02/12/2008NEIGHBORHOOD & AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY BOARD MEETING MINUTES
CITY OF CLEARWATER
February 12, 2008
Present: Lisa Hughes
Donald F. Brackett
Laurel Braswell
Josephine Carbone
Vacant Seat
Absent: Peggy M. Cutkomp
Kip Corriveau
Chair
Vice-Chair
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Board Member
Also Present: Geri Campos Lopez Economic Development & Housing Director
Michael Holmes Housing Manager
Brenda Moses Board Reporter
The Chair called the meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. at City Hall.
To provide continuity for research, items are in agenda order although not
necessarily discussed in that order.
3. Approval of Minutes - November 27, 2007
Member Brackett moved to approve the minutes of the regular Neighborhood and
Affordable Housing Advisory Board meeting of November 27, 2007, as recorded and submitted
in written summation to each board member. The motion was duly seconded and carried
unanimously.
4. Proposed New Housing Projects
Habitat for Humanity - Steven's Housing Project
Barbara Inman, Habitat (Habitat for Humanity of Pinellas County), requested $600,000
of SHIP (State Housing Initiative Partnership) funds to acquire real property at 1884 Betty Lane
that will be used to build new single-family homes for low to moderate income families. The
funding request is for a five-year deferred payment loan. The funds will be repaid when each
home is sold to an eligible homebuyer. Habitat encourages community involvement. Plans are
to seek various forms of funding including funds from the County and donations from
individuals, corporations, civic organizations, etc.
The site is approximately 8.81 acres and is the former Homer villas rental community
presently owned by the CHA (Clearwater Housing Authority). The project is referred to as the
Steven's Creek Residential Community. The acquisition is subject to Habitat building affordable
housing units for mixed income families. Property acquisition costs are $1,189,350, or $20,158
per unit. The housing units currently are vacant and in a deteriorated state. After purchase,
Habitat will demolish all the structures. Habitat proposes to build a minimum of 50 single-family
homes for families whose incomes fall within 30% - 80% of area median income. To keep the
units affordable, Habitat proposes to use volunteers to partner with a general contractor to
perform the work. Habitat also will provide reduced interest mortgages to homebuyers to
ensure affordability. Habitat has a property acquisition contract with the local housing authority
that requires a February 2008 purchase of this property. After purchase of the property, Habitat
Neighborhood & Affordable Housing 2008-02-12
will submit site plans to the City’s Planning Department. Habitat anticipates the bid solicitation
process will begin in July 2009 and construction shortly thereafter. Construction will move
forward in phases with a projected completion date of February 2013.
Homebuyers in this project will be required to attend mandatory classes in preparation
for homeownership and contribute between 250 – 350 hours of sweat equity, volunteering at
Habitat in some capacity, mostly at the construction site. Potential homebuyers also will be
required to make nominal payments each month towards the closing costs for their future home.
By providing affordable homeownership housing, Habitat hopes to improve the housing
stock in this neighborhood, raise the property values, and create economic incentives for
additional public and private investments in housing in areas targeted by the City for
revitalization. These affordable housing units will help the City reach its goal of providing new
single-family homes as identified in its Five Year Consolidated Plan. To ensure a mixed unit
development, Habitat will work with a developer to build 9 units that will be available for families
between 80% and 120% of area median income.
In response to a question, Ms. Inman said, as these units will be purchased instead of
rented, it is expected that the units will be appropriately maintained. The units will be energy
efficient, which will reduce utility bills. Although there are no plans for a homeowner’s
association, standards may be included in the sales documents regarding property
maintenance.
Ron Spoor, Land Development Manager for Habitat, said the project will be built in the
same configuration as Homer Villas. Hopes are that a mixed income component with larger
homes and two-car garages can be built for families with incomes of 80% and above on the
portion of the property facing Stevenson’s Creek. He said phase one environmental testing
indicates there are no issues regarding Stevenson’s Creek. As the Home Villas project was
built in the 1980’s, asbestos and lead are not issues for demolition and removal of materials.
Discussion ensued with support for the concept. It was felt that a maximum of 50 units
would provide more space between homes. Concern was expressed that the community space
as depicted in the conceptual plans would not provide enough privacy to residents. Mr. Spoor
said the community space could be fenced to provide residents with more privacy. He said
HUD requires a commitment of 54 units to be eligible to fund the project. He reviewed the lot
sizes and square footage for the units. He said former Homer Villa tenants are eligible to apply
for these units. Homebuyers must meet specific income criteria and the development must
adhere to the Fair Housing Act.
Member Carbone moved to approve the request by Habitat for Humanity for $600,000.
The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
Pine Berry – Senior Apartment Project
Ken Bowron, Beneficial Communities, said his firm specializes in affordable housing for
seniors. He reviewed Beneficial’s history. Beneficial requests $345,000 in SHIP funds to
develop apartments for seniors at 1225 Highland Avenue. The site is approximately 3.02 acres
and was a former bowling alley. The complex will provide 80 affordable multi-family units for the
elderly, comprised of 40 one-bedroom/1bath units and 40 two-bedroom/1 bath units. He
reviewed square footage for the units. All units will be wheelchair accessible and have energy
Neighborhood & Affordable Housing 2008-02-12 2
efficient appliances. Rents will be set at 60% of the area median income or lower. Beneficial
has a purchase contract for the property.
Robert Lomas, Beneficial partner, said the project will include funding from SHIP (State
Housing Initiative Partnership Program), Federal low income housing tax credits, a loan secured
by the general partner, supplemental funding from Florida Housing Finance Agency, and
developer fees. Beneficial has family products in Georgia and Alabama and 10 in Florida. In
response to questions, Mr. Lomas said this is not an ALF (Assisted Living Facility). It is an
independent ageing in place complex for senior citizens aged 55 and up, and will be available at
a fraction of the cost of an ALF. He said as the developer, Beneficial will retain ownership of the
property. Beneficial will hire a construction and management company for the project.
However, Beneficial engineers and staff will continuously oversee the project’s progress. He
said this project will be an asset to the community.
Mr. Bowron said there is a tremendous need for rental housing units in Clearwater. He
reviewed the timeline for construction and completion of the project. The development will
include an amenity package that includes emergency call service in each unit, a community
center, a picnic area, computer lab on site, laundry facilities with full size washers and dryers,
and a library at no charge to tenants. The site is in the vicinity of a medical facility, pharmacy,
bus stop, shopping, etc.
Discussion ensued with comments that the project would be a nice addition to the area.
Member Brackett moved to approve the request by Beneficial Communities for
$345,000. The motion was duly seconded and carried unanimously.
Kimberly Home – Rental Acquisition Project
Kate Kelley, Kimberly Home Pregnancy Resource Center, requested $150,000 in SHIP
funds to purchase two properties at 1181 and 1183 Brown’s Court to expand the Kimberly
Home Pregnancy Resource Center. The proposed project will add approximately 9,000 square-
feet of property and two housing facilities to its existing program. The properties include three
housing units and will provide transitional housing for expectant mothers for up to a year after
post delivery. Kimberly Home provides pregnant mothers with assessments, crisis intervention
services, individual case management and mentoring, coordinating services with community
resources, and the opportunity for vocational and educational training. Ms. Kelley said the
resource center will be renovated sometime in the future. She said there is a considerable need
for affordable rental facilities for expectant mothers.
Member Brackett moved to approve the request by Kimberly Home Pregnancy Resource
Center for $150,000.
5. Action Item – Proposed FY 07/08 Meeting Schedule
Consensus was that the proposed 2008 meeting schedule provided by staff was
acceptable.
Housing Manager Michael Holmes said this year’s bus tour of subrecipient locations will
be scheduled in March or April.
6. Action Item – Setting the Course for Future Meetings
Neighborhood & Affordable Housing 2008-02-12 3
Mr. Holmes requested board input regarding the effectiveness of NAHAB meetings. It
was remarked that today's meeting was very informative, that bus tours are helpful, and that
staff continue to educate the board regarding pertinent housing and public service programs. It
was felt the board needs as much information as is possible.
Economic Development & Housing Director Geri Campos Lopez said staff will present
information regarding land trusts to the board in March. She said staff will provide information to
the board regarding housing development projects as they are received.
7. New/Old Business - None.
8. Next Meetinq - March 11. 2008
9. Adiournment
The meeting adjourned at 10:00 a.m.
~
. ~1dcc )n}~
oard Reporter
Neighborhood & Affordable Housing 2008-02-12
4