STIPULATION AND AGREEMENT WITH CITY OF CLEARWATER AND SIDNEY R. KLEIN CHIEF OF POLICE
I
.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TAMPA DIVISION
17 f~! "fil, l~~J 'c~~,;
. ,
CITY OF CLEARWATER and ]
SIDNEY R. KLEIN, Chief of ]
Police, Clearwater Police Department, ]
]
Plaintiffs, ]
]
vs. ]
]
CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY FLAG ]
SERVICE ORGANIZATION, INC., ]
]
Defendant. ]
/
~O\i i] {i 1998
Case No. 94-292-Civ-T-24/A
STIPULATION AND AGREEMENT
The parties to the above-captioned action, CITY OF CLEARWATER and SIDNEY R.
KLEIN, Chief of Police, Clearwater Police Department, Plaintiffs, and CHURCH OF
SCIENTOLOGY FLAG SERVICE ORGANIZATION, INC., Defendant, by and through their
undersigned counsel, agree and stipulate as follows:
1. The Plaintiff, CITY OF CLEARWATER, is a municipal corporation in
Pinellas County, Florida.
2. The Plaintiff, SIDNEY R. KLEIN, is the Chief of Police of the Clearwater
Police Department (hereinafter "CPD"), an agency of the City of Clearwater. Chief Klein is the
official custodian of all public records maintained by the Clearwater Police Department.
3. The Defendant, CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY FLAG SERVICE
ORGANIZATION, INC. (hereinafter "the Church"), is a non-profit religious corporation,
recognized by the Internal Revenue Service as a tax-exempt church.
1
TPA1\COMMLl1\29931.3
19682/000110/29/987:12 AM
(-....'..,
f /
1../ c./
,..
4/
C,t_~<"~
.
. .'
I
I
4. Since at least 1979, the CPD has conducted a criminal intelligence
investigation of the Church and its members and amassed voluminous files of individual police
reports, intelligence reports, and other documents gathered through January of 1994 and which
records are the subject matter of this action (hereinafter "Scientology Records"). No criminal
charges have been filed by CPD against the Church or its members as a result of the CPD criminal
intelligence investigation.
5. The Scientology Records also include a multi-volume report written by CPD
officer Ray Emmons (hereinafter the "Emmons" report) which accuses named officials and
parishioners of the Church of having committed numerous state and federal crimes. It is the
Church's position that these accusations are false and/or without basis.
6. fu or around January, 1994, the CPD released some of the Scientology
Records to a newspaper which had made a request for the documents pursuant to the Florida Public
Records Act and all the Scientology Records were later shown to the Church. Subsequently, the
Church protested this public release of the Scientology Records on the grounds that such release
violated the privacy interests of the Church and those who associate with it.
7. Plaintiffs subsequently instituted the instant action seeking a declaration as to
whether the disclosure of any records not subject to exemption under Chapter 119, Florida Statutes,
would be violative of the Defendant's privacy rights and whether the Plaintiffs have any immunity,
power, privilege or right to forbid the disclosure of those documents.
8. The Church counterclaimed, seeking an injunction against further public
release of the Scientology Records that contained sensitive and private information about the
Church and its members, on the grounds that release of such documents would violate the privacy
rights of the Church and its members protected by the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the
TPA 1\COMMLlT\29931.3
19682/000110/29/987:12 AM
2
I
I
United States Constitution and the Florida Constitution; and that release of any documents alleging
child abuse would violate Fla. Stat. ~ 119.07. The Church also sought an order expunging the CPD
files.
9. The parties have taken part in court-ordered mediation conducted by James
R. Freeman of Shear, Newman, Hahn and Rosenkranz in Tampa and have conducted settlement
negotiations on their own. This stipulation and agreement ("Agreement") was reached as a result of
the mediation and independent settlement negotiations.
10. The Plaintiffs agree to conduct a good faith review of the Scientology
Records to determine which of those documents they can destroy as unnecessary. Such good faith
review shall be accomplished within four (4) months of the date of this agreement.
11. At the conclusion of the review process set forth in paragraph 10 above, the
Plaintiffs agree to continue to review the Scientology Records in a good faith effort to destroy the
remaining Scientology Records which the Plaintiffs determine are or have become unnecessary.
12. All records to be destroyed pursuant to this Agreement shall be destroyed in
accordance with the requirements and procedures of Chapter 119, Florida Statutes, and the
Plaintiffs' destruction policy.
13. The parties agree that the CPD will not publicly comment on this
Agreement.
14. Each party will voluntarily dismiss, without prejudice, their claims in this
action.
TPA 1\COMMLlT\29931.3
1968210001 10/29/987:12 AM
3
"
, <,,,
I
I
15. Each party shall bear its own costs and attorneys fees in this action.
Signed and Agreed:
T,ESQ.Of
B , BARNES,
ZIMMET UNICE
Fla. Bar N . 339044
2655 McCormick Drive
Post Office Box 5124
Clearwater, FL 34619
(813) 799-2882
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
PAUL B. JOHNSON, ESQ.
Fla. Bar No. 039966
P. O. Box 3416
Tampa, FL 33601
(813) 258-0087
and
ERIC M. LIEBERMAN, ESQ.
RABINOWITZ, BOUDIN, STANDARD
KRINSKY & LIEBERMAN P.C.
740 Broadway, Fifth Floor
New York, NY 10003
(212) 254-1111
Attorneys for Defendant
TPA1\COMMLl1I29931.3
19682/0001 10/29/987:12 AM
4