FLD2006-04020
~ .;cUearwater
.... -;.:.... ....' > ~
o
(
o SUBMIT ORIGINAL SIG
I
o SUBMIT 14 COPIES 01
application are required
o SUBMIT APPLlCATIO~ MAGGIO, SAL ,
~_Zon~~DR_., ___ ___ atlas# 314A )
* NOTE: 15 TOTAL SETS OF INFORMATION REQUIRED (APPLICATIONS PLUS SITE'PLAN SETS)
~ Planning Department
100 South Myrtle Avenue
Clearwater, Florida 33756
Telephone: 727-562-4567
Fax: 727-562-4865
CASE #: .' ~'J)d.rti.tJ OLl D 20
RECEIVED BY (staff initials): -
DATE RECEIVED:
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 08 2006
801 HOWARD ST
FLD2006-04020
~
!
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
City OF CLEARWATER
FLEXIBLE DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION
Residential InfiIl Project (Revised 03/28/~006)
~PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT~
A. APPLICANT, PROPERTY OWNER AND AGENT INFORMATION: (Code Section 4-202.A)
APPLICANT NAME:
MAILING ADDRESS:
PHONE NUMBER:
PROPERTY OWNER(S):
List ALL owners on the deed
AGENT NAME:
MAILING ADDRESS:
PHONE NUMBER:
CELL NUMBER:
S,r=..
FAX NUMBER:
1.()8& LA~ /~\{E
'7'27 ~ Sh\ - 502"'-->
~T {09
B. PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT INFORMATION: (Code Section 4-202.A)
PROJECT NAME:
STREET ADDRESS
PARCEL NUMBER(S):
PARCEL SIZE (acres):
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
PROPOSED USE(S):
DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST:
1-
Specifically identify the request
(include number of units or square
footage of non-residential use and all
requested code deviations; e.g.
reduction in required number of
parking spaces, specific use, etc.)
PROJECT VALUATION: $
a::::>
10.
PARCEL SIZE (square feet):
FEeT 'To tD FEeT
S \Planning OepartmenllApphcatlon Formsldevelopment review\2006 Fo<msIResidentoaJ Infill PrOject (FLD) 2006 doc
Page 1 or8
Donoghue Wood & Associates, Inc.
ARCHITECTS
332 SKINNER BL YD. DUNEDIN, FL. 34698
PH. 727.735-0411 FAX 727-734-2927
ORIGINAl
RECEIVED
JUN 08 2006
Date: April 20, 2005
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CI1V OF CLEARWATER
To: City of Clearwater
Flexible Development Variance Department
Re: Maggio Residence
801 Howard Street, Clearwater,.FL 33756
22-29-15-07938-010-0010
Dear Sir,
PAGE #2 of 8. Letter D
1) The proposed development of the land will be in hannony with the scale,
bulk, coverage, density and character of adjacent properties in which it is
located as follows:
a) Scale: The scale of the home and property is very similar to the
homes in the neighborhood. It will most definitely be in hannony
with the adjacent properties and neighborhood.
b) Bulk: The bulk of the proposed project is in accordance with the
neighborhood. It is a 1 story single family home wit4 a porch, which
fits in very comfortably with the community.
c) Coverage: The proposed home is consistent with the one-story single
family residences throughout the neighborhood.
d) Density: The home will compliment the lot, not affecting the density
of the area. The area of the lot by code does not allow for more than a
single family residence, which is being maintained. The unimproved
area of Myrtle Avenue only makes the lot look larger.
e) Character: The character of the neighborhood is Old Clearwater.
This home with it's front porch and side stoop truly fits in with the
feel of the community.
1
2) The development of this beautiful upscale home will not hinder nor
discourage the appropriate development and use of the adjacent land and_
building or significantly impair the value thereof. This look of this home
and its value will increase interest in the neighborhood and as a result
increase property values.
3) The proposed development will not adversely affect the health or safety
of persons residing or working in the neighborhood of the proposed use.
The lot originally had an older unmaintained home on it. This was
demolished to accommodate the new modem and up to date coded
proposed home. This new home and the demolition of the older home
will make this a safer environment for residence and people working in
the area.
4) The proposed development is designed to minimize traffic congestion in
the neighborhood. With its 2-car driveway, rarely will cars have to be
parked on the street, thus making the visibility better and safer for the
residence. Children playing will more noticeable and there will not be
curb congestion due to cars being parked there.
5) The new proposed development is most definitely consistent with the
character of the immediate vicinity. This is achieved by the design of the
home being of the Older Florida look - front porch and side stoop -
making it a family friendly, very inviting home which is characteristic of
the City of Clearwater and the surrounding vicinity. .
6) To minimize the adverse effects including visual, acoustical and olfactory
and hours of operations impacts on the adjacent properties the following
applies: '
a) Visual- The proposed home adds beauty to the lot. An older
unmaintained home was demolished from this lot to accommodate
this new proposed home. The new home maintains the charm of the
area but cleans up the lot with a new structure.
b) Acoustical- This is a single-family residence. Acoustically, there are
not any changes; thus no adverse effects will be incurred.
c) Olfactory - This is a single-family residence. There will not be any
changes, thus minimizing any adverse effects.
d) Hours of Operation - There is not a business running out of the home.
The hours of family operation will remain the same as most single
family residences. Vehicles will be in and out of the driveway for
family, personal and job related matters. This will not cause any
adverse effects to the adjacent properties. ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 08 2006
2
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CI1Y OF CLEARWATER
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 0 8 2006
PAGE #3 of8
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
crrv OF CLEARWATER
Response to Residential Infill Criteria of the Application:
l) The wedge shape of the lot as well as the narrow'ness of the lot, make it
impractical to maintain the 25' setback on Myrtle Avenue. Also the
reduction of the front setback on Myrtle Avenue will not be noticeable
due to the fact that Myrtle Avenue is undeveloped. As per Engineering
Department, there is a low likelihood that Myrtle Avenue will ever be
improved due to the existence of the drainage ditch, width of the right.of.
way, closeness to the railroad track and that adjacent properties are being
served by either Howard Street or Scranton Avenue.
2) The development of the proposed parcel is an upscale modular home. As
a residential infill project this home will not reduce the fair market value
of the abutting properties. Not only beautiful, this home is a high end
modular home that will enhance the beauty and value of the
neighborhood.
3) The use of this residence is permitted within the City of Clearwater. The
residence is a single family home, which is permitted. The residence
does not fall into the category ofunpermittable.
4) The use and/or mix of the use with the residential infill project are
compatible with the adjacent land uses. This home, a~ with the rest of the
neighborhood is a single family home, which is what the neighborhood
calls for. It is compatible with the adjacent properties.
5) The proposed modular home is of a: design that enhances the community
character and the immediate vicinity of the proposed parcel and the City
of Clearwater. It is a clean design with a front porch and stoop. A very
nice look which reminds one of the era from an older time in the City of
Clearwater. The porch and stoop enhance the family friendly atmosphere
that Clearwater is known for. '
6) Same as the above (this is the same exact question)
7) Please see below:
a) How the flexibility in regards to the lot width for the new home is
justified by the benefits to the community character and immediate
vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of
Clearwater as a whole is as follows: The lot width is very similar to
neighboring homes and fits well with the 'community character. The
lot improvements will beautify the lot and enhance the look of the
neighborhood and the City of Clearwater as a whole, which all
neighbors will benefit from. .
3
b) How the flexibility in regards to the setbacks for the new home is
justified by the benefits to the community character and immediate
vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of
Clearwater as a whole is as follows: Due to the unimproved right of
way of Myrtle Avenue, the infill request for the front yard set back
from 25' .0" to 10' .0" will only permit a more expensive home to be
placed on the lot in the neighborhood elevating values in the
neighborhood, benefiting all residents. With this unimproved area on
Myrtle Avenue, the home will look as if it is sitting similar to those in
the neighborhood. It will fit into the character of the neighborhood
and the City of Clearwater as a whole. As mentioned before, it will
keep up the family friendly atmosphere, the City of Clearwater is so
well known for.
c) How the flexibility in regards to the height of the new home is
justified by the benefits to the community character and ~mmediate
vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of
Clearwater as'a whole is as follows: The height of the proposed home
is a 1 story, single family home. This height is consistent with
neighboring homes and falls within the flexibility of the neighborhood
and the City of Clearwater. The home's height compliments the
community character and the City of Clearwater as a whole.
d) How the flexibility in regards to the off street parking of the new
home is justified by the benefits to the community character and
immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the
City of Clearwater as a whole is as follows: The 2 car driveway will
enable the homeowner's to avoid parking in the street, which will
actually decrease the use of street parking. This will benefit the
neighborhood and the City of Clearwater as 'a whole in terms of
safety, vehicular vision, child's play and neighborhood beauty. The
neighborhood/community character will remain the same.
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
Richard T. Donoghue
AR.00I0304
JUN 08 2006
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CITY Of CLEARWATER
4
r-
DOES THIS APPLICATION INVOLVE THE TRANSFER OF DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS (TOR), A R EVIOUSL Y APPROVED PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENT, OR A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED (CERTIFIED) SITE PLAN? YES _ NO (If yes, attach a copy of the applicable documents)
C. PROOF OF OWNERSHIP: (Code Section 4-202.A.5)
D SUBMIT A COPY OF THE TITLE INSURANCE POLICY, DEED TO THE PROPERTY OR SIGN AFFIDAVIT ATTESTING OWNERSHIP
(see page 7)
D. WRITTEN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Code Section 3-913.A)
D Provide complete responses to the six (6) GENERAL APPLICABILITY CRITERIA - Explain how each cnteria is achieved, in detail:
1. The proposed development of the land will be in harmony with the scale, bulk, coverage, density and character of adjacent properties in which
it is located.
2. The proposed development Will not hinder or discourage the appropriate development and use of adjacent land and buildings or significantly
impair the value thereof.
3. The proposed development will not adversely affect the health or safety or persons residing or working in the neighborhood of the proposed use.
ORIGINAL
RECEI"ED
JuN 0 (5 2006
4. The proposed development is designed to minimize traffic congestion.
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CllY OF CLEARWATER
5. The proposed development IS consistent With the community character of the Immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development.
6. The design of the proposed development minimizes adverse effects, including visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operation impacts,
on adjacent properties.
S IPlannlng DepartmentlApphcallon Formsldevelopment rel/lew\2006 FormslResldenllallnfill Project (FlD) 2006 doc
Page 2 of8
WRITTEN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Residentiallnfill Project Criteria)
o Provide complete responses to the seven (7) RESIDENTIAL INFILL PROJECT CRITERIA - Explain how each cntena is achieved, in detail:
1. The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for development is otherwise impractical without deviations from the intensity and
development standards.
2. The development of the parcel proposed for development as a residential infill project will not materially reduce the fair market value of abutting
properties. (Include the existing value of the site and the proposed value of the site with the improvements.)
3. The uses withm the residential infill project are otherwise permitted in the City of Clearwater.
4. The uses or mix of use within the residential infill project are compatible with adjacent land uses.
5. The design of the proposed residential infill project creates a form and function that enhances the community character of the immediate vicinity of
the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole.
6. The design of the proposed residential infill project creates a form and function that enhances the community character of the immediate vicinity of
the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole.
7. Flexibility in regard to lot width, required setbacks, height and off-street parking are justified by the benefits to community character and the
immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of Clearwater as a whole. ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 08 2006
PLANNING DE:t1ARTMEr-tT
CITY OF CLEARWATE:~
S IPlannlng Department\Apphcation Formsldevelopmenl revlew\2006 FormslResidentiaJ Infill Project (FLD) 2006 doc
Page 3 of8
" rE""':"STORMWATER PLAN SUBrvll. TAL REQUIREMENTS: (City of Clearwater Storm Drainage Design Criteria
Manual and 4-202.A.21)
o
A STORMWATER NARRATIVE MUST BE SUBMITTED WITH ALL APPLICATIONS. All applications that involve addition
or modification of impervious surface, including buildings, must include a stormwater plan that demonstrates compliance with the City of
Clearwater Storm Drainage Design Criteria manual. A reduction in impervious surface area does not qualify as an exemption to this requirement.
o
If a plan is not required, the narrative shall provide an explanation as to why the site is exempt.
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
At a minimum, the STORMWATER PLAN shall include the follOWing;
Existing topography extending 50 feet beyond all property lines;
Proposed grading including finished floor elevations of all structures;
All adjacent streets and municipal storm systems;
Proposed stormwater detention/retention area including top of bank, toe of slope and outlet control structure;
A narrative descrrbing the proposed stormwater control plan including all calculations and data necessary to demonstrate compliance with
the City manual.
Proposed stormwater detention/retention area including top of bank, toe of slope and outlet control structure;
Signature and seal of Florida Registered Professional Engineer on all plans and calculations.
o
COPY OF PERMIT INQUIRY LETTER OR SOUTHWEST FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT (SWFWMD) PERMIT
SUBMITTAL (SWFWMD approval is required prior to issuance of City Building Permit), if applicable
o
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF STORMWATER PLAN REQUIREMENTS (Applicant must initial one of the following):
Stormwater plan as noted above is included
Stormwater plan is not required and explanation narrative is attached. At a minimum, a grading plan and finished floor
elevations shall be provided.
~,o.
CAUTION -IF APPLICATION REVIEW RESULTS IN THE REQUIREMENT FOR A STORMWATER PLAN
AND NONE HAS BEEN SUBMITTED, APPLICATION MUST BE RESUBMITTED AND SIGNIFICANT DELAY
MAY OCCUR.
If you have questions regarding these requirements, contact the City Public Works Administration Engineering Department at (727) 562-4750.
F. SUPPLEMENTAL SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Code Section 4-202.A)
o SIGNED AND SEALED SURVEY (Including legal description of property) - One original and 14 copies;
o TREE SURVEY (Including existing trees on site and within 25' of the adjacent site, by species, size (DBH 4" or greater), and location,
including drip lines and indicating trees to be removed) - please design around the existing trees;
o TREE INVENTORY; prepared by a 'certified arborist", of all trees 8" DBH or greater, reflectmg size, canopy (drip lines) and
condition of such trees;.
o LOCATION MAP OF THE PROPERTY;
o PARKING DEMAND STUDY In conjunction with a request to make deviations to the parking standards (ie. Reduce number of spaces).
Prior to the submittal of this application, the methodology of such study shall be approved by the Community Development Coordinator and
shall be in accordance with accepted traffic engineering principles. The findings of the study will be used in determining whether or not
deviations to the parking standards are approved; .
o GRADING PLAN, as applicable;
o PRELIMINARY PLAT, as required (Note: BUilding permits Will not be issued until evidence of recording a final plat is provided);
o COPY OF RECORDED PLAT, as applicable;
RECEIVED
JU:'J 08 2006
, ., PLANNING DEPARTMENT
S \Planning DepartmentlApplicallon Forms\developmenl revlew\2006 Forms\Resldentlallnfill PrOject (FLD) 2006 doc OF CLEARWATER
Page 4 of 8 CrTY
" I
r.:.
-, \
SITE PLAN SUBMITTAL REl.cuIREMENTS: (Section 4-202.A)
o
SITE PLAN with the following information (not to exceed 24" x 36"):
Index sheet referenCing individual sheets included in package;
North arrow;
Engineering bar scale (minimum scale one inch equals 50 feet). and date prepared;
All dimensions;
Footprint and size of all EXISTING buildings and structures;
Footprint and size of all PROPOSED bUildings and structures;
All required setbacks,
All existing and proposed points of access;
All required sight triangles;
Identification of environmentally unique areas, such as watercourses, wetlands, tree masses, and specimen trees, including
description and location of understory, ground cover vegetatIOn and wildlife habitats, etc; Location of all public and private easements;
Location of all street nghts-of-way within and adjacent to the site;
Locallon of existing public and private utilities. including fire hydrants, storm and sanitary sewer lines, manholes and lift stations, gas
and water lines;
All parking spaces, driveways, loading areas and vehicular use areas;
Depiction by shading or crosshatching of all reqUIred parking lot interior landscaped areas;
Location of all solid waste containers, recycling or trash handling areas and outside mechanical equipment and all required screening
{per Section 3-201 (D)(I) and Index #701};
Location of all landscape material;
Location of all onsile and offsite storm-water management facilities;
Location of all outdoor lighting fixtures; and
Location of all existing and proposed sidewalks.
o SITE DATA TABLE for existing. required, and proposed development, in writtenltabular form:
EXISTING
REQUIRED
PROPOSED
Land area in square feet and acres;
Number of EXISTING dwelling units;
N'umber of PROPOSED dwelling umts;
Gross floor area devoted to each use;
Parking spaces: total number, presented in tabular form with the
number of required spaces;
Total paved area, including all paved parking spaces & driveways,
expressed in square feet & percentage of the paved vehicular area;
Official records book and page numbers of all existing ulility
easement;
Building and structure heights;
Impermeable surface ratio (I.S.R.); and
Floor area ralio (FAR.) for all nonresidential uses.
o REDUCED COLOR SITE PLAN to scale (8 Y:z X 11);
o FOR DEVELOPMENTS OVER ONE ACRE, provide the follOWing additional information on site plan:
One-foot contours or spot elevalions on site;
Offsite elevations If required to evaluate the proposed stormwater management for the parcel;
All open space areas;
Location of all earth or water retaining walls and earth berms;
Lot lines and building lines (dimensioned);
Streets and drives (dimenSioned);
Building and structural setbacks (dimensioned);
Structural overhangs;
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 08 2006
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CITY OF CLEARWATER
S \Planning DepartmentlApphcallon Formsldevelopment reVlew\2006 FormslResldenballnfill PrOject (FlD) 2006 doc
Page 5 of8
t-1. LANDSCAPING PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 4-1102.A)
o LANDSCAPE PLAN with the following information (not to exceed 24" x 36"):
All existing and proposed structures;
Names of abutting streets;
Drainage and retention areas including swales, side slopes and bottom elevations;
Delineation and dimensions of all reqUIred penmeter landscape buffers;
Sight visibility triangles;
Delineation and dimensions of all parking areas including landscaping islands and curbing;
Existing trees on-site and immediately adjacent to the site, by speCies, size and locations, including driplines (as indicated on required
tree survey);
Location, size, and quantities of all eXisting and proposed landscape materials, indicated by a key relating to the plant
schedule;
Plant schedule with a key (symbol or label) indicating the size, description, specifications, quantities, and spacing requirements of all
existing and proposed landscape materials, including botanical and common names;
Typical planting details for trees, palms, shrubs and ground cover plants including instructions, soil mixes, backfilling, mulching and
protective measures;
Interior landscaping areas hatched and/or shaded and labeled and interior landscape coverage, expressing in both square feet and
percentage covered;
Conditions of a previous development approval (e.g. conditions imposed by the Community Development Board);
Imgation notes.
o REDUCED COLOR LANDSCAPE PLAN to scale (8 Y. X 11);
o COMPREHENSIVE LANDSCAPE PROGRAM application, as applicable. Landscape associated with the Comprehensive
Landscape Program shall exceed minimum Code requirements to offset the areas where minimum Code will not be met.
I. BUILDING ELEVATION PLAN SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS: (Section 4-202.A.23)
o BUILDING ELEVATION DRAWINGS - With the following information;
All sides of all buildings;
Dimensioned;
Colors (provide one full sized set of colored elevations);
Materials;
Sight visibility triangles;
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 08 2006,
o
REDUCED BUILDING ELEVATIONS - same as above to scale on 8 Y. X 11.
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CITY OF CLEARWATER
J. SIGNAGE: (Division 19. SIGNS J Section 3-1806)
;
o All EXISTING freestanding and attached signs; Provide photographs and dimensions (area, height, etc.), indicate whether they will be
removed or to remain.
o All PROPOSED freestanding and attached signs; Provide details including location, size, height, colors, materials and drawing;
freestanding signs shall include the street address (numerals)
o Comprehensive Sign Program application, as applicable (separate application and fee required).
o Reduced signage proposal (8 Y. X 11) (color), if submitting Comprehensive Sign Program application.
S IPlannlng DepartmentlApphcalton Formsldevelopment reVlew\2006 FormsIRes.dent.allnfill PrOject (FLD) 2006 doc
Page 6 of8
. ,
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
K. TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY: (Section 4-202.A.13 and 4-801.C)
JUN 08 2006
o
Include If required by the Traffic Operations Manager or his/her designee or If the proposed development:
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CITY OF CLEARWATER
Will degrade the acceptable level of service for any roadway as adopted in the Comprehensive Plan.
Will generate 100 or more new vehicle directional tripS per hour and/or 1000 or more new vehicle trips per day.
Will a~ect a nearby roadway segment and/or intersection with five,(p) reportable accidents within the prior twelve (12) month period or
that ison the City's annual list of most hazardous intersections. . ,
Trip generation shall be based on the most recent edition of the Institute of Transportation Engineer's (ITE) Trip General Manual.
The Tr IC Impact Study must be prepared in accordance WIth a .Scoping Meeting" held with the Traffic Operations Manager and the
PI Ing Department's Development Review Manager or their designee (727-562-4750)
Refer to Section 4-801 C of the Community Development Code for exceptions to this requirement.
Acknowledgement of traffic impact study requirements (Applicant must initial one of the following):
Traffic Impact Study IS included. The study must include a summary table of pre- and post-development levels of service for all
roadway legs and each turning movement at all intersections identified in the Scoping Meeting.
12-,0. Traffic Impact Study is not required.
, . I i
CAUTION -IF APPLICATION REVIEW RESULTS IN THE REQUIREMENT FOR A TRAFFIC
IMPACT STUDY AND NONE HAS BEEN SUBMITTED, APPLICATION MUST BE RESUBMITTED
AND SIGNIFICANT DELAY MAY OCCUR.
If you have questions regarding these requirements, contact the City Public Wor1<s Admimstration Engineering Department at (727) 562-
4750.
L. FIRE FLOW CALCULATIONSI WATER STUDY:
Provide Fire Flow Calculations. Water Study by a FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEER to assure an adequate water supply is available and to detennine if
any upgrades are required by the developer due to the impact of this project. The water supply must be able to support the needs of any required fire
sprinkler, standpipe and/or fire pump. If a fire pump is required the water supply must be able to supply 150% of its rated capacity. Compliance with
the 2004 Florida Fire Prevention Code to include NFPA 13, MFPA 14, NFPA 20, NFPA 291, and MFPA 1142 (Annex H) is required.
o Acknowledgement of fire flow calculations/water study requirements (Applicant must initial one of the following):
Fire Flow Calculations/Water Study is Included.
-12--- ,0 Fire Flow Calculations/Water Study is not required.
CAUTION -IF APPLICATION REVIEW RESULTS IN THE REQUIREMENT FOR A FIRE FLOW
CALCULATIONSI WATER STUDY AND NONE HAS BEEN SUBMITTED, APPLICATION MUST BE
RESUBMITTED AND SIGNIFICANT DELAY MAY OCCUR.
If you have questions regarding these requirements"contact the City Fire Prevention Department at (727) 562-4334.
MarlIn R WingI..
M. SIGNATURE:
I, the undersigned, acknowledge that all representations made
in this application are true and accurate to the best of my
knowledge and authorize City representatives to visit and
photograph the property described in this application.
~~.... ~~e5
S IPlannlng DepartmentlApphcatlon Formsldevelopment revlew\2006 FormslResldent.allnfill PrOject (FLD) 2006 doc
Page 7 of8
FD10M Donoghue Wood ASSOCi,
Inc
FAX NO.
7277342927
Ma~. 02 2006 01:03PM P3
,
N. f\FFIDAVIT TO AUTHORIZE;AGENT:
I
1. ProvIde nameS 01 all property (lWners on (h~('I:l PRINT' full nClIl10~:
/rc....S/- IVO. ~~/ .._.~~.
: C~~ L~ ""' c~.J....Re; {~C1 h
_.----
--,-----
2. That (I -amIwe t'lre) the owner{s) and record title hOld~((~) of the following described property (address or general location):
go/
1-/0 ~..~sL ~I
ek Co r. tyt.!- (~
-
~L
3. That this property constitute5 the property for which a request for a: (describe request)
j; I <t:f? /'eJ / r:.. d2-e v e/c-~.vo-. .u,/ /-&:; b( /' lot? c", hc-J-.. '<.
4. That the undersigned (has/l1ave) appointed and (does/do) appoint;
~.. r:.- L c..re/ :/) (7 h Oq J,(,.,~
, ./
'-I-
..s4/_ /V;~~/C
8S (hisltheir) agcnt(s) 10 execute any petitIOns or other documents necessary to affll(,1 such petilion;
5.
TIlat this affidavit h<JS been executed to induce the City of Clea.water, FlOrida to consider and act on the above descrillCd property;
6.
That site visits to the property are neecssary by City repretentativBs in order to process this application and the owner authorizes C.i1'L
representatives to visit and photograph the property described In this application; URIGINAl
RECENED
x
authoritY, hereby certify tl1'at the foregoing is true and corrClct.
.
JUN 08 2006
7.
Property Owner
PlANNING DEPARTM NT
Cry: or Ci.;:;'RWAT R
Property Owner
Property Owner
STATE OF FLORIDA,
COUNTY OF PINELLAS
eefore me the undersigned. an officer duly commissIoned by the laws of the State of Florida, on this
l^-A-~. Z 00k> """""~ ,,,,.,,,. I ~"0 u- If~,i / /N> ~ ,"-
Deposes n ys that he/she fut~ I,mderstands the contents of the affidavit that he/she signed.
o <, __ dayof
who having been first duly sworn
Notary SeallStamp
Notary
My CommissIon Expires:
2010
.
""'"'''' W LEE JACQUES
'm'~''''''
I'R.~ i'~ Notary pubrlC . State of Florida
{. .~ CommissIOn Expires Apr 4,2010
~~ :74/ Commission # DC 536987
"-:f OF f\,~~' .
"....".. Bonded By National Notary Assn
~-----.......--
S \PI~Ming Ol!?ilrtmenllAppl.callon Fcrm~\dovelopmenl revlaw\200e Fom\$\ResldenUallnftll Projc:c:l (F~) 200G doc
Page Bor8 '
~.
e'OSTING
MANHOlE
\
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 0 8 2006
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
CITY OF CLEARWATER
NOTE:
LOT GRADING TO BE
SUBMITTED AT TIME OF
PERMITTING
FIRE HYDRANT:
# 1 1751 TO NORTH
# 2 175' TO WEST
# 3 240' TO EAST
SEe lOCATION MAP FOR
APPROX LOCATIONS
HOWARD STREE-r MQQ~;ST~GET(PLAl1
!!!!!!IB!I -
SANITATION --
I.INE FI.OW
(40'.Q'ROW)
3'-OH
_____ 6' CONC. (2500PSI)
(;l w1FIBER MeSH "-
8 EXISTING
- WAER
~
\~
~
~
'i \!'
q
i\ rc:
~
~
?l@
q q,o
\ c- 4' II'
~
~
UNAS~g TO
LOCATE
TREES DUE
TO DOG
VIBURNUM
HEDGe TO
SCREEN A1C AND
I GARaAGE CAN
PAD
\
~ R1!V'.1ll'.atw..
........'"
,,--..
""""'"'
"""""'-'
""'..
FAGC1',,(llIIIflll
-.......
""'"
"""'""'"
'''''''' ......
........
~ ~':..~ra
a.oo._.
'-
, ~a.r
-
-""""
-"""
.....,
-""'"
.....,......
-"
"""'..,
"""'''''
---
...........
.....-
,p
!
~t:::n'~~
"
"
~
..-...
,..",
--
......
""-
""...""""
~
EAST ELEVATION
YET...flDln
--
=:':If1'..",
~.......
........
SlUIlliLES(GRMII'
,~
....-
"""'"
"
u.."..,
""""""
GIDDS(rHm
"
-.."'"
-.0,,,,,,,,,
.....,
.."'-
_0
-,
RIlIJlG[lltIITEJ
~~
SOUTH ELEVATlOO
NORTH ELBlA TIOfJ
$fiEIIlltlAl!2'''
""""''''
ORIGINAl
.- ....~ RECEIVED
~ ......,......
" " """""
I JUN 08 2006
I"" """"'""
.. ...'"
......
$=:U# ...,........ PlANN\NG DEPAR1MENl
"'''''' .....
WEST ELEVATION C\j'{ Of ClEARWA1ER
EAST ELEVATION
..
"
,.
SOUTH ELEVATION
NORTH ELEVATION
WEST ELEVA nON
SCALE: 1/8"=1'-0"
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 08 2006
PLANNING DEPARTMEI
CliV OF CLEARWATEI
LfGfND
8M - Benchmark CB - Concrete Block CL - Center/me GM - Concrete Monument
[LEV - Elevation FNO - F Quod fP - Iron p,pe IR - Iron Rod ASP - Asphalt
L51 - Land Surveyor Reglstrotlon Number N/T - NalJ de Tob N4tD - No.1 &- D,sk
M H - Manhole P R M - Permanent Reference Monument R/W - RIght Of Way
CONC - Concrete PC - Pomt OF Curvature P T - POInt Of Tangent
PRe - Pomt Of Reverse Curvature pee - Pomt Of Compound Curve Ch - Chord
p P - Power Pole W M - Water Meter R R 5 - Rallrood SRlke RAD - Rod,us
R - Record 0 - Deed AI - Measured C - Colculated 0 e - Deed Book
P B - Plat Book 0 R - Off,cIal Recoro Book PC - Page PVMT - Pavement
PO 8 Pomt Of Begmnmg PO C Pomt Of ~Commencement eH B Chord 880"'n9
R P - RadiUS Pomt eLF - Chom Llflk Fence PCP - Permanent Control Pomt
PI - Pomt of IntersectIon
This property lies wlthm Flood Zone AE os depicted on Flood Insurance
Rote Mop Community Panel # 727 03CO 708H Doted' 5 - 7 7 - 05
BENCHMARK' CLEARWATER B.M. ATLAS PG.374A REVISED 70-73-05 ELEV.=52.433'
BASE FLOOD ELEVA TlON: 53 0'
SECTlON_2.2__ TOWNSHIP ..29...5-,_RANGLL5E_
BASIS OF BEARINGS'S, R/W LINE OF HOWARD ST., BEING N.89'52'06"E.(M)
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
LOTS 7 AND 2, LESS THE EAST 5 FEET OF LOT 2, BLOCK J, SECOND
ADDmON TO BELMONT. ACCORDING TO THE MAP OR PLA T THEREOF AS
RECORDED IN PLA T BOOK 6, PAGE 88, PUBLIC RECORDS OF PINELLAS
COUNTY, FLORIDA.
I 1111111111I111
SCALE, 7 "= 20'
BOUNDARY SURVEY
GeNfRAL NOTfS
1 No Instruments of record reflectmg easements, flghts-of-way, and/or ownershIp were
furnIshed, except os shown
2 No (oundatlons or underground Improvements locoled except os Shown
J If elevatIons ore shown, such elevatIons ore based on N G V 0 1929 (MSL = 000'),
Except Pmelfos County Wl1ere elevatIons ore based on NA VD '988 (MSL = 000')
4 Decforotlon IS mode to or/glnol purchaser of the survey II /5 not transferabfe to
oddlhonol Inshlut,ons or subsequent owners
5 Surveyor has mode no mvestJ'goUan or mdependent search for easements of record,
encumbrances, restrlct/ve covenants. ownershIp htle eVIdence, or any other facts
that on accurate ond current tdle search may dIsclose
6 No water meters located except os shown
7 ThIS Survey IS prepared for the exclUSIVe use of those partIes certifIed herem and
IS valId (or one (1) year from Dote of Certlflcotlon
".
LOWEST FLOOR ELEVATION = 55,35'
TOP OF BOTTOM FLOOR ELEVATION = 5535'
LOWEST ADJACENT GROUND ELEVATION = 527'
HIGHEST ADJACENT GROUND ELEVATION = 52.8'
~
_ HOWARD STREET (FIELD) -1JfOORE STREET (PLA T)
40' R/W I
ASP PVMT I
r<>
LINE NUMBER 1
N 89'34 '08 "E. (M)
480'(M) 5'(R)
\
i ':"'\.
VACANTI LOT ~I
~
-
~I Iii? \~
"""~ ~
0_\. ~ ~
~ -, ~
....... <!.
~~ io <>
"'!> ............ z oi ." I~
~'3:. l\l ."
~
(') \J -
l" l"
r AI '" 01
0 !.J E'I !"1
I~
< It "- ,.
IX) ~
~ l'T\ <:> <:>
<:>
Cl - <:> VI
VI
\......... ~
r
Al \ b
0 a
)> CJ)
CJ
\
2 CONC CURB
FND 5/8" IR
(NO I) FNO 5/8" IR
N,E CORNER OF (NO #) ~-
LOT 5, BLO::JK J N,f, COR,
LOT 8, 8L
N 89'53'51"f (M) N 89'58 '09 "E (M)
. /7493'(M) 75'(R) I . /75 II'(M) 75'(R) -QI
(NO #) OPEN V V
N E CORNfR OF
LOT 2, BLOCK J
~
fl~MW \\
POINT ON C L ~
OF RAILROAD
- - - --\
"
N.89'S2'06nE,
WEST 20,0' OF
LOT 2
BLOCK J
LOT 3
BLOCK J
\
I J S89'48'23"W(M) -1J SB9'51'27'W(M) J
V7993'(M) 8D'(R) V 7467WJ75'(R)
FNO PVC PIPE
w= ~~~ ~~'fi
IN CONC (NO #)
S E CORNER OF S E CORNER OF
LOT 5, BLOCK J LOT 8, BLOCK J
\
~\ ---
996~0 \ r
- ~
\
-
_ -~,- - :':"IR
(NO #)
POINT ON C L
OF RAILROAD
LOT 9
BLOCK J
REVISED'
OFFICE LOCATION 1305 SOUTH HIGHLAND AVE
CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756-3508
NOT VALID WITHOUT THE SIGNATURE AND
THE ORIGINAL RAISED SEAL OF A FLORIDA
LICENSED SURVEYOR AND MAPPER.
PREPARED FOR AND CERTIFIED TO:
SAL MAGGIO
LINE LEGEND' TARGET LAND SURVEYING. INC.
CENTERLINE -::l
BOUNDARY LINE ~. ':"'<':"~s>rt-'\""~""-,,, P.O. BOX 663
BUILDING LINE ~ (OL/!!JE'qif.f.i;''(Ifi.I;~ft.\997-0663 PH'(727) 784-0573
:-,>' ;r~",}~ " r -r- "<;" ~'" J / / ,..,"';I~?~rJJt.~
PLAT LOT LlNE~, >, 7:, _...t, h~rebx.' \~(,t~!y.~t.h'?t ottVS' ,:;urve)ll<'W,8.~ mode under my responSible
EASEMENT JJ.!VE ---. ",,' I,;,chor:ge..,' anl;t ,m~(jj,s .the',,r-r1Irllmum, Tecfimc;,ol Standards os set forth
POWfR L~NE=:',!_;_p-2. oY'J-.t/:$ ..,n9r'i{fo\Jl3tltrf{/;,~f{f P'j;ofessio(1ol Land Surveyors In Chopter
WOOp FEt.JCE---;t . 61, :;:'~7"<p:mr~do,,,Ad'!llnis..t[f}ti~e Code, pursuant to Section 472027,
CHAIN LINK FENCE~ Flon.cto~~otu.J,~,~."03~,,,,",: .. :.. Field Survey: 4-24-06
WIRE. FEN9E-), " '"' :. ~t7:::'''~~ Q~':; ,.:<::'~'" ", # EFB P NA
WATtRL!ioOD~ONt .':.!...Nb ;:" ~~~~~,.:- :"",..::.::{B 9
BUILDING TlEfD/MENSION'"",,' ",,,:::.fB:J~ljP.3' J:'{c'<'~:OJ"~~,'~'" ..'" ", '.~ Job# 060420.07
- - - - ~ - - '*";-'- RLS'" 1l':2'{) .5 vB ~~y 0>-;,' "
. ., ' ,. " ";~~1-,i~~;;[j(J"~:" <:,,'~~:'~ ,;,' Oro wn By B. MARCH
_, f 1 . '1 t " 1
""'DA TE OF CU?TlF/CAnON" Surveyed By. P. STOCK
COPYRIGHT IC> 2005 TARGET LAND SURVEYING INC
~ .: \';~~,.,...\o.<".... ';~<
~1)B
11,tt
CLWCoverSheet
ORIGINAL
RECEIVED
JUN 0 F; 2006
PlANNING DEPARTMENT
CITY. OF CLEARWATER
FLD2006-04020
801 HOWARD ST
Date Received: 04/27/2006
MAGGIOtt SAL
ZONING DISTRICT: MDR
LAND USE: RU
ATLAS PAGE: 314A
PLANNER OF RECORD: WW
.
,
I~-
.'
,
'1/
I....
~ ~ ~;1!IIlI(T d I} 7",
^~11 r: ~'J\.,(trT':4( <-'>,
~y -\,' ),....,~,;(J.f" 14."/7/"/. \.1':>'
'~..- ~~. '.J- ~V .).0;::'1.
A'V t& ...~+ f";/ ~
)~~" I ~~~'"
I.. (f! ~ "'...... >. \ 1/1-.' f>h ';t ~ Q
~"~, ...".u, .Yr~.' ~ ~ ~
1:1(.;]): J ---,- -<"~1~j('1
~~...';. - c;, Q~
.,'f'u'" "_ ~ '1
''''-V . , on","
_i ;9," ,,~.~
_ - -/,/:~ ----- /' \." v
.,.,. 'I/A '#I..~' ~'V ~..
......~~...~TH\'6'~.~
glAdD'
C I T Y 0 F
CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
PO'.J OHICL Box 4748, CIIAl\WAIEH, FIOI{II)A 33758-4748
MUNICIPAL SmVICl-S BIIII D1~G, 1005011 J II MYH II J: AVF,L1', CllcARWA I FH, FI OHIDA '337,)()
TI,IJ.PIIO'\l. (727) 562-4567 FAx (727) 562-4865
1.001(, RANGE PJANNl~C;
DEVFLOPMEN r REVIEW
July 18, 2006
Mr. RIchard Donoghue
332 Skmner Boulevard
Dunedin, FL 34698
RE: Development Order - Case FLD2006-04020
801 Howard Street
Dear Mr. Donoghue:
ThIS letter constitutes a Development Order pursuant to Section 4-206.D.6 of the Commumty
Development Code. On July 18, 2006, the Community Development Board reviewed your request for
FleXIble Development approval to permIt a detached dwellIng m the Medium DenSIty ReSIdentIal (MDR)
DistrIct with a reduction to the front (west along Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to
building), as a ReSIdential Infill Project, under the prOVIsions of SectIon 2-304.G. The Commumty
Development Board (CDB) APPROVED the application with the followmg Fmdings of Fact,
ConclUSIOns of Law and Condition of Approval:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The subJect 0.137-acre lot is located at the southeast comer of Howard Street and Myrtle
Avenue;
2. The site is currently vacant but was previously developed with a detached dwelling that was
deemed unsafe and demolIshed;
3. The subJect parcel meets the lot width and lot area reqUIrements under the MedIUm DenSIty
Residential District;
4. The subject parcel is shaped like a wedge, WIth the lot 60.4 feet m width narrowing toward the
south of the lot where it is 31.96 feet m width;
5. As a corner lot, required setbacks would produce an extremely small bUIldable area of 24 feet on
the north side narrowing to three feet on the south side, producing in essence a "shotgun" design
for a dwelling on thIS parcel;
6. Placement of the dwelling on this lot mamtams the mmImum SIde setback on the east, adJacent to
another detached dwelling, while also meeting the mmImum front setback from Howard Street;
7. South Myrtle Avenue on the west SIde of thIS lot is undeveloped, contains a dramage dItch wlthm
its 40-foot wide nght-of-way and is adjacent to the CSX raIlroad nght-of-way and tracks;
8. The Engmeenng Department finds It hIghly unlIkely South Myrtle Avenue WIll ever be
developed, due to the drainage ditch, bemg adJacent to the CSX railroad right-of-way and tracks,
the eXIstence of a raIlroad-crossing arm on BelleaIr Road and the locatIOn of a commercIal
busmess WIth its driveway and parking areas on the east side of South Myrtle Avenue and the
CSX tracks; and
II<I,"~ 111I11\lln, ,\II\()I'
II lll/<- I )()I~ 1,\, U'I ,I II \11 \\1\1 I'
1\111 II l\" 1\, ( "I \, II \11 \1111 I'
~
11<1\ I II \\IIII()\, e'lI /<-1 II \1/ \1111 I!
( II!II ",\ 1'1 III!\I \, ( 'lI \1 111\1 \\111 "
"1-<,>1,,111:,111'11)\111 \1,1,11 Al I 1I!lll!I\'! '\1 I!I), bll'!I)\II('
~
.\
...
July 18, 2006
Donoghue - Page Two
9. There are no active code enforcement cases for thIS parcel.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Staff concludes that the proposal complies wIth the Flexlble Development criteria under the
provisions of Section 2-304.G;
2. Staff concludes that the proposal is in compliance with the General Applicability cnteria per
Section 3-913 and the other standards of the Code; and
3. The proposed detached dwelling is consistent and compatIble WIth the character of the
surrounding area, as well as an improvement and upgrade over the prevIously unsafe structure on
the lot.
CONDITION OF APPROVAL
1. That, pnor to the issuance of any permIts, a Unity of Title be recorded in the public records.
Pursuant to Section 4-407, an applicatIon for a building permit shall be made WIthin one year of Flexible
Development approval (July 18, 2007). All required certificates of occupancy shall be obtained within
one year of the date of issuance of the bUIlding permit. Time frames do not change with successive
owners. The Community Development Coordinator may grant an extenSIon of time for a period not to
exceed one year and only within the original penod of validity. The Community Development Board may
approve one additional extension of tIme after the community development coordinator's extension to
mitiate a building permIt application.
The Issuance of this Development Order does not relieve you of the necessity to obtain any bUIldmg
permits or pay any impact fees that may be reqUIred. In order to facilitate the issuance of any permit or
license affected by this approval, please bnng a copy of this letter with you when applymg for any
permits or licenses that require this prior development approval.
Additionally, an appeal of a Level Two approval (FleXIble Development) may be initIated pursuant to
Section 4-502.B by the applicant or by any person granted party status within 14 days of the date of the
CDB meeting. The filing of an applIcation/notice of appeal shall stay the effect of the deciSIOn pendmg
the final determination of the case. The appeal period for your case expires on August 1,2006 (14 days
from the date of the CDB meeting).
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call Wayne M. Wells, Planner ill, at 727-562-4504.
You can access zoning information for parcels within the City through our websIte:
www.mvclearwater.com!gov/depts/planning.
~~
MIchael Delk, AICP
Plannmg DIrector
S IPlannlng DepartmentlC D BIFLEX (FLD)lJnactlve or Finished AppllcatlOnslHoward 801 MaggIO (MDR) - ApprovedlHoward 801
Development Order doc
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Wells, Wayne
Friday, July 14, 20064:03 PM
'dwai@tampabay.rr.com'
FLD2006-04020, 801 Howard Street
Richard -
The property is 'Iegally described as more than one lot. Our Code requires the recording of a Declaration of Unity of Title
document when the property to be developed or redeveloped is more than one lot or portions of lots. I am attaching a
Declaration of Unity of Title document that I have prepared for you by adding in the legal description. It must be signed by
the owner in front of two witnesses and a notary. Once signed, it must be recorded with the Clerk of the Circuit Court.
Once recorded, submit a copy of the recorded document to me for our records.
Technically, you could go ahead and complete the document, record it and bring the copy to the meeting on Tuesday. The
owner should retain the original for his records. Call me if you have questions (727-562-4504).
Wayne
~I~
--_.::::
""~^
Unity of TItle
Declaratlon.doc.. .
1
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
100 S. MYRTLE AVENUE, 2ND FLOOR
CLEARWATER, FL 33756
PHONE: 727-562-4567; FAX: 727-562-4865
DECLARATION OF UNITY OF TITLE
Property Owner:
Property Address: 801 Howard Street
KNOW OF ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS, that pursuant to the ordmances of the CIty of Clearwater
pertammg to the issuance of bUIldmg permits and regulating land development actIvities, the underSIgned, being
the fee owner (s) of the following described real property (legal description) sItuated in the CIty of Clearwater,
County of Pmellas and State of Florida, to WIt:
Lots 1 and 2, less the east five feet of Lot 2, Block J, Second Addition to Belmont, as recorded in
Plat Book 6, Page 88, Public Records of PineUas County, Florida.
do hereby make the following declaration of conditions, lImitations and restrIctIOns on SaId lands, hereafter to be
known and referred to as a DECLARATION OF UNITY OF TITLE, as to the followmg partIculars:
1. That the aforesaid plot or combinatIon of separate lots, plots, parcels, acreage or portIOns thereof, shall
hereafter be regarded as and is hereby declared to be unified under one tItle as an mdivIsib1e bUIlding
SIte.
2. That the saId property shall henceforth be conSIdered as one plot or parcel of land, and that no portIon
thereof shall be sold, assigned, transferred, conveyed or devised separately except m ItS entIrety, as one
plot or parcel of land.
3. That thIS DeclaratIon of Umty of Title shall constItute a covenant to run WIth the land, as prOVIded by
law, and shall be bmdmg upon the underSIgned, and the heIrS, successors and aSSIgns of the undersigned,
and all partIes clalmmg under them untIl such time as the same may be released m wntmg under the
order of the City Manager of the City of Clearwater. The underSIgned also agree(s) that thIS mstrument
shall be recorded in the publIc records of Pin ell as County, Florida.
SIgned, sealed, wItnessed and acknowledged thIS
Clearwater, Florida.
day of
, 2006, at
WITNESSES:
OWNER (S):
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PINELLAS
The foregOIng Instrument was acknowledged before me thIS
, 2006, by
behalf of whom the Instrument was executed
day of
, on
Notary PublIc SIgnature
Name of Notary PrInted
Notary CommIssIon Number:
(SEAL ABOVE)
Personally known
or produced IdentIficatIOn
Type of IdentificatIOn produced
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Wells, Wayne
Wednesday, July 12, 200611.48 AM
'dwai@tampabay.rr.com'
Staff Report for FLD2006-04020, 801 Howard Street
Richard -
Attached is a copy of the Staff Report for the above referenced case, to be heard by the CDB at 1.00 pm on Tuesday, July
18, 2006, in City Council chambers at City Hall, 112 S. Osceola Avenue, Clearwater.
In order to be placed on the CDB Consent Agenda, please let me know if the condition is acceptable or not by 10:00 am on
Monday, July 17, 2006. To date, I have not received any letters of objection to this request.
Wayne
IiV@1
EJ
Howard 801 Staff
Report.doc
1
t .1 1 'J ~~? '" ':1"",
\ \'\ '(, ~\: - ;'..,;::>
~\~o:>.k "'l)~i~ ~"..",..$;?! \~".
~~'t ;~~ ...~...\.\..~~.(I', ~,~
t)~~~t;.: ~ L ;.t ,~~ I~ ~ ~:;
~~?~, i.: -- - I_:'~: - -\J:~
,.,1'r \') . ~ t '::7 -<:.,
..... 4~F'", ~, {}.... \.
""/ J! ~) t ,,,,\,=1-
=-.]-;1:#';" " .~'Vt~\
~........)1TH\'Olj'
.l?Q.Dl1UD
CITY OF
CLEARWATER
PlANNING DEPARTMENT
PO~I 01 H(,I: Box 4748, CU:AI<WAII:H, FLOI<IDA 33758-4748
MUNICIPAL SFRVICY; 131111 OI:'\G, 100 SOIJ II! MVlrI LE AVI:'.;l;I:, CI b\RWA II R, FI ORIf)A 557'56
TELEPI!O~E (727) 562-4567 FAX (727) 562-4H65
LONG RANG!: PIA]\;NIi':G
DEVEIOPMLYJ REVIEW
June 15,2006
Mr. Richard Donoghue
332 Skinner Boulevard
Dunedin, FL 34698
Re: Community Development Board Meeting (Case No. FLD2006-04020)
Dear Mr. Donoghue:
The Case No. FLD2006-04020 for Flexible Development approval to permit a detached dwelling
in the Medium Density Residential (MDR) District with a reduction to the front (west along
Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building), as a Residential Infill Project, under
the provisions of Section 2-304.G, for property located at 801 Howard Street, has been deemed
sufficient and has been scheduled to be reviewed by the Community Development Board on July
18, 2006.
The meeting will take place at 1 :00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers, 3rd floor of City Hall at
112 S. Osceola Avenue, Clearwater.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call me at 727-562-4504.
Sincerely,
f!.::t;:-wf:; AI~&
Planner III
S 1?lanmng Department\C D B\FLEX (FLD)IPendmg cases I Up for the next CDBIHoward 801 MaggIO (MDR) - 71806 CDB - WW\Howard
801 CDB Letter doc
I'" 1:-'1-. IIIIII\IIU'. i\1 II' >I(
I' 'II' I)OI{ ", C, >I " II \11 \IIIII{
1\1/1 II"" ", ( (>I " II \11 \11\1 I{
*
lion 11\\1111'" COI 'tll\11 \\111"
( II{II'.\ 1'1 II IN , C, l\ " II \11 \\1\1 /{
"Le,lI'AI 1'111'11))\11'/ A'\I)/\IIII{\I\II\! 1\( IIC)' E\II'I\l)I""
i'
.:, .
(J/uJ
1"
LL
City of Clearwater
Planning Department
100 S. Myrtle Ave., 2nd Floor
Clearwater, FL 33756
Telephone: (727) 562-4567
Fax: (727) 562-4865
f-
-
o
Fax Cover Sheet
To: Donoghue Wood & Assoc.
Fax: 734-2927
FLD2006-04020 - 801 Howard Street -
Case Trust No 801
From: Sherry Watkins, Planning Department
Date: May 30, 2006
Subiect: DRC Meeting Thursday, June 1-2006
Message:
YOUR DRC - DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
COMMITTEE MEETING IS AT 11:45 AM
@ 100 S MYRTLE AVE ROOM 216.
PLEASE CONTRACT ME SHOULD YOU
HAVE ANY QUESTIONS @ 727-562-~582.
THANK YOU
Number of pages including cover sheet_
..
'i
'::B III I t jl~ F'EF'C1F'T
:;'
Ma~. 30 2006 11:41RM
YOUR LOGO
YOUR FRX NO.
7275624865
NO. OTHER FRCSIMILE
01 97342927
STRRT TIME USRGE TIME MODE PRGES RESULT
Ma~.30 11:40RM 00'41 SND 01 OK
TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MeaJ' 004.
THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'.
FOR FAX ADVRNTAGE RSSI STRNCE, PLEASE CALL 1-000-HB...P-FAX (435-7329).
, -""
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Wells, Wayne
Friday, May 26, 2006 3:23 PM
'dwai@tampabay.rr.com'
Draft DRC comments for June 1, 2006, DRC meeting
Richard -
Attached are the Draft DRC comments for the June 1, 2006, DRC meeting at 11 :45 am In the Planning Department offices
(100 S. Myrtle Avenue) for FLD2006-04020 at 801 Howard Street. See you then.
Wayne
~\
I,~t
"'.Md>!
draft 6.1.06 drc
action agenda...
1
11:45 am
Case Number: FLD2006-04020 -- 801 HOWARD ST
Owner(s): Trust No 801
C/O ReIlmann, Lance Tre
Clearwater, F133756
TELEPHONE: No Phone, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No EmaIl
Representative: Donoghue Wood & Associates
332 Skinner Blvd
Dunedin, F1 33698
TELEPHONE: 727-735-0411 , FAX: 727-734-2927, E-MAIL: dwaI@tampabay.rr.com
Location: 0.137 acres located at the southeast comer of Howard ~treet and Myrtle Avenue
Atlas Page: 314A
Zoning District: MDR, Medium Density Residential
Request: Flexible Development approval to permit a detached dwelling in the Medium Density Residential (MDR)
District with a reduction to the front (west along Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to
building), as a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of Section 2-304.G.
Proposed Use: Detached dwelling
Neighborhood Clearwater NeIghborhoods Coalition
Association(s): Clearwater, Fl 33758
POBox 8204
TELEPHONE: No Phone, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No EmaIl
Presenter: Wayne Wells, Planner III
Attendees Included: City: Wayne Wells, Nell Thompson, Scott RIce, Lenny Rickard,
ApplIcant: Sal MaggIO, Richard Donoghue
The DRC reviewed this application with the following comments:
General Engineering:
1. PrOVIde UtIlIty Plan indicating existmg City utIlIties and proposed connections for water and
sewer.
Environmental:
1. No Issues
Fire:
1 . Must show fire hydrant on the same side of the street wIthm 500 feet. PRIOR TO CDB
Harbor Master:
1 . No issues.
Legal:
1. No issues.
Land Resources:
1 . Show, to scale, the actual canopy lines on the SIte plan prior to buIlding permit.
2 . The proposed bnck pavers at the 14" oak tree are too close, recommend removmg the pavers at
least 7' away from the tree. ReVIse pnor to CDB.
3 . The proposed brick pavers at the 12" unknown, actually a Hickory tree, must be designed to
place the base material "on grade". Place a note on the SIte plan prior to CDB.
Landscaping:
1 . No issues.
Parks and Recreation:
1 . A recreation facIlity impact fee of $200 is due for each new reSIdential unit prior to Issuance of
bUIlding permit or final plat (if applIcable) whIchever occurs first. Credit wIll be gIVen for any
eXIstmg residential units. Contact Art Kader at 727-562-4824.
Stormwater:
1 . Pnor to CDB please prOVIde a fmIshed floor elevatIon and lot gradmg plan per SectIOn E.
Stormwater plan submittal. ApplIcant prevIOusly acknowledged on applIcation that he was
made aware of this requirement.
Solid Waste:
1 . No issues.
Traffic Engineering:
Development ReVIew Agenda - Thursday, June 1, 2006 - Page 22
1 . Scale on site plan IS labeled incorrectly. Correct scale is 1" = 1 0'.
The above to be addressed pnor to CDB.
General Note(s):
1) Comply WIth the current Transportation Impact Fee Ordinance and fee schedule.
2) DRC review IS a prerequisite for Building Pemut Review; additional comments may be
forthcoming upon submittal of a BUI1dmg Pemut Application
Planning:
1. SIte Plan - Revise the scale for the drawmg from 1" = 20' to 1" = 1 0'.
2 . Provide a dImension from the front property line on Howard Street to the northeast comer of the
dwelling (covered porch) and the length of the parkmg spaces (from the front property hne -
mmimum of 18 feet reqUIred).
3 . ProvIde the project value.
4 . Condition of approval:
That, prior to the issuance of any pemuts, a Umty of Title be recorded m the pubhc records.
5 . West elevation - It appears that the stalrs and rallmg shown on the nght hand SIde should be on
the left hand side, since there Isn't any door on the rear of the dwelling.
6. North elevation - Show the staIrs on the left hand SIde for the door on the east SIde of the
dwelling. '
7. Residentla1 Intill Project criteria #1 response - Suggest mcludmg the wedge-shape of the lot, as
well as the narrowness of the lot, as reasons deviatlons from the front setback reqUIrement from
Myrtle Avenue is necessary. It should also be mentloned that the reductIOn to the front setback
will not be noticable due to Myrtle Avenue being undeveloped.
8 . It IS noted that, based on a diSCUSSIOn with the Engineenng Department, that there is a low
likelihood of Myrtle Avenue between Howard Street and Bellearr Road ever bemg improved due
to the existence of a drainage ditch, the width of the nght-of-way, adjacent propertles being
currently served by either Howard Street or Scranton Avenue and the closeness of Myrtle Avenue
to the railroad tracks and associated crossing arms at Belleair Road.
Other:
No Comments
Notes: To be placed on the 7/18/06 CDB agenda, submit 15 collated copIes of the reVIsed plans & apphcation material addressmg all
above departments' comments by noon, 6/8/06. Packets shall be collated, folded and stapled as appropriate.
Development ReVIew Agenda - Thursday, June 1,2006 - Page 23
. ~ . I:'t
u
FAX COVER MEMO
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
100 S. MYRTLE AVE.
CLEARW A TER, FL 33756
(727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865
TO: K:\~;) V~~"L
FAX: -, 34:. z.., z.. 7
Phone: 735 - 04 \\
FROM: W~~ \r-)Q,\\~
DA TE:~ 5' '2:1J 0 \t,
Phone:~ b '2.. --=-A S- 0 f:
MESSAGE:
RE:-FLPl-oo fIJ - 04-<? 2....0
60' ~WAl'd 5\-..
~~d ~~ ~~ ~~~
~ ~~SJ ,~ ~ ,\: ts- ~~ Ir"'.. our
c..L 0 Mjr-)( L ~ ').
~ ~-...<~ ""-\~O ~~~ -t\A.~ -h )O~ ..J,"- e.~~\.
NUMBER OF PAGES(INCLUDING THIS PAGE) 3
,\
'::B 1[1 I ~ U~ F'EF'I]F'T
Ma~. 26 2006 03:47PM
YOUR LOGO
YOUR FAX NO.
7275624865
NO. OTHER FACSIMILE
01 97342927
START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT
Ma~.26 03:45PM 01'31 SND 03 OK
TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' MeIJ' 004.
THEN SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'.
FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASS I STANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-+H.P-FAX (435-7329).
o
CITY OF CLErtRWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING
100 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756
TELEPHONE: (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4576
WWW.MYCLEARWATER.COM
~ Clearwater
May 04, 2006
Donoghue Wood & Associates
332 Skinner Blvd
Dunedin, FI 33698
RE: FLD2006-04020 -- 80 1 HOWARD ST -- Letter of Completeness
Dear Donoghue Wood & Associates:
The Planning Staffhas entered your application into the Department's filing system and assigned the
case number: FLD2006-04020. After a preliminary review of the submitted documents, staffhas
determined that the application is complete.
The Development Review Committee (DRC) will review the application for sufficiency on June 01,
2006, in the Planning Department conference room - Room 216 - on the second floor of the
Municipal Services Building. The building is located at 100 South Myrtle Avenue in downtown
Clearwater. You will be contacted by the Planning Department's Administrative Analyst within one
week prior to the meeting date for the approximate time that your case will be reviewed. You or your
representative (as applicable) must be present to answer any questions that the DRC may have
regarding your application. Additional comments may be generated by the DRC at the time ofthe
meeting.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at 727-562-4504 or
Wayne. Wells@myc1earwater.com.
Sincerely yours,
tJtIVJ~ M. V~
Wayne Wells, AICP
Planner III
Letter of Completeness - FLD2006-04020 - 801 HOWARD ST
o
C I T Y 0 F C L E ~~ R W ATE R
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING
100 SOUTH MYRTLE AVENUE, CLEARWATER, FLORIDA 33756
TELEPHONE: (727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4576
WWW.MYCLEARWATER.COM
~ Clearwater
May 01,2006
Donoghue Wood & Associates
332 Skinner Blvd
Dunedin, FI 33698
RE: FLD2006-04020 -- 801 HOWARD ST -- Letter of Incompleteness
Dear Donoghue Wood & Associates:
The Planning Staff has entered your application into the Department's filing system and assigned the
case number: FLD2006-04020. After a preliminary review of the submitted documents, staffhas
determined that the application is Incomplete with the following comments.
1. Application indicates that Sal Maggio is the owner of the property. Pinellas County Property
Appraiser indicates that Trust No. 801, c/o Lance Reilman, Trustee, is the owner. Unless you
provide a recorded deed transferring ownership to Sal Maggio, the application must be revised
to show the proper ownership (Trust No. 801) and a revised Affidavit to Authorize Agent must
be signed by the owner (Trust No. 801).
2. "Description of Request" must be filled out on the application with the following: "To permit a
detached dwelling with a reduction to the front (west along Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25
feet to 1 0 feet (to building)."
Section 4-202 of the Community Development Code states that if an application is deemed
incomplete, the deficiencies ofthe application shall be specified by Staff. No further development
review action shall be taken until the deficiencies are corrected and the application is deemed
complete. Please resubmit by 10:00 am on Friday, May 5, 2006.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at 727-562-4504 or
Wayne. Wells@myclearwater.com.
Sincerely yours,
6Iv,~":. (1. LJ ~
Planner III
Letter of Incompleteness - FLD2006-04020 - 801 HOWARD ST
Wells. Wayne
From:
To:
Sent:
Subject:
System Administrator
dwai@tampabay.rr.com
Wednesday, May 03,20064:00 PM
Undeliverable: Returned mail: see transcript for details
Your message did not reach some or all of the Intended recipients.
Subject:
Sent:
FLD2006-04020, 801 Howard Street
5/1/2006 3:09 PM
The following reClpient(s) could not be reached:
dwal@tampabay.rr.com on 5/3/2006 4:00 PM
Could not deliver the message In the time limit specified. Please retry or contact your administrator.
< kcmx03.mgw.rr.com #4.4.7 SMTP; 4524.2.1 Mailbox temporanly disabled: dwal@tampabay.rr.com>
1
r > _)
; Clearwater
-
u
FAX. COVER MEMO
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
100 S. MYRTLE AVE.
CLEARW A TER, FL 33756
(727) 562-4567 FAX: (727) 562-4865
TO: K;- G'Nw- d j) ~ ~ v e..
FAX: . 7 ') L\- -' z- 1 L 7
Phone: I .3 S"- 0 4- \ \
FROM: w~~ Wt.\\~ Phone:.s 102- 'lso1:
DA TE:~ ~) ~ 0 V, RE:Yt-V Z-.oQ b - 0 +.0 l..:t>
~ 0' ~",,"d :st-.
MESSAGE: A~k~ i\ ~ Lo.---\\v- J 'AL~\t~~~.
-~:~~~\~~~~rt?~~~.
NUMBER OF PAGES (INCLUDING THIS PAGE) 'L..
"
'f'
'::.Et j[I I t j[i F'EF'DF'T
Ma~. 02 2006 06:33AM
YOUR LOGO
YOUR FAX NO.
7275624865
NO. OTHER FACSIMILE
01 97342927
START TIME USAGE TIME MODE PAGES RESULT
Ma~.02 06:32AM 01'12 SND 02 OK
TO TURN OFF REPORT, PRESS ' Me.aJ' 004.
~ SELECT OFF BY USING '+' OR '-'.
FOR FAX ADVANTAGE ASS I STANCE, PLEASE CALL 1-800-HB..P-FAX (435-7329).
I
.Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Mail Delivery Subsystem [MAILER-DAEMON@kcmx03.mgw.rr.com]
Monday, May 01, 2006 8:09 PM
Wells, Wayne
Warning: could not send message for past 4 hours
~
I~'
~
ATI753981.txt
ATI753982.txt
**********************************************
** THIS IS A WARNING MESSAGE ONLY **
** YOU DO NOT NEED TO RESEND YOUR MESSAGE **
**********************************************
The original message was received at Mon, 1 May 2006 15:09:15 -0400 (EDT)
from clmboh-mx-07.mgw.rr.com [65.24.7.61]
-----'Transcript of session follows -----
while talking to ms-mta-02.tampabay.rr.com.:
>>> DATA
<<< 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled: dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<dwai@tampabay.rr.com>... Deferred: 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled:
dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<<< 554 5.5.0 No recipients have been specified.
while talking to ms-mta-04.tampabay.rr.com.:
>>> DATA
<<< 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled: dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<dwai@tampabay.rr.com>... Deferred: 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled:
dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<<< 554 ,5.5.0 No recipients have been specified.
while talking to ms-mta-01.tampabay.rr.com.:
>>> DATA
<<< 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled: dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<dwai@tampabay.rr.com>... Deferred: 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled:
dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<<< 554 5.5.0 No recipients have been specified.
while talking to ms-mta-03.tampabay.rr.com.:
>>> DATA
<<< 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled: dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<dwai@tampabay.rr.com>... Deferred: 452 4.2.1 Mailbox temporarily disabled:
dwai@tampabay.rr.com
<<< 554 '5.5.0 No recipients have been specified.
warning: message still undelivered after 4 hours
will keep trying until message is 2 days old
1
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Wells, Wayne
Monday, May 01, 2006 3:09 PM
'dwai@tampabay.rr.com'
FLD2006-04020, 801 Howard Street
Richard -
Attached is a Letter of Incompleteness for the above referenced application. The original is being mailed. Should you
have any questions, feel free to contact me by email or phone (562-4504).
Wayne
~
~
letter of
completeness 5.1.0.
1
CDB Meeting Date:
Case Number:
Agenda Item:
Owner:
Applicant:
Representative:
Address:
Julv 18. 2006
FLD2006-04020
E4
Trust #801
Sal Maggio
Richard Donoghue
801 Howard Street
CITY OF CLEARWATER
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
STAFF REPORT
GENERAL INFORMATION:
REQUEST:
EXISTING ZONING/
LAND USE:
PROPERTY SIZE:
PROPERTY USE:
ADJACENT ZONING/
LAND USES:
Flexible Development approval to permit a detached dwelling in the
Medium Density Residential (MDR) District with a reduction to the
front (west along Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to
building), as a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of
Section 2-304.G.
Medium Density Residential (MDR) District; Residential Urban
(RU) Category
0.137 acres
Current Use: Vacant
Proposed Use: Detached dwelling
North: Medium Density Residential District; Detached dwellings
East: Medium Density Residential District; Detached and attached
dwellings
South: Medium Density Residential District; Attached dwellings
West: Medium Density Residential District; Attached dwellings
CHARACTER OF THE
IMMEDIATE VICINITY: The surrounding area is a mixture of detached and attached
.dwellings. There are two churches to the east on Scranton and Tilley
Avenues. A nonconforming storage use is to the northeast. There
are some commercial uses along Belleair Road to the south.
~--
Staff Report - Community Development Board - July 18, 2006
Case FLD2006-04020 - Page 1 of 6
I
I
I
ANALYSIS:
Site Location and Existing Conditions: The 0.137-acre lot is located at the southeast comer of
Hbward Street and Myrtle Avenue. The site is shaped like a wedge, with the lot 60.4 feet in width
nkowing toward the south of the lot where it is 31.96 feet in width. The site is currently vacant,
b~lt was developed with a detached dwelling that was deemed unsafe by Development Services.
The dwelling and a shed were demolished under Permit #BCP2006-03188. While the South
I
Myrtle Avenue is located to the west ofthis property, it is undeveloped.
I
I
Pfoperties directly to the north and east are developed with detached dwellings, while properties to
t~e south and west are developed with attached dwellings. The surrounding area is a mixture of
d6tached and attached dwellings, with two churches to the east. There is a nonconforming storage
u~e to the northeast. Commercial uses are located to the south along Belleair Road.
pLposal: The proposal includes the construction of a new detached dwelling of 1,340 square feet
iJ area. Two parking spaces within the driveway off Howard Street are proposed.
I
The proposal includes a reduction to the front (west along Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25 feet to
I
10 feet (to building). This proposal is being processed as a Residential Infill Project, as the MDR
:district does not provide flexibility standards and criteria for detached dwellings as a Flexible
D;evelopment use. As noted above, the site is wedge shaped, narrowing from its greatest width on
tne north to its least width on the south. Required setbacks would produce an extremely small
b~ildable area of 24 feet on the north side narrowing to three feet on the south side, producing in
ei;sence a "shotgun" design for a dwelling on this parcel. Therefore, the design and placement of
allY dwelling on this site would appear to necessitate a reduction of most likely the west front
sJ~tback along South Myrtle Avenue. The applicant has placed the dwelling on the lot to maintain
dIe minimum side setback on the east, adjacent to another detached dwelling, while also exceeding
I
t~le minimum front setback from Howard Street. The proposed dwelling greatly exceeds the
nHnimum side setback from the south (five-foot required; 46 feet provided). Due to this wedge
I
shape of the lot, the applicant has located the dwelling on the lot parallel with South Myrtle
lvenue at a 10-foot setback. South Myrtle Avenue on the west side of this lot is undeveloped,
~rhereby the reduction to the required setback visually is minimized. Based on discussions with
I
the Engineering Department, it is highly unlikely that South Myrtle Avenue will ever be developed
a'long the west side of this lot. There is a drainage ditch within this 40-foot wide right-of-way,
<<rhich is also adjacent to the CSX railroad right-of-way and tracks. There is a railroad-crossing
inn on Belleair Road that also is a factor in not developing South Myrtle Avenue in the future.
I
']i'here is also a commercial business with its driveway and parking areas on the east side of South
~1yrtle Avenue and the CSX tracks on the north side of Belleair Road that presents additional
r~asons for South Myrtle Avenue not being developed in the future. Parcels to the south of the
slubject parcel take access to Scranton Avenue, having no reason for access to South Myrtle
Avenue. A reduction to the front setback along South Myrtle Avenue is appropriate given these
Jircumstances outlined. The proposed detached dwelling is consistent and compatible with the
character of the surrounding area, as well as an improvement and upgrade over the previously
Jnsafe structure on the lot. Since the parcel is more than one platted lot, a Unity of Title should be
rbcorded in the public records prior to the issuance of a building permit.
I
Staff Report - Community Development Board - July 18, 2006
Case FLD2006-04020 - Page 2 of 6
All applicable Code requirements and criteria including, but not limited to, Residential Infill
Ptoject criteria (Section 2-304.G) and General Applicability criteria (Section 3-913) have been
mbt.
I
dode Enforcement Analysis: There are no outstanding enforcement issues associated with this
.1
SIte.
i
I
I
I
I
COMPLIANCE WITH STANDARDS AND CRITERIA: (Sections 2-301.1 and 2-304):
i STANDARD PROPOSED CONSISTENT INCONSISTENT
I
MAXIMUM One dwelling unit X
I
DENSITY (7.5
d~welling units per
abre) (One dwelling
nJlaximum)
IMPERVIOUS 0.38 X
I
SURFACE RATIO
I
(ISR) (0.65)
~OT AREA (5,000 O. 137 acres; 5,979 square feet X
s~. feet)
I.JOT WIDTH (50 North: 60.4 feet X
f~~et) West: 133.5 feet
FlRONTSETBACK North: 29.92 feet (to building) X*
(25 feet) West: 10 feet (to building)
REAR SETBACK N/ A (comer lots have two front and X
[
(Five feet) two side setbacks)
S:IDE SETBACK South: 46 feet (to building) X
I
(0 - five feet) East: Five feet (to building and stair
I landing)
,
E[EIGHT (30 - 50 feet 10 feet (to midpoint of pitched roof) X
I. 1)
maXImum
~ARKING SPACES Two spaces X
I
(Two spaces per unit)
I
* ISee discussion under Analysis.
I
I
I
Staff Report - Community Development Board - July 18,2006
Case FLD2006-04020 - Page 3 of 6
i
i ,
COMPLIANCE WITH RESIDENTIAL INFILL PROJECT FLEXIBILITY CRITERIA
Section 2-304.G):
Consistent Inconsistent
1.[ The development or redevelopment of the parcel proposed for X*
I development is otherwise impractical without deviations from the
I intensity and development standards;
I
2.; The development of the parcel proposed for development as a X
I
, residential infill project will not materially reduce the fair market
I
I value of abutting properties.
I
3.1 The uses within the residential infill project are otherwise permitted in X
I the district.
I
4.1 The uses within the residential infill project are compatible with X
i adjacent lands uses.
51 The development of the parcel proposed for development as a X
I residential infill project will upgrade the immediate vicinity of the
I parcel proposed for development.
6! The design of the proposed residential infill project creates a form and X
I function which enhances the community character of the immediate
! vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the City of
I Clearwater as a whole.
7. Flexibility in regard to lot width, required setbacks, height and off- X*
street parking are justified by the benefits to community character and
I the immediate vicinity of the parcel proposed for development and the
City of Clearwater as a whole.
* ,See dISCUSSIOn under Analysis.
I
dOMPLIANCE WITH GENERAL STANDARDS Section 3-913 :
I
Consistent Inconsistent
Development of the land will be in harmony with the scale, bulk,
covera e, densit and character ofad'acent ro erties.
Development will not hinder or discourage development and use of
ad' acent land and buildin s or si ificantl im air the value thereof.
Development will not, adversely affect the health or safety of persons
residin or workin in the nei hborhood.
Develo ment is desi ed to minimize traffic con estion.
Development is consistent with the community character of the
immediate vicinit .
Design of the proposed development minimizes adverse effects,
including visual, acoustic and olfactory and hours of operation impacts
on ad'acent ro erties.
*ISee dIScussion under AnalysIs.
I
I
1,
!.
X
2.
I
X
3'.
!
X
4.
5.
X
X
I
6.
i
X
Staff Report - Cornmumty Development Board - July 18, 2006
Case FLD2006-04020 - Page 4 of 6
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW:
I
F1NDINGS OF FACT
1.: The subject 0.137-acre lot is located at the southeast comer of Howard Street and Myrtle
I Avenue;
I
2.: The site is currently vacant but was previously developed with a detached dwelling that
I was deemed unsafe and demolished;
I
3'i The subject parcel meets the lot width and lot area requirements under the Medium Density
Residential District;
The subject parcel is shaped like a wedge, with the lot 60.4 feet in width narrowing toward
the south of the lot where it is 31.96 feet in width;
As a comer lot, required setbacks would produce an extremely small buildable area of 24
feet on the north side narrowing to three feet on the south side, producing in essence a
"shotgun" design for a dwelling on this parcel;
Placement of the dwelling on this lot maintains the minimum side setback on the east,
adjacent to, another det~ched dwelling, while also meeting the minimum front setback from
Howard Street;
South Myrtle Avenue on the west side of this lot is undeveloped, contains a drainage ditch
within its 40-foot wide right-of-way and is adjacent to the CSX railroad right-of-way and
tracks;
The Engineering Department finds it highly unlikely South Myrtle Avenue will ever be
developed, due to the drainage ditch, being adjacent to the CSX railroad right-of-way and
tracks, the existence of a railroad-crossing arm on Belleair Road and the location of a
commercial business with its driveway and parking areas on the east side of South Myrtle
Avenue and the CSX tracks; and
There are no active code enforcement cases for this parcel.
I
4.i
I
i
5.\
I
f
I
6.[
i
7.:
I
8:
I
I
9,
I
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1; Staff concludes that the proposal complies with the Flexible Development criteria under
I the provisions of Section 2-304.G;
2; Staff concludes that the proposal is in compliance with the General Applicability criteria
i per Section 3-913 and the other standards of the Code; and
3: The proposed detached dwelling is consistent and compatible with the character of the
I
surrounding area, as well as an improvement and upgrade over the previously unsafe
structure on the lot.
SiUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION: ,
The Development Review Committee 'reviewed the application and supporting materials on June
1:, 2006. The Planning Department recommends APPROVAL for the Flexible Development
a)Jplication to permit a detached dwelling in the Medium Density Residential (MDR) District with
a:reduction to the front (west along Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to building),
ai; a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of Section 2-304.G, for the site at 801 Howard
Sheet, based on the above Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, with the following condition:
I
I
I
I
(
Staff Report - Community Development Board - July 18, 2006
Case FLD2006-04020 - Page 5 of 6
Ccmdition of Approval:
1.: That, prior to the issuance of any permits, a Unity of Title be recorded in the publIc records.
I,
P~epared by: Planning Department Staff:
A1TT ACHMENTS:
,
Location Map
Aierial Map
I'
Z~ning Map
Ekisting Surrounding Uses Map
Application
"
i
S IPlannmg Department\C D B\FLEX (FLD)IPendmg caseslUpfor the next CDBIHoward 801 MaggIo (MDR) - 71806 CDB - WW\Howard 801
I
: Staff Report doc
Staff Report - Community Development Board - July 18, 2006
Case FLD2006-04020 - Page 6 of 6
Resume
t
f
I
I
I'
I:
I~
~
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
II
· I' Planner III
ji Planning Department, City of Clearwater, FL
I,
I
Ai5 part of the Development Review Division, prepared and presented staff reports for Flexible
Standard Development (staff-level cases), Flexible Development (public hearing cases) and Plats
b~:fore the Development Review Committee and the Community Development Board and
I
Di:evelopment Agreements before the City Council; reviewed building permits for Code
cG!nformance; prepared and/or assisted preparation of Code amendments; provided public
irlformation (via telephone, mail, email, zoning counter or predevelopment meetings).
(,
I'
.1 Zoning Coordinator
I
I' Zoning Division, City of Pinellas Park, FL
r
I'
A1cting Zoning Director, Represented the Zoning Division on cases and issues before the City
Council, Community Redevelopment Agency, Planning and Zoning Commission, Board of
Aldjustment and outside agencies; Prepared and presented staff reports for land use plan
ainendments, rezoned, planned unit developments, conditIOnal uses, variances and site plans;
r~:viewed final site plans and building permits for Code conformance; prepared and/or assisted
pi'eparation of Code amendments; provided public information (via telephone, mail, zoning
dmnter or predevelopment meetings).
Wayne M. Wells, AICP
100 South Myrtle Avenue
Clearwater, FL 33756
727-562-4504
wayn e. wells(a),mvclearwater .com
November 2001 to Present
March 1989 to November 2001
.
Program Manager, Zoning Branch
Manatee County Department of Planning and Development
Bradenton, FL
June 1984 to March 1989
I
I
I
Tlrained and supervised three employees; Prepared and presented variances and appeals to the
B:oard of Zoning Appeals; Coordinated final site plan and building permit review for Code
dmformance; Assisted in preparation of Code amendments; Provided public information (via
t~lephone, mail, zoning counter or predevelopment meetings). Interim Code Enforcement
l\!lanager- Managed the Code Enforcement Section; supervised six employees; prosecuted cases
b\;:fore the Code Enforcement Board; investigated and prepared cases of alleged violatIons of
l~nd use and building codes. Planner II, Current Planning Section - Prepared and presented
staff reports for rezones, planned developments, special permits, plats and mobile home parks to
I
Pllanning Commission and Board of County Commissioners; reviewed final site plans and
bhilding permits for Code enforcement; assisted in preparation of Code amendments; provided
public information (via telephone, mail, zoning counter or predevelopment meetings).
I '
i
I
t
i:
\
.1
II
I'
I
I,
I:
Prtepared and presented staff reports for rezones and special permits to Planning Commission and
B~)ard of County Commissioners; reviewed site plans and plats for Code conformance; assisted
in!, preparation of Code amendments; provided public information (via telephone, mail, zoning
cdunter or predevelopment meetings). Intern - Compiled and coordinated the Alachua County
I~formation and Data Book; drafted ordinance revisions; general research.
l~
.[:
Planner I
Alachua County Department of Planning and Development
Gainesville, FL
June 1980 to June 1984
Graduate Assistant
University of Florida Department of Urban and Regional Planning
I Gainesville, FL
I:
CjJordinated downtown study for Mayo, FL; coordinated graphics for Jefferson County
CiJmprehensive Plan.
.1: Planning Technician
II Planning Division, City of St. Petersburg, FL 1977 to 1979
pJ.epared pri~arily graphics, for both publication and presentation; Division photographer for 1 Y2
y~:ars; worked on historic survey and report.
I
I
EI:OUCATION
I'
N[aster of Arts in Urban and Regional Planning (Degree not conferred; course work completed,
tllesis not completed), University of Florida, 1981
I
1
~achelor of Design in Architecture, University of Florida, 1976
I
1979 to 1981
1
IhcENSES & CERTIFICATES
.American Institute of Certified Planners
1
American Planning Association, Suncoast Section
. i
t
'I
t
Ii
f
I'
r
I
,
1
I;
L
1
I
I
I
:'
~.~
:":".~
. ~ ~. .
. '. .
... . . ...
. :' ", .
.. . : . "':
.. ....: . ':. . ':' .......:: .
. . ..".
" . .
. ',.,'.' ........
. :.,
.' '.
. ",. .. " .
'. .'
. ....
...... ....
. :.. ,':
. .
.. . . .. ..
. .
.. ... .' ,'...
. ,. I .
Location Map
Owners:
i
Trust No. 801
I Case:
Property
Size(Acres):
FLD2006-04020
Site:
,
801 Howard Street
0.137
PIN:
22/29/15/07938/010/0010
I Atlas Page:
314A
J
,
Aerial Map
Owl,ers:
Trust No. 801
Case:
FLD2006-04020
Site:
801 Howard street
Property
Size (Acres) :
0.137
PIN:
22/29/15/07938/010/0010
Atlas Page:
314A
,615 ~ I \ \ I I (0)
1514 \ \ 1508 1511
\ 1511 1512 1508
1516,\ 1515
r 1516 1512 \.N
I 1518 \ \ 1517 1517 """'"i"'-""'" 1516
\ ~ 1519 1518 1516 ....
'~'\ 1523 .1 1520
I 1528A \ ~ \ "" 1522 1520
1534 \
\ 1526 1523 1524
, 1530 1525
1540 ~ \ 1533 152
t 1529 1535 153
\ \~, 153
I -. M 1535
\
1544 1\\ ' J <<1540 1537
~~- 1543 1540
1540
\1545 154
1549 1545 1546
1548 \ 1546 , 1550
1548 '" ~ ...
'" ~
1550 '"
: 0 HOW~RD ST ,--
1552 \ , ,-- ~ 1553 1554
I '" ~ 841
\
\ I 1556 155
1558 1559 \ ~
156C 156
\ 156 1564
,
\ 156 156
1560 '\ 156
\\ 157G~ 156
\ 157 q;
"- 0) 1571 ~ 1565 1572
- a i2 i2 \ ~
1576
\\ " 1576
<:> 1585 1580
... '"
: - i2 i2 i2 1581 1584
1580
\ \ ~' 1586 I 1588
:C 1584 1591 \ \ 1587 1588
1590 1589 1590
CI) 1593 \ \ 1592
0) '" 0) \R \\ <:>
~ i2 i2 ~ ~ ~ '" ~
1594 1595 '" '" ~
...r-, , ~JI.,.........
.. ... ..
. . ' . : ..-\. ' , ". " , ,. . : . . .' , "
.. ., ..", .. .. .. ' . .. , . 'r" .\' .. t :'''' :1 '..
. . .. .. "'j" ... . .. .... ., .. " ", '. ~ I '"
". ... . . ',' . , . ~ . .:. : .. . ' . ,. &l
.. .. .. :
, f.lSIJ1 :...... : : . '''''''M'''' ,.....: .. .'}.: . . .. .
, . ... ' , . . , ' .
.... .
Zoning Map
Owhers:
Trust No. 801
Case:
FLD2006-04020
Si;te:
801 Howard Street
Property
Size(Acres):
0.137
PIN:
22/29/15/07938/010/0010
Atlas Page:
314A
\ 2 ~ 14 ~ 61' 8 10 11 1:50~ 1511: ~
\ 1511 ~peta h~ 151 151;. _I;. .150
, ~515 s.dweI ings 1516 (!we liBI!~51
\ 53 18 151744 9
~ 1519 52 19 1518 43 10 151
\. =- 51 20 152~2 11
\ ~~\1525:h ~;. 152 ~ ~13152
~ r P ft t' ~l B. ))1~52
\ m 4,_ {{ A.,~';s 153( 152!ifae
\ )>~\ 46 - -8 . 10 15.~
\. ~\;:~eg' ~ UIWD ::~ r 153
\( 41 30 .....n> 154~ 21 154(
2\55 \ 154~0 31 '~4 ~1 22.
Ac (C) 1. 154lj9. 32 1 "" 54~
\ ~ 1546 .
\ d"L. ft1. 34 154 ~ 28 25= UJ
.-=,.. ~ \ l'."e l\\g l!!lIOI'WI '" 27 26 :s
~ (1) \ .__ HOWARD ST ~
\ 't~-- :.; 155346 1 1554 UJ:;;:: 46 1 841
1 \ ~ De . At1. f'hul!Ch 2 :j 45 2
2 \ 44 3 1551 j:: 44 3 15~~
~tWc ~d 2 ~ dw 6 lIw 43 4 ("hur~h 4
4, .. 10 156 42 5 00 42 5 156
welli gs 9 151 41 6 1564 g; 41 6
6 \ Attaclretf6 Det Detacl ed ::; 40 7 15t
7; .11 156 ~ 39 8 39 8
8 \ dwelllJlf:{87 ~ d"k dWelli g 9 156
9 .~\ ~etaCbe1l7 ~ 37 10 ~~ 10
~1W,Qh \ '014 ~o 156536 ,,~1 36 !J ~11157
l.Ie '" e v, eI ng ~ 35 llLI ))12 ~hlllrcl'll H ~12
UJ I welling ~' 16 ~ 34 1="13 34 13 1571
:s \ \ ~: ~ jl\-\tfl!~e~ a>et?1 33 14 1581
~ jjFt~~he~ \ 2~ ~ I we~:nus ~Wi64 :~ ~~
i:! dWMting!i \ m~cia Hef. 18 l:i8 29 18 158
g: ~18 ' \ \ 22 fSB728 19 158 .....hlftch 19
:5 >>Jjta~)ed \ \ ~~ c m:t<l h~1d :~:( ~; ~
~ IAI d1.l';;6tlifigs \ \ 25:il ~ 25 22 ~ ~25 22 '"
4 1594 ___ -1"'" \ 26 '" dwellinllfi '" "'24 23::l
\
: "!'!'~""':'I~::.:"I:,I.!'"'I~~!"'!""'~:-Jl'''':''~""':~.l'!!'''''''!~~.'''':J-."'_'~"~~' '!III"!",,,.~,,~.,.,Ji!~.-LJ;~l&RQ.~_I~~I._"~~"'''
:,: ~~' : :'< '. : ,"', ",,:-,. '..::'.. ':, :::':: "'<:', .X:' +,~,: :.,,::, '" , ..,. :":' . ..... ,:" ~ 214~'
,,; .<. \~f6{/V '" :'. .... i/UJa ." , . ,.. \'.. " ;\
2
4
5
~:
8
9
I
10
11!
6151 2
Detac~ed514 \
dwellings1516 \
I 4 1518\
Stodl!e1528A 1528~1
- 11;;/4
e
dwelling~
1540 '\
:1
~
7 95922. 1544
Attached
QWelllngs
8
1548
12,
~ttached
~ellings 1552
~ached 1558
dwe~
~ 1560
\VDpt~ ~d
d~~IJjI ~
Assist€[d- 6 10;'"
Living
FacilitL ~
62478
'<it '"
~ Licl ed 1580
22 d,,~li~gs 1584
7fl tU( 5 3 1590
~~!
\
\
Existing Surrounding Uses Map
H~~
45 \ N~
151M _
43 10
42 11 152~
41 12
40 g:;:~ 13
15.2f>11 cI lL d52
15
dwe linl!s
153~6 17 15 2
35 18
34 19
153~3 20
32 21 1540
I1~t ,.:~'-~
cAve liBg~50
~ 28 25
~ 1 26
Owners: i Trust No. 801 Case: FLD2006-04020
Site: I 801 Howard Street Property 0.137
I Size (Acres) :
PIN: 22/29/15/07938/010/0010
,
I
I
I 314A
i Atlas Page:
View looking south on South Myrtle Avenue at
subject prdperty (on left)
-------------,-
I
I
View 100k1lng northwest from intersection of South
I
Myrtle Avenue and Howard Street
!
I
I
I
801 Howard Street
I
FLD2006-04020
View looking east at subject property from South
Myrtle Avenue
View looking east along Howard Street from
intersection with South Myrtle Avenue
t1.f1l".I#".AI'
..1~~ ll.li""- .......
.~.~ .~~..
~"' ~' &~
l'~", .,ii~'" ","
.~ "--~",rin1. ..
"ft' ~/,. "~~' 1 .~..
~~~ ~~: ~
"~k_h ~
'\~~~. :'~""'~':l
"'", TEUloli\
, ""H
Conditions Associated With
FLD2006-04020
801 HOWARD ST
Zoning Condition Wayne Wells, AICP 727-562-4504
05/18/2006 Condition of approval:
That, prior to the issuance of any permits, a Unity of Title be recorded in the public records.
Pnnt Date: 07/02/2006
Page 1 of 1
Not Met
CaseCondltons
Wells. Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Rice, Scott
Monday, June 12, 2006 1 :35 PM
Wells, Wayne; Watkins, Sherry
FLD2006-04020 - 801 Howard
Engineering review complete, No approval conditions.
D. Scott Rice
Land Devel. Engr. Manager
727-562-4781
scott.rice@MyClearwater..com
1
iF _ _.....;''\
\,
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Albee, Rick
Wednesday, June 14, 20062:25 PM
Watkins, Sherry
Planning
RE: resubmittals for the July 18, 2006 CDB meeting:
801 Howard-Conditions met.
138 Sand Key- No Issues.
2430 Gulf to Bay-No Issues.
2750 3rd St-No Issues.
1728 Lucas-No Issues.
1532 Stevenson-No Issues,
1100 Cleveland St-Condition required prior to building permit.
2551 Gulf to bay-No Issues.
-m-Onglnal Messagemn
From: Watkins, Sherry
Sent: Fnday, June 09, 2006 11:49 AM
To: Buzzell, Wilham; DRC Members; Gluskl, Roberta; Hufford, Diane; Reid, Debbie; Tracy Harmon; US Post Office (E-mail)
Subject: FW: resubmlttals for the July 18, 2006 COB meeting:
Importance: High
FLD2006-04021 2551 Gulf to Bay Blvd Planner: Scott Kurleman
Sherry L Watkins
Planning Department
Administrative Analyst
(727) 562-4582
sherry. watkins@mycleatwater.com
-----Onglnal Message-----
From: Watkins, Sherry
Sent: Fnday, June 09, 2006 8:35 AM
To: Buzzell, William; DRC Members; Gluskl, Roberta; Hufford, Diane; Reid, DebbIe; Tracy Harmon; US Post Office (E-mail)
Subject: resubmlttals for the July 18, 2006 CDB meeting:
Importance: High
DRC Members
Plans for the following cases have been resubmitted for the July 18, 2006 CDB meeting
FLD2006-04020 801 Howard Street Planner: Wayne Wells
FLD2006-04018 138 Sand Key Estates Planner: Wayne Wells
FLD2006-04022 2430 Gulf To Bay Blvd Planner: John Schodtler
ANX2006-04014 2750 Third Avenue Planner: Cky Ready
ANX2006-03009 1728 Lucas Drive Planner: Cky Ready
ANX2006-04012 1532 Stevensons Drive Planner: Cky Ready
FLD2006-04023 1100 Cleveland Street Planner Robert Tefft
I have placed one copy of the case resubmittal package on the cabinets outside of Room 216 in our office for your
review (please do not take it, as we need it for the CDB mail out), Please review your comments/conditions for this
cases in Permit Plan and determine if they are met. Whether the conditions are "met" or stIli "not met," please affirm
to me via email. Please have these cases reviewed, if possible by 12:00 pm on Tuesday, June 13,2006.
Sherry L Watkins
1
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Wells, Wayne
Friday, June 09, 2006 2.07 PM
Reid, Debbie
FLD2006-04020, 801 Howard Street
Debbie -
While the survey submitted with this application indicates this property to be vacant, this property had been developed with
a detached dwelling. Under Building Permit #BCP2006-03188 the previous detached dwelling was demolished. The
proposed dwelling will replace what was there previously.
Wayne
1
Wells. Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Watkins, Sherry
Friday, June 09, 2006 1 :11 PM
Planning
FW: resubmittals for the July 18, 2006 CDB meeting:
FYI
Sherry L Watkins
Planning Departnlent
Administrative Analyst
(727) 562-4582
shernj. watkins@mycleanvater.com
-m-Onglnal Message--m
From: Reid, Debbie
Sent: Fnday, June 09,200610:55 AM
To: Watkins, Sherry
Subject: RE: resubmlttals for the July 18, 2006 COB meeting:
Please see comments below. Have a great weekend!
Debbie @
nmOnglnal Message--m
From: Watkins, Sherry
Sent: Fnday, June 09,20068:35 AM
To: Buzzell, Wilham; DRC Members; Gluskl, Roberta; Hufford, Diane; Reid, Debbie; Tracy Harmon; US Post Office (E-mail)
Subject: resubmlttals for the July 18, 2006 COB meeting:
Importance: High
DRC Members
Plans for the following cases have been resubmitted for the July 18, 2006 CDB meeting:
FLD2006-04020 801 Howard Street Planner' Wayne Wells [Reid, Debbie] P&R fee still due
FLD2006-04018 138 Sand Key Estates Planner. Wayne Wells [Reid, Debbie] ok - no issues
FLD2006-04022 2430 Gulf To Bay Blvd Planner: John Schodtler [Reid, Debbie] ok - no issues
ANX2006-04014 2750 Third Avenue Planner' Cky Ready [Reid, Debbie] ok - no issues on annexation
ANX2006-03009 1728 Lucas Drive Planner' Cky Ready [Reid, Debbie] ok - no issues
ANX2006-04012 1532 Stevensons DrivePlanner: Cky Ready [Reid, Debbie] ok - no issues
FLD2006-04023 1100 Cleveland Street Planner Robert Tefft [Reid, Debbie] ok - no issues
I have placed one copy of the case resubmittal package on the cabinets outside of Room 216 in our office for your review
(please do not take it, as we need it for the CDB mail out). Please review your comments/conditions for this cases in
Permit Plan and determine if they are met. Whether the conditions are "met" or still "not met," please affirm to me via
email. Please have these cases reviewed, if possible by 12:00 pm on Tuesday, June 13,2006.
Sherry L Watkins
Planning Department
Administrative Analyst
(727) 562-4582
sherry. watkins@mycleanvater.com
1
Wells. Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Watkins, Sherry
Friday, June 09, 2006 8:35 AM
Buzzell, William; DRC Members; Gluski, Roberta; Hufford, Diane; Reid, Debbie; Tracy
Harmon; US Post Office (E-mail)
resubmittals for the July 18, 2006 COB meeting:
Subject:
Importance:
High
DRC Members
Plans for the following cases have been resubmitted for the July 18, 2006 COB meeting:
FLD2006-04020 801 Howard Street Planner: Wayne Wells
FLD2006-04018 138 Sand Key Estates Planner: Wayne Wells
FLD2006-04022 2430 Gulf To Bay Blvd Planner: John Schodtler
ANX2006-04014 2750 Third Avenue Planner: Cky Ready
ANX2006-03009 1728 Lucas Drive Planner. Cky Ready
ANX2006-04012 1532 Stevensons Drive Planner. Cky Ready
FLD2006-04023 1100 Cleveland Street Planner Robert Tefft
I have placed one copy of the case resubmittal package on the cabinets outside of Room 216 In our office for your review
(please do not take it, as we need it for the COB mail out). Please review your comments/conditions for this cases in
Permit Plan and determine if they are met. Whether the conditions are "met" or still "not met," please affirm to me via
em all. Please have these cases reviewed, if possible by 12:00 pm on Tuesday, June 13,2006.
Sltemj L Watkins
Planning Departmeut
Administrative Analyst
(727) 562-4582
sltemj. watkins@mycleanvater.com
1
Donoghue Wood & Associates
332 Skmner Blvd
Dunedin, Fl 33698
TELEPHONE: 727-735-0411, FAX' 727-734-2927, E-MAIL: dwm@tampabay,rr,com
Location: 0.137 acres located at the southeast comer of Howard Street and Myrtle Avenue
Atlas Page: 314A
Zoning District: MDR, Medium Density ResidentIal
Request: Flexible Development approval to permit a detached dwelling in the Medium Density Residential (MDR)
District with a reduction to the front (west along Myrtle Avenue) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to
building), as a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of Section 2-304,Q,
Proposed Use: Detached dwelhng
Neighborhood Clearwater NeIghborhoods CoahtIon
Association(s): Clearwater, Fl33758
POBox 8204
TELEPHONE: No Phone, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No EmaIl
Presenter: Wayne Wells, Planner III
Attendees Included: City: Wayne Wells, Neil Thompson, Scott Rice, Jim Keller
Apphcant: RIchard Donoghue
The DRC reviewed this application with the following comments:
General Engineering:
1, ProvIde Utihty Plan mdicating eXIstmg CIty utIhties and proposed connectIOns for water and
sewer.
Environmental:
1. No Issues
Representative:
.,=: iN.'
" ,. ()~
J)Il.L
~
~(
)'
11:45 am
Case Number: FLD2006-040LO -- 801 HOWARD ST
Owner(s): Trust No 801
C/O Reilmann, Lance Tre
Clearwater, Fl33756
TELEPHONE: No Phone, FAX: No Fax, E-MAIL: No Email
Fire:
No Comments
Harbor Master:
1 , No issues.
Legal:
1, No Issues.
Land Resources:
1 , Show, to scale, the actual canopy lmes on the SIte plan prior to bUlldmg pennit.
2. The proposed brick pavers at the 14" oak tree are too close, recommend removmg the pavers at
least 7' away from the tree. Revise pnor to CDB.
3 . The proposed brick pavers at the 12" unknown, actually a Hickory tree, must be deSIgned to
place the base material "on grade". Place a note on the site plan pnor to CDB
Landscaping:
1 . No Issues.
Parks and Recreation:
I , A recreation facIhty unpact fee of $200 IS due for each new reSIdentIal umt prior to Issuance of
building pennit or final plat (if applicable) whichever occurs first. Credit Will be gIven for any
eXIstmg residential umts. Contact Art Kader at 727-562-4824.
Stormwater:
I . Pnor to CDB please prOVIde a fimshed floor elevation and lot gradmg plan per SectIOn E.
Stormwater plan submittal. Applicant prevIOusly acknowledged on apphcatIon that he was
made aware of thIS requrrement.
Solid Waste:
I . No Issues.
Traffic Engineering:
Development Review Agenda - Thursday, June I, 2006 - Page 22
~t
1 , Scale on site plan IS labeled incorrectly. Correct scale IS 1" = 1 0'.
The above to be addressed pnor to CDB.
General Note(s):
1) Comply with the current Transportation Impact Fee Ordmance and fee schedule.
2) DRC review is a prerequisite for BUlldmg Pennit ReVIew; additional comments may be
forthcormng upon subll1lttal of a Building Pennit ApphcatIOn. ' . ·
Planning:
1 . SIte Plan - Revise the scale for the drawmg from 1" = 20' to 1" = 10'.
2 . Provide a dimensIOn from the front property line on Howard Street to the northeast corner of the
dwelling (covered porch) and the length of the parking spaces (from the front property line -
ll1lmmum of 18 feet reqUITed).
3 . Condition of approval:
That, pnor to the issuance of any pemuts, a Unity ofTltle be recorded in the pubhc records,
4 , West elevatIon - It appears that the staIrS and raihng shown on the right hand SIde should be on
the left hand side, smce there Isn't any door on the rear of the dwelhng.
5 . North elevatIon - Show the stairs on the left hand SIde for the door on the east side of the
dwellmg,
6, ResIdential Infill Project critena #1 response - Suggest mcludmg the wedge-shape of the lot, as
well as the narrowness of the lot, as reasons deViatIons from the front setback requirement from
Myrtle Avenue is necessary. It should also be mentIOned that the reduction to the front setback
will not be noticable due to Myrtle Avenue being undeveloped.
7 . It is noted that, based on a dISCUSSIOn With the Engmeenng Department, that there IS a low
hkelihood of Myrtle Avenue between Howard Street and Belleau Road ever bemg Improved due
to the eXIstence ofa drainage ditch, the width of the right-of-way, adjacent propertIes being
currently served by either Howard Street or Scranton Avenue and the closeness of Myrtle Avenue
to the railroad tracks and associated crossmg arms at Belleair Road.
Other:
No Comments
Notes: To be placed on the 7/18/06 CDB agenda, submit 15 collated copIes of the reVIsed plans & applicatIOn matenal addressing all
above departments' comments by noon, 6/8/06. Packets shall be collated, folded and stapled as appropriate.
Development Review Agenda - Thursday, June 1,2006 - Page 23
Owner(s):
Trust No 801
C/O Rellmann, Lance Tre
Clearwater, FI33756
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX
No Fax, E-MAIL' No Emall
-p~
<<,.'.0"
l)IlC
~~
. r - .
, ,I
11:45 am
Case Number: FLD2006-04020 - 801 HOWARD ST
Donoghue Wood & Associates
332 Skmner Blvd
Dunedm, FI33698
TELEPHONE: 727-735-0411, FAX 727-734-2927, E-MAIL' dwal@tampabaYITcom
Location: 0,137 acres located at the southeast comer of Howard Street and Myrtle Avenue
Atlas Page: 314A
Zoning District: MDR, MedIUm Density ReSidential
Request: FleXible Development approval to permit a detached dwelhng m the MedIUm DenSity ReSidential (MDR)
District With a reductIOn to the front (west along Myrtle A venue) setback from 25 feet to 10 feet (to
bUlldmg), as a ReSidential Infill Project, under the provIsions of SectIOn 2-304 G
Proposed Use: Detached dwelhng
Neighborhood Clearwater Neighborhoods CoalitIOn
Association(s): Clearwater, FI 33758
POBox 8204
TELEPHONE No Phone, FAX No Fax, E-MAIL No Ematl
Presenter: Wayne Wells, Planner III
Attendees Included: City: Wayne Wells, Neil Thompson, Scott Rice, Lenny Rickard,
Apphcant Sal MaggiO, RIchard Donoghue
The DRC reviewed this application with the following comments:
General Engineering:
I ProVIde Utlhty Plan mdlcating eXisting City utlhtles and proposed connections for water and
sewer
Environmental:
, I No Issues
Representative:
Fire:
Must show fire hydrant on the same side of the street wlthm 500 feet PRIOR TO COB
Harbor Master:
No Issues
Legal:
I
No Issues
Land Resources:
I Show, to scale, the actual canopy hnes on the site plan pnor to bUlldmg permit
2 The proposed bnck pavers at the 14" oak tree are too close, recommend removmg the pavers at
least 7' away from the tree ReVise pnor to COB
3 The proposed brick pavers at the 12" unknown, actually a Hickory tree, must be deSigned to
place the base matenal "on grade" Place a note on the site plan pnor to CDB
Landscaping:
I , No Issues,
Parks and Recreation:
A recreation faCility Impact fee of $200 IS due for each new reSidential umt pnor to Issuance of
bUlldmg permit or final plat (If apphcable) whichever occurs first Credit will be given for any
eXisting reSidential umts, Contact Art Kader at 727-562-4824,
Storm water:
I , Pnor to CDB please prOVIde a finished floor elevatIOn and lot gradmg plan per Section E,
Stormwater plan submittal Applicant prevIOusly acknowledged on applicatIOn that he was
made aware of this requirement
Solid Waste:
I , No Issues
Traffic Engineering:
Development ReView Agenda - Thursday, June 1,2006 - Page 22
~;~ t'
I , Scale on site plan is labeled mcorrectly Correct scale IS I" = 10'
The above to be addressed pnor to COB
General Note(s),
I) Comply with the current Transportation Impact Fee Ordmance and fee schedule
2) DRC review IS a prerequlSlte for BUIldmg Permit Review, additional comments may be
forthcommg upon submittal of a BUlldmg Permit ApplicatIOn
\'
Planning:
I.
2,
8,
Site Plan - Revise the scale for the drawmg from I" = 20' to I" = 10'.
Provide a dimensIOn from the front property Ime on Howard Street to the northeast comer of the
dwelling (covered porch) and the length of the parlang spaces (from the front property Ime-
mmlmum of 18 feet reqUIred),
Provide the project value.
Condition of approval.
That, pnor to the Issuance of any penruts, a Umty of Title be recorded m the public records
West elevatIOn - It appears that the stalTS and rallmg shown on the nght hand Side should be on
the left hand Side, smce there Isn't any door on the rear of the dwelling
North elevatIOn - Show the stairs on the left hand Side for the door on the east Side of the
dwelling
ReSidential Infill Project cntena # 1 response - Suggest mcludmg the wedge-shape of the lot, as
well as the narrowness of the lot, as reasons deViatIOns from the front setback reqUirement from
Myrtle Avenue IS necessary, It should also be mentIOned that the reductIOn to the front setback
Will not be notlcable due to Myrtle A venue bemg undeveloped
It IS noted that, based on a diSCUSSIOn With the Engmeenng Department, that there IS a low
likelihood of Myrtle Avenue between Howard Street and Bellealr Road ever bemg Improved due
to the eXistence ofa dram age ditch, the Width of the nght-of-way, adjacent properties bemg
currently served by either Howard Street or Scranton Avenue and the closeness of Myrtle Avenue
to the railroad tracks and associated crossmg arms at Bellealr Road,
3,
4,
5
6
7
Other:
No Comments
Notes: To be placed on the 7/18/06 COB agenda, subnut 15 collated copies of the revised plans & application matenal addressmg all
above departments' comments by noon, 6/8/06, Packets shall be collated, folded and stapled as appropriate,
/\
Development ReView Agenda - Thursday, June 1,2006 - Page 23
Wells. Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Rice, Scott
Thursday, May 25, 2006 2:00 PM
Wells, Wayne
Doherty, Steve
DRC Comments
Wayne,
On FLD2006-04024 - 1532 S Highland - I addressed your comment #14 and #8 in the Engineering and Traffic comments,
On FLD2006-04020 - 801 Howard - There is a low likelihood that this section of Myrtle would ever be Improved There is a
drainage ditch in the ROW. If the ROW were to be vacated it would need to be vacated from Howard to Belleair to avoid a
dead end. A drainage and utility easement would be retained,
The applicant has submitted a plan that allows for the proposed construction without vacating the ROW, Therefore, I do
not believe that increasing the setback along this side of the property is a good reason for the City to impair its rights along
this segment of ROW.
D. Scott Rice
Land Devel. Engr. Manager
727-562-4781
scott.rice@MyClearwater..com
1
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Kambourolias, Sam
Monday, May 08, 2006 4:23 PM
Wells, Wayne
Watkins, Sherry
RE: FLD2006-04020
Sorry
~.
_i~
-^---
"'
zone.doc
n---Onglnal Message-----
From: Wells, Wayne
Sent: Monday, May 08,20064:16 PM
To: Kambourolias, Sam
Subject: RE: FLD2006-04020
Sam -
Need to turn the street names on the Zoning Map only, They don't show up. Thanks,
Wayne
-----Onglnal Message-----
From: Kambourolias, Sam
Sent: Monday, May 08, 2006 3:35 PM
To: Wells, Wayne
Cc: Watkins, Sherry
Subject: FLD2006-04020
<< File: aerial.doc>> <<File: existing.doc>> <<File: location.doc>> <<File: zone.doc>> <<File: FLD Map
request form.doc>>
Sam Kambourolias
GIS Tech.
(727) 562-4769
www.myclearwater.com
1
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Wells, Wayne
Monday, May 08, 2006 4.16 PM
Kambourollas, Sam
RE: FLD2006-04020
Sam -
Need to turn the street names on the Zoning Map only. They don't show up. Thanks
Wayne
-----Onglnal Message-----
From: Kambourohas, Sam
Sent: Monday, May 08, 2006 3:35 PM
To: Wells, Wayne
Cc: Watkins, Sherry
Subject: FLD2006-04020
<< File: aerial.doc>> <<File: existing.doc>> <<File: location.doc>> <<File: zone.doc>> <<File: FLD Map
request form.doc>>
Sam Kambourolias
GIS Tech.
(727) 562-4769
www.myclearwater.com
1
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
~
~^
~~j
--
aenal.doc
eXlstlng.doc
Sam Kambourolias
GIS Tech.
(727) 562-4769
www.myclearwater.com
Kambourolias, Sam
Monday, May 08, 2006 3:35 PM
Wells, Wayne
Watkins, Sherry
FLD2006-04020
~
~
~
location. doc
zone. doc
fJ
FLD Map request
form.doc
1
Wells, Wayne
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Wells, Wayne
Friday, May 05, 2006 3:33 PM
Kambourolias, Sam
Herman, Jason
Map Request for 801 Howard Street
Sam -
Attached is a map request for Cases FLD2006-04020 for the property at 801 Howard Street. I will bring over the
paperwork. The survey that I will bring over you may keep.
Thanks -
Wayne
~
FLD Map request
form.doc
1
Flexible Development Application - Map Request
Planner Name: Wayne Wells
Case Number: FLD2006-04020
Date Requested: May 5, 2006
Date Requested for (date): May 19,2006
Maps Requested
xO Location Map
xO Aerial Map
xO Zoning Map
xO Existing Surrounding Uses Map
Required Documents to be submitted to Engineering
xO Legal Description
xO Survey
xO Map with Proposed Site Highlighted
Map Name
Owners:
Trust No. 801
I
i
I Case:
I
I
! Property
I Size(Acres):
I
I
!
FLD2006-04020
Site:
801 Howard Street
0.137
PIN:
22/29/15/07938/010/0010
Atlas Page:
314A
, lPinellas County Property Apprr' ~er Information: 22 29 15 07938 010 0(11 f:)
Page 2 of5
22 / 29 / 15 / 07938 / 010 / 0010
01-Hay-2006 JiM SMith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 11:40:50
Ownership InforMation Residential Property Add ress. Use. and Sales
TRUST NO 801 OBK: 14652 OPG: 2665
C/O REHHANN. LANCE IRE
801 HOWARD ST
CLEARWATER FL 33156
EVAC: Non-EUAC
COMparab Ie sales value as Prop Addr: I
801 HOWARD ST
of Jan 1, 2005, based on Census Trac t : 258.00
sales frOM 2003 - 2004 :
~5.900 Sale Date OR Book/Page Price (Qual/UnQ) Vac/IMp
Plat InforMation 10/2.005 14.652/2.665 11.000 (0) I
1924 : Book 006 Pgs 088- 0 / L 911 3.631/ 528 5.000 (0) I
0000: Book Pgs - 0 /0 0/ 0 0 ( )
0000: Book Pgs - 0 /0 0/ 0 0 ( )
2005 Value EXEMP T IONS
Just/Market: 41.200 HOMestead: NO Ownership % .000
Govt ExeM: NO Use %: .000
Assessed/Cap: 41.200 Institutional ExeM: NO Tax ExeMpt %: .000
Historic ExeM: 0
Taxable: 41.200 Agricultural: 0
2005 Tax InforMation
District: CW Seawall: Frontage:
Clearwater View:
05 Mi llage: 23.2312 Land Size Unit Land Land Land
Front x Depth Price Units Meth
05 Taxes: 1.096.80
1) 5Z x 130 600.00 52.00 F
Special Tax .00 2) 0 x 0 .00 .00
3) 0 x 0 .00 .00
Without the Save-Our-HoMes 4) 0 x 0 .00 .00
cap, 2005 taxes will be : 5) 0 x 0 .00 .00
1.096.80 6) 0 x 0 .00 .00
Without any exeMptions,
2005 taxes will be :
1.096.80
Short Legal BELHONT SUB 2ND ADD BLK J. LOTS 1 AND 2
Description LESS E 5FT OF LOT 2
Building Information
httn:/ /nao.co.oinellas.fl. us/htbin/cgi-scr3 ?o= 1 &a= 1 &b= 1 &c= 1 &r= . 16&s=4&t3= 1 &u=O&p... 5/1/2006
,,-,Pinellas County Property Appr~:~er Information: 22 29 15079380100(111)
Page 3 of5
Property and Land Use Code descriptions
22 / 29 / 15 / 07938 / 010 / 0010 :01
01-Hay-Z006 JiM SMith, CFA Pinellas County Property Appraiser 11:40:49
Residential Card 01 of I Prop Use: ZIO Land Use: 01 Living Units: I
IMP Type: Single Fa~ily Prop Address: 801 HOWARD S1
Structural Elements
Foundation
Floor SysteM
Exterior Wall
Roof FraMe
Roof Cover
Pie rs
Wood
Fra~e/Siding
Gable-Hip
Co~posite Shingle
Quality
Year Suil t
Effective' Age
Heating Unit/Spc/WI/FI
Cooling
Fixtures
Other Depreciation
Functional Depreciation
EcononoMic Depreciation
Fair
1.936
60
Furn
None
3
Z5
o
o
# Stories 1.0
Floor Finish Crpt/Unyl/SftWd/1err
Interior Finish Drywall/Plaster
Sub Areas
Description Factor Area Description Factor Area
1) Base A rea 1. 00 1. 054 7) .00 0
2) Sc reen Po rch . Z5 144 8) .00 0
3) Sc reen Po rch . ZO 98 9) .00 0
4) .00 0 10) .00 0
5) .00 0 11) .00 0
6) .00 0 12) .00 0
Residential Extra Features
Description DiMensions Price units Value RCD Year
1) .00 0 0 0 0
2) .00 0 0 0 0
3) .00 0 0 0 0
4) .00 0 0 0 0
5) .00 0 0 0 0
6) .00 0 0 0 0
TOTAL RECORD VALUE: 0
Map With Property Address (non-vacant)
~~[t][!]~~
http://pao.co.pinellas.fl.us/htbin/cgi -scr3 ?o= 1 &a= 1 &b= 1 &c= 1 &r= . 16&s=4&t3= 1 &u=O&p... 5/1/2006
;Pinellas County Property Appr~~~er Information: 2229 1507938010001 f)
Page 4 of5
E
ffi22'
-_ ---1
14.84
270(S)
271]fS)
180
~~mE
AVE
lei)
85
0)
3~
(,~T -4~/30
>h
,38
(AN
;T
t)i~~t E
/1 \,1[""
.""'i/Co. ~ u
A 1529 IS
1533 1530 CRANTON TILLEY
MYRTLE SCRA~n ON ,AVE AVE
AVE .AVE 1533 T I eC~Y
CRANTON
AVE AV
~ 1537 1535
~CRANTON
33/01 M'iRTLE 1640 /lVE
AVE SCRANTON 1540
,"") .- c:, ':I) AVE 1543 TILLD
CRAt'J10N AvE
c::::.. Q v....\ 1545 1546 AVE
A c (c) r-: tvflfvTELE SCRANTON I
AVE CRAN1 Ot~
t'1 MY RT L E AVE
H RO
AVE HOVlARD
51
i"-
',J.)
rrl
o
L
"
1555
SCRAN1DN
AVE
I c; c;~
Tltt y
PoV
T I d:~~y
AVE
801 80S 815
'\M.R [HOWARD HOW,AR
S'T 5T ST
o
r..o
o
o
w A)1~11 E
.J A~k
~
a::
>-
:!
>
.
1564
SCPfSt1 Ot~ 15650 1564
..C R At\n Ot'l TILLEY
Z AVE AVE
00
SCR5A~~ or~ 0 )>(0
~ I- < CJ)
A)f"'Ir.
~V Z -.
-0
~ < &0
a::: 1585 v =:'~
~ U SCRA~J1 O~~ T 1~~tY
/lVE ;..;
TILLEY
800 .AVE
BELL E.A. IR
PO
1571
tv1Y RT L E
A\lE
1581
tvlYR1LE
,AVE
tfrF1LE
AVE
1/8 Mile Aerial Photograph (2002)
httn'//n~(\ {'(\ ninplho;: f111o;:/hthin/(',pi-~c'r1?o=1 &a=l &h=l &c=1&r=.16&s=4&t3=1&u=0&o... 5/1/2006
IPinellas County Property Appr'~er Information: 22 29 1507938010 or'"
Page 5 of5
Pinellas County Property Appraiser
Parcel Information
Back to Search Pa..g~
An explanation of this screen
http://pao.co.pinellas.fl. us/htbin/cgi -scr3 ?o= 1 &a= 1 &b= 1 &c= 1 &r= . 16&s=4&t3= 1 &u=O&p... 5/1/2006
,," "
CITY OF CLEARWATER
NOTICE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BOARD PUBLIC HEARINGS
The Community Development Board of the City of Clearwater, Florida, will hold public
hearings on Tuesday, July 18, 2006, beginning at 1:00 P.M., in the City Council
Chambers, in City Hall, 3rd floor, 112 South Osceola Ave, Clearwater, Florida, to
consider the following requests:
NOTE: All persons wishina to address an item need to be present at the
BEGINNING of the meetina. Those cases that are not contested by the applicant.
staff. neiahborina property owners. etc. will be placed on a consent aaenda and
approved by a sinale vote at the beainnina of the meetina.
1. Clearwater Neiahborhood Housina Svc. Inc. is requesting Flexible Development
approval to construct a new single family residence in the Medium Density Residential
district, as a residential infill project, and includes: 1) A reduction in the minimum lot area
from 5,000 sq ft to 4,143 sq ft; and 2) A front (south) setback reduction from 25 ft to 13 ft,
per Sec. 2-304.G. (Proposed Use: Detached Dwelling) at 701 Pennsylvania Ave,
Pine Crest Sub, Blk 7. Lot 11 less E 60 f1. Assigned Planner: John Schodtler, Planner
II. FLD2006-02003
-'
2. Clearwater Centre. LLC (Guy & Susan Bonneville, Sebastian & Elizabeth Dorner,
Anthony Dorner) are requesting Flexible Development approval for a mixed-use
development consisting of 88 attached dwellings and 21,498 sq ft of non-residential floor
area within the Downtown (D) District with an increase to the building ht of an additional
15 ft (as measured from roof deck to mean roof line), and a 26-space off-street parking
lot within the Commercial (C) District, as part of a Comprehensive Infill Redevelopment
Project under the provisions of Secs. 2-704.C and 2-903.C of the Community
Development Code; and a Termination of Status of Nonconformity for ht (148 ft to roof
deck where a maximum of 75 ft would be permitted under current Code), under the
provisions of Sec. 6-109 of the Community Development Code. [Proposed Use:
Mixed-Use (Attached Dwellings, Office and Retail Sales and Services)] at 1100
Cleveland St. and 103 Martin Luther Kina. Jr. Ave., Bassadena, Blk A, Lots 1-14 and
part of Lot 15, Blk B, Lots 9-11 and Lots 14-25. Assigned Planner: 'Robert G. Tefft,
Planner III. FLD2006-04023
3. Gulf to Bay Holdinas. LLC (Chris Tsavoussis) are requesting Flexible Development
approval in the Commercial (C) District for a reduction to the front (north) setback along
Gulf to Bay Blvd from 25 ft to 5.8 ft (to pavement) as a Comprehensive Infill
Redevelopment Project, under the provisions of Sec. 2-704.C, and a reduction to the
landscape buffer on the north property line from 15 ft to 5.8 ft as a Comprehensive
Landscape Program, under the provisions of Sec. 3-1202.G. (Proposed Use: Existing
Drive-Through Restaurant) at 2551 Gulf to Bay Blvd., The Regency Sub, Lot 1.
Assigned Planner: 'A. Scott Kurleman, Planner II. FLD2006-04021
4. Trust No 801 c/o Lance Reilmann. TRE (Sal Maggio) are requesting Flexible
Development approval to permit a detached dwelling in the Medium Density Residential
(MDR) District With a reduction to the front (west along Myrtle Ave.) setback from 25 ft to
10 ft (to building), as a Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of Sec. 2-304.G.
(Proposed Use: Detached dwelling) at 801 Howard St., Belmont Sub 2nd Add, Blk J,
Lot 1 and part of Lot 2. Assigned Planner: Wayne M. Wells, AICP, Planner III.
FLD2006-04020
i?
5. James R. Barae. Kelly Wilken. Betty Salimi. Marrianne F. Meichenbaum Livina
Trust & Marianne F. Meichenbaum TRE. Marvin & Clara Zoromski. Brian & Nadine
Thomas. Dan L. Vo. Michael & Dawn Galasso. Craia A. & Cathy L. Junkins are
requesting Flexible Development approval to permit rear deck/patio additions to existing
detached dwellings with a reduction to the rear setback from 15 ft to zero ft (to
deck/patio) and a reduction to the side setback from 10 ft to zero ft (to deck/patio), as a
Residential Infill Project, under the provisions of Sec. 2-504.F. (Proposed Use: Rear
deck/patio additions to existing detached dwellings) at 138. 175. 214. 215 and 226
Sand Key Estates Dr. and 1608. 1617. 1631 and 1635 Sand Key Estates Ct., The
Moorings of Sand Key, Lots 1, 18, 20, 24, 35, 37, 42, 45 & 64. Assigned Planner:
Wayne M. Wells, AICP, Planner III. FLD2006-04018
Interested parties may appear and be heard at the hearing or file written notice of
approval or objection with the Planning Director or City Clerk prior to the hearing. Any
person who decides to appeal any decision made by the Board or Council, with respect
to any matter considered at such hearings, will need to request a record of the
proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the
appeal is to be based per Florida Statute 286.0105. Community Development Code Sec
4-206 states that party status shall be granted by the Board in quasi-judicial cases if the
person requesting such status demonstrates that s/he is substantially affected. Party
status entitles parties to personally testify, present evidence, argument and witnesses,
cross-examine witnesses, appeal the decision and speak on reconsideration requests,
and needs to be requested and obtained during the case discussion before the CDB.
An oath will be administered swearing in all persons giving testimony in quasi-judicial
public hearing cases. If you wish to speak at the meeting, please wait to be recognized,
then state and spell your name and provide your address. Persons without party status
speaking before the CDB shall be limited to three minutes unless an individual is
representing a group in which case the Chairperson may authorize a reasonable amount
of time up to 10 minutes.
Five days prior to the meeting, staff reports and recommendations on the above
requests will be available for review by interested parties between the hours of 8:30 a.m.
and 4:30 p.m., weekdays, at the City of Clearwater, Planning Department, 100 S. Myrtle
Ave., Clearwater, FL 33756. Please contact the case presenter, at 562-4567 to discuss
any questions or concerns about the project and/or to better understand the proposal
and review the site plan.
Michael Delk
Planning Director
Cynthia E. Goudeau, MMC
City Clerk
City of Clearwater
P.O. Box 4748, Clearwater, FL 33758-4748
NOTE: Applicant or representative must be present at the hearing.
A COPY OF THIS AD IN LARGE PRINT IS AVAILABLE IN OFFICIAL RECORDS AND
LEGISLATIVE SERVICES. ANY PERSON WITH A DISABILITY REQUIRING
REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING
SHOULD CALL (727) 562-4093 WITH THEIR REQUEST.
Ad: 07/06/06
ALAMPI, VANESSA M
14989 NEWPORT RD
CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 7086
CAMPBELL, DENNIS M
1571 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 7116
CARPENTER, EMMETT W
1565 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 71'08
CLARIDA, FRANK TRE
CLARIDA, MARY TRE
1117 AMBLE LN
CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 3704
CONWAY, RICHARD
706 BELLEAIR RD
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2108
DAVIS, TONY D
DAVIS, SANDRA D
2193 KARAN WAY
CLEARWATER FL 33763 - 2414
DUDLEY, HERBERT L
DUDLEY, LUCILLE D
1564 TILLEY AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2184
FORREST, DIANA R
637 BRYANT ST
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2147
GONZALEZ, SEVERINO
GONZALEZ, JUANA F
1589 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 7108
HAMMOND, MARK A
1540 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2152
FLD2006-04020, 68
. .LLEN, TERRY TRE
BURGESS FAMILY I V TRUST
PO BOX 123
INDIAN ROCKS BEACH FL 33785 -
0123
CAMPBELL, HENRY D
CAMPBELL, MARY L
1571 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 7116
CATARELLI, MICHAEL A
1593 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 7116
Clearwater Neighborhoods Coalition
Sondra Kerr, President
P.O. Box 8204
Clearwater, FL 33758
CROSS PEST CONTROL BRADTN
606 SEVERS ST
PLANT CITY FL 33563 - 5422
DELLINGER, SHANE
FLOW,IVAN REM
1540 S PROSPECT AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2134
EGGERS, LUCILLE RAINEY
12100 SEMINOLE BLVD # 108
LARGO FL 33778 - 2815
FREDERICK, EDWARD H SR EST
1545 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2151
H S W ASSOCIATES INC
5018 N CLARK AVE
TAMPA FL 33614 - 6532
HOLDREN, FILOMENA
2042 INDIAN CREEK RD
DANDRIDGE TN 37725 - 6900
...JROOKS, CYNTHIA....ivI
1546 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2136
CANSLER, SALLY R
9925 CROFTON LN
PORT RICHEY FL 34668 - 4210
CHARLES, RUSSELL J
1585 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 7108
COMMUNITY SERVICE FUND INC
925 LAKEVIEW RD
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 3420
CSX TRANSPORTATION INC
500 WATER ST
JACKSONVILLE FL 32202 - 4423
Donoghue, Richard
332 Skinner Blvd.
Dunedin, FL 34698 -
ERICKSON, JAYNE L
1516 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2136
GENTILE, GERALD T
GENTILE, DENISE
1965 MAGNOLIA DR
CLEARWATER FL 33764 - 4791
HAMBLY, MIKE
1612 GENTRY ST
CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 3621
HOOPINGARNER, RAMON
HOOPINGARNER, JUANITA J
1576 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2199
HOWARTH, RICHARDW oJ J DAN MAR INC "HALSA, DEVA KAlJ'R
HOWARTH, PATRICIA A ROBLEY INVESTMENTS LC NIGHSWONGER, MONTE D
1517 S MYRTLE AVE 490 HILLSBOROUGH ST 15 PRIMROSE DR
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2151 PALM HARBOR FL 34683 - 1627 RICHBORO PA 18954 - 1929
LOGAN, DORIS M D J HOLDING CORP TRE Maggio, Sal
P M M LAND TRUST
1526 TILLEY AVE 1616 GULF TO BAY BLVD # B 2088 Lake Ave. S.E. Ste A
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2138 CLEARWATER FL 33755 - 6476 Largo, FL 33771 -
MARJAN, JAMES F MARSH, CHRISTINE M MC REYNOLDS, WILLIAM
MARJAN, EVA C EST 1540 TILLEY AVE MC REYNOLDS, COLEEN H
2787 COTTONWOOD CT CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2138 1545 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33761 - 3809 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2135
MENCHACA, AGUSTIN W III MEYERS, EUGENE R TRE MILLER, MARK A
1584 TILLEY AVE MEYERS, DORIS J TRE 1549 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2184 209 POINCIANA LN CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2151
LARGO FL 33770 - 2663
MT ZION METHODIST CHURCH NELSON, CHARLES D NELSON, VIVIAN G
825 HOWARD ST NELSON, LESLEY K 633 BRYANT ST
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2195 822 HOWARD ST CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2147
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2182
PETERS, JOSEPHINE M PILLAR OF FAITH DELIVERANCE CH PINNOCK, BRIAN L
1544 TILLEY AVE 1555 SCRANTON AVE PINNOCK, TARI
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2138 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 7108 PO BOX 1852
LARGO FL 33779 - 1852
PLANT, NIGEL RELIGIOUS COMNTY SVC INC ROBERSON, MARK S
PLANT, CHIRENE 503 S MARTIN LUTHER KING JR AV 1533 SCRANTON AVE
1517 SCRANTON AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 1750 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2135
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2135
ROGERS, HENRY S JR SEWELL, PAULINE W SHI, XIAOJING
ROGERS, DANIELLE C 1546 TILLEY AVE PENG, ERYING
1580 S MYRTLE AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2138 301 22ND ST
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2141 BELLEAIR BEACH FL 33786 - 3412
SMART, WILLIAM T III SOWELL, CAROL YN L STANISZESKI, HENRY S
SMART, E RITA 1591 S MYRTLE AVE STANISZESKI, BETTY J
1522 SCRANTON AVE CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 7116 1537 TILLEY AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2136 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2137
SULLIVAN, REGINALD TEREBECKIJ, ADAM WALLS, FRANK JR
TEREBECKIJ, K ANJANETTE
2952 ADRIAN AVE 6822 POTTS RD 1535 SCRANTON AVE
LARGO FL 33774 - 1404 RIVERVIEW FL 33569 - 4603 CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2135
I '
WARREN, LORY
1584 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2141
WILKIE, CHRISTIAN SR
638 BRYANT ST
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2148
WOODRUFF, TIMOTHY
1525 S MYRTLE AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2151
WOODS, LUCILLE
1528 TI LLEY AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2138
YATES, JEAN VOYLES
1540 SCRANTON AVE
CLEARWATER FL 33756 - 2136
.
"
l
.
Check list for COB Agenda & Aoolication sent to
Q1y Clerks Office
FLD2006-04020
801 Howard Street
Application Form
ParcellD
Letter of Authorization
Surveyor Leaal Description
COpy of 400 scale Zonina Atlas with property outlined and 500' radius
hand drawn from outside perimter of site
wvJ
INITIALS
~
v
t/
~
2X2~forANX,LUZ&Z
LARG~MENDMENTS
Sherry Watkins
~
YE~
(P-/3-Df.o
\
,
J 1)5
t; 1(1~
FLD2006-04020
801 HOWARD ST
Date Received: 04/27/2006
MAGGIOtt SAL
ZONING DISTRICT: MDR
LAND USE: RU
ATLAS PAGE: 314A
PLANNER OF RECORD: WW
CL WCoverSheet
8(){
alqenei\ ~
Ado:) :\sag
\ I
~~:-p--;~ ~~ f7
J-----<:
~ ROSS N~~~~N PARK
OS/R
~-
~ 3058
.
I)
39il-l09J
\
1..3 II
~-)4.1
'2/02
.1
o
NORTON APTS,
.....~~
IT.l 11 n
I
~-#,
C~ A.~
~r::J ....V
g>
.g
l
...
...
~
s
I
t
$
~
I
~
~
j
~
..
ffi- .
4193-140.
OJ _~~~3_-~~~____ ~~L404 ; 5
n WOODLAWN
~~\s ~~~:.I~'rr ~j
u ,.U.
A ""...-I ~, :~' i -
/ i\ ~ :: ,..., :
/ ~'I .\: ~ :: :. ~
"" "\ lU!1 '" 2 ~ :::: "" :
$ ;:.....,.OWARD :-
, 1 -
"" \, ~
1<""" . ":.: "
44/27,11I0 J ,," :/~ ..
.: ~'J~: ~
171: ~
~ ",,'~ ~p\' -:-
~V :
" ,
ISS2 ~ t ~..
~
,1,,'~~II\~ :..::',.'.'.'..
.. 3218
..
It"
50
,
32/0'
5i [II <s
8 ~ "ft"
:52/04 ~ ~~ ~....
'2/08
,..
l<.
::l
! :~~::. i;~~3__
'"
itU! :
..
.. .
"
..
..
.
II 1114
"
,
"
.
.
""
.tU4
.
26
.
. ,
.
"
.
.
"
g: 44/'0
:- !
..
"
"
u,,,
"
"
:5 2. };I
",",
~5~
., ,
-,--
BE
J',,' .,
, ,-rl~<'t,I,. '~,l 1,
,'~, :F:~:: l ~JJ ~
(J)
A
~tl'~I. ~.i lJ
I ilUlnn "
'2/'2
. 3068
.2th ~~ ~I ,~I,~ 1:::1.. J... I' I 1 r-;r
I~ IHI.. ~~lun1:. 50 L~~~'2 "114 50 " 12 ",14 <. ~f-@l-
. .. - - s~,..L.-" '0 '-
~ Ii; Dpr; 4N .. ~b~1 ;L81;:= I'll :11 I~i I, "".. ""9~;
i COI r~T lp-j: I ,.., 10 -;- .!".
,...k it! "..5 2,,_ ".. T,T I I ~I I . "" I ~..
':"' '~h;'.. ''''~I ! il ! I ~! I! "" I -l'-;-~
E ~t~5 9t~"'" 'I t I 1111 II"': ~~
'!1I I utI.i If' .i__~: ,,.!>'.
....iIl If 3" L:..L-L rr-"..-- llti ~ 10
#II I C~ :t:N ~I -.... lRdSEf..ufN $ 8 I:?- II L ~O
""-';";:.1",' '1 ~~\w-l.~""... 1 '12 13 i1h t "" ".. 3 '0
~ Al.MA $ST i ~ I 7 .:
'm 4, 10 ~ 1<Sl>.i!i t~....!!'.! "" 118117 81lf; ~, ,,,. i ,*-,
"" ~~ i !"~i i "" '0 S-UB, 59~6 9 ~ ,...'
".. II i ~= ~m ~.I,~ l J s I i
"/01 '" ~ ~ ~ ~. u t-l,';;-l" ! '2 "..... ,I-"
~ ~ \;~h, '! ,,;;-1 ~ ~ "i,
I.^~" 1101 ii' I ".. !'i'
3\/10 ~ ~~ 1~ 13 I :'~ ,I; ~
A Pi Jl~:, /117 'I'~ t j /
'0 I 4. I' ,
31/11 31/17 J1n;f Sr 1 IM#>J~:S N '" 11 10U70 "'I 11,., :1,'
II.. 101; i ~.3 · 5 =: i ,JJ:j '..Pm t- m,5 t::
. : ~', ~~WOODST "'!...,,,... ,;i.iI: 8,,, i '; ,!: .(':':8:1:::"'(
~ i'" "'>> '}... 18 - 14 7 "I', ".., ,
~ . 9 68 t, is ~"I II'" -:.w l;U!n;' d,i
; :14" II' _I H~IGm fN Ji, In.fll" ~':l:::'; ,I'
. t -:: 1&, " I
1 . , . .;...". 10"5 12 83 '9 20 ,m ""'ll:
, ", 50 ~ "'!: ItM ...1" r:r," ...':';.1"
..~ J5~ I IT SlllE-;; .- - a ;,~
:E:: '~Ri2ltWf1!~ n ft. ~~ 10 ~ 1 2 50 i i i_ ....". .. ", CD
~ III'" !II l.o.t. 'II" 1 2 3. "2'3" ~ ~
:dii1.' . JONES XEPLAT 7 8 ~ ~ ~ ~ "" 24 5 1:: 2: - ~ ~
tl!1t ELhlONT PARK16-87 i I.J I'"'1f.;: ,., '-\1D. ".. 2$' 8 ".. /'" ':. . I ,
~ ~VERHOH;T. t01S 5/11. I/~J 22 1 "" I.&.. i i::l",
~ " H ~ ~CAN ,., 20'" ... '8 8,... I:::' 2' 8,~~~ t:::~' 8':::
i ~ ..if3 6-70 I . 2,fTt: J ':!::ii 7 "" I ... 20 9 "" ~i ~ ~:::
~ 85 5201,,2118 C'lt178""c""t910Iln W[;:il0' 1'1
:t:: 8"';', ..J.~. 22 '9".. ...'8 9 ".. :f'8 f.u-rm. If ~.I-;j:- ~
...IL..IH 83 ~. 11,,2' 20,... 1,,,,,'5 .0.... :m 17 T t ... '2,,, ~
~ 82 8' ~151i .' 1 i$ i' &3 'i 12 ~'i ,'8.5.. '3 ;'8: 15 ~. .3"
--!!.- !!! it
~a
I~~ 3 .
II
"'..... 118
tilt C 3
....
~8
'f~
.'" fi#I
"",..-u u.,
"50
.
tttt.12N
32/'3
A/02
II?' \..--
4UO-M'
14'4
'"
.
a
i
. 1
'2/11
..
'fl, "
,
u . "
~
J.~~1I~1
rn ~o....
,sl'~ tP "..
;~'5
'IslJm
u,
,
11#1.
.
.
.
..
..
..
, , ..
"
"'
"'
..
I( ..
.
"
"
.
.
.. '"I i .
" ,.
.
", c
" .
.. .
. "~~ "..~
'"
..
.,
.
.
"
"
..
..
SlRE[1'
LMD
-
.
"
.
..
.
.
: :: ~~8~;: ~157 I~ 50 29 28 .L ~ II ~ } ,l!
'. ' '~. ~~... 59,,,. Ilu1~ 30 II.. '0 3df. '''2. 5 ".
". ': .,,,, ' 77 eo IU' ...~ 31'''' "' 9 ,,"" 23 &-~
.. . .. ft..-" 78 81".. ~..T 32 i I:::: 8 $ "" 1....22}5.
II" .... ~ sf '5 &2 I'''' Ion 46 3i11f.7 tfU 7 e II" i 2' ,....
.. t- . " ~ ~ ""'''; \C"'If "10
:: ~,,: :: I :it;;;; ", ,. 63 ""' 'f1' 45 3.,.Jt; ".".& 7 ,." 2 20 9 "'4
: / f. ... ~ i ""',... "''' 35,,,. uI '" 5 8,,,, uI JU' It 10
", II , ~ 3 ",,72 5' IAI ..,43 3&,~.. ,,,, 4 9 ,,,,, '" ~ 11 ""
: ~g ~ l 71 88,,,, ;:;:'2 37 l~ "" '0,,,, "2:; 17 '2
: f-;;-T! t ~ 1.~98t7 .,.0 '9 38 ~2 ~ t' .. f.. '5 .. 13
., I 'H..fi--j;-li~"~~'K";:.'~'~ ,..,,, """, :~, ,.::,:,,! ~~~"I.'~""~'J':-"~"~":' i ~ i ! I
· I ,,~ ! IIDI Ii I~l ~!W/ 'l'!,). ::'11 1 II I ~ I:.!~"" ~ "~I, ~ r
. 2' ,"i",., ' 11t~' ".. 'F'~,' "n' ", i ~', i'i,':' . ~Ii! I ~
,ii' '12" : I ~ lj /, Je,~", l':";:8 ~ ,,12 :~,:j 1 2'-3 41
T 322A
,">">0 ...
.
..
.
..
:::: 24 ,
,..,23'""8 !
"'22 7 ~I
1m 21 s",Q! I i"7 "
,
"" 20 9,."
~~ 19 10.. 1 'l:~,:~l;;i;l
i
;:;: 18 " J ~:.:: '~:'i;,,:,::
:::; 17 12 8
'el~.t 1413 . '"
. 1:1 ........ 9
! '--
IWTn .!-l
'\ ~ Fl' ~), H~;:..;:;";
f Ii, l~,~ 4'~ ,-;lir,
IN' 3 ,!
.- --
CITY OF CLEARWATER
AND VICINITY
P\NELLAS COUN'l'Y, FLORIDA
PREPARED BY
PUBLIC WORKS ADMINI3TRATION
ENGINEERING
loo! II."U. "\It a.ofWoltf, Fl 33756
Ph (n7):I62-H50 FaI (n7)526-H5~
IlUp / /w" dftrtrottf-lI tom/Clt,.J)~ortmtnt'/pUbllc_worh/~n9lnn( /
OI"C1almer
Pvbllc Informatlon dolo I, 'u(J'lllh~ by the Clly of Oeorrot.r
PUl:lllc Works A<lmln'strotIM!Engln..rln9 and must be accepted
and und by lilt recl~l1~t WIth the understandIng that Ih. <Iota
r<<el\led ror cOllected for the purpose of developin9 CI 9"ophk
Introstruclure Inventory As S\lch the City of Cleonrotcr PWA!t
mQke, "0 worrOJ'lIl.. ..-.prund or Implle-d coneef"l'lll'l9 the
occurocy. campl.t.n_1S r-'loblllly Of wltobQlty of this dolo 'or
(Jfly other port/cut or use Furthermore the City ot Cleor.ot.r
PWA/E anum" no liability lIil1lol.o...,.r associated rlth the Uti
or mlsu.e of sueh data
Thl. Atla. p09. I, su~ to perIodic chon9U
'01' lntCll"tl'lotlon oP)oul lotut (.\If,lons p1eoM eoll PWA.!E or
"",II our Web SIt.
EB
o
I
100 200 '00
" ,
SCALE ." = .00'
LEGEND
@ BLOCK NUMBER
1234 LOT ADDRESS
CITY LIMITS LINE
600
I
.
AGREEMENT TO ANNEX
SHADED AREA - PROPERTY
OUTSIDE ClEARWATER CITY LIMITS
[::;.~J
.
CITY OWNED PROPERTY
" ~'
/,1;,
MDR ZONING DESIGNATION
- ZONE LINE
'~ ;:
j':~:
')lllj;111
)plli:,
. RESTRICTIONS 4105-1747
l
RtlClNE ORO
rn 4111 11 /0'2/111
()] 50'2 12/20/90
OJ e155 07/11/97
rn e2e7 OS/21/911
l]l a159712/13/01
REVISED,
5/02/02
SW 1/4 OF SECTION
.,., _ .,n ~ _ it: ~
ZONING ATLAS
.~ 1 4. A