January 1 of each calendar year, the $90,000
limitation set forth in subparagraph (1 )(A)(i) above, shall be adjusted as
and if permitted by the Secretary of the Treasury, and any such
adjusted limitation shall become effective as the maximum dollar
limitation under the Plan for that calendar year. The maximum dollar
limitation for a calendar year, as so adjusted, shall apply to limitation
Years ending with or within such calendar year.
(E)
(i) a. In the event the Participant's retirement
benefits become payable before age 62, the $90,000
limitation set forth in subparagraph (1 )(A)(i) above shall be
reduced in accordance' with regulations issued by the
Secretary of the Treasury, but not below $75.000.
"
b. In the event the Participant's retirement
benefits become payable before age 55, the $90,000
limitation set forth in subparagraph (1 )(A)(i) above shall be
reduced in accordance with regulations issued by the
Secretary of the Treasury, but not below the actuarial
equivalent of $75,000 at age 55.
c. In no event shall the limitation set forth in
subparagraph (1)(A)(i) above be reduced to an amount
less than $50.000 (indexed in accordance with the Internal
Revenue Code) in the case of police or firefighters who are
qualified participants as defined in Section 415(b )(2)(H) of
the Internal Revenue Code.
\
(ii) If the Participant's retirement benefit becomes
payable after age 65. for purposes of determining whether the
benefit meets the $90,000 limitation set forth in subparagraph
(1 )(A)(ii) above. such benefit shall be adjusted so that it is
actuarially equivalent to the benefit beginning at age 65. This
adjustment shall be made using an assumed interest rate of five
percent (5%) and shall be made in accordance with regulations
promulgated by the Secretary of the Treasury.
(F) (I)
In the event that any Participant participates in both
24
a defined benefit plan and a defined contribution plan maintained
by his Employer or an Affiliate thereof, then the sum of the
Defined Benefit Plan Fraction (as defined in Section 415(e) of the
Internal Revenue Code) and the Defined Contribution Plan
Fraction (as defined in Section 415(e) of the Internal Revenue
Code) for any Limitation Year shall not exceed 1.0.
(ii) In the event that the sum of the Defined Benefit
Plan Fraction and the Defined Contribution Plan Fraction exceeds
1.0, then the Plan Administrator shall take such actions, applied
in a uniform and nondiscriminatory manner, as will keep the
benefits and Annual Additions for such Participants from
exceeding these limits. Adjustments shall be made to this Plan
before any adjustments shall be required to any other plans.
1
i
I
l
),
1
~
1
i
(2) This subparagraph (2) shall apply to the amount of Benefit (as
such term is described below) under this Plan for any Participant who is
considered a Restricted Participant (as such term is _ described below). Such
Benefit shall be limited to an amount equal to the payments that would have
been made on behalf of the Restricted Participant under a life annuity form of
payment that is the Actuarial Equivalent of the Restricted Participant's Accrued
Benefit under the Plan.
, (A) For purposes of this subparagraph (2), the term "Benefit"
shall include retirement income provided by the Plan. plus loans in
excess of the amounts set forth in Section 72(p)(2)(A) of the Internal
Revenue Code, any periodic income, any withdrawal values payable to
a living Participant and any" death benefits not provided for by insurance
on the Participant's life.
(B) For purposes of this subparagraph (2), the term "Restricted
Participant" shall mean all Highly Compensated Employees. In anyone
Plan Year, the total number of Participants whose benefits are subject to
restriction under this subparagraph (2) shall be limited by the Plan to a
group of not less than 25 Highly Compensated Employees with the
greatest Compensation.
'\
(C) Notwithstanding the foregoing, the limitations set forth in
this subparagraph (2) shall not restrict the current payment of the full
amount of retirement income provided by the Plan if:
(i) after payment to a Restricted Participant of all of the
Benefit described above, the value of Plan assets equals or
exceeds 100% of the value of current liabilities. as defined in
25
~~l:: :-::
or, <. '
.'. "
t":'
'.- .
.' ,.'
.~. ..
~ "i,
, :,'
. ~<' .
~~. '
~""-'''""
,,"
~:
l,' , "
,:'
r'
~; :
': .
;r.' .
,
'c"
, "
~. ... '
:1: .
~ ': ~
, c
~'" ," .
!. ~ c
F'
11.1 :;
"".,:
; ~: c
,
,"
i. 'c
',I' ,
"
'~ '
:,,: :
) . ' " , . .' "( ""; ..... "',
. . ". .
:..
\
.. c . . ~
. .
,
, <"
1
; !
Section 412(1)(7) of the Internal Revenue Code, or
(ii) the value of the Benefit described above for a
Restricted Participant is less than 1 % of the value of current
- liabilities, as"defined in Section 412(1)(7) of the Internal Revenue
, Code.
26
Section 2.398 Time and Manner of Benefit Payments
(a) Time for Distribution of Benefits.
(1) Except as otherwise provided under this Article VIII:
(A) (i) The amount of the Normal Retirement Benefit to which a
Participant is entitled under paragraph (a) of Section 2.397 shall
commence as of the end of the month that next follows the month in
which the Participant terminates employment on or after his Normal
Retirement Date, continuing as of the last day of each month thereafter
during his lifetime and the lifetime of his beneficiary, if any; (ii) No
payment shall be made with respect to the month in which Participant
terminates employment on or after his Normal Retirement Date;
provided, howevef, that a full monthly payment will be made for the
month in which the Participant or his beneficiary dies.
(B)(i) The amount of the early retirement benefit to which a
Participant is entitled under paragraph (b) of Section 2.397 shall
commence as of. the end of the month that next follows the month in
which the Participant terminates employment on Of after his Early
Retirement Date and elects to receive an early retirement benefit,
continuing as of the last day of each month thereafter during his lifetime
and the lifetime of his beneficiary, ifany; (ii) No payment shall be made
with respect to the month in which the Participant terminates
employment on or after has Early Retirement Date; provided, however,
that a full monthly paym~nt will be made for the month in the Participant
or his beneficiary dies.
I
,
I
I
!
l
\
~
I
i
I
l
I
!
I
I
,
I
i
'I
\
(C)(i) The amount of the disability benefit to which a Participant
is entitled under paragraph (c) of Section 2.397 shall commence as of
the end of the month that next follows the later of (1) the month in which
a determination is made as to the Participant's disability or (2) the
month in which the Participant terminates employment, continuing as of
the last day of each month thereafter during his lifetime and the lifetime
of his beneficiary, if any; (ii) No payment shall be made with respect to
the month in which a determination is made as to the Participant's
disability or the month in which the Participant terminates employment;
provided, however. that a full monthly payment will be made for the
month in which the Participant or his beneficiary dies.
(D)" The amount of the termination of employment benefit to
which a Participant is entitled under paragraph (d) of Section 2.397 shall
commence as of the earlier of (1) the end of the month that next follows
27
i "
!
the month in which the Participant attains his Early Retirement Date (or
would have attained his Early Retirement Date if he had continued in the
employ of the Employer until his Early Retirement Date) or (2) the end
of the month that next follows the month in which the Participant attains
his Normal Retirement Date (or would have attained his Normal
. Retirement Date if he had continued in the employ 9f the Employer until
his Normal Retirement Date), continuing as of the last day of each
month thereafter during his lifetime and the iifetime of his beneficiary. if
any; (ii) No payment"shall be made with respect to the month in which
the Participant attains his Early Retirement (or would have attained his
Early Retirement Date if he had continued in the employ of the
Employer until his Early Retirement Date) or his Normal Retirement Date
(or would have attained his Normal Retirement Date if he had continued
in the employ of the Employer until his Normal Retirement Date);
provided. however, that a full monthly payment will be made for the
month in which the Participant or his beneficiary dies.
(E) The death benefit payable to a Participant's beneficiary
under paragraph (e) of Section 2.397 shall commence as of the end of
the month that next follows the month in which the Participant dies,
continuing as of the last day of each month thereafter during the lifetime
of his beneficiary; (ii) No payment shall be made with respect to the
month in which the Participant dies; provided, however, that a full
monthly payment will be made for the month in which the beneficiary
dies.
(2) Notwithetanding anything contained herein to the contraryt any
distribution paid to a Participant (or, in the case of a death benefitj to his
beneficiary or beneficiarIes) pursuant to subparagraph (1) shall commence not
later than the last to occur of:
I-
I
(A) April 1 of the year following the calendar year in which the
Participant retires on or after his Early Retirement Date or his Normal
Retirement Date; or
!"
_ (B) April 1 of the year immediately following the calendar year
in which the Participant reaches age 70w1/2.
(b)
Manner of Payment.
'\
(1) (A) The manner of payment of a Participant's retirement,
disability or termination of employment benefit shall be the normal form
of payment described in paragraph (a)(3) of Section 2.397.
28
~~.:.':J .
(B) The manner of payment of a Participant's death benefit
shall be the n"ormal form of survivor annuity payment described in
paragraph (a)(3) of Section 2.397.
["
I"
I-
(2) (A) In lieu of the normal form of payment described in
subparagraph (1 HA) above, a Participant's retirement, disability or
termination of employment benefit may be paid in one of the following
optional forms as elected by the Participant. The optional forms, which
shall be the Actuarial Equivalent of the benefit that would otherwise be
paid to the Participant, are as follows:
(i) Monthly income payments for the life of the
P articipa nt.
.
1
:
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
!
(ii) Monthly income payments for a 10 years certain and
life thereafter, under which the Participant receives payments
during his lifetime and, if he dJes after he has begun to receive
payments but before he has received 120 payments, the
remaining payments shall be made to his designated beneficiary;
provided, further, that if the designated beneficiary predeceases
the Participant, the Participant may designate a new beneficiary
to receive any payments due after his death. If the Participant
does not designate a new beneficiary, the payments required
under this option following the Participant's death shall be paid to
the Participant's estate. If the designated beneficiary begins to
receive payments under this option and such designated
beneficiary" dies before the end of the 10-year period, the
remaining payments shall be paid to the designated beneficiary's
estate.
(iii) Monthly income payments for the life of the
Participant and. after his death, a survivor annuity payable for the
life of the Participant's designated beneficiary equal to 100%,
75% or 50% of the amount payable to the Participant.
(B) Each Participant shall have the right to designate a
" beneficiary for purposes of the optional forms of benefit payment
described in this paragraph and to revoke any such designation. Each
designation or revocation shall be evidenced by written instrument filed
with the Committee and shall be effective upon filing with the
Committee.
~
(3) "In the case of a retirement. disability or termination of
employment benefit, in no event shall payment extend beyond the life or life
29
t~. ..'
expectancy of the Participant or the joint lives or life expectancies of the
Participant and his designated beneficiary. If the Participant dies before
receiving the entire amount payable to him, the balance shall be distributed to
his designated beneficiary at least as rapidly as under the method being used
prior to the Participant's death."
(4) In the case of a death benefit, payment
(A) to the designated beneficiary shall begin within one year
following the Participant's death (unless the designated beneficiary is
the Participant's spouse, in which case such benefit shall begin no later
thqn the date the Participant would have reached 70~1/2) and shall not,
in any event, extend beyond the life or life expectancy of the designated
beneficiary; or
(B) to any other beneficiary shall be totally distributed within
five years from the date of the Participant's death.
.
I
" ~
,
~
~
!
j
,
I
1
r
I
I
(5) The Participant (or his spouse) shall not be permitted to elect
whether life expectancies will be recalculated for purposes of distributions
hereunder.
(6) Notwithstanding the foregoing, payments under any of the options
described in this paragraph shall satisfy the incidental death benefit
requirements and all other applicable provisions of Section 401 (a)(9) of the
Internal Revenue Code, the regulations issued thereunder (including Prop.
Reg. Section 1.401 (a)(9)~2), and such other rules thereunder as may be
prescribed by the Secretary of the Treasury.
(7) The Committee may purchase and distribute a nontransferable
and nonrefundable annuity contract to provide any benefit under the Plan paid
in the form of an annuity.
(c) Lumo Sum Payment. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Plan
to the contrary. any benefit payable under the Plan, the actuarial lump sum present
value of which is not more than $3,500, shall be paid in a lump sum as soon as
practicable follOWing the Participant's termination of employment.
(d) No Payment Unless Sufficient Funds. No benefits shall be paid under
this Plan unless at the time of such benefit payment the Pension Fund has sufficient
assets to pay such benefits; provided, that in the event the assets in the Pension
Fund are not sufficient to pay the benefit amounts due under the Plan, the Employer
shall make additional contributions to the Plan pursuant to paragraph (b) of Section
2.396.
30
.'
...':10,,:....
"
(e) Direct Rollovers.
(1) Notwithstanding any provisions of the Plan to the contrary that
would otherwise limit a distributee's (as defined below) election under this paragraph,
a distributee may elect, at the time and in the manner prescribed by the. Committee,"
to have any portion of an eligible rollover distribution (as defined below) paid directly
to an eligible retirement plan (as defined below) specified by the distributee in a direct
rollover (as defined below).
(2) For purposes of this paragraph, the following terms shall have the
following meanings;
(A) An "eligible rollover distributionll is any distribution of all or any
portion of-the balance to the credit of the distributee, except that an
eligible rollover distribution does not include; any distribution that is one
of a series of substantially equal periodic payments (not less frequently
than annually) made for the life (or life expectancy) of the distributee or
the joint lives (or joint life exp~ctancies) of the distributee and the
distributee's designated beneficiary, or for a specified period of ten
years or more; any distribution to the extent such distribution is required
under Internal Revenue Code Section 401 (a)(9), and the portion of any
distribution that is not includible in gross income (determined without
regard to the exclusion, for net unrealized appreciation with respect to
employer securities).
" i
(B) An "eligible retirement plan" is an individual retirement account
described in Code Section 408(a), an individual retirement annuity
described iii Internal Revenue Code Section 408(b), an annuity plan
described in Internal Revenue Code Section 403(a), or a qualified trust
described in Internal Revenue Code Section 401 (a), that accepts the
distributees distribution to the surviving spouse, an eligible retirement
plan is an individual retirement account or individual retirement annuity.
(C) A "distributee" includes an Employee or former Employee. In
addition, the Employee's or former Employee's surviving spouse and the
Employee's or former Employee's spouse or former spouse who is the
alternate payee under a qualified domestic relations order, as defined in
Internal Revenue Code Section 414(p), are distributees with regard to
the interest of the spouse or former spouse.
'\ (0) A "direct rollover" is a payment by the Plan tot he eligible
retirement plan specified by the distributee.
31
I
":"'"~ '-~', . .'
.1. .c.,"
I
Section 2.399 Establishment and Operation of Pension Fund
(a) Establishment of Fund.
(1) As part of the Plan, there is hereby established the Pension
Fund, into which shall be deposited all of the contributions and assets
whatsoever attributable to the Plan.
(2) The Pension Fund shall be held in trust by the Trustees and the
Trustees shall be vested with full legal title to the Pension Fund; provided,
further, that the actual custody and "supervision of the Pension Fund shall be
vested in the Trustees.
(3) The assets of the Pension Fund may be deposited by the
Trustees with an official designated by the Employer. acting in a ministerial
capacity only I who shall be liable in the same manner and to the same extent
as he is liable for the safekeeping of funds for the Employer. However, any
assets so deposited with the designated official of the Employer shall be kept
in a separate fund or clearly identified as assets of the Pension Fund. In lieu
thereof, the Trustees may deposit the funds of the Pension Fund in a qualified
public depository as defined in Section 280.02, Florida Statutes. which
depository with regard to such assets shall conform to and be bound by all of
the provisions of Chapter 280, Florida Statutes.
(b) Records. All assets attributable to the Plan may be commingled in the
Pension Fund, provided that accurate records are maintained at all times reflecting
the financial composition of the Pension Fund, inCluding accurate current accou~ts
and entries as regards the following:
(1) current amounts of accumulated contributions of Employees on
an individual account basis;
(2) receipts and disbursements;
(3) benefit payments;
(4) all interest, dividends and gains (or losses); and
(5) such other entries as may be properly required so as to reflect a
clear and complete financial report of the Pension Fund.
"!.
32
i. "'~.-'.
(c) Powers and Duties of Trustees. The Trustees may:
(1) Invest and reinvest the assets of the Pension Fund in annuity
(including group annuity contracts of the pension investment type) and life
insurance contracts of legal reserve life insurance companies licensed to do
business in the State of Florida, in amounts sufficient to provide, in whole or In
part, benefits to which all of the Participants shall be or become entitled under
the provisions of the Plan, and pay the initial and subsequent premiums
thereon.
(2) Invest and reinvest the assets of the Pension Fund in:
(A) Time or savings accounts of a national bankl a state bankl
or a savings, building and loan association insured by the Federal
Deposit Insurance Corporation.
(B) Obligations of the United States Treasury and agencies
allied with or related to the United States Treasury.
(C) County bonds containing a pledge of the full faith and
credit of the county involved. bonds of the Florida development
commission, or of any other state agency, which have been approved as
to legal and fiscal sufficiency by the state board of administration.
(D) Obligations of any municipal authority issued pursuant to
the laws of this state; provided, however. that for each of the five years
n~xt preceding the date of investment, the income of such authority
available for fixed charges shall have been not less than one and one-
half (1-1/2) times its average annual fixed charge requirements over the
life of its obligations.
(E) Common stocks, preferred stocks and bonds and other
evidence of indebtedness issued or guaranteed by a corporation
organized under the laws of the United States, any state, or organized
territory of the United States or the District of Columbia or any
corporation international in character engaged in international business
and trade, provided:
~
(1) the corporation Is listed on anyone or more of the
fecognized national stock exchanges;
(ii) all corporate bonds shall carry a AA fating as
established either by Standard & Poor's, Moody's Of Fitch; and
33
(Hi) not more than three percent (3%) of the assets of
the Pension Fund shall be invested in the common stock or
capital stock of anyone issuing company nor shall the aggregate
investment anyone issuing company exceed one per cent (1 %)
of the outstanding capital stock of that company; nor shall the
aggregate of the investments under this subparagraph at cost
exceed fifty percent (50%) of the Pension Fund's assets. "
(3) Cause any Pension Fund investment in securities to be
registered in or transferred into its name as Trustee or into the name of
such nominee as it may direct, or it may retain them unregistered and in
form permitting transferability, but the books and records shall at all
times show that all investments are part of the Pension Fund.
(4) Vote upon any stocks; bonds. or securities of any
corporation, association; or trust and give general or specific proxies or
powers of attorney with or without power of substitution; participate in
mergers; reorganizations, recapitalizations, consolidations, and similar
transactions with respect to such securities; deposit such stock or other
securities in any voting trust or any protective or like committee with the
Trustees or with depositories designated thereby; amortize or fail to
amortize any part or all of the premium or discount resulting from the
acquisition or disposition of assets; and generally exercise any of the
powers of an owner with respect to stocks, bonds, or other investments
comprising the Pension Fund which it may deem to be to the best
interest of the Pension Fund to exercise.
(5) Retain in cash and keep unproductive of income such
amount of the Pension Fund as it may deem advisable, having regard
for the cash requirements of the Plan.
(6) Retain the services of a custodian bank, an investment
advisor registered under Investment Advisors Act of 1940 or otherwise
exempt from such required registration, an insurance company, or a
combination of these, for the purposes of investment decisions and
management. Such investment manager shall have discretion; subject
to any guidelines as prescribed by the Trustees," in the investment of all
Pension Fund assets.
(d) Prudent Man Rule. The Trustees of this Plan and all other persons
occupying a fiduciary position under this Plan in the administration of this Plan ,and in
investing and reinvesting assets of the Pension Fund shall utilize and be governed by
the prudent man rule.
34
.
(e) Receipt of Information. Where any action which the Trustees are
required to take or any duty or function which they are required to perform either
under the terms herein or under the general law applicable to the Trustees under this
Plan can reasonably be taken or performed only after receipt by the Trustees from a
Participant, the Employer, or any other entity, of specific information. certification,
direction or instructions, the Trustees shall be free of liability in failing to take such
action or perform such duty or function until such information, certification, direction
or Instruction has been received by it.
(f) Overpayments and Underpayments. Any overpayments or
underpayments from the Pension Fund to a Participant or beneficiary caused by
errors of computation shall be adjusted with interest at a rate per annum approved by
the Trustees. Overpayment shall be charged against payments next succeeding the -
correction. Underpayments shall be made up from the Pension Fund.
(g) Appointment of AQents. Any of the foregoing powers and functions
reposed in the Trustees may be performed or carried out by the Trustees through
duly authorized agents, provided that the Trustees at all times maintain continuous
supervision over the acts of any such agent; provided further, that legal title to the
Pension Fund shall always remain in the Trustees.
(h) Independent Audit. An independent audit shall be performed annually
by a certified public accountant for the most recent fiscal year of the Employer. Such
report shall reflect items normally included in a certified audit.
(i) Expenses of Administration.
(1) (A) The assets of the Pension Fund may be used to pay all "
expenses of the administration of the Plan and the Pension Fund I
including the compensation of any investment manager, the expense
incurred by the Trustees or the Committee in discharging its duties, all
income or other taxes of any kind whatsoever that may be levied or
assessed under existing or future laws upon or in respect of the Pension
Fund I and any interest that may be payable on money borrowed by the
Trustees for the purpose of the Pension Fund. as well as any
settlements or judgments entered with respect to the Plan.
(B) The Employer may pay the expenses of the Plan and the
Pension Fund. Any such payment by the Employer shall not be deemed
a contribution to this Plan.
\
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained herein to the contrary, no
excise tax or other liability imposed upon the Trustees or any other person for
failure to comply with the provisions of any federal law shall be subject to
35
.' \
, "
","
:r.U4~.....~.... I _ .
. ,., . .. .,' ",.
I"
payment or reimbursement from the assets of the Pension Fund.
(3) No individual Trustee or Committee member shall be entitled to
compensation from the Trust (except for the reimbursement of expenses
properly ~nd actually incurred).
, ",
"
I)
'\
36
Section 2.400 Amendment and Termination
(a) Amendment of Plan. The City Commission of the Employer shall have
cO,ntinuous power to amend this Plan in whole or in part; providedt however. that no
such amendment, except as permitted by law:
(1) shall become effective until and unless it is ratified by a majority
of the qualified electors of the City of Clearwater voting either in a general
election or in a special election called and held for the purpose of ratification or
rejection of the amendment; provided, however, that such ratification shall not
be required if the amendment is necessary to comply with applicable state or
federal law.
(2) shall have the effect of vesting in the Employer, directly or
indirectly any interest. ownership or control in any of the present or subsequent
assets held in the Pension Fund;
(3) shall cause or permit any property held subject to the terms of the
Pension Fund to be diverted for purposes other than the exclusive benefit of
the Participants and their beneficiaries; or
(4) shall reduce the then vested Accrued Benefit of any Participant.
(5) reduce or eliminate any benefit in pay status prior to the Effective
Date of the Plant except as otherwise prOVided under the terms of the Plan, prior to
the Effective Date of this amendment and restatement.
(b) Termination of Plan: Discontinuance of Contributions.
(1) This Plan may be terminated in whole or in part at any time by
"the Employer, provided. however, that termination shall not become effective
until and unless the decision to terminate is ratified bv a majority of the
Qualified electors of the City of Clearwater voting either in a Qeneral or a
special election called and held for the purpose of ratification or reiection of
Plan termination. .
(2) If this Plan is terminated, or if contributions to the Plan are
discontinued, the Trustees shall continue to administer the Plan in accordance
with the provisions of the Plan , for the sole benefit of the Participants and
t~eir beneficiaries. In the event of termination, or if contributions to the Plan
are discontinued, there "shall be full vesting of benefits accrued to the date of
termination and" the assets of. the Plan shall be allocated in an equitable
manner to provide benefits on a proportionate basis to the persons so entitled
37
/
I'
in accordance with the provisions thereof.
(3) The following shall be the order of priority for purposes of
allocating the assets of the Plan as of the date of termination or the
discontinuance of contributions, with the date of such discontinuance being
determined by the Trustees.
(A) Apportionment shall first be made with respect to each
Employee receiving a benefit hereunder on such date, each person
receiving a benefit on such date on account of a deceased Employee,
and each Employee who has, by such date, become eligible for a
normal retirement benefit but has not yet retired, in an amount which is
the actuarial equivalent of such benefit, based upon the actuarial
assumptions in use for purposes of the most recent actuarial valuation,
provided that, if such asset value is less than the aggregate of such
amounts, such amounts shall be proportionately reduced so that the
aggregate of such reduced amounts will be equal to such asset value.
.
(B) If there is any asset value remaining after the
apportionment under subparagraph (3)(A), apportionment shall next be
made with respect to each Employee in the service of the Employer on
such date who has completed at least ten Years of Credited Service and
who is not entitled to an apportionment under subparagraph (3)(A), in
the amount required to provide the actuarial equivalent as described In
subparagraph (3)(A) above, of the accrued Normal Retirement Benefit,
based on the credited service and Average Monthly Compensation as of
such date, and ~ach vested former Participant then entitled to a
deferred benefit who has not, by such date, begun receiving benefit
payments, in the amount required to provide said actuarial equivalent of
the accrued Normal Retirement Benefit, provided that, if such remaining
asset value is less than the aggregate of the amounts apportioned
hereunder, such latter amounts shall be proportionately reduced so that
the aggregate of such reduced amounts will be equal to such remaining
asset value.
"
(C) If there is any asset value after the apportionments .under
subparagraphs (3)(A) and (3)(8). apportionment shall be made with
respect to each Employee in the service of the Employer on such date
who is not entitled to an apportionment under subparagraphs (3)(A) and
(3)(8) in an amount equal to Participant's accumulated contributions,
provided that, if such remaining asset value is less than the aggregate
of the amounts apportioned hereunder such latter amount shall be
proportionately reduced so that the aggregate of such reduced amounts
will he equal to such remaining asset value.
38 .
~l;, -..
(D) If there is any asset value remaining after the
apportionments under subparagraphs (3)(A) , (3)(B), and (3)(e),
apportionment shall lastly be made with respect of each Employee
included in subparagraph (3)(C) above to the extent of the actuarial
equivalent, as described in subparagraph (3)(A) above, of the accrued
Normal Retirement Benefit, less the amount apportioned in
subparagraph (3)(C), based on the credited service and Average
Monthly Compensation as of such date, provided that, if such remaining
asset value is less than the aggregate of the amounts apportioned
hereunder, such amounts shall be reduced so that the aggregate of
such reduced amounts will be equal to such remaining asset value.
(E) In the event there is asset value remaining after the full
apportionment specified in subparagraphs (3)(A) , (3)(8), (3)(C) and
(3)(0), such excess shall be returned to the Employer.
(4) The allocation provided in suqparagraph (3) above may, as
decided by the Trustees. be carried out through the purchase of insurance
company contracts to provide the benefits determined in accordance with this
subparagraph (3). The Pension Fund may be distributed in one sum to the
persons entitled to said benefits or the distribution may be carried out in such
other equitable manner as the Trustees may direct. The Pension Fund may be
continued in existence for purposes of subsequent distributions.
(5) After all the vested Accrued Benefits provided hereunder have
been paid and after aU other liabilities have been satisfied, then and only then
shall any remaining amounts of the Pension Fund revert to the Employer.
Section 2.401 Miscellaneous
(a) Alienation. No Participant or beneficiary of a Participant shall have any
right to assign, transfer, appropriate, encumber, commute, anticipate or otherwise
alienate his interest in this Plan or the Pension Fund or any payments to be made
thereunder; no benefits, payments, rights or interests of a Participant or beneficiary of
a Participant of any kind or nature shall be in any way subject to legal process to levy
upon. garnish or attach the same for payment of any claim against the Participant or
beneficiary; and no Participant or beneficiary of a Participant shall have any right of
any kind whatsoever with respect to the Pension Fund t or any estate or interest
therein, ,or with respect to any other property or right, other than the right to receive
such diStributions as are lawfully made out of the Pension Fund, as and when the
same respectively are due and payable under the terms of this Plan.
(b) Effect on Other Plans. Nothing in this Plan shall be construed so as to
39
abridge, alter or in any way affect any of the rights or liabilities of an Employee of the
Employer under any other retirement plan in effect as of the Effective Date of this
Plan.
(c) Forfeiture of Benefits for Certain Offenses.
(1) Any Employee who is convicted of any of the following specified
offenses committed prior to retirement, or whose employment is terminated by
reason of his admitted commission, aid or abetment of any of the following .
specified offenses, shall forfeit all rights and benefits under this Pension Fund,
except for the return of his accumulated contributions as of the date of
termination.
(2) The specified offenses are as follows:
(A) The committing, aiding or abetting of an embezzlement of
public funds;
(B) The committing, aiding or abetting of any theft by a public
officer or Employee from the Employer;
(C) Bribery in connection with the employment of a public
officer or Employee;
(D) Any felony specified in Florida Statutes, Chapter 838
(except S838.15 and 9838.16);
(E) The committing of an impeachable offense; and
(F) The committing of any felony by a public officer or
Employee who willfully and with intent to defraud the public or the public
agency, for which he acts or in which he is employed, of the right to
receive the faithful performance of his duty as a public officer or
Employee, realizes or obtains, or attempts to obtain. a profit, gain, or
advantage for himself or for some other person through the use or
attempted use of the power, rights. privileges, duties or position of his
public office or employment position.
(3) For purposes of this paragraph, I1conviction" shall be defined as
"n adjudication of guilt by a court of competent jurisdiction; a plea of guilty or a
nolo contendere; a jury verdict of guilty when adjudication of guilt is withheld
and the accused is placed on probation; or a conviction by the Senate of an
impeachable offense. For this purpose, "court" shall be defined as any state or
federal court of competent jurisdiction which is exercising jts jurisdiction to
40
---
::. 1:' ~ .' ~
consider a proceeding involving the alleged commission of a specified offense.
" I
'I
I
(4) Prior to forfeiture, the Trustees shall hold a hearing in accordance
with Florida Statutes, Chapter 120 on which notice shall be given to the
Participant whose benefits are being considered for forfeiture.
(5) If a Participant whose benefits are forfeited pursuant to this
paragraph has received benefits from the Plan in excess of his contributions
without interest! such Participant shall be required to pay back to the Pension
Fund the amount"of the benefits received in excess of his contributions without
interest. The Trustees may implement all legal action necessary to recover
such funds.
(d) Indemnification.
(1) To the extent not covered by insurance contracts in force from
time to time! the Employer shall indemnify find hold harmless the Trustees and
the members of the Committee from all personal liability for damages and
costs, including court costs and attorneys' fees, arising out of claims, suits,
litigation ! or threat of same. herein referred to as "claimst\ against these
individuals because of acts or circumstances connected with or arising out of
their official duty as Trustees or members of the Committee. The Employer
reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to settle or not settle the claim at any
time! and to appeal or to not appeal from any adverse judgment or ruling. and
in either event will indemnify and hold harmless any Trustees or members of
the Committee from the judgment! execution, or levy thereon.
(2) This paragraph shall not be construed so as to relieve any
insurance company or other entity liable to defend the claim or liable for
payment of the judgment or claim, from any liability, nor does this paragraph
waive" any provision of law affording the Employer immunity from any suit in
whole or part. or waive any other substantive or procedural rights the Employer
may have.
(3) This paragraph shall not apply nor shall the Employer be
responsible in any manner to defend or pay for claims arising out of acts or
omissions of the Trustees or members of the Committee which constitute
felonies or gross malfeasance or gross misfeasance in office.
~) Uniformed Service.
(1) An Employee shall be credited with service for purposes of
vesting and benefit accruals for his service in the uniformed service (as
defined in the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act
41
of 1994 [the "Act"]) upon being granted leave by the Employer for such
unifofmed service and termination from employment as an Employee with the
Employer, provided that:
(A) the Participant must feturn to his employment as an
Employee with the Employer within the time periods prescribed by the
Act; and
(8) the Employee complies with the Employee contribution
requirements prescribed by Act.
(2) The maximum service credit fOf uniformed service shall be 5
years. or such other time period as may be prescribed by the Act.
Section 3. If any provision of this ordinance or any policy or order thereunder of the
application of such provision to any person Of circumstances shall be held invalid, the
remainder of this ordinance and the application of such provision of this ordinance or of such
policy or order to persons or circumstances other than those to which it is held invalid shall not
be affected by thefeby.
Section 4. A special election for the purpose of voting on the Amended Pension Plan as
set forth in this ordinance shall be conducted on October 24, 1995.
Section 5. The question to appear on the Referendum Ballot shall be as follows:
REVISED EMPLOYEE PENSION PLAN
Shall the Employee Pension Plan as adopted by Ordinance 5890-95, completely revising the
pension plan language; meeting the requirements of an IRS qualified plan; reducing disability
benefits; requiring return to work in lieu of disability benefits under certain circumstances;
revising the composition and authority of the Pension Advisory Committee; increasing
retirement benefit from 2.50% to 2.75% times years of service; providing optional benefit
payments; requiring 8% contribution of employees; and other changes be approved?
FOR
AGAINST
Section 6. , The funds contained in or authorized by the Pension Fund adopted by
Ordinance No. 1832 as subsequently amended shall be applied in furtherance of the
contributions and disbursements authorized pursuant to this ordinance, and the rights, duties
and obllgations provided in this ordinance shall apply to any fund subject to the provisions of
this ordinance; provided. however, that the preconditions set forth in Section 7 relating to this
ordinance becoming effective had been complied with.
42
~ . I
~~~( b'~'........... ..~. ,
. . ~ ~ ,
, ,:'.'
,
Section 7. This ordinance shall become effective on January 1, 1996. provided that
such Amended Pension Plan is approved by the majority of electors voting in the Referendum
on the issue at a ballot special election called for such purposes provided herein to be
conducted in the City of Clearwater, Florida, and upon the filing of this ordinance with the
Secretary of State to the extent either in whole or in part that is approved.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
CITY OF CLEARWATER, F~ORXDA
By:
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to for.m and
legal sufficiency:
;!L;j
Pamela K. Akin
City Attorney
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
I
'\
43
"t~4.~" . ~ , .
R -€..
C/V\ l ~
CITY OF CLEARWATER
Interdepartmental Correspondence Sheet
FROM:
Mayor and City Commissioncrs ~ _ ,/J
H. Michael Luursen. HUffinn Resources Diree'or:::LJ-/'7'kc~~-t-~
Bctty Dcptula, City Manager; Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager: Pam Akin,
City AUorney
10:
COPIES:
SUBJECf: Clarification Re: Proposed Pension Plan Concept
DATE:
August 8, 1995
One of the items included in the proposed Pension Plan is the concept of "carly
retirement." The purpose of this memo is to clarify the process of early rctiremcnt
and pension benefits.
The concept of providing an early retirement prOVISIon in the proposed Plan stcms
from a desire to correct an inequity perceived to exist in the current Plan. The
current Plan providcs that an employee with ten or more years of pension service
credit may separate from the City's employ, leave his/her pension contributions i n
the Plan, and begin to receive a pcnsion on what would have been his/her normal
retirement date had he/she remained a City employee. For example, an employee
might begin his/her City employment and Pension Plan participation at age 35, work
ten years, leave the City, and subsequently begin to coHect n pension ten years lnter
at age 55 (20 years of service at age 55 is a normal retirement date).
Although the process for employees hired at an older age under the current Plan is
the same as noted above, the ability to actually collect the pension becomes less likely
to occur. For example, an employec hired at age 60 could work tcn years and then
separate from employment. and begin collecting a pension at agc 80.
The early retirement concept in the proposed Pension Plan provides thut u n
employee may begin to receive a pension based on the completion of ten ycars 0 f
service and attainment of age 65 (without waiting for any additional number 0 f
years) with such bcnefit amount actuarially reduced:
Ex n In pie: Under the Plan (using 2.75% as the benefit multiplier in the
benefit computation formula), if an employee comes to work for the City at age
60 and terminates at age 70 (with ten years of service), the benefit would be
calculated as follows:
Assume Avcmge Earnings:
Yems of Service:
$30,000
10
Annual Benefit:
Monthly. Benefit:
$30,000 x 2.75% x 1 U = $81250
$8,250 ~ 12 = $687.50
Il
,< ,
~?~,f ',~o"
. J '~';:.: :.~'"
"
Mayor and City Commissioners
Page 2
August 8, 1995
~
I
I
!
This employee could bcgin recclvlng $687.50 per month beginning nt age 80
(ten years from separation). Under the proposed early retirement provIsIon,
the employee could still elect to receive the $687.50 per month beginning at
uge 80. Alternatively, however, the employee could elect to receive $208.45
per month immediately. This benefit is determined as shown below:
$687.50 x 30.32% := $208.45
The early retirement factor shown above (30.32%) is actuarially determined
based on the employee's current age and the number of years that hc/she is
receiving the' benefit early.
The actuarially equivalent percentage would vary 'year by year from age 70 to
age 80 consistent whh the age of the employee at termination and the number
of ,years he/she would receive the benefit early.
(Note: Actuarial number in the above example was provided by
Stephen M. Metz, Principal, Coopers & Lybrand.)
HML/dlf
','
" ., . ~ ., . .; .
b-......., '.
, ~ i;. ~",
(Z-e.
-: C /VI -:1- CITY
l(G
OF CLEARWATER
Interdepartmental Correspondence Sheet
10:
FROM:
Mayor and City Commissioners
, I
H. Michael Laursen, Human Resources
COPIES:
Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager; Pum
SUBJEct: Addendum and Corrections to the Proposed Pension Plan
DATE:
August 8, 1995
On July 31. 1995, at a City Commission Work Session, Deputy City Manager Kathy Rice
provided an overview of the proposed Pension Plan. At that presentation, Mrs. Rice
advised that several revisions would be made in the document based on a joint
meeting with the Union coalition held on the preceding Friday.
The changes to the proposed Pension Plan are summarized below, and a revised copy
of the Pension Plan is included with the agenda packet on Ordinance 5890-95 w h i c h
is scheduled for' Commission action on August 17, 1995.
Pension Plan Changes:
Page 3
Paragraph (c).
The sub~paragraph numbers listed under the definition of "Annual
Additions" is corrected to reflect (I) through (4) rather than (3)
through (6).
. Page 3
Paragraph (c)(4).
The words "or an Affiliate" in the third line are deleted.
Page 5
Paragraph (C).
In the second sentence, the word "beginning" IS added und the word
"after" is deleted.
Page 13 Paragraph (F).
Adds language: "Prepare und distribute to the participants
information relating to the Plun." (This is included as one of the
duties of the Pension Advisory Committee.)
I,
- "
.=i!, t~'c \
'~'.~\..:' '.' .
Mayor and City Commissioners
Page 2
August 8, 1995
Puge 22 Paragraph (c)(2). New !\ub-pnragmphs (D) and (E).
Sub-paragraph (D) to read: "Any hazardous duty designated Plan
Participant who is nssigned to an alternate position in lieu of
receiving disability benefits under the Plan pursuant to provisions
of paragraph (c)(2)(A) of Section 2.397 of this Phm shull continue to
be designated as a hazardous duty employee regardless of the n a t u re
or location of the alternative assignment Such Participant shall
remain eligible for retirement as a hazardous duty employee. tI
Sub-paragraph (E) to read: "The Trustees of the Plan shall make the
determination in each instance if a Participant who has been found
disabled pursuant to paragraph (c)(2) above may be assigned to an
alternative position with the Employer as provided in (c)(2){A) and
(D) hereof."
Page 35 New pamgraph (e) to read as follows:
(c) Direct Rollovcrs.
\.
(I) Notwithstanding' any provisions of the Plan to the contrary
that would otherwise limit a distributee's (as defined below) election
under this paragraph, a distributee may elect, at the time and in the
manner prescribed by the Committee, to have any portion of a n
eligible rollover distribution (as defined below) paid directly to an
eligible retirement plan (as defined below) specified by the
distributee in a direct rollover (as defined below).
(2) For purposes of this paragraph, the following terms shall h a v e
the following meanings:
(A) An "cligible rollover distribution" is any distribution
of all or any portion of the bulunce to the credit of thc
distributee, except thut an eligible rollover distribution
docs not inc\udc: any distribution that is one of a scries 0 r
substantially equal periodic payments (not less frequently
than unnually) made for the life (or life expectancy) of the
distributee or the joint lives (or joint life expectancies) of
thc distributec and the distributce's desiglHlled
beneficinry, or foJ' a specified period of tcn years or more~
any di stri bution to the extent such di sl ri bution is re'l u i r cd
under Internal Revcnuc Code Section 40] (a)(9). and lhe
portiun of any distribution that is not includible in g 1'0 ss
income (determined without regard to the exclusion for net
unrealized appreciation with respect to employer
securities).
< ~ > .
~ ( "'c' " [
"
Mayor' and City Commissioners
Page 3
August 8, t 995
(B) An "eligible retirement plan" is an individual
retirement account described in Internal Revenue Code
Section 408(a), an individual retirement annuity descri bed
in Internal Revenue Code Section 408(b), an annuity plan
described in Internal Revenue Code Section 403(a), or' l\
qualified trust described in Internal Revenuc Code Sec'tion
401 (a), that acccpts the distributee's eligible rollover
distribution. Howcver, in the case of an eligible rollover
distribution to the surviving' spouse, an eligible retirement
plan is an individual retirement nccount or individual
retirement annuity.
(C) A "distributee" includes an Employee or former
Employee. In addition, the Employee's or former
Employee's surviving spouse and the Employee's or former
Employee's spouse or former spouse who is the. alternate
payee under a qualified domestic relations' order, as defined
in Internal Revenue Code Section 414(p), are distributees
with regard to the interest of the spouse or former spouse.
(D) A "direct rollover" is a payment by the Plan to the
eligible retirement plan speCified by the distributee.
Page 41 Paragraph (b)( I).
Delete the period, add a comma, and lldd the following: "provided,
however, that termination shaH not become effective until and unless
the decision to terminnte is rntified by n majority of the qualified
electors of the City of Clearwater voting either in n general or a special
election called and held for the purpose of rati fication or rejection 0 f
Plan termination."
~
~.. """ .
w., .. ~ ".
lj'-!:.1..-:.t ::':. . \
~. " .
I,.
. . ~.. ...;
~
#tJ0
CiTY OF CLEARWATER
Interdepartmental Correspondence Sheet
TO. Muyor and City Commission
FROM: H. Michael Laursen, Human Resources Director
COPIES: Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager; Pam Akin, City Attorney
SUBJECf: Correction in Pension Plan Ordinance (First Reading)
DATE:
August 17, 1995
In reviewing the pension ordinancc which is scheduled tonight for first reading by
the City Commission, I have determined that the foHowing change should be brought
to your attention:
Section 2.397. In paragraph (c)(l)(A), the words "Article VIII" should be
corrected to reud "Section 2.398." Original drafts of the pension proposal wcre
not ih ordinance form, nnd each section was referred to as a particular article.
In the ordil1ance copy prepared by the Legal Dcpnrtment. this change is on page 16.
In the copy which was provided to show in legislative style changes from the draft
copy provided to the City Commission at work scssion on July 31, 1995, the correction
would occur on page 20.
An appropriate Illation is offercd as follows:
Move to amend paragraph (c)( t )(A) Section 2.397 of Ordinance 5890-95 to read:
A Participant who is vested in his Accrued Benefit and who terminates
employment by reason of his disability shall be entitled to receive, at
the lime and in the manner described in Section 2.398, H disability
benefit equal to his Accrued Benefit as of the date of termination of his
employmcnt.
?in
~LI
Clearwater Reflections
Special Edition 1t L/ b
. MESSAGE TO ALL CITY EMPLOYEES- August 16, 1995
PROPOSED PENSION PLAN CONCEPT: One of the items included in the proposed pension plan is the concept of
"early retirement." The purpose of this Special Reflections is to darify the process of early retirement and pension .
benefits.
The concept of providing an early retirement provision .in the proposed plan stems from a desire to correct an inequity
perceived to exist in the current plan. The current plan provides that an employee with ten or more years of pension
service credit may separate from the City's employ, leave his/her pension contributions in the plan, and begin to receive
a pension on what would have been hislher normal retirement date had he/she remained a City employee. For example,
an employee might begin hislher City employment and pension plan participation at age 35, work ten years, leave the
City and subsequently begin to collect a pension ten years later at age 55 (20 years of service at age 55 is a normal
retirement date).
Although the process for employees hired at an older age under the current plan is the same as noted above. the ability
to collect the pension becomes less likely to occur. For example, an employee hired at age 60 could work ten years and
then separate from employment and begin collecting a pension at age 80.
The early retirement concept in the proposed pension plan provides that an employee may begin to receive a pension
based on the completion of ten years of service and attainment of age 65 (without waiting for any additional number of
years) with such benefit amount actuariaUy reduced.
Example: Under the plan (using 2.75% as the benefit multiplier in the benefit computation formula), if an employee
comes to work for the City at age 60 and terminates at age 70 (with ten years of service), the benefit would be calculated
as follows:
Assume Average Earnings:
Years of Service
Annual Benefit:
Monthly Benefit:
$30,000
10
$30,000 x 2.75% x 10 = $8,250
$8,250 ~ 12 = $687.50
This employee could begin receiving $687.50 per month beginning at age 80 (ten years from separation). Under the
proposed early retirement provision, the employee could still elect to receive the $687.50 per month beginning at age 80.
Alternatively, however. the employee could elect to receive $208.45 per month immediately. This benefit is determined
as shown below:
$687.50 x 30.32 % = $208.45
The early retirement factor shown above (30.32 %) is actuarially determined based on the employee's current age and the
number of years that he/she is receiving the benefit early. The actuarially equivalent percentage would vary year by year
from age 70 to age 80 consistent with the age of the employee at termination and the number of years he/she would
receive the benefit early.
(Note: Actuarial number in the above example was provided by
Stephen M. Metz, Principal. Coopers & Lybrand.)
b..::'A,:'"T"
.'l'~
... -
~
\;.\A'~Lp
CITY OF CLEARWATER
INTEROFFICE CORRESPON~ee:sl;j6ET
FIRE DEPARTMENT' .. ,. -
AUG 171995
1
\
I
I
I
TO
FROM
COPIES
SUBJECf :
H. Michael Laursen, Human Resources Director
Robert L. Davidson, Fire ChieyO ~i1'Y N~Ar~AGER
Elizabeth Deptula, City Manager; Kathy Rice, Deputy City Manager
Firefighter/Paramedics Retired on Disability PeIl5ion While Receiving
Assignment Pay
DATE
August 17, 1995
There have been one hundred and five (105) City employees who have retired under the
provisions of the Disability section of the Pension Plan.
The number of firefighter/paramedics who retired under the Disability provision while
receiving paramedic assignment pay was six (6):
yt~~.fil~~~lli{t:~~~~i~t~ltt~lNXMEj~;~~\t::~~~i~g:f.i>{~~:\1{il~~~'j~;~~~ :!i~~~i~w)iMf;~;~Ri3TIRE~}~~;1}gfi}ff,1:f~~0~~ii~
Winfred Caudill . 06/08/80
John Ferzola 01/18/88
William Harvev 10109/89
Thomas Hen 06/15/86
12/02/92
John Nicholson (still on w.e. benefits)
George Toran 05/14/93
These figures are as of August 16, 1995.
)~.>;t-
6 (} (
fUo/€-
'1':<
lJ:f :J-i e- 10 r were... .f-{-
.-!to. i'l r,L...
6 0 J- ,yt e- 'I.J- f- .J-
?U~.....~
RLD:crh
f C ~.~ ..., <- ~/,' c:...5
" .,
: I
',; .' .
',.
l'
I
~.~~r~~, f' ,'~ j. - '.~., "
,.
. .. ~ . 'c, . n. . . >'
"
':..:oio 4
'.l"'" .
. "
. ~
.. .
AGENDA
DATE
1... / 1- q".
,
'~;'
.-& ,
, \'.
t\'
r;~
.....,
::1-
1...,"
~~. .
ITEM #
\
r
t
J
\
I
I
,
F 190G;
. ~. . . " "," ,~...
~N3
Clearwater City Commission
Agenda Cover Mcmorandwn
YiJ
It em tI
Heetlng Date: ____
~ '/7.q5
SUBJECT: Increase in domestic and lawn water rates effective 10/1/95
RECOMMENDATION/MOTION: Confirm the city Managers decision to increase domestic
and lawn water rates approximately 12.53% effective 10/1/95, such increased
rates to be used for the first full billing cycle beginning on or after october
1, 1995
B and that the appropriate officials be authorized to execute same.
Current Proposed %
Rate Rate Increase
Water Rate $1.0254 $1.1902 16%
Capital Improvement
Charge $ .30 $ .60 100%
Total $1.3254 $1.7902 35%
1
\
I
I
l
~
i
l
I
I
f
1
BACKGROUND:Pinellas County approved a wholesale water rate increase on July
11, 1995 of approximately 35%. This increase will be effective for water
purchased beginning October 1, 1995. The increase is as follows:
The ordinance regarding water rates allows for the city Manager to approve pass
through increases in the city's cost of purchasing water from pinellas County.
Since the City purchases approximately 75% of its water from Pinellas County, this
increase of 35% is expected to increase our cost of purchased water by
approximately $1.7 million. Raising our rates by 12.53% across the board will
generate the $1.7 million needed to cover the cost of the wholesale rate increase
by Pinellas County.
The new rates will be used for the first full billing cycle beginning on or after
October 1, 1995.
Sewer rates will not be affected by this rate increase.
Reviewed by: =tt= Originating Dept: Costs: So C~ission Action:
Legal finance Total 0 Approved
Budget '--'r(\~ 0 Approved w/conditions
Purchasing I-K S
0 Denied
Rhlc. Mgmt, WI" User Dept: Current Fiscal Yr.
CIS N/'i)-vlJ 0 Continued to:
ACM FLnding Source:
Other 0 capitol Irrp.
Advertised: 0 operating A tt oc:hIllCnta:
Dote: 0 Other Plnellos County Resolution
~~.. Paper: 95-175
tr] Not Requi red Rate Schedule
Sibil tted by: Affected Parties Appropriation Code:
:/j~ 0 Notified 0 None
cfty~~ r tr] Not Required
JU..-31 ,$ 14: 5eI FRet!:
4 ''''~
I
....
18134!?13944.
~:02
TO: 94626720
RESOLUTION NO. 95_175
B~SQLtJTIO~~ISI~G PlUELL66 COUNTY WATER 5YSTEH
WHOLE~ALE CUSTOMERS WATER ~TES
WHEREAS, the Board of County CD~iBoionerB of PinellBs County,
florida, had heretofore ~ntered into CQntr~ctB with wholesale customers to
fU~!dh water at a whole.ale rate; And
WHEREAS, Ohapter Z9442, LaW8 of Florida 1953, empow~rB tho Board of
County CommieaioncrD of Pin~11aB County, FloridG, to revisQ water ratoa when
nace.aary. by resolution; And
WHEREAS, purBuBnt to .ucb authority, the Board of County
Commissioners of linellau Oounty, Florida, hoB conuidered the incroased C08t~
associated with providing water service to ita wholesale cuatomars; and
WHEREAS, the Board ot Oounty Oommissioners of Pinellas County,
Florida, had afforded sn opportunity fo~ the presentAtion of evidence favoring
or againat the p~opooed Wholeeala WBte~ Rate At a Public Hearine and has
determinld that the proposed Whole.ale Water Rata is reasonable, necessary,
and juotified and should bq adopted; and
WHEREAS, purauant to sUch authority, tbe !oard of County
Oommissioners De Pinel1A8 County, Florida, has ccusidered thff cost. ASQociated
with the investigation, eonst~ction. and replacemGnt.Qf new and exi~ting
facilities requitod to pro~de ~6tor 60rvlee to ita cu.tome~81 and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has determinod ~ Capital
Improvemant Chorge &ate Structure would be beneficial to fund the
invedtigation. construction, and replacement of Dew And exioting facllitie~;
and
WHEREAS, the Bonrd ot Oounty CO~&8ioners of floel1no County,
florida. has afforded an opportunity for the preaentation of evidence favoring
or against the proposed Capital Improvement Cha;ge Rate Structure at a Eubli~
Hoarins, and haa determined that the Oapital Improvement Charsc Rate Structure
is rau8onuble, neceuaary, and jU$tified aod ahould be adopted.
NOW, THEREFORE, aE It RESOLVED by the Board of County Coromiaeionor;
ot P!nella5 County, Florida, in reaular mectini duly odsembled this 11t~
day of July , 1995, that the followinl Whal.isla Watar Rate nnd
Capital Improvement Cha~IQ ore hereby adopted to apply ta wholesale cuntomeru
ot PineLlaQ County Water SYltem, .uch new WholoQalo W.ter Rate Bnd Capital
Improve~~nt Charso to be applied to:
-
1
~
1
1
i
.1
f
f
I
I
!
I
j
't"I"', '"
.1.'
.,.. '>..-.
JlL.3~ 95 14:5e ~:
...
181~?944
TO: 9462672e
PJ:G:: ro
. .. .
a) tho .n~i~e quantity of water ~.eordad by measurine devi~o8 for
the period at the fi~gt full e.tabLished billing ey~le beginning on or after
October 1, 1995, and
b) all quantitieB of water recorded durin I tQgular billing cycles
thereafter;
NDQLESAL~ RATE SCHEDULE
l) Water Rate
$1.1902/1000 gallons
2) Capital Improvement
Charge
$0.60/1000 gallons
Tho Capital I~provement Charge will be reviewed bi~nnu811Y and will
expire an Fabruary 1, %005. Re~olution No. 90-448 (December 4. 1990)
10 hereby superseded after the firdt full ostabliuhed billing cycle
besinn1ng on or after OQtober t. 1995.
(WhoLeB~le Oustomers - 1arpon Springs, Clearwater, Safety
B&r~or, ptnellas Park, 01dnmBr, Dunedin, Utilitieg, Inc. and
Belledr)
Commissioner Tyndall
and move~ its adoption, which was
and upon roll call the vote WBQ:
offered th8 fDr~soing Resolution
!econdod by Commissioner Stewarr.
,
Ayes:
Nays z
Absent
So1bsftt Park&, Tyndall and Stewart
None
~nd Not Voting; R8inay
-
I
I
)
f'
~
H
7-
~~
~
~
.
~
~
"
~
~'
j
I
\
I
I
{, ~.~~,~. ,1.~
;
Page 1 I
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PASS-THROUGH OF PINELLAS COUNTY WHOLESALE WATER RATE INCREASE
EFFECTIVE OCTOBER 1. 19~
I
.
J\~.':):" .
. .
Page 2
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PASS- THROUGH OF PINELLAS COUNTY WHOLESALE WATER RATE INCREASE
EFFECTIVE OCTOBER 1. 1995
Current and proposed water rates for all water furnished bv the city:
PROPOSED
CURRENT EFF. 10/1/95
4-lnch:
Minimum charge with us~ge up to 92,400 cubic feet $1.412.62 $1,589.28
Plus. from 92.401 to 130,900 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet 1.86 2.09
Plus, from 130,901 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet 2.20 2.48
6-lnch:
Minimum charge with usage up to 237,300 cubic feet 3,627.85 4,081.56
Plus, from 237,301 to 270,700 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet 1.86 2.09
Plus, from 270,701 cubic feet up. per 100 cubic feet 2.20 2.48
a-Inch:
Minimum charge with usage up to 400,000 cubic feet 6,115.20 6,880.00
Plus, from 400,001 to 456,300 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet 1.86 2.09
Plus. from 456,301 cubIc feet up, per 100 cubIc feet 2.20 2.48
~. Lawn water rate~
Lawn meter size
Under 1-inch:
Base charge, with no water allowance $2.18 $2.45
Plus, up to 200 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet 1.98 2.23
Plus, from 201 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet 2.73 3.07
1-lnch:
Base charge, with no water allowance 6.54 7.35
" Plus, up to 900 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet 1.98 2.23
Plus, from 901 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet 2.73 3.07
..... . ~, ~
,.....~~
Page 3
"
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PASS- THROUGH OF PINELLAS COUNTY WHOLESALE WATER RATE INCREASE
EFFECTIVE OCTOBER 1, 1995
Current and proposed water rates for all water furnished bv the city:
1 1/2-lnch:
Base charge, with no water allowance
PROPOSED
CURRENT EFF.10/1/95
Plus. up to 1,200 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
$32.70
1.98
$36.75
2.23
Plus, from 1,201 cubIc feet up, per 100 cubic feet
2.73
3.07
2-lnch:
Base charge, with no water allowance
91.56
102.90
Plus, up to 5,400 cubIc feet, per 100 cubic feet
1.98
2.23
Plus, from 5,401 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
2.73
3.07
I
~
1
I
,
~
f.
d
~
rl
?
]
,j
/1
"
3-lnch or two 2-lnch in manifold:
Base charge. with no water allowance
180.94
Plus, up to 13,400 cubic feet, per 100 cubIc feet
1.98
2.73
203.35
2.23
Plus, from 13,401 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
3.07
4-lnch:
Base charge. with no water allowance
Plus, up to 31,100 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
348.80 392.00
1.98 2.23
2.73 3.07
1.052.94 1.183.35
1.98 2.23
2.73 3.07
;.
,.
i~'
'.
J!.
Plus, from 31,101 cubic feet up, per 100 cubic feet
p.
6-lnch:
Base charge, with no water allowance
i
,.
Plus, up to 48,000 cubic feet, per 100 cubic feet
.,
.,
',"
<
Plus, from 48,001 cubic feet up, per 100 cubIc feet
".
.,
J
.<
:,
Note: No increase in monthly standby charges for fire hydrants and fire protection systems
on private property connected to the city water system.
:!
I
H:\DATA\123J:J1
'INS\REPORTS\H20RATE1,WKl
FINANCE DEPT.
07/31195
I
..
p
. .
, .
..
,.
~~u,,~,"": ".o. ;....
IVIEIVt ORAND U1\1
TO:
Mayor and City Commissioners
FROM:
Kathy S. . Ricet Deputy City Manager
COPIES:
Betty Deptulat City Manager
Bill Bakert Assistant City Manager
Cyndie Goudeaut City Clerk
SUBJECT:
August 17 Commission Meeting
DATE:
August 1St 1995
"
r oi '~'.
I
.1
y~~
1(a;t/;"l~
COPIES TO:
COMMISSION
AUG 1 5 1995
PRESS
CLERK I ATTORNEY
I have been requested by a Commissioner to put on the agenda for Thursday night further discussion
on the lease for the tower operations.
I
I
I
i
i,
I
a
I
~
I
J
I
FR01 :
A-GE 1-0.
P01
~,~r . ~]....~ ,." ....
/\5~
COPIES TO:
COMMISSION
AUG 1 5 1995
PRE-55
CLERK I ATTORNEY
TO:
PROM:
SUBJECT:
DATE:
MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS AND CITY S1'AFP
AL LUEWSKI
SKY TOWER LEASB RATE or 15% OF GROSS REVENUES
AUGUST 15,1995
A COttnter offer of 1 S96 of gross revenues was made by the
Commission to Mr. Jim Grogan at yestcrday.s work session. I whole
hearted1y agree with that offer. It provides the City with a
substantial source of revenues without hindering the sky tower's
potential for success.
enclosure
I
I
\
\
\
.
I
t
.
~
~
\
~
t
~
~
l
}
i
I
i
,
j
~
,
I
Enclosed is a calculation of lease income to the City at various
estimated levels of gross revenue and the related rate per square
foot of space leased. I 'WOuld doubt that the City has any other lease
presently in existence that treats the City more favorably! 'My hat
goes off to you if you can accomplish th1s for the benefit of the
taxpayers.
In addition, in my opinion, the tower will stimulate business on
Clearwater Beach and be a good example of what cooperative effort
between the City and private business can achieve.
-;t4~~'
Al Lijewski
FRC:M :
ESTIMATED
GROSS
R&VENUES
500,000
1,000,000
1,500,000
z,ooo,ooo
2, SOO,OOO
3,000.000
3.500,000
4.000,000
4.500,000
5,000,000
5,500.000
6,000.000
F+GE NJ.
REVISED LEASE tNCOME
TO CITY OF CLEARWATER
FROM THE SKY TOWER
LEASE COST PER
I~CO"1~ SOIJAR~ FQQJ
75.000 15.63
1 SO,OOO 31.25
225,000
300,000
975,000
450,000
525,000
600,000
675,000
750,000
825,000
900.000
46.88
62.50
78.13
93.75
109.36
1 ? 5.00
, 40.63
, 56.25
171.88
187.50
NOTE: BASED ON 1 5% OF GROSS PREMIUMS
TO LEASE 60 BY 80 FEET OF SPACE.
P02
-
:?
I. .~...
Basic Elements of a Proposed Lease
bet ween City of Clearwater and JRG Marketing
agreed to by James Grogan Rnd WUliam C. Bakel'
on August 15, 1995
......,'**...*..***.********...**.****.****...***.**********.
1. IRG will pay City a guaranteed minimum rent of $50,000 per year, payable in
12 monthly installments, or 15% of the annual gross revenue, whichever is
greater. The differential between $50,000 and 15 % of gross revenue shall be
payable in a lump-sum payment 30 days following the end of each lease year,
2. The lease term shall be a 20-year period with a 5 year extension period at the
option of the lessee. If lessee opts for the 5 year extension, the percentage fee
will increase from 15 % per year to 29% per year.
3. City will apply for all regulatory permits. City will prepare applications and
all documents relative to the permitting procedure. IRG will pay all applicable
fees and all out-of-pocket expenses relating to the permits, including consulting
fees and services outside the expertise of City staff.
4. IRG will independently establish the tower in accordance with the City's rules,
regulations, codes and procedures. IRG shall have the right to seek variances
as appropriate and available.
5. IRG will pay all impact fees up fron't with a credit applied toward rent.
amounting to 50 % of the impact fees. The credit shall be applied to the
monthly minimum rent in sixty equal amounts over the first five years of the
lease.
6. IRG will produce, at his total expense, four laser shows, one each quarter,
each running for at least 10 minutes per night for 10 consecutive nights during
the first year. City will have complete editorial authority over the show~s
content and approval authority over any sponsorship arranged by IRG.
7. The tower footprint will incorporate space necessary only for the lower
proper, necessary mechanical equipment (attractively housed), a ticketing
facility housing a limited number of retail items, all of which are "logoed"
with a tower logo to be developed by IRG and approved by City. The tower
footprint will be of minimum required dimensions with as little impact on
parking and surrounding areas as possible.
8. JRG to provide surety bond in an amount sufficient to provide for disassembly
and removal of tower in the event of business failure.
9. JRG will provide required workman's compensation and $10 million single-
limit liability insurance in full force at all times from initial start of
construction naming the City of Clearwater as additional insured.
<.:'i.......~_... "
rP_J_
0S\o.\.lp", 0-, \'-\
+ ~\oW
1.) City Request:
JRG Response:
2.) Lease Term:
3.) Permitting:
4.) Impact Fees:
5.) Laser Show:
6.) Parking:
JRG MARKETING
21 6 BIANCA AVENUE
TAMPA, Fl ~ ~ 606
(8"> 2~1..2~09
FAX (8]'> 251..2S09
Lo{'<\~'~'S'O"::'
COPIES TO, .
COMMISSIO~'
AUG 1 5 1995
PRESS
CLERK I ATTORNEt
August 14. 1995
WORK SESSION CONCERNS
15% of Gross. Minimum guarantee of $48,000 against
applicable percentage.
We bring a 2.3 million dollar asset to the project. Virtually
all other concessions, the city provides the building and
lease hold improvements for a lesser fee.
*
JRG agrees to city request.
JRG needs twenty.five (25) years; however, will agree to
twenty (20) with five (5) year option at increase of 5% of
gross.
City secures perm its for its other concessions - why not this
one. (Note:) Would expedite cash flow and get the
operation started in heig ht of season. ( ...j AO - 'f'e.),:)
We will pay - City credit against our rent.
JRG will produce four (4) times during the first year.~ E'5TlrrJf+.~D
COsns /0 .::rRC- ~I bO,OOo
Will absolutely minimize requirements....... Properly located.
project will usurp very few spaces.
J~~~
II.
,"'1 ." - j > '. . ">J -{
~i~~":',f.~' ....:: ..1 ~ ~ ~\ .~.j
./ i' ,.J. \ ,.' ~ 'Iy * ~
:,,'~:"~' ~l,,;., 'i . ;'~." . ; '.. ~.! ~~ ti~ .~ ~ ~~j ..~
'" , ~ ,....,......, , ," ~ ~ ~ l '" ~
. ,'. . ~. ,,~'. : ~........ . .' ' ~ . ..) ~ ~ ) ~~ . '1;1
.:. ,.'~ . :) J .' ',; J ,\.... ~ ,~~j 't
<~~l ~ 1 ~ 'fj~~ ~ j'1'~: ~.; ~
r 1 . ~ <~. ~ ~~ ~ .t
~:,: \:) '~ . . fJ. '. ~ ': ' . ~ 0)
,,' \' ' tr) . . , . .' ~ ~ J ~
;'.,:' ...... .' ". 011~~ ~ . ~ ~ :l~ \1 ~ F~
'.' 80 '" .. "'. ~ - J
~ '.' .
. .
, '.' -,. < ','
, . ~ . "':. I , .' . . .
'. . Ii
. ",. .
'. ~.,~~:':::-.: :.\-1.( : .'. '-.::' ,. '., . '.. ' .'.'" ,": ":,
',~ ~ t~'" l6 ~l 1.'~~ }~. ~
, ~ . ~ \D ~ I'J ~cJ ., , ~ ~ ,.~\~ ~ ~ ~
,;..t;, ~ '1 ~ ~. ~. . ~ r.J ~
. ~', _ 4 .:x.1 ~ . t' ~ ~ ~~ f .~ ~ {, \'-
, l.l") ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~,~ ~... .~ ~ I~ ~ .
..2 en zj'~ ~ t (~' .t... '1 ...J
f2 ~ ~ en ~ . \ '~ ..., ,~~ r'1 J-..,.J ~ ~ It-{
en en tI.l.... . \I ,\.):-J ' ':s: " ~~ ~ IJ ..:j .
~ ::E ~ ~ ~ 't~ ~ 1~ "I)l ;y ~ ,'\) ." .\' ~ ~ c:i';)
& ~ ~ Q. ~ ~}3 i ''-3 r' )J~" ~. .~. '\ J ) ~
c,) u:=l a: . oJ' I:~ \J ~ f'~:i ~
~ ~, O~ II ~ j j !'~ ~ "~ ;~~ i
V ..c;,/ ~ ~ ~ ~ (S ~ ~ t '\ ~
.
" "
''-3'b \'~
~ ~
~ ~
i ~~,
~ ,;:~
....u
I~ .'
.'. . t., ~ .,'
. . ~ ~
~.
\'
;
~
,0
,
,
I
J
':'"
L([ <^,-
AS A l.-\FE l.ONb lZ-ESn::;e"NT OF THe T~'Ba\ ~Y AUG 1 7 1995
PRESS
MEA AN D T2E'St't:::€N"'r t>F CL-e,A.:~w^T'E~ ~'H CLERK I ATTORNEY
FoE. TH e: 'l-?t.. CST E f e, H.,. "-( E AlC=-S ]:.1 t---t "e 1C: y
,CONCEE.Ne-'D A"::J -ro \NH\CH wAY c.U:^1Zv../It-"'tl::'~
.,~I..cH f~ H~A't:>e'p.. r'E~ 60's NEW f..t>()}L
.. .A Nt> AC. "'\1\,' 8'> ~ p'JZBeJ.lT A MoVe J/tJ THE
~'bH"" -O'TC'E:c--r 10 N AND St> v./tl-l..Il-1E 'P126fJSEb
TOW~~~ U.t.E" SHDPi?JNG MA-u..~ Nfle:.l) "ANC-H01?-1f
. S-roRE.S C LE:-A-:.e.'fIA:TE:-~ "O't,A;.C-H. N~t"D5 lTS
tIANCHo~tr AS WELL.-rK& A'NCrrOJ?:.5 'O}!A-w!He:
. MASSeS At4 P -n-1f;. ~}...{ ALLflC!:- SlOEEs :PAJ2T' C Ij'=>Jt1"E..
, -rH'E -rvWGf2- 12c~~'EHTs t:=!OO'D# C LeAN, v.I'H{)~f=,.
.. FVN Fo~ALL-~E"~.-rHE SA1,;i~ lMA€1e lHE: 13~
...~S. \t'1E: EtiJNOM\C-. ~t-^'P~l OF ~E. IOvJ~
..A'PPE~'5 -pJ20Pl TABLE AND C~e-rA1Nl.-(' WOVl,.\::J
;.~e-plZ~e,.rr AN JNI ~J.AL '"D~ OF ~ f\::>E;N-rSI
_..._;:~OT$A-"BI.-t . HA:L.F .-n4~ 'POP\J L.jf17oNS PF- ?/~eI..l..J\S
. _.~P H\\..-LS'Sl>f20 \..GM ANt' t;Hf3 CAt-.{ ~l,...'( f t'-1A€1)~E
. .""1 HE:'Y '-Nt L(.. COM e "'BAC/l- ts~1 Ne J N6 H\tJ.. \ L Y ANt>
.. f12te,v-ps A~p ,,\?,Jl)~S f12Ot"A bV\ or \t)""N. :r.IS
" ..
.. A 61ZE*T AL.TE1?-tJ,4;.:TE CHVICE' Jl)~'" A5 THE Pl"El'..
.. J N t;O\J.1NIlJW-t.J. ~- \1:;-Te-125"Bfv1=El \N H eN LaO~' rJ 5
.. fD~ \/L.-Ac..es 1"0 ~O. \HE -rDwel2- WfJu\,.-'t;> 'pE: FINn- E:L"'"(
~t A '" S \ 1l?~ !/?Aw. \\1 E. "TOvJef- WO v 1.- 'i> \)t PI N rre L"'l
PB AN V~D f"'el1G)l1ec;,s\"~e MWt IN "THE ~lf7HT
'O)~eCf / () N. - PO u& A\- 'p e FaMAi-i
9Jse NA~c'ISSvS ~
C L-\..v. "Be H ~ ~ tf4, ~
61~' 4-*+7-$809
f}-I" - 95 f\f)oup' cl, c..o(\.,\!---
To: ,to1 e -rDW e R. co,...t. """' i "fIE e
-
COPIES TO'
COMMISSION
l'
II
]
j
~".~, ....
..
Cb.X: 1o.
~o,
,
I'
PROPOSAL TO CITY OF CLEARWATER
JRG Marketing or entity to be later named, proposes the following land lease
agreement with the city of Clearwater.
Lessee will provide the following:
LESSEE will erect a 335 foot Willy Biihler 64 passenger Sky Tower with appropriate loading
facilities, ticketing, and waiting area.
LESSEE will establish operating hours compatible with existing operating hours of neighboring
commercial interests. As demand increases, these hours may be extended beyond the operating
hours of the neighboring interests.
The Tower will be inspected daily by qualified technicians and maintained in near perfect condition
and appearance at all times.
LESSEE will provide required workmen's compensation and $10,000,000 single limit liability
insurance in full force at all times from initial start of construction, naming the city of Clearwater
as additional assureds if desired.
LESSEE will allow placement of appropriate name or logo copy designed by the city of Clearwater
to be affixed to Tower.
LESSEE will begin engineering studies immediately and construction within thirty (30) after receipt
of all permits applicable.
LESSEE will remunerate the city of Clearwater in the following amounts:
· $48,000.00 per annum minimum bruarantee against following percentages, whichever
greater.
· 8% of gross receipts up to $1,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 12%, of gross from $1,000,001.00 through $5,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 20% of gross receipts from $5,000,001.00 up per year.
5 years after first day of operation, remuneration will be as follows:
. $60,000.00 per annum minimum guarantee against following percentages, whichever
greater.
· 10% of gross receipts up to $1,000,000.00 per year gross.
. 14% of gross from $1,000,001.00 through $5,000,000.00 per year gross.
. 22'X, of gross receipts from $5,000,001.00 up per year.
0V~RJ
..
~~. ....
'.
II
"I
'\
Twr.Lease.
Page 2
15 years after first day of operation. remuneration will be as follows and remain such throughout
lease tenn.
· $72,000.00 per annum minimum guarantee against following percentages, whichever
greater.
· 13% of gross receipts up to $1,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 17% of gross from $1,000,001.00 through $5,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 25% of gross receipts from $5,000,001.00 up per year.
Payment will be made quarterly and accompanied by computer printout of the quarter's activity on
a daily basis. Initial payment date will be due ninety (90) days after first day of operation. LESSEE
will allow city complete access to its tinancials upon seventy-two (72) hours notice.
LESSEE will provide a bond in the amount of $175,000 to cover disassembly and removal of tower
from city property in event of business failure. LESSEE will at its 0\\11 expense, bear this obligation
for one ( I) year from date of completion of construction. Extension of one ( I ) year to be negotiated.
LESSEE will provide $100,000 working capital until cash flow dictates this amount unnecessary.
LESSEE will provide required Federal Aviation Agency pennit.
LESSEE will provide adequate staff, clothed in distinctive logoed clothing and will maintain the
entire structure and premises in the highest standard possible.
City of Clearwater will provide the following:
LESSOR will provide thirty (30) year tease with option to renew predicated upon negotiated
upgrades to tower.
LESSOR will provide adequate space to erect IITower", loading dock, ticket sales and machine
room. (Space needed approximately 60 feet frontage, 80 feet deep. Space to be east of coastal
control fence, west of street side sidewalk, south of first street, and north of Adams Mark Hotel).
LESSOR will provide landscaping to be maintained by LESSEE.
LESSOR will provide at no cost to LESSEE, five (5) staff parking spaces immediately adjacent to
tower and appropriately marked as such.
'M'I',...'F-ot.r.." ~. "".,. "-t" c' :
. .
! .
I':
,.
'.
...
.
.,.
. ,
.1
, '. >., 'c ~ ,',
. ,,~ < ..', , '.' .
4~~
. Twr.Lease
Page 3
LESSOR will allow LESSEE spot promos on television channel 35 at no cost to LESSEE except
production costs of camera ready video tapes.
LESSOR will provide all required local permits as expediously as possible and will assist LESSEE
in securing all said permits.
A detailed list of permits required will be furnished LESSEE within ten (10) days after signing of
lease.
LESSOR will allow sales of tower logoed Tee Shirts~ miniature model towers, post cards, film and
sunglasses from this facility. Sales of these items will be factored into tower gross and appropriate
percentages paid to city. No other merchandise will be marketed without the express written
consent of the city of Clearwater.
,
I
'c
James R. Grogan, III
JRG Marketing
Date
t;."r:'~ .
',-,t
'\o.'^ .
~~o--
COMPARISON OF TOWER USE IN OTHER GEOGRAPHIC ^RE^~
Description
Total No. of
, No. of Davs Customers
Gatlinburg Tower, open only May 20
throu h Nov 1
Customers
Per Dav
'.'
Minnesota State Fair:
1993
1994
12
10
77,986
56,864
6,499
5,686
,"','" ~,' ~', \.....:..,~. ..:,' -. I/~' \.:,- "'~:-'n' ~. ',,'.' " ..~. .',~.. .',' .'. .~ .-:.:'..:.. r':'~:,,".~,
Sea World Space Tower(See Note):
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994(8 months)
365
365
365
365
243
377,267
386.418
325,625
401,061
233,953
1,034
1,059
892
1,099
961
i
I
J
j
I
I
,
,
Note: Has a capacity of 60; is open only 7 hours per day. Considered highest
profit item in park.,.
:ll..~.: . .':. ::",t,~'.. \: ~ ':.~.: '.',,:::, ',....'" ~ :,::t~ '.:,:.:-'~.~:'.,t ~ .~'.: ...',~ t l.i.>'I'>.~.;' ......~.: : . ':,;, '.1 p,..' :.
Bill Baker estimate for Clearwater
Beach
365
.l..:.',~(~.". 'L'~::'~':""'< ,"':.:';"".. '.:~: ..:;".;.".,.;(;.. ,.: :.~~...'. ,<: ..iii .f',(,'.<:l'.~;.l;>",
1,995
Pro Forma 1 Financial Statements
365
Pro Forma 2 Financial Statements
365
Pro Forma 3 Financial Statements
365
Pro Forma 4 Financial Statements
365
'::,:~",' .~ ......, ~::':::; . ~... .....:' ,;,:'. ~ . ,. .";~u' ..',: .':"'~,'.~~~ .,..,,\.~ro :, :. ,<:. j . ... h'., . ".., ' ,.'
798
Page 1
560,000
728,000
291..200
728,000
291,200
1,534
798
1.995
:;~;'>';'" '. .
-:1.
,i
',"
I:. ,
',1. :c
~.........~
!',
0 I.t'l 0 r-.. N 0 ~.2;\l!!
.... 'l:t I.t'l 0 o tU'tU
o ::J (l)
III . I'.': >-
~ O'll'.':l.r)
< 0-:'
>-~a.~e::z
<::JC2LU~O
COI-~........V)
c:::J:c::>-e::
LUC::UJC::~~
a.WQ..UJ....
V)Q..V)a..Q..a::
gj~Zv)~~
Oo::@~~t;;
';'::J:I-C::C::O
I:: ~ u
>
b
<
n::
LU
==
o
l-
\':
I
'I
!
ci)
~
~
UJ
I-
Z
<
o
...J
UJV):a
~!Zffi
C::UJI-
tn~
UJ<
a::Q..
LU-l
!zLU
->
UJ
-'
Q)
C)
tU
a.
.....
""
, , j
: . ~. ~ )
.i
I .
I.
I
; .
('oJ
~
Cl.l
.t::
tJ)
,
I:
I
I
I
I
ocn V 1"'-('1')0.... 00 I"'-NOCOLn....O
OCOlJ')O('1')('1')Nl"'-r.or.oOV....OlJ')O
~wco~mNwco~~w~~mcicio
CUOLOlJ')cnr.oOr.or.o~r.or.ol"'-~cno
~C~~ONCOlJ')cncn....NCOlJ')mVI"'-
O~lJ')O('1')('1')O~r.o~mm~~OOM
~~('1')....COLONCOVOlJ')OlJ')m('1')r.oco
CClI"'-r--r.or.otDlJ')LOlJ')VV('1')NN....
!z
lLIo::D::
~LLJW
>-1->-
<<
~==tE
a::;o::UJ
z~l:i:
<..J-
au.....
-'u.Q:
u..o.....
~~~
5U
00
~I-
u oCt
V)
'I~
'I:
C.
....lJ')I"'-('1')VCO....OVlJ')NNN
...."'1v":oOlJ')....mr.or.oN....
~....cx:il.Dwair.o,...:r-.:aiLnNm
vOLOMlJ')('1')OCOomcn('1') V
q ~ ,.....~ v~ M LIl 0 f'.~ m ('1') N 1..0 oq-~
Ln I"'- m N ~CO~N l.O al~alV~O
NNN('1')('1')(V)VVoq-lJ')LIltDl"'-
tJ")O
lJ')lJ')
me)
coo
1"'-1"'-
u)M
I"'-CO
~
~
IV
.....
C
v 0 co N.... f'. V LIl..... 0 ('1') (Y'l M 0 Ln.
tJ")('1')....ml.OlJ')....LIlI"'-OOVLIl....O
t.ONuit.O,...:vi~wvi~ai....~oq:M
COMI"'-ml"'-mNVN('t")('1')OCOVM
....m~":.OOl.ON~('t")comlDI"'-"'tLll
u)M....CO~NallO....u)....u)OVI"'-
tDtOtDlJ')LOlOoq-VVMMNN....
....
(1)
C)
~
0..
J
l/') lJ') 1.0
I.D tD l.O
M M'M
('t")('1')M
NNN
1.0 lJ')
tOtO
MM
(Y'l('1')
NN
- -
tJ")lJ')
tOl.D
MM
M('1')
N_ "!.
lJ')LIlLt')Lt')Lt')LO
r.o l.D r.o r.o tD to
MMC't')MM('()
MMMMMM'"!,NNNNN
lJ')lJ')
1..OLt')
C'f'it'ti
('1')('1')
N N
- ~
..-'1""'-..-..-......-.-....-.........-.-.......-..-....
mmO"lmmmmO"lmmcnmmmm
~I
....NMVLt')tDI"'-OOm~
....NMVLt')
..-. .... ...... r- ~
.1 .:'
I::'
':
. '.
.-... ~+
I:.
M
~
Q)
(JJ
.r::
(I)
~
. ;
: ~ .'
"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
V,,"'t......1I"I......CO"t..OtnONM~V
cnO.-COlDM.-tn.......OOmcncncncn
....:ttri-c.d.,:.ccid~.-:.....:....:~....:~...;...:
lDOOcncnooooOOOOQO
....~.......'I""""""...........-.-........r-
-
0 M ('J"l M M ('I") M M M M M M M M M 00
'. 0" M M M M <'1 (I") M M M M rn M M M N
ui . vi vi ui ui ui ui
JW lJ'l tn t..n U'l U'l lJ'l tn U'l
co NN N N N N N N N N ('oJ N N N N
::Iv .- .- .- .- .- .- ..... ..... ..... ..... ,..... ..... .... 0- .....
o - c:ri'ai'ai'ai'ai'cri'ai'cri'alc:ri'oicri'alai'ai'
lJ'l
<(~ WlDWt.OlDWt.OlDt.O W lD c.o t.O W t.O
r--: r--: r--: ......._ " ....... ....... "- ....... ,.... r--:, ,.... .......,.... ......
-
.... ..... ..... 0- ..... .- 0- ..... ..- ..- ..- .- ...... .... .-. .....
.......
-I
<(
Z
a::
w
!z
~Jo
L.:
m
(JJ
>-
.c
c u
08]
'P ~
~ 0
CD
m 'C "tJ
.st;~
1"tJ i:5 .
o c en
.- tU "0 Cl
~ c c
'C ~ CO 'E
UO~tU
IIltncLU
I1l ~ C1) _
ClOEiU
~ ~.5
l'lJ~21
.c c: (JJ
~COa::
~.3o
o-NMVLnt.O,....COcnO
..-
....-NMo::tLrl
.-- ..... .,.- ...... r-
0-
Q)
01
tU
~
I
I
I
I
I
-
~
(lJ
.c
V>
o
o
~8
<q
UJO
>v
(D
('1)
o
i~
0:0
<q
o
>v
(D
M
o
ig
<(q
wO
>'<:t
(D
('I")
z
<(
z
u:
<(
~
0:::
o
o
NO
0:8
<0
Woq-
>w
('1)
o
o
-18
0:0
< ~
wO
>~
('1)
-
Q)
+-'
o
Z
C>
C>
zV>
o-
S: ~
~ c
Q)
>
C>
UJC::
-0
Q)
....
[U
E
't;
UJ
o
q
('1)
co
m
N"
O'l
-
ONNCOcYl
om O'l 0 I'-
roiwenow
COO'l "-N ('I")
O'l"-"Nv
N"oo-ooN"
O")I.r)I.t)COrt)
.- NM
M
o co
q--:
cYl l/1
00 r-..
mv
N""':
O'l w
-
00
0C'f!
M N
co M
O'l O'l
NM
en t.D
.-
Cvv
0l/1l/1
MWO'l
co 00 (.0
m .- .-
Nu:lm
m t.D l/1
,...... N
(.0
o
v
ui
M
1Il"
Q)tft
III C
c:::: 0
~~
~m
en@)
c::::
'.j:j ti
E ~
Q) Q)
Q.+-'
0.5
OON"
-OOv
cO-cO
I.t)VI./')
VI./')"
~uiai'
LnOON
N (Y')
(Y')
o
cYl
.
l/1
..-
en
u:l
Ln
N
Q)
III Q)
C E
QJ 0
e-o
w.s
cu....
~~
0l/1
l'- cYl
~~
coo
OM
Ml'-
co N
M
M
(D _
v-
or..:
M"'"
coo
oui
co N
M
M
CU Q)
Q.
'g ~
'r: 0
c..S
C'b
~ Q)
...J .S
~B
o~
E
~
....
Q)
0::
LO
M
M
00
l'-
Ln
IJ")
M
M
Ln
M
roi
00
"
vi"
an
M
M
Ln
M
M
co
l"-
an
Ln
M
M
lfl
M
M
co
"-
l.f)
LI1
M
M
D
I..,
.E
~
o
i:i:
..c
III
nl
U
.-
o
o
c.i
o
o
o~
o
o~
-
----
ti
Q)
L..
QJ
+-'
.5
;;E:
o
I.t)
....
o
Q)
III
[U
..c
!:::!
~
c..
..-..
o
o
t.O
o
V
Ln~
M
I"-
----
I..,
QJ
;;
~
~
o
C
o
'.j:j
U
QJ
L..
W
L..
.E
C
nl
o
...J
-
(D
r--:
"-
co
ui
Ln
N
en
w
O'l
"
0:)
Ln
co
..-
l.f)
"
v
..-
(D
o
M
N
M
0')
M'
(.0
v
l.f)
u:i
co
.-
u:l
to
r.:
ro
o
...J
C
o
ti
Q)
L..
QJ
.....
.E
v
o
ui
I./')
('1)
ui
M
M
"
u:i
M
~
N
M
"
v
0:)
l.f)
"
m
N
l.f)
M
-
o
M
r..:
N
.-
..-
,....:
v
o
ui
N
CU
Q.
'u
c::::
'c
c..
c:
[U
o
...J
~
o
E
~
.....
Q)
c::
co
(D
.
-
m
co
r..:
"
(D
~
..-
co
(D
.
-
0')
co
,,~
I"-
(.0
-
co
(.0
-
O'l
co
I'-
I'-
lO
-
co
U)
..--
m
co
"-
I'-
to
-
co
to
-
m
co
I'-~
"
to
~
..--
Q}
E
o
u
C
-0
Q.I
C
'ffi
+-'
QJ
c::
....
o
~
o
lJ1
M
M
.
IJ')
N
..--
en
tD
"
~
-
M
C'I1
IJ')
N
-
O'l
(D
"-
-
M
M
lI'i
N
-
m
CD
,....
~
..-
M
cYl
.
LI1
N
-
en
r..o
,....
-
M
M
.
O'l
-
I'-
M
M
L..
nl
QJ
>
..c
u
nl
W
~
o
"C
c::::
\JJ
~~
o
i:i:
..c
III
nl
U
".1,.- ::--J
M
to
o
N
N
o
-
-
r..:
c
o
l!!
Q.I
a.
....
QJ
C.
lJ1
~
ci:.
'C:
....
1.-
QJ
0.
III
c:
o
l!!
Q.I
0-
o
...,.
o
M
.
Lf)
O'l
o
-
V
M
I./')
co
m
en
(D
O'l
~
.....
l'-
Lf)
M
~
....
~
~
o
.c
I..,
QJ
Q.
III
D-
'C:
.... to.:
LJ') m
>.
~1.-
"C ~
L.. III
Q}..:..::
O-Q)
IfI Q)
5 ;;
ON
-CLn
0,:,;
- QJ
Q) Q)
E ;;
~ "-
VI Q)
1Il 0-
< VI
iti ~
+-1"0
0,....
Z
QJ
Ol
nl
0..
......
Ln
\.0
-<i
...,.
co
N"
o
co
M
M
.
en
-
I'-
M
M
~
o
i:i:
..c
VI
nl
U
QJ
>
'P
nl
:;
E
~
u
I
I.
I
, "
I
.-
t;
a.l
.c
V)
I.
o
~~
<0
oq-
)-t.O
M
o
o
i~
UJO
)-~
tV)
o
o
i~
IJ.JO
)-~
(Y)
o
o
~&
IJ.JO
>-~
M
o
~g
<q
UJO
)-v
t.O
M
.--..
QJ
.....
o
Z
QJ
QJ
Z~
III
QJ
::J
c::
QJ
>
QJ
1J.Ja:
0"'0
QJ
.....
ca
E
't;
UJ
OOOOl/)l/)
oooO(,OtV)
M~"":MaiM
COtV)....COO'"lCO
mcoco.-['t}......
Nt.6mO~l/)
mtV)N....l/)l/)
.... NV (Y)
M M
0........ O'"l Vl/)
~~......"!0'"l(Y)
tV)l/)cO..-t--M
CONOmOCO
O'"lMM(,Omr--
N..-~l/)O'"ll/)
O'"lVtV)OVl/)
..- NV (Y)
tV) ('t)
..-
OVV
0..-..-
(Y)
CO
O'"l
N
O'"l
..-
"":0
N ..-
N N
O'"l N
VV
N
o"..,r--
~\O\O
Ml/)CO
COo'"l"
O'"lt.O(,o
NNl/)
O'"ll/)V
.... N
5l cu
t.O~~
o Co tJ
v~.s
l/) -
('t)~~
r-- 0 ~
~tIt}-
III c:
C 0
~~
Jjm
O)@J
c:
'Z:; tl
~ ~
QJ QJ
Q.+-,
0.5
(,0 ..- l/')
co l/) (Y)
aiWM
cooco
......or-..
"M N l/)
mvl/)
M era
(Y) ('t)
tV) co l/)
oo:rotV)
"';o:iM
N('t)CO
MI./")":.
.q:'cOl/)
en M l/)
M (Y')
M (Y)
ro
.9- cu
g ~
'r: lJ
a...5
c:'t:I
ca cu
.s c:
..... .~
o cu
EO::
::J
.....
QJ
a:
p
'....
.E
~
o
tL
.c:
III
IV
U
tl
e
QJ
.....
oS
~
o
l/)
.....
o
Q)
III
ra
.c:
u
I-
:J
a..
....
Q)
~
o
I-
<4-
o
C
o
';:1
u
~
LU
I-
.E
c:
IV
o
...J
o
o
-.i
M
co
t.O
M
....
......
u1
N
M
....
v
l/)
l/)
t.ci
v
~
l/)
v
v
....
"
N
N
~
en
V
......
~
IJl
o'"l
t.O
N
l/)
c:
co
o
...J
t:
o
m
QJ
.....
.5
l/)
(,0
ai
en
M
~
IJl
v
m
......:
o
m
m
v
o
..-
.
"
co
"
l/)
v
....
l.t'l
c.ci
o
o
N
v
co
o
o:i
M
l/)
cO
M
rn
a.
'u
c
'r:
a..
c
ca
o
-1
.....
o
E
:J
+-'
QJ
0:::
CO
c.o
....
en
co
......
"..,
(,0
..-
co
to
....
en
co
....:
"
(,0
....
co
(,0
....
o'"l
co
,...:-
"
c.o
....
CO
c..o
..-
O"l
co
....:
"
c.o
....
00
1..0
....
en
co
f'..
f'..
1..0
....
QJ
E
o
lJ
E
"0
Q)
c
'iij
.....
Q)
0::
0,1-
o
~
o
t.fl
M
('t)
I.fl
N
....
0)
c.o
"..,
r
....
l.t'l
N
r--:
v
co
ui
l/)
O"l
lO
....
M
(Y)
.
l/)
N
tV)
en
.
....
N
"..,
t.6
co
....
..t
....
....
en
t.O
".
.....
M
M
t.n
N
o
t.O
c.O
o'"l
l/)
....:
.....
v
N
....
N
Q)
Cl
IV
0.
..-
o'"l
c.o
......
.....
M
(V')
t.n
N
.....
co
N
.
.....
......
v
0:5
v
U)
d
..-
!
i
~
1
~
,
e
u
,
l
~
i
J
r
l
~
en
(.0
":
.....
('t"')
M
.
IJl
N
.....
l/)
en
vi
v
M
ai
......
co
cO
en
(.0
r--
.....
....
co
Q)
>-
.c:
u
IV
L.U
-
o
"'C
C
UJ
i
o
u:
.c:
III
IV
U
~
o
tL
.c
III
co
U
Q)
>
.+:;
co
"5
E
::J
U
...........I.""f'
;.
I'
I
.....
~
Cll
..I::
U)
o
o
~g
e:::q
<0
UJV
>-~
(Y')
o
~~
_0
e::: O.
<0
UJV
lO .
M
a
a
~&
<a
LUV
>-~
M
o
o
~d
_a
e:::q
<(0
LUV
c..o
M
o
o
...-0
.-0
c:::0
<(0
LUV
)-lO
M
-
IV
....
o
z
C1)
Cll
V)
-
en
IV
:J
s:::
IV
>
IV
LUc:::
Q'C
IV
....
ro
E
't{
UJ
a In
00
MM
co ('I')
en l./')
N I"-
en
.....
000
0..........
M
co
en
N
C'I
.....
~.....:
o:::tN
vv
..fr-:
.....0
N
l./')l./')OLn
00'1 Ln V
lOMOrri
.....COOCO
l./')Vl"-I"-
omcriLn
OMCOLn
Nv M
M M
Ol.l')l.I')
C'I l.I') M
NalM
f'- <X) <X)
l/)""'f'-
Nc.6vi
MI'l.t'l
v~ M
('I') M
o M('I') f'-Nl.t'l
qlnLnV-M
M~""':NenM
COCOc.oMV<X)
C'lf'-I'N V I"-
NOMlO~c5lf)
C'lN..... N 1"-1.0
..... N"":. en
('I') M
Oenenl'NLn
OVVl/)NM
M.....~l.t'lN('I"}
COOCO.....MCO
enl.Ol.t'lVlOI'
N.... lC m c5 ~ LO
enN.....NWLn
..... NV M
M C'>.,
OM
00
M c:o
<X) ('I')
O'l O'l
N .....
O'l M
.....
lO
o
v
vi
M
"'"
IDtfl
lI'l s:::
C 0
IV
c.~
~C'I
O)@J
s:::
.~ ~
~ f!:!
Q} Q}
C-+..l
0.5
tv) I"- N If)
a O'l c.o M
.....CO...,;('I")
NI'C'lCO
C'lONI"-
~..nmlO
N.....Lt')Lf')
NV M
M M
~ <u
~ E
0.8
Jj.s
ro 04..1
o~
t-
(ij Q)
0.
'u E
s::: 0
'1: l,)
a..5
c"tJ
ro Q)
o c::
:: 'i~
o Q)
ED::
:J
+..l
(1)
0::
....
U
L-
~
~
o
u:
..c
III
ro
t::
Q}
L..
IV
+..l
.E
~
o
Ln
~
o
Q}
VI
tU
...c
~
:J
a.
en
o
cci
M
.01-
.-
M
L-
Q)
;:
o
I-
~
o
s:::
o
'p
u
Q)
L..
lJJ
L-
o
....
c:
ro
o
...J
l.t'l
o
M
tv)
l.I')
"'"
o
.-
~
v
v
v
.....
M
l.I')
~
co
l"-
e
N
M
~
.....
o
lO
c.D
N
c
ro
o
...J
c
o
t::
f!:!
Q)
+..l
C
e
l.I')
o
o
"'"
M
co
l.I')
l.I')
ai
co
I"-
lO
,....
N
.-
ai
v
v
c5
"'"
N
N
N
('I')
lO
~
c.o
N
lO
iii
C'I
N
en
Lrl
{ij
c-
.u
s:::
'C
a.
c
tU
o
...J
~
o
E
:J
+..l
Q}
0::
M
I"-
.....
O'l
co
"'"
I"-
c..o
.....
co
lO
.
.....
C'I
co
"'"
"'"
lO
.....
co
lO
.-
m
co
,..:
I"-
1,,0
~
.....
co
1,,0
0-
m
c:o
I'-
I"-
CD
~
.-
co
CD
.-
m
co
I"-
,....
W
......
Q)
E
o
u
C
"0
Q)
C
.m
....
Q)
c:::
Y-
o
~
o
If)
I,j
co
N
iii
N
.....
en
c..o
r-...
M
co
M
f'-.
"":.
.....
e
co
..f
N
.....
M
M
.
Lrl
N
.....
In
Ln
to
v
('I')
N
M
q
tv)
N
m
lO
f':
.....
M
en
Ln
N
.....
-
0'1
lO
t-:
.....
M
N
.
M
N
N
('I')
lO
N
.....
N
('I")
M
1.0
N
-
o
m
,...:
en
o
..f
m
v
oi
.-
M
(1)
0)
cu
0..
en
c.o
I"-
!
1
~
~
J
~
t
~
~
J
.....
M
M
1.0
N
.-
co
Lrl
N
I'-
en
...;
N
"'"
r-:
.....
en
lO
'"
.....
l-
ro
Q)
>-
..c
u
tU
UJ
~
o
"'C
C
L.U
~
o
u:
..c
VI
ro
U
~
o
u:
..c
en
ro
U
Qj
>
'p
tU
"5
E
:J
U
c\'.
.....
, .
:':.<
"
.'
.;
'l"
.,.
..... '.
OVO"NO
.- N lnO
to
ffl
>-o:a..~o:z
<(::>ii:lfic:to
~~l-?;~~
UJ-ffi_o:L1J
a...... .....UJQ.
. L1J Q. UJo.. Q.
lI)Q.lI) ffi
~~z~~Q.
oO::@<(UJI-
~::Cl-ffic~~
> Q. u
t
<
0:
UJ
?;
o
I-
.,.' ..
.,
'.. \~.
: ,_.. , .... ................,.,..,
i
I
!
!
~..?;\~
o ctI ctI
o :J QJ
oic>-
~lf)
....
..
U)
::E
0:
UJ
I-
Z
<(
9
L1JU)::E
~!Zffi
et:L1J1-
I;;~
LLl<(
0:0...
LLJ-I
!zUJ
->
UJ
...J
QJ
0)
ctI
0...
.....
.-
~
Q.)
Q.)
..s=
V)
o
o
~~
~1O
~
o
o
i: &
w<.D
Ln
~
.-
o
o
~~.
~ILn
~~
o
o
NO
~O
o
~l.O
>-1./')
~
o
~
c..
0::::
UJ
~
o
I-
UJ
<
c..
o
o
o
""0
~O
<lO
WI./')
>-'I;t
-
Q.)
+-'
o
Z
Q)
CLI
Z~
I/)
Q.)
::::l
c:
QJ
>
QJ
W~
0-0
QJ
+-'
rn
E
.~
w
0.....
qlO
("I') I"-
COl"-
0'1 CO
N I./')
0'1 to
....
....
.....cn~Ln
t!)("I')O("l')
daiw("l')
lOMLnCO
00.-("1')"':
OOI"-Ln.....
~O('<")I"-
NN .-
..... ....
ONNCOMtn
OO"lmol"-1;'1')
MtDaiOtDM
ooml"-NMOO
O'1I"-I"-N'l;t1"-
NOO.....~N.-
0'1 to 1.00 ("I') I"-
..... N N .....
.... .....
o
q
("I')lJ"lc:ci....
COl"-lJ"l'l;t
cn~'l;tlJ"l
N~.... ...;
m lO I./')
N
.....
.....
00 (X) N
..... ..... 00
I"- In
~M
c:ciM
I./') CO
1"-1"-
.... 0'1 .....
ON I"-
N ....
.... .....
OOOOlJ"ll.l)
qM~I"-M~
MNLf)oq:.....M
00("1')..... COO 00
enO'lmo("l')1"-
N ("I') (JJ en I"-
en<.DLnmNI"-
r- Nr- r-
r-
..... ....
Ov'l;t
Ot.l')ln
('l")u)m
ooCOt!)
m ..... r-
Nl.OO'I
m lO Lf)
..... N.....
r-
<.D
o
~
vr
M
1/)1"-
Q)tA
III c:
r::: 0
8.~
~m
C)@l
r:::
'.;i 1:;;
l:! ~
~l:l
0.5
lO ..... Ln
'I;t....M
cit--:("I')
('I")'l;tCO
COOl"-
u5'Lri..-
mNI"-
..... r-
~ QJ
5i ~
~u
w-S
-401
S QJ
~~
"@ OJ
C-
'u E.
c: 0
'1:: U
c....5:
c:'tI
~ QJ
..J . t:
....B
0&
E
::::l
+-'
Q)
0:::
.....
+-'
U
~
oS
~
a
u:
.c:
I/)
8
.......
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
.....
..........
~
~
Q.)
+-'
.E
~
o
Ln
....
a
Q)
1Il
ro
.c:
~
::::l
a..
.--..
o
o
(JJ
o
'<:t
Lf)
M
I"-
----
L-
Q)
;:
~
....
a
c:
o
'p
u
Q)
L-
LU
L-
.E
c:
ro
o
..J
.....
t!)
.
l"-
I"-
co
LI'i
lJ")
N
en
r.o
en
I"-
co
lJ")
(X)
....
vi
I"-
v~
....
lO
o
M
.
N
M
en
('I")
t!)
v
Ln
lO
00
.....
lO
t!)
c:
ro
o
..J
c:
o
tl
~
Q)
+-'
.s
~
o
tD
Ln
M
lJ"l
M
M
I"-
lO
('I")
V
N
M
l"-
v
c:ci
Ln
I"-
ai
N
Ln
M
....
o
M
r--
N
.....
.....
l"-
v
o
tn
N
rn
C-
'0
c:
'C
c..
c:
ro
o
..J
.....
a
E
::::l
+-'
Q.)
0::
OJ
lO
.....
0"1
co
LI'i
co
If)
co
(JJ
.
.....
m
co
Ln
co
t.I')
00
lO
.
.......
0"1
co
lJ")
co
lJ")
00
lO
m
00
lfl
co
Lf1
00
lO
.
.....
en
co
l/')
co
l/')
Q)
E
o
u
.s
-0
Q)
c:
'Cij
+-'
Q)
~
.....
a
~
o
In
('<")
<"1
II")
N
....
I"-
r--..
lO
('I")
M
vi
N
.....
r--:
f'-
r.o
M
('<")
lJ1
N
.....
r--:
'"
t.O
('I")
("I')
Ln
N
.....
l"-
f'-
t.O
.......
co
lO
o
co
N
00
lJ")
o
~
......
---
L-
ro
Q)
>-
.c
u
ro
UJ
.....
a
'C
c
w
"i
o
u:
.c:
1Il
ro
U
M
lO
ci
N
N
c5
lfl
lO
c::
o
l!!
QJ
0.
L-
QJ
a.
I./')
(,C)
a.
'C
+-'
L-
III
0.
1Il
c:
o
l!!
III
0.
o
N
.....
o
M
vi
en
o
M
'"
cn
co
O"l
cn
lO
cn
vi"
en
N
~~
::::l
o
.c:
L-
Q.)
a.
V)
0.
'c
+-' L
v m
~
~L-
""O~
L. 1Il
lll.:.!
c-QJ
III QJ
5 ~
ON
.c:lfl
o ~
.....~
Q) OJ
E ~
::::l L-
V) QJ
I/) 0.
< III
iU ~
......""0
~I"-
Cl.l
Cl
rn
0-
.-
.--..
If)
M
II")
If)
.....
.....
co
M
----
.--..
co
lO
o
co
N
co
lJ")
o
......
---
::
..Q
u...
.c:
1Il
ro
U
Q)
>
.~
rtI
"5
E
::::l
U
.-
04-1
ll.l
ll.l
.c:
U')
o
o
~~
wtl')
"":.
.-
o
o
i8
<ui
LUtI')
>-"d:.
o
o
i~
<uS
>-~
.
......
o
o
i~
Wtl')
>-v
o
~g
<q
WCD
tI')
'<::t.
.-
.-..
Q)
04-1
o
Z
Q)
ll.l
Z~
III
Q)
~
c::
Q)
>
Q)
c:
"'0
Q)
.....
CIl
E
j1
o 00 0 tI') If)
ooOOCD('I')
M~r--:C"icriC"i
co('l').-ooenco
en 00 oo.-('I')f':
NuSai'W~.-
O'l('l')NNtI')l'
.- NN .-
~ -
.... ....
0........
ql'l'
('I"l tI') CO
CO N 0
Q") M M
'N~~
O'lVM
.... N
..-
o tI') tI')
Otl')tI')
C"iuien
COVN
enVV
N lI') CO
O'lVM
.... N
envll')
N en M
....t--:C'I"l
moco
tOO')I'
.... m..-
Nvl'
N .-
.... ....
IJ')Otl')
oq-....M
or-.:cvi
!'-coco
1J')1'l'-
r-:ui.-
'-Vl'
N .....
.- .-
OvvW.-tI')
O..-.-COll')M
C"it--:cicritDM
(()N.-COOOO
c:nNNl'-OI'
N"a)NcYiN.-
mvv.-vl'
..... NN .-
.-
.- .-
O,....."MCOtl')
OLnLno;:tQM
Mvioj~cOM
COO')I'-NMCO
en c.o c.o M tI') I'
NNuiooOo-
cntl')v...-('I')I'-
.- NN .....
c.o
o
V
tI')
('I')
1/11'-
",tit
III c::
c:: 0
8.~
J1cn
C)@J
c
.;:; ~
~ ~
'" Q)
0......
0..5
.- ,.....
mQJrnQ}
0.
c:: E .:; E
Q) 0 ... 0
a. .. c:: ..
X ... 'C ...
UJ.5a..5
~~C"t3
o2:~Q}
I- ...J.S
.....!g
~&
~
.....
Q)
c:
ti
Q)
~
Q)
04-1
C
~
o
III
"4-
o
ClJ
VI
(IJ
J:.
U
~
~
Q,.
.....
Q)
~
~
\I-
o
c:
o
';j
u
Q)
~
UJ
.....
.E
c:
nl
S
o
o
~
M
CO
c.o
M
....
"
lI')
N
M
,.....
V
tI')
tI')
CD
V
V
ui
V
.q-
......
r'
N
N
a1
V
,....
Ln
vi
O'l
u:l
N
tI')
c
~
...J
c:
o
ti
E
Q)
.....
.E
lJ')
r..o
cri
cn
M
~
IJ')
'Ct
"1
I'-
o
q
O"l
V
o
..-
.
,....
CO
I'-
tI')
V
.-
lJ')
r..o
o
o
N
V
ro
~
CO
('()
Lf)
CO
M
[ij
a.
'u
c:
'1::
0-
C
-9
"4-
o
E
::l
.....
&
co
c.o
.
.-
m
CO
~
tI')
CO
tI')
CO
CD
.
.-
m
CO
If)
CO
tI')
ex>
CD
.
....
O"l
ex>
tI')
ex>
tI')
CO
c.o
.
.-
m
ex>
tI')
ex>
tI')
ex>
\S)
.
,.....
O'l
CO
tI')
ex)
If)
Q)
E
o
u
c::
"C
Q)
c:
'(ij
.....
Q)
c:
.....
o
~
Q
IJ")
M
M
tI')
N
tI')
~
~
ex)
tI')
M
q
tI')
.-
l"'-
I'-
c.o
M
M
vi
N
.-
r-:
,....
CD
M
m
.-
N
,....
C15
tI')
ro
o:i
M
C'I"l
u1
N
.-
,..:
I'
CD
o
w
r..o
O"l
lJ')
.-
CO
r..o
ro
::. N
Q)
Cl
(Q
0..
cYl
C'I"l
vi
N
co
N
.-
,..:
,....
c.o
....
,....
'<:t
~
o
q
ro
C'I"l
cYl
vi
N
.-
,..:
,.....
to
lI'l
cn
u1
V
ro
,....
N
ro
N
'1
~
~
j
J
r
! ;
~
i
1
,
I
I
I
r
L..
(Q
Q)
>-
..c
u
nl
W
\I-
o
"'0
c:
UJ
'i
o
a:
..c
III
nl
U
~
u:
.t:
VI
(IJ
U
ell
>
'p
l'll
:;
E
::l
U
I
I
I.
I'.
.-
~
C1.I
.s:::.
V)
o
~!
WUl
>- o:t'h
....
o
o
~ci
.-0
o
<c,g
L1'I
>-"f:
o
o
~&
<c,g
wL1'l
>- Vh
....
o
~~
....0
o
<w
L1'I
>- Vh
....
o
~~
.-0
c: O.
<c,g
LIl
>- V.
U)
C1.I
:::I
c:
QJ
>
W~
C-c
C1.I
....
ro
E
.~
w
OL1'l
00
Mev)
co M
0') lfl
h _
Nf'oo.
en
....
000
o .... ....
M
co
en
N
en
....
....
OMM
Olfllfl
C'Ii~r...:
COCOc,g
en/"-/"-
NOM
en N ....
.... N
OMM
OVV
f"i~~
COCCO
en c,g lfl
NWm
m N ....
.- N
OM
00
McO
CO M
en m
N....
m M
....
....
lfllflOlfl
omlflV
tDrriof"i
....00000
I.I')Vf'oo.f'oo.
ci vf M ....
OI.l')OOf'oo.
NN ....
.... ....
.q:r...:
o:t"N
vo:t'
.q:f'oo.
....0
N
OLr.lfl
0') lfl M
NaiM
l'- 00 00
lflf'oo.f'oo.
tOu)....
Vf'oo.f'oo.
N ....
.... ....
f'oo.Nlfl
V....M
NcnC'li
("I") V 00
NVf'oo.
N- 0 ....
Vf'oo.!'-
N ....
.... ....
f'oo.Nlfl
LnNM
uiNM
....Moo
Vc,gf'oo.
W.q:....:
("I")I.P!'-
N ....
.- ....
Mf'oo.NLn
Oml.PM
....o:iu-iM
Nf'oo.enCO
en 0 N......
.q:"":ai'-:
NMlflf'oo.
N N r-
.... r-
QJ
I/) Q)
c: E
1O C1.I 0
o ~ to)
"f:w..5
lfl-=....
M .::: Q)
1/)1'-0'<:
Q)~1-
~ c:
Q) 0
c.~
JjO"l
C)@
c:
',p t:
C! ~
Q) W
c.....
01:
-
W
....
o
Z
QJ
C1.I
lJ)
"-"
~Q)
'0 E
c 0
"I: to)
c..-5
c:"t:l
~ Q)
...J . S
-!3
o Q)
EO::
:::I
....
Q)
0:
.'
U
k
.g
~
o
i:L
.c
III
ro
t:
W
~
III
~
1:
#:
o
lfl
"-
o
W
VI
ro
.c
u
~
:J
c..
~
W
~
o
I-
<I-
o
c:
o
'p
u
W
~
UJ
~
.E
c:
ro
o
...J
lfl
q
M
(\')
lfl
,..:
o
....
.q:
~
v
.q:
....
M
lfl
~
00
,.....
o
N
M
V
....
o
1.0
1O
N
('I')
o
00
M
en
....
M
c:
ro
o
...J
c:
o
t:
l!:!
W
....
1:
o
lfl
ci
o
,.....
M
00
lfl
If)
m
00
f'oo.
lD
I'-
N
....
cn
v
v
o
,.....
N
N
N
M
c,g
.q:
1.0
N
lD
LO
m
N
m
lfl
(ij
0-
'u
c:
'r:
0-
c:
ns
o
...J
-
o
E
:J
....
Q)
0:
('I')
r--;
....
O'l
00
lIi"
00
lfl
00
lD
....
en
00
LIl
00
lfl
00
1.0
.
....
en
00
lfl
co
lfl
00
lD
.
....
m
00
l.f'l
co
lfl
co
lD
r-
m
00
lJ")
co
\J')
QJ
E
o
u
E
'"C
QJ
s::
'ffi
....
QJ
0::
<4-
o
~
o
If)
co
N
vi
N
.-
('I')
00
M
,.....
V
h
....
N
V
00
f'oo.
f'oo.
c,g
M
('I')
tri
N
lfl
lfl
o::i
V
("I")
.q:
V
I'-
r-:
....
,...:
,.....
U)
("I")
M
I.T)
N
....
,..:
,.....
t.O
("I")
N
M
N
N
,..:
t.O
o
,..:
("I")
('I')
lfl
N
o
m
r...:
en
o
ci
m
M
ui"
. ('f)
C1.I
en
n:I
0..
.....
,...:
,.....
t.O
M
M
vi
N
....
,...:
,.....
t.O
00
U'l
N
I'-
m
N
.....
,.....
lIi"
'-
(U
Q)
>-
.c
u
(U
W
<I-
o
-c
c:
w
~-
o
u:
.c
I/)
C'3
U
~
o
u:
.c
I/)
ra
U
Q)
>
'p
ro
'5
E
::1
U
N
$
.t:
V)
!z
UJe:::
~~
~~
a:: a::
zL5
<(...J
OUo::
...JLL.
u..O
~~~
5u
co
~.-
u
V)
<.'
.',
OC1Vr...MO....OOr...NOCOLO....O
OCOlllOMMNl'oo-lOWOV....OlllO
IWOO~mNWOO~~W~~~cidci
c OLOlIlC1c.cOWc.c~c.cc.c~MmO
C'O VMONCOLOmcn....NCOlllC1Vl'oo-
...JO~~OMMO~~~mm~~OOM
~M....COU')NCOVOlJ')OU')C1Mc.cCO
WoIr...l'oo-WWlOLIlLllLOVVMNN....
i
....Lnl'oo-MVCO.....OVLONNNLnO
.-MVr...OOlJ')....enlOlON....LOLO
,..,: .... co W u) cxi u) ~ ,..,: 0'; V; N m ~ ci
VOlllMLOMOCOOC1C1MVooO
O~ M~ r... V~ M In O. "" en M N W V~ f'._ r...
Lrlr...mN...,;a5N~m~m~Oc.cM
NNNMMMVVVlJ')LOlOr...l'oo-CO
~
V OCON....r--VU')....OMMMOlJ')
lJ')('I"'J....C1WIn....lJ')r...OOVlJ')....O
tDNui..o,...:ui,...:c.cuioci-o:i~oci-~('I')
00 ('I"'J r-.. C1 r-- C1 N V N M M 0 CO 'It' ('I')
~~~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ci::-~
lOc.cc.cU'lU')lflVV..q.MMNN....
J
U") 1Il 1Il U') lJ') lJ') U') LO U') U") lJ') In LIl
lOlOlJ:lc.cI.OWl.OlOlOWI.OI.OW
MMMMC'I'lMMMC'l'ienMMM
M('I')('I')('I"')MMMMMMMMM
NNNNNNNN.NNNNN
LOLl')
lO Ln
Men
MM
NN
-
......-...-.......-..-...-.....r-..-~r-....'r-'....
C1mcnmC1cncncnC1C1C1enenO"lO"l
~I
....NMVLO
....NMvLOc.cf'.COm~....................
. . ~.J .
. I
.-
cv
C'l
(U
0.
";." ,
(1')
1U
IV
.s:;:
V)
LLl
!z
m
-
o
o
Iw
CO
:Jo::t
o -
If)
<(~
~JO
c
ClI
o
-1
1"0
o C
'p Cll
'C: ~
uO
III If)
IV,,-
o 0
0,)
III
CO
~
~
:J
a.
0-
.......
L.:
ClI
0,)
>-
~
c:: u
08]
'p "-
:J 0
..c
'C: "'C
titfi
i:3 1Il-
"C C'l
c:: .5
ca E
III ClI
1::UJ
IV "0
E IV
~.5
a.19
c: IV
ClIO:
.90
H' ~"._ <. ~
I
(
!
\
,
i
!
~,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
-Mm<.oco.-\"-..mOONIf).-M
Mt.n('f)V~lJ)c..o(Y')OONVIOr--
crio"":"":Mu-;tri,,"':criccicdai
NNMMMMMMMM(Y')('l")
M('I")('t')('t')('t')('t')('t')('f)(Y')M('I')MM(Y')CO
M('1')('t')M('1') ('I')(Y')('1')(Y')M('I") (Y')Mf'I1N
LriviIf)Lriuiu;u;Lnu;t.nLnu;t.nlJ")ln
NNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
.....r-.....~.....-.-....-........-........-..-.........-r-
r-: ,..: r-: ,....- "",- r-..- r-.. - ,....- ,..: r-: ,..: r-: r-: 1'-- ,..:
r-..r-r-..r--r-l'-l'-"r--l'-r--l'-l'-l'-l'-
wc..oWWc.DWt.P(,OWt.P(.OWWlOW
0-
o-NM'lTL/)!.Dl'-C0010
0-
o-NMo;l'ln
~ ...- ........ ..- .-.
Q)
C)
ra
a.
,~~'~ : '. '. ':"
"', ,.,
~ "~ . .
, .
~... ~-'-~. ~
.-
"
r. "I
'.
r
i
.'
-
\
...,,'...... .
"',
I'
'r
0 1,0 0 ,.... NO ~~l!!
.... V IJ')O o tv tv
o :J CI.l
vi . c >-
4fl O'lCI,O
<(
>-o:::a..~o:::z
<~E:W<(O
OOt-WuJV)
o::::I:a:?:>-C:::
Wo:::Wc:::c:::~
Q.WQ.WW
V)Q.V)Q.Q.c:::
gs~ZV)~~
O_O>-WI-
.. D::V><(WV)
~' :I: I- ffi Cl ?: 0
> Q. U
t
<:
0::
W
3:
~
'wv>:;:r
!;t!zffi
O:WI-
Ii;~
We(
C:::Q.
W-1
'!z W
->
w.
Vi ...J
~
c:::
W
I-
Z
e(
o
...J
....,:}
....a....<"'"I:.
t I
i i
o.
i
I
....
Q)
Cl
(U
Cl..
, .
.-
.....
111
Q.J
.s:;
tJ)
o
ig
<q
wO
>-'I::t
c.o
M
o
jg
<q
o
>-'I::t
c.o
-
M
o
o
i'&
UJO
>-'I::t
c.o
M
o
~g
<q
UJO
>-'I::t
\,D
M
o
o
d
....0
0:::0
<0
UJ'I::t
>-c.o
M
-
Q.J
./.-J
o
Z
Q)
Q)
Z~
VI
C1.I
~
~
C1.I
>
C1I
0:::
"'C
Q)
....
ro
E
'tl
UJ
ow
00
rr;"";
CO .-
m <<.0
N lJl
en .-
.....
O'lt'lt
0.-.....
rr;
CO
O"l
N
en
.-
W'l;f'I'<<.o
OO"l"!<<.o
~lJ'Ic.ocri
O"lOlJ'l'l;f'
lJl'l;f''l;f'O''l
c:ci....C'flr-:
OMI'lJ'I
N'I:t.,....N
("I") M
("I")t.P
('I") ....
O"l O"l
O'lN
NN
N
WO'lW
CO .- c.o
rr;~0"l
CO ('I") V
O.-O"l
"":ai"f'.-
....lnln
'I::t....N
('I") M
O<<.oc.o'l::tf'.-W
C!c.oc.oMfJ)fJ)
MNui~~cri
CO f'.-ln 'l::t0"l V
O"l~ 0 0 O'l O'l O"l
NMlOM..nl'
O"lVCI"lO.q-LO
.... NV....N
M M
01'1'
ONN
Mr--:d
CON....
O"l .... ....
N
O'l
....
LncO
Ln'l::t
N
('I")I'W
\'--OU)
enocri
CO'l;f'v
CO en O"l
.... M f'.-
O"l M Ln
('I")....N
M ('I")
ovo;tlOOfJ)
OLnln'l::tCOc.o
critDaidcicn
COCOc,oMCOV
O'l.-.....COCOO"l
NlOcri' ON f'.-
cnc.olnCONLn
.- N C'fl .- N
C'fl ('I")
lO
o
V
\..n
C'fl
ID~
VI ~
~ 0
8.~
~en
O)@
~
'p t:
~ Q)
- "-
III Q)
a.....
0..5
~ Q)
~ ~
a. I.J
~.$
ro w
.....~
r=.-
(ij Q,)
a.
'u E
~ 0
'C u
0...$
C'b
~ Q)
.....J .1::
"-~
~&
;:J
.....
Q)
0:::
....
.E
~
o
tL
..s::
VI
ro
U
-
o
o
ci
o
o
o
o
o
....
'-'
t:
~
Q)
....
~
~
o
LJ"l
"-
o
5l
ro
.c
~
:J
0..
..-..
o
o
u:)
o
v~
LJ"l
en
r--..
....,
"-
C1I
;:
o
I-
"-
o
~
o
'p
u
~
UJ
l-.
.g
l:
ro
.9
I.D
C!
.....
....
I.D
LI'l
....
">t
....
('I")
('I")
O"l
O"l
N
W
c.o
N
I'
o
en
V
f'.-
N
r...:
N
.-
In
LJ"l
V
tn
t.O
CO
.-
W
c.o
l:
ro
o
-'
l:
o
t:
Q.l
....
III
./.-J
..s
r-..
N
c.o
\..n
">t
('Ii
I'-
.....
cn
.-
~
M
.-
cri'
l./')
.-
f'.-
U)
~
cn
q
LJ"l
V
.-
r-..
o
o
'l;f'
cn
M
M
....
o
CO
ci
CO
CO
N
N
..-
ro
c.
'u
c:
'c
0..
c:
ro
.3
"-
o
E
~
./.-J
Q)
0:::
M
CO
~
r-..
cn
c:ci
N
U)
.
....
M
CO
~
f'.-
cn
c:ci
N
c,o
~
....
M
CO
~
I'
en
c:ci
N
c.o
.-
M
CO
oct-
f'.-
O"l
05
N
W
....
M
CO
~
f'...
O"l
CO
N
c.o
....
Q)
E
o
u
..s
"C
III
~
'(ij
./.-J
III
0:::
"-
o
~
o
Ln
f'...
....
N
V
o
CO
.-
CO
....
f'-
....
N
V
o
05
....
CO
-
.-
"""
....
.
N
V
o
cO
.-
CO
....
I'-
....
N
'It
o
CO
....
CO
.-
r-..
.....
ui
M
W
N
CO
l-.
ro
Q)
>-
.e
u
ro
w
"-
o
"'0
C
LU
'i
o
u::
.e
VI
ro
U
v
CO
oci-
o
CO
~
In
M
r-..
c
o
~
Q)
C.
I...
Q)
C.
In
tI}
c:.
'C
./.-J
....
III
C.
VI
c:
o
~
Q)
a.
o
V
I'-
c.o
N
W
f'.-
c.o
M
lJ'I
LJ"l
o
lJ'I
ci
N
r-..
CO
....
r-..
M
.-
......
;:J
o
.J::
l-.
Q)
C.
VI
0-
'C
.... ~
In m
>.
~l...
"'0 8.
.... VI
Q),:.,(.
c.Q)
VI C1)
5 ;:
ON
.elf)
o
.-
C1.I
OJ
ro
a..
.-
V
M
cO
I'--
lO
o
o
O"l
I'--
....
.
c.o
M
c.o
N
CO
.:Z
III
Q) Q)
E ::
;:J ....
VI C1I
VI a.
<( VI
a; ~
./.-J"'C
Of'.-
Z
:t
o
u::
.J::
VI
ro
U
Q)
>
.~
l'O
"5
E
:l
U
!"j"',"",
.-
...
Q)
III
..c
V)
o
~~
<0
w"lt'
)o-t.O
M
e
o
~g
< -
wO
)o-~
('1')
o
o
i~
We
>-~
('1')
z
<
Z
i:i:
<(
::i
0:
o
o
~~
< -
we
>-~
M
o
ig
<q
o
)-v
t.O
M
-
QJ
...
o
Z
QJ
QJ
If)
.......
CI\
aJ
:J
c:
aJ
>
aJ
wo:
C"C
aJ
...
['Il
E
~
o
o
M
co
en
N
en
....
o
q
t'f")
co
en
N
en
~,
o
o
('1')
00
en
N
0')
.....
e
o
M
00
en
N
en
....
o
o
M
00
0')
N
0')
.....
00
qq
Mr--.
00 .....
mq
N'r--.
C"lV
...."'t
M
00
00
Mr--:
00.....
eno
Nr--.
C"lv
....v
M
00
00
cvit...:
co....
mo
N"':
mv
.....v
('1')
00
00
rrir--:
co -
en 0
N"':
env
....v
M
00
oq
rrir--.
00....
eno
N t-..-
env
-"It'
M
~ cu ro 1IJ
c: E .9- E
t.eaJogo
o ~ I.J '1: I.J
v LLJ.5 a..5
~el~~-g
VI ,.... 1-0 ~ .3 .5
aJtfl \l-ftJ
VI c: 0 ~
c: 0 ...
~~ EO::
~m .a
C)@J ~
.5 .....
..... III
e! ~
QJ QJ
a......
O.E
o
q
r--.
....
e
,..:
v
v
M
e
o
r...:
.....
o
,..:
v
V
M
o
o
r..:
....
o
,..:
v
V
M
o
o
r--:
....
o
,..:
v
v
M
o
o
r--:
.....
o
,..:
v
v
M
u
....
.E
~
o
i:i:
..c
III
co
t;j
~
III
.....
.s
~
o
IJ}
\I-
o
&l
['Il
..c
~
::::I
0.
....
QJ
::
o
I-
\I-
o
c:
o
";:;
u
~
w
....
~
c:
fa
o
.-J
c:
['Il
o
-J
c:
o
~
aJ
.....
c:
m
c-
'G
c:
'1:
a.
c:
['Il
o
-J
\I-
o
E
:J
.....
QJ
0:
o
1I1
<:0
o
1.0
M
N
r--.
-
....
o
IJ}
03
o
IJ}
M
N
t-..
....
o
LO
cO
o
LO
M
N
,....
.-
o
Lf'l
c:ci
o
in
M
N
f':.
r-
o
in
o:i
o
LI1
('I')
N
f':.
....
cu
E
o
u
.E
"0
QJ
c:
'Cij
1iJ
0:::
'5
~
o
If')
o
LO
co
o
Lf'l
M
N
r--.
v
C'I1
1'--
v
('I')
-
N
,....
en
vi
.-
.....
o
LO
00
o
LO
('1')
N
"
v
00
co
M
00
00
V
N
o;f
.....
r-
o
If')
cO
o
LO
('I')
N
,....
V
M
ci
M
('1')
Lf'l
N
IJ")
N
....
.-
N
(JJ
0'1
'ra
0..
o
IJ)
00
o
LO
[\")
N
,....
v
co
....
N
co
.-
.-
o
co
ci
.-
o
LO
co
o
LO
('1')
N
"
v
('I')
rri
r-
M
00
,....
o
O'l
....
....
ro
cu
>-
..c
u
ra
UJ
"I-
o
"'0
c:
w
::-
o
Li:
..c
VI
ca
U
::
o
Li:
.e.
lI)
(g
u
cu
>
.;:;
.!2
::J
E
::::I
U
W'V....
.....
~
Q)
.s::.
V)
o
o
~g
a::q
<0
UJ~
)-otD
M
o
o
~~
UJV
tD
('t')
o
o
~g
a::q
o
v
>-~
C'I"l
o
o
~o
.-0
o
<0
UJV
>-~
('t')
c.
ex:
UJ
3:
o
t-
UJ
o
o
~ci
...-0
o::q
o
V
>- l.D_
('t')
<(
0-
..-..
IV
......
o
Z
Q)
Q)
V)
......
III
Q)
:::J
C
Q)
>
UJ&
C1-c
Q)
+J
fll
E
~
,:
o
o
('t')
CO
en
N
m
.-
o
o
evi
CO
m
N
en
.-
o
o
('t')
CO
m
N
m
.-
o
o
('t')
CO
en
N
m
.-
o
o
('t')
CO
m
N
en
.-
00 0
00 0
evi"": ,...:
00..... .-
ma 0
N'r-: r-:
mv V
.-v v
M' M
00 0
qq q
('t')1'- I'-
CO..- ....
ma 0
N' t--- ,...:-
env v
.....~ ~
('t') ('t')
00 0
oq 0
evil'- .....:
co..... .-
ma 0
N't-: ,...:
mv V
-v ~
t\o) M
00
00
('t') 1"-
CO.....
mo
N'r-..
env
.-v
('t')
00
00
M ,..:
CO.-
eno
NI'-
mv
.....v
('\")
~ \U
lO ~ ~
o a. 0
~~.s
lI')-.w
M fJ \U
tIl~~~
Q)
II) C
C 0
2i~
Jjm
Cl@J
C
';:; tt
~ ~
Q) Q)
a.......
05
~\U
'g ~
'C 0
0...5
C"tJ
fll 1U
.3 t:
- .~
o QJ
ECc:
::J
.....
IV
ex:
o
o
to-
.-
o
to-
v
v
('\")
o
o
to-
.-
o
I'-
~
~
M
.~
...
.E
:t
.Q
LL
J::
VI
C'll
1;;
Q)
...
Q)
.....
C
s
lI')
-
o
Q)
II)
fll
.c:
u
.....
::1
0..
...
Q)
~
o
t-
-
o
C
o
.;:;
u
~
UJ
I....
.E
C
m
o
-l
C
m
.3
C
o
1;;
~
Q)
.....
C
(ij
a.
'D
C
't:
a.
t:
fll
o
-l
-
o
E
::J
.....
CV
a::
o
L/")
cO
o
L/")
M
N
to-
.-
o
L/")
00
o
In
M
N
I'-
.-
o
L/")
o::i
o
In
M
N
I"-
.....
o
L/")
cd
o
In
M
N
l':.
....
o
L/")
cO
o
L/")
('t')
N
I":.
.....
Q)
E
o
u
C
"'0
Q)
C
'n;:
......
(11
0:::
.,...
o
~
o
IJ')
o
lI')
cO
o
lI')
M
N
I'-
~
co
ai
co
co
a;-
eo
In
;q:
N
.-
o
In
cO
o
l.r)
('t')
N
I'-
~
M
-
...-
.....
eo
M
lO
lO
eo
N
N
o
1.1')
cO
o
lI')
M
N
I'-
~
co
N
to-
eo
N'
~
.-
.....
-
....
N
o
LO
o::i
o
LO
M
N
1"--
v
('\")
~
c.o
M
a;-
.-
v
m
.....
('t)
Q)
Cl
(U
a..
.....
o
Ln
cO
o
In
M"
N
to-
-
.-
v
00
vi
lI')
co
lI')
m
tD
,...:
.....
I....
fll
Q)
)-0
J::
u
ro
w
-
o
"'0
C
W
~-
a::
J::
II)
ro
U
~
o
a::
..c
III
ro
U
Q)
>
'p
~
::J
E
::J
U
:~. ". . ~'.
~, '.
'r
.,....
". ,
"
Ii
, '.
, ,
, ..
. (~ . I
~I' ...
~: . -~ '. ~
,.
t:: .~.
-"+'.. ~~-7r..,t:r~i;..~0f ~o;t-,...~~: ;",~ ..1....:~ '..... "I'
. ~ .h,. ~ .. ............ 4
1
!
.'
.,. OOVlD""O
I~ " ' ON.-VNO
~I"; .,; .,; 0 <6 0
c: UONOOO')Vl
:'; tu CVVlLllU'1V
0 (U --......-
0' -VlNCX)N('\")
..J &\M.-""M""
" ,.....lD'l:tM.-
~. .
,.,
0 "" t-- 0') ""
000 lD .- N
'1 cici .;. ..t ui
, !z oov en ('\") LIl
'::. 00 en 0') .- V
, . UJo:: .- N('I")~ ui aiC'li
~UJ 0.. N('\")V 1J')f'.
>-1- .- .- ..... .- .-
. , ~<
UJ:: V "" W V to
0::0:::
z~ l/') NlD .- 0
N i c.d ""N C't') W-
i: .-
<...J CO Nt-- C't') .- 4l
Q) au .- .-0 0') to C)
.s:: ..Ju. u5uirri" aiui Cll
a.
V) u.o t,Dl/')...t" No-
: ~~
..j-
" ::;)u v V v v 'It
eOI- ('\") C't') ~ ('\") ('\")
~I-< J r-..: r-..: I'-- r-..: r-..:
lD to lD to c.o
U 00000
II) aiai'cri' aiai'
ooead) 000:;)
r- ...... ..- ~ ..-
~I
;:. .-NMVLIl
I
!
j
~..;............~",.....Ir~"'i.I"''''''-.''
~f~""',
:t]}.1," ~.
,.,\..,.~. >'.j;": "
" T ,,\., -, ~ ',r., ,
I
i,
,\
-:- >' ~
~~~~~::R~~::R~~~~~~
l..O ~ N "O:t N 01 C1") CO U") C1")' f"ow en 0 ..... .-
,....C'I1McnW.....cnN'f.tUlUlUllOlDlO
oq:~m~,...:cricri...r.q:oq:oc:i-q:..;..;~
U:>(00100000000000
..-........-..-...-~........--~r-...-
"'" I"- ...... "'" ...... 000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
..... .- ..... ..... ..... Ln Ln Ul Ul LI"l LI"l LI"lLl"l Ul lJ'l
N N N NN cdcda:i cci CO cci ccio:iccicci
'f.t o;t 'f.t 'I:t 'I:t 000 0 0 0 0000
OOOOOLl"lLl"l UlUlUllJ'l lJ'lUlLnLl"l
05 ex) cci ex) as M M rri M C'ri M M- M- M M
..... .- ............-NNNNNN N N N N
cxt CO_ ~ ~ oq, f': ......._ ,.... ,.... ,........... "'" "- "- "'"
- -
...-...-.............-......,..-~~................-.....tr-'..-
C'I1 .....
~ ~O II)
OJ .-NM'l:tUlW"CCcn 0 ..- N M ~ LI"l C)
-'= L: ...... ..... .... .... .... .-' tIS
V) tIS 0-
Q,)
>-
.s=
c u
m
0 w
"P .....
~ 0
c ..a
m "C "C
0 .ta c:
-l l.U
<( ra -
o c III
Z .- (It "tJ 0)
IX ... c: c
w ~ tIS .-
!z '5 0 l!l ~
lIl\nc\JJ
Q)~G>"C
o 0 E Q,)
(1) ~.5
III
(It 0-I9
...c: c: Q,)
~ coO::
~ o~
a. -10
"
t~,
:t.
~."..,.
~
/<' .-
t . ~~~ .
~, .
~: .
','
I.
'.
. ,.
. .
.\'1'
;..,
OVOI"-
.- N
>-0:9:~
<(::Jo:W
OOI-W
0::I:0::!:
WO:Wo:
a..Wa..W
Ula..C/)a..
e:::C/)ZC/)
::Ja..O>-
~.. 0 C2 Ul <C
:I:I-O:C
W
> a..
t
<(
0:
W
~
<
2
i:i:
v
<(
~
e:::
~
0::
c..
NO
1Jl~
Lfl
to')
0:2
i1j0
>-~
o:W
wa..
0..0:
~~
~ln
3:0
u
. , " .~
" . ,.;
..- ..~.!
.:
I
,
!
!
I
I
~~l'!
o tU tU
o :J Q)
. c:: >-
cncLfl
<(
WUl:[
I-!zo:
~W~
I-::E
Ul>-
w<t
c::::a..
w...J
!zw
->
w
Vi -.J
:>-'
c:::
w
l-
Z
<t
o
-l
.-
Q)
C)
tU
0..
I.
;..
.-
~
(l)
.r:
V)
o
o
i&
WlO
>-Ln
<o:t
o
o
'i~
LUlO
>-Ln
V
o
o
i&
LUlO
>-lI"I
V
o
~~
0::0
<q
w
>-Ln
~
o
o
ci
....0
0::0
< -
WlD
>-~
.......
cu
~
o
z
cu
cu
2~
III
cu
:l
c::
cu
>
w cu
00::
"0
cu
~
CI1
E
.~
UJ
OlOlOV"W
OOOenNlD
M....:.q:uiu:iai
CO.... enOIn V
enWlI1vven
NLOoOr--.:'M'M'
en...... 0 V""
.- NN....q
.... .-
.-
o
0......-
("I")
CO
en
N
en
..-
......
vv
tDentD
CO....tD
("I")~en
CO ("I") v
o..-m
("I") en ("I")
("I")1Jl"
N..-q
..- ....
criu)
("I") .-
en m
en N
N N
N
OtDl.Dvf'o,.lO
Ol.Dl.D("I")WtD
("I")Nl/')-i.q:en
COf'o,.,U')vmv
enooenenq
N ("I") tD m. vi" ("I")
O'I'l;j-M.-'Vl'---
.... NN....O
.-
..-
0"'-"("1')"
ONNI'-O
tvir--.:ciaid
CON....C:OV
O"l..-.-coen
NLnCOr-:M"
en In V 0("1")
...... NN....
....
....
OVVtDO
C!lr!Ll'lVOCl
("I')wencid
OClOCllO("I")OCl
en........ COCO
NlOO'ltDN'
en 1..0 l/') O'l N
.... N......-
....
w
a
v
Lf')
en
Ill"
cuVt
~ C
W 0
a.~
J1m
c>@J
c::
.~ ti
f! ~
cu cu
a.~
0.5
....
~ CI)
ID a
~v
UJ-S
~t;
~<:
ro CI)
a.
'u E
c:: 0
'l:: U
0...5
C'lJ
~ CI)
.....l .S
,,-::3
o CI)
EQ::
:l
~
W
0:::
....
I.D
t.O
en
V
en
("I")
"
a
.-
W
tD
.
lJ')
v
O'l
en
f'o,.,
q
.-
....
U
I...
~
~
o
i:i:
~
III
t'J
........
o
o
ci
o
o
o
o
o
....
.......
~
~
w
....
C
~
o
I./')
"-
o
cu
III
(U
..c
~
:3
a..
..-..
o
o
t.O
o
v_
L/')
M
......
--
I...
W
~
o
I-
.....
o
C
o
.~
u
,Q)
I...
W
I...
.g
c:
(U
o
.....l
I.D
q
....
....
1..0
I./')
....
v
....
("I")
en
en
lJ')
N
tD
1..0
N
f"-
a
M'
v
f"-
N
r--.:
N
....
L/')
Lf')
V
lO
l..O
co
....
l..O
1..0
c::
nl
o
.....l
c::
o
ti
~
w
....
.5
"
N
to
Lf')
~
rn
I'-
.-
lJ')
.-
-i
rn
....
en
lO
....
f'o-
l..O
-i
lJ')
en
LI"i
v
....
f"-
a
d
v
en
M"
en
....
a
co
d
0Cl
0Cl
N
N
....
(U
a.
'u
c::
'1::
0..
C
(U
o
.....l
.....
o
E
:3
....
Q)
0::
M
co
.q:
f"-
m
u)
M
lO
M
0)
.q:
"'-
m
w
rn
lJ)
M
co
.q:
f'..
m
I.D
rn
LI')
(Y)
0)
.q:
,.....
en
tD
('I")
LI')
('I")
co
.q:
f'..
m
tD
("I")
Lrl
(U
E
o
u
.s
"'0
QJ
c::
'n;
~
w
0::
....
o
~
o
LI')
"
.-
N
v
o
tD
N
f'..
/'..
....
N
V
o
r.D
N
,....
""
....
.
N
V
a
r.D
N
I'-
I'-
..-
N
V
o
W
N
f'..
........
("r")
(()
M
w
M
0"1
o
o
.-
........
I...
(U
(U
>-
~
u
(U
UJ
"-
o
"0
C
UJ
~-
o
u:
~
III
t'O
U
v
CO
-i
a
0)
..;
0"1
0Cl
c-
o
l!!
Q)
a.
....
Q)
a.
LI')
En
c:
'I::
....
I...
(U
a.
III
c:
o
l!!
w
a.
o
N
.-
I'-
W
N
w
I'-
00
lD
..-
.-
a
Lf')
d
N
f"-
N'
v
v
1...-
:3
o
~
....
Il)
C.
III
C.
't:
.... ...:
v m
>.
~I...
-0 ~
I... III
w~
a.cu
III Q)
:; =:
ON
.r::1./')
o
.....
cu
en
(U
0..
........
w
w
....
N
("r")
M
0)
N
........
........
("r")
(()
M
lD
M
0"1
o
o
....~
Il)
(U Q)
E =:
:J I...
III Q)
en C.
<( en
OJ ~
...."0
0"
Z
....
---
:t
o
u:
..s::
en
(U
U
cu
>
'';:;
nl
"3
E
:J
U
,-
,
~;1:'" I '~" ....
.....
....,
CI)
CI)
.c
V)
o
o
;&.
<e1.O
W\.Il
Vh
.....
o
o
i8
<eu5
WIJ)
>-v
o
o
~~
~~
o
o
i~
<u5
WIJ)
>- v.
o
o
~g
<~
wU)
>-IJ)
Vh
.....
.......
Q)
"0
z
Q)
Q)
U)
-
III
CI)
::J
c:
Q)
>
CI)
Wo::
0-0
Q)
....
(Q
E
~
o
o
M
IX)
0)
N
m
.....
o
q
('I")
IX)
en
N
0"1
.....
.-
o
o
M
CO
0"1
N
en
....
.....
o
o
M
IX)
en
N
0"1
.-
.....
o
q
('I")
CO
en
N
0")
.....
U)
o
V
IJ)
M
lJ'If'..
Q)vt
VI c:
I:: 0
~~
~O"I
Cl@l
c:
';J ti
e! ~
Q) Q)
a.....
0..5
00
00
cwi""':
CO.....
O'lq
"j M
en U)
.....N
00
qo
M f'..
CO..-
en 0
N ('I')
enl.O
..-N
00
00
M""':
CO ..-
en 0
NM
en U)
....N
00
00
cwir....:
co..-
enq
N M
O")U)
.... N
00
00
evir....:
co....
0'l0
N"cn
0') U)
..-N
~ CU
~ ~
0.0
~.s
lSt
~<:
.....
.....
.....
.....
....
ro cu
,9- E
g 0
'L: 0
c....s
1::1:1
(Q CU
.9 .5
....-,fl
o cu
E~
::J
....
Q)
0::
o
o
r...:
..-
o
M
l.O
N
..-
o
q
f'..
..-
o
('I')
l.O
N
.....
o
o
f'..
.....
o
M
U)
N
....
o
o
,....:
..-
o
M
U)
N
o
o
r...:
.....
q
M
l.O
N
.-
u
'-
.E
~
o
ti:
.s:
VI
(Q
ti
~
Q)
....
oS
~
o
\.Il
....-
o
Q)
III
(Q
.s:
~
::J
c...
.....
Q)
~
o
I-
.....
o
c:
o
'P
u
~
UJ
I-
o
....-
I::
nI
o
-I
o
o
o
o
o
ci
o
o
ci
o
o
ci
o
o
d
C
nI
o
-I
'c
o
ti
~
Q)
......
..s
(ij
a.
'u
c
'C
c...
c
(Q
o
-I
.....
o
E
::J
....
Q)
c::
o
\.Il
CO
o
IJ)
.....
m
U)
o
\.Il
cO
o
IJ)
.....
M
l.O
o
\.Il
cO
o
IJ)
.....
m
w
o
\.Il
c:ci
o
\.Il
.....
M
l.O
o
\.Il
c:ci
o
\.Il
....
M
l.O
Q)
E
o
u
E
"C
Q)
C
'm
....
III
0:::
.....
o
~
o
\.I')
o
\.Il
cxi
o
\.Il
h
..-
M
l.O
V
en
.
f'..
V
('I')
N
LO
q
\.Il
o
LIl
co
o
\.Il
v
co
cd
('I')
co
r:5
N
V
-.;f
.....
M
l.O
o
LIl
co
o
IJ)
V
M
d
M
M
en
CO
f'..
M
.....
M
l.O
o
LIl
co
o
IJ)
v
OJ
N
CI)
Ol
cu
c...
.....
N
co
f'..
LO
..-
M
<..0
.....
('I')
o
\.Il
CO
o
\.Il
h
.....
M
l.O
V
M
M
.....
('I')
u5
N
LO
N
.....
m
>-
J::
u
nI
UJ
.....
o
"C
C
UJ
"i
o
ti:
.c
III
nI
U
~
o
ti:
.s:
III
C'O
U
Q)
>
'p
C'O
::J
E
::J
U
!tl." ~..
"
.....
11)
Q.l
.r::.
Vl
" .. *~ ...t,.
o
o
~i
o
o
~g
e:: a.
lC
UJI./)
>-~
o
o
~g
e::q
<lC
I./)
>-~
o
o
;g
e::q
<lC
I./)
>- v.
o
~~
.....0
e:: O.
<lC
UJI./)
V
.
.-
.-..
Q.l
.....
o
Z
Q.l
Q.l
en
-
VI
Q.l
:3
C
Q.l
>
Q.l
We::
0"'0
Q.l
....
nl
E
.~
UJ
.." ,
o
o
M
Q)
en
N
en
.-
.....
o
q
M
Q)
01
N
en
.-
.....
o
o
M
Q)
en
N
01
.-
.-
o
o
M
Q)
en
N
en
.-
.-
o
o
M
Q)
en
N
en
....
lC
o
o::t
IJ")
M
r--
:G~
VI c
c 0
Q.l
o.~
Jjen
Cl@J
c
.+:; t:
e! ~
Q.l Q.l
c.....
0..5
00
00
M~
00 ....
0"10
NM
en lC
....N
-
....
00
qo
('I') r--
0:>.....
0'10
NM
en lC
..... N
00
00
("I')~
0:> ....
010
N M
m lC
.....N
00
00
M~
Q) ....
010
NM
en lC
.....N
00
00
M~
co.....
010
NM
m lC
.... N
~ lU
ai E
0.8
~.s
t'lI w
~~
.....
.....
.
....
.....
~Q.J
00 E
c Q
OE: tJ
a..-S
C'l)
nl Q.l
o c::
:: "n
o~
E
:3
....
Q.l
0::
o
o
~
.....
o
M
to
N
.....
o
o
r--
.....
o
M
tD
N
.....
o
o
r--
.....
o
M
tD
N
.....
o
o
r-..:
....
o
M
lC
N
.....
o
o
r-..:
.....
o
M
lC
N
....
;!:
U
....
..E
~
u:
.r:
VI
RI
U
1;:
~
Q.l
....
.E
~
o
I./)
....
o
III
VI
nl
.r::.
~
::J
a..
I-
III
~
....
o
c
o
'+:;
u
~
UJ
I-
o
....
C
ro
o
..J
o
o
ci
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
ci
o
o
ci
c
ro
o
oJ
c
o
t:
~
Il1
....
C
ro
0.
'0
C
'C
a..
C
nl
.3
....
o
E
:::l
....
Il1
0::
o
I./)
cO
o
I./)
-
.....
M
tD
o
l.J'i
Q)
o
IJ")
.....
M
lC
o
I./)
cO
o
I./)
....
M
lC
o
LJ1
cO
o
IJ")
.....
('I")
lC
o
IJ")
oj
o
L/1
....
M
lC
Il1
E
o
u
oS
-c
QJ
c
'm
.....
Q.l
0::
.....
o
~
o
L/1
o
IJ")
cO
o
1Il
v
co
al
co
co
en
a
N
05
.-
('I")
lC
o
lI')
cO
o
l.r)
V
M
.
.....
co
M
05
r--
l/')
,..:
.....
('I")
lC
o
\.Il
cO
a
l/')
v
co
N
f'..
co
uS
o::t
O'l
uS
....
('I")
lC
o
l/')
00
o
l/')
o::t
('I")
...;.
tD
M
l/')
tv)
(1)
01
t'lI
0-
....
("I')
tD
.....
M
u;
o
l/')
cO
o
Lfl
o::t
Q)
I.t"l
l/')
00
('I")
Q)
lC
-
I./')
....
M
lC
I-
ro
Q.l
>-
.c
u
ro
UJ
~
o
"C
C
W
i
o
u:
.r:
VI
ro
U
:c
o
u:
..c
VI
(U
U
Q.l
>
.+:;
~
:::J
E
:::J
U
'"
'1't'..
I'
'. . ,\.
, >
k:j
~~~~,,:,,",....'},
I
I.
I :
.'
~;
N
~
III
..c
en
)> - ".. -... +
....,,'.:.. \
,,',
c,'
.........
. ...,-. ,_........ . .'~ ,.." .,.nH,
I
!
"j
oo'<:tU)"-O
ON..-~NO
l1)c.Ouiuiotdo
c:uONt()O')\.T)
~C:~lJ')v)Ln~
O!!!uiN'roN('tl
..Jl>>M..-,....t'f"l.......
m""lD.q-C"1....
'I~
'1:
c..
O....,.....cn....
COOlD-N
cici";o;ttD
COvd1MLfl
o::t cnR d' .... -.:t
NMv)cnM
NMVU')I'-
t-- ,..... .... ~ ..-
~
-.:t""lD~tD
LflNlD....O
trlr-.:NM....
OONf'--('tl....
........OO"llD
t.ci"ui'Malui'
WlJlo:::tN....
.....
Q)
Cl
l'U
a..
"
J
~octvv~
('l")MC'I'!M('l")
r-.:r--:,....r--:r--:
lDlDlDlDlD
00000
O"lO"lalmm
00 CO to CO CO
...... ..- .... .- ......
~I
....N('t")oq-V)
I
I
r
I
.
~~t'!.......,.'. '~',
("I')
~
<U
.c
U)
LU
~
~
....J
<(
Z
~
w
~
-
o
o
Ju:>
CO
::::l"<:t
o -
E~
,.....
~Io
c
cu
.3
1-0
o C
',i:j ro
.~ ~
tJO
IIlLn
W"-
C 0
<U
III
ro
..c
~
::::l
a.
.-
........
L.:
(I;l
<1l
>-
..c
c:: u
o&l
',p "-
:l 0
..c
'C -0
t:~
Ci 11I-
"'C 0'1
~ .S
;'J ~
c::W
(\)-0
E (\)
~c
cu .-
c..l3
c: Q)
cuO::
..90
~~;:Ia~~~~~~~~~~
<:0 en 0"1 en 0"1 (X) 0"1 0 N 0 0 en.'. t"')
NMm V I.1')(1)COI.1')O')N V I.1')tD
N"';ci"';u5r....:ccimmcicido
-NCOen('\"')COt'f)('\"')('\"')"<:t~...,.V
..............................0000000000
.......................U)I.1')I.1')I.1')Lf)Lf)Lf)Lf)Lf)1.1')
NNNNNcOcOcOcoc.ococcio:iaScO
vvvvvoooooooooo
o~ 0 a 0 0 U) Lf) U) Lfl U) I..fl 1.1') 1.1') 1.1') Lfl
tDWv:Sc.DW...:...:...:...................................
NNNNNM('I')M('I'")M(\")MCOMM
,..... ,..... ,..... " f'oo. tD tD tD tD tD t.O tD to tD t.O
.-NMVLf)t.O,.....com~
.....NM"<:tLf)
.......- ..- .-- .-- ....
,t
.....
Q)
0)
CU
c..
;1
!
1
:!
I'
<?-<<>. .'. ' .'
TERMS AND CONDITIONS TO BE REOUI RED BY CITY
· 50% OWNERSHIP IN CORPORATION FOR $1,000,000.00
· 50% REPRESENTATION AND VOTE FOR THE CITY ON THE CORPORATION'S
BOARD OF DlRECfORS
· EVIDENCE OF CLEAR TITLE TO TOWER AT TIME OF CLOSING
· FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND ALL CORPORATE OPERATIONS SUBJECl'
TO INSPECfION AND AUDIT BY THE CITY OF CLEARWATER INTERNAL
AUDITOR OR DESIGNEES
· EVIDENCE OF PROPER AND ADEQUATE LIABILITY INSURANCE AT ALL
TIMES
· EVIDENCE OF WIND TUNNEL TESTING FOR CONDITIONS AT TOWER SITE
· FUNDS TO BE LENT FOR TOWER CONSTRUCfION TO BE HELD BY CITY IN
ESCROW AND RELEASED ONLY UPON PROPER DOCUMENTATION AND
SUPPORT FOR MATERIALS RECEIVED OR SERVICES PERFORMED
· $200,000.00 OF WORKING CAPITAL TO BE LENT TO THE CORPORATION BY
MR. GROGAN AT ZERO INTEREST, TO BE RETURNED TO HIM AFTER
ADEQUA TE WORKING CAPITAL ]S PROVIDED FROM OPERATIONS
· DIVIDEND DISTRffiUTIONS TO BE FROZEN IF CORPORATION IS NOT IN
COMPLIANCE WITH TERMS OF LOAN AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY
· PREFERENTIAL SHAREHOLDER TREA lMENT TO CITY OF CLEARWATER IN
ANY LIQUIDATION OF THE CORPORATION IN THE FOLLOWING
SEQUENCE:
· PA YMENT TO CITY FOR ACCRUED INTEREST ON ANY
OUTSTANDING LOAN
· PA YMENT TO CITY FOR ANY UNPAID LOAN BALANCE
· PA YMENf TO CITY IN AN AMOUNT NECESSARY TO ELIMINATE ANY
NEGATIVE CUMULATIVE CASH FLOW
· PA YMENT TO MR. GROGAN OF ANY OUTSTANDING WORKING
CAPITAL LENT BY HIM TO THE CORPORATION
· PA YMENT TO ALL SHAREHOLDERS BASED ON PERCENTAGE OF
OWNERSHIP
\
'I
\
~ '
t
, .
. I
~!'!.'''''"'"'"'''''''':.,; "."......
. ,.
. ~.... ~
v '.
~1~'1 . ... .
. .
< ,
... ~
DATE
. ,
~
.~:, :
;o.~.'1' .
''1:1''
~" .
':'-r:"
-1';
~J"'
.,-
':i
~'.
.
~~. ,
F.lc;C/
, . . ',~ C TO'+
AGENDA
1~ /1- q~
ITEM # If '1 A.,./J
l
1
. \
j
t
!
!
I
. :1
:'''''"'..,
./V<- =
o CA r 1- +d--.
MEMORANDUM
LI9 a.. + b
TO: The Honorable Mayor and Members of the city commission
FROM:
Robert J. sur~te, Assistant city Attorney, Police
Legal Advisor v<J6
Resolutions Pertaining to Mutual Aid Agreements
August 9, 1995
I
1
I
RE:
DATE:
section 23.1225(3), Florida statutes (1993), states that a mutual
aid agreement may be entered into by the mayor or chief executive
officer of a municipality, if authorized by the governing body of
the municipality. Attached you will find two resolutions
authorizing the city Manager on behalf of the Clearwater Police
Department to execute the npinellas County Interlocal Mutual Aid
Assistance Agreement For Police services" and the tlTampa Bay
MUlti-Agency Gang Task Force Mutual Aid Agreement."
The Pinellas county Interlocal Mutual Aid Agreement authorizes
cooperation ,and assistance of a routine law enforcement nature
across jurisdictional lines by law enforcement agencies within
Pinellas County. The Gang Task Force Mutual Aid Agreement will
authorize the Clearwater Police Department and other law
enforcement agencies within the greater Tampa Bay area,
including, for example, Hillsborough, Pasco, and Polk County
Sheriffs' Offices, to share information and to render assistance
in situations involving gang-related crime.
RJS/jas
Attachments
Copies:
Pamela Akin, city Attorney
Elizabeth M. Deptula, City Manager
Sid Klein, Chief of Police
'0 CAr *1-
L\ q <^-
RESOLUTION NO. 95-66
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE
EXECUTION OF THE PINELLAS COUNTY INTERLOCAL
MUTUAL AID ASSISTANCE AGREEMENT FOR POLICE
SERVICES; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, Part I, Chapter 23 of the Florida Statutes, the
"Florida Mutual Aid Act," authorizes law enforcement cooperation
and assistance of a routine law enforcement nature across
jurisdictional lines by and between such agencies; and
WHEREAS, the City of Clearwater is desirous of entering into
an agreement that allows voluntary cooperation by and between
participating law enforcement agencies within Pinellas County; and
WHEREAS, the City of Clearwater has deemed it to be in the
best interests of its citizens to enter into the "pinellas County
Interlocal Mutual Aid Assistance Agre~ment for Police Services";
now therefore,
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The City Commission hereby authorizes the city
Manager on behalf of the Clearwater Police Department to execute
the "Pinellas county Interlocal Mutual Aid Assistance Agreement for
Police Services," a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A,
between the City of Clearwater and the other participating law
enforcement agencies within Pinellas County.
Section 2. . This resolution shall take effect immediately upon
adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this
day of
, 1995.
and
Rita Garvey
May~r-Cornmissioner
Attest:
'\
Cynthia E. Goudeau
City Clerk
-
~..~}I~~;..
c I pC\r u.;Q. i.e p-.
I.
I
I -
PINELLAS COUNTY INTERLOCAL MUTUAL AID
ASSISTANCE FOR POLICE SERVICES'
.
THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into by and between
the 'undersigned municipalities in Pinellas County, Florida,
and Everett S. Rice, as Sheriff of Pinellas County,' Florida.
WITNESSETH:
. . WHEREAS', Part. I, Chapter 23 of the Florida Statutes I the
IIFlorida Mutual Aid' Act", authorizes' law enforcement agencies
tg enter into agreements for voluntary cooperation and assis-
tance of a routine law enforcement nature acros~ jurisdiction-
al lines by and between such agencies; to such unlawful activi-
ties; and
WHEREAS, the unaerstghed municipalities and
nize that an increasing number of criminals
across jurisdictional' lines and that there is
continuing multi,jurisdictional response to
activities; and
sheriff recog-
are operating
a need for a
such unlawful
WHEREAS, the undersigned municipalities and sheriff de...
sire to secure the benefits of such mutual aid for their re~
spective jurisdictions; and
WHEREAS, the undersigned municipalities and sheriff deter-
mine that.it is in the best interest of the health, safety and
we~fare of the citizens of the undersigned municipalities and
. of the citizens of Pinellas County to enter into a Voluntary
Cooperation Agreement;
NOW~ THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants
expressed herein and for other good and valuable considera-
tion, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged" the parties
hereto agree,as follows:
Routine Law Enforcement Matters
I .
Any party to this agreement may request the volun-
tary assistance and cooperation of any other party
to . this agreement relating to any routine law en-
forcement matter involving more than one jurisdic-
tion.
~
II.
In-Proqress Crime ~ssistance
Whenever a law enforcement officer from one juris-
diction views a felony or a misdemeanor involving a
breach of peace occurring in the cooperating juris-
'EXHIBIT A
'11''''''' ~.. . .
..
III.
'.\
diction, the law .enforcement officer may physically
. arrest . the perpetrator and preserve the crime
scene. Control of both the persons apprehended. and
the crime scene will, be relinquished to the first
available officer from the jurisdiction in which
the incident occurs. Whenever remaining at the
scene exposes either the officer or the subject to
'imminent physical danger, the subject and any physi-
cal evidence may be transported or otherwise relo-
cated in accordance with normal procedure.
!
I
1
I
J
I
I
,.,
J r
i
I
Voluntary Investiqations
On-duty officers from one jl.:lrisdiction may conduct
investigations into criminal activity that occurs
in their jurisdiction and make arrests related to
those investigations in any of the undersigned'
jurisdictions. If enforcement action is anticipat-
ed, the ..,l.oc~t;.i.<;m and nature of the investigation
will ,be told. to the agency I s on-duty communication
liaison person.
IV. Traffic Control Assistance
'\
A. Whenever a traffic accident involving suspected
injuries of a seriou~ nature is rep,orted ,to the,.
jurisdiction in which the accident occurred and
tha t law enforcement agency is unable to pro-
vide the immediate response necessary to render
aid to the injured or prevent further injury,
the cooperating agency may be contacted for
assistance. The cooperation effort shall be
restricted to necessary first aid and tr.af fic
direction.
B. Hazardous Traffic Conditions Assistance
1. In a situation where automated traffic
control devices located within the jurisdic-
tional boundaries of one agency have mal-
functioned and a traffic accident is immi-
rfent unless control is established immedi-
ately, cooperation may be provided.
2. Where an incident occurs on a traffic-way
or so near thereto that the potential for
traffic accidents appears immine~t, coopera-
tion may be provided.
C. The cooperative efforts for traffic accidents
and/or hazardous traffic conditions outlined
above shall be restricted to the necessary and
standard traffic control and direction activi-
-2-
~\.:.""H .
"
, .
I
.'
ties and shall not
ment. Control of the
ately relinquished to
cer from the agency
sponsibility.
include traffic enforce-
incident shall be immedi-
the first available offi-
having jurisdictional re-
V. Boatinq Violations
'.
o
......
Officers of cooperating agencies may enforce all
state boating laws and county boating ordinances on
the waterways of another cooperating agency; provid-
ed that such violations occur on waterways contigu-
ous to and in view of the jurisdiction of the offi-.
cer's employing agency. In the case of a felony or-
a misdemeanor involving a breach of peace, control
of the person(s) apprehended and the crime scene
will be relinquished to the first available officer
from the jurisdiction in which the incident oc-
curs. Cases. ..i~volving only a minor violation may
be concluded at the scene'by the issue of a Boating
Citation or Notice to Appear.
VI. Terms and Procedures
\
A. A participating agency will answer a request
for voluntary cooperation only. to the extent,
that the 'available personnel and equipment are
not required for adequate protection of that
agency. The' commander of the agency, or his
designee, sh~ll have the .sole authority to
determine the amount of personI)el and equip-
ment, if any, available for cooperative assis-
tance,
B. A request for voluntary cooperation shall be
made by the commander of :the agency or his
designee,
C. Voluntary cooperation can also be initiated by
an on-duty officer who views an in-progress
crime, traffic accident, or need for traffic
. control in the other cooperating agency.- The
supervising authority of that employee shall be
notified immediately to enable that supervisor
to authorize and direct actions taken by the
employee.
D. An officer taking VOluntary action should noti-
fy the communication liaison person in the
assisted agency as soon as possible, The as-
sisted agency shall relieve the assisting offi-
cer(s) as soon as possible.
j;
},
-3-
, .
I
. '
"
'\
0'
E. Whenever the employees of any law E;!nforcement
agency are rendering aid outside its jurisdic- -
tion and pursuant to the authority contained
in, or to any written agreement entered under
this part, such employees shall have the same
powers, duties, rights, privileges, and immuni-
ties as if they were performing their duties in
the political subdivision in which they are
normally employed.
!
I
I
l
i
~
i
J
i
.
i
i
1
I
I
t
,
F. Law enforcement officers or employees respond-
ing to a voluntary cooperation request ~hall be
under the direction and authority of the com-
manding officers of the agency to which they
are called. . .
G. All wage and disability payments, pensions,
Workers' Compensation claims, and medical ex-
pens.~9 ~h.a.!l be paid by the employing agency,
unless the' requestin.g agency is reimbursed by
other authori ties, persons or poll tical enti-
ties.
H. Each agency shall be responsible for bearin.g
its, o'1n costs associat~d with any loss or dam-
age incurred to such jurisdiction I s property,-
equipment, or resources as a result of the use
of such property during a voluntary cooperation
situation. .
I. Each party to this agreement shall bear the
costs and liability for its own law enforcement
officers, agents and/or employees arising from
acts undertaken pursuant to this agreement
unless such act was ordered by the officer
directing the voluntary cooperation situation
and each agrees, to the extent permitted by
law, to indemnify and hold the other harmless
of and from any claims, lawsuits and/or causes
of action arising out of the acts, omissions
and conduct of its own officers, agents and/or
. employees. 'In the event that an act or acts
undertaken pursuant to this agreement is or-
dered by the officer directing the voluntary
cooperation situation, any costs and liability
that might arise shall be the responsibility of
the agency employing said officer. However,
nothing. contained herein shall be construed to
waive or modify the provisions ,of F.S. 768.28
as to any party hereto.
-4-
riot ~....... .
!
!
J. This agreement shall be bindi.ng upon the par-
ties' from the date of execution. by a party
hereto and shall continue in full force and
effect until terminated as provided herein
below.
K. This agreement shall be. binding upon the par-
ties from the date of execution and shall con-
tinue in full force and effect until January 1,
1999 . However, any party hereto may wi thdraw
or cancel such party's participation pursuant
to this agreement without liability to any
other parties hereto by providing written no-
tice of such withdrawal no less than ten (10)
days prior thereto. However, the withdrawal
from or cancellation of this agreement shall 'be
effective only as to that party and this agree-
ment shall remain in full force and effect as
to those remaining parties hereto who have.
provIded' 'no written. notice or cancellation or
withdrawal.
1
L. Each agency that. is a party to this agreement
agrees to. adopt the policy attached hereto and
incorporated herein by reference, provided,
however, that nothing herein shall prevent art
agency administrator from adopting an internal
policy which is' more. restrictive than. this
model policy; as regards to his or her own
personnel:
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties heret~.cause their signatures
to be affixed:
I'
~
REMAINING PAGE BLANK
!
i
\
[I
,
Ii
,
-5-
li+ ~ c: .. .
--r- * '1
C) c, A ...l-- c;f...
Lt ~ b,
RESOLUTION NO. 95-67
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE
EXECUTION OF THE TAMPA BAY MULTI-AGENCY GANG
TASK FORCE MUTUAL AID AGREEMENT; PROVIDING.AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, Part I I Chapter 23 of the Florida Statutes, the
"Florida Mutual Aid Act," authorizes law enforcement cooperation
and assistance of a routine law enforcement nature across
jurisdictional lines by and between such agencies; and
WHEREAS, the city of Clearwater is desirous of entering into
an agreement that allows voluntary cooperation by and between
participating law enforcement agencies within and outside Pinellas
County whereby each of the participating agencies may request and
render law enforcement assistance to the other to include, but not
necessarily limited to, dealing with gang and disruptive group
activity, and gang and disruptive group related crime; and
WHEREAS, the city of Clearwater has deemed it to be in "the
best interests of its citizens to enter into the "Tampa Bay Multi-
Agency Gang TaSK Force Mutual Aid Agreement"; now therefore,
I
I
;
J
~
i
t
t
;
i
I
!
r
!
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE
CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
section 1. The City Commission hereby authorizes the City
Manager on behalf of the Clearwater Police Department to execute
the "Tampa Bay MUlti-Agency Gang Task Force Mutual Aid Agreement,"
a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A, between the city
of Clearwater and the other participating law enforcement agencies
within the Tampa Bay area.
section 2. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon
adoption.
. I
,
PASSED AND ADOPTED this
day of
, 1995.
and
Rita Garvey
Mayor-Commissioner
Attest:
Cynthia E. Goudeau
city Clerk
....~ ,
WHEREAS, the subsoribcd law enforcement Hgencies arc so located in relation to each other
I
!
f
f
~
J
f
I
~~21~~;:~:~~~i:i.~~~t~~:~t:~~;5~~~4J;lo/.ih:~~1~:t.~JJ~~~~Jr~;';~~~~.~1gli~~}~~~~f:~d;~:~~{;~;~"~(~,:;~:~~~1~~~~:~~~~~~~~:
;...~".:..,~,'.n._~...,-..,~.r'~t..;'.~~.~~.~.,:i..;;:::,' , TV'" ..... n;;"':~REE t:l' "Y''';:':~''~:':''''':I,:.~,.~'';'b':':-=-~''''''''I~'''''''.''ft':':'
\tr~~~~:~i;~~~7:~ffi.~i[-~~.;i:Z~:.'.;.~~~~~:;':~~;.~~:~~~~. ~ ~. . ...;. '",.. r.. "=:2~t~~~::':~'.~~~~~.:f~~~':--;.t.~~1~~;.i;';;~;A;Y;.~~~~;;
~:iF~:!ED'~;:1J?J!fAMYA]:B~'~~MurlrI.iiA'G~~NOY;li:4NG;'j~NSreFQ~~;r.0.?~~{:::::~~.t~
!f::..:=:..~:,..~~:."i;J.:!; <I .. . ,. r .' . ~":~"':::""::':::..\4.~'t.':1'
""- ...__..... "".~..~.._- ._...'OA4I........ .,,' . . ,.. '......*"'-._.._~__ .....t'.,~..I .. .......1 ,'" ,. ...:." .. 4..... ",. .....,; ~r '.. '.,~l .......11:._..~""'t .......~j1..~,
'1:>oi~ ;...... . ._-~""""""'''':.)"JI..,.;...:..~>~''''I~''~''..~:'.'':''''II>....._......_...~_. '..,:'; .. ..) n9S.~~;.~. l!:J._.;....~-l '" _- .:.':~~~:~:.~....~...~._..:: .:. :1.,...-_..4U,.....,.,~.....~
.,. -"'O:I':~~_..,,~~~ ...-..,",..... "'.,..ll~l~--.... 1'1" ,... :. ".~.'J."::I II.'.' - . .,. '.1. :......... ..~.-, r........"r.:.;..~ ..._.........T~'.... ..~
ItlJi!~~Wt~~~l~~~~~~~~~~~~f*!~~~1illl~lIJijrl
that it is to t~e advantage: of t:ltch lO receive: Bnd extend mutual aid in the form oflnw enforcement
services and resources to IHJequately respond tu:
1. Continuing, Jllulti-juri!idiclional Jaw enfurcernen[ problems, so as to protect
the public peace: and safety. and preserve the lives and property of the
peoplt:; and,
2. Intensive situations, including, but not limited to emergencies as defined
under Section 252.34. F,S.; and,
\VREREAS. it is the intent of this ;agreement that btcaw;e of the existing and continuing
possibility of intensive situntions and- other Jaw enforcement emergencies and in order to ensure
thnt the preparati(ln nf Ii\W euforcement will he adequate to ut:.al with such nctivity. protect the:
publi~pcacc and ~afety. and preserve the lives and property oCtile people; and.
EXHIBIT A
III-
.'
Mull.l.'l1 Aid
MAGTF
1995
WHEREAS. the following asencies have the authority under Section 23. ]2, F.S., et seq.. The
Florida Mutual Aid Act, to enter into a cornli'ined mutual aid agreement for law enforcement
~ervice which:
1. Permit,. voluntary cooperation and assistance of a routine law enforcement
nature acruss jurisdictional lines; Rnd.
2.
Provides for rendering of assistance in a Jaw enforcement emergency
. including, but not limited LOt those defined in section 252.34, F.S.
Panicipating agencies are as foJJows;
Clcntwater Police Department
Florida DeJ'lanmenl of Law Enforcement
HiUsburough County Sht:ritrs Office
Lakcland Police Departmcnt
Largo Police Department
Pasco County Sheriff s Oflice
Pinellf\s C.Ollnty Sherin"s Offir.c
Pinellas Pork Police De'pnrtment
Plant City Police Depanment
Polk County Sheriff'
St, Petersburg Police Department
Tampn Police Departmcnt.
Temple Terrace Police Depanml:nt
University of SOllth Florida Pl)lice Department.
Upon approval of the steering committee, o1her agencies may be included in MAGrI' activities.
Now. therefore. the parties agree as foHows:
~
SECTION I:
PROVISIONS FOR VOLUNTARY COOPERA TJON
Each of the Rforcsilid IRW enforcement ngcncic:~ herehy approve and enter into this agreement
whereby each of the agencies OlRY request and render IHW ~nrorcemenl as!\istancc to the other to
2
~
'Y':"1 "'"
Mulwtl Aad
MAGTF
J995
includet but not neces~rily be limited tat dealing with sang and disruptive group activitYt and
gang and disruptive group related crime.
SEcnON 11:
PROVISIONS Fon Ol'f<:UATIONAL ASSISTANCE
Each of the aforesaid law enforcement agencies hereby approve and enter into this agreement
whereby each of the agencies Olay requel't and render law enforcement assistance to the other to
\.
inclu(je but nut nccclisHrily ~imjtcd 10 civil di:dut'uanccSt rargc prole.'ll dcmcmlOtrcations. concerts nnd
parades related ttl gang and disruptive group activity and gang and disruptive group rclRtcd clime.
Each agency shall have a representative on the Multi-Ag~ncy Gang Task Force (MAGTF)
steering committee. The steering committee will develop operational policies and procedures.
Upon approval of the steering committee other agencies may be included in MAGTF at..'tivity.
SECTION III:
PROCEDURE FOR RF.Ql.lF.STING ASSISTANCE
A participating agency can request the, activation of th~ MAGTF uy conlacling the Chairperson of
the steering committee. who will notify the sub cummittet: un-activation. The steering committee
chairperson will then inform the requesting agency of the resources available. The r~qu~~ting
agency ~iI1 then arrange with each assisting agency representAtive for the deployment of
resources Decisions of the nssisting agency heno regarding the suppl)' ofl'csources an~ final.
J
~..
I"
.'
Mulwa1 Aid
MAOTF
J99S
SI':CfJON IV:
COMMANu ANI> ~aJ1-ERVJSOnY Rt:SI-ONSIDILITY
The personnel and equipment that are assigned by the assisting agency head shall be undcr thc
inUllcdiatc command of n supervising officer designated by the assisting agency head. Such
I
,
I
I
!
supervising officer shall bt under the direct supervision and command of the agency head or his or
her designee ofthe agency requesting assistance.
CONFLICTS:
Whenever an oflicer, deputy ~heritl. or other appointee is rendering
assislance pursuant to lhis agreement, (he officer. deputy sheriff or appointee shaH abide by and be
subject to the rules and regulations. personnel policies. gcneral orders nnd standard operating.
procedures of his or her own employer. if nny such 111 Ie, regulation, personnel policy, gcneral
order or standard operating procedure is contradicted, COnfru\'t:ncu or orherwise in conflict with Ct
direcl order of a superior officcr of the rcquesting agency. thell such rule, regulation, policy,
general order 01' procedure shnll control nnd ~hDII 5upcrscdc thc dircct order nnd notification of
said conflict should be made to the requesting "seney, An oJIiccr, deputy shcri1l' or other
appointee of an assisting agency shall not knowingly violate the requesting agencies rules
regulations, policy or operating procedures.
HANDLING COl\1PLAINTS:
Whenever there is cause to believe that i\ complaint has
arisen as a fesuJr ora cooperalive eBbrl as II may perlalll to Ihis ngl'ccmelll, the agcnc)' heRd or his
or her desig.nee of the requesting ngency shall be responsible fur the documentatiun of said
. .
'\
complaint to nsccrtain at n minimum:
1, Th~ iu~ntify urth~ compll\immt
I
" -
'7
-,
An I1ddl'cSS where the complnining party ell" be conUlctca.
4
-
-
Mutunl Aid
MACiIF
199~
3. The specific al1eglltion.
. 4. The identity of the employees accused without regArd as to agency affiliAtion.
If it is ~elennined that the accused is an employee of nn assisting agency. the above infonnation,
with aU pertinent documentation gathered during the receipt and processing of the complaint. shall
be forwarded without delay to the agency head or his or her designee of the assisting agency for
administrative review. The requesting agency may conduct a review of the complaint to
determine if any factual basis for the complaint cxists and lor whether any of the employees of the
. rcquesting agency violated any nftheir ugency'~ policies and procedures.
SECTION V:
LTABJLITI'
Each party engaging in any mutual cooperation and assistance, pursuitnt to this agreement, agrees
to assume responsibility for the acts, omissions. or conduct of sllch partyts own employees while
engage:=u in nmde:=ring such aid pur~u"n\ to this Itgrccmcnt, subject to the provi:-iolls or Seclion
768.28. F.S.. where applicable.
SECTION VI:
PO\VERS, PRIVILEGES. IMMUNITIES AND COSTS
n. Employees of the pnrticipnting 4\gencics when lictuaJly engaging in a mutuRI
cooperation Rnd assistance olltside of the jurisdictional limits (lftheir t:lTlployer but inside this state
~
under dIe terms, of this agreement, shnll, plIl'sunnt to the provisions of Sc:c.:tion 2J.J27(J). F.S.,
have the same powers, duties. rights, pdvilcgcs and immunities as irthc employee wns performing
dutit:s jnsit.l~ tht: elllpluyee's pulitil:HI subdi\'i~iun or j~lrf~dicl;(lIIUl terri/Of)' in which nonnnll}'
~
-
I
!
I
I
. f
1
}
J
..~;.,..
MUlual Aid
MAOTF
199~
employed. The cross jurisdictional nuthority will occur only when the MAGTFis activated by the
steering committee and will be appHcable only in the jurisdiction orthe requesting agency.
b. Each party agrees to furnish necessary personnel. equipment. resources and
facilities and to render services to each other pl\r\y to (he agreement as set forth abo"e~ provided
. .
however, that no pal1Y shall be required to deplete unreasonably its own personnel, equipment,
resources, facilities, and services in furnishing such mutual aid.
c. A political subdivision that furnishes equipment pursuant to this ugreement must
bear the cost of loss or damage to that ~quipm~nt and must pay any expense incurred in the
operation Rnd maintenance of that equipment.
d. The agency furnishing aid pursuant to this agreement shall compensate its
appointees or employees during the time such aid is rendered and shall defray the actual travel and
maintenance expenses of its employees while they are rendering such aid, including any amounts
paid or due for compensation due to personal injury or death while such employees are engagc::d in
J Cl1dcring such aid.
c. The privileges Rnd imlllunities from liability. exemption from laws, ordinances and
rules, ano all pension, insurance, relief: disability, workers' compensation, salary, death and other
benefits that apply to the Rctivity of lUl employee of all ngcnc.:y when performing the employee's
duties within the territorial limits of the employee's agency apply to the emplo)'e~ to the Sl\m~
degree, u:~t\nn~r. and extent while engi\g.cd in the pelfonnance of the employee's duties,
extraterriwrially und~r the provision!; of this Mutual Aid Agreement. The provisions of this
,
l:
,
section shall apply with cqual crrect to paid, volunteer, auxiliat)', and rcserve employees.
(.
.
~.t:~.t't:i; . .'
Mutual Aid
MACiTF
1995
r. Nothing herein shall prcvcnt the requesting agency from requesting supplemental
appropriations from the governing authority having budgeting jurisdiction to rcimburse the
assisting agency for any actual co~ts or expenses. incurred by the assisting agency perfonning
ht:r~unch:r.
SECTION VII:
INSURANCE
Each party. by signing this mutual aid agreement, certifies that they are adequately insured to
cuver the risk to which that Pilrty may be exposed. Should the insurance coverage, however
provided. of any party be canceled or undergo material change, that pany shall notify all parties to
, I
I
this agreement of such change within ten (10) days of receipt of notice or actual knowledge of
such change.
SECTION Vl11:
Eli',FECTlVE DATE
This agreement shall take eflect upon execution and approval by the hr:reinaf1er named officials
and shall continue in full torce for five ytars, unless termin~tl:d prior tht:reto by the participating
agencies. Any ag.ency may withdraw in writing from the agreement at any time.
SECTION IX:
CANCELLA TJON
, .
Thi:; !!gr~t:ment may be canceled by any pan)' upon delivery of written notice to the other pal1y or
- ,
p:\rties Cancellation will bt: at the discretion of any subscrihing pany
7
'-' .
H'
"..~ :., .
~i '.'
~~;'. ':.' .
~~~ ".
. .
_ '. c
~~!'Jo.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,., ,
j"; .
>,
"
;:
;'
, .'
, c
5' ,"
I '
"
f .
,,' ~
Mutunl Aid
MAGTF
1995
. .~. I..... ". ....,.
I
!
\
i
i
SECl'ION X:
MODiFICATIONS
Any changes to this agreement must be agreed upon by, all agencies involved in tlus operation.
"\
- .
. I
I
~.
hi, 'v
ORDINANCE NO. 5894-95
4q c
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF CLEARWATER\
FLORIDA, RELATING TO THE FRANCHISE AGREEMENT
WITH TIME WARNER ENTERTAINMENT-ADVANCE/
NEWHOUSE PARTNERSHIP, TO AMEND THE FRANCHISE
AGREEMENT TO EXTEND THE TERM OF THE
FRANCHISE FOR A PERIOD OF THREE MONTHS,
ENDING ON NOVEMBER 1, 1995; AMENDING ORDINANCE
NO. 2085 INCREASING THE FRANCHISE FEE PAID TO
THE CITY TO FIVE PERCENT; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 2084 of the City granted a nonexclusive franchise for
the use of City rights-of-way to Vision Cable of Pinellas, Incorporated; and
WHEREAS, Ownership of Vision Cable was changed and the franchise was duly
transferred to Time Warner Entertainment-Advance/Newhouse Partnership ("TWE/AN);
and
WHEREAS, Vision Cable of Pinellas, Incorporated now TWEJAN has submitted
a renewal proposal pursuant to the provisions of the Cable Communications Policy Act
of 1984 and the Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act of 1992
(Federal Cable Act); and
WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 2084 allows the City to adjust by ordinance a franchise
fee not to exceed that permitted by federal and state law; and
WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 2085 established the cable fees; and
WHEREAS, additional time is required for discussions between the City and
ME/AN on a successor franchise agreement; and
WHEREAS, in order to accommodate the franchise renewal negotiation process,
the parties desire to allow for the extension of the current franchise and proceed with
negotiations under the informal procedures of the Federal Cable Act; and
WHEREAS, 1WE/AN agrees to the extension of the franchise term to allow for
such preparations; now, therefore,
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE.
CITY OF CLEARWATER, FLORIDA:
Section 1. The term of the franchise agreement between the City of Clearwater
and TWE/AN. granted by Ordinance No. 2064 of the City, is hereby extended an
additional three months such that the term shall expire on November 1, 1995. All other
"l'~""'''' .
provisions of Ordinance No. 2084 shall continue in full force and effect. TWE/AN shall
operate in the same manner as prior to the extension. Operation in the same manner
and under the same terms and conditions include, but not limited to, access and local
origination operation and funding consumer service and complaint response, and
compliance with all public safety regulations and applicable laws and regulations.
Section 2. This ordinance shall not be construed to infer that the term of the
franchise shall again be extended, or that TWE/AN shall be approved as a franchisee
of the City beyond the extended term of the current franchise agreement.
Section 3. Ordinance No. 2085, Section 1, is amended to read:
liThe Company shall pay, as compensation to the City, a franchise fee of five percent
(5%) three percent (3%) of its gross revenues. The City may, at its pleasure. increase
or decrease the franchise fee unless prohibited by law or regulation."
Section 4. This ordinance shall take effeCt immediately upon adoption.
PASSED ON FIRST READING
PASSED ON SECOND AND FINAL
READING AND ADOPTED
.1
Rita Garvey, Mayor-Commissioner
Approved as to form
and legal sufficiency:
Attest:
Pamela K. Akin, City Attorney
Cynthia E. Goudeau, City Clerk
2
....... __'" .._.~.._.__..._..._...._..._._..._ _.... 'r .
"
'I'd' /'.....
'"
,,'.....
,.'"
~
... --
u
u
S<!ctlon 6. Pr~wlrinR Proiecll
The owner or bullder uC a ruldentlal or comnarclal building or other
project .hall have the right to prOlwire an ent!. e project {or cable .ervlce.
A project Cor the purpo't1 o{ Ihi. .e.cHon .hall be any new conllruction which
at the tlme oC prewlrlnll I. not pa.t thl!! normal .tage o{ electrical wlrlniJo
a. Owner or Bulldor Prewirir11l
Company .hall provide a .l.andard lnlla11allon to a prewired project at
the .tandard in.taUation nte lC the own<lr or build,.r compile' with the
{allowing procedure.
11, Owner or buUder u.e. method. and mAteria" approved in
advance 0 r fupplled by the Com,pany. Company .hall .upply
,p'lcHicUllln. :and mahrtah .t h. co.t upon requett.
IZ, Owner or buUder requellt In.pection and approval according
to a .chedu1e .upplled by Compauy. Company .hall Inspect
and provide technical a..htance at ie. COil upon reque.t,
b. Company Prewirlng
Company .hall provld~ r. .tl-ndard lnstr.llation 10 . prcwlred proj~ct ..t
the .tandard In.taUallon rate II Comp.ny ha. pre....lred the project. Reque.t
{or prewlrlnll .hAIl be .u{r:cl~ntly in advance {or Company to arrange Cor
prewlrin.l except In no <lV!:nt .hall filch advance notice be required to exce...d
{orty-lIve 14 SI day. prior to comm<lncement.
l;. Any aerlalln.taUatlon In exce.. oC I SO teet to a prewlro:d project
shall be l;harlled aCl;ordlng to ..;ectlon J d.
Section 7. Standard Monthlv Service: Rat...
a, Except a. otherwhe .pecUlcally pruvidetl {or, Company may charge
maximum monthly aervlce ntCl to commercial ellabll.lunenU, In.tilutlon.,
alngle-bml1y dwelllnll" .ingle-apartment unit., .Ingle-condomlnlum unit.,
apartment building recreation area. or concomlnlum l;ommOn a reQ. or mobile
~
home! unit. otherwha provided {or under See lion 8, a. {OUOW.I
- ).
Or~t '.I:;JS S
2121/~1
I
I
'\
'.
lJ
u
111 I'lret OuthL
Il) Eaeh Additional Outlet
$6.00
z.oo
(JI Set Top Converter
n/e
14) Remote Control Converter
1.00
15)Sparh Channeh OpUon
z.oo
(6) Each Addlllonal Sporu
, Channel Opthm Outle\
1. 01)
17) I'M Service
z.oo
Scet\o" 8. Splle\lI.l Monthlv S"r..,\c:" Rntu
a. Hoteh, Mote". InaUtutlou and Multi-Family Dwelling UnlUI
11 I Company may (.ha rge maxlmwn n;'onthly lie rvlee ratel to
ap"rt:nen~a. condomlnluma, eooperatlve aparUnenta.' ('!her
multi. lllmlly units, hoteh. moteh, nuralng homea,
hoapitala and other almllar buildup a where thet!! Is
100 pllreent aubacrlptlon. al tollowl'
(a) Each uutlllt
$4.00
(bl Set Top (.~'.verter
n/e
(el Remote Control Converter
1.00
(dl Sporh Channo:lsOptlon
':.00
leI fM Service
2.00
12) One hundred percent 1100":,.1 lubacrlptlon .hll.lt nlean that there
ahall be aa many outleh u habitable unlu In the bulldLng,
b, Publlc Schoola and ColllJgu and Municipal Du\ldlngl anl1
Public Property.
There Ihall be no monthly charlie lor .ervlce to public acheol..
eollellc:J. munlclplll bulldlngl or publlc: property,
Seetlon 9. Tran.cer.
When a eurrent c:uHomer mov... trorn one addrllll within the lranchl.ed
a rea to a aecond addre.. within the tranc:hLllld area and there I. no lap.e In
.ervLee. a lTluLmu.m tnnatl!t charlie of FUleen Dollar. ($15.00) m:lY bc>made.
.4.
OrJ, i. ~035
21ZllqC
I
j
I
i
I
I
1
1
I
I
I
I
}
''',,.' A
.~..~ ~. :...~:.\.~...:I... .... : ~. ' " ". ,I :.', ..' "",\.. .. ~4, :,~;..., ."\. ,'t.: " ..'.oI-lI;'l", :':;\;. ~"'II, ,.."~ ...~,......, :,. ~ . '.'.',
f-
t
I
u u
Sl!ctlell 10, Earlv Extenllon
Company IhalL extend. uvlce puuuanl 10 the early exten'lon pro-
vl.lana DC the lranehhll at ih COltl ,,"hlch .han be apportioned equally among
thOle requeatlnll lhll early extenllon. Co.t. may be required to be pald In
advance or Company may require reallonAble alluranCII 01 paymenl prior 10
commencement ot lueh eltten.lon, In lhe eVent the area Into which early
elttenalon hal heen made reaehlll the denllty required Cor mandatory eltlenJlon.
aueh p.lymenta ahall be treated al eonalderatlon tor e..rly exter.~len lervlee,
Section II. I\econneetlon
Comp01ny .hall reAltorll I "rvice to cuatomer. wilhlng re Itoratlon uf
lervlce. provided cUltomer IhalL llut uthfy Ilny prevloul obUglltlon. Dwec!.
A maxLmum rlleonnllctl~n lee of FIIleen DoIlO1U [$15, OO} may be charged cu~tomllr.
.
S"ctlon IZ. Relocation or Ext"n.\on or Cable
Except lI., otherwlle provided, when A currenl customer rcqueatl an
elttenllon or ruloe:ltlon ol cable to be made. the Company may charge a
maxLmum ol FiIleen Dollars ($15. DOl.
Section I J, Waiver or Certain Fee.
No cha rge Ihall be lTlatle ror any InltaUatlen. tranate r, relocation,
?r reconnectlon which can be accempUlhed without a trLp to the dwelling unit,
Seetlon 14, C"POllltll
CQmpany lTlay require an advance depoa\l Dr.. p:lrt or ,,11 oC the
eatirnated COltl for In.talllltlon, Company may require 11 depoalt lor each
conVerler In an afl"ount not 10 IIltcl:ed the coat ot c:onverterl at lhe tllTle or
Inll:ll1atlon,
~)5. Revlllon ol Rate Schedule
Comp:lny may make appUcallon lor a rllvlalon or the utll Ichedule at
any time alter two ye~u tram date or lhe completion and operation at the
cabie eommunlcatlon lervlee.
'\
-5-
,~ r'j, !: ~ ~ 5
U 211 a 0
I
I
1
~.".
!.
t.
i
t
"
.6.
'-
- '".lot':I. Ii~OOS
un/au
''',I ill
~I" "".. ,>:
~ '< I
[':, :.
, '.
I ~:.'. '
:\." ,
, .
).
'.
~"'~
i {"~ "~'.'~ ,J " l-,'l .
, ." . . ! ~
.". '. .
,
,
'.
. . . ~ ~ .
':
,',.
:,'1 .
,
, ,
~n .
j'.
" '.'
",:' .... -'~: .~ ',' .,..."
~ .f"', ", ' "
. ' ~. " "
August 16, 1995
Betty D:
Verbal Reports for Thursday's Commission meeting:
.r
~so
.' .' ~ > "
Set a meeting for Commissioner's to have Internet demonstration at the Main Library --
preferably in September,
cc: . Cyndie Goudeau
.'
RECEIVED
AUG 1 5 1995
CITY CLERK DEPT.
.',
, '
~ ~, ,~,
',:,.' ., H~ ,., "",'~~I;11
.'
r'':'' .
PRELIMINARY AGENDA
Clearwater City Commission Work session - Monday, August 14, 1995
following CRA which begins at 1 :00 P.M, but no later than 2 P.M.
Clearwater City Commission Meeting - 6:00 ?,M, - Thursday, August 17, 1995
Service Awards
Convene as Pension Trustees
Reconvene as Commission
FN FINANCE
1, No Item,
2, Contract extension for audit services with Coopers & Lybrand, for FY ending 9/30/95, for a total
fee not to exceed $93,300 (Consent)
3, Confirm City Manager's decision to increase domestic and lawn water rates approx, 12,53%
effective 10/1/95, such increased rates to be used for 1 st full billing cycle beginning on or after
10/1/95
f
1
\
~
,
GAS GAS SYSTEM
"
I'
1
"
..'
,
"'
,
1, Contract extension for purchase of Black 3408 polyethylene pipe with M. T. Deason Co" Inc.,
Birmingham, Al, for the period 12/14/95-12/13/96,at an est, $1,018,375 (Consent)
1M INFORMA nON MANAGEMENT
I
~
f
j
I
i
j
1
I
t
I
l
I
I
1, Contract renewal for Unisys A-4 & A-6 computer software licenses to Unisys Corp., Tampa, Fl,
for the period 10/1/95-9/30/96, for $52,681 (Consent)
2, Contract renewal for hardware maintenance/operating system support on the Utilities & Finance
VAX 4000-300 computers to Digital Equipment Corp., Tampa, FL, for the period 10/1/95.
9/30/96, for $45,310.44 (Consent)
3, Purchase of 2 high speed laser printers & installation for Utility Building to Dynamic Solutions
International, Englewood, CO, for $39,380; authorize lease/purchase through city agreement
with Barnett Bank (Consent)
4, Contract for hardware maintenance of the Unisys A-4 & A-6 mainframe computers to Digital
Equipment Corp" Tampa, Fl, for the period 10/1/95-9/30/96, for $33.987.96 (Consent)
LIB LIBRARY
1 . Contract extension for subscription services for library materials with Ebsco Subscription
Services, Birmingham, Al, for the period 10/1/95-9/30/96, at an est. $65,000 (Consent)
EN ENGINEERING
1, Contract for 1995 Gunite Restoration to Infrastructure Services, Inc./ ISI Operating Corp"
Franklin, TN. for $323,711 (Consent)
2, Public Hearing - Vacating a portion of North/South alley north of Pierce St" between Ft, Harrison
Ave. & Osceola Ave. (Peace Memorial Presbyterian Church, V95p1 0)
3, Contract for Hampton Road Widening (Gulf to Bay Blvd. to Drew St,) to R, E, Purcell
Construction Co., Inc., Odessa, Fl, for $588,473.97 (Consent)
4. Memorial Causeway Feasibility Study p accept report in order to set "groundwork" for project,
direction requested to proceed re funding source & future design study type (EN)
8/14/95
1
"
CP CENTRAL PERMITTING
\ .
1. ICont, from 7/20/95) Public Hearing & First Reading Ords. #5741-95 & #5742-95 - Land Use
. Plan Amendment to Commercial General for property located at 509 Bayview Ave, and 508
Meadow Lark Lane, Town of Bay View a/k/a McMullen Bayview Sub., Blk 3, part of Lots 1 & 2,
and S 1/2 of vacated street abutting N side of lots; and CPO Zoning for property located at 509
Bayview Ave" 508 Meadow Lark Lane, and 3009 Gulf to Bay Blvd., McMullen Bayview Sub"
Blk 3, part of Lots 1 & 2 and Bayview City Sub" Lot A, and vacated street r-o-w between Lot A
and Lots 1 & 2 of McMullen Bayview Sub.; LUP 0.70 acres m.o.I.. Rezoning 1.02 acres m.o.l.
IR, Roy Meador, lUP93-43, Z93-541
2, (Cont. from 7/20/95) Variance(s) to Sign Regulations for property located at 387 1/2 Mandalay
Ave" Barbour-Morrow Sub., Blk A, Lots 23-25 (Homer Realty, Inc, I Wedgwood House Estate
Jewelers, SV95-31)
3. Variance(s) to Sign Regulations for property located at 2632 Enterprise Rd. (Europa of
Countryside, A Condominium, SV95-331
4. Public Hearing & First Reading Ord, #5820-95 ~ Amending Sec. 42.34 - LDCA re parking space
formulae (LDCA 94-28)
5, Receipt/Referral- LDCA to modify restrictions on vending machine signage (LDCA 95-17)
(Consent)
,
i
1
l
i
(
CM ADMINISTRATION
~
I
I
!
I
1
J
1 , Pension Ordinance
2. Res. #95-65 - Approving a new Community Redevelopment Plan for the Community
Redevelopment area located in the downtown area of the City
eLK CITY CLERK
1. Direction re Town Meetings
CA LEGAL DEPARTMENT
Second Reading Ordinances
1. (Cont. from 8/3/95) Ord, #5861-95 - Annexation for property located at 1528 Stevensons Dr"
Stevenson's Heights, Blk A, Lot 20 (Rowe, A95-12)
2, (Cont, from 8/3/95) Ord, #5862-95 - Land Use Plan Amendment to Residential low for property
located at 1528 Stevensons Dr., Stevenson's Heights, Blk A, Lot 20 (Rowe, LUP95-14)
3, (Cont. from 8/3/95) Ord, #5863-95 ~ RS-8 Zoning for property located at 1528 Stevensons Dr"
Stevenson's Heights, Blk A, Lot 20 (Rowe, A95.12)
4, Ord. #5869-95. Amending Sec, 2.60(3), relating to term of members of the Environmental
Advisory Board
5. Ord, #5870.95 - Annexation for property located at 109 Meadow lark Lane B, Bayview City
Sub., Blk 2, Lots 1 & 2 and abutting alley to South (Kadlec, A95-14)
6, Ord. #5871-95 - Land Use Plan Amendment to Residential Urban for property located at 109
Meadow lark Lane B, Bayview City Sub" Blk 2, l.ots 1 & 2 and abutting alley to South (Kadlec,
LUP95~ 16)
7, Ord. #5872-95 - RS-8 Zoning for property located at 109 Meadow lark Lane B. Bayview City
Sub., Blk 2, Lots 1 & 2 and abutting alley to South (Kadlec, A95-14)
8. Ord. #5873-95 - CG Zoning for property located at 1969 Sunset Point Rd" Pinellas Groves
Sub., SW 1/4. part of Lots 1 & 2 (Sauder, Z95-03)
9. Ord, #5874.95 - CPD Zoning for property located at 705, 707, 709 & 711 Jasmine Way,
Magnolia Park, Blk 31, Lots 2-5 (Smolen sky and Kornreich, 295-04)
8/14/95
2
i.:."~. '0 .
16,
19.
20,
1 0,
Ord. #5878.95- Annexation for property located at 412 Oakmount Rd" Oakmount Sub., Lot 2 .
and abutting r-o-w IClark. Jr, and Warren, A95-17)
Ord. #5879.95 - Land Use Plan Amendment to Residential Low for property located at 412
Oakmount Rd" Oakmount Sub" Lot 2 and abutting r-o-w (Clark. Jr. and Warren, LUP95~19)
Ord. #6880-95 - RS-6 Zoning for property located at 412 Oak mount Rd., Oakmount Sub., Lot 2
and abutting r-c-w (Clark, Jr. and Warren, A95-17)
Ord. #5881-96 - Annexation for property located at 1236 Kapok Circle, Kapok Forest, Lot 14
(Sarlo and Hassell, A95-18)
Ord. #6882-96 - Land Use Plan Amendment to Residential Low for property located at 1236
Kapok Circle, Kapok Forest, Lot 14 ISarlo and liassell, LUP95-20)
Ord. #6883-96 - RS-6 Zoning for property located at 1236 Kapok Circle, Kapok Forest, Lot 14
(Sario and Hassell, A95-18)
Ord. #5884-95 - Annexation for property located at 1238 Brookside Dr" Meadow Creek Sub"
Blk C, Lot 10 (Coulter, A95-19)
Ord. #5885.96 - Land Use Plan Amendment to Residential Low for property located at 1238
Brookside Dr., Meadow Creek Sub" Blk C, Lot 10 (Coulter. LUP95-21)
Ord, #5886-95 - RS-4 Zoning for property located at 1238 Brookside Dr., Meadow Creek Sub"
Blk C, Lot 10 (Coulter, A95-19)
Ord. #5887-95 - CGS - Gas Rate Case
Ord. #5888-95 - Relating to the Community Redevelopment Agency; providing. for repeal of
Ords, #2576-81 & #3021-83, which adopted and amended the redevelopment plan for
downtown Clearwater; providing for proper notice
11.
12,
13,
14.
15,
17.
18,
OTHER CITY ATTORNEY ITEMS
1) Res. #96-66 - Authorizing execution of Pinellas County Interlocal Mutual Aid Assistance
Agreement for police services
2) Res, #95-67 - Authorizing execution of Tampa Bay Multi-Agency Gang Task Force Mutual Aid
Agreement
City Manager Verbal Reports
Commission Discussion Items
a) Solid Waste Collection Services in unincorporated Plnellas County
b) Beach Tower
c} Downtown Partnership roles
Other Commission Action
I
8/14/95
Adjourn
3
~\
SERVICE ~WARDS
!
i
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
!
~
I
}
~
I
i
j
!
TO: Mayor Rita Garvey
FROM: Betty J. Blunt, Conf~dential Clerk Receptionist
COPIES: city Commissioners, Betty Deptula, Cyndie Goudeau
SUBJECT: Presentation at the August 14, 1995 Work S~ssion
DATE: August 14, 1995
The following presentation will be made at the August 14, 1995 Work
Session.
S years
~tsy Clement - Information Management (letter of appreciation, pin
with city seal)
~homas Miller - Engineering (letter of appreciation, pin with city
seal)
VSean Schlesman - Parks & Recreation (letter of appreciation, pin
with city seal)
~o years
~oseph zagone - Police (letter of appreciation, desk clock)
~John Diebel - Police (letter of appreciation, wall clock)
~nrad McCree - Police (letter of appreciation, wall clock)
~ene Colmenares (~PT) - Parks & Recreation (letter of appreciation
pin with seal)
if Carla collins - Police (letter of appreciation, desk clock)
~tephen Doherty - Central Permitting (letter of appreciation, wall
clock)
lS years
v,{erry Williams - solid Waste (letter of appreciation, plaque)
vDennis Brown - Solid Waste (letter of appreciation, plaque)
20 years
James McGee - Public Works (letter of appreciation, watch with city
seal)
25 years
vbonald Andrus - Engineering (letter of appreciation, day off with
pay, dinner certificate)
Jt":'. .,
CITY OF CLEARWATER
cnlQ.
P. O. Bo:t 4748
City Commission
Clearwater, Florida 34618-4748
COPIES TO:
COMMISSION
JUN 2 9 1995
l\1EMOlJ-ANDUM:
PRESS
CLERK I ATTORNEY
TO:
Betty Deptula, City Manager
FROM:
COPIES:
DATE:
Mayor and Commissioners
~
i
RB:
June 29. 1995
Solid Waste Collection Services
..*.*..*.......~~.............*.......*...+...................................
,
,
I read with interest the copy of a letter. from Mayor Thomas Feaster to Commissioner Steven
Seibert. concerning soUd waste collection services. Perhaps the City of Clearwater should make
a proposal to the County Commission in regards to out contracting for solid waste services in
unIncorporated Pinellas County. It a.ppears that a letter was sent to Mr. Marquis by Mayor
Garvey in September of 1994 on this su~Ject, Just waiting fot a reply from the County isn't
necessarily helping the situation; and yet, we can't force an answer. but we can make a
proposal.
Please put this on a summer worksession, perhaps Mr. Brumback would welcome this
opportunity of expansion.
FAT/rk
\
1
i
I
i
!,
i'
I
.,
"
J
.
1
j
"
~::1~:.~~~" .
Ch-:t: b.
PROPOSAL TO CITY OF CLEARWATER
JRG Marketing or entity to be later named, proposes the following land lease
agreement with the city of Clearwater.
LESSEE will erect a 335 foot Willy BOhler 64 passenger Sky Tower with appropriate loading
facilities, ticketing, and waiting area.
I
I
I
I
I
:
I
I
i
I
I
Lessee will provide the following:
LESSEE will establish operating hours compatible with existing operating hours of neighboring
commercial interests. As demand increases, these hours may be extended beyond the operating
hours of the neighboring interests.
The Tower will be inspected daily by qualified technicians and maintained in near perfect condition
and appearance at all times.
LESSEE will provide required workmen's compensation and $10,000,000 single limit liability
insurance in full force at all times from initial start of constl1Jction, naming the city of Clearwater
as additional assureds if desired.
LESSEE will allow placement of appropJiate name or logo copy designed by the city of Clearwater
to be affixed to Tower.
LESSEE will begin engineering studies immediately and construction within thirty (30) after receipt
of all permits applicable,
LESSEE will remunerate the city of Clearwater in the following amounts:
· $48,000.00 per annum minimum guarantee against following percentages, whichever
greater.
· 8% of gross receipts up to $1,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 12% of gross from $1,000,001.00 through $5,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 20% of gross receipts from $5,000,001.00 up per year.
5 years after first day of operation, remuneration will be as follows:
· $60,000.00 per annum minimum guarantee ugainst following percentages, whichever
greater,
· 10% of gross receipts up to $1,000,000.00 pel' year gross.
· 141% of gross from $1,000,001.00 through $5,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 22lXl of gross receipts from $5,000,001.00 up per year.
.
4
.,
j,
.~ j.:~ ...; .<'
.'
Twr,Lease
Page 2
15 years after first day of operation, remuneration will be as follows and remain such throughout
lease tenn.
· $72,000.00 per annum minimum guarantee against following percentages, whichever
greater.
· 13% of gross receipts up to $1,000,000.00 per year gross.
· 17% of gross from $1,000,001.00 through $5,000,000.00 per year gross,
· 25% of gross receipts from $S ,000,00 1.00 up per year.
~
~
I
Payment will be made quarterly and accompanied by computer printollt of the quarter's activity on
a daily basis. Initial payment date will be due ninety (90) days after first day of operation, LESSEE
wiII allow city complete access to its financials upon seventy-two (72) hours notice.
LESSEE will provide a bond in the amount of $175,000 to cover disassembly and removal of tower
from city property in event of business failure. LESSEE will at its own expense, bear this obligation
for one (1) year from date of completion of construction. Extension of one ( 1) year to be negotiated,
LESSEE win provide $100,000 working capital until cash flow dictates this amount unnecessary.
LESSEE will provide required Federal Aviation Agency permit.
LESSEE will provide adequate staff, clothed in distinctive logoed clothing and will maintain the
entire structure and premises in the highest standard possible,
City of Clearwater will provide the following:
LESSOR will provide thirty (30) year lease with option to renew predicated upon negotiated
upgrades to tower.
LESSOR will provide adequate space to erect "Towel''', loading dock, ticket sales and machine
room, (Space needed approximately 60 feet frontage, 80 feet deep. Space to be east of coastal
control fence, west of street side sidewalk, south of first street, and nm1h of Adams Mark Hotel).
LESSOR will provide landscaping to be maintained by LESSEE.
LESSOR will provide at no cost 10 LESSEE, live (5) stalTparkillg spaces immediately adjncentto
tower and appropriately marked as such.
.:.,0
_~;~~~ ;;~o~ . ~
j'.
I
i, I
".< r 0'
" , ,. I>
.'. '.,.
Twr.Lease
Page 3
LESSOR will allow LESSEE spot promos on television channel 3S at no cost to LESSEE except
production costs of camera ready video tapes.
LESSOR will provide all required local permits as expediously as possible and will assist LESSEE
in securing all said permits. .
A detailed list of permits required will be furnished LESSEE within ten (10) days after signing of
lease,
LESSOR will allow sales of tower logoed Tee Shirts, miniature model towers, post cards! film and
sunglasses from this facility. Sales of these items will be factored into tower gross and appropriate
percentages paid to city. No other merchandise will be marketed without the express written
consent of the city of Clearwater.
James R. Grogan, III
JRG Marketing
Date